CorpusRecord 10555

School Board Public Hearing and Work Session 01/23/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Shenandoah County Public Schools
Date
2025-01-24
Location
Shenandoah County, VA
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,820 words · about 55 min
Collected
2026-06-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e any opposed un opposed all right [Applause] so I have an explanation to read about our hearing this evening a public hearing is scheduled for Thursday January 23rd at 6:30 p.m. in the county boardroom of the sheno County Government Center 600 North Main Street Woodstock Virginia for the shenoa County School Board to receive the views of citizens within the school district in accordance with section 22.1-cu needed for public schools prior to the superintendent's proposed budget for for school year 26 a public hearing is held to receive feedback from the community so the sheno County School Board welcomes such public comment and I'm wondering if there's anybody here to present any requests or anything else of us I'm glad we cut it down to 15 minutes but me too um it's a sole purpose for our

002being here so um we will not be able to convene our next meeting until 64 6:45 uh so uh what I think I'm going to do is just uh adjourn this meeting but um I would ask you to kind of hold kind of tight in the area if somebody comes in with that time period I guess they'd be allowed to speak so if we just kind kind of not hanging your seats but hang around so we can reconstitute ourselves and in any case we will uh reconvene at 6:45 okay thank you e e e speaker shanida County School Board welcomes public comment from shanida County residents parents or Guardians as well as from current students and employees of sheno County Public Schools school board members do not respond to public comments during the meeting or

003hearing the speaker has up to three minutes um I don't think we have to worry about it using 30 minutes from anybody else all topics should address a matter related to sheno County Public Schools budget this evening and School Board expects each speaker will be courteous and show proper deorum and speakers have to uh speak in the order in which they've signed up we have one speaker so I think speaker who signed up will speak first an are you ready okay good to see everybody tonight um I'm here just to continue to advocate for the elementary students um CU they're too young to know the difference of things that we need and I think for the first time I've realized how important it is to maybe stand up for them we are busting at the

004seams we even had a come to our school today or yesterday to do a socio culture with one of our um student support Specialists we couldn't find a single space for them to go to meet to have a private conversation and we ended up displacing an assistant principal who was on the phone trying to have a meeting with someone and he graciously gave his space up for that so and I did want to I just wanted to say that the architect facility assessment study the total that was spent was $316,000 and 50 so $316 $150 and what did we get from that we always L didn't get any concerns about what was going on in at Sandy Hook and that's why I brought that to light I think you know and then I had no

005idea what was going on with the swim team I'm trying to find Outside resources maybe to get a grant for that but if you look at the money that we have what more bang for our book and what more students would we serve if we put a the braks on the vocational get another Elementary School to alleviate the traffic issues that we have on both campuses be able to properly renovate the the the existing elementary schools that we have and do it for the betterment and the health and the safety and the future of those kids and Sho County Public Schools I will stand here and I will be here at every meeting to continue to advocate for that to advocate for them to advocate for our teachers who are most of them are afraid

006to speak up um they've been quiet for too long so I appreciate your time I hope you would consider that in the budget for our next for the future of our kids thank you thank you so that concludes the public comment so I am going to adjourn the first the first meeting and uh that will be at 6:47 p.m. and we're going to move uh directly into um our work session now so I'd like to call the order of the shenoa County School Board pre-budget work session January 23rd 2025 and uh for this meeting I would also ask for a move uh motion to approve the agenda as it has been presented to us I move to approve the agenda as presented thank you Mr Guta second second Mr rer thank you for that all

007in favor of approval of the agenda please signify by saying I I any opposed none uh and so we're moving directly into that work session and um the whole concept of the budget development process Dr Shepard over to you so as I go through these slides you will notice that many of them seem like you may say oh I've seen these before because you have um you may have seen them on October 28th when we did our pre-budget meeting um but when we get later into the presentation you'll see my um my thoughts my focus um on on our fiscal year 26 budget so this evening we're going to talk about uh division goals missions Visions a belief we'll talk about student enrollment um Personnel information budget process and information and then the fiscal year

0082026 budget next steps and then there'll be an opportunity for questions but please interrupt at any time if you have a question so that we can um be on it as we are going through the presentation so our division goals academic achievement and growth is always at the top of our of our list positive School climate and culture family engagement Community connections recruitment support and retain enthusiastic professionals and then high quality and adequate facilities and learning environments the mission of shanida County Public Schools is to prepare each student for a future um of lifelong learning and then you can um read through our beliefs there in our vision we want to be the best game in town we want to produce um students who um Can succeed either whether they go to the workforce they

009go to college two or four year college they go to the military and we want to be um the best in Virginia as well our beliefs all decisions are based on the best interest of our students meaningful learning occurs only in the presence of meaningful relationships continuous growth and Improvement are expected for everyone atmosphere of respect must exist so when we talk about student enrollment you will see in um 2012 13 we had a little over 6,000 students the first line is um our kindergarten through 12th grade and then the second line adds of the lighter blue um bar there adds in our prek students so you'll notice in 2012 13 we were over 6,000 and then over the last um probably starting um there in 1516 we went under 6,000 uh to 5928 for

010our K through 12 and we declined over the next uh many years and then we're starting a a slight uptick at this point is that take into consideration the new um buildings that they're building in stury and all that or no so it's taking into consideration any new housing that is currently um established but these are the students that are actually in our schools at this particular time um in 2020 we had uh 2021 that was um the year of the pandemic we had a lot of students who actually um did homeschool where or went to private schools because we were doing a lot of um virtual online learning so um that you know really started this significant um decrease and then we decreased for the next couple of years and now we're we're on

011an up an uptick and then um this is just a different way to look at it um so the darker blue line is our September 30th enrollment and then March um March 8m um is our number in at the end of March on the number of students that we have in our average daily membership so um so we always start a year with a few more students than um our average daily membership in March so we always lose lose a few due to moving or um or whatnot do we know the number or can we guess a number of not guess the number of students who have in Quotes come back maybe from homeschooling or in other words you know what I'm saying somebody during Co who was went elsewhere or dropped when homeschooling and

