CorpusRecord 1053

School Board Workshop: January 7, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Lee County School Board
Date
2025-01-07
Location
Lee County, FL
Material
Transcript
Extent
33,977 words · about 189 min
Collected
2026-04-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good afternoon everyone it's Tuesday January 7th 2025 this is a school board workshop and the time is 1 p.m. Sergeant at Arms has the lobby been cleared yes thank you Happy New Year everyone there are 13 items on the agenda today Arts seal office of State safe schools second quarter inspection report construction change order November 24 construction projects by monthly update January 25 2526 code of conduct for students pre-briefing 2526 code of conduct for adult students pre-briefing policy review briefing and first reading mental health proposed adjustment to school start times for the 2526 school year legislative priorities institutional board member seats public comment and good of the order per board protocol each member should strive for four minutes with initial comment and two minutes for followup due to the amount of items on today's agenda

002I'm going to try to stick really CL close to that please but to start us off we're going to begin with the art seal Dr Jason thomasi will be presenting hello thank you for having me today I'm here today to present the Florida Fine Arts seal of programs this has been an advocacy effort from the Florida music Education Association and the Florida arts Educators Association effort for at least the last decade I served on those boards when I was a teacher in 2018 and the Rumblings of this seal had started then and it finally became a Florida bill this summer it was passed in July and it is an opportunity to showcase the talents of our students our high school students the Florida seal was established to recognize high school graduates who have meant the

003proper exemplary benchmarks in Fine Arts education throughout the state and the purpose of the seal was to encourage students to develop those skills in both performing and visual art if you're really into learning a little bit more about the seal I included a link in the top of this slide if not I'm going to do my best today to explain what the seal is how do you earn it and what are we doing now to help students achieve this seal later there are three major criteria for the seal one earn a standard high school diploma the number two is they need to receive an A or hire for three years in a fine arts discipline so that could be band choir orchestra dance drama and visual art we consider those the six Fine Arts discipline

004and then there's three sub they need to meet two sub requirements outlined by the Department of Education again the only have to meet two of these sub requirements though there's a long list of things that they could do to earn these sub requirements they only need to complete two of these I'm going to briefly cover them now and then I'll go back and in later slides explain what we do as a district to help students meet each of these sub requirements already first they can complete an IV AP dual enrollment or honors course with a be or hire within their Arts discipline that they choose again that's band choir orchestra dance drama and visual art they partic participate in a district or Statewide jured event for two or more years they can record 25 volunteer

005hours in an Arts related community service event they can submit a portfolio that demonstrate the student is an exemplary practitioner of the Arts and finally they receive District state or national recognition for the creation submission of original artwork now instead of passing this PowerPoint around to every teachers and students we created a one pager to give out to teachers and students and parents it helps outline what it is what they could achieve how can they achieve it and also has my contact info I answer questions from parents and students about this all the time and helping and giving them the information that they need to know how to apply and achieve this outline this is included in your attachments page as well so if you want to read this further this resource is available all

006right so we're going to dig into each of the sub requirements and kind of what we do in County already the first sub requirement deals with the advanced courses IB AP dual enrollment and honors courses they need at least a be or hire just once these are some of an example of some of the courses that we offer including art history AP art history AP drawing AP music theory any of the honors courses like jazz band 5 and six or Ceramics 4 or dance techniques 3 and four just to name a few and any of the IB visual art and music courses count towards this there is a big note and I had it confirm with the Department of Education as Cambridge courses do not qualify for this one I asked for a reason they

007said it wasn't in the original the bill Bill verbage so they did not want to include it in the requirements however there's an opportunity for Cambridge art students later on in one of the other sub requirements that I'll get to later I also have an attachment here that'll outline literally every of the hundreds of courses that students can take to help meet this sub requirement sub requirement two a jured event the state considers a jured event anything where the students get a rating and a score from a profession an Arts professional in our field so we already as a district promote run offer and sponsor so many jured events for our students that take part of if you're a dance student in the county we have the Florida dance performance assessment our all count dance

008showcase as well in in the music world we have our All State auditions you have District soul and Ensemble festivals the music performance assessments NPA to sum which is a huge deal as well as allc County if you're a drama student we have the southwest Florida theatrical Society one act Festival as well as the individual event Festival as well as High School Musical Theater Awards and Broadway stars of the future our visual art students have the opportunity to be part of various art shows like future of the Arts the Florida State art assessment the the state's Scholastic art and writing as well as artfest Fort Meyers art under 20 and chalk block all of these are events that we already do that does not mean we can't add more events as we find that they

009exist or go along or decide that we want to add another jured event to give a specific Arts discipline another opportunity but just these are the this you know the plethora of events that we already offer as a district sub requirement three record at least 25 volunteer hours in arts related community service I worked with Lori Brooks already about this to see if we could double dip with our Bright Futures 100 hours and yes the state gave us permission for that do my ver my person from the state also came back is make sure the 25 hours for this are Arts related we have great Partnerships that we cultivated over the last couple years with groups like artfest Fort Meers Alliance for the Arts in Sydney burn Davis Arts Center just to name a few

010all of those organizations are constantly looking for ushers ticket takers people to help set up and tear down from their events and all of those hours could count towards the seal another cool opportunity that this presents for this specific sub requirement is having our high school students go back to elementary and middle schools and give private lessons and help out the teachers there to help grow the Arts in our younger grade level so this sub requirement has plenty of opportunities for students to meet as well the fourth one gets a little tricky it is students submit a portfolio that demonstrates that they are an exemplary practitioner of the Arts the state clarified for us that the portfolio would be submitted to me the fine arts department of our County I would assemble a group of

011three to five members mostly teachers from our Arts certified teachers from middle and elementary school to help us grade these portfolios the dish the state provided us with a rubric that students can use to when preparing their portfolios we are lucky and this is what I mentioned earlier that this the rubric mimics the Cambridge art rubric so if you are a Cambridge student in one of the end results of the Cambridge Arts programs is submitting a portfolio to the state it's a good precursor to that camridge thing so students who are preparing a Cambridge art portfolio can submit it earlier to us get the Seal Credit while also prepping for their Cambridge final we do not have a due date at this time for this but I should have that in the next couple of

012weeks and lastly the last sub requirement is submitting a piece of original artwork the state defined that as something that is not a copy of a copy so if I'm a band student competing in Sol and Ensemble and I'm doing a Bo piece that doesn't count as original I'm just doing something that Bach has already done however if I wrote my own piece for Solen Ensemble and I got a rating for it that would count as an original piece of artwork even designs and dreams if you travel our Halls we have over 600 pieces of artwork some are copies of star KN world famous art piece and some are original pieces of artwork so the students that submitted original could qualify for the sub requirement because it's something that they created themselves and here's a

013list of some of the other events that we provide that opportunity for students to create their own artwork the state provided us with plenty of forms and tracking devices for students to use moving forward once the students have submitted all of their work with the help of their teachers we are working with Focus the state organization is focus has submitted their final patch earlier this week and we'll be able to track everything that the students submit for for this seal in Focus moving forward we are looking at the documentation window due late March early April for the sake of ordering seals in time for the processing and then ordering seals in time for graduation in May the teacher is apcs at ad have been trained all this stuff throughout the year as we got little

014bits and pieces more from the Department of Education though the law was passed in July this the state doe didn't give us rubrics and stuff like that until October so we're moving along as we get the information from the state communication has been forwarded as well as we go along and then finally this is what the seal looks like the state provided the seal it was created by the Department of Education and will be a fix to their diplomas if they meet the requirements so questions comments or concerns superintendent or board any comments yeah just want to first of all thank Dr tasy for leading this up huge fan of this of the Arts as you are as well the Arts complete our education of our students it helps them in so many ways we

015could start to talk about the research around Math and Science and all of that but just even more than that helping to make them well-rounded great people so just thank you so much for bringing this forward and I'm excited about the State of Florida offering this any other board comments Miss ganelli can we have this PowerPoint I didn't yeah absolutely make sure you get then I could click on the things that you were mentioning absolutely thank you I think this is great recognition however do besides getting the seal on their diploma what other advantages does this help them like get into art schools or actually that is a huge part of that as well so I mentioned earlier the advocacy efforts of the Florida music educators and faea the Florida thesbian the big Arts organizations

016all have Collegiate components on this as well and one of the things when they were working with lawmakers on drafting This was what does a Collegiate what does the what are the Collegiate levels looking for in their art students like how you know typ types of types of activities and that sort of thing so this seal even though it's not until after a lot of them already know they're going to college going through the process will then also help them put stuff on their resume that I had 25 volunteer hours in the Arts I took an Amber IB level music and art program I was in part of these jured events such as soul and Ensemble and all state auditions those are all huge things that colleges are looking for the seal itself since it

017doesn't come till they graduate they already know where they're going to college for the most part but like I said before the process all those sub requirements are things that I know colleges are looking for as well in terms of their art students and their well-rounded students as well like in you know other academic areas so I have another one more question yeah sorry I have one more question the I know that the Arts budget was kind of cut last year did it affect the school district at all I know it affected lots of things that are going on downtown and the Arts Fest and all that they're very concerned over that so do you we know that luckily for us it did not hurt our internal Lee County budget you know knock on every

018piece of wood in the State of Florida that does not change you know we're it did impact Our Community Partners as I mentioned earlier we've cultivated a lot of great Community relationships with Sydney burn the alliance Florida rep all of those groups who were giving us great opportunities for our students moving forward they had to cut some of that stuff back because of their budget cuts as well because they their operation funds you know like I know one of our local Arts organizations lost 50 Grand of their operating funds and some of that was used for educational Outreach for our organization so it's we are still getting great relationships and support from those Arts organizations it's just not as much as it used to be with that Arts funding at the state level okay thank

019you no problem Mr persons just for clarification because there are people old like me out there one of the requirements there was to make an A or higher we came up the highest you could make was an A so maybe I believe with the with the weighted grading system and I pulled I pulled that information from the state the state verbage as well but I believe with certain weighted courses is what they were referring to thank you no problem I just have a really quick question the volunteer your hours that are required can those students also use those for Bright Futures can they double dip yes that's what we were talking about with Lori and I confirmed that they can double dip they can't be paid on our end I know with Bright Futures as

020other requirements and stuff like that on our end it was had to be Arts related was the big one that I heard from my contact was it has to be Arts related okay thank you anyone else all right thank you no problem thank you next is office of safe schools second quarter inspection report Dave nulan will be presenting to the board good afternoon board members Dave nulan chief of safety security and Fleet operations good afternoon to the superintendent Dr n Carlin and our school board attorney Kathy dpri Bruno this is our second quarter inspection report from off of safe schools again this is required by by the statute part of the house bill 1473 became this year is are the compliance inspector for the state will they stop by the schools and ins for certain

021things such as make sure exterior doors and interior doors are closed properly there are certain all the compliance issues things with threat man threat assessment management teams minutes and so forth so this quarter we had over 27 schools in expected for the second quarter which is a large a lot more than the first quarter which was down which was six out of the 27 schools and we discussed this in the 101 there's only seven schools had something minor for the inspection for clarification to these are very minor so how it works the state is once I get the notification that the school was inspected I have a day to acknowledge that they were inspected and within 3 days the whatever if they find something these are these are fixed right away so within before 3

022days even took place all seven schools were fixed these were all minor things could be didn't have minutes for a meeting or something like that right right a really available but it was right away it was fixed and put into the system and I got to say the schools are been a great job with meeting compliance of all the state requirements of being ready when the compliance inspectors come to the schools they are ready to go they give them all the materials they're needed so they've done a great job on maintaining those all those qualifications and inspections and again not knowing when they come to the school these are all surprise inspections they don't tell me they don't tell the schools when they stop by they just do so they are very prepared so I

023want to give him a lot of credit for the hard work and I'll stand by for any questions superintendent just to Echo what Mr nulan said very proud of our schools for the great job that they do with student safety and just want to commend Mr nulan for his leadership in that area I have recently been in Tallahassee in Tampa for new superintendent training and his name is getting mentioned in very high levels in very positive ways so just thank you for the support you provide our schools thank you board members any comments or questions Mr Ribble I just want to make a comment I enjoyed my time with you Mr n we had our oneon-one and I thought you did a great job and obviously you know what you're know what you're talking about

024and you know what your mission is and you have a great plan you're putting forward thank you sir thank you Mr persons when this was originally brought up at the legislative when they were going to do these surprise visits or whatever they that one time were saying they were going to do surprise drills or things at the same time is that not included at all in these anymore or are they able to do that like come in and say I want to see your fire drill or you know they can come in and request copy obviously as part of a request proof they've done the all the emergency drills and fire drills as as required and emergency drills are are done by a very timely sensitive no more than 45 days apart so they have

025to be very specific when they do these but they do check for those now actually actually have them activate one no they do check to make sure they are maintaining the drill requirements for both fire and emergency drills okay that's good I mean they were worried at the FSB F SBA they were going to be doing that so and I see they aren't so that's good just Happ I mean we're doing all the drills so that's yeah and part of the concern too is depending how you do the drill too if you if you notify the local peace app This Bat to make sure they're know they're notified way ahead of time that this is a drill so that's part of the concern too is to be careful when we do that being from a

026practice drill to something that's actually legit thank you how thank you for this how long were they given to cure the defects so how the statute works is two things one I we have to acknowledge it within one day and they're given up to three days to fix the defect but I will say with these they're done within one day so they've definitely within way within the time frame they're fixed when you told me that I thought that was really interesting it was a just a short little window and so I think that's important for people to know that they cured those deficiencies right away so thank you thank you all right thank you thank you we're going to move on to our construction change or report for November 2024 and our construction projects by

027monthly update January 2025 our presenter will be Scott rickenbacher and Melissa Rivera this afternoon good after good afternoon board members Dr Carin Esquire deay Bruno this is your a two-fold report first we'll start with the change order report for November of 2024 as required by Statute as you will see on the front page we had a direct material purchase of the district for $ 7,873 non-direct material purchases change orders coming back to the district we returned back to the district on Project savings a million 27,300 $322 continue gency adjustments we expended 9,386 71 if you go to the second backup page you'll see that we had one DMP six pure change orders two contingency adjustments and I'd like to just make note of the four pure change orders that returned that million dollars and that

028come from four projects where funds were not expended or returned and from value engineering savings are there any questions on the November report Gord thank you for this and my question is Franklin Park we're done with Franklin Park correct Franklin Park right now is in the closeout State and then we'll enter into the auditing State shortly perfect thank you so now we'll move on to the bimonthly construction update I'm not going to read every chart you should have gotten them but what I will do is I will update you on any critical information on each School site so that you're current and up to date with what our knowledge is of the site we'll start with bayor K8 expansion The Next Step that we have coming up right now is a 60 60% design estimate

029due January 16th so for my next reporting to you folks I'll be able to tell you where the dollars are heading for that school and what that budget will look like next slide are there any questions on Bayshore okay next slide please Bonita Springs Elementary rebuild right now that is in a discussion with the community and Schoolboard staff I believe they're actually having a meeting as we speak right now with Adam alloy leading the band on those discussions as to how we proceed with the historic building in the campus we just received what you'll notice from your previous reporting we had a Architects estimate in the amount of 27 million we just received the 60% construction manager estimate and we're at about $ 34.2 million for the proposed rebuild of the historic building the that

030will come down we're still well within our budget of what the board has approved ultimately for a Capital plan budget we see those numbers come down substantially as we get closer to 100% drawings there's a lot of pad in here that are provided both by the CM and the architect they call Design contingency so we should see that coming back as we move forward in time any questions thank you regarding Bonita Springs buildings 17 and 18 are we looking at because it says Renovations interior Renovations and site improvements but building 17 and 18 and I know I spoke with the superintendent regarding this when I was out visiting the bathrooms they're like you have to straddle the toilet to even get the door closed the smell in that in those buildings are we also and

