001now opening the February 12th 2025 meeting of the Santa roses City Schools Board of Education um are there any public comment cards on session it there are no public comment cards right then the board will recess to close session for the close session item okay um confusing all right so our Clos session agenda includes Public Employee discipline and dismissal and release conference with legal counsel on existing litigation conference with legal councel on anticipated litigation student expulsion cases and public employee performance evaluation now now we will recess to close session 2025 meeting of the Santa Rosa City Schools Board of Education please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance and then remain standing for a territorial land acknowledgement and for our land acknowledgement we have a student Adrien Helen lus uh I'm a student of Montgomery High
002School my name is Adrian um I'm here to represent the land acknowled land acknowledgement uh I acknowledge that Santa Rosa city schools is on the traditional territory in homelands of the Pomo people traditional territory in homelands of the Coast Miwok people and honor with gratitude the land itself and people who have stewarded it throughout the generations this land acknowledgement calls us to commit to continuing to learn how to be a better to to learn how to be better stewards of the land that we inhabit by offering this land acknowledgement we affirm indigenous sovereignty and we will work to hold Santa Rosa city schools more accountable to the needs of American Indian and Indigenous peoples all right moving on to report of actions taken in closed session I have a few things to report out um
003so first the board voted to approve dismissal of certificated employee number 313 and we conferred with legal counsel and then the vote the board also voted unanimously to approve approve six resolutions let me find the [Music] numbers all right so we approved resolution number 2024 25-40 for the release and possible reassignment of a certificated administrator case number 2024 25-41 for the re release and possible reassignment of a certificated administrator case number 2024 25-42 for the release and possible reassignment of a certificated administrator case number 2-43 for the possible reassignment of certificate ated administrator case 24 25-45 for the release of classified management and case 2024 2-46 for the release of classified management all all right that is everything for reports of action Tak in closed session um items considered in Clos session for Action an
004open session there were none statements of exstension do we have any um adjustments to the [Music] agenda we are pulling F6 and F7 for a future meeting any other adjustments any pulling of consent and items no all right then we'll move on to our reports first we have our CSEA report it's president Mary Leman here good evening good evening president MCN governing board superintendent Dr Morales student board member cabinet members and everyone listening tonight first I want to acknowledge the people who make this District strong the teachers the students the parents and the community members who showed up tonight your your presence sends a message that we care I represent some 6 70 classified employees the backbone of the district cca's mission is to improve the lives of our members our students and our communities
005we encourage the board to approve the items CSEA has in front of you um approval of chapter F1 chapter 75 2425 M us and F2 approval of a tenative agreement for our successor contract 2024 through 2027 finally yes we look forward to ratification by the membership we are the custodians who keep the schools clean and safe we are the secretaries and registar who keep everything running at all the school sites we are the instructional assistants Food Service workers noon Duty supervisors Library techs and maintenance Crews who support every student every day the district cannot function without us we know the board faces difficult decisions with an unprecedented millions of dollars of deficit leading to school closures Andor consolidations we know the riffs red ctions in force are coming the months ahead will be painful for
006all of us but let's be clear we cannot afford to be back here again next year we do not want a state takeover we do not want another year of uncertainty and financial mismanagement we want a future your decision Visions in the coming months will shape the future of this district for years to come Choose Wisely start now do what's right let's work together with courage with resilience and with a shared Vision vision for the future thank you thank you president Leeman next we have the Santa Rosa Teachers Association report president Katherine Howell good evening president there you are President MCN sorry uh superintendent Morales members of the board members of the community my name is Katherine Howell and I am the President of the Santa Rosa Teachers Association I currently represent about members I
007want to First say thank you for the larger venue uh there might not be a seat for everybody but but nobody's outside standing in the cold and soon to be rain so that is appreciated um we're here tonight uh the school closures are not on the uh agenda but we are surrounded by that thought and that feeling and all of these people are here because the pressure is mounting and the uncertainty is growing when I said that I currently represent 900 members um we have absolutely no idea how many that number will be next year no idea the agenda items tonight are about layoffs reduction in force uh cuts to teaching cuts to classified staff cuts to our Administration and we don't know what that's going to look like part of the reason we don't
008know what that's going to look like is because every time this board comes up with a new uh Innovative or startling or confusing configuration of elementary schools that are on middle school campuses uh 7 12 schools on high schools that can't accommodate them every time the board brings these things up we lose more families you need to do your job you need to mitigate the damage that has already be done and will continue to be done to this community make choices that keep students in our district realize that putting Four elementary schools together puts these kids on a campus that won't accommodate them has no services for our youngest students they don't have bathroom facilities they don't have what they need the same is true for 712 schools middle school students won't have the services
009and the facilities that they need on a high school campus these ideas will be very nearly impossible to implement and um quite frankly and and with due respect we're not convinced that it's going to get able you can pull it off before August just to be blunt about it it's not going to be easy and these new ideas are not going to work right away and we're going to lose families and our community will be broken more than it already has been and we will be right back here next year with budget deficit issues so please save the community save these families from having to make hard choices and leaving our district thank you thank you president Howell next is the superintendent report Dr Morales do you have anything so yes um so normally as
010this is the the meeting of the board um well welcome everyone thank you for being here normally I give a quick report um of what has happened in between meetings from the last board meeting to this board meeting um but today I requested from president mcnali to allow me to share a little bit of longer Report with important information as we move forward and I'm kind of kind of read so I don't miss any of the points I wanted to share so um I haven't had the opport opportunity to meet all of you in person but for those of you that haven't heard my story um I am a proud Puerto Rican um I very much have the Immigrant experience having come to California at the age of eight not knowing any English as Spanish
011is my first language I know what it's like to be unseen and unheard in a classroom because I didn't know the language um but I also know the joy of having a great teacher that made education engaging and made it a family EX experience they knew my mom my siblings they really welcomed the entire family and that's something that has stayed with me and it's one of the things I want to do for our families as well I also know the privilege of having been born a US citizen particularly having been born on a US Air Force Base as my father served in the military uh my mom was also a teacher for about 52 years and retired at the age of 72 so I come from a family with a heart of service um
012I have two grown kids my oldest will be 32 in May my youngest just turned 30 about two weeks ago and as students they taught me well as students they couldn't be more different but they also taught me about the importance of differentiated instruction and really supporting our teachers in that area in terms of our family and Community engagement here um I've learned that as a district we haven't done a great job in providing Community engagement for the community to provide input for the community to have conversations with us for the community to feel part of the process and for that I apologize um board meetings don't have the structure to have conversations um and and that is really not the purpose and I understand that that's the only structure you've had and we want
013to do better um the board I I am committed I think the board is too committed to providing more town halls and dialogue spaces that we can have as we move the district forward um I also I am planning to for us to apply for the California Community engagement initiative that will provide us funds to really go deep into this work around Community engagement um I want us to build a community of Learners I am committed to this district from day one I've moved here I'm working to get more and more involved I visited all 24 sites within the first five days I visited almost all classrooms um in the first semester um meeting with different community members I've met with over a dozen families personally um I've joined the first five commission to really
014have an articulation of from Cradle to to Career um and I am and I've applied and hope to be accepted to the chief's um Community advisory team to really learn about the legacy of this beautiful city this year we started the student superintendent student council we have five student leaders from each of the comprehensive high schools that we meet at least on a monthly basis to be able to talk about a Mirad of um questions that they might have but also to really customize our experiences for what they want to receive and for the first time ever students from the council presented um January 31st are at our all staff PD where the students actually created the questions that they themselves answered and the students loved it teachers got to hear from students and we
015want to keep that going we want to make sure that student voice is front and center in what we do I also know and I am aware that we have been lacking a strategic plan with clear goals and objectives that got that could guide our work in for the several next years to come I also knew that we would be where we are now in terms of right sizing the district and closing schools and it's very hard to do both in the same year so I look forward to us coming together and also building a strategic plan that has the voices of the community so I have the expertise to do all of the Strategic plan I have all this knowledge but that doesn't change anything it takes us coming together a community willing and
016able to think differently and using different lenses as how we view our students in order to change their experience we can continue to say say this worked for 20 years and we're going to continue doing it the same way remember we are preparing students for jobs that will look very different when they're in the workforce and we're actually you know training them for jobs that don't yet exist I was listening to the radio AI positions are everywhere and I'm like have we prepared our students for all the AI positions that are out there now so we have to be willing to take risks and do things differently we need a mindset that shifts to create in a different future and possibility for our students so I've been asked many many times now what's your vision
017and I've had and I've kind of been quiet because I also know with my position when I speak people say oh that's what we're doing because that's her idea um and it isn't we really want to hear from the community so we want to come together and create a community created strategic plan with goals objectives and Matrix that align to a district profile of a graduate um and that will be our North Star guiding our directions into the future we want schools that with specialized programs where students have a clear path to college and or career giving students options and giving them access we need to do a better job about serving our English language Learners and our newcomer students as I mentioned in a previous meeting our resources are spread too thin in order
018to Ser save Ser serve them well for the size of our district we really do need an enrollment center I've had many conversations with families around and received emails why is my experience of enrolling one student at this school so different than enrolling a student in another school so how do we become more efficient and effective and do things differently to serve our families and our community better um in listening to the start team and also seeing it for myself we do need a 712 alternative program for those students there a compr comprehensive High School isn't helping them well and we also need an instructional framework aligned to The Graduate profile that really allows us to see what each student at each grade level will be able to do and how they're going to graduate
019and what they're going to graduate with but on the topic of academic achievement I just wanted to know I wanted you to know some highlights I know everything has been around school closures but we got to remember that we're an educational institution and here's some of the highlights that you might not be aware of this year on the dashboard we had the highest a3g completion rate we went from a 31.6 pre pandemic to a 35.1 our H our graduation rates are the highest ever 84.3 to a now an 86% our Golden State Merit um diploma rate um was at a 15% it is now a 23.1% and so the work that the teachers and students have been doing has been phenomenal um this one you might not know about but how many of you remember
020the API index and school Improvement and all of that under no child he behind well the new version of that that started in 2017 is called differentiated assistance um and it's under the um Federal every Student Success act two years ago or two and a half years no two years ago 20 of our 24 schools were under differentiated assistance so think of it as school Improvement this year we only have three out of the 24 schools in that category amazing work yes please applaud for our students and our teachers and also the last the last point on academics um the hard work that the team has been doing around math is really paying dividends we have increased math scores across all student groups districtwide so there's a lot to celebrate among everything that we're going
021through we want to continue to keep that Focus so how are we going to make sure that this doesn't happen again that's another question that we keep hearing having worked in a large District myself and Lisa August um we've brought to the district the concept of using ratios to right siize our district which basically means as enrollment decreases es all positions at all levels decreases as as enrollment increases we increase positions as the need arise so that's what we mean by rightsizing The District in terms of making sure that the ratios are used across the board so we have significant work to be done ahead in terms of creating systems procedures protocols to make us more in efficient and effective and I I won't go through the timeline because I realize that I talked a
022lot but in conclusion I just wanted to say that we have to do this work together as a United Community I know there is a lot of distrust in The District in the Board of Trustees in my position um and all I ask is that you give us an opportunity to do better again um not trying to you know throw anyone under the bus we just have to do better I know we can and I hope that we can partner together to really engage in ra and Empower our students our parents and you our community so thank you for listening thank you Dr Morales thank you for reminding us of so much of the progress that we've made and the steps that we're planning on um next is my board president report normally this is
023where I would talk about my activities since our last meeting my activities recently have been a lot of reading I'm reading all of your emails I know I hardly respond to any of them but trust me I am reading them also since our study session I have all of my papers with our enrollment capacity budget numbers I am spending a lot of time sitting on the couch running scenarios in my head um that's what I've been doing um and also I just I know we've talked about this before but I want to reiterate so everyone understands the board we can only discuss in Open session so I can sit at home and I can think as much as I want about how we're going to handle closures and consolidations but the board as a whole
024we don't get to talk about it we're not working behind the scenes we have to talk about it in open session so when it seems like we're not agreeing right away or we're coming up with even more scenarios that's the natural process that's how it works um so we're going to be continuing that work um we're going to have another study session on the 18th and then decision on the 19th um continue emailing us continue I especially want to know what you all think about not just individual schools but the different scenarios and approaches of you know larger schools or 7 through 12 whether you have positive or negative thoughts on those things that is what I want to hear about um and that's all for me I'll turn it over to the board for
025any other board member reports I'll go trusty Jenkins and then trusty deor all right new microphones um so hello there we go uh hello everyone I know it's really noisy in the back it would be very nice if you guys could pay attention to the Trustees for a little bit longer thanks um I do not have something completely prepared tonight thanks for the quiet coyotes I saw that uh but I do have some words written down to help me through this um but my first one is thanks because I while we had the consolidation report last week feels like an eternity ago um I didn't personally get to thank the people that were up here because uh we were so focused on the questions and getting more information and I really really really wanted to
026thank uh Leisa August as well as Ben Wolf and everyone who was involved in that consolidation process I attended um I attended all of the meetings whether that be in person or over zoom and I as a skeptical parent who has in the past my trust has gone down in the district part of me going to everything was to rebuild that trust and wanting to make sure that you know oh I'm looking over everything too and are they doing everything right um going through all of it and I was so I personally was very impressed with the process I was impressed with the um what's the word I'm looking for not Clarity but transparency I was impressed with the transparency and more than anything I was shocked that the individuals who were part of that
027committee came up to a decision um that made sense to get that many people on the same page is is a pretty big deal my next word is trust and that kind of goes hand inand so we all have to kind of trust I know it's hard I'm right there with you but we do have to trust the processes that are in place um like I have to as a trustee I need to trust the superintendent right because she is doing the things that she needs to do not all of us up here have jobs like we we work outside of this and we can't put in 40 to 80 hours a week going over everything and it's not our job like we we get your information um we get all of your feedback which
028I appreciate so much and then there's there's a process thank you so much for your opinions I'm still talking though the third word I wanted to say was resilience the third word I want I have written down is resilience and the reason for that is because I don't want the students that come out of our education system to just have resilience I want them to be wonderful educated contributing citizens in our community and while everyone in our community is so resilient we also need them to be well-educated citizens of our community when um when people launch and lastly I really wanted to put out um kindness because we are all going through this together I think we've all I think everyone in this room has had a moment of oh my gosh what am I
029gonna do next week what am I gonna do in the fall and remember that feeling when we move forward with this process because anything we do impacts our entire city and remember that when you are interacting with other people students staff community members please remember to be kind and the feelings that you have had through this experience others are sharing the same and sometimes it doesn't come out the way we want it to but it's usually based in something else right so please remember to be kind to each other to us and thank you guys and thank you so much for being here I really wanted to do the wave earlier but I don't know how it would go over but it it would be amazing in here and I'd love to see everybody in
030the same room and remember we're doing this together before we go on to our next board member report I do need to ask everyone in the middle of the gym to try to separate and leave a center aisle we want to have a center aisle leading up to the P Podium so if you're standing in the center of the room try to find space on the sides as much as possible we can't have anyone standing right in the center thank you thank you for understanding all right trusty deor good evening all thank you very much for your attendance tonight thank you very much for continuing to comment email message see us in public and have conversations um none of us are taking this lightly there are some very large decisions upcoming and they can no
031longer be delayed or avoided and the can can no longer be kicked down the road this is a problem that our district has had for several years and we cannot continue to be upset about how we got here or why we got here we have to deal with what's on our place in front of us right now so this board must remain Resolute and put put something to vote next Wednesday on the 19th we have to make a vote and it's not going to be comfortable and it's going to upset people and know that this board's intent is to attempt to rightsize our district right size our budget with the least traumatic results possible for our citiz and staff we cannot keep all of our schools open we cannot afford to operate 24 campuses any
032longer we are in a very unfortunate position we are not the only District in that position and more and more districts are now hitting the news with the same sad results that we are dealing with we are not alone in this but being the largest District We are continuing to attempt to be transparent communicate and show other districts how to get through this difficult process I thank each and every one of my board members for their continued support and we were not able to discuss this as a board until last Wednesday that was our first appro opportunity and that word opportunity is what we need to focus on here forward what opportunities can we build moving forward the scat committee put a lot of hard work and time into their efforts to provide recommendations we're
