CorpusRecord 106603

SMFCSD Regular Board Meeting - December 12, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / SMFCSD Board of Trustees
Date
2024-12-13
Location
San Mateo County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
28,350 words · about 158 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001hi everyone say thank you trusty Brooks for the motion and trusty say I by okay um item 3A public statements related to non-agenda topics the samto Foster City School Board cannot act on any matter that has not been included and publicly posted on the agenda except under limited circumstances as permitted by law the board May refer matters raised in this forum to staff for investigation and or action where appropriate please limit your statements to three minutes I have some cards here I'll call but if anyone else has anything just let me know um first we have Liz curry good evening superintendent OA and board members I'm presenting a speech I gave last year because the issues it presents have still not been addressed I am hopeful that this year a bargaining year will give the

002fourth and fifth grade teachers of this District the fair and just [Music] my name is Liz Curry and I'm a longtime monory teacher at NSM tonight I am speaking on behalf of the fourth and fifth grade teachers of our district as you know our district takes great pride in facilitating conversations and policy to enact Equity among our school Community I feel proud to be a part of a district that upholds this value and yet there remains great inequity within fourth and fifth grade classrooms as you know class size increases after the third grade a fourth or fifth grade classroom can have as many as 32 students I guess policy makers at large believe that Children's after the age of nine are easier to teach that the curriculum is easier to prepare that the students don't

003have the same academic or emotional needs as the younger students having 28 years of teaching experience I can tell you that is false I spent three years as an aid in a full day kindergarten 10 years teaching second and third grade 12 years teaching a third and fourth grade combination class and for the past five years I've been teaching a fourth and fifth grade combination class the rigors of teaching fourth and fifth graders are equal to any of the other grades kids need just as much time and attention as any of the other age levels the curriculum is more rigorous to learn and present as a teacher the essays the children write are multiple pages long and take hours to grade the emotional needs of these pre-adolescence are just as great as any kindergartner on

004top of that we fourth and fifth grade teachers spend 25 more minutes a day with students than our K3 colleagues this means while my K3 colleagues are preparing for the following day I'm still working with students therefore I'm often working much later and longer hours after school so I can prepare for the next day SMA once calculated the number of extra minutes of fourth and fifth grade teachers spends with students and it came out to be a full week of teaching beyond what our K3 colleagues are working fourth and fifth grade teachers also have six to eight more parent conferences six to eight more report cards to prepare each trimester we do all this with no added prep period something our Middle School colleagues are given please consider ways you can make the working conditions

005for fourth and fifth grade teachers and the learning conditions for fourth and fifth grade students Equitable across the district I propose that you explore lowering fourth and fifth grade class sizes this cannot be done I ask you to explore ways that fourth and fifth grade teachers can get access to a prep period within the school day have more eight time and fewer Adent duties thank you for your time and consideration next is [Applause] good evening thank you so much for letting me speak this evening superintendent board members I wanted to bring up some items about prop 28 so recently we had a meeting back on October 18 with David chamblas and we were asked to give some input and there are so many passionate teachers in this District that have a lot of ideas about

006what we can do with prop 28 funds so my first thing is to say I teach in this incredible School District I've been at Bell Middle School for 15 years I'm so proud of our music program and the whole entire District um I'm so grateful for the ptas across the district to the Ed foundation for what they do for us and then we find out we get all this extra money and what do we get to do with it and so the thing that came up in the session is how do we go above and beyond how do we become a great School District that can be superior how do we get to the next level and I believe it's through the 28 funding so the first thing that we started coming up with were

007are things like what about art programs for the elementary schools what do we do at that level to get more access for the kids and what about music programs like sure it starts in fifth grade what if it started in fourth grade so our minds are just reeling with what ifs and what are the possibilities um I I'm active with the California music educator Association I go to a lot of conferences and so they give us a lot of literature about how we collaborate so I think the main thing is we want to help develop an expenditure plan and help come up with the ideas one of our concerns is that we might be running out of measure V funds but that prop 28 is not supposed to be used for that it's supposed to

008go above and beyond yes we are blessed with so many extra music teachers and resources like I said ptas Ed foundation and all this but when I'm looking through this packet I'm seeing things like Parts education program includes but is not limited to instruction and training supplies materials and arts educational Partnerships programs for instruction and dance media arts Music Theater Visual Arts just so much more and I just I get ideas I get really excited about this all funds must be used to provide expanded Arts education programs so I think the thing I just want to share is that I and all the other teachers in the district want to be part of the conversation we want to help develop the plans we want to be we are already great we want to see how

009we can become Superior with prop 28 funding thank you so much hi thank you for uh giv this opportunity to speak sorry about my hat I'm both in dire need of a haircut and starting to lose my hair so I can't decide what to do um uh so I uh also want read was saying about this being a great place to work and I want to thank you guys for the time that you dedicate to supporting us and letting people come just talk at you every two weeks because I know that's a lot um I think that the the connection I'm going to make with what lean was saying is that I feel like as teachers we want to feel like we're connected to the decision- making process that's happening up here um because it

010has such a big effect on us and it's really hard to make those connections but teaching really is all about Connections it's our connections with our students it's the connections between teachers and it is difficult to feel connected to the decisions that are getting made when we're usually hearing about them kind of after the fact um and sometimes it's a little things like the U air purifiers disappearing over Thanksgiving break and then teachers coming back going but it's cold and flu season why did you take my air purifier and other times it can be big things like at the end of last school year uh the district used to have two science toses that were a huge part of their being a connected cohesive science department districtwide um and they both got reassigned one of

011them had been the science tosa for our district for over a decade um and this wasn't what I was going to talk about initially but I went to Abbot middle school yesterday where from 2 to 4 he gave away a lifetime of the artifacts of his Science teaching career in preparation for moving to Minnesota because when he didn't take the classroom job he was offered by our district he elected um to look for other District level positions and hasn't found something yet so he's moving to Minnesota um and when I think about people I had a connection to in our school district he's the first guy who introduced me to someone as one of our Master Teachers where I felt Pride because he respected what I did he spent more time in my classroom as

012a district employee than anyone else uh even if I count up every other person who's ever visited he was a guy who was in our classrooms connected to us and we got rid of him um as like an oversight you know the department heads from the science departments weren't asked do we need tosa support I know because I'm a department head of the science department of North sheview the big joke was I'm a department of one but we have department meetings for a decade there have been no department meetings this year because there isn't a department without somebody at the district level um and you know the the need for connection and support as someone who spends their whole day giving connection and support to other people our students is real you know it's important

013to feel like you're part of a hole and it just gets hard to feel that when there's these you know Nicks and cuts uh sorry I also have an issue with running on so I'm going to try to come to an ending point um there's reason I had planned on coming today was that about uh toses generally we have a lot of toses not science toses but math toses who aren't apparently allowed to work with students they're were hired as coaches um and I think coaching is great I just finished advocating for having someone whose role was a science coach there was one of him for our whole District we have one person per site as in the in the math posted position and they're not supposed to be pulling groups of students as I

014understand it um they're supposed to be coaching the teachers who were there but we're professionals we have often multiple credentials and Decades of experience we don't necessarily need someone who can only coach and limiting their ability to support students in the way that the teachers at their sites want them to whether it's by pulling students or meeting with groups while the teacher in the classroom just doesn't seem to make sense to me um so the last thing that I was going to say is that another way that we could all try to connect is if we could get more District people coming to classrooms to just hang out and if uh you know make sure you're you're listening to this me rep that we they're they're our voice and um it's a challenge to try

015to get information from people ins solidated into one one channel and that's the best one we've got so thank you very much for your time and I'm sorry that was such a scattershot of different ideas but we really appreciate the time that you you give to our school district thank you is there any other public comments on non-agenda items in this room okay can we check on Zoom please is this working okay is there anyone on Zoom is there anyone when okay we'll be louder um moving on to 3B public statements related to agenda items persons will be called on at the appropriate time so we'll go to item 3C which is foundation committee and PTA Council reports we start with ED Foundation hi and good evening everyone um I just wanted to come and

016introduce myself my name is Karina wilhelms I'm the new executive director of Sano Foster City Education Foundation I [Applause] um a little about myself I am a mom of our district I have three boys I have one at fiesto one at Burell one currently at toale I think our kids play football together get the soccer team together so um I know a lot of people in our community I'm just like a DieHard public education fan um I've also had kids at like Park preschool a kid that went to Sunny break for TK a kid that went through Abbot so I feel like I've somehow touched a number of schools in our district um and I'm really passionate about equity in our district too and um I really wanted to make the jump from kind of

017like a corporate leadership development Consulting background into nonprofit work and um I've been the PTA president of the EST Gardens I'm currently the PTA president of barell so this new job is like a melding of my skills and passions that I'm really excited about and just wanted to say hello and um I'm glad to be here and I'm excited for the work that we'll get to do together and while I'm here I'm going to give a little plug for the readathon no one's thinking about the readathon yet except Colleen and because we're all in like parenting teacher Christmas mode but come January we get when we get back from break we will be like hitting the Pedal Gas Pedal on Rita on it'll be January 24th to February 7th and we'll be sending out a

018lot of communications so look for that thanks so [Applause] much um do we have anyone from PTA Council maybe on [Music] Zoom okay I don't see anyone else from P I was just going to say um thanks to everyone who came on Sunday this past Sunday to prepare readon materials there was a lot of stickering and bookmark counting and postcard stamping and um it just takes a lot of work behind the scenes to set this up and so um I want to rec other this okay I don't there's any item 3D SM CA and smfc upates good evening T trustees I'm going to keep it very brief tonight because I don't have a lot to report but uh SMA is looking forward to welcoming our new school board member that I will be having in

019the next hour or two um and also we want to uh it's been a yearly tradition that cta's Golden Gate service center is holding a Schoolboard breakfast um for all the trustees and at and trustees around the area um after tonight's appointment I'm going to send out an invite but I'll let you know right now that that event is going to be held on Saturday January 9th um from 9:00 to noon uh there'll be other spea me there'll be SMA members there and our CA president David Goldberg will be giving a keynote and there'll be uh other school board members from around the peninsula as well and San Francisco so we look forward to look forward to getting our uh formal invite in the next say 24 hours and what else SMA is currently surveying

020our members in preparation for negotiations um for Collective Bing agreement next year and other than that I really have nothing else to report I'm wishing everybody a happy holiday season and a relaxing winter break thank you they on Zoom um I don't see them on Zoom don't see them on Zoom they almost made it then we can go to oh I'm sorry I do see them Joe that makes me sad um I'm gonna be even briefer than Kathy um I just the you'll notice that the 2023 2024 reclassifications are on your agenda this evening we are really happy about that so I just wanted to um once again thank the reclass committee um for Recon and making that happen and I also just wanted to say that their feedback was very much appreciated and very

021kind and um yeah that's all I've got hope everyone enjoys their break thank you okay now you choose people are going H good evening members of the board superintendent and all of you joining us this evening for those of you who don't know me I'm Doug GIS I'm the principal at oton school in Foster city um last night we had our oton students participating in the script spelling be um a special thank you president Proctor for being one of the judges we had over 50 students participate in the Junior and senior spelling bees and our spelling be Champion is a student who taught me the real meaning of of perseverance he's been participating in the spelling feed for many years he's never made it very far in fact last year he went out in one

022of the early rounds yet he never gave up and he always stayed positive I want to spend a special shout out to Aman our spelling be Champion we're proud of you and all of our spelling be participants as we prepare for the winter break and on the behalf of the smfc administrators Association I want to take a moment to celebrate our wonderful Sano Foster City team thank you to the students who are proving yourselves to be dedicated Learners who strive for kindness I recognize that being a student is not easy and sometimes you feel overwhelmed and sometimes you make mistakes but just like a man you consistently step up to the challenge we celebrate your accomplishments and want you to know that you Inspire us every day and thank you to our families for everything

023that you do at home to support your students and our staff your partnership is key in all the accomplishments we have achieved already and will achieve in the future I want to thank our classified staff being an administrator of a front row seat to the the diversity of classified positions that support our students and teachers from the the office team to maintenance operations and custodial team from Food Services to technology and all the par Educators who provide Educational Services as li like Library PMT Annex special education and more daily you make a difference in the lives of our students and we truly could not do our jobs without you I want to thank our teachers our tosas counselors special educ special who continue to hone your craft and aim to increase better outcomes for all

024students when challenges arrive you meet them head on when students need a caring adult even if they don't know it you are there you dive through the data and build systems of support you engage you encourage you inspire you are our heroes superintendent Ooa board members and District leaders leadership thank you for setting a vision of achievement equity and wellness and supporting us on this journey we are truly stronger [Applause] together everybody the principal school be here with you this year at Festa Gardens has been a season of growth and transition we're thankful it's where you were at last month District leadership and everyone in our community with a continued support and encouragement as we progress on this journey tonight I a few of the important developments this year we are excited to have a

025Restort of Justice TOA on staff we're especially grateful for the training and professional development for our leadership and our School site to make sure that our school May fully develop as one of the first elementary schools soon wtk at Sano Foster City School District to fully integrate restorative practices into our system having a restorative Focus fits into our objective of following the Community Schools initiative and providing support for the whole CH further along with our commitment to our students our focus on Community Schools also drives us to support our parents in their growth and their education this year we had over 40 parents graduate participate and graduate in the p parent education program which we have been hosting on Tuesday nights we look forward to beginning our second round of P classes soon after we

026get back from M of break we're also proud to have our first sixth grade class on campus our DU toses a new role split our two sixth grade teachers are working along with Administration to develop the progress and growth of our program I look forward to hosting our first seventh grade class next year and soon we will have a robust tk8 bilingual program we are also currently preparing for a campus transition we will be able to provide more support to our soon to be six to eth grade students this year has been a time of preparation for that transition all of this demonstrates the commitment of San Matel Foster City School District the bilingual education and I am proud to announce that last year in partnership with other bilingual schools in the district and the

027multilingual uh Pro uh Department J Gardens hosted the first San Foster City School District bilingual pathway award ceremony this year we will expand this ceremony to include not only the bu bilingual participation award but also the prestigious bilingual attainment award thank you once again the board superintendent OFA s City School District leadership and everyone in our community for your continued support and for making this all possible [Applause] um we'll go on to item 3E announcements to do a quick shout out regarding the um B event that the district put on on this past Saturday it at aach was really incredible there were lots of um lots of kids and families and attendance thank you particularly too F and Susie Riley and everyone else who worked on that event um we actually biked me and my

028kids and a friend and my mom actually biked from our house to beach park which I thought was going to be two and a half miles it was really like four over four miles so we made it like barely but um over 8 and a half miles um round trip and like they did great so um but it was really nice to have all these Partners um you know hunting out helmets and locks and the kids were really excited about these lights that go on your wheel um but it was just like a really great Community event and I know it was a lot of work to put together so thank you so much um I will announce that although I couldn't make it to the bike event because I was stuck in Anaheim everyone

029up here we all went to the CP conference um was that last week yes I got sick there apparently um so we went to csba conference in Anaheim and um got to attend multiple different sessions about just being a Schoolboard member and what how we can help our school district be even better and got some time to attend some happy hours and dinners and um it was great so just wanted to say well you were all here we were there and um hope to be able to bring some of those ideas back to our district in addition you heard that I was the spelling at the spelling be at Aon um just putting it out there that I love um judging spelling bees I'll be at about January I'm on the circuit I encourage my

030um my colleagues to if you get a chance it's it's really wonderful to see the students who they're very nervous they prepared they're very very smart um at Aon they asked the students are there any last minut last questions like we just went over the ruls any questions and this one student said um yes is it too late to back out but she and then she went very very far she did great and so I think they are so nervous but they're so cute and they're so smart and they prepared and it's just awesome to be part of it so don't steal my um myell go get your we'll go on to the superintendent report thank you president Proctor um first starting off with our experience at csba um was able to attend um a

031couple of really important workshops one focused on three different stories from school districts throughout California that are built Workforce housing very powerful to sit and hear um school board members talk about the journey that their districts have gone through to accomplish building Workforce housing and each one was a totally different story and um every Community is different so it's just really powerful to be in a space like that where you're able to hear an example from Orange County an example from Fresno County and an example from um the bay area but all just in one place and to be able to ask those questions um on the last day of the conference I was able to attend a workshop uh that was actually led by all students there was um four email high school students

032from San beradino Unified School District who serve on their board as student trustees and I know that uh potentially our incoming president um Brooks has been talking about uh involving our students at the board level uh since she joined the board a couple of years ago I say three but you say two years because it's this was the third time you attended csba but just to to hear their examples um actually Theo you would have been funny if you were there but their uh middle school and elementary school council has called empowering student voices as well um with no coordination but I think they they had a vision to bring kids in early and build up their leadership skills um and uh and I think it's a very similar path to the one that we're

