CorpusRecord 106872

Santa Rita Union School District - Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / SantaRita USD
Date
2024-12-12
Location
Monterey County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
15,970 words · about 89 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e checko too there it is it's going through Zoom see right there perfect I was ch space yeah check one two check one two check check check check all right you're going have to be like the would be on does that make sense let me let me get these that whole e e e is check one two look at the levels there good good good read e look it's it goes through you see what I'm saying yeah e e e can can only pick up got it got it baby can squishes can you take your breath can you take yeah oh you it's oh hello checking 2 two awesome and my levels are there all right y I'm going to edit that here real quick and we should be good good oh yeah

002it's on the red arm so maybe that's why it sounds like that to her yeah um check turn the mat no it's fine because that that that's just for that speaker you I mean you're fine necessarily okay gotta check one to and then um we should have the last one too gotta love technology guys check check check perfect e e e M check we good all right uh good evening everyone we're reconvening into Open Session um during close uh during close session we did uh the during close session the board approved a one-year job share assignment for the 2526 school year for employees number 16046 and 16495 the vote was 5 all right board members hopefully had a time to review our consent agenda any modifications I a motion to approve the consent agenda items

003and also if possible would move uh 9.4 ahead of 9.1 all right can we call for a vote second Sor as amended second thank you all those in favor I I motion 5 Z all right we're going to move on to report and correspondence 6.1 Sorita Teachers Association do you have a member here okay uh so good evening members of the board SRTA would like to remind our board members that we the Sanita Union School District pride ourselves on being a small District that works together well to do what is best for our students with that being said when a board member states that and I quote we value teachers input but that is out that this the cell phone pouches is outside of teachers purview it shows to SRTA that you don't actually value

004our input this is not a well-received or welcoming sentiment for moving forward in future endeavors also it felt that we were being admonished for not attending in person to show our appreciation for ratifying the tenative agreement last week last month SRTA would like to remind the board members that this these meetings are streamed live on YouTube and Technology allows us to attend these meetings virtually not being able to see us physically in front of you does not mean we are not paying attention or thankful for the tenative agreement or anything else presented at board meetings I am not sure why the board the members of the board have decided decided to seemingly push back on teachers but it has been noticed and it will be remembered on a more positive note we would like to

005say thank you to Jacob sandal Cindy Lopez and Ela Ariano for visiting our middle schoolers and thank you to Sarah Turner for reaching out to our board to our members for their opinions on the cell phone pouch discussion it was great to have you all on campus and it was great to have these conversations and I think that truly it was productive and Illuminating for both sides um SRTA still feels that now is not the right time for cell phone pouches but I will allow the public comments from Individual teachers to speak for themselves thank you all right next up we have 6.2 uh cscs uh employees Association do you have a member here uh good evening everyone I'm here to Sunshine for the upcoming reopener negotiations for 24 2025 and I'm going to read

006the articles that we are interested in opening um we are interested in opening article four hours of work CA has an interest in clarifying and enhancing language to maximize and ensure Equitable assignment of overtime extra time access to and Leal opportunities call in call back time Etc but before that I'm going to go ahead and read what I was supposed to read before um the California School employee Association and its chapter 503 are submitting its initial bargaining proposal in accordance to with Section 3547 of the government code for the upcoming reopener negotiations 2425 and again um after Article 4 we are also um CSA has an interest in clarify oh um Article Five compensation CSA has an interest in negotiating a fair and competitive salary increase for its bargaining unit members csca um also has

007an interest in establishing ongoing participation in the state's classified school employee summer assistance program as codifying fire Education Code section 455000 to provide a pathway for its bargaining unit members working 11 months or fewer to assist in Bridging the financial gap experience during summer months when they are without employment or underemployed and ineligible to receive unemployment benefits and to provide them with the opportunity to receive matching funds allocated in the state budget for this class classified school employee summer assistance program we are also interested in opening articles six Health and Welfare benefits csca has an interest in negotiating a fair Equitable and competitive Health and Welfare benefits package for its bargaining unit members we look forward to a mutually productive and positive negotiations process with the district thank you all right thank you very much

008next up we have 6.3 superintendent's cabinet [Music] Rosa were you just gonna hold for your budget okay um chrisha you've got your presentation uh Becky I have no comment at this time thank [Music] you all right we're going to go with the board and superintendent uh reports starting off with Cindy good evening is it working yeah more for the YouTube okay so um all I have to report is uh I last week I was able to do a walk through um both of our middle schools gavan View and John gueras um and it was nice to see the kids um in action during their lunch um it I went to go see the to be aware of you know what we're looking at with the pouches and all of that and see I know um

009Mr battel one of our biggest concerns was you know making sure that our children that are pretenting are engaging and not you know I'm just going to I could personally say I didn't see any of that it was a great walkth through on both schools um there was no cell phone usage nothing like that that I saw when I was present so um I thought that was really good uh both of the principles are doing a great job um the kids there's you know both of the schools are different but it's really nice they're playing activities they are um gavan view there's a um Miss cumins I want to say it was Miss cumins um she has a a great room correct me teachers of them yeah yes it was her okay um where she

010has her door open to um the kids they go out there and I mean if I I would want to be there so it's awesome to see that they're involved you know and that just shows positivity and knowing that at least in our schools as of now what I saw um the cell phones are not you know being disturbing to them like and also I was able to meet with some teachers and you know hear them out and what they thought um one of them being U missb and she was actually my 7th grade teacher at gavan View and um it was it was really nice to see her there and and hear here and um what I would say is I if there was teachers that felt that it was an issue I I

011did wish those teachers would have been present to kind of hear you know what issues if any are arising in the classrooms um so far I didn't get that feedback in my walkr on either school so that's what I wanted to come and report to you guys what I saw when I went with um to those visits at Cav and Jong um the other uh thing was the safety Wellness committee I also attended that um pretty good discussions uh about you know making sure that we are keeping our schools you know healthy alternative snacks ideas things like that um uh we also got a little taste of what chrisa will be showing today um with the new our new camera system a lot of feedbacks from our administrators that are they're loving it they're they're

012being very helpful that's so that was really good um and other than that uh I I wanted to attend sita's um art thing but unfortunately I wasn't able to but I know Elva um Sarah and Jacob there so thank you and um but that's all I have to report thank you thank you so since the last board meeting um I attended the facilities meeting which I always find that incredible informative and really helpful in planning um I went to the mural unveiling the two new murals at sanorita which are absolutely beautiful I attended the music concert at gavlin view which was fabulous and then earlier this evening before our meeting we had walkthroughs on the McKinnon campus and here at New Republic and just to let people know when we do that which is every

013couple months the public is welcome to come with us if they want to see like what we're we're seeing when we're looking at the facilities or um so it just I I love being at the schools and getting to see four of them in the past two weeks has been really good good evening since our last um board meeting um on November the 12th excuse me I went to Harden middle school to observe how cell phone pouches are organized and how their system works on on November 18th I went to the curriculum council meeting from 3:30 to 5:00 it was very productive it was always nice to be there with teachers and get their their feedback and as a result of that meeting um uh Mrs uh who's principal there at at Santa Rita yeah

014I always forget the so I always call her by her first name but anyways Mrs kig um she invited me to come to the walkthr that Wednesday so I did it was on November the 20th and what a nice way to see first of all I have a few notes here um the reason for a walkth through is to provide common language and common tool to help Walkers like myself um to be Learners and also to support Walkers like myself as Learners with a means to calibrate their observations so in my observations I observed so many neat unique stuff that's going on in classrooms such as um uh think PA share sh um all the let me see here's some sentence frames Coral responses um the classroom organization to find spaces for the kids um

015the ccul curriculum being used um as what we had seen um there was just so many neat stuff I mean I can go on and on and um and it was a and it with the team that walked through was um Melissa Becky myself and two teachers and our Reading Coach correct okay and um it was really nice it was really nice to see the kids how the teachers are interacting how the teachers are really working hard um then after that on December 2nd I went to gavan view and um John Terrace to a middle school to observe the lunchtime socialization um to see you know the about the cell phone pouches um very interesting we I saw a lot of socialization um during the lunchtime um yeah pretty much um a few might we

016might have seen maybe a few um cell phones I think Jacob did and um but he'll probably attest to that um and then I also went to December 5th gavine views Winter concert that was spectacular that was the most Nic It Was a Very Organized event um I saw beginners they weren't even beginners but they were were they worked very very nicely um they and I can see where they're going to progress into furthering their their musical abilities and um of course the the um the singers the chorus the coral that was really great too on December 6th I went to the unveiling of two murals at Santa Rita beautiful murals I'm excited they're and Mrs Rosen I think worked very hard on that and um and then today I went at 8:45 to go

017see the Santa Rita um concert there or the sing along or the Christmas presentation and what's our music teacher's name there Jody Clark Jodie Clark great she did an awesome job and so did you Diane for our for the for the the Winter concert um so and then this morning I went to Santa Rita's I think I said that and I also took a two-hour ethics training course and passed it got my certificate and um and then I'm looking and then today like uh Sarah says um we went with Victor to a walkr with McKennon and New Republic um to look at the facilities there um and then tomorrow I'm looking forward to the winter wonderland and also Friday is the new Republic so anyways it was a oh you got it it was a

018busy busy busy yeah you have been busy yeah for me I was able to uh do the mural walk through a sanito school it's amazing to see the murals at the different schools it just feels like it it creates more of a welcoming environment for the students and stuff so I know there's another one item on the agenda which we'll discuss later but I'm H happy to support those items going forward um I did attend the walks but I'll save my comments for our conversation at JN gutas and gabin middle school also just to remind everybody we have a quote drive going on um you can get go to Costco and you can get really good high quality quotes for $25 each um so I highly encourage I think tomorrow is the deadline I believe

