001uh p.m uh I like to call to order for tonight uh open section uh first of all uh there is nothing to report from the close section tonight uh next uh call to the older uh I would like to do a roll call Mr song hi yeah um miss Lamb here Mrs Ryan present Mrs gear here Mr Chen here Ste board member m chck pre of Allegiance I would like to turn it over to Dr lenina RoR to introduce our student who is leading Us in the pl of Allegiance thank you president Chang this evening we would like to invite to the podium the esteemed Mr care from the San Marino High School to welcome and introduce an amazing Titan who will lead the board in the salute to the flag this evening good evening
002everyone one uh Mr President Board of Education Dr dor evident members student board member it is my pleasure to be here tonight to introduce one of San Marina High School's most awesome students she is a wonderful kind funny intelligent and always happy to be at the high school she is one of our she is one of our uh most exciting kids to see every day you smile every time you see her she she is just very very exciting to be around and I am I am privileged to be her teacher during summer school so uh that's why I'm here tonight because her regular teacher could not be here to introduce her and so it is my pleasure to introduce Sophia Sanchez who is one of our um students at our uh special education transition program
003at the high school she's going to lead us on the pledge good afternoon I'm ready to do it Mr Karen yeah everyone rise for the Pledge of Allegiance put your right hand over your heart ready be in I pledge allegiance to the of United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all please sit down okay um Sophia I'm going to ask you a couple of questions so that our Board of Education and everyone present here tonight gets to know you a little better um can you tell me what what grade you're in 10th Grade and can you tell me a little bit about what's your favorite thing to do at samaro high school my favorite thing to do in samaro high
004school is um first period transition to I do CH J okay yes and what do you like what would you like to try uh maybe in the future at s High School uh I would like to try maybe um and I wanted do like the new play in drama okay and can you tell us a little bit about your dance you just went to and last weekend oh yeah I went to the um winter formal prom at the uh Hilton and I think they had um what you think dumplings spring rolls chicken strips sounds good water lemonade TOA Sprite tutties and brownies for dessert awesome you have a good time yes I had a great time I was with Asher cement awesome yes and you know just so you know Sophia is going to be
005probably our first student to graduate from s High School under our new um alternate path for graduation program so it is really H uh it is really exciting to have her here tonight and to um you know tell you how awesome she is so thank you thank you Sophia for being here anything else you want to tell um everyone no nothing else I'm just very happy I did the Pledge of Allegiance today all right pictures Sophia um thank you so much for leading Us in the Pledge of Allegiance I'm G to ask you to come right up here and Mr car you can come up with her um yeah I'm gonna give you the certificate yes we have a certificate for you SOA certificate sincere appreciation for leading the Board of Education and the Pledge
006of Allegiance at the regularly scheduled meeting held on january2 you go swetie okay so we're gonna take Beau smile yes I really love thank you Mr a beauti can thank you so nice to see you you did amazing bye dror no that's Dr Del you did amazing my back up there by this one looks I don't want that was it recently the only difference is the spelling of Mr um Mr okay uh before we go to the next agenda uh it's uh my honor to introduce uh tonight uh the guest uh city council uh J Cho okay to present our Open Session okay okay uh next is uh 6B approv of agenda do I have a motion to approve the agenda so move for the approval of the agenda for okay uh R call Mr
007song here um miss Lamb I uh Miss Ryan I miss G Mr Chen I and uh Miss T thank you uh approve of a minut I'd like to make the motion for the approval of the minutes dated January 14th 2025 in our Board of Education meeting minutes do I have a second second roll call Mr song hi Mr L abstain uh Mr Ryan I Mr gear I Mr Chen I and Mr T motion Carri seven uh public comment the board of education has adopted the board policy 9323 B to ensure the public right to be heard in any matter pertaining to the sarino UniFi School District person who wish to provide public comment we have a three option to submit public comment first submit on form do you have a there were none submitted as
008of 3:30 second uh request to speak during the meeting via room we do have people on Zoom yes so we'll give um one minute starting now Communications from the audience regarding matters not on the agenda or items in the consent or information sections please provide your comments now for items in the action section of the agenda please provide your comments prior to the board beginning discussion on those items if you would like to request to speak please press the raise hand icon to make a request D star9 if you're phoning in or submit a public comment card there is 30 seconds left hearing after this we do not have any participants wishing to speak on Zoom thank you any anyone do not have any okay and third request to speak during the meeting in person
009via the public comment car uh I have a to as you know the the public come and if uh stick with the agenda then we will talk uh when we have a we go to the agenda but right now uh let's go to the first one not on our agenda okay uh J uh topic not on the agenda is talk about the storman yeah yeah yes good even evening uh board president Chang members of the Board of Education and members of the um samur UniFi School District I'd like to uh first all thank uh Mr Chang Mr s Dr RoR Dr Choy for attending a meeting on Sunday to hear some um uh ideas from a resident with regards to the use of stowman as a um school facility to help with some of the
010um uh students and schools that were impacted by the Windstorm and Firestorm um as the uh School District knows that building is uh in disrepair and so would probably not be something that could be readily used uh but I I I appreciate the time that the um the school district took to listen to what the uh concerns and ideas of these res residents are we have um not been specifically approached I've heard of some uh one particular school that has expressed an interest but my understanding is they have not reached out to the city manager city council has given the um city manager the authorization to field any questions or interest as far as that building is concern and certainly the school district would have a interest in that as well since uh it is
011related to um education so any uh further development I will certainly uh share that with the school district and uh to see what would be in the best interest of this community as far as the use of stowman is concerned uh beyond that I want to wish everybody a happy Lunar New Year uh since that is tomorrow so uh sha happy New Year yeah it's the same to you Happy New Year John thank you so much for really um after the election the promise to continue to collaborate with the school district and I appreciate you um bringing that information to us and then being open to kind of a discussion about it and kind of informing us so thank you very much for coming you can enjoy and stay here or go home and yeah
012thank you well actually it's a very special tonight's Luna New Year if so usually everyone stay home and eat together yeah so thank you for coming share your comment yeah yes yes okay uh next is the public comment the board of education has adopt the board policy 93 23b to ensure the public right to be heard in any ma matter oh yeah right public hearing yeah eight public hearing uh not a notice of a public hearing regarding qualified special text um I would like to turn in over to Dr Steven Choy to conduct a public hearing thank you president Chang uh members of the board student board member Khloe executive team and the San Marino Unified School District Community tonight we are conducting a public hearing pursuant to government code section 50077 on the issue