012then decided to come back to public school we have that number I don't have it with me uh but we have the number of students who who went from home school back to public so that would indicate some there would be some significant number here that would be increased from those people who kind of came back home is that is that you think that's an accurate statement okay okay just write myself a note um and you'll look at the enrollment Trends in um this is our elementary schools but notice that um we didn't include the year 20 2020 to 21 because um the fifth grade students were at our middle school so so uh so we took those numbers out because it um it wasn't a an accurate reflection of the number of K through

0135 students that we had and you you know you can see Ashby Lee um had a slight uptick there um between 22 23 and 23 24 and that was because we moved the fifth grade students from um North Fork Middle School to ASP Le Elementary School that year so there's a slight uptick and that will be you know about the average number of students they have over the next few years at Sandy Hook Elementary School you'll see you'll see a downward Trend and our third fourth and fifth grade are are larger than our K12 at Sandy Hook Elementary School um and our K12 I looked at those numbers um yesterday they were in the 10 let me think um in the 20s and then uh is it 100 20 yes and then our and then

014our um fourth fifth and sixth grade third fourth and fifth grade are in the two or 250s 220 and 250 is that right I'm looking right now yeah and then ww Robinson you'll also notice a slight decrease over the last you know over the last few years the element the K1 and two round 120 yes and then the third fourth and fifth are around 140 yeah they fluctuate but around 140 yeah so here are middle schools um you'll notice that North Fork Middle School stayed the same um even two years ago because they traded their fifth grade students for eighth grade students so the eighth grade students U move from uh Stone High School to North Fork Middle School and Peter mberg we were U meeting with her during her um for her budget pre

015um for her budget information and she said that she hadn't uptick in the number of students over the last couple of years look at that about 200 students or my mouth is off today um about 80 students over the last uh year they have increased and then signal knob is is you know had a slight Decline and then they're they're pretty stable now and again year 2020 2021 was not included because of covid grade configurations um here you'll notice Central High School um slight increase and then a slight decrease uh Stonewall Jackson high school again last the 20 223 school year to the 23 24 school year they lost their um eighth grade students to North Fork Middle School and so they'll they'll likely stay stable over the next few years there there is a

016um a few classes at North Fork that are are rather small and then um strawsburg High School pretty stable over the last couple of years birth rates um kind of fluctuate between 399 and 538 over the last uh number of years uh you will notice in 2020 we had a slight uptick and then um in 2022 um that was the lowest number that we've seen um since uh 2000 and then this um relates to our kindergarten classes so took that information and then forwarded it 5 years so our kindergarten class of um 2024 were the students that were B were the kids that were born in 2019 you'll notice that there were 478 kids born in chanida county in 2019 and this year we had 367 of those come to um kindergarten next year is

017is our largest you know our largest number over the last um 12 years so we should see an uptick in kindergarten students next year um based on the number of uh children that were born in shinida county in 2020 and then we'll see a decline over the next couple of years in kindergarten should see a decline in kindergarten students over the next couple of years for introduced lunch eligibility um a little bit all over the place but um over the last couple of years we have been um receiving information from the Department of Social Services to identify our students who are eligible for free and reduced lunch El eligibility so it's probably a more accurate number than we've had um over the last many years how much longer do we have that program going is

018it three more years or two more it's two more years this is the third year of a fivey year and we can always um ask to be included again after that um so just to point out this is kind of relevant in the fact that everyone is getting it right now yes the ones that would qualify for it if we didn't have it yes that's correct that is correct so 100% of our students are getting free breakfast and free lunch um due to the C program and we're in year three of five years so we'll get it again next year and the following year um and then we can reapply the following year if if we're interested in continuing doing that program English Learners we have um this this will be relevant in a future

019slide um probably closer to slide 40 um a slight uptick in the number of English Learners that we have and you'll notice since 2014 to 200 um 24 not quite doubled but we're getting there and then our students with disabilities and our students with 504 plans I do want to point out that my data comes from September and if you see U Miss stratton's data hers her data is always from December a December one count so we're taking um a snapshot at different times of the year so our data may not actually U mirror each other but it's it's you know it's similar information and you'll notice a slight increase in the number of students with disabilities um from last year to this year and also a slight decrease in the number of students with

0205504 plans from last year to this year so Personnel this is information that you saw probably in September and October um teacher retention we retained almost 82% of our staff which means that there was an 18.4% turnover the national average was 23% turnover that is higher this year than the last couple of years we had been averaging 14 and 15% um take a um a look at this slide in particular um you'll see this um on budget request um as well our budget Focus Slide the teachers that we are losing are 11 plus years of experience so it's our experience staff and um so you know a little over 50% of those student of our teachers actually leave um scps those who left have over 11 years of experience I think this has been asked

021before but this doesn't count retirement it does okay mhm it does and where are teachers going so Rockingham Frederick and Harrisonburg are the top three and just um when I compare shenoa County I always compare us to Rockingham and Frederick County because they're always first or second or or reverse order um to where we lose our our teachers to but I want to point out the little sticky note there on the right that 20% of our new teachers um came back to us had actually previously taught in Chenoa County so they're returning to us after having gone to another Division and taught for a little while and then they're returning have we asked them why they're returning it's various reasons a husband's job or a spouse's job um sorry they realized the grass wasn't Greener

022they didn't like the commute so one of the things that Miss Hodes is doing this year is she's doing um stay interview so I don't know how many she's done so far but she's been out at many of our schools doing these stay interviews these are teachers that are high performing teachers and she's asking them um why they've stayed what else what we're doing well what we can do better and what do we need to do keep here MH so and once she finishes that she'll um present the information to the school board on what she's found so looking forward to the yeah compilation of that information yeah so um we filled 98 teacher position six school counselors if you look to the right there were 78 um of these positions that were new to

023scps and then in September of this year these are the positions that remained unfilled so I want you to pay in particular attention to the number of special ed teachers um four and and school counselors at six elementary teachers this is um there were eight and then this um when I said I compareed to Frederick and Rockingham there's our salaries compared to to theirs and this is this year salary scale you'll notice um with zero years of experience we're slightly higher than Frederick County a little lower than Rockingham um and then Frederick county is a little more than us after that and I only went up to year 19 um but I have the whole salary scale compared that I'll share at a later date Frederick County doesn't get any raises from year two to

