CorpusRecord 107023

SRCS Special Board Meeting - February 5, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Santa Rosa City Schools
Date
2025-02-06
Location
Sonoma County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
31,962 words · about 178 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001now opening the February 5th 2025 meeting of the Santa Rosa City Schools Board of Education please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance right thank you all for being here today um we are here in the Santa Rosa high school gym because we we heard in asking for a larger venue um we didn't have a lot of options that were available today this was what we could find that was the most Central the most accessible um and had the most space so we're really glad you're all here um tonight's Focus as you know is on school exposure and consolidation um so really our only items tonight are going to be the presentation public hearing and then board questions and discussion before we start I do have just a quick statement from trusty Medina so trusty Medina

002said I am not present at tonight's board meeting due to my recusal from discussions and decisions related to a conflict of interest regarding school closures then all right so we will start with the presentation from um Ben Wolf our chairperson from school closure consolidation committee Lisa August and Allison Budlong thank you members of the board um superintendent Morales members of the public that are here this evening as well uh thanks for having us here this evening of course we wish it was under better circumstances given the topic but uh we do appreciate the time that we've had to consider all the data over the past uh many months now as part of the committee and our purpose tonight really is to summarize the the process to summarize some of the criteria and considerations that we

003went through in the discussions and then to summarize of course the uh recommendations from the committee at the end of it all of which are contained in the overall report so just quick introduction uh I'm Ben Wolf I was chair of the committee as well also have two kiddos in sen R the city schools and my vice chair Allison Budlong here is also here and she'll be tagging in with me as we go through the presentation and also just to clarify for members of the public there won't be any questions in back and forth right now during the presentation we're just going to go through it and there'll be a chance for questions um from the board after that so just a reminder as part of the background so back in in June at the

004board meeting they established the um the school consolidation advisory committee was initially empowered at that point we had an application process from the public there were well over 100 150 or so applicants for the positions that were available initially there were 21 members that were appointed one of those members did drop out of the process so we had 20 members of the committee through the duration of the process and our task was to uh to recommend of course the ranking of the school sites for potential closure and also potential alternative scenarios so they just a list of the committee members just to show that it was a broad representation across the District of parents committee community members staff teachers uh a number of different folks with different backgrounds different areas of expertise that were members

005of the committee so the process started back in August and we had nine meetings from August through just this past Monday to go through the process it was facilitated by school Services of California and they came with uh best practices as far as what the scoring criteria would be so we had and I'll get into more details on this there were 25 criteria that were considered for each site and weed data on each of of the 25 criteria throughout the process those criteria were proposed to the committee um from California school Services following their best practices the summary of the meetings again back in August is when we started that's where the committee was first introduced to the the overall process and the criteria and initiated some of the discussions around the criteria and how

006we wanted to um receive data on those criteria going through the process we then went through a series of four meetings from September through November there which had uh where we received specific data on the 25 criteria I'll get into the details on those in a few minutes here uh and then the last four meetings we had were the deliberations within the committee members and the beginning and conclusions of our um process for ranking the sites and recommendations so just to touch on the criteria briefly here the first batch of criteria the first six criteria were all focused on demographics and capacity at the different sites so each site and remember this is looking at each site specifically of the 23 sites across the district that were in consideration so we looked at aspects such

007as current uh School enrollment uh demographics from a um diversity perspective looking at unduplicated student percentage to to for the diversity aspect we look at that uh future capacity as well and transfers in and out so those were the types of criteria and data that we received uh with respect to demographics and capacity the second batch of criteria were all focused on facilities so these were looking at the cost historic cost and future projected cost of facilities considering the facilities master plan and Investments That would be needed uh looking at support spaces common spaces environmental factors earthquake fault lines those types of aspects were considered for facilities uh the next batch was looking at educational and student support services this had criteria that a couple different things were focused in here there is the criteria

008on special programs and whether or not they could be relocated or would need to be re relocated and also criteria 14 15 and 16 I'll speak briefly about that uh in two slides here to address specifically some of the rationale for the committee that making the conclusion to remove those criteria eventually from consideration as we looked at all the data sets but those criteria looked at um a couple different things but looked at the state dashboard with respect to Performance of the different sites also looked at performance specifically for English standards and math standards as a whole the final batch of criteria that were considered were based on fiscal impacts and other impacts for each of the sites uh looking at safety with respect to traffic concerns location of the the various sites the potential

009for alternative uses of each of the sites uh and then also looking of course at the net savings that we would project for any site closure as well as operating costs um per student operating costs looking at um efficiency of the sites so I want to speak a little bit about uh the removal of criteria 14 and 15 and 16 specifically it's been a topic there have been a lot of comments on this a lot of questions around this uh these criteria specifically so as I mentioned earlier these criteria were focused on um uh the state dashboard metrics with respect to um the different sites as well as English and math performance and the committee did decide to remove these after considerable discussion it was not an easy discussion there was quite a bit of

010debate uh among the committee for this but it came down in the end to three factors that were considered to be uh enough of a concern for the committee that the committee voted to remove these from consideration in the uh deliberations that we had at the end the first one being with respect to equity the concern here that the these criteria may disproportionately impact schools specifically that were historically serving a greater population of marginalized um marginalized populations the second concern was with respect to just the data limitations with respect to these specific metrics that were um being proposed for criteria 14 15 and 16 some of the limitations um were with respect to limited multi-year data data for example also the concentration of specialized programs at certain sites that had lower enrollment could potentially skew

011some of those metrics um and so as a result of that the the committee felt that those specific metrics may not be the best representation of of true academic performance and finally the third one just the the relevance of these three criteria with respect to the sites themselves and the concern here was around the question of whether or not the those metrics were really directly related to factors in control of the physical site so the focus was on the site and site potential closure and consolidation and there was question whether or not these metrics really represented the site themselves and factors within the control of the sites themselves so in the end the data was discussed considerably it was presented to the committee uh the committee had visibility of course to it as well as

012to the the rankings relative rankings with respect to these criteria but in the end when we summed the data uh and received the summation of the rank scores at the end those these scores were not included in those okay a little bit about the ranking process so I mentioned that the 25 criteria minus the three from 14 15 and 16 that were removed so of the 25 criteria each criteria received uh one or two scores the first score was a relative score which was primarily either one or two for the most part it was a yes or no based on each of the criteria did that site meet that specific criteria or not and it was ranked as a one or a two and then the second score for 11 of the criteria was a

013relative comparison that gave more resolution so for example it would rank with respect to the high schools there are five high school sites so ranked relative to each other each High School would receive a score of one two three four or five and that by nature of doing that we would have more resolution with respect to those sites in particular and that would apply more waiting to those specific criteria so again the criteria criteria 1 through 24 all received that initial relative score of a yes no and then criteria 1-9 as well as 14- 16 and then of course 24 and 25 received the um the the relative comparison scores that had a little more resolution in the ranking there so the S no scores as I mentioned those were equally weighted of course they're

014either a one or a two so when you sum those up across uh all of the sites you would have an equal waiting across the 24 criteria that received those scores versus the what we call the ti breaker uh scores which were the rank scores that had additional resolution so when you look at the reporting out and you see the spreadsheet that has the different sites with the scores there's two columns for each one is that rank score which is a uh relative uh relative score that has the one or two summed for all criteria equally weighted and then the second one is certain criteria 11 of the criteria that had the additional waiting uh that were used as tiebreakers in the discussions so the committee was provided with summation data as I mentioned for

015those two scores and that was used as the starting point I want to emphasize that it was used as the starting point for the discussion so we didn't just go down and look at the scores see which one had the highest or lowest scores and make the decisions based on that it was certainly a factor in the deliberations but it was not the um the only Factor so in the final ranking process the last few meetings that uh that the committee had the ranking process began with the committee splitting into four smaller groups to have initial deliberations as small as small teams to uh discuss all of the data all of the areas of significance as well as the process by which we would go through for ranking the different sites and uh some of

016the considerations that were used by the individual teams included of course the sum as I mentioned of the yes no rank scores uh also looked at locations of each site relative to the other sites so pulling up the map and understanding impact of closing one site on other sites nearby also the impact on local communities within those sites uh and then some teams did give more weight to some of the factor some of the criteria that we had additional resolution on specifically uh enrollment rates transfer rates and um and potentially the financial metrics criteria 24 and 25 in particular so the four teams then reported out on these rankings and we deliberated as an entire committee to come up with the final recommendation and that was over two meetings to come to consensus then on

017the final recommendations for the sites and what I'll say about these recommendations this is meant to be although we didn't put down a specific specific 311 recommendation these rankings um would our recommendation would be that these rankings form the basis for the decisions on the 311 scenario so beginning with the rankings then uh with respect to the high schools uh the final ranking that we had here we we had a lot of debate on this as well of course and came to a consensus of having three tiers the first tier Els Allen in Montgomery High School and they're listed in alphabetic order here just to clarify not one above the other one the committee did not in the end did not want to pit these schools against each other and decided not to decide specifically

018between these two schools as far as which one would be recommended at top of the list for potential uh closure so they're listed as three tiers here the first tier with Elsie Allen and Montgomery second tier being Santa Rosa high school and then the third being Maria Creo and Piner high schools with respect to the middle schools uh again listed here we didn't have any tear on this one we were able to come to consensus with respect to the four middle schools in terms of the ranking with Santa Rosa Middle School being ranked at the top of the list for potential closure followed by Herbert Slater tomstock and then rink and Valley Middle School and just one note here to as well as um as many are aware the the district does have two districts

019the elementary and the secondary districts and so there are limitations to where um uh where an elementary school may be able to be located in s Rosen middle school and um com Middle School are the only two that are within the Elementary District so when thinking of alternative scenarios such as a K through 8 program uh only those two sites would be options for putting that on there just and then finally the elementary schools uh there's considerable discussion on the elementary schools it it really becomes a complicated scenario because of the locations um the populations that the different schools serve the um enrollments at the schools there's features of the schools there's many many variables with respect to the schools so lot lot of discussion here in the end the committee was able to come

020to consensus on two tiers of schools to consider three in the first tier and four schools in the second tier and again the listed alphabetically Within These tiers not meant to be in order of priority within each of the the buckets that we're um looking at here the committee did come to relatively quick consensus with respect to beella Brook Hill and steel Lane elementes being in that first tier the second tier took considerably more discussion time and in the end we we looked at the um the rankings we really went back to the rank scores with respect to these uh four sites that were selected for the second tier and the rank scores as a reminder were the 11 criteria that had more waiting and more resolution were the ones that we looked at for

021the second tier here so with the second tier uh recommendation being Abraham Lincoln ccla Hidden Valley and James Monroe Elementary Schools um I do really want to emphasize that the committee is certainly not recommending the closure of ccla the program it was related to the site here um and I'll speak a little more about the emphasis of uh the language immersion programs in general from the committee's perspective but certainly not recommending a closure of the program for ccla so some additional considerations there are many other considerations in in significant more detail in the full report but these are some of the items that that we wanted to highlight um for discussion this evening as we get into it with respect to the elementary schools first of all avoid closing many multiple um neighboring elementary schools

022that that was one of the challenges we had looking at which sites to recommend is there are several areas of school of schools elementary schools located close to each other and closing multiple neighboring ones would have more of a significant impact um also with respect to the elementary schools looking at which schools serve high populations with disabilities or historically marginalized populations it needs to be a significant factor those didn't necessarily come out in purely come out within the ranking scores and the summation of scores so it's something else to consider as as you're looking at the elementary school specifically uh Montgomery High School as you know has the IB program and the IB Program if Montgomery High School is selected for closure the uh committee is strongly recommending that um we make sure that the

023IB program can be relocated in time for students to continue the program within their time frame So within this next school year that there isn't a gap with respect to that program uh contained in the report there's a list of criteria specifically around the IB program and what it would take to be able to move the IB program to another site um not that it can't be done but there are some significant considerations with respect to that so um the committee's recommending with respect to Montgomery High School to certainly ensure that the IB Program could be relocated by next year um without impacting any of those students since we're not since we're not going through the full report at length tonight I'll just add that in the um excerp in the report that addresses the

024steps needed to move the IBU program it didn't address timeline so that would be something the board would need to look into and request more information about so an additional consideration with respect to really any of the high schools so if any High School is selected for closure the students from those schools they committee felt very strongly they need to receive the support necessary to stay on track for their goals for college or postsecondary post wherever they're headed to after this um as we know this closures will affect all students high school students with respect to where they're at in their academic careers could be more significant so we want to ensure that um that's considered in the selection of any potential High School closure that those students uh receive additional support and then um

025a few other points about Charter schol schools so there and this is again detailed into the report as well but uh our recommendation is to consider the potential future impact of outof District charter schools that are currently within the boundaries so as you know there's a there's a couple of charter schools that are not sponsored by Santa Rosa city schools that are located within the boundaries of San Rosa city schools so consider the potential impact of those charter schools on future enrollment or programs um as we're looking at this as well that was a difficult factor to consider in the data because it is speculation about where things may go in the future similarly both ccla and S Ros accelerated charter schools are also located outside of San Rosa city school elementary boundaries and so

026similar to the previous bullet point consideration of those two programs in particular um from the IND District Charter should be considered so the committee just wanted to highlight those considerations from future impact for enrollment and programs as well so there's been lots of discussion about alternative scenarios as well so we heard that the ranking discussion here for the 311 scenario there was also considerable discussion in the committee um about alternative scenarios and considerable discussion in the community as a whole around alternative scenarios the committee in the end um we didn't come up with specific specific um alternative scenarios but we did come up with a few highlevel considerations and the top of these is to as an alternative scenario to the 311 to consider keeping all of the Comprehensive High Schools open now in order

027in order to do that there's are significant challenges and these are some of the points that we've highlighted here for the next U the next couple of points with respect to do that so if we're if we were to keep all high schools open the committee would recommend looking at um adding grade 78 to some of the sites not all of the sites so again there's detail on the report but specifically looking at LC Allen Piner and Montgomery as potential sites to add seven and eth grad too um in addition to that and really these points could be taken somewhat independent of each other but from a fiscal perspective likely some mix of all of these points would have to be in consideration were all of the high schools to remain open so the Ridgeway

028site not closing the program but consolidating that site and the or consolidating that program onto an existing High School site would likely need to be considered from a fiscal perspective in order to achieve the targets um that we have here if we keep all high schools open of course this program or to keep all high schools open would require more than one Middle School we are the committee is not recommending all middle schools to be closed by any means but it would require the closure of more than one Middle School to achieve that and from the elementary schools again looking at the 311 scenario very likely would require the closure of more than three elementary schools um though again this would have to be rack and stacked on the the financials to um to confirm

029all of that the committee also wanted to recommend there's quite a bit of discuss and um interest from the community as a whole on the TK through 8 programs so um with respect to the TK through eight programs just highlighting the recommendation that that be considered for the comto campus in particular as I mentioned earlier Santa Rosa Middle School would also be another site option for a TK through eight program and these last these last couple points are in the mix of alternative scenarios not necessarily focused just on the high school part uh the next Point here is to consider mixing and matching the grade level options so not necessarily A one- siiz fits-all if we put seven and eight onto some campuses for high school not to do that across the board or if

030we do TK through eight not to do that across the board but to have some mixing and matching as another recommendation from the committee and finally um this was really a separate discussion Point as it's not directly tied to um not directly tied to the financials and the closures and consolidations but to consider a focus on a Language Academy and see if it were feasible to collocate ccla and the French program srfa onto the same campus or uh strengthen ties between the two from a language perspective that is a separate point it's not really related directly to the financial targets that we have with closures and finally just some final thoughts from the committee as a whole as we know this is a rough has been a very rough process going through all the details

031uh learning as much as we have about each of the sites across the entire district and it's going to have a huge impact on our entire community so this is it's been rough it's been a rough um process that we've gone through for everyone involved um and we certainly hope that coming through this that our Focus can be on the students the staff on the programs that we have there are there are many amazing programs of course many many amazing students and staff in the district let's keep our focus on that as much as we can um and the committee really does hope that in the long term we come out for this on the better side once we get through this process and that uh we can develop schools and programs that attract and

032retain folks into our district thank you very much thank you for the presentation all right we're now going to move to the public hearing um I we want to hear from as many of you as possible but we also need to make sure that we still have time for our own questions and discussion so I am going to have the public hearing end 8:30 at the latest that gives us about two and a half hours 90 seconds each each person will have 90 seconds to speak have to open Can You Hear Me no okay I'm going to try to use my teacher voice all right now opening the public hearing I'll call names three at a time so when you hear your name you can line up behind the podium first is Margaret Boon followed

033by Steve Brunner followed by anelie Kumar good evening the district office is saying IB can be continued if Monty closes by just lifting out all the teachers classes sections and admin as a unit and moving them to another school I want you to really think about that that's suggesting whole departments electives dozens of teachers would be moved as one unit so say you close Monty and move IB to Elsie What Becomes of Elsie are they just a host body that's taken over and transformed into Montgomery you lose huge amounts of teachers culture and programs to move IB that's not to say close Elsie either none of our schools none of our high schools none of our schools really are expendable there's no easy or obvious choice and every choice has damning repercussions in addition I

034want to say I emailed you a long letter about the needs of ESN and map kids and I appreciate the responses I did get including from director fiser I also fully believe he's working with facilities to navigate what we need but I will say comto classes have needed in class bathroom since they were at Cook and Cook stopped existing in 2020 five years ago it's easy to say these things going to happen but when everything is in a people and five schools are being red redistributed I don't see that we're going to have that happen for our small amount of kids thank you thank you Margaret next is Steve Bruner followed by I'll lean in it's all right uh thank you very much for the meeting and your time we know this is difficult stuff

035our district is in a terrible budget crisis and as critical going forward we make smart business decisions which basically means return on investment which includes both money spent and actual performance results from the spending I don't want any school to close but even so if it comes down to that or a choice we need to prioritize and some simple math makes it easy for Montgomery the transfer rate out of the district from Montgomery is 18 times lower than the next school we're told is in consideration at the mcgomery campus we have valuable Santa Rosa history great diversity an IB Program already financed new buildings yet to be finished a larger footprint of students that would be affected a lower transfer rate in the district away from the district and according to US News and World

036Report Montgomery High School has a higher graduation rate college readiness rate than any other High School on the supposed chopping block again again I do not want any school to close but given all of this I'm sure that all the people here realize including those in the decision-making capacity that closing Montgomery would be a colossal loss to this entire community and I'm confident you're going to find a way to prevent such a destructive thing from our community thank you next is anelie Kumar followed by Tomas Marcado followed by Andy bunnel good evening my name is Anjulie ker I am a junior and IB diploma candidate at Montgomery High School as we know the IB Program Roots Montgomery to the ground being one of the three IB schools in California since 1995 6,000 students have graduated

037through the IB program today 55% of our Junior and senior classes rely on the program to excel in their education the IB Program takes two students two years to complete is incredibly difficult to reinstate you would be invading another school's campus that has never been exposed to IB before it requires extensive IB training and a coordinator this is assuming that you would be able to take each teacher class and coordinator from Montgomery to a new school how do you know this is guaranteed I have waited years for this opportunity just to fear that I may not be able to experience it this is not just me it is every other current and future IB student Montgomery is the IB program's home our IB coordinator Jeremy Han likes to call us Global Citizens and this is

