CorpusRecord 106224

12/19/24 Regular Meeting of the Governing Board | Part 2

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / San Marcos Unified
Date
2024-12-20
Location
San Diego County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
19,738 words · about 110 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Apologize for the delay. I would like to call this meeting to order. Today's date is Thursday, December 19th, 2024. This is the annual organizational meeting of the governing board of San Marcos Unified School District. Please let the record reflect that all board members are present. The San Marcos Unified School District Board of Education meeting is a business meeting of the board held in public. While we welcome and encourage public participation, the expected behavior is that this meeting will be conducted in an orderly fashion. Only the person recognized by the board president may speak. While the member of the public is speaking, members of the audience must not yell or speak out, regardless of whether you agree or disagree. While public comment is in progress, if you speak out, you are out of order and will

002be asked to leave the meeting. As adults participating in a public meeting, we need to model civility to our children and students. On behalf of the board of education, we thank you in advance for helping us conduct this meeting respectfully. 5.1 Mission Statement. The San Marcos Unified School District is an innovative and collaborative community providing an unparalleled an unparalleled educational experience. Through an engaging and supportive environment, all of our students are challenged, inspired, and poised to excel. [clears throat] Please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance. Ready? Begin. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Do I have a motion to approve the agenda? Moved by uh Stacy Carlson. I'll second. Seconded

003by member Martin to approve the agenda as presented. All those in favor say I. I. I. Any opposed. Motion carries. Report of action taken in close session. Tonight the board met in close session and conferred with labor negotiator Dr. Joel Garcia. No action was taken. Next we discussed matters pertaining to a public employee employment transfer appointment discipline dismissal release and evaluation. No action was taken. Reports by student board representatives. Hi, my name is Sydney Cork. I am the student board representative for San Marcos High School. I'm a current senior and yeah, let's start this. So, I'm going to start talking about some different things that are happening right now. So, we have a pre-apprenticeship construction pathway. Um, and this allows students to start construction jobs while still in high school. And this is also going

004to be added to both Twin Oaks and Mission Hills High School. Next, we have the November classroom hero. So, it was from San He was from San Marcos High School. His name was Mr. Stout, and he's a ceramics teacher, and he also earned a $500 gift card for a visa um with all of his dedication to teaching students with ceramics. Okay, next, some programs. So, our nights at the round table have been pretty pretty busy. They just visited Coreo Elementary School where they spoke to students about living a a healthy lifestyle and afterwards they handed out trading cards and played with the students. Next we have FFA and they um last meeting I talked about a ton of agricultural students teaching some younger elementary school students uh from Knob Hill and they did this again

005and you can see that they all had a lot a lot of fun and they attended the San Marcos holiday parade where they took the baby goats and lambs and they ended up winning first place in holiday spirit which is really really fun. Next we have Link Crew. Um, Link Crew has had several events such as Linksgiving, which was a pie eating contest where a student from my Link Crew class won, his name is Kirk. Um, and we also had an event on Friday called Coco and Cram last Friday. And that helped freshmen connect with their leaders and study for finals. And at Coco and Creme, they really just they built um gingerbread houses and they had hot cocoa and just connected with their leaders a little bit more. Um, we also had a giving

006tree update. So, the 9th annual giving tree donation uh was a super super big success and we were able to get most items requested by families as well as a few extra essentials. We received an estimated total of $6,000 in donations with 2,000 in gift cards. Okay, some sports. So, we just had the inclusivity game. Uh this one was about basketball. So, this week we hosted two. We hosted one on Monday and one on Wednesday. um partnered with LCC and Carlsbad High School to hold a series of basketball games. And then we believe that all students whether in general education or with disabilities should have equal opportunities to participate in sports activities in sports and activities. These events truly highlighted the spirit of inclusion and importance of and the importance of everyone coming together. Okay.

007Um we just had wrestling. They had a really big competition where they had several several students place. um place in the competition. Um you can see one of the students uh went against the sixth the sixth ranked wrestler in California and she ended up winning which was really really cool. Um and yeah, next we have JRTC and they've been working really really hard. We also have a JRTC member which I'm going to talk about later, but they just competed at this competition I think about a month ago where they did really really well. Um, next we have competition cheer and they just competed in the CIF championships where they play second. So yeah, so visual and performing arts. So fall show. So our dance programs just performed the Wizard of Oz. That was two weeks

008ago and it was an amazing performance and we had two completely sold out shows and the one during the day uh was almost sold out. So it's really really good. And we also had a visit from Lam Marada and Discovery Elementary and they got to see the show too which is really really nice. Okay, Nights Regiment. Um we had a per a performance on Saturday in the concert band and s symphonic band. I don't know how to say that. Sorry. Um in the wind ensemble and wind symphony. There we go. At the end they performed a standstill of their marching band show for the very last time and they also had alumni come out and perform with them. So they were all really happy about that. some student spotlights. So, we have a JRTC member.

009Her name is Ann, and she earned a $300,000 scholarship to the Air Force for all of her hard work in leading the JRTC program. So, I wanted to highlight her for that one. Wait, wait, wait. Go back to that picture for a second. So, she didn't know she was this day. She didn't know that she was getting this award. They just called her down and everybody was there. It was really, really, it was really cool. Really, really cool. Full ride and the whole thing. Yeah. And I also found out she got a full ride to Harvard as well. this past week. So yeah, very very great. Everyone's super super proud of her. Okay, next we have her name Malu and she came to St. Marcos High School knowing a little bit of English and she

010worked very very hard and in her senior year she got classified as bilingual and she also joined recently she joined an interpretation class and she's now helping emerging English learners which is really really amazing. Last but not least we have Jaylen Williams. He's a current junior in the basketball team and he just celebrating winning uh getting 1,000 career points. So, such an amazing accomplishment. I've heard he's been getting a lot of um scholarships or um not scholarships. Sorry, I can't think of the word, but um he's been getting a lot of Yes. [laughter] But yes, so he is a rising star. And that is all I have prepared for today. But yeah, thank you Sydney. Quick question. your ASB trading cards with the ASB photos of those of your ASB students. Yeah, the the Knights

011of the Round Table. Yeah. They go to elementary schools and they pass out little trading cards. They autograph them. Yeah. La last year I I went to I did not know the Knights of the Round Table had been there that morning. I was there like an hour after them and the kids were all clustered. I got this one. I got that one. I'll trade you. It was so cute. It was really When I went I loved it. It was so much fun. And they also played on the playground with them after as well, which was really, really sweet. I bet both sides had fun. Okay, thank you. Thank you. Hi. Um, my name is Trinity Moon. I'm the student board rep over at Mission Hills High School and I'm a current junior. Um, so I

012just wanted to start off my presentation with a little bit of a recap for our first semester. Um, starting off with homecoming. So that was back in October. Um, we had a lot we had so much hard work going into this dance. Our junior class officers put in so much time and effort thinking of our theme which was passport to paradise which is really fun. Um, and our ASB class also worked really hard. Um, pretty much every single one of our decorations was homemade or DIY, including that little welcome to paradise sign you see up there. Um, we spent the entire morning putting everything up and we only heard good feedback from all of our students, which we had about 1,500 tickets sold, so that was really fun. Um, next, another fun thing we had

013happen recently, this past week, was our dance team showcase called Ice Ice Baby. It was really fun. Um, another really cool part of that was that 18 of the dances that they performed were all choreographed by their very own dancers. So, it's really cool to see our students and like how much talent they put in um and just their work and how well it turned out. Um, as someone who went to the dance, it was really entertaining. I just I love all their dances and I love to see how well they work. Um, another good thing about that is that they recently qualified for the UDA Nationals when their competition season comes up. So, I'm very excited to see how that goes. Um, another thing I wanted to highlight was our Cardinal Alliance. So, they've

014had a lot of competitions this semester, but one I really like to highlight is um when they always go up to Sofi Stadium because I think that's really cool. I just I love seeing their music and their visuals, which they actually got awarded on in this um competition, including getting third place and a score of 81.275. So, I think that's really cool, and I just love to see how hard they work. Um, another thing that I wanted to highlight is our winter athletics that we've had start up. So, first off, our boys basketball team. Um, last season, Coach Hoffmeister, their very own basketball coach, celebrated his 200th win of the season, which is always really fun. And I know that they will bring him more this season. They work very hard. And, um, another fun

015thing is two of their varsity players have won all tournament teams so far in the last two tournaments they've played. So, that's also really fun. Another team I wanted to highlight was our girls basketball team. Um, they recently won their game against Francis Parker, who's one of the five top teams in San Diego County. Um, I know our girls basketball team, I think they're five time champions. I don't know whether for D1 or open division, but I see how much hard work they put in and it really pays off every season. I love to see how much rewards they get. So, that's really fun. Another cool thing I wanted to highlight was our boys soccer team. So, they're very excited for their season so far. They've played six games and are currently undefeated. Um, they

016have a pretty challenging season ahead of them, but as always, they are very excited to see how that goes. Along with our girls soccer team, who are also currently undefeated, um, three wins, zero losses, with their most recent game being a seven to one win against Ramona. Um, I watched a little bit of it. It was just really fun to see how well they worked together. Um, I also want to move on to some academic achievements because we've had a lot of really cool ones this semester. Um, so our journalism yearbook and video production programs recently attended the G JA National Conference up in Philadelphia during that first week of November. Um, and while they were there, students from yearbook were selected to speak at the conference and presented on how they create a studentled

017yearbook conference to collaborate with the middle school yearbook students and kind of build a connection with them and just share their ideas. So, I thought that was really cool. Another really fun thing I wanted to um to highlight was our AVID program. So, so far 100% of our AVID seniors have applied to at least one 4-year university and a lot of them have been hearing back from those universities with acceptances and just it's really cool. And another like a specific student I wanted to highlight was Adriel Bibiano. He's he was such a hard worker. I know him. He only does amazing things for our school and he recently earned a full ride scholarship to Stanford. So, I think he's such a hard worker and I'm just very very proud of him. Um, one last program

018that I wanted to highlight is our careers and education program. I always hear so much fun stuff about this program from the students and from people who take it. Um, and recently their first year students have begun their weekly internships over at Richland Elementary, which we know was recently redone and I've only heard amazing things about how beautiful the campus is. So, um, the these students have shared their excitement and just their overall like time with the students and how much they love connecting and so I just love to see how this program thrives and I love to see the connections they make. Um, I also just wanted to address some upcoming events we have coming here at Mission. So, this this is a new program that we've been cultivating here at Mission. So, it's

019a peer-to-peer counseling program which is set to start in this new semester. Um so I was one of the few students who was selected to work with a team of other students to cultivate a program um where students would be given the chance to support their peers through counseling. So we already chosen like some of our interns we had a lot of people apply um which is really fun. So the in these classes once they begin they'll learn how to build connections and mentor other students um and they're also paid internships which is really cool. So, while they're learning and while they're counseling these students, they will be getting paid. Um, and the building of our new area for this program is set to begin this winter break. I'm really excited because I got to

020pick out where it's going to go and I think it's going to turn out really cool. I'm excited to decorate it. Um, and then I just wanted to close with saying thank you guys for your time and I know it's been a hectic break and I know it's been a hectic semester and I'm just I wish you all a very happy winter break and I hope you guys relax and get the things you need. Thank you. And as always, go grabs. All right. Uh, election of officers. Thank you. Each December, the board is required to uh, sorry, that's not the right one. That is not the right one. Each December, the board has their organizational meeting where you elect officers. So, okay, you may begin. Sorry, I had the wrong script for the wrong item.

