001Good evening. I would like to call this meeting to order. Today's date is Thursday, December 12th, 2024. This is a special meeting of the governing board of the San Marcos Unified School District. Please let the record reflect that all board members are present. The San Marcos Unified School District Board of Education meeting is a business meeting of the board held in public. While we welcome and encourage public participation, the expected behavior is that this meeting will be conducted in an orderly fashion. Only the person recognized by the board president may speak while that member of the public is speaking. Members of the audience must not yell or speak out regardless of whether you agree or disagree. While public comment is in progress, if you speak out, you're out of order and will be asked to
002leave the meeting. As adults participating in a public meeting, we need to model civility to our children and students. On behalf of the board of education, we thank you in advance for helping us conduct this meeting respectfully. The San Marcos Unified School District is an innovative and collaborative community providing an unparalleled educational experience through an engaging and supportive environment. All of our students are challenged, inspired, and po 6L. Please rise for the pledge of allegiance. Ready? Begin. I aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands. One nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Do I have a motion to approve the agenda? Moved by member Carlson, second by member Amad to approve the agenda as presented. All those in favor say I.
003I. Any opposed? Motion carries. The board met in close session to discuss collective bargaining between SMUSD and SMEA and CSCA. No action was taken. The board also discussed matters pertaining to public employee employment, transfer, appointment, discipline, dismissal, release, evaluation, and reassignment. No action was taken. 5.0 Oh, um recognition you um tonight we are going to take a moment and recognize Carlos and Jamie for their service over the past on our board of trustees. I know I know our other trustees have uh words you'd like to share, but by way of introduction, I'd like to just share a couple of thoughts of my own. You know, not many people out there in the public know actually what a a school board member does. Um, you know, do you come to one meeting a month? Is that
004what it is? You get paid lots of money for all this. I mean, none of those things are true. In a way, there's really no way to know what this role is until you get into it and you're experiencing it. Um, it involves a lot of listening. It involves a lot of learning. Uh it requires a healthy balance of passion and patience as you learn the complexities of the system that we're dealing with and the importance of keeping the main thing the main thing. Uh it also requires strong respect and collaboration with your fellow trustees as you govern together as a team. I can say to you personally as a superintendent that I've worked with many many board members who have come from all kinds of different backgrounds uh but I've never seen a board
005that is as cohesive as this one. And tonight I'd like to personally thank Carlos I lost my place. Carlos and Jamie for your partnership uh for your partnership, your focus on students and for your strong collaborative spirit with your colleagues on the board. Uh you were elected during COVID shutdowns. I just want to say that alone you didn't deserve an award for even wanting to step up and and serve uh the public at a time like that. And if you think about during your your four years on the board, you hired a new superintendent, probably your crown accomplishment. You actually you opened our schools after the COVID closures. You adopted a bold vision for students and our portable graduate and our strategic plan. You approved a series of uh budgets that have stabilized our fiscal
006position. You worked to pass measure JJ, which is going to bring modernized facilities to thousands of students for decades to come. uh and you have governed in a way that has brought health and stability to the district and that all starts right here with the five of you. Um it's not easy. It's a lot of work. Um it's a lot of hours. It's a lot of dedication and commitment to doing what is right for the staff, the students, and the families of San Marcos uh in an incredibly complex, sometimes uncertain and always changing environment. And so on behalf of all of us, I want to thank you for your four incredible years of service to SMUSD and all that you have contributed to our school district. So thank you very much. Your fellow trustees also
007have comments you'd like to share. Well, um I think you said a lot of it. I think that um yeah, in the last four years, I think that a a lot has has been done to bring stability back to the district. I've been on the board for 10 years, and it's been a it's been a wild and crazy 10 years. And I really feel like the last four what were really where we started putting things in place to ideally make, you know, our the community and our staff and our students feel like we're we're back on track. I think winning JJ absolutely proved that, you know, our our community, you know, believes in in the health and stability of the district again. And that was a lot of work. Um, Carlos, the the uh immense
008amount of knowledge that you have instructionally and your commitment to equity um and and making sure that all that all of our students are recognized um is something that I really really appreciate. Um and I've really loved working with you. Um Jamie, your uh your your passion and curiosity and willingness to to learn and change and the empathy that you've brought to the board I you know is something that I think has helped us push um as far as we've been able to push. Um and I just I love and appreciate that about you. Um, and you know, I think that I would Yeah. Yeah. I um I I I I really love and appreciate that about you. I think that's all I'm going to say for right now. Somebody else go. I'm a man
009of few words. Um, I I can't I can't express how much gratitude I have towards both of you for the amount of cohesiveness, the amount of blessings that we've had to be here these past two years that I've served on the board as a new incomer. Um, I've learned a lot from both of you and know that your impact will carry generations through you. You might not see it. You might not ever see it here, but know that that impact will always be there no matter what we do. Um, this is bigger than any one of us, any one of our egos. This carries on beyond, you know, the community. So, thank you. Thank you very much. I am not a woman of few words, but I did write them down. Um, Andy mentioned COVID
010and um I through co Oh, sorry. uh through co we definitely bonded call it trauma bonding as a team and I would say that despite our differences that has made us an incredibly strong team and I want to say it has been an absolute honor to serve alongside both of you guys have brought amazing heart you guys have brought conviction and your experiences and I will add to Andy's passion and patient the compassion you guys have brought to the board I I want to recognize that we took our seats in the J in January of 2020 and there were massive gaping holes, no offense to anyone, in the basic foundation of what would some some would call our district. We had instability at the district office. We had instability at the very head of that
011office. We had mismanaged and had very raw relationships with our community members and staff and the and and the parents and the students. We were financially weak and we really didn't have a direction though we did have a great mission statement. In the last four years we have solidified that foundation. This board has had to really deal with the big things before we dealt with some of the smaller ones. And because we strengthened that foundation, this district and this is your legacy, Damian and Carlos is primed to move be go beyond where we were. Our foundation is that much stronger because of you guys. I think I've told everyone that has asked what the responsibility of a board member is and I always say that an underrated underappreciated value of a school board member is
012what we do to the culture and the tenor of our district because we are the ones that said it and you guys have done that. Jamie have said you've brought life to the district. I don't think there's ever been a meeting where if we're not laughing on dis someone has been laughing up there and on any of our meetings and Carlos you've brought your experience and insight I've come into many meetings headstrong and said oh man I didn't think of it like that so I appreciate that and the culture of learning and having the compassion lives through us and in our cabinet and our teachers our staff our students our parents and on my phone obviously don't um and I know we're still not perfect there's a lot of work to be done and we
013will continue to do that work alongside Lena and Heidi now. Um but it's a continuous but it's a continuation of the work that we've already achieved. Um thank you both for all the heart that's heart and literally sweat and tears that you have put into this district. I know that we have moved at the needle at a great a great deal when it comes to putting students first and making this district one of the best. So again, I love you guys and it's been an honor. I have probably gone through 7 million different speeches in my head in the past, you know, couple days leading up to this meeting. Um, you know, Andy always tells us that this district is like a um cruise line and it takes a lot of work to move a
014cruise line. Not just the boat, but everybody that's in it as well. And I can say that this board has definitely moved our cruise line in a positive direction. And um I know there's been a lot of times when we've been looking under the boat to make sure we don't hit an iceberg or something. Um I am really proud of my four years and I'm really proud to have served with the um the people up here with our teachers with our students with our staff. Um, it's been a really great honor and I'm looking forward to being able to substitute now so I can see all the hard work we've done in practice. Um, I love you guys and um there's more great things to do, so keep working hard. Yeah. I should have a
015timer because I'm a teacher and I talk a lot, right? And um year 34 I ran three times first school board lost. Came in last place and during CO I got a phone call from my board president's husband. He he's from England. He's like, "You need to run." Like why? It's co I'm locked on lockdown right now. It's like mate, you they need you. It's like I've already run three times. I've lost three times. Gareth, please. I left administration because I'm I've returned to teaching. I'd been an administrator for 20 years. Loved being a teacher again. Happy as can be. And um he said, "If I write your ballot statement, will you consider running?" I said, "Sure." I used the ballot statement again, just so you know. And when I ran it, it changed a
016few words. It's like, "If this is what got me elected, then I'm going to use it again. And if God has a higher plan for someone else, I will respect that and I will support that person. And I truly believe that um I know we are very clear about separation from God and also from public schools. But I have I believe in a higher faith and I believe a higher faith and a higher has brought us together to do this work. I truly believe the work up here is God's work. And um Jamie, I'm going to miss your passion for education, your passion for kids, your passion for rolling up your sleeves and getting things done. I want to call you Stacy, but I'm board member Carlson. I have so much respect for you because
