001good evening today is February 4th 2025 welcome to the San Marino Unified School District Board of Education meeting here's our board President Joseph Chang hi good evening uh tonight uh we are have a special Board of Education meeting uh start at the uh 6 uh five all meeting of the board of the education are open to the member of the public and this public notice as a confidential crosssection as follow as Allowed by the law member of the public May address the ball as outl in the public comment section of the agenda the audience of all meeting is a recording and a member of the public may be held liable for any sentance or the otherwise Deary statements in consideration of the PO and the member of the audience please turn off silence your cell
002phone while in the B room the sanino UniFi School District encourag those with a disability to participate fully in the public meeting process if you need a disability related modification or accommodation including auxilary eight or service to participate in the public meeting contact the assistant to the superintendent at the j d e l a t o r r e at s md. us or call 626 299 7,000 extension 1310 at least 48 hour before the schedule Bo meeting so that we may make every reasonable effort to accommodate you document provide to a majority of the Board of Education regarding a open section item on this agenda will be made available for public inspection in the district office located at 1665 West D sarino during normal business hours in addition such writing or document may be
003built on the district website at the www.s smusd.us okay uh right right now let's call to the order uh Mr song I uh Miss n here M Ryan present Miss gear here Mr Chen here uh right now let's do the pred of Allegiance please stand up I I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all okay uh next uh two we approve of agenda tonight can I have a motion motion to approve second any second uh those in favor no no call uh Mr song I miss Lamb I miss Ryan I I miss gear hi Mr Chen I motion carry the public comment the board of education has adopted board policy 932b to ensure
004the public right to be heard in any matter pertaining to the sarino uni High School District person who wish to provide a public comment we have a three option to submit the public comment uh first submit to a online form second request to speak during the meeting beer room three request to speak during the meeting in person via the public commment car first submit through a online phone the public May submit the public comment for the open or Closs section on February 4 2025 from 11 a.m. so 3:30 p.m. comment receive during the time will not be read during the meeting but will be provided to the board of education do do we have a we don't have any members online okay uh request to speak during the meeting via The Zo during the public
005comment the meeting will posst for one minutes to take a request to speak the right hand function is used to take a request during the public comment period for online attendee press the raise hand icon to add yourself for the C for phone attended D the star night the speak the speaking order will be determined based on the order of the request received Mr sh there are no attendees there are no attendees okay skip it okay and next is request to speak during the meeting in person via the public comment do we have any there are no attendees okay thank you per uh next let's go to the a uh I think uh yeah no coming car so let's just go to the four uh po study section Dr dor yes thank you president CH
006members of the Board of Education investive team um we are here this evening uh in response to a board request to go over um our board policies review them and to um determine whether or not there are any updates that need to be made by the Board of Education um accordance with good governance standards the board of education is really responsible for three major functions one is hiring and managing the superintendent the other is developing the school district's vision and then the third is developing Schoolboard policy so this is a very important function and one that we need to um really pay attention to and so what we have done is we have um pulled together all of the board bylaws in the 9,000 Series and to make it as easy as possible to to
007be able to review these policies um what we have done is we have put together the csba which is the California school boards association's recommended policies which are reviewed by their lawyers their attorneys um and we have compared them to our existing board adopted bylaws in the 9000 Series we have identified the differences between the existing policies and cba's re mended policies um which I'm going to cover with you this evening so what you will see up on the screen tonight are the um recommended policies that come from California school boards Association what you have in your folder is a copy of the existing board policies that have been uploaded and are available online through our gamut system um so if you go to our website you're able to look locate our existing board policies
008online and that is what you have in your folders this evening um but we're going to really focus on the changes between the two um which I'd like to express my sincere uh gratitude and appreciation for uh Jennifer delatori who worked uh literally hours on comparing uh existing to proposed and highlighting them so we're going to cover each of those areas tonight and and what we go through this evening should be considered a first reading of these policies so that when we're done with our board study session this evening we can bring them back to h a future meeting in the form of a second reading and Adoption of these policies we really believe that it is important that we update all of our uh policies and make them available um not only to the
009board of education online but to our public online so with that we're going to go ahead and get started if you'd like to pull up the first policy we have before for you this evening board bylaw 9010 public statements again what you're seeing on the screen is csba sample District policy most Boards of Education um in the state of California have just adopted the recommended policies so if you go online uh to and you look at board policies in other districts you're probably going to see something that really mirrors um the csb uh csba recommended so we have highlighted highlighted line number 11 where it says board spokesperson um the difference between our existing policy and the recommended policy is that line 13 through line 15 um adds uh with respect to a specific issue
010or topic other representative as designated by the board or board president I'm going to read that whole paragraph so you have context all public statements authorized to be made on behalf of the board shall be made by the board president or if appropriate by the superintendent or with respect to a specific issue or topic other representative as designated by the board or board president this Clause relates to um any kind of media inquiry any kind of uh press that would show up on a a School site um all of our principles and assistant principles and directors have been trained that um there are two spokespersons for the school district the board president and the superintendent unless um it is they're giving given permission either by the board president or the superintendent to speak on behalf
011of the school district so that's what that means so sorry sure then it just says board spokesperson so does that include districtwide I mean that's what I'm yeah so hear so a board spokesperson let's say that the president is out of the country um another board member could be tapped as a board spokesperson on behalf of the board President right which is what we have done in the past and that person would be speaking on behalf of the Board of Education okay and on behalf of the district got it okay thank you for asking that um let's move down to lines 20 and 21 um this is a simple change you see that um the the words or by law um and then the government code section are listed here those are missing from our
012existing policy and so we're suggesting that we should add them um to be in compliance with the csba recommended policy so moving down to line 23 statements by individual board members line number 28 through line 30 um this is giving an example I'm going to read the whole paragraph quickly so that you have context when speaking to community members members of the public or the media individual board members should recognize that their statements may be perceived as reflecting the views and positions of the board board members have a responsibility to identify when a Viewpoint is held by an individual board member rather than the board as a whole for example a board member may include a disclaimer on the board member's personal social media account that the board member is expressing expressing personal viewpoints and
013not those of the board or the district and and that's pretty important if you do have a social media account to make the distinction between your personal views and those that are held by the board Dr delator I I find that this um entire public statement um bylaw is very important and it's really important um not only for board members to remember kind of uh the chain of command and how we need to represent the district as a whole but also it confuses the public when different people are speaking on similar matters and so that's really important and I I know our cabinet is very well aware because sometimes the in the confusion we actually add to compound whatever might um be of concern for our parents so for our parents in community this is
014a really really important one to recognize that the board president speaks uh for the board and then um you are acting as our secretary and you represent um the school district yes thank you thank you good point um lines 32 through 34 board members who opt to express their opinions on District matters whether in person or online are expected to conduct themselves in a respectful courteous and professional manner and to model good behavior for district students and the community so this again is csba language um and it's in the csba recommended policy so this is board bylaw 910 public statements a first reading are there any questions comments or um modifications that the board would like to recommend at this time any question okay no okay so we can move on to the next policy
015and the policy you now see before you is by law 912 board member electronic communications um you can see that our existing policy on electronic communications is um has been uh I don't have it in front of me Jen do you have the date that our existing policy was adopted um March 13 2018 okay 2018 and the CSP ba recommended was last um updated on September 1st 2024 so it is far more recent and relevant the governing board recognizes that electronic communication is an efficient and convenient way for board members to communicate and expedite the exchange of information with each other District staff and members of the public board members shall exercise caution to ensure compliance with the brown act the public records act and other applicable laws so this language was not in our
016exist board bylaw and should be um as you all are aware we are dealing with a considerable increase in the number of public records requests that we receive uh frequently and also um making sure that we are all complying with the brown act in public meetings is critically important as well so I think it's a good reminder um for everyone moving down to uh Dr territor can you uh for the line seven can you explain f May uh the insure comprise for with the BR ad yeah give sure so um there are um instances where board members are prohibited from having what we call serial meetings so a Serial meeting when you're communicating through email as an example that would be one um example of an electronic communication let's say you as the board president
017reached out to um vice president Gil and you said uh next Tuesday night we have a regularly scheduled meeting and we're going to have uh this topic on the agenda what is your opinion of that topic and let's say that she gave you she responded told you what she was going to vote she's going to vote no on the item right yes um and then you said well could you reach out also find out what uh what uh clerk Ryan is thinking about the same agenda item and so then pres uh vice president Gil reaches out to clerk Ryan and says what do you think about the same agenda item and she says well I'm GNA vote Yes and and so she explains why right the three of you now um which is a majority
018of the board have engaged in what you call a Serial meeting you're talking about something that is going to be or is agendized on a a meeting and you guys are discussing how you're going to vote on that issue and you can influence each other outside of the public process which is a violation of the brown act and so that is an example of a serial meeting that would take place on electronic communication same thing can happen in text messages right um so Mr Chang as president you could talk to One board member but when you talk to another board member um about the same item that is on an agenda um that will will be voted on in a public meeting then you're violating the brown act so that's one example okay thank you
019you're welcome so moving down to item subsequently as well even if um president Chang had only contacted one board member but that board member turned around and contacted another board member then it's still a Serial meeting and just to add um on this electronic communication not only on emails texts but also on social media uh we've had an incident where you can just click on an emoji like over a topic that perhaps parents have been discussing you like it Mr Chang on a separate platform likes it and then you know Miss lamb likes it and there you go we've all conferred publicly that we're all gonna yeah how you feel so just being careful and cautious and recognizing that's an area that the brown act covers to ensure that the public um uh has us
020acting in a way in a manner that is respectful of uh transparency as well as um I don't know it I want to say um that we are we hold to the highest Integrity yes absolutely agreed and that's the purpose of the brown act the brown act um really requires public officials to engage in deliberations in front of the public out in the public so so the public can see how these decisions are being made why they're being made and so closed door conversations are not permitted uh whether they're happening in person or uh through electronic communications okay so looking at lines nine through 11 the only change here is adding uh the government code citation um lines number 17 can you scroll thank you 17 through 24 board members May engage in separate conversations
021or communication with members of the public on a social media platform to answer questions provide information or solicit information regarding a matter that is within the subject matter jurisdiction of the board as long as a majority of the board does not use the platform to discuss among themselves any business of a specific nature that is within the subject matter jurisdiction of the board and we just talked about that and gave examples additionally board members are prohibited from using digital icons thank you uh board member Ryan such as likes or emojis that Express reactions to Communications made by other board members regarding matters within subject matter jurisdiction of the board and there's a government code citation there so that is you were um right on right on spot there right on target um May I um
022I think we need to add like what Shelly was saying too what if it's a third party a parent ranting or or praising uh an employee right so and and their contracts coming up or ranting about something that happened I think we should also include any matters within the subject jurisdiction like made by anybody do you understand what I'm getting at not just board members who post but oh okay we can't we can't show we're agreeing with a parent or another employee unless that's okay unless that's here I mean um no I hear what you're saying so instead of it just being um Communications made by other or members of the public yeah right okay so let's add um do you have editing capability qua or Jen one of the two of you yeah can
023you add um agree or where it says Communications made by yeah we need to make sure that the majority of the board agrees with this but Communications made by um other board members or any members of the public yeah so add after board members put your cursor after the word members on line 17 on line 23 after board members or any members of the public any member yeah and then can you underline that or any members of just underline that one section one line so we know what we've changed thank you okay uh moving down to lines 2 or were there any other questions or comments or concerns about that area if not we'll move on okay lines 26 through 28 board members shall make every effort to ensure that their electronic communications conform to
024board bylaw 9010 public statements and shall forward any complaints or requests for information to the superintendent in accordance with applicable board bylaws so and you're all really great about doing this thank you so much um when there are complaints about Personnel um issues of concern about facilities anything like that um they should be referred to the superintendent for handling um that way you don't get involved and parents don't expect you to you know handle that um you guys are are the the what and we're the how right so you guys develop the vision and we carry out your vision so um you shouldn't get involved in um the administration of the district that's our job to do on your behalf but you can certainly refer those things to us for handling and we will um
025handle them expeditiously okay any questions on that any question okay if not we can move okay to the next one um so we're not yet done with this one right [Music] um a minut where were we lines 30 right yes okay line 30 through 33 to the extent possible electronic communications regarding any District related business shall be transmitted through a district provided device or account when any such communication is transmitted through a board member's personal device or account the board member shall copy the communication to a district electronic storage device for easy retrieval um so board members should make sure that they separate their personal Communications from their District Communications and the reason for that is um the public records you don't want people um asking you for all of your Communications on your private
