001everyone here in the chamber and those watching on ITV and Via live stream and call the January 28th 2025 regular meeting of the Board of Education to order with all board members present uh interim superintendent bagula is joining us remol this evening I see her there online thank you for joining us uh we are going to open with our flag ceremony the scrips Ranch High School Air Force JC Color Guard will present the colors please stand for the presentation of the colors colors can't read colors please join us in the Pledge of Allegiance colors trusty Cruz would you like to lead us I Al to the flag of the United States of America to the rep for it stands one nation under God indivisible withy and justice for all colors colors color turn March thank
002you please be seated a land acknowledgement is a traditional custom that dates back centuries in many native nations and communities our land acknowledgement was developed in partnership with local Kumi leaders students from the San Diego School of Creative and Performing Arts prepared the following video to show our respect for the Kumi people who are the original stewards of the land our school district now occupies we respectfully acknowledge that the Kumi people are the original inhabitants and car Akers of these lands now known as San Diego despite the attempted genocide and ongoing impacts of colonization the Kumi Spirit remains unbroken and their Traditions continue to thrive as they carry the memories of their ancestors who bravely resisted cultural eraser and fought to protect their land and way of life in honoring their legacy we pledge to
003uphold their cultural heritage and right to safeguard their sacred connection to the land for future generations with gratitude and strength we stand with the Kumi embracing the past while forging a brighter tomorrow all right thank you we will now move to Item B adoption of the agenda we have a full docket tonight in particular we have our monitoring report on goal four College and Career PR preparedness with some Associated proposed uh updates to graduation requirements as well as a presentation on our Title 9 work and our much expanded office of Investigations compliance and accountability do I have a motion uh to adopt today's agenda a motion from truste Cruz and a second from trustee baso student trustees okay remaining board members please vote all right we have unanimous approval for the item um Miss stz
004can you please provide information for public speakers uh this evening uh on meeting protocols yes today's meeting of the board of education is a business meeting that is conducted in public and board members will not engage in a dialogue with members of the audience board bylaw 1025 sets the time limit for public comment on agenda items at 10 minutes per side pro and con or 20 minutes total speakers will be able to provide testimony at the beginning of the appr rate agenda item or at the end of the meeting for non-agenda comment please listen for your name to be called speakers are listed and called in the order received when your name is called please come to the podium to speak speakers participating via Zoom will be asked to unmute when their name is called
005if you are unable to unmute yourself we will call the next speaker please follow along with the agenda so that you know when your item is coming up for discussion when you begin speaking the green light below m name on the Das indicates that the timer has started when the light turns yellow you will have 1 minute remaining a buzzer will indicate that your time has expired if you have not yet done so and would like to sign up for in-person comment iPads are available in the back of the auditorium and in the lobby thank you Miss dotz uh that brings us to C1 uh we will now hear a report from the student Advisory Board and a report from our student trustees on their recent attendance at the California Association student councils student Advisory
006board on legislation and education conference trustees balls and Cruz yes thank you president Peterson now as a brief reminder in trusty Cruz and I's responsibilities to represent all 96,000 students in our district we created an Advisory Board of students to help advise us on policies and how we should vote on the Das now today I'd like to introduce Samuel parona to speak to us all about our latest student Advisory board meeting hello everyone my name is samela I'm a chav Vista a ninth grader at San Diego High and I'm a member of the student Advisory Board I'm here today with to speak with you about a issue we spoke about this week in the sun Advisory board that being artificial intelligence we the sun Advisory Board believe that while artificial intelligence is a potentially dangerous
007advancement if used properly it can can be greatly beneficial to students AI will be used no matter what so it is best that we teach students how to properly use it we believe that having some lessons that involve AI as a way to teach students how to safely and responsibly utilize it such as checking for misinformation or adding their own input would be a great way to incorporate it into our curriculum but we also acknowledge the fact that AI must be controlled so this won't get out of hand for this we propose having more oral assignments and tests as to prevent the use of AI to cheat something UC Berkeley has already been implementing this balance would allow students to learn how to use AI while still pushing them to write and put together their
008own ideas in a more interactive and engaging format thank you [Applause] all so Quinn and I had the incredible opportunity to attend the student Advisory Board in legislation and education where for 3 days we were at Sacramento we along with 80 other students all dedicated in improving the educational system wrote and presented resolutions to the California Assembly committee on education these resolutions centered around critical topics such as homeless youth College and Career Readiness and supporting immigrant students our biggest takeaway from attending this conference was we definitely need to place a bigger advocacy a bigger priority on hearing student voices the resolutions the things that we came up with in just 3 days the assembly committee was very very supportive and we are very grateful and tending thank you thank you so much U trusty balls
009and trusty Cruz appreciate the report um and thank you to our student advisory council member um we will now consider item C2 and C3 resolutions recognized in January 29th 2025 as Lunar New Year and the month of February as Black History Month is there a motion to approve items C2 and C3 a motion from uh trusty Hazen do I have a second and a second from trusty whitear pain um Miss doz are there any speakers on this item no speakers would any of the board like to oine we're good yeah okay I think we're good okay um seeing no further comment we will move to a vote student trustees please vote uh remaining board members please vote that's we have unanimous approval of the item all right now we're on to uh D1 report on
010Clos session uh General councel green under item D1 are there any reportable actions from closed session no thank you um let's see now we have items D2 and D3 uh as there are no uh management appointments to announce tonight under item D2 We will now move to item D3 Dr bagula please provide your informational report again she's she's tested she's presenting her presentation remotely she's at a conference thank you president peton I first want to begin by acknowledging and thanking our educator colleagues who showed up today at the beginning of our meeting whether we're talking about special education or the budget Gap we're committed to working with our education Partners to solve these challenges together and with our community in fact I want to remind and invite all of us to our budget Workshop which
011is scheduled for Tuesday February 4th at 5:00 P pm at the Ballard Center we will discuss the governor's proposed budget its impact on our district our advocacy efforts and provide an update on our ongoing efforts to close a budget Gap such as the progress made on the supplemental early retirement incentive colleagues deciding to take this incentive was 27% higher than originally anticipated and I'm glad that we get to honor the work of our colleagues with a retirement pathway that recognizes their commitment and service to our students and trustees while Financial stewardship is a critical component of our responsibilities as a governing board especially in light of the current budget Gap It Is by no means our sole Focus ever today our meeting is focused on meaningful graduation and student safety on meaningful graduation our focus
012is on how we're preparing students for Life After High School you will hear me repeat myself I always like to say 100% of our students 100% of the time um but on students and sa staff safety we will hear an update on the ongoing efforts to strengthen our Title 9 reporting process and respond to reports of sexual harassment civil rights violations and safety so that again 100% of our students feel safe 100% of the time and I know it has only been two weeks since we last met but we have certainly stayed busy with several events we we celebrated Dr Martin Luther King JRR by marching with our students at the 48th annual Knox Middle School parade we were joined by Lincoln High School Chavez Elementary Porter Baker Balboa and Lewis Middle School I also
013want to note that our very own Christy Drake was presented with the Edna Smith award for community service thank you trustees whitear Payne Pon and Hazen for joining us and we also participated for the second year in the row of the 33rd annual San Diego Martin Luther King Parade thank you to all bort testes who also brought families along to march with us we went to several breakfast events that I know many of us attended and this past Saturday we hosted our very first college fair at LMC in partnership with the Mexican consulate and the California Student Aid Commission to help students complete FAFSA and Kata applications I would like to continue to find other avenues to host colleges and universities for our students and families finally my heart goes out to all of our
014students and families and colleagues who have been impacted by the fires over the past week the rain is certainly welcome but I know several of our schools were near fires and smoke last week some of the schools included Linda Vista Tiara Santa Cherokee Point Hamilton Tory Pines to name a few I know trusty Pon you received an evacuation order in your community as well for one of the fires impacting La Hoya community and many of our colleagues who live in neighboring communities have been impacted by the border to fire we will continue to monitor conditions as they change and thank you to our school police department for working with our schools our local law enforcement and our city Fire Department thank you so much thank you thank you Dr bagula hold tight you're you're up
015in a few seconds here again um we will now hear item E1 the progress monitoring report on goal 4.1 and consider consideration to revise graduation requirements Dr bagula could you please introduce the item you're you're muted ma'am yes there we go thank you thank you president peton so today we will hear from Dr Richardson and Dr Roberson on College and Career Readiness their presentation will cover two topics first you will receive the second monitoring report on our graduation goal we will then pause for trustey questions and discussion about our data followed by the theory of action that we would like to pursue to meet our goals I know we have metrics tied to this but again 100% of our students 100% of the time I want to start though by saying that 15 years ago
016this board voted and implemented a uca3 UC a3g diploma which increased opportunity for our students it is great work I even used it when I was at the county when I was coaching other high school districts towards this change it is something to be commended for in such a large system this type of second order change demanded a level of rigidity and accountability this has increased achievement and we should be very proud of this with that said I also believe that we're in the second phase of the second order change as all of our coursework is now UC a through G there is an opportunity to provide choices for for our students that we and when we espouse the importance of student voice and participation this is something that our students have asked over and
017over again to have in a meaningful diploma and I'll give you an example at UC High School we have a robust career pathway in the bi biomedical field the sciences that students must take in order to finish this pathway is not currently aligned with our science graduation requirement demands even though all of the courses are UCA through D so at the end we're forced to sign waivers this is an unnecessary hurt this coursework meets a through D and the pathway completion is also something to be proud of but our own administrative regulations our own red tape to be clear gets in the way Dr Roberson has been leading a collective group and designing for a meaningful graduation this term is very important to me because our diploma should be meaningful but I personally use that
018word because when I graduated from high school and went to the university I realized that my GPA at high school did not translate to the level of preparedness that I needed at my University it was not a meaningful diploma the meaningful graduation group comprised of site leaders parents Community leaders and students have had long discussions about how to ensure our diploma is Meaningful and what to do about the 11% of our students that our system pushes out that takes me to the second topic we have many students that our system pushes out and they're going to alternative schools or Charter Schools or adult education and we're not fulfilling our promise of a meaningful diploma we want to do something about this this requires our board to make a couple of decisions now I know what
019I have been saying to this group and to the office of graduation are about the equity parameters that must be in place in order to solve this problem and support these 11% of students I have been concerned since we've even discussed this idea we now have a robust data system that what didn't exist a few years ago that will allow us to immediately know which students are on track or off track and site leaders are in ongoing discussions about how to support students this data system was not in place 15 years ago go but it is now our challenge now is different than in 2016 the world needs our kids to be prepared for for is more diverse there are lots more opportunities like apprenticeships sponsorships mentorships if a student is prepared to go into
020apprenticeship this should also prepare them to succeed so we're going to transition from a meaningful diploma to a future ready diploma but I want to end by saying we are not backing down from a UCA through G diploma again this is something we should be proud of there are many districts that have been asking for this type of change and haven't had the strength to implement it like we have this is about flexibility choice and alignment and serving all 100% of our students with Equity mechanisms and plenty of metrics to be keep a close eye on our future graduates with that I will turn it over to Dr Richardson and Dr Roberson thank you thank you Dr bagula good evening president president peton vice president Barrera Board of Trustees I want to share with you
021that tonight represents the work of many colleagues that are in the room with us today site leaders school counselors Educators who every day show up for our students and work really hard in their four years to ensure that they get a diploma and that they graduate Dr bugula said future ready and the C State of California is calling it prepared preparedness so not just receiving the diploma Dr whiter puring as you like to shake hands and ask them what are they doing but guiding them through that and getting them to prepared as defined by the state of California our objectives here tonight are to share with you a progress report of uh student outcome Focus goal and progress monitoring on our graduation rate looking also at our UC CSU a through G completion rate and
022also as I shared the College and Career preparedness and then we will also give you time to discuss the student outcome Focus goal 4.1 and then we're going to share a little bit of the Journey of our secondary schools and uh give a recommendation to the board to take action on board policy 61 46.1 while these outcomes seem really easy they do not demonstrate the amount of time energy and focus that has gone into designing this goal the work of our school leaders our school counselors and Educators to really make sure that we're making progress towards this goal and having our students be [Music] prepared tonight uh while I shared the board goal four which is increasing graduation student cohorts level of College and Career preparedness as measured by the California College and Career indicator
023our goal is to move from 59.9 of high school graduates placed in the prepared level which was in August 2023 to 71.9 by August 2030 tonight we're going to look at the interim goal which is really looking at on tress and looking to increase the 9th through 12th grade spotlight student cohorts on track and completion of the a through G course requirements with a C or higher as measured by CDE from 24.7 in Spring of 23 to 42.7 by Spring of 2030 so there's a lot of things going on in this slide and I want to ground Us in some research that our team started with in 2022 and we were taking a look at the work from the University of Chicago and Chicago Public Schools where they were looking at ninth grade success because
024many years ago Chicago noticed that ninth grade success those students who were not those students who were receiving multiple fs and were not on track in nth grade actually matched their graduation rate so they started to do some very intensive work in 9th grade to make sure that by the time a student left 9th grade they were on track and with this work they actually saw their graduation rates go up and so the core districts have done some work um with the Gates Foundation and found that there were five levers that really moved the needle in ninth grade success and those are what you see kind of on the outside of these slides freshman success teaming what does that mean that means adults coming together and talking about students frequently about how they're doing in
025their classes and and how they are supporting their students the e8th to nth grade transition bridging all of our schools have been doing bridging since 2022 and making sure that our students have a strong start to their high school years strategic scheduling this is not only making sure students are in the courses to optimize the graduation but also making sure we have the right teachers working with our ninth graders strong student relationships I don't think any of of us would debate that but that's another lever and looking also at grading practices and instruction so our team took a look at this and also started looking at Conley's work on College and Career Readiness and began to see that we actually needed to look at um preparedness and we believe that there are three levers that
026are going to move our students closer to preparedness the first one we'll look at tonight which is a through G success Early College credit this includes apib and our community college courses and CTE our Career Technical education and our pathway completers this work directly aligns with Governor nome's master plan for Career Education of strengthening career Pathways prioritizing Hands-On learning and having career sustaining jobs along with our work with the San Diego Community College District and partnership tonight we will focus on 4.1 and I'd like to invite Dr Roberson who's going to move into the data part of our presentation thank you Dr Richardson before I dive into the data I think it's very important to acknowledge that each of us sitting up here on the dis and in the auditorium bring our own unique perspectives
027beliefs and experiences with regards to education and graduation some differ and some align but as a unified district it is our responsibility to work together to ensure that every student and I mean every student graduates with a path forward whether that is college career or both what you see on this slide is a eight-year comparison of our graduation rates you'll see it districtwide with the number on top you'll see with the red line it's our students with disabilities the yellow line indicates the graduation rates for our English learners what I want to point out here is you'll notice that our graduation rate for the class of 2024 at 88.3 mirrors that pre pandemic and in the in between years of the pandemic until now I would like to acknowledge that our students were able to