021I'll say that later. So, election of the president of the board. Do I have any nominations for president of the board? I will nominate Sarah Ahmad. Any second? A second. Thank you. Uh moved by uh member Carlson, seconded by I'm sorry, which was it or seconded by member Mum to nominate Sarah Mad as the president of the governing board. Is there any discussion? Right. All those in favor say I. I. Any opposed? Motion carries. Thank you. Um election of the vice president of the board. Do I have any nominations for vice president of the board? I'll I'll move for um a motion for Dr. Martin. Oh, sorry. The other guy. Member Martin. Uh any seconds? Second second by Stacy Carlson to nominate uh member Martin as a vice president of the governing board. Is there

022any discussion? All those in favor say I. I. Any opposed? Motion carries. Congratulations. All right. Election of clerk of the board. Do I have any nominations for clerk of the board? Nominate Stacy Carlson. I'll second. Um moved by member Martin, seconded by member Amad to nominate member Carlson as a clerk of the governing board. Is there any discussion? All those in favor say I. I. Any opposed? Motion carries. Thank you. Congratulations. All right. Communication sess session. If you wish to address the board, you may fill out a request form located in the al cove to the left of the double doors. As you enter the boardroom, please complete a white speaker form if the item you wish to speak about is on the agenda and a blue speaker form if the item you wish to

023speak about is not on the agenda. Please give it to Susie. In accordance with the board bylaw 9323, public comments will be limited to 20 minutes per topic. Each speaker will be allowed a maximum of three minutes to speak expect except for our union representatives who have five minutes. Per the Brown Act, members of the board are very limited in their ability to respond to statements or questions made during public comment. Unless any item has been placed on the published agenda, there shall be no deliberation or action taken. The board may one acknowledge the receipt of the information report and comment. Two, refer to the staff for further study or three refer the matter to the next agenda. A recording is made of all open sessions of the governing board. Again, on behalf of the

024board of education, we thank you in advance for helping us conduct this meeting respectfully. Susie, do we have any speakers? Yes. Norm McKenzie. name is uh Nor McKenzie and I live at 1578 Palomar Drive and I've been a lion for 40 years serving help and serve comm community. I come with good tidings as usual to let you know what we can do for the school district and how we can support the nurses. Uh we've upgraded all the equipment uh if in the on the uh [clears throat] trailers you probably know they've been during pandemic we had them painted had new decals put on them brand new tires and finally put a spare wheel on them all those years never had a spare wheel and uh I got a flat once and I had to take

025it off go and so anyway that and it happened at Mission Hills High School so that was really bad. So, anyways, that's uh kind of kind of the neat thing. And uh what we'd like to do is uh set up a I'd like to set up an uh meeting with these school nurses to go over some of the stuff. Um especially with the new uh in in front of you, you should have some information on some of the new equipment that we would like to purchase. But we want to know what the school nurses really want us to purchase to help them out. What what's what's going to make their job better? That's what we're here for. Our whole mission is is vision. Every child needs to see the world clearly and we want to

026prevent blindness and and our goal is here to take care of a a San Marcus first and I do service other schools and I do a lot of preschool screening and a lot of kindergarten screening and I'm out there. I'm the senior certified vision screener for the club. So that's the main thing on that. And then the student speaker contest. Student speaker contest has been a little bit slack in the in the pa past few years. It was we did a lot uh Mission Hills High School gave us a lot of speaker before the pandemic. We want to get this information out to all other high schools. And uh since you have two representatives here from each high school, I'd like to make sure that the package that I have uh so that that they

027get a copy before they leave. That would be cool. So that's where we're at. And uh that's all I really have on that to let you know that we're here to serve you. That's what we're all about. Service is what Lions do and we do a lot of things other than vision. And uh it's it's kind of nice. And and of course uh you have a new board member that's our chair of our Monarch Butterfly Festival every year and that's an environmental project to teach people how to keep the butterflies from disappearing in San Marcus. So hopefully you could keep up. So, other than that, that's really all uh I I have to say is uh thank you for allowing me to speak and any questions or anything you want to know. I could go

028on and on and on, but I got to shut up. It's three minutes. Thank you, Mr. McDonald. Thank you. We'll have we'll have Dr. Campbell. Sorry, we'll have Dr. Campbell follow up. Kenzie, I wanted to make sure that we have somebody who has your contact information to re so that we can coordinate the the meeting with the nurses. That would be Dr. Campbell. So, she will connect with you to set everything up. Thank you very much. Okay, Jody, carry on. Good evening. My name is Jodie Kerion. I have two children in the district and I'm here to discuss the proposed cell phone policy. I'd like to start by thanking the district staff for all their work on the policy thus far. I'd also like to thank Dr. Campbell specifically for her receptiveness to the various

029emails I've sent the last few weeks. I truly appreciate it. I am so happy to see that the district is proposing a K- through8 away for the day policy. It's a massive step in the right direction and will undoubtedly benefit our students and school communities. However, I hope you can all appreciate that I feel an obligation to question the proposed high school policy. Instructional time only policies can help address issues inside the classroom, but will not address the issues outside of it. issues like invasion of privacy, mental health, de device dependence, and the associated opportunity costs in building social skills. Just this week, the New York Times released an article highlighting how phones are fueling violence on school campuses. The article details how phones have not only become a major safety issue for our students,

030they also present a growing liability risk for districts. So, I respectfully ask the district to reconsider and instead bring forth an away for the day policy at all grade levels. Additionally, I have a few questions I hope you will consider as we move forward. First, we have technically had an instructional time policy in our district for years, but it hasn't worked. So, what will fundamentally change this time around? Secondly, based on the hundreds of stories I have read, successful implementation requires education, awareness, and consistent enforcement among staff. Many districts have also found deterrent systems are necessary. How will the district address this? And finally, there's much to be learned over the coming months as districts across the US adopt new policies. How will our district monitor and measure our policy and can we commit to

031re-evaluating and adapting as we learn more? As I wrap up, I would like to remind us that this isn't simply a kids these days issue. This is an everyone issue. And I say this as an adult who struggles to regulate my phone use despite all the tricks that I've tried. My attention span is worse. The cognitive overload is real. and my mood drops the more time I spend. Perhaps you've noticed this in yourselves, and it's all by design. Oxford's word of the year is brain rot, a term describing a phenomenon in which tech overuse leads to dementia-like symptoms and structural changes in our brain. How disturbing is that? We are devolving into a numbed, distracted, semi-present society, unconsciously buying into the illusion that online experiences are just as valuable, if not preferable, to authentic human

032connection. And our kids are watching. I'm passionate about this topic because our kids deserve better. But it will require us to step up, make a commitment to change, and even address our own habits. Thank you very much. It's okay. Didn't know we were 15 seconds. Good evening, governing board. Is my pleasure to give you a couple of quick updates on district matters this evening. I will begin by welcoming board members again as we did our swearing in today. Welcome back to Trustee Ahmad and welcome to uh trustees Heric and Mume. Right. Okay. We practiced like a bunch of times. Uh I think I got it right. Uh and we did photos this afternoon. So the next slide you see will all be branded and Amy will be happy and all the backgrounds will be the

033same and it'll all be great. Uh but we're very happy to to to welcome you to to the board and welcome Sarah back. Lots of work to be done. So let's get right to it. Uh and uh it's important to recognize that every December we have the CSBA annual conference and our two new board members even before they were sworn in did attend. So, thank you for that. And I know I say this every single year, and I hope I can continue to say this. I hope I'm here next December saying this again, that it is awesome that all five of our board members attend CSBA. Um, there are many districts who don't send any board members at all. And there are some who have a couple, maybe they come, maybe they go, we have

034consistently, every year that I've been in San Marcos, all five board members have attended, which really just um is a testament to the commitment to good governance and to continue learning. It's a great model for staff and for our students. So, thank you. Couple of interesting topics I think this year that stood out to me. Um, there's always a lot of govern uh governance strategy and practice. Of course, that's the kind of the main theme. Um, the two new trustees and I spent the full day on Wednesday, the pre-ervice day, the pre-conference day um in the new trusty workshop. Thank you for attending that. We had a lot of dialogue, a lot of learning, and we joked about drinking from a fire hose. Uh, we joked about some acronyms that were getting we're still getting

035straight and all all those kinds of things on both ends, right? Um but that was really good. So thank you for attending that with me. Uh there were also one of the themes a big themes this year as you you are aware because you were there were statewide budget challenges. Um statewide deficits are real up and down the state. Um declining enrollment is real for all school districts. A lot of school districts out there are closing schools. We have not gotten there and we don't have any projections that we're going to need to do that in the next foreseeable future. So that's really good. But um it's just uh I think a testimony a testament to um the real challenge that our state is is facing right now. And then just today an article came

036out from a report actually last week that Moody's issued a negative outlook for K12 public schools for 2025. Um and that's not a good thing. So again that speaks to fiscal prudence and we you know the board knows that we've done a lot in that respect for the past number of years. Um knowing that the budget cycles as Aaron said last week budget cycles in California are very cyclical. Uh, one of the the images I like to use for people when when they're asking about this is we're like a roller coaster. It's like every every economy is going to have its ups and downs, the way that the te California tax structure is structured is that we have these massive big roller coaster, big ups and big downs. So, we're either great or we're not.

037We're right now in a in a very challenging year. Next year is going to be a little tight, too. After that, it'll it'll start to loosen up again probably. So, um, that was another one of the themes. And then student mental health and wellness. Um, phones is a piece of it and a lot more in there as well. I actually got to attend a session where they screened Anxious Nation and I would recommend that to anybody who wants to look at it and really get a good um firhand view and hear students, teenagers talking about uh anxiety that they're experiencing in a way that um I just frankly you I grew up in the in the 80s and I was in high school in the 80s and we just didn't it wasn't the thing like

038it is now. Um, and they're they're using kind of language and they're talking about things that I don't I don't recall from my own my own teenage years and it's very uh it's very important. It's very troubling. Um, but yeah, if you go if you Google Anxious Nation, you'll see there are screenings of this and and the presenter in this uh session was actually the mom who produced this. She's a writer by trade, she said, but she this is her very first documentary that she ever did. Her daughter features uh very prominently in it. So, they were there presenting. They're actually in uh Tory Pines at Tory Pines High School. So they're here locally and I got to meet her after the session. I said, "Hey, we're we're neighbors. I'm in San Marcos." And I

039asked the student if she would be willing to maybe come to talk to the student advisory and she said, "Yeah, she would." So I'm going to see if we can get that get that dialed in. I think that would be that would be really great. So um that's it for CSBA. Couple of highlights for tonight's agenda. Uh we have um a couple of really important items. We have the NG Energy Savings Project update for phase two. So, the board is aware that a couple years ago, um, Aaron spearheaded this this project that's going to save our district millions and millions and millions of dollars. So, tonight we're going to hear about phase two that's about ready to start. We also have a public hearing and recommended approval of the renewal for Pivot Charter School that's

040coming up. Um, and then the main event, Dr. Campbell is going to lead us through the first reading of revised board policy 5131.8 on mobile communication devices. I just want to say a couple things on that. Uh I will I promise not to steal too much of your thunder, which I like to do. Um I want to commend Tiffany and the team uh because this is a this is a big deal. This is I mean I think we all agree, yes, something's got to be done. Um and the devil's in the details. This is a great example. We were sharing earlier. This is this is a great example where the board living at the policy level says, "We got to figure something out here. We'd like to we'd like to have some more restrictions there."

041and charges the staff with like go, you know, come climb down the ladder and figure out what it's going to look like on the ground. And every question you answer, every every solution or idea you have, five more considerations pop up. Um we had a she still here. So you're going to hear I think most of your questions are going to be answered. Um if not satisfactory, at least they're answered. Uh and some of them I think will be answered satisfactoryy. So um I will say that uh this is the the kind of a a shift that's going to be pretty major for staff and students. So, our plan is um to hear the first read tonight, second reading at the January meeting for a roll out the following week, uh and then we will

042monitor through the spring, kind of see how things go, see what other things pop up, and then we'll probably be back before the board in in May or June with our learnings from from this semester, um this coming semester and and see where we go from there. And with that, I want to wish everybody a very happy holiday and a restful new year. And now you don't have anything to present. What I do best, what I do best. That's why you shouldn't brief me beforehand. I just say it all. No, I'm just kidding. She asked Fency to present. So, thank you. If there are any questions, I'm happy to entertain them. Okay. Thank you. All right. As Andy said, next item is presentations phase 2 energy project at the transportation yard. Okay. Okay, while they're

043bringing that up, um I just wanted to say that the district has been working with NG for almost three years now, um on several different um energy conservation projects. Um I'd like to introduce Nancy Roaraba from NG Services. Um Nancy has been working with the district since the beginning um of these projects um with our original goal being to electrify our bus fleet and um achieve energy savings um districtwide. She will present tonight a brief recap of our phase one projects and then review the plans that we have for phase two of this project. Later this evening on agenda item number 11.2, the board will consider approval of a contract amendment with NG um for these phase 2 projects. So go ahead, Nancy. All right. Good evening, members of the board, superintendent, members of cabinet.

