001welcome everyone watching on ITV and Via live stream and call the December 17th 2024 special meeting of the Board of Education to order with all board members except trusty baso present please join me uh for the Pledge of Allegiance please stand I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all please be seated we'll now move to item B1 adoption of the agenda tonight we'll consider a variety of items including the ratification of a memorandum of understanding with San Diego Education Association for a supplemental early retirement program a public hearing on Health Sciences high and Middle Charter petition renewal our 2025 state and federal advocacy priorities formation of a student outcomes Focus governance task
002force extension of the interim superintendent contract and election of the 2025 board President and Vice President is there a motion to adopt today's agenda as published with item E1 annual organization of the Board of Education election of president and vice president to be heard at the end of all agenda's business and item E2 Health Sciences high and Middle School charter renewal public hearing to be heard first thank you we have a motion and a second from trusty whitear Payne students please go ahead and vote thank you and all other trustees please vote the motion passes unanimously with student board members concurring Miss sultz can you please provide information for public speakers about today's meeting protocols yes today's meeting of the board of education is a business meeting that is conducted in public and board members
003will not engage in a dialogue with members of the audience board bylaw 1025 sets the time limit for public comment on agenda items at 10 minutes per side pro and con or 20 minutes total speakers will be able to provide testimony at the beginning of the appropriate agenda item or at the end of the meeting for non-agenda comment please listen for your name to be called speakers are listed and called in the order received when your name is called please come to the podium to speak speak speakers participating via Zoom will be asked to unmute when their name is called if you are unable to unmute yourself we will call the next speaker please follow along with the agenda so that you know when your item is coming up for discussion when you begin speaking
004the green light below my name on the dis indicates that the timer has started when the light turns yellow you will have one minute remaining a buzzer will indicate that your time has expired if you have not yet done so and would like to sign up for in-person public cont iPads are available in the back of the auditorium and in the lobby thank you under E2 will now conduct a public hearing on the Health Sciences high and middle college Charter petition renewal I'd like to ask deer Walsh director of the Charter School's office to come to the dis and provide information on the item hi good afternoon um tonight's item is for Health Sciences high and middle college the public hearing on their renewal the school is Seeking a renewal of its Charter for a
0055-year term beginning July 1 2025 and ending June 30 of 2030 um in the documents we've provided table one is a summary of the charter petition and the renewals the school currently serves grades 9 through 12 at a district site located at 3910 University Avenue and also operates an independent study program at a site on elone Boulevard we've included an overview of the school's academic results for the cast assessments uh We've included the um enrollment for their 2324 school year is summarized in table three so you can get a sense of where students would have otherwise attended we do note that approximately 16.8% of the enrollment is from outof District students table four summarizes the projected enrollment for the next Charter term uh table five summarizes their current board roster and we also note that
006their is a student board member on the Health Sciences high and middle college board and District staff is reviewing the charter renewal documents submitted by the school and will bring forward a recommendation to Grant or deny the renewal of the charter at a subsequent date thank you thank you we will now take up to 10 minutes of public comment on this item Miss STL would you like to call speakers on E2 yes we have five speakers ERS so each speaker would have two minutes the first speaker is Doug fiser followed by Dominique Smith good evening members of the board superintendent Miss Donovan miss doltz my name is Greg ainger it's my privilege to speak on in support of Health Sciences high and middle college as your previous Chief business official I gained understanding into what
007the board and superintendent expect of schools including Charter Schools as a consultant for hsmc I've had unique insights into the inner workings of the organization and I can say objectively uh the school is in strong fiscal standing the financial policies and procedures uh are outstanding the professional development investment is significant I can also tell you that their alignment between between program school programs and operations and finances uh are aligned and student focused I can say being on campus it is a warm welcoming inclusive environment and I would urge you to um consider the longest possible renewal for this organization it's a great place for kids to learn and staff to grow and I will turn it over to my colleague uh Dr Doug Fisher hi Doug Fisher I'll give you a little bit on the
008uh dashboard data and the verified data uh in 2024 the average incoming n9th grader at health science is high read at the fourth grade level 76% of incoming nth graders perform three or more years below grade level in mathematics upon arrival at our school we are a trajectory changing school we average 1.3 to 1.6 years of growth per year with us more than doubling their historical average of achievement previously to joining Health Sciences they averaged about a half a year of learning for every year of school we accelerate that to 1.3 to 1.6 we have a 98% graduation rate earning blue on the dashboard our English learner progress is 47% earning green on the dashboard our College and Career indicator is 90% prepared earning blue on the dashboard in 2023 we failed to test 95%
009of our students the first time in the school's history we did not test enough students for a variety of reasons and though we had loss scores on our dashboard which is the data you see in terms of verified data our I math scores have 75% meeting their growth Target for the year M uh ranking US effective same with English language arts we are at 71% of the students meet their growth Target on IR in terms of verified data as well our College admission rates attendance rates are 63% exactly the state average our College persistent rate however is 80% % well above the state and national average our students go to college and stay thank you good evening everyone my name is Susanna Heist stanovich I am a Health Sciences graduate I'm also a first uh
010college graduate I went to UC Santa Barbara for my bachelor's in sociology Spanish and applied psychology and I did my MERS at Cal State Long Beach For Speech Pathology I am a proud speech language pathologist here at San Diego unified um during my time at Health Sciences I got the opportunity to participate in various internships such as the emergency department sharp re Ste mental health unit and um the San Diego Youth Foster Care Program as well um it opened my eyes to all of the different oper careers that I could potentially have I also graduated with 18 transferable College units so my freshman year at Santa Barbara I was over a quarter um complete with classes which allowed me to really is into ease into the college experience um and um my memories at Health
011Sciences have been creating really great relationships with a lot of the staff members even to this day I can call them up if I need support with anything if I need help or if I just want to catch up and it truly is such a welcoming and a very fostering environment for growth for students so I do appreciate Sano unified support um for my alma moer Health Sciences hello and good evening uh my name is Antonio Torres or Tony I'm a seni current senior at Health Sciences and I'm proud to represent our students uh Scholars or sorry students teachers and parents today let's go serpents I'm proud to announce that I was chosen to receive uh the N or sorry the questbridge National College match scholarship valued at $350,000 to attend emmer University my aspirations
012are to become a microbiologist specializing in bacteriology research to one day fight antibiotic resistant bacteria this school has given me many opportunities to achieve my educational aspirations especially through earning college credits where I will be graduating with two general Associates degrees at the end of my high school career I have also had the opportunity to participate in our Clinical Laboratory experience uh at our at a local Sharp Hospital I would like to thank our teachers and staff for not only fostering a extremely academically rigorous environment but for helping and supporting students emotionally and physically making us all feel belonging thank you very much good afternoon ladies and gentlemen of the board my name is Ruben Callis I'm 21 years old and I graduated from health science high in 2021 I'm honored to represent the Health
013Sciences students teachers and parents here today I'm also very proud to represent the San Diego fire department which has been a goal I've been working towards since my freshman year when I was introduced to the Fire Technology Program I'm now a probationary firefighter with five months of experience and I'd like to thank you uh say thank you to this school thank you to Captain Swift for helping me complete my dream and this school has given me many opportunities to Foster my aspirations as achieving a reev spected and rounded profession I wouldn't be able to stand here in front of you today without this school the support and guidance from the instructors and the life lessons I developed as a result I hope to inspire students who choose the same path and be a good model