038something we closely identify with as our saying goes we are a people not a place thank you thank you next is Tomas Marcado followed by Andy bunnel followed by Nicole guest hello my name is Tomas Marcato I am a junior and IB diploma candidate at Montgomery High School I'm here to represent my student body and show it is not viable to close Montgomery to close Montgomery the IB Program would have to be moved moving the IB Program would require relocating our principal IB coordinator the majority of Montgomery's IB certified teachers as well as the majority of Montgomery's IB students 55% of this year's Junior and senior class at Montgomery are part of the IB Program moving this amount of people would be incredibly difficult and is unrealistic furthermore it would destroy the educational Paths of

039hundreds of our students many Juniors have already begun the process of writing their extended essays as well as their independent assessments these projects are a vital part of the IB program and are created to introduce new ideas to the world students draw from their relationships with staff and teach on campus to inform and Inspire their projects moving the IB Program would inevitably separate many of these students from their mentors fracturing the personal connections that we spent three years cultivating Montgomery's closure would cause the district and its students much more thank you next is Andy bunnel followed by Nicole guest followed by Holden we hi thank you for this opportunity um my name is Andy bunnel I'm a school-based therapist licensed clinical social worker I work primarily at LC Allen but also at s Roa Middle

040School um and I just strongly strongly believe that I think most of us do in the room that all high schools need to remain open I know it's a super difficult decision um I think you all know why it is a civil rights issue I feel absolutely and I think hopefully most agree um we started the sep uh program which is counseling enhanced program at LC Allen about five years ago and we have felt safe secure welcomed honored and respected from day one when we got a very friendly visit from from the principal um I don't know how many people have been LS Allen but it's an an incredibly um inclusive warm connecting environment that I have not felt elsewhere in my over 40 years as a professional as a mental health professional um yes

041we have a fiscal crisis and I also see it as an incredible opportunity to do something um different bold and I appreciate some of the recommendations um we've been speaking to our students about it they've been speaking to us their concerned and their families and one student um a senior that I work with um who's on on the honor role um somebody who's overcome EX time is up sorry sir next is Nicole guest followed by Holden Weir followed by Jack Weir good evening board members superintendent Morales staff and Community my name is Nicole guest and I'm a counselor at LC Allen High School first thank you to the members of the closure and consolidation committee who are assigned the undesirable task of recommending beloved schools to be closed second I'm here to advocate for keeping

042all high schools open please find other ways to save funds to keep these Cuts away from the students who are the closest to stepping out into the real world and the realities that that world brings last if you must close a high school please do not close LC Allen LC Allen students have many daily obstacles to overcome just to get to their school if their school closes these obstacles could very well become insurmountable for many of those students LC Allen students will bear the brunt of the negative consequences of their school closing on top of income in on top of the income disparities racial inequalities and discrimination that they already face every single day in the words of the great Martin Luther King Jr the time is always right to do what is right thank

043you thank you next is Holden Weir followed by Jack Weir followed by Lily Bray hello my name is Holden and I go to proor Terrace I'm able to to walk to school I will do this at Center Ros of middle as well not all kids have a ride to school and not all families will be able to get their kids further away school closures affect so many kids more than others so you shouldn't do it Proctor Terrace is really special to me but so is every other school to the kids that go there they cannot be ranked do what's right for our students in our town and do not close any schools there has to be another way to save money thank you next is Jack Weir followed by Lily Bray followed by Diego um

044aretta my name is Jack we and I am a seventh grader at Santa Rosa Middle I just played on the seventh grade basketball team and I'm not sure that the same opportunity will exist for me and my teammates if forced to move to another school we deserve all of the opportunities available for our growth and development and for me my name my main interest is sports for some kids sports is what helps them get through school and meet people that can alter their life I love my school and while I want to fight for it I can't do just that I stand for our community and against any other school closures we deserve better we are your future the decision you make as a board on this issue will be your legacy so I ask

045you how do you want to be remembered thank you next is Lily Bray followed by Diego aretta followed by Shanti Cabana hi I'm Lily Bray a student at Montgomery I think you all know deep down that closing Monty is not the right thing to do Montgomery scores highest in academic performance English learner performance and attendance I know you have removed these factors from your ranking metrics but you have not removed them from your minds or your hearts Don't Close Your best performing School our IB program is invaluable my dream to earn an IB degree moved my family into this district and my neighborhood years ago please don't take this unique opportunity for me and hundreds of other students with the same dream now let's talk about those students we've been through some hard times we've

046been vulnerable and we've had to fight we've been knocked down and we got up again we have all been through the trenches together and we rose up as a family if you keep Monty open we will welcome any student from the district who decides to join our Monty family we will be inclusive and empathetic to students whose lives may be disrupted by their school closing our leadership team will welcome welcome them and our IB program will inspire them you've built something great with what Monty has become Don't Let It Go be proud of your work because it shows in every student there thank you all right next is Diego followed by Shanti Cabana followed by Chris Gunther madam president and members of the board and the general public I speak to you guys today not

047as an srhs student nor any student from any school from that matter but simply as a concerned citizen look at all these people right here who have come to show their support for each of their schools it hly makes me sad that even for one of the schools which I went to without threatening to shut them down I can't believe it honestly it honestly breaks my heart but not just for my former school but for every school I mean if we were able to survive fires a deadly pandemic and we've been able to come together and all this like whether you're from Sr J Monty Elsie like like it doesn't matter from which school you are from We're All Humans we're all here to support each other and now we've unfortunately we have come to

048the chance that two weeks it will be Judgment Day so we're now all on edge I simply ask you all that if there's any any alternate solution that no school neither middle Elementary or high school could be shut down I think everyone would be won ever won gain your trust again because this is not out of hatred for you guys we just simply love our community so much thank you thank you next is Shanti followed by Chris Gunter followed by Alexa Forester thank you superintendent Morales members of the board members of the district office teachers parents students and community members all present my name is Shanti Cavanaugh and I a parent at Montgomery High School a nurse and I'm an advocate for our whole Community I oppose closing Montgomery High School I also oppose closing

049ELC Allen High School my stance is save our public schools and make closures the very last thing you consider including at the middle and Elementary School level I do not trust the approach or decision-making process that the district has demonstrated up to this point I don't believe you can make these life-changing decisions that will harm our kids I don't think you're going to be able to do that thoughtfully in the next two weeks I also don't trust that the district has the expertise to implement dramatic changes in such a short turn turn turnaround time take closures off the table and reopen the budget conversations with full transparency um we are a growing number of parents teachers community members and students who will oppose any student Clos School closure um for all listening today I'm gathering

050a contact list so we can work together to oppose closures across the city and work on a solution that's going to work for everyone so um please consider all that we are saying today thanks thank you next is Chris Gunther followed by Alexa Forester followed by luria richer richer duli good evening everybody uh here's what we know for sure closing schools will cause harm the more schools the more harm Decades of research on school closures has demonstrated this here's what we don't know whether these school closures will actually solve the district's budget crisis yes we've been told how much these schools cost to operate and how big the budget Gap is but there's been no meaningful analysis of what will happen to enrollment nor what it will cost to run the district after implementation of

051the proposed closure of consolidation plans in light of this the idea that the district will be more fiscally solvent after these closures is entirely unsubstantiated during this Pro process we witnessed members of the citizens committee gallantly point this out and request the information they needed to make responsible recommendations in response they were told that the additional information was either beyond the scope of the committee's charge or not available again what we know is that school closures will be harmful especially to our City's most vulnerable communities what we don't know is whether these school closures will have anything close to the intended benefits or whether it will be worth the tremendous cost deciding to move forward with causing our students harm without adequate Assurance of benefit is a dereliction of Duty we've been told that the

052only way forward is school closures this is a false narrative whether or not you actually believe that the district has fed that this is the case next is Alexa Forester followed by Luccia richer duli followed by Angel Ortega hello board members I've spoken to you before about why I think it would be a horrible idea for you to close Montgomery I'm not going to repeat that I want to tell you today why I also think it's a horrible idea for you to close Elsie Allen or any of the other schools in our district I would like to read a portion of the abstract of a report completed in 2024 which I have printed for you if you'd like to see it published by Brown University studying the effect of school closures on those subjected to

053them the report is called the long shadow of school closures impacts students educational and labor market outcomes from the abstract the findings indicate that experiencing school closures results in disruptions in both test scores and behavior the study further finds decreases in postsecondary education ation attainment employment and earnings at ages 25 through 27 these impacts are particularly pronounced among students who subjected to closures in secondary education Hispanic students and those from originally low performing schools and economically disadvantaged families given the obvious and unjust harms that will be visited upon a select unlucky and entirely innocent subset of our students if you close any of our schools it is astounding to many of us in the public that you have not not demanded the administration work up at least one option that involves cutting 10% of the

054budget operating costs without closing any schools the least harmful least disruptive way to solve the district's shortfall is not to close any schools thank you thank you next is luria Richard duli followed by Angel Ortega followed by Risha Ruel uh good evening I'm am mon parents of two kids one is already in college and the other is a junior in IB Program uh I'll start with my punchline I think you can be a school board member school board that can be remembered for doing something wise which is not closing any of the high schools you proposed us some options to vote and they were really bad H the only option they would leave the school open the high schools open would be the 7 to 12 which is really risky financially and logistically so if

055you really have to implement something like that the uh committee last week suggested a different option which is start with a pilot program of 7 to 12 in one of the schools like LC Allen then during the first year you see how that works and if really is needed you implement that uh the following years in other schools um all the other options that were presented were really a financially and logistically logistical nightmare um so uh also please do not school do not close either Elie Allen or Monty because they serve the community well high school students have roots and they have been planning their college for or professional years closing their school can change their ability to fulfill their dreams for which they've been working hard and a final comment teacher C Monti are

056beloved and prepare students very well we are very GR your time is up next is Angel Ortega followed by Risha Ruel followed by Karen Sanders thank you for having me my name is Angel Ortega and I work and coach at LC Allen srcs has stated that It quotes remains unwavering in our heartfelt commitment to ensuring that every child regardless of their immigration status feels safe supported and welcomed in our schools to close any High School is already an inherently violent decision to close LC Allen after already closing our only feeder Middle School in South Santa Rosa would be criminal and no ccla was never a sustainable solution especially since its Charter has now been denied renewal not only do we need to say to serve our community's educational needs we're also a safe space for

057hundreds if not thousands of kids as the Trump Administration continues to villainize arrest and support people that look like me we must act to protect our kids if you close Elsie you're not only leaving a community vulnerable to state sponsored violence you're abandoning the very values you claim to uphold keep LC Allen open keep all high schools open shout out LSC Allen shout out Southwest Santa Rosa shout out Morland shout out basol Road thank you thank you next is Risha Rell followed by Karen Sanders followed by Arthur Herer as a concerned parent of a student at Montgomery High School and is somebody who cares deeply for all students in our district I'm frustrated and disappointed by the decision to consider school closures as the primary solution in addressing budget issues we've been told the main

058factors driving this decision are declining attendance reduced funding and overspending why aren't we exploring the options of schools of choice to boost attendance why are we exploring why kids are leaving our district why haven't surveys been conducted to engage the community to understand why families choose one school over another school why aren't we focusing on cost saving measures through centralized Services which could improve efficiency cut cost without closing schools closing schools will likely result in many families moving their children out of the district ultimately worsening the budget challenges instead of resolving them closing any High School in our district would have a devastating impact each school offers unique post-secondary tracks and students have specifically chosen their schools based on the opportunities provided for their future endeavors if Montgomery's C Clos you've already heard multiple times

059that the IB program is going to impact their future to be able to complete the requirements and would significantly impact their post-secondary goals this critical issue should have been fully considered before before schools were rated it was really disappointing to watch as a member of the the staff was talking to the thank you your time is up next is Karen Sanders followed by Arthur Herer followed by Christy boblet thank you to the new board members who volunteer to step in and make the tough decisions to create a solvent school district and an especially tough decision about closing a high school many of us are voters whose children graduated years ago but continue to vote for school bonds and paral taxes opting to close Montgomery in the middle of a $30 million renovation makes absolutely no

060sense and will likely and will likely cause us voters to refuse approving any more bonds or par parcel taxes in the future in addition uh Montgomery's academic scores and enrollment numbers clearly put it second on the closure list most of us don't want to see any high school close but at some point the school district is going to have to address the fact that about half of the student population at LC Allen is transferring to other districts that means about $7 million in annual Ada is leaving Santa Rosa city schools refusing to address the reasons for the outflux of students will put Santa Rosa city schools in this exact same position in the near future and this isn't happening just at the high schools this is happening across the board that is the Crux of

061the issue financially for this District thank you thank you next is Arthur Herer followed by Christy boblet followed by John Beckle hi I'm Arthur Herer I've been here before to speak in favor of keeping srhs open uh Beyond facilities such as the large Auditorium which was needed for this committee work um the shops and other facilities that cannot be duplicated at other campuses we have a central location in great diversity and special ed programs they're all reasons to keep srhs open tonight tonight though I'm happy to see you're looking outside the box and I want to support keeping all the high schools open our town though your numbers show it's not growing our town is growing look at the apartments and homes being built everywhere and if you have to close a high school now

062the next school board will be building one um it's more work for the do this spring to put together a 7 through 12 program but that's their job and it can and should be done thank you thank you next is Christy boblet followed by John Beckle followed by David Martin hello my name is Christy boblet and I have a parent of a ninth grader at Montgomery we live in Sebastapol and my son attends Montgomery High School as an interdistrict transfer student my son is African-American and one of the main reasons we drive to Monty each day is because of the rich diversity of the Montgomery Community for the first time in his life my son attends a school where he truly feels seen represented and supported this is a gift that has no price tag

063Montgomery is the most diverse High School in Santa Rosa and the staff and administration's commitment to supporting and empowering youth of color and students from underrepresented groups needs to be recognized through Montgomery's black student union and the amazing facilitators my son is able to celebrate share and explore his culture and get support in his journey as a black youth in Sonoma County being a student of color in Sonoma County is very challenging Montgomery acknowledges this and is finding ways to support success and create equity in the school and the district closing Montgomery would not only take away these supports from over 860 students from underrepresented groups but also increase the segregation along racial and socioeconomic lines in this remaining District high schools I fear what will happen to my sons and other students mental health

064at this school and their Community are ripped from them keep Montgomery and all of our high schools open thank you thank you next is John Beck doall followed by David Martin followed by Heather gral good evening I'm a Montgomery high school graduate 1971 but I am here to defend every High School not just mine even if I could give reasons why my school is the best it would be crazy thinking to believe there would be benefit in closing another closing a high school is the worst choice of the difficult choices closing a high school dissolves a community closing a high school cuts off the present from this Legacy closing a high school cuts off the past graduates from his present community all choices are better than the closing a high school there are excellent and

065season faculty who can tell you which of the difficult choices is the best choice and the committee I believe has been doing a great job in that process also thank you thank you next is David Martin followed by Heather gromb followed by David gr bomb I want to put out a different option for the board and public to consider the board has been given only two weeks to make a decision that and I say that that's not enough time start working the budget doing administrative Cuts special ed organ reorganizations combine some smaller schools move Ridgeway and look into options of freezing the new Administrative Building using those funds elsewhere use the time to start fundraising doing things like form magnet programs like a combined Language Academy here's the thing that's not been talked about if

066the budget goals are not met the world does not end the county might have to come take over the schools the state might eventually take over in several years but this option would give those involved time to truly look at all the options two weeks is not enough time take a pause please do anything you can to avoid closing a high school but if you must close a high school I ask that you do things in a rational way LC is by far the lowest in R school if you close Monty over LC you'll be displacing 70% more students you would be displacing more socially and economically disadvantaged students by closing Monty P numbers 800 LC students would be dispersed could be dispersed to rosand prep pioner Santa Rosa high and Monty much easier than

0671400 Monty students you would be wasting a brand new $27 million science building Monty also has a very well attended Athletic program and the IB Program cannot be moved as easily as that you try to make it sound thank you next is Heather gromb followed by David grun bomb followed by Carla wiking hello my name is Heather shagan grun bomb and I am the proud Montgomery parent of a 2024 graduate and a current sophomore as a taxpayer I voted for the bond measure to build the new building currently under construction on the Montgomery campus and speaking as a taxpayer it would be the most ludicrous misuse of District funds to construct a building and then never use it for the students it was intended for the IB program at Monty is unique to our district

068and the North Bay and do not mistake the fact that it is sight specific and not transferable did you know that next year every Junior at Montgomery will be taking some form of IB English that will more than double the amount of students enrolled in IB this program is not just for a select few it is a critical thinking program this is your choice to chance to vote to bring this community together people want to know if a 7 through 12 format will work I stand here as proof that it can be successful I graduated from a 7 through 12 format it works I'm fine where I'm from it's the norm high schools launch Futures this entire process has fractured our community the mental to this is taking on our students is immeasurable please do

069the right thing do not close Montgomery do not close any high schools thank you for your time thank you next is David grun bomb followed by Cara wiking followed by Riley Stiffler Weir hi my name is David Benjamin grun bomb I'm the father of a current sophomore and a recent graduate of Montgomery High School I'm also the composer of I love Santa Rosa the song I wrote after the fires to help keep our city together one of the lines for my song is we stand strong we stand together I've been seeing how this issue has been tearing the city apart look no further than the last two trustee meetings when all of us who are loyal to our individual high schools are holding up signs and shouting like we're in some warped version of Let's

070Make a Deal it's ridiculous it's ugly it's horrible it's not Santa Rosa we're putting our faith in you that you will support the 7 through 12 plan Ben Wolf mentioned that only some of the high schools will need to participate let me assure you you don't need to worry about Montgomery the Montgomery families are totally behind this yes it'll take work to assimilate everyone but we're determined to make it work we want to keep all high schools open trustees first of all we appreciate all you do but let me ask you one final question do you want everyone in San Rose hate you no I'll answer for you no so you're in you want to do the right thing you don't want everyone in Santa Ros to Hate You Please pass this 7 to through

07112 program we'll help you make it work we promise thank you thank you next is Carla wiking followed by Bry bryy Stiffler wear followed by Noel Tamba hello um I am the mother of a freshman at Montgomery but I also have two more coming down the pipe I would be more than happy to to have my current fifth grader go to Montgomery starting seventh grade um I love that idea I want you guys to understand that you are our elected officials and we are begging for you to fight for our kids you are the check against the administration you are their boss and we need you to act that way so what we're begging for you to do is really not just take the data that they're handing you and their assurance and run with

072it don't take it at face value check things for yourselves go back to them and ask them to come up with a better solution okay I know everyone is trying their best but it's strange to ask someone who got us into this trouble to fix it without some sort of backup plan you guys are that backup plan and we need that from you please please please do not ask the Montgomery students to celebrate breaking ground on a building and then never let them set foot inside of it it's heartbreaking stop tearing our city apart do not close any high schools I beg of you thank you thank you next is Briley Stiffler Weir followed by Noel Tamba followed by Patrick aeson my children are third generation Proctor terison Santa Rosa Middle School students but I

073stand here in solidarity for all of our schools and our community at large I reject the Narrative of this Administration I reject school closures and consolidation at this time I request that you closely examine the budget and find the sources of the 20 plus million in over expenditures that you've accured over the Year this is not due to a drop in enrollment it appears to be Financial mismanagement at its finest and if it in is in fact if it in fact is not then why has the district been remiss in providing this board with real numbers the district is giving this community only the illusion of inclusion with these committee meetings and theyve appeared to be a waste of the $1.5 million you budgeted for them not because of the effort put in by the

