CorpusRecord 107027

SRCS Regular Board Meeting - December 11, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Santa Rosa City Schools
Date
2024-12-12
Location
Sonoma County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
25,522 words · about 142 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e now calling to order the December 11th 2024 meeting of the Santa Rosa City Schools Board of Education um before starting on the public comment on close session agenda items um we'll be pulling item close session item B4 which is the conference with legal council on anticipated litigation that item will be pulled from the agenda and not be discussed today so we will now be taking public comment on closed agenda items B1 student expulsions B2 Public Employee discipline dismission release B3 conference with labor negotiator and B5 uh public employee performance evaluation um are there any blue cards rep public comments president Medina there are no blue cards seeing no public comments we will now recess to close session we are now reconvening the December 11th 2024 meeting of the seneral City Schools Board of Education

002if everybody would please rise for the pledge and then remain standing for our land acknowledgement ALG to the flag un States of America the stands one nation indiv now please remain standing while uh Landon long from brinken Valley Middle School leads us in our land acknowledgement I acknowledge that Santa Rosa city schools is on the traditional territory and homelands of the Pomo people traditional territory and homelands of the Coast Miwok people and Auto with gratitude the land of s and the people who have stewarded it through the generations this land acknowledgement calls us to commit to continuing to learn how to be better towards of the land we inhibit by offering this land a knowledgement we affirm indigenous sovereignty and we work to Santa Rosa city schools more accountable to needs of American and Indian

003and Indigenous people thank you Landon you may all now be seated uh we will now move on to our C3 item uh there were no actions taken in Clos session um and just uh or people that weren't here um item B4 was removed from the agenda um items considered in closed session for action and Open Session and we will go to our student expulsions um can I have a motion on case 2024 25-8 move to approve second moved by trusty Flores second by trusty deor um can we get a vote trusty Flores hi trusty deor hi trusty Sheffield I trusty De La Cruz I trusty mcnali I trusty manieri I president Medina I uh can we get a motion to approve the recommendation on expulsion case 2024 SL 25-10 move to approve second moved by

004trusty Flores second by trusty uh Sheffield can we have the vote trusty Flores I trusty Sheffield I trusty De La Cruz I trusty MCN I trusty deor I trusty manieri I president Medina I uh can we get a motion to approve the recommendation on student expulsion case 2024 25-12 please move to approve second moved by trusty Flores second by trusty Sheffield uh vote please trusty Flores I trusty Sheffield I trusty De La Cruz I trusty mcnali I trusty de laor I trusty manieri I president Medina I uh can you get a motion to accept the recommendation on student expulsion case 25-16 move to approve second moved by trusty Flores second by truste um theator vote please trusty Flores hi trusty de laor hi trusty Sheffield I trusty De La Cruz I trusty MCN I trusty

005manieri I president Medina I thank you we will now move on to item C5 statements of abstention board are there any statements of abstention see none uh item C6 adjustments to the agenda any adjustments to the agenda board um see none we will now move on to reports our first report is from California School employee um Association uh Sosa chapter 75 report president I think it's it's um public comment first oh yeah going too fast okay so for public comment um real quick um there was a lot of folks that submitted stuff um it looks like if you submitted stuff on school closure we're going to address it on on uh E7 um but outside of that um anything non agendized I'll be calling on right now um I'll be calling three names at a

006time um when to call your name make sure to get up next to one of the comp podiums and um uh due to the number of cards we're going to do 90 seconds um so first I have uh looks like dick Shermer followed by Kathy bassini followed by Chris Gray oh Dirk sorry Durk Shermer president Medina first I want to thank you for your hard work on behalf of this community in particular your vocational work at the LC Allen Foundation as our community sorely needs such programs as you've spearheaded in fact I think actually it's probably more important than having your voice here on the school board however because you were paid by the foundation it creates such a bias in favor of LSC Allen that California law requires you to recuse yourself in the

007chairing of meetings participation in discussions voting and perhaps even being present during discussions of certain budgetary items and in particular any matters related to school closures or consolidations as school consolidation is going to be the largest item on the board's agenda going forward it is highly unlikely that continuing as board president will be fair or even possible I have shared the legal background for this with some of the trustees already but I have also prepared some paper copies of anyone would care to read them thank you thank you uh next I have Kathy bassini followed by followed by Chris Gray followed by Angel Ortega Kathy good evening I certainly hope that You' have been able to see how committed we are to getting a decent raise one that we deserve we don't want to hear

008that there isn't any money we should not have to pay for your mistakes we are the one you're the ones who created the situation you've known for a long time exactly how bad the situation is but yet the teachers got a raise and they deserve it the admin got their raise and then in spite of the critical situation you gave yourselves a raise the ca employee should not have to pay for your mistakes we can barely afford groceries rent utilities gas it's not easy we deserve better instead of making another mistake we are asking you to do the right thing and improve a decent race for us we are asking you to do what is morally and eth ethically correct thank you thank you next I have Chris Gray followed by Angel Ortega followed by

009Samantha sharp Chris my name is Chris Gray I am the C CA Union site rep for LC Allen High School I am also the parent of a child who attends Proctor Terrace Elementary my heart has been heavy this fall we have made it to December and classified employees still haven't received the raise we deserve with school consolidation and imminent layoffs many of us face losing both the school we work at as well as our child school all in the next six months it's heartbreaking what will we do in our entire sense of community is blown up I implore the board to work with CA to increase our wages so that our employees the lowest paid in the district have more financial support when facing what is about to come I also ask that when closing

010schools you try to keep communities together as much as possible instead of cutting apart the student population of each School piece by piece to be redistributed like Commodities this will already happen with staff at every school next year because of seniority layoffs the upcoming decisions of the board will affect the livelihood of thousands of Santa Rosa families please remember that thank you thank you next I have Angel Ortega followed by Samantha sharp followed by Jackson ronelli angel thank you for having me my name is Angel I'm a proud ofum staff and coach of and for LC Isen high school and a proud member of CSEA since my injury in October I've received bills for an ambulance r at $3,600 an ER visit at $144,000 and leg surgery for $59,000 when it comes to our raises

011it's a shame that you put us on hold when in reality we can't put life on hold so Schoolboard be grateful that we care and love our kids be grateful that we love our sites and communities especially in these uncertain times as many May face potential closures and layoffs and be grateful that we only seek reconciliation and not retaliation give us the wage we deserve shout out LC Allen shout out Southwest Santa Rosa shout out CCA thank you Angel next I have Samantha sharp followed by Jackson ronelli followed by Patrick Atchinson Samantha I'm this is the probably sixth or seventh time I've talked talked at a board meeting about the exact same thing at my first board meeting I extended the invitation for all of the board members and um superintendent Morales to come to

012our classified offices and spend at least an hour ideally half a day there since then no one has made an effort to do that um at our last uh special board meeting there was questions about whether you even knew what job titles were in what offices and since then that has also not been rectified and that is still an unknown for you you are continuing to push forward with with budget cuts with school closures and with laying off CCA members in the future without actually knowing what we do or how valuable valuable we are for our schools we interact with the students every single day we are the Frontline for the parents as Daisy Morales said we are customer service and we are doing all of these things and wearing all these hats without AR

013raise for over six months now without AR raise We are continuing to live our lives go to work and do what we need to do for our kids while you guys can continue to put us on hold I'm hoping that at the negotiations on Friday there's a change thank you next I have Jackson ronelli followed by Patrick ainson Jackson hello my name is Jackson ranelli and I am a senior at s Roa High School I am here on behalf of the classified staff members of this District I work personally with these staff members every day and I see how much work they put into their jobs and their students students classified staff members are the backbone of our schools I find it completely ridiculous that the board continues to avoid granting these valued members of

014our community the raise they are asking for these are good hardworking people who deserve our support the decision to exclude the classified staff from the pay raise given to teachers and administrators is frankly unjust I urge you to take a look on what would happen to our schools without classified staff members take a look around you I see familiar faces that are continuously fighting for their recognition in this District I see them why don't you thank you thank you next I have Patrick Patrick ainson hello um my name is Patrick aeson and I'm here to talk about the fiscal stabilization plan involving cutting ties with outside agencies that serve special education interests so I'm a SE teacher one of a few in um the district which stands for counseling enriched program uh we serve students

015who generally fall between the cracks in general education and in our classrooms we have a teacher a therapist and two instructional AIDS in my classroom I have a um District Aid and I have an outside aid from a different agency and um when I first started there was a massive shortage of District AIDS and unfortunately there still is so these AIDS are so important in the classroom they have such beautiful relationships with the students and I don't know how I would do my job without them but because of this shortage which I believe is because the district isn't paying its AIDS enough there is not a competitive pay uh for district AIDS it's about $9 versus 22 starting for contract AIDS um the the district Aid in my classroom couldn't make it because she's busy

016working her second job and can't be here to advocate for herself so please consider paying District AIDS more before cutting contract AIDS thank you so much thank you Patrick okay now we will move on to our reports um um California School Employees Association uh chapter 75 president Mary Helen Leman floor is yours good evening I want to thank all of our members that are here tonight please give yourself a round of applause good evening president Medina governing board superintendent Dr Morales student board member cabinet members and everyone here tonight and everyone listening online thank you to all of you who contributed to the public comment I want to express my gratitude to the classified staff teachers students and parents who came tonight to show the district We Care your presence confirms our shared commitment in

