CorpusRecord 107025

SRCS Regular Board Meeting - January 8, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Santa Rosa City Schools
Date
2025-01-09
Location
Sonoma County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
31,634 words · about 176 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e good afternoon everyone thank you for coming now opening the January 8th 2025 meeting of the Santa Rosa City School Board we will start with public comment on closed agenda items only if you'd like to comment on a closed agenda item make sure you filled out a blue card um our closed session agenda includes student readmissions student expulsions Public Employee discipline dismissal release conference with labor negotiator conference with legal counsel and Public Employee per performance evaluation so those are the only items that can be commented on at this point in the meeting all right I'm going to read names three at a time so you know when your turn is coming up so first we're going to have Laura inong followed by Maria marz or Ramirez followed by Pedro Mendes we have Laura here president

002MC and you will have 90 seconds thank you can you hear me yes go ahead Laura Laura inong my name is Laura inong and I'm here today to ask you to consider reinstating Alan Petty's status in the classroom and on the field I've had the pleasure of knowing Alan for 20 years we met in 1999 he was a teacher at my high school one of the ones that everyone talks about long after leaving school he cares about every student in his classroom and he makes sure that every child is receiving the education they deserve as well as giving him the confidence not many of us have during those formative years he also provided the support that a large number of students in Southwest Santa Rosa do not have access to he made sure you had

003the tools to succeed even if you thought you didn't he made sure you did that's just Alan the educator mobo rugby does not exist without Allan Petty rugby in Sona County as it is does not did not come to FR come to fruition without Allan Petty there are so many players that have come out of Allen's programs and are more than just successful high school athletes we have the elite amongst us USA Rugby USA Eagles players D1 athletes International Players professional athletes all because Allen ran a rugby club all because he helped establish the Women's Club those who felt they had no place found a home here we all found a Brotherhood hood and a Sisterhood that continues to thrive long after we hung up our boots if you look around this room you will

004not only see former students and former players as individuals but you also see families Generations who have had the honor of witnessing the generosity of Alan Petty not only does he give his time but he financially gives to players who cannot afford so I ask you once again please consider the impact your choices have in our community because our future Generations thank Laura your time is up thank you next we have Maria Ramirez followed by Pedro Mendes followed by Josh inong we have Maria oh yeah hello go ahead Maria um hello my name is Maria Ramirez and I'm a senior at El Allen High School um this is my second year knowing Mr Petty as I was in his US History the year before and last semester I was in apgb with them um I'm

005here to talk about my experience as a student as an active student right now um uh I want to talk about one of my biggest problems within School curriculum all over just the US is one of the biggest problems is learn helplessness Mr Petty has always taught us responsibility from that we are not helpless we are capable we have a responsibility to ourselves and to our school to show up to do our work and to if we need help to reach out when we need it and he's always made it available to us when we needed that help he has been very successful at letting us as students know that if we ever need help if we ever need anything he is there for us W he allows us to know that asking for help

006does not make us dumb making mistakes is okay and that despite what everybody else thinks about LC Allen High School and their students we are strong we are capable and we are resilient a teacher like Mr Petty is a representation of everything that is great about oelen and shows that our future Generations are in amazing hands thank you Maria your time is up next we have Pedro Mendes followed by Josh inong followed by Lindsay Verina Pedro go ahead hello my name is Pedro Mendes I'm currently a senior at LC Isen high school I'm a former student of Mr Petty and currently the president of the lobbo Rugby Club I stand before you today to advocate for a teacher who has not only shaped minds but also has made a lasting impact on the lives of

007countless students Mr Petty is nothing short of one of the best teachers and mentors the school has seen he brings an enthusiasm and a passion to the classroom that many teachers fail to convey students thrive in environments where educ educators are passionate experienced and connected and Mr Petty has proven his ability to do this while earning the respect and Trust of his students on the other hand Mr Petty made an impact on athletes in ways that go far beyond the scoreboard Mr Petty has taught discipline teamwork and perseverance qualities that prepare students not just for sports but for life Mr Petty has served as a mentor and a role model who has encouraged students and athletes alike to push through challenges and persevere I didn't performed very well during my first season but despite this

008Mr Petty never gave up on me and stressed the importance of every player on the team in making this decision you have the power to send a strong message to our students our staff and our community that we believe in growth that we value dedication and that we understand the importance of Second Chances Mr Petty has proven his commitment to his profession and his students by allowing his return We allow him to continue making a difference to our students and Community thank you thank you Pedro next we have Josh inong followed by Lindsay Bina followed by Kenya Guerrero Josh go ahead so I'm Joshua aong I'm a current lcen High School football coach so Alan Petty has been there for me for the last 20 years as a friend uh as a mentor and as

009an educator I would not have this job here at LC Allen as a football coach if it wasn't for Alan Petty uh he helped me turn around a program from being 0 and 25 to being the last losing strect for the last seven years to being seven and5 this year and contesting for a championship CIF um Allan has not only been with me for the last 20 years but uh as a senior at a high school um I had a traumatic situation in my life and he was there for my family Not only was he there for myself my mother and my father but he was there for my younger siblings uh he was giving us food every day and uh just to be a support um without Alan Petty and our school system in

010Southwest Santa Rosa they would know that would not be us or not be me uh be able to stand up here today I respect the time and I appreciate you all but to give him a second chance to be able to understand that this man has changed not only my life but South Coast Santa Rosa's life and still continues to impact youth as we speak and with that I appreciate that thank you thank you next we have Lindsay Bina followed by Kenya Guerrero followed by Jenna lietti thank you as a nationally recognized restorative justice specialist who got her start with Mr Petty at LC Allen High School I find it a little odd that we would resort to punitive punishments when we've been preaching to the community that we are a restorative school district for

011almost 10 years the point of restorative practices is to at some point yes we could remove a student from the classroom or a teacher from the classroom but we have a conversation and then we bring them back so what I I'm not seeing is bringing Mr Petty back Mr Petty has actually saved the lives of students he does so every day and he saved mine I wouldn't be standing here without him today so I'm not completely understanding why he isn't being given the same chances as people in this District who have actually done real physical harm and why all of a sudden the district now seems to care about Personnel issues and I think that's what's angering some of us the most because now you care and it's not the right person so if we're

012going to be holding people to the same standard and we're going to be calling out the monsters of the school district I would say we do it to the people who are actually monsters in this school district and not create an example of somebody who we want to just make out to be one thank you thank you next we have Ken Guerrero followed by Jenna lanetti followed by thoron McKay hello I'm Kenya Guerrero I am Allan's adopted daughter Allan has changed my life I say I do not say that lightly but wholeheartedly in my times of great need Allan has been a father figure mentor and so much more when I first met Allan I was in high school and I was an incredibly vulnerable state my late mother suffered from alcoholism through my entire

013life and my biological father was deported to Mexico shortly after I was born for the majority of my life I had no stability in my parents during my junior year of high school my mother's alcoholism reached its peak and she could no longer provide for me and my siblings I became homeless Allan's daughter my friend from school invited me to stay over during this time upon learning of my situation Alan his wife and his children opened up their home to me and IM mediately welcome me to be part of their family one of my first memories of Alan was when he explained the house rules to me this F this moment stand out to me because it was the first time I remember an adult caring enough about me to open me to stability and

014structure growing up in and out of foster system I could imediately sense a difference in his home and his environment Alan offered me a home and unconditional thank you Kenya your time is up next we have Jenna lamp petti followed by thoron McCay followed by Tina Yang good afternoon my name is Jenna lerie and I'm an Elan alumni a mother and forever a rugger I had the pleasure of having Mr Petty as both my teacher and Coach my first year playing rugby we didn't have enough women for a women's Squad and he said you can play but you're going to play coed we didn't go home and cry about unfairness or inequities we said yes sir and Coach showed us how to get better faster and stronger so that we could do it all the

015while not even realizing that he was pioneering the way for women's empowerment he didn't treat us any different he was just equally as hard on us because life is not fair and he would been doing us a disservice to treat us as such in 1999 my teammate and friend Andy Davis ran away without hesitation but with parental permission Mr Petty loaded us up into his van we drove down to San Francisco and we scoured the streets he acted immediately upon an endangered student who was in crisis after 48 hours we found Andy and brought him home in 2021 I bought Mr Petty a greatest teacher card and finally put my gratitude into words because I needed him to know the profound impact that he has had on me and any other students that has been

016in his Circle I never wanted him to spend even a moment of his life Wonder difference thank you next we have Thorton McKay followed by Tina Yang followed by Craig mono hello my name is thoron Scott McKay and I'm here to advocate for Alan Petty the suspension of Allan Petty was wrong and Allan peny deserves a second chance as we all have known throughout the years Mr Petty might be tough and structured as a teacher but he's done so much for the community and so much for LC Allen High School he has done so much for me too Mr P might seem tough structured and harsh but he also has a heart of gold and brings humor happiness and support to the table um wait oh and then when I was going through my darkest

017time and my biggest struggles in my life Mr Petty was there to be supportive and help me both Allan Petty and his wife Joy also supported me with my flight to Missouri to the LC Allen rugby national championship also I can't not forget to mention that I have had some amazing moments with Mr Petty and his family for the holiday celebrations and I've gotten great advice from him throughout the years throughout the years I have known Petty I am so lucky I have gotten the opportunity to not just know him as a coach a teacher a mentor but also as a friend it's been a pleasurable experience getting to know him um please give him a second chance and he deserves it he's going to help so many people out thank you thank you next

018we have Tina Yang followed by Craig Mano followed by Matt Huddleston Tina go ahead I'm here to speak about a teacher whose impact on our community is undeniable Mr Alan Petty he's more than just a teacher like what others has said he's a mentor a coach and a role model he's taken a student who was struggling with a 0.3 GPA and somehow got him to attend class graduate go to the JC and get a degree at Davis UC Davis he also has been credited by a a veteran Marine Corps that it was Mr Petty who helped keep him and his friends off the streets who helped them um prevent prevented them from serving 15 to 25 years or end up 6 feet below below the ground he has an extraordinary way of connecting with his

019students and he was even asked to marry and officiate a wedding in 2004 and ever since then he's he's officiated many more weddings his dedication hasn't gone unnoticed in 2014 he was chosen to speak at graduation in 2018 he was recognized by the Sonoma magazine um and most recently in 24 2024 he was recognized as the champion of children by the Four Seas so it's time for the superintendent and the Board of Trustees to show Mr Petty the same unwavering support he has shown the community for the past three decades thank you thank you Tina next we have Craig mono followed by Matt hudston followed by Jonathan Macha sorry if I mispronounced your name go ahead Craig so I'm here to speak uh on behalf of Mr Alan Petty as it seems like quite a

020few of us are today which is uh really great for me to see um I'd actually first met him as a young man just entering into high school and uh right away I I noticed them playing rugby out there and I went up to talk to him and he encouraged me to come out even though I wasn't a student of his I didn't even attend the school that he was coaching for uh he still really pushed me to uh show up and and to just try it out and just see if it was something that I was interested in and um it was under his leadership and his coaching uh that ended up leading me on to uh play further into college uh I ended up getting to play with the under 19 national team

021while he was coaching me for a little bit and then I continued on to play at a lot of other uh like International countries for club club teams all around the world so I ended up playing in uh England Australia New Zealand um all of this was through inspiration of Coach Alan Petty uh something that I noticed about him uh was just like me just being a random face off the street uh he would really encourage anybody to come out and be involved and I couldn't understand how he'd have such a successful program wasn't until the years later that I noticed is because he could truly bring out the best of each individual um by doing so and uh you know he is someone that officiated my wedding he brought food to my family after

022the birth of our son and I know he's someone that'll always be there for me and I'm just happy to be able to speak on his behalf today thank you thank you next we have Matt hudston followed by Jonathan Macha followed by John tomason good afternoon folks my name is Matt Hudson I'm a chief engineer down at pedma Valley hospital um I also have 14 years as a youth sports coach in soccer softball baseball and football because of this I I've had the privilege of working with a lot of coaches some good some bad and some great coach Petty falls into this category I met Alan petty over 30 years ago when him and a group of men introduced the game of rugby to the area high schools Allen has not only served our country

023honorably in the United States Marine Corps but has served the community for decades selflessly first as a teacher and second as a coach of rugby and football the amount of lives he has influenced over the years is immeasurable and needs to be accounted for this man has the respect of all those around him students athletes coaches and parents why because he's Fair tells it like it is is caring and humble he also makes sure the boys off rides wherever we're going almost always driving a group himself coach Petty is instrumental in teaching these boys how to become young men how to work hard to reap the best results to be honest and respectful our son Connor and the rest of the club are upset about this situation really bum that coach hasn't been allowed to

024be with them to start the season I implore you please don't take this opportunity away from our son we want him the other boys to live the experience that so many other athletes have had under coach Petty LED teams or clubs in closing Allan Petty and his wife Joy deserve both to be treated and respected much better than they are right now our community is a better place with him in it thank you thank you next we have Jonathan Macha followed by John tomasine followed by Angelica Reas hello board my name is Jonathan Moko uh lifelong Santa Rosa resident and current teacher at s a high school um I stand behind a long long line of lives that were saved by Alan Petty I was on a path of Destruction before he turned me not

025only into a teacher but a man and a father and a Community member that's doing everything I can to have just the littlest amount of influence that petty has I know that this is a Personnel transaction that you all can't speak about but I implore you especially the new board but all board members to take a look at the members here the people here today that took time off of work to let you know that our community is in crisis our community is in crisis because Alan Petty is not where he should be in the classroom saving other young men so they can grow up other young men young women so they can grow up and better this community our district lives by the philosophy Embrace engage Empower no one has done that more than

026Alan Petty I challenge any one of you to come come up with somebody that would even be in the shadow of and Petty when it comes to helping the dis underprivileged and underrepresented people of our community as you reach out to the community and we know you're dealing with big things like School closure you're constantly thinking of how can we give a voice to the people that don't have a voice Allan Petty's been doing that for 32 years better than anyone else and there is not a close second please consider the health of our community thank you thank you next we have John Thomason followed by Angelica Rivas followed by leonila uh Bergstrom go ahead I just have a couple comments to make um first of all I'd like to ask the audience who is

027here supporting Alan peny Mr peny okay that's I just want to uh the board to recognize that I've known Allen for over 30 years Mr Petty is a valuable resource in so many ways um on a personal note whenever um one of his uh athletes or students did not have health insurance he would tap into me and call me and see if we could get in and what we could do to take care of that person now he didn't need to do that but he um took it upon himself to do it he um started a wonderful program at LC Allen that I know has um helped so many underprivileged kids he started a youth program in rugby um he's just he's done so much for the community it just seems a little foolish and

028a little bit shortsighted to throw away a valuable resource like that anyway thank you very much thank you next we have Angelica Rivas followed by leonila Bergstrom followed by Hugo Vargas read this um I've been a see I've been awarded trainer of the year for the last three years and that's Mr Petty had a big influence from me moving here from Mexico and being a being a woman that wasn't allowed to play sports Mr Petty gave me this freedom to believe in myself Mr penny has seen me train at the track back 10 miles after school always actually waiting for me to finish when I ran 10 miles to lock the gate for me he has come when I left my car in the parking lot and then the gates were closed just to come

029and open it for me but all along is Mr Petty makes you feel safe comfortable and allows you the freedom to be yourself no matter where you come from no matter what you do but he makes it okay to just be who you are I work alongside with Mr Petty with the football teams right now in the county and uh him and I sponsor a lot of the kids Recovery Services to we help prevent injuries for kids I have a sports performance facility in Kat and ever since I opened my recovery Lounge uh Coach Josh M Army coaches LC Island we've been sponsoring a lot of these kids to go forward in sports and to help them prevent injuries and keep them getting stronger and keep them on the field I personally feel that he's

030a great human being and he's like another figure to me so that's it thank you next we have leonila Bergstrom followed by Hugo Vargas sorry thank you good afternoon Santa Rosa city school board members imagine your own child in high school feeling overwhelmed anxious or maybe just looking for a Safe Haven to run to whether it because due to the typical day-to-day expectations or because of an unexpected event that happened during school that day and their one safe environment and trusted adult was Mr Petty's classroom he created this safe environment for all students whether they were in his classes or not or whether they played rugby on the LC Allen lobal rugby club's team or not from just about 30 years ago when he started at LC Allen from 1994 after it was newly built

031he's created a one-of-a-kind culture there for all students that impacted not only those who attended but their parents and eventually their younger siblings who eventually attended LCL in high school you can imagine how many students that is over the past almost 30 years that he's helped to steer in guiding to open up their future Pathways that they may have never thought possible or even imagined going to college on a scholarship or attaining a job right out of high school do you think it stopped here once they graduated and moved on with their lives no these adults who not only thrived here locally in Santa Rosa throughout California Nationwide and even internationally has stayed in touch with him because of this lifelong impact that he has made on them and their families there's a saying we

032have once a lobal always a loal your time is up thank you Yugo Vargas go ahead hello my name is Ugo Vargas I'm a former alumni of LC Allen High School and also a student of Mr Petty's Mr Petty never once undermined my very early interest in the business world he instead planted the seed of higher education and with parental permission took myself as well as many other students to visit college campuses all on his own dime asking nothing in return every day at lunch myself and many other students would bombard Mr Petty with questions about business psychology history and so much more little did we know he would make a list and invite speakers for these very topics to class so that our curiosity could be fed I was taught fundamental manners by Mr

033Petty like how to shake hands and be present when spoken to he knows how to reach our youth in a way that is very much needed both academically and through Sports Mr Petty is also one of the head coaches for The LC Allen Rugby Club as you may know which has been wildly successful with multiple back-to-back championships and student athletes receiving scholarships and pursuing higher educ every year due in large part to him and the rest of the coaching staff's guidance terminating Mr Petty's employment would cause a ripple effect that would have a direct impact on many other students I am just one of many who Mr Petty has impacted deeply and because of his guidance in my earlier years I have turned around and done the same whenever given the opportunity just as he

034did for me at one point in time in my opinion Mr Petty is a pillar in our community thank you for your time thank you are there any other blue cards there are no other blue cards right thank you all for being here and sharing your voices the board will now recess to close session good evening everyone we are now reopening is there an echo yeah I'll keep going for now um now reopening the January 8th 2025 meeting of the Santa Rosa City School Board um please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance and then remain standing for a territorial land acknowledgement and truste Kirby will be reading our land acknowledgement test I acknowledge that Santa Rosa city schools is on a traditional territory in homelands of the Pomo people traditional territory and homelands of the

035Coast Miwok people and honor with gratitude the land itself and the people who have stewarded it throughout the generations this land acknowledgement calls us to commit to continuing to learn how to be better stewards of the land we inhabit by offering this land acknowledgement we affirm indigenous sovereignty and will work to hold Santa Rosa city schools more accountable to the needs of American Indian and Indigenous peoples thank you all right before we move on with our next agenda item I'm going to hand it over to trusty Casten to say a few words thank you president mcnali I'd like to take a moment to recognize that tomorrow is a national day of morning for former President Carter uh for those that don't know President Carter started his career in politics as a Schoolboard member in Georgia

036and as president he was responsible for the creation of the US Department of Education so if I could ask everyone to just take a moment of silence to recognize as we are on the eve of this day of national morning President Carter's impact on the reason that we're all here today thank you all very much thank you trusty Casten so moving on now to C3 report of actions taken in closed session the board approved student readmission case 24-1 and moving on to items considered in close session for Action in open section I am seeking a motion on student expulsion case number 2024 25-15 motion to approve second that was motioned by truste deor seconded by trusty Medina roll call vote trusty de laor hi trusty Medina hi trusty MCN president MCN hi trusty manier hi