044Pleasure to be here tonight. Um, once again, I'm Nancy with NG. And for those of you who may not be familiar with NG, NG is the world's largest energy services provider. Uh, the company's been in business for more than 150 years and we've been implementing energy conservation projects for more than 40 years. Um, I personally more than 30 years. So almost almost the 40 years. Um but uh we'll talk more about energy conservation programs and the role they play in this phase 2 program as well as the phase one program in a moment. Um this uh slide I just have to highlight though this was a drone shot of excuse me [clears throat] the ribbon cutting that we held at the San Marcos Unified School District Transportation Yard um prior to the start of the

045uh ribbon cutting. And I have to give a big shout out to Amy in the back because Amy was instrumental in helping to put together a fabulous ribbon cutting. So, um I just I just love this slide. It was a lot of fun. Um so, with regard to we're going to talk tonight about the mandate. California issued the mandate um that any public entity that maintains a fleet of vehicles must upgrade that fleet by 2035 to be carbon neutral. Right? We all know that. Um and That is the challenge because as soon as that mandate was issued, all of a sudden, organizations such as the California Energy Commission started awarding free buses to school districts. And the questions we kept getting from school districts, great, we have this these free buses. What do we do

046with these? We have to charge them. We have no infrastructure. How are we going to do this? How are we going to redesign our transportation yards? Um, and more importantly, how are we going to pay for this? And so under our energy conservation programs, we identify savings opportunities throughout the district that collectively and comprehensively can pay for not just the upgrades such as the lighting in the phase one project. we retrofit this lighting um or HVAC upgrades or installing renewable energy systems, but also we can utilize those savings to pay for other challenges or other energy type programs such as transitioning your um your bus fleet to electric fleet. Um so tonight uh we will talk about the phase one program, just do a a a revision. Um we'll talk about the phase two program

047as well as potential next steps. And I see unfortunately this is not the presentation that um that I sent over. So it's going to be a little bit different than what the agenda says and and um but we'll be okay. So for the phase one project um you have an executive director of transportation and Mike Sawyer. I'm sure you know Mike Sawyer. Not only is he an excellent bus driver, he's an outstanding manager of the transportation center, but this guy is a superb grant writer. I have never ever met anybody who can write grants as well as this gentleman. And so he started getting all this grant money. He started getting all these free buses. And he was one of those districts that said, "What in the world are we going to do? I'm I'm

048getting all these buses. We they're going to they want to start delivering them today." And I'm not sure if you know this, but the uh bus manufacturers in California no longer manufacture combustion engine buses. They're all electric buses. So the push is on. it is really on. And so under this phase one program, we went out to all your sites um identified energy savings opportunities. And I'm sure you all know that when you change out a fluorescent light to an LED lamp, you immediately realize 85% of electricity lighting cost savings. So that is a huge opportunity to collect all the savings at the district. We retrofit uh your LED lighting facility lighting at 19 of your different sites and that savings help pay for some of this electric charging infrastructure. We also installed renewable energy

049systems here at the at the um North County Regional Education Center. Um also at San Marcos High School, we added additional solar. And then over at the transportation yard, we added renewable energy system. the solar, the micro grid system, um enough for 40 buses. Now, we would have liked to have built out the whole infrastructure, but SDG& um all the investor owned utilities require commercial customers only build out the systems that they can support with regard to their current consumption. And that's why we're coming back with the phase two. We could only build it up to 40 chargers because that's the amount of buses that Mike and the district were awarded at the time. Um when I look at the phase two project, we're going to install um five additional solar canopies, which I'll show

050you in a moment, and um another uh micro grid system at the district at excuse me, the transportation center, which will help support the additional 35 chargers that we'll be installing. I also want to point out not only in the phase 2 program but the phase one program NG will be providing your maintenance on all these renewable energy systems for the next 20 years. We guarantee the production. We guarantee the savings and so it's our responsibility to make sure that these savings and these systems are operating at peak capacity and peak efficiency because if they don't we have to write a check for the difference. All right. So, for the phase 2 solar layout, this is kind of tough to see, but um arrays A, B, C, D, and E are kind of in the

051pinky red color. In between arrays C and E, and in between arrays A and B, you'll notice kind of like a long elongated lighter gray shade. Um, those two solar arrays have already been installed as part of the phase one program. Um, and so the phase 2 program would install the additional five arrays A through E. For charger locations, the first 40 chargers have been installed in the um the original two underneath the original two arrays, the the gray shaded ones. We will install five additional chargers uh under that northern array. The red dots represent where the new chargers will be installed, and the uh additional chargers will be installed under arrays A and B. With regard to warranties, they're the same for phase one as they are for phase two. Um manufacturer warranties, 25

052years on the uh solar panels, 20 years on the inverters, 20 years on the battery systems, the EV chargers, 5 years on the parts, but once again, we will maintain those all for 20 years. So the pricing, okay, this is let me jump to phase two. Here we go. So, um, with regard to phase two, the price of the phase 2 project is 12.8 million. I'd like to point out that the grants and utility incentives will pay for more than 8 million of this project. In this proforma, the green columns are the savings columns. On the far right is the net savings over the life of the project annually. And down at the far right, over $22 million in savings or close to $22 million in savings. The red columns are the cost columns. And

053um I believe Erin, you wanted to make a comment or two about this. Yes. I just want to point out to the board that the the overall cost of this um project is the $12.8 million. Um and um you can see overall it's going to produce net savings of over $21 million over a 30-year period. Um however, you can see like about in in year two, um we do have a cash flow issue. Um, so I am prepared with some construction funds that we have available to be able to um pay for this project and then wait for the reimbursements from all these um incentive credits that we'll get back that will make us positive, right? But um it we will have um have to put out some cash initially and then we will get

054the credits back as well as achieve savings in the general fund um over time. So bottom line, phase one, that was a $28 million project. That project cost was not only paid for with the savings in the grants that were available as a result of that project, but it also provides annual net positive cash flow every single year. So over the life of the program, not only will that program be paid for by the savings and grants, it will also generate an additional $50 million back to the general fund over the life of the program. That's the beauty of these energy conservation programs. For phase two, once again, the pro the program pays for itself. There'll be more than $8 million in grants. Uh phase one, more than $6 million in grants. Uh phase two,

055more than $8 million in grants. This will gen generate more than $20 million over the life of the program. All that goes right back to the general fund. So for the total project, both phases, the total project pays for itself obviously with $15 million in grants as well as generating more than $70 million over the life of the program. And what we the whole reason we started with this was to make sure that during public safety power shut offs, those students can still be transported by the electric buses. So what you have at the transportation yard or what you know what you have under phase one and what you will have if you move forward with phase two is additional ability to take care of this. But you can operate your fleet during those times

056when the grid is not operating. You will have the micro grid system that steps in when the grid shuts off. So even if it's four days long you will be able to transport those students. Um, if uh the district decides to move forward with phase two, I think everybody's heard about the upcoming tariffs that are coming in. It doesn't matter if it's from North America, if it's from Asia, wherever it's coming from. Um, we would want to capitalize on making sure that we order equipment ASAP to we don't want to we don't want to, you know, obviously come back with any cost increases. Um, it would take us six months to design the infrastructure on this phase 2 and then about a year to install it. that installation would start in summer of 2025 and

057um would finish about 2026. Now, we do know that the district has about 33 buses right now on site um that they need to charge. They have two uh child nutrition center box trucks they need to charge. Mike uh and the the transportation center um received word that they're getting 24 more buses. They've been awarded 24 more buses. Those will arrive before summer of 2025. So in the next six months, he's holding those off as well. Um and then after that, he'll get about another 14 or 16 buses between 2020 summer of 2025 to summer of 2026. So he's he's just on a tear. He's amazing. Ask a question real quick. Um I think you told me this before, but I'm gonna ask No. Not that it's about winning, but it's about winning. Are we

058once we get all these electric buses, we are one of the biggest electric fleets. You are, as a matter of fact, um you I think you will be the biggest fleet that I know of in Southern California and possibly all of California. Marino Valley right now has 36 Chargers and 36 buses, but you'll obviously come up to 59 very quickly. And that's that's Mike Sawyer's work. He's in this area. Yeah. Any other questions? Yeah. Thank you. All right. Report by board members. Um, does any board member have any information or important issues or events to share other than happy holidays to everybody out there and to the students and staff and teachers and certificated classified everybody, thank you for all the work. Yep. I'll just echo that. Happy holidays everyone. This is our last meeting

059for the year and wishing everyone a very happy holiday season and a very I was going to say very merry new year but you guys didn't want to represent very happy new year as well. All right. Um action agenda 2025 uh governing board meeting date. Do I have a motion to approve the 2025 governing board meeting dates? So so moved. Um any anyone second? Second. Okay. I think that was Mium. Okay. Um moved by Carlson uh me member Carlson and seconded by member Mam to approve the meeting dates as presented. Student board representatives representatives please say your v vote. All those in Yeah. Say your vote. I. [laughter] All those in favor say I. I. Any opposed? Motion carries. this one. Okay. Uh, all right. Consideration and approval of the first amendment to cont contract

060with NG services. Aaron. Okay. So, on December 15th of 2022, the district previously adopted a resolution and entered into a contract for design and construction of energy conservation measures with NG services. Um and we made certain findings um required by the government code section 4217.10 finding that the cost of the energy conservation measures contemplated by the contract were more than offset by the energy savings to be achieved as part of the phase one work. and NG services and the district um is now proposing a phase two scope of work as we just heard um with additional um conservation measures consisting primarily of the installation of additional solar panels and bus chargers at the district's transportation yard to serve our new electric buses. Um the cost of the phase 2 work is the $ 122.8 8

061million and will be initially funded by the district out of available construction funds in fund 25 but will be offset by reimbursements from grant funds in the amount of $8.3 million. Um and so as we looked um reviewed earlier, the district anticipates a net savings of more than 21 million just on the phase 2 portion of this project over the 30-year period. We do not anticipate any impacts to cash flow out of the general fund. It's really important, but the general fund will absolutely benefit from the long-term energy cost savings of this project and staff does recommend approval of this phase 2 um contract amendment. Any questions? Do I have a motion to approve the first amendment to the cont to the contract with NG Services Incorporated? To approve. Any second? I'll second. Okay. All

062right. Moved by member Carlson, seconded by member Heric to approve the amend amendment as presented. Student board representatives, please say your vote. I I. All those in favor say I. I. I. Any opposed? Motion carries. All right. Public hearing charter petition to renew for Pivot Charter School. Tiffany. This is the second public hearing that the district is holding regarding the renewal petition of Pivot Charter School. On September 24th, the district received the posi the petition from Pivot to renew its charter with SMUSD. And on October 10th, the governing board held a public hearing to determine the level of support for the hearing for the petition. At that time, numerous members of the school community offered their support for the school. On December 4th, the district posted its findings regarding the petition, which will be discussed

063in the next agenda item. Tonight's public hearing is held for any parties wishing to offer comment since those findings have been posted. This public hearing is now open. Susie, is there anyone who wishes to speak? Yes. Liz Jones. Good evening, esteemed board members. Congratulations to those of you who were just sworn in recently. There's some new faces here. Um, and thank you all for your service. We really greatly appreciate working with you all. My name is Liz Jones and I'm the chief business officer for Pivot Charter School. Um, but actually my career here began 14 years ago as a math teacher. So, um, I've seen firsthand a lot of what you heard about at the last public hearing. Um, the transformations that Pivot has facilitated for students and their families. My background as a teacher

064also helps me stay centered on what's best for students as I work with our governing board, executive director, and business team to manage the budget and finances and ensure ongoing fiscal stability. Pivot's board members demonstrate a wealth of fiscal oversight experience. Uh they have worked as school district superintendent, city managers, investment bankers, and entrepreneurs. They're wonderful leaders and mentors who cultivate capacity within the organization, and they don't hesitate to ask the hard questions, especially of me when it comes to finances. Um, the board closely monitors enrollment as well as the broader state and federal funding landscape and has worked with our business team to establish plans and contingencies for a variety of scenarios. I'm sure you're all very familiar with that as well. As Superintendent Johnson just mentioned, it's it can be a roller coaster,

065so we need to be prepared for anything. I'm happy to report uh that we have actually made excellent progress toward meeting our enrollment goals for this year. Um and we had 90 students reported for our official fall enrollment count. Um in the staff report there had been a note of our previous few years. Um and the most recent year last year was 82. So that's almost a 10% increase over last year's count. So um we are showing a a gradual rebound after our blip where we dropped our in our enrollment. Um as of today we actually have an enrollment count of 100 and two currently pending. So that brings our count up to 102. Um, our enrollment typically increases throughout the fall and winter, peaking around February. So, we do expect to continue to see

066a little bit of growth in our enrollment over the next few months. I'd like to thank uh the San Marcos Unified staff for acknowledging our prudent financial management in their report. Um, the recommendation for theou to include a 10% reserve requirement is entirely reasonable to us. So, I just wanted to comment that it's also in line with some previous internal um benchmarks and targets that our governing board had set with us. Um so, we're grateful for the ongoing support provided by your team. Um especially the business services team I work uh with directly. Um and they're are wonderful to work with. Um so, we look forward to our continued partnership and the opportunity to serve many more students and families in the years ahead. Thank you. Thank you. Sorry, Gail Gonzalez. Good evening, superintendent, assistant

067superintendent, board of trustees, staff, student representatives, and community. My name is Dr. Gail Gonzalez Colloyan, site administrator at Pivot Charter School San Diego. I'm also a proud member of the SMUSD community as a parent of two current students and one graduate at Mission Hills. This is my eighth year at the um in the PI on the Pivot faculty and I'm here to voice my support of Pivot Charters renewal. I look forward to continuing to support our students with our regular one-on-one check-ins and to discuss their academic and social emotional concerns as well as to celebrate their accomplishments. I look forward to continuing to provide an equitable and personalized education that challenges every student while providing academic academic supports like tutoring and workshops and social emotional supports like counseling and explicit instruction in our home rooms.