031I know someone had been out there are we also looking at that when we're doing the scope of the renovation no ma'am two separate Scopes we can get an answer for you at a later date and share it with the superintendent and the board if we go into the existing buildings and we start to repair many things that I would for lack of a better term call grandfathered in we open up the potential of having to renovate the entire campus to current codes so that's not to say that maintenance doesn't have some of those things on their radar for this year's budget to go out there and renovate the bathrooms and they have an IQ Department that obviously will handle anything that doesn't smell appropriate but it would not be part of the rebuild for

032the historic building but again not to say it's not being accomplished by operations in the maintenance division look moving forward but we'll definitely mention those concerns and I'll report some type of answer back to you on that status of those items thank you I just because of the fact it said rebuild remodel that's why I asked that question so thank you I'll wait for that answer any more questions on that next slide please Cape craw Technical College expansion just prior to the break on December 9th we were due to have a 90% estimate which gets in typically speaking about 5% within the dollar value of what we project the architect's projected value for that school was 19.1 million and the cm's projected projected value was 20.5 5 million so we're right where we need to

033be be where I create a total project cost estimate usually I bring that forward to you with the phase one we're right where we need to be within the board approved budget of 25 million and again as we get closer to the 100% drawings and it's getting ready to go out on the street for bid we see all of those design contingencies start to shrink even further and then it's the market bearing what the true cost will be so we're we're tracking we've done a lot of ve to maintain and stay within the board approv budget so are there any questions on that go ahead okay next slide Cypress Lake Middle School I don't know how many of you drive past that but we had a successful opening of Portables over the Christmas break I

034want to give a shout out to Matt burbach who's the project manager and Tina silox who headlined that and got that over the whole Christmas break spending many of their own days out there relentlessly we have a CEO the only change to this slide that I would like to make note of is originally we had a July of 2025 substantial completion total project cost no total project cost to the board that will now be March of 2025 coming to you so that's the only change we made to that slide that you wouldn't see in we release your information slides a week prior to your board meeting and these are just one of our updates with our one-on ones with our staff members any questions on Cyprus next Hector caffara K8 rebuild the just some notes

035that you won't see on your slides but you'll see it being put on for the next ones we did submit the Army Corps of Engineers permitting for that site on November 14th of 2024 what I've asked staff to do is on all the all the schools that have Army Corps provide those dates where we could submit it so when you're looking at these charts you can say wow it's been about eight months have we heard anything and right now we have our legislative staff that the board and Dr Carlin have brought on board they're working with the legislative people to try and keep us Forefront with that whole process so hopefully we're at the top of the Heap and we can start seeing some permits getting released and we got our fingers crossed there is

036one issue that cropped up we need to prepare and I know that Adam Malloy and the planning department and operations we have to do an Ila with the city of Cape Coral the Ila that had previously been in place it expired in 2016 obviously this is one of the first schools we have built out in the capee so they're working and they'll be with the legal staff creating an Ila agreement to move that forward with the city of cap yes sir thank you Mr rickenbacher my question every two months I know we're waiting on the Army Corps but how are we looking for shov on the ground in April sorry well you know know we're avoiding Wetlands many of our projects were totally avoiding the wetlands we're asking for what is called a no permit

037required so it's very limited we're hoping that they can come out and do site visits and expedite that permitting I'm hoping on January 20th I think I've said it before that maybe we can go back to something similar to the 404 and it'll start pushing this thing forward a Lot quickly I don't hold a crystal ball I can't put a shovel in that ground I mean we can but it's at what risk would the board want to engage in on that thank you just wanted an update I know a lot of the community members ask me about it thank you next slide Innovation preschool 8 slide has not changed we're still in the 60% design estimate and it's going to be due to the board May 13th of 2025 that's one we'll be presenting to

038you the for that school the 60% estimate we had to give them a little bit more time which we reported previously only because staff has changed Direction on that campus has changed and we had to Value engineer and reconfigure some of the program for that school I know we've spoke about this school multiple times and I thought the last time I was trying to find my notes that we said we were going to take away that name because it's really not going to be an innovation school any longer and I actually I think it was Miss G vanelli that brought that up the last time so is this are we still going with it as The Innovation School Dr car thank you thank you for the question that may have predated me so I'm going

039to go out on a limb here and say that I would like an opportunity to speak with staff to get clarification on that but we will get that update to you thank you thank you any more questions okay next slide please Elementary School L as you can see we are du a 90% estimate February 19th of 2025 so that'll tell us exactly within 5% as I mentioned before of where the value of that is coming in regards to our projection of what cost we felt would be at the time where we needed to put together a bid package and as you aware that's a combo site that's on the corner of Daniels and 82 I believe and the two schools are going to kick off together so we're still working o is done but we're

040still working to finish this up and they'll both sit they'll be the reason you'll see a delay potentially is the Army Corp because until we get that pering we can't really go out for bid there's too much exposure there so the designs will be done the estimates will be provided to you folks where we are at that moment in time and then once that Army Corps is released then obviously we'll be going out for a bid session and bringing the dollars to you as a GMP Amendment any questions next slide Elementary School M we as you can see right now the project for risk mitigation army Cor cors was submitted in December 15th 2024 for our permitting on that side to put the entire Army corpse package together the actual full submission won't be it'll

041be delayed until January this month when we go in we had some mitigation issues out there and an additional research we had to do the 30% design estimates were received just before Christmas break so we got the drawings on the 15th however they've requested a couple of weeks to get the estimate from the architect to us so by the end of this week the beginning of next week we're hopefully going to have a 30% estimate from the architectural side of the project team to let you know where that project is heading in terms of dollars and how it relates to the Capital approval plan any questions next slide High School nnn I do want to report we had one typo that we picked up so in the presentation you'll see that it said 90% on

042the presentation up on the screen on the documents you received last week it said 60 so we've corrected that for this meeting we have received the cm's 90% estimate and it's 161.5 million which is still within the so what we'll see here is we get closer to 100% And we go out to bid we may have to do some ve to remain within that budget or ask the board for more if it's deemed appropriate to provide it but that's part of the process when we get to that point we ve and we get what we need and we don't take some of the extras in some cases to get back within budget we're right we're right on the border there any questions and again that was filed in June 8th of 2024 with the Army

043Corps so they've done site visits they're communicating the legal side has been communicating with or legislation side has been communicating with those folks so we're putting the bug in there we're trying to get them moving next School Middle School o in the E Zone again I just mentioned to you how that is symbiotic with L those two we look to bring a total project cost to the board and that's inclusive of the Army Core time frame from when we started hopefully August at the latest August of 20126 we're hoping to improve on that if we can we certainly will because we need seats and we need to get things in the ground going but right now if we were to allow a full 24mon Army Corps review period that would be the time where I'd

044be bring in a total project cost into you guys for both schools any questions I see you're all seeing a very similar pattern here Army Core Army Core Army Core you have a question okay what's your best estimate on the Army Corps delay as far as raising the cost per year is it like 5% a year in construction cost or 10% years 5% went out the window about four years ago it's stabilized somewhat but you're still in seeing area of about 10% inflation Factor every year so a 2-year delay would be a 20% increase on 100 million well school could be 120 million I mean I just want the public to sort of be aware of that well when we were forecasting it's temporarily been pulled off the capital plan but I believe it was

045high school o out in the cap I believe it was to be delivered around 2030 we are over $200 million to that high school okay thank you that's with an inflation factor that we projected forward High School o so I just spoke to that next to last Riverdale High School the remodel everything's the same we're on target they're utilizing all the various areas as we marched through great team effort there Rob stefen Berger working with the principal cook out there I think I think everybody's pretty pleased with how things are moving out there I do want to bring to light you'll notice that there's a $358,000 expenditure I mentioned that to you before about all the underground plumbing that had rotted just keeping you at the front Cutting Edge we are using the project contingency

046and we believe we're okay we believe that's what the contingency is for we believe we're absorbing that through the project contingency we don't believe we have to come back but I just want to make you aware of these unforeseen conditions that come up in these older campuses and they're just for some Plumbing that was not known $358,000 so we're getting it right we're getting it fixed and we're hope we're staying within budget up to this point and we believe we will stay in budget vpaa renovation of teal they're moving forward we're out there doing the rules the windows you've probably seen the videos of the black box theater again that's still on schedule no changes in there and we just started I believe we did a work authorization where we're going out the same product

047we used on the leek building here to seal up the moisture we're using on the lam teal building as well to seal any moisture that's an old brick building and there's been some moisture infiltration so it'll be a similar product different paint schemes but similar product utilized to stop that as well and last but not least is just a monthly construction update that my team utilizes to report to my supervisors and to the Operations Division shows all of our projects this was a December report and that's for December every we just issued a new one this morning that'll go to my upper management first and then that'll be presented to you for next month as well approximately 50 projects any questions Miss Jordan just the ones that I had noticed that the ones that are

048behind schedule were doing everything to get them to where they need to be correct that is correct yeah there were not a lot but there were some and most of the ones that are behind schedule are the traffic Improvement projects we have a vendor we're actually he was late in providing the drawings for that it's a new vendor that's from the East Coast civil engineering firm so we're going to have a come to Jesus meeting with them on Friday it may be the point where I have to rec contract with another vendor but I want to give them the opportunity to present supposed to have everything this Friday too us we just had this conversation in our shop before we came over board members any other comments or questions all right thank you for such

049a diligent Workshop I appreciate it to both of you thank you very welcome we're going to move on now to the 2025 2026 code of conduct pre-briefing and the 20 25 2026 code of conduct for adult students pre-briefing the presenters are Dr Jessica Duncan and Chuck Bradley good afternoon board members attorney Deo Bruno and superintendent Carlin we appreciate the opportunity to come to today to review our current code of conduct and some of our proposed revisions for next year so today we'll be going for through a review of what we have put in place for this year and some of the changes we enacted we'll also talk about some of the feedback groups and how we got input on this year's code and then we'll review the proposals so just a quick review of our

0502024 2025 code updates that were applied to the current existing code we added the unauthorized area related to restroom use to bring our code into compliance with Florida statute 55386 5 known as the safety and public spaces act we updated the student personal electronic telecommunication device information which indicated that students are not permitted to use cell phones during the school day unless authorized by a teacher administrator we're now living in the world of artificial intelligence and so we added a statement that explicitly requires that the use of AI and presenting that as one's own work it is cheating and then we added a local code which we have labeled physical harm which captures everything that's between horl and simple battery typically horl that gets out of hand and but does not rise to the level

051of simple battery we also expanded the definition of peer conflict and which provided more options for administrators when peer conflicts were pre-planned took place in secluded places like bathrooms or or other secluded areas we added Spanish and Creo translations and we utilize the additional language option of our web page to provide our code in 100 plus languages we updated the definition of infra of the infraction of insubordination and disrespect and basically that this includes additional pieces that help Define what insubordination disrespect is and then we updated the profanity Plank and included a sarc option A Success Academy Review Committee option especially for racial slurs we replaced our plans in each level with levels and level options this was a technical change and this also brought our code into compliance with the Florida Florida cessor taring

052we were backwards at one point with our level one being the lowest and our level five being the highest and the state is the opposite so we brought our code into compliance with that we included tier consequences for drug tobacco and alcohol use in particular we in we wo in interventions to be used especially for first time use and second time use in the current code and then we clarify the definition of and consequences for fighting and again this is to help understand the difference between fighting and peer conflict and we also went further in defining a level two fighting offense when pursuing joining or pre-planning were evident in that piece and then we updated our off-campus felony definition to align with current law enforcement definitions so we made a lot of changes last year

053that we were able to implement many of those ideas came from our feedback groups those feedback groups are really important to us if you're familiar with the code you know that we have over the last several years made significant changes it used to be two separate codes Elementary and secondary each were about 80 pages in length so it was very difficult for parents to read it was not very familyfriendly so we made again significant changes and then substantial changes to the code to support our schools so going along with that we had our feedback groups for next year's code and you can see the groups listed administrators we did invite at least a teacher from every school to a teacher focus group we met with our student groups we had student advisory a group of

054students at Success Academy we also had a behavior and discipline task force and that was made up of a variety of individuals law enforcement we had Parents we had a parent advocate we had school security some School staff so it was a very varied group we met with the that group three times and we have two more meetings planned with that group in January we have over the last several years had Community conversations we continued that this year at four sites we had a meeting offered in each area and in that we do a large group presentation so we talked about vaping and then we had breakout groups on the code of conduct mtss and ese mental health and Health Services we met with superintendent's cabinet we also did a significant survey collection this year

055we did that with anybody from our community conversations we also had some of our regional support staff go out to a school when they were doing a food drive and they were able to collect several hundred survey responses at that site we have two more potential opportunities talc and spal have been involved in our Behavior discipline task force but we've reached out to them to see if they have additional input and then we will also be meeting with our district advisory council at the end of January so again the behavior task force the goal of this was to really look at student behavior and what the impact on that was on learning and staff retention this outlines the members which I already shared and we also had some higher education Personnel T spal assistant principles

056and that group was divided into four subgroups and they talked about data tier two which are those classroom behaviors tier three which are the more significant behaviors and then professional development and then in addition to the teacher task course we had a separate administrator task force so we did a lot of Outreach and really got feedback this year from our important stakeholders so we have some proposed updates that came out of this feedback for the 2025 2026 code of conduct obviously we're going to update branding board membership and superintendent information and then we've heard from many groups to separate disrespect and insubordination into two infractions so the current definition if you read it there is really a definition of insubordination this is a refusal or failure to follow a direction or a directive we're proposing

057to add a definition for disrespect which would be any deliberate or overt action including verbal and non-verbal actions with the intent to interrupt undermine or disregard established classroom or campus rules and this would Encompass things that are considered impolite rude or offensive and that demean to grade antagonize or humiliate a person or group so this is everything that would be below harassment and bullying in that category and this was also on the advice of some of our district committees that and our teacher and edmin because we looked at disrespect and insporation they're being very two separate and distinct infractions so as we look at this one of the reasons we are recommending making this separation is to give us better data and currently in subordination disrespect is the second highest reason for classroom referral and

058has been for the last several years so we're looking at trying to get that to be more granular so we can determine better inter interventions and actions that can happen at the school to prevent insubordination and disrespect you'll also notice in this data that we're projecting right now what our extrapolated data should look like by the end of the school year of the 2024 2025 school year currently we took our quarter 1 data and extrapolated that out to what it would look like at the end of the year and at this point we look like we're on target to reduce most of our major offenses in the district another proposed update is amending the consequence for drug use and possession so this was a change that we made last year and we implemented this year

059with the current one you can see the first second and third consequences and the proposed amendment is a little bit more significant on the second offense so with the second we were proposing level three with up to 5 days OSS that's our current and with our second it would now move to a level two and this gives schools the opportunity if they do want to recommend a reassignment to Success Academy they can do that with a second drug offense another proposed our standard update we're updating all of our web links all of our QR codes to make sure that those are current we're also looking to amend our consequences for bullying right now in the current code it's a level four proposals for it to be a level three which this provides the opportunity for

060a sarc review that's the Success Academy Review Committee so a school could not necessarily send a student directly to Success Academy but based on the specific circumstances they could ask the Review Committee to look at the situation and see if Success Academy placement is appropriate and then one of our other proposed updates is to amend the consequences to sexual offenses these are sexual offenses are a category in the code of conduct typically these are consensual acts that happen on campus but they run the gamut between things such as inappropriate behavior in the hallway all the way up to a sexual act that may happen on campus so our current code keeps these at level three with the first time being level three repeated with a level three with a sarc review and we're proposing that

