001Janu January 23rd 2025 and it is 5:34 and we will uh call this meeting to order uh can I get everyone to follow me in the flag slope ALG to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all we'll start with roll call trusty hul here trusty Tran here and truste Kim here I'm here too trusty Proctor online here we will uh begin our agenda uh just a quick summary the citel Foster City School District cannot act upon any matter that has not been included and publicly posted on this agenda except under limited circumstances as prohibited by law the board May refer matters raised in this form to staff for investigation and or action where appropriate please
002limit your statements to 3 minutes the agenda should approve the agenda yes I make a motion yes uh I would like to um make an motion to approve the agenda for January 23rd so I'd like to make a motion to approve the agenda but per President Brooks's request we are going to be removing items 5A and 5B from this agenda to be picked up at a later time if that's okay with the board a motion to approve the agenda with uh striking 5A and 5B second all yes all in favor say I I I I'll do a roll call vote president pro excuse me uh trustee Proctor yes can you hear me yes okay yes yes trusty H yes trusty Tren yes trusty Kim yes all right with that we will move [Music] to public
003statements to non-agenda topics where we go yes oh those are I think she was supposed to call we'll start with uh Megan good evening members of the board and thank you for this opportunity to speak my name is Megan Freeman I've been a teacher in this district for 17 years and I here representing Parkside montauri one of two public montauri schools in our district with the support of this school board Parkside has successfully transitioned from a traditional school with a montau track to a fully implemented montauri model serving twice as many students as we did previously thanks to your backing our classrooms have been equipped with furniture and learning materials that align with the montor philosophy this helps our students engage in a Hands-On student- centered approach to learning we're also extremely proud to share
004that through District funding almost all of our teachers have completed or are working on completed completing accredited montau training programs I recently completed my training just a few months ago we've built a strong professional learning community at Parkside thanks to cohorts attending training together and having the ability to Focus parts of our district PD days on our growth as a montauri school this work has helped our staff become better equipped to meet the diverse needs of our students and ensure their success a Cornerstone of our program success and its sustainability is the role of our monor coach currently held by Julie mammo in order for teachers and training to receive their montor credential they must meet regularly with a coach to reflect on their teaching practice lessons ask questions and study the children in their
005classrooms you might consider it a one-on-one professional development to help the teacher as they learn a whole new way of teaching this coaching doesn't stop once a teacher earns their certification newly trained teachers rely on the coach to help them Implement what they've learned navigate real world classroom challenges and build confidence as they establish their practice and even fully trained and experienced teachers benefit from the coach's guidance as they continue to grow reflect on their practice and adapt to the changing needs of their classrooms the montor approach requires continuous professional learning as teachers are called to observe students closely respond thoughtfully to their developmental needs and deepen their understanding of the curriculum and materials because the montor method is student centered it asks teachers to take a step back and examine what the students are
006doing and then determine how to guide them further on their developmental path it is so introspective our montoo coach is perhaps the most valuable resource for us as teachers regardless of our level of experience they also play a critical role in supporting our District's literacy and math coaches helping them adapt their expertise through a montauri lens and they oversee the inventory and distribution of montauri materials to ensure Equity across classrooms the presence of a trained montauri coach is a required piece of the national Center for montauri and the public Center contract that the district signed the position previously funded by the school was previously funded by the school district however that position at parkite is now only 50% and is funded by our PTA this Reliance on PTA funding creates inequity and instability making it
007harder to ensure consistent reliable support for teachers and students investing in a district funded montauri coach is about sustaining our program it's about ensuring that everyone every one of our students has access to a rich child- centered education and that each of our teachers is equipped to meet the needs of every learner Public monitory Schools like Parkside are rare and they provide access to an educational approach that is often only available in private schools ensuring Equitable District support for our coach and materials helps us fulfill the promise of providing this highquality education to All Families regardless of their income we deeply appreciate the board's continued support of Parkside montauri and we would love to work with the district to explore how we can ensure the ongoing success and sustainability of our monor program together we
008can continue to Pro provide Equitable access to this unique and transformative education for for all our students thank you for your time and for your commitment to our students and schools [Applause] next we'll call Rick sukot Rick sakota move to the next one Mayor Rob nsome sure good evening uh I'm mayor Sano Mayor Rob Nome here today speaking not as the my capacity as mayor but as a citizen of Sano uh although I was requested by local council member Danielle Soro Kiki and Nicole Fernandez who both are a district and council member training up in Sacramento uh the neighborhoods are very concerned about the impact of the new bus parking lot uh I came on behalf of myself to convey two messages one I'd like to encourage your the school district to please double down
009on communicating to people that are affected by changes you'll be making whether this be new buildings moving schools creating changes in traffic patterns or decreasing or increasing traffic to different areas by and large our community are extremely supportive of our schools but please please please be transparent communicate use Outreach and engagement secondly in my city as mayor I would like to make sure that you knew that the city of Sano is very proud to be partnered with the Sano Foster City School District anything we can do to help you assisting with evaluation of impact of traffic patterns or we anything we can do to help make schools and their surrounding neighborhoods safer we are all in that said I just want to make sure that you understood that our our resources from the city and
010our partnership are extremely important and anything we can do to make it a successful relationship we would like to thank you thank you right we'll Circle back to Mr Rick sakuda good evening thank you mayor for uh speaking for us I find it incomprehensible that this board and the former board could not fathom that adding 70 buses support Vehicles drivers their vehicles to our community would not have a serious impact on our quality of life here and that we were Unworthy of your slightest consideration to be informed or to be notified of these changes all this lack of transparency does is create a air of acrimony and distrust among the community and the board and you can see there's a lot of people here I don't what everyone's going to speak on but this is
011not typical I heard from a Community member say I'm not going to vote for any school bonds anymore people are upset the community outreach and communication was an abject failure because most of the people here knew nothing about this and the only person that I understand has been communicating with the community is Mr Cam and thank you I hope that the board can find a way to work with the community our mayor our city Council and find a solution that will minimize the impacts to our neighborhood and rebuild the trust thank you um president president Brooks president Brooks if I can um make a a comment should not sure if some of these should be moved to the agenda item the agenda Miss uh Natalia gulan um hello everyone my name is Natalia guen and
012I am the mother of an eighth grader at Abbot currently in the Spanish Immersion program and a fifth grader at Festa Gardens as you are all aware Festa Gardens is becoming a TK through 8th grade school and will move campuses this summer despite years of knowing this plan the Middle School planning has been very delayed and slow and frankly nonexistent until recently when we started conversations about Middle School we were never told that middle school would look much different at Fiesta than a typical Middle School in the district we were we were told that there would be Sports and music and electives and it would be great well as we started learning more this year about the middle school program at Fiesta we learned that there wouldn't really be an extensive electives option Sports or
013music programs and the real kicker there would be no advanced math Pathways ever we also learned that Abid Spanish imersion program would be discontinued and the only Spanish Immersion offering would be at Festa this would all make great sense if there was a true Middle School offering at Fiesta where kids would have a full academic electives music and sports experience with their Spanish Immersion program so now this that the Middle School option that Fiesta students have always had access to through the continuation of the his Spanish emerger program at Abbot has been removed and downgraded the middle school being offered at Fiesta is nowhere comparable to what has been offered to Fiesta students in the past this is a disservice to our kids especially our fifth graders who have invested six years into the Spanish
014program and want to continue the program without losing the academics and options that have always been available transition is hard and takes time so I understand that time is needed to get a brand new Middle School up and running however that shouldn't be at the expense of my child I am here today to ask that Avid continued Spanish emersion program for our current fifth graders given that the middle school program at Fiesta is still a work in progress and nowhere near what it should be our children should have the same opportunities as all Fiesta kids that came before them not less this transition shouldn't affect them and this is why the most reasonable path forward is to keep the Abbot Spanish Immersion program until there is a solid Middle School offering for Fiesta students the
015Spanish emerging program at abbid will continue next year for seventh and eighth graders the teacher and curriculum are in place so we're only asking for the program to stay as is for sixth grade as well my fifth grader is interested in music is advanced in math and wants to explore all of the amazing electives offered at Middle School while also continuing his Pathway to biliteracy why should he have to choose between the two I have been in conversations with Dr rakawa I have reached out to you the school board and the last email I received from superintendent Ooa stated that there would be no option for the Spanish Immersion program at abbit earlier today I did speak with Dr Ruba Gaba who did offer some hope of an advanced Spanish class at Abbott I am
016pleased to see some movement with this request and though I think an advanced class at the level appropriate for our students while keeping the biliteracy standards with the goal of having the biliteracy award at the end of 8th grade would be a good compromise I would still like to see the full immersion program continued adap it for our kids again I am looking for the same opportunities for my child as every other child at Fiesta the fiesta Middle School is not ready let's keep the options available for everyone during these transition Years thank you for your [Applause] time Christina B hello everybody I'm not good at public speaking even though I work with a public in healthcare but this is a little scary for me I'm Christina and I have two kids currently at Fester
017Gardens including a fifth grader I have to say the K through five has been absolutely incredible I love our school our community and our teachers and our previous um director who's here she was amazing um I'm here in support and hopes of keeping the Spanish emersion program at abbit Middle School while I know Festa Gardens will be an amazing Middle School down the road I do have legitimate concerns as to the quality of the school once our kids start sixth grade in August we know the school will be open but will our kids have a rich Middle School experience I have to say I was very disappointed to learn that there will not be a middle school building until the spring of 2026 if all goes as planned there also will not be a soccer
018field when they open in August I think our kids deserve to LEAP into sports if they want my son is not super into sports but because of the current Fiesta field he did get into soccer I asked him would you want want to go to a school where you can play soccer and represent your school and he said absolutely which is not really typical for him to be out there like that um will there be clubs offered dances these may may seem small to us adults but to kids these are a big deal and they make an impact on them I feel that our families should have the option to continue with the Spanish Immersion immersion program at Abbot while the new Fiesta Gardens DK through 8 school is getting established the responses we've heard
019about the Spanish Immersion program at Abbot have all been very positive Abbot seems to offer a robust High School preparation experience we would love for a son my husband and I son to have that same experience if keeping the Spanish emerging program is completely off the table which I hope it is not then please at least offer some sort of alternative elective class for the Spanish Immersion kids thank you very much for your [Applause] time Lissa Pino good evening um like the two um strong women who spoke before me I also have a child at Abbott in this fanish immersion continuation program and I'm also a parent of a fifth grader at Fiesta Gardens I am speaking to you about a deep concern regarding the transition of the current fifth grade Fiesta Garden students into
020Middle School these students have already faced significant challenges due to the pandemic and the current offerings of the Middle School options exasperate the inequities they are facing as you know the district has presented families with two options for Middle School one like Abbott Middle School that offers a comprehensive well re well-resourced Middle School experience including extracurricular such as clubs dances competitive sports teams and updated facilities as well as academic opportunities like math advancement the other option remaining at Fiesta Gardens as it transitions to and builds a new site allows families to continue their focus on Spanish language immersion but lacks these resources and opportunities this dichotomy in our options does not PR present an equitable choice for families who wish to prioritize by literacy in Spanish the opportunity to do so comes at the cost
021of vital extracurriculars and academic advancements this is not an equal Choice it's a forced compromise the current fifth grade class as you are aware has already been significantly impacted by the pandemic due to early disruptions in their education this cohort only had a few months of kindergarten Spanish before the world shut down every teacher of these of these students has indicated that they are behind in their Spanish language development and now these students are being asked to make an impossible decision between continuing their education with a robust middle school program or focusing on improving their Spanish at the expense of everything else superintendent AOA has acknowledged that any change will face push back while this is understandable it is more important to ask do we need to impose such drastically different options on a class
022of students who has already been significantly affected by the pandemic should these students many of whom are already marginalized due to their disrupted learning experiences be forced to choose between a comprehensive education and language Proficiency in Spanish California Ed code establishes that all students are entitled to an equitable and comprehensive education which includes the opportunity to develop and maintain biliteracy skills specifically Ed code section 305 and California code of regulations Title 5 Section 11308 outline the rights of students to receive education that Fosters linguistic proficiency the district's current and polarizing options are a clear violation of this I urge the school board to take action and advocate for a solution that allows our students to receive a balanced education that nurtures both their academic growth and their Spanish language Prof um sorry Spanish language development
023we should not be placing Ames in a position where they have to sacrifice one critical aspect of their child's education for another as a teacher myself I fully recognize the complexities involved in funding and the master schedule but given that this adjustment could be made through strategic scheduling and efficient use of already existing resources such as expanding language offerings within the current staff or facilities at Abbott this solution is not cost prohibited prohibitive and can be implemented without significant financial strain on the district we ask for your help in ensuring that the district provides Equitable and viable options for all students especially those who have already faced considerable challenges in their educational Journey please prioritize the needs of our Fiesta Gardens fifth grade students and work with the district to create a more balanced comprehensive
024solutions that do not force families to choose between opportunities that should not be mutually exclusive thank you next we'll have Abigail morani all right hello thank you for the opportunity to speak um my name is Abigail I am also a parent of a eighth grader in the abbid immersion program and a fifth grader at Fiesta Gardens um I would just share first what an amazing experience my son has been having in the immersion program at Abbott and um I appreciate the districts support in helping Abbott come along so far as a school I feel like under the new principal principal Belzer you know he's very committed and things have really shaped up at Abbot and made it this amazing place that we want our kids to be at which was not always the case in
025the past um so my daughter of course sees all this as we're going over there with my son uh the one in eth grade and she says I want to go to Abbot and um and yet at the same time it's vitally important to our family that all the immersion work that our kids have done since kindergarten at Fiesta be able to be continued you know my husband's first language is Spanish it's you know just so important to um build all these cultural things um so I feel like the lack of options like many of my speakers before me have said the lack of options that are or the options that are being presented for fifth graders right now are just not fair I do feel like in the long term a kr8 immersion program
026is a wonderful idea and it will be a wonderful school as someone else said but let's not kid ourselves we are not going to be there for next year's fifth graders we should not be asked to choose between continuing the Spanish that is so important and also or choosing a school where you get the full Middle School experience you know I want my kids to have the opportunity to participate in sports teams clubs dances um music drama whatever they want to participate in that they may not not even know that they like right now um I feel like at Fiesta those things are for the most part not going to be available for next year's sixth grade class um the classrooms as you've heard will not even be ready for them on campus either um
027I feel like at Abid if we ideally like Natalia said before me continuing the emersion program at Abbot for another cohort uh starting with the sixth graders next year would be the ideal way to go everything is set up it's a wonderfully run program um there are you know we have the immersion teacher there already there's not a lot of reallocation that the district will have to do I've spoken with both the principal and the immersion teacher and the um vice principal as well the former imersion teacher everybody is in support of us continuing to have Spanish at Abbot to support our Fiesta students if the district will just make that possible um so like I said first choice of course would be to continue the immersion there if that is absolutely not possible then
028you know we did get a glimmer of hope just last night from U Mr rubac caber there about um that there may be a possibility of having a Spanish for native speakers or a similar highlevel Spanish class at Abbot next year and at the very minimum we need that to be an opportunity for our kids so that we can choose Abbot and continue get the full experience for them but in both the languages and the extracurriculars so thank you guys [Applause] next we'll have Marlene Lea sorry good evening thank you for the opport opportunity to speak um I have been with the Fiesta Gardens Community since 2016 since my oldest son entered kindergarten um I like others who just spoke have an eighth grader at the Abbott immersion program uh and a fifth grader at
029Fiesta Gardens uh my sons are able to speak read and write in Spanish all because of their education at Fiesta Gardens Elementary School it's been a great school and I wish it luck and it's it's been a really big part of our life but as a fifth grade parent if i' like my son to continue his Spanish Journey that he started six years ago I'm forced to stay at Fiesta Gardens a middle school program that is not yet fully established and that we're not interested in attending because it lacks a lot of the things that we're looking for that a traditional Middle School does include Abbott Middle School is an established program um we have experienced it with my older son and it has been great um and it has a lot of things to
030offer my son my fifth grader such as the clubs the sports the music the theater the leadership program social events and just exposure to a bigger School uh I feel like last year the parents at Fiesta Gardens had options on how they would like to pursue middle school and this year I feel like that we we don't have that option it will take a few years for for Fiesta Gardens Middle School to be established and we shouldn't be forced to be part of that process I'm asking that Abbott Middle School offer an Advanced Spanish option or better yet a continuation of the current immersion program for the fiesta Garden students who want to attend a traditional middle school and to continue their Spanish lessons um I think the other thing is that you know the
031community we didn't have a say in the decision to shut down Abbot yet we're the ones impacted by this decision so again I asked the board to please consider having more transition years while Fiesta Gardens establishes its Middle School program and to give the current fifth grade families the option to continue their Spanish education at Abbott medal school thank you for your time have Jill Lang so um in light of what's going on with the Spanish Immersion schools we're from aabon elementary but we support that and um 100% agree with what you're saying and we were glad to be able to come and listen to um this very important topic um ours is not quite as important as yours but um we have two issues that we wanted to consider with our current curriculum one
032is the um Reliance of on technology and um one is the age of the curriculum technology definitely has a place in education but we're concerned about the overemphasis on online learning and that it may be uh hindering engagement critical thinking and the personal connections that students need to thrive many teachers parents students have shared concerns about screen fatigue and the lack of opportunities for collaborative Real World Learning our students are becoming addicted to or perhaps overly reliant on screens we've introduced a number of online programs during covid and here we are five years beyond that and it's time for the teachers to get back to using all the skills that we have developed over the years instead of staring at a screen to make sure our students are staring at the right screen and waiting
033for a computer program to tell us where our students are struggling we are highly trained professionals who have worked hard to form connections with our students and we much more capable of meeting their needs and supporting them in a meaningful La lasting way than any computer algorithm ever will be the other issue is age specifically of our social studies curriculum the adopted curriculum was piloted in 2007 it has Arnold Schwarzenegger as Governor uh dated approach to colonization and expansion that's not reflecting current understandings our our students are um uh upset when they see the words Indians instead of native of Native Americans they are complaining about it so we hope you will take the request for limited time on technology and updated curriculum to heart as it comes from the teachers on the front line
034with students from all backgrounds and needs thank you very [Applause] much next we'll have Alexander gulian thank you for the opportunity to speak um I am a parent of a student at Fiesta fifth grade as well as another student at in eth grade at Abbott um I would like to say I don't want to reiterate some of the things that we said but I do want to point out some things uh that they touched on first I think it's wonderful that the district has two immersion programs that are really very um well supported uh by the community by the district by Administration by the teachers it's wonderful and I would love for the district to continue that and to recognize all the previous boards all the previous teachers all the previous staff all the previous
035students who have invested their time into these programs and invested everything they had to the education of these students the students for lack of a better word are the product and these students in fifth grade coming out are looking at really two not equal choices right now they're looking at a school a middle school that does not have facilities they're looking at a middle school that does not have sports activities that doesn't have other extracurriculars that lacks um electives and frankly doesn't have the same academic rigor as the other middle schools in the district the fact that the school will not have a opportunity for the kids to advance in math to get to you know do algebra in the eth grade is a real problem that the current uh students have to face so
036the investment in the Dual language in the Spanish has to kind of go away if what you want to do is invest in the high academics and in the high math uh my eighth grade student at Abbott is able to do both the Spanish Immersion and the double math class to be completed and have algebra done and get into you know high school and be ready to go everywhere they want and again that is thanks to the investment that the board that the staff that the teachers that the students have all put into the program that he can do that that is the kind of thing that the parents want to still be available for the students and it shouldn't be that just because they happen to have been in fifth grade this year instead