017during co we were getting 60 emails a day. 60. And having been a former principal, I return every email just because that's how I was trained. You have to. And you really gave us so much direction. you were kind of our lifeline that first year when we didn't have a full-time person and I just can't thank you enough for the stability that you brought to the five of us. Um, I didn't know Sarah before running and we've carpulooled. You know, she's my board sister. I'm going to be PC now and say the right way, right? I've downgraded. Yeah, I know. I called her my board wife and oh I got really like another person got upset about that but anyhow I'm past 55 so I can be a little bit unp right um thank you
018it's okay go ahead okay go ahead go ahead thank you for the stability that you have helped bring to us the vision and also the clarity um as a person who has that business background, but also always thinking like a mom. You always put your kids and thinking of your kids, and that's what I always will remember about us. Um, always putting that perspective of the kid in place and the impact on kids. And I always like to say, I'm the first Latino with an O, not Latina. Stacy was the first Latina elected to the board. I think I'm the first Latino and and he's the second. And I can sleep better now that we have another Latino on the board because the majority of our kids are Latino here in um and Latina in
019San Marcos Unified. So I think representation matters quite a bit. Voice matters and having someone that kind of looks like you and speaks your language matters. Um so I'm just so grateful for your service and your willingness to be a part of this board and and serve the kids of this community. Um, Andy, one of the best decisions I ever made was bringing you to San Marcos. I know I hold you accountable and we squabble quite a bit and I'm sure you're happy that I'm no longer going to be on the board, but dude, you have brought so much stability to San Marcos and because I know so much and I've been doing this, it's like I just wanted the best for our kids. And you always exceeded my expectations. Always. I would ask this
020and Andy would take it here. And and so that's why I always did it. And I'm no longer going to be there to push you on this side, but you I may come to the podium to push you, but just know that I will let you know beforehand so you're prepared. Um yeah, I'll email you guys. But you have, like I said, have brought stability to this district. And in my opinion, and it's just mine, is one of the greatest things I feel that we did to bring you. and I just hope that you continue on here and doing great things with cabinet and teachers and the students of San Marco. So, just know my intentions were always to push you, but not over the edge, but sometimes I kind of feel like I may
021have pushed you over the edge, but thank you for always being so respectful and allowing me to push you and and uh just know how much I speak for Jamie when I say this. We we do care about you and we truly love you and um we only hope you continue being that leader that we brought on and and you have been. So, thank you. So, the uh holiday floral arrangements are for you guys. They were they were made by our floral design students. So, those are for you. And we also have a small token for you. So, I'll ask you guys maybe to come up and then maybe we can all come up and take a photo with uh with Jamie and Carlos. And thank you to Sudi who is the designer and Oh,
022I know. They're so nice. exeutor. I know these great gifts. reports by board. I sorry, I just want to say um thank you for spelling my name correctly. It's been many years. I know, Susie, you're amazing. Uh, it just a Everybody spells my name wrong. It happens all the time, so it's always special when it's done right the first time. I just going to say a few more words. Sorry. Before we move on. Um Erin, thank you for helping balance our budgets and keeping us fiscally responsible and um you are very focused and um and uh we wouldn't have that Moody rating without you and so thank you for uh for all you do of of keeping us in the black. Tiffany, I've so much enjoyed getting to know you these last four years. I
023know during co it was so chaotic and and you helped bring that stability. You you did not ask for it, but you were thrust into that position. And um I personally just see you as anchoring this community and this district. And uh I just like I say I hope that this will always be home for you because for me when I think of San Marcos uh school district I think of you and and everything that you brought to it. So thank you Joel. Um you are you've completed our our cabinet and our dis and um thank you for coming to San Marcos um and and and continuing the work that needs to be done here to recruit and retain the best and to work as our labor negotiator with our unions and just to uh
024to build that sense of um inclusion and voice and and and that you know you are heard and um and we're here to support you um in this whole process. So you you've completed us. Okay, I will get another opportunity to talk about Susie because she's amazing. She's another five minutes, but we're going to just continue on with the meeting. Okay, thank you. If you wished the board if you wish to address the board, you may fill out a request form located in the al cove to the left of the double doors as you enter the boardroom. Please complete a white speaker form. If the item you wish to speak about is on the agenda and a blue speaker form if the item you wish to speak on about is not on the agenda. Please
025give it to Susie. In accordance with board policy 9323, public comments will be limited to 20 minutes per topic. Each speaker will be allowed a maximum of three minutes to speak except for our union representatives who have five minutes. Per the Brown Act, members of the board are very limited in their ability to respond to the statements or questions made during public comment. Unless an item has been placed on the published agenda, there shall be no deliberation nor action taken. The board may one acknowledge receipt of the information report and comment. Two, refer to staff for further study or three refer the matter to the next agenda. A recording is made of all open sessions of the governing board. Again, on behalf of the board of education, we thank you in advance for helping us
026conduct this meeting respectfully. Susie, do we have any speakers? Yes, we do. Dale Penik, thank you. Good evening, Board President Carlos Uoa, Vice President Sarah Ma, Clerk Andres Martin, Member Stacy Carlson, and member Jamie Chamberlain, Superintendent Dr. Johnson, Deputy Superintendent Dr. Tiffany Campbell, and Assistant Superintendent. My name is Dale Ziggmund Luchie and I am president of the San Marcos Educators Association. SMEA represents over 10,000 members, not only teachers but also counselors, social workers, nurses, speech language pathologists, school psychologists, and certificated staff. SMA wants to thank the board for its continued commitment to public education and public public educators. And a special thanks to to Dr. for Yoa and Jamie Chamberlain for all you guys have done in supporting teachers and educators the last four years. It's been a lot to do with and Sarah of
027course winning election but yeah it's and and the rest of course too but I want to especially thank you guys for outgoing. Um as we approach the holiday season I want to acknowledge the incredible dedication of our educators the teacher magic that has helped our district rank fourth in the county according to the 2025 best school districts in San Diego County report. This magic comes from countless unpaid hours spent after school planning lessons, providing feedback, and ensuring our students receive a world-class education. I deeply appreciate the sacrifices our educators make and made a committed to fighting for the recognition and compensation they deserve. This has been a challenging season of negotiations made even harder by the district's recent communication. While expressing gratitude for our teachers, the district simultaneously signaled budget cuts, including credential reductions in
028teaching positions. For years, we've been told that declining enrollment is the issue. That yet the only solution proposed has been aggressive marketing campaigns. Meanwhile, SMEA has stepped up developing programs and continuing to deliver an exceptional education. SMEA urges the board to scrutinize how the district is addressing declining enrollment and using its commitments to mitigate the proposed budget gap. We also call on the district to offer a retirement incentive to help minimize classroom and site level cuts. Unfortunately, we've seen a familiar pattern in the district's approach. During the last right sizing effort, 97 certificated positions, roughly 10% of our union were proposed for elimination, all in the middle of negotiations. This was framed as a one-time adjustment to stabilize staffing levels. Yet, here we are again facing proposed reductions in force. We urge the board to
029ask the district how it plans to manage these cuts and ensure they are made as far away from school sites as possible. Moreover, we implore the board to vote no on these potential reductions, particularly since this district has funds earmarked for declining enrollment mitigation. These funds can address the budget gap while staying under the statemandated 10% reserve threshold. As a former history teacher at San Marcos High School and a graduate of San Diego State University, Golassex, I often think of the phrase history doesn't repeat itself, but it rhymes. Unfortunately, some of the rhymes I've observed as SMA president, including the timing include the timing of proposed riffs and the district's reluctance to prioritize educators. Another rhyme, um, excuse me, u, uh, sorry, that's my place now. Another rhyme is SMA's continued commitment to improving our
030schools, including our endorsement of Measure JJ. We worked hard to support its passage, encouraging members to vote for it, funding mailers, and even in allowing my image and quote to appear on district provided materials. We support a measure JJ because we understand the importance of modern facilities and fostering student success and attracting and attracting new family to the district. The bond's passage offers financial flexibility to the address these needs. Yet history reminds us to stay vigilant after SMEA supported the passage of Prop K. I'm going to give you a history legend. It should have been called measure K, but they called it Prop. It was a misnomer, but whatever. That's my job as a teacher. And in in 2010, that was Prop K in 2010. It was misnomer again. The district responded with layoffs, salary
031reductions, and furlow days. Today we see echoes of 2010 proposed riffs, refusal to offer a meaningful salarying increase and unwillingness to commit to retirey benefits. SMA has continually partnered with the district in good faith to improve our schools, including help pass Measure JJ. Now, we ask the board to reciprocate that commitment by standing with educators and prioritizing the staff who make our district successful. Thank you. Do we have any more speakers? No. Thank you. Hello. No more speakers. 8.1 public hearing. Oh, sorry. 7.0 report by board members. Does anyone have anything that they would like to report? Actually, yes. Um, a group of us attended the uh CS California Schoolboard Association annual educator uh conference. Wonderful workshops that we entered and looked at. My apologies the two new board members. I did not meet you
