CorpusRecord 106496

2024-12-18 Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / San Mateo County Board of Education
Date
2024-12-19
Location
San Mateo County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
19,479 words · about 109 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening the December 18th 2024 meeting of the Sano County Board of Education will come to order as is our practice this meeting will be recorded the board provides remote access for members of the public and welcomes community members joining in person and remotely the board is following the requirements of assembly Bill 2449 which en AES remote participation by board members only under specific circumstances we use simultaneous interpretation in Spanish for those attending virtually through the end of public comment translation will continue further into the meeting if people are utilizing the channel thank you to our interpreters Anna Cruz and Paulina basv for joining us remotely for meeting attendees wishing to access the Spanish translation channel on Zoom click on the interpretation button on the menu bar we ask all speakers to be mindful of

002the Spanish interpretation and speak slowly and clearly I ask board members to speak directly into the microphone and remind speakers wearing masks to remove their masks when speaking in order to be clearly heard by all attendees for item 1B the County elected officials reelected in the TW November 2024 election will now participate in the oath or affirmation of office with respect to trustee area 7 only one person Hugo Torres was nominated for elective office pursuant to the California education codes code section 5326 and 5328 truste Torres is hereby seated at this organizational meeting of the board superintendent McGee will administer the oath to myself and Hugo Tores for item 1 C so we're doing that before we go to ony sorry um yeah why don't you why don't Hugo and Chelsea join uh me in

003the front of the room if you guys want to stand I think do you want to face the audience or do you want to face the board or do you w to stand here and face everybody okay perfect um so this is really a pleasure for me to do with you um uh and I'm going to uh we're going to um recite the you'll you'll recite the oath together but we'll I'll go slow at the start so you can each say your individual names okay so I and then state your name oh sorry raise your right hand um and repeat after me do solemnly swear or affirm that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States the of the United States and the constitution of the State of California and the constition

004of the State of California against all enemies foreign and domestic that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of California that I take this obligation freely without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion and that I will well and Faithfully discharge the duties upon which I am about to enter you are now swor in for a new term uh County Board of Education congratulations and thank you for to all the audience members who are here um to witness uh accepting a public service which is a a very big um commitment from our resident citizen leaders okay uh for item 1 C the County elected officials newly elected in the November 2024 election will now participate in the oath or affirmation of office superintendent McGee will

005administer the oath to newly elected board members Mike O'Neal and Patricia Le well take the same stance here um I do want to acknowledge um those in the audience that are here I know um board member Love's family is here and I believe uh we have supervisor Ry Mueller observing this the uh ceremony so thank you supervisor for being here and to all of our staff and other supporters so we're going to do this a little bit different you're each going to say your oath individually because it's your first time here at the County Board of Education and we want to make sure we hear every word um clearly from each and each of you we'll go in alphabetical order so that has you Patricia going first and what I'm going to do is give

006you the microphone and I'm G to use this microphone raise your right hand I and state your name I Patricia love do Solly swear or affirm solemnly swear or affirm that I will support and defend will support and defend the Constitution of the United States the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California and the constitution of the State of California against all enemies foreign and domestic against all enemies foreign and domestic that I will bear true faith and allegiance that I will bear truth faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States Constitution the United States and the constitution of California and the constitution of California BRE that I take this obligation freely I take this obligation freely without any mental reservation without any mental reservation or purpose

007of evasion or purpose of evasion and that I will well and faithfully and that I will well and Faithfully discharge the duties discharge the duties upon which upon which I am about to enter I am about to enter congratulations board member love okay Mr O'Neal your turn uh I state your name I Mike O'Neal do solemnly swear or affirm do solemnly swear or affirm that I will support and defend that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California and the constitution of the State of California against all enemies foreign and domestic against all enemies foreign and domestic that I will bear trueth faith and Allegiance I will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States to the Constitution of the

008United States and the constitution of California and the constitution of California that I take this obligation freely that I take this obligation freely without any mental reservation without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion or purpose of evasion and that I will well and Faithfully that I will well and Faithfully discharge the duties discharge the duties upon which I am about to enter upon which I'm about to enter congratulations board member on thank you okay item 1D is the approval of the agenda is there a motion to approve the agenda move second there's a motion by trusty Gerard and a second by trusty Alvaro is there any further discussion seeing none all those in favor please say I I I all those opposed say no the motion passes with a vote of 70 and the

009agenda for tonight's meeting has been approved item two is public comment guidelines for public comment are available on the smcoe website and in board docs as well as on the table outside the boardroom in both English and Spanish if there are speakers who require Spanish interpretation our interpreters Miss Cruz and Miss vasilia will interpret following each speaker's comments at this time members of the public May provide comment for topics not included on the approved agenda the County board of education does not act upon any matter that has not been agendized except under limited circumstances as permitted by law it is the policy of the County Board to refer matters raised in this forum to the superintendent for investigation and or action where appropriate superintendent McGee do we have any comments submitted prior to the meeting

010we do not thank you speak speakers are invited to make a live comment and have three minutes to speak the board's executive assistant Jennifer Perna will keep the time and advise when a speaker has 30 seconds left please keep within the time limits to make a comment over Zoom members of the public may use the raise hand feature instructions for using this feature are provided as an attachment in the board packet once the hand is raised please wait to be acknowledged by superintendent McGee superintendent McGee are there any members of the public attending remotely who wish to make a comment at this time we have one member Janice pazari and Janice I'm gonna click the button and you should be able to talk now good evening president board president bini uh board trustees superintendent McGee

011um I'm here just to wish you all a happy holiday and um let people know that we're working hard out there in both all programs um and just want people know that we are it seems like things are getting better and I'm hoping I'm not just imagining it but I don't think I am and I want to also appreciate the board members who came to Gateway and did a little tour and took a look at our CTE classes and saw what we were doing out there now and I think that's all so happy holidays and Patricia so thankful that you're on the board I'm looking forward to working with you guys bye thank you are there any other speakers no other uh virtual speakers okay members of the public may also provide live comment in

012person uh superintendent mige are there any submitted cards we do not have any cards okay public comment addressing a specific agenda item will be heard after the board's questions comments and discussion on the item if members of the public wish to speak to a specific agenda item please use the raised hand feature when the item is announced or if in person please submit a card in advance of the item item 3A is the election of board president at this time I would request that superintendent G preside over the election of president for the Sano County Board of Education for 2025 yeah thank you board president benini um this is the annual reorganization meeting for the County Board of Education where um annually you elect your upcoming President and Vice President um before we begin the

013nominations um are there any members of the public who wish to make comments okay seeing none turning to the board are there nominations from the board for board president of the Santo County Board of Education for 2025 Miss banini I would like to nominate Hugo Torres for president for 2025 okay so we have a nomination is is there a second Miss Gerard second um okay we will take care of that second thank you Mr art are there any other nominations from the board for board president for 2025 okay seeing none is there any discussion from the board okay we will now um we have a nomination for Hugo Torres as President we have a second and we will now administer a roll call vote um Miss Perna Miss Alvaro hi Mr kamacho hi Miss Gerard

014I miss Miss love I Mr O'Neal I Mr Torres I miss benini hi uh I do believe by a majority vote of 70 um board member Torres has just been elevated to president T and I do believe there's a change of seeding in motion so board president Torres the uh the the rest of the meeting is is yours on your shoulders awesome thank you um for item 3B is the election of the board Vice President are there any members of the public wishing to make public comments on this agenda item I see no comments thank you um are there any nominations for the board for the board vice president of the Sano County Board of Education for 2025 Miss benini um I would like to nominate Beverly Gerard for vice president for 2025 is there

015a second second um we have a motion um for from trusty bonini and a second by trusty Alvaro um are there any other nominations from the board for board vice president of the Sano County Board of Education for 2025 is there any discussion from the board okay we will now administer our roll call vote when your name is called please indicate by a yes or no whether you wish to vote for um Miss Gerard as the 2025 Sam County Board of Education vice president um Miss Perna may I please have a roll call though Miss Alvaro hi Miss benini hi Mr kamacho I M Gerard I miss love I Mr O'Neal I Mr Torres I by a vote of 70 Beverly Gerard has been elected as the 2025 vice president of the Sano County Board

016of Education congratulations for item 48 the December 2024 Employee of the Month May Tran Administrative Assistant 3 office of the superintendent um will may please join me in the middle of the room I love your fan club so each month the board uh the board and the superintendent recognize an employee for providing outstanding service for the month of December we recognized May Tran Administrative Assistant 3 in the superintendent office May joined the County Office of Education in 2000 she supported several departments across the organization including District business services for 16 years before moving to the superintendent's office in June of 2022 there she became an invaluable member of the communications and environmental literacy teams M May was instrumental in the design and implement ation of the communications help Des ticketing System earlier this year and

017has since introduced the system to many departments she monitors the system assigns work to team members follow follows up on projects as needed and makes recommendations for improvements May is responsible for reviewing and updating the county office website helping to ensure it is compliant with the state and federal accessibility laws she assists with drafting Publications including the county offices staff newsletter connections a school news summary for district superintendents and Ecco times the environmental literacy newsletter as an essential member of the environmental literacy team may employs her Keen skills in developing and shepherding requisitions M us and contracts she also supported the organization and the implementation of several important environmental literacy events this year including the environmental youth Leadership Summit the environmental solutionary teacher Fellowship program the climate ready schools Symposium and the sharing nature Workshop

018where she skillfully led an activity that built on her deep connection with nature that is a lot uh May is always willing to step up and help with events outside of the regular workday this year she supported the black Educators welcome reception staying to ensure all detail details were addressed and that organizers and participants felt supported and able handled leg sticks at several weekend environmental literacy events May is organized detail oriented and can effectively effectively juggle many tasks at the same time she actively joins in and supports County Office events celebrates team members with thoughtful gestures and has a smile and warm welcome for everyone we are proud of our County Office of Education staff and are pleased to recognize May Tran for her outstanding work congratulations to May for being named employee of the

019month for December 2024 would you like to say a few words thank you um good evening uh board president Taurus members of the board superintendent McGee um and um just want to really thank you for this recognition and I really appreciate everything you guys do you know in public services and um to Patricia and Julie uh my my two awesome uh supervisors um I've been working closely with them the past two and a half years and um I'm deeply you know appreciate uh your exceptional leadership um always there to um to be available to listen to us and always constantly um asking us how we're doing and really appreciate that and consistently um you know offering suggestions and encourage us to to move like grow personally and professionally um I'm really grateful for that and

020um to all the superintendent staff always there to um answer questions and um there to help out and assisting whenever needed I'm really grateful to be on the team and um thank you happy holidays and wish you all a Happy New Year thank you oh one more before you leave this is for you so thank you so much thank you for item 5A superintendent McGee will make a presentation honoring Chelsea bonini's year of service as board president so this is always a um kind of a special time to look back on a whole year of service and see all that has been and can be accomplished um before I begin my comments though I want to direct everyone's attention to the front table um we have a um a tradition here of buying uh a

021new round of um books for our Judy Muma Hill Crest Library um and each book is uh in honor of the outgoing board president and each book is um has a stamp inside that um um I guess former president bini has your name and um and service inside each book so anytime a a student in our Hill Crest Library pulls that book out off the shelf they'll know that that there is a caring leader in the community that is looking out for them and and your name will be attached to that um additionally our other tradition is the um the gavel plaque um everybody needs a gavel plaque on their wall at some point um or in your garage or wherever it ends up um but it does speak to um literally hours and hours

022of time spent on hard work in advocacy for um not just the students in our program but across the county across the um the region and across the state so it's really actually a very meaningful um designation about public service in honor of what's best for kids and so your name is attached to that with the year of your board service 2024 and um uh I won't do a formal like hand over to you we'll leave it on display there but do um take that with you when you leave today and then just turning to a few highlights of um your service um this first photo is from the Kent Awards which I believe you're involved in organizing um but also the um s County School boards Association honored our safe routes to schools program

