001okay good evening and welcome to the regular scheduled January 14th meeting of the St Louis Coastal Unified School District Board of Trustees the board previously met in close we engaged in some Personnel review and possible action and um also discussed three items of anticipated litigation um um resulting from that closed session the board voted uh unanimously to deny a government Tor claim do we have consensus on the order of business yes okay um then we will move on to well actually let me say that we have translation services available this evening um in the back of the room you will find you see uh one of our friends holding up headsets if you uh need those they are available if you are joining us via Zoom you may press on the globe icon on your
002screen and you will be directed to translation thank you so our first item of business then is item 5 01 the Simer program highlights right good evening I'm gon to try to pull up our presentation really quickly here see if I can find it oh perfect thank you okay so you will see behind me many of our student council and student Senators here and they're going to introduce themselves as they come up um but they are going to be leading most of our presentation today so I am going to once that presentation pops up somewhere I need to pull it up okay you come on up and we'll make like a line in front of that we can do both sides too yeah come this me come chair you guys pulling it up far no
003thanks jery you're welcome what's the agenda on item by the way let me see here roll call public comment you got it good all right perfect okay so hello we are sun shimer I'm Jessica Miller I'm the principal here at Sun shimer um and we have an amazing school and amazing group of students who are going to walk us through some of the cool things that have happened at Sun shimer this year and some of the things that we are working on next slide please do I have control over that there we go all right so I'm gonna pass it off to Tanner he is one of our student council members hi my name is Tanner um I've been a proud Stinger since kindergarten um and what we're working on this year is academic progress
004social emotional learning and building our community and that's what we're going to talk about with you today thank you um hi my name is Finn I'm a fifth grader at sin Simer Elementary School something we have started this year is math interventions and language arts interventions thank you uh hi my name is Vincent and I'm a sixth grader at s shmer Elementary and we have a new uh Ela curriculum which is Benchmark and we're working on trying to get uh people to like it more and getting U and getting the teachers to understand it because it's a little different from what they used to do and what they used to learn back then we're very honest here at Sun shimer um one of the things you'll notice on there too is our cubed in success
005time and that's been a huge support for our teachers this year so they're working with our SBE position um and really learning that curriculum diving deep into it and figuring out how to best use that and implement it to support our students um so that's been amazing as well uh hi I'm Leo and I'm in sixth grade at Simer Elementary um at Simer we have the sore expectations these guide our students to be the best students that they can be the the four expectations are safety ownership achievement and respect these are all essential for our school Simer also provides plenty of leadership opportunities some of these opportunities are student council and Innovation team we also have students clean up after lunch this can Inspire kids to want to be leaders oh thank you hi my
006name is Sierra and construction has just started at our school in December and will make classrooms more comfortable in addition we also have spirit days on Fridays where we wear black and yellow or sting our wear to school hi my name is Kyla and I'm a fifth grader at Simer s shimer has lots of extracurricular clubs and Athletics from August to December we had boys soccer girls volleyball and cross country coming up early this year here we have girls soccer and boys basketball some of the clubs that CER offers are science yoga and theater hi my name is Taylor Parsons and I'm a fifth grader at Simer Elementary at Simer we do lots of school events including the wathon where we raised lots of money for our school and my favorite event that we did
007is the Skydome assembly where we got to learn about planets and constellations in a really fun way thank you for listening we also did events like the book fair and the Time Capsule at the Time Capsule we opened it at an assembly and then put it out at lunch for everyone to explore and at the book fair we raised $2,800 for the library all right thank you to our amazing Stingers for coming tonight and participating in our presentation and thank you board for your continued support I didn't ask for questions are there any questions okay you all know how to get hold of me if there are thank you okay thank you very much uh the next item is student representatives to the board and tonight we'll begin with Moro Bay and that is Nate
008land help me out here Nate landweer thank you uh so for those of you who don't know me like she said I'm Nate land Weir I am an ASB co-president at Moro Bay High School along with Zara segler I am also the ASB co-president at Mor Bay High School uh so what we have to share with you tonight is just some future things we're looking forward to and amazing things that have been going on at our campus I there we go uh so first off the drama performance of their miscast production which will be mean girls is this Saturday at 7 p.m. the show will be super fun and hilarious and it is free for everyone so if you're available Saturday at 7 please come and enjoy the show it'll be a great time uh
009coming up on February 1 Dance Fusion is hosting dance Beyond a countywide High School Dance convention uh the day includes taking two classes of each student's to Choice hip-hop lyrical or contemporary dance taught by guest teachers from cowply Allen Hancock and Klein dance studio any student wanting to participate can do so and they can be a beginning to advance dancer everyone is welcome regardless of skill level the day will end with local high schools showcasing their school and a performance for all to enjoy it'll be an amazing show uh mced by some of our students at Mora Bay High and thanks to our Dance Fusion team and Mrs Smith for putting on such a great local Dance convention and just a quick share I don't think we've done this before but an amazing club we
010have at our school is the student L peer Tutoring Club students needing help in any of their classes from math to history and science uh can get support from their fellow students if they're struggling and kind of uh go over topics they may be struggling and get some peer Insight on how they can improve and better ways to understand topics uh that meets Tuesdays and Thursdays at lunch and it's amazing opportunities that students started at our school I wanted to briefly talk about uh the seniors at Mor High um mbhs has a senior job shadow project this project builds upon the required job research project that all students complete during their junior year students contact a job shadow prospect that will afford them the opportunity to have a real life experience being able to Shadow
011someone in a profession that they're interest in pursuing students will spend four hours shadowing and then interviewing their job shadow and getting a firsthand opportunity to see components of the career today I actually went to do my job shadow and with Miss Fay at Monarch Elementary and it was a wonderful experience and the students are so lucky to have her and just a little bit about college as well things are in high gear for our seniors both the nbhs local scholarship application and the slow Community Foundation application are now open and our students are working on their applications our financial aid night in December went great students and families were able to work on financial aid applications with in-person support from quest's Financial team team and Miss Macintosh from the College and Career Center and
012super awesome also seniors began to work on the quest of promise with a presentation from our counselor Miss Hoy about how to choose a major the steps for applying to Questa and receiving those tiers for fee free as well as just the timeline and registering for classes so we're super excited for all of our seniors oh there we go thank you uh and for sports League kicked off last week for all of our winter sports teams and all the teams are super excited and ready for League competition our surf team competed last week in Carpenteria and we were head-to-head against do pblos high school our team continues to have success as they won yet again uh another recent highlight is our girls and boys wrestling teams at the lady Apache tournament at the selland arena
013and Fresno our girls did amazing as a team little Moro Bay High School took 10th out of 51 teams uh boys varsity varsity wrestling did great at the San unz battle for the valley Shay da awson took first place in his weight class and was named the outstanding wrestler of the tournament so special shout out to Shay and all he's done also our annual CIT wrestling tournament one of the largest high school wrestling tournaments in the nation will be held on Friday and Saturday the 24th and 25th of this month last year there were 855 wrestling teams that participated we have on over here uh and we have 90 teams participating this year so five more teams than last year uh this tournament was started by longtime teacher and Coach Sam Boyd and this year
014will be the 69th year of the tournament it was also worth noting that Albert Garza our boys and girls head wrestling coach competed himself in the tournament in high school he won his weight class during his sophomore and Junior years at Sanger High School in Fresno County the CIT is a big part of nbhs history and culture and we are very excited for this year's tournament uh the boys soccer team had their first League game on the 10th against Mission prep Mor Bay came out with a win of 1 and0 this was an amazing way to start off the season for the boys the girls soccer team also had a great start to their season uh with leaving their game in Mota with a win we are so excited to see how the girls do
015for the rest of the season and we're excited for the rest of winter sports and spring sports are not that far away so all amazing things ahead um I have one more note uh this year we have been so proud of the work that our Wellness Center has done because it has been crucial to the student wellness with many students finding safety and understanding with the center but sadly in March we're losing one of our teammates Anna because she's being let go Anna has personally built relationships with so many students on our campus being the original opening and ribbon cutting that many board members and admin attended and mbhs will be devastated sir thank you again for the opportunity to share tonight we always love it thank you thank you first let me say that
016I neglected to um introduce Zar segler representing Moro Bay and I apologize for that and now we have Linda G roas from San lisal High School good evening everyone wow I'm so excited to be sharing all fun stuff with this many people um I've got lots of stuff to talk about so let's get into it um firstly in the of ASB we've been working really hard and we've been coming up with some really cool ideas and one of them was a senior rally so we had this on Monday during our tutorial period and we had lots of fun with the seniors um we got a chance to talk about some important topics and talk about stuff like the senior breakfast and Senior showcase where we even had one of our own our ASB secretary do
017um a performance for our students and sing a song for them so that was really cool and we also got a chance to play some games and just kind of connect on that level of being a class um let's see if I can get some pictures up here there we go yeah we played some knockout basketball it was really fun um it really felt like we had a connection um another thing we have coming up is our club Rush number two if you recall we had our first one earlier in the year and it's basically where all of our clubs come out and we kind of have it in like a farmers market Style where we have every single one of our clubs on campus come out display what they're about um it happens during
018lunch so everyone is welcome and everyone can see what um clubs we have on campus and everyone is welcome to join um so we're having our second round tomorrow during lunch um same place same time so that everyone can come out um if some students missed it um or if you want to join more clubs this is a perfect opportunity for those students another thing we recently started is every Wednesday um we will have a different activity for students who are on campus to participate in um we have some big Jenga coming up we've built Juju bread houses in the past we've done um sidewalk chalk um just fun stuff for people um and yeah we're hoping to keep all that fun stuff coming in the FFA world we are very busy um we are
019having our annual FFA um bowling meeting at calply Mustang links coming up on January 16th um many of our students are applying for uh State proficiency and those are applications that students go through um get some awards at the state level we have three students applying for that this year um January 25th and February 1st we will be having our first two parliamentary procedure contests of the Season we have an advanced team and two novice teams both of these teams are really well trained and they have gotten State um State levels before and they've gotten first and second place places so we're really proud of them and everything that they're doing um on February 4th we will be having over 20 students um we will be taking at the sectional public speaking competition these are
020comp competitions such as impromptu prepared public speaking extemporaneous speaking and job interview and a couple other ones we are also gearing up to begin the M the our Middle School Outreach committee and present to the eighth grade science classes about opportunities in agriculture and FFA um so be on the lookout for that because I'll be reporting about that soon in our Athletics World our tigers have been very busy um our boys basketball defeated Morrow Bay on Tuesday um but we fell short to St Joe's on Friday our girls basketball defeated Templeton at home and our girls soccer defeated both at Tuscadero and retti to start two and zero in League Play and wrestling had a great showing at the tournament in Sanz on the weekend where three wrestlers placed in very competitive fields we had
021students take eighth second and fourth place um to one of the best in the state so we're really proud of our wrestlers additionally this Friday uh we are having a super Spirit night and our future tiger night for basketball and me and the ASB secretary will be heading out to both of those games um our girl soccer will have tacos for the people who would like to come out to that um so I'd encourage you if you can come on out show your support for those teams um it'll be really fun we are starting something new called tiger talks where we will be interviewing the players or the coaches or anyone who attends the game and just to get a feel for our community and all that support that we show here some other upcoming
022dates are let's see here one second um 102 to 10 to 214 are trials for spring Sports so those are going to be coming up we're excited to see everyone come out and show some love for that um on 220 we will be having a choir concert and our winter formal is also coming up so our ASB sophomores are working really hard to get all that planned get everything prepared for everyone that's going to come out um we also we'll be having our spring Sports parent meeting that will be at 6 o'clock on February 24th so lots of good stuff to come and I think that's about it for tonight so thank you so much everybody thank you all for coming and sharing with us tonight the goings on at our high schools um we
023are mindful that you have other things that you should or maybe would like to be doing so you're certainly welcome to stay with us um we would love that but we understand if you need to excuse yourselves okay um the next item is we have our annual report from Dr Jim brussa our County Superintendent of Schools good evening president Roger uh superintendent Prader and well student trustees that just left thank you um it's one of my um functions to report to all school districts throughout the county the Board of Supervisors and the various City councils on the status of schools throughout our County okay so I guess and I have a brief presentation we can't see um I wanted to just start off with reviewing where we are and the over 4,000 square miles that
024we cover if you look at the uh the the map right here just reminding everyone again our smallest School District Pleasant Valley which has under 100 students and our largest being lucar which is over 9,000 students across the county we span into multiple counties we provide services for Monterey County for Kar for kings and for Santa Barbara depending upon the school district and the overlap um all of the school districts are solvent everyone has reported positive certification uh and I'm pleased to say that we're not um examining closely any of the districts at this point in terms of their fiscal health and what's being turned in um so there just kind of a a brief overview right there let's see if I get this correct there we go um a few of the stats that
025I wanted to share with you and I thought I would take a a 10-year snapshot and just look at uh the state of California because there's there's some some accurate and somewhat misleading information that's out there about schools and and population if you just look at the state as a whole in terms of the number of students 10 years ago uh we were at 6.2 million compared to 5.8 million currently our student enrollment is going down if you look at the enrollment for San Louis abiso County the same Trends are occurring slightly higher percentage drop than other areas I think some of this um has to do if you look at the population of California though uh the population has increased since 10 years ago there was however a spike in 2019 and we've dropped
026since then so if you look at a 10-year average we have more people in the state than we did 10 years ago but we actually have less people than we did in 2019 um so excuse me years ago oh where did we go I'm not touching anything is that you in the back um the the biggest thing that I wanted to report in the 20e span there that we were looking at is housing and I think that this is one of the challenges that we see for our enrollment countywide if you just look at what median housing prices in slow County were and the state compared to 2003 with 2023 you see a huge shift right there and by the way that is slow count if I drilled that down to San Louis abiso proper
027those numbers go up even more um because this includes Shandon as well as Pismo Beach so we have the averages across the county what we're seeing and I presented this to a group of of Educators Saturday morning is that we're seeing the population growth in our County go up but the student population go down and where we are starting to see enrollment growth tends to be at the middle school secondary level uh because you're seeing older families with possibly a little higher resources coming in uh we did see a population jump during the pandemic uh throughout but less children than you would have anticipated and that's one of the challenges that we're seeing so 30,000 more people in the county than 20 some odd years ago but we have less students so those are some
028of the challenges that we're seeing in our County and even across the state okay we can move to the next one now uh a few things that I just wanted to provide you in terms of of updating uh our school uh wide or our countywide uh participation and I really wanted to just focus on some of the positive things that are happening uh we have our web page where we and our site where we're articulating things that are happening through all of the school districts and let's see if that will play for me can you hit that first one is that you over there or me there we go good that's it once everything's perfectly organized I'll start working on my thesis gramly will ensure you good things are happening in schools throughout St Louis
029abiso County our schools have an incredible impact on shaping St Louis abiso County's unique character and we're proud of our success through Innovative education we're addressing the needs of Learners in a rapidly changing World embracing change and creating inclusive Equitable and engaging learning experiences further we're forging Pathways for students to live and Thrive here into adulthood equipping them with career ready skills and qualifications to meet the demands of local employers beyond the classroom we know the success of our schools extends far into our local communities contributing to the prosperity safety and health of future Generations I hope you'll join in recognizing and amplifying the positive accomplishments of our schools throughout the county good things are happening here learn more at good things. slco.org and this is emphasis of positive aspects that are happening in all
030schools across the county uh there are several articles that are referencing s Louis Coastal uh shanden all of the school districts these are the uh public service announcements that are appearing on KSBY and all of those shots of classrooms were classrooms in our County so it's really pleased to see that and those are just some some highlights of the good things your district is very good about providing material to us of all the positive things that are happening in the community and and we would just want to share that I think that's very important because if you look at that population going up in our County and the population with children or grandchildren in the schools going down we have more people that live in our County that have no interaction with our schools than
031people who do have interaction with our schools so we have to carry that message um I wanted to to comment again about board support and thank you um for the trustees here Ellen especially that support other trustees across the county we had about 20 individuals that were newly elected uh show up to the workshop Saturday morning just to learn about government governance and Service uh in our community you as the trustees are part of the largest group of elected officials um not only in the state but in the country if you look at school board members and and what you do is very important so I thank you for that and I appreciate your continued professional development I wanted to share a little bit about uh the governor's message on Career Technical education and some
032of the uptick that we will have I don't know if any of you maybe Chris might have been on that the old ROP board the jpa so it was Mark okay um when I started uh in this position in 2014 I was asked to take that over uh the county office had no operations of of Career and Technical EDS so the Career and Technical education director was me um and I have to admit I had no experience in in Career Technical Ed we hired someone we brought them on board we rallied the troops for all of the districts this County San Louis abiso County by percentage has the largest number of dual enrollment students in the state by percentage because every K12 school district has students taking dual enrollment with Questa College as a parent
033that saved me $10,000 when our daughters matriculated to high school so I want to thank San Louis Coastal for participating in that and I'm uh proud to announce that we're expanding to a second facility to promote Career and Technical Ed as well as apprenticeship in our boot camps we have the one where we took the old um Supply Depot that we had at in the county office across from Questa where the film strips the slide projectors the maps and and 35 millimeter films were stored that went out to every school um at one point in time it was just a warehouse turned it into a training facility we've just signed a lease with a property in pasor robbles on Railroad Street that's about 5,000 square feet that will be the same thing so it's another
034facility in the county to promote um dual enrollment Career Technical Ed and Pathways so um I wanted to talk briefly about disaster and emergency preparedness all of our school districts met at the beginning of the year with the Sheriff's Office all of the police departments and we discussed uh safety looked at the digital mapping reviewed all of the changes in landscape at all of our schools because we have multiple schools that have gone through Bond issues and uh Renovations the Sheriff's Office coordinates the digital mapping so that every law enforcement and Emergency Services has a digital map of school sites when they're responding in real time and your district has been very good about working with law enforcement and Emergency Services on that so I'm pleased to see where the preparedness across the county is
035for that we still have the benefit of um the emergency preparedness because of Diablo so we coordinate not only with the K12 uh public school districts but all the private parochial schools and the child care centers as well throughout the county on uh emergency preparedness our district attorney and our Sheriff um consistently attend these meetings and we have a a fairly solid communication chain with all of them I I wanted to briefly talk about uh employee education uh fund matching and that I'm continuing to put half a million dollars a year of County Office of Ed budget to match dollars of school districts paying for any educational training or upskilling of our current employees the three questions I have to ask is is it good for the employee is it good for the agency they
036work for meaning the school district school um Charter and do they work for us in some capacity after that it's up to the school district um I'm pleased to say that we've we've moved almost 250 people who are employees across the county through this program since I started it three years ago and all of the leas and Charters are participating throughout the county U and we'll continue to to move that forward um I and I I want to Advocate the grow your own your your principal Jessica that was here is a local was a local student when I worked at calpoly I had student teachers placed in her classroom she's an example of someone we tapped on the shoulder and said hey would you consider and I think I remember talking you into that Eric
037and saying would you teach a class of calply with me and let's look at some of your teachers that have potential to be leaders because of the cost of housing in this County and how difficult it is we have to look in our own backyard for employees and the best way to do that is to fund their training out OFA and if they're going to to paully or to UMass Global help pay for that so thank you San Lis Coastal for doing that with your employees I will continue to offer those funds on the fiscal front you've uh heard the governor's report you're you're probably for you as a community funded District you're just looking at your Cola increase for certain programs and whatever property tax bump um the good news is it's not going
038to go the opposite direction that we've seen in previous years but um the three Community funded or four if you count Pleasant Valley um do need to look at their budgets um and and be mindful of where your spending is as you're going for because I don't see any one-time dollars those have all timed out this year and those letters I'm sending the same letters every District gets about being mindful it's not any Slam against Ryan or his Department it's just that you need to to M the U the fund balance there the uh housing project we've moved forward with the Board of Supervisors uh we have the uh the permits I'm hopeful that we will be breaking ground in the next few months on that project and that will uh bring seven units online
039the property uh that we have across from Questa those will be offered up to um not only County Employees but District employees at reduced rental rates uh they won't be able to buy them but they can rent them at a reduced rate in hopes that they can save our first prototype um we have two classified employees who are a family and they live in that unit they have saved enough and they're actually getting their own place here in San Louis abiso this year as they offer that up for someone else so I'm very pleased about that and then the last two topics I wanted to just highlight um you can look at the video clips on your own I know you have a full house tonight so I'm I'm trying to speed things up um
040our Sela governance has been very effective we're continuing to Lobby uh with the state for additional funding I don't know where things will pan out with the feds on the the change of administration with uh funding for special education but I do want to quell concerns education is a function of state government there's a portion of our budget that comes from the feds we'll know more as the year progresses if that is is uh in Jeopardy or not but the majority of our funding comes from state government so just kind of reminding people on that the uh the final piece there is um our our school district superintendent Council where all of the district leadership and the two College presidents come together and we meet to discuss Collective issues we're meeting again this Friday mainly
041to discuss things such as the grand jury summons we've had the public records request acts uh consistent litigation our legal Consortium has saved School District about $400,000 over the last few years if they would have had to pay for some of those things on their own we try to combine resources so when there's a common issue for all districts my office takes it on gets Legal Information then disseminates it to all the 13 agencies um so that's just a a little overview and then the last slide were just some some happy pictures there I wanted to share and I'll answer any questions okay are there any questions for Dr brussa upper left is our signning Santa program at the deafen heart a hearing program um and Santa there was doing a signing um song with
042students uh I believe it was at the fireside room in Luci Mar this year um the upper right is our Grizzly Youth Academy program where we're back in full force we've added an an additional female cohort this year um so it is at capacity uh we can't take any more students each cohort and the the guard is looking at possible expansion we've also opened up the post residential program in Orange County we were finding that a lot of the grizzly uh completers graduates wanted to stay they did not necessarily want to return to the environment where they were struggling um Orange County we have three programs one here in slow one in Orange County and one in Stockton the Orange County program is allowing graduates to stay on the base and go to a community
043college until they are able to move out but that really is only for our 17 18 year olds our are 15 16 year olds are that's they're not eligible for that um lower uh leftand uh Corner was the uh our treat to all employees across the county and that was the Beauty and the Beast uh show at at calply we will do that again this year in May uh the employee uh education Employees Credit Union is our main sponsor for that and I will offer tickets to whatever production is appearing at calp the melodrama Blues baseball and that's offered to all school district and Charter employees across the county and their families in the month of May just to say thank you for your service and then finally um we had a very successful Hospitality
044boot camp uh this last summer and we'll offer that again for 75 young people across the county one in South County one here in slow and one in North County this was a Hospitality boot camp put on by um our office as well as individual businesses Farm Supply V robable it ranged depending upon who was there out of the 75 students 72 were offered employment post completion of the program now these are part-time jobs but the idea was to upskill and the hospitality agencies have been asking us to do that we'll continue to provide those boot camps so I I tried to make it short because I know you're busy tonight so anything I can answer any questions that you have for me or from our eye office right now Dr BR I don't see
045any questions oh Mrs Balon um thank you for the presentation I also just wanted to thank you and also miss cheffer who was involved in the new trustee training that I got to attend on Saturday that was very helpful wonderful and we will provide the um ethics workshops again for free and we'll continue to that also your trustee dinner is coming up next month that is for any of the trusties as well as the superintendent and we're hosting that um this year in Madonna we try to alternate back and forth between Nord County and slow so that'll be the Madonna in all right well I just thank you again for your service everything you're doing and oh mron I'm sorry Brian yes hi uh Dr brussa um in regards to funding for Community um Community
046funded districts like St Louis Coastal do you expect any notable changes um you know particularly in regards to things like transitional kindergarten or other programs that have been really big topics over the last six months sure good question um I understand that there are multiple Community funded districts that are lobbying with the state right now to have some of the the funding that the the lcff districts or the the revenue based districts are receiving this is a hard year for that ask with the state um but I know it is being asked I know it is on Senator Le's agenda um we've discussed it I'm not getting any any indication that that will come forward but I know it is one of the agenda items that's out there because you you similar to if you
047take our Revenue limit or or lcff districts that have different levels of funding the same thing for for you all you don't receive funding per student across the board only for certain programs like title one and and and other things or Lottery where you'll you'll get those fundings um so I wait and see on that one I I don't see that occurring in this year's budget unless some magic happens between now and the May Revis I mean Ryan you want to add any more to that that's sort of my read of the tea leaves there yeah I know there's a fiscal update coming up in my office on Friday um I didn't get any indication from the governor's office on that and with the the expenditures on the fires I'm I'm hopeful that we're going
048to be able to hold status quo on state allocations to schools we may even see some revisions in the other Direction okay thank you Dr BR thank you thank you have lead uh next we have item 6.01 correspondence and at the time the agenda was published no official correspondence had been received 6.02 is public comment and I have something I'd like to read thank you to all members of the public who are here tonight to listen to and or participate in our board meeting the board has a number of important matters on our agenda tonight that we need to discuss based on the large number of public comments we received for tonight's board meeting it is clear that we need to hear from the public and our community on these important issues as well I
049I want to welcome you all and thank you for sharing your voice our board has always prioritized receiving feedback ideas and opinions so we can make more informed decisions as we have done in the past when we receive a large number of public comments and correspondents I want the board to consider how we can hear the Public's thoughts wisely and efficiently I want us to hear from the public but also make sure we end our meeting tonight at a reasonable time so that we are not making any midnight decisions when the public is asleep I propose to the board that we act consistent with what is listed on the agenda and board bylaw 9323 that we have the initial time for public comment be reserved for individuals to address the board on non agenda items
