CorpusRecord 106561

SMUHSD Board Meeting - December 19, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Board Meeting
Date
2024-12-20
Location
San Mateo County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
21,007 words · about 117 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001by trustee Chavis the board approved resolution number 25- excuse me 24- 25-8 to wave the confidentiality of discussions in close session meetings relating to the circumstances surrounding the decision to vote to non- reelect employee number 17055 the purpose of Defending against the allegations and the petition for RIT of mandate filed by employee number 17055 on June 12th 2024 in San M County Superior Court case number 24- C- 03585 the votes were as follows trusty Griffin yes trusty Jake Chavez Excuse me yes trusty Jacobson yes and I voted yes trusty land was absent in close session upon the motion of trusty Griffin and seconded by trusty Chavis the board denied a liability claim with a vote of four to Zer the votes were as follows trusty Griffin yes trusty Chavis yes trusty Jacobson yes and I

002voted yes Tristy land was absent all right right I will turn the meeting over now to superintendent Booker thank you very much so this is item J swearing in of elected uh Board of Trustees um just I want to give a little Preamble before we do the swearing in as certified on December 5th 2024 by the Sano County chief elections officer Mark Church whereas the number of nominees for the office of governing board member does not exceed the number of offices required by law to be filled at the general election ction on November 5th 2024 within the Sano Union High School District for areas 2 and four the following persons are required to be appointed to fouryear terms trustee area 2 Greg land and trustee area 4 liia Andra Zuniga tonight I will administer a

003ceremonial oath of office so if the two of you could repeat after me I State your names I do solemnly swear do solemnly swear swear that I will support and defend that I will support defend the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California and the constitution of the State of California against all enemies foreign and domestic all enemies foreign and domestic that I will bear true faith and Allegiance that I will Bear full trth and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States to the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California and the constitution of the State of California that I take this obligation freely that I take this obligation freely without any mental reservation without without any mental reservation or purpose of

004evasion or purpose of evasion and that I will well and faithfully and I will well and Faithfully discharge the duties discharge the duties upon which I'm about to enter upon about to enterer congratulations both of you four more years four more four more years can we do a photo absolutely yeah okay let's go where do you want to go if we can go toward that way yeah okay no you're good yeah I'm coming will this be okay not self so thanks for the Indulgence um I just want to um honor one of our special guests here we have former uh trustee and csba delegate uh Clayton coup from Jefferson Elementary District so just want to acknowledge and thank you for repres being here thank you all right I'm Gonna Keep Us going yes sir okay

005letter K is the organization of the Board of Trustees uh at this meeting the board shall first elect a slate of president vice president and clerk from its members then we'll do a second motion second and vote as the board shall appoint the district representative for the county committee on School District Organization for one year and then thirdly we'll take a motion second and a vote on appointing a secretary to the board so at this point can I get someone to nominate a president vice president and a clerk from its members point of information or point of order um in our bylaws we have a specific set of rotation so I just wanted to maybe remind everyone of that rotation we kind of call it the Dave Pine rule so I just wanted to make

006sure that we're honoring that rotation I believe so yes is that a yes yes okay yeah that's all I wanted to know yep thank you someone needs to make a motion I'll make I'll make the motion is the motion for all five or just three it's one at a time so a president vice president and clerk we start right there those three one at a time all together okay okay I'll make the motion for Griffin for the president myself trusty Chavez for the vice president trusty Jacobson for the clerk second okay hold on real quick because that is the order okay A a motion made by truste Chavez for Robert Griffin to be president Terry Chavez to be vice president and Jennifer Jacobson to be uh clerk with a second by Greg uh Gregory land

007all those in favor say I I I opposed extensions all right motion passes 5 Z thank you very much next the board shall appoint the District representative for the county committee on School District Organization for one year can I entertain a motion I'd like to volunteer okay uh I'll second it's just a once a year maybe twice a year meeting that's all I'm volunteering for done it a couple times I haven't done it in a few years so I did it two years ago the was canceled actually exactly it doesn't do a lot so I was like but once in a while it gets interesting okay I have a motion by truste land and a second by truste Andra Zena for Greg land to be our District representative for the county committee on School District

008Organization for one year all those in favor say I I I opposed exensions all right motion passes and lastly we need the board to appoint a secret AR to the board I'll entertain a motion I move to appoint misso as secretary to the board that so point of order I think it's me I think it's the superintendent and he gets to orign I make a motion to appoint Mr Booker second sorry about that uh we're gonna do a second by Mr land thank you um okay all those in favor for superintendent Booker uh to serve as Secretary of the board say I I I any opposed and any abstentions okay that motion passes and before I hand it back over to Mr Griffin uh as president of the board uh I just want to take

009a moment to thank lehia or trustee and ofuna uh for her year of service uh mentorship support um you know all of the above you've been a fantastic sounding board this past year you've made my uh second year of being superintendent really special uh we traversed a lot uh a lot a lot a lot and uh I think we've done really great work with the support of the rest of the board and District staff all of our Educators our families our students and really moving the needle in support of our students so we want to thank you with these flowers uh and and and really just shine a light on your service uh we're so grateful so thank you very much I my very it was a really good year thank you thank you you

010know I just I just want to say lehia you had a very it was hard to just come in as your first time as president in this year there was so much going on and you handled it with Grace and Poise um and your expertise was well needed all throughout the year um so really congratulations you did a great job and thank you for taking the for us I could just add to that real quickly we we've had like you said a lot happening this year we've had a lot of things happening worldwide issues Folks at the podium arguing with other folks in the audience and back and forth and you've done such a tremendous job of just thank you calming the waters and and really saying you know we're going to limit the public

011comment or also just stepping in there at the right time and saying we have to have a civil conversation or we can't continue the meaning as is and thank you for your leadership thank you I'll second that third that whatever's left um you know it really is difficult and I think you know you had so much tack when you tried to get people to behave and be quiet and uh um you really you know you really did a great job I appreciate it thanks thank you very much I will force that a thank so much thank you very much thank you everybody know it's great and I love this district and I love this just what we do here and the student and I enjoy it so I enjoy you all so thank you thank

012you all right Mr Griffin it's all yours gav's yours gonna now we get to do chaos no I'm just kidding I right let's see how he handles it yeah the last time I did it was uh covid oh yeah yeah it was it was no picnic but anyway welcome everyone to the meeting tonight uh I think we're at public comments if you are joining us in person and wish to make a comment about an agenda item or during the public comment section at the beginning of the agenda please fill out a request to address the board and form and submit it to the secretary this form should be given to the secretary before the agenda item begins if you are joining us virtually use the raised hand feature on Zoom to be recognized when invited

013to do so so your camera must be on before you are called upon to make a public comment we will call on you to begin your comment once we have been once we have promoted you into the meeting if your camera is not operational please email your comments to the Board of Trustees at boards smsd.org that's boards SMU hsd.org please note that comments are limited to three minutes the board president may increase or decrease the time allowed for public comment depending on the topic and the number of persons wishing to be heard I will call on in-person comments first there are no in-person comments okay um well actually says Mr Keen are there any hands raised on Zoom there is one hand raised I'll now promote Cassie cook Miss Cook you can accept the invitation

014he's not accepting on her end well thank you um governing board comments actually and I'm going to back it up uh Greg Greg started this so I'll uh I see we have a council member at uh from Foster City here and I'd like to recognize Patrick Sullivan it was concerning me because I'm wondering what's he here for it he didn't say anything but anyway welcome Patrick welcome congratulations on being reelected y look forward to your service I okay okay well I'm sure I'm I'm the lia Zone to Foster City somehow so we'll have to get together and you can fix that pothole in front of my street anyway anyway welcome glad glad to see you okay governing board comments I would like to start with our student board Representatives good evening hi my name is

015tville pentu and I'm from Mills High School I would just like to give a shout out to my high school Mills for the outstanding Winter concert that we held this past Friday um I would like to say that our students at Mills are incredibly talent in the musical field and that I'm so proud of them for the three concerts they put on during school and one after school so shout out to our Mills um musical students thank you hi my name is Elizabeth bors and I am also from Mills High School as a recap in events at our high school in the previous month we are slowly winding down in our Sports and Club participation as finals have arrived and with that this entire week Mill students and all students across Sano Union High School

016District have been completing finals with their teachers additionally um it is noted that within the past two weeks many students have been receiving decisions for universities if they are seniors and I proud to announce that I've been accepted to Stanford y conratulations congratulations awesome thank you for that Sterling report appreciate it uh board comments uh trusty andr Zuniga yes yes yes yes um I attended the equity advisory committee last week and we really we need more people to attend so if you all can if anyone out there wants to join us please do we went over the um three different um topics one was about our ml students one multi students one was about our attendance and suspensions um or suspensions and and uh expulsions I believe sorry and there was one more um that

017we had as well and um one of the nice things about this this committee is that we can sit with different people from different schools and then also um from different districts um we get to talk um with parents and um sometime students join us but we really need more people um to keep moving this work forward and I just want to say thank you to to um to Dr uh kmy um she and um Mr Simmons run these groups and there it's great um let's see I also um with the county committee on School District organization um it's a very important group so we need people that are interested in giving comments or finding out about what the group is about and it's important for our families to know so if you're interested um

018we have the information on our website of when we meet and so please please come to the group if you're interested in giving comment um we also all attended the Schoolboard Association conferences um that was it was really nice to see everybody from the different districts um but some of the information that um that we really that we got out of it was um about our students and moving the needle um it's kind of in the same theme as the other conferences that I had attended and that if you know if we're not moving the needle we need to ask more questions and we need to um evaluate what we're doing in our district to make sure that needle is moved um if we aren't if our students are not excelling then there's something that

019we have to to change that so I want to I strongly believe that that's what we do here so um then thank you to our it folks and to everybody that keeps our our district going um happy holidays and um thank you that's it thank you trusty Lan um I'm I'm gonna try to be a little brief because um trusty Andra Zena said it pretty much everything I wanted to say but um first it mine was in different order so first happy holidays um break is coming up I just want to thank the teachers staff and students for all the work they've done getting through the finals this week um just really appreciating hope that they can enjoy the break with their families and you know I think that's important I apologize I'm in the

020ugly sweater day uh my whole staff was you know and our principles and and Burling game we're wearing these kind of sweaters for a little levity um second of all I do appreciate going to the you know California school boards Association um my take was uh there were some really valuable um sessions uh for me the most uh the best takeaways were about Ai and I know we've already started some work with that and I appreciate the study session that we did but what I'm noticing is you know we really have to evaluate how to utilize AI it's not going away and how can we best utilize it for our students for our staff um even for our board we you know AI there was a whole session that paloalto did on how we can

021increase our capacity through you know summarizing policies and having ai go through the stuff that maybe we don't want to go through as as quickly as we you know and so we don't miss things um it was really an interesting meeting um also I was part of the delegate assembly um I'm that might come up again but through the delegate assembly we were really talking about the federal changes that were going to be taking place with the new Administration coming in and the concerns that special education funding might in Jeopardy yeah and that title 9 and um laws that we have just gotten recently passed the shift that for Title 9 actually might be taken away and and dismantled so yeah um these are things that we need to be aware of and we need

022to as Schoolboard members need to be on top of and know what's going on and protect our students and protect our schools um finally I will end unfortunately on a on a more somber note um while you know you mention you know trusty and Andra Zuniga mentioned the BHS student well the BHS student was also a bis student and a lot of my teachers at my school had such an impact on what happened because they had taught him for years and just it's just and it also touched home for me because a very similar experience happened to one of our neighbors um and they his parents have set up a foundation um Riley wator had something very similar happened and it's just I hope we can serve our students better and can we find a

023way to help them so my family my heart goes out to their family um and their friends and and to all of BHS I I do want to commend Dr fun and and superintendent Booker for sending out the information so quickly and and readily just so people would know what's going on so I thought it was handled very well so thank you guys that's it for me thank you trusty Jacobson I will um also add my condolences to all of those who were impacted by the the passing of the student at BHS um and thank uh trusty Andrade zuda for the resources that she um that she mentioned and uh I will also add my um comments about the California school boards Association conference I'm grateful to the district for um sponsoring us to go

024to that it was a really um you know good education experience I attended also a conference the day before um at and attended sessions on Student Success so I Echo some of the same concerns that um trusty Andrade Zuniga brought up about um you know moving the needle for our students and um especially we talked about the science of reading which affects more of Elementary School level but also um the the data point that really stood out to me and that was that kids who aren't proficient at reading by the end of third grade um they really never catch up and we need to I I'm interested in learning what our district does to uh help students in that in that uh situation um also math and um I did attend some sessions on CTE