074committee members but because this committee was done too soon when others when you had other options but in the background of these meetings where we parents have forged a common Bond I'm hearing Amazing Ideas scenarios that far exceed those of this Administration thus far school closures are not the solution to this gross over overspending your rhetoric and scare tactics are harming our children and damaging our community the District needs to take accountability for this problem and not force you the board to balance a budget on the backs of the children you are elected to represent in a twoe time period I ask that you put a hold to the closure and consolidation of schools at this time you do not have the time needed to do it safely and equitably you will harm students and

075you will go against your mission stating that you ensure equable thank you your time is up next is Noel Tamba followed by Patrick aeson followed by by Dylan baitman I'm Noel Tamba at this point you guys have all received numerous emails and Communications for me regarding all of these topics um first of all I want to say that I fully support what Aaron Grady got up and said at the committee meeting on Monday and the fact that she abstained from making a vote tonight I'm here to also urge you to take a step back before you move forward there's new budget from the governor that is very favorable to the schools these numbers will provide a very different picture what the district is facing especially coupled with actual data the current data well you are

076not being provided with these updated numbers before you're making this decision it doesn't doesn't make any sense you guys should be given this and the decision to close schools should be a very very last resort the district should be working through the ratios of teachers to students to determine how they can cut back on Staffing at the district level then at the school level first and I realize that the number of students is dropping while our staffing levels have remained constant this should be figured out budgeted and determined losing the teachers is heartbreaking but losing an entire school is even harder the district should be providing an overlay with the new updated budget numbers to that to relook at all of this information prior to asking you guys to close a school we started with

077what should have been the last case scenario you are looking at closing Five schools and you're three 311 ratio you potentially don't have to do thank you your time is up next is Patrick aeson followed by Dylan baitman followed by anandi okubo hello my name is Patrick adeson and I'm a counseling enriched program teacher at LC Allen High School while I would love to tell you not to close Elsie and to tell you how great it is that's not why I'm here after the last board meeting I've had many great conversations with parents from Montgomery High School and we shared concerns and commiseration about the possibility of our respective schools closing in the last few months we've witnessed the passion that the students parents and teachers and Community have brought forward about these schools the

078greater local community has come out in defense of their own therefore I ask the board to consider not closing any high schools and to explore the 7 to2 option or other cost-saving options I don't end with your position but I hope that you can make a decision that causes the least harm possible thank you thank you next is Dylan baitman followed by anandi okubo followed by Wendy Aila hi I'm Dylan baitman I'm a junior at Montgomery High School and this is why I believe Montgomery shouldn't be shut down even though Montgomery has faced challenges in the past many families still continue to transfer their students to our school for the level of Education wide range of sports and extracurriculars we offer there has been immense amount of effort put into changing the atmosphere and climate

079at our school into an inclusive and kind one by starting our Fresh Start Club having open talks about school climate and providing more Mental Health Resources and mon as Montgomery continues to grow they are constructing a new building for classes logistically it would not make sense to close a school after just implementing reconstruction that would greatly benefit our class our campus by providing more room for classes and opportunities to start new programs one standout program that Montgomery has is the IB Program which me and 55% of the Junior and senior students are a part of yes the program can possibly be moved to a new school if Montgomery is shut down but in that event it would make it impossible for all of the IB kids to continue it on into the rest of their

080High School careers all of these students wouldn't be able to transfer to the one school that the IB program is moved to forcing some of them to end their IB education this year it would be devastating to the students to not be able to continue their IB careers where we G college level education preparation and credit overall just for my three years at Montgomery I have seen great change put into making our school a better place and provided with amazing opportunities that prepare me for my future all of us in Montgomery have put an immense amount of efforts to make our school a better place and it would be a shame to shut down after how much progress progress we have gained in such a little time thank you thank you next is anio Kubo

081followed by Wendy Aila followed by Courtney baitman hi State guidelines quote option should improve racial integration into the district consider race and ethnicity socioeconomic status and disproportionality I'm disappointed that only one Committee Member expressed concerns at the last meeting regarding the evident lack of data sourcing collection analysis application and the overall absence of data there was no Financial breakdown provided just one individual protested against the committee's recommendation also of utmost importance is that our immigrant brothers and sisters who have been silenced by fear tactics and recent political regression have been excluded from this decision alongside the indigenous groups and Rich cultural values that make our community the beautiful place it is our community has the power to be a beacon of safety even when the rest of the country faces challenges the decisions were devoid

082of humanity failed to incorporate evidence-based Solutions and that demonstrated a clear lack of financial literacy when our country's leadership threatens every marginalized group and undermines our democracy why are we not working tirelessly to create a safe and welcoming Community for our neighbors I urge you to take a step back make an informed and fair decision instead of rushing to cause avoidable suffering in the future of our entire Community for years to come if city leaders are unable to advocate for the community members they represent there are numerous civil rights organizations ready to step in and provide support thank you thank you next is Wendy of V followed by Courtney baitman followed by Sarah tristano hi all I just wanted to really come to you and appeal as parents I am a parent with two kids

083with special needs our kids were just moved to baella and now baella wants to chain wants to be closed or is is superly on the top tier of being closed I we had to tour four schools to find a good help ful place for our kids I my kids are like an alphabet soup of special needs and this is the only place where it feels like we are home our community doesn't care that my daughter has Down syndrome she's the mayor of the school our our community doesn't care that my son has CP and he's a little awkward because he's nine our community doesn't care they just know who they are and I just parent to parent please please don't close our school that loves our kids so much please don't I guess it's not

084a don't it's just be open because I haven't heard anything about what we're going to do with kids with special needs are my kids going to have to figure out what is even happening next year let alone I mean it took us months to really settle into a school and all of these kids were finally moved to baella just this last summer and now we're thinking about moving the program again to a school that looks like a prison it feels like kids with special needs are thank you your time is up thank you next is Courtney baitman followed by Sarah tristano followed by Megan Castillo hello my name is Courtney baitman and I'm a proud mother of a sophomore and a junior at Montgomery High School of course I'm here to advocate for Montgomery but

085I'm here to advocate for all of our high schools closing one of our high schools would mean that you are impacting the violence rate and impacting the dropout rate the 7th through 12th grade model is a viable model and I know all of our high schools are very open to helping making that work all of our high schools have viable and important programs that are unique to those campuses and those communities I know that those programs could possibly be moved to other high schools but you cannot guarantee that all of those students can continue with those programs especially the ones with the IB program they are planning that for their future all of our high school students are planning for their future careers and future educations and by closing any one of our high schools

086you will have a negative impact on their Futures thank you for your time thank you next is Sarah tristano followed by Megan Castillo followed by Heather Ashton black hi my name is Sarah tristano for you to know my two kids attend a high school that has not been recommended for closure but I feel this request is important I'm here to ask you the board to ask Lisa August to present you with financially viable hybrid solutions to not closing any high schools not one size fits all options at the December 16 consolidation committee there was an absolute ground swell from the community requesting that no high schools be closed it is now 7 and a half weeks later there are a lot of permutations but I have to believe that at this point Lisa August must

087have crunched the numbers and must know scenarios that could work and ones that don't if she hasn't crunched those numbers at this point then it will just confirm the community's suspicion true or not that everything has been massaged towards a 311 solution I know community members that have crunched the numbers I know Ben Wolf has crunched the numbers so I have to believe it's been done behind the scenes the consolidation committee tried their darnest to come up with thoughtful solutions to not closing any high schools during the very limited time they had to brainstorm on January 27th there were some great ideas but um none of the members knew if any of these solutions would actually help the bottom line it was very much the cart pulling the horse but absent beam provided concrete data

088on Solutions that's all they could do so please pause tonight don't just ask Lisa August peac mail questions about very certain scenarios instead ask her to provide two or three financially viable you your time is up that she's already identified thank you next we have Megan Castillo followed by Heather Ashton black followed by Brie Mattel thank you for the opportunity to speak tonight as a former Proctor terce tiger srms cougar and srhs panther I am deeply disappointed in the current state of our school district I convinced my husband to move back to Sonoma County ensuring him that our children would have an amazing educational experience just like I did so I enrolled my sons in Proctor thinking they'd have that same opportunity I've reconnected with multiple classmates whose kids are also attending that school and

089are friends and sharing classes now and now I'm staring down the face of telling them that may not be your reality I don't know if you'll be able to go to school with your friends next year and I have to explain that to my husband so I find the solution of closing schools unacceptable for a number of reasons um I'm deeply concerned about student safety I think as we all have been over the last couple of years and I don't see how a consolidation or closure in trans spring a bunch of kids around is going to help I'm also deeply concerned about uh the opportunity for these students being Consolidated to have uh the opportunity to participate in extracurricular activities or Sports there are a number of high schools cutting kids by the dozens because

090they don't have the opportunity already and now we're going to lessen that oh uh I would ask that you find a way to delay this decision until all solutions have been researched presented and considered this decision has too big big an impact on too many people to be made in haste you're asking school children to pay a debt that they did not incur these children did not mismanage the budget or lack the foresight to see this deficit coming your time is up next is Heather Ashton black followed by Brie Mattel followed by Maria kintana hi guys uh forgive me I don't have a written statement I didn't plan on speaking but I have a sort of multifaceted Viewpoint that perhaps is of use I'm a mom of two kids who went to later and now

091I go to Montgomery one's in the IB Program one's a football player I'm also uh the mom of somebody who wanted to start kindergarten next year but nobody's allowing kindergarten tours nobody can go uh nobody knows where they're going we're in walking distance from Brook Hill maybe uh and I also run three preschools um with a a bunch of kids who were hoping to start kindergarten and now everybody wants to stay in preschool or home school that's actually happening everybody is jumping from this District like we should probably do something with the money we put into it because everybody wants to leave um I'm also a mentor teacher for the California Mentor program of teacher training with JC and SSU and there's teachers who are tripping out on all of this too nobody wants to

092be here and that's a real bummer because this is a pretty great place to be um I Heard It suggested earlier that students who are in the IB Program now should maybe take steps so that they stay on track for next year but it's already affecting them whether or not they get to keep their program they're already feeling dissed for lack of better words they're feeling that what they do now doesn't matter um and I don't know if you're familiar with football players but putting two schools of football players together it's like throwing pits in a ring like I don't know how you're going to mix schools in that way so um I think we all just need to give the kids their place and let the grown-ups do their job thank you next is

093Bri Matel followed by Maria kintana followed by Amy Merkel hi my name is Briana Mattel and I'm a parent of a freshman at Montgomery and a sixth grader at the French American charter school and hopefully at later next year I believe the elephant in the room that needs to be addressed before we can even talk about closing a single school is the presence of outside District charter schools in our district from my data polls there's over 2,155 middle and high school students that are currently tending these schools within our district but not in our schools it it is not our population that is declining as much as these schools are attracting our students students if we close a middle or a high school we are balancing our budgets on the backs of the students many

094with less priv privilege who have stayed in District rather than the students who are leaving instead why don't we work to end the charters of these schools while also creating programs that attract these families back into our district and imagine Slater as an IB Middle School with the French program Comack as a stem medal School LC with its own Spanish emerging middle school and Santa Rosa Middle with an Arts Middle School rather than having K through 8 at a few campuses let's move to Middle Schools act and make actual middle schools that preserve them we can have a vision for Santa Rosa city schools when we start closing schools we are going to keep losing students and the vision will be lost thank you thank you next is Maria kintana followed by Amy Merkel followed

095by Jim Point High School High School hey I will be translating what Maria kintana said um my son is a student a senior student at Montgomery High School who has been um using transportation from Stony Point all the way to Montgomery um which shows the love he has for the Montgomery High School this has been happening for the last three years um he lost his father in 2020 and Montgomery has not only helped them but the staff the students and the principal have always treated him like a family um this has this just shows you how Montgomery um help has helped them um and he also helps a lot of students he also helps a lot of students that don't speak Spanish so that um is another reason why you guys shouldn't close Montgomery High

096School students like him can help others um be better thank you thank you next is Amy Merkel followed by Jim Ley followed by Tina Javier my name is Amy Merkel and I'm the parent of a sophomore at Monty and a seventh grader at Slater first off I would like to state that no matter what school you're here to represent we are all in this together I stand with all the families who are attending a school that has unfortunately been ranked to close this morning I visited the district office wow is that a nice space to get signatures on the inter District paperwork for two other districts that our daughter is willing to attend should Monty close as was stated by a member of the consolidation committee it is not a best practice to send students

097from a high performing School to a low performing school for numerous reasons I have heard from countless current and future Montgomery families that if Monte is closed they will be removing their children from the district I would like to see a show of hands of families here tonight that are exploring that possibility thank you other districts are advertising on social media that they are accepting in District transfers families have already had their entrance interviews with private schools students who will be seniors are exploring graduating early or enrolling at an online High School while also taking classes for free at srjc I've heard over and over that the district office is running scenarios in the background and I truly hope you have run the scenario of how inter District transfers will have an impact now and

098in the future thank you thank you next is Jim Ley followed by Tina Javier followed by Victoria triola thank you my name is Jim lety and I'm a proud parent of two LCL and alumni and I want speak to you tonight on the idea that all five high schools serve this community this is a high school district and high schools are part of the planning the housing the Workforce Development they're part of the local fabric that make our community they are a Gateway from childhood to adulthood and most important in the educational aspect for a high school district is having five viable high schools that serve all of our neighborhoods what I would like to thank is that there is a path forward and it is a painful path but there's a path forward where

099you do not close a high school there is a path forward where you have to make some difficult choices and some difficult Cuts but you can preserve how each of these communities is served by one of the five high schools for if you close one high school this year you will be closing another high school next year because you will lose more students than expected I hope the board can find a positive path forward after they've made these choices and bring us all back together invest in telling the truth about all these campuses breaking the misperceptions that are out there bringing these communities is not just as advocates defending their schools tonight but help us rebuild the relationships and be partners in this process to invest in education you have a high school district with

100professionals you have caring parents you have incredible students we can turn this page after you have to make this difficult Choice hopefully in the process forward you're looking at Santa Rosa as a whole and the RO they play thank you next is Tina Javier followed by Victoria triola followed by Merl Hayes I'm Tina Javier and have two kids at Albert f baella bellaa is more than just a school it's a vital part of our community providing programs in stem bi bilingual Pro education and a large special education program in three languages ASL Spanish and English Bella is safe with no concerns about needles or beer bottles being found on our campus we are not next to dangerous gang affiliated Parks have two exits to our school for safety and so much more has the committee

101superintendent Board of Trustees truly understood the community built at baella how many times have you visited ba before making the decision we're also concerned about the district's priorities teachers and classified staff are being cut while the District staff grows we can't even reach a live person on the phone at the district it feels our children's needs are being overlooked we need the cuts to be balanced most importantly we need our children's future to be top priority thank you thank you next is Victoria triola followed by Merl Hayes follow by John Ley hi Victoria triola Monty 85 um I also have a 2019 graduate and a current Junior at Monty and I've already submitted my letter and thank you trustee Jenkins for acknowledging that I appreciate that I had some talking points in mind um but

102them hearing everybody so I'm also a teacher I've been teaching for about 32 years um um and in my class when we hear something that we agree with we do this and I want to say that I really hear I see and I agree with everything that I've been hearing and what I'm hearing is they want you to look at alternative Solutions um that is the only path forward that I see honestly and um the one point that I came here to make orig was I also serve on the site council at Monty and this is my second year and what I have seen in the last two years under the leadership of April Santos and her admin team is phenomenal and the momentum that is now happening at Monty and to end that would

103just be a complete travesty because without her I have seen her lead this school and the and the way she teaches our children respect for themselves for our community thank you your time is up next is Merl Hayes followed by John Ley followed by Logan Ley good evening uh like to thank you for thinking out of the side of the box and listening to the community when we had the the dot session uh and and some of these suggestions came from that session uh I am here to support Elsy Allen Elsy Allen isn't just a number uh I've heard that you know say they will have this or they have that remember it's the only high school that does not have a fe feeder Junior High which does affect the numbers of Resident students kids

104like to go from Junior High into the high school with the friends that they made where they were sent since the Southwest students have been divided up into three different Junior highs so they want to go with their friends to the next high school so Elsy uh I'm there every week as an adviser I've spent 10 years as an adviser on the LC campus I've also been a volunteer in every other High School here in different programs over the years so I have been on every campus and have found outstanding students and programs in all the schools but my last 10 years has been at ELC I would like to just support the programs that are not transportable as been mentioned can Santa Rosa High School take 325 egg students can another school absorb 90

105dance students those are the intangibles that you're going to have to weigh when you make your selection and I would certainly say no high school is to be thank you your time is up next is John Ley followed by Logan Ley followed by Laura I'm so sorry how hi my name is John Ley I graduated Lon high school as Val Victorian in 2020 I want to start by first saying I don't think the district should close any High School Monty Elsie Hiner whatever every single high school should stay open each high school offers a different opportunities for their students that live near the high school at LC I was able to get to the University Center that allowed me to take SSU classes starting at 16 years old these SSU classes provided me more sort

106of Hands-On college experience than any AP or JC class ever did and so when you have to write that term paper that's 20 pages in one night I already had that SSU but I fear that if you close elsc that many students on the south side of town especially Southwest will no longer have really any presence from The District in their area because cook clothes and because ccla is having issues with their Ral the district will have no schools South of Highway 12 that are run by the district and I feel if you close LC Allen these students will go to annaly they will go to Rancho and we already have a lot of bleed to those districts we have more bleed to the rosand district which means that in a year we'll be back

107to the spot if not the year after because we're going to lose another 400 kids Rancho's right down the road if you live on the western edge like I do anal right down the road so we're going through Highway 12 in the morning or going up the Piner would take longer thank you your time is up thank you next is Logan Ley followed by Laura HP followed by chrisa cologne uh thank you uh uh I went to Elan as well so I'm here to come out and support a school but I also want to make sure that I come out and say that I hope the board when come to the decision they need to make um presents a plan that doesn't close any High School just I feel the district needs to be a

108priority of a high school district first especially because when it's coming to a kid's k through2 education I feel like the high school years are fundamental when they are choosing a college or choosing programs they're going into during the high school it's fundamentally when they're taking the next step from going from a kid to an adult I feel if you close any High School essentially is punting on or I feel it's punting on the kids who are at that High School get closed down because then like oh first two years you're here next two years you be might be busted around to somewhere else so also with that much uncertainty I'm unsure if kids will be wanting to stay in the district or would they want to sort of peel off the someone say or

109at at least I know that the boundaries I'll be in this boundary instead of somewhere else so I believe the best course would just to be not to close any High School it will just mess up the kids experience at their high school or any high school and it'll be just be better for thank you your time is up going on thank you next is Laura HP followed by chrisa Cole grave maybe followed by gosby I would like to start by just taking a couple of deep breaths anybody can join me I'm the proud mom of a junior at Montgomery High School and a proud mom of a graduate from Santa Rosa High School spent a lot of information lots of facts and figures but not all that speaks to the community that we have

110at Montgomery and the community that all of our wonderful high schools have my son has a team he has a track team he has cross country team if Monte closes they're going to be split up my son also has a band and Orchestra program if Monte closes they will will be split up Monty has Community Monty has inclusivity my son has special needs and is now an IB student something I never expected my son has friends this is community but I want to speak more broadly because I do not wish this on any student or any parent in Santa Rosa We Are One Santa Rosa we ser survived we survived the 2017 fires okay that was not your time is up and we need to consolidate school districts thank you next is chrisa Krave followed

