CorpusRecord 105866

Board of Education, Board Workshop Goal 1:Wellness

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / San Diego Unified School District
Date
2024-12-10
Location
San Diego County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
15,686 words · about 88 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening I would like to call this December 9th 2024 student outcomes Focus governance Workshop focusing on District goal one student wellness to order with all board members present we'll now move to adoption of our agenda as published is there a motion thank you I see two hands so we'll say motion by trusty Barrera seconded uh by trusty Whitehurst Payne Miss sutz can you please do a roll call vote of student trustees and all other trustees [Music] yes barera oo Hazen present here hon here white Hurst Payne baldis and Cruz here thank you thank you we'll now move to section c a workshop on District goal one student wellness our board has adopted four student outcome goals to guide the work of teachers principls and central office administrators from 2024 to 2030 to ensure all

002students reach their full potential of these four goals which are primarily academic in nature our board intentionally identified student wellness as our number one goal and top priority while we all want to see increased levels of student achievement in College and Career Readiness we agree that Wellness is foundational to long-term Student Success when our students are emotionally well and possess high levels of self-efficacy self-con confidence resilience and self-regulation and executive function skills they can take ownership of their educational journey by setting personal goals and charting their desired course towards College and Career Success conversely when our students are not well it becomes difficult for the best instructional practices and curricula supports to yield Student Success while our board has clearly identified Wellness as our top student outcome priority area we have not yet we have

003not yet received a recommendation for how to define student wellness or how best to measure it that's why we're here today to hear from the district team that has been meeting with external experts and engaging with students and Educators so that we can adopt a measurable student wellness goal by the end of this school year and begin monitoring progress against that goal next year I'd like to thank the entire team uh that's been working to refine our well school and everyone that has worked hard to develop and will be facilitating tonight's Workshop I'd also like to acknowledge that our student outcomes Focus governance coach Ben Macky is here tonight to help guide us through this process I'll now turn it over to Dr bagula to share your opening remarks thank you so much thank you

004president Hazen I'm excited to be here surrounded by colleagues but also by Partners um we really believe as as um president Hazen said this is one of the most important goals that our board adopted um and I know last time we work together in this room we were talking about um housing and we talked about maslo before Bloom and maslo is again there's the physiological right of Housing and food and safety but he continues with that uh hierarchy about safety love and belonging estem and self-actualization and this is again another Workshop about maslo before bloom um but I also want to say Ben thank you for coming on your birthday I appreciate that happy birthday thank you we als I'm also grateful for our partnership with San Diego County Office of Education Melissa Spen has

005been of great support so thank you um in the audience today we have some Partners from the California Department of Education Dominic Robinson who's a director of the whole child division is here along with some of our partners from San Diego State who are sitting right behind me and I think it's important for us to say see how um it this really is important for all of us the wellness and the human development of our students is important for all of us to do do this and be together um so I want to start I know we have a a PowerPoint but I want to get into the next slide if that's possible please before we get into this Workshop I want to remind us about where we've been because there's been a lot of

006work um that that has had happened based on this gooal so for example my myself I have met with researchers from the University of San Diego from UCSD from San Diego State with Dr Jeff Duncan andrad several different ways of how might we measure the outcomes of thinking about student wellness um even though there's a lot of desire to explore this topic all of them have said in one way shape or form that this is very Progressive and that there isn't something that's out there quite yet and we've even gotten into discussions around is it a measurement of joy is it a measurement of stress is it a measurement of belonging or is it a measurement of how strong my identity and the power that I hold is and so there's even discussions about what

007Wellness might mean um and so I want to make sure that this Workshop where we come together and think about not only what we mean by Wellness but also how we're going to measure what are we thinking about measuring um I have often described this goal as being very Progressive and I'm actually very proud of it and at the same time we also have to continue doing some of the supportive work across our school sites I've often described Des this as a parallel process of continuing to support our schools in the development of Health and Wellness but at the same time exploring and being Progressive about what we want to do and I just want to remind us that our San Diego unified has long been supportive of student wellness and we have made a

008several very key decisions to continue that so as a direct response to the incre increased need of social emotional and mental health supports after the pandemic we've made historic Investments we renegotiate iated the elementary counselor case load which in most cases doubled the amount of days students had access to outs outside counseling services this increased by 35 counselors we also partnered with seven local Community and Mental Health Providers to increase access to on-site individual in group therapy serving over 8,000 students since January 2022 we have opted to participate in cohort one of the student behavioral health incentive Initiative Program and Children and Youth Behavioral Health Initiative we've increased three wellness centers at our high schools to 12 wellness centers located both our middle and high schools in five clusters we continue to collaborate with school-based

009health centers to provide both medical and dental services at eight locations in our highest need communities we have leveraged our participation in Community Schools grant program to increase the number of designated Community Schools focused on providing whole Child and Family Services from five schools in our initial cohort to 25 during the 2425 school year and 10 more schools will be added next year so we continue to Embark in this work but always making sure that we understand that the wellness of our students and I'm going to add and our staff are key to this academic achievement um and so I'm really happy to see all of the I'm gonna say our village here today to really think about what we mean by wellness and how might we measure it I do want to say one

010thing that um I've been wanting to say for a long time so I'm going to go back to a meeting we had we had a student and I believe she's here um by the name of Addison Berard from Point Loma and when she gave her testimony to us about the um her work at Point Loma around helping students feel well or access Wellness I wish I would have gone on microphone to sit in the discomfort um because she spoke a lot of Truth to us about the current conditions of what a high school student is experiencing at their school and when I received it I know I wanted to sit in that discomfort a little bit longer fully knowing that we had a full agenda but I also want to say thank you Addison because

011your testimony was very impactful and I'm going to continue to carry your words with me as I help lead this District so thank you I'd like to invite Scott Irwin our executive director of student services to get us started Scott thank you for all of your hard work in putting this workshop together and thank you also to Melissa Spen from sdcoe for pulling up alongside us and taking us on this challenge so I look forward to learning together and to continuing our learning as we think about what do we mean by wellness and how might each and every one of our students Thrive at our schools so thank you very much you're welcome and for those of you that never met before my name is Scott Irwin I am the executive director of student services

012and I'm really excited to um be part of this learning opportunity that we're going to have together and and so uh I think it's important to uh start off with here we go I'm learning how to drive the I know that um there's a lot of work that you mentioned that's been taking place for a while over the uh goal of wellness and up on the screen you can see where our first attempt was as a district was trying to define something that we could live with something that's such a important goal that's so Noble to try um but really what we're here today to do is to share with you the learning that's taking place regarding Wellness um prepare a definition for you to look at and to um learn together about how we

013plan to assess this and I know that um that uh Fabby had spent some time talking about the why but I think that for me um one of the uh key Paces that I wanted to show is that from our research that we've been conducting with our partners recently that we have found a close Coalition between Wellness and success and I thought the quote that's on the screen really shows that not only Wellness is something that's important to us as human beings but it's something that uh people in the industry are looking for when they're looking for um people to work with them in the future so there was going to be two parts to our activity that we'll be doing today and the first half will be around defining wellness and the second will

014be then how to assess it and I what I really wanted to do was to um start off by um introducing some key people to you um but I wanted to let you know that these key people are going to speak to you about a Common Thread that you'll be hearing about today um in this presentation which is what is Wellness how do I know when I'm well and how do I assess that that's going to be a common Strand and um you're gonna bear with me here but you're since you're talking to someone who's a former Middle School administrator I can't help but feel that I'm a teacher all the time and so uh board members I'd love for you to take a look at your packet because we actually have um a document

015that I'd like you to refer to right now we're calling it The Board Workshop not catcher take a look in your packet and find this because we're about ready to ask you to engage into an activity uh that you're going to do right now your packet um if you don't have this document the not catcher in front of you just let me know because we have extra copies that we can hand out to you we also have pens too by the way what I would like for the for you folks to do right now is to take a few minutes on your own to just jot down your think which is so important as Learners is to have some processing time and the question that I would like you to reflect upon as a board

016member is how do you know when you are well and what measurements do you use to measure your own wellness it's a very individualized question but take take about four minutes to jot your thoughts down and then we're going to create an opportunity for you to have a conversation with a thought partner yes ni has a do we do we break that box of pens excellent yes I'm good thank you I'm good thank you for e e so give me like a thumbs up if you had enough time or or maybe you can give me a number sign that tells me I need another minute to finish my thought got some thumbs up got some thumbs up I think we're doing okay you know communication and conversation is the key to all learning right and

017so we're going to engage in some partner talk now because this is a classroom and we've just rearranged the seats recently now to kind of redefine who our our partners are our elbow Partners so my elbow partner is Ben so I'm so I'll be having a conversation with Ben and we'll kind of go down the line figure out who your elbow partner is and now what I'd like you to do is take about four minutes to share your thinking explain to your elbow partner how do you define wellness and how do you know when you're well by understand how to own so what would your answer be so my answer would be I'm able to sit Cal without thinking about the next I'm able to e e that people doubt that always e so as

018you're having your conversations keep them going but we would like for you to focus in on the question on the slide that says what do you have in common with your partner so just be thinking in your minds what elements of your conversation do the two of you have in mind that are the same e okay folks we're going to try to pull you back together again I just wanted to uh hope you appreciate the through line that will be taking place in our learning today the question of how do you know your well and how do you measure it will be the same question that you'll be hearing from the students that'll be speaking today and it's going to be the root of our conversation that we'll be having later on about measurement before