050and then we ask that the public give their comment about specific agenda items when that item comes before the board also consistent with the agenda and board byw 9323 I suggest we limit the initial time for public comment on non-agenda items to 20 minutes and then provide one hour of public comment for each agenda item I need consensus from the board for these suggestions yes yeah Mrs Balo yes okay thank you with that consensus for those of you who are planning to speak please make your comments brief so that we can hear from as many members of the public as possible within the 20 minute time limit I'm also asking that you not repeat the comments of those speakers who came before you if you are going to make the same comments I ask that
051you merely indicate your agreement with the previous speaker or speakers and not restate what we've already heard so that we will be able to hear from others who wish to address the board additionally for those who have submitted written comment before the board meeting you may have noted that the agenda states that we will hear public comment in the order of in-person comments then virtual comments and then written comments if we do not get to your written communication it will be entered into the record and included in the board agenda packet for tonight's meeting depending on the communication it will be in the packet as either correspondence consistent with board policy uh 1100 or as public comment more details are listed on the agenda we are a board that Prides ourselves on reading all comments
052and correspondents sent to us we did it during Co and I expect we will do the same for tonight's meeting and I thank you all for your cooperation in advance so which is to say that all of the written corespondence that has been received by the district um as of uh 4 o' that was I think 206 letters were we to read those tonight that would be well upwards of 7 hours of reading correspondence before we got to the board's business so we will all be receiving those letters you know the packet in its entirety and you may be assured that all of the board members will be reviewing them and um and considering the positions that people have stated hey so what I have done as as uh you the form States I went
053ahead and pulled out those that said for the listed agenda item I prefer to speak during the public comment period so the others at this time will remain to address during that agenda topic when we've reach that number so I'm going to read out uh a few names and if you could approach and then we'll know when that we'll be I'll be informed when we've reached our 20 minutes so we we'll be able to get some Headway here so I have uh Fiona Lloyd mofet followed by Amanda Alexander followed by Emily calano they gonna help us I'm good oh okay well it is but it says I prefer to speak during the public comment period so the general the General Public comment period would you prefer to wait and you are okay then is Amanda
054Alexander wanting to speak now okay we'll do it we'll do it this way and Emily you'll wait uh Julie Dodson Kristen Eldridge Kayla Townson okay so uh is there anyone who would like to address the board at this time during the general public comment period anyone who's present okay um uh did you fill out forms y okay so they're in here somewhere but I didn't reach those because it wasn't at this time okay um Mr low okay you ready yep we're good uh on July 1st in 24 a letter was sent from the district office to dozens of teachers at Laguna Middle School informing them of my wife's request for copies of their contracts the letters indicated that Dr jacqulyn low was seeking records regarding their employment with the district it goes on to propose
055an option for teachers to obtain a court issued protective order to preclude their contract from being disclosed it concludes with bold underlined font stating if you have any questions about your legal rights You may wish to seek immediate legal counsel if you have legal representation please immediately forward this letter to your attorney as this information is times sensitive a copy of that letter has just been provided to you this unnecessary letter with this alarming rhetoric went to five of my son's six teachers we pleaded with Dr puchia uh that this approach was actually a violation of the California public records act because the CPR explicitly states that contracts for public officials are non-exempt from disclosure meaning that there is no option under the law to withhold public officials contract for employment as a result we
056filed a petition to the court for rid of mandate demanding the disclosure of these records our position regarding the letter that went out to staff was ultimately adjudicated in the ruling to dismiss our petition and is the reason why we were not required by the court to pay the district's attorney fees you could see this in the last two paragraphs on the last page of the packet when trying to resolve this matter uh we were told by uh with with attorney Joshua Whiteside with Lozano Smith we requested four items from the district which were provide the documents we requested provide education to staff regarding proper administration of public records we also asked for an apology and to help with our son's teacher uh clarify confusion with our son's teachers and uh to pay our $435
057petition fee we eventually got the documents the judges ruling states that the letter wasn't legally required and I'm sure the district paid far more than $435 in legal fees this means that all the district achieved in court was the right to not have to render an apology nor clarify the confusion with our son's teachers frankly I find the need to defend the egos of District officials unnecessary and kind of embarrassing I also find it ironic that the district went to such lengths to conceal public employees contracts but didn't take care um to conceal my wife's identity with our son's teachers it seemed that to us that the district took exception to us requesting public records for the purpose of filing complaints against the district I want to share with the board that we should not
058be viewing the complaint process as contentious in fact it is simply the only process available to members of the public to hold their public agency accountable and the very reason why the public records act exists thank you go ahead okay uh good evening my name is Dr Jacqueline low and I'm here tonight to request that the board prioritize an open discussion about how the district engages with the community since it is clear that I am not allowed to participate in the parent task force that I advocated for over a year ago I am requesting that the board provide the community with opportunities to speak about our experiences I'm grateful for the forums that are being provided this week and I invite a similar Forum that allows the community access to the board Dr pooia and
059Mandy Dawson significantly hurt my family and my son's experience at lagon at the start of this school year I had to take the district through a legal process because Mandy Dawson and Dr puchia unnecessarily exploited a simple public records request for non-exempt public records further when I requested that they repair the harm they caused they refused I bore the costs of time and my own Financial Resources in order to bring evidence to this board that the district leaders are using public funds to pay for legal fees in order to block and dissuade the community's right to scrutinize how this organization is being operated this board must act on District leaders waste of public funds to hurt the community because they refuse to be accountable for the way they operate the school district as well as
060the blatant waste of public funds to violate the public civil right to access public information without procedural DeLay So as you hear the pleas of parents and families about the importance of transitional kindergarten programs and hear from our teachers as they advocate for their needs remember that your leaders continue to waste hundreds of thousands of dollars to pay for lawyers to clean up the mistakes of Dr Prader and his cabinet this District administration must learn to work with all parents and to meet the needs of the community as we express them and if these leaders can't get it together then it is the board's responsibility to protect the interests of our community I am requesting again that Dr puchia send communication to my son's teachers that I was not infringing on their privacy and that
061they exaggerated a public records request that did not violate their rights I am not an adversarial parent and I am requesting that the board requires the HR department to repair the harm they caused to my son at lagona middle school with five of his six teachers he has this year thank you is there anyone else who would like to address the board at this point anyone on on Zoom who would like to address the the board now I would like to make public comment on the non-agenda item okay are we are we ready back there okay could you state your name please and sure my name is Elizabeth Coleman I'm one of the parents in the TK class I understand this is non- aggenda public comment I just want to comment on the procedural decision
062to hear an item where over 300 people have logged in No Doubt with serious interest in this question to compress commentary down to 1 hour um I did submit a written comment but on such an important matter that is a matter of both equity and education I would urge the board to reconsider that decision and agendize this for a longer time where they can excuse me address the matter more completely thank you it's if there's any if there is anyone else on Zoom who would like to address the board please use the raise your hand icon anyone else um I have my hand raised okay um good okay hello U my name is Caroline K I'm a teacher at lososo middle school as well as the Secretary of St Louis Coastal Teachers Association I'm speaking
063today to express how disheartened I was after the December 17th board meeting when many of your employees spoke about the untenable demand placed on them due to increasing needs for our students in special education after they left one board member and two cabinet members made snide comments about them leaving four separate Educators who stayed or watched the video later have spoken to me about how disappointing these comments were and how hurtful they were these comments were made after these Educators waited two full hours to speak to their elected board members in case it wasn't abundantly clear they had many other things to do that evening it was not their job to be there they came to explain to the board and cabinet just how much is being asked of them and how much it has
064changed in recent years one Cabinet member referred to their comments as complaints I was shocked and dismayed by this if you think it's complaining when special Educators tell you what their workload is maybe that's the point because what they're describing is simply too much after hearing your responses throughout the rest of the meeting I can't help but wonder if this is how you talk about your employees in public how do you talk about us in private thank you Julian metf hey good evening my name is Julian metf I'm a parent of two students in the district I do not have a student eligible for TK but I just learned about the news today and I want to express my concern um learning about this issue just now it's my understanding the district has been spending
065money um Bond money obviously not from operating funds preparing for um TK students and it seems like there might be a shortsighted uh planning in some of this and anticipating some of the long-term needs um I appreciate your consideration I realize the budget from the state is very difficult to manage and some of these decisions are outside of the district's control but nonetheless this is not new information and I'm surprised this is being discuss now thank you for your time thank you uh coren Colin and please excuse me if I miss pronounce any names hi uh my name is Karine colon I am a educator locally as well as a parent of the St Louis Unified School District I'm here tonight to ask the board why you even in education like how can you be
066doing this how can you even be considering taking the TK away this is just to even suggest removing the TK K is like suggesting removing sixth grade it just seems so unreasonable TK is where students start to learn start to form their social relationships and I just feel that it's so important I have a son who missed out on TK and I have seen the firsthand effects of having a child miss out on TK and you know it's probably going to affect him his entire life as well as many other students in his position so please adhere to your public position and fiscal respons responsibility and provide TK to the children of this District thank you is there I don't see any other hands up on Zoom so we at this time we'll come back
067for public comment uh throughout the meeting as we address agenda items the next item is item 7.01 business and budget updates Mr Pinkerton you for the board sake in light of the uh we're gonna have a fiscal update tonight I'd like to just defer any comments about the budget to that to that uh that board agend item okay thank you then the following item 7.02 educational services update M good evening board and Community um we have kicked off this new 2025 year in a busy fashion in the educational services department just today I had the opportunity to be at Laguna middle school with slow High staff uh and also Mrs badano um with our leading Equitable schools teams um speaking with students and looking taking a culture walk around the school also last week I
068had the opportunity to collaborate with other District Partners um at the San lispo County Office of education's Educational Service Council and there we were talking about learning more about the new math framework that has been adopted by the state of California and making plans for implementation in our school district as well as the reading risk screener assessment that is going to be required of all kindergarten first and second graders next school year um had the opportunity to do a couple of School site visits throughout our school district as well as we attended um led a few principal meetings our elementary principles met today secondary principles met last week and then we also had a collective joint principal meeting just yesterday and collaborated on a couple occasions with our foundation slcf Foundation board um on upcoming
069projects for the New Year as well as I wanted to highlight and celebrate our school and school district is getting ready to celebrate Martin Luther King Day next Monday students aren't in school but all of our students and um have opportunities to learn about the great legacy and work of Dr Martin Luther King Jr and the Civil Rights Movement thank you hey Mr Pinkerton you're up next with the measure C update yeah so um in terms of measure C again Bond projects uh going right now at um several of our school sites I'm happy to say that we finally got Los Ranchos out of DSA that right now is in the bidding process we'll be taking bringing that to the board very soon to begin construction there um Hawthorne just kicked off cimer um kicked
070off uh we have some schematic designs for uh Baywood Elementary School that we'll be sharing with um the public public with the the staff very soon as well as the board and um most likely looking at moving our next study session maybe to Bishop Peak to see that construction there so the board can get a a visual on some of the projects that are happening right now um again we're difficulties in terms of getting things through DSA from the structural standpoint uh more so than ever before but um have been working with kind of the DSA leads to to make some adjustments with some of the people they have working on our on our school sites um as long as with our Architects um we expect uh Pacific Beach to come out next month and
071get that project kicked off um as well as Pacho so hope hopefully that those are you know kicking in so again it's just nice to see uh and for the public to see some of those Bond projects kicked off moving and and uh and looking forward to you know having construction at all of our sites uh the elementary middle schools and as well as PP okay thank you the next item item is item 8.01 it's a public hearing the uh regarding initial proposals for slct and SEIU negotiations good evening can you guys uh pop that on the agenda good evening the St Louis unified uh Stan Louis Coastal Unified School District Board of Education slct and seiu's initial proposals for negotiations are being presented in accordance with government code section 47 this public hearing provides
072the opportunity for public comment on those proposals and just for for The public's information item 10.4 actually holds those uh those documents and the initial proposals from the district and our bargaining partners and the last piece of information is to share uh ca's um proposals are forthcoming okay thank you then uh with that I'll open the public hearing is there anyone who wishes to speak to this anyone on Zoom okay seeing no one then I'll close the public hearing and we'll move on to item 9.01 which is a resolution resolution number 16- 24-25 authorizing the filing of applications for State allocation board administered programs yeah so the next two resolutions uh that we're asking the board to approve tonight basically um are two new steps that uh that have been put in by the office
073of public school construction that we have to have a facility master plan uh in place in order to go after both state matching funds um you know any basic state match construction mization funds um and so that is what this first resolution is asking the board to do it's basically letting uh opsc know that we do have a master plan in place and that when we do move forward um to apply for these funds uh again we've got 349 million in bond funds coming to the school district over the next six seven years we hope to turn that into another hundred hundred million maybe $450 Million by the time we're done um by obtaining as much matching uh grants as we can so um again tonight asking the board to approve this first resolution tion
074which is basically stating that we have a facil master plan in place and that we will provide it when we apply for those funds okay thank you um this resolution I'm seeking a motion in a second oh I beg your pardon is there anyone in the public that would like to comment on this item seeing no one is there anyone on Zoom okay then I'll bring it back to the board and I'm now seeking a motion in a second I move approval of resolution number 162 2425 authorized filing applications for State allocation board administered programs I'll second it okay I have a a motion by Mr anger a second by Mr Banfield um this is a roll call vote Mr anger yes Mr Banfield yes Mrs balad Dono yes Mrs Sheffer Mr Buckman Mr Clawson
075yes okay that passes unanimously so the next resolution is kind of along the same lines it's the same exact um same exact requirements that opsc is asking us for um and this would be if the districts move forward with the need for any facility hardship grants or Hazard mitigation seismic mitigation programs um at the current time we don't foresee that but just in case something were to happen we want to be make sure that we have this resolution in place to go after any funds that the state may have uh should they be needed okay thank you I'll go to the public is there anyone who wishes to speak to this resolution okay seeing no one is there anyone on Zoom no okay then bring I'll bring back to the board if there's no board
076discussion then I am seeking a motion in a second Mr Banfield I'll move that we authorize resolution 17-24 d25 thank you thank you then I have a motion by Mr Banfield second by Mr Buckman this is a roll call vote Mr Banfield yes Mr Buckman Mr Clawson yes Mrs Sheffer yes Mr rer yes Mrs badano yes thank you that passes unanimously so we'll move to item 10.01 which is an action discussion item uh California's accountability system the school dashboard update State indicators Mrs Yay good evening um again board and community members I am here with Miss Sheffer and Mr nef um to speak with you about the outstanding performance performance of our students on the California state assessment system um and the dashboard is the way that our state compiles the information and Compares schools
077and school districts and their performance across the state um as I stated it's a datadriven approach to give a big picture view of how School District programs um are doing and to communicate to Educators and their parents um things like graduation rates and other measures of Student Success it also allows us to identify areas of strength or schools that are particularly excelling in one thing and copy those and replicate those items across other schools in our district and it also lets us Peak into student groups or certain areas of our performance that are weaker relatively than others and allows us to work together to design changes and tweaks and programming and Staffing to support our students and staff we the dashboard indicators include State indicators and there are seven of those that are all the
078same across schools academic performance which is English language arts mathematics and science are the three three test areas on the state assessment right now there's a discussions about attent adding nonsocial studies at a later time but that is not assessed at the state level we also measure chronic absenteeism English learner progress High School graduation rates suspension rates College and Career Readiness and I already mentioned science and schools and districts overall get five levels of status red is uh oh problems take a look at this and figure out what's going on and how to make changes all the way up to Blue which is like very high excelling whoop woop everything's going in the right direction um this is also kind of compiling two years of data it's your current status how your students are currently
079performing combined with the progress or lack thereof they're making so it's not just how your students are doing this year on any one measure but instead how are they doing relative to last year did they improve or are they struggling more than the year before come up okay was that good evening board I'm Stephanie Shepard director of Elementary here in St Louis Coastal um I'm going to review a few of the measures and then I'll hand it over to Mr nef who's our secondary director so in terms of our academic performance measures we have conducted already in the fall a presentation around Casp our California assessment of student progress and performance and that is what the state then utilizes as Mrs yamasa said to take 2024 as well as a comparison to 2023 to then
080determine where do we fall on a 5x5 grid that is colorcoded as she explained also included in this score report or status report that we have given to us is the California alternative assessment a final piece that um we are weighed on is our participation rate and I'm really excited to share that through the work of our teachers and our principles we met our 95% participation rate for 2024 so we are looking very healthy thank you we are looking healthy as you can see and in the green in both English language arts as well as mathematics the way that we um are calculating this or the state is calculating this is looking at our distance from standards and that is then turned into a point conversion and so you can see the summary is that
081within Ela on the left hand side we increase 3.8 points and then as we look over at mathematics we maintained although we have that 1.9 points I will be sharing uh with as long along with Mr nef and Mrs yamasa in our um Friday notes I'll be sharing all of the 5 by5 grids that show you exactly where we fell um across School sites as the district as well as within our subgroups so that you can dive deeper into this data outside of the public um presentation new this year um you'll see more rainbow colors along the bottom there's an equity report and this is very helpful for us because it allows us to take a look at although we are scoring Green in both Ela and math where are we falling within each of
082our subgroups so for example you'll see the red indicator on both English language arts as well as mathematics we have one subgroup that is falling into that red category for both of those um performance indicators it is our ltels our long-term English learners that are falling into that red group so again I'll share more in the Friday notes along with my colleagues a second indicator is our English learner progress measure this particular measure is um only it's the only measure that only looks at one subgroup and so it's looking at our progress of our English Learners through our elpac assessment again we have a celebration here because in comparison to uh last year's performance we're seeing that increase of 3.6% proficiency we have one group in the blue and those are our ltels so although
083they're scoring and showing up in the red on the previous slides here we are celebrating the fact that within the elpac in terms of their language English English language acquisition they're actually making significant progress and chronic absenteeism is another measure this is something that we dove into um as a leadership group very heavily last year and we were able to see the benefit um and this is one in which it's a little backwards because of course we don't want to see an increase in chronic absenteeism we actually want to see this measure Decline and we did we saw that 6.9% decrease which is a big celebration and reflective of the work that's being done at our school sites and here's Mr n thank you Miss Shephard board members community members I'm Dan NE and secondary
084director so I get to share a little bit about some of the secondary things one of which would be the graduation rate so that's an important metric we use for our high schools um i' say pretty self-explanatory there's a little caveat that can conclude uh students that finish in their fifth year not not very many but it does include um that part that metric so as we look at it great news uh we increased 1.9 almost 2% this year or sorry for 24 at a little over 96% graduation rate which is very high we're in the blue as Miss uh imas explained earlier that's where you want to be right so doing good there uh and an increase from we were actually in yellow last year at 94.4 so we both moved in percentage and
085in our indicator color dial thing um as well so good celebration there and then looking at our subgroups some work to do one in the orange but majority of our groups are in green and blue so it's great news there suspension rate is I would say probably self-explanatory as well students are suspended with a caveat for one full day or more um sometimes students are suspended for maybe a part of a day uh but this is measuring those one full day or more and so this would one um like with chronic adism we actually want to see a decline most of these indicators you want to see an increase right this one we want to see down and that's what we saw a little bit so we declined uh almost a percent from last year
086and we are in the green uh so obviously still work to do and those things we are addressing very much in our mtss our proba behavior intervention systems and work that we're doing in our Equity work um at our schools but we are seeing that work started last year you know was happening last year as well but seeing uh growth there as well so that's a good thing College and Career Readiness is a great indicator looking kind of overall how are we preparing kids for their post-secondary lives the caveat is it's complicated and so that some of that will be in this Friday focus in the L links are in there there's a number of criteria it's not just one thing uh that it's measured it's multiple things so you can have if you pass
087a certain number of AP tests if you get passing scores on your C test if you take um certain number of semesters of college courses if your a through G which is when I presented that in the fall is maining eligibility to apply to a university that plus one or more of other things so there's this kind of um rubric in a sense of that they used to calculate it but overall what we're seeing they have maintaining a little bit of an increase um and that and you can see we you know obviously still work to do and and how we're providing options and helping support kids be ready uh postsecondary is is a big part of our work at the high school level but even at the middle school level as well um and
088so we're in the green which is great but you know we always have work to do to improve that and better prepare kids um in what we're offering and supporting them being successful and those CT Pathways AP courses and the cast exams um lots of different I said kind of metrics built into this uh particular indicator um so overall doing well but we have work to do uh to continue to support our subgroups as well as overall get into that blue right that's where we're shooting get into that blue science science has been part of the cash test for a while now the data has not really shown up and so this year the data sort of showed up in that there is not a performance code this year or 2024 I should say so
089I guess last year uh is a baseline here and so there isn't a you score low high low whatever sort of thing it's a baseline year for everybody we can see where we're at in terms of kind of um pointwise and then in terms of State overall and so we we have some work to do but there is um not an association with a particular level or color that will come next year and so science kind of what we've seen with English language arts of mathematics for the last several years now science coming on board with that of starting you have a Baseline and then each year on out they'll do comparison uh so we'll see that in a year from now when we report on our 2025 C data science will be then part
090of that dashboard indicator um but for now it's just the Baseline here for everybody so there is no color or indication with that so in conclusion um I I am here to celebrate the excellent work of our students and staff and the the um additional staff and programs that we have put in place in San Louis Coastal definitely are helping students achieve more than ever before and get back to post-pandemic numbers and none of the school districts around us in this County's dashboard looks any anything like ours um and so I want you to take away from this perform this presentation tonight as far as academic indication goes we maintain very high levels of performance in ela and math don't get me wrong our work is not done and we're not going to leave any
091students behind in our tracks but overall it's looking very good we did a great job significantly reducing chronic absenteeism again we're not quite back to pre pandemic rates chronic absenteeism but we are significantly better than the rest of the nation at large and doing very well um working with families and connecting with students to come regularly to school our English learner progress also has moved all the way from low up to high as you know with the implementation of our Benchmark curriculum and the designated ELD portion of that reading language arts curriculum we believe is making an impact and difference last school school year just during the pilot as well as at our two DLI schools which had started Benchmark a year before so we find that to be very promising our graduation rates increased
092and again that's much to celebrate our suspension rates which we know that when students get suspended they can feel like they don't belong and school is not the place for them and then are more likely to reoffend or not be able to engage academically and we are pleased to report report that we are reducing the number of suspensions there are certain groups of students like students with disabilities that are still being suspended at higher rates than we would want them to be and we are going to continue to work with our special Educators as well as our general Educators and school leaders on how we can help support those students with disabilities to make choices that are more in line with school expectations and finally our College and Career um performance is very high if
093you would like I invite all of the community members as well to dig into our dashboard data in more depth this was very high level all levels but there's lots of interesting information there and these are some of the resources you can use hey thank you uh comments from board members Mr Buckman followed by Mr Banfield I do have a question um and I just want to point out that Lisa and I spoke for 15 20 minutes today so I have one question as opposed to all the ones I started the day with um first of all I want to congratulate the administration but I also want to congratulate all the teachers all these numbers are looking just great and it's it's always good to be come to a board meeting and see that so
094my my question that was most pressing this morning was this is great chronic absenteeism K8 but where's The Chronic absenteeism data for 9 through2 and I thought the answer was important enough to have it shared here yeah let me explain so as I understand it and as I said the state of California on the school B dashboard does not include chronic absenteeism for our high schoolers because High School attendance is kept a little bit differently period attendance also some high schoolers finish early and some schools across our state will allow students who have met minimum requirements to not be enrolled in a full schedule of courses because they may be dual enrolled in other colleges Etc so they would look true and but really they're seeking education in other places and so the state decided
095that a better indicator of student engagement at the high school level is related to graduation and how many students get across the finish line not how many students come to school each day okay but what I thought was most interesting is while the district could could get by on that and the graduation rate you want to share what you shared with me because I well we have been working very hard alongside our two high schools and have included them in our work on reducing chronic absenteeism with our principles with Mr Dowler and SAR board meetings as well as communicating and developing tools and resources for families to get our high schoolers to school and what I had shared specifically um with Mr Buckman was that when for example moral Bay was digging into their chronic
096absenteeism information they quickly discovered a habit or pattern of students with disabilities being absent more than other student groups in their school and so they started to create specific systems through their site Equity challenge work um that we're doing with inclusion and belonging 2011 and 101 to develop specific systems and supports to address those needs of those students with disabilities who may be more likely to not be attending school so while the state is not actually keeping um record of the high school chronic absenteeism we are still monitoring it by student group at our high schools and you get monthly updates as well in the Friday Focus so thank you very much thanks to all the teachers as well Mr bfield what combination of things do you think has brought about that 0.8% decrease in
097suspensions oh man I wish um Mrs gold is here because her her group and the work of um you know it it takes a village to make a change like that and primarily it starts at the beginning of the story where students need to understand what are appropriate and and expected behaviors at schools and that is done through our tier one work that we are trying to refine across all classrooms and that involves counselors and administrators going into classrooms and helping teachers and students understand what kind of behavior is most um conducive to learning in school then we also have secondary tier 2 systems in support of students who maybe make mistakes or behavioral challenges and they meet with counselors they can meet with administrators we have referral meetings with care teams Etc that can