033not ignoring those recommendations we are not ignoring elementary schools we're not ignoring anyone we are attempting to find results to put to vote that will provide the best opportunity for the students moving forward in the least traumatic way possible thank you Other Board member reports trusty Casten thank you um I'm going to address some of the things that the electricities have addressed by want to start by talking about some of the actions that as a new board we started taking at the beginning of this year recognize that of this board three of us are new within the last three months five of us are new within the last two years and about two months so uh there is a lot of things that are going to be happening differently as we start to govern differently
034one of those things was at our very first meeting as a new board we had adopted and formed a finance committee now that is something that exists for a lot of districts and governments but we didn't have one and the purpose of that finance committee is to look long range look at liabilities look at projections look at a lot of the things that have created the crisis that we're dealing with today and this isn't going to help us today but it will help us for next year and so the board uh Finance subcommittee uh we are having our first meeting on March the first Monday in March I did not write the date down the 3 uh it will be meeting from 3:30 to 5:30 and we'll start meeting regularly uh each month as the
035board finance committee uh through June on the first Monday from 3:30 to 5:30 and that information will be posted it's a standing committee and that transparency as well as the opportunity for us as a committee to be meeting and talking about those things is one step we're taking towards looking forward in being prudent in our financial decisions I also want to just speak briefly and I know a lot of us are speaking to it to the closure process if we had had a closed process where the president superintendent went behind closed doors came out with a recommendation um and we all voted on it or a process where the committee's recommendations came up and we voted on it without having the conversations that have led to much of the revelations and shocked in the last
036few days we could be sitting here talking about having just implemented super elementaries with no one actually really having realize that that's what we were talking about but because we had this open process and we were able to ask questions we're learning more about what these proposals mean and it means that you're now here again able to tell us us what we need to know about something that wasn't truly understood until last Friday so The credibility of this process is strong because of that transparency but unlike a business where they want to come out with a clean message that rallies everyone around it we want to come up with a solution that included everyone in creating it and that's naturally going to be messy but it's going to make it a better Sol solution in
037the end and I appreciate all of you I visited with many of you at your campuses I'm still trying to book every single one of those appointments uh that I've gotten on emails so you know let's let's keep this dialogue going seven more days for us to make what is going to be a very difficult but in the long term a very impactful decision and I thank you all for your participation so I want to inject just to give Clarity when he mentions the process that the district selected so there's there were three options that the district could selected around student consolidation and the committee so one the board could have decided and remember again this is the previous board could have decided to do that work themselves meet every month on a separate meeting
038to go through all of the criteria that the committee went through they could have done that they chose to actually have an ad hoc committee that did that work for them and had that work done transparently in public the third option was that they could have had it be a superintendent committee where it could have been done without brand act um limitations and then the recommendations would come to the board through the superintendent the board in my opinion selected the best possible transparent option which was they didn't have the bandwidth to do all that work they hire they put a committee together of 20 members which is normally called a 7-Eleven committee because in that committee it's usually seven to 11 members but the board said no we need more representation hence why we had
03920 we had 21 to start with one dropped out so we had 20 members of the committee I know it seems like it was divisive and everything happened in public that was the most transparent way that the board could have selected to have this process done as divisive I think as it seems because I know I heard someone say at the last meeting why didn't you do the rankings in secret that's not the that's not the selection that the board made the selection that the board made was to have the most transparent process as hard and difficult as it has been the other thing I wanted to add is the Finance commit subcommittee is to the board the district has always had a fiscal stabilization or actually a fiscal committee made up of parents staff
040bargaining Partners um and this year um Lisa August and I talked about adding a student to that finance committee and we'll be opening up because we need more parents the parents that are currently sitting on the finance District committee um their students are aging out so we new new participation in that committee and we'll be putting that out in in the spring so that parents can join this is an additional um finance committee of the board where they're going to be looking at four to five years out where are we at in the fiscal picture so like um trusty Caston said we're not this in this scenario in five years the board will be looking long out uh while the fiscal Committee of the district looks at What's Happening Now however are we spending what's
041where are we overspending and things like that so I just want to provide that Clarity so everybody understands why the board selected the process they they selected thank you for the clarification and we have one more board member report trusty Kirby check hello everyone uh thanks again for being here I love the great uh turnout of everyone we certainly appreciate and want to hear your voices so I'm going to try to keep this brief so we can get to the public comments um just a just a quick recap um since our last meeting I've been to as many schools as I could fit in I went to Ridgeway Proctor Terrace Hidden Valley Luther Burbank steel Lane part of the Santa Rosa uh campus here I'm trying to get to all the campuses that I can
042um I I want to physically put eyes on everything to be able just visualize what we're talking about when we see these campuses um I also want to thank again Lisa August and the district team uh for the incredible amount of work that they've done uh we're taxing them uh significantly with all of the information requests that we've uh put forward to them and they're doing a great job of getting us the information we need and we really appreciate that and that's it that's all I got uh student board member Zuniga do you have a report oh they're actually GNA sit there so I met with the superintendent student council yesterday um and we were at Maria CUO thank you Maria C for hosting us and they wanted to come together as representations of all
043of the school RS and share kind of a message with the board um so we have pretty much representation I think om will let us know who's missing and why they're missing um but I will turn it over to our trustee um suniga to share what the student superintendent student council wants to share with the board and the community okay can you hear me okay awesome pretend you're eating the mic so they can hear you I'm I'm gonna eat the mic eat the mic okay um okay hello uh community and all in attendance and board my name is IGA I am the student trustee and the president of the superintendent student council um I am a senior at Santa Rosa and I stand here sit here um representing Santa Rosa High School on this committee
044before we begin I'd like to preface that we've built this together in community and collaboration and in collaboration um koreo is representative couldn't be here tonight um but their thoughts and ideas are displayed and a part of this live report um so I'll hand it over to Sydney St okay hello board staff students and Families my name is Sydney strad and I'm a senior at Montgomery High School over the last four years at my school I've experienced what it takes to elevate a school that is sitting at Rock Bottom into a supportive and caring Community I've had the privilege of meeting my best friends connecting with some amazing teachers and achieving academic success all on one campus I love my community and I'm so proud to be sitting in front of all you today to
045share that none of my experiences could have happened without the Santa Rosa city school district as I look to the right of me I see so many amazing students that have put in so much effort and time into their own campuses and communities and it makes me proud that we are all sitting here together at this table tonight while we are all from different backgrounds communities and high schools we shared the same passion and energy for our education and cultures the Santa Rosa city school district has offered so many students a safe environment to grow and become the most successful versions of ourselves but none of this would be possible if we weren't United as one group we need to stop seeing ourselves as different from one another but as a shared Community all searching
046for the same concept that is Unity sad sadly in these past few weeks Unity is something that I feel we've lost side of recently in light of school closures schools have been pinned against each other what happened to the community that is the Santa Rosa city school district we need to unite as one to get through this dark period we need to support one another through this difficult time because we all know how we would react if we knew that our school was closing it's very immature to react poorly at students in pain we need to remember that as a community kindness matters and respect is an essential component of achiev of achieving a unified district let's rid ourselves of the hate we are throwing at each other because at the end of the day
047we are all students teachers and faculty that coexist in this District together um so um as a committee um we ask that you the board make sure that in the future when eventually we have to consolidate schools um that a safe transition be held um and that resources are allocated to those affected um we know that there are plans in place but we want to make sure that we reaffirm those plans um and make sure that families know that there are plans in place we want the board to make a decision that will have the least amount of impact on students and make sure that with this decision we are not back in the same place in 5 years time we don't want to keep pushing back these same issues um and postponing these problems
048as a council we've discussed scenarios um and reviewed data and numbers and we strongly believe in those data data in that data and those numbers um we've gone over scenarios like the 311 321 um the idea of closing middle schools as well as um three elementary schools or Closing one high school and adapting the others to a 7 through 12 model we've had numerous conversations all of these were workshopped to meet a goal of about 10 million that we hope to achieve through through these consolidations thank [Music] you hello um good afternoon board community members and staff my name is Savannah maayan I am from LCN high school and I am a junior and I just wanted to talk about if it does come to the case that we do have to shut down one
049of our high schools that we would we would need a plan for any students especially students who are coming in who are going into their senior or junior year we want to have we W to we want them to know that you guys you all can support us in our studies and in our going into our college career and just in general we want to know that we are we still have your support even after all these dark times I know it's not easy and I know all of community members and a lot of our high school students can agree that this is just it's really tough but it's the reality and we really want to make sure that we have your support and we have we know that you all have our backs we
050want to make sure that we we have sorry we have come up with some examples of how to support us we want some examples is if we do if it does come to that situation wherever we transfer we want to be able to have whenever we do graduate we want to be able to have a certificate if not the diploma of our original High School another example we have or we all came up with is we can wear our cap and gown from our original high school as well I also want to mention that if we can keep supporting our students with scholarships and different different types of stuff like that that can help us with especially helping our low-income students especially from St High School I do come from a lowi income family and
051it is really hard especially with my mom she works almost every day to keep a roof to keep a roof under my head and I do want to make sure that you all can still help us if it's not just I know it is a bit hard to promote that our our school is doing an excellent job promoting all our scholarships and helps with our seniors and juniors currently I just want to make sure that even if does happen I want to make sure that we can still have that hope even in different schools thank you hello my name is Vincent Roman I am a freshman at Piner and I think the rest of my friends here have already said what they wanted to say I just want to lightly touch up and reinforce the
052idea that we are community that we are the students the teachers The Faculty the staff the board members the parents who came here tonight I just want to thank you all for coming here too so I just want to reinforce the idea that we are Community we don't want to hate one another right we want to love one another we want to respect one another so we just thank you so much for your ideas of trying to get to 10 million to not wanting to close down a high school school because in my opinion every single high school is a Cornerstone piece of our community if we remove that how will we work as a body to move as one so I thank you so much for your time and that's really all I have
053if they're members of the superintendent student council on the audience so any superintendent student councils in the audience if you can stand or raise your hand so you could be acknowledged superintendent student council members it is my privilege and my honor to work with this group of students and thank and students I thank you your voice matters and we want to continue hearing your voice thank you for sharing your hearts with us today all right now for the part of the meeting that I think most of you are here for public comment on non-agenda and consent items um if you've been to a board meeting before you know that as the board president it's my discretion to set the time limits for public comment I have more blue cards than I think I've ever seen
054before um so I want I want to Prior prioritize hearing as many people as possible even if that means you can't say everything that you want to so I'm going to put a total 2our limit but only one minute each I know that's short I want to give you permission to skip the niceties a lot of people start with you know dear president MCN superintendent skip it get straight to your point I also want to be able to somewhat prioritize student voices so what I'm going to do is we have it separated into students and non-students and I'm GNA I'm going to alternate between the two piles so that I think we'll be able to get through all of the students possibly not all of the adults okay I'm going to call three names at
055a time so when you hear your name line up behind the podium and again just one minute each so first we be pain alternating oh Leila Payne followed by Elizabeth ridlington followed by Danica Schwan um are all of you ready when does my timer start on my first word go ahead okay uh hello my name is Leila Payne I am currently a senior at Sosa High School I am the vice president of art Quest theater a member of the softball team and co- captain of Debate Club I am also a fourth generation high school student something people from other schools can not often say Santa Rosa High School is one of the most historically significant places in Santa Rosa itself I would like to talk about art quest which is a magnet program that brings
056in students from outside of the district however as vice president of this club I have learned that the district does not have any respect for this program from shutting down our shows to demolishing our buildings it is clear it is clear they will not spend the time or energy to keep it alive this program brings in people who otherwise go to other schools outside the district an SRS closure means students leaving the district therefore losing more money I want to end my speech by asking the trustees this what sacrifices are you making thank you Lea your time is up thank you next is Elizabeth ridlington followed by danah Schwan followed by Nadia CA I'm Elizabeth ridlington I'm the parent of a sophomore at Santa Rosa High School my concern is that we've spent many months
057talking about what schools to close and what we're going to lose in this process and we haven't spent very much time at all talking about what our new school communities are going to look like and I think that's why this feels so terrifying and very rushed to the community my request of you is to put off this decision for at least a month to give us more time to understand what our reconfigured schools might look like thank you thank you next is Dana Kwan followed by Nadia Kura followed by Rachel grun Bal hi everyone my name is danawan and I'm a sophomore at mcgomery high school I'm the vice president for a school at our club called best buddies best buddies is a club where high school students with and without deop developmental disabilities are
058matched in a one-on-one friendship we have meetings at our school every other week doing different activities some of the events we organize for our school include a countywide inclusive prom Special Olympics and even tickets to college sporting events mcgomery also hosts the soccer Special Olympics at the beginning of the school year mcgomery students are that are a part of best buddies organize cooking classes for students with disabilities once a month where everyone is welcome best buddies is one of the many diverse clubs in mcgomery that help create an inclusive and welcoming culture on our campus we have have really created a welcoming inclusive and diverse community at our school and it would be really sad to see it go thank you next is nadiaa followed by Rachel grun Bal followed by Reed heavner hello I
059am a freshman from Santa Rosa High School I attend the artquest program and Santa Rosa high school offers so many opportunities for people who wouldn't have it otherwise we have a college right next to our school which provides so many opportunities for our students and by closing the school this would be tearing apart the diverse community that arquest has and the creative community that we have at this school we want to preserve this and as a as a community we want to rise our make our school better we are the only school with a debate tournament that goes to actual tournaments these our Debate Club that goes to actual tments these helps political leaders grow this helps youth help convey themselves to the public and this school means so much to me without this school
060we would be tearing apart this diverse Community which allows so many kids to get the things that they need to be able to support themselves thank you next is Rachel grun bam followed by Reed heavner followed by Bradley George hello my name is Rachel gr bom and I a sophomore at Montgomery High School I want to say thank you for valuing to keep all of the high schools open I am the vice president of the Viking voices the school newspaper at Montgomery my older sister Caroline who graduated last year brought back the first physical newspaper to Montgomery and one of the only physical high school newspapers that exists in our County this is the just one of the examples of the valuable programs available to the diverse population of Montgomery the IB Program creates a
061culture of diversity inclusivity and critical thinking that is not just available at any other high school I'm in student government and we are more than ready to welcome new students onto our campus as a part of Montgomery family closing a high school will decimate college acceptances and the thriving Community we built please do the right thing and vote to keep all of the high schools open thank you thank you next is Reed heavner followed by Bradley George followed by Carrie Joseph I'd like to address the board but more specifically trusty Jenkins um you spoke earlier at this meeting about building Community Trust which I really appreciate thank you very much but in the past you said um that as a Montgomery parent that you were not interested in the future of this District quite as
062much if Montgomery were to shut is that not right my apologies I must have I've heard from quite a number of people that you've said you are I put that wrong I'm sorry that you are interested in maybe leaving the district no my apologies then I I would like to end my time my apologies but thank you for your uh commitment to building Community Trust sorry thank you next is Bradley George followed by Carrie Joseph followed by Alicia mut mutunga is Bradley George here no then we'll go on to Carrie Joseph hi I'm krie Joseph and I've worked at sah High since 1997 as an English teacher and still as our track and cross country coach I'm I'm here to ask that we keep all five high schools open but specifically I will be speaking
063about San Ros High San R Roa high is a foundation and essence of this very City most San R Roa natives walked these hallways its central location literally anchors this city the school offers extraordinary programs that are both comprehensive and unique resulting in a kaleidoscope of creative and motivated students unparalleled in this District Santa R Roa high is the historic heartbeat of Santa Rosa it is this City's lifeblood it is a symbol if you want to see the impact it's made and The Roots it's laid down look no no further than our oncampus Museum our $7 million endowment and this crowd closing San roah high would be an emotional gut punch that would permanently impact Generations both past and future do not close the heart and soul of the city thank you Santa thank you
064next is Alisia Munga followed by Laura Robinson followed by Eloise Bower hi my name is Alicia matunga and I'm the junior class president here at Santa Rosa high school I'm going to start by thanking the school district and its board members for the amount of notice you guys have given us about these school closures I really appreciate how upfront and loud and strongly you guys came to us that is not what you did instead you shamefully kept it from us and at when we needed it most you pitched us against each other there is no one single person a blame and this was a failure from the district as a whole and I'm disappointed by the leadership ability that has been presented while handling this situation every single high school is individually unique so I'd
065like to remind you that not closing a high school can be an option to put this into very clear words let's put our thinking caps on and turn them to 100 and find a way to save the young adults whom you're supposed to protect and support High School can make or break the entrance into adulthood and interrupting these crucial Li years to your lives is ruining and putting on hold well over 1,000 individuals education and lives and it's thank you next is Laura Robinson followed by Eloise Bowser followed by manona Bruin hello no high school should be closed the district is telling us they have to close a high school to fix their budgeting problem but we elected you all to stand up for the rights of our children and to fight for what's best