013of calling an election on June 3rd 2025 to impose a qualified special tax on all Parcels of taxable real property in the district's boundaries this is the procedural item to allow for public input concerning the district's calling to renew measure R an education partiel tax that has been in place since 1991 and is due to expire on June 30th 2025 I will now defer to Mr Hong and Miss Jennifer delator who will take requests from the public to speak we'll start at the one minute counter Communications from the audience regarding qualified special tax please provide your comments now if you would like to speak uh please press the raise hand icon to make a request if you're dialing in from home please dial star9 to make a request or submit a public comment card there
014is 40 seconds left there are no requests to speak okay and next we collect the uh public comment from in person so we have a one uh uh Chris K and topic on the agenda uh a notice of a public hearing regarding qualified special uh text Ree yes thank you uh board member Chang and thank you uh board members of the San Marino Unified School District uh superintendent de la Tori and members of the cabinet I am here tonight to request that um you all uh consider supporting the resolution to call the election to renew measure r measure R is a parcel tax as Dr Troy mentioned that's been in place for the district for many decades I'm a proud uh homeowner and um and the parent of a HMS middle schooler that benefits from
015the revenues of this parcel tax as we all know the state does not fund uh sufficiently to provide the kind of educational services and the level of Education that we uh expect from our school district and this source of Revenue is a locally funded source that will provide uh additional monies for teachers particularly in the areas of math and science important technology Services um to service our school districts our all of our schools um going forward we're asking that that uh tax be kept at the same level that it's been at um that it's currently at so it's a no tax increase much like the bond measure m and one important distinction that's different from our the recently passed Bond measure is it uh this tax actually qualifies for an exemption for seniors so uh
016I uh together with a group of us that were worked on the campaign for the bond measure are uh willing to step forward and help inform the community about this renewal um in the upcoming or potential election so with your support tonight uh we were are happy to charge forward and uh inform the community and answer any questions that may arise thank you for your support thank you uh J any more that's a okay so we can for the tonight PA hearing okay next uh nine consent section do I have have a motion to approve the consent section from the 9 a through 9k move to approve second Lo call Mr song I Mr Ryan I Mr lamb i m gear I Mr CH I Steen Bo member m t motion carry can uh communication
017section a communication from the board board of education we ask that each board member take no more than three minutes to share uh your communication uh start from the MR song thank thank you Dr Linda directory and executive team for your support in the maintaining clean air quality at our school and despite the challenges posed by the fire I appreciate how she prioritize student health without compromise manage the situation effectively from the financial standpoint and actively communicate with the parents throughout the process I briefly volunteer as a parents providing the right to the HMS Science Olympia to the USC and attended our ceremony while our HMS team gave their best effort and they really try hard but I notice that they still need a significant more support from our community our parents as well because
018of for example the Miss Nina need to carry the the heavyweight by herself and you know the Miss Wong need to carry all other big letters and I ends up helping them out but I think we need to lot more support to them and we need to financially and as a parents more volunteer Powers but I really appreciate I'm really proud of our team thank you so much thank you uh next go to the miss Lamb oh um thank you I also want to board member Joshua's sentiments um for the appreciation to our superintendent and the executive team for all of the work done during the the fire that we've experienced my heart goes out to all those affected um on a lighter note and happier note tonight like Mr Chang had mentioned is Lunar
019New Year's Eve it is a huge huge celebration um for our community and for my family in particular um last Friday I had the honor of attending the Lunar New Year event hosted at Carver so that was really well uh done thank you to the PTA Chinese club and Carver for having us um I wish everyone a very prosperous year of the snake especially our district and um yeah look forward to many other events thank you thank you so much next uh M Mr Ryan I've already taken over um I I I do want to um emphasize um a thank you or to really kind of uh express our gratitude um on behalf of the board to our cabinet uh Team Dr delatori through your leadership um their response and their coordination and working with
020you know the tree trimmers to um our custodio staff meeting on weekends late nights uh everybody kind of pulling in and working together despite um even personal hardships because you know we all had family members and friends that may have been affected and so we were dealing with our own struggles as well as uh being displaced uh Beyond um losing the home so thank you so much and uh in in record time you guys were able to um gather the social emotional Wellness Resources for our students and uh I seem to see that um the return to school was very successful very smooth um thank you Mr Chang Mrs Gil for serving breakfast on the return I was kind of looking gee I could use that burrito um at work and I saw pictures and
021I want to thank you um say thank you to our principls who are here tonight Dr Wolf um calwell and then of course Miss hazelet um just thank you for all the work that you do and your leadership on site getting the campuses clean so really appreciate it also so on behalf of the board thank you everyone thank you uh next Miss uh k um so I love going at the end here because everyone has already articulated everything so well that I want to say um you know Mr Chang and I spent a good amount of time over the last uh two weeks actually since uh the first week of January reviewing the committ citizens oversight committee um applications which we received 35 so we've spent some time on that which you'll hear about soon
022um later in the agenda and I attended the Valentine PTA meeting um let them know what we're working on here and that everyone was quite happy to hear that there will be a measure M um item on the board on the board agenda going forward so they could just uh find that information quickly and easily going to the HMS uh parent party this Saturday looking forward to playing some pickle ball uh to benefit our children and H Happy New Year to everyone thank you uh as my board member already uh address about the how uh how much we appreciate you know after uh the Big Stone and the fu fire you know the I think all the school district from the administration and the teacher and the staff and uh we have the community uh
023on behalf the Board of Education I I I just like to one more time to thank to everyone and the next uh for the last two weeks I did attend uh sarino School Foundation trustee meeting and know I also attend sanino high school PTA meeting as the Miss Gia mention yeah we spend a lot of time uh to figure out how to select the the the bang oversight Committee Member so later we we will give you the report thank you and the next B communication from the student board member m t thank you so on the 18th um the high school Science Olympiad USC in was their USC Invitational and they placed 21st out of 81 which is so good and they had seven medalists and last Friday was Carver and Valentine's Lunar New Year
024celebration and last Friday was also hms's sixth grade dance and um last Saturday was the high school's on winter formal our theme was clue it was at the Hilton it was very very nice and this Monday was the 100th day of school and so both elementary schools celebrated and throughout throughout this week Valentine is having the Lunar New Year celebrations and today was um cver fifth grade panoramic picture day and on Wednesday is the high school's hoopcoming game against Monrovia and this high this Friday is the high school's student teacher volleyball game and then the varsity basketball senior night and also a night of choreography dance show at the N thank you uh next uh go to the C communication from the superintendent Dr Dori thank you president changing members of the board executive team