033on in terms of of to give these teenagers access to speak publicly have growth opportunities um and at the end of the event we asked um you know what interest they might have in running for elected office you know serving on on a school board and uh one of the the students said I will be the governor of California in 30 years and then the student seated next her whose last name is also CH and a relationship she said I will be the presid of the United States in 2044 I like kids with a plan signing up to support their campaigns 30 years in advance but just just a powerful example of what kids can do if you really um give them a lot of license so that was first second um huge thanks and

034congratulations to Karina with the new role with the foundation I can't let it go without also in Colleen and the time you spent um in the bridge between losing Sanja and all the work you did we're working together with one of our partners on a really big Grant application right now and it's going pretty well we feel good about where we are um we hope to be able to come to the board with an update sometime um in early spring but just a lot of work on Karina's part and a lot of collaboration with colle um in order to get there um Susie's in the audience so I wanted to publicly acknowledge Susie we had a team here uh from the commission on teacher induction uh that uh really does a very very thorough exhaustive

035site visit for Teacher induction programs our district hosts our own teacher induction program um and there are many that don't there are many that provide the service through the county so choosing to offer a program it's a lot of work and it's a lot of coordination um Susie Riley LED this process for the last six months um and just did a stellar job I attended the um closing ceremonies where where we got to hear their report um verbally they did share with us that they anticipate giving us a seven-year accreditation with a with a review which is an excellent accreditation and that Still Remains to be seen because it has to go to the commission and they vote on it so it's at this point it's a recommendation but every single person on their team

036spoke to Susie's quality and caliber and her um politeness ethics and we see it every day but it's just really great when other people can remind you about that kind of thing so congratulations um we have H an event that we started hosting few years ago and this year we held it last weekend on the same day as the bike event so you may have passed by the event on your way on your Eight Mile hear that story of how it got four miles but um it's called Fiesta op and it was created years ago to um invite families from nor Central Sano from the sunny bra neighborhood the Park neighborhood the Laural neighborhood to learn about our magnet programs to encourage them um to think about our magnet programs and to apply and so

037um the first year was you know we did our best and we tried a little hard and it was fun we had about 120 families attend that first year which we were just really uh jazzed about and last weekend we had over 500 people attend our um and uh we had 60 early registrations we had 60 applications to magnet schools in this District uh parksite College nor viewa Gardens um about 80% of the of the participants um are served or live in the park Laurel the sunny or in our Central Sano so we really landed on a strategy that has succeeded in in getting the word out to our families and most importantly when they show up we have employees who all volunteer to work on a Saturday um and they sit with families and

038they help them fill out every form to make sure that it's submitted and completed on the spot so there's no waiting another week and hoping it gets turned in when they leave it's it's complete um and then there are others who show up with an eight-month old and say we want to know when we can get on the weight list to we still have those parents out there too and we're excited about them in four years and with that I'll pass it back to you thank you um moving on to the proposed consent agenda all items on the consent agenda are considered by the board to be routine and will be enacted by the board in one Motion in the form listed below there will be no discussion on these itemsi the time the board

039votes on the motion unless members of the board staff or public request specific items be removed and discussed from the consent agenda superintendent and staff recommend approval of all consent items movement of any recomend rended recommended consent item is appropriate at this time items that anyone would like to remove see um anyone in the room here in um that would like to remove any items from the consent agenda anyone on zoom two speakers this is for the proposed consent agenda we have the speak [Applause] uh anise please go ahead they have to start over yeah [Music] it's we're gonna move on so um anyone like to make a motion I'll motion second thank you trusty Brooks for the motion trusty k for a [Music] second we are now moving on to item 5 a interview

040and selection of candidates for pro provisional appointments to the Board of Trustees um we are gonna go let just and we can all decide if this is all right with you but I was I was thinking we could just go in order of what's on the agenda give everyone like five to sevenish minutes to speak just freely tell us what you want us to know we'll ask some questions and then move on to the next candidate does sound okay with up here okay and then if there's followup we'll deal with that but let's start with Diana Harris um I'm G choose theol people go back and for all right good evening everybody uh reflecting on my Journey here I keep coming back to the importance of and power of community my husband and I grew

041up here he and S tale and I in Berling game and we moved to Southern California for work in grad school when it was time to start our family though we knew we had to get out of there and come back to San Mato because it was the perfect Community for us my journey in the district began at bage middle school and coming from teaching in a rural area near Riverside that was predominantly next Foster City was a culture shock um however as I taught and formed connections with students and families I discovered what makes Foster City such an outstanding Community I had never received so much support as a teacher and truly began to appreciate the power of the H School connection and I'm fortunate to still be in touch with many of my

042students from those days I love how seeing them even as a 12 and 13 year olds I could see glimpses of the amazing well-rounded people they would become Beyond teaching I began to know the district from a parents perspective my son attended two District preschools samil park with Miss Amy and Miss DOA and Turnbull with Chen lashan and both preschools provided engaging and enriching activities that helped Foster my son's love of learning for elementary school it was a tough decision but we chose Meadow height our neighborhood school um you really can't be a one block commute uh I started summing there and instantly fell in love with the school Community the ptaa was active and welcoming the staff were warm and provided the structure that my kids needed to thrive and there was a diverse

043Community with many opportunities to get to know other families and soon I found myself teaching first grade while serving as PTA president like most of us yeah um over the years I've worn many hats I've been a teacher a parent sub student teacher which is very different from a regular teacher parent educator and volunteer and these roles help me develop the ability to explain the reasoning behind school and District decisions to families that are new to navigating the school system I often found myself acting as a bridge between parents and staff helping each side better understand the others perspective because I've experienced so many roles I have a deeper appreciation of how District decisions Schoolboard decisions affect students and staff in the classrooms to illustrate this let me tell you about my most memorable school

044year which may be a memorable year for many of you in this room the year we return to in-person learning I had 23 first graders some of whom were entering a business musical classroom for the very first time among them were several SBC students um many English Learners a few newcomers to the country and children dealing with anxiety and fears about getting sick while academics are important I quickly realized that creating a safe space and fostering Community were the top priorities growth mindset quickly became a theme in our classroom and the children celebrated each other's strs and supported one another in the most heartwarming ways and I've carried many lessons from that year with me we all have different strengths and by coming together we can support each other in the best ways possible as

045my son transitioned to Abbott Middle School a couple years ago I took the opportunity to substitute teach and volunteer there getting firsthand insight into the state of the school I was delighted to share with parents the sign significant progress being made under Mr Belzer's leadership first in school safety then culture and then an academic rigor this experience allowed me to support the school and contribute to the community in a uniquely meaningful way I've also been unofficial PR for Abbot middle school for a number of years although I'm a pretty phenomenal teacher many of my strengths can serve our students beyond the classroom and that's why find myself here I love our community deeply and my calling is to support the community by making the biggest impact I know how if chosen to serve on the

046board my intention is to continue volunteering at our many schools so that I can gain an even deeper appreciation of our community and help us truly make the most responsible and effective decisions as a district I am the strongest candidate you won't find a candidate who knows the district as well as I do I know the current realities of the classroom I can easily relate to our certified and certificated staff and I'm already making a positive impact at multiple School sites I'm primed to be a great asset to the school board and I'm ready for this opportunity thank you um let's start with board questions can I ask um why you didn't run for this position I did not run because I love my job dearly and in order to run I would need to

047quit preemptively and then and make it go for it uh the reason why I'm here now is that through connections Colleen salivan from the Ed Foundation reached out to me and she got me thinking about how I can make a bigger impact and I touched face with Ken chin and some other people and I realized that this is my opportunity I believe in being open to possibilities and opportunities when they come because they come at the least expected times and as I began the process of filling out the applications and really thinking about it and reflecting on myself I was like oh my goodness this really is in alignment with everything I've been doing it doesn't take me out of where I am because I'm allowed to volunteer I give so much of my time

048and I love it because our children are amazing our staff are so dedicated and I get to be a little fly on the wall as I'm helping first graders with path or as I'm um doing some yard duty at at a school so yeah that's how I'm here just to be clear what's your current position that you would have to uh I let all my supervisors know uh that I may have to resign very suddenly uh I am currently the uh Lego engineering teacher at metal Heights Elementary teaching kindergarten through fifth grade I also work for the district as a Lego lead and um supporting other programs because uh additional training is needed for teachers to become comfortable with the with the Lego lab I am also a mentor teacher for a new teach at

049s Park and oh yeah and in the spare time that I have I am a par educator assisting in a first grade classroom at metal Heights OH thanks again so my question for you given your long history with s bity school district can you name one or two decisions that the board has made during your time that you were involved in District that you disagreed with and what you would have done differently had you been on the board at the time that I disagreed with oh my goodness I was prepared to say things that I wasn't a fan of I think it's not so much board decision that I have disagreed with it's more had to do with implementation I know that um the district does its best at these higher levels to make the

050best decisions however I've seen them in the classroom and so sometimes we get opportunities like the Lego grant that we were able to get which is phenomenal boxes of thousands of dollars of equipment just started showing up but Although our science tosa was phenomenal in gathering resources we just weren't ready to get up and running the only reason why um my school was able to do it is because the PTA was willing to um pay for a part-time teachers and so I was in a very fortunate position however it would have been nice in making decisions to think about what the roll out is what speed is appropriate and constantly check in with the with the different stakeholders and teachers and everybody to see if they're moving at a rate that is realistic because we

051had so many other priorities as we're getting more effective curricula into the classrooms that understandably it came at the bottom of that list I totally get it and I teach it and I love it but um I just think that I can bring a perspective that can point out these other things so we're just more mindful when making such decisions thank you um through the duration of your um time here in the district you name a time where it was incredibly challenging for you and how you overcame it well to be honest the roughest experience I had was um when I was teaching first grade and our school population was going down because of the numbers they had to cut a teacher and I was going to be that teacher I had offers to go

052back to teaching middle school science over at bage and I seriously considered it but as you heard in my speech I am committed to the communities that I'm in and I love those kids and those families so much that I would rather volunteer than um leave and so it it was a tough decision and then the PTA found this Lego opportunity for me and I like to think other other campuses have benefited from it because I am not a gatekeeper I share whatever knowledge and wealth I have so sorry I still get a little teary because I I loved it so much thank you so much for your you know dedication to our community um I wanted to ask you know you have listed here Mar's needing Improvement and um I think you know it's

053um you know we' talked about like literacy we've done so much at the elementary level and or at you know sort of at the beginning of the career and um I know there's always work to to be that right um and so I I I really appreciate your feedback on on that aspect of you know things that we need to improve um outside of curriculum um like instruction from an operational perspective is there anything that you um can think of that the district could do more on as well well with our declining enrollment for various re some which are out of our control as people move away for jobs and stuff like that but I feel that the district can make more efforts to both Recruit new families who live in our neighborhoods blocks away

054from Fantastic schools and people who are in the schools but feeling like their needs aren't met and so they're switching to private school I am out there talking to families reassuring them telling them about the good things that are happening because they are mostly looking at Great Schools um which is not portray an accurate picture of our our school and the opportunities that we provide we' made big strides especially with Diego Perez and his um push on social media and communication and that has been great but we also need to build more inres towards the preschools we need to really make the people who feel like their children aren't being challenged enough feel heard and point out some of the other things that they are learning even if academically not challenged they are learning how

055to work with people who are different from them people who come from different backgrounds and that is one of the most important life skills there is and I just think sometimes people need to be reminded of the world Beyond pushing your your child to be the strongest academic learner they can be I had another question did okay um so just kind of like looking at where we are today and looking forward what are some of the biggest issues you think facing our school school district and how do you think you could be part of the um path I one of the big things that is um a focus in the district right now is restor of Justice uh I have seen it and heard um of how well it it's being implemented at different levels

056and really um I feel like we should offer in information sessions to the community some people they understand it on a certain level but then what they hear from their children and and teachers in practice it doesn't seem to match up and that could be because we are learning we're growing people are getting trained right now we have just implemented restive justice tosas but along that process we need to Loop more people in because then that way we get more buyin and as we have more buyin there'll be supportive conversations at home they'll the kids will be more familiar with the processes that they're going through and it should make the whole thing a little smoother um for everybody involved I was going to ask something similar to what president proor asked but I guess

057the way I phrase it now is if you you're funding a bandwith ored issue and 12 months from now you want to say these are the three things you accomplished as a new trustee what would those three things be I'm reing W an issue within within reasonable liit okay I would want us to make it so that it wasn't possible for a child to be in a combination class more than one year in a row granted monor is not among that because that's a completely different structure but um I've seen how successful and how challenging combination classes can be and when a child has that experience experience sometimes there are setbacks if they keep having that year after year we're chipping away a little bit at their opportunities to really have a rich experience in

058the classroom I would suggest that we try to be more intentional with that um I would also encourage us to reopen the possibility of people requesting to go to schools that are not magnet schools when you have people opting into a school they are more invested they are more willing to work with the school for their child's success and if parents really want their child there and it's not even an option to try to apply it's very discouraging and sometimes they will just say you know I can apply to private school somehow St Gregs will cram another child into that classroom but in general making smaller class size it's such a huge difference I have taught classes that have 32 kids I taught classes that have 24 kids the numbers don't seem that different but

059you need that oneon-one time just like they they spoke about earlier and so I would do everything I could to ensure that our kids are getting the attention they need from their teacher their teacher should know them as well as possible and have that strong connection and we can only do that that when it's a manageable size and when these kids are given the opportunity to be with the correct group there any other questions thank you so much don't leave thank you guys for listening um next is Stacy h good evening president Proctor trustees superintendent Ooa and members of the community um to quote that student from udon um is it too late to pull out just kidding I want to take the opportunity to introduce myself my name is Stacy ho I am a

060Northshore view parent that good nor representation earlier today and I've been an educator for 17 years in both public and private schools across the bay area I started my career as a middle school counselor in the Oakland Unified School District actually when um David champas was a middle school principal in Oakland and I have since worked in a number of different schools but today serving as director of College counseling and academic advising at Pacific Bay Christian School in Pacifica in my schools I have leadership positions in the areas of school Improvement and diversity and inclusion I've been parts of teams that turned struggling schools and to schools of choice and good schools into Great Schools all with the power of data research-based practices deep understanding of the community that we served and a lot of

061blood spite with tears seriously even blood um I can say this because I literally thrown myself into the middle of a fight before to break it up and if you're wondering how I did that as a petite Asian-American woman uh my hot tip is to take down the smaller one it is one of my my life's callings to promote access and equity in any space that I enter in my 17 years I have had the privilege of working with a diverse range of students in terms of sex race disability religion age learning difference socioeconomic background language and national origin I believe that that diversity has uniquely prepared me to to understand and serve the range of students and families that we serve here in Sano and Foster City my work in both public and private

062spaces has taught me so many lessons one of which is that no Community is a monolith some people think that I may saw my hardest cases in Oakland yes there I did support students there experiencing the Foster system teenage pregnancy and houselessness but at my current private school I serve a population that's almost a quarter of first generation college students and recently I helped refugees from the war torn countries of the Ukraine and Myanmar navigate the American college up system similarly the Sano Foster City School District is not a monolith people will look afar from afar and say wow Sano Foster City schools are fantastic and we are um but they don't pull back the curtain and realize that we still have students who can't read in the second grade can't access algebra in middle

063school and are experiencing insecurity around food housing and basic everyday living expenses I'd like to share one of the target areas I would like to focus on and given the opportunity to serve as a trustee and honestly even if I'm not chosen I'm grateful for this platform to at least bring up an issue that I'm passionate about as we all know we have a significant immigrant population in the district and I see it as one of our greatest strengths our diversity and our ability to bring communities together I deeply worry about the safety of our International students immigrant communities and or undocumented students starting January 20th new immigration or travel policies could be enacted as early as January 20th and educational institutions around the country are already urging students to account for the possibility of

064delays or other issues when applying for new entry visas Mass deportations could change the very fabric of our district and the strength that we celebrate in my daily role as a college counselor we are navigating whether or not to counsel undocumented students whether or not they should fill out their FAA I honestly can't believe the words coming out of my mouth when I tell students that they should consider not applying for need-based financial aid decisions like this are difficult when it feels like it's a no- win situation but their safety is Paramount to me similarly the safety of every single one of our children in our district is one of our greatest responsibilities I want them to be able to sit in their classrooms and that their biggest worry be if they can turn in

065their homework on time not wondering if they'll lose everything they know because fear of deportation last but not least I want to say that I'm excited for the trustee board tonight because all the candidates are highly qualified I know this because I read your all's essays you have done amazing things in education and law and in your communities I see demonstrated in your essays wonderful capability ability and strength and I feel honored frankly to be single selected among the four who are being considered tonight I also want to recognize the passing of Christina L May her memory be a blessing thank you for your thank you so much um questions I can start off with by same one um why didn't you run my disposition um if I'm being perfectly honest um the whole election

066and campaigning thing is just really intimidating um it's something that I've always thought about and considered but I was like H that's so scary and really what what pushed me this time was you know um if I can speak freely is you know the I've been bolstered by the results of our presidential election um and I really feel as as a citizen that um and as an educator I want to do whatever that I can to protect the students in our district that include my two [Music] children and other school districts um if you can um please share a ccum of um I think one of my greatest challenges if I'm again being honest I'm I'm known for being very quickly honest um is when I actually made a transition my first transition from public

