CorpusRecord 105865

Board of Education Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / San Diego Unified School District
Date
2024-12-11
Location
San Diego County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
15,163 words · about 85 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001everyone watching on ITV and Via live stream and call the December 10th 2024 regular meeting of the Board of Education to order with all board members present we will now go to our flag ceremony the San Diego High School Army jrc Color Guard will present the colors please stand for the presentation of the colors left please join me for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for [Music] col thank you please be [Applause] seated now move to our land acknowledgement land acknowledgement is a traditional custom that dates back centuries in many native nations and communities our land acknowledgement was developed in partnership with local K Kumi leaders students from

002the San Diego School of Creative and Performing Arts prepared the following video to show our respect for the Kumi people who are the original stewards of the land our school district occupies we respectfully acknowledge that the Kumi people are the original inhabitants and caretakers of these lands now known as San Diego despite the attempted genocide and ongoing impacts of colonization the Kumi Spirit remains unbroken and their Traditions continue to thrive as they carry the memories of their ancestors who bravely resisted cultural Erasure and fought to protect their land and way of life in honoring their legacy we pledge to uphold their cultural heritage and right to safeguard their sacred connection to the land for future generations with gratitude and strength we stand with the Kumi embracing the past while forging a brighter tomorrow tomorrow we'll

003now move to item B1 adoption of the agenda tonight we'll consider a variety of items including the first reading of the 2025 26 Title 1 eligibility ranking report a resolution recognizing December as disability awareness month the 20242 first financial report and 202 324 external auditor financial statements and swearing in of reelected trustees Barrera baso and white hurse Payne I'd like a motion to adopt today's agenda as published with items h10 ceremonial swearing in and H3 and four external auditor reports to be heard first is there a motion thank you we have a motion and a second uh from trusty baso student trustees please go ahead and vote thank you and all other trustees please vote motion passes unanimously with student board members concurring Miss sutz can you please provide information for public speakers about today's

004meeting protocols yes today's meeting of the board of education is a business meeting that is conducted in public and board members will not engage in a dialogue with members of the audience board bylaw 1025 sets the time limit for public comment on agenda items at 10 minutes per side pro and con or 20 minutes total speakers will be able to provide testimony at the beginning of the appropriate agenda item or at the end of the meeting for non-agenda comment please listen for your name to be called speakers are listed and called in the order received when your name is called please come to the podium to speak speakers participating via Zoom will be asked to unmute when their name is called if you are unable to unmute yourself we will call the next speaker please

005follow along with the agenda so that you know when your item is coming up for discussion when you begin speaking the green light below my name on the dis indicates that the timer has started when the light turns yellow you will have one minute remaining a buzzer will indicate that your time has expired if you have not yet done so and would like to sign up for inperson public comment iPads are available in the back of the auditorium and in the lobby thank you it is now my honor uh to move to item h10 and begin our formal agenda with the ceremonial swearing in of trusty baso Barrera and white Hurst Payne who were reelected on November 5th 2024 trusty bazo will be sworn in by her daughters and future son-in-law trusty Barrera will be

006sworn in by the chavistas and trusty Whitehurst Payne will be sworn in by Reverend Eugenio D Rafael pastor of St Paul's United Methodist Church of San Diego we'll begin with trusty baso who's been reelected to represent subdistrict a so I'm just going to request if someone else uh either Richard or Sharon can go we're waiting for one more person to get here so absolutely the next be on the list we'll continue with trusty representing subdistrict D what makes they Podium mic test test um Wanted if you could just each introduce yourself in your grade in School first and then we'll do my name is Kaa delattin I go to Clark middle and I'm an eighth grader my name is samuela and I'm a ninth grade at San Diego High School my name is Emanuel sparza

007I go to Hoover High School and I a senior my name is Victoria guangos and I'm and I'm and I go to shman elementary academy and I'm in third grade raise your right hand and repeat after me I state your name I Richard Perera do solemnly swear or affirm that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States do solemnly swear that I will defend the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California against all enemies foreign and domestic and the constitution of the State of California against all enemies foreign and domestic that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States that I will bear true faith in allegiance to the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State

008of California and the constitution of the State of California that I take this obligation freely that I take this obligation freely without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion without any mental res orp of Evas and that I will well and Faithfully discharge the duties upon which I am which I am which I am about to enter I will andarge [Applause] duties Tristy barera you want to come on over this way for photos all right we will now continue with trusty Whitehurst Payne who is representing subdistrict e okay would you raise your right hand and repeat after me I Sharon wher pain I Sharon do Som solemnly swear that I will support do that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States will support the Constitution of the United States against and

009and the constitution of the State of California and the constitution of the State of California against all enemies against all enemies foreign and domestic foreign and domestic that I will bear true faith that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States that I will be witness to the faith of theti United States and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States you said that and the constitution of the State of California the constitution of the state ofia that I take this obligation freely that I take this obligation freely without any mental reservation without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion or purpose of evasion and that I will well and Faithfully that I will well and Fai discharge the duties discharge the duties which I'm about to enter I

010am to enter [Applause] amen okay and now we will continue with truste baso who has been reelected to represent sub District a I think good evening everyone my name is David baso I am the first gentleman to trusty Baza I'm Mara bazo I'm her oldest daughter um I'm Eliana bazo I'm the youngest daughter I am Nan Jackson I am a future baso we will now take the oath of office raise your right hand and repeat after me I state your name I Sabrina boso do solemnly swear do solemnly swear that I will support that I will support and defend and defend the Constitution of the United States the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California and the constitution of the State of California against all enemies foreign and domestic

011against all enemies foreign and and domestic that I will bear true faith and allegiance that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States to the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California and the constitution of the State of California that I take this obligation freely that I take this obligation freely without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion and that I will well and Faithfully discharge and that I will will Faithfully discharge the duties upon which I am about to enter the duties of which I'm about to enter [Applause] thank you yes yes okay so we do him first then we'll go me okay everybody you get behind on next step move in a little

012bit a little there you go thank you [Applause] doing that afterwards okay I'd like to now give each of our reelected trustees an opportunity to say a few words why don't we start with trusty baso and we can go down the line thank you president Hazen um board uh uh Dr buul our staff that's here our members of the community our students my family um so honored to be starting my second term on San Diego Unified School Board and uh I was just thinking back over reflecting over the last four years that I've been on this board and I'm so grateful I think John le ev's left but that I got that call from him in September 2019 when I thought I was in trouble for some I was like why is John Lee Evans

013calling me and he uh suggested that I run for Schoolboard and here it is here I am um so I just wanted to take a brief look back over the last four years um since I've started on the board when I swore got sworn in last time this is my first time in it with people here um it was a completely dark empty Auditorium because this was December of 2020 um I Think We snuck my husband and my one of my daughters in and it was just a dark room I don't even think the board members were in here were they they were I think they were on yeah all on Zoom yeah yeah so that's how I that's how that started our our schools were still dealing with the covid shutdown and uh I

014i' I've learned a lot since that time both personally and on a professional note um we didn't I didn't have our my first inperson meeting I think for about a year until that so I didn't even meet some of the board members for a year I remember uh Mike mccy uh didn't come in person and um you know I think Kevin Baer so anyway um things have changed um a lot of the staff I hadn't met the first time I met Andre I wasn't sure I recognized her because she came to talk to me I was like oh I know who that is um few weeks later there was an Insurrection that happened in uh trying to overthrow the government so that was kind of like the tapestry that I was starting on a school

015board and then we found out that superintendent was going to be moving to Washington to work for the White House with the Department of Education which was exciting for her but I that made me concerned because you know I'm just coming on this board um Flash Forward now I'm on my third superintendent so so in in four years but um it again a lot of learning in that time and very happy to have Dr bagula leading us um in April of 2021 my mom passed away after several months of being seriously ill and she was one of my strongest role models in life um and I was very close to my mom so that was a difficult time sorry then 2023 February my husband was diagnosed with a gleo blastoma and if you're not sure

016what that is it's a type of very aggressive brain tumor so I'm very happy excit and and grateful that my husband is still here with with us today it's been almost 2 years and uh if you look at the diagnosis for glol blastoma it's not good um and so the fact that he's still here with us and able to be here with me today along with my family who's always been very supportive um they also keep me very humble and remind me what's important when they think I'm getting too big for my britches being on Schoolboard they bring me down make sure I know what my priorities are so I share those things because although there's been a lot lot of challenges during this time period there's also been a lot of Joy um I

017know we talk about that and again my family supported me through a lot um but just from you know happen with my husband just the people that have reached out and supported our family I just could never have imagined the level of support we've gotten um family friends but also like the UCSD Community who my husband's worked with for for 30 years recently retired and even here the school district all the love and support that we've um you know received as a family just it's been just overwhelming and and such a and I'm very grateful um and uh I'm also very honored to be part of this incredible team here at San Diego unified being a candidate alongside for my second time with my um partners in crime Richard and Sharon um you've both been

018such a gift for me and I admire both of you so much and um really appreciate um you know go being in this with you um has has been tremendous and and I really appreciate the uh partnership we have and then bringing our fellow colleagues Co Cody and Shaina on in 2022 and of course the student board me all the student board members I've worked with most recently Quinton and Joseph have been incredible and I feel very grateful to be part of this team and um when I started out as a school board member you know was again we're in Co shutdown I was all excited it was like this Eager Beaver to get started and I joined this program a governance training program through the Council of great City Schools which is um the

