CorpusRecord 107024

SRCS Regular Board Meeting - January 22, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Santa Rosa City Schools
Date
2025-01-23
Location
Sonoma County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
36,173 words · about 201 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e good afternoon everyone now opening the January 22nd 2025 meeting of the Santa Rosa City Schools Board of Education we will now take public comment on closed session agenda items only um I'm going to allow 90 seconds each for public comment and I'm going to limit the total public comment on closed a session session to 20 minutes um I'm going to call three names at a time so that you know when your turn is coming up first we will have Ricardo MOA followed by Dan bartholomy followed by Dennis mcer so Ricardo if you're here you are first either of our microphones behind you the podiums behind you you have 90 seconds go ahead thank you I just want to quickly introduce myself my name is Ricardo MOA um I'm a LC Allen alumni um

002and was a student of Mr Petty who you know I think most of us and not all of us are here to discuss today uh superintendent Dr Morales board MERS board members Medina maner Jenkins mcnali delator Kirby and Cason uh thank you guys very much for reading the letter I sent you guys uh I know some of you guys had the time to respond thank you very much uh so I'm just here to speak on behalf of petty not just as a teacher a coach a role role model but as somebody who has proudly profoundly changed the course of my life uh growing up I struggled to stay on the right path it was easy to make the wrong decisions and I at times I felt lost but then I met Mr Petty and he

003didn't just see a student he saw potential in me he didn't just see me as a student um he kept me accountable out of trouble and when I was at a Crossroads his disbelief in me wasn't just words it was action he showed me that I was capable of more than I ever thought possible Mr Petty inspired me to pursue a path I never imagined for myself he encouraged me to serve my country which led me to join the military a decision that gave me a purpose discipline and a sense of pride a even after that he your time is up thank you for sharing next we have Dan bartholomy followed by Dennis mcer followed by Chris laer Dan go ahead good afternoon my name is Dan bartholomy I'm a teacher at El Allen High

004School I've worked with Mr Petty for 20 something maybe 25 years now and I've coached football with him for 10 years and I coached rugby with him for 20 years Mr Petty has done so much for so many students you've heard him over and over again how he has changed lives he's helped people go from a life of potential crime injury death you name what he's helped them and he's brought them into a productive member of our society but he's also taught us he taught me he taught me the number one thing to be in a teacher is to in Inspire young men I don't want to just teach them I want these young men here to be proud parents and fathers and and husbands and people of our community that I want next to

005me when I need them I could almost point to an individual here and I know they've got my back because Mr Petty taught us that he taught me he taught them and if you have any ideas about letting him go or any way to stop him from leaving you would be making a huge mistake if you didn't if your decisions are based on political agendas if your decisions are based on staff numbers if your decisions are based on anything but our children in this community you're making a mistake our children need Mr Petty we need Mr Petty thank you thank you next we have Dennis mcer followed by Chris Laurer followed by Joe div it thank you I'm Dennis mcarter I'm a 99 alumni of LC Ellen also the owner and wine maker of mcarter

006Sellers and a judo instructor at the community filing Center I met Petty in high school doing his international relations class he encouraged me to do rugby and when I couldn't afford cleats he actually intervened and bought me cleats to make it possible um coach Petty taught me discipline taught me accountability taught me the the me of sacrifice and to lead by example um dur my time at Elie Ellen I've seen him heavily involved in rosin and encourag many people to turn around when they were about to drop out of school and um he's a hidden hero um he's not very botal about it but we need more folks like him in his community so all I ask you guys is to give this man his job back thank you thank you next we have Chris

007laer followed by Joe MCD divit followed by Tina Yang good afternoon members of the board uh my name is Chris laer I'm a chief warrant officer in the United States Army with 21 years of service including 16 years as a Green Beret in Special Forces I've LED soldiers through 10 combat deployment earned an NBA with honors and completed Ranger school at 40 but none of this would have been possible without the foundation of leadership resilience and discipline instilled to me by Mr Alan Petty my teacher my coach my mentor and lifelong inspiration alen Petty didn't just teach he transformed at 15 I was a founding member of the LC Allen liba rugby team Mr Mr Petty challenged me and my teammates to grow through Blood Sweat and Tears and hard work he created an environment

008that demanded greatness a place for accountability selfless service and perseverance weren't just lessons but a way of life it shaped me and the soldier leader and man that I am today alen's reach extends far beyond me for over 30 years he has been a Lifeline to students many from undeserved communities in Southwest anosa he didn't just coach Sports he gave young people hope Direction and belief in themselves when no one else would he has created leaders teachers public servants and countless others who owe their success to his unwavering commitment many of whom stand before you today now the district stands at a Crossroads at a time when we desperately need strong Educators and Role Models this community cannot afford lose a man of Allen's caliber dismissing him not only tarnishes the reputation of a man

009who has selflessly served his community but it robs future students of a mentor who changes lives I am proove that Allan Petty creates I would not be standing here today without his guidance and his leadership and I'm just one of many I urge you no I your time is up to do right thank you next next we have Joe mcdot followed by Tina Yang followed by Tony Ruiz hi uh thank you for tonight um my name is Joe mcdot um I've been an educator in s rosa city schools for 11 years I'm currently at s Roa Charter School for the Arts I taught at the art Quest program I have taught in San Francisco East and West Oakland Vallejo Napa um and now back in Santa Rosa where I grew up I've known Petty for

01030 years he was my mentor my teacher my coach he single-handedly got me into Berkeley and what he is so much more than that was a safe haven for me um there was a a time in my uh early 20s when I was at Berkeley and I was struggling in a low place I uh was working full-time I was taking on a full hor load my father at the time was terminally ill um I was just doing a lot and at the time I was in the process of coming out which um uh to say I was in a low place is an understatement um because of all of this I failed out at Berkeley for about a year and I came home and talked to Petty and the first thing he said to me

011knowing way before I did was Joe I just want you to be yourself I love you for you this was a time when I was afraid to come out to my parents when I was afraid to come out to anybody in my life I never even had to come out to Petty he always knew and I knew then and it started the pro process and the Catalyst for me there's so many countless students on that campus and in the future that are going to be uh at a loss without him he's the fabric of our community and I implore you to reinstate him please thank you thank you next we have Tina Yang followed by Tony Ruiz followed by Terry Curtis go ahead superintendent Board of Trustees HR Personnel why are you here today will

012you serve Santa Rosa city schools for just a few more years just enough to add to your resume or will you commit like Mr Allan Petty who's devoted 30 years to shaping students and this community Mr penny has been more than a teacher he's a mentor coach and role model leaving a lasting impact beyond the classroom before teaching he served as a marine bringing Direction resilience and service to our schools his dedication to Excellence extends to both students and the community now I ask you will you honor this Legacy of service or allow it to fade losing Mr Penny would be a grave loss not just to the district but to every student and all of Sonoma County Superintendent Board of Trustees HR Personnel his legacy deserves to be continued will you be remembered for

013destroying it or will you be remembered for ensuring it thrives for generations to come thank you thank you next we have Tony Ruiz followed by Terry Curtis followed by Mark sharpio uh good evening uh my name is Tony re I served in the military currently still enrolled in school and I have been a student a player and one of those people who have been inspired by Mr Petty uh for me he was uh definitely the Catalyst in my life uh when I was going through school I had no direction I had nowhere to go I didn't think about doing anything other than just being at home and getting a job at some retail store but Petty saw potential in me he took me out to events he drove me to wherever I needed to go

014whether it is for games or back home from school uh it didn't matter to him he he treated me similarly to a son it really made a difference in my life because he saw potential in me that my own family really didn't have uh visual of and because of him I left home joined the military served my country came back now I'm working on my degree to be a radiologist and all that just because he saw something in me that nobody else really did and you know for me that's one person that I know we'll see a lot more in others than some random teacher you pick up now off the streets he's dedicated his life to this this is his craft and he's one of the best please reinstate him we need him people

015like him are what we need thank you thank you next we have Terry Curtis followed by Mark sharpio followed by Mario Vasquez hi my name is Terry Curtis I'd like i' like to introduce myself a little bit so that you have a reason to understand why I'm taking up your time today I'm a product of Santa Rosa city schools started uh in 1950 graduated um Montgomery High School in 1962 went off to college and then law school at the University of Chicago and came back to teach at Santa Rosa JC for 14 years U and also came back to start a rugby club in Santa Rosa there had not been one um I know a little about education then and I well actually I know a little more about education I went from Santa Ros

016up to Chico State where I taught for another 30 years and spent the last two of them as the associate dean of the College of Education with all that experience in both rugby and I know uh Mr Petty very well and in education I would encourage you not to allow this to be a binary decision when a student complains that he has been misused or abused we have to take that seriously but when a faculty member encourages this much honor and love we have to take that seriously too you have to find a way to make sure that both concerns are cared for thank you thank you next we have Mike sharpio followed by Mario Vasquez followed by Linda Maloney uh good afternoon everyone my name is Mike sharpio I'm the department chair the history

017department chair at LC Allen High School and uh as many people here would agree with me Allan Petty needs to be back in the classroom right now um I hear what all the people were saying I listen to the meeting last week I know that there's been a number of um letters that have been written and whatnot and I'm not going to repeat that uh because I agree with them and I also know them to be true um and I believe that you know also uh I would encourage you to do the right thing and get Mr Petty back into the classroom uh there I hope that you have the fairness integrity and and Justice to to make the correct decision here um and then the other part I wanted to bring up that I

018don't think anybody else has is at a time when our district is very resource challenged it seems to me that we should not be um shedding resources but trying to use them very very WI wisely and I think having Alan Petty in the classroom is definitely a plus for the district and its students and shoot my department as well um in addition to that not having Mr Petty in the classroom we're paying somebody to be a substitute teacher in there and two teachers are also getting paid to write lessons and grade the work I know it's not going to solve a multi-million dollar deficit but anything's going to help thank you thank you next we have Mario Vasquez followed by Linda Maloney followed by Chris uh adario good afternoon my name is Maro Vasquez I'm

019a local business owner um definitely a very involved in local uh nonprofits that serve uh the youth uh that need help assistance uh heavily involv in that I think uh in the experience of the last 10 years that I've had serving our community I've Lear a lot of that uh skill set through my school years of uh being a alumni to LC Allen and Alan Patty taught us uh I'm just here has another example as many of you guys hear uh the core principal values of serving our community with Integrity uh and I'm just another example of his product um so like the second gentleman prior to uh Shapiro here Mr sharpio spoke is as many more examples uh we have to continue to allow Mr pet to come back to the school district and

020continue to do what he does best um it would be pretty harsh to lose some considering how much of an example how much of a uh youth he has in essence uh changed our lives so I just I'm just here to Advocate on his behalf I hope you guys would consider that I serve chops I serve um boys and girls club and I'm just one of many examples thank you thank you next we have Linda Maloney followed by Chris adario followed by Bo Bergstrom hello my name is Linda Maloney and I've been a resident of this County for nearly 40 years I'm a full-time faculty member at the Santa Rosa Junior College and teach Child Development my husband Joe is a coach a science and math and construction teacher at Amarosa Academy and we have

021four adult sons who attended anley high school and were athletes and three of the four played rugby at LC Allen High School we first met Allan in 2002 when one of our sons was a freshman in high school at the time he was a football player and quarterback at annaly but begged us to play rugby at LSC due to the remarkable program Allan had built in time our son wore us down and in retrospect we're glad he did knowing Alan Petty was one of the highlights of Our Lives he models discipline and morality and builds skills on the rugby pitch that impact athletes in school career and all Al their family Allan has worked taught and coached some of the most underserved students in our County his commitment to these kids is unmatched by any

022other teacher or coach I have met Allan attended UC Berkeley where he played rugby at the highest college level Cal has won more national championships in any other program in the United States coach Petty's work with these athletes inspires them to reach goals that would otherwise be pipe dreams without his influence and connections um on another note Petty keeps in touch with his former players he has officiated more weddings than anyone I know Allen has provided stability inspiration to hundreds of our youth in a society where many fathers are absent um I just your thank you very much thank you next we have Chris aario and then Bo Bergstrom and then we will probably be at our 20 minute limit at that point hello and good afternoon uh my name is Chris Alano and uh

023I don't really speak much I'm a very quiet kid but today I want to be heard um Alan Petty was he was a very respectful man when I first met him and he helped me out a lot um when I first joined high school or got into high school um I didn't know what I was going to do with my life be honest um freshman year I wasn't a very smart kid you know I didn't really make smart decisions and when I met him and joined rugby it switched my life um I started going to class um I was very disciplined after and uh in rugby he showed me how to actually be uh a member of society um he really did discipline me and show me how to be respectful and show me how

024to just be me um when I talked to him I felt comfortable enough to talk to him about my situation at home uh not at home at school he he was my teacher as well he he just he's a very good man he taught me a lot and if it wasn't for him I don't know where I'd be in life um right now I just I really want you guys to really think about your decision because he's helped a lot of us uh me a lot of rugby students a lot of LC Allen kids and I think I think there's a really big opinion on him and it's thank you your time is up next is Bo Bergstrom and that will be our final public comment hello good afternoon my name is Bo burkstrom I'm

025a 1998 LC Allen alumni uh I could talk about Allan but I'm going to talk a little more about me I've been coaching for 10 years with Allen and I've seen what he does with these kids day in and day out now that he's not with us I'm the head coach and I can promise you that I'm a poor substitute for Mr Petty uh I will not be driving the kids to college campuses during the summer when our rugby season is off to give them tours of college campuses I do not have the patience I did not have the time and I don't have the that skill set Mr Petty does have that skill set um right now I have a 16-year-old player at LC Allen he's a junior in high school I know he's

026smoking weed I'm not on campus with him every day to try to get him to do something better with his life I've spoken with them my coaches have spoken with them his players have spoken with them this young man is not coming out to practice I know Mr Petty could talk to this guy and we'll probably get him out but you can't if he's not on campus um you know and that's what what we're here for that's what we've been doing for 20s something years when I played rugby when my brother played rugby my son played rugby um it's important to us but it's it's helped make us men better better fathers better parents better husbands better Brothers better Sons um and lastly can uh everyone who is here to support Mr Petty please stand

027up to show the board what this means to us thank you thank you to everyone who came out I want to apologize to those of you that aren't able to comment we do have a full agenda that we need to get through thank you everyone um the board will now recess to close session all right now opening the January 22nd 2025 meeting of the Santa Rosa City Schools Board of Education please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance and then remain standing for a territorial land acknowledgement I acknowledge that Santa Rosa city schools is is on the ter traditional territory and homelands of the Pomo people traditional territory and homelands of the Coast Miwok people and honor with gratitude the land itself and the people who have stewarded it throughout the generations this land acknowledgement calls

028us to commit to continuing to learn how to be better stewards of the land we inhabit by offering this land acknowledgement we affirm indigenous sovereignty and will work to hold Santa Rosa city schools more accountable to the needs of American Indian and Indigenous peoples thank you you may all be seated all right moving on to report of actions taken in close session no actions were taken items considered in closed session for Action in Open Session there are none statements of abstention do we have any statements of abstention seeing none are there any adjustments to the agenda trusty Medina like to pull G9 and uh I think that's it all right we will pull item G9 any other adjustments all right then we will move on to our special presentations for students and staff members of

029the month um we are welcoming Cesar Chavez Language Academy and elsc Allen High School I believe we have principal Diaz from ccla to start us off good evening I am AAS principal of SES Travis Language Academy thank you for having us I am proud to present Yia Vega Munos as s Chavez Language Academy student of the year she yes she is truly an exceptional student who exemplifies the qualities we strive for in all our Learners leadership responsibility kindness and strong commitment to both her academic and extracurricular Pursuits yuvia has had a wonderful experience at her school since she started in kindergarten she has had build positive relationships with both staff and students her academic strength are in math and English where she consistently excels she has a passion for writing especially realistic fiction and enjoys

030crafting stories and developing characters as a natural leader uvia serves as a student body Treasurer a role she takes on with great responsibility she enjoys handling finances counting and organizing and takes interests in selling items Beyond her academic and Leadership roles yuvia is deeply committed to helping others she has been involved in kwondo since the age of five and currently holds a black belt she takes pride in teaching younger students ages 4 to n guiding them with her lessons she has learned throughout her own Journey her desire is to teach the students how to avoid the mistakes she made along the way and she genuinely enjoys helping others in addition to her Taekwondo accomplishments yuvia has been dedicated member of a member of VI folclorico since she was 6 years old learning and performing traditional

031Mexican dances from different regions she is also an accomplished violinist having been part of the LBC mariachi group for the past three years yuvia is also learning a third language Korean she hopes to one day visit Korea to partake in Taekwondo there in sixth grade yuvia received the Rosio Munos award for her kindness respect and responsibility quality she continues to exemplify each day she is a strong advocate for other s always speaking up when she Witnesses bullying and offering support to her peers yuvia is a wonderful example of what it means to be a leader and a compassionate individual she consistently demonstrates excellence in everything she does and is with great pride that we recognize her as our Student of the Year and thank you parents for sharing her with us me go your flowers

032come here m for it is my pleasure to introduce as our classified employee of the year anel Leon B yes anel has been working as our middle school regist for many years anel on by is often the first person our parents and students meet as a register as an incoming students of sesat Chavez Language Academy she is tasked with the management of Student Records however it does much more holding space for parents and students to unload their stories and identify resources to support our families walking through our doors furthermore anel communicates with the counseling team with any information that they will need in order for this students to feel welcome at our sesa Travis Community anel goes above and beyond from managing and recordkeeping she is often the first person to offer assistance during orientation

033days in July back to school nights in September and during our lottery in December throughout the years the administrative team has had the privilege to pick up students to pick up students in the morning or drop them off after school for various reasons anel has accompanied Us in the car and fostered a relationship by seeing the students for who they are and always encouraging students to try their best in our most recent Adventure we have walked to school with one of our youngest students and she has sung counted and ensured the safety of school arrival for the student it is an honor to have her company during these times and she does it with Grace and happiness when there is a personal absence in the office she's always willing to help throughout her tenure and

034it has embodied the S Chavez Language Academy Vision by fostering creative honest and kind citizens of the community and the world in all of interactions with the staff parents and students CES Chavez Language Academy is a better place with her and all her support e okay it is with great pleasure that I introduce our certificated employee of the year Leah tasel Leah has been in education for for 12 years she is an exceptional educator who consistently demonstrates an unwavering commitment to both students and colleagues she is known for her willingness to support others she is always ready to land a hand offer advice or collaborate with fellow teachers to ensure everyone succeeds her caring nature extends to all students creating a nurturing and inclusive environment where each individual feels valued and supported with high standards

035for both academic excellence and personal growth she challenges students to reach their fullest potential while providing the encouragement and the resources needed for Success her classroom is a place of opportunity where every student is empowered to thrive in every challenge is met with determination and guidance Leah exemplifies leadership compassion and dedication and everything she does Leah is deeply committed to the power of bilingual education as a natural leader she works tirelessly to ensure that ccla offers the highest quality dual language education to all of our students her dedication is evident in her daily collaboration with staff and her constant reflection on best practices to enhance student learning it is such an honor to work alongside her every day thank you from the bottom of our hearts for your hard work and dedication to all of

036our ccla community excuse me everyone I have to briefly stop the meeting to ask that we clear the aisles the Fire Marshall is asking that we clear the aisles there needs to be space for people to move through the aisles that includes the top there is a speaker outside there's a speaker outside you can still hear from Outdoors we cannot continue the meeting until the aisles are clear they those gates are locked we don't have the keys stairs need to be so the stairs on the side need to be clear the back needs to be clear people need to be able to move through all right all right um the stairway does need to be clear and and the Fire Marshall walk through and giv specific Direction you can use this microphone what if they

037know that hello everybody my name is Paul othal the City's Fire Marshal so there was some concerns that were called in by just based on the number of people within the the chambers so we do have an occupant load typically allow people to be uh up against the railing at a uh at a maximum and sometimes up against the back wall but the sheer number of people that are up in the upper area we just can't have you in here right now our concern is really for your safety if something was to happen in here the ability to get everybody out of here is just not it's not feasible right now U we've actually not seen this many people in the chamber and we can't continue the meeting until we start to clear some people

038out I know that a lot of people are probably here for item number D7 the school closures so we totally support that and want people to have their voices we're not trying to keep you from uh using your voice but we just need to ask that people wait outside until that until that item gets here and you're called to speak so we won't be able to restart the meeting until we get the upper area completely cleared out with the exception of people up against the railing or up against the back wall where the window is but we cannot have the so the sheer number of people in here how about the people on the stairs right here yeah we also can't have anybody sitting on stairs so you either need to be in a signed

039seat up against the railing or against the back window wall everybody else has to has to has to leave the building please and we do have the system is set up so that you can hear everything that's taking place from the courtyard e back on yeah all right I also understand that there's people that are here can you guys listen up for a second I understand there's people that are here listen for this particular presentation so when people leave we'll be able to let people back in so we'll kind of do the onein one out thing right now but we again we respect that people want to be here for the presentation I want people to be able to listen to the meeting we just we got to start clearing people out of here for

040your safety e thank you montgomer thank you those of you that are moving out we do hear your comments about needing a larger venue we are in the process of locating and selecting a larger Venue at the very least for our February 19th meeting and we can discuss using it for our February 5th meeting as well thank you to those of you that are moving out yes I believe if you are up against the rail or against the back wall you're fine we just can't have any additional layers between that is the Fire Marshall still here are we where'd he go he stepped outside for just a moment but he'll be right back okay I will wait for his all clear so once again we need everyone to move off the stairs and we can

041only have a single layer in the back up against the railing and a single layer against the wall no one in between those two layers and I see there are some seats that have opened up if you have a seat if you could possibly scoot in to make room for others there are a few seats on my right your left so thank you everybody so far that's heated the request we still need to get people out from in front of the doors people that are blocking the stairwells the exit doors please get off the stairs out of the front doors all right okay yeah I'll go do a quick walk and okay okay e e e okay we're going to get the meeting going what we we're going to do is we're going to keep

042walking and make sure that people either up against the railing or up against the wall um we'll keep things excuse me we'll keep things as clear as we can but we're not going to let any more people in it'll be one person in one person out so I appreciate everybody's cooperation again we're not trying to be difficult we're just trying to make it safe for you guys to be here so I appreciate your time thank you all right thank you so much to those of you that moved outside thank you to the Fire Marshall for keeping us safe and thank you everyone for your patience um we now have principal alv Vera from LC Allen High School thank you thank you Bo president MCN uh yes my name is Gabriela the principal LC high school

043and uh it is my honor to be recognized back sorry to recognize students and staff at LC Allen High School and I'd like to start off uh elcen High School would like to recognize Michael Bernardin as our student of the month right next to me you all might have seen him out there with the band uh very proud uh Michael's an amazing young man uh Michael enrolled with us at LC Allen High School last year coming from beautiful Haiti despite the short amount of time that Michael has been with us he has found his way and created his own path to be not only a scholar but a true leader on our campus at school Michael has demonstrated solid leadership skills bringing in fresh ideas and perspectives he has shared his creativity as a member