014to even those who don't thank you for your time and attention hello board my name is Dominique Smith and I'm the proud principal of Health Sciences High middle college and I stand here in Partnership today with our lead of our parent committee Liz Menace and as you've heard from our alumni a current student and you're going to hear from a parent you're going to hear that health science is lives for one reason it's for our students and what we look at is to be a community school and what we try to do is bring the community to you and so when we look at that I'm hoping that you can see something that we're striving to be making sure that we're fostering relationships with students and living and creating aspirations for whatever they want I'm
015hoping you see tonight students in their gear and saying this is where I want to go as we look at this and where we're trying to go you've heard some really awesome things the other thing that we'd want to Spotlight is last year we had a really great moment with our CNA program and our College uh program we are able to offer or not offer but we are able to have two students get direct adits into San Diego State's nursing program a thousand applicants 100 get selected and two of them were ours as we leave today we're going to do the same thing we always do we're going to strive to be the best we're going to work really hard to figure out aspirations and want to work with every student especially students in inner
016city to figure out what their aspirations are we hope you hear us we hope you visit us you're helping us build a really nice building uh there's a nice remodel going there so we need some construction hats uh but we appreciate you and I want to give the floor to Liz hi my name is Liz jenez um and I just want to say that this school offers so much for our children it has offered opportunities for my kids to excel in school to find their I guess themselves as a person they're both in the fire science program all the staff is amazing they have great support I really can't imagine how much much harder it would be you know maintaining the kids focused and all without all the support we have behind me um so
017please reconsider you know just let us keep the school renew us please thank you thank you all very much do any trustees have questions or wish to discuss this item that trusty white her pay to everyone who came and spoke I have one question if you can answer this in seconds that's the vision that we have for all of our schools so what is the secret sauce that makes it happen at your school the secret sauces the adults that are in this building the vision that we continue and the kids that help us live up to that vision the secret sauce is right here we know it's there we got a little piece of the sauce and we're just trying to make the sauce a little bit [Applause] bigger anyone else vice president peton first
018of all that was a in terms of organizing people you organized a very good speaker panel so I I'm always we're always paying attention to how people put their panels together you did very well um and uh I hope staff is always paying attention to these successes and figuring out per the 1992 enabling legislation that we're actually learning from each other and so we're up here paying attention and I'm sure the staff is doing the same so thanks for showing up tonight yes I I agree appreciated uh all the feedback you shared about the great experience your students families uh and educators are having and having visited the school I've seen it myself uh and I do think their opportunity is for us to learn uh together um about your secret sauce and how we
019can replicate it for more kids at more schools so thank you all for coming and sharing with us today all right I think those are all of our comments this item will be brought back to the board for Action at a later date and our public hearing is now closed than thank you all right we will now consider items C1 through C3 collective bargaining and Personnel matters is there a motion on these items thank you I have a motion from trusty white Hurst pay and a second from board member balis are there any speakers on section c okay any questions or discussion from trustees all right uh let's go ahead uh and just trustees please vote thank you the motion passes oh oh oh Richard all right we're gonna all vote one more time okay
020trusty please vote third time's the is that accurate I shifted yeah I'm soet all right we're gonna vote again for the third time okay everybody all right please vote everyone all right okay we we got it we got it all right the motion passes unanimously we'll now consider board consent agenda items D1 and D2 resolutions affirming the values of the San Diego Unified School District as a welcoming district for all students and a resolution recognizing Middle Eastern or North African Mina as a distinct demographic group Dr beula I believe you have remarks on these resolutions thank you president Hazen first I want to express my gratitude to trustee Peterson Pon and trusty Hazen for championing this resolution and working closely with our team to ensure that we can implement it effectively your leadership and dedication
021to addressing this critical issue are deeply appreciated as you know I've always believed in the power of data to drive meaningful change when we collect data we gain the ability to truly see hear and understand our students without it their stories and needs can go unnoticed and we miss opportunities to support them this is why adding a middle eastern or Northern African category is so important it is not just about statistics it's about ensuring every student feels represented and valued and it's about equipping us with the tools to provide the interventions resources and supports that they deserve by taking this step we align with the recent revision from the Federal Office of Management and budget which includes the addition of Middle Middle Eastern or Northern African Armenia category and this is our guide on how
022we develop this category we will continue to follow up with the State Department of Education and engage with our elected officials to ensure alignment at the state level as well I also want to extend my heartful thanks to our arab-american community for bringing this issue to the Forefront during our community advisory meeting earlier this month your voices Have Been instrumental in shaping this conversation and your advocacy reminds us of why this work matters this is how we create real change by paying attention to data by lifting up the voices of every child and by committing to see them and serve them all together we're building a district where every student is seen every voice is heard and every need is met so thank you for inspiring us to keep striving toward that goal and I'll
023turn back over to president Hazen thank you and here here to everything you shared is there a motion on D1 and D2 thank you we have a motion is there a second there was a question about uh inserting judicial warrant I see let's get a second and then I'll take the question so I think we have a second from vice president Pon who was the motion oh the motion was trusty Barrera yes all right and then we'll take speakers and then questions okay we do have a number of speakers on items D1 and D2 I'm going to call uh those speakers together in a group each speaker will have three minutes the first one is Yasmin bosen is Yas me here thank you president haen vice president Peterson board trust white her pain did I
024say it right Sharon I hope so vasel Bara and superintend superintendent vula on be on behalf of Latinos and Latinas in action and our community based on city highs I want to thank you for being as a forward this resolution it means a lot to our community the reaffirmation of District values to stand by students family and staff there are no words to express our gratitude gratitude for stepping up and standing by human rights and human values thank you thank you thank you so much it's very well appreciated thank you thank you the next speaker is Linda Williams Oh and actually uh uh superintendent Pula didn't complete her comments so we're going to go back finish comments and then oh she didn't realize that it was both resolutions oh I'm sorry sure I apologize and
025this is too important um so I appreciate I appreciate the comeback um and I've been thinking a lot about this um this entire time so thank you for for this um so it's both an honor and profound responsibility to speak to you as we navigate a world that feels increasingly uncertain while National and Global events May challenge our sense of stability here in in our schools we remain steadfast in one essential truth every student regardless of how they identify or where they come from deserves to feel safe supported and inspired to thrive today I reaffirm our District's commitment as a welcoming District a place where students experience belonging joy and Limitless possibility our responsibility as Educators extends Beyond academics We Are The Architects of environments where young people can dream and boldly learn boldly and
026learn authentically this resolution underscores this commitment it's not just a policy but it's a promise it declares that discrimination harassment and bias-based harm have no place in our buildings Beyond prohibiting harm we pledge to cultivate spaces where every student experiences the profound Joy of being seen heard and celebrated teaching involves a myriad of daily decisions every choice we make from the books we include in our curriculum to the stories we amplify teaches our students what we value so we choose to reflect their diverse identities celebrate historically underrepresented voices and confront Injustice with courage and compassion this is not easy work the political landscape around us may shift and debates about identity and Equity May intensify but here in our schools we stand as a collective Force for justice and love we recognize that students bring
027their whole selves into our classrooms their cultures their dreams their fears and we have to meet them with unwavering care to our Educators and staff you are at the heart of this work every lesson you plan every conversation you hold every decision you make shapes the lives of our students we know this can feel overwhelming especially when societal pressures seep into our classrooms but know this your dedication changes lives and your colleagues at central office are here to support and stand by you to our students you are powerful you belong here your voice your perspective your identity enriches our community we see you we believe in you we will stand by you and to our families and Community Partners we need you this work cannot happen in isolation together we can create a district where