032uh during those two couple days we were there. Uh but thank you for attending the orientation meeting. Very important to lay the groundwork for you both. Other than that, wonderful workshops. We walked away with insightful conversations and I did take notes. I think I shared those with you, but I could share them with the rest of you. Thank you. Public hearing action agenda. public hearing to hear comments from the public regarding the financial provisions of multiple agreements with bargaining units between the San Marcos Unified School District, SMUSD, and the California School Employers Association, CSEA, and at San Marcos Chapter 413 and San Marcos Educators Association, SMEA. Aaron, on tonight's agenda, the board will consider approval of multiple collective bargaining agreements with CSEA and SMEA. The government code requires school districts to publicly disclose the provisions
033of any bargaining agreement, including the costs that may be incurred prior to considering its approval and allow for public comment. The twous regarding dual enrollment with SMEA tonight have no financial impact to the district. The twous with CSEA regarding noon time supervisors and the athletic trainer job classifications are expected to cost the district approximately 54,000 for the remainder of this fiscal year and $83,000 on an annual basis. This public hearing is now open. Susie, is there anyone who wishes to speak? There are no requests to speak. This public hearing is not closed. Do I have a motion to 8.2 disclosures of collective bargaining agreements with the California School Employees Association, CSEA, and its San Marcos chapter uh number 413 and San Marcos Educators, SMA. Aaron, to comply with the government code, documents have been prepared
034that disclose the costs of theus being considered tonight. As required, the superintendent and I have certified that we can afford the cost of these agreements in the budget and the disclosures were provided to the San Diego County Office of Education in advance for their review. Do I have a motion to approve the disclosures of collective bargaining agreements with the California School Employees Association CSEA and its San Marcos chapter 413 and San Marcos Educators Association SMEA? So moved. Moved by member Martine, second by member Carlson to approve the disclosures of the collective bargaining agreements as presented. All those in favor say I. I. Any opposed? Motion carries. Memorandum of understanding with the California School Employees Association and its San Marcos chapter 413 noon time supervisor salary range. Dr. Garcia. Yes. Uh good evening board members. Uh
035this minimum wage in California will be increasing to 1650 per hour effective January 1st. Currently, the classification of new and time supervisor uh is the only classification that falls under that uh minimum wage or that um hourly rate, excuse me, and only at step one. Uh with thisou, we would adjust the salary range from range one to range two to remain in compliance with California minimum wage. Uh this is an action item with a recommendation to approve theou as presented. Do I have a motion to approve the memorandum of understanding with California School Employees Association and its San Marcos chapter 413 noon time supervisors salary range. I'll move to approve. I'll second. Move by member, second by member Carlson to approve theou with CSA as presented. All those in favor say I. I. Any opposed?
036Motion carries. 8.4 for memorandum of understanding with the San Marcos Educators Association dual enrollment programs with Palmar College and Cal State San Marcos. Dr. Garcia. Yes, board members. As Dr. noted in the introduction, um there are two separate here um with SMA both but in relation to dual enrollment courses with Cal State University San Marcos and Palomar College. The terms of theou include uh the specifics of the courses taught, the selection of the San Marcus Unified School District instructors, uh their employment status and compensation to make sure that we clarify those terms within within theou. Um and also the assurance that no SMUSD teachers will be reduced as a result of this agreement. Um I will say we appreciate um the collaborative efforts with SMA um through the partnership and dialogue related to this agreement
037and this is an action item with a recommendation to approve theou as presented. Are there any questions because I have just one. Sure. So um I know that there's a big push at the state level for us to have dual enrollment programs with our junior college and um our Cal State. Has there been any discussion to looking at dual enrollment with our UC system for those who are wanting to go to a UC to get UC credit? Not at this time. Um the focus currently is on Palomar College and on Cal State San Marcos. Thank you. Any questions? Do I have a motion to approve the memorandum of understanding with California School Employees Association and its SEM? Sorry. Do I have a motion to approve the memorandum understanding with SMA dual enrollment programs with Palmar
038College and CSUM? CSUSM. So move. Moved by member Martine, second by member Chamberlain to approve theou withme as presented. All those in favor say I. I. I. Any opposed? Motion carries. 8.5 Memorandum of Understanding with the California School Employees Association and its San Marcos chapter number 413 uh CSA regarding revisions of the current job title and description for the position of athletic trainer. Uh revise classified salary schedule. Dr. Garcia. Yes. Board members with SMOU CSA and in the district agree to revise the classification. um in several different areas including the title uh the performance responsibilities, the certifications required to hold the classification of athletic trainer and the salary range as well. Uh thisou would be effective upon board approval. Um and again this is an action item with a recommendation to approve theou as presented.
039Are there any questions? Do I have a motion to approve the memorandum of understanding with California School Employees Association and its San Marcos chapter 413 regarding revision of current job title and description for the position of athletic trainer revise classified salary schedule. Move to approve and I'll second. Moved by member Carlson, second by member Ahmad to approve the MOU with CCA as presented. All those in favor say I. I. Any opposed? Motion carries. The governing board will now address matters related to the community facilities district number 17 of the San Marcos Unified School District. For agenda items 8.6 6 and 8.7. The governing board will be acting as a legislative body of community facilities district number 17. Agenda item uh agenda item number 8.6 conduct sec second reading of ordinance number 2-2425. Ordinance of Community
040Facilities District number 17 of the San Marcos Unified School District, authorizing the levy of a special tax within community facilities District number 17. The board previously took the first two steps for this CFD formation on October 10th and November 14th. Tonight is the last of three board meetings to approve the special tax ordinance. Um, this project in North City includes 408 residential units is located in the city of San Marcos at the corner of Discovery Street and South Twin Oaks Valley Road and Shea Holmes is the developer. Um, CFD number 17 is to finance a mitigation payment of 132% of the district's level one fees. This is estimated to generate approximately 5.6 million for our school facilities. To approve the special tax, the board must conduct a second reading and adoption of the ordinance this
041evening. Do I have a motion to present a second reading of the ordinance by title only? I move that ordinance number 2-2425 be presented by the reading of title only and that the clerk forgo the reading of the entire ordinance. Moved by member Ahmad, second by I'll second. Second by member Carlson to present the second reading of ordinance 2-2425 by title only. All those in favor say I. I. Any opposed? Motion carries. The title of ordinance number 2-2425 reads as follows. Ordinance of Community Facilities District number 17 of the San Marcus Unified School District authorizing the levy of a special tax within community facilities district number 17. Agenda item number 8.7, adoption of ordinance number two-2425, ordinance of community facilities district number 17 of the San Marcos Unified School District, authorizing the levy of a
042special tax within community facilities district number 17. District staff and legal council recommend that the governing board take action to adopt ordinance number 02-2425 for the reasons previously discussed. Do I have a motion for the adoption of ordinance number 2-2425? I move to adopt the ordinance number 2-25. Oh, second. 2425. Sorry. Moved by member Ahmad, second by member Carlson to adopt ordinance number 2-2425 as presented. All those in favor say I. Any opposed? Motion carries. The matters related to CFD number 17 are now complete for this meeting of the governing board. The governing board will no longer be acting as a legislative body of CFD number 17 for the remaining items of the agenda. 8.8 8 uh 24 25 interim report and positive budget certification. Erin, tonight we are looking at the first interim financial
043report. Um as always the the full budget report is very lengthy. It's 110 pages tonight. Um it is was attached to the board agenda item and as always available on the district's um website for public review as well. Um my present presentation tonight is just a very high level um overview of what that very lengthy report the first report is due to the county office by December 15th. Um is only the the first time we're looking at the budget in six months. So, the last time you saw it was back when we adopted the it for the first time in June. Um, sometimes, um, in the summertime, we do a 45day budget update. Um, if the budget that the state adopted is significantly different than the assumptions that we used in the adopted budget and
044this this year, that wasn't the case. The budget was pretty much identical. That finally got adopted by the state. So, we didn't do a 45 date update. So, this is the first time we're seeing a revised budget for the 2425 school year. um in six months. At this time, we are projecting our revenues to be 313.8 million. As usual, the bulk of that is coming from our local control funding formula, which is generated by our students in attendance every day. Um 72.6% of our revenues in the general fund are coming from LCFF this year. um followed by about 40 million in local funds, 34.3 million in state funds, and finally some federal funds of 11.6 million. Just want to briefly review the changes um in the revenues since the adopted budget. So as we look
045um really no changes um in LCFF since June, we are using the three-year prior a prior three-year average for um ADA for LCF funding. Just as a reminder, um under federal revenues, um we are getting $2.8 million more. We're recognizing revenue that was deferred as as carryover um from the prior fiscal year in several federal restricted programs. Um we actually have a reduction in state revenues um because we are recognizing that we're going to be returning to the state $2.6 million in ELOP program funding. That was a brand new um before and after school program that the state started a couple years ago um with very little guidance on how to get that program started. Um, so this is common. There are many, many, many school districts across the state um that are returning funds.