061we separate these into minor first these would be minor events would be a level three and minor repeated being level three with a sark review but also adding a category of major sexual offenses these would be sexual acts that are done out in the open or in in the presence of of adults or other students on campus and recommending that these be considered at a level two and giving the again the administrators the option to pursue recommendation to Success Academy we're also going to talk about changes to the electronic telecommunications device section and making recommendations there so looking at this is the current electronic telecommunication devices policy and basically what it allows for is discretion administrative discretion for the phone to be used in the school or in the classroom basically anywhere in the school

062with discretion in a review of policy we find of the very large districts when we compare them their policies some permit for instructional some permit for administrative discretion so we outline those now in practice you know there are some larger districts who have more restrictive policies for cell phone this is their current written policy that they have on their sites but we are aware of some of the larger districts this year that have implemented some more restrictive cell phone policies on their campuses and when we looked at our current School procedures because we do have differen is from school to school and we asked our schools what their current procedures were and about 14% said they do allow some cell phone use so that's in line with our high school so at Elementary and most

063middle schools are not allowing cell phone use at all but our high schools do have some level of cell phone use in the schools and when we talk with those groups we surveyed all of our principles but we specifically made sure we had Outreach to each High School to get some information from them the elementary and middle were in favor of having a policy where there is no it is in the bag put away from Bell to Bell at the high school 13 of the 50 schools would prefer the phone off during academic time but would like some discretion during non-academic times this would be like the hallway the cafeteria so that was the feedback that we received from our schools so here's our current proposal for changes regarding devices that they may possess them

064so this is very similar to our old personal Wireless communication while on school grounds includes but not limited to cell phones auxiliary devices that includes watches earbuds and all personal wireless communication devices must be turned off and in the students book bag at all times at the high school level and at discretion of the administration wireless communication devices may be permitted in non-instructional spaces such as cafeterias at all levels wireless communication devices are permitted when the device is approved by the school to be used for to monitor a health condition documented through medical records so at this time this is our current timeline and we are on target to meet this timeline for bringing the student code of conduct for students forward for board action in March currently we're at our pre-briefing we will continue

065to work on the code and meet with our stakeholder groups to provide revisions based on feedback and bring that forward to our first board reading in February and then upon approval anticipated in March we will then finalize print and distribute the student code conduct so at this time we'd like to bring it to the superintendent for superintendent's comments and board discussion on the proposals thank you very much and thank you for the presentation very thorough and very in-depth as you all know the team has been working very diligently to secure stakeholder feedback to use the good information that they have in their years of education and working with again a variety of stakeholders on this updated code this is a very important conversation to have today we've talked about at this table before since my

066election and since my two colleagues my fellow board members were elected school safety is Paramount that is I know our entire board our whole governance team shares that philosophy that school safety is our number one responsibility obviously student achievement is extremely important but nothing is going to happen that's going to be productive unless it's in a safe environment so just want to publicly appreciate the team for their work on this and we look forward to your conversation and your discussion today board members any comments questions Mr persons just a couple comments on the cell phone policy you said they prefer to have it off during instructional activity I believe that's a state law now right they're not allowed to have it on during classroom time so there's really no Choice there I'm fine with Elementary

067Middle School High School worries me a little bit less at the cafeteria than in the hallways so I just worry that seems where a lot of the trouble starts as they in between they're talking and on their phones meet me at this place or whatever but much better than it was you know where they had unused cell phones so keep monitoring it I'm glad to see the incidents of violence and everything else are going down I hope that stays that's a great Trend so that's all thank you shavana in regards to the cell phones specifically for high school I guess for for the time that they have when they're walking to their classes it's not a lot of time right that they have to kind of Shuffle and get to one end to the other

068so the use of cell phones during that time I don't think is critical or important I really don't see the value there personally I would love to see it gone during that time they should just be getting to class if if we had to give a little during lunch I guess they could connect but then it's everyone on their cell phones and no one is talking to each other during lunch so that's kind of sad to see so that's my I don't yeah so if we can I'd say a little stricter and remove it just all together and just free during lunch I'm okay with but during the hallway they should just be getting to class Mr rivel yeah I have I have a few comments first of all I applaud the presentation you f

069have worked hard over the last several years I've seen you get a little bit better moving the needle with accountability of students behavior each and every year I was pleased to see you have tal and spal involved with this thing there was a piece over the years that you folks used to report on was a percent of parents has signed off on the code of conduct how are we doing with that are we still moving the needle with getting more parents to accept the responsibility of signing off so we would get that information from the folks Focus team and we can get that for you and I can provide that to superintendent Carlin for you yeah we're going to be doing a lot of parent parent meetings in the community so that' be good to

070have that number one other thing I don't know how many folks were on social news shows on Sunday but there was a great show that was on Sunday morning and there was a professor by name a Jonathan ha who's written a book The anxious Society it's a 400 page book I spent a lot L of time doing the cliffnote version I didn't go through all 400 pages but I did go through the book if you have any concerns about cell phone usage in the schools refer to his book when you're done with those 400 Pages you know we don't need to have cell phones in schools it affects the lack of social behavior students don't know how to interact with each other they can't have a conversation they were talking about several schools I went

071in to that were restricted at lunchtime and they couldn't believe the difference in noise that happened because folks actually were talking to each other rather sitting there and staring on their phone but Dr Hoy H HT the anic society look it up you'll be convinced to support our code of conduct here in Lee County thank you any other comments Mr fiser then Miss Jordan thank you thank you for this presentation I appreciate it I'm I'm a bit torn on this I know well most of this board I should say we talked about actually implementing essentially what the elementary and middle school essentially the total ban a couple months ago I know we were possibly considering amending at that I get and I've mentioned this with during our meeting I understand you know part of it

072obviously is making sure obviously enforcement I mean High School principles have so much in their plate I'm very torn I know a couple of us have some high school students up on this dis and unfortunately those phone what they can be used for including I mean you know even you know filming you know fights and stuff like that I mean that's a consistent issue so at the moment I'm not on board going forward but I'm still open on that at least with that I would be more in favor of going to Elementary Middle School model forgive the High School principles I know it's a lot but at least looking at it right now we actually fsba some of us were at a panel that had students talking and I think was it maybe County there

073was a student from there that actually talked about you know that they weren't in favor of the ban they talked about it went through it and then actually after they adapted to it they were good with it they didn't even question anymore that point so I know it'd be a big move on that part but the other part of it comes down to obviously and we've had this discussion with Dr Carlin is you know the changes throughout the code of conduct are great I appreciate it but it comes down to enforcement and equal level of enforcement with schools and I know that's that's an issue I know that you've been addressing so but that's where I at at the moment thank you m Jordan I think everybody pretty much has spoken about it but the

074hallways for sure I see no sense in that for what M shanu just spoke about because first of all they need to be paying attention to where they're going not looking at a phone that drives me nuts and then to the earbuds how in the world would you even know if it's on or off so they should never be in their ears I mean you need them to be focused and yeah I'm iffy on the other as well and I have plenty of grandkids out there that are probably really mad that I'm saying that but I just they're there to learn so thank you Miss ganelli so I'm excited to hear what my other fellow colleagues think of this I had a great discussion with Dr Bradley and their team regarding this and I actually

075agree with you that's more of a distraction in the hallway and they probably shouldn't have them in the hallways at all I mean or out of their out of their book bag at that point because I think once it's out it's a distraction and then they're going to be late to class or they'll have an excuse I mean and they won't say their phones are excuse but because that'll be at that point in time it'll be probably put back in their book bag but I think you have all made great points that I think that we really are concerned because I watched the Vero started this year and I we talked about this Vero started with no cell phones and the and the kids testified that they didn't miss it they didn't mind it in

076fact they enjoyed the conversation at lunch and I saw a whole different they did a whole video on it because I don't believe it was news I believe it was on their it was something that come up on my Facebook news feed or feed and the students didn't mind it so I would think that's a sampling of really how kids will take it and embrace it versus really complain because I think it we have to get back to relationships and I think that's what's happening with the phones are interfering with relationships we don't have them including respect because how do you respect a phone that you can control and that's really their conversation and that's where their relationship is with the phone so not the people thank you any other comments I just have a

077few if you go back back to slide nine it discussed the data there it is so if you go to quarter one and it says Electronics to tell a Communications at 874 in subordinate report so far and then in the footnotes it talks about the fact this data doesn't include hallways cafeterias PE and recess so that's very alarming to me that it's the projection is 3500 and that doesn't even include the areas that we're discussing that we may or may not let them use their cell phones I think that's really quite High I have three kids myself one of a high one high schooler and the biggest problem is the inconsistency not with just in the with from school to school but class to class some teachers let them some teachers don't not sure why

078they're letting them if it's part of their own conduct in their school you know that the teacher should comply to to me that's also I guess I'm going to look at this as a team oriented view but if I've got teacher down the hallway peer teacher of mine down the hallway and these are these are kids terms okay so forgive me for not being as more professional here but we've got the cool teacher down the hallway that lets them use their phone anytime but we've got the teacher that's truly trying to stick to curriculum and it's and the kids behave for one differently than they behave for the other especially at the high school level I mean I've seen it for myself if you haven't had the opportunity board members to take a visit through

079a high school and ask to see a bill change that will be eye opening at a high school just ask to see what looks like when that Bell Rings students walking with headphones heads down on their phone because it is happening at several of our schools it like I said it's eye opening I support Bell to Bell K through 12 I've I'm very familiar with the bishop vau and some other private school processes and policies that they have in place and it has provided nothing but positive results and the kids they do appreciate the actual opportunity to have conversation I think that when unfortunately when we went through Co and went through you know a lot of online learning relationships were Stripped Away from kids 5 years old four years old old 15 years old

08018 years old that were supposed to graduate that year and I and I think that we really need to try to start separating ourselves from what happened in 2020 but the two schools this is interesting to me on the slide that you said 13 out of 15 schools yeah slide 16 at the high school level 13 of 15 schools would prefer the phones off during academic time I'm I'm just curious what what were the other two schools in favor of bell to Bell or anything goes well we do have one school currently who does not allow Bell tobell the other one was more just academic time but we have one high school right now that for the past three years has not allowed phones Bell to Bell and I would love to see that data

081that school compared to our other schools how are they doing and like right like we said Safety First Student achievement second so I'd love to see that pulled from that school in a one-on-one you could bring that up that'd be great but I appreciate the presentation I know a lot of hard work has gone into this as a as a parent who has very little time the fact that you've condensed in alone has helped so many families get through this and I know that they can look it up so much easier on the website you type in a keyword and it and it pops up so I appreciate the effort of the entire team going through this and making it more user friendly but that's all the comments I have are there any other follow-up

082comments or questions Mr persons and then attorney dupay I just want to say the one thing I've gotten from parents is what if there's an emergency well the students are allowed to have their phone in their backpack it just has to be off so if there was an emergency I'm sure there's not one teacher is going to say oh you can't use your phone you know I mean if there's something along those lines like we all worry about and the other one they said was well if it's often I need to get a hold of them how can I get a hold of them you call the office like they did for years forever and they'll send someone down to get your child or get a message to them and the last thing I get

083told a lot when I brought this up two years ago is the buses you know have a tracking system but the phone is actually a better tracking system so a lot of the kids turn their phones on when they're in the bus and the parents knows exactly where the bus is at that particular time so it's I just want to point out we're not saying they can't bring a phone to school you know CU some schools around the state they put it in a bag at the beginning of the day or whatever or in every classroom and they really go way out we haven't gone that far at all we're just saying please have it off and I agree with the majority of this board I think Bell to Bell and all the schools is

084where maybe we're out here but what I've heard thank you I think that's it for this topic oh I'm sorry attorney J bro thank you just for clarification too because Mr person's mentioned that it's the law now so I just wanted to put it on the record what law he was referencing which is Florida statute 1 0 6.07 subsection 2 which discusses the code of conduct it makes it very explicit that you cannot have a cell phone during instructional time and that the teachers are supposed to actually put it someplace so that the students are not able to use it so that's just for clarification thank you very much and first of all again just thank you for the conversation today one of the reasons we bring items to you especially important items like this

085is to hear how you feel relative to this topic and like we said at the top of the presentation the team did a great job getting stakeholder feedback but very important to hear your feedback so when we come back to you with a recommendation we are hearing the general feeling of our board members and I've been taking copious notes over here in terms of some of your questions as well as your comments and we will take that back to our cabinet to our team and have that final com conversation before we bring something back to you Mr Ribble you asked a question about the code of conduct being acknowledged I do have that information 72% in Focus have acknowledged the code of conduct and so that is obviously something we continue to work on so

086thank you again for the conversation thank you want to we can continue to adult code of conduct okay so for the adult Cod there are no significant changes this year there is one change where they included tobacco and vaping and some consequences for that starting with a warning but there other changes all pertain to their logo updating board members any errors they may find any spacing things like that so when there is any legislative so last year when we had the unauthorized restroom that was something that impacted our code it also impacted their code but for this year they only have really ex with the exception of adding the tobacco and vaping all of the other changes are more updates or typographical for the adult code the one thing I will say is that when

087you see this again next month because we'll see you again in February and then the final the final approval will be in March when you see their code next month in for adult code you will also see it in Spanish and creole that was requ EST from previous board and we have made a point this year to have those available after we get your feedback at this one and we put them in the red line to have that available in all three languages all right thank you any comments Miss Jordan I just and it's going back and I apologize the infractions because I know Miss FL had spoke about that it's the one where the infraction is the disrespect in subordination and I know a lot of the conversation came to be because of the

088fact of what is it understood how how are they understanding it are they really being disrespectful are they really being insubordinate so I really appreciate that you have are going to separate that because of a lot of times language barrier does create that of what they believe that they're being disrespectful when they're really not understanding what the heck's going on so thank you for that thank you this way all right thank you thank you all right as they are exiting we're going to go ahead and move on with next thing on the agenda which is our policy review presenting our policy review today is attorney Kathy dupe Bruno and Benny broy for thank you good afternoon board we have three policies for the board's consideration today one of them is public participation at board meeting

08901691 and then 0175 which is the student disciplinary hearing and 0176 which is employee disciplinary hearings the two hearing ings the changes are very minor but they are significant to ensure that there is as much due process as we possibly can give for the student as well as the staff when charges are brought forward and discipline is a potentiality so instead of having the parent or the employee State their case or explain why the discipline is not appropriate and then have the District then move forward with their allegations we are asking that it be flipped around so that the district can State their case first and then the parent or the employee has an opportunity to respond any questions or concerns about those two policies okay and then the next policy is 01691 as the

090board is aware there's been a significant change due to a case that came out in October 2024 moms for Liberty versus Bard County in which the 11 circuit made some rulings as to solidifying and increasing if you will some of the First Amendment rights to include the ability for members of the public to Levy attacks if you will or personal attacks is what they've called them in the in the case the reason for that is to ensure that there is not Viewpoint discrimination when people come to speak the board is responsible to the public the public has the right to say positive things as well as negative things and the 11th circuit reiterated that so we have removed personal attacks from the policy and we have also defined a little bit more in terms of

091what abusive languages and that's also coming from the case wherein that particular District did not have that definition so we've now added that definition into our policy to ensure that the public is aware of what we consider to be abusive language and we also of course state that prior to public comment as well any questions from the board or concerns on those and that policy all right Madam Vice chair do we have the ability now to move this forward to Second reading board can I get a thumbs up if you all are ready to move on to seconds thank you very much looks like you have that thank you next on the agenda is a presentation by Lori Brooks regarding Mental Health okay okay good good afternoon and thank you for the opportunity to present