067schools to private schools um you know I was working in the Oakland Unified School District and then I moved over to a private school because they paid for and um when I was there and I was serving the students I was really I had a really hard time navigating just the vast disparity of access to resources um and opportunities for students um I you know I remember so clearly when you know I was working in Oakland Public Schools I would have students come to my office and this is when I was a a high school counselor I would have students who again you know were facing food insecurity and could not even pay the reduced lunch fee at that time and I know every you know meals are all free now but that was was

068at the time and you know I as a result had just like a drawer that I would keep food in and you know non- perishable food and I would give it to students who told me that they were hungry right and then I moved over to a private school and literally within my first week I had a student in my office in my memory sobbing because their parent when when the student turned 16 didn't buy them a new car but bought them a used car I was like what what am I doing here um and really ever since I've moved over to working in private schools and and my role as a college counselor is primarily found in private schools you know I've really been looking for opportunities to you know kind of almost make

069to achieve Equity again even in my professional life right and I've been doing that by participating in a lot of different organizations that you know have to do with diversity inclusion um at all of my schools but um that was definitely one of the hardest moments for me like why am I here why am I really doing this like you have car I'm going to ask a slightly different question than previously so I guess one of the things that's great about our board is that we do bring diversity up perspectives to the Das and even though typically we're able to kind of align on those it is really important to us that what we bring in also helps to kind of diversify the viewpoints perspectives that we have I guess what either views experiences background

070do you feel that you bring that we would bring as a trustee that would then add to what we have already been working on collectively yeah um that's a question I think one of the unique um aspects about me is actually you know what people might perceive as actually my greatest flaw but I actually think might be one of my greatest Str is that I actually work in private schools and I've worked on admissions on some of these places and I know why families are leaving I know white families are leaving their public districts not just Sano City but but everywhere and I really feel that that's a unique place to be able to address problems right you know like whenever someone loses a job right not loses a job sorry they decide to move

071on you know HR will come and interview them and it's like an exit interview like why are you choosing to leave um and where I sit is actually a front seat of having those answers right so for example I've seen people leave um or you know local public schools because of lack of after school uh it's extensive after school care right so um one of my neighbors um was going to go to one of the I don't want to like call are like which school but was going to go to one of the S City Schools ready to go very excited wanted to be part of the community and didn't get into Annex and when they were looking at other after school care options they realized the price of those after school care options was

072the same price as private school that would carry the kids longer throughout the day right and so you know so that was one reason another family you know left another I had another family and I mentioned this in my essays right um safety was a huge concern consideration um the child of a friend of ours was the victim of a hidden run at a middle school was hit by a car and surprise surprise they left they left the district right uh because they felt that their child safety was at risk every single day going to school um so I I being at this place you know I have a unique understanding of you know almost I want to say like the Lost Revenue um that our district is experiencing by families choosing for the past

073I'll go again I have a few more um I did I didn't want to question asked previously so you know we our district has gone through a lot from the pandemic to a lot of decisions we've made in terms of changes of policy let's say over the last five to 10 years are there any particular decisions that you're aware of that you disagree with that the board made and that you would have handled differently and how would you handle them I don't think I would necessarily say that I've disagreed with any decisions I think maybe I didn't always have the F picture right of of decisions that were being made um I did want to perhaps challenge you know the way that we looked at something so it's not a full disagree um so for

074example you know I mentioned this in my application um you know we were looking at you know the whole District really we we participated the Ruby Bridges walk just right um you know and the entire District gathered around you know including my students um in our school and um you know we gathered around to celebrate the memory and the legacy of a an incredible woman who was a child who had to go through kind of be Unthinkable and I think while programs like that are really great in terms of education and um helping our students understand who Ruby Bridges was and that maybe empowering them that as a child you can make a difference I do find that to be a bit performative when it comes to True diversity if we're looking really if our

075if our goals as a district are Equity wellness and achievement kids walking to school waving a purple flag doesn't doesn't do that um it doesn't you know waving flags and walking to school doesn't change the realities of black and brown communities being able to access higher education right it doesn't change it doesn't increase their Wellness well maybe a little bit gigs and steps in um and you know it it doesn't change their achievement right and so I think for me while I well I'm a counselor and I'm all about you know Feelgood moments and helping people rally around um kind of causes that are positive um I you know and feeling good about it and and seeing something that you can do that's tangible I I do question the efficacy um of of events like

076that on our lar goals sorry just to follow up on that so I know in your application you might be told the same story talking about I guess a focus you felt there was focus more on performative inclusion than on what you thought real inclusion I guess can you give examples of real inclusion policies that we do not currently practice that you would like to see practice yeah um so one of them would be for example making Algebra 1 accessible to all middle schoolers um so you know I mentioned this in Mya as well so as a in my role as a college counselor um I can tell you very very carefully right like I can lay it out you know how Algebra 1 is such a gatekeeper and in accessing high quality and highly

077selective colleges if a student doesn't have access to algebra one I'm just going to like map it out right so let's say a student takes Algebra 1 in ninth grade geometry in 10th Algebra 2 in 11th grade and pre-cal in senior year they're almost automatically disqualified from IV leagues the most selective uc's you know colleges that can potentially really open doors for communities um and so if a student is given the uh the the opportunity to be an algebra 1 in e8th grade I'm not trying to say that every single student is ready and qualified to take algebra one in but having the opportunity to do so it'll put them then on the path so that they hit calculus my year right and that is just in my opinion a very very small but major

078Improvement that could change change futures um I saw this when I was working in Oakland Unified the old school district when I was at a middle school and I was you know I worked first at a middle school called end Brewer middle school and then I worked at Oakland Technical High School and I had kids who I followed from Edna Brewer to Oakland Tech and I saw how the kids coming from my middle school were again just placed on a math track that then opened up a whole world of science like there are certain levels of physics that are again that are required by the uc's the CAL States and other highly selective colleges that could not be unlocked with without a certain math level being hit right um AP Physics could not be taken

079without AP Calculus you know and and so forth right so if a student doesn't have the right spaces for Math and this is just one example I clearly I'm very passionate about this um if they don't have access to that it really just blocks out their opportunities and so that's an example of something that I feel would be very meaningful and people wouldn't say oh Algebra 1 equals diversity but algebra one equals access and I think that is really really huge and Mak make sure that we are able to provide full opportunities for our students well thank you very much for your time and next is maram Norton can I back out too all um good evening superintendent Ooa Board of Trustees and members of the republ my name is Mariam jav haran Norton um

080I am an applicant for the Sano Foster City School District Board of Trustees for area three I want to take a few minutes to introduce myself and tell you um why I'm interested in joining the school form hoping I don't repeat too much of what was in my application um I am a dedicated supporter of our public school system and in particular our incredibly vibrant unique in diverse schools here in Sano County which they played such an important role in my life um I went to school public schools in Milbury I moved to the United States at the age of five and literally within days of moving here started kindergarten without speaking a word of English I didn't speak English my parents didn't speak English we lived in a little tiny apartment outside of the

081airport um so and it was a long road we faced a lot of challenges um but we stayed and we um I successfully completed my education in Sano County I graduate from M high school I went on to college at UC Davis I was the first in my family to go away to a four year of college right out of high school um I'm the youngest of four um and I went on to go to w school at Santa Clair University um I my husband and I um decided to move to Sano um and started our family here we've raised our three children in Sano Foster City School District um are a biracial family I'm Iran my husband is black um we chose Sano primarily because of its diversity um we felt like you know

082there's not a lot of people that look like us are mixed it's pretty unique but we felt like Sano really was just such a mix that it was the one place we felt like we could raise our children in a place where they would be treated um fairly and it really has been that way we have been here since we've been in our current home since 2009 um and we have felt at home here um each of our children have had their own interests their own challenges their own struggles throughout the years and we've had to navigate the SCH system and addressing them um and part of I think what makes my perspective a little bit unique is that I actually have two children who have completed their primary and secondary education in San they

083went to Baywood they went to Bell they went to Aragon and they're now in college and 10 years later I have a third B it was currently a big one so um you know I really have the benefit of seeing how things have panned out kind of all the ups and downs and being through it and then now I get to do it all over again um so you know it means that I've I'm still engaged I'm still committed to our um Public Schools our elementary schools and I know Middle School is just a few years years away um but I also know kind of what's to come I know Middle School I've dealt with the math situation you know all these kind of things so I feel like I have a lot to um

084add I guess to the um board um I'm also a practicing commercial real estate attorney and I know that there's a few other attorneys on the board um but you know I'm a purely transactional attorney and I really feel like I've over the years I've been practicing for a long time I have really strong problem solving skills I've learned to collaborate with diverse parties on different issues and really I'm I serve almost like inside Council to a couple of companies and so um I'm really involved in the financial aspects and the contractual aspects of what the companies are doing um so I think that um those skills are really going to be invaluable to this role um I've been really active in my children's education um starting with the about all three of them attended

085to go out preschools I've always was in the classroom um I have volunteered at and shared at all sorts of events over the years at all the schools um I've been on the PTA executive board at Burell and at Aragon um I was a theater Mom I have a kid in theater I had a kid in dance which is a lot um I had sports kids my S years of club soccer and um now my youngest is into softball so I was a Dugout mom and I'm trying to learn how to you know keep score which is like a whole other whole other thing so I've kind of I've kind of done it it all um you know and I really thought when my youngest was coming back first I thought no way in my

086son year call out preschool and I did and then I thought well we'll go back to bwood but I'm not GNA do all the things again and I did and it really it's been so fun um it's been really rewarding to get back into it I'm on the PTA executive board at Raywood now and um it's really especially postco it's been really um nice to kind of be able to give a little bit of history of a lot of the programs that kind of went away and trying to bring things back and really build up our community again and I guess I just want to emphasize that I've done all these things you know not just for my children's benefit but really for the benefit of all the families and all the children in our

087communities um over the years I've things I've seen how things changed um so many things have improved I will say since my younger kids were going through the school system you know that Outreach the inclusivity the equity that our um district has been focused on I've seen such a remarkable change um student wellness and all the extra um resources the centers that we have um in the Middle School level even in the elementary school level the restorative practices that have been adopted these are all amazing things um and you know all that being said we continue to hover our challenges um the pandemic was such a difficult time and I know that our students and our teachers and our schools and our communities are really still struggling with it and dealing with the ramifications um

088other things like I've seen how the increase in technology use is so different now um the increase in our housing costs and the living expenses for our teachers and you know the changing political climate you know impacts everybody as well um so I mean I guess my my end of all this is that you know we came here because of the diversity in our schools which is such an asset but also makes it really difficult and I see that and we've seen it over the years and to meet the needs of the kids that need that you know help with the basic foundational aspects and to meet the kids that meet the challenges um to to rise to their full potential um and really I feel like insuring Equity is means you know being able

089to reach everybody's needs which is a very difficult task um I guess let me see what else do I have to say I mean I think that our district has a lot of work to do I think that my um experience both as an immigrant myself and then now you know raising my children in the school system gives me a lot of personal understanding that I think will be helpful and I definitely have ideas based on my experience of what I think will help but I think more importantly I really have the problem solving skills the critical thinking skills research skills to kind of gather information and ask good questions and you know help make informed decisions um thank you for your time and consideration thank you very much um we'll go to questions and

090I'll just start since I have the same question how come you didn't run for the election um partly because I cannot my see myself over doing that I'm definitely not this this even this was big um so that that's part of it and um you know honestly it did come up um you know I kind of wasn't paying attention I think you know partly but it did come up when there was only one person running for our position before and when it came up it was already past the deadline to apply I don't know that I would have but to put your name in but um but when it came up like that I was kind of surprised I was like wow really like we're such a involved community and have so many involved community

091members I was surprised that there was only one person so then you know when I got those emails I kind of it sparked an interest you know and then I had a few people from different parts of life approach me and suggest like why don't you look into it you have all this experience you bring all this background and so I thought I looked at the application I was like okay if I known involved on this I don't know that's yeah thank you for being here tonight I ask my same question um similar to me I have the age Gap and the children and the other one um can you talk a little bit about your experience with the older kids and the youngest one now and challenges bed in the school district um maybe

092one just stand out the most that has yeah I mean I guess I mean I think everybody could relate to it but I think you know the pandemic was an incredibly challenging time in my household um both because I had a freshman son who was super outgoing and you know into all the things all of a sudden you know cut off from all of that I had a daughter who was a sophomore um and she's a bit more of an introvert so she actually flourished and did great and she was so self-motivated and she did wonderfully online you know she was like if I don't ever have to go back to school I'd be happy and then I had a 5-year-old who was at home doing TK online so it was you know a challenging

093time and um honestly that was when I mean I do remember coming to board meetings a few times beforehand when it involved some things that affected our school and our teachers and so forth that it was really during the pandemic that I started listening into all the board meetings and I remember thinking I would never want to be in their position because it was such a difficult time but at the same time it was really you know it was it was definitely a time where you really had you had to dig deep you know what I mean you had to dig deep into your own personal philosophies into what really mattered and how What affected you you but you really tested you to also think about other people so it was it was a trying

094time and then to come back to school was also really difficult right I was on the board of Aragon when the pandemic hit when our school shut down when we opened back up with a bunch of high school kids that were so messed up after a year and a half of being you know in their bedrooms in their beds and so it was it was really hard to improve to get people back into it and get the community built back up equally at Baywood I mean like we didn't have anybody wanted to do anything anymore you know we had all these programs half the people had never even been like the first you know auction which was like our hugest fundraiser we had we had 20 people signed up to attend the week before the

095event because half the school was gone half that was there had never been to an auction before and so it really it took a lot of work to kind of get things built back up but it feels good it feels like we're we're there so that's been nice I'm going to ask a variation of my prior question so I made this comment when I ran for the board a year ago that I feel like most people only learn their Schoolboard members names when they're angry you mentioned that you've been to a few part of board meeting been this isue for many years so A variation on things you would change I guess what moments as a parent were you angry in District that caused you to turn tune it into the board to pay attention

096and again how would you handle the situations different now if you were on our side of dice yeah I mean I think well like I said the pandemic was really hard and it was an anomaly it was incredibly frustrating as a parent to watch but at the same time it wasn't like you could blame anybody you know what I mean it really felt like everybody was trying their best you know but it was hard because again I mean the needs of the the district are so different um but it really felt like if we are having such a hard time and we had so so many resources available to us you know I before the pandemic I worked from home fully um my husband you know worked but he was now then working from home

097but we had the space for him to work from home our kids had each had their own bedrooms you know I mean like we had all the things and it was still so hard I felt like are we not seeing that the people that have less than us and how are they even getting by you know what I mean so it was really it was really difficult but I can't say that I would you know feel like as a board member I would have done anything different it was more just the lack of information in general you know you were trying the it wasn't even you guys you um but it was just you know I know that everybody was trying their best it's more some of the things you know that I think are

098more added value in a normal circumstance are more kind of the implementation of things I guess um you know like I feel the the fact that we have all these tosas these additional resources is amazing it's so amazing it's not not something we've always had to the degree that we have now um but I do feel like sometimes you know you know I can only speak to what I see at Baywood but I know that like our classes are the the spectrum of skill in a third grade class is huge you know what I mean there's kids who are barely reading and there's kids who are you know Harry Potter and God knows what else in a deck you know what I mean there's like this huge level and it's really hard as one teacher

099in a classroom with you know 28 students to to meet that need and so you know I I wonder and we have and we have the PTA has AIDS for each grade you know um funding that which is amazing but they're only there for a short period of time during the day but it really is you know to see how we can use those resources I feel like the kids who are struggling could use so much get learn so much more from more 10one time or small group time um and and that way you can really meet the needs and really bring the kids up to to be more at an equal level um so it's more those sorts of things that I think and I'm not blaming anybody but that that sort of input

100that I hope that I could get thank you so much um I mean you've had so much so many years of experience um with you know your your older children and now with your younger one um I'm wondering in terms of like a vision for going forward like know we currently have we're we're within our strategic plan our fiveyear strategic plan still but like if you were to start you know the next strategic plan what would that look like for you or what what are the things that are standing out to you most as like like the beac that should yeah I mean I think more more of what we're doing I I feel like it's all great things um one of the things that I'm really excited about and I see that it could

101be a huge benefit is the work that's going in for um the housing task force for our teachers um and our our staff because I really that's something that you know I I B what I've seen a lot is we have a lot of teachers who have been there a really long time and they're amazing and they're wonderful but every you know everybody's ready to retire which is amazing good for them but then you know hiring new teachers I saw it a lot when we were at Bell um hiring new teachers is really really difficult and the cost of living is crazy and you know all these things together are is such a struggle so I'm really excited to see that the district is you know working on that and that would be something that