019we introduce it to the students though I thought it was important that we sort of recap where we have been um and you know as you listen to to Fabby just mentioned about a lot of the work that's taking place with Community Partners and other groups grp for us to come to a consensus regarding our definition of wellness and um and and a measurement tools I I think that what was really important though on this slide is to emphasize the fact that there is a lot of work that's been taking place recently especially since that July 16th board meeting that we had if you remember during that board Workshop the ask was find out what Wellness is and how you can measure it and we've done that and that's what you'll be learning about today

020um but what I would really love to do is uh kind of follow up on our conversation that uh I had actually with with Richard barrero we were talking about the importance of student perspective and you can see that's represented inside of this journey along with some of the other groups that we partnered with you'll hear about later and we actually conducted a student wellness think tank that took place in the 20th of November we reached out to students from all across the district you'll notice that there are elementaries middle schools and high schools that are represented and we asked them the same questions we just asked you and spoil alert later on you're going to learn a little bit about what the wellness framework we're sharing with you today but feedback from that Wellness

021Think Tank was incorporated into that definition along with the feedback that we received from the other groups that we've been partnering with we were very impressed with the information that the students had to share we showed them the wellness definition we created and they said it was clearer that an adult wrote that un that's that's was there before we knew we needed to figure that one out but what we thought would be interesting that you might enjoy would be an opportunity to listen to five of the students who were present at that Workshop who volunteered to come tonight to speak to you so we have been uh you'll be learning about lots of Partners during today's presentation um Dr belan Works in our whole child department and the San Diego County Office of Education and

022Dr Mariana Gomez is the director of counseling for the San Diego Unified School District and both of those uh leaders are going to help facilitate a conversation with these five students I'm going to turn the microphone over to Dr Tan and Dr Gomez and I think she's going to have the students introduce themselves now when the students are speaking again we're learning look at your note catcher you'll notice that there's a section section called the student panel section and this is an opportunity for you to chop down any ideas or thoughts that you might have as you're listening to students um because later on we will be reviewing the wellness definition and we want to make sure that their perspective is incorporated into it so uh please uh give a round of applause to Dr

023Tan and to uh Dr Gomez and the [Applause] kids good evening everybody we're so happy that you're here today and most of all I have the pleasure and honor of facilitating with my partner in crime Mariana all the students voices here today um before we ask the questions we're going to have all of them introduce their name their grade and what school they're in okay and then we're slowly passing the mic down so go for it I'm Isabella Russell I'm in seventh grade at Marshall Middle School um my name is Kevin I'm at Stanley Middle School and I'm in eighth grade my name is Lauren Lee and I'm a freshman at script High School hi my name is Addison Boward and I'm a junior at pointloma high school all right good evening everyone we're going

024to go ahead and get started with the few first question to the students and I will pass the mic to Addison the first question is how do you know when you are well so during our discussion at the think tank about Wellness I think one of the biggest things that came up it's not anything spectacular but it's like I'm someone who's involved in a lot of different organizations and activities and it's things like this like coming to an environment like this and wanting to be here rather than feeling like I have to most of the time I'm an incredibly motivated student I care about my classes I'm involved in AP and honors classes I do things outside of school and I want to do all of it but in periods where I am not feeling

025well it feels like a chore getting out of bed and going to school feels like things that I'm dreading even though I know I want to be there and that there are environments that I care about being in so it's simple things like I know you can see I'm in a basketball jersey right now I came from basketball game so it's things like that where instead of feeling like I have to do it I feel like I want to do everything I'm involved in I'm happy to be there I'm appreciative of being in environments that I chose to be in and it doesn't feel like I have to go from thing to thing it doesn't feel like I'm dreading starting the school week and it doesn't feel like I'm dreading tests and doing homework and

026studying for classes instead of motivated grateful for the opportunity to be there and I know that that it differs on a Case toase basis but in overall periods of not feeling well the majority of my life feels like a chore and that's a moment where I have to reflect upon my own wellness and realize that it's probably not as good as it should be because I enjoy everything I'm involved in and so when I'm not feeling well it's typically the opposite and the second response is from Isabella um I know what I'm doing well when I'm um alone and um I don't have to like worry about anything and I feel hopeful in myself that I know I'm doing well in school I know I have a place in my school with like friends and

027things and um I can just like breathe well and then I also feel well when I'm with friends um and I don't have to worry about anything and I have nothing on my mind thank you so much the second question how do you know when you are not well and we're going to pass this to Kevin and Lauren so for me um feeling not well is kind of based on a combination of things so first physical health um one of the main things of physical health is like sleep like a lot of people actually in my school they don't sleep like the recommended amount of hours and I can see they have lack of performance in school which makes them feel even more down and it kind of leads to more and more bad things

028um also like nutrition and fitness PE is very good it makes you go outside um and eating bad foods means I'm not well and if I have low exercise and the other thing is mental health um relationship with your family friends um and if you feel unmotivated or stressed um or unhappy and pessimistic um a main thing is your opinion of yourself which allows you to appreciate others which forms good relationships so it's very important to have a good opinion of yourself and it's also what you choose to do with your free time like if you choose to do good things like read take a walk um that's well but if you do bad things like just spend all time on screens that means you're not well and um so I think the main things

029are like the amount of sleep the amount you drink you need to get good sunlight you need socialize and lastly um it's mainly you're well if you have joy not pleasure so like Joy is longterm pleasure is just like getting fun out of eating good food but joy is like always been happy so you're like what she said you're looking forward to go to school thank you can pass it to Len um I'd like to add on to Kevin's statement I'd say that when I know that I'm not well it's basically a discrepancy in my typical lifestyle um I usually withdraw from friends and family or social activities because I feel so overwhelmed to chat with them and usually this is because I feel irritable or overly sensitive because of the overwhelming stuff going on

030in my life like homework tests maybe even just like a friendship that like just ended unfortunately and this makes it a struggle for me to express my feelings to them comfortably and this puts me in an awkward situation and also I procrastinate a lot especially by going on my phone and scrolling on social media videos um that always like happens and I also neglect self-care practices like Kevin said and like exercising eating well I typically eat a lot of sweets and snacks I hate to say that and during these situations and I usually have changes in my sleep like Kevin also addressed and I have like sleep disturbances like insomnia and this also leads me to my next point of I feel like I have lower grades when I'm not well I see a correspondence

031or a relationship between these two when I feel unwell my grades lower and when I feel well and like vice versa my grades go up because when I feel not well and my grades are tanking that makes me feel even worse and I continue to do well and I spiral down this like constant Rabbit Hole of like bad grades and I also avoid situations I normally enjoy like hobbies that I would do again like um Addison said that like if I'm not well I would not do like things like outside school like extracurriculars that would take more of my time thank you good job the next question is what information do you use to tell you that you are well and we're going to pass it to Addison and Lauren thank you um to tell

032that I'm well it comes from a bunch of factors so I know you talked about grades citizenship is a big one for me so a lot of how citizenship is measured isn't just your ability to show up to class but to show up to class on time so especially being a junior and upper classman I'm able to drive myself and so waking up early and showing up to school ahead of time being prompt to my classes especially with we had our uh passing periods reduced in time so making sure I'm getting the class on time I'm not talking to other people I'm not walking on my phone I'm trying to get to where I'm supposed to be that's a big thing for me um also with citizenship comes wanting to raise my hand wanting to

033participate Beyond just what's like expected of me but what I want to do I want to get engaged I want to communicate with my like peers and so a big one for me is citizenship which I feel like goes goes along with grades just your overall participation in class um another thing for me is just my ability to like have self-confidence and be prideful in myself so um I identify as queer and being a queer student and being involved as our GSA president a big thing for me is being comfortable in my own skin being comfortable within my identity and being comfortable at school as who I am not feeling I like as if I need to Shield myself from other people or as if I'm not welcome at school so a big thing for

034me is knowing that I can go to my classes and feel safe that I'm welcome as who I am and just you know overall have self-confidence which I feel like especially at the high school level and Middle School level is a thing that students struggle with a lot so it's just feeling like you're welcome at your school and like you know that the places that you go to are safe spaces for you and then for eating habits and things like that too like I know that my Wellness goes hand inand with exercise my ability to show up to things like Athletics and to want to be there too so when I am well I eat well I exercise a normal amount and I want to engage in all those activities when I'm not well the

035opposite occurs I'm eating either not enough or I'm eating bad foods I shouldn't be eating or I'm exercising to a point where it's unhealthy or I'm not exercising at all and I'm finding excuses to avoid either showing up to class or showing up to extracurriculars I enjoy thank you and Miss Lauren yeah adding on to Addison I'd like to say that I feel comfortable seeking help from my peers when I'm struggling that's how I know that I'm well and also I like to say that I'm nicer to my friends and family which is not a good thing um when I'm well I just feel like I'm comfortable like having fun with them doing fun things with them talking with them and also I participate more in school like Addison said because of course I'm in

036a better mood and I have a more positive outlook for the day and I feel energ more energized more engaged in the Hobbies I enjoy I eat healthy and I exercise a lot more especially when I'm feeling well and that typically helps me motiv like motivate for like the rest of my studies that I have to do after my exercising and I talk to my friends a lot more if I didn't say already and I think overall my sleep is regular and all my lifestyle habits are like constant throughout thank you thank you question number four imagine yourself doing well who are you with and what are you doing we're GNA ask Miss Isabella and Lauren so for me it depends sometimes if before I was not feeling well I would want to feel well

