001all this meeting order yep no actions taken in close session and yeah we can stand for the flag salute pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible liy and justice for all okay announcement of results of board member election as per elections code 15400 all right so for area three correct no action taken in closed session it's kind of echoey is that just me or is it no okay okay all right so for the G Elementary School District area three we have Casey raboy that will be appointed as board trustee and in area four Matthew a ward will be appointed as trustee for area 4 and we will move forward with the oath of office for both trustees we'll start
002with Casey r boy we'll go we we'll come down here and we'll I have a certificate for you and I have the oath I might get a picture here to e e e okay now uh annual organization uh item 24254 five annual organization of the board election of officers okay so this is an action item we have a few different um officers that we need to vote on the board needs to take action the first one would be the election of the president in your packet you have outlined for you the duties of the president would you like me to read all of these or it's up to you I could read them all no okay so open it up for discussion or nomination um for the next president of the board um I think
003all of these individuals would be great presidents and bring something very unique and and a a good strength to the um to the role I would however I think uh like to nominate Katherine I think she would do a wonderful job in in that role so I would like to nominate Katherine Harper for president any discussion on that or any other nominations I was gonna bring up Casey as being the president she's been here three years this is her third third year going on her fourth year and uh she's done the clerk she's done the vice president like to see herb president okay all right I'm happy to serve um I am happy to serve I was gonna defer to Casey because she has been here longer um but I am happy to serve it
004you know if that's what the board decides okay Casey how do you feel about about the nomination uh I'm fine um I've been here a bit longer but Katherine is also excellent so I'm I will support whoever the board wants to vote for president I will be 100% supportive so if we W to so okay so then we had I I think the first nomination was for for Katherine so should we vote on that yes we need a second and then we vote okay okay do I vote on that or do I let them vote Yes you can vote okay yeah so we have a a nomination for Katherine Harper as president from Anette yes need a second okay do do we want to do it as one action item or do we want to
005do each each role maybe we should do each role okay this time all right I have a motion from cther excuse me from manette cozie to nominate Katherine Harper as president seconded by Matthew Ward Casey raboy uh no Katherine Harper I Wesley Kagel no the motion carries by Three A's from Anette cozie Katherine Harper and Matthew Ward next is the election of vice president do we need to switch seats now if hour always wait until the end we can wait okay let's go we'll finish this agenda item and then we'll switch roles sure okay I don't like to nominate Casey for vice president we need a second I'll second thank you I have a motion from Wesley Kagel to nominate Casey raboy vice president seconded by Anette cozie Casey r boy it was seconded by
006Katherine I yeah I secondine oh I'm sorry I would have but she be seconded by Katherine Harper Casey raboy hi Annette cozie hi Matthew Ward thank you the motion carries unanimously next is the election of the clerk I'll nominate Annette I'll second that was Annette that seconded it was me you sound the same I'm so sorry okay I have a a motion from Wesley Kagel to nominate Annette cozie clerk second by Katherine Harper Casey raboy I Annette cozie I Matthew Ward thank you the motion carries unanimously next is to appoint the superintendent as secretary to the board I'll nominate leis I'll second okay I have a motion from Wesley Kagel to appoint the superintendent as secretary to the board seconded by by Annette cozie um Casey raboy I Katherine Harper hi Matthew Ward thank you
007the motion carries unanimously all right thank you so we'll s before we go on isn't there supposed to be a fourth position like the the the regular board we can do that it's not in our board policy but we can do that I was going to nominate Matt for board representative okay we can do that um so Wesley so you made a motion to nominate Matthew Ward board representative do I have a second I'm sorry I missed the first part board representative to to where the board representative typically attends these County Office meetings and any other meetings that that may happen throughout the county okay and is that that's coming up inary in the Committees yeah do we need to vote on that now or should we maybe we should wait under the committee since
008it wasn't agenda eyes separately for the rep that will come up on next item okay or actually after governance calendar the Committees will come up and then maybe we can we can announce that then okay is that okay okay okay and then we'll make sure it's in the minutes okay so the next agenda is 24254 six approve the schedule of regular meetings and board governance calendar okay so you have the calendar for the um next year for our regular board meetings they are the third Wednesday of every month except for the month of July um the board can we can have special board meetings at any time um the meetings are held here at 7 o'clock unless this chamber is not available the calendar is provided for you and you'll note we do already have
009a board study session that is scheduled on the calendar for January 88th that session will be held at the district office conference room can I get a motion to approve 2 42546 I'll second thank you have a motion from Wesley Kagel to approve item number 2 42546 seconded by by Anette Coy on Ka that was Matt that made the oh I'm sorry Matthew Ward um let me start over I have a motion from Matthew Ward to approve item number 2 42546 seconded by Annette cozie Casey raboy I Katherine Harper I Wesley Kagel I thank you the motion carries unanimously now we have um 242 547 does board representatives to serve on committees all right so the first committee we have is cast that's schools and cities together it's typically held uh four times a year
010there are two um board representatives from each School District the elementary and the high school district as well as City staff as well um the next meeting is already scheduled for February 11th they're typically 5:30 and we rotate where those are held between the Elementary District the high school district and the city currently right now um we had Tracy Skinner and Casey raboy that attended those meetings or attended on that committee and then we can alternate Katherine and we decide them one at a time or are you going to go through all of the Committees first um it's up to you what would you like do you want me to describe all the Committees and then have a discussion sure why don't we do that okay all right so the next one is a transportation
011committee and that is typically three to four times a year and that is also to representatives from the high school board and Elementary board that meeting is already scheduled the next meeting is January 8th those are held at 10 o'clock and we hold them at the district office um the Elementary district office conference room but we also provide a zoom link so those that can't attend in person can attend via zoom and those right now and sorry that's a typo on your your agenda here um Tracy and Annette are currently on that committee and Casey is an alternate um the Sacramento County School Board Association this is uh next meeting is scheduled for February 5th there are two annual meetings these are held at scoy Sacramento County Office of Education um there's usually a dinner
012and a guest speaker and we need all all trustees are invited to attend these um but we are required to have at least two that serve on the committee and hopefully we get at least two that attend um right now we have kathern Harper and Tracy skanner and Annette cozie is the alternate for the csba county um Board Association W going and then the last committee is the board policy committee um meets as needed um the committee this committee they get the board policies ahead of time to review um prior to going out in the board packet and so it is their job to thoroughly review those policies and be prepared to speak to any additions or changes that the board might consider and ultimately potentially have an action item and currently right now that
013is Anette cozie and Wesley CLE uh Kagel and Tracy Skinner is the alternate um so I'm happy to serve on any of these except I am unable to do the transportation committee due to it just being right in the middle of my workday um I have not I've served on transportation and uh Sacramento County Schoolboard Association and that was that was a nomination is that right Wes that you had nominated someone was it for that or was it for something else oh yeah I guess it's going to be for the S csba right that why yeah I've been on that committee I've enjoyed it a lot I'm happy to stay on it but I'm also so happy to let somebody else have it it's been really informative and helpful to me I'm happy to be
014on the transportation committee okay great I'm interested in not so someone else and then I'm currently on the policy I don't mind staying on the policy but I'm also someone else about being on the policy I'm open to that I know Casey you had been on the cast and then Tracy so yeah I would right right no I am interested on in cast I have a um a high school student and so I really like the continuity of the city and the high school being part of it but I I kind of feel that um some of these meetings other board members can attend can they not yes I mean they they they as board members they can attend these if they're interested in participating in um some of the meetings I mean being mindful
015of the brown act but even the alternates can attend these meetings these meetings are really informational and discussion there's no action taken in any of these meetings so if we did have more than two if we had three that attended it wouldn't it wouldn't break the brown Act right because we're just kind of listening to what the superintendent from the high school and the superintendent from reports yeah yeah myself I'm very interested in the cast well just like Casey I got a two boys that are at high school and uh I'm very interested in what the cities what the what we're doing towards all the Housing Development and all that so so I'm happy to stay as the alternate on cast that's totally okay fine with me is that Casey and West for cast I'm
016comfortable with that yeah and then yeah if I get interested I'll just pop please um lot a good information shared and I'll stay on the policy committee okay yeah so for transportation we have Matt was there going to be another person on that one um I can I don't want to say I can try to make the meetings but um it is in the middle of the day so sometimes work obligations I would be unable I mean I can go on there I was able to attend I think most when I've been on there but there is that the alternate um I could also be alternate on Transportation I'm in the same boat with the transation I yeah work in Stockton so it's kind of right yeah so we have Matthew for transportation and and
017who else for transportation I mean I can try I can mostly attend and then do we have an alternate the alternate okay I know if I have that day off I can I can make it can you run the list down of what we have so far just so yes so far I'm quite correct me if I'm wrong we have for cast we have Wes and case alternate Catherine and then for transportation Matthew Casey alternate Wes and then I think for policy I think Annette you said you'd stay on that so I think that's all we have so far so then the SC the uh Sacramento County School boards Association do we have anybody for that at this point no I'll be happy to to to take that one on is that the one you
018were also gonna I can't remember who else was you were interested in rep in nominating someone for something yeah was yeah I I didn't know if Matt would want yeah I'm happy to be on that as well yeah okay problem so we have Matthew an Annette is that right for the cspa cspa and then finally for policy I think Annette was staying on and so I'm happy to be the second person on that roster do we have an alternate for the csba I'll be the alternate okay and then I think we just need an alternate for the board policy committee I'll be an alternate I'm happy to be an alternate okay all right kawhai you want to read them all back okay for cast I have Casey raboy and Wesley Kagel alternate Katherine Harper Transportation
019Matthew Ward and Casey raboy alternate Wesley Kagel um Sacramento County School Board Association I have Annette coony and Matthew Ward alternate Katherine Harper and board policy committee I have Annette cozie Katherine Harper alternate Matthew Ward okay just need a motion okay I'll just can I get a motion to approve 242 547 I'll make the motion I'll second thank you have a for Matthew Ward to approve item number 2 42547 seconded by Katherine Harper hi oh sorry Casey raboy hi Annette cozie hi Wesley Kagel hi thank you the motion carries unanimously so next we have um board meeting protocol okay yes thank you now we're getting into our regular routine business for our meeting I will review the board meeting protocol our meeting is recorded it's open to the public and it's broadcast live through Zoom
020teleconference for public comments there are 3 minutes per agenda item the board shall limit total time for public comment for each agenda item to 20 minutes with board consent the board president may increase or decrease the time allowed for public comment to make public comment in person um please complete a public comment card um at the doors there and give to miss Bach our board meeting assistant email public comments um should be sent to the superintendent 24 hours before the the board meeting and they'd be posted with the agenda to our website we do have we did receive one public comment that is posted to our website board vote and connectivity each motion will be followed by a roll call vote for Action items should a board member attend the meeting remotely and lose connectivity
021by teleconference or phone the meeting will be delayed by 5 minutes and regular meeting shall be adjourned by 10:30 we have one public comment it's posted to the website yes okay and then I have um public comments for topics not on the agenda so that would be this I not on the agenda um I don't believe so no yes it's not on the agenda so that would go now okay so gayen Gomez know I should watch to see what he does Podium right thank you um good evening um thank you for allowing this public comment my name is Galen Gomez I'm the president of G Elementary faculty Association and the reason I'm speaking tonight is um board member cozie made a comment at the last board meeting in November that I wanted to address I
