CorpusRecord 106112

SLCUSD Board Meeting, 02.04.2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / SanLuisCoastalUSD
Date
2025-02-05
Location
San Luis Obispo County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
26,981 words · about 150 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening and welcome to the regularly scheduled uh February 4th 2025 meeting of the San Louis Coastal Unified School District Board of Trustees the board met previously in closed session we discussed one item of anticipated litigation uh a Personnel uh review and possible action on employment and conferred with our labor negotiators and no action was taken we have translation services available if there is anyone that requires translation um at the at the back of the room we have headphones and if you are joining us via Zoom um there is a little a little ball icon at the bottom of your screen if you click on that uh you'll be connected with translation services Maria are you with us thank you okay the board is uh now in Open Session and I believe that all of

002the board members all board members are present um do we have consensus on the order of business we do okay uh then we move on to item 5.01 student representatives to the board uh Mor OB Bay please begin hello everybody my name is air segler um we have a slideshow for tonight okay starting off um our Dance Fusion hosted dance Beyond which is a countywide High School Dance convention on Saturday February 1st the day included three classes of each students Choice hip-hop lyrical or contemporary dance taught by guest teachers from calply Allan Hancock and Klein dance studio 73 students from area high schools attended and it was very successful the day ended with a showcase performance from all the dancers last week we hosted The schoolwide Poetry out loud competition and the contestants blew us

003away all mbhs students participated in poetry out loud the week before in their English classes congratulations to Orion Ray first place ashed Barnett Davis second place and ASA viad third place Orion Ray will be representing mbhs in the countywide competition on Saturday February 8th we all we did our ASB inter mural volleyball tournament last week it was so much fun and even though the staff team won the championship game last Frid we still were very excited for it um last Friday we held our Adam Sandler day at school and it was wonderful to see everyone dressed up and showing off their school spirit it was super fun and all the students were excited about it and so for some other campus events cowply admissions is hosting their United by Excellence love Legacy and culture event

004on Friday February 14th and at this time we have over a dozen nbhs students that will be lucky enough to attend last night there was a screening of the film New Providence at the Bay theater an nbhs alumni of the class of 74 Jack Smith produced the film about the final season of six on six girls basketball in the mid in the midwest in 1993 the screening was a fundraiser for the Moray high school girls basketball team and I was well attended and the donated amount was well over $1,200 so thank you for everyone who attended that event the county Mock Trial Competition kicked off on Saturday nbhs is 2 and0 so far defeating both slow high and Templeton High This Week Tonight Tonight and Thursday we will compete against Mission College Prep and AG

005high school so good luck to our mock trial team for that and some of our students in interact Club attended the Take the Lead leadership and ethics seminar hosted by the rotary of Atascadero on January 25th the students participated in activities in the areas of team building leadership and ethics and met other students from northern County high schools so is a great for our interact Club to be a part of that and lastly on General School items our biotechnology students took a field trip to Santa Rita Ranch near Templeton to search for and identify various mushrooms next they'll post their observations on the citizen science site inaturalist.org tournament one of the largest high school wrestling tournaments in the nation was held on the 24th and 25th of January there were 101 high school teams wrestling

006and participating a special shout out to our own Shay Dawson as he placed third in the 138 weight class just for perspective there were over 70 wrestlers in his weight class so we're very proud of Shay uh winter seasons are in their final stages we had senior nights for uh wrestling boys basketball this Friday there'll be a senior night for boys soccer and Tuesday is a senior night for girls basketball next week uh teams are doing well in League Play and most likely will be in the playoffs and we can't wait for the start of spring Sports so thank you uh for giving us the opportunity to share tonight and now we give it on to slow all right um hello everyone good evening um thanks again for having me I'm not your typical Linda

007agu roas I'm Leo dorus I'm the vice president of slow high schools ASB and yeah I'm subbing in today for the president presentation thank you all all right so first on the docket is the ASP activity as sorry uh asb's had a pretty busy week yeah good yeah okay okay uh yeah asb's had a pretty um busy week this past week we had our um first rally of the second trimester which involved bringing out a lot of the school um sports teams and all that jazz we' announced our winner formal team uh which is going to be the masquerade ball it's going to be on February 22nd tickets are going to go on sale next week and it's a big thing for our sophomore class officers very proud of them getting that ball rolling as

008well um ASB is also continuing our weekly lunchtime activities uh as you can kind of see on the little slide there in the left we had a basketball competition pop a shot out in the Commons and um next week or today sorry this week um tomorrow we're hosting another engine an engineering challenge where kids can build popsicle sticks and Dixie cup towers and we're going to be giving out prizes to see who do the best so that is what we're doing at lunch um as well at that last rally we announced we were going to bring back mock Rock very big announcement um it's an old event that ASP used to have it's very important and our wellness club is collaborating with ASB this year to bring it back as well so we're all very

009happy about that we had a bunch of teachers perform at the rally as well uh there's some great videos out there um our dance teacher Mr metler dressed up in a Deadpool costume and just it was fantastic so all right next up as well we also had poetry out loud it was or wait yeah we had poetry out loud it was just like more it was fantastic we had lots of students um compete from all grade levels uh Ethan Desta ended up coming out with the win um he's a fantastic student if you had seen the performance he did an absolutely amazing job but we wanted to extend our thanks to anyone who um participated they all did amazing and we're gonna be sending Ethan to hopefully compete with Orion and in the county in

010the county competition so yes very successful and with help from the black and gold booster it was a great event um we handed out a Kindle prize to our winner and we're it's been growing in popularity year-over-year it's become a really big event here at sloh high and we're very proud of it all right next up we have all of our Sports and so it's a very busy time in slow high for sports just um around League before CIF starts uh tiger yeah it's been a lot of stuff happening girl soccer for one we're having a fantastic season they just recently beat retti and Pastor robbles going off to start uh and boys soccer as well defeated retti um they tied Paso they're also doing very good and they have two games left in league

011for the rest of the season uh girls basketball's having a fantastic end of league as well they're I believe don't quote me on this but they're either 22 and4 or 21- four they're undefeated in League they're having an amazing job um if they win their next two games they'll go on to their first league title in the I think since 2003 so it's a very big game this Friday if you have the time please come out to the tiger gymnasium it's a huge huge game for girls basketball I they're actually also playing right now down in the gym so go Tigers um boys basketball as well sadly lost to St Joe's recently but we can't be that mad because they're the I think 15th best team in the country um but we held our own

012so we're very happy about that and we also took down AG it's the first time in a long time that um sloh high was able to sweep the season series against AG so we're all very proud of that and as well um in terms of wrestling boys wrestling recently defeated Loke in a dual meet and our girls wrestling team went to Hollister where Eve of cabia took fifth place and her sister Haley cabia took sixth place in the tournament overall also very proud of them and next week I believe League Play will wrap up for those two teams and we'll be moving on to CIF brackets as well as for most of our other sports teams so it's very very great and on the last note for sports um winter cheer um finished up their

013season they had or not finished up my apologies had their um senior night where they recognized is escabedo and Liz Vargas two of our amazing winers winner cheer athletes out of game as well last Friday so that is what our sports teams are up to which is a lot all right and lastly uh to end my presentation we have a little bit about FFA FFA Future Farmers of America group they've been doing a lot they've been keeping busy uh they had their annual January meeting uh consisting of lots of bowling and besting Langs as well and they just started a new initiative called greenand week in order to welcome all the freshmen at sloh high who are just starting a new a class for the um third trimester uh the greenand um week and involves

014participating in a scavenger hunt dying your hands green decorating cupcakes and letting people make their Mark by printing a poster um as well as tonight uh as we speak a multitude of students are participating in a sectional speaking competition um such as job interview preparation um prepared and EXT extemporaneous public speaking as well as impromptu competition so our FFA team is up to lots of good and we all wish them lots of luck tonight and that is the end of my presentation I hope I didn't blow through it too fast and thank you again for coming and letting me speak now okay are there any board questions for our student reps well seeing none then thank you very much for coming um as always you are welcome to stay and participate in the meeting um

015but we're mindful that you have other obligations as well so um me feel free to leave us now with our thanks than you moving on we have item 6.01 which is correspondence at the time the agenda was printed we had received uh four items of Correspondence one from Tamara Campbell regarding of transparency transparency for the January 22nd meeting apparently there was some difficulty with um being able to uh submit the request to speak via Zoom at at that meeting Lee Clark remark uh regarding the removal of funding for TK classes Nancy Reed with some helpful ideas and Amber Wilkerson proactively thinking about special education the budget and what is best for students and families so we thank you all for corresponding with us uh the next item is item 6.02 public comment um before we

016embark on public comment I I would like to um see what the board's pleasure is um anticipating that there will be significant comment tonight and also that we want to be able to engage in a robust board discussion um of our of our budget issues I'd like to propose that we limit public comment to two hours um and then public comment and proceed with the board's discussion what is the the feeling of the board Mrs Balano no okay anyone Mr rer I am in favor of having a stop in two hours however I would at that time like to see how many folks still wish to speak and think that we may need to at some point limit public comment from three minutes to two minutes okay what at what point would we gauge that

017um I think at two hours why don't we stop the public comment and then have a discussion with the board and see what's left on the agenda how many people want to speak to us um and then make a decision from there because we do want to hear from everybody yes um so we'll go with three minutes up to the two hours and then right reassess going forward with and and I think we would want to ask people as usual um to try to to try to make their comments um under three minutes if possible and and if they are uh repeating what other people say if they could indicate that too so that we can gauge get a gauge of support for um what different folks are saying Mrs Balo that that makes sense

018to me um and what I was going to also propose I just want to also point out as it's printed in our agenda we typically do have the prerogative to limit public comment to 20 minutes per agenda item so it's a significant increase from our Norm um but I do agree that it would be good to pause at two hours see if how much is left and then make another adjustment at that point okay Mr Buckman yeah and also I'd like to think about um adjusting it to two minutes at the beginning and that ultimately that'll probably allow more people to speak so that's just throwing it out there okay well what do we think about that I guess I'd be interested in seeing how many people who are here right now plan on speaking

019and then we can make a judgment from there I'm sorry what how many on zoom and and how many yeah and I guess we get a sense on Zoom too so um let if we could sort of get a sense for how many people actually want to speak I think then we could decide whether a two or three minute limit would be best at this point okay well I anticipate that that most of the people who are present will be wanting to speak to item 9.01 I don't know how much General general public comment we will have tonight now and if people would be so kind as to fill out a yellow sheet so we can accurately so you have 10 people currently for general public comment present in the room and if those of

020you who who may wish to speak would be so kind as to fill out a yellow form so we can more accurately gauge um as we proceed with making a decision as to how to do this and then I don't know Miss Dawson is there a way to get a sense on Zoom as to how many may wish to speak so th you mind if I do that if those of you w who are anticipating wishing to speak via Zoom would you please use the raise your hand icon so we can do a quick count for general for general public comment or for it at all um I mean we'll divy it up we've got some for general public comment and some for the budget item but uh if you would click on the raise

021your hand that'll let us know where where we stand as we make a decision as to how as to how to best use the Public's time and the board's time three or four three or four on Zoom I guess I should say so I would suggest based on the num the response that we have so far that we could uh as Mr younger stated start with the three minutes and then evaluate it two hours and switch to two if that's the board's pleasure Mr Stronger Yeah I have a clarifying question so are we talking about general public comment for two hours or or because we have general public comment and then we'll also want to have comment on item uh 9.01 so are we talking about a total of two hours for both of those

022okay I am I I I believe that's what we're we're proposing great thank you okay then then that's what we'll do um before we begin public comment um I would like to let you know that we will um be limiting our speakers and we'll be really diligent about this to three minutes um if someone else has already expressed what you were hoping to express um we uh it's possible to save some time by just raising your hand as they speak and and acknowledging them and we will be aware then that you are uh expressing the same issues or concerns [Music] um we will take the we will take the public comment of those present in the room first and then we'll move to zoom hey and then written and then written public comment if there

023is any okay this is cheffer okay thank you um in order to save a tiny bit of time I'm going to read out three names this is for the general public comment section of our program tonight and then you can be prepared to to address this Jody Peterson followed by Debbie Hil followed by Darcy Castro yeah the microphone needs to be turned on please we're getting there we go there you go okay that's a little bit much sry okay I'm talking about more Elementary one of the trustees jobs is to IDE the terms and conditions of selling the moral elementary school property I hope you are considering an option that benefits both the district and the City of moral quote selling or leasing with option to P purchase the property must be offered to a

024group of designated entities for Park and recreational purposes pursuant to government code these entities must be allowed 60 days after receiving notice to respond and are also entitled to an negotiation period of 90 days after giving notice to the district of their interest in the property this requirement cannot be waved this quote unquote this quote is from the Lozano Smith 2021 checklist for sale or lease of school Surplus property if the district accepts a lump sum the many the money can only be used for infrastructure or buildings more advantageous to the district is to lease for 999 years for leas to buy accepting payments over time allows the money to be used at the trustees discretion it allows for flexibility the community is also very interested in retaining the soccer fields and playground areas and

025presses the city to do so this is an option the board cannot wave we desire for you to work with us on this I also raise for consideration whether the property was modernized or improved since October 2nd 2013 with State funding from the state allocation board or Sab if so it is our understanding that such money will have to be returned to the Sab at the campus is no longer in the districts finally the question is begged why is the district removing four of our your programs and two rental programs now at the end of the school year when the process of getting either the city or some developers project through the process will take years why not maintain the stability of your four programs why not continue to bring in substantial income from the

026two rental programs even if the elementary school property sells sooner rather than later it will be profitable to the new owner to have money coming in while going through the multi-year planning process with the city thanks for thanks for listening thank you very much I'm Debbie Hill um a retired public school teacher been in moral Bay for over 20 years I also would like to talk about um having the city of moral Bay have the property that now is um called the moral Elementary um with the district choosing the exempt Surplus land option that requires um a waiver from the State's Department of house Housing and Community Development or hcd the district has already applied to the hcd but what we don't know is what kind of waiver the district has applied for it could

027be exemption number two which is about land for affordable housing the community of moral Bay prefers um option or exemption three the land is dedicated to other public uses the community prefers um number three because we support the city previously stated consideration which was to move city offices to the school grounds um that would free this this scenario would free up approximately two and a half acres of land owned by the city to be used for housing which we need for Workforce and seniors making this move allows both preservation of the historic Elementary School and the fields and it offers us freed up land upon which we could build the kind of housing Our Town actually needs uh we request that you and your staff be forthcoming um with what kind of waiver you seek

028we desire to work with this uh with this we we desire for you to work with the city for Mutual benefit um both now and in the future as the district will seek to support support um seek the support of Marl Bay voters for future Bond measures we um have a very Lively group of activists in moral Bay and we have successfully been the only city in the county to pass measure L for um the County Library System we also successfully passed an ordinance to prevent camping on the Embarcadero and most recently we passed a land use ordinance to bring voters into the battery storage process um we want to partner with you and we want to have a Cooperative relationship thank you thank you next is Darcy Castro followed by Betty wi holdz and

029then uh Tamara Campbell feel like I need a stepping still okay good evening hello my name is DRC Castro and I am a resident of moral Bay and I am also here to discuss concerns I have with the proposed sale of the moral Bay elementary site um you are a school board and you're beholden to serving our community and the children in it um this is definitely not an investment property um but rather it was land that was clearly gifted to the city of moral Bay this land was sold for absolute pennies to create a school to the children of moral Union Elementary School District it was made possible by moralay taxpayers hard work and support of the community this was long before San Louis Coastal District acquired this property and I do not find

030it unreasonable for citizens of moral Bay to ask for transparency due diligence or forthcoming information or being forthcoming with the information specifically in accordance with the nailor act the community has not been informed as to whether an advisory committee of 7 to 11 people has been formed since the decision to sell the property as outlined by the Lozano Smith legal firm this is a required legal step before declaring a site as Surplus which I believe is already in the process it seems disingenuous at best if a community or a committee has been retained from prior attempts to sell this committee is supposed to be a diverse group of individuals that represent Community interests and ensure transparency the committee advises the school board as to whether a property is retained for public use or to be

031sold this is an essential group to ensure due diligence and maintain public trust it is also unclear as to whether the district notified the city of moral Bay and writing to ensure the sale of this property that it does conform to the city's already adopted certified General plan and then give the city the required 40-day allowance for reply additionally no information as far as I know has been given as to whether the former Property Owners owners of moral Bay elementary site have been notified the 60 days in advance to facilitate a meeting of resolution this is also a requirement I believe in this instance it would require a notification to the Quintana family and or relatives your decisions have a deep impact on our city our residents and our future and so I would really