024year six yeah so during um the recession of 2010 2011 a lot of scales they call it they called it compressed were compressed so um and that happened to a lot of Divisions we fixed our compression three years ago I believe um so that we didn't have teachers that were on or or staff that were on a scale that was Zero um zero 1 to 4 5 to 7 um so we we separated that but some School divisions are still working on uncompressing their scales thank you and that happens when you don't have money to give pay increases kayln do you have anything else to add to that it's important to give your staff especially your teaching staff a step each year because that's what progresses them on the scale when you don't give teachers

025a step that's what causes compression thank you and then our health Insurance um last this is um us compared to Frederick and Rockingham and employee only you will see that we are um we're competitive there um employee plus spouse we competitive um employee plus family we still have a little work to do but we made a lot of ground over the last three and a half years years um we started um that it was at $1,249 and now for a family plan and now we're down to $83 so that's that's $450 that's um in in our employees Pockets at the end of the day we still have work to do and then here are our rates from 20 20 23 24 compared to 2425 so you'll see employee plus family we um improved that by

026a little over $100 um and we made a little bit of a difference on employee plus child in health insurance and salaries have been two areas where I have focused a lot of funds um in the last four years during and a half years so then um the budget process the code of Virginia 221-921-1888 um we have to submit it to the Board of Supervisors by April um of each the first day of April of each year and our timeline has us doing that I think uh we submit it to them uh sometime in May um March for if our timeline goes as scheduled and here's our here's our timeline so this evening we have the pre-budget um public Hearing in the work session um on February the 13th you will have my proposed budget

027and you'll have your budget book at that at that meeting um February 22nd is the general assembly concludes uh we'll have a um a work session on February the 24th and then we will meet with our Board of Supervisors to talk about what we believe our requests are going to be um sometime between um February and March that dates to be determined March 13th when we approve it and then the Board of Supervisors um establishes a tax rate and then they um do their public hearing and then they adopt a budget and then our final um work session is on April the 28th and then our budget um starts July the 1st so our first um approval for the budget is March the 13th and then the Board of Supervisors will say this is what

028um shador County Public Schools is going to get so then on April the 28th we will have to revise our budget and then we will send out contracts first part of um May 10th 12th 14th to um to our staff after we have an approved budget so where do we get our Revenue um and this has been you know a topic of conversation um for federal we get about one uh 1.3 million State 48 .6 million and then local is 35 million our technology fund is um about 500,000 where we support the County government with their technology our Capital Improvement last year was uh 3.3 million and then other which is in our special budgets is about 343,000 so you'll so you can see on the pat chart there that you know the majority of

029our funds you know a little over about 55% comes from the state um the federal is uh less than 2% so 1 and a half% and then our county is 39.3% which is right there so you'll see our federal revenue has remained pretty static over the last um eight nine years except for the year 2122 and in that number there was some cares funds that that were umri uted to that to that year in our federal funds our state funds um we talked about this a little bit last year come from our local Composite Index and our local Composite Index increased not quite 4% last year which meant that we had um State funds were a little less than $2 million than we would have had had our local Composite Index not increased by by

0304% and you will see what how the local Composite Index is um created it is by the true property value and the true property value here in Chenoa County went up significantly from um the previous LCI to the last LCI I think that's when we did reassessments for our our property so um and the LCI is calculated every two years so um we will get this is the second year of this LCI and then we will um we usually get information about this time about our LCI for um next year this time next year we'll receive what our new LCI is but adjusted gross income is the is another Factor that's considered and then our taxable retail sales you'll see minimal um increase there it's only weighted 10% though true um true value of property

031is 50% adjusted gross income is 40% and then our uh retail sales our taxable retail sales is about 10% so our state funding would have been $2 million more last year if our um if our LCI wouldn't have increased by 3.96% and um in your budget book from last year um we weren't the only division that increased there were like 66 divisions that increased 66 divisions that decreased and the others remain the same so um there's this Balancing Act every every bium when it comes to LCI and then here is our um our local funding for operational and you'll just note that this does not include CIP or technology funds so there's been a slight increase over the last eight years in local funds so where do we spend our money um almost 90% of

032our money is spent on salaries and benefits so it's people materials and supplies about 3% miscellaneous fees about 3% Professional Services about 3% capital a little less than 1% so state budget information on December the 18th Governor yunan um made proposed amendments to his 20 his banial budget and um those um this wasn't an amendment but he maintained the 3% proposed raise for School Division employees and then he did some technical updates to reflect actual student enrollment and demographics and then he updated um Lottery proceeds and sales tax based on recent performance and part of his proposed 2426 banial budget um sales tax revenue was updated uh he provided funding for um lab schools and shinida county is a partner in two of the lab schools one is a um teacher prep program it's the

033teacher Academy which will start for us next year and one is with George Mason University and it's um with technology so we are part of two lab schools at this time um Governor yunan proposed to develop a new state assessment system which will uh replace our current assessment system all right so the next slide is um are the things that we have been considering here um as far as our Focus so before you go on so I saw that about a month ago that yunan was talking about a $139 million enhancement for for building projects MH MH and if that comes to fruition I assume that's sometime in the near future but um is that up to the legislature to to bind into that this session or when does that get uh scored away with

034with the legislature yeah so Dr he Garner and I both looked into that and I think it's already been allocated if I'm remembering correctly um they are going to send out information the first like February and um School divisions will have to apply what we're unsure of is whether um our projects have to be ready for actual construction or can we just be on the Continuum of planning for them um and I don't think we've got a real clear answer about that um so we're waiting on that information based on the information that I know is um the last time that this was done School divisions could get 10 20 or 30% but it's based on Miss Campbell fiscal distress fiscal distress so a County's fiscal distress so um we are not distressed no however

035there were some school divisions that did receive $7 million for a building project that weren't fiscally distressed either um but you know it's it it'll depend on what the criteria is so we're we're continuing to look for it because we want to be um on board to hop on to that whenever it's ready and available that's kind of strange that during our planning process it might just be that we catch the Cog in the wheel but we can't plan for it right because it could be either or so we're you know we're we're keeping our eyes open for that the release of that information so um you'll notice I have um separated into three kind of um buckets if you will compensation and benefits new positions and increase um existing cost so under compensation and