066for them and their educational needs I recognize that on this board there are members who are parents at other schools who are alumni but no one in sport has a personal connection to Santa Rosa High School when making a decision as huge as this that impacts not only the students in their families and their teachers but the entire Community I am hoping that this decision will be made for not for personal reasons but for reasons that truly benefit our student Community as a whole you are suddenly looking at Santa Rosa high school that has the most students that brings in the most money into the district the math doesn't add up if you are trying to save money for a district this probably isn't news to you but if you close Santa Rosa High School
067families will drive outside of this district and go to another school we have lost faith in the Santa Rosa city school district and we are already a working family thank you your time is up next is Eloise Bowser followed by minona Brin followed by Dean Jansen hello my name is Eloise Bowser I'm a student at Slater Middle School I'm I'm representing my beautiful school and here to tell you why you shouldn't move Slater to Montgomery or close our school entirely I have a sister at Montgomery and even with her there I'd be super scared to go to school with high schoolers as a seventh grader I needed and still do that little cushion that Middle School gives us along with many other seventh graders I had a t hard time getting to classes and opening
068my locker if you were to throw us into the deep end without teaching us how to swim that'd be the same thing as making us go from elementary school skipping middle school and going straight to high school last but not least what what do you think would happen to our Sports you may not see the importance of these but our Sports keep us in shape build life skills and bonds that could last a life time that said even though I'm rep protesting Force later not to get switched Monty closed at all I still do not believe that you should close any high schools or middle schools thank you thank you next is manona Brin followed by Dean Jansen followed by Ali Meyers hi my name is manona I have a son at Proctor Terrace Elementary
069School and a daughter at Santa Rosa Middle School looking forward to attending Santa Rosa high school next year in the art Quest program I don't understand why this district is closing 20% of the schools when there is an 8% budget deficit the rinken valley Union School District had a 7% deficit and they just closed it without closing any schools I am dismayed that our district Business Services has not presented did any scenarios to balance revenues and expenses they could have presented their revenues sorry the revenues and expenses uh scenarios in August yet they chose to do this extended committee ranking SCH thank you your time is up next is Dean Jansen followed by Ali Myers followed by Elanor McCoy hello hello my name is Dean Jansen I am the ASV vice president here at San
070Rosa high school and the art Quest theater president here at Sanara high school we are dis distinguished not only by our Legacy but also by our specialized programs and location just adjacent to the S Rosa Junior College this proximity gives our students easy access to college level courses greatly enhancing their educational experience with Santa Ros High School boundary only holding 750 students which is the the the smallest boundary of all high schools in district yet we have over 600 students choosing to transfer to SRS we consistently attract families from across the county seeking our highquality education we offer mainly through our specialized programs such as artquest recently the arquest theater program received the spirit of Len award for its extraordinary leadership skills among numerous of other prestigious awards at at this theater Ceremony this recognition
071highlights our program's excellence and exceptional opportunities we provide making ARS one of the top performing performing Performing Arts programs in the states I urge your time is up next is Ali Meyers followed by Eleanor McCoy followed by Ashley Bell hi um I'm here to ask and Advocate that you keep all high schools open uh but since youve just recently turned your attention last Friday to Santa Rosa High I feel like I have to speak up on its behalf um I think it should stay open it is the school with the city's namesake dates back to the 1800s and I don't know about you but I don't know anybody who knows anybody from the 1800s it's historic it's a landmark um the foundation raises millions of dollars every well not every year but it has seven
072millions in an endowment fund with 50 scholarships offered last year it's centrally located with 13 bus routes nearby it allows students to get here with ease even students with very little means with the free bus routes um and the Dual classification being next to the JC is is a win closing any High School is the wrong decision and these students this this group of students have endured so much and they deserve a little bit of your grace because of all they've been through thank you thank you next is Eleanor McCoy followed by Ashley Bell followed by Dalia uh Bia I would like to thank our school district for causing chaos and competition at a time when we should be United instead of carefully Towing the line of reason they have Amplified rivalries and made students
073angry I would like to thank the district for possibly closing the oldest school which just hit 150 years thank you for possibly closing the only school with the magnet arts program with in a 20-minute car ride it would be really cool if the town of Santa Rosa didn't have a high school named after it thank you for choosing not to acknowledge all of the students that choose to wake up early every day and commit to Santa Rosa from 20 to 30 minutes away because they prefer their education and safety at Santa Rosa high school thank you for pushing our Quest aside and insisting that it will have a future when you have done nothing to safeguard and assure that future including the recent censorship and lack of communication per recent events knowing that the program
074is well acclaimed and the only program that can compete with Marin School of the Arts located in Novado and noo at Windsor High both are extremely well-known programs in all of C California but only arquest is the only able being able to compete with these high ranking programs thank you for carry more thank you your time is off next is Ashley Bell followed by Dalia IA followed by Jim Carol hi my name is Ashley Bell and I have the privilege and honor of being a history teacher here at Santa Rosa high school we have many programs here that cannot be moved we have a barn a wood shop a metal shop an auto shop here on campus our artquest program is as movable as Monty's IB program and offers nine Specialties that draw students from
075across the county we have a 60 acre offsite farm and a brand new barn and a six acre Vineyard we have the ninth oldest high school title in the state we have the second FFA Charter in the state we have the second most diverse student body we have an exceptionally large and beautiful campus that costs less per square foot than any other high school campus we have more students transferring into our school than any other both inside and outside of our district at surface level we appear to be the most costly to run however when dividing the overall 2425 School total costs by student enrollment you will find that we rank third when it comes to cost per student we have a teaching staff with over 1200 years of experience we have a foundation with
076a $7 million endowment that gives $250,000 to Santa Rosa students every year thank you your time is up next is dollia ABIA followed by Jim Carol followed by Jason Dennis hi my name is dollia buik I am a junior at Santa Rosa high and treasur of art Quest theater I am a level three of art Quest theater class had an amazing opportunity to make it to the lanaa theater Festival from the Festival we won 11 individual Awards plus the spirit of Len award Synergy gold for our one act redacted out of the 74 schools art Quest was the school that won the most Awards plus only four schools get gold for their one act and we were one of them art Quest has made their name as the top performing arts program in this state
077I commute an hour to be a part of art Quest program it has been it has been the best of my life and this is with this most amazing Community I beg of you Santa Rosa High School is an has amazing opportunities and its programs and history thank you thank you next is Jim Carrol followed by Jason Dennis followed by Christina tce first for this whole process felt [Music] likeo it's a lot think I think the best is we need toct we need more students cut our schools anding them Le eles anding our schools it's not attractive to people they're not thank you your time is off next is Jason Dennis followed by Christina Tri followed by Eliza Evans e I see Rosa as a school thank you your time is up next is Christina
078Trice followed by Eliza Evans followed by Michelle Crosby got your heart and ask yourself if your family was living here would you want your child in a super Elementary with over 900 students when you were looking for a small neighborhood school would you want your 12-year-old in a high school with 18-year-old adults stand up for our communities our children and what is right do not allow the District staff to continue to pull the wool over your eyes they have continuously withheld permanent information to fit their agenda time and time again their excuses continue with a fault line when experts have already shown geological analysis can be completed in just a few months too proor terce has done before and can do it again closing a school due to proximity shows how disconnected the district is
079to the communities being affected their priorities are not the safety or well-being of our students it's about numbers don't get the middle of the Santa Rosa for the sake of convenience there's a reason why you're using the Santa Roosa high school gymnasium Central your time is up next is Eliza Evans followed by Michelle Crosby followed by elel Rodriguez Garcia hello my name is Eliza Evans and I'm a sophomore at Montgomery High School I'm hoping to take IB classes next year and I know that this has been said many times but the conditions needed to move the IB program at Montgomery seem extremely difficult to do considering that we only have less than six months there are sophomores and juniors hoping to take part in this program next year and they would all like to continue
080on this path of Education closing Montgomery right now would not give the necessary amount of time to get this program program up and running this causes the students who are already taking part in our IB program to not have the ability to complete it next year I have found and created a community that is irreplaceable inside of Montgomery and I would hate to see that all leave I know that you guys are trying your best to find the right solution but please please please do not make that closing Montgomery thank you thank you next is Michelle Crosby followed by elel Rodriguez Garcia followed by Aaron Matthews hi my name is Michelle Crosby I'm a proud alumni of sersa High School class of 96 I'm a CPA with extensive experience in reviewing budgets deficits and the
081need for consolidation in my work I analyze financial statements daily and while I understand the importance of scrutinizing costs and expenditures it's equally vital to focus on the revenue side of the equation San Ros High School is the highest operating budget in the district however you consider the current cost of operations divided by enrollment SRS is less expensive than other schools in the district I recognize that the board faces incredibly difficult decisions however closing San Rosa High School will not help meet fiscal objectives such a decision would devastate the community and undermine San Roosa City School's ability to attract and retain students the data clearly indicates that SRS has a net positive transfer rate underscoring its importance to families in our feeder districts closing any school with a positive transfer rate is fiscally irresponsible I
082urge you to keep sose High School open for the benefit of our students community and the future of San Rosa city schools thank you next is Rodriguez Garcia followed by Aaron Matthews followed by matys Murphy Santa Rosa High School a high school so great they named the city after it I I want this school to be the school my younger siblings attend due to their curricular such as FFA CTE classes like wood shop auto shop and due to its art Quest program did you know Santa Rosa High School is the first High School in this District that is going to perform at kegi Hall did you know did you know that Santa Rosa High School is one of two high schools that offers an orchestral class Santa Rosa high school has many classes to offer
083for anyone interested in potential art careers or in trades just recently the Woodshop classes is teaching peers about Plumbing about life skills that people can learn and finally our spring play has returned because of our stagecraft classes this amaz these amazing opportunities offered at the school can't be replaced anywhere else thank you thank you next is Aaron Matthews followed by matys Murphy followed by Chris Gray I'm here to say no to Super elementary schools and yes to Neighborhood schools I'm appalled that this scenario was even brought to the table it's not in the best interest of our students you will lose District families and could end up erasing savings you might get we will we want what's best for our kids and a super Elementary is not not that Elementary School students have between six
084and 14 years left in this District they are the future of this District you have as much responsibility to our TK through six children as you do to any other grade I ask the board to follow the committee's recommendation to close three elementary schools Portables can be moved to ensure that there is space for all students closures could be staggered over a two-year period to allow rain remaining School sites to be prepared to welcome new kids a super Elementary School is not thank you your time is up next is matys Murphy followed by Chris Gray followed by Allison green my name is Matthis Murphy and I'm a fourth grade student at CCA I am here to share two things the first is that I have heard that ccla may need to move campuses again we
085have once moved before and I hope we do not have to move again the last thing I would like to share is please don't close Santa Rosa High School my dad teaches there he's a good school other schools are good too thank you thank you next is Chris Gray followed by Alison green followed by Patty roboam Carreras after Friday's study session most of us are questioning the school district's ability to provide you with accurate thoughtful scenarios that can be implemented by August why the 311 model they came up with was never feasible and we are just now hearing about how will not easily work so why did Lisa August ask the school consolidation advisory committee to identify a 311 forclosure why did we even have the five Town Halls why has the school district continued
086to provide you with unrealistic scenarios most concerning was presenting with the idea of the super elementaries which would gut almost all our neighborhood schools understand to save all the high schools means sacrificing all our elementary and middle schools if you lose enough Elementary School students next year you will end up closing at least one high school anyway you have a responsibility rep to represent all our students best interest not just the high school students sorry guys make sure you are getting accurate information from the district moving forward to make your decision Proctor ter is in the house thank you your time is up next is Allison green followed by Patty robathan Carreras followed by Haley Javier hello my name is Allison green and I'm a senior srhs I am known to be blunt by my
087friends and I would like to spew My Views to you you as a board have set our school up for failure you targeted art Quest specifically censoring theater and got your feelings hurt when the community fought back on your actions you downplayed the severity of school closure so we wouldn't show up you fired our principal and replac him with a district plant and you have created a huge divide between all of the schools causing more stress and hate when we should be uplifting and supporting each other do you really want to be known as the board that closed one of the oldest high schools in California do you want to be known as the board who doesn't care about people and only about their wallets no matter what happens people will be displaced and depressed
088I am asking you to wake up everyone loves their school with all their hearts thank you for hearing my words thank you next is Patty roboam Carreras followed by Haley Javier followed by Aaron giri my name is Patty Carreras I'm a secretary of the Santa Rosa High School Foundation board and a 1966 graduate of Santa Rosa High School my sisters and my brother graduated from here before I did my sons went to Montgomery my granddaughter is at koreo and other family members graduated from Piner and I have neighbors who were teachers at LC Allen and a neighbor who was a student there none of these high schools should close currently in development in the Santa Rosa H zoning District 168 units on mesino Avenue 129 units in railroad Square Pullman Lo lofs Phase 2 40
089units next to completed one phase one with 94 units Fountain Grove apartments on Fountain Grove Parkway 23 39 multifam units and at 3575 manino Avenue 532 multifam units thank you your time is up next is Haley Javier followed by Aaron giri followed by Riley uh Pier if I say your name wrong just say it at the start of your comment hi I'm Haley Javier and I can say that as a current sophomore at SRS that this school has created such a great Community for all of its students Santa Rosa High offers many opportunities for students with our Artest program AP and honors courses and our CTE programs as well I take wood shop and it provides me and others with Hands-On learning that prepares us to enter the workforce and prepares us for our futures
090our connection with the srjc provides us with yet another way to help us with our futures and allow those who wish to continue down the path of college to be able to experience what their future may look like Santa Rosa high is not just a plot of land or a bunch of buildings it is a place where an amazing group of individuals come together to create a safe inclusive and welcoming environment for anyone and everyone who comes onto our campus thank you thank you next is Aaron Gary followed by Riley Pier Peele what oh okay followed by Matt Davis all right um I'm here as a parent and as a teacher I am not here to argue for anyone's School even though I'm connected to several because everyone here believes their school is special and
091should be spared I believe that no schools should close this disorganized process has brought chaos and stress to our community all because of the district's fiscal mismanagement the district wants to balance their budget on the backs of our children and has pitted our schools against each other it feels like a dog fight when we should really be all on the same side fighting for fiscal accountability so board members ask yourselves we live in one of the wealthiest places in this world where is the money going school closures do not end up saving as much money as projected is there another way and finally how did we get into this mess you have free agency as individuals do not vote for something you do not believe in and when the dust settles from from whatever decision
092you make understand that our district will continue to bleed students if we do not create a sustainable Vision that attracts people to our schools thank you next is Riley Perell followed by Matt Davis followed by Zack pton I was proud to talk about my experience in Career Technical education several weeks ago when you passed the resolution for February to be Career Technical Education Month I hope you were listening just as I listen to every single one of you when you talked about some of your individual experiences in your own life that involved CTE education which is why I'm surprised that you were requesting financial information to close the only truly comprehensive CTE High School in the district Santa Rosa high school offers over 10 different Career Technical education Pathways has the smallest boundary but over
0931,500 students students like me come to srhs outside of our district I would like to remind you of those experiences that you have with crew technical education that shaped your life and have helped develop the person you have become I would like to remind you of your pledge to help fortify existing Creer technical education and I would like to remind you that the multi-million doll your time is up next is Matt Davis followed by Zach p numbert 10 followed by Brian Beaver Matt Davis I've been teaching physics and science at Santa Rosa High School since 1996 um since you will be closing unfortunately approximately 20% of the schools within the district you the elected board should definitely direct the superintendent to cut the district office budget and P Personnel by at least that much if
094not more one could argue that further Cuts than that should be made since 2014 14 or so enrollment in the district has gone down the number of positions at the district office has quadrupled or more that's not right um the superintendent will not recommend that to you her assistant will not recommend that to you it's an imperative upon you you you owe it to the taxpayers to the kids to the parents to cut the district office also the point's been made Santa Rosa High attracts more students from outside its attendance boundaries than any other school you will lose some of those kids to other districts if you close Santa Ro High your time is up next is Zach pton followed by Brian Beaver followed by Fiona gwe I just want to start this off by
095saying I came into this school fully expecting to transfer to a different school next year but this school changed all of that all of the communities I'm a part of whether it's arquest theater football wrestling or sports are so rich in the entire Community here in itself is amazing it would be almost impossible to shut us down especially with the 150 years of buildup not just save SRS but all the other high schools as well thank you for your time thank you next is Brian Beaver followed by Fiona garwe followed by John coding is Brian Beaver here all right moving on Fiona garwe followed by John coding followed by Mario harez Osorio hello my name is Fiona gway and I am a junior at Santa Rosa High School this school has been part of my
096family for Generations from myself and my three older siblings to my great-grandfather who graduated 80 years ago I am at Santa Rosa High because of its so-called movable programs and how they work together to make a biger community I am currently an art Quest who allows self-expression and development for students who are becoming adults I have taken classes at the JC since freshman year because it's within walking distance and convenient after school allowing me to Advance at my own pace I am an Santa Rosa FFA a program that's almost 100 years old and teaches employability leadership and Entrepreneurship skills and I am one of the captains of the debate team whose current team is heading to State qualifiers these programs together is what makes Santa Rosa high school special and are not movable as you
097say you'll lose so many students if you break up this school and the programs that go with itk you your time is up next is John cotting followed by Mario harez Osorio followed by Heather grun Bal is John cotting here moving on Mario harez Osorio followed by Heather grun bam followed by Payton Joy hello my name is Mari Wares I'm a student I'm a senior Montgomery High School um I'm involved in in various clubs and in choir and band um closing these schools will have been significant impact um in the community um not just at Montgomery um we feel a lot of we have a strong um we've been involved in all this stuff um uh so uh we have um we've been we we've been through a lot of stuff in our school um