102you know I don't know Bley is a real estate lawyer I'm like you know super excited about and think that there's so much potential there to be able to make a difference and not how that will impact our district as a whole um it's just one example um I have a question you mentioned so Baywood you talked a couple times you said there about auction you talked about the PTA funding so you know not every school is as fortunate so what do you like how do you envision that some of the schools that don't have that like Financial support and just Family Support what do you like what do you think about them and how how will we support those schools yeah I mean definitely I think that that's that's a big part of it

103is I you know feel so grateful that we have that and I mean I've only looked limited on the financials I know that there's you know Financial sources from other sources that other schools get that are different than what we have I know that there's the Ed Foundation um you know so I think really bolstering a lot of that up and um you know cross um you know more better communication amongst schools and the different ptas of the different schools and so forth because there's a lot of programming that I know that we've done things that we've seen other schools have done to then try and you know what's worked and what hasn't worked and really kind of improving that so to you know bridge that Gap I guess you to paraphrase um question that

104I asked actually right I feel like you've address it's officially comments you don't want to keep me you don't hear me talk um we won't hold it against you that you're also an attorney okay but I I am curious again we do really value having your perspectives and I think we as a board when we went out to the community to try to recruit as many as qualified candidates as we could for this opening we were cognizant of the fact that we feel like we do have blind spots as a board we're fully aware of that fact we wanted to recruit candidates who hopefully could speak those issues or improve on the work that we're already doing and having those perspectives on the board we've seen both our previous members and our current members does

105change the way that we operate when you have somebody who's hyperfocused on certain issues that lived those experiences they directly involved in those communities it does make a difference so I guess expanding on that and you've spoken a bit to maybe Beyond what's in your application here can you give us a sense of what you feel like you would bring to as a fifth trustee that would help to event again improve our district and improve our board yeah I mean I think there's a couple things I think one of them like I mentioned before but the fact that I've been through this once before you know and I've seen kind of how you know I know it's a unique experience but I've seen the process of moving from middle school to from elementary school to

106middle school I mean we had a huge shift moving from Baywood to barell um and um that kind of the struggles and the changes that happen and the kids being prepared for that for that change I think I have a unique p and then and then Middle School on high school which is a whole other world um and so kind of having more of that long-term vision and long-term experience and some of it is um some of it is knowing that there's many options you know what I mean there's there's many things that can happen along the way um and so that that I think is defin an added value um and um I had another thought and totally escap me happens to me all the time yeah I should have written it down any

107other questions okay thank you sure okay um so we will we have a public comment we might have others but I I think now of you so just everybody remember your thoughts okay don't forget um let's do public comment and then we'll come back and do discussion I to do it online yeah yeah I have um good evening my name is Megan merch and I'm a math teacher on special assignment at S Park elementary school to this I worked at Meadow Heights Elementary School where I had the pleasure of meeting Diana Harris in 2017 I first encountered Diana when she became a new parent at Meadow Heights and it didn't take long for me to witness the profound impact she has wherever she goes Diana embodies the district's five key building blocks family and Community

108engagement professional development data informed decision making shared leadership and a responsible fiscal support these building blocks are anchored in the district's overarching goals of achievement equity and wellness and Diana continuously brings them to life to her dedicated which you heard a lot about when she was up here over the past 14 years Diana has served the Sano Foster City School District in a variety of roles including um a credential teacher parent substitute teacher PTA officer including PTA president Lego lab extraordinaire volunteer and an advocate for students with disabilities and multilingual Learners through her service Diana has demonstrated her deep alignment with the district strategic plan she generously shares her expertise with schools throughout the district always making herself available to collaborate and further key initiatives such as Lego La path inclusion Multicultural night and many

109more Diana's extensive experience within our district allows her to offer not just her own perspective but a diverse range of view points that enrich every conversation I firmly believe that with her remarkable talents boundless enthusiasm and unwavering Drive Diana Harris would be an invaluable asset to the board a strong and dedicated voice for students families and staff across the district Community thank you thank you um next Colleen suiv good evening Lord um I I'm going to keep this very brief um as a prior School Board member when I am listening in on a board meeting and there is someone who comes across um in a very thoughtful and measured way um and respectful way when they're asking questions at the board that sets off a little light in my head and and I remember that

110person's name and then as that person comes into my life in different ways I'm like oh wait I've met that person before um and so when this position well when you guys were frantic on the Friday that the applications were due um one of the people that I reached out to was Diana Harris and so when this application [Music] came up through the unfortunate circumstances I again reached out to ask her to entertain the idea of coming forward and one of the things that I feel is really a strength of hers is that this is a the ramp up for all of you as you all know is is long and even if you have been on PT and volunteer Ing and aware and coming to Schoolboard meetings that ramp up is long for Diana

111it will be shorter because of her involvement because of her presence on board meeting calls she knows more so then the other candidates are fabulous absolutely fabulous and I think it was scary for all of them to look at the the applications but um I I can't come here and support not just because I reached out to her but because I think she would be a remarkable fit to your board thank you thank you any other comments this room okay can we go to zoom please see if there's any public comment there six hands rais hello hello hi hi my name is Rita Stevenson and I would like to um do a little shout out and comment and support of Diana Harris who is um applying for this uh particular position I've had the privilege

112of meeting Diana when I moved my son from a private school to public school for his IEP she has been instrumental at the Lego lamp and having him um participate as a mother of a child in special education I appreciate her efforts at inclusion and dedication to the school as a whole um I've also had the privilege of working with Mrs merch while she was at Meadow Heights the community I just can't speak about the community I've had such a positive impact on myself as well as my child and Diana Harris has has been so instrumental in that he loves Lego L uh lab he um resonates with her she is just has an infectious smile that just makes everybody feels incredibly great about themselves thank you uh thank you I appreciate the opportunity to

113speak to the board and I wanted to also um voice my support of Diana Harris uh I'm a parent uh in the school district we've been in a number of different schools in the district and uh when we moved into the Meadow Heights district the very first person to welcome us was Diana Harris and I was very impressed with what she shared about her experience and I can tell uh from knowing her person personally and from being a parent at the school that what she shared is truly sincere and from the heart um there was nothing that she shared that um that I felt was hyper H um hyperbolic at all was hyperbole at all because uh that's been our experience and in our uh relationship with her um she really has helped make the

114meow Heights Community the community that it is today and I really hope that she has the opport to help translate that um into the board and into the larger uh Foster City School District so thank you thank you good evening board members thank you for hearing my comment um I've been so impressed with the quality of the candidates we've heard from tonight we're so Lucky in our district to have so many community members willing to step up and serve on our school board like you all are um but I really want to speak in support of Diana Harris um I have am a parent um of two children in the district I'm a teacher in the Sano Union High School District we've been at four different schools in San Mato Foster City and I have

115never met anyone in our eight years in the district who serves the way Diana serves um from the first day I met her when my son started TK at Meadow height we were overflowed to Meadow Heights for didn't have a TK she um was welcoming she was teaching um she has invested in the success of every single student her community doesn't just involve students who live close to Meadow Heights and can walk to Meadow Heights her community also is the students who come on a bus from North Central they are just as much a part of the Meadow Heights Community to her she truly walks the Walk of inclusion she knows and loves every single student at Meadow Heights and I've never seen anyone reach out I've never seen anyone so focused on hearing from

116all of the different stakeholders making sure that programs work for the entire Meadow Heights Community not just certain students um she really wants to see every student succeed she doesn't just care about her two kids all the metalite height students are her kids and I think you know while we have so many wonderful candidates Diana really wants to make sure that all the students in this District in this community succeed and she really knows these individual students and what they and their families need to feel connected the other reason I want to recommend Diana to you is because of her range of experiences she really understands the processes in the system like di like Colleen mentioned there is a big ramp up to being ready to communic uh contribute and understand how the process of

117supporting a district works and Diana has the vision but she also has the Practical nuts and bolts skills she knows how to get things done she knows how to build consensus um and I just see that our school board would really benefit um from her working along with all of you thank you thank you a different topic think she's already gone Joe hello this is Grace man I am also here to speak on behalf of di Diana Harris for the role I am a mother of two um my current kids are an Abbot and Hillsdale and they also went through six years at meal Heights um I have known Diana for eight years and I know her has a mother an educator a friend a volunteer and most importantly I think she's an awesome leader

118she leads by by example she walks a walk and talks a talk I think she also is an ideal candidate because she has a great moral compass whenever we come up with a decision her first thoughts are what's best for the student and their families what's best for the teachers and what's best for the school in the district I think that is always the most important thing when you come up with a difficult decision and um the other reason I think she's ideal for this role is that she things outside the box I think education and how we teach students is ever evolving and she's not afraid to try something new do something different and not always stick with the norm um and so for these reasons I think Diana would be the perfect candidate

119for this role thank you thank you no more public comment okay perfect um we are going to take a quick break so people can you know get themselves back to here but we we will discuss in a few minutes so let's take five minutes and no discussion [Music] us I love your sweater I need borrow it oh my [Music] goodness that has a lot of potential post e e e [Music] okay so we'll start off with board comments and we can go from there there's anything anyone need clarifying let's do all excellent just wanted to thank everyone for their time putting in the effort and um wanting being willing to serve um so I'll just you guys start a discussion or um I feel so fortunate that um this is a hard decision to make

120because there's just so much dedication in this room um to all of our students and you know I I'm just really um grateful that we have such um wonderful families and um that the people in this room care so much about them so um I am really impressed with all of our candidates um I think um for me one of the most important things is rounding out the board um and and so for that reason um the Educators in that applied um stood out more so to me and I don't know I guess I think I have um I have a preference but I just wanted to explain my reasoning a bit because I think you know everyone has really important um professional and and personal qualifications that for me and maybe sparing our non-

121lawyer colleagues on the board um but um I think I would love to have someone who has spent time in a classroom and has you know and has understands how the districts work from um that perspective is is um that's um the most important questions if you have some can I feel like I know the answer I'm going to get but I did want to ask all candidates uh as you're all aware this is a 4-year time and so do any of you anticipate any reason you may not be able to be four years or anything as that keeps you in the district for four years and similarly at least as of today do you expect if you are picked tonight that you will run again in four years I guess we'll go in reverse

122order if you want to start off um the four years is not an issue I'm not going anywhere um after four years God I have no idea depends on how the um I would agree I think for me I want to see how the four years go before I say like yes I'm G to run again but I will say that you know my initial hesitations right like and feeling intimidated by campaigning and running you know I'm the kind of person when I'm put in a space where I have examples and I have mentors who can kind of share with me what their experience was like I I I learned very well in those circumstances so by enjoying my four years on the board and with mentorship with whoever is going to be the at

123that time um that is something that would feel lesson to me because it's like I have someone I can call who I know who can guide me through that that would help me kind of cut that ination factor um I'm in a slightly different position because my family is well aware that my income will go to zero if I if I take this position and my husband is my biggest supporter he is fully on board he says he's happy to have me volunteer and serve here and do whatever good I can put into the world and um as I said I I appreciate opportunities when they come and I can totally see myself running in four years I still have Harris postings I just need to modify it a little [Laughter] bit I also find

124it ironic that I just asked that because as coling others remember I was asked to see her go and I said I wasn't going to and here I am like full circle um any other questions you all have also we love an eco friendly queening um I don't have questions I do have some comments but I wanted to make one is um thank you again for everything that you guys have all the effort you put into this I wanted to say you know asking the question about why you didn't run um for election was because you know we've appointed this is we are now our third appointment for the current board like you know and um when I ran last nobody ran against me nobody ran against batisa um it seems like we're having a

125challenge getting people that want to step up and like put their name out there and although we have found really great candidates through this process it is a bit disappointing that we're not getting and oh and the this this position that we are fing only had one candidate as well so it's disappointing that we're not getting you know a huge turn out but I also see I know that it's intimidating to run and so um it makes me think back to our you know discussions about trusty area elections we're we're just not seeing this huge like Rush of people wanting to be on the school board when we our our goal was to reach out to to communities that are not being represented on our school board um I while we were on break I

126pulled up just the stats you know 41% of Hispanic Latin Latino people uh students in our district there's uh what was it like 36.2% socio economically disadvantaged and 202 2.2% English Learners we don't all represent those students on this school board and I think it's really important that we that we have that perspective while I think about um the candidates that we have tonight um what stands out to me is um some of the comments that we heard about equity and making sure that students feel safe safe and that they're um that they are you know whether we can't personally represent them because they're not our own kids but making sure that we are looking out for all of our students that and that they know um their safety is important to us so I

127just wanted to say um you know thank you for for what you all brought tonight um when I think about my decision that I want to make um is just making sure that we are adding to the perspectives that we have here and that all students and families feel that they have some representation um on the school board so yeah whatever you want you can any comments [Music] on I'll just be candid I think I think at this point we're not necessarily going to any more questions but I did not well I am pleasantly surprised by how hard this decision is and I I'm not being polite here for those of you who don't know I actually used to do candidate Recruitment and training for five years and I would gladly support G candidates that

128came in front of us today um I think you all BR very different skills and perspective which I really appreciate like trusty Tren I really do one of the things we really wanted to see was an educator perspective and also obviously communities that we feel like when represented well on this board at the same time I think for each of you obviously huge you know Community experience and support for all the folks that wait in but also everything you've been able to do across multiple campuses both as an educator parent um just deeply plugged into our community I think in a way that even as board trustees is enviable just how much you are plugged into the community you serve I think Stacy you know again uh I get told a lot that I come

129off Stern when I ask my questions but actually I really appreciate that you called out the equity issue I think you know we just lost trustee who was one of our biggest Champions equity and one of the things she constantly pushed us and reminded us Is that real Equity is what matters and not necessarily the things that make best headlines and so when I was pushing on this issue it's actually because I agree with you and I think that you having that ability to call us out as a trustee is profoundly important because part of what we do isn't necessarily datto implementation we're not in the classrooms we're not the ones building out the programs we are the ones providing oversight setting priorities and so having that perspective was helpful also one of my top

130concerns that I've expressed as the power board meetings is the federal landscape moving forward is the state budget situation moving forward in a vacuum there is a lot that our district is doing right when this storm hits I'm very concerned about how our community and our board will come together to solve those issues and I appreciate that that's something that was Center in mind for you it's even part of the reason that you're here today and the maram as another fellow attorney someone who has experience doing oversight someone said so many years in our community the Ed the housing task force is one of the biggest things we put forward this year it's one of our Central priorities um you were one of the few people who spoke about that and kind of how your

131experience might be able to help and we're going to face a lot of issues we are just at the Inception phase right now and so having someone like you would be tremendously helpful so when I say I'm torn it it's not me being polite stepping into public leadership is incredibly hard I say this not only someone who's in your shoes exactly a year ago but also who then had to run a campaign and defend my record and reach out to the community I am in tremendous admiration for all of you I would be honored to serve with any of you and I think as we have this discussion we'll have to figure out what makes sense with this for this year but at the same time I think the fact you're step up put your

132name out there in public I know how you know everyone your friends can see this on Zoom just one out to community and the fact that we are so honored to have three candidates like you if you had been my district I wouldn't have to do this this would have been nice so just again without any type of prous whatsoever just a huge amount of respect for all of you and we will have a discussion in terms of what makes the most sense moving forward I just quickly want to um add something very briefly um well said I just we have some amazing candidates and I am absolutely torn and I have to say that in the past uh two years that have for three years that I've been on the board that I've been

133on the board I've had to go through this process a few times and um by the end of the um interviews I felt like I was very clear about who um should be selected for the uh position and today is just very difficult for me um I think you all bring very unique um skills and knowledge and abilities that will benefit our district you know for years to come and I appreciate you all throwing your ring and your name and the hat um and the ring excuse me and um I just I'm I'm really torn right now so um I'm GNA have to lean on my fellow trustees to kind of help me out to steer me in this direction so I'm G let them make the motion okay I'm going to make a motion

134um to appoint Stacy hoe and then so now would be a time for the board to considering that we have this motion we will need a second just to be able to discuss it and and then to decide from there I'm on a second thank you board discussion if there's anything um for me I would prefer to select Diane Harris um for a couple reasons um I think there's something you know as as Le trust um trusty BR mentioned you know he's really plugged in and I'll be honest there's something about Diana that really speaks to me in terms of how when I when I first read her application the way that she talks about the students um there's this I don't I don't know how to express it exactly but just the way that

135she speaks about the students I feel that she loves them and I feel that she cares about them that she sees there um her potential um and you know that I think that heart is something that um I really value um and then just to add on to the fact that she has so much experience in the classroom at these different um ages in um in our district and has has seen it firsthand um I think to me that [Music] um that's kind of what is selling me on Diana um obviously we've heard from so many people within the community um about all of the candidates but particularly for Diana I think you know and not just I think across I think I would say across the spectrum of um of people and um for