037by like staying in my room and uh being with my dog and just listening to music like just isolating myself from everyone else so I can have my alone time and like think to myself and um just like see what I can do to make the day better and just so I can have time to myself just to feel better but if I had a good day and I feel like I did do well that day um then I would want to spend my rest of of the rest of my day being with friends and family um like every Friday I go out with my my friends and we just have fun and that's most of the time when I'm feeling well um I was gonna say something take your time oh right and then

038um I noticed that a lot of people feel better when they're around their friends because they're just happier and like themselves so I recommend doing like more um outside of school activities like like socials like dances kind kind of and um doing like to get the students more involved so they can be with their friends more often um yeah thank you yeah adding on to Isabella um I as a member of like Mo trial mu Science Olympiad I feel really engaged and happy to be a part of like a bigger Community being more productive and in a welcoming environment with others that share the same interest as me and again I like hanging out with my friends and family where we can talk have fun together engage in small talk and I feel like being

039a part of a club really helps like expand your horizons and it really motivates me to continue pursuing other interests because clubs really they're your surrounded with people that push you to do better things and pursue things that go above like your standards that you're typically accustomed to so that's what's doing well is bettering myself by being around those who are also bettering me thank you [Music] the last question is how do you take care of yourself so you feel well and we're going to pass the mic to Addison and Kevin so a big one that unfortunately has not been going so well for me recently is sleep I think that as many of you can imagine High School's very stressful and with finals coming up I was always someone who slept eight hours and

040unfortunately the last couple weeks it's gotten a lot less I feel like a big thing is like time management so ways that I take care of myself is knowing like I can't take on this extra thing if it means I'm going to be sleeping less that night so looking ahead at the begin of your beginning of your week trying to you know not just take it on a day-by-day basis but recognize that this time next week I'm having a lot of things after school I also know that I have finals so I might need to take on less that I'm able to get my homework done get studying done and still be able to sleep so I'm not up until the middle of the night because obviously when you don't sleep as much you're going

041to score not as good in your finals the next day so although it may seem in the moment like a good idea the next day you're struggling to get through everything and it's getting really challenging um another way that I try and take care of myself is meal prep and I guess like I that's like a a pretty random one but like at the beginning of the week if I have enough energy which goes along with being well on a Sunday night than prepping my breakfast and lunches at the beginning of the week because especially like I feel like a struggle of student athletes is there's not a lot of time during school and so you just might skip lunches which ends to either you know binging behaviors later or or just overall fatigue during

042games and practices so a big thing is like having access to meals or just driving myself to school soon enough where I'm able to access school lunch and things like that so getting to school early enough so I'm able to get School breakfast because I know it's a priority for me to eat and eat good food before school so I feel like it's just those typical behaviors taking care of myself like showering enough you know eating enough drinking enough water water is a big one for me and just like making sure that I'm able to show up to class ready to learn every day and then Kevin [Music] working hello oh now it's working you need a few seconds okay so it just depends on like how often I'm doing my hobbies versus harmful things

043like such as like spending time with others playing instruments running um drawing um and to help you do this um I learned about this thing called implementation intentions where you um write the exact time and um the exact time and date you want to do something and like how long you would do it so like it's not just based on motivation if you do good if you do your hobbies and you won't just um end up just always being on the screen um and because what you do has a lot uh to do with how well you are um and relating to that I feel like if you're more successful you'll be happier which would lead to more success so I feel like wellness and success are kind of linked in that way so but

044it's the same thing vice versa if you're not well you'll be less successful and that will lead to um being even worse so and another thing I think can help is like trying to improve yourself setting goals um that can make you feel optimistic and proud of yourself and also another thing is posture um also um smiling and um make um smileing is actually shown to make people overall happier and um what I think schools can do to make us feel more well is they can teach more about like the important things like sleep and rather than forcing things to do things they get them to want to do things um also um don't overload them with work and um improve their relationship with the teacher to make sure they have someone to talk to

045and um I um read something I think that like schools in Finland they focus more on collaboration than competition and it's shown that actually they have better grades and they have more success than anywhere around the world so that links more to my point where Wellness leads to success and another way is to teach time management and I had this teacher who like every Friday instead of assigning homework she assigned what she called Soul work where she like tells us to do something that would be good for our mental health for example like taking a walk I think this should be more widespread and more teachers should do this thank you so much Kevin everybody give a hand to all our students today and I know it'll be a great impact all your words as

046Kevin already told us about our posture all everyone fixed our posture your words are going to be very important for our work so thank you all what I what we enjoyed so much about listening to the students in the wellness think tank is the feedback that they provided us really fit into three different categories if you were listening you heard them speaking upon what is Wellness you also heard them talking about how to measure it and then you also heard examples of solutions they had for promoting wellness and so it was a very useful experience for us as we're trying to figure out next steps in this goal because we had elements that we were able to incorporate into a wellness definition that we're going to share with you shortly there's Concepts that they'll be

047involved in in the spring when we're uh spoiler alert but we'll be talking to you a little bit about how we're going to get student feedback on assessing and then finally you can already see they're already given examples of strategies you can use and so um it was just it was just a wonderful experience and what I wanted to do was U before we jumped into the next step which is for you to to be able to explore the current draft definition of Wellness I thought there was a couple pieces of information that I should share with you the first is a quote that we found in some of our research that's taken place recently that talks about the importance of the importance of us defining Wellness before we move forward with the assess it

048this article that we had found was very fast fasinating because it mentioned that there is no one Ideal tool for measuring Wellness because there's so many different ways to Define it and how can you measure something you have not defined and so what we loved about this H quote here is that it really emphasized the importance of the work that we as a group have decided to do which is today to Define Wellness you know uh before this meeting I had an opportunity to meet uh Dominic Robinson who represents the whole child division of the California Department of Education and I gave him a copy of the wellness uh draft Wellness definition and framework that you're about ready to view first thing came out of his mouth was where did this come from I just

049thought that I thought it was such a poignant question and um well I wanted to let you know that it came from a lot of different sources and this screen is designed to highlight some of the Community Partners that we who've been incorporated into their thinking into this and you can see how the alignment we put division 2030 but I think there were really two pieces that I really wanted to emphasize to you first so that you can be keep an eye out for it as you're reading this on your own the first is the fact that we decided to ground our definition of Wellness in the work of a gentleman a psychologist named Adolf Adler who believed that Wellness uh that Wellness was really driven upon our connection with others um his his con

050he used the term individual to describe his version of what Wellness was but it was really based on the idea that we Thrive to be with other people and that we want to fit in and we want to be included and you heard that kind of language when you were listening to the student speak um I think that the other piece that I think it's important to emphasize is that when you're looking at the wellness definition look for where it references safety and love and belonging and self-actualization I when I was listening to the student speaking I heard them using language such as I need to feel like I can be in control of my situation that I can have supportive uh supportive spaces that I could value my connections with others feeling connected you

051will heard the students and uh referencing the importance of healthy food and exercise in the physical being and you will um and referencing Hobbies healthy ways for me to be able to release my energy um but you also emphasized uh you heard students emphasizing their own versions of self-actualization when they were saying things like I know I'm well if I'm able to accomplish goals and if I'm able to have successful time management remember sleeping all night long working all night long studying and then being bombed out the next day just doesn't do you well when you're trying to take a test all of those elements that you heard those students uh share we've tried to incorporate into the Wellness definition you're about be ready to review and so we have an activity for you again

052um take a look at the draft Wellness definition framework that's inside of your packet because we're going to ask you to take some time to review this document as a matter of fact it's going to be a two-part process you'll be using your um elbow partner again so remember who they are and what we would like for you to do is to review that draft Wellness definition and as you reviewing it we we'd like to for you to think about the questions that are in the note catcher underneath the third section on the first page you'll notice that it says what assumptions do the authors hold about wellness and then what do you agree or argue with in that definition these are elements that we use with students all the time when they're accting a

053piece of text it's a great way for us to make meaning so use your annotative skills for the next five minutes or so we're going to have you on your own uh review The Wellness definition be highlighting parts that you like or you you agree with or you argue with and be thinking about what do you think the authors are trying to say about what Wellness means when this is finished you'll have an opportunity to share your thinking with your elbow partner so we'll give you about is there any questions on what the next task is thumbs up from the Learners I see two three four five okay good all right so uh you guys have five minutes to review that text you can mark it up and then we'll get back together and talk

054about next steps in a second e e e good question yeah if you haven't started turning and talking please turn and talk and just uh uh remember to try to summarize your thinking with your partner and what elements do you agree upon e e e so we'll give you folks about another minute to finish up your conversation regarding what elements you agree upon and what you think is missing and then we'll have a whole group conversation e e okay we're going to try to bring the group back together here because our goal is for us to take the learning that's taken place over the last few minutes together to engage in the whole group conversation regarding wellness and for us to find something that we can commit to so that we can continue our work

055in this area I wanted to just remind you that we had that opportunity for us to build our knowledge around the working definition of wellness and Ben Macky is going to lead us if a conversation with the board um regarding what our learnings are what we agree upon and what are um do we have something we can live with thank you so much and first I want to say thank you and congratulations to the San Diego unified board Administration Community this is a conversation I see happen a lot across the nation with different Boards of various types um and the level of depth with which you all have engaged and chose to really dig into this says a lot about the values and the purpose and what you're trying to achieve for the students and