092on school mental health Dr Duncan and I will share our presentation with you and first I would like to recognize the school counseling and Mental Health Services team because they work very diligently on mental health along with our larger student services team and that would be if you could wave maryn Rodriguez Sher welzel and Meredith Barry today's presentation will begin with the development of school-based Mental Health Services which really began in 2018 in the State of Florida will then Define comprehensive School mental health services offered under Florida statute and then we'll conclude with the future expansion of services this graphic really represents the Continuum since July 2018 of school-based mental health school-based Mental Health Services in Florida as you well know began with Senate bill 7026 which was the legislative result to address or in

093response to the tragic shooting on February 14th 2018 at margerie Stoneman Douglas High School Senate Bill 7026 defined new school safety and school-based mental health initiatives so it really was that game-changing piece of legislation that married together school safety measures and also how are the children what are we doing to address their mental and emotional Wellness as well as the interventions for those with indicated need it set forth a recurring allocation under the general Appropriations act for mental health and schools based on unweighted FTE and it established the requirement that districts must submit a board approved mental health assistance allocation plan annually on August 1st of each year and Report outcomes for mental health on September 30th of each year to the Department of Education so as you can see when you review this graphic

094we started with Senate bill 7026 and throughout the years there have been some fine-tuning measures and then also future and continued buildout of services so the first bill 702 really addressed school safety and Mental Health Services then Senate Bill 7030 added additional layers and requirements and to to those requirements in September of 2019 the State Board of Education passed required instruction so you can see they're starting to tear in how are we educating children about what is Wellness how to identify resiliency skills and how be resilient and cope with the stressors that life can hand us and then we look at 2019 and also 20122 where we have worldwide stressors of a covid pandemic and then we have a local pretty intensive stressor of Hurrican and we are now in our seventh year of mental

095health services and as we frequently discuss as a team where would we be now if we did not have this legislation and accompanying funding since 2018 because prior to 2018 we had support for students we lacked mental health so this timeline really encompasses a lot of those initiatives and how the Department of Education and our state legislature has built out supports for children I don't want to overlook July 2021 with Senate Bell 5 590 which also codified a lot of best practices districts including ours were following when working with students with suicidal ideation and they put them into the law however so we know we need to follow them and continue to work on that process and how we handle that so the district mental health plan as I mentioned was one of the main

096requirements of 7026 and there are three components to each District's Mental Health Plan by legislation the plan must support students and all of the funding must be pushed into mental health and so we align and expand our school based Mental Health Services we have Master's degreed and very talented school counselors School social workers School psychologists and licensed mental health professionals in our schools this pulls all of those professionals together into a teaming mode and then also we're called to contract with our partnering agencies such as salus care and other Community Partners to increase access for students and families to school-based mental health during the day and then also connecting them to outside Services if necessary or desired by the families and then also training teachers and staff which now we also have required instruction for

097students because we know our eyes and ears are our teachers and our staff in the schools and without them having the training on what is Wellness what is a concern what does that look like and then where to go with that information we would be unable to engage our students in these Services to the extent that we have been able to do so comprehensive School mental health is a broad spectrum from prevention and assessment through intervention and at times postvention for example we provide District Crisis Support for mental Health when we have squatting incidents when we have the loss of a staff member or a student all the way through any other school-based incident that could create or natural disaster that could create exposure to trauma it's the comprehensive mental health is essential to our

098school's ability to ensure safe and healthy learning environments support students academic success and also identify and respond appropriately to mental health challenges and we dove with a community-based service coordinated system of care we are called not just to be a school district we are actually charged with engaging in our community-based partners our parents are the most important Partners along with our students and create that system of care approach we also practice evidence-based practices and while we have always done this as a school district it was nice to also see this embedded into the requirements in State Statute to ensure that districts are following we're not spraying and praying and hoping it works we need to absolutely operate in tear of support we need to conduct needs assessments and then re map our resources to where

099those they're needed we engage an interdisciplinary team what I would call collecting and connecting the dots of a student's you know the kind of the fabric of their life at school and outside of school and we collect data analyze and report it and then of course we adapt what we're doing based on that data we engage in evidence-based treatments and then we are called to diversify our funding and consistently grow our Partnerships so when we look at the system of supports we can see at this triangle that there are some things that all students get so all schools we want them to be creating a culture where students are building their resiliency where they have a positive outlook and where they also feel comfortable accessing supports here's where they can access bullying prevention they can

100build their social skills and this is where we talk about PBIS at this level where everybody gets it at the next level this is where some students will get supports and this is where we're connecting some students with Community Resources there might be a checkin and check out where we see the student in the morning and then again at the end of the day but they may be doing their own thing for the majority of the day successfully it's targeted in sort of a small group approach and then you get to the top of the triangle and we have a few students who fall the top of the triangle and this is where the more coordinated supports are where they have the more individualized services where they may be meeting with a mental health professional

101getting Crisis Prevention Services or crisis intervention services and also accessing the community- based mental health supports in our schools we have school mental health teams and this team is made up of a variety of very valuable professionals and school-based staff the team meets weekly they employ a fact-based problem solving model so they'll review the existing supports that a student is receiving and they'll also look at any potential new students who may need supports and they'll look at that data and observe behaviors to say what are the student needs are we meeting the student needs or do we need to adjust the supports that student is receiving and that mental health team is made up of the school counselor the school social worker the school psychologist a licensed mental health professional and those acronyms you see

102at the end are potential lur where it could be a licensed mental health clinician a licensed clinical social worker a licensed family therapist so they're they're different things but all these individuals are licensed and then the school nurse and then input is also provided by an extremely valuable provided by the parent Guardian the student teachers administrators any community service providers that the student is working with if the student is served in ese or is getting esol supports anybody who can speak to those supports and then again anybody else who might be an important part of that student's world those mental health Team meetings also with parental consent could involve an outside Service Agency or agencies so that's something I did not put on the slide but whenever a student's involved in outside Services especially intensive

103mental health as long as the parent has signed consent for that individual to be present to discuss that student they also participate in those team meetings just related to that student so in 2018 districts had to move quickly legislation passed it went into effect July 1st and districts honestly we were scrambling to implement school-based mental health and we made it happen and we made it work however as we exited the 189 school year and we meet as state directors of mental health districts were grappling with we needed an additional position and many moved to the licensed mental health professional position as an additional member of the scho based mental health Team and Lee County also moved in that direction so now we have licensed mental health professionals in addition to our school counselors social workers

104psychologists and School nurses and their primary role is the supervision and quality assurance of mental health implementation we want to make sure that we are compliant with our statutory requirements and those timelines direct support of the Comprehensive Mental Health Services the lmhp we call them insur because you know we're all about acronyms and education the L mhps deliver the most intensive mental health interventions to students with indicated need and also they are an integral part of providing interventions as part of the school-based threat management team if a student that is a part of the threat management team needs intensive intervention they are the ones providing that of course with parental consent and then also offering evidence-based trainings to staff staff parents and students we have a little laundry list of additional lmhp functions here but

105I'll jump to Staffing currently we staff 57 lmhp positions from the mental health assistance allocation our growth in that position is based on three pieces of information one our data we look at the number of mental health needs and the Acuity of those needs at each of our schools we also obtain our school leaders feedback and school mental health team members feedback regarding their needs and how well they're able to meet those needs and then also it's based of course on the annual mental health assistance allocation increases because without that funding we would not be adding positions and of course the indicated need needs to be there to add any additional positions so we've grown each year now we're going to shift to really talk about what do we do to assist students that may

106be in crisis mode so students who exhibit signs or verbalizations of suicide ideation so the district we followed best practices and then I mentioned Senate Bill 590 which went into effect and we actually we applaud that legislation because it codified as I mentioned earlier the requirements Statewide for districts to follow so when a student of concern is brought to a mental health Team Member they are required to delivery deliver a Department of Education approved suicide risk assessment there are two of them this District does the we use the Colombia suicide severity rating scale or what we call the Colombia in short it's administered by a school-based mental health professional and also we are required to be trained in and engage in verbal deescalation while we're ALS o talking to the student this is an open-ended

107conversation it's not a checklist where we just coldly ask students questions it's a conversation and also verbal deescalation the required level of response is based on the assessment results and so if we have a student who has has a little bit of they might be thinking I don't want to wake up tomorrow but they have no means no plan and these levels are indicated on this evidence-based instrument we have levels of response the levels of response always will include the parent and I will tell you full disclosure we have had to make significant progress on how we implement this protocol and you'll see in our numbers that we're working diligently on reducing the number of students placed under a baker act so we involve parents we are required to make a reasonable attempt to notify

108parent guardian of a minor student a reasonable attempt means that we are required to try phone text email the parent and also an emergency contact so that we can at at some point we have got to get in touch with that parent or guardian and we have to document we're required to document and report to the Department of Education the time of each the time of each contact the method and the outcome until we achieve contact with someone now if we reach out to to an emergency contact we are unable to share details with them but we are charged with letting the emergency contact know can you please get in touch with the parent of this child we absolutely must speak with them immediately so we are also required to make a reasonable attempt schools

109are to contact a licensed mental health professional prior to the initi the initiation of an involuntary examination under the Baker Act and we are required to enter each of these if we have a Baker Act we're required to enter this into the state Reporting System the state Reporting System allows no field to be unfilled so as you can see there is a level of oversight from the Department of Education where we are required to follow this protocol and be specific about it and also if we cannot leave something blank we have to explain what we did so I'd like to talk through through some of our data I have data from 22 23 23 24 and thus far this school year through December 6th what you'll notice in this data is the number of Baker

110acts in column one and then the number of students placed under a Baker Act in the second column the difference in those numbers is the fact that we have some students that are high Acuity students that have multiple agencies involved in their world and they may have an involuntary examination under a baker act at school more than once so that's why you'll see the higher number in the First Column when you look at the number of Baker acts administered by the mobile crisis response team and I'll cover the team in just a minute this is that clinical team that has to really engage in additional verbal deescalation we want the parent or Guardian to be present to be part of that process unless there's a suspicion of abuse and then we're required to document that

111we had to call DCF and then also they engage sometimes this takes up to two hours for this clinical team to work with the student the parent Guardian to identify protective factors to really feel comfortable that child will be safe being released to go home rather than being involuntarily hospitalized when the mobile crisis team is unable to report the next person charged in statute is our school resource officer with making that assessment and so you'll notice that our number of Baker acts initiated by mobile crisis and the number initiated by the school resource officers in each row will total the total number of Baker acts because those are the only two ways that an individual can be placed under a Baker Act while at school medical doctors can also do this as you probably well

112know we don't have those at our schools so that's why we have these divided out now you may wonder if we're doing mental health and we're doing it well why in 2324 did our number of involuntary examinations go up from 129 to 163 and what we see is anytime we have a stressor and you've probably heard this related to co all over national news media Outlets just as we see the decline in academic performance but it takes a year or two for that to really reveal itself we see Mental Health crisis in a delayed reaction after things like covid but this was the response to Hurricane Ian so after Hurricane Ian we were pushing out all sorts of access to resources groups for students groups for teachers to process through parent supports and it they

113really are under utilized while people are putting one foot in front of the other just trying to survive daytoday and then all of a sudden we start to see that they're ready for that support and to access that support unfortunately there are times that we're unable to see that until we have a student in crisis so we continue to work on becoming better at early identification and so you'll notice in 2425 almost through the end of first semester we are running lower numbers on our involuntary examinations so I think this is twofold one we're trying to mitigate and working through helping our students with their response to the hurricane and also some carryovers from the pandemic but second we're getting better at making sure we're able to support our students and when the mobile crisis

114team comes and I'll move on to the slides that describe this team their entire is deescalation and connection to Services The Last Resort for the mobile crisis team being a clinical assessment team is to place someone involuntarily into Salis care or another local facility so the mobile crisis response team is our circuit 20 mobile crisis response team it's through the center for progress and Excellence we have a very robust partnership ship with them they have added teams to serve our schools during the school day with additional grant funding and part of State Statute is that school districts partner with their mobile crisis team so when we deliver the Columbia suicide severity rating scale and it indicates that we have a level of ideation that warrants clinical assessment we're calling the parent guardian and we're also

115asking the mobile crisis team to come to the school so that all of them can get together and engage in deescalation the team can and further clinical assessment again their goal is to reduce the number in of involuntary examinations through active Crisis Intervention techniques if they're successful at deescalate a student their next step is connecting the parent to services and followup mental health and then we also support them at school in the spring and I'll I'll take you back to the number of Baker acts on slide 13 from the mobile crisis team and then from the sro's we have identified and been building out our own team for the past three years and because we now are almost fully staffed with our 57 LM HPS by Spring of this year we should be ready to

116deploy our district care team that's our crisis assessment response and Education team that's our own mobile crisis team we will still engage circuit 20 but if they are unavailable our next resource was our school resource officer now our next resource will be our own mobile crisis team in the district of licensed professionals our school resource officers want to invite mobile crisis in they welcome this next layer of clinical assessment as well because their least their least favorite part of their job is when they have to make this assessment and so each region will have a dedicated care team ready to deploy and so if circuit 20 is unable to come to the school then our own team will come to the school and then we'll move into Community Partnerships so in order to support students

117we know that the school district cannot do all of this alone we rely heavily on Community Partnerships and the student services team specifically in this case the mental health Team Works diligently to maintain those Partnerships so you can see here they are closely involved with seven U several different areas Lee Health sales care we have several members of our team who actually volunteer with these organizations so this just isn't anou and paper this is actual working daytoday collaboration and that is a critical component of student success building resiliency is first lady desantis's initiative and when the State Board of Education passed their required instruction rules in 2019 this became the state graphic and this really does encompass staff training and also the mental health assistance allocation it's all of the pieces that pull together for

118our students and then this particular part of that this component is how do we really help students understand that they have coping skills we can develop coping skills so that when life stressors touch their life they can identify previously through this instruction what might work for them yoga doesn't work for me it might work for Dr Duncan yoga makes me angry I don't like it she might love it but how do I know that I have coping strategies and what I like unless I've had education that makes me think about that so the resiliency building we call it Wellness Wednesdays in 2019 when this was developed we focus grouped it we did a lot of research with students teachers parents administrators and we've branded Wellness Wednesday as with anything else we need to revisit that

119periodically and we are at this time and we're really working through what could this look like and should it look like as we move forward one of of the pieces of Wellness Wednesday that I think is really valuable is we ask parents we give them a letter every month the week of Wellness Wednesday about the lesson topic we post the video on Le schools.net and we ask them to engage in conversation with their child around their learning because they are such an important part of this resiliency education and we would like to see that continue whatever this looks like as we move forward and again just to provide clarification on this that the wellness W Wednesday is required health instruction so while it may look differently and where you are reassessing we do have to

120make sure that we meet the state requirements related to that instruction we also engage in parent awareness and education likely you've seen our monthly News letters that are released by our team here are just some screenshots we also have a school-based Mental Health Services flyer that schools will distribute to families that actually contains the names of their school mental health team members and contact information and we also use it at the district level so that families understand what they can have access to should they choose school-based Mental Health Services and then excuse me our mental health and wellness portal is live on our school web our school district website for parents and the community if they're even if they're up at 2: a.m. and they'd like to click on some resources ources they have access