136someone to have this broad support I think is really um it's you know it's really nice to see and um so for that reason I would um I would say that I would prefer Diana to serve I I think at this point I I'm torn between two candidates as well um I I agree with trust and I clearly Dan has a very strong heart for service for this community I I really appreciate what you shared up there and clearly this is something that is very real to you um s their needs and I think it's something I tremendously admire and obviously the love and respect you have from our community comes from that comes from the service that you've shown dedicated and regardless of what happens ton and all of us here will still be

137part of this community working on this work together um and again Stacy I said with the focus on the issues you talked about and I think that the thing that's difficult for me now is that our role as a trustee is fundamentally different than the work that we did as advocates before we came up here and I think what I'm trying to figure out the best voices to bring to the table obviously both bring the educative perspective as well that's where I'm I'm struggling and I don't know that I've come to a decision so I would love to hear what my colleagues are thinking as well but that's to me trying to figure out whether this role is the best role for the folks in the room and that's um I was also torn between

138Diana and Stacy I think what during the like question and actually not the question answer but more of the um like them speaking to us directly I felt that Stacy was more like policy driven and Diana was more like Hands-On and wanted to talk about what's actually happening class which is I think is very very important but our role is to kind of step back the we have District leadership we have teachers that are leaders in their own right that um are driving what's happening on the day today but I think in terms of just creating policies that are that are best for our students and for our employees and for our community I felt that um Stacy was stronger in that area and and that's what kind of like pulled me towards her I

139can uh quickly comment on my reason of um seconding right away which uh Stacy was first choice for that reason also um more policy um I again this is a hard decision all of the work that uh Diana is doing in the classrooms at the site level um is tremendous I mean we really need um Advocates and oversight that she brings to the site level I think um again being in this role you have to be able to step back and make decisions and they have to be very tough decisions that may not be favorable in many instances and sometime I believe if [Music] you have that drive to stay at the side level and that's the strength that you um possess it is I I think just being with the kids is a huge

140huge benefit and I mean honestly I would hate to have to lose that that kind of performance at the site level I think it's much needed um I think you provide amazing support and um and I just I feel like in terms of policy and being able to make tough decisions the experience the knowledge the skill the skills the ability I think you know I think you in my opinion uh Stacy would be the strongest well you heard from everyone are we ready to take a vote are we do um a roll where they put trusty Brooks oh yes the motion was for Stacy yes yes okay um I'll go on trusty Tri let make it dramatic no I'll vot yes let's go to trusty Kim come out early I mean another thing is that

141I think and I don't I mean I feel like this is slightly a little bit unfair but um I think that Diana will also have more flexibility to like hit the ground running in terms of like getting to know all of our um all of our other school sites um additionally she is her like her kind of area of focus or the like geographically we don't have anyone who knows that part of like that geographical area of the district very well um and having someone who has spent a significant of time at abbit I think is really valuable um North s you know North Shore View is a K8 so there's you know I think it um we have kind of some of the magnet like I know it's not totally the same but like

142we have some of that covered and in terms of like geographically I just think that Abbot for so many years is kind of I don't want to say you know like I think that it it can use a lot of um um appreciation um and so like kind of part of the reason that Diana stood out to me is like like one of the things that's important to me is seeing kids for who they are like giving them agency giving them independ like showing them how to like shine um and not necessarily like yes I believe that like access to algebra and academic achievement is important but like I think that all of um like kids want to know that they're respected and valued and so um I don't know like it's I think it's

143hard for me to like talk about this without being super super emotional about it but I think like when I go to like my PID school and I just see kids that you know you can tell that they they're um they haven't had a great experience schol you know that they um because when you talk to them as if they're you know full human beings like they just respond to you in this really special way and I I feel like Diana has that that same touch um and I want someone who will be a champion for those kids and I want someone who thinks you know it's like I've you know I've sat in on on interviews where when someone says like all of these kids are our kids like there's something to me that

144is really special about that and um so I think for me I want someone who have that mindset that's what I would say I respond um I you know I I took those things into consideration and one of the things I want to just highlight is that um we do have um a lot of onsite experience as schools um I know that uh de has 14 years and I know that uh Stacy has 17 um what stands out to me in her um experience is the fact that she's worked at many diverse wide range I mean the spectrum is wide from open Tech to um sta um I mean you just have a Pacific Bay Christian School you just have a well-rounded um experience in different institutions and I think that is um a huge

145asset also the fact that you are um an an academic counselor that you have been guiding kids and not saying that either one is different um because they both are equally great and they are equally needed um However the fact that you do have the uh counseling experience and U and even a greater amount of time of experience being at the school site I think is a huge asset I apologize the board I'm going to ask two questions to St for time but also because I'm gener curious so I'll start with Stacy Stacy I guess one concern that came up community members when you applied was the fact mov to this one on the DI is that you have chosen to be involved in private schools and so I guess if you were to take

146a role on our board and essentially have to sell the greatness of public schools while at the same time having made those career choices on your for yourself how would you respond to those types of questions coming from parents in our district and you know I I recognize that that's I was TR to you know proactively address it in the application first I send my kids to Public Schools you I have the ability to send my kids tuition free to the school that I'm currently working at and I chose not to um and really you know my kids AR for you um and you know when I look at other options right so I use that algebra example right um I hope I'm not throwing in one on the bus here when I say this

147but you show is one of those School sites that doesn't have algebra one and I talked to my student my my oldest child who's in the fifth grade and I was like so like what should we do like how are we going to handle this let's talk about this as a family you know and you know she said you know I love the community at show VI I love I I can't imagine myself anywhere else you know and I was like okay you know I I I value this I've been part of the and have done a lot of volunteering into there and you know I'm saying okay you know I'm I'm going to keep you there for Middle School and I'm willingly choosing a school that doesn't have Al one that goes against all

148my things and against you know what I'm trying to say is that it boils down to me is what is the greater good here and for me the greater good for her is having community and that's the same reason why you know I'm applying here and and and I was saying earlier about my earliest you know my my hardest challenge right was finding that balance between going from public to from working in a public institution to working at a private one and having to navigate within even myself right like where do my values lie how do I can I still stand with my values at a private school and I've learned that actually yes I can um and I think you know also being in a private sector right you know and I know you

149know we have attorneys we have CPA entrepreneurs just because you're in a private sector does not mean that you have an ability to connect with the public sector um and so I I believe that you know all of my core values really match the San Antonio City School District values um so even though it might be potentially in conflict with the schools that I that I've recently been working at um my values are not changed and then D my question for you when I experienced this coming as a college partner and I went head to being an advocate for those families who now being a trustee representing the district and it is a complex rearrangement when you're still in the group chat still hearing the angry text but now you're in a situation where you're

150limited in what you can say and do and you know the insights into why certain things are the way they are are but they're not you're not pry to share those necessarily until it's ready to be publicly disseminated do you see any particular challenges given your deep relationships in the community you I guess position more as an advocate for families to then have to be in a situation where we might be the ones having to deliver bad news especially if we go into a tough fiscal environment or even the story that you shared if those types of situations are ones that we're faced with down the line do you feel comfortable being the face of those decisions first of all I'd like to start with um I was PTA president for for three years during

151the pandemic I had to oversee a quarter million dollar budget and make very unpopular decisions however my connections with the community and my willingness to give them a voice and give them the opportunities to speak up has help me gain their trust I am not just active in our school district I am active in our cities I am very well known and trusted because they know me they know my intentions are pure and I have and will make unpopular decisions however I believe that I communicate clearly enough and when people when I tell people trust me it's not an easy decision they do they might not be happy but they do and I have had people hurl a lot of hate towards me in it but even though I am dedicated here and it'd be

152a loss to have me in the classroom I am incredible ibly capable I am one of the fastest Learners and one of the most committed people so I will do whatever it takes for the role in order to ensure that we are really reaching the biggest impact that we can make as a board if you don't take this opportunity to have someone who's deeply connected to the community to serve on the board many people will feel like you are dismissive of their repres presentation of their voice you can ask all kinds of people who don't even go to the schools I'm at and they'll be like oh yeah Diana Harris was willing to help me make hard decisions about going to Turnbull and College Park or elsewhere I am just that kind of person and

153if I don't get this opportunity it's fine I will make an impact however I think the district will lose out discussion at this point so you know as part of the the deliberation these folks have interviewed they've given you the written responses you've asked all your questions there is a motion on the board that's been seconded and voted on so we do need um I think based on what we've heard tonight I'm inclined to vote Yes and to burn to our current our current future president and so yes okay well thank you um that's a vote three to one we have a new trustee trustee um Stacy H [Applause] congratulations I really do yeah sure yeah so we're going to go um after you get a little break we're just going to go into 5

154in a second okay moving on to item 5B swearing in an administration of oath of office to provisional board member all right this is the oath of office for the position of board member on the S School District board I'm going to read this to you and you'll repeat after me I state your name I Stacy how to solemnly swear you Solly swear that I will support and defend that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California and the constitution of the State of California against all enemies foreign and domestic that I will bear true faith that I will bear true Faith an allegiance to the Constitution of the United States an allegiance to the Constitution of the

155United States and the constitution of the State of California and the constitution of the State of California that I take this obligation freely that I take this obligation freely without any mental reservation without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion for purpose of evasion and that I will well and Faithfully that I will well and Faithfully discharge the duties upon which I am about to enter discharge the duties upon which I am about to enter [Applause] congratulations should a second to the agenda are we yes take a five minute [Music] recess e e e now have our fifth trustee up here trusty hope and we're going to move on to item six where we will recess our regular meeting and convene an annual organizational meeting 6A is election officers so we will be electing um

156president vice president and Clerk and as the current president I would like to um have this honor of nominating trusty Brooks for president so I'll make that motion sorry I had to make a motion Miss I second that motion thank you um so trusty Proctor made the motion trusty K made the second all in favor please say I I I I congratulations near the president okay so we'll go into um nominating vice president um okay I would like to nominate for vice president Maggie Trent second again all right thank you trusty Brooks for the motion and trusty Kim for the second all in favor please say I I I did you vote Yes congratulations you're our new Vice we'll go on to clerk I will nominate trusty himim for Clerk I will second um so

157that was trusty Tren for the motion and I did the second all in favor please say I I I congratulations trusty Kim you are now the clerk I'm now gonna hand the meeting over to the new president to go to item 6B thank you everyone good evening um I would like to start with item 6B and uh let's see for the appointments I would like to um continue okay for Maggie uh I'm gonna sign you to Ed foundation and to the city of s Matel leaz trusty proor I would like to assign you to the Foster City Leon and Communications and see that and for trusty Kim I would like to assign you to legislative representative as well as s Matel County Council and for myself I will be assigned to the Foster City pleas

158on as well as the PTA Council and home for all and for misso truste ho excuse me we're going to assign you to D and to the equity task force and then for the Secretary of the board wonderful superintendent sorry if I missed it do we have one for PTA council is that yes PTA council is for myself and then we're going to move to item 16 and would someone like to make a motion to adjourn this meeting motion to adjourn the organizational meeting second all in favor say I all right I'm going to move to item seven and reconvene to radio item n item 8 a is the approval of the 2425 Community Schools ini okay a we're gonna move to um the community school initiative update please [Music] drins there we go can

159you all hear me yes great um Board of Trustees superintendent and the public I'm honored uh to provide our an update on our community schools initiative um my name is Dr chrisand alava the superintendent of student services a little bit on the agenda I'm going to start off with setting the context uh for the initiative uh really for honing and on the Strategic PL and the community school pillars I'll then move on to um talk a about that transition from the planning to the implementation for our for our five schools that uh are undergoing this transition with a uh focus on our multi-stakeholder uh voices I'm also going to uh hone in on the third component which is the implementation phase activities that are currently taking place and have taken place uh as a result

160of where we're at with with our schools uh and I'll end with continuing the initiative right uh uh bringing up the new that we're including um and you know moving forward as we continue our timeline um setting the context with our strategic plan go without saying cannot over uh emphasize this part because it's super critical um I'm super uh grateful for the equity leaders and the equity leadership and action for the board without your backing and the backing of our superintendent uh and our executive cabinet members a lot of this work would not be possible so I do want to thank you and this kind of lays out where we're at in terms of the timeline with our year three of the Strategic plan and how it mirrors and I see that it's not going

161up there so I apologize for that I'm on my I'm on my third [Music] slide what I could do is just leave it like this better yeah I'll just leave it like this and I I'll click kind of manually um uh to date uh we have had five uh this is the fifth uh board update um on our community school initiative uh our strategic plan really calls for Equity um and is undergraded by these five building blocks um and uh as I Showcase in my next slide you'll see just like the nice kind of alignment between our strategic plan uh goals as well as building blocks um with the community school pillars which is really the integrated student supports expanded and Rich learning time and opportunities collaborative leadership practices and the active uh family and

162Community engagement so there's like this really nice alignment between uh uh our strategic plan which is the foundation of our work these are the five participating schools that are currently um a part of the implementation plan for your their first year you the gardens inter National School Laural Elementary lead Elementary sale Park Elementary and sunny BR Elementary uh a quick uh kind of uh reminder uh of the awards uh that are four of five schools as we know Festa Gardens though did not receive the award we're still moving forward the Community School uh model which really exemplifies our commitment to to the model and to these wraparound and after school enrichment programs uh but this kind of remains intact in terms of the funding that we're receiving we do receive it yearly um and this

163is kind of like the grand funding levels uh uh for the schools um with the exception of Laurel um given their size uh they were provided uh the annual amount of $300,000 per year while the other three schools received the $250,000 um I want to now transition to our uh multi holder voices as a part of this initiative um and really honing in on like that that transition from planning to implementation which is our task for this first year of the grant um I start with voice right multi-stakeholder voice was uh super critical and important um and and it is something that we have progressively you know worked on systematically putting into place surveys for um our staff our students um in our families uh and even our Community Partners uh they've been uh a

164part of our steering committees and that's been really critical but this kind of lays out um you know some of the professional development where we were able to collect inperson input and that's always super powerful right um and and super helpful uh but we also you know as part of the process and you know as part of the community school initiative you know there's a traditional survey collection and the and and I just want to commend our steering committees um because uh they have really taken on the charge on literally creating and crafting you know the surveys themselves and they've done just just such an amazing job in in doing that um so you can see the check marks here are some of the things that we've already completed throughout uh the year and some

165of our two next steps which is an upcoming professional development where again we'll get more input in person um and staff survey uh the traditional way uh yet another around uh in January and this is kind of like throughout the year the steering committees uh can Veer off this path because if they need you know if there's some question they have and they need to survey they do so right um that there's always that opportunity to continue to to serve their stakeholders um I do want to mention that one of the greatest kind of uh activities that I I believe has occurred um is through our PK uh parent Workshop uh it was one of the strategies um that was heavily noted in the during the the two-year planning phase families and staff you know

166they wanted workshops and education for families to empower some of our most historically marginalized uh voices in our community and PK stepped up um and as you can see very systematically met with families we have some really solid numbers right here across the board from all all of our schools um and you know they went through this process and this is really like what the community school model means by Empowering Families uh is this commitment to systematically meet them not just once or twice but like throughout and keep coming back to them and build relationship and build that sense of understanding so that not only do they create a sense of like an opinion about some of the things that they want uh but it builds a sense of belonging right and and and we've

167seen just so many great um families who stepped up during the graduation and our superintendent oroa attended many of those uh ceremonies alongside myself and our principles um and we just saw a lot of leaders par you know parent leaders step up and and speak and and and share their story and share their goals uh uh regarding you know how they feel a sense of belonging within the school to help their child which is the ultimate Quest here the um these are images of our fall end of fall session one PK workshops U where families you know we showered them with a lot of validation through certificates and you know showering with a lot of warmth and and just camaraderie right because uh these were some of the families that kept coming you know week

168after week to the PK sessions um and you know they were contributing and were a part of something bigger than than themselves right than than their school it was really really neat to see them um in the spring um we are serving families uh we have some topics in mind and PK has many topics that they can explore but of course we want this to be driven by the families and so they're currently in the process of collecting um survey data from the families to see like what some some topics that they can um that they would like to explore and learn more about in in the spring um so you know some of the ideas have come up are family engagement right deepening that understanding social emotional learning uh literacy K to5 how to

169help at home and how to be involved with their child's literacy trajectory so a lot of great things are happening with the PK and I you know want to give a major shout out to to the the PK program because they really came through and collaborated with our staff at each of the five schools we even had a an English version an English uh class for um that Drew families from all five of the schools numbers weren't as high but we did offer it right we gave an opportunity for any families who didn't speak Spanish right which was um the predominant language of the PK workshops um I want to move into uh this next implementation phase of the activities that took place around shared leadership family centers enrichment toolkits um as you know when

170we pulled across two years these were kind of like the the major themes that came up at the at the sites in terms of what they wanted um and so I want to report on like where where we're at with those pieces right families were very clear on some of uh the school activities and the wraparound services and the after school enrichment programs that they wanted for their kiddos including student voice that was uh uh showing up a lot of these Trends uh and so I kind of want to you know tell you know update you on some of these pieces family centers are beginning to be built uh I know that there's a couple that have already kind of come up like at Laurel there's a CSS kind of Family Center um uh that