056families of San Diego unified um and so for that I just thank you for allowing me to be a part of that before we get into this discussion here and I think it's so critical I have a question for the board and it's going to be from two different questions that have been asked here tonight what's the difference between asking are you feeling well and ask asking how do you know when you're feeling well and what do you do about it who will be the first to share Richard it's a I love that question Ben and and I think it's it's why we're here tonight um if you ask are you feeling well I've got an assumption of what that means the person I'm asking that question to has an assumption of what that means

057and so we might not even be able to have a have an honest conversation with each other about what that means um so I think that's that's one big difference between that and actually coming you know to a common framework that um that then if we have a common framework that then we can start to actually know whether we're feeling well but we can't do that and until we get past assumptions and have a common definition yeah thank you for sharing that we have a we we can get past assumptions and have a common definition that way I know when I ask you if you're feeling well if you're responding in the same way that I'm pering it that's what I heard thank you what else is the difference between those two questions Cody well

058the first is you're eliciting a feeling and the second you're eliciting thought or metacognition um and I you know right off the top of my head I one of the things I appreciated about the student panel and my partner here my elbow partner is that grounding in something much more basic you get on a board and it's a bunch of Eggheads and we start thinking through thinking about it and so for me that getting back to what it the the bodily experience of wellness and the the mind the the feeling experience of Wellness I I I appreciate that yeah what I hear you saying is you those two questions elicit a fully different response one is about eliciting a feeling that might be in the moment or might be longer lasting another one is something

059deeper it's a metacognition it's an understanding of General what's going on and how can I then verbalize it or actionized thank you for sharing Quinton yeah I was gonna say to Cody's point it's so important that second question to get more basic I mean as a district it's easy to get so over complicated in the intricacies of Wellness when truthfully Wellness can just be you're have healthy body healthy relationships and a healthy mind so I think that second question just getting very ground level is so important thank you for sharing yeah getting ground level to a deeper element of it thank you Quinton sha yeah and I think you know maybe that second question gets a little closer I'm thinking about the other work we've done in terms of the other goal domains um but

060a little closer to an outcome right so not just how are you feeling but what difference is that feeling making for you um and I think it allows us um to understand if the way you describe what that feeling actually looks like and means and how you you know it is common um to our understanding um and if then if we can sort of like compare that across you know entire student population um to make sure we're understanding this all accurately yeah thank you for sharing that it definitely gets closer to an outcome and you know what we talk about is what students know and can do versus a momentary feeling which oftentimes in a school system adults are the ones creating and so thank you all you have chosen to dig into this work

061and really try to understand and get to the point about how am I creating a system where students are able to understand their Wellness really dive into that and take agency in creating that Wellness going forward but before we can get to all of those questions go ahead Richard there one other thing that occurs to me in the question that you asked so I think we've probably all experienced this um I've often heard from people who grow up in other countries that when Americans ask how are you doing we don't really want to know the answer you know it's just like a proor thing um and so then if somebody starts to answer that you know it's oh God why did I ask um so I think what we're getting at is taking this seriously

062enough that we're not just saying oh yeah Wellness matters or we care about Wellness to the point that you know I hear fabbi making which is okay but now if we have a definition we have some metrics then what are we going to do about it once we you know really are hearing especially from students so I think there's a seriousness to the second question that is not in the first question thank you for sharing that um and so now we'll move it to the first task of tonight which is if I'm gonna ask you how you're doing or how you're creating your Wellness I must be sure that we are on the same page with what we're talking about in terms of Wellness um and so you had this draft definition and framework that

063you were able to speak with with your elbow partner about what you agree with or what you argue with I want to our goal of this conversation and as we kind of move through it I am going to push us towards like saying thumbs up or thumbs down this this feels like there's been a ton of work that's got into this is this something we feel good about for the direction of San Diego unified or no and if you are saying no we're going to push you to be really specific about what are those elements to argue with that we feel are missing that we would want to incorporate um but I'm going to first before we really get to pushing that element I want to open it up for reactions and Reflections on this

064and what came up in your conversation about this definition and framework work Quinton my initial reaction was I i' really don't support this definition I think it's extremely over complicated I feel like the second half is too convoluted if we have a definition of Wellness it shouldn't take me two three four reads to understand what it's saying if our audiences students parents families we should be able to understand that just nice defition of Wellness with the first draft and I feel like the first sentence Wellness means keeping your mind body feelings and inner self working well together I think that's perfect but everything after that is too convoluted thank you for sharing who will be the next to share Shaya I'll share only because 100% so exactly what he said where the notes that I

065had taken before um that yeah everything after that first sentence um don't help doesn't help clarify what we mean by Wellness um and I agree I think there's a lot that's not clear or easy to understand so terms like working well together good relationships like what do we mean by working well what do we mean by good um and then in the second half um which I think is confusing to me Wellness responds to community needs I don't even I don't know what that means um and then going on like being the best they can be that idea seems way too broad what I appreciate um about it is you know certain you asked us to think earlier about assumption so I like that it reflects this mindbody connection um the importance of relationships um

066overlap between individual and Community all of those things I think are right um so I don't think there's anything here I disagree with but they don't help to clarify the definition of Wellness for me thank you who will be the next to share sha or Sabrina sorry yeah I think to add on to that um although it seems like it should be simple on the surf surface Wellness I I think it can be but I think there's a there is a lot of complex actually that goes into being well I mean if you're lucky enough to be born into a family that has enough food to on the table that lives in a zip code that has a good you know uh public education I mean now I guess being a parent and seeing all

067of that evolve um there's a lot you know when a student walks in the door it's not just you know are they ready to learn there's so many different things that go into that before they even walk in the door to school so although I think it is you know I think I agree Quenton that like on the surface it's it should be just yeah I feel good but do you have a supportive family you know all those kinds of things really Encompass what Wellness is for um for everyone but I'm thinking particularly about our students thank you Sabrina Cody first of all I just I want to thank staff for jumping into this thing I mean this is we're trying to create a goal which we absolutely need to create which is like dealing

068with the primordial essence of what it is to be human so this is like a very challenging task I just want to acknowledge how towering the problem is um and um and and I want to Echo what my colleagues have said about the the need to for Simplicity I think um one of the things that I'm often thinking about is how you go out and talk to the community about this and if I were to walk out to my community be like wellness and go through this thing they would glaze over um and whereas when you talk to them about the real basic you know we were working on this together um and one of the things that came out of it in in our conversation was how B basic and bodily all our youth

069have have talked when they talk about Wellness they're talking about sleep they're talking about anxiety um stress uh eating and so you know what I would love to see come out of this is some there there's so many levels of analysis and so so many difficulties in typologizing how is and different levels of analysis one of the things we were talking about is this sort of like uh you know to start from the the body out you know healthy healthy body healthy mind healthy relationships now that then brings up the next thing what does healthy mean um but I I feel like one thing is but if I go into my community and I went and talked about wellness and somebody in a in a fairly you know culturally conservative group of people who have

070kind of turned a little bit against social emotional learning and I said I'm we're not talking specifically about social emotional learning we're talking about social emotional Wellness what do you mean by that well and you tell the story about what it means to you to be well and one of the dads came up and said man I never would have thought about that this but my daughter got cut out of her friend of groups that she's had since she was in elementary school and all she does is stay home and she cries he's like I don't know what to do I I'm choking about it because he was choking it and it's like so when you get right down to it if you you get super simple about what it is in the core people

071respond to it right away they understand what you're talking about both as an individual because they've been through life and they know life and as a parent um and so I would just Echo everybody I would love to get down to a statement that is very simple about what it means bily in terms of Body Mind relationships and then maybe there's another sentence or two about what we mean by by health or what we mean by good but that that basic thing is just about the the core of what we all as a community feel in terms of Wellness without the complexity of the additional language thank you Cody um this is I want to interject in here one moment and this is I think a really great conversation what I've heard so far is

072simpl we need to be able to share this broadly and it be an encompassing definition but there's a lot there's a whole lot of complexity underneath this this is no different than reading if I'm a parent General parent a kid I want my kid to read and I know what that looks like or not I might not know everything about phonics and all of the different ways and know how to teach it and all of this stuff but I know if my kid can read or not and this is kind of what we're doing here there will be a lot of complexity and a lot of Frameworks underneath this that are going to have to be developed to understand like are we really getting to that complexity that basic issue there but that's not necessarily

073for a definition so what I'm hearing the board generally talk about is we need something simple that we can say that this is what we mean by wellness and four sentences might be too much for this people can dig in more if they want to we can take that as a note I'm going to ask us look at the framework here there were four bullet points broadly speaking of this framework about what we really mean by it and Cody in your last response I heard you mention some of these physical health mental health which I read is potentially inner self relationships connections so let me ask the question for the board reflecting on those four bullet points of a framework does that Encompass based on what you've heard tonight from students your own experiences Etc

074is that more or less encompassing of what you conceptualize to be Wellness when you wrote and talked about this goal or there elements missing and if so what are those missing elements Richard I I like the framework I think some of the words could be they they're a little bit jargony and so I I think they could be you know written in a different way that you know uh no but I think I think James canning could I I think there's I think there's good uh communicators that could sort of translate these words into um you know things that you know uh what Quinton is saying that people could really understand and and especially that can translate in down you know to the classroom teacher working with kids I mean that's one level of operationalizing

075this that becomes really important but I the concepts um feel right um I'd probably lean more towards rather than connections to our world it's like contributions to our world so there's something about being in a um in an environment where you feel like you're making thing the world better that I think is important to to Wellness um but I think what I really appreciate is the point down here that says any if you if you start to make progress on any one of these areas everything else improves that's important um because otherwise I think people could get overwhelmed and think oh my God I got to get all four right or you know I'm not well and the point is just you know at that point in time focus on the one thing you know