121to this so on this slide this just highlights some of the work that's in progress we currently are in conversations with University of South Florida on a couple of projects one of the projects is Midas and this is with the early identification and screening of students who may have some mental health needs this mental health Team are working very closely with our school psychology department on this as they may very involved with this component in terms of using a screener and producing a risk ratio to say what needs a student might have like how significant or severe the students needs are at this time so that's just one of the things in the works right now and then another project through USF is the smarts project for school mental health assessment response and training for

122suicide prevention this would Target up to 10 middle schools and it provides USF provides staff training in suicide awareness and intervention evidence-based interventions even at the mental health level and care coordination and it really provides a pathway for schools to become a Department of Education Suicide Prevention certified school which we have a great interest in providing a pathway for our schools to become certified in suicide prevention which means their staff has been trained in suicide prevention training evidence based and also how to connect students to that support that might be expressing concerning statements or behavior so those are potential expansions that we are in discussions with USF regarding now and that will lead us to superintendent comments and board discussion well thank you Dr Duncan and always Miss Brooks I know that this is an

123area of passion for you certainly and just really appreciate your knowledge and expertise to our board members I know that this was a presentation that has been requested quite a while ago and so we're very honored to be able to bring that to you today just want to thank our team for everything that they do and I'm talking about our team not just here at the district office but most especially in our schools for the work they do each and every day with our students you know obviously our mission is to educate students but we also take their behavioral and their mental Health very seriously and so we turn it over to you now for your discussion board members comments or questions Mr fiser thank you madam chair thank you Miss Brooks and Dr Duncan

124and Dr Carlin and Dr Savage as well I requested this a few superintendents ago so I really appreciate that we're now able to discuss this is a vital vital topic especially coming off the recent hurricanes especially the things we've seen in the schools first off thank you for addressing Wellness Wednesdays I look forward to seeing some of the information feedback on that I know a lot of us receive a lot of inperson feedback on some of those so I appreciate that regarding couple things and I kind of asked you this both last time what can we as a board as a district what can we do better to help out you know resource wise I mean I know legislatively we're asking for mental health allocation I mean I know that you know as the Esther

125fund have run out there's you know obviously some changes and transitions with that you know funding and positions but what can we do as a board in a district to to help out and make sure that it the services are still being you know service provided but help increase the level of services to our students I think the first part that we really appreciate is your willingness to just meet with our team and listen to the work that's done and listen to the concerns questions wins successes out in the school and bring those to us anytime we do that and we work collaboratively as a team that's a win for us because our team is diligent they are they will put in 110% but they aren't a large team and with a district this large

126with all of us doing that's going to be helpful you mentioned with Esser funds Miss Brooks talked about the increase in the mental health allocation so that's helped to alleviate some of that but we're always looking at different ways to use resources differently I think you also pointed out with Wellness Wednesday just the information that is feedback that you do get out that our students and staff do understand that is required instruction so while we want that feedback on the best way to provide that and ensure we meet that compliance that we do it in a way that also works for them so that's also something I think as board members that would be helpful thank you again for asking that question and for the opportunity to present I would also I think we're where

127are we struggle is also qualified staff and I don't know that's something the board might be able to fix I think we struggle with this across the state we have a shortage of school counselors we have a shortage of school psychologists those are the two really critical areas and I just I mentioned that just so that it's within your context as we're trying to encourage individuals to pursue that specialized training through the Masters and EDS programs and we appreciate the board's support tremendously for our students one more thing Madam chair if that's all right go ahead thank you and also getting back to parental awareness and you guys put a lot of stuff out and I'm kind of you know unfortunately sometimes like you guys had mentioned you know things are not seen until it's

128too far far down the road and you know parents not necessarily being aware of the services even so you put a lot out I'm wondering just throwing this out here for the board and the superintendent maybe look at some kind of mental health campaign or a PSA from a district level maybe to help increase that awareness so but that's all I had thank you any other comments board members Mr persons the Miss Jordan we have currently have 57 licensed mental health professionals for 100,000 or so kids how does that compare to other districts proportionally wise I do you know that or I mean are we way below what other districts are I'm sure it's not enough but we're where where do we sort of fall along those lines the districts are using their mental health

129assistance allocation to staff as many as they can mostly they're using their allocation specific to that and their school counselors social workers psychologists and nurses are under District budget and so yeah I always look at this as a team approach too because an lmhp is unable to deal deal with the most intensive need students if a school doesn't have a school counselor or if they're missing a team member then all of that unmet need will kind of roll up to that top of the triangle where an lmhp is trying to work with a lot more students so my answer is simple in the fact that they're funding these positions through their allocations so whatever their allocation is they generally are spending it on that and then the other piece to that though is out of

130District budget the psychologist social workers nurses and school counselors State Statute also says that districts are charged with trying to continue to expand those positions as much as they can through their budgetary means and so I think it's really beyond the allocation all of the team members too so I think we're comparable as far as how we spend our allocation I know we are and then it's partnered with but where are we also with those partnership dollars with the other team members to make sure all tiers of mental health are able to be adequately served at the appropriate tier Jordan I Believe You're Next well this is something that I know you know it's de near to my heart and when I'm looking at this and thank you so much for explaining reasonable because when

131I read that I was like wait a second yeah what are we going through that again and of course in our Board of policy it states what that yes exactly is so I had to go back to look to make sure that we had that in there because that to me is really important that it doesn't just say reasonable that we are doing everything in our power to make sure that we contact that person and when I was looking at the trained teachers and staff on page four is that mandatory or optional it's the foundational training is youth Mental Health First Aid training that is required sorry that is required by job code per the Department of Education and so employees that are in I think there's over 100 job codes on that list are

132required to be trained okay and then of course that is the foundation and our dream world is we're training everybody but the funding is supportive of training the required staff which is a lot of Staff it's everyone from teachers to bus operators to our Food Service workers there's there's a lot of individuals on that list based on job code great and then also the license professionals I know we just said we had 57 so when these when we're having the meetings the school mental health teams meetings they meetings weekly yes how are we putting all those people together when we don't have the people so how are we having these meetings when they don't exist are we pulling them from other schools how does that so our school counselors as you're aware are hired by

133and staffed at their schools so they're there five days a week we do have some schools that have not been able to find a school counselor but ideally they have them and then our school social workers psychologist nurses and licensed mental health professionals they're itinerant so we have 57 L mhps but they cover all of our schools so they have days at each school now each of our high schools has a full-time lmhp our K8 schools have a full-time lmhp and our elementary and midds get about two two and a half days each it's dependent on needs so we don't blanket a sign we really look at the needs and the Acuity at each school but we try to get all of our itinerant and the school counselor in that building on that one meeting

134day a week and if we're unable to they join via like teams or Zoom they tell what do you call that not tella Health when we virtual they do it virtually and so they required they're required to meet but they may not all be in the building on that meeting day okay and then I'm really glad that we're finally going to get our own team that assessment team because the fact that we know even though it says that they're available 247 that does not happen so a lot of times you have we don't have the full team there making decisions or there's no deescalation it's just it's given to the SRO who has no choice but to therefore send a child somewhere and I guess I'm curious because when we're looking at the number 24

135how did we get to that 24 with the sro's what happened in that case where the 24 had to go to them which then they would automatically send over to somewhere regardless if it had if there was dis deescalation or anything they automatically have to send them so two conditions have to be met well two different conditions one if a child is in imminent danger putting themselves or others an imminent danger and remember to I did not mention this but from previous presentations the principal in Senate Bill 590 it puts the principle of the school it gives them really a better authority to control when does the SRO get involved as far as if I'm a nmhp I'm working with a student who may be suicidal the mobile crisis team let's say I'm a school

136counselor the mobile crisis team cannot report I cannot go get an SRO I need to brief my Administration and let them know the situation and they determine if we're going to in include the SRO in that which we really need to because they're the next person that can vet that right so it's imminent danger that needs to be mitigated in that moment and then it's also if the mobile crisis team from circuit 20 is unable to get to the school and we did add in though if the child is going to after school program in elementary school we can wait for them to arrive that's the other piece if the student even though it's the end of the day we let them know this child is in after care parent is on the way we'll

137wait for you and mobile crisis team will will report as as soon as they can but if they're unable to report to the school in an hour or so then the principal will need to get the student resource officer involved so those are the two reasons we get to the 24 what will have and I think with the 24 you're mentioning thus far the baker acts by SRO this year what we'll have next is they'll call our dispatch if mobile crisis for circuit 20 cannot get there they'll call our dispatch and we will deploy the Regional team to the school and that will then be that next layer of clinical assessment and I trust me I so appreciate everything that you all have done the team all of you it's just the fact that I

138just want to make sure that we are always making sure that it's consistent and we are doing all of this that the principles are engaged because there has been times when that did not happen and the SRO was there and then it went right the other way and I guess I'm wondering too have we ever and this will be my last question have we ever had a report on those that we that have been sent by SRO or by us come back to say why did we send this child there because it really there was no need to because we know once they're there they're there for five days by by law so I would be curious on that's an excellent question I do not have that data once the child is at the receiving

139facility it's covered under Hippa so unless the parent releases it to us we're unable to collect that data and then speaking seven years into mental health and really since 20 1 2021 with Senate Bill 590 as everyone's getting used to new protocols and then they really have them more memorized the process document just like the board policy is multiple pages long because we want to spell everything out we see with greater success our schools understanding and unpacking those situations in alignment and I think too that's why even though our numbers went up in 23 24 but you do look at 85 Baker acts by mobile crisis and 78 by sro's I can't predict if 78 would go down if we had a secondary team but I can tell you 85 is a significant number from

140a clinical team you know that we did see that spike it was more in alignment with student need and so that need is we're mitigating those needs but also we all have a much deeper and more comfortable understanding even here compared to pulling out the process of what we are required to do thank you Miss Shavano and then miss tanelli one thank you for this and I know we had a lot of conversation when I met with you guys prior I just wanted additional information on slide 20 where it's the potential expansion with USF for the suicide prevention certified school what that criteria is and those steps that are required for that to happen either Financial Training what that looks like for that to happen yes and I'm happy to send it in writing to

141Dr Carlin to release in short is that School staff need to be trained in in addition to youth Mental Health First Aid training they need to be specifically trained in evidence-based suicide prevention training and so it's an additional training that goes deeper youth Mental Health First Aid does talk about how do I how do I address a an individual in this case students but really anyone how do I find out are you really suicidal and then this training goes deeper and so the school staff would need to be trained and then it's an annual certification with thresholds that you need to continue to meet with your new staff that you maintain that training and I can get you the whole the list of of what's required it's three or four things and then we can

142be a suicide prevention certified School District but 100% of our schools need to be certified schools perfect Miss janelli and I'll piggy back off the training do we give training to any of our guest teachers and especially Our Guest teachers that are in in our schools weekly I mean they're habitual they're constantly working in our schools and do they get that opportunity to have that training as well with youth Mental Health First a training or suicide the reason I'm I'm hesitating is Chief nulan has been doing the youth Mental Health First Aid training oversight so the last few years and I'm not quite sure if guest teachers are on the list I do not believe they are we can verify and get that to Dr Carlin and so there's a pay component involved that would

143you know there's a fiscal challenge with that certainly we'd be happy to offer training to Our Guest teachers there's just there's usually a pay component that needs to be involved it's a six-hour training so it's just something to to we could talk through well and I'm just curious because I mean I think for people that are there to be trained in the awareness and to identify these these issues they're we have a lot of guest teachers now that work in schools they're at different schools but they're they're working five days a week I mean and I know several of them so I mean I think that opportunity somehow I mean we you were talking about 100% And getting you know everybody being certified well that would be like that's Kudos if that could happen my

144opinion on on the having that knowledge so that was just curious because that was one of the things that a question that was asked that triggered that for me but one of the other questions is the West W Wednesdays I'll be honest with you I get a lot of complaints from students they think is worthless so what what is the impact what what is the what what are the evidence what are we seeing that this is effective so I will state that at our state meetings districts are grappling with the most effective way to push instruction into classrooms it's a struggle and that's why we're revisiting how to do this especially years in now what's the best path forward we have had anecdotals from students I mean we have data of the teachers that are

145showing the videos and engaging the students I only have anecdotal student stories one which was on the news that I included in one of the board updates where the student credited Wellness Wednesday with saving her life because she knew who to talk to when she was suicidal the data that we have really because we pushed this out districts push this out not through a health class it's it's required instruction that needs to fit somewhere is really did the teachers engage in the instruction so that is part of our discussion is how do we know the return on investment student by student and so that is part of our discussion now and trying to figure out the way forward so that we can also measure that thank you I just know the kids some they' they

146say oh it's just a waste or you know that can we do something else and I they made recommendations so I don't know how we keep them engaged but I just know there's a there's somewhat of an issue so I wanted to bring that up the other thing is regarding the mental health teams so I want to make sure that I'm understanding because it sound like it sounds like there's a team in every school but but really there's really they're multi Schools they're these are teams that are mul instead of multitasking they're multich schooling I mean right I mean they're having to go to these there's these teams that go to different schools could you can you ver can explain that a little bit sure so the school mental health team is each school has

147their own team every school has their school counselor school counselors each school has a social worker assigned to just those schools same with the psychologist nurse lmhp so they're for that school like Cape cor high school for example they have their social worker their lmhp their school psychologist is theirs they're not there 5 days a week they're school nurse either they're their certain days a week but they team collectively they do a lot of communicating together but they the team meeting every week is really to make sure that we get everyone around the table from all those perspectives and talk about students for example when I was a counselor at Cape Coral high school Sher wsel was the social worker her office was one door down from me and we kind of called it driveby

148counseling because we'd catch each other in the hallway and I'd say hey I noticed so and so in your office is everything okay she would have context on my student about potential homelessness or becoming at risk for homelessness that I needed to know but this gets us all around the table at one time to talk about all those pieces so we have itinerant staff in answer to your question every school has their own itinerant in each area that they become a part of that school fabric so yes they are that school team they're not teams that travel around but the itinerant do have more than one school that they serve I thank you cuz I knew all those positions that you mentioned they weren't at each School filled in their full-time that they had to

149be traveling around so I I just wanted to make sure that people understand that because I because we're we're we are stretch thin so thank you yes any other comments Dr Carlin I would just like to respond to a couple of things most importantly the Staffing around this so you've heard me speak about teacher Recruitment and Retention this also encompasses other employee groups right so we are going to have discussions we are currently engaged in discussions at the cabinet level about how we effectively recruit and retain individuals certainly salary is always going to play a role there's no question about it when we talk with teachers when we talked with other team members however there's also the other parts that go with it working Traditions culture you know is it attractive to come to the

150school district when particularly in these areas they can hang a shingle you know they can hang up a sign and they can maybe double or triple what we're able to offer so we really want to be looking at different ways that we can recruit and retain and really what it goes to is yes salary but also working conditions and how do we make it attractive for people to come to the school district of Lee County so we have some ideas coming on off of a campaign you get lots of in information so I do have some ideas and we'll be talking more about that in the coming months at cabinet thank you all right I just have a few quick comments I applaud the results that you that you are seeing from from the actions

151that you're taking regarding Wellness Wednesday and I won't beat a drum but well yes we get quite a few complaints about it I will say that in our elementary Schools they're actually they actually enjoy Wellness Wednesday a little more than they do in maybe our secondary school so there is there is something working there but I think too maybe whenever you all are coming to the table about how to revise this plan I would encourage you to not just think of those High Flyers there are students that have high stress that aren't necessarily High Flyers and I'm sitting here thinking about my son and all of his friends and there's the amount of stress they're under as where do I go to college am I going to tech school I mean those are all things