098throughout school years uh We've supported each other we built um we've made a Resources closing our school campuses among under schools can destroy the well-built families each other and programs that were established there over the years on every campus closing schools ac across districts will not only displace teachers and those who were who are employed on campuses um these are just the list that will also ruin um a lot of things that um have been established L there and I believe like you guys should do a well job that you guys um you guys should do a good job thank you your time is up next is Heather gral followed by Payton Joy followed by Lori n thank you Trustees for your hard work and creative work my name is Heather shagon grun bomb I
099am the proud parent of a 2024 Monty grad and a current sophomore as you stated Santa Rosa city schools operate the only public high schools in the city and it is up to you to honor our high schoolers and the fact that they are out of time I would like to speak to the equity of the IB Program which is not transferable unlike AP IB is not just for a select PE honor students students who take IB courses get college credit regardless of if they receive a diploma IB prepares students for the workforce military service and college IB is applicable at the elementary middle and high school level you say this is a new creative board a 7 through 12 format work this is the norm at countless schools the format builds desperately needed Community
100the entire process is hard but doing what is hard is often what is needed do the right thing be creative keep all high schools open thank you for your time thank you next is pton Joy followed by Lori n followed by Alan Javier hello I'm Payton Joy I'm freshman here at s a high I would like to start by saying we've been told many things one of those things is that we have a$2 million deficit where does that money go why don't we have it right now why are students being punished for your guys' mistakes another thing we've been told is that the board has to make a difficult decision why is it the board has to make a diffult difficult decision why are we not thought of right now we are going to be
101impacted by this our students are lives are going to change you cannot say it board has to make a difficult decision without saying the result of that decision will hurt many people why why did we wait until now to have these conversations when we could have started in August why thank you thank you next is Lori n followed by Alan Javier followed by Shanti Cabana and Lori could you state your full name for the record course Lori noria my name is Lori noria hi dear board um no one is saying to keep doing the same thing we've always done clearly things need to change we know this is a situation where you won't be able to make everyone happy but I do think you can make thoughtful and prudent decisions that the entire Community can
102get behind but we have to have confidence in you we have to have the confidence that you have eliminated conflicts of interest that jeopardize an equitable process used clear data that support meeting your stated fiscal goals so that we aren't having this conversation next year and that you are setting all of your decisions through the filter of will this help our children and Community heal and then Thrive just to be clear it's not Community engagement if you have pre-made Solutions and it's not transparent it's not a transparent process if you have an unstated agenda save Santa Rosa High School save all high schools thank you thank you next is Alan Javier followed by Shanti Cavanaugh followed by um yoselin Orosco hello I'm a fifth grader at Albert fbl Elementary I'm heartbroken that you want to
103close my school I'll tell you a few reasons why my school should stay open it is a safe place and the road in front is not busy the teacher really care about their jobs and especially their students there are so many after school programs to do I joined bacon club and got to bring some cheesecake home we have an ADA approved pray CL and I get to C on Minecraft education every Tuesday there's a multi-purpose room which is used for a lot of things like concerts movie night Nifty kid triester Awards and more we even have our own basketball team we also have a garden that looks beautiful we get to play instruments we have some of the best special needs programs and we have a library my school deserves to stay open just just
104because we don't have a lot of people attending doesn't mean my school should be closed if the school closes hundreds of students would never experience the same things like I did like B says be safe be respectful be responsible be thank you thank you next is Shanti Cabana followed by yoshina Rosco followed by Bri Mattel thank you for hearing our community my name name is Shanti kabana I'm a parent at Montgomery High School I'm here to support the children of our entire District I beg of you do not close schools I want to and need to address the international Balor program because there's been a huge oversight around IB the IB Program like the AP program enables high school students to get college credit this is amazing 45% of Juniors and seniors at Monty take
105at least one IB course but the IB program is about more than Personal Achievement it is about empowering students to create a better and more peaceful world it invites kids to deepen their International and Intercultural understanding IB Fosters the kind of critical thinking in students that goes beyond test taking and last as part of their core values the IB culture at Montgomery did not develop overnight and it is a precious community resource that we must protect next year Montgomery is moving to an IB for all to make what hundreds of students already access even more accessible to every Junior and eventually every Senior English student we're not talking about a portable program but rather a mission rooted in the DNA of our school Community the sustain you your time is up next is yosel Orosco
106followed by Bri Matel followed by Mary basa hello I am a student at LC Allen High School and I'm a freshman um as a freshman I already have a lot of opportunities like I'm in the Sonoma State program and I'm already eligible to get a scholarship to enter a university of any choice um closing Elsie and any other school for that matter would mean separating F students with their friends separating T students with teachers and counselors that they trust Elie Allen is also the only School in South Santa Rosa so people who liveed there would have to go and find transportation to other schools further away where would everybody go and how would they get there personally I go on the bus so everybody who would go on the bus would need to find find
107a different way to travel personally I think no school should close but that's just my opinion thank you next is Bri Mattel followed by Mary Basera followed by Samantha sharp my name is Bri Mattel and I'm a parent at Montgomery High School it is a school where academics and Athletics thrives and all models closing Montgomery will lead to a more segregated Community is that really the you want to be known for I see the board being faced with hard decisions and I feel strongly the administration is not listening they are not from our communities and they are not enrolling children in our schools they have had multiple recommendations on how to cut cost from the fiscal stabilization committee but instead worked on ridiculous models that they did not share with you for months they are
108not listening there more there are more and more districts Nationwide that are not choosing school closures and they have lots of model models on different ways that we can cut costs 12 million is not a magic number it is not it is a changing Target and it really means nothing if we were already over budget 13 million in the first quarter please continue to fight for the district do not let them corny you into decisions you know will be bad for our community stand up against their manufactured crisis and choose to serve the students insist on a long-term plan and a vision that focuses on our students and an educational Vision we stand with you thank you next is Mary basa followed by Samantha sharp followed by Bo Brown I'm Mary bada I'm the president
109of the Santa Rosa High School Foundation and an alumni from the class of 1974 the foundation was formed back in 1988 we have 19 board members and we manage 7.5 million in endowed funds last year we gave 55 scholarships totaling $138,000 plus another 100,000 towards students and staff field trips and new sound system for the football field just to name a few things Santa Rosa High School is a CTE pathway we have wood shop metal shop and autoshop those three shops by the way are are funded by CTE funds and also we have an endowment through the estate of Gary rashy that upgraded those shops to a tuna $400,000 spent Plus thank you your time is up next is Samantha sharp followed by Bo Brown followed by Amy Salazar thank you for your time um
110I would like to start by saying there's a very big difference when you're talking about moving programs between can move and whether it's realistic to move in the time frame that we have there are many things like Montgomery's IB program and more specifically as I'm wearing my orange all of our programs at San Rosa High School our art Quest program cannot be moved those buildings cannot be moved our auto shop cannot be moved our farm is used by our students every single year I would also just like to add that we found out today that Santa Rosa high school was voted the best public school by Bohemian best of North Count North Bay 2025 we just found that out today you should not close the school that was voted their best public high school that's
111all I have to say thank you thank you next is Bo Brown followed by Amy Salazar followed by Adrien quas is Bo Brown here is Amy Salazar here is Adrien quas here hello my name is Adrien quas I am a freshman here at Santa Rosa High School I stand before you today and urge you all to reconsider any plans to shut down any school here in Santa Rosa this High School is a vital part of my life and to so many others education is a very V vital part of sorry is a very part vital part of all of our lives and shutting down schools would only cause overcrowding making an already challenging situation even worse and also will cause more black brown and Indigenous kids to drop out due to lack of public transportation
112if low-income students have to transport across town thank you thank you next is Chanel Gillian followed by Daniela Vargas Medina followed by Alexa Guerrero Med Sol sorry your time is off he has someone that's going to translate for her okay hello good evening everyone my name is danela a student tired of Corporation in discriminatory Injustice that are experienced every day in different ways so so for this point I will be as honest as possible I have realized the unfort unfortunalty that the school board of directors are only only care about their econom economy since by their behavior they make it known that they do not care about all their Community or their students closely some of the primary middle schools middle and high schools will significantly affect our future doctors lawyers police officers accountants students
113who dream big and who have desired to create a better country a better country for their future students who will also contribute to the Future economy as Cooks homes cleaners field Pickers and many other jobs people who are called immigrants contribute greatly they support the economy by unfor but unfortunately there is a bigger problem of discrimination in the United States if it were not for the pickers thank you your time is up um was Chanel Gillian not here Chanel okay so next is Alexa Guerrero followed by Megan King followed by Joel Grogan I Jesus thank you your time is up hello my name is Alexa Guerrero growing up I face discrimin because of my speech and my movements yet at Santa Rosa Middle School I truly felt welcomed the teachers and staff saw beyond my
114disabilities embracing me for who I was their support made a lasting impact so much so that I continued to visit my favorite teacher and return every year to present to the leadership class about self- advocacy Santa Rosa Middle School isn't just a school it's a Cornerstone of our diverse Community a place that opens its doors to every child regardless of their background losing it would mean losing a space where students like I once was find acceptance support and the opportunity to thrive I urge you to keep Santa Rosa Middle School open thank you next is Megan King followed by Joel Grogan followed by Christina grael hi I'm Megan King and I have been a Slater teacher at Slater Middle School for 13 years my entire career tonight I stand for you to insist that you
115pause a plan that is hatched in crisis is no way to lead how did we get here a process that was supposed to be data driven has disintegrated into an emotional mess where the loudest voices are being heard and of course the 7 through 12 model has gained fast momentum are far more High School stakeholders in our community than middle school and meanwhile we feel like we're being tossed aside merging middle school students onto high school campuses is not just a bad idea it's a logistical and developmental disaster waiting to happen middle schoolers high schoolers operate on completely different schedules have vastly different academic and social needs and require environments tailored to their unique stages of growth how would this work conflicting Bell schedules are we going to have two Bell schedules stared facilities will
11611y olds really be expected to share locker rooms with 18 years olds with Portables middle schoolers deserve real classrooms and not makeshift learning spaces cremp into high school campuses middle schoolers are still developing your time is up next is Joel Grogan follow by Christina grael followed by Florentino Garcia good evening I want to ask all the elementary and middle school families and students to please stand up all of you this board has a legal and ethical duty to consider the needs of both Elementary and secondary students in its decisionmaking any plan to save all high schools at the expense of our TK to8 students is irresponsible and unfair the the town halls and public survey results were clear Elementary and Middle School families are not in favor of the 7 to2 students displaced from closed
117schools at all levels should go to their next closest higher performing school and lastly if closing three elementaries is necessary capacity can be found by reallocation of space moving Portables or delaying closure of one school for an additional Year please don't sacrifice our youngest students the future of our districts just say no to Super elementaries thank you next is Christina grael followed by Florentino Garcia followed by Jessica I'm from Ridgeway High School per Ed code we provide a unique program that meets the educational needs and intensive guidance services for at risk students we have an extended period CTE and unique Bell SC schedule we are on the quarter not semester system and taking new students as kids graduate our kids know when they sign the contract upon registration this is their last chance at getting
118a diploma they are eager to turn the page start a new and engage in their education most for the first time they are um students experience a beautiful safe campus wrap around services and staff who connect with and motivate them according to the youth tooth survey 75% of Ridgeway kids feel they have the support and attention they need to succeed compared with 23% on the big campuses we are thank you your time is up next is Florentino Garcia followed by Jessica Moran followed by Adrianne Glatt good evening my name is Florentino Garcia I've been a teacher for since 20 01 in the district and I was going to say something first but uh as I'm sitting here listening uh there was discussion about creating an alternative school but there's so much alternative in Santa Rosa
119already I don't think you need to pursue that I'm saying that because I do work at Ridgeway and some of the discussion has been to move us onto a campus and I think that's a big problem for our students because by choice they are coming to our school rejecting the larger campuses they need this and if you put us on a larger campus you are creating more uh failure and more Dropout and that's the whole purpose We Exist our separate our separate campus creates that safe environment if you look at our numbers if you look at our suspensions you can see that we have our kids in check and they want to be there I asked my kids today why did you choose to leave your school why did you choose to come to rway
120and they said we feel safer there because it's smaller and we have a large population of students who do not well do not do well in large schools they need something smaller thank you your time next is Jessica Moren followed by Adrienne Glatt followed by Ginger sasher hello everyone my name is yesica Moran I am a health and science teacher at Montgomery High School today instead of listing all of the reasons why you shouldn't close your school I'd like to share my story just to highlight how important and special all of our schools are I moved here from Mexico at the age of six I attended stelan Elementary where I learned to speak English comto middle and Piner High where I had the most amazing biology teacher shout out Miss barcelon Elie Allen is where
121I did my student teaching in Montgomery High School is where I continue to flourish and grow as a teacher I wanted to teach in the district that help shaped who I am today I know that some of you on the board probably share my story that's why you're here today our district continues to shape lives and I'm only one of many these students are our future closing our schools will hinder their future our community's future let's open doors for them let's Inspire them but let's not punish them for something they did not do please think outside the box find another solution thank you thank you next is Adrienne glat followed by Ginger sasher followed by somebody wrote everyone's mother if if you want to come forward it's turn and St your actual name go ahead
122hi guys my name's Adrien Glatt I'm a teacher at Santa Rosa high school and I've been here since 2008 um I don't want to repeat a bunch of stuff that other people have said about Santa Rosa High School except to remind you guys that it's um you know 43 Acres a very large campus and you know in the 2017 fires we were an anchor for the city we um we facilitated all kinds of stuff to help support the community and I feel like I'm seeing that right here with everybody coming together supporting all schools in this fiscal crisis and um and so I think the question that I really have to ask is in terms of downsizing or rightsizing I would really like to know what we're downsizing and rightsizing out of the district office
123because the it's been said that the district office keeps growing but we are shrinking so if there are 25% cuts from schools why not your time is up next is ginger sasher followed by everyone's mother followed by Nicole guest I am here on behalf of all the mothers who cannot be here from all the schools in city of Santa Rosa my name is Elizabeth Castillo I'm here representing those who feel defeated and unheard despite them going and giving everything they have to keep up with all these meetings and protests I am here as every everyone's mother to say shame on you we're making our students look at each other as competitors rather than fellow students trying to make it in this great big world if you know anything about maso's hierarchy kids need to have
124physiological needs to build their lives Foundation our kids spend 8 to 10 hours a day at school the second foundation in the maso's hierarchy is Safety and Security for some you do not your time is up thank you Ginger not here you're Ginger okay so Ginger sasher followed by Nicole guest followed by Wendy Aila hi my name is ginger susner I am a parent of three teenagers and uh I want to talk about responsibility responsibility means doing the right thing even when it is the hard thing to do demanding answers before making terrible decisions is the right thing to do keeping all high schools open might be hard but it is the right thing to do in case you are unfamiliar with this sign this is a photo of the actual sign currently hanging from
125the fence at Montgomery now under construction a new $27 million stem building there are to be 17 classrooms including science labs an art gallery and all gender restrooms creating a place of inspiration safety and inclusion and we are supposed to accept that the district will simply take this well documented source of inspiration away from our children you your time is up next is Nicole guest followed by Wendy Aila followed by Danielle Cain hello my name is Nicole guest and I'm a counselor at LC Allen first thank you board members for requesting the information that you need to make hard decisions regarding school closures while the scenarios continue to morph and change shape I stand before you to continue advocating for keeping all high schools open it is possible to Pilot the 712 model to bring
126feeder middle schools back to high schools especially Elsie Allen who lost their feeder school with the creation of ccla my main message is keeping all high schools can be open please continue to think outside of the original 311 model which does not seem to be meeting the targeted 12ish million dollar in Cuts look at different continuation High School models bringing possibly bringing this service back to their home high school campuses keep asking the questions that you're asking keep requesting the information you need from the District staff it is possible to keep all high schools open even though your time is up next is Wendy Aila followed by Danielle Kae followed by Sandra msas hello board members I am here once again like I was last week my name is Wendy Avala I am mother to
127two kids with special needs and once again we don't have any answers for where my special needs program is going what is gonna happen it's a scary Prospect because we just found beella please don't close beella why is that one campus one that you're willing to close when some of the other elementary schools look like prisons and our and our special education Community is relegated to the back instead of being part of our community beella is one of the only places my kids have felt special they feel like they're part of the community they are really included and that's something that every parent wants and I just I'm really begging you to find another to close if that's what you need to do or really just keep looking through and help our special education and
128our kids that have special needs help them to thrive in a place that actually loves them thank you your time is up next is Danielle Kane followed by Sandra msas followed by Daniel Hughes hi my name is Danielle Kane I'm in my 18 year of teaching art Quest theater arts and by the way my 25th year teaching in the theater department at somoma State University and we've all seen what happened there with closures um Arts is about bringing people together I'm very disappointed about how this process has pitted students and schools against each other it is absolutely not what should be happening and it is not about it is not about the Arts our Santa Rose High School students have already spoken eloquently about the amazing CTE programs at Santa Rosa High School including arts
129art Quest so I'm not going to talk about that I want to talk about the Arts the Arts teach team building looking at things from different perspectives developing empathy learning about other people and cultures we learn creative problem solving and how to make bold choices and how to commit to them how to lead by listening these are skills that our students will need for any career they decide to pursue the young artists in our district are the storytellers of our future and by the way they're going to tell the story of tonight thank you your time is up thank you next is Sandra msas followed by Daniel Hughes followed by Mara D Newman tonight I want to focus attention on our kids with special needs as a mom of two with special needs students at