019program that we're doing the student outcome Focus governance work and when I started that I thought you know this is great it it gave me kind of an outlet to learn and during my presidency in 2023 we started working with them on the student outcome focused governance and we've come such a long way with that and I think president Hazen has taken that really the next level and I'm really excited about the work that we we're doing around that because it's really using um keeping our students at the center and really having tangible ways that we can really drill down and make sure we're reaching our most margin especially our uh hardest to reach students our black and brown communities our marginalized um um population including our lgbtq students um talking about mental health more

020the discussion we just had last night and it's all um you know I I really think we're making um you know we're going to continue over this next four years to continue to make that progress and also again keeping our students at the Forefront always making sure that we have their voice in the room so um I'm truly excited to continue this work with all of you and I see a lot of great work being done as as we're moving forward and and staying the course and now is really the time to continue delivering on those promises and continuing the fight so we have a strong stronger more Equitable community and while also like I said keeping our students our families needs in mind with every decision that we make so thank you thank you

021Tristy Barrera thank you president Hazen um thank you everybody for uh for being here H thank you especially to our chavistas that U made time to to come down here it was just a I don't know a month or so ago that Darius and Aiden and Samwell and others came and talked to us about the work that you've been doing uh to educate your fellow students your families your uh your your teachers about our democracy and you know uh superintendent Bou and I were on a site visit to uh Florence GFI join our Elementary School uh last week and we were visiting um some kindergarten classes and I just thought about how extraordinary it is that we as a group of people have continued to make the decision that we are going to provide for

022every young person in our community regardless of who they are where they come from how much money they have what language they speak uh and education and we're going to do it in these institutions um or these places called schools um so in those classrooms were kids whose families came from all over the world kids whose families um you know have been in San Diego for gener ations kids whose families came from different parts of the United States and they were coming together as a school Community um to make sure that this group of young people will be able to go out and meet the challenges uh that you will meet in the future and that you will do it successfully but more than successfully you'll do it with love and you'll do it with

023uh commitment to a set of values that affirm how much we care about each other we don't have to do that as a society we've got choices all the time sometimes it doesn't feel like that right sometimes it feels like um well there's always going to be school kids are always going to have to go whether you want to go that morning or not um taxpayers are going to have to you know pay taxes to to make sure that we have schools and it's just this thing that we can take for granted very easily I think we're at a moment right now in this community and in our country where we know we can't take things for granted where we know this commitment that generation after generation after generation of San diegans Americans have made

024in the belief that if we create schools that our young people will go forward and make our community our country our world a better place that needs to be we need to recommit ourselves to doing that every generation it's not something that is a guarantee that will always be there but what gives me Faith and confidence and excitement uh to know that our world is going to be a better place is you the what you do every day the way that you show up for your school for your community um for your belief in your ability to help shape the world going forward no matter what the challeng Alles um that can only happen in a great community and a great society that's what we have built Sabrina and Joseph and Cody and Shaina and

025Sharon and Quinton and I have a title called trustee and I think that's a great uh word because it it means we never own this place we temporarily have the privilege of ensuring that our schools are as good as they can possibly be now and that they can always be better going forward into the future that's our job as trustees to think about the schools that we have now and trying to position ourselves so that our schools can be better in the future so that our young people can go out and do great things in the world and all of you will do that and all of us have been where Victoria and Manuel and Samuel and Ka and Aiden and Darius and Vin all of us have been where you are a lot of

026us you know my parents my dad came from Colombia um grew up there didn't speak English when he came to this country my grandparents came from Europe um didn't speak English when they came to this country and they fully threw themselves into the idea that they were already contributors to this country the day they walked here walked into on onto our Shores and that their kids could contribute more and help lead this country into the future we've all been where you are now we haven't always done uh the best uh at at ensuring that your future will um be something that uh you know that uh that we can feel good about um but the one thing that we've done is we've committed ourselves to give you a shot at making our future and our

027and our world a better place and you are also trustees in this project you have the responsibility and the privilege to make sure that five years from now 10 years from now 20 years from now when your younger siblings Victoria when vaita is your age uh when you've got kids that we're still going to have schools we're still going to commit ourselves to young people and that we're always as a society going to move forward and do Justice by young people we're all trustees our entire Community are Trustees of that idea we're in a time right now that we have to confront our responsibility it's not something that we can take for granted you don't take it for granted you step up every day and you get yourselves ready to make this world a better

028place so thank you to chabis say thank you to all of our students you're all leaders you're all amazing trustees and it's an honor to to serve you you thank you trusty Barrera and now trusty WHUR Payne thank you president Heen and this is an opportunity for us to do a real sermon I I had my pastor here he left so he didn't have to hear my sermon uh but this is a a privilege and an honor to serve the children the people here in San Diego and as I listened to my colleagues talking about immigration and so forth as I said this going to be a sermon tonight so uh Andre you can close your ears for a little bit um because I I am a Christian and I I Define myself as one

029but I am having a little bit of difficulty dealing with this whole notion of immigration and folks who say that they are Christian when Christ went to Egypt he immigrated and uh he was cared for in Egypt he obviously believed in Immigration if we care for people and that's the way I look at my role as someone who is responsible where I set for all children if you come to us then it is my responsibility as a part of this group to be honest with you to educate you to do what I'm supposed to do to make this Society a better place and that's where I stand because of where I sit tonight because when I look at my mother and my father my father uh my grandfather was a product of misation which was

030his his father was a slave owner and his mother was a slave and how we came through that line in the state of Virginia where it all started then I say we should get over this you're not like me or you're not this or you're not that we are all here together and we're supposed to work together it's not coincidental that we're here we all have a responsibility and an obligation to each other to do the best we can to help one another that's how we become great is when we help others it's not about building ourselves up but when you do for others and you think about others as yourself how would you like to be treated what do you want to do for what do you want to have done for yourself do

031you want to be talked about and disrespect it like that do unto others just implement the Golden Rule which is you're doing for others that you want to have done un to yourself and so I mean I don't I'm not saying that I'm perfect no none of us we're not perfect I don't care who you are you are not perfect if you here on this Earth got news for you but we're all striving to help one another to do good to help those children those students in our system to do their best to help them to nurture them to help them to grow so that we as a society can be a better society and embrace others probably said too much already but that's how I feel about it and those are my core values

032tonight I commit myself and that's why last night at the board meeting I said we're not all represented here we have to try to do representation to help all of us to come to the the place where we can all succeed and do the things that we can to help one another so I am thankful for this opportunity to serve it's about being a servant it's not about being up here to be served but to serve in any way I can to help you my email is still screwed up so anybody who's been trying to get me through email I would ADV advise you to call the district office or whatever or just use my home email address so that you can get in touch with me uh but that is my role here I

033am here to serve you and that's to serve every child in this system so that we all can come into unity and be the best city the best society that we can be thank you all for giving me the privilege to serve with you and thank [Applause] you thank you all for your incredible service the incredible words you've shared this evening and your steadfast commitment to our children it's truly an honor and I would say a unique one as I look at school boards across the country to be surrounded and have the honor of serving with people who care so deeply about our kids first and foremost so thank you to all of you and congratulations uh and I know I speak for all trustees when I say we look forward to our continued work

034together to support students across all of our communities we yes photo break please stand by spe whe e I SC e together frco e it of for e e e all right we [Music] are back with all of our trustees and we'll now continue on with items H3 and H4 our external auditor reports and financial statements for item H3 the board is being asked to accept and approve of the external auditor annual financial statements for fiscal year 2023 24 and for H4 the board is being asked to accept and approve the external auditor financial and performance audit reports for proposition SN Z measures U and YY for fiscal year 2324 before I call on the audit committee chair and our Auditors to present these items I'd like to note that trustees Whitehurst and boso represent

035the board as members of the audit committee which meets four times a year to monitor the district's external audit and now and thank you for standing by and waiting I'd like to invite San Diego County Treasurer and tax collector Dan mallister who chairs our audit and finance committee and a representative from Crow LLP the district's external auditing firm thank you both for being here well first of all for that great great introduction I appreciate it it means a a lot you know hearing those kinds of words uh but we appreciate it very much and with me tonight is Charles uh who represents the audit firm that we've used for some time now um and Crow L uh AP uh and he was here to address any questions that might come from any of you um

036because it's important to include them um and they have done a fantastic job for us too very very positive um let me talk just quickly though over um a couple of personal things when I first started here 16 years ago I was up with some of the best and brightest people that you have uh for those total numbers of places but more than that my parents grew up here in San Diego my mom was an in uh an active person in the administration here as well as any number of um other uh placements uh vice president president I mean there were things that she got into that were terrific and we're very proud of that my dad started his career at Claremont High as a teacher and later uh others and uh everybody but me

037turned out to be a teacher related person uh and I'm very proud of those people because they've done a great job for all of us here as well as all of all of everybody out uh in the greater um area um we uh just talked a few minutes ago about uh what was good and what wasn't but we talked about the U good in place of adding too much of the negative side we don't want it but um there isn't much to report on the negative side I should tell you and uh um I asked our auditor to be here to take any questions that you might have from a his the get I'm pacel that's hard to do but please um come to the podium see if there are any questions that you might