019yeah I believe tomorrow is so just kind of a reminder to everybody and that's all I got to report thank you um what been kind of a busy uh couple of weeks um you know a couple of things I've been uh with my students uh doing a lot of volunteer work in terms of Thanksgiving dinners and as well as the Parade of Lights um very proud of our community for coming together for that um I did get a chance to go to harden uh Middle School one of my uh former students is one of the classified AIDS who's in charge of the uh pouch program there but we'll talk about that as time comes but I'm looking forward to the uh concert and the presentation for the school district so having said that here we

020go everybody knows how busy the two weeks between Thanksgiving and the winter break car um and so lots of fun events um going to as many of our music concerts as possible I know um the school site's doing some really fun activities with their students some always a good time for Spirit Week um and so being able to visit the middle schools today um I know JG was anything but a backpack day which is always really fun to see what and GB was what Christmas sweater day Christmas sweater day um yeah we're at the district office we Becky is planning a candy cane day for us next week where we're going to wear our red and white so we're going to get in on that action um a lot so a lot of great um

021programming for our students and our families going on which I think is super important I want to give um Julie Johnson a shout out for an amazing Turkey Trot again this year um every every year that I've been here it just feels like it's bigger and better but I do think every year the challenges get are I'm like wow now we're every year I feel like this gets harder um and you know the stations and everything but it was really fun this year to see um other students helping man the Stations from one obstacle to the next which also included math um art and as well as the physical exercise to to get that done how many turkeys this year 240 that's amazing one's heading up the co drive also District Co Drive she is

022student of our kind of been a place anarita has been a place for Ed Victor's work for many many years Lisa I forgot it's also went Ed family services and it was I could do without the teacher donations and people that contributed so it's all done through 100% donations awesome um and so so that's about it I appreciate everyone um putting in all the energy I know how how like taxing that is and all the things but like seeing how many people were there helping at the music concert I know Mr zmer was there handing out the singalong sheets and the yeah and and doing all of those things and like uh Miss Johnson said like how much um teamwork it takes to pull things off and um so I always appreciate how our community

023comes together to do some pretty amazing things so thank [Music] you I don't know it's okay all righty then we're going to move forward with the public comment 7.1 non-agenda items I know and yeah okay I'm just gonna talk for non-agenda items we have three public comment before we do public comment I'm going to make the standard announcement that um each speaker has 2 minutes do um you are not allowed to seed your time um to another speaker and a total of 20 minutes on any particular topic all right so we have um first up is AJ organista a non-agenda item all right I've been on calls all day so pardon me if uh my voice is a little horse um my name is AJ organista I am a parent of a second grader at

024McKinnon Elementary School um I am also an avid Walker to go pick her up um I hope that everyone is privy to the construction that's going on in front of McKinnon Elementary School with respect to the baronda widening project um so I have a couple points I wanted to discuss or at least bring up to the board here um for you know Food For Thought with respect to student and Public Safety uh some of the things that we can accomplish in house that will kind of prepare us for the future uh number one is the idea of a crossing guard as it stands Mr M uh principal who's out there at McKinnon is constantly going out on his own free will to support as a crossing guard um I'm hoping that maybe there's an opportunity

025to weave some type of funds into a budget or somehow incentivize a student or admin or staff member to support as constructions going on um also looking ahead to the construction with well excuse me the implementation of a roundabout Crossing is not going to be any easier from the plans that have been set forth it seems as if though there are four intersections that students by themselves need to cross um so I think it's a very important topic to take into consideration as we move forward into 2025 um with respect to time 30 seconds okay um another item to consider is the amount of parking that's going to be lost at McKinnon Elementary School um the winding project is going to seep into the school property so it's important to consider how much parking is

026going to be taken away for parents to pick up and drop off before and after school um also taken into account that more people are going to be walking so crossing guard is still considering um and then the other thing is to remind all the folks at each School uh traffic speed with with proximity to a school uh constant reminder that uh people got to slow down and pay attention uh before the next speaker goes up Melissa if he can um I know one of the items he brought forward when have been discussed before was the crossing guard can you kind of give more clarification and then how maybe reaching out to City how we can kind of work on something like that um so right now the city is um supposed to be providing

027staff to help with the morning and the afternoon Crossing particularly with the construction going on and if they're not let me know um the I want to clarify one thing the um construction area and the new road will not be encroaching on the McKinnon property and um it McKinnon is a 10 Acre Site the School site and so it's actually it won't encroach now the increased traffic of course when the development goes in will have some impacts um and when uh they widen McKinnon Street accordingly that would but and not into the school itself but adjacent to will have some impact okay next up we have uh Diane giling I know just being me first of all I want to um I want to talk about a little bit about the winter concerts and then

028I want to talk about the honors which I'm sure Tina has not told you about yet this year so first of all thank you to those of you that came to my winter concert um last Thursday it was a show um it went well I was really excited about it and it's been the first time in a long time that I've been able to have um all the kids be at the Winter concert um and that is in part due to the new scheduling this year in a six period day versus the seven period day um so we'll see how well it keeps up following years but thank you again for your support the concert was great it was awesome um we recently got results of which kids um both at J John gutier middle

029school and galin view tried out and who made it to the honor band Middle School honor band Honor Choir and honor Orchestra um Tina right now is calling me her boss so cuz I'm getting her the stuff out to the John Gutierrez and she's calling me up and says what do I do how do I need to do this they have two students um that tried out for Honor Band um Isaiah and I don't remember the last name and Diego I know Diego Isaiah has escorcia but one is a trumpet player one is a baritone player Tina thinks he's a bar he's a bass cler not player but we we're working on that one um and then they had one student trial for Honor Choir and she's a say um Earth she's also made or

030audition and made Honor Choir last year and then they had two students try out for Honor Orchestra this year and um no actually one cello on cello and that student also made it so um so John Gutierrez even without the fact that they don't have a dedicated um like a single music teacher they have the group I believe um taking over them that they did really good these kids were motivated and um they took the initiative and then I had I have several kids between the choir and stuff so it's going to be a good year when I get chance I will tell get the dates out to you thank you okay and next we have chance holsworth hi everybody the last time I was here I was kind of negative I was really wanted

031to be here for something positive and this is unfortunately a little bit more of a mixed bag than I was hoping for but first I want to thank the board members for coming to GV U I want to thank Miss Ariano for making me blush in the first time of member she brought up when she was working in the second my second grade classroom when she was a TA in that class class and oh man that was great um you know the not positive Parts is watching board meetings last few months there's been comments that feels like the teach the district doesn't really value it's teachers um you know we had a contract Mr battel you you should Express frustration that teachers weren't here last month and you know we had a contract that we

032voted for that asked us to work for less money next year I'm going to have a smaller paycheck next year and we voted for it and that contract can make teachers feel not valued by the district you know what when you look at comments saying teachers viewpoints don't matter at the board meetings that makes teachers not feel valued and these are all things I've seen the last few weeks you know I don't believe this is the case I I actually believe every board member I believe our district office do believe in our teachers and value our teachers I believe our district has questions without easy answers I believe our board members feel frustrated by so many comments from frustrated teachers and I think sometimes that leads to frustration coming out but you got to realize

033when you hear when you're frustrated comments from teachers it's because we care it's because our goal is to help our kids to have as best a chance at having an amazing life as possible and we will do everything we can for that we don't want to come complain to you I don't want to complain to the district office I don't want to complain to the school board I never want to bring up something negative that's never a goal I don't know any teacher that does but we want our kids to do well we want our kids to succeed you know we care enough that we voted yes on a contract to be paid less for the privilege of teaching our students am I out of time H went on too long my apologies I hope

034the if the intent is not to make teachers frustrated I just ask that you might want to think about changing the approach a little bit how you respond to teachers and how you get feedback from teachers the pay in any bit the benefits uh cost of benefit you said Pay excuse me you said Pay I said my paycheck is shrinking sir yes and my paycheck will be smaller next year because the cost of benefits is increased by 12% and the M you're increasing to cover we'll cover 10% of that the 2% of the increase up to my benefits cost will be removed from my paycheck I will be receiving less money next year to do my same job I apologize if I was [Music] unclear agenda items all right next up 7.2 uh public comment

035agenda as items okay I'm just going in the order that these were handed to me so no particular order other than the stack Miss Mia Commons good evening I'm here tonight on behalf of many teachers who are unable to attend but who still wish to have their voices heard uh I teach at Gavin View Middle School and as a middle school teacher I believe I understand firsthand the challenges we face in managing cell phone use in the classroom however I also want to point out that the concern that has been raised about cell phones and specifically the concern about how to manage their use during class represents a very small minority of our staff in fact only about 7% of teachers in the district have expressed an issue with any issue with cell phones at

036all so the large majority of teachers have clearly already found classroom management strategies that work for them given that I'm struggling to understand why the district is proposing to spend nearly $200,000 of an already very tight budget on these cell phone pouches money that will not be used oh sorry money that will be used to implement a solution for a problem that is not widespread this estimate does not account for the inevitable cost of replacing brok broken pouches which will become an ongoing expenditure for the district These funds could in defin or and certainly be better used Elsewhere on field trips on athletic equipment we really need laner Chromebooks for students uh even providing teachers with professional development on classroom management which would benefit a much larger portion of our staff and our students yet

037all of these proposals have been met with resistance from the district on the grounds that we do not have the money for them so we see now where that money would be going and we do not support this choice in the district's November curriculum council meeting we reviewed feedback from both parents and staff on the issues that they most want to see addressed by the district and the proposal to spend the substantial amount of money on cell phone pouches was by far the most frequently raised concern 33 people to be exact felt compelled to say something about that uh in fact more people Express their concerns about the purchase than the number of teachers who originally stated that cell phones were an issue yet it feels as though members of the board refus to acknowledge