044of our Dance Program where he performs with confidence great enthusiasm and amazing dance skills he has supported the younger students by being a role model and motivating other male students to join Dance Michael has also been a participant in a bar FICO uh club fashion Club lowo Band and this year he joined the wrestling team Michael took the initiative to connect with students and staff about starting a fashion club and boom just like that LC Allen High School had a fashion Club it was born the club has already had donations of sewing machines and materials all due to Michael's leadership of course Michael in my opinion is a superhero he's fluent in Haitian Creole French of course English and now he's learning Spanish Michael stated that uh as a young boy uh he learned English

045from his mother as well as uh watching TV uh he's a big fan of uh Pretty Little Liars he say he learned English through that all of this is amazing but what really sets Michael aside from everyone else is that he's also humble and a thoughtful young man who is determined to succeed and thinks and cares of others Michael has two passions fashion and nature so he would like to pursue either a career in fashion design or be hired and he said this not me as a full-time Steward for lamp paaths I don't know if lamp paath is in the house I'm just saying um Michael would like to thank his teachers at LC Allen High School but especially Mr carbo for believing in him and pushing him to be his best I personally would

046like to thank Michael's mom Miss Marlene for bringing Michael to LC Allen High School we are a better Community because of Michael's presence and Leadership LC Allen High School is honor to present Michael Bernardine as our student of the month so [Applause] uh El on high school would now like to uh Angie Nunes again LZ Allen High School like to recognize Anica Angie Nunes as our classified staff member of the Year Angie is a wonderful human being that started working as a student safety adviser at LC Allen High School in the spring of 2024 although she only has one technically year under her belt she's no long she's no stranger to LC all in high school as she has had three of her children who were Lobos Angie was on our School site counsel for

047several years and then came the opportunity to do more for LC Allen High School and she decided to apply to be a student safety adviser and how lucky were we when she accepted the position when it was offered to her there are many things that Angie could be doing Prof professionally but she chose to be a caring adult on our campus as a student safety adviser you need to build relationships with students so that they can trust uh trust you and that characteristic is something that Angie has in abundance she has connected with students in so many ways that students view her as a mother figure coming to her for personal concerns or just to get an ear to uh just to have an ear for to hear our students out she sits in on

048many of the administrators discussions with students she helps Translate with students and parents her empathetic nature comes not comes out organically she is not fake and the students know it she is supportive establishes expectations and is consistent with her performance and her expectations from students I don't have to tell you that the student safety adviser position comes with little recognition so I would like to also thank all of the student safety advisers out there because it is an important role yeah absolutely Angie has literally saved lives a couple of months ago we had a very traumatic situation on our campus one of our students had a seizure in class that caught students to St off guard the student had stopped breathing and was not uh he had stopped breathing a student came out of the

049classroom and found Angie outside of the classroom and Angie went into the classroom and instantaneously jumped into action she began to do CPR and started chest compressions we are lucky to have called 911 quickly and by the time the paramedics got into the classroom the student had already began to breathe on his own the paramedics praised Angie for her quick action and acknowledged that the fact that if Angie had not addressed the situation things could have been much worse for our student that is who Angie is she represents the nurturing and caring qualities of a mother on campus it is for those reasons that LC Allen High School would like to recognize Angie Nunes for classified staff member of the year e all right uh Mr plot fleser yeah come on down LC in high

050school would like to recognize Mr Paul fer as our certificated staff member of the Year Paul has been a staple for the gram just as we say a staple of education at LC Allen High School uh for over 30 years he's a veteran teacher who teaches the wonders of Earth Science and psychology and works extremely hard to make his lessons interesting and relevant to his students Paul fer supports students in accessing the rigor in his classrooms and sets high standards through consistent routines and practices students in his class learned the valuable skills of being personally responsible for their education and he challenges students to achieve to their fullest potential and supports them along the way Paul makes it a point to constantly communicate with parents and it's always motiv inating them to be part of

051their child's education he's routinely seen at students I and other supported meetings over the year Paul has been a volleyball coach class advisor currently the adviser of um excuse me uh currently the adviser of the dis golf golf team leader of yes absolutely leader of the psychology Club as well as advises the regenerative environmental action Club Paul has a wicked sense of humor and of course has a great love for all things that are rock uh his school spirited is second to none especially during Halloween when he puts on every costume that you can think of and he's a kind person who goes out of his way to support all of his students over the years he has taught himself Spanish he could be a better support for the LC's diverse Community while many students

052say that Mr flasher is the hardest teacher he said it up there absolutely uh shouldn't even took the off me where I was going um well many students said Mr f is the hardest teachers they also say that they're made grateful for the challenges and support that Mr fasher has given them every time they walk into the classroom what is almost what is that also important is that LC High School Community has the longevity and consistent consistency of Mr fer exemplifies at any point in time in his career Paul would have uh gone and taught at any other school in our community but he didn't he chose to stay at LC Allen High School and work with our community and because he believes in our students uh that they can overcome circumstances and be resilient

053our students and our parents have not overlooked the fact that Paul has wanted to be a lobo for his entire professional career and they will never forget Mr fer LC Allen High School is honored to recognize Mr Paul fer as our certificated staff member of the year thank you thank you happy birthday happy birthday and congratulations to all of the award winners we now have our School site parent organiz ization updates so from Cesar Chavez we have our elac president and our ccla foundation president no we're good thank you it looks like some folks are clearing out after the awards so there will be more space for some people to come inside Elizabeth hello everybody oh hello everybody my name is Elizabeth angano and I am the Caesar Chavez Language Academy Foundation president for this

054school year the ccla foundation has been busy fundraising so far this year we have fundraised over $25,000 for all the students at ccla we committed to helping the marching ban with over $10,000 to help them Reach their goal of $30,000 so they can March in Disneyland in June we set a record at our fall book fair with over $6,000 in sales2 2,000 of those dollars came from just our literacy night we supported 46 teachers with $200 checks for their classroom supplies we had the largest turnout at our annual Posada with over 200 students and families in attendance we will be kicking off the new year with two more schoolwide fundraisers and in March we will be having our Caesar Chavis celebration that will feature student performances thank you s and I will translate it in

055English good afternoon uh School Board trustees uh from center of the city schools my name is Elia Selenas and I am the President of elac this is my first year as president and we meet once a month on Thursdays uh some of the elac themes that we have gone over has been about the elpac tests that happens the importance of reclassification for students and how to uh how parents can help out their students to academically achieve we've also received a lot of information about uh bullying prevention and uh many topics about with our counseling team from the school site we have also participated in different meetings and we are excited and we appreciate everything um every single meeting and thank you so much thank you all for the work you do for ccla students next

056we have a few folks from LC Allen our School site coun representative elac representative and LC Allen High School Foundation representative all right good evening hi everyone thank you for having us um my name is Jamie Padilla and I'm thrilled to be here this evening as president of the um Els Allen height site council could you get closer to the mic please yeah of course thank you um there has been a wealth of activities and accomplishments since I sat um before you last year first and foremost my son is a senior this year and I'm looking forward to seeing him graduate um Elsie Allen High School bad Mitten team won the conference Championship last spring and recently our football team went to the NCS Conference Championship game in our division this is the first time

057ever that our football team went to the NCS section Championship we are very proud of our student athletes hos our Visual and Performing Arts department has been extremely active including our marching band and color guard performing in multiple parades and Veteran events our Mariachi and foror dancers also have performed at various events throughout the county our ceramics Department being featured at a sco I'm sorry sco exhibition and Fine Art Department creating new and exciting murals on our school property our CTE programs continue to thrive with the public safety education for those interested in becoming teachers and public and Community Health program we have been fortunate to have opportunities for our students to attend class over the summer to receive their CNA designation and have had two groups of students go through the lime Foundation the

058nextg Trades academ Academy Academy sorry currently students in the public and Community Health pathway are participating in a job shadowing experience at Suter Hospital in the spring all Juniors on our campus will par participate in the career day focusing on listening to various Community professionals about their job and their experiences and participate in resume and job interview activities our a Agriculture and FFA program at LSC is robust and brimming with activities we have a barn and a greenhouse on campus that support agriculture FFA activities further our amazing agriculture mechanics program allows students to use state-of-the-art welding laser and wood production equipment to produce a v variety of products and tools our students raise sheep and pigs to show at the County Farm and raise chickens for egg production FFA members particip at in a variety

059of activities including leadership conference and speech contests last week in a degree banquet ceremony 54 students received greenhand degrees and eight students received chapter degrees exemplifying their leadership and accomplishments um academically we have accomplishments as well in partnership with the Santa Rosa Junior College we were able to offer Santa Roa JC class taught on the LC campus for students College and Career access Pathways class classes are college level courses that high school students can take at Elie Allen High School CCAP classes are part of the dual enrollment program and are taught by Santa Rosa JC professors so that high school students can be awarded both college credit and high school credit for a single course we hope to continue this program and expand offerings in the future um for LC students to receive college credit

060without leaving our campus our accelerated academ mic program continues to thrive University Center with students being about to take classes at Soma State University for $25 a semester we also continue to support support aspiring college students with our Avid programs on campus our UC Center and Avid students last year were accepted at Sonoma State UC Davis humble State University UC Santa Barbara um Cal State Northridge CSU Bakersfield just to name a few finally a celebration we are no longer in CSI comprehensive support and Improvement school and we continue to provide targeted and necess necessary support for English Lear Learners and students with disabilities we are so proud of the great work that our staff and students are doing and we are encouraged with the progress we have made moving forward we would like to thank

061the board for the continued support of our Lobo Community thank you so much good evening members students parents member communities my name is H Martinez and I'm here tonight to speak about uh elac at LC Allen High School I would like to start by saying that I'm a proud L of parent and proud to be part of LC Isen in our El meeting we have discussed and learned about various topics concerning our students parents and community members we have the present we have presentation by Community organization such such a Norway organization project sooma Community Action Network and 10,000 degrees in our meetings we have had the opportunity to learn about positive positive dis discipline and how to check our students attendance and grades on areas and how to communicate with teachers and staff using parent

062Square we also learn about Community Resources such as parenting classes and receiving information about renters and immigrants rights the LC Allen High School staff also provid us with a par parent resources folder containing information about the school and our Santa Rosa Community we have had the opportunity to voice our opinions and discuss the support we as a parents need as well as the support that our students need we had a we have had a conversation about school closures and consolidations and I'm sure that everyone knows that we want our beloved LC Allen High School to remain open to keep um the Legacy and history of LC Kaman Allen we have attend meetings for a school consolation committee and the road show Community meetings I feel like I feel that is very important to stay informed

063so I can bring that information to our ilck meetings in LC Island and share with our parents I see that parents at LC Isen care about the students education of course we want our students to succeed we dream of our students graduating high school and fulfilling their dreams through a college or career pathway please continue supporting lsie alen to keep Elie kamanchi alen Legacy and history Alive by keeping Santa uh Elsie Allen High School open our schools uh can continue to change the life of our students our parents and a whole Community by keeping High uh elsc Allen open we can keep our community to be strong please consider to keep our high school open I was surprised that in our one of our town hall meetings the only school that support to keep all

064high schools op was our Bel love LC Allen High School we want to keep all high schools open and keep our and keep our community together and strong please consider this when we need when uh when there is a need we can work we can work with creativity as we said in Spanish I creativ thank you good evening my name is Vince figeroa and I serve as a president of the LC and high school Foundation I'm here tonight to share with you how we support our kids and to speak on behalf of the foundation and our board of directors directors in strong opposition of any consideration of closing LCL and high school LCL and high school is far more than just a school it's the heart of Southwest Santa Roa and the only public high

065school in this part of our community it serves a diverse and hardworking population many of whom are first generation families striving to build a better future for their children sir I'm going to stop you for a moment I know that you want to advocate for your school out of fairness to all schools I want to ask that you do that during public comment the purpose of this agenda item is to hear about your actions um I can share I can sure I can get to that okay thank you so much so a lot about we do a LC Allen as a group is bring opportunities to the students of Southwest s Roa through the foundation we've spent the last decade investing in our students and their Futures together with our donors in our Community Partners

066we've awarded over $900,000 in scholarships including more than $170,000 last year alone the scholarships have have helped graduates attemp top universities such as Harvard Stanford Dartmouth and UC Berkeley in 10 years we have invested over $1.4 million in our students and saved over $2 million in our endowment that will allow our foundation to award a minimum of $130,000 in annual Scholarships in perpetuity to the graduates of oel and high school scholarships are just the beginning in the past two years we've taken incredible leaps with our programs and we've and we're just getting started the programs at LCL and high school are transformative for both college and career- bound students the University Center allows students to earn up to 24 college credits at somoma State University while attending High School the nextg Trades Academy in partnership

067with the line Foundation equips students for high-paying jobs in the trades with tools training oia certification and career placement loal in the healthcare created with Suter Hospital provides hands-on experience for students pursuing careers in public and Community Health CNA program in partnership with Santa Rosa Junior College supports a students who go through a certified nursing assistant summer program and gain certification to start a career as a nursing assistant or move on to continuing studies in the medical field the foundation Club is an extension of the foundation board and is made up of students they gain valuable leadership skills while deciding how to distribute funds for student services through this program we fund AP tests college application fees Textbooks For Students taking classes at srjc and SSU field trips to college campuses teacher grants and much

068more and programs like Public Safety agriculture mechanics and FFA helps students Gain real world experience in critical fields in fields that are critical to our local economy I want to make sure I don't oversteep my boundaries here so I'm going to I'm being very careful or I'll be careful not to to um read all of my comments here but um I I just want to share um as I I myself uh share a common background with a lot of the student population that we serve uh my parents came here from Mexico um and like many of these families uh that we support at LC Allen uh we worked very hard to make ends meet as a teenager uh I was on a troubled path my father went to prison uh I lost my brother to

069drug and gang violence and um it my brother was somebody that was very close to me in age so he just I was a few years younger than him I had opportunities that he didn't and it's a stark reminder to me of how crucial the support uh and opportunities can be um for art risk youth uh we were both on very similar paths but me being a few years younger um I simply received opportunities he didn't and small those small changes led to incredible uh uh differences in in our in our lives um today I own and operate an accounting firm here in Santa Rosa and I'm passionate about paying forward the opportunities that we receive much like our the rest of our board who don't have a a connection necessarily to LC Allen uh

070but they're there to support our uh risk population so um with that I want to say that um uh We've invested 1.4 million in scholarships programs and career train over the last 10 years and we're committed to continuing this work um but we need your partnership to ensure that LCN remains a vital Institution for generations to come thank you thank you all for all the work that you do for our students thank you we'll now move on to the reports section of our agenda um first we have our CSEA report is President Leman here yes yes can you hear me yes I'm here good evening president MCN governing board superintendent Dr Morales student board member cabinet members and everyone listening tonight I am Mary Layman president of Santa Rosa city school's CSEA Chapter 75 I

071represent some 670 classified employees a special thank you to all of our amazing employees that are here tonight please give yourself a hand cca's mission is to improve the lives of our members our students and our communities and thank you to everyone else the teachers students parents and the community who came tonight to show the district We Care we congratulate the students and employees of the month especially our classified employees anel from ccla and then helica from elsc Allen we support the manyi discussion action items we have resolution tonight February 3rd to 7th as the week of the school counselor what would students do without [Music] you resolution number two February as the Career Technical Ed Education Month we have wood shops video editing classes culinaries and many more resolution three um we support the

072africanamerican history of the month for February um in resolution number 242 the early tell incentive for classified we thank you for offering our classified members the early ta incentive stipend equal to those of the certificated staff we appreciate being treated equally let this be the beginning of a positive change embracing classified employees as equal Partners in the vision of the district's future we are looking forward to professional development day Dr Morales reminds us daily in her emails we are all teachers by referring to us as maos and mess it means all of us are considered teachers we are all teachers if we are all teachers are we being treated like all of the teachers in this District if we are teachers why are we not receiving the same increase in wages we again thank SRTA

073members for supporting us in our demands for an equal raise who are we custodians secretaries instructional assistance grounds and maintenance building maintenance Food Service Library techs registrars noon Duty supervisors and more the lowest paid employees in the district without us you cannot teach some 14,150 students attending our 24 schools every day here's to being engaged empowered and waiting to be embraced let's walk the talk together with courage and compassion thank you thank you president lemman next we have the Santa Rosa Teachers Association president Howell good evening president mcnali superintendent Morales members of the board members of the community I'm Katherine Howell president of the Santa Rosa Teachers Association I represent about 900 teachers uh in the district um I want to join president layman in saying congratulations to all of our honores tonight I I

074always love hearing the LC El Allen band combined with ccla band members tonight so that was a nice treat for us um thank you for the resolutions uh that President Layman has mentioned I just want to say thank you to all of our school counselors um absolutely for the care the care and the love that they show to our students every day they keep them on track throughout their uh educational career and they get them ready to face the future um so they can meet their goals and dreams thank you for recognizing CTE month um I do want to point out that in fact the bouquets that were given to the LC Allen um honoraries tonight were made by LC Allen students in a CTE class uh I understand that that same class makes um

075bouquets and awards for many honores throughout the district for lots of schools so good job for CTE and thank you because we know that the CTE teachers have the classes that keep our students engaged they teach them skills that they can use Beyond High School uh and so um yeah we appreciate that um we want to say thank you for bringing the s rou conversation to a board meeting it's been a long time we've been waiting we're interested to hear what the new the makeup of the new board will say about SRO and the the the new voices of our three new board members SRTA continues to support the return of sro's to our schools but we know that the reason most of the people are in the room still tonight is because of the

076school closures uh we know that school closures are bad for students this might be happening it doesn't mean we have to be happy about it it's going to hurt the kids it's going to hurt the community it's going to hurt every educator and every support staff person in this District it will not be good for us and it's concerning that these plans are going forward when at the same time recent budget presentations to this board says shows that we're spending more than we budgeted this year where are the cutbacks where is the belt tightening why is the only solution seem to be to cut teachers and Clos schools when we're overspending every time we turn around we're concerned that even if we close five schools and reorganize the rest of them it's still not going

077to be enough history or history shows us and research shows us throughout the state and throughout the country that school closures don't save as much as you think they will what is this District doing to mitigate the loss of student enrollment probably everyone in this room has seen an ad from another school district in the last week encouraging those families early enroll come on up we've got an open house we'll give you Pizza we've got a jumpy right come on up here and check us out and enroll in our district what is Santa Rosa city schools doing to stop the loss we're concerned that even though we that even though that the school uh the fin what are we calling it these days the budget committee um I've lost all my nouns but the committee

078last year said hey let's hire a consultant and see what's going on with special ed so we did we paid over $30,000 for a special ed consultant to come in and tell us that guess what if we actually paid our CSEA brothers and sisters a living wage we might actually be able to hire inhouse classroom AIDS and save millions of dollars but instead of paying attention to the the recommendations of a paid consultant we are instead offering CA less than what the teachers are getting less than what the administrators are getting and it's insulting to CSEA we cannot run our school without them they need to get at least what we're getting what the teachers have already gotten have already been spending for half of this school year while they wait around to get the

079leftovers it's not fair it's not Equitable it doesn't treat them in any way shape or form as true Partners in education in this District and finally although we are I am very much looking forward to hearing from every single person that put in a blue card the fact that this meeting started by people being asked to go stand outside is disgusting these people are here because members of the board have said now I guess School number one doesn't care because they haven't come to a board meeting to tell us how great they are this process has pitted School against school and people have shown up to make their voices heard and to say we do care don't write us down is not caring and they were met with we're sorry go stand outside it's not

080okay it's going to be this way every meeting in February you've already scheduled four of them you better start planning that every single one of them needs to be somewhere bigger than this room because these people aren't going away they're coming back I'm going to recommend Santa Resa High School's Auditorium it's big it's free it has the electronic wiring that we need and you shouldn't how many a thousand let's see it's a thousand wow so I will very much look forward to the next board meeting and we'll happily address you from the floor of Santa Rosa High School's Auditorium thank you thank you president Howell next is the superintendent report superintendent mores do you have anything to share just that we continue to work um on the town hall so be um the last week

081we spent doing Town Halls it's the first time we've done Town Halls of this magnitude um so we had about 150 on Monday 150 on Tuesday about 10 the same number on Wednesday and then Maria CIO we had about 500 and so looking into tomorrow's um at Santa Rosa High we expect another large contingency so we're restructuring so just know that we're working on that we are welcoming everyone to come on out um I know that the board meetings are not a structure for dialogue because of what the way it needs to be conducted so we welcome you to join us at Santa Rosa High um we met with the team this morning to disaggregate all or type up all of the um information from the town halls and we'll be sharing those with the

082committee for Monday as well as posting it on the website um and I will um as un Lisa comes to talk about the consolidation report I know we're also putting out for those that could not attend um a a a video with the slide de giving the different scenarios as well as giving opportunities for people to give input if they weren't able to make it to the to the actual in-person town halls and we're also looking to once um the committee has made their recommendations the team is working on a map on our website that you can go and look at the the very potential scenarios that you might have so I'll let Lisa talk a little bit more about that but the last couple of weeks have been kind of all hands on deck

083um having those um dialogue at the town halls in order to be able to get more input from all of the community so thank you to all of you who have attended and we hope to see you tomorrow thank you Dr Morales next is my report as board president um there were a number of things I wanted to talk about but I know we have a lot of public comment we have a lot of business to get through so I'll keep it brief I want to announce my appointments to our board subcommittees um so for the 3X3 commit subcommittee with the city of Santa Rosa trustees Medina and de la Tor will continue and they'll be joined by trusty Jenkins for our fiscal analysis board subcommittee trustee Casten trustee Kirby and myself we will serve

084and trusty Casten will chair that committee for our board policy update subcommittee trustees Medina Casten and manieri will serve and truste Maneri will chair that committee um additionally trustees Jenkin and Kirby will serve on the district safety advi advisory round table and trusty Medina will serve on the ethnic studies District committee um I do want to put some ideas out there for the whole board to consider and possibly specifically the policy subcommittee um I am looking for ways that we can restructure our board meetings to make them more efficient I've seen over the past couple years we often end up with our most important discussion and action items very late in the night when we are not at our best um so some ideas that have come up are starting Open Session earlier in the

085day maybe holding Clos session after open session or possibly splitting Clos session in two it is currently in our board policy that we start open session at 6 PM so that might be something for the policy subcommittee to look at um I think that's all that I will share for today I'll hand it over to other board members for reports see trusty Medina and then trusty deat to thank you uh president mcnali um there's a lot on my mind a lot a lot that we're dealing with um one thing that's really important for me is that um especially our undocumented families um feel safe sending their children to school and coming to school you know there's been a announcement yesterday um from the new Administration about schools and churches no longer being safe from immigration