037trusty Casten hi apologize trusty Jenkins I and trusty Kirby I so motion passes 70 um all right are there any statements of exstension Rusty Casten I have on item G3 uh two potential clients of clients to my company I haven't been able to confirm whether the conflict exists or not so out of an abundance of caution I'll be abstaining on the item thank you and that was G3 you said correct any other statements of abstention all right adjustments to the agenda FY Medina like to pull G9 and G13 please okay for for discussion not pull them off G9 and G13 any other adjustments superintendent Morales um yes on item oh that's loud um J2 board conduct and code of ethics that is actually now part of the um board governance manual that will be updated

038end of um January or early February so is accidentally put on there from a previous last year so if that could just be removed that would be great thank you superintendent Morales any other adjustments all right then we get to move on to our special presentations for student of the month and employees of the month um for Lewis Early Learning Academy and Proctor Terrace Elementary School uh do we have principal Pella here e right everybody well this is Giani and it is you got it see you B all right it is my absolute joy to present the Leela student of the month award to a truly remarkable preschool student Giani soless this is gian's second year in the program and he has come so far academically socially and personally every day gianny steps off the

039bus with a radiant smile lighting up the classroom and brightening our days he greets everyone he meets spreading joy and positivity over these two years Giani has demonstrated incredible growth transforming from being unable to communicate using Picture Exchange communication systems regularly what stands out most is his unwavering determination even when faced with challenges Giani never gives up he has a ton of try and continues to inspire us with his hard work and perseverance he's gained essential student skills become a model for his peers and is a kind and loyal friend to all Giani embodies everything this program stands for effort growth and Community he is a rock star in every sense and it has been our honor to witness his journey so congratulations to Giani we are so proud of you you get to go

040take a picture ready yeah all right um up next I have uh the classified employee of the month and I'd like to welcome down [Music] Yoni good job Dy okay it is my privilege to celebrate Yoni Hercules pan in The Amazing impact she has had on our school she has become an indispensable part of our team and our school family in such a short amount of time Yoni joined us in August of 2023 and from day one she's brought her own special light to room 16 Yoni is more than just an instructional assistant she is a ray of sunshine her energy warmth and positivity brightens the lives of everyone she encounters from our students to her colleagues her perfect attendance is a testament to her dependability but what truly sets her part is her initiative

041and intuition Yoni sees what needs to be done and jumps right in always ready to support uplift and make a difference she has an incredible gift for working with our students making each one feel seen heard and valued her intuitive nature allows her to understand their needs and ways that make her a true asset to our classroom Beyond her skills yon's Joy is contagious her laughter her happy spirit and her funloving personality create an environment where everyone thrives Yoni you have been an Allstar since the moment you walk through the doors you embody what it means to care deeply about our students and to work as part of a team you inspire us every day and we are so grateful for all that you do congratulations Yoni you are a shining star list take a

042photo also all right ch Che alrighty and up next please congratulate with me certificate Employee of the Month Lacy helming so let us celebrate Lacy helming a preschool education specialist who truly and deeply loves her students Lacy your colleagues nominated you for this award because I quote you love these kiddos with a depth and sincerity that is nothing short of remarkable end quote that's really nice I'm not crying but that's really nice like our other preschool teachers Lacy is responsible for teaching our students how to regulate their emotions communicate participate in daily living skills like eating and toileting to understanding preacademic concepts how to share how to be a friend how to be a student and so much more Lacy is committed to doing what is right for children and sees the potential in everyone

043she builds relationships with the families advocating for them and supporting them through their first Public School experience she also leads a team of instructural assistance and works collaboratively with service providers Lacy's Sunny personality is as warm and bright as her love for all things yellow bringing light positivity and joy to everyone around her she balances gentleness and firmness creating an environment where children feel safe nurtured and empowered to grow we are so grateful to know you to work with you and to see the amazing impact you make every single day Lacy thank you for being the bright passionate and dedicated person that you are congratulations I'm good okay you want to be the photo you go thank you so much do we have principal Moore here come on down good evening Santa Rosa City School

044Board both incoming members and previous members we're so happy that you are here supporting the school district I am so excited to introduce the Proctor Terrace Elementary School student of the month London Miller the moment I met London I knew she was a student who was kind and resp respectful and over the past year and a half that I've gotten to know her my intuition has proven to be correct as a student at Proctor London has been playing cello for the last two years through the school music program and loves it she also participated in the multis School Musical performance last year and plans to participate again this year London also had a role in the San Francisco Opera production at proor terce for the last two years and just last month was one of

045a handful of upper grade students who participated in the St hcia performance outside of school London has participated in Girl Scouts since she was five and is currently a Cadet through which she does a variety of community service projects she also plays softball she has playing so been playing softball since she was five and when she was eight she started playing at an advanced level which included playing with the traveling team she placed catcher put an can also play Third Base and left field a true utility player she recently tried out and was accepted on a new travel ball team out of nevado this is an a travel team and competes at a higher level than she's ever played before in the offseason which is only about two months she does circuit training with other

046young athletes at a gym in Petaluma London is outgoing sweet natured and loving and serves as a teric role model not just for other students but for us all she always gives 100% at anything she tries she's naturally athletic artistic which doesn't always go together but London has the ability to excel in both here are a few comments from the staff at Proctor as to what an amazing student she is London is a hard worker who wants to do well she's always kind to others and willing to help London is a fantastic kid she's polite smart and fun and will always come up for a chat during recess letting me know what softball how softball is going or her on her hearing Journey London is a delight to students and adults alike we congratulate London

047Miller she's an amazing gift to all of us and we are so fortunate to have her at Proctor Terrace good St and then we can shake thank and now you can picture oh good job lendon I'm a bit sad to be up here alone with our our classified employee of the month for Proctor Terrace um but she had a wedding to attend out of the country for her brother so we gave her a pass on this one um Maria aruan Castillo uh is commonly known as Andrea Andrea throughout our community she is the family engagement facilitator for Proctor Terrace Elementary School where she has enjoyed being part of the team for the past two years before stepping into this role she spent three years as a part-time child care assistant and new Duty supervisor working

048working with children and supporting the district over the last 5 years has been truly rewarding for her she is passionate about helping our students and their families engage in their education and looks forward to making more Connections in the future however perhaps most telling are all the comments made um by the staff at Proctor Terrace on the joy that Andrea brings to our campus here are a few Andrea is one of the most caring sweet helpful women on campus she is always happy to help jumping into many different possessions when needed the kids absolutely adore her she is definitely a trusted adult to many students she makes Proctor a better school Andrea always has a smile and a warm greeting for everyone she is so helpful to parents and kind to students she is always

049willing and ready to help anywhere where she is needed she is always a helpful person with a ready smile kind words to say working with Andrea is a delight she is a huge asset to our school she always makes herself available to anything you need there is never a time when Andrea isn't smiling are you are you sensing a pattern here she is a light and joy um and the students around aren't around herc are always around her because of this warm attitude and uh her welcoming appearance to all we are so fortunate she is an important part of the Proctor terrce Community helpful kind students love her a smile on her face I think that about sums it up she is dedicated helpful and kind in closing we are so grateful to have Andrea

050as part of our team and are pleased to have the opportunity to honor her wherever you are Andrea we love you all right so finally the certificated Employee of the Month Caitlyn Cameron some of you might recognize Caitlyn she's although she did start her professional career as a corporate meeting and event planner but soon realized that working with adults can be challenging however helping K kiddos learn how to learn through differentiated instruction and supporting and supporting them in gaining access to the curriculum intrigued her to become a teacher she now has 15 years of teaching under her belt she has served at beella as a student teacher and then later at Lincoln Elementary and Ridgeway High School where she was nominated as teacher of the month twice Caitlyn enjoys finding ways to connect with students

051who need extra support and currently serves on the alt Ed committee additionally in De in demonstration of her growth mindset Caitlyn is participating in two fellowships through sco teacher leader in mathematics and the literacy Fellowship the following are a few comments from the staff and colleagues at Proctor about Caitlyn Caitlyn is a great teacher her students are always happy in her class and they always follow her instructions she was always very friendly and happy she advocates for herself others and of course students she is a true leader Caitlyn is a fierce advocate for her students she is so caring and wants to see them at their academic and social best she creates high expectations for her students and follows through with these expectations the structure of academics academics in Caitlyn's classroom is outstanding especially coupled

052with her kindness she's fun honest hardworking and can work through anything Kaitlin has a terrific can do approach to everything she likes to get to the source of things and is definitely a team player we are fortunate to have her as part of our team um and she has a great attitude Caitlyn is a colleague friend and she taught my son I admire her for her cander humor and as someone who always seems to have a finger on the pulse she is engaged in our school our district and Community if I ever have questions on how things work she always takes the time to answer unbiased and truthful and afterwards she lets me know her own opinion which I truly respect as a teacher she has a wonderful Knack of finding balance between running an

053organized classroom at the same time creating a space that our students feel seen respected and cared for I have one more child to go through first grade and I I will feel very lucky if she ends up in Miss Cameron's class these comments are certainly evidence of how much we admire and appreciate having Caitlyn at Proctor Terrace congratulations again to all of our students and employees of the month we will now move on to our school site parent organization updates from Proctor Terrace Elementary School starting with our elac president thank you principal Moore sorry about that I have a statement from our elac president um my name is pea Z zakarius and I am the President of elac for Proctor teror Elementary School in this message I am letting you know that during our meetings

054in 2024 we shared information and resources for our community and we discussed some important points of our school such as the different entrances that are that our school has we were looking at important points for safety for our students also in one of our meetings at the beginning of this year we had people who joined in from a folkloric I have struggled with that word Folklorico dance group in our first meeting our principal introduced herself to to us as well as the new parents and let us know about the important activities on the school calendar for this year soon we will have our first meeting on January 29th thank you and we have our PTA representative hello my name is Aaron Matthews I'm here tonight as the Proctor terrrace PTA board vice president and Communications

055chair I'm also substitute teacher at Proctor and a parent of a third grader it's right over there I'd like to start off by saying how proud I am of the people being recognized tonight I know them well and to say they deserve this recognition is an understatement knowing them enriches my life and I know they do the same for anyone fortunate fortunate enough to spend time with them this year our PTM PTA membership has more than doubled compared to last year and years prior we have 53 members which when you look at most PTA numbers is impressive this year we really wanted to focus on creating a strong PTA membership intentional and productive meetings and ultimately providing support to our school all students and staff we've already had a ton of fun as well so

056let's talk about that fun we kicked off the year with a free ice cream social volunteers made up of parents and teachers served ice cream families got to mingle and play while getting to know new and familiar faces even PT tiger our school mascot made an appearance our annual fan favorite wathon took place at the end of September and the entire School participated those who fundraised helped raise a whopping $32,000 this was an incredible way to start off the year financially and because of this we were able to double our field trip budget and liberally ex uh liberally I'm sorry liberally fund the requests of teachers and staff to enhance the school experience for all our kids then came tigerfest our fall festival that is free and open to Proctor families and friends tiger Fest

057has been happening for over 60 years and when you talk to Proctor alumni they fondly remember it from their ATT childhood it's truly a special event next year or next we offered a free night of bingo it happened to be on a very very rainy night but that didn't stop our community our MPR was packed even students and the boys and girls after school club attended it was such a fun night we've had a number of Dy and donates this year including sy's Pizza who is our fabulous supporter um as our school neighborhood pizza joint and often find you can often find fifth and sixth graders hanging out there after school our D and donates so far this year have already blown our fundraising goal out of the water we have many more events in

058the works including our annual dinner dance and auction that will take place on April 5th the theme will be party like an animal and thanks to their generosity and desire to support their neighborhood School the flamingo has agreed to host our event because of course nothing says party animal more than a flamingo more things we're pleased to share are that this year all of our PTA event and informational Flyers are now being translated into Spanish um and our PTA meetings are being translated as well since doing so we've experien the greater engagement from all of our families some of whom have started a bay full Folklorico club which had its first meeting today we funded a girls volleyball team for fourth through sixth graders and they were amazing the school spirit and camaraderie was so

059great to see in action we've had an incred we have an incredible school garden that is being maintained by a volunteer committee and volunteer groups this year Pacific Market our neighborhood grocery store purchased and sold more than three 300 of our Persimmons that were grown in our garden I just thought that was so cool in early December the PTA hosted an informational Zoom meeting to ensure families are aware of the upcoming decisions that you will be making in February more than a hundred people attended this meeting many of which were our Spanish-speaking families as Miss Andrea simultaneously translated the meeting by the way I'm so disappointed that you weren't able to meet Andrea tonight she is true magic and goes above and beyond to ensure every person in our community is included and comfortable at

060our school this meeting although an unfortunate topic made me feel so inspired by our community our school is truly loved and cherished our PTA has thrived this year many thanks to our amazing Community they are th uh we are thrilled to be a resource to our teachers students and staff and to continue to expand in the ways in which we are are able to support all of the students we are very proud of our accomplishments and we've had and we we very proud of our accomplishments we've had so far and we're looking forward to many more to come thank you for giving us the opportunity to brag about our Beloved School and the efforts of our PTA thank you all right we're going to take just a 5 minute break so those of you that

061joined us for the celebrations have time to step out and then we'll come back to our uh public comment section e e e all right we will resume with the meeting so we are moving now to item D which is public comment on non-agenda items and sent items uh currently I only have two blue cards if there's anyone else who wants to comment on a non-agenda item please fill out a blue card um when we do public comment I'll read three names at a time right now I only have two but generally I'll read three so that you know when your turn is coming up uh so first I have Margaret Boon followed by Catherine Howell and you will have 90 seconds for public comment tonight good evening I wanted to speak once again in

062support of our classified staff I know in December they received an offensively low offer from the district I do know we have no money but we cannot expect our classified staff to carry the weight of our financial wos they haven't create this fiscal disaster and they've already sacrificed too much for too long I heard they asked for for a 10% wage increase and I want to argue that's actually too low and it's generous of them to be willing to settle for 10% later tonight we'll talk about special ed and how it's eating up so much of the budget that actually fixing special ed would seemingly fix the budget maybe we should do a deep dive into how to expedite that I bring that up though because a large part of the overspending is because the

063huge amounts of money wasted on using outside agencies to fill all our empty positions because we can not hire in house we don't hire in house because we don't pay enough that's the only reason I have an assistant right now who wanted to work for the district saw what we paid and went with a job at an outside agency I know a dozen people working in ESN who have said the same we need to pay more in my 13 years with the district we've never been fully staffed ESN is the only one that is fully staffed and most of our people are outside agencies if we ever paid anything reasonable we could actually save money by not paying other people to sta our schools thank you thank you next we have Katherine Howell uh good

064evening I'm Katherine Howell um and I am addressing item G9 which was on the consent agenda uh which is or sorry G8 which is a proposal for um electronic locks on all of our school buildings uh we know that our bond funds are only covering about a third of what we need for our schools and we recently used Bond money to replace pretty much all of the locks in the district we're wondering uh at this time at the time that the other locks were replaced electronic locks were not chosen and yet here we are replacing all our basically new locks with newer locks um how does this show public confidence in how the bond is being spent uh how are these locks going to make our students safer are these locks giving more access to

065the teachers um I've heard there's been a lot of issues with sort of the pilot ones that we have around um and there's also been some concern amongst uh teachers that these locks track who goes in and out of buildings and what time they go there and it seems a little in invasive to the privacy of teachers who are just trying to go to work and so that's why I wanted to ask those questions of the board and um make a comment thank you thank you president how are there any other blue cards for non-agenda items no there are no other ones for that um item all right then we will move on to the reports section of our agenda starting with our CA report we have President Leman here yes I am good evening

066president mcnali governing board superintendent Dr Morales student board member cabinet members and everyone listening tonight welcome and thank you to the classified staff teachers students and parents who came tonight to show the district We Care we'd like to welcome the new board members Nick Casten Sarah Jenkins and Mark Kirby we hope you will reach out to your liaison School sites and talk to our classified employees as well as admins and teachers congratulations to the students and employees of the month especially our classified employees Yanni from Lewis Early Learning Academy and Andrea from Proctor Terrace Elementary School we support the approval of the resolution recognizing January 27th the international Holocaust Remembrance Day we continue to be concerned about the increased in classified Staffing by outside contractors as their salaries are increasing too we met with the

067district for negotiations December 13th and December 20th we are still waiting for a fair and Equitable compensation package that the majority of the district have already received July 1st 2024 six months ago thank you SRTA members for supporting us in our demands for an equal raise we are some 600 classified employees without us you would not have a school district with courage and compassion we look forward to a happy New Year thank you thank you president amen next we have our Santa Rosa Teachers Association report president Howell good evening me again uh good evening president MCN superintendent Morales members of the board and members of the community I am Katherine Howell SRTA president I represent about 900 teachers in Santa Rosa city schools SRTA stands with CSEA we support their need uh for a fair

068and Equitable and even bigger raise than SRTA members got because Mary is 100% correct this District doesn't work without them and teachers can't do their jobs without the classified staff they need an offer that makes sense that isn't insulting and that will actually improve the living conditions of these classified members um I'm going to talk a little bit I uh it's interesting that Mr Casten brought it up we have the national day of morning coming we've all been hearing things about Jimmy Carter um I was six years old when Jimmy Carter was elected and he's kind of the first President I remember as being a president and knowing what that meant and I was listening to the radio about a lot of his achievements and one of the things that really struck me was there

069was a conversation that it was on NPR so was a couple people talking to each other and they were saying that at some point during his presidency President Carter met with a group of advisers at Camp David and they said to him you know Mr President you're not you need to improve you need to be better at your job and one of the pieces of advice criticism that he was given is that he was doing a pretty good job of managing but he was not being a leader and this struck me as my position of leadership in this district am I being a manager or am I being a leader and I'm going to ask each one of you that same question we've got three brand new board members we have a new board president

070and what this District needs right now is leaders we need you the people at the Das right now to lead us through some Vision so that we can get through the next few months and the next few years and the chaos that we are all being enveloped in right now we need leadership to lead us through that chaos I think we've had a lot of management but not enough Vision we need tonight we're hearing about the vision that we need for special education um I've lived through the past four and a half years as no three and a half years as president listening to peac meal changes to special ed and oh this is going to change and that's going to change we're going to try this but there's never been a vision for where

071our special education department is going and how are we serving those students we've got the school closure committee I'm on the school closure committee I was on the the fiscal advisory committee I was on the F facilities Advisory Board I'm on the Committees and I still am not seeing Vision I'm seeing a lot of managing going on but no vision we don't know what those schools are going to close and we don't know what we're going to do with them once they're closed we've got chaos amongst our students we have students spending their evening here pleading for their schools rather than you know focusing on being good students which is what they need to be doing and we also have a couple new board committees being formed tonight I think I'm happy to see that

072there was a time not too long ago when this board removed and abolished all subcommittees but we're a little bit concerned SRTA is concerned who's on the committee is it just a couple of board members and the superintendent because that sounds like an echo chamber to me right where is the vision in these committees how is it going to get reported out to the public is the public going to be part of these committees or is the board going to take comment from the public during these committee meetings it's all kind of a mystery to us and it's again a lot of managing but not a lot of vision so I'm going to ask you just like the advisers asked President Carter please focus on vision and not so much on management thank you thank