026cell phone um or your private email account and as long as you don't mix the two you can say I don't have any District um related Communications on my um text account or on my um personal email so then that won't be a problem and it protects you and it protects your privacy so three out of the five are active parents in the district I personally use my personal email when I'm emailing with a teacher or that's okay because that's you have rights as a parent that's okay that is not I was trying to keep those separate so I wasn't trying to see that's that's your your mom role and responsibility which is your personal life your elected official position has to do with uh District governance okay and so as long as you're not
027mixing those to you're you're fine um Okay so where am I lines 35 through 36 this bylaw does not apply to board member electronic communications not related to District business or not conducted by a board member in the board member's official capacity so for those of you the three of you that have children in our schools you have your parent hat and your board member hat and so um they're two separate roles that you have and as long as you keep them separate you're fine okay any questions concerns or can we move on to the next policy okay next is uh byw 910 thank you yes uh bylaw 9100 is organization um so lines six through eight um we're adding during all other years the meeting may be held on any date in December but
028no later than December 20th and then the Ed code citation and this is for um the annual organizational meeting which we're always in compliance with and just for context I'll read the whole thing each year the governing board shall hold an annual organizational meeting in any year in which a regular election of District board members is conducted the organizational meeting shall be held within 15 days following the second Friday in December after the regular election so we we do that um and Jennifer delor is an expert in making sure that we're complying with that Ed code um lines 10 through 17 this is absent from our current policy during any year in which a regular election is conducted the board at the regular meeting held immediately prior to the the second Friday in December shall
029select the day and time of the organizational meeting for any other year the day and time of the organ organizational meeting shall be selected at the last regular meeting held immediately before the annual meeting on behalf of the board the superintendent shall notify the county superintendent of schools of the day and time selected within 15 days prior to the date of the annual meeting the superintendent shall notify in writing all board members and members elect of the date and time selected for the meeting and that's an code uh 35143 and we do provide you with the calendar of all the board meetings and it complies with this section any questions on that okay we can move to the next okay oh hold on we're still here um on election of it's still within the organization
030policy sorry Joseph um so let's scroll down so on the election of officers um we have option one and option two so option one through csp's uh recommended policy says the board shall each year elect one of its members to be clerk SL vice president this member shall be one who previously has not served in this office unless all board members have previously served in office after serving one year as clerk vice president the elected member Shall Serve one year as president of the board that's option one option two um which is what we have in our current policy and is what I recommend option two just says the board shall each year elect its entire slate of officers I think option two provides the Board of Education with the most flexibility because we don't
031know um you know what the future holds and we have had some turnover on our board in the past um as an example we had a board member who was elected served six months and abruptly quit and then we had to um appoint a board member to replace that individual and then we had another who um who left so it think you give yourself as much flexibility as a board to determine your slate of officers um depending on the circumstances around you and you don't paint yourself into a corner by using option one which is just cookie cutter standard you know this is how it goes no matter what yeah so that's up to you though you're the board I think that's absolutely correct because at one point um we only had three board members
032and um even if we all filled a position there were still you know like who is nominating who right so I just think that um the flexible one is option two and I think we need to go with that okay great does anyone have any other I agree with yeah I like to as well okay okay perfect okay so we'll keep uh two and option one is stricken um moving down to line number 50 this is what csba had in their recommended policy um no board member Shall Serve more than blank consecutive years in the same office and I think that's like saying you know if you're president for you know you can't serve more than six years as president or five years as president or whatever and you you don't even have to have
033this in your policy again if you want flexibility um because at some point you may want the same person to be president for longer for some unspecified reason I don't know um this doesn't say I I mean this this kind of paints you into a corner also depending on you put in there but it's up to you yeah I think we should leave it up to the board to decide and not have the language in there dictate only because as a board um there are circumstances and needs uh for instance um Co yeah uh the um hiring of a superintendent there may you may want some uh transitional period uh for the superintendent also bond election time times uh partiel tax and then there are some times of uncertainty so sometimes you may not want
034to have that person leave the leadership role if something may take one or two years it just depends I think the board should have discretion that's just my thought rather than saying can only do this and then that's it and since you have to vote on who's the president anyway um you're not really losing anything to Omit this because you all as a board are making the decision on who's President every year right so any other comments or concerns on striking that strike strike okay striking it yes okay let's strike that okay now we can move on thank you okay okay next let's go to the by 9124 okay attorney yes this is um the CSP recommended policy on attorney it was last updated um in 2023 so it is more updated than ours um
035the governing board recognizes the complex legal environment in which districts operate the need to provide legal representation for the district and the importance of reliable cost effective high quality legal advice and services in order to meet the district's legal needs the board May appoint legal counsel and fix and Order pay paid legal council's compensation as an employee or as an independent contractor in this is Education Code 3504 1.5 um the board may enter into independent contractor service agreements with law firms attorneys and private practice and other public or private legal service entities and there's the Education Code citations there and the government code citations the board also supports pursuing collaborative legal efforts with other districts as well as other governmental or government agencies as appropriate um see that section really referring to you know if
036this if the selpa had a legal claim you know we would come together as a a group of districts to file that claim also um we have a jpa that covers multiple districts and provides uh legal support and services um to San Marino as well any questions on lines 4 through 17 okay uh for this uh chapter I I like to uh share the the previous uh experience uh with our board member you know one time among the five board member we have a three uh lawyer so I I like uh superintendent to share the when you are the board member and you are also the lawyer how to deal with the issue so that's um yeah that's a difficult thing to respond to but I will yes so I think that um you know
037public education law is a niche area uh of of discipline and expertise and we have um several attorneys that are experts in that particular area of Law and um when you are a practicing attorney typically you have a certain discipline or area of expertise that you focus on and if it isn't public education um then you have to to rely on the expertise of those people who are experts in that area this is what they do all day every day for you know year after year after year and so I have found that relying on the advice of experts in this area is the best practice and even if you are an attorney and even if you are an elected official you should still rely on the expertise of attorneys in that particular area of
038expertise um even Within public education firms there are attorneys who do certain things there are attorneys who specialize in special education law there are attorneys who specialize in labor and employment law there are attorneys who specialize in real estate transactions um all within the public um School District environment and I think that um in the past you know even when you we've had attorneys that are on the board they recognize that they need the expertise of those individuals does that help yes yeah yeah just like the eye doctor cannot fix your arm pretty much right so each doctor has a Specialties and even it has all the Specialties everybody's different I think you you want to reduce your own exposure yes um as well absolutely to um any sort of litigation if you are on
039the board and then also speak giving legal advice I don't think that that um I think it is inom is what I'm trying to say it is it is absolutely in conflict and so I agree with that thank you but like you say so two different hats two different hats I mean I think it gives you a different perspective in your role as a board member but your role as a board member is to govern not to provide legal advice is to you know again hire uh the superintendent evaluate the superintendent develop the vision for the school district and develop policy and so providing legal advice is something that you know public School attorneys should do and I think for the most part everybody understands that thank you okay any more question on the by
0409124 if not let's go I think we have do we have some more under the same one though we do sorry trying to canate that okay um so under retaining legal council lines 34 through 49 um when the district is seeking legal advice or representation the superintendent or design shall identify prospective attorneys firms and legal services uh legal service entities the district may but is not required to initiate a request for proposal to advertise and solicit proposals for legal services and evaluating the prospective attorneys firms and or entities the board and superintendent may consider the attorney's uh firms Andor entities background experience and relevant legal reputation experience advising and representing school districts in California fees and experience of Attorneys At The Firm who will provide Legal Services any attorney representing the the district shall be
041admitted to practice law in California that's the Education Code citation the board and superintendent shall periodically evaluate the performance of the firms and or attorneys and the E efficiency and adequacy of advice the results obtained for the district the reasonableness of fees and the responsiveness to and interactions with the board Administration and community and I feel like that evaluation process is going on all the time so um this is kind of in keeping with what we're currently doing scroll down the may use such evaluations to determine whether to renew any current agreements for Legal Services we have um decided to change firms with respect and this was several years ago with respect to our labor and emplo employment attorneys and uh we have been very happy with the new firm um so that does happen
042uh the board may also con uh contract for specialized Legal Services as appropriate when a majority of the board determines that the unique demands of a particular issue or emergency situation require such representation and again it has to be the majority of the board that is directing that not one board member or two board members has to be three or more um and then under cont contacting excuse me legal counsil um line 60 we're just adding or design may add their discretion to that line um which is the board president or superintendent or design may add their discretion confer with District legal council subject to any limits or parameters established by the board so what this is is allowing is if for some reason um I'm out of town and let's say a special education
043issue comes up and uh I need Dr RoR to be able to talk to the attorney about a settlement uh proposal that comes through um it allows her as a designate to do that and we have that's been our practice anyway so this is just memorializing that in policy uh moving down to line 66 um we're just adding the word superintendent which is absent from our current policy individual board members other than the board president may not seek advice from District legal council on matters of District business unless so authorized by the superint tenant the board president or a majority of the board so when you're board president you can uh you are the spokesperson for the rest of the board um and that is the person who can have the conversations with legal counsel
044unless um the board president decides or the superintendent decides that it's more appropriate for let's say there's a subcommittee um comprised of two of you that are working on uh a particular issue let's say that we were engaged in a uh real estate transaction and we wanted um uh uh board member lamb to be involved because of her expertise in real estate and um board member Gil because of her expertise in real estate to be a subcommittee and we wanted you to talk to the real estate attorney right I mean it would need to make sense and that's what we have done in past practice okay um so this is because the attorneys represent us in our capacity as a total board not individual board members absolutely correct as we've kind of um maybe seen
045some confusion in the past yes that is absolutely correct yes yeah and it's it's really important that we emphasize that it should go through uh appropriate channels instead of you know I'm reaching out to our attorneys or whatever it has to be um so run through by our president and or yourself should be included um rather than me contacting them because we all have the same information right and it should be um that you know the majority of the board really has already authorized that the board president even contact the attorney right so so you're not getting carved out of any conversations you're a part of that you understand why it's happening and what we're doing um it's just that the board president is really the the spokesperson representing the entire board as you stated
046thank you you're welcome okay so is this okay yes okay so we're moving on to board bylaw 9150 which is student board members and um we were just bringing this up I think about I think vice president Gil uh brought this up and this basically clarifies that issue um this would add to our existing policy in the highlighted area is um student board members may this is lines 8 through 10 student board members May at the board's discretion receive elective course credit for service as a student board member based on the number of equivalent daily instructional minutes for the student board members Services provided so that is an option but it's not necessary and we haven't done it in the past so I don't know whether you want to include it or not but it
047is an option um they do typically serve for a full year um but normally their schedule is already full and they're already you know good with their electives so I'm not sure that it fits with um San Marino's schedule I I sort of disagree with you in that sense because I feel like they take so much of their personal time here at late meetings and I think that that's definitely worth something plus they are definitely learning about governance um MH and it's at the discretion I mean the high school would probably have to create some sort of thing but when you're looking at um you know registering you get priority based on your unit and so I do think it's worth something if you if you guys want to add it it's it's doable it's
048in the Ed code it's available so credit for like social science or civics or what what I'm not clear just like extra credit kind of that mean she can she can only have to take five classes not six classes in the year when she's in the school I think it would just be just like extra like taking a zero period a zero period kind of thing yeah like a zero period or you know like a I think they should be entitled to it honest or they get graded not that they get graded it's just like an extra credit no credit no I I tried to figure out what kind of benefit they can have will increase our pool of applicants that I don't know how large the pool we we don't have any problems in
049getting students being on the board we don't um I I just see like when you're talking about entitled to reimbursement mileage and all of that um I'm wondering though um only because um I don't know if this is like a position that that you know they represent their student body and then to say they should get entitled to be reimbursed I don't think you're read sorry to interrupt I don't think you're reading it in this in this just for mileage right you're saying mileage in the same extent as other board members so if we have her go to a conference or we have her go somewhere that's a driving like you know we don't get reimbursed to come to this meeting because this is your work basically well I think the way it reads make
050it seems she is getting or whoever is going attendance at board meeting so maybe it just needs to be outed in some way only just because we just talked about board members being compensated every month and year so I'm just worried yeah but shall not receive compens monetary compensation for attendance at board meetings is that any monetary including mileage if you put that including well no what that's saying is that she's not entitled to receive monetary compensation for attendance at board meetings that she would be entitled to reimbursement for mileage to the same extent as other members of the board but other members of the board aren't getting reimburse so that's why that's hard just eliminate that whole I mean that's my personal because we don't have our student board members going to conferences right