017making srcs the best it can be we are engaged empowered but not yet fully embraced we stand in full support of the resolution recognizing srcs as a state Safe Haven School District to provide a secure and welcoming environment for our students their families and our community to protect all against the threats of immigration enforcement and discrimination tonight's discussion action item F4 the 20242 first interim fiscal report is what we have been waiting for it includes a proposed positive certification the district has invited us back to the negotiating table this Friday Friday the 13th we hope it will be a better day than what Superstition suggests we deserve an equal compensation package that aligns with what others have already received we urge the board to prioritize fair and Equitable compensation for our classified employees Who Remain

018the backbone of this District their hard work and dedication deserve recognition and yet they are still waiting in closing I ask the board to lead with transparency accountability and empathy while the road ahead will not be easy it is essential that we move forward together ensuring every member of our district is engaged empowered and embraced with courage and compassion thank you thank you next we have our Senator Teachers Association report uh president how floor is yours good evening president Medina uh superintendent Morales members of the board members of the public I am Katherine Howell president of the Santa Rosa Teachers Association I represent about 900 teachers in Santa Rosa city schools um I'm going to start by saying once again SRTA is 100% behind cssea and their bargain thank you president Layman for your words

019I'm going to say something thing that I don't think you need just equality you need more you need a bigger race than the teachers SC in my opinion because you are so underpaid your percentage should be higher than what we got and the these CA workers are indeed the backbone of this District the teachers cannot do their jobs without them we cannot have schools without our CCA members and we need need to collectively recognize them embrace them and pay them what they're worth um I'll move on to the next topic that I'm sure we will hear quite a bit more about in a few minutes and that's School closure and consolidation it's on the top of everyone's Minds we've been heared about I've been hearing about it for months I'm sure the board has gotten

020hundreds if not thousands of comments from community members uh it's not going to end anytime soon and uh frankly will hurt this community for years uh absolutely um the number of people in the room the number of comments we haven't heard yet I think we are absolutely experiencing um chaos because there's not enough information the community the committee will be making recommendations with no guarantees or assurances of any kind that the board will follow them uh all the schools are still on the list with no ability to say oh yeah let's narrow it so let's keep the whole city in panic as long as we can right it's horrible um there's so many rumors out there because there's no concrete information out there and that needs to be something that maybe we can deal with

021it also is uh I think important to point out that with this first inim coming out uh the district got more money than they anticipated yay revenue is up but oh guess what so are expenditures in a year when we knew way back in August when the committee started that school closures and con consolidation was on the table somehow we get here to December 11th with uh $7 million more in spending shocking right how can we expect these school closures to do anything if we can't even control our spending in a year when we know we shouldn't be spending money we have studies from Oakland from Chicago from Washington DC that shows that school closures don't necessarily save money in every instance the school districts have discovered at least a 20% difference between what they

022anticipated send saving and what they actually saved so school closures don't necessarily save money we know that school closures are bad for students they're bad for communities they're bad for families they're bad for our students it's a negative impact on academics there's a negative impact on behavior and there's a negative impact on attendance we also have no guarantee that all of the students that are currently attending one of our schools that will be closed will stay in Santa Rosa schools we have no way of predicting the attrition and we might be right back here again because we have lost so many students that the closure of our schools made no difference I'm going to ask some questions why why are we spending more money than budgeted on Consultants why are we spending more money than

023budgeted on outside agencies why are we spending more money than budgeted on administrator salaries why is the district spending a million more dollars on administrator salaries than they budgeted for where did that million dollars come from why is a district projecting 13 million more dollars in spending than budgeted for why are you still planning to spend $96 million out of a bond that only covers a third of the improvements needed to our school sites why would you consider spending that even a dime of that money on a new district office when we're going to have empty schools I'll wrap this up I'm going to ask the board SRTA is asking the board to please investigate seriously some sort of retirement incentive SRT is expecting the bulk of the layoffs to hit teachers because the savings

024predicted in school closures already includes administrators and CSEA so the extra $8 million in layoffs we're expecting it to come from the educators of this District retirement incentive let's look into it do some serious mathing and figure it out right in the last few days s San Francisco announced a retirement incentive for their District that is struggling maybe it won't be a savings in one year but it might be a savings in two or three years we know that the top 81% of our teachers make about $9 million just in salary not even including the uh driven costs of pension and health insurance and the bottom 250 make about $18 million so our top 81 members cost about the same as two or two and a half of our lowest paid members so let's look

025at a retirement incentive let's keep our young teachers in their positions and let's help those that want to retire Let's help a few people out with a little bit of a pat on the back and a thank you and let's try to keep our district as healthy as we can thank you thank you president how and we now move on to our superintendent's report uh superintendent Dr Daisy Morales hi everyone and welcome tonight um well I have been responding the bulk of my time has been responding to emails about school consolidations and closure and I know a lots of comments are coming for that item and I'll wait till um our um associate superintendent is giving that report um it's going to be a hard time for all of us and we're really are committed

026to making it that the most compassionate empathetic that we can as we go through these challenging times and that's the message that I've been sharing with everyone that has been emailing us or the board has sent me their emails um last week during the conference I had the opportunity to sit at a table with one of the board members from the Alam Rock School District in San Jose who's very similar to us in demographics and number of schools and number of students also in the number of deficit that they have to reduce and so she was able to give us give me some pointers in terms of what they did so we're going to be collaborating with them so that we could learn you know follow kind of the process that they have done that

027has been successful so we continue to learn and I want you to know everybody know that we will be doing five town hall meetings in the month of January in the next couple of days RPO will be sending out a flyer with the dates and the locations so that the community can continue to give us input before the Board of Trustees makes any any final um decisions so I encourage and invite everyone to attend those thank you superintendent Morales um looks like it's my turn um first uh I I'd just like to start off by saying we're we're towards the end of the semester um I see there's a lot of like student performances when a performance is happening say make sure to head out and check them out see the amazing work that our

028students do um they put a lot of time and effort um to creating Beauty for for us and um it's it's why we're here we're here for our students you know I'm wishing that everybody um enjoys this time that we have I I must admit that lately I've I've been having a lot of trouble sleeping we we have very difficult decisions ahead and it's it's ultimately the ones that are going to be impacted most and struggle the most is going to be our students I mean that's why you all are here why we're here it's about our students and it's not easy it's not going to be pretty um it is unfortunate there's a lot of misinformation out there um and and it's causing a lot of chaos and fear amongst people and but I

029I'm glad that people want to fight for their schools it's important I agree with with President how um there's a lot of questions that I know we as board members uh want to see answered um I I know that building a a new uh district office doesn't make sense now and we shouldn't um until we see um what happens with school closures I think the the one thing that I I don't see any benefit from closing schools aside for money and I would love to see alternative Solutions but there's very little time in terms of what we got to do and that's and that's one of the big struggles we face I I don't want to be in this place and I know nobody here wants to be in this situation but it's where we're

030at right now and if people have alternative Solutions I know we'd love to hear them um so I'll leave it at that and I'll open up for other board members for reports um trust Lor thank you president Medina there's a lot that could be said there's a lot that should be said um ultimately I'd like to address the room I'd like to address everyone that's made it here tonight I'd like to address everyone that's watching us on Zoom this evening and following this very difficult path that we are on I ask that you be in this room with respect and civility understanding the immense pressure and Trauma that we're about to embark on now is not a time for pitchforks and torches now is a time for engagement and understanding I am glad that you're

031all here I glad that you're all paying attention whether you found out about this 7 months ago when we started talking about it or 2 weeks ago when you got a flyer in your mailbox I am glad you are here I am glad it is on your radar I invite Community leaders to spread facts and not myths and rumors about what may happen ultimately we do not yet know any named schools that could be closed or Consolidated all 24 campuses are going through a matrix for data purposes to see what those savings could or would not look like so do not assume your campus is being closed because your neighbor Told You So if you are this involved if you are this engaged I invite you to contact your neighborhood school and see what they

032need connect with the parent organizations connect with the sports boosters connect with the Arts programs and the music programs attend the performances attend the games donate your time if you have funds donate funds chaperon be involved in your students and children's lives there's a lot of energy in this room right now and it doesn't all feel like cupcakes and rainbows so I invite you to indulge me please the younger generation all knows how to hard reset their new iPhone the older generation was told by it to turn it off and reboot it and see if it restarts we have this beautiful unique mechanism in the human body that if we take three deep breaths we can actually recalibrate ourselves and give ourselves the energy and the composure to be in the moment and share the

033messages that we want to share to share those messages with anger and vile and hate will fall on deaf ears so please collectively silently as the room close your eyes leave your eyes open whatever feels best take a deep breath in exhale breathe in and feel that breath inhale all the way into the core of our bodies down to our diaphragms exhale and respect yourself enough to do this last one properly take a deep breath in feel it bring in the moment bring in the opportunities and exhale and breathe out we are here to listen we are here to answer questions we have answers to and questions we don't have answers to the greatest tool in our till belt is to make sure those questions get to the appropriate people that can answer them enough

034with the myths and rumors enough with the fear-mongering collaborate as a community let's work together and let's get through this very painful time and decisions that none of us want to make but we are put in these positions to make those decisions it is not my vote it is not my opinion it's the vote of my constituents that put me here to make the best best choices possible to provide opportunities for all of our students teachers and staff thank you trusty Lor other board members reports I'll go trusty MCN then the Cruz hi everyone I just want to give a quick report on the csba conference um I was one of the board members that attended and I know there was some some questioning of why we were spending money on that and honestly I

035I don't know whether that was the best use of those funds but I do want to be transparent and just let you all know um what I learned and what my activities were at the conference um so I attended sessions on school safety um which focused a lot on Partnerships with law enforcement and fire so I learned a lot about that and got to hear from other school districts who have similar issues to what we have I also attended a session on closures and consolidation um and learned about the proper procedure for that which seemed to align perfectly with what we are following here we are following the procedure that is recommended by the state and that other districts are following um and something that did come up was really the importance when those decisions

