CorpusRecord 105496

SCSD Regular Board Meeting 12-12-24

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Vimeo / San Carlos School District
Date
2024-12-13
Location
San Mateo County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,343 words · about 80 min
Collected
2026-06-17

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Good evening. Welcome everyone to the December 12th, 2024 regularly scheduled meeting of the San Carlos School District Board of Education. Calling this meeting to order at 631 p.m. First, we need to approve our agenda. We are moving 4G and 4H to discussion action so they'll become 7H and 7I. Any other changes? No. That's it. Is there a motion to approve? I move to approve the agenda moving items 4G and 4H to 7H and 7I. I have a second. I have a second. Does anyone have a second? I have a second. Is there a motion to approve or no? Now we move on to our special recognition recognizing board Trustee Emeritus so Neil, come on up. Position of importance. We have a number of people we'd like to say a few words. First, I wanted to

002share that Senator Becker, Assemblymember Pappen, and Supervisor Mueller all send their regrets that they couldn't be here, but they have official resolutions recognizing your service, and this one is from Supervisor Mueller. Thank you. And first, we're going to start off with Randy Shelton. Sorry about that. But it is an honor to be here tonight to recognize Neil after his many years of service. I'm here on behalf of our principal team in San Carlos, but I want to take a moment personally just to say it's been a real pleasure to get to know Neil, not only as a board member, but also as parents, and to get to know his whole family, including Kate and Eloise and Rory, who you should be exceptionally proud of, and who should also be very proud of you and the

003service you provide in your community. In true elementary school fashion, the best way to honor you, Neil, was with an acrostic. And I didn't take the cop-out way. L is for loyal. Neil is loyal and devoted to the San Carlos community, and we are lucky to have your leadership in our schools and now across the whole town. A, let me pick just one, advocate, agency, and autonomy. Neil is a strong advocate for our schools and has helped to chart a course for our district while still allowing schools and leaders and staff to have agency and autonomy to best be able to serve our students. Why? For years of service, many years of service and dedication, clearly with more to come, and we're excited to have a strong ally on the city council. In fact, we

004already talked about you today during our PDM Royale talking about PVL and how we're going to use your expertise on the city council to help us plan some solutions for national investors. T for tenacity. Neil served during some challenging times in our school district through COVID, through superintendent transition, but always keeping the best interest of our students in mind. For open-minded, Neil kept an open mind and listened to community members, parents, students, staff, leaders, and used all of that input to guide his thinking and find common ground to benefit everyone in our community. And N for nurturing need. And two examples come to me that I wanted to share. One, I got to spend a little bit of time with Neil in Southern California during the Distinguished Award recognition ceremony and in time, and seeing

005Neil's pride in our schools and our teachers and our students through that process was really, really special that we had that opportunity to share together. And then also hearing Neil speak to our staff at our welcome back breakfast and just the care he showed to our staff and our teachers and the whole community stood out. Middle school administration also asked me to share how much of means to them they come to promotion ceremonies and spoken to students and come to their expertise. So with that, we will greatly miss your leadership and advocacy on the board, but look forward to continued partnership throughout the community and continuing to get to work with your banding up. Thank you, Mindy. Next, we have a couple of a couple of your fellow former trustees now, Carol Elliott and Irene

006Chen. Let me make sure the mic is on, Carol. I just want to appreciate the years of service that Neil has given to the district. He came to this work in the spirit of public service. And one thing that stuck with me, and it was during the candidate forum, was you said your inspiration was a teacher. And I think that really reflects what you brought to this district, that humble servant approach, centered on staff, students, outcomes, and the district and staff and students are very fortunate to have had your leadership and your stewardship over these past seven years through some really challenging times. You have done a really good leader, so I really appreciate that. Public service can be a thankless job, so it's really important to say thanks in a big and public way.

007And so it was really important for me to be here to recognize you. I really appreciate everything you've done and it was great to work with you and serve with you. And I'm very excited that you're moving on to City Council. We're lucky to have you, same with the crossover between the school board and the City Council just makes for a better town altogether. So thank you so much, Neil. And thank you to the rest of the board for your service. Thank you, Carol. I also want to address not just you and the board, but also Neil's family and Kate, because it's truly, you know, a lot of support at home to support the many years of public service that you provided Neil. There's a few stories that really kind of spring to mind. One,

008I want to build on the tenacity that Mindy, you spoke about. I first met you, I think in 2015, I think it was in 2015, it was probably the most hard fought school board election that the community has seen in a decade. And I hope that you and I both feel very proud about that, because I think it's good to elevate awareness among our citizens about the role that the board plays. And you and I ran into each other on a hill as we were both going knocking door to door. And I just had a lot of respect and mutual admiration that I think you and I were both going to kind of lock door to door to kind of speak to you both. Another memory that Carol alluded to was one night you were

009here in the boardroom, and your response to an issue that we were debating began with naming all the teachers that you had in your life, from like kindergarten to grade by name. And that shows, you know, of your profound respect. I also want to add that I really just have always admired your deep sense of purpose and your deep sense of service for this job to your community that you're carrying on to the city board. So I, oh, and I want to conclude, close with one little story about open mindedness that I think Mindy brought up. Um, a lot of times people mistake that the role of the board members, you know, to come in to be an advocate for a strong friend of you, and I think the best board members are here to

010kind of guide and make wise decisions. And that means being open to debate and to taking in the information if you're given it. And I've seen you do that time and time again. I remember when you and I were serving on a subcommittee to kind of guide the selection for the new superintendent, and we walked into the subcommittee meeting having an idea that the process might be ABC, and in the course of conversation, we altered it because we realized that conversation got it so better out. So Neal, thank you so much for your many, many years of leadership. I know you believe in this, and I also know that there will be great new community members to step up. Now we have our SCTA president, Dan Lanier. Thanks for being here in person, Dan. I

011think I'm pretty mic'd, yes. All right. Good evening. I've had the pleasure of knowing Neal for the past eight years in his role as our school board trustee, and in my role as the president of the San Carlos Teachers Association. Neal has served our school district well. Even in our toughest times, Neal has retained his steadiness, calm, and his sense of humor. He's helped guide us through budget crises, bonds, impasses, parcel taxes, superintendent hirings, and the COVID pandemic, which has a special place in my heart. For that, teachers and all staff are grateful. Pre-COVID, Neal occasionally had to bring his young children to school board meetings, and they would be in that room right over there that you can see, and they would be in this little side room, and we could hear them sometimes

012during the meeting. Sometimes it would be a little noisy, so Neal would raise his eyebrow like, oh God, what am I going to do? He would go back and try to get the kids to be quiet, which they would for a little bit. This was really sweet that we got to see that he had a sense of humor, and it brought sweetness to our meetings. What I admire most about Neal is that he has respect for his mother, who was a teacher for many years, and you're here tonight. Yes. Over the past eight years, I sat through a large majority of the school board meetings with Neal in person and on Zoom. Most times that Neal praises teachers, which is often, he begins by referencing his mom, who was a teacher for so many years.

013When Neal does this, I can always hear the love and respect that he has for his mom and all teachers, and I really appreciate this about Neal. The City of San Carlos will be fortunate to have Neal as a city council member. We'll miss Neal as a board member, but we're thankful that he'll be just a few streets away at City Hall. Thanks. We have something a little different. Amber is going to read a poem, and we have some slides. Hi, everyone. I'm Amber Farina. I'm the Director of Enterprise and Community Relations, and I've worked with Neal over the past five and a half years. We put together, our cabinet team put together some thoughts and memories of our time to highlight the hours we spent together with the board, and just some fun memories

014we have of Neal. Here is our ode to Neal Layton. In San Carlos halls where choices were made, you led with resolve, steadfast and unafraid. Through trials of meetings, big and small, your wisdom and calm steadied us all. Hands to your head in moments of stress, your scents and poise were always the best. With your Topopo Chico in hand, right there, you can see his favorite drink of choice. Grace, on your side, you chaired the board with unyielding pride. Vigilant always, you'd pause and recheck for public comments to honor and respect. You gave us a phrase we'll always relay, a standard you set, the San Carlos way. Now onward, it sounds like a Christmas calendar. Now onward to counsel your next chapter planned, still guiding this town with a steadying hand, your legacy stands as

015a beacon of light in service and heart, your impact is bright. Thank you, Neal, so much. We have just really enjoyed having you on our board and we will miss you dearly, but we will come and visit you. No worries. Thank you. Well, I previously shared my gratitude for Neal's contribution to San Carlos and I appreciate his investment in the success of our broader vision and put self-interest aside. But tonight I'd like to acknowledge the support he has received. His parents contributed to his service orientation and we frequently hear Neal reference his mother. Ginny, a former teacher, we know helped set his North Star and continues to be a touchstone for Neal. A big thank you to her. His life partner, Kate, who endorses and promotes Neal's public service. An accomplished attorney and busy mom,

016she's an ardent supporter and confidant. We thank her for allowing Neal to spend the countless hours board service requires. And then finally, Eloise and Rory who aren't here that like her father when he was young has learned the importance of citizenship and service and of volunteer work and sacrificed home cooked meals and extra TV time to hang out in the superintendent's office while dad ran and participated in board meetings. Thank you to them. Strong women continue to be beside Neal as we saw on Monday night at the city council swearing in and that gives me such confidence for his and our future mom and for Kate's and I know that you have other family members. All right, trustees, it's our turn. I think we have Tracy going first. Oh, or did you want to go

017last? Okay. All right. Then I'll go to Sarah and then before I start crying because I'm seeing Neal cry. So I wanted to just start with a little story about when we first met for a one on one, it was when I was running for office two years ago and we had coffee and I was eagerly hoping for your endorsement. And you politely informed me that you had already endorsed someone else. But you did it with a directness that was infused also with thoughtfulness and kindness. And I actually left what could have been a very awkward situation with a really positive feeling about you, because I knew this is a person I will always know where I stand with Neal. And when we disagree, it will be done with respect and thoughtfulness. So that really

018set the stage for me for how our working relationship could be. And I am going to move forward in my work with sort of two pieces of Neal wisdom. The first is that you often ask all of us, are we giving clear direction to staff? And I think that consideration of how we're fulfilling our governance role has been so important to me that we're not here to pontificate or question alone. We're here to guide and direct and achieve our mission. And also the other sort of takeaway for me is you're always asking and redirecting us, are we focused on the strategic goals, on the priorities? Are we doing what's right for kids in our district and doing what we need to do to advance the excellence of our schools? And everything else is a distraction.