022thought it was a comment um that um we share in your concern um and the comment was about um how it was heart dropping to see the low and dropping test scores as we were um looking over the the data that was provided uh for our uh students and again I want to Again State restate that we share your concern some of the fact s that affect that are certainly out of the district's control and others are very much within your control and some of those um factors include smaller class sizes the elimination of combo classes access to current curriculum IA schedules and staff morale I really think that if you want to see students achieve at a higher rate you have the power to do that with um some of the addressing some of
023these items um as far as class sizes we've seen the benefits of smaller class sizes including core size uh the classes of the size of core classes at mcaffrey um we've seen the benefits of the smaller class sizes um if we want to see students achieve at higher rates in respect to combination classes we have actually seen firsthand the detriment of combination class to a grade level that hosts them uh the only benefit being very direct the only benefit um the large benefit of a combination class is financial anytime we make a decision to have a combination class it's strictly Financial uh again when we're talking about students and student achievement those are things we need to take into consideration um again I feel like some of our curriculum is actually in core subjects quite
024outdated and we keep waiting and waiting and waiting to get that curriculum updated if you want to see students achieve at a higher rate give us access to our curriculum please IA schedules we have a rotating schedule of IAS that come and go come and go and we are constantly replacing rehiring uh interviewing and I'm going to explain why I believe that is we have positions that are 3.92 or 3 .75 just below um the threshold that would require us to give benefits to those people when a position opens up that's five hours or six hours those IAS and nobody blames them jump they jump ship to go to the positions that hold that have greater hours and that offer some sort of benefits to go with them I encourage you as a board to
025really dive deep and look at a cost analysis to see how much money you're really saving by offering that position that's be below the threshold of um offering benefits um and please when you do so take into consideration the amount of time that HR puts into again having to review candidates interview candidates and that whole process because I don't think you're saving that much money and honestly our students would benefit from having consistent staff let's see here what else um and you know again honestly speaking to staff morale um there seems to be a little bit of a top- Down autocratic management style here and it doesn't necessarily boost staff morale we're the ones working in the classrooms with the students we would like to be a part of the decision making and I offer
026as an example of that the recent tours to mcaffrey middle school that occurred last week normally We Tour mcaffrey as sixth grade classes they tour the the end of April or in in May sometime it's a time when they get a chance to check out the campus they get a chance to look at explor exploratory classes select those classes it's a time when teachers are giving recommendations for those students who should be put in remedial classes or advanced classes our our teachers are now being first of all our students um went in December um our teachers work very hard to keep our sixth graders um focused on Sixth Grade their job as sixth graders is to become as proficient as they can in sixth grade standards they should not be thinking in December about being
027seventh graders furthermore we narrowly dodged um a very bad weather day which occurred on the sat on Saturday um it's just not ideal additionally when we're talking about teachers being asked to assign students to remedial classes or give suggest questions for that we aren't even halfway through the school year that's not practical a lot of things happen in the next four to five months this decision was solely made based on mcaffrey Administration Desiring more time to create their master schedule this is not a student centered decision and I I take issue with that um we were told that it was based on teacher request uh we could not find a single teacher who could support that claim this was again um a decision made to make um administration's job more simple um to give them
028more time to do something that administrative staff has been able to do for decades um well I don't know how long mcaffry has been a school but you get my point we have this has never been this early before um anyways the other thing I wanted to do as we as I address this is I want to remind you based on the data we looked at last um at the last meeting G elementary teachers are exceeding the county and the state as far as percentage of students who are meeting or exceeding state standards in both mathematics and and language arts your staff is making this happen and so now my question to you is as a leader how are you going to continue helping us move in that direction and I would invite you to
029sit down with groups of Educators and listen to their concerns their ideas and their suggestions in an environment that's not like this because this does not promote dialogue I would invite you to do that um and last but not least again I just want to say um your staff members they are a key part of the puzzle of the Student Success of Student Success and achievement and I really encourage you if you're looking for answers don't leave us out of that conversation so thank you I wish you a good evening and a happy holiday thank you now we have I reports yes so we are starting with um elcap goal one trauma inform training will be our first report I'll turn it over to co start good evening so as we have shared at previous
030meetings we were awarded a grant funded through the Department of Health Care Services to provide training and velop in-house uh capacity and Trauma informed practices Susan Jones who's walking up to the podium right now um has 25 years of individual experience in building connecting aware awareness and resilient environments where colleagues student staff families and people have the chance to thrive and do better Susan has provided districtwide training um on two occasions and has a third schedule for March uh she is currently working with a couple of school sites and implementing the wellness centers has a book study um to be launched after the new year and uh provides coaching and training U by monthly to our Wellness coaches um we also have scheduled a training for our classified staff starting in January as well so
031with that I would like to introduce Susan who can share some information around what she's provided for our staff so far thank you Susan thank you col je so first off congratulations and thanks for having me and uh I just want to share with this uh two-year Grant process has um been a had a a running out the door start what K Jeet just shared has all been done since we started school in August and uh this two-year Grant go ahead in thank you um really starts with having a better understanding of normalizing what is our stress response system this isn't just about the students that have experienced uh significant levels of trauma it's really getting into understanding that we all have stress response systems and we either react or we respond and um teaching
032about our stress response system you can see on the slide we have um normal stress which is is that little kick of adrenaline and cortisol that we all have and we actually need for our brains and our bodies to remain functional and then we have um something that's called tolerable stress every single one of us has experienced something that felt very very stressful in the moment but in the back of your mind you actually knew you were going to be able to get through it and be okay and then we have something called toxic stress and that's really what we address in the word trauma so a lot of our uh students stud families a lot of people across the entire nation actually have experienced high levels of trauma but to have a better understanding
033of our stress response systems and how our brains and our bodies work through these different moments of time is really the beginning to be able to unravel what might be happening in front of you as an educator with a student with a parent or even with a colleague so toxic stress is what I'm going to address is the red zone that's when we will really have that heightened reactive um stress response that I'm going to show a little hand model of a brain If you take your your thumb and wrap it inside your your hand and you wrap your fingers around what this is is your prefrontal cortex on the outside and your amygdala on the inside and what this signifies is when we are becoming very very reactive our lid flips and I like
034to say nobody here in this room has ever flipped their lid right so again I'm normalizing the fact that we have the ability to respond when our lid is not flipped but unfortunately the majority of the time when we are overly stressed our lid begins to flip a little or yes it completely flips one of my favorite uh memories as a fourth grade student this was a years and years ago and I was teaching and he said Miss Jones Miss Jones and I was overwhelmed and I turned and I looked at him and he goes and I thought oh my gosh he's he's listening to me he's recognizing that my lid is flipped in this moment so normalizing our stress response systems is the first most important component of bringing a trauma aware um resilient
035building component forward and all of this is based on something that is called the adverse childhood experiences study are you guys Amar I'm just curious okay the adverse childhood experiences studying I'm going to go through it very quickly um it is an easy read and easily accessible online it was done in the mid 90s by Dr feli and and and what they discovered was that when a child experiences some level of abuse neglect or household dysfunction and those are the 10 different criterias of those three different Arenas what comes later in life is a very correlation to behavioral physical or mental health concerns later in life go ahead and switch the slide I switched the slide away pretty quickly because I'm going to talk about something that is your Ace score and what I don't
036want you doing right now is figuring out what your Ace score is in the middle of a board meeting so what I do ask you to do though is go online and look at the adverse childhood experiences study and see what your a score is and you're going to discover that at least 2third of the population in this study that was done in the mid90s 2third of the population that was predominantly Caucasian and predominantly college educated had actually experienced some level of adversity in childhood the reason why this is so important and this is what we've been teaching the last couple of months is this is what causes our Lids to flip much more easily than to be able to connect communicate be present be authentic be vulnerable learn engage Focus all of those components
037that we need for our students in order to be successful as well as our staff and our families so that is in a nutshell of what we have done a deep dive in over the past couple of months and the impacts are on perceptions what we perceive is based on what is actually a threat so when your lid is flipped you are consistently scanning the environment for perceived or for some people very actual real threats that do exist sometimes throughout their entire lives and that can be based on culture race a whole plethora of different things but what the impacts are is on beh behavior and communication go ahead so what we're doing throughout all of this increasing awareness about the Asus study and as well as our stress response systems and the impacts of
038communication learning Focus engagement uh resiliency relationships is that all of these different shifts in resilience building are things as are these PDS the book studies the things that K Jeet mentioned already coaching and encouraging the wellness team the wellness team is actually going to be doing breakout sessions on these different topics at our next whole staff uh PD in March um I'm doing site visits observations um we're really just increasing the awareness that Lids flip and normalizing what that is and what it looks like and how to actually bring a lot of these practices that are based on really just bringing regul to our students as well as our staff and our families so all those regulation practices is a whole plethora of different tools we've shared many different lists of tools through the different
039PDS and workshops and also with the wellness team and they're going to be representing and doing a deeper dive on some of them in the March PD but really it's all based on regulation and then be able to of course the goal is to be able to increase the academic engagement for our students students thank you Susan no small task thank you Susan any questions holidays have a good night do you guys have any questions feedback thank you for that informative sure absolutely thank you Susan oh after the meeting's over um if you just if you just Google the adverse childhood experiences study it'll come up thanks thank you all right so we'll move on to our second report under elcap goal one District reading assessment data our Dr for fall 2024 turn over to
040Cle thank you and as kaai um puts on the screen the the report uh I want to remind you that our district administers a the reading assessment three times per year to all students in grades K3 we refer to this District assessment as the Dr District reading assessment the purpose of the uh Dr is to measure students ability to Bland and manipulate letter sounds it measures students knowledge of spelling patterns and sight words as well as assessing reading fluency and accuracy we use the reading rope that's the um uh graphic you see there to guide our work in the area of literacy the Dr measures progress on word recognition which is the bottom portion of the Rope part of our elab goal one includes an increase of Dr results by 10% each year we measure
041this growth from Spring to Spring the data sets included in your pocket reflect the overall results for the percent of students who met all of the reading targets for the first trimester so if we take a look at the first data set which is this one here um this data set reflects results by school and by grade level overall you can see that most of our schools have more than 60% of our students meeting targets if you look at the overall you can see that Lake Canyon came in at 67% of the students meeting all the reading targets for K3 if you take a look at Kinder I want to um highlight again Lake Canyon with 82% of the children meeting the targets I want you to take a look at Val o 80% of