098help work together and make plans to help students succeed I think also helping educate our Educators about alternative means of Corrections and traditionally in schools often times it was thought that if a student did something that was outside the bounds or disrupted the learning environment they were kicked out of that learning en environment but instead we're trying to refocus on repair and reteaching skills and alternative behaviors so that those students can still learn and kind of make amends for whatever damage to the learning environment has happened but they still have an opportunity then to re-engage in a more positive frame I think those are some of the things and as well as we have particularly also focused on communic ating more effectively to families about the importance of coming to school and if their or
099their children are experiencing barriers to coming to school we want to know about it and become their partner in solving the barriers and those problems and um we have a lot of tools in our toolbx when we know that a problem is happening Mrs Bal thank you uh thank you for the presentation tonight there's definitely a lot to celebrate um I I do encourage folks to you know go online and dig into the details it's actually very interesting and I appreciate that the details in those individual Equity reports that we see for each indicator um will be included in the Friday Focus um and so I I just want to know um when you drill down into the details of the data particularly in that Equity report does that then guide your direction or your
100interventions or can you just speak to that please yes of course we and our team with the principles dig down into those Equity reports and look at at areas um of challenge that are presented and then collaboratively come up with Solutions or systems to provide extra assistance so for example one of our elementary schools was a red indicator last school year um and in specifically their eels not achieving and passing at the elpac like we wanted them to and so as a school and cabinet team we were able to put our heads together provided additional Staffing at that elementary school that we also redid the way assessments were being done at that school we also looked into how parental notification was being done at that school and I'm happy to report that that school now
101has shifted all the way to green and they made huge growth and strides in one day one we year however we had an another Elementary School Now flip and land in the red exactly for El's the good news is we have a system in place that already worked at another school and those supports um so we do drill down into the data to look for student groups or schools that need specific help and support and then make sure resources are directed there thank you uh is there any additional comment Mr hunger yeah I I also took a look at the individual school reports and overall our schools are doing a great job and uh mostly blues and greens the few yellows and orange occasionally um and we actually have a couple of schools that were
102blue and green all the way and I think those schools are to be congratulated so everybody I think is working hard and looking at the data um and taking into account the needs of our students so I I want to congratulate all of all of our school sites and all of our school staffs for the hard work that they're doing and the parents too for supporting our kids at home thank you uh I neglected to go to the public is there anyone from the public that would like to speak to this item uh yes i' like to speak okay we'll take uh the public that's present in the room before Zoom so I see please come forward oh you need to come to the microphone please and thank you I know all official I'm just
103curious if we're cutting funding for the par Educators and for their support staff how we are going to be working with these like chronic um absentee issues and then also the special um I think you said the disabled students who are chronic offenders if we're taking away all the resources from those classes in this big budget cut like do we have a plan for those those students yeah we I'm sorry the board cannot respond we can we can take your comment and hear you I if Mrs Yas should has an answer out the ready Dr Prader I just think this is like something a lot of the parents are very concerned about taking away we you know res tonight I appreciate the question it's been in what you're what you're asking has been something we've
104been wrestling with for a long time and it's and it's part of this process that we're we haven't gotten through yet tonight we're just talking about where we're at in our fiscal update and potential reductions I I'm sorry I don't know your name uh Jerry Al Sydney Jerry Jerry Al Jerelle Jerry Al from my perspective the question about how we're going to structure our interventions how we're going to help the kids that all is part of that spring process once we once we determine how our budget's going to land then we back backward in our supports so we will engineer those supports you see it in our dashboard we will figure out a way to do it and we don't even know what those reductions are going to look like yet so it's premature I
105can't speculate but what I can't tell you is we'll find a way to do it it seems though that this year before we've had these large budget cuts the special education has suffered dramatically with increased class sizes with reduction in teachers with ruction we can't engage in yeah this'll evening yeah it's not a town hall meeting I have lots I could say to that but that's not what tonight is yeah I don't mind being is is there anyone else uh present who would who would like to speak on this subject okay yeah we'll get to zoom I'm just checking in the room okay if you would come forward please and state your name and then we'll start the start the clock hi my name is Katarina howal um I just wanted to have one comment
106which is that college readiness and all of those things increase when you have TK that's all I'm want to say is there anyone else present in the room yes please come forward and state your name thank you hi my name is Sarah McGrath I have two students in the district um I have a son who uh entered the school system needing a lot of IEP support because he was born with a uh genetic disability when we first had our first IEPs um the team which was only the school people recommended he be in an isolated special day class classrooms that he could learn how to learn um luckily I had a daughter who was already at um our neighborhood School blocks from our house that um had a bilingual program my son already knew English
107and Spanish he already knew how to learn because all four-year-olds are learning how to learn they're all the same at that age because we had um it was at the time it wasn't TK it was preschool um because there was a teacher there who said of course your child belongs here of course he does we started our education Journey um in TK or preschool and my son with a uh speech delay and a lot of speech support needed amongst other things was included in the in the typical population in general education throughout his um time in school he is now taking general education classes um at lagona Middle School um he has par educator support and he has a really bright future because of how his education started even when an administrator came to that
108first teacher and said are you sure you want this child it can they be in your classroom are you prepared and that teacher said yes they belong and it's made an impact on his life our family's life all the students who have been educated with him for the past nine years it's influenced their life as well and I don't know where all the budget things will end up falling um but support for TK support for um special education services they the things that happened early on they they last a lifetime and I just wanted to share a personal story to kind of bring some of it thank you is there anyone else in the room that would like to speak yes please hi my name is Aon chatini I teach fifth grade at Hawthorne Elementary
109I was also a member of the piloting committee last year I heard um some information shared about the success rate of our English Learners and I just want to make sure that we do have all the facts yes The Benchmark program does come with a designated ELD component it's my understanding that aside from our dual mergence schools that designated ELD component was not given to our e resource teachers until January many of our lpac assessments ments are given in the middle of the tri second trimester so we are crediting a program that maybe wasn't entirely responsible for that success what I can tell you is responsible for that success are programs like our academic intervention our social emotional intervention and support for our resource programs many of our English Learners also cross over into needing
110those supports as well and those are three of the things we're talking about cutting so I just want to be mindful about where we are taking things from for our most um gosh sorry um our most disadvantaged students thank you is there anyone else present that would like to speak please good evening superintendent prayer assistant superintendent board members and families in the room my name is Luchia Stone I'm a parent a wife of an educator in a city of San Louis viso local elementary through calp educational preparedness that is your fiscal responsibility as a representative of the public education system tonight's board recommendation is the beginning of San Louis San Louis Coastal unified school districts demise and the detriment of our children you all have a fiscal and moral resp responsibility to provide our kids
111with a quality public education and tonight you're failing us if this is a political Ploy against the state of California to fund TK because we're a basic Aid District please know you're doing so on the backs of local families your neighbors your friends and your family we are already struggling to make our mortgage feed our families and pay our taxes which is your salaries we are not here tonight to hear about why the district has not prepared and planned well enough for TK knowing you've already spent the Esser covid funds on 174 new hires and already spent the funds from $349 million measure C to build brand new TK classrooms but yet you lack the funds for TK for my daughter Sienna and thousands of other children the district has had the time the forest
112side and the Acumen to prepare to fund TK the proposed Savings of $2.8 million next year is detrimental to children your budgeting negligence will cost each household an average of $21,000 a year in child care which is not locally available for the 400 plus stranded TK student you need to re-evaluate each budget item and explore utilizing the $10 million funding at the San Louis Education Foundation TK is the first and most important step to learning superseding other programs you're looking to fund TK gives every student an opportunity for Quality education instead of just those who can afford private school eliminating it is an educational justice issue additionally TK allows districts to discover and address learning disabilities when it is easier to address the problem early on a quality TK thank a quality TK should cut
113remediation costs in the upper grades which you all know all too well Stan Louis Coastal Unified School District is blatantly defying the state's mandate showing a malice disregard for families when eliminating TK we Californians pay for it through the state and receive the service we need it here too we cannot afford your temper tantrum with the state please don't put this on our backs and let our students Thrive thank you okay is there anyone else present okay let me just say that we're talking about the this agenda item we're not talking about the budget item in transitional kindergarten at this time so if you spoke to TK now um please know that you'll not be speaking to it again hi my name is Rita Rodriguez and I'm very proud to say that I'm a teacher
114who was s Louis Coastal I began my career as s Louis Coastal back in 2011 the reason I bring that up is because that year the 2011-2012 I helped open the first preschool here in St Louis Coastal so I was here at the beginning before there was TK there was preschool in the beginning there was approximately three preschools and four TKS from there we expanded to nine the reason I bring that date up and that information up is because on the board dos that I was looking through the slides no data was stated prior to the last couple of years the last few years that there was TK there was preschool data that was left those numbers were not included back in 2012 that impact that those programs made was not included um currently according
115to that information there is 323 students in um our 2K programs next year it's projected to go up to 400 if we look at the numbers in those with those types of eyes we can see that that's basically one Elementary School I believe currently Hawthorne itself has about 422 students so that closing of TK would actually be similar to closing an elementary school I want that to be stated in there um we've also also experienced life without counselors or not enough counselers we also experienced what it was like returning to the classroom with students that did not enter preschool they did not have play dates they did not have TK we're still filling the ramifications of the pandemic to get rid of or underfund those programs is not doing a service to anybody I really
116want to make that point clear also being back in that 2011 I remember many times hearing ELC cap presentations stating that we needed to cut preschool that's one of the reasons why I left the preschool classroom I was afraid now I'm afraid that if we let go so many new teachers so many counselors we're going to end up with a really sad District thank you is there anyone else present yes please hi my name is Rod gothro um I have a question regarding the suspensions um I it's may be an unpopular opinion but I'm just wondering I appreciate the fact that we're trying to establish good behaviors but what are we doing to those disruptive behaviors that are forced to stay in the classroom what about the other kids that are eager and wanting to
117learn so now they're having to stop learning in order to address this bad behavior um when I think it's just a matter of having the stats looking good that the suspensions are going down um but at what expense to the rest of the kids thank you thank is is there anyone else yes please my name is cie Walter um I work in the wellness center at St Louis High School um and mine is about the suspension rate but at the high school level um we have a point or an .9 decrease in suspension at St Louis high school and um I think it's important to note that um suspension decreas is directly correlated to well um appropriate Wellness in our use so that funding there is really important thank you is there anyone else who
118would like to speak okay then on Zoom we have um Carol caboom yes hi um I do want to I have a student in um a parent participation preschool at the moment and we're looking forward to being able to have him um attend TK uh we were pretty shocked to see that this is on the cutting block um specifically after your message about having good metrics good metrics don't just materialize out of the nir um especially with your hoo-ha about uh absenteeism being down for K through well I feel like not having TK preparing these young kids to be in school be happy to learn um that's going to I think greatly impact your absenteeism so I think while we want to congratulate our teachers and our schools for bringing that metric down I do
119want to say how do you plan on maintaining that metric in a positive trend when you take away such a resource that can correlate directly to seeing success for these kids um also um I do want to say that trying to limit people uh talking about TK and then saying you can't speak about this later on is in bad faith I do think that this comment that I'm making right now is about the metrics the success rates um the budget issue I think is still a valid issue that parents should be able to also address um so while I think comments about why TK is so important for our educational metrics we also should have a say about why it should be prioritized in our budget so I think again limiting parents from being able
120to speak on those two matters even though they share a commonality is in bad faith and that's it anyone else on Zoom okay thank you Okay then if there's no additional comment in the room or on Zoom we'll move to the next agenda item which is 10 point there there is a hand raised I beg your pardon sounds like we have one more hand raised one more on Zoom oh yeah with one comment I was going to see how the this is like the okay we're ready your the clock is running this should be quick but I did just want to say that while the 9 through 12 chronic absenteeism is not available on the California dashboard it is reported and collected and available via data Quest um so it is out there and available
121if anybody was interested in looking at it it definitely has nuanced variables that were mentioned um but it is available if anybody was interested thank you if there's no one else then we're moving on to item 10.02 the fiscal update and programmatic impacts Mr Pinkerton yes so thank you for having me tonight and uh I have a few slides I'm going to share in this presentation we have Mr yashida who's going to share a few slides and Dr Pia who will also share some slides um the fact that people are here to hear kind of you know the information tonight so that they can again understand kind of where we're at as the school district where we're headed um and again we for everyone to know we we also again Dr Prader will share at
122the very end we have a couple public forums coming up for people to share their thoughts and that kind of go more in depth um tomorrow night as well as the following Wednesday as well um so without any further I'll get started on this the presentation itself so this is um the purpose of this presentation and I told the board about this that we'd be coming back to you um when we did our first inter budget presentation back in December so December 17th we did first interim I shared with the board our 10-year budget um which basically outlined that we had overs spent last year by $7 million and we're projected to overspend this year by five and that we have a structural deficit ongoing that we have to do something about um I wanted
123to wait until the governor came out with his budget summary which happened last week um so that we could share that information and then we would start to dig in um and start to look at first of all why why are we even having this conversation today as well as what are some of the items um that the board will have to wrestle with um as we try to cure the structural deficit um in terms of ongoing um so again from the governor's budget update and for the people in the audience we're we are a community funded District so we are it's called a basic Aid School District so basically our property taxes fund our students um other districts around us that are state funded you can look at it as a jar of water
124or a glass of water right the property taxes fill it up about three quarters and then the state fills the rest of the the glass um for us as a basic G School District in Stan Louis Coastal our glass is full because of our property taxes and maybe even a little over we get a little extra because of it there are some basic Aid Community funded districts that have three glasses of water filled with property taxes so that's part of the issue when we ask the state for funding or we go after funding um they oftentimes don't want to you know hey you're funded enough you have enough money as a basic Aid School District not realizing that there are very different um levels of of being in community funded status there's a paloalto or
125Carl and then there's s Louis Coastal um so just good information to know and to to have right as we as we have these conversations um again key takeaways from from the governor's budget you know hearing Dr brussa thinking about the fires in Los Angeles it does concern me that's maybe some of the one-time dollars different things that uh the governor had kind of planned uh potentially for this first budget um may go away because of what's Happening um as well as again uh for for everyone to know our our budget and the state budget is really based on um property values as well as how the stock market goes right people's paying taxes and so um it's an interesting Dynamic for California in terms of how how that funding um um happens but again
126a couple of programs that the governor has focused on um one is to continue the expanded learning opportunities program or ELO funding um this is dollars that are required to be spent on extending the school day for our English Learners our economic disadvantage and our youth as well as adding 30 days to the school year so that's what elope funds do it's what they that we require to be spent on um so for us in San Louis Coastal we have been doing that we have free child care before and after school for those groups that I described as well as we have our summer experience program for students that give them that extra 30 days of education so it's good right those are dollars that are are are given to school districts outside of the
127local control funding formula so we actually receive those as a basic Aid School District um and those have been great programs for us summer experience we have as the board knows you thousands of kids have benefited from that program um as well as of course helping those parents with before and after school care in a place for kids to go uh is is incredible um also along with that the governor is focused on continuing free meals for all uh so that is something again with our food service department has been huge right in terms of being able to offer free meals to all students both breakfast and lunch um and even after school meals at some of our schools that have higher rates of economic disadvantaged students uh so those are those are great things
128um 2.43 cost of living adjustments State program so we do receive some um money from the state outside of that that student funding such as special education funds up for everyone to know in the room that we have a what's called a maintenance of effort for special ed so we cannot spend less dollars on an annual basis on special education so we we we can't cut the presentation we'll talk to you tonight is about we have such a huge growth in the number of special ed students and the number of Staff we were hiring that that's having an impact on our budget so it's not cutting back it's h h it's looking at this the system itself and and process for that right so it's I think there's an important understanding so anybody who's special
129ed parent we won't be cutting special ed staff right we can't it's part of the maintenance of effort that we have to we have to abide by um so there there was uh one other cave there's lots of other things in the budget you can go on the link it's the governor's summary that lists everything um in terms of Education wise he did describe a little bit of uh some potential one-time um funds which would be great right again we're not going to receive 1.8 billion that is for every student in the state of California so we don't I have a budget um update tomorrow webinar I'll be attending to kind of see so how much money does that mean potential for S L Coastal right um and so hey again it's one-time funds so
130one-time funds help for a little bit but they don't um they're not ongoing right so it may soften a budget well for a year um but but isn't going to help you long term um so those are again just the key takeaways from the governor's budget so really not a lot there right um in terms of uh s Louis Coastal and just for everyone's edification right to know so we we received a large amount of onetime funds for covid um and that was because our kids were struggling after covid our teachers were struggling right so to get back into to school to get kids online to um you know from computers I mean just when they were home versus coming back to school so um we spent we we have been and the board allocated
131a plan it's public it's on the board agenda we've been following that plan over the past um five years right uh to provide those extra supports for kids to get them back back on track um and it's nice to see that in both our academic as well as our our student data right from our surveys and things like that that we're seeing growth in those areas um based on all those things that we put in place so those are wonderful things we wish we could continue them forever and grow them and expand them it'd be great right um but a lot of those unfortunately are onetime funds um but again back to our expenditures we are a people organization so most of our budget is people so when we talk about making budget reductions I
132don't just cut outside the class don't cut people cut contracts but but 88% right now 87.8% of our budget is people right so yes we are looking at non-personnel reductions and we will be cutting some of those back but the reality is if 88% of your budget is people then like 88% of the cut should probably be people right long term um in order to cure that structural deficit so those are the tough things um to the board has to make again you see certificated salaries classified salaries statutory benefits which include um and you'll see a slide later about the the cost of retirement benefits Health Care um Social Security all those things right workers compensation F all of those go into the benefits part um again benefits now the cost of benefits for the
133school district is more than we spend in certificated Sal or classified salaries that's how how much that that amount has grown over the past 10 years 15 years um due to some of the things that the governor has has put in place and at that time it was Jerry Brown um you'll see other service operations um books supplies Capital outlay other outgo so again this year we are projected to spend about five million over um what we are bringing in and so some of that is on purpose right because we had large reserves from the one-time fund so we have spent those down and and so now we're at a place where okay we spend them down we kept these programs in place kept class SI done other things but now we have to do
134something about it because our revenues aren't keeping up with our expenditures um again from the board standpoint we've always tried to maintain a 10% Reserve it's been a board goal for the past 24 years um as a Focus right and that's as a basic Aid School District if something happens to property values we we drop out of basic Aid status I mean you can imagine Los Angeles right now with the fires or destruction things like that and the impact that that's going to have on property values and the corresponding loss of Revenue to schools right um and so those are the that's the reason for the 10% that's the reason for the 10% Reserve that we've tried to maintain right in the past um so again there's a mandatory 3% that you have to have
135as a school district by law you we won't pass our budget the board is Tred to maintain a 10 if we continue on the same path and don't make reductions we will not have a 3% Reserve in two years th why we're having this conversation right um so again School Services kind of an organization that focuses on budget 17% is what they recommend we're not recommending that but but just so you know that's that's something that is part of the recommendation um for districts so again why why why is this happening why are we you know at this place so many different reasons right so the first one um is because we received a ton of one-time funds which was great fantastic like $13 million um and we hired a lot of people and put
136them in place and kept class sizes low and added interventions and um added counselors back and added more special education we all those things which were great and it has made a dramatic difference for kids um but those people are still in place and those onetime funds are spent special education staff in program growth we've added a ton of of of support systems in place intervention aits the counseling support we' talked about um s Cube teachers working new new interventions for kids um and even with that our special ed numbers are growing and with that growth we're seeing that again there's that there's a need for more Personnel that goes along with it right um and so that that is something that we have to look at and examine and why and how is it
137happening and um what are the sports we're having in place and and and are they working or not right and so again we that's one that's kind of a mandatory we have to have um our employees uh it's really expensive to live here and we negotiate with our employees uh and we have over the past you know again we've we've had good Labor Relations we've we've come together for uh for deals uh the past three years we've given our employees excellent compensation increases right um really to maintain what other districts around us have given and so those are ongoing costs that we've again added to the school district so we've added Personnel we've added special education staff we're we've added raises right um the stir and purs amounts which are the benefits rates for our
138employees for um for for their retirement has gone up so dramatically over those years again you'll see a slide that talks about it we also have the unfunded implementation of transitional kindergarten so we have added a grade level in our school district right um it is something that the the board strategic priorities 15 years ago 12 years ago when you put it together um you were the first board to have like District preschools right that we paid for and we hired certificated teachers to teach those classes because we felt it was important the board felt it was important to have the best staff teaching our kids right and so you'll they're here tonight those first Preschool teachers that started our program are here right um and so it has been something we've tied in when
139TK started again okay yes it's great for kids let's do it let's get it going so we started with a few classes it's grown each year as the amount of of um you know months expanded right so this next year it's supposed to expand another three months up to 400 students um again we we have tried letter campaigns we've worked with schools for sound Finance which is kind of a lobbyist for basic Aid school districts um there has not been a desire at the state level the legislature to give to S Louis Coastal for for TK right because they see Carmel they see Pao Alto $40,000 a kid they see other districts and they equate that with us right and so there's just not an appetite at this point um even though it's so we've
140had to go basic school districts have had to go the route of trying to um go to like the the mandated program through the state and go through that process to show them that this is an unfunded mandate that they have placed upon our school district to try to get that funding again Dr prer and our community newsletters have put out to to send letters those types we've never had like a huge amount of support right in terms of moving forward in that direction and trying to get that accomplished um and so it's it's been tough so but we've continued to again try to get that funding try to have it in place I mean you you have your superintendent almost you know getting in fist of cuffs with our state senator ride over these
141issues types of things no that didn't happen but just again a battle right to try to get what's just for our kids for our school district um so so don't think for a second that we don't love the program want to keep it and would love to get funding to do it right when I uh did the numbers with my director of fiscal Services it's about six million dollar we would receive if we were a state funded District so if we were to receive the funding that goes along with TK because that he's not only expanding TK to 20 to2 from 24 to two he's actually even putting extra money into the budget to provide an extra adult in each of those classrooms we would love to have that funding and have that in place
142um so again that's one of the things that's put us in the situation we also have the closure of D Canyon so D Canyon um brought our school district and one of the main reasons why we are a basic Aid School District was the amount of unitary tax we received at the time so when I first started in this position it was roughly $10 million that we received in unitary tax um with the potential closure of the plan of course um we had to fight to get sb1090 pass which basically gave us about seven years of funding as they depreciate the plant and pay less unitary tax so that has continually decreased over the past uh seven years right next year will be the last year that we receive sp190 funds it's about four and
143a half million dollars that goes away after next year um and again oh well Dao is gonna stay open it's G to keep going we should get not yet there's no plan to begin to have unitary tax again you know for the plant to stay open for 20 more years even though we think it is and we're we're actually hopeful that it is at this point right to hopefully get those those funding levels um but but there is no indication at this point that we're that unitary tax will be reinstituted if the plant stays open so are they just going to depreciate the plant and keep it running and like hey it's a used car that's not valued and we're just gonna we think we're going to keep going for 20 years and not pay
144taxes on it or are they going to have to revalue the plant and move forward so for everyone to know we are currently lobbying for those funds we're going to be meeting with PG meeting with State working with our Community Partners um to try to get unitary tax reinstalled reinstated um so but again that funding goes away so the next year is our last year so that's another Revenue drop of four and a half million dollars that we have to we have to take into consideration um is is why we're here and then also as everyone else in the room knows your electricity bills more your water bills more your sewer bills more well it's the same for a school district those costs have all gone up dramatically over the past five years um and
145so again you'll see all of this all of these five or six things that I've presented tonight or or why we're here tonight in this situation of having a structural deficit okay it wasn't one thing or the district didn't plan or oh my God I can't believe this is happening no I've had a 10year budget at every single one of our budget meetings and they're four times a year first interim second interim budget development un audited actuals where I've showed this happening right we've known this is going to happen we're just there now right we're there now um and again our employees we're going into negotiations with all three of our unions as you'll see tonight on the agenda and and and so yes they they want compensation increases as well right so again there's
146all of these things go into our current fiscal condition um and so it's something we just have to address it right the board is has to bring us uh our fiscal solvency back so that we can move forward um and you know be financially stable as a school district I wanted to review and share some of the Fantastic pandemic and post pandemic work that your leadership team and all of you have approved that plan that that Mr Pinkerton was referring to so since the 2019 2020 school year these are the full-time Staffing equivalent positions um that we have increased in San Louis Coastal and again how hats off to the great work and programs our students are soaring many of them most of them doing better than ever um with these additions but in in
147short um there were three principles placed on special assignment at the district office to work on Special Projects um those positions were eliminated in The 2324 school year we've also grown and added the 14 TK teachers and 14 instructional assistants that are ever so important and working in those classrooms we've added additional 5.2 elementary school counselors because there were parttime counselors and then we increase them to full-time Elementary counselors we've also added three secondary academic counselors to our high schools and middle schools we've added four School psychologists 5.1 speech and language Pathologists those are both roles that play an integral part of our student services special education teams we've also added 11 academic intervention teachers and those are teachers who work part-time on a reduced year calendar to deliver interventions specific tier 2 programming to