019So your laser focus on what's right for students and for our schools is something that I hope to emulate as I move forward as a trustee. So just thank you for being a role model for me. And I will truly miss working with you, but hope that we will continue to cross paths in public service. So in some ways for me, this feels a little bit like a graduation. And you've done more graduation speeches than all of us on the board combined. What's unique about this one in many ways, you have been the teacher and we've been the students. And today you're graduating and we're all so grateful for what we've learned from you. I remember my first conversation with you, which was I have good news and bad news. You're the only one who

020applied and you're on the board and you're the only one who applied. But also I remember my first, so we were still on Zoom and my first board meeting, we were doing, it was LCAP and I was like, are these goals high enough? Are these goals not high enough? Like literally rookie baseball guys. And instead of shouting me down, you just said, do you have a proposal? Are you going to call a vote or are you not? And so we called a proposal. It got shut down. One of the only votes that's gone down, but I learned, I really learned from that. And what it really said is we're a team, we're a governance team. And this isn't about pushing an agenda, pushing a perspective or playing a particular role that you might've imagined when

021you watched Hollywood films of people running for positions, but it's really about how we work together as a team. And you fostered that teamwork in such an incredible way. The full mark of someone is do they leave something better than when they started? And if you look at everything that we accomplished and we talk about survive, thrive, transform, survive is the hardest time. And you spent so many years working through that so that we could do all the amazing things that we do now. And I just feel like this board is in a great place. This district is in a great place. And your students have learned so much from you. And now I'm so excited for you to bring that same wisdom and that heart to city council. So thank you so much. Hi,

022Neil. So a little over two years ago, I spoke to three people, Michelle Nayfack, Neil Leighton, and Jennifer Fentress before making the decision to run for a seat on the school board. And Neil and I didn't really know each other, but Neil's advice was just so clear and candid, couched in humor with a little bit of cynicism sprinkled in, which turns out is kind of trademark Leighton as I've learned over the years. And I think the thing that was surprising to me was during my campaign, and even after in my first months of being a new trustee, Neil would like, I don't know why I'm getting emotional, but he would check in on me. He had his own life. He's a very busy guy, but he would check in on me, see how things were

023going. And it meant a lot to me for him to do that. So I think Neil comes across sometimes as like too cool for school. He's like slick head and boots and his laid back posture sometimes. But he's got a really big heart and he's got a lot of room in there for lots of people. And it's just evidenced by his seven years on the school board and his continuing move to city council. So Neil, I will miss trademark Leighton and the wisdom and experience that you have. We've been so fortunate to have for these past seven years on the school board. I guess for me it was only two, but, and I wish you the best on your new adventure. Thank you. That leads me with Neil's seven years of service as a trustee.

024A lot of people have seen who he is as a public facing leader, his steadiness, his sense of humor, his willingness to make hard decisions and provide an alternative perspective on issues. But what I wanted to recognize as others have is who you are, Neil, as a leader behind the scenes and how generous you are with your time and support. For me personally, there have been countless times over the past two years as board president when I have really needed a thought partner. And every single time I've texted you to ask, Hey, do you have a few minutes? I need your advice. Your response has been, yes, absolutely. Even though you have a demanding job, a busy family life, you made time to talk to me every time I asked and you didn't have to

025do that. No one would have known, but you and me, if you'd said, I really can, I've got too much going on. And frankly, I wouldn't have held it against you if you had said that. We all have experienced the struggle of balancing this role with other life obligations. So I feel like showing up when no one else is watching really demonstrates the true character of a leader. And I want to thank you for being that kind of leader for me and for this board. And I wanted to be sure to express appreciation just for a couple of specific ways in which you've had a meaningful impact on the district. It's already been referred to, but you were board president during the pandemic when we were in full-time distance learning and we went back part-time.

026Then we hired a new superintendent and then we opened full-time in the fall and you were president through all of that. And I can't imagine how many hours you spent between board meetings working on all of that. And then all of your work on the facilities master plan, the bond, the facilities committee, all of us owe you a really great debt of gratitude for all that you've done on those things. So I want to thank you for your dedicated service to the district. We look forward to seeing your leadership continue on the city council. And we have a few gifts for you to say thank you. One of Dante's palatones. It was the latent family discussion that's still on the list. Still on the list. Hard for all of us. We have a shirt just

027to hold on to for the future. It says because I'm the mayor, that's why. For home use. And we also had, I was at the CSBA conference and I was, one of the vendors actually had a a gift that they wanted to give to you. They're still recruiting. Are you going to tell them the story, Tracy? Just let everybody wondering what's that about. So when we went to CSBA two years ago, last year, there's a company that specializes in for school fencing, you put in like fake grass to cover up the fencing. So basically it's so you can't, it's basically meant for schools that are in more urban areas that are to a busy street, you cover it up with fake grass so people can't come in. And I think I told everyone on the

028board for maybe a good 45 minutes, like, I can't believe there's a company that's dedicated to only making fake grass for fences. And we go to dinner. I can't believe there's a company dedicated to fake grass for fences. So we come to the next meeting and Tracy comes up with a fake letter, like recruitment for me to apply for a job with the fake grass company. I fell for it so bad that I kept saying the whole time, I can't believe this company, like how they find out about me. And it wasn't until we got the closed session that Tracy was like, did you look at the box? And I was like, yes, I mean, this is like a real life box. And Tracy goes, no, that's an Amazon box for my house. And I

029was so impressed with just the general ability to come up with that. So at this point in time, big grass and I, it's a future of mine. For wrapping wine bottles. Yeah, for wrapping wine bottles. So I thank you all. Yeah. Thank you, Neil. Anything else you want to say? I do have some words as always, because, but I have to, as a prosecutor, they only do that same. So those who've been on board with me, if I don't write things down, if I'm not well prepared, I have a tendency to ramble. So I wrote things down tonight in the best way I could possible to try to make it so a letter to the person who would take my seat next is the best way I could try to phrase things. It's difficult for

030me to write, to go through the seven years. So to whoever is next, congratulations on becoming a member of the San Carlos School. You have successfully been appointed to the most rewarding and frustrating job of all time. Your days will now be consumed with acronyms, budgets, and mandatory state forms. And the good news is that once you get comfortable with the acronyms, budgets, and mandatory forms, Sacramento will pass a law renaming, reformulizing, and redoing all the things you just read. Like it or not, now you're a politician. A good politician would take this time and letter to tell the accomplishments that the previous person did succeed well. But being a good school board member is not about being a good politician, it's about being a good leader who's going to make the same sacrifices for

031other kids as you would if not. So in this letter, I'd rather answer the question I get the most. What advice would you give a new member than talk about my accomplishments? So first, you can only do this job because of the people that support you. I was fortunate enough to have a large village of supporters for this job. It wasn't poor Michael Cade who supported me in this. I could not have been a school board member. It has always been on the receiving end of frustrating conversations, confusion about board decisions, and constant questioning, constant questionings on if I should continue with this. But without her, I would not have made it through budget shortfall, business decisions for being a board member through COVID. So make sure your husband or wife knows that you're appreciated

032for sharing in your sacrifice to be on this board. Also, remember there will be times that your significant other cannot take one more conversation. So I suggest you have multiple venting tools. Fortunately for me, I have my mother. I speak to my mother almost every morning when I drive to work. Many of those conversations are dominated by the current dilemmas the school vision is going through. My mom would always listen and provide feedback from the perspective of a 20-year-old teacher. She provided me an outlet for my frustration of the job, and they needed perspective to keep it going. So I suggest you have a backup. If you can't find one, I'm sure my mom will pick it up. Second, remember the hard times were temporary and absolutely never related to education. When I joined the

033board in 2017, we had over-promised on our bond. We lacked capacity for after-school care. We hired a new superintendent that led the five principals and senior staff leaving the district. Had to cut 6% of our budget in two years. Big map was knocking on our door to take over the district, and in 2020, there was this thing called code. Maybe you heard me. And this is just a short list of problems I encountered which I felt were insurmountable. But in looking back, those problems that led to massive public comment and meetings, hundreds of emails, distrust on the board and the district, and me wandering Trader Joe's hoping no one regretted were only temporary. I always thought I was going to oversee the end of the San Carlos school district, but I did not. And despite