038the majority held opinion we would like for the district to hear us and to trust that we as community members know what would best serve our students why ask for feedback if it is going to be ignored I ask on behalf of myself and many others that the board please seriously reconsider this use of funding and thank you for your time and consideration okay next is uh Miss Jennifer Alvarado good evening uh I'm here to speak out against the cell phone pouches there are many reasons why to be against it but the biggest reason is why we do not need cell phone pouches I did conduct an informal survey in my classroom regarding cell phone pouches um in the classroom this so 72% of students bring their cell phone uh to school every day 69%

039of the students say that um the the distractions in the classroom are not cell phones they are related to talking to other students daydreaming and other students disrupting the classes uh and just 1% report that uh cell phones distract in the classroom then at lunch uh 85% of the students say that students are not on their cell phone at lunch 89% of the students say that they're playing sports or talking with their friends instead of being on the phone and 64% say how could lunch be improved would be to allow students to talk on the phones or uh use their Chromebooks I believe the simplest solution is best let's just enforce our existing policy no cell phone use at school rules do not need thems rules do not enforce themselves so there is a problem

040then more consequences must be issued to the few students that break the rules to ensure compliance additionally Banning policies like these usually are ineffective the compliant students will dutifully place their phones in the pouches however those that break the rules will find ways to skirt the system such as placing a dummy dummy phone in the pouch or forgetting or losing their pouch or simply state that they have no phone in conclusion I see that cell phones use isn't our biggest most pressing problem certainly not a problem big enough to justify the expensive price tag and Logistics of enforcing a cell phone pouch policy I think taxpayer money excuse me be better spent helping students academically and increase discipline when they are most certainly are in need furthermore we need consequences in addition to restorative Jus

041Justice practices to best educate our students into productive citizens thank you okay next we have Ava Alvarado hello my name is Ava Alvarado I am a sophomore at monov Vista Christian School I attended La Hoya from first grade until fifth grade I also attended Gavin View Middle School and was one of the valorian in 2023 I am speaking out against cell phone pouches at gavan view I think the schools do not need them in my experience at GV teachers the principal staff and yard Duty adult did not allow students to be on their phones at school since students didn't want to get in trouble kids weren't on their phones in conclusion I don't think gavan VI needs cell phone pouches because students aren't allowed to be on their phones at school thank you for your

042time next is Miss Julie Johnson I don't want that I have to that's better oh you guys know me I've been around a while really is am I too loud okay sorry all right so most of you guys know I'm Miss Johnson Julie Johnson been around longer than a lot of you guys have um I want to thank the board Ela I don't know I know for first name Elva Cindy lho Jacob andal um for coming by check us out with our cell phones um Dr Alderman that's weird to call you that Becky came by too also um I'm out there yard duty all the time we're always playing we're doing some type of stupid activity shooting for Otter Pops or racing down playing Mario Karts kids are talking getting dates finding boyfriends girlfriends we're

043not on cell phones yeah we had a couple we've got two that have absolutely no English um so they communicate on their phone one is uh MCO and one is thank you Arabic and so that's like that's those are the couple kids we've got on them um but uh you know it's it's I appreciate you guys it was super fun to be able to sit and talk with you guys and communicate I got some things from BK oh sorry chuni um and we got stuff from the board members it was really nice to be able to talk it's probably the first time in a long time I felt like we were actually heard on that and it was fun it was kind of cool we got some great ideas on how to accomplish this let

044us try to fix something everything everybody's jumping the gun to we got to do something new let us get going and let us practice let us get this in effect for a year so we got the general fund isn't big enough to to support something like this we've got many other things I mean a lot of you guys had a lot of things to say and there's many that are going to support there's other places that we could desperately need the monies um and I do want to make one comment because I know that beeper is going to go off I haven't had that much coffee yet um as one comment I was here for I was one of the teachers from the last board meeting um with the construction people wasn't quite sure why

045there were so many there but I figured out that they were trying to get jobs and appreciated the fact that we were listening to them um but the comment was made continually about the construction workers in the union having a quality of life and I would like to see the board president I'm sorry to put as much consideration in our teachers trying to have that quality of life when I've got colleagues that are working two and three jobs working extra ours to have what is considered an adequate adequate lifestyle not a a comfortable lifestyle I've been teaching 34 years I am just now getting to a comfortable lifestyle that's concerning okay and I'm not a young teacher so please I'd like to appreciate that um I I can't talk speak my tire okay next is

046uh Miss Ashley trip hi okay I'm here to read other people's statements who wanted to present their statements and have them write aloud instead of emailing them directly so up first we have greetings and happy holidays Grant Howton here robotics teacher at John Gutierrez Middle School I have a few thoughts I wanted to share while we are all while we all agree that cell phones are a major struggle for the youth today I would Advocate that teaching the self-control and social skill awareness of when to use and not to use devices is the appropriate response these skills are taught through direct action and consequences at the site level not removing devices from student hands so that they are that they never gain the opportunity to learn that self-control Additionally the cell phone pouches have multiple

047methods for defeating them that are easily Googled such as magnets or using a second cell phone in the pouch these are widely circulated among students furthermore when our stem robotics program at jgms has its budget cut by 60% this year and I see the massive price tag attached to a program with limited efficacy I might question if the significant cost of implementing a program such as this is appropriate for a time period in which we are experiencing budget cuts I am happy to discuss my my thoughts further if anyone has any questions thank you for your time and all your hard work and creating such an excellent District sincerely Grant Howton okay second one I want to express my concern about the proposed expenditure on cell phone pouches oh man okay um and already see

048students managing these guidelines well I I have not seen this as a major issue in my classroom and find the idea of spending money on pouches that will do nothing to enhance learning a complete misuse of taxpayer dollars and a slap in the face to teachers who are spending hundreds of dollars per year to fund their classrooms while on the same token being told by the district that we do not have money for supplies that we need to succeed and Thrive I hope that you will take teacher input into consideration as we are the ones doing our best to make sure that all of our schools are placed where our places where students Thrive Okay the third one I only have two more um the cell phone pouches are a flawed solution that fails to

049a effectively prevent their usage in class while they may seem a sec seem secure at first the reality is that these pouches are easily compromised with a few simple tricks these methods are an Open Secret and most students already State they have plans to find a workaround if these pouches are implemented the pouches create a false sense of security while doing little to actually stop cell phone usage it's been mentioned that teachers won't have to deal with pouches so it's less work for them but at the but the same students that have cell phone issues now will be the ones that are not using the cell phones the pouches as intended and therefore will find a way to disrupt the classroom environment regardless we will we would be investing significant funds into a system that

050is triv that is trivially bypassed with a little with a little Ingenuity and an internet connection it's irresponsible to waste limited education budgets Budget on such an effective measures okay thank you so much next is uh Cynthia Chavez hello good morning or good evening uh my my name is Cynthia Chavez this is my third year teaching in a I'm a teacher at JG Middle School um I'm also a product of Santa Rita District so I just want to say last year was our year that we really started pushing the policy it definitely had its struggles definitely with our eighth graders because for the first two years sixth and seventh grade they didn't have to put their phones away correct um their eighth grade year was difficult I had a lot of push back myself with

051students when students had phones out we would say like hey give me your phone they' be like no no no no this year completely changed students know what the expectations are we say it every day in announcements every time a student has their phone out we tell them to give their phone no argument they give it parents that's a lot less well it's a lot easier now this year last year we had a lot of issues with parents not wanting to come and pick up cell phones this year not an issue we put it in our newsletter every every Sunday parents are also aware of the requirements um I all I ask is that you please hear us out at the end of the day we are the ones in the classrooms with these kids

052every single day we understand our students at JG specifically this isn't an issue a lot of our kids are very respectful when it comes to phones uh many of you have came to visit us at our school site those kids they can communicate with each other and it's slowly getting better at the end of the day technology is only going to advance even more and we can't just take it away cuz it's you know it's not going to work out we got to work with it um um so we have lots of students who are doing a lot better they're working a lot with us I will admit I will let my students use their phones in class to listen to music as you know covid was not that long ago and right now a

053lot of our students are struggling academically and being able to listen to music in class while doing work really helps them out and by taking their phones away we that can cause more issues for us cuz those students will not be able to take the time to really pay attention in class I'm also that activities director at J's middle school so as much money as you guys want to push for this please come talk to me cuz there are lots of things on campus that we can use that money for to make kids excited to come to school because they are excited to come to school but with more events with that money we can fund those events make them a lot better and want kids to be excited so that's all I got to

054say but again if you would like to talk to us about budget I'm definitely here we have lots of things um that we would love to do with the kids thank you all right we're going to move forward with 8.1 technology department presentation all right thank you very much I'm here uh to talk to everyone about our uh installation that we have with our grant for the cops grant that we earned last year and as the presentation's coming up it's okay over the um the course of last year um we spent a lot of time writing the cops Grant um we were able to work with a grant writer in order to acquire funding initially we were looking at um just doing an update on the camera system itself and using what funding we did

055have to incorporate with our current system um and then with that grant that enabled us to have the Monies to be able to do a fullon upgrade for our camera system along with sensors as well for our middle schools it's okay so um I'll just kind of go over the overview and then we can push forward because I do have a video that will come up with that as well um so the overview of that in the spring like I said we did some site walks of uh spring of 2023 that way we were or of 2022 I mean um we were able to use the safety review that was um produced by Kimble and Associates to have an idea if you want to go ahead and move to the next slide thank you um

056to have an idea of camera placement um where safety concerns were um areas that we were needing um further coverage with our camera systems along with that with the site walks we started a pilot of our cameras and as I said initially it was to um find ones that would incorporate with the loric system that we did have once we were able to acquire the cops grant our Grant application we awarded that funding um we were able to look at cameras and sensors we continued with the pilot of the cameras and sensors and this was at uh GV that's because it was attached to our our uh district office site um so we were able to very easily monitor that since that's where our main frame was um so with that uh with the cameras