086raids so I just want to let people know that I've asked our superintendent to um consult with legal on what that means for our schools and how that's going to coincide with our safe haven policy that we we updated in December um because I think it's really important people feel safe coming to school um aside from that I would just like to ask um if we can take a brief moment of silence to recognize one of our former employees Ernesto Sanchez who was an amazing man humble man I've never heard anybody having anything bad to say about him he passed away recently and um there'll be a celebration of life for him on February 8th but if we could just take a quick moment of Silent I'd appreciate it than thank you trusty deor and

087then truste Jenkins thank you very much president ganali um there's obviously a lot to try and get through and we're really hoping to get through it um so I'm going to keep this brief tonight thank you thank you for being here um I do apologize for the capacity limits and thank the school communities and the parent and communities that have reached out to me and allowed me to engage with them for their thoughts and ideas and processes um so that we can continue to dig into all this information for these very important decisions that are coming up next month um we are very aware we are paying attention um nothing is going unre nothing is going onard and thank you guys very much for your commitment to this process um as painful as it's been

088um I also like to recognize that the community as a whole um has lost some more young lives this week and that has hit some of us uh closer to home than others and I just want to why I have your ear to pay attention um be respectful let's honor each other take care of each other and ensure we're taking the time to spread love because no moment is guaranteed thank you so we'll go to trusty Jenkins then trusty Casten then trusty Kirby hello um I'm going to do this old school Style by reading what I wrote um and I know we are short on time but I am going to read this so it has been a busy couple of weeks um I've been embedded in the community listening and participating as a board

089member and a parent I've attended two Town Halls so far and plan to attend Santa Rosa um tomorrow I attended the school closure and consolidation meeting on Friday of which I truly was pleasantly surprised by the process and the discussion and the thoughtfulness of the rankings um I was at the the Bonte versus Santa Rosa basketball game and saw om cross the way Sport and panther Pride I love that um also helped out at the Montgomery Education Foundation crab crab feed which showcased our beautiful Talent as well I've a meeting with groups of individuals groups and individuals discussing the challenges we're facing and making sure that all of the stones are being looked under for Creative Solutions I want the public to know that I'm reading every single email and we have gotten a lot

090I'm not responding to all of them um especially if there's other people on them but I am reading every single one on a personal note the continued stress the closures are creating is palpable I've got I personally have two high schoolers who have to submit their class choices for next year by Friday then turn 16 the next day hbd Offspring they are third generation Montgomery um and Bennett Valley roots are strong in this town we're already losing students and quite frankly my team my term as a trustee would likely also be cut short um as I personally may need to move if this nonsense continues and we will deal with that as it comes um I do continue to stand with our community regarding the high schools and I want to make sure that the

091least amount of harm is done to the communities directly impacted by any of the closures that we decide on next month we've done enough harm to our older students by not protecting them in the last couple years and we've seen numbers decline at certain schools directly related to ignoring the community cries for help it's important to address too to address too that as a trustee um we've not had conversations about even what each of us is leaning towards I'd love if a decision was made but it has not even begun we have not made any decisions I know the rumors are flying but we have not even had the start of a conversation as a board and as a team finally I want to take um a second to recognize parents so often we hear

092that parents are not pulling their weight we need more volunteers Etc I want you all to know that I see you I know so many more parents would love to be here tonight and students however there were excuse me um they are where they're needed and that's supporting the schools and this and their youth um I see you trying to get food and tummies and making sure that jackets at least are available even if your little one refuses to wear it I see you volunteering when you can I see you sending emails sending snacks sending supplies appreciating staff I see you doing the absolute best in the everchanging stages of parenting and leaning on each other when our communities are in super challenging situations I see you and I appreciate you thank you thank you

093I'm going to keep my uh report very short uh I attended the governor's budget update presentation provided by the California school board um Association uh looking at many of the things that are going to impact our discussions next month and I also had the opportunity to attend uh a course on the foundations of governance both of those were virtual and provided by uh csba I've had lots of meetings with parents groups of parents and teachers and uh staff from the different schools at this point I think I've met with at least someone from every one of our high schools please use the email um we're never going to have an opportunity in two-minute increments to be able to share um information in these meetings and to the extent that I'm able I'm going to schedule

094as many meetings with you all um as moving through this process so please reach out through the email my invitation stands um and don't think you're not important enough to ask for that because you absolutely are I'm a parent in this district and you should not hesitate to reach out to me and ask to meet with me uh I had the opportunity to get a tour of ccla with um truste Jenkins appreciate that um also attended the Mont Gunner crab feed which was a great event and I loved all the student performances the dancing and the uh musicians very impressive and I attended the Piner Town Hall I'll be at the Santa Rosa uh Town Hall tomorrow night and I want to emphasize that just because we're hosting these on high school campuses these are

095the town halls that are considering all of the consolidation reconfiguration for Elementary in middle school so just cuz it's at a high school campus please do not uh think that that doesn't mean that this isn't the venue for elementary and middle school conversations I have heard that from some folks and um you know so tomorrow night is the last of these and I I hope to see you all there thank you and again quickly I attended the Town Hall in Montgomery last week will also be in Santa Rosa tomorrow night um additionally uh piggybacking on what director Jenkin said don't think that because I'm not answering your email I'm not reading them I have read every email I appreciate them all um there are just so many there's no way I'm going to be able

096to answer all the emails but I am reading everyone thank you student board members Zuna do you have a report okay uh really quick um so the superintendent student council met um recently and I wanted to go over the professional development day on the 31st um and it will consist of a a student made and student organized panel where the council has put together that the council has put together to serve and provide insight to teachers and staff from all around the district regarding our student experience and what we would like to see hear and feel from our teachers and staff in the future um remember to please reach out to myself and your representatives representatives from each High School um from the council and we we serve to represent your needs um voice and

097requests um reach out to me through email or just D DM me on Instagram um and remember to get to know your representatives um from each high schools because those are the people that serve you um and though this is a new system it can be as a great tool in the future and right now so thank you so much and now we have our school closure and consolidation report and we have associate superintendent Lisa augus here to present thank you president MCN excuse me superintendent Dr Morales members of our board and our Santa Rosa city schools Community here in person as well as online uh just a quick uh report as it's been shared uh last week we held four Town Hall dialogue events and all were well attended ranging from approximately 150 participants

098to close to 400 uh we especially appreciate so many student voices uh we have one more scheduled tomorrow evening at Santa Rosa High School uh unfortunately the format that had worked well for 150 did not work so well for um the larger group as far as flow uh with tomorrow being the last today we are expecting another large turnout and are adjusting the format of the way that we will hold our breakout groups we also received feedback that some members of our community were not able to access uh the in-person evening events and based on this Fe feedback as well as as one of the trustees mentioned that some uh parents felt that it was geared towards high school or the high school voices were maybe louder than some of the elementary um so we

099based on that feedback uh we did create a survey that uh went out this evening on parents square with video links explaining the alternative scenarios as well as the standard scenario of the closure of three Elementary one middle and one high uh so that went out on parent square and it's also linked on the district's main page uh while the meeting was going on this evening responses received by Friday morning will be included in the summary information provided to the school consolidation and closure advisory committee at their for their meeting on Monday uh last Friday that committee uh did hold a special meeting to continue their work from the December meeting and we're so very appreciative of our support staff and the committee members for their work late on a Friday evening uh they were

100able to reach consensus on some rankings and will continue their work on Monday January 27th this is scheduled to be their last meeting in order to finalize recommendations and their report however we do have a special date held for February 3rd if they're not able to finalize those details um only if it's needed we are working to finalize location for upcoming meetings to accommodate the the larger public participation our business services team has also been working um as I've shared before on details and preparation for potential scenarios one way this is happening is in our information and evaluation Department uh where Dr bardelli has been working on a boundary map that uh will be made public to that will be made available to the public to be able to try some different scenarios and then

101to submit them so when we come to you with recommendations related to boundaries we will have some input um on which are preferred with some some things in there um gives us a way to to run some here if this happens then where where does this look like it would go AI kind of starts it for you and then you can move around specific census blocks so we expect that to to be released next Tuesday after the um committee has finalized their their rankings thank you thank you now this is a report not a discussion item so are there any quick clarifying questions from the board before we go to public comment all right then we will go to public comment I have a number of blue cards um each public comment will be limited

102to 90 seconds and we will limiting the total public comment on this item to 90 minutes that means that we might not get through everyone I hope that we do um unfortunately this meeting has a hard cut off at midnight and we have other items that we need to get through so 90 seconds each 90 minutes total I will read names three at a time so you know when your turn is coming up um first we will have Deja Jones followed by Mike Lope followed by Gabriela geffner president MCN just one clarification if people are outside is there somebody like announcing or making sure that they're able to come up can we have a staff member um helping to manage that if folks are outside when their turn comes up thank you you thank you

103hello yes go ahead uh hello my name is Deja Jones and I am a senior at Santa Rosa high school and my brother graduated this past year I'm involved in many sports two being Varsity softball and cross country I'm in three different choirs one of which just sang with the uh Warriors or just sang at the Warriors and with the Santa Rosa Symphony multiple times um in addition I am the secretary of the coral Student Union and many of my friends are a part of arquest and our student athletes as well Santa Rosa offers programs uh to learn different skills Concepts and techniques in a variety of programs and classes rquest FFA CTE band choir and a variety of sports peer counseling and dozens of student Le clubs and electives only scratch the surface of

104what Santa Rosa offers to its students largely funded by the Sant Rosa Foundation fund the spirit of the Panthers is so strong we've lasted over 150 years we fought in 2009 to keep our wood shop open that was that is paid for by the federal and state taxes and like all of our CTE schools we fought in just this year when the district shut down our show Dog Sees God and every single time Santa Rosa has per prevailed our flame never extinguished this will be no different nowhere in the district will you find a school so open so diverse so Community Based than Santa Rosa the Beating Heart and Soul of this town is the high school our students staff and alumni all agree that Santa Rosa is worthy of lasting to this day I

105don't think any school should be shut down but do not punish Santa Rosa's students teachers and staffs because you think we don't care once a panther always a pan than you de next we have Mike Lopez followed by Gabriela geffner followed by Don newfeld hello my name is Mike Lopez I'm past president and a founding member of the Allen High School Foundation 14 years ago I got a call from Willie toile from the ltia factory you telling me that he we needed to help to the kids on the south side of town they're they're being grossly under underlooked and we met with the principal at the time Mary gaale stabin Brian phoh and five brace students who shared their struggles to stay in school there wasn't a dry ey in in the room that day

10615 community members uh committed to change the lives of these students and we created the LC Allen High School Foundation to help the underserved uh you heard the results from uh the foundation from president uh Vince furora so the results speak themselves but it's much more than scholarships it's about giving kids hope uh we now have alumni that are serving on our board proof that the full circle impact of our community closing LC in high school would be a tragic loss for these students in the hardworking families they deserve a chance to dream plan and Achieve and give back to the community they love I understand the difficulty of this decision however I urge you to consider the progress and promise of Elion high school students when weighing your options let's continue to give them

107the opportunities they've earned thank you thank you next is Gabriella geffner followed by Don newfeld followed by Rustin prior ottenfeld good evening my name is Gabriela geffner and I'm a senior at Santa Rosa high school but the panther pride has been ingrained in me since I was born as my dad has been a counselor at srhs for 23 years my brother graduated from the school in 2023 and is now a successful student at UCLA I grew up excited to attend the school going to the 140th anniversary celebration at 7 years old in this past fall performing at the 150th celebration as the president I've been given endless opportunities to challenge myself and become prepared for college with a well-rounded we well-rounded resume I'm a three- sport athlete with amazing coaches and take AP classes with

108wonderful teachers all while learning music as a fine arts student the art Quest and journalism programs have given me the resources to start a school podcast with professional recording equipment and a studio I have many friends in the FFA program who give me confidence that California farming will be in great hands these programs I speak of are just a sliver of what SRS offers and the history of our school speaks for itself please don't close srhs a school so awesome they named a town after it thank you thank you next is Don newfeld followed by Rustin prior hodenfield followed by Natasha starts with a D good evening my name is Don newfeld I teach academic language development newcomer English sophomore English and advanced placement language and composition at Piner High School this is my 24th

109year teaching and my third year in the Santa Rosa city schools district and I will most likely be getting a reduction in for Force notice in March the rumor is that anyone who has worked in srcs for four years or less should expect a notice I'm here tonight to ask you the board to be incredibly Mindful and intentional about giving out riff notices to School Employees this March I ask that you only riff the positions that you know are not going to be needed last year srcs gave reduction and force notices to 78 teachers only 17 of those teachers received final riff notices that means that 61 teachers did not actually need to go through that extremely chaotic itic stressful and disheartening experience over riffing staff in Santa Rosa city schools is a longstanding mismanaged

110response to a history of mismanaged funds please be intentional not to do this again we will lose many great teachers and support staff this process impacts students teachers and families please be mindful intentional and deliberate when determining riff notices thank you thank you next is Rustin prior hodenfield followed by Natasha D followed by V hang so I'm not really a good public speaker but I thought I'd give it a try um because I love my school um hello my name is Rustin PR hodenfield I'm a senior at San Rosa high school I'm a fourth generation Panther um I grew up dreaming wanting to go to Santa Rosa High School my mom went there and she said that she had an amazing time and I grew up dreaming one day that I go to C Roa

111high school and uh I play two sports I'm a baseball player and a football player um I'm also a member of student government I've been in there all four years um and just what centera high school means to me is that just all the opportunities that it gives me from the um the uh College and Career Center counselor Miss bachelder has helped me with my college applications and getting to the next Point um helping me find what I want to be when I grow up um and also the coaches who have um taught me how to be the best version of myself and to keep striving for perfection even though I may not make it there because nobody's perfect um what I also love about our school is just the um history the tradition such

112as the fight song that you've heard us yelling numerous times throughout this meeting um and that's in the main building upstairs led by our history teachers one of them Miss spell um and I just uh this school is just going to stick with me for the rest of my life and I hope it could stick with the future generations of our community as well once a panther always a panther thank you thank you next is matasha D followed by V Hong followed by m Lee pervis good evening and could you state your full name for the record uh Natasha deacons good evening I've been a teacher for 25 years in this District at Maria Creo high school and I can tell you 25 years later all Santa Rosa city schools look very different I don't

113envy your position I'd like to acknowledge that the work you've done about to do is incredibly challenging but it must start with an honest reflection of who we are today and more importantly who we want to be tomorrow well it's easy to blame school closures on declining enrollment it's evident that our current lack of vision and guiding principles has led to to a fragmented school system one that is now pitting School against school is pretty evident here tonight whatever decision you ultimately make I hope you'll not look at just making cuts for today or next year but you help craft a long-term Vision a Clear Vision moving forward is essential to Healing the pain this process is causing consider this why do our superintendents continue to come from outside our own Community you have a

114hard task but you also have a golden opportunity to make Santa Rosa city schools better I hope you find the courage necessary to do so thank you next is V Hong followed by m Lee pervis followed by to fam hi everyone my name is V hang and I'm the associated student body president as s Rosa High School this school has become a second home to me my second family and a safe place where I feel like I can learn and step up step out of my comfort zone and just this year s Rosa high school has celebrated its 150e anniversary ensuring that it's the eighth oldest school in California the school that paved the way for other schools everybody knows that Santa Rosa high school has one of the best spirit and tradition and that

115is built on generations of Panther Pride besides all of this all of this facts of the past we are one of the most populated campus with around 1,600 students and have one of the highest transfer rates across the district this is the School of the Arts the school where creativity generates possibilities to turn into reality Sosa High School is a great school and it's a school that can never be replaced thank you thank you next is May pervis followed by ta fam followed by Gemma Roberts I am ba pervis I'm an engineer parent volunteer for Science and Math at Santa Rosa high school at the December escac meeting the community overwhelmingly asked to please minimize the impact to high school students who are at a critical juncture in their life for Career College in teaching

116CTE engineering robotics at Windsor high for stem core had homeless students migrant workers English learners but it was my transfer student from the recently closed El Molino that stumbled when the promising stem student fell into a funk and stopped coming to school for weeks in second semester I and their mom intervene to get them back on track to narrowly graduate now take that one student who went through the trauma of their school closing would you choose to multiply that by a thousand students or by 1500 students please please do the right thing and minimize the number of displaced high school students do not close Santa Rosa one of our largest schools do not displace more students than needed for a couple of rank points thank you thank you next is tfam followed by Gemma Roberts

117followed by Nessa cile good evening everyone my name is tfam and I'm a proud freshman at Cal high school to me CA High School is more than just a school it is a historical Place filled with 150 years of beautiful memories from generations to Generations as I walk through the Halls this school resembles a true High School experience like the ones where I always see in TV shows and movies even with little experiences I am proud that our school is filled with tradition spirit and energy before entering a sport game I can always hear the Roars and Echoes from the students whether we win or loose and this energy is truly unique closing down CA High School is not just shutting down a school it means losing a piece of our Town's heart it's a

118place where students like me can build memories that will last a lifetime I stand here today not just as a student but as a panther proud of my school and honored to be part of his long Legacy I hope this school can last for many more years for future generations and a place I can always come back to thank you thank thank you next we have Gemma Roberts followed by Nessa Cecil followed by shik shikaya kahoro do we have Gemma Roberts Messa why don't you go ahead while we wait for Gemma hello my name is Messa Cecil and I'm currently a junior at Santa Rosa High School I absolutely hate public speaking but I'm here because this is very important to me both of my teacher both of my parents teach at Piner and I

119grew up on campus while my parents graded my brother went to Piner but I always knew that I wanted to go to Santa Rosa High both schools feel like home to me please don't close any of the high schools this is a pivotal time for students they're create they're making friendships that will last their lifetimes please don't rip us apart I know that many teens feel the same and I see everybody here from many high schools please do not hurt our communities thank you thank you did we find Gemma Roberts all right I'll put her card to the side for now so next we have shikella kahoro followed by Lee Corey followed by Juan Diego um hello hi um good evening I'm speaking today on behalf of the students of Maria Coro high school as

120a senior I am currently the ASV president our leadership program is Central to our school inspiring students to be active participants in shaping our Puma Community these students are dedicated to creating events supporting their peers and building Unity on campus muray koreo is a place where students are constantly putting their best foot forward whether it's in your education participating in school events or working together as a community instead of having numerous students speak on behalf of Korea we created some handouts which you've received in an email yesterday and they were provided tonight showcasing some of our school successes because the board meetings occurred during final exams multiple School sporting events and even drama rehearsals we've been busy being students we also want to respect your time and not overwhelm the meeting with student prospectives all

121saying largely the same thing save our school do not mistake our lack of speaking out as a sign of apathy of lack of concern we're deeply caring and concerned about our school students and the Korea community in fact we have well over 500 community members attend last week's town hall meeting and many were koreo students hoping to have their voices heard we are proud of our school proud of our programs and proud to call Maria Korea our home thank you thank you next we have Lee Cory followed by Juan Diego followed by re he Reed heavner thank you members of the board and good evening my name is Lee Corey and I'm a senior at sanza high school I'm here to urge you not to close my school it's a pillar of a broader Community

122within our city and has has been since it opened 150 years ago what is truly unique about Santa Rosa High School is our history it's the oldest school in the district and the ninth oldest in the state we have an on-site Museum this school is so old that we have enough history to have a museum just about Santa Rosa High School on our campus that kind of History cannot be erased in the name of financial stability to make up for mistakes that our school did not make that kind of history is incredibly unique to close santha high school would be a mistake you may be wondering why the support and advocacy for Santa Rosa High School you've seen tonight is coming now long after this process of school closure began I personally did not speak

123before last week at the school consolidation advisory committee meeting because I understand the weight and complexity of this decision and know that this board is not making this decision based on whether or not I like my school but some recent comments about Santa Rosa's lack of participation have drawn me here to make my thoughts heard and to let this board know that Santa Rosa does care so I urge you do not close Santa Rosa High thank you next we have Juan Diego followed by Reed heavner followed by Emma Vega is there a Wan Diego here can I start right now yes go ahead hello good evening everyone my name is ju Diego and I arrive to this to the United State we noting in December 17 class mariao on January 6 of 2 of 2023

124it was my first day of school and I fear and fear consumed me because I thought I would understand anything however from the moment I arrived this institution welcome me open with open arms and gave me the opportunity to progress as a student and as a person in my second year of high school I decided to take to the Le into AP and nor classes I want to show that Latinos can do it too I know that each one of us has a dream I know we can make it happen not only those of who of us who have left behind part of our life nostalgic memories that stain us today but also those who were born here who have deep history and wherever they go on this B land we always feel at home

125so we only one J in the United States I decided to start my AP PAAD my teacher like Mr Henry Mr hitchko were always there for me to help me in my classes the most training how the educational staff at this of this institution cares about the performance of their students I couldn't have do it alone you always need guidance along the way and my and I'm thank I'm thankful for the entire Maria K high school team for not leaving me alone during these years I decided to take the leadership class with the goal of contributing to my institution which has given me so much for since my arrival and now in this ins in circumstances today I speak for the students for us Mario Kio is not just under High School in Santa Rosa

126is the of all of us is like a family thank you so much thank you next we have Reed heavner followed by Emma Vega followed by Jordan Walton hello Mar heavner we the students of Santa Ros High School are members of an active Dynamic Community we take joy in our community and in the interactions that transpire there we as a community do not want our school to close and do not believe that it should be closed we thank the members of the cers of City Schools school board and school consolidation committee for the consideration of this petition that was the petition that over the last week was signed by 476 senat of high students because we care about our school recently we've heard talk that SRS students don't care that we don't show up enough

127that we won't fight for our school and I'm here today to say that that's wrong we care so I'd like to ask this board please be fair I know that on paper we look like an easy school to shut down but there's so much more to the story than what the statistics say both financial and otherwise so please set aside your biases and look at the Fuller picture please don't close our school I would like to present these signatures of the petition to the board thank you for your time thank you next we have Emma Vega followed by Jordan Walton followed by Katherine starts with an R good evening Santa Rosa school board members committee members and Community my name is Emma Vega I'm a senior at LS Allen High School I want to start

128what LS Allen is doing right now with these amaz amazing programs like FFA band Dance Art Mariachi and sports L is one of two Santa Rosa schools that have FFA FFA teaches agriculture leadership builds confidence problem solving F fa brings Community as you can see I'm currently in my band uniform we recently just got these our band is doing amazing things our main focus currently is getting our name out June 11th we will be performing at Disneyland we are also the only High School band that performs with the middle school which is ccla we love being together as a community I want to give praise to our football team this year they have gone they have achieved something Elsie Allen hasn't been able to get in a very long time this year they went to