023this last year and um you can see um that board members Gerard Tores and board president benini were present to to honor that really amazing Innovative work that we do here at the County office through safe routes um as I do in these moments I read pour back over the board minutes and read all of my notes and look at my calendar and there's no way um president benini to capture everything that you've done this year I you're kind of everywhere all the time and I I very rarely know where those things where you are but there are some uh things that really Rose to the top that were very out front and center that I was able to um capture and so I apologize for anything that's missing but um you know that last

024year in 2023 we revised all of our board policies which is a huge task that the board took on and um this year your job was to operationalize that into some sort of like flowing process which um is no easy easy task given um both trying to sort out the Cadence of the board policies as they come in but also navigating the actual technical tool of gamut which is no easy task either um and then um engaging the board subcommittee on what updates would be necessary and then bringing it to the full board for discussion um working in tandem with County attorney CH and the county office staff so that is a huge huge task and um you're really exceptional at it so um you you have been at the Forefront of bringing these uh

025policies into the 21st century so and to keep it going so that we don't get behind um you are a ongoing um committed passionate advocate for um um helping people understand the importance of learning to read and understanding the kinds of challenges that can get in the way of a young reader um particularly through um disabilities like dyslexia and coming up with policies and supports to ensure that kids get the instruction and supports that they need um the same would be true for how you stand up for um special education and Disability Rights one thing that I didn't list in the um PowerPoint but you um we worked together on bringing the um transition fair to the county office this year at your request and the building was full on a Saturday um there was

026a band out on the out on the patio that I think uh we really enjoyed um there was great food here there were amazing um presentations um kids and families filling the building and um and that is like um an a a very real end time indication of the power of leadership and advocacy that you bring um you this year there was a it was last December that csba um changed its direction on how it was um uh wanting to structure the ccbe the California countyard Boards of Education um there was a lot to understand about that the board had many discussions there's lots of leadership on this board around this issue but um I believe you as the key author of The Sano County board response to csba became a model for all um

027the other um County Boards of Education across the state to follow and really articulate at ated the talking points and the real advocacy positions um including a lack of transparency and um not a very good job of communicating uh what actually was happening so you raised the challenges while also articulating the importance of the role of the county Boards of Education in that letter um it was um highly effective and very powerful for the county board members across the State of California um for the board's governance um you were very um interested and wanted to initiate a board governance calendar for the board um again these things kind of take a little bit of time to sort of test out as a draft and then see if that's what everybody wants to do and I

028think we can still improve on the board governance calendar but we have a functioning one it's on the website and it does provide um additional information and guidance for the board members to do their work effectively under your leadership and then uh board president Torres will carry forward the work that you started drafting the um board governance handbook you've gotten the board really well far ahead on that um and now it's a matter of um fine-tuning it and making sure everyone's voice is uh heard and reflected in the governance handbook um and I know you will continue to be an important part of that discussion but thank you for uh however many hours it took you to put that together and bring it forward to the board while doing all those things um I think

029you should win a separate gavel plaque for your subcommittee service um I think um it's one thing to be on every subcommittee it's another thing to be uh the chair of most of the subcommittees um this is a ton of work um it can be overwhelming um when especially when issues come up and are Urgent and need to happen simply just getting everybody in the same place at the same time to have a conversation is a is a task uh uh that can be very challenging so um you served as the board policy chair the Gateway uh chair the superintendent salary chair and the legislative chair um you sat on the inter district attendance appeal subcommittee which gave you a little bit of relief I believe because I don't think there was much meeting there

030this year um but you were the um County board's representative to the S County School boards Association very active lots of activities going on there um and lots of leadership involved inside uh the um the culture of the County office you also make every effort to try and attend as many events as you possibly can again I probably missed some um but I tried to capture what I had on my calendar and what I could remember um but that was a really special day the Fred koram Matsu day at the courthouse um last February we had our staff uh big part of organizing that and Jay Takahashi one of our um uh staff members here played the role of um Fred kuramatsu that day in the courtroom it's very powerful and it was really great

031to have you be part of that I know you attended the climate ready School Symposium and reported out in a board meeting how um inspiring and impactful that was um so many 17th District P I should have put PTA in there PTA um events honoring smcoe programs that's volunteer where you're actually making cookies and bringing sandwiches and bringing lunches to our staff and celebrating them in special ways um you attended every graduation went to as many school visits as you could possibly get in and then um in March no not in March um in June you joined the March um for our first uh participation in the Sano County Pride Parade which is a really joyful fun day um glad to have you part of the team on that day that's meaningful to not only

032our staff but our districts and especially our students they need adults standing up and walking for them in service of their civil rights and Liberties and then uh we did a really big thing last year we produced the United for youth blueprint Vision 2030 around um student Behavioral Health and you stepped right up um in your role as a um commissioner to the commission on disabilities and I think also in your role as a County Board member represented on that work as a group as a work group member um and produced a really um powerful Five-Year Plan to raise up the needs of student students in our County um who are suffering in their mental health of course lots of activities going on across the county all the time the 17 District PTA doesn't just

033uh serve our own programs but they also do all kinds of other events Founders Day luncheon um the superintendence lunch and various meetings and convenings that they hold I know you attend did ribbon cuttings in the S Foster City School District because we were there together on those days and then you also attended the S Foster City School District Summit on science of reading um you participated in most of the Sano Union High School District um convenings that they call let's talk and again that's only some of the things that you've attended to support our districts um especially those in your trustee area and um I know again I'm missing things that you're doing Statewide but I do know you're a csba member a delegate assembly member am I right about that yes yeah and

034um and I know that is time away from family trips and probably lots and lots of emails reading through documents um so this picture is from the most recent csba um annual education conference where we were able to gather with the board members and staff together for a really nice evening meal um and your Statewide leadership is greatly honored and appreciated so from the bottoms of our hearts at the County Office of Education we thank you president bonini for your service this year and I'm sure that your fellow board members do as well and um we've saved their comments for the end of the program um and I'll turn it back um over to president Torres thank you president bini thank you superintendent McGee and um Miss benini so for item 6A the board will

035now take a brief recess in honor of outgoing 20124 board president Chelsea bonini we will resume the meeting at 7:55 life e e e okay welcome back everyone thank you that was delicious cake and cider um for item 7A uh is there a motion to approve the minutes of the November 20 2024 regular board meeting as presented so moved second we have a motion to approve the minutes um made by trusty Alvaro and a second by trusty Gerard is there any further discussion all those in favor say I I I all those opposed say no the motion passes with a vote of 70 and the minutes of the November 20 2024 regular board meeting um have been approved item eight is the consent agenda the consent agenda is not debatable and requires a unanimous vote

036for passage an item may be removed from the consent agenda and placed on the regular order of business for separate discussion and action if any member of the board the superintendent or the public so requests is there a motion to approve the consent agenda so move is there a second second yes there is a motion to approve the consent agenda made by trustee Gerard and a second by trusty Alvaro um is there any further discussion all those in favor say I I all those opposed say no the motion passes with a vote of 70 and the consent agenda has been approved for item 9A Joy dardel executive director District Improvement and support will provide a presentation on the 2024 Williams annual report specific to compliance reviews conducted in the county by the Sam County Office

037of Education staff executive director dardel the floor is yours why does this look so different today looks different today right oh okay so it is working okay thank you thank you good evening board president Taurus members of the board superintendent McGee it's my pleasure today to be presenting our 2024 Williams annual report on countywide compliance reviews this evening my colleague Jeff Schmidt is ill so I will be presenting um by myself and let's go ahead and get started so in um according to AB 599 for the Williams Act there is new criteria this year the 2425 school year for Williams including schools that were identified for comprehensive supports and Improvement which we often call CSI and additional targeted support Improvement which is often referred to as atsi schools also so that where 15 or more

038perc of the teachers hold um permit certificates or other authorization that's less than the certification of a preliminary or clear credential are also on this list I'll point out that that group of teachers and um schools that are identified for that reason for credentialing is the one that um is the most unexpected because with CSI and atsi we see indicators coming up on the dashboard so that we know but but um in terms of the teacher credentialing it it can be variable and surprising at times so this year the 2425 school year was also the first year where Charter Schools were identified for um Williams compliance reviews and just to note dashboard alternative schools which we sometimes call Das schools are exempt from Williams visits so the timeline looks actually starts in in the spring

039even though our visits actually happen in the fall in March of 2024 we start training our new um eleas and then in June we we start to do Outreach to the specific sites including talking with principles in and collecting instructional materials from coordinators and um also working with our facility directors this year between August 19th and September 13th we scheduled all of our visits and we completed them all on time so uh just to uh know a little bit more in terms of the identification for this group we had five CSI schools and six atsiz schools as well as eight schools that were identified for Teacher credentialing um this is 19 schools is reasonable for our staff um and you'll see that in terms of um looking at estimates for the following years a lot

040of districts or sorry county offices were concerned about the possible increase of CSI and atsi schools moving forward but currently the number of schools that were identified was 19 in summary for instructional materials we had 100% of classrooms that had sufficient textbooks and instructional materials there were zero 5-day letters that were issued meaning that um they were all sufficient upon uh the first visit versus needing to have Corrections some of the um noticings that we had from the field observations from the field were that there's definitely an increase more in using digital materials school districts were responsible and also showed documentation for how they were supporting students using digital materials including providing devices and hotspots to ensure that students had access to Wi-Fi we also heard appreciation from school sites Thanking us for that support

041to ensure that they got all of their ducks in a row prior to students arriving um and that was one of the pieces is a feedback that we heard from districts in doing the reviews in the beginning of the year the second part of our review includes the Facilities Review we use um a form the fit form to the facilities inspection tool to look at all the school um facilities there were no extreme deficiencies in any of the schools one of the things though in terms of just um observations from the field that we saw this year was that schools are still struggling a little bit with the menstrual equity for all meaning that um in Prior years it was required that um they had menstrual products in all women's bathrooms um all gender bathrooms

042and at least one men's bathroom in grades 6 through 12 and this year we were checking from grades three and up and um some of the schools were having difficulty with that in terms of ensuring that there were free and accessible menstrual prod products available in all of those um locations partially because of vandalism and some discipline issues where um some of the students didn't know what to do with this the new found products that they were seeing appearing in their bathroom and so there was were some vandalism challenges so our team in having those conversations made sure that we also talked with them about um different types of resources like positive behaviors interventions and supports or other ways ensuring that the schools were helping to support their students and knowing how to interact with

043uh the materials that they were finding in the bathroom in a way that was appropriate um we also checked for the school accountability report cards for all of the districts or sorry all of the schools that we were checking um and all of the SARS that we reviewed met met the basic reporting requirements for the instructional materials credentialing and Facilities we also today are reporting on our uniform complaint procedures that we that get sent to the county office um in the first quarter we had zero in the second quarter there was one for insufficiency of textbooks which was resolved prior to today um and then two in the third quarter one for Teacher vacancy and U which was resolved and the other one for facilities the fourth one was for facilities and it was also

044re resolved in a timely manner so um between when this slide was created and today we got new information but I'll present the information first that's on this slide and then I'll give you an update so um we had to create an estimate of what we thought may be the estimate for the schools identified for the 2025 2028 year it's important for us to estimate these things because we have to create plans for how we're going to staff that many visits if we had 65 to 75 schools when this year we had 19 and it all has to be done within a short period of time so our original estimate in looking was that we would anticipate 10 CSI schools and uh 35 to 40 atsi schools and then possibly another 20 to 25 schools

045for Teacher credentialing um since the dashboard just was released we have some new updates on that and so there are three schools and only three schools identified for CSI there are nine schools identified for atsi which is 12 versus 45 and we still again don't know about the number for Teacher credentialing that's the one that we can't really predict ahead of time until we get the information from uh the CDE in terms of schools that um don't meet the credentialing requirements so our next steps are that still waiting for That official Williams list and that's going to be expected in January that will include the CSI schools the atsi schools and the schools that um are qualifying because of teacher credentialing similar to past years in March we're going to start rolling out our training