068I'm happy to report that since our last public hearing, we have received the preliminary dashboard results which showed gains in both ELA and math assessments as well as graduation rates. I hope to continue to be able to pro provide our on-site program with a very low teacherto student ratio where our goal is for every single student to feel seen and heard in a caring environment. I hope to continue seeing our graduates come back and share their stories about the colleges they're attending, the programs they finished, the jobs they now have, and thank thanking us for this preparation they received and for helping them to uh pivot their educational journey. I hope that after hearing our students and parents speak tonight and at the public first public hearing in October, we leave no doubts in your

069mind that Pivot is a very important and beneficial part of our San Marcos community and that you enthus enthusiastically support our petition for renewal. Thank you all for your support. Raquel Madden. Good evening, board members, superintendent. My name is Raquel Maiden. I am the new vice president of Southern California Advocacy for the Charter Schools Association for the state, and I'm here today in support of the 5-year renewal of Pivot Charter. Um, we commend the San Marcos Unified School District staff for their thorough review of the renewal petition and for recommending its approval. Pivot 2 is classified as a middle track charter school by the California Department of Education based on its performance on the California school dashboard. Use under education code 47607 C. This designation qualifies the school for a renewal term of up to

070five years. The school meets all legal requirements for renewal and throughout the process, Pivot 2 has demonstrated a strong commitment to collaboration, working closely with district staff, families, and stakeholders while leveraging resources provided by CCSA. Pivot 2 is also dedicated to fostering academic progress and serving its unique student population with a tailored educational approach. By approving this renewal, you are supporting a program that provides critical educational opportunities and prepares students for future success. We f fully support the staff's recommendation for renewal and urge the board to vote to approve pivot charter for another five years. Thank you for your continued support of highquality education options in San Marcos. Arthur Congo. Good evening. Uh my name is Arthur Congo. I'm the director of local advocacy with the California Charter Schools Association here in San Diego and

071we're here to support the 5-year renewal for Pivot Charter School San Diego. Uh we thank staff for their comprehensive review and collaboration during the renewal process ensuring that the school's commitment I'm sorry um during the comprehensive review and collaboration during the renewal process ensuring the school's commitment to addressing both academic and operational priorities. Pivot 2 provides a unique and vital educational model with a specific goal of helping students catch up on credits or learning through a customizable individual online curriculum. The school also offers a small, safe, and nurturing environment tailored to students who thrive in such settings. This approach is essential for ensuring that all students, especially those needing additional support, have the opportunity to succeed. District staff's recommendation highlights Pivot 2's prudent financial management and dedication to academic progress despite enrollment challenges during the

072recent years. The school has implemented robust measures to stabilize and increase enrollment which will further enhance its financial position. So we urge the board to follow staff recommendation and approve pivot 2 charters renewal. Thank you for your leadership and commitment to supporting innovative and inclusive educational opportunities in San Marcos. Thank you Julianne Cochran. Good evening everyone. Thank you for your time uh and for your service to many many students. Um my name is Julian Cochran. I'm the curriculum coordinator for Pivot Charter and I have been with Pivot for eight years. Um but like Liz, I started as a math teacher as well. Um and my background is in making sure that math makes sense to kids. So, a lot of that work that I do at Pivot now is really focused on that. Um, a

073lot of what I get to do in my day-to-day is make sure that our curriculum is aligned with our state standards, but also accessible to our students who are so unique. Each of our students has different needs, different reasons they came to us instead of one of our larger high schools. Um, and so we want to make sure that what we do makes them feel comfortable, uh, able to do the education that they need and then also be able to go into the world and be successful. Um, one of the other things I get to do is I get to work with a team of educators. I have 11 um, educators that work with me one-on-one with students. They tutor them all throughout the day, even into the evening. I think there's maybe even one

074going on still right now. And they offer that support so that students can get help whenever it makes sense for their lives. especially some of our students who um are parents or also work full-time to help take care of their families. Um so they're wonderful, wonderful educators and I just want to uh advocate again for our school and our staff that work hard to make sure that the needs of all students are met. Thank you. There are no more speakers. You this public hearing is now closed. Resolution number 28-2425, approval of pivot charter school renewal. Tiffany, [clears throat] good evening everyone. So tonight I am going to highlight a few of the findings from Pivot's chart petition um and make a final recommendation to the board. So, just a bit of background that you have

075heard. Um, Pivot Charter San Diego 2 is a non-classroombased independent study charter school. Um, originally authorized SMUSD at for by SMUSD in 2018. As discussed on September 24th, we received their initial petition. October 10th, we um conducted a public hearing and within that time we have now reviewed the full petition per the criteria for renewal. Um, as a reminder to the board and for our new board members, the renewal criteria, um, we review 15 elements. So, the petition is required to have these 15 elements. I will not read them to you. You can see them here. Um, we can deny a renewal, the board can deny a renewal petition for very specific reasons. And there are four very specific reasons. Um, the school presents an unound educational program. Uh, the petitioners are demonstrabably unlikely to

076successfully implement the program that they put forth in the petition. The petition does not contain an affirmation of each of the conditions that are set forth and it does not contain reasonably comprehensive descriptions of the required 15 elements. None of these are the case with the pivot charter petition um that we have reviewed. Um just so you are aware of what we are looking at when we are talking about pivot charter. Um this information was in the petition and is from the 2324 school year. So at the time pivot enrollment was about 82 um slightly lower than its previous than its previous enrollment that you've heard just recently. U I do want to point out that Pivot serves a different demographic uh than our comprehensive um district does. So they're about uh 50% socioeconomically disadvantaged.

077And the large number here that I do want to point out is that they are over 30% students with disabilities. So that is a pretty large number um of students with disabilities that they serve. Particularly when you compare it to SMUSD, we are high um at 14% and then the county um at 15 almost 16% in California in general. So they serve a very different population. Um their high in 232 24 was about 120 students. Um the majority of those students came from middle and high school with a small percentage from elementary. 62 of those lived within the San Marcos Unified boundary. Um as you may or may not be aware, they pull from other districts as well. Um but about 62 of them come from San Marcos Unified. and 57 of those um at

078some point in their educational career attended a San Marco Unified School. Um as you've heard, Pivot Charter is in the medium or middle performing category. I do want to give you some context for that. There about 201 charter schools in California that were placed as high. 95 were placed in low and the vast majority of our charter schools in California are placed in that medium category. So as we reviewed their educational program um as was mentioned we do our findings do show that they have been making reasonable progress in their educational program. um it is difficult to measure um and really assess how they are doing with Smarter Balanced and CASP because they're because their population one is transient and two because there is a very small number of kids that are actually um that

079they are actually testing. So in 2024 there are 53 students that were tested. Their performance was comparable to other independent study charters. Um and we were beginning to see improvements from those post-pandemic drops. Um for their verified data, they use I Ready, which we also use in our district as well. And we see that they were making reasonable gains in both math and um ELA from fall to spring. Chronic absenteeism, also notable drops in chronic absenteeism, a high in 2019 of 34.8 down to 23.4. four and we were happy to see that they also have a goal of under 10% which is where we are as well. So when we c when they're categorized as a medium or middle performing that's based on the the the CASP and I ready data CASP I Ready CASP

080data as well as other dashboard data. So dashboard data is across the board um but the academic data is based on that I based on um the CASP scores. Okay. Thanks. Um we also look at other areas for pivot because of their t because of their population. Uh the school has a goal of their students earning 30 credits per semester as well as a goal of students graduating in four years even if they start um with enrolling in start enrollment with credit deficiencies. So we see um that their graduation rate was at a high of 77.1% in 2023 68.4% 4% and I'm happy to hear that um that percentage is improving um as the year as the year progresses. With that in mind, um our overall review of the educational program and performance criteria is

081that students are making adequate progress given the nature of the program, the student population and the and the impact of CO 19. Um as was as was mentioned um the mission of the school is to enroll students with very low academic self-confidence, low test scores, low low motivation or need for a small environment and pivot them um and pivot their attit attitudes towards school. They have appropriately identified gaps within the student academic performance. They've detailed multi-tered systems of support within the program to address student needs. And annual parent and student surveys show high levels of satisfaction with both the curricular program and also staff support for meeting educational goals. Their governance and management and I want to pause and give a shout out to our business services team for doing the hard work uh in

082reviewing this section of the of the petition. So, um, they are governed by six board members. Um, they are holding their meetings at least quarterly. I think they're holding them more than that because I get a whole lot of I get a lot of emails about their board meetings. Um, parents and the public have access via video conferencing. Um, we have consistently receive their board meeting agendas, their supporting documents. Um, and as permits, um, a SMUSD representative attends the annual meeting, that's me, um, upon availability. So um I have been a couple of years I have been to their annual meetings. Their financial outlook um they did experience a decline uh between 202122 and 2022 23. Um so we did make note of that. However, in 23 24 we did see stabilization uh with 82

083students a pro a projected increase uh to 98 students and happy to hear that you are hitting even higher than that. Um their multi-year projections have shown prudent budget planning for the authorization period with healthy reserves. So we are seeing thoughtful governance with clear avenues for advisement and engagement of staff, parent, guardians and students as well as prudent financial management with healthy healthy reserve levels. Um there are reasonable assumptions in the multi-year financial projections which indicates a solid planning process. There is fiscal stability and the ability to absorb unexpected fiscal challenges um that um may come about. So with that um we are recommending that the SMUSD governing board adopt the resolution number 28 24 25 and grant the renewal petition of pivot charter San Diego for a period of 5 years to begin July

0841st 2025. Any questions? I mean, I would just say like I I I um have been to the site a few times actually over the years. Um and I think it's it's very I would absolutely encourage the board to go and tour the site. It does not look anything like a school. Um, however, uh, what I think is is very interesting and compelling for me personally when I go is that there's no possible way that I can provide that at my at any of my schools, right? Like our schools just don't have the ability. I walked into this one room and there was a student under, you know, underneath a weighted blanket with a flashlight reading a book, right? And I I was just like, "Yeah, I can't I can't do that." Um and I

085I think that it does serve um a portion of students who are really high need that, you know, as much as we might want to or try, you know, and we do try, right? Um, I think that, um, you've hit a niche in the community that, um, is really meaningful and, um, I I would absolutely recommend and and move to to approve um, the resolution um, and and really recommend that that the board at some point just find some time to just drop by and and check it out because it is it is very compelling and it's very different, right? like I think you just need to to go there and see it so that you can kind of get your head around what we're really talking about here. Um [clears throat] and they would

086love for you to visit always. Yeah. Yeah. And I would echo um so go ahead. Go ahead. I was I was I'll echo um Stacy's comments. The stories that you guys and your students and family shared during the October meeting were profoundly moving and it is u I I know like Stacy said some of those students we couldn't serve at our school. So thank you for those that you do. I was very impressed with that presentation as well. My only question is in terms of the student the 31.7% students who have an IEP, an active IEP, and I know it's a little bit more complicated, a little bit more entailed with the graduation rates, but are those students who aren't able to graduate on a four-year plan, are they afforded that fifth year, and does

087that affect your graduation rates because of that? So, I don't know if that I'm [clears throat] I mean I know it's a little bit deeper than that and it's very specific and in the weeds, but I'm just saying for my reflection I would I'm assuming that's why the graduation rates is Yeah. Well, [laughter] they were drawing straw. They were drawing straw in Yes, the answer. I currently have a seventh year high school senior, so we're not getting rid of you. 100% yes. Being a fifth year does affect our graduation race that lately. [laughter] So yes, speaking to graduation rates and special ed, um that does happen, but I do want to say without a piece of data in front of me right now is our special ed students generally do make it in four years,

088it's the students who are benefiting from the way we run our school as a special ed school who are more likely to not graduate in four years. If that makes sense. Did I leave anything out? No, but thank you. Thank you for again, as Stacy and my colleague Sarah had pointed out, working with that your population. Thank you. Thank you. We'll see you on campus soon. All right. So, um, this motion was moved by state member Carlson. Do I have a second? A second. Seconded by member Miam to adopt resolution number 28-2425 as presented. Student board representatives, please say your vote. I I Board members in favor say I. I. Any opposed? Motion carries. Congratulations. All right. Item number 11.5, student readmit case number 2-2425. Tiffany, the board has received background information regarding this case.