046So across those last two years, we received over $12 million. So we spent the bulk of those funds. And so this $2.6 million that returning is just the difference um that we weren't able to spend. And so that's the reason why you see a reduction there. Um in addition that that that um return of grant funds is offset by additional grant funds that we're expecting in CTE and community schools. And then in local revenues we're expecting a little over $3 million more. Um primarily from carryovers across all of our school sites. Um we have some additional bus service contracts that we're providing additional service to Oceanside Unified and several other districts that we're providing field trip service for. And we have a new um peer-to-peer grant of $1.5 million as well. So um in total
047recognizing an additional $4.4 million of revenue since the adopted budget. Right now we are projecting to spend this year $342.8 million um with the bulk of that salaries and benefits for our staff. That number is typically higher. This year, um you'll notice that we have much larger percentage of capital outlay um in our budget. Um that is primarily for a very large school bus purchase of um 21 EV buses, almost all paid for by grant funds that we're getting. Um but because of that, typically you don't even see a sliver in the pie here of capital outlay funds. um because we have that this year, it is offsetting the percentages that are typically spent on salary and benefits. As we look at changes um between the adopted budget and first interim um our both of
048our certificated and classified salaries um are up a little bit um primarily just to um account for several um grant funds that we have received that are have some staffing tied to them. um benefits is declining a bit. Um we just looked um just clean up based on the actual staff that um we've hired since the beginning of the school year. Um we had a reduction based on the projected amount that we're paying out for um retiree health benefits. And then we're also have um incorporated the new um rates, health benefit rates that start in January. Um books and supplies are up a little bit um just to account for um site sites that are spending in that particular category and federal programs that are being carried over is going to be spent on supplies
049and then services are up there. Um this one is also due to the current year um ELOP program. We have um some a couple large contracts with the Boys and Girls Club and Champions um to serve that program. And in particular, we have a services and operating expense category. Um we also have services going out for um federal special education in this category as well. And then in capital outlay is up by $1 million for additional planned equipment in CTE that that peer-to-peer grant that I talked about earlier as well as some kitchen infrastructure funds. be buying some kitchen equipment. But so in total, um expenditures are up 5.9 million since the adopted budget. And this is just another slide delineating the different assumptions that went into the expenditures at this time. Again, we've accounted
050for all newly hired, classified, and certificated staff to date. and no salary increases are included in this because negotiations are still pending for both bargaining units. All those health benefits um caps that are increasing have been incorporated and then changes based on um pretty much based on restricted program changes in books and supplies services and capital outlay. Erin, does this include theus that we just approved? And it looks like it looks like the the increase in in benefits that we approved last meeting was the last meeting that those included here um the the two the twous tonight that I said cost 54,000 have actually not been incorporated into the budget yet. We don't typically do that until it's official and and board approved. Okay. Thanks Erin. I have a question about ELOP. Is that was
051this just during postcoid? Is it is it no longer exists? Was it just for this year? Because it's quite a bit of money to be giving back. I just I know our district, neighboring district, we used it for for intervention, for after school, for clubs to create that sense of belonging. And I know those are big goals of ours. Um is this going to be ongoing money or is it just one time that's It is. It is. The state is very serious about providing before and after school programming for our students also and um time during um inter sessions as well and we do believe that ELOP is an ongoing program at this point in time. Um and so yeah, we absolutely have a very robust and I don't I don't know how many sites
052have ELOP and we are providing it for many many of our students. Yeah, I'm just I'm I'm glad that we we the state has committed to this funding. Is this a shame that we're get having to give it back, right? I mean, there's no you use it or lose it. There's no carryover. There isn't. We had we had two-year period of time we had to spend the funds. And um I think the good news is is like the state doesn't like it when we return money. But we're not the only district. Many districts are sending back money right now. I think what they're going to do, I hope what they do is they're going to collect it all and then it will be redistributed back to the programs um all the districts that are running
053ELOP programs in future years perhaps. So that So, we probably will hopefully get some of that back in a in a red distribution. I'll just remind the board, you're you're right. We never want to get money back, but this was this particular program could re rewind a couple of years. They released the funds to the school district to correct me if I'm wrong on this. And we were waiting and waiting and waiting and waiting and waiting and waiting while the clock was ticking for the rules and they weren't releasing the rules on how to spend it. And so, we were and then finally when they released the rules, everybody scrambled to get the get the staff hired and get the pro but then the the clock ran out before we could spend it all. So
054we are we are hoping that they that they reallocate those funds. Just going to ask why did we not spend it often? Okay. All right. Sorry. And in the midst I I recall now in the midst of that waiting there was also threats of penalties if you if you spend it incorrectly. And so we were wait either and and incur penalties and fees. So it was a tricky one. Okay. Okay, so this is what the budget numbers look like after we ran through all of the new projections for revenues and expenditures. When we look at the ending balances, we always want to look at the two pieces of the general fund separately. So we break out unrestricted and restricted. Um you can see that we are deficit spending in both categories this year. Um restricted
055programs is deficit spending by quite a bit. um almost $20 million. Um that is to be expected. There are a couple very large one-time grants that the state gave us. Um the largest one being a learning recovery emergency block grant um that we accepted revenues a couple years ago on and we're spending those down o over a five-year period. So the restricted part of the budget is doing exactly what it's supposed to be doing. We're we were took in grant funds and we're spending them um over time that we've received in prior years. The unrestricted budget is something that we do um want to achieve a balance on. We want to um we don't want to be deficit spending um by this amount. Um there's some good news here at the adopted budget. The the
056unrestricted deficit was running at about $11 million. Um so we have been able to really get in there. We looked at where we closed the books for last fiscal year. were able to bring down our budgets to where we think we'll realistically be um in the unrestricted budget. So, but the deficit is still that $9.1 million, which brings the balance down and our reserve percentages are at 10%. Um that balance does include $7.3 million of commitments. Where are those in restricted or unrestricted? All of the commitments are in unrestricted. Okay. And that's money that we had set aside because we knew that we were going to be declining enrollment. We had those set aside for specific things. Correct. And in the actual budget report, um I don't have a slide tonight, but um the actual
057budget report um on the first page of the general fund budget, all of those commitments are Yeah, I was going to say I know we we've talked about what they are um when we when we agree to set them aside. I just want to make sure that they're not like getting rolled into other that there aren't other things that we that are part of this. Okay, they are they are set aside there. Okay. So, because enrollment and attendance play a huge part in our funding picture, just want to review that a little bit before we move on to the multi-year projections. Um, this is the snapshot of where we are with ADA projections currently. Um the dotted line everything to the left there is what's actually happened of the last five years and then we
058have our projections moving forward for the current year as well as the next two years that we are required to put in the multi-year projection. Um our seabeds count that's the the daily we count enrollment um for the year um was is passed it was back in oc October 2nd. Um and at that time um we had 18,860 students enrolled which is a decline of 514 students um over last year. Um just as a reminder our adopted budget um did assume that we were only going to decline by 200 students. So we have made those updates in our multi-year projections. Again, in the current year, it's not impacting our revenues because we're being funded in the prior three years, but the ADA that we have today, this year, will impact future years. So, we've made
059those updates. And at this time, we are also projecting um a decline of 100 students in each of the next two years. And that is aligns with our demographers um projection, current projections as well. I'm just want to point out if this is This year in 2425 is our sixth year of declining enrollment. Um if you count up the cumulative um loss of students, it is 2,143 students that have um we've declined since 1920. I just want to point out that that's very significant. Um on average um annually it's only one and a half to 2% per year. Um but cumulatively it it is a very significant number um that is impacting um our revenues significantly. Do we gohead I was going to say can you remind us like why we're seeing this declining. Is
060it because we're losing kids to other schools or is it because enrollment at you know where where do we see the loss? Sure. So so the biggest driving factor is um birth rates are significantly down. Families they're people are just not having as many kids as they used to especially this year. this year the kind incoming kindergarten kids is the lowest birth rate. We're actually going to see it tick up um next year. That's why the loss isn't as big for next year. Okay. Um so that's the biggest contributing factor. And then there's definitely some out migration out of California because of the high costs of housing. Um young families are can't afford to live here because of the housing costs. Um so we're seeing that as well. that is a trend all across um
061California. Yeah, this is a big conversation at CSBA. Everybody everybody's dealing with with with this. So, I'll add to that that in our particular um uh district, another added layer to this is that when you look at our enrollment K through 12 all in one piece of paper, you see the 12th grade and then 11th and 10th and 9th. So that's was another last year we we graduated a larger 12th grade class and brought in a small kindergarten class and that this year's 12th grade class is bigger than the 11th grade class. So this is going to continue to be a challenge for us going forward. Right. When I started on the board, we were we were a growing district and that was a whole different set of issues and problems to have and I
062would much prefer that to to these types of problems. But um yeah, I don't think this is going away anytime soon. And actually we lucky because we do have significant development, right? We just formed a new CFD tonight and that those new developments are bringing some kids in and it's just helping offset this lower birth rates and other other natural kinds that we're seeing. So that that's a that is a positive for our district. Okay. So now we're going to move on to the multi-year event. Um as always the multi-year projections um are only as good as the assumptions that we are using that go into them and they absolutely will change. Um the governor will be presenting his January um budget um by January 10th and the numbers will absolutely change um by then.