028graduate in 2020 under uh the emergency modified diploma requirements in 2122 our students were able to then uh graduate under assembly Bill 1 104 which allowed our students to graduate under the state minimum graduation requirements and you still see that in 2023 we maintained a higher level of graduation rate and that is as a result that there were waivers and exemptions still due to the pandemic in 2024 our office the office of graduation became more stringent with regards to the exemptions and wavers that were allowable um you'll notice that um as a district we have made uh significant growth in the um it I'm sorry we have made significant growth with our students with disabilities that is intentional work that has um been made across our district one of the the key things that I
029would like to highlight with this is that we removed courses that our students with disabilities that uh were taking that then remove them off track for graduation and a a through G requirement um an example that I could provide is gradually re removed applied classes when a student takes an applied class they are immediately off track for graduation therefore um there's a lot of intensive support that needs to happen um you'll notice that there are disparities with our English Learners with regards to the the graduation rate um we have fluctuated throughout the years and most recently we dropped 5% it is important that we address the disparities in the graduation rate with our English learners but it's going to take a multifaceted approach so we have an English uh language learner group that meets frequently
030where we're looking at student transcripts we're looking at strategic scheduling of our students we're looking at is are we assessment protocols if you will and so we're we're data diving into that what we've also found is that we have students that have um multiple classifications their English Learners and their students with disabilities so when we have students that are taking extra support class classes that then takes them off track for graduation so as a team we're collectively working with our counselors and our site leaders to really look at strategic scheduling as Dr Richardson mentioned and ensuring that our both our English Learners and our students with disabilities have all the supports necessary to graduate high school one thing that I want to highlight with regards to this slight is slide is the national Clearing House
031data which we look at closely over a span of eight years has showed that of our graduates 67% of them go onto a college or university half of that 67% goes to a 4-year University half of that goes to a 2-year University with over 30% of our students left with no future goals they do not enter College whether it's fouryear or two-year that has remained consistent with San Diego unified for over a span of eight years this slide is extremely important to acknowledge because our recent class of 2024 just recently graduated as I uh previously shared we had the graduation rate of 88.3 which you'll notice in the the middle when our students enter nth grade they are assigned a cohort when students entered n uh ninth grade the class of they were assigned the
032class of 2024 there were 6,761 n9th graders that entered our system what I want to point out in this highlight uh in this slide and highlight are the slivers that aren't in blue the big chunk are our graduates the slivers are our students that we have either pushed out and have not yet earned a diploma that equates to 753 students and so we want to lead with that and frame this conversation because as we talk about the class of 2025 which is our current seniors I'd like to acknowledge that that we have 1,338 seniors students 21% of class of 2025 that is currently off track and at risk of not graduating as Dr Richardson mentioned um in the slide we are progress monitoring to towards several things in order to progress monitor for College and
033Career indicator our students much must graduate from high school so graduation is um of the utmost importance when our students graduate then they are um then uh measured if you will on the College and Career indicator this means that they have taken courses um that align for CCT completion apib passage rates the passage of esac Etc one thing that we want to acknowledge um is that as Dr richon mentioned one of the key levers that we're addressing tonight is a through G however we as a district and office of graduation alongside our leaders and counselors have adopted a focus a streamlined focus on a through G early college credit and CCT completion you'll notice that our intentional work with our site leaders at the middle and high school have led to a 3% gain over
034the past year of this intentional Focus we added this slide um in order to frame the upcoming conversations so it's really important to recog I that we as a district adopted an A through G course aligned diploma but what I want to highlight most importantly on this slide is that in order to be AC uh UC CSU a through G aligned eligible our students have to earn a c or higher in their courses our diploma allows for students to earn D's our students can graduate with these and the minute a student graduates and earns or I'm sorry earns a d and therefore gradu grates by earning a d they are off track for ucsu and they are no longer eligible that's really important to note before we move on to these um subsequent slides so
035that when we know that we're graduating students while we're graduating students they may not be eligible to apply for ucsu simply because they either missed a course or two and or they've earned a d on their transcript so what you're going to see on this slide and it's important for me to highlight um that there was an update to this slide slide nine in your packet changed because the column numbers did not add up uh correctly there was a clerical error so Marty will make note of that in the meeting notes that this slide was updated to correctly um adjust the that percentage what I want to share with the team here is that you'll notice that we've included at the top of each bar graph um the graduation rates for our students in each
036of the class of cohorts so I want to um draw our attention to the class of 2024 our students we had a graduation rate of 88.3 of the students that graduated in that 88.3 uh percentage 69.3% of our students were eligible CSU UC eligible but there were 30.7% of our graduates that were not UC CSU eligible which brings me to progress monitoring and how we as a district want to do better by our students and ensure not only our students graduate they complete a through G and we're progress monitoring that we worked alongside our data team our site leaders counselors to get in uh input as to how we internally Sandy go unified are going to then progress monitor towards a3g completion so this is s San Diego unified a through G on track benchmarks
037that we have set for ourselves and that we're going to use continually on an ongoing basis to monitor our students progress what this means then if we start at the ninth grade level we have the expectation that our students will end their 9th grade year passing English with two credits with a C or higher passing math whether that's am1 im2 I3 with a C or higher and passing a level of Science by IEM physics or those that align with a C or higher knowing that they are taking additional courses we prioritize these uh core um courses to progress monitor you'll also see that these are often the core content areas that our students struggle with the most then moving into the 10th grade year what you're going to see is it then becomes twoe we
038add in a year of English so after their 10th grade year it is the expectation that they have past two years of Engish English pass with their CER higher two years of math here's where they call it the 10th grade uh crunch right because um we add in then world like world history and then two years of Science and then subsequently you're going to see that we add in those benchmarks and that is how we as a district are internally going to monitor our students progress which then takes me to our progress monitoring of not only our Spotlight students but I would like to First share with you um the progress of our students 9 through 12 with regards to a through G uh on track this so based on the benchmarks that I just
039shared 57.8 of our students districtwide in grades 9 through 12 are on track for a through G completion this slide though highlights our Spotlight students identified by our high school leaders counselors staff so what you're going to notice on this slide is the progress monitoring of our Spotlight students which is um our interim goal of 4.1 so how we read this slide is starting with the class of 2028 these are our ninth grade Spotlight students we have identified 875 Spotlight students across the district in n9th grade you'll see that of that 635 um are off track meaning they have not earned a see or hire in English math science now you may Wonder um what is the the difference between a 4x4 versus is a six period because a 4x4 then has more opportunities to
040um earn these credits the way in which we've set up this um tracking mechanism is that if a student is in progress for a s uh traditional six period day then it counts for towards being on track so these are students who have um failed or earned a D in at least one credit of their science English and math at 9th grade and then subsequently you see the data for our 10th grade students which is class of 2020 7 we have 888 Spotlight students 87% of the students are off track for our 11th grade year class of 2026 we have 832 students um 85% of the students are off track and I included for you because I previously just shared how many of our total uh seniors were off track this then highlights um out
041of those 1,000 uh students that were off track for graduation 54 47 of them are identified as Spotlight students and 79% of them are off track uh for a through G which um also uh implies that they're off track for graduation as well and with that I'm going to pause here and allow for the board to have discussion and pose questions before we move forward so to be clear we really need a motion to discuss but the motion is on the whole of the item so I understand the logic behind what you're saying but you see what I mean we'd have to entertain a motion to get the board discussion so that's what I'm well that's what I'm saying so it it's a little bit awkward to to take a motion in the middle of
042the report I see the logic behind why why you paused but why don't we just continue the report for the sake of the Roberts R order here sounds good yeah but it's important to flag you're you're flagging a shift from one segment of the report to the next segment report thank you go the okay thank you for that um so we're going to talk about the Future Ready diploma that we opened with and um look at the board action um for board policy 6146 point1 and I want to pause and enter into this conversation with um board trustee Cruz said this evening of going and working up at the capital and working with students the mentioning of student voice and the power of student voice and in some of the reading I've been doing of
043professor John a pal he talks about how policies are often absent of the voice of those it impacts and so really this evening this board action on graduation requirements was in the spirit of bringing student voice in I have a quote from John pal from poverty and race through a belongingness lens that we've grounded our work in which is in a legitimate democracy belonging means that your well-being is considered and your ability to help design and give meaning to its structures and institutions is realized members are more than just individuals they also have Collective power it is not so much that they cannot speak as that they are not likely to be heard in considering the work of our meaningful diploma led by Dr Roberson we sought to hear listen and design as a collective
044a diploma that allowed for individualization and belonging for every student the group convened for over two years to collect the voices of students families High School leaders school counselors and educational Partners to design a diploma that is more flexible while maintaining the Integrity of our a3g diploma this work group has iterated various designs to consider more options of the a3g courses and Pathways towards College and Career preparedness opening opportunities for all of our students considering internships apprenticeships certifications jrc courses and other existing Pathways towards career in college this is about individualization for all students each student getting their diploma thank you this slide further highlights the work not only of the designing for Meaningful graduation workg group but also the work of our middle and high schools um if the board recalls in October of
0452023 the the board adopted the office of graduation and uh we began the work with our middle and high school colleagues alongside area superintendent Michelle Irwin um I'm happy to share the Journey of our secondary schools because this is very important um a and to me and to everyone in this room this evening um we have worked as a collective to over the years to really understand the needs of our students and understand the needs of our sites in order to not only prepare our students for graduation but prepare them for a future and to be Future Ready our office did data Dives with regards and and not only our office but in conjunction with our site leaders and the workg group did data Dives to really take a look at what is it that
046we have offered across the district in our clusters and we looked for cluster pathway alignment and what we saw were a lot of obstacles and barriers in in SE several of our clusters where there was not a through line there was not alignment with regards to course offerings and Visual and Performing Arts whether our students were able to accelerate in math math whether they were able to accelerate in any um CCT Endeavors and we we uncovered some roadblocks some unintentional roadblocks that we ourselves as a district have um placed upon students and placed upon schools and so we spent as Dr Richardson mentioned over two and a half years discussing what those obstacles and barriers and the unintended consequences of the systems and the policies and the procedures that we put in place as a
047district and and we had um very heated conversations um it was not all Rosy um but it was needed and the reason it was needed because we um were tasked with with really having true and honest conversations about the obstacles and barriers and then the inequitable practices that exist in our system that prevent our students from graduating high school and therefore preventing them to be future ready so we address many of those cluster pathway alignments where we worked with our middle and high school colleagues to then um come up with creative strategies for ensuring our students can advance in math ensuring that there was cohesion in a Visual and Performing Arts pathway a CCT pathway and then we began to work with our schools to do strategic supports and interventions we brought our middle and
048high school colleagues together as a collective to begin sharing their instructional practices because we felt that they and they have also shared this they would rather learn from each other than learn from us and that is um that was met with great respect because what is shared is the best practices can learn from be learned from one another and they themselves can replicate that and I missed an opport Unity when we were talking about El's and the graduation rate I wanted to bring out a spotlight a bright spot for our school moris high school was one of the only schools that went up in graduation rate for English Learners that is strategic on their part because of the focused intentional work on on listening and speaking across the entire School within each of the the
049content areas and in the classrooms and I neglected to bring out that uh bright spot um and so I apologize to Dr Lin who's here um and to Dr Whitehurst Payne because it's really important to note that while we as a district have been having ongoing conversations about budget Gap in our resources and whether we're able to afford fiscally different resources and supports by our leaders sharing best practices then they too can adopt those best practices in their spsa and use their own site funds to replicate some of the things that that um our schools have been doing so we then have uh utilized data collabs for our leaders to come together and share best practices with regards to Spotlight students most recently Dr Stephanie Brown shared about uh Lincoln High School's intentional work with
050Spotlight students um uh Mike ptis principal at UC also um shared his perspective Nicole albas at MTM then brought in the breast practices at midlevel so that we as a collective could begin to um create a a bank of best practices so that we could share and learn from from one another and that is really important for me to share because what comes out of it is that we at high school have a heavy responsibility of the students that enter day one into our high school whether they're on track or whether they're off track and each of our colleagues work um hard every day to ensure our students have a meaningful experience on their high school campus uh they're able to take the classes that are necessary to earn um an A through G diploma
051but there are times when we have tried all the interventions and supports and we have to have another approach to supporting our students and that was much of our conversation that we had as a workg group with that said um this was really a Grassroots effort by our district alongside our site leaders alongside our students alongside our counselors and school communities with when we go out into our community and we ask what does it mean to have a meaningful diploma what does it mean to be future ready we went out as an office and we worked with high school students across our district and we pose these questions that you see on this slide I want to highlight when we ask what does the word meaningful mean when you hear the word meaningful diploma we
052asked our high school students that question and then I want to highlight we asked if we were to redesign the high school experience what would it what would some of those improvements be what course off offerings would we change how would we better then provide a meaningful experience to our students it was a very powerful moving uh opportunity to hear the voices of our students and at this time I want to share with you uh a limited perspective if you will because it was four hours long um so ceue up this the video please My Name is Izzy I go to Patrick Henry and a meaningful diploma to me means something that you're proud of so when you're graduating you can have like experiences that you're proud of and you feel confident moving on to
053college or your next step if college is not for you so something that you're than that you've worked hard for for four years hi my name is Lena and I'm from Crawford High School um a meaningful diploma to me is a diploma that sets a student up for Success I'm a high school senior so I have a few more months left before I get my diploma and it's not going to be meaningful to me until I feel like it's really set me up for a good future um and to me meaningful diploma is something that is purposeful and like relevant to the real world right now um I think it's something that should go far beyond just my requirements but also things that are going to prepare me for the real world um when I
054hear the word meaningful it means something special to me something that I hold dearly to my heart something that I put a lot of my time my energy like my everything into um so when I hear the term meaningful diploma it's like you really like worked your hardest and persevered and like went through every heavy thing like easy different like everything that like affected you in your past you made it through and you made sure that like nothing was going to stop you from getting this dipl I feel like certain things like um for like at least for my career path there were certain um classes and stuff that I wish I would have been able to take but either like they were like full or like maybe there like there's a like we have
055a journalism class where there's only one teacher so it's a really small amount of people who get to participate in that and then I wanted to take a black studies class this year but not of people requested it so I was like to have that so I just feel like I missed a lot of opportunities to really like enrich myself and stuff that I would have been able to take on to my career um just because like the school wasn't able to provide it forever reason yeah similar to what clay said I really wish there were more AP stem classes at our school I was able to take AP biology last semester but other than that there aren't really any other stem APS in addition myself personally I feel like I've had a lot of