032like to work with you the community of moral Bay um so thank you for your time thank you Betty winholtz is next good evening my name is Tammy Campbell oh you know I'm sorry we have Betty winholtz next then you follow you follow after that you're fine you're fine Daddy my name is Betty winholtz and I'm from moral Bay also um I just want to make sure that you all saw the letter from our city council um that said we are very interested I know that you first received word uh back in December from our Council that um we were going to at that point not be interested in pursuing a purchase of the ele school and that uh since then with pressure from the community the council took another vote and sent you a

033hopefully you all received a copy of our letters and said that we are interested and are looking forward to working with you both in terms of the nailor act the 7-Eleven committee even though you have an old 7-Eleven committee my question to you does that still apply or 20 years later do we need to have a new committee um there's lots of questions the waiver what kind of waiver so just to sum up thank you for working with us we look forward to this it will be a it'll be a process and so um thank you very much thank you thank you now tamon Campbell who will be followed by Kristen eldrid and then Emily calano hi my name is Tammy Campbell and I've been an education advocate for over 40 years um I've served

034on countless ptas site counsels uh even a Citizens budget advisory committee a redistricting committee you name it I've served on it um I also am a member uh a resident in Northern California and you do not want to go through the budget crisis that we went through it was the worst in the state of California and made ESPN news in the early 2000s so we wanted to we were the school district that wanted to cut Sports so I think communication is key I appreciate the fact that you guys are willing to extend but in these particular budgetary times I want you to think about listening to everybody let everybody have a voice let them be heard because sometimes it's really nerve-wracking for people to come up here especially firsttime parents um as a district who

035needs to make some really impactful decisions in the next few years because you're going to have to make some big budget cuts I've looked at your budget I'm concerned and one of the things I think you need to do is communication right and I want to commend whoever put this together great work this is on the budget but it's on budget cuts I think we need to educate the public about how budgets work in the state of California school districts are underfunded and are in the process of trying to survive so I would like to com ask that you start a Citizens budget advisory committee composed of your your District CFO one representative from each one of your unions so they can be heard one to two parents from each educa educational level high school

036Representatives their leaders in their communities and Business Leaders working together to understand the budget and get the information out because you guys have very few years before you're going to have to make some drastic cuts um and I know what it's like to close a school I was one of those members the committee to close a school on behalf of the other 28,000 students in the district and it's a hard thing to do um but we need to educate people your B about your basic Aid District your restricted versus unrestricted the cost of Staff compensation um understanding maturation cycles and uh economies of scale uh I would like to know if you Schoolboard members attend City Council meetings on a regular basis and Report out so you get on their minutes so those citizens here

037um and I I do want to say something that might be a little controversial but I'm wondering about the sale of the property maybe it's time we think about the retention of your employees and maybe building housing for them because this area is getting really expensive I'm telling you I I'm looking at the prices and I'm just shocked so teaching citizens is really key and really important I'm here to is Christen Eldridge um hi I'm Kristen Eldridge I am a teacher and proud parent at Hawthorne Elementary and on Monday morning um we had our uh our principal principal jamo presented to us our achievements session um in the library there at Hawthorne the Li that's half under construction and it's exciting and crazy and chaotic but um it was really um an an exciting moment

038to see how much we have grown and achieved in the last four years um the data was there in front of us and um one of the slides that really stuck with me was about our counseling program and I know I've been at Hawthorne for um I believe this is my nth or 10th year and um our school counselor care ship cot is just an invaluable resource to me and our staff and our students and um the data there was amazing she's doing small group sessions she's doing individual sessions she's teaching lessons in classrooms um she has met with 800 I believe the number was 830 students now we only have like 450 is students but 830 student contacts and I quickly was like wait this is like the 103rd day of school so how

039is this it's just amazing um she uh of our highrisk students she has met with 98% of them of our high-risk students I know she gets our students through the day she gets me through the day she gets our staff through the day with her wonderful laugh um that I can hear all over campus and um I just hope and pray that we have her on our team next year and I also just want to say that um over the years Hawthorne has had some openings that have been tricky to fill and um recently we got to bring on Coach McCully into our PE program and I just when I see these Cuts I think about him because he's new he moved hundreds of miles away to come to San Louis biso where the cost

040of living is challenging and um we're so grateful to finally have like somebody that's like all in and part of our team and again just these are people behind these numbers I know your job is really hard but I just want to speak on their behalfs thank you thank you Emily calano hi I'm Emily calano as second grade teacher ala Haw and I'm the vice president of the teachers union um members of the board and um everybody here um I'm here really in support of our 7,000 plus students that are more than likely will be affected by um and greatly affected by our proposed cuts and counseling as you know by the data that our district requires our counselors to compile our students need and greatly utilize our counseling services this has uh evolved through

041the post-pandemic era to a place where our students are keeping are um receiving proactive care support and tools to assist them through difficult times they encounter cutting counseling which will result in a two to three day program per week will not serve students when they need support um comparing the prepandemic counseling service which was as you know two to three times a week to the current Services uncovers the true needs of our students on a Monday through Friday basis cutting counseling turns it into a Tuesday Thursday or Monday Wednesday Friday program tell that to a grieving student we don't have a counselor here today we can't help you we have no one to help you to take you for an hour when you're crying because you miss your mom who's not alive anymore who will

042support that child who will support our 20 something children who need support daily daily at our schools thank you thank you so I would ask at this time is there anyone else in the room who wishes to address the board on General Public comment if so please approach and state your name and then we'll go to zoom so good evening board and cabinet um my name is Elizabeth abisher and I am the El specialist at CL Smith Elementary I want to thank you for listening to all of our public comment and I recognize that you are going to be making very difficult decisions that will impact our community and our students profoundly I am glad to know that you plan to offer TK to our youngest students and I request that you are mindful of

043our families who may not have the opportunity or courage to speak up about their needs at our last staff meeting our principal and us that registration for TK will be first come first serve in an online format in the first week of March while this may seem fair it is not Equitable this approach to registration will likely exclude many of our socioeconomically disadvantaged families it will and our English learner families and families in transition who are not aware of this early registration date when our principal informed us of of this at seal Smith we all were kind surprised and disappointed and we agreed that we as a staff would make efforts to reach out to our socioeconomically disadvantaged families that we know have incoming TK students however we will likely miss some of them many

044of them in addition we most certainly will have vulnerable families in transition who will move into our neighborhoods during the summer or just before the school year these are the students who most need the benefit of Early Education they should not be turned away because they were not able to register first come first serve this form seven months before the start of the school year this has also been the case with Summer experience fames families should be signing up now for summer experience which is often tricky for our soci socioeconomically disadvantaged families in the past the district has prioritized these families for the programs like TK and summer experience when my children were of preschool age it was my understanding that the district had a policy that was there was an income threshold and the

045families who really needed that service were prioritized especially if there are any kinds of cuts and TK is not fully implemented I recommend that this the process of being um first come and first served be analyzed and really we prioritize the students who really need this services our District's greatest goal and challenge which I strongly affirm is to narrow the achievement gap for our socioeconomically disadvantaged students and in order to meet that goal our district must make steps to provide Equitable access to TK and summer experience for these families this could mean reaching out specifically thank you okay so I'm just saying he is there is there anyone else present in the room okay I'd like to okay just keep in mind that you know for people who want to speak later on WE yep

046hi uh Tim Jou my daughter graduated from St Louis high school last year I'm actually glad she survived public school um that's not a joke anyways um maybe I missed it earlier maybe acknowledge that it's black history month I could have missed that um I'm not going to stay around for the budget talk maybe I mean referencing what Elizabeth said maybe some of our problems will be cured by immigration's Customs Enforcement I you know I don't know if that's a big thing on the school board's minds but I was at the last meeting previous and all I saw was Dow faces talking about the budget we're talking $5 million that's what four houses in sandless B I would like to see you people people angry and fighting for children not how do we cut $5

047million from the budget I mean you sound I mean that's like that's what they're doing with federal government we're tearing it down right now I would love it I don't know maybe nobody would get on board i' love what she said about going to city council and pointing it out I mean the city of slow right now is figuring out how to hire more police officers Cal po figuring out how to control Cal Poly students up the budget up the budget up the budget there I know you have zero public support generally and I'm sorry for that and I'm one of the guilty parties but God I'd love to see you guys angry about this not just going down the list and seeing which people are going to have to cut so thank you um

048I spoke briefly at the last meeting but I felt compelled to come here again um and represent a population of our community families who have children receiving special education services would you state your name please yes sorry Sarah mcra I am a parent of a child at lagona Middle School St Louis High School I am also a service coordinator for the tri County's Regional Center and have a case load of 80 children with uh disabilities who I advocate for um first I want to ask a question uh for those who are willing to share in the whole room can you raise your hand if you have or are in a close friends with a child receiving special education services okay well that's that's good that's good because I I found often that in speaking about

049you know equity and inclusion um so often disability neurodiversity is often the last thing mentioned unless you have a connection to it so I'm happy to see that there's a lot of people here um it takes a village to raise a child we know that and when your child has special education supports that Village has to be even larger I think a lot of parents might not have been super clear with a handout on the agenda um for example where par Educators fall and I know that the agenda mentions some areas such as student support Specialists and instructional AIDS um I tried to reach out to as many parents as I could to encourage them to attend tonight uh but the the wording wasn't clear necessarily how much this would affect our children receiving these

050supports um I was going to say that um I know that with the individuals with disabilities and Education Act we have Federal Protection for our students but now even that is in question and I just I I'm kind of exhausted and this isn't the most eloquent thing I've ever written uh but least restrictive environment is part of that law and it's says that children be educated to the maximum extent appropriate with their peers without disabilities um and that special classes separate schools or other removal of children from the regular education environment occur only when the severity of the handicap is such that education in a regular class could not be achieved my fear is that the supports that my child and other children receive to be part of their larger School community might get looked

051at too carefully and cut and and narrowed down and children might be asked or children might be put into the classrooms and environments where budget-wise and staff-wise it makes the most sense economically for the school perhaps putting them into those um special day classes in those smaller classrooms when so many of our children benefit from larger environment and having that par educator support I'm almost done um um I know I know we can do better um I will end it there because I'm but my my son did want to say something very briefly that he just wrote about um the par educator support he has received over the years at both element speak but your your time is up so we'll start the clock again please and if you could state your name please my

052mom and I um is a PR is my teacher and Ean is my in school Andia is my teach elementary school and I miss you a lot and I wish I would go that's is there anyone else in the in the room who wishes to speak on uh General comment okay would you state your name please at the microphone hi my name is Rita Rodriguez and I'm a second grade teacher at Hawthorne Elementary um thank you for your time and I know that in the next several weeks or next several days you're going to be faced with making very difficult decisions decisions that I have absolutely no Envy for having to make um the purpose purpose of my message is to reinforce the concept that our school D district is based upon people people in

053the budget the term Personnel is mentioned we in turn are serving people it's about people not just Personnel what I want to remind everyone is that Personnel is made up of people the very people who work with the students and families of San Louis abiso those people include an El instructional Aid who has the gift of being able to connect with students from preschool all the way to high school I've seen her in action counselors who Ser serve ve all students who have either faced or are now facing trauma the numbers of children facing trauma only increase they haven't decreased and our counselors are doing their work teachers who have purposly relocated to San Louis Obispo to work for Stan Louis Coastal to teach and to have purchased and they purchased homes that they may

054no longer be able to afford that they may no longer be able to stay here in San Louis abiso teachers who have person special education professionals with ever increasing responsibilities with lessening resources less people teachers who are new to the profession and bring with them the knowledge and the energy that inspires students those are going to be some of the first people to be cut unfortunately there is no winning in this scenario no program is of more value than another I want to make that personally clear um instead with the level of these budget cuts District employees our district and most importantly our students will ultimately be facing the burden we're all going to lose we're going to lose talented people our children are going to lose teachers they're going to lose counsellors I know

055there's no magic pot of money but it needs to be very deliberately thought out and decided how it's going to be proceeded upon thank you thank you see anyone else okay then Miss Dawson can you tell us if there's anyone on Zoom for general public comment okay then I do oh okay Carolyn Kota hello um my name is Caroline C and I'm a sixth grade teacher at losos middle school and Secretary of San Louis Coastal Teachers Association I'm speaking tonight to tell you about the students in my advisory class the following names I have fictionalized John's dad died suddenly less than a year ago Isabella and Shivam have expressed fear about current federal immigration policies Amy's Grandma is dying Shayla is questioning their gender identity miles is experiencing bullying due in part to his ADHD

056Francis is in foster care Candace's parents recently divorced leading to substance abuse that she witnessed at home Scarlet experienced severe trauma with her mother as a child who's no longer in her life Lulu had a restraining order against her death until his death a year and a half ago Emily's parents divorced and I just found out yesterday her counselor connected her with a social worker and um they're going to Family Court due to something her dad has done since Zak's mom is unhoused addicted to drugs and her father doesn't believe she should get an education that she should be home to cook and clean for him these stories represent 50% of one class and what I have learned about them outside of counseling the reality is there's a lot more that our students are coping

057with even than that these are 11 and 12 year olds counselors are critical to the emotional and academic success of students cutting counselors removes the opportunity for students to access their education their work is critical and I ask you to seriously consider the amend impact of cutting counselors especially from our needy neediest students speaking of which earlier this year during the presentation to the board regarding test scores a board member asked why teach elementary scores are so much higher than the other Elementary scores the reality is um that teach is not accessible to the students I mentioned these students cannot fundraise the required $1,000 a year field trips they do not have families and resources that can support the many projects that must be completed at home teach has high scores because it segregates our

058most privileged students from our most disadvantaged it's a private school funded by public dollars our students who are furthest from Justice deserve access to our best resources and our counselors are critical to their well-being and academic success thank you that's all I have Mrs Roger for general public comment okay thank you very much uh then we'll move on to item 7.01 the business and budget update Mr Pickerton yeah just a few items it's been a busy few weeks as you can can imagine um I did attend a moral Bay uh Planning Commission meeting last Thursday um the point of that was uh for the city to talk to the community about the process of development at moral Elementary and um kudos to airand singal the um community development director she did a great job laid

059that out I've shared that with the board um so it was just a it was a good time to kind of hear the from the city in terms of how the process for that property um you know it's it's it's been an interesting uh couple of weeks I would say for us up here you know Dr Prader um put together some public forums right both with staff as well as public and I think the first meeting you know staff for an hour and then the public for maybe five to six hours um and then again the following Wednesday another you know robust dialogue so you know as much as it was kind of like wow how's this going to go it was it was really critical for us to hear I think give people a

060voice and we didn't have a time limit and didn't do anything else just just listen to people right through that process both again both staff and and community so um a lot of that is the things we took in as we um tried to you know figure out our plans and we'll talk a little bit about the night you know tonight but but I I think it was a it was a great thing for for us to do and to have those meetings on the coast in the city and to and to really open that up for for the public to to again voice their concerns with us and and the things that we were discussing um outside of that man president Trump is really it's been an interesting few weeks right in terms of

061from public education employees from Ice concerns to budgetary concerns to I mean all types of things I we we had a group that was from Across the Nation come and and talk to us uh talk to our food service director Aon primer um because we have a great program if you didn't know our food service in San Coastal is absolutely fantastic and Aaron does a great job um and so and literally at the in the middle of that meeting there was all of a sudden we we weren't going to necessarily maybe get federal dollars for Food Service anymore and so just kind of a roller coaster right in terms of okay and all these people in the audience and that she was speaking to um but it's it's to say it's an interesting time right

062so we do feel that we're trying not to get bogged down in the you know all the different things that happen right but really trying to focus on okay what does this really mean what impacts will it have some of it we won't know for several months right but we'll um trying to do what we can for kids you know in the meantime and and help them it to you know especially some of the things that have come through so I just wanted you to know that we are taking those in listening hearing from our kids our families um we had a great immigration Forum recently that um shamas should can talk to you about but um that was kind of talked a little bit about then with with I went to a capital advisor's

063budget uh kind of updates state budget um and that was an interesting Dynamic so often times we we kind of hear from the you know after the governor's budget in January what what's happening what's going on with the the state budget so um a lot of unknowns right now and particularly because of the LA wildfires so how is the state gonna um use dollars and I mean several scho schools burned down right so in terms of helping them and other districts taking on more kids so it'll be interesting to see the the funding that may go towards that that issue and as it should um so we'll we'll see how that all unfolds as we go through um yet another item that came through um Dr PR was at the superintendent's um uh get together