034often thinking San Carlos would never be as good as it once was, it has always gotten better. So just remember, what seems like the darkest days will always be followed by the brightest hours. The only reason I'm mentioning this to you, all the difficult things that I went through, is the best piece of advice I can give you is be grateful for your fellow board members and staff who did this job well. I have worked with nine different board members, three superintendents, one assistant superintendent, thank god. I need three HR directors, three CBOs, and ten different principals and assistant principals. Hundreds of teachers and hundreds of classified employees. I can tell you from the bottom of my heart, everyone who participates in the San Carlos school district does it for the right reason. We're about

035a high quality education for the kids who are not their own. You're going to get yelled at, you're going to be compared to other districts, and you're going to be constantly told about what you don't have rather than what you have. But you will not do it alone, because you're a part of a dedicated group of smart, professional individuals who want to give every child in the town the best shot at success. So always remember to be grateful for the other speakers to share this experience with. I personally will always be grateful to Michelle, Irene, Carol, Kathleen, Sarah C, Sarah K, Tracy, Wendy, and Ben for putting up with my long speeches, bitterness, and poorly timed adjectives. I will forever be grateful for Jennifer Han, Jen G, Denise, Eric, Amber, Vivian, Veronica, Dan, Lisa, and

036Kamala, and all the principals and teachers and staff who taught a prosecutor how to succeed in education. But I think summarizing my experience on the board was a phrase my dad used to tell me when he was diagnosed with cancer. Life is 10% of what happens to you and 90% of how you react. And nothing that sets me more than that. We're going to take a quick break and then we'll come back. Okay. All right. We're resuming our meeting at 715. Thanks all to your patience while we celebrated, Neil. Before we move on with the rest of our agenda, a reminder about public comment. As a reminder to the public, the board will take public comment on each agenda item as it is discussed and will also provide time for comment on non-agenda items at

037the end of the meeting. If you're addressing the board on a non-agenda item, please be aware that the provisions of the Brown Act prohibit the board from discussing or responding to such matters at this meeting. Excuse me. If you'd like to address the board here in person, we ask that you fill out a blue card. If you're online, please use the raise hand feature. All right. On to our consent agenda, which contains items that are routine in nature and for which no board discussion is anticipated. So we act upon them with a single vote. Do we have any public comments on the consent agenda? Okay. Thank you. All right. Is there a motion to approve the consent agenda? Minus 4G and 4H. Do you approve the consent agenda with the removal of G and H?

038Second. All in favor, please say they're saying aye. Aye. Aye. Right. Our next item is our determination hearing for the San Carlos Charter Learning Center charter renewal for 2025 to 2030. On November 7th, 2024, the district held an initial public hearing to consider the level of support for the petition from the district's teachers, other employees, and parents and guardians. The governing board of a school district shall either grant or deny the renewal of the charter within 90 days of receipt of the petition. At tonight's hearing, the board will vote on the renewal of the charter. So before I gavel us in, I'll outline the process, which is as follows. The board will hear the district staff report and recommendation. The San Carlos Charter Learning Center staff will be given equal time for their analysis and

039response. Then we will take public comments. And following public comment, the board members can ask clarifying questions and then we'll deliberate and make their decision. And then the public hearing will be closed. Before I gavel us in, I just want to double check that everything's working and that we are recording this section. Great. All right. So I will gavel us into our hearing and we will start with the presentation from the district. Thank you, Sarah. Excited to be here tonight. The purpose of the presentation is to give an overview of the criteria that we as authorizers use to evaluate San Carlos Charter and to provide the staff's recommendation for renewal. You've previously seen or heard about all the information I'm going to share with you this evening, so I'll be very brief. As Sarah said,

040SCCLC submitted its renewal petition on September 9, 2024. We had a public hearing on November 7th and we posted staff findings and recommendations on our website on November 22, 2024. Slides four and five list the statutory guidelines for renewal, including performance categories. SCCLC is in the middle level, middle performance category for charters and is therefore eligible for a five-year renewal. Slide six lists the 15 elements that a renewal charter must address. A full account of each of these elements can be found in the appendix included in the presentation as slides 10 through 17. Slide seven and eight, to sum it up in our recommendation, staff believes SCCLC has met criteria for renewal in all 15 element areas with a very thorough petition and well done. Staff recommends an approval and recommends a full five-year renewal

041of the charter June 30th, 23rd. Thank you. Excellent. I believe Fran is going to provide a response from Carter. Excuse me. Thank you all. I'm here to appreciate the support you've been putting in for the last five years. We've been a part of this community for 30 years and the whole program. I want to appreciate this team and your staff for all the work that they need to do. We feel fully supported by you all. It's clear that we share the same goal of ensuring a broad set of options for learning for all of us. We believe that we put together and Thank you. All right. We'll now take public comment. We'll start in the room. We have Erika Kendall and Trustee Park will keep time. We have three minutes. I just wanted to echo

042Fran's appreciation for all the work and the thoughtfulness that went into the whole process. We're very excited to be doing this. And I also wanted to share, I know it was important for both of us to have a five-year FUA and MOU in place along with this renewal petition. So I'm pleased to share that last time we were able as a board to review both of those documents and we passed both of those nets. So we have all three of those in front of you this evening. We look forward to that. Thank you. Do we have any public comment online? Okay. So for the trustees, any clarifying questions, comments? Had lots of opportunities to discuss the various pieces on anything related to the petition and renewal. I just want to express appreciation for the process.

043There were a lot of steps along the way here. And I know resources were put into working with Jeff Schmidt from the County Office of Ed and bringing in capital advisors to do a study session. And it just made it very clear and an easy to follow process as a trustee. So I appreciate, I'm sure there's was a lot of work behind the scenes that we don't see. But to get us here from the trustee perspective, I felt very well informed and just the process was outlined really well. So thank you. Thank you. Yeah, I would just say I think it's very like a big step forward for us to align our agreements together. So that during the, feels futuristic to say, but the 20, 29, 30 school year, we are in deep partnership. I

044guess for most of these processes, this represents the end of a process. And I would hope that it's the beginning of an even deeper working relationship. There's things like food services that we collaborate on. There's things like raising future parcel taxes that we need to collaborate on. And I think that the, in June, when some of the items came up around the MOU, it was actually a catalyzing moment for us to be as governing boards, like more closely aligned. And so I just encourage us to keep that going and five years can feel like a long time. So those types of relationships really rely on that frequent communication and so on. So that's my hope that this is yet another incredible moment in the first charter school in the state of California's history's evolution as

045we continue to grow together. Thank you. No, sorry. I'm just going to not talk much at all. Okay. Amazing. Sorry. I agree with everything that was said. It's very clear from the district's review and evaluation that charter has satisfied all the retired renewal criteria and that the renewal should be granted for five years. So I think as if we're ready to move forward, if someone could make a motion. I move that we approve the St. Carlos Charter Learning Center charter renewal for 2025 to 2030. Second. All in favor, please state by saying aye. Aye. Aye. And that is 4-0. And I will call us out. Congratulations. Thank you for your partnership throughout this process. All right. We will move on to our information and discussion item, which is a teaching and learning update on the

0462024 California school dashboard. Okay. Thank you, Sarah. Trustees were excited to sort of reprise some of the remarks that I made just at the last board meeting on the 21st. We'll go into things with a little more detail. Really highlighting the progress toward our initiatives and our LCAP goals. I cannot express the excitement that I have in presenting this to the greater community as well and sort of getting in on these slides in black and white if you will. Some great headlines to share just to start with. And I do not need to reiterate these as we go through slides. I don't want to be repetitive because this is really the best way that we can review what our students and our staff accomplished over the last school year. Remember that the dashboard is based

047on results from the 2023-24 school year. We do have some live data that we'll talk about later in a couple of areas. So for the dashboard that was released publicly on November 22nd, we had 23 of 33 possible ratings that as opposed to 13 of 33 in either green or blue, which is an impressive gain. Distance from standards, 79.2 for English language arts, big increases, respectively 6.7 and 4.8 points in language arts and math. Chronic absenteeism, I can't talk enough about it. I'll talk a little bit more about it later in the presentation. Just amazing gains that are almost unprecedented in the state when you look at the data and really dive into where the rest of the state is. These last two are something that I know that we all as a governance team

048hold near and dear because they speak to our work in DEIB and our work in social emotional learning. But students experiencing poverty and students learning English made measurable gains in every area receiving only areas of yellow, green and blue. Just so impressive. And finally, students learning English had impressive gains on what we call the English Learner Progress Indicator, which is based on the summative LPAC rather than the other academic ratings that are based in CASP score. Before I move any forward, I want to remind the board that dashboard is two-dimensional. If you go deeper into the dashboard itself, you get five-by-five grids that are based on current levels and then improvement levels. So, it can be a little confusing. Like, wait, we went up but we didn't go up enough to get blue and why