025team and student board member who also serves on my superintendent student advisory Council uh which I held recently and it went really really well um one of the the sole purposes of uh developing this council is to really Elevate student voice and I sincerely appreciate just the level of maturity and engagement um that these students provide during our exchanges um and I appreciate that Dr Wolf is there um to also just sit and listen uh to what students have to say about their experiences and uh Dr Troy being there uh this past time to um initiate the uh survey that all of our students took and just uh the students willingness to speak up and out about um issues of concern uh what we're doing well where they think we need to improve uh it's
026just so valuable for um planning purposes for the future um and related to measure m going forward which um I'm going to provide an update on a little later um but I also wanted just to let everyone know that um last night the federal office of um management and budget issued a memo mandating that federal agencies caus dispersements of federal grants loans and financial assistance by 5:00 pm tonight and this announcement caused a wave of anxiety among organizations that rely on Federal funding to provide services and is receiving notable considerable media coverage and generating some uh Community inquiries at noon today we received information clarifying that funding for public school programs such as those for students who are either lowincome they receive special education services are unhoused um or um would qualify for free and
027reduced lunch will not be impacted Ed by this um and then later on in the afternoon we learned that a federal judge has blocked implementation of the funding freeze entirely until Monday so that has been put on pause um these are short-term assurances um they are positive it's positive news uh but we will nevertheless continue to monitor all developments um related to this situation and we will communicate any potential local impact um widely so we're hoping that that um this two Shall Pass um I wanted to also express my um sincere best wishes for everyone celebrating the Lunar New Year this evening and also to um just say thank you for um being here when really you should probably be home with your families celebrating and enjoying um this time together but I'm grateful um
028that you're all here so thank you so very much also just a quick shout out to um my executive team for really helping to make the reopening of school seamless um thank you so much for the board of education's leadership who all really helped um provide guidance and help make our jobs easier in that endeavor um and also the principles who stepped up they were here um on their campuses walking the campus making sure that we were inventorying all the damage from the Windstorm um making sure that we short up any unsafe conditions and maintenance and operations did an amazing job I have to um acknowledge uh our director of Maintenance and operations Mr Gil cardinez for all the work that he's been doing and I also want to reassure our parents that we are
029providing the the safest environment possible under the current conditions as a public school district and I have been communicating with um many parents who have had concerns that are understandable under the circumstances um but but we are also communicating with Dr Barbara ferer she's the director of the Los Angeles County um uh Public Department of Health and has given us guidance that we are following strictly um we are certainly doing what we can to make sure that every single classroom has good air quality our principles are all consistently monitoring the air quality every single day to make sure that it's safe for our students um to be outdoors if it is not they will Implement an inclement weather schedule and that would happen districtwide um so we feel at this time based on Expert advice
030and guidance that we were doing all we have within our power to make it a safe clean learning space for all of our students um and we're going to continue to do just that so thank you to the principles thank you to the executive team thank you to Dr RoR who is still evacuated from her home in aladen and living in a hotel room in Glendale um for showing up every single day she hasn't missed a single day her work ethic is beyond reproach and we appreciate her leadership um so thank you very much my pleasure that's it that's it promise yes okay thank you for Dr territory uh next 11 is a information item 11a Governor budget overview Dr Steven Cho thank you president Chang members of the board board student board uh member
031Chloe and executive team it is my pleasure to provide an update on the governor's 2025 26 budget this evening the governor's budget this year is special to me because not only is it my first time presenting it as the CBO it's also special because Dr delator and I had the unique opportunity to be in Sacramento on the day of its release and meet with the experts who develop the budget with the governor tonight I will highlight key themes from the governor's proposal summarize the economic Outlook and highlight the education budget before concluding with our next steps Governor Gavin Newsome's 2526 budget proposal was in viewed during a very challenging period marked by severe natural disasters the governor's budget prioritizes protecting California's residents and economy while emphasizing fiscal resilience while balancing essential services in education prop
03298 will be put to the test prop 98 continues to guarantee a minimum funding level for education but concerns arise as the 2425 minimum guarantee appears to be underfunded by $1.6 billion despite this the budget proposes stable investments in core instruction and learning one of the key things to understand about the education budget in California is how closely connected it is to the economy so it's important to understand a few economic factors and how things look at the federal and state levels let's start by taking a quick look at the US economy as a whole in terms of the gross domestic product the US has demonstrated for the past few years that it is continuing to grow some of our State financial experts have stated that changes to tariff and immigration policies May reduce growth
033another economic indicator is unemployment in the top right chart you can see the unemployment and labor force participation rates are stable at 4.1% and 62.5% the consumer price index which highlights the rate of inflation as another indicator to consider the chart at the bottom left shows the inflation peaked at 22 and 23 however the FED set an inflation Target rate of 2% and while inflation has improved the CPI is stubborn at 2.9% finally we can't ignore Wall Street at the bottom right all three indexes hit New Heights in December of 2024 but there has been some volatility since Wall Street is significant to California's economy because a major portion of the State's income tax revenue comes from the stock market especially from high income earners whose wealth is tied to stock performance experts point out
034that with a new Administration in place there are mixed sentiments about the stock market's future and as we look closer at California's economy we must consider the big three taxes which include sales and use tax corporations tax and personal income tax on this slide we can compare the governor's perspective on the economy in relation to the legislative analysts offices uh the governor's budget in green here forecasts higher revenues compared to the Lao uh the governor's budget has traditionally been more optimistic than the laos's and it's no different for 2526 so the good news is based on the projected higher revenues of the big three taxes the Governor's budget does indeed recognize a budget surplus of $6.5 billion for 2526 compared to what was projected in the 2425 enacted budget with the economic indicators demonstrating continued
035growth and the state budget projecting a surplus what does this mean for Education remember two major challenges that most California schools continue to face which is one declining enrollment and two the depletion and expiration of one-time funds these two factors alone are the reasons why many school districts are deficit spending which simply means they are spending more than what they bring in let's take a closer look at what's in the education budget we cannot talk about the education budget without talking about proposition 98 prop 98 establishes that minimum funding guarantee for K through 14 Schools ensuring that a certain percentage of the state's general fund revenue is allocated to education educ ucation funding continues to encumber a significant share of the California's annual budget as you can see here education spending has averaged 55% of