129a championship they created a community with being a team and seeing them work and communicating together shows that yes they can do it LC Allen can do it in the last four years being at LC I have seen community and everything we do we LC Allen come together and make great things our programs make us come together so I ask you please consider keeping Allen open thank you thank you next we have Jordan Walton followed by Katherine RDA followed by Payton Sanson hello and thank you to the members of the board for letting me speak my name is Jordan Walton and I'm currently a senior at San Rosa high school and and hopefully a next year senior at Santa Rosa I'm currently in the concert choir and we will be playing varsity baseball in the

130spring for two and a half years SRS has been a place that has offered me and many other students the opportunity to learn new skills the through the art Quest and Career Technical education classes like autoshop and Manufacturing that are offered at s Ros I've also met new people that I'm glad to Now call friends and I've strengthened my prior friendships that I got in Middle School Santa Rosa is the only only school that I have had the pleasure of having these opportunities thank you for your time thank you next is Katherine R followed by pton Sansone followed by Meg Peterson hi everyone I want to urge the board to consider the 7 through 12 model this would bring about the same Financial outcome as this 311 closure scheme with better outcomes for youth in

131our community for example data from other large districts show that High School Clos closures lead to significant Dropout rates increased crime lower educational achievement such as attending junior college or college and kids who attend high schools that close also make an average 4 to 8% less over their lifetime compared to those not experiencing this in contrast youth who attend s through 12 programs have better outcomes both socially and emotionally and educationally than youth attending middle than high school for example youth in 7 through 12 programs tend to have higher attendance and lower Dropout rates this model would also allow for the consolidation of resources into larger schools attracting students with special programs such as stem or Sports um I'd like if you could ask the school consolidation committee to suggest alternatives to just the 311

132such as closures to support moving towards a 7 to2 model um and there is data showing that elementary school closures do impact educational outcomes similarly to high school closures but the students recover likely because they a lot more school to go through thanks so much thank you next is pton Sanson followed by Meg Peterson followed by Dorian Decker apologies if that's wrong hello my name is pton and I'm a sophomore at San Rosa High attending this school has been the best decision I have ever made no place has ever made me more feel more loved and cared for than this school I honestly don't know what I would do without it I love going here every day knowing that I have staff who who genuinely care about me I also have met some of my

133closest friends here if I had never enrolled at this school I would have never been able to make have met these incredible people and it pains me to think about how my life would be if they weren't in it our campus is also extremely inclusive I'm not afraid to be myself and be judged for it I also know that many other kids here have found their true colors and are no longer afraid to let them shine a big contributor to this is our amazing Artest program this unique and unmovable program allows many students like myself to be able to express their emotions in doing something they love I've seen students who have gone from completely hating school to absolutely loving it because of the connection to the Arts but srhs isn't just a School for

134the Arts it's a school where everyone's voice is allowed to be heard a school where no one is allowed to be excluded and most importantly a school where students and Staff feel loved I seriously cannot express enough how much a school meets me so please listen me when I tell you you cannot close this school thank you thank you next we have Meg Peterson followed by Dorian Decker followed by Erica lipin vich hi I'm Meg Peterson I'm a parent of two students at Hidden Valley Elementary School I want to implore the board to seriously consider and perhaps confirm that they will not be renewing the charter middle and high schools in feeder districts these schools are taking students from our school district and disrupting the funds that we should be receiving if we are closing

135schools in our primary and secondary districts we should not allow the feeder districts to steal our students and further impact our fiscal stability I implore the public that if you're truly passionate about saving all of the high schools get behind the 7 to2 model it's done successfully in both urban and rural areas throughout our state other states and internationally it's been proven to be the best education model outside of a TK through eight system seventh and eighth graders are typically separated in sub campuses much like TK and kindergarten on the elementary school level they don't have much more interaction than a TK or kindergartener does With A fifth or sixth grader outside of planned things such as extracurriculars advanced studies or in sports 7th to 12th has been proven to be to reduce suspension rates

136reduce behavior issues and reduce gang activity it's been proven to increase academic scores graduation rates and build stronger and more robust communities they can often expand programs such as Monty's IB Program into the seventh grade it can allow schools to specialize and provide more and better academic Athletic Club and extracurricular activities for all students thank you next we have Dorian Decker followed by Erica lipin vich followed by Ross win hello my name is Dorian Decker and I am a senior at Santa Rosa high school I'm also the president of our instrumental music program on which I'm speaking out today to me the band room is my home and the band my family I spent so much time with my peers and band and I would not choose to spend it any other way we have

137worked so hard together and we have accomplished so much together over the years our ensembles have traveled the world from the Great Wall of China to the Serene and holy beauty of the Vatican and then just over a month our band will be going to New York to play in Carnegie Hall not only will we be performing the music we have selected but we have also been chosen to work with composer Amy scua to write a brand new piece of music that we will play the world premiere of we are the only School in the district who has ever had such an honor and we will not let this incredible Victory be be turned into a defeat our concert will be one of Celebration not one of mourning everyone in our ensembles all of my

138friends have worked so hard to grow our music program and as it is finally starting to go beyond what it used to be I hope the district can see what an incredible Community we have at our school and will continue to to support all of the programs makes Santa Rosa high school so important to the community thank you thank you next we have Erica olenich followed by Ross win followed by Angelie K hello my name is Erica leanovich parent of two kids at Hidden Valley Elementary School I'm not from Santa Rosa but my husband is I'm here to tell you about how I fell in love not with my husband but with the Santa Rosa Community when my now husband and I met freshman year of college all he could talk about was his amazing

139group of Santa Rosa High School among omry friends the stories he told were legendary the relationships he fostered there were epic and when I finally met the sananta Rosa crew I felt like I too had found my forever of friends I knew then and there I was in love 20 years later when it was time for us to start a family we boomeranged back to Santa Rosa to settle down largely because it was where the Santa Rosa high school and Montgomery crew settled down to raise their kids and it's the community we always dreamed of for our kids I'm here to speak in favor of a 7 through 12 model not because it has statistically better overall student outcomes not because it's the only model that saves all the high schools but because it's the

140only model that will give our kids the opportunity to start making their own life long Santa Rosa friendships sooner I'm in favor of my kids joining the panther community to years earlier save all the high school support 7 through 12 thank you next we have Ross win followed by anelie K followed by Zoe Ser hello everyone my name is Ross win and I am a junior at Santa Rosa high school now CER of the high school has a big um connection to me and my family because because my family's been going to Santa Rosa high school for four generations my great-grandfather went there my grandmother and grandfather went there and my mother went there and now I am there this school means so much to me that it's unimaginable I have made so many friends

141at santaa high school thanks to the amazing art Quest program that I don't know what I would do without them in freshman year I was an outcast I was not the person you want to hang out with but thanks to arquest and everyone in it I was able to come out of my shell even more than I already was and make friends with everyone there artquest and Santa Rosa high school has changed me and I'm so happy for it and I really hope that you decide not to close Santa Rosa because I want to give other kids that choice thank you thank you next we have Angeli k followed by Zoe Sero followed by kayn Wen and anelie could you say your full name for the record my name is anre ker I am a

142junior from Montgomery High School as well as an IB diploma candidate I am not here to put my school against others but to advocate for a high school that calls itself a family and so are 560 other monk Army students as shown on the signed petition in front of you while they may not all be here in this room their advocacy for Montgomery is just as powerful these signatures were collected today in one day and they represent nearly half of our student body to close our school would be a tragic disruption not only for my IB education but the entire school's education we host the Special Olympics each year have a new building under construction several new murals around the whole campus and the largest special education program we send and have sent our students

143to Stanford Yale Columbia Berkeley UCLA and many more incredible universities and most importantly we stand to be the most diverse High School in the district our students are asking you to preserve their family I hope that you can hear my voice their voice and everyone's voices thank you thank you next we have Zoe SEL followed by kayn Wen followed by G Dean Johnson good evening my name is Zoe Sero and I'm a senior at Santa Rosa High School I've attended five different school districts and for a long time I struggled with bullying even though I live outside the district the artquest program was the reason I was able to transfer here it gave me the chance to focus on my passion for music explore opportunities I wouldn't have had anywhere else and build lifelong friendships

144since then I've received a lot of report support especially from the staff in our College and Career Center and I'm proud to say that I'm now a questbridge national match finalist I couldn't have gotten this far without the resources and guidance the schools offers as an introvert I never saw myself in leadership roles but Santa Rosa High has helped me change that by providing me the confidence to try I've taken on roles such as vice president of our school's choir club and the Secretary of our aapi club the activism present at this school sparked my interest in serving my community which is why I'm a youth leader for Sonoma County environment program and an employee of the city of Santa Rosa Santa Rosa High has given me more than just an education it's helped me

145grow into who I am today shutting it down would take away the opportunities that so many of us rely on to succeed please keep Santa Rosa High open for us for the community and for the future thank you thank you next we have kayn Wen followed by Dean Johnson followed by Chanel deser good evening I'm kayin junior class officer at koreo speaking on behalf of my school we'd like to personally thank Jeremy deor for kindly showing up to our town hall meeting last Thursday at all the previous Town Hall meetings the board displayed their four options including the 311 plan for the public to have a chance to vote on which option they prefer for those who missed it at our koreo meeting a student organized poster was displayed entailing our option six which suggests

146the closing this number of schools ensuring that the district office fa equivalent cuts and stops overspending this option not only prioritizes us students but seen through the total of votes it's it's obviously the most s sought out option the overwhelming and apparent reaction of option six continues to prove that none of the options suggested by the board should even be considered because simply they aren't sufficient enough I urge you to keep all high schools open and listen to your community thank you thank you next we have Dean Johnson followed by Chanel deser followed by sorry I'm I'm struggling struggling y'all um uh first name starts with a J last name Burgess hello my name is Dean Jansen I am the ASB vice president at s Rosa high school and a senior in arquest although here

147here representing s High School I am speaking for all high school and middle school students in the district over the years we have had to handle a w fire a global pandemic violence in our schools an oppressive Administration and now the closure of a school a Brown University study shows high school closures lead to a dislocation that causes a dramatic decline in test scores a surgeon behavior issues and other traumatic issues these are not only statistics these are now our inevitable future I urge this committee committee and the board to truly recognize the weight of the traumas we've carried and how these budget cuts will have lasting impacts on the students lives I urge you to provide extensive support to the students as well as the teachers who are being displaced particularly those 10th and

14811th graders who will be forced to attend foreign high schools during these critical years of development this upheaval will affect them long into their adulthood you are now responsible for the Mental effects these students will face you are now responsible for the districtwide decrease in academics that is bound to come you are now responsible for making the the the budget and funding to make sure that these statistics don't become our reality your overspending has lost the Comm Comm community's trust as well as the over the years you consistently failed to fulfill your primary responsibility to protect your students and provide them with a high education that effectively prepares them for the future thank you thank you next we have Chanel deser followed by Jay Burgess followed by Kristen Reed Janelle deser follow followed by Jay

149Burgess followed by Kristen Reed go ahead hello everyone my name is Chanel dor and I am a junior at Maria CIO High School I stand before you today not just as a student of koreo but a representative of all Juniors across the district as a junior I'm preparing for the future and my education at Creo has been vital to that process many of us like myself have worked tirelessly towards building relationships with teachers and staff who understand our needs and ambitions losing the school means overlooking teacher and student ties and the teacher recommendations that students like myself have worked towards achieving as seniors but I am not alone all Juniors at all high schools are experiencing this fear I urge the board to look closely at ways to keep all high schools open and if

150that's not possible a transition plan must be formed immediately it's not easy for students to just transfer to a different school and they all need extra attention and support wherever they land any last minute moves disrupt all social and academic ties between students which affect their last and most important year of their High School career thank you for your time thank you next is Jay Burgess followed by Christen Reed followed by Maddie Smith um hello everyone my name is Janie Burgess I am a senior at CIO and I'm delivering this message on behalf of the student voice Club of which I am the President of this situation has been tough for all but we want to emphasize just how much more difficult this has been for students at all schools and in all grades every

151school has felt scared these past few weeks scared that they won't have a school to return to after graduation or that they will have to abruptly spend their next few years even their senior year at a new school with completely new people but why have we been the ones that are the most worried when none of this is our fault and why are students facing such grave repercussions from mistakes that did not come from our end not only does closing schools greatly hurt students but it also hurts teachers who fear of losing their entirely live entire livelihoods all of this is why the cuts being made to make up the deficit must be fairly distributed between the school and the district level this should not be a reim this should not be a reimagining of

152how students and teachers can change their lives because the district level the place where the whole issue originated is where changes need to be made it is not any school fault for this deficit it is the districts and the changes made in the upcoming decision need to address that thank you thank you next we have Christ Reed followed by Maddie Smith followed by Rob Bert thank you on the side good evening my name is Kristen Reed and I teach at Montgomery High School I'm here this evening to speak about the school consolid and closure issue I have very deep reservations about our district administration's ability to implement and manage these changes and closures reservations born of nearly 20 years working here what previous program or policy implementation on a level like this has the district

153enacted successfully the a tog roll out was abysmal and has resulted in among many other things waves of waivers of a startling breadth and number frequently in the 11th Hour causing Untold hours of additional work for counselors and stress for students and their families yes we're ahead of the state's curve with offering ethnic studies courses but again the teachers in classrooms have been tasked with picking up the slack and forging ahead after initial trainings and that's just two things in the secondary Arena the problem with for example something like a 7 through 12 model isn't the model itself there definitely strengths that if it was structured soundly implemented properly and supported fully would make it beneficial for the school Community the problem is that I am supremely skeptical of the district's ability to do this

154I fully confident that it will be utter chaos from start to well into the beginning of school and any amelioration of that would be due to the Herculean efforts of staff on site making their desperate and exhausted best efforts to do right by the students who come to us to learn to have a secure place to be I urge you as the board to hold District administrators accountable for the work for which they're responsible to ask them critical questions to refuse equivocation to force uncomfortably honest your time is up next next we have Maddie Smith followed by Rob Bert followed by Cheyenne Sena hi my name is Matti Smith and I'm a senior at Korea I'm here today to call attention to the district's consistent lack of effort to provide long-term solutions to its own

155problems right now the district is in a huge deficit and their solution is closing schools but my question is how long will it take to be in the exact same position one two or five years down the line if the district doesn't stop overspending and budget effectively school closures is a short-term solution to a way bigger problem we need to stop the bleeding first sure but the community has seen no plans and no commitment from the district to change its behavior and that is the issue we have absolutely no reason to believe that this will in the long run solve the problem we can't make and throw out policies and budgets every year when another different person comes in with an idea we need someone to stick around and stick to a plan the community

156should not be in this situation students should not be in this situation please show the community a sustainable plan for regrowth and prove to us that being here is worth our time thank you thank you next we have Rob Bert followed by Cheyenne Sana followed by Jude wiking my name is Rob Bert I'm a charter member of LC Allen created the drama program there for 22 years I witnessed daily how important it was for young people from underserved communities to have a place that was theirs in a city that often felt like it was not theirs at all my students produced Dynamic theater because they had a place of Their Own that gave them the agency to create I had students win playwriting awards at Stanford and Harvard respectively one of my students was the

157only Santa Rosa student ever to be named a presidential scholar take away the only place in Santa Rosa in Southwest Santa Rosa where there is a strong public school and you will rob those students of their unique identity LC Allen students have been resilient and productive with huge numbers of them going on to serve their community in Santa Rosa as a whole Elsey Allen students stay in this community and give back by working as teachers nurses firefighters business people they must not be abandoned eliminating their sole Community School will provide economic hardships surrounding transportation and child care doing their families a great social disservice by making them assimilate into other schools it's time to stop marginalizing the Southwest Santa Rosa city schools must do what's right and recognize the injust of shutting off the Southwest

158Community to opportunities that have made them and Santa Rosa strong an entire generation thank you your time is up thank you next we have Cheyenne Sena followed by Jude wiking followed by Tomas Selenas hello um my name is Cheyenne Senna and I'm a senior at s Wasa high school I have one younger brother who's a freshman here and another one who will hopefully be attending here next school year I can't even begin to explain how how much of an impact this school has had on my life being a member and a captain on our track and cross country team a peer counselor in our new Wellness Center a singer and choir and a new member in the band has truly shaped who I am as a person the community in each of these fears on

159campus are truly rich and unlike anything I've ever experienced and I know many students staff and alumni I feel the same our school spirit is loud and proud our Panther Pride coursing through our veins we bleed orange and black in every track meet cross country race basketball game wrestling match football game and so many more events I've been to santaa high school is always the loudest and proudest team to be there we show up when we fight we encourage on one another and lift each other up we have history rooted in our foundation and we share the name of the city I encourage you all to remember who we are as a school who we are as a community and who we are as a family do not take our home away from us we're

160here proud to rep our orange black proud to be a panther don't even try to take that away from us thank you thank you next we have Jude wking followed by Tomas Selenas followed by Carla wking uh hello I'm Jude wiking I'm a freshman in Montgomery High School um I love going to Montgomery High School I participate in sports and after school activities I'm in all honors classes and my dream is to go to a UC school closing this school would damage my chances of getting into any of the schools that I would like to attend because I won't be able to get into the classes that I have set up for next year I have two younger brothers that more than anything want to go to Montgomery High School and Montgomery High School is

161more than just a school it's a community and a culture closing it wouldn't be fair to any the students that go there or any that plan to go there thank you thank you next we have Tomas Selenas followed by Carla wiking followed by Isabella Martinez is Tomas Selenas here all right I will put his card to the side for now so we have Carla wking followed by Isabella Martin followed by Kimmy P hi thank you uh my name is Carla wking and I am a parent of a freshman Montgomery student you just heard from him and hopefully I will be at Montgomery for 12 years because I have two more boys waiting in the wings um I would just like to start by saying that I'm heartbroken that our larger Santa Rosa Community is being

162pitted against each other it makes me very sad and I don't want to see any high schools closed um but I need to say my two cents for Montgomery I feel like we're being punished for for image and for begging for help and I don't think that's fair our school is full of diverse and resilient and amazing students and teachers and we deserve to stay we have excellent classes excellent programs the IB program the Athletics these things cannot just be picked up and moved unless you move the entire cohort and I don't know where you're going to put 1500 kids we are surrounded by a community that loves these kids and wants to see them succeed and I would just beg you to think about how you're hurting kids from all different backgrounds and needs

163if you close Montgomery please do not thank you next we have Isabella Martinez followed by Kimmy P followed by Mia Chen hi my name is Isabella Martinez I am a senior at Santa Rosa high school and my brother graduated from Montgomery High School this last year I met my best friend in art Quest video art we really bonded over like art and film making unfortunately on May 3rd of 2022 she called my dad and was afraid that I was going to take my own life that night I'm going to try really hard not to cry um I really hate the idea that another student like me might be coming into high school without these wonderful teachers and these wonderful students uh to support them and make a life that's like worth living I want thousands

164of more students to go through High School feeling like they belong somewhere uh with students and teachers that care so deeply for all of us I don't often talk about this attempt if ever because it doesn't Define who I am today uh yet I'm here up in front of my loved ones in front of my friends and a bunch of strangers talking about something that was so difficult for me to prove a point and that point is that Center as a high school is why I'm able to stand here and talk to you today thank you next we have Kimmy P followed by Mia Chen followed by Lily Roman Kimmy could you state your full name for the record I'm actually Aaron Matthews speaking on Kimmy's behalf um Kimmy had to leave she has a

165third grader that was here needed to go to bed um I'm Kim I I'm Kimmy I'm a part-time attorney and substitute teacher in the district I'm here to advocate for my schools my daughter's school Proctor Terrace Elementary Proctor is unique and amazing for a number of reasons including its central location Diversity of students high level of parent involvement and a bunch of um and a bunch of school spirit High attendance academic performance which we hope the board takes into account when making its decisions one of my favorite aspects of Proctor Terrace is how special education is handled the school really emphasizes keeping students even those who in need of extra academic um or other support in their main classroom without interrupting the students ability to be with his be without his or her peers Proctor

166has a wonderful program a push and model where many if not most students have some special who have some special needs are placed with an RSP teacher for certain Limited hours during the days this practice Works to prevent any unnecessary stigma in the event a student who is miscategorized needing to be in a special education class all day every day well there are of course some students who have more severe disabilities who legitimately require a placement in the full-time SDC classes in which Proctor has two of Proctor goes above and beyond to try thank you your time is up thank you next we have Mia Chen followed by Lily Roman followed by Lucas Shaw hello my name is Mia Clen and I'm a senior at San Rosa High School I've been in arquest theater program

167for four years now this year having four out of six of my class periods being theater theater has been my life passion for as long as I can remember artquest has helped me pursue that passion the reason I came to Santa Rosa High School from out of distance out of District at that is solely because of art Quest I wanted to join this program and art Quest has helped me more than ever in so many ways it's helped me Express who I am as a person learn how to stand up for myself like be free with my creativity and just helped me be who I am today I know that this has Art Plus specifically has done this for so many other people and the children of the future fut deserve to have that same

168opportunity as you know our last show dog se's God was cancelled and now we're facing our show currently is being censored even Sonoma State just had their arts and theater classes cut now more than ever art Quest is important to have in our community the Arts is what brings us together as people we are people art is part of us it's not just me it's not just the art Quest Community it is everyone in the world I don't want to go through ART Quest being forgotten art Quest being canceled just as our last show was we deserve to have the Arts and be who we are as people what makes us who we are do not close Santa Rosa high school thank you thank you next we have Lily Roman followed by Lucas Shaw followed

169by Heather Benson hi good evening my name is ly Roman I'm here as a sister to a student who went to ccla is now at LC and part of the football team my little brother is 16 years old I also come as a parent on the former ccla merger Committee in which I spent years advocating on many forget that ccla came out as a result of a lawsuit after the closure of Doyle Park where many disadvantaged families particularly latinette families were displaced those on the merger committee wanted to ensure that unlike a traditional Charter ccla would be inclusive to the neighborhood students by offering educ ational tracks for bilingual English only or newcomers in addition we weren't just thinking about our school we wanted to support all students in the kn5 407 zip code our

170vision is that ccla feeds into LC and then SSU to build up bilingual biliterate bicultural skilled Global Citizens of the world as you consider school closures I want you to remember that the 95407 area ZIP code AS noted in the portrait of cema county is an area in which many bipo families experience negative disperate outcomes life expectancy for those in that area is far less than other areas among other factors as I see it if LCN closes it presents a civil rights issue it's the only Public High School South of 101 in unincorporated in one of the poorest areas consider the data in the portrait of ca County these youth deserve better thank you thank you next we have Lucas Shaw followed by Heather Benson followed by Edith L my name is Lucas Shaw and