152that can be con that can have conversation during Wellness Wednesdays when we're thinking about our secondary that can start as early as a as freshman year just how to deal with those stresses in life as they mature so I feel like that could be part of the conversations and that they're having on for wellness Wednesday I mean some of our students are having to figure out at a very young age how to juggle work in school that's a high stress which I think can be tackled in this Arena so that's just my own two cents about that I have a question though watching a Baker Act is it'll keep you up at night and I can't imagine how it feels as the parent when those situations are happening on weekend s holidays and summer breaks

153how is that communicated to the school I mean it's probably not required for the parents to are you getting a report or anything how how are we managing those things that are happening outside of school that families are dealing with I'm glad you asked that question we are we received reports from all of our law enforcement agencies and also our mobile crisis team circuit 20 for any outside of School in voluntary examinations under the Baker Act when we receive those we reach out to the school mental health Team for each of those children and they will call the parent and offer to follow up with a support plan at school connect them to additional Services the ones that we do not know about are students who are sent to the hospital to be medically cleared

154that's under Hippa and therefore our law enforcement Partners would not necessarily be transporting because an ambulance May or it may happen in the mental health counseling setting a private or in agency counseling that's under Hippa we would not know unless the parent self-disclosed or the student and then doctor's offices so if it's law enforcement involved we know if it's mobile crisis team through circuit 20 we know outside of that we encourage parents to share with us and sometimes students do and then there are times when we do find out through our law enforcement reports we'll reach out to the parent and they're not happy that we know we work hard to build relationships and to tell them we're just here to support you know and so I think that has become more accepted in the

155past seven years since 2018 and so we do have that communication and then we generally receive a positive response when we call the parent to develop a support plan at school when the child returns okay thank you and just a tagline off of something Mr fiser said earlier about a PSA or some sort of a campaign throughout the district I know that I mean that is so wonderful that these organizations are partnering with us but I'm certain there are more they just don't know that this is something that is a need so I would encourage you to you know reach out to fi and Community Co-op YMCA I mean multiple places so any other comments followup thank you so much for the hard work being put behind this I appreciate you and the team thank

156you very much you're welcome we're going to move on to proposed adjustment to school start times for 2526 school year our presenters are Dave Newland Dr Nathan Shaker and Jared McKinny McKinny this afternoon thank you for well good afternoon again board members superintendent Dr jise Carlin and School Board attorney Kathy depri Bruno we are here today to discuss a proposed safety start Initiative for the transportation department with a proposed new bus route tier system to start the 2025 2026 school year and before we begin the presentation again with me is Chief academic officer Nathan Shaker and transportation executive director Jared McKenna so why are we here what is the need for the change some of the things we hear what the main issues we hear from the public is feedback about our busting system or

157things as students get into school late in the morning morning getting picked up late at the end of the day at school which causes students to get home late this is a safety concern this creates a hardship for everyone the parents students and staff as a safety is a is a priority we don't want students waiting at the bus stop for an extended period of time a lot of times with both parents working it creates a hardship with delayed bus routes their child not being picked up on time and or getting home late parents usually have a very regimented schedule and any deviation can create a hardship or stress on the family so what if I told you today that we have a solution to this and that's why we're here then we would be

158happy so again the rationale for the change we want to enhance Safety and Security we want to improve student achievement we're respond to public feedback we want to increase operational efficiency and we also want to be fiscally responsible So currently the this is our tier system in the morning we're dropping off at 7:05 a.m. this high schools getting out at 1:35 and as you can see between TI 1 and two there's only a 25 minute deficit there that does not provide enough time in the afternoons between dismissal for dismissal time on the ramps and for our drivers actually drop students off and create make it to the next tier so with this time being so compressed right now we're setting our drivers are failiure at the beginning of the day every single day so what

159we're asking is to create create more time between the tiers which we'll get too but right now there's only an hour between tier 2 and three but we don't factor in the time for dismissal that it takes to get off the ramps from the buses so with that time being so compressed we're setting our drivers up for failure like I said late every single day and right now we started with the deficit of 67 drivers every morning that's before any absences take place and that's what why we're so late everywhere so that's why we're kind of coming to this tier system so our as mentioned before our current tier system the tiers are too compressed to pick up students and drop off students consistently also the current routes are in efficient due to Staffing time

160and constraints so with our new tier system this provides a safe or more consistent route and again it designs to support the improved academic achievement as well if you look at it again one of the things too I want to bring up too is the proximity that was put into place that was VE a very tremendous help to the to this busing transportation system but again remember the other part that we're talking about to is the restruct of the tiers which is kind of that mechanism of making sure that we that works out as well because of being too close together you're looking at routes how close they are between one the other giving the drivers enough time to complete those routes on time so what I have here you look at now is the

161is a transportation route system this is your ontime data if you look at the orange bar now this is a average of all the of all the diff different Transportation within our district as well so the orange bar is your am arrival time of students that arrive on school on time the blue bar is your PM pickup time students being picked up for school on time so if you look at the orange bar right now as an average we are maintaining the 82.75% average being on time in the amm however for the PM pickup time we are at 59.5% so we have some work to do to improve those times so going back to that tier system that Dave just showed you right now currently we're budgeted for 580 positions for drivers we actually carry

162517 at the moment we have no U which would be our unassigned drivers that we have on our books but because we don't have positions filled we don't have sub drivers sitting around like that so and we currently make 5,721 bus stops daily making how many routes is 1177 I'm driving the 9 million miles annually so we do not have a sub pool and maintaining that average is not acceptable to us so what we want to do is when this conversation started is create achievable goals for our employees and doing so and creating this new tier system will help us step in the right direction getting there which leads to the next one so with our new system will only and I want to make sure I make it clear that we're not saying that

163we want to we don't want the message bonr that we don't need drivers because we do this is not to decrease the need for them this to create more efficiency for us to maintain a better on time average every day so under this new tier system we'll maintain 520 drivers we'll have 500 routes actually which will give us a time to have 20 U which will be five at each compound putting us in a positive every day and we'll still make the same amount of BU stops but it creates more time in between for us to actually make it so if you look at the our new proposed system this is a proposed three ter transportation system program we are proposing to this way it sets up the drivers to have more time in between

164not only to get their rout on time to get students to school on time but also get enough time if needed to take a break and also we have taken consideration some of the things we can control we can't control traffic right now with traffic Lee County right now now at one point it was seasonal now it's year round so we have to make sure that we have to take that into into account we adjust these schedules with each route that we give that into consideration giving the drivers time to get from A to B on time taking consideration the times when traffic is really congested also you know with the driver trying to get there it creates stress there's a propensity to increase traffic crashes because you're are you're deal with a lot of

165traffic trying to get students school on time and home on time and also again it could has a increase could increase traffic violations as well too because they're trying to achieve that goal of getting kids a school on time and home on time so as a reminder safety is our priority but not only for the students but also for our drivers as well that's why it's so important so if you look at the tier one for example you'll see that we have an approximate 466 routes for tier one now this includes our high schools we haven't broken down the show how many routes per High School $3.99 we have our K8 schools at 49 routes and then Sky Elementary at 18 so why have you arranged it this way well number one I mentioned before

166we given a timeing between tier one and tier two and tier three to finish those routes to get to the next one however the K schools we talked about with with staff and we got a big group together with you know different departments kind of discussing the strategy what's the best way to arrange this and with Kate schools then we have Elementary we don't want elementary school down in in tier three being that late in the day in school also we look at for Scotland Elementary for example why is Scotland Elementary there well because if you look at where Scot Elementary is currently located it's right next to Patriot so you think about two schools at the same time traffic comeing in and out buses comeing in and out it can create a very bad

167traffic problem so we had to look at this for very again look at these reasons fix these problems so doesn't become a future problem so by looking at this and you go to tier two and tier three the routes go down they minimize as you go through this which means that gives our drivers availability to meet those goals for tier two and tier three so look at tier two we have our elementary schools we have our yep and for the audience that's youth parent education program our ECC which our early childhood Learning Center so we have those programs for our tier 2 which goes down to 411 routes again it's approximate now and I'll reiterate this why approximate because stops can change stops can be taken away they can be added it depends so that's

168why we have approximate this can change tier three goes down to 300 routes as an approximate route that's your middle schools includes Buckingham Royal Palm and Success Academy so we feel with these routing system the way we have it divided up in the times that'll give drivers the success to meet the goal of getting kids to school on time getting them home on time and make the next tier go to tier two or tier three so but again this proposal this is going to give less time for students waiting at bus stops unattended again safety is priority so we don't want students sit in the bus stop longer than they have to this is going to reduce hardships for parents and staff this will improve driver route efficiency and obviously improve Fleet Maintenance as well

169there will absolutely be an academic impact on the move as well with the additional time with the reliable drop offs and Pickups we can we can start looking at adding student instru instructional minutes which is something we've wanted to do for years in order to kind of get in line with our peers ker right now runs a 49 minute period Charlotte runs a 50-minute period we are at a 47 minute period with this increased efficiency knowing our students will be there we can absolutely start running a 49-minute instructional period in both middle and high school and with Elementary we'll have an additional 25 minutes of instruction that we can factor in there this includes time for a 30 minute lunch for our staff and for our students which is something that working with t and

170working with spout has been something that a partnership that we've been working on for a while I can say timely drop off and pickup results in increased time efficiency in the school day when students are not arriving late when parents are not concerned about the lack of a bus and picking up early it overall just allows us to use our instructional time much more efficiently consistency I mean additional positive impacts consistency of ontime student arrival increase access to breakfast service this will have an impact on Food Service decrease negative student behaviors it impacts student services decrease in A disruption to the learning environment that goes straight to academic Services as Dave had mentioned also increasing the stability of driver and routes performance this produces driver ftig fatigue which factors into Human Resources it's going to

171decrease bus accidents increase ontime arrivals for routes we really feel like the increased efficiency of the system is going to is going to Ripple is going to have a number of of major effects to that end we absolutely welcome any super superintendent and board comments on this proposed change to our schedule first of all thank you to our team for bringing this proposal forward so one of the challenges that I've given our teams to think differently to start looking at some of the challenges and taking them head on to be bold and to be brave and to be courageous and what I mean by that is on behalf of children on behalf of student learning on behalf of safety we have an opportunity here and I am really excited about this proposal all the things

172that are on the agenda a you know obviously mental Health's important all of that but very excited about this for a number of reasons one we continue to struggle with hiring bus drivers and we are working really hard to try to put some things in terms of retention strategies in play we've heard our drivers we understand we've listened for many years now because this is not my first time at the rodeo right I've had opportunities to talk with drivers on the campaign Trail I've had opportunities to go actually out to the compounds when I was previously employed by the district serving breakfast at Christmas time or going out and we had a big meeting Miss Jordan you remember we were all there and we listened to the concerns this is an opportunity to address a

173number of those concerns student achievement you know I'm real passionate as you are about that when we get to add instructional minutes to a day and I've shared this with you privately and I'll share it with the public out loud of all of the things we do in our instructional environment a high quality teacher and more time are really the only two variables that we can control that impact student achievement more time high quality teachers that's why you hear me speak so passionately about this proposal and you will continue to hear it allows our teachers to have more time our children more time to be instructed and very importantly going to teacher and Driver Recruitment and Retention so for all of those reasons yes we will have a small adjustment in some start times but

174I think the little bit of pain is worth the tremendous return on invest that we know we will see in all of those areas so we are excited to bring this for you to you today we can't wait to hear what you have to say and we look forward to your comments I'm going to go to miss Shavano and then Mr Ribble H thank you guys for putting this together I had questions on two slides so slide nine with the tiar breakdown for Skyline versus I guess Patriot from tier one to tier two so 50 minutes is basically the difference so that's going to be enough time we think not to have a traffic issue cuz I know in the morning our parents are just eager to drop our kids off and those lines are

175like ridiculously long and wrapped around the building so just making sure with like traffic and kind of those eager parents to get in line there that's going to be enough of a gap for them so yes because you have one going one way and another coming in so that definitely won't be a problem that's why we separated those two so absolutely that's being addressed okay cuz that it's not pretty sometimes yes okay and then slide 11 in regards to adding 25 minutes for elementary does that bring them up to 40 49 minutes to kind of keep them in line for instruction so the Elementary number of instructional minutes isn't necessarily dictated by State Statute right at the high school level and the Middle School level 47 minutes is really the bare minimum of instructional minut

176that we can have what it's going to do is provide us time in the day to do more intervention to do more instruction to expand a math or a reading block and it and we can fit it into this tiered system right yeah so again when we're looking at adding time I'm all for adding more time for elementary specific because obviously that's their foundational and kind of critical learning time yeah early from like know first to third grade it's kind of The Benchmark we're looking at specifically for third so anything we can do to add more learning minutes I am all for and obviously getting our teacher more time to actually have a lunch break I think would be great they'd appreciate that so yeah no I think that's all good thank you so much

177Mr Rebel yes Mr Nan you went over that gave me a flavor in our head-to-head about this or our 101s if you will and I was impressed now I really got the into the meat and potatoes of this whole thing but certainly having a need for 60 less routes we got to applaud the plan the whole plan looks great to me in the industry we call Loop dispatch but here we're moving children around instead of packages I just have one question are you folks covered this with the drivers have they bought into the plan because I think that's have to battle well that's the next phase we were this is the first phase to present it to you all and then we'll start releasing it out and having conversations so I can almost wholeheartedly say

178being a transportation so long it I believe they'll buy it's it's a great plan and again it gives them achievable goals like our drivers really do want to be on time you know they don't enjoy you know having to rush having no downtime having to do all these extra things that they don't have time for so I can absolutely seeing them loving this great thank you're welcome Mr fiser Miss ganelli next thank you thank you Dr Carlin and staff for bringing this forward obviously the district we're not where we need to be with academic performance and things like this will truly make a difference I appreciate that two questions I have first is from the teacher administrator standpoint when you're looking at these schedules I know it's kind of you know obviously still experimenting with

179where you're at with it when it comes to teacher planning and plc's and those things are there any impacts one or the other to those it will make the daily schedule a little bit tighter we're looking at Bell schedules that have 10 to 15 minutes at the start of the day as dedicated teacher planning time obviously their planning period will then be increased by 2 minutes which will make the contractually required 40 minutes of continuous planning there we'll meet the 60-minute requirement ideally at the end we are going to have additional time where teachers have a little bit of contractual time to to get together and work because we will be picking up kids in a more timely fashion we can have a bus ramp loaded with all of the buses that need to take

180the kids load those in at the end of the day and have them off campus in 10 minutes right now we do a lot of holding our students for a fair amount of time after school which is going to cut in not only to teacher contractual time as they supervise but also Beyond contractual time okay thank you next question I have in regards to many of us went through proximity obviously in the changes especially the parent pickup lines do we imagine you know outside of skyline Patriot and Challenger I know with even proximity there was always issues just how you know close some of the schools in K cor built near each other but in regards to parent pickup do we see any changes one way or other at the moment I know that's very

181hard to anticipate as well as wor you know a year in on two years in elementary and a first year into Middle School proximity right now the only issue was the skyline the other ones we don't anticipate any issues but we'll keep it on the table it's always an option and if things of that nature come up then we can adjust in thank comments oh miss chanelli thank you actually Mr fiser stole one of my questions was the first one but regarding the impact of teachers so I'll just add to that or ask the question so in reporting that's going to adjust the teachers or Staff Schedule somewhat a little bit right they'll either work a little longer or they'll but they'll come in a little later in the morning now I mean or or