057and sensors the sensors being the Halo ones that we have in the restrooms and those were Middle School only um and then for spring of 24 uh 24 we were able to do some of our final reviews for our site needs and Equipment orders we um landed with quovo as our installers um and we are using a vigilon camera systems along with Halo sensors for at our middle schools all right I'll just keep moving it's okay Tech happens all right I'll go ahead and go back one more please back there we go all right so um now in the fall we did all of our camera installations uh thanks to Our IT team they uh you know volunteered in their hours to uh move their time into the evening so that way we could work

058with quovo to get all the cameras installed we started with a incremental installation um starting with a GV Middle School um sensors as well asot and so we slowly onboarded we just finished with all of the camera installations just in this last week with those installs we're still working on making some adjustments um the sensors were calibrating still all those types of things um we also had some preliminary systems trainings for our Administration and those that are administering the cameras along with our um site safety Liaisons so that way um um they got a really quick look shock and awe being able to navigate the system so that way um now on to the next for our current status all the cameras and sensors at the sensors at the middle school they Middle School are

059installed and active um we're actually getting in fact I touched space with our um Middle School admin they're getting all the alerts um and so that's been really good along with our campus supervisors they have iPads so that way if an alert comes up they're ready um to be able to do an investigation if needed um our system components for naming and mapping of the sites and all that that's what we're working now currently and onboarding that so we can name the cameras their locations and have that be incremental throughout the district so that way if we have anything it's it's a synonymous naming for each of our sites uh camera angles and like I said the sensor calibration um and I'll show you a view of of what that looks like um for the

060sensors in the next video and we'll also be um preparing for further system trainings for our admin so that way they're even more familiar with the system it's a very robust system we're starting with all of the basic pieces first but there's a lot of other increments that we can start building in over the course of time and training right so some of the key features uh we it is a cloud-based dashboard and I'll be showing you a video of that here in a moment the what that means is it's not what's a DVR based one so as the camera's picking up that footage that footage is going and getting stored into the cloud which gives us a longer period of time so things aren't overwritten on the DVR which is very nice um we

061have cloud and backup camera footage storage locally on the cameras as well in case there's any you know system outages or other things that we can get that backup off of a card um we are able to within the system select dates and times for playback which is one of the things that our principes have really really liked it's saving them hours of time um as they said in the safety committee meeting for having to review um we are able to zoom in and search there's some really robust search features in there and you'll see a couple of them um in the video coming up as well uh the cloud holds footage for about 35 to 45 days depending on the on time and the amount that it's pulling in and we're able to bookmark

062Clips so if we see something or something comes up we can go to that time and date and bookmark it for later and it'll hold it in the system so we can go back to it as well as Rec report and share video footage so before we're having to download it transfer it now we can do it with links and and other things that really and can actually time out the footage so if we send out a link someone can view it for a period of time and then we can shut it off so that helps us with that exchange our Middle School sensors as I said do send alerts to admin and campus super supervisors both via email and a popup and so that's coded for them so they can see those so for

063the video can you go back one and the video queued up here thank you okay so can you pause it for a second and on the enlarge okay so on the video system what you see here this is and what I have is just a view of some various some areas from our various campuses um one of these over here as you can see up at the very top there is are some green sensor lights up here these cameras and we have multiple cameras engaged um to be kind of pointing near and around the bathroom areas at the middle schools so that way we can see when the sensor goes off the sensors themselves um have have the ability to not only pick up air quality vaping um there are also some um some noise

064elements to it it's not recording people talking but it's you know gives alerts if there's like a commotion or something happening in those restrooms um so with these green sensors those are all that tells us they're tied to the cameras and you can go in and search alerts as well as see them in playback if you want to go ahead and roll that footage thank you all right so as you can see we've got some clarity in and around um each one of the campuses had their own challenges for camera placement um with the eaves and and all of that again we're working on some of those pieces but as you can see here we've got some camera accounts I can zoom in on a student and let's say go ahead and pause for a

065moment I'd like to see all students that have a backpack during the day we're trying to see what's happening with backpacks or whatever it is um I'm able to do a a quick people search um the robustness of this again is um if you go ahead and pull it one more time go ahead and play and you'll see it start popping up all instances where we have students with backpacks the nice thing is is it does take the human quality to be able to identify and pinpoint which one we'd like to maybe see um so it's going to pull up all kids it gives a time stamp where we've seen it and let's say okay we want to select a particular one to track and maybe we pick a purple shirt with a backpack so

066it'll pick out those instances of purple shirt with backpack um there's other things that you can do within it if you want to pause one more time um where you can just cue like colored shirts um gender any of those types of things just to be able to see um especially through an investigation if you're trying to track um you know movement or any of those types of things uh go ahead the other piece with the zoom um this is out in front of one of our other campuses um you're able to um pull then I just to see the clarity of the section I did blur out a couple things on this like faces and other thing things um but as you can see you can zoom in on license plates and I'm sure

067someone might recognize their car but not their license plate cuz I did blew out some of it um I did want to show some of the clarity though um so that does have that viewing the other piece of that is if you'll notice we've got um some boxes around this purple indicates Vehicles the blue indicates motion from um individuals walking and so the cool thing with that is if we wanted to say track down a like a white pickup truck for any reason we can ask it to look for vehicles color those types of things as well in in for those investigations and as you can see in these timelines I'm in a playback mode right now I'm rewinding to see some action this is lunch not too much action but kids running around having

068some fun um we can get some people counts in here um in the corner as we're going through if you notice there the little toggles going from 8 to 10 sometimes people overlap but you have an idea a of how many people are in a particular area at one time which is really nice again for that human quality of hey we got a lot of kids kind of over here let's maybe get a person to maybe monitor um not for any reason other than just you know keeping things safe you'll notice there's also boxes for people counts um that are on here that show action as well all right we also have um in all of our campuses in the fores OR at least pointing to the front offices where we don't have a 4A

069all entrances have camera systems so we're able to see all the cameras um again various angles allow us to see things and do counts and you'll notice um here in this next one I'm setting it up to see some of the multiple camera angles you see here where it says task 18 and 19 it has point1 two and three that's one Dome camera but it has three separate camera angles on it to be able to see out and give a wider view rather than a bullet point and shoot type camera um and here's what I'm doing is I'm on this particular one I'm loading the cameras to be able to see various views from that task so this is all One camera but it has multiple views pointing out to the campus for the supervision

070I'm able to go into this this and as it drags over I can change layouts so in this particular one I've got more of a panoramic look with three cameras underneath but I can change the panes to have even multiple cameras running all at the same time um one of the instances that you'll see in here in a second is the time increments I can set them up to be all at the same time for that camera view and here in a second you're going to see as it's rolling through you see a gentleman walking through here you can see the shadow coming up over here and in a second he's going to pop up and walk in through the system so that was all a live view at the time in the playback mode

071it also did the person count in the play Black back mode I was able to see you see the spike here it's showing there's an instance of a number of people walking um you'll see students up in an upper quadrant over here walking they're marked by a people box here in a second you see them in the corner and now in another second you see in the playback it coming across here for the increment again that's one of the features that when of the principles pointed out was really nice because sometimes instances happen over an area so they're wanting to see everything in in the frame so that and you saw the night view that was up um that's just the shot of a new Republic at night so it has a really good Clarity

072so we can tell the difference between a raccoon and a human being um encroaching on campus um so if we get those late night reports um that's it so I just really want to thank um you know again the team in working all the hours and getting these um these installed and I really very much look forward to all the trainings and things that we have with the system any board comments yeah it looks really good I appreciate the new system we have I know on the said that it records up to 35 to 45 days I know sometimes for incidents that take place sometimes the feedback can be further how is that kind of determined and is it possible to record it longer if needed I'm just seeing sometimes there's incidents that you might

073want to go back further but if it's erase after 30 days or 35 days yeah and so that's one of the things I'm working with kovo with to see um I don't I'm not sure if we'd have to pay for a little bit longer length of cloud storage but really 45 days is a a pretty good increment and I said um with those instances we can bookmark and that will reserve it for a long time so if we know of an instance that was happening we can bookmark it and it'll still keep it in in perpetuity for as long as need be I was thinking more you wouldn't discover the incident yeah in that yeah in for the discovery yeah I understand what you're saying with that but but either way it looks really good

074a lot of features that'll definitely help out STS great um thank you to everybody for the hugee amount of work that the grant writing and the installation everything else uh the question that I had because we're adding classrooms um I'm assuming that that's that that we've used up the Grant and as we add classrooms that's going to come out of our own funds yes yes for the expansion uhuh anybody else all right thank you very much that was a excellent presentation all right we're going to move forward with our agendized items our action items actually and we're going to go to 9.4 first which is approval of Yonder cell phone pouches for 6th through 8th grade I'm going to go down the line uh maybe start with Cindy and just some input I kind of

075already put an input I could revise afterwards I'm sorry I kind of okay um I did listen to teachers uh from Santa Rita I reached out to the middle schools in um uh Selen Union High School District my initial feelings have really changed over time in terms of I was very much in favor of the pouches in the past at this point that's not the way that I feel about it in terms of I just I we have such limited resources and um I need to feel like every dollar that I'm spending is going exactly where it needs to go I will say that the feedback from the high school district was extremely positive and they felt like they had real problems that have that have really been solved but in terms of of um

076moving forward for Santa Rita at this time is not something that I'm in favor of okay um so I met with um well Jacob and I met with a couple of teachers and a well three teachers and um a principal and um after um looking at are visiting the sites the two middle schools Harden middle school of course Harden middle school it's in their first year I believe of um cell phone pouches um it it gave me a a a big picture of what it entails but I from listening to the teachers and their the policies that they're following with the cell phones in their classrooms it looks like from last year to this year it's gotten much better it's improved and um I say give it more time give it more time um it's