111by Jeff gosby followed by Amy Ang hello my name is Kristen kve a voting and property tax ping citizen of Santa Rosa I attended comto junior high school and graduated from Piner High School my husband attended Cook Junior High School and graduated from Montgomery our kids attended Hidden Valley Santa Rosa Middle School and graduated from Montgomery I proudly worked at Montgomery for seven years and currently work at Hidden Valley for the last 10 and a half years I'm proud I'm proud of the history of these institutions and all of our Santa Rosa city schools we are locals unlike many of our Santa Rosa District officials I'm disappoint disappointed Ed to learn that Omar is not present due to recusing himself from a vote even a suspended athletic team player still sits on the bench when

112they can't play why are we not questioning the overspending by the district where is the audit where is the transparency you continue to spend and spend and spend no cutting the fat at the district office you rent fancy Office Buildings with high security and new furniture you gave raises you couldn't afford this exploratory committee is expected to recommend closures with not enough information provided you cry low enrollment but you stole hundreds of your own students to form charter schools to the detriment of those who do not attend them at the end of the day we are here for the kids our kids are losing their safe places due to your overspending thank you next is Jeff gosby followed by Amy Ang followed by Katherine Howell my name is Jeff gosby I'm a lifelong resident in

113product of Santa Rosa public schools as are my three kids and I'm here tonight as a longtime Trustee of the rinken valley Union School District and on behalf of our entire board I want to address public comments made by your staff at numerous School closure town halls and public meetings in January and February that Santa Rosa city schools has not been able to consider consolidation withal local feeder districts including tk8 and 68 options because feeder districts including Rick and Valley have passed resolutions to refuse to speak with or otherwise cooperate with San Ros City Schools while some small feeder districts did pass such resolutions Rank and Valley Union School District considered but refused to pass such a resolution as our trustees are unanimous that we have always been open to discussions with San Rosa city

114schools and do not want to limit options for changes that could benefit our shared students family staff and Community rinka Valley's District leadership and trustees remain open to such discussions but have never been approached by anyone from Santa Rosa city schools as you make your decisions about school closures and especially afterwards we hope you will encourage your staff to reach out to your feeder districts including riken Valley to explore and collaborate on long-term Solutions it's misleading and confusing to the public to state that we have refused and are unwilling to work with you when we have never been approached thank you next is Amy Ang followed by Katherine Howell followed by Tanya Hoffman good evening my name is Amy Ing and my son is a junior at Montgomery last night along with a group of

115parents I organized our senior night for our boys basketball team this memorable event will be occurring this week at all of the high schools my fifth grade daughter was inspired to one day soon join the Montgomery cheer and dance team last night I left the gym feeling so overwhelmed and sad thinking that my son may not have a Montgomery senior night changing schools coaches and teams will have a life-altering impact on athletes who are looking to play Collegiate Sports this is true for all high schools a Additionally you will likely lose many student athletes who currently attend Santa Rosa city schools additionally my son is in multiple IB classes and has worked incredibly hard to continue these classes next year to earn the IB recognition and be able to take the test after two rigorous

116years of work as you heard this is not offered at any other school and is not easily moved it is a philosophy of teaching that are amazing Montgomery teachers have been trained in and have offered to so many students I ask that you do not close any High School due to the long-term negative effects it will have on so many students thank you for your time thank you next is Katherine Howell followed by Tanya Hoffman followed by Anna Ramirez uh good evening Katherine Howell SRTA President also a member of the closure and consolidation committee um so I have a lot of hats and a lot of representing a lot of people but I want to start by representing myself as a middle school teacher in this district for the last 25 years I have and

117many of our Middle School teachers have grave concern about the 712 model we are not convinced that it is good for our students and more importantly we will need some convincing that it can actually get pulled off in a way that makes sense for our students and their families and the teachers by August that's not something we believe can really happen um on a wider scale the teachers are really concerned about the budget in this District we're not convinced this is going to help we're not seeing the Outreach to uh the families to find out what they want are they really going to buy into this 712 model we're not convinced that that's going on we're worried about budget spending and where that's going to lead us in a year in two years are we

118going to be right back here with a deficit that we still need to solve so all of those things combined I don't have any uh miracle cure but I'm asking this board be leaders make decisions harm as few people as you possibly can and realize that any decision you make will damage this community thank you next is Tanya Hoffman followed by Anna Ramirez followed by Anna V hope good evening Tanya Hoffman I'm a parent of a fourth grader and sixth grader at Proctor Terrace I'd like to speak to the board and District administrators regarding the positive opportunity that this pending restructuring of school system of our school system will provide I'm hoping that the district administrators and the experienced educators will see the value in introducing more rigorous programming to our schools students and parents

119don't want less challenge we don't want less programming we don't want Less hours less staff Santa Rosa families want more from their public education system I beg the board to ask of our district what is the district doing to ensure that every school has attractive programming that's compelling compelling programming for our youth that wants our family are you know attracted to the families that want to bring have their kids go there what efforts has the district made to consider magnet programs what research has a district made to actually look at other districts that are successful in the nation maybe in the state with even less of a budget same population even less what kind of research has been done in that regard so I'm hoping that you guys can look at this as a good

120Rich opportunity to really be creative and really kind of think outside of the box and think about each school as kind of an attractive opportunity to really make it something that people want to go to thank you thank you next is Anna Ramirez followed by Anna VI hope followed by Haley Javier for for okay so this decision that you guys are making is affecting all the schools not only the school that my daughter is in um Albert ba School the school um baella shouldn't close because we have an amazing gynasium um other schools other elementary schools might not have we also count with the sorry um with the food bank that helps helps feed 80 families including people with no families um that have no students there at the school it would also affect our

121students with uh special needs and students that need um help language help um English language help we also have a good neighborhood sorry with less vandalism um we also have less traffic in our school uh we also have a lot of um parking available and we just received a new a new playground that will help our students with special needs um we also have space to add more building if it's necessary we are the only school that is new um most of our new students um or students that walk to school so please don't close baella school um or other any other school the families in our school are very United and we have many events that have um that get yes that um get funds for to help the school and our families um

122that is how the school helps each other thank you thank you next is Anna VA hope followed by Haley Javier followed by Mia Bower hello I am Anna Valia hope and as of Monday I was actually part of the consolidation committee as well um but I'm not coming here as that today today I'm a parent and I'm a Community member and I am that first and foremost and always have been so with that being said blo was at the top you heard heard by Bea parents it is true I also wanted to add that on the reports it says about um Portables the back Portables are actually on a foundation they cannot be moved they are ADA Compliant those are here to stay which means there are five Portables at the front that can be

123moved with that being said we have a huge population there that is um that is special needs and that is something that they they Thrive there we love it there um it's safe 455 seconds got it so as a community member and the business owner that you put me on for I understand that if something doesn't work you have to take a step back reevaluate and make it better you have a chance to do that now your public has spoken we have said what we've wanted to say please make the right decision in which campuses to close this is a business this is this is your clientele these are your customers there's too much at stake here to have them move they have options to move they can move move so please when you make

124these decisions keep us in mind cuz at this point there's too much competition and you always got to make it balanced you got to cut it from the top too I pay my employees last thank you thank you next is Haley Javier next is Haley Javier followed by Mia bowler followed by Heather gones and those are my last three blue cards so if there's anyone else that wants to give comment please fill out a blue card go ahead Haley I can say that as a former student of Albert fella and a current sophomore at SRS that these two schools have created such a great community and place for both children and teens I have two siblings who go to beella when they come home I hear nothing but fun things that they do in school

125I mean the other day my brother made an amazing nobaked cheesecake in his baking club and it was delicious the best thing about Vella though are the teachers and the staff they care about their students my sister's current prek teacher Mrs Winters is here and one of the best sixth grade teachers Mrs Evans is also here whom I still have a great connection with I remember having an amazing fun and better yet safe experience at bellaa but let's talk about Santa Rosa high now Santa Rosa High offers many opportunities for students with our art course program APN honors courses and our CTE programs as well Santa Rosa High Santa Rosa High's commitment to these programs ensures that our students are prepared for their Futures me included so please save Albert fella and Santa Rosa high

126thank you thank you next is Mia bowler followed by Heather gregonis hi my name is Mia bowler and I'm a proud parent of a Proctor Terrace kindergartener and Aunt to Proctor Terrace fourth and sixth graders we love Proctor and the community there especially the amazing teachers that our family has had the privilege to have I'm also a former member of the LC Allen High School foundation and I love that school so much obviously it's difficult for all of us to be here none of our high school none of our schools are expendable and I agree that it seems impossible to close any High School um and there have been many good points made by uh community members about Athletics academic programs and just the impact on current high school students but I also want to

127advocate for our elementary school and middle school students uh the feeders for our high schools uh strong beginning is important and I would urge you to reject any decision that unfairly shifts the burden of school closures or disruption on our youngest students there many of us Elementary parents who are very concerned about the prospect of 7 through 12 schools and I do wonder if that is in the best long-term interest of the district and our students or if it's more um of a creative solution to try to fix the immediate problem that we have I am in favor of preserving our middle schools I encourage you to look at Creative Solutions that minimize the number of schools closed and actually show a vision for the future of Santa Rosa city schools and lastly just before

128you vote I encourage all of you to and I know you're working at this but to be as informed as possible to ask all of the questions have answers to all of the questions that have been posed today so that before you vote to close any school you know that you can believe with full conviction that you made the thank you your time is up thank you next is Heather gregonis followed by Jonathan Moco hi thank you for being here tonight um as much as I respect the sentiments and agree with the sentiments regarding the importance of keep keeping all of the high schools and how valuable they are for our community I disagree that a nearly across theboard 7 to2 model is the right option whatever model or combination of models is chosen I

129advocate for one where our middle schoolers stay or have the option to stay in an environment tailored to their academic and emotional development need developmental needs what I remember from the town halls and the survey that followed the most stickered option was the 311 none of us like the idea of a 311 but I suspect that many of us um who voted this way is because we were not comfortable with the 7 through 12 Arguments for retaining middle schools have been plentiful at other meetings and in articles in our Press Democrat and have been whispered between almost the entirety of parents that I know in our district only those with children already in high school seem to be comfortable with the 7 to 12 model please don't push my daughter into high school next year

130when the district is ill-prepared for this level of change we all but especially kids at middle school age need to be seen and feel seen to grow in an environment that develops confidence this is a challenging age with lots of changes where you feel like you're under a microscope in a giant crowded school where the sheer number of students dwarfs prior experience at our small elementaries with all the newness that comes with secondary education this is a bridge too far and I fear we would sacrifice the youngers for our current high schoolers as I advocate for Middle School I stress that no high school should close into next is Jonathan Moco followed by Erica leanovich hello Jonathan Moko uh teacher here at CA Rosa high school and I actually wanted to take this moment to

131be another voice for the middle schools that are out there and how wonderful they are I know they aren't here in uh in mass as much because we tend as a community member to grab on to our high schools but the students are prepared for those high schools because of our middle schools uh myself and Miss Bell and other teachers last uh last year traveled to C Middle School to see what they were doing and some of the great successes we're having at Santa Rosa High School this year were direct copies from Santa Rosa Middle School ask teachers in the high school level how even though we're all credential to teach secondary how many of them are ready to go teach middle schoolers they're going to run out of the room it's the least confident

132thing that you'll get the least confident thing you'll get from a group of teachers facing a classroom full of 13year olds they may not be here they may not be loud but those schools are absolutely necessary to the student development and our facilities are not prepared for a 7 to2 model we don't have locker rooms for them we don't have gym space for them we don't have classrooms to segregate them the way everybody envisions this this is not Utopia so let's not force something that will make things even worse thank you thank you next is Erica leanovich hi everyone Erica leonovich I wasn't going to say anything but I just had to um I wanted to tell the board myself that I am so excited about the idea of um reconfiguring our district into a

1337 through 12 model I've done a lot of research I've looked at it I've looked at schools um if anybody wants a breakdown one of my awesome friends came up with a awesome spreadsheet that looks at all of the different 7 through 12s in districts that look very similar to ours demographic socioeconomic Etc that have excellent dashboards greens and blues across the board it's amazing it looks awesome my I've spoken a lot at these meetings um some of you may know that my husband actually went to Santa Rosa High School go Panthers um but it unfortunately it's not one of the ones that it's slated to look at 7 through 12 so now I'm sitting here wondering if maybe in in many years when my kids are out of TK in first grade first grade

134whether or not I might actually be sending my kids to Montgomery or or maybe Piner or even Elsie I really I mean it's just such a beautiful model I I like to see the positive in in human nature see the positive in our community and I think if we as a community stand together and say yes this is going to be hard yes they're going to be growing pains but if it keeps our high schools open I'm willing to put that work in starting now and I will be there volunteering to make 7 through 12 happen even though my kids are not there so thank thank you next is Liliana Santiago followed by good evening my name is Liliana Santiago I'm mother of a beautiful seven yearold um who's attending bellaa and I want to

135tell you that in the short life of my little one he7 he has attended three schools already finally he got settled at v um uh with a special needs cover he is social emotional academically it would be so sad and so shocking for him to be moved again baa is a school that has a lot of community with special needs please consider that and I know everyone here has a story everyone here is you know trying to defend their schools and I'm just wondering is this the best we can handle this is this the best way we can we can manage uh to to to manage the funds Administration are we willing to take less and to invest Less in our kids are we not pushing to get more I mean I I know you're

136doing the best you can but I wonder if we can do better and I guess we can I know we can right thank you so much thank you next is so on hello my name is SAA am I firmly believe that Elsa Allen High School needs to stay open our high school has developed an incredible sense of love and Community many of us worked through and overcame a plethora of personal and academic obstacles so let's remember to support and protect and have equity for our V vulnerable communities please don't break the family we have at L Al high school once a lobo always a lobo thank you thank you are there any more blue cards all right then this public hearing is now closed um the board will now take a short break before coming

137back with questions and discussion e e e everyone could please take your seats we're going to resume the meeting all right this is now an opportunity for the board members to ask questions of our presenters um we'll do questions first and then go into some discussion and hopefully give some guidance to our district team um trustees any questions trustee delator thank you very much for your time thank you for your time and efforts with the committee to get us to this point of the process c um it's much appreciated what I'd like to know from the committee is is there any particular criteria that you felt you may not have got enough information on that you would like this board to be considering um for our part of the process yeah so I you know

138there was and Allison can weigh in on this as well with her thoughts my perspective from the committee is that we received obviously quite a bit of data but the data um as many people know was drawn from you had to make a line in the sand so for example enrollment numbers um transfer rates uh even the criteria 14 15 16 with respect to academics was based on a timeline and in some cases that data just because the limitations of the process were based on certified State data which maybe was a year or two old from today's data potentially so I think from um much of the many of the committee members that would be one area that would be potentially worth looking additionally into is refreshed numbers with respect to enrollment or transfer rates

139um in particular I know that a couple board members were um wanting more updated transfer information to the extent that it's available uh to pull that report um kind of current year past couple months just again looking at the sustainability of choice in terms of risking attrition that was a question that came up thank you both very much for that um and this is just a reminder to the community that this is is a process and this is now our turn on the process to make sure that all these questions are being asked and that we're taking the valued input of the committee and then putting more input in to try and make this very difficult decision as correctly as possible other questions trustey Jenkins so can we get that information I guess would be

140the next question or Friday or whenever so what I'm doing sorry that was that's okay I we end up fighting with the with the remote or the the um microphones so what we're what I'm doing right now is making a list for my team of all there most of them are watching so that we can make sure that we're we've been working on a lot of this but the additional asks we're working on our list right now to bring for for the study session as much information as as we can so the more specific um the request more helpful it is for us if I can add one additional piece of um data as I'm looking through the criteria um just to further answer that question with respect to the uh dollar amounts the cost

141for projected savings when sites were closed specifically the numbers that we received um in general were with the Assumption if a site were to close those students and uh would be Consolidated to other sites and that site would be closed down um in totality what was not easy to tease out of those numbers if for examp example a middle school were to close and those students were to be Consolidated onto a 7 through 12 program on a high school campus those dollar savings would be different than what we had presented so that's just another area where it's St we just didn't have as far as if you were to close one Middle School consolidate them onto a high school the dollar savings would be different than the numbers that we were um presented with because

142of the assumptions into it trusty dtor very good point um Ben and those numbers are going to be asked specifically by a lot of these board members I'm sure um but while we're on the student numbers um Miss Aus if you can please also ensure that we get as accurate as possible up to-date numbers for enrollment um I really am curious about what our um 7 through 12 enrollment is and our K through six enrollment is and if we have the ability to break that down for campus so we can see actual numbers opposed to last year's numbers or other data that wasn't verified yet um that'd be very helpful with this process trusty Jenkins um I when I was looking through this there were revised pages that had that information in it is that

143correct um I did see the the enrollment for 2425 as well as the updated enrollment for last year's the whatever the correct term is certified qual um the the calpads the seabed certified data yes so there was a bit of a a difference between the numbers originally and then the certified and then this year's enrollment it's very interesting there's different Trends than that I than I personally expected thank you for that yes thank you trusty money are go for it okay I warned warned my peers on this board that I had 15 questions um for this team coming into this conversation so if there aren't any more um I'll just go through them um my first question is around data what population Trend data informed your recommendations so we've been talking a lot about not

144just declining enrollment but future trends for district and how many school aged children we can expect to see in our district and we've heard a lot of conversation around development so what um what population Trend data informed your recommendations yeah I was just trying to look up which criteria it was but there uh within the um demographics and capacity data set that we received there were um projections with respect to uh housing developments in particular so looking at housing devel developments across the community and their relative location distance-wise to the various campuses with projections going out to the uh 2029 30 school year um regarding estimations so there was demographer that came in to provide those data sets so that was informed one at least one of the criteria that was in here and those

145data were included thank you I think maybe to clarify what what was the source of that data where were we getting those numbers from so that was from the um consultant that did our demographic study for the facilities master plan through Keen Consulting and so at the time of that he did reach out and he did reach out again to verify change you know where the difference was as far as because there were some delays and some housing starts we didn't see the number of students come from those housing um developments that we had expected especially from some of the multif family units and so he did look into that before coming in and speaking to the committee thank you that answered my question um the next question I had uh could you explain your

146methodology for calculating facility capacity particularly how you accounted for specialized programs with lower class size ratios so again that's through our facilities Master planning process so that that was the information that was presented to the board um through um qka um Rel related to that facilities Master planning when that was approved so to to go back through that I I yeah and the intent of my question is to understand how these spaces might have been weighed differently from standard classroom sizes in Your Capacity calculations so part of that has to do you have the standard that as the state who looks at okay every 960 square feet is a classroom regardless of what the actual configuration is and for us what we staff at is maybe a little bit different especially we're looking at a

147specialized program so some of your vocational programs or your special education classes things of that nature so it it really is program dependent for some of those capacities and that is reflected in the in this report in the data that was looked at yes so if you look at there there's because you'll see there are different numbers and so it's based on okay what's a state number versus our internal numbers on the way that we staff got it thank you um my next question is did the Committee conduct a formal student impact analysis similar to what attorney general bont outlined in his guidance um if not well what alternative process did you use to evaluate impacts on special student populations particularly English Learners and students with disabilities sorry it's I'm sure it's my ears I'm