025and and one specifically about a a biotech internship that I'm hoping we can explore um bringing here to our district so it was a fruitful um conference and I also want to just um acknowledge all of the the Traditions holidays that are being celebrated by many different faiths this season and um wish everyone in the district and the community uh a wonderful holiday season and happy New Year and hope that our students and staff get the rest that they need and um some well-deserved rest that we all need um so thank you trusty Chavez thank you I I want to Echo what a lot of my fellow colleagues have already said so I won't reiterate all of that um I do want to uh of course um offer my my condolences to the family and

026the entire Burling game Community as well um I want to thank our student Trustees for mentioning the winter concerts because this is the year unfortunately that I haven't attended any winter concerts but I know that they're all amazing at each School site um I think about two weeks ago I did attend a sister act with uh trusty Jennifer Jacobson at Aragon that was amazing and I know all the plays at every School site are amazing and just wonderful and I still don't understand everybody remembers all those lines every play that I've been to is about two hours long there's a little intermission in the middle so people can run and get snacks but I still am so amazed I looked around the um stage and I don't see any scripts hanging from the ceiling so

027I just still can't I'm still amazed at at everybody memorizing everything um I also want to mention about the California Schoolboard association annual conference I was very excited to attend that with my colleagues here it was my sixth conference and it my sixth annual conference and they're always amazing and they're always focused on students and that's that's the great thing about you have thousands of Trustees from around around the state of California coming together we have some keynote speak speeches that we attend uh and then for the most part you're picking your own classes whether it's Equity or Workforce housing I attended one of those or or it's on AI or it's on um multilingual Learners it's whatever you think your District needs and you want to focus on that and learn more from either

028a panel discussion or a presenter I I just think the classes and the keynote speeches were great as well as networking with fellow trustees um I do want to piggy back off of what trusty Andra Zuniga said it's about moving the needle for our district and ultimately our students um I wanted to mention one thing real quickly because the holidays are coming and tomorrow I think is the last day of school um let's see I took a hold on a screenshot earlier so sometimes uh during the two week break it's challenging for families with financial needs some Sometimes some families are challenged with making sure you have enough food on the table so I wanted to mention that there is I'm sorry you guys there is Second Harvest um Second Harvest is Silicon Valley visits

029different cities and and there's always a pickup we just had the one yesterday in San Bruno um I have friends that volunteer there once a month so that's how I know about it it's also on social media but I'm sure that there are others that if you're interested in looking if you need food um I'm concerned about our students not meet not receiving their hot lunches but there's also they have a 1 1800 line 1800 984 3663 if you need to get in contact with Second Harvest to find out where they're having the the food drop in the next couple weeks there's also Samaritan House Pantry their number is 65341 481 and they're open every day in morning and afternoon the reason why I bring this up is because when I grew up in my

030my family was uh food I grew up with the food insecurity so during the holidays it's fun to sleep in and and hang out at home and and go on just fun walks but you know when you're looking for something to eat and you have Financial insecurity food insecurity and financial insecurity go hand inand I just want folks to know that there are resources out there available in every what wherever whatever City you live in there's resources but those are a couple resources that I just that I just stated there so I just my heart goes out to just want to make sure folks are are being um communicated the phone numbers um and and being helped and supported by the by us okay thank you so much for leing me share okay I'm GNA

031have to pick up my own comments and talk faster because we got a long no no in all sincerity we really haven't met in a while and we haven't had the chance to talk and share what we've been doing um csba was great I focused on finance and budget uh the state budget and you know uh the other issues uh was academic achievement and then superintendent relations and superintendent evaluation and the evaluation was just jam-packed and Lou Lono LED that the the the improving board relations with the superintendent was so crowded that they clo I know did anybody try to go there because they closed the door oh wow that they you know they literally would not let people you know in you know because you know a lot of times a popular session people

032are on the walls and sitting on the floor yeah that one I guess it was just you know a fire code violation so anyway I enjoyed that um my next comment um has to do with um Mary Janney and I don't know if anybody recognizes that name um she served on this board for 10 years we got at least one other oldtimers recognizing that Mary Janney had served on both the Burling game board and the SEL Union High School District board and she served on this board for 10 years and um I took I took her seat when she was here and she was she went on to serve on the Burling game console and she was she was an oldtime real basic uh School Board trustee I think she was common sense no nonsense

033and I enjoyed seeing her uh her in action and she passed away at 87 um recently she had left the area but you know it was one of those things that she really did a u really did a good job for uh for the school district so um and I think the only other thing is wishing everybody happy holidays uh gets the rest spend time with loved ones and I guess we'll choose sides up after the first of the year so that's my comments um Communications to the board of trustee superintendent Booker are there any Communications none this evening recognitions are there any recogn none this evening thank you okay okay we're going to move on to the consent agenda p um does anybody wish to pull any eye oh hold it hold it hold

034it hold it I'm reading my I'm reading my script and um somewhere along here I'm lucky I pay attention at other meetings because I think we have don't we have to approve the agenda well I I just pulled that one out it's not on I don't think it's on there no it's it's not on there we we in when we we were developing the agenda and we placed the um ceremony and it got erased off the agenda okay I make a motion to approve the current agenda I second that okay we have a motion in a second all in favor I I I mean you know and I I am just glad I I you know I paid attention to that because that would have been I was gonna say you're on it I'm impressed

035well don't worry there's you know there'll be something else I'll I'll drive right through the stop sign on so anyway way okay trusty Griffin sorry we have to ask the student board reps how they vote oh sorry it's okay how do you vote on on the agenda in favor I okay thank you okay now we're gonna move on to P got to get my mouse moving the consent agenda does anybody wish to pull an item if there are no items to be pulled I will make a motion to approve the consent agenda and I'll second that okay we have a motion in a second uh uh Mr Kino are there any comments from the public there are none are there any comments online there are none okay does the board wish to discuss any of

036these items okay all in favor I I Okay so the consent agenda item P passes student board rep the student board rep and the board rep that's the one you got to remember that's new for us yeah how do you vote I I okay you know when I'm at work and I do something over and over and I don't do it right I I take a post it and I put it on my monitor so I mean because almost every activity occurs on the monitor so I got to I got to put that I got to put that on my laptop here we'll be your Post-its in the meantime yeah so we'll move on let's see that was P regular reports the report of the superintendent yes thank you very much so uh like others

037mentioned from the Board of Trustees I want to acknowledge that we have a lot of holidays that our students our Educators our community celebrate over the next few weeks we have Hanukkah December 25th through January 2nd it's a Jewish Festival that reaffirms the ideals of Judaism and commemorates in particular the rededication of the second temple of Jerusalem by the lighting of candles on each night of Hanukkah this year it begins on sunset on December 25th and lasts through January 2nd and for all who celebrate uh may this Festival bring blessings upon on you and your family uh we also have Christmas and we want to wish all of our members of our community who celebrate Christmas uh a merry Christmas with family and friends togetherness and peace uh moving on we uh every month we

038award the golden apple uh to um unbelievable uh Educators across our district and uh they go to deserving employees who go above and beyond really uh they show exemplary service dedication and resourcefulness among many other positive qualities and these presentations truly are one of the best parts uh every month um I get to watch staff come together encourage and love one another and feel recognized and this month uh we awarded two of our classified employees our CCA members golden apples the first is parvine Raman who is the library assistant at Sano high school and she has been with the district for 12 years principal V Shu said of parvine she is hardworking diligent thorough kind thoughtful and generous she has been an integral part of Sano High School since 2012 and she always has the

039students best interests in mind and at heart she wants the best of our students always making sure they get what they need and she recognizes student office AIDS by always nominating them for a bearcat award at the beginning and the end of the school year she works alongside her parent volunteers to get out and check back in thousands of textbooks and novels and during the summer she checks in when she knows we are expecting a textbook order she makes herself s available to come in uh as necessary to get books processed so she can start the new school year off prepared and ready for students and teachers when she wakes up at the crack of dawn to do some cooking she shares her wonderful and tasty treats with the staff and who can't turn down

040a cup of chai or on a cold morning parvine is sweet and kind and always wants to do the right thing and we are so lucky to have her in the Bearcat family next we have samiko shiroma and she's a mental health therapist at Hillsdale high school and she's been with the district for three years our director of mental health April Torres said of suo she has been an indispensable member of the Hillsdale high school team and the mental health and wellness program consistently bringing invaluable expertise as the most seasoned Wellness counselor at Hillsdale high in addition to her clinical expertise siko has been instrumental in supporting the onboarding of our new mental health lead and offering critical guidance and mentorship as the most experienced clinician she's played a pivotal role in ensuring a smooth

041transition for the new staff sharing her knowledge and or organizational skills to the benefit of the entire Hillsdale Community her advocacy for marginalized students particularly those in the multilingual population has been nothing short of extraordinary siko is dedicated to ensuring that these students receive the necessary resources and support and she continuously introduces Innovative student- centered ideas that address their unique challenges siko is also a v contributor to our collaborative environment she fostered strong relationships with site staff and her Wellness colleagues bringing a positive and supportive energy to the teams in both individual and group supervision sessions she arrives fully Prof uh prepared offering valuable insights that enrich our discussions and enhance the collective growth of the team siko is truly a rare gem and we are incredibly fortunate to have her at s Union High

042School District all right and then for the winter recess finally I want to acknowledge the hard work of all of our Educators this past semester uh at our January board meeting next month I will share highlights uh of the fall semester which illustrates the dedication of our team and when I say our team I mean the entire smooshed Community as we prepare to go on recess I especially want to recognize our 12month employees who do the work behind the scenes to make our campuses operate without a hitch thank you to all and if you are traveling over the recess I wish you safe travels and I always like to remind our Educators and our students even our families alike that uh winter recess is an excellent time to hit that reset button uh I hope

043all of our community members will take the time to rest reflect and reset if they feel that uh will serve them well as we head into 2025 and on a personal note I am really looking forward to 2025 uh I can't wait so let's get there uh so thank you very much thank you okay report of the district Teachers Association good evening president Griffin members of the board uh and District cabinet um uh it's it's congratulations to uh trustee Griffin uh on being president again he's the the second person I've heard about serving two non-consecutive terms as president lately um but I assure you there's no comparison with the other person um I do want to recognize um trustee Andrade Zena for her work and effort and support of all the students in the district

044the families in the district and of course all the Educators in the district so thank you and thank you for your service and looking forward to working with you in the future um there are two two items uh on the agenda tonight that are of of particular note um the first is uh the first I'll mention is is the um uh certificate or the approval of the first interim report um I'm always uh pleased or at least since the early 2000s I've been pleased that our district has been handled in such a sound um Financial way uh that the the leadership and the the the management of our district in terms of finances has been so so effective and efficient um you know uh Mr Hawkins always uses uh the often uses the phrase that

045we're in strong financial position to face challenges and and that's that's not something every District can say and sure we're we're an excess tax District basic Aid District so we're we're a little bit better off but um a lot of it does uh uh depend on uh good folks in the uh in the business department so of course uh yansy and also um uh Miss Miller and miss castano so I just want to recognize the work that they do to keep our district uh in a sound financial situation um the second item is uh I'm looking forward to hearing the presentation on the multilingual learner program um this is this is an incredible Endeavor that the district is undertaking uh the magnitude and scope really can't be overstated um that said uh and I'm glad

046to see that there are so many successes but that said I think there are still um as I've said before there's still a long way to go and I think that Journey starts with um making sure that the educators are are truly heard and supported uh in in this process um these programs and the implementation of the pro of this um well new to our district program uh will touch almost every teacher in the district and whatever resources that we we as a district can put behind um those efforts and and um that we can all act in concert to uh meet the needs of the students and really support our Educators who are uh delivering that curriculum I think it can't be overstated how important that is um so again looking forward to uh

047seeing where we're at but also recognizing that there's a long journey ahead and I appreciate uh trusty Jacobson um talking about um you know how how we do address uh reading levels and and where we're going and I think widening the scope of that discussion and including all stakeholders is a really important uh Factor um and a couple of things I'll pick up then on a couple of the things the board members uh had had said uh first of all um yeah trusty land I think AI is incredibly important you know we we everybody's talking about finals finishing up but there are still two more exams tomorrow and the presence of AI in our students lives um let's just say it's noticeable um so it's important to to recognize how important it is that that

048we all um uh educate ourselves and um are thoughtful and deliberate about how we um implement or or incorporate AI into uh the service that we provide I think there are that's sort of a a two-sided coin if you will um and I think it's very very important um you know unless you're looking for you know the answer to how many RS there are in Strawberry um I think trusty too AI would have no problem selecting that sweater as the winner of the contest um yeah I I'm so thankful that you mentioned it was it was for an event I I was afraid to comment on it otherwise um the uh the other item that I really appreciate trusty Chavez's um discussion about uh food insecurity that's something we take pretty seriously here at Hillsdale

049and I just want to put in a plug for uh the peace pan country and the community closet at at Hillsdale um we serve uh so I shouldn't say we uh the the ETA and the peace Pantry serve so many families um uh in our community and countless volunteers spend every Friday morning packing food and delivering food um there's a holiday giving plan uh currently right now that you can you can go to the Hillsdale website and you'll you'll be able to find it um or just call Brett Stevenson he'll always answer the phone um and then finally uh I'll just say uh again I've said before happy holidays um I am looking forward to the break and uh just want to say how much uh not only um how much the uh the association