073you president Howell next we have our superintendent report Dr Morales so happy New Year welcome back to everyone um I know we've been gone for two weeks and I know that what's on everybody's mind is school closures and consolidations so I just want to uh remind everybody that our town halls start next Monday today we sent out our January newsletter in it it has a section with a link to our proposed we've heard from the community I've received I can't even count how many emails around different ideas and scenarios within the the people our community members have had we've taken those and have created a a dialogue session that we will have during the town hall so it's not just a sit and get we want to be able to put out some scenarios that

074we've received that the committee has received and get your input so we're actually I'm calling them Town Hall dialogues in instead of meetings so please look for the um parents square that was sent to you click on that link look through the slide deck look at the pros and cons that we've um come up with we're going to ask you to come up with more pros and cons um get your ideas so it's truly a dialogue so that the board has different options to choose from when they come to make a decision around our consolidation and closures so please come to our town halls it will be next Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday and then the 23rd um and it also on the newsletter it has um what schools we will be at so please stay

075engaged with us in the conversation as we look to create an as um president how said redesigning um and really establishing a vision together of what our district could look like in the future so thank you thank you Dr Morales so next is the board president report I don't have much to report at this point I'm settling into my new role as board president I've been working with Dr Morales on setting the agenda and looking ahead to Future agenda items I'm trying to ensure that all trustees have a voice and what we're setting on the agenda um so if any of the trustees if I have not had a chance to meet with you oneon-one yet I would love to set that up anytime you have something you'd like to see on the agenda I

076want to know um other than that like Dr moral mentioned we have the town halls coming up I want to encourage you to attend those if you have any question questions or concerns that's where you can get the information you want and welcome back everyone I hope hope you had a good winter break do we have other board member reports okay I'm going to start with trusty de Tor then trusty Jenkins then we'll go from there good evening thank you president mcnali welcome to your new seat um I just want to say Happy New Year and welcome back to our community and and look around this room this matters this is important you showing up you are engaging you communicating what's important to you and that's really important to us uh I welcome the three

077new board members to this DS and look forward to working collaboratively in finding Positive Solutions on how to come through the chaos we see it we hear it I'm present I'm listening I'm learning I'm engaging before winter break I had the joy to visit eight campuses and wish our teams a happy winter break and there's nothing better for a board member than to be in the classroom and connect with a student and hear first perspectives on what's going on I've had some really engaging conversations with fifth graders and second graders and that's where the impact is happening our children our students we do not take any of these decisions lightly we understand what's at stake and it's very important that you keep showing up and communicating what is on your minds and hearts so that

078we can put the best decisions forward as possible thank you guys very much look forward to you being at the Town Hall dialogues so you can get more information and connect with your board email call send messages so that we know what's going on and where it's going on and we can be involved in the community thanks thank you trusty deor trusty Jenkins thank you pres president MCN um I wanted to take this opportunity to introduce myself to the community as a new trustee um while you can find my board bio on the website along with a recent selfie um I think it's important for you all to know who I am there is information about my education as well as Community involvement on there um I've interacted with many of you in one way

079or another over the years and if you have older kids in the High School District there's a good chance I taught your teen how to draw Snoopy when they were little or shown them a giraffe or a cheetah more recently if you work in the mental health field with youth we may have interacted within the county system of care additionally I'm hoping many of you have seen me in the community and have heard me speak at board meetings maybe we've met at a parents meeting seen each other at a sporting events or volunte in in the community maybe we've crossed paths in the Dance World personally as a general reminder I am a human and a mom of students in our high school district this type of position is not one I have taken on

080I've held a variety of board roles over the years within ptas Franklin Park Co-op Safari West Wildlife Foundation Etc and I'm definitely a systems person but I've not yet been part of a group of individuals whose decisions impact tens of thousands of our community members this role is not taken lightly and I've been actively engaging with folks to stay up to speed on all the information that has been put out by the district do know that I'm in this for the community I'm in it with all of you through the grief that we'll experience together and through the reimagining of our schools to achieve academic excellence in the coming years there are a couple things that I do want to get out of the way um right off the bat though I am going to

081cry this is just me don't worry about it I'm a crier it's okay I'm likely going to offend someone and do my best at walking it back once it's been realized I know this isn't great I also know that being um able to make mistakes in our communication and sincerely attempt to repair misdoings makes relationships and Community stronger I'm going to laugh at the wrong time and I'll try my best at controlling my face as I'm not used to having the camera on me and recorded for several hours at a time a few times a month I'm sure I'll roll my eyes or for my brow smile with my whole self or accidentally zone out but I will get better most importantly I'm going to do my absolute best at being a trustee who is

082engaged and as transparent and honest with you as I possibly can be um on a more business related note I want to request to all of you if you are here to make a public comment or maybe here um in support of someone being recognized I highly encourage you to join the zoom when you leave to stay up to speed with what's going on stay plugged in reach out and get to know folks attend the town halls if you can if you can't please send a representative of your peer group and report back um I don't know if you guys know this I didn't know this for a long time but if you look on the screens in the little corner that's how many people are watching on Zoom it's kind of cool and then

083lastly I wanted to plug an awesome event coming up put on by the Montgomery Education Foundation who enriched the environment for all students at Monty their annual crab feed is coming up on the 18th at the fredman center and ticket sales are open right now through their website tickets can be purchased individually or by VIP tables which is awesome because you can have your very own wrestler for the table for to help you throughout the evening um if you guys have trouble accessing the website you can feel free to reach out to me directly but I look forward to working with all of you in the future thank you thank you trusty Jenkins trusty Kirby hi yes uh good evening I'd like to introduce myself as well um again a lot of you didn't get

084to really know us uh since all the new members ran unopposed so uh um I'll give you just a quick and my bio is not yet up on the website so bear with me I'll bore you a little bit with some of my details um so I grew up the son of an educator uh back in North Carolina where both of my parents were first generation to be able to attend college in their families I attended Duke University on a Navy RTC scholarship where I received a degree in cultural anthropology I then served in the active duty Navy uh and reserves while in the Navy I also completed a master's degree in aviation and Aerospace operations from emry Riddle University my father instilled to me the belief that you should always try to leave something

085better than the way you found it to that end I've always been actively involved with improving our community with a heart of a public servant our schools were once were once safe and secure Havens for our youth to learn grow and get involved and Thrive but now sadly they are not I hope to be an integral part of this governing board that helps return our schools to the level of greatness that they should be I'm the father of three graduates from Santa Rosa city school district I've been very involved in volunteerism and school Improvement for many years I served as president of the Maria Creo High School athletic booster nonprofit program and led a team of dedicated volunteers including director delator um parents and students in the successful effort to install a new artificial turf

086field and track at the school the only one in the district that did not have one uh additionally I've conducted uh alumni interviews for students in the area applying for admission to college for over 15 years as the current commander of the American Legion Post 21 veterans organization here in Santa Rosa I'm in charge of the boys and girls State program and interview potential delegates for this valuable governmental education experience I currently serve as an elected member of the executive Council for my labor union at my work and I serve on several nonprofit boards as well I served on the community ad hoc committee that studied whether or not school resource officers should remain on our school campuses obviously after many weeks of surveys and discussions the overwhelming majority of committee members voted to keep

087the sro's on our campus is while updating theou with srpd students who feel safe are more connected to their school and care about their education this includes physical safety to Shield them from violence theft weapons and threats as well as emotional safety as emotions influence one's ability to process information a layered approach using both restorative programs and a law enforcement presence will help lead to the safe and secure campuses our students teachers administrators and Community deserve I want an education system that encourages critical thinking and intellectual growth uh children should learn how to think independently not just what to think I hope to work with the other board members to help build up our CTE programs and join a collaborative effort between other districts and counties to send our students into the world as independent

088and productive citizens an important lesson another important lesson my father taught me was that God gave us two ears and one mouth for a reason I am here to listen to you and advocate for the positive direction our district needs and just a report uh I did visit um Hidden Valley Elementary School with uh director Casten on Monday and we had a nice visit um and saw the uh Deen heart of hearing students there it was a a real joy to get to meet some of them and uh it was it was u a very nice visit and that's all I have thank you trustee Kirby Other Board member reports trusty Caston thank you president M uh similar to my other new trustees I just want to take a moment to introduce myself with the

089benefit of a campaign we've had many months to have this conversation and we're trying to do it as short as possible so not going to I'm going to try and get my bio up on the website so you can look at my history but I want everyone to know where I'm coming from as I look at the things that are coming before us both in the next couple of months and then over the next four years setting priorities and making goals is about not just choosing the good things that we pursue but choosing the good things that we don't pursue and I'm always going to put the decisions that focus in my understanding the most on education and enrichment programs for our students first what that means to me is putting money back into the

090classroom putting money back into the programs that make it so students want to be at campus not just need to or have to be at campus and by focusing on those two things first I hope that that line of decision making leads to solving many of the symptoms that are problems that we have put resources into solving so please reach out as uh director Kirby mentioned had a really good tour at Hidden Valley um had a great time learning with many of the other trustees up here at the csba conference uh if you send me an invitation to come to a campus or to meet with a parent group um the emails are on the website and I'd like to come and learn and meet from you and share more of my story in one

091toone environment thank you thank you trusty Casten trusty manieri thank you president mcnali um I really like this this was really cool I feel like I got to learn more about our new board members at the same time as our community which is just what a what a gift um and um maybe in the future we can I don't know maybe this is like a note for superintendent Morales but um it'd be nice if the current board members might be able to reintroduce ourselves to the community as well it's it's not um every meeting that we have a packed a full house that is is listening to to what we have to say and so um it would be great to to be able to do something but I really like this thank you for

092doing that um I wanted to uh share that I went to the um LC Allen Winter concert and it was a really fabulous time um the Mariachi the I mean all the students are just amazing and so I I feel very lucky that I was able to make it to that um and got to see some folks I haven't seen in a long time so congrats again to the to the Lobos and such a a wonderful concert um I also because we do have a a full house um also wanted to take a moment to thank you all for showing up and for advocating for your schools and your communities I see all the signs and you know please know that we're we're looking at this and we're listening and um it's it's really exciting

093to hear that the district is is moving away from a meeting um and rather having dialogues um with regard to specific scenarios that we can actually look at and start to have a conversation about and so I just want to encourage all of you who are here to talk to us about consolidations and closures to bring that same energy to the dialogues um and to also come with an open mind there are um I presume a lot of different scenarios that that we can look at a lot of different ways that we can move forward together as a community um and and that takes work and it takes open minds um and at in at the center you know doing it all for our students because that at the end of the day that's that's

094why we're here that's why every single one of us are here um and so I just want to share that that's my vision you know president Howell thank you for talking about Vision I've been thinking a lot about that too how important it is to have a vision through something so transformational through such a critical transition so my vision um is that we move forward through this together as a community not pointing fingers at each other trying to take another another school another Community down but rather uplifting one another and all of the strengths that every single one of our sites have um and seeing how we transform our district into something just so much better you know we can always go in one of two directions during a crisis we can kind of fall

095into um like a a a spiral of of chaos or we can choose to see the bright side of things and so I'm I that's my vision is that we all see the brighter side and that we Center that um in this transition so thank you all for being here um and I also wanted to you know quickly share um because I've gotten this feedback from even friends uh you know why isn't the district why aren't the board members talking more about the consolidation and closure uh work that's being done why aren't we you know using our platforms to talk about them um and so I just want everyone to know that we're we're respecting the work of the committee and and there's a lot of work that they've done and that is to come

096um and you know board involvement even one of us board members going to social media and saying this is what I want to do this is what I want to see um you know that could be seen as interfering with the work of the committee and that's not something that would be productive and it's not something that we that we want to do and so we are respecting the work of the committee and when it comes to the board for conversation that is our time to have conversation um some of us will be present at different town halls to listen um and to observe um but it is it is these meetings where the board conducts its business and so I just want to know I just wanted to let everyone know that we are

097listening we are absolutely taking everything into consideration um and we're also following a process thank you thank you trusty M any um we'll go to our student board member okay good evening and happy New Year um welcome back to all the seniors this is your last semester of high school congratulations um congratulations on finishing SL working on your college applications figuring out your career paths um and paths to graduation and after um thank you all to thank you to all the teachers that wrote us recck letters and for taking your personal time um out of your day and break to help us as for the next scsc meeting it will be um Monday the 13th at Piner so students make sure to get your voice um heard and reach out to your represent um to

098get organized and um I you know I love I love seeing all the students here right now thank you for showing up and being present this is this is exactly what we need um and I really appreciate it and I don't think I've seen like this many and in a really long time um and so I totally want to connect and get to hear from you all so just Reach Out um yeah thank you so much just really quickly I wanted to highlight that yes we will have trustees at the various Town Halls just so that everyone knows we can't have more than three trustees and at any one school event um where School business is discussed because it could be potentially a violation of the brown act so know that some of the trustees

099will be there but will never never be more than three at any one town hall and they they've signed up for the days they can go but I just want you to know that I want the public to know that that's why you won't see all of the board trustees at every single one of the Town Halls just wanted everybody to know that thank you superintendent for clarifying that next we have our school consolidation and closure report we have Lisa August here to present thank you president MCN superintendent Dr Morales members of the board and our srcs community excuse me well Dr Morales kind of stole my report here tonight no not just thank you that that is exactly um what I was going to share um I do have a little bit um more

100to add to that so our recent meetings and information events have been uh very well attended and we want to we want to make sure that we're continuing to provide larger spaces for public attendance for those meetings um and just a reminder as I shared last month that just as board meetings the um School consolidation and closure advisory committee meetings are brown act meetings so they are um held in public but they're not with the public it means that the business of the committee is conducted and the public has a right to comment within the prescribed um times and subjects under the purview of the committee it's not a a Q&A back and forth at those um we did add that information item um on the scac agenda um for correspondents we continue to receive

101um a lot of written corresponden um from many members of the public and we are going to be sharing those with the committee as attachments under that item we um as Dr morala shared we've scheduled those Town Hall meetings um over the next two weeks and they'll be specifically focused on that um with the potential to reimagine our schools um we are excited about that this is a painful process but we get to do this we get to look at how we can do things differently and provide more amazing programs for kids in the future by better utilizing the resources that we have excuse me um so the um again that'll be more um of a of a dialogue where we'll have different stations um for people to go through and do Gallery walks and

102probably a a spend a DOT type activity the information um is previewed in the superintendent newsletter which I think came out today via parent square and our next uh committee meeting we do tentatively have an additional meeting scheduled for January 17th we are currently trying to make sure that we have facilities and support staff available um that is a a Friday evening uh so more information will be coming out on that it will be considered a special meeting so it will be posted probably not in that same 72-hour timeline there won't be additional new information aside from the public comment attachments The Correspondents it will be a time for the committee to continue their um analysis and actually maybe have some time um to work in their in their discussion groups that we had um

103scheduled for last time something to be aware of is that we are asking the committee to rank schools for not only the requested recommendation of the 311 with the three Elementary one middle one high but the rankings will also be needed for any other potential scenarios or for any future changes that that may be needed or depending on what the the board ultimately decides to do so that is important that the rankings happen regardless of of the alternative scenarios um the timeline we have again our ongoing internal planning and approximately 90 Elementary scenarios and dozens of middle and high school combinations including now alternative scenarios with you know many that we've heard with the 7 through 12 6 through 8 or TK through 8 or the split primaries and and um things of that nature

104uh the January Town Halls will conclude prior to the um last scheduled scac meeting January 27th for the um School consolidation committee meeting will again be a workshop style meeting to write the recommendations and report and the um there's a potential additional meeting scheduled for February 3rd to finalize that report and recommendations which will all come to the board for that uh special meeting on February 5th for the presentation um of recommendations and public hearing um and then the board meeting for Action is scheduled for February 19th and announcements will go out to the community right after that question from the board trusty Caston and then trusty deori we appreciate the timeline what can parents expect for the timeline after we've made a decision on knowing when they if they're in a school that closed

105or is reconfigured um on when they will be asked to elect to make op to make decisions or have options so we will be getting time there will be information that will come out with that communication about if there are student if there are families who wish to put in a an interdistrict transfer um or intra District transfer moving from one of our from their residential school that they would be assigned to as far as that is in their their area of residence if they wanted to um request a transfer to another there'll be information that will come out with that around that same time so we're hoping to get all of that information out before the end of February so they would receive that information at the same time that we're making the action

106that would be expected yes it'll we'll need the action based on some of the scenarios that we bring forward and then we'll have we'll have some pre um scripted messaging that will be ready that we'll need to update based on actual board action so it'll take us a little bit of time um to get that information out based on and I'm asking specifically because I want to address anxiety and fear that I've heard about we could be making decisions in July about or our kids would be or things like that so no no no no talking February people are going to have certainty based on our action very quickly after yes um our executive director Stacy deser has a plan already laid out in terms of as soon as the board makes a decision to

107notify the parents as to what the next steps will be so they we normally have like a 30-day window when we take to analyze and send out responses we're hoping to shorten that to like three weeks so as soon as the board makes the decision an email will go out to all the parents that have requested it with kind of followup of what's coming next so we'll be parents have requested or parents are impacted both because we already have a list of parents who have requested placement in different schools that we have them on a wait list so it'll be both trusty de Tor thank you very much Lisa for all information um in your opinion have we adequately been able to satisfy the committee requests for current upto-date data and information requested for them

108to make their recommendations so I would say that would depend by a Committee Member we are never able to provide everything that everybody would want we would be constantly updating we would never actually be able to provide information for a decision to be made if we continued to update the information each time that's why we look at certified data so that's why we do have historical information and certified data rather than providing something that changes you know our enrollment changes actually day-to-day there we want to make sure that we are providing concrete information not whenever we can not guesstimates um we do that we provide the best information that we are able to but the information is constantly changing and we could go down a 100 rabbit holes if we if we continue to do

109that the the major we provide as much information as we can so that they can make an informed decision but there will always be additional questions and do we have a date on when that certified data was certified for what the current committee is working with they're working with last year's data so 2324 was the certified data so this year's data gets certified this month so really if we looking at the time for that analysis it really is not again that changes too fast too often for us to be looking at current year data so that's why we do have Trend data in there as well so it's not just looking at one snapshot in time I understand not being able to go down 100 different rabbit holes but I do have concerns of last

110year's data being used by the committee to make recommendations because a lot has changed there's a lot of active data I understand that might not be feasible but we should be able to provide we got a month left of them working and um going through this if there's any information if it's drastic if you can take a look at some data points and there's drastic changes if there at least made aware of those um that could be part of the decision process I also am curious if there's anything we can do differently design wise in the workshop style meeting to ensure the committee has adequate time to actually do a lot of the heavy lifting they're trying to do right now which I know seems near impossible um with time limits and constraints so what

111I can chair is that the next meeting because we aren't we don't have a presentation we're not presenting new information they'll be reviewing the information that they have so we'll be starting out by calling to order you know making sure you know a roll call all of that and then that they will go immediately into their into their working groups and have time to have their discussion and and ask ask questions you know work on work on that discussion piece then we will have public comment because it's a special meeting agenda it will only be on what's on that agenda that evening excuse me and then after that public comment it would just be at that point that they would actually choose their the ranking piece of it which is what the action is for

112for that evening thank you trusty Jenkins and then trusty manary I know this has been mentioned before but just to say it again um the boundary situation that is that will be coming forward with the examples with the proposed ideas correct yes that will come to the board the the propos the proposed boundary changes so that's will be based off of the Geographics depending on what comes out of the committee that's the work that we're doing on the back end that would then come to the board with that recommendation of whatever those changes are so the boundaries aren't the bound boundaries aren't a function of the committee the boundaries are a function of of the board that we prepare and and provide to you and and you can you know choose to accept those or