042the children uh meeting Targets in first grade again I want to highlight Lake Canyon 74% of the children meeting targets I want you to look at Val 85% of the children meeting Targets this includes children in our DLI program our dual language immersion program in second grade I would like to highlight again Lake Canyon with 73 and Maringa Ranch and River Oaks both have a 67% of the children meeting Targets in third grade I would like to highlight paringa ranch with 56% of the children meeting targets if we go to the next data set here you have that same information or the same results but here we have it by District cohorts and the reason we like to look at data by cohorts is because we like to see how the same group of children
043does from year to year so we look at cohorts groups of children so if we take a look at Kinder from last year Kinder last year 74% of those children at the end of Kinder met all the reading benchmarks that same group now as first grade now we have 64% of those children meeing first grade benchmarks our goal is to increase by 10% so if you take that 74 and add 10% that's how we are we came up with the 84% Target by the end of this school year so if you take a look again last year's first grade 54% of the children met the targets now in second grade 63% of them met the target the goal is 64 so they're very close to already meeting the Target that we have for the end
044of the school year take a look at second grade from last year 54% of them met the Target that same group of children now sitting in third grade 44% of those children are now meeting the targets keep in mind that we're expecting that um 64 of them 64% of them excuse me will meet the all of the reading targets by the end of the school year and I do want to highlight all because we have children that meet the blending they meet the side words but they don't meet one specific uh group of Assessments and we don't count those children as meeting targets so we want to make sure that that percentage reflects children that have met all the reading targets for the first trimester if you take a look at Greer probably just want
045to when we say all there's Pro depending on the grade level there's probably five to eight correct different assessments and so if you're up there meeting all of them it could be up to seven eight assessments yes thank you um Lois so we have the same information by school um I'm not going to go over every single score it's the same information again we look at cohorts but for Greer I do do want to highlight um third current first and current second grade they are uh they increased that cohort increase from last spring if you take a look at Lake Canyon I would like to highlight second and third grade again they are coming in higher than last year if we go to the next set of schools for Morango Ranch I would like to
046highlight second grade the have increased uh from 44% last year to second grade now sitting at 67% for River Oaks similar scores last year's uh first grade was 48 second grade now that same group 67% of them are meeting the reading targets and for Valley Oaks um although not an increase it's pretty impressive to still maintain that 85% at the end of Kinder that same group now sitting in first grade still 85% of them are meeting the reading targets it is early in the school year um with plenty of room room for growth so we are very hopeful that we will meet or exceed the reading uh targets that we have for the spring do you have any questions or any comments my question is who sets the targets are they set by the district
047or are they set by the state how's that set we set the targets based on knowledge that we have gained from um um either research that we have looked at or previous presenters that have helped us identified targets we look at standards Matthew and we look at what skills and what is most important and at what level do we want the children coming in by looking at the future or the next grade levels um standards so we want to make sure that the targets that we have have the children ready for next year's standards I had um two questions one is so just doing some simple math say it's at 60% so you have six if there's 100 students you have 60 meeting and then there's 40 that are not meeting all of the targets
048what happens to those 40 students after third grade like are they identified as needing extra support when they move on or what is the practice and then ultimately how many are leaving the district that are not meeting the standards I think to answer that question aned we would have to look at sixth grade in the spring and we don't give the Dr to Fourth through sixth grade students so what we have is map okay um or esac okay um I I don't want to guess on what percent of the children are not ready for for high school um I would say an indication would be esbc is probably our best bet I do want to um remind us that we work with children and children are extremely unpredictable at times in front of us we
049think they have it they answer the questions they're following along they can produce writing that is exceptional and then we put a test in front of them and they don't perform yeah so it's we use um the the data with plenty of caution and we use we use multiple data we never look at one set of data to make decisions on how what to do for a child right we look at map we look at espc we look at reading fluency we look at reading accuracy we look at reading comprehension we try to listen to um a child read and based on all that then we try to determine so why is this child not producing in there are times honestly some children have anxiety with testing there's nothing we can really do about that
050um they you just put any test whether it's paper or a Chromebook and they cannot perform and if they could I I can tell you that those children are probably performing at the 90th percentile but they can't do it on the spot they just can't um we also have you know with the little ones if if they're not wearing the right shoes on the day of testing they don't do well on the test so it's it's um we work with children we we do our best but we certainly take into consideration that one set of data even this even though these scores have multiple sets is not enough to make decisions on what to do for a child um I can tell you that we have a former tosa that was part of the mtss
051process that has provided support to Children um in the intermediate grades Jessica anything that you can add um we do Provide support and I use the mtss process the multi-tiered support system uh process to look at those students who are struggling looking at those multiple data points and then finding ways to support them in the classroom whether that's um additional um support with in math or uh reading and we use data to drive that support and then if necessary looking at the steps which which could be a 504 it could be IEP testing whatever that might be but we do have um a system in place at all of our school sites to support those Learners great thank you and then my second question is so on where some of the percentages perhaps um indicates
052a higher level of need um in the results there's probably some students then that are like the higher performers how do you ensure that they are actually getting the what they need to reach their full potential as well how is that balanced I I don't want to speak for teachers but if I could give you a general answer that's why we have an encourage small group instruction right because we do have children that um don't really need us Annette right and and I have a feeling that some of you sitting up here probably went into Kinder already as readers so what do we do for children that come in as readers right how do we um maintain and support children who um who who need a lot more than what we can offer because they're
053that much Advanced and that's why we encourage small group because that's probably the best way we can provide groups of children um what they need to do that it requires time it requires excellent classroom management it requires um you know that maybe for our new teachers that someone is guiding you and supporting you so we we try to do that with a mentor teacher for our new teachers because um you know some may may not know how to do that doing small group instruction although it's easy for me to say well just do small group instruction it's it's actually challenging to do that and it's challenging to do that as the children get older because as you are working with one group of children if you're lucky you have an IIA working with another group
054but then you might have two groups working independently and how do you balance and at the time of a child working independently with a child working one-on-one with the teacher which you know that's powerful but there's not enough time in a school day to do that but to answer your question small group instruction addresses the needs of the the children who need more repetition and the children who are waiting for the next steps that's the best way we can do that yeah I can just it's it's really impossible to meet the needs of all of your students in the class whether you have 18 kids 20 kids 30 kids 32 kids without differentiating and providing small group instruction because your kids are at all different levels whether they're below grade level on grade level or
055above grade level and so we are very fortunate that we have we have excellent teaching staff that provide small group instruction we have had more of a push especially at intermediate to require our intermediate teachers to use the small group instruction that's provided in Benchmark that is our English language arts curriculum and there is small group instruction embedded into that program and it should be a big part of what you are doing um teaching Ela or English language arts to intermediate students because that Gap is even larger when you get to fourth fifth sixth grade and up um we do what helps too I think is a lot of our online courseware because most of our online courseware is differentiated and it's at the students level and in many cases when a teacher is pulling
056small groups students are working on this courseware that's at their level um also I think we're very fortunate to have the level of instructional assistance that we do on our district um it is unique there are many districts that do not have the level of instructional assistance all of our primary classrooms have IA support for small group instruction and a lot of our our intermediate do as well and we base that support based on student need in those classrooms and so um we we just it's it's a good system that's we're seeing growth I'm excited to see that a lot of these numbers or these percentages are getting closer to 80% ultimately we want 10% growth each year but the goal is really to get to that 80% just the whole bell curve if you
057can get 80% of those kids reading on grade level you're doing a great job and so it just you know when you ask okay 40% might go on to the next grade level not reading at grade level I I think it doesn't mean that all 40% of those are really really behind they might just be missing one assessment maybe they're just missing site wordss but they might be reading even above grade level so you really have to look at your data multiple sets and then like Jessica said the multi-tiered systems of support um when we have students that are are really struggling I would say the 15% of a grade level that probably are missing multiple assessments um there's systems in place for them and and sometimes we end up testing for special education um
058but we have to show that we've had interventions in place before we can do that as well so I think we're we're starting to see growth definitely thank you it's very helpful I want to add um Annette that we also recognize that children are that are extremely high they're also at risk it's the same risk as our children that are falling behind the ones at the top 10% they're also at risk so then we we do try to monitor the the progress of that top 10% because they could easily drop um but before we move on um Joshua is uh I think he has something to share I was just going to um add you know the question about what we do for an extension for students who are more advanced it's actually really um
059impressive to see when a strong teacher does it um I had the opportunity of mango to see this probably about a month ago in which I went into a classroom for an observation and during that observation they they the students were working on math and kind of um like superintendent y shared um some of the students there was a small group of them that were working on one of their supplemental online programs and then the teacher had taken a group of students who were struggling and they were using math manipulatives with the teacher a group of about three or four students and then there was a small group of about five or six who were doing an extension activity that was more complicated math in a collaborative group and I kind of checked in on
060them and I was so impressed with what they were doing because these students could have this conversation could resolve these problems and then the teacher could focus on these others and then check back in and so it was nice to see that professionalism when it is working well you can get what everybody needs and still support the students that are the most needy as far as Learners so it's nice to see action when it happens and and to end I for the children that are very Advanced what we try to encourage on it is that those children don't want more they want different so um again the needs of of that 10% we do keep in mind thank you we have a public comment related to this report Miss C hey thank you um while
061you all were speaking it just kind of sparked some thoughts for me um so I have anything prepared so I apologize if it's a bit disjointed um I guess I will start miss cozie you asked how we can engage um what percent of students are not prepared to go to high school last year in last month excuse me in the board packet the map data showed that eth graders we only had approximately 44% meeting grade level standards and 41% from mathematics that means approximately 60% are not ready to go to high school um I will also address I guess a couple other items um for those kids that are above grade level like mine they are being forgotten I will tell you that right now I walked into my daughter's classroom last year fifth grade
062and I'd say a little over half the kids were below grade level some of them were still at first grade reading levels first and second grade reading levels you have 30 plus kids in that class that teacher cannot teach those kids that are at a first grade reading level and a high school reading level they cannot all get a proper attention Okay when you look at math again you had kids that were way below grade level you had my daughter and a few other kids they were testing at high school math levels so what did the teacher have to do she stayed after class she worked with those kids she worked with my daughter so that she would actually get some attention but how can we expect our teachers to be stretched the thin that's