050you know appreciates the support of the district uh but also um a few things that have happened in the last few months in which uh I've been thinking about way back in the n early 90s maybe mid 90s uh then superintendent Tom Moore um was championing uh the establishment of a strategic plan and one of the tenants of the Strategic plan was to develop and support a culture of collaboration and I really feel strongly not only as an educator but as a as my role uh in the association that I really appreciate the the the that culture that I think um didn't have to exist didn't have to be supported but I appreciate the um the work of uh superintendent Booker Dr Black Dr Kemp Dr kmy and um uh Mr Hawkins as well and

051uh just want to appreciate that that we can we're all professionals we're all Educators and we all work together for the same goals so thank you and happy holidays thank you rep of the CCA chapter 519 representative apparently there is no report tonight okay a report of the SEL Adult School Teachers Association and apparently there's no report tonight either okay special reports and appearances superintendent Booker yeah thank you very much uh and I appreciate the comments from Mr Chris uh our focus on multilingual Learners is imperative uh the data indicates it as such and I'm really pleased this evening that tonight's presentation by Dr Kempy by Miss fight and others uh doesn't serve as a presentation of just successes uh we do have a lot of work um to do in this area and we

052will identify uh those points and the things that we are uh looking to tackle uh to improve our multilingual Learners opportunities to thrive and to graduate so with that I'm going to hand it over to Dr kmy thank you good evening um so I'm really proud to introduce the spotlight on student learning on our multilingual Learners um there has been a tremendous amount of work over the last year year and a half um in support of our students and it has taken a lot of support from all Educators from all parts of the organization as Mr shris um indicated it is um an area of focus that we need to have ongoing support for and collaboration um and I think some of the changes have challenged us as a system as it's required anytime a

053system goes under under goes a lot of change um however we're really committed to the work I really believe in um what you're going to see tonight in terms of what we're providing to students that is rigorous it's inclusive and it's what's ethically and legally is right for our students um and I'm really fortunate to have the the leadership of Miss Joanna fight she's actually has over 15 years of experience in leading um ml programming um prior to being here in our district she um LED efforts in San Francisco under um a lot of important changes that happened there that she has brought insight to make sure that we're doing um right by our students here as well and um really I think uh change is one of the themes of this presentation that we

054know we have had to do some organ gational change and what we really do hope is that that will start impacting um our students at at you know in very important data points um graduating but also that they're learning English because we know that's a way for them to access um resources um jobs everything else in our community so and at her side is Miss Nicole alens Martin um she you may recognize her she was formerly a World Language teacher a school administrator and now she's joining us at the district office this year as our ml coordinator um so going to have them come on up here and I have um the clicker for them as well they're going to provide an overview of the ml program um they're going to show some of the

055data talk about a lot of those changes that we've made and talk about the Partnerships teacher supports that we have as well as um a student panel so we'll hear from our most important constituents there are some students here t T that will be part of a student panel and um with that the last thing I'm going to say is just that our programming really is about serving a very diverse um student population across 10 different schools and um again we really want to see our students Thrive we want to see them included in um grade level classes and a lot of the um program supports that they're going to talk about are ensuring that our students are accessing it so with without further Ado I'm going to hand it over to them you're right

056thank you start again good evening president Griffin trustees and members of cabinet our students should be walking in any moment they were just taking a picture outside before coming in and finishing up their Pizza um so I'm going to start with providing just a quick overview view of the programs that we have um starting with our newcomer program and our newcomer program is a program that defined by California and federal law can exist for up to three years for students who have been in the United States for less than three years in in the United States educational system and while three years is the guidelines we do have exceptions for students who can exit the program sooner if they have met their proficiency and the exit criteria sooner and we also have exceptions for students

057who need to stay in the program more than three years so it's definitely always based on each student's needs and what the teachers and the administrators at the sites are seeing are as the needs as the students our newcomer program um based on the slide serves our students from0 to 3 years and we have that program at four of our schools brid Academy cappuccino Hillsdale and San Mato then we have our second program which is our standard program and the standard program exists in all of our schools uh the standard program will serve our Advanced newcomers those are the students I mentioned that might exit the newcomer program early but they are still considered a newcomer um we have our medium-term students who have been in the US for four to six years and then

058our long-term English Learners who have been in the US seven plus years one thing to note that um is something we changed due to the audit is that in Prior years our newcomer students were not allowed access to their resident schools if they did not have a newcomer program and legally we are required to allow any student to participate at their resident school so you will see that some families have opted out of the newcomer program and are now attending their resident schools such as Aragon Burling game or Mills welcome students so we have some students for the panel and then they also called some students to help support them through their presentation so we got a good representation here of students um and we're saving that the best for last uh so the next

059thing I wanted to talk about is a little bit about what our data is currently showing about our programs and how our multilingual Learners are doing so first thing is around our enrollment Trends while the slide on here talks about the last three years if you really think about the last seven years our newcomer Pro or sorry our multilingual learner enrollment has increased by almost 50 15% and the newcomers in particular by 50% % and by the numbers you can see over the last 3 years that our newcomer population has maintained at almost 50% of all of our MLS we are at about 40% 47% newcomers and then the rest are our medium-term and our long-term English Learners multilingual Learners and I think one of the um implications of this is that we really need

060to look at how we are serving that 50% that we um have seen come in and maintain and they have a very different need in terms of their programming in order to progress their uh English profic proficiency this next slide pretty much shows the exact same information but it is shown just in a table form um again just showing the um trends for enrollment in terms of the different types of multilingual Learners our next slide will show the multi single learner population at our school sites so what we see over time is that the trend has remained the same in terms of the percentage of MLS Sano high school has the largest number of multilingual Learners followed by um Hillsdale and cappuccino close behind and then um Bridge Academy has uh 70 students and they

061have all newcomer students and they have our most vulnerable newcomer students at at that school a lot of them who are unaccompanied minors who have come here later in life and as an as an 11th or 12th grader experience trauma and need a lot of extra support in order to get through um school and through their life good evening and this slide here is showing our program enrollment um with one keeping in mind one of the mandated changes that we had through the audit which was to allow asan had mentioned earlier um all students to have access to their resident home sites and so as you could see here there are now newcomers that are at all of our schools um especially Aragon Burling game and Mills which do not have newcomer programs these schools

062have the standard programs um but here we see that Aragon and Berling and excuse me Peninsula as well because Peninsula Aragon Berling game and Mills now really need to prioritize teacher professional development around serving newcomer students that are now at the sites and weren't previously um we really need to increase the access points for them in all of the content area classes and while we do advise families about the benefits of uh being at a site with a newcomer program and being part of the newcomer program when they enroll and some families do choose to um opt out of going to the newcomer program they really want to be at their home and Resident sites and so we continually need to help those sites with the standard programs Aragon Burling game Mills Peninsula be accustomed

063to the fact that newcomers do have have the right to attend their home uh their home sites and the schools need to also make changes to help to ensure that they succeed this uh slide also is showing the same type of detail and table format you'll see the percentages of the MLS within the population at the sites and then the columns that show newcomer medium-term and long-term groups are going to show the percentage breakdowns of each of those groups of students within the ml population at the sites so for our graduation rate um we did see an increase in our ml graduation this year Yay good news um we also did have a 5% increase last year so that's great um however they still we still see that our multilingual Learners have the lowest graduation

064rate in the district and um part of the a few of the possibilities or reasons why our students have the lowest graduation rate are that some of them um some of some of it is attendants and some of it can be that they have not had access to some of their uh graduation requirements and then for our newcomer students we see a lot of um competing priorities where they have to work to make money where they have to take care of their siblings or other things that are impacting their school life so several things that can be impacting uh the graduation rate for our MLS on the slide you'll see some of the bright spots so these schools also saw an increase in the grad rate for their multilingual specifically at their sites so most

065of them were increases some of them were maintained I do have to name that this is the first year that the California dashboard is separating our multilingual Learners into two groups which is English Learners and long-term English learners so the data is a little hard to compare sometimes to last year um but this is how it's going to be moving forward um and so it's important to look at these particular students and why they why we were able to increase the graduation rate for these students to determine what was it was it access to more classes was it the supports they were given was it increased Credit Recovery opportunities um these are some growth areas for our graduation rate um we saw that at Aragon both of the categories of students declined in graduation at

066Berling game you only see one on there because for the longterm Ys they have less than 11 students so then they don't um give a score for that um at cappuccino they had one Decline and one maintained and then at Peninsula they maintained as well so again looking at what was good at the other schools that we could maybe replicate for the these schools to also continue to increase on their graduation rate um this slide talks about attendance for the all the different typologies of our students so the first chart on the left top is talking about all of our multilingual Learners and then under that is our newcomers students who have been here for up to three years medium-term 4 to six years and ltels 7 plus across all all the MLS what you

067see is that the absentee rate increases as the they become longer term English Learners most likely because of their lack of progress and getting frustrated that they're not progressing in their English um sometimes it can be a lack of connectedness at their school sites and also possibly um being able to offer them more credit recovery options than we do right now because some of them come in credit deficient and then they might not have as many opportunities to recover their credits to graduate on time um I'm sorry to gra to uh be able to come to school and be able to graduate on time for the College and Career indicator a reminder of what this is the College and Career indicator has many measures that can be used um to meet it to be prepared

068some of the ones that are more popular for our San Mato students are enrollment in AP classes and a and three on the exam um a CTE completion which is two years of a CTE pathway um also a through G completion and then taking a dual enrollment or a college course for our English Learners our multilingual Learners we see that there has been a decline part of the reason for that decline is that we need to improve our access to these AP to the AP classes to our CT e Pathways and to access to the a through G courses that we have as well as a college course and we have started taking some actions around those things for example in a little bit I'll talk about the intake counselor that graciously the board approved

069last year and one of the goals of that position is to actually offer a newcomer College course so in this slide we are looking at the ml progress and what the M Mo progress means is that it is looking at how much a student progressed in their lpac test every year um at the bottom of the slide you can see lpac levels and typically not typically the lpac comes with four up to four 1 through four but when you're measuring the English um proficiency indicator they're looking at the six levels that are underneath the slide the 2L 2H they don't have to jump and entire number to show progress so they're looking at if anyone went from 2L to 2H or to 3L Etc so um based on our on the data up there we

070maintained for our multilingual learners but we have declined for our long-term English Learners and that is a pattern that we see across all of California and actually in the entire country this next slide shows um the lp again the English proficiency indicator by School site and again because the long-term yells are now separated it makes it a little difficult to compare both years but um I can highlight that Aragon Burling game and Mills did have a slight increase and cappuccino and Hillsdale had a slight decrease now last year both capucino and Hillsdale had increases so it has been pretty inconsistent in our data in terms of decreasing and increasing our reclassification rates so last year I talked about the jump in 2022 23 and I'll repeat it again due to the pandemic in the prior

071years we were the state was not offering the Casp exam and that is one of the criteria for reclassification so when that was offered again we saw the big increase in students who couldn't have been reclass classified in the past and hence the jump to 22.1% in 2223 now if we compare 2021 22 to 23 24 which is more of a compar of to comparable years we can see that we had about a 3% increase in our reclassification rate which is great um part of that can be um that we started offering more of their designated ELD courses and also really focusing on how the they're progressing on their English in different content areas so one of the other measures that the district um has is around advancement through ELD and in this year we

072can see a slight decline in almost every school and I believe part of the reason we see the decline is that one of our past practices was that we allowed students to continue to take the same El level even if they passed the course that is something we were found out of compliance in so um we've made some changes to that and in this next slide this is a proposal of how to continue to look at that but with the new measures that we're having so with our new guidance that was given from the Auditors we changed the courses from integrated ELD and designated ELD into ml English and designated Eld ml English is a class that is treated like any other content class with the same passing and failing criteria so now they will

073not be able to repeat it unless they fail the class they will pass along to the next level if they're passing the class designated ELD is by proficiency level and the state says that sometimes they move forward sometimes they do not so if we really want to be measuring the progress of their advancement we need to be looking at their m English um and you can see that for the fall of 2024 we had quite a huge increase this is partially because in January due to the audit we had to move several students out of the newcomer program because they had been in there for two many years um and also in this fall we already moved a lot of students out of the newcomer program so every year some some students will either age

074out of it meaning they've been there for 3 years and they need to move forward and they're ready um or that they've met the exit criteria to move out of the newcomer program let talk about the road to Improvement um here you will have seen a couple of the slides at the start when Joanna began about uh the multilingual learner typologies and these are ways that we are able to identify the amount of years that students have been in US schools and previously prior to the audit we were not using the typologies in this way with this type of a breakdown so it's extremely helpful for our teachers and for others who are trying to um have a better understanding of what students expected language proficiencies may be again based on their years in the