056access to experiences and programs for the pathway that I want to go into I was able to do an internship last year last year in the summer and that was able to open my eye to a new like pathway that I want to go down instead of what I was originally interested in and other students around me aren't able to have that same experience only five kids from my school was able to go to that internship and if other students at my school was able to get the same experience that I did at that internship they would know what what they want to do because I know a lot of my friends and other students at my school they aren't really sure about what they want to do in the future so also more pathway
057classes we only have four Pathways at my school so classes that teach you about business and marketing and many other careers would be really helpful so the student perspective helped then um Drive the conversations for the designing full designing for Meaningful graduation workg group we prototyped over 15 different diploma Pathways we then vetted those prototypes with our site leaders our counselors and reive feedback much of which um it expressed similar uh concerns that the board has brought forth to us with regards to equity safeguards and so what we have developed and what we're sharing with you this evening is um while we're asking for some of our graduation requirements in essence to I'm gonna pause for a second because I'm taking Dr Richardson's slide so I'm going to pause okay and I'm going to hand
058it over to her thank you thank you thank you um there's three big parts of the well there's four parts of consideration for the action that we're asking the board to make tonight the first one is really about having more um flexibility within the courses that our students can complete so in the past we've been very prescriptive of what courses meet you know ninth grade English is English one to um very prescriptive in science and bio chem and um physics and so really the first part is giving more flexibility to students to pursue like the example Dr bagula gave us at UC of our biomed actually meaning science it's approved by the ucsu and recognizing that as meeting our science requirements the second piece is our ethnic studies requirements and and just formalizing the fact
059it is um taking a course over two semesters and having that be consistent in our policy and the third action here is about our students with an IEP who qualify for the California alternative assessment to receive an essential diploma the last part is what Dr Roberson was starting to allude to is recognizing an alternate sequence for some of our individual students to complete a prescribed series of coursework to receive the diploma and make sure that it aligns with the California college career indicator and preparedness as we've talked about in this presentation through a district panel approval process so with that we will now allow the board to have discussion based on our recommended action thank you so much um Jen and Aaron um so I'm going to uh attempt to get a motion here on
060this and just to be clear We There are two separate items here and that's why the our our reporters here uh paused Midstream one of which is our um our report a progress report which is a monitoring report in association with our student outcome focused governance and the other is a um a recommendation for an update to the graduation requirements which in theory addresses um or will assist in additional progress in with in relation to the report given so um in order to have it have this enter the floor for for discussion and debate uh I am entertaining a motion on both of those items um I see trusty Hazen with a motion do I have a second and I see trusty Cruz with a second so we have a motion and a second uh
061and we will start with uh seeing if there are any speakers from the public on the item and it looks like there may be yes we have quite a few speakers uh we have one virtual speaker on this item Amanda Courtney if Amanda is available go ahead you have two minutes to quote the incredible Maya Angelou do the best you can until you know better then when you know better do better requiring all San Diego unified graduates to complete a tog cours work is a wonderful goal in theory in reality education is not a one-size fol journey in the years since the a tog implementation we have learned a lot and have had the ability to analyze student data putting it plainly we know better so it's time to do better by providing multiple meaningful
062Pathways to graduation and amending the graduation requirements for our graduates we are living up to our statements about being here for all students as a San Diego unified graduate an employee of this district and a parent of a current student I hope to see these proposed graduation requirement changes approved by the board and implemented immediately thank you and we have 13 in-person speakers so each person will receive one minute of time if you could please come to the podium Carly Johnstone followed by Corey Hoffman oh was okay hi um I want to appreciate the o or i want to I appreciate the opportunity to speak tonight thank Dr richardon Dr Roberson and the team who has worked hard over the past several years on another path to graduation for our students I'm the principal at
063Claremont High and at Claremont we pride ourselves on our efforts at inclusion for all of our students into our community incl including all academic spaces though this proposed additional path to graduation will benefit a range of students not just those with IEPs I do want to focus my short time on this subgroup each year when I share the California school's dashboard information next to our graduation rate I want to add the asteris that would State quote of the students eligible for an sdusd diploma because we're a small school even a small group of students can have a several percentage Point impact on our graduation rate our extensive need students and many of our students with moderate disabilities who aren't able to meet the a3g requirements and either earn a certificate of completion or need to
064move to adult education to access the quote option to diploma are counted as non-g grads this is unfortunate and doesn't represent and reflect the efforts of our staff and the growth of our students and adding this path to graduation would definitely do more for their efforts and um allow them to uh count as graduates of our site and our district thank you Corey Hoffman followed by John Brooks sure hi my name is Corey Hoffman I'm the central office resource teacher for the deaf and heart of hearing program um we have a large program at Madison High School and right now our students have the option if they want a diploma they have to be in mainstream classes learning instruction filtered through an ASL interpreter or a transcriber instead of being in separate class classes for
065the deaf with an instructor who can directly communicate with them who have expertise in their contact content areas and who according to CTC have the credential in order to provide diploma credit um it's a real disservice to our students also with California law ab1 1938 it requires that students have opportunities for direct instruction in the pupil's language and communication mode our students deserve full communication access while also receiving access to to a high school diploma poor communication accessibility through poor Visual and or auditory access in schools compounds the issue as it hinders even students with long with strong language foundations from learning please help make this Equitable and give our students access to the educational programs the same as their hearing peers John Brooks followed by Tim Farson uh good evening my name is John
066Brooks thank you for having me here tonight I do work at Madison High School I've been working there for about 12 years now and I work every day with our students and they constantly ask me questions about life After High School and I have it's terrible to tell them I have to be very blunt with them and let them know they may not get a diploma and that's really heart breing to tell our students so I decided a few years ago that I wanted to collaborate with my colleagues and see what it is that we can do better and how we can better serve our students so I have been collaborating with people like Corey who just spoke and resource Specialists within the district so that I can teach content that aligns with our classes
067as well as making sure that my role is as a teacher and be able to be a co-teacher in our educational classrooms as well as the deaf classrooms that way they're is a full picture of content that is aligned and keeps them on track so I'm hoping that tonight with all of a stories that we share from all of us that you will consider giving us and our dhh students and programs an opportunity for a diploma thank you so much for your time good evening I am Tim fars and I'm principal of the San Diego School L gr and Performing Arts where every day we pride ourselves that students get to learn live their passion and do and live what they love every day and I see the results of that over and over again
068I think about the importance of access to these opportunities the importance of thank goodness we're six by 6 through2 on a 4x4 schedule where our students who have intensive needs and supports have access to do what they love in addition to these requirements I worry about schools that don't have that opportunity secondly at a school like ours difference does not mean less than and I'm very passionate about that we are always on the naughty listed SCPA because we have a belief that with high expectations and support our students can achieve their aspirations our sophomores for example take AP language even though it is not a recommended course why so our students have access to the Community College the Junior and senior years is one example where this policy gets in the way of the dreams
069of our students and I believe firmly that with the correct belief system in our students and this policy change we can do incredible things thank you Karina Ramos follow by Kyle paw she just went to the restroom oh okay Kyle paw hi everybody my name is Kyle p and my native language is ASL and I am a proficient in English as well I have a high school diploma since my education was accessible to me in ASL and my local school supported my education now I hold a bachelor's degree from gadet University where I completed all of the courses in ASL so what's stopping the deaf high school students from getting a diploma a failed system that lacks support for them what happened to the No Child Left Behind this school district has clearly left hundreds
070of deaf students behind and many of them are in awful places in life it's vital for the San Diego Unified School District students to have a deaf centered classroom with qualified credential teachers you guys are already just say yes to the alternative approach for the deaf students to get their diplomas please do not steal their futures from them bilingual education is a necessity for the deaf students to succeed and to have a higher quality of life this must become the future of the deaf education throw out the 20th century mindset no deaf Child Left Behind please thank you Terrence Jones I am supportive of diploma my name is Terrence Jones I am a 34-year-old deaf person I am a half black and Mexican amican my story as a deaf person is very common and it
071happens to many deaf people almost every day in the school districts here in California my family of both sides are at a low advantage in life with many traumas and abuses my mother was not involved with my education but my mother always expected that my School Lakewood High School would ensure that I get a good education and that I will graduate with a diploma I was given a certificate only because the courses I took were in ASL are deaf and heart of hearing courses and that was not considered equivalent to those in mainstream school I had to face 5 years of fighting for my high school diploma I suffered mental health crises as a result such as being suicidal undergoing depression I was not able to pursue my dreams of going to college that shouldn't
072happen that should not have happened to me or any other deaf students please give the students their diploma I have mine right here this is a real diploma from 2013 please give the students their diplomas in their language and decentric classrooms thank you so much for your time Laticia Mendoza hi uh my name is Lea mosa I'm aota if you don't know what that is my parents are de so I'm in the culture of the deaf I'm also a minister and a pastor for the DEA Community here in in Spring Valley California and I support the alternative education for the de um I have the opportunity to teach and preach in ASL to the dev community and I see the Improvement of being mainstream or separate only in their language uh de are able to
073learn in their native language English is their second language and they need to be taught in their native language and in English the de students do not have a learning disability or delayed in learning they have been deprived of Education due to their lack of teaching of native language which say as H de children are not delayed again learning or delayed in learning they need the school needs to give them a diploma you seen these young people five years later they got a certificate in high school five year later they fought for the diploma five years later after they got the certificate their children are not delayed again their label in the system as delayed but they're not they're just this human as you and me they're only deaf and cannot speak but they have
074the same brain the same ability to learn like any English spoken but the the thing is that they need to be taught in their own language which is American Sign Language and have a classroom in American Sign Language with teachers please remove these barriers in the community I support the diploma for the Laur students oh sorry Laura Kim hi my name is Laura Kim I am one of the dhh Deen heart of hearing teachers for the school district I have been working for 16 years I teach Math and Science to our deaf and heart of hearing students at Innovation High School additionally I volunteer as a board member for the National Association of the deaf the NAD representing Region 4 which serves 13 states on the west coast since 2020 I'm here to ensure that
075de student to explain that de students receive a diploma it's not just an educational Milestone it is a fundamental affirmation of their civil human and linguistic rights the National Association of the deaf advocates for Equity that spans a lifetime from early intervention and education to employment Healthcare and Beyond a diploma represents more than academic achievement it is a gateway to opportunity Independence and Leadership denying this right increases the risk of dependence on the the welfare system mental health challenges and even involvement in criminal activities by upholding the standard you are not only empowering individual students but also shaping a more inclusive future for millions of deaf and hard of hearing Americans so again by upholding the standard we are empowering these students and shaping them for a more inclusive future the decisions made today Ripple
076across Generations Paving the way for Access equity and progress in every facet of life thank you for your time Sarah Thomas good evening as our as the Director of special education um I see firsthand how rigid one siiz fits-all diploma pathway um does fail many students especially those who learn differently um or have unique um or have unique strengths too often our students disengaged because of their coursework doesn't align with their interest or aspirations um our system assumes what students want a lot of the time um and as you heard in some of their voices um that's not always what they want uh the numbers speak for themselves our graduation rates are stagnant our Dropout rates are rising students are walking away from the system uh we're refusing to evolve uh we are seeking opport
077they're seeking opportunities elsewhere or or Worse they're losing hope um we are failing them uh we're clinging to outdated methods instead of creating more meaningful experiences um I urge you to approve the meaningful diploma pathway it it's one that keeps students engaged by offering courses that align with their passions we heard two weeks ago students at Lincoln asking and begging for another way that was more meaningful to their future um whether it's skilled in trade or entrepreneurship or Technical Training along with helping prepare them for four-year College um is what we're asking for our role as Educators is to open doors not close them and it's time to build an education system that values every student's future not just ones that we expect for them uh so we um we hope that the time is
078tacked now thank you Stacy Williams hi I just want to make sure that we when we're developing this alternative uh pathway that we definitely include the um Community Based instruction which is through Trace I'm afraid for some of the mild mod students that don't get that um because they never have the opportunity to go to trace what we provide instructionally is way different than a comprehensive site so I definitely want to make sure I get that in and then I wanted to suggest a change for BP 6146 actually an addition because uh some students will still continue to go to trace and choose that pathway to finish their diploma and or other ways um but right now the way it's stated they cannot participate in the graduation ceremony with their peers and I noticed that
079there were exceptions for foster youth uh students that were in juvenile hall students with military families and migrant students who um enroll later so if we could also include our mild mod students who finished four years that choose to go into Trace that they'll be able to participate with their class after that four years and then go on to trace if they choose to do so I'm just advocating for that but I I think you know having more Pathways and opportunities for students is great I just worry about that community- based instruction piece because that's all we do in Trace and we want to make sure that we keep that in there at the high school so the students don't just end up getting a diploma and sitting at home okay thank you Cara tesner
080hi my name is Cara tesner and I am very blessed um I work at SCPA and I have been working for this District since 1999 I not from here I come from a central part of California where all the Farms are and I'm one of very few students who went away to go to college all of my classmates most of them went into the trades went into you know whatever their family business was and you know I know a guy who knows a guy who can do anything right we build HVAC farming um welding you name it the biggest change for me the biggest like culture shock when I became a a high school counselor here in San Diego unified is I felt that we were a factory producing students to go to a university
081and that was it they did not have any opportunities to do anything else I wasn't um I don't want to say allowed to but I wasn't we didn't have the resources really to tell them okay there's different trades that you can go into there's apprenticeships everything else it was a3g a3g you everyone needs to go to a fouryear university and I've been on a soldier on the ground a steward of the district for the past 25 years and I can tell you that 30 years ago when the when all of us were going getting our um figuring out what we were doing in high school and postsecondary plans the landscape has changed a 100 times over it is so competitive to get into these universities the universities are outrageously um priced we have a student
082debt uh crisis in America and we have a lot of students who want to work with their hands and we have a need um here in San Diego especially for trades and other opportunities I mean we have a student who came to us yesterday who really is interested in becoming an electrician and he goes to SCPA and um to be a a firefighter so of course we hooked him up with the the trades and talk have talk to one of our teachers who's a volunteer firefighter just to give him some exposure so I really think that as a counselor for the past 25 years this alternative diploma is huge we absolutely need it we have so many students who want an alternative um pathway for their post-secondary plans thank you Julio Bravo hello my name
083is Julio Bravo you can call me Armando I'm deaf and I use sign American sign language as my primary language I'm an alumni of Madison High School within this district and I've witness many peer struggle within the school system they've conducted all the courses just the same as their hearing peers and yet they were given certificates and their hearing parents who are immigrants Latinos blacks were all under the impression that their children would get diplomas and this ongoing system of misleading the students in their families getting it getting certificates is very destructive and has placed many of them at a low Advantage St in this life this needs to stop give them diplomas in their language ASL is a basic human right topaz Johnson our lead Newar if we can move her to I believe