049does that one stay yellow? And when you look at the five-by-five grid, it clearly shows you, well, you gained between this many points and that many points or you declined between this moment and then we go to the other dimension and we find out where we are. So, it can be a little confusing to think about, but what's great about what we've done is so many things have moved and that's what we're trying to highlight tonight. Dashboard ratings are, again, based on growth and decline from the previous year. In math and ELA, that's based in distance from standards. So, the slides that we're going to show are based on distance from standard and for chronic absenteeism and suspensions, it's based in percentage. So, in language arts, again, overall gain was 79.2 points above standard, which

050was a game, a significant gain, about seven, a little over seven points. All student groups increased in their distance from standard. You see that students with disabilities increased 11.8 points. There are still 27 points below the standard. However, that is an amazing gain of almost 12 points in that area. This just speaks to the effectiveness of our efforts in standards-based instruction and MTSS, including continued implementation of science of leading pieces and research partnerships. And this is commensurate with our gains that we had on CASP, as I already mentioned, so that's important to know. In math, again, commensurate with our increases on CASP, students averaged 70.2 points above standard, and all student groups maintained or increased in their distance from standard. And it's a little bit confusing, again, when you look at it, because well, why

051did it go up? Why did that one stay yellow? Well, this is basically means that we maintain here for our Hispanic group of students. Once again, this shows the effectiveness of our programs that we've implemented, the hard work of our staff, our support staff, our leaders, and teachers and staff in this area. Students learning English, again, to speak briefly, I really enjoyed this graph. In particular, you can see the growth that we had between these two years, and we had a little dip, and then we had massive growth here to a point where we hadn't reached before. So 61% of our students made progress on the LPAC, which is higher than any number we have ever attained during the last four years and beyond. I looked beyond that previous to that as well. This is

052a direct effort of our focus in ELD and our focus on English language development instruction. And also not to be forgotten, our recently reclassified students, and this data here, the bottom of the slide, talks about our recently reclassified students. They're doing really, really well. So if we had any pause to think that we weren't doing the right thing by our aggressive reclassification, this gives us really some assurance that we are doing the right thing and that our students are prepared to compete with our English-only students as well. All right, so chronic absenteeism, I think this is probably hard to express how proud we are in this area. There was a lot of work in this area last year. To a person, if you ask a leader, what was the focus last year? In addition to

053academics, it was attendance, and phone calls, and letters, and really developing that sense of belonging for students and wanting to be at school. And communicating with parents who were struggling about the importance of being there, and how can I get there? Also highlights the work of our community liaison, right, that came in, started last October, boots on the ground, just hit the ground running, and started reaching out to parents that we knew immediately needed some assistance or to be linked with some resources. So this just really speaks to the work that we've done, the hard work we've done in this area, and what a great recommendation that we made in having that community liaison position and the importance of keeping that position as well. Suspension rate is no different. It also speaks to our work

054in PBIS and positive behavior intervention supports that our leaders and our teachers really have increased over since the pandemic, probably tenfold, along with our work again in social-emotional learning, which is really coming to light in results like this that say, well, our suspensions are down, which means we're really working with students on restorative practices and alternatives to suspension that we know keep kids in school as well. So some of that recent, those recent outcomes, this slide is, when I was developing this, I thought, can this be for real? And I had to double-check the data more than once to get up to 97.2%, which was where we were just before the Thanksgiving break. That's exceeding pre-pandemic levels. Now, granted, we haven't made it through the whole year, and we know that there is a slump

055in November and December when folks start having illnesses and whatnot. And yet, 97.2%, it's just a pipe dream for most school districts. They can't touch it. And we just continue to work with our leaders. We talk about it regularly. We're monitoring attendance constantly. And when we make it important, they know it's important, and so do our families. So it's showing in the data. These declines in chronic absenteeism year over year are absolutely amazing. I mean, students from low-income households, declining 6.3 points, and students experiencing homelessness declining 11%. It's just absolutely amazing, something really to be celebrated. Now, of course, the challenge is maintaining that. So we know that the work is not over, and we know we need to remain diligent. In a previous meeting, I think it was November 7th, we had a chance

056to talk a little bit about the exciting professional development we had on November 1st. And just a reminder of some of the things that we did and the timely professional development and professional learning that we did in standards and tasks in ELD. And also for our electives teachers that for the first time ever, electives and PE got the chance to go and mingle and collaborate with like-minded and job-alikes from surrounding school districts. And we had great accolades around that. In fact, our results from that professional learning were the highest we've had since we've been here. That doesn't mean we made everybody happy. It does mean that everybody got something out of the day, which is the most important thing. It also speaks to our initiatives and the effect. And so, you know, in closing, what

057can I say more than these results are clear in that our initiatives are working and we're really going deeper. As Ben likes to say, we're trying to get to thrive and we're approaching that, is what these results say. So I think we also take great pride in that. And that concludes our presentation. Happy to take any clarifying questions. Coming up in the next couple of months, we'll have a report on some social emotional learning and some early results on mid-year for that. And then we also have to do our annual mid-year LCAP update. So we'll have some more outcomes to report in January or February. Thank you, Hans. Lots to celebrate. But I will pass on to trustees for questions or comments. Sarah? I don't have any questions. I mean, it's pretty remarkable what types

058of gains can be made just in one year. I guess I want to repeat what you said about the community liaison. And when we look at our opportunities for growth and certain student populations that maybe aren't achieving at the level we would hope for, that that position is really a critical glue to help those families and those students overcome whatever barriers are preventing them from accessing the education. So just reiterating support, it's a choice to put resources toward a position like that, but I think it was an important choice that we made this year. Yes. For me, whenever I look at performance over a year with a company or whatever, we look at the dashboard and this just shows incredible results. I really liked how you put the 2023 one next to the 2024 one,

059just to give a sense of where we were, which was strong and where we are. I think a challenge that most people may not appreciate is the difference between 95% and 97%. That is very, very tough to move. It's never easy, but you can take strategies and move performance among groups or attendance or those types of things. When you're in the 80s, to move it to 85, 80 to 85, you see that commonly, but we're reaching some numbers here that are somewhat asymptotal. Kids are going to get sick, or I'm also looking at the English language learning, you're going to have newcomers. So I guess my question would just be, in addition to maintaining the strong performance, if you were thinking forward to next year, and what would be some areas you would want to

060focus on where you think we could still move the needle? Are there one or two areas where you still think that there's a real opportunity for focused effort to move the needle? When you look at this, what is it telling you? Well, I think first of all, the science of reading piece is really important. I think that we haven't completely moved the needle there. We're approaching that. We kind of had a grassroots effort around phonics instruction, phonemic awareness, that has spread very naturally. That we will complete as the year goes through. We'll also talk a little bit about, in a future meeting, about a new screener that the state is putting in place that's required, that's our new reading screener. Then we're hoping we'll give us another look, a different look at data, something else

061to look at. We'll be piloting that as we go through the second half of the year and be bringing a recommendation at the end of the year. There's always opportunities in English language development, every time. As you said, it's a moving target, it's variable. The number of students that we have that are learning English, the number of students that come to us with no English, that are newcomers, is not something we can control. The fact is, it is a challenge when you have few in a school district, as opposed to many. It might sound a little counterintuitive, but it's true. I think that is an area where, for a real opportunity, as we look into adding resources or bringing back resources that is in English language development in early literacy as well. Yeah, I'd probably

062add that I think that I would argue we're ready for transform, that we have students who are bumping the upper limit, who are ready for more personalized learning and more competency-based learning. I think that's an opportunity for us. Then our students with learning differences, we want to make sure they all have the opportunity to access the general curriculum. It's pretty hard to do well in math if you don't get access to math instruction with a math and George teacher, for instance. I think that that's going to be our double down on early learning. The more that we get students with learning differences, what they need early on, as they progress, it makes it easier to include them. I think that our bets are the right bets, and we've got some of our principals already leaning

063in on competency-based learning, which I think would be a really great opportunity. Thank you. Thumbs up. As I'm listening, one thing that I'm thinking, which I haven't asked before, so if the answer is we'll let you know, that's perfectly acceptable. I'm just curious, how does this information get? I feel like there's so much to be proud of. Did the staff get their performance information back to them? I want to celebrate them and what they've accomplished. I'm curious how that happens. Yes, there will be a message likely tomorrow or Monday. Amber and I are working on it together, and we'll have something that goes out to the community and something that goes out to staff as well. Yeah, one thing, thank you for saying that. Dan's here as a representative of the teachers union, but really

064teaching causes learning. We have learning because of the really good work that our teachers do, and then the hard work of learning together. I think we're doing a better job of making sure that our experienced teachers are with our less experience, more opportunity and collaboration, ways for teachers to model in each other's classroom and help each other out, and that shared learning is really what's a big thing that's pushing the needle for us. Yeah, we'll be celebrating that. Then also, we shared it with our PTA coordinating council, which was really fun. We had them get into the dashboard. Hans kind of led them through an activity, so there will also be something to our community about it. Sounds good. Do we have any public comment, Veronica? Okay. Thank you. That's a lot of good news.