075US and their educational history uh and as a reminder on those kind of the top half of these are our newcomer students and that makes up about 50% of the population of our multilingual Learners on this slide you can get a glimpse of what the multilingual learn journey is within the district when students arrive uh based on the home language survey and also the amount of years in um the US schools they will be identified and given the typology like what you just previously saw and students are offered to be in the newcomer Pro program if they've been here for three years or less um or our students who are the advanced newcomers or medium-term or long-term will be in the standard program and as we also discussed the families can also opt for students

076who are new comers to continue at their home site in the standard program as well so they may choose not to be a part of the newcomer program if it's not at their home site and that's what they choose uh when students are at either site whether it's a newcomer program or a standard program they are taking designated ELD it's called CLA at the standard program which is community and literacy and action course but that both courses at both programs they're taking either D or CLA in the newcomer program they're taking the other ml content class classes um ml English being one of them like Shanna just mentioned and after the 3 years the newcomers will move to the standard program and of course the ultimate goal is that students are really developing in their

077English proficiency moving towards reclassification and then of course graduation we also have a group of students who come to us with interrupted formal education or limited interrupted formal education which are our cyh or S students as well as unaccompanied minors that are coming to us and we have sever different indicators that you can see there on the bulleted list of who are students that may be identified as cyth or SLI and we do see that we have three General groups of students within Cipher life that we are supporting one as a group that overall can't read or write uh it's a small cohort but we do have some students in this um in this group and then the other which is quite a bit larger and the majority are students who can um read and

078write and have literacy in their home language or what we'll call their L1 um however it might be might be a lower grade level than High School level and then we also have a group with interrupted education but they are progressing quite quickly um part of this especially to address that majority group um in the middle we've developed a SLI task force where we're looking at literacy um course potentially for our students in this um category and other ways that we can really support our s students and the unaccompanied minor here you'll see another General overview of our uh newcomer and standard programs and our placement guidelines so on the left you'll see again our schools that have the newcomer program and also that exit criteria for the students who may be newcomers here for

079three years or less but then are um meeting the criteria to be Advanced newcomers and going into the standard program and you'll see the different courses that they will take at each and then the stars are next to that uh state required designated ELD class both the standard program as CLA or in the newcomer program as dld one of the really exciting and positive moves this year has been the curriculum um development and adoption for both ml English and for cl um there was a robust pilot last year if you remember and then in uh the spring when the board graciously approved um and uh the 24th of May the the new curriculum for these programs so MLA f um ml English focuses on the ELA content standards which is required by Ed code this

080is the course that's at the newcomer sites um and we do recognize that we need to continually increase our expectations for our multilingual students in these courses they are resilient um and we want to give them rigorous curriculum that's meeting standards in CLA we are also using a National Geographic um curriculum and we are following the California ELD standards in the course we are working a lot on assessments as well to prepare students for the lpac as Joanna was saying the lp is one of is the major indicator of student progress and so our CLA teachers are really helping students by practicing the interim elpac and getting them to work to understand um what that takes for them as they're also nearing reclassification one of the big benefits with all of this and major benefit

081has just been the consistency of the curriculum and the assessments across all sites and to really have that joint togetherness and that way we can better track the program success across all um oh and how are we supporting our teachers and staff there is a huge need um and especially as I mentioned earlier with our sites that are not accustomed to having newcomers on site a huge need for how we're supporting our teachers and staff across the entire District we have some external providers that have been giving excellent PD throughout this year as you can see there on the left and also many internal opportunities as well um I would say we are continuing to see quite a bit of low participation in the external providers PD uh but teachers are asking for PD so

082we need to find out ways to support teachers to be able to better attend these PD opportunities so monitoring of our MLS it is required by the law to monitor our all of our MLS a few times throughout the year including our reclassified students for up to four years and um I wanted to also thank the board for approving the increase to a 1.0 ml coordinator because that has also allowed us to one in the slide before offer a lot U more internal professional learning opportunities for our teachers as well as increasing our monitoring um our monitoring and interventions for our students so some of the examples of how we um monitor we implemented a new system where the ml Specialists will review the grades of all their MLS and the sixe grad period and

083then they're ensuring that these students who have multiple FS are getting interventions at their school sites they work directly with their APS to make sure that and they're going to their tier 2 team and getting assigned interventions um there's also frequent check-ins on student progress and most of our schools have an ml tutoring program after school to support students and another thing that the board approved was our M Mo clubs and the M Mo clubs have really had a great success in building the community for our students and making them feel more welcome at each of their sites um we do have some new developments and monitoring for example at uh s High School they started me a new mentoring program that the ml specialist is has a group of students that have recently transitioned

084from the newcomer program to the standard program so far the pilot has shown great success has showed some increase in attendance some increase in their grades um and we're hoping to be able to expand that and bring it to the other sites as well we all meet and talk about things that are working well at each other's sites I also know that Hillsdale is um has sent out a new process for their transition of their newcomer students from the newcomer program to the standard program so they're thinking about it six weeks prior what are they doing with the students the first six weeks in um the standard program what are all their check-ins and what are they monitoring they're making sure the students have a buddy in the standard program and all these systems for

085monitoring and checking that the students who have recently transitioned are doing okay as well as all that we have been tracking the progress of all of the students who have transitioned from the newcomer program to the standard program we check their GPA and their attendance um every six weeks to see how they're doing if they're improving decreasing and you know we have a lot of students who are doing well but we have some students who have been maintaining and some who have not been doing so successfully but that is expected um the other thing in terms of always monitoring which Nicole already mentioned is the S task force we had our first meeting and again this came out of seeing that there's a need to support our students who are coming in with very interrupted

086education and another part that we were found out of compliance was with a yearly program evaluation and as mentioned before now that we are making some consistency across sites we will be able to actually look at and evaluate the program across the district and how how each school is doing it because they're doing the same assessments and the same curriculum um another thank you to the board was the approval of our intake counselor for newcomer students and families it has been an amazing success so far um we so baras she was a longtime counselor ml counselor at cappuccino high school and is now serving in this position has a lot of experience working with these families and students um she has been able to provide really individualized newcomer student and family support during the enrollment

087time um our transcript evaluation process was kind of messy it was different at each site students were getting credits different ways so we have spent a lot of time looking at the credit and stabilizing the consistency of how credits are received um and then the other piece too is that we had a goal of ensuring that students who enroll and are seated in the classroom within seven days of their first contact with the district office since um September 25th we've had 82 students placed within 7even days and 18 students placed within 8 days and the only reason they got into 8 days was that their initial lpac wasn't available to start the day it was supposed to so really happy that that's going so well the other part of this position is that it um

088let will be a dual enrollment or a college instructor and we are aiming to start that course for the first time in the fall of 2025 so some of our family engagement highlights um we continue to have family engagement coordinators at all of our sites and they are their front line for our families they do workshops for our families around how to use canvas how to use Aries a lot of them this is all new um there's multiple workshops throughout the week and every month um they're building Community with our families have cultural events um and they help at our back to school night open house this year they also started a new newsletter and each site has their own specific newsletter about news and events that are happening and it's in Spanish and sent

089out to all of our multilingual learner families we also have our deac our district English language English learner advisory committee we meet monthly and it is probably one of my favorite parts of my job is meeting with those families um I love hearing their voice and they are very um active in the meetings and active in providing um advice to the district and you know we had our meeting last week and one parent we were having a conversation I wanted to share this and out of the the question was nothing around this but the family the parents said that change that we did this is all in Spanish but that change that we did where my son is now in all English-speaking classes has been the best thing for my son and he said his

090English was not progressing because he didn't need to learn it but now he sits in class and everything's in English and if he doesn't learn it he's not going to understand it so it was really exciting for me to hear a parent say that um and then the other thing I would highlight in terms of some family engagement is that one of the processes that we've changed in enrollment is now talking with the parents about not only the age the student is and what grade level they should be in but also how many credits they're coming in with so we have had I wrote the data down I think it was 33 families this year so far who have opted for one grade level lower than what their age is and what that allows for

091them is that the students will be able to complete their High School graduation requirements by 12th grade um one of the other things I want to highlight is our wellness and Community Partnerships so we have two newcomer social School social workers and they serve our four newcomer programs so they literally spend two and a half days at each of their schools Bridge cappuccino Hillsdale and Sano high school and so you will rarely see them in the office because they are truly School social workers they are involved and support the tier 2 and tier three intervention teams at each of their sites they assess students for mental health and connecting families with services and providing Crisis Intervention another huge piece of work is connecting families and students to Our Community Partners that can support the families

092even F further so on this next slide we have some photos of some of the events that we've already had this year we had our legal aid uh workshop on December 5th which uh we had some information for our immigrant families and their rights um and then we also have the medical clinic which is extremely important because a lot of our families come in without health insurance and then they have a hard time filling out the forms so we have these clinics where the families can come in get help filling out the forms and ensure that they have health insurance in our next slide this highlights again the same programs and how they have grown over the last two years one new partnership that we're very excited about is the peninsula Family Services we are

093piloting a program around financial literacy there will be financial literacy workshops for our students and then Financial educational workshops for our parents and caregivers and this will be launching in January of 2025 um this next slide just gives you more information about each of these agencies I'm not going to read through them but it just lists more of the what the services that they are providing to our students and families so moving forward um one of the things that we truly believe is that the changes we are making are the changes necessary to help our students improve their English be successful and be able to graduate um we need to continue to Center our students and advocate for rml students we also need to be holding all of each other accountable for change this is

094a as we say a 1061 we are all a part of this and all need to be involved in the change and the change that we're making needs to be around Focus goals that are measurable and that we can account for to be able to tell us if we're doing the right thing or not and the best now is our students so I'm gonna ask you guys to line up here and so I have the questions posted up here I'm going to ask one question and then they're each going to answer their question sh I think they're gonna just come up here um so first question what is your name grade school you attend and where are you from so hi my name is Angel La Cruz and um oh sorry um hi my name

095is J La Cruz and I'm from Mexico I was born in Utah but I was Raising in Mexico I came back to the United States when I was 14 years old to learn more English and to improve myself and also I go to his high school um second one hi hi everyone my name is Mayim I'm a junior from s high school and I came from savador Tre years ago hi everyone my name is Angelica Vasquez I'm a sophomore in hillsel high school and I came to United States like one and a half year good evening I'm Mar and S from capuccino high school and I'm from Niara hello my name is j Guadalupe I am in 12 in 12th grade and I attend to capuccino high school and I am from Mexico hello my

096name is Brian Hernandez and I in 12th grade I attend in capuccino high school and I'm from Costa Rica all right our second question how is your experience at school this year compared to last year um this year has been more difficult than the last year because this year I am a senior and all my classes are more challenging as a seniors we we have to do more writing and all my classes and is and writing is is my winess I work very hard to getar my gr up but sometimes has been is stressful moving from LD to regular English has been a challenge for me but also it was a very important success for me and comparing this year from last year this year I feel more confident to participate in my classes and

097I feel more confident with my level of English than last year there having a lot of changes during the transition from the multilingual learning program to the standard program at first I was car moving to a new place like when where everyone speaks English and but then I realized that there was was nothing to be scared of uh because all my teachers have been really supportive and always encouraged me to do my best and to get out of my comfort zone and my classmates always make me feel comfortable and I never feel that I will get teased for saying something wrong or incorrect my experience in the school compared to the last year uh is was so good because I can experimenting um how starting the school and I because when I come to uh

098this country and enter to the school um it was uh almost to the end to the first semester and I feel a little scared nervous because um I don't know how can I handle the school in this country and I think that during the SP semester was like a POS for me for um a doctor in there and uh hand there and also I feel so bad for myself um for finished this semester in capucino high school H comparing to last year this year I am participating more in the sports and clubs I am the bo boys varsity soccer team and part of ml Club this school year has been more difficult compared compared last year because if I lose focus for a little bit I get lost and I really need to pay attention

099all the time I forgot to add one thing that most of these students have recently transitioned from the newcomer program to the standard program third question what are some things your teachers have done that helps you be successful in class all my teacher held me when I feel confused and when I when I don't understand most of my classes use computers something that I'm not used uses to to B but all my teachers make sure they help me they also remind me when my tendance is bad or when I'm fall in the class my teachers are very supportive supportive and always give me a guys when I need it my teachers play a very important role in my success in class because they create an environment where I wasn't afraid to make mistakes and they

100were always telling me that make mistake is part of the learning process my teachers have been very helpful and I'm very glad for all the support that they give me and some of the things that they do is that they are always checking if if I'm understanding or if I need help with something I I can always ask them uh they also offer support or help during office hours or tutorial which really help me in some of my classes that I was having a hard time with um this the thing that the CH have um for help me is like for example um give me a purer in in Spanish for understand better the topic while we talking about that day and also they ask me question and I feel okay or I need help