028every student is not only safe but is celebrated and uplifted let us hold the complexity of our world with Grace while keeping our vision clear a school system where every child experiences Joy belonging and possibility and let us remember that our duty is not only to react in the moment but to help design the future as Educators we're Builders of hope we must be relentless in ensuring that each child walks into our schools feeling loved and knowing that they matter and believing that they can achieve anything so this is our shared calling today tomorrow and always and I want to add um that today I was talking to a reporter who was asking a lot about this resolution and what I said was you can hold both you you can hold a need for having
029some sort of radical immigration reform but you also need to hold the safety of each student that enters our buildings and so that's really the when you sign on to a contract to work for San Diego unified when you're a teacher in California my hope is that you know that you're responsible for the health and well-being of every child and that's where we stand so thank you and I'm sorry about um no need to apologize and just for clarity so first of all thank you for for those remarks and support of uh now both of these resolutions and for clarity uh we are taking speakers on items D1 and D2 which are the two resolutions affirming the values of San Diego unified as a welcoming district and also our resolution recognizing Middle Eastern or North
030African as a distinct demographic group all right now Linda Williams thank you yes uh my name is Lenny K Williams and Dr bagula thank you I would like to underscore and put stars by so many of your statements thank you and to the esteemed board I appreciate bringing forth the D1 and the D2 uh I think it is absolutely wonderful that you are calling out the recognition of um campaign promises shall we say that can cause fear concern concern confusion sadness anger or anxiety in staff students and their families and this message to me says we hear you we see you and we want to address this and walk with you and support you and I was also thrilled to see the part about advocating at the state and federal levels to support what you're
031talking about in all of the above this is exciting this is wonderful and boy what a change from decades ago which many of you won't remember when principles were told to assist ice so moving on to D2 um I great appreciation for the ways in which this honors the um resolution from April of 2024 and also the ways in which it is taking another step forward to promise the support and the commitment to students whose voices are not currently being heard who students who are scared students who have been bullied and I am taking this as an additional promise that their needs will be met with very uh vigorous and ongoing efforts I would like to make a slight suggestion that in the future after of course unanimously approving this tonight that uh it perhaps
032be considered that instead of mina we go for the non-colonial term which is the um wsa Southwest Asia instead of Middle Eastern that is the non-colonial term just as we no longer say Oriental we say Asian so thank you and much appreciation for both of these resolutions thank you Remy Corona farita erat hi everyone my name is f de Erica I work at the Majel Arab Community Center of San Diego we're a resource and Community Center for the arabic speaking population in San Diego but predominantly elone where there's a lot of newcomers um regardless I also graduated from San Diego unified a long time ago um but having grown up in this District I can affirm and celebrate and be very excited about the implementation of a Mina category um I can personally attest to
033how much we believe this will make an impact for our students um there were students who wanted to come tonight but couldn't because of finals um so they're studying hard but we all as a community are just very excited about this opportunity and are hopeful that you all will continue to collaborate with Community Partners such as ourselves and others in the actual development and implementation of what a Mina category looks like but just want to thank you all for your work on this thank you Ryan fan dinting hey good afternoon members of the board and steamed uh student Representatives as well uh my name is Dr Ryan fan and I also work for the meel Arab Community Center uh we're to reiterate what F said we're very grateful for you collaborating with us to develop
034this resolution and with other community organizations and as superintendent bagula said better data hopefully translates to better support for all of our students regardless of their diverse backgrounds um and I wanted to share a personal anecdote is when I worked as a public educator in San Francisco for five years I taught and mentored dozens of students who fit into San Francisco UniFi Middle Eastern and arabic speaking category and just them not being counted as white changed a lot of the program available for them so we're able to offer improved ELD programs an Arabic World language program Community leison student groups and activities and translation and interpretation Services just to name a few we are able to track their academic progress celebrate successes and support them through specific challenges that it seemed like certain demographics were
035experiencing I'd also like to share some updated numbers from the US Census Bureau so I know we've shared a few numbers already but digging through the numbers more in a more detailed fashion we found that San Diego County actually is home to over 105,000 people who would qualify under California's current definition of Middle Eastern and North African um and given the huge menop population in San Diego County and that there is a comparable category that already exists in San Francisco and also in Glendale Unified and a few other places too we're very eager to collaborate with the board and other community organizations to implement and facilitate this demographic category being um I said implementation already to facilitate this category imp imped um as smoothly and swiftly as possible so of course in alignment with the
036state rollout of ab 2763 but also developing updated definitions for the student intake forms and for making sure that there are PDS for teachers and administrators to improve cultural competency not just to give a box for somebody to check off right um so that's all I really have to say thank you again for all of your work on this resolution and we look forward to collaborating with you in the coming years thank you Dalal erat good afternoon thank you for the opportunity to speak I'm D and I'm with the Mel a community center of San Diego and like fita and Ryan said just now we're very excited to see this resolution because we believe it's a great step towards better representing our community and more specifically our aut of Youth and students I'm a student
037fellow with Mead and I'm a recent high school graduate as well and I've witnessed firsthand how misre represented our communities are and specifically our newcomer communities and like Ryan mentioned like ELD programs uh will be better represented or better equipped with when we're better represented as well and categorized under the meno category and just generally I wanted to thank you all for this resolution because I think it's a great stop and it's a significant move towards better repres presenting a of Youth and the a of community as a whole and I look forward to seeing how it'll be implemented within the district and schools and as Mel we're just here to show our full support for it so thank you so much thank you we have seven virtual speakers the first speaker on Zoom is
038Janine erat hi good afternoon uh thank you all for the opportunity to speak today I wanted to um thank superintendent for bringing this forward um I went through through San Unified School District K through2 and I just want to affirm everything that has been said so far about how transformative this experience would be um and that this would be really important for community members to be able and students particularly to see themselves represented and to get to see themselves um in the in the data and numbers I when I was working on advocacy levels for language access at the county um two years ago one of the greatest challenges was Finding adequate numbers on the middle eastern North African Community so I just want to thank you all for bringing this forward and uh urge
039you all to enact it um because I think it'll be we'll see the change um not just in the immediate for students but in the long term um in the meantime until we get an official census category so thank you for your time thank you an Elliot an thank you yes thank you I'm I'm I'm on it now um I uh had Stu children in this uh Unified School District years ago and um at that time of course there were no you know possibilities of um looking at the diverse composition of students that we have um the big difference between what my kids went through and what these kids go through is that you know they weren't immigrants they didn't come from situations of War or conflict or um famine and um they didn't come
040into a school district with this the the emotional burden that people who have experience these things go through um and on top of that um because they kind of you know um seemed to be just sort of one of the crowd they weren't um subject to I know what happens with a lot of students from the Middle East and North Africa being um Islamic there's so much uh you know an anti-islamic um sentiment that these kids have to deal with that it's really important that the school districts know who they have in their schools and how they need to help them so that they can overcome the the um psychological um burdens of the the the past that they've lived through and and also to deal with um being treated as a fair and and
041um equal Humane beings um so this is a wonderful thing you're doing and I'm really glad to see it happening and thank you very much thank you David David vidmar I thank you so much for all the comments and all your work on this I've worked in 15 years as an educator and administration and um and I had some comments but I reached out to a a friend in the Bay Area who has taught for 30 years and done Administration for been a principal for 10 years and talked to about this and just wanted to quote what she said um I think the important thing this that that this is going to be better serving the needs of the district students by creating this category they all do have unque cultures and experiences and face