089The student has met all requirements for readmission and re-entry plans have been developed in collaboration with the district, the school site, and the family. As such, staff is recommending approval of the student read case 02-2425. Do I have a motion to approve the re the readmission of student case number 2-2425? Make the motion. I'll second. Moved by member Martin, seconded by member Ahmad to approve the readmission as presented. All those in favor say I. I. I. Any opposed? Motion carries. Right. Item number 12, consent agenda. Do I have the motion to approve the consent agenda for discuss discussion purposes? So move. Okay. I'm being here guys. Second. Okay. Moved by member Carlson, seconded by Dr. uh by member Martin to approve the consent agenda for discussion purposes. Is there any discussion? All right. Um do

090I just do they do they approve it as well? Right. So moved by member Carlson, seconded by member Martin. Student board representatives, please say your vote. I I. All those in favor say I. I. Any opposed? Motion carries. Item 13, information agenda, policy revisions for mobile communication devices. Tiffany, drum roll, please. [laughter] Okay, it seems like I was just here. Okay, thank you. Um, so as um Dr. Mr. Johnson mentioned a lot of work has gone into um looking at our uh our processes and our policy of mobile communication devices very formal our cell phone our cell phone policy. Um I have with me today uh to talk to you us a little bit Miss KB Gonzalez Fernandez um who is a recent alumni of Mission Hills High School. Um so she will be talking

091a little bit about the student voice um in this process. Um I also want to acknowledge director Frius who is our director of student services who really has been um a large force um in getting the information um out and talking to folks um about our uh about our policy. So with that we're going to get started. So just a brief recap of where we were. Um in September we did give anformational update to the board about a about AB2 3216. Um this is the phone free school act that was signed by the governor. Um the governor um has us school districts developing a policy to limit the use of smartphones by July 1st, 2026. we actually had a policy in place already. Um but the board directed us to really look at our policy

092and see how we could tighten that up a bit. Um so between October and November um we've we sent out student staff and family surveys. We had student staff and family focus groups. We reviewed the data. Um we've made some draft policy revisions. We have talked to principles. We have talked to students again. We have talked to lots and lots of people um to help us create what we hope is a um balanced uh approach to um this huge um issue that we are facing. Um with that I am going to have uh KB talk a little bit about the student input. First of all good evening. Thank you for allowing me to speak today. Um, I'm super honored to be speaking on behalf of students and uh, voicing their concern. Um, one thing to

093note is when we're when I'm referring to this and when me and Tiffany are talking about this um, making sure that we consider that when we say data, there are stories behind this um, statistical analysis and there are stories of students, families and parents behind all of this. So, we need to consider that too in our um, in our analysis of all of this. Um so right here we have uh earlier in the semester students were sent a cell phone survey that asked about cell phones in school and these were sent to our secondary schools. This is the breakdown of grades. Um it's important to note that 2thirds of the total engagement with the survey did come from our middle schools. So as we progress through the data analysis, just keep in mind that twothirds

094is representation from the middle schools and only about a third is from our high school students. So uh these are questions pulled directly from the survey with the language that students were asked about. This is our our first question we're going to take a look at where students were asked how often they use their cell phones or other electronic devices including smartwatches, AirPods during the day. It's uh I want to point your attention to the yellow area which is the largest portion which they answered that sometimes the second largest portion often in green and the third largest portion is in red and it's rarely. And when we look at this, we have to also acknowledge that our students are very conscious about their cell phone use and they're able to tell us how often they

095see themselves using cell phones. Um, so we also need to trust our students um that they know what uh what they're talking about because they use their cell phones. Um, and we also have to approach this as um as clear as we can because I want to point your attention to the purple which is almost always uh versus the red which is rarely. And often what happens is we get really attached to data points that are true. But we also have to recognize that our biases will make us hold on to those data points and kind of stretch them out. So we got to take in the data um as it really is. uh versus getting our letting our biases get in the way of what we choose to believe. For this section, students were

096asked when they think it's appropriate to use their cell phones. And not surprisingly, students recognize that there is validity in using their cell phones during breaks and lunchtime and for academic purposes. down at the bottom, it has about a 3.4% for students who responded that cell phones should not be allowed for the day. But this this also makes you consider how cautious our students are about when they think it's appropriate to use their cell phones. Um, and although this might seem contrary to what we think our cell phone policy should be, we also have to consider the amount of social socialization that happens for our students today and how it can be very scary for us to see them attached to their screens, but I'm sure it was scary for everyone's parents um to see

097them calling on cell phones too or using their pagers or however, you know. Um, so it it's scary when we see like new generations start to use different forms of communication. So we have to keep in mind that socialization can look very very different for different generation. I have a question about this. Were students allowed to select multiple responses to this? Yes, thank you for bringing that up. Yes, students were select uh for this uh any of the purple that looks like charts. Students were allowed to select multiple choices. So that's why our numbers are relatively off because it says like 3,000 um and such. But yes, this was a multiple choice uh selection. So yeah, just on the note of communication and how it can look different for different generations. This is how much

098students believe cell phones distract them. And unsurprisingly, the majority is that students think that overwhelmingly cell phones don't distract them at all. um which we can say about our favorite things, our favorite shows, we can say they don't distract us, our favorite music. Um and so just making sure that we take this data in um in a human approach and seeing and recognizing that students connect to different things and although we all know it can be distracting um putting ourselves in their perspective of of this is something that they used to connect with other people and how they used to socialize. Yeah, I I'll just add that it's uh they may not recognize it because they don't know what it feels not to be distracted by the cell phone because I I definitely recognize my

099distraction. I know what it was like beforehand. I know that before us. Okay. Uh this was another question pulled from our survey which is asking students what kind of cell phone policy they would prefer and overwhelmingly uh they supported phones allowed only during breaks and lunch. Our second one was phones allowed during academic purposes um in class. And our third largest category was unrestricted access um at students discretion. And we have to recognize as well here that they're telling us, especially for the red and the yellow, they're telling us that they are aware that restrictions should apply to them. And so when we move forward with uh these decisions about cell phone policy, uh when we're making those decisions, we need to consider that we have some buy in from majority of our students because

100what this is showing us is that they agree that restrictions should apply. And so when we start moving forward, we need to make sure that we're not overstepping and we're not abusing the power of buyin that we already have from our students um as we move forward. And to summarize all of our student input, we pulled from focus groups uh from the two high schools, Mission Hills and San Marcos High School. A group of students was gathered and asked overall about cell phones in school. And what came out of that was first that they recognized the dual impact of cell phone use in school. One second. Oh yeah, they recognize that there's a dual impact of cell phone use in school and that it can be used in a correct manner. It can also be

101used irresponsibly which students came with that. So um second of all that they believe that a policy should be progressive in the way it's disciplining students. Third, it consider they students really wanted us to consider emergency situations and safety as a high priority when we're making decisions about uh cell phone uh proper use. And then these Oh, sorry. Hold on. Before I reveal it, these next two points are something that really really stuck with students and I want uh us to spend a little more time reading these. And the first one is engaging teaching practices. And I'll speak to that. Um, students recognize that when they are engaged in classrooms, they are less likely to use their cell phones or pick up their cell phones. So, what this is telling us is that students don't

102want to be on their cell phones. Students want to be engaged in learning. And so when we're approaching this cell phone policy, we need to make sure is it our students who are wanting and choosing this choice that we perceive as negative or is it that we're not offering another option for them to be engaged in learning in the classroom. And lastly, what came out of this focus group was equitable policy and flexible um flexible policies because students voiced their concern about policies that are going to be made for them versus with them. They want to be a part of that policy making solution and so that we need to recogn I did not know that did not end. Sorry. And so, uh, they really recognize the importance of like being part of that process

103of building this policy together and not the policy not just being made for them, but with them. Yeah. I think that student do you think that students understand that by being by by participating in the survey and participating in the focus group that that is them being involved in the policy? Yes. But from experience we also need to consider that uh we're actually taking this data and using it when we're creating policy versus so because the I think what students were kind of getting at here which which I really understood was that a lot of the times we're hearing and we're we're actively hearing, right? We're hearing student voice, but we're not listening. We're not implementing what they're telling us to do. And so I think that's the the difference between participating in a survey,

104which is hearing them, and actually implementing what they say, which is listening to them. That's kind of what And we have two board members, too. I was going to say we have two student representatives. Do you guys want to add your two cents to this topic? Um, I just want to start off by saying um again um Miss Campbell and Cuba's presentation, I think it really hit a lot of points that um I personally really agree with because I definitely think I agree with what you were saying too. I think it's hard for students to realize like we're distracted by our phones because we don't really know life outside of like using our phones and like it's kind of just how we grew up. Um, but from my perspective, I really agree with what Key

105was saying with making a policy that's with our students and not for our students because, um, I understand what you were saying with like taking surveys. Um, students may perceive it as they're involved in a policy, but I think speaking from experience as a student, we take surveys all the time. We take surveys for so many different things and we don't really look at it like look at it as like a, oh, I'm being involved in this thing. I think it's just like another like survey, yet another survey that we have to take like every single year kind of not in the same way as I Ready, but it's just like it's an annual thing. We know we have to do it. So, um I really think focusing on student perspective, especially since it's something

106that directly affects our students and our staff as well. So, I think making sure that that's like our main focus when creating the policy is that it's something that both our staff and students and parents and just our community agrees with. I would definitely have to agree with Trinity on this. Um I think it's very very important to consider the emergency considerations when creating the policy for emergency situations. Um and yeah, I think that's very very important and making sure that the students are okay with the policy and not that it's being forced since it's going to be very very sudden with one week without it. So yeah, having them involved with especially with this focus group is very very important and maybe involving them a little bit more on it and hearing maybe some

107of their feedback in a little bit which we plan to talk about in the advisory council. So yeah, that's what I have for now. Any comments? Yeah, just I I appreciate that the students were willing to contribute um information. I think that's important because like you said, we don't want it to be where we're kind of dictating to them. We want them to be involved with the process. But with that, I think it's also important to recognize number one, there's a huge difference between the middle school and the high school. Um, but do the students that are participating in this understand the negative effects from the cell phones or are they just seeing I don't want that taken away from me. I'm used to having it. um because those are two different things and that's

108where we're it's nice to collect the information how they're how how they view the cell phone and how they kind of want to engage with it at school but it's also important for us to look at data from outside to say we're seeing nationally what this is doing to our society um and there's something that we have to do about it so I was going to add kind of um you know similar to what um Lena was saying so the questions that we asked the students spec specifically around you know does it impact your academics right or are you distracted in the classroom one of the points that I always get back to is when we did the wellness survey with our students right and a lot of our I mean over 60% of our

109students felt that they didn't belong at school or they didn't feel connected and so for me that was all about the social um emotional type of aspect and the experience of school um school is hard middle school's tough social life you know is is tough it's it's you I get it. Been there, done that. Blocked from my memory. Um, but it's stuff like that that I also wonder about, right? Do they do they see they socialize on their phones? I understand that. But are you having the students that are left out because they don't have someone to socialize with in person, right? And because we are all so comfortable being behind the screen, adults included, right? That we don't put ourselves out there to make friends. we don't see the pain or happiness in someone's

110eyes and kind of connect with them at different levels. So that's what I'm also wondering. Have we overlaid, you know, the percentage or the number of students that have may have come back with saying, you know, not feeling connected and not feeling, you know, not having that social emotional balance at school versus just academics because it's not just academics, right? Um, and I I don't expect the answer. I'm just saying, you know, when we come back, maybe having that information overlaid with it. So I I Well, were you gonna Did you Okay. You were just Okay. Um No, my So I I I think again I'm kind of I'm stuck a little bit on this um idea of student participation and students saying we want like you know we want to be included, right? And

111I totally get that. Like one of my favorite it's a South African, you know, saying like nothing about us without us is for us, right? And I we like in activism we use that all the time. I totally understand that. And then only a third of high schoolers actually responded when we're trying to say, "Hey, what does this mean to you? How does this affect you? What do you think?" Right? So 1,200 1,200 high schoolers actually participated and said, "Here's what we think. Here are our voices. We want you to know so that when you make this policy, you're doing it with what we want in mind." Right? And so it's so much harder to make a policy where only 1,200 high, you know, for for for with the students in mind when you know

112when they're not saying when they're not really participating in that, right? So I can really just go off of what what the people who responded what they're saying and hope that that is representative of the broader group, right? Because that's really all I'm left with. this is the data that I have when we when we are trying to get that and I'm hoping that this is something that you guys can bring back to your sites and say look like when we're asking you these are like these are important things when we're asking you like we're trying to get the input so that we can make decisions that absolutely affect you and it's really important that you tell us what you think because we'll listen to you want to listen to you but if if people

113don't tell us then we're left with you know we're left with what we have um and I think that that's something that is really important for the I mean this isn't just you guys by the way right if you look at how many adults responded it was way less okay so like the community [laughter] I mean when you look at any board meeting that we ever sit in and you guys are new right but there's like five people and most of them are paid to be here right and so like it's it's it's a thing about you know participating in general right and and then people come back and they're like well wait a minute and it's like well you know to get the input um and so I just think that that's something that

114frustrates me when I look at the data because I'm always looking at well who who responded and what does this really mean when I'm looking at like how do I how do I weigh and value this data um I have to I have to I have to consider it because that's all I have but also you know we don't have a it's it's clear that there's not a ton of participation either and that's that's a little frustrating on my part so all right continue Just to kind of ease us back into this, I think on a on a brighter note, it's not impossible and it has been done. If you look right over to your left, all of you, um, Portugal graduate, it was done designed with with students that last section. Um, and that

115was part of an advisory that was held with maybe about 20 students mass. And so I think um we can't get too caught up on the logistics of like how are we going to get 23,000 students to you know join in on this um because we've done it before and you know we'll do it again. I have a comment about the top right of that slide engaging teaching practices. I think it's worth noting that that is like a chicken and an egg situation. Um, and I think it's worth [snorts] just considering that as Sarah said, school's hard. You know, it's it's not going to see a movie where you're where you're going to be entertained, right? And so I think there's going to be classes and certain subject matters that are just difficult. Um, and

116so you could easily flip that phrase around and say that eliminating cell phones in class could make the teacher more engaging. So, um I think it's just worth noting that not every subject um should be as engaging as the student's expectation is because sometimes it's just not. There's material that we've all learned that I can look back on and say that was boring but I needed to learn it. It was part of my education. Thank you. Thank you. Offer a quick data point because I think the the comments of the board so far are very well taken. Um in terms of just straight up survey statistical validity, TW 20 to 25% re okay 20 about 20 to 25% response rate does give you that sample that that you had mentioned. Yeah. So that's maybe maybe