064and uh and one of our our partners that helps us sell our bonds when we go out for Bond sales we actually have a group that that assists us with that process and um they informed us of uh the fact that he was talking uh the president's talking about getting rid of Interest free Government Bond sales so that that's how we sell our bonds and get money to fix up our schools and I mean so it's just it's a crazy time right so everything we're dealing with here on top of it all those other things going on so it's it's been a trying month there's a lot happening right all that said um I again I can't overemphasize how important those public forums were to hear from everybody um and I think all of us

065were impacted by um all the things we heard through that time period thank you um 7.02 educational services update Mrs Yan yeah good evening board and community members um lots of exciting celebrations for our school district to share um Mr Pinkerton mentioned the Fantastic immigration Forum congratulations and hats off to PCO Panthers over there and Mr huar and our our um lots of community part ERS um involved to help support families and get information out um in a timely fashion and also hats off and thank you to our slcf our foundation um Christine Robertson and the team have been busy um we H had the opportunity to go to the reach ideas and action Summit in Santa Barbara reach is a nonprofit organization focused on economic development and there are three words are jobs um

066people and homes and it's how to build a better future for all of our young families on the central coast and we heard some really interesting connected ideas and I know board members many of you are there thank you for your time but some um blue laser Fusion company is going to be hiring 500 employees and Amazon has a giga computer that they're building here on the central coast and um there was another um SpaceX was there talking about all the jobs and how they've gone from doing one launch every year to doing one launch every 3 days and there was a professor there talking about exactly why vandenbberg is the perfect and only spot on the whole earth to get things in the right orbit apparently there's some special orbit that things have to

067be in to Be an Effective satellite for communication and vandenbberg is the best place to get them up in the sky anyways there was a lot lots of interesting information about job creation and related to our CTE career pathway so that was super exciting also the foundation helps support our elementary Athletics for achievement program and we just kicked off our winter tournament so thank you Mr Angel and Stephanie Shepard for helping lead and guide that work we had boys um it's boys basketball and girls soccer and they'll be going for another two weeks on Fridays at lagona if you want to check it out in addition to that we've um had multiple principal meetings I've done site visits I also got to visit YMCA's program at Monarch Grove for our before school and after school

068care as that became a a great um point of Celebration and need for our community at large I was able to learn more about the educational programs that are going on during our before and after school care we had our board policy subcomittee meeting to try and continue the actual development of new and updated board policies to keep them Timely as well as attending the budget Town Hall which of course uh created an opportunity to meet with many individual community members at large as well to answer questions and help them understand and get feedback and finally um in the fall I had the opportunity to work with our future ready and healthy technology implementation task force with parents and staff and we drafted a three-year implementation plan and so I'm just now beginning to work

069with our internal team on the long list of things we're going to do who's going to do what and when we're going to do it all so it's exciting times oh and just yesterday we received notification um that Pacific Beach High School has been named a model continuation High School for the State of California for their excellent job um and more information to come there's a celebration dinner Gala up in April we'll get more information out to you and the public as well as we'll definitely do some kind of Celebration event locally at the school so the students and staff can celebrate but we're super proud of Mr dor and his whole pack Beach team absolutely thank you so much um back to Mr bton measure C updates yeah so on the measure SE front

070um we did receive word on a couple of opsc Grants um as the board knows with measure D we went out for a lot of matching funds through the state and so the nice part about receiving those 15-day letters it's basically like putting us into line to receive potential matching funds and so though we're done with measure D those monies will come in and will help supplement of course our need for projects and funds um through through measure C that we have more more projects than we have funds even you know which is crazy considering we have a $349 million Bond measure um but there's there's a lot of work to do with at 10 Elementary sites and two middle schools and and uh and Beach um the process continues with with DSA to be

071really slow um structural analysis it just seems these projects that um we're taking you know a year to get through DSA or now a year and six months so we're plugging along uh I can't you know kudos to the staffs that are waiting and dealing with construction at their sites and those types of things um we are trying our best to make it happen as quickly as possible through that process so um I'll be updating the board very soon um on measure C at our our next study session thank you okay item 8.01 is a resolution Mr Pinkerton yes this resolution kind of goes along with that same prop two which is a a state Bond measure that was passed um back in November um along with this also ties into developer fees so um

072this resolution uh if the board passes it tonight allows the school district because we have a facility master plan we have um a uh a a deferred maintenance plan um all of the things that we're supposed to have in line to be able to receive those prop two dollars what that also does is it allows us to continue um to collect developer fees like we have in the past and so when somebody goes to build at a property um they have to basically pay school fees before they can start their bu building permit there was was a law that passed that started in January that um for school districts basically to collect developer fees that was going to happen potentially after building right um but because of the fact that we have those things in

073place that go along with prop two um we're able to continue our same process that we've been doing um in the past of collecting those fees prior so tonight's resolution kind of goes along twofold right it helps us with our prop two and getting in line for prop two dollars because the board's basically saying that we have these things um in place um and also helps us with that developer fee uh concern as well we've actually notified the agencies in terms of having these things in line um and so tonight's resolution just supports that okay bringing it back to the board is there any discussion oh going to the public I guess first does anyone have discussion on um this resolution and no one on Zoom okay then I'll bring it back is there board

074discussion that I'm seeking a motion Mrs um I'll just note that there's a lot of legal ease in the resolution and so it was drafted and approved by legal council it's basically the 's a mechanism for us to use the procedure we've been using up until now to receive those developer impact fees prior to development as opposed to having to wait under a new law till after development because we already have some procedures in place so um it's complicated but it makes sense and so unless there's any more discussion I move to appr approve um resolution looking for the number 18 242 five a second that okay so this is I have a motion by Mrs baldano second by Mr Clawson this is a roll call vote Mrs Balano yes Mr Clawson yes Mr Buckman

075Mr hunger yes Mr Banfield yes Mrs Sheffer yes and I'm a yes bigass a 70 thank you he okay the next item is 9.01 the budget reduction recommendations and this is a presentation by Dr crater and Mr bton okay and Miss Mrs Yash okay good evening board um you know I spent um several days um with my colleagues across the state just recently and I felt like I was getting ready for the Super Bowl I was getting myself pumped up I was getting myself prepared to engage a group of superintendant and all the people that come along with superintendant which are typically um um people from Sacramento who have an interest in what it is we're doing in K12 education tk12 education and um and so when I went there I was part of some

076presentations but more more importantly than anything I was there to try and figure out how to acquire funding additional funding for our district that was my mission that was my interest and I found several people with sympathy who are in similar situations that I'm in that we're in and and simultaneously I'm sitting in a room with 150 people and the Santa Monica Malibu superintendent speaks about the fires in LA and how the Palisades families were lining up in the in his district trying to get in well he's a basic a district like us and so um a few hundred people people parents want to enroll their children in his district with no funding in addition they have the same issue as we do regarding TK and so he was expressing not only um was he

077in the governor's office a couple weeks ago pleading for payment to for the new families enrolling their children in the district that they didn't budget for um and the answer was a unequivocal no and so it took the air out of the room it was really difficult because um the the tenor in in and across the state is a a divisive one as you can imagine so what what I lean in on at this point after speaking to dozens and dozens of people is that because because I am um someone who likes to build things and create systems and structures for kids um I know I need a revenue stream so we met Mr Pinkerton and I met with uh Tom Jones um Eric Daniels from pg& and we talked about pgme funding for when

078the the plant um becomes operational or continues to be operational and um and he made it clear to us that the best pathway for achieving that is through a legislative process and um so the very place I'm going to try and acquire TK funding for basic a for our district and and by way of that other basic Aid districts is the same location that I need to go to to get a legislative intervention for the continuation of the dcy nuclear power plant it's a very interesting time that we live in and of course while I'm there people were getting up constantly looking at their phones because day in day out it was something just changed federal funds just got frozen uh immigration ice agents everywhere I mean it was it was quite a it's quite

079a time to be alive um in our field so let me start by saying there's nothing about this that's in front of you that I like not a single thing nothing about it is good everything about this tonight is um is the result of the our Lifeline our lifeblood which is funding and so when the covid dollars came we saw and recognized the need and we match that need with support and meanwhile as all of you know the um State Legislature decided not to fund TK programming for basic a districts so it was a double hit and as all of you know this the sb1090 funds expire next year so we have some challenges in front of us they're not over they're not uh insurmountable but their challenge is nonetheless and I'm an optimist I

080think we're going to get that funding somehow someway now with that said what brings us here tonight is to talk about pulling back not eliminating completely but pulling back on the things we added with the onetime dollar the Esser funds this is what you see here tonight are the things some of the things we added back many of the things we added are not on this list and um to make those decisions and to try and fet this out has been quite an incredible challenge I'll reiterate there's nothing good about this you know um and I I'm sorry I'm having to put this discussion in front of you and and our community because I think we had um we have one of the finest finest districts in California with the finest educators support staff finest

081parents and um and I I I do not take that for granted this is a challenge and we are here tonight to try and address that challenge in the best way possible and um tonight you'll hear from Mr Pinkerton who will talk about some of the elements that got us here and Miss yamashta will talk as well about some of the creative ways we think we can um make the best out of a rotten situation so I just want to say thank you for being uh willing to engage in this discussion and um make these very difficult choices um that I know are right before you addressing the structural deficit is key because we can't do anything unless we address that once we address it then we can find a way to reconstruct and rebuild

082in a sustain able way thank you yeah so we're going to start with uh just talking you the first section of this first couple pages and then U Miss Yas and myself will kind of trade off on the proposed potential reductions and then of course hear from the public and then this is again a time for the board to ask questions and tie into you know kind of these things right the board didn't get a lot of time to speak at our last board meeting um so hopefully this is a good time for you to hear what we have to say and and uh engage in that conversation um so again just to kind of start as somebody brought up hey what inform the public what do we do right how how's this work as

083a basic aade School District so um you've heard me say this probably every budget presentation that we go through um so sorry for repeating it again but again we're a basic aade School District so figure water glass right um property taxes for most school districts that are state funded their property taxes fill the glass up about halfway and then the state fills the glass right that's a lcff school district in St Louis Costa we're a basic Aid School District right so our property taxes fill the glass we don't get any state aid now for Stan Louis Coastal our glass overfills a overflows a little bit right but know that there are other basic Aid school districts that have two glasses right so that's the part that sometimes people misplace when they look at you know

084basic gate School District districts that there's you know I think when I first got here we were may we were like $20 million in the Bas decade and now we're down to n and dropping right because as we add more kids as we grow in terms of enrollment with TK next year um that number will will decrease because there's a lot of State funding that goes into TK so they have CL sizes of 10 to you know 20 to two right um extra special funding to make that happen next year so a lot of those things so again we're getting closer to a state funded level um and so when we look at the types of services programs we have we're getting closer to what our neighbors are have right and and that's something that's

085very different from us we've always prided ourselves on paying our people the most having the best programs having um all of those things in place right so um when you look at our overall spending as somebody said we are a people business yes we serve people and we are people so most of our um most of our budget is spent on people now you can't look at the overall Personnel cost based on expenditures right because we're $5 million over in expenditures so normally you take that amount that we we look at Personnel cost and you apply that to our our Revenue stream what what how much are we spending on people compared to the money that we're taking in um and so for us we're at about 87.8% okay healthy is down be below 85%

086and so we've we've kind of got there the last time this happened to us um I was actually an HR in in human resources for the school district so it about 10 years ago that we went through this process um the last time um so you'll see it's a little funky because you have the stirs back and forth M Rogers kind of pointed that out to to me um I believe yesterday but that's stirs is kind of weird they they want to take credit for the money they give teachers in retirement so it's a they give us money and then they make us put it in the budget it takes out so it really doesn't equate to anything um but you'll kind of see most of our funding of course is property taxes um so

087we look at these reductions you'll see at the the when you look at our expenditures very little of it utilities operating expenses books and supplies from benefits admin salaries classified salaries certificated salaries that is our that is our budget that is most of it so we've tried to um look for some areas to reduce outside of people right you'll see that as we'll present it tonight um but but know that most of the reductions unfortunately have to do with Personnel have to do with people um and so and we'll we'll talk about each of those as we go through uh in terms of enrollment you'll see that we have some slight enrollment growth really you know compared to 1819 It's relatively stable uh we dropped postco um parents had choices to go other places right

088uh didn't want their kids wearing masks coming back to school I didn't like online learning those types of things um and we're we're getting some of those students back I would say over time but but they're still you know a little bit dip and so our growth really has been the influx of new TK students so each year we've been adding a few months right three months next year we'll add the the June July August dates right for four year old so that's why when we've talked about increasing in TK going from you know 320 students to about 400 anticipated in the fall um the only other thing I would say so all of this in terms of as we go through this no enrollment hasn't happened okay um first I've ever heard about early

089TK enrollment happening just so you know that's not something that in fact it was brought up and we said no you can't do that so I'll I'll work with site and talk about our schools right in terms of Elementary sites and how that goes but that should not be happening um so it maybe it's a again mistake we'll we'll talk with sites but um for the exact same reasons that were brought up tonight um we can't ask parents to enroll in February it's to they're not they're not thinking about school yet so absolutely yes right um so it it should be no different than what we've done in the past um in terms of enrollment processes TK those types of things right so no changes from what we've done in the past um so but

090we'll we'll clarify that with principles tomorrow make sure secretaries understand um we talked to them we had a secretary meeting and we talked about um you know really keeping track of TK students and making sure we know enrollments right because as we start to fill classes I want to make sure that we have enough Staffing and how this is going to work so that was interpreted by the secretary to start having people sign up so I don't know but I will find out and we'll we'll make sure that that is that's um corrected um in terms of what are the restricted funds so you see on the right hand side I want to make it clear when we we we have um our general fund right so that includes state federal dollars um so you

091know local property taxs those types of things but some funds are restricted so for example Food Service Food Service funds are absolutely separate outside of our budget so they have to be spent only on Food Service only on food only on meals for kids right so all the Staffing everything that goes with food service is all in the Food Service budget um when we look at our bond measure those dollars cannot be used for salaries they cannot be used to fix this problem to solve issues as we go through they can only be used on building okay so um other things that that have been brought up so again you'll you'll notice some things we left off of this list so know that we we left things off right the things we heard from the

092public forums from staff um there are no special ed reductions that we're talking about right now the the only things we've talked about in terms of special education is trying to contain the the growth of the program right so just know that so um we have a a we have a maintenance of effort requirement we we actually can't reduce the amount we spend on special ed you have to spend $1 more than you spent the year before okay so um are there some process things we need to look at procedures with special education and AIDS allocations and teachers and class SI absolutely um and those are things that Miss Yash has we've met with Mrs gold every every week for the past three weeks just discussing what that would look like and ways that we

093can um go go through that process um again there's some Career Technical education dollars that are are focused in a certain way our ELO funds can only be used for the before and after school care right we also tie it into our TK program as well as it's a mandatory 30 days extended school year for kids that is how ELO funds are spent tk6 only not high school summer school not anything else not Middle School only those things right so and these are all programs that I'm discuss I'm discussing now that are all audited so Auditors come in they check they go to school sites they look at our ledgers they make sure that funds are spent as they're supposed to um again Title One Ida funds that talked about special education uh the lcap

094itself is something that the board will still um go forward with and develop right and we'll have our final budget will be done in June um but those those funds are focused on our El Foster Hess youth economically disadvantaged students and then lastly Adult School Adult School for itself that that we used to actually give adult school money we I think we gave about $75,000 a year um had some great questions from board members about Adult School um but that is basically a self-funded program so because of such huge interest with parent participation which actually charges they actually pay for themselves right so and a lot of the other adult school programs benefit from um those funds that they receive right so our GED program and other things like that so they're they're separate from

095that general fund that we're discussing and that's where the structural deficit lies um on the next page you'll see a a section that just kind of outlines how Co funds were spent so back in uh 2002 or 2022 uh the board approved a covid funded spending plan and basically the items that I've listed here those are the things that the board approved for us how how we're going to spend our Co dollars right um and Mand did we spend them well right we developed the great mtss systems we had a Counsel on special assignment at the district office that worked with counselors K tk12 right a set up programs teaching lessons working with kids um more more intervention programs worked with our El staff our El's AIDS our teachers I mean fantastic with these dollars

096that we we put together and I think we spent them well um and which is great and honestly I tried to hold off as long as possible before this day would happen right so um we receiv received and again you can go through some of them of course were um we paid teachers to come back and uh some of our special education staff work with students in person during covid right in small groups because it was best for the kids and so those teachers were were given you know some extra pay for that um you know buying computers we had masks for kids all those things that went into kind of bring kids back but for the most part it most of the funds were were established to set up our mtss programs again we