036are made of how that trans transition is going to happen and how the receiving schools are going to welcome those students so when we get to that point um I hope to work with superintendent Morales on making sure that that happens that's done well um I also attended sessions on uh superintendent evaluations which is a key part of the board's job and on the cost of conflict and the importance of getting along as a board and as a school district um so that's something that I've been reflecting on a lot and I'm glad that during the conference I was able to spend time with superintendent Morales with um Dr xans and with two of our incoming board members this district is going through a lot of change um welcoming a new superintendent earlier this year

037and welcoming three new board members next week um so I think it's really important that we be we get to know each other and that we make sure this transition that we continue to get along and solve problems and not create more problems um so yeah I just wanted to let you all know what what I learned what I was doing at that conference and why we were there thank you J mnal to La Cruz um hello and good evening Beloved Community thank you trusty de for starting out with making sure that we're all on the same page and informed and aware of where we are in this process of school closures um we haven't had a regular board meeting in quite some time so I just wanted to share some love to the Santa

038Rosa high school art Quest theater program um it was really beautiful to go to the cinear theater um and to celebrate you know the work of kids telling stories about their lives um that we need to hear and listen to in a good way um and just with so much gratitude for your work thank you arquest students um this board I'm really proud of the way that we are continuing to work together as a board and an Administration to make sure that the decisions that we make about how we roll out and approve um Student Art throughout our district um is really thoughtful and caring and responsive to the concerns that we heard but also to um really uplift and respect the work of student artists so thank you I see you back there yay

039art Quest um and then just sending lots of love to kids who are right in the middle of that week and going into finals so adante see SE weather thank you TR L any other board member reports uh trusty Manti thank you president Medina um I came prepared to share some upcoming concerts um for folks to attend we have a really busy week this week across our high schools with all sorts of performances and um as trusty the mentioned being involved and engaged um and showing up for our students is is one of the best things that we can do right now and that really requires us to to go and to show up and so I just wanted to make sure everyone knows what's going on in our dis in our across our high

040schools with regard to concert and performances um tomorrow at 700 p.m. Piner High School is performing their Winter concert in collaboration with Comstock middle school and so that'll start at 700 p.m. for those who can attend on Friday at 7 p.m Elie Allen will be having their Winter Music concert um they will have the drum line performing Bal folclorico Maria Loos and the band and color guard will also be performing again at 700 p.m. on Friday and Maria CIO high school has their Winter's Night choir concert both tomorrow and Friday at 7 p.m and um they will be bringing their treble choir base choir chamber singers the back row and The Nightingales that also starts at 7 pm both nights um and similarly yeah and similarly Santa Rosa High School's art Quest vocal choir is

041having their Winter concert uh tomorrow and Friday at 7 p.m. um um and I understand that they'll have a special performance with former uh santaa High School Coral director Dan Earl uh directing a really beautiful performance with alumni from from the choir so that sounds like it'll be a really special performance I hope that um we can all show up to one of these performances I know I'll be going to one um and again this is one of the best things that we can do for our community right now thank you thank you justy Manti um justy lauz sorry I got all excited about art Quest theater and I forgot to mention art Quest band at Santa Rosa High School um it has a historic opportunity to um play in Carnegie Hall at New York

042and in New York and specifically to play a piece of music that was written for this band um so they are debuting the first ever um performance of this piece of music and the band has crashed into um a really hard wall of fundraising efforts and bureaucratic challenges and so um this is a it's a historic opportunity for this anosa High School band um and I would just love to ask every single member in this room and of our community to dig deep and find ways to make sure that our kids get to play on um worldclass stages um and Mark you know just such critical moments in their career as artists um so we'll continue to uh update you about best ways to um contribute and to support this historic moment for our district

043and our kids any other board member reports I'm sorry any other board member reports okay see then we'll move on to a student trustee your report thank you for all the updates go Center's High School band um so I'd like to raise the questions um these questions for students regarding um recognizing sers of City Schools district as a safe haven um what can we do to follow up with this commitment as students and as members of the community um how can we as a community and as students work towards protecting our students and their families from threats of new um administrations I encourage students to participate in this discussion um and Advocate because this is what's happening right now is going to directly affect us um speak with your superintendent student council board Representatives um

044and ask them to bring your concerns to the next meeting so we can have so we can take organized action um last week I attended the csba conference in Anaheim with the rest of the board um and I Reed training um that I can use to help aid this process and be the best Lea on possible for student voices um I learned about the essential rules and responsibilities of each um team in the district um I received training on how to better myself um and be more pres in present and engaged in these meetings um I was briefed on the lcap and its connection to the dashboard and I encourage you guys to go and check out the dashboard it's an amazing um way that we can see how we're doing it as a district

045and what we need to do to improve um I was also trained on bettering my ability to show up um as a representative to all students and their voices um and how to organize student voice and get that input their input on policy um so lots of Big Dreams and lots of ideas are popping into my head so I encourage you guys to um organize with me thank you so much thank you trusty uh next we'll move on to our school consolidation closure report um superintendent leis August thank you president Medina Dr Morales members of our excuse me srcs board and our Santa Rosa Community uh just want to give an overview there were links included just for reference if anyone is interested in looking at our web page that's Now new and improved and

046and um has our FAQs that we are continuing update on there um we just conclud concluded our elcap budget Road Show presentations uh those are our annual presentations where we go out and provide information and this year we also included information about our fiscal stabilization committee work as well as our school closure consolidation advisory committee work uh the next um SCA or School consolidation advisory committee meeting will be held on Monday December 16th at 5:30 in the Student Union at Montgomery High School our recent uh information events have been well attended and we wanted to provide a larger space um for more public attendance going forward for these meetings just as board meetings these are brown act meetings which are held in public but they are not with the public this essentially means that the

047business of the committee is conducted in public and the public has a right to comment within the prescribed times on subjects under the purview of the committee it's not a Q&A session and so I want to make that clear because I know that that can be frustrating for attendees if they think that they're going to come and receive if it's an interactive process um we are adding an information item to the end of that agenda for correspondents um I've had many members of the public who have sent written correspondents and so we want to make sure that the committee has an opportunity to see that so those will be attached um the next committee meeting will focus us on the analysis of the information presented at earlier meetings this will be more of a workshop

048than a presentation and staff will be available to clarify information for the committee members we are asking the committee to identify three Elementary one middle and one high school for recommended closure the committee will also be asked to rank at least five elementary and each middle and high school so that when that information comes to the board there's some in some choice in what they recommend as far as some ideas of how they got to that um to those recommendations we are scheduling Town Hall meetings as Dr Morales mentioned in January and that those will be specifically focused on school closure and consolidation and the potential to reimagine our schools right now we are spreading our resources so thin across so many sites that we are not providing as focused an effort or as Rich

049of individual programs as we could be by consolidating th those programs and sites uh the timeline so we do have ongoing planning um which for us on the back end because we don't have what you know that narrowed down Choice yet that that looks like 90 scenarios for elementary schools possible combinations and dozens of potential middle and high school combinations so that's the work that our team is doing on the back end so that we can when that recommendation and information comes to the board it's as complete as possible um it will have recommended or some options for boundaries all of that information um so as not to have to delay uh information for families after decisions are made on the December um 16th Workshop style meeting for analysis and potential spendid do exercise so

050the intention is that by the end of that meeting we will be very close to the final list of recommendations and it may come down to really having almost like a I don't know a lot of people have used the spendid dot um activities where you're given so many dots dots and you have to choose where those are going to go it's really hard to get 20 people to come to consensus on especially some really difficult recommendations the January Town Halls um will conclude prior to the last school consolidation advisory committee meeting so that that information can be provided to them as well as to the board the January 27th uh will also be a work workshop style meeting is what we expect to finalize recommendations and writing of the report the potential special board

051meeting um we would like it'll come to you for Action at another time we are looking for on February 5th for for presentation of the report recommendations and the public hearing hearing then a potential special board meeting hopefully February 19th for board action and after that would be announcements to the community regarding those actions so it it is a very difficult timeline these recommendations and the ultimate decision by the board are not easy it is hard for our community and we understand that we are all going to be going through that grieving process which understandably includes anger and deny and it's painful and so I am sorry that that is the process that that we need to go to go through but in the long term we are looking towards fiscal stability and being able

052to offer richer programs in the future thank you and I do have a significant amount of public comment cards on this item so I'm going to get to public comment um again folks uh you have uh 90 seconds to comment I'm going to call out three names at a time when to call out your name please go to one of the podiums um and we'll start off with Abigail Mel followed by am Amy Merkel followed by Erica lainovic Abigail orle hello my name is Abigail Merkel and I'm a sophomore attending Montgomery not only is Monty's history so rich but its future is so right Monte has been through many ups and downs especially after the tragedy of spring 2023 if a death of a student were to take place at a different High School do

053you think your reaction would have been the same no it wouldn't have no other school would have been to able to come together and support each other in the toughest times because the people at Montgomery are what make Monty Monty closing Monty would be separating our community a community where so many have worked so tirelessly to build a support system a community where so many have come together to celebrate our similarities and differences a community that thrives with social economic ethnic and academic diversity after all the loss that Monty has faced we have gained so much we have gained something that's more than a St statistic used to decide if a school should stay or go will ever be after constantly being inspected by the Press fighting to be heard and trying to defend the