148having a hard time understanding the full breath of your question and the and not the not the um a meaning but the actual words so could you just repeat it sorry thank you did the Committee conduct a formal student impact analysis similar to what attorney general bont outlined in his guidance and if not what alternative process did you use to evaluate impacts on special student populations particularly English Learners and students with disabilities no the for really what that was was the information in the demographics that was pulled and the way that school Services you know advised us as far as how you the um demographic study information is looked at there was a lot of discussion amongst the members of the committee who had um and reason for selecting the way that we did um

149for for the committee the representation specifically looking at okay what are the impacts of say large um concentrations of special education students at to particular schools um you know Lincoln and baella have because of Decline and this is something that happens regularly in districts when you have declining enrollment you have open space so you tend to have a concentration of either English Learners or special um education students placed there because of space availability what that does is takes them out of their local residents you know attending develop with their typically developing peers or their um you know English only um peers things of that nature you don't have the same um ability to integrate that into their into their residents area so it wasn't a formal evaluation but it was a a deep dive um

150discussion into those impacts and and really that that's not really the best practice is to concentrate students at a particular site but rather that they should that we should have classes at each of their local schools um for the general education um population so it sounds like we didn't really have like a systemic way of evaluating we didn't have any Equity criteria in this process we didn't okay no that would be if there's a specific area that the board is asking for additional information on we looked at the demographics and kind of the impacts but no if there's additional information that the board would like that's what we would be bringing back to with that request yeah I think I would like to make that request um I'd like to understand the kind of demographic

151distribution across our district and how um any of the recommendations or proposals affect our demographic makeup of our schools please so Dr uh bardelli is working on that piece and some of the information that that we will have on Friday um yeah sorry I was just gonna follow up briefly with one additional thing that from the uh unduplicated student population and the demographics those were in there within some of the criteria so they were discussed and there was discussion around them but yeah not not the formal study I think that you're referring to and specific to Southwest Santa Rosa and we've heard already the impacts of closing the only public Middle School in the area and how that's really affected enrollment um and attrition to our only High School in in the area and so

152I'm wondering if this analysis and this process accounted for these historical changes um and if your data um took into cons into consideration the cumulative impact of these past changes um if they were integrated into the recommendations that were brought forward in this report we were able to review historical enrollment data going back to 2016 so that predates the closure of the feeder for LC Allen um so we did look at that data and take it into consideration and thinking about um viability of the site in terms of enrollment yeah and I think additionally even aside from just the data from a discussion perspective uh there was extensive discussion around the impact of the closure of um the feeder school for LC Allen in particular and uh that was in the discussions when we were

153weighing the different options with the high schools as well as alternative scenarios so yeah I I think the committee was very aware of that impact and the history some of the history around that great thank you um moving on to my financial questions um if we were to not close any High School what would it take in order for us to still meet our budget uh s to meet our our numbers sorry for a lack of a better word phce so it would mean that's one of the things that we need to look at is specific schools um and what that and what that impact would be because each school has an actual different dollar amount so we do have one of the things that we will be looking at on Friday is actually different

154configurations of that Dr belli's been running you know he's amazing with the way that that he is able to make to run scenarios based on if this then that um so we do have that information to that we can look at some scenarios on Friday so specifically if we're looking at not closing high schools what other combinations looking at the Al I'm looking to make sure I'm on the right track with where we're going is looking at the alternative scenarios um recommended by the committee so maybe some out of the box not all the same thing across the board so if I'm understanding are you wanting to look at 712 at all schools or are you looking at the combination that as recommended by the committee so that we head in the right direction for

155those numbers so I'm I'm asking for clarification are we looking for seven through 12 only or I mean I have my thoughts right that's a board decision so I'll wait for other board members to chim in thank you I had a quick follow-up question um because I have heard so many numbers now is what what is our number currently I've heard as low as 11 and I've heard as high as 16 and a half so the combination between all reductions between school closures and staff reductions so the combination is close to 20 million the remainder is from other things in in budget reductions so a combination between school closures district office staff our Central Support Services it's whatever combination that looks like it will be from a variety of sources so it's not one specific

156okay in the budget we did assume 125 from school closures but some of that is also reflected in Support Services it it's it's not a flat this or that it's really a combination overall what did you say the number was so in the original budget was 125 was 1.5 million last year assumed from closure of one elementary school so from our budget study session in November when we looked at the fiscal stabilization plan it was adding another 11 million so it was a total of 125 but then we also have Staffing reductions that go on top of that what I'm hearing is that the combin what we have to meet is 20 million but that is not all going to happen through school closures there are other measures that we're taking cuts to the district

157office so Central support services that are also going to make up the remainder of of those 20 million it's not going to all be 20 million Cuts in schools correct okay one additional follow up to the cost question they're just from the committee perspective maybe to clarify the altern one of the alternative scenarios here to get to that cost number and the caveat here again is like I was saying earlier the cost numbers that the committee was working with were based on site closure not necessarily a move to um another site but the um scenario the alternative scenario of keeping all high schools open which would put seven and Eights on some of the high school campuses is um really hinged on the Ridgeway campus the Ridgeway site and being able to um achieve some

158savings by moving that site onto an existing high school so uh I think the recommendation from the committee to the board would be to investigate what additional savings could be realized from the Ridgeway consolidation onto a site uh seven and eights onto some sites which would then be maybe two middle schools maybe three or four elementaries and that whole scenario would build into that so that was maybe a little more context around the alternative scenario trusty deor I know director manary has a lot of other questions and I wanted to get to them but I just I don't want to walk away from this quite yet what exactly are you going to need by the end of the night from us to make sure your team has direction to get the proper numbers um is

159it just looking at the recommendations from the committee are we offering other recommendations um obviously you guys don't have time and resources to look at everything under the Sun so we are trying to narrow this down but I want to be very clear what you need from us tonight for Direction so your team has proper direction to do the work that's needed so again the if there are specific combinations that you want us to look at to come prepared with that's great we do have the ability to run some scenarios with you know a program that that Dr bardelli has created that has some kind of canned information in there but as far as getting that updated information into into there we'll be able to get you better information on that um once we have

160more specifics so again if we're looking at moving if you have a preference for us to look at exploring large elementary schools and more closures there or um you know which would be obviously um the only two middle schools that would work for that would be comto and or Santa Rosa Middle so if that's the desire then that would look at more Elementary closures outside of probably you know to make that work I will I will share that boundary wise with the where students live it would mean looking at different schools rather than those that are necessarily in the top one or two tiers there would be some different combinations there so we're looking at those things based on the direction that that we have from the board for what you'd like to see trusty

161Casten so I I have additional questions but following up on um the net savings that's net so if we say we want to move to a different model but these are the programs that we need to do that would make moving to that model be done well we would need to account for that with additional savings correct and some of the things that that we need you know to to take into consideration is when we're talking about a closure what programs because a closure of a site may or may not mean closure of programs so if there are particular programs that you're looking for financials on that's much different than looking at a site as a whole and and what that looks like moving so those types of things as far as priority programs for

162um preservation or movement or re or reimagination would be are those are helpful so you're looking for us tonight and through the rest of these to provide Direction and feedback not just on what we see as consolidation and reduction opportunities but also where we believe investment would need to be made to make our schools better yes absolutely I I I think that that's extremely helpful when we're looking at how because if we remember why we're if we think keep in mind why we're doing this it's to make sure that we are restructuring and right sizing our district for the future not just with the number of locations but the programs and and our offerings and our configuration and then how do we support those so so that all is very key to us bringing you

163real numbers that make that make sense um for what what we will need in order to to focus those res resource resources most effectively thank you I have additional questions but if truste Mani was still going I don't want to interrupt her y I have my questions kind of sectioned off by category so if we have more financial questions then um my NE my next question is on the sorry this mic is even less useful all right uh for the assumptions for the cost savings for the sites uh my saying is it's based of a percentage within that assumption uh can you identify the elements of consideration specifically loss of attendance because folks won't transfer to one of our schools um and the other things that make up the Assumption on the actual savings from

164closing a site so when we look at a if we're taking just a highlevel you know assumption so what we baked into basically when we were looking at the initial review in our fiscal stabilization plan if you remember that was okay to provide direction to the committee as far as to to look for what you know the combination and then it really depends on where we go from there for implementation there are two very different things so the the Assumption in you know the large pictures we'd be looking at a 40% savings and that's in a combination of operating costs and Staffing um or you know Supply you know just all of all of that stuff and when we were looking at that that was specifically from unrestricted funds so the costs that are listed

165on there for running a school that was listed as the unrestricted so not looking at your maintenance and operations budget that's you know your 81 8100 you know your your restricted 3% of the budget which naturally will have to decrease as we reduce our budget amount um so there's that you have different um supplemental and concentration Grant funded positions or title funded positions special education all of those things are outside of that 40% saving so it could be an increased cost or a decreased cost depending you know there may be a restricted program that actually it with a reduction or a change could result in a reduction in cost to the unrestricted based on the amount of contribution needed or match or things like that so it's it's not a straight this for that it

166really comes down to the specifics of what we're moving and and and what that looks like but with within the Assumption we're assuming we're maintaining a certain level of current Revenue which is fundamentally current attendance uh I'm assuming that we didn't assume 100% so what within the Assumption just for the model what percentage of retaining of attendance did we assume for that savings so at this point we have not adjusted attendance projections um we look at where our current rates are which will depend on you know what we what we think this is going to look like so we can make some assumptions based on prior closures and what that loss has been that's where it really comes down to being very strategic that we you know I that we maybe don't recommend closure of

167a site that's really easy for kids to go right down the street to another to another District school um there are things like that that really will play into what those what those projections are now we already had projected a loss of enrollment going going forward that's part of why we are looking at at these reductions is because we are projecting in all of our multi-year projections that continued loss uh of enrollment so thank you and for the committee members um first off thank you for your service I know this hasn't been Pleasant and it's been very long and um I appreciate you both and all of those that served with you uh so thank you for that the proposal of um 712 and I'm specifically thinking of LC right now that also contemplates the

168creation or reestablishment of a fifth Middle School um map within our current map to what extent when you were looking at the data um would that impact the de the 78 demand in the Slater Montgomery and Piner comps in the other areas of the city where those students would be would have a new 78 area to go to was that a part of the committee's discussion yeah I think um so yes that was part of the discussion is the the short answer but looking in particular at Elsie and the fact that there isn't a natural feeder Middle School in that area of the the city and currently those kids are out of District or going other places or split up um the discussion around looking at LC as a potential site for adding 78 specifically

169was to recreate a middle school in that part of town to be able to receive those kids and have that natural feeder through so that was yes it's very much part of the part of the discussion and and looking at that how would that impact the usage of the current middle school campuses um as as far as what you see for um uh space room needs for those other uh campuses with the creation of a fifth Middle School area I'll take a stab at this so so in looking at the projections it there were no concerns raised around in say the far out projections was 2930 that um having a 7212 model on the LC canas based on the projections would cause a problem um it didn't seem like it would breach capacity uh based

170on the projections that we were presented with is that what you're is that what you're trying to get at or am my misunderstanding the question so I think if if I'm understanding your question correctly it really has to do with boundaries and that I I think and correct me Comm you know um if I if I'm wrong here that really the consideration was not just an addition of a of another Middle School boundary but really maybe more a redrawing of some boundaries and maybe it's a combination of closures of other middle schools or it wasn't I I don't think that there was that that far down the the road so this is just an example um we were under the understanding that the boundaries would need to be redrawn in any closure scenario consolidation scenario

171that that would um need to happen to reconfigure um turned off uh so when we were looking at scenarios and we were discussing it um we didn't we we did look at geography and and as uh Lisa mentioned that might impact or affect the order of ranking for say middle school closures if certain schools in proximity added a 78 doesn't make sense to have the closest Middle School be the one still open so it there is a cascading effect that you'll find in the report um that talks about what would happen if say LC went 712 and Piner went 712 versus Slater or Montgomery going 712 so there are a couple considerations that are built into the report and the information from Dr bardelli when we look at the at the boundaries we C we

172can look at those configurations if what I'm saying so correct me if I'm wrong but it sounds like there is a desire from the board for us to look at some configurations of 7 through 12 as we're that next so um before before I state that I have one last question uh before we move into comments and requests to move forward uh the committee was recommending the potential moving of uh the Ridgeway alternative education program I I understand part of the context of that is potentially going to another campus and incorporating it did the committee look at the concept of moving it to a location where it could expand and offer um that style of Education not just for 11th and 12th graders but for uh all high school and potentially all middle and high

173school yeah just to clarify as your question so yeah we were we were speaking about consolidating Ridgeway more or less the program as it is onto an existing campus you're asking did we look at expanding it and having it be more of an opportunity that specifically no I don't think the committee specifically discussed the expansion of of Ridgeway in particular what we did discuss was uh and it's part of the recommendation for the board look at the programs that do attract students or have weight lists are are impacted and find ways to double down on those and ways to expand those programs and so uh potentially that is one to look at as well but we didn't specifically look at that expansion and my very last question and uh it we've talked about charters in

174multiple directions so can we clarify the existing Charter renewal process which is not a part of this process with the contemplation of policies impacting out of District Charter and those things which could be a part of this so right now we don't have control over what happens with any of the charters aside from our own dependent Charters um that are operating outside outside of um or inside of our district however there are renewal processes and so it when they come up for Renewal they will their Charters will have to make a determination as to how they want to proceed which could be right now you have a combination of dependent and independent Charters and so they would I would expect that we may receive um petitions from some this board may receive some petitions for

175Charters and so there are only seven criteria or seven reasons that a charter can be denied and one of those is Financial impact however there's an appeal process for that as well so it's I I would not say that the um what would happen with other charters in the future is a consideration for I I think that we need to keep it in mind but it's not a cart blanch that they can be denied there there's a process to go through and and so I don't believe that we can count on the outcome of that it's something that we need to consider and plan for in our you know have a contingency plan for for what happens um one thing I will say is that and this is not I I want to be clear

176that this is not me advocating that we need to close more sites or it or anything of that nature closing sites is is hard it is much easier to open a new site after a site has been closed and surplused because of the way that the model works just from the state it it's an easier process to add buildings or sites than it is to go through the closure and Disposal or to continue operating something to the point where you can no longer support it Ju Just to be really clear about the charter aspect of the question the chart that I've seen is that all of the dependent charters and all of the out of District Charters and all of the non-public Charters have a renewal date that is either 2026 or later yes the

177um if I recall the only one that had a renewal of 25 was not um it was through right Charter and the or right district and they decided not to renew it right so for everyone that's the timeline for that that was my last question thank you trusty dor so a couple budget questions um I'm going to ask this just because it's been asked a lot and it needs to be asked so it can be answered in public record um you've done a phenomenal job I appreciate you is there 10% of our budget available be cut and operating costs so I will share that the majority of our of our costs are in Staffing over 80% of our budget is spent on Staffing and so to think that okay the remainder of that so you're

178talking textbooks um you know all of you know keeping the lights on all of those things it's incredibly difficult to think that there would be 10% of the overall operating budget that could be reduced from all of those things without Staffing the majority of our staff is at the school sites um you know I I I absolutely understand the the reaction you know the visceral reaction to saying that we're out here asking for school closures I want to be very clear and remind that it's not that we are only looking at school closures it's that we've asked for the community's input on how those on what those closures look like what the impacts to sites look like because that's where they are impacted the most that's where students are impacted the most it's our job

179to figure out where we can where we can cut outside of the sites and still provide a level of service to those sites because regardless there still has to be the food served on campus there has to be materials that make it to the sites we have to have maintenance staff and custodial staff to take care of things we have to make sure our bills get paid Aid and that we have properly credentialed teachers all of those things and that we're compliant there's there's a big part of it is reporting and compliance so there's all those you know unsexy things that don't directly impact students that's that still have to happen and yes we are making Cuts in those areas but we still have to be able to meet the needs of our sites and

180and that's something that is not obvious to the public when we're present what what a school closure looks like it's those un those underlying things that the public doesn't see I appreciate that response and I want to remind the public that this District started making Cuts last year to Staffing this is a discussion that does not just start this school year so um we are trying to get ahead of this um the next budget question does the state's current protected budget change anything significantly enough so yes um it actually is about a half a percent less in the cola the cost of living adjustment so budget um the adopted budget from the state included a 2.93% projection for next year for budget and the governor's budget update projects a 2.46% there is a proposal for

181um some discretionary one-time funds but again that's exactly why us and many other districts are in this situation now is because ongoing costs have been paid for with one-time funds and so there's still no guarantee there's not enough information about that there's some questions about constitutionality of that um of the way that they are um proposing to structure those onetime funds um we have been provided you know I was just at a budget Workshop the other day with Capital advisor sharing you know kind of what should you include what shouldn't you include and it is there may be additional one-time funds don't count on additional ongoing funds and remember it's a half a percent less so while yes it looks good for schools in that we are protected from Cuts there's not Cuts projected to

182us that doesn't mean that we're seeing the large increases that we were or a lot of discretionary funds I think it's really important in the public to hear that answer because um we are trying to make this very difficult decision now so that we're not continuing to have to do this year after year we want to do this now we want to do this as correctly as possible and we're trying to avoid having to do this again next year um my last question um before we move on to other trustees is about a program is there a way to get verification on if any of the IB program is actually transferable to another campus or not because that verification would be really important for our decision Mak so I would actually if Dr Castro is

183here I would defer um to him to be able to answer I know that his team has been okay all right thank you um I I'm not sure what you mean by verification so we're hearing several concerns from the community that if we were to close Montgomery then the partnership we have with the IB Program would not allow us to move that program and its credited teachers to another campus as a trustee that's going to make a decision on whether that campus gets closed or not it's a really important decision I need to be aware of if that's there's any viability to that or not as I presented I think twice to the scac um the school consolidation enclosure committee I provided documentation not from me directly from the international balate organization they have told

184us and in several conversations because we're in conversation with them at this point now almost every single day they have told us that um the transfer from one school to another is quite viable they have also given us an example a very specific precedent of students that are in the 2-year last two-year program Junior and seniors from the junior to the seniors um of a president of a similar District that had to close the high school and whose Juniors were able to graduate um when they transferred from one school to the other so in terms of viability my findings would show that there's nothing that would automatically mean the program would cease to exist in terms of the spec in terms of the specifics they're in the document that I provided thank you very much

185Dr Castro um I also like to just clarify on that so you were saying that the Cur there's been examples of current Juniors and seniors being able to complete their program I'm curious I'm just I I hear that you've had examples of Juniors and seniors being able to finish their program but I'm also curious if that means an IB Program would survive beyond our current enrolled students is it something we would be able to offer um for future students opposed to just who's currently enrolled yes that's correct that was our interpretation and like I said we are in continuous communication with them I think we as recently as yesterday Dr P is we we're in communication um with um the world senior manager of IB um and that is the information that we get as

186a matter of fact we've been communication with them so many times during the week to just try to verify this information the viability terms of guarantees um there is a list of criteria as one would expect moving any program whether it's IB or Avid we have dozens of programs that we look into and we have been looking into the viability of moving it's just like any program in terms of moving them from one space to another you have to look at I would like to ask for there to be a certain amount of respect please for people that are up here speaking thank you so just like any program I would um that when it's transferring from one um space to another they have to meet a certain um set of criteria and so we

187would have to definitely do that um as a part of this process we're also in communication with them because we'd like to expand it so but yes and that documentation is part of um the file that um the consolidation committee has the documentation that he was speaking of is included in last night's minutes or not Monday night's minutes they're actually the last two pages of the report trusty Kirby I uh I just want to first uh recognize uh Mr Wolf and and the rest of the committee for their fine work they did having been personally involved with one of those committies I understand the uh Blood Sweat and Tears that all of you put into this and uh it's much appreciated uh everything you did um I I've got some kind of specific questions just