065I'm going to take 30 seconds and get a hot drink. How about if I get a hot drink for you? Okay. Did you want hot tea? Yes, please. Do you need hot tea too? All right, so we can move on to our discussion action. And last, is Jennifer taking the calendar? Okay, perfect. So our 25-26 instructional calendar is our first item. All right, great. SCTA, San Carlos Teachers Association, approved the instructional calendar for 25-26 yesterday, 12-11-24. Highlights, our teachers will return on August 14th. School will start August 20th, 2025. Mid-year PD is moving back to January, and the last day of school will be on June 11th, 2026. It's pretty much the exact year of the calendar we have right now, with the exception of the PD day. So we're asking for you to approve

066the calendar for 25-26. Just out of curiosity, why did the PD day get moved back? Well, I don't have a lot of intimate details on that. I do know that they took a vote, and basically, the majority of teachers voted to have it back to January. Okay, makes sense. Any questions? I will say from a parent perspective, I like it moved back to January, just because it was abrupt to have so many three-day weekends in, and with child care and so on. It's a little bit easier to extend an existing break. I guess the one thing that I would say is just our professional development days are a sacred day, where having full staff attendance, it gives everyone the ability to align on things, and especially coming off of a break, to show up fresh

067and be ready to engage and say, okay, here's what we want for second semester, or second half of the year, second trimester. I think that could be really successful, but I just want to make sure that we're finding ways to encourage everybody to attend that day and not take a vacation day that day, because then we've all been part of school districts before, where people just take that day off, and then they've extended their vacation, but you haven't really gotten that PD centering day that allows people to really launch into the next semester or whatever. I will say, anecdotally, January day has always been really long-term, so it's not freshness. I think that does matter. Do you have anything? I can make a motion. All right. I move approval of the 2025-2026 instructional calendar. Second.

068Do you want everybody to say aye? Aye. All right. On to our first interim. Thank you, all trustees. I want to first say thank you to Chris and Denise, who put this first interim together. I need to share the screen, so give me a second. So I share the screen. Okay. Thank you for having me here today. My name is Ralph Crame. I'm the new chief financial officer here at the district, and I officially start in January. So I appreciate the time here to get to know the budget. I had a chance to sit with Chris and Denise to understand and get to know this budget here in San Carlos. I really appreciate the work they've done, and I need to make sure that they get recognition for putting this together. They put the presentation

069together, and I'm just here talking about it and highlighting the hard work that they did in the background. So thank you to Chris and Denise for that. So as we move forward here. Okay. So a quick overview of what we're talking about today. So you have the interim and review, and the first interim is just the checkpoint of the budget. You approved the budget back in June and July, and this is to show where we are in regards to that budget. Is our spending on track? Are we overspending? Are we needing to adjust any of the budget items because something came up? So this is the first interim. It's just a check to make sure that everything is going as planned and see if we need to make any adjustments along the way. You'll see

070the multi-year projections as well in this presentation, and then you'll see a summary of other funds and what the next steps will be as we move forward. I just explained what the first interim was. That's a snapshot, as I just mentioned. And you'll see there's the adjusted revenue in here. There's revised salary expenditures based on actuals. So sometimes you have vacancies. Sometimes you have other factors that are affecting these salaries and expenditures. Budget cycles. So the highlight down lower right-hand corner is the first interim where we are, and you can see it cycles through, and it's just a continuous cycle as we go through. After this, the next interim report will be the second interim report. Again, it will be another check to make sure we're on track with our spending and to see if

071any major adjustments need to be made to the budget in Guantanamo. Reporting requirements. So you can see we're mandated by Ed code to fulfill the requirements that you see here on the screen. First interim is from July 1st to October 31st. Second interim goes from July 1st to January 31st. And then the three qualifications that we would file, depending on how the budget is and our evaluation of the budget, are positive, which is what the district will be in for this first interim report. That means we will meet the financial obligations in the current and subsequent fiscal years. Qualified is we may not meet those obligations, and a negative is we will not meet those obligations in the out years to come. So the district at this point is in a positive certification standout situation.

072I like this slide a lot. This is the budget aligned to the district priorities and goals, and you saw a lot of those goals that Hans presented in the testing and results that are positive, and so a lot of progress has been made. That means that the budget is in alignment. Sometimes when you don't see positive results on presentations that Hans has presented, that means we need to look at budget and how it's aligned to those goals, and do we need to realign where the spending is and make sure that the dollars are going to the areas that are going to have the largest impact. Attendance is a large impact. 97% is a great outlook because the original budget was on a 96% projection of ADA, and so when the ADA increases, that means increased

073funds, increased dollars from the LCFF. It also means that that's a little bit longer that you might stay in an LCFF situation versus a community funded or basic aid. The higher the dollars you get from ADA and your LCFF calculations, which is enrollment and other factors, the further away you are from a basic aid district. That's just something to note there as well. Here on this slide, you see the revenues versus expenditures. You see total revenues combined, unrestricted and restricted, of $50 million, and you see total expenditures of $53.5 million. At first glance, you say, well, that's not good. That's deficit spending. One thing to note here, the majority of the deficit coming in the restricted category. You have revenues that are realized in prior years, and you have an ending fund balance in your

074restricted revenues because it could be from ELOP carryover or other carryover amounts that you recognize the revenue in prior years, and so you're spending down that fund balance. It looks like you have a deficit spending model where in fact you're not because you have to look at the multiple years and the multiple years you have to spend money. For instance, you have $28. You have three years to spend that. You recognize revenue in the first year, and then you're using the next three years as expenditures on that, so it could look like deficit spending. Your unrestricted category, you are in a positive cash flow situation, but keep in mind that there's a contribution which is same in every district. The contribution is from the unrestricted to the restricted category, and that covers some of the

075special education costs because that's where the majority of the contribution comes from. Special education, you're not only educating those with disabilities, but they are also general ed kids as well, so they're not just students that have IEPs. They're also in the general ed classes, and so there is a contribution that has to come from the unrestricted category to make sure that you're covering all the expenditures for those programs. You can see the fund balance is circled there, and you have a negative fund balance, so the deficit spending that is occurring is drawing off of that fund balance, and there's a healthy reserve, and so the district's done a good job over the last several years to build up that fund balance, and so that's another reason we are able to keep a positive certification because

076of the ending fund balance. Now, if the ending fund balance wasn't as high as it was, we might not be looking at a positive certification, so the district's done a good job over the last several years to maintain that fund balance in these times where we are a little bit deficit spending. The transfers in and transfers out help with that as well, so you see there's transfers in which are, you know, coming from sources to make sure that we're maintaining that. I believe that 1.55 was the 20, correct? Yeah, that's from the retirement, right? Yeah, I designed to host retirement benefits, right? Fund 20 is coming in, and you can see, move on to the next slide, so this is just a slide where you have the components of the ending fund balance, and it

077shows where each of the dollars are in each of the categories for the ending fund balance in the restricted and the unrestricted categories. You can see the unrestricted first column there, you have a total ending fund balance of $2.6 million, and you can see where each of those dollars are in each of the categories, and you can see what they are being set aside for, so to speak. You have vacation accrual, so there's some vacation liability that the district is responsible for, so making sure that we have money for that. There's some site technology that is going to go towards refresh of teacher machines, so to make sure we have the resources for that. The insurance flood assessment is something that makes SIG is potentially moving forward with, and that's something that other districts are

078also having to set money aside for as well. It's just part of the insurance group that is making sure that we're having enough, and then where the school districts that are in that situation are setting aside money and are contributing to that, because the insurance continues to go up as we all know. And then the reserve for the TK expansion, that is making sure that we have enough resources to hire staff to make sure that it's the proper ratios, because you have to have a 24 to 1 ratio now, and it goes to a 10 to 1 adult to student ratio in the future, so making sure we have that, and to make sure we have appropriate facilities. Do we have the place structures that are rated for those ages, because typically some districts have

079not had play structures that go below five years old, so you want to make sure that they have the appropriate play equipment as well, and appropriate facilities in the classroom for teaching and learning to go along with that to make sure we're setting up for success. You have the restricted ending fund balance there as well. You can see that's made up of lottery and other block grants. I mentioned before the arts and music block grant, along with learning emergency recovery. So those dollars are there, but those dollars will run out in the future. So those are one-time dollars. These are the planning factors to not only plan for the budget for this year, but the out years as well. So you can see the cost of living predictions going across the top. Right now, 24-25,

080it's a 1.07 cost of living increase that we had for this current fiscal year. 25-26 is predicted to be 2.93, and this is a little bit outdated, because the most recent information is that that is closer to 2.2, 2.3 right around. So that is a moving target, as always. As you hit January, the governor's revise will come, and then we'll get more information in that 3.08. It would be great if it was maintained, but with economic uncertainty that we're all aware of, that may change as well in the near future. Enrollment, you can see the enrollment projections here, mainly due to TK. There's a little bit of increase from adopted to first interim. You have a little bit of an increase, mainly due to TK. Then you can see it's a projected decline, which is

081not uncommon with school districts here. Many districts in the state are facing this decline. There are some developments happening here in San Carlos, so that might help stave off some of the enrollment decline, but it won't be significant. The funded ADA, that's the projected funded ADA based on, like I mentioned before, 96% attendance in ADA. The uncontrollable factors are STRS and PERS, so you can see the projected cost of those as PERS is increasing quite a bit to 27%. Unemployment usually is about 0.05%. That hasn't changed much over the years, and it's not projected to change much. Then you see the funding for the lottery unrestricted and restricted per student funding for the lottery, and then the mandated block grant is there as well. Those are planning factors for multiyear projection. This is a really