036benefits you will notice I included either a step plus a 2% scale increase or a a 3.16 um% sale incre scale increase and those are the same dollar figure so um they would cost uh our budget would take the same um number for both of those health insurance we're anticipating a 12% increase um but I would also like to continue to increase our employer contribution for employee plus children employee plus family that's that number that was at $83 I would like to get them closer to where Frederick and Rockingham are um we had an um a teacher who was interested in coming to shanida County and um she was all on board until she found what out what our family plan was um it was a special ed teacher and um she just said she

037couldn't um she couldn't take that hit and yeah which is understandable because that's real money in in in our employees Pockets um I'm going to let um kln Campbell explain the hourly um align hourly pay for bus drivers um a little bit so sure um our current salary scales while initially are based on an hourly rate once you increase the hours expectation for a bus driver it no longer aligns with the hourly rate it becomes a percentage uplift for the total salary what we're hoping to do here is align with hourly rates the whole way across to make make it very clear and transparent how bus drivers are being compensated and when you were doing research on that that has been the practice since 2015 I believe so it's not something new it's been in

038place and we're trying to correct something that um to align the hourly hourly right for our bus drivers and then the next bulleted item is a line athletic director pay um with responsibilities currently our athletic director pay is on scale four um or grade four where our assistant principes are on grade two and um for high school and our athletic director responsibilities align with our um assistant principal responsibilities at our high schools um they are required to do discipline they're required to make really tough decisions they're required to make students so we would like to um align the athletic director pay with with their responsibilities and then um the last bullet is targeted retention sign on stien so when we looked at um when we looked at our positions that were remained vacant um our

039special ed teachers and our school counselors were twoo that we have difficult time filling so what the consideration could be um is that we give our special ed teachers a retention bonus and then anybody who signs up to be a special ed teacher then they get a sign on bonus so you know that's I'm just throwing that out there it's worth discussion um some of the other divisions that are around us are doing something very similar the other um school counselors is another place where we have a difficult time filling um our vacant positions and it's such a critical need in our school system so in our schools um that would be another place that we would consider doing a um a signon or retention bonus so just you know kind of throwing that out

040there for consideration the other um consideration is when we looked at our the teachers that were losing um we noticed that it was plus 10 years of experience or plus 20 years of experience so is there an opportunity just like we have um stiens for teachers to get a master's degree or teachers to get a master's plus 30 um is there an opportunity for us to put in a stipend for teachers who have been with us for 20 years or teachers a number you know um and so that could be an opportunity for us as well to say hey we we appreciate you staying in shanida county for 20 years so this is what we're considering so that's another thought that um we're we're considering so which would save us money in the long run

041because we're not having to train new teachers and these are people who already know our system so yeah so any questions about that before we move on so you know at the end of the day we're going to have to figure out um what we're going to prioritize because you know we only have so much money so anything any questions about compensation and benefits before we move on to new positions so are you going to be able to give us um like if we want to do the second option and prioritize are we going to be able to identify what those positions would be like this type of teacher and so we'll have that before we have the discussion and all that okay so you will you will receive my recommendation on I think it's

042February the 13th and then we'll have a work session on at the end of February it's maybe the 23rd I'm not sure exactly what day it is where you guys give me your feedback and then March the 13th then um we should be at a point where we're ready to approve a a budget so the February one would have those two options that you just talked about okay y um new positions um you noticed we had increase in our um students um our English learner students um and we have to increase this is to align with the updated state standards of quality five English learner teachers and Miss Proctor do you want to talk about where those positions would go uh mostly to the southern campus Ash would get one and a half that half

043position would be split with North for North would get the other half Stonewall would get a full-time position Peter millberg would get a full-time position and then the other position is already at the northern campus but I'm paying for it out of our title one and we can't pay for it out of title one anymore that would be considered a planting so that position would need to come into the local budget so that one's at Sandy Hook so that's not a choice we we have to do that one so you will see that one again um of course required but the state doesn't offer to pay for it it's funny how that works is that state or federal state what was it state or federal state state state and then um we currently Claude Claude

044Moore paid for our otpt um teacher this this school year so that needs to come into our local budget um if we're going to continue that program and we've had good great success with that so yes we do want to continue that program that Claud Moore Foundation is is not going to pay for it next year and then we um we currently had added a um assistant principal and we paid for that with our um all-in Virginia funds so if we're going to keep that assistant principal then um it's we need to fund it in our local budget one of the considerations is if we want to add the aviation program at um triplet Tech then we need a um a halftime uh teacher there at triplet and I am working um with someone that

045maybe they will fund it just like the Claude Moore did for the otpt position we may have this funded for one uh one year but then we'll have to pick that up in a following year so so we'll see we'll see how those conversations go the next um item down there is um add for bus drivers which will reduce our double runs and when you talk to our principls that is one of the most difficult um things that they have to do is um with uh double runs because there are kids that are staying there for 30 40 minutes after you know um all of the kids leave there's there's still kids there and our teachers are on a 7 and 1 half hour day is that right so um we have to find coverage

046to make sure that we are um taking care of of those students and then um the three student support Specialists that were um decrease from the budget for this school year I've included them there and then um a transportation assistant which would um help out um Mr long and his his absences so uh it would be an um a supervisor or a specialist position any questions about those just one uh comment was in Richmond yesterday with the legislative uh round table and it's U just talking to some people who have started just begun to to create technical education Aviation programs MH through the roof MH and the students I mean if they'll if they have 10 slots they got 90 people and if this let's happening up at Frederick and places like that so this

047is something we could get started sooner rather than later we could excuse my term cash in to uh I mean this is a highly uh coveted educational track so but um my but my take on this is this is the new positions here seem to be very well thought out and then moving on to the last um column there increase uh of existing cost and you'll notice School budgets here um Peter mberg you notice they increased 80 80 students over the last um two years but we haven't increased their the money that they have in their in their local school budget so we need to do that and then triplet Tech they've increased a number of students as well but their price of their product is going up too so culinary has went up you

048know a dozen eggs has went up or a gallon of milk has went up so um we increased them a little bit last year but um we still need to increase them a little more so they're able to do the things that they've done um over the last continue to offer their program and then um the transportation this year um I'm looking at Mr long this year we are replacing all of the cameras on all of our buses to be updated and we have to maintain that software so that's a um we're going to have to continue to purchase that software over the next many years so that is correct and our technicians are doing hardware install the same as well MH yeah so and that will eliminate the hard drive on the buses yes