148students who are identified through screening process as needing extra support in Reading we have added the nine Student Success Specialists we call them SC cubes they were formerly mtss teacher roles that their job description and title has changed because they are focused primarily on ensuring all students success so they look at student achievement screening data they help design uh intervention learning groups they support the aits working with student groups they also coach and support our classroom teachers in delivering our curricular programs in a inclusive and supportive way we've opened and added the two Wellness centeral counselors we've added 29 par Educators those are adults that support our special education students as they move about campuses during the school day we've added one assistant principal position at lagona middle school as their enrollment increased dramatically and
149a0 five summer experience tosa I mean I'm sorry a0 five summer experience principal as well as 11 approximately 11.6 um El and other instructional AIDS those are other classified staff members that support students and classrooms around our campuses so just to um put a little bit of kind of make it look a little bit easier uh the information that Miss Yasha just shared and and Mr pinker's overall from 2019 to 2020 or 2019 2020 school year to 22 2425 you can see at the top we have we've had additional 27 certificated classroom teachers we have an additional 53.2 three non-classroom temp teachers those are our counselers our school psychologist the toses again these are the people that are in the class at the site level providing much of the uh the intervention that Miss yaser
150was talking about uh part of the the learning recovery and the um the information that the the the goals that we're set forth in the um the pandemic funding uh certificated administrators we've uh shared with you up there you just saw one and a half increase that was an assistant principal at ATA and then the half princial for the summer uh summer program classified staff this is a little the uh classified staff is a little bit more complicated because many of our classified staff work tempor are part-time so the number on the left are the total um uh number of people and on the left is the FTE which is the full-time equivalent so again you can see that we've we've increased by 69 total people and 93 FTE so again and much of this
151is um in support of students in the classroom which again very very positive our our confidential classified staff these are some of our classified management um as well as our classified confidential staff here at the district office uh that has um that has increased by two and uh so our total increase across the district in this five-year period is 173 FTE and at the bottom you can see we have increased by a total of 110 student students and typically um you know basic math is uh 30 students equals one FTE of of certificated FTE and then the ancillary supports that come with that so you can see we we've far exceeded that um we've just wanted to share a little bit with uh with the general public and the board as well um the district
152Stan Louis Coastal has continued to strive to have really low uh teacher student ratios or staff student ratios um our school psychologist at this point in time Statewide average is is one to a thousand students for school counselors now yes there are recommendations by the American Association of school coun coun school psychologists much the recommendations are much lower than that but the reality is that these are the these are the the Statewide averages in this moment in time so our counselors again we have 25.3 the ratio is 1 to 306 in our K3 classes our our CBA which is our collective bargaining agreement the state would allow us to go up to 33 students in a in a K3 classroom we've worked with uh slct to have a cap of 28 students our currently our
153our average across the district in the T K3 range is 24 students so again you can see we're we're below the average that we've even negotiated in far below the state average which is 1 to 30 and then our 4 through 12 the uh our negotiated number is uh average of 32 a Max of 35 currently we're at 1 to 2 now do we have classes that are higher than those numbers certainly but we have so that means we have classes that are far below that number and then our last one is just the certificated administrators currently across the district we have 30 the uh recommended State ratio is 8 to eight administrators for every 100 uh teachers our number is six administrators to uh um 100 teachers we're even still below uh we're not
154staffed we're not overstaffed from a certificated administrative standpoint and then this slide is just again gives you a breakdown of our enrollment uh over the past 10 years and plus a projection for next year uh if it um you can see again we we've in the K12 ranks we've actually stayed very flat and where we've added is in the the TK range so so again we've maintained a relatively flat enrollment with an addition of again 170 additional 170 additional people um supporting our students wanted to share a little bit with the district related to our um just our historical comp compensation um and and through our negotiations with our respective unions um so you can see year over-year we have strived to uh keep up with Cola and our property taxes and we've done a
155pretty a pretty solid job of that um so that that is um and again that that's we want to do that as a district we want to compensate our our staff they are the backbone of of of you know what we do we're here to serve students and we want to make sure that our our staff both classified and ricated are compensated and are are are satisfied in their work and can come to work and and be focused on work and not worried about things outside um but again one of the big hurdles that we are facing um and again this is all districts is the increase to the district stirs and purs uh contributions that's the State teachers retirement system as well as the uh public education a Public Employee Retirement System uh in
1561415 uh it was 8.3 and 11.7% respectively that the district would contribute to um each of these uh Employees Retirement System in 2425 uh for our state teachers retirement it is currently at 19% and 27 and a half% for the pur so again for every uh dollar that an employee paid the district puts in 27 27.5 cents you for every $100 so so it's not insignificant it is it is a it is a it's a big contribution to retirement and um that that is that is what it is and that's a statutory benefit and there's no way around that and we're happy to pay that but there's also the other piece just so everybody understands that there is a a pay raise built into what's called step in column in each of our pay scales
157so every year that a teacher and or a classified staff member um works there's a two and a half% increase for our certificated staff and a four and a half% for classified staff at some point you know both teachers and um our our classified staff hit the tail end of that uh salary schedule but again that is that is built in an increase year-over-year and then we also pay statutory benefits uh to uh Medicare FICA Etc um this next slide just shows a little bit of again the compensation across the county uh Dr brush was here a little bit and talked about all the districts across the county the you know we talk about large districts and small districts across the county kukus currently has the highest Max compensation which is their their pay plus
158their District contribution to benefits um but they only have 180 students which which equates to roughly I'm GNA go on a ballpark and say probably about 10 10 teachers uh maximum uh so you can see in St Louis Coastal our Max compensation is at 135 which is the salary plus a contribution to benefits of $155,000 plus so again we we have strived to and have maintained um you know salaries commensurate with our um our neighboring school districts across the county so this slide just again this talks a little bit about um some of the some of the potential reductions that the board should consider in in in where we go um we think that we're hoping that you know we'll work with all three of our uh bargaining units to see if we can get
159folks to who are planning on retiring or or not coming back resigning so we can get those folks um off the books we know they're leaving that means we could probably save somebody who's who's intending to stay here um and there may be some temporary staff that that would be released that would be most of this could be could be met through that again and that's not a that's not a positive but that's just to stay you know when people think about and consider um the options that those are those are some of it we may be reassigning non-class uh non-classroom teachers back to the classroom potentially again we've talked about this pretty in depth at this point is a closure of transitional kindergarten would be an option um reduction of the post pandemic all
160the programs that we've put in place all the interventions all the social emotional supports um and and so so again not ideal but these are these are things that we'd ask you to consider um develop in it here uh some special education Staffing ratios so again just kind of understanding the number of uh of adults that we need in a classroom to support our students with special needs um and and what that ratio would look like and trying to maintain those ratios and be mindful of that when we meet with uh families and we want to make sure that our students have the services they need um but at the same time not making you know we have situations where in some of our classrooms there there are more adults than there are students um
161at this point hiring free just looking at as people retire as people leave at the end of this school year not backfilling those positions unless they're absolutely necessary um and then the other thing would be U an implementation of a formal uh reduction in force a riff people people typically think about it as a as a pink slip the upside of a of uh doing that process is we can be a little bit more strategic with and work with our three bargaining units to um you know work collaboratively on what that looks like and and and really at the end of the day make our Cuts as far away from the classroom as as humanly possible that's you know we want don't want to impact the instructional program um any more than we have to
162so that's that's our goal and that'll be that'll be addressed through the um lcap adjustments uh as as the we get into the spring and you make those recommendations and miss yamas and her team will go back out to the community and and seek input and and make edits as NE necessary so again it goes without saying that these reductions are going to be painful and uncomfortable to students and staff at our school sites um we are charged with trying to think creatively and outside the box with how we can deliver the high quality education and instructional supports to our students while we may be having fewer um adults and Personnel on our campuses and pending um the decisions that you will make in the future will Define as we move throughout spring how we
163intend or plan to do that um if could wave a magic wand and sprinkle money down from the ceiling and keep every wonderful program we have I would very much um choose to do that so some possible areas recommended for reduction we already discussed um starting at the district office is important and looking at all the roles and positions um here as well as non-personnel related costs so we do hire and work with excellent Consultants we have contracts with professional organizations community-based organizations throughout San Louis abiso professional development organizations um and we're going to look to reduce some of those we are going to be Staffing our classrooms um at the ratios that our collective bargaining units um collective bargaining agreements currently allow us to which will be higher than the rates that you saw
164currently today um we are going to look at and recommend the closure of the TK program pending future funding um we are also going to look currently at the academic interventions and supports that we've been able to put in place in the past um few years that provide opportunities for students who are falling up behind to get the supports that they need as well as look carefully at the social emotional learning intervention programming through our counselors and other mental health supports that provide our students behavioral um training that goes beyond the hard work of our our regular uh standard classroom teachers are already delivering and administrators are already delivering um but these would be the out ofthe classroom sorts of um supports that we currently have in place I'll go a little bit off script
165but not too too far because I know there's lots of people that want to speak in 2010 I know members of this board who were there at that time remember that you adopted 10 strategic initiatives part of those strategic initiatives was to address what was missing in St Louis Coastal at the time there's no defined preschool program in our district there was Head Start there was State preschool but wasn't State preschool was not assisting Us in this District the students in this District so part of that initiative that we created and you adopted was the initiation of preschool at our most needy sites we started at Pacho wood and Hawthorne we were so thrilled with the but with what we saw that we began as um Rita mentioned we began to as the money allowed
166us to we began to add additional programs at additional sites and now I share that with you because this board was at the Forefront of this work and it's important and so I don't I can't imagine me I I really can't imagine I'm standing here even talking about this because it's a it's a jewel our our TK program is I think one of the best in the state it's phenomenal it's phenomenal with that said each year as I fight and I can't seem to get any traction I'm very very uh disappointed and I'm still not done fighting for this the state has caught wind AB 167 I believe it is where Governor Nome came out in 2021 2022 and declared that transitional kindergarten was indeed something that we should pursue as a state and so
167with that we all cheered and we all rallied but with it also um came this surprise and that surprise from my circles as a superintendent in the basic Aid World fell like a ton of bricks and that was a decision by the state legislature to carve us out of that funding picture so that is the primary reason as those costs escalate and more kids come into the program and you look at the perfect storm that's in front of us that's the new framework that I'm really trying to talk about here we I wish we had more options than we do I really do I sincerely wish we had more options and I've been figuring out all kind of creative ways but every every creative idea that I have to sustain it either the Ed code
168or or some sort of uh board law board policy or I should say State Ed code law prevents us from doing that partnering with other districts partnering with a charter just won't allow that to happen so I'm still seeking out Alternatives but what I'm left with is a shrinking pie of resources due to the things you've heard about tonight and I won't go through them all but suffice it to say that San Louis Coastal is in a really precarious spot right now and we have some really tough decisions the toughest decision that didn't come out loud and clear tonight from the presentation but it needs to be mentioned is that um it's really an if then statement if this then what because those choices that you make in this next cycle will determine so um
169there's not a single person in this room doesn't doesn't value TK but there's not a single in this person in this room doesn't value Counseling doesn't value intervention support doesn't value reasonable class sizes and all of those things equate to people so when I share this with you tonight or when we've brought this before you tonight it's not recklessly it's not without a whole lot of thought and consideration yes I am fighting and will continue to fight for TK funding and I hope the energy in this room follows me to Sacramento because really that's $6 million that we're not getting six million that's that's a big number and I'm here to tell you it's growing so you can't just ignore that then I will say to you dblo Canyon P gen is announcing they're going
170to extend the life of that plant we're waiting for some other details but that could be another sizable chunk of money anywhere from five to 10 million dollar a year for us so hopefully in the coming months and certainly in the out year we'll have some good news on those two fronts which will bring us back here and have a much better conversation but absent that I don't see how these choices none of these options are good not not any of them so I'm here tonight just to tell you that um we have to make these tough decisions we we we can do tough things now beyond that we can also Circle back around and figure out well if not that then what right and these are the things that I'll be continue to work
171with you on so with that um we do have um in the next um slide um a timeline and you might say well gez that timeline's really tight it is it's tight because we're up against a timeline with our employees we're up against a timeline with our parents we're up against a timeline with local agency that can support us if we don't have that then how can our local agencies help our families um we have a lot of planning to do and a lot of work to do and um it's not lost on me that time is of the essence so if we can somehow get a budget trailer bill for TK funding for basic Aid districts which is the right thing to do then we'll be back here again okay if if we can
172work with our outside agencies and come out with some Creative Solutions for our Working Families I'm all in and I'll make that happen so I'm here tonight just to say here's the timeline this is what we're up against and um I appreciate your patience as we go through this Mr Clawson yes so I just wanted to make a couple comments I know I'm looking forward to a lot of input and hearing what everyone has to say I think the first thing I want to say is I just really appreciate everyone that's here um this is a community discussion and the fact that you're all here to be part of this discussion is is really important um also as we as we kind of dig into this over the next next next couple hours um I
173I want to convey that any discussion about reducing or removing TK like just makes my stomach sick and I think I think that's true for so many people up here um and this problem can be solved two different ways one is by finding new sources of income and and the team's touched on those a little bit but I think we all need to Advocate Sacramento that's a general thing but we're losing uh five $10 million a year from the the nuclear power plant and a lot of that is through through some clever accounting that occurred because the plant was going to close it was devalued it's not closing but we're not getting our funding and if we can fix that you know we're all having a very different discussion so the more you can all
174advocate in the community on both of those topics we we' really appreciate it um I guess my my other comment though is um when it gets to this this decision um there's some things that aren't in presentation that are really really important over the last five years we've put support infrastructures in place through counseling through support systems at our elementary schools at the K through 12 level and I mean we could talk for hours about how valuable transitional kindergarten is and we can talk for hours about how valuable those support infrastructures are and and I don't know which is right but but um there there's things being kept in place at the K through2 level that will benefit every child in our community and um it's just a really difficult tradeoff but um more than
175anything again thank you for for being here and we're going to do our best to try to do what we can but um thank you thank you is there any other board comment Mr bu I think all of us are but I just want to say I think Brian's talking for a lot of us and our I appreciate him coming up with the words but I think for me and I think for everybody I know on the board it's it's pretty much the same thoughts Mrs Bal I'm sorry I want to just um add to that and just remind the folks that are in the audience I really appreciate you being here tonight I Echo all of my colleagues comments um but I just want to remind you how um important your voice is from
176an advocate advocacy perspective I come from an advocacy background it's very powerful to have numbers of parents and teachers and Educators um to voice their concerns um with the powers that be and so it's one thing for us to Advocate I will be sending my own letters um we are collectively constantly advocating through our lobbyists but um I know from experience um that you get a letter signed on by multiple multiple multiple families and and parents and teachers that's very effective for our elected leaders um and phone calls to their office as well are very effective please I would like the public to know that as a board member and and studying all this this is a very painful thing to me some of you know me I taught in this district for 31 years
177and as a teacher I remember so well how I became so jaded towards the district office it was always a Us and Them kind of mentality and uh when people say well how's the board Rob what's it like and I'll say well it's a straight up learning curve I am learning more and more that there are really two sides and both sides are very important my gosh we're talking about people we're talking about children and this is painful but we do have to do something we can't be fiscally irresponsible we just can't do that and if you have listened tonight even with half a heart to what are our district office has been trying to present you will understand that we are between a rock and a hard spot or as we used to say
178in the 60s we're facing a catch 22 this is really something I hope you've been listening I hope you are willing to understand what we have to approve my gosh I want to right now tell you I have never worked alongside a group of more dedicated honest Earnest individuals as this board they have no hidden agendas none they don't favor one program over another nothing like that I hope you will understand what we are facing long after you go home and we go home it will be on our minds what are we going to do thank you all right we will as we as Mrs Roger stated at the beginning we will have an hour of public comment uh you might be mindful that there we have many names here and the shorter you are
179the more time for others to speak so I'm going to call about three names at a time so if you can come forward and be in line then we'll be able to if you haven't filled out a sheet they're in the back but we'll be doing these in the order so yeah I have the online forms so if you if you um if you could move forward to kind of be in line as I uh say the names and that will help things move along also so I have I have uh Lu you know we need we need to be able to move this along please we have Lucia I have Lucia Stone followed by Jessica Boon followed by Josh War so if you could the three of you come up please and we'll and
180get in line and then we'll get going I spoke but I'm willing to speak again on the record well if you spoke already on this topic if you wouldn't mind to give others an opportunity okay so you could just let me know so then I've got Jessica kaboon Jos War followed by Fiona Lloyd maet and we're ready to go hi thank you for your time um I won't take long I just want to re reiterate what we've already heard tonight and that um I've had one daughter go through the TK program I have one enrolled currently and one hopeful for 2026 and it's been um amazing to see the progress that my children have made through this program and I'm hopeful that will continue in the future thank you thank you Lea Lloyd M followed
181by amand oh Josh oh Josh War I'm so sorry I'm gonna get ahead of myself go ahead hi uh my name is Josh Warren I live in lososo about a 100 yards from Baywood Elementary I assumed to be four-year-old daughter and I teach special education at R Grande High School Mr pinking Jen mentioned that sped budget and services cannot be cut because the district is legally obligated to provide them and he's absolutely right uh it's protected by federal law TK is a service the district is legally obligated to provide by California state law according to the California Department of Education TK is the only option within the broader upk frame that will be universally available and free of cost for all four-year-old children we asked District representative if the district knew you were violating the
182law and we were told yes but the punishment from the state is usually revoking funding and because the district isn't receiving those funds as a basic Aid District you are going to take the risk I don't think the district is adequately assessing the risk separate from the negative effects on our children you are joining districts in the most affluent counties in the state including delmare and Sala Beach that Mr pingon mentioned to deny legally obligated services to hundreds maybe thousands of students this is simply a recipe for a lawsuit perhaps several from parents with the resources to pursue legal action please understand I don't mean to threaten this is merely a risk assessment from a fellow educator the state will not be a reckoning parents will as a special education teacher my student my students
183are protected by fake rightfully guaranteeing them a free appropriate and public education I absolutely believe our general education students should receive the same protections it's possible this is just posturing by the district to coers the state to Blink and send funds to support the Decay program I just heard the superintendent say the district began DK before the Mandate uh but now that it is a mandate and you didn't get the money you thought you were going to get you want to cut it Mr pinkton said there were all uh budget issues we knew were coming so why didn't you include that in $340 million Bond you got two years ago I don't really care I don't want my daughter's education or professions of others Educators use vehicles in your game of chicken with Sacramento again
184it is not my intent to threaten but if I have to drive my daughter 50 mile round trip to harlo Elementary Every Day next year to receive the services she's legally obligated to receive I can tell you who's going to be paying my gas mileage thank you I have Lloyd m followed by Amanda Alexander then Emily calano thank you to Dr Prader and to our leadership and to the board and to all of our community here who has come in person and on zoom and have written so many letters in support of TK and my colleagues my hotor colleagues and Rob Mr meld I'm listening I'm listening with my heart my heart is breaking right now these are our youngest children our most vulnerable children we have to find a way we have to find
185a way to provide this service to all of our children we know and all of you know that and we people will speak to this but TK this year has the opportunity to help our children succeed not just in school but in life we know that their cognitive school scho um their cognitive skills and their language skills and Mathematics and Science and their curiosity their joy for learning their self-confidence their their ability to self-regulate to cooperate to share to become the humans we want them to be and that our world needs them to be resilient empathetic loving ones who believe and are curious and motivated to learn and all of that we create in this TK in our TK classrooms every single day and I think I I have cried so much um and my
186heart again feels like it's going to break and then when school started Amanda's my colleague the children walk in and we know that every day we meet them with love and compassion they are known they are safe they are loved every single day and I truly believe with this engaging joyful magical handson meaningful environment that we provide them and learning community they will soar and they will Thrive and I know we want our children in the blue and the green and we believe so deeply in that in equity and providing every child with this access and we have to start with our youngest children we've made that commitment you have made the commitment I'm so proud that you did that years ago go and I just trust that you'll you're going to find a way
187and I believe in you and I believe in this community Amanda Amanda Alexander followed by Emily calano followed by Julie Dodson Amanda Alexander Emily calano Julie Dodson good evening members of the board my name is Amanda I'm proud to be a transitional kindergarten teacher in St Louis Coastal unified well this is my first year here in the district I've been in early childhood education for many years and previously taught TK in the Bay Area and my family moved back to St Louis abiso I had several offers but I chose St Louis Coastal because of your vision and commitment to early learning your belief in giving our youngest Learners the strongest possible start is what drew me here it's what sets us District apart every day I have the privilege of watching kids discover grow and
188thrive in ways that are nothing short of magical taking away a program that ensures that all four-year-olds have access to high quality Early Education would be a significant step backwards research shows that every dollar invested in early childhood education saves money long term by reducing the need for intervention services improving academic outcomes and raising graduation rates but beyond the numbers it's about the children TK changes lives fam's lives and children's builds confidence curiosity Independence and the foundational skill that set children on a path to success not just in school but in life cutting this program would mean turning away from the very values that brought me and so many others to this District I urge you to keep your focus on what you know is right investing in our youngest Learners it's an investment in
189their future in our community and in the legacy of St Louis Coastal thank you I'm Emily calano I teach second grade at Hawthorne and I'm also the vice president of the Union teachers union um I want to thank you all for your time and your thoughtful consideration of what is our concerned citizens parents Educators and community members are saying here tonight as I study the recommended the recommended um reductions and slides and the ones prior to the reduction slides the recommendations I'm left with a lot of questions I'm also I'm I am hopeful that all of you our board members are also uh left with questions I'm specifically concerned about some staffing ratios that I saw on the slides that are inaccurate and additionally some of the slides that appear um not to tell the
190full story and history of some of our programs um and for this this sure can hinder making an informed decision on important programs that will have a devastating impact on our students therefore I urge you to continue to dig deeper ask questions for our board members to keep looking at funding sources what's funding this what's not how much is coming out of our general fund what's not because I know we have things that we can't touch but there are some things that we're probably using and I just want to make sure that we dig deep that we ask more questions so we scour these spreadsheets our students families Educators and community members need our inquisitiveness they need all the work that you have been doing and continue to do for us to be successful and
191to save our programs that are really important for student wellness and for Success otherwise we're going to see a different picture in a few years it's not going to look like this when you see the dashboard it's not going to look like that and um and I know that's really important and I know you do important work but we just we need to actually dig deeper not just if someone tells me something I was taught to do um to always question but in a healthy way right and so question this in a healthy way and question and ask where did this come from how much are we using what else can we get from this um I think that's a really important piece next step in your um in in the board because we haven't
192had these kind of funding Cuts in a long time and I think that that's something that we really need to scour so thank you Julie Dodson followed by Kristen Eldridge followed by Kayla Townson I'm Julie Dodson I'm a grandmother and my have a I have a girl who's a sixth grader in our classes when it became for her to be in um TK there were only three schools that had TK and we picked CL Smith to be TK her mother is a teacher as well so when she finished with TK she was moved over to Hawthorne because her mother wanted her to be there she felt that was the best place for her to be and when I was working with her in the TK class I learned a lot I got um I got
193a u check and they said I could spend some money to go in and help them out I could go in and maybe I could uh help them out and I asked the teacher if they needed anything and she said we'd like to have you come in and be the office or be in the building for maybe 10 to uh 10 :00 to 11: one day a week so I did I spend a lot of time with those kids I watched them and I saw them help learn how to work with each other how long they learn how to find things how to build things we did a lot of PL of uh painting and all those things that they did they had so much that they learned and then when we moved to Junior
194High or I mean to excuse me to Hawthorne in kindergarten there was a difference there was quite a difference between those children learned to those who are learning from kindergarten there's a very big difference and um so one of the other things too I'm not just a grandmother I'm a volunteer with dental Coalition and I screen kids in February and March and I also was asked by them to do Kindergarten Roundup so I was working with children that were going to be in kindergarten kids that were going to TK and the one thing I really found out this last summer this last year that surprised me was that some of the parents who were ready to take kids to to uh kindergarten wanted to get the kids in TK first they were saying we don't
195want to go into kindergarten yet we want them to do TK and so they were asking please do TK first so then they could learn their their other one so um I think that's important very important and I'm hoping that you don't take it away because I think it was very very important for those kids and so please don't take them away if it's possible to hold them thank you hi my name is Kristen Eldridge and um I am a teacher at Hawthorne Elementary School and I've been teaching for 22 years and this job is hard and I keep doing it every day because I care deeply about my students and I believe in them and I am not a TK teacher I for the last several years I've taught sixth grade this year I'm
196teaching fourth grade and um you would not believe what an invaluable resource to me and my students is our TK program um my team at Hawthorne I could not do my job without them my TK team at Hawthorne has supported me with my upper grade students tremendously our TK classroom has given individual students as well as um my class through buddies but individual students more so like that space to grow and lead and mentor and play um learn through play without a screen in front of their face and um it's just I honestly some of my students I'm thinking about specific individual faces right now like I don't know how they would have made it through the year without the support of our TK program so um I don't end the decisions you guys have
197to make um a Teensy side note that popped into my head tonight um I was shocked to hear about um the cost of benefits health benefits um uh I know my husband to work he gets a tiny cut uh Kickback for uh foregoing his benefits so he's on mine so I don't know maybe that's something we could look at but uh I just want to say that um I appreciate your thoughtful decision making so thank you good evening my name is Kayla Townson and in 2022 I had the honor of being hired as one of the new full-time Elementary counselors that this District agreed was essential in order to support their students I was so eager to work in a district that was choosing to prioritize student wellness and could not wait to be a