171I'm here to express my first frustration as a student of Santa Rosa city schools more and better communication from the district regarding their plans is necessary the public should be better informed about specifically what went what went wrong to bring us to the state so that does not repeat in the future the district has relied on a convoluted way of doing things to hide their mistakes from the public eye information needs to be accessible to better inform the public and better the future of this District despite how hard you think you have tried to accomplish this I would like to point out that despite our fiscal deficit being accumulative issue the community clearly didn't know about it especially school closures until the last few months with a better informed public we can hold the people

172making these errors accountable which will prevent us from returning to the state all of the cuts should not solely affect one group especially not those who are innocent in this situation teachers and students thank you thank you you next we have Heather Benson followed by Edith L followed by Elizabeth angano Santa Rosa Hyde class of 93 I have family enrolled at Santa Rosa High Montgomery and ccla I have taught social science in Santa Rosa city schools since 2008 and at Piner High School since 2012 when I started at Piner it was a struggling school and enrollment had dropped below a, students Piner has worked as a dedicated team of teachers administrators and support staff to build our programs as we were tasked to do to compete with other high schools Piner now has around 1,400

173students enrolled we have a growth mindset and value the potential of all our students we have Early College magnet with Santa Rosa Junior College and Upward Bound with Sonoma State University our stem certificate program has monthly guest lectures and planetarium shows which are open to the public we have Innovative teachers who offer based learning and Community engagement opportunities and internships we also have the grace program which gives a second chance to students who need extra support to graduate we help students who are the first in their family to graduate high school the first in their family to go to college our College and Career Center Center does constant Outreach and support to make sure that all our students have a post-graduation plan Piner serves a unique community and has a diverse population with multiple Generations

174attending our school our school includes Coffee Park which survived the TBS fire of 2017 Piner is worth saving thank you thank you I want to let everyone know that we have about 30 minutes left for public comment on this item next we have Edith L followed by Elizabeth angano followed by Jason Dennis hello everyone my name is Edith the cpra and I'm a freshman at Montgomery High School I've only been a student here for the last 6 months I've already grown to a door The Establishment that is Montgomery High School this school isn't just a place I attend every day it's a community where I've grown deeper connections with my classmates and found a community where I truly feel like I belong if you close Montgomery not only will I lose the community and relationships

175I've worked so hard to build but so hundreds of other students that have found their place at Montgomery I also am a future IB diploma candidate and if you shut down my school you are ruining my future and many others at getting the IB diploma and crushing our academic plans thank you thank you next we have Elizabeth angano followed by Jason Dennis followed by David Martin hello everybody my name is Elizabeth angano and I attended ELC Allen High School and now my son is a freshman there currently these are reasons why LC Allen High School should not close Elsie is essential to Southwest Santa Rosa by providing the neighborhood with the nearby High School Elsie provides support to an underrepresented and an economically challenged Community ELC provides value and a high regard for belonging through

176its diverse student de demographics Elsie provides the award-winning University Center a partnership with Sonoma State University which is a specialized program designed to provide intensive preparation in college courses LC provides work-based learning educational Pathways such as logos in healthcare nextg Trades Academy the healthcare pathway and agricultural mechanics Elsie provides an award-winning marching ban who fundraised to purchase new uniforms after wearing the same uniforms for 30 years Elsie provides an award-winning FFA program that is a student L leadership development program Elsie provides a newcomer Center which helps students transition from to surving into the country Elsie provides opportunities for Hispanic heritage Traditions by providing programs such as Boro and Mariachi Elsie provides a Spanish emerging program which gives the students at Caesar chavas Language Academy a pathway to continue their dual lurger education ELC provides Elion

177High School Foundation which provides mentoring career days scholarships college campus visits and testing assistance LC Allen provides LC Allen act boosters which purpose is to support the agricultural program LC thank you your time is up thank you next we have Jason Dennis followed by David Martin followed by Sydney stoud hi my name is uh Jason Dennis and I'm a junior at sah High I play three Varsity Sports and uh I help run various clubs and my mom used to work at Santa Rosa high school and through all this experience I've learned one thing the thing that makes Santa Rosa High special is all the numerous integrated communities that run throughout it uh it to quote Doug C Marsh the man our track is named after and a coach of mine we are an everything school

178if you want to look into a trade school we have a state The Arc uh trade program that goes through all of the different uh varieties if you're looking towards a we have a on-site barn and offsite farm that will help accommodate any student looking towards that if you're looking for uh academics we have a uh seamless JC dual enrollment program uh especially mentioning we are located not even a block away from it which makes it very easy for um inperson classes which is much harder to do at other places um and looking even towards extra and clubs I mean we host we host the biggest chess team uh our debate clubs going to uh a meet this Saturday the list just goes on and on and the thing that's amazing about these is each

179of these different groups are all cultivated by dozens if not hundreds of students they all combined to create a an environment that is welcoming and open to anybody s Rosa stands as a school where everyone is welcome where everyone can find a place and learn to be themselves thank you next we have David Martin followed by Sydney stad followed by Moren Cecil do we have David Martin here on then Sydney stoud followed by Morin Cecil followed by Sierra Stewart sure it's good um hello board my name is Sydney stoud and I'm the student body president at mgy high school for the past four years Montgomery has been has became my community as I have found numerous supportive teachers classmates and advisers who helped me on my journey as a successful student I am so disappointed

180in how the school board has treated my school not only did you guys let someone die on my campus but you did nothing about it simply forgetting it ever happened you ignore us always put us last and disregard us constantly we waited years for our two-story building to be finally built and when we finally thought you guys cared about us now you want to close us shame on you Montgomery is not only the most diverse school on Camp in our district but it is home to so many amazing sports teams clubs and programs such as the IB diploma program which is the only one North of San Francisco so please think a little bit longer before you decide to close Montgomery I'm proud to be a Viking thank you next we have Moren Cecil followed

181by Sierra Stewart followed by Alexa far farer hello um my name is Moran Cecil I am a teacher in this District I teach at Piner high school but I also have children who have been here currently are are leaving um for higher levels um I've heard a lot of people tonight and the thing that I think is most resonating with me and I'm not going to read what I prepared because I think the Board needs to think about what is really going to be the future of our schools and will The Cutting of schools really save us that much money I did a little research between grading and lesson planning um we have a $243 million budget and we need to cut $25 million that's 10% you should be able to cut 10% from somewhere

182else than shutting down schools and um sorry shutting down schools and firing teachers thank [Music] you thank you next we have Sierra Stewart followed by Alexa farer followed by Dulce Rodriguez castanos Sierra Sierra Stewart I am a Montgomery student I'm proud to be it I am on JB basketball and I've Loved this season and now I'm doubting if we will have another I am in theater I'm in theater production and now I'm doubting if we'll I'll ever have another play I'm excited for world history and higher classes and excited for my sophomore year but now you are making students doubt if they will ever have another sophomore year mgy so many um there are so many ways to there are so many teachers that put in so much effort into our school like um our

183band director um Mr Perez who is um my brother looks up to I've known and Perez has prepared so many students for so many programs like nor NorCal that my brother has gotten into and he's even had students create their own band inside the band room and his unique teachings have led so many students and um right now um they were playing at Slater for the Bennett Valley area concert my brother is a junior right now and your decision changes whether he can graduate his high school that he's been at for three years or he's going to have to switch that and he's going to have to have everything change you say you want Monty to fight for at school you've had a fight you've had a fight both for this with safe schools now

184in which my mother has started and we'll keep than you your time is up next we have Alexa farer followed by Dulce Rodriguez castanos followed by Joyce deala good evening board members my name is Alexa Forester first I want to thank all of the students who came out to fight for your community you make me have hope for the future I'm here today to share my family story my sons would love to be here too but they are playing at The Joint concert at uh Slater with Monty High um both my 11th grader and my eighth grader two years ago our older son Cameron was a freshman at Monty when it was a complete mess both in terms of student safety and Facilities although some families abandoned Monty at this point we decided to stay

185and invest our time our money and love and encourage the reforms that would help Revitalize the school and I'm happy to report that it is working the new cell phone policy the stop it app the campus upgrades the love and time that the mon students families teachers and administrators have invested over the last two years have helped it turn the corner if Monty is open in the fall we will happily send our younger son there for ninth grade together our sons will take advantage of Monty's excellent IB Program theater program Band program and athletic teams they will learn in a new wing of beautiful classrooms and will and we will continue the work as a community to make it the great school it can be if Monty closes my family will likely be uh forced

186to leave the district my older son Will will be facing the fourth great disruption of his young life and the beautiful new wing of bond funded classrooms will sit silent and unused as a family and Community we refused to give up on Monty when it was at its lowest point and we hope you won't abandon us now thank you thank you next we have dce Rodriguez castanos followed by Joyce sta followed by Olivia Rankin is d say here all right then we will move on to Joyce hello I'm Joyce defala and I am a resident in Santa Rosa in the Northeast part of town I want to acknowledge everybody here for your commitment your hard work your supportive education as an American citizen it during these times it's very enhe heartening to see the passion

187in this room for education I hold a doctorate in Multicultural education and I'm very fond of each of the five high schools I hold the vision that there is a path forward to keeping all five open in that context I would like to say a word for Elsie Allen ELC Allen is a campus that welcomes diversity in ethnicity ethnicity in ability in financial standing as such it not only welcomes a Divi a diverse population it creates Community among all those diverse components this is a big thing that supports not only its the people at that campus but all of Santa Rosa and indeed our American democracy thank you next we have Olivia Ranken followed by Jose Martinez followed by Leslie pra all right is Jose P Martinez here how about Leslie pra good evening board

188members thank you for letting us have the chance the opportunity to share my voice my name is Tessie PLO I am a junior at LC Island high school and I'm here to share how Elsie Allen has positively impacted my life first I'm speaking for folkloric Club as the club president I've been in it for two years now and the past years it's been taught by students from LC Allen this year we were able to have an official instructure thanks to the hard work over the years being part of this club has been an incredible experience and I do want to state that our school has the most amount of Hispanics this club helps them be more closer to the roots therefore I would love for it to continue and once more be an opportunity for

189our people for more people to be closer to their culture and learn from a culture I would also like to speak about the UC program which is only available in LC Allen It's a program that helps students get into colleges and even gives Juniors and seniors the opportunity to take free classes at tanoma State University I took an SSU class last semester and it was a great opportunity to get to see the university experience many more students seek this opportunity in our school but for this reasons I believe elsc Allen should stay open thank you Goos thank you next we have Jennifer auk followed by Kira tast followed by Christopher O'Brien Ashton first of all board thank you for letting us have this platform to speak tonight Proctor Terrace is an academic caring diverse and

190inclusive community my name is Jennifer auk and I was a proctor student during the 70s a JC student volunteer in the 80s a parent since 200000 a substitute teacher from 2005 and a teacher there since 2012 I love Proctor terce our Proctor Terrace Educators have a combined total of over 300 years of teaching experience we love teaching and supporting our students and their families we are a diverse community of Learners 41% of our students are unduplicated we have 150 family members who currently have completed the requirements allowing them to volunteer their time on campus every week there is roughly 60 volunteers on campus assisting students and staff in classrooms from TK to special day we are a community of shared resources we create meal trains for our families when tragedy strikes we partner with the

191Salvation Army in adopting families and gift giving during challenging holiday times we fund raise for our local Humane Society through kindergarten chores for change our dedicated PTA raises about 10 $100,000 yearly to support academic athletic artistic and Afterschool enrichment activities we are quick to help our families in need we have long a long-standing and dedicated daycare that has been in sight for over 40 years we are fortunate to host an Afterschool Boys and Girls Club program to support our students and families thank you for listening and for your support thank you next is Kira tast followed by Christopher O'Brien Ashton followed by Isabella gersen is Kira here all right I'm Kira test and I go to LC Allen LC alen is the only public high school campus in Southwest Santa Rosa since LC Allen is

192far from other high schools buses will have to drive longer distances for students who live in Southwest Santa Rosa to their new schools if it closes I like this school because the teachers and students are nice to me and my set class helps me feel safer uh I would have a hard time getting used to a new school if elsen gets closed thank you thank you next we have Christopher O'Brien Ashton followed by isab B gersan followed by azulito Bernal my name is Christopher Ashton I here on behalf of Elsie Allen High School as an alumni that graduated last year first of all the closure of these schools should not divide anyone as this is not any school's fault and I shall not stand on a silent platform waiting for my school to close I

193am here to talk about the relationships between the staff and the students at LC Allen in my opinion relationships and a community are the most important part of a teenager's life and I believe that Elsie Allen has went Above and Beyond in this virtue Elsie Allen has changed my life and I didn't I didn't just leave a high school I left a family that gave me a platform that I could truly be myself when I hated going home I think of all the teachers and it's hard to pick a favorite because of how unique and special each one was I think as a student I knew that my teachers the staff and the people that I saw every day in my Halls cared about me and that's a feeling that shaped who I am we

194cannot close a school with such a large community influence I truly believe that this is a school this is not just a school I don't see the people working at lsie Allen as just faculty I see this as family thank you your time is I next we have Isabella gersan followed by azulito Bernal followed by Betsy Guan Sanchez is Isabella here I'm Isabella gusen a student of srhs and art quest in the choir program here currently a junior the choir program and just the music program in general here are remarkable from the teachers to the students to the music we make together it is all such a unique that can't be replicated anywhere else I love my choir they are the highlight of my day and my literal Lifeline for the motivation to push through

195school without them my senioritis would have kicked in sophomore year and I would have been done for they make me laugh make me Ponder let me sit back and hear the music around me and remind me that we work together to perform as a family the Santa Rosa High School choir has such a legacy that shouldn't be erased rows of trophies operas concerts Disneyland performances legendary alumni and a fierce Spirit of camaraderie for one another is something that should be preserved for future generations of panthers the choir room the music library and our concert attire are all core parts of this choir's vast history and to have it torn torn down would bring shame to our teachers our students and the music community of Santa Rosa and beyond our former choir Direct Dan Earl is

196a master of his craft he steered his choir to many levels of achievement in his day and he still helps lead us towards greatness now I don't want to see his legacy go down with ours so please if I may say save Santa thank you your time is up next we have azulito Bernal followed by Betsy Gan Sanchez followed by Diego a is azulito here okay how about Betsy go ahead Betsy good evening members of the board staff and community members my name is Betsy jitan Sanchez I am a proud member of the community at Piner high school thank you to our wonderful Educators staff and students overall grateful forly supportive individuals I have been able to strive further than ever and have the privilege to call Piner my second home I am not only

197a junior but the junior class president of our wonderful graduating class of 2026 along with this I play number one singles and I'm the vice president of our Tennis Club as well as the treasurer of our California scholarship Federation Club I have been able to take in ongoing number of 14 Santa Rosa Junior College classes thanks to our early college magnet program additionally I am fortunate student of a strong advanced placement and honors program as well as our stem elective classes located in our very own Planetarium and Spark Center there are so many more wonderful things about Piner but I would need all the Time in the World to continue talking about our school again thank you to all of our pioner employees and student bodies who have made pioner what it is today since

1981966 I also want to thank our phenomenal Miss Korea for being the best principal and for assisting me in joining the superintendent student council and big thanks to M Dr Daisy Morales and Mrs melenie Martinez with all this being said I ask you today to let us commit finding better Solutions let us ensure that we can not only keep Piner safe but also continue other schools with stepping stones for our thriving students thank you thank you next we have Diego a followed by Christina Kramer followed hopefully by Tim Decker we have less than 10 minutes left I think Diego left you know Diego Christina Kramer no Tim Decker Kristen a and after Kristen will be re Basham minz hi my name is Kristen not and I have been a proud teacher at stel Lan Elementary

199for 25 years I reading this on behalf of a parent who could not make it this evening I am a proud and dedicated parent of a student at steel Lane a school that has been part of my life for the past eight years steel Lane isn't just a school it's a home a sanctuary and a safe haven for so many it serves some of the most vulnerable populations unhoused families low-income households and English language learners for these students steel Lane is a place where they feel safe loved and cared for it's where they can count on being fed supported listened to and loved closing our school would strip away the sense of security and stability these children desperately need why should the mistakes of this District fall on the shoulders of our students and families

200the three elementary schools that have been mentioned for closure all serve lowincome neighborhoods it's clear the consolidation committee knows this and is relying on the assumption that our families lack the resources to move their children to other districts meanwhile wealthier families are threatening to leave the district and we're supposed to let this dictate the decision why are we prioritizing the voices of small privileged percentage of the district over the majority of our community where is the equity in this decision this is your chance to demonstrate thank you your time is up next we have re Basham minz and then Angel Ortega my name is z I'm going to be speaking on behalf of Ry here had to coach our girls tonight Santa City School States in its mission that it has been recognized Statewide for

201our equity and social justice initiative it is unconscionable that a school district which Prides itself on set values would so readily abandon a physical presence in the entire half of the city with the prospect of ccl's Charter not being renewed and the potential closure of el High School the district would no longer have a single School South of Highway 12 the easy solution in that scenario would appear to be the busting of students across Highway 12 aka the pr verbial train tracks those who know history know that that is not a sustainable and Equitable solution I Ask of the school board and the district is that Vision that Santa Rosa city school s Santa Rosa city schools wants LC island is an integral piece of the fabric of not only the district but the entire

202south of Santa Rosa no other High School in the district faces the same community stigmas in the same proximity to other high schools in other District a portra of Sonoma County a report produced by the county and Community Partners makes it clear the inequalities we see in Sonoma County are the results of decisions and policies of people ower different decisions can create better more Equitable outcomes please make the right decision and act on the values you claim to a spouse thank you I I don't think I can let you do a second comment someone else I know I'm I'm sorry I mean you've let it happen before why why am I the exception no that Patrick would you like to speak on my behalf thank you um I have cards in order of when they

203were received and the next I have is Shawn Logan I'm I'm very sorry I feel that we need to stick to procedure in order to be fair to everyone is Sean Logan here yes go ahead and this will be our last public comment tonight on this item good evening everyone my name is Sean Logan and I am a parent of a student uh my six-year-old son Daniel goes to steel M Elementary School um I just want to say that I'm here on his behalf and here on behalf of all the students at that school and I really do not want that school to be closed um I'm also here in solidarity with all of the students all of the family and all of the teachers here in the room tonight uh especially these students they

204shouldn't have to be here tonight you know they should be out having fun maybe even doing homework but they shouldn't be here having to worry about their school's closing because the school district can't balance a checkbook it just doesn't seem fair and it doesn't seem right um uh steel Lane is a wonderful school they have amazing teachers my son is autistic he was born uh with a very challenging speech impediment uh that he's overcome and uh we owe that to the students and staff or to the teachers and staff at seing elementary school he started out in TK in special education and within a year and a half he's now uh in regular uh classes he doesn't need a teacher's aid and we owe that to those teachers he wouldn't be the the amazing kid

205who just won't stop talking even though we'd never didn't know if he was going to talk ever if it wasn't for the hard work of those teachers so thanks thank you that brings us to the end of our 90 minutes thank you for those of you that shared your voices and apologies to those of you that we did not have time for please email us your comments president mcnali I'd like to make a motion that we extend the meeting to 11:50 p.m. second right um so we have a motion and a second to extend to 11:50 p.m. is all in favor say I I I hi motion passes um board I'd like to ask that we get through our public comment on non-agenda items and then take a break all right okay mean comment on

206agenda items oh that was no those did these were not there when called these were the ones we didn't get to oh also not there all right we are going to move on to item e public comment on non-agenda or consent items um you will have 90 seconds I'm going to ask that folks have a seat or clear out so that we are able to hear the folks that are here for public comment on non-agenda items first we'll have Lisa greens Greenstein followed by Samantha sharp followed by Gary arof these are comments on Lisa's not here non-agenda items only okay no Lisa is Samantha sharp here Samantha sharp no Gary arof Gary arof Karen Wagner go ahead Karen so I'm here for all of us in this community I'm also here for our classified staff

207to have a fair and Equitable raise with all of the these cuts that are be to going on um those who remain will have their hands full with um working with all of our students in our family and we will be there for them please respect the classified and pay us what we are deserved and embrace us um I do appreciate everything that's going on I care deeply for everybody's concerns um and I really want to advocate for um the people who work with these students on the ground we're in our tennis shoes we're running with them we work with them daily so it's the cafeteras it's the classified in the classrooms it is the the um office staff so please help us out and uh respect us and embrace us thank you thank you

208next I have Courtney baitman follow by Michael titone is Courtney here is Michael here Marney baitman hi there my name is Michael donon I'm a Community member um I'm also a csca worker and I want to Echo what the previous speaker said please listen to your workers please value us we are essential and also listen to your students listen to your staff I'm in awe of the community that showed up today to advocate for their Futures and for all of our futures this is super important um I'm also I also would like you to reconsider the impact of subjecting your students to sro's on campus and the criminal justice system especially at this time the current immigration enforcement director sir that is an agenda item this is public comment on non-agenda items only okay so

209do I want me to wait yes if you want to comment on sro's it would have to wait for that item sure all right thank you all right I have no other blue cards for non-agenda items um we are going to take a f minute break we're now moving thank you Melanie we are now moving to our F items which are our discussion and action items starting with resolution recognizing February 3r through 7th 2025 as week of school counselor we have Dr Luc Elena Perez and Debbie cardoo good evening board um I'm so uh very proud and excited to be able to uh be the person getting to present this resolution to to you to the board um as Council s a very special place in my heart um so this coming month is national

210school we have National School counseling week which is the week of February 3rd through the 7th and we focus on public attention on the unique contribution of our school counselors within the US school system National School counseling week is sponsored by the American School uh counselor Association and it highlights the tremendous impact that school counselors can have in helping students achieve school Success and plan for a career National School counseling week is always celebrated the first full week of February and so I want to thank uh our director cardoo for the work she does to support our secondary counselors more importantly we have an amazing student who's going to speak about the impact that counselors have had on his life hello my name is Anthony Wilson and I'm a junior at Piner and the captain

211of The Varsity boy swim team when I was a freshman I was an extremely introverted and somewhat troubled kid I was duel enrolled at a school called an NOA Center for Education which is a school for children with social and cognitive differences due to the nature of Anova I had been assigned an individual education plan which I had multiple accommodations I won't go through all them but I will tell you that one of the most important ones I have received as Counseling Services my first counselor at pioner high school is a woman woman named Sydney Miller Miss Miller is a freshman counselor she is an energetic funny and kind person and she was the first of many great supporters during my freshman year some of the many reasons I love Miss Miller is she's very

212supportive and continues to be a large part of my support even though she's not my counselor anymore when I was a freshman I was very withdrawn antisocial and nervous I came to miss Miller's office almost daily some counselors teachers or anyone for that matter would have gotten tired of my continual needs but Miss Miller never turned me away I always F felt welcome and heard in her office this allowed me to gain the confidence I needed to grow into a new into a new person at my new school even though Miss Miller is no longer my counselor because she's only a counselor to freshman students at Piner I still stop by her office literally every day just to say hi just like in my freshman year she's always happy to see me Miss Miller however