077just like any other thing you want want to implement you don't know whether you're really going to that particular whatever we're voting on but I just say give it more time and also the teachers are saying give it more time I think um I think they're doing a good job right now with um really implementing the policy and if we've got a policy in the district already um we should just we should just give it another year and um and and let's see how um how it pans out but um that's that's what I feel about it well there's a lot of other things I could say too but um I I guess we have to listen to teachers and we have to really you know I one comment that was made um uh from

078couple of teachers were why are they been asking us for our opinion if we're going to imple the board is going to implement it anyway so I really think we we need to listen and we need to just stop and think and the money but the MoneyWise too um uh it is a big expense so let's just try and give it more time okay well I got to attend the two School sites it was a really uh good conversation uh back and forth and um one of the reasons why I wanted to have that is because I know at board meetings it's always tough to have those type of dialogues so I wanted to be able to have more of a back and forth where there's more kind of an exchange of ideas um I

079think something from the surveys actually did come out um I know there was a teacher that mentioned um you know it's only 11% of teachers we were kind of looking more at Middle School teachers um and for me not that saying pouches are the answer necessarily but I still feel that the service did bring up an issue that there is issue of cell phone use um and I think even when I met with some of the teachers and you know Julie was there and and stuff is I think um there was enough teachers that was a cause for concern that at least we need a plan if pouches are not the answer where um some comments were made like well maybe it's teachers that having you know um established good classroom management or or whatever

080the case is but I think I felt like there was enough voices in there um and I think I looked at the numbers I think it was of Middle School teachers who filled out the surveys I think it was close to like 47% um that said that there was they felt like there were some issues of cell phone use in their classroom and also at lunchtime so that was an alarming rate for myself um they did mention that I didn't know this that the cellone policy had been more I guess implemented this past year and then this year year um so one of the kind of thoughts we went kind of into is maybe do a follow-up survey after some months to see if it's improved because if there is Teachers out there that are

081having issues we do need to have a plan in place because obviously it's impacting either learning or uh lunchtime so when I visited uh John gutieres um it was interesting because people they talked to some of the staff and they said um you know we never really see it on at lunchtime and it happen that when I came there was two two groups of students that had cell phones out so it was kind of the thing I don't know if it was just bad timing but I think not to say that pouches are the answer but I think that it's good to have conversations and finding out that there might be an issue is not a bad thing is in itself as far as like why is there a problem but it's an opportunity right

082to figure out if there is a problem how can we support either the teachers or staff to what's kind of going on um so what I kind of came through the conversation was okay if you guys don't believe cell phone pouches are the problem provide some solutions because I think I didn't want to just here and says well it's not well it's only the majority of teachers or not teachers says well that's true thankfully it's not the majority if it was the majority I'd really have concerns but even if it's 25 or 40% that's too many teachers you know or or even if it's 5% if I think five or 10% I think that's five classrooms they're having ISS with Sone that's a lot of students that are impacting their learning that's the way I

083tend to take a look at it is the cound phone patches that's what what the initial issue was like if there's five teachers that says they have issues of cell phone use in their classroom five times 25 students or whatever that's a lot of students are having their their learning impacted so I think what we came out of that uh meeting which was really good was some opportunities was like let's create a plan if it has to do with um uh PD days right or having uh spaces or maybe teachers can share some other concerns or kind of stuff so I'm open to that as long as there's a plan um then I can see why we can say you know more time is needed as long as hey like there's an effort right cuz

084we did hear I know there was a teacher today that said hey I my kids listen to music totally understand that but it also kind of creates the inconsistency sometimes because it's like hey so and so teacher allows me to use in so and so it doesn't allows me to use it so obviously there's something inconsistent can happen I think what I'm open to and we continue to have more conversations as the board is we need to have a plan in place and if we don't see the results are improving right cuz it's all data B driven right if we do another savior with teacher and the same percent of teachers still say there cell phone issues right and we implemented the process longer then we do need to figure out other Solutions because it's

085not so much people were focusing on the product itself but the way I saw it was if there's disruptions in the classroom taking place as a result of cell phone usage then that's a learning loss right that's taking place for the students and that's where I saw the potential investment that might need to be needed was if there's teachers that aren't able to deal with the cell phone use and so we're helping them them in a way have an extra Aid in the classroom right because if it you know and I did hear a lot of times people say well there is kids that are going to look for a way around it right but if that's the case it's almost like why have any rules in general because somebody's going to find a way

086around it right and that's not the case you try to find ways to lower the amount of students that will do it right and I was thinking of of something of seat bels I first seat belts you know you had to wear seat belts and then eventually not enough people wore it so you got to get a ticket and so it's like you find find ways to lower the amount of students you're still going to have somebody that doesn't wear seat bels even though they're not going to they're going to get a ticket and even though it's against the law but at least you try to minimize the effort and I think that's what I'm trying to look for and give direction with the superintendent is like what plan are we going to come up

087with that minimizes the cell phone usage so when we do these surveys to teachers right and it's important for them to be open and honest if they're having issues like we need to have results true right but if it doesn't work you know we come back and say cell phone pouches it's like we gave it a shot right and I think that's kind of what I wanted to kind of engage in the conversation and I think um a lot of times if you guys have a lot of concerns I've always since I've been on the school board been open to meeting with anybody um and having those type of do dialogues you know because I think this space is good for everybody to speak but I think obviously the one inone helps so I encourage

088you if there's issues in the future and I'm sure anybody here on the board would be open to meeting as well you know to oh ask for that space you know or superintendent can reach out and say hey can we have another their at hoc committee where two board members can meet this is a kind of a concern we have so okay um you know I I I want to step back a little bit and um explain to the teachers here where I came from and that was this idea I must protect this District I must protect to protect the students and especially the staff media is getting worse not better the proliferation of AI students recording videos inappropriately through the cell phones and then sprinting it it's not localized anymore and I understand Gavin

089View and JG we have a special community and we've had a small family for so long and we've able to control things and we've able to handle things but this is not the same world we live in anymore we live in a global world now where one picture one AI one photo can destroy an entire teacher's life in terms of employment and God knows the bullying and the AI stuff that goes on there's an explosion going on up there and we can't sit here and close our eyes and ear and say well it's not it it doesn't affect us it hasn't affected us yes we have a small family and so my whole thing was how do we get ahead of this it's not a question of if it's only a question of when and

090I understand 85 90% of the students don't use the cell phone that's great those not the ones I'm worried about I'm worried about that one bad actor maybe two and then what do I do then I have a teacher exposed in the media I have a student being bullied or God knows what Ai and we as a district have to deal with this and then what will you come back and say so this came from an idea of protection how do I protect my teachers other teachers have lost employment already because of stuff Ai and videos the students have produced there have been students who have committed suicide because of the bullying and online videos that have been recorded and I hear you teachers I do but when you say I don't want to hear

091about teachers I do want to hear about teachers but the when I went to harden I asked teachers do you deal with the cell phone they said no the classified staff they deal with it we have nothing to do with the pouches anymore and every school that's implemented it they've had much better results and so I hear you teachers I do but I want to protect you this didn't come from any idea of hey let's ram something down anyone's throat it's not a question of if the question is when if any one of you believes that you are protected from not having a one bad actor recording a video and edit it and then put it on air and then explodes you tell me now where's that protection you're telling me about I love this

092school I love this District I want to protect you guys and unfortunately this I don't know this exploded into another situation and yes we're going to probably vote it down I'm we bringing it back next year I I pray I hope that between now and next year not a single video of a bullying or fighting is recorded and spread on Facebook Instagram Tik Tok I pray that doesn't happen but this part of me knows that I can't guarantee that this is the world we live in so having said that that's where I'm coming from I Love the teachers of this District I will fight for you the reason I joined this board was because this was the lowest paid District in the county if not the city and my one promise to the teachers was

093we would always be on the top of that pay range and I've honored my commitment year after year after year asked the CBO and yes there are costs are going up and what do we do after the health care we we are unilaterally agreed to subsidize it even further and at the time when we negotiated a pay raise we didn't know about the increase in health insurance it wasn't a real it was a real pay raise if there's somebody to blame blame this National Health Care System we're not the enemy last last V meeting we voted to improve and subsidize the Health and Welfare benefits and that's why we get a little upset sometimes or I do we got to think outside of the box I got to think about the future so yes this

094is probably going to go down I understand that but the question is why why did I even push this why even I even started this conversation was it out of a negative thing let me create a way to create additional burdens on teachers is this what was May to get them all upset at me is that my intention so here we are I pray I pray we don't have any negative stuff that happens on mass media I do every day but I teach high school students every day I see what goes on and to protect this district is my number one duty and I will always fight for that and I will always be outspoken on that thank you very much any other questions from the board let's go ahead and go for the vote

095yeah I I motion with direction to create a plan uh for now not to approve the cell phone patches but with a direction to for GU a plan so we can uh reduce the concerns that were brought up in the service I would cheen that too I think so what you're asking is that we table this item and bring back uh a plan yeah instead okay so can I get um a second for tabling 9.4 and the directive that we bring back a plan so second Mr Patel seconds all those in favor I motion 5 Z okay we'll give everybody an opportunity in case you want to say for the rest meeting great but if you want to step out off to the action item then that's okay too and thank you everybody for the

096comments what is that how is that you guys didn't give us a time frame when they were talking I I'm allow to talk so tell to shut up to um is you guys talked about maybe next year so what's when you guys said we're going to table it what how long is that is that like two weeks is that a year is that I don't know months so with a general table directive like this it would be tabled until the board requested that we bring it back for an action in the future something can be tabled for in it can be tabled indefinitely as such so as the superintendent I've been given a directive to come back with a plan um in lie of this item moving forward does that make sense yeah and so

097I know and if it's okay I'll just clarify a little more in our conversations with teachers in the boardroom and then at JG the following day um we talked about getting some more um qualitative conversations going with teachers rather than sending you another survey because I I know those are fun um and that right to ask you know well tell me about that right and then what can we do to make the current policy stronger and what can we do for any of those teachers who do feel like there's a management issue or a cell phone issue because of that right so you know I'm not going to make a plan in isolation I I would make a plan collaboratively people absolutely what that time because a lot of people wer in haven't had the