051it's too and you don't you don't get reimbursement yeah and it'll create a lot of work it's kind of convoluted too yeah yeah St that whole yeah section and move on so we're moving down to um line number 18 petition high school students May are you are you sorry uh vice president Gil you're okay with um that credit under like the CT umbrella or whatever I think I am I didn't hear what the consensus was not everybody I I like the credit idea I think it's just it's nice and it's deserving you know there's a lot of time commitment it's we're not like I don't know this isn't a this is not like uh like service club or not that fun Red Red Cross service club or whatever they're with their friends they're here to
052help govern and represent the student body that's their voice and yeah I would still look at that only because let's say we say three hours twice a month that's six hours a month it needs to be kind of equivalent because then we're just padding um credits on a student like meaning with with same for instructional minutes okay so to minute okay so instructional minute like they would get six extra hours per month 180 minutes or something can you go back up quock to that one section that we're talking about like I just want to be careful because a lot of our classes and courses daily instructional minutes yeah for the student board member service provided so it's in there it would have to be equivalent and I tell you what what if we take this
053back to the administration at Sam it's hard for them to keep track and to kind of and to manage the minutes like on a a kids transcript to say okay she gets two units out of five because she's or whatever I just want to be careful because most of our classes are all UC approved calate approved and then to put something in their transcript we need to be really intentional about really what it is we're saying let me ask uh consult with the high school and then bring that information back to the board so that we can make a better informed decision yeah and I just want to make sure it does not negatively affect them in the people transcript because I'm a 5.0 GPS stud there now your GPM 4.8 now you know something
054like that it wouldn't even be a past fa it's just a participation yeah okay so it's not going to be weighted graded anything like that right credit it's like credit yeah okay I think it maybe in L community service you know how the kids service oh they could use it as their hours service service I like that one better okay to the high school about it and Mrs stator will you please make a note that I need to contact Dr Wolf tomorrow to discuss this for service hours service hours great idea um vice president guil no it really is um it's just we also have to be careful yes it has to I mean there has to be the correct framework and definitely just a consistent way to formula of doing it or whatever but
055um good okay yeah please consult with them that it's their it's their school so yeah thank you okay we will do that um so line 18 petition high school students May submit a petition to the board requesting the appointment of at least one student board member we've not done that in the past can we strike that yeah let's strike it yeah which which one Lin 20 through 21 we've not done that and we have it um just that one paragraph so far let's take them through okay lines 20 and 21 strike those two lines oh actually you can you can strike 23 to 25 because it's related all the way down actually yeah section yeah let me see a student board member chosen by yeah you can strike the whole thing if the board doesn't
056want to go through that convoluted process except for the last paragraph right the term of a student board member shall be one year commencing on July 1st however the board May adjust the term of a student board member only if a vacancy occurs or in order to give more students an opportunity to serve on the board I think you want to keep that right the term uh chosen by so how how are they chosen so they are chosen the principal technically approves the student it comes from ASB leadership student body and so um the ASB coordinator usually um takes them through a process and then chooses and I'm not sure what their specific process is but um they're the ones who present us with the board member well do you want to put something in
057there for choosing and memorialize that's the process or chosen by I think it says um it does have that language in here somewhere right Jen as we go down of student board member under line 19 it does currently have it in there go go up to 19 on the csba oh I'm sorry I'm looking at the district one yeah okay don't have anything in the csba one about the principal or as so let's keep the the on line 19 um for this policy position can you read it oh yeah I see Jen on the district policy yeah the student board member shall be selected by the San Marino High School principal and shall be enrolled in the high school in accordance with procedures prescribed by the board yes so can I think we keep that
058line and can you type that in there under um choosing student board members keep the heading choosing student board members okay and then type that underneath okay got it and that's all we had right on SEL ing student board members in our existing policy correct yeah that takes care of that um I think it's I think it's a good paragraph to keep above it to are we keeping what we have and just adding to in The District in the district one because it also says that um the board may elect to uh uh eliminate I thought uh it says the position I'm thinking that if if there's a problem with the specific student so I thought that the csba hand that uh recommended policy said that once you create the position you can eliminate it
059and if you had a problem with a specific student you would talk to High School administration and they would just they would handle it yeah can can we showen the tumb maybe not one year like every three months or something like that I think that might because challenging because for continuity's sake I see um we get a more chance to the student to experience more the the high school um with everybody's schedule I mean it's just been one per year I see um to have a different one come every three months I think that would be yeah it's like ASV it's like ASB a year term right yeah I should be the board was like a part already ASB already and So within the ASB they can take a t to come to the board
060like that because that's different than ASB story because they already in the ASB yeah no I I um Joshua I I really appreciate that um you want to look at opportunities for more more students and for equity and inclusion and all of that however uh I just want to remind everyone that the school board is here to conduct business for this entire school district and say we read something like today we read all these policy and let's say the cut off was tonight was the last meeting and in two weeks from now there's another meeting right and a new uh ASB student comes in she's not going to know we read all this in first uh reading she's not going to know uh what we voted on and why we had that discussion or he
061and so it I agree with what you're saying Linda about continuity but I also want to make sure that there is no disruption to the order of business here right it it it is a sampling it is an ability for students to be civically engaged and to be in this leadership role but also um this is is a this is running of a school district and it may not be the right place to offer those leadership yeah um but I like your idea about giving more um opportunities it's just the superintendent advisory Council yeah that really good 22 kids superintendent um advisory Council and they're all very engaged and very communicative so it is a great opportunity for them thank you yeah thank you all of you okay so um uh but back to uh
062vice president Gil's comment about the paragraph before I'm sorry could you repeat that the paragraph before and our existing I'm sorry we weren't listening to you I thought she made a good point but I I nobody knows what you said I I IED the board has created a student board member position that shall remain in effect until the board by majority vote of all board voting board members approves a motion to eliminate the position yeah in the event the board has eliminated the student board member position the district's high school students May petition see we have petition in here already yeah for a board student member right so historically since the position was created we've not had a problem and it's been fine so I think that's where that other language for petitions yeah was
063coming in to replace this but um right I think of you choosing student board members a student board member shall be selected by the San Marino High School principal and shall be enrolled in the high school in accordance with procedures prescribed by the board and then let's go down U keep going right there um so all materials presented to board members except those this is important related to closed session shall be presented to the student board members at the same time they are presented to other board members student board members shall also be invited to attend staff briefings or be provided with a separate staff briefing within the same time frame as the briefing of other board members in addition all materials given to board members by the district between meetings except for materials that
064pertain to close session items shall be distributed to student board members and there's an ed code citation so um this just really reiterates and solidifies that student board members are not privileged to access Clos session topics agenda items they can't vote on close session items so we shouldn't be asking them for a preferential vote on any close session items that we're approving an open session um so there's an ed code citation line 62 through 64 that's all we're adding there um and then scrolling down to lines 75 through 79 student board members shall be appointed to subcommittees of the board in the same manner as other board members and shall be made aware of the time commitment required to participate in subcommittee meetings and work um and of the right to decline an appointment the
065availability of subcommittee members including the availability availability of student board members may be considered when scheduling subcommittee meetings so we in the past have not assigned I don't think a student board member to a subcommittee so I don't know that you even want that because our kids are so over scheduled already um I don't know that they would even have time to do something like that we we only uh ask the opinion yeah like one time we have a the stent homework yeah we ask I don't I don't see a problem with leaving it in if that's what they are it it to me it doesn't do any harm doesn't do any harm it's there if you ever wanted to use it but you don't have to like if we want our student board member
066in a sub say Shelby right Shelby oh you have to be the same manner as other board members and shall be so if you need to choose two board members you're choosing but like an example we choose we selected two board members to serve as a subcommittee for the oversight committee right so you don't necessarily pick them right they don't they're they're not owed a spot on the subcommittee is how that you just shouldn't we just strike it then yeah I think we should just strike strike um not May and so it kind of It kind of implies that if you're creating a subcommittee that they have to be to be added um and I think you could always you know if you wanted them to you don't necessarily need a policy always bring you
067could always Dr Richard has students serving on her lcap right Y and so she didn't need a policy for that she just asked them to serve no you're right okay so we could strike that and it's really important we always want to include student voice they're included in safety committees they're included in a lot of things um you know debates forums all those things and then they're on your um represented superintendent um committees and and so forth so I don't think we need the language and just being aware that we always want to include them is I think fine okay great um lines 81 through 82 student board members shall be invited to attend all functions of the board such as forums meetings with students and parents Guardians and other General assemblies um do we
068need the policy don't need the policy we can if you guys are comfortable okay I it just creates more work for staff um and it might put more pressure on the kids feel encumbered by that yeah okay um line 84 student board member training um 86 through 89 the superintendent design May at District expense provide learning opportunities to student board members through trainings workshops and conferences such as those offered by csba and other organizations to enhance their knowledge understanding convenient oh yeah they want us to pay for their their trainings yeah of course so um we haven't pulled kids for that in the past but I mean and again if we wanted to we could we don't necessarily need a policy for it but right for instance when we were at the Disneyland one they
069had a separate student governance thing oh yeah but they they sort of ran it like a camp where they had chaperons and they had all this stuff so I mean I I don't think we need the policy either but okay to um are we good with that striking it okay let's strike that um line 91 through 94 superintendent of design May periodically provide information to student board member candidates to give them an understanding of the position once chosen or appointed incoming student board member shall be provided an orientation designed to build knowledge of the district and an understanding of the responsibilities and expectations of the position we informally do this so I don't have a problem with this language and I'm happy to um continue to provide an orientation to student board members we already
070have that language yeah so you w to leave it in there okay um alternate student board member if the board determines that the student board member's Duties are not being fulfilled the board May appoint another student to serve out the term of the student board member if an alternate student board member is appointed the board shall suspend the prior student board members rights and privileges related to service on the board and so there's the you know fix for if something is not going well um but I I have faith in the high school that they're going to pick the right person yeah and and and also um all of our student as long as Mr Chang has probably been on the board 25 years we've always had very good student board members um but there
071may be a time in which from for extenuating circumstances health reasons travel or the like that it could affect the students attendance or whatever you know so that's definitely an you know an area we can look at but I don't think we need a policy I think if something came up we could all um consult with the uh the high school and have an alternative if somebody can't fulfill their duties I also think need to remember that this position is still a minor position I would feel very uncomfortable taking a vote them here to kick them out I think it's and you know kids do a lot of things that they learn from early on so strike that yeah yeah take it out because we don't we can do it in a different manner to
072support the student right that would it's not supporting them whatsoever yeah got it okay and then elimination of student board member position this is something that I think was in the other policy well at the PO agenda it in the one 197 187 or 197 197 107 you mean 107 no no one n that's 107 yeah zero s yeah I was like wait what what okay so one one three to 107 oh okay continue exist until the board but so do you no take it out take I think you could put it's at the discretion of the superintendent and high school principal honestly I think I don't I don't know we just take no policy just take it out because we yeah okay it gives us more flexibility and it supports the student you know
073being able to accommodate what their needs as well okay good great I'm going to step down all right we're making progress okay the next policy uh can you go back to 40 4 the line uh okay they said the turnover stent B member shall be one year right and then however the ball May adjust the I knew you were going to do that Joseph I knew that what what what do you mean however the ball May adjust the turn of a stent board member only if a vacancy occur why well I thought that that meant if a student couldn't serve the full year and they create a vacancy then you can fill it with someone else right so then their term would be the remaining number of months in the year right so in other
074words if you had a student who started in um August and um they they were here August September OCT October they serve three months um and then they couldn't serve any longer because let's say they moved to the east coast yeah then you would have to get another student and change the term for that student to the remaining I think the term should be the the final um board meeting of the year not a year term because um the term of a student board member shall be uh the com um one shall be consistent with the academic year right yeah so first yeah be consistent with the academic calendar um right yeah okay so can you type that in there shall be consistent yeah right so it's kind of August to May Academic Year August
075to May is yes June now it's going to June yes and and also no more than one one the academic year yeah yeah so I have a term limit yeah yeah students um okay I knew you were going to pick that one up okay so at the end of this um okay why don't you say um student board memb shall be limited to a maximum of one term do I even need that policy though either I guess it's fine I am sorry can you repeat that again student board members shall why don't you say Shall Serve a maximum of one term um and then one term is defined as one academic year and then do you still want the language however the board May adjust the term or you want to pick that out you
076want to leave that in there okay so we leave that in there okay so underline that thank you okay this one all right okay let's move to the next one okay by law 9220 governing board elections um so we just have the Ed code citation in the first paragraph um that is being added go down um recalling a board member was not was that not in our policy Jen we did not have that that one we did not have the section in our policy at all um so I'm not I'm not sure if you need it or want it but um a board member may be recalled as permitted by elections Code 11 um 0000 through 11386 to commence a recall of a board member proponents Shall Serve file and publish or post a notice