063not acceptable and why are we cutting IIA positions like we did a few months ago librarian hours like we did a few months ago when our budget is sitting at 11 plus perc in reserve I think that this Board needs to really look at that budget and go line by line and really speak to the teachers and really figure out what's going on in 2016 I started looking at this data more than two-thirds of the students were passing on map for reading and math and now we're at 44% and 41% for eighth graders that that just it's not acceptable and I think that you all need to do more thank you thank you we ready to move to the next report yes any other comments or question if not we'll move on to the dashboard
064thank you the California dashboard was released to the public on November 21st uh the California dashboard provides the public with information on both school and District progress on several local and state indicators it goes beyond test scores it focuses on multiple measures it replex reflect status and change there are five performance levels or colors red orange yellow green and blue with blue being the highest we need to see or they need to see two sets of data or two years growth to calculate the difference and then obtain a color so that's how you get a color with two sets of data on the next uh thank you so tonight we will share the progress on the academic performance the academic engagement and conditions and climate this is District out a glance the first five indicators
065are the ones we will talk about tonight these are the state indicators the last five are the local indicators and we brought these two to you back in June so the California dashboard is a combination of both both state and local indicators or measures here is the academic performance for language arts math and English learner progress with um English language arts we have a performance level of green we are um Five Points below the standard we did increase by um Five Points I do want to highlight that mang Ranch and maccaffrey obtained a performance level of green in the area of language arts in math we are 36 points below the standard we maintained even though it shows a negative of of three points because each indicator has a different by by 5x5 um table
066we can go into that in a different time but even though we still have a a negative three points it's still within the maintain range and for mathematics Lake Canyon Morango River Oaks and Valley Oaks they have a performance level of yellow with the English learner progress um 50% of our students are English Learners are making progress we did decline by um almost 5% um I do want to highlight that Lake Canyon River Oaks are green and maccaffrey shows a performance level of blue in this area there's a lot of information that I can give you overall what I want you to walk away with is that we are certainly showing progress with Ela we are hurting still in the area of math um but we are maintaining and in the area of English learner
067progress even though we show Orange that we do have schools that have that are making much greater progress than what what um that shows this is again looking at the academic performance at a district level the next two areas uh KET will talk to us about all right thank you Cleo so for academic engagement the indicator that measures that is The Chronic absenteeism and um you know we've talked about chronic absenteeism here on multiple occasions and uh we we saw District One wide a pretty significant decline in the number of students that meet that criteria um so we were able to increase our um our color range to Yellow um and just kind of uh briefly The Chronic absenteeism indicator is triggered for TK through 8th grade and it is based on the number of
068students who were absent 10% or more of the school year and here um decline we we want to see decline right we don't want to see increase so as we see that uh the number of students declining then our scores go um up um although we did see an overall decrease for all student groups we did have two student groups that we saw the least amount of decline with and that was our African-American students and our long-term English Learners um sitewide we saw pretty significant declines Lake Canyon s 22% decline Morango so s 12% River Oaks 6% valo 10% Greer 18% and mcaffrey 10% um Fair sites was the only site that we saw an increase in the number of students that are chronically absent um Fair sight is our TK population and um historically
069we have seen higher absenteeism with our Kinder students and so I did project that we'd see it in our TK um TK group and and the and the team over there are looking at kind of how we can strengthen that practice but overall um you know really some great gains and once again I do want to highlight the site teams that worked really hard for this you're talking about your sighted Administration your social work workers your office staff that do the the the you know the work in the trenches to make sure that the kids are at school so great job to site administrators and site teams okay okay so the conditions in climate uh indicator is measured with our suspension rates um and suspension is um so we have declined slightly but we did
070Decline and again we want to see less suspensions so this indic represents the the number the percent of students who were suspended for at least one full day okay um during the school year we did see a couple of student groups that have increased suspension from rates and that's our African-American students and our uh long-term English Learners um two or more races and then our students that uh were identified as Filipino um however we saw declined suspension rates for our students with disabilities our hermatic students homeless students um our socioeconomically disadvantaged students our Els and our Asian Asian student groups um we saw a decline at Lake Canyon River Oaks mcaffrey Valley Oaks maintained um and there was some slight increases with our Morango and Greer campuses and sometimes the increases could mean that they
071were significantly uh less suspensions last year so even one more student bumps them on that um 5 by5 grid and then kind of bumps them up to the next level but um definitely we are moving the needle towards the more positive we have lots of systems in place at each of the school sites um Greer mcaffrey has implemented Greer is two years in but mcaffrey is starting it this year the positive behavior interventions and supports this is a very uh structured consistent way to identify behavioral expectations teach those expectations and reinforce those expectations and then having very systematic process in place for um students that do break those rules so these are evidence-based practices that help to um address behavioral needs on school campuses thank you co on the next slide you see all the
072schools out a glance by the same five indicators that plus that you see indicates that that school improved one at least one performance level in that area so for Lake Canyon you see the plus with suspension so they um are doing better they um went to a green performance level Morango and English language arts they increased by one level at River Oaks suspensions Valley Oaks English language arts um Greer two areas English learner progress and suspensions and maccaffrey they increase in four areas English language arts English learner progress chronic absenteeism and suspensions on the very last um slide we do want to share with you that when we look at English language arts math and um suspensions for a specific group the long-term English learner that ltel English a long-term English learner that means children
073that have been English have been identified as English learners for seven or more years so for that specific group because of their performance in ela math and suspensions we have been identified as needing support from our County office that support is called differentiated assist differentiated assistance we had our first meeting actually this morning and our goal is to work side by side with the county to come up with a process to improve the results for that particular student group with that um any questions any thoughts I I know it's a lot of information it's it's a lot of percentages it's a lot of numbers it's a lot of words about declining improving and colors I think overall what again what I want you to walk away with is that everyone is trying their best to
074give children our best and we aren't losing ground we continue to make gains sometimes there's baby steps sometimes we see pretty large uh growth but we're not declining we're not going backwards with any of these um indicators local or state um you have an admin team that works extremely hard you have a very committed and dedicated teaching staff you have a classified staff that will do anything to help children but again we work with children and each child has individual needs we do our best to meet individual needs but when you have 32 or 34 children our best approach is small group we cluster them um and again I want to highlight that that top 10% is also at risk so we we look at that group also um with that any thoughts or any
075questions I just wanted to share Cleo too that with the sko differentiated assistance um I wanted to really highlight that Val Oaks the growth that valy Oaks has made um and mcaffrey actually last year they were on an ATS academic team support they had to note that in their school plans and we found out today that they are no longer in that group and that none of our schools are on the CDE California Department of Education list of needing that kind of support and so um I think if if if you watch these scores for a while I think you you're probably seen the growth that Valley Oaks is making um their scores are now um you know comparable to the other Elementary School sites and and they have been historically lower in the past
076and they have a different population as well um you know more more English Learners more students that um are qualifying for a free and reduced population and so um I really want to highlight that growth that we have been seeing at Valley Oaks um it is huge great and I also want to just remind us and and caution us although I don't like even going back to you know referencing anything with the pandemic and that but we have to be careful that we're not referencing um academic data or even attendance data pre pandemic we we can't look at scores really previous because we all know we took a huge loss when schools were closed and students were not in class and we've talked about that a lot we came out of that pandemic with scores
077in the teens you know attendance record you know chronic absenteeism almost in the 30s high 20s and so we've got to really look at how we are growing since then and and I think we should feel proud as as a district or as board teachers staff Administration the growth that we we have made since then yeah so just the one thing I was going to ask is it I saw that it said chronic absenteeism has dropped 12% and I was just going to see is there any particular reason why you think that has happened and I also noticed like on the third to last slide it showed that fair sight was readed for chronic absenteeism so they obviously had like the worst chronic absenteeism so is there any particular reason why you feel like it's
078dropped 12% that seems like a considerable drop as like the district been doing something to try to address that and then like also with Fair sight do younger students are they typically more chronically absentee is that kind of how that works I don't know I really don't know absolutely so yes so we actually last year did put together an attendance campaign um this entailed um creating attendance teams at every School site and that consisted of uh a site administrator a social worker their attendance clerks and then they looked at their data monthly and then we met as a district monthly as well and we were trying to identify Trends uh best practices um and all and also addressing barriers to why kids were coming to school so a very concerted consistent effort we also put
079into place um home visiting so if we if our kids aren't showing up our parents aren't um answering our phone calls we went to the home to figure out okay what's going on um then the second step is after you know we've uh proactively put some things into place these sites hold what are called um attendance review team meetings with the parents again this is intended for parents and the school sites to have these uh this collaborative partnership in terms of tell us what you need so we can help you to get to school um and then obviously if it continues to um attendance doesn't improve then there are certain um educational code requirements for the district to hold and like sarb type of meeting so the messaging I think the messaging districtwide was the
080same um at back to school every administrator had the same slides around attendance so doesn't matter if you went to Valley Oaks mcaffrey River Oaks everybody was communicating the same message about attendance so that played a huge huge role and and definitely the incentives that each School sites puts into place for their own kind of daily attendance um you know perks that helps as well so that's what we saw um we saw we we see a fair sight TK is in red and it really mirrors what we used to see with kindergarten um TK is only half day um and sometimes you know uh with the fouryear olds um parents may feel okay you know if they have a little sniffle or you don't want to go to school that day then there's this greater
081um response of keeping them home so um it is something that we are going to continue to address um I'm not as surprised to see it I kind of anticipated it's now there the you know the lower grade level so and and TK is not compulsory right and so compulsory education starts at six six years of age TK is for our um five year olds right turning four turning five so and parents see that they know that you don't have to go to TK or don't have to go to kindergarten so yeah there was another question you asked yeah wondering if like if at the lower ages at kindergarten if you expect to see more absenteeism we do we do but majority of our schools have full day Kinder programs now so that that does
082help okay um I think it's those half day programs with our younger you know grade levels okay it's TK they don't have kindergarten there right correct it's preschool and TK okay and the preschool is run by the state right correct they run by the state yeah and that is not factored into the dashboard okay yeah thank you yep I had um a couple questions so and my apologies if you already said this in your presentation um how is English learner progress measured I'm going to say both questions and then you can answer them together and then the valley O's red um Factor I'm guessing that that doesn't reflect the DLI program and that hopefully the go is that that program will continue to make gains in that Arena so that that would possibly you know