037of fifth grade last year that they lose that opportunity um we all recognize that the transition will eventually have a much better K through 8 program we recognize that but the fact of the matter is that is not ready and won't be ready for a couple of years so during that time all we are asking for is to continue with the Dual kind of opportunities available for the students to take either one or the other um thank you for your time Joel can we please check online to see if any hands are raised for non agenda related topics yes uh checking right now no public comment on Zoom thank you right um we will now move to public statements related to agenda items persons will be called on at appropriate time we will start with
038Robert Denise don don thank you thank you so I'm also here to speak to the Bayside bus terminal or bus program uh I was actually notified through a text message last night uh from one of my neighbors so I don't have any prepared statements per se uh but I do want to thank mayor Nome for coming up and uh kind of kicking things off for those of us who are impacted uh I've had children come through Bayside Parkside monori as well uh through Aragon I actually live right next to um joinville school I mean joinville Park so for me commuting through past you know Bayside or going up Roberta now that both schools have gone K through 8 um creates a much larger uh impact uh on the roads and and commuting in and out
039of effectively a cold sack area uh adding in an additional 40 buses that will be coming in four times a day in and out um and then the extra traffic as those buses are loading or coming in and and delaying the traffic coming in at the school area to me is I think a little bit inappropriate at this time especially with notification one day before the final approval I assume is what the board was trying to do tonight uh had and and then the other part of this is the um removal of uh some of the facilities at the actual Park it was never my understanding that the area where the picnic tables are are actually owned by the school board we all assumed they were part of Park and rack and owned by the
040city um but I guess mayor Nome that's not correct yeah I don't believe that okay so uh I think that I literally only had an hour before the meeting to actually go through the uh guidelines that were in the agenda not the agenda but the uh there is one one exception which I believe may not necessarily be true and that's the exception sixth exception uh regarding historical resources um in your um documentation about the fact that this was not an appropriate that you don't have to qualify for that exception in that there is no building the park um uh facilities that are there that are in use which are the picnic tables the only sort of large picnic Gathering area in this portion of the city will be removed based on putting a warehouse there
041instead which I believe since those that picnic area has probably been there as long as the park has which I think was back in' 65 or 70 um I didn't actually live in the neighborhood at that time but I do know people who actually went to the pool at that time and I believe that the uh picnic tables were there at the same time may qualify it as a historical resource and I'd like you to evaluate that the other is a potential site for the warehouse at least so you don't have to remove the tables where the temporary parking is for the construction work that's going on um uh for the um the the sewage treatment the the sewage treatment plant exception where buses that actually had enough space you could probably put the buses
042and the warehouse in that area and just create an entry off of a four-lane highway effectively to make it even easier for the buses to get in and out without impacting the side street areas where we are all impacted by that area uh that's all my comments thank you [Applause] um we we do have members of the public who submitted other comments on this topic so I want to make an announcement about the agenda so um this is an item that's agendized for tonight's meeting your welcome those of you who have already spoken to um uh go ahead and make further remarks if something else comes up after the presentation or just as a result of the discussion you're also uh welcome to just stay and and listen um we do have a handful of
043other um blue cards so if you would like to hold off on your remarks until the item comes up we can do that or if you would like to speak now and then again potentially speak later in the meeting so as we call your name if you just let us know I'd like to speak now or no I'm going to wait until the item comes up um that will help us just get through the the remainder of the meeting okay looks like no one is interested okay so we'll go ahead and um move to three let's read their names one at a time and see if they want to speak now or okay or hold off until the item com up okay Amy Jessel would you like to no I'll speak now okay I'll keep
044it quick I'll just keep this really quick because you've all heard from me I'm a writer not a speaker so what happens is I've already written the board um I am a journalist I started out as a journalist so I'm going to start with democracy dies in darkness okay so this transparency is a big issue here we have a problem with the whole Community being a bit outraged at the fact fact that we are all impacted by traffic and by these decision-making things I also though have a weird different hat in that I'm a substitute teacher so Parkside monu which spoke here and Bayside I have actually taught of both of them um I can tell you they're already impacted uh they've got a ton of kids that are going to be impacted by this
045traffic and and uh such as well I'm worried about Public Safety I haven't seen traffic Corridor studies I haven't seen any of these things and I'm I'm concerned about all of it I have other people that are part of our our board um that can speak to this more because I didn't prepare comments because I already wrote them uh but joinville I definitely do not feel that moving it to Across the Lagoon from Mariners island is the way to go um we've got homeowners that already are having to endure the sewage treatment plant sounds every morning in and out bouncing off of the water you don't have any idea how this impacts all of us and to move it that used to be Parkland and that was ripped up again under the the the coat
046of Darkness where they just started bulldozing trees we're going to do it temporarily it's supposed to be done by 2023 and it was not it's now 2025 so we have a lot of lost faith in this community and this is the kind of thing that we need to really have public meetings about not board meetings not Schoolboard meetings not even just City Council meetings but RIT large in the media we will be having a meeting on X Y and Z not [Applause] all Michael Lamb otherwise I fall asleep it gets too late um my good evening my name is Michael limb I am the secretary for the sheview Parkside neighborhood association and so we've had a lot of people that have have um contacted us and we've had a lot of comments from people people
047are not happy there are several things that are problematic one there hasn't been much Outreach to the community and I found out about Tuesday's meeting at Bayside just by a fluke I had to call up the school and find out if there really was a meeting and then I couldn't find the notice that I had seen previously um but that's kind of an old tactic you know that you don't give out a lot of publicity you don't get very many people attending um and that but you've washed your hands you've had a meeting two supposedly there has been talk with the city well no one on the city council that's for sure because I went and asked and so um that's that's a problem three uh traffic is a huge problem you already heard a
048little bit about the traffic huge huge problem I have not heard anything about a traffic survey or study about how the traffic problems are and how it could be alleviated thank you uh four squa which is the Environmental review is supposedly giving the district an exemption but they haven't met yet um there are a lot of birds that nest in the trees that are going to be taken down uh the trees are supposed to be taken down in February and I hate to tell you this but the birds are already nesting I know that because I watch the birds five what is the arrangement between the district and the city pertaining to jurisdiction over joinville Park um I've heard District people with an attitude that they can do what they want with the park because
049they have jurisdiction over it I don't know it's something to look into six many parents have no clue that they're plans to for a bus depot because there has been so little Outreach seven the 36 or so bus drivers will have to park come in the morning and park their cars and the cars are going to be parked in the joinville parking lot joinville Park parking lot and then surrounding neighborhood which means that if somebody wants to go to the park where's the parking area for them uh eight I'm sorry but the superintendent's words on Tuesday and I know you probably don't want to hear this is it's a done deal deal uh well it was kind of whispered because I know you know it's probably not the best thing to say one former city
050official that I talked to today said quote the district has a history of ignoring the community and I think that's borne out here because that's a continuation it's a theme that kind of says it all doesn't it that there needs to be better transparency better communication there should have been people that were working on this together with the community I do have to remind you that the board is the superintendent's boss but the residents and the voters are the trustees boss [Applause] good evening school board members I'm here to talk about the buses that are going to be stored at Bayside Middle School or so to speak they are uh this is a major problem that should not happen as some of my previous speakers have just conveyed uh there's no such thing as a
051d deal or tying your hands I can tell you that firsthand by representing the no sellouts group of Sano where we prevented 5G towers and given 300 foot setbacks okay so there's no such thing secondly for all of you who haven't seen this this is an ordinance growing up so I'm a scientist my background is cancer biology I grew up in Sano I was born and raised in Sano we moved to to Norfolk Street near kho and loai uh in 1979 we've been there since 1979 my concern is about these buses if you drive down kho there used to be a sign that said no vehicles over the weight of 5 tons can drive down kho Avenue those signs still are I think are still there somewhere but this ordinance prevents any vehicles of any
052sort of going down kho Avenue Beyond norol street so you can take 101 to Norfolk Street and that's it you can't go all the way down Bayside this is a s city ordinance if you want a copy I'm happy to give it to you so until until you guys follow and adhere School District does not supersede city ordinance law so please follow the law secondly uh there was some comment about public hearings who when where were there any representatives of District 4 surveys who when where were there any representative of District 4 next thing I want to talk about which is very near and dear to me which is Idle car pollution these buses are diesel buses even if they're biodiesel or if they're electric electric is a different story but if they are diesel
053there's a thing called idle car pollution Wayne mow with students at Carlmont High School have now made it illegal for parents to wait for their kids with their cars idling now so parents have to turn their vehicles off due to idle car pollution that is a significant problem if there's traffic up and down kho that's idle car pollution that means lung diseases asthma and long-term lung cancer okay that's a proven National fact that's not something pie in the sky that has been proven published worldwide not just in the United States okay next thing I want to talk about road damage if you know anything about road damage when Sam TR comes up and down our norfol street we get fissures that's why Norfolk is paved so frequently and so commonly also our front doors have
054cracks on them every single house on norfol Street will have cracks on their entry doorway because the houses shake when the buses go by okay the average weight of a school bus is 7 to 18 tons keep that in mind that exceeds the 5 ton limit that can go on K Avenue Home damage traffic access to EMS Vehicles okay Shore View is landlocked we only have three entry points and exit points and they are crucial we're landlock please please please do not use District 4 as a Dumping Ground we are not a Dumping Ground my suggestion is ask the banan group to store the buses at Hillsdale mall parking lot because we gifted them measure te that's the least they can do for our schools yeah thank you for your [Applause] time andna no done
055you were great got you hello thank you for the opportunity to talk to you I've lived in shiew for 30 years and this uh you know played in the park sent my kids to all the schools but the bus depot caught me by surprise and I am aware of what's going on in the city never heard of it until a few years ago a few weeks ago so I immediately saw the problems that can emanate from it and I don't know every detail about it but I can tell you that this whole thing that people talk about um uh communication you know visibility uh transparency is really really important we have um uh an organization for our community and you could have come and talked to us we have meetings every few months um the
056people here are trying to participate in this with the city city council Etc so it would have been nice nice if we had known about all the plans because it's a pretty big deal for us um there was a a meeting a couple of days ago I only found out about it an hour before the meeting happened at baysite so I couldn't attend and that's another thing with transparency and communication the city apparently didn't even know that you were doing and which is unbelievable um and then there was the whole issue of traffic because the city has plans they're doing different projects Etc millions of dollars are being expended to upgrade this to improve that and then you have plans so and there are also things that are coming up in the future so it
057would have been good if you guys have been talking to to the city to public works to see the impact now I don't know if it's true but someone showed before I came in someone showed me a map and it says that the picnic area is going to be moved the soccer field is not going to be there anymore I've been going to this park for 30 years and there are always people picnicking there are always guys playing soccer and kids so if you have plans like that it's really going to do damage to what the community can can do um and also I was wondering where are the bus drivers going to park because if there's going to be 30 or 40 buses it's going to be 30 or 40 drivers and I don't
058see in your plants a parking lot for the bus drivers that's just one little specific thing thank you thank you bites I don't speak publicly but my daughter is probably watching hi I want to thank you for your time uh everybody's talked about so many things I wanted to talk about um sheview is a very densely concentrated neighborhood of generational homeowners multi-generational dwellings new homeowners with children narrow streets they walk to school the bus depot is not going to service these children that's not what I want to talk about bide Academy is a k through eight school where the bus lot is going to go is the playground it's the soccer field this is a K through 8 school where the parking lot is going to become sorry the basketball court and the soccer field
059is going to become the parking lot where are the PE classes going to be held where are they going to be condensed to you're talking about children between the ages of 5 and 13 having their recreational time at the same time I'm not a parent but I don't think 5-year-olds and 13-year-olds should have recess at the same time together this is not going to just impact recess it's going to impact physical education I think that every student should have the opportunity to get outside and run around in an age appropriate socialization for their own activities in between classes it seems from their bell schedule every Tuesday and Thursday their breaks are at the same time K through 5 and Middle School sharing space outside at the same time I'm very concerned about the activities that
060might occur during this during this time everybody's talked about the parking the streets the infrastructure the buses uh the emissions the noise um I live across the lagon the water's going to travel it's it's not a done deal thank you for everybody who's spoken I would hope that you would reconsider the positioning of this best lot thank you okay not Tuesdays and Thursdays I at their bell schedule their breaks at the same time cursive is now a skill me it's me hi that National Archives want yeah it's Monique L marcino yeah so um thank you for this opportunity to come here I actually just got notified about this meeting um just shortly and um my husband's actually lived in that area for almost 40 years and we live um right at the end of kho
061on Lake Street and we suffer through the traffic and we love the school that's all fine but adding these school buses is atrocious they they're they're not agile they don't turn just the just the whole thing about it is um it's just really unacceptable there's got to be other options um that we can look into I'm in construction and 30 years in construction and I look around there's places under I mean under the bridges I mean there's so many places actually the one guy that was sitting here he had he has some really good points about coming in on the other side where the water treatment um I run through there and and I see that you know there's something that we could do to maneuver but bringing those school buses in in our area
062um you know I I'll I'm very interested in the environmental impact report um was there one done was there an environmental impact report done on on this does anyone know no okay well I'll be looking for that cuz um it is important and it's not and it's all the kids walking to school and and and back in h and the cars and and just everything it just seems um just seems It's just shocking the planning and then just not engaging all of us it it affects us it will affect us so um I just really hope you guys consider and um and like like the gentleman said I hope it's not a done deal because um we it affects all of us and we should we should have a say in a voice and and
063a lot of this it's crazy cuz I just heard a lot of people just say that they just heard about this so anyway I I'll just add on we're neighbors um but uh someone said just that I think was the gridlock of our neighborhood if you go to our neighborhood at 8 in the morning if you go to our neighborhood at 3 there it's like tack on 20 minutes of traffic and I have um called to school myself and said hey you guys need to have somebody out there better at the crosswalk because if I have a dentist appointment and I left like at the wrong time it's like another 20 minutes and if you add buses coming in and coming out there's just there's no repre and in light of you know the fires
064if there were a tragic accident in our neighborhood something went wrong and you're trying to exit our neighborhood it's impossible you add I don't know if the timing of the buses if it's like one after another if they all disperse at the same time is just not a good thought out plan n and it doesn't seem that you guys have answers also um so for the neighborhood for the people that are impacted we deserve better so thank you and we should all get to because for so many people not knowing about this I mean because this really affects our it is our daily life my husband we reroute stuff just just for the school and we can live with that but adding buses I mean I know my neighbors a lot of my neighbors didn't
065even know I talked to two of them and they didn't even know so they weren't able to come back and and I we we participated with the flood when the when the water and we will get a big showing so um I really hope that people people plan and do something about this because this isn't the end so thank you for your time can we can we uh Joel can we please check to see if there's anyone online to address this topic yes checking thank you I don't see any public comments on Zoom at this time thank you all right we will move to um three C Foundation reports committee PTA reports we'll start with uh SMA is there anyone from SMA uh yes I'm here oh thank you Kathy okay one second uh first
066of all I'm sorry I'm not showing my screen and not in person today I'm still recovering from the flu but I wanted to extend a welcome to SMA uh from SMA to trusty ho since your appointment came uh after our statements last month uh so welcome to the board earlier this month uh the Golden Gate service center which SM is a part of held the annual Schoolboard breakfast and we wanted to thank trusty Kim trusty Kim for attending and as a result of that breakfast we realize that there is a lot of value of being able to hold these uh candid conversations between Schoolboard members and then Educators that they serve and these type of conversations aren't necessarily going to occur just by visiting a governing council meeting but they can genuinely happen when we're
067sitting together at a table discussing a specific topic our executive board and governing Council have since discussed this and have some ideas of how we might be able to make that happen so please be on the lookout for some communication about this um from one of our executive board members in the coming days and finally tonight I want to mention that there is a lot of concern right now stemming from decisions that our federal government has made uh this past week the safety and well-being of our students and families are the top of everyone's mind right now and I'd like to thank our District staff who have worked to ensure student students and their families know that our district is committed to to protecting and supporting them and uh their communities but there remains a
068lot of uncertainty and anxiety from Spa members around this issue I'll remind the district that communication goes a long way uh that more is always better especially in time in uncertain times and I also hope that the board considers reaffirming board resolution number 0 51718 which outlines protections for undocumented students and School District members uh thank you thank you Kathy uh we can now hear from CA is there anyone from C sea online Joel uh I see well I saw earlier um uh Miss Bishop hold on there Shear are you guys able to hear me it's not working how about now can you guys hear me yes yes excellent okay well uh good evening trustees and superintendent Ooa and all present excuse me for those who are not familiar my name is brim Bishop I'm
069here on behalf of the ca uh chapter 411 which is the union serving the classified staff members of Art District happy New Year everyone um uh recently our chapter held elections to name uh the new governing board for our Union chapter and the results of these activities are as follows Alicia Aragon will continue as president dinora Smith continues as vice president Joanne Murphy continues as Treasurer John Harrison continues as Chief Union steward I have moved into the communications officer position and we welcome Felicia how as secretary uh Elicia asked me to convey her apologies for forgetting to announce our board to you at the last uh meeting last month uh as for tonight we'd like to acknowledge an item further down on the agenda Workforce housing first we would like to extend our many thanks
070to the district for taking this ambitious step and we're looking forward to positive outcomes with great anticip ation and enthusiasm uh additionally we would also like to take this opportunity to address some complimentary ways to assist with employees abilities to afford housing in the Bay Area and assist with other very large and competing Financial issues starting with Healthcare currently Sam Tao Foster City School District pays for the only the employees health care premium while Health Care coverage is available for employee dependents there is no no premium assistance available for employees uh children's coverage or dependence uh I don't think there's anyone here or listening from home who's not aware of the outrageous cost of Health Care insurance these days a single parent with one child pays a minimum of uh $1,113 for that child to
071share Health Care coverage for many of our employees that is about a third to almost a half uh in some cases of an employees take-home salary some of our members hope to qualify for medical which is a very unpredictable option often leaving families just Out Of Reach for qualifying for medical if someone is lucky enough to qualify for medical each year thereafter they have to reapply and hope that the stars align to be reapproved for continued coverage um it's not a guarantee uh if there is an tent for staff to be able to create personal savings while living uh in the future housing by doing so they would automatically become disqualified to continue medical coverage um once one of the requirements for eligibility uh is proving that you don't have access uh to available funds
072so building even the smallest savings for those residents uh would be counterproductive uh that being said many of our employees would not qualify for medical um alternatively Covered California could be an option but a lot of those programs come in a very high monthly cost and with high deductibles uh plus greater out-of-pocket costs exploring health care options for employee dependents would greatly lessen the financial and emotional burden of ensuring our children have health care coverage while continuing to keep the roof over our heads it's important to note that the Sano High School District seoa High School District and Jefferson High School Districts all offer paid health care for employees and their dependents Ravenswood District offers dependent coverage uh paying Approximately 80% of the dependent Premium One proven method of attracting and retaining employees is by
073being competitive with our neighboring districts and offering Health Care not only to our employees es but to their dependents as well that strategy also costs a lot less than an apartment complex uh one more thing that costs less than an apartment complex is the classified school summer assistant oh classified school employee summer assistance program this is a program that our school district has opted out of they if they close uh if they chose to opt in the state of California would match funds to be paid at out during the summer recess period to participating classified employees this would help all of our 10mon and 11mon employees making less than 62,400 essentially the employee would opt into the program and instead of having their yearly amount divided by 12 they would choose a dollar amount to
074be deducted from each check and the state would match that dollar amount they would then receive those State matched funds during the summer months the 10-month employees would only have to put aside in F for one month and the 11-month employees would only have to put aside uh for half a month this is another easy way to Pro put money into the pockets of employees the catch with this option is that the district would be responsible for the taxes the quote we received was about $50,000 but we're pretty sure that the quote included people who make more than 62,400 annually and therefore those employees wouldn't qualify for that program to be very clear we are very much on board and excited about this Workforce housing project we are pro anything that makes our unit members