042discrimination uh this Mina category should enable the district to be aware of the needs of these students in a better way and they can serve these needs more successfully also it can help staff teaching and support staff and being aware of special needs and challenges that may be facing and one of the things that we discovered over time is that when starting tracking different ethnicities of students who's um we became more aware of their needs and we were better able to help them progress academically socially and emotionally and those are her comments after 40 years in education seen the changes over the years and so I appreciate the progress that um we've been making and I've also connected with the community here and have heard the stories of of some of the children who now
043are adults have and um who have been experienced comments of um asking if they're terrorists or if if they have a bomb in their backpack and how just little comments like that are bullying or um often go unreported because they're fearful of um repercussions and and sometimes even are reluctant to report those things because it's been shown sometimes our teachers or people in Authority have um even added to the misunderstanding or lack of awareness of what's going on and and these children as has already been mentioned are coming from places where they have experienced great hardships and families and death and um and are among them neediest um because of the trauma that they've experienced and so it's a hope that this type of thing will help us to um be better aware of how
044to meet their needs and make this at that welcoming environment that would Thrive um help them to thrive in their places so thank you for um your work on this and proving this and I think it's a great step move forward appreciate it thank you Omar abam yes hello good evening my name is Omar ausam I'm here representing K the Council on American Islamic relations I first want to thank you all for bringing forth this resolution I want to emphasize the importance of including Mina the middle eastern North African as a distinct category on School District fors Mina individuals are often we've seen them being Cate cized as white and that doesn't reflect our unique cultural and social experiences so I think by including Mina as a separate category schools can collect more accurate demographic
045data which is very very important for equity and inclusion it allows our districts to identify gaps in academic performance participation and access to programs ensuring that minia students are not overlooked or yeah often over because they are often overlooked it also Fosters a greater sense of inclusion and representation this uh this can also help us be seen and understood in their school environments this change would help create a more Equitable education system where all students regardless of background even if they are from Mina category or whatever category they are they have the opportunity to thrive and be representative uh accurate representation is essential to understanding our communities and ensuring that schools serve every student effectively yeah thank you everyone thank you for your work and we appreciate it thank you e Ahad sh s uh
046yes hello uh my name is ahed shamen I am I'm a fourth year educator uh not in this District but for two nonprofits uh I'm a Lebanese American and I volunteer with a multitude of organizations including UCSD meu Middle Eastern Union and Care um this is amazing to hear that this resolution has been proposed and should be passed um that means that our community and our population is being heard and that we are reaching out to the campaign of the District members and we are really supporting our students um this proposal will provide Improvement and and to fulfill a promise for our district our administrations and the educational equaly that it will provide for our underrepresented Middle Eastern students it it would it has no longer become a want it's become a need to both
047the legal and social stabilization of our school environment that our students now have to venture through uh with the inclusion of this category you you provide room and space for our culture clubs our Mina culture clubs and school to really flourish to really reach out to other students and to spread their culture and to be aware and to be represented you provide the state uh information and statistics and demographics in which organizations like scholarship organizations and other opportunities and other uh science programs can be reached out to students of those populations and fulfill their educational opportunities and and fulfill a better future and we provide a way for our students an early step actually towards the district mission where our students want to feel included they want to feel safe and they want to feel
048like they belong again and to recognize that identity their culture and the history that they bring with them but also feel that they can reach out for help when conflicts in the Middle East are slowly devastating families and we I'm ecstatic to hear this uh about two three years ago I ran a high school club uh in my old high school to really push this Mission nationally and and even within our own districts and within the state and this is amazing to hear and we hope you can work with organizations like care and and other uh local community organizations to really uh fully implement this with uh in quick enough time without without losing the aspect of our mission here thank you thank you Sean zere Sean zere yes hello please go ahead hi yes
049um I am San Z I work with um actually the Mell Center is part of our sing Refugee communities Coalition um and just uh very excited to um sort of the progress being made um as far as the men category being recognized and um uplifting a lot of our communities and and their identity and and being able to to give them space and and feel heard and well represented so just wanting to thank you all for that for the work being done and for your collaboration and tia Aban I believe Tia is not on Zoom so that concludes public comment thank you and I know I made you wait a long time but trusty what H Payne did you want to ask a question on these resolutions wow just hearing all the comments um there
050was some question about whether or not we should say wasn't expecting that whether we should say um judicial warrant on is this in the welcoming District resolution yes to be sure that folks know that um they won't be confused and misled as a lot of times they apparently bring things that they say or civil or um administrative warrants and I guess there's really no such thing it's really judicial but we just want to be sure that folks understand that so is the request to amend the resolution to ref that judicial so that FKS would understand that okay and I'm wondering General Council green if you can speak to that um does the resolution as it stands address trusty white Hurst pay's uh concerns or is concern we want is there such trusty barera yeah I
051think um uh Andre you can speak to our existing resolution that um that does uh prohibit immigration enforcement officials on our camp campuses without a Judicial warrant correct and and that's way I would recommend we keep it the judicial warrant difficult to get than another warrant so it sounds like existing board policy already includes the judicial warrant uh and this wouldn't not supersede that no it would not it's reflective of what we already have done since 2017 okay is that satisfactory yes I I just got a an email this afternoon from somebody lifting that point up and I don't really know what the difference is in that sense so we want it to be we don't want them on our campuses period so it sounds like their request is already something that we do which
052is great thank you any other questions or discussion yes either one or both vice president patter all right um first of all thank you to everybody who showed up either in TV land or in person um to speak on these items uh we always appreciate feedback from the public sometimes it gets a little lonely in the chamber and so it's good to have you here um let me start with D1 and say uh I appreciate working with staff on this um and uh it was a sort of reiterative process and uh uh and I appreciate appreciate the work in particular that um that our board president haen um did on this this item um I I just want to Echo what our what the superintendent said in relation to there are things that are challenging
053about politics I mean we live we live in a nation that's deeply divided the nice thing about working on a board of education is it's pretty simple ultimately all the pressure in the world it doesn't really matter our criteria is is it in the best interest of our students and so the question is does this harm our students does it make it harder for them to achieve their goals uh and their dreams uh is it socially harmful physically harmful emotionally harmful academically harmful if the answer is yes then we're just not going to do it and so um I I am glad to work with these colleagues and our staff and to frankly to be on a board of education in which it's that clear the data is clear both in relation on immigration issues
054and on LGBT plus issues um that discrimination is harmful that worrying about um the immigration status of your family and deportation is harmful um that bias is harmful and discrimination is harmful so frankly it's a pretty easy call for us to to make these commitments ultimately because that's it we have a bottom line there are other agencies I'm sure that have more complex bottom lines that's our bottom line and I believe broadly speaking that our community is with us in that that's our values that's our community's values and that's our call um so thank you for coming out today and testifying and support of this um in relation to our um D2 ARA item uh just a couple of clarifications here first of all I'm very happy to have this uh I always think of