083move that needle so that's that's it the English language learning progress yeah so the the English language progress is measured by elpac so it and that test specifically measures how well children are learning the English language with the drop at Valley uh David Nelson and his team started looking at the data a little more deeply last year they redesignated um I want to say between 50 and 60 children that scored at the highest level of elpac so when you remove the top the younger children taking the test for the first time may not score as high as the children that have been taking it for three or four years or five years so then it's not that we should expected a net but it makes sense that if if we remove the children scoring a
084four then it's going to take us a little while to kind of build up um that group so and we can't re redesignate them as proficient English Learners until they reach that level four so they remain eel's until they get to a level four once they reach a level four as well as doing well in their um reading and and having good grades and good writing samples then those are the children we redesignate as fluent English speakers I don't know if that answers your question yeah so it sounds sort of like a nice problem to have right that the yes that you've done more of yes English Learners being successfully but then that impacts the number data yes but it is a nice problem to have yes what we want and again it's how we
085view the data and you know I can make numbers look any way I want right and all of us any of us but it really kind of does explain why the how did we go from Blue to Red in in 10 months well it's because we redesignated and and we want to make sure that we redesignate as many children as possible because if if we don't and they go to mcaffrey seel's they don't have access to an exploratory we place all those children in an ELD um class removing an exploratory from the same thing happens when they go as Els to high school they may not have access to all those wonderful electives because we have to place them in either a second Ela class or ELD class and again lowering their chances of getting
086enough of the right credits for them to then qualify to go to the college they may want to so it's critical that we reclassify as many children as possible as soon as they meet the criteria thank you that's very helpful the last thing I want to say before we move on with everything else this is our biggest competition in any class in any grade for any age group I do think that at some point we as a system need to recognize that what children need now is very different from what we have been trained to do what we have been trained to do we do it well some teachers do it exceptionally well but this is the concept constant competition so I do think at some point some of the things that we do have
087to change otherwise we will always have the same scores that we see right now in it we're not going to go beyond the 60 the 65% if we want to go beyond that then we have to recognize that the children the children's needs have changed the way they learn has changed the immediate information that we cannot provide we can't provide information or entertainment at this level it we just can't so something's going to have to change at some point in the classrooms thank you so much I just wanted to address two of the items that were talked about and so I was looking I first of all I've seen this this I think this is the third time I've seen this set of data um and I think the thing that always jumps out to
088me when I look at it is the suspension measurement and so it's interesting to me that it's included in the dashboard I've always thought it is interesting that it's included because it is something that we I would say have the least amount of control over because would we like to see Zero suspensions absolutely we would um but the reality is that students make choices that are unsafe for themselves and for others and so we actually have an obligation um when that does happen to protect the rest of the population from those choices and so I would I'm just and so what I have to say next piggybacks on that um because I did visit Greer about three weeks ago and Stephanie sat down with me and showed me and I'm sorry I forget the terminology
089for the PBI is that what it is PBIS um it is intense and it is a big ask of teachers I was pretty amazed um basically what you're doing is you're tracking student behavior in like 90 minute blocks would you say that's like that's accurate and so you have teachers who are or whoever is in charge of that you're having them basically track and it is it's it is a team effort with the student the student understands and they're on it and and I think it is a big incentive for them but I also recognize the intensity of that for the staff so that's I just wanted to to put that out there that I've actually seen this and I do think it's an interesting visit if this is something that we're looking at implementing
090school or districtwide I think it's an interesting thing for the rest of you guys to maybe look at and I know Greer has been has had it the longest so yeah it Greer is in their second year and the idea is um that you have um it's a tiered response right so that first tier are these Universal practices that you have in place and then as students are requiring more assistance um the individualized programs are put into place and that's probably what you're referring to when you had um a teacher or an IIA having to document um behavioral incidences for specific student um we've been very fortunate with the grant to be able to um have an additional uh board certified behavior analyst work with Greer and and Greer is seeing some results like out
091on their playground and um some of the training is around um kind of how do you respond positively right how do you how do you encourage students to make the right decisions and that's about responding in the positive manner so thank you do we have anything else related to that can we move on okay okay we are on to other reports I'll start with the measure H facility Bond update um thank you to the voters and G um the measure has passed it was close but it passed a little over 56% I think it was 56.5% we've included for you the certification of facts with the total number of votes in both San haen and Sacramento counties um our next steps with this we will be bringing to the board in January a board resolution
092that would need to be adopted certifying um moving forward with this with B the bond um we also are in the process of establishing an oversight committee we need to bring that to the board in February to appoint the oversight committee um members cannot be an employee or an elected official um so we are actively recruiting um members of the community that would like to serve on this on this committee so it's just it's a huge investment this $27 million what this will do to improve our schools our facilities um quality of Education of a lot of it is related the your your facilities impact student performance it impacts morale for staff um your neighborhood it increases your home value there's just so much that goes along with positives when you you have the funds
093to keep your facilities upgraded safe clean and top-of-the-line technology or supports um facil ities for teaching staff has there been any interest yet for PE people in the community to be on the oversight committee not yet not yet I have um a little message about it that will go in the January newsletter um I have a few in mind that I that I probably will personally reach out to um I I think I have a few that that might join how many people do you need five to eight 5 to eight is ideal and we will meet in the beginning once the bond first starts probably meet for or five times a year um the the purpose of the oversight committee is to make sure that we're spending the funds the way the funds were
094intended to be spent reviewing audits reviewing expenditures um that's what the the goal is or the purpose of an oversight committee thank you you ready to move on to our final yes so two more reports so I just wanted to highlight that we had a team that attended the California School Board Association conference um December 5th to 7th I was I was there with Alejandra gabbe our chief business officer Casey raboy and Matthew Ward um we were each going to just highlight um one or two two items the takeaways I would say from from that conference or the sessions there's lots of breakout sessions there's a couple keynote speakers and then you have the rest of the day to attend various different breakout sessions we provided for you um a glimpse of what was offered
095um I don't know if anybody would like to jump in and say a few words or yeah so I was able to attend that conference two weeks ago and I was very grateful for that opportunity and some of the highlights for me including included so number one I went to the new orientation training which was a one-day training and for me that was really helpful because obviously I don't come from a school background so that was really helpful in terms of understanding the role of the superintendent versus the board members principles Etc so that was really good also kind of gave an introduction to the brown act which was great for me also really it gave a whole cheat sheet for the parliamentary procedures which is really good for me as far as understanding like
096how to make em motion and second emotion and all those good things U I went to several breakout sessions so most notably on understanding the revised Title 9 regulations I went to one of those breakout sessions and then most notably for me were the sessions on AI so that the sessions on AI they like really really blew my mind just on like how AI is being used by uh districts as well as schools and so most notably they were talking about a program called notebook LM where you can actually take the school board agenda package and you can actually put it in upload it and it'll literally turn it into a podcast between a man and a woman speaking to each other so I I did that I took this P I took the schb
097agenda for this meeting I put it in there two days ago and it turned into a 29 Minute Podcast like light-hearted jovial between a man and a woman talking to each other about oh did you know GS going electric they're getting electric buses and all it's like it was really cool it was like scary like I cannot even believe I'm hearing this right now it's blowing my mind and then just today I was in class with um working with Miss Nelson students and one of the students was talking about how they use I think called Magic AI where they'll literally analyze their writing and give them real-time feedback on what they did well or what they need to do better and the kids were just amazed that this is even available so am I I'm
098amazed as well and so those are two uh also like what was really U valuable to me was just getting to know the team getting to know Lois Alejandra spend time with Casey and also the high school team including uh Anna tranell Kristen Terry Melissa and Carol so that was good just to get to know like what's people's background where are they from what are they what's their role like what issues has the district dealt with in the past what are they dealing with now that was really good um same with like at the breakout sessions for the board the board orientation just being able to sit with the city of sack U board representatives and talk to them like okay what's going on in the city of sack what are the issues and some
099of them talking about they having to closed schools like that being a real issue and so that was really helpful to me and the last thing I will mention is that um the day after the conference I did email csba csba and I did Express observations that I made regarding political s sexual expressions at the conference in terms of one of the speakers and attendees and then I did I had a follow-up conversation with the chief Communications officer Troy Flynn to basically understand like what is allowable expression at the meetings as far as from speakers as well as attendees as far as like what can you wear as far as making a political expression or text on your shirt or etc etc so we did have a conversation and he clarified for me like what
100they will enforce or not enforce and so that was helpful and that's where that was left and that we had a good conversation and then I understand that the 2025 conference will be in Sacramento and I'll look forward to attending that hopefully thank you Casey would you like to highlight anything or uh yeah I had three um favorite sessions I did attend one on AI um enjoyed it learned a lot I did attend one on mental health and it was kind of a different take um they showed um the importance of District nurses as being the first line of the mental health Team and also being um a licensed person in the school the often the person that administers medication for ADHD and and um other types of medication for seizures and different disorders um
101and being part of that team and also their presence seemed to uh increase attendance thereby helping the school's overall attendance rate so it was very interesting I had never thought about that um and yeah no I just a lot to intake and I enjoyed the whole conference I look forward to it being up North near us so we don't have to do the flight it is a great networking opportunity I really enjoyed getting to know our our team that was there our own District team but then also um getting to know know the high school team as well um I I think one of my biggest takeaways was AI um I attended two different breakout sessions I couldn't believe how many breakout sessions were related to AI almost every session there was at least one
102you could attend um one of the takeaways I'll I'll not forget this now but he said sometimes you think of art the word artificial artificial intelligence there could be a negative connotation with artificial he encouraged us to use amplify intelligence Ai and augment intelligence AI um it was really it was mindblowing to see what some districts are are doing some districts one District in particular even um in our County um but it's just I was really thinking of the lens of what we need to do next and how we need to support our teachers with AI and staff in general not just our teachers there was one District that shared they were from a county office a large County office but they were sharing just how ready how already their HR department is using AI
103to save time with um with reports or data um curriculum Department's using AI to data reports that used to take you two weeks to run you can put it in AI if you know the right systems and get it done in hours and so just what what do we need to do and it kind of goes along with what Cleo said we have to start thinking differently are kids have been using many of our kids have been using AI for a long time already and what do we need to do in the classroom um what policies do we need to put in place um before we really launch this we already have quite a few teachers across our district that are using this magic school and are already starting to share successes and how it