036the state's general fund revenues since 2015 and in 2526 it's no different one of the more controversial aspects of the education budget at this time is that the government is proposing to fund education at 117.5 billion instead of 119 19.2 billion which should be the minimum guaranteed based on the projected revenues the governor explained that the lower figure reflects a recognition of economic uncertainties potential fluctuations in tax revenues particularly from capital gains which can be volatile by proposing a more cautious budget the governor aims to ensure that the state can meet its Financial Obligations without overcommit resources thereby reducing the risk of future budget shortfalls however critics are calling this under approp operation of prop 98 as the governor's maneuver 2 which may be unconstitutional the local control funding formula or lcff is used to
037determine the distribution of Education funds to schools here we have the 2526 lcff funding factors the key takeaways here are that the 2.43% cola will be funded and there is an increase in the TK add-on to help fund the full implementation of universal TK requiring the student to adult ratio to go from 12 to1 to 10:1 however School Finance experts are bringing attention to what the real changes could be in 2223 and 23 24 significant Investments were made to the lcff per Ada while growth in 2526 will largely be driven by the implementation of universal TK and redu Staffing ratios the concern highlighted here is that the statutory Cola and the funding increases do not translate for dollar-to-dollar gains due to declining enrollment and expiration of one-time funds highlighting the need for careful Resource Management
038budget experts are also advising schools to look very closely at Federal versus State one-time funds school districts receive received the historic amount of one-time funds beginning in 2020 and many have consistently spent federal funds uh such as sr3 in similar ways year after year however These funds expired on September 30th of 24 in contrast State revenues were recognized as they were apportioned with the largest influx in 2022 due to the learning recovery emergency block grant and arts music and instructional materials discretionary block grant some of the next steps that school districts will be working on including us here in San Marino is that we'll be monitoring and Examining The Changing requ requirements for the learning recovery emergency block grant monitoring the student to adult ratios for TK and following whatever requirements and funds that may
039be available for several new or revised uh proposed programs as part of the governor's budget and this includes the discretionary block grant uh A literacy screening program literacy and math coaches program and a literacy Network the budget also fully funds the universal meals program and proposes one-time funding for specialized kitchen equipment and training the budget also included some additional funding for the expanded learning opportunities program elop but those changes may not significantly benefit us due to the fact that we are well below the 55% unduplicated pupil count threshold one other program that is not listed here uh but is of interest to us is funding for the school facility program we anticipate more information to come from The Office of Public School construction soon as the proposition two program is being implemented by the state
040moving forward we will use the school Services of California Financial projection dart board to translate our numbers on Cola employer contribution costs and other factors including mandated block grant revenues for the immediate future we will continue to work together with our administrators teachers parents students and the community to develop the lcap in fact I'm looking forward to presenting to the elcap committee tomorrow on school budgets over the course of the next few months the state budget process will move forward with the Senate and the assembly providing input and feedback on the governor's proposed budget the governor will release the revised budget in May with more updated info uh the legislature will release its version to the 25 26 state budget by June 15 and negotiate with the governor in hopes of reaching an agreement by
041June 30th I will be presenting to the board our second interim report in March and will'll provide another update once the May revise is available and as I conclude the governor's budget update I am once again reminded of my recent visit to Sacramento with Dr delator earlier this month during one of the Q&A sessions Dr deltor raised a thoughtful question to one of our state experts asking how does San Marino Unified School District One of the lowest funded public school districts in California navigate the ongoing fiscal challenges associated with Rising employer contributions and the increasing costs of special education the expert paused and as Dr delor and I waited for a potentially insightful response that might address our District's Financial challenges she responded and asked did you say San Bernardino or San Marcos this moment
042highlighted a sobering reality while the state budget constitutes a significant portion of our revenues San Marino unified is not always at the Forefront of consideration during the development of these budgets our District's Financial Health Health depends heavily on local revenues and the support of our community this includes contributions from our schools Foundation longstanding parcel taxes measures RN e and the recent Bond measure M and the tireless efforts of our ptas and Community groups who consistently step up to address the funding gaps left by the state I will conclude with that thought as I look forward to the budget developments in the weeks ahead thank you any question or comment on the Dr Choy uh I have a question uh for those uh data I think that's before the storm right correct correct you think this
043is still effective or we should wait until the March there there's going to be a lot of uh a lot of work done uh in response to the governor's proposed budget uh and you're right it was developed mostly right before the the wild fires in the emergencies so we're we're we're looking forward to uh what will happen in in the May Revis and they're also going to postpone um you know the tax deadline yeah the filing deadline um which you know causes some uncertainty um which is you know always a question of whether or not the revenues are going to actually uh bear out but um Dr toy I think you did a great job thank you um question sure yeah go ahead okay so two of the considerations were the onetime money expend uh
044being going away basically and declining enrollment and we have neither of those issues so what do you see like for us in this kind of Crystal Boulder sort of giving you yeah the the the issue of onetime funds I I think our district and and the school board uh uh in fact has done a very good job uh managing and allocating and utilizing those funds in a very responsible fiscal way um the the issue of declining enrollment continues to be something that we we have to work on I wish we had a crystal ball that could tell us you know that it's not a problem and in recent years we've been very fortunate um however um you know that that is still a Statewide problem so balancing between the two we are in a very
045good position compared to many districts but yet at the same time you know one of the goals of budgeting is to develop a stable uh fiscal budget and that's something that we will consider and have to take into consideration with our projections and so one of the things that is a Nuance here is um that the governor's executive order has um eliminated the residency requirements temporarily and therefore um any student who has has been impacted by the fires has the right to um enroll in uh the school of their choosing basically um and the District of their choosing yeah not the school the district thank you and so um we have uh being a good neighbor and trying to you know help the situation we have been accepting students who um either live in San
046Marino and they're p in a private school has burned down to the ground or is not um habitable we have accepted them uh they're they've been our priority as resident students um then we have uh students who have attended those private schools and live in the neighboring communities and have been impacted by the fires so I will tell you that um our in our enrollment was already going up and now it's going up even further executive order is um through the end of this school year so we're anticipating that there will be some kind of a a trailer addendum to this at some point um but it is right now only supposed to last through the end of this year and then those students would be returned to their uh District of residency or their