130BL Elementary I am worried about the possible closure of our school this is not a subtle change for our kids as most know transitions are difficult for our kids kids with special needs putting them into a new school will take them months to adjust and this will not only affect them but everyone around them my daughters have seen tremendous growth since attending baella and I want that growth to continue please reconsider and keep Yell Elementary open and I want to ask you what are you going to do to protect the rights of our kids with disabilities and special needs thank you thank thank you next is Daniel Hughes followed by Mara Newman followed by Donna Doyle there's a famous quote once said by Maya Angelou I've learned that people will forget what you've said people
131will forget what You' did but they will never forget how you made them feel please don't make the students feel that you didn't pay enough attention to them to make them Su succeed as you can tell everybody gets nervous up here speaking I have a dad of three that are at baella and I just hope for their growth I grew up in this community Sonoma County has been amazing but there's no need for them not to have a chance that we've had you know give everybody an opportunity to rise and that's all we can ask for thank you thank you next is Mara Newman followed by Donna joyle followed by an donagan hi my name is meridine Nunan um I'll make it short because I I'm fourth generation ation my first no in graduating was
1321880 my grandfather is 1923 my dad 1949 my mom 1950 and me I was 1976 I was yeah and I was very lucky to be one of the first girls when Title 9 came out to go on the Santa Rosa High School swim team boys team that's why you can't close Sant Ro it's so much history and so much that our family and everybody else brings to this community we really want SOS I to stay open thank you thank you next is Donna Doyle followed by Anne donigan followed by Jeff skull hello my name is Donna Doyle I'm a founding board member of the santosa high school Foundation Money Matters and that's why think it's important for the board to understand that Santa Rosa High School in many ways is saving the district money the
133money that this Foundation Garners for students at Santa rosah high is used for a variety of purposes which relieves the District of many financial responsibilities currently the Santa Rosa High School Foundation has $7.5 million dollar and grows substantially each year the foundation is robust and our alumni support is strong our our financial support includes field trips student supplies teacher supplies classroom equipment and beautifying the school buildings and grounds the foundation has a scholarship program that supports students and their goals whether to a college or a trade school last year 55 Santa Rosa seniors received thank you your time is up next is an donigan followed by Jeff skull Follow by Emma Thompson thank you so much um I want to say that I appreciate your transparency tonight but I also think it's problematic that you
134all admitted that you don't have a strategic plan to to to go forward with these school closures it is completely irresponsible to close any school until you have a real plan please put together a group of experts right sociologists psychologists people who are experts in Special Needs what's the impact on the economic Vitality of our community until you do that please do not close any school hit the pause button and do the right thing please please everything should be on the table including the number of Administrators and their salaries someone just commented on somoma state that was your time is up thank you next is Jeff skull followed by Emma Thompson followed by Joshua Morgan you are surrounded by schools to the north and south of you that have visions roner Park and Windsor combined
135to have over 500 interdistrict transfers you have no vision you are scrambling to to save your political Futures if if your vision will include the portraits of a graduate your actions will destroy that Vision the three of you last Friday that changed your votes on the 311 to close Santa Rosa high school should stand up right now and be accountable Mark I'm looking at you Sarah I don't know who the other one is voting to close a high school removes the vote of at least one board member and makes that vote inequitable I'm also here to express my concern thank you your time is up next is Emma Thompson followed by Joshua Morgan followed by by Liliana Santiago hello I would like to ask the district office to please provide support to the board and
136give them accurate and correct data that they have asked for and that they will ask for when making this decision we need to remember that we are here to educate students to help the Next Generation grow to be productive citizens and schools are where that happens to the board please do not let the do Bully you into making a haste decision we have time and resources so that you may weigh all of your options may we remember that we are here for students and not for budgets thank you thank you next is Joshua Morgan followed by Liliana Santiago followed by Scott green thank you for the time look around you this is community we should be proud of ourselves the board had to move its meeting to a larger venue change sucks change is inevitable
137and elections have consequences the outrage and fear experienced by all is unifying let's keep the pressure on the board by continuing to show up they are unable to come up with an acceptable solution we vote them out a strong and engaged Community can manage this bureaucracy which means we manage our tax dollars once a solution is achieved we need to keep showing up let's remain engaged United and powerful thank you next is Liliana Santiago followed by Scott green followed by Christine Williams good evening I'm mother of two beautiful kids one in Santa Rosa High School our Quest student and uh one at Albert baa so I'm here since we have a lot of representation for high school I'm going to advocate for baa tonight tonight closing arabellaa would be cruel and a shortsighted decision I
138urge you to consider to keep this vital school open their harm caused by closing Arbella would be particular harmful to special need children my son is one of them who often thrive on routine and familiarity via serves a significant number of special need children and closing it would be a Dev stating blow to this family and those students please find alternative placement oh no I'm so sorry finding alternative placement for this students will be challenging and many would like end up in schools that are know well thank you your time is up thank next is Scott green followed by Christine Williams followed by Jennifer grave um can I go um hello my name is Scott green and I am a junior at Santa Rosa high and I would like to say that I don't want
139any school high school to close I have spent my entire life rebuilding what I what has been broken in fourth grade my high school was burnt and I lost everything I was homeless for three years and I was able to re I wasn't able to rebuild my entire life because of the pandemic my middle school career was ruined and my life and many others in this room probably also has been ruined time and time again and I was unable to rebuild it my dad passed away last month and yet instead of spending time with my grieving family I am standing here scared that everything I've rebuilt will be torn away from me yet again I beg you please keep all the high schools open I I have built a community here at Santa Rosa high
140school and I'm not ready to lose it please keep Santa Rosa open thank you next is Christine Williams followed by Jennifer grave followed by Irene Gil hi my name is Christine Williams and I'm here speaking on behalf of families and students from all these schools to say that we are disgusted and exhausted at the way you continue to PE schools against schools and students against students tonight I read your message on parents Square stating that you wish to collaborate and ask to demonstrate Unity but like when the superintendent denied it with censorship when you shut down the art Quest fall show your actions speak louder than words all the talk has been about how much money you'll say but I've heard nothing about how you plan to support these kids' mental health and the families
141during this painful transition while they are feeling lost and abandoned so far it's all about the money for this board and you have demonstrated that you care nothing for the welfare of these kids the citizens of this District should be reading in the Press hypocat more about how you plan on serving these students than about how many millions of dollars you will sh you'll say you should be ashamed of yourself and if you think it's funny you need to stop smiling thank you next is Jennifer grave followed by Al Irene gilc followed by Holly retzinger it's Jennifer grow a resident of District 5 my dad was a carpenter and there's an adage in that trade measure twice cut once the district The Architects if you will have asked for a three bed one bath onecar
142garage house but have provided no clear blueprint of what it will look like that is your job is laid out in AB assembly Bill 1912 a district quoting shall do all of the following all of the following before approving the closure of a school and share at minimum the following plan for use of the schools once vacated criteria used to assign to place pupils options and timeline for transitioning including home to school transportation needs none of this information has been shared to facilitate Community Buy in which makes this process more difficult than it already is for this board to do the work without a Clear Vision the district tasked the closure committee to cut Lumber using measuring tape with incomplete and missing data the assumption that Montgomery's IB Program could be simply moved not having
143a clear picture of what families might do should their schools close data a simple survey could provide but the committee did its best and have left pil thank you your time is up next is Irene Gil followed by Holly retzinger followed by Leah Murphy hi I'm an Elementary music teacher I teach at five schools I serve over 300 students um and I see firsthand the impact of large class sizes on these students in each school um students with in larger classes feel more overstimulated and they are more chaotic and the students with the most need tend to be more easily lost in the shuffle so I want us to keep in mind when we consolidate elementary schools we are inevitably creating the conditions where less learning will happen and so how are going to mitigate
144this catastrophe how will the district prioritize reading Specialists prop 28 funding and other programs to increase the amount of small group Time by significant amounts each day we got to strategize now thank you thank you next is Holly ringer followed by Leah Murphy followed by Erica leanovich hi my name is Holly red singer I'm a pioner teacher um and proud mom of a Slater um 7 grader you cannot understand what a special and supportive Community Slater is until you become a part of it however I'm here to advocate for all our middle schools the seventh the 7eventh through 12th grade model is a deeply flawed plan a high school campus is not the place to Foster the specific social emotional academic and developmental needs that our 11 through 14y old children need our middle school
145children need to be sheltered supported and nurtured in a way that can't happen if they are surrounded by older teens and young adults and especially if they are forced into crowded facilities that are haphazardly created in less than four months I'm deeply concerned about what would happen to our athletic electives and extracurricular programs at the middle school level if we per pursue this model I see I'm about to be cut off so please if you must close two secondary schools use your original criteria and select a middle and high school do not move middle schools onto high school campuses do not close the next is Leah Murphy followed by Erica leonovich followed by manona heand hi my name is Leah Murphy I'm a parent of a child in first and fourth grade at Caesar shabz
146Language Academy and my husband teaches at Santa Rosa High um my first comment is about the budget $20 million deficit that's a lot to cut what hasn't been clear for quite some time is how the district office and the admin will cut can we please have a detailed transparent report shared on District spending budgets restricted and unrestricted funding including details of the line item costs of the proposed new district office building and a serious proposal of what will be cut from the district office to close the deficit this will add greatly to transparency um and then second just a comment about this 7 to2 model as a parent I have many concerns um I am a parent of kids at ccla that have merged with it hasn't been easy it's worked well but it's been
147challenging and so I would just seriously consider what that's going to look like uh facilities all those things before you thank you your time is up next is Erica leanovich followed by manona heand followed by Mitch xie hello Erica leonovich I'm here to push back on the narrative that the state takeover is eminent because according to assembly Bill 1200 when districts are in financial Peril local County offices of Education not the state are brought in to review District budgets so as long as we're working with sonomi County Office of Education and our finances improve which they will we will avoid a state takeover before it gets there though board you need to demand that the district follow rink and Valley's lead and put forth teeb cuts for you to vote on so we need money
148I suggest closing the proposed three elementary schools and close or phase a middle school then take a step back and if needed work with wh go come up with a two-year plan to phase in your vision for our district I'm putting a plug 7 through 12 we have time the state is not pounding on our doors yet you're on the right track please do not let the district force you into this hurried timeline and derail your vision for our school district thank you thank you next is minona heand followed by Mitch uty followed by Tanya Hoffman hello I want to reiterate what Erica just said uh I'm dismayed that the district Business Services has not presented any scenarios that balance revenues and expenses to continue continue Educational Services to all students the board is being
149asked to make a decision to close 20% of schools without understanding where those students will go or how specialized programs will be continued The District staff are using the threat of a state takeover to rush through a school closure process without a reasonable plan for how to continue Educational Services and programs if there is not a balanced budget the Sonoma County Office of Education will come and audit the accounting and make suggestions for cuts this may be uncomfortable for the administrators whose work will be scrutinized but it isn't the end of the world nor does it definitely lead to closures or discontinuation of programs I would encourage you as the board and trustees of all of these students and community members to not close any schools if thank you your time is up next is
150Mitch uty followed by Tanya Hoffman followed by Tina Javier howdy I'm Mitch Udi I'm the autoshop teacher here I graduated from Richfield High School in wo Texas in 1983 I was the last graduating class we had a wood shop we had a machine shop we had a welding program we had Electronics we had a planetarium none of those things are portable I teach at Santa R Roa high school we have a wood shop we have a fabrication shop including CNC equipment welding fabrication we've got a computerated drafting program we've got a construction program we've got art quests none of these things are portable now as to being the last graduating class at Richfield High School it is a lonely feeling whenever you're left out in the cold and there is nobody coming after you and
151my back still hurts for that knife sticking in we don't need to do that to our kids been there done that let's not repeat it thank you kindly thank you next is Tanya Hoffman followed by Tina Javier followed by Julie Bernard good evening Tanya Hoffman Proctor terce parent I just want to let you know I I never come to these meetings before until the school closure thing so I did a lot of the school closure advisory committee meetings and I thought they did a g really great job and provided a beautiful report in a nice package with some good suggestions so much thought they even really wanted to work so hard in creating alternative options without the 311 and witnessing being told by the consultants and Lisa August that really their position was to only
152pick 311 and to to actually witness the frustration of you guys receiving the report and then being told that the closure of three elementary schools is not actually possible after they've been doing all of this since August to me is represents a little bit of some ineptitude of whatever is going on with the district and being able to communicate with you guys what is going on and the challenges so just that level of needs to be looked next is Tina Javier followed by Julie Bernard followed by Joe Reynolds hello I hope my email found you all well um today I'm here for Albert fella um Albert fella must stay open it is in a safe location and offers diverse programs as Allan has shared earlier an 88 approved playground and a strong special education department
153providing a place where students Thrive and are prepared for the future beella is more than just a cute school it has the tools to help each student succeed offering opportunities at nearby schools can't if these programs are lost we may need to seek a district that can value US rebuild trust by making Cuts evenly across the district not just at the school level thank you thank you next is Julie Bernard followed by Joe Reynolds followed by John Beck doall hi my name is Julie Bernard and I have two children at Bela Elementary School it is a great campus you should consider closing a different one say Monroe or Helen Layman or any other one we have a really nice program we have great teachers I brought my kids there at TK these are my second
154set of kids that I adopted the first that graduated they're 30 years old and I want my children to go to the school in my neighborhood where it's safer Monroe is unsafe to the drop off is crazy there Helen Layman just doesn't add up we have a new uh we have our basketball team we just bought you know uniforms for and I'd like to see them continue their their music programs we just got our ADA Compliant um uh playground in and it just just now I've been waiting six years for that but now I have to leave that school my kids have to go we are breaking up communities and and and our Quest as far as Santa Rosa High you should keep Santa Rosa High the diversity with Santa rosah high is amazing my
155niece graduated from there and my two stepsons and I don't agree with the seven through 12 thank you next is Joe Reynolds followed by John Beall followed by Christopher Young hi I'm Joe Reynolds I am a CTE teacher here at Santa Rosa High School I teach Uh Wood Shop 3D CAD and Manufacturing we're the last manufacturing class in the whole County it is obviously not movable we have CNC machines we we have plasma cutters we have a uh an amazing amount of rad materials and uh that just can't be moved you were saying that you you don't think that our students are being trained for the jobs of the future well that's exactly what I'm doing the future of this country is in manufacturing I'm teaching kids how to make a 3D model and then
156build it out of real materials I'm teaching them Cutting Edge um Cutting Edge processes that will get them real jobs in the community so they will not be dredges to the to the society they will build this community up and become uh pillars of this community not the other way around so please don't close Santa Rosa high school thank you next is John Beall followed by Christopher Young followed by Nathan good hi I'm John Beckle I'm on the board of the mccy high school alumni Foundation and you have heard from across the district that closing high schools is a terrible idea don't you want to know why the worst solution is on the table in the first place why are we debating the versions of the worst solution why are we not debating tonight the
157best Solutions with the high schools open to save enough money to preserve the character of the elementary school experience why are we not debating the best Solutions with the high schools open to make our schools the best there are when will we talk about vision and creativity talk about Innovation and methodology let's begin that better ation thank you next is Christopher Young followed by Nathan good followed by lucrecia Rich duli hello my name is Christopher Young And my son Sawyer goes baella he has Down syndrome that being said Jeremy you brought up a statement saying that you were just going to close a school anyways so that being said with all of that what's the planning on for any of the kids that have down like down or any special needs I've heard nothing I've
158heard closure of other special needs schools or programs that are in this in this but I've heard nothing about anything else other than that where's all the money you have a school being built that is just going to be sitting there you have a faculty area that's just going to go for $61 million but yet we're told that there's a deficit of $30 million where is it you have the ability to shut down these projects even though it's said that you don't you have the ability to but you know what I'm gonna go with what Sarah said you went ahead and you said it's not your job thank you your time is up next is Nathan good followed by lucrecia Richard dly followed by Daniela via seor good evening do the least harm to to
159the least amount of people you claim implementing the super Elementary School by sending 800 k or six kids there ripping the small school from them would psychologically harm them our kids would face Trauma from the obliteration of their small neighborhood school where they receive individual attention depression and overcrowded rooms wait at this super Elementary the kicker is that you displace 400 happy Santa Rosa middle schoolers so you could say see we made a super Elementary closing three elementaries Each of which cost less than half of what one high school cost to operate saves the district virtually no money Santa Rosa city schools would pay to operate a super school where Santa Rosa Middle stands defeating the only reason for closing Santa Rosa Middle I am a parent of Proctor terce Tigers the sixth grader who
160would attend Santa rosea middle and a fourth grader who attends Proctor terrorist transferring my youngest out of the district if the super Elementary happens time is up next is Luccia Richard duli followed by Daniela via seor followed by Kimberly lley C Rees hello I'm L Richard dully mom of one in Montgomery and another one who graduated and I think I can summarize the point that everybody's trying to make is you are rushing through a very important decision and it is irreversible you cannot rush it and uh especially there is no thread of a state over uh State takeover very imminent uh so I I really beg you not to do this not to close any school but uh the high school are even more important because they have a Finish Line and you're taking away
161the Finish Line without a clear direction thank you thank you next is Daniel vior followed by Kimberly Lonley C Rees followed by Paloma Ramirez hello I am danela vior and I am a senior from Montgomery High School I am in choir and theater and I hope I could speak for a lot of my performing our community members that we are giving so many opportunities that we are not guaranteed to have in our lifetime and even though I am soon to graduate I acknowledge the fear and uncertainty that my friends and my other classmates are feeling right now we want to achieve our dreams in the place we started dreaming and this applies to every program Sports programs you know choir programs dance programs and regardless of what the decision is I hope you acknowledge that