101and also they try to um participate in all the activities that we doing in class some things that my teacher have done to help me be successful in class is taking time to answer all my questions and taking some breaks during class to to stretch my teachers take extra time to explain the classwork to make it easier to understand our next question is what makes you feel welcome at school uh some things that makes me feel welcome in uh in the school is that all the teachers are nice and always say hi to the students and also ask about your day another thing that makes me feel well welcome in the school is to support my ETA grp group BR me uh this group feels like my family because when I need help with something

102like my homework or problems outside of class they are they are there for you and care about you also they give you motivation to improve yourself I feel welcome at school when people are kind and patient with me and when they respect my level of English and also when they make feel including everything and no matter what that is something that makes me feel welcome at school is that everyone in campus can support you and help you if you need it and I feel like I have a lot of support from staff members especially Mr boys because when I need help he always knows how to help me um when I wake up in the morning and I come to I go to school it's early and I so a little tired and the teacher

103um has a good ad like for example hi everybody how about you day and I'm so excited and that I think that behav made me so welcome in the high school the St of capuccino makes me feel welcome one example of this is the clubs events Mr Castillo organizes every month where students come together and have fun in general my teachers and Mr Caso are very caring and their understanding final question is what is a goal that each of you has for next semester uh for the next semester I have many goals to complete one of the goals is um is l English and complete all my credit for graduation one goal that I have for myself in the semester is to continue learning and ignore the barriers that prevent me from fulfilling my dreams

104and to continue learning new things more and to have better skills in my English and to show to myself what I'm capable of achieve with responsibility discipline and determination um my goal for the next semester is to succeed in all my classes keep my good grades and also get involved in more extra extracurricular activities one goal that I have for the next semester is be part of a d Sport and enjoy this last semester of D last year and the high school and also um getting the credit that I need to finally grad away from capuccino High School my goal for next semester is to graduate from capuccino high school and improve my English my goals for next semester is go to college and keep playing soccer and I will say I don't know improve

105my grades and everything I I do all right thank you guys I appreciate you so much um for being here um have a seat because they might have some questions for you I just have one more thing to say but the board might have a a few questions for you okay um I also want to thank our APS Lauren Pony and Jesse boy for being here and helping me prepare the students and our ml specialist Sal Castillo who's also our ml Club coordinator um who helped prepare our students as well for tonight great job yes so really I just want to summarize a little bit of tonight and um some of the summary is that you know our enrollment continues to show that our overall ml population is steady um we're at about 12% we've

106been at about 12% for the last three years at least um with our newcomer students at about 50% the uh data also shows that our MLS do continue to have our lowest graduation rate and that our English progress indicator is inconsistent from year to year but our commitment to success is around family engagement continuing to really increase our family engagement and communication with them professional development for teachers administrators all Educators in the district increasing supports for our newcomer students and families in particular and building the capacity of all of our schools so that they can all serve our students adequately um I do want to ask our students do still have finals tomorrow so if you have questions for them if they can go first that would be fantastic so we can let them go

107okay well thank you I want to personally thank well I'm G on behalf of the board very seldom do I speak for the board Lord knows but uh I want to thank you the students for being willing to stand up here and uh you know communicate with us ask ask you know show your emotions um your Express you know your difficulties your challenges what makes you you know what makes you feel good about school it's not easy for anybody and certainly it had to be difficult for students and I I really appreciate that so um having said that let's start focusing on the student questions truste andr Zuna you have any um I just wanted to Echo what you were saying um thank you so much for being here and um I guess if one

108of you wants to answer um if anything what would you say to other students who are feeling kind of you know scared about progressing uh to the different class what would you what advice would you give to them or to the newer students that are just coming from other countries not everybody at once I will tell to keep working hard because every sacrifice have his like it uh every sacrifice has it um consequence or something like that so but they have to keep working and if they can dream it they can get it good good thank you and you can be a mentor to them you know so pay it forward uhuh thank you trusty l i I just want to say I think it's incredibly Brave to be able to go up you're learning

109English and you came up and present it's hard for adults to do that and for you guys to all come up and be so well spoken and really articulate and talk about what you feel I I just have one question but I really want to thank you I think it's really hard to do this and you did guys did a great job so thank you um do you miss how was it getting I I know this was one of the questions but from a personal standpoint do you miss the newcomer Center and that the school that you were there or you really enjoying your new environment at your high your your high school that you're you're going to now are you all happy to be at your new high schools I'm really excited about it

110or you want to go back thank you all right so uh so name is from my classes for m is um all all my friends uh but something bad from there I'm I'm I'm just gonna say it's not bad but the thing you you pass time more with people that you speak Spanish and so you know learning I think so you need to like to practice more I mean like try to hang out I don't know with the older boys you know and try to to learn something from them I mean like you can improve yourself uh for me for learning is they Tak me for years so uh one thing that a lot help me to to learn more English was the music um and I know meet more people yeah thank you thank

111you really appreciate that that's it for me okay trusty Jacobson I don't have any questions for the students I just want to thank you for being here and sharing with us tonight good luck with your finals trusty Chavez thank you I don't have any questions I just want congratulate all of you for all the all the effort you made in the past couple of years you're almost some of you are almost graduating it's exciting and I'm just so proud of all six of you you did amazing up the microphone you articulated yourself very well and um I wanted to mention I want to give a plug for the school set Council I was on the school set Council for a couple years at capuccino high school and we had um all grade we had we

112had student leaders attend those meetings the monthly meetings we had students represented from all grade levels all four grade levels but we also had student represent representation from the multilingual students um student Club I guess it was a student Club so I would just want to um mention how important your thoughts and concerns are as as far as the student leadership at the school site Council so whatever school that you attend you know I think it's really important if you want to get involved in the school set council meeting because your opinion and your your thoughts are important and thank you again for for speaking tonight okay so I think those are the questions for the students if they want I just had one that I thought of just now if that's okay I I'm

113I'm just curious do any of you have a job outside of school one two of you yeah okay does that affect your ability to come to school okay good yeah please yeah come on I gonna be honest like havea y right here like a good for me because I improve my English like a lot of times and and I think that's it like for me thank you for sure it's more challenging so we commend you for working in going to an attending school so I we do have a couple of I believe we have couple more questions but not for the students so we thank them for your participation good luck on finals thank you again thank you again and thank you to the staff who came to support them oh I I just want

114to say thank you for inviting me here and was a pleasure to be here thanks for having me and thank you to the parents for coming and supporting thank you I just also before they leave I wanted to highlight like a couple of the people I spoke about tonight um our newcomer social workers are here that's DEA Deanda and Lisa Mia soval and then our new intake counselor letia baras so just wanted to thank them as well they help all these students and are awesome people to work with Okay you can go thank you I was going to say thank you I wanted to ask about the ml club uhhuh and who organizes that and how does it work sure that was I didn't know if they wanted to answer yeah I do you want

115to talk about it I'm sorry I knew he was leaving I was like no don't leave I have a question for you no I wanted to know yeah uh yeah so um the ml Club was actually an idea of myself and a c a couple other people at cappuccino where uh you know a lot of students they I feel like they want to hang out after school but since there's nothing to do they'll just go to like a McDonald's or or they would go somewhere so I had an idea to do some like after school things and um something that helped me out was being the ELD soccer coach I got to really know a lot of the students and it was the same year that I was doing the MLS position that I'm currently

116in so uh Mr Rodriguez who's the assistant principal of cappuccino was the one that told me to do it even though I was kind of hesitant and I'm really glad that I did that because um two of the boys that were here today were from the El soccer team so they're kind of you know they thanked me because I've kind of been in their uh high school life these years so um but yeah the ml club today actually we had an event uh we did like a gingerbread uh making contest and we made some hot chocolate so kind of a holiday themed thing but um last year we did we had a field trip to the Exploratorium um and we did a we have like a Halloween theme thing uh than giving potluck which has

117kind of become a yearly TR uh Tradition now so um yeah I'm just trying to make these events so hopefully these students come by and we've had some really good participation numbers so um was it field day oh yeah and field day so at the end of the year we do like these uh it's a fi field day and um we have all these uh games where we have the three different ml English CL uh levels so like ml English one two and three their teams they get their own personalized shirts that they design we get those printed out for them they wear them on the day and then they play against each other in various games you know like uh there's like kickball like penalty kicks uh Jenga and all these other things and

118then the winner gets a trophy that the teacher gets to put in their classroom for the whole year so every year it's just trying to see who gets that Trophy and then actually our principal Mr Gomez uh he's actually great on the grill uh he'll he he CS up some burgers and uh hot dogs and so uh just a really nice time oh so I'm glad to do it and and hopefully can keep doing it I'm I'm glad you stayed to be able to talk about it because what was so impressive was the kids mentioned it about that was the connection that kept them interested in what they're doing and where they're going so Kudos and really wanted to hear about it I wanted to copy it for bis so yeah thank you so much

119for for asking about it because I love talking about it it's a great program all right excellent thank you thank you You by thanks s so s is also the ml specialist at cappuccino does an awesome job and um while it started at cappuccino we then spread the M Mo Club to um Sano to Bridge and to um Hillsdale as well we created a budget for them so that they could go on these events and it's been a huge success with also teaching them some of the American culture that they might not be um accustomed to during the holidays yeah hey we you know we focused on the students of first pass around so if we've got any residual questions as we close this out we'll uh um we'll give everybody a chance for one

120last fight at the Apple trusty Andra Zuniga um can you come back to me let me get to my notes okay thank we'll see I'll take her time no go ahead you you were next trust I know I'm just I was joking I take up some of her time um no really just first thank you I thought there was an incredibly in incredibly informative uh presentation really in depth I it multilingual Learners is very important in my world because as you know this is the thing that you said it in your your your presentation this is something that all of State of California and all of the country has to deal with and is not doing it as well as they could and we need to keep improving it and disrupting it um couple questions

121that I have are um really about The Chronic you had a great slide on chronically absent students in fact your percentages were pretty darn good compared to mine and and so my my asking is what do you do in circumstances where there's absences where where things start rising and there's a problem do you have Solutions have you come up with things is there strategies that you know that maybe you can share with us or just kind of tell what's good working you know kind of thing um well you know it really depends on the type of student so sometimes with our newcomer students it's a external factors that need a lot more attention than some of the interventions that we can do at schools um and so really connecting them to services and figuring out

122how to modify sometimes their schedule so that they can be able I know that um Miss Jacobson you asked those two students if work um impacts their schedule but and for them it doesn't but for many students it does because they have to work during the day um or they have to work early in in the afternoon some of them so it depends we have our social workers um at all of our schools who are either working with our newcomer students and then our other District social workers who are also working on attendance and that looks at like really looking talking to the families um and looking at how um informing the families of the importance of a lot of times what we find is a a connection with a student or a connection with

123an adult today I did a home visit with a Brazilian student and Miss showman from the bridge um academy uh we've been trying to get him back to school I think we're going to get him back I really really he has like two more classes to graduate um so just that continued um Persistence of talking to the students now I'm going to not put you on the spot but I don't know if the APS in the audience have any addition to like some of your strategies that have worked around attendance with your MLS just just to dig in on on what Joan shared I think it's about just trying to get students to really be open with us about what is the barrier because I think often times particularly our newcomer students there's a fear

124around admitting that they're working or a fear around admitting that there's other things going on in their lives and so I think it's really building that trust and then what I always tell kids is like if you tell what's going on we can always find a solution but if we don't know what's going on I can't read your mind and so once we know okay this is the schedule that you're working now we can work to move that seventh period to something else or can work to do something online if you we can be creative and working with our counselors and our newcomer social workers particularly with our newcomer students to really to do that digging and building that relationship so that we can can really get creative and I think what I've seen is

125students once they they earn that trust they know okay wait I told Miss Ponty that I was working and she was able to make something happen for me then I find them come back to me next semester my work schedule changed can I actually and I'm like yes thank you for telling us now we can find some solutions together so that's been really helpful but having those social workers that can do that and having our counselors have a you know a case load where they can build those relationships with students I think is is really thank you thank you yeah the only thing I would add is I mean I think like in the newcomer program at Hillsdale we follow a really a really we follow our mtss structure and I think the thing that

126has changed over the last year and a half is we now have robust resources at the tier 2 and tier three level which we didn't previously have so our initial data scrapes and referrals on attendance are it's the same process if you're in the newcomer or the standard program and we start a four-week checkin checkout but most often for some of our newcomer programs who for students who when you start looking at graduation data um they they haven't attended School in this country for a few years perhaps at the middle schools or um they're arriving without um a biological parent the the challenges they face are far more significant than just having an adult staff member care for them on campus and so the addition of social workers and mentorship um I think has been