084she's saying she wants to speak at non- Agenda public comment if we can just move her name to the end of the end of the meeting sure and then uh Karina Ramos hello my name is Karina I'm a 30-year-old deaf woman who happens to be an immigrant as well as my whole family ASL is my primary language I'm a little emotional give me just a moment um we moved here to San Diego from Mexico to in pursuit of a better deaf education from for me we placed our trust in San Diego Unified School District to educate me and give me a better future I did all the same work as my hearing peers except in American Sign Language our trust in the school district was shattered when I was told I would not Reed diploma
085today I still have no diploma or a GED because of the lack of access for me in American Sign Language I'm stuck struggling finding a job and even to get a higher education please start harming the deaf students give them diplomas choose to do the right thing that's all the speakers all right um thank you for your testimony we will move now to board discussion do any of my colleagues uh have any thoughts uh trusty haen I'm curious just procedurally if you want us to do all of the progress monitoring questions separate from um the board policy questions what would you what would you prefer together uh why don't we just love them all together because I don't I don't think we may we may not get that many on on all the aspects of
086it okay I'll start with uh progress monitoring um and I think it's a little challenging because there wasn't a lot on um how we're doing against um the inm goal 4.1 and I talked to um our Consultants at Council of great City schools and just want to bring to the board's attention that it appears um that the information presented in the item doesn't quite constitute um a goal um monitoring report for interim goal 4.1 based on our shared agreements um about progress monitoring between the board and administration and the sofg model model um and I think it's really critical for the board um and for me to be able to fulfill my responsibility to improve outcomes for kids especially as we're asking principles and ssc's to monitor progress against their spsa goals um it's important
087that we model effective monitoring for our district um and also just again this is just sort of procedural and Technical um at yesterday's student outcomes Focus governance task force meeting Ben Macky from the Council of great City Schools also reminded us um and we sort of see today why it's difficult that a progress monitoring report you know agenda item should be separate um from any other action item um so that we can receive thoughtful insight and Analysis about why we are or aren't on track to meeting the specific goals in this case intrum goal 4.1 um and I guess I'm trying to understand so the goal for um 4.1 is that we wanted to see growth from 24.7% um of 9th through 12th grade Spotlight students um they were on track to complete a through
088G course requirements with a grade of C or higher um so 24.7% in the spring the goal um by 2030 is 42.7% um and I know we got us I think it was slide um I don't know was like one of the last ones in here where we saw across all of the cohorts where we are but where are so I guess the question is we know where we were in 2023 where were we where were students where is that cohort 2024 where are we now and also where did we want to be so what percent of Spotlight students were on track in Spring 2024 what percent are on track today um and what is our Target for both of those periods um I'm guessing that we wanted to go up about 2 and a
089half% each year um to get to that 18% growth but I don't know so if you could share how we're tracking against that goal specifically it would be really helpful and then I'll ask my other questions I think it's um first it's really important to note that it is this is the year that we have standardized with regards to the criteria for our Spotlight students so if you recall in September uh I came before the board and I presented the progress monitoring of our Spotlight students from last year that was a small subset of only ninth grade identified Spotlight students for the criteria we as a district then alongside our our data um support team work to then expand that 9 through 12th so that we can begin to progress monitoring so this in um
090my professional opinion would be the Baseline for our common understanding of what Spotlight students are and how we're measuring them as a district so I would not I can um I'm happy to provide the board with uh a follow-up data report from last year's identified Spotlight students who would then be in 10th Grade now in comparison to our newly identified Spotlight students but we cannot compare the two because it's apples to oranges so just for clarity so the Baseline in the goal we adopted of 24.7% isn't the well I think it's important to note that that Baseline is of our graduate right so this is framing the conversation of when our students graduate then they're assigned whether they've met a through G completion so we as a district then have said we want to then
091progress monitor our ninth graders our 10th graders 11th graders so that when they graduate they then meet that Mark of earning a CR hire so that comparison um or the actual data points won't be derived until our students graduate from high school so we have set we have Set uh three Romans in the audience and I can get it up in a minute it um the goal is three I believe it's three percentage Points each year and so we have those measurements we have those metrics um but that is that goal in itself is of our graduates we internally are then monitoring our students as they progress through their educational journey in 9th 10th 11th and 12th so that then we could achieve that goal so I guess maybe we need to come back and
092think about refining the goal language because it sounds like the interim goal 4.1 doesn't align necessarily with what we're tracking that the Baseline is inaccurate um it's it just sounds like yeah it need it may need more work or more discussion is that accurate so I think there could be so I uh yes and yes and there could be a subset of a goal but we don't want all these goals right so there is that we have the those that graduate from high school they then um meet preparedness for College and Career indicator and then we want our students that graduate our Spotlight students that graduate with us to be prepared and meet a3g um if we were then to go back we would then be adding another goal in my professional opinion to then
093uh add in additional progress monitorings but we're happy to do that if yeah I mean I guess I'm just trying like s simply just to know are we on track to meet this goal and if we aren't able to know if we are aren't right looking for a number compared to that 24.7% or and if we can't today if we can come back with a I don't know uh superintendent bagula is it possible to come back um with a more specific narrowly Focus progress monitoring report on interim goal 4.1 so we know how we're doing compared to the goal and and if um we recognize based on the data analysis work we're doing and getting better at monitoring that some of the numbers were inaccurate when we adopted them and need to be tweaked I
094think that's an important conversation also yes and I do believe that having a task force that meets monthly well and I'm happy that you actually began that work because I think it will be important um and I also believe that there's going to be several iterations of this that we're going to encounter um so this being one of about thinking about a graduation goal and getting those numbers mathematics as you know this is our Baseline year so again it's going to be a little bit of a learning curve um and then the same thing is going to potentially happen to us we have to kind of think about it if we do decide to not use fast as our assessment so there will still be a little bit of growing pains throughout this process but
095the most important piece which is having a goal having metrics and ongoing monitoring which is the most important part is still going to be fulfilled um it is just about building up our data literacy build building up our data systems and then continuing to engage in these conversations but yes I will have that we'll have that ready thank you and just I mean appreciate all the work and I know that everybody's been digging into this so don't want to belabor it um but just want to make sure that we have interim goals that are meaningful and that we can monitor progress um against so thank you for that um and then also knowing as part of that report and I asked the question um before the meeting but just want to reiterate that I'm hoping
096um to also find out um in which clusters schools and grades are Spotlight students growing the most struggling the most or not moving up or down towards this inm goal or at least something close to it and then in terms of um board policy um I support um I know there I think there are four elements of the policy um and I think the first three um I'm very excited about I appreciate all the work um that I know so many principls Educators leaders students have done um over the last two years to get to this point um I know I've spoken to a lot of principles about the work um and really appreciate all all of it and all the feedback um that I've received and really our shared commitment um to making sure
097that students have more choices and are more Future Ready um so I think it's really exciting um to be at this point and appreciate what Dr vula said um that you know we about a decade ago or more you know adopted a through G and now um we understand students needs uh to be a little different and and how do we adapt um I do have concerns um about the fourth element of um the board policy um so and I just want to specifically read it because for me it isn't necessarily a concern um about an alternative sequence it's about how broad um the wording and the policy is so right now um the policy reads in addition to exemptions required by educ ation code the prescribed course requirements listed above may not accommodate the
098needs of some students therefore a district panel May provide an alternative sequence for individual students to complete a prescribed series of coursework to obtain a high school diploma that meets Education Code and it's the minimum uh State diploma and fulfills the California college career indicator preparedness requirement I'm concerned that it's too broad and so I'm really trying to understand to whom does this apply um and as I think about you know the motion to approve this I'd like to amend it um to reconsider just this one sentence um so not to adopt that today but for stf for the superintendent to come back to us um at a future board meeting with specific eligibility criteria more detailed plan about who would make decisions about eligibility how decisions would be made anticipated numbers of impacted students
099some specific Equity guard rails um because I think having some students feels way too broad um to me and I think as a district committed to equity when we leave so much flexibility it also leaves room um for historically marginalized students to continue to be marginalized um by a diploma that may or may not me their needs so thank you for that I I agree with you that's been my biggest concern this entire time I'm sorry Dr peton um it's it was one of the things that has concerned me about this plan um and I think we have to be very specific because I know exactly who the students are that we sometimes um funnel into a different uh Lane and so I want to make sure that we have very detailed requirements and a
100very well thought out plan and quite frankly I really have been impressed with the leadership of Dr Roberson and Dr Richardson of engaging such a large community and making these decisions and my hope is that they come at that with the same Spirit um of like how let's think through this so that this is not an equity issue later on um we want to make sure it's clean so that doesn't matter who is leading this work but that it's very clear for for students so thank you for that thank you I believe Dr buul is speaking to an amendment that has not yet been accepted to the floor but I will take that in advance of the discussion um so I believe trusty Hazen is asking for an amended motion to return in a period
101of time um with some equity safeguards and some clarification of what the parameters of of that alternative path would be um before we before I see if we can get a I believe that's a motion to amend before if I before I get concurrence from a second and concurrence from the authors or the previous motion makers about how much time might you need to do that to return to the board with those [Music] safeguards our plan was to engage with the meaningful diploma workg group again and begin to map out and design what that could look like um and so I know Dr Roberson and I had discussed this and and felt like you know 60 days would be a good amount of time to come back to the board with a design okay um
102do the makers of the original motion who were I believe it was O sha you're a maker of the motion and and Joseph do you would you accept that amendment to your motion I would I thought you might um and trusty Cruz okay so uh Marty do you have that amended okay um so with that we will move to further discussion from the board trusty bur or vice president Bur no thank you president Pon I so I um I I agree with the um kind of spirit of the amendment and the intention to get clarity around um the alternative pathway and and the specific questions that truste Hazen is asking who who's eligible for going before the panel what are our safeguards um my only hesitation is I think this um concept of the um
103the alternative pathway is core to this policy update and because an alternative way to do this would be to um support the policy and then ask for the superintendent to come back in 60 days um with implementation uh uh guidelines and and the only reason I'm hesitant about this is I don't want to send a message to um to everybody who's worked on this uh and and and you know to our to our schools and our community that we not potentially supportive of the concept of the alternative pathway um what we're trying trying to do is is uh tighten it and Define it so I I guess I would ask um superintendent um and and Jen and Aaron to give us a sense of um we're we're all wanting these definitions that trusty Hazen is
104asking for in um the fourth piece of this um are are you comfortable with us tonight not adopting the alternative pathway as part of this policy and then coming back and considering it in 60 days um or is your preference to adopt the policy and and and and come back to us in 60 days with um Clarity around implementing this policy I I I'll leave I'd be interested in the reactions of the superintendent I defer to you Dr bagula our preference would be to adopt and come back in 60 days with Clarity so we can move with the rest but to be clear let me just clarify the the nature of this thing I I think what you're asking for is a signal from the board that we are supportive of this item four which
105is an alternative sequence but that to the extent we we we accept the amend motion that it is that that if we combine what what trusty Hazen has said and vice president barer said that we would signal that we are supportive of this item but that we would require implementation guidelines I mean I guess that it hinges on the question of if we didn't have them if they weren't satisfactory when they came back in 60 days would that then would they then not move forward you see I think that's the distinction there and I think what trusty haen is saying is from her perspective if the implementation guidelines were not adequate at that point in time she would not be comfortable supporting it without adequate implementation guidelines is that accurate you asking me yeah I
106mean is that am I yes and I I mean last around imple implementation but I think and I think superintendent beula said it better I think you talked about um whether it was equity guard rails constraints I mean for me my concerns are concerns rooted in equity and making sure that you we heard um from people within the deaf Community about how we have not been meeting their needs understanding that yes an alternative sequence like this is absolutely important for Deaf students and understanding more specifically who we're talking about who this applies to who this doesn't apply to because my fear is um when there aren't all of us sitting here and all of the people who have done this work that you could and I shared this with superintendent Pula you could have a
107superintendent who says all I care about is getting to a 95% graduation rate and what's the easiest way to do that is just to start issuing this alternative sequence diploma and who ends up suffering are the students who've been historically marginalized by this District who have not been treated equitably and so for me it's getting specificity getting Clarity so that there aren't unintended consequences down the line and so to answer your question yeah I don't think I could move forward if I didn't see that specific you know that kind of specificity is there potential that it comes back and it's not specific enough and I can't support it maybe but I think we're going to do the work in and get it there is it is it possible I mean that so with that because
108I agree with you please know that like I'm actually also very concerned that's been my concern I will stand on that um but we're asking the board to approve all the elements but also to direct staff and myself to come back with an implementation plan to approve and we would not move on implementing anything until the plan is presented and approved would you board policies give the framework and then we can operationalize it understood trusty baldis do you have a some oh okay yes trusty baso yeah thank you for this discussion and I understand what trusty Hazen is saying I also understand what trusty barrer is saying and I think all of us want that you know I think the staff I mean I think we need to have confidence in our staff that they
109are going to come back with that I mean I think we all know that that's what's important and I think at this time if you know B based on the recommendations and the work that's been done um we should go ahead and approve with the stipulation that they're going to come back with the the more detailed implementation plan but I think we're all on the same team here we all want that and I I trust that we're going to get that that detail um to give them a little bit more time for that piece but that we go ahead and um approve this evening I we first have to understand what the motion on the floor that we approved or not approving is so I want to get clarification on that to continue to sh
110a point the motion on the floor currently is that we would move forward with a three and they would return to 60 days I my understanding is that advice um the vice chair um Barrera uh would like to move forward with the entirety of it um with uh with imple implementation guidelines coming back in 60 days um I I might try a a a compromise which is to vote on all of them with a statement of with a with a recognition of support for item four that we are we we approve it in principle but that we await for final decision on item four uh for that 60-day return back is that is that acceptable to staff can you work with that we can work with that I think um just semantics is that um
111it won't live in the board policy it would actually be through a circular or another means um of How It's implemented so I just wanted to be really clear that it wouldn't live in the board policy but rather it would live in a circular which we have circulars and other things which helps um staff and schools operationalize and and in practice you wouldn't move forward with the whole thing within 60 days anyway it was never Our intention Our intention was to again go back to the meaningful diploma workg group and design those safeguards because that was the consensus of the workg group was that we knew we needed that and we know that um there have been past practices of adults making decisions for our students and so that was always the intention okay so