076that can really help um and then that's going to improve everything else I I really like that idea yeah so what I hear heard from this is overall the framework seems those four areas seem to take most of this though we might suggest different words like a contribution instead of connection um and underscoring the fact that all of these four work in concert with one another thank you Sabrina yeah and tagging on to that um I think the four Encompass quite a bit I think where it says relationships I don't know I I struggle with that word maybe something more like Community or something that goes beyond relationship because when I think of a relationship I think of like oneon-one but this might be with like organizations or um so it's not just a personal

077relationship although that's part of it but one thing I was thinking too and looking at these especially with kids also for myself I'm more of a visual learner so having this set up in a way where it's more visual to look at I think would make it make more sense probably possibly to people to see something that's more um you know I don't know shown in a different way that might make more sense um overall and show like how they all kind of come together I mean I'm not an artist but just a thought that that might be a way to help explain it better yeah and I have no doubt that whatever we land on will encom will Encompass those things but the question is what is it going to look like first and

078then put in those visuals thank you Cody can I just say um you know just two two brief things one before moving forward I do want to point out that methodologically at this point and that may be a necessity given our society or whatever our unit of analysis is the individual I mean these are well we're talking about well individuals but I just want to pause it that there is an aspect of this which is also about well commun and and just to say that when you target when you target interventions toward an individual when you think about Wellness in terms of an individual you then you end up creating a motivation to Target the individual rather than Target holes and so I just want to say that Wellness is in addition to what we

079experience as whatever lack of anxiety or lack of stress it is also quality of a whole and I would say this is AAL as an anthropologist you go to communities where it is still very much the wellness of the quote individual is very much interwoven with the wellness of a of a community of a whole so I just maybe maybe this has given our society what we're stuck with for the time being but I want to recognize that we can also think about definitions that that encourage our staff to Target holes and the way they're put together rather than the individuals within those holes and then one last thing I want to say I think what part of what's happening is the first sentence is a definition we can nitpick the definition um I think

080it's too like what I would think of agentive like means keeping your mind it means not having to keep your mind your mind just it when you're well you're not like oh I'm Gonna Keep it all together no it means having your mind you know what I mean so it's not about the work you do to do that but so we can nitpick the definition but I think everything that comes after it um is kind of a hypothesis about about how you achieve wellness and there's certain in place because we're going to need those intermediary hypotheses about how we achieve it but I think part of what's causing problems for us is like okay if we just set aside the hypothesis focus on the definition and then push the hypothesis to somewhere else in the

081document which I think you basically do in the in the framework thank you sorry to go on can I I just want because I want to the point that Cody just made I I think is so important and I wouldn't want us to just say well this is the world we live in so let's focus on the individual because I don't think that's the world a lot of of our students come from and so I think you know and and there's references to culture in here so I think this definition of is the community well has to be part of what we're working towards and I appreciate that Cody yeah thank you Richard go ahead I thought you're comment about the role the community plays in Wellness is spot-on and I think that one of

082the ways in which that concept shows up is the fact that two of the four Frameworks are dedicated towards group that's that was the origin of where that came from and that was strategically chosen based off of some of the research we did not only off of Sweeney's work around the concept of the group but also what we' learned from our partnership with Duncan Andrade it was really showing that Wellness is more than just myself it's the people that are connected to me and Al how I connect to the world and that's what the attempt is that and that was the interesting reason why we were choosing the word connections you were wondering why why why not contributions and that's a good point because we do want people to be contributing members to society but

083at the same time we're trying to figure out how the relationship between how I am connected to who I am who's a human being and what my background is and how that plays such a critical role in that and so this is the line that we're sort of uh uh trying to move through when we're calling out half of the framework is being about the group Scott um we'll go to Quinton Shaina and Sharon actually go to Sharon we'll go to Sharon first we haven't had heard from Sharon you haven't I've I'm a little Disturbed that we are not getting a representative group um to even weigh in on the initial construct so as always you all know me and you know who I am and I have to be who I am which is

084to say that in everything and I want to stress that word in everything we always have to go beyond to ensure that we are getting representation across the district and whatever we do otherwise from my perspective it's not valid and from my community's perspective they don't want to hear it so I'm putting that aside and just um somebody was saying we couldn't get people to participate anytime you need representation Richard is a person who can do work magic to help us to ensure that we have representation at all levels in everything that's number one and I'll put that aside I think what we're talking about is Body Mind Soul and Spirit people know about um starting off with that we have to have your body in line and your mind your soul and the differences

085among these um elements and then it expands you have to have the connections beyond in order to be existent as long as in our definitions and in our work that we do we ensure that everybody is a part of then I'm okay with it but I just have to say that that just is a barrier for me tonight and I would hope that going forward we will not do that we will ensure that everyone's perspective on a representative level is presented as a part of so that folks don't feel excluded enough said in a nice way tonight and I leave it there thank you thank you Sharon Quinton sha yeah I wanted to talk specifically about the language to use for relationships I don't specifically think we're getting at caring deeply about family friends and

086Community I feel like it's more contributions to the community and the family I mean we heard all of the students present today when you're not feeling well you're not contrib reading to your family you're not going out to your community you're not doing what you like to do so I would really want to change that language from just a mere caring for your community to the contribution where specifically are you looking uh the second framework relationship relationships thank you Shaya thank you and want to First foremost um agree with what trusty WHUR Payne has said it was the first thing that stood out to me um we heard great insights from students and there were a lot of students we didn't hear from tonight and and that's challenging um both as we think um in

087terms of students backgrounds geographic representation you name it um we saw a very small sub uh section of our student population so want to make sure everyone's represented um in terms of um the elements of the framework I think they get close [Music] um I do think um so I guess I get a little bit stuck on um I think some of these things overlap so like relationships versus connections um is do we mean the same thing or something different um right because it talks about relationships when you look at the relationship definition or description relationships are caring deeply about family friends and community and building strong bonds and connections also talk about Connections to community so I think making clear the distinction um but I do think what we heard from students here tonight

088and what I hear from students generally is feeling connected um to someone um is important to their Wellness whether it's a family member a friend a teacher a coach um so I think relationships get at it I hear um trusty baso saying well maybe relationships has this sort of romantic connotation or mean something else and so might there be a different word um but I like where we're going with that notion um I like the idea of physical health we heard it loud and clear from the students tonight um and I think so much of the research out you know the overlapping nature of um physical and emotional health and and wellbeing and so understanding that these two things um go hand inand and we also heard as students talked about um some of the

089steps they can take to improve their wellness and I think to trusty barrera's point right like you do one thing right just get more sleep that might make me feel more more well and so understanding the importance of of physical health um inner self the I'm like stuck a little bit on the term I think on that word um and inner inner self is complex and so I guess um I'm not quite sure what we mean by Inner self and so I don't know maybe Scott or like can you clarify what what we mean there or what we're we're trying to get at there you go the term inner self actually is or its Origins come from some of the work from Duncan Andra where what he's trying to do is differentiate Wellness from a

090community or from the group that I'm in versus Wellness that comes sort of from within my own being and that the origin of that word that's actually one of the few words that actually is stayed true to that original research that we found um I don't know if that helps kind of clarify the rationale for inner self but it's really in relationship to the framework number two and three thank you yeah and I think like as I look at um the description of inner self something that really resonates with me and that I appreciate is um this feeling in control of your life uh and again thinking back to what we heard from students when you feel like you have agency you can you know do things to achieve goals um or get out of

091a rut or whatever might be in the way so that feeling of being in control or having control I think is is important um and likewise agree with what vice president Pon said about community and so I'm sort of thinking about I don't know if it shows up in the framework or the definition maybe as we get further along in terms of implementation planning and thinking about um maybe inputs or output like how how do we think about how Community um and communal Wellness fit into the work we're doing um as we work to understand if our individual students are are well um just looking through my notes to see if I miss anything um oh the last thing that really stood out for me about what students talked about was motivation and so I'm

092not sure where that fits in but it seemed really important because we heard it a lot um and the other thing I'm mindful of is we have motivation in our guard rail um and so how do these two things maybe fit together thank you Shaina we'll go to Joseph next hi um going to relationships and connections to our world I think we really need to highlight individuals responsibilities you know to their job their academics their family their friends you know when we talk about individuals contributing to society whether or not they are equipped to do that the society contributes to the individual and so really highlighting can can well well individuals can contribute to society they can stay responsible they can up they can uphold their responsibilities and burdens so should highlight that in our

093framework thank you and if I'm hearing you correctly it's really around doubling down on the point that was made earlier about maybe instead of connections it's about contributions and the ability to contribute above and beyond the connections am I hearing you correctly thank you Sabrina we were talking about over here about um again the connections to our world where um or maybe it was the we're discussing different cultures and learning more about your cultures but that that's complicated too because both of us grew up in houses where our parents were completely different cultures kind of thrown together so in one place I was too much of one thing or not enough of another thing and so I think a lot of students don't always know where their culture is or how you know if if

094they're mixed or whatever you know that so that's GNA that would be something to kind of keep in mind of it's not just going to be just one thing you know 100% all the time but making students feel okay with that you know that it's okay to you know be have multiple cultures that you represent um and uh yeah real clarifying question on that I yes I think you're looking at the inner self one about knowing who you are your culture and feeling control of your life and I'm hearing a specific suggestion here that it's not just one culture it's your cultures even is that am I reflecting that accurately okay and you might feel more part of one culture than the other and or vice versa and then also kind of following up on