047private schools wherever they land um but we are taking those kids I will uh say that today I was informed that Carver has um 802 students right now which is the largest enrollment I think that school has ever had in its history um so we're going to be looking at capacity and space availability um within our grade levels and um you know Dr Rich I know has even been looking into the feasibility of of of a portable um to how some of those students so we're taking a lot of those kids um and we'll we'll you know provide them with as much support care and concern as we possibly can to get them through this but we're not like all the other districts right now in California I shouldn't say all the other districts but
048a good majority of them are in declining enrollment including Pasadena before this happened they were already in declining enrollment and closing schools um we have the opposite challenge which is a good problem to have we're looking for space and so um I'm so grateful that community supported measure M and that we are going to be able to you know present those challenges to the board to help us resolve and um it's for long-term planning and for fiscal stability in the out years I think that we're in a very strong position okay uh any more question comment if not let's go to 11b uh major M up uh Dr derory and Dr Choy thank you so we just pull up my presentation oh well that's the wrong one that's not the measure in one that's um
049vice president gills [Music] well while they're pulling it up I can say that the board of education has requested that um we provide uh a standing item on our agenda on um measure M so that we can U be as transparent with the community as possible in providing necessary updates so we provided a measure M facilities Bond update um during the last meeting and um we're going to uh add to what what the board is already aware of and just give you the latest and greatest so if we can go to the next slide um so as you know just by way of um history on November 5th uh we passed a $200 million facilities Bond measure with a 71% approval rating which is very uh favorable and um our commitment at that point was
050to secure the most qualified Bond program Partners in the industry um we want to provide a high level of bond oversight and communication with the Board of Education and Community um and we are going to be hiring a highly qualified and top rated Bond program financing Team all of these things are instrumental in making sure that um this process is seamless go to the next slide so I've already talked to the Board of Education um and I've already presented publicly on our next step so go to the next slide and I want to focus tonight on the bond program uh management process so uh on December 18th 2024 we posted a request for qualifications or a an RFQ for a bond program management firm uh related to our measure M the district responded to questions
051related to the RFQ on January 2025 and subse subsequently we received six responses on January 17th 2025 which was the deadline uh these submissions are currently under review and we anticipate interviewing prospective firms to select the district's Bond program manager um and we expect and anticipate that that will be at the very beginning of March we're working out those dates now uh and putting together the panel that we'll be interviewing our most current estimated timeline uh is to thoroughly review the responses and conduct interviews um as I mentioned no later than mid-march I'm hoping it will be earlier than that and our district aims to Leverage The expertise of our bond consultants and gain knowledge from attending the upcoming cash conference um and for those of you who aren't familiar cash stands for um the
052California adequate School housing authority and they are um the Statewide organization that really provides information professional development and support to um anything related to school facilities in the state of California um we are um we are really looking to hire in the interim a financial um person who is going to be a bond consultant um and that is going to be uh something that I place in the weekly board memo um with information and a resume on my recommendation for doing that um as soon as possible so that that individual can serve on uh the panel for interviews for um the bond program management team um the six firms that responded are highly qualified highly reputable very experienced um good references and so it's going to be a matter of just determining the fit for
053our school district um and we look forward to that process so again that is looking like um early to mid-march no later than mid-march uh and then we will bring that firm to the board um and then once that's done we're going to be in a position to start working with the board of education on uh putting together their priorities so we are very excited about that things are going to move a lot quicker um once we have our bond program management team in place next slide I'm not going to go into detail on the bond oversight committee because that is a presentation that will uh be delivered by vice president Gil this evening um except to say that we are super excited uh that this committee will be seated um the deadline was February
05410th we are well in advance of that deadline and um I want to congratulate the subcommittee of the board I know they worked very hard on going through 35 applications uh it was a a big heavy lift and um they completed that process and worked really hard in making sure they made the the right selections um and we've already gone over the responsibilities of the bond oversight committee so I'll pass that up let's go to the next one and you've seen this organizational chart this gives you just a sense of what um we're looking at in terms of putting our team together for measure m go to the next slide please and then this is the bond program financing team uh which will be really instrumental and um we're we're looking forward to assembling that
055team as well so that's um the uh budget and disclosure Council financial adviser underwriter uh paying agent through the county rating agency and credit enhancer which I don't think we're going to need because we really have a good credit rating already um so we can probably foro that next slide and then I just open it up for questions does anybody have any questions on where we're at I say to the board that we are within our timeline even though we got sidetracked because of the Windstorm and the fire uh we were closed for three days and yet we're still uh within our time frame so I think we're doing pretty well anyone have a question no no question just a quick statement to um basically you know thank you guys for working on this it
056was over the holidays and um then you know following the fire and everybody else working so hard so thank you Linda for your leadership thank you Mr Chang and Mrs Gil for your tireless work um it it must be so hard because you have so many qualified candidates and we have such a wonderful problem when we had so many you know now apply and wanting to serve so that's a wonderful thing but it makes decision making really hard because you have you literally could have picked everyone and then you would have been okay but we are kind of confined to only having seven well we still need help so no no I'm Chinese New Year so I can't you know be helping that's convenient of course I will help okay that's um no I just
057want to thank you guys for working so hard I know what it's you know like to you know to do that so okay okay uh uh please uh for this uh presentation to PO PA can after New Year they can study yeah thank you for that great Foundation of information for the community at large and I think that's a great thing tool to build on going forward and we don't need to like you know redo it every time we just keep adding to it it's great great thank you so much okay uh next is a 12 action item the 12a audit financial statement as of June 30 2024 I would like to turn in over to Dr Steven chy and the district auditor Mr T Uris to present the this audit financial report okay thank