098opportunity to agree so I can send out some additional communication um about setting up some time and space again for those conversations to and where we can make a plan that we feel is good to bring back to our board at a future meeting good thanks for letting me have the time to explain that all right next next item 9.1 so 9.1 is um for the verbal summary of the financial terms and approval of the superintendent's contract for 2024 through 2027 um Dr Alderman's contract is currently set to expire on June 30th 2025 at the end of this school year the approval of this contract will suers proed her current contract and extend her employment through June 30th of 2027 so the verbal summary of financial terms must be read aloud either by the board

099president or his design before a board action is taken on the next item would you like to go all right summary of financial terms of superintendent employment agreement the district will whoops let me increase size here the district will consider approving an extension of the superintendent's contract a summary of the financial terms are as follows number one the term of Dr alterman's employment as superintendent will be for a term beginning July 1st 2024 to and including June 30th 2027 number two the base salary of the superintendent for 2024 through 2025 school year will be $239,700 of the superintendent salary schedule number four the superintendent will continue to be provided with the same health insurance benefits that are provided to other certificated management employees in the district number five the super the superintendent will not be

100paid a monthly allowance for an automobile or for cell phone travel outside of Monteray County will be reimbursed in accordance to the district policy number six the district will pay for the superintendent membership in the association of California School administrators and the California Association of school business officials number seven the superintendent will have a work year of 225 days with no vacation days number eight the contract provides that the board May terminate the superintendent without cause but if the right is exercised by the board the district will pay the superintendent her salary and benefits for a period not to exceed 12 months or the remainder of the term of the contract whichever is less did I skip three actually the numbering system was off I apologize is there a number three there's there's number so

101uh numbers four through 8 should be R numbered 3 through 7 thank you for that modification as amended okay at this motion do we entertain a motion yeah yeah discuss yes you have to read that and call for Action uh comment tarah are are we at that was just 9.1 so are we at 9.2 okay um I have a request if we can pass it on to our HR just Department um just so that the public is aware we do do an evaluation of the superintendent every every year and um this approaching summer when we do the evaluation I would appreciate it if the HR department um was able to get us comparisons of superintendent salaries in Montery County and based on um also looking at enrollment we haven't done that in several years and

102just so that everybody knows we do that with the teachers we do that with the classified we did that with the superintendent when we originally created a salary table and we have not the other groups have gotten raises in that time which we have not adjusted the superintendent's salary I I am not saying that we are going to adjust it in the summer but I would I feel like we need to go through a process when we do the evaluation to look at if what we're doing is comparable or not and also um motion to approve do we need to amend the numbering you mentioned it for can I get a second I second you can call all those in favor I all those against I myself thank you motion passes 5 Z all right

103got keep moving forward here we go all right 9.2 approval employment contract for assistant superintendent of Education Services was that taken we just did that right no you just did mine oh I'm sorry assistant sorry about that all right the assistant superintendent of ed services contract is set to to end currently June 30th 2025 this um contract would supersede her current contract and would have an end date of June 30th [Music] 2027 any comment board members can I get a motion please motion to approve second all those in favor I motion 5 Z all right uh 9.3 approval of resolution storage shelter this is the board um agreeing that these storage sheds will not be used by students and teachers as an instructional space and is required for us to be able to have these

104on our campuses motion to approve second all those in favor motion 5 Z all right 9.5 approval of contract with monor County Arts Council for New Republic thank thank you um with our proposition $28 we are required to allocate additional art services to each School in our district um so this contract would support that and would also support beautification of the campus with a mural um motion to approve and if you haven't seen the other murals go and see them because they're awesome second same thing um we were just in two differentes and um I've seen the one in gav in person and some pictures of s it makes it very more welcoming to our school so definitely all those in favor motion 5 Z all right next item 9.6 approval of first interim budget

105report for 2425 school year good evening I'm going to go ahead and stand up so you can probably hear me better I have a presentation and you should have a copy in your but your seat or on your desk so this is um the first entrance budget report this is kind of call it kind of like the real budget this is after we already closed the book so we have real uh beginning balances now uh we roll those forward we have more accurate data um so that's what I'm going to go ahead and be presenting so we can go ahead and go to the next slide some of the highlights for this presentation during my July 1st I'm going to be comparing my numbers to the July 1 budget because that was the last budget

106that I uh brought here to the board um I know we talk about or the state Cola which still at 1% and what would be the cola at the district level back when I was doing the July 1 budget back in may we were projecting a -3% it came now to a -2% for the main re as I explained on my summary budget letter is due to the um collection of the income forms this year which the district did a great great effort so usually when that happens um if we are losing for example 100 students and we have 80% of them that are unduplicated meaning they qualify for their lwi income they're migrant or they qualify for free um lunches usually 80% of those students will be the ones that if they leave it

107would be 80% of those because that's pretty much our percentage now what happened in this case is that even though the number of total students decreased districtwide with the increase of the collection of the forms or District actually recuperates some money for the elcut funding so I'll talk a little bit more about that there is an LC lcf F reduction not as bad as the projected in the July 1st again now we close the books um we got more funding on the elcab due to the income forms so instead of being a negative 1.4 it came out to $43,000 comparing to last year funding okay um some of the other challenges that we have is special education increases as the number of students keep increasing and the needs that they need um keep keep increasing

108every year we have the challenge of every year we have you know teachers and and staff go up on the step in college benefits are going up also inflation as you know operating cost is going up as well um everything in regards to things that we need to to continue our operations such as for example or absence Frontline um system or accounting system or um electricity the bills that we pay every year as well is going up so all of that um affects U of how much money we have um something that I really want to focus as well is the shift of funding as we're moving towards this new year as you know we had a lot of that one-time funding um there is a lot of that shift of funding that as we

109talk about budget reductions on the unrestricted funding there is money that we keep getting on only restricted funds so I want to explain this because I know in the community or with the teachers or staff they might seem like Hey we're talking about budget reductions we're talking about we're have the funding how can you afford um doing this for for music or for Arts there are specific grants that come from the state that are restricted that we can only use it for those specific problems so uh uh programs I'm sorry so I want to make sure that we all understand this and the more the that I mention hopefully you get familiar it's not because we're discriminator we want we don't want to allocate funds these funds are pretty much coming from the state they're

110telling us where we need to spend um something that I want to highlight as well is in your Criterion and standard form from the packet I know it's pretty big but if you look I believe it's page 21 around there there is a section that talks about the salaries and benefits um percentage out of the unrestricted fund and for this year the 2425 we're at 81% um if we continue everything as we are doing right now and we don't do any Cuts next year is projected to be at 88% and then 91% and as I mentioned before anything over 85% is already a red flag something that we need to watch for um with this budget and we talk about um on the previous presentations that we needed to make adjustments because we were going

111into the deficit spending we talk about the Ada cliff and how we're going to have this dip of funding this reduction and and um how to balance the budget so something that I want to highlight is that we need to recognize this year on 2024 2025 um budget cuts for $2 million so we can maintain our reserves uh for the next following year and then on 26 27 an additional $1 million as well so we can go ahead and go to the next slide this is pretty much um based on the on the on the adoption of the budget from the state does the state Cola does the district um Cola like I said we are a -2% um or District enrollment we lost 99 students compared to last year enrollment um or 88 to

112enrollment percentage still at 92 and then just some of the numbers for um Coster Spurs and unemployment rate we can go ahead and go to the next slide student enrollment this is just a graph so you can see um um pretty much a little bit of History starting on 2020 2021 during the co years that was like the biggest drop that we had losing 164 student as you know the district get funded on current year or prior three years so last year when we were here we were getting funded on these three years so as you can see we were still getting funded on the on the highest enrollment this year on 2024 25 we're we're getting funded on this lower three years so as you can see this is the 88 Cliff that they've

113been talking about and this is why we have a a reduction in in funding in the lcff you know Rosa this uh this graph above anything else is probably the most shocking for um this yeah this graph is probably the most shocking for me you know um this is our primary bread and butter here this is our income driver and this massive reduction uh you know more than 10% you know from 30 almost 3500 all the way down to almost 3,000 um you know and it fits our demographics you know as the prices of homes are going up we have less younger families moving in and so this trend is very alarming and so I'm just always worried about the next three years coming after that and so as I'm looking at this that's what

114my main concern is is how do we protect what we have knowing that if the demographics don't change that we're in for a tough uh three four maybe five years thank you and just um to follow up to what you were mentioning um on the last conference that I attended they did mention that Statewide they're on declining rollment by 11% so this last year for us was at 3% which is um lower than the state rate but again um we are declining it's been since the first year to 2024 to current year we lost a total of 383 students with that being said we haven't made any reductions in staff we're trying to to be very cautious and making sure that the savings that we do um we don't disrupt the students or the staff

115as well so um so that's pretty much um something that to to take a look and and again we do get funded on on attendance and enrollment um we can go ahead and and go to the next graph so with that being said or lcff funding like I just not to get it confused I when we when I was talking about the budget reduction on the lcff I was comparing it to last year now we're going to be comparing to the July 1st budget because that's the last budget that that it was B approv so I'm going to be comparing those numbers lcff uh funding came in higher again mainly due because as we close in the Years we're getting final numbers on enrollment anything also that changes for um mcoe special Edge student enrollment

116it does affect my lcff calculations so all of that is included in there but mainly about 400k it was due to the income forms that I do want to thank um summer Steam for making those phone calls making sure they were following up not only that but they were reviewing the forms and then they see something look weird that it wasn't fill it out correctly staff was making picking up the phone um calling it and making sure that what the information that they put in in there was correctly so on in regards to UND duplicated account we were at 85% um of the students meaning pretty much lwi income this year we're at 87% so that number increased I thanks to the collection of the forms in regards to federal revenue um about half a