113change yeah will the information then go out at the same time as the information of the closures and consolidations to the public yes perfect thank you so much jusy manieri thank you um we've gotten some feedback that translation hasn't been available at past meetings can you provide any insight into that I've heard that about a couple of the the last meetings and I'm curious if what plans we have for translation for future meetings including the town halls so we've had translation available at every meeting um we have had that we mentioned that at the beginning and share that who they need to to see for the devices and we do have it available online as well um and at our last scac meeting we also had as translation they let us know ahead of time

114um that that they would be coming and we needed to have that available um I know that there have been difficulties with the online trans with the translators being able to hear appropriately online especially um the last meeting we had um a group of people that were standing close to some of the um to some of the technology and when people are speaking or commenting or or wrestling and and um it can make it very very difficult for the translators to hear or when there are additional side conversations going on we also don't have a way when we're in a workshop we can't project what's happening at each individual small table but again not none of those are a quorum of anyone having that conversation that piece the report out happens into the microphone which

115is then broadcast across zoom and transl ated um so if if somebody's having having a problem they can always reach out to myself or to um yesica I might follow up with you Lisa or Dr Morales um because I have heard some people having issues with that please thank you any other board questions Medina two things no no questions um I think uh just procedurally and request like if we're going to do Q&A it it be put as a discuss not a report that way I could recuse myself appropriately and to um just request the superintendent if we could make sure that we post the information of the Town Hall dates and stuff on our website and on the calendar or even on the scac um page because I just looked through all of our

116website and I don't see it I know it's on social media but it's nowhere on our website um yes I just actually about an hour ago um sent an email to to the team to put a popup on our on our on our website page for the town halls to pop up they'll have to ex out if they want to go to another location but it should be up within the next 24 hours thank you thank you all right then we're going to move to public comment on this item um I have a number of blue cards I'm going to read three names at a time so you know when your turn is coming first we will have Vincent Roman followed by Dalia Castro followed by Betsy J Guan Sanchez and you will have 90

117seconds hello my name is Vincent Roman I'm a freshman at Piner I'm reading a letter from another student who currently can't be here because he's at work so hi I'm Anthony Wilson I'm a junior at Piner and the captain of the boy swim team when I was a freshman I was extremely introverted and somewhat troubled kid I du enrolled at a school called an NOA Center for Education which is a school for people with social and cognitive differences due to the nature of an NOA I've been assigned an individual education plan in which I had multiple accommodations I won't go over all them but I will tell you that I had a flexible schedule and counseling my first look at Piner was a woman named Sydney Miss Miller is a freshman counselor at Piner she

118is energetic funny and such a kind person she was the beginning of a great experience of my freshman year in which I began the process of becoming the student I am today when I transferred to Piner full-time my iepd or my IEP transferred over and I kept the flexibility but more importantly I kept the counseling my new counselor was Rick Durr in the past I had trouble connecting to counselors but Rick and I clicked instantly he helped me through some dark places in my life during sophomore and junior year and another huge part of my success as a student is the Piner Early College magnet program led by Christine urkin with her help students can dual enroll in the JC with all expense from transportation to textbooks paid off in full ECM helps Piner students

119get started with their college career early leaving more time for personal activities later in life we also have amazing sports team and sure we have the big sports like basketball soccer football but it's our smaller teams and where we show our care inclusive or thank you Vincent your time is up thank you next we have Dalia Castro followed by Betsy J Guan Sanchez followed by Dylan lefon Dalia go ahead my name is dollia Castro I am a junior at Piner High School I am proud to say that I am proud student and I am a daughter of to a teacher at Piner my dad has been teaching at Piner for more more than 20 years it has been a home to me longer than I have been a student here this is this school has

120also been considered a home to me and many of my family members including All My Siblings Piner High School helped them to uh shape for Success also help shape them as individuals in in society my dad in all of the years at P working at pioner has never been anything bad to say I have noticed how much Piner has helped him as grow to grow as a person Piner high school has welcome and welcome me and welcome him as individuals as we are I never felt rejected coming into Piner I felt wanted there thank you Dalia next we have Betsy Jan Sanchez followed by Dylan lefon followed by Bianca Valdivia Hernandez go ahead good evening members of the board staff and community members I stand before you all today not just as an advocate for

121Piner high school but to be a voice for the students families and community members who understand piner's value within the Santa Rosa city school district I recognize the financial challenges our district is facing marked by growing debt and difficult decisions are significant but tonight I urge you to consider the greater cost of losing Piner High School the long-term educational social and Community impact to us Piner High School is more than just a campus over decades we have built a reputation for academic accomplishments strong extracurricular activities vicious or Victorious athletic teams prospering communities within clubs and a unique diversity within our students as a whole it is a place where Innovation thrives whether through specialized programs in science technology engineering and Mathematics advanced classes and programs or its Equitable opportunities for many families Pina represents hope

122a place where their children can discover their passions prepare for their Futures and feel as they belong whether it is tempting to look at the financial books and see closure as a solution to the district step we must remember that schools are not businesses they are public goods and serve our students in our community closing Piner would disrupt hundreds of students educational Journeys Force many to travel further for schooling and ruining the sense of companionship that we have worked so hard to build I ask you today to thank you Betsy your time is up thank you next we have Dylan lefon followed by Bianca Valdivia Hernandez followed by yenia Carmona uh hello as you know my name is dy Leon and I would like to first off say thank you for this opportunity of letting

123us speak I'll first like to start off on how this uh school has created a great Community with all the students teachers and faculty alike for me this uh school has a lot of meaning to it seeing how my family has gone to this school and for generations and generations and each family member has has said how this school has created a positive impact on them and helped them throughout their school my dad graduated high school there my uncle gr graduated high school there and it just helped them throughout College speaking of college something that really helps something that's really unique with our school and helps our students go to college is the ECM program ECM is something that only we provide at that school and having us provide that really helps our school and

124our students to like also our community is very joined together we're loving Community alike there's no hate at that school we all love each other we all support each other and we all have each other's back there's always people willing to help each other there and everyone's always have each other's backs there and also for me personally my community is very awesome there and there's no negativity ever we always be there for each other and losing pineer would be a great impact on many people giving the surrounding area area thank you for your time thank you Dylan next we have Bianca Valdivia Hernandez followed by yenia Carmona followed by Jennifer Nora hi my name is Bianca Valia I am a Piner high school student and I'm the student of the year you might recognize me

125from my honoring on November 13th I have came here to show you how pioner has changed my life if you had told me my freshman year I would be standing here today and I would probably have laugh because of it was a very rough transition for me from middle school to high school I didn't know I didn't do very very well in any of my classes but my counselor Miss Miller she didn't even need to ask me for uh if I need help or anything she just went ahead and came and supported me through all along fast forward my junior year where a pioner trans uh transferred me once again I joined a program where an elective Has Changed Me Grace an alternative education program for students who are motivated to graduate to a program

126focuses on community building within our classes complete volunteer work in Santa Rosa motivating one another and making positive changes p is the only school that has this unique program that gives students a chance to graduate and find their way back being part of Grace helped me make up credits and still participate in Piner High School my grace counselor Miss Pomo has been there for me in every single step of the way encouraging me to keep on pushing and keep on going that's what made me student of the year uh also yearbook thanks to yearbook I was a very social person and then thanks to being able to uh join social media I since I run the accounts I was able to put myself more out there also put the school recognizable uh between the supportive

127teachers counselors admin and friends I was able to find access community and space that was my own I am proud to be graduating from Piner Piner high school and know that this school needs to be here for many future students and thank you Bianca your time is up thank you next we have yenia Carmona followed by Jennifer Nora followed by um Lucian we hi my name is and I'm a senior at primary high school when I joined ECM before my freshman year at Piner high school I had no idea what I wanted to do with my future throughout four years in ECM I took the advantage of taking classes at the Santa Rosa Junior College not only did I take classes for my graduation requirements but also for myself to discover what I wanted to

128study for my career I took various classes like psychology Spanish US history art history and different type of science classes after many classes I found my interest in environmental science and I started to look for programs and internships that could help me advance for my future I want my friends and family who are going to pioner to have similar experience as I did with ECM and achieving their goals staff and teachers help their students towards their goals nor M the difficulties this Falls some semester I am going to college as a sophomore student because of ECM please don't close Piner high school thank you thank you next we have Jennifer Nora followed by Lucian Wei followed by lilan bastante Rodriguez hello my name is Jennifer Nora and I will be speaking for Piner high school

129closing Piner High School will impact students in the community the school provides special education to students in need of assistance from their impacted lives no other student has provided the grace program it aids with credit Rec recovery Piner has two wonderful and successful programs that have supported students to achieve above the level I have participated in two of these programs be in the early college program and Spark if the grace program is closed the number of rates of undergraduate students and dropouts will increase making the education system worse than before the closure of Piner will not only affect me but other students as well it will destroy the progress we have the Comfort transportation and more most importantly the offers and opportunities I have been able to access to thank you thank you next we

130have Lucian Wei followed by lilan bastante Rodriguez followed by Sydney Miller hi uh my name is Lucian we I'm a student in a athlete at Pine School I do football and wrestling I just want to say that I love Piner uh it's been a big pillar in my life and kept me from some dark past that I could have gone down uh Sports especially I'm also in the early college magnet program which really helps because without that I wouldn't be able to attend college and that's all thank you Luan next we have lilan basante Rodriguez followed by Sydney Miller followed by Art Herer go ahead are you Lillian yes yes go ahead Lillian um I am a junior at Piner high school and with my three-year experience it's been an amazing years uh with my

131good and uh with my good teachers and my principal the counselors everybody I ever met in my three years has been good to me when I first joined Piner I was I didn't really had my friends with me my childhood friends but I did had two and it made me really happy I made good friends over the years I was in I was a good good students they the teachers um inspire me to get into college to think about JC the university it made me realize that I can do whatever I can do and it can help me get into college our counselors can help me my teachers can inspire me every year has gone by and every day I've been doing myself a challenge I I've been afraid in the beginning of the year

132but last year I I was proud to be who I am I was proud and I wanted to inspire people I danc in the front of the PE other people and I got invited to do leadership with ASB it made me happy it made me whoever I am because I am native we have people thank you time is up thank you next we have Sidney Miller followed by Art Herer followed by um Kim casee good evening my name is Sydney Miller I'm one of the seven counselors at Piner High School my case load consists of the ninth grade students at Piner we are one of we're the only High School in the district with a freshman counselor why is that important we know that when our students start high school the counselor dedicated to supporting

133their individual needs they have a foundation to build on for the next three years and as you hear tonight there are there are students that remember this impact since their freshman year unique to Piner High School is an event called freshman first day this dayong team building event is unparalleled in its goal to connect students from 10 or more feeder schools with this new high school the student shared experience Fosters connection community and awareness of support as well as the expectations at Piner Piner High School is the only school that runs this dayong experiential team building program for incoming nth graders events such as freshman first day ongoing programs designed by our Associated student body are stem certificate programs as well as unique educational Pathways such as the health science and biotechnology space science GIS

134ECM culinary and our countless clubs support student growth and development from n nth grade through their senior year supporting students to develop the mindsets and behaviors to reach success in the post-secondary opportunities is essential for all student graduates our work as a school Community can be seen in the data presented by the Dashboard last year we had the highest student graduation rate in the spring thank you Sydney your time is up thank you next we have art Herer followed by Kim case followed by Christine urkin my name is Art Herer I'm representing 800 alumni of Santa Rosa High School in the foundation um Santa Rosa high school as you all know is the ninth oldest public high school in California currently celebrating its 150th anniversary we'll email you the resolution that we've passed but I

135just want to touch on a couple of highlights from it um throughout those 150 years Santa rosah high is received Awards in academic arts and Career Education we are a flagship School of the district and frequently featured in films and commercial production further enhancing The District's Public profile and resulting in financial gain for the district the sen of high school Foundation since its founding in 1988 has contributed over $4 million in direct support to srhs programs scholarships and student initiatives making it the largest and most significant such contributor to high school education in Sonoma County um the closing of Sosa High School would not only cause loss of the school's historic and educational values but result in the termination of this critical financial and Community Support senos of high school foundation will continue to stand

136in strong opposition to any efforts to close srhs and will pursue all available legal and public Avenues prevent such closure from occurring ensuring that srhs remains a Cornerstone of our community and a beacon of excellence in public education signed by the 19 school board or uh Foundation board members and representing 800 alumni thank you thank you next we have Kim case followed by Christine urin followed by Jose Castro hi my name is Kim case I'm a social science teacher at Piner high school and I also run ASB my request to the board this evening is please don't close a high school high schools are the launching pad for young adults when we remove one of the launching ing pads and move these students around the district we can expect substantial number of students to struggle

137moving forward the focus will be centered around readjusting learning new systems meeting new friends and for some struggling with their mental health in an already transitional time in their lives pioner high school has grown in student population each year every year we have students from all over the county transferring to our campus we have so many reasons for this but one is the spark Center um I worked in the spark Center over the summer because I helped teach in the science camp program for elementary and middle school students The Spark Center is piner's Gateway to a stem focused education with Spitz s Pome XD Touch system planetarium a computer lab that supports piner's geospatial in intelligence systems courses and the grand dam a 22 foot serious Observatory collectively Piner high school has a classroom like

138no other it is uniquely innovative with learning opportunities that are literally out of this world uh Piner High School is the only High School in California and beyond that has an oncampus Planetarium and research grade Observatory did you know that it's a well-kept secret but now you know thank you next we have Christine urkin followed by Jose Castro followed by Angel Ortega good evening uh my name is Christine kkin I graduated from Montgomery High School in 1982 my daughter graduated from Korea I was a school counselor at Santa Rosa high school and I'm currently a foundation member for Santa Rosa High School Foundation I was a counselor at Santa Rosa Charter School for the Arts and I'm currently one of seven counselors at Piner High School our high schools in Santa Rosa are fantastic I

139know this from personal experience please don't close a high school pioner is the best kept secret in Sonoma County it's time for the public to get in on this secret our student population continues to grow why do so many students want to come here it's no secret to us we have an amazing staff administrators parents students facilities and programs as a counselor at Piner I run the Early College magnet program which has been growing for 17 years this year we have 407 students succeeding in ECM that's almost a third of our entire student body taking free college courses with support from srj personnel and a full-time Piner counselor dedicated just for this program our partnership with the junior college allows for Piner students to have free transportation to and from the JC during the school

140day if needed ECM students college textbooks are paid for we have a freshman elective class dedicated to Preparing them for skills they need to be successful in college here are some impressive numbers last year's senior class included three Juniors that graduated early due to earning so many college credits in the ECM program our seniors took a total of 4 classes in their four years in the program your time is up thank you next we have Jose Castro followed by Angel Ortega followed by Joanna Pomo hello and good evening uh my name is Jose Castro and I am here to represent uh my school pioner high school I'm here as a teacher I'm here as a parent Dalia C just spoke a few minutes ago um I'm here also especially as a community community member I

141want to say many things about uh Piner uh that we offer my colleague has mentioned this before um but I want to concentrate on the students as you notice many of them have eloqua the need of for you guys to to advocate for or school not to be closed in that's what we want to have uh I've been in education for 25 years uh two decades with uh pioner High School in every single day I enjoy being in the in in that Community um I'm proud to say that I um I part of the Great Community um I I had so many um hats that I need to that I wear at Piner high school and I'm so proud to do this because I every time that we do something is for our students and

142for our community I know that uh I'm advocating for our Piner but also for our next generation and that's what we want to have thank you thank you next we have Angel Ortega followed by Johanna Pomo followed by shiu Wang hello my name is Angel Ortega and I'm an attendance Tech bil langual interpreter and soft and girls soccer coach at LC Allen LC Allen is the only srcs High School South of Highway 12 we serve the largest community in the city in Southwest Santa Rosa many outside our humble abode enjoy mischaracterizing our identity and who our students are however unlike others I actually work there and I can tell you that my kids are intelligent resilient and hardworking Elsie Allen is in a unique position where the majority of our students are English Learners lowincome

143special education and or first generation 51% our school is not only an educational institution but also a pillar in our community uh Schoolboard we must find Creative Solutions to keep our high schools open as we prepare for a White House Administration that villainized Educators and aims to rid people that look like me now more than ever it it's imperative to maintain our schools as safe havens for our kids so Schoolboard remember that come next month shout out rosand shout out Morland shout out Southwest Santa Rosa thank you thank you next we have Joanna Pomo followed by shiu Wang followed by Cameron Rose good evening my name is Joanna pmo and I am the proud Grace counselor for Piner high school I'm here today to highlight why keeping Piner open is so crucial not only for

144our school but especially for the students who need us the most the grace program is a life line for students who are credit deficient and face significant barriers to accessing their education these students may not fit into the traditional mold but at Grace they find a family we are not just a program we are a support network our students volunteer encourage one another and push each other to meet goals they might otherwise think impossible for many Juniors and seniors in the program Grace has been the reason why they haven't given up on school without it they would likely have walked away from their education entirely at Piner we strive to provide these students with every opportunity for success and we work non-stop to support them before ever considering sending them elsewhere our school is not

145just a place for learning it's a community that understands the challenges our students face and meets them with compassion and commitment keeping Piner open ensures that programs like Grace can continue to make the difference in these students lives let's continue to support our most vulnerable Learners and help them succeed at Piner thank you thank you next we have shiu Wang followed by Cameron Rose followed by Jose Vargas Miranda go ahead dear board dear board my name is shuang I have two children studying in this school district the Elder one in Mario Caro high school and the younger one in elementary school if Mario career high school will be closed we then have to leave this school district district to find another High School somewhere else for my Elder son which means our educational or academic

146requirements my younger child will be leave too as we move together we are not alone I talked to quite some Mario Careo families that I know most of them told me that they will have to leave this SCH District due to the same reason of pursuing academic Excellence these families are my colleagues in kyite or from other high-tech companies in the city doctors and Professionals in Kaiser sat Memorial Hospitals since most of the families I know that I know will do the same thing I would imagine that there will be easily several hundred students including those from marioo high school and their siblings leaving the school district due to the same reason if Mar career is closed that will that will result in several million dollar reduction of Revenue of funding for the school district

147which makes the school closure totally fail its purpose to to close the revenue to budget Gap unfortunately this is not in the current consideration so please consider it seriously and make a decision thank you Mr Wang your time is up thank you thank you next we have Cameron Rose followed by Jose Vargas Miranda followed by Paulina Lopez good evening my name is Cameron Rose and I am a colonary arts teacher at Piner High School uh I'm here today to express my concern from possibly closing Piner High School our school is a very unique and one-of a kind place for our students to learn at one example of this is the Hidden Gem of Piner high school and that is our culinary arts program as most of our students sitting in here tonight can attest our

148program is one of the most sought after class on campus not only because they are able to make food for themselves but also to build on their skills in the kitchen in our program we currently have over 250 students enrolled in culinary arts every year to learn about the hospitality and food service industry this important this is important because it is one of the largest Industries here in the Sonoma County aided by our local tourism industry in our classes our mission is to ready our students for a career in the hospitality and food service industry and we do this with our successful three-year program to allow them to not only learn the basics of baking and pastry and colonary arts but also to become work ready right out of high school the reason I know