213is not the only amazing counselor at Piner high school now that I'm a junior my counselor is car Miss Carol Ramirez Miss Ramirez's flexibility helped me to be in classes that better suit my needs which has allowed me to be more successful in school I am a straight A student and I attribute much of my academic success to miss Ramirez's kindness support and willingness to find classes that better SU me I've been in private specialized education programs since fifth grade when I came to Piner I thought that' be just like the movies where nobody seems to care I was wrong the counselors at Piner High School genuinely care about their students I have another counseling support team member at Piner who I want to mention Rick Durr Rick is a school therapist in the past

214I have had trouble connecting to counselors but Rick and I clicked instantly he helped me through some dark places in my life during my sophomore and junior year and another huge part of my success as a student is piner's Early College magnet program led by Christine urkin Miss urkin is a coordinator of the program but she's also a counselor I also see Miss urkin every day because her office is right next door to Miss Miller Miss urkin works with me on my JC coursework but she is also a nice person to be I mentioned earlier that I'm captain of the swim team and Miss urkin was the one who pushed me to pursue swimming as my sport in high school and hopefully in college even though Miss urkin is a counselor and not a swim

215coach she helps me with my job as Captain by encouraging others to join the team she'll call me into her office when she has new students that need a team to join and need to meet friends because she knows I'm a great person to make others feel included had I not come to pioner and had these amazing counselors I would not have made the jump from troubled kid to thriving in advanced classes and being able to comfort comfortably take on 10 classes in one semester with an a average I wouldn't be a swimmer I definitely wouldn't have the confidence I've built with the help of so many counselors can make the difference they definitely have for me thank you Anthony I would like to now request that the board consider the approval of resolution 24

21625-34 recognizing February 3rd through 7th of 2025 as week of the school counselor board are there any questions I see truste deor I always do this no questions just comment Anthony thank you so much for coming and speaking those are beautiful words they came from your heart I'm so proud of you and where you're at now and I can not expressed enough gratitude to the counselors that were so impactful not only on my education but my children's education um and so many more so thank you very much and really look forward to this resolution I don't have any blue cards on this item so board further discussion I'm I move to um approve this resolution second right that was moved by vice president Maneri seconded by trusty deor is there any further discussion all right

217roll call vote student board member Zinga hi trusty banier hi trusty de laori hi trusty Casten hi trusty Kirby hi trusty Medina I trusty Jenkins I president mcnali I motion passes now moving on to resolution recognizing February as Career Technical Education Month and this says that we still have Dr Lucena Perez and Debbie ardoo good evening president mcnali superintendent Morales and members of the board again my name is Debbie cardoo and I'm a director of College and Career Readiness and I'm very proud to bring forward the resolution to recognize February as Career Technical Education Month in Santa Rosa city schools Career Technical education also referred to a CTE programs provide students with relevant and meaningful learning experiences from teaching Technical and essential skills to providing students with early college credit opportunities and work-based learning experiences

218these programs truly are preparing students to be ready for post-secondary training and continued education future careers and life Santa Rosa city schools has 20 CTE programs offered throughout our high schools and a CTE exploration course at Santa Rosa Middle School tonight we have with us a few of our CTE program teachers and their wonderful students who will be sharing the impact of these programs we did have U miss Patty herado she's a public and Community Health uh program teacher at Elon high school and her student here tonight Unfortunately they had to leave due to timing um they actually have job Shadows scheduled for tomorrow morning at S Health and so they um they needed to go home and prepare for that but I do have um the students uh speech that I would like to

219read on her behalf okay good afternoon esteemed council member members fellow peers and guests my name is Wana Gonzalez Valencia and I am truly grateful to be standing here today to talk about something that has completely transformed my life Career and Technical education or CTE like many students I struggled to figure out where I fit into the larger picture of my education I knew I needed something Hands-On something that connected with my interests and my goals that's when I discovered CTE through CTE I found that just a program but a pathway to a future I never thought was possible I had the opportunity to explore the healthcare field and under the guidance of an incredible teacher I was able to earn my certified nursing assistant licenses at just 16 years old one of the most

220powerful things about CTE is the teachers they don't just deliver lessons they Inspire students they didn't just teach us technical skills they taught us the value of hard work dedication and most importantly the belief that we could succeed CTE is uh not just an educational pathway it's a GameChanger it provides students with the tools to succeed builds confidence and most importantly gives us the opportunity to chart our own future I'm incredibly thankful for my CTE experience and I know that without it I wouldn't be standing here today with the same sense of purpose and excitement for the future thank you okay and so and now I'll turn it over to miss pay good evening my name is Catherine Payne I'm a business oops my name is Katherine Payne and I teach business at Montgomery High

221School and I am pleased to bring my student Adrien hi my name is Adrien Helen limos and I'm a proud representative and student of Montgomery High School's Business program in Deca Club our school is unique in Sonoma County Montgomery is the only school that offers exceptional business programs that exposes students to Entre Entre entrepreneurialism in business which serves our community at large for a thriving economy these programs have provided invaluable skills opportunities and experiences that are crucial for our future success it is truly inspiring for example making real Connections in the business Community understanding the realities of leadership in creating a business harnessing ambition and creating your niche in the market CTE classes have been extremely beneficial to my own growth and development they have equipped me with essential tools and knowledge that have directly

222contributed to the success in my own business venture closing our school would Rob students of a beneficial opportunity to identify a path for a success they never thought about these classes are invaluable for students seeking help to develop their own business and entrepreneurial skills I may be only one student speaking on this particular topic tonight but your decision has a weighty impact on untapped future entrepreneurs in the County thank you hello my name is Jessica Moran Valencia I am a CTE teacher at P um not Piner what at Montgomery High School and I teach introduction to healthcare this is analie mendosa with you guys tonight hello my name is analie mza I'm a junior at Montgomery High school and this is my first year in a CTE class I was immediately interested in the class

223when my counselor mentioned introduction to healthcare the class is not only giv me the opportunity to learn new things about the healthcare field but also new things about myself with the CTE class I've been able to learn from our very own athletic trainer go to our one of our community health clinics and hear from amazing healthc Care Professionals and be a part of many Hands-On Labs introduction to healthcare has been very helpful in helping me understand what I'm truly interested in and giving me more clarity on the future pathway I wish to take in the healthcare field thank you good evening board my name is Lisa Peele from Santa Rosa high school I'm the CTE department chair and I'm here tonight representing the agriculture portion of CTE but offered at both Elsie Allen High School

224and Santa Rosa high school today we have Santa Rosa ffa's president Kean Walker and Santa Rosa ffa's secretary Riley Peele hello everyone my name is keln Walker and I am the Santa Roa FFA chapter president I am not only here to talk about myself but the other 273 students who are enrolled in an ad class at s r Roa High School FFA is a National Organization that helps students become leaders public speakers and this organization uses Hands-On learning to teach at the beginning of this school year Santa FFA members and I were given the privilege to participate in the 150th anniversary of Santa Rosa high school walking around main building in this blue corduroy jacket I was stopped by generation and Generation by FFA alumni who told me that they have the same jacket hanging

225up at their house Santa Rosa FFA was found in 1928 making it the second official chapter in California this jacket not only represents myself but our school's chapter at the state and National level thank you hello my name is Riley Peele I'm a junior at Santa Rosa high school and I'm Santa Rosa ffa's chapter secretary and the junior class vice president I came to Santa Rosa as an interdistrict transfer and Santa Rosa high school has opened me up to a world world that I would have never been able to fully Embrace had I not attended a world of dedication professionalism responsibility and accountability FFA has allowed me to travel the country compete as a state and National finalist with agroscience projects and participate in conferences that make me the leader that I am today inside

226and outside the classroom I've learned how to work with others effectively human or not I've been able to care for something other than myself treated as an extension of me the most valuable lesson that FFA has taught me is to be an advocate to educate myself about agricultural topics and in turn educate others in an unbiased and informative way representing an industry that is the backbone of America in a positive light which I would never be able to do without srhs others should be able to do the same we we welcome all of you to take those flowers home with you they were made by the advanced floral students at Santa Rosa High School enjoy your evening okay we will now turn it back over to the board to consider approving uh this resolution to

227recognize February as Career Technical Education Month in Santa Rosa city schools thank you thank you so much so board I do have a blue comment on this item so questions only first are there any board questions trusty Medina yeah um was for Debbie um I was wondering what the Govern new announcement on a master plan on Career Education might um mean to our district um if there's anything known and um what our involvement is or how we can engage whether as board members or as a district yeah great question and so yes uh that is uh great that the state is coming forward with additional guidance and anytime that state comes down with additional guidance that definitely drives a work and how we move in Santa Rosa city schools um we'll have to go through

228it and see where there is alignment naturally and then where we may need to Pivot you know accordingly so so yeah definitely um informs our work as any federal or state things that come out I think the the other thing I think today was really abundantly clear that we have amazing programs in yes all our high schools um as presented here as well um I know recently I reached out to uh assistant superintendent Castro about potentially using CT model curriculum um to create a Visual and Performing Arts pathway at LC um but one of the obstacles often times seems to be um teachers needing special CT certification so I'm wondering what um resources are available for us to help provide professional development to our teachers so we could provide more of these opportunities to our

229students you know maybe adapting existing programs to create these opportunities that then potentially bring more funding for our district to help provide these Services yeah uh another great question so we're fortunate to have a currently educator Effectiveness grant funding that we've been leveraging to support uh teachers with securing their designated CTE credential um if they have appropriate industry experience in that particular industry sector um and so we can definitely support that certainly as we look at establishing any new programs whether it be CTE or or anything we need to look at the landscape of the school what the school can accommodate facilities and things of that nature but we definitely can continue to explore uh further development of our programs um we're really excited we just established The healthc CARE program at mcgomery this year

230an education program at elsc Allen this year as well so we're continuing to build and grow um we do definitely see uh student interests and then uh definitely wanting to prepare our students for um College and Career and all all opportunities and so if there's um an opportunity to explore with a certain School site then we can have that conversation with the site Administration and look at how we could make that work um if it fits and I think the the other thing that I'm really excited about you know we ran into each other at the ca County uh Coalition for internships I'm wondering if you'd be able to talk about that work and how it impacts this um CTE within our schools yeah absolutely um I'm really proud of our work around work-based learning

231experiences we actually in the county are a leader in the development of our scope and sequence as well as defining what what that means and what that looks like and how to actualize that um in the classroom and and Beyond um and so we have been working uh very closely with the CTE Foundation of Sonoma County they are a strong and long-standing partner um with our school district and has supported CTE programs for a number of years um so in conjunction with their support and the Sonoma County Office of Education we are looking at um work-based learning experiences countywide particularly on that further side of the Continuum internships um and how we can collectively first starting with Healthcare um identify partners that would be willing to um host internships for our students um and and

232working through I mean there's a lot of liability and and things that you have to work through to to make those work um but we've definitely come together as a county to really try to collectively work on that and so we can provide these experiences for students and then in conjunction with that um we've also been providing professional development for our teachers on how to implement work-based learning as an instructional strategy so we know that we want to get kids out to internships right but they need to be prepared to do that internships which includes experiences like job Shadows which our LC Allen students are experiencing tomorrow at Setter um health or uh in Industry tours or guest speakers we had a great career day for our middle school students um this fall for eth

233graders and so we are doing a lot of work around that and again I'm super proud of that because we have other districts that are using the work that we uh created and built not only with teachers but with industry and Community Partners um as a model and they're modifying it um and implementing it um in their District so yeah a lot of great work around that my final question you know earlier in in in our public comments we heard about people receiving ads about attracting people to their schools and all that um you know as well as I know that we have amazing programs in our schools and often times I feel that people just don't know about them and I'm wondering what could we as a board um do to help better promote

234that provide the district resources or direct the district to better inform the community of these amazing programs and opportunities that exist for our students stents um because I I think it's clear that we need to do a better job um so yeah your your input would be greatly appreciated yeah um that's uh one of the elements of a highquality CTE program is the uh program uh recruitment retention that Focus um so that's something we've actually been working on uh with our industry advisory committee so we have a district CTE advisory committee that um I support um and work with Partners uh to talk through these very things um I mean as a board member um I think that messaging and and just word of mouth is a great way to get get um information out

235I mean you guys are um very well connected individuals and so I think that we can be our best Advocates and really um sharing about all the different opportunities that are available um I know we have some new board members and so if if there or and also folks that have been with us for a while so if there's ever um a need to see RCT programs in action so you feel more comfortably speaking about them um we invite folks out to our schools um to come see all the amazing things not just here about it tonight but see it in action because it is truly amazing um yeah so I and I know what we are working on is we have like marketing materials and Publications and we're trying to figure out how do

236we get into different spaces that we maybe haven't thought of so we recently formed a partnership with our local libraries to put our CTE Publications in those we went went to daac um this month and they said that we um they would like more um information shared with parents and so that's something we're trying to figure that out um but I will also um say if there's something else that you all think that we can do better I I welcome feedback as well because collectively uh that is how we message about the amazingness of our programs is um working together um and I don't I don't have all the solutions um but I I would love to design something that would Outreach even further than what we've been working on I just ask are are

237feeder districts as well do we interact to communicate with them or if so how yeah so we have um when when the counselors go out and do like course requests and things like that I mean they're connected to feeder districts absolutely um but that is something that as far as doing like a special event or something like that we haven't um looked at that but that's definitely something that we can explore yeah absolutely yeah and I think too something else I wanted to add um there's a lot of Grant Monday money in CTE and recently we just received preliminary notification that um we were awarded a million dollars um in CTE incentive grant funding and it and it gets uh approved by the state board this month um and then typically we receive our notification

238official notification a little bit later after that um but the reason I bring that up is because a part of that grant that I wrote included Middle School career uh CTE wheel courses and so our students can be more prepared um and make a more informed decision when they go into high school and so we're very heavy CTE at the high school level but we're looking at middle school and my dream is to go down into Elementary you know and so how can we start preparing our students even more which I think is also a form of recruitment um and and information and power um of choice in in that sense so yeah okay JY Kirby hi yes um thank you for being here um so CTE programs is one of the areas I'm most

239passionate about and one of the reasons that I chose to take on this position um I you know you brought up the grant um is there anything that we can do further as a board or at the district level to help you with writing these grants or getting you know getting that out there because I know that's a big there is a lot of grant money out there available is there are we providing I know we don't have a grant writing team per say which I think we should have one it's me and um and I will say I um I was just totaling up how much and I'm and I I'm very modest like I'm a very humble like I don't like I'm not a Rous person but I was totaling up the grant

240size manag I was like man this year I've been busy you know and um and I'm proud to say I don't have the official number on me but I it was um yeah three point over $3.5 million that I've secured uh for our district to support CTE initiative so I thank you thank you thank you and th and those are just grants that I have written um so whether that be the CTE in Grant the Perkins Grant and we also have AG incentive Grant um we have a College and Career access pathway grants for all of our five Comprehensive High Schools we just got Golden State pathway grant funding um there's a long list um and those are grants that I have personally written I submit I manage um all the reporting around that but

241then we also have other grants and so um we have like the American Rescue plan act Grant uh through the CTE uh Foundation of Sonoma County that was for five $55,000 um and so we have that and although we're not the lead on that we are a partner in that so we benefit from that um we also partner in some Consortium grants with the county office as well um there's one that we have it's a K12 strong Workforce in education and that was a little over 60,000 so um so we're um yeah I if you could um figure out how to clone me no well thanks for all that St program could do that um but yeah I I mean I just I I I say that jokingly in that um I've been in this

242District a long time I'm I am a CTE student I grew up on a dairy I was an agriculture teacher at Elon High School I am CTE like I I love CTE and so I'm thankful for the support and I share that to say that um we've been very fortunate that our board has always supported CTE programs and has seen the value of CTE and um and it it's just it's been wonderful and that's why we are able to build and keep going after additional funding um because of that support so just keep the support coming that's yeah that's great thank you well thank thanks again for all your hard work and getting those grants um one area that um I went to some of the seminars during the um onboarding process um I was

243a little surprised that Sonoma County is one of the only counties that doesn't have Intercounty um CTE programs with you know like maren and um some of the other Napa um they they form the re Regional Partnerships and share their CTE resources so to speak amongst each other so at some point I'd like to try to help get us involved in that and uh instead you know I I appreciate working from the bottom up Elementary but I also want to keep expanding outwards and and expand our Pathways yeah absolutely great thank you other questions board just one more just real quick um do you know when the um our CTE funding from the county arpa grant money ends yes um it was originally scheduled to end December of this year 31st and it was extended

244for another year yeah thank you yeah you're welcome all right I have one blue card Angela giglia you will have 90 seconds hello my name is Angela gilea thank you for the time given for this um SRTA appreciates all of our CTE teachers the classes and programs they offer and the efforts they make to impart soft skills to our students while teaching other job related skills California dashboard recognizes students as career ready if they complete a CTE pathway which is three courses in succession and pass one cback cback exam sback exam sorry SRTA members invite the board to consider creating a CTE pathway for graduation that does not require the a through G requirements for many students that would benefit from the CTE courses they are limited to the ability to enroll in them because

245they are struggling to repeat over and over the a through G courses to gain reir required units to graduate for the use UC CSU admission requirements srcs requires students to pass courses meaning with a d which qualifies them for graduation requirements this does not qualify them for the CSUS and S uc's this disparity creates a particular difficulty for students especially in the course pathways that build upon each other like the world language and math requirements students with additional English Support classes also find it nearly impossible to complete the CTE pathway three courses we need a CTA pathway thank you your time is up I have no other blue cards so this comes back to the board for discussion uh trusty deor want to thank the teachers um thank you so much thank you to the

246students that have come out and offered your Reflections on your opportunities um like director Cur I'm extremely passionate about CT as well um as a founding member of the Cloverdale FFA chapter over 30 years ago I can attest the Blue corteroid Jackets do not change great to see them um but being able to experience culinary autoshop wood shop they are things that um guided me in my Mechanical Aptitude to do what I do professionally now and have a passionate neediness to be in school and experience those it wasn't just Math and Science but it's what else can I do what else can I provide and I'm grateful that our district is offering these and I'm looking forward to more opportunities to continue and add growth to these robust programs that are so important to so

247many of our student body trusty Caston thank you all for the presentation and I obviously support the recognition month um I didn't graduate with a high school diploma I got an equivalency uh when I was 16 and was able to re-enter higher education through uh CTE programs so I I know the value of it and they gave me a pathway to eventually earn my Master's Degree so there's a lot of value um and I appreciate all that work I it seems from the questions that we're having that there's a lot more to the scope of our interest in this than the recognition month and so perhaps we could also add this as a future board item to go further into the grant strategy and the other things that trusty Medina and Kirby brought up any

248other board discussion trusty Medina I would just really encourage board members to really um take lot take time to look at the state's CTE model curriculum standards um I think it's really important to understand I think one of the important things to also understand is on the state dashboard the new College and Career indicator um that's the newest one and really understanding what goes into it as we look at developing policy um in terms of what we expect of students and and what we focus on I think having an understanding of those things will be critical so please go to the state department of education site and you can look these things up and learn more if there is no further discussion we are seeking a motion motion to approve resolution number 25-35 as Career

249Technical Education Month in Santa City Schools second moved by trusty deor seconded by trusty Medina any further discussion roll call vote please student board member Zinga hi trusty deor hi trusty Medina hi trusty Casten hi trusty Kirby I trusty Jenkins I trusty manieri I president mcnell Hi motion passes and I just want to say that Myra Moran a couple of months ago she was the teacher of the month um at by one of the radio stations so congratulations again Maestra thank you everyone we will now move on to our next resolution recognizing February as African-American history month and we have Dr rodri Castro and students from Piner High School's black student union Dr Castro had to go pick up his daughter at nine so Dr Pettis is taking Point thank you Dr peris yes my

250pleasure um so we have uh this very important resolution recognizing February as African-American history month is an annual celebration of achievements by African-Americans and a time for recognizing their Central role in US history the 2025 uh Black History Month theme African-Americans and labor focuses on the various and profound ways that the work and working of all kinds free and unfree skilled and unskilled vocational and voluntary intersect with the collective experiences of black people indeed work is at the very center of much of black history and culture Black History Month acts as a reminder to reflect on and amplify black voices and discover the ways African-Americans have contributed to American culture through scholarship music dance Art Theater language food Athletics fashion and values and with us we have um some students from the BSU from Piner

251High School cool introduce your do uh good evening uh members of the board and Community my name is judita and sorry I'm a student at Piner high school and I want to talk about why recognizing February as National African-American history mon month is important this resolution goes beyond just honoring history is about making sure that the contributors of African-Americans are seen valued and remembered from people like Dr Carter G Woodson creating negro history week in 1926 to Black History Month becoming a national celebration in 1976 this tradition ensures that black voices and stories would remain something that's important and part of our history and for a student like me seeing my people's history recognizing schools makes me feel represented and it reminds me that despite challenges of racism and Injustice African-Americans have continued to persevere

252and move forward shaping this country in countless ways and this resolution highlights that African-Americans have enriched schools and communities by promoting fairness equality and justice for all it also calls for Santa Rosa city schools to encourage critical reflection courageous conversations about systematic racism and bias while affirming that the rights of African-American students to be treated with respect and dignity would not just be words they would be actions that would help create schools where students like me can feel safe supported and valued and the 2023 theme black health and wellness is another powerful reminder of the importance of equity today it encourages us to recognize how health and equities still impact black communities and to celebrate the resilience and contributions of black leaders in medicine wellness and advocacy this resolution would help Advocate the long history

253of African-Americans from when we arrived in 1619 to not only fighting for their own freedom but for the rights of all Americans thank you for supporting this [Music] resolution second student on the behalf of Piner High School my name a senior at Piner high school thank you and I'm just representing BSU with my unique perspective and continuing what Judah was saying whereas in 2008 the first African-American president of the United States was elected and whereas in 2012 President Barack Obama was elected to serve a second term and whereas in 2012 California historically elected the most African-Americans to serve in the leg legure Leisure legislature thank you um totaling 12 members and whereas in 2018 marked the highest number of the African-American members serving in the United States Congress totaling the 55 members and whereas African-American

254and African-Americans have been great inventors inventing and improving on Innovations such as air conditioning unit um Al um automatic gearshift blood plasma bag cloth dryer door knob door stop the electric bulb um P the electric bulb elevator fire escape ladder fountain pen gas mask glove tea um golf tea sorry horseshoe Lantern lawn mower lawn sprinkler lock lubricating cup refrigerator um spark plug skos scope telescope um and traffic symbol and a the typewriter and whereas African-American history month commemorates and celebrates many different achievements as African-Americans whether that be in academic Pursuits business Fine Arts political action and science now therefore be resolved be by the governor Board of the senat res City Schools district and the district takes great pleasure in recognizing February 2025 as African-American history month urges everyone in join to join in celebration