117million dollar schem for that safety grant that krisha was just talking about it's going to cover the purchase of the cameras uh we included that in there on the state revenue most of it about $1 million of additional funding based on a new allocation from the state on the elop so this is where I'm talking about the the shifting of funding right while we we are getting less money on our lcff compared to last year here it is more money for elop and and Arts and Music and things like that so that's most of most of the increase in there um as well as the Cal shape Grant we got half of it about half of it last year and now we're budgeting again this year with that we're going to finish the project that

118was kind of like a summer project it went over to July so we have to budget in July for the new year that that was part of the increase as well um in regards to local Revenue we had a small decrease due to a special education grant that we receive from MC and when it comes to salaries and and benefits so as you can see on certificated salaries we did have we we are including that one-time payment for certificated um unit only uh for 2,700 at one time there's also a lot of changes in regards to salaries and benefits we had this projection July 1st was in May so now with new teachers coming in any movement that happened during the summer it also includes um six positions of savings we had a meeting um

119with HR Melissa Becky and everyone pretty much looking at on positions that we didn't F this year we didn't F last year and some of them even prior year so in regards to having more accurate budget and more accurate information um it does include those savings for dispositions in there in regards to classified salaries some savings due to vacancies when we upload vacancies is showing um savings from July through the end of November so for those vacancies that we didn't hire there is the Savings in included in there now when it comes to the benefits you we did uh provide an increase on the benefit cap um to the teacher unit for a temp % uh that is included in there there was open enrollment in November as I was able to capture the more

120uh most up-to-date information so as we excluded those six positions and the benefits that we're not going to pay and as um the employees are getting signed up for the new uh plans we do see an overall reduction in regards to books and supplies pretty much funding from Lottery that was from more book at option for this year some of the items arrive in June some of them in July so we have to coordinate there and and budget this year moving the funding from last year to this year other services include mostly um on the camera installation that chrisha was talking about there is a district match for about 600k that is included there so it's included the half a million dollar Grant plus the um District uh match for the specific Grant um and

121then capital La as well and other services also include a onetime project for our district office as you know we have a safety concern as we have the glass door and um cannot be locked from the inside so if there's an emergency that we need to lock and protect our employees inside somebody have to sacrifice themel pretty much and close a lock it from the outside um so there's some changes there um there's also plans for a painting the office office as well those funds that we're going to be utilizing it is restricted funds for um specifically for uh facilities that we get through our through our grants um on the 7,000 it the last line that you see on expenses it's pretty much the billback from mcoe as they get more students and as

122they have now more accurate data or expense for that increase by about 300K quick question on that chart um so some of the items you kind of mentioned are um like onetime expenses that are making like the cameras and stuff and like the grant that we got from the cameras did we receive that money this year or was it received the the prior this year so it's based on reimbursement until we spend the funds then we get the money we apply for it we already have the grant we have the grant letter we we apply live for the gr we got it but now when they issued the cash is pretty much as we spend it they're going to be issuing that cash it's based on rum so the cash that we're receiving for example

123for that Grant is that reflected in there and that's how we go to receive then it'll be on the updated one or yeah so the there is another form with the cash flow sure this is um pretty much just budgeting saying we're going to get the cash because we are going to get we're going to finish that project this year and I know in the letter you kind of mentioned that there's sometimes vacant positions but you mentioned part of that savings is already there cuz he said 1.7 in uh vac vaces so the 1.7 is pretty much um active positions that are on pretty much on edge Jo that are needed that the district still needs and are currently hiring yes and and those are pretty much from anything from December all the way through

124the end of June so as I make my next budget Revision in March or sooner if we have any big impact in the in in the overall budget um then there's going to be savings if we don't hire those people savings from July all the way through February that's usually when I build the budget and so on okay um let's see so at the end of of Revenue and expenses we still at the um negative or deficit spending of $6.6 million you can go ahead and go to the next slide so this is part of the unrestricted ending fund balance as you might see when you look at the overall uh fund one you might see more funding but remember that a lot of that funding that is restricted we have to use it for

125those specific regulations that the state or federal funds are telling us to use the funds for and just a reminder that 177% of our reserves it would only cover about two months of our expenses um about three to four months of salaries and benefits if we don't pay stiens or extra hours it depends so it really a 17% is not a lot and uh that doesn't solve the issue for deficit spending what it does for example for this year is to help us um have a little bit more time or having this year to decide where we need to make the cut so or reserves is not something that's going to fix um the deficit spending problem we can go to the next slide so as you can see make sure I don't trip um

126this is the current year on this year if you see the total expenses we're decreasing it as our onetime funds are decreasing so we're decreasing the revenue for those onetime funds but we're also decreasing um the expenses in here if you look at your multi-year projection it is already included the $2 million cut so if we don't make the $2 million cut on this year instead of a negative $3 million this could be a five negative five5 million and then if we don't do anything about it instead of doing $2 million it's going to be four because it's already two years so it's really important that we recognize that this year so it doesn't overlap and it get us into a bigger problem um so it's it if you look at the nyp it doesn't

127state where we're making the cut it just says that we have to we acknowledge the district a knowledges that we have to make that car um in case we didn't let's say we we don't recognize that and we leave it like that I would get a call from the county and say you need to you need to fix this this is not going to get approved because you're not meeting your minimum requirement so as the district um and I don't know if you saw on on the approval of the budget this time I added an additional paragraph where it does state that we acknowledge that we have to make that cut and the district also acknowledges that if anything major changes that it's going to change that $2 million to a different number we're going

128to I'm going to come here and present to you another budget with our evisions I know you mentioned that uh it's the expenditures are going down because we're expending some of the onetime costs that's correct correct okay um because I noce the biggest year obviously is a a deficit spending of 6.6 million is some of the larger spending onetime funds that we have received in Prior years and now it being spent uh this year yes so a lot of the fans that we have is or learn learning recovery as well which um it also have some staff salaries in there because it is also restricted and we move some positions or when we hire new positions it was specifically for that specific RIS and like mental health and counseling and things like that yes we

129have orpd Grant as well that's being helping out through the years um so so we we are spending out little by little and that's why our yeah our expenses are decreasing or revenu is decreasing as well okay how much of the 6.6 would you say was part of onetime funds that we had received in the past and was earn was shown on the report as that year so the it so we have our fun one we have the restricted and then the unrestricted and right now I'm covering about the combine but I can tell you that over $3 million was part of the restricted and part of the funding that we need to spend out because we're we're not going to have it next year yeah and and part of the reason I mentioned that

130because I know kind of what happens is sometimes they get ask questions from the public it's like hey how did you go from deficit spending 3 million to now it's 6 million like how can you not catch it but some of it is like money that you're spending out that you had to receive the prior I mean we're still having deficit spending in general which is still an issue that's but the the the the amount of the deficit spending is kind of I can't think of a better word but like skewed in a way because it's money that you had already received the prior and you're now you're now reflecting the spending of it this year prior yeah you got the revenue in Prior but you're spending it in this year in so correct so

131to give you a visual the money for example if we got money on last year and we didn't spend in all of it because some of that money we're spending it by year that money sitting right here right now at the end so when you're taking your Revenue you're adding your expense because you want to spend this money here and because it's at the bottom it does create the the deficit spending it's not at the top anymore it's at the bottom and there are different rules for the so some grants some of them are based on reimbursement kind of so if you spend it you get it if you don't then you have to recognize it the next year and some of them is like here's the money and we have we have it right

132here and we're just slowly spending it no I just want to say thank you for presentation I do apologize I have to leave I was kep pushing another meeting that I have afterwards 7:30 7:45 but it's beyond where I can push it so so I apologize for liing early uh we can go to the next slide right so some of the challenges like I mentioned before the client enrollment over the five years um reduction based on lcff and the onetime funds as well increases on special ed um operating cost I feel like I already did that slide for some reason is repetitive we can go to the to the next one I already talk about that all right so some of the highlights um that I want to mention is that the district has been

133making an effort for doing savings as you know we have been offering early retirement incentives for the last probably last three years or so which has been able to slowly saving money over the years um like I said it is we already identified six positions that it doesn't interrupt classroom or or anyone because they have been vacant on the last year two years or even three years um we're also making sure that all of the Department's budget and school sites um maintain B they maintain balance meaning that if they're interested on something else another emergency came up they're going to have to balance their budget they cannot add more to the deficit spending they either going to have to to cut somewhere or prioritize if they want to um implement this new program or this

134new expensive is going to be I want to do this but I'm going to reduce it here keeping that budget balanced uh I already talked about the shift of funding might seem that we spending on things that maybe not everyone is an agreement again this is coming from the state and it's the money that we get we're going to spend it student attendance drift Revenue 1% of attendance can be worth a about 400k it depends on the student if it's on duplicator if it's um just a regular student uh just to give you an idea one day of absence is worth about $95 so if you're if for the community or the parents that are hearing about that meeting if you're student if if you're planning a vacation or a doctor's appointment or whatever it

135is something that you can manage to do during the time after school or um during the summer winter when the kids are not not in school that can really help out um with the district budgeting I recommend that um to push those appointments or those vacations when the kids are are not in school besides that the school the students are missing on academics as well which is really really important and then um something that I wanted to highlight too that I didn't add it on the slide is that teachers and they might ask like how can we help or is there anything that they can do to help and something that I was analyzing is that we have been spending a lot of money on substitute teachers so again recommending the teachers that if they're

136planning to do vacation or they're planning to doctor's appointment or whatever they have instead of hiring a substitute if they can do it after um their work time or during um you know during their their time off that will be great just to give you an example preco we used to spend about 300,000 on substitute teur this last year that we closed the books 23 24 we spent $1.2 million so it has been moreal of teachers everywhere you just can't get appointments the postco world is different and it it I I just have to speak up for my colleagues in terms of I don't know that there's much they can do thank you thank you for sharing that I was giving some ideas um yeah that that has been increased a lot and and yeah