149the success of this program is because I was also a student at Piner high school and I was unrolled in the same culinary arts classes back when it was first available in 2005 as a career pathway if it wasn't for the culinary arts program I would not have had the career that I have today what makes our program different from any other culinary program in the district is not just the successes of our current and previous students in the field out in our community where you D today but what also makes us different is our state-of-the-art facilities thank you thank you next we have Jose Vargas Miranda followed by Paulina Lopez followed by David Chen hi um Jose is at a basketball game right now so he asked me to read this for him I'm

150his teacher um my name is Jose Vargas Miranda I'm a junior at LC Allen High School I live on the south side of Santa Rosa and LSC is the closest school to me in my freshman year I started with mostly Straight A's but then in my second semester as well as the start of the sophomore year I got all fs and stopped going to school but then I entered a program at LC Allen called sep counseling and Rich program and the program helped me come to school more often I really like it here now the things I enjoy about this school are the programs and fun activities we have here right now I'm on the basketball team and I enjoy it a lot I think the high schools should not be shut down I also

151think that Elsie should not be shut down because it's the only School in the south of Santa Rosa south of the 101 and if they do that the district will lose a lot of money because the students will go to ronner park schools instead if LC closes there are another no other schools close to me thank you thank you next we have Paulina Lopez followed by David Chen followed by Lisa Jang and I apologize if I mispronounce your name go ahead Paulina good evening bues Morales and board me Members as my student know me I'm Miss Lopez I am a social study teacher at finer high school when I first be my teaching journey I knew that I had to be intentional in the school I would appli to thankfully I found Piner High School

152a couple of summers ago a Hidden Gem Piner High School offered me the opportunity to work for alternative education in the grace program Grace stands for get ready and change your education this program gives uh a second opportunity for students to recover credits in order to graduate from their own high school this is a special program a one of a kind and as it is the only credit recovery program within a high school in the district I have been working with the great students for the past three years it has has been beautiful challenging and a unique experience to be able to serve some of the most marginalized students in our community the great students have taught me that no matter what love life thrs at you there is always a second opportunity and that

153there's hope which they have found within Grace every single student that I have taught in supporting the program has their own unique story as they come from different backgrounds they come from being challenged in plenty of ways every morning I see the great students I think of them as my as lotus flowers to Piner I I have personally delivered the letter so each of you should have a packet please thank you your time is up next we have David Chen followed by Lisa Jen followed by Ashley Avalos go ahead Mr Chen good evening president superintendent Dr Morales trustees and member of the public my name is David Chen I've been living here in s Rosa since two 2000 and raised to adult children who graduated from our schools in 2012 and 2014 as a professional

154licensed real estate professional I work with a lot of Cl client who choose to purchase a home near where I live because of the wonderful schools the high performance schools there are historical data shows that a good per performance School add to 15% of real estate values likewise if such a school is closed we will have a loss of property values likewise so please listen to what we have right now we have over 600 signatures to re reinstate criteria 14 15 and 16 and 420 signatures to keep all high schools open please take public comments into your decision thank you thank you Mr chair next we have Lisa Jen followed by Ashley aalos followed by Olivia Morris hello everyone good evening I'm Lisa I'm a junior at Maria kilo as much as I love math

155and numbers the numbers in these reports don't fully reflect the qualities that truly Define a school community so what are these qualities first of all dedication to teaching my AP Chemistry his teacher for example wakes up at 500 a.m. every year to revise her lectures ensuring that they're aligned with the latest curriculum and are as clear and engaging as possible once she had a medical condition where a vein in her eye burst but even as a pirate she still showed up to class and that level of commitment is extraordinary second caring for students my c teacher not only helps people succeed academically she makes sure to attend every single basketball game dance performance fundraiser to cheer us on and capture each moment in videos and photos she's quite popular on Instagram we have so many

156amazing teachers like them at Careo last but not least peer support and Community engagement we have programs such as the study spot where students can help other students and we career students also run programs like math counts and coding workshops at near by middle schools to give back to their Community these qualities may not show up on these spreadsheets but they're what makes our school Irreplaceable thank you thank you next we have Ashley Avalos followed by Olivia Morris followed by Joe Fang hello my name is Ashley Avalos and I am part of Piner High School's class of 2024 and I would like to start this speech with a quote I strongly believe in and and kindly ask that you keep in mind kids who are loved at home come to school to learn and kids

157who aren't come to school to be loved I'm here to share with you why Piner High School not only means to me but how it has shaped me to become the person I am today my freshman year at Piner was online due to the pandemic and along with everyone else I struggled to stay on track academically I struggled with my mental health but I especially struggled to feel a part of something now I have never felt more a part of something I could gen I could genuinely speak about the grace program for hours if you asked me this program helped me not only to recover academically but it gave me the confidence and motivation to succeed because this program became the because of this program I became the first person in my family to graduate

158from high school I was introduced to a community I had never felt in school before I had incredible teachers and staff surrounding me who personalized who prioritize creating relationships with their students but also who pushed me when I thought I had nothing left to give while doing what dealing with hard times at home the grace office became a home to me the teachers became more than Educators and I never thank you Ashley your time is up thank you for sharing next we have Olivia Morris followed by Joe Fang followed by Jenna Jewel hello my name is Olivia Morris I'm a senior at Piner High School even though I live in Santa Rosa High District I chose Piner as well as many of my friends who don't live in piner's attendance area what mostly convinced me

159outside of my friends here was the environment and the community the first thing I noticed was how nice and involved The Faculty are in students lives no matter how big or small some of the office um Staff feel like close family friends which is super important in enriching and in a safe environment for all involved and I want to look back at my senior year and be like that was my high school some important mentions our incredible stem program provides different levels from stem level one to three above helping many aspects of those technical careers I took part in um Sam's rocketry Club a great opportunity for students from any grade level to learn and participate in engineering of a rocket and then go off to competition and see colleges do all that um sort

160of thing and being a member of ASB I want to mention our Monroe Elementary School Drive and we give them Christmas toys and invite them to our winter rally which is a great event for all our College and Career program which has been mentioned many times has helped so many student students graduate early and um there are many different club sports and other programs that I've been a part of that I couldn't mention and please consider this one closing schools thank you for listening board meeting members thank you next we have Joe Fang followed by Jenna juel followed by Jessica Len hi I'm I'm Joe Fang I'm one of the local physician here uh in Santa Rosa I have three kids two of them are at Mar Creo I'm here in s Rose for for

161the last 16 years I'm here to support keeping high schools all the high school open including Maria Creo over the last seven years s Rosa has experienced some severe strug severe shortage of healthc Care Professionals largely due to multiple challenges including fires and pandemic most care most of the healthcare professional are not from santaa or Sonoma County to attract them and stay here they are looking for safe neighborhood and quality Schools public schools Maria Creo is definitely one of those schools that has the highest academic achievement and attendance and I strongly encourage you to make the best decision to ensure that we all can attract and retain Health Care Professionals for our future and for the this is critical for the long-term health of Santa Rosa thank you thank you next we have Jenna juel

162followed by Jessica Len followed by by Angela giglia Jenna go ahead hi my name is jenet juel and I'm here with my son Benjamin an incoming Piner student um and I'm a proud Piner teacher I'm here today um as a 14-year veteran in San Rosa city schools 13 of which have been proudly served at Piner High um I am a San Rosa native so I went to Helen Layman Montgomery High School Slater Middle School the JC and Sonoma State I am truly embedded in this community um and I think what's special here is that we have five amazing high schools that all have such wonderful attributes the reality is that each of these schools are filled with Dynamic students driven Educators support staff and administrators all of these traits are shared and so it almost

163seems moood to point them out though I need to so after acknowledging that it will be devastating for the communities to close any of these excellent sites I have to and must say the reasons some of which I can't even get into but why Piner is so special it really is the best kept secret in somoma County um and I think it's an impact for the community at large to keep this school where it is our ECM program which has been mentioned keeps us connected to the JC we also have a stem certificate program which keeps us connected to Sonoma State as long as our Upward Bound Pioneer program we get opportunities for students to go to college to start a career and to create Community also geographically speaking we're in a location that is

164dependent on this site for so many students who need it thank you thank you next we have Jessica Lin followed by Angela g gataa hi there my name is Jessica lehow I'm a president of the PTO at Santa Rosa Charter School for the Arts I'm treasur of art Quest at Santa Rosa High I'm also so um on site Council for Santa Rosa High I've put two students through Montgomery High School including a foreign exchange student um and I'm here just to Advocate that uh in your report you reported to the board that all necessary data was provided to the committee and that's just flat out not correct um as an example the Santa Rosa Charter School for the Arts has a wait list in six of the eighth grades of which the board here or

165the district blocked us from accepting those students into our school and I think that's important data that you should be presenting to your committee that just because enrollment is at a certain number doesn't mean there's more interest in those schools and it's not just about Santa Rosa Charter it could be every school every school has a wait list and um that's important data when you're considering shutting a school down if you provide the committee with a a certain number but there's actually this whole Blacklist of families waiting to get in um the interest is higher um I would also say that your idea of a school bus needs to be readdressed my daughter was h a victim of a registered sex offender at a public bus stop and she's getting ready to testify against him

166you need to come up with better plans thank you Miss lehow and last I have Angela you can tell me how to say your last name gilea um my name is Angela gilat I have a very quick kind of announcement hope um you know that this the next few meetings are going to be packed with parents and students and teachers and counselors and board and just Community please think about having it at a different venue so that people that come here are not standing outside and listening and are able to come in and and listen for the rest of my one minute I'd like to finish what Ashley Ashley Avalos had to say because she had to compose herself she was not allowed to have her whole time most importantly I had an amazing counselor

167who is the soul of the Grace's program and truthfully changes the lives of every student she meets I am now a classroom leader at kowana Springs Elementary and Implement everything Piner has taught me in my own classroom hoping to be even an ounce of what pioner and Grace program have been to me for the younger generation Piner not only academically has prepared me for life but it shapes me into a better person the sense of community in Piner is unlike anything else I've experienced and if given the opportunity it will continue to do the same for others thank you thank you are there any other blue cards all right thank you all for being here and for sharing your voices we are going to move on now to the next part of our agenda our

168discussion and action items I'm going to take a few deep breaths before we move on all right our first action item F1 this is an item that I requested approval of resolution recognizing January 27th 2025 as International Holocaust Remembrance Day um this is something that I requested this year is going to Mark the 80-year anniversary of the liberation of awit um and I firmly believe that it that Holocaust Education remains a key part of interrupting hatred and discri discrimination in our community and our society at large um so I ask that this be brought forward should I read the resolution all right I will read the resolution for us okay recognizing January 27th 2025 as International Holocaust Remembrance Day whereas on November 1st 205 the United Nations designated January 27th the anniversary of the liberation

169of Switz binau International Holocaust Remembrance in honor of the 6 million Jewish victims and millions of other victims of the Holocaust and to help prevent future genocides and whereas the purpose of international Holocaust Remembrance Day is to serve as a date for official commemoration of the victims of the Nazi regime to promote Holocaust Education throughout the world and to reject any form of Holocaust denial and anti-Semitism as well as threats of genocide in other parts of the world and whereas this year marks both 80 years since the liberation of the largest Nazi concentration and death camp and the 30th anniversary of the genocide in Bosnia and whereas genocidal regimes throughout history including those in Cambodia Rwanda and darur have deliberately fractured Society ities by marginalizing specific groups and in our commitment to disrupt hate and

170violence from tearing the fabric of our society we urge our local National and international communities to stand together in order to end racism the spread of anti-Semitism and xenophobia and prevent ethnic cleans cleansing and whereas member states of the United Nations are encouraged to actively preserve sites used by the Nazis during the final solution such as killing centers concentration camps and prisons so that they may Inspire leaders and citizens of the world to confront hatred prevent genocide and promote human dignity and whereas we must be vigilant about the Discrimination racism and hatred that continues to plague society and be cognizant of the fact that if left unchecked they give rise to the mass killing events that continue to occur in the 21st century and now uh therefore be it resolved that the Santa Rosa City

171Schools Board of Education recognize and promote International Holocaust Remembrance Day activities that help us learn about the past bear witness for those who have endured genocide empathize with their suffering draw inspiration from their struggle and reaffirm Humanity's common aspiration for Mutual understand and Justice are there any board member questions trusty delator so I'm curious do we have any activities or any meat and potatoes to go with this resolution to provide this education and be sympathetic of those um that this has affected generationally and still affects that is an excellent question um I brought this up sort of last minute so I don't want to blame staff for not being able to attach anything superintendent Morales do you know of anything going on in the district I know the team has been talking about it but

172because we got it during break we haven't actually have been able to flush out what that could look like but we can bring that back to the board um as we were able to create it before then um I appreciate our opportunity bring resolutions forward and use our voices and opportunities to continue to educate um I just want to continue to remind this board um as we do these it's really important to tie them to something tangible um so that our students are actually getting the education that we support and lift up absolutely thank you trusty dilator any other board member questions do we have any public comment any blue cards on this item there are no blue cards any further disc discussion by the board trusty Caston I just want to briefly state that

173at this time and in this tenor in this nation this resolution is really timely and the fact that we just have to say that the holocost happen is a very unfortunate statement of current affairs uh my grandfather got a Purple Heart in World War II in reference to some of the things that are in this resolution and so I appreciate you bringing this forward um I just wish that it was truly talking about something that was 80 years ago any other discussion trusty Medina yeah I think um well first off um very supportive of the resolution I think it's important um to recognize um and you know I'd encourage using this is an educational to to have discussions um I'd also you know like to highlight not only history but existing issues of what can

174be um I looked at was genocide you know darur currently D in Ethiopia and also the Gaza Strip I think it's important to have those those uh items included in the discussion as as we move forward but I think recognizing the Holocaust at the very least is something that we have to do and I'm and supportive any other discussion trusty manieri I think I just want to Echo what um director delator said about you know making sure that our our resolutions have substance um attached to them and so um I think it's it's kind of also an invitation if there are any Educators who are listening or students who are participating in actions on their campuses please let us know um often we we want to know about these things we want to support if

175we can so um not leaving it up to the the district admin to give us this information um we'd love to hear from anyone else who might be participating trusty Jenkins actually wasn't going to talk at all but from that I wanted to just throw in um and I am in full support of this thank you for bringing it up um I attended the well not with the school but the eighth graders at a lot of the schools go to DC and part of that trip um is often to go to the Holocaust Museum and I had the experience of going to that a few years back and I would um I would assume that some of those teachers may be wonderful people to kind of pull in their thoughts on how to how to

176really bring this up in um in the educational process especially with those those middle school kids and teachers who are are really experiencing the depth of of that thank you any other discussion I can say that in my day job I'm an English teacher and I do teach a unit on the Holocaust so if there are any teachers in the district that want to connect about resources and and pedagogy I'd be happy to talk about that just in my capacity as a teacher not as your board president um so if there's no further discussion we are seeking a motion I move to approve resolution recognizing January 27th 2025 as International Holocaust Remembrance Day second okay that was moved by vice president manieri and seconded by trustee Medina roll call vote student board member Zinga hi

177trusty manieri hi trusty Medina hi trusty Casten hi trusty Kirby hi trusty Jenkins hi trusty de laori hi president mcnali Hi motion passes unanimously all right then we will move on to our next item which is a discussion item special education review and here we have Dr William glesby and John fiser we have a power point and I'm just queuing it up right now with me for one second thank you well they do that President MCN I'd like to make a motion that we extend the meeting to 11 now instead of doing it in the middle of their presentation all right we have a motion to extend till 11: p.m is there a second a second that all right so motion by trusty Casten seconded by truste Medina roll call vote board members in Ina

178hi trusty Casten hi trusty Medina hi trusty Kirby hi trusty Jenkins hi trusty de laor hi trusty manary I president mcnell I motion passes unanimously we ready yep go ahead we're ready to go uh trustees I want to welcome Dr William gaspi with whom the uh District contracted to do a special education study over uh the course of about a week's visit I believe with interviews with number of folks in the district uh and information provided from specialed education uh business services and uh Educational Services and it's a very important time uh when we want to there was talk about Vision earlier and reimagine a vision for special education as part of the vision of the district going forward so without further Ado Dr gaspie thank you uh good evening Madame President board superintendent staff

179and Community uh you've had your hands full tonight um it's uh I've been on the other side of this I was a superintendent for 12 years and of course when you look at my background I was a deputy uh administrative officer for the fiscal crisis management team and uh that was a very challenging U job that still is throughout California but uh I'm going to go through a little overview it's a very extensive report it had over nearly 150 recommendations maybe 80 pages so we're not going to get through it all tonight in a very detailed basis I won't bore with all the details the superintendent does have that um but I'd like to just mention accom accommodations that are listed throughout the report that the district is recognized for having and employing outstanding professional

180staff there are many positive Services being provided for students throughout the district to hardworking teachers and classified staff staff are commended for providing the best education to students that are available to them in the board you're commended for hiring a new superintendent has the capability to move your District forward you've got an executive staff I've worked with hundreds of them throughout California I'm pretty experienced in analyzing uh School Board superintendent relationships that's one of the things we did with fcmat the fiscal crisis management team and you have an excellent um d Direction uh the new board new Administration uh it's very positive as many as as much challenges you have before you there's an air of optimism of of a new era of doing things differently more effectively for kids the report does have over

181a 100 recommendations uh providing the district with those recommendations a comprehensive road map to develop systems and procedures and policies that ensure a coherent and comp cohesive special education delivery system through the interviews and I had many from classified certificated uh related services staff Administration it was evident that sta seek clear guidance from Administration creating a unified system and procedures dist districtwide by fostering collaboration Mutual trust respect between the board the administration and on-site staff the district has an opportunity to develop a model educational delivery system students are considered general education students first not special education but General Ed special education is not a place it's a service and through those lens you'll see this report throughout the study based on my experience one of the things that's key to change in a school district

182is a key indicator of fiscal distress in a school district is a lack of alignment and support between the board and a superintendent while the public is important and it's essential the board's responsibility extends Way Beyond popularity it involves making informed decisions to ensure the district's long-term fiscal stability and success it's apparent from just watching being in the district this week and and watching the board operate uh you are in a very good situation to move forward with your new Administration and the and the new seated board in this study there was 14 study objectives it's a very comprehensive challenging study uh and I'm not going to go all through those you've seen those but there's 14 different study objectives that we went through there's a little bit about myself you can see I hard

183to keep a job throughout my 35 year career I went from teacher to to all through the ranks of everything um and with that you have some challenges of course and this is a perfect starting point for a study like this uh for the the newly hired district superintendent who's very qualified and capable of moving the district forward you have a new executive director that's very experienced you have a coordinator of special education that who is knowledgeable and and she's an experienced administrator they will be able to develop an administrative organizational plan ensure fiscal accountability and strengthen the special ed delivery system there's a lot of good people in the district but there's a lack of direction that has left the department without syst systems or a cohesive special ed delivery system the absence of

184such structure is set forth in a in the 2015 one system report that I think you got a copy of to the interview process the staff were passionate and hardworking and professional is imperative that all stakeholders understand the status of the special education delivery system and make certain that policies procedures and systems ensure legal compliance meaningful education for all students in addition this District should continue reviewing budget development monitoring and development appropriate educational op options for students who are below grade level before placement in special education the district does not have a coherent system for education for all children within a coherent system students who struggle to compute or read with specialized help as soon as they need in general education these children are difficulties are identified in preschool or earlier and research shows that