058you president Chang members of the board student board member Khloe and executive team on the agenda we have an action item and a presentation of the audited financial statements as of June 30th 2024 this item provides a comprehensive overview of our financial position and operations for the past fiscal year as evaluated by an independent audit to walk us through the highlights from the audit report I'm pleased to welcome Taylor alrich our auditor Taylor has worked closely with our team to ensure the audit process was thorough and transparent please join me and welcome Taylor to present the report thank you Dr Choy and thank you board members for having me here to present the results of the audit uh once again um as I like to always point out the audit uh is a very long
059process it started last spring and just ended last month in the middle of December and involves not just the the hard work of the business office to provide us the information we need but we also deal with the school sites and a lot of the other educational service departments to fent many of the compliance areas and that we're required to look at too so it really is a whole District uh effort to provide us all the data and backup support that we need to provide our uh opinions on the audit report so um go ahead and go to the next slide just kind of a a quick what's the audit purpose um it's our job as Auditors to give is to give an opinion on the audit report it's actually your audit report and then
060there's going to be four letters which I'll or four opinions which I'll talk about that is our piece that we give an opinion on various aspects of that audit report and you can see the various uh departments and uh federal and state departments that require this as well um so the next slide these are the four audit independent Auditors reports that we provide so as part of that nearly 90 page report there's four letters in there that are that coming from our firm and where we're going to Aline on various aspects and I'll just go straight into the first one the main one is the report on the financial statements go ahead and go to the next slide that could be found on page one and that's the overall opinion we're going to give on
061the financial statements and the notes and the uh required supplementary schedules and things that are there uh we were able to give an unmodified uh opinion which is the highest opinion that we can give and it basically means that the financial statements are fairly presented and in accordance with the proper accounting principles um I do want to point out that because you have uh because of the relationship with the foundation we do include their uh financials as part as they're were considered a discreetly presented component unit but we actually do not do the audit of the foundation but the numbers are in there and we refer to the other their their they have their own independent Auditors and we refer to their opinion on that so our opinion is just on the district's um financials
062just want to point that out um so another a very clean audit there or report there uh Gohan uh the next one so because you're a governmental entity one of the things we also have to report on is uh we have to review the internal control structure over your financial reporting and on your compliance and give an opinion on that uh that's near the back of the report on page 74 and we were able to give a clean opinion there that we did not come across any deficiencies in internal controls that we consider to be material weaknesses or any material non-compliance so a clean opinion there um right left following that is an opinion on the uh next slide sorry is because you receive uh above a certain threshold in federal funding um you're required
063to have what we call what the federal government calls a single audit where we test various major programs and give an opinion on that this year the two programs were the Child Nutrition cluster and the special education cluster and we were able to give clean opinions there that there were no major there were no material non-compliance or discrepancies in internal controls with the federal programming so a very clean opinion there and like I always say lastly the state wants to get involved too and asks us to do some work as well uh that's that opinion is on starts on page 78 okay or so sorry 79 but I like to point out page 81 is actually going to show the whole list of all the various programs that we have to test and that list
064just keeps expanding um and so it's just more work and more things that uh were required to look at on behalf of the state um and with that we were able to so a lot of new things that coming and for us to test but this year we were able to give a clean opinion on the again there was no major um State compliant oh sorry we're next next slide uh there were we're able to give a clean opinion that there were no uh deficiencies in compliance reporting that any material compliance issues and the internal controls were clean on that uh the next slide we did want to point there was one reportable issue that we had to report on this year it had to do with one of these new newer programs the expanded
065learning opportunities program elop uh the requirement was that you offer it for 30 non-school days and during our testing we discovered it was it was operated for 26 non-school days uh so it was something we had to report but again it didn't impact our opinion over the compliance um and the again the controls and things that were in place um and then just some other parts of the the of the audit on page 67 is just a nice reconciliation page so the UN audited actuals come to you in September uh back in back in September and there's a Reconciliation page where we show the differences between this Auto report and that uh there was one tiny little one and it just had to do with uh this new lease standard that we have um I
066believe it was like $3,000 or some different like some difference there but pretty much everything else was clean and exactly what you approved and saw back in September uh and then we also would report on if we had any uh difficulties or disagreements or issues with management as we do our audit there's audit standards that were required to report that to the district and we did not have any of those to disclose so again very clean audit very good job uh with just the one um again just the one state compliance issue that we had to report on related to the L program um so again I want to thank the staff and all the help in again we ask for a lot we we're sending a lot of requests it's a lot of hours
067on our part and uh I appreciate the the work that you're able to give and the responses they able to give so we can do our job and issue this opinion so any questions or can I take question any question okay thank you so much for your AUD the report uh this is an action item that the board uh take action approve can I have a motion second okay uh Lo call Mr song I M lamb hi Miss Ryan I miss gear I Mr Chen I Ste board member m t i motion carry thank you thank you okay uh next item is a 12 b b oversight committee application recommendation member of the sarino UniFi School District Board of Education as you know the last uh school board meeting at January 14 I already uh
068update for each of you uh what we are doing right now for oversight sub committee and tonight uh is the time uh to represent for our finalist seven under seven category so right now I'd like to refer to uh my colleague in subc Committee Member uh vice president uh Franchesca thank you um president Shen good evening members of the S Marino Unified School District Community thank you for joining us tonight for this important Schoolboard meeting uh I am pleased to announce that the subcommittee of the board of education has completed its search for members of The Measure M Bond oversight committee after carefully reviewing 35 outstanding applications the subcommittee is ready to recommend seven highly qualified individuals to the full board of education for a 2-year term the purpose of the bond oversight committee the
069measure M Bond oversight committee plays a crucial role in ensuring the responsible and lawful use of funds allocated for the construction repair and modernization of our schools this seven member committee is tasked with I'm not sure where this you're good okay you're good okay yeah okay number one monitoring expenditures ensuring bond funds are used strictly for construction reconstruction Rehabilitation replacement of school facilities Furnishing equipping or El Leasing Property for school facilities number two public advising informing the community annually about the appropriate use of bond funds ensuring they are not diverted to operational costs such as salaries number three compliance verification confirming that Bond proceeds are spent only on projects approved by the public prior to the bond measure vote that would be our project list number four audit review evaluating annual independent performance and financial