075lives easier and healthier at the same time it is worth noting that this housing will benefit approximately 100 employees if we are talking about building housing to reduce cost for employees so that they can afford to live where they work then why aren't we also exploring other exploring other cheaper options to make it so more than 100 employees can afford to live where they work as well if a bond were to be set forth for this project of Goodwill then why not include the cost of Health Care and csap on it and to make it so that everyone can be helped thank you for your time and your and the opportunity to share some food for thought for down the road thank you that's all I've got for tonight thank you we'll move to SMF
076CAA updates what's happening hi good evening at the same time we are also having a Burell incoming informational meeting that we had to reschedule via Zoom back there so my team is welcoming new families um my name is Jessica Gad I am proud principal of Burell and I'm wanted to start off by thanking the board and the cabinet for their dedication and communication regarding immigration rights it's essential that all students feel safe as they are entitled to a free and safe public education thank you Tuesday we welcomed board and partners to Burell I highlighted our great teamwork and restorative practices and electives each year we've seen a decrease in suspensions and increase in interventions as we've implemented the restorative framework we've dropped this year uh 13 suspensions from last year to only six first quarter
077and increased 68 restorative practices interventions last year to 124 this year first quarter for electives we're gearing up to start second semester on Monday electives are a place where students have choice in their learning it's important to us to offer access to all electives to our students we have a thriving AVID program CCE double math leadership art drama technology I can go on and on I wanted to highlight our Burell instructional leadership team so our instructional leadership team or ilt is a dynamic group at Burell of 12 teachers they participate in ongoing professional development to focus as their leadership um growth and also they lead staff PD on building academic discourse and a sense of belonging to support all students with a particular focus on supporting our long-term English learners the committee has looked at
078data and engaged the staff to adopt and use a variety of academic sentence structures to help students take an active role that now can be seen and heard across campus I'm proud of our Ela team who has dove into my perspectives new curriculum and introduce new novels this year to students that are culturally relevant and super engaging I've enjoyed reading them all as well I wanted to thank our district Partners including Janette Ramirez for helping us guide through the Journey of becoming a community school we hope we've learned so much from students staff and families through several engagements and our big survey we have even implemented small things that we've learned that we were able to put in place based on feedback like our morning cozy Club um starting last year I wanted to uh
079share how much we've grown our elac planning team which has resulted in our elac meetings filling our library each month at at our next meeting on February 6 we'll review immigrant rights and share resources that will also be at the upcoming daac meeting finally I always want to take the opportunity for uh you all to know the the awesome things uh going on at brell we have our informational meeting happening right now and next week we have our music concerts on Monday Tuesday and Wednesday night we have SpongeBob the musical opening on February 28th and we have our big cultural Fair focused on food music and dance on April 30th uh if you're interested in learning more about Burell jump on the link it's on our website and thank you so much for this opportunity
080to share and be part of Burell and the district good [Music] night um good evening um jingying qua that means happy New Year it's going to be next week um I did want to start off I was going to see first if uh Joe you can help out I wanted to kick off with a celebration um and before you um Joe share the video baby um I wanted to I don't know how much all of you know about College Park we a mandarin immersion school dual language and we attract a diverse group of families and on the next slide I wanted to highlight one of our students she's a kindergarten student and she happens to be the daughter of our AA um at home they are teaching her Spanish and she's developed such a love
081and passion for uh learning Mandarin as a kindergartener and I'm just going to I just want um just share a couple of videos which her mother did give um me permission to share with you so so this is um I want you to meet uh Sophie Garcia she is an inspired dual language learner and hopefully you'll be able to hear and um Joe can you check the mute we can't hear any volume thank you all right let me try again okay thank you it looks like well if it doesn't work um this is Sophie Garcia and she after school goes immediately she's so passionate about learning Mandarin she goes immediately and independently um to her homework and this is her at home um and her mom said that she plays school and she play school
082as a mandarin [Music] teacher so I just wanted to share right this is just an example of one of our inspired multilingual Learners um the other thing that I wanted to share is a deep gratitude in support of our superintendent and Board of Trustees for your support in creating a pk8 mandarin master plan which you will soon see it really has um provided our school as well to develop a Core Curriculum that is aligned um our teachers work so hard so hard to provide um a rich and rigorous and engaging um experience for our students who are learning both um Mandarin and English um so and some of the things that we have been working around on around our three um strategic goals around achievement equity and wellness that I'd like to highlight is our
083work around um we have been um focusing our learning around streets data and what street data is is it's a a Next Generation model for Equity pedagogy and school transformation and it really urges us to you know in the way that we are flipping the classroom to give students more agency and Authority um we are flipping the dashboard and what that means is looking at day-to-day minute by minute data that will help inform are we um making an impact on our students and we um the street data requires us to build what we call formative assessment muscles where you listen to what the students are doing and saying You observe what they're doing and saying and you really pay attention very close attention to how they're feeling as well um we also have been continuing
084this is our second year working with teachwell and teachwell has worked with the Sano County of um Office of Education to pay attention to adult wellness and well beinging um um and we know that is so important right so important for our teachers for everyone to show up and do this work that we're so committed to doing and um so we have been this year with the support of teach well we have been also they have been framing our learning and I'm learning with the teachers um uh our Wellness um professional developments have been around Sean gin W's work on the four pivots and our last session was looking at um right because we have to use data to inform the work that we do was around um pivot 2 which is going from transactional
085to transformative and um we were and looking at how do we address a sense of belonging care and how do we make ourselves vulnerable knowing that this work really requires us to be uncomfortable and to disrupt things that need to be disrupted so um it helps us to be brave in the work too so it was um it's been um exciting and those are just the main highlights that I want to share aside of the fact that I'm so grateful to be part of an incredible Learning Community um all the staff and teachers are just so wonderful and working hard so thank you so much for all your support right all right we will move to item four the proposed consent agenda I think 3 oh did I miss that oh announcements excuse me uh
086we are does any uh trustee have any announcements that they would like to make um I just want to announce that the s um the smfc Ed Ed fund is kicking off it's readathon this Friday um there's going to be um some events at the library s Public Library on Saturday morning I believe at 11:00 um actually let me pull that up so I don't have the the wrong um dates um see but yeah so it starts this Friday runs through Friday um February 7th all smfc students May participate from preschool through 8th grade um you can look at the website the Ed fund website for more information um and we're hoping that each Elementary School site can increase funds raised and minutes R by um 20% this year so we'll see but um there's
087two main events samil main library um 11: to1 and then F and and that's on Saturday all of these are on Saturday and then Foster City Public Library from 2: to 4: so they're both on Saturday but one is 11:1 and one is 2 to four and yeah um hopefully we can have a great readathon and um get some more friends to spend on Sports and music and all of the good things thank you trusty Proctor do you have any announcements trusty Proctor do you have any announcements you would like to make I don't have any thank you all right uh superintendent report thank you very much president Brooks um I want to uh start with remarks about our school partner visits this week um a big thank you to Burell and sunny Bray aabon
088on um all of our schools uh that hosted uh visitors from around the community and uh from our our partner organizations um students from our empowering student voices Council uh so just very thankful um for the visits that took place I I wanted to make some remarks about um two teachers in particular that really um stood out and wowed uh our visitors and the first is a fifth grade teacher at aabon and um she has a you know a fairly large class probably 28 kids or so um these kids that go to oton elementary school are very tall I don't remember kids being 5 foot s when they're in fifth grade but these kids are really tall um so the high school district's going to have something to work with in a few years but
089um she had them all sit sitting together um facing the Whiteboard and she was doing a lesson um it was an opener where the students were being asked which of four visual models of fractions uh didn't belong in the group of four and so the visual models were uh all representing 1 and 38 and in one representation they were triangles in another they were circles and another they were rectangles and then in the other it was like a plot right like on a map and so you know I think if all of us gave our opinion on what that would be we might view it differently but these are you know 10-year-olds and what she did to pull from their their mathematical reasoning um and every student that spoke she wrote their name on the
090Whiteboard and she wrote down what they thought and she drew a physical model of it so the way that she uh honored their perspective and and reached deep down to really show them how differently people think about math and how many different ways there are to understand math it's really powerful it it represents the type of math instruction that we have going on in the district starting in kindergarten and going all the way through 8th grade so that was just a really wonderful thing to observe and then the second teacher um was working with four-year-olds at Brewer Island and when we walked into the gym into their multi room uh he had set up a um what looked like a bad mitt area and but these are four-year-olds so they're just like really little people
091and he had uh rackets that were made of sponge and he used a balloon instead of a ball or instead of the the bad mitt and um he had it all color quart ated so after the students used their racket they had a place to put the racket next to them there were a group of kids who were sitting on dollies like kind of furniture style dollies you know four wheels and like a little square um but he had them moving on a little track and their little legs were just I mean they were just really like working their core like a very cardio heavy uh exercise and then he had four other stations throughout this gym um when the kids and interacted he didn't do any talking he used music to cue them on
092when to start an activity and when to move from the activity the students put everything away properly the first time in the right place because he's obviously built a relationship with this class of kids who he only sees once every couple days where um they know what's expected of them and they were all joyful and then on the way out he had three pieces of paper on the wall one said good one said great the other said wow and uh he said on your way out um hit see if you can hit wow if that's how you're feeling because he was asking them to convey to him how much they enjoyed the activity they had done which is just another way as the adult to say your experience matters to me your opinion matters to
093me I want to hear from you so all these little kids are jumping up trying to hit wow and uh and then on the way to class he told them uh rub your stomach and Pat your head at the same time because for him walking back to class just solely walking back to class would be a waste of time that he could do something with these kids to utilize even though it's only a minute and a half to walk walk back to their class and it just made me feel so inspired about education to see a teacher like him uh Mr noou just absolutely star and we have so many teachers I we have every single school has teachers who are doing work like that um but I really just wanted to call it out
094because he was able in that you know 20 minutes we observed and and everybody who went in this partner visit was just shaking their head we had a lot of people at that visit um and it was the same at at all of our visits we saw exceptional work happening um and we have a lot of people to thank for that and we have a um a wonderful group of Educators who come in and do this work work every day um so I wanted to share those two examples because I think it really um tells us about what the future can be like for us and how we bring uh teachers uh into more leadership positions and connect them with their peers um and continue to see the district moving forward and then I will
095be at the readathon event so I'm excited about those as well in our public libraries yeah thank you thank you superintendent now we will move to item four on the consent agenda all items on the consent agenda are considered by the board to be routine and will be enacted by one one Motion in the form listed below there will be no discussion on these items prior to the time the board votes on the motion unless members of the board staff or public request specific items to be removed and discussed from the consent agenda this superintendent and staff recommends approval of all consent items movement of any recommended consent item is appropriate at this time does anyone have any items they would like to remove from the consent Jenna for discussion trusty Proctor no I don't
096have anything all right that I'll take a motion to approve this consent agend agenda motion to approve the consent agenda second all in favor say actually I'll take a roll call vote truste Proctor yes truste ho yes trusty Tren yes trusty Kim yes and that is a yes for me so that passes 5 let's see yes all right um we will take a quick five minute break and then we will um return and start with five thank you e e e good J all right are we ready to start Joel on the agenda yes you're ready to go all right thank you we will reconvene to our regular board meeting and we will um start with 5c uh the approval of the educator house uh housing task force recommendations thank you president Brooks um my
097honor to present on this topic tonight uh this is the sixth update that this board has received um as part of our process in convening uh the workforce housing task force the educator housing task force uh we took an approach that was um multifaceted in inviting uh members elected members um from the city council of Sano um the City Council of Foster City the County Board of Supervisors uh the College of Sano um all of our employee unions our district office staff um as well as Community Partners we also went through a rigorous process of analyzing the district's facilities of considering housing models that have been successful in um the peninsula and uh taking the group through a rigorous analysis of the district's uh employee um statistics um and the very real challenge that we
098face in um employee turnover as a result of the unaffordability of housing particularly for staff members who are in years 1 through 10 in the district across both the classified and certificated uh employee groups and so at our December school board meeting the board was presented with a list of recommendations Joe if you can help me and put those recommendations uh tonight's item up uh for View and uh the board engaged in a in a uh spirited conversation that evening um we took uh all of the feedback and remarks from the board at that meeting and we've updated the recommendations uh based on the board uh comments and so what the board has before them tonight uh are what we consider to be our final recommendations to the board um each recommendation uh indicates a
099time frame for the work to begin and a um userfriendly um description of the work that's going to take place uh and so on the document you have uh both the a written version and uh a visual showing when these recommendations are going to take uh effect and those uh are listed for the board uh the changes that were put in are um reflective of um minor changes to um when when work begins and substant substantive changes to uh how we conduct the survey instrument with our staff um and with that I want to pass it back over to the board um the recommendation of the administration and the housing task force uh is that the board approve these recommendations and uh it's before the board tonight for your action all right thank you so
100PR Al CH up for this update I'm ready to pass uh is any questions regarding this item president uh no it's president I haven't transitioned yet we we all have that we do that trusty Proctor do you have any um questions regarding this item I don't all right can you please check online Joel to see if there are any hands raised yes checking no public comments on Zoom at this time right any comments um I am really happy to see the this move forward Togo knows I'm a huge um supporter of this work and I am just really looking forward to um seeing this move forward with the um you know with with including you know just not just the background stuff happening that um needs to make um this project happen but also looking
101at the communication plan as um I think we can see that you know communication is is always important um whether that actually reaches the people um at the time that we intend it to is not always not always doesn't always happen um but I think it's it's really important that we communicate our intentions um and also have you know something for the community to look at as soon as possible um so that they can visualize what kind of what kind of um development we're talking about and um what that will mean for our educator community and the students that they um they serve every day so thank you so much I I just uh want to reiterate the comments that I made at the last meeting specifically about the task force and the work that
102we've done first I just want to thank everybody involved I was lucky enough to be a part of some of those meetings and just to see the amount of support we had from the county from both cities for folks who've gone to this experience before from neighboring districts the amount of expertise we pulled together from Council and other experts was just great to see that we went through all the steps to build up the proposal that we have in front of us today but as I mentioned last meeting and I feel like we saw earlier this evening there is this issue issue around communication and an issue around trust and I do think especially for something as ambitious as a district taking on an entire housing project on our own having that level of coordination
103support transparent communication very strong good faith effort to reach out to the community is going to be vital I really appreciate Mary Newsome being here earlier and the comments that he made as well I do think that we have Partners in the city and the county who have been part of the task force who stand ready to help us but to the extent that we can also again not only engage parents but the neighborhood associations others who may be impacted I think you know over the past few months in particular we've all reflected on the fact that when government makes decisions folks want to understand why that's happening whether it's something hyper local like educational housing or nationally like a Tik Tok band there's so many decisions that happen that Community feels like they didn't
104have a sense of what motivated it and even if they have faith in some of the elected officials who make those decisions I think it's going to be incredibly important for something as again as Grand as ambitious as Vision that we have to be something that we over communicate on so even understanding all the improvements that we've made in communication over the last few years I want to again emphasize especially for this project and anything like this I want to see a full court press on a level that we haven't had almost as if we're already thinking about the bond on day one as opposed to coming up with a plan and telling people here's our plan I think they need to understand that this is a community decision that we're trying to make together
105and so to the extent that we can really drive that point home on the communications recommendations which I do appreciate appreciate I just want to reiterate again how important that's going to be I think for our board to make sure that we see that level effort and that the community is with us as we move forward on this thank you trusty K with that said um can I get a motion oh uh trusty Proctor do you have any comments I do have a few comments um first of all thank you for all of this information and um I really appreciate the very clear timeline of all the steps that are going to happen I do agree with truste Kim that we um need to have very clear and transparent communication around this um just in
106order to inform the community and get people to support us and and um obviously a bond is going to be something that's takes a lot of work to pass um through the voters um the one thing I did want to mention which is slightly off topic but um the update from CSEA earlier tonight it got me thinking about how we can strategize about other ways that we can support our Educators that maybe um would maybe they don't need housing but there's other ways that we can just be supportive and provide benefits to um continue to retain our top talent so um I don't know if that's something that can be rolled into a bond or what that is but um just want to keep that on on our minds at the same time thank you
107thank you do we have any online comments Joe checking thank you no public comments on Zoom at this time thank you um I will go ahead and take a motion to pass this agenda item a motion to approve this agenda item second thank you truste Proctor yes trusty ho yes trusty Tren yes trusty Kim yes and that is a double yes for me and that is a 51 pass 5 Z oh would I say I one 5 Z okay we will move to the next agenda item that is 5D the approval of resolution uh in support of the uh preservation of the safe bicycle lane on humbo Street in s Matel thank you president Brooks uh tonight's item is a resolution put uh before the board um folus fusing on something that um for many
108years has been part of of a long-term plan um it was put into effect uh just a few years ago these bicycle Lanes uh these um run in and around um College Park Elementary School in the north central Sano neighborhood um a couple weeks back we as a board and myself uh received a sample of a letter of support from from the San Mato Foster City School District PTA Council which is a group that represents the uh ptas in our school district um and this letter that was sent to us um was uh very clearly advocating for um the city um to keep these Lanes uh in place and uh at the same time um also encouraging the board um to consider adopting a similar letter or a similar resolution um in work with um
109with um trustee Tren um we were able to um put together um tonight's um resolution in previous board meetings we've read the resolution aloud I'll leave that up to the board to decide if you choose to do that um if not I wanted to um invite trusty Tren to make any remarks that you feel like you want to make at this time uh and then uh pass it back to the public into the board for discussion thank you superintendent Ooa so I requested this item um I am a bicyclist myself I use these Lanes frequently and um I see a lot of our students using these lanes and um I you know I think that oftentimes there's um a false um uh I would say a false choice between you know um bicyclists and pedestrian
110safety and you know and um driver convenience and safety um I think that that is it's a it's a false choice because a lot of people who who walk and bike around um our cities um also our drivers and you know who isn't a driver is any of our students right like and I and I want to make sure that they have safe ways to get to school um that when and when you have different modes of transportation conflict with each other that's when accidents and injuries happen and so separating um giving specific space to each mod of transportation is one way that we encourage people to um to you know move their bodies um it helps with emotional regulation as kids go to and from school there's just so many benefits to active Transportation
111um but we can't support that without the infrastructure to do so and so um that's one of the reasons why I um encourage um the city council of Sano to retain these bike lanes and um you know it it can connects um a lot of it connects different neighborhoods it's it's really the only um and connects to the the only safe um you know it's like the main Crossing um between on the sides of the 101 I know there's one further north but that's kind of the main one so that's um long-winded way of saying I think this is really important um so that we have a safe way for for kids to get to school and it doesn't just serve College Park it ALS you know we have kids who live in that area
112and attend college uh an intense school on the other side of the 101 and that that does help them as well so um yeah I just um I don't feel a strong need to have to read it but that just wanted to provide some of my reasoning for why I requested the item thank you thank you for requesting this item because it's a very important um issue that has been um really developing over the year over the years especially with the um electronic or the excuse me the electric um cycling uh for our kids uh I see them all the time and it is it it looks very dangerous so these uh lanes are very important thank you are there any board board comments or questions on this item trusty ProAir nothing from me thank