055this in terms of having um of having instruments in the cockpit and it's very hard to address challenges that our meia communities have facing if we don't understand we don't have the data if there's no instrument our cockpit to tell us um that they are scared that they're suffering or that they're facing some academic challenges um in particular current concerns and therefore to get those resources and support they need so I'm very happy number one to have this instrument or get or move toward having this instrument in the cockpit um number two there was some testimony about San Francisco um having a pre-existing category so if staff could look into it I know we want to have a category and there was also reference to a swana category um we have a mea category because
056that is the federal uh minimum category currently um and so we want to articulate with the state and the federal government if if there is a way of implementing this in advance of um the state government and not have it jam up jam up our system and our articulation with state government then can let's explore that and figure out whether San Francisco successfully did it in a way that was not problematic with CDE and then also in terms of um I'll close just by saying this last session um a bill died in committee 2763 one of the T one of the folks at test I think Dr Fam uh alluded to it which would have adopted meeting at the state level it was held in committee where it died I talked to um a Sal's
057office some member of Sal's office Sal and Freedman were the sponsors and um there there is that bill is dead but they plan to re uced so um we may want to revisit this uh issue at a later date once that Bill gets introduced so we can kind of support that bill and so we can get the state moving and therefore have more ease of articulation um with CDE so uh that's all thank you again for everyone turning out tonight thank you and I'm so glad uh that vice president peton and I could introduce both of these items uh as it says at the top of uh the welcoming resolution we're committed to providing safe safe stable nurturing relationships and environments for all of our students period anything that gets in the way of our
058ability to do that um isn't something that we want to be doing and anything that helps us to provide a better education for all of our kids where they feel supported and loved and where we can give them exactly what they need we want to do more of that and being able able to now have a Mina category where we can collect data understand in a much more thoughtful and nuanced way the needs of our Mina students as vice president Pon said will just give us more tools in the cockpit to be able to better to provide a better experience to all of our students so I'm very glad to be bringing both of these resolutions today we have a motion a second we can go ahead and vote student trustees please vote thank you
059and all other trustees the motion passes unanimously with student board members concurring we'll now consider consent items D3 D4 and D5 consent items are considered to be routine and will be enacted by one motion followed by a vote there will be no separate discussion of these items unless the board member uh or the public or staff respect uh request specific items be removed from the consent agenda for separate discussion and action any agenda item removed will be voted upon following the motion to approve the consent agenda uh would any trustees like to have items D3 four or five pulled um from the consent agenda okay has anyone uh signed up for public comment on these items very good we'll keep it easy is there a motion on items D3 through D5 thank you we have
060a motion from trusty waur Payne is there and a second from truste baso student trustees please vote oh please yes sorry thank you president Hazen I just um on item D4 I think we want to just make one um small Amendment which is that the purpose of um a Regional Housing Finance Authority would be to develop housing not just for our Workforce but as trusty baldis um you know commented at our Workshop uh potentially for students and families as well so if we could just expand that definition got it so updating D4 specifically okay to include students all right so it does the motion do your motions and seconds apply all right very good okay now student trustees please vote thank you and all other trustees the motion passes unanimously first time first time very
061good amazing all right we'll now consider item E3 approval of 2025 legislative priorities Dr bagula can you please introduce the item thank you president Hazen today we have the privilege from I used to be an English language learner and my accent's really coming out today so so I'm feeling it okay thank you president Hazen today we have the privilege of hearing from Dr Sierra cook our director of government relations who will provide an overview of our legislative and fiscal advocacy work in addition you'll have the opport opportunity to review and consider for approval the proposed advocacy priorities for 2025 as we look ahead I want to reaffirm my unwavering commitment to securing our District's fair share whether in Sacramento or Washington DC advocacy remains at the heart of our mission and our work continues to
062grow stronger through collaboration recently at the csba conference we joined forces with our superintendent colleagues from Los Angeles and Long Beach crafting a United strategy to tackle the challenges we face you may recall my testimony at the Joint hearing on budget subcommittee on education finance and the assembly education Committee in that testimony I pushed for increased of lcf funding a regional cost of living adjustment and lowering the concentration Grant threshold all critical to ensuring we can meet our obligations and provide for our students on a personal note I've been advocating specifically for reforms to better support our middle school students it's no secret that the State has yet to make sign significant reforms to improve middle schools and this has been a key point of conversations and my discussions with assembly member Alvarez these students
063deserve attention and action and I'm committed to keeping this issue front and center as we move forward with our Middle School transformation plan I also want to Express gratitude to assembly member Alvarez for his support in helping us secure the license for an needo this is a major milestone for our district and I'm thrilled to announce that the ribbon cutting ceremony will take place this Friday all trustees are invited to join as we celebrate this important step for our students and families finally in addition to fighting for fair funding we will remain steadfast and advocating to protect our students and will oppose any legislation that infringes on the safety or civil rights our responsibility is not only to educate but to ensure every student feels secure valued and supported I know that the path won't
064always be easy but I believe in the power of a collective voice and before I turn it over to Dr Cook I would be remiss if I didn't congratulate Lincoln High School for winning the CIF state championship in football this past Saturday congratulations to our students coach Den co- principles I with El and brown and I will say this I had never gone through a football game before I'm just like that I know it's was a little strange I got a lot of strange looks but one of my favorite pieces of of of like action that happened on the field was hearing from the principles all the beautiful stories of where our athletes are also Scholars and hearing all the universities they're going to be joining it was absolutely Ely beautiful to to celebrate and
065see and I love all the love that the principl had for the kids as well so with that I'll turn it over to Dr Cook whose leadership and expertise will help guide us in this vital work thank you Dr Cook thank you for the introduction and good evening um board members uh so today I'll be giving a quick presentation um on our 2025 advocacy priorities so just to get us oriented um we're going to start with a recap of our 2024 priorities go over the fiscal context we're entering in 2025 that's going to impact the advocacy work we approach and then go over the proposed priorities which are in front of you for consideration and adoption tonight uh and then we'll have time for questions at the end but before we launch in as something
066to kind of frame everything we're about to talk about I wanted to include this vend diagram that lives rentree in my head and is what I use when I'm thinking about which policies to really Elevate to the level of a priority um and these are really the three very basic criteria which is are they aligned with the goals and values that we hold and what we believe in as a district are they politically viable and in this year in particular with a focus and emphasis on are these proposals that will help reduce the budget deficit that we're experiencing um so with that proceed with a recap from last year going to spend a little bit of time here because as you will see um the advocacy that we pursued last year the what I'm proposing
067we work on this year really builds off of these priorities um I'm sure I don't need to remind anyone here of the fiscal context we were operating in in 2024 there was a $45 billion deficit at the state that they were working to close and so cuts across the board including in education were on the table so it was a very challenging year of advocacy um but nevertheless the end result was that education was mostly protected from those cuts and I'm going to go through our prior priorities and the outcomes that we achieved um on those so it's not an overview of all the advocacy work we do but just specifically the priorities and the outcomes related to those so our first priority last year was increasing funding through the local control funding formula or
068lcff um there was a lot of talk of not funding a cola last year because of the unprecedented position of the state budget however um uh we did succeed in fully getting the cola funded it was a small Cola but it was fully funded at the statuto required level um second stabilizing expanded learning opportunities program funding elop funding um so kudos to our expanded learning Department um which oversees all of our after school summer school all of the enrichment that happens outside of the regular school day because they identified really early on I think before most districts were aware this was happening that there was a structural issue with the funding for formula that we received money from the state for these programs as a result of that structural issue in the formula we had