162you're going to force kids to Envision their dreams differently thank you thank you next is Kimberly lle C Rees followed by Paloma Ramirez followed by Kai plat Kai good evening my name is Kimber and I'm an eighth grade student in I slat Middle School first is Slater Middle is a school designed for students in a critical stage of their education the transition between Elementary and high school the environment as Slater is designed to support our needs as middle schoolers activities are tailored to us positively impacting our learning and growth moving us to a high school campus will not provide us an age appropriate environment High School is meant for older students and we will be out of place in that setting we will also lose all the opportunities for the kinds of programs and extracurricular
163activities that are designed for middle school students as later we have clubs sport sport team and special special events that focus on the interest and needs of students our age if our campus is moved to a high school campus many of this program will be lost or mixed or Worse mixed with high schoolers people who are potentially six years older than some of the seventh graders it's also crucial to consider the safety aspect middle school students like us are at the different stage of emotional than you your time is up next is paluma Ramirez followed by Kai plat Kai followed by Katherine rout hello my name is Paloma Ramirez Slater Middle School is a magnificent place with wonderful staff teachers and students the Slater teachers and staff work so hard to make it a place
164where students can feel welcomed to me Slater is a second home it is a place where I can cry laugh or do both and still get the support I need the teachers work incredibly hard to make sure we are educated not just during school but outside of it too whether it is knowing our rights or how to play basketball they also ensure that we have delicious food a clean and safe campus and a place to go if we need support or help not only does Slater have great faculty and staff but it has an amazing and diverse range of classes for all levels of learning from your everyday classes such as English and math to awesome electives such as industrial Tech ethnic studies drama and so much more there are so many other things that
165I would like to say but what I really hope is that the board takes all of these factors into consideration and put the students at all schools first thank you thank you next is p plat P followed by Katherine rout followed by Leslie Gonzalez hi my name is Kai Platt and I'm part of the manufacturing class and baseball team here at Santa Rosa High School the first thing that I wanted to inform you all about was our manufacturing class here at Santa Rosa high school I know that um some of you think manufacturing is a waste and takes up too much money but I'm here to tell you that it would be an absolute travesty to lose this program and the school in one semester I have learned how to Arc weld Oxys settling Weld
166and proper shop safety and loads more one of the greatest benefits of the manufacturing class is that it is open to all um individuals and opens up so many more opportunities outside of schools such as internships stainless steel welders and rig welders to name a few I didn't even know what those were five months ago and now I'm considering it as a career how many classes can you really motivate uh can really motivate and see a kid like that thank you for your time good evening thank you next is Catherine R out followed by Lesley Gonzalez followed by Logan Caper hi my name is Katherine rout I'm a parent of two kids at Hidden Valley Elementary and two more that will be in the district this process has actually brought some bright spots like having
167us consider special programs to draw on students and the 7 to2 model which is actually evidencebased better for kids if implemented the right way um but I am asking the board let's slow our rooll just a little bit and the reason I asked that is I think the August deadline has led to some fear mongering regarding State takeover and using erroneous data to make decisions if you review um assembly Bill 12200 which is what guides District budgets and the fiscal crisis and management assistant team oversight guide the uh next many steps after a qualified budget include a vote um chosen by the board and then County funded budget Review Committee which is experts to help um with these decisions and help you balance your Budget Loans from the state that are up to 200 um
168I think it's 200 times your current thank you your time is up next is Leslie Gonzalez followed by Logan Caper followed by Lena uh Mal is Leslie Gonzalez here Logan Caper good evening I'm Logan Caper a science teacher at Slater Middle merging our middle schools with our high schools is not the Magic Bullet that some of our louder voices claim it will be it is painful to Fathom the thought of losing one of our high schools but please do not close our middle schools the turnaround to merge our middle schools would leave our middle schoolers lacking the facilities they need for the education they are legally owed will our seventh and eighth graders have their own science labs have their own music room eating space locker rooms will portable rooms installed in a slap Dash
169fashion over a single summer help us keep our Middle School families and how long will it be until we actually have the budget to give our middle schoolers the education they deserve by building them their own homes on our high school campuses I look around my own school and I see my kids I see kids I ask my students if they want to graduate from elementary school directly to middle school and even my big tough eth graders tell me they would have been terrified thank you uh my name is Lena Molen and I am a sophomore in art Quest theater at Santa Rosa High I implore you not to consider closing any schools but because you have forced us against each other I will just have to speak on Santa Rosa you have already heard
170many students talk about art Quest so forgive me if it sounds gratuitous but it seems that despite our passion being spoonfed to you you simply do not swallow it and that needs to stop now you have to understand that art Quest is not movable our separate art Quest campus is vast and is complete with a blackbox theater a dark room a studio for film students to name a few art Quest is supremely important to us and brings in the most in District transfers and it does for a reason there is no other program like it art Quest allows students not only to have a creative outlet but also to learn serious professional skills for the art subject that they are pursuing you have got to get money off of your minds and instead consider the
171emotional weight that this situation carries I know I speak for many of us when I say that if art Quest didn't exist I would likely be depressed if soraa High School dies art Quest dies and we will not let that happen thank you thank you next is Brent Stewart followed by Madonna feather followed by shayana Kirk and I do want to let everyone know we have less than 15 minutes left so we might not get through everyone it's possible that we will um is Brent Stewart here yeah hi my name is Brent Stewart um I just want to say um I don't really have anything prepared uh if you're shedding 20% of the schools we're already way more than 20% of the district that needs to be shut down financially we're taking we're they're already
172bloated that money needs to be cut from there um in terms of uh which high school to shut down I'm Montgomery parent um don't shut down Montgomery don't shut down Santa Rosa frankly thank you thank you next is Madonna feather is Madonna here okay then next is Shaya Kirk followed by Rebecca samit followed by Jessica Mullen hi there I'm hoping to call attention to something that's not sitting quite right with me so if the board does not have it it's ethically appropriate to have black and white proof that school closures are the one and only thing to save the district from State takeover now I have tremendous respect for Lisa and the District staff that were are working diligently on this matter but please show documentation from the fiscal crisis management team proving that we're
173truly in pre- receiver ship the distress or crisis and to necessitate this decision under such a tight deadline if this is a proactive measure the time for proactive action would have been one to two years ago if we have time anytime it makes sense to plan more strategically and not put on already stressed community and new board members through such an important decision-making process at light speed now and potentially fumble so terribly with such so much at stake they say time is a gift whatever happens myself and many others will be there to support the process perhaps begrudgingly so thank you your time is up next is Rebecca samit followed by Jessica Mullen followed by Daryl otellini hello we need you to be on our side we need you to Advocate to help fill the
174Gap to make sure that all of our students and all of our schools stay open give us the chance to figure out a way to keep our schools open there has got to be between fundraising philanthropic Adventures whatever we can figure this out but closing our schools so close just so rapidly is very distressing and I don't know exactly how it got here and I don't know it I don't know who does I haven't seen the budget yet yet I don't know if it's been released but I will be looking into it and to help figure it out but as someone mentioned we don't have time or we can't really figure out how it got this way except to prevent it from happening again but give our kids a chance thank you next is Jessica
175Mullen followed by Daryl ellini followed by Patricia herado I'm a proctor terce parent obviously I also want to highlight all the little Proctor terce tigers that are now home in bed I'm going to cut to the Chase and I'm going to tell you that the super Elementary idea is a no for me sending my seven-year-old to a school with 800 kids is a no for me if the district keeps treating elementary students like they don't matter what does everyone think they're going to do when it times it comes time to Circle back around for high school if you make us feel like we don't matter why would we come back if we leave to escape a super Elementary every parent in this room has power every parent doesn't realize how much power they have every
176parent in this room has a choice we can leave if we don't like the scenario if you don't listen to us now you will hear us when we all leave and the savings you thought you'd get gutting our schools will evaporate listen to us now before it's too late we don't want super elementary schools please don't send my seven-year-old to an 800 person school when I have a model School block next is Daryl ellini followed by Patricia herado followed by Meg Peterson I just like to say uh that this is a sad watching these teachers parents kids beg you not to close their school it's like P is asking their caps not to appuse them and and your comment ma'am about oh I want to see them they do the wave that's about is incentive
177of Joseph manga asking their patient so I just want to I just want to ask if uh you do close a school and you guys give your uh Administration more raises mind you the ones who haven't been paying attention on their phone for 90% of this conversation why don't you cut there I see that a lot of the comments here is them asking over budget and overpaid ma'am you came from a a a school that voted you out for incompetence and yet you're here now uh in the same situation you were a year ago asking us to stand by you as you're calling to close our schools so why don't you just uh cut some of their salaries because I'm looking at about over a million dollars worth of salary that we're all getting buyers
178and Morse from thank you thank you next is Patricia herado followed by Meg Peterson followed by Bernice Espinosa good evening and thank you for listening my name is Patty herado I'm a teacher at LC Allen High School and I have a dream a dream inspired by this community just by looking around look at all the different schools here with the same request do not close schools I dream that the district finds a different way to handle the financial crisis it faces I dream that instead of closing schools which still carries Financial costs not to mention the social cost the district is able to find the needed funds by generating income I dream that instead of closing schools the district promotes the amazing programs our schools offer we've heard it all night long I dream that
179instead of closing schools the district implements better boundaries and policies to retain our students and capture new ones I dream that the board decides what is best for our students thank you thank you next is Meg Peterson followed by Bernice Espinosa followed by David Benjamin gral thank you I believe you when you say that you want to be transparent none of you especially our new trustees and even our new superintendent got us into this situation but all of you are tasked with getting us out of it I do question however the transparency that the district has provided to you and to the public data keeps changing Financial targets keep moving and there seems to be no accountability on the district's end for why we are here and why this conversation didn't get started years ago
180I question if the district has considered enough cuts at the district level instead of claiming student school closures are the best solution and that we should have to make up the bulk of the deficit rinken Valley which is a third of our district size just came up with $4 million in budget cuts without consolidating a school why can't we do the same surely there's more than $8 million at our district level that we can cut maybe start at the top thank you your time is up next is Bernice ESP noza followed by David Benjamin gral followed by Tanya cordiva good evening I am not a parent and I did not go to schools here I am an attorney I was a public defender and now I'm an immigration defense attorney and I'm a co-founder of
181the pipeline pods an intergenerational legal mentorship program I came here with my mentee from LC Ellen we were working on writing up biography for our program and I asked her do you want to include the name of your school she said why I don't know if it's going to still be open this year she's going to be the first one in her family to graduate from high school she is also a first generation student when I came to this area nine years ago it was Elsie Allen that opened up its arms when we had the fires it's Elsie Allen that had the opportunities for me to go over and teach know your rights when there was discussions about the Rosland um Library when there's discussions about the thank you your time is up next thank
182you next is David Benjamin gram followed by Tanya cordiva hi I'm a parent of a Montgomery sophomore tonight we've heard a few people putting down the 7 through 12 model oh it'll be so hard uh last meeting uh the word that District kept using was oh it'll be so hard you know what's hard destroying the lives of over 1,000 students by closing their high stream so of course it'll take some work to move to a 7even to 12 model but it can be done it's the right thing to do no High School in Santa Ros should close as far as the idea that we will lose students specifically because of the 712 program let's talk about the elephant in the room what do you think is going to happen if you do close a high
183performing high school and reassign them to a lower performing high school they're not going to go okay so that's the real reason the district is going to lose tons of students we at Montgomery welcome expanding our IB program we were telling you this we're happy to do it many other IB programs are 7 to 12 and we're happy to do this so please do the right thing go with the 7 to 12 proposal and save all our high schools thank you thank you next is Tanya cordiva is Tanya here are there any other blue cards all right that ends public comment on non-agenda items the board will now take a 10 10 minute breaks thank you all am I we're going to continue with the meeting if you could please take your seats if you're
184planning to stay um we're moving on to our F items discussion and action items starting with an action item approval of California School Employees Association chapter 75 24-25 and we have Dr Vicky xans here ah thank you president mcnali uh superintendent Morales and members of the board um I am happy to be here tonight to present to you um three four umus that we have agreed to with our CSA Partners um the first one is an amendment to our student safety advisor job duties and job description adding back in the sentence breaking up disturbances the second is for the position control and Reporting technician and job description the third is for um payment to our classified members who are sometimes called to do classroom supervision which is beyond um their job duties and we want
185to compensate them for that and the last one is for our family engagement facilitators and compensating them for having the language skills in Spanish to be able to do some translation at some of our IEP meetings so I am here tonight to ask for your approval of both the job descriptions andus that are attached board members any questions are there I don't have any blue cards are there okay no public comment um board discussion or a motion can we approve all of Theus at once in one motion yes you probably have to approve them separately motion to approve amendment to CS CSA 752 2425 number two student safety adviser job duties and updated job description second any further discussion roll call vote who was the second sorry Kirby director Kirby thank you trusty deor hi
186trusty Kirby hi trusty Caston I trusty Jenkins I president MCN I motion passing do we have a motion on um number three position control and Reporting technician job description motion to approve second any discussion roll call vote trusty de laor hi trusty Caston hi trusty Kirby I truste Jenkins I president MCN I motion passes do we have a motion on number four emergency classroom supervision so moved second discussion roll call vote trusty Caston hi trusty de laor hi trusty Kirby hi trusty Jenkins hi president mcnell I motion passes do we have a motion on number five family engagement facilitators so move do we have a second second moved by Caston seconded by Kirby roll call vote trusty Caston I trusty Kirby I trusty Jenkins I trusty de laor I president MCN I motion passes all
187right moving on to that was everything right yeah okay moving on to um approval of a tentative agreement between Santa Rosa city schools and California School Employees Association chapter 75 for successor contract 2024 to 2027 okay thank you um as happy as I was to present those M us I I am even more happy to um ask for your approval of the tenative agreement with um csca chapter 75 for the successor contract for 2024 to 2027 which also includes an agreement on um compensation for both 24 25 our current school year as well as 2526 um attached you'll also find our ab1 1200 disclosure with um all of the financials any board questions are there any blue cards there are no blue cards uh board discussion or a motion I move that we approve the
188Ten of agreement between senat Ro City schools and the California CSA chapter 75 for successor contract 20124 2027 but I'd like to make sure we have discussion second okay uh moved by trusty Kirby seconded by trusty Caston roll call vote can we have a discussion before we go to the vote oh I I could sorry I can't hear you very well sorry no worries um I'm still reading Clos captions to get everything with the reverberation in here uh I just really quickly wanted to say that I really appreciate the partnership with csca the fact that we were able to come to a resolution this quickly and within the budget that I know isn't what our employees were hoping for or deserve many ways but is what we could do and I just want to commend
189the the team that led the negotiations for both csca and the district and um you know I was not actually anticipating seeing this happen in February so thank you all any other discussion did you did you actually second it or did I just mishear that okay roll call vote trusty Kirby hi trusty Casten hi trusty Jenkins hi trusty de laor hi president mcnell I motion passes all right moving on to a discussion on the 2025 26 Governor's budget proposal we have Lisa August and Joel dantos thank you Dr xans good evening president mcnali superintendent Dr Morales members of the board and our SRS srcs Community online and those still remaining here with us um I'm Lisa August and I'm here with Joel dantos to uh present at the information that we've received on the governor's
190budget proposals and provide a little bit of information on how they impact us okay um just a quick review I'm gonna go only spend some time on some particular slides please um we can go back at the end if there's information that you if there's a slide that you would like additional information on from us um I always share um this or we share this um kind of visual every time that we provide a budget update just to remind everyone of the ongoing cycle and that yes the the information is always changing we only have one time a year when there are are final numbers that's in September for the prior year another thing that I did want to talk about while we look at this is the the ab200 process assembly Bill 1200 which
191is that we do work with sco so every every time we have a budget update every time we have a tenative agreement any of those things they are sent to sco for review we work very closely with um our our fiscal analysts there the um external director as well as the CBO so my counterpart um so just making sure that people realize that that that is an ongoing collaborative relationship um so they do guide us along the way as well and much of the information here came from both School Services which I know Joel attended as did some of the sco um staff and then I attended a presentation at sco with Capital Advisors so did you want to talk about this part at all just real quick okay yeah so um we're presenting tonight
192the governor's January uh budget proposal for next fiscal year 2025 26 um as a a state agency and and part of the overall state budget um we have to PR start preparing our budget for next year knowing some parameters assumptions that the uh state budget will have and that state follows the process for our agencies by um starting off with giving a budget proposal and then that budget proposal is reviewed um by the uh uh State Legislature and others that are in the state and they have uh um negotiations back and forth between the governor and then in May uh the governor comes out with his May revision to this proposal and then we also start building our budget for next year around those uh May updated assumptions and then just like we adopt our
193budget in June the state adopts their budget in June as well so when we adopt our budget you'll see it largely based on those May assumptions and then uh we both adopt our budget in June and then we locally here will update our budget uh 45 days after that budget and bring that to the board and that is kind of the process of how this state budget Works along with our local budgets so really um something to be aware of with this um budget proposal from the governor is that it was announced right around the time of the fires so so we know that there are likely to be changes between now and the May revise um what is not um what is really uncertain is there was a one-time um proposal in here um