117we're just a tick above that on this. So I would I would think this is probably unless there was some anomaly and there only a specific section of kids, you know, answered it. But yeah, where's K? KB, you did a great job on your very first forward presentation except that you broke our microphone. So [laughter] Yeah. Yes. Yeah. First time. So, I'm sorry. As long as we've taken a little interlude for our new board members. Keybe uh graduated last year. She was part of my student advisory for three years. Kbe I think the whole time. And and I told her when she graduated that, you know, when she's queen of the world, not to forget us us little people. And and we're very very happy to have her here this evening. And Kay is an

118actual SMUSD employee. um she is uh one of our community liaison working mostly with our students but she has been in our uh she's been in our focus group sessions she's been doing a great job okay um so as we move from the student survey I think one of the takeaways that I would I would like to have in your brain is that we are going to get various perspectives on this issue um our students have perspective um and it is varied perspective even within the student community. So as we move to our staff input um we are going to see a similar piece of varied perspective on this. Okay. So with our staff uh input we received 759 responses. Um can I put uh Dr. Garcia on the spot. About how many employees do

119we have, Dr. Garcia? So, a total of about 3,300 staff. So, 759 responses. Um, people were pretty engaged. I've given you a little bit of a breakdown on where we um where we had engagement. So, we had um clearly you see the majority or classroom teachers within that Sorry, just wanted to say just for context, uh the 3,300 would include part-time people, would include substitutes. Yeah. So, so the core staffing is probably closer to 2,000 and change. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. Um so you will see that blue area. Um we had our largest number of staff members. Um elementary had about 139 teachers, high school about 163 teachers. um who are participating or engaging in the survey and you can see down the list of the certificated folks. When we say certificated other that could

120be counselors, social workers, um psychologists, etc. Um classified school site, classified school site is that's our um like uh office managers, campus soups. uh classified other could be CNS employees um that are more itinerate and not fully at one site uh site administrators and then we also had district administrators as well. So for the staff input on how often do you notice students using cell phones during instructional time kind of evenly split if you will from never being at 22.3% remembering that we have folks here who are folks who took the survey who are not um at a school site or not in a classroom um to almost always at 14.9%. Um, this is a breakdown of what that looks like as we dig a little deeper into that question. So, with elementary, 52% say

121never, which is not a surprise. Um, our policies at elementary, our elementary kids don't don't have their cell phones out. It's pretty much a bell-to-bell policy as it is. Um, K through eight, we're at 33% saying never. And then the number plummets at middle school and high school which um you would expect. Um almost always we look at the we see the opposite. So in elementary never see kids on. Um at high school 38% of our high school um folks are seeing um students using cell cell phones almost always. So in your opinion what's the most significant issue related to student cell phone use during the school day? Um the bulk of folks said distractions in class. Again, you see a breakdown between elementary, K8, middle school, and high school. 80% of our high school

122respondents um felt that distractions in class was the most significant issue. Um the numbers are a little lower at elementary, K8, and middle school. The second highest um was cyber bullying or inappropriate social interactions. It is notable I think that only 7% of high schools um felt that this was a significant issue whereas our elementary K8 and middle schools um saw this as a much higher uh issue. I will say that this part of this is developmental. It is the maturity of students. Um what do you think should be the primary focus of the school's cell phone policy? Again, um it is going back to that previous data point of uh distractions being the most significant thing that um they were concerned with. Um so primary focus feeling is reduction uh reducing distractions during class

123time. Again, you can see the breakdown high school and middle school both very high um with reducing distractions at um at elementary and K8 levels. There was much more of a um engagement with supporting responsible and and appropriate use of technology. Again, in thinking about um where staff's focus lies and thinking developmentally about where students are. Um our elementary and our K8 thinking about how do we help teach our kids whereas our high schools are kind of expecting some responsibility already um to be to be there and their focus is on teaching content. What would be your preferred cell phone policy for students during instructional time? Overwhelmingly, no phones or electronics allowed in class across the board. Very high numbers. Um, which is our current policy. Devil is in the details of course. Uh, which

124we also will get to. Um, I am actually surprised that we had a couple of people say no restrictions on cell phone on phone use. I'm assuming the elementary person. I don't see it anyway. Um and then also at the other the other is district office folks. Um no restrictions probably because they don't see it but the bulk um landed in only for academic purposes or not allowed in class. Um do you feel that the current cell phone policy is effectively enforced at your school? This falls in line with what we have been hearing in practice. As mentioned, we do have a policy. Um, our elementary schools are um, yes, it's enforced well or somewhat, but there are inconsistencies that are pretty high. Um, at our high school, we see that it is not enforced

125effectively. 40% of our high school folks saying it's not enforced effectively. um somewhat but there are inconsistencies is where the bulk of us lie which is not surprising. So we also did a focus group with our staff. Um we saw some similar things actually that we saw with the students. First this idea of a dual impact of cell phone use. What is very interesting is that while 71% the vast majority um really um are saying that a a no phones in the classroom is important in where they want to go. In our focus groups, there were conversations about um specific use of cell phones and types of classes. If I am the art teacher, if I am the ASB teacher, my students use their cell phones for academic purposes. I have students who use the

126QR code on the cell phone. So, there were there were these conversations that the staff um was grappling with and will continue to grapple with as we move forward um with a cell phone policy. Um consistent implementation and policy enforcement. That was number one across the board. Um very important for our staff. Uh consistency in implementation of the policy. We heard loud and clear that our teachers are very concerned about I'm doing it in period one then in period two their teacher allows them to have it out. I don't want to be the bad guy. I don't want to have the power struggle. So if we're going to implement this policy, it really does have to be a policy that is consistently implemented across the board. And we have to come up with some common

127agreements as a staff in order to make sure that's happening. Um, and then the burden of monitoring cell phone use, possible power struggles, liability issues. So, if I take a cell phone and the phone breaks, am I liable? Um, those types of things they had questions about. And frankly, they don't want to be the phone police and we don't want them to be the phone police because their job is instruction. So, how do we have a policy um where they aren't having to spend enormous amounts of time telling kids, "Put your phone away. put your phone, etc. Um, were our labor groups involved in the focus? Were they part of the focus groups? Um, yes, our union president was in the focus group. Uh, SMA union president was in the focus group and we had

128representatives from SDSA. Okay. In our focus groups. Thank you. Question while we're on it. Is it possible to get a breakdown of just the classroom teachers input? Yes. Okay. Thank you. Okay. Um balance policy suggestions regarding the education of students and families on the responsible use of cell phones in addition to a policy that limits access. So our teachers do understand that cell phones are ubiquitous and it is more than just about in the class. We also have to do some things about teaching responsible use. We actually heard that from our students as well like in the education piece behind um why are we why do we have the policy and what does cell phone addiction look like? You we're addicted to our screens. We're addicted to our screens. Um so what are some better

129ways uh that we can start to implement ways to um deal with our addiction kid and adult? Um discussion of a possible gradual release of responsibility. you saw that our high schools were a little less concerned um with the usage of the cell phones and um were more um they had a more they were more open to flexibility. So perhaps more flexibility given at upper grades uh in high school. And then there were questions regarding teacher discretion for particular courses um which I touched on earlier. And then the logistical difficulty of enforcing a cell phone free policy at the high school level during a passing period or lunch due to the size of student body and campuses. um that came from some of our uh classified staff in particular of if you see hallways at

130San Marcos High School, it's real tough to get into the middle. So, there were some questions about that for sure. Okay. Um before we move into family input, are there any other questions on staff input or discussion on staff input? Yeah, distractions in class. Okay, so our family input, we had about responses. We have a large district. I will tell you that this was a lot of engagement based on um our typical surveys. Uh the surveys went out first via um the district. Thank you Amy for that. Um and then also the principles were individually sent the survey out to their families as well. Um so we tried to get as much input as possible. Um for perspective we usually get between 800 and a thousand for our annual LCAP survey. So this was engagement

131for us. Um you can see the breakdown of uh where responses came from. Elementary had the largest amount of respondents, 949, and we got gradually lower um from six through eight and 9 through 12, which is kind of so um how concerned are you about your child's use of cell phones and electronic devices? So the pie looks kind of evenly split a little bit. Um we had 31.1% who were not concerned. Um you look at the when you look at the breakdown that 31% makes a little bit more sense. 37% from PK5 I am gauging that to be my child doesn't have a cell phone. Thus I'm not real concerned. Uh yeah. Um 9 through12 was 29% and then 6 through8 was 25%. So that 31% makes a bit more sense. Um 28% 28.9% very

132concerned. That's kind of across the board in the 30s. High school a little less at 24%. And then moderately concerned 25 and 26% at our middle and high schools. Um, this is that bar graph. So, as Key mentioned, this is the bar graph that allows you to click more than once. Key has something to say on it, though. That's why she stood up next to me. Um, so because families are able to click more than once, you're going to see a lot of responses. Yeah. So, uh, when we start looking at the breakdown of like the largest categories, we have before school being one of the largest and after school and then following that during lunch and breaks. Um, but I want to draw your attention down to this. Cell phone use should not be

133allowed during the school day, which makes up about 34.9%. Uh, however, I want you to note that this it was a multiplechoice uh, selection. So families were able to select cell phone use should not be allowed as well as during lunch and breaks and before school after school between classes or during classes. So when we actually isolate the variable of which families actually believe school should be or sorry which families believe phone should be allowed or sorry let me start when we actually break down the specifics and isolate the variable of families who believe cell phones should be banned during the school day. It actually shows about 13% of families only agree with a complete cell phone ban during the daycl. This also includes families that responded only before school and after school. Um, so

134it's important to see the data for what it actually is. Um, when we isolate these things, we actually get to see the real numbers and consider that that's like a little bit over 10% of families who actually agree with a cell phone ban. Thank you. And there is we're going to go to the next slide which has a little bit more um detail on that. a little different way we ask the question. Um, what level of cell phone access would you prefer students to have during the day? Um, so this is no access during school hours was at about 26%. Um, limited access meaning only during breaks and lunch was at 37%. Um, unrestricted access very small percentage of almost 6% and then access for emergencies and academic purposes at 31%. We do have a

135breakdown of that. Just the slide was real busy so I put on a separate one for you. So um that breakdown from elementary, middle, and high. So unrestricted access there was not a whole lot of there was not very much engagement with that limited access. You can see both middle and high school. Um this was their highest section. Um breaks and lunch only. And then access for emergencies and academic purposes only 39% for PK5 30% for six and eight uh and then high school at 23%. And then no access during school hours or high school was at 10% middle school was at six uh was at 25% and then um high number at the elementary level. And this unlike the previous question, this was a force to pick one choice. Um, what do you think

136should be the primary focus of the school's cell phone policy? 42% for reducing distractions during class, ensuring safety and communication was at 23% and then supporting responsible and appropriate use of technology was at 35%. So, this looks a little different than what our staff um than what our staff one did. You'll see that our staff survey um had a larger percentage really focused on reducing distractions. About the same percentage, however, for uh supporting responsible and appropriate use of technology. This is the breakdown of where um it where that question was answered according to grade level. So 44% um reducing distractions during class across the board. Ensuring safety and communication um was higher at the elementary levels and then supporting responsible and appropriate use of technology um equal numbers in middle school and high school, a

137little lower in elementary. Do you think there should be restrictions on other electronic devices? It's about 5050. We see here um yes, they should be restricted like cell phones 50%. And no, they should not or restrictions should vary almost 50%. Um and you can see where that breakdown is in elementary, middle, and high school. If your child needs to use their cell phone for personal or family emergencies, do you believe the school's policy policy should allow flexibility for these situations? 71% um say yes, there should be flexibility. Um here's the sticky widget. The definition of emergency certainly varies among um our students, our staff, and our families. Um that is where uh we get into we really get into the question because an emergency may be I forgot my lunchtime and I need you to

138come and bring my lunch and emergency could be I need to pick you up later at school or emergency could be oh my gosh the house is on fire. So there is a broad broad range of what our families um are considering emergency. So we did a focus group as well um with our families. Um I put this little note that it was very interesting. Uh this is this was not a random focus group. It was a focus group that picked out um we wanted to get input from a wide variety. So those who were much more on this end of very very restrictive also to not restrictive and everything in between. So the group did grapple with balancing the benefits of technology um for education and communication and emergency situations with what is the

139obvious negative effects with socialization and classroom management. How many people were in the focus group, Christy? 20ish. 20ish. About 20ish. and like breakdown of parents like in elementary versus secondary. Okay, thanks. Separate. Um, this group was actually the only group um that really talked a lot about socialization and addiction. Um, and I think part of it is because you see your kids at home as well as in the classroom. So this is this was very important. Um cell phone use is hindering students ability to socialize and interact with each other both in and out of the classroom. It came up across the board really in the focus group. Um there was a desire for more integration of digital citizenship and responsible cell phone use in the curriculum. So this idea of responsible use and helping