049MH and our principles will actually be able to access that um camera footage from their office instead of having to go to the bus get the hard drive out and um Andor our technicians being taken from their duties to support that system as well be happy to answer any of those questions I think again here's the timeline so there's the dates February the 13th um I will propose a budget to you February the 24th we will talk about it we will um say yeah I like this one no I don't like this um I didn't see this but I hope before the 24th you'll come to me and say hey I didn't see this and I would like to see a number because then we can we can calculate it um before we get to

050the meeting um so that uh we have those numbers so that on March the 13th we can actually have a budget approval thoughts questions concerns all right thank you all right we'll um transition to the capital Improvement plan um and just kind of take a few minutes to update you on that as you recall there a month or two months ago I gave you the the first rendition kind of talked about it um just in a 50,000 ft view um I've placed at your seats the entire C Capital Improvement plan document online it is electronic but I've given it to you in three staple sections just to make uh referencing it and you and looking at it easier for you the first section is simply the The Narrative it gives a lot of information on

051how the CIP is developed um and um some summary inform about transportation and summary information about the um total amount of of the CIP one thing I would want to point out that is a bit that is new to this section is on page 11 of that first document that has Capital Improvement plan written on the front of it if you look on page 11 what's a new section there references uh launching a long-term facilities plan we we had not had that before because we did not have a long-term facilities plan um and as you know that's uh coming to a closure here before long uh where we will have that plan and so I just wanted to reference that in that little section there on page 11 um that you can read of course

052at your leisure but it it talks about um how that plan could then inform the CIP so look at that and if you have any questions um then we certainly talk about it at at some point but we can talk about it now too if you wanted to but um the the vehicle listing is also part of that first stapled section but I I know we want to get to the meat and potatoes so let's look at the second stapled section and has a yellow heading [Applause] yeah it's a completely separate stapled document and it has a yellow header these These are the modernization options that um that I shared with you a few weeks ago there's only one um well there's a there's a couple changes that were made to them first of all

053that bottom box that shows elementary schools new elementary school middle school high school that information is new um that was not there as part of the original presentation so we wanted to add that so that you had some figures right in front of you that were based on 2024 cost um so that you could kind of do some figuring on your own when you see square footage okay this is about what the square footage is this is what it's costing you can you can kind of do some figuring on your own one major or one one big addition is the third page prior to this we only had two options and of course this is all draft and this is just some thinking it doesn't it's not the way it's set in stone of course

054this is just to try and drive conversation it's trying to drive ideas it's trying to show different ways of looking at things and that's certainly what you do as as a board but the first option option A that's based on the the the the hierarchy and of the phases and which schools or facilities are in what year is based on the facilities condition index if you recall that um worst for facilities first kind of mindset the second option took that same approach but overated with the oldest facilities that haven't been renovated so you can see that kind of drove the elementary schools a little further up that phase approach well the third uh option the new Option um takes that one step further and and basically just says let's let's triage these in a in

055a in a way that might embrace our our most neediest facilities forget about facilities index forget forget about a we know and as as you can see there in the very first and I just started with 2025 as if if we really want to take this serious and try to do something well we we've talked about new Elementary School we've talked about triple Tech you know now again these are just the ideas this this isn't this isn't um you know set in stone this isn't these are just ideas to drive conversation to drive thinking you may want to come back to us and say you know what I like this but can we can we move this could we add this could we change this could we look at different different years for different things

056and and this is your document we're just trying to give you some information to start the flow of of thought around having a long-term facilities plan something that we have wanted to have for many many many many years um and so this is a an effort in that direction the third staple I'm sorry I have a quick question sure Pard my ignorance here but um so if we were to do for example a new um elementary school so that's something we just include in the budget doesn't have to be going to a separate no and that's something I should have said from this is totally separate from what Dr Shepard just went over all right that's that's operational and that's that's one pile of money the CIP is purely uh its own Standalone pot of

057money and that's purely from our Board of Supervisors but we include a new build in there so it's not just whatever we're fixing is any new oh absolutely and that's and that's exactly right and so where it says um you know new Elementary that's what it's referring to yeah that would be a new build and as a matter of fact I had new build in there and it took up so much space in that I took the word build out of there but that's exactly right and I would like to say that that um this probably needs to follow our budget process um because when we submit our budget to the Board of Supervisors we also submit our um Capital Improvement to our Board of Supervisors so and they have um some of the members

058of the Board of Supervisors have been asking for a long-term facilities plan so you know I think we need to take a a deep dive into this and say I really like option A or I really like option C um and and look at you know the years that we have attributed to them and say well I don't know the number of years maybe it's two or three okay maybe it's not two or three maybe it's four or five but you know I I think we um should move forward and adopt something so that our Board of Supervisors kind of know where we're at and and that's a very good point I I I just I looked at a 25e period basically but obviously could be 50 or you know it could be 35 years

059be whatever you know we feel like is would be doable but um that's all for discussion and points for you all to to decide on all right the last thing and and really the meat and potatoes of of our daily daily work CIP is that last section that's stapled together that has a red header at the very top and um so again this um one thing I wanted to make sure I forgot to mention also is the document that you received or had got electronically the first time the the figures have changed a little bit all right I found a mistake and and then that I didn't realize was in there the first time and then we've edited some some of this to move things into different years so if you have any printed out

060documents laying at home you know make sure you don't reference those um this is the the newest um most upto-date version um so you can you can see through through there the things that we have listed um the estimated cost and then the year that it is um planned for and again I'll tell you the same thing that I said a few weeks ago you know this is for you to look at and for you to say you know can we move this from year 2526 can we move it to a year later on out or or can we move something that you see that might be in 2728 can we move that sooner you know those are all the kinds of things that we would take your feedback on and and um you know

061and and edit this you know at the end of the day you you can see how much money we're talking about in the in in the tally the priority levels urgent necessary and then the lowest is desirable correct that's right I know in past years we've typically you know based off the money we get it seems like urgent is usually we definitely get to that or at least almost always and then some necessary and then kind kind it goes through a that that's right that that's exactly right you know most many times the desirable unfortunately you know doesn't get doesn't get funded and and and what's unfortunate about it is that the desirable then becomes un necessary um because it continues to erode or whatever you know and then it becomes an urgent you know