137it it as you can see that was preco after Co it went up to um 742 on the 21 22 22 23 $1 million and this last year uh $1.2 million so yeah it has been increasing significantly so if they can grade and then if they can then then we'll just continue to to have the best efforts as we can so this is our ASB fund moving forward um pretty much not a lot of changes additional 2000 um they've been doing great great staying on on their budget they're doing uh popcorn sale sales and pretty much everything that they do for the fundraising I'm not going to go into detail but I'm not a lot of changes there we can go ahead and move to the next slide this is the cafeteria uh something just

138to highlight there is that uh Revenue slightly came down as some of the grant that we're getting now we're getting it through elop so we decreased the the funding here and it it increased on the elop um salaries and benefits did increase as you know we we added a new position because this grant are this fund specifically talking about shift of funding it is um we're getting more funding than before and now the the funding the the way that we're getting funding changed so they're still on a surplus on this fund so we can go to the next one so or fund 14 this is pretty much money that is left over from um last year's uh project we had the santarita restroom and we got this money left over and now it's being used

139to um pay our employees to do projects um around our school for district purification uh whether it's painting or something that needs to be replaced not necessarily something that is has to do with safety but again These funds are restricted specifically for facilities use we can go ahead and move to the next one this is the the bond fund and this is pretty much where we have or um all of the place structures I know we had just um a facility uh walk through for some of the OM more sites but that's where we are paying um the place structures and also um La Hoya we have um three Portables the we're budgeting for and uh the playground as well and guarding relocation for GV and a part of it is the GV portable um

140demolition that was between the summer so some of that it's in there also the four Place structures of the four um elementaries we can go ahead and go to the next slide this is our uh Capital facilities fund this is pretty much the funds that we receive for any um construction going on around our area this is based on actual so this is pretty much how much funding we have received um it's looking better than last year we're planning to spend all of it um we have been using that fund and pretty much to pay anything that requires um facilities or anything um in the past we have paid for any uh legal fees that involve facilities so we can go ahead and go to the next one finally this is our fund 35 this

141is the fund where we purchased um the land for soberana and we it was on last year the final purchase end up being in July so we move it to this year's budget fund 40 I don't have um we don't have any activity there but remember that's where we used to have the $1.5 million for GV projects and .5 million for JG however you remember last year we did a fund transfer of half a million dollars to be able to purchase the land so there's half a million dollars here that we use that need to go back to that fund as soon as we get the state funding just want to remind everyone that okay we can go to the next slide so those are pretty much the forms that's the cash flow if you're

142interested about when are we actually getting that cash for those grants that's where you can get an idea it is by the months or form a is how the district getting funded um the next slide it represents any interf funding activities between funds and you're pretty much familiar with the other ones criterian standards is a budget analysis it does have a lot of detail on any differences on the object codes so I I did put a lot of the grants the amounts um even the resource code if you're interested on that and then at the end or TRC which it verifies making sure that all of the resources balanced uh my page is clear it's always clear um so if you have any questions please let me know that's it sorry I took too long

143it's a lot of information yes so um one of my biggest concerns um I know I have brought it up before is you know that going into those red numbers you know anything over the 85% and having us you know being scared with money you know and like the districts that you know we see in local not that much long ago about like not having enough to you know pay our teachers and all that kind of stuff so I know that we saying we're working on like where we could do you know cuts and all of that but I would like to see um something put together to to us so we could see okay what do we have working from from here on out to avoid at all costs getting you know where we're

144at especially because like Mr vatel said that it's very concerning to see that declin of of students and it seems like it's just going down down as as year passes so it's just concerning to know where we're going to stand in two three years from now right hopefully I mean there's an increase in enrollment but now you know there's parents used to have five kids now they have one if if if any you know so there's just a lot of things that play take this into effect to make to see that enrollment um decrease but I would just like to see something put together for us like okay this is where we're planning on doing these Cuts it's going to do this and to see what those numbers are and I know like you said

145you're working on it but I would like to see something like that that's first thank you for the huge amount of work not just for you but all the staff it I'm just impressed every single time um I would just like to say in terms of planning and this is more directed at the cabinet as a whole i' really in terms of where we need to cut um like to make sure that we're having deep conversations with teachers we're having deep conversations with classified we've added a lot of positions in my time on the board and it may just be with declining enrollment that that some of those outside the classroom positions are not sustainable so we need to talk about what's really working what's really having an impact so that when we make cuts

146that we're keeping the quality of educational product still high but acknowledging that um we got huge influxes of money um in Co and there may be things that are just not sustainable long term thank you Rosa for your great presentation there I do I am concerned at you know with the declining enrollment especially um and I can remember back when we had a skeleton crew where it was just horrible during those years um and we cut and cut till we were the the district office had only like maybe four or five employees um I'm hoping that it doesn't get to that point um and I'm going to be really um positive about that um but the decline enrollment does bother me um as any other things that you know where we have to be cutting

147I I I just don't want to see our district um you know and you're doing a great job I'm you know I think it's you you've um um you've made it for us we can in you interpret a lot for us that um a lot of times we have questions for um and you've answered them very accurately um but I'm just I'm just afraid of three years out you know and it and it's nobody's fault because kids aren't coming and then not only that but now with our new um um kids might not be coming back from Mexico or they might not want to be in our our district but you know we might be seeing more dine I'm just trying to be not pessimistic I'm trying to be optimistic and um hopefully you know

148we'll we'll get through this we'll get through this oh you've got sorry um thank you for a great presentation but thank you for stating the facts no matter how good they are or bad they are you know and we need to be able to trust the numbers and so that's what before I say anything that's what you know I've been relying upon for the last four or five years because you know we've had issues with that but having said that um Aline Sarah I think you know when I came on this board 14 years ago I I always wanted to prepare for this day and I've always talked about a few things and one was hey we have income coming in but I was always worried about the market going down recession whatever we grow

149especially with salaries because that's a number one expense that whatever we offer the teachers in salary we can always maintain through the roughest of times I as a teacher and you probably have as well have been through times where we had to take a pay cut had to take furos and as a board member I vowed to try to do everything to protect our staff to avoid that and so over the years you know we've always looked at the numbers and we've May made the best possible increases to teacher salary making him competitive long before you when he wasn't Ela you remember those days and at the same time the issue was always can we maintain this step and column throughout the worst of times and that's what we have done I think the issue

150is not I think we prepared ourselves for maybe 2 three years the mitigating factor is hopefully the new homes come in and bring in the replacement but there are many factors coming in the way number one being we have a new Administration talking about massive changes to education and federal dollars we're talking massive issues regarding immigration and fear and just recently today the Zar announced that he's going to make it there was a policy for them to avoid schools and uh churches and they're going to do away with that as well so it scares me and so we need to do everything possible not only protect our teachers and this District financially but also as a whole you know and protecting our students you know and that's another conversation I want to have when we

151talk about new agenda items but having said that I think this district is ready I think we're probably the best District prepared for this in this area having said that that we're going to have to make some difficult choices coming up but our my goal has always been you know protect the classroom you know and I agree with you uh Sarah and Ela I mean you know um you know for me I think we have to protect the staff and the teachers classified staff we have added more to the the top level of uh management as well as toas and Etc and those are PR we have to look at my last thing I want to do is to do any Cuts with teachers and and student ratios we protect what we have and we

152honor the promises made and so having said that I I thank you for your honesty and your uh soberness in terms of bringing this information to us because it is quite sobering I'm pretty sure all the board members are pretty uh I open right now and hopefully the public is too because we're not the only District this is a Statewide program and Nationwide Pro uh uh problem I apologize so you know we will deal with it you know that's what we like it to do having said that any further comments before entertain a motion to accept what is it 9 motion to approve 9.5 9.6 second 9.6 pardon me 9.6 all those in favor I I I kep motion passes 4 Z 9.7 approval of sun sign letter with CA chapter 503 to open contract

153negotiation with the district thank you as um Juanita presented during cca's um report this evening um csca has submitted a sunshine letter to open negotiations for the current school year um I know thatana reviewed what they would like to open and so this is um just the formality of the board approving their Sunshine letter to open negotiations entertain a comment or motion motion to approve second all those in favor 4 Z all right we're at our next board meeting is December 16th uh 20 well next this coming up Monday uh suggested for future board items I do have one item um Ela and Sarah sind hope you okay this um I would like to get a little bit more information from legal regarding immigration status and uh potential issues that District we might have in

154terms of uh protecting our students you know who are we are vested to protect and under current federal law and see if that does change you know what can we do to mitigate any circumstances um so I would like to get maybe some input from legal on that if that's okay with the board it doesn't have to be the December 11th meeting the following meeting after that you know is that okay yeah okay fellow board members uh can I clarify our meeting on Monday um because this was an election year we are required uh to hold our annual reorganization meeting between December 13th and December 27th it it's on a timeline most years our December board meeting fits this year it didn't um and they said no so we're going to have a short meeting

155on Monday that's December 16th yeah I think I had it on my calendar um Mr Torres missed public comment um but he did want to promote this um second annual harell hangout with the girls basketball program programs from our district and the high school district and so I have a flyer for each of you regarding that thank you so much any further uh comments board members all right I think this is probably my last uh board meeting in terms of uh you know do a little Shuffle I just want to say uh before next week I know he's not here but uh I want to say thank you you know it's it's it's always been uh we always seek consensus and I think that's one thing I'm proud of each and every vote almost you

156know has been consens is driven and so um thank you for all the hard work you always do and thank you for uh allowing me the latitude to lead this board for one year and thank you that's all I can say you know hopefully I did uh more better than worse you know as I would say thank you very much having said that I would like to motion for the end of the meeting can I get a first I motion toor second second all those in favor I I captain motion 4 Z

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.