046for any of the new eleas the new schools that are going to be participating in the reviews and then in April through May we're going to start collecting the documentation from those schools in May through June will'll be scheduling all of our site visits and then July through September we're hoping to um take care of it all in an efficient way so that we could come back here and share more stories from the field and um hopefully with with stories of how people are really figuring out how to meet the needs of students every year um as we have new challenges and new ways of and new expectations really of how students are experiencing school with that said um thank you and I'm available for any questions thank you are there any comments or questions

047from the board Miss alvara thank you thank you very much joy um I just had a question about when you were talking about trying to predict I mean good luck we need to buy a Christmas crystal ball because are are there any schools that overlap and I realize CSI and atsi are different but the ones with teacher credentialing issues could that potentially be a school that's already identified as either CSI or atsi yes and so if they're already identified for CSI or atsi we wouldn't count them as one for Teacher credentialing because um those would be the ones that would be in addition to ones that were already identified well in terms of Staffing I mean you're already going out there so yes that's that's it so you but you're really just not sure yet

048where that falls in yes we're not sure okay thank you we have um actually tried to work with internal staff also in HR to try to figure it out ahead of time um just so that we can predict but the way of pulling the data out at a site by site level across the entire County would be very labor intensive any other questions or comments um I have two um for the menstral products I know that weren't in the bathroom was it that they had them they just didn't place them in the bathroom or they didn't even have them that's a great question so most schools actually had the machines available and products within the machines but what we were hearing was that students would find them and then do things with them um that

049would lead to vandalization so it might be that you would see products that were stuck on the ceiling or people would just start taking them and and bringing them to all different places um the menstrual Equity act actually ensures the privacy for students so some of the ways that schools were trying to solve this problem was to pass out tokens and to people who may need them and then to say when you need it come to the nearest classroom and we'll give you products or when you need it come to the office and we'll give you products but that's not in the spirit of the law the law is that it should be available in a private setting and always be accessible from grades 3 through 12 and so um that that was what we

050were hearing thank you and then um my second question is I know you mentioned um that there was an increase in digital materials um are we when they're doing the visits and checking are they only looking at the physical or do they have something to assess and look for all the digital materials as well so we look for digital materials including licenses so they actually have to show us the product codes per student to ensure that each student student actually has individual access to the materials plus all documentation for Wi-Fi and access and hotspots when um requested you guys are amazing those are all my questions thank you um are there any comments from the public no comments there is no action to take on this item thank you thank you um for item 9B

051uh Jared Prolo executive director um research and systems planning Educational Services Division will present the 2024 California assessment of student performance and progress a Casp and the 2024 California school dashboard executive director floor is yours thank you uh board president Torres members of the board superintendent McGee did you turn it off Joy maybe there thank you good evening board president Torres members of the board superintendent McGee I'm here to present information on the uh California school dashboard um in this presentation we're going to talk a little bit about the dashboard um we'll have some time to look at insights into countywide Trends and then we'll have some time to talk about accountability identifications uh the 2024 dashboard is the first year that will actually have a truly complete dashboard um it has been a long

052tale of the um impacts of the pandemic interrupting some of the indicators uh some of our ability to look at change over time time and now for the first time since 2019 all indicators are on the dashboard and all of them are fully represented with colors there is a small exception to that in that this is the first year science is being reported the the Science assessment uh is reported on the dashboard but it's for information only uh you will see on the dashboard status and change information for all students but there is no color represented because they haven't made the 5x5 chart they don't know what the cut scores are going to be yet or where the um change cuts are going to be so uh it is for information only this year as

053a reminder the performance levels are assigned on this 5x5 grid which is a combination of the vertical access being the status the last year's um overall uh performance and then the change compared to the prior year um further up and right is better uh because that is both higher performance and more growth uh and each of those squares are assigned to color and every 5x5 is a little bit different um so even among the same indicator uh high schools have different um cut points for suspension rate than elementary schools do um so it is uh dependent on the indicator and uh the grade level for each case on the dashboard they have these little baseball cards the state calls them baseball cards uh that show the uh every student group uh with their indicator and

054uh some information about the sample size of how many students are in that student group along with the status and the change for each case and so this would be the place to get all of that information about each of the student groups when you visit the dashboard in general we want to make sure that we're using the dashboard in the right way and it is large scale Summit of data all of these things are generated once a year and this is really the place not to find answers but to ask better questions and so uh often times will look at this and say like oh why is this happening and and that's a great question and you can't answer that just with the dashboard that's where schools and communities need to work together to

055dig a little bit deeper and and uh do some inquiry and and find more information about what might be root causes another thing that's really valuable about the dashboard is looking at those student groups and so there is this Equity report that happens on each of those baseball cards that shows where each of the student groups show up and I always like this example because of the um fact that the school district uh for English language arts is in the green indicator which is uh generally thought of as good but you dig a little deeper and you see that seven of the student groups are in the red and orange indicator and four the student groups are in the blue and green and so the question should be asked is why is school working very

056very well for some of these students and not working for some of the other students for each of the indicators I did include some information from the state that goes over a little bit of detail of where the indicators come from sometimes it's difficult to track what year and who is part of the indicators so for each of these slides I have for your reference um who is included in them the academic performance being the English language arts and math assessments uh to kind of give you an idea of what is generally happening across the county I made these charts each of these dots is a student group at a school in our County so these are all the student groups at all of the schools in our County um the size of the dot

057is the number of students so larger dots are larger student groups and the color corresponds with the color that's reported for each of the student groups on the dashboard um there's a lot of information in here and so I want to be clear these aren't really meant to be like L let's dig into detail these are more Vibes charts we're just kind of getting a sense of like where about we're seeing things um are we seeing more students above or below that sort of middle performance line are we seeing more students experiencing growth or experiencing decline one of the things that I think you'll see in a lot of these cases is the largest differences in change are oftentimes these little tiny dots just speaking to the higher degree of variability that's inherent to small

058student groups and so for English language arts we see that it's mostly vertically oriented we don't see a lot of change students who are doing well continue to do well students who are not performing as highly continue not to perform as highly and there's not a lot of change it is a similar story in mathematics that it is that sort of like very vertically oriented mostly centered around that no change Mark um and that is pretty consistent with what we saw with the overall cast results and relatively consistent with the trends that we're seeing Statewide uh chronic absenteeism yes yep quickly but before we go too far can you explain the axes real quickly yeah so so it is um the vertical axis is that status so it's arranged like the 5 by5 chart so

059um the in this case it is the distance from level three um that's that's charted on each of those so level three being meeting standard um and so that zero line is is where like exactly meeting standard would be um and then uh the horizontal axis is the change compared to the prior year so to the I put a little guide post there the horizontal guideline is um the median level on the 5x5 chart and the vertical is at zero change and so generally we want to see students above that line because that's performing in medium high and very high levels but we especially want to see students to the right of that change line because that is the the student groups that would be making growth chronic absenteeism has been an area of extreme

060Focus this was uh dramatically Changed by the pandemic and has been an area of Interest both in our school districts in our County and Statewide um as a reminder chronic students are chronically absent if they miss 10% or more of their time enrolled just dependent on the time that they're enrolled and in this one really want to call attention to that vertical line and seeing how a vast majority of student groups to the left of that line which is a good thing because that's that's declining uh chronic absenteeism this is one of those indicators that we want to see smaller numbers because that's we don't want to see as many students who are chronically absent um this is a pretty significant change um and this is relatively consistent with what we saw Statewide and if

061you looked at sort of the press releases from the CDE and some of the other things chronic absenteeism is substantially down for the first year um since the pandemic um which is a very positive thing and it's also why you see many many fewer red dots on this compared to some of the other slides that there's just fewer students in the red category because there's a lot of declining chronic absenteeism I do want to preface or prep the group here for something that may happen though and I think in terms of like Improvement a lot and and oftentimes if you've ever tried to make personal improvements doing the Improvement is hard but sometimes once you get there holding on to it is harder and so often times if you make an improvement and then hold

062it that's usually a good thing but we have so many student groups that are still very high chronic absenteeism that's actually not going to be good enough in this case because every student group that's above that red line even if they just hold on to exactly what they did the prior year they're all going to be in the red category um we really need to get these students out of that very high um category in order to to move them sort of out of the danger of being in the red category so something that I'm a little bit concerned about is that we're really excited about the good work that's been done by our schools and districts in in reducing chronic absenteeism uh but there is a substantial risk of it looking like we're backsliding

063even if we just hold on to the gains that we made this year uh English learner progress is probably the most complex indicator on the dashboard because we're looking at really two two-year intervals we're looking at the Improvement that students made between on the um elpac the English language uh proficiency assessment um seeing the Improvement that they made between two years compared to the Improvement that they made between another two years um this is just English Learners and long-term English Learners and I did a little bit of a different chart for this one because it is just English Learners and long-term English Learners uh every District in the state is represented on this chart um the C dots in purple that that La um magenta color are um our County um the dots that are

064in blue are our region the Bay Area region and then all of the gray dots are all the rest of the schools in in California um and again kind of looking at Vibes um it is kind of randomly distributed in some ways there's not the sort of like clustering effect I will say that in general you can see that we're that sort of heaviest cluster is is a little bit lower and a little bit further to the left than than what the overall State trend is and that's been pretty consistent for the last few years that that our work with our English Learners has not always kept up with the trends that we're seeing uh in the region and in the state um by a little bit um alternately graduation rate which is the percentage

065of students who are graduating with their cohort does continue to be high and very high for almost all of the students uh groups in in our our County um that yeah most of our student groups are centered in that that green and blue range in that higher very high category for graduation rate suspension rate uh is another one that was really interesting to look at for us um is is students who have uh at least one suspension um during the previous school year and again this is another one of those that we want to see student groups to the left of the line where we see declining rates suspension um and again there's very few red dots on this chart compared to others because of the um higher degree of clustering of of student groups

066that have made uh improvements have declined um in suspension rate when the state talked about like improvements in the dashboard a lot of the focus was on chronic absenteeism which was certainly a big part of the pandemic but we did recognize that there was a pretty big INT uptick in suspension rate as well coming out of the pandemic difficult student Behavior students having a hard time adjusting back to being um in in the school context and this is an area that count in our County we did see substantial Improvement again it wasn't this way with the state or our region I have on the next chart looking at the U like the um means um the averages for the other counties in our region um and you can see that that we're both lower in

067rate and substantially improved compared to the other um counties in our region and I think that's interesting because like with chronic absenteeism if it's happening Statewide you know we have certainly had some influence in that but there could be broader trends that are just sort of happening um whether it's it's uh State programs or just changes in in in culture and what's happening in in the um general public but when you see something where it's we don't see the same Trend in the state and in fact we don't even see the same Trend in the region then there's probably more action that our districts and schools have done to influence this directly than sort of overall General Trends and hopefully that makes sense but I do want to highlight this because it's another area of

068substantial Improvement that our schools and districts made um that made a big difference um in accountability and we'll talk about that a little bit later for College and Career Readiness this is that multi-dimensional um indicator that talks about how students are prepared for College and Career uh it includes things like are students fulfilling a through G requirements are they U meeting standard or above on the assessments are they completing their seal by literacy are they passing AP exams IB exams and you can kind of get credit for meeting this on a variety of ways um it it is interesting to me from the standpoint of um first of all it looks pretty narrow which looks like it's going to be um very uh you know not much change in in student groups compared to Prior

069years it's a little bit deceptive because you can see three tiny little dots in the far left that's are like very very low and very very far declined um I actually think that might be a data entry error this is an interesting indicator because we see a lot of problems with schools correctly reporting what's actually happening uh for this because it depends on coding all of their classes correctly for a through G compliance it requires them submitting um AP and and IB uh test scores correctly um and so it this is I think still a work in progress but it's not just are we actually getting students there it's that are we actually mechanically recording and Reporting the information correctly which continues to be an issue for some of our school districts on this indicator