054rumors and reputation put on Monty we have never let go what separates us from the rest our power is in our people and will continue to shine through the many more obstacles we will go through Monty has proven its strength through its overpopulating clubs such as fresh start bring change to mind best buddies BSU metcha and many more they all focus on up uplifting each other our sporting teams have become a family to athletes courses and extracurriculars such as band drama ASB earbook choir all add up to the bigger picture of Monty School is a place of learning but it's also a place of growth Monty has grown endlessly over the past couple of years that have been brought together by Community I can learn anywhere but can I grow anywhere not just as a

055student but as a person Monty's Community challenges us to than you Abigail your time's up next I have Amy Merkel followed by Erica lainovic followed by Karen s Amy I'm here to highlight a few unique features of Montgomery High School demographic makeup is most aligned with the overall district with 48% of the student body being unduplicated 42% are from a socioeconomic disadvantaged background if you paid your property taxes this week you saw that there were three bonds for the Santa Rosa height district one from 02 14 and 20 22 measure C part of the 2022 bond is the money that is being used to pay for the new building at Montgomery which is designated four students with 17 classrooms and two science labs then our national baloria program has been at Monty for 29 years

056it's the only IB High School in somoma Marin and Napa counties next year it will launch the IB schoolwide initiative where every Junior and senior will take an IB class there are 40 te teachers at Monty who are trained the IB curriculum if IB were moved to another site it would have to go through the IB approval process which is similar to wasque and it would cost about $2,500 to train any new student for the program student engagement is really high and when students feel connected to their school they are more likely to succeed according to the school performance overview Monty is the only High School in the green for graduation rates in the district almost 25% of the student body participated in a fall or winter Sport and there are are seven more coming

057in the spring there are 34 clubs at Monty with an estimated 40 400 students participating in best buddies Eco vites the Asian Culture Club and stem these are all unique features that need to be thank you your time is up next I have Erica lainovic followed by Karen s followed by Meg Peterson Erica thank you esteemed board at the last meeting I spoke about the consolidation committee decision to remove the academic Criterion from um regarding academic performance please allow me the opportunity to explain to you why this decision personally affected me so deeply I come from immigrant parents my mother's family was from Mexico my father was born in Guatemala his earliest memories were living with his mom a single woman who could barely afford a small one room home with a dirt floor and

058a straw roof despite the odds my grandmother moved with her son to the United States with the hopes that she could provide him a better life it as a single mother with no more than a sixth grade education her opportunities for employment were limited to cleaning hotels cleaning homes so she understood that education was the way to lift her family up it was for this reason that she stressed the importance of prioritizing her son's academics it was his emphasis on academics that saved him from The Gangs of Los Angeles and enabled him to be the first person in his family to graduate from high school then college and then medical school I understand that test scores don't show the full story and the decision was made specifically to benefit the disadvantaged communities of Santa Rosa

059but when the committee voted to remove this criteria it felt like they were saying academics are a luxury that only the privileged and affluent communities of Santa Rosa can afford and that disadvantaged communities would rather see their failing schools stay open then move to another school thank you your time is left next I [Music] have Karen Karen s followed by Meg Peterson followed by Hannah Morel Karen Karen s if you could State your full name for the record please I'm sorry if you could State your full name for the record oh Karen Sanders thank you here are key points from attorney general bont's memo that the school consolidation advis committee is choosing to ignore by arbitrarily eliminating the academics criteria from their process quote studies show that schools chosen for closure are sometimes not the

060lowest performing schools but that students only benefit from school closures if they are reassigned to higher performing schools higher quality schools are often in high demand over enrolled and or not accessible to students from dis displace schools so students in a closing school do not benefit to improve Equitable educational opportunities and abide by the legal mandate to alleviate segregation all districts should proactively plan for displaced students to access higher quality educational opportunities Priority Access should be thoughtfully designed to give students a realistic chance of enrolling in known highquality and college preparatory schools in closing AG bont States a transparent and Community centered process can help ensure an end result that reflects the community's interests eliminating academics is not in the community's interests thank you thank you Karen next next I have Meg Peterson followed by

061Hannah Mor followed by Noel Tama Meg thank you uh thank you for your time last time I spoke I spoke about being an interdistrict transfer family who benefited from the Open Enrollment provided by Santa Rosa city schools this is unique to Santa Rosa city schools and helps provide Equity to families who do live in lower socioeconomic parts of our town to be able to attend schools in other neighborhoods should we see that it feel fits the needs of our students the past several weeks have allowed me to dig more into the um data provided to your school consolidation committee and at pass board meetings something that was glaring to me was the lack of looking into retention rates and attraction for transfer students how can you equitably say that closing a elementary school that has

062a 72% retention rate of neighborhood kids which is the highest out of all of your elementary schools is and also attracts the most transfer students is more Equitable than closing a school an elementary school that only retains 55% of its neighborhood students and accounts for the largest part of students transferring out of that neighborhood School likewise at a middle school that has 98% retention rates and accounts for over 50% of Middle School transfer students or a high school that has 98% retention rates and accounts for so many open enrollment requests you can't even thank you next I have Hannah Morel followed by Noel Tamba followed by David Shen Hannah hi I'm Hannah morio and I'm here to speak about the school that I went to um I currently live in rinken Valley and I graduated

063from ELC Allen High School uh I'd like to take us back you might remember this Omar Medina to November 1994 only a few months after LC Ellen opened you can go online and search for a press Democrat article which has a quote about students getting to our school paraphrased here you either tromp through the mud and get muddy or walk in the street and hope the cars don't hit you four years later in December 1998 an Els Allen student was struck by a motorist he was walking home after school in the dark after it rained trying to stay out of the mud that student died from that Collision this is something that is very familiar to a lot of people in the southwest the community is that we are overlooked and don't have basic infrastructure

064basic care basic funding it's hard to hear a huge section of the city talk about how they will be impacted losing the valuable enrichment programs they have when you are a student who doesn't have a safe way to walk to school our parents went out and put pallets in the mud so that we could walk safely thank you thank you thank you Hannah and that student's name was Patrick Scott um next we have Noel Tamba David Shen and Sarah DRC Noel Tamba I'm right here go ahead um I would like to respectfully request that the board in a closed session with legal council presentent agendize and review all potential and actual conflicts of interest for the current and new trustees in relation to the closure of schools has come to my attention there's an inherent

065conflict of interest that should give rise to the refusal of at least one trustee president Medina is employed by LC Allen Foundation as a full-time employee and he's the only full-time employee of the entity the LC Allen Foundation is an independent nonprofit but it is directly tied to LC Allen High School thereby creating an inherent conflict of interest for president Medina this employment directly impacts his ability to make an impartial decision related to closure of schools when the result and the decision has the ability to directly impact his personal employment president Medina should have no choice but to recuse himself from the vote as well as all commentary and discussions in the choice of schools that will be forced to close due to this fiscal crisis failure to do so would result in the potential

066for legal action against the board and S City schools in navigating this already difficult process adding both to the cost and creating new unnecessary uncertainty for students and families of the district there is potentially other trustees that also will have conflicts having legal council presid present and doing this in a closed session with this advice of council should be done and completed as soon as possible thank you and just for transparency all out our legal council is already looking into my situation David Shen followed by Sarah drill followed by Diego [Music] are oh there go um David good evening Mr President trustees and the superintendent Dr oralis our community is facing a very difficult and challenging times and because of the mismanagement of the previous or the existing admin and the board members we are

067now facing a 20 or even $25 million budget deficit something went wrong terribly because you had not listen to the community have their inputs now when we facing the difficult time to determine which schools to close the most important criteria is to be to be evaluated is the 25 however you choose to ignore the three academic related criterias that's wrong do not make another mistake put in it back thank you thank you David next I have Sarah next I have Sarah drill followed by Diego aruo followed by laara fry Sarah hi my name is Sarah Derick good evening members of the board and Santa Rosa city schools I went to the elcap meeting at Piner on the 4th and I asked some questions because I'm concerned that the board can't make informed Decisions by ignoring

068facts I asked if I asked how the school consolidation advisory committee was formed and how to get information on that I asked if I could move forward with the assumption that all areas from our school district were equally represented in this committee and I was told no I asked how to get more information about that and I was told that I could file a public records act request and I have done that I have not received a response I think you have nine days I think you can ask for an extension um I'm wondering if anybody in the room would also like access to that information once I get it I'm also concerned about your decision to cut funds from special education your district is historically not compliant with special education needs you are currently

069under investigation from the Department of Education Office of civil rights and that costs our district a lot of money so I will be making another record thank you your time is up thank you next I have Diego anduo followed by Laura fry followed by Brianna L Diego the fact that we even have to discuss school closures is honestly just a travesty in itself I see many faces many faces that I know and many faces I don't know but I mostly see school spirit from Maria gillo to Elsie SRS pretty much every single School in the district they afraid that their Futures at the future for their siblings their friends and all that will get ruined they'll be destroyed the the fact is that we even that we have to even discuss this honestly makes your

070credibility as board members even lower the community has lost faith in you they have lost all credibility of your actions and all that for them you are liars you are liars and it it breaks my heart that that's even though I'm going to graduate this year see many of my friends and all the other people that are showing up here fearing that their school might have to be closed is honestly just sad it breaks my heart it breaks my heart especially I have a sibling who's in who is a sophomore and knowing that if my school gets closed it'll be harder for her to get an education think about that when you go to bed tonight think about your action to think about the many people you are hurting thank you thank you Diego next

071I have Laura fry followed by bana L followed by uh miy Parker Laura hi my name is Laura fry I have two students at koreo and I'm here to ask the board to keep all the high schools open in our district the current 9th through 11th graders are the fourth fifth and sixth graders who lost a year and a half of normal school due to covid closures they're the kids who are woken up in the middle of the night to evacuate for wildfires let's not add another trauma to the list everybody knows you don't make a major change when your kids in high school because the mental health risks are too high not to mention the acad mic and professional ones and I'm not just talking about getting into college I'm talking about the kids