077of intention to circulate the recall petition is specified by law and any applicable County elections officials directives additionally the recall petition shall be in the format provided by the Secretary of State and include among other things an estimate of the cost conducting the special election is determined by County elections official in cons in consultation with the district within 14 days after the regular meeting at which the board receives the certificate of sufficiency of signatures on a recall petition from a County elections official the board shall order an election to be held to determine whether the board member named and the petition shall be recalled the election shall shall be held not less than um 88 nor more than 125 days after the date that the board orders the election however the election may be conducted
078within 180 days after the issuance of the board's order to consolidate the election with a regularly scheduled election um and there's own election code citation a recall election of a board member shall be conducted in accordance with elections code 11381 through 11386 if a recall of a board member is successful that board member seat becomes vacant and shall be filled in accordance with Education Code section 5090 through 95 and board bylaw 9223 filling vacancies consolidation of election so first let me stop there um this is not like the board initiating a recall this is if the community were to initiate a recall how the board is obligated to respond to it so it's really just providing guidance to the board on what is the legal way that you would respond to um the fact that
079somebody is is trying to recall a board member and I'm sure this will never ever happen here but it's happened in a lot in Orange County and in other areas in California because of the political landscape um so I felt that it was important at least to bring it to you so that if you know it should happen here which I don't think it willever um that the board has a policy that would guide their actions and their responses to that so any questions or concerns about this section okay because it's all in accordance with the elections code um consolidation of Elections the board May consolidate Board elections with the local municipal or Statewide primary or general election in accordance with elections code 1302 additionally if a regularly scheduled Board election held other than on
080a Statewide election date results in a decrease of local voter turnout of 25% or more compared to the average local turnout for the previous four Statewide general elections the board shall take action to consolidate Board elections with Statewide elections in accordance with with the elections code 14051 through 14052 in order to consolidate elections the board shall adopt a resolution and submit it to the County Board of Supervisors for approval not later than 240 days prior to the date of the currently scheduled district election and there's the election code citation when every regularly scheduled Board election is changed due to consolidation of Elections the term of office of incumbent board members shall be extended to align with the next applicable election any questions on that section okay elections process and procedures for each election upon certification
081by the County Board of Supervisors the board shall declare who has been elected to the board in accordance with law a board member whose term has expired shall continue to discharge the duties of the office until a successor has qualified by taking the oath of office election using atlarge voting method board members May reside anywhere within the district's boundaries and shall be elected by all voters in the district the board May review The District's Board election method to determine whether any modification is necessary if the district seeks to change its election method the board shall follow procedural requirements and hold public hearings in accordance with election codes 110 and 2100 through 21150 before adopting a resolution at an open meeting specifying the change and obtain approval from the county committee on School District organization having
082jurisdiction over the district in ordance with Education Code section 509 5019 the election method or trustee area boundaries in effect at the beginning of a board member's term shall be used when any vacancy that occurs during that term is to be filled even if during the term the district has adopted we I think I don't think we need that section 87 through 90 because that would apply to uh trustee areas and we're an at large not a trustey area so I would say strike due to the size of our community and that and then we move to uh line 92 campaign conduct all candidates including C current board members running as incumbent shall abide by local County state and federal requirements regarding campaign contributions funding and expenditures a board member shall not expend and a
083candidate shall not accept any public money for the purpose of seeking elective office however the district May establish a dedicated fund for those seeking election to the board provided that the funds are available to all candidates who are qualified pursuant to Education Code 35107 without regard to incumbency or political preference um not sure we've ever done what is the definition for poty money um so public money is like School District money right we receive public funds um the uh city has public money that they have right so how how about the organization How about if a five 513 organization that give money is that profit no public money would be cities municipalities school districts right um if you had as an example CTA could donate to your campaign if they wanted to right right because
084they're a private organization even though they represent public employees um the police officer Association that's private money um it's a nonprofit organization but it's private money but you couldn't get the um city of San Marino right to donate to your campaign and you can't get Samano Unified School District to donate to your campaign because that's public money make sense yeah okay um so in order to help protect the Public's trust in the electoral process as well as the Public's confidence in the board in the district the board encourages all candidates to sign and adhere to the principles in the code of fair campaign practices pursuant to elections code 20440 statement of qualifications um so we have option one which is um congruent with our current policy which is a 200w limit for our candidate statements
085and then there's option two right clock can you scroll down um option two is 400 words and then I think there's an option three oh No Just option one and two so I think we want to stick with 200 right by by the way for for this option I thought the we are follow for L County or or we can come own I thought you could do either right you just have to pay more to do the 400 right yeah looks like twice as expensive U to do 400 words so we have done the 200 word to keep the cost down so are you good with 200 or you want to I'm fine with 200 okay 200 me too okay so let's remove option two people stop reading after 100 I know that's especially in
086today's day and age that's right okay um option one candidate statement paid by District the district shall pay the cost of printing handling translating mailing and or electronically Distributing candidate statements we're not doing that now right Jen no we're not we're not and I don't recommend we do that um we never had before option two candidate statement paid by candidates it should be paid by candidates um in a district like San Marino so um because if we had you know 10 candidates for can you imagine the district having to fot that Bell um and elections are already expensive for the district District so are you okay with keeping option two yeah okay um so Tai votes in board member elections um option one Tai decided by lot whenever the county superintendent of school certifies to
087the board that there is a tie vote such that it is impossible to determine which of the which of two or more candidates has been elected to the board the board shall immediately notify the candidates who receive the tie votes of the time and place where the C candidates or their representatives should appear before the board the board at that time and place shall determine the winner by lot that's Education Code 5016 um option two Tai decided by runoff election um whenever the county superintendent certifies to the board that there is a TI vote such that it is impossible to determine which of two or more candidates has been elected to the board the board shall schedule a runoff election in accordance with law I think um one is cheaper one is cheaper but I
088mean if we're looking at public funds one is cheaper uh for sure I feel like a tie is probably highly unlikely an exact tie right it is we haven't had it yet because we don't have a um percentage amount you need to win by right so right an exact tie yeah but stranger things have happened in the world which is why this policy exists so you just never know but if you guys are good with option one then we'll go with that what is what's decide by lot you know it's like a lottery like Lottery yeah a lottery like that yeah I the board would have to decide Oh I thought they just vote on it or something yeah but can you imagine the political ramifications option two is like a you do the election
089again right option two is safer option two is safer for sure well option two is also even though it's cost us money it would really reflect like the the will of the people yeah you know right which is what we're here to serve so okay I think I think option two is fine I mean it's not gonna happen yes it's gonna happen right it's not gonna happen but it looks more fair so yeah it does okay let's go with option two thank you they don't just pull their name out of a hat right we you know what that happens with us when we're doing um layoff and we have to assign points because high in seniority date literally we have to roll dice or pick straws it's terrible it's like a loan roulette yeah it
090is it's not but it's our system okay so let's go to the next one this is by law 9223 filling vacancies um and events causing a vacancy this is highlighted the adjudication pursuant to a quo warrant to proceeding declaring that an incumbent is physically or mentally incapacitated due to disease illness or accident and that there is reasonable cause to believe the incumbent will not be able to perform the duties of the office for the remainder of the term so that's one of the um causes and we do not currently have that in our policy um a board member's resignation we've had that a board member's removal from office by recall we've never had that a board member ceasing to be a resident of the district that could happen a board member could move out um
091and still want to serve a board member ceasing to inhabit the trustee area that's that we could strike because we're not a trustee District um a board member's absence from the state for more than 60 days except in the following situations um a upon District business with the approval of the board B with the consent of the board for an additional period not to exceed a total absence of 90 days or in the case of illness or other urgent necessity and upon a proper showing thereof uh for more than 90 days C for federal military deployment not to exceed an absence of a total of six months as a member of the Armed Forces of the United States or the California National Guard if the absence of the board member for this purpose exceeds six
092months do we already we have this language right we do okay so we don't need to go through that because we're gonna then will you go back to the part that's highlighted that we need yes oh so nothing nothing needs to be just that the one in in yellow so is it 60 consecutive days or 60 it's 60 calendar days total it's not 60 business days it's like 60 calendar dat be consecutive it has to be yeah okay okay so let's go down uh and then we just are citing the government codes that these um sections can be found in and then the Education Code um Education Code Education Code eligibility for appointment um are you highlighting that yes that should be highlighted okay so in order to be appointed to fill a vacan on
093the board a person must meet the eligibility requirements specified in law and board by law 9220 governing board elections um this covers what we need to have covered for provisional appointments um when as authorized we we have this in our our existing though right okay scroll down Education Code section okay so that paragraph when as authorized by law the board seeks to make an appointment because of to elect the board by resolution May approve any additional procedures for selecting the person to be appointed to the vacancy and we have done that in the past that gives the board flexibility okay and that's all on this policy are we good this one that's uh okay board by law 9230 orientation um all of this uh in yellow is uh csba recommended the governing board recognizes the
094importance of providing all newly elected or appointed board members with support and information to assist them and becoming effective members of the board incoming board members shall be provided an orientation designed to build their knowledge of the district and an understanding of the responsibilities of their position such orientation may include the provisions of information support Andor training related to board functions policies protocols and standards of conduct as early as possible following the election or appointment of the board members one or more orientation sessions shall be held during open meetings of the board the board president and the superintendent or design shall develop an agenda for the meeting and shall identify resources that may be useful for incoming board members we have not done that in the past we have done a board orientation um in
095the superintendent's office with the executive team and in some cases principles um with followup I don't really think that it would be practical to have one or more board meetings for the purpose of orientation I think it's more meaningful to have the new board member or members um in the superintendent's office with a big you know resource binder or the documents can be provided electronically um and a Q&A an open dialogue can take place in the superintendent's office um on each of the areas that they need to be um briefed on so I would recommend I don't know it's up to you guys I would recommend that you strike 11 through 14 agree as we are complying with that first paragraph and providing orientation um 16 through 23 upon their election or appointment incoming board
096members shall be provided a copy of the brown act and informed that pursuant to government code section 5495 2.1 they must conform to the acts requirements as if they had already assumed office additional information for incoming board members may include but is not limited to board bylaws related to the limits of individual board member Authority the conduct of board meetings and other board operations governance standards for ethical conduct legal requirements related to the conflict of interest and prohibited political activity protocols for speaking with District staff members of the public and the media and Publications on effective governance practices um we are providing all new board members with that information in addition we are um having new board members attend the cspa annual meeting where they go through new board member um professional development which includes
097um raining on the brown Act in addition the superintendent or design shall provide incoming board members with specific background information regarding the district including but not limited to the district's vision and and goal statement local control and accountability plan and other comprehensive plans student demographic data student achievement data District policy manual District budget and minutes of recent open board meetings the superintendent design may offer incoming board members a tour of district schools and facilities and may introduce them to district and School site administrators and other staff incoming members are encouraged at District expense and with the approval of the board to attend the csba um orientation for new trustees I just talked about that Institute for new and first term board members and workshops and conferences relevant to the needs of the individual member um
098the board as a whole or the district we good with that okay we are good with that and we are moving to the next one or training okay this is where it's going to get fun okay bylaw 9240 board training the governing board believes that the board's ability to effectively and responsibly govern the district is essential to promoting student achievement building positive community relations and protecting the public interest in school districts board members shall participate in mandatory ethics training as outlined below and are encouraged to participate in ongoing opportunities for professional development sufficient to help them understand their responsibilities stay a breast of new developments in education and improve governance skills so there was a bill that passed that requires all um school board and County boards to go through ethics training um commencing I
099believe in the 2026 school year so you will all have to go through that um once every two years it is part of the Masters of governance so we've already completed it then awesome right not all of you but yes but right yeah okay so unless a board members term it but you have to go through it every two years so okay yeah thank you uh unless a board member's term expires prior to January 1st 2026 each board member shall complete ethics training in accordance with government code um 53 234 through 5323 5.2 by January 1st 2026 and at least once every two years thereafter once completed the board member shall inform the board president and superintendent who shall ensure that records are retained for each board member's participation in the required ethics training the
100board president and or the superintendent or design shall provide an orientation to newly elected or appointed board members consistent with board Viola 9230 orientation the board president shall work with the superintendent or designate to include funds for professional development and Associated reasonable travel expenses for the board as a whole and for each individual board member in the district's proposed annual budget board members must complete the csba Masters in governance program within their first year of becoming an elected official all board members should attend the annual education conference and trade show legal Symposium for experienced board members board presidents Workshop Brown act Workshop policy update webinars and ethics trainings scroll down individual board members are encouraged to share the knowledge or skills acquired from Individual professional development opportunities with the full board thereby benefiting the board