185the earlier the ID identification the better the results cenal to a coherent system in the development of culture of collaboration and coordination between the district and numerous educational Family Services there's influences the child's education inclusive practices a strategic plan updated you have a board policy and and goals they are are outdated uh they're 19 uh 2 2019 to 24 24 this should be reviewed and the board should take on re review doing a new vision a new goals and with that uh we'll talk about where special Edge comes in because special education on the website should have a set of goals and objectives as well through this uh lens that we look at is the one system reforming education to serve all students students report the California's Statewide task force for special education and the

186summary of that is California's current policies including funding credentialing and range of service to deliver options is a bolt-on special education to general education while certain examples exist in California the prevailing model has made it acceptable in some cases is desirable to isolate special education as unique and separate system the project summary is inclusive practices Integrated Systems and coherency are essential to providing high quality costeffective special education programs that's kind of the the summary of the background of using the State Department of Education the state legislator's report that was here I'm going to flip through this uh pretty quickly and at the end you can ask ask any the questions that you have some of the challenges you know when we look at a Statewide average we look at identification rates of students in special

187education your identification rate is way over the Statewide average um and then I I was looking at a figure around 19% based on this District information and looking at the State uh dashboards and the Cal facts ads um documents but why do we have over identification why do we place more kids in special education than keeping them in um on a on a Statewide average or even a Sonoma County average well one of the reasons is that classroom teachers and I talked to lots of them and I was one myself is that they find and I go through the report several reasons why this happens but one of them is that there's not a a strong Intervention Program available for the teachers so when they're having these students are struggling in your classrooms they go

188to well let's get the child tested let's get them services in special education and really the the really Mark of a strong general education program is keeping those these kids these marginal kids these kids that are a couple years below grade level in the general education classroom uh and the report if you take some highlights through the through this report that I gave you and to the superintendent it really speaks to some of the disadvantages of when we over qualify kids that don't really need it they get a stigma they're in special education maybe for their whole career there's very little exiting of kids out of special education um so there's and not only that you know you've got the end result of course it's twice as much cost to put a child in specialized

189programs than in the general education programs that's the least of your concerns the real concern is the education of the child and your superintendent has been very strong about how that's the important driving force and how do we serve our kids here in Santa Rosa city schools but a lack of interventions is a reason um the strategic planning um we need to we recommend uh creating a district special ed strategic plan I've written the all the objectives and the goals for that it's a matter of John and his staff putting together uh a St plan developing um clear systems policies and procedures uh this is really initiated um by the superintendent comes to the board the board says an action item that we're going to have us goals and objectives and and a three to

190fiveyear plan for special education um how we're going to reduce over qual over over identification how we're going to put more kids in the general education classroom how we're going to reduce Transportation how we're going to reduce uh kids getting extended school year all those areas that I put in there the board sets a policy superintendent carries it out professional development is is critical providing a comprehensive trading for the mtss your multi-tier systems student study teams we we' probably I I probably done hundreds of special education studies in California hundreds and it's the first district that I've come to that did not have a board adopted policy or administrative regulations for student study teams now what a student study team is and I outlined what the student student study team is in the report but

191basically it's what it what it calls for It's A multidisiplinary Team at the school site classroom teacher has concerns about the learning or the behavior of the child they bring this child to this team and they make recommendations of intervention to go back in the classroom that's modify what you're doing so the child can be successful you do have student study teams but you have no comprehensive cohesive system throughout the district that this is how we do student study teams they kind of Hit and Miss throughout it and and in some places we find where there is a a parent uh demanding testing for their child a classroom teacher a principal a vice principal whatever may say we will not even go through the student study team let's just go get the child tested another

192reason why over testing takes place the student study team is a Jed Ed process it's a general educa it's not a special ed process here in Santa Rosa when you do use it it is a special ed process it's the Gateway not always but in many cases into special education Educational Services you have a fantastic assistant superintendent of ed services once the superintendent gives this to him and says we're reworking this we're taking a policy to the board we're writing administrative regulations we're developing a manual we're going to have a consistent coherent delivery system of student study teams throughout the district we're going to stop this de this increase of kidss being referred into special education and like I said once they get in many times they're they don't they're not act um exited so

193the special ed Department lack submission and envision statements in alignment with the district goals we recommend that uh the board updates your goals and they have a whole section for special education which includes inclusion um there's no inclusion initiative to reduce special ed numbers meaning keeping kids in the general education classroom and when we do have kids in special education what are we doing from a board goal setting that we're going to include more kids that are in special education in the least rest restrictive environment placing them back in the regular classroom with support and that comes from the board saying we're going to include more kids in general education we are too restricted we're too isolated with these kids in our present program s establish this K12 Continuum of special ed services breaking down

194Elementary and high school there's a real alignment here we have high school and Elementary we need to have the discussion that it's a K12 District I know it's separated I know it's you got a high school elementary but there is a somewhat of a an H separation there the uh the special ed Department um adopting a policy a vision statement a mission statement just like the board is that their statement relates to the the Board of Trustees I've talked a little bit about this strategic plan it's all written into this uh report the goals and objectives uh three to five years this is not easy work this is work that as you know newly elected board members find out it is one of the most difficult demanding jobs in educ ation is being a school

195board member it is uh what goes on behind the scenes is so demanding that people don't know they that will not know but your responsibilities are so important and you have information that sometimes others don't have but you have to make the right decisions for kids this is that identification rate um this is kind of what we use not a standard throughout um California um there's some discussion here among this identification rate but the most important thing about it is that yes you're I overidentifying um kids compared to a Statewide or a countywide level and there's approximate cost to the district of 26 million that's a lot of money that money could be used to help kids that are struggling stay in the regular classroom um with interventions and I write some of the factors

196of why in the report why that's happening and then you do have your uh educational services department has an excellent document on overidentification of English Learners and he certainly can talk about that at some point to the board they're doing some great things to to deal with this problem with overidentifying Hispanic kids into special education um and a lot of these bullets I took right out of the document that your assistant superintendent of V Serv Services has so he's an excellent resource to really talk about what are we doing to reduce this number and how do we deal with it more effectively uh so I really hit the student study team process U I make a lot of recommendations on what to do strategically about that there's some really good information in the report on

197how to go about doing it the teacher staff and in ratios there's the document there um you do contract with some County program s it costs about $104 per 104,000 per student annually it's a lot of money um once uh your department of special educations in conjunction with general education it they're bolted together special education is a res is a result of what's not happening in general education it's it's not special education it's general education saying we need to have these kids over here in this restrictive environment so so we really got to deal with general education and and and build up the interventions and the support and the professional development to keep kids in the least restrictive environment to the Poss and once you start doing that you can start bringing some of these

198kids back from the county it's a lot cheaper it's they're not County kids they District kids it's a benefit for parents it's a benefit for this the the community to bring bring these kids back because once they go to County programs they're County kids they're District kids and eventually in a three to four to fiveyear plan U how do we bring a number of these kids start coming back and having the facilities and the um there's a a an issue of uh on instructional assistance you have a lot of really good ones but you um and again uh you have a fantastic Business Services and HR department um with some collective bargaining and negotiating in good faith and a common ground and collaboration we have a lot of contracted special ed assistants out there I

199mean I think there's like 190 now those are really good people but what happens is they're not really they're not wearing the the the elementary or the high school t-shirt they're not part of the dist they're contracted your employ your District employees they're part of the district they wear the T-shirt they wear you know the colors so what I recommended through uh collective bargaining and good faith uh discussions um and you have the team to do it you really have a terrific administrative team that can sit down with the unions I interviewed both the classified and certificated Union they were fantastic to work with they want more structure they want guidance they want procedures they want policies they want a coherent delivery system they want to be held accountable there's been a lack of that

200in the district they're calling for leadership to do the job for instance when we get to the school psychologist and the slps in the you know the speech and language the school psychologists I think I recommended a not only a district-wide procedural manual but a policy procedure manual for every one of the related Services OT PT SLP school psychologist outlines their roles the responsibilities the eligibility the school psychologists fantastic group they have a school psychologist procedural manual never been used legal councils reviewed it it's there been no leadership to say we spent all this time in developing this manual we've had legal opinions on it we've spent all this money and there's been no mandate by Administration this is what we do and we'll ins service every School site on how we what our role

201is they want that they want that direction they're calling for some accountability and and it's really exciting to see a district that's that's saying that from the union the classified and the the the bargaining group staff so with this idea here going to the table and talking how do we restructure this salary schedule so we can take contracted assistants who are ke key people or important people back into the district um so that's going to be a real uh suggested compensation and I did negotiate compet uh competitive salaries and classified um general fund contribution the say white average is about 60 65% of the general fund supports special education you're at 56% your associate superintendent and your business office doing a fantastic job you have um one of my jobs when I was working for

202the State uh legislature through the fiscal crisis management team we trained over 350 cbos in California they're still training them that was one of my jobs when we started uh the calling was how do we change the landscape for training Chief business officials in California I was given that responsibility we've traded over 300 through C California uh school boards Association and casbo um you have one of the top candidates that went through the program I mean she is really that good she is one of the top ones that we went through our program so you they're budgeting very well but also we recommend more monitoring of the of of the budget hold um at least monthly meetings with HR the director of special ed um the business service to really monitor transportation cost and this

203and that one of the things I kind of threw in with the approval of your superintendent is the Ada if it's very complicated and Lisa could tell you how complicated School Finance is but also it's not complicated in this sense it's based on enrollment and attendance when your enrollments going down you've got some deficit problems when when attendance School attendance is down you're losing money so your attendance rates aren't all that great and you do have a department that's a pretty Dynamic department so I did put this in there that um just by 1% if they increase your attendance by 1% over the next five years you're going to generate nearly $6 million just by getting kids to school and first of all if kids aren't at school they're not learning they're not socially engaged

204um and who knows what's what's happening to them when they're not in school so we want them in school for all the educational benefit but also it has a financial benefit and that is a real deficit to the business um Department specialized Transportation it's pretty expensive some of the um I think you have some great services with it but I outlined it there you know nearly $10 million for the number of kids you're serving uh I think negotiation continues to um to be discussed and uh determin what kids really need to be transported I really wrote a uh in the report is a decision tree process every kid that gets transported needs to go through that process it's about a five or six page document and the I AP do you meet this criteria and

205what other options can we get the kid to school if we don't need specializ Transportation now if we need it we need it we provide it and we do it in the safe manner I'm not saying change it up with uh wcta but also be just the board being aware this is what it's costing with a number of kids and it's got To Be A Conversation Piece the extended school year we don't call it summer school we call it extended school year because it's part of the IEP extended um you do have some forms again you do not have a uniform system of a eligibility determination what we call Ard uh uh Admissions and um discharge committee uh Review Committee so I recommend that I've got that system that can recommend to the board to

206use uh to the administration but um and then we get into the related Services the school psychologists the speech services there's a lot of information under the slps and you're kind of aware of that what a speech language therapist they have a case load 1 to 55 if you're not aware of this it's in the report it's public information you've got very professional very hardworking speech language pathologist how however you have in their contract language that they get a stipan of $15 per day per kid over their case load now in in our world as we look at that sometimes you could perceive that as as an incentive not to exit kids I recommend and I have the manuals to give to the superintendent and to special ed if they want is a speech and

207language pathologist handbook and it's eligibility criter area exit what's the role of a speech and language pathologist um what's the referral bases you have to start exiting kids off of those speech roles because you have some slps that are working hard and they're way over the 155 so they get a sipon they may be up to 70 80 kids you have some that may be at the end and it could be verified verified by the business office or HR maybe $50,000 at the of the Year 50,000 for having more kids on their case load um that's a high number but they would justify it by well we don't have enough slps we got to take the work this and that so I think with leadership from your Administration this this report it sets it blows

208down blows out the windows and knocks down the doors you've it's a road map of change and with the leadership and the strength of your superintendent and the backing of the board you can really do a lot of things and speech pathologists uh I know lots of them lots of them are my good friends throughout the state they're working hard they don't want to have a case load of 90 but for some reason they're not being monitored and evaluated enough to control that you've had so many loose ends here that everybody just does their own thing it's time to to bring in the wagons circle the wagons and say we've got one system it's throughout the throughout the district it's a procedure and everybody's on the same page doing the same work um and to

209do that I'm a we've got to be transparent I believe that the superintendent brings to the board a task force a special ed task force of stakeholders you've got community Le I interviewed Community leaders Advocate groups parents people people want to get involved and make change we don't do it from the top down we do it from the bottom up we get the stakeholders in you have a committee and this is a big one maybe 20 25 people you have a agenda this is what we're doing you take this report you break it down you have an action plan a strategic plan who's doing what when what's the outcome and as a diverse stakeholders that with and that's how you start to build that with the people who are doing the job ask them how

210they're doing the job how we can improve the job that you're doing they know how to do it they need support from the administration and the board to go get it done the SAT take Plan that's just the action plan I was mentioned you take um any one of these um head identification rate extended school year Transportation what's the goal who's going to do what what we're going to reduce and um you build a cohesive um um system throughout the district through this action plan and it comes back to the board every six months and you can look at it what's happening who's done what how are we doing it's a measurable Matrix goals objectives who's doing what when it's a really and we've done it throughout California and schools it's been very very exensive

211but it's not done overnight it's two to five year plan and and it's based on collabor collaboration and and transparency the procedural manual talked to John about that if when we don't have a procedural manual that that manual is basically how do we do special education business you know what's the timeline when we get a referral for special education who sets in on an IEP meeting um how do we determine eligibility you know what's the exit price all that's outlined so once you get this proced and they're they're all over California and and John's working on one right now but it comes comes to the superintendent the task force develops it you just take it from other districts and modify it and go go from there comes to the board the board adopts it I

212keep talking about the board role on this because once you adopt policies for student study team procedural manuals here's this the the the task force the superintendent has brought to you it changes everything when the board's involved because now the board's involved the board's expecting something out of this and staff they follow that and without that and what is lacked in Santa Rosa city schools is that connection between superintendent and board and staff on implementation of systemwide policies and procedures so there's a lot to that but then every School site does it every principal has it every psychologist has it every special ed teacher has it and so this is how we do business in Santa Rosa consistently throughout the board through this manual and it's it's a it's the way to have the cohesive

213uh delivery system put together and the last one that came up was your non-public schools and nonpublic agencies there's some costs there again um you know you're talking of $10 million of kiding kids in nonpublic schools I outl in the report what is a non-public school what is a non-public agency how do you deal with that $9 million um those those kids have been been placed in non-public schools you can't bring them all back but what kids can you bring back and how do you develop a plan for them and again we don't want we want these kids they're Santa Rosa kids they're not a non-public school kid now I understand obviously some kids are going to go there but you have a a great number of kids that maybe in an analysis of what

214can what kids can we start bringing back what parents can be engaged bringing their kids back to their local schools so that's kind of I kind of um I know we don't have a lot of time with this it's not a board workshop on special ed and you've had a long night um and I appreciate your patience and and going through it um but you have the right team uh I feel great about this board that I've seen in action tonight the the respect um of with the community and the appreciation of people coming forth and voice and voicing their opinions and being open about it I think that's wonderful um you've got a great team a team that can get this work done a lot of hard work a lot of negotiations but it's

215it's all M every one of them of the 150 recommendations are fixable it's about what do we prioritize how do we go about doing it and who's involved in doing it and I just like to thank the staff the staff was great to work with they were professional uh you've got a great executive director that is really well qualified that will lead this charge uh the coordinator his right hand um she's knows the district she knows how to get things done you've got the right team and you've got a superintendent that knows about systems and then and what happens to a school district with lack of systems in place um so you've got the right makings and I know you have some questions so I'll answer them the best I can thank you for your

216patience thank you Dr Gillespie and board members I want to ask that we really stick to questions first and save any comments and discussion until after public comment we do have several public comments on this so questions first um I saw trusty Medina trusty manieri then I'll get to that side thank you uh first off uh thank you Dr delesie um this was very insightful um and I agree with you um I think we have a great team I think uh director Fischer and superintendent Morales are you know have come in and the fact that you're here right now um I think is a sign of the fact that we're really working to try to solve this problem one of the questions that I have is um maybe costs um associated with um litigation that

217we're facing I think that's one of the biggest frustrations that I've seen having been on the board that's not usually out on this end but ineffectiveness in our systems like how how big has that impact been you know collectively and and as we work towards um goals how can we reduce situations that get us in in in those places where we're facing um you know legal issues that's costing the district money as well you want to take a shot at that sure with respect to to litigation um I can speak to this year for sure um we've had five depress filings um coming out of special education um there is also a I'll say special education related tort claim um uh that has been filed uh We've settled um three of our due process claims

218and we have uh two two pending right now we have haven't had uh any at this point that have gone to um Fair hearing um in terms of dollar figures uh first there's certainly there's lawyer fees there's my time involved etc etc etc which is um which is significant and um if I had to Ballpark the uh aggregate in terms of settlements in in the neighborhood of $758,000 for the for the three um which in special ed world I un fortunately that's that's not that high but um it my expectation is based on the number we've had this year we'll have uh a few more during the year and so we're talking at the at the low end um in terms of settlement costs uh low six figures um and that again that's not including

219uh fees from our lawyers and again the time cost uh in involved in that um in some cases those are the results of procedural errors on our end in some cases I would say not um but uh what we try and do when we have litigation is I try and identify why it happened or why it got to litigation because certainly we want to prevent that in the future and it's it is super frustrating either when we drop the ball in some way through a missed assessment or something of that sort um to um spend a significant am amount of time and I do spend a significant amount of time on litigation um so it's it's a significant cost to our our district and I would say so far in terms of payouts we've been

220it's been relatively good I mean I hate to say that but it's been relatively good this year it's it's an unfortunate pretty good pretty good on a Statewide basis for district this size that's not a lot of um litigation that's that's um that's pretty good yeah the other thing I'll say is there's um and this is also I'm going to segue a little bit because there was the the talk about non-public school placements and there's an issue we've been looking at with with respect to the state which is disproportionality and that is disproportionality it can be um uh by race it can be by ethnicity socioeconomic status Etc and having we're we've been involved in a process through the California Department of um education called compliance Improvement modering monitoring when we don't meet certain targets

221so first off I want to say our um placement rate in non-public schools is 8% which is almost triple the county average um and is more than triple the state average in a district that is in essence a unified school district that's the largest school district in Soma County those are extremely high numbers because with the the wide range of programs that we can offer we would expect that we could serve those students and we do have the widest range of special education programs in Sonoma County um and then digging into those numbers a little deeper um our non-public school placements are approximately 15% of higher socioeconomic status students with IEPs in the secondary District are in non-public schools that's a mind-bogglingly high number almost one out of six higher socioeconomic status uh students in

222the secondary District this gets back to the I think one of the points that um we're getting at sometimes litigation comes from um higher socioeconomic status parents that that's that's what I'm going to going to say about it we have one non-public school um at which we have 42 or 43 placements and again about 41 out of the 42 fit that demographic um and whereas with respect to our other socioeconomic populations and our other race ethnicities relatively close to the state average so there's a signif when when bill has talked about being able to bring those students back I think um that is one significant one significant thing we can focus on that requires building programs ourselves which we have built significant programs and there is cost associated with that but in the long run

223um that is a better environment for the students they will actually have opportunities to um participate in in general education and they will be served in their home District my second and final question is um you know some of this data on English Learners um like really popped out at me um I think well first off the the issue of procedural manuals and all that I think that's I've seen it as a chronic issue throughout my time and I I really like the fact that that's being addressed but I think as it relates to English language Learners as this work is done I think um will the English learner master plan kind of be reviewed to see how those the cross-section of those two items potentially interact absolutely and there's currently work being done with