038have or they might have okay uh good evening my name is Charles R um senior manager with Crow um happy to and pleased to have the opportunity to present to you the results of the end uh year ended 2024 audit um we have given an unmodified opinion over your financial statements over your uh Federal compliance requirements and uh we have a few State compliance findings which I'm sure everyone likes to zip to the back and look at those sets of findings on the back but uh relatively minor uh in the scheme of um the number of items that the state asks us to look at um in regard to State program so we have um you know no major issues to identify and and report on so I'm happy to address and um speak on

039any particular topic or address any questions you may have thank you very much I want to add also that uh everybody here who's supposed to be there uh shows up for the meetings and that's very very helpful to you as to well as our situation because we want the very breast and brightest of uh this effort uh each year um are there any questions that we could answer um yes ma'am not really a question but I just wanted to say thank you to Dan for chairing the audit committee and also to grow for helping with our audit and uh the meetings are always really informative and I think we have a good group and um you know questions are answered well and promptly and and it's a very comprehensive report and but explained in kind

040of like a way that you can understand it if you're not an accountant which I appreciate so I just wanted to really say thank you for your work uh in supporting the district and uh it's I've been enjoying being on the committee working with you thank you so much I appreciate it anyone else any other question yes ma'am I'd like to also reiterate that I think I've been on this uh committee eight and a half years um since I've been on the board and uh I really find it helpful to keep us on track as a district of there are concerns that we have the committee will bring in folks and talk to them and uh help us to look at things that we hadn't looked at so I really appreciate the role that this

041uh committee has served and thank you to Crow for all the work you've done for us so we'd like to continue you're welcome and we would as well any any other questions or comments again thank you so very much you run a first class operation really really impressive to work with everybody that I have a chance to work with here and uh it's really abundantly clear that they've got the best and the brightest here so thank you very much thank you is there a motion on items H3 and H4 thank you a motion from trusty white her pay and it's like a second from trusty baldis uh let's go ahead and vote student trustees please vote and all other trustees thank you the motion passes unanimously with student board members concurring and we'll now move

042to D1 general counsel green are there any reportable actions from closed session there are not thank you uh Dr bagula under D2 can you please share the management appointments you'd like to announce tonight yes thank you president Hazen I want to make some quick remarks about today's interum appointments today I'm excited to announce the appointment of some familiar individuals to keep positions to ensure stability and consistency in the work that we do on behalf of all of our San Diego unified students in making this decision I considered my own interm status while ensuring the least amount of disruption to the organization and the ease of absorbing additional workload with that I want to first thank Carol Osborne for serving as Deputy superintendent on a temporary basis and now please join me in welcoming the following

043individuals to the interim positions Nicole dwit as interim Deputy superintendent m Leo Allen as interm senior executive director of instruction who will lead our thriving School communities portfolio and Veronica Lopez Mendes interm senior director of instruction who will lead our multilingual education department finally we're also making the following appointments Amy Shackleford welcome back as senior Executive Director of Finance and Sandra McClure as principal of Ross Elementary School I'm really excited to have this team in place and so thank you so much [Applause] congratulations to all of the people named and thank you Dr bagula uh for continuing to move forward and assemble your team we appreciate it uh and now we'll move on to D3 if you want to please provide your information report beautiful thank you president Hazen and today I wanted to share

044with you where we have been together because we're headed to wrap up our 2024 calendar year and it's been about about four months since I took over as interim superintendent but just like I've done my entire career I welcome this um dive myself into this role and really want to make sure that I make the best possible decisions and Leadership moves for all of our students so working to make a difference in how this District operates and serves our students is my main goal here so first we pursued accountability through our data and metrics because we hold ourselves to high expectations we launched progress monitoring on our goals and guard rails to help us drive toward success UC ful to successfully educating our students with the Knowledge and Skills that they need to be successful

045once they leave our classrooms just yesterday we all participated in a workshop to Define um what we mean by student wellness and really get clarity around our student wellness goal this new year will bring even more progress with the clarity and purpose and intention that we have created through our student outcomes focused governance second regardless of the pressures that our children face outside the classroom we have the responsibility to make San Diego Unified School safe secure socially comfortable and thriving environments for all of our students that's what I'm here to do I have done this before with San Diego unified for democracy where we created Partnerships across our city and provided resources to contribute towards an informed and civil engaged electorate and student community and we recently celebrated the opening of our newcomer welcome centers

046thank you Dr Pon for joining us that will provide Refugee immigrants and newcomer students with resources and support as their families adapt to a new school system I also want to say that there's more work to be done but I'm excited to be in partnership with you I know where our value stand third we continue to be student centered as we strive to have a student and parent voice in the work that we do thank you trusty baldis and trusty Cruz for making the student Advisory Board a place where all of us on this board can hear and see student perspective I know I've enjoyed going and talking to them specifically about the cell phone implementation plan um and and luckily enough and this gave me a lot of joy is they already found a

047loophole in the rule so I think that's pretty funny but you know that's that's students reading the law um I've also really made made sure to establish a strong relationship with our PTA and so I want to thank PTA for making themselves available for several hours to look over our new title 9 requirements but also the cell phone policy from a parent perspective so thank you so whether the topic is Title 9 or compliance or goals and guard rails I want to continue to ensure that we're partnered with our parents and partnered with our students in order to be successful fourth I know we can do big things in San Diego unified so I won't say a lot now but I look forward to our upcoming presentation on the first interim and what it means

048for our students and colleagues at San Diego unified but I will say that we that we're looking for money in all places um we recently hosted the Harvest money festival at Lincoln High School thank you Dr um white Payne for being there where our children were able to access money for college I know we're planning the next one at lmec I believe we're even going to have a low rider show uh to join but we want to make sure our students have access to the college money that California has set aside for them finally we've done a lot of work together in just four months and of course there's much more to come we are here to deliver the best educational experience possible for our students um this is why I describe myself first as

049an educator at heart and as a steward of taxpayer dollars we have an obligation to keep students Cal to every decision we make be accountable to the students and families we serve and provide information about the district's progress and challenges in an open and honest way that is my commitment to you as in Trum superintendent over the weeks and months ahead there is no doubt that we have a lot more work to do but we're making the progress every day and we'll continue to do so thank you for everybody's support but also for all of the team that has been working very hard thank you and adante thank you drula we'll now hear item E1 the first reading of the 2025 26 Title One eligibility ranking report title one is a federally funded program that

050provides financial support to schools to provide students from low-income families with a fair Equitable and high quality education in order to meet academic standards Dr abula can you please introduce the item thank you president Hazen I'd like to invite diio Gutierrez director of strategic planning for student achievement for the first reading of 2526 Title One eligibility ranking report I'll turn it over to you now AIO thank you thank you good evening good evening trustees uh Dr bagula this evening my name is Dario Gutierrez I am the director of the strategic planning for student achievement Department it is my pleasure to be with you this evening and introduce uh tonight's Title One first read I prepared for each of you a very brief presentation on Title One and the title one first read report so just

051want to contextualize if we can get this clicker to go okay I think yeah now it's on thank you appreciate you so just want to contextualize for each one of you the purpose of title one so at its core is to support support uh student achievement for our economically disadvantaged students Title One is Grant funded and is determined by the percentage of lowincome students at the district as of a US Census date which this year was October 2nd 2024 so the services provided by title one must be supplemental to our district core program so that's very key for title one because Title One is Grant funded there are restrictions to the fund so they do come with some strings attached to it you can find a list of all the questions that must be answered

052by sites as a budget expenditures for the following school year so we're talking about 25 26 it is imperative that the expenditures are based on data and that they are explicitly listed on the school plans for student achievement which we uh hopefully will be presenting to you sometime in June or July for the following school year so this slide uh just provides a historical context of Title One funds here at our central office or District uh we have it through the year 2018 so an important consideration as we base our Title One funding is it is based on a projected Title One entitlement for the following school year so our financial County department is projecting about $38 million for the upcoming school year but we don't actually know our actual entitlement into well into the

053school year as a matter of fact we just found our final allocation just yesterday I was just given how much where our Title One allocation is for this particular year and it actually was a bump up from what our projected allocation was the previous year we were projecting $36 million for this year uh we just got received a report that's about $41 million for this uh for this actual school year so for 2526 the title War r ranking the following qualification formula is used so student eligibility is based on the percentage of students who are qualified to be low income or they're done through a direct certification process through the county office so sites with 40% or more of the students qualified for Title One are included in the formula I just want to um

054bear fruit that 40% is the minimum uh threshold that we have for Title One federal guidelines to run a schoolwide program school so a lot of questions about what is our minimum Thresh old it is 40% to be running a title one school white program school so based on the data that we've received thus far for 2526 we have 139 Title One qualified schools of which we will be uh having three new title one schools will be Ericson Elementary Sal Elementary and Henry High School so those will be our new uh Title One schools for the following school year for 2526 none of our schools dropped below that 40% threshold that I talked about typically when a school drops below 40% and they stay within 35 to 39 the board has that uh reservation to

055be able to grandfather them for additional year but because of the direct certification and the amount of the lcff forms that we receive from school sites we were able to maintain every single one of our school sites to be title one for this uh this particular year so also key at the consideration for school distribution of title and funds is you can see that Title One percentage has also grown from the years we you know 2021 you see uh 54% of our students were low-income qualified or direct certified uh for title one this year it's approximately 60% of our enrollment uh when it comes to title one uh some other things to consider is just a brief example of how we do our title one uh ranking reports in our allocation for school sites so