104is enhancing instruction and how it's saving them time um grading and planning so um you know definitely some thought I I think we do as a district need to put a plan in place on how we're going to address this and making sure that we have appropriate staff um to to train and help us with policy just to add and I agree I I I'm thankful for the opportunity I was able to network and um get to know our board members a little bit more um and I I I attended several um workshops so one of the ones that I got attracted to the most was maximizing Grant impact and enhancing school districts financials it provided me a lot of resources so I could go out there and see what we could apply for the
105district for any grants um any uh available opportunities and some of them that are currently out there I'm going to be researching in the next month or so so what does it look like for safety um security um it it was a great Workshop where they provided us the direct resources where to find this information and the steps to take to try to get those grants so be looking into that a little bit more um another one that it's uh I liked it's the school Finance for board members it gave me a perspective to see what board members would like to see a a different view of what I normally um view our financials but it helped me see another perspective of a board so it was it was a great opportunity and I was
106thankful for it thank you okay our last report we'll do our school calendars and I I know we have some of our administrators that are online with us tonight if they're online we'll have them report if they're not I can report further school we'll start with faight laara Marquez is she with us tonight yes I'm here can you hear me little bit go ahead Laura okay um at fairsite in January we have several field trips going on our TK team uh taking their students to the wow Museum in Loi that's the world of Wonders and we have a couple of preschool classes who regularly take a walking field trip to the G library and then on January 22nd we have a puppet show assembly and that is for all of our students all of our
107preschoolers and TK students um and that will be at 2 times in the morning to accommodate our our school in our little cafeteria thank you thank you Lara uh Greer Elementary I believe we have Leah wheeler online with us yes I am here good evening sorry I couldn't be there I got the got to go and enjoy our staff Christmas party that was hosted at one of our teachers homes this evening so I appreciate you guys letting me zoom on in I am going to be presenting um f grer and what is happening in January is we will um be working with the sa County DA's office and bringing the I smart presentations to our campus on January 9th and they are going to be doing those presentations with our fifth and sixth grade classes
108um above and beyond that I think Jessica Rogers is there she's gonna um present for Valley Oaks along with River so I'm going to roll it on over to her because we share our sites now thank you Miss wheeler I will just go next Lake Canyon I will present for Lake Canyon tonight I would like to share that on January 31st they are having a family dance at 6: p.m. then we will move on to mcaffrey Mr Sate yes good evening members of the board um so a lot of stuff happening over at mcaffrey we're so excited so um as was already brought up we recently were able able to welcome some of our incoming seventh graders to mcaffrey and we have also as a result on the 7th um coming up an incoming 7eventh
109grade parent webinar where we give that opportunity via Zoom to get some parents some information on kind of not only what their students heard but how they're going to be able to register for classes some of the selection process and all the other steps that are concomittant with getting into this transition into the middle school um also the day after on the eth we have a motivational assembly this is something that we often will try to do when we get our students come back we'll give them a reminder of some of the expectations at mcaffry Middle School go through our handbook and also just help remind them what they should be focused on the academics they should be focused on supporting each other right um getting ready for their transition to high school focusing on
110the some of the tests that are coming up and just being good neighbors to all of their friends and helping people at the school um additional things if you look on the calendar on the 22nd and the 29th kind of going along with this incoming seventh grade transition is this this is kind of that time of preparation for some of the transitions is that this is often where high schools do their Shadow Days as well so we have our eighth graders going and visiting the high schools kind of like we have our incoming sixth graders our incoming seventh graders do the same so this is their opportunity to go over to the high schools check out some of the classes get to know the administration the counselor some of the teachers and just get excited
111about this opportunity it reminds me of my previous job as a high school leadership teacher and how we would welcome kids in that kind of jam January February and just get them excited and at maccaffrey you know we hear you know kind of what is said and it is hard in these transitions but we also try to focus on hey you see what's coming your way focus on that class focus on your eighth grade year focus on your sixth grade year get ready because excitement is coming some changes and you need to be ready and you need to focus on what you're doing now to be ready for the future and it's a really good opportunity for them I'll pivot over to Morango um so a few different things happen at Mingo um girls basketball
112is going on so there's a lot of practices you can see some of those practices in the calendar with um first games coming up and some of those basketball games uh coming up in January additionally there's um a sips coaching so some instruction for our um instructors for our teachers that come from a very well prepared and professional trainer um Linda P that comes in and supports them so that's great for a little bit of practice with instruction on Phonics and site words and phonological awareness we also do on the 27th our School site um council meeting to hear from some of our stakeholders and know what we're doing well where we need to focus and where some of our funds are spent and just hear from some stakeholders on areas they would like to
113see us focus on and then our parent conferences the 30th and the 31st where we get to support our students who you know um are needing support from our teachers and check in with their parents and just see how their progress is going also an exciting event that's happening in January at Morango is I will be returning there again because right now I'm at mcaffrey full-time um since our colleagues are returning so I think that's a very exciting date also so thank you for that and we have Miss Rogers for River Oaks and Valley Oaks all right thank you so I um am going to report on River Oaks first so there's some like uh Josh said there's going to be basketball starting up and on the 28th is our first game they're going to
114be playing Greer and uh we're also having a PTO Bingo night and so our PTO will be putting that on on the 22nd and we have several field trips planned um to our preserve with sat with our fifth graders going to Staten Island and then our sixth graders going on uh doing their cumus field trip and I know that that's an annual trip that's put together for our students and they get to go experience uh the birds and everything at Staten Island which is wonderful it's a really great field trip and for Valley Oaks uh we're going to be uh they're also going to be having the icart presentation on the 17th and they're going to have the family on the 23rd there's the vo family math night which is going to bring our parents
115into the school with their students and they get to explore math and all the grade levels will have a different station set up and the students and the parents can do it together and that will be at 6 o'clock and um vo will also be having their on the 28th their first basketball game against Lake Canyon so uh lots of great things coming up yeah it I I near it's it's near um it's near The Preserve it's they do kind of a multi-rip they stop in at Staten Island which is um there's a Greenery somewhere out there I don't know exactly what road it's on but they get to drive down there and because it's this the an the birds are starting to come in and they get to see all the birds out with
116at the greenery and they get to look at they drive down the road see the birds and then they get to go over to The Preserve and do some more bird watching which is wonderful yeah we're getting close to the bird Festival thank you administrative team and we'll move on to consent calendar I just wanted to highlight donations um we have two donations both are going to the a department one's from Carson's industrial Plaza they donated $1,000 and then Carson's Coatings Inc donated $2,000 and again both for the maccaffrey a department one other item in the consent calendar I just wanted to highlight there were some new fundraisers for fairsite typically we bring those to the board earlier in the fall but the parent group added some more fundraisers can I get a motion to
117approve 2 2 42. 548 consent calendar thank you I have a motion from Wesley Kagel to approve item number 24 4 2548 seconded by Matthew Ward Casey raboy I Katherine Harper I Annette cozie I thank you the motion carries unanimously next we have 2 42. 549 oh we don't have anything that was removed so we'll move on from that 24255 board consideration of approval of the school districts 232 for audit report by Christy white Associates he so this is our annual um financial report for our last fiscal year and um Christy white is our Auditors and we're gonna have tonight um talking going over our audit John Peta I hope he is he on the line he'll be going over our audit and then I'll I'll be describing a little bit more um because there
118there is a finding but um the our corrective action our plan what it looks like but I'd like him to go over the it first and then I'll go more in details of what happens after thank you Alandra so I'm going to start sharing my screen can you hear me yes yeah perfect you see my slide perfect okay he's pulling it up in a bit sorry I couldn't hear you do you do you see my presentation it's coming up yes we do see it thank you perfect thank you okay so hello my name is John Peta I'm a supervisor at Christy white um so I'll be going over the financial audit report for fiscal year ending June 30 2024 and throughout my presentation slides I noted a few key Pages um if you wanted to
119follow along on the audit report which physical copy first and foremost I want to talk about the audit responsibilities so the district's or Management's responsibility is to design and Implement effective internal controls you know one of my favorite examples is segregation of Duties um so for example one person can't approve their own purchase order and make the and make the expenditure purchase um you know that's a big red flag if we you know review expenditures um so the district has done a great job with their internal control so I'll talk about that more in in the following slides another responsibility is to preparation and fair presentation of the financial statements on the other hand the auditor's responsibility is to obtain reasonable insurance that the financial statements are free from Material statement and provided related audit
120opinions there are three audit opinions that I'll be discussing in further detail on the following slides as well it is important to note that the opinion does not address the finan ccial condition of the district I'm happy to report that the district Reed an unmodified opinion which is the best possible audit opinion that means that chrisy white issued an unmodified opinion across the federal Awards op opinion the state Awards opinion and the internal control financial statement opinion um you could you you'll see this on the on the first page of the audit report in the second paragraph so going into more detail on you know the three opinions that we presented um the first one is internal control over financial reporting you know do we test accounts payable accounts receivable Revenue expenditures um Capital assets
121um we're happy to note that there's no significant deficiencies and no material weaknesses the second opinion I wanted to go over is is the federal compliance piece so the federal compliance piece is you know we don't give this to every District unless they meet the federal threshold of 750,000 expenditures for the audit year and typically G does meet that threshold so this Federal compliance opinion is you know pretty standard and we tested two major programs this year so we the first one I want to talk about is the education stabilization fund discretionary grants this includes sr2 sr3 and ARP funds but as you know we all know this this funding is a one-time funding and it's about to be exhausted so this is probably the last year that we'll be testing it and the second
122program that we tested was a Child Nutrition cluster so you know we look at the free and reduced meal program um you know the Commodities and overall we noted no significant deficiencies and no material weaknesses the last opinion and the hardest opinion to get an unmodified opinion is to State compliance piece as you can see like I this table right here is pulled directly from the audit report there's a whole bunch of areas that we test every single year and it grows every single year or twoo so I highlighted the two new ones it's proposition 28 Arts and Music in schools and expanded learning opportunities program um you know I'm sure the district is aware of all the new requirements for this the long list of them so it's really great that the district um
123did not receive any findings for these CU it was quite common for a firm especially for the elot program uh I'm still happy to report even though we did Note One finding for unduplicated um there was no significant deficiencies and no material weaknesses which still results in an unmodified opinion and I'll be discussing the finding in about two slides and this slide I just wanted to show like a summary of the audit results is also pulled directly from the audit report on page 80 um this just kind of really nicely summarizes everything I discussed on the previous slides you can see there's the financial statement piece the federal Awards piece even list out the dollar threshold used to distinguish between Type A and type B programs um the major programs tested also shows the state