112uh vice president barer would would is that acceptable to you that we we move forward on these three items on a hard approval of the three items on the fourth item we move forward the statement of principle in support of it but we defer to the actual vote on it for the 60-day return is that acceptable okay is that okay trusty crew could I take my amended motion back okay I mean what in what sense what what portion of the amended motion just to agree with back to the original yeah the original the you want to go back to the original with the modification I want I want to talk about the process because I feel for staff uh and I don't want making changes every five minutes we have to put something in place
113and look at it yes we can be more specific each time but at some point we have to lock it down and uh give them something to work on and come back we you know that's part of our problem in education we make a goal and we oh let's change it here let's change it there let's move and we never get something done so uh to that end I'm I'm just sending this message out now futuristically that we're not going to jump every five seconds and make all these random changes whether they're good bad or indifferent we have to put all of our thinking into it when we make a goal and say this is what we're going to work with going forward and we will make adjustments as staff is talking about here because
114otherwise we'll never get anywhere because we're always chasing our tail having said that I also thank Richard like colleague for putting me on that uh task force yesterday and we met with with uh Sheena and the two students and I thought it was a very good meeting that we had we recognized that we're trying to refine it so we've got this independent group that's meeting uh monthly and then you have your group with the principles here meeting and so forth so there are a lot of moving pieces that we want to bring together I think we all have the same intent um the same intention to accomplish something for our students I commend the um dhh Community for being here today and work with Staffing of the schools I mean with the dhh department and
115um there a lot of groups there that we have some pieces where we have to be more flexible we're all not the same we have to we must be more flexible and I think that's what we're trying to do but not to keep it running so that we never get anything done superintendent willing to yield to your perspective here thank you I think we're all agreeing to the same thing I think we all want those Equity safeguards I think we don't want to funnel children to a pathway that would be unequitable I also think that we all agree that the design of having a collective come together problem solved with student voice much like um both truste uh Cruz and trusty baldis talked about in their report is important and so I think we're all
116saying the same thing I think we're just getting hung up in maybe some of the rules um for the board so I'm just curious about this notion of having approval and agreeing to come back to see an implementation plan that we can then think about are we thinking about our students does this enough safeguards can we try this on what's going to be our data collection who's going to be watching these kids all of those questions that we all carry I think we're all pretty much saying the same thing um but I really I just want to say um I appreciate uh president Pon thank you for that I I I want to apologize because I'm the one that merged the pieces and maybe I shouldn't have um because it's causing some some uh disagreements
117that I don't think really exist I think we're actually all saying the same things uh I think we're good we have an amended motion on the floor a motion can't be withdrawn um so um so far Marty do you understand the amended motion yes thank you um so we have an amended motion on the floor what is the the amended motion is we move forward with all of them we're going to have a return back in 60 days for with a vote on item four but to trusty Hazen's point it's not just a question of implementation it's a question because there are a whole set of questions of principle that are associated with any metrics and parameters so so it's not just merely implementation it's about there's philosophical elements to it there are metric elements
118to it so I just is that acceptable does that reflect what you're Amit emotion know you're talking yeah sorry just to make sure I'm clear so what I'm hearing is um the strong approval of I'm looking at this slide so bullets one two and three of um of the policy and support of the spirit of the fourth one knowing that in 60 days it will come back the board will vote when we see more detail um to ensure that we're upholding our Equity principles is that that's my understanding of M motion I apologize Marty it's a long motion she's scribbling over there Marty's got the motion let me pull back from this we have the motion on the floor can we pull back and talk in honor of our staff who's presented tonight does do
119do do trustees have any comments more broadly speaking both on the monitoring and on the um and the proposed updates to the graduation requirements vice president bur yeah thank you president Pon so so first of all I also appreciate uh trusty Hazen's points about um feels like we need to clarify our goal goal um are 4.1 what what I'm hearing is that the goal the the progress that we're monitoring is are we making that 3% Improvement um uh with Spotlight students with our our definition of Spotlight students um so that would be good you know to be clear that that's what we're monitoring um so I I I I I agree with that um in terms of the the policy change I just want to thank superintendent bagula thank um Aaron and and Jen and
120everybody who's worked on this and I think it's been made the point has been made a couple of times um that we have to evolve based on where our students are and the needs of our students a tog for all was a policy that was all about opening up opport unity and we were very clear at that time that uh there were many students in our district whose opportunities were limited so you know seniors who would go to their counselor and say I want to apply you see CSU and the counselor telling them you can't you didn't have the adg courses and nobody had ever talked to them about that and in fact at some of our schools you didn't even offer we didn't even offer the the adg course so that was a um
121an attempt to get rid of the limitations that existed uh and to open up uh opportunities and as I think in the presentation and superintendent bagula LED with it's been an tremendous success of this district and it took um incredible work uh by people over many years uh to to implement that policy and and to see those I we didn't go all the way back um around the time that policy was adopted 200920 but I think our numbers were about 45% of our students of our seniors were graduating having met a tog requirements at that time and among Latino and African-American students those numbers were in the mid 20s and and those numbers Rose to that 70% for all students including African-American Latino students you know getting to that 70% we have plateaued um which
122is a which is a concern but it was uh hard work that we said we're going to open up opportunities for students and we did and we saw um uh results what we're talking about now certainly we're talking about the 11% and it's critical uh and we and we need to make sure that um that that those students have a have a opportunity to graduate but as truste Hazen said um our goal is not to go back to an inflated uh graduation rate and in fact you know students are are experiencing what superintendent bagula experienced um where they're not prepared you know for college that's that's not our goal can't be our goal the importance of these safe cards is exactly right because the day that none of us are sitting here um could be
123the day that we Backtrack on on equity and I I completely agree with that what's so exciting about this though is there are ways to for the 89% to have a more meaningful diploma that opens up opportunities that allows students to continue to meet the ad requirements and to have a a career pathway opportunities that um that that are opened up um and apologize for the you know keeping going back in history but the night the board um passed the ad for all policy there was a piece of that policy that true to uh trustee White her Payne's point we gutted from the dis which would have made at least one CTE course a requirement as well and that got removed from that policy on the dis and it got removed because there were people
124who were concerned that um if you take even one CTE course that is going to somehow get in the way of your ability to get into some Elite University and it was not true then and it's never been true but that's what happened and I think what we're doing now is we're understanding that um being College and Career ready is not those are not opposing uh Concepts you know and in fact it's our responsibility to make sure our students are College and Career ready are are both and so this is about opening up opportunities I think the UC High example of you know alternative ways to s safy the science requirement that's engaging and and and motivating to students really exciting thank you for the work thank you for you know bringing us to 2025
125and saying let's look let's take a look at the opportunities that right now we're limiting and that we need to open up for our students it's the same concept but um you know brought into into you know uh current reality so thank you am I able to please do yes there was a there must have been a question in there somewhere but um it's a bit of feedback as a recipient of the conversations that we're having and the unclarity that I have with regards to the motion that was made and the proposal coming from staff so I did hear Dr bugula recommendation of moving forward with the board policy and then coming back with the implementation plan um I'm not going to speak for Joseph but I don't know that he um when he made
126that motion for the amendment that he knew what he was advocating for because I heard him pull it back so I don't want to interrupt the protocols and procedures here but I do feel um as a staff and listening to the superintendent that our our preference is for us to adopt the board policy as written and come back to the board with the impementation plan and I did as an listener I heard that from several of our board members so I don't know that we're all if I'm not clear I don't know that we're all on the the same page with regards to the motion on the table oh well okay so what from a Robert R's perspective what's happening is we do have a motion on the floor but there is there remains some
127concerns about the motion on the floor and there are some people who are appear to be expressing some interest in voting that motion how it actually go go about is voting that motion down and returning to the initial motion that's perfectly possible um we can have the amended motion on the floor and vote it down yeah you read the motion the original motion that was um the amended motion right the original motion was from Shaya and Joseph to accept staff recommendation and then the motion was amended to return with additional details on the fourth recommendation in the board policy 614 6.1 approval of one two and three on that Spirit of the fourth come back in 60 days with implementation details that is as I understood it I mean if if folks would like to
128move for a vote and vote it down that's that's their prerogative but but I I um as a listener I felt that it shifted in the conversation of what Marty read but perhaps that's just me often times in discussions shift in relation to the to approval or disapproval of the motion on the floor um what I would suggest is we have we finish off our discussion here we move to a vote if folks would like to vote down the emitted motion and return to the original motion we can do so so I would entertain additional comments from board members and then we can take a vote on the amitt motion if you do not like the amitt motion we will return to the to I will take that as a signal to return to the
129original motion but Dr Pon I think a lot of well as um Dr Roberson mentioned I think some people are confused about the difference between the original motion and so with the supplemental supplement we would not be voting on the fourth piece of this correct and that's the part that we were we would be voting to defer final consideration of item four for 60 days when staff returns to with a with a more detailed description of what item four involves what the parameters are what the constraints are what which that's the part we have concerned about because we I think some of us have voiced concern about that motion I think the motion is I I think we're voting for items one through four and we are saying with item four we want to have
130staff come back in 60 days um with clear implementation guidelines okay that's not the motion as reflected this is I mean the motion is a motion she read the motion so there's no debate about what the motion is the question is what I'm hearing from the board is that there is dissatisfaction with specifically with regard to item four that instead of being as the motion stated approval of the spirit of item four but a deferral for 60 days until we get additional details for a final vote on item four that I believe is the motion as read by Marty so we can we can kill that we can take a vote on that motion and kill it and then return to the original motion if that's what ends up happening as a result of this
131discussion so if we can just finish this discussion about the item and then we'll take that vote and if so if we vote that down I will take that as a reflection that the board wants to return to the original motion so with that does anybody have additional items on the monitoring report any additional discussion on the monitoring report or on the um the proposed changes to the graduation requirementsa thank you president Pon I did want to share um one thing I think that's missing and I think um based on what trusty Hazen was saying it is a little confusing because we're smashing a lot of stuff together so um but the first part where we are talking about the goals and the um student outcome Focus governance piece of it um something I shared
132with staff but I didn't see it anywhere in here was also how important the parent engagement and Community engagement is going to be in this process I think one of the reasons that we're having issues particularly in our English language Learners group um you know I think a lot of parents especially if they don't speak English are not going to really understand um I know we have College and Career nights at schools but again from an equity standpoint not all parents can take off work to come to those and so I don't see a lot when my kids were in high school my oldest I'm sorry my youngest graduate in 2018 like reaching out to our community and I we need to have more of that because um a lot of the parents don't understand
133and if the parents don't understand they're you know they're not going to be there to support their kids just like the um example I used was my youngest um when she graduated in 2018 you know she wanted to apply to UC schools and CSU schools but we learned that she didn't have enough science uh she didn't have all of her science where she was missing a class and I'm a very involved parent so if I didn't catch that you know and of course my daughter should have as well but um then I know there's probably a lot of parents out there that there's a lot of confusion about this and I just think our parents that are more affluent who have been to college are going to be the ones pushing their kids and saying
134hey did you get all these classes whereas those parents that maybe didn't go to college or you know students are first generation are not getting those same resources so I think it's really important that we're we're talking about parent and Community engagement in this discussion um I think it might have been Dr bagula that mentioned when we were talking something even a screen that students can look at with their family that's visual so let's say you're not you know um really fluent in the English language they could say Hey you know I finished this this you know something that's like I don't know a circle with you know different you know parts are are completed so they can just say oh what about that part did you do that so something that they can just
135pull up and and look at and share with you know whoever might be their Mentor helping them um but but just wanted to share that because I think that's important part of this I agree with you um truste Ando um one of the really beautiful things and I actually when I finished speaking with you the last time I went to check to see where we were um because Dr the I team and our data department is creating an app that's visual so that our parents can actually see like there's a missing chunk of this pie that is necessary towards my high school graduation um and so I know we are creating an app um forward- facing for families and students to be able to navigate and then I spoke about the same thing that you
136discussed with our daac committee um that is actually one of the reasons why we had our inaugural bilingual college fair um I want to continue to pursue those opportunities because the American school system is hard to navigate especially if they don't speak the language so thank you so much for carrying trying to make any Avenues to do that but we're again aligned in our values that way thank you thank you um trusty balas well first off thank you for the report and thank you to the members of the community who have been working on this my main question would be how would this affect our interim goal 4.1 if we're trying to increase the level of Spotlight students completing all a through G course requirements but now this policy says that students can graduate without
137completing those courses with the CR higher how do you think this is going to affect that goal is the amount of Spotlight students who take this path is it going to be negligible to it or is it going to make it much harder to complete this my response to that would be all of our courses are a through G so the deviation from the uh path to then apply to a CSU UC would be different for our students but it would still be UC a through G compliant so for example we have students who um may not want to pursue a world language course but they want to major in CCT pathway or they want a major in um jotc pathway those are still a through G aligned courses our students will still graduate a
138a through G aligned in their diploma but they may not be applying to a ucsu school and as I shared earlier our national Clearing House data does show that a huge chunk of our students do not have any desire to go to a for you University so I don't see this as a step moving back I see it as a step moving forward and differently trusty W name Richard um my colleague J Barrera went back into history but the reason that you all that that board had to struggle with it was because we saw discriminatory data and that's what I shared with you all last week that we Absol whenever it was we met um you absolutely must monitor what's going on because if you find that you're having dis uh discriminatory issues with the
139alternative pathway then you need to look at it make adjustments as necess Neary um I I just think that we are in the 21st century am I right and we're not back in 100 years ago or 50 years ago things have changed and we we must be flexible and change too if we want to adhere to the same old thing that we did 50 60 years ago that's not going to work so this is an attempt to make some adjustments and you're bringing this forward to us tonight and I think that we need to look at it accept it with some some um modifications coming forward in the future so that we can adjust all going forward but we can't just not accept something so we can move forward thank you um uh I'll just
140say very briefly uh with regard to the monitoring first of all thank you very much these are grueling sessions and I appreciate all the work you put into this um with regard to the monitoring report I I can see some of the conceptual challenges here and some of them in fact most of them are artifacts of of the of board board decision- making board you know we did adopt as our interim goals the spotlight goals which at the time we recognized it's a little bit strange because the spotlight is only a small port of the overall goal so therefore treating that as the interim it's a little bit and and so we've kind of in a way poison pilled it because not only that but Spotlight is still complex and still being put together so
141we've established our interim goal a metric which is not yet fully established and which is Shifting under us and which only becomes meaningful at the end of a year when you actually have a graduation so in fact the only cohort you have data for is last year's cohort because they graduated and the spotlight category wasn't fully stood up so in a way as a it's very difficult to monitor a thing in which all you're doing is establishing a baseline so I want to I want to acknowledge the work you're doing and the fact that we it we really set an impossible standard on that um and I also in terms of both ourselves and our staff and our and you know whoever's out watching in TV Land you know the spotlight data is given that