063So this these are the assumptions that we have um as of today. The revenues are primarily for LCFF um numbers and how we get those calculations since that is our largest source of revenues. So I have the cola projections for the next two years there. The enrollment figures that we're using, we're using an attendance rate of 93.6% which is what we were able to achieve last school year and we're hoping that that number holds. Um our funded ADA is again based on that three-year prior average to have that there. Um our unduplicated pupil count um plays into this for how much we get for supplemental funds in the LCF. have those percentages there. And then we get an add-on in LCF for TK. And so TK is always a little hard to guess, right? We
064don't know how many um families are going to send their kids to TK. It's not required and how many won't. So these are our best projections at this time for TK in the next two years. And when we look at expenditures, we don't have any um salary increases built in. We are assuming that health benefits will rise by two and a half percent. We have the district contributions to stirs and purs is stable. The pers rate continues to increase slightly. Um we have attrition savings built in of 600,000 in each year. just typically what we see in our school district with the um number of staff that um retire or resign on a on a given year produces some savings as we um replace those positions. And this the multi-year projections that you're seeing here
065do include 1.25 million of ongoing expenditure reductions starting next year. Look at those. Um there is a much many other assumptions that go into these projections. Just want to share that in that full report there are three pages of very detailed other assumptions um that um we are taking a snapshot of what we what we use to get these numbers. Okay. So before we look at the numbers I want to we want to talk about the budget reductions here a bit. So, the board adopted a resolution back in June with the adopted budget that we would commit to reducing um expenditures in 2526 by $3 million. So, the good news tonight is that we've been able to reduce this number. So, we're asking the board to make reductions of only $1.25 million um as we
066work towards next school year. I have some things here I want just want to walk through about how we went about making the recommendations um for the categories of reductions. So first we we used the governing board's budget guiding principles as a guide. Um we looked at maximizing grant funds and eliminating services for that um for grants um upon the expiration of things. So we do have some grants that are expiring in the next two years um that we are going to be making reductions related to that. Um we always consider non-staffing reductions first. So that's the first category non- salary reductions that you'll see on these charts. We look at reorganizations of functions or departments for increased efficiencies. We always have to maintain compliance with our collective bargaining agreements. Um, as we looked at
067this though, we still we looked at the numbers um because we're arable to get those deficits projected um reduced sufficiently and we are recommending um that we work towards a $1.25 million reduction for next year. So the chart on the top um kind of we used as a guide. We took in our unrestricted general fund these different categories and what percentage of the budget they represented. So you can see there the non-s salary um percentage of the budget was 9.7% um in the adopted budget. And so we tried to use that as a guide for this million dollar number that we needed that we need to reduce. So we look down at the numbers in the different categories. What we're targeting at this point in time is in non salary reductions. We are looking to
068cut $200,000. What kinds of things are in non-salary? That is primarily we're reducing supply and travel and conference budgets across all district office departments that are funded with unrestricted funds. Okay. For example, in ed services department, they have a lot of different departments that are funded by grants. Some of those grants are specifically for professional de development. They need to go to conferences to learn how to use those funds, they will continue traveling, right? You're going to see that happening. But in for those departments that aren't funded by grants, like mine for example, um we will be reducing travel for all staff um as well as our our supplies and those are all at the district level. So just to share, we are not proposing that any supply or travel budgets be for school sites.
069Okay, the school sites will maintain their allocations next year. Certificated, we're looking at a targeted cut of 602,000 which is roughly um five teachers and that is simply because um right now we are a little bit overstaffed because of that larger reduction in enrollment. So that is simply bringing um our class sizes down to contractual levels. And in classified we are looking at reductions of 325,000. That includes some district office department reductions and reorganizations, a reduction of overtime for some of our staff. Primarily the the departments that get overtime are custodial and grants. Um and then a little bit of aligning school office staff um to the equal based on the enrollment of students that they have currently. So how are you going to balance you know not having custodial you know janitors on school
070sites and the school sites need to be cleaned and maintained. Um and so are we going to try to add somebody in so that we don't have to pay for overtime and so we're just shaving off a little bit or how are we So, I just met this morning um with our um custodial coordinator um our lead um trainer with CSEA and um Ted Norman, the executive director of M. And we have definitely some ideas to to reorganize and shift some of our um part-time staff around to be a little bit more efficient. Um and so we'll be doing some of that. Um, we're also going to be leveraging um some of our use of facility funds um to use for ground like to to maintain fields and things like that through our grounds department
071a little bit more effectively. Um I can't promise that it's may not be, you know, noticeable if some of the grounds aren't as impeccable um as they they are. We are used to them being um but we are looking at ways though it won't the impact won't be as significant reducing this overtime. Okay. And for the gen janitorial staff it's not just at the district office it's all sites. Correct. Correct. And not we're not talking about reducing any staffing positions for custodial. We're just talking about trying to control and minimize the overtime that they're doing. So I had I I thought that the like the PTO's if they had janitorial staff that had to come in after hours that they had they were paying for that. Is that is that a different thing? Yes, that
072is a different thing and that will continue like if the PTO has Saturday custodian required to to come in to cover that event and they pay for that. Um those kinds of things will continue. We're talking about districtf funded overtime to get a painting project done or something like that. Okay. Um that we we like to do when we can, but you know, we just don't have that luxury right now. We need to bring things on just a little bit. Well, I just know that you know over the last several years we've been working on trying to get the the budget balanced and and and cleaned up as much as we can. And so over the last several years, we've done cuts, right? And so cumulatively it's like okay if I go on if I
073go onto a campus right now it looks different than it probably would have looked like eight years ago right because you can see how those cuts impact the campus. Um and I'm I just I'm I'm worried that you know we're going to continue to see that and it's it's hard to see. So, I mean I I mean I get it, right? Like we're in the budget situation that we're in, but at the same time it's like it's I mean we've I mean we just know because we've had to cut before and you know it's like anything that anything that was easy to cut we already did cut, right? And so now you know the impacts are going to be felt I think a lot more closely. Um, and you know, I just kind of want
074to make sure when when we see this stuff that we're being really conscious of the fact that I mean that's gonna we're going to see it. You're you're going to see this on the campus. Um I I'm sorry. I have I have a really quick question. I mean um I appreciate you giving us the um the percentage of the budget and percentage of the reduction. We did we use those percentages as a starting point of how much you Yeah, we used it as a guide. We didn't use it when like saying we have to keep going till we get to that percentage. We absolutely didn't do that. We looked at what's realistic. Like when we're cutting supply and travel budgets, we literally ran every department individually. And I met with some of them that looked
075too big with some of those um department directors and I said, "Is that doable? Can you do that?" Um and we did make adjustments in a couple a couple cases. We're not asked a couple departments to make as large of cuts um as as others because they just do it. The reason I'm asking is rather than um uh how do I put this? Rather than going off of how much what percentage we should be reducing from each one of these categories, I want have we looked at each one of these categories and and kind of analyzed what can be cut like what is some what is what is fat? I mean we limit ourselves when we start with a percentage, right? versus looking at a category and saying what is some I know we don't
076have fat right now we've cut already but you you know what I'm saying like is what is what can we cut and um and and not really bind ourselves to starting percentage or or trying to be fair in that regard just I can share that we absolutely did do some of that like okay for example we ran um the at the office staffs right of every single school site side by side to compare us like does anyone have something more than another site, right? Something like that. Oh, this site's running with, you know, two and a half people and this site's running with three and a half. We absolutely looked at that thing, looked at that and that um gave us um the guide for for some of these these reductions. We did we did