113you I just want to say on this I just want to say on this resolution um I really appreciate the amount of outpouring of support that we've received on this particular topic a lot of community leaders that many of us have been working with for years um the ptaa council folks that we Rel on to I'm a college park parent so this is something that I heard directly from the parents on my site but also with the campus swap happening next year a lot of parents from Fiesta Gardens neighboring areas from the high school district Etc um so many folks have very strong feelings about this I have heard some from the other side in terms of the local residents who have concerns around parking and I understand the city council will be taking that
114into consideration but I think speaking as a parent at College Park speaking as Trustee of our district on behalf of our parents our Educators and everyone else that we've spoken to there is an overwhelming amount of support for protecting these bike lanes and making sure that we try to make our city and our schools safer easier to access reduce the types of traffic accidents and fatalities that we've seen on the rise and so I think this is an important issue for us to take up as a board just based on how much we've worked on this issue and everything from St R to school Vision zero everything that we've dealt with since I was on the board um has kind of come led to this resolution as well so thank you to especially uh vice
115president Tren and others who've been advocates in this space for many years now thank you Joe can you please check to see if there any hand raise regarding president Brooks I have one comment I forgot to say um on the second page of this resolution it says um Diego's the clerk and I think it's trusty Kim so might need to change that I I also have a clerical uh I believe the second Clause is says meanwhile instead of whereas and so I would advise making both of those Corrections on the draft before it's signed by the board thank you for that Joel can you please check to see if there are any hands race yes president Brooks we have one uh raised hand Max mountainer please go ahead thanks am I unmuted we can hear
116you great I I'll try to be as brief as possible I'm mner I'm a Sano resident I want to thank you board members for agendize and considering signing on to this letter I realized the physical environment around schools is not the jurisdiction the board controls but I do believe that the physical and mental well-being of students parents Educators is a critical interest to this board the city of Sano is building out their bike Network slowly step by step and they're regrettably soon considering a step backwards on safety around school campuses in north central along the humble quar and as you may well know studies show the tremendous and measurable physical and mental health impacts to young adults from getting physical activity this is also true of parents and children U performing physical activities together like
117traveling to school um I see parents and children using these bike Lanes uh I myself live in the neighborhood and I also note the tremendous congestion around pickup and drop off at scho these schools and just want to emphasize the powerful effect that bike infrastructure can have on changing the ways in which parents evaluate options for how their children reach school so all that being said please do sign on to the letter sananto city council needs to hear the safety needs of our communities parents students and Educators quick as side I also want to say thank you for allowing remote public comment as it is not so easy for me to reach the physical location of this meeting as I don't have a car so I really appreciate that thanks thank you are there any
118inperson comments all right I will go ahead and take a motion to approve this agenda item motion to approve oh with the edits from uh trustee Kim and and trusty Proctor second thank you trusty Proctor yes trusty Hill yes trusty Tren yes trusty Kim yes and that is a yes for me past 5 we will move to item six Education Services uh 6A report on digital curriculum and student device usage in our schools good evening evening Board of Trustees cabinet members and superintendent Ooa my colleagues Miss bartfield Miss Cook and I are here tonight to share information about technology integration and curriculum in our schools so our uh uh work supports um teaching and learning for both staff and students our teachers and students have access to standardized hardware and software uh software helps staff
119and students Monitor and Report issues when they may need help and uh while there are several state and federal laws and acts that we must follow a specific example of that is the children's internet protection act uh sipa known uh uh for short overseen by the schools and libraries division of the Federal Communications Commission FCC this act requires all districts that receive certain federal Monies to have protective safety measures in place and give miners training on the proper use of Technology Joe sorry to interrupt but um sorry isn't sharing on the screen we have it in front of us but it's not showing up on the zoom ah okay sorry about that try it again there we go you can see um okay um so sipa uh this act requires all districts to receive certain
120federal that receive certain uh Federal Monies to have protective safety measures in place and give minor training on proper use of Technology our district uses goguardian as our primary content filter to help keep inappropriate content away from our students and it also has tools to help our teachers keep our students on task other syst systems that help us with this are uh Google's workspace administrative system settings our district firewall and our uh platform specific settings such as Google and YouTube's safe search and I'll hand it over to my colleague good evening everyone um I really appreciate the timing of this presentation tonight um I'd like to be able to clarify uh for you what digital curriculum looks like specifically for me and our elementary schools um what you might see onetoone devices being used where
121you might see whole group and specifically what's required by our programs and what might be used as teacher discretion all of our teachers definitely want to use technology to enhance learning not get in the way of learning so these next few slides I'm going to talk a little bit about our Elementary programs and how how technology is being used first all of our programs are print-based um there are some digital components whether it's through class link or um through our zern program but everything has a print component or a print partner so they're print based first um in elementary schools our Core Curriculum in our language arts we have path hegr Benchmark all of those programs are primarily print-based Benchmark does offer what we call Benchmark Universe where teachers might go on to get lesson
122plan sometimes there's some videos on there there might even be audiobooks for students but typically when you're walking in a language arts class you're seeing students engaging with text working with the teacher I know everyone's seen path and action in the lower grade so you're typically not seeing um students on a onetoone device you might see a teacher showing a video um up front that that kids are using to either blend sounds or hear sounds um in our math program as everyone knows um there's a digital component to that program it's not the whole math block as superintendent AOA mentioned ear ear we walked into a math classroom math mindset routines are really teacher and student engaging in math talk um our zern program does out of all of our programs is the only one
123that does have a digital requirement from the program we did hear from teachers over the last few years that it felt like a lot so we went with this year we went and rolled out zerns minimum requirement to use it which is 30 minutes three times a week and so that this school year is what you might see if you walk in a math classroom where students are working on zern that's what you'll see Ono one so you'll see a student on their individual device doing the zern um program in that portion of the math um teachers again may choose to create some slides or um we've seen some teachers show some video to help students engage in some of the math talk that they're doing but the only portion of that where you see
124one to one is unzer um twig science again it's science so it's very Hands-On in our district there is again like Benchmark a digital component but it's not required for Teacher use you might see teacher showing a video in front of the class showing them how they might engage in the experiment or some of them U they might I've seen one where it's like what is a phenomenon they kind of launch it with a question to the students but teachers don't have to use those videos they can choose to just do that with having conversations with their students our social stes program does not have a digital component either and then in physical education there's not a digital component that's part of it it's typically very Hands-On next side sorry all right um we also
125have a lot of um you know this over the last couple years we've been lucky to be able to put in a lot of um specials for our students so in art and music again it's most of these don't have a digital component with these specials if you walk into a Lego room typically in Upper Grade you might see students on their devices because part of the Lego lessons there are videos that show the students how to actually create the robotics or the Lego pieces that they're doing but when I walk in Lego rooms i t i don't usually see one to one that's where groups of students might be around one computer we do have stmath and f2b for the district we recommend those to be used at an at home um you know
126as a parent myself I feel like it's always a part-time or full-time job monitoring your own child's devices at home so we really want to limit how much we're asking our families to do at home but these are programs that we've seen really help students improve their learning my own child's on stmath as well um footsteps are Brilliance we've seen lots of gains especially for students who are you know bilingual and multilingual that they're is really helping them through song and games really acquire the English language there are some other programs that you might see in schools or that we know that teachers are using that are not required by the school district I've grabbed a few of them there might even be a few more um Spire is one of our special education programs
127it's not fully a digital based but it has components um some of our schools have um licenses to programs like Lexia reading newella Brain Pop and eye station again those were site based decisions that they felt these programs would enhance student learning slide these are some samples I just want to share of what a curriculum embedded um you know uh technology integration might look like versus what's not part of our curriculum so you can see some samples so here on the left this is like a twig this is a twig science video again it's getting the students ready to start an experiment showing them how to do it sometimes teachers look at the video sometimes and then they explain to the kids but sometimes they find it's really helpful when the students are watching it
128um Benchmark like I said has a program called or a component called Benchmark Universe there are a lot of great little um songs and things that teachers might use and show students up in the front of the room we also see uh teachers pulling videos like you see on the right so they're not part of our district curriculum and they're not required by the district but we do have teachers a lot that like to have kids really hear letter sound so sometimes the teachers are doing it and then they want kids to hear it more so there's some really great s that have um people showing how to make the sound what the mouth looks like there's some very up close to the mouth which work a little odd but those help students really see
129where does your tongue have to be placed in order to say certain sounds and then brain pop across our District's pretty popular um brain pop offers a kind of a fun way for kids to learn a little bit about um different concepts before they get into them with the teacher and then uh finally just wanted to share what does a day look like what are what would you expect to see if you spend a day and I chose first grade because I think you know our L our youngest Learners are ones we want to make sure really handson with they learning so when you go into a first grade room you're typically starting the day with a morning Circle most of our teachers use Second Step curriculum that does have a digital citizenship component I
130know um my colleague canetta we'll talk a little bit about that more in Middle School um but most of morning circle is hand you know really kids talking to each other about the topic of the day um we do spend approximately depending on the grade level 90 minutes in Reading language arts and ELD again those are programs that are mostly you know uh print based and students reading text engaging and talking teachers using big books so I would I would think you see very little digital curriculum use during the language arts time we I do know that some teachers may choose to bring in um the program footsteps of Brilliance during the school day for students to do centers while they're working with other students as well um again math is a pro anywhere from
13160 to 7 D5 minutes depending on the grade level and one of the things we always really want to get clear about math it's there's three components to our math program our teachers have been doing an amazing job really um integrating the math mindset routine it's almost like a morning Circle but talking about math so math class usually starts with let's talk about mathematics and get kids ready for you know opening up their brains to the thinking getting comfortable sharing and talking about mathematics there again is three at minimum three times a week of students doing zern one to one that part of the program allows students to really show what they're learning in the rest of the math class and for a way for teachers to keep track of it on zern um a
132lot of times on the zern it really moves at the pace of the student so if a student is struggling in one area the zern will keep them there to make sure they really get that piece of it um you might see the whole class on the zern during that time I've also seen teachers do do it in half class or um in small group and then we also have concept exploration where the kids are getting Hands-On with the mathematics then you see science or social studies um usually switches off week by week or day by day 30 to 45 minutes depending on the grade level again not there's not really any onetoone digital during science or social studies teachers may have some slides or videos they're sharing but it's usually in the front of
133the classroom and we always have a special art music Lego or Library which are weekly or Bly programs and then you know we have PE that students are accessing um at least 200 minutes every 10 days and then again the Little House talks about our recommendation as a school district is to be on footsteps of Brilliance 15 minutes daily and then in K1 it's 60 Minutes weekly for sta I'm going turn it over to my colleagues to talk about Middle School all right thank you Pam um good evening everyone so I'll walk you through some of our main curriculum that we use in Middle School um similar to Elementary um all of our curriculum has a technology component um math Desmos exclusively has a technology component but when you look at Ela social studies and
134science the other three major content areas there are hard copy so teachers who have a preference for hard copy use they use that every day with students and keep the kids off the Chromebooks um it varies from classroom to classroom based on teaching styles and pedagogical preferences what people prefer but it it really is one of those things that teachers are realizing um we need to minimize the Chromebook use in class because we know particularly in middle school that students love their devices they love their cell phones and they like to be on their cell phones so teachers are very aware of that and mindful of minimizing that in um middle school with the exception of math there is a piece of it where if you've been in our math classrooms you know that teachers
135do the input part but you see collaborative conversations happening you see students working together you see academic discourse and making meaning being at the Whiteboard those kinds of things so let me talk a little bit about what happens in an 85 minute block um during an 85 minute block which is what our comprehensive middle schools are on teachers are used to chunking the lesson and what that means is you take 10 or 15 minutes of a lesson and you focus on maybe the digital component or maybe the direct instruction but you don't do more than 10 or 15 minutes of that because it's important for students to have opportunities to engage with Hands-On activities collaborative discussions so they can make meaning 85 minute lesson is a very long time um and it's important that students
136are not fully engaged again on our Chromebook but have times to make meetings in um groups and with each other in pairs um so let me give you an example so we teach Math and Science open STIs or science curriculum um it is very heavy on lab activities which really Taps into the kinesthetic side of learning and the visual side of learning in our math classrooms and in our science classrooms you see students using materials and manipulus that's where the majority of the time is spent during 85 minute period it's spent using those visuals and those manipulus to make meaning um on this slide I also called out two of our major elective offerings our College and Career exploratory elective Paxton Patterson um and music so let me first talk a little bit about Paxton
137Patterson although there's um a technology component to it and you'll see kids on Chromebooks and iPads again that's a short period of time for the input piece and when you're in those classrooms you see kids are inter interacting with devices they are interacting with each other um whether it's a nursing unit or the drones they're making meaning Beyond just the iPad and Beyond just the Chromebook um in music I wanted to call that out because we have huge music programs and make music is an app that some of our music teachers use that app is really helpful for students um to practice at home they could even compose a piece of music and help tune their instruments it's a powerful tool that allows students to can continue to grow and learn as a musician on
138their own own and even with that there's variation in terms of how much kids are on it it from one teacher to the next it can be 15 minutes to about 30 minutes um per week so those are just some of the things that kind of keep in mind um when we're thinking about what does technology integration look like in Middle School it varies but the only component that we have that is strictly on a device or not component the only subject that we have is math that's strictly on a device but even in no space is you're going to see the collaboration you will see um the manipulus being used and you'll see students making meaning next slide please um at our middle schools we also think it's important to talk about digital literacy
139and digital citizenship and what does that mean so first this idea around digital literacy is really thinking about how do we teach um students to be aware of how they show up around um media and devices so in our advisory classes we use lessons from Common Sense Media second step and um our social OT which is our social emotional learning curriculum and restorative practices to touch on um some of these digital citizenship characteristics in Sixth sth and eth grade um students really do need to be taught how to um show up online safe online safety is key whether they're in sixth grade seventh or eighth and so throughout their time in middle school we take the time to talk about social media safety master and practice not only how to use some of these Google
140Suite tools but how do you recognize when something is a fishing scan how do you know when not to click on a particular email even as adults we have to be reminded of those things right so proper use of using a tool like that uh chat GPT we talk about that so that they understand the difference between using it as a tool and plagiarism um so those are the things that span the grades and then I called out specific pieces that we teach in sixth 7th and eth so digital citizenship and being aware of how you show up um um as a student around digital media is one of those things that Middle School teachers know that is important to address and address not only at the beginning of the year but come back to
141it after breaks because that's when kids have been on their devices and that's when they have perhaps engaged in a lot of technology is when they have been at home so it's important for us to touch on that throughout the year especially around the time when they come back from their breaks next slide please this is our really a opportunity now for us to take your question and thank you for bringing this topic up we really wanted to have a chance to engage with you about it thank you very much for this wonderful presentation as we know the digital world has really transformed our um experience um over the years and um as they get to High School I believe the usage increased significantly more than it do in their uh their younger ages um
142uh thank you for uh sharing the uh safeguards that you have um implemented for our children's safety uh regarding time and the wellness um and the overall experience um are there any questions s by the board yes um I have a question um thank you so much for the presentation um I really appreciated on um slide eight when you kind of broke down like how many minutes a day um minutes a week um this You Know sample schedule for first graders looks like you know really keeping in mind what the teachers from audabon shared earlier you know about you know um the overreliance on screen time um I was curious you know um what are you know I would love to see the and I don't expect today but I would love to see kind
143of what are the average amounts of minutes per day or per week for all grade levels um not just first grade you know but k through eight um and then also you know a breakdown of what's required um you know and what is optional um again just kind of you know agreeing with what the audabon teachers you know shared as a concern and you know what we really see in re education research around um you know over you know too much screen time and how it really affects students well-being in terms of you know mental health stress and ability to regulate in a lot of other areas as well um thank you to everyone for this presentation it was really helpful to see a breakdown of um what um components of our curriculum are digital
144only versus digital options versus hard copy only so that was um really helpful I think um you know I think the I'm sure the the ages of the par parents in our district um varies greatly and as well as the level of sort of um whether they are digital natives or not um and you know I certainly remember growing up and not like we you know there was one computer for the whole family um we're in a very different world now where there might be even more than one device per person and um and so I think there are certainly a lot of parents who may not even understand what are the risks of um you know what are the risks that the the students face online and so um I'm wondering if there is
145anything that we're aware of or any resources that we could possibly provide um to our parents especially uh parents of middle schoolers to maybe give them some of the flavor of what we're communicating in class as well um so that they're aware of some of those same concerns that would be my question of like can we do this to some degree for parents too thank you all for this presentation uh just a few I guess clarifying questions and comments on these um I do want to really thank you all for preparing this because this is an issue that we hear about constantly from parents in our district with differing opinions about the proper use of Technology a lot of uh techn ology fatigue following the whole Co shutdown but also understanding from a lot of
146parents that technology has allowed us to scale and to serve some of our students better and I think striking that perfect balance is a different conversation for every student every family we talk to but I appreciate the amount of thought and effort that went into this one issue that I raised previously and if we could speak to broadly you know the long list of different educational resources Partners platforms that we've incorporated into multiple levels of our curriculum you know I've constantly asked about how evaluate the success of those whether or not we need to revisit them um you know every single platform we have is praised by some parents and you know concerning for other parents who feel like it's not the best fit for their child's needs but I did want to get a
147sense of how we both Source those how often we evaluate those and how we determine when it's time to move on knowing that especially in this space for Education technology and all the different services available now with the emergence of AI that there has been so much transformation are we committing ourselves to 5 10e contracts are we real ating every two years um just wanted to get a general sense of what our strategy and approach is on these in terms of um how we make those determinations and how often we re assess that would be my first question and then I'll hold until I have a chance to go through the other ones I can speak for Elementry um you know for zern it's our for the zern component it's our current um adopted curriculum
148for mathematics so for us to as we monitor we what you know we're looking at student data how our students do doing we can go on zern see students that are using it you know at the recommended amount how are they doing on their Cas or how are they doing on their CFA so that's one way we monitor we do a similar with s um stmf and footsteps of Brilliance um I know again for zern as we kind of think about different adoptions in elementary coming up because we do have a few that we might be ready for that's one way we would look at what's next for us in mathematics um you know for you know stmath and footsteps of Brilliance around um longevity of use I know we're in year three of using
149those programs so you know as we continue and think about what our next few years in our school district looking like we'll be looking at those programs to see how are they doing for our students and how are we matching what we usually do is we'll take our um we'll take our data that we do throughout the year and we kind of align it to our you know students that might be struggling if they're using it are we seeing progress if students aren't struggl struggling in Literacy for example in the early grades f2b might not be something that they necessarily need so that's a couple of ways I know in elementary we're looking at that in a in kind of that green size and let me just add on that a little bit for middle
150school so when we went through these most recent adoptions Ela the most recent one prior to that social studies and before that um was the other one science it was really important for teachers that there were hard copy textbooks for students that came through loud and clear in the adoption process so to your concern into what's been um shared by the board and shared by some of the teachers teachers really do want to have that flexibility they enjoy the Blended opportunity but they want to have that flexibility to close their Chromebook lid and say this lesson we're we're using a student workbooks or at home I want you to use your student textbook and so that was really important because they recognized that coming out of a pandemic they really wanted to move away from