070U one last thing I wanted to highlight was the sort of average level change um a challenge of the dashboard when looking at it at the county or state level is is a lot of people like okay so give me the overall General Trend and it's it's intentionally not meant to be aggregated that way because it's meant to be primarily used as a communication tool between communities and their school district for things like lcap engagement and and other sorts of strategic planning purposes I'm trying this to see if like this can kind of give us an overall view this is showing every student group in the county um for every indicator and just did were there an level changes so did did student groups move from yellow to Green making one level of change in

071growth or did they move the other way so positive numbers are making uh positive levels of growth on average um negative numbers are making negative levels on growth and and this highlights some of the trends that we saw from the charts um chronic absenteeism and suspension rate overall um levels of change that were positive across almost all student groups um graduation rate was a little bit improved CCI was a little bit improved um a concern going forward is going to be those flat almost completely flat academic um indicators so like I said the dashboard is really meant as this tool that Spurs good questions drives inquiry um is a communication piece between uh communities and their schools uh around elcap so they can dig deeper find root causes and and embark on this collaborative continuous

072improvement process and strategic planning process um it is also our accountability system that uh in our agreement with the federal government that the the dashboard determines uh what districts are eligible for assistance as part of our accountability plan uh we call that accountability plan differentiated assistance uh and so school districts are eligible for differentiated assistance if a student group is in the red indicator across two or more um indicators uh two or more uh priorities so for example this student group would qualify for differentiated assistance because in priority four they're in the red and in priority six they're in the red so if they're in the red in two or more um priorities then they that student group qualifies the district for differentiated assistance on a little overview of the differentiated assistance situation uh we

073had a number of districts in differentiate assistance last year and the first group I want to talk about are these districts are exiting now last year the state made a change in how differentiated assistance was administered districts are now eligible for two years uh regardless of what happens in that second year so these districts are still receiving support from our office around these issues but the support this year is going to be to make these improvements permanent um because these uh student groups and and and areas of identification are no longer um qualifying the district on this year's dashboard so all of these districts saw Improvement in these areas and are no longer uh meeting the criteria although they will continue for their second year of the two and differentiated assistments the next group of

074districts to talk about are districts who exited a lot of student groups but then added another student group so these three school districts um saw a lot of their student groups improve and have a lot of student groups exited but they did end up with new identifications uh in those three areas so the exited is going to be highlighted in blue the new identifications I highlighted in yellow for these student groups these two school districts saw a mix of all all the above they have some student groups that continued highlighted in Orange some student groups that exited because they improved and some student groups that are added as new student groups uh identified for differentiated assistance and then finally we have yes thank you I should have defined that that is long-term English learner and

075it is a new uh student group on the dashboard this year so it is uh students who are have been in US schools for seven or more years and are still not yet proficient on the uh English language assess uh proficiency assessment so it they they have to have been in our schools for seven or more years so um when a student comes to our schools um the uh family is and part of registration is given a home language survey to find out is are there languages other than English spoken at home and if there are students are given an initial assessment to see are you fluent in English or do we need to provide English language development services and so then from that point if a student has received English language development services in

076our schools for seven years and is not yet proficient then they be are classified as a long-term English learner sorry I know I understand sorry I'm new with this um if when this information is shared to the um with the districts is it then broken down just by District or is it broken down by school grade level or how is it broken down the dashboard is broken down by uh District first of all and then you can get every individual schools read out of all of these as well so the dashboard itself does display uh district and and school um then if you continue to dig deeper because like there's more reports that you can find and you kind of Link follow and then you can get you know individual grade levels and and and

077continue to sort of drill down in the data as you sort of Click through more links but the initial pages is is district and school does it get broken down into the individual student so that that individual student can maybe be pulled out to give in instruction that would be part of the process of what I was speaking about that sort of inquiry um thing that if if we're at the public level we don't identify individual students right um but we would hope that the um School community in engaging with their parents would ask the right questions they'd collect additional data they would find out like what might be some reasons why the students are not making the progress that we expect and then with the schools resources and the information that the schools have

078internally Target some additional resources um to to make those improvements and then what support do we give the individual districts and schools to to help them do that because is there additional funding additional teacher credentialing that gets done what is the support the county does yeah we are funded by the state um the county offices are to provide um this assistance in differentiated assistance it is a it is a major defined function of our office and and um executive director Dell leads the team that primarily uh supports districts through this process um it is one that we are working with them side by side on um their particular um concerns and and support needs to to both support the problems that they're seeing um in the data but also to build capacity so that they

079have more skills to do this inquiry and Improvement on their own when we're not providing assistance anymore um we have had the opportunity to share some detailed um information about that work in the past um and um I think we could probably share some of the work that the county superintendents have produced about the impact that that sort of collaboration ation and support has and then do we contact other counties to see if there's best practices that we're not doing but you know some other county is doing to try to get Improvement yeah we meet every month um both with uh the curriculum Council and the geographic lead agency which is another piece of the California systems of support that has been established where there is a lead Agency for our region this year it's

080it's Santa Clara and and we we meet to talk about those exact issues that like how are we uh working together on these sorts of things what are the the the challenges that we're encountering as we're doing the work and and how can we share resources and information so that we can all improve okay and then one more question is when um a student comes in is from a foreign country or long and they they become a long-term English language learner if they move from one city to another I'm assuming the file that's in the file and gets transferred to the new districts and new schools yeah the the the data point that that is part of the state data system is is the US schools entry date that that establishes that and that does

081f follow the student with a record um to any school in the country okay thank you and then finally we we have the the district that are identified new this year who who were not previously receiving differentiated assistance and and have been identified for the first time under the student groups um this year um it is maybe of note that that in we are tracking in some cases where we have worked with some of these districts in the past so we're not stepping in in year one like doing the same exact thing it's like okay we've worked with you in the past let's pick up the work um even though we we have had a gap in in support um the charter schools that we had been supporting um did exit uh and they are

082a little bit different the 2-year uh support uh rule is only for school districts Charter Schools receive one year so we will no longer continue um providing assistance to these Charter Schools uh overall if we look at the student groups who identified 23 student groups individually are identified uh for differentiated assistance in last year's dashboard and 21 out of the 23 exited which is huge that's substantial Improvement and and it's I want to highlight the again that chronic absenteeism and suspension rate reductions because that's really why so many districts um exited differentiated assistance um some of those student groups are still in those red indicators on academics which was another um very common area um but again since you have to be identified across two indicators lowering chronic absenteeism and suspension rate did remove them

083um from the uh differenti systems the other thing I'll just sort of um acknowledge is that uh there aren't any schools that are identified any districts that are identified um for students with disabilities this year which is a um pretty significant difference um for Statewide Trends as well um in their place is this new student group long-term English Learners which is the most frequent identified group um it makes half the identifications this year um and there is a lot of talk wide about how long-term English Learners are going to become the most identified student group for for accountability systems um the way that it's currently constructed and you know it's going to cause us to have to think about how we're going to change our supports and strategies in order to um support districts through

084this new challenge that I would be happy to take any questions thank you um are there any comments or questions from the board and trusty love thank you um thank you Mr Prolo that was an awesome report as usual um I just listening to you and then thinking about the data had a question um when we look at the cast data and everybody is you know just upset because maybe 50 50% of students across the county maybe 55% it was at third grade or at standard but then we see 91% % are graduating from high school and so it feels like is there an issue with the test that isn't really a good predictor um I mean these kids have gotten through these big Suburban high schools and have graduated and that's an enormous accomplishment

085but we have this sort of this negative like students aren't doing well in school all the time by all of these State tests so I don't know if you have any thoughts on that I I think that's the motivation for the College and Career indicator is that the the graduation rate was the huge standard and and in some cases students were very well supported to be able to graduate and in some cases um districts were able to improve their graduation rate um and so the College and Career indicator as that sort of multi-dimensional thing is saying okay we're going to recognize that students might have different Pathways to get prepared they might take a CTE pathway um and do their Capstone and CTE they might show that they're ready through um IB or or AP

086testing they might show that they're well prepared by um being biliterate um you know having the state seal of by literacy and and so I think where you might see a little bit clearer distinction of of where um students being prepared versus students being able to graduate is looking at those differences between the CCI and the graduation rate and I think that really was the motivation for including that CCI indicator it just seems like it pulls in so many other things like graduating from high school is an enormous accomplishment and now we've kind of muddied it with all these other indicators that are showing that the students aren't actually doing as well as we thought they are when we're looking just at graduation rates a recognition that that that being truly prepared for participation in

087career their communities and and college does um now require more than just having a diploma and trusty Alvaro thank you thank you Mr pist you always give us so much data to think about and and you parse it really so that we actually understand it but I have I did have one question and I have a comment when we talk about graduation rate and I know I've asked this before you say graduating with their cohort are we talking their ninth grade cohort or their K12 cohort it it is their ninth grade with an asterisk that we're also going to count like there are five-year graduates that do count in that cohort so it gets adjusted as students may be summer graduat or so there it's it's not just a strict with their ninth grade in

088four years there is a little bit of complexity but I they do count it still from ninth grade yeah so we're still not looking at whether kids who enter our schools in kindergarten make it through 12th grade we we just don't look at that okay it's not your fault I just I keep bringing it up and maybe one of these days somebody will say wait there's an idea um and I just wanted to mention on the long-term English Learners there's another factor and I have observed this in my community I've observed this with people I've talked to all over the county which is that when English is not spoken in the home the kids are more likely to stay as long-term English Learners and I I actually know a number of kids who came into

089kindergarten in our County born in the United States not speaking a word of English and so they've been long-term English Learners even though they were born here so I realized that this is not your purview but I just sort of throw it out there that I think if we really want to improve the the long-term English learner success it's not just a matter of looking how we serve the student in a school I think it's a matter of looking at how we help support the family to become English Prof English proficient in English to become able to then support that child in his educations I've just observed it too many times where I found it sh a few years ago before the pandemic we had a group where we had third graders we we called

090it reading club at the library and we had third graders that were referred to us by their teachers as needing support and reading all of those kids were long-term English Learners at least half of those kids were born here so and they're not the that was just what really opened my eyes to it so I just say that throw that out there I think we need to look at how do we support the family and I know there's one more thing for the school District to do but it should be something more the the community needs to understand that there's something else going on here it's not just the schools aren't doing a good job it's that we collectively need to do a little bit more to to make it so these kids can be

091successful thank you and trusty banini um I have a question related to miss arl's question um I've heard from a number of you know Educators that I don't know what the the grade level is necessarily but once the students pass third grade or fourth grade that the test is very it changes and it's harder to pass so I'm wondering if we think that it might be um the the tendency for students to stay as a as a long-term English learner might be you know coincide with that um I've literally heard teachers say well I wish my student had been able to take that this year because next year I don't think they're going to be able to pass it like in a you know certain classroom environment I'm just curious like your thoughts on that

092when we adopted the lpac um it did make some pretty substantial changes and one of the big changes compared to the prior assessment that we used was that it became very academic language intensive that was adequate to the content of that grade level so for example the the writing sample might be related to a science lesson that's gr appropriate for the assessment that's being given so so the the difficulty does increase appropriately so we would expect a 10th grader to um be able to have the English to interact in their classroom at a level that a 10th grader would no longer at the same level as when they're in fifth grade so the B grade bands the test are split up in 3 through five 6 through eight 9 through 12 grade bands and there

093is that sort of leap and difficulty between Fifth and 6th 8th and nth grade um as an aside there there has been some uh hesitancy um that used to exist for some schools where they would not want to reclassify a student in that last year before they switch schools because they're thinking that oh there's so many changes we want to continue to give this student supports um I don't hear of that practice anymore because I think that people sort of caught on that that when a student's ready to reclassify like their proficient reclassify them um the challenges of the test are significant and I think that the other thing I hear about that is going to be probably something that our districts will um work on address continuing to address is um high school students