101and District consistent with board bylaw 9320 meetings and notices board members shall attend a professional development opport opportunity as part of a conference or similar public gathering such as the annual education conference and trade show hosted by csba so long as the majority of the board members do not discuss among themselves other than as part of the scheduled program business of a specified nature that is within the district's jurisdiction so the entire board can participate in cspa as long as we're not talking about um anything that would appear on an agenda and should be talked about uh and voted on publicly so um this policy requires that all new board members um go through the Masters in governance training through csba so uh but within their first year were you aware of that by the
102way okay so it's online it's on Zoom you can do it online on Zoom okay yeah and it's really good I mean it's very helpful it is um in learning you know how to navigate as an elected official okay so are we good with this policy ready uh by the way I have a question uh on the Json for the the district uh staff what kind of the annual training do they do for for from the HR so every year at the beginning of the year they have a series of trainings uh that seems to grow each year um I think we had six or seven this yearning so it is everything from sexual harassment to workplace violence to umand reporting student suici so for this to so not not applying to the school board
103right SE sexual harassment or violence no I I don't issue you trainings no so no unless You' like unless you'd like that we what the for a company I think uh I think they have to do SE sexual har a and yeah TR oh yeah all companies do in the state of California there's so many uh hours that you have to provide of of that type of training every year and we're in compliance with that and and most of our trainings um Dr Rose can tell you are through Target Solutions so our employees do it online and they have to complete modules and so we have really good recordkeeping on who has um completed all of their mandatory training and so we make sure every single employee in the district is compliant I huntt them
104down I have a list of who has not comp and I make sure that they complete it so that there's no one who has not so we're in compliance with the law but thank you for asking that question if the board would like any of those trainings we would be happy to provide them I'm sure Jason wouldn't mind okay so so that's a new law is that we have to get a train every two years is it the ethics um yes that that was a new bill that the governor signed in 20 22 I want to say so so it's it's not like we have a choice we have to do it right yeah we can't just strike it you do not have a choice um County boards and school boards used to be Exempted
105but because of the bill that the governor signed um in 2022 um they're no longer exempt so you do have to do it every two years but we could um we can actually bring a trainer out to the board okay um just like what we're doing you know um on the 14th is it the 14th or the 13th um we could bring a csba trainer out to do it for the board every two years so that you guys all get signed off at the same time not a problem okay we'll make it as as painless and as easy as possible but it also helps you with your 700 form and a variety of other issues um can we go back to 35 the uh that paragraph I feel like that's so specific to it sort
106of limits us and I mean I don't I I understand what they're saying but they're with their words painting us into a corner to only do their stuff and it's there are there are board policies and I don't know that um having like conference um I don't know advertising basically in board policies seems appropriate yeah you could totally take that out so you could say consistent with board with board bylaw 9320 meetings and notices board members May attend professional development opportunities um as part of a conference or similar public gathering period yes put the period after that and take out the rest strike it yeah I can see that I I think you should leave in the part about don't discuss amongst yourselves I think that's important oh yeah okay um after csba yeah okay
107so so 937 yeah take out um such as the annual education conference and trade show hosted by csca and then um put the comma after the word Gathering and then so long as am I making sense probably not but they put a period in there where it shouldn't have been yeah and then take that out and then put a comma after the word Gathering and then so long as the majority of the board members do not yeah that's good and and I think csva does that because of course this is their recommended policies and csba is the the premier um Organization for board members in California yes for the line 27 yeah I guess that's where I was talking about too 27 do they have to attend every year no sound it doesn't say you
108have to it says should so that gives you the option and and not all board members attend every year but most do because it's the only training available to board members um that is you know but if you don't have to attend year do don't you think we should just strike it out and maybe just let I I think we should because we're in education we should encourage professional development and it's the only professional development for board members right so I I it's up to you guys you tell me but I feel like we should be I think it's fine to be in there yeah I don't think we need to strike it it's it says may it says may attend right May attend it says there may ATT 10 right you can't okay but
109um I liked it kept in there only because you need a baseline minimal and you need some growth and you know yeah training because it looks like it's easy right it looks like what we do is easy but there's a certain level of um expertise competence there's a certain level of um almost decorum because of the way in which you conduct yourself to represent the school district so at a minimum there needs to be some training in professional growth right I mean it's not even about um what the expertise of the person you could be high-powered you know CEO you can run a Fortune 500 company but still in education it's very specific on how things work and how things are conducted yes right it's a very different landscape and we're expecting teachers to go
110to professional development we're expecting our administrators to to remain current on um you know their practices best practices and so we want our board to uh remain current as well and to get professional development when and where it's available but again it's not forcing you yeah is okay anything else okay we can go to next okay all right so the next uh board bylaw is 9270 conflict of interest so um all that you do not see highlighted is currently in our policy and what you see is not conflict of interest from campaign contributions is this um entire section uh most of the board sample uh the wording is different in our policy okay but it but we have a conflict of interest um section in our current policy um so do we have highlighted areas
111uh so line 63 Pro campaign contributions is not in our board by law oh this whole section oh that's okay so prior to the district rendering a decision in a proceeding before the district involving a contract license permit or other entitlement for use is defined by government code section 84308 a board member whose Campaign Committee received a contribution of more than $500 from any party or participant to the proceeding or from an agent of such a party or participant in theed 12 months and the party who made such a contribution shall both publicly disclose the fact on the record of the proceeding additionally if a board member willfully or knowingly received a contribution to the board member's Campaign Committee of more than $500 from any party or participant to such proceeding or from an agent
112of a party or participant in the prior 12 months and knows or has reason to know that the participant has a financial interest in the district's decision the board member shall not make participate in making or in any way attempt to use the board members official position to influence the district's decision in the proceeding however a board member may make participate in making or attempt to use the board member's official position to influence the decision if the contribution is returned within 30 days after the decision was made or after the board member knows or should have known about the contribution and the proceeding whichever is later all board members in the superintendent are prohibited from accepting soliciting or directing a contribution of more than $500 to a candidate or ballot measure Campaign Committee from any
113party or participant to a proceeding before the district involving a contract license permit or other entitlement for use is defined by government code section 84308 or from an agent of a party or participant while the proceeding is pending before the district and for 12 months following the date of the district district renders a final decision in the proceeding if the board member superintendent knows or has reason to know that the participant has a financial interest in the district's decision however if a board member or the superintendent does does accept solicit or direct such a contribution during those 12 months but did not do so knowingly or willingly the board member or the superintendent may cure the violation by ensuring that the contribution or the portion exceeding $500 is returned within 30 days of accepting soliciting
114or directing the contribution the board member superintendent shall maintain records of curing the violation for a board member or superintendent a proceeding becomes pending when an item involving the contract license permit or other entitlement for uses defined by government code 833 84308 is placed on a board agenda for discussion or decision or when it is reasonably foreseeable that the proceeding will come before the district for a decision for a party or participant and the agent of a party or participant a proceeding becomes pending when the application is filed with the district or if the proceeding process does not require an application when the proceeding is before the district for a decision or other action the contributions disclosure requirements and restrictions above do not apply to contracts that are required to be competitively bid labor contracts
115personal employment contracts contracts valued under $50,000 contracts where no party receives financial compensation or contracts with another governmental agency and I think this is all covered in the ethics training and conflict of interest um section so let's go down form 700 U by the way for for lo you just uh mention is that this the new version or this this is a new version this is the recommended policy our policy doesn't have this right Jen recommend by csba or csba by csba and it was updated in 2024 ours was updated in 2022 so this one has a lot more info than ours does because of this look very new to me yeah it's uh uh how about you you think the the city council they're going to have to do the same thing with they
116are same thing you you know from the from the uh when you became the candidate for election when you when you collect your donation immediately if over the 1,000 so you you need to report to report yeah so but this one is a 500 yep it's uh updated to 2024 I I don't know is that the the county they will also make a change you know when change it low down to the 500 or it must be because it's um this was updated in 2024 and the government code section is here but we can look into that before we bring it back to the board for second reading can you make a note Jen to um check with um county registar recorder's office thank you okay so form 700 all of you have to fill
117out a form 700 every year each District official shall annually file a statement of economic interest form 700 in accordance with the disclosure categories is specified in the district's conflict of interest code an individual who ceases to be a district official shall within 30 days file a revised statement covering the period of time between the closing date of the last required statement and the date the individual ceased to be a district official additional requirements for boards that manage public Investments any board member district employe or District consultant who manages public Investments as defined by government code 87200 and who has a financial interest in a decision shall upon identifying a conflict or potential conflict of interest and immediately prior to the consideration of the matter do all of the following publicly identify each financial interest
118that gives rise to the conflict or potential conflict of interest in detail sufficient to be understood by the public except that disclosure of the exact street address of a residence is not required not discuss or vote on the matter or otherwise act in violation of government code 87100 for a board member the board member shall not be counted toward achieving a quorum while the item is discussed um leave the room until after the discussion vote and any other disposition of the matter is concluded however the board member district employer District consultant who manages public Investments is defined by government code 87200 may speak on the issue during the time that the general public speaks on it additionally for a board member if the matter has been placed on the consent calendar the board member shall
119abstain from voting on The consent calendar or if the board removes the item from the consent calendar the board member shall abstain from voting on the item in any event the board member shall refrain from discussing or voting on the item however the board member is not required to leave the room during consideration of the consent calendar if a decision is made during Clos session disclose the interest orally during the Open Session preceding the Clos session this disclosure shall be limited to a declaration that the recusal is because of a conflict of interest pursuant to government code 87 1 0 the board member district employer or District consultant who manages public Investments is defined by government code 87200 shall not be present when the item is considered in Clos session and shall not knowingly obtain
120or review a recording or any other non-public information regarding the decision conflict of interest under government code uh 1090 financial interest in a contract and that needs to be oh it was your cursor never mind um going down to line 156 remote interest exception to government code 1090 a board member shall not be considered to be financially interested in a contract in which there is only a remote interest as specified in government code 1091 if the interest is disclosed during the board meeting and noted in the official board minutes the effected board memb shall not vote or debate on the matter or attempt to influence any other board member to enter into the contract noninterest exception to government code 1090 a district official should not be considered to be financially interested in a contract if
121the is reimbursement for actual and necessary expenses incurred in the performance of official duties and the employment of a spouse registered domestic partner who has been a district employee for at least one year prior to the board member's election or appointment or in any other non-interest specified government code 109 1.5 common law Doctrine against conflict of interest a district official shall abstain from any official action in which the district's official private or personal interest May conflict with the official duties pursuant to the common law Doctrine against conflict of interest incompatible offices and activities board members shall not engage in any employment or activity or hold any office which is inconsistent with incompatible with in conflict with or inimical to the board memb duties as an officer of the district can we add in there including
122um any executive board position of organizations like PTA um all those School sites you know Council oh okay because I think here is where you would put like I don't think a trustee on the foundation right would be appropriate to be a board member okay I don't think doing something big with a financial interest such as I I don't know like grad night or like um Carver Carnival you know like those big fundraisers yes okay so um after the period degree I mean yes I it's the appearance of conflict of interests right because boosters it's also the conflict of interest is special treatment not necessarily Financial correct and we need to definitely you know everyone gets the same equal treatment every single student is our student so um I don't know where you want to
123put that kind of language but I think we need to spell it out okay so Jen is your cursor after the word District yes okay yes board member shall be shall not hold any official or unofficial position with boards or committees I think committees might be overstepping because as parents I think we do help in certain ways but I don't think you should head them so I'm thinking of like um the PTA boards I'm thinking of like it's not well uh chair you could say chair okay you know um any offic Jo wants to be on you know book fair committee I think that seems totally we're just not chairing B just not chairing not head not head board members shall not hold any official or unofficial chair or um president executive commit um executive
124board committee chair or executive board wait does this mean like but then you could be president no that's an executive board but can you be like historian like no office title at all each each School site has an executive board that's it's called okay so I'm sorry Joanna what I mean I think we had a board member that was like a historian right so you can't hold any office title is that what we're saying yeah but previously she held the title and then she became a historian okay so you know most of our terms are hold any officer position Bic well exact I think ex yeah officer position officer position right like there's no you can be a member large comma executive or officer um positions right Officer yeah you could say officer or executive
125board yeah yeah take out committee because I think um it's fair to participate um should we be specific and say with um uh School connected organizations or should we say just leave it like that uh open-ended oh well yeah with school oh yeah yeah with school with school school related because I mean look just on boards I mean I think those are direct conflicts we unofficial um chair or executive officer positions with any school connected organizations yeah yeah sure I'm sorry with any school connected getting hungry organizations does that look good or you guys want to word Smith that a little more no I'm no I'm I'm processing and I really think um we need to look at this area again so that um our language is a little no because I want to also