124Awards opinion so there's a really nice page to refer to and finally I'm going to be discussing the audit finding in more detail so um you know students classified as free A reduced price meal eligible frpm you know who are not directly certified on the calpads 1.18 report um must have supporting documentation that indicates a student with eligible for the determination so a um we had to verify compliance which Education Code 422 38.2 um in section W of the 2324 guide for annual audits basically State audit guide um we only noted one error so you might see a difference from the physical audit report that you have and um the question cost that I have right here um so the error rate was 1 out of 24 and usually we we extrapolate that over the
125entire impacted pop population which includes the other sites but since this was you know um not a pervasive issue it was only one student at one site um we kind of interpreted the state audit guide differently it says um individual School sites so on the physical audit report that you have right now um that's over all the sites that we tested but with the new calculated question cost it's only the one site that had the except so with that in mind the extrapolated error rate dis allowed an additional two students for a total of three students the total question cost has calculated using the unduplicated people count auditing finding template total to only about 8,653 so the question cost is really low um and like I said the the method is different there's another District
126where almost the whole population was wrong and they had 60 students so that was one of the most costly findings I've ever seen um so with this method it's a lot better just because it's only one go site that was um that had to issue um is there anything else you want me to expand upon on this finding I I just want to add that the additional documentation he's referring to is the one on the binder outside um so the it's not the fiscal impact it's not that 13,000 it's that 8,000 he just went over and B basically what this means is we had one student that we had coded qualifying for free and reduced meals based on income and when they pulled the reports or they pulled the data we did not have the
127application in place for that student so we should not have been recording them as unduplicated and when you your population you get funded based on your unduplicated population so we received 8 basically $8,600 in excess because that student stent really did not qualify if that makes sense to try to explain that okay thank um John did you have okay so um I do want to add um there is a corrective action plan for this and um we've been working close to with um with our fiscal supervisor and our food um food food nutrition supervisor of a strategy one of the steps the district has taken um this year is we're going electronic we have put this form electronically in the system through the parent view app and um this will reduce the amount of any
128human error ideally we are um checking the system um by the list as well just because of this so not only are we doing this electronically but we have um another additional layer of checking these applications to make sure they're getting um they're classified correctly on the system so um it it was it was a it was a good idea that we went electronic this year it's going to hopefully prevent any future findings on this anything else you want to add John no um I'll open it up to the board for any other questions about reg relating to the audit yeah so my only question was what is the purpose of it is it done for to satisfy a district requirement or is it a state requirement that this audit be done it's a state
129requirement okay thank you yeah to stated um each district is you know supposed to have an independent audit you know um to make sure the statements are fairly presented and making sure that the district is meeting all the state requirements you know as as I noted in the previous s there a lot let me know and I no the firm is in San Diego so how does that work does anyone actually come up here and come to the office or is everything done electronically sub midle no so we work remotely you know especially during Co um The Firm really want mostly remote and it's been doing pretty well for us and this District does a really great job uploading um so yeah thank you yeah no problem let me know if you want me to
130expand on that no I can just prior to co it was at it was in person at the district office and it took weeks to get all of the boxes and all of the paperwork into the district office conference room and Auditors would be in there for at least a week if not two weeks just going through everything but now it's nice that it is everything's uploaded very streamlined it saves a lot of time but not only going remotely um doing everything remotely our processes have gone more remotely and filing and saving documentation that way when we do get audited we have the information right there available then trying to search for it in paper and some the boxes in our warehouse any other questions thank you John thank you have a good night thanks
131can I get a motion to approve 24255 I'll make I'll make the motion or oh sorry go ahead I'll second thank you have a motion from Casey raboy to approve item number 24255 seconded by Annette cozie Katherine Harper hi Wesley Kagel Matthew Ward I thank you the motion carries unanimously and I before we move on to the next item I just wanted to recognize and thank our CBO and fiscal supervisor Brenda Bachman for a very great clean audit it's a takes a lot of work and it's just just a it it's example of how well the team Works to to have an audit that that way thank you moving on to 24255 one board consideration of approval for the 2425 first interim report so um thank you this is our our first INR report is
132the district's reporting um financials from July to October 31st and um youing the most recent information from school services for the projections for a multi-year feel free to um interrupt me and ask me questions by slide um open to that that way we could refer it to then um during the presentation so um what I want to highlight is um there is a process where we report to you besides our annual audit um throughout the year we provide um different reporting periods um recently September we provided last year's actual estimated um or un audited actual and um right now is first interim reporting for in December while we'll be bringing up um another interim period in March so it's part of our our annual process to keep the board informed the community informed of our
133projections go to the next oh thank you um so um some assumptions that we took in place and um the information that we gather from school services to build our first intrum um included a CO of 1.07% for the fiscal year our our retirement system stirs and purse um stores remain the same Pur there was a slight increase to um to the cost um the enrollment projections that we're using for our our multi-year projections is at 3,452 um leaving our ada8 is our average daily attendance of our students uh a projection of 3,197 that could that going to change once the actual reporting period comes up in April um we're just using the best estimate information available to us to make a projection when we build our interum reporting there was a slight decrease to
134our UND duplicate unduplicated pupil percentage this is um what we talked about earlier is uh the applications for um um lowi income free and reduced applications the reason for the decrease is because it's using a three-year average so it's just taking the last threeyear average and it it just looks a tiny decrease on that the other thing that I wanted to um note that LC lcff is our local control um formula that we use for that we use to calculate the revenue increased due to the U the increase of average daily attendance so that average daily attendance did increase compared to last year so you'll see an increase in that portion of the revenue the the learning loss funds educator funds are expected to be fully expensed this year um these are one-time funds that
135we will no longer have and we have some plans of of continuing some of the U items in that with general fund and and our alcap funds to be able to provide those services to our students yes um it's so there there is a ideally you want to get as close as possible to your enrollment um I know K G has worked hard for to increase that um attendance and we've seen an increase compared to other years as we're we came out of a covid and um I'm hoping by April in our next reporting period we'll see that number get closer to our enrollment number correct it's an average yes yes um so the district's funded in um and um two main focuses we have unrestricted funds is basically our general fund uh what the
136state provides to us and it has very little restrictions as long as it's allowed by Ed code and then we have Education Code I'm sorry and then we have um restricted revenues which has specific guidelines of how we could spend those funds this includes Title One funds um it also includes our expanded learning funds which is our EOP gel programs they have criteria that gets audited by our Auditors that have to be spent in a area our prop 28 funds is another example of restricted funds for that so we we try to ensure that our restricted funds get spent according to the state requirements that way to prevent any audit findings that get reviewed annually uh the district's fund balance is a the the in our current first interum it's the projection fund balance that
137we anticipate we're going to have at the end of the fiscal year um this changes by reporting period but it's the best estimate information based on our projection numbers here is our cost of living adjustment this information we use from our school Services is a resource from the state um um as we mentioned our Cola for this year is at 1.07 their projections for um the 2520 School 25 26 school year is 2.93 and the 26 27 is the 3.08 I I want to note that I know we all feel the cost of living is increasing dramatically and this is not not going to outweigh that but note that the cola is designed simply um for an increase or inflated cost not it doesn't correlate with real spending that's one of the things we want
138to knowe this is the information um this is what the state provides to us of what they're able to um provide an additional Revenue each year based on the state's budget and another note too in January there's an a January's budget which this can change in our next reporting period this is what was provided during U the approved budget in July um the components of um lcfm Revenue so this is the local control funding formula this is a picture of what our funding is composed of and um it it separates it in different areas so our total lcff funding is about 40 million um 40 million in combination with our supplemental concentration and um grants the supplemental concentration grants um that I want to note this revenue is connected to the unduplicated pupil percentage which
139is our lowincome uh free and reduced um applications that we get so that percentage that 62 percentage that we went over earlier it's connected to that additional funding we're able to receive for supplemental and concentration here is our big picture of our District's Revenue that we receive so our total District revenue is about 53 million of the lcff that graph that we showed previously about 76% of that is um from you from our supplemental concentration and the lcf formula other local re revenues include State revenues Federal revenues and you can see there the amount we get for that and some examples for State revenues include the ELO program the expanded learning program um Lottery also funds um that's part of that Revenue um but overall the district receives about $53 million here is our projected
140expenditures for the fiscal year so total um projected expenditures is about $62 million um leaving about a total of for salaries and benefits we we spent about $47 million of that $62 million that presents about a 76% spent on salaries and benefit for our employees I do want to note that our expenditures are more than our actual Revenue received because we do have carryover funds that we have over the years that we need to be spending and we project to be spending um throughout the years to reduce that deficit number showing but $62 million um still leaves us a fund balance at the district and Lees leaves us in a position where we're able to meet our obligations so here's uh our multi-year projection of our fund balance uh uh restricted unrestricted Reserve levels so
141for the fiscal year 2425 our projected Reserve is at 133% following year is about 12% and that last third year that we're reporting out is about 11% I do I want to add to this is this do not include any salary increases um and this does meet our required 9% board policy that we're required to meet yeah expenditures exactly so it's a it's based on your expenditures and we do have a state requirement of 3% that were required to me but we have an additional board policy that allows that to keep that maintain that 9% to leave the district in a good fiscally stable position so um here's a our district enrollment and um our funded Ada Trend um one of the things I want to highlight here is for the 2425 school year we
142have begin to stabilize meaning we are beginning to get actual funded based on our actual Ada that we mentioned earlier that 3,197 um and our enrollments 3,452 Ada is funded in three different forms either the current year your last year whichever was best or the average of three years this year became the first year that we already we already met our funded Ada and we're getting funded our actual students attending school so it's good to be in this position because that means we're increasing and hopefully to see that increase in Revenue so overall the district has met all our um Financial Obligations meaning the district will be certifying positive in our first interim report and um we're able to meet that with our Cola and all our onetime monies that we have and that carryover
143funds that we're able to spend and um the the district continues to prioritize of the safe and well-being of our students um also investing money in our curriculum we do have that coming up um enhancing other measures and our facility maintenance so hopefully we'll see some improvements um this coming up year any questions I have a question so for those colas the 1.07 the 2.93 the 3.08 are those just expected State colas that you expect the state's going to give you that much additional in those years but it's no guarantee so the for this year the state did approve the budget for that 1.17 we are going to get that but for the out out years the subsequent years those are the projections that they're they're anticipating we make it get that changes by January