097had a principal on special assignment Laura storm was here right working with our team developing assessments with kids looking at um common assessments across the district right um I mean just a lot of different things that were Investments to kind of set the programs as Dr Prater said he likes to established programs for kids right and get those set up um so that that was about $13 million um and what I would tell you is last year's deficit was over 7 million and this year's proposed deficit is about 5 million so that's where the co funds right so we've we kind of ran our Surplus up and now we've brought it back down where we were so the problem is is now it's not it's not this year it's next year right where we have

098a potential structural deficit of about 6.3 million dollar um what what Mrs yamas and I are going to speak to tonight doesn't even get us there so the reductions were so tough as we even went through them we didn't want it we didn't want to cut anymore we only got to 5.8 million we didn't even get to 3.5 or 6.3 right so um that said there's a lot that can happen between now and June where we'll look for other things in the budget we'll see what happens with the May Revis other things right in terms of it um but but this was you know again as Dr prer said this was about as tough as it gets in terms of going through and and trying to have to recommend reductions and and how to do

099that um again guiding principles of the board your board goals is fiscal solvency right that that has always been one of the the main goals of the board um since I've been for the past 14 15 years um is to ensure that we are uh fiscally solvent and um and again trying to keep our Reserve levels at a place that's safe right should something bad happen um so again some guiding principles we talked about so again returning closer to prepandemic levels um trying to preserve as much as we can of Student Center priority programs M Masha will talk about those as we go through them and then maximize the impact of programs that reach the greatest number of students so um all of those things tie into um what we thought about right is as

100we try to uh make reductions as we go through this so um so again I'll I'll start and I'm going to go through my uh potential reductions that that I will talk about and then Mr will talk about um the other that are on the list so we we'll jump around a little bit um but we'll kind of go through them so the first one which is our biggest um item right that we talk about when reductions again total reductions um again projected right now we don't know for sure what's going to happen with property taxes where where we end but but again based on our conservative projections this is about where we feel like we're going to fall in terms of next year it gets even worse the following year I don't want to

101go there yet right I think it's just let's focus on 2627 or 2526 um and and not not the following year at this time right though that will be something that we'll have to consider as as we move forward um once we hear from the governor with the May Revis um so again most of most of our Personnel expense is classroom teachers as it should be as it should be right so um we have kept class sizes really low as a school district over over the past five years and and focused on that right I mean I think we we added three classes in August last year to not have combination classes at at several of our schools um now I will tell you there are teachers in this room right now that have 34

102kids in their fifth grade class and they'll be like Pinkerton what are you what low class sizes you you haven't been in my class um but again if you look at the whole totality of classes across uh s Louis Coastal and the elementary level grade levels they are very low right compared to our neighbors and we did it on purpose we kept class sizes low on purpose our teachers again even teachers had a hard time coming back from Co it wasn't just kids it's tough it's tough work and when you're dealing you're working with kids that have a lot of needs and um you know it takes a lot right it takes a lot for teachers to to to do the work and and to do it well with kids um and so none of

103these things are we're GNA talk about I don't take that lightly that we're going to potentially try to raise class size some we're not going to raise it you know even going through the class size just to raise it to 26 to1 tk3 is painful right as we go through it it's not our Norm kind of what we do um so it's again we looked at it we went through so at this point not knowing what enrollment is going to be okay until May right once people sign up once people comeing we have a we have a pretty good idea by may you know where where we're going to be enrollment wise of course there are kids that move in and the summer and those things and we make those adjustments in August and um

104July right as they come in but but for the most part we'll we'll we'll have a pretty good idea by the time the board passes the budget um in terms of where what where we look like it with class size but that said um Elementary in particular is where most of that extra class size has gone that's where most of the positions have have been to keep class size is low we we in fact most of the things you'll talk about you'll see tonight is is very Elementary oriented ented because as a school district we focus on Elementary we do that's where a lot of our support systems um that we put in place are really Elementary Centric right with the goal that kids by the time they get to middle school and high school

105they're they're on board they can read they can write they can you know move forward so like for for example all of our title $1 except for some funds we have to give to PB because of the number of Economics disadvantage students there um they all go to our elementary sites that are title one when I was at Roy gry High School I got Title One sites Title One funds right as principal there but in our district we focus those at the elementary level so just know that we've done that since I've been here um for a long time right um so if it seems a little heavy element Tre that's that's why right because most of the things we've added have been at that Elementary level um so again in doing that exercise of

106looking at class sizes and kind of seeing you know basically just taking this year moving it to next year what can we do um we we got to uh approximately 14 elementary teachers through that process and then about seven secondary teachers through that process um which is 21 and then again if we're going to cut 14 Elementary classes and potentially not have PE with TK classes and do that a different way there's the potential of us cutting a p teacher okay so that's where we got to the 22 FTE in the first category um so the next thing I will say is you're the reason why this is kind of why we're bringing this to you now is we have legal guidelines to notify staff by March 15 so we would love to continue to

107talk about this and see what happens but unfortunately we have to notify staff and and honestly for staff it's good that they have to be noticed that they're not waiting around until June to know if they have a job or not right um but in the state of California we have to know the staff both certificated and classified it used to be easier with classified you only had to give them like three months notice um 45 days but now they're the same as as teachers so new law so everyone is around that March 15 deadline so we're going to present these reductions we're going to hear from the board today we're going to hear from the public um and then we're going to come back to the board at our next meeting ask the board

108for a decision about where where we stand right in particular because we the board will have to pass a resolution which will include the the riff right which is basically um releasing really probationary tenur employees so when I say 14 in 22 class siiz 22 um reductions for this 1.87 million know that um it's not lost on any of us this these are temporary teachers these are our youngest brightest staff that's what this cut is so there will probably there will probably be no no teacher riffs at the next meeting right in terms of that resolution because of the temporary staff that's lost now as retirements happen those types of things we can hire people back and and um as we know so that is something Dr Pia will be working with the board on

109and kind of Enlighten you so again as this process unfolds I want to be completely transparent we understand the impact it has I'm not telling you that no nobody's affected by this no no no 22 individuals are affected by this first reduction right so it's it's tough um and so that again that raises our class size average to about 26 to 26 to1 tk3 and then um the seven reductions at the secondary we kind of have a bubble going through secondary right now in particular at slow high school so they there's a group that was going through lagona um at the time they about 50 students but they're supposed to lose about 70 next year so that that group is now at slow high so slow High actually is not no cuts but we're asking

110them hey can you take these kids put them in your classes right and try not to add staff so that's how we get to the seven basically um through that process so so that's the class- siiz teacher um proposed reduction I'm going to shoot down to summer athletic stiens again I'm going to go through the ones that I I will uh discuss and then u m shash will talk about the others summer athletic sens this is something we worked out with our our uh our coaches and our slca we did a part-time mou for three years right until this next round of negotiating which we're beginning on Thursday with our teachers um but it was basically a way to pay uh summer coaches a little bit extra for doing summer programs a lot of sports

111are year round now um so no this reduction does not apply to this school year 2425 because theou we have goes through this this summer but this would be for the following summer the 25 26 school year right in terms of that that would be something we would budget for so again negotiations will happen we'll talk about it with our Union um but that is one that um we we have brought forward uh the other you're going to see two or site Title One positions um so in looking at Title One funds and M yashida will be working with our mtss team to try to figure you what are the best ways to support all of our schools um in s Louis Coastal in terms of that that mtss support and she'll talk a little

112bit about that um but these reductions the site the site at the title one positions our reductions after talking with principles um these are things that again the sites will still have Title One funds and they will get to decide how they want to use those funds with their staff and their School site councils right so some of these may be brought back but for right now by making this reduction what we're doing basically is kind of opening up their field they can see kind of what the district's going to support and then they can then work with their staff and their site School site counsil hey what do we want to bring back right to supplement um what what uh what the district is is giving us and so you'll see there's some reductions

113that are listed there um things that they have so again if they decide to bring back a counseling Aid or an IA or they'll be able to do that um on the secretarial front we did have again we've we've tried to do some attrition so in all cases we try to save jobs we try to keep people employed as much as we can um so you know when you see like IAS or any anybody on the classified realm all of those positions all the positions we're going to talk about will be on the the Riff paperwork that you will receive um I think at the beginning of our March meeting right so classified we have to list um in those cases so um again with classified as we go through the process we have to

114negotiate with the Union um if if I'm an IA I will be offered a par educator job we have openings right so there will be positions that we have within our organization where we will try to keep people employed um you know it may not be the perfect job the one that they want but we will we will try to work with them to to save people in terms of um as that unfolds right so um so in terms of the secretarial we had a we through attrition we had a secretary leave at slow High because lagona has dropped dramatically last year and next year um we ended up moving the secretary we just added to lagona last year over to slow High to fill that vacancy again reduction already happened um we also had

115a part-time teacher or part-time secretary excuse me at teach elementary school um that was helping with breaks and lunch those types of things there and so that person retired so we didn't we didn't backfill that so we will use other staff within the district to cover those break and lunch periods um for the secretary there we also had three District Department staff um you'll see on the right uh the the negative3 FTE there so um we had a person in payroll retire um we we have a person in HR that's going to retire soon um and we had an ex an executive secretary um at the the superintendent office um she retired and so we didn't backfill that position um and so those are reductions that that have happened um even this year right that

116will count towards this deficit for next year so I'm going to do two more and then I'm going to hand it over to MIM masida um the the one at the top on the back page principles and counselors on special assignment the minus four so as I discussed with covid we added three principles on special assignment at the district office and a a counselor on special assignment at the district office um we are not we are not at a loss that nobody no nobody's going to care about district office staff right um though we do a lot of work and we do important things for the school district uh to make it run effectively um in this case we actually reduce those positions first so those those were reduced two years ago right as we

117went through that the process and um seeing this kind of unfolding in the future but all three of those principles on special assignment are gone no longer at the district office um and then also this this counselor that we had on special assignment is gone now we do have a counselor that's on special assignment now that's Grant funded that came along with the wellness centers um and there's one more year of that grant for that person again we talked about restricted funds so so she will she will be on for one more year and then that position will will go away after that unless there's some other categorical funding that comes up to to pay for that position um and then lastly for me non-personnel reductions again as you can see the the the people

118cuts are are the most painful as we go through they are the most painful right um people's jobs I mean I'm my daughter's a first year teacher I she just got laid off yesterday in lucr I I personally feel the pain right of of that process and speaking with her and talking to her about it um and it's you know it's rough it's rough it's a rough time to be a brand new teacher in California with all these things happening because it's not just us it's throughout the state this is happening um and then lastly again these non-personnel reductions we've we've done a lot of great things we've brought in I mean our our um you know our Equity um and and inclusion and diversity programs and um the work that mimashi has done with

119our staffs this year focusing on the high school level right and making goals for kids and and the secondary level I should say middle school as well um have been fantastic our elementary Athletics um programs leader and me other things so I don't want to Discount these cuts that they're not important and they're not meaningful because they are they're very meaningful right it doesn't mean that we can't do the work without a consultant and so that's what we're going to be tasked with that's what her Department M's department is going to be tasked with continuing this work without the $50,000 contract person to help you it right they're going to have to take it on themselves um hopefully we have a framework some guidelines now because we've done this for a couple of years now

120and we'll continue on that path using what we've learned um but again all of these things that you'll see that are listed there are all they're still painful we have asked our foundation um to try to pick up some of these costs through it we've heard that a lot Public hey why not the foundation what's the foundation doing um so we we have asked them some substantial um inclusion in terms of their budget things to to take on I innovate teachers materials supplies um Elementary Athletics uh some things like that right to help um help the district with some of these cuts and I'm going to hand it over all right so Bard if you'd like to go back to page three um this one I'm going to start second box down on the left

121so as um doc Mr Pinkerton mentioned we have a fantastic I innovate program that we just expanded to our middle schools it's an opportunity to ensure Equitable access for all of our students including socioeconomically disadvantaged students to get Hands-On learning opportunities and career coordinated Pathways with lessons that were written and designed to go along with our language arts curriculum Benchmark Advanced at the elementary level and braided funding with our um prop 28 at the middle school level to include digital media arts instruction and we are very hope F that our foundation partnership will be able to continue to support there are currently two I inovate toses teachers on special assignment that teach lessons write curriculum collaborate with Community groups and support two instructional assistants that also teach in the labs they keep the machines running

122supplies at hand Etc so we are currently asking the foundation to take on the full cost of continuing that program during these times because again our goal is to try and keep our student centered priority programs but reduce things furthest from the classrooms and Main core instructional programming um so we will have to await information from our foundation board and their decisions about the ways in which that that programming will be able to continue in our school district but we remain very hopeful that um that will still continue to be a part of our work here so on the top right hand um is the counselor's reduction again this is not something we take likely or would like to be doing we understand deeply many of our students are in Desperate traumatic situations and need

123supports that can best be provided by a professional in that realm in addition to all the other wonderful caring adults at our schools um however due to the limited amount of funds we have and trying to maintain some kind of access and support continuously across all the TK through 12 levels we're recommending a 5.5 reduction so 4.5 FTE of that would be in the elementary and again that would be returning to the pre-pandemic Staffing levels that we all had you all had before as well as reducing 05 at each of our middle schools for a total of one reduction in the secondary level um this does continue to keep both of our Wellness Center open and operating with the therapists that were hired at the beginning of this school year um hoping to be able

124to continue that as funds become available um through the fee based payers schedule through the California Youth and behavioral initiative um but more information to come on that as that program comes up and online over the course of this school year we are also leaving again the additional we just added a counselor to the SLO High staff so instead of four academic counselors they will be having continue with five academic counselors because of the large size of their school so to keep the student to staff ratios nearly equivalent the next reduction um is related to the academic interventions that we provide our students and I do notice our Student Success Specialists are here in force um and I want to celebrate that they ensure our most vulnerable students uh by overseeing and coordinating all of

125the academic interventions and elel services that those students receive they support and train the academic intervention teachers and which programs to use for which kinds of kids they assess and diagnose students with reading diffic difficulties um and this again this need of students with academic gaps in their learning is clearly not going to go away we hope it's reduced as our test scores um overall generally continue to improve and we have uh new evidence-based research-based um program that we are has many components that can be helpful to struggling students um but we will need to continue to look for either different funding sources than our general education funding to support reading Specialists um reading specialist grants for example are supported in the governor's budget and I reached out to our local um County Office of

126Education to find out if we would be eligible to receive any of those formerly we were not eligible because our socioeconomically disadvantaged numbers did not put us in the eligible category but we are looking into that for instance um so again as we move into to the spring we'll be working closely with um our principal team and our current Student Success Specialists and do our best Innovative job of figuring out how to get all these tasks for these students in needs completed um which will likely include both T classroom teachers learning to give new assessments to students as well as running small groups um and and helping coordinate um elel teachers is one of the areas that currently um we are not looking to reduce at this time and so they'll be taking on some

127of the role and guidance for helping serve our eel students needs that will continue to take more refinement and planning by the entire educational team in St Louis Coastal um we are also reducing teachers on special assignment other classroom teachers who again um have done an amazing fabulous job but we are reducing here as you know at the district office as well and so some of these position are duplicative um in title or role and Elementary Athletics will be hopeful that the foundation will continue to support as we move forward as that's one of their main core programs and then um the principal support we are collaborating with a new uh Statewide funded program to offer principal leadership support moving forward so more information on that summer planning days and grade level planning days again

128our teachers have standard professional development days written into our negotiated teachers contract um but there is no limit to the wealth of opportunities collaborating with Partners on new programs and materials can provide um so we had added previously additional time beyond that contracted time both during the school year when teachers would get pulled out as a grade level team for example or a department and be able to work as a team on curricular issues and design as well as um we added some summer planning days so principales could pull their staff in for a summer planning day as well so those additional PD days um funding would not be um supported at the district level again that is something that could be SES specific in the future if their title $1 or specific site funding

129allowed them to continue that work okay so that's the end of mine on page three if you'll turn it to the back side page four on the top right hand corner I'm going to start with the instructional AIDS um we've added several instructional Aid positions um across our school district and so we are looking to reduce it by about 11 these are the general education instructional AIDS um they are not are special ed par Educators that is not within this reduction because of course those are defined by IEP student specific needs Etc um there will be a PE Aid reduced at if the elementary PE position um gets reduced due to fewer classrooms because they also have an aid and then as I mentioned before the two instructional AIDs that work with the Foundation program

130that will be pending um Foundation decision to choose to continue those two positions or not but due to noticing requirements on contractual issues we have to be able to notice them that they might not have a position moving forward and then I know transitional kindergarten um we've all had an opportunity to talk talk and think a lot about and so I'm going to try and um clarify some of the plan moving forward so here on this document we're Counting about $1,500 in TK savings and that is due to our TK teacher team being creative and collaborative about the schedules that they are um working on developing collaboratively together as well as and the number of students which will be placed into those classrooms um more information we we are still trying to receive feedback from