094getting kind of burnt out on trying on the test um that it you know you're sitting in front of this test for the third year in a row and you don't seem to understand why this is connected to why you don't get an elective anymore and um there is actually kind of an effort problem that sometimes takes place um is is there just one more question is there an indicator or a way that we can know um how much intersectionality there is for these long-term English learners for instance with students with disabilities I'm sorry what was the end of that so like of this the long-term English Learners the percentage that are different related to different demographic groups if it's high more represented by different groups maybe I think that might have to come from

095the districts oftentimes that sort of like intersectionality is is requires student level data so sometimes it is hard for us but I could look into that thank you um I will just add from my principal perspective and working with alcap or Alpac um there are four sections to that test so it's the Reading Writing listening and speaking and um they might score really high in some areas and then really low in certain areas that prevent them from exiting out um and I think there needs to be more training for the teachers in regards to what the the tests look like not to teach to the tests but to help them enhance um what they're doing in the classroom to support the efforts for that um that's something that I'm currently doing with my school site

096and I I see it as a need but I just wanted to add that um trusty O'Neal you had qu uh your hand up no awesome um trusty kamacho thank you for the data sites um and for your your real in-depth knowledge of all the things um all these things related to these indicators um thank you trusty alvado for for highlighting that there are long students identified as long-term English Learners who are born here um so it's not always the case that they're born elsewhere um one of I was struck by when you said districts eligible for or leas eligible for um differentiated assistants have to meet a subgroup has to meet um has to be in the red into two priority areas but not two sub priority areas so you can be red in

097ela read in math but higher in all of the other priority areas but what I'm getting at is persistent red over time that district is not going to be eligible for differentiate assistance in their priority 4 area I I did leave out a little bit of detail cuz there's sort of this weird logic thing that happens um Ela and math are really paired together as sort of one and you're in the lowest category if you're red in both or red in one and orange in the other and so there is that sort of additional little logic that goes into just the ELA and math which are sort of paired together as one so let's say that this an Lea is doing okay in priorities 56 and although I'm sure they are related right the performance

098we're seeing on cast is probably related to those other priority areas but let's say that they are able to address those other issues in areas five six and eight could a district be eligible for differentiated assistance when there's a persistence in red or orange in just the priority area for not the way that the uh accountability is written currently so then that would just be left to the district to really figure out like we've got this persistent thing for this sub group okay thank you for that clarification um and I I love your inter intersectionality question because it there's so much involved in that right of seeing like how do we look at this data even clearer and understand the the multitude of diversity of our students and and how they experience um school um

099it also makes me think about how this data intersects with itself in other ways um because I know we we constantly stand by the statement that students that aren't in school can't well I won't say can't learn but students who aren't in school AR aren't absorbing what's happening in school um but I'm also curious about whether anyone is looking at um for students who are chronically absent how is it related to the other areas because we do also know that there are some students that you know perform just fine without being at school um and you know just to be honest like last week I received two text messages from my school from my teachers at my school that said that your child will be watching a movie for days next week like that is

100not a valuable use of my child's time in school and so I'm thinking about how do we account for that where students are actually progressing and doing and being successful in school um through these metrics um I don't know do you kind of get where I'm going with that like I I do a little bit and I think that's that's that's kind of the the beauty of the dashboard right is that all of that stuff is represented right and so if um and this is why across two priority areas becomes important because if you have high test scores and you have low suspension rates and your chronic absenteeism is a little bit high like yeah you're probably better off reducing it but you're not going to be identified for accountability purposes right we're really identifying

101that if you have these low performances across multiple areas that's where we're seeing more like we can rely on it being more systemically an issue right yeah another thing I wanted to thank you for is um I know we're always cautious about releasing the names of districts and definitely Nam releasing the names of schools where we want additional support for those places I was struck by um this morning I actually read um an opinion piece by um jod de Salvo who just retired after four terms on the County Board of Ed in Santa Clara and he highlighted which I never really thought about this is that charter schools are require like if they don't meet these things they are they have to close now and traditional districts don't have that same thing so we can

102continue to present this data over and over and over again but um how do we make how do we make how do we make the progress that we're hoping to make so that's kind of the impetus of my question so that's not really a question for you but it did make me think about like what do we do with this data because I always try to remove my educator hat that I have and I try to put it on as a member of just a member of the community who's like what do you want me to do with this because I've got this I've got this score report from my kid and I still struggle with understanding that and I heard they could change the colors have you heard about that did they change something

103on the individual reports I if you heard yeah um they're gonna change the the the language on it now too and that's gonna be an lovely um so I'm trying to figure out how how the county office kind of helps districts help their Community use this data better because I know it help I'm I'm assuming it really helps Educators try to do their jobs better how does the county office help districts help their communities understand it and engage with it better that's a big part of our work this year you know it is part of our strategic plan to really um improve that aspect of um Community engagement and and Community understanding so I I hope that we will have some things to share um soon um because it is sort of in the planning

104stages but it is stuff that we are actively talking about and working on as part of our strategic plan as an office thank you so much your uh your knowledge on this and your commitment to it just be on off the charts thank you any other questions or comments um I I have a question sorry um I know our County website has um a summary report um for families is that something that's given to us or something that the county office does say I'm sorry say that again so I know the um smcoe website has a summary of the dashboard um is that report done by the county office or is that into us so we have started to to take a bunch of public data and sort of like begin making sort of an

105open data portal that has a lot of visualizations and dashboards for a lot of different things um it is on the Center for Learning analytics page um some of those things are in really active development um but it is all public data that's just sort of been reshaped um but uh we're hoping that that can help our districts and communities to to see things in a different way and and and assist in their conversations yeah I just want to say that the reports are very digestible for families and I love that it's also available in Spanish for our other families and um do we know if we need to make it available in other languages um if we have something to get input from the community if we need it other than just English or

106Spanish um but that's it to come thank you thank you um are there any comments from the public um there is no action to take on this item um for item 10A Kevin Baltimore Deputy superintendent Business Services Division manette man executive director internal business services and Marian Reyes manager fiscal services will present the 2024 2025 a first intrum financial report um Team the floor is yours uh good evening board president Torres members of the board superintendent McGee I'm really just going to introduce the two behind me they do all the heavy lifting I'm going to get out of their way let them explain the first interim budget good evening okay so we're here to present the first interim um so on our first slide we just wanted to um note the change es that we

107um made um from the original budget to the first intering period so we did a recalculation of the lcff using the fmat calculator we also did some um position control analysis to um to make salaries and benefits the numbers that we have um reviewing vacant positions and any changes on FTE we also did some changes on the multi-year projection um including and accounting for the enter prise resource planning software so that's the financial software that we're transitioning now and also um updating restricted program carryover amounts based on actual um carryover and any update of allocation from CDE so our next slide is the income statement showing our unrestricted and restricted Revenue so on the unrestricted um side we have 44 million and under restricted is 35 million I just wanted to note that um on

108the lcff even though we get that 70 million we are required to return about 36 million back to the state for the excess property taxes um so going further down on the unrestricted we have total expenditure of about 44 million and restricted side of expenditure of 39 million so this slide just shows a graphic representation of our Revenue um the V of a revenue coming from lcff followed by the local state and federal so again that 71 million um we all you know we have to return back 37 million of that for excess property taxes the next slide is just our expenditure showing the percentage of you know how we're spending those um funds so the biggest one adding in um certificated classified salaries and benefit account for 43% of our budget um followed by

109that 29% of that excess property tax and then um the next major expenses will be at 24% for services so here on this graph we just um pulled out some numbers that are accounting for that um Services account um so on the just to note some of the bigger numbers here for the outo Ed educate at 1.3 that's the contract we have with YMCA um for the CCC so that's the financial software that we're using um and Then followed by the Erp implementation at 1.1 so that's the um new system that we're transitioning to the next big item is the the transportation at 2.5 which is the contract for First Student on the under on the restricted service just to note on the um the San Mato Health commission at 1.7 and then the capacity

110Grant at 2.9 so this will be um a contract that we're um the program is working with Santa Clara Coe and then also on the special ed at 1.8 for um special service Education Services so I'll be passing it on the next slide will be discussed by minute thank you Marian good evening board president Taurus members of the board superintendent McGee I'm here to continue our presentation on our first interim budget so on this slide this is just the gra um to highlight uh that top portion you probably saw on the sax report under fund one comparing our original budget to the interim revision so if um in June we presented to you a uh full budget meaning um budgeting for all the vacancies um assuming that programs will be operating at full cost now

111at second interim I mean sorry first interim we have made some adjustments um the very first line You'll see that we the lcff has an estimated increase of about 1.6 and that is mostly attributable to the increase in property taxes and then also a little bit of an increase in um local Revenue so total revenue increased by about two million then going down our expenditures as Marian mentioned uh we did a lot of position control adjustments and that isri attributable to the um meetings that our business staff has had with our program um leaders in reviewing their plan program plans as it relates to the numbers of their Pro you know budget so we did um look at certificated and classified salaries that are in their specific budgets and you know of course um attached

112to those salaries are the corresponding benefits there are also adjustments in um operating which are the books and supplies services that capital outlay is attributable to the Erp implementation that we are undergoing right now um with a go live of 71 2025 and um as our property taxes Revenue increase there is a corresponding increase in the amount that we have to return to the state so that's what you see in the other outgo as also an increase overall our total expenditures is about break even from the um total revenue and then we go into the transfer in the transfer in is um because of the plan to um or the decision we made to support the Erp implementation by um funding it through our savings account fund 17 so that is the transfer in from

113fund 17 we also have some transfers out that 534,906 an increase from the 140 from the original budget is uh due to the transfers to to support our early learning programs so at the bottom um you'll see that at original budget we were estimating to be in the negative of about 600 we have turned that around and now it shows a positive number of 500,000 so I think um in the past we've um shown the slides for our court and Community Schools so we're doing the same now comparing original to now first interim for our Gateway and Community Schools um the budget overall did not change but there were shifts within the categories between certificated classified salaries of course employee benefits books and supplies so there were kind of shifts and but overall number did

114not change moving on to the cayen Oaks budget there's not a lot of changes here it's the same um just moving around between the categories within the operating expenses of the program but overall number did not change as compared to original budget finally with our Hill Crest schools there is a bit of a change here as uh we have um gotten more concrete or um close to estimate numbers for lcff um calculators so we now have adjusted what we expect to be coming in from sff revenues or property taxes and then um of course to balance the budget we have to make that contribution line and also if you see there's also a little bit of ships in the certificated classified and employee benefits lines but not a lot of not no no changes in

115books and supplies and services so overall budget it's still at the same um funding level of about 1.4 million so now I'm going to move to our multi-year projections but before that we I would like to point out the assumptions that we made that we used in coming up with our multi-year so our 2324 and 2425 budget continues to show a decrease in countywide um Ada or average daily attendance we have also um updated our position controls to calculate certificated classified and benefit cost we have adjusted our Revenue as you um our Roland Road Road lease is expired ing at the end of January um there is no plan at least for meta they did not renew our lease um we also included step and column in cost estimated cost estimate with a 1.5 savings

116um due to maybe possible retirements we have adjusted Services Capital outlay transfers in related to the Erp implementation our s employer cost is not changed ing it's staying at 19.10% however first employer cost is projected to increase from 27.7% and 28.3% in the two out years respectively and we did apply our Consumer Price Index rates for um two for 28 2.86% for 2526 and 2.81% for 2627 so this is just the representation of applying those assumptions based on what our interim numbers are and projecting for the 25 26 and 26 27 years so um using those assumptions we are coming we are still showing a net increase in fund balance in 25 26 up a little over 300 but in 26 27 we are showing a deficit spending or a net decrease in fund balance