151the heavy Technology based um curriculum and like I said Desmos is something that we adopted during the um our math curriculum during the pandemic and so that does have a exclusively digital component but um every adoption after that it was really important that there was a student workbook and so for that reason you do see teachers using the hard copy textbooks in Middle Schools um often uh we can look at usage data with most of our curriculum but because we have that flexible model and we don't have students on um devices at school uh for social studies and um Ela it's a little bit different we can track more closely usage for something like stmath um so that's just just a little bit on the Middle School side trusty Kim let me also just add
152you know the framework for thinking about the cycle of of curriculum adoptions is generally five to seven years um so you do an adoption obviously ketta is mentioning you know literally in the last three years we've added new curriculum in ela um Science and History social studies um in math basically were about obviously just coming out of the pandemic we're about at the fifth year in our use of Desmos um so we might start looking at you know um in the next year or two whether we want to rethink um that usage I think that needs to be weighed against what we're seeing is some pretty impressive improvements in our math performance on on casps for example and so that's a that's a positive feedback that both the curriculum and the curriculum guidance that we're
153implementing are actually having positive effect um at the elementary level you know it's it's a similar pattern we just recently adopted twig that's only about two to three years old that's the science curriculum uh the teacher earlier on was quite right we have uh in history social studies we were approaching an adoption just as covid hit and then we had to adopt new um new curriculum for that and so the question was coming out of covid do we ask teachers to you know as they're still getting used to the materials in front of them do we ask them again to do history social studies so we've made some choices there that um definitely have some drawbacks to them but and I think one of the things we're trying to make sense of is the the
154community feedback that we're getting and and teacher feedback about the amount of online time because if we if we look at how much K5 for example we're requiring is basically 30 minutes three times a week in zern and the rest of it is frankly uh must you know it would be perhaps teacher option um we don't include that if a students are sitting and engaging with something a video that's on a monitor we don't consider that quite the same kind of um uh you know sort of versus being glued to a a screen on my own Chromebook so um so we're trying to make sense of the feedback because it doesn't jive with what we're requiring as a district um so we've got some work to do um trying to clarify how our guidance and
155what we're seeing at the district level is not is not aligning what with obviously what some teachers and and parents are experiencing that that's really helpful to hear and I appreciate that and I think to follow up on what trusty H said earlier the sense I get even just from the class in visits we did this week is that there is a lot of variation in screen time depending on the teachers or even individual students we were in classrooms where there are groups of students meeting together working on an issue and one student might be going ahead on a onetoone device or I'm not sure how frequently that happens but I could sense that even in one classroom there might be different levels of usage which I understand for some of our parents is a
156very concerning phenomenon and while that is nice that that allows them to maybe go at a stagger Pace or to go to deeper dive on certain topics they may be familiar with the drawback to that is they spend an hour on screens you know just judging from my own kids when they come off of that they're dysphoric it's harder to pay attention it's just it's lot to introduce and I know that's a balance we're still striking but it is helpful to know that we've spent a lot of time thinking about it um and I did want to follow up specifically on the Middle School example which I thought was really great to hear because I've raised the board meetings previously this concern around digital literacy preparing our kids digital citizenship I did want to ask
157for the middle school program is this curriculum that we're talking about where we're working with common sense and second step is this incorporated into social studies is it something that all middle school students are required to take is it something just as part of teachers professional development to emphasize when it makes sense I wasn't quite sure how this was integrated into the curriculum that we have um thank you for that question so advisory class which we have twice a week is where there's opportunity to do the common um sense lessons and to um do our seal curriculum our seal curriculum is called second step and part of a second step um topics like cyber bullying um your digital footprint uh social media safety all those things are covered as things throughout the year and so
158teachers can spiral back to some of those um topics depending on how things are going in our class or depending on Trends we might be seeing at a school if we're seeing an uptick in certain behaviors online in a school they can use that advisory period twice a week to touch on some of those um things that are coming up around technology so it's during the advisory which is twice a week at our comprehensive middle schools got it thank you for that and I know this particular issue not only is something I've talked about but the superintendent and I when we met with Governor Nome a few months ago this was something that the first partner really emphasized as well just in the media environment that we're living in especially in an AI environment the
159importance of having this inner school so it's great to see that it's being integrated into our curriculum here as well um that's all I have on my end but thank you so much for the presentation thank you trusty Kim uh trusty Pro do you have any clarifying questions yeah actually um just kind of clarifying question and comment at the same time my question was similar to trusty Trends question about how we're um rolling this out to parents I do think that um you know it's important that we share this information I don't know that you know I'm on all the same social media platforms as my kids and as much as they hate that um I like I need to know what they're doing so that I can talk to have conversations with them when
160things don't align with our values or um I see something that they may make a poor choice um that you know the internet's forever and I don't want them to kind of ruin their future so um I'm wondering and I know that parent education um nights aren't always the best event but um maybe a podcast with superintendent Ooa where we can push it out and people can listen at their own Leisure but I do think that we need to encourage parents to be on these same platforms that their kids are on to just kind of monitor what's going on and by the way you can go on Tik Tok and you can search any one of our middle schools just the name of it and you'll see a whole bunch of videos from kids and
161they may be your own kids and you may not love what they're doing but um it would then spark a conversation thank you we'll now move to call Victor and Emily Ward thank you so much we are really delighted to be here today and just to be able to attend especially because this is a lot about education technology I'm Emily Ward I'm the CEO of uh competes TV which is also showcase and real time this is my husband and our coo Victor Ward so we work together um very closely uh we have a video platform for students and I know we're talking about a lot of tech technology here but think about it as creativity and communication with our video platform either the students create the videos or the teachers create the videos but the
162important thing about our platform is it actually can be either private or public at the choice of the school or District so I think um trustee Proctor you were mentioning which is very smart you guys are very Advanced District of checking out the social media platforms for the schools but also what are your kids doing right what are your kids looking at they are going to make videos I'm sorry they are going to go out there make videos do a lot of stuff and part of it is the creativity that those kids have that it's so important to be able to help them to learn but also to protect them in a safe way with our platform we have at the choice of the school either it's totally private so the only people that can
163get in are the administrators the teachers the students and the students family that's it unless the student family decides to send a link out to someone like the grandmother who can't appear at a theater event or something else but otherwise it's closed we work very closely with the schools anything that seems to be problematic School contacts us we take it down right away we are not trying to be the next Tik Tock or YouTube we are trying to provide a safe and structured platform for students and teachers and families to be able to communicate with each other other real time um I'm going to turn it over to Victor I have more things to say but he'll complain I'm taking up all the time I want to say um thank you everyone uh we have
164a couple of products and one of our products is called real time which is a digital video yearbook and it allows students and teachers administrators parents to upload their own photos their own music their own videos their own memories and and um you know some of the happiest times of a school are the beginning day the first day and the last day but those days aren't captured in a yearbook and um about 30 years ago I was a long-term sub in a school in Oakland and I was teaching fifth grade and uh it was graduation and the kids saying uh I believe I can fly I won't sing it right now although I was toying with it but um and I was sitting there I'm a long-term sub so and I'm I'm crying I'm listening
165to these kids sing the song and I'm crying but uh you know a traditional yearbooks are wonderful but that moment is not captured no graduation moment is ever captured in a traditional yearbook because they have to be printed long before the the year is out and graduation is like the most special time um the other thing that's never captured in the traditional yearbook is anything like your theater your play your music and music is such a wonderful and Powerful educational tool I was uh we were uh we were picking up our son and uh there was a little restaurant it was a Hong Kong barbecue and I told my wife I said oh that reminds me of there was a show I'm much older than anyone here probably yeah no I'm not going to s
166that it was called Hong Kong this the show was called Hong Kong fuy um and so I looked it up on YouTube and I was like I still remember the song because that's the way music is it's memorable it's educational um but again you you lose that the traditional year wonder is always wonderful and we don't want to get rid of that but we do think it is 2025 um you know the yearbook has been around for about 200 years so we think now it might be a good time to you know roll out maybe version two so yeah one thing I'd like to mention cuz I heard and you have a tremendous District you really do you're very advanced in your thoughts towards technology and usage of Technology I'm hearing a lot about communication
167right it's the how fast can we communicate and how well can we we communicate um with our video platform because depending on how the school wants to roll it out it's really pretty close to instantaneous and it's limited to a safe and structured environment I'll give you an example our son is now 11 when he was in pre- they did this thing where the teachers asked what do you want to be when you grow up and our son a lot of people said doctors firemen policemen our son said he wanted to be a cat so I heard about it afterwards I never was there I couldn't capture that moment right that's a moment I'd love to have for history and probably show his wife and children in the future right th those moments that you
168kind of lose because you're not there in the moment our platform is designed to actually give the teachers and the parents and the families real time information about their kids and what their kids are doing and also give the kids a chance to create because you're right those kids are on video they're creating videos and you don't want them putting their videos on a place where a bunch of strangers are going to see them you would want them putting their videos on a place where it's a community of people that love your kids that care about your kids and will actually work to protect your kids so that's what we are really trying to do um the great thing is you know are also because it's an Arts education it is actually also covered by
169prop 28 which is a plus as well I'm so sorry my time is up but thank you for your attention and we would just ask that if there's someone that perhaps uh superintendent chood would like to um ask us to follow up we're certainly happy to so thank you everyone thank you are there any other public public comment in person comment uh president Brooks I also wanted to add one more thing um so you know as a parent um and I would be remiss and my my daughter who likes to you know listen in on Zoom during these meetings would be very upset if I didn't bring this up um you know um uh you know Mr Chamas when you're sharing about the contract links right you know five to seven years I would love
170to see um some kind of you know like uh trusty Kim was mentioning some evaluative aspect to it um zern has been especially um as a parent um very difficult and I see the 30 minutes three times a week I'm like nope that's not my experience and um you know my fifth grader along with a lot of her class is starting a um petition at North Shore View for a ban on zern um and she wrote it for her persuasive paper um and you know also in addition to that you know when we had open house in the beginning of the year you know you know parents were talking about zern and what turned out what started out as openhouse ended up turning into a Zur support group for parents um I would really love
171for you know that evaluative piece that happens every five to seven years to include you know and I know you know kids can complain about things but if it's working you know you got to got to balance a lot of different factors but I do think that you know understanding kind of the family and the parent perspective and student perspective of these software um I would love to have that as part of the evaluation process perhaps um you know when I was talking to superintendent Ooa perhaps like a serve a parent survey um with with these Technologies um yeah because it definitely um has you know even if we've seen gains and achievement um you know I can definitely say that zern has taken a hit to Wellness um in our in our home and
172and the homes of a lot of uh families that we are we know sorry I was inspired by ask two other questions actually somewhat related or piggybacking off of that one question I did have um with zurin I'm not going to Echo what trusty ho said but with zurin and all these other tools my understanding is one of the primary uses District uses them for is assessments and the ability to quickly assess based on ass set whether or not students are at level I know some of that gets incorporated into our report cards but I am curious one of the platforms I think at csba that was being highlighted were digital platforms that essentially aggregate all the different curriculum tools and create a report card for parents to show exactly you know even if it's
173math there are particular weaknesses word problems or graphing issues and we've been able to repeat this it's gotten better but it gives them very line atom data some parents will not want to look at but I think for some of us who are very data driven just having that level information now that we're capable of creating it is something that's interesting so I wasn't sure if there's anything on that level whether it's for our internal usage for our Educators or eventually something that could be presented to parents that kind of Aggregates all these different tools that we're putting together that was my first question for either David or the folks here uh I want to make sure I'm understanding your question so um I think there is the ability for example in zern to um
174to certainly get feedback on where the student at a very concrete level has specific strengths and and and needs um we also have the ability actually we're we're doing an analysis now it's it's a pretty complicated analysis but uh where we're integrating how is the student performing with the amount of time that they are actually spending on zern because we can pull that information down and triangulating that with um with st math um performance and that kind of thing so we're pulling so we're doing that but but only in the content area of math um I want to make sure I thought I might have heard you saying is there the ability to across content was that was that kind of what you were asking so each of these platforms and tools that we have
175is essentially creating similar assessments I do want to know whether or not there's any way for parents to benefit from that data that's being collected in terms of seeing a level like especially math you can see a breakdown of your child is you know struggling with fractions but it might be good at other types of issues or something um but whether or not there is some way to then present a comprehensive report given that we have the benefit of technology that 30 years ago you know we weren't able to do superintendent definitely um because our systems are our software based programs um will produce reports for teachers um these reports ultimately can be brought down to a source level they can be brought down to um a CSV document an Excel document we have staff
176that can turn that into a report for parents it will look really different based on the grade levels because an eighth grader is going to have a whole lot more statistical data than a Kinder um we piloted a few um versions of it uh internally um two years ago Trust trusty um trusty chin at the time had an interest in it and uh and we worked out on a couple of different versions of it we would probably lean more towards bringing on a partner who can help us with it because it it is pretty intensive in terms of creating the visual tool for parents to look at and as you heard at at the conference there are companies that do that work um we can just on an initial basis Reach Out make contact with
177those companies um to find out what that process might look like in terms of bringing on support to to be able to create parent reports that bring in the reading score the most recent math CFA the science score the state test score the ELD score and things like that in one location maybe even include the students grades or the students most recent report cards plus the report card of the prior year to see what growth looks like um and we can do that one thing uh for the board to consider um as we move forward is um any curriculum change process is going to have two components that are um fundamental to being successful the first is the cost component so our business services department um would need to uh think on it and give
178us um an estimate of what it would cost to replace one curriculum versus another uh in some cases you do spend money every every year on the curriculum because you need need to replace material so um it's not necessarily cost neutral but it might you know we'll get a dollar amount to find out what that is um math is a very essential subject so it would be money well spent kind of no matter what the cost is in a sense um but the second component is to bring on teacher experts um because we have some really highly trained uh folks who do this work um and we actually have an internal team of um I want to say 15 or so Math teachers on special assignment these are um teachers who don't teach a typical
179group of 25 kids they focus all day long all year long on math math instruction uh and they often support um grade levels uh within a school uh in terms of their their math instruction and um and these folks are some of the best in the business and we want to invite classroom teachers who do do this math instruction on a daily basis if we were to go away from zern I as a superintendent I would want a room full of Math teachers to tell me that that's a good idea or to listen to them about why it isn't a good idea or to consider multiple curriculum and different curriculum options and think what are the benefits of option a option b option C um and so on and so forth and um at the
180same time something that I think is a potential very critical strategy for us as it pertains to Community Schools um uh School District facilities access uh curriculum adoptions um is to think of involving our parents and our students in a way that we haven't done before and I think that's that that's what we've seen over the last 9 to 12 months is just that question of how can we have a voice in this process um and that would be a really great project for the ed services department to start thinking about uh as a board I would uh ask that we um think about this as it pertains to our plan going into the spring and into the fall um because any curriculum uh transition or or adoption process just takes time but as David
181pointed out 5 years is about uh the amount of time that we use to think about when we might um consider a new Adoption and so we're sort of on time as it pertains um to when that timeline is and uh and I think it's a project that we can put the right people in the room and get a really really good outcome from it so we don't have support groups of parents who should be who should be celebrating their students work and not uh grieving together over their their technology experiences yeah yeah that's super helpful thank you superintendent um thank you David as well and then one last just comment in passing so on the reverse side of this question about technology usage in incorporation is that you know my daughter is learning how
182to use canva in Google slides in class she is arguably better than me and I have an MBA and she's better than me at design at like fifth grade level I love that I think that's a great thing that she's learning a very practical skill something that's very useful to her another way she can Channel her art into technology I guess now my concerned than looking at it from a district perspective is do other students have the same level of access do they have access to instructors that can then guide them along and understanding we have certain limitations and you know not something we necessarily need to scale districtwide but it would be helpful to get that audit to get a sense of where we are which campuses which classrooms is it a instructor specific
183type of thing um because even on the video uh piece that was discussed earlier I recall when I was in Middle School I had to create video presentations for classrooms but it was very like instructor specific and back then we used video cameras and VCRs kids won know what those are um but I am now wondering as we start to try to incorporate more of these oportunities into our classrooms is it coming out in an equitable way in a way that all of our students are able to benefit or access those and on a broader level the superintendent and I have looked at talked about maker spaces and something more Tech driven that creates those opportunities for students who are inclined to pursue opportunities along those levels so it's just something as part of that
184ongoing conversation it would be great to see where we are as a district in terms of where those capabilities exist and where there might be interest from our students and our parents to try to create more of those opportunities or spaces thank you uh Joel are we able to see if there are any hands raised regarding this item yes check no public comments on Zoom at this time thank you is this one up for there's no vote on this one it's a presentation okay just okay all right we will move to uh seven uh the approval uh for business and F Finance uh the approval of the 2023 and 24 audit financial statement yes thank you so much uh president Brooks uh we have for you this evening the 2324 audit I want to thank
185the U shoban Associates auditing firm who came in and worked uh with our District staff with site staff um extensively um generate their support for us want to thank all the business team and the sites too who helped uh share this information everyone who participated in this uh in front of you tonight is the auto report um and I'll just read an excerpt from the beginning of it which I think summarizes very well this 105 page document and I know what I've seen over the 25 years I've been doing this I see Bo flipped to the back page that it says there's findings and recommendations which there are none which is great that's what you want to see um opinions that the otter have provided it says we've autoed the accompany financial statements of the
186governmental activities business type activities each major fund and the aggregate remaining fund information of the samon tale fost School District as of and for the year ended June 30th 2024 and the related notes to the financial statements which collectively comprise the samon tale Foster City School District's basic financial statements as listed in the table of contents in our opinion the financial statements referred to above present fairly in all material respects the respective financial position of the governmental activities business type activities each major fund and the aggate remaining fund information of the district as of June 3 2024 and the respective changes in the financial position and were applicable cash flows thereof for the year ended in accordance with accounting principles generally accept in the United States of America so this is um a nice summary
187for you um and we're asking for your approval of the audit report tonight for 2324 and I'm going to jump in like I do every year when this item comes up U because uh Patrick does a good job of presenting it but he does a bad job of um explaining how much um analysis and how much work goes into this audit report um if any any member of the public any member of the board were to just do a Google search today for school district Cuts School District budget School District you'll find a list of school districts that are all throughout the state of California that are making massive really terrible reductions um and looking under the hood if you will um you'll find audited Financial reports that have 8 9 10 15 exceptions and
188ex exceptions are basically mistakes um and so to not have any is really hard to achieve because what happens is the firm they camp out and they look through everything and it's completely randomized and it goes down to like I want a a hard copy of the attendance report for this school on this day for these classrooms and I want to review it uh I want to see the minutes of the meeting where this was approved specifically this language so it's just a very very rigorous um analysis I think as a superintendent I always want to be able to work with the school board and say your business services and your financial services are unimpeachable and these folks are really just saying this this process was complet this is um you know done according to