072who need to be ready to work a full-time job upon graduation I understand there's a sentiment that certain student bodies may be better able to handle a high school closure than others but the truth is the negative risk is equal to all the New York Times published an article this past July about the negative impacts of multiple moves in childhood and long-term depression into adulthood and I'm going to make the argument that Clos a high school in the middle of your high school career is equal to the impact of a move and the most surprising thing about this study was not that it led to depression but that it didn't matter the socioeconomic status of the kids impacted in fact the author of the study stated in the article even if you come from a

073rich neighborhood your chances of depression are higher than if you hadn't moved at all and had come from the poorest neighborhood let's do right by our high schoolers at the very least let's honor the current 9th through 11th graders let them them finish out their High School career and please at the very least book to a closure thank you your time is up next I have bana L Brian L followed by Micky Parker followed by dul Rodriguez Briana hi my name is L and I'm currently a senior at LSC Allen and even though I won't be there next year I wanted to Advocate on his behalf I think ELC Allen is a commun is a community I began LC Allen and but I transferred from C Roa High LC has woken me with open arms

074even though I didn't have friends at the time I felt safed and cared by the staff I was able to find a support system and I wasn't that I wasn't able to find at other schools where culture is an afterthought at other schools and it's the center of Elie's Mission this is an apparent in the art around C campus school events and special programs being at LC island has given me the opportunity to be part of the counseling image program that has supported me in my path to graduation I couldn't have done it without them this program along with the ESN program are not considered in criteria being by the consolation committee committee even though it would be traumatic for these students to move schools overall I'm ex extremely grateful and proud to attend LC

075and I hope you all take into special programs like e c that future Generations have an opportunity to be a part of them thank you Briana next I have Mickey Parker followed by Dulce Rodriguez followed by Michelle Crosby Mickey miy Parker okay if not we'll move on to Dulce Rodriguez dul here all right then we got Michelle Crosby followed by Jeff gosby followed by Dirk Shermer Michelle my name is Michelle Crosby and I'm here to support San Rosa high school I'm a proud alumni class of 1996 who went to the JC and graduated from San Diego State I have a current Junior daughter in our Coast dance program I fear that the district will not be able to cover the deficit because the savings from closing the school will be diminished by families and students

076leaving the district it's already starting families chose middle schools with a path to a high school and with all the uncertainty in our community right now now families are choosing to leave the district now and establish their place in another District you'll lose more families and students if you close any of the five high schools my prediction is at least 50% of families will leave the district this is not factored into any of the charts or analysis happening with the committee I implore the board to consider other scenarios keep the high schools open consider establishing K to8 schools or even consider a K to 12 school exploring the development of an online school meeting the students where they are when they don't want a traditional class from experience it feels as though the state recommended

077best practices is just the cookie cutter approach declining enrollment started 10 years ago and unfortunately the tough conversations were not happening and instead of rightsizing the district over the last 10 years you are now faced with a bigger problem that is going to Gravely impact our community SOS high is so much more than what the charts present and the data you see you have strong programs agriculture Career Technical programs the art Quest program to close or try to move any of these programs would fracture the foundation that has contributed and developed so many students who go to pursue than you time is that next I have Jeff Jeff gosby followed by Dirk Shermer followed by Camila Salazar Jeff yeah my name is Jeff gosby and I'm a lifelong resident of the district in Santa Rosa

078and all three of my children went through district schools um these comments reflect my opinion alone and are not reflective of my term as a member of the rinken Valley school board or the seven years I've been on the budget advisory committee you must take decisive action to make deep Cuts because if you don't in a year or two the state will take over and decisions will be outside our local control made by Outsiders based mainly on math you must also make the leap to operating with a minimum 10% Reserve to have more capacity to handle crises in the future I guarantee you there will be more crises while making major ongoing cuts that start for the next school year I want to encourage the incoming board to make decisions based on a long-term Vision

079grounded in what's best educationally for students I strongly encourage you to reach out to neighboring districts to find long-term educational solutions for the community of Santa Rose as a whole as an example uh when consolidating schools you should seriously consider EXP expanding our middle schools to grades six seven and eight this better corresponds to educational curriculum and the social emotional needs of kids and you use available capacity your middle school and no longer turning over half their uh student body every year you can't do this alone and it can't be done by feeder districts on their own we did this in rinken Valley five years ago until you have a je your time is up thank you Jeff your time is up next I have dick Shermer followed by Camila Salazar followed by Adena Flores

080erk Shermer hi uh Dirk Shermer for the record uh my wife and I grew up in Santa Rosa when a large reorganizing of the boundaries instituted siblings were split up between high schools at different sides of town student and peer groups were disrupted Transportation was lacking for Working Families these peer groups are vital for student and parenting success I would ask as opposed to when Jeff was suggesting consider closing all the middle schools we could then repopulate the elementary schools in all elementary districts with seventh graders and repopulate the high schools with eighth graders this would keep peer groups and families together and preserve all the important specialty programs which seem to be mostly located at the elementary campuses this would be an equitable equitable distribution of a little bit of pain to everybody and

081not devastating to one particular part of our community it would most importantly preserve the social Equity programs already in place in many of the schools the Junior High s sites could be sold and the assets would then provide an important source of reserves and funding for the organization uh redistricting itself and for better programs moving forward thank you next I have cila Salazar followed by Aden Flores followed by Katherine R out uh Camila my name is cila Salazar and I'm a former cheerleader at Maria Cel high school and current cheer coach I'm here with a statement from current cheerleaders at the high school the Maria Caro High School cheerleading team is deeply saddened and concerned by the potential closure of our school this decision would not only impact the futures of students who depend on

082its programs but would also dismantle a cheerleading program that is truly one-of aind in our district mariao cheerleading is unlike any other program in the area our team consistently performs and an advanced level of difficulty setting us apart from other local teams however the true value of our program lines in the bonds we create and the impact it has on its members for many of us tree leading provides a sense of purpose structure and motivation that keeps us focused on our goals it has helped team M team members develop essential life skills overcome personal challenges and form lasting connections that extend far beyond the gym what makes this even more remarkable is how much the program has grown in such a short of amount of time the cheer program at Korea has only been operating

083at this advanced and competitive level level for 3 years and in that time it has become a space where girls can learn grow and Achieve to stunt its growth now would be a disservice if this level of success has been achieved in just 3 years imagine what we could accomplish with more time more than just an activity cheerleading at Maria Kio is a Launchpad for the future it has opened doors for higher for higher education that were never imagined to be possible for these girls thank you thank you next I have Adina Flores followed by Katherine row followed by uh chinu Adina good evening uh I am the former executive assistant to this board who just won my settlement so I'd like you to understand why these decisions are me being made the reason that

084we're closing schools is due to a lack of enrollment which leads to also a lack of funding that being said I would hate to see Elie Allen closed I just attended a tribal council Mee meeting and the Native Americans are extremely upset when we preach Equity that we're going to be closing a school that represents our bipo students primarily uh that's really upsetting we have a foundation LC Allen High School Foundation uh principal AB Vera does a phenomenal job however I have no idea where that funding is going that could go towards keeping that school open or helping in some way um Mr Medina as you admitted at a previous meeting you're still under investigation with the state the the foundation received $2 million and why are students coming to me to tell me they

085never got their scholarship money where is it going uh and secondly I've had several at least four whistleblowers come forward to me from Child Nutrition services to state that they've been asking for equipment for their school sites that was denied and actually legally required uh pertaining to keeping food fresh and having it not be expired before we serve it to the students so why are they being denied equipment keep to disclosure schools were going to be use why are you cutting my mic use the commission as a scapegoat thank you and God bless thank you uh next I have Katherine row Katherine row followed by Shinu shinzu followed by Shi Wang Catherine hi I'm Katherine R out at the last board meeting some of the members cited the californ attorney general's guidelines as reasons to

086exclude academics from consideration their decision for school closures another public comment quoted the Attorney General's guidance and educational code uh which by the way is on page four paragraph two um that shows the statement was inaccurate I would like to add uh data over the last decade shows school closures regardless of which are closed impact student performance uh this is an absenteeism which should be in particular importance to you since that's tied to fund um it also increases disciplinary action of students in the following three years um uh they're less likely to attend college 5% less likely to attend college complete College 1.3% less likely to be employed had incomes 3.7% lower these are all kids who went through school closures that's their outcomes minority and lower socioeconomic status students see this more but there

087is an evidence-based way to prevent it and that is to uh close middle schools instead I would like to point out no one in any of the board meeting has been like save my middle school everyone loves our elementary schools everyone loves our high schools right but there's been a number of case examples and actual empiric evidence that shows if you go to a k to8 and then 9 through 12 or K to6 and then 7 through 12 model that's actually better for students there's lots of data to show Middle School um has failed as an experiment than you next I have shinsu followed by Shi Wang followed by I think it's Wai Shi shinsu yeah my name is ch um good evening U I appreciate the leaders and the board members that you show

088that you cares and one of the board member L the inhale and exhale practice I'm sorry that doesn't help because that doesn't solve any problem okay so I understand their emot there emotions here and in such time I urge you to remain rational and uphold the principles of fairness as you provide recommendation of Clos uh closure of the schools okay unfortunately I have noticed some significant issues with the EV evaluation criteria that you're using okay there are some clear mistakes for instance there's one criteria criteria number eight focus on the retrospective cost which is also called sunk cost which is irrelevant in future decision making okay focusing on sunk cost will likely lead to incorrect decisions and that's not the only one um in addition many criterias are related or even redundant okay so such