117of about close to 450,000 but I believe um it shows that overall even though that's the trend in 26 27 overall we're still showing a healthy ending funding balance and the numbers below shows how we are um setting them side at the end of I mean right now at first interim and then um in 25 26 and 27 so this is just another representation of how our multi-year projection looks like highlighting the other outgo moving it up so that it gives us a net SM Coe lcff Revenue up giving that number um more clearer and then highlighting all the expenditures um overall it shows the the same it's just a different representation and this next slides is our it's just a graphic representation of how our reserves has um p in 2223 and 23 24

118those are actual numbers 2425 is as a first interim and then 25 26 26 27 are based on our projections okay so um we have three um interm reports require certifications there are three kinds of certification positive meaning we will meet obligations in the current year in the next two years qualified means we will we may not meet them in the current year and the subsequent two years negative means we will not meet it in the current or the next subsequent year so um we smcoe is self-certifying that we will be um our first interim budget is positive so just um just to summarize um smcoe shows a budget that's almost balanced however you have seen that we did a transfer of that amount from fund 17 to to support our EMP Erp implementation there's

119also um we also show a deficit in the restricted programs because of the spending of the restricted carryover monies that were that expired also um smcoe still maintains a healthy Reserve in the general fund and in fund 17 our savings account um important to note that the compensation agreement with our teachers union our smca group is now included in our first interim budget but there are future considerations that we have to remember um the classification and compensation study implementation our multi-year agreement with um our teachers group and our continued implementation of smcoe is strategic plan and increasing unrestricted contribution to restricted programs that actually concludes our presentation and we're open to your questions thank you um trusty alvara thank you very much you always have you collectively always have such good reports that are easy

120to understand but what I can never understand is this relationship we have with the state of California and so first of all thank you for pointing out that 29% a third of our total expenditures is going to be used by non-educational use in the state of California and I just like it's not that we're just giving it back to the state we're giving it back to the state to not use for schools I just need to point that out every single time because it makes me crazy but I did have a question on the slide where you showed the unrestricted only and there's that big green arrow our increased property taxes went up by about 1.6 million but what this what the increase that has to go back to the state is 1.8 why so

121the lcff calculation is composed of a lot of funding buckets um including the decrease in Ada in our um Court in our school programs so that is upset by the increase in property taxes so even though the number is is um only 1.6 in property taxes it's being net by the decrease of funding attributable to the decrease in Ada but the still because the calculation on the property taxes is still at that level it still shows that we may we are still returning more than yeah okay thank you I will have to say that's also my heartache whenever have to write that wire transfer to them every single May yeah yeah it's hard thank you tresy banini excuse me thank you for the report um both of you um my question has to do with

122um the multi-year projection reserves on slide 14 and then also um so I'll prace it with my question around fund 17 you said that the Erp costs or some of that is coming from fund 17 so first Could you um are you able to tell us the balance of fund 17 and then help me understand um which I think it's a higher balance than I'm seeing on slide 14 why it doesn't get reflected here I believe the balance on fund 17 is about 8 it's about 82 million sorry what was this the second question is so I'm looking at slide 14 and it's showing the M the reserves the highest level um from 2223 shows that at 25 million when I know that fund is much higher than that so I'm not understanding uh why

123it doesn't show here or just if you could explain that so I believe in 2223 that's when we made the decision to move um 9.8 million of what is in our unrestricted Monies into fund 17 so that's why if you see that under 22 23 we have that big purple bar that's part of that and uh we have moved that out from our general fund and now it's that's why it's now sitting or now it's moved to fund 17 making it the balance at 82 okay so then I guess my question is um on on slide 14 where it's showing um the different amounts that are reserves oh sorry why so why do it's those are just restricted okay I see okay so the different the other funds that have restricted Reserve amounts yes right

124right for specific purposes okay thank you trusty kamacha thank you um I just I want I think I noticed for the first time this is the first time where the excess property taxes is more than 50% of our income now right um I I I think that's it's another time for sorry I think it's another opportunity for conversation um public conversation about that that it's now over 50% this is the first time it's it's gone over 50% yeah and um when we were talking about funding I'm sorry there's not a question here I'm just going to warn you on that one when we were talking about um funding adequacy um it was so abstract the way we were talking about it we ended up starting saying you know this amount would get you one more

125school nurse this amount would get you that and when I look at a number like $36 million versus what we spend um because of what we have to give back what would $36 million additional to this County Office do for education in this County I think we've reached that point now that we're at this 50% threshold of like we got to put some real things behind this $36 million not going to schools so um I think this changes the game at at this point um it's extraordinary but um manette Marian thank you so much for how you present the data it's it's really helpful to see the story over time um um and I I love that we still call that section out and I think we need to tell that story more but thank

126you for your report thank you truste jard yes I I just wanted to comment on your comment and it was very interesting um at the conference in Anaheim I was in three different meetings and this was one of the Prime discussions in the these were all County Board and I will say um that there was a csba person in one of them and when they were questioned it was the answer was basically well we've tried and it's not worth trying anymore because they keep turning us down um but it is at the Forefront with County boards trusty L um I just have a quick question as we look at the implementation of the Strategic plan and that's mentioned in here is there any possibility that the county office can seed the education fund for the

127county or play some kind of role in getting that um fund going are you looking at that as well I'm just going to leave at that because it's a budget question Kevin address that thank so we're talking about using general fund unrestricted dollars to fund um a foundation Education Foundation um we would need to research that a bit more the reality is if you look at the cesam the California schools accounting manual it references if dollars are received by districts or leas for specific benefit purposes we have to keep those in a separate fund fund 19 but it doesn't speak to if we used our own dollars and put it into Fun fund 19 so we would need to research that a little bit further any other questions or comments okay um we do need

128to oh are there any comments from the public no comments okay we do need to act on this item is there a motion to approve with positive certification for the 2024 2025 first interim financial report so moved is there a second second there is a motion to approve with the Positive certification for the 2024 2025 first interim financial report made by trusty banini and a second by trusty Alvaro is there any further discussion all those in favor say I I all those opposed say no the motion passes with a vote of 70 and the 2024 2025 first interim financial report has been approved with positive certification thank you thank you for item 11a Randy Perez executive director Personnel commission services will present the 2023 2024 Personnel commission annual report executive director Perez good evening let's

129use this is that on there we go good evening uh newly appointed president president Torres me members of the board and superintendent McGee um I'm here to present the 2023 2024 Personnel commission annual report this is a report that we're statutorily required to put together every year it's just a summary of our work and goals that we accomplished in the preceding year um so I'll start by talking a little bit about the Personnel commission much like a governing board it is an in independent governing body made up of three commissioners ERS and they serve staggered terms to ensure that we're able to establish a quorum and Carry Out business um and they're responsible for overseeing the implementation of the Merit system um so Sano County Office of Ed does uh operate within a merit system

130and there are two overarching fundamental uh goals of the Merit system is to ensure that um employment hires are based on um uh highly qualified candidates uh and not on you know political influence or bias or favoritism and the second goal is to ensure that uh job applicants and candidates are um are provided due proper due process rights um the core functions of the Merit system as I U shared you know open competitive selection um you know I think that that you know we want this is you know our salaries are funded by public dollars and I think the public has an interest to um ensure that that you know our our there's a vetting process right that you know where where we're ensuring that the people that are taking these jobs are highly qualified

131so we base our assessments on the knowledge skills and abilities that are required to successfully perform in the job um the commission also uh establishes you job or class descriptions and pay structures uh I'll be talking a little bit about the comp class study that we recently approved um we also adjudicate a variety of protests and appeals again thinking back to providing due process to job applicants and employees um we also approve Personnel policies to ensure the efficient operation of of the classified service so about a year and a half two years ago we overhauled our Merit rules uh we we revised about 24 articles within the Merit rules uh and then of for of course we uh collaborate with our employer the superintendent to ensure that we're meeting the employer's need and aligning with

132her vision um so we have three Commissioners one commissioner is appointed by the classified employees that would be the largest bargaining unit which is csca 887 that's Veronica Palmer uh we have a commissioner that is actually appointed by the governing board that's uh Karen Schwarz and then those two Commissioners appoint the third commissioner which is Anette shrie she's the U commer U commissioner appointed uh commissioner and then for staff myself uh LTE kintar is our Personnel commission analyst and Sylvia pay our Personnel commission specialist so this past year um our Focus was on three primary goals uh big one was the class and comp system or class and comp uh study um I felt like this kind of um impacted other um work goals and tasks and so laying this Foundation was really really critical

133to our operations um it impacted our uh recruitment strategies as well as um our work in aligning with smc's uh vision for equity so the um the study was actually started in March of 2023 so it was actually the year before but bulk of the work was uh conducted last year working with the consultant our employees our management cabinet you know making sure that the major Milestones of this project were were getting pushed forward um and then in this this past October the Personnel commission approved the the study but the study had two main phases it was the classification phase and then the compensation phase the uh classification phase um for for that part of the study the most important part was really building a system we really didn't have a system before the study

134we had a bunch of job descriptions that did a pretty poor job of capturing the work that our employees performed we didn't really have a system of classifying our our uh our positions so the consultant came in and built these broadly based class structures or categories and now we can build positions from those categories for the compensation phase uh the goal was to build a competitive compensation structure where we're we're looking at the top earning potential of our job classes but we're also looking at um uh non-compensable perks like our Health and Welfare benefits um longevity PTO practice um you know paid time off uh uh uh rights um SDI and retirement contributions we were looking at all of these things and how do we match up with the neighboring Market in the end we

135had 37 uh classification modifications 10 reclassified positions and six new uh job classes so the the compensation study revealed that um taken as a whole we were about 3.6% above the median the median is the the most commonly used statistic in a study like this um some people use the mean or average but we find that there are outliers whether it's like an agency that pays really high that would skew that number and bring it up or you know on the flip side an agency that pays really low and that would bring that number down so we're looking at really the middle number that's that's kind of like the most commonly used statistic and our goal was to be 5% above that median so you know you know just based on the salaries we saw

136that we were about 3.6% above the medium so we still had a little work to do to get to that Target but once we considered the compensation packet or I'm sorry the the benefits then that number dropped to 1.9% below below the the market median so um the goal of the consultant was to put together a plan that kind of positioned this so where we were more competitive with our our Market it' been about 20 years since we did our last successful study I think the agency did we tried to do a study about five years ago but it wasn't successfully implemented so this is um it's an accomplishment it's been about 20 years and this is one of the the outcomes of the study um it's kind of a silver lining for us because

137we had talked about uh doing more marketing for our our positions uh never really getting around to it most agencies will just post a job description if you were to go on uh any agency's ATS system you'll see a job description as they're posting right but what we um are doing now is being a lot more intentional a lot more strategic in a marketing our position so we're talking about the department that is going to that where the position exists the team that they're going to be working with um the characteristics that we're looking for and and then front and center is our uh the smc's equity Vision you know we want to make sure that we're bringing in people that align with that that that vision and then like I said you know we're

138aligning our work with you know smcoe Equity Vision um and this is done through our selection process so for the next three slides this is um related to data that um the first slide is related to uh Recruitment and selection you'll see that we didn't have as many recruitments as we had in the previous year and that's not indicative of anything that should there's an EV and flow to the work that we do um but that impacts the data that you see down below you know we didn't administer as many um examinations we didn't have as many eligibility this but again this is you know there's an EV and flow to this work um I do want to show I do want to point out the applications received you see that even though we had

139fewer recruitments you know we did show that there was an increase in the applications receive and that tells us that you know smcoe still uh remains an attractive employment option for our employees and uh the public for appointments and separation um we were we went down from the previous year we had uh 47 hires both Promotional and uh open and new hires uh in 2223 to 39 hires in 2324 um so again you know we're doing less recruitments there's not as many positions to fill one thing I do want to p uh point out is the um the substitutes um we've steadily increased our subpool I mean that number is not going to blow anybody's hair back but um you know that's we are very aware that there are Staffing shortages in our uh special