194for some discretionary funds that may or may not happen there's also that the governor is in his projections essentially shorting prop 98 which is the minimum amount that we are guaranteed um by about 1.6 million billion dollars um but that 1.6 could end up getting swept up into Fire Relief or something like that so there's some back and forth that's happening about that right now um so it'll be interesting we'll see what happens with that one of the concerns is that prop 98 right now it's supposed to be our floor and really what that's equating to is um it's our ceiling it's our floor and our ceiling there's not a lot of wiggle room that happens um that is how we've seen like the one-time funds over a number of years it's kind of the
195way that they get it in there to make sure that we're meeting that prop 98 guarantee but not growing that minimum for going forward in our Cola our cost of living increase um and you'll see later the the effect that has on the com on compounding for us over the years so overall though it's a pretty healthy budget um education is um pretty well protected did um just like last year however we do see a um lesser percentage uh proposed compared to the time of budget adoption at budget adoption it was 2.96 I think and now it's at 2.43 so Joel will cover that in a few minutes um just a reminder that there are because of the way that schools are funded um we were rely heavily on the big three taxes so personal
196income tax is the most at all and that's what a huge percentage of of how funds are are gathered and distributed that's where they come from so that's why we see the swings so often so just a kind of comparison of where those are trending that we always take a look back at the prior year because there's a settle up time for that and then the current year and then the next year and this gives the comparison between the enacted budget that happens in June compared to the legislative analyst office um projection which happens usually November December and then the governor's budget proposal that comes out in January okay and again um you know we don't have the it it says the onetime discretionary we have been advised by sco as well as school services
197and capital advisers not to include that in our in our March um second interim project CS so we want to make sure that people realize that yes that's money that could come in if so it will be one time again which is exactly what the issue is where we where we are today on the plus side it does uh project fully funding the cost of living adjustment there are um times when they suspend that they don't actually fund it and just showing the percentage um or the difference between our minimum guarantee and the actual state budget you can see here this was the effect of those one-time funds in the state so lots of people got a lot of one-time money um both on the individual level as well as the corporate level there were
198a lot of things that happened there then you can see that it dropped back down um after that and this is that difference that we were talking about with it's not accounting for $1.6 billion here this is what he's projecting the revenues to be and it's actually projected to come in a little bit higher than that and so this is something that is really we need to be paying attention as you know everybody you know knows that yes there's some stability at the state level you know as far as the you know there's not a huge swing this year like there was the prior year when it went from 3.9 . 4% to 1.07% we're only seeing about a half a percent difference in that projection so that's some stability for our budgeting but what
199we have to work on is what we're doing here locally to make sure that we are monitoring very closely our projections as well as the different line items in our budget and so thank you for approving the position control position tonight because that will help us to get there that's been an element that's been missing in our in our work um that will help us to keep a better much better um eye on on those things so again we're going to be paying really close attention and um looking at everything in much more detail as we go forward and working closely with scope yeah okay so here we'll look at the local control funding formula and the uh Cola so the local control funding formula is the state's main Revenue source to school districts it's
200our largest local Revenue here with about over 60% of our revenues um and they increase that each year by the cost of living adjustment you can see um this year their uh the January's proposal proposes a 2.43 cola um again as Lisa said it that is a um slightly lower by 0.005% from last Summer's um enacted budget Pro jection for this Cola um and you but you can see it increases about you know $244 um per Ada and then also included in the local control funding formula is the great span adjustment along with the suppl supplemental and concentration grant funding that we uh um uh invest in our lcap and uh as well as there is an increase to the TK um add-on which is uh the state's funding um uh tool for us to
201have the uh lower adult to child ratio in the TK programs and again that is in 25 26 going to be up to the Target fouryear Old level that they set a few years ago which that actually means that we have to lower the um adult to student ratio in TK beginning in 2526 so class um and that's that would apply to splits as well so if you have a combo with a tkk it has to align with the TK requirements of a 20 to1 class size with a 10 to1 adult to student ratio it also requires um more specific um experience or and or early childhood education units so not it's not every multi-ub teacher who qualifies to teach TK so there's some differences there that are going um into effect next year yeah
202and okay so here we're looking at how this kind of affects our our school district so again it is a slightly lower Cola oh and it's just a quick note um we did update this slide to show the four years and um the the impact on that on that 2728 year um so you can see and we did include this year just for clarity that the the uh Cola is enacted this year with that 1.07 and then you can see the update to this year this next year proposal uh 2.43% as opposed to the uh 2.93% you can see how that affects us locally here however included with the um information we got from school service California they gave us the dart board that projects uh the two future years colas as well and you
203can see that um those comparisons to the um last Summer's enactive budget projections there is a slight increase so um over the four years there's less of an impact there the reason that 20 um Lisa's got a really good uh uh what do they call it uh the block the glare protector and there's not a TV there's not a TV so I have always used to S that's what I'm sorry so you can see that with the about half percent reduction it is compounding so the increase in 26 27 isn't as great but it does catch up in 27 28 and and the good news about the the cola this year um is it is um funded with ongoing revenues this year for at the state level whereas in the past last year it was
204funded with some reserves so that is a positive thing with how the state is is operating um and the last thing about the um Cola is so it is increasing the local TR funding formula however Cola the state Governor's proposal for January includes funding the 2.43% cola for other state funding like categoricals like our special education Child Nutrition uh the mandated block grant and state preschool that we have get that us locally here as well and we look forward to seeing the um May revision as well because there is some thinking that there might be some uh positive revenues with that as well okay and um so yes we do expect to see that increase um to the base rate for special education funding one of the things that we do want to make sure
205is um you know that we start talking about though is that at the local level at our Sela so the um special education local plan area so we belong to that group um for Sonoma County and the over the last 20 years the funding model has not aligned with the the way that the the funds are actually distributed from the state to us um this the county um had and the the county that's in the districts who make up the the plan the the self the selfa plan area and there's a superintendence council that actually you know monit has the leadership they serve as the board for that the allocation model um is is really um outdated it incentivizes um identification of higher needs of students um for higher higher needs to be funded at
206a higher rate um and so over the last few years they have been talking about whether that model should be changed and we had a a finance subcommittee that I was part of um Joel sat in on some of those um John fiser sat on that as well and along with numerous other um organizations and we really looked through what is the right model what's the most appropriate how are the funds getting to the students in the same way that they're coming from the state and that was ultimately what was recommended is that there needed to be a change and there was a vote and so thank you Dr Morales for getting us the step into that um rather than the band The rip the bandid off um approach which is that we know this
207is going to have a reduction in revenue for us for special education and it was a very close vote um they ended up going with the committee's recommendation which was to step it in over two years rather than a full implementation in the first year so Santa Rosa city schools has been bened from the allocation model for a number of years and now it's really changing the distribution to to to align with how the funds come into this to the Salpa one of the issues has to do though with our identification rate or the that students are um maybe being sent to us who could be served in another in a home district and they're coming to us maybe on an inter inter trans interdistrict transfer rather than enrolling with their home district and then
208the district pays to place the student here with us so there are a lot of practices um and and conversations that we're having um with how to change the way that that identification work rate works and you know with our selfa study as well all that to say to say that we do expect a hit of somewhere around $1.8 to2 million next year in special education loss of Revenue and so that is where that special education study is really important that we are following the best practices and changing what we do and how so that we're aligning the right services and the right um supports for students while still remaining fiscally responsible so again that's a step in it it would have been closer to $4 million can I pause you for a second I
209think we need to motion to extend I'll move to extend to 11 second all those in favor say I I I any opposition motion passes go ahead thank you sorry I know it's a long one but I thought that this was important to spend a little bit of time on do you want questions now or later maybe maybe we get through and then and then we can go go back we're we're almost finished um so um and there are a couple of other things that happened with the with the funding as well to take some some of the brunt off of extensive um Health needs to have some um off the toop funding to help offset some of those costs so it's not all a revenue deduction or reduction but it it's really looking at
210how we can support each other as districts because we are all here to support our special education students in Soma County and how do we um most responsibly serve serve our students um as um Joel mentioned earlier the um state budget does protect expanded learning opportunities program Universal transition kindergarten and uh nutrition and Facilities so there's the state bond that was passed so that's separate from the budget um and then in nutrition right now it does look that we will still like we would still be receiving Universal um free meals for students that there's um concern about the reimbursement from the federal government if there's a change in the community eligibility provision as far as the rate of reimbursement the way that the law is currently written that doesn't impact us locally it impacts the
211state because the state would backfill any shortfall between what the federal government provides and and that cost the concern is though is that that then has to come from somewhere and so does that come from somewhere else in prop 98 very likely so so that's it would be a you know trade-off of where else we would lose the funds in order to cover that so you know we're advocating very hard to maintain the level of or Community eligibility provision for us to qualify for those state reimbursements or federal reimbursements um next steps just again looking at we don't know exactly what's going to happen with those um additional funds one one thing that is um expected to be put back into the budget are some funds for the learning recovery education um block grant so
212those funds were swept by the state a couple of years ago and we expect actually to receive some more those are restricted um but they would be able to be to be used for things that we're already doing such as you night school or some intercession program supports um that learning recovery so that that's definitely a plus for us um and I think that was estimated around 800,000 but I I can't remember for sure on that one um again we don't know about the um the discretionary block grant that would be very flexible yet that would be onetime funds um looking at um potential for literacy mathematics coach coaches um literacy screenings doesn't mean that there's a ton of money for that but these are maybe some supports that could be provided and again we'll
213be working you'll be seeing us in a couple of weeks with our second interim our audit um and working on our community messaging making sure that we're messaging you know far and wide as far as what our what our budget is where how our revenues work how the expenditures work what reductions are going you know are planned um so again that's a big part of what we will be doing over the next um few months we will as Dr Moralis mentioned earlier during her report continue the work of the fiscal stabilization advi advisory committee along with the finance subcommittee work and we'll be bringing stuff back to you soon I'll stop sharing and turn it back to president mcdal uh trusty Caston thank you for the report and you everything else we have going on
214this one of those longer term past this month things but it's very important and I just want to ask uh two categories questions but let's go back to Sela just briefly just so everyone understands our vote in Salpa and this change that's being implemented to fund our students less when we're voting in Salpa we get one vote for sah High one vote for the elementary there's no waiting to the population of the districts there's no consideration of the size of the budget there's no waiting to the size of the population no and actually we might end up losing that second vote that's coming up for consideration and voting at the Sala level so it is possible if the section superintendent vote for it we might lose that second vote at the elementary level but that
215is a possibility okay so I just I think it's important for everyone to understand and this happens in other parts of the government with like the Metropolitan Transportation Commission and Son County transportation AGC where really small districts really small jurisdictions get an outweighted control over how the funding is divided and it can be disproportionately impacting the largest parts of the population and so I no Solutions unfortunately but I think awareness is really important that in a lot of ways this is an inequality in representation for our students yes it it absolutely is um one of the things to realize is that that that's an important factor that that we were talking about in that finance subcommittee and and that we spoke to the superintendent's Council about is that while it's a big hit for us
216it's a smaller percentage of our budget as compared to some of the small districts who had a big swing to the negative as well it that could have been detrimental to to them even even un larger scale than to us so it was something that we felt was extremely important to step into obviously with our fiscal condition but also with some of the neighboring districts as well and then within this discussion with Sala I want to confirm because our death and heart hearing program at Hidden Valley is 100% off the top correct and then anyone in the county can is able to place those students that qualify for dhh without an impacting our budget that's all staying the way it is correct that is an off-the-top program in fact there has been some uh discussion
217about a potential for expanding that um through you know the upper grade levels as well so that we can keep students local here in Sonoma County rather than sending them off to a residential school um Lisa can you share because I know the communities you know watching our reports and our budgets very closely we will have a negative impact to our expenses the next two years just off the bat with this decision how much are we talking about in this year or next year in the following year so we don't have our updated numbers from Salpa yet so allation of what was shared in Salpa yeah all of the projections have been based on 23 24 and so it looks like about 1.8 to 1.2 million for next year and closer to 4 million for
218the following year based on those prior year numbers those are expenses that are getting our books those are a reduction in Reven yeah reduction in Reven reduction in the revenue which has a negative impact on the bottom line correct going to prop 988 questions um the prop 98 reserves were completely depleted at the state level in 23 24 and my understanding is the 1.5 billion contribution this year is replacing not adding to the 1.1 from last year correct okay and then those reserves are still under the limit the the mandatory limit for prop 98 Reserves at the state level yes they are which for us with our current Reserve isn't um isn't concerning for us as far as the the reserve cap trigger how however it does you know that is a mechanism that once
219the res the reserve the prop 98 Reserve at the at the state level reaches a certain point then districts are capped at a 10% Reserve level our Reserve level is we were just barely meeting our 3% which I know we've talked about um looking at that in policy in the future but my reason for asking isn't related to the cap but more the philosophy be behind why the cap is lifted when the state is under the prop 98 reserve and that's because the state is basically saying that they're not in a place where they're going to have a reserve so therefore they're letting us have have a bigger reserve and so can you just talk a little bit more about why that cap is lifted and because that's the risk element for us looking into
220next year absolutely the the there there are two things there's a whoops there's the reserve and there's cash flow and the reserve is an indicator of your abil of a District's ability to meet that cash flow that doesn't mean that that's necessarily money that you have in the bank but that's meant to be that estimation of what of the cash that you have on hand and as um trusty Casten you know talked about that this last year in order to keep education whole to keep us from having huge cuts and even to barely fund us at the 1.07% they had to withdraw all the funds from that rainy day fund specific for schools in order to keep us whole and so they're replacing that a little so that's 1.5 billion only so that's all that
221they have available as a cushion for schools essentially so that's why our Reserve is important going forward that we look at addressing that because that's what gets us through the lean times when there are those big cuts at the state level thank you these microphones um um oh kind of piggybacking off of what Daisy I'm so sorry Dr Morales and trusty Casten um were saying regarding Sala that the cut they were getting the dip um so we're looking at like 18 next year what is the following year closer to four million like four for that year or four total oh gosh okay and so then the follow the next question was more bottom line is you'll be receiving an update in a couple of weeks when we come back after going through all through with
222a fine tooth comb coming back with multi-year projections that include all of the known and expected factors at this point so I do want to just say out loud because that's I guess what I do is oh that's hard for special ed especially like those are our most vulnerable oh man okay and then bottom line is again because it's being asked everywhere how does this does this impact our school closures like does this impact our bottom line numbers for what we need to get to that's that's what we are working on now is to determining where else we can find anything to get us through and again that is I think what we've talked about is coming with several scenarios at m at um for second interim as far as with onetime funds without onetime
223funds what does it look like if we so some of the what we'll be bringing next week um for the special study session is if we do look at phasing what does that look like where does it get us to um how close and you know what it means is deeper Cuts in program or Staffing or other things and so identifying where that could potentially come from additionally because we're talking about money I have also heard people say well why can't the public fund raise can the public fund raise can absolutely so the public can fund raise to keep schools open yeah absolutely we'll take we we would take donations absolutely what we can't do is require right that that people pay we can't we you know have to be very careful about that but
224yes there's nothing saying that that people can't fund raise or that they can't make donations we are we are a um as a quasi state agency we you know we're tax exempt so so they do get a donation letter we we actually receive a lot of donations every year we have great support from our community and it's really support it's really appreciated you'll see that there's actually the donation tracking page on the consent agenda is all is all from that and and people can direct donations when when they do make donations um but this the board does not the board has the option of whether to accept that with the with the strings attached or to say no thank you and just a further followup on what um director Jenkins was mentioning so all the
225data that we were we've been looking at in these special sessions and everything it's all none of that included this projection right just correct we we were aware that there would be some kind of change likely we didn't know if it was going to be we were hoping for a three-year implementation and that was not ultimately something that was recommended by the finance subcommittee because it we knew that that was not likely to be approved um we knew there was a really strong push for a full implementation it actually had to go back for a vote again after saying wait a second those those the was an there was an issue with with um the counting of the votes and then they had to revote as well because the it was a split yes it
226didn't benefit the majority of the school districts so the first scenario was to absorve all of the either increase or decrease in one year um and that would have oh that would have done Us in so there was a hiccup in the county of votes and we were able to put forth the motion that at least went for the two years we were hoping for the three but we knew that wouldn't pass and kind of polling all of the superintendents so the best we were able to get was a two-year tier um expense hit and again that's why it's really important the work that happens in the um special education advisory committee to make sure that that we are monitoring that closely to make sure that we are um for students who don't belong on
227a case load still who really are thriving without without those additional services and my daughter was you know had speech services and you know I I I know how that works and so there are some things there are some lwh hanging fruits that that you know that John and his team are working on and and we're working very closely together so another followup then because 1.8 first year 4 million second year I know you don't have a crystal ball I mean is that the end right we're in the clear after that or is it going to get even worse down the road it will all depend on the the well there a couple ways to look at this so our funding comes in based on Ada the ab 602 funding which is our spe local