062and but the reality of it is we we we can only do with with what the amount of money that we have to do it and um that's what folks do to the best of their ability da let me drop back to the U to the three options for the long-term facilities modernization remarkable document um because you're looking way out uh And yet when we come down to we're going to have to salami slice it down year by year right uh and so it would require a buyin for longterm approach that clearly we're going to have to be in League with the Board of Supervisors um but is it also I mean it's also kind of scary to think that when you're committed to that and you don't know what enrollment is going to be

063like or what the economy is going to look like or whatever when you when You' committed that far out but it's it's it's remk remarkably Adept at being able to do the two things we want to do is look out there and still apply it to a year-by-year annual budget so well it it would you know would absolutely require yearly maintenance no question about it the way things change the the the the circumstances that our facilities find themselves in Daily it would definitely will take um year by year you know maintenance tweaking and and a plan Bas you know what we we're going to have to adjust this you know absolutely I've been part of a long-term facilities plan and um it was a 15-year facilities plan it ended up being 20 couple years but

064what happened is there was a recession along the way and and you know a building didn't get completed maybe in three years it took four you know something like that but everything stayed on it it just moved down just LLY so yeah so flexibility along the way absolutely and so I really don't have a whole lot more to say about the the the last section there the the actual CIP projects that you see um we've tried to you know again I just mention real quick you know we've gone around with every head custodian and every principal talked to them in their buildings um got their feedback um so you know feel good about we've sure there's probably something out there that that needs to be on here that's not and and if it is we'll

065absolutely get it on there but um I have another question can we get um because for example if we're still thinking about triplet we may build be building new or be renovating then if we did that there's a lot of things around here for triplet that we wouldn't have to fix now that's right that's right so is there a way that we could like separate that so that we can have a total amount and just kind of you know asterisk if we do decide to do the any triplet or renovate then we don't need to make those expenses right now mhm I I will caveat that if I may that some things will depend on timeline if we say go on triplet but in 5 years we still may need to do some of these

066right but at least we would know because if we're building new or renovating right away then at least we can kind of play with that but no I I understand what you're saying yeah but at least it would give us kind of it would help us decide also which way would make more sense and quite honestly that's the predicament we've kind of found ourselves in for the past number of years I'm going to say close to 10 years do we want to spend several $1,000 on this school or that school when we might renovate it right and and the and the word might is like an all capital letters It's continues to be a might you know and at some point in time we have we have to do it even if we want to

067turn around and and renovate them but even that may help us decide which way to go mhm sure so I had calculated the Urgent out of just the um the 2526 and it's 3392 million and what was it that we got last year 3323 yeah so it's within 60,000 3.39 it's 3.3 92 and then we got 323 am I missing something in here I see where we're replacing in the carpet with uh lvt tile at Ashby Lee but I don't see anything about Sandy Hook am I missing that or was that missed in the CIP I have to look a lot of it's already been replaced um but they may have some that hasn't been but I'll look at that um some of the spaces you know it's kind of been a request to keep

068carpet um like music spaces places like that but I'll look at that because that's yeah an overall goal is to quite honestly get rid of as much carpet as we can um so I I'll look into that yeah if there's if there is honestly if there's carpet and we got rid of a bunch of it last summer um as we're really trying to move away from carpet in any of the schools like I said except for the band room band and Acoustics they really has to that but other than that we're trying to get rid of any other questions thoughts do thanks that's quite a an now we should well it's team effort there's a lot of people involved put this together thank you Dr shepher we're going to talk about committtee assignments is that

069right so in order to U maximize board member impact the board has established committees and the board um is also represented on various committees entities and organizations um policy BCE School War committee um says that the school board will assign school board members to various standing committees the recommendation is to discuss the committee assignments at the January 8th meeting and then tonight um to to finalize those committee assignments so uh we made some considerable progress the last time we talked uh and I have done I've done a spreadsheet that is slightly simpler than Dr h gardeners so I'm going to ask uh my stalard cohort if you'd pass these out um far as they'll go and but certainly the school board members uh and then just pass one back to me thank you did you

070get one of these Dr shepher will thank you okay so um community assignments are kind of u a mixed bag because there are uh few there are I think there are nine that are standing committees uh there's a functional committee and there are U committees that have to do with um representatives to other other boards and um and they're all important they all do um important stuff and so we have in in essence 17 uh committees that we need to in quotes uh I actually know that there are divisions in the state that don't have committees at all they just they just don't do it uh and everybody looks at things on their own and and and kind kind of chips in from there uh I think uh I think we saw this last year

071that having some continuity in these uh these areas uh has paid off uh and um and I I'll say that uh I think this last year 2024 probably saw greater uh participation of Schoolboard members in their own committee assignments than than in the recent I'll just say in the recent past and I'm pretty confident in saying that so we've got some very active and proactive school board members to to to look at these um I uh I have this this uh little short circuit um spreadsheet here only to indicate the the number of committees that that people are on and so we only have one or two per committee generally the person who is the principal and person who is an alternate uh but there are several committees where it's not just enough to have

072the alternate the second person on the committee has to be kind of an integral part of that committee now the two I could think of offand is one is Personnel that that encompasses so many actions and activities the other is policy review uh which requires uh a lot of um a lot of going over policies in conjunction with the with the central staff such that we can actually uh make make progress on them uh and U the other one I I added kind of subjectively on my own uh Mr Vance's U the ones have to do with um special ad because you happen to be on two of those and that is obviously not obviously but it's an emerging and high-profile area where um continuity of thought and and action I think is is uh

073is important so um so it looked like you know when you when you look at the number of uh those in the lead um now unless it's changed Tom have you down for four four lead lead positions and uh I think your activities over the last year indicated that you've taken it seriously you you you've you've done quite a lot and I'm so I'm not sure so I'm guessing at the at the moment you're still you're still the chair if you will for for for the the four that are still indicated on our 2024 list if that's different I need to know that um but um Gloria's pointed out that um she had um quite a number of these now we each kind of ponied up and volunteered for some things we'd like to do