056Title One regulations stipulate that you cannot fund a lower rank School uh at a greater Pur student amount that a higher per uh rank school so uh at the very least we have to either maintain the same amount per student or we can uh give more per student at higher rank schools and we choose a latter in our school district so in our district we provide um intensive support to our highest need schools and the way our ranking reports is of of the 25 million that we will be uh giving out Distributing to school sites uh we give a base amount of 627 per Title One qualified students again at those High need schools and then for each percentage Point decrement uh and perc uh ranking report there's a $550 $5.50 decrement uh in the

057title one distribution for that so for ibar elementary here in this example there are 98% qualified Title One School site and that site received $621 50 per Title One qualified students and you could see their allocation for projected allocation for next year's 23679 to students uh dollars for a school like ocean beach where 50% of their students uh qualify for title one uh based on that $5.50 per student decrement each student uh qualified student would be receiving 350 $ 357.50 for a total allocation of 76,500 $5 I do apologize because I wanted to State something it's not a the student doesn't receive it it's the school we don't typically say they are a title one student it is a title one site and so I just want to be clear about that because when we

058run Title One schoolwide programs every student in needs of services receive those Services funded by Title One and that's the important of school white program schools so here's just a report that's on there all of you have access to the reporting in we have 139 schools that are Title One qualified for the upcoming school year uh they are ranked uh we do not have this year a 99% school it starts at 98% and we go down all the way to 40% again and you can see each of the projected allocations for the upcoming school year so we look at what the next steps are right now I talked about that October 2 census date we are still or the research and evaluation department is still finalizing the data from from that October 2nd census date

059to give us our final numbers there's going to be very few variances between the first read for tonight and the second read on January 14th of 2025 uh some of the stuff that's also happening is we just met with the da our new board uh last Wednesday and we shared also the title one ranking their interest is uh uh providing to the DAC General body what are the allowable and effective uses of title one and what are the unallowable and potentially allowable but uh not effective uses of title one so they are very interested in that we've provided already already finalized our Title One guidelines for the 25 26 school year and we will be ready to present that to the DAC General body uh next Wednesday so also additional next step is to also

060receive feedback from the DAC as far as the title one ranking and I will be ready to present any kind of uh feedback from them School sites are about to receive their uh SBB site based budget budgets for the upcoming school year so one of the things we'll be need to start doing is to start doing the priorities uh for the upcoming school year so that's the number one step they need to do is be looking at their data uh analyzing uh What uh is being implemented the School site currently and then start making uh determinations of priorities for the upcoming school year so at this moment I'm just happy to be here this evening and answer any questions you may have again the second read will be January believe 14th of 2025 thank you

061very much we'll now open our public hearing on the proposed 2526 Title One eligibility ranking report Miss stz are there any speakers on this item okay do any trustees have questions or wish to discuss trusty Barrera thank you president as thank thank you Daria so just a couple questions so going from 54% in 21 to 60% this year is that largely fact that we're doing better data collection do you think or it just reflects kind of the realities of our families well I could say that this year we did a much better uh job of collecting data from our families the low lcff forms I believe that may be a a speaking point in one of the following presentations believe we received about 96% % of our families whereas previous year we were only Gathering

062uh receiving about 86% that's fantastic a lot of families don't believe they have uh qualifi for services and so forth and so as we receive more data we want to get 100% but as we receive more U data from families were able to uh receive the funding that we know we these students are entitled to or these schools are entitled to receive that's great thank you so sometimes uh year over-year we may have a school or a few schools that take a significant hint hit um I'm wondering if we're noticing any of that this year uh I'll be happy to script through the data so the allocations are ranked on two parts they're ranked on the ranking percentage but it's also based on enrollment right so if a of a enrollment or Title One number

063of students does drop I believe I thought alcohol Elementary they dropped in percent but they also dropped in number of students so I don't want to say it's a double hit but they are being double hit when it comes to the allocation so it's not just percentage ranking it's also enrollment at the school site so I'm wondering if we do see that you know is there a way that we can kind of tailor a strategy to to a few schools so they don't have you know we can help ease that transition um rather than a school that just you know kind of has the botom Fallout uh from one year to the next absolutely I'm happy I believe we have a meeting on Friday for the January 14th I'll be happy to present that data

064for you yeah again the only stipulation from federal guidelines for title one is that we're not allowed to fund more per student at a lower rank scool yeah thank you trusty waiters pay thank you thank you uh you commented on the fact that one of my complaints pet peeves is we never know how much money we're going to get we're operating on a budget and you may have I don't know the state may say we're giving you this we're taking it back feds may say we're giving you this and we're taking it back the revenue comes in all different times lower higher and yet in this particular case as of yesterday you said that um we received $5 million more than we had anticipated that is correct so at the last board meeting in December

065the projected allocation for title one for the current year was about 36 37 million uh again they didn't the state doesn't give us the actual values and figures until right about now um one thing that we do to stabilize School sites is our the projections can go higher or lower uh what this title one ranking first read says is that we will we are uh committed to each School site that you will be using these values for the upcoming school year so uh the centralized services that we provide for Title One sites is what kind of absorbs that um uh Rank and in this case it actually was uh significantly higher than projected well that's a good news to the schools wouldn't you say yes right now it's that nice Christmas present thank you uh

066truste Cruz thank you president Hazen uh me personally I think this is one of the most important sources of funding we get not necessarily out of quantity but of purpose and so my question is how often how do we and how often do we check that this funding is being used as effectively as possible so that's a amazing question is actually a requirement uh for receiving Title One funds that each School site evaluates the effectiveness of the program um again tital one funding is to elevate the school services at the school site that's why it's called School White programs uh at the backage each one of the school plans for student achievement each School site is required to say uh what activities and strategies made a meaningful impact for your school site uh that was

067strictly funded out our title and fundings and which did not make any impact for it so it is a site by site basis we talk about uh Fidelity of programs implementation uh that off often is a concern for some school sites where we have a program or a service that uh seems to be making lot of progress at school a and then school be attempts to do the same thing but they're not able to implement it just the same because you know our schools are unique and they have certain situations that don't allow them to implement it to with that fality and so at the very least each School site is responsible for uh asserting uh that the title and services are making a meaningful impact for their students superintendent I I do want to

068add something to that question because I think it's very important um and that is actually the key feature of what a very healthy schoolside Council should be looking at on a monthly basis and one of the things that I appreciate from the team that we've been able to do is not only have data at the fingertip tip of principles um I heard yesterday when we were at marar ranch with u trusty baso the principal herself said this is the most access to data that I've ever had as a principal she's been a principal there for six years so having achievement data throughout the school year not just at the end is going to be beneficial and also thato thank you to your leadership we also have a very easy way for principles to look at

069their budgets on an ongoing way every single day if they want to um but what we were seeking was when you have your C meetings you can literally print your document for finances and you can also print data so it should be an ongoing study and discussion I know we have to work on the quality of SSS and true engagement but we really wanted to alleviate any sort of barrier in having that type of information information matters knowledge matters and now we're going to work on the quality of those meetings but I think we have a good um map to have um to to engage in a healthy way thank you for your question trusty baso thank you and just to follow up on what Dr bagula and trusty Cruz was were mentioning I know

070that recently we received a reports saying showing tital one funding that hadn't been used at schools yet and so having been out in the community at cluster meetings and things and I know this is contrary to what's being said but some I'm hearing from some of the principles that they don't always know how to access their F the amount of funding they have or in some cases and talking to the um vapa programmer program director is that they can use it for vapa and so there's still a lot of um I feel like not it might be some of the newer principles that are uncertain but um I guess just you know back to what you were saying Dr bagula we just need to make sure that all of our school leaders have that information

071and even maybe if they have it they don't realize or you know um that it's really specific so they're not realizing at the end of the year that they have $90,000 that they haven't spent and uh you know so that we we're making sure that those that funding is getting spent even though we're saying that they have the information this some of the prils are not are we're I'm hearing differently from out when I'm out at school so agreed and I I think that it does require training right because I think about as we enter the the field of being a principal we have a teaching credential we're in the classroom principal school doesn't do all of that and I know I at the dis I actually said that it was very hard to get

072the finance information I remember being frustrated so I was really happy to see that it's literally one screen now and so um I will gladly uh not only share that with principles one more time but set up a system to help support them so thank you yeah and also that they know what they can use it on in some cases too that's the other P I always had my little cheat sheet I understand like what's this code again oh that's right I can use it for this yes if I if I may yeah I'm excited I have an incredible team that I work with and they have developed these amazing tools um just one of the resource teachers last night just create this tool that is I told them this is sliced bread this is

073what I call it I'm going to call it I need to get to slice bread because the quickness and it's it's instant what he was able to develop where a principal will instantly see what their current budget status is instantly see their budgeted Field Report instantly see what they spend on peard it is amazingly quick what is out there that we've developing but it's about also communicating those tools for them but also uh providing the opportunity to share what that data shows right because I'm very familiar with the tools out there and what I'm looking at the reports and they may not be and so I know there's a communication the finance department I am uh incredibly grateful for the collaboration we have with them they were able to go to I believe 98% of