189um the regulations and um and and it really speaks to the work that Blanca and Joanne and Anna and so many wonderful people who work in the business services department who sadly they're unherd unheralded most of the year but um they make sure that we um can keep the lights on in the school district and they make sure that our over 1,000 employees get paid on time um and then it all ends up into one small Report with a summary for the board so just um congratulations to your team Patrick and um and to everybody who puts in uh so much work because these folks are just the definition of professional in in the work that they do so thank you to them thank you very much thank you do we have any board clarifying
190questions or comments trusty Proctor do you have any questions or comments uh just a comment thanks for this update and Patrick congratulations to you and your team for another clean audit I know that it is a ton of work so good job thank you any online Joe okay no public comments on Zoom at this time all right thank you um I will what that yeah I think we have to approve this one right you make yeah please thank you I have a motion to approve this item motion to approve um the audited financial statements second thank you president pro oh excuse me U trusty Proctor yes trusty ho yes trusty TR yes Kim yes and that is a yes for me that passes 5 Z thank you I'm getting the hang of it we're going
191to move to item 7B to adopt a resolution determining that uh bide Academy Playfield and EV Bus Parking project is exempt from the California Environmental Quality act deciding to carry out the project and directing the fulfill the filling of a notice of exemption Miss Amy it's a mouthful thank you I know you want me start first please please go okay good evening Bo president Brooks trustees superintendent Ooa and the audience my name is Amy rufo and I'm the executive director of facilities and construction for the school district the item before you determining that the Bayside project is exempt from squa review was thoroughly reviewed by our legal council and their environmental and Construction Division legal council determined that this project qualifies for four different exemptions the class one exemption exempts a project consisting of minor
192alterations to an exist existing public facility class three exempts a project that consists of construction and location of limited number of new small facilities or structures and installation of small new equipment and Facilities including Utility Systems accessory structures such as patio areas and fences this proposed project consists of a new prefab Warehouse building maintenance yard which are small new facilities that meet the definition of class 3 categor categorical exemption class 11 exempts a project that consists of construction placement of minor structures accessory to existing institutional facilities and the class 14 exemption applies to minor additions to existing schools that do not increase student capacity by more than 25% or 10 classrooms whichever is less um the project meets all four of these exemptions um also in in the board write up there are six exceptions
193that would then make us that we don't apply um for those um four exemptions which out of the all six it was reviewed and none of those apply to our project so I'll open it up if you have any clarifying questions or would you let me just say anything I think it's a good summary Amy to to share to for the board to begin the discussion so this is an action I'm you're asking the board for action for this uh item tonight is that correct Amy correct yeah any clarifying questions or comments yeah I mean I have um some questions um I know that we had a number of public comment earlier and you know thank you for to everyone who came especially those who spoke for the first time and um you know people
194may not be aware that we can't always respond in the moment right away to a particular comment um but I do know that some of the comments referenced an accurate information that was just who knows where it came from um and I know that you were at the meeting on Tuesday and so I was wondering if you could maybe give us a quick overview of what concerns were raised at that time um maybe clarifying some of the inaccuracies that were shared earlier um by by some of the public commenters and you know obviously don't expect everyone who makes public comment to like have a full background of the project um but you know pointing out for example that uh this is actually the seventh board meeting at which this project has been discussed and so
195just want to clarify that for anyone who may not have been aware but you know if you could maybe speak to some of the things that um that people may have misconstrued or misunderstood that would be really great sure so um one comment was that the the the field or soccer fields at both the um the way I took the comment both at the school campus and at the park are being demolished that's that's not true um the design utilizes unu mostly unused um land between our soccer field and the creek Edge so um we're looking at a loop road down the road that's between um Bayside and joinville park and the majority of joinville Park um is under a um 40-year agreement between us and the and the city but it is District land
196that is leased to the city so looking at uh creating a loop road around the existing neut tur field that we recently put in um and then this is to create facilities for electric buses now currently the buses are they range in different fuels mostly gasoline and Diesel um we're looking at um roughly around 35 38 buses um 10 to 12 being a Transit bus which is 40 ft long the majority of the the the the remainder of the buses are 25 ft so that is um what you see for a special education transport much smaller much uh agile buses um and then as it wraps around the site it does um come into a little bit of the existing playground um in conjunction with our measure T Bond we are um redoing the the
197black top at the site um installing new playground equipment new striping I've U met with the school site twice um this project first came up in early 2023 um so I've met with the school site um I'm I meet along with Patrick and other members of our business services team with the with the city so we met multiple times with um I believe her titles um the director of Transportation so or transportation services mainly it's about roads so it's about safe routes to school um condition of the roads what projects did the city have that might affect us like with up and drop off when are they going to pave and we do the same thing we then tell them what projects we have going on and what any concerns they have so um both
198these projects were discussed at the same time this and also um the expansion of Fiesta Gardens to the um College Park campus and and another key point there is um our staff meaning yourself Patrick um others in your department we work with our our Council our legal councel and um with our service providers who assist us with all of our construction projects so when we coordinate directly with the principal Transportation planner for the city um you know that's really highlevel coordination you know these are folks that do this as part of their daily work and they assist us on so as you know we're doing projects s all over San Mato and Foster City and so I I also want to just affirm that the work we did with the city was not solely verbal
199we're talking about looking at plans um making time and creating space to discuss concerns um and it's been a twoyear process our our very initial uh work with the city was dating back to March of 2023 uh so we're just coming up on 2 years from now um and it continued on throughout the process follow-ups couple months later follow-ups a couple months after that our meetings uh with the school staff began that year as well uh to the point of saying uh this project is moving forward and we want to design new playground facilities for your kids now Bayside having done a lot of District events there it's a beautiful school it's a humongous facility compared to to the Brewer islands of the world and the meal Heights of the world um but that black
200top is in terrible shape and it has 16 basketball hoops when it should have eight or 10 and uh it's uh it's showing its age we put a big beautiful uh field out there um but everything between the field and the buildings is in bad shape so meeting with the staff the focus was what would an ideal um playground experience be like for the kids so the the visuals the design was something that resulted from those meetings with key staff members who have been there um and have done that work and we T we touched on that a bit at the meeting um the other night as well yeah I'd like to also mention about the picnic area since I came up a few times so adjacent to this we well a adjacent to the
201driveway we're looking at a warehouse building this is for um both areas for a lounge for the bus drivers plus to be able to do some work um to the buses so that right now is directly adjacent to the picnic area I think there's a corner of the building shown on the concrete of the picnic area um but it doesn't show right now removing any tables so the plans for that building is still being finalized um our main focus focus is to get the driveway in and then we'll we'll be looking at a pre-manufactured building Warehouse um to be installed the plan is then to relocate if need be any tables the same amount um if they need to be adjusted on the Parkland um there is some trees being removed um we we've talked
202to the city about um we're going to be replanting some on our site the School site proper and any remaining trees to come up with the total number being removed be plant planted on the park that is also our land and there's there's a a lot of room um because this the school district owns all the way to the neighbors fence on the other side of the park it's more when you get down to the um the tennis courts and the and the pool where become city property so it kind of It kind of jogs there um and in conjunction with the housing project when we did a deep dive in our facilities we were continually looking for other options so we we continually looked well can we do this here can we can we
203fit it on another site can we buy property can we park it under overpasses we um mostly Patrick but we went around and round with so many different vendors um um other agencies we talked to the county um can we park them at the fairgrounds we went all different directions and came up with dead ends so looking at our whole portfolio properties um how this is one of our I think it is our largest site I need to compare next to about it but it does have the largest field the area of the field is larger than the high school football field um when you count the total square footage um so there's a lot of space um with oneway one um oneway traffic and um that this is able to um and we've talked
204with PG with um electrical concerns it can p it can charge um up to 40 buses so the infrastructure is there and uh we're working with PG other agencies like Bay Area air quality for grants for the buses I have one question uh regarding the staff parking um of a concern that was raised sure so there is parking um that we are developing for cars um behind the the gym building and right now looking at the number of spots it's a roughly can fit about two 2/3 of the number of drivers um so there's there's some amount of cars that would need to park um either in the school parking lot or in the shared parking lot um between so we we are creating more parking in the sort of um Dead Zone behind the
205gym that the school doesn't currently use just some other concerns M you're I'm sorry um you had asked also too about concerns and some of the other concerns we heard too from the community Community ORS regarding the impact of construction and the time of construction so we shared to um that uh what what our plan is for that too the contractor we'd bring in for that and it's a contractor um some of us have worked with for quite some time and and our experience of doing billions of dollars of school construction one of the best contractors I've ever worked with is a contractor we're talking about doing this work um so that was part of the concern um we certainly heard uh some of the same sentiments from ke members who weren't here tonight um
206who who voice concerns just about um student safety traffic um uh I think we heard uh one of our um community members tonight talking about a crossing guard I have notes I took notes of every word everyone said tonight but that was one of the comments I remember hearing about Crossing yard um we hear concerns too about potentially bus drivers wandering onto campus um there's a back gate issue there concerned about some of that um and so so we try to reassure people about um about that and share folks too that we've also been having conversations about um as opposed to having an outside vendor provide these Services we've been doing analysis about internalizing this whole operation so this would be our own employees driving our own students um we think that um is Will
207could be beneficial on multiple fronts so we're we're having those conversations too we shared that with the community that's just a couple of the other concerns I remember hearing about because your question was about concerns so uh specifically to the concern about timing um one of the questions was you're going to start a new project that's going to take four years to be completed and so the parent um you know brought that perspective to the meeting uh we had um Mark Cheryl who works uh as a senior project manager under Amy and he explained that um All The Hardscape for the buses um would be expected to be complete by the end of Summer and the new playground will be ready for the first day of school that's what's currently in the plan um so
208that was I think that was a shock because I think we sort of have a memory of what construction is like around us and it seems like it takes a really long time um and you're always sort of anticipating it it's going to take a lot longer than does um and yet you know we sometimes finish construction and as you learned at Sunny bre we have to go back and change something about it so you know that always remains a possibility um but in this case it's Hardscape and it's installation of new um baskets and new playground equipment so it does happen a lot more quickly than uh raising big physical buildings which as you know they can take 18 months or more um and so we were able to to talk through those those
209different items uh at the meeting and um and then of course bring it forward to the board for tonight can I also ask about um some people raised questions about the weight of the buses and the impact of you know kind of the wear and tear on the road I understand from superintendent NOOA that a lot of these electric buses are much lighter than like what we're maybe you know envisioning as um as like the tradition bus and so um do you have any details on that we're still in the process of buying the buses so we were looking at the specs um about the the range of the majority of the buses are the the smaller ones and and they kind of they range roughly I think like five to seven tons still looking
210it up nothing that we we're we haven't actually purched yeah we would have to pull the pull the exact models and and those kind of things um what I think is it was also you know an eye opener at the meeting a couple nights back and and certainly something we've talked about is we would think of school bus transportation and think of the long 83 passenger buses or like the long city buses um but the majority of the buses that would be part of our Fleet um are 25 ft smaller buses so these um naturally because they aren't as big they don't don't weigh as much so you'll have two different uh vehicle weights you'll have the larger uh passenger buses and then the 40 foot passenger buses and then you'll have the 25 foot
211and the 25 foot outnumber the longer ones three 2 to1 3 to1 type of thing uh ultimately when we get down to it uh the other consideration is how um overtime uh transportation is changing for our district in terms of the number of students who are um remaining in their neighborhood school um I'm happy to report this is something we've talked about for many many years um in terms of Just For example kids who live in the sunny Bray attendance area who have requested transfers out of kindergarten Sunny this year um it's been reduced by 50% over two years ago and that is part of a long term strategy of having kids have access to preschool really changing our really up implementing our district enrollment policies to make sure that kids are encouraged to stay
212in their neighborhood schools that results in fewer buses it results and less time on the roads um and those changes I'll concede they take time um but I think at at our meeting we did talk a bit about the ratio of the special education buses and and those are buses for children who have significant uh academic physical ambulatory needs that um put them in a situation where their parents can't provide daily transportation to them from school um and we have adults who are doing hand toand like the parents are bringing the kids out to the bus we're getting loading them on the bus and when the bus arrives at school there's an adult waiting for that child um to come off the bus so these are children with a lot of really individual Iz needs
213and we talked a lot about what that meant in terms of traffic flow uh and in terms of uh departure times so um we gave a couple of examples so a bus leaving uh Bayside would pick up a child who lives over by the Hillsdale Mall but that child is in a classroom at Sano Park and one of the other bus riders in is in a classroom at uh bral Middle School which is somewhat near uh Sano Park so the departure time for that bus from Bayside has to be significantly early to pick the child up at home knowing that there's a second bus rider who lives somewhat near them in the Hillsdale neighborhood arriving to two separate schools so the coordination means that the departure time from the Bayside neighborhood takes place so much
214earlier than the schools Parent uh and pedestrian traffic that goes uh to and from bside that um from our uh Bus Time sort of analysis and the school bow schedule analysis um these are you know these are really far apart times so there won't be that um you know crosssection of the transportation of the bus itself for the child with special needs and then the typical uh mom and pop taking the child to school or walking the child to school and we did talk about that at the meeting as well all right um truste Proctor do you have any questions or comments related to this item no thank you okay Joel can you please check online to see if any hands are raised of course checking um no public comments at this time okay um
215we do have in person yes we do but she's still up so are we done here I I'm done unless you have any other questions no okay uh sorry you can uh thank you for staying late and uh allowing us to speak um and thank you for the uh engineers and designers and budgeters for doing this um one of the things I'd like to uh start with is is that um ordinance number 2008-10 um should have been reviewed two years ago when this project was incepted or proposed um there's a specific reason why um this ordinance is in place and you and whoever you spoke to in the city should have uh made it very clear and unfortunately we've had such turnover in Sano city that um uh they're not aware of these historical ordinances
216that are not outdated they're actually up to dat um and these ordinances do not allow any Vehicles exceeding 5 tons to go down past Norfolk Street on kho um and there's a specific reason for that the um yes Shore View is landlocked but it's also on a bowl of jelly and the Land There is not as stable as people think it is or assume it is and so for that reason um many years ago I've been I was born and raised here so and you know I've been here upwards of 50 years of my life here so um uh I I know the history behind this and and the people knew that we wanted to send Sam trans down kho Avenue at one time and that was not possible because of the the shaking of
217the home so when Sam Tren goes past my house on Norfolk Street uh my house shakes it's like a miniature earthquake um and so I understand that you're the school and you're trying to serve students and students with special needs but as part of um our job as a community and your job as the board um it's to make these assessments and make yourself aware of these laws and ordinances ahead of time to make your planning uh smoother and and less uh uh you know um risky it's to drisk these items um and so for that reason uh it is important to understand that I agree that maybe these smaller shuttle buses might be five five tons or less uh but once you put people on them they exceed 5 tons uh even one pound
218greater than 5 tons is violation of the ordinance um secondly there are these longer buses which but blatantly will be exceeding the five ton limit um and so there are many other places in the city I know that you had mentioned that there were options for other places but uh there seems to be a little bit of a disconnect between planning and understanding with the community what would have been a better place like you had suggested the fairgrounds what a beautiful place to park buses right so we need to know about these things and we need to chime in and brainstorm together the community especially that little Community by Bayside I went to Bayside uh you know I I went to horal school I went to Aragon I went to CSM and then you know
219I went and got my PhD I went to UC Santa Cru blah blah blah blah blah so I I've done that and and we're all Scholars here uh to a certain degree we're all educated here we're part of the education board and so we should spend our scholarly uh aptitude in applying it to these types of situations um so you know special needs buses are great uh but they're not unloading and loading people at Bayside they're going somewhere to load and unload so for that reason it's still causing it's still a violation problem one of the things that I wanted to mention is is that I I realized and somebody had already told me that some of the infrastructure has already been built unfortunately um that was a mistake unfortunately uh not that your efforts
220are dismissed but it was a mistake and that mistake needs to be realized and understand understood um Citys city council is being informed as we speak mayor is being has been informed city manager City attorney is being informed about this ordinance um given now that you're in the know uh any buses that c does damages to people's homes as in cracks on drywall um the cost of fixing those starts at $1,000 per home per claim just to let you know um the city because of this can also claim that the damages to the road is is part isn't is a cost incurred to the city um so uh I would say that really deeply think about this before moving forward because a lot of You Are have Endeavors of political Endeavors of growing and moving
221forward um you don't want to be known as the person that bankrupted the the the school district um uh because of these types of claims to the to the school district okay um this is also a child impact issue um if you're trying to protect children which our school board should be doing um then the pollution even though by the way I I believe last time I checked an electric school bus is actually heavier than a gas one because of the battery so it's heavier um just like a Tesla is quite heavy too because of the battery so um look into that you can look into the specs but anything even an ounce exceeding 5 tons is is a violation of the ordinance so please check uh check into that um but nevertheless the the
222the pollution that's being emitted what a lot of people don't understand is is again Shore View District 4 is a landlocked area and so the traffic that people can fudge the numbers on the traffic impact report but take it from um what's called R rwe you should write that down it's called real real world evidence um that's being used in my field which is the pharmaceutical industry we use real world evidence to actually make our judgments and how to make decisions we don't use what an assessor goes out and assumes they know we actually use real world evidence and I can tell you that every morning in front of my house on norfol street is a parking lot and the emissions coming off of those from a gentleman by the name I mentioned earlier Wayne
223michod um he actually changed the law in the entire state of Virginia uh you cannot idle your car in front of a school anywhere actually for other other public places um at all in the state of Virginia you have to turn your car off um which and he had proven successfully that idle car emissions is particularly harmful to kids more than adults because adults have adapted their immune system other types of things of their bodies where they can actually adjust but the children are more susceptible and so when you create a concentrated area in District 4 and now you pack in more cars and more buses and more commute into there you've now increased that concentration of pollutants exposing the children and so for that reason uh please take that into into into account there
224can be waivers and assumptions and exceptions for squa and all these kinds of things but those are usually um politically Exempted they're not real world evidence-based and for that reason I would say uh please take the time to reconsider I know you've spent some money but um it might be good to just spend a little bit of extra money and relocate the the parking of the buses um because um like I said ordinance number 2008-10 is a clear violation for that particular specific area and it says right here 510 kho Avenue president Brooks pardon my Interruption but are we adhering to the three minute um public comment time okay that's okay I'm done thank you I appreciate it all right we need an approval for this item right um may I please have a motion
225to approve this item sorry just a point of clarification are we is it the notice of exemption that we're approving or is there a separate resolution that we're approving there is a resolution and I'm looking at the attachments and I don't see it currently attached so it is the same verbiage that is in the board item um with all the different classifications but when I created does have exemption there's there it's both it's a resolution to file the um exemption oh I see I'm just wondering um this gentleman has raised this issue of um the S ordinance and I wanted you know I want to be cognizant of that and I'm not sure whether that was raised at any point before this um do you recall any discussion of this so we did discuss with
226the the city and the transportation department um it was not brought up at that time um looking through the ordinance again tonight um there is another exemption that we're checking with legal counsel um about um about buses specifically um and so we are still waiting on that I don't know if we heard back officially but it's um passenger buses under the Juris jurisdiction of the Public Utilities Commission so long as they do not deviate from their established bus route also in this is um garbage trucks and and other things that weigh more um as well as like delivery vehicles so Amy sorry to interrupt you but I believe I believe what what the ordinance speaks to as well well as truck traffic and there are exemptions for emergency vehicles garbage trucks and buses but that's