198part of a foundational group who got to establish what it meant to have a full-time Elementary counseling program since then I have built trusting relationships with my students families and staff that has allowed me to do this important work at my site since my very first welcome meeting I have repeatedly been told by District staff that part of my job is to make sure that I continue to prove my worth because my position may not be able to stay after our first three years knowing this every counselor has spent hours of time each week off and outside of contract time collecting data and creating reports trying to do the impossible of numerically representing the job that we do every day having counselors on every School site is worth it not only that but the reality
199is that we're currently being asked to work Beyond a sustainable level between our 10 Elementary sites Elementary counselors are currently working at an average ratio of one counselor to 412 students even though our national governing board recommends a maximum of 1 to 250 for my own site between August of 2022 and now I have logged 2,262 points of data for individual interventions I've done with students I've taught 284 classroom seal lessons that I researched created and prepped for eight different grade levels at my site I've seen our Universal screeners change from showing that student belonging was our lowest rated area starting in 2022 to this year not only being our strongest area but the highest rating of any school in our district yet these number do not truly reflect why my job has been worth
200it my job is worth it because of the kids this week whose mom passed away who could not wait to come back to school because we've made School such a safe place for them my job is worth it because of the student I'm working with who's been having panic attacks leaving home and who has successfully been at school for an entire week for the first time since October my job is worth it because of the group of boys I'm working with where one of them today said I never knew boys could talk about their feelings like this I thought I was the only one going through this stuff I have hundreds of more stories that prove what I already know our counselors are an essential part of our school Community yet despite this I'm still
201here trying to remind you of our worth the budget cuts have been preliminarily laid out to be discussed in the agenda today put us on a path towards deconstructing the systems that we know are directly serving student needs such as minimizing social emotional supports decreasing academic intervention programs and increasing class sizes I'm urging our district team to go back to the drawing board and come to us with a better plan to address the deficit and prioritize the programs that are directly benefiting our students wellbeing and achievement each and every day thank you for your time next we have um Chris Christine ready then Michelle dornish and Alysa buol and again please forgive any mispronunciations you did a great job on ready all right so uh my name is Christine ready I am a mother of
202one soon to be two future s shimer Stingers um I've also been a high school teacher at NPO High School for the past 13 years so just down south and I'm also professor at quester college so I'm super well versed in the workings of the TK through 14 uh School District environment and I know the budget's really challenging um but I do have a really great way for all of you and you've heard this before uh but to really help out with all of that chronic absenteeism and your suspension rates and as a bonus it'll actually probably really help out all those sped teachers who are uh feeling extremely overworked and that is the transitional kindergarten uh program so to be frank I've always felt really lucky to work in lucr but to live in
203St Louis Coastal um one of the big reasons that that is the case is because of the incredible programs that we offer here in St Louis Coastal um I took my son to the parent participation program he still goes with my mother every week it's an incredible program there are families from Luc Mar that come into s Louis Coastal for that program and it's really because of the excellent start that it gives to our kids um but now that we're having this conversation about transitional kindergarten I'm starting to have to rethink where I want to send my kids to school right maybe they need to go to the district that I work in instead of the district that I live in because I really want to make sure that my children have that opportunity so
204even if it means I have to drive them to Nomo Elementary every day that might be the better option for me if TK is on the table there and it's not on the table here um when I heard about that Statewide Universal te program I was super excited about it uh as a teacher Juniors and seniors as well as graduates I can still see the impacts on students at that level they're 17 and I can still tell who went to preschool right it is a major impact on their lives it really impacts them from day one through the the day that they graduate right it's a huge huge impact um and beyond my own an anecdotal experience people have talked about the educational research in this area we all know that this is really important
205um TK is going to make a positive impact on our kids not only in that K K12 education but also as they become members of our community right we're going to have them for the next 14 years in the school district and as we move beyond that they're going to live in our communities majority of people stay where they grow up if they have that opportunity which is harder in St Louis because it's so expensive but it's really really important that we do that um as a mom I also have a vested interest in that TK program for my own children my son is supposed to go to preschool in the fall uh he won't be able to do that if TK goes away because the two four-year-olds who are in the program will be
206taking his spot so from the perspective of a parent right this is going to have huge fiscal impacts on everybody moving forward and especially only giving parents a few months to plan is really not going to benefit our community thank you so much for your time hi I'm Michelle dornish I am a parent and I'm a special education teacher my son Julian uh has very patiently waited this whole time is going to turn four in March uh and should be enrolling in TK for the fall um I do 100% believe that every single one of you believes TK is important and none of you want to cut this but I also heard that you feel like you are going to have to vote to approve this and I don't think that's necessarily the case I
207do want to piggyback on what uh Emily calano said and say that there's got to be more Creative Solutions to this problem because we all know how valuable TK is uh from a sped background I can tell you that our beautiful blues and greens are going to start turning to yellows oranges and reds if we let go of this program and if we cut our social emotional and academic interventions um it's hard not to get emotional about this from both a professional and personal standpoint um with my son supposed to be enrolling and me facing very similar situation where I might have to drive him to a district that is not where he lives but where I can enroll him because I work there um I would much rather he go to a neighborhood school
208that he has been expected to go to for over a year he knows he's supposed to be a Hawthorn eagle and he's very proud of that fact um and I would encourage us to think not only of being fiscally responsible but just morally responsible we talk about equity and all of these values that we stand for as a city and as a district and it's not Equitable and it's not going to be Equitable because there's going to be families who can afford Private Preschool and there's be families who won't be able to afford that I um also just want to urge that we've been finan fiscally responsible by having 10% in the bank and we only need 3% and maybe that would at least buy us a year to fight the um state with you
209because letters are already going out from uh my friends and um from me and my husband and calls are already being made to our Representatives and we want to be a huge part of that fight so maybe with one more year of time we can do that and at the very least one more year of time giving families to actually plan for this closure because six months from now the local preschools and daycares are not going to have room for 400 kiddos so we really need to keep all of that in mind as we make this decision thank you I think I'm for the next um are youa yes I'm for the next um thing schule okay then we I'll set that aside thank you thank thank you okay um and is that the same
210for Scott yeah okay that's okay um then I have Roslin go goco gothro followed by uh Carrie dagio followed by Jason dornes hello again my name is Ros gothro I have two children in the school district one who is scheduled to attend TK in the fall I stand before you today as a concerned member of this community deeply troubled by the proposal to cancel TK I believe this decision if implemented will have far-reaching consequences for our children families and the future of our education system TK is not just another program it is a vital Foundation for Young Learners it provides our youngest students with the opportunity to engage in structured developmentally appropriate learning before they enter kindergarten for many of our children TK is the first introduction to the school environment it helps them build
211entral social emotional and academic skills setting them up for success in later grades first and foremost cancelling TK would disproportionately affect our most vulnerable students TK offers critical support to children from low in families English language Learners and those who may not have access to preschool or early childhood education by taking away this program we risk widening the achievement Gap and leaving behind the students who need the most help second TK is not just about academics it's about preparing our children for the Social and emotional challenges of school the early years of education are when children develop key skills such as emotional regulation teamwork and problem solving these skills are essential for their future success in school and in life by removing TK we are depriving them of the structured environment they need to grow
212learn and Thrive Additionally the benefits of TK extend beyond the classroom parents and families rely on this program for their child's development knowing that they are receiving quality care and education the cancellation of TK will create a burden on families who may not have the resources or options to find suitable Early Educational Alternatives it will place undue stress on working parents and ultimately the entire Community will feel the Ripple effects we understand that budgets are tight and difficult decisions must be made however we must ask ourselves can we afford to take away a program that serves as a critical stepping stone for our children's education can we in good conscious deny them the opportunity for an equitable and successful start to their academic Journey instead of eliminating TK I urg the board to explore alternative
213Solutions whether it be reallocating funds seeking outside grants or finding other ways to ensure that our youngest Learners continue to receive the support and education they deserve there's no question that education is an investment and TK is one of the wisest Investments that we can make in closing I ask that you reconsider this proposal and preserve TK our children are our future and it is our responsibility to give them the best possible start in life life let's stand together to ensure that every child has access to the foundation that they need to succeed thank you good evening my name is Carrie dagio my husband and I have a child who's currently enrolled in TK at s shimer Elementary um we are both shocked and deeply concerned to hear about the potential funding cuts to TK
214I want to just share a little a little bit about my daughter um when we first learned that she would fall into the right age bracket to attend TK it was just such an enormous sense of relief to us um she's an early September birthday kid and she falls almost exactly on the cut off for TK in kindergarten and um it was very clear to us from an early age that she would benefit immensely from that extra year before entering kindergarten um she's a smart kid but she has always trailed her her peers socially and emotionally um and what she's learning in TK is aside from academics is is to work with others and to make friends and to solve problems and just to be a developing person around other developing people um if she
215had been thrown into the academic rigor of kindergarten and it is rigorous for that age um she would have been trying to navigate the complex social emotional changes that she's going through um and it would have been nearly impossible for her to succeed academically at that time um right now she's doing really well in school because she's in TK um and as other people before me have stated I also can't help but think of those families whose children face language barriers disabilities and financial hardships cutting TK funding would send a message that the needs of Young Learners and struggling families are not a priority and we risk leaving behind families who need the program most you have the opportunity with this decision to show that our district values equity in education um I want to
216thank the district for um kind of the the background and the lesson of the history of TK and um explaining some of the complexities of the budget and the way that TK fits into um the the basic Aid District that we are um that was enlightening for me and hopefully for other people as well um please I urge you to continue to be creative um in finding the money that we need please continue to be tenacious and to advocate for our district and for our children thank you Bas dornish followed by Bill angel and then Dr low good evening U members of the board um my name is Jason dornish parent to Julian over there who's excited to be a TK hawthor Eagle next year with his cousin Christopher if the result of tonight is
217negative he may have to become a gusd bobcat um which Guadalupe is a district that does is not um uh basic Aid District but somehow they have a successful TK and prek program I will remind Dr Prader and the board tonight that they can snap their fingers and receive state funding for TK this comes at a budget reduction of around $10 million by dropping the district's basic Aid status though I don't envy the board the uh staff of the decisions ahead I am encouraged by the fact that 85% of the other districts in this state do this somehow with less I will say that the letter handout provided by the district is something as stated the budget situation is not a surprise to the board or staff tying the fate of the TK program to
218begging for State funds which is thus far not been successful isn't responsible my the rest of my comment comes in the form of rhetorical questions for the board I do not expect you to answer these but rather for you to consider these in the decisions ahead and I will email these to the board after I put my son to bed tonight um number one looking at San Louis Coastal 10-year budget projection and the uh current 20 2425 budget and update there appear to be sufficient reserves to keep TK funded through the 2526 school year as a stop Gap though you might not meet your reserve quotas is that correct that TK could be funded number two does San Louis Coastal as a district understand the community impact of opening a TK program and then shuttering
219it has the board and staff considered the impact to private preschools and daycares and is there any initiative to help fix the child care Gap that you have created and by that I mean that child other uh private daycares and preschools have closed or reduced uh capacity for their older child daycare and uh preschool programs and the district is now expecting to put a 400 student glut into that market um has the board and staff researched whether St Louis Coastal is the First District in California to end its TK program is the board prepared to make the argument with the state perhaps in court that this program that they have run for years is not mandatory when CDC guidance clearly states otherwise go on the cde's website it's there um and has San Louis Coastal
220researched what happened to Miller Creek School District's proposal to end TK my admittedly hasty research in about 10 minutes of Googling indicates that this isn't the first time a district has tried to end a TK program but it seems like they ultimately chose not to so perhaps there are some lessons learned thank you well oh I'm sorry to do this but I'm gonna jump the line for a quick second because I have a future TK member this fall who would like to say something before he falls asleep on my lap So This is Nico forella and what do you want to say for your public comment I really want to go to TK good evening I'm Phil Angel and I'm not quite sure I can follow that last speaker I represent slct as the president
221and I know Mr Pinkerton mentioned that we've known for a while that we've had to make cuts on December 18th we all got the merry Christmas letter from Dr Prader and it is reality I understand that it is reality and we need to make budget cuts it's December 18th when we got that letter that didn't give us a lot of time a lot of time to work with you to have our professional Educators and our community work together to find solutions to help our school board out I don't envy you guys I've sat there although I sat there at a better budget time so I I'm yeah I just don't envy you it's not easy to make those decisions however I want you to know slct wants to be involved and we want to be
222creative Partners in finding ways to support our students as a general education teacher uh Lisa yam mentioned that uh we will staff to our classroom our contracted maximums that's awesome we've done that for years from time to time and um we've done that before the pandemic however after the pandemic our kids need a lot more support we thank you um we uh absolutely are prepared to teach to our 35 classroom ma our maximum of 35 we we want to continue having the supports necessary that benefit our students thank you Dr L Dr low followed by Tim V and then um Michael L okay um as I heard Mr Pinkerton speak I found myself wondering who Bears the responsibility of the fiscal reality of this district is it Mr Pinkerton Dr Prader I think that's too
223easy of an answer I am even tempted to believe it's solely the board who must account for the ways they've enabled a lack of discernment and a lack of foresight but I think it's us the community for not paying attention until we hear that we're losing something personally I shouldn't be the only Community member asking why did we pay for Handover research and not use it why are we paying so much for litigation for harmful staff members why are we paying for litigation to save leaders from their own egos this District paid $800,000 in litigation over last last year just for human resources alone one year systems operate as they're designed and budgets operate as they're designed and we have to evolve this conversation Beyond deficits and CVS or blaming the state or our funding
224we deserve fiscally competent oversight we don't need excuses we need reform if our district leaders refuse to evolve the board has a respons to do better I want an answer to why we didn't plan for the loss of the funds I can't help but wonder if proposing to cut TK has only been placed before the community so that the district has leverage against the teachers as they're going into negotiations to the community I'm proud of you for showing up please keep paying attention we didn't get here all of a sudden Mr Pinkerton told us that he predicted this and that the board smiled and approved recommendations over the years we have to be involved in our educational institution and I hope that you see tonight is demonstrating that we have a bigger issue at hand
225it really isn't about TK we have to interrogate the story of why we are here and planning to be here isn't good enough we have to come together as a community to solve the predicament that this board has created for us they don't have students in our schools we do so to our community please keep coming and keep paying attention uh good evening board my name is Tim Beach I am here on behalf of my children and behalf of my community I a business owner in Los Osos uh we go to a dual lingual school we were very pleased to put our daughter in a dual lingual school and she got to be part of a TK program there and I got to see the teachers firsthand have an influence on her life and a
226way that I hoped that my second daughter would to learn that you guys will be removing or even justifiably deciding to remove a program that is so essential for a dual lingual program both for people that speak Spanish and English is reprehensible what an embarrassing night for you folks to stand up here and say the things that you said to Pat yourself on your back for all of your green scores that came up on your beautiful little Rainbow of how well the Community is doing and then also in the same meeting come to us and tell us yeah we're so good we're doing this and by the way we're going to rip the foundation of what we've done and the reason those scores exist to a community that has done nothing but trust you you
227all said that there was 10 years of planning that has gone in to the understanding that this was coming down the line yet Mr Pinkerton and Miss yoshim I'm sorry I'm butchering your name Yamashita both promised my wife and I as our daughter was accepted into the TK program this year and then four days before the start of the school year told it was an error a clerical error and she would no longer be able to attend that for sure she would attend next year when you knew you were going to cut this from the budget so this is either BS posturing which is wasting my time this community time everyone else's time in this building so that you can get your money or you're ties and you knew this was coming down the pipe
228you knew you were going to cut this 10 years ago talk to me like real people talk to me like community members I run a business in this community I see these faces on a weekly basis I see their children I have seen the impact that TK has given to Loos to a Bilingual School for you guys to stand here and to be able to look at us in the eyes without shame is reprehensible we need a new board we need people that are responsible we need people who don't look at a budget and say we'll take care of that later we need people who can look at a closure in Diablo Canyon and say we're gonna have to make changes we're gonna have to make them now you are currently cutting the foundation of
229a good school district out from underneath us because you don't have money now how are you going to be able to kick that can down the road in four years in 5 years in 10 years when these problems rear their ugly head when the green goes to red when your notes and your pats on the back lead us down a road of an inept School District that's failing their student you're welcome um we have Michael low and then Milan to Lany sorry um and then Beck Banfield oh no I'm sorry and then um hold on I just need to get my well go ahead Mr Lo uh good evening um I've been a bureaucrat for a better part of a decade I've worked with local municipalities and state legislators and I just want to share
230with the board that I'm a little shocked by the boldness of staff to outright blame the board uh for the pending deficit during the presentation and I don't think they're doing a great job of supporting you in this moment um I can't believe how many times during the presentation I heard that you knew the cuts were coming and it made me question if you guys actually knew or understood what it meant while you're being told that the cuts were coming and I say that because my wife and I have been coming to board meetings now consistently um for last 18 months and I have never seen a single board member disagree with staff recommendations meaning that all of your guys' votes have been unanimous in support of what's being presented to you um the county
231superintendent just told you that enrollment growth occurs in our area because parents are not uh moving here because of how expensive it is for them while trying to get on their feet uh but in July you all voted to increase developer fees that increased our housing costs and TK is not just about educational head starts but it's about a full extra year of child care for parents that are trying to get on their feet continuing TK incentivizes young families to come to our area and I want you to see that this is an opportunity to exercise Equitable governance and I ask you to recognize the greater social impacts that your decisions or the recommendations that are coming from staff have on our community thank you hello members of the community and uh board uh as
232well as superintendant uh my name is Millie Tani and I am an early childhood education advocate in St Louis bispo um and I just as an expert in early childhood would like to share with you all the unintended consequences and the impact of the decision to cut TK could have on four-year-olds served by stainless Coastal Unified School District um as you know our early childhood that sets the foundation for all learning for our students and that 85% of a child's brain is developed by age five transitional kindergarten is an integral part of the California Department of education's rule out of universal pre kindergarten or upk we recognize that there have been difficulties in implementing such an ambitious goal of ensuring all of our children receive high quality Early Education and that being said we applaud
233St Louis Cool's dedication to our young children however this proposed cut of transitional kindergarten means that not every four-year-old and I argue many many four-year-olds would not have the opportunity for a solid Educational Foundation timless Coastal implementation of transitional kindergarten is an integral part in supporting other publicly publicly fun funded center-based Early Childhood programs like State preschool and hezer as well as all of our privately funded center-based programs and family child care homes which can't survive if transitional kindergarten is cut we urge you to reach out to additional Early Childhood partners and the families that will be impacted by this decision to cut transitional kindergarten we know there are many partners and resources that would love to share if the board is willing thank you all we have Matt pole followed by Sherry Hamil and
234then Sam Oren hi it's late now um uh sorry I for my unpreparedness I only found out about this at 5: uh tonight and an hour later after dinner was told to come here um um uh I just want to point out uh you know much of I can just reiterate everything that everyone has said I just would encourage the board to think about um a couple things one uh research has shown that there's one nice paper in the uh education of Economics review that says that TK has is estimated to have a 4 to1 benefit to cost ratio so a lot of these people are talking about the educational benefits and everything else in the medium short to medium term um but there is research out there for longterm benefits as well in terms
235of adult earnings um I'll also reiterate the people the people have talked about these other benefits and I would urge them the board to think about uh Pennywise versus Pound foolish uh you cut programs here but are you going to have to spend more to deal with the programs uh the shortfalls of uh sorry the short fols uh uh that the benefits that these TK uh produce uh third I can uh sympathize with Mr Pinkerton about telling people about possible side effects and no one really listening um I would encourage you to maybe have a different tact of talk reaching out to the PTA uh to find out to let them know you know if we knew this about this a year ago you know we could have maybe helped you Lobby the state uh
236and so forth and it's it's not just not just people that are directly affected with TK my daughter is not in TK anymore she's in fourth grade and I still sat through all of this to say this so you can have support from people that are not directly related because TK is important um budgets are hard good luck I'm gonna go home hi um my name is Shar Hammer I'm here with my husband and my daughter Marley who is two and a half we moved to St Louis bispo three years ago from overcrowded and densely populated Orange County in the promise of giving our daughter a better life in a smaller town and in a much better School District we have loved every minute of living in this community and we have enjoyed watching our
237daughter make lasting relationships of her own my father taught high school for 35 years and at s Clin High School in Orange County my entire childhood is filled with memories of my father voicing his own frustrations with his school board and the lack of appropriate appropriations of funds that had a direct effect on his ability to teach in his classroom these types of situations and lack of support led him and my mother to ultimately enroll their two daughters into private school for their entire K through 12 school years my father once won the California teacher of the year award yet he chose not to enroll his own children in the public school system I do not want that from my daughter I believe in our community I believe in public education but cutting TK is
238another example of letting our children down when they are most vulnerable as many parents in here can attest to child care in slow county is already at a crisis level it is almost impossible to find a spot for your child and if you are lucky enough to land a spot many facilities have plans in place if they have not already done so to cut their TK or four-year programs with the idea to open more space for younger families since these children are supposed to go into TK cutting TK leaves these kids in limbo and creates an even greater financial burden on already stretched families but TK is not child care TK FOC focuses on the socialization and transition into an academic setting in kindergarten all you have to do is ask a kindergarten teacher to
239get an understanding of how vital this transition is to these kiddos the difference in preparedness of children who have been exposed to an academic learning environment at four years old is vital to their future academic success as I said before I love living here but this is the biggest disappointment and potential failure of our local officials please do not fail the brightest minds of our fa of our future do not cut TK thank you we just have time for a few more Mr Sam oim made it in time uh I'm gonna switch it up and not talk about TK uh however I do hope we as a community can figure it out because it seems like the taxpayer base has some pretty strong feel about the subject um however I am here first and foremost
240as the labor rep the union rep for the CSEA classified employees of your school district um a lot of whom are here tonight and I think probably more of them would have spoken um except they realize kind of the energy of the crowd and I think they wanted to make more space for the families here which is very indicative of the the culture of classified employees that I found I also uh represent the the classified employees in the rest of the school districts in the county and my daughter goes here as well so just so you know I'm not here just advocating for the staff right I got a vested interest in my own household um what I don't want to give you all any more grief it seems like you got a lot of
241that tonight I would like to however help you get to know your classified employees a little better because I think that frequently they end up being kind of the unsung heroes of public education um originally yeah right they're amazing uh originally I wanted to do this whole thing where I was going to ask them all to like raise their hands and then lower their hands if they couldn't afford to live in slow because it would have been all of them but it's not I'm not going to do that anymore because most of them had to leave because they got to get back in the morning to take care of our kids right um what I want to direct your attention to is the state of things with a lot of your employees I know that
242there was a lot of good stuff talked talked about tonight about all the great things that your district is doing and I don't want to take away from that but I've been spending a lot of time lately talking with your classified employees and I gotta tell you there's a lot of dissatisfaction um you got tons of clerical staff that are doing medical work you got nurses that are complaining about too much Administration you have ridiculous amounts of classified employees in almost every School site in the school district that are not taking their breaks and you know look like there's some shared responsibility here right like at a certain point they just decide to keep on working they decide to keep on working because they've got our kids standing right in front of them and they
243want to do the right thing but there's a shared responsibility for that and part of that is on the leadership of this District because we have allowed a culture where we balance the budgets on the backs of the least paid employees to normalize and that's not okay um I I'm not here with all the answers tonight but I do want to say we have negotiations with CCA as well around the Corner the reason why we're not on the agenda tonight is because we're taking a little extra time to really get our ducks in a row we want to come with some creative approaches and I hope that whenever we do make ourselves to the bargaining table that we can meet all of you with open ears and open minds and we look forward to collaborating
244together car I me I may have to cut the line I need to go home to the my kid and also teach tomorrow atoly I'm a professor atoly my name is Rodrigo maning and I think this is important for you to hear I think that removal of TK is going to create a problem that I seen in my classroom a poly every quarter that is you're going to create a two population of students population of students from Rich families that were able to go to preschool at the age of five they know how to read I know what they are learning in PCO they know how to count a population of the students that are four or five year old that do not know how to count and how to read now in kindergarten and
245every other course afterwards you have two serious population of the students once that are advance and ones are not what are the professors going to do are they going to teach two classes in one as we do in cpoly if we have to we take the students that are Advanced we give them more information so they can move forward the students who are behind we pre prepare Qs sessions extra class or they are going to teach to the middle if they teach to the middle we are slowing down the ones who knew how to read but we're slowing down the ones who know how to read only here not in Atascadero not Inon now it's a problem it's a problem that did not exist before TK because before we we were slowing down everybody in
246California now if we remove TK here you're going to slow down slow down only a student here in s Louis oiso not in templon not so someone who reach might say this hasn't affect to me I have money I send my kid to preschool and the age of five knows how to read goes to kindergarten and so on is great no it's affecting everybody including the rich people because those rich kids are going to go into a class with kids that didn't know how to read either and they're going to slow down so if I reach I will take my kid out of the St Louis Obispo and take it to at tcad where everybody is going to be at level not two population of students so I know the buet I you have buet