074school sites and talk to the front office and talk about those tools are available um at uh our our front office of our our first line of people sometimes the principals are in classrooms and they're working with plcs and so forth at the very least we have somebody at the front offices uh now accessing those particular tools thank you uh vice president Peterson thank you president haen so thank you so much for this um I probably bring this up every time a bit of a broken record on this thing but given my my subdistrict I I I see it probably more than it's typical in the other subd districts which is that you know you have very very affluent sites that have very few um very few um meal eligible students and they typically have

075foundations and they kind of back filled back filled out a little bit of the foundation money but the majority of the sites they're still up in the 30% range and I understand Title One there's a hypothesis and I think it's accurate in a lot of ways it certainly had concentration of disadvantaged in poverty certainly has a it obviously has an effect as concentrations of of advantage and financial Capital Social Capital educational all that they clearly have an effect but I you know as you're looking this there's probably I don't know ballpark figure I'm looking at all these 30% on the elementary side that fall you know you have this infinitely variable decrement that's going down and all of a sudden you have a Ste function that just drops them off but there's probably 20 thou

076or I don't know 15 thou 10 to 15,000 students who are free and reduce price uh meal eligible who are not getting anything really any additional funding and so I I I what I would I don't know how we think about this but and again that concentrated Advantage disadvantage that's having an effect so there's certain argument to to be made about it but look the student that comes from Cabrio or dwey which is they're whatever 65% or something they go to Dana and then they go to Korea and then they drop off they don't get any funding so that literally the same exact student who had the funding at Cabrio and Dy they're now in Dana and Craig not getting the funding and so I just kind of want to think through what it means

077for those students who are still they were benefiting from that funding when they were certainly benefiting from at kuo and they're still needing it at at so I don't know whether and and and lcff concentration funding kind of reproduces some of these challenges as well I I don't know what we do as a district in terms of making those students acknowledging that concentration of disadvantage is real but also that how do we make those students whole because they're still suffering a lot of those disadvantages just because they went to New School site and lost the funding they're still experiencing that so it's a big question maybe a little bigger than right now but it's something that's on my mind yeah and I think you know it's a choice I've asked that question in the past

078and I think you know what I've heard is it's a choice the district has made right there are other models um and maybe Dario can speak to this other districts where the dollars follow the child um the student um rather than the model we've implemented um which is looking at schools who meet this 40% threshold and there are I think pros and cons to each model but if you want to speak to that so the title and funding follows a by School boundaries so they could choice in but it stays with the presid in schools um as far as uh your question about like uh lcff and you say about the drop off when it comes to uh uh the lcff they get funding for three types of students we have the low-income students which

079would be the me eligible and then we have the uh Foster Youth and then we also have the English Learners um there's this um I don't want to say myth but that L lcff is not just low income there's uh we receive funding for English Learners that are not meale eligible or low income qualified so we we do receive a funding for that and that funding lcff goes to the school sites and that's why a school like is mentioned like Dana uh those students will receive uh some of that necessary funding through the lcff uh resource that we do provide to school sites again Title One is Grant funded you know I talked about you know there comes with rules and regulations and unfortunately uh when it comes to one of those rules is that

080minimum threshold we're not allowed to go below 40% for title one school way program schools that is the minimum threshold that uh set in guidelines I guess that's really helpful I'm wondering isn't there another option though in terms of a model where um you could do it differently so that even if there was one title one student at a school um the dollars would follow the instead of the way that we do it with the um sort of concentration based on the 40% threshold and maybe something to come back to us yeah I'll I'll double check with the county office have a strong connection there over the state and just follow up with that question give you the accurate thank you um did you have go ahead do you think we could advocate for there

081not to be a threshold for their what for there to be not for there be no threshold 4% threshold uh is Big go ahead Dr bagula I we're advocating for some change um we I already went to Sacramento to speak of this because is when we think about um the income the what's qualifying as low income for the state is very different than what qualifies as low income for San Diego and so we're advocating that that consideration and I know that other urbans large urbans we I met with the superintendant last week and we we're all having that discussion too and I have a couple questions clarifying questions I was trying to quickly sort of add up the numbers and appreciate you sharing the data for 1819 and then 23 24 24 25 um and

082then what we're projecting for next year and it looks like that in 1819 we received $76 million for title one and then again uh for next year we're projecting $76 million uh which is wonderful and surprising to me right as enrollment is declining we're not seeing I guess is it right we're not seeing significant decreases any over the last few years in terms of Title One funding is that accurate I'm sorry did you say 76 million yeah is that the I was trying to add up on the slide where you showed the different um title one so 1819 is approximately 38 million oh okay 15 was being uh allocated to school sites and centralized services so our centralized services are used for like restorative justice it's used for parent engagement it used for ah I

083summed up all I see what I did so but all to say 38 million in 1819 and again looking at 38 million so that that stayed the same even as we've seen significant decreases in or decreases in enrollment yes that's correct okay thank you and then you shared and I think it's great to hear that we're getting more Title One funds this year than we had projected um at budget adoption where do those funds go are they use centrally do they go to schools so it's uh part of the centralized Services uh for example um one of the the the new allocations or the that variant is going to be used to transportation for our homeless youth great uh mckenley vento act allows us to be able to use our Title One funding we currently

084uh have been using uh gfu for that we can actually use tital one funding for that particular purpose so it's thank you Cally and I really appreciate all the work um that the central Office Team and all of our sites have done to collect um more more forms I know you know going from the 85% of households to 96% is significant um and I know I believe it was last year um we had a parent from Patrick Henry who was saying there are a significant number to vice president Peterson's point a significant number of low-income students at the the school but because the school was above or I'm sorry uh fell below the 40% threshold they weren't receiving funding and this year they did a really great job of collecting forms um and now it

085looks like based on um what we're projecting the school will receive about $320,000 in Title One funding because it's such a large school and we're talking about about a thousand students uh so just really want to appreciate the work and encourage everyone all of our parents our families our stuff to continue working get us to 100% collection because every single form makes makes a difference um and brings more dollars to the district and to our students um I also really appreciate what um board member Cruz said um I think asking like how do we make I think it was remember Cruz about how do we make sure the dollars are used well and how do people how do principles and sites know how to use dollar as well and I think as we start to

086see these bright spots that are represented uh in our progress monitoring reports um and I know we just heard about seoa and as I looked at the list right seoa is receiving $65,000 in Title One funds I think be really interesting and important for us to hear how some of these sites are using Title One funds in particular uh to advance some of our district goals so and we heard at seoa that uh they have professional learning communities and are you know coming together um are they using some of their Title One funds to support that work um so that other schools and other principles and s's um can learn from the work um of principles like the one at seoa so thank you for coming for sharing for the work to help us collect

087more money oh last but not least oh yeah thank you very much I want to go back to the question that I feel like all of the trustees have been talking about you know we have these amazing programs before and after school on Title One sites can we look at advertising those to the entire district and to students that specifically qualify for free or reduced lunches if those programs are available for those schools we could look into some sort of way of transporting students there after schools before schools to benefit them if they're at a school that is beneath the threshold it's a great idea thank you oh and last last word trusty whiters pay um this discussion is one that we've had I think every year and usually it comes from the DAC rather

088than from the uh trustees themselves uh about disseminating letting the money follow the children and it it sounds really good uh but I think this law came about about from the kennedies uh John F and and his brother Robert worked on this way back whenever and uh I know way way way back if you go back into the history of this original act and they were trying to address the concerns of schools that uh had traditionally been marginalized and um there's the assumption that if you're attending certain schools then um the atmosphere the status the uh availability of things is greater in some some schools than in other schools so they were trying to meet those those needs and I really don't care how our kids learn I want them all to learn that is

089my passion and uh it's why I'm I'm really fighting for us to do whatever we can to help our students and right now the focus is on those schools that need it the most thank you thank you yeah it this all came about the elementary secondary educ elementary and secondary secondary Education Act it's all based on the war and poverty that's really what it was about been about 60 years now we're approaching 60 years since uh title one has come into play and that's again it's it really intent is to support student achievement that's really at the heart of what title what is about thank you Dario and thank you Trustees for discussion and questions we'll now close our public hearing and the district advisory Council on compensatory education our DAC is scheduled to discuss

090the title one ranking process and allocations at its December 18th meeting and then a second reading and requests for board approval on this item is scheduled for the January 14th board meeting we'll now consider items F1 through F3 collective bargaining Personnel matters and student discipline is there a motion on these items thank you I have a motion from trusty WHUR p is there a second second from trusty baso are there any speakers on Section F and do any trustees have questions or wish to discuss these items okay uh trustees please vote the motion passes unanimously we'll now consider board consent agenda items G1 and G2 proposed schedule of July through December 2025 board meetings and a resolution recognizing December as disability awareness month consent items are considered to be routine and will be enacted by

091one motion followed by a vote there will be no separate discussion of these items unless the board member of the public or staff requests specific items be removed from the consent agenda for separate discussion and action any agenda item removed will be voted on following the motion to approve the consent agenda does the board have any items they'd like to have pulled uh from the consent agenda and has anyone signed up for public comment on section g all right is there a motion on items G1 and G2 we have a motion uh by trusty Cruz and is there a second thank you from trustee baldes student truste please vote thank you and all other trustees the motion passes unanimously with our student board members concurring we'll now consider item H1 the fiscal year 20242 first