127a huge benefit to all of us who serve in the newcomer programs and so adding those resources at the tier two and tier three level at least the school sites thank you so much has been you know a huge asset yeah yeah um just just to continue on I just have just one or two um what I will say is just kind of echoing what um Jesse was talking about I really feel like we've put in a lot of good things systems into place for families I mean is incredible to see the pictures of all the the presentations that are taking place and that they're attending and families are attending and the Outreach and the deac and all of those things I think I'm so proud of our district and I'm so proud of all

128the work that we've done and I see it and and I could see that success and it just seeps through what Jesse was just talking about and what we have um my question now is going to shift to curriculum so you I saw the the you know about PD about udl about constructing meaning I know we've been doing that forever but I'm I'm so proud of that program that you have to help the students transition is there any other types of uh you talked about curriculum being consistent the National Geographic I guess is what you're talking about um tell me a little bit more about that curriculum and how it's valuable and what are you guys doing to expand language development because that's where kind of rests is or language development and written development writing

129development you know thank you no it's a great question so the um for the CLA class and ml English we have these Partnerships with National Geographic um they have actual consumable workbooks that the students are using as well as it's integrated really well with canvas which makes it nice um focusing a lot on especially for the designated ELD CLA class on reading and writing speaking listening and critical thinking so it is very much about global competencies and really being able to do some real world application and thinking about um how we're using language and even though you know the levels of language are are building based on the proficiency students are really placed in the class um based on their proficiency and we have actually an online placement test with the um with National Geographic

130that they can take in order to see which you know level of the curriculum is going to be best for meeting them um but the CLA teachers specifically are really working on the ELD standards and trying to make sure that students can have access to all of the different types of language and cognitive functions and and everything in all of their courses which is helpful but um I would say that really having across you know being able to have the whole C CLA PLC from all the sites meet together a few times a year is um very valuable and being able to unit plan and really backwards design and really dig in and there's a whole neat Google Chat that they all have of look at this resources I made look at this and so

131it's really neat seeing the cross collaboration um that everyone's doing based on it and that's the same for ML English too with their um with their levels of the ml English books I think the other thing I would add is that we were using some pretty outdated books that um you know weren didn't have some necessarily the most relevant topics for our students um didn't include phonics which some of our students needs which we're still working on that um but just bringing some new materials that are more up to date on what um English language proficiency looks like and developing that you got any of those phonics let me know that's exactly what we're worried about too anyway awesome presentation thank you can I have my spot back so we're going well we're going yeah

132um trusty Jacobson I'll get back okay um thank you so much for the presentation it was very comprehensive I very much appreciate it I do have some questions um the first one is going back to the conversation about work outside of school is there a way that we can get students high school credit for working outside of school because in my mind when we're talking about College and Career Readiness the indicators that you mentioned you know taking AP classes taking dual enrollment taking a through G these are all college kind of the only one that wasn't was CTE Pathways um the gal that did my hair yesterday she told me this was in Utah I was in Utah um she told me that she got her hairl license in high school and that she got

133part and I said how on Earth did you get enough credits to graduate while you were doing this hair cosmetology program she said well I got some credit for doing it I Got High School Credit so I'm just wondering I think that it's great for these kids to work they need to work and the one kid said I'm learning English better by working so can we incentivize the kids to keep working but also give them High School Credit is there some way so um when I was in San Francisco I ran the uh College and Career department and one of the things that we did was trying to find exactly that a way to do that and it was probably three years ago though California changed their requirements for giving credit for work and there

134needs to be specific curriculum that is taught while they're being while they're working to be able to get that High School Credit so um that is the one requirement and a lot of like the jobs that our students are in are places that are not going to be willing to provide curriculum as well um and but one way to do it is also through college courses where you can be doing there's um at Skyline and most of the colleges they have programs that are at Skyline it's called a co-op program and that's um they're on the job and then they're doing goals Etc getting credit and they can can be so then that way they're getting credit that also goes towards their High School graduation that would be excellent I would love to see something

135like that be being more um utilized yeah um next question um so one thing that we didn't one one group that we didn't hear from tonight was the teachers um I know that some teachers have some concerns that we've heard um and I did hear from the some of the students as we were asking them like what helps you in school or what helps you succeed I heard many of them say the same thing which was the teachers take extra time to explain things they take time to answer my questions and my question is if they're take if teachers are taking extra time to do that how does that affect the pacing and the amount of content that they're able to present because if it's like if they have to slow down especially like in

136an AP class there's so much content that has to be covered um I that is a concern of mine is how how is it impacting the rest of the students so I think one of the things that we try to talk to our teachers about is around um well one differentiating the instruction but also providing spaces where there are different groups working on different things in the classroom so while a student who might not be needing extra help on this one particular part of the curriculum they might be doing smaller group work with other students who are focusing on that part that is easier said than done but it is possible to do it takes training um but that is how we see a lot of classrooms being run where you have heterogeneous classrooms with

137students at different levels okay thanks and then I in terms of AP we don't see a lot of our mls in AP classes yet so um I don't see that really impacting AP classes in particular but I do hear that happening yes sure um okay I think one more question um so you said that in the ml English classes you will move on to the next level as long as you're passing the class do teachers have a hard time knowing how to grade students this is coming from the letter that one teacher wrote if they grade the student I guess what I to put it bluntly what about Mercy grades are we are we giving Mercy grades or conversely are are teachers incentivized to fail students because they're not mastering the content standards but they're

138giving good participation I don't know do you hear what I'm saying I totally understand what you're saying I think I think that's also part of the new curriculum with the um ml English curriculum there are benchmarks that the students are meeting or trying to meet so the teachers are being very clearly guided for the ml English of what benchmarks the students have met and have not met um we also have implemented a new um assessment that is tracking students reading ability and or progress I should say and one of the things that exact path does it it identifies the gap gaps in the students skills and then what it provides is individualized lessons for a student in order to work on that Gap independently in the class so they do have very specific guidelines in

139order to be tracking progress for students and when they are ready to move along in ml English and you know I want to remind that the designated ELD they're not required to move them forward every year that is the class that is designed for development of English proficiency so if students are not quite ready in their English proficiency they are they can stay at the same level of their designated yd I don't know if you have anything else you want to add thank you okay well I'm going to ask the remaining speakers to ask their most important question then I'm going to call on the student board members then I'm going to call on the public and uh truste andr Zuniga that was not a slight but if if you have something else you want

140to question please I I'll I'll email you I'll talk to you later yeah it's okay I'm going to get to you trustey Chavez no for trustees well I also want trusty to be able to speak too I just I I don't have that many questions I want to say thank you for this your your amazing presentation and those amazing students speaking there I don't know many students who are willing to come to the podium to speak and they did an amazing job um you guys um really supported them staff really supported them and I'm sure their families did as well but I just think that they were just amazing and I don't want to get I know I'm the emotional one of the group so I have a couple things to mention um this is

141really um important work and continuing to make progress is is so so critical um my question is how can we support the teachers and staff and and yourselves more what can we do to be more supportive I know you mentioned throughout the slide deck that couple of the FTE you know you really appreciate it totally moved the needle how can we how can we support more I mean I think you know we provide a lot of uh professional learning opportunities and then there's not necessarily the mentoring that the teachers get after in terms of implementing the things that they learn at the PDS so that's one thing that would be nice to be able to provide teachers is at that level being able to go to their school site and then show them how to

142implement it within their own content area um and something that Nicole said is we're still trying to figure out what we need to do to support teachers to want to come to the PD they don't want to be away from their classrooms they don't want to be away from their students they also want to take their summer break so it we have to continue to find a way that we can get the teachers to come so that they can um participate in the learning totally makes sense and I thank you and one one more quick comment um I just want to thank you for highlighting and showcasing our partnership partnership programs such as medical Kora Peninsula family services and and and more on this on the on the slide deck because it's really important for

143all of our families to know that those Support Services exist and so thank you for showcasing that and also thank you for talking about how important family engagement is and do you think that the more we're involved with family engagement the more the more engaged the families are I would think that the ab that helps with absenteeism as well is that correct I would hope so you know and I think part of our um District social workers uh the ones that are not the newcomer social workers that's part of their focus is working on attendance and the importance of attendance and engaging the families to learn about attendance and the importance of attendance so I hope that that is a way that we will continue to increase attendance and I think and I think you've

144done such a great job having all those family engagement um activities and and workshop so that that definitely helps so thank you again for for your presentation thanks you know you had about three or four comments in one breath and you thought that was that was I I'm I'm just lightening it up uh do uh either of our student board members wish to comment yes so I'd like to quickly reiterate what triste Chavez said I thought that the presentation was thoughtfully created and presented and I especially want to commend the students that came tonight because especially from their goals of wanting to learn more English and their explanation of their experience in the classroom they have been again and again you know taking that effort to step out of their comfort zone and really grow

145which I can say is an amazing stride and accomplishment for them especially comparing to the average high school students um disposition um kind of a clarification question I had was on the specific slide of reclassification rates where we discussed that in 2022 through 2023 there was a an increase um in reclassification because cast tests were retaken and we noted that in 2023 through 2024 there was about a 3% increase comparing to a previous year was that in comparison to 2021 through 2022 was that preco no yeah it was comparing 2021-22 to 202 3 24 so what was what were the reclassification rates um kind of just estimated preco um honestly I'd have to look that up I don't know it off the top of my head thank you um I don't have any questions for

146you tonight but and although the students are no longer here I would just like to thank them for being here because their voices are incredibly important and as student Representatives like them um it's really amazing to see them step up and really speak for themselves I thank them okay well thank you for the presentation I I offered her and she said she'd email I it's okay then we don't get the benefit of hearing what you're it's 9:15 I don't want to hear you I'm good I'm good really you know one of the things and I uh I'm charged with a couple of things following the agenda and moving the meeting along because if we get to 10:00 then we have to go through the assessment now you know this is probably one of the most

147important things we ever do and we spent a lot of time last week on budget and you know and clearly every time we come have the opportunity to talk about an academic area and improving outcomes we all get engaged I mean and it is important but I'm trying to I'm making friends and enemies depending on how many you know how many times you get to well but it's got to be fair I mean the same amount of questions you can't give you know certain board members well that's try to talk and then the rest of us that's that's you speak right now because we want to hear what you want to say well still I think if you wanted to talk you think you should talk well still I mean I just I'm not I

148just I'm good thanks because you know it's difficult to uh actually it's difficult to stop people from Talking once they get started but I don't want to a bridge I don't want to abridge anybody's right to speak so uh um I encourage you um but we'll do a better better job of U managing the agenda next time we put it together so anyway um we'll move move on to uh section our department ask construction is there anything to discuss no nothing okay we'll move on to uh division of Human Resources Personnel consent agenda yes we have a consent agenda with uh eight items for approval personel consent I make the motion to approve unless somebody wanted to pull something for discussion you know before we go there I did not ask for and this public

149comment on that last item there were no public comments requests um okay then we'll move on to uh um is this let me just make sure this is on the consent yeah on the number three the CTE teacher you'll pull you'll pull it okay yeah I I I amend my it's not that I wouldn't approve it I just had yeah that's that's why we pull it so then amend my motion to I want to um amend the motion to approve the consent agenda except item number three which is being pulled okay is there a second second okay we have a motion in second oh is there any comments or discussion on the part of the board okay is there any on the part of public there are none okay and that's online or in-house okay

150thank you um okay call uh for the vote how do we vote hi hi hi hi hi okay the item passes 5 and now we will move back to um was item three yes so H when I read this it said that we're going to this person is going to be developing two new CTE Pathways um my question is have those Pathways been identified yet and if so how was it determined what they will be so there are two Pathways that have been identified we haven't received the grant for these positions as of yet we're putting them um we're posting it as in hopes that we do get the grant um the two areas are um business and then medical a medical pathway and they're based on student interest um for one and then the

151second one we always have to find um potential teachers so we actually have um a potential individual that can help um develop the business pathway in particular so we're hoping that the funding comes through and that we're able to begin them so um there has been a little bit of trouble with this grant where they've promised the fundings pulled it back and then promised it again so we're hoping that we'll hear in the new year for it but those are the two areas that we're looking at I do hope so it would be great if the I don't know what the medical one is but it would be great if the kids could get a medical assistance certificate or something like that at the end of it yeah and after nine I forget exactly what

152it is but I will find that out specific speically and let you know okay thank you that sounds great uh do I move to approve that one separately need a motion if somebody yeah okay I move to approve item three okay we have a motion and second on item T3 all in favor I I who who seconded that one I missed it sorry thank you great [Music] okay uh division of Human Resources yes the first item is the personal actions addendum there aren't any special recognitions today does the board have any questions or comments I make a motion to approve the Personnel actions addendum I second that okay we have a motion in a second um is there any no comments online or in person okay all in favor I okay motion passes 5 Z