182does that change not change that's what I was curious the teacher worked will still be 7 and 1/2 hours which is what it has been really we're just we're we're going to have we're going to be in front of students more more during that time we're going to have less time without students during the day okay great that's it thank you I'm excited about it by the way I mean I think this is long overdue so thank you thank you Miss Jordan yeah I'm excited too they've asked most of my questions as well but the only other question that I would have and it probably isn't has nothing to do with you all it's dropping these kids off we're talking about dropping them off but we're talking about the kids who are not being dropped

183off and where are they going when the time changes are we having before care for the schools that would be my question because parents a lot of parents are at work by 8:00 and so at 8:30 where are those kids up for those 30 minutes and I can say that just this morning I was on a meeting looking at the before and after care programs they've grown pretty robust with proximity it was a it was a requirement going out that we created programs when proximity took place so I don't anticipate at having a huge impact what we may have is a change in the way that we price it so for a school that opens up their before Care at 6:30 in the morning but their kids were starting at 7:55 they would charge a

184lower price than what would be charged in the afternoon we would just invert those if the start time was now 8:30 and there was more more child care taking place in the morning and less in the afternoon did I explain that well yeah and I would just hope that we really look at that because I know right now there are several schools who don't even have the capability even though they have two different forms of before care and after there's just not enough space for other children so these kids are now you know the ly kids or I don't know where their parents are dropping them but I just want to really make sure that we're aware of that absolutely and I know Thursday we look forward to sharing to to sharing more in depth

185with our principles we've had some great focus groups but our principles are going to be are going to have some great input to give us on Thursday I appreciate this thank you thank you what is your anticipated timeline I mean this plan is so good I'd like to see it start tomorrow but fortunately it can't start that way but do you all have any kind of a timeline to or you just thinking next year I mean our plan is to start this next year the 25 26 school year get this some place obviously gives the parents a time even when the en rollment starts out as well to plan that ahead of time for the year the only thing I would add is to piggy back off that comment is you know School choices coming

186up and obviously the sooner the better with this plan so that parents can start to make some decisions I think it's great I'm like you I'm like I don't know why we're waiting but I mean I do know why we're waiting but I think that the fact that we will have cushion of unassigned drivers that has to help the transportation department do you all ever run this is a question I I spent six years on on the bus ramp I had great tan great Tan Lines to write a passage we all did it and it's something we would always discuss out there is do you all ever run a like pseudo Transportation Route before school even gets started before day one like if a if a bus stop takes you 3 minutes approximately to load

187kids do you all run anything like that before the school year starts to see if something like this really works like it looks great on paper Yes actually we actually created a simulation for this progress for this plan so absolutely we do we create the routes first and it gives you the approximate time and it's pretty accurate but only thing is it does not factor in the additional traffic of course so you know but other than that it's it's pretty good to the tea okay all right terrific well thank you I appreciate the hard work I can't wait to see it put to play anything else all right have a great afternoon moving on legislative priorities looking forward to hearing from Christina hulahan and Riley Kempton this afternoon good afternoon superintendent Dr Carlin and board

188members Riley and I are here today to give you a brief over overview of our 2025 legislative priorities for this upcoming session and to just provide you all and also the public with some background information on how these priorities were formed our lobbyist Kim mougle with gray Robinson met with each of you individually and heard each of your individual priorities that you wanted to be brought forward they then brought that information back to us and then we brought that information to our cabinet members and we were finded a little bit to see their actual needs that meet with your priorities as well and then so that is how we formed the priorities that are before you today and this is the information that we will share with the public on our website and then also

189the legislators whenever we are in Tallahassee first on our list of priorities is Administrative efficiency for administrative efficiency we will be supporting and advocating for legislation that reduces the red tape and unnecessary regulations allowing the school district to innovate and compete operate more efficiently and maintain cost Effectiveness this covers a multitude of policies that will help streamline processes and regulations to make it easier for teachers to do their jobs the district to operate more efficiently and ultimately enhancing educational opportunities and outcomes for the students next on our list we have increased student achievement which includes supporting the increase of per student funding by at least 5% so that'll take us from 8,959 in financial year 2025 to 9,431 in fincial year 2026 this is a pretty standard ask and this will help as prices increase

190for us to also match that with increasing our Pro student funding additionally we are also requesting a specific appropriation of $25 million for the advancement of a Career and Technical education College Community Partnership in the East zone of Lee County this is a continuation of our request from last year for the East Zone Technical College which we will pursue in collaboration with Community Partners and local businesses our goal is to ensure that students are job ready upon graduation and remain in Lee County our goal is also to fulfill the CR critical Workforce gaps in businesses that are in urgent need of skilled trades people lastly we are asking to allow districts to established school start times based on the input from parents and families with students attending district schools and just to clarify this is

191different than the presentation you all just heard but we did send out a survey to both our parents and to our teachers and just a quick update which we got just before this presentation we have received 1,624 responses from staff and then 4,43 uh7 from parents and that's been out for about 2 and 1/2 weeks and we plan to push another send of that and then keep it open for another two weeks and then that is the information that we will bring to Tallahassee with us to legislators and what we can go ahead and do is before we do that next push before we go to Tallahassee next week we can also give you guys kind of the high level overview of what that kind of looks like but we do want as much feedback

192as possible that's why we're going to extend it out the additional two weeks the following student achievement or sorry priority we have is safety priorities or safety priorities and this are supporting an increase of the safe schools allocation in the Florida education Finance program to ensure funds are available for student safety initiatives also we are supporting the recommendations of the school safety officers guardian and law enforcement officers to address any unintended consequences from the implementation of House Bill 1473 that was the school safety Bill last year that was passed during 2024 with this we are also requesting a specific appropriation of $5 million for school safety for upgrading critical security systems and hardening of school facilities this $5 million will help continue the advancement of current practices and to implement new Cutting Edge practices in

193the field that will enhance our safety measures along with some of the feedback from house bills or 1473 that was passed last year we are also watching other key pieces of legislation that has been filed and looping in Chief nulan as well as to how that would directly impact our district if it were to pass next on our priority list we have teacher certification and retention and this the first one that we have listed here this is a continuation of us asking from the past two years but we're hoping we'll get it across the Finish Line this session which is amending Florida statute to exclude social School social workers from the instructional staff that must take and pass the professional education exam Florida teach certif certification examination to maintain employment in a public school this

194is just a costly and excessive regulation that we have on our social workers and by removing that we'll be able to recruit more social workers and then also we're asking supporting the streamlining of the requirements for individuals who want to renew their teaching certificate but are not currently employed by a Florida school district currently teacher certifications are tied to The District in which they work for and whenever they leave the profession but might want to come back it is both costly to them and there is no mechanism that allows them to pause their certification unless they are going to leave for a private institution we're asking that just be extended to all teachers and that will make it also easier for us to recruit recruit qualified teachers next we have our financial initiatives the first

195one is to ensure that funding follows the student in real time and we request that the Department of Education to issue an RFI request for information to identify potential solutions for realtime student and financial tracking this came up of a concern as Florida is leading the way with school choice we just want to make sure that we are keeping track of where the dollars are going based off of where the students are in real time second we are requesting an increase in the mental health allocation to better address the growing needs of students and staff increasing our mental health allocation is a crucial ask and by increasing these funds we may better equip our mental health professionals with the tools they need to support our students this will also significantly enhance the students well-being and

196academic performance lastly we are supporting the funding of the high growth District Capital outlay assistance grant program for districts with a five-year average of increasing student enrollment this would help districts manage significant growth by funding the construction and additional schools to address ongoing overcrowding issues as you know we are growing and we are growing fast and it's not slowing down and we're asking the legislature to both fund the grant for the school districts that are high growth and also to award that Grant to the Lee County School District to help with the construction cost of these new facilities and last but certainly not least we are asking to include all pre kindergarten classes and programs in the department of education's Florida inventory of school houses calculations to ensure that all students receiving instruction in Florida

197school districts are accurately counted for and receive adequate funding from the doe essentially our prek kids right now are not included in our person student funding but we are both housing and instructing them so we're just asking that they be included in that calculation so that we can ensure that we're receiving the funds for those kids and with that highle overview we welcome any superintendent and board member comments so this is our first opportunity to really highlight our dynamic duo here so we are really fortunate to have Miss Hulan and Miss Kempton join our team as you can see and as you will see next week in Tallahassee they are very familiar with these processes and will be U guiding us along with Kim McDougall through the Tallahassee Maze and the opportunities that await us

198as we Advocate strongly for our children and for policy changes that are going to positively impact not only student achievement but all of our other priorities as well so we welcome your conversation and look forward to your feedback board members any comments or questions Mr persons and Mr fiser on the school social workers if you could get some information before we go up there on number one how many we have maybe lost because they could not pass the teachers exam I know there were a few last time I don't know what the figures are over over the last few years you know it's obvious that makes it difficult to recruit new ones because they don't even want to take it and they do not teach for the public to know right you know they're not

199teachers I think in maybe in past years decades ago or something they taught and were social workers both but I know in our district that's not the case we can certainly get those numbers for you and we did meet with Paul in the social work department and he said this would be crucial for him to get more social workers in there thank you Mr fiser thank you I have a question actually I see it in here so I want to thank you both in the short amount of time the hard work that you both have put in how much you've elevated government relations so I'm I'm excited to have you both thank you for your hard work thanks any other comments or questions Miss ganelli I'm excited to see how we all work together next

200week so I think it's going to be great actually I'm I'm just excited about U that opportunity I actually there's a couple of these I just I just like love I'm hoping that we can get these through to the finish line so I'm excited so I just I am curious have yall reached out and what fsba what they're going to be what they're going after because some I obviously we do different because we this is for Lee County so I'm just curious what anything that's kind of similar yep quite a few of these policy initiatives actually mirror FSB as well when we were in Tampa for the conference we met with a lot of their legislative folks and they were fantastic with briefing us on all this so it's it's going to be fun because

201we're not going to be the only School District really trying to push a lot of these initiatives which is a good thing thank you any other comments thank you ladies for the hard work we look forward to seeing your work in Tallahassee thank thank you the next presentation which is our last present ation is institutional board member seats presented by Dr Ken Savage good afternoon superintendent Carlin and board members so today I'm here just really more to help facilitate your annual activity of designating which board members sit in which liaison seats as per the board manual as well as per our policies we have a document here to kind of guide that work we did have a recommendation as a pertain to some of the current board advisories that certainly you can have any more

202follow-up conversation if you'd like to do that as well that is embedded into the agenda item but the rest of it here is just we have basically board discussion to make sure that you all have the opportunity to put the proper lias on for the different institutional seats that remain the ones that we presently have already identified based on the fsba for example is Miss Langford Fleming as the fsba advocacy committee term with Miss Jordan as the alternate with Mr fiser as the F on the fsba board of directors for that two-year term with Miss Jordan as the alternate we also had Mr Ribble with this was a newly requested institutional liaison seat with Florida Gulf Coast University and so that again information is brought forward all of these things are something that you all

203as a group collectively get to decide historically in the past it has not required any type of formal process but more just conversation so with that said I know some of our board members who are experienced in this effort through numerous different board terms if you'd have anything you'd want to add I'd turn it back to you Vice chair as you run the meeting that's totally up to you for any conversation I'm here to assist thank you Dr Savage so in the past I know that we had open discussion in an orderly Fashion on who would serve on what committees for those of you who are new to the board so I am happy to open up for discussion if we want to start where if there's any particular interest in a specific role here

204somebody that's wanted to serve on a committee that they haven't or continue to serve one more term so we can just have open discussion if you will miss Jordan I see your hand up thank you well I've served on every one of these with the exception of Dak and so I am willing to serve on any of them but I've I've not I've subbed Dak but I've never actually sat on that and just for clarification for some of you new newer board members you're welcome to come to any committee meeting that you want we're just asking for your attendance as much as you can if you're actually the ladies on I just wanted to clear that up you're not ex it doesn't exclude you from going to any meetings so and maybe perhaps U Miss

205Fleming too where this says conven how they have the other board the other advisory committees and then it says ad hoc as needed I think maybe that needs to be I know we had a conversation on that but how would one be the representative or the liaison to the as need it because then they would just be notified we need you now and so if maybe needs to be explained as well that's a great point I and I can help clarify so our recommendation again that can be undone it really is just a recommendation our job is to make recommendations to the board to give you the rationale for that you as a board though these are your advisory committees in that top section and so right now because our current recommendation was to allow

206them to live within the deck there would only be one board liaison seat because these others would only be convened in an ad hoc basis so that would basically be only as needed so if there were a particular construction item if there were you know a design a desire on the part of the board to say I would like a special ad hoc committee formed within Dak to address a particular issue such as like a proximity plan something to that effect a strategic plan it could be any of the elements that you would want that would then live within that piece so there would not be a board liaison beyond the daak liaison however as Miss Jordan and as Miss lenord FL mentioned all board members are invited to attend and listen this just officially

207allows one board member as a representative of the board to be the liaison to basically carry information back and forth between the board so that's why these ones are blocked out we could very easily open the mech up again if the Comm if the board were to say they did not want to follow through with that recommendation wanted to stay within the existing structure in any way and if I may if I can just add one piece to that thank you Dr Savage part of your question I think Miss Jordan at was regarding how we would do that so just as Dr Savage said if there was perhaps a new school you know being constructed and there were or there were issues you know or we would want input you know maybe on construction contracts

208or something to that degree we could make a decision do we want to run that by the entire deck or are we looking for maybe a group a subgroup to pull off just like you would do with any ad hoc Committee of any group and say okay we're going to be looking for some specific feedback around this particular issue strategic plan is a great example of that as well those of you that might have some interest in helping us with a strategic plan we're reupping on it we need to refine maybe some of our goals or strategies or run something by you those of you that are interested we would pull that together as an ad hoc committee so if you serve as the liaison our anticipation would be that we would join you at

209one of those meetings and say this is what we're going to be looking for and throw that open to the entire Dack so then people that were interested or available or you know that type of thing then could join us so it be more ad hoc of the of the nature correct no I I understood that part but are we looking to assign people for those as needed positions at this meeting and then the standing committee meeting as well which is edac which is the standing one of that are we looking to put someone so if you have that the need for strategic plan okay it's Mr Ribble that's you so he would then be that person that would go to that meeting or whomever here we just assign at that time the intention if

210I may the intention was there is a the daak is the larger advisory committee there is one board member as the liaz on to that to communicate back and forth again you're all welcome to sit there listen to conversations but just the one and that person would essentially carry the water from the board between the two the direction from the board to the committee and vice versa okay thank you so if there's if there is anyone besides Miss Jordan that would want to serve on the deck is are we okay to go ahead and start adding names to list Dr Savage are you ready for that happy to do that okay Miss ganelli so I'm just bringing up Dak and this is kind of a little bit off topic for a second because in our

211ethics training that we had I sent this to the board attorney there was and I can't forget which video but they talked about subcommittees and what Dak does is they meet in they meet all together on zoom and then they break out into these subcommittees which does not allow for the for the public to be able to go to Every both subcommittees so that from the video that I was understanding that was a violation of sunshine because not everybody can see that and hear that those convers that are happening in these sub committees I if if you could elab if you could clarify that through the chair if I may so you're correct Miss janelli the subcommittees that are part of these board advisory committees are supposed to abide by the Sunshine Law so a

212couple years ago what we did was to notice those subcommittee meetings separately so that there was a time certain when they were going to commend minutes would be taken and they would be open to the public now starting this year it's much different where they're not going to be using as much in terms of the subcommittees because the subcommittees were elementary middle and high school now we have the zones that are all mixed in together so I don't believe they're going to be using that format as much but if they do have to break out to subcommittees they will then follow the same procedure notice it properly take minutes and make sure it's open to the public so the video that I watched they didn't recommend that and so I'm just bringing that out there