171includes a lot of resources for families uh some SE tail park has also worked have le lead is currently working you know to to to uh provide this this space uh so there's a lot of movement with our Family Resource Centers which were a part of uh the planning Grant application that that we submitted um now for uh the pillar on extended and and expanded uh enrich learning and time opportunities um I did uh provide an attachment to this presentation uh because this is really where um our steering committees really shined uh to survey their stakeholders and to look at vetted programs that are have great reputations around Community um and that are based on student interest so there you know there's a tool that each of the uh site steering committees uh worked on

172um to determine what programs to bring and and and and things like that like why two of the most popular programs um were soccer right and sports and basketball and volleyball so we're uh we're excited to bring AYSO which is a soccer program as well as uh bo and Girls Club who will be running our our volleyball and basketball so it's really exciting because again this is the kind of a toolkit that provided the steering committees an opportunity to organize their thoughts uh toward the end of the um uh toward the end of the packet I I put in so so you can get a snapshot these are not final and when they do become final where we have a fully itemized I will you know come back and update you all on actual numbers

173but I wanted to give you a glimpse into like some of those snapshot these are not created by myself or my team at the district office these were these final Pages at the end following this timeline um were created by the by the site steering committees um on November 22nd we had a very special day where we you know uh I welcomed our uh site steering commities from each of the five Community Schools and they were able to uh essentially you know provide their requests for these programs so that we can get those uh going with our programs and and and and continue on this timeline journey of betting the programs and bringing them in and you know doing all that back work that that we need to get done uh but you can see

174here images of just a very excited faces after all the work that the site steering committees did at the site level um I I you know there was one team to suil Park which is the first uh uh Team here you will see two student reps who actually attended you know they they they drove with the principal to the district office and and and provided their their request right for their school and so that was like a really special moment for them um this is a quick Glimpse again just a snapshot in time um by no means official because things are fluctuating and I imagine a lot of these numbers will even go higher as we start bringing in the programs um but uh uh regarding uh the requests that each of the sites during

175committees made this the number of students that our after school enrichment programs will be serving and we're we're looking at instruments Sports um dancing dancing was super popular uh ukulele um so there a lot of great uh and kind of an an explosion of of of after school and richment programs uh that are you know we hope and Will Change some of our our kiddos lives for the better uh they're just going to really immerse themselves in that in terms of continuing the initiative um I do want to um uh commend uh the principles and this uh and and the staff of Abbot middle school barell middle school and Fiesta Gardens these are the three schools that we are uh currently working on submitting an application for uh the implementation Community School Grant so I

176laid laid out here kind of a timeline of some of the activities that we've done uh including you know you know driving that application and start you know and beginning to uh uh speak to staff so they underwent an abbreviated version of what we did over the last two years with their staff but they were actually able to embed it with elac existing structures and they assembled steering committee so I just really want to commend the work of these three sites because they went above and beyond the Call of Duty to to get this done uh for for our students um without compromising multi po Voice without compromising you know the process so um we do do have the due date due date deadline of February 7th and I can promise you that we will

177make that deadline uh just like last year we will be two three weeks early uh in in in assembling that um so just as a quick overview this is what the CDE is looking at right 50% of the application uh falls on this unduplicated pupil count and they're according to the application it remains at 80% of what they're looking for and 50% is on the quality of the application and artifacts however I also want to bring in some hope here because although we're these three schools do not meet the 80% Mark uh we do know that the CDE every year last minute for some mysterious reason or maybe because they want to share the love they lower the bar they did that for us last year um and for schools across the state of California

178um and so anyone uh you know in May 2023 stuck to their guns right and kind of kept it at 80% last this this last year in May uh they actually went from 80% to 70% which allowed us to get four of our schools in um and so we're hoping right that in and this is the final leg of the of the grant they're they're not they're sunsetting it after this round uh due to lack of funds and things like that uh so we're hoping that you know they might lower it to 60% maybe they L to 50% to allow us more schools to be a part of this um I end with gratitude U because I know that our School principles have done just an amazing work um you know Dan dor Daniel ress

179at Fiesta Gardens Natalie D hunt at lead Cindy chin at Sunny Bray Carrie Hazelton at s tail Park Jessica Murphy at Laurel Jessica na at Bal middle school and Paul Belzer at Abbot Middle School I cannot thank them enough and their teams um uh for collaborating around this and getting the work done for our kids um uh to ensure that you know we can either continue to uh make you best use of these funds or to you know go in the case of the three Fiesta Guardians Abbot and Bell to seek out funds and get the planning going um in an efficient meaningful manner I also want to quickly thank you know the steering committees because they meet I kid you not I mean it you know at the beginning of the planning two years

180ago we were looking at like you know a monthly meeting now they're meeting either weekly or bi-weekly so they're constantly meeting and so I you know I want to thank all of our steering committees at lauro at lead s Tao Park you know you see the names updated names of all of our members there students involved as well Sunny Bray Abbott team orell team they've all assembled you know come together uh and of course I I do want to do a a special shout out to the district steering committee that is led by our principal in special assignment Miss Ramirez um who have done just such a great job I know Kathy Pratt you're on you're on that steering committee um and it's a lot of work right you come together different voices all schools

181are represented um and you know in addition to the district steering committee I know Janette meets bi-weekly with our Comm uh Community uh uh School specialist rcss is at each of the community schools and does you know know some really deep work uh to ensure that they all are dialed in collecting voice and and getting these kiddos you know what what programs that they need and want so a major shout out to to Jad and her team and with and with that I um Board of Trustees ret the public I open up to questions and comments thank I'll open it up to the board for any clarifying questions I have a question um one of the csba like sessions that I went to was um the Hupa School District that has I want to say

182they had like 25 or something schools it's a k through 12 district and I think they said 18 of them are Community Schools and so what they found was really important was that um like the elementary schools that fed into the middle schools or Community Schools and the middle school that fed fed into the high school were also Community Schools and I'm just wondering thank you for sharing about Abbott Morell um do we do any work at the high school district to see like if we truly care about Community Schools and we truly care about the kids in the community do we do any work with them to ensure that they're maybe on board with this or if they need any assistance since we such experts at at this already yeah I mean I'm happy

183to you know reach out to them um I'm it's not I'm not I don't think there's a Community High School school right a community school high school and and my uh knowledge of of the high school Feer high school that we have but I'm definitely open to to have that conversation with okay I think because you know Abbot and Hillsdale are like a block away from each other it seems like it would be something that might be interesting to explore thank you excellent strategic thing but also uh we do have a partnership with Hillsville High School through the empowerment through um program that's operated and that's a very direct link to uh incoming ninth grade students um I think um when we're able to take a deep breath in May and June and think about

184the work with our high school district um I can speak on behalf of our executive um team and and really um advocate for us spending more time with our our uh High School District in order to continue work on Community Schools um dismantling school to prison pipeline serving our MultiLing Learners and all the really critical strategies we have um that I think you know as you pointed out uh truste Proctor um you know it's just it's just essential being a K8 District to put in basically the extra time to have that conversation with High School District hi Dr Raba I just had a quick question so I know when we first launched the Community Schools initiative there was a very concertive effort to reach into almost every corner of the school bring in a lot

185of parents family members who hadn't historically been engaged and with the second phase with um Abbot foral and Fiesta Gardens I see that we you know because of the timeline had to essentially doing Q4 of this year so what efforts were made to make sure that we weren't just capturing say the loudest the most responsive voices but also putting in the same type of concerted effort and strategy we did the first time around to make sure that we were again engaging parents and others who historically may not be responsive to emails or typical surveys can you describe some of the efforts the district made to make sure that that was still part of our process reaching out to the three new sites absolutely so one of the key strategies that we implemented to achieve that

186is that um we leaned on each of the school sites elac um teams right our English language advisory committees uh which we know historically um you know brings in families multilingual families families you know from you know an array of of differences right to to empower them right with knowledge of the school system and so instead of having Standalone meetings we actually devised very uh intentional and thoughtful meetings along with our elac because of the connection that there is between the two right the community school and the elac goals uh kind of come together around language right um and so that's one uh important piece that we were able to to achieve and um uh you know the middle schools Fiesta Gardens they were pulling really you know significant number of families at these because

187not only were they coming to learn about elac goals right how to reclassify how to you know tap into resources at school but they were also invited uh to give input and be a part of the community school process so it was kind of two goals in one meeting um and that's how we were able to to ensure that we got historically marginalized voices as a part of this and to follow up on that is there a certain percentage of responses I think to quote um now Cho's comment earlier especially when it comes to survey data in this type of setting it can feel performative it can feel like it's affirming a conclusion that you're already heading towards and so to make sure that we are collecting both desending voices or different opinions or especially

188when it comes to things like after school planning is there a certain percentage of families we're trying to reach out to or what was our definition of success in terms of our Outreach yeah absolutely so there's a couple metrics that the sites and the steering committees use um one which right is the traditional you know number of surveys that were taken right uh another uh and in person one uh is less about number and more about quality right um because we did have step members who were coming in and and having one-on-one conversations or small group conversations and that's really where you get a lot of powerful information um uh you know where you get an opportunity to tap into resources in the moment but also provide a voice uh for our family so it's

189I I would say uh uh trusty Kim is that is is a combination of both of getting as many uh you know survey uh respondents uh you know those numbers but also you know getting that you know qualitative data on the ground um at these meetings and then my last question on that front on the first round we had heard comments from Educators and other partners that they felt that they hadn't been given as many opportunities to be included is that something that we rectified in terms of the second round Outreach that is correct and that's why I'm let me show you the slide here this slide here here kind of showcases a direct response to that uh both in terms of surveys but also in terms of inperson uh voice that we collected thank

190you um I have a question as well um thank you so much for your presentation Dr Raba um clearly I'm new to this um I was looking on slide eight um I was wondering if you can give me a little bit of um context on why Fest Gardens didn't receive the community school Grant absolutely so um if I may so I'm sharing the slide that you're referring to but I would also like to go to this slide okay um so I go back to this slide here um the application like on paper which is available to the public states that um 50% of the of every application submitted um will depend on the the site how having 80% or higher unduplicated people count um unduplicated people count is basically you know percentage of number of

191kids who fall under English earner income and eligibility you know Foster youth um here as you can see um in 22 this is the data that they requested us to submit last year 2022 2023 um Fiesta Gardens was at 57.8% just below the 60% indefinitely below the 80% they were also below the 70% which is what they actually went with so that is why um it wasn't on the quality of our process or the application submitted it was unlik thank you so much you're so all right we uh Joe can we open it up to zoom any clarifying questions yes Che no public comment on Z okay public comment anyone ink all right I'll open it up to the board for any comments who would like to make a comment um on slide 18 where

192you um discussed the different tools that were being um discussed or potentially um going to be offered I wanted to um just kind to give a comment about um the sports there's a lot of kids who do not engage in sports one of the things I realized during the pandemic when um Sports came to a screeching Hall there were a lot of um sports that resumed on uh zoom and there were no physical fitness um programs offer just physical fitness because either kids make a team and then at Le those who do not um either make the team or it's always tied to a sport and I would love to see uh a program that offer just physical fitness I think that would be an amazing uh asset or offer that uh that we offer

193to our kids and then also I saw um a clothes shop that we're going to be Implement I like that um however I do um I would like to bring to your attention that uh Hillsdale offer um it's called the peace pantry and I think the name of it is amazing um and I think instead of um calling it you know a cloth shop that we consider some other options and I want to give you that I kind of here I'm I'm a Windows [Music] person just a couple of suggestions um you don't have to take these but just to throw them out there um instead of calling it The Clothes Closet U we consider something like the little threads Boutique or um the thread shed or something like uh the swap [Music] spot thank

194you Dr for all your work on the Community Schools initiative um um you know as you know my kids are at one of these Community Schools and I just really it's really exciting to see firsthand how much um these programs impacted our school Community um just having somewhere safe for so many of these kids to go where they get to you know spend time with their friends get more support academically um have time to be outside and play in a safe um safe location with supervision and with you know just with um stuff that really um do a really good job like you connecting with them is it's just really exciting to see um and so many of our parents um I think it's also a way for our parents to get to know each

195other like in the pickup line and um so I just am really grateful for all of these initiatives and um to have more people who historically have not you know been at the table to have a a big and strong voice about the direction of our schools so thank you so much um I agree about um you know just emphasizing um other potential options for you know being healthy and and fit that don't necessarily involve organized Sports so um thank you for raing that trusty president BRS um and that's that's it for me thank you as alwaysa I just want to thank you for all your work on this um I don't want to repeat myself because every board meeting we talk about Community Schools I do talk about how it to me is one

196of the highlights of our district one of the most exciting things we're doing and if someone who's done it poliy for 1520 years now one of the best examples I've seen of us really trying to address a lot of the issues outside of just what happens in the class what happens in funding uh but I also do want emphasize the point we made previously in our working group session is that one of the concerns I have looking ahead just knowing both our state and federal situation is trying to figure out you know we hear comment all the time about great initiatives that the district has launched but five years later 10 years later when that funding dries up when we no longer have that podt the ptas and others are called to fill in that

197Gap or other you know the foundation is called to fill in and it would be helpful now even though we have a few years left on our Horizon and we expect to try to renew just knowing what the situation is that we are constantly thinking about how do we plan for the sustainability of the programs are doing because the worst outcome would be to invest all this time to build something that we're genuinely proud of that's a model for other districts and then to run out of the resources to keep that going and so I know it's something that's already on the district's mind but I just like to bring it up especially given the climate that we're in but thank you again for everything you're doing not just in terms of the program but

198I think especially that engagement piece is something that I know the district has always prioritized but to see it in action to see that level of service and I've said this as a student who I felt like my parents were always on the outside looking in um that type of meeting people where they are to let them know that they have the ability to shape their child's education again outside of just what's happening in the classroom but so much that we're building around that I think it's just a phenomenal thing it makes me very proud to be trusted here thank you trust again thank you so much for the presentation and just want to thank you for all the work that you're doing and just scrolling through these final slides where it shows that all

199the teams at each school and then the um the steering committee I know this has just been a long time of a lot of of work and so we're just really looking forward to seeing what's next and um you know just in terms of communication I think a lot of people that aren't part of these Community Schools may not know all of the work and what's like what is going to be what does the community school look like and what does it mean so as much as you can continue to share communication districtwide and in beyond our school district as well you know people that live in those communities that might want to know what's going on I think that would be really um powerful so thank you thank you all right I'll open it

200up to the public now 9A that one is the approval of the 2425 first in report thank you so much and uh couple comments I think that the word I've seen Dr did is really brilliant just that's to summ it up it's really brilliant work so admire your work um another comment to trusty Proctor you talked about the high school district I got a meeting tomorrow morning at 9 o' with the CBO from the high school district so it's on the [Music] list it's not all about numbers right okay you see that side so um we're sharing with you just some information tonight about C room where we're at in the cycle and trusty ho I'm more than happy to meet with you in detail talk about the whole process you may be really familiar

201with it but um from your experience from 17 years sitting through some presentations but have to spend time with you to talk about our districts have particular questions and I want to thank as always our executive director of fiscal Services Blanca who does uh incredible work too so thanks to her for all her work time she's available there's any particular questions Blanca was a student in the district she was a classroom a at one point in time she's worked way up through to she knows we don't want to say uh she's omnipotent but when it comes to the school district she knows a lot so it's great to have her as a resource so thank you BL for all your hard work and the whole team okay so couple slides in here too um this

202first slide just tells we're in the cycle first inter we at this point in time of the year we've Incorporated some information from closing the books we're taking a PLL somewhere things are running with the OWN on a whole variety of things salaries and benefits contracted Services etc etc utility we incorporate that into the macroeconomic information we give to you at a macro level um our first ter isn't dramatically different from our adopted budget so um we're tracking close to what we um anticipate the budget will look like we try to Capt for you here tonight too in the first interim highlights just a couple things that not just impact the current year but as truste Kim was to the long-term sustainability in the district so we just Capt for a couple things in here

203in this slide deck that talks about some things we've Incorporated in the current year but also things are going to impact us for the next perspective couple years we've got the colas listed which are really the lcf colas uh looking at 2526 our enrollment forecast and Staffing for the upcoming year we're looking at some decline in our enrollments we're making some adjustments in our staffing ratios for next year or two um and we also have Incorporated some information regarding some anticipated reductions some administrative positions too looking at some retirements and some other things too uh so we've got some administr reductions built into this uh budget as well too another item we have in here the learn recovery block rant we've talked about multiple times an open session here to how if your defit spending

204in of itself is not necessarily a negative thing if you have one time money you received in a prior fiscal year which you're spending down the current fiscal year it equates to a deficit relative of the current year so this is an example of we have Lear block rent funds which we are spending down but we've anticipated the elimination of those funds and so our budget reflects we're we're managing those dollars accordingly okay so these funds have been used for whole variety of different Services over the past school years so the tremendous benefit of our district and we're going to making some adjustments to um reflect the reduction in the actual funding so that's been woven into our forecast okay I put in a comment here about preschool expansion and again to talk about brilliant