228special ed funding where State special head funding is based on Ada just as everything else and so depending on where our enrollment and our average daily attendance ends up that determines what our revenues are going forward and identification rates and funding and all of those things and percentages they change all the time so right now that's what that looks like that doesn't mean that that's what that Revenue stays at going forward um you know it's really going going to depend so those are things we have to monitor really closely and lastly um so I have was redo I was for a moment I was happy and then you kind of dashed it a little bit sorry apparently the killer of dreams I'm sorry well I did read about oh there there may be onetime funding
229available for the nutrition uh to uh for funding of equipment and training yeah to provide freshly prepared meals with locally grown ingredients for our schools I was like oh yay maybe we can get some of that but now you're saying H maybe not so fast I was one time funds may be getting pulled back so couple different things that one our our balances in our um nutrition services are very healthy so we and we have gone after grants and and funds for the preparation of of Fresh Foods our our kitchen actually our Ed and his team have been great at you know coming up with new recipes of things that kids are going to want to try and eat and so that's a really big push and that is um not impactful to our general
230fund so completely separate and that um is actually very healthy and while we've seen a reduction in students we've seen a substantial increase in participation so we're serving more meals now than we were when we had more students so that's actually an extremely successful program you know we have nutritious Foods getting out there and we're constantly working on that so not not a concern there that is absolutely a bright spot and to be celebrated and even if there is a change in that piece from the from the federal side we have we have the funds there to be able to absorb that for a little while um it's the general fund that's that's the concern and it is completely separate s right two more followup um I just wanted because we're talking about two things
231we prop 98 and we had Sala here yes so I just want to us to all grasp on the prop 98 front this is a more future thinking conversation because the May revise will give us new data we'll get revised trailer Bill language out of the legislature and then even that June date that's only when they're going to improve the numbers in July and August implementing language will get pass through the final negotiations on trailer bills and really September is when we'll know what our budget that starts in July is as far as the restrictions so when we're looking at the prop 98 part of this conversation it's there's a whole lot of moving Parts it's going to change a lot and then with the fires they've delayed all collections for some of the most
232capital gains rich neighborhoods in the state so and that's being delayed out till October so that's there's a lot there and a lot of what we have here isn't anything we should rely on uh it's at best you know kind of putting our fingers in the air and uh you know having a little water there so we have a gist as to which way the wind's going but with the Sela we have we're talking about a very real number very real analysis we talked about it on the side of how the formula is changing for the revenue we're receiving but I just want to make it clear that our um maintenance of effort requirements do not change and can you also just elaborate on what maintenance of effort means and that this means like we
233can't go cut the expenses from the things that this is funding correct so so any our special education is funded three ways Federal funding which is a very small percentage of it in comparison um State funding which is the funding that we just spoke about and then local and local is our contribution so local is the amount that comes from our unrestricted general fund to offset the costs in our special education programs something that we've been paying close attention to with that maintenance of effort because we talked a little bit about this at the last session which is essentially if we spent if we had 500 special education students and we spent a million dollars last year then this next year if we still have 500 education special education students and we still we still
234spend a million dollars we've met our maintenance of effort if we only spend 800,000 and we still have those 500 kids then we're penalized that difference and if we spend more so say that year we spend 1.2 million then the next year that 1.2 million is our new goal that's our new bar and anything that we fall below that is that penalty and that's kind of a simplistic look at it because there's actually four ways to meet that maintenance of effort um which has to do with a combination of state and local funds overall so if it's $10 million then each year it's $10 million from the combination of state and local funds or it's $10 million from only and I'm just throwing that out there that it's not a real number um if our
235state if our local funding is 10 million then we can meet that at the local level with that contribution and that's one way to meet it also on a per special education student basis so if we have say 500 students that first year and then the next year it Drops 400 students as long as we're spending the same per student then we then we can lower those overall costs cost s and so that's where the identification rate is important that we're getting that right that we aren't um over referring students that we are providing um supports you know in the classroom so those making sure that there are interventions that there's that all of the steps happen prior to them being referred for special education because that's the most restrictive environment or you know setting
236for them versus you know providing a you know a um you know some type of inter intervention ahead of time so we tend to have um historically it's it's typical and not I don't know if it's typical necessarily if that's the word I'm looking for but an issue tends to be the Dual identification of English language Learners so if somebody is not a native English speaker they are often identified for special education services when maybe that's not actually the need when really it's a communication need not a a learning need I just want to re-emphasize though the reduction and revenue does not reduce our reduction in our maintenance of effort and so that means that we will have to increase our local contribution so barring the reduction of other rate baring one of those other
237things Happ thank you so back to bottom line stuff excuse me um how does so there are all of these factors that we have absolutely zero control over it's fun to be living in and how does that play a part in our bottom line and what we have to do to drive the ship right like we're trying to steer the ship everybody's got their hand on the wheel um but when there's so much that is out of our control how slow can we drive this ship and that's why it is important to look at not just now but in the future because you can have a a large swing at any point that's you know trusty Casten was talking about the fires and the delayed reporting that's exactly what happened when we went from a
2383.94% projected Cola to a 1 0 7% Cola that's why that happened and so really setting good policy is the starting point for that making sure that we are setting a policy that that helps us to be able to weather the storm and that that's not something that's going to happen right away I mean that if we tried to go from a 3% to a 10% we'd be shutting down you know I can't even think of of what that would look like but really looking at incremental progress and looking not just to fix things for now and meeting that 3% but looking at where we're projected to go finding ways to better direct our resources it it's again all of that work and it's constantly changing so it it's having those open conversations um looking
239for you know ways that we can do things better improve our practices and you know create our our systems going forward so again good policy you know consistent conversations we collaborate regularly with sco um and they're guiding us with that and so just to clarify since that ab1 1200 came up and what that process looks like that there are two things the the receivership happens if we run out of cash you can run out of cash with a positive with a pos positive budget those are two very different things and um so the the what happens with the qualified budget you have you know three in a row then what happens is you have a fiscal adviser appointed well that's the official piece of it we work unofficially all the time together and so sco
240is already involved and know they know what our fiscal stabilization plan is they know what we're looking at with school closures and staff reductions and all of these things happen regularly it's just not that formal intervention and that's because we are working to to fix it ourselves can you just say a little bit more about what that means like running out of cash as a school district because I think that is very elusive when we talk about like the the qualifications and then what what does that mean so what that means thank you ahead of time yes so essentially what it means is that we don't have money to borrow or transfer so right so Joel and I were talking about it earlier and a really good analogy is when you've gone through your savings
241at home and you've also maxed out your credit cards and your home equity and now you have to pay your mortgage and you have no money to do it you you know who knows how you're going to do that you might go into foreclosure and so that's essentially receivership it's that we run out of cash because we've used all of our internal money because remember we write our cash flow we only get money at certain times times during the year which our expenses we have a lot of expenses early in the year so between July and August or July and December we get very little money and then our TA our local taxes come in when when people pay their local property taxes we get some money in between but the majority of it happens
242then but in the meantime we've operated Summer Schools we've you know gotten classes up and running and we've started paying people all of that expense happens first so we have a line of credit through the treasury that we use to get through the for cash for the beginning of of the year until we start getting those those in and it's what about a hundred million dollar on our right so our property we get 85% of our total property taxes which come in in December and April yeah and then we so there so there's that so if we didn't have that line of credit we'd be out of cash but we have that to borrow from we also have internal funds that we can borrow back and forth from but they have to be repaid so
243be repaid so we can borrow internally but we have to be able to pay it to pay it back um sco has a small reserve fund that they can do some you know small loans for as well but you're talking a few million dollars which for us is not you know a whole lot as far I mean our cash flow needs are are much larger than what theirs are and what they have available so once you've exhausted all of those things and you still don't have enough to make your your payments because you don't have enough cash on hand that's when you end up in with that emergency loan from the state which is receivership and the Takeover but that skips the qualified it can right it can it it may happen in conjunction with
244that or it may skip it so they can happen independently so the qual the first step if you aren't running out of cash but you're just having a budget problem that's the qualified you know three times in a row and then you have your fiscal advisor and you work to to fix the budget but if you run out of cash in that time that that's when you go immediately into receivership so there are two very different things one can lead to the other but they are not always dependent on each other any other questions from the board and just for transparency we did include a cash flow it is on there so we are monitoring that very closely thank you we will move on next on the agenda is resolution number 2024 25-27 criteria to
245determine certificated Personnel who shall be exempt from the order of layoff by virtue of their credentials assigned or assignment or certification Dr xans welcome back okay thank you um so I am here to ask for approval of the um what we call the skipping criteria which is the criteria that we use to um determine uh teachers with specific credentials that we will skip over in the cases of doing layoffs um this given criteria that we are asking for the board to approve today is um very similar to the skipping criteria that we have in past years uh possession of a single subject credential for Spanish or a clad or the French equivalent of a bclad which is a b RF um possession of a single subject math or a single subject science credential possession of
246a special education credential all teachers who are assigned to the dual immersion program at srfax all teachers who are assigned to teach a course in Spanish as part of the dual immersion program at ccla or LC High School all teachers who have successful experience teaching transitional kindergarten within the last five years as well as school psychologists and speech language Pathologists holding a bilingual certification and so in order um what this does is it allows us to keep teachers who have specialization in areas that are hard to fill board any questions Caston two initial questions um can you define successful for teaching TK yeah there is um there is Ed code on how to decide if a teacher is eligible to teach TK what we're asking for is successful teaching completion of teaching of TK in
247the last five years and that means just that um both the teacher and the administrator have found that TK is a good fit for a particular teacher we have had teachers who have um gone into TK and decided that this was not the right place for them and have moved out of TK the very next year or teachers who you know by choice of the administration have been moved out of TK we don't want to offer that as a skipping criteria if the teacher is not going to be a teacher that would be teaching TK in the upcoming year and that's a process that's already occurred through the choosing to be placing them in a classrooms so would be objective and not subjective yes and then uh I don't see reference to any certifications or
248uh special training related to any CTE uh is there I can't go weld um so is there any protection for CTE related uh specialization so the way that we determine our needs in that area is by how many students are choosing to take those courses and determining how many teachers that we need to teach those courses so um in order to be able to teach the course you would have to have the appropriate CTE credential so that's captured in the skipping criteria to it's captured in the ability to be able to teach the course so we wouldn't be able to assign somebody let's say with an English credential to teach you know CTE welding but what so I just to be really clear but we also wouldn't lay them off and then not be able
249to offer the section like that's it captured in this criteria yes if um we did not have enough students selecting the course and we had to lay off a teacher then yes and just when you were reading off the criteria here like on number one uh I just want to make sure it's not a typo on the French part you you use a different acronym is is that correct the way you have it here or did yeah so um we call it if you get it in California um it is a bclad which is a bilingual um whatever clad stands for which I cannot remember at 10:30 at night um but there's also another authorization there's actually additional authorizations in Spanish as well so there's a bilingual authorization in Spanish which is a basp and
250there is a bilingual authorization in French which is the bfr so there are several that fall under that same category of being bilingual okay thanks any other board questions are there any blue cards there are no blue cards for this item further discussion or a motion yes just a discussion Point um and not necessarily now but it's me needing to say something uh regarding um bilingual staff while I understand that we need to move forward with this I do think that it's really important that we give in the future and maybe we already do this I'm not sure new uh but we give teachers especially ones that have been around the block for a long time um the opportunity to take classes whether that be on the I mean hopefully on I mean whatever but
251to take classes to uh expand their own language base to meet the needs of our community as well Caston like to move approval of resolution 2024-25 d27 resolution skipping criteria and wave F the reading of the text is there a second a second any further discussion roll call vote trusty Casten hi trusty Jenkins hi trusty Kirby hi trusty D Tor hi president mcnell I motion passes all right moving on to resolution number 2024 25-28 to adopt seniority date tiebreaking criteria to determine the order of termination among certificated employees with the same date of paid service okay so in a perfect world the seniority list would just be straight seniority we'd be able to figure it out um unfortunately when it comes to layoff sometimes it doesn't work that way and we have several teachers with
252the same credential that um have the same date of hire and so what we do in order to break the tie is we look at several other criteria including um any credentials that they have that might be specialized like if they have a bclad if they work in a dual immersion um those kinds of things then um we look at their years experience teaching prior to their current employment so do they have more years of experience in another District before they came to requ ests um credentials that permit supplementary authorizations so that may be um a social studies teacher who has an authorization to teach English that would give them an extra point the number of teaching or special Ser specialist service credentials a degree Beyond a bachelor's degree so extra points for a master's
253or doctorate and then um teachers that have a national board CER ification so um we give a point value that is explained in number three based on each of those a through F and then using those Point values we're able to rank teachers that have the same date of seniority um if after doing all of that there is still a tie then um we use a specific very um Tech teal tiebreaking criteria which is a deck of cards and we pull cards and the highest card is you know the highest seniority and the next and the next and the next and we actually did have to use that last year several times um kathern how and I had fun doing that the cards so we we'll qualify that fun was not actually what you were
254having I was being a little sarcastic with the fun yes my apologies I think we're all going to have to hold our jokes for a few more weeks here so word questions yeah perfunctory to my last question nothing within here is subjective everything is clearly objective everything is based on actual dates years of employment credentials held there's nothing subjective in the tiebreaking criteria thank you does the uh we've got listed here K through 12 does it need to be TK through or it would be TK through 12 although um I guess theoretically there could be an issue with TK I think it we just haven't updated it since we've introduced TK is that something we can amend now here kind of thing okay well I I move that we amend the resolution to change the
255K12 where it appears I think two times in here to the tk12 I think you can make the amendment with the friendly Amendment yeah but I do have a public comment card I'm sorry sorry um is Alice jobson still here I have to only give her a minute right yes yeah so you only have one minute oh okay so um I'm here for my fellow teachers fear full of layoffs and school closures and for my students um I've been an educator in srcs since 2015 um help my students through the tubs Spire through teaching through zoom and um I still remember hand delivering materials to my students who couldn't get to distribution days um but in spite of my love dedication and support and permanent status and seniority I will likely be laid off with
256the many of most recently hired teachers and this is due to a changeable policy in 2022 I resigned due to burnout and one year later in 2023 I was rehired and was not given my original hire date back the stress of these layoffs in school closures not only affects me um but it hurts our students um we are loving and irm constants in their lives so please consider not only the effects of the layoffs but also this higher date policy um thank you your time is up are there any other blue cards no other blue cards no other blue cards right trusty Caston a question on that the higher date policy is that set in contract yes it is sorry I was asking if the higher date policy was set on contract okay so now
257seeking a motion with that friendly Amendment I'll move resolution 2024 25-28 resolution Ty baking criteria with the amendment to include TK on criteria B 2B and wait for the reading of the text second any further discussion he roll call vote trusty Casten hi trusty Kirby hi trusty Jenkins hi trusty de laor I president McNelly I motion passes and then items six and seven were pulled so thank you Dr Sans so we'll move on to our consent items seeking a motion on items G1 through n so moved second moved by trusty Casten second by trusty Kirby roll call vote trusty Casten hi trusty Kirby hi trusty Jenkins hi trusty de laori hi president McNelly I motion passes right moving on to approval of minutes from previous meetings um need a motion on the minutes of the
258regular board meeting held on December 11th 2024 motion approved can we not we don't have a forum on this yeah we'll have to bring it back I think okay um is there another one for December I don't have it we might have to bring both December ones back uh December 18th it was when they when the new uh trustees were sworn in so I think that they can vote on that one yeah okay well I'll bring back the 11th okay so approval minutes of the regular board meeting held on December 18th 2024 so moved second okay discussion um if I could uh amend part of it just so that the notes show that I did request a meeting in July and that it's being addressed with a um special meeting it would I would just
259like the notes for the calendar yes okay I will I will make note of that okay sorry I couldn't hear who moved and who seconded Okay move by trusty deor second in by trusty Caston roll call vote trusty deor all trusty Caston hi trusty Kirby hi trusty Jenkins hi president mcnell I motion passes approval of minutes of the regular board meeting held on January 8th 2025 so moved second moved by trusty Casten second by trusty Jenkins roll call vote trusty Casten hi trusty Jenkins hi trusty Kirby hi trusty de la Tori hi president mcnell I motion passes approval of minutes of the regular board meeting held on January 22nd 2025 so moved second moved by trusty Caston second by trusty Jenkins roll call vote trusty Casten hi trusty Jenkins hi trusty Kirby hi trusty de
260laori hi president mcnell I motion passes all right item I are there any board member requests for for information justy Kirby I just want an up update on the request for when the um SRO moou meeting has has there been any um yes I had reached out the day after um with um our city manager and we actually got an email so trusty Jenkins trusty Theus and trusting Bina got an email today to do a doodle poll to set the meeting with the city any other requests for information I'm so sorry I'm so tired okay seeing none um we have our information items at the bottom of the agenda any last words superintendent thank you for sticking with us good night meeting adjourned