092interim financial report and resolution in the matter of intent to declare positive certification at first interim and identify the amount of budget Solutions needed for fiscal years 2025 26 and 2026 27 Dr bagula can you please introduce the item thank you president Hazen today you will hear from both drew our Deputy superintendent of operations who's joining us on the Das and myself um on the first inum um before I I begin thank you for joining us Dre it's good to hear will you navigate The Click yes I got you thank you perfect here yeah thank you in San Diego unified we hold ourselves to high expectations we're here to De deliver the best educational experience possible we have an obligation to keep our students Central to every decision we make be accountable to the students

093and families we serve and provide information about the district's progress and challenges and open and honest way that is our commitment we set out earlier this year to develop a series of goals to help us drive towards successfully educating our students with the knowledge and skills they need to be successful once they leave San Diego unified classrooms I want to make sure that we have get into the habit of always centering ourselves in our goals and guardrails hence the beginning of this presentation our goals of course involve student wellness communication and literacy mathematics and problem solving and College and Career Readiness we ALS Al have established guardrails to hold hold ourselves accountable for being better communicators with our children and families ensuring financial literacy as part of the curriculum for our graduates and keep our

094students keeping our students motivated to be in school and in class taking these goals and guardrails into consideration has been Central to the development of our budget when we adopted the budget in June and as we have continued the budget conversation in the budget Workshop in October we reported San Diego UniFi was facing projected deficit of 176 million for the 2526 school year today I'm pleased to report that tonight the projected deficit has been decreased by 36% and is now down to 112 million since our last report we have met with our school communities parents teachers principles to discuss the difficult realities of having to address a significant deficit as administrators we have challenged one another to be judicious and creative in our decision-making and to always be student centered to drive the projected deficit

095down from 176 to 112 we will be recognizing that we have $25 million in vacancy savings there is a lot of positions that haven't been filled including the deputy one that we just approved so thank you we will receive about $9 million more this year and next year for our unduplicated pupil percentage a 1.1 increase from our 2425 adopted budget we received this funding due to the number of economically disadvantaged students English language Learners and Foster and homeless students we have in our district and I really want to thank the entire team for increasing the lcff return rate thank you Dr delrosario for leading that charge we are also projected and having in excess of 25 million more in projected Revenue increases the places where we expect to see these increases include impact Aid 5.5

096Million Lottery 2.5 million interest 12 12 million and home to school transport at 6.4 all were increased this gets us down to 112 12 million from 176 we are making progress but between now and the next interim budget presentation in March we have more work to do we're already working on driving that $112 million to zero a couple of ways include a supplemental early retirement plan and attrition and a commitment to streamline our central office work by limiting our work to what is mandated and seeking efficiencies in all that we do one of these Solutions Drew Roland will discuss in Greater detail today is the implementation of the supplemental early retirement plan or the serp if you hear that acronym that's what it means for these reasons we are requesting that you today approve our

0972324 external and financial statements that we approve the first interim report and that we certify the projected fiscal Outlook as positive next slide earlier I mentioned the engagement we' done with this Comm the community involving the community in this budget is new this year we're really we've got a lot of feedback that how we were trying to engage really wasn't engaging so we changed a couple of things um so how we engage is at the Forefront of my leadership and so for example I'm currently reviewing two lesson plans that Dr Roberson created for teachers to potentially use in their classroom to gain more feedback from students I think we need to leverage student voice and so that'll be an offer offering that we have for classroom teachers that we will send out our Administration thinks

098involving those affected by our decision-making is vital to the success of our district and we need to hear their ideas and level set on what is and what is not possible we did send out a survey to learn more where families think and where we should spend our limited resources and about 600 responders have have contacted us and I still think we need more so we're going to continue to to show that not only what we receive but also an invitation to respond um and we're going to continue to hold budget workshops so there's more to come um some anecdotes we've received all types of ideas and we look closely at them and while every idea is appreciated not every idea is feasible so for example one of the ideas that kept coming up was

099to get rid of free lunch we've had several folks suggesting to get rid of free lunch to create cost savings but what those who suggested didn't understand is that free lunch programs come from a pot of money that cannot be allocated elsewhere so we're going to keep providing free lunch for every child who needs it this is also would be Central to our to our value system um we believe and I know I've said this now the last two workshops of maslo before Bloom children need to be physiologically taken care of with um as Izzy I believe said yesterday with a full belly to be ready to learn we also um have folks to say that we're to look at cutting from the top and we are looking at that for districtwide what are we

100doing at central office how is it how is a true impact for school sites what is mandated versus what is optional and really thinking about efficiencies at central office our overall assessment of our District's new approach to doing more Outreach and asking for feedback about the budget was informative for both our team members and the community so thank you if you've participated and if you haven't there's still opportunity to do so I commit to you that as superintendent we're going to continue to create opportunities for Meaningful dialogue between our district and the community around budget but also around other important DEC decisions we must be in Partnership this is all of our work these are this is all of our money and these are all of our children so I'm going to turn the presentation

101over to Drew Rollins our Deputy superintendent operations who's um been leading the the team and I also want to say thank you to the team of Educators who's been United with um Drew in order to achieve this so thank you drew thank superintendent just coming back to the slide for a moment and kind of focusing on the right hand side the actions for today been a little bit of a financial theme already um but you already took action and approved the audit of the 2324 financial statements and um in part that's a reminder that it's relevant here because the ending balance of 2324 is the starting balance of 2425 but you've seen that now we have the first inter room report and then also what a company's the first interim report is the certification of

102the projected fiscal out Outlook so just a reminder of the things we're trying to achieve with this presentation tonight um before we dive into numbers though I think it's important to set a level and our path for getting to that zero that $112 million uh down to zero as we develop a balanced budget for 2526 we have our first inter report which as you've seen and we'll hear numerous times we're at $112 million as a projected deficit right now we have a marker out there with the governor's proposed budget uh what the governor uh presents on January 10th uh certainly is very important to us and will be the foundation of of the work ahead uh we'll touch on more that uh the supplemental early retirement program or Ser uh two weeks ago we opened

103our Sur window for uh eligible employees on January 15th that window closes and which will tell us how many team members have chosen to retire and leave the district and I have a slide later that we'll get into that a little bit more we have the budget Workshop uh in February that's February 4th um and that is where we intend to bring these things together the governor's budget the ser and all that work we're doing on getting us to zero will be shared that leads us to the March 2nd interim uh again our intent is that at that point in time time our projected def uh deficit is resolved and then leading us all to the budget adoption that we have to do um in the month of June looking at 2425 we tried to

104just provide some of the insight into what we uh the factors we had for our Revenue when we looked at at the budget and was adopted in June and where we are are now in the first interim um as you can see we tried to also show a little bit of graphic of where those changes are slight dip in our uh enrollment slight movement then related to that with our Ada uh there's been a lot of conversation this evening already about our unduplicated pupil percentage that change that goes from 60.1% to 61.2% uh change of 1.1 um that and I guess just be clear on the conversation with that versus when we think about that in Title One versus what we're looking at here so this is related to the local control funding formula supplemental

105and concentration pieces of it so um as we uh we earn more money in in rlcf for each student that is qualifying under this unduplicated pupil percentage and again as Dario mentioned it's and and uh superintendent free uh economically qualifying English language Learners and Foster and uh homeless and again that all the unduplicated part of that is if you happen to be all of those three things you only get counted once that's the unduplicated part but again that translates that increase from 60.1 to 61.2 translates to approximately $9 billion for us across this year and next year and again thanks to uh Dr Del rosar Del Rosario and the data Insight team for the really tremendous work and the focused work they did on pursuing this and and the surveys uh to the families that

106that go behind this and then finally if you look at the bottom of three row those you see revisions to revenue projections which um total an increase of $12.7 million there's these are some of the ones that again superintendent mentioned and I'd like to point out that if you go back to our budget Workshop in October we had school Services of California they with us part of the tasking with them is a budget review that they actually just finalized we we literally got the report today but some of that work with our team and their team and that conversation is what drove these um understanding and realizing these these increased revenues so again we appreciate the continued collaboration with them it is just what that is it's interest earned on our money in our in

107our accounts with the county in our yeah y y and I and it is just that particularly we've we are carrying a balance that has earned and and we we are projecting it higher than we originally were Drew can I just since we're on this slide real quick the average daily attendance current year and the funded what's the reason for the difference it's not much of a difference but I wasn't sure why so um average daily attendance current year is exactly that is what we are projecting for it to be for this year how you get funded there are options you can either fund based on current year you can fund on previous year and you can fund on the average of the last three years and so there's a a little calculator we go

108into to determine what's the most Advan advantageous number for us in doing through that but that's why there's that again that subtle difference with it thank you we also look at our uh budget development planning factors um and we Tred to uh break this down into three groups because again I think we can hit you with a lot of numbers and we're we're trying to be a little more sensitive to that uh but you'll see the first band of being revenue revenue year-over-year changes and that's where we're talking about our Cola second band being uh year-over-year expense changes and then uh our slide got a little messed up there but you can see the bottom band is just that breakout of the employer uh contribution to the retirement programs count cers and calsters um a

109few things to highlight here as we show the circles going back to the top with our CA so we're watching that then we also uh circled as you can see that step and column um and again that is just recognizing that as our Workforce potentially changes with our Ser these assumptions uh a lot more of our higher uh tenure Employees leaving it changes the dynamic of th those calculations in that number so we just want to point that out as well but again it's all the work behind the scenes that goes to build the numbers that you see on this next page um so I guess again you'll see Circle the $112 million you'll also see as our projected deficit for 2627 $ 210.8 million that is a slight change from what you saw budget