082busy slide. This is the multiyear projection for the San Carlos. You can see that we are projected to deficit spend, and the healthy ending fund balance is what supports that right now. There's going to be some work to see where we can look to save money, to kind of make sure that the budget is not continuing to deficit spend over the years, because I know what's looming out there is the parcel tax, and that is something that is not in these years. The next year on this column, so if you're looking at 27-28, that would be the last year that the district would receive the funds from the parcel tax. We should be preparing for that, and we will be looking at that, and looking at all of our expenditures, and making sure we're not

083frivolously spending, and making sure we see areas that we can tighten the belt, because you never know with the uncertainty of a potential parcel tax, and with that revenue. It's just an uncertainty. Transfers in are coming from, that's a Fund 20 that is helping support and making sure we're not deficit or support deficit spending, and you can see the issue here though is that that will be fully expended by that year of 26-27. So 26-27 will be the last year that we'll be able to transfer in from that source to help with the deficit spending. Here's a summary of all the other funds outside of the General Fund that came from the ASB account all the way to the Enterprise account, and you can see the highlights here. The star was referenced. That's the Fund

08420 where the money is transferred into, and you can take a look. The Child Nutrition Services Fund 13 with Universal Meals. That's a healthy account right now, but if Universal Meals ever does go away, then that fund would then encroach on the General Fund, is how that typically works. But with Universal Meals, there's a higher reimbursement rate because all students are getting access to free meals at this time. And you can see the other funds listed there. The Enterprise Fund is another one that there's a balance there, but that's also a fund that helps support other programs throughout the district. This slide is put together to make sure we're highlighting the considerations and challenges for the district. You know, continued budget pressures. As you can see, salary increases. You have COLA. Goods and services are

085going to increase. So if we go into an economic downturn, that would affect funding for the district as well. You can see expenditures are outpacing local revenues. We mentioned the partial tax was something that's looming out there. It expires 27-28 as the last year for that funding and the foundation contributions. The continued costs of implementing and managing mandated programs. So TK and Universal TK is putting a burden on the district and a lot of districts. Having that ratio is not easy at times. You have to find the right staff and you have to make sure that you have the right aides in the classroom. So that puts a pressure on the district expiring of remaining one-time state grants. So the Arts and Music Instructional Block Grant is going away. The Learning and Business Recovery Grant

086is going away. So taking a close look at what those are funding to make sure that those are funds that are not going to end up on the general fund or what are we going to do with anything that is being supported by those programs is important to look at what's going on there. The risk factors, state budget deficit. So the LAO warns that there's potential downturn and economic uncertainty. You can see the COLA here is projected 2.46 for 25-26. We've talked a little about that. And then the federal funds, possible policy changes impacting those and special education and the implications that those have because special education is always an encouragement on the general fund. And then you know the question about LCFF versus community funded. We talked a little bit about that but right

087now San Carlos will not be a community funded district for this year. We'll see how the economy is and your property taxes but that could change. Things have been looking up but you know they're starting to slow down as well. So we just keep an eye on that and make sure it works. We're monitoring that. So the purpose for tonight was to answer any clarifying questions and also to request approval from the board for this presentation of the first interim that Chris and Denise have put together. Thank you Ralph. It was a big lift to come in for your first meeting and present first center. Nice job. Thank you. It was a bit of a challenge but it's important work because I need to know what's going on and it was just a great way

088to sit with the experts that are in the budget for the last year and making sure that I know where their concerns are and I know what direction we need to go in the future. Thanks for being here. Questions? Trustees? You want to write down a question? The funding that's been set aside for textbook adoption. I'm just jogging my memory. That's for math. It's for math and language arts. We hope. I don't know that it will stretch that far but we definitely, math adoption is going to happen next year. So around this time next year they'll release the list of acceptable materials then we'll start the pilot process. So Denise and I have been in discussion about the whole list. We just need to put it aside because we know we're going to need at

089least that much. And then when would we be looking at the language arts? The following year as of this moment but that's also it's really kind of a state moving target but right now they're saying is 26, 27 will be the adoption. They haven't updated the framework yet. I don't know how much work has actually been finished with that. My questions were really around STRS and PERS and why those are relatively flat given that we really come out of a long period of ratcheting and escalation. And then the other question is around healthcare costs and how we've thought about ratcheting healthcare costs. It's something that's hitting our staff in their pocketbook and also hitting us. And I recall that there's some changes potentially in how much those prices could go up meaningfully. And so I

090just want to make sure like how are we thinking about those in our budget? So retirement, STRS and PERS and then healthcare costs. Yeah, that was good questions. Retirement, STRS and PERS, those are projections we get from the LAO. So those are numbers that the 19% and 27%. So those are numbers and projections that we have for there. Fund 20 was something that was supporting some of that in the past. As far as healthcare benefits, that's always on the mind when we talk about negotiations and what teachers have currently and what they're going to be requesting. It is a way to attract and retain teachers if you have a good benefits package. So that's a discussion we will have as a cabinet to see where resources are to potentially increase those. But those are some

091things that we do think is important for employees and staff that they have the appropriate benefits. Yeah. I mean, I would just say that those ones feel like a little bit out of our... I look at what are the variables we can control and what are the variables we can't control? And I find it interesting that they would say that STRS and PERS went up a little bit in the outer years, but are essentially flat. If you look at some of the other elements of the state budget, you would never expect that to just be a flat number. That said, the stock market is doing really well, which affects the retirement fund. So I don't know whether that's a short-sighted budget thing or not, but the sensitivity just for 1% movement up, it's just very,

092very expensive. And so I just think those are things going forward that need to be really monitored closely because we won't have the ability to change that course. We'll have to just react. Absolutely. That's something we definitely need to closely monitor. Okay. Jennifer, you and I talked about when we were looking at this in one of our meetings, the transfer of that 6.6 million from unrestricted to restricted. I think Ralph spoke to it a little bit with the encroachment of the special education, but can you repeat what you said to me? Because I thought it was helpful just to understand what that represents and why we do that. About the OPEB? Well, why we're transferring six and a half million dollars from our unrestricted to our restricted. I don't remember. I'm embarrassed to admit. Chris,

093can you help out on that? Maybe I'm misremembering. No, I'm sure you are remembering something. I just don't remember specifically the contribution that we make from the unrestricted funds to the restricted. It's mainly special education and other restricted programs. You make that contribution because you are deficit spending in some. Maybe the expenses are higher than the restricted funds will go. And so then we have to deliberately make, and some people call that encroachment, contribution. But it is an encroachment essentially on those funds. Is that the one? Yeah. And we had added that actually to the executive summary. So there's a special education, the routine restricted maintenance account. So that mandating that we have that 3%. And then transfers of unrestricted funds to the Sequoia health care district grant, measure K grant that we have program

094shortfall, right? The cost of that has been increased. Those grants are covering. Yes. So I'm following now. I got Sarah's thing. So one of the things that can be hidden in this budget is that our education foundation does a nice job of raising the same money this year as they did last year, while salaries and all expenses are higher. And so both. Yeah. So thank you, Sarah. So essentially we're trying to make that money go further than it can go. And then we end up encroaching on other things to pay for it. That's true for the Sequoia health care district funds. That's true for the parcel tax, although this board agreed with the parcel tax committee and Denise's recommendations that instead of saying the parcel tax covers this much of each of those staff positions

095and the budget, the general fund budget covers as much to make sure that we're really clear that the parcel tax is covering fewer teachers than it used to because those salaries are going up. And so, yeah, we do need to make transfers. Thank you for my recollection on that, because I think that sometimes we don't talk about that as frankly as we should, but we are essentially trying to do the same with fewer dollars and all of our cost utilities even have gone up. And so now just being really honest with where our revenues are actually covering and what they're not covering. Thank you. Anything else? We're ready for approval. Make a motion. I will move approval of the 24-25 first interim budget. Second. All in favor, please state by saying aye. Aye. Thank you.

096Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Glad to have you. All right, move on to a resolution for authorized signatures. Yes, we're asking that the board approve these authorizing signatures. Obviously, we have some familiar names, but you'll see that Ralph Crane's name has replaced Denise Laquan. I ask that the board approve these persons to sign on the dotted line. Thank you. I just realized I didn't ask for public comment, but I have no hands and I have no parts. All right. We assume no public comment from this. Is there a motion to approve? So moved. Second. All in favor, please say by saying aye. Aye. To our MOU and FUA with charter. Thank you. Thank you. San Carlos Charter Learning Center and SCSD have been working together in partnership to develop the agreements being considered for

097approval this evening. A first reading was held publicly at the November 21st board meeting where representatives from charter were present and able to provide public comment if needed and the charter board has already approved these agreements at their board meeting this week. And so we recommend approval of the Memorandum of Understanding and the Facilities Use Agreement. And I'm highlighting just the edits of the MOU include moving the 1% B structure to that document of the MOU as suggested at the meeting and putting it with Section 9 where it is discussed and flows better. And the first whereas was edited to reflect the school year and a June 1st deadline was added to participate in nutrition services if they prefer or want to. And the Facilities Use Agreement edits include making the term of the agreement

098a whereas, clarifying the language describing the relationship between space allocation and enrollment and removing the 1% fee structure as it now resides in the MOU where it's more appropriate. So we really thank you for your partnership in this and the journey that we've all gone on and the collaboration and the work that we've done together. And I recommend that we approve these both both of these agreements tonight. Thank you. Justice, any questions or comments? Just repeat what I said before. I think it's great to have all these aligned and I'm hopeful that you know when you sign a five-year operating partnership things are going to come up and if we need to make amendments we can and you know whether it's a rainstorm or whether it's traffic like I hope this sets the framework for

099a really successful partnership for years to come. Thank you. All right. Public comment? Thank you. I do not have public blue cards. After two years I still forget. Exactly. All right. Well I'll move approval of the Memorandum of Understanding and Facilities Use Agreement with San Carlos Charter Learning Center for 2025 through 2030. Second. All in favor please state by saying aye. Aye. Aye. That's approved for zero. Thanks again to the Charter Team. Yay. Five-year vacation commits. Two more items. No, three more items. Five more items. All right. On to our lease-leaseback agreement and resolution. And I would like to say a few words before I turn it over to Jennifer Gabri and we'll likely need a little bit more than five minutes but not too much more than five minutes. I just thought it'd be

100helpful to kind of bring us into the work with a reminder to the board that in the fall the district requested proposals for qualified providers of a lease-leaseback district-wide HVAC upgrade project. The goal was to identify and vet a company to complete the important phase one project of HVAC for our six district schools consistent with our Measure H bond and to support the facility master plan. Seven proposals were received and a process of scoring and interviews followed. This involved district staff and the facility steering committee. Ben is here representing that group. We're here to ask for approval to enter into an agreement for Flint Design Build to upgrade the HVAC at six schools to be completed by the end of summer 2026. As a reminder, it was just a year ago that this team was

101approving a resolution for Measure H. So it's pretty amazing that we're pulling this together. There's a resolution here and then attached agreements developed by attorneys which Jen will briefly discuss and I'll invite Trustee Cornell to provide additional information as well as the steering committee person. This board will see several things related to this following tonight. Again, we're asking for approval of a resolution but there are several next steps including negotiations phase, pre-construction, et cetera, et cetera. One of the things we're trying to get in front of is possible tariffs and price escalation because we do have a big goal of getting three schools done this summer 2025 and summer 2026 is a big priority for our community. And I'm going to turn it over to Jennifer Gabri to give more details. Okay. Thank you very

102much, Dr. Frentress. And it is amazing that it's only been one year since we started talking about Measure H and now we are bringing it to action. So having been given the direction expressly to move as swiftly as possible to realize the facility's master plan and particularly the climate ready products or projects, sorry, of phase one that include district-wide HVAC upgrades. So we have a resolution on the board tonight, number 12, 20, 24, 24, 25, hard to say that with the slashes, but supporting the award of the lease lease back agreements and authorization to enter into the lease lease back agreements with for the district-wide H grade upgrade project. I know that you may have numerous questions around some of the things we're engaging in and we'd be happy to have a study session as

103we have more decisions to make related to Measure H and we can start to learn a little bit deeper about more about all of the delivery methods and understand them and I'm happy to set that up if needed. So our lease lease back structure is explained in the request for qualifications and proposals then obviously known by its initials mostly and so we have had that on our website and it's been out in the public eye since October 12th so that was a way for us to be able to communicate to anyone who's interested in participating in this Measure H project. They had the invitation to participate and we are really grateful for the best value proposal that was submitted by Flint and therefore we recommend that the board approve this resolution and authorize us to

104move forward with this proposal and we do have a goal of six schools being completed by summer of 2026 and so in light of that goal we have some cost estimation that has been provided by our DSK architects team and that was included in our proposal request for proposals that we put on our website and that has been approximately 14 million dollar project over the course of two summers and we also are asking tonight for an early procurement allowance that's recommended for approval to allow materials with lengthy lead times and that are in high demand as you know there's many regulations related to heat extreme heat and it applies to classrooms and learning environments as well and so a lot of our state and other across the nation are engaged in this HVAC work right

105now and so and being able to be ahead of procurement makes sure that we are able to be ready when the summer comes we've got our things that we need to do to get the work done so our next steps are site surveying dsa plan submittal dsa feedback resolution dsa approval again construction scheduling equipment procurement and communication with school sites surrounding communities and families our this firm was particularly uh you know it was evident that they were interested in making sure our families around the schools are knowing what's going on and that was really helpful to have a focus on that because we all know that we're in this together and we are working towards having learning environments that are available to students any day any climate any you know situation we're facing outside and

106we know that our communities support that but we also want to be kind and friendly neighbors and let them know when the trucks are coming and those types of things so i know that we'll engage in all of that once we hopefully get your approval this evening to move forward with this project and we'll continue to revisit the guaranteed maximum price as in it's in evolving negotiation so with the proposal includes a costing structure that you may have seen in that is used to generate the gmp the cost estimation of the project is continually evolving because you're responding to the dsa revisions in the plans the materials costs and the subtract subcontractor bidding process and so some of those things will impact the gmp so our attorneys have advised us that it is a multi-stage

107discussion that you have and it may come back to the board a few times before we settle on the gmp so i just wanted to share that a little bit into the process i hope i'm not getting too far into the weeds into what we're up to here but you know again we ask for your proposal your approval tonight of the resolution and give us permission to go into a contract thank you yeah so i think um you know whenever you have a facilities master plan and you have a bond passed you're starting the journey not finishing it and um the way that these processes work is you pick the people that you want to work with based on their track record their evidence of success also aligned expectations etc and then they're essentially your

108partners to help you work through that and one of the important partners that we have is the architect and the firm that worked with us on so much of the facilities master plan so there's continuity through that to make sure that we're delivering on the vision that we outlined in the facilities master plan and all of that work and then when you go through these bidding processes where you have different firms pitching you you actually learn a lot it's a very helpful thing because you can take even if you pick one you can take some ideas that the other firms had around how to stage it or schedule it or what kind you know you learn a lot about air conditioning systems frankly and and um and you know i think one of the salient

109things you learn is it's not just about your one-time cost of buying it but also the services costs and the maintenance and the complexity of your system and given that we're a small district how how can we manage all of that so you know approving this resolution doesn't lock us into a specific cost like it would normally would when we bid something out and then we say this is what we'll pay but it does give us the chance to move forward with a partner who can really help us coordinate that at the detailed level and they they really showed a track record of finding low-cost ways to work with schools having done countless schools the second thing i would say is we are this is probably not going to be the only item we're kind

110of in a race against all these other people that just passed their bonds in november so we this was part of our original strategy of like a march bond was going to allow us to get shovel ready much much faster and the air conditioning project was kind of a signature element of the bond and so i think there's a real asset in moving this forward quickly but that said we did consider the idea of doing all six sites all in one summer and what we as we actually asked people about that we realized that staging it and doing three and three was really the most thoughtful conservative like winnable thing to do and as you're trying to move around summer programming it gives you that space also it allows if one project is behind it's

111not going to throw off all the other projects so and there was an element around having people on site that we really feel like having somebody who's accountable on site that the school leader or staff can go to was also a real important piece so that's really what led us to choose this firm and i know just give kudos to jennifer for leading all of this and you know it is a it's you know we're a little bit down on our stat like low on facility and maintenance staff to go through this but it was a really thoughtful process and i like came away with a ton of learnings and i think that you know i'd highly recommend that we support this thank you thanks for providing that context um sarah any questions or comments

112i don't thank you for all of the additional contextual information that i know was pulled together very quickly um but i feel informed and great even forward okay agree with that thumbs up all right i don't have anything else so we're ready to move the approval i i move that we approve 70 the big the big note on my computer that's a public comment oh public comment public comment no all right go ahead i move that we approve 70 okay all in favor please say by saying aye aye aye thank you thank you very excited to move on and then are you doing the next yes project yeah um so this is agenda item s and so you may have heard the words cal shape project for some time now if you've been on the

113board or in the audience and so we're we're thrilled to know that this has been present in board discussion since 2022 or the school year of 2021-22 and we're bringing this proposal forward for approval to complete the work associated with this grant and the improvements in the co2 monitoring as well as the air quality that accompanies this installation of our pelican thermostats which are over there to work with our hvac upgrades and concert and done adjacently to this project so that we can finish this whole project together and so we're excited to finally be at this stage in a project that i know has been um been ongoing and i'll say that yeah so thank you so i recommend that we um approve this project for this evening okay questions i don't have any questions

114i was very excited to see this moving forward i have heard concerns from um parents about indoor air quality um some of the school sites so it's great to see it advancing okay good i will move approval of the agreement with is that an acronym kya project second all in favor please say by saying aye aye thank you all right um item g discussion of filling a board vacancy i will pass the mic to them hi everyone as some of you may know i recently uh had a career change i got a new job as ceo of a new company and the company happens to be located in san diego and so i'm going to be commuting from the bay area between uh here and and san diego and so as such it's really hard