142it's really just a point in time it's a baseline it's concerning but it's concerning because it's topologically concerning because the reason why they're the reason why they're a spotlight student is by and large because in part because they're not on TR on track so um that data is bad and it should in a certain sense as a metric it should be bad because that's that's why we're spotlighting it so I want to make that clear to the public um and that hopefully next year we'll have an additional data point and instead of having to go back five years to create a narrative you can actually just go back to the previous year so in and in a way some of that earlier data is really just kind of make up making up for the fact
143that we have no trend line because we we only have one data point which is last year's partially implemented Spotlight students so I just want to make that clear in terms of the monitoring um so in a way there's not that much to say because it's one point in time um and I look forward to the updates being being very digging into to some hypothet some hypotheses about why we are or aren't succeeding um and then the other thing the last thing I'll say is about um or the second to last thing rather I want you know we had a lot lot of discussion about the alternative sequence but I do want to for everybody to highlight the three other things which are very large Parts they large parts of this this um plan the
144alternative diploma which is a which is a state requirement so thank you for finally you know putting doing the work to implement in a in a um in a in a reasonable and productive way this state requirement on the alternative diploma and I I get contacted by families who are concerned about this alternative diploma all the time so it's very important the other is on I think studies we I think we had to give a number of waivers this year because we didn't entirely land the plane on on getting the proper offerings on EIC studies so I appreciate the work on that and then on this a to G there are a lot of students in our schools that are actually taking a through G qualified courses but because we haven't we defined it so
145narrowly they're not getting a through G credit which is totally reasonable to be doing that um I I'll just say finally you know and certain elephant in the room is when you try to make an amendment anytime when I watch boards or or or councils or whatever trying to make Amendment floor like oh God here it goes It's always a bit of a highflying act um but but what I will say I even though it gives me a headache certainly as a chair and even as a board member when you try to make an emotion it's also reflective of the fact that you have board members that are very engaged they care about the subject they care about the details um and oftentimes when boards aren't engaged you never get you never get anybody trying
146to do the the highflying work to put an amendment from the Das um and so even though it's timec consuming and and uh you know there's a lot of back and forth and feelings and thoughts and ideas um I I appreciate this this the the board doing that work to try to try to land the plane on that so with that we do have an amended motion on the floor U Marty if you could I believe our general Council might want to weigh in as well yes thank you president Patterson um what I wanted to say was that we've had a long focus on the four bullet points that are in the presentation yeah which are the bases for the recommendation for the board policy but the staff recommendation was to approve the board policy
147itself and that fourth B bullet point is only addressed in one paragraph at the end of par of page two so what the motion should be is either to adopt the staff recommendation or as amended either take that paragraph out or leave it in and have staff come back with implementation plan for that that portion of the board policy does that make sense I see what you're saying yeah and I think that's what I initially said because I read the the paragraph so that's certainly my intent when I say fourth bullet I mean that one sentence at the very end of the exemption section so then the amended motion would be to approve the board policy and have staff come back with a plan to implement that particular paragraph Yes so to clear you are
148okay with moving forward that item there but just have an implementation return well I guess the thing I'm trying to understand when it comes back with more clarity with Equity guard rails constraints are we taking action on it or is it simply informational for me to be able to move forward I would want to uh know that we would take we would be asked to take action on the details around um more specifics um or if you want to call it an implementation plan um for that last sentence so whatever the language around amending or what your your your main concern is that when it returns in 60 days that it it has has a vote on it not just that it comes back as a report on it but it actually has an up
149down vote on yes that okay does that does that you understand that motion that we're that as as proposed we are moving forward with the whole of the item a as is but that there is in 60 days there will be a return we we will call it we can call it implementation or I heard a circular whatever it is whatever it is something that this a circular a circular will come back with an up down vote with an up down vote in 60 days so did the maker of the motion and the amendment agree that that is what you're wanting to vote on is that acceptable to the maker and the second come again that's not acceptable I guess I'm still confused so you what we're trying to do here is the motion that's
150on the table is not to include the fourth no the current motion is actually I think there's confusion okay okay correct me if I'm wrong Marty but as as described we have the motion is essentially the original motion however there in 60 days there will be a return with a circular for an up down up up down vote on the details in and for for the details but in particular on item four and item four being reflective of the paragraph the last sentence sure and I think the confusion is because um we focused on the four bullet points being the action item and they're not actually the action item the action item is to approve the board policy understood and so if um if there's not a desire to agree to an amended motion there
151could be one motion followed by a second motion to request that the plan come back for she yeah yeah the mic was off on that it shouldn't be off it's showing on is that better that's on now yeah okay it's I'm not very tall so um she was s suggesting that one possibility is to take a motion on a vote on the clean the clean motion the original motion and then take a second vote um to instruct staff to return with the circular on implementation is that correct yes or whatever format it would come back to lay out the manner in which those courseworks would be addressed and the way the alternative diploma would be developed okay we're going to okay we're going to start with a motion we're going to do two motions per
152Council suggestion the original motion is on the the the first motion and I will entertain a motion on the the vanilla motion the vanilla agenda item that originally came to us do I have a motion on that trusty Cruz we have a motion do I have a second okay vice president barera okay we are going to take a vote on this motion and then we're going to come back and I'm going to entertain a motion on the second which is the return with a circular for an updown vote in 60 days so with regard to this first motion student trustees please vote remaining trustees please vote that pass oh oh that's a 41 vote on that so you got that okay so we had a 4-1 vote on that and then on we will I
153will entertain a motion to return in 60 days with a circular uh do you understand do I have a motion trusty wers pay with the motion trusty haen with a second uh we've had a lot of discussion I will move to a vote student trustees please vote trustees please vote we have unanimous consent on that all right all right okay let's just resituate here we've uh We've entered into we've entered thank you so much we really appreciate it thank you we're in the back yeah you can clear out if the high hopefully the H Jinks are over but um thank you for coming tonight um we are now entering the back nine here with item F1 we will now conduct a public hearing on item F1 initial proposals from the San Diego Education Association to
154bargain a suc cessor agreement in accordance with Section 3547 of the California government code and section 1031 of board bylaws the public hearing is now open sorry about that sorry so very forceful gavl strike um Miss STL so there any speakers on this item there are none okay uh thank you the public hearing is now closed slightly lighter okay um so now we will consider items F2 through F5 collective bargaining Personnel matters and student discipline is there a motion on these items I have a motion from trustee Whitehurst Payne and a second from truste baso um M stz are there any speakers on these items none uh any thoughts from the trustees seeing none we will move to a vote um I believe this is uh full trustees okay um trustees please vote um trustees
155please vote we have unanimous consent for those items all right um motion passed unanimously uh we will now now move to items G1 and G2 this is the board consent uh calendar author authorization to excuse board member absences and approval of minutes consent items are considered to be routine and will be enacted by one motion followed by a vote there will be no separate discussion of these items unless the board member of the public or staff request spef specific items be removed from the consent agenda for separate discussion and action any agenda item removed will be voted upon following the motion to approve the consent agenda does the board have any items they would like to have pulled from the board consent agenda no items to be pulled Miss doz uh has anyone signed up
156for public comment on section g all right um is there a motion on items G1 and G2 uh trusty Hazen moved and a second from trusty baldis um student trustees please vote all other trustees please vote trusty Bur Vice all right that is unanimous consent the motion passes uh we will now con oh no that's good we're good nothing was pulled all right um wow wow we're now on to District operational matters very exciting part of this oh actually this is exciting um we will now hear item H1 Title 9 progress and Dr bagula would you like to introduce this report yes thank you Dr Patterson so today you're going to hear from our executive director of Investigations compliance and accountability also known as AA farad tby or as he is known to as Shaw
157who will present on our ongoing efforts to strengthen our Title 9 reporting process and respond to reports of sexual harassment civil rights violations and safety when I entered my Deputy superintendent role one of the first things I did was to hire two more people for the title 9 office which at the time was an office of one person person the new hires included a counselor to support victims and office staff to ensure timely responses since then we have continued to hire experts and develop a robust system of reporting and investigation it is now done by Title 9 trained attorneys and professional investigators all of this occurred before any of the controversies we have faced we were already strengthening and improving our practices and the work has continued I've been working directly with the PTA to
158develop parent role and an implementation plan so that we can continue to cultivate a culture that protects our students and staff from sexual harassment civil rights violations and to ensure their safety no student no person in our district should experience sexual harassment civil rights violations or fear for their safety that is what we strive for at San Diego unified and with that I will turn it over to Shaw thank you thank you all um I guess everybody wasn't here to see me but we'll uh we'll carry on so thank you for the opportunity um I'm going to try and keep it succinct but I don't get a lot of opportunities to brag about the work of our office so um so although this is focused on Title 9 I think um it's important to understand
159the evolution of our office the changes we've made as a district so in 2003 I joined the district as the executive director of the quality assurance office um my wife was actually a teacher she was looking at positions here and she said you should apply to this um and as a career prosecutor Deputy attorney general um specialized in human trafficking and child exploitation my response was what is quality assurance um but essentially quality assurance was created by uh former superintendent Cindy Martin um and it was a One-Stop shop where parents students Community could voice concerns beard my team would document that and ensure that every one of those was tracked and addressed usually by sites we also had a team of three internal investigators who did investigations into uh General employe misconduct and you know
160when we talk about the improvements I also want to highlight I inherited an exceptional team um I was fortunate where I got to build on basically uh the work of that office and um part of my discussion when I joined with um my boss general counsel Andre and District leaders ship was how can our office bring more value to the district and we talked about focusing more on compliance more serious misconduct Civil Rights sexual harassment and one of the things I immediately identified is that um there just wasn't that c centralized subject matter experts that dealt with um violations of policy and serious misconduct and and those are separate from law enforcement issues criminal issues and legal issues um so as we stated our goal is to create a system that promptly and effectively addresses
161concerns in compliance with District policies federal and state laws so one glaring issue that has uh brought some attention to the district is um our response to sexual harassment um we were found to be out of compliance between the years of 2017 to 2020 by the office of civil rights and before I get into specific changes and improvements what I want to emphasize is not only are we in full compliance with the regulations but we're building towards being a model of a title 9 office that all other districts around the country um can look at and that's not a goal that's an expectation for me and my team so aside from um the years I spent as a prosecutor and Deputy attorney general I also um was the tile n coordinator at the University of
162Hawaii for two years and so I knew coming in that title 9 is very technical Nuance burdensome um in terms of compliance with the regulations also involves very sensitive issues involving sexual abuse Dating Violence and other serious forms of sexual harassment so our title n office was essentially operating almost in a silo there's a lack of support lack of resources as we all know especially right now resources are not easy to come by so um what we decide to do is have the title 9 office come into the quality assurance office and join our team and eventually that evolve um into the office of Investigations compliance and accountability and what that did is it gave the title n officer the support of an entire team of professionals uh professional investigators and Specialists and we also
163started to add staff that's specialized in these areas of uh again sexual harassment sexual abuse and Regulatory Compliance um so Anna Ward um who's right here is our Title Nine officer she um she started in April 2024 her background ground um is in family law and she also headed uh the Mississippi State AG's anti-trafficking and child exploitation victim Services um we added two additional investigator positions to be able to uh take on these investigations and um the increase of cases uh Carlos Rodriguez retired law enforcement he's a national expert and child EXP exploitation Sarah MCU is a she was an investigator at the public defender office and handled serious cases like homicide we also converted the title n counselor position into an equity compliance cordinator Eric Rico um he has experience um with federal regulations
164in representing victims of domestic violence um so these changes again having this entire team um the change in process allows everyone of these sexual harassment reports to be evaluated investigated and resolved by our office and our trained team um we also follow best practices where um everyone on our team is tile n certified and um we follow trauma informed um approach to every case so here's our entire office um our manager Connie Perez has been with the office since it started team of investigative Specialists Eda Sylvia lazette Charmaine Raphael and then our internal investigator team Martha candy Carlos Janette and Sarah and again this supports Anna she has the resources and um experience expertise of everybody in the office when we're getting slammed with reports or uh heavy case loan so these are some numbers
165um and when James our new uh executive director of communications looked at it he said wow these numbers I don't know if it looks good um but to us this is actually immeasurable of success the 43 one reports those are actually reports from um supervisors site administrators we have a policy that requires all employees to report any form of sexual harassment so that could be something from you know an inappropriate joke to Serious sexual assault um so the changes and in the process and the things that we've implemented have increased the number of reports um this is just from the last year so 431 and what that allows us to do is every one of those cases then is evaluated by our title line officer or someone on our team every one of those cases
166the 385 that do not rise the level of a title 9 case a formal investigation we are still documenting we're following up up with the sites to ensur safety measures are in place supportive measures we're sometimes uh connecting directly with those students with the parents and then we're ensuring that those are addressed it could be addressed as you know a bullying other type of misconduct but we're recording that in our system and then also just in that time period we've handled 46 formal um Title 9 investigations and every one of those cases are handle from beginning to end by our um experience investigative team and that was something previously that that fell on sites to have to investigate that fell on human resources that fell on other supervisors so um it's in compliance with the
167regulations and it's also again best practice and supporting our students and staff so that initial work was really about um making sure our process was in place making sure we are addressing every one of these cases appropriately and um with the highest Professional Standards what we've shifted to now is supplementing that also with education and information so um we're doing a lot more in terms of Outreach proactive um proactive education I have I'll pass these out later but these are some title n Flyers that um we produce we're going to start um Distributing them you can pass them around too uh starting with the high schools and middle schools and I think this will help educate parents when these issues come up um about you know what the title 9 process is and also the
168resources and support that's available we're also updating District websites um each School we're going to make sure that the title 9 information the reporting information is linking directly back to our site uh we're updating our school Publications and then also partnering with Community organizations um and then also um superint superintendent mentioned um direct Outreach and coordination with students parents I met actually with the two student board members in their group and discuss some of this um we're also doing more awareness internal and external Communications when things come up updating uh and then we have a public awareness video that will show at the end of this presentation um and then just to hit on a few add additional highlights of um our office and our team and I think this is this is a very
169important um organizational structure that allows us to operate so our office is one of the few offices that does not report to the superintendent uh we report to general counsel and um Andre advises the board and being independent crucial to our role um ensures we can be fair and impartial if we find misconduct if we find violations doesn't matter your title doesn't matter who you're friends with doesn't matter what you do there's going to be accountability and even though I report to general counsel um I'm fortunate that she allows us to operate independently as well because there are um you know the nature of compliance in our cases sometimes conflicts with the interest of liability we could find misconduct by employees and that could lead us to liability but um we're allowed to operate where