247problems all the time I have grants I know what the money is and what the money is not but removing TK is going to cause a problem our at our professors in all the levels kindergarten and beond able to accomplish that task it's teaching top populations of students to bring them together and not as slowing down the ones who are more advanced and those who are more advanced are no more advanced are at the same level than templ that's going to be a problem here and I don't know what's the solution to this problem that's our problem okay thank you um I'm Cheryl shereff proceed I'm so sorry and then Elizabeth turbo and Lauren Shaw good evening my name is cherl Shiva Prasad I am a school psychologist in our school district working primarily at
248Hawthorne and also at s shimer um I'm also the mother of Everett who is a wouldbe member of the 2627 Hawthorne Eagle cohort um but I know we have a lot of representation of those parents so I'm going to talk on behalf of the school syes um our group went into a little bit of a frenzy when the presentation with the numbers on school psych ratios and increases in Staffing um in that like others have stated the numbers just didn't seem sound and looking into it um initially the presentation it has since been corrected said that we grew by 10 school psychologist positions when in actuality uh it's only been four since Co occurred um what wasn't mentioned either is that before we increased that for since covid the past two directors have regularly contracted
249with outside school psychologist agencies because of the impact of our case loads and that we haven't had sufficient time we've been underst staffed and so um really where we are now is that we're able to meet the demands of the Assessments in our school district um as well as providing our ursus Services um so that was challenge also are ratios um I think that the way it's been portrayed it's hard to really nail down the school psychologist position because we can be used very differently across different districts yes our national average right now not National our state average um it's not quite 1 to 1,000 the last solid numbers are that um it's 1 to 814 that's who we're being compared to um um in California and saying that our numbers are one to 541
250within our district um so that is not the case in the sense that we cover Ursa Services we have five and a half school psychologist positions that are directly related and tied to student IEPs so if you look at our allocation purely um towards assessments and other school responsibilities and the way that we're being compared to our other peers in the state our numbers are actually 1 to 993 um so so much of our Workforce is devoted to Direct Services which is a wonderful model but other districts don't use that same model so um similarly to what other people have said I see my time is almost up um we are a group that would love to be a part in shouldering the burden of the work that you have to do and would um
251invite a visit to the school psych group at any time because we have a lot of input and um we want to be heard as shareholders as well as many other people in this room thank you so much okay thank you I'm sorry we have gone over the hour that we allowed for public comment on this item two people that we do the these two so my name is Elizabeth Martin one we should we should at least give this person the opportunity are we are I had indicated I called the names of Elizabeth turo and and uh Lauren Shaw and those will be our last our last two speakers an important if we could have these speakers and then we'll discuss it with the board I don't know what I thought speak she's up here
252Elizabeth turbo is at the microphone um my name is Elizabeth turbo and my children will be third generation students to go through this school district my son is supposed to attend TK in the fall and he is so so so excited about it we go to Bishop's Peak on the weekend and he calls it his school he's he's unbelievably excited and I don't know how I'd break the news to him if this opportunity got taken away from him this afternoon was a whirlwind I spent it connecting with other parents who are scared and nervous for the future because everyone's Futures are up in the air I also spent the afternoon calling my local representatives and state representatives to tell them about this meeting some of which did not know this topic was up for discussion
253which seemed concerning I didn't plan on speaking tonight but very honestly the budget um presentation made me very upset the tone was extremely condescending and it seem as though the decision was already made um my big question from the presentation is I truly don't understand how you could build programs on a one-time funds and not plan for the future it doesn't make any sense why are our students the ones to suffer under what seems like bad management of the budget hi my name is Lauren Shaw this is my first year for slow being hired by slow I'm a par educator I did work last year for slow but I was an agency par um I am on the pr Council for Los Ranchos um I just want to talk real quick I fell in love
254with my job last year as an agent two parent and I got the privilege to be a par this year for slow and I'm so greatly appreciative but I feel like if we cut back Paris our classrooms are getting bigger instead and we right now we're not fully staffed and we're dealing with things that are crazy every day if I were to tell you I'm not I don't want to complain I love my job I love being there every single day I'm going to drive home an hour to get up at 5:00 to be back at work tomorrow morning I'm going to do with a smile on my face as I absolutely love it but we have pars who are taking the breaks crying because we don't get breaks we don't get to tap out
255we don't get to do things because we are understaffed and we do not have the staff to be able to swap we don't have the avilability just to be like oh okay I'm just not going to go to work today because no one's going to be there to take our spots we do not have steps we do not have Replacements we the ones that are going to be online if our job so much come on we love our jobs so much to where if we're sick we don't want to call off because we know we're not going to get that sub if we're we have other priorities I'm a mom too and my kids don't have a TK school I am a TK and Kinder class special day by the way just to put that
256out there and I love that when I say I work for sers Coastal they're like you work for a great School District I wish I was at your school I wish I worked for you guys work every time I talk about St Louis Coast my kids go to Orchid and they didn't have TK they don't have TK at work at they have like one one school that has it and it's like half day and I think it's so important for our kids especially special education kids to have that early access because we get to get that IP in we get to get them set on their school their goals and get them to be in Janet eventually and get them to be so on schedule and get them regulated get them used to school and
257stop behaviors we I work with kids who have massive behaviors and if I don't have the staff power to tap out or to have my teacher who's getting hurt constantly because no one is there we if we cut back on Paras and we cut back on special education our classrooms is going to get bigger and our behaviors are going to get worse our kids cannot handle being in a class of 30 and that's why they earn instead so I feel like that's the most important thing is that we take a look at special education and Paris and keeping the regulated ratios please and according to I thank you so now the Board needs to make a decision we're well over the hour that we allotted um for public comment on these items but we have
258public that continues to want to make comments what what is the pleasure of the board how many more yellow forms do we have well we only have a few yellow forms but we have about 12 people who had submitted forms online earlier who hav't some of them some of them have um a couple of them have spoken already but many several have not so I I think it's important for us to hear from the public however I do think that we have other business to attend to and i would support allowing the people that have signed up to continue to speak but I would say that we need to reduce the time from three minutes to two minutes is yourtime more important than you know we this is a discussion Among Us right now so
259just hold off please for a second sorry Mrs Roger okay our meeting okay well so what okay so we have 14 more speakers that doesn't and that doesn't includes zom so separate from uh my bedtime or your bed time um there's like there's there's kids here to present on future topics and I I I want to be respectful to our whole agenda but I I definitely want to hear everyone I I mean I I think asking us to be concise and and really make good point is is a fair ask if we can hear everyone um is that Spirit good yeah I would definitely support that to go to two minutes um Mrs yeah I'd like to continue to hear from everyone um but I would really just implore people to not repeat anything that
260has been said if you have something different to add to the conversation because I assure you we are hearing all of it we um we want to hear from you um but we do have a full agenda that we need to get through when can we have a meeting where these things can be discussed I'm not sure if I can be heard but I think this deserves more time this is oh I don't either so are we going to go to the okay so what we'll do is we'll go ahead and um hear public comment from the people who have submitted requests and those who submitted online so the 14 people but we'll reduce to two minutes please because we have other items on this agenda and a lot of people here to speak to
261um the other agenda items as well so all right so hearing that um we'll the clock will be changed from to two minutes you guys got it okay so then we have Heather Benson Jane pomoy and Sally llas I I wanted to but okay uh Heather Benson okay great good evening to everyone in the room and uh thank you for staying for staying so long uh my name is Heather and I'm an employee in Stan Louis Coastal I understand the value behind the TK TK program but I also fully understand the importance of employees as Mr Pinkerton mentioned this district is run by people teachers secretaries par Educators it professionals Etc without people this District would not function and without people there couldn't be programs like the TK program I would like to urge the
262board to prioritize Staffing and to consider scaling back the DK program rather than cutting it out completely we have had the TK Lottery successfully in the past and I wonder if this could be a good compromise at least until we hopefully get the state funding we rightfully deserve thank you for your time hi my name is Jane Pomo I'm here wearing two hats uh first I'm the mother of a three-year-old in preschool at brightlife play school which has been impacted by the TK roll out they had to close their TK campus um but I'm also here as the Community Partnerships manager with Community Action Partnership of St Louis bisbo County I'm here to ask the district to consider having discussions with caps slow and other Community Partners to develop options for families we're committed to
263addressing Early Learning and child care opportunities in 10 counties of California and of several Partnerships with school districts from San Diego to Monterey we are open to discussing ways to partner and we're really good at coming up with Innovative Creative Solutions to complex problems and doing it collaboratively so please reach out thank you hi my name is Sally llas I've been here with the district six years I was a par educator at slow high school and then I came to Simer and was a par of there and this year I'm an aid and what I think we can all agree is that we love who support our children and we love the programs otherwise we wouldn't have started them it is our responsibility all of us not just you all of us and there are
264things we can figure out about how we use our money and how we communicate to each other so everyone has buyin and understands what's going on in a good amount of time so that we can all put in our talents and ideas before it becomes a crisis but it's our responsibility as a community to support what we know is helping we know that TK is helping we know I know that Paris help counselors help intervention helps we all agree on this so here's a weird idea it may not work but we have been using technology more and more we did online school during covid what about something like a GoFundMe account where we ask our community this is our school your school our school it's all of our school could we do something like a
265GoFundMe um would you support one perah for a year until we get things figured out maybe with the state would you support one resource teacher how about a TK teacher how could we think outside the box Syria did amazing things with technology Obama perhaps got elected because of Technology how can we use our technology to spread the word to the people who are invested everybody even if they don't have a child are is invested in this entire Community these are the people who grew up to go to high school who grew up thank you thank you um so then uh we have Stephanie McDonald Nathan adamsky and Emily Hardy hi good evening my name is Stephanie McDonald I'm coming to you this evening as a human resources professional in the county um I've worked at
266cply I now work for a private business in town and probably interviewed over a hundred to a thousand candidates wanting to relocate back to slow the two things that they say are hindrances availability of affordable housing which we all know and availability of child care my kids are actually out of the TK and you know potential seen for this to be a personal issue this is an economic decision if you look at the initiatives that the reach Council are looking to do and Implement if you look at the I innovate lab initiatives they all Trace back to education and how we prepare our students to become servants in our community and to be able to stay and live and raise a family that contribute to this community taking away TK will absolutely impact that thank
267you hi first thank you well thank you for for letting me speak um I'll try to be quick I just wanted to Advocate um for my my daughter she was her due date was um March 16th uh 2020 but she was born December 2nd 2019 she was 1 PB 5 O and she spent 3 months in the NICU and um by all you know by all metrics she should be behind you know mentally and socially just just by her development but in in Miss Max's class she's thriving and she's so proud to be a stinger and she loves going to school and I just want to thank you guys so much for giving her that opportunity and the amount of amazing staff that she has met and how much they've changed her life I I
268I couldn't imagine um how how I can't even think of what she would be like differently so I just want to say thank you she um today like I was telling her what I was going to do and and we were kind of describing it and she kind of mirrored but she said it cuter than I said she said you gotta go fight for miss Ma dad and I was like okay it's pretty easy so so there we go so that's it thank you guys thank you very much hey Emily Hardy then Ellison Hobs then uh Christine slom hello I'm Emily Hardy thank you for the opportunity to speak and make him up decision um I'm a mom of two I have a first grader at Baywood and an almost four-year-old who we planned on
269starting TK in the fall I've seen things go out about TK registrations so this whole thing about this not being a surprise is kind of shocking to hear because I've seen things about it from the the schools um I also have to be a credentialed teacher and former Elementary educator my family has been happy so far with our experience in St Louis Coastal but one thing that has come up recently is that we wish that my now six-year-old son had had the opportunity to be eligible for TK he was not so he did struggle some with learning how to learn in kindergarten and that you know we see that that TK helps bridge the gap I taught kindergarten in a California public school and I have seen fir the difference that TK can make our
270academic state standards for kindergarten are intense and they are much more intense than when I was in kindergarten which was in the 2000s and I imagine much more intense than when everyone in this room was in kindergarten and understanding that understanding the foundation that TK gives for students in kindergarten is important important ly this decision to end TK in the district will not necessarily hurt the children of families with the time education and resources to support their children before kindergarten there are other ways that those families can ensure that their children have a strong Foundation entering our school system instead the decision to end TK programs will absolutely disproportionately affect those children of families who do not have access to Quality preschool or the ability to spend the considerable amount of time and energy it
271takes to teach the foundational skills to their children it will disproportionately affect children of families who do not speak English at home which are children we've talked about today it will affect children of parents with lower educational status and children with both parents working outside of the home thank you thank you our children deserve Christin slom then Alec buckon then Ryan Walter okay then we'll go to Alec buckton Ryan Walter and then Ricardo CA noo hi I'm Alec buckton um father of two one is in TK right now one we were hoping to go in 2026 or 20 yeah 2026 I was going to talk about all the things that um I've watched my own son gather gain from TK it's been an amazing thing but honestly I just wanted to take a step back
272and just say I think I speak for a lot of us when we say that we're just shocked by this most of us heard about it today you say we've heard about it we knew it was coming 10 years ago or more um it just I don't know I mean the shock of it is just too much it feels honestly like a failure you say that it's Sacramento we should be going to and honestly I would love to be there behind you going back to them if that's really what it is but it feels like we should have been having that conversation a year ago or more and the fact that most of us know about it now is it just it's disappointing um sorry just really disappointing um what it makes it feel like
273especially as you go through the spreadsheets and the salaries and all those things is you're trying to pit us against our teachers who are doing so much for our children and I just really want everyone here in this room to not let that happen because we they're on our side I want us all to be on our same side so if there's something we can do to go back to Sacramento or whatever the idea is we have to go back to it but I think we can not cut any of these things and still have the the school program and meet our budgetary whatever that fiscal responsibility thing you're saying is so thank you than hi good evening uh my name is Ryan waler I'm a local educator at calply um I also have a
274proud I'm a proud parent of a student at Hawthorne he's currently in kindergarten he had the wonderful opportunity to go with TK with Miss lyd Moffett who you heard about of earlier she's the most wonderful human being that I know uh one of them my wife's watching on Zoom so don't tell her um but uh you know she is just amazing and I can say that TK has been one of the most foundational influential experiences for my son um to this date and so I won't go on and on about all the research and evidence based of how influential T can be from an economic social you know cognitive perspective um trust me can go on and on about that but what I'm here to talk about today is the decision that you all have
275before you right you look at the reserves there's currently more than 25 to30 million 25 to30 million currently in reserves right and that's according to your website on the budget and that is four times of economic uncertainty certainty the state has a mandate or a law that requires 3% of operating expenses the board approved rate is 10% of operating expenses 10% is around $14 million that means there's still nine plus 10 plus million dollars available in reserves for times of economic uncertainty the board members are giving me this look like they never knew about that Dr Prader I hope that you can uh you know speak to that Mr Pink I hope that you can speak to that right the irresponsibility to know this 10 years into the future you talk about fiscal irresponsibility I
276understand that that is your agenda to limit fiscal irresponsibility but this is fiscal irresponsibility 10 years in the making creating this issue use the reserves to keep the foundation of our youngest brightest Minds in this area Okay use the $25 million for economic uncertainty this is a time okay and another option your time is up thank you I would like to according to according to your rules I'm allowed to finish my last sentence that is in your bylaws so I'd like to finish my last sentence in that there are also three assistant superintendents that each make a quarter million dollars of year that right there one assistant superintendent is the equivalent of three TK classrooms if you look at teacher salaries so if you want to consider all options let's consider that this is uh
277rard followed by Martin lap and then Karina Howard hello I'll be quick my oldest went to TK aacho was amazing my youngest is now going to go and with deal with that it seems I just wanted to point out in the numbers that you saw us today you saw us over the past five years an increasing enrollment of 1% a total increase in Staffing of 20% and an increase in non-class staff of 86% or most of it seems to be funded by onetime funds I just wanted to point that out thank thank you hello my name is Martine Lee I am a parent of a Hawthorne eagle and I'm very proud of that status I also am a um professor at uh calpol where I'm a sociologist and I'm a faculty fellow at the Harvard
278Center on the developing child and I'm speaking today as a concerned parent about the decision to potentially close the transitional kindergarten program but also as a researcher who studies the incredible impact that early life has on the um life course of individuals but not only that on intergenerational well-being so I want to talk about my own experience of TK I had the value of um enrolling my son in TK um in 2022 and it was very clear from the very beginning that it was a magical program and I encourage every single person on this board to visit the TK classrooms that you are considering closing because it will change your life um we had the privilege of having Miss Lloyd Moffett and miss Monica teach my son Henry and he thrived I'm cutting my comments
279a bit shorter than I intended today in the interest of time but in short I want to say that he we saw tremendous growth in our son and witnessed his love for uh learning truly Blossom however our son also experienced disregulation and challenges as an early learner that many four and five-year-olds experience the teachers were incredibly well equipped and uniquely qualified to meet those needs those are valuable skills that my son now holds in his heart and in his mind knowing that Educators and adults will protect him create a safe space for him and support him through the advocacy of his teachers we discovered that he had a significant hearing loss that he had likely had since birth it meant his little body was working overtime and the teachers advocated for him to have the
280services he needed because the teams were in place to provide those resources I want to just say that my daughter is also excited to start TK in the fall fall you are pulling the rug out from underneath parents who have prepared for years for this opportunity and I implore you to think about the opportunity to make a more positive decision with the budet thank you Daniel Justin filed by followed by Kylie Singh is Daniel Justice in here uh Kylie Singh okay those are all the speakers I have okay before we move on to the next agenda item I think that uh we need to take a short break two people signed up online I don't have them okay um if you could approach you'll have two minutes and state your name please so we can
281have it I don't have those so uh good evening my name is Dr Ryan Boo and I'm a member of this community and a proud parent of a current TK student as well as a third grader at hawthor elementary I'm speaking today on behalf of my family to voice my opposition to the proposal to end a TK program so my family and I moved to San Louis abiso in 2021 so that I could start my dream job here uh which was a 10e track professorship to teach Asian-American and Pacific Islander studies at calp my family and I quickly discovering when we moved here though that San Louis abiso while beautiful is an extremely unaffordable place to live not only did we find that the rent was astronomical but regular Child Care was almost impossible the
282cost for child care was too high and the wait list for too long and it became not practical for my wife and I to both work outside the home I speak for myself but I know for a fact that many families in this area struggle with this exact same dilemma there are many ways to tell people you aren't welcome in this town and one way is to make it hard to live here I think and hope that many would agree with me that every family regardless of their income deserves child care not just those families who can afford it when our son reached um the age to be accepted into TK we jumped at the chance since starting with Miss fion Lloyd Moffet this past August we have seen our son's development grow Leaps and
283Bounds every single day my wife and I get to witness how our son's universe is expanding how his sense of curiosity and wonder grows every day before entering Miss Lloyd moffett's class my son was very introverted but now he eagerly approaches other kids his age to ask if they'd like to play his language and his ability to verbally Express himself are also skyrocketing the very fact that all of these developments happen happen in these ways over the course of five short months is no coincidence and we give all our thanks and appreciation to miss Lloyd Moffett and other Educators like her who dedicate their time and energy to attend the delicate Garden which is our children transitional kindergarten is proving to be an Irreplaceable foundation for my child's ability to learn and grow but most
284importantly to enjoy school it's a successful program that benefits All Families thank you make the right decision make our life easier not harder thank you you could state your name please yes of course um my name is Jason Chung um I am a father of a TK student um who goes to Hawthorne and I just wanted to share just real short um so my daughter is enrolled in TK like I said um over at Hawthorne and the experience has been nothing more uh or nothing nothing short of transformative TK has provided her with an incredible Foundation helping her Thrive academically develop a sense of community and grow remarkably in her social and emotional awareness and confidence um this year has been pivotal time for her offering the freedom to think independently Explore her world and
285under the expert guidance of two exceptional TK teachers um Amanda chass Alexander and Fiona Lloyd Moffett um they're dedication and nurturing care have profoundly profoundly impacted my daughter and countless other students uh I cannot overstate the importance of preserving this program um uh for her and for other students it's an investment in our children's growth and success and we simply cannot afford to lose it uh I strongly urge you to explore alternative Solutions and this is where I go off script um as parents we we will support things like things that you offer up to us we will help you um this community is is fantastic lean on us and we will help you that's it thank you hi I'm Jamie Lewis um I have three kids in The District Two in high school one
286in the special education program and one well she'll soon to be in the district she starts TK in the fall and I've just been here crying and sweating for this entire meeting because this is pretty heartbreaking and I don't envy your position but it's also really hard for us and I hope that you have taken to heart all the stories you've heard tonight and really think about what it would mean to our community to lose this program and for all of us individually financially for our long-term prospects as a community as a County uh I just yeah everyone's already said all the things things but thank you thank you to everyone for being here um parents could you state your name please my name is Jen sley thank you to everyone being here teachers parents
287staff everyone who devotes their lives to making sure our community our schools um are the best they can be and every child's life is important and thank board member for being here um your job is tough your seats are lonely and I imagine you're exhausted every decision is easy if you'll get all the facts and I hope that if you haven't had a chance to step into the TK classrooms you will as community members not just as board members and many important things have been said this evening but one thing I I'm I don't remember hearing is we don't just have TK we have world class gold standard TK and that's because we have world class gold standard TK teachers please visit Miss Lloyd maet at Hawthorne or Master Garcia at Pacho and be renewed
288by the energy of what you see there and more importantly what you feel there so that you can go back to those spreadsheets and head to Sacramento renewed by that energy I had a friend from Africa visiting recently he went into the classroom yesterday and he said wow if we had this type of education we would have no problems left in the continent there's a lot of great wisdom from the continent a lot of tree analogies one generation plants a tree the next enjoys the shade let's not be a generation that cutting down the trees that we've planted and let's remember that if you have a branch with especially beautiful fruit even if it's the newest Branch that's not the branch that we cut off thank you everyone in the room has had an opportunity
289to speak we do have some people on Zoom okay we have some people waiting on Zoom what is the pleasure of the board um I need a three minute bathroom break we absolutely need a break we'll be taking a break but uh do we want to go ahead and listen uh hear from the people on Zoom with the twom minute um caveat and if anyone had written in already you that counts as your as your comment please don't double up okay three people on Zoom um it's my understanding we may run into a battery issue also before launch so when we take a break we'll be fixing battery okay okay well if we only have three people on Zoom three and then the break okay so I have Jake Jacob Johnson Paige robard and Carolyn
290BD Zoom so you to sign Jacob Johnson in two minutes am I good to go yes yes hi I'm Jacob Johnson um I'm a par educator I actually work with Miss Moffett or I've had the pleasure of working wither this year wonderful other people have touched better on all the benefits of TK um one of the things I want to note and I'm curious about I think he been kind of touched on but the costs of not having TK and the value of early intervention I think are likely to cost the district more down the line in terms of the intervention required to fix problems caught later and I I wonder is others have mentioned if it's worth dipping into some of the budget Reserve to keep the program to avoid those costs having to
291incur those costs later um I think that's pretty much all I have to say um I know you guys have a lot to consider thanks for being here for us thank you paig P hi thank you um I won't spend time telling you the reasons why we need TK and special services for our kids you already know them well and we all know they're critical um it's obvious that it's not a needs issue it's a money issue I I have the ultra fun experience of being the parent of a student with high functioning autism he is in second grade I also have a kindergartner both at Hawthorne my son um being high functioning on the autism spectrum puts him in this massive gray area of students that are in general education settings that need more
292support across the board I've seen firsthand over the last 3 years in this school district that our students are routinely not being served well because of lack of funding and lack of Staff our teachers are working overtime so hard to serve our students and still our meetings are getting missed my son this school year alone has had three changes in his par educator and quite frankly while the par educators are wonderful and well-intentioned the district's um standards for hiring someone as an ed a parent educator is just North of a warm body with a pulse so how do we fix this how does our district get the attention it needs to get funding will a lawsuit do it Sacramento School District knows a little bit about that will when people are named as defendants does
293that give them motivation to dig a Little Deeper I'm curious about that personally just because you've known this is going to happen doesn't make it acceptable um I I appreciate your that you guys are apologetic but quite frankly your condolences are worthless to our children I understand budgets and administration is difficult I have experience in the corporate and legal sector in those ways but when you're failing our children you're failing and that's it full stop so we need a better solution um you we this is what you say to us in our these meetings um many of us know the reality of the situation is what's not put on the presentation slide um I'll close with this in the midst of fighting through the cat and mouse game of getting basic services for my son
294I will finish my sentence thank you I asked one of his teachers if our family a household with two working native English speaking parents with access to resources have had such a hard time getting the district to budge to give my son basic services that are owed to him how do families with less advantaged circumstances get any help for their children and that teacher's answer was and I quote they don't and the district counts on it thank you very much Carolyn B hi thank you for having all of us here this evening um I will keep it brief I'm a new mom of a baby girl and a future family of your Simer school um and I have a niece and nephew who go to Hawthorne and TK and first and I just wanted to
295State at the beginning of this how much of a positive impact and um how much our schools have helped those kids Bloss and Friends kids Blossom and become their full selves and um so I just appreciate all the work of your staff and your leadership um I'm also a local business owner and well before ever having kids I've been a huge supporter of the positive impact of schools on communities and I just there's no need to restate all of the things that you've heard tonight in terms of affordability of child care Equity of education and so many other things but there a few speakers who spoke about the economic importance of schools as well and I just wanted to offer up you know one potential action that we as a community could be talking about
296and looking into is could local businesses be part of a funding partnership they talk a lot about the need for child care to create affordability and equity for their staff who can't afford this area so could local businesses employers Chambers and reach Maybe be a part of a conversation on how to maintain especially TK which helps parents of younger children um and as my brother-in-law Jason said earlier you know know that we not just parents but the broader Community are here ready to work together and find Solutions um and I hope that you'll pull everyone in I think going deeper than just you know several of the speakers uh giving presentations talked about the need for parents to show up and advocate but in what ways it would be really helpful to know the school
297district's policy platform or specific ways that we could be helpful in the Diablo Andor State advocacy thank you very much thank thank you okay I I think a break is in order yeah so it is 10:27 let's take a uh 10 minute break 10:37 e e e you see that on to um item 10.03 middle school programs and the grow teach parent initiative uh now now you can hear me okay um good evening board and Community um thank you for allowing us time to connect with our grow teach parents and students and former students that are here with us tonight to discuss uh their recommendation for a possible teach expansion into grades 7th and 8th grade this um I want to start with a little bit of History which was last spring the board had