069been losing per pupil funding year-over-year um so we were advocating to instead of getting a different per pupil rate every year to have a fixed funding rate there was not budget capacity to create a permanent fix for this which would have been a few hundred million dollars from the state level however we did succeed in getting a short-term fix um in the budget last year where they're going to collect unspent elop funds across the state and repurpose them to help boost the funding rate at districts that lost funding like at San Diego unified the Department of Education is currently in that process and in January we expect an estimate of how much funding we'll receive um from that policy uh TK so uh our third advocacy priority was um advocating for funding for TK expansion
070and for the 1 to 10 Staffing ratios that districts will be required to um adopt starting in 2526 uh San Diego UniFi is an early adopter of TK so we are already serving all ages of four-year-olds but it's critical that the state follows through on their commitment to fund a greater and greater proportion of those students each year so we were successful in um getting the expansion of TK funded however they postpone the conversation about funding the ratios to 2526 because that's the budget year in which which that allocation will be made so as you can see some success here but also some some things to build off of in the current year at the federal level uh we also had three priorities at the federal level so the context again was a little bit
071dire um because as a result of the um the debt cealing agreement that was made in the summer of 20123 it put spending caps on non-defense spending for the next two years so last year budget and also the budget that our members of Congress are currently working on um as a result of that it was essentially a zero sum game where any increase in education would be a cut from some other non-sp spending program so a difficult advocacy environment um our priorities we're advocating for impact Aid which is a program that funds um supports for our milit military connected families and uh we achieved s there was a $7 million growth in that program nationally that's not the increase that we received um but that was the incre to the increase to the program overall
072uh we advocated for increased title funding um including title one which is one of the greatest sources of funding that we receive from the federal government and that program received a 20 million increase and we advocated for increased idea funding to support students with disabilities and that program also received a $20 million increase so on the scope of things these are small incremental increases but I do want to emphasize that in the net environment where we we were in where non-defense funding funding received a small cut overall any growth in these programs indicates that our members of Congress were choosing to prioritize education over other non-defense priorities so I do think that there's some hope to be found in these outcomes um so that was 2024 moving forward current day uh what is the context
073that we're working in for advocacy in 2025 uh positive news is that the state level for Education funding we are looking to be in a better position than we were in 2024 this graph shows the projected growth from the legislative analysts office of proposition 98 so our education funding um over the next several years the light blue background is the uncertainty in that projection so we are working with a large degree of uncertainty um but overall it's looking positive and the purple line shows what the 2425 enacted budget level was so there's a step up small increase in funding between the increase in revenue for prop 98 and some cost savings that are predicted to happen within prop 98 we're looking at $2.8 billion available at the state for new education commitments so that's really
074we're targeting our advocacy to what we want from those dollars uh the picture when we look outside of proposition 98 so outside of education is not as positive um the state as a whole is their budget is roughly balanced for this upcoming fiscal year 25 26 but there is a projected budget deficit growing to around $30 billion in 28 29 and while education funding is protected and as you can see it's looking more positive I did want to include this information because it sets the context that we're advocating in last year a lot of non-education programs experienced deep cuts and we hoping that they would have their programs restored Bo but instead they're facing what looks like some really lean years ahead as well and so our lawmakers are going to be balancing that context
075as they decide what they want to fund in the upcoming year at the federal level um the context is ambiguous in many ways currently um we do know that for the 2024 25 fiscal year which Congress is still working on um there the debt cealing agreement is still in place that caps fun at 1% but I would say that that would be a positive outcome in the environment we're looking at for Education spending um there's a lot of unknowns right now about what about what will happen with the Department of Education title funding um so it's something that we're following closely um and cautiously but at this point there's not a lot of information about what we can expect so that's the context um which brings us to in this context what am I proposing
076that we focus our advocacy on in the state and also at the federal level um so our proposed 2025 advocacy priorities at the state as you'll see really build on the progress that we made last year uh the first is maximizing Equity focused Investments so this includes um lcff which was a priority from last year but getting more specific uh when the budget was enacted in the summer 2024 they provided an estimate of what the education Colo was expected to be for 2526 and that expectation was that it would be around 2.9% um since then in November it was updated to 2.46% and now it's not on my PowerPoint because I heard this yesterday but um experts are saying that it's looking more like 1.8% uh our budget as you heard last week in our
077first interim budget report is based built around the numbers we had at the time which was the higher col so we want to advocate for the cola to be funded at that projected level because it's what we built our budget on um and every half a percent of State Cola decrease is around a $5 million loss for San Diego unified so it's a big impact um secondly advocating for increased funding for special education services and I'll say that both of these priorities were discussed and are shared among the other urban districts that we met with last week with that um interim superintendent Pula met with uh so we're not alone in the this advocacy uh we know that special education costs are a increasing need our population of students with IEPs has grown 13% over
078the last 5 years so it's a it's a rapidly increasing area of need um and finally investing in the success of our middle school students um they are when you look at lcff funding some one of the lowest funded grades per student in lcff and yet we know from their um academic test scores and disciplinary rates that they are facing some of the most significant challenges second priority um continuing to advocate for a fixed rate for expanded learning funding the short-term fix in the budget was greatly appreciated but it doesn't solve the ongoing structural issue this bar chart shows the amount of funding that we've lost year-over-year due to this $ 13.3 million so far but there's a clear downward Trend um the bar graphs that's the per pupil rate that we've received each year
079um so we're advocating that this level just be fixed at the 2223 pupil rate so that we will continue to receive a predictable and adequate level of funding for these programs funding the 1 to 10 TK Staffing ratio so this was the part of the conversation that was kind of punted to this year and this is where we really need the state to take action and uphold their commitment our estimates are that this will cost upwards of $5 million to implement um so we really need the state support to provide adequate funding for the lower Staffing ratios in all of our TK classrooms finally um cost saving policies those first three are really focused on Revenue how do we increase our revenue or how do we protect ourselves from decreases in Revenue um but there's
080also ways that state the state can support us in local cost savings and the one example that I'm working on right now is um we are required as a district to maintain in inventory of all district equipment priced at over $500 uh that level was sent in 1984 and never updated so even adjusting that for inflation and this is something that we have to spend hundreds of thousands of dollars a year on so um updating that for inflation is very easy no-brain solution that will result in some cost savings for the district at the federal level our priorities really remain unchanged even though the the context is different um I think this will be a really important year to focus on increasing idea funding it's the 50th anniversary of the idea program first being implemented
081and it when it was implemented Congress made a commitment to cover 40% of the costs of funding um of providing services for students with disabilities nationally they're averaging 10.2% of that cost so nowhere close to the commitment and because locally our costs in this area are higher than the national average our Ida funds only cover 6.2% of our district special education costs um protecting Federal title programs again the federal context is a little bit unclear but there have has been a lot of conversation around targeting particularly title one so we will be making sure that all of our Congressional Delegation understands the impact that these programs have and the importance of preserving this funding to serve our low-income students supporting our military connected students again through the federal impact aid program this program is another
082one that has not been fully funded since the 60s and 1969 was the last year that um the federal government fully funded this program if we were to receive the amount of funding we're eligible for um and the program was adequately funded we would receive around 10 times the allocation that we do receive uh these numbers are from 2023 I apologize that the 2024 numbers just became available but it's a very small change we're still sitting at around 10% of our eligibility and then finally protecting our vulnerable students and families we've heard a lot about this tonight it's really important acknowledging that we're in an environment where some of our students our immigrant students mixed students from mixed status families our lgbtq students and others may not be feeling a safe coming to school and