126respect my fellow board members who have children in the sure uh in the in all of these organizations and you know um Mrs Gil pointed out the fact that it's not just the undue influence financially but it's um the other kinds of power in terms of the position that you influence that you hold um so yeah we want to be we want to Wordsmith or or craft that a little better okay so we I would leave it for now there are yeah or you can work on and then just bring it back to us CU confident you could do this yeah concern uhuh I appreciate what sh was saying because I have some concern like School connected organization is so broad too broad yeah because right now like I I hold a position in Girl
127Scouts for example is that a school sepan and policy like Chinese Club is not connected I think um Chinese School not connected right um like things like that I think it's something with San Marino in the title honestly any like 501c3 like the friends of vapa could be considered a school connected organization right um PTA tab is a tab yeah those would be school connected organizations so we have a definition I can bring that definition back but I can also Wordsmith it because we definitely want to make sure that you know it's not going to hurt anyone with respect to their parental rights um because you have the right to be a parent and a board member yeah as long as you're separating those things out but I can see where there might be a
128conflict of interest in signing contracts and and there being you know liability for the district if you're a board member in a in a separate role that signs a contract and then something goes south and you get sued you know are you signing as a board member are you signing as you know that official from that organization so is the board you know going to be liable for an agent of the board signing that contract so those are the kinds of questions I think it's a legal question maybe yeah yeah yeah I can get councel on that too yeah yeah um okay okay so is that is that good for now and then I'll I'll um check with Council on that and we'll word Smith it and then we'll bring it back what I what
129I just remember there's the academic advisory um committees at each School site there's lcap I think that those are undue influence as well because they need to do their work and bring it to the board right so it would be a conflict of interest for you to serve on a committee that's making a recommendation yeah I think it is don't you from yeah is that a rule already no I think that's like an Unwritten just common sense kind of thing but well we thought it was yeah okay okay okay all right got it okay so let me work on that and I can bring it back for our second reading with more information and legal uh definition okay so moving on to line 185 gifts District officials May accept gifts only under the conditions and
130limitations specified and law including but not limited to uh Gifts of travel and related lodging and substenance shall be subject to the current gift conditions and limitations except when the travel is in connection with a speech given by a district official provided the lodging and subsidence expenses are limited to the day immediately preceding day of and the day immediately following the speech and the travel is within the United States number two the travel is provided by a person or agency specified government code 89506 including a government governmental agency or authority Bonafide public or private educational institution is defined in revenue and Taxation code 203 or nonprofit organization exempt from taxation under Section 501c3 of the internal revenue service code Gifts of travel Exempted from the gift limitation as described in items one and two above
131shall nevertheless be reportable on the recipient statement of economic interest form 700 is required by law a gift of travel does not include travel provided by the district for district officials and that's in government code 89506 a question yes so the this policies for uh board member what what is the policy for the School dist employee for U distri for the yeah GI yeah uh it's really the same which in the conflict of interest they were talking about board members and superintendent not being able to accept but but this the the policy they they Define the is a amount right oh are you travel District No No for accept the gift yeah we don't accept gifts we just can't accept gifts the teacher yeah oh that our gift policy 50 $50 and unless it is
132a um group it can be a group a group gift for a coach so if you wanted to give the coach of your soccer team a gift um everybody could contribute to that and I think that's 500 right in policy we'd have to pull that so if there's a policy how to to to cover for this policy well this is for public officials which is in government code yeah um so this is all prescribed by government code for public officials are you asking for board policy on Gifts Mr Chang is that what you're asking for maybe not in this chapter but is that they also have a policy there should be a board policy on that restrict the PO there's a law yeah it it's part of the ethics and the the you know um
133conflict of interest policy and training um board members really shouldn't be accepting gifts inchange for votes or no we we're clear this is this is regarding board members I think Mr changen is looking at yeah we've in the past talked about teachers that accept gifts they're getting employment they're flying to um um destinations they're getting um yeah yeah but they have been doing it and he's asking if I'm understanding Mr CH where is that in our board policy it's in the 4000s right Jason the 4,000 series gives um oh 4,000 yes and we'll get to that um so Mr Jang is not there yet it's not in this section I'm just trying to clarify yes thank you but now it is it's $50 you cannot accept anything um that is of a value over $50
134Jason I'm GNA have to take back that $50 I gave you at Christmas okay or you're gonna have to claim it that's right $49.99 49.99 499 I'm just referring to that chocolate bar I gave him that yeah Canadian Dollars Canadian dollar to add your travel cost to the cost of that so um There are rules that that personnel must follow and we must enforce and we do and we talk to employees about it every year um to make sure that there's no conflict of interest and part of our training you know does discuss how generous and benevolent um our community is and uh we want to make sure that um we're not getting you know gifts and exchange for letters of recommendation to colleges and universities or things like that right just there can't be
135um gifts accepted and then expectations gift so we try to avoid that okay um so moving on honoraria District officials shall not accept any honorarium which is defined by uh defined as any payment made in consideration for any speech given article published or attendance at any public or private conference convention meeting social event meal or light Gathering um and this is specifically for um District officials the term honorarium does not include earned income for personal services customarily provided in connection with the Bon ified business trade or profession unless the sole or predominant activity of the business trade or professional is making speeches any honorarium which is not used and within 30 days after receipt is either returned to the donor or delivered to the district for donation into the general fund without being claimed as
136a deduction from income for tax purposes advice any District official who in good faith believes that they may be subject to the requirements of this bylaw and has questions is unclear or unsure regarding the application of the requirements of this bylaw to any particular instance or situation may seek advice from The District's legal council with the permission of the superintendent board president or majority of the board training unless a board member's term expires prior to January 1st 2026 each board member shall complete ethics training in accordance with government code 53 234 through 5323 5.2 by January 1st 2026 and at least once every two years thereafter as specified in board bylaw 9240 board training are we good with this one okay moving on oh by the way uh Mr song have you SE the form
137700 form 700 you hav't not term long enough to see this yeah no I mean we can give you the example so you can take look okay another train okay training on the form 700 yeah um Jennifer's an expert right Jen okay there's a new system so it changed a little bit okay um let's go to the next policy please okay board bylaw 9320 meetings and notices um what we have highlighted here is what we're adding in accordance with law and is specified in board bylaw 92 board member electronic communications a majority of the board shall not outside of an authorized meeting use a series of communications of any kind directly or through intermediaries including social media and other electronic communications to discuss deliberate or take action on any item that is within the subject
138matter jurisdiction of the board we spoke about this earlier um and it's just reiterating you know the the brown act provisions and how they apply to board member electronic communications um line 22 we're adding superintendent um however the superintendent or design May engage in separate conversations or Communications with board members in order to answer questions or provide information regarding an item within the subject matter jurisdiction of the board as long as as long as that employee or District official does not communicate the comments or position of any board members to other board members um line 20 or I'm sorry 30 um we're adding any doubt about a request for accommodation shall be resolved in favor of accessibility notice of the procedure for receiving and resolving such requests for accommodation shall be given in each instance
139in which the not of the time of a meeting is otherwise given or the agenda for the meeting is otherwise posted and this is to comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act with regard to accessing a board meeting and then moving down to regular meetings um lines 38 through 40 unless otherwise determined by the board the board shall hold blank regular meetings each month starting at blank pm on the blank day of the month uh at the district office board room um so you could could fill that in or you could strike that either way it's usually the the second and fourth Tuesday of the month um starting at 7 p.m. um and so it's up to you whether or not you want to memorialize that in our policy no okay strike it yeah we
140we just follow the current practice Yeah practice yeah no worries okay so we can strike that yeah um at least 72 hours prior to a regular meeting the agenda shall be posted we do that already that special meetings that's all just memorializing what we do emergency meetings we're adding this paragraph the board may meet in close session during emergency meeting so long as two-thirds of the members present at the meeting agree or if less than two-thirds of the members are present by unanimous vote of the members present and that is government code 54956 25 I thought this was the one that um the emergency meetings could not have like superintendent contract or salary or those things right right is so it's all that language is still in there okay thank well so called for a
141disaster right yes say we had a mass of earthquake um that we don't but if we did we might need an emergency meeting to uh make some really important decisions also if there is a safety issue um you could meet have an emergency meeting with the chief of police in session that is one of the um the safe harbers or the exemptions for an emergency meeting okay without notification yeah so uh let's go down we have government code um citations that we're adding in there study sessions Retreats public forums and discussion meetings um we're adding government code citations location of meetings um see uh is this section in our current genen te traditional tele conferencing let me go back we were gonna 18 is prese zoom preum yeah I I wanted to get more information
142on this one actually um because it keeps changing the rules keep changing around this so um we can look at it and then when we bring it back I'll have more information this whole section has been updated and broken down into categories that's the difference with ours this whole section okay and then what's the date on this policy um this one was updated March of 2024 okay so it's it's pretty current um traditional teleconferencing a board member May participate in any meeting by teleconference which includes both audio or video uh so long as the following conditions are met all votes taken during the meeting are by roll call the meeting is conducted in a manner that protects the statutory and constitutional rights of the parties or the public appearing before the legislative body of a
143local agency the location of the board member participating by teleconference is open and accessible to the public during the meeting except during Clos session such that members of the public May observe and person the board member participating by teleconference may hear SL listen to the meeting in the same extent as the board member participating by teleconference and may make public comment during the same portion of the agenda as other members of the public from the same location as the board member participating by teleconference uh number four the location of the board member participating by teleconference is noted in the agenda and the agenda is posted at the location of the board member participating by teleconference in advance of the meeting statutorily required based on the type of meeting number five at least a quorum of
144the members is within the district boundaries um I would say for number three I think in the interest of uh protecting our board members who may be traveling for work or whatever it says the public can observe them that sounds like they can go into their hotel room I mean I think I think that that's the law so we need to check I think I think observe if we put something like I mean check but if they say you have to stay on camera I mean something like that let me look into the legal um advice because I think I've been to a couple just feels really I know but that's the rule um because again um they supposed to post something even on your hotel door your door on your hotel door the agenda
145right and if a member of the public comes and knocks on your hotel door and says hey if you're having a meeting I'd like to observe that you're supposed to let them man let them observe because you're you're engaged in your official activities as an elected official it's a public position a board member uh or a board meeting is a public meeting and that's that's just the way it is however the likelihood if you're in let's say that you're in New York the likelihood of somebody even knowing that you have this posted on your door and knowing you know that they have the right to do a strange person's walking by in your hallway I don't think it's safe I think safety over I mean I'll get a a legal opinion for you on this
146but I think definitely with the transparency definitely people need to see that you're not being unduly coursed or um otherwise you know whatever but uh yeah or that it's really you you know who's on if your camera's on on or whatever and it doesn't go into that but let me get a legal opinion on that because that's always that's what the way I've been trained that's what the attorneys have told me in the past um and this is cba's uh again recommended that's been vetted by their counc but we'll look into it what is the title of this one too this one uh go back up to the title it is um notic meeting TR ton this section traditional teleconferencing huh okay keep going uh okay teleconferencing by individual board member due to just cause
147until January 1st 2026 when there is Just Cause preventing a board member from attending a board meeting in person the board member May participate in that meeting by teleconference without including the location of the board member participating by teleconference in the agenda making the location of the board member participating by teleconference open and accessible to the public posting the agenda at the location of the board member participating by teleconference a board member needing to participate by teleconference for Just Cause shall notify the board at the earliest possible opportunity including at the start of the regular meeting of the need to do so and include a general description of the circumstances relating to the need to appear by teleconference at the given meeting and that's in government code uh 45953 for the board member to participate
148by teleconference under this section all of the following are required all notes taken during the meeting are by roll call at least a quorum of the board participates in person from a singular physical location clearly identified on the agenda the board member participating by teleconference utilizes both audio and visual technology to participate in the meeting the board member participating by teleconference publicly discloses before any action is taken whether any individual 18 years of age or older is present at the board member's location and the general nature of the board member's relationship with each such individual the public is able to access the meeting via a two-way audio visual platform or a two-way audio service and a live webcast with real-time public comment being allowed via the platform or service in addition to public comment being
149available in person the platform or service may require members of the public to register in order to make public comments so long as the platform or service is not controlled by the district the agenda for the meeting includes information describing how members of the public can access the platform or service if the platformer service is disrupted such that the public cannot access the meeting or give real-time public comment the meeting May continue but the board member may not take any action on any agenda item until the disruption is resolved a board member shall be permitted to participate by teleconference for just cause for no more than two meetings per calendar year for purposes of this section just cause may exist for any of the following number one a child care or caregiving need of a
150child parent grandparent grandchild sibling spouse or Dom partner that requires a board member to participate remotely a contagious illness prevents a board member from attending in per person a board member has a a need related to a physical or mental disability not otherwise reasonably accommodated a board member is traveling while on official business of the board or another state or local agency teleconferencing by individual board member due to emergency circumstances until January 1st 2026 when a physical or family medical emergency would prevent a board member from attending a board meeting in person that board member May request to participate in such meeting by teleconference the board member requesting to appear remotely shall submit the request as soon as possible and include a concise General description of the emergency that necessitated the request the board member