188about the report itself um before I get some other stuff but um the capacity criteria when I read in there so just clarify that the Portables on all of our campuses the 210 Portables in the district are not counted in our capacity is that is that correct so not necessarily there are different pieces of the capacity there's the permanent capacity and there's the capacity so and th and there have been some changes due to construction happening this year that are not necessarily reflected in that that is part of the information that we will be bringing updated on Friday okay good that was my next question on that um and in particular I was looking uh the permanent number of classroom seats is in there can we also get the updated how many portable seats that

189we actually have in the district yes that's that's part of that information okay thank you because when we're talking about moving parts around and campuses I I want to make sure we've got the accurate information and people can fit where they are where we're trying to put them um all right next um I just wanted to have a quick discussion about the the criteria 14 15 and 16 since it was kind of a hot button issue um so the committee chose to go against the best practice and and exclude that data correct yes yes um and it seemed to be as I read through the report one of the reasons it said that the in regards to the equity it said that it may impact some of the school rankings did you guys find any

190evidence that it actually did impact that how did you determine the May was kind of vague so yeah and and I I guess I would say it was in intentionally vague because once the committee um came to consensus to remove those criteria we no longer included those criteria officially into the summations as we went through the process um however yes the data was presented the data is in there and the rankings for the um all the sites are in there with respect to criteria 14 15 and 16 and they did come up into discussion with um with the committee when we were initiating the deliberations and so they were not pulled back into some but pulled back into some I mean suum to sum sum up the total of the rankings that were pulled back

191in uh for discussion there as far as would they impact the um the scores from the peer rankings not significantly for all schools now if you looked at um certain schools there may be some flopping that would have happened with respect to them but uh as far as gross movements there W weren't significant impacts there um and in fact many of the cases wouldn't have impacted at all so you would have to go through and look at each site specifically add those back in and see but they it didn't dramatically swing it wouldn't have dramatically swing the um the scores so I I noticed um that you it says that the data the data for those criteria were presented to the committee but they were not included in this report not even as an addendum

192or any they should be in there as part of the as part part of the minutes or report from a specific um night if not they can't they can be accessed and provided to the to the board yeah so all of the notes um the agenda minutes the agenda and all of the presentations are all in the final thing 300 and something pages yes and that would have been the program meeting so I think it was meeting number four then okay I just wanted to make sure that that that data was available to the public if they wanted to go find it because it said it wasn't included in the report but it is actually in the report if you want to okay okay I just want to make sure clarify that I guess um

193okay then on the final ranking uh you're it said that when you guys broke up into the groups that some of the groups included uh they waited enrollment transfer transfer rates and fin Financial metrics and then some groups didn't so I wasn't clear on why some groups I guess followed the rules and some didn't so to speak when they came I can answer we we were broken into uh individual groups to facilitate more productive conversation around getting to a prioritization um getting to a ranking um and so it was a combination of maybe there was some misunderstanding in terms of um where people place the charters in the conversation but in terms of waiting the ranking I think that was part of the intent of you know as your table able to kind of rationalize

194how are you coming up with a ranking bringing it back to the group and in a very transparent way explain your thinking and come to some consensus on what the group The majority of the group agrees on appropriate ranking and appropriate weight Ju Just additional clarification on that as well I think in the process so remember in the the the scoring 24 of the criteria had the yes no basically the one or two um and those initial rankings down the board all all the committee members really started with that as the initial starting place so no waiting everything was an even weight with the one two scores and that kind of produced the first numbers in many cases those numbers were very close to each other between the schools and so then the next level

195of um resolution some groups went to discussion right away at the next level resolution looking at factors like location impact on community other specific factors and other um discussion went to looking at adding extra waiting to some of the criteria specifically that had the 1 through five or 1 through 13 uh resolution added to it and so that's where those the enrollment transfer rates and Financial metrics um I think it was criteria 1 for 24 and 25 specifically were pulled back in for those waiting uh being applied in there in some cases so it it was it was a mix of the discussion it wasn't at that point it wasn't a firm the entire committee came to a consensus around one approach there was a lot of discussion around the thought processes and then ended

196in the deliberations with the committee so that was um kind of the the intention was to have small productive group discussions and then report out to be able to say okay well yes the numbers are the numbers what's important to our com community and where what are the Unseen factors that that need to be considered like the special ed distribution you know things like that what are those impacts that you know are important to us and that's where it then led into that larger group discussion I would I would just add it I feel like it was a productive way to balance quantitative and qualitative analysis um that's that's all I would add okay thank you um and leading that leads into my next question kind of so when you list uh did the second

197tier of elementary schools um you guys chose to use the rank scores versus the uh Rel scores uh the 11 versus the and could you just clarify why you did it that way for that second tier yeah that that again for for better resolution if you look at the rank scores the the one two scores um for all of the sites or for those sites they were all really close to each other with respect to that so then we had to apply waiting and so um the discussion came to let's just use the the additional the additional uh r rank scores so the 1 through 13 for the elementaries that were added up in totality for all 11 as opposed to having additional discussion um about should we wait just criteria one or four or

19824 or 25 or we just decided to let's just apply the waiting as we had it um had discussed through all of our data acquisition meetings uh across the board so it was really it was a decision it was a way to further differentiate from the initial um non-weighted criteria I guess okay thank you um just got two more for now um Lisa I think you may have this already but you are going to get us the the kind of two different cost estimates for Ridgeway as far as moving it to a as a whole maybe to another campus and then there was talk about uh Distributing it to different campuses obviously the cost differences are probably if that's something that you'd like us to bring on Friday we can take a look at that

199um one of the things that I did um share with the committee is that often when you because of the nature of that type of school um it tends to have smaller class sizes and so the one school which is Piner that currently has a program like that it's their Grace program they choose to have larger class sizes and and structure their um their schedule differently in order to accommodate that within the sections that they're allocated if you if we're looking at allocate at doing that at other sites it could actually be an increased cost when you're looking at a staffing perspective of that so it it it may or may not actually reflect a cost savings but we will bring the the the data if that's in interest of the board and it looks

200like that is one piece that you'd like us to yes I would like to see both if we could that'd be great um and then lastly just I know we're talking about the overall budget and everything so so the assump one of the assumptions you're making with the the budget and the the money that we need to save is that still utilizing a 3% Reserve or are we trying to step that up so the re one of the reasons that you've heard different numbers as far as what we need to reduce really is because if we are only looking to get to that 3% we will always be in the situation of making Cuts we will not be in a in the position to be able to expand and you know have that that cushion

201for for when there is a downturn so the low end is meeting just barely our 3% um if you do if you look back to our first interim projection that included these reductions in there it does show that by the time that we get into that second and third year as long as we're aren't we aren't adding other things in as well then we're starting to increase that reserve a little bit over that that 3% so again it's we need to be very Mindful and the better that we plan strategically for how we um not how we get above just that minimum and my mic is on yeah that's weird I don't know it just is okay is that better okay um we have to be strategic in thinking into the future how how we

202meet not only that 3% but but make long-term sustainable changes so so is that one of the directions you kind of need tonight uh as far as what we as a board would like to see as a reserve is that one of the things that helps kind of determine some of the rest of the things that need to happen correct I would say that's always helpful to have that kind of Direction um where we would be looking at that specifically would be when so yes we can bring a combination of things to realize more than those savings and that may be a step into over multiple years rather than an all at once Band-Aid um ripping off because if if you think about the projections what we're looking at right now is okay how do

203we squeeze in for 25 26 and then still make sure that that we are cutting enough that as we get to that lower enrollment in 2930 we've made sub we've made substantial enough reductions over that period okay that's all I've got for now thanks jusy maner you had more questions yes I have a couple more um I'm very interested in understanding what process was in place to ensure all committee members had equal opportunity to contribute to the final recommendations particularly when there were disagreements um so my question is how are dissenting views captured and incorporated into this report um would it be possible to generate kind of a a Minority Report um so that we can see alternative viewpoints that maybe aren't reflected in this final report my my mind is turning but I don't

204know if I have a good answer try sure um so I don't have a great yes or no answer around can we generate that data um what I will say is uh you know having been on the uh minority side of a vote um you know they're definitely you know we were operating on the consensus model um and it was not a strictly you know yes you know here yes no abstain it was a consensus um we may have seen it we were doing the thumbs up thumbs down um there was one Committee Member who was very vo vocal and went on record with a dissenting view which um is recorded on Monday so that's I'm sure part of that transcript in terms of other minority uh opinions dissenting opinions we have the transcripts from

205all of the meetings we have uh when we would get into deliberation and have discourse over differing views that's all in the transcripts um so I guess theoretically it is feasible to go back through and pull out tease out that data if that's feels like the best use of resources um that's helpful that's my best uh that's kind of my answer for now want to add Ben yeah they I think um first of all in the discussions I think there were there were many there were many dissenting views expressed in the discussions um that didn't necessarily come out on you know maybe both sides or every side more than both sides there's many more than two sides on all of these discussion points so I I think um it would be very difficult to have

206a to get consensus on a minority Viewpoint I think we would end up getting would be multiple interviews from the committee members expressing different viewpoints I think it would be very difficult to come to a process to actually have one sustained dissenting view on this because there wasn't just two sides to it there are so many so many variables um through the discussion we could pick any any variable um and have discussion on it and have folks that maybe had minority Viewpoint with respect to any one of those variables so just I I think we had robust conversation I think we really tried to bring conversation out from folks that had dissenting views during the conversations um as far as putting that into a report I think would be challenging I would just add I

207think the best way that we found to capture dissenting views that felt um really relevant to your process was in some of the notes at the end of the report in terms of consideration uh for instance uh the consideration of being aware of special education populations in elementary schools um you know so there were some dissenting views that we tried to really capture in the notes as considerations that didn't quite they didn't make it as a strong recommendation and one other followup on this as I'm remembering through all the discussions and and um director Kirby maybe a little bit to your point as well around or question around the um tiers for the elementary schools in that second tier so the committee came to relatively quick consensus on the top tier those first three the

208next row down was very difficult and there were many many dissenting opinions I would say it was a collection of dissenting opinions um for that second tier which was very difficult and the committee was very close to not rec making any recommendation there and in the end the consens the consensus came to well from a qualitative perspective there's too many other factors here when you start looking at needing to close four or five or six elementaries it just becomes so complicated uh so the consensus was well let's use the the ranking system that we have here and be more quantitative about that tier and just draw a line um and and put that back to the board then so that was I think an example where there was much dissenting discussion and that dissenting discussion

209in a sense became the majority sorry I think Ben and I are reliving all the meetings as you're asking this question so it's coming to us as we're talking about it um I would just say also the tier for high schools the top tier for high schools that's definitely a reflection of like strong dissenting views so some of that is baked into the report when um in terms of what we ended up recommending maybe not aligning with what was asked of us I appreciate the response I mean often in qualitative data analysis things will emerge as themes and so I'm just kind of looking where in the report I can find these themes if it's in the considerations if they're baked in in other places um so I I really do appreciate appreciate the response

210I just um you know want to make sure that we're we're capturing different parts of the process and and not just kind of what came out on top as the most popular maybe um and so kind of my next question um actually I have a couple of questions for do Morales if that's okay one question do Morales um just going back to the criteria that the committee um ended up removing from the process um I understand you consulted with other districts to see if this um while maybe it's it's perceived as not com oh sorry I no worri U if it's you know I I know it's pered as not best practice to to remove but um uh just kind of wondering what you've learned from consultation with other districts so yes I've been um

211conversing with other superintendents that are also going through this process um I reached out to alen rock who is very similar to US 24 schools and they've um voted about a month and a half ago to close Six schools and so I asked him some of the questions that have been com coming up and they too um removed academic um achievement from theirs as well as um I was at a webinar at in a conference last week um where we had um a whole panel of superintendents who are also going through this process and they also mentioned that they have removed um academic achievement it tends to be an equity barrier and not allowing could be prejudicial as they as they share it in terms of not looking at students through just academics because it

212tends to be a focal point so I shared that with Stephanie and um and our one-on-one that we had this week and so she wanted me to share out it's what I've seen from other superintendant who are also going through through the same situation that we are and if I can maybe add to to thinking about part of the discussion that that we had because the the conversation about those criteria actually began with the organizational meeting so at the very beginning it was brought up as a concern and so what we did is we went we gathered the information and then brought it back at that other at the next meeting because it was the charge was what else do we have that we could that we could bring and use in Li of dashboard

213and because we hadn't implemented any um with Fidelity over a period of years um anything that showed a growth model for for tracking aside from you know the limited model on the dashboard I would say that that was a large part of the conversation had we been able to bring something that showed that growth model um versus a straight test score I I think that would have been a very different conversation with the committee I can add something to that it's what it's one of the reasons the state is now um not just having the dashboard but they've moved into a growth model on the dashboard so that districts can use the dashboard as a point that speaks to growth not just a number in you know in time um and so the dashboard will

214be now having a growth model when we do um the ed services team will be presenting to the board at the end of February our dashboard data and they just released the growth um model that we can use going forward so you'll learn more about what that growth model is in relation to the dashboard at the end of the month thank you I appreciate that response um my second question for you l Morales is um you know as as we consider these recommendations um and kind of different configurations and all wonderful ideas about how we can um transform our schools for for the better what do you see as the key opportunities and challenges in implementing these recommendations and can you share your vision for our District's future um and how these proposed changes or

215possible changes align with that Vision okay so this is me dreaming out loud um I remember the board makes all the decisions so in look listening to the 712 that has continued to surface since we brought them to to the town halls I've had conversations and I know Heather I got Heather's number because I wanted to have a conversation with her I had many parents that said I I did a 712 model and it was and it worked out fine obviously there's has to be systems and procedures and all of that in place but it is doable if we do that could we imagine a a way that we have really special specialized high schools if we keep them all by doing 712 really specialized model high schools where we invest in making sure that

216Piner has if Piner a steam school they're a steam school if you know um Maria kuo wants to be the the college prep school and we maybe invest in making them the a tech school um Napa has an amazing High School tech school that we can go and see I visited in previous years so how do we build those specialized programs I took down the names of all of the people that spoke and said let's redesign because that's what we need to do and so how do we do that collectively yes it's going to be painful because it will require us to close elementaries and potentially um middle schools in order to make this happen but let's think of it different I'm all about throw away the Box let's create something different because obviously what

217we have is is not working as effectively as we want it to work um I love the idea that someone mentioned um let's bring together services so that it's not spread out all over over the district um we have enrollment being done at every single school that makes us very inefficient and ineffective I've had conversations with parents at the Town Halls enrolling my student in this school is completely than enrolling my student in this other school isn't it the same district and so we there's a way of bringing together and doing an enrollment center we have the same issue with our English language Learners we have we our resources are spread out so thin that in all honesty we are not doing a great service and um being our students who are English Learners and

218our homeless youth how about if we have a newcomer Center bring it in our newcomer teachers and really serve those students for the first two or three years when they land and then do a warm handoff to the school that they're going to go to and really bring those resources together instead of continu spreading them apart um so I can dream I just want the board to dream with me and I'm going to reach out to all of you that say you want to do it let's do it together we can do it but we've got to get through this painful um um process and I've asked uh president mcnell to let me share a little bit more of what I can see us doing differently on our February 12th so my report that day

219will include a lot of what I'm saying today but there is I can see it on the other side and we can do it together so thank you that concludes all my questions trusty Jenkins and then trusty delator I have a few and one of them might be a little there's they're kind of a couple of them are piggybacks um and also just to kind of about the vision and stuff my concern is that by August we can't do all of this so a question for that is and this is my bigger question so I'll I'll come back to the other ones in just a second if we do not come to you with $12.5 million of school Cuts can the district find that elsewhere so the issue will be that so the answer is

220not a straight yes or no it's going it really takes okay which of these things that we've been working on for years with centralizing where do we have this combination of savings because we are already looking at $8 million outside of school Cuts in in staff reductions so there's those are already there I don't know I mean if we're talking a small amount yeah maybe we can make figure out some something you know I wish we could just do a little deferral like the state does from June to July and make it all better that's not the way it works for school districts they just get to do that to us um so it would depend um on on that because it's an always it's an everchanging number because again we have our projections we

221know what we expect and then we have areas where we see savings areas where we see different you know unexpected costs or less revenue or more Revenue there's all those different little pieces that shake out the issue isn't are we going to be say it it's slightly less than than 12 million and we don't make quite our 3% that's much different than we're out of money and we have a state takeover there are different levels to it so it's if we aren't able to quite get there but we have a plan that is that we aren't going to run out of money and we you know have an extra year where it's a small amount that we car over into that then that creates the qualified budget again you know is it next year or

222is it the year after where we have the problem it depends on when we have the problem in in the money that that really is is the answer to that um and there are again varying levels there's the multiple qualified budgets in a row there's a negative certification and there's a no cash issue so different levels of involvement between um an appointed advisor from say sco and involvement from fmat versus estate loan that then actually takes all of the you know basically negates any of your power and replaces our superintendent likely myself all that there there's there are varying degrees of it what we want to do to set the district up for success is make sure that we are meeting that that 3% is that's really what our charge is are there ways for

223us to work with that if we're at 2.75 that's probably a much different conversation than if we're at 1% because remember 3% is not even two weeks of payroll so that's that 3% is not an arbit it's it's a fairly arbitrary number it's it's written into code that that's what we're required to have but the reality is it's is whether we can pay our bills or not that's where the real problem comes in and if we are we're skating awfully close at that 3% if it's any less than that we run a real risk of aate of running out of cash which immediately triggers the state takeover okay I have a couple more um this one was mentioned the very beginning but I wanted to just make sure that it's said as far as the

224transfers in andout in inside of our district can we get more clear numbers like for instance when kids are transferring say out of Elsie or Monty where are they Landing if it's in our district or if it's not but specifically like it would be great to know why kids are going where they're going and I mean that's such a huge marketing thing going forward anyways um why kids are going where they're going why they're not going where they're going and then um paying very specific and this one did I lose it am I back I'm not back hold on stayed blue are you there hello hello uh oh I need yours I know it's not working oh there we go um and I I know that we probably cannot get this specific information right now

225but if we could get it going forward starting to get some data especially if Frank and Valley is um on board with things uh with our feeder districts specifically I get are we calling I don't know what we're calling them but the other districts in Santa Rosa the elementary school districts um finding out I mean a lot of them have 78 Charters which is concerning um but why they are choosing to stay in their Charter or why they are choosing to go to the schools they are whether it's with us or not but those those places those time frames where kids are entering our districts whether that be tkk 7th or 9th depending on the situation Gathering in that information is so incredibly important to then guide a vision at some point so um whatever

226amount of that information that you can get would be fantastic yes we can absolutely bring um the internal data that's a lot easier for for us to track the E the external data we have some of it but not with Fidelity because it's going to depend on where they've enrolled if they've gone you know overseas out of state if they've gone to a a um private school versus if they're in California in another public school we receive that information so it's very it's available to varying degrees and we can ab we absolutely um so we did do some Outreach this year related to that we my understanding is we had very um low a very low response rate as far as why people were leaving um and that's that's not unique to hear you know

227we I've tracked at other districts as well when people are leaving unless they're really upset they want you to know that they pretty much just don't tell you um that sometimes they do sometimes they don't we can't require it so it's again varying degrees but yes the information that we have available we will bring and in the future we do plan to get more of that data it is a little more difficult with having fewer staff to be able to to to track things as well so it's it's a that balance of what do we need to support and where do we focus the resources that that we have finish CL no it's on this too I just want to respond I just want to like respond to the complexity of this question too because