110adoption um but what we really expect is as we take this work now from the 112 million and and bring that number down that is going to get at what we believe to be a lot of recurring costs and you'll see that with that we'll have much more movement and impact on the 2627 number um I think also just to point out we also show a strong longer ending balance for 2425 you saw 2324 coming in looking good 2425 ending balance looking good which again is affecting the numbers as we as we work through it and again get to that um projected deficit that was 176 for for 2526 was 176 now down to $12.7 billion as always this is a dynamic process and the numbers we present this evening are the best for now

111um and the numbers will continue to evolve and change on this slide are just some of the re many factors and reminders of what could influence our numbers and just to also tell you that our team is continuing to watch and monitor these one of our tools um for our budget work is the supplement Al early retirement program or plan known as the Ser it's underway uh the Ser provides an opportunity for some of our most senior uh retirement eligible staff uh to take this is a uh for those interested they must again apply by January 15 uh as you can see at the top uh the entire pool of eligible employees is 5,9 it's about onethird of our Workforce of 15,000 give or take and then according to our Consultants algorithm their expectations are

112that we will find uh that 755 employees will find that this is incentive is best for them we'll see I think some of us feel like the number could be higher but we'll see um obviously the idea behind this is it reduces our Workforce and provides the opportunity to replace a senior employee exiting our system with a lower cost Junior employee and also provides the opportunity to look at our organization and make decisions for the needs of the position into the future um as we know and as we are discussing here this evening we are driving to a balanced budget with no deficit for next year and ultimately we'll make the decisions necessary to do so in that sense the Ser provides an opportunity for voluntary attrition and will will reduce or eliminate the need

113for layoff notices that we would have to provide in this spring again that's all part of what we're doing and what we'll work towards um and again as we have it as our scenario draws it we are projecting that over the course of five years this is roughly cost neutral as we saw in the budget cycle slide uh early in the presentation the budget process is continual basically but there's just a few more comments we'd like to point out um when we think about the following the work from this point resolving the projected budget of $112 million here are some of our next steps um central office departments are working on their budgets the Departments received their budgets yesterday and into today um and they're now doing that work focused on streamlining and really getting

114down to what we are truly mandated to do and I think as importantly with that is how we go about doing it um as I mentioned before we're tracking to what opportunities come from the the Ser the window closes on January 15 uh we will have the data right behind that and we'll be evaluating that all of that leading to I mentioned the central office budgets then we will be uh providing the school sites with their budgets starting on January 21st which will incorporate what we have learned from the from the Ser in there um and then again as I mentioned all of this kind of coming together so that we can um participate in the budget workshop on February 4th review where we are and recommendations behind that to again get us to a

115balanced budget as I mentioned in addition to approving the first interim report report the board must also certify a fiscal Outlook related to the report there are three possible certification statuses positive qualified and negative and as you can see really comes down to that underlined keyword are making the difference between the three statements following that same order the district will meet may not meet and unable to meet staff is recommending a positive certification based on the progress we've made uh to date resolving that deficit or moving that deficit from 176 to 112 and knowing that we have the plan and an approach to resolve the remaining balance so again as I mentioned at the beginning of my presentation after passing the external audit we are seeking two additional Financial actions this evening approval of the

116first interim report and certification of the uh projected Financial Outlook and again with the uh recommendation that the sub the financial outlook for the current and subsequent two years is positive and thank you very much thank you so I am now looking for a motion on item H1 to approve the fiscal year 2425 first interim financial report and to approve the resolution to declare positive certification at first interim which affirms the school district will meet its Financial Obligations in the current fiscal year and two subsequent fiscal years by implementing budget reductions of $12.7 million in fiscal year 2526 and $ 2106 million in 2627 as outlined in a detailed budget reduction plan and will sustain a high quality education program for our students thank you have a motion is there a second thank you vice

117president Pon do any trustees have questions or wish to discuss these items yes now I know I spoke about this at the previous budget Workshop but I feel like I would not be doing my duties as a student representative if I didn't repeat some of the topics I spoke about right now as we see our average daily attendance going down our enrollment going down when we navigate this budgeting issue we really need to protect the programs that students love programs like vappa Roc the things that wake students up at 8:30 in the morning with a smile on their face ready to go to school we can't cut those programs if we do that our Ada our enrollment it's just going to go downhill and we really need to protect them they're not waking up at

1188:30 right waking up at 7:30 they're really quick they get up and out the door in 30 seconds uh trusty baso and thank you I remember when you mentioned that at the budget workshop and I'm completely 100% in support of what you're saying um trusty baldis and I think a lot um most if not all of us feel the same way and um again I sound like a broken record now too but um you know that's why I come back to the vapa programs I don't agree that we should just be cutting all of our programs 20 % without looking at what specifically that program is some programs like you mentioned are to see things that get kids out of bed in the morning we shouldn't automatically just say oh we're going to cut that

11920% we need to look at all the programs across the board and see which ones are going to is that going to really s make that program suffer um and more about quality I guess than you know just making a check checking a box that okay this program's qu cut 20% we need to look at what that is going to entail so thank you vice president Pon um so I got a couple of first of all just to be clear site budgets are not going to be impacted by 20% this is I'm not this is you she trusty baso knows that but just for the public that that's in reference to um central office uh cost so just to be clear just to not spook spook FS out thank you um and uh but I

120I just one of the things we've been talking this about a little bit you know we there's when you frame it in terms of projected deficits it doesn't really it it's it's a it causes a misconception of how you put a budget together I I would actually I mean presumably that category is necessary for state law but it we're really talking about projected required reductions because we're not going to not make those reductions and so to talk about it as a I don't when I when I look forward to next year and I go hey here's our budget next year I don't freak out about a deficit I like we have a deficit I just look at it we've allocated resources in a particular way and we're going to have to have a projected required

121reduction we're all committed to reducing that our labor Partners I assume are also so committed to reducing that nobody's going to push us into receivership so I just want to be clear to the public that is a required reduction and we will reduce to that to that extent it's NE it's never going to turn into an actual deficit because we don't run deficits period so I just want to be clear about that I also want to say I I personally and I I I think my board colleagues are are committed and and to to your point um we're not burning Furniture you know this is not about onetime we're not for we're not looking for onetime fixes ver there may be some additional onetime fixes but but broadly speaking the vast majority of these reductions

122for next year should should affect out years as well so I think that that is like as a board um that is my belief and to the extent that we discussed this in other context I I I I know that's the board's feeling as well so you know sometimes the public will come with some onetime fixes of various kinds but really in the end that's our goal is is some I don't know 95% plus of our reductions we want to be able to see those in now years as well so um those are the main things I want to say and I think also in relation to what we said last night and this to Echo um trusty boso the bells and whistles are not bells and whistles they're foundational um and one of the

123things we heard from almost every student and and um um trust trusty baldis was my elbow partner and and he brought it up again and again in terms of Wellness they talked about their their body their their their physical health which is an interesting thing you don't when you're at 40,000 feet you're thinking about learning and and Minds growing them minds and then they're talking about I didn't get enough sleep I didn't eat right I haven't gotten exercise I can't I'm I feel like when I'm not well I'm not managing my daily routine I mean so it's like I think we're all committed to ensuring that not only do we keep the reductions away from students but that we keep them away from the things that help students physical well-being and their relationships one with

124one another like the core of what we heard from students last night and have heard previously from students and I hear from my students if they don't get sleep we know about it and I'm sure their teachers know about it as well so anyhow that's all thank you and I agree and really appreciate that tonight's report LED with um our goals right really working to build a budget that aligns with our district goals and what we want and what students want for themselves I really appreciate that work um and that this budget will allow us to achieve goal one which we talked about last night which is student wellness um which aligns with this commitment we have have to student motivation and so that comes through things like Visual and Performing Arts as we heard

125rooc it's you Middle School athletics all of the things that motivate students um to come to school to be engaged in their learning uh and so I appreciate the work we've done to get us to uh $112 million uh and the work that we're going to do while maintaining um a focus on achieving those goals and those guardrails um that ref the vision and values of our community I am curious though um on slide eight where uh we have the cola um we you know what we've been told officially is uh the cola is 2.93 right that's formulaic we don't decide on that um that's decided for us and you shared that we expect it to reduce um potentially by 1% um and it could be about $1 million and so would that mean the

126deficit would then grow by 11 million doll potentially when you come back to us in a few months yes if if that were to play out that way it'll just reduce our lcff revenue and potentially that same Cola is applied across many other programmatic areas as well but yes that's what it would mean to the general fund unrestricted okay and so as we work to develop this plan the plan cuts are we mindful of the likelihood that the deficit is actually about $1 million higher anything of for anything that's why we have to go with what we have but what I'm hearing is it's highly likely that it'll yeah yeah it'll go down but that's that's that's true um I think the other maybe maybe somewhat of an offsetting component against that is we're also

127hearing uh Rel ly good news regarding funding related to utk and the reduction reduction in class size you know where we have the the 24 and 20 student class size this year depending on the age of the student next year all classes will be at 20 and it appears they potentially fully funded some additional funding support from the state to implement that is is again what we are hearing yeah and I think just to clarify and maybe particularly for student trustees who may have not be aware so uh we have uh required TK ratios for our youngest TK students which require us to have um one teacher for every 10 students but we're not actually funded in alignment with those ratios we're funded uh 12 to one and so what I'm hearing is it is