095trusty wher's pain um in addition to having representation I think also the acceptance that not all families or organizations are going to be accepting of this work they might think oh this is like really touchy feely why you doing this and might not really be supportive of their student doing you know this kind of work so I think we need to realize that and give people acceptance some people jump in some kids you know like our students tonight have been amazing but others might be uncomfortable or might just not have that support to you know might see it as a sign of weakness or something to even kind of discuss these kind of things so kind of keeping that in mind as well thank you Sabrina Cody followed by Sha um so in terms of

096resolving some of this stuff I would if we're going to stick with this framework and I think it's pretty good I would um move the physical health to the top because then you know then you move outward from and you might think well I'm move the inner self to the but I think the inner self is actually the mind is sort of as somebody who spent late teen onset with very bad anxiety the it emerges from the body you know I mean the body is where it starts and in a certain sense the body is where it first gets solved you know you go out and take a jog you you know and so I would encourage us to maybe move the physical health to the top it seems like mind we're talking about mind

097basically with inner self I understand that there's a sort of a connection to the to dade's work I think in terms of having a framework for our thinking about in terms of mind there's probably details on why is mind isn't perfect but I think in terms of communicating to ourselves and our staff and our communities and students I think you're talking basically about body mind it's moving out into relationships and then to the whole um and I the last thing I'll say I we're getting into Hy this is hypothesis here in distinguishing definition from hypothesis about how you serve it there's this word that I keep coming back to which is mattering and it's a it's a funny word we don't use it that often but we have such a crisis of mattering and I

098see it with my kids um they can close their ears for a second but I I certainly feel it myself I see it with so often that we really have a crisis of mattering where it it's do you matter at the campus does somebody notice when you're gone from the class uh do you matter to your friend group do they cancel the birthday party if you can't show up you know what I'm saying and I would just say for me when feeling I feel an enormous amount in terms of self-reflection if I feel like I matter Wow versus if I feel like I don't matter I don't even show up if I don't matter I'm gone you know and I'm an A grown grown ass adult as they say and so sometimes when it doesn't

099matter I'm okay being gone but imagine being imagine being 12 you can't afford to have the sort of self-efficacy you go I'm I'm out I don't matter here I'm out you actually need to be there and therefore you need to matter so I don't know how we fit matter again but I really think it's fundamental to what we're talking about thank you Shaina yes I love that term so 100% mattering is I think what we're going for um so really appreciate that um I was you know as I heard Sabrina um talk about um you know different sort of intersecting cultures and backgrounds I also thought you know they ter identities right because it may not your cultural background it may be another um source of identity but this notion of you know pride in

100who you are um which may sort of overlap with mattering but may might be different um I I think that's important then the other thing um that's come to mind and this is more in sort of what Wellness maybe looks like and it doing um but the idea of pro-social behaviors but doing things that contribute meaning to others so sort of getting at this um being well isn't just an individual Pursuit but something communal um I recognize pro-social behaviors as jargony and not easily understood but if we can find an easier way to describe pro-social behaviors um right working with others cooperating volunteering sharing all of those things um I think could be important thank you Shaina Sharon I would like to go back to what Joseph was talking about because mean I don't think

101we got the full impact of what he was talking about when he said um people work together to do or not do or they may not have a capacity or can you go to what you were I don't think so going back um are you well enough to uphold your responsibilities and burdens you know to your job your academics your family your friends yourself you know yeah I'm just trying to drill it down to the student level what you're saying as an adult is one thing but as a child well enough to make contributions to the group to the class to uman can you just play it out a little bit further yeah you know at the student level is the student well enough to do their homework you know is the student well enough

102to talk to their parents you know to go on a play date you know that's the type of stuff um okay well pause before we continue on the next one because I want to summarize some of the convers I just give you one example that came to I'm sorry uh What uh what Joseph just said so um Fabby and I and Gabe we were on a site visit to Joiner we got to join her parent right here um last week and we walked into a Kindergarten class and a student was was taking attendance and she was up there and when we W the principal walked in and said oh are you the teacher you know and yes she was right now and it was so great because you know she's up there you know taking

103leadership and every student was there and the teacher was able to then say okay we accomplished our goal so they set a class goal you know of everybody being there and here was a student you know leading that and I think to me what Joseph what you were just saying about are you equipped you know to make that kind of contribution this student was um so yeah yeah so and this this will be the weeds of do this what does this look like on the ground but that is not what we're here tonight for we're here tonight to get to a make sure the words that we say the simple words that we say at this table and in the community are brought enough and at the same time specific enough to reflect these types

104of things so I want to summarize some things I've heard and make sure that it relatively reflects this because and I'm going to recommend even though we have other elements on the agenda we really can't move on to talking about what measurement would look like until we get clear on what this is and so this will be the priority until we can get clear on that tonight um so a couple things that I've specifically heard come back over and over and over again what I've heard is essentially these four things with some specific language adjustments do seem to Encompass most of what we're talking about some specific adjustments that I've heard that we've talked about here just to make sure on the same page is going back to this idea of the ordering so I

105heard maybe we move physical to the top and then Cascade it from inner self Andor mind or some kind of conversation here I've heard this conversation about these next to relationships and um connections but also really being clear about defining what the difference is between relationships and connections and I've heard from at least five individually mention contributions more than connections as a as a deeper example of what this can look like and also to Cody's Point originally about individual versus Community the first two physical health and mental or um inner self are more individual focused whereas the other two connections contributions relationships however we specify if those are more to the communal Health aspects of this as far as items missing from this framework that we don't see reflected here I've heard two specific in

106here number one is a question like where does motivation fit in and maybe Scott and the team I'm sure have thought about some of these things they might be able to tell us kind of where that is we just need to make that more specific and this idea of mattering where does this idea of mattering come in and then the specific conversations around you know making sure that cultures or identities is reflected not just one culture identity some of those but overall I will pose this question again so given that this is going to be a working thing we're g to kind of Define to that number one did that reflect kind of The Wider conversation about the specific nuts and bolts of this framework that Scott and the team are going to take back

107to and B is there anything that is also missing from that what we've talked about so far that we don't see reflected in this framework at all sha I think as you described it it getss there for me the one thing and I was really glad um that Richard lifted it up because it hits on what I've been thinking a lot about is do the proposed definition and framework apply to all students um so to students of all ages and so I really appreciated you describing this kindergarten example um but I think it's important that we sort of run this through um we heard tonight from older students does it work when we think about a three or four year-old sitting in a TK Class come August as well as it does um with an

10818-year- old is they're getting ready to leave um I think it does I'm not quite sure for the littlest kids and so that's just the one thing I'm holding on to yep Scott you know Shan like the concept you're talking about is fascinating with one of the partners that we worked with with Wellness together her name was Britney Stone she made a point of stating that part of the work of supporting Wellness is the continual redefinition of Wellness based upon who you are as as a student based upon your background or your age and that we would be if we truly believe that we want that kind of self-actualization in students want them to be able to Define and measure their own Wellness we knew that we would have to figure out ways to Define

109it in ways that make sense to a four-year-old and also ways that they um that using assessment tools that they would take seriously and that was actually one of the rationale for us trying to put together a student wellness assessment team where there was some students that we wanted to pull from different grades um to work with us in the springtime to be able to help them um be part of defining what makes sense to them and what would they take seriously as a student when it comes to measuring that concept so when you're saying um will this definition work for airh group I don't know if we ever will have one single definition that makes sense to a senior and a second grader but we will be able ble to have like a common

110framework that we'll be able to build language into and that's kind of our thinking yes so I think I think that's helpful and I you know my desire is that we do have a definition and framework that applies to all ages even though the measures and ways we assess will be vastly different based on the age the development um of the child but I think having a common understanding of what we generally mean by Wellness is important thank you Shaina Sabrina um I just wanted to address about physical health being at the top or whatever I guess I kind of see it a little bit more as a Continuum um I also suffer from an anxiety have my whole life have a very anxious brain and I think I started being more physically healthy when

111I knew that heal was going to help my inner self so I feel like the inner self was kind of motivating me to be more physically healthy because that was going to make me feel better so I guess I see it more of like an Continuum rather than like one thing being at the top and one being at the bottom for me because then if you don't have good relationships and you know maybe you're not being as physically healthy I don't know but it's not a list yes Cody um I'm happy with where we're going conceptually the hardest thing is to figure out what's missing I mean always yeah and so um I don't have a a lot of lot to give on that what I would say is in trying to think about the

112first is I um I think that there is given that we have students that are going TK to 12 and then onward there's a temporal e aspect to Wellness which is about not just understanding your place in the whole but is having a sense of that you're moving towards there's some progress in your life growth so if we could get get that temporal quality of like age appropriate Place appropriate sense that you are making progress toward where you you're growing what I mean maybe progress is a little bit too teleological but I mean some sense that you are on a path somewhere you know and the other thing um I would say is it's a little bit adjacent to the definition but I do think it's it could potentially strengthen it let's just say hypothetically

113dropped out a lot of the stuff that's hypothesizing about how you get to Wellness and you have something which talks to the fact of this is wellness and part of what Wellness is is what it is to our project which is to say this is what Wellness is and wellness is the foundation of learning and achievement do you see what I'm saying um I think that that's really powerful because then when we give the definition we're not just like we're going for wellness well why did you make this a number one goal but if you have that as part of the definition how it fits into the into the hole then it's like oh Wellness is this and it is a the Foundation of learning and achievement and yeah thank you Cody and thank you