074we thought we'd be good at and uh not everybody could get first choice but it it kind of fell out pretty well uh and she made it um clear last time we met that um with the assignments she would like to um devest herself of the U agent to approve bills um alternate and uh Mr Vance is uh volunteer to to um to take that over as the alternate and so that kind of rounds us out a little bit better than than we were in uh 2024 and only leaves us probably one one area where we probably have to make a change and that is that um another one that uh Gloria would like to um devest herself of is the um finance and budget one so I had a question to U Mr gut

075Shaw as uh the chair of that committee is um how how would we function how would you function uh with uh with no alternate uh there do you need one how how much do you need one and I'm also going to look at the superintendent and ask you Dr Shepard um if you have any you've been through this a long time if any of these look like we really shouldn't let them go wanting maybe you could give us a u uh you know your experience or or your recommendation but let me ask uh Mr Guta first how he feels about being the the the chair of that with no with no alternate I think it would still work operationally I mean it helps to have another set of eyes in the room but um I

076don't think it would cause any catastrophic issues and an alternate generally is somebody who is there if you can't be there anyway in other words uh let me let me pick an example I've had happen on the past um the um the representative to um County Parks and Recreation uh we don't have a lot to do necessarily with what they do but it's nice to go to their meetings and see what cross over and what uh and just see what they're up to because they use a lot of our facilities etc etc but whoever goes to it doesn't have to necessarily be an expert but can be somebody who goes there and so if um so I'm so that would be um so Tom if you can't make it to that but you knew that

077um Gloria or Mike could and you say can you cover that meeting and so forth it would they would really generally not have to be anything they have to be brought up to speed on but just something they could attend and let us know if there was anything to remain to Schoolboard um and so that's kind of the way I see that and that's the way it would probably work out for you is that you could ask anybody else on the board to step in for you uh if it was a I'm not sure that works for finance but so that's my question to you it's not anything complicated okay and so Dr Shepard do you have any um feelings feelings about that I'm just going to concur with u Mr gut Shaw that it's

078nice to have two sets uh two people there to you know have a conversation then yeah when I say it's not complicated I'm not saying Finance is not I'm saying our role as a member of that committee it's primarily we're looking over CIP and giving our feedback and those things so so if you would be comfortable with that and the school board would be um given notice that they might get a call from you one of us to to take that on um because you can't make everything all the time so so that would be understandable um then if that would be the case and everybody is happy with the assignments that they've had other than that we could just declare the a a done deal the way it is do but that would take

079a consensus that is nobody could be in nonc concurrence with that is anybody have any problem with that I would like to ask Tom about the uh parks and recck every meeting I go to they ask if you're going to still be the primary on that that's that's what I say if it's okay with you because any him and I could swap to make it even well um so far I've the one that's that's great with me if if that's what you you guys would like to do between the two of you we can uh say have their meetings early that switch and now you're back with the rest of the Mortals like us and you only have leadership of three instead of four so anyway but I appreciate that that's uh that's helpful uh

080and we'll um so Cheryl if we can capture that the fact that um uh Miss Mr Street will no longer be the chair for if you want to call it a I guess we will for the um shendo County Parks and Recreation Advisory Board and that slot will now move to um Mr Rickard and then the other is that there will be no formal alternate for the finance committee um I think we're good to go unless again is there any other discussion so we don't have a list of the actual proposes so it's basically the last year and then just those changes um I've got one copy here but I'm sure we have other I know but this is the old one yeah I was wondering if we had a new one with the changes

081already no no I just want the idea was to find out tonight what those Chang would be um so we'll put it together um in the morning and post it on board doogs um tomorrow afternoon okay so I just want to formerly IND we haven't passed it as such but there is a consensus among the six board members what we just articulated is the way we'd like to go and and when Cheryl captures that and puts it on we'll consider it not official but if anybody has any Demmer or discussion we we can we can discuss it Mike is now be that's correct and Street will be alterat that was the one where we had two alternates and if you if we want to keep it that way that that that's fine yes and then

082the other um change is Agent to approve bills that's Larry Vance is the alternate agent and finance and budget CIP KY gut Shaw is the only um representative there and we had to that that particular move of having um M Mr Vance uh take um agent the agent to approve bills as the alternate agent we've already discussed that previously but we want to lock that in now list you had from last year yes yeah um so I think that does it school board Norms Dr Shephard so this is the opportunity for us to talk about the school board Norms um I have um there's our adopted policy on board docs or our adopted Norms on board docs and then a proposal I received a um recommendation for a change from Miss carlino last evening that

083she can talk about um but the um the intent is to um request this for approval at the at the February 13th meeting so now is the opportunity to talk through that okay um and I think each of us have received at this point Gloria's input for that correct I think so I have a onew change I'd like to suggest should I do that now this is the night I'm going to keep it simple um the superintendent or is her desn't is that your word change well I have another word change then oh do you okay good just one word though well good um okay uh why don't you go with your first go ahead so just to be proper the bottom paragraph request for information from principles and staff it says the superintendent or

084his design so get that corrected so we can be proper there okay and uh my suggested change will be uh under U how we govern uh second bullet under that the second heading under that is Schoolboard meetings and the second bullet there is the chair will continuously poll members regarding agenda or report items this isn't going to be as never mind so continuously I would like to strike that word and con and instead instead insert the word continually instead of continuously and I'll I'll give you some rationale very quickly and then I'll be done continuously means without a pause or Interruption of any kind so somebody um Works continuously for 6 hours or don't take a break or somebody's talking for a minute on without appearing to take a breath it's continuously continually is something

085that happens repeatedly so it happens often but it doesn't happen like continuously consistently all the time I know it sounds like a like a a small matter but there is a difference in um meaning that uh apparently can be uh meaningful so I would move to not move but I'm I'm the suggestion that we consider replacing the word continuously with the word continually it's my only suggested change any other discuss question on the school board Norms so we have one action item this evening uh and it is the uh dealing with the library policy 2bp and we have um before us tonight um the culmination of that recent process in which um December 5th the subcommittee the parent Community advisory committee met into discuss the five books that were requested for reconsideration the five books

086are listed there uh the five books that were listed submitted for uh consider reconsideration uh came out of that committee and with a recommendation that three be removed from the final approved Library materials purchase list and those three titles are listed there um just quick question chairman um was Gloria going to give us a presentation on her changes to the board Norms yeah I was wondering if I think Dr Shephard had had hinted to it but oh I'm sorry I I I asked if everybody had gotten it oh okay uh but but we can certainly go over it now no if there's no questions about that we can just so we're going to be discussing that later or at the next well we're going to yeah we're going to be discussing the board norms for