255um of the comish ments of the African-American during this history month and encourages the staff and students of the Santa Rosa city schools to recognize not only how many different talents of African-Americans but also the great achievements contributions and sacrifices that have been made to help create equity and equality inside and outside of the classroom thank you thank you so much I I really appreciate having our students here to to speak on behalf of of this very important resolution uh the work that we do in our ethnic studies classes across our district where we've embedded ethnic studies really elevates as well the importance and significance of our of black of African-Americans in our community and in our schools so um uh I'm really really happy that you were able to stay and be here for

256this resolution so so we now ask the board to consider approval of resolution number 25-36 recognizing February as National African-American history month thank you so much are there any board member questions justy delator thank you students so much for your time your energy and your beautiful words um not to put you on the spot but while you have the board in front of you is there anything you'd wish to ask of this board to ensure that your culture and people are better represented and celebrated as we're discussing this resolution I would like to say that there are so many other programs that have been implicated and I feel like an elementary schools I didn't go to an elementary school in Santa Rosa city schools but I feel like if you talk more about history altogether

257like ethnic studies that's already being implemented everywhere and if you just include that more in the curriculum that's all we're looking for thank you very much yeah I would like to add to that because I went to elementary school in like places like near Bennett Valley like Spring Creek Elementary School when it used to be called that and up until now Piner was the only school that I've known that had any like clubs or programs to morning like black or African-Americans and what a beautiful opportunity to share these experiences at such a younger age and help you be seen and heard and loved early on so thank you for sharing that and we're going to make sure the district leadership takes those notes and um we continue to blaze a path for betterment thank you

258thank you for other questions I have no blue card so board comments discussion I move to approve the resolution recognizing February as African-American history month second moved by truste manieri seconded by truste Medina any further discussion roll call vote student board memb Zinga I trusty manieri I trusty trusty Bina I trusty Caston hi trusty Kirby hi trusty Jenkins hi trusty de laor hi president MCN I motion passes thank you for having us thank you so much all right we will now move on um chisty uh I mean president mcnell I was going to ask that maybe we um move that G9 item to vote on it really quick just because we have a legal obligation to make a decision on that and our time's running out are we able to make adjustments to the agenda

259at this point if nobody objects we are I'll object I yeah I think we needed to we should have made that adjustment in the beginning we didn't have to but it's okay we extended the meeting until 11:50 correct not 10:50 okay correct all right so we'll move on to item F4 discussion of the working group school resource officer mou and guidance to the 3X3 committee um I decided to bring this forward as a discussion item it feels like this board as a whole has not talked about school resource officers in a long time um the 3X3 committee has been working for a long time on this mou and so I wanted us to get all of the work that has been done so far on the table for the entire board to see for the

260public to see and I want us to have a discussion so that we can give direction back to the 3X3 to help them in finalizing anou draft um Dr Morales is there anything you want to say no I uh we have the working group document that the working group actually facilitated back in um May I believe and then I know members of our uh 3x3 collaborated on some additional changes and Troy Medina put that that together so both of the documents are on there and because I knew um people want to know would want to know the difference I did the line by line comparison with the bolded Awards so so people could see where the differences were at um I don't know if members of the 3X3 that can um made comments into that

261document would like to comment but that's I I gathered all of the documents and kind of helped facilitate um seeing the difference between the two uh I see trusty delator and then trusty Medina uh thank you for bringing this to the agenda and I just want to be very clear there are not two separate M us um sometimes this is GRE as division there's not anou that the working Committee created and then a different mou that srcs has created it is one working mou created by the committee that involved no elected officials and the suggestions in here or suggestions that were made within the ad hoc committee with our 3x3 and the 3X3 of the city council this was not just the San City School boards 3x3 making suggestions that didn't go forward um I'm

262as of the essence with this which is why it's so important that it's brought to the agenda tonight um I requested a pilot program in December 2023 um and we're 13 months later still trying to get some stability and Direction on this trusty Medina yeah thank you um I think just I'd like to provide a little bit of a background um just um as trust Lor mentioned um this board voted to uh look into establishing a pilot program back in December of 2023 um from that prior to that um a 3X3 uh committee had already been established to look at addressing issues that we could collaborate with on the city with the city and the district something that had not occurred for many years um this was the primary focus of the work that occurred

263within that 3x3 committee um um as we've been dealing with a lot of things there was a transition um from our previous superintendent to our current superintendent um our last meeting is a 3X3 occurred with our prior superintendent um from that meeting um what was kind of left out there was that theou that had kind of been generated um it would be accessible to all the members of the committee to look at and provide input and feedback um and then I did make one attempt to try to get another meeting going but it was really hard to get everybody scheduled as everybody's really busy that serves on that committee um so what I looked at was the a lot of the input that had been provided um primarily by um former Trista lacruz and Sergeant

264Matt Crosby um was where a lot of the input primarily came from um I kind of compiled that into the final document that then um between our last meeting and this meeting I sent an email with that document to Tristy mcnali as well as Tristy Manti as well as uh mayor mayor stap as well as uh vice mayor Eddie Alvarez for that transition of leadership to understand kind of where we were at and and my suggested uh path to move forward was to ensure that we each have our legal teams give one one one additional review to this and then maybe we um bring it back to our respective bodies to make a decision to move forward and after that and we could direct our staff to start collaborating if it was passed um towards

265uh looking for funding um because cly funding would be an issue I know the city strapped for money and I'm pretty sure you all know we are too um so that would be that was the suggested path forward that I um hope forward in in the email to our leadership as well as the city's leadership thank you trusty Medina for giving that background and I'll say for the reason I agendized it this way I think because so much of um the work that you did happened after the last 3x3 meeting I would just want to make sure that this goes back to the 3X3 at least once before we send it to our legal team for us for a review um I see trusty Casten and then trusty Kirby a question on the item I'll

266save my comments for after public comment um it it says the working group consisted of srcs srpd sco the NAACP and then nonprofits and parents is there a more specific list of the people who participated in the working group no the working group the 3X3 or the working group to vote the working group that drafted the I just can we expand on what nonprofits and parents means I I I think one of the things if I may just was that um there there was a lot of the idea was to try to have those people stay kind of uh I like not really Shar too much because of fear of outside influence like I don't even know who who was on it um but but I know that um Sergeant Crosby and chief KGAN um

267were involved I know that Chief KGAN was the one that put the original proposal forward but in terms of who was totally on there me personally I don't know um because I think that was part of the thing to kind of keep that um close off so that those people didn't face um undue influence and and I'm not I'm more asking just because I want to understand the scope of the diversity of this committee because my understanding is that it was pretty Broad and so um if if we don't have the specific information that's fine and we can move forward trusty Kirby um just some clarification on the background um so the the copy that we have with the bold letters that are in here these are the the edits that that you added in

268correct so these were so you know how on a Google doc edits are are kind of made and stuff they were kind of edits that were clicked accept on and so I don't know if that makes sense so but but what I looked at was what you know there's a lot of commentary from both sides on on what and why and these were to me it was like the compromise language that made sense okay in my opinion well the follow is so in the group you said that you sent this to for to look at again I didn't hear you mentioned srpd who is this this agreement is with them so I'm concerned that they then haven't seen your edits that you're saying that you added in I'm sorry I did I did actually also

269include Sergeant Crosby and and chief KGAN when I sent it out and they they agreed to all of these uh additions since since I sent that out to to the leadership of both organizations I have not heard back um this is how it was first presented to me since that email this was the first okay so that so they haven't responded to these additions yet not to me okay okay so trusty Kirby um I've seen the Google Doc with all of the comments and there were comments definitely from former trustee DEA Cruz and from Sergeant Crosby I didn't see a way to present the Google Doc with comments to the board um so I appreciate the work that trusty Medina did in trying to create a draft that represented those comments but I want us

270here tonight to discuss those possible changes um hopefully that answers your question a little sure I just wanted to make sure that srpd was involved in this and it sounds like like they are kind of but haven't yet responded these potential changes they were involved in making in making suggestions but they this this draft Is Not An approved draft okay that okay thank you uh trusty delator yeah just confirming and making sure this is very clear to this board the old on this document are suggestions made during the ad hoc these are not not approved revisions through that ad hoc these are suggestions that were made by multiple parties through that process unfortunately that process was last commenced in June 2024 and we had not gotten back to this um Sergeant Crosby and srpd and

271CH crean are aware of these suggestions they're part of that ad hoc committee Sergeant Crosby was um but we're bringing this to this board for information to be viewed um ultimately what started all this was a nonviable non-active mou um in 2020 that's and to this date in 2025 we do not have an approved active mou and a memorandum of understanding for both agencies to collaborate and work together and that is putting more students and staff and community at risk to not have that understanding agreed upon trusty Medina I think I I'd add you know again for for history and and I know you trusty kby know because you served on the ad hoc originally that um us as a district um through our ad hoc the commitment was to continue the Soro program with

272changes unfortunately when we sent our letter in December of 2020 to the city um there was never response and nothing got done there was no followup there was a lot of staff changes both at the city then here and then um we had to deal with schools um reopening from covid so a lot happened and then unfortunately what happened in March of 2023 at Montgomery happened um but but from this body the intent has always been to bring the program back everybody knows I'm completely opposed to it but it's still will of the body um I think in terms of uh this document and what I said um in that email I think there was one other component that was important and I think I'll add that I sent that because knowing that I was

273no longer president this work needed to continue and you know I don't think it was up to me to decide how to follow up but the the one the biggest thing that I think there isn't an agreement on is on the training part and that's the part that I put in the um and the email that I sent um the idea that on SRO um should have SRO training I think was critical Medina I'm yeah I think this would be better for the discussion part could we go to public comment first okay I I want to hear what you're saying I just feel like it it's part of the the board discussion okay are there any other clarifying I thought that's what we were at but sorry are there any other clarifying questions trusty Casten

274so my understanding is there's two timeline issues out there one is the testing of officers uh through their contracts for special assignments which occurs in the spring and then also a funding deadline which requires um collaboration for applying for grant funding and with a I've heard something around about closing June but obviously it would have to be developed is there a date that's being considered as a if it doesn't meet by um the 3x5 because a part of the concern I'm hearing here is this is also a committee that's been so hard to organize it hasn't met in seven months and so I'm just like when you're contemplating at least one more meeting is there a time frame to the contemplation of that one more meeting meeting I don't have an answer to that Dr

275Morales if the board would like to consider because I understand from my predecessor that it was the head of each of the 3 by3 they kind of try to get the both sides together I know that my counterpart um maresa um and I could start trying to schedule the meetings cuz I and everybody's really busy but I know used to be in his role as president Medina with the lead of the of the city trying to get the teams together but I could her and I can facilitate when the meeting will occur to maybe make sure it gets on everybody's calendars we can do that work of scheduling those meetings um if if it's at the pleasure of the board so that we can facilitate kind of try to pick up some um momentum to

276get those the two sides together if the board would like truste delator I would highly approve of that approach because time is of the essence here we cannot continue to kick this can down the road and ignore this very important situation and the inability of another committee to get together and approve this has delayed this long enough so if you could work with the city manager that'd be amazing to get something on calendar so that can come back to both enti for voting whether it's approved or disapproved it needs to come back in its final form for a vote and then also I recommend that our 3x3 meet as soon as possible and remember we are still on questions trusty Jenkins yes um I it's a request not a question hold off would you prefer

277hold off okay clarifying questions trusty Zuna uh can I can I be present for the 3y3 I'm allowed to participate not participate but just be be there or not three by three I think we we'd have to get the okay from the city because it's a joint meeting and and uh I think one of the critical things is I think because there's not a majority of anybody I think people feel um the ability to be very honest and open and and so I I I don't know if that would be okay but I think we'd have to ask our city Partners before saying yes or no all right I would like to get to public comment um I have a number of cards starting with Michael titon followed by Brent Stewart followed by Adriana a

278and as a reminder you have 90 seconds each go ahead my name's Mike theone um I asking you to reconsider the impact of subjecting students to sro's on campus and the criminal justice system especially at this time with the current immigration enforcement directives coming from Trump the potential harm that can be done to members of our community by putting a criminal record on students has always been terrible incarceration and criminalization should be avoided at all costs as they exacerbate the issues that are underlying um the violence and other problems that we see that that lead to situations like this um but it's never been more terrible um we're being told that schools are now a potential Target for ice and but the risk is also students confronted by law enforcement um is just greater now

279um if they're arrested and they go through the jail um there the risk of of being targeted by ice is is there as well um and you know at the very least protective guidelines that respond to the new federal directives should be defined um and I would like to see us work as hard as we can to keep students safe um not only from from harm on campus but also from the harm that that we are generally you know more complicit and okay with um as a society thank you next I have Brent Stewart followed by Adriana Arison followed by alria De La Cruz yeah my name is Brent Stewart um a Montgomery parent um my junior was a freshman um one class down when uh there was a murder in art class in front

280of the teacher um that student bled out because there was no Sr on campus to clear the scene paramedics waited I don't know the exact stats 35 45 minutes well that student died one life is worth whatever budget concerns you have about sros and if we're talking about emotional distress of being around a police officer how about the emotional distress of having your high school shut down um I think we can do better 13 months we fought 13 months ago to get this back on the agenda and some of these um board members have intentionally kicked the C down the road making sure it never happens um thank goodness some of them are no longer on this board some still are um the failures of this board not just on this topic but on the

281budget on the schools frankly I have no confidence in this board I kind of think you should not I know I shouldn't jump subject let the state take over they can't do worse than what you guys have been doing thank you next we have Adriana Arizone followed by alri DEA Cruz followed by Scott concade thank you my name is Adriana Ron um I'm a Committee Member and also a concerned parent of a Montgomery High School student actually two of them when just graduated last year um I'm in constant uh constantly concerned about my children's safety everywhere they go school should never be a place that I should be concerned of U about my child's safety and with the new presidential Administration threatening their humanity and their safety further with eyes being given access my concern

282keeps growing feeling safe is fundamental to learning as you all know feeling safe is fundamental um I'm sorry police officers on campus are not safe to my children and to me our children are facing many threats don't make another decision that further threatens them like Council member Sarah I believe said earlier you've caused enough harm start repairing support students you want to stop school closures you want students to show up then please show up for them please do not Place police officers on school grounds instead use that funding to support your teachers counselors and other caring adults to support loving relationships with our students thank you next we have alria DEA Cruz followed by Scott kingcade good evening board it is such a sad statement about the over politicization of the issue of safety in

283schools that our partners at the city couldn't schedule a meeting with us for six months yet in less than a month of this new board being installed we have M us for discussion in front of us this is not a time to bring to police back on campuses we live in a community where our criminal system continues to collaborate with ice and is less than transparent and honest about the real impact on our families on our communities um with regards to its ongoing collaboration for immigrant Children and Families now more than ever police and schools do not result in increased safety if anything given the horrific recent actions of this new federal administ ation it will res result in increased risk to safety and this mou does not reflect the hard work and the thinking

284that went in to so much of the work that the 3X3 did and that this board directed the board previously to do the current mou before you removed critical protections and clarifications about the limited role of law enforcement on campuses where there is only a clear and present danger or where all other interventions have failed also removed is an agreement to undertake a quarterly review of this pil pilot program to determine the model's Effectiveness especially with a with a special eye and care for students who continue to be over represented in the criminal system finally the cost cannot be be bor by your time is up last we have Scott concade good evening board uh thank you for your time this evening uh taking it all the way to potentially midnight uh I've been supporting

285sro's for far longer than the 13 months uh that you speak of because we started uh right after uh the incident at Montgomery High School trying to get sro's back on campus that was nearly two years ago uh this board has not taken action this board has Delayed Action for far too long theou in front of you is clear uh it allows for a program to start it allows for changes and modifications to be made there's a termination clause for terminating it within 30 days I'm pretty sure you have the controls in place to move this forward what has been discussed tonight is nothing more than continued delays the the discussion if you want to call it that at the dis tonight between uh the superintendent and other board members is lip service absolute lip

286service well we'll see if it's the board wants to bring it back and we'll see if yeah they want to bring it back they want to make a decision it has been worked on far too long make a decision implement the sro's and let's see how the program works as a comprehensive safety plan we have all the other components in place we're missing the sro's thanks to SRTA for sticking through it with us and uh CSA is going to have members that are active on this thank you your time is up need Fair all right I have no other blue cards so this comes back to board discussion truste Medina I cut you off earlier you were talking about training for SRO yeah so um what I highlighted in that email was the issue of

287training seemed to be the biggest issue of lack of agreement and basically the idea that um I think the original language was that um officers could receive SRO training like as soon as potentially available um meaning that they could be placed on our campus without that SRO training um the the idea that they wouldn't have SRO training would just make them a cop on campus it wouldn't be an SRO and so I think um understanding that is is critical and I I don't think this board should support any program that doesn't allow for proper training um I think um you know L Cruz and Miss son brought up important issues right now that that I think are important to consider and that's what we're dealing with in terms of this Administration today I had my

288mom tell me that she was afraid and my mom's a naturalized citizen I mean to not understand the impact of what's going on right now um and what will happen I think the other big thing the the pardon of over 1500 people I think it's going to embolden a lot of people to I mean in all honesty just be racist and act upon um the fear feeling that it's okay to get away with it and I think that's going to have tremendous impact in our communities and again going back to our safe haven policies I think our schools need to be a safe place earlier I didn't get to talk about um my intro but I think it's important to know that my motivation to read run to serve on a board was after the

289murder of Andy Lopez by a cinema County Sheriff Deputy I mean this me serving here is about ensuring that this voice is heard I understand that I'm a minority voice in in this discussion but I will make my voice heard and I because it's not just me this is the voice of many other students and young individuals and young men of color that have dealt with these situations that don't feel safe around someone in law enforcement and and that's just the reality um and I think our schools need to be a place where they are safe and so I I I do get upset when people always seem to blame me for this because I definitely oppose this this the 3X3 is three of bars three three in the city and I saw no leadership

290from anyone in the city to set up a follow-up meeting no one I was the only one that attempted it so so I I just want that to be clear um I didn't hear from anybody um we you know I struggled when we transitioned to a new superintendent because there was a lot of new things to take care of and so I didn't in the role of President I didn't put that on her um I finally waited till she was able to meet our city manager and then I tried to set up a meeting but it didn't happen and so so so I I say that to say you know people could blame me all you want but but this this involves a lot more people than just me so I think if if you're

291going to Target me also reach out to those city leaders for not taking any action or leadership to set up a meeting um please please stop interrupting the time for public comment has passed this is a board discussion now so so I just wanted to share that folks um I like I said I truly value democracy it's critically important for people's voices to be heard um including mine and the people that that I have chosen to represent people that have dealt with my experience um but I will always respect the will of this board and that's why I made sure to continue that message because I know it was the will of the sport to bring that forward but I think it's also critically important that this voice is part of the conversation so that's

292why I appreciate continuing to be part of the 3X3 because originally when the ad hoc was created um the police Union messaged emailed our board president at the time to make sure that I was not part of that ad hoc committee when I had requested it and so it's important that you all have that background thank you I want to focus us on the purpose of giving direction to the 3X3 on what revisions we want to see um trusty Medina brought up the training issue so I'm wondering first if there are responses to that trusty Kirby uh yes just a followup on that there seems to be I guess a misunderstanding about the training of SRO they aren't just taking officers off the street and putting them on our campuses um I sent all of

293uh well I'm sorry superintendent Morales sent all of you a copy of the SRO uh PowerPoint presentation from back that they presented here to the board back in October uh 14th of 2020 um just to highlight a few of the things um the SRO selection process is a full-time assignment appli for within the department they're chosen through a testing process the evaluation selection considerations are oral board score and performance performance evaluations on the job personnel file review prior experience coming into the assignment desire to work with youth and proper temperament candidates and college degrees are given greater consideration then there's a whole slide of all the training that they do specific to SRO um this is all based on the basic uh resource officer School the nazro and behavioral threat assessment to students um social

294media investigations they they learn how to do child forensic interview training National School Safety conference uh Gat instructor School active shooter school safety tobacco education education schools pal grooming stands there's a whole list uh of training that they go through prior to uh showing up on our campuses um so I mean that's specific to the training part of it I don't know U anyway that's my comment right there on the training can can I clarify is it a direct response yeah yes go ahead I think exactly all that additional training specific to sro's is issue that would need to be done um I think what was expressed is that it potentially couldn't be done in time they're only able to send maybe a couple people um and so to me what I think it's important

295for this board to ensure that we say yes before you put an officer on our campus they need to have this additional training that's specific to SRO because again if they don't have that SRO training then they're just a cop on campus and that's the point that I'm making delor so just for clarification my understanding of that conversation and the 3X3 was timing timing was the essence if we wanted to have an SRO program that school year there may not have been time for the additional training srpd now goes through which is in addition to what was on the 2020 documentation from that ad hoc that we were talking about if we want an SRO the following school year there might not have been time to do the training nobody from the other side said

296that they did not want to the training or agree to the training it was a specific time and issue was there may not be time to do that extended training prior to that school year so nobody was in disagreement that the training shouldn't happen it was a time and I need this board to hear that clarification trusty Jenkins and then trusty manier and that is exactly why we need to meet as soon as possible to get this agendized um to push things along because of the timing and the training it does take some time to get the officers through all of this training so the longer we drag our feet on making an actual decision the longer these kids are going to be in this situation I do want to point out like on on

297a personal basis for myself the last loaded gun was in the locker directly across from my son's my child okay and I have personal experience with losing a friend when I was in eth grade by gun violence so this is extremely near and dear to my heart not to mention the increase of ghost guns in the community and the thousands of calls that srpd is responding to on campuses regularly manier thank you um I came prepared to this conversation with um a a Word document kind of going through sections of the mou that I think um still needs some work so I'm happy to send this over to um Dr modales to share with a 3X3 because it's a lot um so I'm just kind of going to go through it so that it's out

298in the open for the public to know um so the first one and I have five points number one while theou mentions addressing disproportionality it lacks specific measures or accountability Frameworks to track and mitigate disproportionate impacts on students of color there is also limited mention of how to avoid reinforcing stereotypes about students of color um for example through profiling or selective surveillance that is the The Limited mention of that is very concerning so my suggestions what I would like to see in this mou is the inclusion of more robust oversight mechanisms such as independent evaluations and mandatory reporting of all SRO student interactions dis segregated by race ethnicity and socioeconomic status um also the integration of a structured feedback loop like a stakeholder committee that give students families and Advocates particularly from marginalized communities a

299formal role in shaping the program and to review and provide feedback um on the sro's program's implementation focusing on minim minimizing fear and protecting vulnerable populations number two theou discusses restorative justice but but does not outline clear processes or metrics for ensuring its consistent application I would like to see clearly defined restorative justice methods and also require that SRO involvement be contingent undocumented failure of these methods so really we need we need our adults in our system um they need to be able to clearly demonstrate that they have exhausted all other options um I also don't see any mention of in response in this and I know that in response um is is a city service and our law enforcement Works uh very closely with them I would like to see that as it that