115for me to continue on the board and after how you rolled out the red carpet for neil i mean come on um uh but i will say i it is really with like a tremendous um sadness to leave the board at this time of really incredible opportunity to move from thrive to transform i really have loved and enjoyed the work here and we'll have more to say on all of that but uh with that i have to prioritize my family and time with the family and you all know some of the stuff we've been through with health issues and so on so um this is just a important moment for me to be with them when i'm in town and since i'll be on the road so with that i'm gonna resign from the board

116effective february 10th or uh whenever you find someone to replace me and i didn't want to sit on that um i wanted to kind of bring that here to this process so that we could run a excellent process to fill two board spots and i hope we find two great people um so i'm you know forever a friend and supporter of this san carlos board and i will be a parent and an advocate going forward so thank you all and thanks for understanding thank you for your years of service and we'll have the opportunity to recognize and celebrate you more fully um at the january 16th meeting but thank you for willing to being willing to you know give us some runway um we still have you on board to find a replacement we're certainly

117sorry to see you go don't wish you best of luck in your new role um so the three of us i'm gonna recuse myself from the vote yeah yeah so the three of us have to decide how to fill ben's seat so given that we're already undergoing an appointment process to fill the seat vacated by neil um the recommendation is that we use the same process to fill those seats um we do have 60 days from today to fill ben's seat so that does give us until february 10th but ideally we could fill both seats with one process which will be complete by january 14th um either of you have comments or anything to add on that um the meeting on january 14th where the interviews take place is that the only um topic for

118that meeting okay because it could take additional yeah time yeah okay yeah yeah because we also we have a regular our regular meeting is 16th right okay we're doing it on a on a separate day so that we have enough time yeah i mean all the reasons i had for doing an appointment still exist um so oh so we just need to um you know approve that and then i also i wanted to be sure that we formally create the temporary subcommittee that tracy and i are serving on to manage the process we've been serving in this capacity and you know ensuring compliance with the brown act and actually a temporary subcommittee of two board members is not subject to the requirements of the brown x but i realized that in our last meeting we

119didn't actually officially create the committee so i want to do that as well um but first let's vote and to fill the seat through appointment and then we can do that committee do we need a motion to fill the vacant this additional vacancy through an appointment shared appointment process yep i'll move that perfect second all in favor uh please say by saying aye aye that was 3-0 um with an abstaining and then um a second motion to create the subcommittee i i think a motion to create a temporary ad hoc subcommittee to manage the appointment process that will be do i need to name the members that would consist of sarah cassinago and tracy park a second all in favor please say by saying aye aye thank you so much um and then i thought

120i would just highlight key dates um for anybody who is listening or watches this later we'll have two virtual candidate information sessions uh next week during which two current trustees will be available to answer questions about board service so those are the 17th um following our reorganization meeting so that'll be from eight to nine and then the 18th um from seven to eight then candidate information forms are due january 8th at nine and we will have a meeting on the 14th to interview all candidates who've submitted a completed application and are determined to be eligible to serve um and we will interview everyone in public and then discuss and make a decision regarding appointment at that same meeting and if you're listening please do consider whether you or someone you know might be interested in

121board service um it really is a meaningful way to serve your community it was a great actually to start the meeting with neil and hear you know what he what we had to say about him and what he had to say about serving um and i feel like we've worked really well together as a governance team and look forward to having some new trustees join us all right then we will our final two so start with the city field management agreement yes uh so what we have before you is a memorandum of understanding amendment uh that relates as well to a broader agreement we plan to develop with our city partners um we have uh at the board's direction reached out to all of our city partners to form a joint use agreement that would

122memorialize all the ways that we partner with the with the city staff uh from safe routes um and crossing guards to our summer programming use of fields uh etc um meanwhile we have an agreement that is sunsetting on december 31st so this would allow us a few weeks time uh to get that meeting off the ground jennifer gabrie is point on pulling this together with the city staff the first week of january and then the two plus two committee will be an opportunity to deliberate further about that and then this board would consider approval of that joint use agreement but in the in the uh intern thank you uh we want to make sure that we have an agreement in place so both of these agreements are related to that extension that then will come

123back as a longer term agreement with all of our shared interests and collaborations codified so i'm asking that you approve this and because she uh is struggling to speak uh tracy park has suggested no you're fine okay it's okay very good just when you're fine never mind any questions comments i'll move in uh move approval of the city field maintenance agreement for heather no yes that's what we're on yes uh maintenance agreement for heather central and tiara linda l second all in favor please state by saying aye aye two four zero and then the next is the amendment to the mou with the synchro youth yes the youth organizations and that is the one that tracy park feels like she should recuse herself from um given her involvement with ays so is that right synchro

124this unit i'm on the board of sync plus g9 ah thank you yeah okay do these two agreements always follow the same cycle are they always in alignment for dates um well so they have been one way but we predict there will be another way because of our intent to try to get everything sort of together in agreement um i don't know all the ways in which that might evolve that hence the meeting of staff from both the city and the district but they should be aligned obviously since they are interconnected right yeah but the the youth organizations we do that on an annual basis and that's would be the approach going forward regardless of whatever term we set with the city agreement or that might change too it might change too i mean the

125way we have the agreement right now may change but i do expect that we'll be bringing the board up to date after we have that meeting and we meet with the two plus two of how it evolves we can't be exactly certain how that will evolve this also just allows us to have more time to navigate this process in a thoughtful collaborative way with our partners and so we want to just extend this agreement that's already been in place until the end of this school year so june 30 2025 so no change until that time thank you do you want to make a motion go ahead uh approval of the amendment to the memoranda of understanding with san carlos youth organization second all in favor please say you're saying aye aye and that's approved three

126zero trustee park statement okay that was all right yes all right uh future agenda items we have our reorg on tuesday and then our appointment meeting on the 14th and our first regular meeting of the year of the 16th that's right anything else that we heard about from hans you'll have no doubt all sorts of interesting things coming back related to hvac etc um and then a study session uh after that in february on literacy okay good uh trustees anything all right so do public comment on non-agenda items right finally done it's your turn play group comments so sweet to speak i know thank you for being here we need a mic room okay up to her old days these meetings used to go to like nine so good evening uh the san carlos teachers

127association is appreciative of the tentative agreement that we've reached with the district um the increase in salary and health and welfare helps teachers in their daily lives uh we had about 91 of our teachers vote yes on the agreement and we had the majority of our teachers vote large majority so thank you to superintendent barber and their team and to you for uh for helping make this race possible uh thank you to our sct negotiations chair angela notton and her team for serving our teachers and our school counselors you have a happy holiday season and a healthy evening again uh do we have someone from csa online okay great board member comments um penny was anyone like to start uh i don't have a whole lot to say given everything that was said today but

128i do think um uh this is the time of year where we go to break uh for a lot of families it's easy to head out early you saw our attendance numbers please show up to school those last days important learning can happen and i know our educators are also scrambling to get those projects done and some of the most meaningful learning experiences we have happen right before the break so um before you check out make sure your kids are attending those last days of school with that i will pass okay um so a smaller group of us went to the csba education conference this year so i wanted to share the most exciting nugget that i learned which was a session on measure n which was a parcel tax in davis that recently passed

129and what they were able to do was pass a permanent uh parcel tax uh which is the first time i have heard of this um but i really think it's something we should be starting to consider learning from this example certainly polling on when we get to that point in a few years um and some of the the things that led to their success um they had some really strong messaging around um this is the ultimate in total local control this local funding that is permanent um that um you know just the ability to maintain excellence in their schools without threat of a funding cliff um they said that their teachers association was heavily involved and they in fact were able to draw down resources from the california the statewide association that helped them with

130their canvassing efforts they provided software for that effort um so lots of really great tidbits let me see the pta is endorsed um it's tied it does increase over time um tied to the consumer price index and they passed it in march of this year so just a really cool example and i'm hopeful that we could learn from them and maybe do something similar in a few years thank you okay all right yeah we've there's been a lot to say tonight so i just wanted to end with a thank you to our school staff teachers administrators district office staff um for all you do to get through this busy time of year and keep our students happy safe and learning have a wonderful holiday season with your loved ones over to you you know uh

131dan sort of stole our thunder was there anything else you wanted to add about uh we've had some wonderful time at the negotiations table that um i would say my colleagues always experience but through interest-based bargaining um and shared uh collaboration we've accomplished a lot is there anything you wanted to add to what dan talked about yeah i think you hit the nail on the head the the interest-based bargaining process has been so prosperous for us um just candor transparency real honesty at the table mixed in with a little bit of education that is well well taken and well respected um it's really gone a long way and moving forward our relationship with sc and we just feel so great about we went back to the table actually on we we settled last week we

132went back to the table this week and we were able to do some other pieces as well so um just beginning the whole journey of a big contract and anytime you can accomplish just one or two little things on a whole day when you're doing the entire contract it's like wow that's great um and so you know it was a great way to to be ending december is to say we're finished with 24 25 and we're hopeful about finishing the 20 20 26 to 20 28 contract um you know as quickly as possible but just that candor and the respect of the table is so highly valued i think on both sides so it's great and that's it thank you all right the board will now go into closed session to discuss items 14 a

133and b as listed on the agenda can we have any public comment from this session all right the board will now thank you oh are you ready okay uh the board will now leave closed session or reconvene into open session uh pursuant to california government code section 54957.1 no reportable action was taken in closed session on items 14a or b we adjourn our meeting at 9 20 pm

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.