089as those on capacity and the facilities I hope you don't simply add them up that will make lead to a a a a wrong decision okay I feel more concerns when I learn that the Criterion on student academic performance were excluded no and there's no Criterion evaluating teaching quality you're not adding any of them this is unfair to the students and the families who want their children to receive a quality education and succeed academically okay so I hope the Board of Education can find a better way to save operating cost thank you your time is up next I have sh Wang followed by W she followed by Christen leely sh you hello my name is Shang thank you for having me um I want to talk about our concern about the uh uh criteria of

090uh the school closure since this is a so important decision I believe we should have a complete and balanced criteria um if we don't have that as as mentioned all the education quality and academic performance criter uh criteria were selectively explicitly uh removed from the uh scoring Matrix I don't understand I don't agree I think that's very import very important because that could lead to a very unfortunate situation that is after the school closures we will lose our competitive of the district we don't want to lose students to other districts but to be honest they if close the best school especially the high school in this in the town there will be many many students leaving the district my family will definitely leave I told to about 10 families they will leave district for sure

091and they may leave the city that's that's also one thing for the city you are not making a decision for solving the budet issue but you are reshape the portfolio of Santa Rosa if this country this city doesn't have a good education resource many uh families will leave the city and and eventually that will impact the families that need help because there will be less job opportunities in the city that's a very big issue so please reconsider thank you next I have uh w a she W she followed by Christen LV followed by um let's see Brian Mills no okay Kristen levely my name is Kristen leely I am proud to be a Creo parent and an rvms parent and my daughter is a junior at Creo I have gotten to really enjoy being part

092of our music program there and we've had a lot of discussion about academic and I agree academics are incredibly important um and I would like you to know about our music program I feel like it we need to shine some light on it it is the Encore Visual and Performing Arts program and it really provides another uh wonderful diversity to our education it consists of 30 different fine arts classes ranging from instrumental music choir theater Dance Arts taught by seven faculty we have honors level and AP classes get this the estimated population of students that attend Encore is 900 students 56% of the population of our school it is the largest instrumental uh program in the North Bay as well as the largest um public Orchestra in the North Bay our Coral groups Jazz and

093honors wind for one to two decades have consistently earned the highest rating of all um the competitions so we are a very rich um program as far as talent and we recruit from all around the area we have the only Mar class thank you your time is up thank you next I have Brian Mills followed by maky Parker followed by I'm going to recall Rodriguez so Brian Mills yes good evening my name is Brian Mills I wanted to recite for the room and for the board straight from the California Board of Education the vision mission and goals of the California Board of Education Vision all California students of the 21st century will attain the highest level of academic knowledge applied learning and performance skills to ensure fulfilling personal lives and careers and contribute to Civic

094and economic progress Mission create strong effective schools that provide a wholesome learning environment through incentives that cause a high standard of student accomplishment as measured by a valid reliable accountability system goals standards adopt and support rigorous academic content performance standards in the four core subjects for kindergarten grades 1 through 12 achievement ensure that all students are performing at grade level or higher particularly in reading and math at the end of each school year recognize in a small number of exceptional needs of students must be expected challenged and assisted to achieve as individually determined and appropriate at that level assessment maintain policies ensuring that all students receive the same nationally normed and standard-based assessments grade 2 through 11 again to recognize that a small number of exceptional need students may be separately individually assessed it is

095within the mission statement and goals of the California Board of Education that standards be the top priority of the performance level of our schools you therefore cannot leave it out as an assessment criteria for if a school should be kept or not thank you thank you next I have uh Makey Parker are you here Makey Parker dul Rodriguez oh Parker maybe go ahead hi everyone my name is Makai Parker I am a part of the counseling enrichement program at L Island High School I've been attending L Island high school for 2 months and I've grown accustomed to this school as a new transfer student and I don't want to change schools already this school has been going well for me because I am part of the en counseling Arrangement program or c for sure this

096program has helped me get accustomed to the school LC Island this program has helped also helped me perform better in classrooms and in the school in general thank you the last call for dul Rodriguez and wayi either of you here what's your name okay and up here are you his teacher and I was going to speak on her behalf if that's okay go ahead okay um it's actually dolce's birthday tonight so just wanted to wish her a happy birthday she was here but had to leave early um this is her brief statement that I wanted to share I feel that since we are students we have a different perspective and we are fighting for the school board to acknowledge us our school's mental health is skyrocketing through the roof with nowhere for it to Land

097There are kids with depression anxiety ADHD Etc who are struggling to get through school every day and if the board closes Elsie Allen and our mental health our counseling enrich classes will be uprooted that help kids in need and make sure they are able to graduate I want to emphasize that there are two counseling enrich programs on the LC Allen campus um these classrooms serve students with trauma and severe emotional and behavioral needs um this is uh statistically the most marginalized demographic of students overall not just within the district but overall uprooting these classrooms and moving them would be traumatic specifically to these students um and I want to recognize that these two classrooms on LC's campus are not included in the criteria for special programs on um that the school consolidation committee is taking

098into consideration um and they definitely should be these are our most in need students and they should have special emphasis and be highlighted in these meetings which they are not thank you could you uh could you add your name for the record as well I said could you please also add your name for the record um my name is Mel de thank you thank you and I also got Linda Aguilar last card from Linda agil thank you good evening my name is Linda agular I don't have a prepared speech I graduated from Santa Rosa high school I'm a retired nurse graduating from San Rosa junior colleges School of Nursing I'm also blessed to be the granddaughter of Elsie Allen when she had her name submitted which none of my family knew it was an honor

099to have the first indigenous woman up against Luther Burbank Jack London and I don't remember the other gentleman it is such a heartwarming experience to see all the students here expressing their deep concern about their schools my concern is that we are all standing on Pomo land and it was a honor to have that school named after one of the master basket Weavers and I would advise most of the students that go there don't know the history of why my grandmother was chosen look Google her and she's the reason why culturally we have an exchange with our art through our baskets our family display is on the inter uh cultural museum at Santa R Junior College I would urge the board to look at Equity diversity and figure out what's happening with the money it's

100nothing new and may Creator bless us all during these chaotic times thank you and that is all the uh comments that is all the comments we have on this item um thank you uh Lisa um before we move on to uh our F discussion items I just wanted to um add um uh an event that was highlighted that was missed when when school performances were were being announced um Montgomery High School's drama production of Salvation Road uh it's the 12th 13th and 14th at 700 p.m. um and as well as their holiday concert which will be uh next Thursday December 19th at 7 p.m. at the cinema Academy Theater so now we will be moving on to our discussion and action items our first item is uh the approval of resolution recognizing C of City

101Schools as a safe haven school district and that comes up to me um so just a little background on this um um after uh well the Cur the current president elect in his first election uh back in 2016 after that there was a lot of Rh that really caused and created a lot of fear especially amongst our undocumented communities um this board back then um I think the only one that was here then is maybe frusty Sheffield um passed a resolution I believe it was uh January 11th of 2017 um calling for centeral City Schools to be a safe haven District we are now bringing back that resolution um to reaffirm our commitment to have Sena Rosa city schools be a safe haven district and adding some additional language to um ask our superintendent to

102make this policy and to ensure that our staff um are trained on on what to do in situations that arise that could impact our families and again to ensure that families feel safe coming to school to address the fear especially as the r rhetoric break around um the issue of immigration continues to get worse and cause fear amongst our families so I'll pass it on to our superintendent um for a comment um yes we are wholeheartly behind this resolution and I'm glad that um our Union Partners also mentioned it um I will be working with our cabinet team and our leadership team to put together protocols and procedures that um our principles could follow as well as our front office staff and I'll be working with the team to also turn it into a board

103policy that will appear um along with all of our policies online so that should be done um hopefully by the next board meeting oh I'll open it up to the board for any questions or comments trusta lacruz thank you so much for bringing this forward um I want to acknowledge the beautiful leadership that's in audience of folks who are really stepping up um on behalf of our immigrant Community students and families in our district and those voices are so loud and beautiful and scream with so much pride to be seen and to be recognized with dignity um throughout all of our systems so I'm grateful for that organizing and for that perspective that they have brought to leaders throughout our our community about the importance of making these kinds of statements but not just statements

104actual action um so I'm grateful that that this board resolution actually does more than just resolve that it actually turns into board policy um I'm interested in hearing a little bit more about the process because I feel like this resolution still needs a lot of work um and then the other thing that I'm um I just have a question about is we actually have state law that required our district by July of 2018 to have um protocols and policies already throughout our systems um to protect immigrant children and their families from um their data being improperly released and so I just wanted to hear a little bit about what's already inside of our systems that we're using um and then again my second question is about like what is the process that we're going to

105get from this resolution to an actual board policy so I'll invite Stacy Doda if she is here still um if you can join us talk about what kind of data is put in Student Records so I will start us off in terms of um whenever win roll a student we don't ask for any proof of citizenship there's no social security number required um and any data that is needed of that type if ever um is kept separate from their folders and I'll have Stacy speak more to all of that that goes in a student what is known as a student C folder I'm I'm more curious about what policies and procedures we have that we adopted pursuant to the state legislation in 2018 requiring us to have limiting our school's ability to cooperate in Immigration

106enforcement actions um so what existing policy do we have currently in line with that legislative requirement and then how are we going to bring that forward to kind of look at as a board as a whole about how we're going to update those policies into you know hopefully protocols that are already in place but if they're not then let's kind of talk about that too um I would need to do a little bit of research because 2018 was before my time with the district but we do not collect information on any students um residency status their immigration status um when a student enrolls in our district there are traditional pieces of information that we are required to collect we need to collect a students immunization records that's one of the non-negotiables we need to be