213and I mean that was our ethics training regarding sunshine and they didn't recommend that at all in fact they recommend because they said even if two board members are in cuz that happened cuz the last meeting there was a glitch and a problem with the team or the with the zoom or teams I forget which one it was and not everybody was able to even get in then they were they were out so then everybody was down and nobody was and then you got back in it was it was complicated so I just I'm concerned and I think I can put a little clarification I think you're talking about breakout rooms and so forth that the way the Dak shoot in breakout rooms I think that is one of the issues that there is an

214awareness of when you utilize breakout rooms where you they're all segregated where they have the ability to have separate conversations that an attending public could only hear one of them couldn't hear others there's no record that's that's I think the specific matter of interest that you're referring to Miss J is that correct and so I think that's any type of subcommittee type of structure would have to operate not as a breakout capacity to avoid that very matter whether that meant separate minutes essentially it's falling within the larger DAC structure but it is that has more to do with how you comprise membership how you have nomination procedures all those different things to kind of element those aspects of it in terms of the sunshine the desire would be that it is conduct within full compliance

215of of Sunshine Law minutes so for structure all those things to support that you're missing the point the point was that a public could not be in all three breakout rooms which were going on at the same time and that is I'm telling you that is what's happened I just got off a de or I'm getting off a deck I'm sure and that went on for over 12 months of the ability that it did not allow the public to get to go in all three breakout rooms it only allowed them to be in one and only allowed me to be in one I'm sorry I wasn't being clear that's I understand exactly what you're saying what I'm saying is that's not what this structure is this structure is not designed to be breakouts for that

216particular piece that's not the intention of it's it's I was trying to explain I just didn't do a very good job the breakout structure that you talked about within Dak that was as as attorney Depo berno mentioned one larger meeting they then break into separate distinct sub breakout groups that were and they attend their meetings virtually essentially that allowed for a person not to be able to participate in each of those things this structure of what we're talking about is not that we're not we're not recommending that we move to a breakout capacity where the group is meeting about a larger topic and then this particular group goes and segregates during that same time period that's not what would be advised this is a subcommittee within the Dak structure so it's joint membership it's members

217of Dak who could could also be a member of a subcommittee meeting at a separate and distinct time and so forth and so that's the intention there okay now I got you and that's what I met when I said that it has to be properly noticed for a specific time to be able to meet and the minutes taken and open to the public so I do know what you're talking about CU it was a problem I and we there was a lot of discussion about and some push back when we were trying to fix it but now I don't believe it's going to be like that anymore I mean we're not doing that same type of breakout it has to be properly noticed that makes sense but it's a separate meeting in other words we're

218distinguishing it as a separate meeting not a continuation of the prior meeting they meet at least this is how they were instructed to do it so I wasn't at every meeting but this is how they were instructed to do it the they'll say you know in their notice at 1: p.m. we're going to have the subcommittee meeting for elementary school they start their meeting they close out their meeting and then they say you know we will rejoin this particular meeting so it's a completely separate subcommittee meeting yes but they're giving recommendations they were giving they were giving clear recommendations back to the district one was just done recently regarding the the time and so I could not attend every one and they were done at the same time so I could not attend all of

219them I couple times I would pop in one and pop in another but the whole point being is that if the public is starts at at Dak and then they break go into these breakout sessions they're done at the same time there's no way that individual public person could go into all three of them it's not possible yeah we'll have to look into that a little bit more so I think what I'm hearing is that the DAC is the big umbrella of the other committees that we had chosen what was it last meeting or the meeting before to blend these together and then if within that Dack there needs to be committees being we are dis discouraging the DC should be discouraging breakout sessions during that time slot let's say if they meet on Wednesdays

220from 5: to 7 they should all be in the same room from 5: to 7: meeting if they feel as though there should be a breakout session meaning like the new school start times perhaps needs its own subcommittee then that subcommittee would form they would meet on Tuesdays from 5: to 7:00 as the subcommittee for the am I understanding you Dr Savage that's correct when whenever they would need to meet with Whatever frequency they would need to meet they would be properly noticed keep going j keep going okay I'm just making sure because we're doing so well and I'm like we need to continue to put people in the Committees Miss shano and then we're going to go ahead and move on oh I'm just signing up for committees okay so I want to go

221back to Dak though so that we can make sure we're clear here that Miss Jordan would like to serve as a Layon on the Dak committee should they need a subcommittee you as the lays on I would imagine would bring back to the board they're looking for a subcommittee for XYZ is that clear am I being clear I understand okay great but I do understand what she was saying because I watch it I witnessed it so yes okay I just wanted to make sure okay so moving down the list the audit committee Mr persons has been serving on that is a committee that we are going to continue to have is there anyone that is interested in serving on the audits committee especially since we're going to be sorry I've never served on the audit

222committee so I love the opportunity okay that's good you're retired and then the iso committee I have no problem serving on that again unless somebody else is interested in that's discuss the CX okay moving on are you are you keeping notes Dr I'm also doing it's live I'm doing it in in real time absolutely okay Early Head Start policy Council they do meet once a month the last time I had served on this they had discussed going by monthly Miss Morgan's not here any longer so I'm not sure if that's the case but I know that it's important that we keep tabs on how often these meetings are occurring because I know we all have outside responsibilities also so just wanted to point that out is there anyone that would be willing to serve on

223the Head Start program committee I've been on that it's a midm morning meeting okay we'll go back to that I'll serve on it I don't have okay value adjustment board meets twice a year yes you and I have already been appointed to that's the one that the chair and the vice thank you school health advisory committee I don't mind at all serving on that again it's good okay Dr Savage you can put down board member Fleming thank you Horizon council is served by the chair and the vice as an alternate instructional calendar Miss Shavano y yes Insurance task force I know that Miss patrique always talked highly of this so okay great Mr Ribble yes the foundation board will be served by the chair and the vice chair as an alternate so we can move

224down to S fsba Advocate advocacy committee oops ma'am I think that we missed the Coalition for drug free Southwest Florida I think was oh I'm sorry I missed that one we'll go back to drug free really quick before I so Mr fiser has served on that for the last two years so is anybody willing to it's a great committee I'm happy if someone else wants to do it really gives you a good perspective especially on some of the mental health issues even we talked about today free anybody willing to serve in Mr Fischer's place do you want to stay on that board yeah if nobody else will do it I'm happy to do it okay Mr fiser is not retired from that board he's going to stay there now let's go down to the fsba

225advy committee Miss Jordan you currently serve well yes so that position is closed until May May is when we need to start looking for new people to sit on that okay because they need to have that information that runs from July 1 to June 30th of each year and then so Jui May is when they would like for us to start thinking about it and send it forward it's a one-year term okay so we can put a notation in there maybe Dr Savage about addressing that we could could we possibly talk about that in our one-on ones once it gets closer to may just to see who is interested yes ma'am absolutely all right thank you and then if I may also the so drug free Coalition that's open to anybody anybody in Le County

226can go to that so it's never closed to any any of those and it that goes with the other and I know Dr Savage and I spoke about this morning and that's the same with the other the ones below as well the Learning for Life I know that's really they have our kids they use our kids they don't use them but they participate with our children but the other ones uncomon friends really is doesn't have anything to do with the education it's just a and there's were a couple other ones that we've already taken off of here because they were not part of the education the teachers the students so I just wanted to and I know he asked me to share that so I'm sharing that thank you thank you moving on to learning

227NOP fsba board of directors it's a two-year term M excuse me okay thank you Learning for Life Miss G of nelli served on that one for the last two yeah I've been on for a while go ahead but that's what I was saying so those those yeah those two the bottom two are really not school Rel it's not really School related as the other ones are so I mean they've been on here as well as many others that have been over the years have diminished or went away okay because we do that because we do that even though they call us to go we need you to be our judges or we need you to do to do this that really doesn't have a role in The District but uncommon friends does actually because they

228have a scholarship program if they're not involved with the schools they can't do this they don't get the scholarship they give money out but they get money and I think I think that's why the relationship was my understanding and they haven't done that the only thing they've been working on for the last two years is the house the property so scholarships we've not seen any scholarships come out of they used to give out scholarships and we you know judge Savage can you go ahead and discuss these two do you want to talk about those two particular yeah absolutely Vice I'm happy to do that so as you know so one of the things we you noted and I think Miss Jordan tried to speak on this a little bit too is just in the author

229committee purpose section what we've listed is some of these committees are required by law some of them are institutional seats based on various different configurations some cases as Miss juvell was saying you know entities in order to try to serve their purpose they're nonprofits they may be written into their bylaws that they will have a standing member of the board school board for Lee County as an Institutional member without reviewing each of their individual bylaws to know it and a lot of times we Rely Upon Our board members who serve in these capacities to continue to engage with us so as she mentioned there are a number of ones you can't see because they've been eliminated they are either committees that no longer meet there're ones that allow either a staff person to now meet

230in instead or that they just no longer meet and so it really depends there's kind of an EB and a flow with this and so what I would say to the board is if there's a board member interest in serving in that LE and capacity one of the first ERS of businesses to engage and can introduce and say you know do they still want to have that institutional seat if there is no no real interest or if they'd rather us as staff reach out to these entities and say we on behalf of the board would like to just kind of engage a little bit with you and get some clarification on maybe what's your recent work are you still doing student scholarships we'd be happy to bring that information back to you all in your

231one-on ones so that the board can make an informed choice of whether you'd like to take the time today to appoint someone or whether you'd rather delay and get a little more information on these two particular entities because we have filled all the rest of these institutional seats but those are two that we'd be happy to research unless board members are so inclined to want to do carry that water for us it's totally up to the board I'm in favor of postponing and reaching out staff reaching out Miss Gianelli and Miss Jord Mo made great points about it but maybe we need to get some more information to see if they're really looking for a board member or perhaps a staff member to engage sounds great we're happy to do that okay Miss ganelli and

232I'd like to add to that like so I also do stastics through the Edison Festival light as well as the fairs which is the science fair and that's actually involved with many of our teachers and staff at our school district and I would like to add that's kind of would fall under one of these as well and I do participate as much as I can on the Edison fairs because they do it by Zoom now but I can't always attend there somehow there's a conflict sometimes so like Dak actually so I if you could reach out to Gary Nelson and I can give you that but I think it would be ho us as well to have someone involved in that just to because they are always looking for judges every year and I judge

233when I can last year was a conflict with the the parade was of the same day as the judging so but that would allow maybe someone else to run out there that morning and do the judging because it's usually till like early morning to noon so if I would like to add that because I find it important and you know that whole Edison fairs I may be wrong maybe the others don't want to be be involved but I just wanted to add that and put that out there as well Miss Jordan thank you and I and I mentioned that to you this morning I mentioned that this morning because I was trying to go over all of these in my head what is out there but you have been such a great person where every

234time there there is a need of Judges or this the as a community member and involved in that you have always shared all that with us as a board to get us excited to be a part of that so I don't know if that's that's a something that should be on here or if you continue to do that it's it works so I'm happy to provide a little a little more clarification again so the goal of this activity right is to address for where there institutional seats where there are defined memberships that is a it's it's really about the relationship with the entity so in our case you all as individual members of the board if you are relating to another entity in a formalized manner in the case of something like you know serving

235on a governing board as is the example that's listed in the uncommon friends it's a part of that governing board what's different and distinct from that I'm hearing a little bit is sometimes you as members of the community as as members of our board are often invited to participate in various different functions such as serving as a judge serving as a relationship in that piece if it isn't a defined entity that has a need it may not necessarily fit into this activity where we would on an annual basis appoint a member as a formal liaison that means there could be other relationships that don't necess mean here I'm not saying that is or isn't but we could be happy to do that additional research much in the same way we'd be doing it for Learning

236for Life on uncommon friends to kind of get an update with that I'd be more than happy to reach out to from Edison fairs as well stem clarify what the nature of a relationship is clarify for the board what the nature of the ask is in terms of your service in that liaison capacity so that again you'd be making an informed Choice certainly bring that information back to one-on ones and then if you want to have more Fallout board conversation certainly the direction of superintendent I'll be happy to follow on that as well Dr Savage I appreciate that was sort of what was in my mind because I know I Ser I serve on a numerous Sports here in the community but you know I it's not as superintendent of schools it's just by virtue

237of things that I've done or been affiliated with in the past so I appreciate the research on that and we will come back to the board and advise you thank you to get information on that for starting in our one-on-one okay and we do have a new institutional request lays on seat and I do know that Mr Ribble is the one who would like to serve on this if I am correct is that is that right okay is that okay everybody good with that yeah it's just getting added as an Institutional request yep I'll be an alternate okay Dr Savage do you have everything you need I have everything I need thank you ma'am all right thank you we are able to now move on to public comment attorney dupay Bruno do you have can

238you please address public comment thank you madam Vice chair there is no one signed up for public comment okay next up is good of the order I know that a few of you are going to hold your comments for this evening with this long meeting we've had but if I will go down the row anyway just in case anybody would like to mention anything I'll start with Miss Shavano do you have anything for good of the order no I do not Mr persons not at this time Miss Jordan not at this time thank you Mr Ribble not at the time Mrs ganelli not at this time Mr fiser yes sorry always has to be me so just real quick updates auditor position is currently I asked it that it remain open based on your discussion

239last time I've had a brief discussion with sheath monterano and I'm going to kind of catch up with her and I will send out some messages in regards to where we're at with that process I want to give you that update so second thing is I did have some further discussions with Dr Shaker as well as Dr Duncan in regards to students involved in meetings I had mentioned this we kind of went back some of you probably about a year ago had asked about this kind of shifting from a model of passive to active and part of that I've kind of asked for to see what a model would look like if we had either a workshop or Action meeting not quite sure where it would be at probably a workshop would be my guest

240but have either a student or multiple students present something to us from that model so as things come down you know let make sure that the administration we'll keep you informed of that anything else so last thing just a quick Foundation report since this is the time we usually give that Dr Carl and I attended the Foundation they're going through their strategic plan finalizing that process and that will come out I believe in our January meeting so that will be kind of a big update of how they do things at the foundation and also as relay they had a record number of golden apple applicants people that actually fulfilled and went through it too so that was amazing so that is all I have until tonight thank you okay thank you I'll save mine for

241this evening as well but I do want to say thank you to all of the commit all of the whole staff today did such a great job on the workshops and moving through it slowly so I truly appreciate I know that the board does too moving through that very clearly and understandably Miss attorney DPA Bruno do you have anything yes I do thank you madam chair so in December legal met with the attorney for the city of Bonita Springs with regards to Bonita Springs Elementary there does seem to be some confusion with regards to certain facts the recommendation from both councils is that we have one liaison from each board uhu meet with councel so we can have a discussion probably with superintendent or her designate as well as the city manager so I would

242ask that the board designate one individual to serve as the liaison for the board so we can move forward with this meeting so we can resolve the issue with Bonita Springs Elementary is there any board member who would like to serve on this committee go ahead M Jordan I just a question what is the what would the board liaison be doing just there to listen to what is because of course they would need to come back to us to have that conversation on what we are wanting correct so I just want to make sure what yeah what that looks like yes I saw Mr Ribble raise his hand is that something you'd like to serve on yes okay all right thank you're welcome Dr Carlin thank you very much I have no comments I'll Reserve

243those for this evening as well but just thank you for your attention thank you for your enthusiasm and thank you for trusting our staff to bring forward high quality recommendations we are pushing the envelope we know but we're doing that on behalf of student learning and school safety and just appreciate your attention today so thank you today we have our regular Action meeting starting at 6 pm at this point seeing that there is no other business to come before this body and no objection this meeting is adjourned the time is 4:29 p.m.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.