140students um learn to use technology more responsibly. And then there was a discussion of school versus parent responsibility in the child's uh use of cell phones. Um how much is my responsibility? How much is the school's responsibility? We did have folks who said I tell my I tell my daughter do not have your cell phone on. I check what app she's on. Um and we also had folks who said it's real hard and we need help from the school sites and how are we partnering together? um classroom management across the board was um reports of distractions in class. Uh our students don't think they're distracted. Um they go home and report things and it's obvious they're distracted. As one who has a child in the district, they are distracted in the they are distracted in

141the classroom. Um, and it is all types of students are distracted. I have a straight A student and I get text at various times and I think isn't it what aren't you in class right now? Um, so it is across the it is across the board. Sorry honey for outing you safety and emergency situations. Um, I talked about this on the previous slide. So um also different than what was talked about in both the focus groups both our uh student and our staff so uh focus groups there were clearer concerns about inappropriate use of cell phones um and privacy um recording of fights taking and spreading unauthorized pictures um more so at the middle school level um this idea of kids are not using their phones responsibly possibly and we have to give some we

142have to put some restrictions on that and that's the non-instructional time piece that we are seeing the desire to be able to contact their children during emergencies very varied and I just point out I was in a lockdown at one point in in my district and I remember sitting next to a student that we went into a closed office and the student right away was on social media I I turned to him. I said, "Do you realize you're geotagging yourself in a situation where we did have a lockdown due to a active shooter, you know, in the in near us?" But he kind of had that aha moment. And his mom right away said, "Turn that off. Get off your phone." Yes. I will say when there is a lockdown situation though, as a parent,

143I'm I'm on my phone. I'm like, "Are you safe?" You know, I I I that is on the on the opposite end, you know, you will walk through fire, you know, to find out if your kiddo is okay. So, but that's an emergency situation and god forbid that happens here. But we heard that same thing. Both sides. Yeah. Both sides. Yes. Yeah. Um balance and logistics questions that came about um teachers and staff need support in supporting a uniform policy that came from our community, that came from the focus groups. High schools may be too big to enforce restrictions. Kind of the same thing we heard in our staff group. And um we had families uh we had parents who were in who had students who had IEPs, students who had 504s who use their

144phones. So questions about um how do we continue to support students who may need their phones. So, a summary of lots of stuff that we talked about and we have agreements across the board with all of our groups. Excessive screen time and cell phone addiction universally acknowledged. Even in talking to our students, our students did agree that there are there are some students that are addicted to their stuff. Yeah. Them. He is totally that one. Yeah. Yeah. Not those guys. Um they there is agreement that some students are using and distracted by their cell phones in some classes. Um and some students are using cell phones inappropriately outside of the classroom. We have agreement there. Uh students and parents need education on digital citizenship and responsible use of cell phones or smartphones. The final policy

145needs to be universally universally and consistently enforced to limit power struggles in class. Um I should have bolded this one because this was really really really big. Um this idea of consistent enforcement. Yeah. Mainly because we have a cell phone policy but it is not consistently enforced. Um and then collaboration between the adults will be needed to achieve successful implementation with students. um that we adults have to be on the same page uh if we are going to get real traction in what's happening. Particularly our schools, our teachers need to be on the same page. Um and our adults need to need to understand that this is an issue that is going to take all of our efforts in order to um move the needle. And we have to model the behavior that we want

146to see among our students. Um and then there are different needs. Parental attitudes and involvement vary. Some were some advocating for strict control, others prioritizing accessibility, definition of emergency, which I've talked about. Staff opinions vary on the level of restriction within the classroom. Some are absolutely using it for instructional purposes. Um there is use during independent work. Oh, sure. You can have your your headphones on while you are working independently, that's fine. Or when your work is complete, yeah, if you want to take out your phone, you can do that. Um, and it varied across the board of some being very comfortable with it, others saying absolutely not. Um, and then the idea of grade level differences, student development, how they are using the phones, campus logistics between elementary, middle, and high school. Um, there

147are certainly some differing needs there. Okay. So restricting access uh other considerations um the board did ask us to do some research on yonder pouches. Um there also um we have a lot of classrooms that have the wall pockets as well. So we want to give you a little information on that. I always I I got all the hard slides. So you're gonna all the interesting ones keep all the interesting ones questions. Okay. So um daughter poucher there's something that are very popular right now. LA Unified um right they have all yonder pouches and and all the pouches that you can have. So when we think about uh the breakdown of logistics between our populations on middle school or first of all our populations from elementary to middle school and high school it increasingly gets

148uh larger. So when we look at the actual logistics of the time it will take to lock all all of the students pouches over over 3,000 for our high schools. Um, we also know the amount of time that our teachers have during class. Five minutes uh at the end of the at the end of the period, I don't think is enough for 30 to 40 students to get their phones unlocked. Um but apart from that there's also different accessibility on campus and where we place uh certain magnets because the yonder pouches are unlocked by yonder magnets that are bought through the company as well. And so when we think about where where are we placing these magnets, how many magnets are we getting and where are they going? Uh we really start to see like

149this is more complex than just purchasing a bunch of magnets and a bunch of pouches. Um but then then to break down the cost for about for to get a yonder pouch for every single student in our district, we're looking at about half a million uh dollars uh just for the pouches alone. That doesn't include the magnets, which cost I think uh I didn't search that up, but I did see a range from $60 to 120 for the yonder magnets. Um, and then we also think about are we considering to buy a magnet for every classroom in case of emergency situations or are we buying a a limited amount of magnets per school site? And because we pride ourselves um in how creative and critically our students think, we also have to consider um their

150ingenuity. And it did not take me very long. It actually only took me the word yonder to come up in YouTube to find videos on how to open them. 10 videos actually. The first 10 videos that came up were how to open these magnets. It varied from sticking a pencil in it to paper clips to putting your like just banging on the table. And so I think um considering the ingenuity of our students, I think this is not looking like a situation where uh the pouches will stay locked. And I also want you to consider that um apart from buying the Yonder magnets from the company Yonder uh because it has the fancy little logo on it. Um it didn't take me very long to find a $10 magnet on Amazon that could open the

151pouch just because I was watching these videos and they were like, "Oh, here's the link to the magnet." overnight shipping for this like fishing magnet that opens it. Um, and they actually showed it. So, uh, we have to consider how stu uh when we start to uh think about these things, we need to consider how creative our students are and how desperate they are to unlock those pouches. Can I can I add that uh I went home and I told my son that we were considering a policy and he said the minute you approve a policy is the second that we will start figuring out how to break it. So my freaking own son ingenuity my own son. I know I'm like red in the face but I'm just admitting that [laughter] you outed yours

152too. I totally outed my son. I don't feel so bad now. and and then um like Dr. Campbell mentioned uh classroom wall pockets which are happening uh you'll see them around certain classrooms on certain campuses. Um but when we're considering policies especially uh equitable policies we start to think of what what is actually behind all of these policies. And I think that one of the things that comes up often too is when we are displaying like so so let me explain it a little bit. the pocket the classroom wall pockets essentially it's like a bunch of different pockets numbered 1 through 40 and students are assigned a number and told to place their phones in the pockets and usually typically that is in front of the classroom behind the teacher's desk um near some sort

153of like alarm or whatnot. Um but when we think about like what actually is going on when students are putting their phones in the wall pockets, we start to some inequities because a lot of the times this is a display of who can afford a phone, who doesn't have a phone, and just kind of outs the student, especially concerning our students with uh health health and medical reasons as to why they need to keep their phone on them. It just kind of outs our students. So, when we're thinking about an equitable approach, we have to consider that not all of our students have cell phones to be put on display in front of their classrooms. And they're also very creative. They will swap out and put a a decoy phone or a calculator, which I'm

154sure you've heard of. And overall, we we trace it back to that piece of teachers don't want to be in charge or responsible for a lost cell phone because often teachers are turned to the board. And you know, it's just like situations where they don't want to be constantly monitoring cell phones. And then we break down the cost and it's about 15 to 20 per classroom. And then again going back to that how many uh how many students have the phone and how creative are they? So yeah, student ingenuity. Okay. Um so that's just kind of we did some research. The wall pockets are being used some successfully, some a little less so. Um but it is something that we want to consider as we think about what are the things that we are saying

155are absolutes as we put the policy in place. Okay, that was a lot of input. So based on that input um we are looking to create a balanced approach um to our BP. So, our current BP language, students may use cell phones, smartwatches, pagers, pagers, or other mobile communication devices on campus during non-instructional time as long as the device is utilized in accordance with law and any rules that individual school sites may impose. Um, devil is in the details. The policy is a policy and enforcement is another thing. Um, I do want to point out that there is ed code surrounding mobile communication devices that we must be in consideration of. So, um, a student shall not be prohibited from possessing or using a mobile communication device under the following circumstances. In case of emergency,

156when a teacher administrator grants permission, when a licensed physician or surgeon determines that there is a need, or when the possession or use is required by the IEP. So, that is something that must be considered. Um it is ed code regulation. So here is what our recommended revisions are. Elementary and middle school and away for the day policy. Um students must have all mobile communication devices including but not limited to smartphones, smartwatches, headphones, earbuds. did take pagers off, but it's all communication devices uh turned off and kept out of sight during the school day both in and out of the classroom. So, this is from when school begins to when school ends. Um the phones are to be away at the high school distractionfree learning environment. So again, all mobile communication devices including smartphones, smartwatches,

157headphones, and earbuds turned off and kept out of sight during instructional time. And we are defining instructional time as bellto bell for the class period. This is a big shift for our high schools. It's a big shift um any other time during the day when schools are expected to be engaged in a learning activity. Um, at our high schools, they may use their devices before school, during lunch or break, or after school. As long as they are utilized in accordance with the law, they they need to behave. Um, we are also recommending an additional um administrative regulation, which we do not have um in order to help with consistent implementation of uh the policy. So, a progressive discipline policy for non-compliance that will begin with a verbal warning um and include confiscation and return to

158student where the parent is notified, confiscation and a parent guardian pickup and then a behavior agreement and ongoing monitoring. Um it is important that staff is monitoring behaviors, making available social emotional making available social emotional and mental health supports um where students are having difficulty. And we're going to talk a little bit more about that in a slide that's coming up. So, there are a couple of exceptions that must be included based on our ED code. When a district device is unable to be used, please note when a district device is unable to be used, students may use their mobile communication device for documented medical reasons as part of the IEP or section 504 plan and during school emergencies or at the direction of school staff. Um our goal is that um we are going

159to get a lot of communication um and gather data on what is happening in order for us to make some make some um informed decisions as we continue this imple as we implement uh this policy. So we are asking our school sites first off to communicate the policy but then gather data um to ensure how the implementation is going and compliance. So we want to have that documented in synergy or some other um place so that by the end of the year we can see how many phones are getting confiscated, how many kids are being talked to, is it really is it really big at the beginning and then it tapers off. So, we want to gather that data um so that we can see um how it's going. Tiffany, really quick question. You say

160that there's an exception during school emergencies. Understood. Or at the direction of the school staff. Does does is is that the loophole that we're looking for? It is a loophole that is in ed that is in that ed code regulation. So, has to be put in. Okay. However, That does not mean, well, I said they could take it out, they can take it. Yeah. If I'm the art teacher, I've told the students they could take it out. Or if I'm the ASB teacher and I'm directing the students to go and upload your photos on your phone, then then they're doing that and and I've I've directed them or given them permission to do it. We have had um we've had some long long conversations with our principles about um how does this look in practice

161and There must be staff commitments to this process. They have to have it. Our ed code specifically states when a teacher administrator grants permission to the student. It is what the it is what the ed code regulation says. Um this has been vetted by the attorney and the attorney said you need to make sure that you put that in there. Yeah. Know I get it. I just don't see how this is different from our current. I think what's I I will say I think what's different is that there are there must be we're going to do it there there have to be commitments and I will say we've had this policy on the books for since 2019. This is the first time that we are having a real discussion about how we are doing it.

162We are coming to agreement with enforcement and policy. Yeah. I think the different I I hear your concern. I I think the difference is I agree with Dr. Campbell. is this is a um very much now on the on the radar so to speak. I think this is now going to be directives for all of our principles to have these conversations with their staff and to come up with the the actual on the ground agreements what these things mean which we haven't had we haven't done it's been very loose and then co in the middle of it you know what co did to everything um so I think this is this is the time when we can have these conversations and as a former site administer I would say I think that is that's where

163the power comes we're all sitting in a room looking at each other eyeball to eyeball and and agreeing to what we're all going to do so that's where the power comes I have a question so we we We we had a conversation about, you know, math teachers using the phones as for a scientific calculator. I remember as a student having a very hard time paying for that $400 scientific calculator that my family couldn't afford at the time. So these things are very very important. But so in that situation, we can provide. Yes, we can provide. I that's a perfect example. In our conversations with our high school principles, we asked that specific thing. What about the students who are using the scientific calculator on their on their phones? Um, Mr. Baker, Mr. Baker, thank you.