083our priority is ensuring that they can feel safe and supported so they can focus on learning so um we don't know specifically in the education realm what is going to be coming down from the federal government in this area but we want to make it a priority to make sure that if the rights of our students are threatened that we are standing by them to Advocate um to keep schools a safe place for all so those are our proposed priorities um happy to take any questions thank you and before we take questions is there a motion uh on this item thank you um board member baldes I think a second from trusty Barrera uh has anyone signed up for public comment okay and now questions trusty Barrera thank you president Hazen thank you uh Sierra
084that was um really uh very clear and appreciate you going through what our advocacy priorities were last year and what the outcomes were I'm just in my head I'm hearing my dad in 1984 talking about something that would cost $500 oh no no no no um I'm wondering so in addition to advocating around the Cola with lcff I'm wondering kind of what our conversation is around the potential uh increased prop 98 revenue and how that would be funneled into increased lcf maybe increasing the base ground or whatever that would look like yeah yes that's certainly a conversation that we've been having with um you know folks in Sacramento and also the other urban districts as declining enrollment creates additional capacity within problem I think it's important that you know we have a conversation and are
085aligned in you know where would we choose to prioritize that funding so um you know in our advocacy so far we have focused on just using terminology such as as additional capacity you know occurs in Pro 98 not specifically uh making that connection between declining enrollment but that is a conversation that is starting to happen at the state level and that we want to be a part of and whether that's an lcff or special education I think will be um you know a conver A continuing conversation that we have thank you trusty baso and just to add on to uh trusty barrera's question it um also at the national level so through the council great City schools and I know a lot of those schools are in States they're having declining enrollment as well so
086it would be good to make sure you're working with advocacy directors from the large Urban schools throughout the country because I know that that's an issue elsewhere as well yeah that that is a great point and I think you know looking forward towards us next year um those Partnerships that we have through the council and understanding what other other districts and other urban districts across the country regardless of their state policies I think that that partnership in our advocacy will be even more important this year than it has been before thank you trusty whiters pay I just want to say thank you to Sierra Dr Cook you met with uh I believe Sabrina on Friday night a week ago and then me on Saturday morning and very your your response is very clear and you're
087very focused on what we need to do and I'm glad that you're there working on our behalf because I think you are articulating what we would like to see and I keep saying when the feds fund everything that they're requiring us to do then they can start talking a little bit more but for right now I think the students are ours in special education 6% I mean really don't even complain feds because you're not giving us any money for the kids we're we're really carrying them because we're committed to our students and um I know some of the folks in the General ad population feel that we're taking from them to deal with special needs but we have to do that because we're committed to all of our students and I want to thank you
088for focusing on the needs of our students and sharing thank you vice president Pon just very tiny I your your these priorities are dead on in terms of what we've talked about over the last couple of years as long as I've been on the board um if I can just tack on uh make to this is in reference to the makers of the motion if we can when a introduces the successor Bill to the Mina um to 2763 could we just tack that on in terms of supporting that was that okay with the makers of the motion in terms of can you can you clarify what that bill would do yeah sorry yeah and I alluded to in the last one but there was a bill carried that died in committee which was to adopt
089the federal um minum minimum category um for the census at the state level it didn't get make it through committee and the S intends to introduce it again in January so once that happens if we could tack that on is that okay with the makers of the motion is that so I one thing I'll say and I that's I think a board decision um but in addition to the specific priorities which are really the areas we were you know focusing a lot of our budget advocacy that we may be leading at the state level but that is in no way the full realm of legislation that we weigh in on and I do feel like um in the policy principles that we are also adopting tonight um you know it speaks to creating cultures of
090belonging uh as one of the priorities in the legislation we will support so I think that could fit within that scope if you feel like that's implicit in the in the instruction already that's fine yeah thanks all right thank you and I appreciate all the work you've done Sierra and all of the work you do with us individually to bring us up to speed but also to get our feedback and listen to our feedback and incorporate that into uh the priorities we have um I am really hopeful that we get funding for 1 to 10 ratios for TK as we think about what our youngest students need why is it that fouryear olds if they're sitting in a preschool classroom are entitled to one ratio but if they happen to be sitting in an elementary
091school classroom that we call TK a different ratio applies so I'm very hopeful that at the state level uh they see that four-year-olds are four-year-olds and need to receive adequate funding so that we can provide appropriate de well developmentally appropriate ratios so glad that we are continuing to fight for that one um and also uh elop funding um so we can provide uh all of the after school and Extended Learning care our students need so we have a motion a second um let's go ahead and vote student trustees please thank you and all others all right the motion passes unanimously with student board members concurring we'll now consider item E4 reappointment of Dan McAllister and Sharon WHUR Payne to the audit and finance committee for the period of January 1st 2025 through December 31st 2026
092is there a motion on e4 thank you we have a motion from trusty baso is there a second thank you vice president Pon are there any speakers on e4 and do any trustees have questions or wish to discuss okay student trustees please vote thank you and all other trustees please vote the motion passes unanimously with student board members oh did oh we're missing we missed Mr Pon all right we're g to vote again let's be the last he's that's right okay so please everybody vote we did it all right now the motion passes unanimously with student board members concurring we'll now consider item E5 board member appointment reappointment to the csba delegate assembly and the San Diego County School boards Association San Diego unified holds three seats on the csba delegate assembly trustee white Payne
093is serving a term ending March 31st 2026 trusty baso is being considered for reappointment for the term of April 1st 2025 through March 31st 2027 and the board is asked to appoint a trustee to replace trustee pson for the term of April 1st 2025 through March 31st 2027 and I'm happy to volunteer to replace trusty pson for the 2025 through 2027 term is there a motion to approve the reappointment of trusty baso and my appointment to the csba delegate assembly in County csba oh thank you that was very kind of you we have a motion from truste vice president Pon is there a second thank you all right we have a motion and a second are there any speakers on E5 okay student trustees please vote okay now everybody get ready I'm going to call
094for a vote okay all other trustees please all right the motion passes unanimously with student board members concurring we'll now consider item E6 revision to existing board policy policies administrative regulations and Exhibits is there a motion on E6 thank you we have a motion on E6 is there a second and a second are there any speakers on E6 okay any trustees have questions or wish to discuss E6 okay student trustees please vote thank you and all other Trust IES the motion passes unanimously with student board members concurring we will now consider item E7 formation of a student outcomes Focus governance task force over the last year our board has worked in partnership with the superintendent office and Council of great City Schools to conduct listening sessions with students families and Community Partners clarify the vision
095and values of our community and adopt measurable six student outcome goals focused on Wellness academic achievement and College and Career Readiness we've also adopted guard rails that affirm the district's commitment to communicating transparently ensuring students are motivated to engage in their education and promoting economic self-sufficiency and financial literacy and we've adopted a plan to monitor progress against these items and while we've completed many of the foundational planning elements of our student outcomes focused governance work there is still significant work left to do over the next year to complete our work to focus our governance model on student outcomes the formation of a time-limited one-year student outcomes focused governance task force is proposed to ensure the successful implementation of the district's sofg plan by December 2025 the task force will be composed of two adult trustees