131all the TK teachers there are currently four different daily schedules under consideration by the team and so as soon as the team builds and has consensus about which schedule will work best for students families and staff we will then be able to publicize that to the community starting in in March and having people sign up for TK that will also give us the opportunity to coordinate and collaborate with our Community Partners about the before school and after school care but essentially um all students who are TK age eligible will be invited to enroll in our TKS on a rolling basis there is not going to be any cut off based on we're full if a particular School site becomes full we could choose to add another classroom at that site or we could offer to

132a family alternate sites that they might want to attend for TK and then switch to their school of residence for kindergarten so that will all be determined at a later rate but to be clear we are going to be enrolling all four-year-olds at whatever time they show up at our front doors to get them into a TK program and we will be offering all day long supervision and care and education for the children in addition to our amazing food program so again I want to make sure that um you know this is to contain the costs that the future costs that TK could have ballooned into um It's really because we heard loud and clear that our community at large does not have enough child care or preschool spots for four-year-olds to take the three

133or 400 children that we would not be serving because they have shuttered their doors in the intervening years where we've been providing uh gold stand TK program and we will continue to try and pursue um additional funding for our TK programs and we are in consultation currently with caps slow as well as um State preschool programs like headart to find alternative um funding sources to continue the program moving forward so to close in terms of information um again this the reductions we talked about tonight um get to us about 5.9 million you know approximately um not 6.3 5.9 um again when we look at a slight a slight budget deficit moving forward you know with 136 million dollars budget yeah 400,000 okay like we can handle that right as we go through um but in

134terms of just six million is it it would eat up our revenues right so um so I'm going to put my budget hat on now as your CBO right as your assistant super for business services and we have to make reductions we we have to cure this structural deficit um the board's going to get to talk to us about these of course right but I we we need to do this work and this is not putting it off a year this is not two years let's let's see if we get funding no we we have to get our our our bank balanced right um and so that's why we're we're disc ing this tonight um it it's hard that we have to do this quickly right during February I you'll see the timeline there what

135we've kind of been through in terms of trying to let people know and talk about it um again the the bottom part is just to show for the public that we've we the board discusses this in your meetings all the time this is nothing new we've had our 10-year budget that's shown this budget deficit for for all of these years right that we talked about and you can go right online they're all on video you can see all the information all we've all talked about it right um we have held off to to to now right we could have done this last year we could have done it the year before um but but I mean you heard you heard people you've had people come to the board meetings to talk about the needs of

136kids the needs of teachers our staff we tried to hold we tried to keep everything um as as long as we could and unfortunately we're at a point now where we we can't we can't anymore we just can't physically do it um that said I think we've we've really tried to listen to everybody um as missas said you know the well in the centers are the things we try to keep in place um but some things have been you know are for reduction that are that are painful um and so that is again the general information how we got to uh the reductions that that are here before you um and I look forward to being able to answer your question after the public is able to give you some uh some of their own

137insights okay thank you um before I open the public comment the the board has been in session we have been in session since 4:30 and I believe that we need a short break to use the restroom so uh it's 8:01 come back at 810 thank okay a house isn't going to stand without our loadbearing walls if you walk on any Elementary campus our counselors are always there they're always visible and not because they're required to do supervision which they are that's a whole different discussion but they are there with our kids at lunch where else are they they're at Athletics Mason Rodriguez out there coaching kids um Jasmine aldinos coaching kids with Elementary Athletics uh oh my gosh I lost his name the one from Mor Bay U Delmar Elementary Mr n Keenan thank you

138he's out there coaching kids so our counselors are coaching they're working and where else can you find our counselors um oh yeah the food bank some of our families are scared to go to the food bank because of what's going on in the federal level who goes and gets food for them our elementary counselors It's sad to see that they they may be cut and so what I'm asking I understand you have to make Cuts is that you honor your guiding principles invite them into the room and see if we can come up with some Creative Solutions to help our save Elementary counseling much like you guys did with TK thank you good evening board members my name is Jennifer danowitz I'm a parent of a TK student at the wonderful Hawthorne Elementary School and

139a teacher in a neighboring District tonight I speak personally and professionally when I urge you to consider another course of action I sincerely appreciate the commitment to preserving the Integrity of the TK program and now I urge you to please reject the district's proposed budget cuts in favor of a path that puts students interests first the district Ides itself on the principles of all means all collaboration and civil discourse a culture of care and safety high expectations continuous Improvement and respected Integrity the district's plan is just opposed with the district's guiding principles and our budget and practices need to reflect our principles the district's plan asks you to accept recommendations to cut nearly 40 teacher Anda jobs this will raise class sizes cut Support Services to counseling and academically struggling students and reduce the support

140for our Els Learners who have made tremendous gains as you can see on the California dashboard and who right now need our support and are rallying behind them more than ever the district has laid out a clear proposal in their handout it outlines that class size increase is still under contract caps and the five remaining counselors would support students schools with the greatest need but the students who need more are going to be left behind students who needed AIDS in the classroom are going to be left behind most students will be okay but after all all means most in the student and Community pathway you can use that 14 million additional Reserve that according to your 2024 2025 budget document is specifically earmarked for times of economic uncertainty due to the district's basic Aid status

141and reliance on pg& taxes Dr Prader made it very clear that these are specific reasons we're facing this structural deficit and Mr Pinkerton mentioned the uncertainty with the fires and the current political status we have a lot of uncertainty if you choose to use the reserve fund for its intended purpose now and support the continuation of these programs the children of St Louis Coastal School District are bought another year of the highquality supportive and vital education systems that they in the community have grown accustomed to these are the programs that are keeping our district and our students safe and having those high expectations while we as a community and a board and the staff work together with civil discourse and integrity for the Integrity of our students preserving the student facing jobs is about $4

142million there is still a substantial amount left in that deficit or in that reserve for you to work with please use your taxpayer pay your money your voters money to support our students and not make these Cuts yet thank you Hala Townson to be followed by um Mason Rodriguez and Elizabeth a name I can't decipher so excuse me for that but um Kayla Townson good evening and happy national school counselor week my name is Kayla Townsen and I'm the counselor at Bishops Peak Elementary and I'm joined tonight in person and on Zoom by our entire amazing counselor Elementary team there are currently 10 of us counselors that provide direct social emotional Behavior interventions for the almost 4,000 elementary students of this district and under the current budget proposal our team would be cut in half

143next year a few weeks ago I spoke here about the importance of our role and today I would like to address a major concern that I have with the point that was made in the plan for Elementary counselors next year the proposal notes quote Elementary counselors will be distributed to schools based on need and size of school and quote I have three things I would like the board to consider with this statement one we are not an asset that can just just be distributed like paper pencils or buses we are integrated members of our school communities and the relationships that we have fought to Foster are an essential component to doing our job successfully to indicate that we can just be dispatched to any school and show up in fix a problem is naive and

144unreflective of the strong roots of trust with the kids and families that we need in order to do our jobs number two trauma and adverse childhood experiences are some of the few things that are not correlated directly with socioeconomic status race or gender traumas are experienced amongst children and families of all backgrounds to say that counselors will be distributed to schools based on need and size ignores the fact that we have large populations of students who have been through extreme traumas at every single one of our school sites that we are responsible for supporting regardless of them being Title One or not our student needs are not going down I do not know a single one of our counselor team who end any day saying that they were able to see every single kid that

145needed to be seen that day we are running we are multitasking we are not caring for ourselves all because that is how drastic the needs are on our campus lastly along to that point if we are truly to distribute counselors to schools based on need and size we would need to hire at least six more Elementary counselors in addition to our current 9.5 this is based around our national board recommendation of a ratio of 1 to 150 which allows counselors to do our jobs to Fidelity if we are reduced to five counselors there will be needs unmet and I know this be to be true because there are already needs unmet at our sites it is not possible to spread ourselves thin enough even when we sacrifice our own well-being to try to meet the

146needs of our students this is not not what is best for our students or staff of the elementary counseling team that I started with three years ago many have moved on to higher paying jobs with more manageable case loads you will continue to lose amazing qualified dedicated professionals if you do not act to support your staff and correct the reasons for our poor retention rates under the current proposal you will simply speed it up thank you for your time and I'm happy to host any of you at Bishop's Peak if you'd like to see why reducing my time there in half would be detrimental thank you Nathan and I apologize for mispronouncing names it's just hi my name is Mason Rodriguez uh I have many titles conflict mediator individual and group interventionist social emotional educator

147School Senate liaison teacher in charge resource referral special crisis responder trusted adult suicide risk assessor student safety plan collaborator threat assessment conductor culture of care implementer and most recently coach if you couldn't tell uh my actual official title is elementary school counselor uh and the reason I'm here today is I'm asking you guys to please reconsider uh the recommended cuts and reductions to the elementary counseling program elementary school counselors provide crucial support to our most at risk students Comfort grieving children struggling to cope with the loss of loved ones teach positive coping skills to hundreds of students through classroom lessons address increasingly troubling behaviors all while helping to implement a culture of Care at our sites for all today I spent about eight hours supporting students parents support staff teachers our administrator and my fellow

148counselors as reflected on the possibility of our program being cut and reduced I'm going back tomorrow to do a all again with a smile on my face because there are kids who need me to do that and be there for them next year Elementary School students principles and teaching staff will be unequivocally affected by these budget cuts and it's reasonable to assume our principles and staff will be drastically overwhelmed and expected to absorb all these responsibilities please do not add to this by removing full-time school counselors from students during their most foundational years for all for a lot of these students we are the only Advocate and support that they will receive thank you for your time and Happy National School counseling week Elizabeth that looks like it starts with an A oh okay thank

149you uh then next we have it looks like Lucy Stone oh sorry and then Emily Goodman and Sarah McGrath who I think SP be okay good evening superintendant board members parents and community members my name is Luchia Stone and I'm a concerned parent and a slow local from elementary to cowply in this District these past two weeks we've all become really familiar with each other um in you may recall I was the parent holding the handwritten sign that identified a legislative pass forward with P gen uh amending s SP 846 using the reserves in these times of need and what they're identified for and still to consider Al loone with the endowment of the St Louis Education Foundation um SB 1090 was put into law to support the district and its core programs I'm not

150saying to remove those programs but to at least explore this idea which it has not to my knowledge so far and while I applaud you keeping TK and identifying and valuing its role in child development I am a little concerned with how the new version will play out and I know that it's still in motion but above all it does need to be fair and Equitable as you know and as parents we will make sure it's fair and Equitable and Dr Prader well you may consider yourself the Tom Brady of basic Aid Statewide advocacy group then we are your team so please let's get ourselves a Super Bowl ring the district's move to cut Tay sent a message to the state and I feel like it was really shortsighted as we know but now we

151are all involved the state is aware PG is aware the community is aware and we're ready to take action and to the board as you all know it is your responsibility of what happens in these next moments this is probably the most critical time in history or in your time of Public Service where it will matter whether what's going on federally or here in our own backyard and I just want you to remember that as you guys move forward I've heard a lot about the school counselors and they are dealing a lot are dealing with a lot every day uh CPS sex trafficking and now ice raids these are important times to maintain mental health as a society um I mean who in the room has not had their mental health affected these last few

152weeks um I spent my Friday worrying about the well-being of my husband as AG high was on lockdown with a gun standoff all students were evacuated including medically fragile special education students which were led by my husband these students will need counseling the staff will need counseling the family members will need counseling um these are not times to take away counseling and to really explore all of our options and maybe take a little more time and I understand that we're running out of time and while this is happening in a neighboring District this is all real life for us and emergency preparedness also needs to be front and center that is my background that is an LA one last line I agree with other parents we need a community advisory committee and given I've already

153written your FAQs and pges which were approved thank you let me be your first member of an advisory committee thank you and let's be part teammates for the next 14 years go Tigers thank you um Emily Goodman then Sarah McGrath then Jen's Al okay good evening my name is Emily Goodman I know many of you from our community maybe I went to school with your children maybe my mother taught your children um and now I have for children of my own three who attend mon [Music] Grove and um a three-year-old Who currently attends the mar Bay parent participation program I know this is a very difficult time and I thank you for hearing public comment and being available at Community for forums and to uh Miss yashida for having a one-off meeting with me thank

154you it is exactly this open dialogue that will lead to the best possible solution in light of our current situation and for the record I think a coordin Citizens budget council is a fantastic idea in light of our changing revenue streams our cooperation with the Boe and creating legislative action is absolutely in order for our district to get the proper funding back from pg& and I would argue even before they're operating again I'm happy to see that a resolution has been found to keep our beloved TK um however that I have other serious concerns with the proposed cut specifically regarding the heavy cuts to Personnel to our people so to the poor please do not accept this recommendation as is I think there are some creative Funding Solutions to be found with additional problem solving

155I know that my suggestions are only partial Solutions and may not be plausible but I feel to compelled to at least try and I hope for the people here and on Zoom they are inspired to do the same thing bringing your unique perspective knowledge and life experiences to the table with that here are my thoughts for your consideration some of which I'm happy to have already heard tonight I understand that grants cannot be included in the budget but wouldn't it be possible to reduce non-personnel expenses and work work with organizations like the San Louis Coastal Education Foundation to step in with funds for example can't you cut book some PL supplies and let them come in with funding after saving jobs I'm happy to see that you're already working with the Education Foundation it shows

156there's healthy collaboration but this is a huge pot of money that was funded from PG's mitigation settlement and based on their 2023 tax filing it appears they have much more funding to distribute now yes this is an endowment fund but anything over the endowment requirement needs to be distributed we are in our rainy day moment now we do not need to save funds for rain any day is there an option for the foundation to hold a non-interest bearing promisory note to pay back once our unitary tax is established to the higher amount I understand we don't want to exacerbate our deficit with liabilities but considering there is only one current liability on our balance sheet for which I as an employee benefit that cannot be repaid an additional liability could be in order thank you

157Sarah mcra okay um then we have Jen's omley did I mispronounce your name you did great thank you and thank you for all of the the teachers and staff and counselors and PE teachers in attendance who uh devote their lives to each of our individual children and thank you to the board and administration for listening and taking action recently it takes a village and the thought of cutting TK awakened the villagers and I hope that will benefit everyone uh and it wasn't just parents with their apps and group text it was also the older siblings of the next generation of teers first and second graders who are horrified that their little brother or sister who they spend most of their time arguing with wouldn't get the same opportunity that they did so thank you uh

158and also thank you on behalf of my students at calpol um I have the privilege of teaching the most wonderful students in the world Child Development students liberal studies students future teachers who get a chance to spend time in our worldclass gold standard TK uh classrooms my sense is that your job is to keep one eye on the year to come and one eye on the decades to come we don't want to lose anyone in our village so please keep the villagers informed involved and mobilized and I look forward to seeing the Creative Solutions that come out of Partnerships with Community organizations and the fact that in our village we happen to have a worldclass university with students who are always looking for new ways to serve who have um a lot to give the

159students and supporting the teachers and counselors and others who are working with the the students okay so again let's stay mobilized as a a village and my request to the board would be spend as much as we can to keep as much as we can as we look for more thank you again to each of you for your time appreciate it you is there anyone else in the room wishes to address this if not I'll go to zoom Miss Dawson I'm able to see the rais hands um I'm just going to go through them that's yeah okay perfect so um I have Jordan bonnaville all right hello hi my name is Jordan bonnaville and I am a seconde temper orary Elementary School teacher at CL Smith a title one school I am extremely concerned not

160only for myself as a temporary teacher but my fellow teachers counselors intervention teachers students and everyone else at my school who I now consider family this year I'm a fourth grade teacher with 30 students and the year prior I was a third and fourth grade combination teacher having both of these experiences I can assure you combination classes nor high class sizes are beneficial for students in their success yet with these proposed budget cuts that's what teachers and students are going to have to endure I urge you to question why the class size reductions made up 3% of the covid budget yet cutting teachers in raising class sizes make up 30% of the proposed budget cuts in my current position 40% of my students leave my room for intervention supports that is nearly half of my

16130 students not only will these proposed Cuts get rid of all of these supports but the need will not go away it will only place more of the responsibility on the teachers and we all know burnt out teachers do not promote Student Success I welcome you into my classroom to see why these supports and small class sizes are so vital and necessary for all parties involved especially for students in Title One schools and I'm hoping that in this consideration Title One schools are especially thought about um so I thank you for your time I know this is not an easy decision but I hope all of these things are considered thank you thank you right next I next the next hand is Annie F who uh wrote in but I'm going to presume you want