298both public comments as well as written correspondence submitted by many of the community members that are here tonight to encourage us to consider expanding teach to seventh and eth grade it currently is a school of choice for grades fourth fifth and sixth grade there is a lottery for students to join and currently um for the past few years all the students wishing to attend the school have been able to attend the school um because the lottery children leave and then new students get LED in over the course of a school year Etc um so these parents had known that we are doing um great planning with Mr Pinkerton around measure C and the development of the teach campus right now Soka is there um and we have you know known that they were going to
299be moving out so that we could do renovations to the campus and it seemed to the teach initiative parents that it would be the right time to try and make a capital investment and restructure programming so after multiple meetings where their presence was known and heard and listened to by the board it was requested that I meet with the teach community at large um and we held a community parent Forum that was a bit of an informational session thank you to Mrs contras um who was there representing lososo middle school and Mr Jones who was able to attend representing Luna Middle School Mr nef and Miss Shepard were all there and we were able to engage with the community to hear more um about what makes teach so special and what they would like to
300see continued at our other middle schools and what other implications they could see might happen um if we were to expand teach so following that repeated engagement and I shared the responses with you board um in a teach FAQ document um back in I believe it was November I'd have to see when that was developed um but following that recommendation with their request was to have the board you know consider expanding teach and so that was the purpose and development of this presentation tonight so we are actually going to begin looking at really our Continuum of Middle School programming because this would be one part of that so we'll begin with Mrs Keras showing sharing about osus middle school and um Miss min Mr Miner is here to share about Laguna middle school with his
301team followed by The Grow teach um parents and they will have five to eight minutes to speak about the proposal which has been shared with all of you um and then Dr Prader will share his recommendations moving moving forward so with us with that Miss curus if you can please join me um up here [Laughter] hell good to see you all hello everyone uh I'm Heather contris principal at the wonderful lososo middle school and I have here good evening board my name is Vanessa Parsons I'm the assistant principal at losos Middle School all right okay so lomes is a school who cares about our students growth we are a student centered Community Guided by Three core values of building Community being responsible and being thoughtful and caring the Coastal Community including our students and parents
302care about the environment being neighborly and wanting the best for their kids we are on slide three just thank you we are deeply committed to fostering a vibrant and diverse student population where every lion feels valued our focus on belonging equity and inclusion ensures that all students have the opportunity to thrive regardless of identity or background through a supportive and weling environment we are dedicated to helping every learner succeed and reach their full potential if you refer to the visual that we have on the slide deck you can see we currently have 486 students enrolled we have 55% students that are socioeconomically disadvantaged which is a little lower than our state but as you can see a little higher than our County we have 5% English Learners 177% with student disabilities and 7% of our
303students are experiencing um home challenges with 1% Foster youth lom's continues to perform well in Statewide assessments we see the need to personalize support and are always looking at other ways to close our achievement gaps with dedicated teachers and motivated Learners our students continue to show growth the following data reflects students who met or exceeded grade level standards we have 63% in English 46% in math 49% in science and 71% of our English learning students have made progress in English language proficiency we've also lowered our chronically absent rates and suspensions while still maintaining a safe and restorative approach to discipline our youth truth survey was fantastic this year we had 100% of our students participate 80% of staff and 51% of our families it's excellent thank you and thank you to my loms community we
304saw increases in every question but one and saw statistically significant increases in engagement academics culture diversity and inclusion we are also very proud of our ongoing commitment to Excellence since 2018 lomes has been recognized as a national school to watch the schools to watch organization uh ensures that we are constantly re-evaluating our programs based on an extensive rubric in the areas of academic excellence developmental responsiveness social equity and organizational structures and and processes we are a school chosen to participate in a national study on using data to improve School climate by the Learning policy Institute one reason lomes was selected is because of the work our student Senators do with our youth Tru survey results the studies Linked In This presentation for anyone who wants to read more about that we are also a school
305who was recently named a best middle school which I wholeheartedly agree with we also celebrate being recipients of local grants from slow Subaru and slow Sprouts I'd like to give a special shout out to Mrs Stoneman and her dedication and Visionary work to our school garden that earned us a $10,000 Sprouts Grant okay our students have the opportunity to engage in many enriching experiences most recently we had our band perform at our pack and and they're also able to participate in enriching exciting field trips and also see guest speakers we have over 10 diverse clubs at loms um including heavy metal um most recently crochet because of the high demand and um that students are able to explore their passions and really find their genius additionally we have a robust counseling support system that really
306um caters to our students needs we have our own version version of our Wellness cent of a Wellness Center called our counseling enrich Center where students are able to check in throughout the day and leave regulated additionally we have a team of two counselors one is bilingual we also work in conjunction with our County to have a a Pei counselor look um and see groups of kids and then we have a true tier three intervention intervention support with our mft who sees students oneon-one around 40% of our students are involved in a leadership role our goal is to be as student driven as possible this is seen in our leadership students creating and leading pep rallies student Senators facilitating listening sessions with their peers to learn more about why students responded in a particular way
307on a survey question and then follow through with actions and our advisory Representatives meeting as a student council to hear from all of the LOM students at lomes we offer an array of sports including um oops wrestling and um via Morrow Bay High School our brother's school um so students are able to engage with students from the high school and make connections early on we also have 11 different sports offered annually so it's no surprise that 60% of our students either participate in one or more of our Sports at loms so go lions in addition our lunch intermurals and leagues are available for students every four to six weeks during lunch we have many students to observe and cheer on and it's just a fun and inclusive way to get involved when we think about
308loans we think about a school where fun kindness and giving back are prior prioritized along with the place where we learn from both our achievements and our mistakes we are a school Community aiming for every student and family to feel valued and connected we continue to celebrate students through their achievements and just to keep them also engage so for example for achievements in academics and citizenship we have Coan breakfast where we recognize students for their outstanding GPA we also are dedicated to fostering strong connections with our families so for example we were able to rent out the moral Bay theater recently and our have our first annual family night out our movie night out and watch the movie Elf um which was awesome we also have an upcoming Bingo night to welcome families on campus
309and then we want to welcome you we have on the lawn this Friday where families are able to come on our field and have picnics with our students we're also looking for parent volunteers if you guys are interested as well as we have over 70% of our students attend our dances if you'd like to get to know Lums more please do not hesitate to call us um this is our um contact information our Instagram has over 600 followers and so we're very proud of that in our community um we also have our website email and location listed so thank you and one more thing we have our student created promotional school video courtesy of Mr Garcia's class linked here for you to view later and again as Miss Parson said uh Vanessa please join us
310for our lunch on the lawn we also have an upcoming pep rally on January 31st you're welcome to um in addition to gardening we have something for everybody so um we look forward to having you thank you thank you Lon we appreciate that and next up Mr Miner and lagona Middle School P this presentation want oh there it's up okay it's not up here well good evening school board we're happy to be here tonight and I'm here with one of my two assistant principles Chris Jones um we apologize the Third of our team had another commitment tonight and so they weren't able to be here with us so um Liz Den is also an amazing outstanding member of our team and uh she looks forward to joining us sometime in the future so we're going
311to go ahead and jump in we're excited to talk about lagona we love our school we're really proud of it um Laguna is an amazing place and has been that way for many years and yet I can say this um our staff is continuously thinking about how we can grow and improve what we do um in fact we were just today um having great deep conversations and appre appreciate you being there Erica um and Lisa you were there as well um about just things we could continue to Tinker with and make our school a better place um and so it's been a fun process to continue to do that and pursue that over the last few years as I've gotten to be there as a principal so um two things I want you to know
312we have two kind of guiding goals as a School site um that guide everything we do first one is about wanting all of our students and staff um to be safe connected and supported in our school Community we see this as foundational it's difficult to get to the work that is actually schools um in learning and thriving in the classroom and in other activities if these things aren't happening and so um throughout the presentation you're going to see both of these things um and the ways that we pursue this at lagona middle school and a lot of fun and unique and very Middle School ways um so want you to know a little bit about our community so we have around 800 students this year this is our data from last year um and it's
313a diverse group um one thing I absolutely love is this beautiful moment of bringing together um students from across our community from a variety of elementary schools even schools outside of our districts um into one Middle School in which we get to really create this community that then will move together for the next six years two at lagona and then four at sloh High um and really just looking around our campus we have such a diverse Campus of students with all kinds of backgrounds and experiences and it is beautiful to see and it was fun to see it through other people's eyes even today um of just how um each friend group even is so diverse and who's interacting and engaging and watching those new bonds build as kids come together in Middle School um
314I also want to add because a huge part of our diverse Community is our parent Community um we really see parents as key Partners as we work together to help students through what many of us remember is some of our hardest developmental years um regardless of how great it actually might have been just because of the awkwardness of those transitions that experience emotionally and socially and physically through Middle School um and it is so fun to partner with parents as we work together um to do that work and we have so many opportunities for parents to volunteer um PT our PTA is very active and engaged with our school we have a very interactive elac um that's super engaged in what we're doing um and there's just all kinds of opportunities for us to collaborate
315around individual students and around our school in general with our parents Community as well um I also want to just point out that we could not do what we do without our incredible staff um we are as you can see a uniquely goofy group um and that is important when you work with middle schoolers all day every day and they are incredible um and they do such a great job working with students and each of these people purposely chose middle school and we all get that same response everywhere we go when we tell people what we do Middle School why Middle School um and every single person on our campus is just thrilled to explain that middle school is their favorite phase to work with u so I'm super grateful for these people that I
316get to work alongside every day as we pursue those goals together of supporting our students and connecting with them but then also seeing them grow to be the most successful people they can be I also want to highlight just the fact that we have countless activities at our school um in that top left you can see a picture of our Monster Mash dance um this last year in the fall we had 52 students show up to that and I'm particularly proud that 12 of those 512 were every every single one of our newcomer students newcomers are students in their first two years in US schools um and we work hard to draw in students that might to normally try to slip to the periphery of what our school is and as a big school um
317that was something that I was incredibly proud of our team and pursuing and connecting with students to where they felt comfortable showing up to something that they've never even heard of before many of them because they had never had a school dance um and so it's really exciting and then lots of lunchtime activities and fun chances to connect we have dress up days um every other Friday and as you can see our students get very into it some of the pictures of our staff they get very into it it's just chances to be goofy and fun together in fact last Friday was bring a stuffy day and we had an incredible number of students and staff show up with their favorite stuffed animal um and some of them were ridiculous and silly and some were
318genuinely this is the one I've SW slept with since I was a little kid um and you could just tell that it was worn and loved and it's so fun to just get to know kids in different ways through these things I also want to highlight the fact that we have some incredible things happening um in addition to um just these fun big schoolwide events we have uh 17 clubs this year and you can see a long list of different things that have existed over the last couple of years um that our students are heavily involved in in fact currently we have uh 270 students that are actively involved in our clubs at lunch um and that is huge for these kids to find these different things that they can get involved in and meet
319their people this one of my favorite things to hear is kids say at my elementary school I was the only kid that liked this and now I found a group of kids that all like this together um and that's one cool thing as students come together and connect and I also want to highlight we have uh three uh Academic Teams two of which are new this year we have an Esports team um we have a mock trial team and we also have a robotics team that are all um preparing and competing together on um together against other schools which is pretty exciting and I'm going to hand it to Mr Jones for a couple of other highlights good evening just to Echo Mr Miner's comments regarding this time in students lives when they're Middle School
320it's it is an awkward time it's time of transition and time of change and finding their people is a critical part this might not be the people they're going to be with for the rest of the education but for for that time it's an important time to find people that find have similar interests and that's why it's this critical that we have these clubs and we have to thank our teachers for the time that they put into support supporting them our students also kind of finding the right place for that students want to hang out uh it's it's it's Unique to the student and there our school environment we have you know during our break time and during lunchtime students have different choices the places they can go uh we have students that just want
321to socialize in the quad a lot of our students take advantage of that others that go out on a black top and they'll they'll play uh basketball or some to go out on the grass and play football and and and but then you have some students that uh just want to go in the library and just want to spend time with a few students doing like a a small quiet task uh I actually have uh a student at lagona and that's my kid he likes to go in the library and I went in there today and to ask him if he was gonna see the sunshine at some point and he was just content building a tower uh with the D Jenga blocks that were in there and that's and that's you know that what
322works for him and his his social group uh I also want to touch uh touch on our Athletics and one of the great things about lagona is the majority of the sports that we have will take all Commerce um prior to this year I was in the classroom at Laguna and I had the opportunity to coach water poloo and we started a new water poo program the last three years and we took everybody and we we taught them the game and most of our Sports provide that opportunity for all students to come out and be a part of our sport sports program regardless uh if it's the first time that they're participating in that sport or if they've been participating in a club program program since they were uh two years old here Mr M
323talk about any murals here all right and um we also in addition to our inner School sports where we're competing with other schools we also offer interner murals which is super fun for our students and it really has a a low intimidation level of just jumping in and playing in fact next week we begin a bad Mitten tournament which is kind of a fun um nobody's great at bad Mitten yet at Middle School in fact many of them have never played before they've learned in PE and now they finished their PE unit and they're leaving up the Nets and we're going to have a lot of fun with some bad Mitten tournament at lunch so um LS and sent out an invite I'm going to throw out there if any of you board members want
324to come and do some bad Mitten at lunch come on out and have some fun it'll be a great time uh we also want to highlight in addition to all the fun things that we do to try to connect our students to our school and make them feel that sense of belonging that at the end of the day they are learning and growing and thriving in the classroom and that's so important for us to highlight and so um just a few things that I want you all to be aware of because it's so important um is first of all we have amazing academic programs for our students um and two of them are things that are measured by our state and that our our school is doing an outstanding job of and you can see
325some of the data up there um but we have accelerated math um where students actually in their first year at Laguna will complete two years of math and then be jumping into what's normally a high school class and Algebra 1 is eighth graders um we also have collaboration math where we have students that um are needing a little bit of extra help to really make that jump to being successful and at or above grade level standards and we actually have two Math teachers in a classroom working together to support those students with amazing results of those teachers really seeing students grow and move from really a little bit behind in math to being highly successful and that's in a grade level class with just two teachers really doing that tag team work and then we
326also have after school math lab where we're supporting students and we've got 198 kids that have come so far this year which shows that it works and they want that help and then very similar structure for our English classes of having Advanced English and then this year it's new we have collab English classes as well um really targeting specifically our English Learners our long-term English Learners um we have a big picture goal of ideally having every long-term English learner be redesignated by the time they go into high school so that they're ready to thrive and be successful in that environment and Mr Jones is going to jump in and share a little bit more about some of our other academic programs I'll just touch on a couple real quick for the sake of time you
327know we we uh have a robust dual immersion program uh that continues uh from our dual immersion feeder School PCO we are uh we enjoy having a history class that existed for many years 20 plus years we've recently added science full emersion science and then this year we've embedded within our history uh it's full emerging history class uh Spanish langu language arts to help prepare our students to be successful as they move off to the to the high school and the anecdotal reports I've had from speaking with the high school teachers and students that they're been very successful as they've moved into to Spanish four as as freshman this year um and then the other piece of it is the our program that we have as far as having advisory and tutorial so advisory we
328have on Mondays and it's a 20 minute block of time it allows for us to communicate with our students social emotional lessons uh and other things that we need to discuss with our students as a as a schoolwide uh student body and then on Fridays our students can sign up for a tutorial period and that's about a 30 minute period on Fridays and students can choose whatever teacher they want to go be with in order to receive additional uh support uh opportunities for reteaching opportunities to for retakes makeup um different assignments it's been a an invaluable uh opportunity for our students we've also had guest speakers and we've had a number community members come out and present to our students about 100 students uh each week get to hear from a Community member um one
329other thing I also want to highlight is our our newcomer program uh as we serve our English Learners Mr Miner referred to it previously we have 12 newcommerce students and it's an opportunity for them to receive targeted support um I've worked in education 20 plus years and I've worked with English learners for for most of that and and I've never seen a program where students have seen have been so integrated so supported and uh included as part of our school Community right off the bat uh we I can only credit our our our great team of teachers that do a phenomenal job and you see the pictures up there uh and it has been um it's been amazing to see them uh learn and grow we have one student that's already transitioned out of the
330newcomer program and is in grade level English two that have gone into uh grade level math and we we look forward to the great things we'll see from this program moving forward here and I already mentioned earlier about our long-term English learner program that we're doing this year as well so I'll move by that the last thing I want to talk about with our academics is just that we also offer in addition to this one great thing about Middle School is electives and so kids get a chance to choose and we have a long list of things that we offer our students um and they really cover all the different things from art performing arts and um our more classical Arts but then also we have multiple CTE introduction experiences um that really build directly
331into what students have opportunities at the high school and so it's really this beautiful chance for kids to start to experience things and get ideas of what they're interested in and good at as they then build towards going to slow high and then being able to continue and maybe even ideally um jump in and do and complete an entire pathway at the high school level in those areas um and then lastly just because Middle School is something that is amazing and important and we're celebrating we have an amazing endof year celebration to celebrate our students promoting to high school and afterwards the eighth graders get to enjoy an awesome promotion dance and so you can see a couple little images of what that is and um just want to shout out our amazing school um
332we do a lot of great work there and most of it is about the students and the interactions by students and staff on a daily basis and yet I do want to say um that we're really proud that we've been recognized as a California National School to watch and also a California distinguished school um we really feel proud of what we do every day at lagona middle school thank you all right and thank you I'd like to invite the teach boosters who would care to speak to the podium thanks hi uh I'm Chelsea Ruiz I am the lead organizer for the grow teach oh the slides sorry I don't know what the slides are we don't have them in the board agenda the board members have the packet the board members have the proposal but
333not the presentation on on the other screen it's on oh sorry is this how I Advance perfect thank you yeah and then yeah oh no it's separate I'll just look at this one thank you Hi Chelsea Ruiz lead organizer for the grow teach move mement first of all we want to thank the board for taking time out of your numerous and very delicate topics to give us some time to talk about this proposal and for your thoughtful consideration of all of the parent comment that we've had over the past several months and I just want my team really quick to give a quick wave all the the parent leaders Scott Valerie um this definitely was not um an effort Alone by me um so let's see I what we are proposing is to increase choice
334in the district's middle schools by the expansion of the teach program as an extremely costeffective and lowrisk solution to the district's goal of Cl closing the achievement Gap and improving the Middle School experience for our students districtwide um what has brought us here um we are asked is to increase choice in the Middle School level and we believe the that the expansion of the teach school is part of the district's comprehensive plan that will um assist everyone and in the interest of time I'm going to skip the slide which just want to be respectful of your time and also in the interest of time we're going to skip this slide but I will direct you to the proposal that we have um given each of you on page nine it talks about some of the
335benefits of the teach program um but I won't go into that and we'll let you read that later I want to touch on the success of the teach program so that we have some context for why we're advocating for its expansion um teach has a legacy of um being successful it was started in 1981 43 years ago um by the vision of the district creating space for this Innovative program and it actually was maybe it's not ironically enough but it was a group of parents that advocated for the creation of this program um and we're also very grateful to the group of parents in 2013 that advocated for the continuation of this program okay um and we're going to touch on a few of the um successes of teach just very quickly um it's been
336recognized can I have the next uh I can I can do it Scott thanks um we've been teach has been recognized as a National Blue Ribbon School three times California distinguished school three times and an honor Ro scholar um school three times it's uh ranked number one for testing in the in the entire district and ranked number 28 in all of the elementary schools in California and all of this is just to say that the teach program works for the past 43 years it has been working to inspire our high Achievers to um achieve academic success um and all of this uh is despite the fact that um it only has six full-time teachers and has been imp portable since 2013 so what we're trying to say is that the success of the teach program
337does not necessitate millions of dollars of infrastructure and Staffing and additional costs but this is something that has been done on very low budget and the teach program is not is not about the facility it's not about a giant staff it's about the the staff that is there and the students the teach program is successful without big amounts of funding and um if you would like to um check out page five that has some of the specific structural elements of our proposal um and this success that we're proposing is very lowc cost we are advocating for a smallscale pilot that minimizes Capital Improvements and minimizes the ongoing Staffing costs that we know are a a very important issue to the district and to us um we advocate for increasing school choice in investing in a
338teach expansion as very low risk there is an existing k38 program sloka that has been operating on half of the school site for many many years so this isn't we're not asking for a big giant um investment and there are some things that we can take advantage of that don't cost any money like Partnerships with CP that's right across the street like this I eii lab that's basically brand new and the School site really is ready to be utilized once the site is made completely available utilized for um other programs and something that I that I want to just pause and make sure that we address which I really appreciate the district bringing up their concern of declining enrollment um especially in our Coastal schools we we hear that and we um definitely don't want
339to be pulling schools away pulling students away from those programs which um you know we've seen in the presentations tonight are very successful our elementary schools are very successful students are happy there they are thriving there our middle schools have high academic excellence and a rich array of um extracurricular in sports and so we are we are proposing that if teach was to be expanded that we're not going to see a mass Exodus from our excellent elementary and middle schools to this teach program but the students who are leaving it would be have a minimal impact to the coastal schools because these programs are so attractive and are so successful teach the purpose of it is for a very small subset of students that are not able to be served by the traditional programs and
340that would not change if it was expanded to the Middle School uh I want to spend a moment to talk about the cost effective measures that we are recommending we are very grateful to the district for your fiscal responsibility um that should be your highest priority we recognize that and we are not proposing any kind of unwise spending right now with this budget deficit but we are advocating to have a formalized planning effort moving forward so just so we're clear we're not asking for millions of dollars because that would not be appropriate um um so the teach program would not be to try to replicate all of the existing Middle School offerings that is not what people value in the teach program and that is not cost-effective um we do want to leverage the site
341and leverage the economies of scale that exist with the current teach elementary school program on the site so the same principle could be used the same teachers could be used the NPR could be utilized The Innovation lab could could be um utilized by both the elementary school and the middle school um students um and here's a little pallet cleanser here we have is Camden still here oh so Camden current teach fifth grader um caught wind of this discussion that we were having and created his own draft facility Master site plan um and so we're grateful to Camden for his contributions and the last thing I want to say is that teach students feel empowered to take big problems and solve them and so thank you Camden for illustrating that so well I'll just have just
342one more thing before I give it to Scott to bring us home um I want to talk about school choice and the achievement Gap and our goal which we believe is aligned with the districts is to close the achievement gap for fourth through eth graders and we see Teach as an integral part of that solution we believe that there are lessons that can be learned and applied districtwide and we also believe that when a classroom teacher has a very broad range of student abilities in their class and there's pressure right to help the kids that need the most support and pressure to help the kids that want to do more if we remove those students through their own self- selection and put them in a you know a School of Choice then that frees up
343that classroom teachers time and energy that they can focus on the students that are struggling the most which is where they should be focusing on and so we feel like um this additional support that they might have been providing to the high achieving students can go to the students who are struggling the most and I'm going to turn it over to Scott to talk about our ask a little bit more and next steps yeah thank you Chelsea I think it's important to talk about what we want wow I've you'd think I can do technology uh what are we really asking for I think there was some confusion that we wanted something implemented immediately in this school year it was never the case I want to point out that none of the parents that you see
344here are actually ever going to be the beneficiaries of a Middle School of Choice we re recogniz this problem we're lucky to be here to have seen it but our children are going to go to lomes lagona private whatever it may be our goal is to stop that bleeding we want to keep them here we want that enrollment to to stay we understand what the community funding that's difficult that doesn't necessarily help us so we want to start the work on a formal plan believe it or not the last year year and a half this work is to get you the concept and a vision and show you what's possible and what we've been surprised is we've gotten help from our students and they're just fourth graders um the second thing we've realized when we
345went back through the history of teach we found that teach was at risk of being lost actually Dr Prader helped save it and find a home at its current location which has been instrumental with Partnerships with calply exactly what you had hoped would occur the catch though is there was an identical request made back back in 2013 to the board at that time and nothing ever happened it didn't go anywhere they asked for a work group essentially so what we're asking you for is to start that work but have regular Cadence and check-ins with you as in give us Milestones give the district Milestones so that you're checking the progress to see if we're on track for a final proposal or not you can't plan these things overnight it takes a a year this is
346the rough time timeline that we see just so you're aware there's no shovel in ground or implementation work we have real problems that we don't understand yet so we need to understand about the site right it has a lei on it uh we thought CL The Classical Academy was going to leave that's not the case that may be a thing that occurs next year and the year after that and the year after that so at some point we have to figure out what we want to do to that site and we have to figure out what the Strategic value is the the other loss there is is income and so we have to kind of figure out what our community engagements are how are we going to get funding we don't expect to raise this