153and we'll move on to You2 second uh the second item is the summary of financial terms of the employment agreement for the superintendent which will be recommended on the next item uh the district let's see before the approval of the superintendent's employment agreement a verbal summary of financial terms must be read in open session so I'll read those now unless you want to do that no thank you no okay uh the base salary of the superintendent's contract uh for recommendation at the next item will be $362,000 based on a 224 workday year uh it will include Health and Welfare benefits up to 33,5 151.90 and then transportation and cell phone reimbursements of $275 a month and various subscriptions memberships and reimburse ments for Approved District expenses that's item two okay item three item three is

154the recommendation for the amendment to the employment agreement for the superintendent for the 2425 school year any questions or comments board no there's no question or comments I'll move to approve there a second a second okay we have a motion a second is any comments from the public in person or online no who was the second my apologies it was me Jennifer okay I um before I call for the vote I you know I've wanted to U say something so that uh I think the public and our con stakeholders constituents understand at least my and this is my statement my thought process um on the superintendent's evaluation as contract um since since uh superintendent Booker has joined us a couple years ago I think he's demonstrated a willingness to take on new challenges to think

155outside of the box uh he's shown leadership commitment and dedication to the success and Welfare of the um the entire you know the district the students and the employees um when we hired him I think we considered a lot of factors in setting his his his salary and negotiating a contract and that included prior experience demonstrated capabilities the amount of responsibilities that he had and since he's come here I think he's he's taken on tough tasks just like this multi- learn learner uh multi- language uh learning presentation and um he's he's pointed up blind spots in our Collective Vision you know then we were talking about things like uh uh sa school safety you know and and Welfare uh he's shine light on areas that we need attention and he's taking on those challenges um

156you know I I looked myself at at you know the salaries and we how we compare AED salaries uh with other districts of comparable responsibilities um I've tried to in my own in my own mind recognize the scope of his responsibilities and um I think the adjustment lines up with our commitment to attract and retain top talent uh ensuring that we maintain strong leadership um to serve to serve our students and I think that I'm confident that this adjustment reflects the superintendent's values to our district and to stakeholders and um I I definitely support uh uh this contract Amendment and I thank you for your effort we're not a uh we're not a a easy crew to work with and you know I guess shown tonight no you know and I guess one of the

157things you know if if I had to say what your biggest challenge was is dealing with this board mhm I you know I mean we were kind of finding we're you know we're still working on our sea legs and finding our identity collectively and you made us read that I won't say that dumb book but you made us read that book you know darn book and I you know and I appreciated it well a new version just came out and I'm about halfway through it so far you had to start that anyway halfway through so get ready anyway that I mean I just wanted to express press um you know I spend I spend my money like I'm a taxpayer and I you know and I try to make sure we get value so uh

158that's my thought on it if anybody wishes to trusty land so in honor of brevity I'm just going to say one thing but it needs to be sincere ditto yeah but completely yeah I I'll just say that I agree as well yeah I'll say that yes we discussed this statement together before um and and we are in agreement of what trusty Griffin has said okay so we have a motion oh I'm sorry I just you got flowers away that's why you can't see her you H definitely proved me wrong thank you okay we have a a motion and a second uh all in favor I thank you very much okay and as your next task would you move her flower so I can see oh my gosh I think that's why he's blowing you off

159he can't even see you thank you yeah true I mean you could have put them on the other side I just you know but they're beautiful okay they're nice flowers though wow okay well we're gonna plug keep going yeah yes the next item is to approve three more contracts for non-represented employees one administrator has moved positions and then two will be new um I mean two administrators have moved position and one is new to the district uh if I may I'll read those out the terms the terms for Valley arbizu director of student service interim salary 145,146 126 work days that's prated based on an annualized salary of 200 $ 47,800 on a 221 day work year okay Barry Tyler assistant principal interim uh Berling game high school salary $91,900 [Music] 103 and a half

160work days that's prated on an annualized salary of $190,000 and $190,400 with a 214 day work work year and those are recommended for approval okay does the board have any wish to discuss this item have any questions or comments if not is there a motion I make a motion to accept approve that I second that okay we have a motion and second are there any comments online or in there are none okay okay all in favor I I okay the item passed is just do a point point of clarification I just wanted to make sure that um for the item item two and item three um that the motion and the second for superintendent Booker's um Employment contract and also the approval of the amendment that that that was a joint uh yeah yeah just

161want to make sure that was so we can so there's no confusion there was a joint because it was two items it two is not a voting item three is the voting item I see I see we combine those it's one's a summary I think he presented the summary and then then he moved on to the to approve it yeah sorry okay did we done with that one okay the next and then we'll go to five five okay so the next it the next item in the one following is on the um contract proposal reopener for the American Federation of teachers that are adults school this item is an information item and that should be followed by a public comment hearing public hearing so there items for information and then any questions or comments okay

162move on to um item six then that's the public hearing get your gavel out okay we open the public hearing are any comments there are none okay we close the public hearing move on to item seven yes this is the approval for classified position bridgeo Bridge coordinator at Hillsdale high school it's for the uh empowerment program I think it was mentioned tonight and the bridge is from um the Middle School to the high school and then from the high school to the college and this will be a bridgeo bridge coordinator and we recommend approval of the job description if no comments I'll move I just want wanted to ask is this a position that already exists no it's a new position it's a new position uhhuh are you saying this was part of ATM the

163uh yes and empowerment through ETA and action is it funded through ETA yes it's funded through ETA yes well there you go we got our questions answered thank you okay great I make a motion to approve I second already moved oh sorry okay second again you do it you do it just brevity I just want to yeah we got a motion and we have a second are there any questions or any comments okay okay all in favor I I okay item seven passes unanimously we'll move on to item eight item eight is a job description revision and title change from the cap facilities fiscal manager to Capital facilities manager we redrafted the job description to focus more on the facilities and less on the fiscal aspect that we needed before before we um Incorporated a

164nonrepresentative position that's going to take care of that part okay any any any questions any comments discussion okay um okay is there a motion in a second I'll make the motion to approve second okay we have a motion and a second all in favor I I okay division why student services we have any No not tonight okay W division of instructional Services same not tonight okay item X division of Business Services all right all right thank you um we're pulling up a presentation here uh while we're doing that I'd just like to start by thanking the fiscal team uh as I've noted before they do the vast majority of this work and I just get to come up uh and give the board an update on where we are uh where we are is at

165first interim first interim is the first of the three major budget updates that we will give during the year uh the second will be second interim in March and then the estimated actuals that come with the proposed adopted budget in June all right um first inter room includes all the activity in the district Financial activity through October 31st of this year tonight we'll go over the key themes and takeaways uh the look at the budget calendar talk about significant changes since the budget adoption um look at our budget assumptions look at the actual numbers and then get into the multi-year projection uh talk about the positive certification that I'm asking for the board to approve tonight um and then go over our step down of one- time expenditures uh that we talked uh in depth

166about last week so I won't spend too much time on it uh and then we'll La we'll end with our future considerations things to be looking at in terms of our key theme te and takeaway uh we still uh are looking at the long-term fiscal impact of the onetime covid-19 funding and we'll hit on that uh later in the presentation um we still see continued negative pressure from State mandated pension rates uh although uh the stirs rate has stabilized at 19.1% um we'll look at as you may have seen some of the uh news today uh continued interest rates pressures and which impact our mortgages um and impact potentially home prices which then potentially impact our assessed value increases um as uh as Craig noted earlier tonight um I do say this a lot and

167it is uh uh it is really a testament to this board and the financial team um that we are in a strong financial position to face these challenges that we're moving ahead with um and uh as always we are a community funded District uh but we also have to look at the state economy um uh and uh the potential budget deficits at the state level in terms of budget calendar I noted we're here uh We've we're at first interim capturing all activity through October 31st um and uh we'll be moving forward uh into second interim but at that point we really start looking at the budget in terms of uh significant changes since budget adoption uh we have seen a decent Improvement um that is due to uh secured taxes High coming in a little

168bit higher couple million dollars higher uh than we had at the budget adoption uh we also saw unsecured taxes come in uh about a million dollars uh of those two the secured taxes are more important because those are ongoing taxes whereas the unsecured money is one time uh in terms of Staffing we've now staffed based on actual enrollment and Staffing and placement so uh our staffing numbers should look uh pretty good with the exception of potentially unfilled positions uh going through the rest of the year in terms of one-time commitments uh uh we have about $1.1 million of site carryover so that was not included in the budget adoption but has incl has been included in first interim um we have just under $300,000 in emergency preparedness that was set aside uh by the board

169um and that the superintendent uh is working uh on and uh we have a 2.4 million one-time contribution to Health and Welfare uh we talked about that last week it'll be be an important thing to monitor uh as we move forward that is for calendar 2526 I'm sorry calendar 25 and that's why you note that the impact is split between 2526 and um in terms of budget assumptions I'll just hit on uh two quick things as you can see the out years include 3 and a half% assessed value growth um but as you can see in terms of salary increases in the out years we don't have a projected salary increase because we have not negotiated that so it's important when we look at the multi-year projections to note that they do have some assessed

170value growth built in uh but no salary increases it gets down to the number um uh we're looking at hold on I apologize uh the main change uh from the adopted budget to First interim um is actually the posting of the actuals on restricted funding um as the board knows uh when we post back our uh restricted fund balance then we also post the expenditures for that um for both our uh ending fund balance uh grants as well as our deferred uh Revenue grants uh this is a pretty detailed slide but I just want to get into a couple of numbers uh as we noted last week we focus on the UN we want to focus on the unrestricted side of the budget so for 2425 um we see just over a $2 million uh

171excess of expenditures over revenues uh but I do want to note that uh 1.1 million of that is one time in terms of uh our site carryover that has been posted um and then about 300,000 of that uh is uh for emergency preparedness onetime allocation so on an ongoing basis for uh uh 2425 we are showing a a very small uh deficit uh that I expect us actually probably to make up uh in the year uh as we get uh through the year uh in the out years it's just important to note that uh we do have the three and a half% built in uh in terms of assessed value growth um but we don't have the the raises so although we have uh about 3 million and 4 a. half million in 25 26

172and 26 27 respectively um that's without any raises um built in and a little bit over $15 million doar uh per percent there in terms of certification um tonight uh I will be asking the board to approve a positive certification that means that our the district uh District staff believes that we will be able to meet our Financial Obligations for the current and two subsequent years we went over these next three slides last week so I won't spend too much time on it but here is the list of major one-time funding still available that's why you saw that large uh increase uh uh around uh restricted expenditures um this is the carry the carryover and the spend down of those um plans in terms of uh the step down of our one-time expenditures this slide

173shows the uh positions currently shown to sunset at the end of June 30th 2025 um and June 30th of 2026 I'm going to hit a note on this slide as I go over the next slide of what are we doing in terms of monitoring and looking at that one thing we noted in the spring was monitor the budget explore funding opportunities um one thing actually that's come up literally since last week's budget presentation was we received our formal Title One allocation uh for the next year um and it saw a bump year over-year and it looks like we will be able to uh fund one FTE uh out of that positions that we're uh planning on being sunsetted at the end of June 30th 2026 so we're already you know seeing some movement there so

174that that was one piece of good news that I wanted to let the board know that it's actually not even included in the um the numbers because those were only through October 31st uh but in the fall we'll we'll gather principal input we'll hold our annual budget study session and we'll continue to explore those funding opportunities uh and then in the winter the board will take formal actions on whatever sun setting is finalized so future considerations you know keeps me up at night at property tax growth um that's the number one Revenue driver so uh I'm daily looking at the uh at the the AV growth website that our our county office or the county has for us um we look at the phase out of the one-time funding that we just noted over the

175last couple of slides uh and the sunsetting of the positions funded uh by onetime funding uh we'll look at negotiations uh noted a couple times that there's no increases included in that myp um Health and Welfare premiums we do have a one-time uh allocation for those this year but we're going to have to work with our labor Partners uh on figuring out some solutions around uh Health and Welfare uh with the the significant increases that we've seen over the last few years uh in terms of State mandated pension rates uh hopefully we're at the end of the road with the stirs increases uh but we still have to uh monitor the pur increases those have shown the projection of a little less than a 1% increase over the next couple of years in purs so

176hopefully those don't change too much uh you'll see in the next uh couple of months our enrollment projections for 25 26 and Beyond so uh you know continuing to monitor that and see if we continue to have a slow decline of enrollment in the district um monitoring interest rates um and uh looking at special ed Education costs and needs over uh the foreseeable future with that I'm happy to answer any questions board have any questions any comments yes oh you you you were I was hesitant I only have a few trusty Lan all right thanks so in the first interim financial report page it went from federal reserves in 23 24 to about 7.4 million dropped to adopted budget of 3.5 and then first interum is at 4.1 seems like a big variance so can

177you just kind of update me on what the variance is and why so many changes um so the UN audited actuals so for for last year uh you just specifically the federal just Federal yeah the for the federal res I have another question after that that's why I'm asking okay um so for the federal resources we had some um additional federal revenue in the prior year so 23 24 um in 2425 uh our initial budget we only uh include our um Regular allocations um but we at first interim the increase is due to the deferred revenue of UN spent um amounts out of all of our federal grants they don't end up on our fund balance um just because of how the state requires us um they're not technically grants they they're earned when we