164Um, said specifically, we have scientific calculators that students can check out and if we need to buy more of them, we'll buy more scientific calculators. I'm thinking of other alternatives, too, like you mentioned the art teacher and music, and I know everyone has a Spotify list, but at some point, you know, I mean, you guys are going to laugh, but could it be like nifty to provide everyone like a Walkman? You know what I mean? Oh my gosh. Oh, I just sort of revision policy. Sarah armband that's gonna that's gonna sweeten the pot. And you know also what I'd like to staff would like to respectfully sorry I was just saying it's staff would like to respectfully require that we also add um groovy eight tracks in there. I think that'll be really awesome for

165the kids. I will I will comment just on a more serious note. I think this is like anything. It's like ripping a band-aid off. Yeah. Yeah. For up like I have a fourth grade daughter. When she reaches middle school, she doesn't know anything different. Do you know what I mean? So like with each class that promotes into the next site, it'll be so much easier. I think it's just the kids that are in it right now. Yeah. That are It's going to be really painful for them and the staff. But in a couple years it's not right. There will be pain for sure. But to your point it will get it will get progressively used. I do I mean it's interesting because we we have this policy. We've had this policy for a long time

166and elementary school does not have it. And so you would think that it would be really easy when when they get into middle school then they they're just not used to it and but they do. they like all of a sudden it's like oh I and you know I'm I'm older now and I get to do this thing and they know it's there and they know like I'm older now and so this is something that I can do and I'm going to do it and don't don't you know like I have a high schooler and I'm not going to out her other than to say that we have had some very passionate conversations [laughter] about the cell phone policy and what it really means to students you know in in various situ you know scenarios

167situations and I think that it's going to be difficult for a while um to you know but I just I I guess my thing is is that the policy is a policy I don't see much difference in the policy than you know than what we've already had and so really it's just now fidelity to the policy essentially um and it's not our kids it's the staff who are not implementing the policy to fidelity, right? And so what are we going to do to train and empower our staff because this policy isn't different? And and so like I just Yeah, I just don't understand like I um I will say that the policy is not super different at elementary school. It feels it will feel different at middle school, but middle school has already started kind

168of dipping their toe in. Um it may seem on paper that it is not vastly different at high school. It is vastly different for high school. It is vastly different. Um when you can have your earbuds in and any various time um it's going to be different when your teacher says take your take your earbuds out. Um it will be vastly different when teachers are not saying pull your cell phone out and use the QR code. This is going to be um it's going to be a heavy lift for our principles and our administrators to help get our staff on board. Um our staff absolutely wants distractionfree learning environments. Um what that means across the board is going to be a very difficult it's going to be a heavy lift for our staff. So because

169there are things that they do that you don't even think about oh yeah I can't do that. I I should not do that if I have agreed that cell phones will not be out. I just have a plea to the parents out there. I mean, there's very few out there listening right now, but my please, that consistency and implementation. I have a seven-year-old and he's saving up money for a Nintendo Switch. Took him to the store the other day and I go, "You do realize that you buy that equipment, all that that case that has all those little boxes in there, that's $50 now out of your pocket that you have to pay for." He goes, "Oh." So parents please please please well and and another thought we don't know how this will influence famil

170family's behaviors because right now fifth graders as their graduation gift many get their phone at their fifth grade promotion and parents feel a certain sense of pressure. Oh well Johnny got a phone for his fifth grade promotion so now I got to give my kid a phone. And so by middle school making that a way for the day, I think that'll be liberating for parents and it'll be interesting to see if purchasing of cell phones like drops for middle school students. I think it might. It'll be interesting to see. Yeah, I would say I see one of the observations I see is that the commitment to us as a district or staff to not use our phones for educational purposes. You know what I mean? That I think is going to be a big one.

171Mhm. Um, I personally, for example, had a little bit of an opposite problem. I had my phone for work. Every time I picked up my phone to call my mom, check social media, I'd start working because it was on my phone. It was that easy. And I got I got addicted to work. Um, so anyways, that being said, I had to split my phones. You mean you know what I mean? So that being said, if you're not using our phones, if you split use the use of technology for educational purposes, I think you'll find some relief just in doing that. And I think that's a good good thing that we're doing there. Um, my only concern is just as a parent, um, I think Stacy, you mentioned that as our kids get phones, you know,

172we go through the struggle and the pain to teach them how to use it correctly, to respect the responsibility that they have. And a lot of those conversations happen because they did something and then you got to come back and you got to teach them, right? Right? I mean, mistakes are made even from by parents and so so on and so forth. So, not that it's a really big concern, but one big concern is that if we take it away, elementary and middle, come to high school, it's it's going to be a parenting thing, right? It is a parenting thing. It's a parenting thing because now all of a sudden they will have it, right? But you haven't gone through that like it's pain of learning how to use it. in school you you aren't

173getting in trouble of having a phone in school. If they are if they have the phone the phone outside of school there is definitely a parenting piece. And we have talked about also the need for parent education, not just with here's what the policy is, but let's talk about cell phone addiction and how do you help your student, your child um really use the cell phone effectively, effectively, responsibly is a better is a better word. Um and as adults, how would we model that better for our children? That's hard. Um, we had that conversation of the modeling piece where if we are telling our students, do not have the cell phone out in class, we've got to model that behavior ourselves, teachers, we have to model it as well. Our student board members. Okay. Um,

174I have a couple points, but I'm just going to call myself out here. I'm addicted to my phone. [laughter] I'm sure Trinity can say somewhat the same. Um, but I think it's really really important to set up students to be future ready, especially with the portrait of graduate and stuff. So like teaching students how to use their phone correctly. Like for me personally, I have like time limit apps that I set up for myself, but do they necessarily work? No. Also the password to Yeah, I bypass all the [laughter] time. But yeah, I think it's really really important and taking it away like sometimes like I don't know if my mom takes away like something I'm going to want it more, you know? So, I think just like having students be able to say like

175I don't need to be on my phone at this point in class, which is good. And I think um if you guys want to introduce the yonder pouches, put maybe introducing them first for those students who constantly like are having their phones being taken away or they're constant like the teacher's constantly telling them to take their like to put their phone away. So you can like I think there's a slide that says um like warning and then um parent pickup that I think that could be a consequence there because honestly for me I don't know if this is bad to say but getting those Yoner pouches it seems like a consequence for those students who are on their phones or not on their phones. Sorry. Yeah. But yeah, I also have a question. Um, what

176do you plan to do for students who have Apple computers or personal computers? Because it would not be really fair if you had those Yonder pouches or something where you have to put up your phone in the pocket every day, but then a student can just access all the same things with an Apple computer. Wait, are they allowed their own devices on campus? Yeah, this is my computer for school. Oh, see, I just told someone they're not allowed that. Engineering. Okay. I don't have the answer. We don't have the answer. I mean I mean all of our students have Chromebooks that they can that they can access a lot of this on and then they have their their personal computer and everything and our firewall is student ridiculous. Don't even get me going on that.

177But so I I think at this point I think that you know policywise you know we're there to me this is really more of a matter of implementation and we just have to you know I think we just have to say okay well let's you know this is what we're going to do we're going to roll it out in January and let's see how it goes and then we'll we'll revisit it at the end of the year and see what happened and and adjust um as we need to because I I mean I don't really see what else needs Yeah. truly. I mean, I think it's having the it's having the buy in, right? It's not I mean, Heidi mentioned ripping off the band-aid, which ideally, yes, as long as we're implementing the policy, then

178moving forward, it gets easier and easier. If you don't implement it, then it's going to be the same thing next year when we're here again, right? So, um, kind of getting the buyin from parents and students and staff to make sure that everybody's on the same page and understands the why behind this and that it's not just because we're being mean and we want to limit how much you can text, you know, it's it's so that you can promote social engagement, you can avoid distraction. So, that that is kind of the the messaging. Um, and then I I also think it might be a good idea to think about doing something positive on campus. Um, for administrators to think about what we can do for these students that are going to be missing their phones,

179right? So, the middle schoolers, I mean, my son's a middle school and at lunch he said there's either the boys that play sports or the boys that are in their phones. Like, that's what it is. And so if we want to move away from that, like what can we do so that they're able to engage with friends and learn how to like talk like ice breakers, I don't know, but something. Um, so that type of thing. Um, and just remembering that like addicts lie, right? So like most most kids that are addicted are going to go home and be like, "No, I wasn't on my phone. I didn't do it." It's like it's just a thing. So they're like, "No, I didn't do it." So I think that that's something we just need to be

180conscious of. I'm gonna have um Miss Green speak to a little of that. Thank you for the really nice segue. Um we know that for a lot of our for our kiddos because they've been raised with nothing else but screens. And you know, unlike us who were in a world before screens were there, this will be a very big shift. And so for some of them, this is their mode of socialization. They don't feel comfortable talking to their peers. To your point, they don't know how to start that conversation. Yeah. So, a lot of the things on this screen um currently happen on our school sites with our counselor, social workers, school psychologists, and other support staff, but we want to be a lot more deliberate with this knowing that we're going to have students

181that have a bit of a withdrawal if we're thinking about addiction. Um I know that, you know, when I was researching different things along with LA USD did a lot of research into what what needs to happen with that withdrawal. Um so, we focus on connectment and belonging anyway here in San Marcos Unified. And so, just kind of takes that up another level. So, looking at things like our counselors and social workers are always available to support students who are experiencing anxiety, depression, social struggles. We do a lot of individual check-ins um and we do some groups and so really focusing on that group uh work so that not only are they working on those concerns, but they're doing it in a group setting so that they're learning those social skills at the same time.

182Um teacher and teachers and staff do receive training um within our LCAP on trauma-informed care and practices. So they are learning how to identify students who may be at risk or may be withdrawing so that they can refer them to the appropriate resources um and have those conversations with them as well or find other ways to connect and engage with them. We have lunch bunches that happen throughout the district. That's typically at elementary and in the middle school for students that struggle with with making friends already or with social socialization. We have our social workers that run those groups. We have social work interns counselors and a lot of times teachers come in and volunteer as well. And those are just fun places for them to learn how to engage. So it's not so much

183counseling. It's more playing games and to your point, ice breakers and activities to really get them to start to break down some of those walls of social anxiety. Um and then students being encouraged to join more clubs or team- based events um that create positive social experiences outside of the classroom. Uh I know that at a lot of our middle schools we have sports happening um at lunchtime to your point. Either they're playing sports or they're on their phones. So trying to find other ways to draw students into those lunchtime activities so they aren't feeling kind of lost with what do I do if I can't go scroll my Instagram or I'm sorry I'm old Snapchat, Tik Tok. Um I might have Facebook. Okay. And then just regular check-ins with students experiencing that difficulty because

184we are going to have students that are in that tier three level of really needing intensive support because this is the only thing that makes them feel safe when they're at school. Our comprehensive high schools are large and so for some of our kiddos that don't feel like they quite fit, that phone sometimes can feel like a lifeline to them. So really focusing on those kiddos and making sure they have those trusted adults and we have plans in place for them so that we can connect them and have them have other places. Maybe they aren't ready for a lunch bunch, but they need to know that at Mission Hills we have a Zenen and that's a place they can go and they can regulate and they can feel like they're not so overwhelmed with everything

185going on around them. So all of these things, like I said, take place, but we really want to make sure we enhance enhance these services for students is through this roll out because we know that there's going to be an impact. Thank you. Okay. Um so, uh we actually would like to we're thinking about in December now, um beginning preliminary communication to our staff and families, um that pending board approval that um an updated cell phone policy is going to be implemented in January 2025, as in when you come back. Here we go. Um in January, our school sites prepping our campuses with their staff, students, and families. I will say that um at our high schools, they've already started to give this information to their staff um because they know it's coming. Um and

186then a final reading and approval of the revised policy on uh our January 16th meeting and then implementation of the policy beginning January 20th um which Dr. Johnson did preview at the beginning of the meeting. So thank you for Sunday um in June coming back to the board in May June to review our the implement the implementation data um that we've received from our site administrators report those to the board and then determine if what the updates are needed because I think we're going to learn a lot in this second half of the school year on what this you were saying when are we going to come back and review our not the end of the year but you're thinking March time frame once we implement just like to get June. Oh, June. Did I

187miss it? Oh, I thought it was March. No, Mar. I think March will be a little quick. I think we're going to need a little bit of time. Yeah, I we'll we'll see how it goes. If it this June is kind of what we're thinking now. If we want to bring it in May, we'll we'll see if we have stuff. Yeah. Before we move off this item, Madam President, I just want to make sure. So, this is the first read of the policy. I think I'm hearing consensus from the board just so that we so staff knows what we're bringing back in January. I think we're bringing back the policy as it was presented this evening in January and you will take action on it as as it was presented this evening. Okay. Yeah. Got

188to start somewhere. All right. Item 14, closing items. 14.1 organizational matters. The next board regular board meeting will take place on Thursday, January 16th, 2025 at 6:30 p.m. in the media center of the North County Regional Educational Center, 255 Pico Avenue, San Marcos, California, 92069. Um 14.2 adjournment. This meeting is adjourned. I do this. All right. Happy New Year everyone. Merry Christmas. Poor microphones. Ke look my blew off. Did you do AP statistics? Because you did fabulous. I did that. That's how I knew how to isolate everything. Yeah.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.