162to address the board via Zoom rather than having your comment read yes please possible sure um okay good evening board members my name is Annie ginu and I'm speaking tonight not just as a concerned parent but also as someone with extensive experi experience in state and local government I worked for the California legislature and with local government entities and I'm now so grateful to be a political science professor at kpali I'm AC I'm acutely a familiar with the complexities and urgencies of these issues particularly when it comes to securing stable funding for public services passing Statewide legislation for a district specific bill is not easy it requires proactive leadership strong advocacy and political will unfortunately I'm not seeing that level of urgency from this board regarding our District's financial future my C my personal concern

163is rooted in both professional expertise and lived experience my 5-year-old daughter attends s shimer Elementary School due to her summer birthday she was not able to enroll in TK but luckily she's doing fantastic in kindergarten this year um but now my three-year-old approaches school age and my family is hopeful that she will have access to Universal TK next year however the looming budget deficit raises real concerns about the sustainability of this program and the broader implications for our district there's a clear and untapped opportunity to help mitigate these Financial risks renegotiating the unitary tax from PG and Diablo Canyon I personally worked on California Senate Bill 968 and Senate Bill 1090 which provided the temporary transition atory funding but now that dblo Canon is increasingly likely to remain operational why has there not been any

164movement from this board to work with our State Legislative Partners to renegotiate this agreement and to refine the CPU agreement and um statute this process takes time and every delay puts our district and programs like TK at a greater risk other communities have successfully secured District specific fiscal agreements yet our board appears to be sitting idle beyond the financial concerns I also want to highlight the barriers to public participation and transparency parents should not have to fight for access to critical decisions about the future of their children's education while I appreciate the recent improvements in transparency it should not take public outcry to ensure that families have a seat at the table I urge this board to act immediately especially considering the deadline to introduce legislation is in two weeks by engaging with our legislative

165Representatives prioritizing renegotiating the unitary tax and commit to transparency and accessibility for All Families the financial stability of our district the future of universal TK along with the many other staff members Educators and amazing educational programs our students enjoy and the trust between this board and public all depend on it thank you so much for your time and attention to this important matter next next is Crystal basinet uh yes hello um my name is Crystal baset I teach second grade at CL Smith in San Louis abiso um I've been with the district for five years now um came in just after the pandemic and um I just like to say along with everyone else um I do not envy the decision the board has to make um regarding these budget cuts their heavy decisions um

166I just wanted to have a show of support for our classroom elementary teachers um many of you sitting on that board were inspiration to me as I was going through a student teacher program and you know firsthand the impact class size can have on students and not just students but also the teachers teaching those students um at the beginning of this year my class started at 30 students I am now at 29 and I frantically Spent My Summer not only moving my classroom but figuring out how to make my room developmentally appropriate for 37y olds learning a brand new curriculum that I was learning and making it an effective classroom environment for them this is a daily task that teachers do every single day and I am honored along with my colleagues like Jordan and

167other colleagues at my school that do this flawlessly every single day advocating for their students the other thing that we saw at the beginning of the school year where I had 15 of my 30 students that were significantly below grade level in reading and math and through our support program at school through our uh multi our mtss tosa who is amazing we were able to get the support needed for us in the classroom and I've gone from 15 students significantly below to six within one trimester that is an amazing immediate result just this school year of these systems that we've built as a district as a res as a as a response to the pandemic and it was just an incredible response and to have it now just taken away and to say well classroom

168teachers you have to do more with less doesn't seem like a really Equitable or um Fair solution for anybody and um I just wanted to kind of be the voice for that for those students and for those teachers who are here late at night fighting for our students trying to think of innovative ways to meet all of the needs because there's no worse feeling than knowing a student needs you and knowing you just can't get to them so thank you so much for your consideration appreciate apprciate it Ashley her hello I'm Ashley Hern school counselor at losos Middle School who attended elementary middle and high school here in slow Coastal I'm worried I'll go over the three minutes so I apologize in advance for how quickly I'm going to go through this statement as someone

169on the front lines of this work I cannot emphasize enough the impact that a loss of school counselors would create there is a ripple effect to reducing mental health professionals that goes beyond our offices for some students the school counselor is the only person they share concerning issues with the only person that becomes aware of neglect or abuse inside of a home and the only person to intervene when a student is considering Dying by Suicide as a listener please take a moment to reflect on how that last statement sits with you my side of 500 students has already seen five hospitalizations for mental health crises and potentials for suicide mind you those are only the hospitalizations there have not been there have been numerous safety plans created for self-harming actions in addition to those hospitalizations

170the statistics behind student mental health are staggering according to a report by the World Health Organization published in October of last year quote globally it is estimated that one in seven 10 to 19 yearolds experience mental health conditions yet these remain largely unrecognized and untreated end quote it only takes a brief calculation to show how many of our own students that could potentially be and let us not ignore the fact that this is a global stat and the State of Affairs in our nation might very well be spiking that statistic here at home not only do school counselors discover these mental health needs most frequent ly but when other Educators administrators included discover these needs who do they reach out to to take the next steps school counselors in a statement I wrote for the

171community Forum but didn't get a chance to read I plan to clarify to non school counselors what the job actually entails because I think there is some confusion in one blurb I was able to Rattle off 40 different activities that a counselor could be found doing each week which barely scratched the surface our roles change at break neck speeds from moment to moment counseling a student who experiences daily psychological abuse could transition quickly into a student whose parent is undergoing intensive cancer treatment only to wrap up with them and be pulled into a suicide risk assessment so if a counselor isn't there please tell me where does all of that weight go before closing I would also like to respectfully point out some language that has been hurtful to us employees on the receiving end

172of the budget information disseminations it's been stated that the covid onetime funds were needed and that's why they were used the word needed past tense has been repeated over and over but I must emphasize that when it comes to mental health the need is now additionally while a05 FTE cut to middle school counselors would leave us quote with more counseling than they had prior to the pandemic I urge you to note that student mental health needs have multiplied since then I know that tough decisions must be made and I am not naive to the magnitude of this situation as a matter of fact my empathetic counselor heartt sees the human in you and acknowledges your inner turmoil each and every one of you but I have to be frank when I say that losing counselors

173could harm children in irreparable ways they are tired and hurting and and they cannot pass classes get good standardized scores or carry our District's Legacy beyond our sites if they are not mentally and emotionally cared for and we are the caretakers happy National School counseling week especially to my brothers and sisters and thank you for your time Katie bravante and that's the last speaker shown on Zoom if anyone else wishes to speak after her please use the raise your hand I con um good evening um Board of Trustees and community members and Dr Prader um and teaching staff and support staff um here this evening um I have been a music teacher for this district for I think this is my 15th year I've also worked in the atascar Unified School District in the Pas

174RS um School District as a music teacher I am no stranger to budget cut because we are usually the first to go um I lost my job in Paso due to budget cuts and um only because I was secondary teacher um and tasad was able to keep my job through even though I was pink slipped and this District used to routinely pink slip music teachers um so they didn't have to tenure us um so um I am not a stranger to this process I understand you have a very very difficult um job to do but um it's really hard to come to these meetings and speak up and then um time and time again even though we have public outcry we have hours of well um articulated comments from the community from teachers from support

175members from parents from students about um why a certain cut shouldn't be made um the the board typically almost always unanimously um um accepts every line item every single cut and what I am urging you to do this evening and over the next two weeks before you um come to your decision is to not do that don't unilaterally accept every single budget cut um like other speakers have said um there's a reason why you keep that rainy day reserve and it's not raining right now it is pouring um the students I am I'm asking for you to reconsider cutting the counselors every single counselor um I work currently at lososa middle school and Moray high school and I know that um personally Ashley herni and hos vialta are incredible stewards of our students um well-being

176and if you make those cuts it's it affects every single student um it's hundreds of kids right as opposed to I know classroom size well I was in charge of 50 first graders all at once because they thought that was okay our district thought that was okay for music teachers to teach 50 all at once I understand um class class size um makes a difference but cutting counselors will make a much much much larger impact please Rec consider please do not accept this cut do not cut the cancer thank you Callie Walter hi my name is Callie Walter um I have a daughter that's eligible for TK next year um but I was surprised to find out she was eligible for TK I didn't realize that it was an open door to TK um and

177I am was surprised to find that that was the new rule um and I don't think that that should be the rule I think that TK was never intended to be a universal four to four-year-olds um I think it was meant for children that weren't quite ready to start kindergarten and I think that we should reconsider bringing it back to the September to December birthday window um I'm also a counseling intern at our district um and I see the work that counselors do every day I get to do that work with them and um we that I I leave in tears um it's amazing work and I'm really honored to watch it I'm really honored to learn from them and um you honor your your District honors itself on um learning and oh gosh sorry

178I'm losing myself in my notes um you write that um gosh sorry where am I um oh oh oh oh sorry I got nervous um um sorry I I lost myself um but I I just think you really you really need to look somewhere else your counselors are too important um they're doing the work that you need done at your schools thank you Angela AA hi I wasn't expecting to speak tonight um I'm a teacher at Los OS middle school and um both of my own children graduated from moral Bay High School and I just have to stress the importance of um mental health like Ashley was mentioning earlier I totally agree with what she is saying our children um needs so much help they are exposed to so much um I'm thinking middle school

179middle schoolers seeing what they see on um their phones trying to figure out how to deal with with that and um we need our we need our M um our counselors also I wanted to mention about the public forums I was grateful to be able to talk at that um and to hear that information we as a staff really only had a half an hour to speak I went to the Morrow Bay Forum and it was from 4:30 to 5:30 and we heard information from the district office from 4:30 to 5: and then we have as staff members had a half an hour to express our concerns or ask our questions so please um some people might not have had a chance to um Express themselves so please make sure you look at the comments

180that we're taken when we had a chance to put things down on the um I don't how they gathered the information I forget what exactly what it was called but anyway just I wanted to make sure that that was clear thank you thank you that's those are all the speakers we have Mrs Roger okay thank you um Mr Pinkerton were you oh you're we're here we're here to answer your questions okay so then we have closed public comment we'll bring it back to the board um who would like to begin thank you and thank you to everyone who's here tonight and who has spoken tonight at our last meeting at our many Community forums um I have a few questions but if I only allowed one at a time I can appreciate that I will

181wait for my turn um I I appreciate that teachers and parents and community members um and our hardworking staff uh you know came together to collaborate to minimize the impacts to our beloved TK program um I want to reiterate the importance of this board and this District simultaneously continuing to work collaboratively with our elected leaders um in Sacramento and other similarly situ ated school districts basic Aid districts across the state to continue advocacy for State funding for the long-term viability of this program I'm also mindful that TK was never going to be the only program potentially impacted by these difficult but necessary Cuts so I want to make sure that we're not insulating the TK program which is set to serve maybe 400 students next year um without also insulating programs that serve some of

182our most vulnerable uh students that comprise the other 7,000 students that we serve um this board's number one priority is to close the achievement Gap not make it bigger and I also appreciate the guiding principle on this budget document that says you know we are Guided by the principle of maximizing the impact of programs that reach the greatest number of students in creative and innovative ways so can you just explain to me and and to to the audience um members of the public how these proposed Cuts what you are recommending here today were designed to minimize impacts to our English language Learners our foster home with youth our s students our students with disabilities and our newcomers so can you can you point to some of the things that that you've done the the decisions

183that you've made to minimize impacts to those vulnerable student groups some of the dis decisions we're making here haven't um we what I'm trying to say is some of the work through the lcap that's going to be coming up later on this springtime in addition to individual School sites ability to use their Title One funding to meet the needs of those specific groups those plans will be developed later on once the scope of these reductions in programming is known those plans and dollars should then under local control be able to support exactly those student subgroups that you mentioned there is no way to remove 40 or 50 adults from our school buildings that serve hundreds of kids a day and think that there won't be any impact of their absence so with each of these

184reductions what we're trying to do is the uncomfortable business of taking a little bit here and a little bit there and a little bit here and being able to maintain services and supports to our highest needs students in that particular area whether it be social emotional learning or academic learning and as I stated before that's going to require us to lean on different members or roles in our organizations and school sites to learn and do things a little bit differently than they're doing now so that the students as best we can as school teams continue to get the services um that they require to thrive and grow it will also rely on us reaching out to our parents and families and the village I love that comment I don't know if but we we obviously

185have activated a village and we are going to need our village with us in our classrooms um as we always have but I feel like it is um more pressingly evident that um our students need us now more than ever and our staff is going to need us now more than ever so as we've made these reductions um it's been described as you know using a scalpel not a hacksaw and trying to make very delicate targeted cuts that we can um work collaboratively with staff to figure out how to fill those holes so again most of the things we talked about too to kind of address the same question are the things we're reducing what we didn't talk a lot about is what we're keeping right in place right so all the AIT positions um

186those are academic intervention teachers uh El teachers Ela it's um you know just last year we added full-time I a to kindergarten classes that was just last year so we're talking about reducing those to a halftime but still maintaining half a halftime Aid at each of those in each of our our kindergarten classes across the district so you know there's a lot of those things that were saved again we're focused on the things that we're talking about reducing um but trying to keep again those mtss supports for staff supports for teachers that's what I wanted to know is what you know it could have been wor it could be worse right and and there's been some real thought and I know a lot of hardworking people um to try and do the best under a

187really difficult circumstance i' I'd also like to add we didn't talk about our mention yet specifically that um we are looking at ways to um provide services but through through cost cutting measures so for example of course there is no replacement for having a well-trained element counselor at your side on call any moment I don't mean to suggest any tella Health community- based program would be equivalent till that that it's not but we do have now um 247 family multilingual T virtual counseling Health supports that are that are coming online and getting off the ground that more people can access similarly we can um return to using contracted employees and services to provide some of the things that we are currently doing with our own people we also kept all of our school psychologists many

188of those who are um doing all of our Mental Health Services that that have been I mean that's a recent ad where we've taken that on and added school pych so um those those Mental Health Counselors are still in place with the plan even with the reductions um and those are serving all of our mental health needs with through IEPs um those types of things as well so again a lot there's still a lot of things in place you know when we talked about adding 173 we're talking about I can't remember you know somebody added up the number well 50 so um I mean it's still we're still maintaining 120 more people than we had so it's not like we're cutting back to pre-co levels no we're we still have way more support than we

189had in the past um and and there's a need as someone who grew up in a mental health family um my dad's an mft mftc and um uh so as my sister uh so I kind of feel like through osmosis that's just part of who who I am so I feel very strongly about maintaining Services as much as we can for students especially at this time we know that academic Su success is intricately you know related to emotional well-being um so I do want to make sure that we get the word out to our families um starting now that these services like you said they they can't replicate an in-person counseling session but 24hour a day counseling services and my understanding is that that those services are going to be expanded and they students will

190qualify for them so I want to make sure that that's um clear to our families um and and you've addressed some of the other questions that I was going to have so I will lastly just um say that we know that these proposed Cuts aren't going to be the end of the budget crisis right we're still going to have to look next year um and so I'm personally committed um to doing what everything that I can do to Advocate on um with the Diablo Canyon situation um and I just want it to be clear that my understanding is that advocacy has been going on for a while and will continue um there's a timing issue there's I involved and so um just tell me where to be Dr Prader and I will be there um

191so I just want to be clear though so that people are on notice now what what do we potentially looking at for next year and you don't need to you know nothing's planned but you know we we the the things that we've already talked to you about we're not cutting aits we're not cutting eel teachers we're not cutting transportation we're not cutting buildings grounds custodial we're not cutting everything on that list of not cut is going to be reconsidered next school year yeah and so we will continue advocating in the meantime yeah for that state funding thank you and again we're in kind of a weird spot right so we again the board's goingon to approve a budget in June and you won't even know for sure what your revenues will for sure be until

192November that's just part of being a basic Aid School District right so again we we try not to you know in my try not to ask for too much for the board to reduce too much right at this point enough to get us through next year again we couldn't even come up with curing the deficit for next year based on these reductions right because of what you heard tonight um so it we'll you know kind of have to each stage we'll see how it goes May Revis will be the next point on the information point for us to know you know what's going to happen in state budget thank you I'm I'm just going to call it the way I saw it I saw Mr Banfield then I saw Mr Clawson then I saw Mr

193younger then I saw Mrs Sheffer Mr oh and then and now I see uh Mr Buckman so where Mr Banfield were you next I don't please I'll speak you know me I'll always look at things in kind of a simple way Dr Prader tonight and folks I most of the comments that um I received had to do with an urgency regarding counseling I will tell you this that not just in our district but in general counseling will become even more and more important as we go on it's it's the times that we live in and I don't know I just I feel so much for what people are saying parents and teachers Alik if there's any which way that's all I'm asking thank you thank you I think Mr Clawson yeah okay um first of