347alone one of the things that we're very strong at in this school is fundraising and we want to seek investment on specific programs especially in Social entrepreneurism to get these kids involved doing things in their Community now not just later and we want those kids to return well there's many other alumni that have gone to teach that're here in our community that want to give back they credit their time at an elementary school with having been important in their life how many of us think about our Alma moders our universities colleges that we've gone to well to get there we had to be successful in high school and to get through High School something had to happen that caught us we didn't fall through the cracks and that's what this is trying to prevent for
348those students there's a lot of financial issues that we need to get into we're pretty creative we've got a lot of fundraising ideas but most importantly those portable classrooms that the our kids are in now those are luxurious if you're wanting to do a daycare or something else and calply right across the street that's a wonderful Avenue there's so many more things than that that the the group has thought through but this is something we actually have to talk about and see what are we allowed to do what do we really want to get into the business of what do we want to have for 10 years down the line same thing goes for what staff might look like we have a few highlights from The Proposal we won't go through all of this for
349you you can take a look at these slides later but everything that you've kind of seen here all all the questions we've tried to put in that that document for you and I I guess I'll leave you with what's possible you know we we have a project based curriculum and it's integrated into everything that's done at that school that's really unique and it hasn't yet been replicated in 43 years we haven't found a way to replicate that in the other schools so when Chelsea got up here and said that we're going to do this Middle School we're not looking to replicate what the middle schools are doing we think that's a disservice the goal is we have this Gap and we fell into it we see it we recognize it other parents have done it
350and they didn't do anything their kids leave the district they go elsewhere or kids complain um we want to stop that bleeding we think the district wants to solve this problem and this is a really costeffective tool to do so uh but it needs exploration and it needs your imagination um and so we're very excited to kind of see where this goes in that Spirit shelsea had this really great idea of something that we could pay forward yeah gra we're done don't worry um so we have some seeds for you guys and what we want to leave you with um at the end of our presentation is that what we've given you in this proposal are seeds they're ideas and so we're really looking forward to continuing the discussion with this group on what to
351do with these ideas so thank you so much for your time okay I think you have request to speak yes I do would you like public comment before your presentation or after let's let's yeah go ahead Dr sorry I think so right we were getting ahead of you hey before I move on I I just want to take a quick moment acknowledge um Heather Vanessa Nathan and Chris it's been a long long day for everybody but uh you know I appreciate them coming here and presenting and I really appreciate uh this uh teach exploration entrepreneurial team I really do appreciate the um the energy and the framing of your interests I do I in fact I go back um many years where um I was having conversations with Darla batistic who is the principal at
352teach and we were having conversations at the time where we were seeing uh growth in our district and she and I sat and talked about the possibilities of of um a Middle School of Choice actually being this teach program and so but then way LED on to way and our circumstances changed and um and so my recommendation before the board really has two options but I I just really think I want to expand on it just a little bit the first option was to not move forward with a a um creation of or extending the grades seven and eight at the teach campus at this time and and I'm hearing that's the same same interest from this group and my reasons for that are outlined in the recommendation the second one of course is Do
353It ultimately it's your call expand it but then we would as you can imagine have to discover and find how to fund it and make it happen and manage some some of the challenges that go with it uh as Chelsea spoke to um the um the the last numbers I saw were approximately 90 students um who are coming from the coast that would probably stick around and um and of course that's my primary concern is is what this might do to the to losos middle school and and moral Bay High School um even if half of those students chose not to go back to their home Coastal Community to attend school it would have an impact um a staffing impact now with that in mind within the recommended option that I put forward to you
354option one I did um leave room in that option and I I do hope you give the consideration for there I didn't call it a working group um with Milestones but I am of the opinion that our board is ready to explore the middle schools um in their next iteration of the Strategic Direction so we currently are at the tail end of the current 2021 to 2025 strategic direction for our programming including Middle grades education since you adopted that strategic Direction both middle schools Laguna and loms have elevated their gain they're both now recognize the state and national middle school programs super proud of the work they've done I happen to think intentionality delivers really good things when you put your mind to it so with that I think as we develop with the help
355of Miss yamasa who I would lean into to help develop this as our assistant of ed services um to include um The Advocates for this um Middle School of Choice concept and vision when we do it how we do it if we do it could really be explored and developed because I I hate to shut down a um a a highly engaged and interested um in entrepreneurial group I I um have spent some time at teach over the years and um I I love the energy I love the spirit um I don't know how this would all fan out but I do think our two comprehensive middle schools would benefit from the engagement I do think when you get willing and interested and motivated people around some Middle School Concepts and ideas good things come
356out of it my recommendation includes all that is what I'm trying to say there's nothing I heard tonight that I have a problem with personally I think I think the day might come down the road for St Louis Coastal to have a middle school choice program and I think that sounds really intriguing to me uh may not be to you right now I'm nervous about it for the many reasons that you've heard but that but if you if you create the content text or a working group within a strategic document like the Strategic direction that we bring back to you um with some of these Concepts and ideas for a future cons board to consider I think that's just good practice so it's included in my recommendation to you tonight option one so that's my
3571134 recommendation to to you at this point for your consideration okay well let first let me go to the public is there anyone from the public that would like to speak to this item yes uh we have some very patient people uh Alysa buol am I saying your last name correctly yeah followed by Scott hols and you'll have your three minutes yeah um hello my name is Alyssa um I'm a sixth grader at teach element Lo um I am a sixth grader at teach elementary and I would like teach elementary to have a middle school I think teach is really um Innovative they have a whole um Innovation lab where you can build stuff and create a lot of things and they even bring over cowply students to come with us and innovate stuff it's
358really fun and I think they do amazing with um seventh graders and eighth graders and um yeah I think they do really great for all the upcoming students thank you thank you okay well that doesn't seem fair it's good to see you again um you know my first time with teach was a recommendation from a neighbor after we moved here and things didn't work out we went to a another school in the district uh by surprise it was called Belleview great school it just didn't work out for us and um and then a year later we discovered teach got on that lottery that you heard about and of course lost and so we are we're making preparations to we're going to stick to this public school that's my wife there you know we're going to
359do this we're going to do Public School we're not going to go back to private and um sure enough the way list opened a couple days before school uh Alyssa had just moved here she was heartbroken loved her old school uh up North and then Astro Camp happened which is a science camp uh and I understand this is going to sound bad to to some folks you've got to understand you know it's all funded by the parents and every child goes does not matter if that child can afford it or not has no family everybody goes uh if they want to and at Astro Camp as a chaperon was exhausted because the kids are getting up every day at 6:30 in the morning and they don't go to bed until 11: they have class until
36010:30 it's it's unbelievable um the clicks disappeared she met people I saw all the kids the kids that were on the side you know the troublemakers or ones that were just a little too weird and you just know where that goes it all disappeared they're working together they're doing ropes courses they're lifting their teacher in the air they're learning about the electromagnetic spectrum something I don't think I got to learn until College playing with all of the devices you can imagine looking at the stars that was my start to teach that wasn't just a field trip and it it lasted all week and I asked the the organizers at the facility how many public schools get the chance to come she oh long time ago was quite a bit maybe 50% today there's three Public
361Schools we're one of three public schools that send their kids there everybody else is private that's the type of education that is starting to get lost um the kids worked on that curriculum the entire time it wasn't a one-time thing that fed into their steam activities their lab is used all the time they build things there was then uh at the second half of the year a fuel cell Challenge and you know they built with the help of Cal P's racing team uh and those kids loved the little ones what an amazing partnership to see and witness uh kind of at the tail end the kids thought of them as Heroes and they're asking questions about College University what was that like and those big kids they love teaching the low kids it kept them
362out of trouble too kept them focused that this teach thing is pretty special and uh I I think Middle School takes it to the next level but it doesn't require a ton of money or facilities right you have Valerie Baptista followed by Becca Banfield hello my name is Valerie I currently have a fifth grader Camden and U at teach and an eighth grader who attended all three years at teach and I'm grateful to those before us those parents before us that have thought for teach let's remember that teach did start over 40 years ago because parents teachers students students and the district saw a need to serve a niche of students who craved more from their education there was in 1981 an investment in the students no matter what the situation was at that time
363we are now seeing second generation students attend teach elementary because their parents gained so much from teach I was sharing with them when we were working on this presentation that my senior year in college in business college we had to create a business and products and sell them and I was like oh my gosh that's what our teach mini mall does they're doing it in fourth grade and I did it in my senior year in college that's how Innovative they are and how far ahead they are going to be when they get there um just as the teach elementary culture curriculum and project-based style has not been able to be replicated at any other their schools for over 40 years in our district thus the need for teach elementary still teach Middle School will not
364be able to be licated in our current middle schools we are asking you to expand on what is already working to ignite fires in our middle school students so that they continue their passion for Learning and be around like-minded students who believe and and value the same just as iron sharpens iron students around students who build them up challenge them and help them to rise up to be the best they can be will go on to change the world thank you thank you for being here at this late hour to hear us my name is Becca Banfield and I'm a mother of four children two of whom attend or have attended teach elementary school I'm here today to encourage continued discussion about the potential of expanding teach elementary into a middle school my 10-year-old son
365Parker attends teach right now as a fourth grader and he just came out of teach's mini mall project the mini mall project requires kids to work with a partner to come up with a business idea they must present a prototype decide on a price create a flyer poster and a commercial with an original song and generate at least 45 products to sell at the school's mini mall event where students and parents can shop Parker and his friend created a heart of a tiger soap product with essential oils and a hidden Jewel you can find that's the heart of a tiger inside the soap um I wanted to bring an example to pass out to you guys but we use them all up in our house because we love them um Parker also started vacuuming cars
366to raise money for his teach Camp experience and was so successful that he now plans to make business cards and continue the adventure to earn money for college he is so excited to do this these are just a few of the experiences that make teach the perfect fit for my son what an opportunity this special school has given him and our family I recognize the district is facing very difficult budget concerns as well as many other high priorities my request is not to squeeze more from the district at a time or in a way that doesn't make sense or isn't fiscally responsible that is not a um this is not a request to rationally push through an idea at the expense of the greater good um but it is a a request to explore options
367in a thoughtful responsible way to build on something that already strengthens our district and serves students with a specific learning Readiness and style I believe that teach is one of the jewels of our district I am so proud of this school teach makes our district shine it strengthens our students who must always come first it can strengthen the neighboring schools if we choose to learn from teach's successes and it strengthens our entire community at large the students are begging for more of it alums are coming straight from their basketball games on a busy day to articulate Something That Matters to them a future goal that won't even impact their own academic path I don't see how their voices can be ignored these are the kinds of kids teach is cultivating these are teach kids and
368they make our district shine we're not asking for this to happen tomorrow we can honor the budget and our children it doesn't have to be one or the other please keep this door open Maisy de gr and then real bfield did I say that correctly real okay so Maisy then B I love teach my name is Maisy degra and I'm a freshman at Mission prep I went to teach Elementary fourth through sixth grade my first year at teach I immediately felt a positive change within my education each student in my class wanted to be at school and they wanted to learn each day I became a better person and learned how to utilize my skills within our small project groups I was comfortable and learned how to have confidence when sharing my ideas versus my
369previous School experiences where sometimes I was the only one contributing to our conversations or I was too afraid of what others would think of me to where I wouldn't share or when we did share we argued whose idea was better and what one we would do at teach the differences that after everyone shares their own opinions we worked together and realized that by contributing the best of each of our ideas we were able to accomplish so much more and make something that we were really proud of to share with our teachers and other classmates it is not only the projects we did together that made teach such a great school there is a culture that cannot be recreated at any other place you will notice at several schools that Twins and teenagers are often comparing
370themselves to others and feel alone or secluded which often is distracting to your studies and can make you feel really sad at teach we lifted each other up we respected one another and made each other better you might have noticed how I mentioned I was now attending private school although I left the school district I would have stayed if teach was an option as a middle school now at private school I recognize several faces from teach who transferred because the other Public Schools were not the right fit for them and they missed what they experienced at teach although extending the elementary school into a middle school would come with a cost the loss of students in the district because they are looking for schools that better suit them would lead to a greater loss I
371loved my teach experience and I'm speaking to you right now because if teach was a middle school option for me I would have been there and I wish I had that opportunity I know I'm not the only one who has shared this desire and I want the privilege for anyone who loves teach to stay there for as long as they can my teach experience was Unforgettable and I loved it so much thank you for your time real and then Jessica cple CL uh hi I'm really grateful for this opportunity to be here uh my name is BR bfield I'm a freshman at Mission Prep High school and I can say without hesitation that my experience to teach elementary school was one of the most wonderful School experiences of my life and it's not just the
372unique like Project based learning uh as Scott mentioned um that made it wonderful it was because I was surrounded by an environment that loves to learn and it was such a good fit for me because teach offers us opportunities to those of us who are excited about learning and we're ready for a challenge in a faster Pace we love the Hands-On activities and it is so amazing that we have uh lomes and Laguna and these other options for kids whom that's not the fit but for those of us who are excited and ready for these challenges it gives us a place to grow and Thrive and feel thrilled to go to school every day and after leaving teach I uh could definitely noticed a really big difference in just how there wasn't much expected of
373me and I missed it a lot and I wish I could have had an extended teach experience through middle school because it is my my teach experience that ended in sixth grade that has been the real platform for me to jump into this really rigorous season as a ninth grader and I feel ready for it because of teach and what it gave me and how much more ready would I been if I'd been able to have a teach experience all through Middle School um I absolutely would have taken that option um oh if I'd had the option to go to teach Middle School in earlier years I absolutely would have taken that option instead of moving to an outof District option I think it would be a great idea for our district to take the
374time um you need to address the pressing budget matters absolutely but to please still be open to creative ideas for expanding teach once these pressing issues settle and thank you for the opportunity to share my thoughts hello I'm Jessica pultz and I'm sure you can tell that um you're a parent of a student in this room um and I'm sure there's a lot of facts and figures and information that you know we could all provide to explain why we think this is a really good cause but I just like to point out that the students that are here you know really are the attestation of how good the programming is at teach and how we wish that this would open up for further grades and come um you know School of choice for seventh and
375eth um the students that we've met as now young adults outside of the current programming um when we meet them out in the public every single time we've met someone they have been someone in the community that um you know has come back because of their love for the school um actually just recently we um as a family were outforce back riding and never suspected that uh the gal that was taking us out was a a student uh at teach and she credits um her connection with her uh teacher and with the school for um who she is today and for her successes and her um you know good outlook on her future so um we thank you for your time and really hope that um we'll consider you know working together to make this
376something that could be a possibility for teach to be a school of choice in seventh and eth grade thank you is there anyone else present who wishes to speak and I don't see any I don't see any raised hands on Zoom anyone on Zoom so we'll bring it back to the board I can't hear yes well and we the board reads everything we receive thanks thank you Mr Carson I have a few few comments and um I guess just few things I want to share um so uh personally my three kids went to teach and I had fabulous experience for all three my three kids also went to lagona and they had fabulous experiences at lagona so um I I understand the perspective of what you guys are are asking um part of the experience
377at lagona was because of Mrs Ahern but um uh anyway but so so here's kind of what I wanted to dig into um so so Scott you mentioned that in 2013 wasn't a structured process there there actually was Dr Prader created a cross disciplinary Comm Committee of parents teachers from local elementary schools teachers from teach administrators and um I I know because I I was on it um was actually my first real engagement with the school district um later I led the bond campaign and joined the school board so watch out um for what you get into um but but so so um here's my point though um one thing that Dr Prader did in 20133 that is different than you're asking and the context then was Bishop's Peak was out of space teach didn't
378have a home teach might have closed we had to find a home we found the current home and and that was the output of that that committee but it wasn't a teach committee the the the committee was actually about how do we do accelerated learning in the elementary schools across the school district and and um why that was important was because um if you if you make it about teach then teach is good something else is bad and that's not the case I mean my perspective is lagona is a fabulous option and um and LS is too even though my kids didn't didn't go there I I have really high esteem for both of them um but but so here's the thing I I don't think that we should create a committee that's like how
379do we expand teach I I I think we should create a committee that's how do we do middle school education well across the district T taking into account the the things that teach does great and the things that Laguna does great and the things that lomes does great and how do we bring those together to a solution for our future Vision that you know incorporates that and incorporates input from parents like like you guys and um so so I'm not sure if that aligns with what you're asking for but based on my personal experience advocating for Teach as a fifth grade parent um it actually was a much more successful outcome than it would have been if it was just a find a new home for teach committee and so um in short I I'll
380wrap it up I I um I like option one I I think option two would be really messy right now um and so I don't like option two this year um and I think anyway having Administration in put into this plan that you started is really important so um I like option one I think it should be broader though and and incorporate um Middle School um you hopefully every middle school student in our district benefits from this thought process would be my goal um the other thing I would I would add is perhaps you know uh there was a comment made about teach being for high Achievers so students teachers could spend more time paying attention to the rest of the class which leads me to feel that maybe there aren't High Flyers at the
381other schools and I think that's that's something that that's something that parents struggle with who choose not to send their kids to teach and you know for various reasons so I would suggest also including parents of high achieving students who choose not to have their kids go to teach because I think their their Devotion to finding out why they choose to at their local school which is a choice that I made even though it was recommended that my kids go to teach but we loved our local school and I I am as connected to it as you are are sound that you are to teach so I think that including having a broader approach to why parents you know just just being a little more inclusive of parents who stay in there at their home
382school with um with any kid you know why they choose to do that not just High achieving but you know teaches the school of choice for any student from any school within the district who chooses to go there so okay Mr hunger Dr Prader thinking about what um Brian and Ellen said do you find do you find that that's in alignment with your proposal the spirit of my proposal for option one is to is to engage with thought Partners around middle-grades education and not to dismiss Concepts ideas that surprisingly might benefit the whole of kids I've seen it in my life right so so so my my my response is is I think I'd like to think I'm saying the same thing it's it's a the idea of um of a middle school option or
383parent choice for middle school to me could very likely come out of this discussion when the economics work when the Dem demographic work it does make sense to me anyone who's been around or has had children in Middle School knows it can be a bumpy ride and we all love our children we all want our kids to thrive and be successful and I've seen it happen to Ellen's point in all of our schools in various ways I'm super proud of our schools in all of them so thought partners are important making sure we're not in our silos or fixed in a certain mindset around middle-grades education and inviting in um maybe a different perspective that honors um parents experiences with their own kids is in my experience of value and I was hoping to capture
384that in option one as we redevelop and reconstitute the district's strategic direction for the next five years that's my interest in number one maybe this is just um sloppy language but I'm that's my intention okay so it it sounds like you uh your option number one would include um Ryan and Ellen's Ellen's suggestions you know moving forward on something like this yeah I mean there's parents sort of an OP you're you're looking at at at a sort of almost a talk about a Reformation of our middle school programs and what process we would use to make that happen um using whatever available resources we have and whatever parent input we have is that pretty much what we're talking about yeah I have a unique perspective because I work with so many students in the student
385Senate right so I see all different kinds of kids and they are spectacular and um and I get to work with the teach students sit next to the Hawthorne students and um and it's a a fascinating experience um so yeah I would say there are parents and students that belong in that conversation around what middle-grades education should look like um and with Nathan and Heather sitting in the back there they know how I feel about Middle grades education it is a place where kids should Thrive and and bring out so much of that Curiosity and enthusiasm for learning new things um and I don't want to stifle them and so there are kiddos that are are because of the age Dynamic there are kids that are ready to do more than others um and so
386the program has to be flexible in that way so I'm excited to see where that goes where Miss yamashta takes that with this group this working group if you would and then of course the board keeps their hand on the rudder you know we bring it back to you and discuss it and share our thinking I think good things come from that I really do and I I believe option one captures the spirit of what we heard tonight that's that's pretty much what I was thinking I see Mr Banfield has his light on as well but um I after his comments I'm prepared to to make a motion Mr ramfield from what I'm gathering then option one is a great possibility I just don't want to close the door on what's been presented tonight if
387we incorporate what they've said along with what we're saying here I'm all in favor of that yeah I mean I just I want to be really clear though this is a strategic Direction y it's not what we're doing next year for teach this is strategic Direction which I think incorporates what I heard from Mr book Holz as a concept um um the same idea of a working group with with Concept and vision in you know really looking at the developmental needs of kids at this age and and how they learn and really paying attention to that is of great interest to me and I think that we we are now in a position more so than ever before to have that conversation in a meaningful way than ever before we've come a long way on
388a lot of U programmatic and um issues around um um the whole Schools to Watch piece is important to me because it really takes into consideration kids in such a meaningful way that um other program models I haven't seen but I love the I really love this idea of um of exploring Middle grades education outside of the norm um I I love the entrepreneurial spirit I love the things that that teach can do and um the replication of some of the things that they do um um are within our reach if that's what we choose to do in in a bigger scale um there's so much so much potential but I but that's past me that that that thought partner work is something that is of great interest to mine that's what I'm saying Mr
389Banfield okay Mrs Bal toon thank you um and thank you to everyone that we heard from tonight our middle school principls and assistant principles and uh teach families as well um so I'm looking at the district strategic direction from 2021 to 2025 and so what I'm understanding is that uh the idea is to incorporate some real focus on middle schools for the next strategic plan 2026 to whatever it is um it's too late for me to do that math real fast um but um but I just need a little clarification because I'm also hearing working group and I imagine that a strategic Direction planning process you're going to hear we're going to want to hear from a lot of different stakeholders um and so it's it wouldn't be just one working group driving the show
390but one voice of many or just a diversity of parents across can you just clarify for me how the how your vision fits in with the strategic planning process yeah so I've gotten a lot of traction in my career using the accordion model um where you um have I can Envision um working with a staff group and flexing back to a main group and then flexing out to a student group and then flexing back and going to a um the a key group of of parents from The Grow teach initiative and get their insights and I just think the the accordion concept the structure of that works for me and that way you ensure you get a lot of touch points um with a whole lot of different folks also there's research out there that
391we would EXP for um Middle grades education there's a whole lot of research out there right now for what kids need at that age and um and and you have an industrial model that we are trying desperately to kind of form into our own kind of our current model you can hear the presentations tonight from our two Middle School principal teams that you can see that they're trying to bring energy and trying to bring inclusivity into the learning and the the identity of the campuses and that's not always been the case it's always been hard to do because of the volume of kids um and then there are kiddos um that I know that aren't ready for a comprehensive Middle School setting and yet they're 13 and they're 14 and they kind of go into
392a shell and I know this because I know a number of kids that are flexing out into charter schools and and home schools and things like that because they're just not ready for that environment I think our strategic document needs to capture that and find a place for kids um I I think if you're intentional about it you can design it into it I mean we heard Nathan talk about the newcomer program and how intentional you were about making sure those kiddos those 12 kids are engaged and involved at the beginning well that's the adult engineering that I'm talking about right and what I'm after in this process is to bring back to the board a wellth thought out evolved document that really considers the Middle grades education for our kids which could include the
393following boom boom boom okay that's what I'm after thank you I appreciate that and I'll just say just coincidentally I spent several several hours at a middle school today because I got to take part in the um leader leading Equitable schools process um uh at lagona middle school so I can just attest to the wonderful things that are going on there and I know there's wonderful things going on at teach and as a parent a current parent with kiddo in the district um uh who uh would have who who thrived at lagona and would have also thrived at teach um uh I look forward to that comprehensive and holistic strategic planning process okay Mr Mr hker um I would I move that we accept uh option one of the superintendent's recommendations I'll second okay so
394we have a motion by Mr anger and a second by Mrs Sheffer that's roll call vote Mr rer yes Mrs Sheffer yes Mrs Balo yes Mr bfield yes Mr Buckman Mr glawson yes and I'm a yes so that passes 70 okay um item 10.4 the initial proposals for slca and seu negotiations no worries for negotiations yes the district uh earlier in this agenda the Board of Education held a public hearing on slcusd Board of Education SLT and seiu's initial proposals for negotiation the board has asked to accept adopt the proposals at this time and provide uh Dr Prader and executive cabinet by default the authority to bargain on your behalf okay uh it's late it's really late uh so is there anyone from the public who would like to discuss this there was scattering he
395anyone on Zoom anyone on the board no I'm seeking a motion I am seeking a motion to uh to authorize uh to accept proposals from slct and SEIU and to authorize uh the district's negotiating team to engage in negotiations the team comprised of um individuals as selected by Dr prer seeking a motion seeking and move I'll second thank you so I have a motion for Mr Clauson a second for Mr anger uh it's a roll call vote Mr pawson yes Mr anger Mrs badon yes Mr Banfield yes Mrs Sheffer yes Mr Buckman I'm here oh yes and I'm a yes that passes 70 okay we're moving on now to the consent agenda please let me know if you would like anything pulled item 11.1 the approval of purchase orders and Cal card purchases 11.2 the
396approval of furniture and Equipment requests 11.3 the approval of warrants and payroll 11.4 the approval of certificated and classified Personnel items 11.5 the approv appr of quarterly report on uniform complaint filings the Williams settlement 11.6 the approval of the 20242 lcap Federal addendum I move to approve the action consent agenda so I have a motion by Mrs shef for a second by Mr Buckman to accept the action consent agenda in its entirety um Mrs shefer yes Mr Buckman Mr Clawson yes Mrs badano yes Mr rer yes Mr Banfield yes and I'm a yes as well uh does do we have any items for advanced agenda your lights okay seeing none um are there reports by board members te one Tey thing Clark Mr at Monarch Grove is as gidy as a kid in the candy
397store he's so happy to be there you principal okay and I was there right after you were there introducing myself and I would agree that he is um excited and enthusiastic he's just so he's so excited it's great very fun to um see that kind of enthusiasm so if there are no further board reports then this meeting is adjourned feel like 24