205work uh several people involved in the expansion of preschool for our district um but we look at currently that the the program itself on the state funded side is operating of death of the current year but the way that the pr skill program works is you have to incur that expenses show the need which is a little zany but that's how it works so it can be seen as a one-time expense which we will see and we have seen that we will receive fun more hopeful and thanks to the tremendous work in the superintendent uh and his knowledge in this uh in this area too we've seen a tremendous increase in our funding which is we talk about that strategically as a district the tremendous influence it has on our community so thanks to the

206superintendent and the whole team for their work um the directors we have just do incredible work and a lot of people on that team just doing great work for us partial tax planning again for us measure B uh we have a reserve and we've had a reserve in the past we spent down we spent some onetime money in the p in the prior year uh when it came to recuring retaining but just like measure B we'll have to make some adjustments into the next fiscal year because we're spending on some in the reserve this year and it's nothing that's it's man we're managing it it's we're we're it's not a passive thing we're aware of it we're doing deliberately special education our special education expenditures continue to increase we talked about we heard from several

207folks on stac you talked about too earlier tonight about the impact of the pandemic so we're still you know helping people walk down the path okay but we're seeing increase in our expenditures and we're working on that too shortterm long term uh expansion of TK this is just more of a political commentary too about uh how basic gate districts don't receive TK funding and there's initiatives underway to see that funding uh come to basic gate districts so we are St expansion TK which is fabulous as well too but it's not a uh it's not there's not State funds that we deliberately receiv for that which non-basic districts receive uh the California youth behavioral health initiative and we've a comment here too how district will be able to build for reimbursement expenditures that are covered by

208the California youth behav Behavior he initiative and thanks to Susie Riley for her tremendous work in this area too um and we anticipate we'll be able to incorporate those funds into our Budget moving forward we haven't as it yet but I expect those funds will materialize will help relias some of the expenditures we incur currently okay so again we're looking at a lot of different facets of the budget okay and Community Schools funding we we're going to incorporate that into the the budget too and it's going to provide us some relief for some expenditures we incurring currently that are funding out things like Lo recy block grant okay so that's a big snapshot 20,000 flip view for you on the high level things looking at highlights we provide you these assumptions spreadsheets too and a

209summary for the public to which condenses down things like Cola and enrollment and Ada uh these are pretty straightforward um we look at some of the FTE changes we're looking at for the upcoming year 2526 six and we have things in here like Sten column increases our statutory benefit increases too we're looking at and we incorporate to the multi-year document you have in your in your saxs report document tonight too okay other assumptions here too we've got property tax growth rate uh for the current year and the next two prospective years at 4% uh as of yesterday after as thanks um we'll see how that goes oh that's me okay um So currently for next year is tracking right now the rooll track right now for next year is about 2.58% that's about what it

210was for you know for the when we budget the current Year's growth the 4.5% for the current year um we were about 2.5 or 2.75 last year in the same so I expect we're going to see in this range of 4% but it's a forecast for next year as that tax roll grows um this is what's really really uh the nucleus of our funding is what's happened with the property taxes because we're a basic district and uh we're depend on let our proper tax growth is okay um there's comments about what's going to happen at the federal over funding I think it's a question mark for everybody but we've got a longstanding history of baring of a very conservative fiscally responsible District that's part of our strategic plan it's a core to our district too

211so we're optimistic but we're also conservative and we'll manage whatever whatever the changes are we'll manage it and take care of our community okay so this giv you breakdown some of the assumptions built in for the current and future years then there's a couple slides here too of you know general fund uh projection at a glance total revenues total expenditures what's happened to our in fund balance in in the current year and then um also this continues into what the revenues we have for the current year unrestricted and restricted what those dollars look like and then again we look at our first inter general fund expenditure on both the unrestricted and restricted side and um and then this gives you a snapshot to of what our multi-year budget looks like what our multiple year projections

212look like and again at the end bottom here we shall be getting fund balance in any fund balance and this isn't dramatically different what you have the adopted budget level okay so again a snapshot for all of you what things are looking like um the unrestricted fund balance projections to and the components of that what that looks like for the current year and perspective years as well too and that's not dramatically different from what was the adopted budget so this is giving you a snapshot what it looks like for us to on the unrestricted side what those components of it are okay and then this also has a slide here to of the other funds not just the general fund but the other funds in the district too and what our uh beginning balance are

213what our anticipated revenues and expenditures are and will we estimate our any fund balance be okay so that's a quick snapshot for you we give a written narrative we give PowerPoint slides there's all those sax documents in there too which have a lot of different components of information there for you as well so that's a quick snapshot for you of um some data and then the next checkpoint we have for you is our audited financial report for the 2324 fiscal year which will'll bring to you in January okay January February all right so that's a quick snapshot for you and I will stop sharing thank you very much presentation I'll open up to the board now I have a question about um slide four okay regarding um billing for the behavioral and health yes um

214have we always uh been able to build medical for uh students who are not qualified or is this something new I'll jump in on this one president Brooks during the pandemic um the federal government and the state government opened up you know some pretty significant sources of funds for school districts if you recall um gear Esser and learning recovery block grant those dollars are expiring they're expiring you know in very significant ways for districts uh because we're conservative in how we budget we've quietly kept things um from feeling destabilized because we budget in a very um thoughtful and strategic way um but while those new buckets of money were being offered to school districts uh the state did something uh that could potentially be very helpful to school districts they opened up a new source

215of funding called the California youth behav behavioral health initiative and they did it because at the time during the pandemic children were on weight list of six months a year to be able to see a mental health clinician at a county office and so they passed this law establishing this this initiative and essentially assigned this whole project to the Alita County Office of Education saying figure out how school districts can build for Behavioral Health Services that are provided uh on school campuses and we'll start to funnel money to school districts so that kids get direct service earlier we've never had this money before so three years ago alam's County Office of Ed created the first pilot to be able to document this service being provided and only this year school districts and county offices throughout

216the state have been invited to utilize money to set up these these systems to to account for the services that we're providing kids so we um as a school district receiv received just over 200,000 this year to basically to develop our time accounting system and we have a partner that we work with um Paradigm that already has a different type of system place for us so they're basically taking what they have for us and they're creating you can call it version 2.0 for us um and at the end of this school year we believe that it's going to uh lead to uh the full-time establishment of these approved time accounting programs so think about when you've had other presentations where the district talks about how many counselors social workers Mental Health defs toses for student

217support restorative toses work in the school district and potentially those very people could be part of this uh youth Behavioral Health Initiative to account for the services they provide because in so many other districts those positions are funded with those onetime dollars in our district we've actually built it into a lot of our ongoing funding so we're more protected and what this is going to do is going to be able to make those Services much more permanent for long and we hope fingers crossed uh we already actually have a separate example of this and that's the medical reimbursement they call in education we refer to with his mom MAA and uh and and this has been going on for many many years it is tedious and it is difficult and you get the money a

218lot later but you do get the money so we're feeling really good about this as a potential source of money for us but it is absolutely a new source and I have one more followup question um regarding that um initiative if a parent uh does have uh medical insurance for their kid and we also are able to provide um uh Services as well can that be um a hybrid where it provide more comprehensive um services for a student as I understand and I I'd like to come back to a future board meeting um with a very thorough answer but as I understand it um when students have external um uh you know insurance coverage to be able to to receive U mental health support whether it be through a counselor or Clin uh school districts

219very rarely provide the additional uh service to the student one reason is in the counseling domain uh sort of the importance of having of not having the the two counselors or the two service providers providing a a you know if you want to call it not necessarily identical but a similar type of service um and I think we would just need to get an answer from um the state and from the county office on uh how that might sort of work in the future in terms of that pilling process um I I think there it's an interesting question but I definitely want to research it and come back with with a good answer for you thank you one of the things I was considering um when I ask that question is that if there are

220um students who may need more comprehensive support um if we are already providing it if we can provide the provide it to the extent that they need it and then we are able to build their insurance I I believe that and and like superintendent was saying too that we'll get clarity on this explicitly but I believe there is a thread through this I think that some of the intent is that there is a um proximity um uh to provideing support that students need um at their School site as opposed to how to travel elsewhere so I believe there's a thread through this that will if I'm not mistaken Susie you can correct me but that will work through if someone does have insurance that they may u that they may get build somehow but the

221funding comes to us for services and that's an awkward way for me to say it but there is some connection but I don't have the explicit details yeah thank you anyone else like to have any clarifying questions this is an acent so if I could ask for a sorry I'm sorry but we do need to open for public com sure yeah okay I'll open up for public comment anyone in the audience anyone on Zoom Joe checking on Zoom no public comments on Zoom thank you well this is up for a vote um I get a motion to pass this motion to approve all in favor say I hi right we will move on to item 9B educator housing Task Force update Mr superintendent take it away all right while we were in here it seems

222like uh Patrick you were in here with with the group and John but it seems like it was at least seven or eight days ago seems like it was a long Kathy you were in here it was last wasn't it it was earlier this morning this room looked nothing like this and we had a very different meeting uh I don't know if somebody else on on the day on the executive cabinet can project the item go in and share your screen Patrick that's okay Patrick um but what we have for the school board this evening um is for your um it's a report for you in which this group that has been at this since August uh and over the last five months it's been 16 different individuals uh we had a pretty consistent um

22312 that came to multiple meetings um during this process um and as some of the board um saw first hand um you know these meetings they're three and four hour meetings and uh we had um you know some practitioners who came and talk to us we had legal council come and present to us our uh Deputy superintendent and I presented uh and we really went through a very very rigorous and thorough process to discuss um Workforce housing and educator housing and so at the end of our November meeting the committee really felt that we were approaching um strong consensus on making recommendations to the board and I think from the very beginning the committee understood that our role was advisory that ultimately the five members of the school board are in a position to U

224make decisions about the direction that this District goes in um and really it's the five of you all that will decide what takes place um moving forward with educator housing and the group wanted to give very strong recommendations so we Coes the ideas in the room and they were sent out to our committee members uh prior to today's meeting and we conducted a survey and shared the results of the survey today with everybody who was in attendance um we had seven recommendations and you see them up on the screen if you have a computer you can see them right in front of you these recommendations uh went through the very initial survey process with our committee but they also uh went through a second process today in the meeting where the group deliberated for about

225an hour and 20 minutes on these seven recommendations in some cases members of the group felt like the wording was spoton and we felt really really good about the recommendation and others we went back and forth for 20 minutes on just one recommendation and we landed on some changes that are put before the board so what you all are seeing is the final version of these recommendations recommendations that first came from the sourcing and the coalescing of people's comments ideas uh suggestions that were formulated into a survey instrument that was sent out to everybody on the committee um where these committee members um then essentially gave feedback indicating their strong agreement agreement or their disagreement or in some case a strong disagreement um and and then through a discursive process this morning we arrived at

226what you all are seeing today I asked Diego Perez and thank youo for doing this to lay them out in a way that showed what this might look like over time um because the committee did feel like certain recommendations could be and should be implemented sooner than others um and so I'll go through what they are the first recommendation is a leadership subcommittee recommendation and the recommendation is for this board to direct me to uh gather interested parties to serve on a Workforce housing leadership committee and this is a committee that would ultimately guide the work Champion the work and present publicly on the work uh with no more than nine members on the committee there was a a survey recommendation indicating that within 30 days we should contract the services of a firm that

227would put together an effective and upto-date current survey for our classified certificated and administrative staff to be sent out uh with a total focus on housing housing needs housing uh access um and and long-term needs for the potential employees there was a 60-day recommendation uh that this board craft dra and approve a board resolution um that would indicate the strong support for this work that would help the public understand the context for needing this work to take place and potentially include um directive language that would guide the the process that would continue to uh unfold as it pertains to Workforce housing um we did discuss that it is ceremonial and in this this case we felt like this ceremonial um approval process would be important it would actually really bolster the communication of what's likely

228to take place um and so for that reason we felt we felt good about that recommendation there was a Communications recommendation that within 90 days um the board would direct myself and Diego perz to craft a Communications plan process uh not to complete the communications work but to devise a strategy around deep engagement of internal and external uh constituents to establish public town hall meetings to host informational sessions in and around potential properties for Workforce housing uh there was a recommendation for a 90 within 90 days for a feasibility and architectural recommendation uh ultimately this board would consider um bringing on an architectural firm that could uh give us a pretty uh well well researched well analyzed uh report indicating the likely number of units that would be possible at a locations such as chess

229drive or at the NES um the feasibility of doing those at each site and uh potentially develop some renderings now we did hear during this process from a trustee in the Jefferson Union High School District who really Champion having something visual to look at because it helped um dispel myths about what Workforce housing might look like and so the last would be to uh engage in the process to bring on bond counsel um for the purpose of um analyzing and considering uh the involvement of a of a bond in order to support this work so in our last uh Schoolboard meeting President Proctor indicated that at tonight's meeting receiving these recommendations would be really helpful um and she indicated that it would feel more right it would feel more logical to um again agendize in

230January so that the public and yourselves have time to sit with it um think it over and and ultimately on our part uh give it the due consideration before moving forward on any recommendations and as a board you all have the right to say we want to do it in February or March really ultimately or we want to change this or we think the language should look one way versus another um I having spent this time with the committee uh that was in here one of our Board of Supervisors Mayors and Council persons from both of our cities representatives from the Community College District both of our employee unions um staff members who have a vested interest community members um multiple members of our executive team we did have a very very rich array of

231background and um and experiences and so I can I can certainly attest to how thoughtful and how rigorous the process has been for everyone involved and uh it's with that background and that context that I present this uh to the board you will have members of the committee coming to your January meeting knowing that it will have given us time to sit with it and the public time to sit with it and I know some of these folks want to come and talk to you in person so I've invited them to do that um either via Zoom or or actually physically in person uh and then with that I would my recommendation to the board is uh to the extent that you want to ask clarifying questions or potentially discuss this initially but maybe just

232keep it at those very initial discussions to avoid uh getting too deep into it knowing you want to bring this back at a future meeting and with that I'll turn it over to president Brooks thank you superintendent open up to for any I have a couple questions um one is so in the feasibility and Architectural recommendations are the only two properties we're thinking of are Nos and chest drive at this point in time those are the two properties under consideration okay and then um so I know we have some land at Bayside that we like explored land swaps or anything beyond just these two properties as it pertains to the the committee work that took place over the last five months we haven't uh as you know we do have considerable property there um just

233adjacent to joinville um and it is under an agreement with the city of Sano that um spans through 2040 um and so that you know I think correct me if I'm wrong Patrick but I believe it's 2040 um and at the same time you know these agreements they're always something you know that's part of the the discussion between the two entities of how to utilize it and what it's best uh there for um the this group the housing task for did Focus you know all their time and energy on chess and the okay um I just one more question so on this survey recommendations um it says select a firm to develop and Implement a housing interest survey will like Educators be included in developing the survey so that we're asking the right questions and

234no no because the sa the psychometricians uh these firms uh do essentially do this on behalf of of entities on behalf of school districts I think um if the board had an interest in um bringing on a firm and then having this a process to vet questions or take it through um a review prior to implementing the survey I think um you know we could certainly pursue that um as the board might direct us to do so um we wanted to pull ourselves meaning like the District administration out of the process because when we create surveys you know we're not professionals at this so we do our best but even the survey I gave to the committee you know in preparation for today's meeting there were multiple instances where committee members said well I thought

235I didn't know you meant that with that question so I answered it in this way but you know we're doing our best but we're not you know we're not survey writers so that's sort of where it comes in is wanting a you know a professional in the area of writing survey questions to have that um that responsibility but at the board's direction we could act absolutely bring on maybe a subcommittee or a small group to look at the questions before we administer to all of our employes I guess I'm just thinking I don't know is are there firms that specialize in educator housing surveys are we get like I just want to make sure that the right questions are being asked and that they know our area and who the people are that would there

236I you know the firms the the survey firms um produce them for district as you know there are lots of districts that are doing this Statewide they certainly create surveys for you know private businesses and for public entities and um and so I don't think that necessarily only focused on that specialization which within their their field um but but it's certainly something that we can uh interrogate if and when the board would uh direct us to do this we could bring on uh the selected firm and um potentially have process where we look at the the survey instrument and run it past you know as you know we have uh folks that we meet with in both of our unions um you know just basically give it the smell test and say hey there is

237there anything in here that just doesn't look like it makes a whole lot of sense or even like I said a small focus group or a subcommittee to kick the tires on the instrument um because when once it goes out it's out right so I sense you know the question of like you know how does this sperm necessarily know what to ask teachers and what to ask classified staff um so I think it's probably a really good secondary process to thank you um I can I just um thanks for for bringing this to us and I know that um a lot of people spent a lot of time on on reviewing the options um with respect to I think the the property that trustey Proctor was mentioning I think um one of the concerns with