194all I appreciated the the parent that suggested that we should be angry and that we're not angry and uh I I am angry and I'm I'm angry for a couple reasons I think cutting cutting counseling uh is extremely upsetting but um I'd like to talk about a possible solution and I I'd like to dig in on on really why I'm upset is that I think a solution exists in the community and I want to start by thanking thanking the new times for for covering our meeting last time and they started discussion I mean in that discussion they pointed out that the depreciation of the nuclear plant um was done in a way that there's no tax basis anymore uh that nuclear plant is is still running and I think it's it's not part of a

195solution to go get the unitary tax I think that is the right effort to do but I think that will take years and I think we need a solution now and um I I really found that article interesting because it talked about the fact that we lost $10 million of funding and and PG responded and their response was the legislature says we don't have to pay that and I think really the point is it's not about whether they have to pay that it's about whether they should pay that and and I would put forth to the community here that we need to work together because there is a social and moral contract that has existed for decades between Diablo Canyon and the school district and if you look over the past decades $10 million is

196the low low water mark of the funding that we received from Diablo Canyon and I I was in Santa Barbara at the reach Economic Council last week and PG presented and they very proudly shared that they're at 94% capacity and that plant is cranking and it's going to be cranking through 2030 and and and I think that's fabulous I hope that the plan is extended for another 20 years I think it's I think it's the backbone of California's energy ecosystem and it's a jewel of our community so so I like it but I think it has a community responsibility to support us and I think there's a very specific solution that I'd like to propose that is we'll go after legislative change but in the near term I would propose to pg& contribute to us

197at the level you always have as long as you're open we have a foundation you can donate to our foundation if you commit before February 18th when we have to vote on this that you will donate the minimum of $10 million you've given us for decades I I commit that I will vote against any cuts and so and we're going to hear that's not possible it is possible they can do this and next year we're getting $4 million of funding from pg& if stay at that 10 level that means six more what's the size of your cut that you just presented 58 it takes it off the table furthermore $10 million a year after takes these cuts off the table and and it puts us in a situation where we can pursue unitary tax if

198we get it this donation should go down by however much we get but I think it is wrong for us to get no funding and PG need to be going at full capacity at higher energy rates than ever and there's a very immediate solution and it's for this group here to articulate to pg& and diabo Canyon that we are a community we we we educate the children of their employees we are in a partnership with them and they're not pulling their part of the partnership and because of that we are firing counselors and student support services and teachers and we don't have to so so in short pg& before February 18th just make a very very basic commitment that you will provide this district with the $10 million that you've given us for decades in

199one form or another and if you do that all our counselors everyone in this room I think is is saved and um I I don't think I'm being dramatic I think this is really simple I I think the community can solve this and I would like them to and and I hope they do the right thing Mr stronger I like your I like your idea Brian and your suggestion um I I hope that that that I was going to use the word benevolence but but that that's probably not the correct word to use to think about the relationship between pg& and the what they owe are not only and and I'm an advocate for our schools but not only our schools but our community as well because our our cities and our County as well

200are suffering from the loss of those taxes and I understand that um munificence maybe something like that right uh to the to the person that suggested that we weren't working to try to get a solution to that I I have to I have to disagree with that we have been working with it um I would also point out and something I've been working on for probably 20 years is the fact that education in California is just flat out underfunded uh we we know that props 98 is a floor not a ceiling although um certainly because we're a basic aade School District it's a little bit more complicated than that but but but even that our state effort toward education is is lacking and has been lacking for years probably since Proposition 13 um that's my

201soapbox I I have a question for both of you though a couple of things and then then I probably will have other questions Ryan people talk about are 10% reserved uh we received a letter from Dr brussa the other day uh regarding the the approval of our budget he claim he stated that we had about at this point about a 4% Reserve sitting in our in our coffers is that true so again there's two things there's and I explained this I think at the last board the last board meeting I want to make be very clear yeah so there's there's sax right which is the state software that we we use for budgeting and the problem with Sachs is it shows everything that you have in revenues you have to say as expens expenditures So

202based on that yeah we're at the 4.6 if we make these reductions I think it rises to nine after two years again that's the sax form that's why we created the 10-year budget production which shows kind of where we actually are right because otherwise people are going to see that and then they're going to see what falls the bottom line and go oh you're lying you know what are you talking about you have more than 4% over the course of the year um so again that's the 10year budget kind of shows where we think the budget's going to end at the end of the year so again it's that it's it's kind of a funky system that that's unfolded but it's it's because we have to use that tax form and that's the information that

203we turn to the to the county but reality is we don't spend every single thing that we budget for there's always things that we we don't do over the course of the year right and those dollars fall to the bottom line we have multi-year grants in our budget right now that Sachs will show that you know hey we have to put in you got it you expend it at all but in reality no it's we're going to expend it over a few years so so that's why it's a little bit different but yes um in terms of the for the county it's been a long time since you got a letter that showed that we were under 10% right even using that sax information um and that's that's kind of why I'm pushing you know

204for us to cure the structural deficit and if we can cure it in other ways where are we what's that in actuality where are we the 10 year budget I would I would pull up the 10 year budget give me a percentage I I don't know 14 well I'll I can go back to my desk and look at the are we in excess of 10% or do we have 10% we well yes thank you yes at this point we will be at the end of this year yes okay but if we don't make the reductions we won not be in 25 26 we will not be we will not be at 10% okay and I in the you have also talked about at what point we fall below 3% which it puts us in state

205receivership which is something that that we've see in other school districts skirt here in s loupo County and something we don't want yes so tell me about that so again so that's so so next year we we fall below the following year um we would be below 3% so so so of a non-player right if once you get to yeah in two years so that would be the 26 27 school so two years so in two years we we our statutory Reserve level 3% and we go fall into State receivership okay we' probably be a qualified district and then we would be okay one one thing I I I haven't I think is interesting I haven't heard anybody disagree with the fact that we have a structural deficit and that we need to address the

206structural deficit the question is how are we going to do it um and and I think I'll have some other questions but one of the things I'm curious about is you came up with this list and I appreciate the hard work you put into it what are some things that you looked at that you rejected that didn't that that would have been even more Draconian than what we're looking at now well we've we've talked about some of those things right again so the aits El teachers Ela we also um class reduction at the School having you know could could be more significant um like main classroom rest we are still below the contractual agreement we have with our current teachers union um and the CDE Ed code on class sizes so we could push class

207sizes even higher K ptk through 12 but know that that when we do that at the secondary level programs go away so if we if we went just based on class size and certain programs you you would you know can you run an autoshop can you run certain CT programs are there you know some of those things right we have some of our choir programs or our low low numbers right so are we G to C chire or we so again we we stay away from those those decisions because for the most part it's secondary um classes are based on what kids sign up for so that's that's how they make their Master schedules that's how they build them right so we we've kind of based so so those are things that we've gone into

208um again I could I could cut even more in class size at the elementary level but but it was too painful there's too many com combination classes there's too many you know we I I can't come before you and say that there are going to be 30 kids in a Kindergarten class like I can't I mean I just can't do that right even though we might be able to that's not something that would recommend that's not that that what we're talking about here gets nowhere near that number right um so things like that those are the things that you know we we talk Transportation that's come up before right not having we we we we didn't have high school transportation for a few years our secondary sites um and man that was for our El

209parents painful painful for them that's all we heard about elac elcab meetings um so we we didn't at this point we didn't go there and I know that that that's that that's a key issue for our El parents especially the after school buses um so those are the types of things okay and and then the other thing I'm i' I'd like to just us to think about is I think we're we're not just talking about $486,000 for counseling but also when I look down non-personnel reductions we're talking about about $270,000 contacts with Community Mental Health supports and Community family advocates so we're really talking about over $750,000 in cuts to seal programs for our kids um I don't know where else we will cut because I believe we need to make these cuts and I

210believe we need to be fiscally responsible that's something that has been a g board priority for as long as I've been on the board we can not spend money we don't have but I would like to know if there are any alternatives to spend to that loss of seven that cut of $756,000 for student mental health supports okay I mean it could be intervention programs it could be other aits it could be other things that were I mean you know it's kind of where how do you how do you want the reductions right I mean we tried to keep those npss academic balance it with reductions in counseling again we kept we've added six or seven um school psychologist mental health over the years right did not touch those and they're they're they're not doing

211psychology they're they're counseling students right that's what they do all day so again there's other you know when you look at the overall addition so I I I know I know that this is painful no matter what we do but I also know that school psychologists in addition to counseling that they might provide uh are doing special education intervention and special education evaluations and things like that which the ability for them to do those we have school sites for that yeah okay right and then these are the the the counseling minutes on IEP that are done by a separate group of we've taken on we've added that you know we've taken that on as a district instead of Contracting out so so yeah Mrs schaer thank you uh I appreciate the my colleagues comments um

212and I to Mr younger's point I think there's no way to get to our budget without uh affecting Personnel costs because as we say over and over again we are a people organization um to Mr clawson's remarks I agree I think Diablo needs to step up we are making over concerted efforts in that regard uh both legislatively and in discussion with pg& I saw that for part of the meeting tonight uh Eric Daniels attend was on Zoom but unfortunately he's isn't with us during this part of the uh the meeting but uh Seer it it did indicate some interest at least in checking in um as um you know we no matter how long Diablo is here the results of the plant will be here forever in the uh in the waste that that has

213been left behind so we continue to experience that part of their uh their industry whether or not we they remain so I would hope that the fact that they are uh getting the additional permit and and Licensing and moving forward I agree they need to step back up to the plate and and support us to at least to the minimal amount they were before of $10 million a year we had times when it was much higher I I don't know whether uh reinstating the unitary tax is or is not the answer uh I agree that that would be take some time and in the meantime we need to come up with some sort of bridge at least until something is established again to make get us back on track uh the county as a whole

214everyone the whole Community is suffering from not from pgn's lack of attention as you pointed out not only do we educate their children uh many those with uh dual in families they're employees of ours they're working for us so I think that it is really important to continue to pursue that actively which I know we have been doing and at the at the local level at the sacramental level and we'll continue to do that I think one of the things that concerns me a lot right now is that we are in a time of Education with great uncertainty you know we receive it we think and there's no arguing that these cuts are are distasteful they're painful they're not what anyone wants to see if indeed at the federal level the Department of Education goes

215away we lose another $10 million or so overnight if that occurs so to to think that that this will be the end of it I think just in this time of great uncertainty is unrealistic now I don't feel that we need to anticipate that and cut in anticipation of maybe that will happen but I think we need to be realistic about it um that we just don't the unpredictability is really um destabilizing I also want to talk about um TK we are maintaining it we I hope if the board votes that way um we could have solved our and I think that was the initial presentation we could have solved everything by eliminating TK or prevented other Cuts we chose not to do that and int and and instead to try and maintain it and

216solve our problem in another our budgetary problems in another way however I don't believe I'm not sure that that TK at with what we're doing may or may not be sustainable and we may need to look at it again next year and and come up with some Alternatives that may not include eliminating it but a sliding scale um it pay you know figure out ways to keep TK at least for some of our families my desire is that or my request as one board member is that as we go through this process and and try and read the Tes of what may be coming on if it appears that TK may need to be looked at again next year that we really get the word out as early as possible for our families for or

217for caregiver caregiving opportunities um alternatives for our families I think um that that's an important thing to keep in mind to and to really stress I think a sort of strange positive of the going through this is people are paying attention to the budget people are paying attention to to what how this how this works we talked about this forever we we indicate we we budget uh reports and uh information is available it's discussed Mr Pinkerton gives a report at every single board meeting and doesn't we don't talk about cuts at every board meeting but we do talk about what the budget looks like what we're anticipating where the money comes from where it goes this is a really important piece of the work that the board does and often times times during the first

218part of the meeting when we have public comment before we have the superintendent reports people come and speak about you know we need to be doing this we need to be doing that and I said to people before stay for the budget report and listen and they'll say no I just I've said what I want to say and they leave and so listening being aware of of the budget piece of the the really difficult the challenging work that we do as a district and as a board having that information becoming more educated the public becoming more educated about that will serve our students and families and help us make better decisions so I would urge everyone to maintain this level of interest and curiosity about what we do it's why we're called trustees and um

219it's a it is a big important part of our job sitting up here is to uh decide make crucial decisions about how our limited resources are distributed thank you Mr quman thank just a real quick question I um I was able to spend some time on one of our new buses and it was El and if I remember correctly the bus cost $500,000 okay so just real quick do we have a bus on order at this time we have another we have 10 buses on order we have 10 okay well we have grants to pay for them excuse me we have grants to pay for I okay so we can't goodness we can't or we wouldn't have 10 buses out order I appreciate that so it's just not a matter of cancelling one bus no

220no I just just just had my my fingers crossed okay um people said um or at least one person said we're not working up in Sacramento and we've all said I wonder or if you could share the names uh there's one name in particular my understanding is former Governor Jack oconnell is is in our corner and working up is that am I allowed to say that okay so not only not Governor but okay sorry the part education education lead sorry for the CDE yes but but he's in our Corner he's working so it's not just a frivolous talk we've really put some time and effort into this and then I just I just have a maybe two short stories and just to support the need of the counselors we were part of an immigration Workshop

221we had the attorneys we had I can't I can't there had to be 150 200 people in that room one woman's story stuck out to me and she stood up and she said if I'm walking down the street with my two children what happens if they pick me up and that that for me said everything but I think the interesting thing is our kids know it's not like her parents are up here discussing it the children know and so the need for counseling is magn ified I all the stories we heard it's got to be magnified 10 or 20 times 100 times instantly for the kids I've attended two elac meetings in the past month and that's all that's being discussed it's it's one of the principles just said I have stuff that I'm supposed

222to tell you and I it's not even worth my time telling you because there's so much other things so I guess what I'm going to come down to say is as long as I'm on the board and some way to stop it I'm I'm not going to let counseling be stopped whether it's whether it's through PG whether it's the foundation money that was brought up and whether it was the reserves which hammered in for me over and over again rainy day this is why we have it that the foundation was set up with PG money whatever the source of money is we have to find it and because just many people have said the times now I guess it's my turn um couple of things that I just wanted to clear up uh it was

223one of our staff members had um had spoken at the podium and said that it was first come first serve for TK enrollment and you you said that was not correct and that person also said it was first come first serve or was happening now um enrollment for um summer experience it where where do it does that lie so um the Isla team and I are currently working on finishing all the enrollment documents communication that's going to be going out to school sites so I'm I'm not sure at this time she said she heard from her principal um but we haven't noticed our principles directly yet just that we were working with our TK team to develop a schedule and more information will be coming and going out to families um the current plan is

224to enroll into TK in the same fashion that we always have and that they'll be in person there'll be banners it'll be in Spanish and English um we're going to be taking all the students that are four year olds at whatever time they come to us if they meet the birthday cut off date what um I think may be alluded to is that as our current practices if a TK class in the city is already at the max number of students and an additional student comes in October that may qualify for that classroom then we work with the family to figure out how many siblings what other school could possibly meet their needs right it's kind of Taken on an individualized basis to ensure that families can get placed in a place that works for

225them um while also maintaining our contractual requirements with our teachers so it could be that if a TK classroom is full we will decide to either add an additional TK class create a tkk combo or invite the family to consider a nearby TK placement and then plan to return in kindergarten with the rest of their school but again none of this is changed or different from our practice currently and that that goes along with every grade level in the district right so you might have you know we can we can only have 35 kids in a class so that 36 kids shows up in August will will bust them to a different school right well in public education we take all comers so in terms of summer school summer school we make a concerted effort

226to enroll our El Foster Hess youth economically disadvantaged okay Jeff Martin I mean this is what his team focuses on we send out list to El teachers we ask people right like we we really try to get those families to sign up first and give them the opportunity so before we open it up to anyone El right so they get first shot that's ELO funding those types of things now it's not to say that in June an e family comes forward and says oh I wish I could have enrolled in summer school and I'm not on the list that could happen so but but I mean I just want you to know the focus and the intent and effort and then even then in June Mr Martin's going to keep a list and we're going

227to do everything in our power to make sure that that student is INS right so I think you you see Dr Prader shaking his head and this is his baby right like summer you know yeah that's not Happ sum experience we heard tonight is key is not accurate that's not what we're doing so now but but again not to Discount that she might have had a student a particular student that had an issue right that might have happened but to think that that's just a widespread hey oh no after this date no you're done you don't get to come no no we just want to dispel that so one more piece about high school summer school we are also Dan Dan nef and the High School principles are working on a special plan for our