114for adding one more of these and digging into the question about what is missing this idea of growth like you know whatever it looks like growth or progress or something um and where is that reflected any other thoughts and Reflections on the framework specifically if we feel like anything is missing Bobby the part I I want to address because I take we take this very seriously um Dr her pay please know we're committed to making sure that we have a representation across um that was a discussion that we had even prior to bringing this group we talked about like do we have representation who's actually G to come and we actually knew we we weren't like we said okay we have to do better so I I think that that's the part that's missing is

115as I hear Scott talk about the next iteration with another student group that we have to ensure that we have full full board so I just wanted to make that public commitment and understanding that it was missing so given the summary that I kind of put forth generally of the discussion plus the addition that Cody noted here around this idea of growth and knowing there will be another iteration that is going to get feedback especially with the idea in mind of representation based on this conversation and kind of the adjustments we have talked about does the board I'm going to ask each board member do you feel pretty good with that set of framework elements and then we're going to circle back to the definition so who would like we'll start here so BR do

116you feel good with those additions and those conversations if that gets Incorporated that this framework pretty much is describing what we as a board meant when we set this goal originally yeah I think so I think it's a a good starting point I mean obviously this is a a really complex issue to make it get to a point where it's simple we have to get through the complexities I guess first but I think we're definitely um you know going in the right direction and because that was my big concern was like well how are we going to measure this like when we first discussed all this and to the people we were talking about that old say say well why are you doing this touchy Fey stuff like how is that helping you know I

117think really getting to the context of that and that it is really going to ultimately be impa in our students academic achievement you know is one of the ultimate goals but um I do feel better now a little more settled that we're actually you know getting it into more of a tangible framework right here yes Richard yeah and I I think this is great to keep going so you know I don't want us to ever let the perfect be the enemy the good I think we know that we're making the road while we're walking and so let's keep walking but but I think we can you know go forward with this framework yeah and and the additions that You' me yeah thank you [Music] Sharon I'm sorry fine with it in the context that we've

118talked about because as I said my orientation already is body soul mind spirit it's all there anyway whether you call it something else or not it's in the same realm so I think people even in the larger community don't have a problem with that thank you Sharon Shaina yes I think we are on the right track right Joseph yeah I think where we started off was good but with these additions we're going to be much better off thank you Cody yeah I'm happy the framework apprciate all the work g into it Quinton okay so we have a framework that we feel a lot closer to so now I want to Circle back to the definition and I've got of been workshopping based on what I've heard here and want to posit a place for us

119to start number one I heard from the very beginning Simplicity and making sure this is simple straightforward it doesn't have to be all inclusive this should be one quick thing that we can share then I heard some specific conversations about what words to do I think um I forget the word you used Cody when you talked about keeping the word keeping or removing it and it just is um so I'm going to pause it I'm I'm making an adjustment to this first sentence and I'm going to use it as a way to start I don't know if we can type it up somewhere or I can just share it and we can kind of work off of this but essentially where I would like to start us is just sticking with the first sentence dropping

120everything off of this and what I heard is some iteration of Wellness is your mind body feelings and inner self working well together it is the foundation of learning so using that or iterating on that first sentence as we think about a definition what are thoughts reactions adjustments that kind of Encompass the framework without saying the framework can you say it one more time Wellness is your mind body feelings and inner self working well together it is the foundation of learning so I don't hear relationships in that I don't hear community in that yeah and are you pulling relationship so pulling those comma things from the framework okay making sure that those match yes thank you Quinton yeah I would say I don't know if the root cause of Wellness is everything working well together

121I feel like it's more having good like body feelings having good mental health I don't know if the exact language should be just working well together rather than h something in the realm of having positive Health okay so question around is working well together the right description of these framework elements coming together I would Echo that I mean I don't think I think a lot of the the ver the verbage here in terms of literally verbs is is a little bit problematic not problematic it's just not I'm not feeling it exact or I think it's unnecessary so the means keeping I mean I would just say Wellness is as a definition you know it is something so we can drop that off and working well together I don't know that that's the most fundamental thing

122what I would say is in terms of a definition I think the most important thing is not that we're defining Wellness for every organization in the universe like you know Wellness is gravity you know not distorting light or you know I mean it's like we're talking about what is Wellness to us as an institution and we come up with that definition I'm thinking down the field because we're going to throw a ball to ourselves down the field when we talk about implementation and we talk about metrics and um I'm thinking of a definition of Wellness that has these elements I think the framework particularly is good and when we think about the framework it's fairly challenging to impact the inner self directly or the Mind directly it's fairly challenging to impact their connections to the

123world I mean Lord knows look at all of us watching the news every night like that's very hard when we get right down to it the ways in which we're going to my I anticipate us targeting Wellness is in terms of relationships and in terms of physical health those are just looking at this that's the low hanging fruit for us and that's not to presume what the data and research is going to show us but my guess is that's where you get most bang for your buck is intervening at those two levels and so I really would like and and I think in terms of the physical health all of our students said all of them had some element of sleep and stress and eating and um and routine and time management I mean these

124are very very sort of bodily things so I would like to see a definition of Wellness that does not is not so interior mind inner work self-working feelings those are three interior things that are going to be very hard for us to to get purchase on I would say as like a default I'd say okay let's pull the framework which we've all just gotten excited about let's pull it into the definition um with in light of how we anticipate Wellness mattering for our students and our staff in terms of addressing it thank you for that and I think that makes that that seems to align with the conversation I've heard so far is starting with Wellness is the framework the four elements of the framework whatever the final answer is Wellness is these four elements

125to what end if there is an end or is it just those four elements and it's a question that I'm asking specifically if the board has any thoughts around like what should that if it's not working well together what is it or does it fall off entirely before I ask if the board has any thoughts on that Scott I I know you all have put a lot of thought into how this came together if you could speak to why you chose working well together as part of this process and what what what that means I think the two elements that I are important to call out come from different areas one gets back to the communal sense that we've mentioned before but the second comes from our quest to try to write create documents that

126are in the language that um our students will understand so some of the word choice that's there is based off of um some of the feedback that we got from students regarding what makes sense and what doesn't earlyer re iterations actually use different language and I think that that kind of gets back to that concept I was mentioning earlier from um Britney Stone who mentioned that um while the framework will stand strong that the language that's used will probably vary based upon who your target audience is so I think that would be I hope that helps provide some context to some of the language you see thank you Scott Shaina and then Richard so I I'm all for Simplicity and I'm trying to distill what I'm hearing and but I keep going back to it

127I wrote it down is the basically Wellness is feeling good and knowing you matter like something as simple as that um and then the framework helps explain it's it's inner self it comes through relationship like how you get there but I think something as simple as that one sentence would would do it for me Scott do you want to add anything I did also just it's a thought that I forgot to mention when we're asking what is the significance of the concept of working well together ironically that is um comes back to the concept that we learned from um Sweeny and from Myers who their Wellness wheel which was a term that the concept that they came up with it's been sort of foundational um one key element of that philosophy op of Wellness was

128that it's holistic and that those four elements could not be teased apart and so the language works well together was designed to let students know that the four elements are interconnected and that actually working on one helps you in other areas and that they can't really be seen as individual and I think that's really important and I think like when I said feeling good for me it gets at all of the different ways one can feel good right it's feeling good emotionally sort of in terms of my inner self physically good um because I think it's something that we all understand maybe universally um we'll go to Dr magula followed by Nicole I'm I just want to think about you said you Ed the quote about not being perfect and I kind of want to

129lean into the Improvement science notion of possibly wrong and definitely incomplete um because I have a feeling that the more we talk to students the more we talk to families when we start to engage we're going to want to come back and redefine this and so I think as long as we have some elements that we meet with and the more we go out and talk and we go you know they pushed us on this and they changed this I actually think that's a part of our learning and of actually being a well organization right an unwell organization would be like this is our definition and sorry but this is it so I think having that little asterisk on the bottom of possibly wrong and definitely incomplete would actually allow us to kind of be

130in this space of we're creating with what's emerging um and I also feel like all of these things are very situational um there's a Chronos system that exists um like I will often say I love this role and then when you talk to me about budget and I get really depressed right away so I think that there's some things to be said there about about the notion of we're going to go at this in a way of wanting to learn and wanting to actually learn from students and learning from the students experience at our School sites in community in the classroom and in community at their school and so I I don't know I just want to push us to say it doesn't have to be perfect but we can continue going with the notion

131of we're going to continue learning ourselves thank you Dr Bula Nicole so I've just been sitting here listening and reflecting on what folks are saying and so one of the things that I was thinking about as well and it came up when we were listening to the students is that self-actualization piece right so like how are you taking ownership of your own wellness and what does that look like so I have an offering um just based off of the notes that Ben's been taking that potentially a definition for wellness could be that Wellness is intentionally attending to the health of Your Mind Body relationships and overall Community um because I do think that speaks to the framework and then we can say take some time to like further Define um what those elements of the

132framework are but again taking that own ERS ship back to self and saying that you are very intentionally attending to these areas of your own Wellness which then contribute to your overall community so that would be my offering thank you Nicole Richard I so I really appreciate what Nicole and Shaina both did because you can imagine you're a teacher you're a parah you're you're you're in the classroom working with kids having that one sentence you know in in your you can imagine students having that one sentence uh in their mind and I think that's I I I think we had a lot of energy in this discussion when we got to the framework I think word smithing the definition is always you know feels like it sucks energy out and so number one I would