300added as an intervention to be taken before law enforcement intervention um we do have the theou with the suggestions by the 3X3 members it does say that the parties agree that law enforcement activity against a student is a last resort after all other interventions have been exhausted but I would like for documentation to be a requirement not just an agreement that we find this to be true um number three around the selection of an SRO i' would like for this section to include not just one District representative on the advisory panel I'd like to see I'd like to see there be room for student voice and parent representation from existing groups like deac or maybe some of our um existing student groups on on our different High School campuses number four theou does not explicitly

301state that all training must be completed before sros are placed on campus it only outlines the topics and indicates that the training will be determined jointly by srcs and srpd um due to this lack of clarity I would like for this mou to clearly state that all training must be completed prior to deployment on campus I hear what you said trusty dtor um and I'm hoping that we can kind of figure out how to do how to how to figure this out but I I really do agree that we need to uh to clearly have this laid out that training is going to happen before deployment on campus with ongoing professional development occurring afterward um and then number five sorry I lied I have six number five right now we are starting to hear a

302lot of fear and mistrust of law enforcement because we are seeing how the new federal Administration is planning on targeting non-citizens and our immigrant community so while theou aims to rebuild trust it it says that um it does not address how the physical presence of uniformed armed officers um might deter students from immigrant and immigrant families from engaging fully in school life um so what I would like to see to address this is um I'd like to see language explicitly prohibiting SRO from inquiring about or sharing students immigration status to reduce fear among immigrant families I'd like to see strength and protections for Student Records by clearly stating that SRO may not access information related to immigra immigration status under any circumstance ances um I'd like to see reassurance that they will comply with furpa

303family educational rights and Privacy Act and state privacy laws to protect sensitive student information and I'd also like to see a provision that any information shared with law enforcement is strictly limited to what is required by law with no voluntary disclosures to immigration authorities and lastly number six um the Clause allowing for the carrying and use of firearms and use of physical restraint could be very triggering for marginalized students and their families and so I would like to see um that sro's I'd like for us to consider I know this might be kind of a larger discussion but for us to consider that sro's remain in plain close and avoid carrying firearms during routine school activities to reduce um the perceived threat um those are my six points and I'm happy to share them with

304whoever needs to have them truste Casten and then trustee delator have questions specifically on the training and I have broader comments but I'll stick with the training for for this moment because of the direction we're going with the conversation I in theou from the working group there are several required trainings identified including Crisis Intervention training which from my work I'm familiar with the deescalation um implicit bias uh harm reduction um there's also so listed trainings that are required around uh interaction inclusion and equity and all of these are shall and must language in theou I I'm I'm trying to understand and I'm thinking about this in the reverse direction if someone was giving us anou that was requiring us to go to one of our Union uh bargaining units um and say that we're executing

305anou and it's impacting all these trainings that we're now required to implement and then that they'd have to go back and renegotiate the entire labor bargaining unit uh relationship in um around the timing and the execution and all those and I can already imagine Katherine coming in here um if we sign off an agreement that was requiring SRTA to meet all of these deadlines before teachers could do it because we signed inou with another body and so I'm just trying to understand if we're at the place where we're saying all of these are required trainings and we're setting anou and an agreement that in good faith we're intending to execute together where the difference is going to come in between the structure of theou and our working partnership with the the department it just seems

306like we're trying to solve a bunch of theoretical things or things here that are going to trigger a lot of Labor negotiation issues between two government entities trying to work together together and so I'm just trying to understand the philosophy of why this will and Shia language isn't getting us where we need to be can can I add I think on on all these trainings um there's been agreement You Know Chief is okay I don't think they have any issues with their Union on it the only issue and it's the only part highlighted in in section seven of the training is on item 7A where if you'll see in bold the difference is they have um as soon as practic practicable upon appointment and that's the disagreement like again if you're going to be on

307campus have the training without the training you're not an SRO that's the point that I'm making so but on all the other part there's been agreement um in terms of all those trainings I do want to say for myself um um the training is a top priority for me I would rather have our SRO fully trained and have them not there on the first day of school then have them there on the first day not fully trained that's I'm only one vote that's my stance yes trusty manary I mean I also want to add that there's no funding for this yet um it's going to take time to figure that out and so to your point trusty Casten if we're negotiating in good faith and and doing this in good faith um I would hope

308that they that the that srpd can begin to do train to to offer training and to get a pool of of candidates trained or their folks trained um because it it's just going to take time even even if this mou were you know approved tonight like we would still have to figure out the funding piece of it and so I'm hoping that that that time can be used wisely and if we're if we're negotiating in good faith I hope that they're also coming into to this with good faith and and training their staff to be ready for when we have the funding I think trusty Jenkins has been waiting thanks um I wanted to just put a is this my time for a request yes um I think that it would be extremely beneficial if

309we requested someone from the police department whether that be Chief krian or Sergeant Cosby um to field some of these questions from the board if it gets to that if if we need additional time I also want to just put it out there that this conversation started at I don't know 10 to 11 um and unfortunately you know that the people that we had here earlier was a bigger crowd than by a little bit not by much Maybe not maybe not bigger than our SRO crowd that had been here in December of 23 in that entire 23 yes in that entire year um and I think that we owe it to the community to be able to have this discussion in front of more of them at a time that doesn't start right after our

310normal meeting would end so I do request that um that you know after we get this 3x3 meeting on the books and hopefully done that we bring it back for a discussion with the public at a time where they can actually participate too can I respond to that really quickly I mean this will be brought back for action and so there will be public comment time then so regardless it will come back for the public to comment on I'm going to go to trusty Kirby deor Medina um so again just some of the training um it's my understanding is some of the training that we're requiring the SRO to obtain is only available once a year some of the class so again operating in good faith like director castom was suggesting you know there needs

311to be there's going to have to be some kind of compromise that okay you're 90% trained you're missing this one class maybe you can still be on the campus depending on what the class is I guess but just know that some of the training that's available is is only available once a year again we need to get this done but and to the funding they can't go out and request funding until we actually have anou that and an agreement in place that they go okay they're going to agree to allow us on campus now we you know you can't go get funding for something that you haven't even been approved to to participate in so you know it's kind of put in the car before the horse but we got to get the first before

312we can go find funding or they can go find funding thank you director Kirby um that's absolutely true we're not going anywhere until anou is approved so there cannot be good faith efforts there cannot be good faith training until we approve anou and let the city know that as San City School Board we may want an SRO program this previous board voted on and approved an SRO pilot program to be implemented and it's still stuck on anou um I really need to know where this discussion's going so that the next 3x3 meeting can actually get something actionable done and bring that back to both entities for a vote um director Medina you had expressed how you had reached out for another meeting that reach out didn't happen until I asked for this Smo you to

313be put on the agenda so I that email was was not sent until I asked for this to get to that agenda this year that has been 7 months since anou was drafted and we're still nowhere near completing it I do have a push back on the restrictive language of sro's being the last resort after everything else isn't exhausted my direction would be that an SRO is part of the entire restorative process that is their point of being on the campus not to wait till everything else is exhausted um this has we've not had an SRO program for over five years we've had one death we had had several children criminalized for behaviors on campus without an active mou and an understanding of how these two agencies are going to work together and collaborate and

314keep our students and teachers and staff safe then we are putting everybody at danger because we do not have that understanding of what they're what we expect of them when they're on our campuses how we would like them to operate we can put all that language in anou to ensure they're protecting our students and our staff and right now without an approved mou they're operating as they are trained and 911 is called is a lot different than an SRO program and it's not just trainings of the sro's that I want to talk about it's training of our staff with srcs we are missing out on vital opportunities to train with srpd on threat assessment dangerous situations active shooting drills even something as important as the every 15 minutes which we no longer apply on our

315campuses within this District we just lost two lives in our community under the age of 23 and we haven't had an every 15minute program here for I can't even remember the last time but as part of a relationship with anou that we can create those type of trainings to provide collaborative efforts on how to keep each other safe how to collaborate and work together so we got to find the right language that lets everybody do what they are good at doing and collaborate and work together and we need some kind of Direction this could go on for three hours to have the discussion what do we need for that 3x3 to work on so that something actual can actually come back to this board and to the city's board okay my turn um a lot

316of things to comment on here first off um trusty Kirby um did you on waiting for funding I mean it's important to recognize that prior to our board um having this decision the city cut off the funding they used to fund it with measur row which is now measure age funding and um if if the city wanted to have people ready I mean they could decide to fund training for these officers I mean it won't hurt to have extra training so if if they if they're serious about having this done and being ready to go upon the passage of Anu they could be funding officers to get that training now and be ready and have a a pleora of officers with the training and I think it's training that that would benefit them in the

317big picture in terms of interaction with our students and our youth and our community in general um but with that said I think um in in response to utra in terms of my message I didn't know about whatever I didn't know about whatever request you made um the the follow-up meeting that I requested was back you know sometime last year so this this this recent email was between our last two meetings and unaware of your requests um I think it's important to acknowledge in terms of this in terms of suggestions um there's the the section on collecting demographic data which I think uh trusting Mone brought up one of the things that we want to make sure um and this goes to the other section on quar review because this is a pilot program so

318we want to review and assess if it's working so that's why that additional bolt section is in there but demographic data is important part of the issue that we wanted to address from the ad hoc committee was who is being impacted is or um bipo students being disproportionately um impacted by having officers on campus we had no data nothing about data so in terms of assessing a program whether it works that's why this additional item is there and we would hope that um the city and Sr and srpd could agree to collect that because I'm sure they have an interest in ensuring that they're not disproportionately um targeting our students I think the other issue um aside from the court of lead review is that complaint system we need to make sure that we have

319a a complaint system that's Anonymous right we need to be able to have people trust and be able to complaint um without feeling the fear of Retribution and I think that's something that that was also um listed in there that we needed to add and I think in terms of uh the training and training of our staff I think that's something critical um but I think this idea of what the role is and the limitations on the role is critically important because another one of the big issues that the ad hoc committee identified is that our staff were overusing sro's in situations that they shouldn't have that they were situations where staff um should have been the ones dealing with those discipline or whatever issues and they were over relying on SRO so it was

320about clearly um distinguishing these roles and that's why it's critically important for us to invest in training our staff as well I think again these are issues that you know we spent months and months with an ad hoc committee reviewing and that were highlighted and that need to be addressed and this mou attempts to address them and I think some of these highlighted portions in there um are to address that and so in terms of moving forward forward um I think that is the ask um seeing what's highlighted in this section as a board are there some of those items that you disagree on um and I think maybe we could do some sort of like Collective straw polling or whatever to figure out any of that but I think these are the important issues

321that are being brought up and again it's honoring the work of the ad hoc committee bringing that stuff forward um so I'll leave it there so we have about 20 minutes left and I I like the idea of a straw poll I want us to be able to give direction on at least a couple things the two items that I'm hearing disagreement on are the timeline for training and sro's being a last resource are there any other items of disagreement that we would need a straw poll on Rusty Casten I'm concerned about the either or SU situation of a straw pole in those because we're looking at theou so the contractual basis to be in a program that's going to be developed through collaboration with a department um that is going to involve a lot

322of additional things that happen on top of and above this a lot of the things I'm hearing that I absolutely agree with as being a part of the program I find very challenging to have contractually bound into theou and and a part of this is also who we're working with and you know in if we talk on a national level school resource officer programs are something I have very deep concerns about and would not be in general uh inclined to support in Santa Rosa in 2004 they passed as a city we passed additional funding to specifically start moving towards neighborhood policing models and at that time was called Gang intervention and that has evolved over two decades to move to violence prevention and programs that have integrated the police to be at the lead on

323Statewide reforms around these um we have a police chief who used to serve or may even still serve on the Nami board before he became Chief and helped create the response program and there's a lot of innovation in a direction that I strongly support law enforcement moving in that's happening with this particular Department that gives me Faith in our ability to have a collaborative relationship for our specific program and I worry when we say things SRO can't get involved until after all these other things happened because a big part of that neighborhood and Community Police concept is building relationships when you're not in an enforcement Rel position and it would be inadvertently be adding language that would prevent the very type of preventative Upstream non- enforcement interactions that um are are what this is supposed

324to create um and forcing it to actually become an enforcement only uh program so for for me saying yes or no on the straw pole items is it doesn't work because the collaborative process that starts after we actually agree on theou and that's where that's where my concern is about doing it that way I hear you I think a straw poll is not necessarily what I want I think I want us to go down the line and have each trustee share briefly where they stand on those two issues so that the 3X3 knows where the board stands and can take that forward and consider it we know they may not be able to accomplish everything but I want the 3 by3 to know how the entire board feels on those two issues which seem like

325are areas of disagreement just a quick point of order kind of um since one of our members left the 3X3 who is going to make up the 3 by3 trusty okay I missed that part somewhere okay thanks sorry again it was timeline for the training and what else um so timeline for the training and whether or not sro's should be a last resort so could we we're low on time could we go down I'll go first Medina I I think they need to have the training before they're on our campuses so that they're actual SRO um and in terms of last source of inter I think again we've worked so hard to develop so many um interventions that that SRO should be the last the last point of intervention in in the situations that are

326required based on La trusty Kirby okay um yeah I do not think that they have to be the last um uh the last to be called the last part of intervention that they can be a part of it as you know as the training as as theou lines out that they don't have to be the absolute last uh line of defense so to speak um and then as far as a training I would say I would like to see something in there um basically stating that they either need to be I don't know what the proper percentage is let's say 90% % trained Andor scheduled for training um for the rest of their training before it they're allowed on campus president MCN before we continue could I just read that portion so everybody just clearly

327hears the language that we're talking about go ahead um the language is the parties agree that SRO involvement is limited to situations where there is a clear and present danger or where the superintendent or her design has determined that other interventions have failed so that's the the specific language that we understand trusty Jenkins um with the training I think there's Nuance I agree that there should be as much as possible done but I also understand that there are time constraints of training in general um I do like the idea of making sure everything is at least scheduled if it's if it hasn't been completed and there should be a certain percentage that's already done um if not all of it ideally and then as far as the Last Resort thank you for rereading that um

328I mean they're I see sro's as as a big part of the school Community a big part of the community in general um so yes last resort on on a huge situation but those the SRO are going to be interacting with um the entire School community on a very regular basis and I don't think that our wording should hinder that justy manieri um I agree with all the suggestions in theou um with the suggestions by members of a 3X3 that version of theou that we're looking at so yes that includes I agree with the training beforehand um and also the The Last Resort language um I really think that that that version of theou the one with the suggestions by members of the 3X3 is the floor um and I would like for my other

329points to be considered I agree with that language on both counts as well trusty deor um my thoughts on the training and you know this is why we need to approve the mou so quickly is yes I would like and SRO to be fully trained with any additional SRO training that is available but if this mou is approved sooner than later then that puts the ball in srpd court to ensure that training can get scheduled and take place so like we've all agreed upon we don't have funding for this the city doesn't have funding for this but if we can approve anou we can then have an agreement on how we're going to collaborate and work together so I like the Nuance of fully trained or scheduled to train and the sooner we prove this

330the sooner they can get the ball rolling on their training as far as the last resort the way I read it is very restrictive that we are not going to call on an SRO um until all their Avenues have been exhausted and unfortunately we have not seen that all avenues are being used and enacted appropriately and quickly enough that I think an SRU is part of the entire process and part of the rest s of process is a team approach to get to the hurts on this child's heart on what is happening and as a collaborative for everybody to help this child get to where they need to be for their safety and the safety of others so I do not agree with them being um put in this document as a last resort trusty

331Casten on the training um on training I I do like the uh the potential for language I would say that the trainings that have been completed or is scheduled I think we need to be cognizant of um just how trainings get scheduled and the timing and and make this operational um with that said to get through the testing for special assignment within the police department I'm familiar with that from my previous role on their oversight committee and um it's not a like you can't get through that testing without having done a lot of the concepts that are in here as far as training goes so uh I'd like the committee to consider Nuance that reassures Us in the community that they are going to be well qualified but doesn't create a bureaucratic burden for being

332able to implement uh the program uh I I think the biggest value to SRO are when they're not enforcing um so any limitation that uh that could be interpreted to eliminate the ability for them to be part of the Campus Community to be uh mentors uh to honestly there's a lot of six figure really good paying jobs that are paid for by our city that I would love to see us actually growing the next crop of St Rosa police officers through that inspiration and we just had a presentation on CTE like how can we have this also be something that benefits having those jobs go to people that live in our community and are currently our students to improve leasing throughout Santa Rosa so I anything that restricts the ability for those interactions those mentorships

333those relationships um I would not support going into the document um really quick on Ice they were one of the first departments to sign on to the um local accountabil the local law enforcement letter um restating their commitment to all the laws that restrict collaboration ice Chief krian co-signed with a majority of this board the loen letter uh recommitting to all of those things just weeks ago uh or I guess months ago now and so um all those concerns we should be very cognizant of and realize that we're working with anou with a organization that has joined us as Leaders already in preemptively signaling um that they agree with us on this and that there shouldn't be collaboration with ice so um you with all of that said speed is of the E Essence I

334would be happy with this mou um because I believe that a lot of things we're talking about are going to happen once we get to actually implementing and collaborating on this I see you trusty Medina we have 10 minutes left I know okay go ahead I um I think it's important for folks to understand again this this last's work what section it's under it's under the discipline right and and I'll read the part that went before um that srcs and SRS will utilize the following graduated response model which provides the progression of consequences for continued minor student misconduct as such students in need receive appropriate redirection and support from in school and Community Resources prior to the consideration of SRO involvement or Court Referral and this is when we go into the again limiting a

335involvement to a clear and present danger or when the superintendent and her design or her design um determine that the others have failed and I think it's important to understand that um most likely the design for each campus would be the the principal right so if the principal is saying hey we need your help it would allow for that but again it's really understanding that the intent is is to try to avoid interaction with law enforcement in in the context of discipline this doesn't limit them from interacting in other ways in a positive ways on campus um yeah great thank you everyone for the respectful discussion I believe Dr Morales has been taking notes will you be able to give those notes to the 3X3 I will CL them up all right I do think

336we need to move on with the agenda um so next we have resolution number 25-37 early tell incentive for classified employees okay I will do this as fast as I can um so um I want to present to you um president mcnali superintendent Morales and members of the board and the public a resolution for an early tell incentive for our classified employees as we move to the time when we will be doing layoffs we'd like to encourage employees that are thinking about retiring or resigning at the end of the school year to give us their notice as soon as possible so we'd like to give an early tell bonus of $1,000 for those that inform Us by January 31st a bonus of $750 for those that inform Us by February 15th and a $500 bonus

337for those that inform Us by February 28th this is for classified employees they would still be required to F finish out their um contract year so they would um not be able to leave until the end of their contract year which would be no later than June 30th and no earlier than their last contract day um and it would be an irrevocable uh letter of retirement or resignation so we're asking for your approval on this resolution truste Medina move to approve resolution 2024 25-37 on early Town CER for classified employees as presented moved by trusty Medina seconded by trusty Casten any discussion roll call vote trusty Medina comment I I have no blue cards hi trusty Caston hi trusty Kirby trusty Jenkins hi trusty de laor hi trusty manieri hi president mcnell hi I motion

338passes moving on to resolution number 2024 D 2024 25-38 can we wave the presentation yes thank you do we have any blue cards no blue cards I move approval as presented second moved by trusty Casten seconded by trusty Medina trusty Casten hi trusty Medina I trusty Kirby hi trusty Jenkins hi trusty de laori hi trusty manier hi president M McNelly I motion passes seeking um Point privilege on on the net consent items um I also need to pull um G8 CU I'm not voting for it uh I don't we can't pull items after adjustments to the agenda before we have that discussion can we go to G9 since we have legal requirements around it and take it up for a vote and then we can have the discussion about whether or not we can pull

339G8 sure let's go to G9 so again I pulled it this is the same issue on the minimum wage as before um again I'd like to um move to amend the 1650 to be 1787 to be equivalent to city of Santa Rosa a point of order and link to object to that as it is posted a notice stating that any adjustments to it would require is going to be done through a process that's in the brown act published agenda stating that it'll be G done through subcommittee and so I believe the motion is not in order and I'd like to then move to a motion on what's presented in the agenda I I would disagree it's posted we could make an amendment on what's posted um my concern with the amendment is our relationship with

340our CA Partners who we have promised that we won't give any other raises in until we've settled with them I'd like to revisit this as soon as we've settled with them I think they've consistently made the point you know about being the least paid workers and I think this is an example of lower paid workers and I think they would be supportive I would hope of nobody getting paid less than the local minimum wage um so I'll continue my motion if nobody seconds it then obviously nothing happens I I want to second the motion but I very confused what about like what's going on parliamentary wise so we have two motions and no seconds mine wasn't I was just saying that I believe because it's notice saying that there's a process specifically to do what

341TR D Medina is wanting us to do now that we've noticed the public that that's going to happen and if we don't take this action we're not going to be in compliance with state law which is why I don't believe it's in order and because and if we don't have a second then we can just move to the motion to actually get the 1650 and we only got two minutes so Lisa Aus has a information about the legalities of things no I was actually just concerned that we weren't going to get to the consent item but the Reas if if it helps the reason for the compliance has to we have to pay the minimum wage regardless our employees will receive at least the State minimum wage the issue is that two things one the

342um for stirs and purs and things we have to have an a board we should have a board approved salary schedule that matches what we're paying as well as we had we realized that there was confusion related to the way something was worded and there was contradictory information so we need we are asking for approval so we can clarify that because people were paid at the wrong rate based on that in the past is there a second to either trusty Medina or truste caston's motion trusty Kirby uh to approve it as is I second that motion yes uh there's no public comment roll call vote trusty Casten hi trusty Kirby hi trusty Medina no trusty J LS hi trusty deor hi trusty manieri hi president MCN I motion passes I move approval to consent agenda

343items 1 through 14 minus uh item nine objection I I need a G8 I can't object also minus G8 so we can just get to the these things passed so I'll move approval of interr consent agenda uh 1 through 14 minus 8 and N second roll call vote trusty casted hi trusty Medina hi trusty Kirby hi trusty Jenkins hi trusty de laor hi trusty manary hi president McNelly hi motion passes uh we have on on G um you want me to go um I I don't think that this is a service that we need um I from looking at what this service does it's really um the news that we have is primarily local and Regional and it seems like this would allow us to monitor news like throughout the world and I think the

344the amount the cost of it for what we need um I think is excessive and I think what it accomplishes we could do by just setting up some simple Google alerts on news on our district on our schools locally that would help us identify articles within the local area or throughout the country um this basically seems to me like we're paying a lot of money to have some service that tells us when we're in the news um and I think it's overpriced for for the little news that we get so I believe we'll have to push that to our next meeting meeting adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.