107able to determine where a student is living so proof of residency that can either be proven by uh sharing documentation about where their family lives like a pg& or a water bill or an Affidavit of cohabitation if we have a family living with other families we don't question or challenge we just ask that there be a piece of paper signed by the owner of where the student is living indicating that these people are living with me um one of the areas that is sometimes a little bit confused is the uh providing of a birth certificate there's an assumption that every child must provide a birth certificate and that's a little bit inaccurate by Education Code we are required to collect an Affidavit of age a birth certificate is one means of providing Affidavit of age

108as is a passport as is baptismal records or hospital records or a family can simply sign an Affidavit of age all of which are options we have training for our community our staff our enrollment staff um about what some of the options for families are when they come to our schools and our priority is immediate enrollment of all students without barriers we work with staff when they have a unique situation we even have uh some of our staff who are able to assist with either facilitating access to immunization records or assisting families with creating catch-up plans so we have a very firm position with training at all sites on how to remove barriers from enrollment when uh there are legal documents that are um asked to be processed they come to the district office for

109review we don't have schools trying to manage information like subpoenas that comes to the district so that we can protect our school campuses from being a place where um documents are trying to be served other questions TR I um I guess you know what are the current protocols and processes in place that protect student and family data um when they are being requested by federal agencies any requests of Records come to again to the district office and the first step that we do is we coordinate with our legal council and we um determine whether or not that request is something that the school will provide furpa has very specific policies about what kind of information can be shared um we have a policy of unless there is an emergent uh concern of somebody's safety we

110don't provide any information short of a a warrant or a public records act or things like that even when something like uh an emergent situation might be happening the only thing we are at Liberty to release is directory information there is no additional information without warrants and and other pieces and we don't make those decisions we only act under the guidance of our legal council okay yeah there's some really clear guidance that districts have to follow with regards to only assigned judicial warrant either a federal or a state judge right or an actual subpoena again signed by a court um and so those are the kinds of you know policies and procedures that I hope we also are very clear with our community about um you know to our students and our families to make

111sure that they also feel like we know how to protect um that information and um you know address location certain families of where students are living um because we have the ability and the responsibility to actually block that information unless it's being requested under these specific circumstances um that's you know I think I think having some deeper Clarity in um the resolution that we adopt tonight um that's that's more than just kind of you know the superintendent will develop policies and protocols like to be more spe specific about exactly what those will be with regard to information requests as well as the presence of ice agents um or of immigration you know enforcement agencies in any in any capacity coming onto our campuses so I also wanted to ask about that what are the policies

112and procedures currently active in our district that protect against immigration enforcement activities happening on our campuses I I'm not prepared to speak to the specific policies I would need to do some research so that I can use the specific policies but that is uh something that we can look into and report back okay that's something we'll be updating because as I believe um president Medina shared um last Wednesday the Attorney General updated all of the procedures for this coming year um and so we're going to be using that to update our current policies and if there isn't any make sure that there are um the other question that I had was around the ways in which um we are using this opportunity to strengthen the relationships that we have with community- based organization and specifically

113with immigration legal service providers to make sure that you know students and families have the opportunity to develop to develop you know guardianship plans and other preparedness documents that sit within our within our system um to make sure that you know in the case that enforcement activity is happening within a family then there is some clarity and some ability to know where to go to get those resources so um I think you know how we are making sure that those resources are communicated throughout our systems is really important in this um I also had some specific suggestions about language that I hope goes into this resolution um that also solidifies for our community right that we're not making up new rights right we have California Constitution Article 1 Section 28 F1 right that makes it

114very clear there's um Ed code sections two 200 and 201 that are very clear anti-discrimination policies um and then throughout our resolution we talk about the 2016 election but our country did this again in 2024 and so I think just updating you know specifically what happened in 2024 and that actually there is a much clearer plan in this second Trump Administration and much clearer threats with a lot more capacity to actually make sure that they you know happen so we have Trump Administration surrogates right now talking about shock and awe on the first day of um of his presidency and so that means that we have to be you know the urgency is now to really get ready um for what it means on January 20th and 21st in our community to really know that

115this is the best way to show you know that we are prepared that we're thoughtful that we're taking care of our responsibilities as an institution and that does so much to make sure that the that the fear and you know the distress that's being felt throughout immigrant communities and our and you know certainly here but all over the country we can show that we're actually doing something about reducing that fear and making sure that we are very clear on our responsibilities um the other thing that I wanted to just lift up here is that you know this board is contemplating a new uh memorandum of understanding with a law enforcement agency on our campuses and as I have raised in the past the presence of law enforcement increases the risks to Immigrant families and children

116as a result just of by being in in contact right by falling into the criminal justice system we need to be very very clear that anyou that is entered into in this District requires law enforcement officers on our campuses to agree that they will not participate in any any immigration um you know any any participation in Immigration enforcement that that falls outside of you know the agreement that we may enter into with any future law enforcement agency and I just want to raise that now because right now it's completely silent in our resolution and or in any future policy and I just want to tie those two things together because for this board when we contemplated ending theou with srpd one of the main reasons was that we did not hear from that agency an

117ability to culturally be culturally responsive in the way that it treated immigrant Children and Families um when they came into contact with law enforcement so I just want to make sure that that is really contemplated in anou so just just CU there was a lot there um are there um specific resolves that you want to add to this one could you so there's there's an um an eclu uh model policy that is kind of the gold standard that I would really hope that we are utilizing um to strengthen this policy um as well as to be very clear on you know all of the different ways in which uh our district can be continuing to sit in a place of of leadership on this issue so when our board adopted this in 2017 we were

118the first institution in our County to do so um I think that speaks a lot to you know the importance and the recognition that we have in serving you know arguably the largest population of immigrant children and their families in our entire County um and I love the way that this board has always stood up with that recognition with some pride and some responsibility in that um so again if we're thinking about being the gold standard on this issue the ACLU model policy um and there's a couple of different versions of that starting in 2018 where we really saw community- based organizations and institutions stepping up in this way um but in terms of like what's put in this resolution is there like a specific line that I could add to it or under one

119of these res resolved further or or a whole separate one you would like to Amendment see I just don't want it to get lost yep um I sent you president Medina the um the v um example and the Vio example has um whereas the California Constitution Article 1 Section 28 F1 provides quote all students and staff of public primary elementary junior high and Senior High Schools comma and community colleges colleges and universities have the enable right to attend campuses which are safe secure and peaceful and then whereas the California Education Code section 200 provides it is the policy of the State of California to afford all persons in public schools regardless of their disability gender gender identity gender expression nationality race or ethnicity religion sexual orientation or any other characteristic that is contained in the

120definition of hate crime set forth in section 42255 of Penal Code etc etc so we can cite kind of California Ed code section 200 um and I'll note that nationality includes citizenship country of origin and national origin so that's how we kind of wrap in an anti-discrimination protections for immigrants and then California Ed code section 201 I would ask that we add that whereas where it just says All Peoples have the right to participate fully in the educational process free from discrimination and harassment and we have an affirmative obligation to um combat racism sexism and other forms of bias um and then language specifically you know around um require Provisions in any future mou with the law enforcement agency that they shall not participate in Immigration enforcement efforts on our on our campuses um and

121then with regards to ice request S I think it's you know this is kind of towards the end of our resolution um so I think and then it's just updating I think it's the second to last whereas on page one of the resolution updating it to say whereas the 2024 National presidential election um November 5th yeah and the very clear plans laid out in Project 2025 um to to wreak you know pain and fear and damage to Immigrant communities um is it within our perview right now to to make a suggestion to uh to have U this resolution go back uh to a subcommittee so we can re-evaluate and resubmit it for next week uh next week is primarily organizing committee is there something we that transition happens before any work oh your mic yeah

122so it would be the following board taking on this because we do the the transition happens before any work done and we are limiting it just to that transition meeting so if this board wants to take action on it it would need to happen today so I respect all the additions that have been suggested um they do seem a bit redundant because it's following Ed code and California Constitution that we have to follow anyways so it seems like it's adding a lot of information that's not readily available into a resolution that we're hoping to pass tonight um there's value to every one of those aspects but I do agree with director Flores that this really feels like it need some more time to be properly vetted and thought through and I don't think a resolution

123on this should be mentioning anou with law enforcement that we haven't even seen yet and hasn't been presented so it' be tying conditions to anou that we haven't even seen and reviewed yet um I'd like to if we do move forward with this resolution we stick to um honoring our commitment to protecting immigrant students and families um without trying to add too much in just because we're hoping to get it through with this current board so just really quick I I hear you um trusty Flores um I think I have most of this language um that trusty lcus is adding because it's I'm just copying and pasting from the Vio resolution the three rases um the the part that you recommended um to address was changing obviously the the election from 2016 to 2020 um

124so all those references right and um I'd like to add and I can just read it into the record if possible so um that you know whereas this board directs the superintendent and her designes to not cooperate with Federal immigration authorities except as required by law that we make it a very clear policy that this board stands against immigration enforcement on our campuses as well as cooperation um and then that we reaffirm the authority of the superintendent to protect the data and identities of any student family members or school employee because these are also our employees who are immigrants um who may be adversely affected by any future policies or executive action that results in the collection of any personally identifiable information to the fullest extent provided by the law um and then again this

125is just for clarity for our community so it's not just kind of letting the board know that ice is on our campus as soon as possible but it's just saying that be it fur further resolved or whereas should an immigration agent or you know um request access to a school site that we clearly authorize the superintendent as and her designes to ask for the ace ENT Ace Ice agents credentials to ask an agent why they are requesting access to the school site and then to demand a warrant right or a court order a subpoena ass signed by a federal or state judge um and that again whereas District employees shall under no circumstances on their own respond verbally or in writing to any request made um about the immigration status of any student or student's