151shall not be required to disclose any disability medical diagnosis or personal medical information exempt under existing law if the request is received timely it shall be added to the agenda as the first item of business at the meeting even before any Clos session items if the request is not received timely it shall be taken up by the board before the first item of business at the meeting the request shall be granted upon a vote by the majority of the board if the request is granted by the board the board member May participate by teleconference without including the location of the board member participating by teleconference in the agenda making the location of the board member participating by teleconference open and accessible to the public posting the agenda at the location of the board member participating
152by teleconference for the board member to participate by teleconference due to emergency circumstances all of the following are required all votes taken during the meeting or roll call all at least a quorum of the board participates in person from a singular physical location clearly identified on the agenda the board member participating by teleconference utilizes both audio and visual technology to participate in the meeting the board member participating by teleconference publicly discloses before any action is taken whether any individual 18 years of older or 18 years of age or older is present at the me board members a location and general nature of the members relationship with such individual the public is able to access the meeting via two-way audio visual platform or two-way audio service and live webcast with realtime public comment being allowed via
153the platform or service in addition to public comment being available in person the platform or service may require members of the public to register in order to make public comments so long as the platform or service is not controlled by the district the agenda for the meeting includes information describing how members of the public can access the platform or service and again this is like redundant um because you you know I read it before can can we do it by discretion of the board president who would speak for the board rather than a vote a majority vote because I'm pretty sure how do we have a majority vote if it's an emergency and then we're so I'm pretty sure this is Memorial in law because you know how it says um until January 1st 2026
154these are the provisions that are in place now that will expire January 1st 20 26 um and and we don't have the new ones yet or we do no we don't have anything I mean we'll get it closer to January 1st 2026 but I think this is what it is now but having said that I'm going to confirm with Council and let you know I don't think these are um Provisions that the board can change because you can always do more than what the law requires you just can't do less in your policies so you can't modify um a provision that is required in law but you can always you know enhance like do more when the love requires you so let me check on that because I mean I've been through um professional development
155sessions where they've talked about this and to me it seemed pretty straightforward that this was what was required of board members participating remotely let me check Okay so let's scroll up or down scroll down sorry um teleconference meetings during a proclaimed state of emergency um it's basically you know similar rules right um so for the purpose of determining whether the meeting in person would present imminent risks to the health or safety of attendees due to the emergency when the board has been uh when the board has been determined pursuant to item number one above that the meeting in person would present imminent risk to the health or safety of attendees due to the emergency um the board May hold a meeting by teleconference during proclaimed state of emergency without including um the location without uh
156making the location of board members known without posting the agenda um for the board to hold such meeting of all of the following all the following are required scroll down so again votes are taken by roll call the public uh is able to access the meeting um the you have to have an internet-based platform um the agenda for the meeting includes information describing how members of the public can access um scroll down if the platform if it's disrupted then you um you have to discontinue the meeting until you get it corrected or resolved for any public comment period with the time limit the board may not close that public comment period or the opportunity to register until the full time for public comment has elapsed um for any other public comment period the board shall
157allow a reasonable amount of time to allow members of the public to provide public comment and to register to do so the board may continue to conduct all meetings by teleconference through one or more 45-day periods so long as prior to the beginning of each 45-day period the board has reconsidered the circumstances of the state of emergency and determines that it continues to directly impact the ability of the board to meet safely in person so that's that was a lot um to digest and I'm going to bring back you know the legal citations and whether or not there's any flexibility um on any of that language prior to January 1 2026 I think I think it's just mainly the I guess I I get need Clarity on what traditional teleconferencing is and then they go
158into all the different ones so it seems strange it it was um Co that that really um allowed for us to have um teleconferencing um when you know school districts weren't holding classes in person and Boards of Education were holding their uh board meetings on Zoom or other platforms um these these rules started to appear and I think there was always the traditional teleconferencing option um and everything else was added later and a provision of law was extended um so I will research because the way that they write if you wouldn't mind going back up to um can you go back up where it says traditional teleconferencing to me it's referring to an individual board member a board member May participate in any meeting by teleconference which includes both audio okay so if so that
159is saying we can just do that but any meeting basically individually which is not really our policy so um the current law is traditional teleconferencing and then assembly Bill 361 uhuh um was past state of emergency option it's current law and it expires upon termination of any state emergency or January 1st uh that expired January 1st 2024 and then there's assembly Bill 244 9 specific circumstances option and this was effective January 1st 2023 and it expires January 1st 2026 this part uhhuh okay so and so it says the governor signed ab2 449 in September of 2022 the purpose of the bill was in part to ensure minimum standards for public participation and notice requirements allowing for greater public participation in teleconference meetings to accomplish this objective assembly Bill 2449 adds a slew of requirements related
160to access to the meeting notice agendas and cause for remote participation to the existing Brown act requirements distinct from assembly Bill 361 boards do not have to make any findings including the findings required every 30 days by AB 361 related to a state of emergency to use this option among the new requirements are the following at least a quorum of members must participate in person uh members of the public must be able to remotely hear visually observed blah blah blah the meeting notice must include the inperson location um the agenda must describe the Public's ability to attend the meeting board members May participate remotely but only pursuant to the requirements and limitations described below okay so so they have to treat it like a true noticing meeting all that if you want to do it
161but if you have a just cause the requirements are um different yeah where they have defined a just cause um does that require a board vote can you go to Just C I think the roll call so I understand I understand so any of us have that option to just zoom in but we must post it on our front door and say where we are and do all this stuff someone could come sit in your living room with you if you want I mean right Tech be right sorry am I boring you no I'm sorry okay um okay so okay so through this whole year this whole year they have that's what applies and I just want to make sure yeah so notify the board including at the start of a regular meeting of the
162need to do so include a general description of the need of so it's if you think for the next meeting you would have to know in advance and you notify the board so to be clear the traditional teleconferencing option right is currently available under the brown act um the and it has no expiration date AB 361 expires either on January 1st 2024 or upon the cessation of the current state of emergency by the governor who has announced it will end on uh that's February 208th 2023 ab2 2449 which goes in effect on January 1st 2023 expires three years later on January 1st 2026 so that's where you at the January 2026 so this is an assembly bill and I don't think we have flexibility can we go down though scroll down um down down down
163down Okay so this one doesn't require a board vote that's fine I mean I think that seems um unrealistic yeah and then when this one expires we're basically going back to traditional conferencing as an option and following those rules right um because this um assembly Bill 2449 is going to expire January 1 2026 which is one year from now yeah which will go by very fast and and hopefully we're not having a lot of you know meetings where people are conferencing um right but you never know right okay so we could add to like board what what are they called when it's like Norms that we meet in person yeah and we're having that meeting on the 13 yeah so um we're going to develop because it does create a better Synergy and collaboration and
164transparency yes agreed yeah thank you anything else on this policy okay so let's go um go to the next one or are we almost I think we're almost done three more this the last three only three more there's there's only three more policies we do this okay 9321 close session so what you see highlighted in yellow is what we're adding um in the first paragraph it's just the education code and the government code sessions that we're adding as citations um line 11 through 15 um in the open session proceeding the close session the board shall disclose the items to be discussed in close session as specified in this bylaw the board May either State the information on the agenda or refer the public to the item as listed uh by number or letter on the
165agenda in the closed session the board may consider only those items covered in its statement and we're complying with that already so it's memorializing our current practice um line 17 through 22 after the closed session the board shall uh reconvene an open session before adjourning the meeting and wa appable bless you shall publicly disclose any actions taken in close session the votes are abstentions thereon and other disclosures as specified in this bylaw such reports may be made in writing or orally at the location announced in the agenda for the close session as required by laws memorializing our practice lines 24 through 32 when an action taken during close session involves final approval or adoption of a document such as a contract or settlement agreement that becomes public upon uh such approval or adoption the superintendent
166or design shall provide a copy of the document to any person present at the conclusion of the Clos session who submitted a written request if and that's that's uh pursuant to to law if the action taken um results in one or more substantive Amendment ments the superintendent or design shall make the document available the next business day or when the necessary changes to the document are completed whenever copies of approved agreements will uh not be immediately released due to an amendment the board president shall orally summarize the substance of the amendment for the purpose um or I'm sorry for those present at the end of the Clos session confidentiality uh a board member shall not disclose confidential information received in close session unless the board authorizes the disclosure of that information or the information has
167been publicly reported by the district the board shall not disclose any information that is protected by state or federal law in addition no victim or alleged victim of uh torturous sexual conduct or child abuse shall be identified in any board agenda notice announcement or report required by the brown act unless the identity of the person has been previously uh publicly disclosed Personnel matters appointment employment performance evaluation or disciplin dismissal release the board May hold a close session under the Personnel exception to consider the appointment employment performance evaluation discipline dismissal or change in employment status of an employee such a close session shall not include discussion or action on proposed compensation except for a reduction of compensation that results from the imposition of discipline Personnel matters uh specific complaints or charges the board May hold a
168closed session to hear complaints or charges brought against an employee unless the employee who is a subject of the complain requests an open session before the board holds a closed session on specific complaints or charges brought against the employee employe the superintendent or designate shall ensure that the employee receives written notice of the right to have the complaints or charges heard in Open Session this notice shall be delivered personally or by mail at least 24 hours before the time of the Clos session Personnel matters application for early withdrawal of funds in Deferred Compensation Plan the board May hold a closed session to discuss an employees application for early withdrawal of funds in a Deferred Compensation Plan when the application is based on financial hardship arising from an unforeseeable Emergency due to illness accident casualty or
169other extraordinary event as specified in the Deferred Compensation Plan I don't think that applies to our District 65 through um so I'm going to look into that one and bring information back um can we scroll down can you highlight that that one paragraph Jen and make a note that we need to review that and then scroll down security matters um the board may meet in close session with the governor Attorney General district attorney District legal counsel sheriff or chief of police or the respective duties or security consultant or a security operations manager on matters posing a threat to the security of public buildings to the security of essential public services including water drinking water wastewater treatment natural gas service and electric service or to the Public's right of access to public services or public facilities
170such discussions may be held in close session during an emergency meeting called pursu to board bylaw 9320 I was talking about that earlier um the board may also meet in close session to consult law enforcement officials on the development of a plan for tactical response to criminal incidents and to approve the plan real property negotiations the board may meet in close session with its real property negotiator prior to the purchase sale exchange or lease of real property by or for the district in order to Grant its negotiator Authority regarding price in terms of payment for the property um and this anticipated litigation we have that in our current policy Jen uh yes okay so we can skip that uh existing litigation based on the advice of legal counsel the board May hold a close session
171to confer with or receive advice from its legal counsel regarding existing litigation when discussion on the matter is in Open Session would Prejudice the district's position with respect to such litigation litigation is considered to be existing when the district has been named a party to the litigation or a district officer or employee has been named in a party to the litigation based on prior perspective activities or alleged activities during the course and scope um of that office or employment including litigation which involves whether an activity is outside the course and scope of the office of employment for this purpose litigation means um any adjud I'm sorry adjudicatory proceeding including imminent domain before a court administrative body exercising its adjudicatory Authority hearing officer or arbitrator um Tor public or workers compensation liability the board may meet
172in close session to discuss a claim for payment of tort liability losses public liability losses or work workers compensation liability incurred by a joint Powers Authority formed for the purpose of insurance pooling or self- Insurance authority of which the district is a member joint Powers agency issues when the board of the jpa has so authorized and upon advice of District legal counsel the board May Mee in close session in order to receive discuss and take action concerning information that has direct Financial or liability implications for the district and has obtained in close session of a jpa of which the district is a member during the board's close session a board member serving on the jpa board May disclose confidential information acquired during a close session of the jpa to fellow board members review of audit
173report from California state auditor's office upon receipt of confidential Financial draft audit report from the California state auditor office and before the report has been made public the board May Mee in for session Top's response to that report after public release of the report from the California state auditor's office any board meeting to discuss the report shall be conducted in an open session unless Exempted from that requirement by some other provision of Law and then we have an education code citing on line uh 226 and that is it for this policy are we good uh can you can you explain the California state auditor office so if if the district were to be audited by um that particular office um then the board could discuss response to that um in close but I thought usually