228Avid and NextGen eel students Foster homeless youth students to ensure they all have a specialized plan to enroll in the appropriate High School class we are again working on an acceleration plan for our Avid nextg students so that they can take um a high hybrid um peap prep class because what we're hearing is that cohort is moving into 10th and 11th grade is they want more support feeling prepared for AP tests that they because we encourage them to take at least one AP class but they're sharing that they don't feel prepared for it so we're going to do an AP jump style Avid prep for those students is currently what we're looking to do this summer and in order for them to take that AV elective during the school year they have to they pretty

229much have to take a summer class right because there's just no room in their schedule especially on the college prep track okay and then you know I've been on this board a long time and U many of my colleagues have served with me and I I don't think anyone would dispute that I have been a fierce advocate for counseling always and it is so painful to think about having to make cuts to counseling now I know it used to be perhaps it's different now but it used to be that none of the surrounding districts had Elementary counselors do they now have them have they recognized the need I'd have to check I know in some cases there are some yeah there are some yeah there are yes okay so if we were the word on

230the street as lucar has counselors on the management um Pace management scale I I don't know I am I'm not familiar with te counseling although um my sister is has a doctorate she counsels her clients via Zoom or over the computer and it seems to work very well I don't know because I'm not really familiar with it I don't know how how it would really work for a second grader or how it would you know so right now the tella health for elementary school is always family based counseling okay and so it's a family based session um we have successfully had in 50 or 60 students get to multiple sessions with the teleah health right now we've had over 180 I think Janet yeah about do you have the number right there okay um a

231little less than 200 total referrals they are mostly I'm doing this off the top of my head from the slideshow they are mostly related to stress worry and anxiety it's a predominant concern and complaint from families and students seeking support okay that's a new new program this year so Janet's been again got it off the ground with Angela riy and and it's just started we had no no real reports on it so I don't know much about it um if it's family based for elementary students and a a child um is struggling or is in pain because there is abuse in the home or there is something else that in that they would not want to share with their family or be fearful to share with their family then how would they that availing themselves

232of that doesn't work correct that would be the limitation of that support and um that child would need to receive the other kinds of supports that we have okay so what I'm what I'm hearing tonight really loud and clear is that our our teaching staff um you know the people who are really in the trenches absolutely value the work of our counselors and I am wondering then I I love Mr clawson's idea but I'm not sure how that could be made to happen in such short order that pg& would just come down with a check for 10 million and say you know we're going to hand it over I'd love it just to be clear it's going to require more than me asking I think everyone involved here need to participate that call I'll call

233them tomorrow okay so I don't know if there's a great likelihood that that's actually can occur before we have to to um approve noticing people but if we want to preserve counseling and we want to maintain all of the systems of support that we've uh enjo enjoyed is a funny word that we've developed come to have during these postco years would all of those things be preserved if we increase class size by one more student at every grade level because I know that's hard on teachers and teachers you know but we'd still be under the contract maximum here I would tell you um so a few things the 14 that I pulled Elementary in the seven secondary we don't have enrollment yet TK we're going to try to maintain 14 classes we don't have enrollment

234yet what if it's over 80 what if it's 100 TK kids you know well we had we had 2ks at CL Smith this year they've always had three so I I I mean I again these reductions that we talked about are they're probably more on the light side and you just haven't heard from the elementary teachers yet because they don't know what their classes are for next year so though you're hearing from counselors tonight you'll you'll hear from them right when when they see what their classes are in May and June so it's it's not it's and we're hearing from teachers you know speaking you heard T behalf of counselors or just telling their personal experien we tried to tried to focus a lot of reductions on teachers outside the classroom um but but make

235no mistake losing the S Cube teachers that help run our mtss programs and academics I mean to think that we're just gonna now one person's gonna handle everything for nine schools that's it's not going to be the same right so again that's where I mean this is I know I know get down to the bone in some of these areas right especially class size some of those we have to reduce Personnel understand we go secondary then classes under 20 and I'll get you a list those I don't know that we can maintain those and those are going to be programs like choir those are going to be jazz bands those are going to be you know some CTE programs right that will be they'll be cut also small because they won't be able to maintain

236them small AP classes um you know things that we've maintained at moral B High because we want to make sure that things are fair that they have the same offerings at moral Bay High and sisp high school right so all those things that we've tried to again these are the like Mr Jer said what are the things that you tried to as you're making these decisions what what's going through your mind right and so all of those things are going through going through our minds one more that we we talked and didn't move forward with is a reduction in uh you know any kind of classified staff in our teacher librarian team right they are now full they are full-time employees well that's because they manage all of the technology we have in our schools

237they are not just people that keep beautiful lovely learning spaces open during recess and lunch they are operationalizing all the technology across our schools so again it wouldn't make sense to take that employee group and and furthermore they are not an employee Group which can make mill a million doll problem go away for us the elementary counselors too I mean again it's some would say that our current Staffing is not fair is not I'm sorry it's not fair fair they have have one full-time counselor to school with 225 kids and then a full-time counselor to school with 500 kids so even our current system has some inequity in it right now right so um you know so again we all those things are things that are going through our minds as we're kind of looking

238at trying to you know again minimize it as much as possible but make the get to a point where the necessary reductions again we couldn't even get to the 6.3 million I couldn't even find another 500,000 that we could even live with right so yeah let's let's spend on the reserves a little bit and and you know move through this process but no waiting on the wings if PG doesn't just donate $10 million to US each year or that we it takes more than one year to get our unitary tax established or TK funding or those things this board will face a 2.7 million to you know dollar deficit next year and then we will be talking about those things we just discussed so that's the you know that's the tough part right I didn't

239want to go there tonight with these yeah but but that's what's facing us if these things don't come to fruition um and and that would be very deep very hard very painful this this is going back to those painful things if the department of of education is closed those are happening any yeah we're back for us we're back here this summer we don't have a timeline on that so no for me I think you know I'm I'm gonna take the next two weeks between now and the next meeting and be trying to think of ways that we can preserve as much of the counseling because that is it's a value across the board it's what we heard from everybody preserve as much of the counseling as we can and I'll be coming to you with

240you know with ideas and I I just would assume that my colleagues will be doing the same because everyone here seems to want to preserve as much as much as possible yeah that was a lot of talking to get nowhere I mean we just we just have a big problem well could I just respond to your comment um I want to take issue with you joking about the fact that PG might donate money and I want to take issue with the fact that you had no confidence that they will and and I I I understand but my point if we don't expect them to step up as a community partner we're litting them off the hook our our lack of expectation in them is exactly what they want and is what allows them to not

241meet very low expectations I have high expectations for them I I like I said I want them to be in this community for decades longer and and I want the community to benefit from them and on top of that I think when they donate and come through they should have our admiration and respect and thanks because they will be pulling their weight in our community and I I just want to be clear because I don't want this to be a joke I I I didn't bring this up because I didn't want to address budget cuts I actually think there's a solution here and we all need to push on it and and having low expectations is exactly the way it doesn't happen briyan I don't think it's a joke I don't think it's a joke

242and I don't think we need to be thanking pg& either I don't think it's laress I think it's their obligation we have everyone in these communities our Coastal communities and town we have uh taken the risk with our lives and the lives of our children since Diablo opened and I think it is their obligation to uh support us rather than uh a laress on their part and something that I need to be particularly thankful for they should be thankful that they're able to operate in our community a agreed it's two sides of the same coin whe whether they step up because we asked them to or whether they step up because they should when they step up I will be grateful I will advocate for their extension I will be a advocate for them in

243the community because they will have done the right thing and and I will want to thank them because they will have saved our counselors and our teachers and more importantly our students and they can save our students yes they can but historically they haven't done the right thing until they have been sure the fact that our expectations are so low is not a reason not to push for an expect I agree okay I agree with you there well that's was called a dialogue we have many monologues but we had a dialogue does anyone else have a comments okay Mr to be clear Mr Clon to be clear that approach is a one-time fix it's not because you still have to advocate for the longterm unitary tax unless that's not what that's not what I'm proposing

244not I'm I'm proposing they commit to 10 million doll a year of benefit coming to this district for every year that plant is open I see if it's open for another 20 years it's not not a near-term fix if we replace it with unary tax great then it's a bridge if we never get unitary tax it's a solution but but it's a solution I think okay I misunderstood no no it's not like hey give us it's not fixed this year it's live up to the obligation you've had for decades for decades they have made that contribution and the plant is going to continue just do it as long as the plant's open so we need to harness the organizing and Leadership of our te teachers our parents and our community to focus their attention there

245and AG we can set the example yes so know would we go about doing that I mean first first steps us I'm sure they hear us right now I I I I know I know they're listening so so the message hopefully is clear um I I think we need to have a discussion with them I I I think I think it's straightforward I think the county needs to have a discussion with them I think the county is down the street contemplating layoffs right now also and they lost funding our community is losing jobs and hurting and it's very fixable and like I said if they do it I will admire them and thank them but your question I think we need to have a discussion a very quick direct discussion saying here's our foundation here's

246the solution we don't need funds by February 18th but we need a public commitment that you're going to provide us funds next year and that solves our budget problem so if it's uh and they uh P gen is listening by the way um and um what I would what I'm hearing you say is perhaps um a well-composed letter um and um the ability to um engage them on these terms in a meeting um and Mr Clawson it sounds like you'd like to join me I'd love to meet with them as a valued Community partner like I said I think it could be a really productive relationship for everyone okay you know I would add that that we a few weeks ago when handing out pliers with legislators information we know it worked because we heard

247from legislators that they were being um hearing that being inundated with emails and contacts so you know we need to do the same thing with pg& you know they're they're easy to find they're in the neighborhood look up the number of their uh their website there's a contact us link and do I would encourage the public to do what they did with um with the legislators listed on the flyer and let them know that we're paying attention and that unlike some of the legislators who are kind of higher up and live in Sacramento or other parts of the state and may or may not have a close association with us these These are you know they do they they live here and to take that same approach and that for those of you who contacted

248legislators a few weeks ago to do the same thing with um with pg& sure yeah so so in the room just recently we had slct I know CSEA was here um the board is here administration's here you know every once in a while all the groups agree strongly agree on something and so I think Mr Clawson is a great idea I think the superintendent's a great idea but I would invite if it's okay I'd like to invite all the organizations to come together and make make that approach um and if that works for the superintendant or if it works for Mr Clawson but I think that's one hell of a powerful voice so I know it's worked in the past for public education I that not everyone yeah but anyway just an idea is there

249any additional comments okay then I'll just add one thing and then we'll move on um this information is pretty Antiquated but there was a time when I was told that when uh writing letters such as the ones that we're we're contemplating here um that if you sent a handwritten letter that it was counted uh as though it represented six computer generated or written letters so um for those of us who remember getting penmanship instruction um it it may be worthwhile to uh send a handwritten letter and with that said we'll move on to the action consent agenda please let me know if you would like anything pulled 10.1 approval of certificated and classified Personnel items 10.2 approval of the expanded learning opportunities program plan for 2025 26 10.3 approval of field study trip requests sure

250uh 10.04 approval of furniture and Equipment requests I'm pulling that one 10.05 approval of the minutes of November 19th 2024 06 approval of the minutes of December 17th 2024 10:07 approval of the minutes of January 19th 2025 oh pardon me January 9 uh 10.08 approval of minutes of January 14 2025 10.09 approval of purchase orders and Cal card purchases 10.10 School accountability report card CS 10.11 approv with 2025 26 Transportation plan and 10.12 approval of warrants and payroll so I am seeking a motion for the approval of 10.01 10.02 and 10.05 through 10.12 I'll make a motion to approve items 10.01 and 10.0 2 and then I believe you said 10.0 five 5 through 12 so not 10.04 no 10.05 through 10.12 I'll second that okay so I have a motion by Mr anger a

251second by Mr Banfield Mrs wal on out yes you voting are we voting we're voting okay I didn't hear the yes yes uh Mr hunger yep Mr Banfield yes Mr Sheffer yes yes M yes okay and the rest of those guys and I'm a yes so uh 10.03 Mr Buckman thanks I was very excited to see um Mr B's um trip coming up I'm pretty sure this is not his first time I went and looked at zeper Point Presbyterian conference center it's amazing and you can go up there and bring your family and get a cabin so I know where I'm staying next time but um my concern is is we're going to send some um younger kids up there and just as I could have my family up there other groups could be there

252at the same time and so my concern is is will we have enough adults for our group in case the in case this group comes up at the same time and they're maybe not compatible I don't know so I was just concerned because the all the units are really close together yeah thank you um I I'm looking at the field trip slip right now to make sure that we have the appropriate um level of supervision um adults to students and we'll we'll double check and get in touch with Mr beler before that um happens but yes we we have a board policy which outlines how many adult chaperon are required on approved field trips and and I appreciate that and I'm interested to know but I'm also just wondering in this case whether we might

253need more or less so I I'm just so I'll move appr I'll move approval of what is it 10.3 10.3 10 I'll move approval of 10.03 a second please I'll second okay so I've got a m by Mr Buckman a second by Mrs Sheffer Mr Buckman Mrs Sheffer Mr Banfield yes Mr hunger yep Mrs baldano yes and I'm a yes I'm a yes too oh I beg your pardon I beg your pardon Mr Clawson so that passes unanimously okay I pulled uh 10.04 which is the the fur um Furniture equipment request only because as I read through everything uh I noticed that there was a switch gear on here for $155,000 and I thought wow I've never seen one of those come through on a first that's a big big draw so I spoke with

254Mr Bonin and that is um actually more appropriately applied to measure C and it was just a coding thing and it's been corrected so just in case anyone else wondered you know why we were buying something that expensive out of the general fund um that's what it was that said I'll move approval of 10.04 I'll second thank you so uh motion by myself second by Mr anger Mr anger yep Mrs badano yes Mr bamfield yes Mr Sheffer Mr Buckman and Mr Clawson yes okay and I'm me yes so that passes unanimously uh anything for advanced agenda Mr your lights on did you want to nope okay uh in that case then board reports Mr rer I'll make it quick um I two went to the capital advisers meeting that Mr Pinkerton went to um and

255it was as he said it was really quite interesting um not not a lot of I thought not not so much for basic Aid school districts but mostly for Revenue limit school districts uh I also met with several people from moral Bay regarding moral elementary school and got some interesting insights there um I attended the immigration forum and the community meetings and along with Mrs badano and Mr Claus and I went to the reach ideas and actions Forum as part of my commitment to to the foundation okay anyone else Mrs B yeah um I just want to acknowledge that these are scary times for a lot of our families um there's a lot of anxiety and uncertainty and so I was really pleased to attend um a very well attended program on uh immigration uh

256at PCO Elementary School I think there were something like 300 people on site and another couple hundred or 100 50 on Zoom so that was good to get to to be uh in that place together there were other board members there as well um I've had a phenomenal meeting with our food services director um and I've met with a lot of directors of different programs in our district um through my uh you know attempt to um meet everyone and spend good quality time with everyone uh in addition to the boardwalks that I've started to do um but I just want to say that I'm very much looking forward to on Thursday I'm going to be doing mock interviews with our Avid students at slow High School um who are practicing for scholarship interviews and I'm

257looking forward to doing that okay Mr Buckman yeah just real quickly um I didn't know um that I you're going to be doing the interviews as well I'll see you there that's going to be exciting um I met with uh Rita casab who is the um director of the diversity Coalition we talked about the effect of this immigration stuff on students and what the Coalition the diversity Coalition is going to be working on and as I mentioned I attended um two elac meetings um so far towards the end of the year and um what's happening in Washington what Trump is doing is just the scariest thing I have ever heard of I'm online right now trying to see whether he's closed the Department of Education yet because it could have happened already but it hasn't

258but it's it's just so scary okay well then I'll just say I can't remember everything that I did I I attended uh both uh together with most of my colleagues both of the community forums regarding the budget in town and in Morrow Bay uh I met with three community members in moral Bay regarding the moral Elementary uh situation um nothing else really stands out in my mind I I think that's what I did so can I pop in oh absolutely just since everyone else is I'm not gonna I attended many of the things that my colleagues did I don't need to repeat that but I want to get thank uh Mr Mayfield I visited CL Smith last week because I felt a great need to be on the ground at a site with kids and

259um I appreciate his welcoming me on short notice and the opportunity to sit and watch kids the kids film the kids from the leadership class filming their um weekly updates for the next week and announcements and it was really fun to watch them they'd written the script they would had a director in the room a student director they have student editors and uh student announcers for the um the Superstar news that is presented every Monday so it was great fun and um always important to see our work in action so thank you and with that we are adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.