238that not just the the fact that it's um it we have an agreement till 2040 and so it affects like the urgency of of development but also the fact that it is by the water um and so um I think within the task force we had discussed um being you know thinking in terms of climate change how that might affect any development and if this is like kind of our one opportunity to develop the significant um amount of housing um these the other two partials seem to make more sense in particular Ms so um I think just in case I was talking about swapping the land not building okay got it um yeah I think oh I think we were sorry questions um um for the um leadership subcommittee um who like who would be

239part poti part of the subcommittee uh given this leadership uh subcommittee recommendation uh and if the board would direct me to put this together I would come to your subsequent uh board meeting with the composition options that you would have I think there are some groups that are sort of no matter what we absolutely have to have them included on both of our employee union groups your Deputy superintendent and Facilities person so if we count those as four and two school board members that gets us to six if you've got a School Board of five and you you know one of the benefits of having two Schoolboard members is um you know really the visibility and the communication of the work and um and the possibility of it um you know having that that leadership

240Vision level voice in that room um and then so you start to think about uh in in our group today we thought it might be nice to have somebody who uh Works in a nonprofit space or somebody who uh represents other constituency groups within uh the community and um but you also don't want it to be 15 people because then it's really hard to make decisions and and through this process uh you know if the board chooses to go down this path you're going to have a lot of decisions to make and sometimes a Schoolboard meeting is 30 days later than when you need a decision to be made so that's where this leadership subcommittee comes in um and then in our meeting today uh one of the remarks had to do with just wanting

241the balance to not be too heavily uh on elected officials and District administration so nine gets you a balance where maybe five out of the nine are not either an elected official or a district administrator and they that felt like a really good balance for the group today thank you I two clarifying questions I guess off let try that again I to clarifying questions um the first on the board resolution I think I've asked about this previously what how far I guess would the resolution go would this be green light we fully in or would this be we're authorizing an exploration the reason I ask is because it sounds like the communication and public engagement follows that and the concern that we have is we are operating in a room our all of our planning

242meetings have been people work fully bed but when I'm out in the community I'm still hearing questions like couldn't we just get everyone a stien instead and so I don't feel like we're at a point where there is a consensus in community and if this is contingent on eventually public approval of a bond the idea of have of approving everything with a leadership team and the board and then going to the public to sell them as opposed to giving the opportunity to engage before that decision is made seems critical to me so if this board resolution is essentially an all-in green light and then we start launching Communications plan to me that feels like in my backfire and On a related note I was going to ask with similar bonding issue as previously at what

243point do we do a poll because one thing we're heard to csba from certain groups is that there is a feeling that Californians as a poll are getting like you know meas me T pass and S but there is this sense of the constant biannual Bond measure losing Steam and so to what extent do we want to see where we are at before we start laying down all the ground work and spending fun I'm going to try my best um yeah every Bond measure is different and even in Santo County there are school districts and entities not just school districts but as you know other public entities can pursue Bond measures uh who struggle to pass even one Bond and might have to go three and four times before they get one pass um I

244think we got to a place in this District where it was on you know a knife's edge on a couple of bonds one that didn't pass and then um I know some of Allison and some others on the board lost a lot of sleepless nights trying to get you know the public support and rally around uh Bond measures that are currently in place when we went out for our bond the district identified a billion dollars in needs for facilities and our last Bond was over 400 million so we knew at the time that the district's facilities needs were not going to all be addressed through this one Bond measure uh we have some very talented people uh who are doing incredible work all over the district um and as you know each time we we

245open up a new facility it's an advertisement for the work that we do and for the fiscal responsibility that goes into um turning a campus um from kind of downtrodden and sad to a place that you say wow I'm really glad my kids go to this school and um and so I think to before we address the resolution on the bond side of it I think we as a district come into this with um you know over the last six seven years with the parcel tax delivering on what the parcel tax was intended to do and with this school construction um Bond delivering facilities that are beautiful and UNS schedule and on budget um we're coming in with some really strong you know uh things in our favor the resolution and the recommendation from the

246committee that met earlier today is that it's important as a board to consider making public proclamations about what you believe and why you believe it because it it calls to everybody's attention that something is coming down the line so this resolution wouldn't be a green light because there are a lot of things that would happen after this to to agree to pursue a bond potentially to approve architectural renderings to uh you know this process has a lot different components to to find the partner to help us manage to determine criteria so there's just a lot of work that would lie ahead this would be very much um a resolution that I would that I would put forth to president Brooks and to vice president Tren and to everybody else on the board indicating uh recommended

247language that would uh be clear enough for our resident base to really understand what this board has an interest in doing um and forecast what might be coming down the road so it doesn't really lock the board in and uh the reason and and sort of connecting it to the communications plan is again on our part an attempt to um be communicative to the point of building support for this as opposed to um sort of playing catch up with families and having to explain things you already did um I will say you know in my remarks about Bond measures every bond is different but one of our partners in Santa clar County passed a more than1 billion doll Bond and educator housing was one of the sentences on the flyer that was about the extent

248of what was shared so some so you might have Bond consultation that says be really really brief about it don't go into too much detail and then you have my might have Bond consultation that says let's go door too and really sell this thing and let's give as many details as possible because we know this is a multi-year process we want this communication uh and our recommendation to the board is to go this publicly with our communication to really facilitate this broad level um discussion because we believe the need is so significant and our tools and our toolbag are so um ready to implement that this is our time to do this work and just to follow up and thank you for that clarification on the resolution itself I think my only encouragement would be

249to move up our communication timeline because again when we are in the community it's less about how are you going to do this but there's still a very strong sense of should we go through with this and I think one thing we learned to CBA last week I believe with San Diego on District move forward they had a very strong fiscal rationale for why this made sense and I think much most of the board don't know TR is on this but most of the board here has been very public about the support and moving forward but at the same time we learned this past election that voters don't like to be told by experts what they should like they have their own formed Impressions and so to the extent that we can meet them where

250they are they may not know that we own property in N they may not know why the rationale makes sense to have a school district build a property become the landlord and what potential revenue streams or risk that opens us up to and so I know that'll be part of the collective process but to the extent that any of that is available beforehand that we can get it up online so that even those of us out in the community can start to test these ideas and see the typ of reactions we're getting I think will be helpful and so just moving up that timeline but I don't necessarily think it's changing the direction of the board just making sure that we have that information before we end up in a situation where we essentially decided

251the direction and now we're trying to tell people why board members like to ask me clarifying questions right open up to the public all right we open it up to zoom Jo excuse me checking Zoom no public comments on zo we have an in person oh we have an in person and have an in person yeah was sharing the fact that trusty ho is now sitting in that position best um okay so I am so impressed by this timeline because my brain was thinking that you guys were going to hear a recommendation in February so I'm I'm so impressed and the due diligence that happened and and the meetings that occurred um I just want to give my thanks to all of you for supporting that and this is not an easy thing to do

252and I also appreciate the followup questions that you guys have asked um particularly the two that you guys asked because that shows a level of understanding of what our community is going to be concerned about so thank you for all that work thank you very much all right the next we oh I had a comment um just to kind of pig back off trusty Kim's um comment in terms of the like timeline I'm wondering I think it would be very powerful to have the survey results before we communicate before we do a board resolution just to show like what is the actual need and desire of our Educators that we're building this housing for um so I don't know um how long it will take for survey results to come out but I think that

253that could help build a strong message I think I had another comment but now I can't think of it oh oh I so I think also with um you know a lot of bonds and partiel taxes I think that by moving forward with this in a way we're saying facilities is like we could we can't do two bonds we can't do a facilities Bond and housing Bond I don't I don't I mean I'm sure we could but I don't know that the taxpayers and voters would support that so just want to make sure that we are all in alignment that right or no h yeah is this all housing or I I think I kind of understood um the bond would come at the direct in terms of strategy would come from the bond strategist

254and that could include both facilities and housing okay um it based on our need that's how they would determine what wording would be and what would be encompassed under that information that okay thank you for that and um I just have a comment regarding the housing the housing market here is not g i mean it's only going to get worse and I know that um we have an issue with retention just like many other districts and many other just you know businesses in general um we need housing in fact we we have to build housing here in Fuster City and in San Matel everyone has random numbers that they have to meet um and then in order to sustain um you know the best teachers the best staff we need to be able to provide

255affordable housing in my opinion and I mean I do um agree with the survey however I do feel like um making a commitment to this District building housing which is a high priority and a um you know a real need here I don't I mean I the to me the um survey would be to understand you know who but we know for sure we need to move forward in my opinion I'd like to make a comment as well um you know as an educator when I finished my master's program um my first job was with the okah high school district and my first job was $40,000 a year and you know this this is something that is is really true to a real struggle for um Public School Educators so this resonates very deeply with

256me so I I um V to move forward with the recommendations that I don't I know we have to take a vote but I'm just so we'll bring it back to the board in January anyone else thank you um now we will go to it 10 and we discuss the theal changes [Music] to and that is Mr Cosmos thank you very much good evening Board of Trustees superintendent Ooa and our audience uh John Cosmos Executive Director of Human Resources um I'd like to briefly review with you one of our recommended changes to board policy specifically regarding TK credentialing requirements that will go into effect on August 1st of 2025 um attached to the board agend is a Redline draft of those credentialing changes um starting on August 1st 2025 one of the ways teachers can

257qualify to teach uh transitional kindergarten is to have what the state of California is calling comparable experience that each School District can determine um with board approval so so basically in lie of having um for instance uh 20 for units of Early Childhood uh education or for instance a Child Development permit both of which would qualify you to teach TK um in lie of those two things you can meet the comparable or comparable experience requirement if the board approves that that um experience so with that our recommendation um to the board is that the comparable experience be one year of full-time experience in TK or kindergarten um and if that the board chooses and tonight this is just for information and discussion um but if you choose to um approve that recommendation then all of

258our TK teachers who are currently in our our classrooms will be eligible to teach transitional kindergarten for the 25 26 school year so with that um are there any questions comments I have a comment I think that's long over do thank you um for U bringing us to make those changes uh we have a lot of qualified people who absolutely deserve to be able to teach um if they haven't gone through this process of become certificate so thank you thank you for this um I wanted to ask um is are other dist like I guess how does this compare to what other District we've actually collaborated with with um districts within the county okay we go to our um District HR meetings once a month and there's been lots of conversations and we've had a

259lot of discussion with other districts now it doesn't mean we need to do exactly what they're doing but this is right this is in the ballpark of what other districts um are looking at doing as far as comparable experience and so um we feel it it it really is it's comparable to the 24 units or to the um Child Development teacher permit is to have that experience and so that's what um it'll be next meeting where we're going to ask for that approval and then the board um policy for transitional kindergarten will be updated accordingly okay and for um it says one year of full-time experience so I'm just wondering like is that one school year or 12 mon like is there a definition of these terms it's one full school year one school one

260school year and then fulltime is like is there a number of hours that's or is it just okay it's just sort of yeah okay fulltime or parttime right it um I have a question um I'm in support of this I just wanted to ask you know you were sharing what would the number of people who would not qualify if we didn't make this m that's a great we actually looked at that and there were going to be a few that would have had to go back to school and get additional units um so that was part of our thinking too we we we understand you know our teachers are already working very hard and have a lot of wonderful experience and one of the things I didn't mention it's in the policy you have to

261have a California multiple subject credential that's like the starting point for this so they're already credentialed and you know our feeling is if you're going to ask experienced teachers to go back to school teachers who have been already doing what we're to want them to be doing um we thought this was a real Fair approach um as far as getting you know meeting the state requirement and I didn't mention we did have meetings with our transitional kindergarten teachers we talked to our uh to SMA about it with Kathy so everyone's in the loop and everyone agrees this this would be a good good way to go forward that my question um and I just want to e what said about the Define terms especially when we change World policy I guess I did want to

262ask whether or not an approach is considered to I guess do a temporary waiver to each with transition but it sounds like your perspective is that this is better as a permanent change and that our view as a district is that the type of exceptions we're making are in our view equivalent to what would have been the original requirements we would like this to be not a waiver of five years but more so a permanent change to how we evaluate the Readiness for transitional C because the state is giving us that Latitude to to determine as as a school district as a board if that comparable experience meets the need and so it's it's you know every school district might be a little bit different but as I had said before we talked to with

263our colleagues and this seems we're right within the range so that's right thank you I have one followup question um regarding those um teachers who qualify to move into that um category I just want to make make sure that I understand that they won't receive less pay than the person who actually has the certificate that no they won't so they will actually be able to get paid the same as yes the person who technically would have went or who have gotten credential that's correct okay all right um is it I'll open it up to the public are there any questions or comments from the public any on Zoom checking on Zoom no public comments on zoomk I'll move to item 11 um board member statements and request for a future agenda items first I just

264want to say um congratulations to uh trusty Stacy home thank you for joining us today um it was a difficult process but it was a good one I feel like this was a good choice that we made um and then I just want to say thank you to everyone for um your contribution to the meeting today and I want to say just have a wonderful holiday and off rest time off I have a few things I went through um I know I know we're already running LA but I did have a few statements I wanted to share uh first off I just wanted to thank uh some M time happen so trusty TR and I had the opportunity early this week to meet um with a lot of the newly elected officials all across the

265peninsula at a breakfast that she hosted and as part of that we were able to spend time with our new San Mato city council members uh Council M Fernandez and council member siski and also our Foster City new Council memb council member pishin benat and also um Susie needer Hopper and so it was great to be with them but also we had a chance to then participate or to attend the we Ceremonies for both Sano and Foster City so we have our new mayor Rob new in Sano vice mayor Lorraine and outgoing mayor Lisa Diaz Nash who's been very involved with housing task force the work we've been doing similarly in Foster City we have a new partner and our mayor of State menz vice mayor Kel and then mayor Patrick suvan as well so

266just want to thank them for reorganizations Echo what president Brooks said welcoming our new trustee here trustee Stacy ho um it was a an interesting process but I I hope you know we're very optimistic about our future together as a board and also want to congratulate you know president Brooks and vice president Tren one thing I wanted to add in part as a future agenda item actually before I do that I know Diego is not here anymore but I did want to know when we got that tsunami warning last week and all of us were in Anaheim for cspa there were a lot of parents and others who were very concerned got the on their phone they were just very complimentary about our District's response the fact that we were able to get a statement

267out that quickly the fact that every parent got a phone call and got text messages and other messages immediately they were just you know they're used to inefficiency when it comes to public care offeres and the fact that our district handled that as well as we did especially when the superintendent and trustees were offsite was just a huge Testament to the team that we have here so District leadership to Diego and others who were involved just want to credit you again because when we do things like that right it helps to restore so much trust with parents and I'm on a lot of different Facebook groups and group chats where people have mixed feelings about our performance but on that they universally just praising the fact that we were able to do that so quickly

268and in many cases even faster than their places of employment or other public agencies were able to and so which is very helpful in terms of diminishing the kind of panic and uncertainty initially set in um the future agenda items one of the hottest topics that we heard at csba was specifically around Ai and I know that's a hot subject it can be a problematic subject bring up in schools but there were issues about whether or not teachers should be allowed to use it for assisting with grading or work on the background or reducing cognitive load there are a lot of questions about elementary and middle school students who will start an next in ch GPT and they might finalize it in word but when they take those steps does that violate our academic honesty

269policy does that how does that play into the type of rules that we have existing in the district and are they up to date enough so whether it's on cyber security Ai and a lot of other kind of policies that may exist I would love a chance to reevaluate whether or not those are meeting the moment that we're actually in right now and similarly I think the topic that many of the trustees have heard the most about over the last few weeks is this issue of after school care and a different contexts we know that some changes were made in District but also specifically for college park man emerging school and Gardens there was a question about whether or not the annex program would be able to provide in language immersion after school which is

270a large part of the reason that parents send their children to these schools and one reason they can sometimes do not opt for the annex is because they would rather find a paid service that allows for that immersion but in an Ideal World we would be able to do that in the annex as well with staff that we hired and so that's one thing they brought up but also across multiple sites we had changes in the after school offerings on site which for a lot of parents I me for me personally as a parent district is one of our greatest sources of uncertainty changing year over a year is a big pain point for us and so to the extent that we this may be something that happened this year that moving forward will have

271a smoo transition but it is something that I'd like to be able to communicate to our families because I know there's been a lot of news that came up this month right going into the holidays that has a lot of parents just a little bit frantic about what their next steps might look like so to the extent that we can provide more visibility and information I think that would be helpful um just I I think this is coming up in January but um I um want to just reiterate that I want to have a a robust discussion about digital safety and um you know we have some policies in our Middle School that help with this but um just thinking more broadly about like what um programs our students have access to and um what

272is in terms of like the purpose of the technology that we issue I know that we've heard some concerns from parents about like especially younger students getting a little bit too attached to their devices and um just like having that be a struggle so um I I want to um flag that again and just make sure that we have are able to um you know invite those concerns and those parents into the room with us all right um future dates um future meeting date next is January 23rd for motion toour motion to all in favor say [Music] I for

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.