096up to two student board members the superintendent our sofg consultant and director of board services and will ensure the district's successful transition to a more student centered governance model is there a motion on E7 thank you is there a second thank you are there any speakers on E7 okay uh any questions or discussion two student board members and two adult up yeah so we can only have up to two adult board members because of brown act and both student board members can participate if they'd like because Brown act doesn't apply yes I was going to see could we open up a spot for one student representative on this to other than trusty Cruz and myself like from the student Advisory Board yeah someone from the student Advisory board or any other student that'd be interested
097in this yes I'm is that okay with everybody okay okay all right so and including a student Advisory Board member okay so we have a motion a second with this amendment um student were you trying to vote go ahead thank you Madame President um I just want to say having live through this on the in executive officers uh with um president Hazen um I'm very happy to make this motion uh it's this has taken a the the sausage making involved in this process has been enormous and I really don't know how we would have gotten through it without um president Hazen's leadership on it it really is something that takes a lot of sustained attention uh and she is uniquely well suited to focused attention and uh putting together agendas and I really deeply appreciate
098her leadership on it thank you I appreciate that all right let's go ahead and vote student trustees thank you and all other trustees the motion passes unanimously with student board members concurring and before we move on to public comment uh I'm wondering so I am interested as you suggested uh in serving on this task force I'm wondering if there's another trustee who would like to join me volun told isn't that the best way do you expect the accept the volun holding thank you all right and then student board members are either or both of you interested yes I'd be very passionate about serving 100% all right all right okay so we've got a great team and I will look to our student board members uh to bring this opportunity to the student Advisory Board and
099identify a student Advisory Board member to join us and the first meeting of the task force will be in I think late January all right we will now receive public testimony on non-agenda items have we received any requests for non-agenda comment yes we have two virtual speakers um Orin Robinson you each have three minutes can you hear me yes go ahead please hi good evening this is on Robinson with project on Youth and Military opportunities project Dio several of us with project Dio spoke at November's board meeting well we thank the board again for taking responsible action to protect students in August 2023 is resolution requiring fully informed consent for the district's jrtc programs however as we wied at that last meeting the issue is that the current version of The District's jrtc consent form
100still in use today stands in clear violation of several parts of the board's own resolution from over a year ago so we're coming back to speak again today to thank the district thank the board for delegating this matter to staff back in November and we request that the board publish the newly Revival and fixed JC consent firm when it becomes available and particularly want to urge attention to this issue because board members and the public have been recently made aware of new related violations of students rights just in the past month we learned that within our district because a particular high school lacks sufficient physical education PE resources it has resulted in at least one known instance where a student was forced to enroll in jrc despite their misses this kind of involuntary enrollment into
101jrtc violates both State Education Code as well as each student's right to fully informed consent about their own education so thank you again for attention to these matters thank you and Remy Corona Remy Corona are you available on Zoom uh yes go ahead please you have three minutes a spech please go ahead yes I feel that as board members I feel it is your responsibility and duty to look over the rights of students and I thank you all for your work and for your effort and doing that does that complete your comment yes that compl my comment okay thank you okay thank you all for taking the time to provide your comments to the board and superintendent today we appreciate your input and please know that your perspectives help us to better serve our students
102parents and the community this concludes the agendized business of the board we will now conduct the annual organization of the Board of Education election of board President and Vice President Miss stts can you please conduct the election yes I'll provide the background information first um pursuant to Education Code section 35143 the president President and Vice President shall be elected from the members of the board at the board's annual meeting held within a 15-day period that commences with the second Friday in December following the regular election in a year in which a regular election for governing board members is conducted board bylaw 10002 describes the process for electing officers the President and Vice President shall each receive the votes of a majority of the full membership of the board before being declared elected the election shall
103be conducted using written ballots on which every board member's name appears separate ballots will be cast for President and Vice President each board member including the student trustees will vote for one adult board member for the office being voted upon until an adult board member has received at least three votes following each ballot the board action officer myself will announce the result results of the vote identifying the members voting for each candidate prior to cast prior to the casting of ballots board members may speak in support of a particular candidate under this procedure all adult board members are eligible for election and there will be no nominations board bylaw 10003 sets the term of office as one year During the period commencing with their election and until their successors shall be duly elected and qualified
104the term for the next set of officers is December 18th 2024 through December 10th 2025 and I will now distribute the ballots you're going to start with the orange paper president as could I just yes please I'm hoping that at least somewhere in this country we get a vice president to ascend to the presidency so see may I speak Cody is looking like you have a question yes please oh I would like to encourage folks to vote for Richard barer for vice president I think he's earned it thank youting them all right so please send your ballots down to the right so that they can be counted thank you yes please for yes as ballots are being counted we have some discussion I'm just noting there have been a lot of Elections lately a lot
105of Elections I'm all for it though all right for the office of President we have Cody Pon being voted for by Shaina Hazen Sabrina bazo Cody peton Joseph Cruz Richard Barrera and Sharon Whitehurst Payne and for Shaina Hazen we have Quinton baldis voting for president so we have a majority for Cody Pon Cody is now president [Applause] and for vice president we have a unanimous vote for Richard [Applause] Barrera congratulations to both of our new officers uh before we close out the meeting I'd like to share just a few words it has been an absolute pleasure to serve as board president uh with trustees and with an interim superintendent who are so aligned in our Focus to ensure every student meets their potential when I stepped into the role of President last December I don't
106think I could have predicted some of the challenges our district would face over the coming months and while we had to navigate choppy and at at times uncharted waters I've continued to feel grateful for the sacred responsibility of caring for for in educating our children and having the fortitude to continue working tirelessly to improve outcomes for our kids lately and I don't know about you all when I run into people outside of the district I'm greeted with a common refrain are you doing okay and without fail they are surprised to see me with a smile on my face and hear that I'm doing great because I have the privilege of working alongside board members District leaders principes and educators who are working hard to challenge the status quo and build a school district that addresses
107the wellness academic and extracurricular needs of our students and while we certainly have more work to do to improve outcomes for all students and particularly those that have been historically overlooked and underestimated I would be remiss if I didn't take a moment as we close out 2024 to celebrate all the progress we've made in service of our students and their families there are a few things that stand out to me as I think about the strides our system is making to do right by kids over the last year we've significantly expanded our after school Prime Time program to support students and families at every elementary school and are now providing about 3,000 more students with Afterschool care than we were last year it's making a meaningful difference in those kids and those famili family lives
108and we've significantly increased access to Visual and Performing Arts now providing every Elementary student from TK through fifth grade with art or music instruction at school not to mention the exceptional Early Learning experiences were offering nearly 5,000 four-year-olds through free highquality full day transitional kindergarten and I couldn't be prouder of the continued expansion of our College and Career Pathways for high school students in the last year with a refined emphasis on measurably improving student wellness academic achievement and College and Career Readiness we are using data to more thoughtfully and accurately understand how our students are doing and focusing on the evidence informed practices that will yield the most positive results for our Spotlight students who have fallen through the cracks I know I push really hard and am exceedingly impatient when it comes to Transforming
109Our School District but please know how proud I am of San Diego unified and what an honor it is to serve on on this board now it is my pleasure to pass this gavel to my dear friend and esteemed colleague Cody Pon congratulations well it isn't The Infinity Gauntlet but uh it's as close as we come it's an honor thank you ma'am uh and it's you leave some very big shoes to fill so with that this meeting is now adjourned the next regular meeting will be held on January 14th [Applause]