140ed program and Court courton Community Schools so um we've made a conscious effort to build our subpools um you know it it has its own challenges you know it's hard to find people that want to do this work on on call as needed basis without benefits and retirement contributions but and the people that are on our sub pools they're also subbing in other areas so their reliability is you know it's difficult it's really difficult and this uh next data set we didn't have a whole lot of data to report on this because we were going through a comp and class study so a lot of the new job classes we defer to that that process and then goals going forward um now that we have have the comp class study done um you know we

141want to establish a system for where're where we're periodically reviewing our job classes and pay structures so that it doesn't you know get out of whack you know what happens when you're not looking at this for a long period of time you know um you naturally have these class errors um and you know redundancy in classifications so um put a process in place where we're you you know constantly reviewing this stuff um continue to build effective Recruitment and selection systems um and uh use CPI continuous process Improvement and in our work since I've been here you know I've I've consistently used CPI analysis to look at um the work that we're doing our service and see how we can get better at what we do and that's it um do want to thank the it

142and Facilities departments they're instrumental in setting up our rooms for when we're doing our meetings or running our exams so you know we can't do what we do without them and then everyone that participated in oral panels as well we want to thank them as well I don't know if anyone has any questions are there any comments or questions from the board I see none um thank you um are there any comments from the public no comments but if I can say that um executive director Perez was an amazing leader through the comp and class study it's a very difficult thing to pull off without um dismantling the entire organization and um Everybody did their part they leaned in they shared their feedback there was we slowed down to listen more um we made adjustments

143along the way and we kept on going but um executive director Perez's leadership is really um stellar and and it's a very big deal that the county office was able to get ourselves into this position that we are and the greatest thing is that it honors all of our employees um so um it's it really speaks to what we aspire to be as an organization thank you um there is no action to take on this item um for item 11b Kevin Baltimore Deputy superintendent Business Services Division and Tammy Moore ass associate superintendent Human Resources will present the public disclosure of the collective bargaining agreement between the San Mato County Superintendent of Schools and California School Employees Association and it's chapter8 for 2024 2025 so the timing of this is very appropriate because we just talked

144about the class and comp study and really this represents um a one-year agreement to implement the class and comp study um with our csca 158 group um we note that the total cost of this agreement is um $61 12,151 that's an estimate and because this is being implemented with an effective date of January 1 the fiscal impact will be about half of that for the current fiscal year but we did want to point out that that is a cost that will be ongoing by moving to the new salary schedule um we're very pleased with this agreement the reality was one of the priorities we had um when we received the class en comp study was trying to make adjustments as close to the classroom as possible and it was noted that our PA professionals were

145some of the most under Market funded positions that we had in our organization so this implements the study we're pleased with it um I would also report to the board that CSA 158 has also ratified this agreement on their end so we provide this as information to you and to the public any questions or comments from the board any comments from the public no comments thank you there is no action to take on this item for item 11c the board will receive the initial proposal for from California School Employees Association chapter8 to the Sano county superintendent of schools for the 2024 2025 reopener collective bargaining agreement this item will be brought back at the January 15 2025 board meeting for a public hearing Moore associate superintendent Human Resources is available to answer any questions the

146board may have associate superintendent Moore good evening board president Torres members of the board superintendent McGee you have before you the initial proposal from uh CCA chapter8 to the Santo county superintendent of schools for the 2024 2025 reopener collective bargaining agreement and I am available for any questions you may have any comments or questions from the board any comments from the public no comments thank you there is no action to take on this item thank you um for item 11d the board will receive the employer's initial proposal for the sateo county superintendent of schools to California School Employees Association chapter8 for the 2024 2025 reopener collective bargaining agreement this item will be brought back at the January 15 2025 board meeting for a public hearing Tammy Moore human um associate superintendent Human Resources is available

147to answer any questions the board may have you additionally to um add to the last item you do have the initial proposal from the Sano County Superintendent of Schools to CSEA chapter8 and I am available for any questions you may have any comments or questions from the board any from the public no thank you there is no action to take on this item for item 11e um the superintendent will have comments superintendent McGee do you have any comments to share just very quickly congratulations to the new term to board members benini and Taurus on being reelected to your seats and to newly elected board members love and O'Neal um looking forward to working with you in the 2025 year um I also want to extend congratulations to um board president Hugo torz um I learned

148through social media that you uh were recently uh named as the region five educator of the Year by the California League of Educators and California League of middle schools as principal at voices Flagship College Bound Language Academy and that is uh a pretty sign significant honor to be the educator of the year as a seconde principal 16 months 16 months there you go so congratulations um principal Torres that's a really quite astounding and uh finally just wishing everyone a happy safe and healthy holiday season I want to extend that to all of our staff um to their families and to all of our board members and or families um smcoe is closed to the public starting next Monday December 23rd through Sunday January 5th um we are open for business again on the 6th of

149January 2025 that's all my comments thank you for item 12a the board will discuss and act on joint resolution number 24- 59 regarding the Sano County Board of Education joining the association of California County Boards of Education acbe board member Gerard would you like to start this discussion um yes I I really uh would like to uh reiterate um my enthusiasm um for our new uh accb and I would be happy to answer any questions that uh any of the board members may have um if I can regarding it um I will say that the good news is that we're very excited that on Monday evening at their meeting pler County and talami County both voted unanimous unanimously to join um the accb um are there any questions trusty Alvaro I had the same questions

150I had last time Mr rod which is how is this going to affect our gamut our other which you know I don't much like gamut but it's what we use and our other csba services and what about the overlap in fees and not paying the county search charge with csba have they made any decisions have they made any motion about what how this is going to look I mean they meaning csba uh C SBA hasn't said anything about the overlap of any kind of funding it doesn't affect our gamut services or any of those services at all will still be a member of csba and so consequently any services that we're currently receiving from csba we will continue to receive there will be no change there um and uh it was discussed um at the

151conference but uh C SBA is remaining very silent on anything that has to do with with any kind of uh fees and the way that they calculate um all of our fees not only just County boards but school districts as well they're not being forthcoming with any information at all so we made a decision a while back to withhold we paid our csba fees right we paid our gamut fees we paid all the other things when we made a decision to withhold the piece where they were going to charge us double basically for existing we're still doing that and here we are at the end of the year so my question is they there's been no mention and I understand you said they were silent I'm just saying about they're not going to suddenly go

152well you didn't pay your no okay can I yes add on um so I I met with Beverly and with many other County board members who are forming that have you know been working to form the entity when we were in Anaheim and ask them very pointed questions exactly as you raised them because I wanted to be able to have that you know answer that if I could um what I learned in addition to what um trusty Gerard to Shared is that there are a number of other counties who have not paid the the former ccbe portion um and uh most all of them also use gamut and they're paying the same as we are and that um the percentage of the amount of fees that we from our budgets you know that we pay

153for that amount is it's very minuscule it's something I think Beverly had um some stats about it but it's like fractions of a percent of budget right and so uh I was also had that similar concern because I obviously we we want to make sure we have consistent service um I think it was really incumbent upon csba to address it and they haven't and it's been this long and um so I'm really comfortable with the fact that those fees are better placed in this new organization that will really have many other it will be performing a lot of different um uh very useful um services for us and we will be able to participate in those that csba really is not doing in terms of our advocacy the issues that we have raised tonight around

154the excess property taxes those kinds of things those are issues that the acbe will focus on probably not csba and so I feel really confident about that um and you're right we haven't heard from csba and I think we should have if they they had an issue with it I think they should have raised it but they have been as Beverly said well they made a promise I think that they were going to have a resolution for the December meeting that you went to and got absolutely no answers right no are you talking about csba csba yeah yes uh we met with them um on uh Tuesday Morning um the group that was in the transition group and basically the questions that we had been asking other than the very general ones that they did

155address and that was sent to All County board members um any of the things about budget and transparency were not answered and what I can say is that we're paying our csba dues as I said we'll get all those Services gamut is actually a a separate fee from the csba so as long as we pay that and we belong to csba we get that service um and the fact that they are refusing the transparency um is concerning not only to us but to District boards as well it's something that County boards brought up that District boards now and the board of directors are also saying hey wait a minute you know how do you figure out all this money because what we pay is minuscule compared to some of what of the larger counties pay

156and our our fee actually for um ccbe was $4,225 a year and uh one of the well Ivon Chan of the LA County Board actually went through which is amazing to me every county in the state and calculated what percentage of their budget and she used the county offices budget for the year 2223 to figure out what percentage that was that percentage of our budget of samon County Office of education's budget for that year was Point 004 that's how much of the budget went to ccbe so that's how it was calculated it's on the website um that we've established so if you want to go in and look you can do that and uh and see exactly what it says yeah my concern isn't what is going to be paid to the new organization um

157my concern is what csba is going to turn around and say in a couple months what like you didn't pay that so I I honestly can't answer that because csba is forth coming with anything right and in fact they're completely ignoring when it's asked and it it's been asked over and over and over they know they're in hot water quite frankly they know they're in trouble with that because all of the county offices are screaming bloody murder that we're being charged double for things that district offices are receiving for the current um amount of money that they're paying for their dues and it that's not fair and so we're not the only ones questioning that good thank you any other comments yes um trusty kamacho uh so when when we if we adopt this resolution

158this is committing us to being a paying member of this right pardon me if we adopt this resolution this is committing this County Board to be a paying yes member and so what the dues for discounting will be the same as what they were for csba it'll be that 4,000 something it's exactly the same okay so it's the same yes um what and I'm assuming that it is that initial pool of dollars is going to come only from boards that adopt this and become members correct so we have an unclear over or a ccbe has an unclear sense of what budget they're going to be operating with we actually have a budget and again you can go into the website and see that and there is additional monies um we actually have several people and

159organizations including um the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors that are giving us money um as a feed to start the organization so um we've already been able to hire someone that is helping us with like our uh websites and all of those kinds of things with that feed money okay um I I was going to add if I can um you know the hope is I think that um all the county all the counties would join um but I think the fact is that not all the counties are actually members of csba so we probably won't have all the counties um and um you know so it's it's a a they're they' they're working really hard to get all the counties on board and so just the fact that recently or last week or

160whenever it was that um pler and follow me and they you know so they were reporting out on it I was just attending their their subcomittee meeting but um seems like it's getting pretty good traction that's my my feeling about it we actually have a whole spreadsheet that we looked at at our last meeting last Monday night um with all the counties listed and we have um about 27 counties right now that have committed to joining um in November um I mean January excuse me I don't know where November came from um in January and February and then there are others that are are maybe in there are only two out of the um entire state that are nose um since it's a public discussion I just want to be kind of upfront with my

161hesitations and where they come from um as an example we heard from um you know our own Center for data learning analytics whatever that is the title I'm sorry if I got it wrong there is so much reporting and so many agencies and so much overlap and so many things going into things that are not direct student service pro don't provide direct student services so much so that csba has commissioned this study on like how many reports do we have have it to do and I get nervous about creating another body in a in a time when csba and I have lots of you know all the thoughts I have about csba and its leadership but um csba has been able to establish itself as at least an influencer in policy and sacramental that is

162something that is a true thing and it's taken time for them to do that alongside that the California county superintendents have been have more so allowed themselves to become an influencer on legislation in Sacramento and so I just where my hesitation comes from is how do you do this startup thing how much does this startup thing take away from the efforts that and it is slow progress and you all know that I'm the least patient with slow progress in education um that's all this is based in is I'm nervous about that in January um we have slated uh two pieces of legislation that we're going to be addressing and working on and we all have gotten the help of the San Diego uh County of office education and they're private lobbyists are willing to work

163with us and those two pieces of leg legislation one is in partnership with the PTA on literacy which is a direct reflection on students and the second piece is on um getting student board members onto County boards throughout the state and that's the second piece that that we're looking at so those are our first two um that we really want to look at and are very very excited about and uh we're working in Partnerships with people that can help us do that and part of our function and it was the same thing with ccbe is advocating for students for our students we have as I don't I'm preaching to the choir here we have completely different students than than uh District students that we're dealing with and um we fall through the cracks so part