077that too. We analyzed it in multiple different ways. We didn't just run and go right to these percentages of theart for that. The chart on the top, sorry, the chart on the top is just to help us um make sure that we're not getting lopsided one side or the other and just making sure that we're we're being thoughtful. I have a question. What percentage of the classified uh budget is is over is for overtime? because I having been a principal for 20 years, some sites like everything had to be pre-approved through the principal and there were some sites you arrived as a brand new principal and people just really ran wild with that overtime and it was just it was a problem. So, I'm wondering is this is this a big part of this classified
078budget with overtime? I don't have the percentage right in front of me, but it's like the number is a little over a hundred,000. So maybe roughly a third of that $325,000 number. Um yeah, it's a big chunk. So it is big. Without going too much into the weeds, uh hopefully in the future we could have some sort of a report on what you briefly talked about and that was the use of facilities of outside organizations that come in because I bet you we're the best kept secret and the best price for you know I mean some pretty big issues there to to tackle at some point and we're working on those but yeah I'm sure yeah because I'm sure it's a little but I hey that little can mean a lot. Thank Okay. And then
079finally, um, we are planning to reduce one management position at the B district office. All right. So, can can you talk a little bit about the certificated of are these positions that are not going to be filled? Are they layoffs? What it's those are essentially just right sizing based on the number of students that we're serving right now. So just right sizing based on the class sizes meaning meaning that last spring when we were hiring for teachers uh we hired based on the numbers that we thought we would have and then when the students actually showed up we had much fewer we had about 200 and some fewer than we had anticipated we were going to come. So we were over staffed by about five teachers which you said. So next year going into the
080going into the fall HR is going to staff tighter on those uh numbers and then that'll take care of that. So these are these are the cuts. These are the the layoffs that are that are being proposed without adding anything to salary. That's correct. Correct. And some will be layoffs and some won't. Right. Some will be vacant positions that don't. So So layoffs is the second layer of this and we'll do in February. Yes. But yes, that's without any salary. HR is already watching for when vacancies occur. um if there are any of these positions that we're looking at, they won't be built, right? So to eliminate a layoff, right? And we believe there will be some opportunities to do that. So the layoffs will be we we feel at this time fairly minimal by
081the time we get into this. I just I just want to point out how I appreciate how in the past when that has occurred, you guys have found those people the right positions that weren't being filled or that needed to be moved around from those that retired or etc., etc. I think that's that just shows foresight within your your department. Okay. So, this is what what the numbers look like um when we take all those assumptions that we tal I talked about um and put into place. So um you will see that revenues are going to drop pretty significantly next year and this is the combined this is the combined general fund unrestricted and restricted all together. That in mind um and we're going to continue to deficit spend and so I peel off the
082unrestricted deficit spending. Um and with these reductions included of the 1.25 25 million were able to maintain that deficit at you know around 9 or10 million dollars. So that's important. We don't want that to grow out of control over time. So we're able to um keep this stabilized. So that that's a that is definitely um a positive thing. Um we will continue to monitor again as the January governor's budget comes out. Um we will be prepared um to make additional reductions right if needed for 26 27 um as we get closer to that year. But at this point in time this is what we we think's needed um across the three-year multi-year projection. So these are with the the the new the colas, right? Yeah. And so those are included in our in our outears.
083These numbers are going to change, right? No, I know. I know. because because that stuff changes but the 2.93 the LA couple weeks ago said the cola is 2.46 46. So that that's dropping already, right? But right now we're using 2.93. So that shifted on us last year. If you remember the cola at this time was like 4% and now it dropped to one. That was huge. That was a huge drop that we had to adjust for very quickly. Um right now we're anticipating that the changes for next year to be hopefully smaller than that. Um but we're going to make adjustments as Okay. I just wanted to make sure that those are included in the ongoing in the ongoing revenue and it's and and that's okay. Yeah. But then but then that changes and
084then everything changes. Yeah. So Okay. changes. Yeah. That's why those assumptions are important, right? They're detailed. They haven't written in the full report. Um and we we make adjustments as those things change. This is just if everything as we know it today holds, this is this is where we are, right? Thanks. Okay, so this is just uh graphically to show where we were historically with our any balances and our reserve percentages been holding pretty steady the last several years around 10% projecting that to continue for this year and next year and then drop in 26 27 if everything stays as we assume it is today. All right. So we want to a little bit before we finish this up tonight about our LCFF revenues and how the bullet projections and declining enrollment um declining ADA
085impact the multi-year projections. Sorry, sorry, sorry. Just um before we move on to that um so this this 6.6 in year three that does are we including the restrictions or no? I'm I just want to make sure the Are you talking about the commitments? Yes. No, the commitment. It doesn't include that. Okay. Get out to that third year. Um there with with one exception, we always um hold back any um school site donations, okay? and use of facility revenue because those people paid to use a certain school site and we need to use those revenues to maintain the field or whatever it is over time. So there's a couple things that we bring in money for that we make sure we don't spend um we give back to those school sites for their donations and
086to the employee. So there's a couple very small but the but the low I think it's down to like a million just under just a little bit over a million for those very specific things by that third year. All the other commitments are will have been used. That $7 million will be used and by that time all the other um commitments that we've set aside have been okay. Okay. So yeah know that's just that's important, right? Over the next two years we're spending that already on what it was set aside for. Okay. Think that it was held aside. Yes. Correct. Okay. Thanks. Okay. So as we look at the current year we got a cola of 1.07%. 7%. Um, and so that does not mean that we got 1.07% more money. Um, the per student
087funding amount goes up by that amount. And then we'll apply it to our much lower um, ADA. Um, we get $226.1 million. Um, and that actually is $4.7 million less state LCF LCF funding that we received last year. Okay, that's why this year is presents a significant challenge. Um, this is the first time in about a decade that we've actually received less funding from the state than we had in the previous year. Uh, and $4.7 million is a is a big number and that is why we are deficit spending. Um, and so we look at percentages, we get a little over 2% less than um as we move forward to 2526. If that poll was 2.93 right the calculation we'll get 1.6 million more which is great but only less than a percent more money
088and then in 2627 if the goal is 3.08 it gets a little better right a little better out there because our ADA numbers start to stabilize a little bit at that point um we get 4.6 6 million and just 2%. So um just something really important to consider is that school district costs increase three and a half to 4% annually just to maintain status quo just to do everything the same we did the prior year. It it costs about three and a half to 4%. So when the state funding received is less than those amounts um your budgets are going to be strained. It's going to feel uncomfortable. um it's going to create operating deficits that reduce your reserves over time. Um so that's why we are recommending um a very modest level of budget
089reduction so we can just try and control that deficit spending as best we can so that we can keep you know paying for the things things that cost are going to cost us more um on the trip. Um, important also to remember that the California state budget is very cyclical, right? We have really good years and that we've just been through about three really great years in the state budget where they were flush with money and they were pushing that out um to schools. Um, but what happens in this California state budget is those very good years are followed by some very lean years. Um and so we are in that now. You can see with these much lower projected colas um we're going to be in one of those downyear cycles um in the
090state. State revenues will absolutely eventually improve um and we will come back up again. Um but we just need to remain cautious and spend conservatively until we experience that rebound again. So, you know, it will not be forever. just a couple of um some tough years that we need to just pull tight and get through. I just have a quick question. When can we expect a report from uh Kevin Gordon's group? So I can request him to come down. I he Yeah, he comes down at our request basically. So we can we can discuss that if that's word others. Yeah. So Erin, if we did not cut the 1.2 million, right, what would our what would our certification then end up being? Um I actually think it would still be positive. Um we'd be closer