170our findings are um independent and since I've been here I've never been asked pressured or influenced by anybody outside of our office to come to a certain determination or finding um and I think again that's a testament to our leadership the board not every district has an office like this and that goes to all of us being willing to hold ourselves accountable as well as each other um so we do continue to Pro provide that original service um from the quality assurance office in terms of being a resource for students parents in the community what we have taken on as well is employees can report um their complaints we noticed there wasn't necessarily you know a place to go at human resources and so um we started uh and we coordinate with human resources but
171we provide the intake documentation um before that's forward on and we're also becoming more of a resource for administrators um one of the the things we're doing as well with uh some of our new initiatives and task force which I'll touch on in a second is having um a support line directly for site administrators so um you know our office I see us as a subject matter experts when it comes to policies um and compliance issues we also um are training we should be uh also the support in terms of them investigating cas es um I'm not going to dive too much into this data um but I think what it does reflect is the fact that we provide a lot of oversight and accountability so the initial um numbers there of our online ethics
172Point Reporting System just since 2023 just so you understand the volume that my team um handles we've had over 3500 reports those are all assigned to an investigative specialist those are all documented um they're tracked until there is an outcome before they're closed all of our cases are closed or 98% 2% pending are ones um you know that are currently assigned so that was uh kind of part of the initial qao all the others we've essentially taken on as a we've Tak taking the responsibility of the oversight of the online bullying Reporting System um while we don't investigate those cases what we do is we monitor every report we um ensure that the schools are investigating and they're required per policy to provide an outcome report so that's a significant number um and any sites
173that don't we harass them until they do give us the outcome um probably not the best term of our in this context um we are diligent in terms of making sure that these are addressed um our employee misconduct we have shifted towards um only investigating the most serious types of cases so those that can result in serious discipline uh discrimination violations of civil rights um cases that may have you know federal state oversight uniform complaints um that's also that's under state law and uh Eric handles those as the equity compliance coordinator um we also took on student expulsion referrals so uh the goal of that and I think um some of our measurables are we hitting those marks where um we want more consistent Equitable outcomes and so I think the big number um with
174this is out of those 45 cases that we've been contacted and sites of um wanted to move forward with the expulsion 32 of those we've worked with them and said either they don't meet the policy or um there are opportunities for additional restorative practices and uh we try and connect them with um our equity and belonging office we also um a lot more of the tech technical type of regulatory complaints title 2 compliance and then we respond on behalf of the district to any um state or regulatory complaints so that can come from Office of civil rights um civil rights Department of State um California Department of Education but that that's been a big piece of our additional workload but what we've realized is again this is something that was falling on site administrators people
175without that background and um and it's something you know my team doesn't always love when we take on more work but I think we're the ones that should be doing the work and uh we have the experience to do it and the last piece even though we are independent um the collaboration and coordination with other departments is also um you know a big part of our work and and um you know one of the one of the examples is collaborating with um ebony who's the executive director of equity and belonging they go and do trainings about you know discrimination and how to implement practices that um aren't going to discriminate I can come in then with the enforcement hammer and say actually we have policies as well so there's going to be consequences um and
176then similar partnering with um Christine Morad the executive director of HR doing trainings for supervisors site administrators how to investigate how um to implement discipline so we have the accountability and then this is a recent task force we created to address kind of heightening concerns with the new Administration and um another great example of I think the collaboration of the different types of departments so uh we also include um our strategic communication and information director um again Human Resources school police thriving School communities and um these are the goals of our task force and some of the big issues right now is addressing the concerns about immigration enforcement and I think you know everybody uh here the board superintendent those are things we're trying to get ahead of and making sure everybody feels safe and
177uh welcome at our school so with that thank you um and then we do have the video short video to play it's part of our awareness and Outreach all right Q cu the [Music] video hello I'm Fab bagula I'm your proud superintendent for San Diego Unified School District I want everyone to understand and be clear that sexual harassment and sexual misconduct have no place in our schools I am committed to ensuring that your children come to school to experience the joy of learning and the friendships that are cultivated at schools one of the ways that we're addressing change and accountability in this area is to establish not only a department that oversees an investigates but Staffing this department with well credentialed people that are knowled experts around this field so we have leaders that understand
178Title 9 that understand the laws and have set up parameters onto how to investigate how to respond and also how to counsel victims the office of Investigations compliance and accountability we're essentially a centralized place that employees students parents Community can be heard with empathy can report any type of concern that can be anything involving employee misconduct violations of policy sexual discrimination and the easiest way to do that is through our website routed through the right process and procedures we take privacy confidentiality very seriously everybody who's either a witness or has experienced some type of misconduct they're telling their truth they shouldn't have to feel guilty about speaking up when there are complaints we have a direct hotline that receiv receives that phone call they are able to begin an investigation immediately if you become aware
179of any sexual harassment or misconduct against a student or a staff member please don't be a bystander please report it our district is on the right track we are committed to building a culture of accountability proactive prevention and an unwavering support for those who have been impacted this is our promise we will do better and we will not rest until every member of our community can thrive in a safe and supportive environment all right thank you sha um Miss St are there any speakers on this item all right do any of uh our trustees have any comments I see trustee we's [Music] pay I must say that I am delighted to have you all on board as a team and I speak as someone who spent 17 years in this District defending this District um
180with the attorneys um in fact I walk in the courthouse and they thought I was an attorney and that was never my desire to be an attorney so I can commend you all I um the way I defended it was to get in people's faces and investigate and whatever was necessary in terms of discipline and I still have people coming to me now saying thank you for um hearing me investigating but to me it was ridiculous that we had one person doing this the entire employee classified applicants anybody uh and so I was pushing for that and now we finally have a a real team on board of competent folks who know what you're doing and uh I'm just thankful I love your backgrounds U your experience your qualifications I think you're here to let
181people know that we're serious because when I did it was from 87 to to 04 and after then I don't know who did it or what happened um who who who took care of our our EEOC and DF and OCR and all of that but I think now we have a competent team and um it's unusual for school districts to have such a large competent team but it's necessary as I said earlier this is 2025 it is not 1905 or 1925 it's 2025 and we need help we need folks to realize we need the workshops we need what you're doing and as an individual I support you totally uh and hopefully this board as a collective we support you and if you ever have any problems let us know and we will be there that's
182my message you thank you trusty trusty Cruz thank you president Peterson um I had a question so on the equity civil rights and safety taskboard I noticed that there is a lack of uh student voice is it possible to add a student onto the task force so that's kind of just the chair members and the task force itself um were including area superintendent students um this is something that was just created and adopted with a resolution a couple weeks ago um there's just a sense of urgency with some of the issues but um so we're getting moving on it but I'll definitely take that to the team and we are you know again we're going to need your voice we're going to need your support at the site level so um we'll definitely be following
183up any initial comments trusty haen thank you and I Echo uh trusty WHUR pay's enthusiasm uh and excitement about this I just appreciate the significant work that's been done I think particularly over the last two years um to really make systematic and Trauma informed improvements to all of our work um that you oversee and particularly Title 9 I think centralizing this work um and ensuring the highest standards in everything we do is so critically important and ensuring that concerns about student safety and well-being are appropriately investigated and addressed whether these are title n issues or bullying issues or expulsion issues so thank you for overseeing all of it I hadn't seen um the student expulsion referral data um and it's really great to see um the difference that's been made in the last year with
184it coming um under your team's leadership I'm wondering in terms of um some of the data I know you said we're seeing an increased number of reports um which is a good thing because presumably those things were happening and not being reported previously um and I'm wondering how the current investigation rates and metrics that you shared um around oversight and accountability compareed to previous outcomes um I think it would be helpful to see multi-year data to the extent that we have it um to know how we're doing now I think we know better but how much better um compared to some of what I would say are probably subpar outcomes that were flagged by OCR so is it possible POs to have sort of year-over-year day data or to be able to compare yeah when
185we're putting this together that was part of the discussion I think the issue is um not necessarily an issue but a positive outcome like I mentioned is that the numbers are larger but that's good because of what we're doing right and I think most of the changes um come down to the procedure and the quality right and um so we can definitely provide numbers I think that's where it was hard I didn't want to just put there without the context but we can and it sort of I mean it hens back to our previous conversation even around some you know graduation related metrics we didn't maybe weren't tracking or doing similar things so I guess whatever you think would be appropriate for us moving forward to be able to see how we're doing to compared
186to how we were doing and how do we know that we're continuing to make progress and defer to you about the best ways for us to understand that and then just a small thing um that I think probably important so you mentioned um prioritizing distribution of this flyer and information on middle and high school campuses um and I would say if we can also include Elementary sites um just yesterday uh I heard about um and this was an old incident um about a year old um but of something that sounded like or similar to um sexual harassment on an elementary campus so I think let's make sure that students of all ages and families of students of all ages have access to this yeah I should have provided context we printed the first thousand that
187are going to start going out immediately at the high school and middle schools but we actually get um a lot of reports at the elementary school level because those are mostly students who um talk to their parents about these issues and the parents bring It Forward whereas we know a lot of these issues are under reported at the high school middle school level because um you know they're not um Consulting with their parents and things so it's definitely we'll get them printed we'll get them to every one of our schools and um it's kind of the start thank you trusty baldas I saw your hand up I just quickly want to say I just quickly want to say thank you all the work it sometimes goes overlooked but I feel like as a district we
188really vow to appreciate this and I think we can all say that we appreciate all the work that you do so thank you trusty bazo thank you president Pon and I'd like to Echo the voice of my fellow colleagues in saying that this is truly truly a step in the right direction and you know such an improvement from where we were and that will continue it looks like as well um I just had a question about you know I I always think that it's better to be proactive obviously than reactive so you talk about you talked about how we're doing training um with of the I believe for like the administrators but how like are we tracking that because I know you know this past summer um we talked when we were talking more about
189Title 9 one of the things was is it something on the area superintendent checklist to me to talk to their principles is it on the because some principles might you know it's they're busy they have a lot of stuff going on and if they don't have it somewhere on a list or something that they have to mention it they might you know it might get lost and you know um and it's not that they're not it's not important but you know it it it's has to filter down to everyone so that's I guess what my concern is trying to increase that awareness and make sure we have that there so that possibly we don't have as many of the complaints and I think in order to do that there should be some procedure process in
190place so we know that if the information is getting out to every school in the district and not only to the principal level but that that's then getting down to all the staff level and like how do we measure that or how do we determine if that's actually happening or not um so we do have a mandatory training for all employees um and I'm not going to use the term harassed again but I do make every effort to basically say give us a time and a place and we'll do a training we'll do it for a small group we'll do it for a site we've gone down and done a presentation to just one school's administrators um we've been invited to office hours with some of the area superintendent so virtually um there's some upcoming
191I think optional training AP Institute we did one um so yeah we're tracking that especially since we have to report some of that to OCR um but like I said the initial goal was getting our team our process is making sure that we're addressing these issues and now the big push is you know we don't just want the Baseline training right we want to supplement that with specialized training and so um yeah give us a place we'll show up we'll do the training but I do think um you know the numbers do reflect that the system and the way we set up the process um if you go on our reporting for employees like we outline it almost is a training for them as they fill out that form so we're finding as many ways
192as we can um we did a training for athletic directors cuz we're seeing issues right in sports trainings with our police and coordination our hro so that they can advise the sites as well so um we're definitely making a push we can track that and provide you all with updates on that too trusty Bas I did just want to comment on the online bullying reporting system I know I don't have much context on that but that number of 217 actionable reports received to me I feel like that sounds quite low I don't know if Joseph can talk to that but in my opinion I think that there are a lot more reports that aren't getting out so as well as we are prioritizing getting these pamphlets out I really think we should also focus on
193something for bullying because that is something a lot more pervasive on on campus I just want to ask Joseph do you feel that that number is low yes 100% well and I'll just say this is through the online buling system so a lot of reports that go directly aside administrators don't necessarily go through our system so again it's one of those things like that as a student if you don't feel comfortable coming forward we want to be able um you know to have you know that you have a place to go and report it and we'll follow up but yeah in terms of the numbers of bullying incidents and things that are reported and being addressed it's it's probably a lot higher but that's what's coming through our online system principl we we have not
194removed principles from their jobs of dealing with bullying because I mean on the playground running around I mean yes playgrounds for the little ones um but that's an ongoing process where they are dealing with bullying and counselors and so forth but I think what he's talking about is just the online portion where Joseph just pulled it up on the website that they can go in and do it externally okay trusty vice president Barrera thank you president peton sha I just want to again Echo everybody's comments uh thank you for this work and for um you know building uh what we hope is an exemplary um effort in in our district and I want to thank Andre uh green uh for recognizing the need to build this capacity uh and uh and really you know kind
195of pushing pushing this forward um so I'm interested in sort of when we say a a situation is resolved so some of the examples that the OCR report um talked about were let's say you had a situation where a a student harassed another student um and whatever the process of investigation that was done there might have been a yes that happened but for instance those students were you know left in the same classroom together there didn't seem to be any actual resolution and I wonder how your office then works with schools um you know in situations like that to actually recommend resolutions that we're going to make sure everybody is safe so again it it depends I I guess we can talk specifically on those those are the Title Nine specific um cases they were
196looking at um so for those depending on let's say there's a formal investigation if it's an allegation of sexual assault then that would result in an mandatory expulsion um for cases um where is a finding of General title n sexual harassment our restorative discipline policy that's not expellable so what we do sometimes is alternative placements also with students um we call those the supportive measures so every one of the cases every one of those um 400 I forget I don't have the number um whether or not they rise to to formal title 99 we're still working with the site to say you know safety measure needs to be no contact if we can separate move them to a different class sometimes it is and and some of it too um we can do informal resolutions
197and um so some of those situations might be to move the student to a different school to ensure safety um but yeah I think not only are we making sure that's being done but we're documenting in every one of those cases so we do work with the schools there's certain limitations obviously with student placement um and then restorative discipline but we're tracking that yeah all right sh it's been a long night um I'll just say um you know what I really appreciate most about this is 99% of the concerns I get from I I must get 10 10 a week emails or whatever 99% are ultimately when you peel it back process concerns very few people are are reaching out to complain about outcomes and when when you when they are it really is because