227some so that's just that's just us we this is the first time we heard about it tonight um and again we did meet with the city and and so appreciate the community members sharing that and um making us aware of his concerns for the greater good of the community um but in looking through it tonight that's what we are seeing as what's referred to in and it's talking about truck traffic and there are exemptions for those items I just said and then Joe um if you can hear this we have a notice of exemption on on the agenda item will you pull that up um and display it on on the screen and then um we have a question for Patrick here you brought it up is it possible to zoom in on it Joe
228some all right and just as context this is something that um we do for like building the solar um turf fields building a new building this is um a very typical form that's filed and then the agenda item is the approval the resolution but Patrick it if is the resolution not attached to this the verbiage I believe Amy you drafted is embedded in the the cover sheet which is a language which is if it was in the form of a resolution document itself but I think it's also you're saying that the resolution language is inhering your form it's one of the same also written in the same format with all the whereases and all that the intent for was it to also be attached I'm as I'm looking at the documents um it's not there
229currently I'm wondering if we can you know since there are some open questions um about um both the ordinance that was mentioned and then um just wanting to make sure that this is really clean um when we you know consider you know adopting the resolution um since the resolution it's like the text of the resolution itself um is not on here I would propose that we maybe table this until the next meeting um so that we have a chance to confirm with legal counsel or whoever we need to confirm with um before we vote on it so my motion would be to table this until next month I I I would second that and just add the comment that I think especially not having the language of the resolution understanding that it's meant to mirror
230the exemption form it puts us in a tough situation in terms of not having shared it with the public in advance and not being able to go through our typical governance protocols um I also think that a lot of the comments that I understand were shared on Tuesday night that were shared tonight at the board meeting would be great to share with the community just something that would be helpful to address a lot of the misconceptions that are out there but also just to show that we are striving to be transparent and to show the amount of diligence we put in I've often said our district does a good job of doing the work we don't do a great job of telling the story or taking the wins and so knowing the amount of diligence
231conversation coordination with the city of San Mato that went into these decisions I think it's helpful background it won't necessarily alleviate all the concerns that were raised by the folks who came forward today but I do think it helps to let them know that these conversations were ongoing and that these are all questions that we had approached tried to answer gotten legal council opinion on so I think that would be helpful but specifically because the resolution language wasn't made available I I agree with vice president Tren then may we want to table this for now but open to comments from the other trustees um I agree with both um trustee Tren and trusty Kim trusty Pro yeah I agree too I especially would like to get clarification on the ordinance um to make sure that
232we've addressed that with the city and proper authorities but otherwise um yeah I agree we can I'm okay with tling this all right can I get a motion to table this to a future date a motion to table this resolution to a future date second uh trustee Proctor yes trusty H yes trusty Tren yes trusty Kim yes and that's a yes for me uh that passes 5 we will move to number eight on the agenda Human Resources the uh approval of updated transitional kindergarten board policy thank you president Brooks and good evening everyone um this next item addresses board policy updates regarding transitional kindergarten credentialing um just as a reminder we reviewed the current policy um and the proposed new language at last month's board meeting um the most significant update to this piece involves
233uh a piece they call comparable experience and that's where a board can decide um as part of the credentialing criteria what that comparable experience might be and in our case we recommended that the comparable experience would be one year of full-time experience in TK or Kinder classes kindergarten classes with four-year-old students and so um this is an action item and so thank you for your consideration if there are any questions before you vote um you can ask thank you for um proposing this item I think I spoke pretty excitedly about this item in the last meeting um far too often we have staff who are amazing who have the experience to come in and teach they've been there they've you know experience the classroom and can offer a lot of great assets to not only
234our school but to our kids as well from real life experience and um in addition to this being considered for uh this prek level I mean I would really highly consider uh would like the district to consider this in other grades as well because we do have a lot of amazing staff who we could benefit from being in the classroom and our our school our students as well agreed do we have any other board comment trustee Proctor sorry were you asking for comments or vote comments at this time I don't have any thank you question okay this is up for a vote a vote can we get a oh uh any public comment Joel checking no public comments at this time all right up for vote uh motion to approve the updated transitional kindergarten board
235policy second trustee Proctor yes trusty H yes trusty Trent yes cim yes and that is a yes for me that passes 5 thank you let's see where we are 9A uh pre oh no we already I thought we oh no here we are uh preschool update from student services Joe if you can um admit uh Christina Haley and Amanda drif are two directors of childhood development who will be provid this update just a moment thank you I don't see oh there they are thank you good I only saw uh director Amanda thank you very much will you kindly um allow us the ability to share screen when you have a moment good evening superintendent Ooa trustees staff District staff and members of the public I'm Amanda Drisco and this is Christina Haley and we are
236your directors of Child Development here in Sanel Foster City and we are very honored to be here tonight to share a preschool update with all of you tonight we will be sharing about an update on our expansion efforts to increase access to preschool we will talk about supports in place for our staff families and students how we're preparing and continue to prepare our students for kindergarten and building an inclusive school program just give me one moment to pull up our slides all righty here we go so in 2122 we identified a thousand students that are preschool age in our district who didn't have access to prek so we have been working hard on that we have been growing our T the preschool program in our TI to one schools at turull in Foster City we
237opened up 10 new uh classrooms so we are busy you can see see around our district we have 12 different preschool sites with 567 students and just letting you know that we are including SDC we are including fee based and we're including the state funded preschool program Al together that's what we're doing for as as a whole program now as you can see we have grown tremendously from 164 students all the way up to 56 7 we have been making slow and steady progress and ensuring that we're getting to that number of 1,000 students that needed to be in preschool and didn't have the opportunity so just so you know with the cspp program the the state funded preschool program when we started out with 164 students we were earning a state contract of about
238$3.1 million doll as we have grown our state contract has also been growing and now you can see where with as many students as we have we're needing more to grow our program and to ensure that we have the space for all of our students and that we have all of the staff that we need to be teaching them so the state is now awarding us with $6.8 million we've received an extra expansion Grant of$ 2,200,000 um and we were getting about 4.6 million so that's where the 6.8 million is coming in all right and as we grow our program and support more and more students we are developing um the supports necessary to help sustain our teachers and being the best they can be supporting students and welcoming families to their first school experience
239we're going to talk a little bit about um what those supports currently look like and how we hope to expand those moving forward um for staff later we'll talk a little bit about um additional grants we've received our a lot of our work a lot of our professional development currently is focused around inclusion um we were um fortunate to receive a large inclusion Grant this year a little over a million dollars to support this professional development work um currently focused in the area of trauma response and giving families excuse me staff um the tools they need to support our kiddos um from the moment they enter our classrooms we've implemented some of the strategy IES we're bringing from our elementary principal days of developing care teams and a model of um professional collaboration where we
240discuss how to support students um so they can be the most successful and how to support each other so we too can be successful as a staff this also includes developing an mtss framework um with preschool in mind and um developing those tiered supports um from one all the way to the most um intensive supports um again all with the goal of ensuring that our teachers feel that they have the tools to um dress student needs um that our students feel that they can access those supports to be successful in the classroom a large part of our program is supporting our families and how we do that we have three community service specialists who are reaching out to families ensuring that they have their needs met and connecting them with Partnerships in our community who
241can help them um if families need food or if they need um some uh housing if they're looking for clothing these are all different ways that we can connect them with Community Partnerships that will support with their needs we have mental two mental health consultants that are working with our children and our um staff in the classrooms to ensure that they're doing um what they need to do to like students when they're three and four aren't able to talk about how they're feeling but they act how they're feeling so that information is really important and our mental health consultants help us see that um and then we have family workshops for um to ensure that we can share information with them all right last I'll be really brief about um just one more thing so
242uh at the beginning of the year we kicked off the school year with a new model for um holding a family um orientation we invited all of our Community Partners so that it was not only a chance for families to learn about their new classroom meet the new teaching staff that their child was going to be with all year but it was also a way to engage with the Community Partners to know how can they access resources to benefit both their children and their families um and that is what the work that our community service specialists continue throughout the school year um we you if you have children yourself you may be familiar with um developmental screeners that are used in um pediatrician offices to um help monitor student development or children Child Development um
243we use those here also in our preschool program to um monitor student development Child Development um also providing families with resources to support those areas of need that are identified in um the ages and stages questionnaire moving into student supports um these are all of the areas the skills that we um want our students to have access to and ire so that they are ready for kindergarten um I would say that this bottom part of the triangle is what we spend a lot of time on in preschool it's so very important that our students are going to kindergarten with the self-regulation skills with the ability to express themselves with the ability to care for themselves and develop those fine and large motor skills to support the large more challenging academics and physical Endeavors they are
244going to pursue in kindergarten um this year is our second year implementing um Second Step which you've heard about from other directors this evening across our district we this is our social emotional learning curriculum that we use um as well as Learning Without Tears um and again our goal is that all of our children are um entering Kinder Garden ready to engage in circle time ready to engage in those more rigorous academics um and and self self-starters and dependent Learners I just briefly want to touch on this year um a huge focus in our classrooms is um ensuring that all of our classrooms um include these elements that we consider huge elements of Universal Design for Learning um we believe in our that our preschool program in order for our students to be successful they
245need to have access to a calm corn to to a clip system um all of these I uh ideas strategies that are listed here are things that you will see in every single preschool classroom um and they are supports that we know students um need access to to succeed Equity is very important in our district one of the number one things that we know that is part of our strategic plan and everything that we're about what that looks like in preschool is that we are a full inclusion program we have all students in classes together and they are learning and um getting supports that they need in class we're integrating all the mission of preschool in all of our classes so our whole program is about an incl being an inclusive community we mainstream our
246students that are in our stdc classes into our general education preschool classrooms on the same campuses and that's been working really well to give students a chance to be together learning um and giving all students every opportunity for Success they have access and they have participation and support in everything that they need for successful learning just like Amanda said we have um received some grants one of which is in addition to the state funding we received the Eep Grant of a million dollars to expand our inclusion program which is exactly what we need and that's going to look like a new playground at the turble campus because it's in need of um being more inclusive all right next steps we definitely are continuing to work hard between articulation with the systems that we have in
247preschool we've just gotten up everything into Aries our preschool is now in Aries which is a big thing and now it's that way of connecting Aries in um preschool to kindergarten to send all that information to them um we are trying to have it be a much more seamless way of getting information to our kindergarten team um and then you know we've been working really hard on high quality Early Learning we are having um the class assessments come and it's an assessor who comes and looks to make sure that we're doing that work in our classes and we're doing a great job of improving our scoring um and last year we made significant changes this year we're making significant changes and we have been really working hard to get to be this size it's very
248different for this program to be 567 students strong but we're continuing to grow and we are building new systems to um continue that growth so we will be training our staff we're asking the state for a couple of more um professional development days we need that to continue learning together and we are going to continue doing the great work of collaborating and planning together um with the SDC preschool teachers as well all together learning um it's been a phenomenal already half year um and we can already see is going to be happening into next year we're excited about these opportunities and at this time we will open it up for any questions you may have thank you very much for this presentation um actually no I don't have any questions at this time are there
249any questions from the board uh thank you so much for this presentation um I was really encouraged to see you know kind of expanded access to preschool and kind of the rising numbers um Through The Years um is just really encouraging um I wanted to ask just kind of a clarifying question you know when you were stating that there are you know um in 2122 there are about a thousand preschool aged children um who don't have access to prek um does that number include you know families I I kind of want to understand a little bit what that 1,000 is um does that include who for example maybe chose a Private Preschool um program or were these families who you know wanted to access our prek programs but couldn't I was just wondering kind of
250where this number came from and if you could explain that for me yeah absolutely um if and I we we did go pretty quickly um but we can go back to the L3 report from 2021 is really where that um highlights this in even greater Det tell um but in at that time period when we were looking at our fourth grade uh reading data and looking at our most marginalized students who were at or um near Benchmark um the common thread for these students was preschool and accessing um a state preschool program in our district and so at the time we were um trying to identify how many um how many many families in at the time in our Title One schools um had preschool a children who were not accessing preschool and so at
251that time of kind of data Gathering com uh CSS is contacting families um that number that we reached was around a thousand students so we recognize that there are around a thousand students in our community who do not access um preschool and so we you know that's kind of that number that we keep in mind as we're GR growing our program is we recognize that yes we are growing and and we are welcoming more and more families into preschool each year um but we know that there are still many children in in our County um who who do not access um high quality preschool would that help much yeah that that uh perfectly answered my question I also wanted to ask another clarifying question um I I was really excited to hear about the community
252service specialist um and the work that they're doing um I just wanted to want uh ask you know are was there an emphasis in hiring you know multilingual um Specialists um you know I'm thinking about families who you know may not be familiar with the American educational system for example yes definitely so if you walk into the ter bble office you would see that all 10 of the staff in the office are Spanish speaking um and we are absolutely 100% supporting our our families who come in from other countries and are needing support by communicating with them in their language by understanding what their needs are by listening to them talking to them what's so beautiful about the Cs is is that they can take that time to really listen to what their needs are
253and know how to connect them with the right resources we're really lucky and fortunate to have a team of cs's that really do that great work right here at you know with our families doing it so we can tie into the asq work along with being a CSS so we've kind of done this dual role with the positions and also a CSS who's also an enrollment specialist and that is another way for listening to the families during enrollment and the whole process of understanding what their needs are helping them get connected then with the you know everything that we know about our Community Partnership so it really has been a huge difference for us to have these positions you know in our proog program thank you so much um to piggy back off of trusty
254host question about the identified need um do we know I mean since 20 you know since 2021 2022 we've rolled there's been an expansion in the TK program and I'm wondering um do we know if this thousand students number like doesn't need to be adjusted or I I mean obviously that was maybe the identified need at that time but are we adjusting um our goal or our enrollment goal um you know how is that affected by the TK expansion so TK is an interesting um you know part of our program I want you to think about TK um and as we have rolled it out you know with the state um it is a number of minutes in the program so let's say it's 280 minutes that TK needs to be um happening during the
255day well in our program what we're doing is we're teaching fouryear olds and TK are teaching foury olds as well and what we have actually found is that the families that need more time in the day to be able to go and work we have an eight hour program here the students that can go to TK could actually be in either the TK program or the preschool program so a lot of our families that are in our our um our state funded preschool classrooms they're choosing to stay in preschool for another year because they know that they have eight hours of care for their children that's been a huge difference for TK we aren't taking any of the students away from our TK program the students that are going into TK are going and the
256families are supporting the three and a half hours or in some cases we'll have Boys and Girls Club that will support um the the extra hours needed but our families are getting the option of staying in preschool we're giving them a choice because the programs are so similar for four-year-olds and what the expectations are in child development is what you're teaching four-year-olds is what they need to be knowing in whatever program that they're in does that make sense yes it does yeah and yeah that makes a lot of sense um and I'm I'm sure that yeah I mean I I do know people who were deciding between the two programs and you know everyone every family can um make the choice that's best for them so it's great that we have these options um my
257I have another question and I think I already know this but just for um the people who may not know what a clip system is can you explain like what it is and why we have it yes you bet you bet and I hope you have a chance to see it in action as well um but we use this clip system as a self-monitoring system so if you can imagine um Learning Centers in a preschool um setting which is an envir or an a play that you will see children engage in throughout their day in preschool because it t it is play based um when CH students have an option think about it as Center so you have may have seven different centers that you can choose from um and students actually there's one right
258behind the door um students um select the area where they want to learn um and put their clip on their shirt we use it at staff development to model using udl so I keep it in my office as well um so I if I select to go to the art area I'm going to wear my yellow clip um and when I'm my time you know when I've decided that I want to move on to another area I select a different Center um it's all based on the student choice however um each area will have you know sometimes in the sensory bin area you know that if it's water play there might only be space for um for children to play play safely so um students have to use that visual clue of oh there aren't
259any more yellow Clips I can't go to the art center I need to choose a different Center um and so it's also a way for the teachers to um change change out the ways that children are engaging with each other throughout the day so some of the activities that teachers select for to put on the um actual Choice board um are you know related to um the curriculum or related to a certain skill that they know um many of their students in their class are working on um and then some of those favorite activities they know their kids want to have access to every okay thank you and I have one last question um which is maybe a little bit more open-ended but um I you know we're at these 12 preschool sites and my
260question is you know for um the preschool sites the you obviously there's the turble um Child Development Center which is kind of a little bit Standalone um but for the other ones they're all housed at elementary schools or t um or you know pre TK through 8 and I'm wondering um is there currently a plan or like a district-wide plan to inte like for how much or how you know how to integrate the preschool classrooms into the larger um School communities because obviously a lot of them will have older siblings in um in the other upper grades but also you know um I think it's nice and I and I know it's a little bit difficult because you know you're the the preschool program principles and then like the individual site principles and so there's
261a lot of coordination but um I know for example that Laurel has made a lot of um effort into you know integrating the the preschool into like the The Wider workings of the school and so I'm wondering um if you could talk a little bit more about whether what the plans are going forward for for that I think when you think about this from a sense of community um when we think in terms of community and Community Schools um the ideal scenario is that from the time children enter the school as a three-year-old they or a 2.9 yearold um you know they're a an included member of the community there and and that's their first day on Laurel's campus right but they're there all the way through fifth grade um I think what tend what
262can also happen is you know preschool operates under licensing regulations and so that can um limit some of the ways that we interact with the elementary school sites um and those are all things that we're working through as we even build our relationships with each site principle um in understanding like how do we further develop this collaboration so that um our families and the children feel um like a very included person on that campus from the day that they begin um and again I think that comes with time of of being more and more familiar with having these little ones on campus and um incor figuring out ways to be even more inclusive even um you know thinking about expanding our ideas of you know te typically as a preschool program we run our own
263we call it parent advisory committee it's kind of like the P it is the PTA of of elementary school so figuring out way ways and creating these new ways of understanding of how to build that sense of community um that it doesn't need to be this separate entity even though in a lot of ways it can feel like a separate entity with um different leadership and different regulations to abide by I'm picturing when the Mandarin program moves to Fiesta with the rest of College Park they're going to have an opportunity to all be together and like we're having this big Lunar New Year celebration next week and next year the all get to do that together and it's going to be a beautiful way to bring the community together for preschool up through well eventually
2648th grade um but fifth grade for now and so it's just having that opportunity to build together as a community some schools haven't had that opportunity yet and it's new for them and they're learning how to coexist with preschool um and some have been on their campuses for a really long time so getting together for let's say um Halloween or celebrations that you can have throughout the year or movie Nights those are all ways that families come together whether you're preschooler or whether you're a fifth grader and you're enjoying being a student at that school and enjoying building community so it's actually a really wonderful way to do just that thank you uh thank you all for the presentation and first I just want to commend you all for the work you've done to really