070audits to verify proper allocation and expenditure of funds in summary the Education Code mandates the bond oversight committee to review and report on bond fund usage and uring transparency and accountability to our voters the selection process the subcommittee received a diverse pool of applicants each bringing unique skills and experiences our selections represent mandatory categories and demonstrate exceptional knowledge service to the school Community relevant experience and active association with required groups such as senior citizen organizations taxpayer organizations the business community and ptas after a thorough and thoughtful process we are confident that our recommendations provide a balanced representation of our community to serve on this committee subcommittee recommendations so allow me now to introduce the seven recommended members in the category of parent Kevin changen Kevin has a background in j a JD in tax law
071a Bachelor's in Business Administration and he is a licensed real estate broker his experience includes director of construction for the City of Hope overseeing a 1.5 billion Capital program he's a former member of the smusd facilities advisory committee for measure M A Planning Commission member and a chair of design review of the design Review Committee for the city of San Marino his contributions are extensive in his expertise in design and construction instrumental and developing our facilities master plan next please me oh sorry they're both parents number two parent and active PTA member Mrs Lisa Wang her background is as follows she has a bachelor of accountancy from the University of San Diego a MERS in taxation from USC and is a licensed CPA her experience includes she is a Treasurer and auditor roles for Carver
072HMS and smhs PTA and ptsas she is the current president of the smhs PTSA she's active in National charity league and School site Council uh additionally her community involvement is she is active volunteer for over 15 years raising four children in smusd with deep Family Ties to our schools next number three uh the senior citizen organization Committee Member is Richard brunette his background he has over 40 years of legal practice in finance Banking and real estate his experience includes being the chair of the building and grounds committee at San Marino Community Church overseeing sign ific construction projects Community involvement he's a former board member of the San Maro schools Foundation active in Little League Boy Scouts and the San Marino City Club for over 25 years number four a business organization that serves our community
073is Mr Paul Callahan his background bachelor in histories from UCLA MBA with marketing minor from Claremont Graduate University experience owner and president of Casa Bonita development Inc with 35 years in construction familiar with budgets contracts and school construction Finance Community involvement he has twice served on the facility advisory committee and he is a respected longtime volunteer an Old Guard member uh number five the taxpayer organization M Mrs Stephanie Duncan her background owner and operator of a spinal surgery practice experienced in financial management and Property Management she has experience and she is a former member of the smusd oversight committee extensive experience in designing and building office suites her community involvement is quite significant she is the PTA she was a PTA president at HMS and smhs served on several parcel tax renewal committees active for
074over 40 years and is the current president of PT Affiliates number six member at large is Mrs Jeanie cball her background is managed a large portfol portfolio of commun commercial construction loans and financial performance management experience led the facility advisory committee a two-term board of education member from 2001 to 2009 and a board trustee on the schools Foundation her community involvement includes having been an active PTA volunteer member of PT Affiliates extensive history with smusd construction projects seventh and last member at large Eric Luke his background is he is a licensed architect with over 33 years of experience specializing in construction management and building Finance experience he oversees a global Property Management portfolio and independently developed projects his community involvement is he is an active room parent a carnival Carver Carnival representative volunteer for HMS
075cheer and smhs dance department and a longtime smusd supporter and I'd also just like to mention that all seven of these committee members are sarino residents so in conclusion each of these candidates has been meticulously selected to ensure that the measure M Bond oversight committee is composed of dedicated knowledgeable and Community oriented individuals they bring diverse expertise in accounting Finance construction law education and Community engagement all essential for Effective oversight and transparent reporting we are confident that this impressive slate of employes will uphold the highest standards of fiscal responsibility and Community Trust ensuring that our bond funds are managed effectively for the benefit of our students and future Generations thank you for attention Mr Chang I defer to you to request a motion okay uh before we make a motion I would like each board
076member uh if you have a question or you have a comment uh please share just um really appreciate the thorough the thoroughness of how got to get some more water um of um your dedication to the selection I just found a a a really nice um diverse group in terms of how to manage the different facets of the oversight committee and so I'm very well done so thank you for the presentation and for your hard work I just wanted to say that I didn't have a question um thank you was it was challenging we have a lot of very accomplished applicants and uh we just did our best so thank you for saying that how about uh Joanna or uh well like uh Miss Ryan said I am very appreciative of the time that President
077Chang and vice president Gil has put into reviewing 35 I'm sure very very well qualified in Long application because everyone's resumes were just impressive so it must have been a very hard decision but it looks like a very informed decision and um if Joshua doesn't have anything to say I would make a motion to to approve yeah I second on it yeah okay there you go okay second second okay hello co hi Mr song hi Mr lamb hi Mr Ryan I miss k i Mr Chen I Sten board member m t Okay motion carry uh I congratulate uh the seven finalist actually to me this very tough to make a choice uh more than my election or 6 time because uh everyone is a very qualified but one thing I also want to mention you
078know there there's a several you know um they just join the samarino community so I believe the uh this is the twoe turn so I think uh for the first seven I think they were carry from the last two two decade the history and then the experience and what encounter before and then join to there's a seven there Su is a uh School parent and with that those uh the uh African you know this time they not pick up you know because they are new but they they can learn I think two years should be very quick to pass yeah so I think everyone whoever want to serve for some know UniFi School District Community always have a chance always welcome yeah yes and thank you for your application everyone right okay um uh if
079there's no more question I want to conclude for uh this uh surve election this a to me is a long process yeah okay thank you to everyone okay uh next let's go to the uh 12 C second reading for policy 615a independent study Dr Lina RoR thank you president Chang members of the board student board member T and superintendent Dr delatori and executive cabinet item 12C board policy 6158 independent study is being presented as an action item tonight board policy 6158 was presented to the board as a first read at the January 14th regularly scheduled public board meeting since the first read there have been no requests or any updates or changes made this evening staff is bringing this item to the board as a second read with a recommendation that the board take action