091to about 3%. Um the thing that that I would the board with is um any dollar amount that we cut today is compounds over time. Right. Right. So if we say we don't want to cut the million dollars today. We want to wait we want to wait out wait it out for another year. If you wait one more year, you're going to have to cut double that amount. It becomes two and a half million and then it becomes three times that if you wait two years, right, to cut it. So these the numbers just double and triple in the multi-year projection. So um when you know Vicknap was here um a couple of years ago they always say you know cut now the the the earlier you make reductions the less painful it's going to
092be because if you wait it's going to be doubly and triply um more painful because it will have to be larger cuts if you wait. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Erin, so much for that very clear picture and that closing comment. Do I have a motion to approve the 20 242 first interim report and positive budget certification as presented? I'll move to approve. I will second move by member Chamberlain and second by member um Carlson to approve the 242 first interim report and positive budget certification. All those in favor say I. I. Any opposed? The motion carries. 8.9 um resolution number 26 uh-2425 resolution to identify the amount of budget reductions needed in 2526 and those and 2627 Aaron. Okay. So we have a resolution that the um county office asks for when we're making
093budget reductions. The res resolution tonight simply states that the board is um committed to making 1.25 25 million of cuts as we enter 2526 that will be ongoing cuts that will then al such that it will also apply and um to the 26 27 year as well. So in the past when we've passed these resolutions it's been really clear that you know if anything changes or whatever we may not end up needing to do all of these things. Correct. Right. It just means that we will do this if everything stays the way that you just presented it. Correct. That's absolutely correct. Yeah. Yeah. And if if something comes out in January and there's a whole bunch, we will absolutely stop and we will, you know, undo those those cuts. We will not move forward with
094them. So, we can we can adjust that over time. Absolutely. Do I have a motion to adopt resolution number 26-2425? I move to I'll move to approve. I will second. Moved by member mod, second by member Carlson to adopt resolution number 26-2425 as presented. Board members in favor say I. I. Any opposed? Motion carries. As items 8.10 through 8.12 relate to a matter that would impact my renumeration. As a board member of the governing as member of the governing board, I recuse myself from discussion and voting on these items. Thank you. Uh trustee M Martin 8.10 10 first reading of amended board bylaw number 9250 uh renumeration reimbursement and other benefits. Do I have a motion to approve the first reading of amended uh board bylaw number 9250 for discussion purposes? I'll move to approve
095to I'll move to approve. I will second Moved by member Amage, second by member Carlson. Is there any discussion? Yes. I Yeah. Oh, so this was this was your resolution, right, Carlos? So, do you want to introduce it so the people? Yeah. So, when I first got elected to the board, this was uh something that was shared to me by our interim superintendent, uh Kevin Holt, is no longer with us. Um and um when I ran for board, I didn't run for the $400 we get a month. By by no means that was the the motivation. And um but the work that we do and quite a bit of the work like conferences, it's professional development and neighboring districts um don't have to use sick days to go to a conference. If I sent to
096a conference in Escandido, I go to the conference. I get paid by the county office of ed for my service on San Marcos as I do in Escondido. So, it's the same pot of money. Um, until this year, I I I actually stopped even even to discussing it because it went nowhere. We actually voted on it once and it was never on an agenda, so it never happened. So, I just let it rest. Um, if I were to run again, which I probably I don't think I will, but I'll probably be retired. So this will not impact me at all in four years. The only person that it would currently impact would be U. Member Martine and he has reclused himself from this vote. Um what it really comes down to is education code allows
097up to 20 days. In my opinion, I think 5 days is more than enough to go to CSBA, to go on site visits, to go to the welcome back breakfast. It's more than enough. 20 days would be excessive for a certificated employee to be gone from their site. Um, but education code allows up to 20. Once again, I have no skin in the game. Tonight's my last meeting. We're going to be having cake in about 10 minutes. Hopefully, you're going to dinner with your family. And I, you know, my time is up here, but I would hope that the board would really consider this to encourage people who are certificate employees in other districts to run to be a part of this dis for not only voice but representation. So, um, not I don't need
098to say who asked me to bring this forward, but I'm bringing it forward. And, um, like I said, I have no skin in the game. When I've gone to CSBA, I had to use sick days. When we went for on our advocacy tour, I had exhausted my sick days because of COVID. I got COVID four times. So, I had no sick days. So when we went I got docked significantly to go and I was okay with it because it was work that we were doing together. It wasn't my work it was our work. So in moving forward I really would you know this is an opportunity to discuss it's do I think it's um not fair that public or private employees you know don't give their um employees off. I I don't think it's fair.
099I don't That's just me. I mean, I would But this is something that the state legislature decides. Um but as a public employee, we're not in it to make millions. I'm I'm not and I know you guys as board members are not in it to make millions either. You're here to represent and to be the voice of the community. So, this um bylaw 9250 really is about acknowledging and recognizing our certificated employees, which would be teachers, counselors, social workers, um even principles, you know, anyone that's certificated in the state of California. Um ED code allows them up to 20 days. And but the districts, the district where they work has to agree to it. and the district where they serve has to agree to it. And then the two districts have to agree on a
100approved calendar in order to make this legit. So, for example, I can't just decide I'm going to go visit schools one day. That would be on my dime, right? I can't just It has to be an approved calendar that Andy would submit to with the district Y work. So, I'm I'm recommending 5 days. No more than five days. Um, and if you use the five days, great. If you don't, great. It's just it's for me, it's uh it's part of your professional development. And um like I you know, when Andy goes to a conference, he doesn't have to use sick days. When Tiffany goes, yes, she doesn't have to use sick days. So, here we're the governing board and we're having to use sick days. Can Can I Yeah. Okay. So, my issue with it
101is that it's not equitable. That there are people in professional careers that are on the board. It's not just teachers. There are people that have children who can't who would, I'm sure, love to go to all the things, but there's daycare problems. And when you're in a when you're in the private sector, you have to you'd have to take a day off. You do have to use your sick days. And so contractually when you become a board member you do not have to do the board towards you don't have to do all of those things. And so it's hard for me to say yes that this is okay for certificated but it it's but nobody else gets that benefit. And so for me it's not really an equitable practice. And so that's that's my concern
102with it. I hear you on that. I do hear you on that. That's why I step back. Um, but I see that neighboring districts, Escandido have this as part of their bylaws. Vista has as part of their bylaws. Oceanside has it part of their bylaws. The county office of ed has this part of their bylaws. And it's unfortunate that they don't practice equitable things then because it's not fair. This is another form of compensation essentially. This is this is I mean it's literally going under the bylaw of renew renumeration and reimbursement and other benefits, right? So, it is another form of compensation. And I'd like to point out is, you know, we do have certified staff, but we also have classified staff. We have private sectors. Um, we we can have a stay-at-home mom that
103runs for a board or or dad or whatnot. And, you know, there is cost involved in attending every, you know, uh, as Jamie mentioned, the optional uh, you know, the optional events, if you will, uh, for the board. And uh the only required and I think by our bylaws the only requirement um and what we get reimburseed on is the attending these regular meetings. I do understand I do understand where you are coming from but like Jamie said I understand that it's not just the certified staff that would be in that position. And furthermore, if I understand correctly, you're only using your sick days if you've used up your vacation days, right? Um, so there's another Well, that's not the case. Oh, sorry. You can't even using your sick days. Correct. But if you run
104out of sick days, then your pay gets docked. Just like if you ran out of sick days at work, your pay would get docked. Thank you. So where that would where that comes into play then is that is that SMUSD would be reimbursing whatever district there's a certificated person. Okay. For that or that pay. Okay. So that the employee doesn't get docked. But like your company like you would just get docked pay, right? You wouldn't get to Well, I just used medication. Yes. And so that's um but if you used if you had used all that up, what would happen is that would just come out of your paycheck then. and no paid day. Yeah. Correct. Yeah. Yeah. You would just not get paid. And so that's what would essentially that's what this is, right?