087approval um are we doing it is it scheduled for for February meeting February 13th so we are all under advising at this point to check out the suggestions that Glory's put forward the word that I've done and the uh the politically correct word that miss that that c put in there so um so if we're all good with that we'll just take a look at our at okay so we'll get um a list of proposals for the next meeting and then we'll be able to discuss them yes okay sorry about that no no no I a good point of clarification um so um I'm going to unless there's um anybody wants to have discussione U I'm asking for a motion to approve the 2025 spring oh wait a minute uh yeah I'm asking for a

088motion uh to that effect that we accept those those the three books that were to be removed you're asking for a motion I'm asking for a motion yes on the school library book yes I move to approve the 2025 spring final approved Library material purchase list as thank you Mr Rickard is there a second second second by Mrs garino discussion hearing none call we'll call for the question it's not um and I that we're in a work session I'm not sure we have to do a roll call should we Cheryl we can do a roll call I know we can do okay let's do a roll call okay yes Miss Caro yes Mr gsha yes Mr Vance yes Mr R yes and Mr bar yes so we'll indicate that that was a unanimous decision not

089a consensus but unanimous decision by the board and I think the only thing we have at this point our school board member comments is that correct anything else first anybody want to go first Mike want to go forward I guess um first I want to thank Miss Stratton I went to the uh special education advisory committee meeting last night and I feel like this might be the time to bring it up but we're talking about the budget and man you want to talk about a wealth of information the stuff I learned last night attending that meeting um I really think we need to start a conversation of maybe because we have a hard time filling those special education teacher positions maybe if we could um start a different pay scale for special education teachers the

090the workload that they have compared to a regular teacher is unreal and Dr Shepard even commented last night at the meeting that uh we do have teachers with special education credentials that are not teaching as special education teachers and maybe if we had that other pay scale it would attract some of those teachers to come back over to the special education side um it may even attract some some really good teachers from the outside if we had that differing pay scale when you talk about the the workload that's on those teachers compared to the regular teachers it's unreal um and I never realized it until last night um and then I mean we think about special education you think about a child has one specific special need but I learned last night there's some students

091that we have that have three different special needs um and we have to accommodate all those special needs um so I I'd just like to start a conversation on that and for us to give some thought on that um I think it'd be a good idea of a way to retain those teachers and maybe even attract some highly qualified ones um something we can look at something we can talk about maybe a solution to uh our sped issues um other than that I really don't have anything I don't think okay I'm going to go right around the horn if you don't mind good okay I'm just looking forward to the to the rest of the year obviously I made a decision today to announce that I'm going to be running for Board of Supervisors this

092year for um 2026 so um look forward to serving with you all the rest of the year and then hope to continue working alongside the school board and a different capacity moving forward Mr Street um nothing really I just want to throw out I know the weather's been a challenge here and I just want to thank everybody that that effects and uh decision making and trying to deal with the cold weather and I know it's tough but want to thank those um for dealing with it and getting through it so that's all I don't have much to say I just wanted to thank uh Miss wiin kin for always coming here and keeping us a breast of all this stuff that I would otherwise not know and every meeting I want to say thanks but

093by the time we get to talk you're gone so I'm glad that you're here that I can actually tell you thank you for all that um first thing I wanted to address the fact that um I I want to thank Dr shepher sending out the U information today about the fact that we we didn't have the um any positive action on our request to dismiss the NAACP uh suit um and um but I do have some concerns in in what I read and I from what I've read Glory has some of the same concerns uh and so I'm going to be calling our attorney tomorrow with some questions about what happened certain things that did that were articulated Where Do We Go From Here some other things so um since I'm the point of contact

094for him if you have any questions you want me to send forward to him or ask him uh tonight or tomorrow morning I need it quick because his his window is tomorrow and I want to get him kind of quick so any questions you have about and even if you don't you know want to specifically ask something about it if um if there if there's just something you want to know about time frame or anything else that you'd like to ask about it this is my time to to ask uh M Mr gwy where where we go from here so that's the first thing um second thing is that and I hate to say this after we've just talked about committees but um the sbma had a round table yesterday with our with some of

095our legislators and with some um some lawyers uh to talk about um various various things uh about the the drug problem in school and Title 9 and some other things that are really going to change quickly with this new Administration which is going to be kind of interesting and probably some fun if you like that fun but um but there there was a a lot of you know Josh hler he came up with a really good uh suggestion for school board members uh which is um he he stressed the fact that it was um a lot easier for Schoolboard members to try to uh get a bill sponsored it would be for a regular um citizen in that um the legislators already kind of pay attention to Schoolboard members who are public officials number one

096uh and he offered up the Family Foundation as an organization that could help write uh the bills and um provide their good offices for places to go in and and and uh kind of use a headquar ERS when when uh we visit our legislators and I know a lot of times we've run into something that could be done if there was just a law that would allow us to do it and he had some U he had some interesting uh points on how how we could do that most effectively so uh he he he recommended that we develop a um a legislative committee that would take a look at the at the things now I know that we uh have a process where by we look at legislation that's coming along but this would be

097more dedicated to would be be monitoring some of those legislative changes but also give us the ability to perhaps suggest uh legislation that could be uh sponsored by Senator or delegate uh and uh he had various tips for how to do that we have obviously couldn't do that for this year because they've got a very truncated session it's going to end in just a couple weeks but these um bills uh pretty much would have to be done written in some basic form in late summer so we may want to think about anything we would like to um kind of clear the way uh for things that we would like we think would be important to do and uh so we might want to think about U forming a if you will legislative committee that might

098work with Family Foundation or anybody else who would you know our own our own um our own U legislators uh about about uh if not if not coming up with their own sponsored Bill a bill to be sponsored at least a way to monitor more effectively what what was going on in Richmond so anyway um so uh I guess that's it uh can I have a motion for dismissal adjournment move to AJ thank you Mr gutel thank you for that motion second second second Mr Rickard all in favor please signify by saying I I opposed un opposed we are at 8:21 you think I was going to say d oh he's doing class

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.