178spend them got it okay then my next question is in the multi-year yep so I'm concerned about the next two-year predictions for federal money you have it at about 3.5 million seems pretty consistent I'm just hearing from California school boards Association Federal you know their lobbyists that there could be con some concerns about revenue is that a concern of yours or not a concern of yours it's a concern uh of mine um of that three and a half million uh a vast majority of it comes from two different sources um the first is federal idea or special education dollars that's about 2 million um for us annually um and then uh the title one money that I was talking about uh it was about 600,000 in these numbers um we actually just got our allocation

179it's about 800,000 so we saw we did see a bump there um in Title One funding um primarily actually related to demographics um not necessarily big changes at the federal level um but you know with there is uncertainty um at the federal level um you know we'll have to monitor that um but so I I would say I don't have specific concerns that oh I'm very worried about Ida I'm very worried about I have General concerns just given um uh some of the uncertainty that's out there a change in administration um uh and the incoming president's um things that he's noted about education um but you know those are more General concerns last question um so multi-year projections I don't percentages reserves so if you can help me it helps me understand the three-year term

180of how we're doing positively or negatively so what are our reserves first inter room 2526 and 2627 overall what are our reserves so um they are still probably under I don't I don't have the exact number so I I don't want to give you the but um they're lower than what they were um in 2324 projected we have a little bit of a deficit we were right about 19% in terms of our um unrestricted Reserve um our budget is increasing a little bit um and we've got about a $2 million deficit projected to come down so that probably decreases to around 18% um in the out years I see uh those numbers going up a little bit um but those are without uh up as in the reserve goes up or the the deficit goes

181up and therefore the no no no sorry the reserve goes up in 25 and 26 uh due to as of right now um we show a $3 million and $4.5 million excess of Revenue over expenditures uh and so that would bump up um but still under 20% in terms of unrestricted Reserve okay but it helps me you're asking for a positive certification well a healthy Reserve is a positive certification so that's but I've been doing this for years yep and that's how I know yep well maybe maybe we can add a percentage um on this slide for moving forward but I appreciate your yeah sorry iin math yeah yeah did we go over that in the study session right I wasn't there I'm so sorry I know I know so I did a quick question

182just to make it solve for me so that was just for mey you have any questions I just want I don't have any questions because um you did an amazing I mean we spent almost two hours in the stud budget study session but I do want to thank you and your staff you know I love looking at numbers and I I think uh you guys do an amazing job putting everything together the only thing that I didn't like was uh page 10 because I don't like um the one time step down that's the page I don't like um because I don't like saying step downs but I know it's onetime funding and that's necessary to have the one time step down um one of our csba conference speakers had shown us evidence that students still

183need additional support uh even postco but we don't have that additional source of the funding then then I understand why we why we have one time step why we have onetime funding we have to have a step down but I wanted to thank you and your staff for putting this together I know you worked really hard yeah thank you thank you uh just uh to trustee L's um superintendent Booker um showed me a slide from the the budget study session um where we did have those percentages and so sorry guys no no no no no no no it was a good because um in the adopted budget we actually showed a deficit in the in the two out years um some of the positive news around secured property tax growth some of our other um

184expenditure savings um in first interim um have improved that outy year and so in that it actually showed uh de decreasing exactly kind of how you noted that but which is very typical so I'm not too worried if it's a dramatic yes but if it's insignificant then I'm fine no but yeah we did have an improvement from the budget adoption till now so in know one one week's time that that has shifted and so you're more accurate than what you did the previous presentation I we're more you know give us a little more time and we're a little bit more accurate so it sounds like he's doing a great job that's all I'm saying you heard me but this is the only page I don't like but everything else was fine I'll change I'll get

185off that page then thank you the board have any other questions or comments if not entertain I make a movement a move a movement I'd like to adopt our first I second that movement okay we have motion positive certification we have a motion and a second for the adoption of the positive certification all in favor I I I passes 5 Z and now we'll go to the presentation of the independent auditor report normally my favorite part of the whole board meeting yuck y have a big book no goes with this right all right so um while our Auditors are jumping on here um I want to introduce James Marta um James Marta is the audit partner um um from James Marta and Company looks like there's maybe some yeah yeah it's the music video filter

186is that what that is I don't know can you hear me yes yes we can so yeah I'd like to introduce James Marta um The District's Auditors um and we will go uh James if you just want to tell me next slide I will move forward in the present yeah he's gonna make sure I move forward good so um we have a short time so we're going to go through this quickly so let's just move ahead and so our our job is do an audit over the district as a whole but we also have to make sure that we communicate to you certain things so we're going to go through the audit and the compliance letters next and so the um the scope of the audit is to do the district audit but we have

187a lot of state federal money uh that we have to report on and we have certain elements to report on next um next so our responsibility is to give an opinion on the financials so when you look at this 93 page report um you call it the audit report but really the letter on the front's the audit report the rest is a representation of your management team and next and so we work closely with them we do we start in the spring we do a lot of work throughout the year I think uh Valerie had to respond to over 400 different um request documents to do this audit and so a lot of work since the spring through now next um we didn't have any issues or disagreements next um the biggest estimate on these

188financial statements are really your pension liabilities perhaps accounts receivable but we don't have any real issues with that next slide um audit is more than just matching up the numbers and checking it to reports we look at the systems the policies controls to ensure that they have systems to protect assets to reord them to meet comp uh compliance next um we have met we we completed the audit as planned next so on the financial audit we we'll go into some highlights so we have an unmodified opinion so as an board member that's what you want to see an unmodified opinion next slide um the yansy and his team they work and make a really good management discussion analysis a great place for you to look at and understand what's happened during the year and they

189have some nice charts and other information that are a good to look at in understanding the overall financials next so the financial position you see that assets have strengthened most of that is because of capital assets but you also have liabilities have added to that the net position CHS a negative I will tell you that is everything put together I will explain why that is and that's mostly because you have bonded debt on there we have to show the debt but you don't have to pay it those are General obligation bonds and I have a slide that will show that that we have um $897 million of of um bonded debt but you have a negative net position of of 100 million so you really operating you do not have a negative but that's how

190we have to show it next slide um so these are the financials you can see on the lower part that negative but that's because of bonded debt that your District won't pay the homeowners will next slide so um this shows the negative and over here I have a little chart that shows how much of your debt the homeowners will have to pay and that's the $897,000 but that does show on your financial statements because but you get the buildings but they get the debt next slide so you can see that statement of activities your your revenues were higher but as yansy reported you have um a lot of these one-time fundings going away you see these total expenditures um really the prior year you you had those one-time expenditures that were kind of coming off

191now and so you're going back to normaly um your financial position did strength in um but part of that is bonded debt funds that have come in also next slide so this is the showing the activities for the year so you can see um where the expenditures are and and instruction and instruction related is the Lion Share of that you can see where your funds come in um and so most of it is local taxes and so you're considered similar to what's called a basic aade District most your your money comes local next slide so this is where I'm showing lcff Lo is local funding control but most of your funds are from the local taxes um you did have $7.4 million of federal revenue in this year so we're looking backwards the N see

192what he showed is looking forward and so um a lot some of this um emergency funding about three million that you were getting in the past is going to go away so that's what yansy was talking about so last year you had that this year you have some but it's kind of going away next slide um most of your expenditures are employee benefits uh and salaries salaries and benefits and you can see the rest is books and supplies next slide um so this is a little bit about what yansy was showing she was showing going forward we're going showing some of these numbers backwards um under this calculation that the Department of Education wants to show you're showing a reserves as a percentage of outgo so this is kind of a a conservative look at

193it but the 3% is low and so that 3% is like the the minimum and so I heard you talk about that you do want to make sure that you have um a stronger position in that and that's why you have to look at having some surpluses in those years so that um if unexpected expenses come up you have the chance to have some absorption of that and so you are you have good District guidance that you're getting from yansy to um attend to that going forward next slide so you can see that your average daily attendance is kind of flat you have some erosion I actually seen more erosion in other districts across the board um your District looks stronger than most so I think um the erosion I see across California Washington in

194Oregon has really been people going to other you know aging of the population but also people going to other education sources but you've been attracting and retaining them so you are different next slide so the audit is a critical look at your organization we have to you have a lot of compliance we do have one attendance finding I'll report to you we have no findings on internal control or compliance and no federal findings so let's go over to the next side and talk about the finding so what happened is how they were count counting some of your Ada they were over they the calculation overstated it and so we looked into it the district found out uh what they did and they did correct it um the impact to a normal District would about about

195500,000 there's no Financial impact to your District however because the state requires any attendance counting things to be a finding it is is a finding but there's no District there's no impact because you don't get any funding from the state for this so you don't have to do anything else on it but we have to report it so not a big deal um and so prior your findings there were none next so the district's financial position actually strengthened this year you benefit from the you know good forward-looking um fiscal management we really want to thank Valerie and her team and yansy yansy he does roll up his sleeves once in a while and and find things and help us with it so we really appreciate um all the whole team in helping to make this

196a successful audit with that are there any questions board have any uh questions comments how often does yany roll up his sleeves no I'm just kidding just kidding I do have been a while that's it trusty trusty Jacobson this this goes back to Greg question about the reserves and um our guest mentioned that it was we had 3% is that a different yeah that's the state mandated Reserve minimum I thought so so it had it also had another slide where it showed ending fund balance right above it so the state mandated Reserve um was about 7 million and then we had about $54 million in terms of uh overall I just wanted to make sure that we were above we were above the above the 3% we're above the% Asus by board policy um yeah

197and we're actually we're in line with the state average in terms of fund balance thank you any other questions or comments okay I make a motion to accept the independent Auditors report I second that okay we have a motion in a second are there any comments either in person or online line okay um call for the vote how do we vote I I high so item passes um 5 Z we'll move on to why y one C csba delegate assembly nomination so I'll take that one so I was hoping our board would nominate me to continue what I'm doing which is being the delegate assembly for our region five area so I want to Hope want to you would nominate me so that I can use the paperwork so uh shark could help me with

198the paperwork before January you know the first time you you volun the first thing that you slipped in you volunteered now you're asking for help from the rest of us I I want to nominate uh trusty L for that and I I also wanted to ask a question because somebody reached out to me because there's a couple of delegate openings and so yeah Alyssa maoy was telling me that we there's some that are appointed but my my election is up oh I see so I'm in the rotation where if I want to continue doing what I'm doing with the reelection I have to run again so we couldn't nominate two people tonight for those for those open yeah they could be nominated by appointment different oh I see so yeah so somebody can take those

199positions in a different way okay I nin you okay there a second I'll second I'll second okay we got a motion in a second all in favor I item passes 5 and uh what we got board policies Z everybody have a chance to review the the board policies I don't think there's any on there I I didn't have a chance to review them as as closely as I want and I I'm GNA have some questions so should I do those over email once I've had a chance to look it over better or and I did I gotta confess I did not look at them this time then how can we vote on it we're asking that they move to consent for next meeting but if you have questions in between so what I would suggest

200is send uh send me those questions I'll work with staff to answer them or we can have a phone call uh any questions that you send and that I answer I would send to the whole board so everyone has a sense yeah and then we would with your permission with the board's permission or direction we would put this on consent if you had further questions at our next board meeting you can always pull this item during consent talk about it approve all of consent except for that item or talk about it and approve that item however you want to do it okay yeah sounds good so it will be on it's scheduled for consent and correct if we're still curious we'll ask questions and and and clear the item so okay um let me get

201back to my agenda is that is that it oh anybody want to add anything to uh future board agenda item yes I I would like to see that we really get our self- evaluation done during the coming year bring it up somehow deal with it um the other item and I'm going to slip it in here for lack of an an item on the agenda I'm going to ask all my colleagues to send suggestions to the superintendent on how we can make board discussion more Equitable and fair and and I have to say this because I've sitting here a long time and when you're number five which means you're you know sometimes you're first up sometimes you're last up and you know and what happens and this isn't you know it's like sometimes you get

202well I I can ask all the hard questions and de you know and really get engaged and then the last person has the same stuff and well well okay I'm still here you know call me first next time so I I want I want the discussions to uh include everybody and I want to be able to balance that with moving the agenda so um let's get some suggestions if we could fix that then I can I can I can call it quits and right off in the sunset and I'm sure you guys be glad to see me go so anyway let's try to let's try to come up with some suggestions make that process better so we're all included you have an item yes um is there a way that we could do kind of

203a followup to tonight's discussion about the multilingual learning with teachers for sure thank you absolutely yes and and also um I would like uh some kind of update formal update we got a weekly but about what the what you guys found about math after looking into the Casp scores and and our math situation yes and we've been talking about that so for sure thank you okay anybody have any other item

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.