105Which doesn't happen. Like you just can't do that in the private sector and take a no payday. Yeah. I mean you can you can I mean but but what I'm saying is I understand the issue but I in order to fix it I can't just fix it for one I can bring myself to fix it for just one segment of the population. So I I can only speak for myself. I had buo sick days until I returned to teaching. I returned to teaching. Being around kids is like being around the sick. Okay. There are incubtors for every illness. I my my resistance has grown quite a bit. But my first few years I burned through my sick days. I accumulated so many as an administrator which I burned through. So for me this would and
106Andres it's a non-issue. he has buo sick days for me where it becomes a problem is that or that it's not necessarily a problem but this is it's education code and so right now it's on the books in neighboring districts and for me where is the equity and the practice so not everyone uses it and I personally this year have not got I still have sick days so I could continue if I were to be on the board use But I don't have one year I didn't and so that's when it became a problem. So when you go through your sick days your docked your your daily rate which the daily rate is very diff rate that the district would be charged and if I could have paid the sub rate I would have paid
107it but education code doesn't allow that. The only way they allow it is if the the district where you're serving has an agreement where the uh the district where you're serving. So it's for me, like I said, I I could have easily paid the sub rate and that would we wouldn't even be having the discussion. But there is no education code for me to reimburse my district the sub rate for professional development on a board that I serve in a neighboring district. So I I think um for for me there's there are kind of two things that I want to say about this one in in principle I agree right I mean typically what you used to see is you know people who served on boards like this where you really don't get paid is
108it was all just like old retired people right because they could afford to you know they're you know they're retired they come and they can do this they're not you know they're not taking days off work they're not dealing with you know I four of us have kids in the district and we're running around and and and doing all the things and then we do this on top of it, right? And I absolutely think that philosophically, right, if if we want to get more people to be involved and participate and do things like this, then there is going to need to be some compensation involved that's that's more than, you know, $400 and then they tax it, right? I mean, it's ridiculous. And so like like in principle I totally agree with with what you're
109saying and also I feel like it would be really difficult to have one board member who gets additional remuneration and no that nobody else is entitled to because there's a loophole. you know, that allows that one person because of the job that they're in, that one person can get additional remuneration that no one else is entitled to. And I think that when four years ago when when I asked for a legal opinion on this, the reason it never really went anywhere is because our attorney basically said, "Can you do it?" Yes. Should you do it? Probably not. because it it they've seen it cause issues in boards and you know our our big thing was we want to try to you know we don't want to do that right like we want to try to
110all be unified and if one person has the ability to get something more than somebody else then it can cause a problem. I honestly I feel like where this probably should be litigated, discuss, whatever would be at the assembly, you know, at the assembly member level where they start talking about remuneration for everybody and making it equal. But I wouldn't be able to support saying, well, yeah, one of my colleagues can get something that no one else can get because I I just I don't feel like it's fair. Um, and I do feel like it's exploiting a loophole. So that's where I'm at on it. Yeah. Well, I agree with you. It's not fair. I I I agree with you on that. But once again, this is edge ed code and ed code. It's it's
111very clear on that it is it's it's legal and I once again our neighboring districts. Um it's used to encourage to people that are are in currently in education to be able to not be docked their sick day if if they if they run out of it. Um, like I said, this year it was not an issue for any of us. Um, our board since San Marcos has been in existence. Um, you know, we've had Alan Brown who was a a teacher. Um, I'm a teacher. Andreas is a counselor. I I I mean, I don't know. I don't know any more people. Becky, she was retired. uh another person had to leave being an educator in San Marcos in order to serve on the board. We can continue supporting the status quo which for me
112if it's okay because the status quo is around us everywhere. The status quo is everywhere. I breathe, eat, and sleep the status quo. That's what so we'd be voting on the status quo and I'm okay with it because my whole career the status quo has governed and ruled. So this is recognizing people who are in education which there's we're talking about three people in the last 50 years who this would have impacted. right now it's one person who is you know a counselor in another district and if I were to run again which I highly doubt I'm gonna be retired so I can go to everything and anything at any time and volunteer but that's not the case right now and I don't I don't want to have to get a substitute I don't want
113to leave my kids you know I I just don't and I don't for me this is it's not fair but I'm bringing it to you because it's education code and it's about equity for for pe for for a very few people. Um, I I'll say like I think the principle of it I think we all agree. Okay, it's it's not fair. The principle we're getting reimbured, you know, like uh Stacy mentioned, we have different diverse folks that are uh taking seats on boards. Um, I'm okay with advocating for a change, but that doesn't mean that um, this is the way. This is the right way to do it. I don't I don't believe this is the right way to do it. I don't think it's the right way either, but this is education code that's
114been on the books since the 70s, but this is optional educ code. This is not this is a we don't have to. We can make a Cobb salad out of every education code if we choose to. We could be here till 1:00, which many school districts are, when the board doesn't agree. I I'm I'm agreeing with you. I'm agreeing with you because this would really impact one person and maybe hopefully encourage another person in education to run that hasn't considered it. So, I I'm agreeing with you. I hear exactly what what you're saying. That's why I just stepped back and chose not to go there. I'm just I don't want to say this is my last harrah, but I'm just wanting to to have us because we've never really talked about this, have us open
115discussion about the status quo and the inequities in neighboring districts that really discourage people like me and Andress to run. It's like Cinderella. You can't go to the ball unless you have XYZ. Why? Because the stepsister say it's not fair for you to go. I mean, but Carlos, okay, I have no more discussion left. I have no more discussion left. So, I'm just letting you know this is about not me. I'm I have no skin in the game. I'm bringing it forward to you because it's about access because and equity where that's what we hopefully we've stood for and I continue feel like we do. But this is about access and equity based on education code. an education code that neighboring districts do respect and follow and any any education code can be be interpreted
116differently. So I see where you're coming from. I respect where you're coming from. I'm glad that we had this discussion because it's was long overdue and my feelings haven't changed about any of you. So So you know. Okay. But now you call So now you have to call for a motion. All right. There's no action to be taken on item 8.10. That was the first read. So, if there's no further discussion, the board can move to 8.11, which is a waiver of the second read because the board uh board bylaw 9310 requires a first and a second read, but you also have the option to wave a second read so that you can move on to item 8.12 and take a vote on this item on this issue. So, we're now at 8.1 if the
117board chooses to move to 8.11. Okay. 8.11 waiver of second reading of amended board bylaw number 92.15 in accordance with board bylaw 9310. Do I have a motion to wave the second reading? So moved. Second. Okay. 8.12 adoption of the revised You need to take a vote. Sorry. Vote on. I have a mot. You have a You have a motion in a second. Oh. Moved by member Carlson, second by member Chamberlain to wave the second reading uh of amended board bylaw and 9250 in accordance with board bylaw number 9310. Board law. Our board members in favor say I. I. Any opposed? Motion carries. 8.12 adoption of revi revised board law uh renumeration reimbursement and other benefits. Now we have to now you have to ask for a motion for this. Do I have a motion
118to adopt the revised board bylaw 9250? Okay, you can move it yourself, but um I'm not going to move it. I'm just glad that we had this discussion. Um, once again, we all live in the status quo. As women, you live in the status quo. You live in the shadows of the status quo of society, but you are all leaders, and I appreciate your leadership and rising above the status quo. And I as men of color, we live in the status quo every day. But Carlos, this only really works for the men on the board, the ladies. So, I'm going to Sure. If you're certificated, if you are certificated Yeah, Mr. President, forgive me. Yeah, the forgive member Carlson. The the the item item 8.12 has not been moved. Yeah. Right. So, it's not on
119the table right now. It failed to move forward for a motion. And so, now we're going to move on to consent. Correct. All right. 9.0. I just want to say a few more things before we close tonight. Tom, thank you for all your leadership behind the scenes keeping us on uh ma making sure that we are always on task and all our technology is working. Thank you, Amy. You've been an amazing addition to this whole team as our PIO. You um have put San Marcos on the map from the small little town, little chicken town that it's been known for. And you know, you got us our many, many recognitions. continue doing that great work. And in closing, Susie, um you keep us in line, you keep us focused, and um you're the boss of
120Andy and us. And uh I'm so grateful that you're in your role and position. And um I'm going to miss you, but I know you're going to continue doing great things and um continue doing professional development in the county in your role and training other uh superintendent assistants. So, thank you. All right. Consent agenda. Do I have a motion to approve the consent agenda for discussion purposes? Moved by member Ahmad. Uh, second by member Chamberlain to approve consent agenda for discussion purposes. Are there any discussions? Moved by member Chamberlain, second by member Ahmad. Uh, board members in favor say I. I. Any opposed? Motion carries. Closing items. The next regular board meeting will take place on Thursday, December 19th at 6:30 p.m. in the media center of the North County Regional Education Center, 255 Pico
121Avenue, San Marcos, California, uh 92069. This meeting is actually before you adjourn, can you recognize our uh former student board member, Abby? future um San Marcos Unified uh board member, Abby Koko, who was our student representative for San Marcos High School and uh I love seeing all your wonderful posts on LinkedIn and going to the UN and um in Switzerland. She interned in Switzerland. So, can thank you for coming back this last two Christmases to come see us and say hello and sit here at this very boring board meeting. Yeah. Meeting a journ.