224special services and Ed Services I was talking about compliance Improvement monitoring and one of our focuses in that area is to look at the identification rate of English language Learners and ideally bring that down because of over identification secondly English language Learners um who are duly identified as special students uh with disabilities and English language learners tend not to participate in General Ed very much and so our second focus of that is to um improve the general education participation I'm going to mention one initiative and this came through multilingual Services who um and that is developing a an ELD or Al is the the term in our district um curriculum that's aligned with Avid if you're familiar with that program um in our uh being piloted in directed Studies classes those are um classes that

225are in high schools for students who are in general education placements in terms of General Ed participation if a student is in a directed study and an Al class that's taking up two classes in the schedule so that's one of our significant focuses right now um in addition in our special education world with special education teachers we want to focus on the Improvement of the delivery of Al uh instruction to our duly identified students and there's clearly based on the data there is an over identification and again oh thank you I just want to say the very fact that um our executive director is able to speak to this right now shows the cross functional conversations that we've been having over the last six months to a year and I'm really excited to just be

226able to let him sit here and talk that so it's really neat I I want to let him continue to speak to it so I will say multilingual has has has taken almost a driver seat in this and I I truly appreciate that um and again I'm looking at it as as reflective of looking at students as general education students first and we're we're optimistic with a a class that started at uh Montgomery High School and and is extending to the other high schools one small step but that's a piece that we're specifically address it's wonderful seeing them set in together because that's what it's going to take those two those two departments working like this that that's right here that's that's what has to happen and thank you Tristy manieri thank you um I

227feel like I have a lot to kind of comment on this but um just to keep it short I have kind of one curious question this review that we've done um is this was this like a a mandated review or is this something we're doing on our own accord that's fantastic I was hoping that that was the answer okay this was on our coming in yeah sorry yeah in coming in as a new superintendent the two things you really want to do a study on is FAL and sped and so and in terms of sped it's always good when you start seeing um in ed services disproportionality of our English Learners because we were in differentiated assistance for that and so when you start seeing these things you you want to be able to drill

228into what's happening and the best way to do is to have a specialist come in and then do an in-depth analysis and we'll be working on creating this is I've done this before as when I was in Dr casto's seat in terms of coming into a new district and saying sped is an area that we need to address a study like this is the best way to do it because it will give us the recommendations to look out for the next four or five years put the task force together um and really delve into all of those manuals and as Dr glasby said systems is my thing and so I'm super excited to be able to provide support in this work and work alongside Dr Gastro and John fiser as we do this work together

229and we have been keeping an eye on this and just um I guess it would be a good time to say um to the group that we have exited a differentiated existence um for all areas except for special education at this point so that includes English Learners so that's something to be uh very proud of over the last couple of years as of um December so thank you that is that is really great to hear and I was hoping that that was the answer um I saw in the presentation and also in the document uh so much comes back to the Strategic plan and so I'm wondering if um maybe Dr fiser director fiser if you can speak more to that what plans do we have for starting a task for task force and the

230strategic planning process and um if there are any insights into a timeline for that process um sure so the the first step was the the study by Dr gpie and bringing it to the board and with the encouragement direction of the board we would like to bring begin that process of a developing a task force one of the first priorities is going to be to develop a strategic plan um alongside de I think alongside developing a procedural manual which we're already taking uh steps to do um so my hope is that we could start the task force this year and start the planning process and I don't know what a timeline for that bill would would likely be but have a strategic plan in place yeah certainly by the end of this year before next

231year great and that kind of leads me to my next question um you know we've got a lot going on in our district these next several maybe even years will be um there will be a lot going on and so I guess my question is how are we going to ensure that this doesn't get lost in all of the transitions we're going to make um and that we don't lose this really great momentum that we've started with this presentation and review well I I I think ultimately the the commitment is going to be from the board and uh the superintendent and for me to be able to commit my and my Department's time to be able to start this work um I don't think we can right size or uh develop the district in the

232ways we want it to develop with a new vision without working on special education I I don't think we will be successful in this we successfully integrate special education into our new vision for the for the district yes with potential School consolidation there's a lot of logistics involved and so forth but that said we absolutely can't lose focus on our uh longer longer term vision and special education is is is necessary to fix to be able to fix that part and to build on that the The Matrix I talked about the action plan so when you write one of the goals and one of the things that by the end of the year maybe you don't have a lot of um a lot of action in the next three to four months you've got a

233pretty well playful but with the staff taking this report it's the road map when you develop uh the goal we're going to um review the student study team that's an easy one right um the all the recommendations are the activities that you do so John and his staff and his coordinator um and with ed services they bring to Dr Morales they bring here's our 15 page action plan and one of the student study team um we're going to get get a board adopted policy we going to get administrative regulations we're going to develop a manual we're going to develop forms and that's all listed out I mean I actually wrote the whole thing you just put it all in there and then you bring it to the board and every annually or whatever you want

234six months you say where is that action plan and it comes there and it's a now it's an accountability report card for the superintendent answering to the board what have you done with that report and it gives the ed services and special educations Department that that uh Power that Authority say this is what we're going to do and I just talked to so many staff and they are going to embrace this believe it or not the structure the direction the the accountability when you're going to do something where um so it's it's I I think it's going to be embraced by most of the staff ones I talk to anyway but I think that's the partly the answer to that question is that action plan by the end of the school year and then going

235into next year we've got the task force we're starting to do starting to implement now we're starting to take on these things um but now you guys are tracking it and they coming back and just making a check do we accomplish it or not where are we at with this and all the columns or that and I can give that to John and and Ed Services I'm I can give that document and as a format and we start working with it and uh then you have a good accountability plan where we're going really quickly from our part we have two branches we deal with aned services division operations and then on the other side it would be instructional pedagogy technical which is immediate like servicing interventions and then the Adaptive which is more of a

236Visionary Arc and which you see the um the tier one component which will be evolving inor of a tier two including the the development of the SST what you're referring to which has to do with the changes that were undergoing this year would affect more of the operational um aspect more of the technical but in terms of the long-term Visionary components that we're talking about that shouldn't be affected by it when we meet on a on a weekly basis to discuss these issues so that we're Nimble able to make changes and um we're very well aware and we try to be sensitive to what's going to be happening over the next few months so that we don't drop the ball on anything thank you great and I promise I have one last question and it's

237not for those of us here but more for those who maybe are going to be giving public comment if this is a question that can be answered um something that really stood out to me in the presentation is that staff wants leadership like that was repeated several times and so my question um if anyone can answer this um I know we have some um special education staff in the room who might give public comment um is what what would what does that look like what will that look like um what does leadership in this context mean to you and what is it that you're envisioning when you when you hear that or maybe even if you were one of the folks who said that thank you trusty deor um first and foremost thank you very

238much for the presentation but I'd be remiss if I did not mention the amount of times it was mentioned of how great of a staff we've hired and a very well-paid staff we've hired and we've had to make an investment into an outside consul agency to review what's very obvious in hemorrhaging some funds for special education this is not a new problem it's something that this district has been dealing with for quite a few years as a parent of a special education student multiple students um we've continued to try and Advocate and ask about this and like director Medina had mentioned and other trustees um this district has chronically lacked policies and practices and coherent uniform systems and I am very appreciative of superintendent Dr Morales and her systems experience to come on board and

239try and write this but it's something I've been asking about for the last two years it's something other directors have been asking about for their time on the board and nothing's moved forward so all of this planning and review means nothing without actional plan I'm very curious because I'm um it's very frustrating to see those numbers of overidentified students that we may not be serving appropriately have we been able to or are we able to look at what may be causing those students to struggle to lead to the over identification I I think I listed seven or eight points in the report but they were General points and one of them and I think that uh would recognize is the transfer of kids coming in that's one thing you have no control over I think

240uh the lack of a strong student study team process and from what I was um was interpreted and was pretty validated is that teachers really don't use the the multi-tier system approach there's not they say they have it but they really don't implement it and that is you know when these kids are underlining um below grade level uh Behavior academic whatever there should be a system and you certainly can talk about that it's tier one understanding really understand what what tier one is in the classroom and that's what we've been working on a calibration of what quality first instruction is that's what he's referring to so so you know that's that's so talking to teachers they they said well that's may we have it but it just needs to be stepped up you know by

241the superintendent saying to the Ed to the ed services special services and then the site principles this is what we've got to get the system in place so that that we keep kids in the general education program as much as much time as we can and and not just referring kids because they are labeled they don't get exited and it does have a long-term negative effect on them when it sometimes it's not necessary special education and the theme in that report is not a place it is a service and that we have to and one of the things it should be a banner in the special ed Department and the general and Ed Services is that all kids or general education kids first they get specialized Services special ed e whatever it is but that

242culture mind shift has to change of not just placing kids in an isolated bolt-on system that we found that exists in California we need to actually start thinking differently and then we have to give our general Ed teachers the support when they say I can't deal with this kid in my classroom we have to say well what is it that you do need you've got string of slps and school psychologists and behaviorists that people can go in through direction of special ed and say go into the regular classroom and give them the support we don't always have to pull kids out in an isolation and do oneon-one push into the classroom one of the school districts I was working in just real quick they were having this problem and they were going to go with

243the student study team where they sit and talk about the kids and try the interventions well what happens go try this teacher go try this go try this well the teacher comes back and says you know I tried that I've got 20 some kids I it's not working well what this one school district did it's about 15,000 kids they the deputy superintendent says you know what click for every intervention that we recommend that goes back into that general education classroom we assign a staff member an a school psychologist to look at Behavior if it's a language issue we're going to have this SLP go in the classroom and work with the kids um the behaviorist you have behaviorist you have some great behaviorist in this District instead of pulling out go into the classroom and

244work develop their behavior plans and and mainstream least restrictive environment keep those kids there so because you don't have those systems you're those numbers may be somewhat off but the fact is there's too many kids going into special education that could remain in general education so I appreciate the outside District perspective I'm really need to focus and St interested on S City Schools situation um I have spoken to special ed Educators in our district and one of the issues some Educators feel we're dealing with directly and this needs to be looked at and seeing if it's true or not is when we mandated a through G for all and we did not have a proper on board for that mandate it left some students struggling in not being on um the track to graduate high

245school that it forced their families to evaluate and test that they need special education services and that has led some of those families that may not necessarily need special education fully but need to be addressed in a general education classroom that they have proper opportunities to address where their shortcomings are educationally and not be put into a special education bracket where I don't want to have contracted special AIDS I want it to be classified and certificated employees working with our students how do we get to that in San City Schools that's a d That's a darn good question um and I think the superintendent is going to probably be taking this on with the their leadership team of really negotiating and um and the unions they're going to be open to negotiating because you know

246you know how the union works that's membership that's bringing back membership for us so the union supportive so it's a it kind of Falls in HR and and business services like well what's the dollar figure but when you're Contracting for these instructional assistants out correct me if I'm wrong but the data that I got was about $50 an hour that's that's it's higher than that it's higher than I mean so they're getting paid pretty darn good money the contractors and so I'm not saying the district can afford that but you're competing with that that that private contractor they're paying a lot of money um but what you want to do and I I agree and I I recommended it we need to bring those people back and be part of the team be part of

247Santa Rosa city school district yeah trusty Casten yeah thank you um I going to save my comments and stuff for after public comment uh and so just to confine my questions I'm looking for the one word to three sentence answer I appreciate the robust responses you've given but I want to make sure my questions are furthering our discussion after uh I just want to clarify the headline number is roughly $30 million in Savings in here which is a number that correlates uh to some of the other matters we're discussing at this time in the district your recommendations are not recommendations that would result in that Savings in one year it is something that is over a longer time period correct yes um within here we jump to overidentification very quickly in the logic within the

248report what I don't see is other statistical references such as comparable districts I don't see mode and mean um evaluation to see how we are compared to similar um you know District sizes and how frequently 12% is showing up within the Statewide data is that data available to us yeah you know that's a really good very good point and when you go into and and they have access to it it's called Data Quest and then there's Ed uh Ed what a data Quest and Ed fact whatever I I forget what it is Ed data isn't it and uh so you you can Flash on those and you see that data to give you some feedback on that and it's a really good point is that um the Statewide average however they come up with that

249the state California is is right under right at just I I'll call it 133% of the students in California schools are identified with disability in Sonoma County based on however the the Sela comes up with that number and John can talk about that he he's an expert on that is that it's about 15% and so I kind of use that same format on come coming coming up with the 19% of looking at the kids that you have in the district um special ed and then dividing that with the by the general population it came up with the 19% not really scientific but it kind of gives us that ballpark that you're certainly over the county level of identification and certainly over the Statewide and the breakdown John can talk about that because you can go

250on the website I know data Quest is one of them that breaks it all down pretty clearly like look at comparable districts and things of that sort which I think would be a useful Endeavor have have we looked at it uh where would we look at it within the process the line outline for Stephanie's director moner's question sorry within the process that you outlined earlier where would we be going and looking at and confirming the data um I think that would be very early on in the process if you're asking in terms of time because we want to get AC relatively accurate figures uh with respect to districts with similar enrollment and similar uh demographics where are we at with respect to um uh so-called overidentification and then second point is are there districts of

251similar to us uh that have tried strategies and have a significantly lower rate um to see what strategies that they have used I would think that would be very early in the process and I don't think that difficult data would be difficult to get challenge for when I'm looking at this data is that we move from We're above average to it's because of overidentification what other causes were we viewed for what I would first think of as over concentration is there anything else that is contributing other than our identification of students to that number um speculation at this point um speculation that uh we could have students moving into charter schools out of the district for example that don't reflect a special education population I don't have data to confirm that but that's uh a

252potential other uh additional costs um and um it could be as Dr gaspie referred to is that we don't have appropriate practices for identifying when students are exit uh that's another potential um Factor uh we another potential factor is uh interdistrict transfers uh we also have students that are placed with us by other districts on a fee for service model again that I know how many we have now um we have 11 um and depending we can tease those out of the data relatively uh relatively uh easily I've have not looked at the percentage of interdistrict transfers but that is another possibility in addition to that that's different from us identifying is our um what are the identif identification rates of our feeder districts um to see those coming in so again these are not

253even hypotheses yet but potential other additional explanations with similar rigor to overidentification being review being reviewed as a cause here yeah yeah you know I really stressed the first part of the whole report really talked about the role of the board and and I actually wrote some statements the board could actually adopt and as well as special ed in in the sense of inclusion you know really saying we're an inclusion model District that we're including kids and and then when and then you know there are again I have the breath of experience in school districts all over California I mean from Imperial County to cisu County I've been in every county in the state of California is when the schools side administrator takes on the ownership of saying we're not we're keeping kids fully included

254in the regular classroom to the maximum that we can are school districts that have a four to five% identification rate in their districts because they set at the board level at the superintendent level saying we're including kids we're having strong Educational Services Department doing the professional development pushing teachers special LED teachers into the regular classroom you know the co- teing you know I think you have some going on thank you just to jump in there because actually Dove Tales beautifully in my last question to confirm this report was exclusively looking at supports for our students with IEPs and doesn't include our population of students who have disabilities that are being served under 504 supports is that accurate go ahead yes that's accurate this was limited to to students with disabilities correct there's there's a some

255school districts are really looking at their Ed population and um if you're not familiar with the 504 it's it's a it's it's kind of like would you say a medical condition mostly the what these days probably more extensive than that I would say is fair to say from uh but it's 504 is when a student doesn't require special education services but may need accommodations and other L interest of time I I appreciate my question's been answered so thank you yeah quick okay trusty Kirby sorry just a couple of quick questions uh I promise um thank you again for the report I actually when I saw the $26 million potential savings down the road uh obviously got my attention um just a couple things because the um reports out there public and everyone's hopefully going to

256be reading it and looking at it um like in your executive summary you mentioned a 2025 report on uh one system is that just a typo or is that another update to the 2015 yes that's an updated one yes so another one will be coming in yeah yeah okay good to know thanks for reading that well also I would my ask to you would be can you go back and look at some of your findings and recommendations because there's actually some typos in there and some of the some of them are kind of not readable or they're not clear what what they are I would just just I can show you I appreciate that you know when I was working for the fiscal crisis management team we had three professional writers and mean they edited

257the report um you never saw them now I edit my own reports and uh so my apologies for that it's fine just just to let you know thanks all right let's move to public comment um I have Karen Wagner followed by Margaret Boon followed by Jessica lehow and again you have 90 seconds good evening I'm Karen and um I'm a special ed assistant um working with the district for two decades now well 21 years getting ready to go on 22 so what I want to say is that I've been truly blessed to be able to work with this community and um I do have an amazing U team and staff uh I've worked with the RSP I've worked with the LH community and then you know like um and then the ESN which is essential

258needs right so severely handicapped that's been the majority of my um experience but what I want to say is that the assistance we really do need to get when I first started here there was so many of us and now we just have so many Outsiders that they change daily and our students kind of react to different Personnel coming in the classroom all the time I know that reality is is that eventually they're you know the world might might be like that where people come in and out of the world but we really do need to get assistance um that can work with the kids work with the teachers work with the staff that they could trust you know and that they feel like that they have a core community and you know what we

259work a lot on social skills all day long I work on social skills thank you your time is up next we have Margaret Boon followed by Jessica lehow followed by um Demaris Cordo um we are on an all-time high with initial IEPs and this has been increasing significantly since the pandemic in several places within his presentation Dr Gillespie said we need more tier one interventions as teachers we agree we need consistent tier 2 interventions as well if we had proper RTI we would catch kids that are struggling but don't need special ed then we could give them the interventions they need to keep them out of special ed the issue is the district has cut the people who do those intervention ions like our reading toses and the district has suggested they're going to cut

260up to 195 more teachers how will we ever do those interventions when we have larger and larger class sizes more and more combo classes in elementary school and fewer teachers 26 million is a lot of money to save and we really need to figure out how to do that but cutting all the people who can do interventions is not going to save us money it won't fix our special ed program issues it'll exacerbate them and that will waste even more money also we have been short slps for years and we've actually had to bring Outside Agency people for that trying to prevent overages even doing speech over Zoom we have case load limits trying to Li keep our workloads a reasonable size not as a way to boost our paychecks with overages we aren't allowed

261to say no to overages people have asked and instructing an extra 10 20 30 kids is a huge amount of work and keeping kids in a service like speech is an IP team decision not unilaterally made by SL please thank you thank you next we have Jessica Leo followed by dearis Cordo hi there my name is Jessica lehow um I wanted to make comment as a parent of a child that has a 504 uh specifically because uh my child has had a 504 since she was like eight years old and she's 15 and a half now so I've been through the elementary the middle school and now the high school um and really I'm my child's manager my child is has never had a manager my child has never had anyone in the district that

262I could go to for education of myself as and as well as holding the teachers accountable in my experience the teachers don't want to be held accountable they refuse to be involved and it never fails every single year even though my child emails advocates for herself I'm advocating for her I always have teachers that refuse to follow they make violations they call my child out they say that she has required to carry her 504 with her and present it to them and educate them and that's wrong and you know why because the union protects them to such a degree that your special education department cannot hold them accountable you guys can't hold them accountable the union is in control here and unless the rules around the union and their protection change I really don't think

263that anything is going to change and if it were me I would Advocate to get an IEP just so that my child would have support and guidance and that I would be educated as a parent thank you last we have dearis Cordo hi thank you my name is Damaris Cordo and uh you know I was at home but decid to come in person because this is a very important topic that you uh discussing here and uh I appreciate the way the gentleman present the J subject thank you for the sensibility and Clarity which uh you spoke uh I'm a mother of multilingual student who was recently evaluated and accepted for 504 plan and as the gentleman mentioned we need this four and the superintendent to take action action on this our childrens are not receiving