133say let's not bog ourselves down in the definition but number two I think what Nicole and Shaina both did is they got us to a goal of having one sentence that's you know that can stick in people's heads and that can until we're ready to improve it you know we can we can move forward with with that yeah thank you Cody I'm largely okay with that I would just say and again sometimes we get into the weeds in terms of our own ideologies about this stuff but when when I see people most well they're least intentional I mean they're in the moment they're just living their lives when I see people surfing or hanging out with their friends I'm a person that lives 99% of my life in a metac metacognitive State it's not well

134per se you know so I just think I definitely see especially from an instructional District standpoint that intentionality is important but I really think if you look at people that are well they're not being intentional about it or metacognitive Val they're just being well 100 sha and then Quinton 100% right because I think we're getting closer right when we said you when we got rid of you know keeping your mind that it's not an act of doing it is an act of being um so I really appreciate Cody highlighting that because for me same thing um it is when you're not actively trying to do it but you are feeling that way anyway um the other thing I'm thinking about is there seems to be energy around this idea of like it happening in an

135atmosphere of growth um that it is you're not done being well um but that you it's sort of maybe part of a Continuum or that you're moving in a positive direction thank you Shana Quinton yeah I really just want to show my support for what Shaya said the one sentence about Wellness is feeling good I mean Wellness we can come up with the definition of what it means but our definition isn't going to be the same for everyone so we have to leave it up to interpretation to whoever reads it and if we do keep it short I feel like it'll be more accommodating to everyone's needs I will point out from a standpoint of being a body of multiple individuals charged with the overall Wellness for the entire District specificity really does matter um

136and I there is a value there's one thing we can leave reading up to whoever's interpretation of reading is and what's comprehension anyways you know it's what you take from it but getting to a clear understanding like now this is what we mean it's not to Cody's point it's not this is not Wellness for everybody all the time and there is definitely some of that but there is a value in some level of specificity in terms of what the system means by wellness and how we're going to then think about all of the strategies that go from that and what we're spending our money on and spending our time on and how we talk about this work because we have a common definition of it and so that there is some value to specificity that

137I am going to push our board to to make sure that we're we're doing that hard work to get there so so going back I've heard a couple different things here I've heard this idea of Wellness is and stating what it is whether it is the framework elements or whether it is bridging them up to a broader language where in which you lose complexity there's some balance there and then there's this to what end is it intentionally attending to or totally unintentionally being in that state or is it you heard from Scott and the the thoughtful reason for why they chose working well together how much I'm curious from the board's perspective how much do you have a clear saying like this is what we meant by that versus we're going to now defer to

138the administration to say if they say working well together is what really means we're going to go with that because we're going to defer in that way Richard um I'm thinking about Scott one of the early slides you showed was I think where the board left you with uh show show that slide for at the beginning I I think it's actually earlier the messy one nope keep going there we go there we go there we go so that's what we did and then the staff did it a lot better so I would definitely lean on I I think if if Fabby and the staff feel comfortable that you've got a sense of where we're at I would much defer to your ability to keep going forward with the definition rather than what we came up

139with thank you Richard I'm so sorry to me I can see the clock we're not this is where we're gonna be but so I think we're at the point where we kind of sum up what what we are happy with and what we at this for the time being defer to staff and I would Echo with Richard right now I think we're we've got consensus around framework which I think is quasi miraculous and I think in terms of a def definition we can craft staff can craft it and we can have a reiterative process maybe come back in a normal board meeting or something but I I think I'm very happy that we got to the framework stage I appreciate [Music] it I will then ask the administration either Dr Mula Scott do you have

140clarifying questions in terms of the direction that you need more direction from the board on or do you feel like you've got from this conversation a pretty set good set working next on your definition and framework I think so and I really am going I think we have to um hold on to that possibly wrong and definitely incomplete um but I do think that we have working ways to continue to do this work um to think about other communities and other students to get more feedback and closer um and I actually think that potentially next year we're actually going to have a different slightly different conversation about what Wellness means given what we learned this year too so I actually appreciate the openness of having some of that wiggle room because just like it was

141complex to get us all to agree that's how complex it's been when we talk to different departments um so I appreciate the complexity and so like let's try something on until we learn and come back I think would be really really beautiful I think to add on to that the one of the thoughts that comes to my mind was something that Shane and you and I talked about which was the idea of why let perfect get in the way of progress and if we have discovered that our ability to measure Wellness is based upon our ability to Define it and we have landed Upon A framework well that framework is the tool that we'll be able to use to now figure out next steps as I look upon the structure of tonight's board Workshop we

142actually had designed it to be in two parts the first part was what we just did the second part we were going to bring in our subject matter experts from the county to tell you how we are going to go through the process of defining how we're going to measure Wellness maybe that's something we'll move on to the next time that we're all together which I believe will be in February and hopefully we can ask Melissa to come back again and share your learning and what you have in mind but I guess what I wanted to say is that concept of um uh not letting perfect get in way of progress will give us the opportunity to move forward with the goal that we've all defined is to be something very important and Cornerstone to

143Student Success so I'm excited about that as well sounds like we have what we need to move on to wherever um board president superintendent you all want to take this next um but I will say I'm again it's just an honor to be here with you all listen to you discuss and dive into this I can tell you again there are eyes Across the Nation watching what you all are doing as you all sort through this very tricky um tough really meaningful issue for the best of your students and community so thank you thank you and I think before we wrap up can somebody CL clarify for the board what the next steps are and also for Melissa who I think is going to have to come back again so I think what and when

144would be really helpful so we are scheduled to provide the board an update in February regarding the status of the wellness goal we knew that one of the uh First Steps was for us to land Upon A framework of Wellness we've done that tonight and so now we'll be able to use that information to help start to formulate how we're going to measure Wellness um maybe during the February board Workshop or the U board meeting we can spend some time um if it's appropriate talking about the methodology behind that and I'll let Nicole add on to that um president I think we could use some clarification as well on what the board expectation would be because just basically listening from the conversation we would be taking um the notes that been gathered on the framework

145and some of the additions that would need to made in order to work um with a very one sentence simplistic definition and also build out some more Simplicity with the framework as well I think the wondering would be if that is something that can come back in February or if there's an expectation that that be shared um with the board sooner um potentially in some sort of memo format I I was about to say sooner yeah so um in February when we do give that update I think in the meantime we should actually work with uh the definition that of all the feedback that we got I also think that we should engage other voices and other perspectives as well in the meantime and then actually have some iterations already set um so that when

146we come back we actually have some examples so thinking about diverse voice um a couple of drafts around the Simplicity of the of the definition and then also some iterations of of this piece so we shouldn't wait for the next Workshop but we should continue moving forward those are the three things that I think we should do thank thank you that sounds great and I'm looking to other trustees is that I see that thumbs up over here excellent so over the next sixish weeks by the end of January having this definition refined by working in collaboration with Community um getting feedback from trustees so that when you come back when we all come back together on this topic in February we've got an essentially fully baked definition um that we're just formally affirming in February

147and then able to use that February Workshop to talk through uh the measurement piece which hopefully Melissa you will come back and and join us for um as we continue to then get clear um about how we're GNA then roll this out and implement it uh next year um all right let's go on to public comment uh let's see Miss sutz do we have anyone here for public comment thank you and how long can you provide some guidelines three minutes hello okay thanks everyone Isel martinis uh par educator president and piff Early Childhood special education working out of the School Readiness program um if you want examples of where students at the three and four year old age are living into this um Wellness definition come to Claremont Canyon academy uh we work adamant about

148reinforcing their self-awareness acknowledging their social emotional growth and being able to have them acknowledge where they're at and their own bodily self before anything else is accessed a child will not be able to attend to lecture if they don't have food in their tummy if they are upset over their drop off or maybe something was said to them at recess they're not going to be able to attend to any of that so we are already teaching them how to access those emotions and those um coping strategies I want to call them to be able to address their emotions in a healthy way so that then they could access all of the academics so while you all were defining and redefining I wanted to propose um a possible suggestion to the definition Wellness is being aware

149and committing to our body mind and connections where we address our physical and mental well-being as well as teaching and refining connections with family friends and Community which is the foundation of learning and achievement um one of the points that I saw in the draft Wellness that I really want to uh re iterate is that the it's the very last sentence in that sheet it says school systems and teachers play a big part in helping students develop all these areas um we are the models and if we don't feel like we matter that won't resonate with the children so I go in every single day showing these children modeling what healthy Minds healthy body look like and hey let's go run let's go down the slide let's go communicate how we're feeling if I'm upset

150I'm going to let you know hey you kicking me is gonna is GNA hurt me I'm not mad but you need to tell me what kicking means to you why are you kicking oh you you ended recess earlier and you wanted more recess time well this is when it ends if we are working through all of our work this is the next time we're going to get to go outside so I think it's really understanding all of those aspects of the child and then being able to refine it thanks thank you that's all well thank you for sharing and for reminding us to go to our littlest ones to get uh the most important insights I really appreciate the work we've done collectively here over the last few hours appreciate the extra time uh that

151everyone has put in particularly Scott I know Nicole um and the entire team that has collaborated work together so thank you all I'm excited about where we are I think we all have a lot more clarity um and are going to build a system that supports Wellness in all students so this meeting is is now adjourned our next regular meeting will be tomorrow December 10th 2020

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.