164of what what we're doing with our advocacy and um all of the things that we want to address are meeting those needs of those students that are falling through the crack so we want to be very very proactive um um with legislators and saying and we've already started by the way there's a lot of legislators uh legislators that know that what we're doing and are very supportive um because that over the over the uh time some of it gets through with csba but a lot of it doesn't because they are for district boards and I'll argue that till the death so um part of what we want to do with acbe which we did with ccbe is Advocate and and process and go after all of that legislation that wasn't addressed through csba and I'll

165just add that I um I understand the hesitations um I was I had the opportunity to connect with folks in Anaheim um specifically um the board members of accb and the drivers behind this group um I know is going to make an impact and be as influential if not more than the other organizations that currently exist and I think our goal is to event to collaborate and get all people on board so that we have stronger groups attacking legislation and other issues that we want to tackle um as a group that's just starting again with the people driving it I don't see the harm in in trying it out this year and if it doesn't work we can revisit it for next year um and it's not a a huge Financial Risk to to embark

166on this just my thoughts trusty banini oh I also just want to add that I in my questions to the the accb board and um just around their goals and their purpose and we did talk to them a lot about um the student Focus like we brought your questions to that board all of our questions from our board and it's really um whether you know obviously working together with other organizations is a it's a two-way street so they have to want to work with you but there was no one in the room in the table that was saying that we wanted to go this on our own and like just do County boards like we want to partner they're already doing Partnerships with the PTA um any organization that wants to partner so if there's

167alignment with what's going on I think the same as when it was ccbe alignment with csba like we want to work with csba you know and the superintendent Association so um or or any other Association that's aligned so I think it's a yes it's a this and and it's a growing concept but I think that Bev's absolutely right that when I've participated in the legislative action days lately the last few years there's there aren't County focused issues um they can only focus on so many to sort of have talking points that it's rational you know for a short period but um our issues don't make it to the top of the list I appreciate all that additional context and for taking the questions to Anaheim um I would reiterate Mr torres's his highlight is let's

168make sure we don't become another un like we talked about cycles of continuous Improvement right let's make sure we continue to revisit that instead of becoming another entity that's just an entity for its sake its own sake that makes me happy that this is a group that's going to be committed to that um because I'm willing to try something trusty lab just wanted to say um I was a little ambivalent about all of this before until I went to Anaheim and um you know there was a strand for County offices but it wasn't a genuine strand this the sessions really weren't I'm a new board County Board member and this is going to help elevate my thinking and that really was clear with the breakfast I was just kind of Blown Away by the County

169Board breakfast was CCE coming and doing a presentation and they kind of compete with the counting office on some things so that that was the decision um to have present at that meeting just seemed like really out of touch so my mind has shifted a bit since that meeting thank you um any other questions or comments from the board okay I'm seeing none um are there any comments from the public no comments okay is there a motion to approve joint resolution number 24- 59 regarding the San Mato County Board of Education joining the association of California County Boards of Education don't move is there a second second there is a motion to approve joint resolution number 24- 59 made by trustee Gerard and a second by trusty banini is there any further discussion all those

170in favor say I I all those opposed say no uh the motion passes with a vote of 70 and Joint resol solution number 2459 has been approved thank you so much you we won't disappoint thank you for being patient with all those questions but this you know there's two sides of it one is what's this going to benefit us yes the other is is it gonna come back to bite us later on and we don't really know so thank you for being patient you're welcome thank you for item 12b the board will discuss its compensation and potentially act on changes superintendent McGee thank you um the board has the opportunity to discuss and increase its comp compensation on an annual basis and I would say that um for this particular year uh I would encourage

171the board to increase its compensation um we are in strong strong financial standing we are current with all of our negotiations there's no um political overshadow on um the board adding a few dollars literally to your monthly uh earnings so um my recommendation would be that you increase the amount this year and um and I turn it back over to president Torres to lead the discussion thank you are there any comments or questions from the board any from the public no comments is there a motion regarding the board's compensation does um is there a second second um do have to State what the motion is yeah I think um board member O'Neal just State uh I move to I move to increase the board compensation to 378 a month there you go thank you um

172and is there a second second um there is a motion to increase the board's compensation made by trusty O'Neal and a second by truste Gerard is there any further discussion all those in favor say I I I all those opposed say no the motion passes with a vote of 70 and the board has voted to increase its compensation for item 12 C when an ad hoc subcommittee meets or a representative attends a meeting related to their given assignment uh board members may choose to bring a report to the board at this time would any board members like to report out are there any comments or questions from the board I'm assuming none from the public thank you there is no action to take on this item for item 12d the board will discuss topics for

173future board agendas would any board member like to discuss agenda ideas yes trusty O'Neal hi I'd like to um ask that there be an agenda item in January to form a subcommittee for the low-f funded school districts for the county to begin a dialogue to see if we can do something about the lower fund districts I checked with the superintendent and there's at least eight school districts in this County that are considered lowf funded low wealth and I would like to see if we can have a subcommittee to meet with those and open a dialogue with board members superintendents Etc for those districts are there any other agenda items or ideas to discuss or that you'd like to add [Music] on okay thank you are there's no action to take on this item for item

17412E board members will comment um trusty love thank you I just want to say that I am filled with gratitude tonight um to be here with all of you for the 28,000 plus voters who voted for me and then for all of the County Office of Education people who have been my family for the last seven plus years it's been wonderful and we couldn't find better people to be in these roles and I have a lot of gratitude for all of you and all the folks who aren't here Jennifer for working alongside me so just a lot of gratitude tonight thank you thank you chess onel I'd like to say I'm looking forward to working with all of you and meeting some of the challenges we have in education my background I was on the

175board of Pacifica school district 14 years the city council for 10 years so I have some you know extensive background in elected office and I also want to thank the staff because the onboarding process has been pretty easy so thank you very much thank you and happy holidays everybody trusty Alvaro thank you um I want to start out by saying goodbye to administrator love and thanking her for seven years of service the communications from this office it's always been a challenge and we've talked about it since I've been on the board I've never seen them done as well as they've been in the last several years you set a really high bar I've actually enjoyed looked forward to reading the school news and and other things that come out of the Communications office um so

176I wanted to to just say thank you for your service and we'll miss you and then I want to say um congratulations to Chelsea and Hugo and welcome to Patricia and mik um W Hugo educator of the year you didn't tell us we had to find out from superintendent McGee I don't like to br [Laughter] you know as we move into a what could be a very difficult period for public education it is it is comforting to be surrounded by people who always have the students best interests at heart I mean I know that we that we disagree on some particulars but in the main we sit here completely United for what the work needs to be done um um Chelsea I want to thank you for your leadership this past year it's not been

177a real easy year and you've represented us really well out in the world as well as here and uh chairing the policy committee I mean what a huge lift that was we're not done ever but we got the entire I mean we got this huge thing done it's all up online it's all able it's all findable and thank you for cheering that committee because that was just a huge amount of work um and then Mr Mr Paris is gone right he's not here anymore well I'll say it anyway I think that was probably the most informative report from the Personnel commission that I have heard in all of the years I've ever sat on this board um yeah I'll leave it at that I I just think that was the most informative report I've ever

178heard so thank you and happy holidays thank you trusty kamacho um I just would Echo all of um trusty alvaro's comments about welcome and congratulations and thank you so welcome to our two new colleagues and um congratulations to president Doris and thank you to trusty bonini for all she's done this year um earlier this evening I got to join um the Santa Clara County Board of educ a as they um seated two new members um who are friends to a lot of us in this room um J Pacho and Jessica Spicer who are going to be incredible County board members in Santa clar County so I was really excited to be there for that um and then just a little minute on Anaheim um it seems like it was a long time ago but maybe

179it was who knows what happens with time now um I I I I appreciate trusty love you bringing up like those the absence of a county presence was very it was very apparent um more so than in past years um I think there was probably an an assumption that an entity as big as csba could figure it out and it was apparent that they did not and I don't know that they want to but um what I did appreciate was being able to spend time with you all um to while we were there in Anaheim it's always also great to connect with other County board members across the state um who who knows if we're going to see each other as often anymore um given the new structure but that the annual conference is just

180a great time to to refocus on um good governance on sharing of ideas um and just reconnecting with our colleagues so I appreciate being able to spend time with all of you um in Anaheim um thank you superintendent McGee for hosting us for a great dinner which was a combination of board members and staff so thank you for those of you that I was able to see down there um and and uh I think that's it so I'll just say oh and thank you again for those reports I always feel badly because we ask these questions or don't ask questions and they're just standing there like well it's not really you it's the system um but I I would please if you can re-extend our thanks for the incredible professionalism and and just the knowledge

181that they bring to every presentation is it always knocks my socks off and uh makes me proud to tell others about the things that our people do so thank you thank you trusty bonini thank you um well I'll start by um appreciating the very kind presentation thank you for that superintendent migy um it was really such an honor to serve as president for the last year um just there's so much that that we can do together and I really um I enjoyed um serving in that capacity and I'm excited that Hugo congratulations that you're going to be moving moving into that role um and you know uh we'll figure out who's going to do all the the chairing and the the Committees we have a lot of committees um yes we'll see um and so

182yes so thank you very much um I also want to appreciate the reports um I really uh enjoyed U Mr Polo's report um because it was just so detailed and and as I think um trusty kamacho stated very eloquently just like there's so much depth of his knowledge in that regard and I learned a lot from listening so I really really appreciated that I um I also wanted to appreciate M Tran for her amazing work um with the county office I know um a lot of people who have spoken with over the years who with her and that's she's just I know that was very well-deserved and very amazing um Welcome to our new board members I look forward to working with you both in this and I want to wish everyone um a restful

183break and happy holidays thank you trusty Gerard um thank you um I'm also echoing um trusty alvaro's comments she always is very eloquent and says things so beautifully that I know I can't do as well um so I'll say ditto um to Chelsea and to uh Patricia and um to Mike is it Mike or Michael Mike Mike okay some people are very particular so I just want to make sure um and the reports were amazing tonight uh you're right um there was tons of information and all of it so important and I've learned a little trick over the years um I'm usually real quiet because if I wait long enough everybody else on the board asks all the right WR questions and I get all my answers and I just have to sit here and

184smile and that happened tonight so thank you all um for being eloquent um I also want to thank you again for approving the resolution um we're working really really hard and having um pretty much weekly meetings that are lasting two to two and a half hours um but nothing until after the first of the year now so that's good um and I was very disappointed quite frankly in the uh csba conference and for all the reasons that everybody else has said um as far as networking went that's always Priceless and not only being able to meet and talk with um County board members but also board members from other districts throughout the state and um I uh lost two cohorts that were always there and I have to mention them and that's Juliana F ferani

185from talami and Janet from monay and both of them Janet um lost her election and Juliana has retired so it's a huge loss because both of them are amazing amazing board members and people and huge advocates for students so anyway um I want to wish everyone a very happy holiday and uh a very very very happy new year and I'm looking forward to seeing everyone next year thank you thank you um I'll start off by congratulating um trusty Panini and then just thanking you for um your year of service and then also working with you in that year to learn and just prepare me better for this role so thank you um Welcome to our new board members um I'm really excited to do this work um with this group moving forward and um our

186time in Anaheim was great thank you to superintendent McGee it was really great to have um the team there with the board um I think we need to start doing that more frequently that was just um a beautiful time that just flew by um but it was very meaningful a lot of beautiful conversations and it just deepened our connection and a reminder of our why our Collective why um so that was just beautiful and just thank you for interesting me with this role um I feel very honored and very privileged and I just love all of you so thank you and I hope you all have um a great holiday break um item 13 is the adjournment uh the next regular meeting will take place on Wednesday January 15 2025 at 7 p.m. and this

187meeting is now adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.