128that accurate yeah yes I mean it excuse me it's been a a transition and the transition is completed next year when all classes are uh the lower a 20 and a ratio of one teacher to 10 and with that uh it appears there's the potential for so for some additional State funding to align to that that's great and I know it's been an advocacy priority of ours um because the district has led on TK implementation and it's great to hear uh that folks are listening so that's great um let's see I had one other question um in terms of our reserves um looking on oh I think it's slide nine so does this these amounts um in terms of so on slide nine the ending balance which says includes required Reserve um does that reflect

129a reserve of two the minimum of 2% for each of so for the next two years correct we have for 2425 we're projecting that we will uh have a balance of $102 million but when you work through 25 26 we will end that year at just the required reserve of 2% which is reflected basically reflected in that $44 million yes got it and likewise in 26 correct correct thank you okay and oh I thinkk thanks for being my oh go ahead wait you know I I just want to say uh first of all I want to thank the staff because as I always say you're dealing with Jello you're trying to um solidify something that daily and I mean literally daily is changing and you're bringing to us the best that you have at the

130time and so I knew we were going down that rabbit hole of now the deficit the U the cola is changing so it's going to mean this is going to be something we have to we have to compensate for all of them and that's why I appreciated the um what's his name came here just a moment ago and talked Dar Dario yes he talked about the fact that we were not expecting to get but 30 36 million or 38 whatever it was and we wound up with 40 41 that's the nature of being in this public business we are at the mercy of we don't know what we're going to get this is the best that we can do tonight given where we are it will change I guarantee you tomorrow a senator or an

131assemblyman will get up and pass a bill that will change something else on the equation and we have to be flexible we have to be flexible and deal with it as it comes and that's why we pay you guys we appreciate all the work that you're doing because I know it's giving you more gray hairs absolutely but I don't have any more room there's nowhere else to go we do appreciate you guys staying on top of it trying to be transparent and give us the best information that you have but recognizing it will change I can guarantee you that it will change agree and and if the numbers aren't changing we're not doing our job um so and our we have a great team that has been working very hard to get us to this

132point we're very excited about Amy joining us and then uh we just have a lot more work ahead of us and and they're ready for it thank you oh truste Cruz so first and foremost thank you and your team for all the incredible work guys have been doing so I have a three part question so where were our biggest gains in reaching zero uh how did we find these gains how did we know that we could reduce here and could we Implement these methods of finding in other areas in our district so I I think when you when you really look at it um I would I would offer like one of the biggest pieces in all of this is vacancy savings and I would offer that we really have been what you're seeing here

133is US continuing to work the plan we've talked about and so um and and I think in in a sense it really is about um we're not waiting until July 1st the start of the next fiscal year to um begin to solve that problem so it's the work now um it is the being judicious about vacant positions and the idea that it saves US money now and we also look at it and say as we're doing all this work we really have to consider should we be filling that position is it needed and do we see that in the the the plan for next year and so it's been a lot of that it's the continued work as well on coming through resources making sure we are utilizing them as best we can uh utilizing

134uh a resource that has restrictions on it first and you know the last place it goes is to our general fund so it's things like that um um but there's a lot of um there's still a lot of work ahead of us there's there's interesting and good input from our budget survey and our community outreach that we'll continue to bring together to get the best solution that serves our students and serves our district as really as best it can thank you thank you Jesse Barrera thank you president hayen um so it's great discussion about you know what's going to happen with the call what's going to happen um you know with utk funding and and all of that is of course you know we know things are going to change you know just kind of

135wait and see what happens but then there's the work that we do to influence what happens and you know the we are so fortunate to have you know somebody as uh capable as Sierra cook you know in Sacramento that positions us as part of a larger Coalition of advocacy and so we we have the ability to also help determine um based on our advocacy uh you know what these numbers in the end look like and there's a reality that um that I think is important for us to focus on you know right now which is we are not in a recession and we've talked about this for the past couple of years in fact the economy is growing in fact the legislative analyst office most recent projection is I again three and a half to

136four billion dollars more for prop 98 Revenue okay so state general fund is growing under prop 98 that means money that has to go to uh K to 14 is also growing districts like ours um but this is true on you know on a average across the state are losing enrollment so we know we're in an ADA funded system which means we get less while the prop 98 Revenue Grows Right so that I think is always um in a in a in a time like this where we've got declining enrollment within school districts but growing prop 98 Revenue at the state level the question I think we all always have to ask ourselves is what is the state doing with that with that Gap and you know to the extent that you know the governor

137and the legislature are looking at using that Gap to help plug you know their own issues that's where you know I think our advocacy has to um you know has to Zone in and that can be in the form of you know pay us for the you know the ratios that we actually are establishing in utk and it can go to a lot of these priorities but we're having a discussion tonight about $12 million challenge in front of us um but the state is going to have to determine what it's going to do with at this point what's maybe an additional $4 billion you know for prop 98 in an environment where school districts are getting less of that ADA funding so there's choices is the point that the legislature and Governor will make and

138we've got um you know a person who can Zone in specifically on what those choices are and and as part of a coalition help develop you know our our budget advocacy points um so the work in front of us is the work that you know our team internally has already been doing and will continue to do but it's also the work that we're doing in Coalition with other school districts and education advocacy to influence the way that the legislature basically and the governor spend a windfall that should be coming so that we're not having to cut $112 million um uh and so that's that's work in front of us yeah thank you oh yep superintendent so thank you trusty Barrera for bringing for raising up those points I know next week we will be considering

139our legislative priorities um and we're also have been working with several foundations including that so I appreciate you bringing it up thank you we're Partners in them yeah thank you and appreciate the reminder that we are continuing to do the work in Sacramento to bring down as many dollars as we can get to support our kids let's go ahead ahead and vote student trustees please vote thank you and all other trustees the motion passes unanimously with student board members concurring we'll now consider District operational matters items H2 H5 H6 H7 h8 and H9 report of final cost information for prop s and measure you Bond sales agreement with Phase 2 systems emergency waiver for repairs at Henry High School easement to sg& and acceptance of the November 5th 2024 certificated election results is there a

140motion to approve items H25 6 7 8 and nine thank you we have a motion is there a second thank you and a second down there do any trustees have questions or wish to discuss these items all right student trustees please vote and all other trustees please vote the motion passes unanimously with student board members concurring will now consider items i1 through i46 the superintendent's consent agenda consent items are considered to be routine and will be Act enacted by one motion followed by a vote uh does any do any board members have any items they'd like to have pulled from consent okay has anyone signed up for public comment on Section I all right um let's oh I is there a motion uh on the section thank you and a second thank you student trustees

141please vote and all other trustees motion passes unanimously with student board members concurring we'll now receive public testimony on non-agenda items have we received any requests for non-agenda comment yes we have five speakers each person will have three minutes the first speaker is move to the other list Matilda Meyer um hello my name is Matilda Meyer um I'm a junior at Mission Bay High School this year and president of our school's Eco Club um this year our club has noticed just how much plastic our high school School alone produces through our food services um our Forks our spoons our salad containers our noodle containers um our wrappers they're all plastic um and those meals and the trash that comes with them are used for breakfast they're used for lunch they're used every day for every

142student that wants them um and they're available for in every school in this District um and that's a lot of trash moving us a lot farther away from San Diego's zero waste initiative um of reducing landfill disposal by 90% by 2035 um I'd also like to remind you that plastic utensils and food covered containers are not recyclable um and commonly used in school lunches um roughly 40 billion utensils end up in landfills every year in the United States alone Additionally the city of San Diego has already outlawed plastic utensils in the food service industry because plastic is not biodegradable it's a threat to the environment and the Earth um and it's also a potential contaminant in the recycling and organic waste recycling streams as a student I'm also concerned about the health risk of plastic

143utensils and containers research has shown that frequent uh use of res use can result in chemicals leeching into our bodies and bloodstreams and microplastics entering our organs these contaminants are particularly harmful to developing children and young adults like me um so what can we do uh I agree that providing free lunches to all students who need them um is really important so the best way to reduce waste become more sustainable and help ensure a healthy future for my peers and I is to reduce um the plastic that we use by replacing them with more environmentally friendly options um such as reusable metal bamboo or paper utensils and containers um because of this in the future I'd like to work with you to pass a resolution that calls for this transition from plastic to sustainable and

144lays out detailed timelines and guidelines for implementing this change um so I look forward to working with you and thank you for your time thank you Yasin Zia Yassin Zia Zia Mary Monk thank you for this opportunity to address the school board uh the Walter monk foundation for the oceans would like to thank all of you that came to the Walter monk Day event and we'd like to invite you to bring uh your families and friends to the map of the Grand Canyons of La Hoya over the holidays um we will be back uh in January hoping to um interest you in supporting um field trips for the underserved students to come to mount solidad and then down to the ocean it's our understanding that 75 to 80% of those students have never been to

145the ocean yet they live within a few miles how can they care about something they know nothing about we really thank you for your support and we're leaving you a few goodies here to enjoy over the holidays thank you thank you Orin Robinson and Eloise Kum Kima Kima that concludes public comment thank you all for taking the time to provide your comments to the board and superintendent today we appreciate your input and please know that your perspectives help us to better serve our students parents and the community this meeting is now adjourned a special board meeting will be held on December 17th for

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.