001e e for e good ready okay I would like to call this meeting to order today's date is Thursday December 19th 2024 this is the annual organizational meeting of the governing board of San Marcos Unified School District please let the records reflect that all board members are present um item two oath of office superintendent Johnson will now administer the ceremonial oath of office to board members Heidi herck lenina Mia and Sarah M first I will come up first oh can I add that um when we come up if the family members want to come up and take a picture or stand with us you guys are more than welcome thank you so pursuant to the California Constitution Article article 20 Section 3 and government code 1360 prior to entering upon the duties of their office
002all Board of Trustees members shall take the oath or affirmation required by law so at this time is my pleasure to swear you in to the board so I'll ask you to raise your right hand and repeat after me I Sarah mod do Solly swear that I will support and defend the constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California against all enemies foreign and domestic that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California that I take this obligation freely without ental sorry without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion and that I will well and Faithfully discharge the duties upon which I am about to enter congratulations rock paper scissors however you like to do it
003they are oh the whole crowd okay thank you I'll ask you to raise your right hand and repeat after me I lenina mume do solemnly swear that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California against all enemies foreign and domestic that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California that I take this obligation freely without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion and that I will well and Faithfully discharge the duties upon which I'm about to enter congratulations welcome and here comes family all right welcome big moment for your mom it's my pleasure to swear you in as well so I'll ask you to raise your right hand and repeat
004after me I Heidi herck do solemnly swear that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California against all enemies foreign and domestic that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California that I take this obligation freely without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion and that I will well and Faithfully discharge the duties upon which I'm about to entv congratulations and welcome all right item three communication session for closed session items tonight's Clos session agenda includes the following items for discussion one conference with labor negotiator Dr Joel Garcia two matters pertaining to Public Employee employment transfer appointment discipline dismissal release evaluation reassignment if you wish to address the board you
005may fill out a request form no yeah request form at the AL Cove to the left of the double doors as you enter the boardroom please complete a white speaker form if you wish to speak about it uh if it's on the agenda and a blue speaker form if the item you wish to speak about is not on the agenda please give it to Susie in accordance with board bylaw 9323 public comments will be limited to 20 minutes per topic each speaker will be allowed a maximum of 3 minutes to speak except for our Union Representatives who have five minutes for the brown act members of the board are very Limited in their ability to respond to statements or questions made doing public comment unless an item has been placed on the published agenda there
006shall be no deliberation or action taken the board May one acknowledge a receipt of the information report and comment two refer to staff for further study or three refer the matter to the next agenda a recording is made of all open sessions of the governing board again on behalf of the Board of Education we thank you in advance for helping us conduct this meeting respectfully Susie before we journ to close session do we have anyone here who would like to speak on an item on the Clos session agenda yes we do Susan Smith good evening my fellow teachers members of the School Board Dr Johnson and Welcome to our newest members Heidi herck and Lena me I stand here tonight as a dedicated educator deeply committed to the students of smusd but also as a
007member of a community that is struggling under the rising cost of living I want to address our District's refusal to provide a salary increase for teachers a decision that not only undervalues our contributions but also jeopardizes the stability of our schools over the past four years the district's Reserve has more than doubled from 23.6 mil ion to an astounding 51.2 million this is far above the 3% Reserve mandated by the state sitting Instead at 16% while the San Diego County average for salary increases is 2.56% smusd teachers are asking for just 1.5% a mere 1.7 million of this growing Reserve this is not an unreasonable ask it's a necessary one teachers in this District do far more than what is outlined in our contracts over the last few weeks I volunteered nearly 30 hours of
008my time to make last night's La Costa meows talent show happen other staff members also donated their time to help with auditions rehearsals and the final show this level of commitment is not unique to me or my site as some USD teachers grade essays late into the night plan lessons over weekends run before and after school tutoring sessions and organize events like talent shows we regularly show up at school events to cheer for students volunteer as coaches run clubs and give up our prep time to meet with students all because we care deeply about the students we teach and want to create opportunities for them to succeed but care and passion alone can't pay the bills gas electricity water groceries continue to rise in cost for some of us like me the challenge is even
009greater as we support our own smusd graduates through college many of us can barely afford to live in the very District where we teach and the Gap is growing wider every year I've considered finding a second job to help makes make ends meet but the reality is I don't have time my dedication to my students leaves little room for anything else if I'm forced to find another way to make money it's the kids the students who will suffer teachers like me won't have the time to provide opportunities like the talent show or the extra support that helps our students Thrive meanwhile the district has made $19.1 million in financial commitments prior to negotiations without consulting our labor teams over $2 million of these funds are earmarked for technology while technology is important it should not
010come at the expense of teachers struggling to afford basic necessities we are not asking for luxuries we're asking for fair compensation that reflects the rising costs we face and the invaluable work we do for our students every single day it's time to invest in your teachers the very people who make this District's success possible our teachers are heroes not zeros thank you Elliot Howell good evening uh board members superintendent Johnson and fellow union members I'm Elliot Po and I'm a teacher at San Marcos Middle School you can tell what a district value by how it spends its money today I want to highlight two important programs that impact our district in very different but equally important ways the importance of providing health insurance for retired certificated employees hired after 2007 and the importance of providing