174they start from the L County right all right I think if you're being is is the one like a financial or the other we have our own audit firm that audits our budget yeah um but the California state auditor office would likely be auditing something else like dis appropriation of funds of some sort like a special C so I think if you're being audited by the California state auditor office you probably um are in trouble yeah and so we don't ever want to be audited by them yeah so we're gonna avoid that that's why you don't know about yeah yeah that's reason I'm not used to yeah yeah that's just in case right yeah all right yeah that'll never happen while I'm here okay uh review of assessment interest oh that's not anything we need
175to worry about okay so can we move on to the next policy yeah okay we're in the home stretch by law 9322 agenda meeting materials I thought we just did that yeah Am I Wrong didn't we just do close session yeah oh okay I'm sorry sorry I thought we did agenda no we just did materials but okay I'm wrong sorry they're all looking the I get your coffee yeah I need one right okay um board by law 9322 agenda meeting materials agenda um content governing board meeting agendas shall reflect the district's vision and goals and the board's Focus on student learning and well-being each agenda shall State the meeting time and location and shall briefly describe each item to be transacted or discussed including items to be discussed in Clos session so that's memorializing our
176current practice the agenda shall provide members of the public opportunity to address the board on any agenda item before during the board's consideration of the item the agenda for a regular meeting shall also provide members of the public an opportunity to address the board regarding matters within the subject matter jurisdiction of the board which are not on the agenda the agenda does not need to provide an opportunity for public comment on an item that has been previously um has previously been considered at an open meeting by a committee comprised exclusively of board members provided that members of the public were afforded an opportunity to comment on the item before or during the committee's consideration of the item and the item has not been substantially changed since the committee considered it the notice and agenda shall
177describe the means available for the public access to the meeting and Prov public comment in person and if a board member is appearing remotely due to an emergency circumstance or for Just Cause pursuant to government code 54953 through an internet-based service or Callin option the agenda shall include information regarding how when and to whom a request for disability related accommodations or modifications including auxiliary AIDS and services may be made by an individual who requires accommodations or modifications in order to participate in the board meeting as well as the procedure for receiving and resolving such requests as required by law each agenda for a regular meeting shall list the address designated by the superintendent or designate Open Session item or for records of a statement threatening litigation against the district to be discussed in Clos session
178when such documents have been distributed to the board less than 72 hours before the meeting each agenda shall include a statement regarding the option for students and parents/guardians to request that directory information or personal information of the student or parent andg guardan has to finded an education code section 4961 and or 497 3.2 be excluded from the minutes the add shall also state that the request must be made in writing to the secretary or Clerk of the board um scroll down okay if the board president and superintendent deny a request from a board member to place an item on the agenda the board member May request the board take action during a board meeting to determine whether the item shall be placed on the agenda the board president and superintendent shall also decide whether an
179agenda item is appropriate for discussion in open or close session whether the item should be an action item subject to the board Vote or an information item and when the item is placed on the agenda in order to promote efficient meetings the board May bundle a number of items and act upon them together by a single vote through the use of a consent agenda consent items shall be items of a routine nature and items for which the board discussion is not anticipated and for which the superintendent recommends approval when any board member requests the removal of an item from the consent agenda the item shall be removed and given individual consideration for Action as a separate agenda item the agenda shall provide an opportunity for members of the public to comment on any consent agenda
180item unless such item has been previously considered at an open meeting of a committee comprised exclusively of board members scroll down a agenda dissemination to members of the public agenda related materials distributed to the board shall be made available to the public upon request without delay however only those documents which are are disclosable public records under the public records act and which relate to an agenda item scheduled for the Open Session portion of a regular meeting or which contain a claim or written threat of litigation which will be discussed in close session shall be made available to the public at least 72 hours prior to a regular meeting the agenda shall be posted at one or more locations freely accessible to members of the public in addition the superintendent or design shall post the agenda
181on the homepage of the district website the posted agenda shall be accessible through a prominent direct link to the current agenda or to the district's agenda management platform in accordance with government code section 549 54.2 when the district utilizes an integrated agenda management platform the link to that platform shall be shall take the user directly to the website with the district's agendas and the current agenda shall be the first available if a right writing which relates to the Open Session agenda item or which contains a claim or written threat of litigation which will be discussed in close session during a regular board meeting is distributed to the board less than 72 hours prior to a meeting the superintendent or design shall make the writing available for the public inspection at a designated location at the
182same time the document is distributed to all or a majority of the board however if the writing is distributed to at least a majority of the board at a time when the designated location is Clos to the public this requirement may be satisfied by posting the writing on the district website if the following conditions are met an initial staff report or similar document containing an executive summary and any staff recommendations related to the agenda item is made available for public inspection at the designated location at least 72 hours before the meeting the writing is immediately posted on the district's website in a position and manner that makes it clear that the writing relates to an agenda item for the upcoming meeting the district lists the website address where such writings may be accessed on all
183board meeting agendas a physical copy of the document is made available for public inspection at the designated location at the beginning of the next regular business hours not less than 24 hours before the relevant board meeting the superintendent or design shall mail a copy of the agenda or a copy of all the documents constituting the agenda packet to any person who requests the items all materials shall be mailed at the time the agenda is posted or upon distribution of the agenda to a majority of the board whichever occurs first the superintendent design shall email a copy of or a website link to the agenda or a copy of all documents constituting the agenda packet to any person who request such items to be delivered by email if the superintendent or design determines that it is
184technologically infeasible to do so a copy of the agenda or website linked to the agenda and a copy of all other documents constituting the agenda packet shall be sent to the person who has made the request in accordance with mailing requirement specified in law any requests for mailed copies of agendas or agenda packets shall be in writing and shall be valid for the calendar year in which is filed written request must be reviewed following January 1st of each year persons requesting mailing of the agenda or agenda packet shall pay an annual fee as determined by the superintendent or design not to exceed the cost of providing the service any document prepared by the district or board and distributed during a public meeting shall be made available for public inspection at the meeting any document prepared
185by another person shall be made available for public inspection after the meeting these requirements shall not apply to a document that is examed from public disclosure under the public records act upon request the superintendent design shall make the agenda agenda packet and or any writings distributed at the meeting available in appropriate alternative formats to persons with a disability as required by the Americans with Disabilities Act that's this policy are we good with this policy any questions comments okay we're moving on to the next one um we're good I just want to make mention um one incident that had occurred previously regarding um materials um so a speaker came in and provided material and proceeded to just pass it around I think there needs to be some sort of practice that it just can't you know
186perhaps somebody that has an agenda has mental health issues cannot just come and just start Distributing material um because it can be disruptive to the order of the board and the business of the school district right um also um you know when someone has prepared something we don't even know the authenticity or whether it's valid you know somebody produces data of some kind and then pass it around I think it should also subject to somebody giving us something it has to be per uh our board president and you examining the document and then you can disperse it to us right that it's great that they bring documents but I think that was one thing we need to kind of think about that has happened three times in the past yeah okay so I yeah thank
187you all right thank you let's move on okay um one what about what about um sorry board members um like if preparing some sort of thing that's not on the agenda to present do you think is please should you know should not be producing documents or PowerPoints or slide decks those because if it's not agendized item it's not agendized but also it distracts from our cabinet that works hard you know in producing the material and we too don't have an opportunity to authenticate what it is that's being shared out right can that be something that we memorialize in our board um communication protocols and norms or do you want it in policy I guess it's a question and I'm posing or do you want something in policy that says it's during meetings that we're given
188the material and it's also during meetings that people are presenting to the public so if I have a personal agenda I think it needs to be a policy okay yeah I need to make sure I get the president's approval and presid sets the president will set the agenda yeah and it it shouldn't be sprung on President uh Chang for instance I can't just produce something and then share it and then president chain doesn't even know about you don't even know about it okay but but we have one organization they always using the public comment then they they get the yes but should not be provided material to until you guys review it right you can take it we're going to take the material it's just it should have this process right yes yeah um so
189I'm gonna yeah the great points all good comments and questions and statements and I'm going to take all of your feedback um and do a deep dive on you know where it should go and then I can um incorporate it into a draft second reading um that you can take a look at um when we bring these policies back I appreciate that thank you all right you save the yes for last yes meeting conduct this is by law 9323 um we're adding an education code citation to line 21 and 22 under public participation lines 41 through 44 we're adding except that if the meeting is conducted using remote public participation or with a board member attending remotely pursuant to government code section 54953 a member of the public Desiring to provide comment through the use
190of a third-party internet website or online platform may be required to register as required by the third party provider so this goes back to the previous policy um and the assembly bill that we were talking about um so under um can you go back up yeah right there in order to conduct District business in an orderly and efficient manner the board requires that public presentations to the board comply with the following procedures the board shall give members of the public an opportunity to address the board on any item of interest to the public that is within the subject matter jurisdiction of the board either before or during the board's consideration of the item number two at the time so designated on the agenda at a regular meeting members of the public may bring before the
191board matters that are not listed on the agenda the board shall take no action or discussion on any item not appearing on the postage agenda except as authorized by law um number three furthermore the board or board member May provide a reference to staff or other resources for factual information ask staff to report back to the board at a subsequent meeting concerning any matter or take action directing staff to place a matter of business on a future agenda number four the board need not allow the public to speak on any item that has already been considered by a committee composed exclusively of board members at a public meeting where the public had the opportunity to address the committee on that item however if the board determines that the item has been substantially changed since the
192committee heard the item the board shall provide an opportunity for the public to speak scroll down um lines number 145 through 147 under recording by the public members of the public May record an open session board meeting using audio or video recorder still or motion picture camera cell phone or other device provided that the noise illumination or obstruction of you does not persistently dis interrupt the meeting that is in the csba recommended policy is not currently in ours um but that is the law they do have the right to do that as long as it's not creating a disruption so you will have to decide if you want it in the policy or if you don't want it in the policy but it is permissible by law um I mean we already record and post
193the meeting so I don't see the difference I I do think taking out persistently because I think does not disrupt sounds [Music] clearer um okay you want to strike through the word persistently okay yeah makes sense any other comments questions concerns so what is so what it's saying is they may not record corre they can come in with their we have a recording it's posted but they can still do that if they want it's aot it's like if the if the if the Press came in you know it's it's open we have to allow them to to do that as long as it's not disruptive correct yeah so if they came in with a big Spotlight and we couldn't see we were blinded by their Spotlight that would be disruptive the board president could stop
194the meeting I think we take out persistently in the next paragraph As as well yeah and then seems fine uhhuh yeah you can't like have your flash on I'm almost I'm almost almost hesitant in this part I I get the public right right it's a public meeting yeah but I have seen film footage of other um school districts that don't have clear policy on this and you have a circus you have the media you have television you have bands of marching people coming into your and and that's within their right but still within the scope of what we're doing um it should not be disruptive or in such an expansive matter that it takes over on what which is disruptive and it would be within the board's right to stop the meeting if it becomes
195disruptive to the point where you can't even um conduct business because it's so disruptive and that has happened and in multiple districts and Boards have stopped the meeting and then yeah where they're escorted out by police and things like that but I'm almost wondering if it's not even under this recorded by the public but see because if you allow recording everybody to do their recording they're allowed to modify their recording they can Show snippets of it they can heighten some protest to where even if there's two people in here it could seem like it's you know gone Bonkers and so I'm just wanting to make sure that somewhere in our policies that we make sure that there isn't that going on well it can actually do that with our current public posting as well like
196everything you they could just download and I mean that's just that if somebody has a will to do that right they will do it we have right we we but then we can still run our meeting and can still do it and AD you know change our videos yes I think just they don't disrupt um what you said um Dr deor was interesting where you said meetings have been stopped which is so activities um that's referring to the actual action of recording or whatever they're doing the noise or whatever but does the president have the um ability to actually just stop the meeting you can say yes and you can say that here or is that in a another place it's it it is it's a different place right yeah and it has been used
197and it has been done so you you would say the president would would pound we have in Sano we have actually stopped a meeting Mr had no because I've never seen it in 12 years there's meeting Stu no but but um we have had some disruptions and the board president has said you know this is disruptive um we need to conduct our business please you know quiet down or sit down and um we've had comp compliance for the most part and we got on with the with our meeting but that doesn't always happen in in some districts and so the board president if it got so disruptive after he's asked people to stop doing whatever they're doing that's causing this dis disruption and they don't stop then you can you know stop the meeting and
198everybody would leave the room and then you can either come back and you know start the meeting again uh once people have settled down calmed down and people are quiet and compliant um or you would reschedule you know a continuation of the meeting for later on that's my understanding and that has been used elsewhere so um I don't see that happening here I I'm you know we have really good great people with good public so uh anything else on this policy again is this the last one okay okay all right thank you okay I meeting at 9 o' your