144in our governor the governor's budget and it can change again in the May revise once we get our May revise that is it rarely changed it has changed have experience changed um but may Revis will provide the closest Cola for the next um uh fiscal year but I've always seen the third year change a little um once we get close to our May revision report not cooperating um so I had a question are does this also does this presentation also include the attendance recovery piece like if I have questions should I be ask no you can asking those now okay yeah yeah so the attendance recovery piece I saw um mentioned it's a new law um and based on what I understand it's sort of the circular function because it it provides some attendance recovery
145but it's also an unfunded program so if you need to pay for teachers um to do the Staffing for this attendance recovery it doesn't necessarily provide additional funding for that that's something we would have to take out of our budget is that correct yes and um some more information has come up come up about this um so during the adopted budget for um the state um some of the major um state budget included this attendance recovery which now notates because this year is basically our our prep year we we're learning how to do this what we're going to do and how we're going to plan it um uh the role that I would be taking on this is how are we going to collect that average daily attendant how is that accounted for and um
146How am we going to fund it right that's what it is um there is a resource that allows us to use expanded learning funds to be able to pay for this having to have a certificated um staff be able to do this either during or after school um to be able to recover some that um daily attendance how the prog program is going to be run is more of um K G um I I'm going to we're going to strategize of how we're going to do this I'm going to figure out how we're going to collect that ada8 because if there is a recovery we will we will eventually see a um income coming from that we'll just have to invest a little to see that um the money come to be able to support
147our students and provide that additional support but um this year what we're doing on the fiscal side is getting the training and support to be able to calculate that and I know um um K has been attending some meetings regarding attendance recovery I if you want to add yeah just real briefly I mean the conversations are starting to happen of like how do you want to do this and so as Alejandra mentioned um you know some of the examples are before school after school weekends intercessions um it it essentially does serve uh a two uh twop Point purpose it is to recoup some some of the Ada but is also intended to provide some learning recovery as well um you know where you know as a district We've ran summer programs as well so I'm
148not anticipating it's going to be a challenge for us to do this but it is um we would be using the elop funds to fund the Staffing to be able to provide it so and then what is our role I mean just on principle it's I mean I have my thoughts I don't probably know enough but I have some initial thoughts on is our role just we you know understand it and the decisions are made at a different level whether as to whether we want to participate in this attendance recovery or is it just something a given that the district will participate or you don't know enough it's a may you don't have to yeah May it's a it's way to recoup funding but also to provide additional support to students that have been chronically
149absent learning require them to come we can't require kids to stay after school or come on Saturdays and just like we can't require teachers to teach during those times either um but we do I I think historically our district has done a good job with summer programs and after school extended day or acceleration blocks those types of things can be incorporated to try to recoup funds it's just a little concerning that if if we establish a program and are paying for it and the student is not attending regular school then are there is there going to be a teacher that we're paying for and they're not no one's there to show up because they're they're chronically absent in their daily life and then are they going to be chronically absent in this program as well
150so it's just some of those initial things and then you know that's some thoughts so I I'm guessing it's too early for all of these things but um just some initial thoughts that I had and then um I know you probably were you gonna make a comment on this because I have another comment I was gonna say the same thing as what is the incentive going to be for kids to attend and for parents to bring their kids if there's already an issue with attendance I just was that's I'm not clear on how that is going to be effective right and then my other comment is sort of reading through the materials I was glad to see sort of a little bit of reticence because I was reading the lao's fiscal outlook for California and
151it's very tenuous I mean based on the factors that they're considering for some of the positive factors are very um transitory potentially so um I would it's sort of like you're okay this year but don't you know don't don't hang on to anything for future because there's a lot of uncertainty in this fiscal environment and then that doesn't even include the new um California air resources board regulations that are anticipated to increase costs of gas about 40 to 60 cents a gallon and as that blends into the overall Market that's really going to drive I mean that concerns me as to how that's going to blend into the cost of Labor you know cost of goods and how is the district impacted and none of that is even included in the budget you know numbers
152I agree I recently saw an article they're they're looking at increasing SDI as well and that's not included in this in this reporting period um and as we get closer to January's budget and hopefully we'll have more information to say oh this has changed this increase um and it's year to year you're right um a lot of the projections is based on what we have now and the state budget changes very it's very very often I think it's the times are uncertain I think it's it's really prudent that the board um require us to stay at that 9% um when you're you need a larger Reserve when you're a smaller District um most smaller districts have a reserve anywhere between 15 to 20% um and so we just we don't want to go back to
153the days of when you know we were at 3% barely making it because when times get tough and costs increase um you know you're you're forced to look at things like reductions in staff um and so we don't we don't want to go below that %. and if we wanted to go above it would that be something we would raise as a board like if we wanted to reconsider because of all of this uncertainty in the environment yes and that's what bring back yes yes that's what the board did um gosh it was probably five or six years ago when they adopted board policy um stating that that we would maintain a 9% unless there wase unprecedented times you know unless the board could make the decision to go below 9% say we were looking
154at some big reductions can I get a motion to approve one I'll make I'll second thank you I have a motion from Matthew board to approve item number 2 42551 seconded by Katherine Harper Casey raboy I Annette cozie I Wesley Kagel thank you the motion carries unanimously next we have 24255 2 board consideration of approval of resolution number 10 accepting the final completion of contract for Greer Elementary School portable classroom project so last August the district contracted with rbh construction to um Repair actually sorry to demo two portables and replace them with two new Portables At Greer Elementary School and so that project is substantially completed and we need to move forward with a notice of completion the original contract amount was $315,000 we came in slightly under budget the final contract is $39,000 or
155almost 310,000 and we used expanded learning opportunity funds from for those Portables and so um with that we have resolution 10 and then notice of final completion for board approval any questions surrounding that I'll make the motion to approve 242 552 can I get a second I'll second thank you have a motion from Katherine Harper to approve item number 42552 seconded by Casey raboy Annette cozie I Wesley Kagel Matthew Ward I thank you the motion carries unanimously next we have 242 553 public hearing of approval resolution n annual report for developer fees for fiscal year 2324 so our the government code requires a district to present to the board our annual sorry do we need to open public hearing oh we do need to open public webly open it before she presents it generally yes
156okay so we go ahead we'll open the public hearing um so do we have there are no public comments okay board member okay so we'll go ahead and close the public hearing okay sorry um so our government code requires us to have a public hearing on their developer fees um Collective for the last fiscal year um and we're supposed to show what we expense and the income we received and um I'm going to be highlighting some things from the um this public report we did post this um on our website on our website and we on the newspaper that way um our community can have time to review the information but I do want to highlight some things on the the annual developer fees report on page two um we could see that total um
157Revenue collected was about 1.3 million of that 1.1 million was from developer fees um the district did have a beginning balance of 1.2 million um our total expenditures for last year was um $950,000 U doar some projects that I want to highlight that the district was able to do with the developer fees is that Valley Oaks classroom building um we were able to um use about 5 157,000 in combination with um with fun 35 as well to be able to um bu build those classrooms another item that I want to highlight um is this is on page three is our facility facility master plan development um this is this was shared earlier in last fiscal year about the district's plan um facilities plan and what it looks like and um items that we need to
158take care of of the district overall so total um um total expense there it gives you an estimate of using the fund 25 about 67,000 but overall on page two leaving a ending fund balance of $1.6 million in our developer fees account so every year we'll be presenting this information of what we expense and what we get um it's an annual report um we open up for the public any questions when you say developer is it like school fees when someone goes to build a house and they're paying school fees is that what that is yes correct the the part we split is our commercial fee with the high school that's the the 385 is for all new residentials for us or the commercial fee yes yes and even though it does say public hearing
159are we we also need to vote on this is that correct yeah the next item yes okay oh I see okay we I don't so I don't read that one so it's the next item is do are there any other questions on that okay okay um so 242 Point 554 board consideration of approval of resolution number nine adopting the school district annual report for the developer fees program in compliance with the government code section 66006 and 66001 can I get a motion to approve I'll make a motion I'll second thank you I have a motion from Matthew Ward to approve item number 2 42554 seconded by Annette cozie Casey raboy hi Katherine Harper hi Wesley Kagel thank you the motion carries unanimously next we have 24255 five board consideration of nominations for California school boards
160Association delegate assembly sub region 6B all right so this is the opportunity for the the board to take action item to nominate a trustee to serve as a delegate assembly I would like to nominate Annette cozie do you accept I was going to say yeah do do you want my thoughts yes I'm I'm happy to to be nominated okay and serve if if if selected anyone else can I get a motion to approve 24254 I'll make the motion I'll second the motion thank you I have a motion from Katherine Harper to nominate Annette cozie to the delegate assembly subre sub region 6B seconded by um Matthew Ward Casey raboy hi Annette cozie I uh Wesley Kagel thank you the motion carries unanimously and So based on that looks like the next point of action is
161coming up very quickly yes so and S yes you have to file by um January 7th and it's all online so there's a bi biograph biographical sketch and that you have to do about yourself and that will go to csba and then what will happen is by February 1st they will send the ballots to the board and so the February board meeting we will bring um the actual election ballot let us know if you need any help with that but we can send you the link but I'm sure you know how to how to find that but yeah they used to send us things hard copies but it's all online now thank you moving on to public comments for topics not on the agenda do we have any more public comments there are no public
162comment requests Miss thank you moving on to pending agenda items it looks like we have a couple of those those um were you going to cover any of those or are they um number one National Suicide Prevention month that's probably going to be a couple months out I think um work with the high school on that um that's not something we really need to have in place until um August or September we won't wait that long but probably a couple months on that one we do plan on our January meeting bringing you a report on our routine maintenance budget so that will be next month do we have any more pending agenda items we can do that I know there's a math adoption possibly happening or will be happening yes we're in the math pilot
163piloting yes just just about finished up the second pilot so we're on track with that um pilot materials be available to the public really soon and we're on track for an adoption for next year for math but we can give you definitely an update on the other areas that you have not heard about yes anything else uh I just wanted to close the meeting and before I do that uh just mention that I um ad judged a spelling be at moringo I yesterday it was seems like longer than that but um and it we had we started with 10 we did 19 rounds and it was I have never judged a smelling Mee um and so I really enjoyed it and I would encourage you guys to do it if you ever get the chance
164and it just really allows those kids who have worked so hard to shine and it's really fun to watch them and even watching them deal with the disappointment when they get knocked out it I mean it's a huge learning experience and I character building and just very very valuable so it was a good time I know Wes I think you did that too another school yeah yeah it wasn't very big L yeah pretty Rowdy okay yeah yeah yeah and we'll highlight the two winners from both schools from Morango and Valley Oaks and our January newsletter but yeah it was very very well run I I try to attend at least one of them each each year last year I did Morango and this year I did valy so okay yeah um I'm going to if
165there's nothing else that you guys have then I will go ahead and adjourn the meeting