264early intervention as he mention and this is not only in this District my son became from a ringcon valet Union district and he never was evaluated and uh never receive the support that he's supposed to be doing uh and this is why I'm here to please you know help us with our student they deserve better education uh they they so they they deserve support I don't want to see our multilingual student just pull them you know apart like you know like they they don't matter and um that's why I'm here I like to advocate for all the multilingual students because I see a lot of parents you know reaching out with a lot of frustration coming reaching out to the principal but there's not there's nobody who can help us because you know like he

265mentioned also that uh thank you miss your time is up don't have the support thank you thank you are there any other blue cards no other blue cards all right then this comes back to the board but I do want to point out to the board we have about 35 minutes left there any discussion trusty Caston yeah thank you and I appreciate the report and the focus um we have all the makings of measurable data in this report and I'm concerned about whether or not we have the right data to be measuring success I I think it's really important that we challenge the assumption that that this is overidentification and we look at other causes and we're making sure that we are thr in that and very specifically and I went back and read the

2662015 one system report and in the report a quote from it is unfortunately parents often do not possess the confidence and the legal skills they need to confidently occupy and fulfill their role in the special education process and when we do 504 meetings and when we do IEPs when we even learn as parents that those things exist there is no one that assists in actually saying what they can do or how they can support the students and I worry that if we are saying by policy that overidentification is the cause that we have determined to be true we're going to create more of a confrontational environment with parents that do have students with disabilities and are already struggling to understand not just these tools exist but what things to ask for within those meetings you

267don't walk into a 54 meeting or an IEP meeting and have people say these are the types of things that can help your kid you usually have to start by actually coming up with those and going in then saying I want to try these and then you keep having to go back and reiterate so for me making sure that we're measuring the correct data and we're identifying all of the causes so that we don't Implement solutions that cause problems or aggravate existing problems is going to be really important um I also want to point out that the 2015 one system report said that the Statewide average for contribution from the general fund was 57% and so we are now at where the Statewide contrib average contributions that means everyone else has actually gone up by

268that 10 to 12% and it seems interesting to me that we should make sure that we continue to look at that and what we were doing right and identify those uh to make sure that we continue on those cost uh saving areas I'd also really like to see a bigger discussion about selpa structuring and how we can have programs like the dhh program where we have 100% funding for the program that we're doing on our campus in relationship to the IEPs and lastly I very much want to make sure that a part of this is a structure in which the 504 and the IEP environments our two populations of students with disabilities are being managed even closer together and I do appreciate seeing both of you up there together but 504 supports could be a

269solution but there's still an accommodation for Disabilities under the law thank you a trusty manary and then trusty Medina just quickly two things um one is you know one of the next conversations we're going to have is about um committees and one of our board committees on the table is a policy committee and I just urge whoever is going to be on that committee from our board to um prioritize the the policies and the recommendations in this report um so just wanted to put that out there and then the second thing I wanted to um mention and also kind of plant a seed um is that we really need to take a hard look at pay I mean we have been talking about pay for such a long time um and this is something that

270this board wants to do like that this is not something that we are opposed to um and so I think that it's important that we work with our bargaining units and identify Y what the real barriers are um so that we can get to to a place where we all want to be and we have to also at the same time realize that we're working in in some really challenging fiscal realities and that we can't do everything um but those are those are going to be conver they're conversations we just have to have and so this is an invitation um and it's also a hope of mine that we can work with our bargaining units on this because it's something we we both want um but there are challenges that we have to work through

271try Medina thank you um first off again thank you superintendent Morales for your leadership on getting this going uh Dr Gillespie for your work and um Dr fiser for for everything that you're doing and and what I hope to come um I would hope that as we develop metrics that they could also be added to the lcap um as we develop a task force I don't know what or who is planed to be on that but um I think as we as we look at that Community School model that we you know reach out to to agencies such as like DHS uh you know Health Services Human Services um and get them all engaged so we collectively as a community um achieve better outcomes for our students think of it as an upstream investment um

272and I think my ask is also that in the near future maybe we get a timeline of what we should expect in terms of process because I think part of the ask is that it's upon this board to to make this happen so in order to hold yall accountable we need to have those timelines and stuff to to know so I think getting us a timeline on what we should expect when um would be helpful in that process thank you any other discussion uh trusty Jenkins I'll be quick um I just wanted to throw it out there that I personally have gone through this on a professional level in the last year while my role has shifted as a case manager in the mental health world we had a ballooned case load and a lot

273of it was the lack of assessment and overidentifying so I have recently gone through this process um professionally so I'm really excited to see this report I'm really excited to get going on the work that can be really transformative um not only in our schools but in our community at large and getting these kids to the place where they where they really should be um it sucks to get a label if you don't really need it uh so I really look forward to the work that's coming ahead thank you so much any other discussion trusty Kirby just one quick one um you know you brought you started off with talking about the Strategic plan and I couldn't agree more with you and and not only the Strategic plan for special education you were talking about

274but that actually we have to back it up and our strategic plan as a board we've got to task ourselves to go back look at that get our vision get our mission uh and before you guys can then come you know the special ed part of it can come up with their strategic plan so as far as a timeline as director Medina mentioned you know we need to start there first that's it all right thank you both for the presentation we will move on now to item F3 approval of board member School site liaison assignments for 2025 this is an action item this is an annual item um every year we appoint board members to several sites outside of their trustee area uh trusty Medina you have a question I just like to move approve

275to approve the board of School site Lees on the assignments for 2025 is there any public comment on this there's no public comment all right so I had a motion from trusty Medina there a second discussion all right um let's go to trusty Medina not M Casten and then de laor I have concerns about signing School Liaisons prior to us completing our process in February um I think right now is a time where any sign of us working on any one campus instead of all of them um is just not the right message to send and so I'd really like to see this matter postponed until March trusty delator my question was just regarding School assignments if they change cuz I have the same leing on S sites that I had last year not that

276I oppose to that because I go to all the campuses but I just didn't know if this needed to be moved around at all so perhaps this does need to wait till further time to be reevaluated can I jump in really quick my understanding is that they didn't change because of all of the transition that is going to take place so rather well I guess we got neutres so that maybe doesn't make sense but that was kind of my understanding was that we didn't want to move too much because of the transitions at someone can correct me if I'm wrong trusty Medina yeah I think um it's just uh the new the outgoing members are no longer there they had their assignments that were now no longer assigned so the new trustees um get assignments

277so if you you the year is the Academic Year so yeah you have the same ones um uh the presidents change because the president doesn't have any specific schools so that so those are the changes to reflect the neutres coming in trusty Kirby my separate motion would be to table this um my schools that are assigned are within my jurisdiction and so that it's against board policy so I would say we again move to table this until further second all right so we have a motion by trust Kirby second and by trusty Casten um trusty Medina yeah so I think I'd just like to correct to trusty Kirby um if you look at the assignments right there next to each school it says what trustee area is in so you're in truste area five um

278all those assigned to you are area seven or three well I am in truste area three so U is incorrect uh okay also a motion to the table is not actually debatable so if we could move to the vote uh roll call vote trusty Kirby I trusty Casten hi trusty Medina no trusty Jenkins hi trusty de Tor hi trusty manieri I president M MCN I so the item is tabled so then we'll move on to F4 um board subcommittees and District committees 2025 this is discussion and possible action um I am hoping to establish some board subcommittees to hopefully make our work more efficient I thought that these two areas fiscal analysis and board policy updates were two of our most pressing needs and opening two committees would give us a chance to have each

279board member serve on one of these committees um I'd like to know if the other board members um how you feel about establishing these committees and which committees you would be interested in serving on um let's see I saw trusty deor first then trusty Casten so I'm in support of establishing committees but that is the caveat that they actually go somewhere and are actionable I do not want to form committees where we just have isolated silos and discussions that aren't available to the public and we don't actually do anything so one of the things from the special ed presentation was that accountability of every six months having some progress um so if we do go forward with these committees we just have to find a way to actually ensure we are doing something and it's

280progressing and it's not just a committee to Kick the Can on some really important issues down the road trusty Caston a question to confirm but it also I think will make a point um these are intended to be standing committees correct and thus they would be subject to the brown act and increase transparency on these conversations yes that's my intention and that leads to my point which is having even tonight where we're extending the meeting while we're having really important conversations around large Financial ma matters having standing committees where three of us are in the room being able to have that discussion open to the public an additional place for public comment an additional place for asking questions before it gets here so the questions we're asking then take it to the next level so

281we're not having to ask basic things that staff could then go back and refine I think is incredibly important to good governance and I commend you for these two areas it's also important for us to focus on that and um I'm fully in support of this I Echo the comments about making this mean something but I think them being standing publicly accessible committees where we're able to have more robust conversations not confined by uh the theater of this Amphitheater um I think is really important trusy Medina did you have your hand raised um give me a second you could go to someone else any other board questions trusty Jenkins I'm curious um in respect for time as well because this may be a conversation that may take a little bit of time maybe not I

282know um but I'm just wondering if there would be a benefit to push this to the next meeting this topic for selecting just wondering if that's all interested um I guess I would just ask like what what's the rationale behind pushing it out um some of it is well for me personally as a brand new board member I really want to be involved but I also want to have more information like I want to be able to fully dive into well I have done a lot of it already um to better understand like what I'd be getting into so a discussion of kind of what the what the subcommittees would look like and I know it was kind of discussed that we would come to that after um after selecting the subcommittees but having an

283idea of what we want these to look like prior to selecting uh of who's on what are you concerned about like time commit ment I'm just trying to understand what um maybe a little bit the time commitment but more so um like I want to be as involved as humanly possible but I also want to come into it with as much knowledge as possible as a new board member I I could my understanding for board subcommittees which is a different board policy than District representation committees is that the process for appointments is a recommendation from the superintendent an appointment by the president instead of an action by the board so if we establish them then the superintendent and president could meet with all of us and talk to us exactly about those things prior to

284making those appointments thank you for that clarification that's helpful is that correct so we just need to establish the Committees and then um you can I can either receive your interest now or there is a Google form where you can tell me which uh which committees you're interested in serving on trusty Kirby well that was kind of my question that that form that was sent out with the extra committees I mean so there we're only doing two of those tonight is that what is two of those already exist these are the two that we need to establish oh and the other ones are two that the board already exist the other ones are district committees that are handled by the district and in my recommendations I think there's only one that I would say recommended

285for a truste to sit on so the focus would be on the subcommittees and um establishing these two new ones we can come back to the timeline and who's going to you know when them when it will be meeting because it'll be three board members it it won't be bound by the B Brown act so we can establish what those will look like okay thanks thanks for clarifying and for that Google doc of the additional subcommittees that's something that will be looked at later yes and you can just let us know which On's interested in and the um president can make the assignments or which ones we may suggest of committees that wouldn't work okay so it sounds like right now we just need a motion to establish these trusty Caston I'd like to make

286a motion to establish two board standing committees one on fiscal analysis and one on board policy as described in the item a second okay moved by trusty Casten seconded by trusty Maneri roll call vote like well there's discussion on the motion um I would just ask um from a staffing perspective will these be staffed um in terms of Staff resources who will be directed to facilitate the board in terms of running these posting the agendas all that stuff I think that's it so so yes it would be it would be myself helping whatever committee members are part of that and the committee will decide how to report out sorry excuse me um normally these these are not open to the public but I know that we've heard from the community in terms of being open

287to the public so we can kind of delineate what that will look like we could definitely put on the website um the meeting agendas and the minutes to make sure that everybody's aware of what's being discussed it will be up to the committee to kind of make that decision the sub commmittee to that the the the motion is to create these as uh uh standing committees um coming into this I I don't know assume that they'd be ad hoc specifically especially the board policy update subcommittee so I'm just thinking just clarifying standing committees have to be agendized and notice 72 hours in advance right those would be ad hoc committees I believe no the the standing committees are the one this is for standing committee vote and those are the ones that have to be

288agendized and noticed right then yes and then it will require much more of a team to put those together and that's what we're do can to answer yes my motion is for a standing committee the intent is that is that is because that what make it makes it a brown act one and that increases the transparency and many of the important conversations in here being able to advance with full disclosure so that when we get here we are able to be more or further along in that conversation when the items come up to hear um so that is the intent of my motion is that they be standing committees okay so the motion on the table is for both to be standing committees I will say that I personally would I would be open to

289the fiscal subcommittee being standing and the policy update being ad HW I would agree I'm okay with that as a friendly Amendment with the caveat of what was stated about posting the work kind of similar to how fiscal stabilization was um so that people can track progress on special ad and such I think the only thing is if it's an ad hoc you have to have a specific time so how long will it be for so I I agree board policy should be an ad ad hoc but um then we need add for long what do we think three months Ward there's a lot of policy work from the csba um consistency so I would suggest we go for one year great I agree so is that a that's a friendly amendment to a standing

290committee for fiscal analysis and a one-year ad hoc committee for board policy update yes whoever seconded the motion has to okay the friendly as well I accept the friendly Amendment as well all right roll call vote trusty Casten hi trusty manieri hi trusty Kirby hi trusty Medina hi trusty Jenkins hi trusty de la Tor I president MCN I right motion passes unanimously let's move on to our consent items can can I request that G8 also be pulled in light of the comments that were made during public comment yes um sorry can someone remind me which items have been pulled G8 G9 G13 so we need sep motion G3 yeah so we need seeking a motion on items g 1 and two 4 through S and 10 through 12 no moved second roll call vote who

291who made the first motion that was trusty Caston seconded by trusty Medina thank you trusty Casten hi trusty Medina hi trusty Kirby hi trusty Jenkins hi trusty deori hi trusty manieri hi president MCN I motion passes all right seeking a motion on G3 so moved moved by President sorry trusty Medina second seconded by trusty manieri roll call vote trusty Medina I trusty manieri I trusty Casten stain trusty Kirby hi trusty Jenkins hi trusty de laor hi president mcnell I motion passes all right um so now we're looking at G8 yeah on this one I'd just like to ask that um um we we table it and bring it back it sounds like there's some concerns with um are unions that maybe need to be addressed and discussed before we actually make this decision so um

292I would move to table this there a second trusty Kirby hey just just to be clear this is just for the design fees correct this is not or the actual electronic locks that comes later this is just for the design of the system is that correct Lisa August has some information that the board might want to hear oh sorry go ahead yes that is correct this would be for design fees only and we would actually be able to move to remove um specific sites based on what the consolidation um and closure committee works you know looks like this is to get the ball rolling the other thing to note is that this actually doesn't replace the lock that we've already put in this is an added security measure that helps control some of the issues

293that we have or where we have um access where we have to give physical keys to people who are not employed by us with having electronic locks we can do the when you think of a hotel and the key swipe we can we have control in who does or does not have access um the physical locks actually still remain we have those Columbine locks there are reasons that that these work together and this is um something that was identified in the facil master plan as part of that overall safety um there was the the sorry it's been it's been a long night my brain's a little a little fried we had the safety analysis that threat assessment done and so this is part of all of that piece of it so just so the board

294understands that that piece of it and I'll just add that I I I think it sounds like something good and positive that makes sense I just hear there's concerns that maybe need to be addressed and I think it makes sense to address them before we even invest in the design so that's that's my concern um and and that's why I'm my ask is that we take this back have some sort of discussion with the units to understand those concerns and maybe get some sort of agreement on that and then bring it back so and that's why I made that is there a sense of urgency around this Lisa some sort of like timeline we're bound to not necessarily a timeline we're bound to it was that safety was one of the highest priorities identified in

295the facilities master plan and so while we can't we've had to put a lot of things on hold this is one of the items that would be able to to at least the planning piece of it start moving forward especially as we're making Transitions and changes it it's something that just sets us up for Success um in meeting other timelines in the future it's not a we need to have this today um it it is just helpful in our overall planning and securing our campuses so we have a motion to table is there a second is it reasonable to ask for this to be taed but brought back at the next meeting so that it's not just carried out forever yes we'll be happy to do that that this could could have been something addressed

296at our facilities advisory committee but we did have to cancel that and move it because of the addition of an of a special board meeting this last month well I'll I'll second um director Medina's um motion with that timeline of bringing it back at the next meeting thank you roll call vote trusty Medina hi trusty manieri hi trusty Casten hi trusty Kirby no trusty Jenkins I trusty de laori hi president mcnell Hi so the item is tabled to be brought back next meeting um now we need to talk about G9 okay so I pull G9 um I'm just want to U move to amend the extra Duty uh um salary schedule on the um A1 accompanist uh a 3 after school athletic program Elementary um A4 Auditorium supervisor uh A1 ticket taker time keeper scorekeeper

297and B one student worker so that they match the actual local uh minimum wage for Santa Rosa that went into effect on January 1st which is 1787 um the I think the important thing to to know here is that um this is a group of people that aren't represented don't have anyone arguing for them so it's up to the board to make any decisions on this um you know as as we're often reminded um people are struggling um with the cost of living and so um I think all other employees um are you know with what's on the table um would already be above that 1787 so I I think it it makes sense and it's the right thing to do to make sure that um we pay Folks at the local minimum wage of

2981787 so I would move to make that amendment to this document Casten I would like to refer that motion to the board policy subcommittee because there's also the city's local ordinance which includes some collective bargaining language also around it I think there's a lot of Merit to this and it's something we should definitely be able to pursue but it would benefit from the very deliberations that we just talked about and if we did it through policy to where whatever we do today becomes something that automatically happens in the future instead of it requiring us to be up here and remembering tonight uh the next time this item comes forward I think that would give us a more long-term uh solution Med in in general I would agree and I've tried to go that route for

299multiple years still hasn't happened there's been obstacle over obstacle um I think the the thing to know is that um the longer this is delayed this is potential lost wages for these folks that could be getting paid at this rate you know um which is what everybody else in Santa Ros is likely getting paid um at the least um there is no retroactive measure on this if we change this later on um so the longer we wait the longer that happens you know while bargaining units their their wages go retroactive to potentially July and they would make up for that but for this we wouldn't so I would say um you know for this pay period this would impact these people um the cost um you know for what was stated here is $3,000 um

300going from 16 to 1650 going from 16 to the 1787 it's 11,200 $20 at that same amount of hours so it's just an additional $7,000 Which is less than a half perc of you know what we're currently dealing with on additional negotiations so that's my ask you know um a ple for these people that aren't represented I'm going to Second so that I can then make a motion to refer to the committee so I second the motion and I'd like to make a motion to refer refer this to the ad hoc committee on board policy okay what do I do ask for a second there a second for trustee caston's referral second that roll call vote uh discussion on that second motion so I would object refering it and and I would say vote no

301on the referral um and then approve the um the initial motion the main motion so that it could go into effect now so that our staff can have the time to implement it and make sure that these workers um are are paid minimum wage for Santa Rosa okay so a roll call vote on trusty caston's referral okay uh so that was trusty casted made the um motion and was there a second or was it Medina and then Casten sorry uh seconded by trusty Jake Jenkins gotcha um trusty Casten hi trusty Jenkins hi trusty Kirby hi trusty Medina no trusty de laor no trusty manieri no president mcnell Hi motion passes right and then um I make a motion to extend the meeting to 11:15 we can only extend once we would just um ask Clarity

302so we referred to a committee that doesn't yet exist right well we've established the committee we just need to appoint trustees to it okay um I what what happens so those items get moved to next next meeting all right meeting adjourned have a good night everyone

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.