011a stien for teachers running the model United Nations program for our middle and high school students first let's talk about health insurance ensuring that all our retirees have access to affordable health insurance should be a priority for the district unfortunately this is not the case certificated employees hired after 2007 don't receive medical benefits upon retiring if every teacher hired after 2007 retired tomorrow and met the requirements currently in place we'd only be talking about 30 teachers and the costs would be small every surrounding District offers health insurance to all their retired certificated employees San Marcos unified is the notable exception under our current systems certificate ated employees who retire in 2038 and our under Medicare age would receive no medical benefits after having taught in our district for over 30 years we urge the board
012to address this inequity immediately now let's talk about the mly United Nations program model un Fosters leadership and teamwork as students work together to find solutions to Global challenges it encourages curiosity develops confidence and connects students to the world around them more than a club students us usually meet after school at least once a week to learn about the issues of the day and prepare for conferences that generally take place on Saturdays a year-long program students usually participate in two to four conferences a year and now while everything that I just mentioned aligns perfectly with the qualities outlined in the district's portrait of a graduate our district refuses to offer a stien for teachers willing to take on the challenge of bringing this program to our students perhaps if they did there would be more
013than just two schools in our district participating in this important program we have an amazing District because of our amazing Educators show them that you care by supporting them with the health benefits they deserve and while you're at it let's provide a stien for teachers who are willing to do the hard work to provide our students with the educational and Leadership opportunities that model un provides thank you and I yield the remainder of my time to the chair Emily McMullen good evening on behalf of the special education teacher ERS at smusd we are tired of the continuous messaging from the district office that if a case load is below 28 we are overstaffed and have plenty of time and space to take on more work this is an outof touch dismissive disrespectful and degrading sentiment
014as teachers we default to best practices yet the district conveniently defaults to state legal limits we are one of the only districts without Casal limits below the archaic 28 at the secondary level San Diego unified has 20 Vista has 22 Oceanside and Escondido have 24 our special education FTE are based on Cas load numbers but the reality is that we are teachers and co-teachers in the classroom for over 70% of our day during the remaining 30% of our day we are also required to complete timec consuming initial evaluations non-public school evaluations and meetings for these evaluations which are not included in our case numbers nor our teaching responsibilities outside of our teaching time we are required to fulfill the expectations of being a case manager this includes writing legally sound IEPs collecting data and completing
015progress reports for hundreds of goals multiple times a year scheduling and rescheduling IEP meetings holding interim annual trienal and addendum IEP meetings formally testing students for triennials setting up and holding transition meetings adhering to firm deadlines staying in compliance and case managing students we don't even see during the day additionally when a sped teacher goes out on a leave the rest of the sped team is required to absorb their case load without any additional pay incentive or release from adjunct Duty last year our team presented 45.5 hours of additional work to cover our colleagues leave and we were denied compensation she's still out almost a year later with no replacement leaving four co-taught sections without a credential sped teacher we are expected to set our students up for success but we are not set up
016for success we're losing our best sped teachers and our best instructional assistance we are one of the only local districts without case Lo limits in moderate severe programs Vista and Escondido have 12 to1 Oceanside has 11 to1 we are one of the only local districts without Cas limits in the seas and base programs viston esano have 12 to1 Oceanside has 11 to1 and we are one of the only local districts without quo limits in speech and language programs Vista and Nido have 55 to1 and we want 55 to1 we want contract language providing sped teachers with an additional five work days per year in order to prepare for the start and the end of the school year when scheduling and paperwork are the most impactful we want an established cap on the amount of initial
017assessments our contract language needs to reflect reality and the times that we are teaching in thank you Karen IES hi good evening board members welcome um and superintendents all of you and my fellow teachers my name is Karen IES and I'm a kindergarten teacher at Twin Oaks element mement and have been there for over 20 years I've seen a lot around the district and I'm here to respectfully ask the district to not increase class sizes in K3 the district now follows the California recommendation of 24 to1 and K through3 but unlike other places we don't have a hard cap per classroom so what that means for us is that if one grade level at the site has low class sizes then another grade level at the site can have 28 29 depends it because it's
018an average K through three number so that gives the district flexibility that we see so what you say is the difference of a few kids in the classroom well there's a pretty big difference the biggest one from so many teachers that I've talked to comes from not being able to provide the more kids in the classroom the less specific immediate feedback you can give to students um there is not as much personalized instructions to address needs of students early intervention hugely important this is when we identify learning difficulties this is when we prepare them for their future can't do it with more kids in the classroom research shows that students in smaller classes perform better academically English Learners in a smaller class size have more support and more chances to practice their English speaking so
019to become a district that's providing an unparalleled educational experience and to graduate Future Ready young adults it all starts in the primary grades so let's give them the best chance ever let's not focus on the relatively small amount of financial benefit that the district is going to gain from one more two more kids in a class it's about focusing on the students I get concerns as the elementary rep at large from the whole District the biggest number one concern that I've had for the past two years is excessive behaviors dramatically increasing behaviors and the lack of support staff to help every additional student affects this let's count all classes more in each class is not the answer there are no more requests to speak with no more speakers present we will adjourn to close session
020thank you e e e e e e [Music] [Applause] [Music] oh do e e e e e e