228like I personally know people who use addresses and other boundaries that they're not supposed to to get their kids to go to a certain school when they should really be going to their home school so I just want to kind of add to the that this data is so skewed for so many reasons and so if we get this and when we get this we have to be very careful about how we use this data to make decisions because it is so so skewed yeah and just a a quick um note for one I I want to clarify um because I appreciate very much um Mr goosby's um input in and conversation um what he had shared we're we're really talking about a couple of different things um one that he was speak that I

229shared was that when we went through the consolidation study that most of the districts that I was incorrect rck and Valley was not one of them that passed the resolution not not to explore consolidation so so that that is my error um but the consolidation study that was asked was about consolidating all districts and so there and the Outreach for that was not something that came directly from the district it was part of that consolidation study through Christy white so I just wanted to to clarify that and there's so Santa Rosa city schools has um we are not a unified district we are a common Administration District so we have not merged we didn't go through that process to create a whole new District if if we are talking about merging School schools with other

230districts it's a potential to be that col consolidation there's not aside from like this common Administration agreement the complexity of doing that is not something that we can't explore it it's just not something that's easily done within Ed the current Education Code so I wanted to clarify that that's where those statements are it's not that I don't know if that's helpful absolutely thank you um additionally is there any way that we can get numbers of of students within our districts who have applied for out of District transfers um in like the last couple months so if they have applied for that and brought the and we've processed the paperwork um I would defer to um director desider on on the tracking of that okay um I had another question about oh I'm sorry was there

231something was it going to be a thing already can you do that Miss desider and and if so we could bring it on Friday if it is available making a list of everything you need yeah I just wasn't sure if it was available you can bring perfect so um we have just opened the window for interred district transfers that is something that we traditionally do in the month of February um but when we process uh applications for families that um may be applying for a district whose window opens a little before ours or a little after we do track that information I did not bring that spreadsheet with me tonight but we'll have it for Friday for discussion purposes thank you um facilities so uh W to call people by their first names trusty Kirby

232um had asked about the Portables and I had gone through the sheets and the capacity with Portables versus without Portables and then permanent numbers um when going sheet to sheet and school to school looks like you remove the Portables and we're about flush how does that line up with permanent capacity so that would be the permanent cap capacity but when you think of where we're talking about also we're looking at remember 2930 and we have changes that that are are expected so yes if you remove remove all the Portables we may be we may have the right number of classrooms but that doesn't mean that we can staff appropriately spreading resources across it's not just about specific you know okay how many rooms do we have that's where you look at it's one of the

233reasons why we have so many combo classes at some school sites and just because it's flush across the district doesn't mean that it's flush sight to site with projected enrollment changes tricky yeah yeah no easy clear line you know path right there I wish it were that might have been it hold on one second oh miss August I had a question specifically because it was mentioned I am super curious um because you're you do crunch all these numbers and I don't know if this is something that you could talk about maybe Friday or another time but I am curious about the ones that would work the best number-wise um configurations and things of that sort that would be very uh interesting I from at least my perspective on what works best in your brain and

234and I that is some of what will the board will be able to look at on Friday I would say that you will receive varying opinions from different people on my team based on whether we're looking at it from a purely um general fund operating perspective versus a facilities cost perspective versus a logistics perspective so um those are my my team will be there on Friday to share some different views based based on your your requests I have one more I'm so sorry I just remember um because we had talked about the number I mean we're constantly talking about numbers but I'm wondering as far as is it possible to do a phase a phasing in because while I love the idea of 7 to 12 in certain circumstances logistically facilities ages kids across the

235board it's super scary um and so much and the facilities the shops in The Culinary departments um that aren't necessarily at the other the schools that they would be going to I'm wondering if there is a way to do a phasing system so that we have a solid plan and what do is that something that can be discussed like if we have a solid plan for how we're going to get there but not in August so that will depend on on what that looks like so phasing if we identify more schools you know and that okay here's what we need to have happen by August and then here's the stuff that needs to happen to be in the right place by 2930 then yes that's that that's something if we're looking at can we phase

236out a high school by grade that logistically would not be something that that we could recommend thank you you trusty deor thank you very much um thank you guys for hanging in here it's long night I know but obviously this is important so ultimately my number one priority and goal is to make these very difficult decisions with the least traumatic chaotic approach possible to our students families and teachers so that being said the city of Santa Rosa currently has 10 school districts we are two of them there are eight other feeder elementary school districts in the city of Santa Rosa so when I am considering elementary schools there is a potential a much higher potential of Landing spots for elementary students opposed to us being the only public high school 7 through 12 District in

237Santa Rosa so if we were to dismantle close our high schools we are then sending families out of the city of Santa Rosa they have a a couple Charter options that are really small they have a couple other districts down the highway but I think it's very important that we focus on the needs of the city and the student population and understanding that we currently have five high schools strategically placed within the city of Santa Rosa and is there a way that is feasible and will actually work to keep them open so that's going to be that's going to be really important for for us look at of the 7th through 12 model is that even feasible and possible if so what do the numbers look like here here and here um I understand the

238concerns being a parent and raising kids preschool through college of that 7 through 12 campus model have we actively looked at if it's possible for a 678 model to keep our middle schools and high schools often that makes a little more sense but I understand it might not work because of the elementary and high school but if our feeder districts are willing to work with us is it something that we can consider so the um the mention that that Mr gosby had earlier today is something that we will need to look into with legal counsel as far as whether it's something that would be allowable within the Ed code to look at kind of a it sounded you know just very basically it sounds almost like a swap of grade levels um so that to

239me is really a change in District B you know in boundaries between districts which is that's much more complicated um so that's something that we will need to get advice on so yeah if we get some clarification on that that'd be great because we need some answers these really important questions before we make the ultimate decision of how to move forward ultimately this all depends on what's actually feasible so I'm looking at facilities I'm looking to um our budget team on these recommendations are any of these even actual feasible for the next school year because there's a whole lot of work that has to happen between now and then and we're going to be in a study session on Friday and we need some answers and we need to be able to have more questions

240that we're going to have to ask to try and make the decision that is going to be the least traumatic possible for our students ultimately that's what we all want that's what everybody in this room wants that's why our community has been so vocal and active and we're so appreciative you coming to these meetings and having these opportunities to share your thoughts and opinions and send us emails the 7 through 12 model came out of multiple discussions with Town Hall meetings and brought to the committee I want us to be as Innovative and creative as possible I want our future Vision to be sustainable I I Envision s City Schools being a high school district that all the feeder students want to go to that High School this is the high school I wanted to

241go to because of this when I'm in fifth grade I'm on track to go to the school and once you get to the high school that high school is able to provide the opportunities and classrooms and teachers that make students want to go there ultimately that's the goal K through 12 amazing opportunities throughout the city for there is no greater value than a good public school system that we all need to work on collaboratively I spoke to 40 districts Monday night and put this plea out there and I'll be working with Dr Carter with st County Office of Education of how do we work collaboratively trusty gosby knows me very well worked with him for 19 years in rink Valley why are we operating as isolated silos with isolated information and talking about you versus

242me why are we not collaborating working together Transportation child care extracurriculars what can you provide what can I provide at elementary so that it waiting at high school and everybody wants to be involved Rusty Caston thank you I got two additional clarifying questions and then I'll also be ready to move to this discussion because it seems like we're slipping into that anyway um on on the clarifying questions Portables or uh non-permanent structures because they don't look very portable to me um are we leasing do we own what's the current status we have a combination of leased and and owned buildings and on the leases this is something that we've been working on for a while is wanting to get rid of the leased Portables first um wherever possible because some of those we've had for

243a very long time could have bought them multiple times over um and no they aren't coming out of our general fund in those lease payments but it still impacts you know funds that we would have available to redevelop you know other classrooms or or or things like that so it's a combination and it really varies um one thing that um I know Eric will be prepared um a little bit to talk about on Friday is that if we have to depending on the configuration if we need to add classrooms at a site um normally we would say okay we would temporarily bring in Portables while we look at the the permanent reconstruction with the fires in La it's very difficult to get Portables right now how so we would be looking at having to move

244Portables that we have so he's identifying looking to identify which sites would have if they're closed may have Portables that we could move logistically you know in the short in the short term so so that's a wrinkle that we were not expecting but related specifically to the fires so and in addition to being ready to speak to it if we could actually just have a Bight understanding of currently under lease owned um yeah for that conversation he he's working on that one right and and okay so I guess I had three clarifying questions I'll call this 1.5 after we go through this process we will need to revisit our Master facilities planned because we're going to be looking at reallocating bond funds in addition to things along this so can you just clarify ify a

245little bit about the timeline not big details but just the timeline for that yes he's actually depending on what the scenarios are there are some things that he's already looked at as far as okay if you know in general it's a you know whatever the configuration is that would then free up funds that would need to be redistributed between other sites and if you were to do look at the 712 model then what additional facilities would be needed and that's actually a very costly Bond number um so that that changes other things that can be done so those numbers are those different scenarios and and what if this then that is already being looked at as needs for the facilities Master Plan update um and where those funds would would need to be shifted it

246does not um it wouldn't take into account yet the fact that we would actually still need to then have some re-engagement about once we know what specific sites are we would need to do that update to the facility master plan and need to have new community engagement with that site perfect thank you and just to clarify when I'm looking at my computer screen because I have closed captioning going here because I can't hear anyone so um I'm not ignoring you I'm just reading what you're saying uh my second and last clarifying question retan trustee Jenkins question about phasing from a yes no perspective for the board yes we are able to lay out a plan that would say year one we want to do this year two we want to do that year three we

247want to do another thing but the consequences of it those choices are are where you're saying you would strongly advise us not to go there but it's not that we can't not unless it's that we are looking at so so I would advise from a fiscal perspective that we identify at least the minimum that is needed in this first year to have happen that that move happens but that there will be because we know there will be additional phases that need to happen such as we wouldn't just thinking from a programmatic from the from the recommendations from the committee and kind of what I believe I'm I'm kind of hearing over over the months as far as some priorities it doesn't sound like would be an appetite to actually close one of our language Charters

248however there may there we know that there needs to be physical movement of those neither of those have to physically move this upcoming year unless it's part of a change you know that's associated with the cost savings so that would be potentially a phased thing just as an example not that that's what would happen obviously it would take direction from the board but just those are the different scenarios that we're start that we're looking at with phasing is okay what are some things that could potentially wait or that need to happen regardless and do they need to happen this year next year the following year what does that timeline look like so in this process we can and likely will lay out a multi-year plan yes absolutely absolutely I I'm ready to move to discussion

249and stuff so I'll pass it back to the president question trusty Kirby and just a couple more follow-ups um so you mentioned 80% of our cost Staffing what percentage of that is the district I don't have that offand but our TP typically when you're looking at an because the way that it breaks it out I I I can bring that back to you on on Friday for for you to to see um but typically Administration is around 5 to 6% um you know but that's not yeah if we could get that just as an idea because yeah we're restricted and unrestricted so we we'll have more of a breakdown for you based on that because much of the many of the Departments are mainly restricted funded so so that's one of the the things to

250be aware of that that would be a great breakdown for us to look at because obviously we hear from the public a lot they want some shared sacrifice um absolutely from the district so um that's some are you going to be bringing some of that on Friday as well like your projected uh uh Department C uh Cuts like Personnel so we are we are trying to make sure that the cuts that we have identified that we have some meetings and conversations with people prior to them seeing necessarily their positions listed on on something publicly um so we're trying to be sens to that and also get you the the information as quickly as possible so I would ask if when we bring something forward that we identify maybe costs by Department rather than by specific

251positions you know that that type of thing unless there's an objection to that that makes sense um so along those same lines I know it's been brought up a bunch about the district uh headquarters so to speak um the administration um um can you publicly maybe address is it possible we've already talked about stopping the the current project and and it's been brought up several times is it is the district is it possible for the district to just rent existing office space somewhere in town and or sign some kind of short-term long-term lease in their current location rather than spending all the money for the new building sure that's actually um there are several pieces to unpack with that um and so the current office space that we are in is leased I think we

252have to be out of there in 2028 based on the way it is right now we did it's actually split up into a couple of different leases one is a subas that came furnished and so that's part of basically they left the Furnishings they left the technology all of that stuff there and we have it at an extremely discounted rate um so that's a a piece of it overall we looked at several different options um for those of you who who weren't on the board just as um some information the Portables at the district office that made up about 50% of the of the office space there were 70 years old 70 years old for for many of them we had they were not um we have yes we have a responsibility to provide safe

253spaces for our students we also as an employer have a responsibility to provide safe spaces to our employees and it was reaching the point where that was not the case um I will say it in that way and so there was a very urgent need for the for the move that occurred there are different phases to the dis to the district office there are different areas to it there's the warehouse and Central receiving which we it it was not serving the purpose it was actually two buildings combined and kind of mashed together which as were many of our other things were kind of frankensteined over the years um and we had actually losses and um of equipment of materials and things because of the lack of Maintenance um or funds that were directed toward Central

254Support over over the years um because of prioritizing schools as should be however there's that balance um and so you we you kind of reach a point of critical mass and so just as we are with our budget that's where we were with that facility and so we are in process right now of the construction of the replacement warehouse space and that's also where technology is housed you know there are lot lots of of pieces to that that will be up that will be finished sometime this this current year there there's no stopping that train and there's not anywhere else in within the district that would have worked for the type of facility and support that's needed for that when you say Warehouse I'm thinking like Warehouse how what are we talking about it it's

255a warehouse facility so it's a a a framed facility but there are offices in there as well because that's where our technology team is is H is going to be housed as well so rather than them um having office space in the in the district office that it's it makes more sense as far as the um workspace needs that they have in order to be able to Process Equipment and things like that to be actually in the warehouse so we're being very mind ful of how we construct and how we design to make sure that we're we're using things in the most effective way um we also had to move the data center out of the Portables right now it's currently housed in the Portables that will be moved into the warehouse so it's a

256multiphase thing so there's that piece of it the remainder is the office space and the boardroom and all of those things so right now we've paused aside from the work that we're doing with the with Architects because regardless of whether it's at that site or a School site or anything else we still will have to make Renovations and work with a design team so that piece is still in process as far as us selecting a team that mention that the bu building will also include classrooms yes so the the plan for the district office is not only the district office but it's also our 18 to 22 transition program so right now they're they were already on that shared space with us in and at 211 Ridgeway they're kind of right now in between Ridgeway

257High School and the do space So the plan in in all of these plans from the beginning has been to bring them actually into the district to give them some exposure to the work environment you know with that with that transition also helps us to stay more connected the original plan was to move the um to create a space for the um for our special education preschool um and some Head Start and all of that at the same in the same facility looking at the fact that we are closing elementary schools it makes more sense that that's very easily convertible for that space and more appropriate and you know cost savings compared to to building a new DSA standard class classroom set you know facility for for those um for those students so two very

258different things of needs by students versus what's needed in office space so one of the things that we would obviously be looking at is whether because the question comes up regularly should we you know should the district office just move into a school site and that really will depend at as we start looking at things it may seem counterintuitive that may be much more expensive for us to renovate a School site than it would be to actually build a a a space that that is designed for office space and if you're if you look at the proximity the location of that of that space compared to any of our school sites that are in different areas in the city it changes the functionality um for not only our community but for our staff in being

259able to collaborate and and be responsive and and available so there are a lot of different factors that the board ultimately will need to make a decision um we will you know after we have sites identified to actually say yes these would be viable we can run numbers and bring that information to you um but preliminarily it looks as if it would be much more expensive to convert a site than it would to to proceed with with the build building again that will depend the C the variance on that could be from a couple million dollars up to you know tens of million so so those are numbers that we'll need to run once we have act an actual site or sites to compare that to and that district office needs to be within the

260elementary boundaries if we're going to hold board meetings and things like that there so I know that that was a long answer to your to your question but it's not it it's a little complicated is it a question or just okay go ahead trusty Jenkins related to the facilities master plan um so is the whole thing GNA have to be redone is that kind of what I'm hearing because my concern around that is that while on S the safety advisory Round Table we had um you know got over those and the backlog was like before the fires because we've just had crisis after crisis after crisis so the concern with the question is that there are so many things that haven't that have been overlooked and I know that's in here number-wise um but how

261how are they going to capture all of it so it's it's not a complete redo of the facilities master plan it's an update so because there are already at each of our sites we've already had things identified and budgeted and so if we know that okay these are the sites that are closing those funds no longer need to go there they need to be redistributed and then we need to figure out what what does that look like and so there have already been um projects that have been identified as priorities districtwide that's that doesn't necessarily change so does that does that okay board if we're going to go past 10 o'cl we need a motion to extend trusty Caston I move to extend till 1:00 am and I hope we don't use it no I

262just say this because last time we did an extension till 11: and we had like five minutes of extra business to talk about so I would like to extend to a time that we will obviously not get to so we don't have to cut off one of us with five more minutes of conversation be had so that's why I make a ridiculous motion but I I I seriously do say let's extend to 1: a.m. so we don't run into the issue we did before of someone getting cut off because of a five minute arbitrary situation H how about midnight sure midnight I also hope you don't use that midnight is there a second sure our second all in favor say I opposition motion fails no it was wasn't that 33 no it's 3 three it

263was 3 three I saw I saw okay so it doesn't pass it's even it's 3 three you have to try it again it can't be the same motion I'm sorry I just been up too long today uh I make a motion that we extend the meeting to 11:45 all in favor say I I I opposed motion passes okay I would like to turn us towards discussion and I want to clarify our purpose here is to narrow things down for our staff um because they cannot possibly bring us crunch numbers on every single scenario um so you know for example looking at 7 through 12 do we want do we want to look at a pilot program at LC Allen that recaptures that 78 enrollment that we've lost do we want to close Comack and have

264712 at LC and P er do we want to close comto and Slater and have 712 at LC Piner and Montgomery these are the kinds of options sure go ahead so so may I um so if we have some general you know descriptions for or direction for this upcoming meeting we can get further into the details and bring back more I have a lot of Direction here as far as the types of information that you want to have available which is extremely helpful because we can um there are some things that we can run almost live not live but within a few minutes based on some scenarios if we have some basic ideas of okay we want to look at yes running the scenarios that the committee recommended as far as the 712 at the

265school sites we can come back with it would require probably the closure of these other things and then we might need some massaging from you on direction for that so I I just wanted to share it doesn't have to be super super specific but enough specifics that we can narrow some of that information that we're bringing thank you for clarifying all right uh trusty manieri and then trusty deor okay uh please let me know if you need any further guidance Lisa but this is kind of what I would like to see and board members can agree or not and we can kind of see if that moves forward um so I I also agree that we have a responsibility to keep the only public high schools in Santa Rosa open so I would like to

266see scenarios that keep all high schools open through a magnet not done thank you not done um but specifically looking at our schools through a magnet program model so I'm dreaming with Dr Morales here what are we doing to make sure our students know what they're getting at their high schools what are those Specialties what are those Niche things that our high schools do what are those identities that our students can see themselves reflected in and so really through that Pro that magnet Pro program magnet program model specialized program specialized programs sure is a different kind of a school we don't want to specialized program specialized programs I love it um I also want to see scenarios that pay special attention to special services at the elementary level like special education and special populations like