265expand the number of students students we've been able to serve all of us here who work in education know how important that Early Education component is to long-term outcomes and success and so seeing that we've not only been able to serve a broader range of students but at multiple sites that are more convenient for parents and families is just a really good sign of kind of Direction our district is going to better serve the communities that we're in I had two questions somewhat related to the uh topics we've already touched upon my first and this is a followup from a conver question I asked previously so with the campus swap happening next year minor understanding is there's going to be a shift both in Fiesta Gardens and Turnbull I just wanted to get a sense
266of how many students do each site serve now and what is the expectation of how that will change come next year whether it'll be a pure inversion whether we expect turn Bill to still remain much larger because I understand the terb used to be expected to serve a much broader range of students and part of our transition to more local sites was to ease that burden and then now with the campus swap happening if you can give us a sense of what that transition will look like and then my second question question since I'm uh going through it following up on vice president tren's comment about integration I was curious to the extent either now or in the future that the curriculum for some of the preschools will also in some ways mirror the schools
267they feed into so for both our montauri schools to what extent the preschools incorporate any monor practices for a manderin immersion Spanish Immersion to what extent is that emphasized or accessible at the preschool level I wanted to get a sense of where we are now and whether or not we hope to eventually get to a point if we're not already where the preschool curriculum somewhat mirrors the immersion program or magnet program or montau program that it feeds into exactly great questions you want to take the first one or the second one I already forgot the first one okay the first one thinking about the number of students cha this is Diego can you hear me yeah yeah let me take the um K5 component of of uh College Park and and Fiesta um historically both
268schools were bigger you know especially Fiesta Gardens so Fiesta Gardens had um over 500 students attending Fiesta Gardens at one point as you know the pandemic had a big impact on how many kids go to public school and Fiesta wasn't an exception in that uh regard and so it was about 415 or so um we are working on our enrollment projections right now for uh College Park and um College Park is really predictable we maintain really you know really close classes about 72 per grade level 24 kids in each class um so that just extrapolates out to the mid 400s um and it does change because older kids sometimes will move on to other uh places or just move out of the area and it is harder to find a student who might be in
269third fourth or fifth grade and be able to come into a mandarin immersion uh program without having been there uh Kinder through five um so that component of the switch is going to be pretty like for like in terms of the the overall student enrollment and I should say the capacity for enrollment so um in the preschool program uh one of the biggest areas for growth for us are kids who live in North Central but don't go to park Laurel lead or sunny bra BEC or fiest because they go their siblings go to Highlands or to Meadow Heights or to barisford to to non neighborhood uh aligned schools um but that's their their homeschool and so in Prior years um something that Christina and and Amanda didn't touch on but um I'm sure it's only
270because they are just such wonderful lovely people um you know our preschool program um was hard to get into and parents would tell you I I don't know I I don't know how to get in I I um think I've turned everything in and I can't get my child enrolled into this program and so a lot of the early work on revamping our um preschool program was based on some highlevel analysis we did of specific cases where in enrollment was being held up for I'll just give one simple example a parent was an Uber driver and uh one of the expectations at the time was provide us with proof of income that you meet the income requirements well Uber drivers they have to print out these CRA these really really long reports of all the
271the trips they've made essentially and uh and then do a calculus to it and it's very complicated so this parent brought us you know 100 pieces of paper to prove um one year's worth of Inc income and um was told we need 13 months and so as a result the student was now almost school age and hadn't gone in so we started to pick cases like that to really try to understand what was the true barrier because you saw that number down at 167 when I saw that I was re as a new superintendent I was really really concerned I was knowing we have 11,000 kids um and and it really resulted in the staff saying let's hire community service specialists whose expertise is in being that warm hand welcoming you into the office to
272say let me figure out how I'm going to help you fill out all this paperwork to get your child enrolled so we don't do things anymore like hold on to paper until papers until people come back and see us we now say we need you back back here next Monday I'm going to help you fill out these forms that I know you're going to you know like the alternative income form or the Declaration of residence form um in some cases we have families who are waiting on that first bill well why would we make the child Miss 30 days of school let's have them fill out a declaration of residency and get that you know sort of the the non-official address form uh submitted and and we do a lot of things like that because
273Christina and Amanda have changed the procedure and now that we have these established programs at Sunny BR Laurel Park um and then as you know at at College Park next year um we we'll have extra space at uh turull in order to be able to serve kids whose siblings go to Highlands Beford um meal Heights Baywood but they don't go to a preschool at one of those schools because we like in at those campuses there isn't space to build a brick and mortar um preschool facility so um but as you know they do live near College Park well what is you know the the current uh location of College Park and so they can just walk their kids to that school yeah and then I'll turn it over to Amanda and um and Christina for
274the other question I think well I think I'll answer the other question um briefly and just to say um I did not go into depth in how our magnet programs are um slightly different right yes we're all teaching social emotional learning and we're all um ensuring that our students are developing those fine and large Motors that they need to be able to eventually hold a pen and pencil um but that that um that experience does look quite different in in the various magnet um programs in particular um obviously our both of our monory teachers are monory trained so yes you'll see components you'll still see them hold us a run a circle and teach an seal lesson um but you'll also see this the the very same um routines and and methods used in our
275Kinder first second um montor classrooms um at Parkside and Mont and um nor shy excuse me um and I think I'm excited to hear about the work of our prek through eight master plan team in a couple weeks um I'm really excited for for moving that work together as a community forward as a community um and and seeing where we where we take that right um we can we can be a language specific um or we can be a language immersion program and but we all we will follow the components and um what we know um our three and four year-olds need to um meet those developmental milestones and be prepared for kindergarten regardless um of that particular Focus for the preschool do you want to add anything I was just going to say that
276um when we had a speaker today talk about Parks size tosa and wanting to keep her that same tosa is working with our preschool program to ensure that the monory methods are being followed through so we are whenever there's learning like that like you know as we're working on um let's say our Mander immersion program and this whole um idea of coming together between PK and 8 that is something that our preschool program is getting to learn from and understanding what the needs are of the students in that preschool program um and so really it makes a big difference to be working together with the sites that are doing some specific work around immersion or monitory training or play based any of those learnings are important great and just to Circle back to my first
277question and I understand you know obviously it's only January so we don't have exact numbers but do we have a sense of what the size of ter bill will be next year compared to this year and vice versa what will be College Park next year but is Fiesta Gardens this year how many preschool students will be served on that site what we're expecting for next year versus this year three classes so three classes are here Mandarin immersion those three classes are going to be at the fiesta Garden site so we're moving over the three teachers well four teachers really um at the three classrooms with 24 students in each classroom they will continue on into the kindergarten program when they are um finished being a preschoolers in our program and then in Fiesta Gardens there's
278one classroom that classroom will come over here so we will have have two Extra Spaces one of which could be another cspp class our need is so much greater at turble which is really positive turble didn't always have the best reputation and right now all families want their kids to be in teral they really love where it's located and they it really helps for them just like Diego was saying you know because their kids let's say are far away you know in the highlands you know or trying to get up there they love having their kids here at turble so I'm glad that we can grow our program here at turble and give them more opportunity to have their students right near where they live and one last comment related to this um in terms
279of turnbull's capacity and and just our around our inclusion work um as we begin to build an inclusive playground and reflect on our experience with um our various SDC preschool classrooms across the district and some have access to a gened preschool classroom on the campus and some don't um I think we'll keep this in mind as we move forward and plan as well and um you know do we consider as a district having an additional SDC class at turble where um students will have access to mainstreaming and also have access to an inclusive playground if they have mo mobility challenges um so I think those are all things that we will consider and and work with our leadership team in in deciding moving forward as well our first foray into have an inclusive playground is
280Laurel if you ever get a chance to see Laurel's preschool playground it's it's a true inclusion playground and that's the work that we're trying to do over here at Turnbull to really make it inclusive for all students that's great to hear thank you for that information and as a college park parent I can attest to the fact that turble has a fantastic reputation in the community so it's great to hear that we'll be able to expand access uh to serve additional families as well thank you thank you thank you very much uh are there any raised hands online Joel no public comment on Zoom at the moment right all right okay now we will move to item um 10 and if there's any board members who would like to request any future agenda items I
281would like to start with um C te uh really uh diving into um bringing Career Education um education uh into our district in a full capacity I I have a few potential agenda items or just items that we'd like to address in some capacity another um one I want to bring up that I think I talked more about last year is around our school lunches nutrition and food waste I understand both there's been some changes that we've implemented at the district level but also state laws and other changes that we've had to respond to and so I know that's something that I'd like to get a better sense of coming out of the pandemic all of the changes we made to improve our school lunches to diversify types of food we have to make them
282more nutritious more fresh I think would be a very interesting analysis to have but also if we can treat it almost like a school visit to go see what the facilities look like to go see what a lunch hour looks like I think would be really great insights to have um and I also get report outs from my daughter who does eat school lunches and tells me whether she likes it or didn't like it for that day so it' be nice to compare notes with what she's bringing home um related to kind of the broader discussion we've had tonight about the need to overc communicate with the campus swap that we referred to several times coming up I do want to make sure that that is something that's happening I know early on maybe last
283year there was extensive meetings constant communication um the superintendent Diego pre and others were constantly meeting with the community I think as we start coming up to this summer I am still getting a lot of questions from parents so to the extent that we can adopt the same posture of overc communicating I think it's helpful as they start navigating this unusual transition and really selling the vision that we have for both sides and then one question that I received a lot of relates to the power outages last week so a lot of parents were asking us if we've implemented all these solar panels and all these sustainable Investments why is it that the schools don't have the ability to rely on some of that power and use it and I my understanding it's a complicated
284answer to that both budgetary state laws and other issues but I think I would love to get a better sense of why that's the case especially now with the new bus fleet conception whether or not there's some way to take the fact that we've installed all these solar panels over the past year is there some way that that can be then fed into either backup generators some other type of support some other usage piece on that and then lastly related to the power outage the communications again we've had to deal with tsunami warnings and power outages and a lot of fun things in the short you know last 30 days but in that process some parents expressed frustration that while we did a good job of trying to communicate in a timely manner they were
285told their children need to be picked up at 11:15 a.m. at 11:15 a.m. and it wasn't immediately clear maybe that they had a longer window but it just we got a lot of upset responses from folks understanding we were dealing with that situation but it would have been nice at 10:00 to say if power is not restored by 11:00 a.m. you know your children will need to be picked up somewhere between 11:15 and we'll have adults on staff and so again not expect well actually to be H maybe we should be expecting this to be more frequent occurrence trying to figure out how we improve our protocol so that those messages are loaded ready and communicated to parents who aren't aware of the types of restrictions that we have as a district PR contracts per
286protocols um even the fact that the preschools operate on a different set of licenses different set of rules confuse a lot of parents who heard one message from the school saying your child is going to remain on site and simultaneously the pre schools saying pick up your child immediately and so I know that's kind of partly because we're operating on different systems but understandably a lot of parents were thrown out of loop when this goth this messages and whatever we can do to improve that process I think will be helpful especially if these types of climate related power outages become more regular currents um actually that did remind me of um maybe not a future agenda item but just maybe updating our the script for um public comment to kind of set expectations that for
287um people who may not be used to making public comment that um like what does it mean to have comment like on the agenda item versus non agenda items um and like our ability to respond in the moment and and such so I think maybe we can look at updating that language um so that it's um kind of at the top of every meeting and and people know what to expect so other than that I don't have anything else at this time thank you all right um um all right we will move to any board member statements um I just want to say you know for me this week um as an American as a woman as a person of color um Monday was a difficult day for me um I think a day that
288you know has been set aside to honor one of our greatest civil rights icons um Dr Martin Luther King Jr was stained um for me by a series of events um and executive actions um that represented to me what feels like um an unsettling next four years um with that in mind I wanted to take a moment to recognize um the work of super intendent Ooa uh Dr Christian rubel Caba Patrick GNE ala barera Cruz um a lot of work being done on the school sites um and many others across the district um I really appreciate the proactive work that's been done for the protection of our undocumented students across the district um and I want to thank you for that thank you um trusty how I I would that um that sentiment in whole
289um I think um yeah I think it is unsettling to see like a lot of the protections um and progress that we've made you know feel like they're they're being turned back um and yeah that I think you know that's that's really difficult um for our most vulnerable populations um I wanted to you know today we had a lot of um on a sort of other note um we had a lot of commenters here today A lot of them were making comment for the first time um and I've said it in the past um but I want to extend a a big thank you to everyone who showed up and and you know made comment it takes time it takes effort um and energy and you know I think um getting feedback directly from the
290Community about things that we can do better or things that we may have overlooked uh things that we might want to take some more time to look into that's all really useful information even if we don't ultimately agree about the outcome or you know the method or anything you know any specific part um I want to also say thank you to the the team um Amy rufo and her team especially um overseeing projects of this scale across the district just take so much effort and Co coordination and um I just want to really um commend them for the for the work that's been done over the last few years that so many of our campuses um and you know it's it's really transformed the the student experience on campus like having these beautiful spaces to
291to meet in um you know upgrading from the dingy PTA closets from 30 40 years ago it's very nice and and it's just like really all in service to our students and I want to make sure that we keep that um at the Forefront obviously we want to be good neighbors and we want to um be cognizant of what what the neighbors um think about our plans and and take that into consideration and at the same time my primary um you know motivation for being on this board is like how can we make life better for all of our students um but I you know I do want to say thank you to everyone who showed up today um and for sharing your ideas thank you I just quickly want to um also thank the
292staff um for um implementing the supports and the um for our uh immigrant families and uh our students very very important uh near and dear to um the cause of being here is helping the students that we serve um and I also want to share um my highlight of the week in our um uh board partner visits it's always a pleasure and a wonderful experience to see our kids in action and watching how they are so um involved in uh very I would say feeling they look like they are part of a community when you walk in the school in in their class there's no one out of place and that is very important to see thank you I just have a few statements to piggy back on what the other trustees have already discussed
293um I I think as all the trustees Express there is a great amount of concern in the community about what the coming weeks coming years are going to hold for them and so I do want to reiterate that understanding I I appreciate it for example that Sano County Board of Education president Torres uh superintendent went out and made a statement reiterating their Sanctuary policies as Kathy raised in the smia report I do think that our district should refresh and take a second look at our own policies and maybe reaffirm them in this time and as I've discussed previously back in 2017 I was working in the LA educational system when a similar chilling effect was happening and it wasn't that parents would come and tell us you know I'm concern about my kids or my
294family or you know someone following my kids home to investigate our families uh they just didn't come to school and so to the extent that we can be mindful of tracking any rise and absences any spikes we see any forwarded what that miscommunication misinformation reports that I will be on a campus just based on speculation I think to the extent that our District staff is tracking that that our community Specialists and others are in the nail about it I think it's helpful and all the Community Partners that we worked with but whatever we can do to again reaffirm our commitment within our power to really protect our family something I would want to reiterate I think Monday similarly was mixed feelings for me but one thing that was really great and one I would do
295want to call out I have the opportunity to be at the Sano Cal train station with the Sano chapter of the NAACP with our supervisor Noelia Coro and then also sponsored the MLK celebration train sponsored by calet or Cal train that we took up to the march in San Francisco hosted by the norel MLK foundation and I think a lot of the speakers a lot of the community that came out the faith leaders and Community leaders really reiterated this idea that the movement is continuing on in a lot of the work that we do and so I'm again proud to always be a part of a community in a district that's constantly trying to do the best for our children for our families and trying to be brave in uncertain times and really push forward
296the vision that Dr King and so many others have always had for our country and for our community um I also want to piggy back on what Kathy said uh thank the California Teachers Association and SMA for inviting me to their breakfast um and I think that was a good conversation setting for us to have really candid conversations about things that we can't always talk about in the board meeting type place and so you know as trusty Watkins than I did last year continuing to build that relationship and talk just as Citizens as you know people concerned about our students in our country I think it's a great space to have so again I welcome more opportunities than all the trustees do to have those types of conversations ongoing um and again always appreciate all
297that are Educators and staff for doing related to these particular issues uh like President Brooks I did want to thank basite Academy that hosted us for our campus visit I had a chance to be there with several of our high school trustees with several members from Sano police department and from the city and it was great as always to see that on site also to have a chance to tour the campus and see the new construction and also some of the issues that were raised today um and then lastly I want to Echo with vice president Tren said I always think it's um amazing in our community how many parents our community members will come out and take the time to engage with us and whether they're upset or happy or supporting something or against
298something I know how unusual it is to take that time on a Thursday evening to be out here late at night to take that time away from family to come present those views to be recorded in public and in the public record it's very intimidating it's something that I understand doesn't come naturally but our community cares about these types of issues and the fact that we have a community that's so engaged and does care I think is just always something that's a sign of strength for the work that we're doing here at the same time I do want to emphasize something that I think our previous trustees used to always say is that there are a lot of families that don't have the time to come out here that don't have the resources don't have
299the language skills and so to the extent that we're also trying to reach those families those parents and also Center their perspectives because it's not always the people who have the privilege in time to come out on Thursday evening there are a lot of community members that are impacted by the decisions that we make and again I think that's something the board the staff here does exceptionally well but I know especially in the coming months and years I think could be more important than ever so I appreciate everything that our team does to make sure that's always a part of guiding the work that we do here on the board thank you all right we will move to to talk to announce uh future meeting dates um our next study session will be held on
300February 13th um math K through 8 uh and March 13th for early literacy and our regular board meetings are February 27th and March 27th and with that we will now uh close I think we have to take public comment oh yes uh Joe can you please see if oh I'll do in person uh public comment first are there anyone in the audience who would like all right Joel can you please check to see if anyone online would like to make public comment yes checking no public comments on Zoom at this time all right we will recess the close session Susie you're in the public you might want to e e e welcome back to the uh Foster City uh regular school board meeting um we will be reporting out for item 14a and close session
301the board by unanimously vote decide to hear an appeal of an investigation decision for item 14 C the majority of the board voted 4 zero to approve um a compromise agreement in office of administrative hearing case number 202 411 0564 to resolve claims between the district and student by providing a 30-day transition period with support services and funding for an independent education evaluation not to exceed $88,500 item 14d the majority of the board of the board voted 4 Z the board unanimously voted to approve a compromise agreement with parents of a student to resolve potential and threatened claim against the district in exchange for funding of an alternate program for student during the 2425 school year item 14e the board voted 40 to approve a compromise agreement in office of administrative hearing case number 202
30241106 6 to9 to resolve claims against the district in exchange for a total not to exceed 35,000 in Fund in funding for students private education services and a total not to exceed 177,000 in attorney's fees item 14f the majority of the board voted for zero to approve comp um compromise agreement with parents of student to resolve special education claims against the district including compensatory education service and attorney's fees in exchange for a waiver of special education claims to date items 14g a majority of the board voted for zero to approve uh compromise agreement and office of administrat and and excuse in office of administrative hearing case number 20241 0642 resolve claims raised against the district by providing funding of $1,684 for a students's educational expenses and compensatory education which has been incurred and or will
303incur during the 20 22 to 2023 to 2023 to 2024 and 2024 to 2025 school years and with that that concludes my report out and if I can have a motion to adjourn motion to adjourn second all in favor say I I I right this meeting is over at 11:56 11:56 we will during this meeting