080to approve board policy 6158 independent study as presented so moved second thank you Lo um Mr song I miss Lamb I miss Ryan I miss gear I Mr Chen I st board member m t hi motion carry next's go to the 12d resolution number 11 2024 to 25 resolution of the Board of Education of the sanino UniFi School District calling for a election for voter approval to review to to renew a education par text on the June 3r 2025 establishes specification of the election order okay Dr St Choy okay thank you uh president Chang members of the board student member Khloe and executive team item 12d is an action item for the Board of Education to approve resolution 11 calling for an a mailed ballot election renewing our measure R parcel tax on June 3rd
0812025 as you may recall at the December 10th 2024 board meeting I along with joy cummer from Team Civics presented and shared that measure r one of the district's long-standing parcel taxes established in ' 91 and renewed in '95 99 2003 2007 2013 and most recently in 2019 is expiring this June joining me tonight is relle Lewis from Team Civics who will also be available to answer any questions we may have about the parcel tax renewal process resolution 11 calls for a renewal of the parcel tax to continue for another six years at its current annual rate of $415 per parcel with an annual cost living adjustment that starts in 2026 the resolution includes the same available exemptions for seniors over the age of 65 for those receiving supplemental security income for a disability and
082for those on Social Security disability insurance the resolution also continues to treat contiguous Parcels as one along with the resolution There's a summary of The Measure ballot label noted as exhibit a the measure R partial tax is important as it generates approximately 1.6 $6 million in Revenue to pay for 11.4 instructional support positions across the district the resolution includes exhibit B which specifically authorizes money raised under the measure to support the maintenance of existing educational programs retain and attract the best qualified teachers and counselors maintain reduced class size support academic programs in science and math maintain district-wide Library Services prevent the elimination of teachers specializing in math and science and maintain adequate technology systems for all students by retaining technology service technicians it is important to point out that on the terms of this draft
083resolution uh it used the word Librarians on page B1 uh but it should say library Services since the district does not technically employ positions with the title Librarians at this time so if approved the resolution will be updated and reflect Library Services moving down to page B4 one last important change I want to bring to the board attention is that while General obligation bonds like the one for measure M do require an oversight committee partiel taxes do not and under accountability measures we will remove the independent oversight committee verbiage to match what has been done in Prior years for consistency in program Administration the district will continue to keep parcel tax proceeds in a separate fund and will continue to prepare and file with the board an annual accountability report no later than December 31st
084of each year finally Exhibit C is the formal notice to the LA County register's office to call the election on June 3rd it contains a notice that must be submitted by the county superintendent on March 5th this is an action item and it is recommended that the Board of Education adopt resolution 11 with the changes I highlighted we will also answer any questions the board may have at this time move to approve with your changes oh for the mve through approve yeah any anyone have a more question okay so the uh Miss GE make a motion any second second okay R uh Mr song all miss Lamb hi Miss Ryan I miss gear I Mr chair I Sten po member m motion carry thank you okay uh the last one uh action item uh e
085uh compensation for four member in accordance with the provision of section A5 of the California education call for member for a district of less than 10,000 ad8 and more than 1,8 are entitled to receive a Maxima of a $240 compensation per month the PO where we asked to determine the amount of the compensation member will receed for their service okay um it's an action item right yeah it's action item is that uh uh dror you want to also help to to uh to explain the what what is the conversation in a public school district yes so pursuing to California Education Code um elected officials in public schools are entitled to receive compensation monthly for attending meetings and for their uh related board member duties and so for a district R size um each board member
086is entitled to receive $240 per month um for their services as an elected official um in the past um the boards have donated that back to the district by not accepting compensation um which has obviously helped to increase our budget um and so that will be up to the board whether or not you want to receive um $240 per month for your services as an elected official or if you want to um wave that and essentially it means that that money would be kept by the school district and can be used for other purposes okay uh I I would like to open to each board member what what is your comment yes Miss I'm in favor of uh waving compensation um and allowing the school district to keep it in the general fund and then
087I would love to have an accounting of of it at the end of the year okay um um Mr well considering the amount of hours that you put in and just looking at this last two weeks while you guys poured on all the hours you guys basically get about $4 an hour when you multiply it out so yeah I think giving up $4 you know can can actually yeah yes I understand that um but um I very much agree with Mrs Gil um to be transparent and to be really um mindful of the contributions not only um in terms of time but monetary and and so forth I mean not to you know to mention all the elections that he's had to run to be elected I mean I think about that um so yes
088I would agree so have you made a motion or we let's also share with each of Our member she she doesn't care us about uh Islam what does the city council do miss you are coming did you want to answer you get zero dollars okay no no they get they get um compensated as well yeah they didn't tell you just you yeah just you are not getting compensate I'm just saying he's a volunteer yeah public servant okay uh let me make my comment you know the they want go ahead goad they want be caring about that doesn't care us either does not care I wanted to go on record as saying that yeah well um I I am in favor of also waving I think that um this this post we sign up for it's
089it's for the kids it's for the community and an opportunity for us to do do service um for the district for the community for what it provides to us as citizens of San Marino so I am happy to wave it's wave wave wave yeah how about Steen opinion Josh yeah I'm I'm I'm favoring the waving too because though I I mean I appreciate all the board and they're working so hard and they just just pouring all the heart and energies and they want to even pour the money to the whatever the we get conversation so I I'm willing to in the same board and I'm willing to just participate in this community and although it's not that much I wish they can help the school Community okay and St Paul opinion give us a direction
090give us the directions tell us what to do yeah oh we get them one did you say give it to you give it to me uh she says to give it to her okay I mean is she is right now I don't think students are although there is some legislation proposing that but yeah wow I'd be okay with the student actually taking it and not the grown-ups yeah okay um okay my comment uh I I I been W for conversation 24 year if right now you give me the check I don't know how to spend yeah so okay for dinner I move for the Board of Education to wave compensation second any second second okay a r call uh Mr song All U Mr l i Mr Ryan I miss gear I Mr Chen I
091St B motion carry our Sten B tonight make a lot of motion Yeah Yeah from the the Pang to the the PO conversation very involed okay uh the next is a the last one is a PO superintendent discussion item okay New Year yes well I I I I I like to contribute one item so is that we need to monitor for the the through Virus issue yeah due to the winter yeah well I I think our health services um department is doing a very good job of uh staying on top of communications coming from the Department of Public Health and we're we're always you know looking out for the safety of our students so definitely we're monitoring okay uh if uh there's no more uh interest item then the I think a meeting a: thank
092you thank you thank you