267children experiencing homelessness and eel I want to make sure that they whatever um movements we make where we are not having them bear the the burden of of these movements we know that they are the ones who are most vulnerable in this situation um I also want to see scenarios where ccla and srfax can expand their programming inside respective boundaries for grades so if the programming for elementary is going to continue then I would like to see those um reflected in scenarios within the elementary boundaries and then likewise for secondary seventh and eth for both um even if that means they're on the same campus or different campus however those scenarios might work out um I also want to see different scenarios for Ridgeway specifically I'd like a cost comparison between the distributed small school

268model um where you know folks were thinking they'd go back to their their kind of prospective high schools um versus relocating the entire continuation program to a single existing campus so I'd like to understand the the cost analysis behind that um can I get what I would like clarification on that are you looking for what was talked about earlier with an expansion or are uh of that into an alternative Ed type of site or or are you talking about um just trying to expand I guess that's about the about Ridgeway I well what I'm one of the recommendations right was to move rway right um and so there's kind of there are some ideas about how we might do that it as 11 through 12 on a campus versus Distributing to many to many sites

269or are we talking about the expansion that there was a question about think what she's trying to say the difference between sending them those classroom rooms back to their individual high schools or moving Ridgeway as a whole onto onto another high school not the expansion those are two different things not the expansion are we talking about like Having a Grace at every school exactly okay so distributed between the schools or just moved in its entirety to one school okay I was just going to say I thought director Casten wanted another a third version and looking at an expansion I believe is that correct so ultimately if we do a if we look at 7 through 12 models and we're talking about moving a continuation program could that be available for 7 through 12 students because

270currently it's just 9 through 12 and there are students that need that continuation model that we're not able to serve and if we can find opportunity to serve those students on our campuses that might really help them stay connected to their communities option from a process perspective do you want each of us to outline everything that we're asking for and then move to discussion or should we because I I'll hop in here and say what I'm thinking about for Ridgeway or I can wait and it for going down the line um discussion okay so yeah then looking at a 712 and specifically I'm thinking if we had in the 712 model for high school campuses what would it look like if we took one of our middle school campuses not in the Elementary District so

271Slater or ccla um and looked at that for um a expanded alternative continuing education model similar to what's currently at Ridgeway for those of you know that for those of you that know the S um strategic plan that was created a year and a half ago that was actually one of the recommendations from the start team was to have a small um they were thinking at that time high school so expanding Ridgeway to service those students that don't do well in a comprehensive but I'd love to see a 712 alternative to be able to keep our students who aren't thriving in the comprehensive Comprehensive High Schools so that's the third option that now we're going to look into thank additionally that was a approved by the board last year so that'd be great to get

272it going I also know that there are other ideas splitting out there too with the online school through um that mon Armory has proposed so kind of combining those things I want to jump in too because I have the mic um getting some numbers on the Comstock Monroe B Layman Lincoln area the idea about a DK through 8 um over there just kind of what that looks like as well as numbers on combinations of two of the four schools um because I know they all have different numbers attached to them and they all have very different situations um I had the in the rain over the weekend I went and explored all of the schools over there it was so much fun if you guys haven't done that do it um because there's so the

273schools are so unique um but having the numbers on that is would be great because I have opinions thanks justy delator so an emphasis continue to be making sure we're looking at those numbers on what a 7 through 12 would look like and just work keeping it General that way we can have those discussions on Friday in our study session of where will it actually work and if it does work there what are those costs and what are those savings by doing that um again another emphasis on paying attention to to our special ed students especially with a high concentration at be and Lincoln if those are schools that are be considered to be Consolidated or closed what is the landing plan for those students so that again the burden is not on those families

274they go search for another home um due to this displacement and is a k38 possible anywhere um I know we have boundary limits but is there a K3 possibility for any of our schools does it make sense in any of our boundaries so that we can look at that model and see if that might fit some of the schools that we need to consolidate um we do have um a responsibility to ensure that our marginalized Community students have opportunities to get a good education and if we can really stick to that um better edication opportunities are going to be provided throughout oh justy Caston missing the slight curve in our table um so so I think at first I just want to say that school consolidation reconfiguration re reimagining is a part of a bigger

275effort and a bigger crisis that we're dealing with and you know I just joined this is my third meeting with actual agenda items on it and one of the reasons that I joined was I felt that we hadn't been tackling the tough issues and in a lot of ways we haven't but that's not just Financial the financial issues that Force this conversation start with having quality programs that keep our students here and actually in our schools and in order to get to the place where we have quality programs we're going to need to make decisions about what we're investing in laying out the vision of what we want to do and then making sure we hold ourselves accountable to doing it well and so I say all this through the lens of our goal today

276isn't to lay out a process of closing schools our goal has to be how are we going to create excellent programs currently we do not have any empirical information to say that across this District we have excellent programs we don't have that in our dashboard in our scorecards for academics we don't have that when we look at M programs when we look at students leaving in order to access programs they can't access within our district and so we have to be looking to how we're going to solve that because if we close a campus and the students don't go to one of our other campuses we will have not saved any money so just fundamentally for me this has to end there with that said I want to acknowledge that that crisis is not our

277teachers our staff or our administrator responsibility I really view it as a responsibility of a failure of government and of us tackling hard conversations which we're starting to now I'm going to lay out some options they're going to be a little bit more detailed um some of them are mutually exclusive uh some of them are going to be tough choices if we go down that road and some of them will be really awesome if we could succeed and just recognize that we have at least two more meetings on this uh so I'm hoping to narrow it a bit bit today and then narrow it a lot Friday and then narrowed it even more on the 19th for but I do want to say flat out I'm not interested nor do I need additional information on

278a 311 um I don't see closing a high school as something that we need to continue studying looking at a 712 option um the way I see one of those potential working out with themes is a 712 option at Montgomery that would have a 712 IB Program because my understanding has currently only offered two grades uh so expanding the IB program to be 712 for its curriculum offerings and then also have the 712 French dual immersion component uh looking at ELC with a 712 Spanish immersion and then a Health Sciences Focus recognizing that SSU is in the process while they're cutting they're also expanding just like we're talking about doing and one of their expansions is in the Health Sciences for nursing physici assistants and so forth and if we can take our current transfer

279program with them and secure guaranteed entrance for our students into a health program there that would become a real magnet uh attraction uh for LC's campus I see Piner with a strong Focus leaning into the Sciences uh we already have spark they're already doing a lot there in a continuation of their uh JC magnet program though I'd like to see the administrative side of the magnet program helping with the paperwork of students being able to take JC classes be something that we actually offer districtwide um and have the transportation for the magnet at Piner continue but the whole thing where we help facilitate having to run back and forth from the campus to get the paperwork done that should be something that all of our students have access to uh looking at Santa Rosa high

280school and this gets to touches on elements of the Elementary programs I'd like to see what that looks like with the Arts and art Quest and kind of the Hands-On CTE components that are currently there and if we were to reinvest and restore some of the classes the Arts English classes and the things that have been taken away um as we look at when those things were taken away over the years we also see the drop in enrollment in art Quest there's a direct connection between the quality of our programs and students attending them so seeing how we can restore those efforts um and then also looking at um an opportunity for something totally new so I'll moonshot on this one but at Hidden Valley we have the dhh program There's an opportunity there for

281a 50 50 dual immersion program with ASL to give an access point for folks that are not dhh students but have siblings exist in the community to be actually able to learn that language as close to natively as you can with ASL um with that then being able to continue on to the JC campus and then the ASL program at the JC and then picking up where Dr Morales left off I would see koreo under this having to focus as a new Tech High and specifically when I'm looking at our neighboring districts that pull our students what are the offerings that our students are leaving for and the technology high is one of those offerings um it was it's cited and there's two other places that you can go to for it we don't have

282that available and cio's current success in the AP World I think would very much merge with an additional Focus around the tech high for this model I think it's also important we recognize costing out of adding freshman Athletics we lose students to all of our neighboring districts that offer freshman Sports Athletics and my understanding is in past years one of the reasons we weren't able to do that was because not all schools were able to field a freshman team if we're going 712 we could for those schools look at what a combined 89 uh freshman team would look like in order to be able to field freshman teams because they don't need to follow the same competitive um guidelines and rules as we have for our JV and our varsity teams uh also if we're

283recognizing themes we need to be okay with the fact that we're going to field teams in a sport that we can't field everywhere um but if there's interest on a campus we don't want students to leave the district because we didn't offer it um at the campus where the interest exists on the elementary level for this I'm okay actually the elementary things in some ways combined for both of the options we lay out so this next set of things will contradict some of the things I just said um but the I'd also like to see scenarios around what it would look like to have K12 specialty programs at LC with a relocation of ccla and whole to the LC campus at Montgomery with the relocation yeah SOC cannot be okay just to make sure but

284but that also pre uh there's also talking to the Local District about it so um I just want to look at this uh and then I want to look at a K12 option with Montgomery uh with a uh TK 12 option for French and for IB um International Bachelor curriculum programs are offered for threey olds up to 19y olds so is there an opportunity for a TK uh 12 12 IB program in the in the district with it all being loc on located on one campus um and then similarly what it would look like for the Arts Charter to be fully moved onto a tk12 program at s rosah High I know there's challenges with that it's mutually exclusive with what I was saying before but I think it's good for us to look at

285as comparisons and recognizing that some of that would require us to negotiate with other districts um and then lastly for the elementary schools not included in that batch um and then also the charters looking at what a scenario with the committee's recommendations of beella um Brook Hill and steel Consolidated uh to move to other campuses and in addition Leman so those four campuses consolidate um beella Leman Brook Hill and steel thank you so specifically two on the west two on the East it would leave two on the west two on the East and Burbank kind of right on the in the middle uh would be the remaining and with those Maps would look like if under that scenario and we are moving the we're doing the 72 model ccl's k6 program moving to commstock or

286S Rosa middle French Americans k6 program moving to Comstock or French or uh San Rosa middle and then there's seven eights moving respectively to where the current tracks are of dual immersion for Montgomery uh French and for LC Spanish so enabling those k6 programs to move to campuses where they could expand um similarly Arts Charter having their 78 moved to St rosah High and the k6 staying there and looking specifically at because all three of those schools have lotteries weight lists and students being turned away what those moves would enable for us to be able to admit those students and not reject them uh in future Years also recognizing that Charter money is samee money so if we were immediately able to accept those Lottery students and weight lless students through giving those schools more

287um space on those campuses what the additional Revenue um in Ada would look like because we have we do know that we've turned how many students we turned away and how many we could have taken if they had more space and then within that specifically looking at um The Early Learning Center moving from Lewis to Bell uh with the Bell campus also considered for Partnerships with Southwest Community Health's Pediatrics program similar to how we have their program on elsc and then also specifically for partnership with first five and four c's for the other uh the other elements of that program and then through all of that lastly um and and I don't think this is something we can solely answer in the consolidation Pro process but a very specific eye to having a reserve um

288currently the state is not funding their prop 98 Reserve uh one of the things that happens is that the state tells us we can't have a reserve above 10% unless they're not funding the prop 98 reserve and the reason is because the risk we face when they don't fund the prop 98 Reserve is that we're going to get same year and even possibly same quarter cuts and so if we're not doing our due diligence to have a reserve when the state's telling us oh hey we don't have a reserve um we could end up having to cut uh while we're executing and so we need to have a reserve that's going to enable us to do these things well because the other part of the crisis we're in is a crisis in a faith of

289confidence that we can actually do anything well and we need to change that and the only way we're going to do that is by doing it well I want to specifically say to the folks who have suggested that we just turn it over to the state into the county um I hear you I did not volunteer for this job to abdicate my responsibility to do this right so I don't consider turning it over the state an option not just because it's expensive and not just because it's going to result in all of us including members of the public from being excluded in the process but also because we as board members have a fiduciary responsibility to actually do this and we need to do it so those are my options uh Friday is going to

290be fun and um for folks that don't know what we're talking about when we reference Friday we're going to have a study session that's where we're heading towards where we're able to talk about more ideas we won't be making decisions there either but it's going to enable us all to talk without having to try and wave them wave each others down it's going to be public and then we'll be back at on the 19th for for another public meeting so thank you buy Jenkins I am also curious about moving accelerated to Arts to bump up their numbers because it's 56 combining the two yeah as far as collocating yes collocating thank you for the correct terminology so I missed some of trusty caston's comment but adding to what he said about doing things well um

291I'm I'm really interested in 7 through 12 I want to know what our options would be of how small we could start with it um like can we keep all high schools open if we're only starting with one 7 through 12 site or if we start with two if we start with 7 through 12 at LC and Piner and we Clos comto what else would we still have to do to keep all high schools open um because I I believe that creating those special I 7 through 12 programs could be that could be the Revolutionary change that we need in this District but I also I don't know if we do it at all our schools all at once yes go ahead I'm super excited to hear you say that being a middle school teacher

292I was really curious to where you said where like you thought about the seven to 12 um so thank you oh yeah I I love it I'm an eighth grade teacher if you didn't know and a huge problem I see with eighth graders is that they don't think their grades matter because they can't see that like jump to the high school and I think having a a cohesive program where they know they're part of it and they know what's coming I think that could get them so much more engaged trusty Kirby uh yeah I just wanted to to add I probably didn't make it clear earlier but so I am definitely a proponent of keeping all the high schools open for sure um I just want to explore all the possibilities that we can to

293make to make that happen um and just kind of jumping on what director truste Caston was saying you know I I feel we really need to embrace all the uh you know each school has its own kind of personality I I don't think it's you know we need to embrace that all the differences that all the campuses have you know some have FFA some some don't um so you know we need to build up those programs to draw the students there they so they all want to be there we can't make them all the campuses can't be the same we need to embrace all the good things that each campus can can uh provide so anyway that's it trusty de Lisa it is noted to check if the 678 was even an option okay thank

294you um and trusty Kirby and I can attest to this as parent Advocates and volunteers um for several years in this District that there was a time and point where this District was and the former boards in the past were all or nothing so you couldn't bring something that two schools wanted because all the schools couldn't have it or weren't ready for it um you're looking at a new board that is attempting to be creative Innovative and provide opportunities to provide spes that your students want to go to school and it's not going to be easy but we're willing to put the thought and effort and time into it to try and find those opportunities um we all have a lot of amazing perspectives and lived experience to put us in these positions and we're

295going to use that to attempt to build something better than we've had and something that allows room for growth besy Jenkins me again um I lost it it's coming back as far as like admin combining administ administrators um with campuses uh like for instance if we are not combining right away to a 712 model maybe combining admin um so like there's a a main admin and then some I don't know how to explain that principle with maybe Vice principles that so a shared principle with Vice principles of specific sites correct if that would cut down okay yeah I am I'm curious in going to a 7 through 12 school how how would that change the admin setup like would there be an additional assistant principal the ratios so everything would be based on the ratio

296at the school remember our new conversation our new tool is going to be ratios so as we are Staffing from here into the future we're going to have ratios based upon students the number of students on a campus um I know that for our teachers we've had the counselor ratios for a long time currently is 400 to1 so we're going to have similar ratios for our administrators and all of the other support plan so that would be taken care of through the ratio work trusty Caston that actually prompts an additional so when we look at the themes for each of the campuses contemplating in the ratios where we're not getting to microman Agy but we're making sure we're executing on what we're committing to what ratios are appropriate for those specialized themes not just general

297classroom sizes uh and I don't know if that's a Friday thing or a part of the four meetings we have coming up in February but if it can land on one of those and then the other thing because it's in the committee's report is I'd like to see uh potential language on enacting our options under ab57 which is where we select uh where we have the ability to say whether or not we are going to be renewing or allowing other districts to renew out of District Charters this is a little off topic but so if we're going to ratios then would consolidating sites then reduce the number of staff that have to be split between sites like counselors would that allow counselors to more dedicated to a home site it it may it may also

298at some sites create more of a split so it it would depend the numers any other guidance for our staff and what they're going to bring us on Friday trusty Kirby sorry just one more thing I forgot to mention since we had the conversation earlier about the reserve um and that does Drive some of our numbers um personally I would like to see at least double like a 6% Reserve I don't know where where everyone else falls on the the committee I know it's uh or even five but somewhere it's got to be above three I just um if you can help run some of those figure that in I know that's I don't know how hard that is to figure that into everything else that you're already figuring in but uh um anyway I

299would like to see the reserve something higher than three for sure trusty dor so I think it's just really important to reiterate that a lot of positive information is being discussed um amongst us right now and that we do not expect this to all happen overnight um that has to be reality as these discussions are being had that there's a lot of great ideas that are being had and some things on some campuses are working and we need to use that to our advantage why we figure out the things that aren't working and right size this district and our budget so yes we need to grow and move forward but we don't all have to do it in the next two months getting to the budget stabilization plan is what we need to get figured

300out and that's on um and your team's been working day and night to take care of that we just wanted you to hear that that's appreciated and bring us what you can Friday and we'll keep having these discussions on how to move forward did we narrow it down or did we make it worse a little both but I I know many members of my team are listening tonight and already already working on on what this is what they're going to be able to prepare so we will bring as much information as we can we will try to prioritize what hits kind of the the common themes between everybody that seems to be the the highest priority for conversation will be what we tackle first and and kind of move from there trusty Jenkins and you're

301going to bring your recommendations too right your one your favorite of all of them you're the numbers person appreciate it so for me it's um I I have to say it's not just about the numbers which is what makes that difficult because really the numbers and why I do what I do is not about making sure that we have a balanced budget but really driving what you know the budget should be driven by what student need is and so that's why we have such a collaboration between all of our departments but specifically you'll notice when we do budget presentations it's typically Rodrick and I doing it together because it is about program and budget combined and that's why the lcap comes before the budget is is because that's what it's driven by so we can

302run all kinds of numbers but until we know I mean we we can I can make recommendations for cuts but in order to bring you real numbers for the future I need to know what we want programs to look like because that that's how we determine what what works or doesn't work in the budget I I know in some ways it's cart and horse um or the Chicken and the Egg but but it really they they do go hand inand and I I can create a budget in isolation but it's not going to be um if I'm looking solely at numbers it's not going to be necessarily what's best for kids and so I want to be very mindful of that sorry just thought of one more thing um did you want to I know

303publicly we may not have uh gotten the if someone didn't go to a town hall about the moving map the the the thing that everybody can go on and kind of play around with and you want to talk about that a little bit sure so the the the boundary map tool um was that was created internally that's part of how we're kind of looking at okay if we did this scenario then that means that we have so many kids we have to R distribute um so we have um our our team has made that specifically Dr bardelli has made that available for the public to be able to kind of paint my numbers and and you know see what some of those scenarios would look like and and kind of create their own versions there's

304an email address to submit those two and what he'll be doing is kind of overlaying them and bringing kind of the most popular scenarios so it's not that we're using it as the public needs to create these boundaries for us it's it's just another tool for input and also to help people understand the complexity of of the fact that we have basically a thousand of our kids liveing a really small area and the configuration of schools related to that it it's really difficult to to redistribute those so you know it serves several purposes one so the public can kind of understand a little bit about why it's not as clearcut as we would love for it to be um but also to come up with some options because we don't have all the answers we

305need the Public's input and and we want that because we're here to serve what works for for them and their kids is there any more guidance that you need from us I I think that I I I think that we we have probably more than we need um but we will do our best to to bring you what you're looking for we will be able to like I said adjust some things within a few minutes of you know during this study session and some of it will be that we'll need some more Direction and clarification from you at that time to be able to to get more information out there thank you meeting adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.