198what they're really identifying is that the process wasn't fair and I I just I try to keep out of courtrooms but I just wrapped up a divorce and people say how' it turn out I don't even remember really how it turned out what I remember is the first time I was in front of a judge and I realized this person is here to make it fair fair and really at that point you have much less concerned about the outcome because you believe that the process is fair and that the people at that table are there to to um address your concerns in a way that's rational reasonable um Equitable and just and so I just really want to thank you and your team and it kind of chokes me up because it's there's a lot
199of people I mean especially when I first got on here before you you came on there were a lot of people who had really profound concerns about the process and I really wasn't confident to be able to tell them to to for from my own conscious say this this is a good we have a good process and I see your team I see you leading the team I see Andre committed to it and I think I I can speak for the whole board and I I am very grateful that you've established a process that our families and our children can trust thank you you're free to go my my friend congratulations you made it through I think everyone's free to go right or you guys have we have non agenda well actually we have a
200couple more ad here but we'll sail through I think thanks for bearing with us and thank you sha um we now have um yeah we will now consider items H2 and H3 revisions to annual resolutions and approval of preliminary Proposition 39 offers to charter schools for the 2025 2026 school year is there a motion on items H2 and H3 uh I guess truste Wurst Payne and vice president bre with a second um do we have any speakers on this item okay thank the gods and uh does the board do my fellow board members have any comments on this these items okay seeing no further comment we will move to uh a vote student trustees please vote uh remaining board members please vote that is unanimous consent on the item okay we will now consider items
201uh i1 through i27 the superintendent's consent agenda consent items are considered to be routine and will be enacted by one motion followed by a vote there will be no separate discussion of these items unless the board member the public or staff request specific items be removed from the consent agenda for separate discussion and action any agenda item removed will be voted upon following the motion to approve the consent agenda does the board have any items they would like to have pulled pulled from the consent agenda seeing none um we will will um uh we will move for uh disc to discussion are there I'm Sorry Miss stall has anyone signed up for public comments no okay um Dr Pula would you like to um would you like to say anything as a preliminary uh sure
202there's an item uh i22 that's tied directly to our guardrail for student motivation it's in agreement with the media arts center of San Diego which will provide workshops for our Educators at a few of our schools on technology and skills as it relates to media arts and professional development in media arts so students will then learn media arts for self- expression communication and social social change this partnership will allow students the opportunity to enter their work into scholarship film and Festival Awards with no fees thank you thank you Dr beula um do I have a motion on uh the agenda um thank you very much trusty baldis with a motion and trusty baso with a second [Music] um okay we've got a motion in a second um and we everything has remained on consent so
203we will have no further discussion with the board um student trustees please vote all other trustees please vote that is unanimous consent with students concurring okay oh here we go the moment many of you have been waiting for um we will now receive public testimony on non agend items Miss stz have we received any requests for non agenda comment yes we have one virtual speaker and we have 10 in-person speakers so we'll go with our virtual speaker first uh Ivonne Payne if Ivon is available you have two minutes hello um hi can you hear me yes oh hi uh good evening I'm Ivon Payne I'm a veteran and educator and a parent of a TK student at M Ranch Elementary I'm I'm here tonight to express my concerns about the direction the school Community is
204heading in particularly in light of the proposed Spanish dual immersion program I don't take this decision rightly as a middleclass black woman I feel compelled to speak out because I believe my perspective might resonate with others who share similar concerns or who might not fully understand the impact of the situation when my family first moved to scrips Branch I was excited my excitement quickly turned to uncertainty and disappointment as I encountered unexpected and troubling resistance at the parent information meeting I attended in September I heard a comment that I cannot forget if the program starts children won't be welcome at the school as a black mother and an educator I was stunned whose children were they referring to this kind of rhetoric felt exclusionary and frankly while the though it had undercurrents of prejudice it
205forced me to deeply consider whether M had a welcoming School community and to be honest I'm still wrestling with that unfortunately that was just the beginning I've witnessed parents some in positions of power on the FFA and the Sgt bulying administrator intentionally dominating me meetings meant to inform families and pressuring others to oppose the program additionally I found out that this process has been delayed since its initiation it's been about 2 years as a newer parent to the school Community the overall atmosphere to me quickly became one of intimidation an environment where respectful dialogue seemed impossible as a parent I cannot ignore the reality that these vocal individuals do hold a significant influence in the school whether or not the Dual ersion program starts next year if this is how things are handled how can
206I be confident that my child and others will feel truly welcomed in safe here I was not expecting such a strong negative outcry and below the belt tactics for a new language program within the San Diego Unified School District especially as there's a need for the program in the northern section of the district and also as a black mother I worry about the additional weight my child may carry being even more othered in a community where we already stand out I cannot remain silent when I see the potential for my child or any child to feel excluded I am deep ly disappointed by the reaction of some members of the community some parents have stated that they'll no longer contribute to the school if the program starts which you know is their preference or discuss
207their fears about more quote unquote Choice families coming to M overall it's disheartening to see that the focus has shifted away from what's best for students your time has expired P oh okay thank you in person Jennifer nanini followed by Leanne samic you have two minutes okay hi my name is Jennifer nanini and I am honored to serve as the chair of the newly established exemplary teacher advisory committee here in San Diego unified this committee composed of both current and past teachers of the year was formed to bridge the gap between Educators and District leadership fostering a collect a collaborative environment where teachers feel supportive and empowered our goal is to create a space space where teachers can connect share best practices and advocate for the resources and strategies that will best serve our students
208across the district in our initial meetings it became clear that one of the key areas where our committee sees potential for growth and impact is in the implementation and expansion of restorative justice practices teachers at every grade level from utk to high school have shared compelling feedback on the positive effects these practices have had on both student behavior and overall School climate we are excited to present our work and to continue fostering meaningful change across San Diego unified we believe our Collective experiences and perspective will serve as an invaluable resource to help shape districtwide initiatives that will not only benefit our Educators but also strengthen our community and student outcomes thank you for the opportunity to introduce myself and our committee I look forward to collaborating with you all in the upcoming months to bring
209initiative teacher-driven solutions to this District good evening Dr bagula and trustees my name is Leanne samk and I'm a member of the EAC committee and teacher at Fulton I would like to speak to the continuation of funding for the restorative Community lead positions under the restorative justice department this two-year Staffing increase ac across the district allowed for an increase in forming and utilizing site restorative discipline plans an increase in student attendance and an increase in positive student in staff interactions and relationships restorative Community lead positions are still in the developmental stages we recommend more time to implement RCL roles and responsibilities as it relates to restorative site discipline plans San Diego unified's Vision 2030 and the district's local control accountability plan site restorative discipline plans are in their infancy 48 to 50% of schools allocated
210in RCL have Resort of site discipline plans or are in the process of creating one through leadership teams with however there's still work to do to ensure tier one and tier 2 behavior supports are in place in all classrooms rcl's alongside site leadership and administration will assist in the implementation and development of these restorative site discipline policies San Diego Vision 2030 strategically aligns with restored practices diving deep into the learner profile of collaborative communicators and emotionally intelligent thinkers San Diego unified has aligned these profiles and values in support of proactive restored practices we celebrate the board's adop option of the elcap goal number one strengthening social emotional development we know that fostering students social emotional development leads to the decrease in level one behaviors and escalating behaviors ultimately resulting in a lower suspension rate the
211likelihood of achieving the elcap goal increases when F when facilitated by the use of RCL leads the district is dedicated to fostering safe stable nurturing and welcoming environments for all students RCL leaders and restorative practices are at the heart of these values thank you for your time okay Renee Thomas followed by Tom Courtney good evening my name is Renee Thomas and I'm also a member of the exemplary teacher advisory committee and a teacher and restorative Community lead at marsten Middle School while we're very aware of San Diego unified's budget shortfall we continue to advocate for prioritizing the existence of the rjp department and the restorative Community lead positions restorative justice practices we know aligns with San Diego unified's Vision 2030 and is essential component to achieving our goals around student wellness and Equity we've personally
212seen evidence that these two factors can also translate to better academic outcomes I would like to read a few statements from students who share their experience of being in a restor restorative classroom versus a non-restorative one it provides evidence on how of how building relationships a sense of safety persevering through difficulties and taking risks has impacted them and is guiding them to become collaborative communicators emotionally intelligent thinkers and problemsolving innovators as indicated in a learner profile student one says being a part of a restorative classroom has boosted my confidence a lot my teacher really prioritizes students feeling comfortable in our classroom usually I don't raise my hand in any classes but this class with how my teacher discourages any put downs and has proven in the past that it's okay to be wrong I found
213myself raising my hand and gaining more conf confidence to engage in conversations because of my teachers reassurance student two being a part of a restorative classroom makes me feel like I belong here it feels like a community I feel like when I enter this class it's different I feel World respected and it makes me want to be a better me NE says one thing I like is how my teacher deals with conflict I like that she gives us privacy when we're in a vulnerable state in my teachers class I feel more open to ask questions which helps me with my thinking and makes me more engaged in my learning while in other classes I feel more hesitant I feel like I'm in a safe and loving classroom environment with my teacher and my classmates with
214high fives clapping and encouraging each other in everything shall I stop okay hi it's been a long night and I'll keep this brief my name is Tom Courtney proud proud teacher at Millennial Tech Middle it was referred to earlier we're making changes at Millennial Tech I'm proud to be a part of that change it became clear when you get a room of 18 teachers together to talk about what the one thing is we really want to see change it became clear in all of us very very early on that restorative justice practices above everything else was the one thing that we wanted to see pursued and extended in 2022 I served proudly for the California Department of Education I was one of two only teachers on that committee to refresh the California standards for the
215teaching profession in the fall of 2025 this year those California standard teaching professions will become the new job description for all of the teachers in the state of California as well as all of the teachers that you have in sendu unified and I can safely say the restorative justice practices fulfills the commitment of the work that I and the members of that committee did for all of our students thank you so much for your support and for hearing us tonight we would look forward to sharing more with you in the future we appreciate you Valerie Trina hi it's me again Valerie tra resident of District e and volunteer with the 501c3 nonprofit organization defense of democracy I'm alarmed by the recent reversal of the 2011 policy that now allows ice officers to make arrests at
216schools schools should be a safe space for students teachers families and visitors this is a direct violation of article 26 of the United Nations Declaration of Human Rights rights and it will have a devastating consequence for immigrant families and their children and all kids at school who find themselves suddenly exposed to raids and arrests of their friends while in the classroom I've read newspaper articles about how San Diego unified doesn't volunteer students immigration status to Federal authorities however the writers share that if ice has a warrant in hand to search for immigrant students the district will comply is that correct how will you protect immigrant children if teachers and administrators intend to comply with Federal warrants have faculty and staff been trained on how to avoid compliance with these directives can you reassure me and
217my group that students are truly able to feel safe attending school schools in our communities thank you Caitlyn willly hi um I'm Kate willly and this evening I'm speaking on behalf of my 8-year-old child uh who is part of the queer community and has been a member of the of our elementary schools rainbow group for the past 3 years our daughter experiences social anxiety making it challenging for her to form and maintain friendships the rainbow group at her school has been a Lifeline for her a consistent inclusive space where she is connected with peers who accept and support her through this group she has enjoyed positive social interactions and often comes home with art projects she's created as parents we are deeply thankful for a space where she feels supported accepted and free to be
218her authentic self the rainbow group group has been has had a profound impact on her well-being and we sincerely hope the district continues to recognize and prioritize the importance of these spaces for career students thank you topaz Johnson Arlene newarth good evening as I've added the board to multiple emails at this point I'm going to skip the particulars of my situation except to state that I am currently on short-term disability for my mental health The Tipping Point for me having been my principal most recently trying to force me back into a special education position at the elementary level as the Union's demonstration tonight was on the lack of sped teachers and support for students with disabilities I want to address some of of the issues with teaching special education that I personally have encountered having
219worked my first year in sped at an elementary school and the next two at a high school there's a vast disparity in workload and supports between special education teachers at different levels high school special education teachers have daily prep time and did have a clear focus on academics when I was there though that is no longer the case in contrast Elementary special education teachers frequently juggle more demanding scheduling requirements more diverse needs behaviors more onus of responsibility for failing students and fewer resources this imbalance guarantees that sped Staffing will never be adequate at the elementary level as the supports are insufficient to meet the needs of teachers and subsequently the students currently to deal with lowering enrollment at the district cut mild mod sped teachers at the high school I was at while support hours
220are still technically meeting the letter of the law because Spud teachers are specifically instructed to write Sport hours for only half a classes teaching hours the district is failing to meet the intent of the law to provide students with disabilities the consistent adequate support they need to succeed that is for the classes that have support at all the counselors are not allowed to channel sped students into the same classes and occasionally special education students end up in classes with zero help many of these students cannot complete the work even with daily in-class support so how does the district justify offering that support sporadically this inconsistent model undermines learning and also robs students with disabilities of the Equitable education they are entitled to I will be sending the rest of my email Ida list Christen Schwarz
221and Miles timson good evening good evening members of the board uh Shaina Richard Cody uh Sharon and Sabrina miles timson math teacher please don't interrupt my satire this time I brought a toy transource Rex one take a moment to acknowledge the T-Rexes this all used to be Dinosaur Land want to speak about the district standards line math curriculum I do believe that the district is in legal compliance with the Williams Act we do provide a standards line math curriculum to all students in the district that that said I think there's a lot of room for improvement in both the standards and the curriculum the data shows that the Common Core math standards have not been good for our students personally I think we need to revise the math standards but I know there are some
222people in this room that are fans of Common Core math and whether you like it or not the Common Core math standards are the current standards so changing the standards is a conversation for another day operating within the current standards the curriculum we provide is aligned I'll just say I wish it was better aligned leave it at that I know the district recently adopted a goal to improve test scores in math I think that's great I hope I support that goal the way it's written if scores improve every year for six years students will be below grade level just less below grade level than they currently are I hope the district stays accountable to that goal if the goal is met and scores go from terrible up to bad I hope that the math leadership
223team is appropriately commended and if the goal is not met and scores remain terrible I would see that as evidence that we need new math leadership new math curriculum or both Marty I'm concerned with your ability to do your job some of your notes have errors you've directly misquoted me and are inconsistent with the time you might want to consider the serup the rest of you thank you for your time that concludes public comment I want to thank everyone for attending tonight uh thank you for your input uh and uh thank you uh super inent bagula for attending remotely I know it's kind of a drag but we appreciate you being here with us uh and um I think after a long grueling night I am about to adjourn this meeting this meeting is now
224adjourned um a special budget Workshop will be held on February 4th 2025 the next regular meeting will be held on February 11th 2025 thank you so much e e e