126family and shall refer all uh any and all such requests about immigration status to the proper design of the district office um so again it's just this level of clarity to our community that I think will again make it clear and bring down that sense of fear right now um both for like to our board about very clearly what the superintendent Authority already is under state law um but just reminding ourselves as an institution as well as our community right that we are really standing um strongly in these rights and responsibilities to our community as a whole um okay and I'm happy to kind of throw this up on a screen that you know we vote as a board to include this language that I've cited um and you know I completely agree with you

127um trusty de that you know I'm not necessarily saying that in this res olution we shall agree or state that we are saying something about a future mou that refuses to be negotiated while this board is in is in these seats um but that we are very clear in the future about the importance of needing to have that kind of information in an mou around what our law enforcement Partners um agree to follow if you know on the campuses in line with this board policy right that it that it needs to continue being enforced at multiple levels lels as we move forward as an institution so I got most of those um I just wasn't clear on that last part of the future mou was their line for that particip on that yeah could you

128please um I would like to for it to say be further resolved that the district shall not shall not enter into agreements with state or local law enforcement agencies or any federal agency to use District resources including Personnel to conduct or support immigration enforcement activities that's straight from the AC ACLU guidance you email me that real quick so I could just copy and paste into here do you want me to to send it to you please I can send it to you huh I can send it to you yeah please yes and that way I'm going to go through the whole resolution with all these amendments um and hope that we can um get to a vote so go ahead and send that to me um and I'm going to go ahead and go with

129the public comments and then we'll come back to this is that okay um so I have a few public comments on this um first we got Amy rot Tapia followed by ronar followed by erandi Hernandez Aguilar uh Amy hello good evening I'm am rapia a senior at Santa Rosa high school and I'm here on behalf of my safety belonging cohort um we're a group of high school students in Santa Rosa from the Santa Rosa city school district um committed to creating a culture of safety in our schools I want to start off by saying we students are the future and right now we are afraid we are the heart of our community a community that includes every single one of us regardless of our immigration status we are here to demand something fundamental safety in

130our schools when we talk about safety we are talking more than metal detectors or security guards we are talking about feeling secure enough to learn to grow to dream we are talking about safety from Fear for students of color trans and non-binary students student with immigrant families safety means knowing that coming to school won't risk our family stability it means knowing that our parents won't be torn away from us because of our immigration status it means feeling protected not targeted but right now these families but right now these families live in constant fear fear of deportation fear of Separation fear that a simple task could mean losing everything this fear doesn't just hurt families it hurts all of us when immigrant students and families are afraid to interact with law enforcement when they are scared

131to report crimes or domestic violence our entire Community becomes less safe we are asking to take a stand we thank you for reaffirming the safe heaven resolution and ask that you push the county to pass the ordinance on Dignity Health and safety of cema County immigrants ensure that no County agency will provide information to ice that could lead deportation protect our community's most vulnerable members thank you your time is up next I have ronar followed by erandi ernandez ailar and shandre Bautista ronar hello everyone I'm here to encourage the board to approve the safe hav resolution as I believe school should be the last place where a student has to fear of being stripped away from their home community and the life they've only known losing a relative friend classmate to deportation is a reality

132I hope which students never have to endure by passing this resolution also I really want to Echo the recommendations from the La Cruz and um the reiteration of theou and ensuring that the police on emphasis whether what whatever that agreement looks like ensures that there is no collaboration with ice as that is a big really big fear of the Immigrant Community um uh but yes by passing this resolution you're taking one of like the first steps to prioritize the safety of all students regardless of immigration status um and I'm really excited to hear what the procedures look like um and what that will be reported back so we can um understand what what it is what it means to ensure Safe Haven and passing this resolution instead of it being a symbolic gesture we also

133don't know what to expect with this upcoming new Administration and it's time to get prepared now so thank you thank you next we have erandi ernandes agilar followed by chandri Bautista erandi RC [Music] in um uh I also have it in English Okay English please Gracias my name is arandi I'm the president of meta GC and I'm really glad that the board members here are taking the action to reinstate the resolution I think it's also important that we note that the superintendent has the last call in deciding whether ice goes onto campus or not as mentioned earlier by the judicial warrant and I think it's also important that we note that in the second to second and third to last demands in the 2017 version of the resolution it states that the board should not

134allow ice onto school campuses and I think it's also important that we pass this resolution as it's critical that our schools including facilities and material property on school grounds can act as safe refuge in the event that undocumented students and individuals are subject to deportation please make sure that the document is accessible in all languages through different modes of communication including platforms of parent communication such as the website and social media I also urge that you utilize inclusive language in your resolution that to ensuring the protection of our most vulnerable and marginalized communities regardless of their immigration status ethnicity race religion sexual orientation ability sex and gender identity social economic statuses or beliefs help us strengthen our protections to our undocumented Community because it's your students families and most vulnerable community members who will suffer

135for it if elected officials don't take action K Mayu thank you uh next I have chandri Baptista I'm sure sorry um but my name is HRI my I'm with the Immigrant defense task force I am also um working with Ra's coltiva which has me Crossing into the grounds of um Santa Rosa um City Schools um I'm here to Echo what was mentioned that the superintendent does have that last say in approving Federal um warrants and um ice and police agents local and federal police agencies entering campus so just want to put that on the table I also do want to encourage the superintendent to take this conversation up to the scope level um and also further connect with other superintendant in the area there's a lot of conversations happening with nearby districts um reinforcing and

136reaffirming or incorporating their first Safe Haven resolutions um so I would encourage you as a superintendent who has voice and connection to further you know amplify that networking and Echo those voices two I also want to encourage and demand language Justice within the ways that um campuses um facilitate when ice does come and when um students community and faculty and staff are taking Refuge um and I also do want to Echo that policing in schools is the same conversation as this our local agency the sheriff has existing communication and relationships with ice that further jeopard jeopardizes the safety of of our immigrant undocu population we know that federal agents um are not fully manned to carry out these orders will your your time is up thank you can you say something okay um superintendent mores

137sandre I have your phone number so I'll call you so that I can meet with all of you guys okay and um your emails are just looting so I'm waiting on on that end do you put on the mic three three okay sorry so I'm just telling president Medina that I sent the warehouses with regard to the California Constitution and the two Ed code sections um and I got those from the resolution further resolved and then there's a couple of other statements in the resolution about um I think some of the things that we just heard from um our activities test in the house around recognizing the impact the negative impact of law enforcement activity on our schools um so there's kind of three separate warehouses around the impact of immigration enforcement on school campuses

138and then there's the last suggestion that super um uh trusty manetti said which was um that the district shall not enter into agreements with state or local law enforcement agencies ET ET okay I am um so here's what I'm going to do I'm going to go ahead and read um what I have um pending what um what what I still haven't received and then you guys let me know what I'm missing no can I put it on the screen you to zoom okay let me go to zoom sure you talk yeah I'm just going to move it off into one document no it's not a Google doc it's word doc but I'm just going to copy the existing resolution and then yeah just let me uh work this through real quick PDFs don't work yeah

139it's not working as easy as I hoped [Music] okay all right I'm just going to go ahead and go through it and then switch from screen to screen we'll go okay um share my God I have so many windows open okay is that the right one no that's the wrong [Music] one okay okay all right so I'm going to go through here first um start with what we have so where is the CER of City Schools Board of Education is committed to the success of all students irrespective of their immigration status ethnicity religion sexual orientation ability sex and gender identity socioeconomic status or beliefs the whereas the declaration of independence of the United States of America recognizes every individual's right to life liberty in the pursuit of happiness whereas the United States of America was

140built by diverse peoples both native and immigrant like whereas education has played a critical role in furthering tolerance and strengthening our society whereas the United States Supreme Court held in plyar Vio in 1982 that no public school district has a basis to deny children's children access to education based on their immigration status citing uh the children have little control over their immigration status the harm it would inflict on the child and Society itself and equal protection rights of the 14th Amendment um so after this where as um we would go to these whereas the California Constitution Article 1 Section 28 F1 provides all students and staff of public primary elementary junior high and senior high schools and the community colleges colleges and universities have the inalienable right to attend campuses which are safe secure and

141peaceful whereas the California Education Code section 200 provides it is a policy of the State of California to afford all per to afford all persons in public schools regardless of their disability gender gender identity gender expression nationality race or ethnicity religion sexual orientation or any other characteristic that is contained in the definition of hate crime set forth in section 42255 of the penal code equal rights and opportunities in the educational institutions of the state and per California Education Code section 212 nationality includes citizen ship country of origin and national origin whereas the California Education Code section 2011 provides all pupils have the right to participate in fully in educational process free from discrimination and harassment B California's public schools have an affirmative obligation to combat racism sexism and other forms of bias and a responsibility

142to provide equal Educational Opportunity now we go back and then where asked this would be changed to on November 5th 2020 voters in California and Across the Nation participated in the Democratic process by casting votes whereas California voters during the 2020 general election expressed strong support for public schools oh 2024 yeah both of those 2024 um well actually this one would be 2016 because it I don't know that we have the same sadly unless we can site some strong support for public schools in this last election okay so should we remove this one I think we can just strike the wehous on that one okay so we'll remove that one uh whereas more than 50 different languages are spoken in center of the city schools district uh schools including Spanish Vietnamese May Mandarin talik T

143Punjabi and Lao um whereas are these updated figures okay whereas 8 8588 of 14370 students in cental city schools are of uh Latino Latina descent 10547 are students of color and more than 72% of Elementary and 56% of high school students qualify for free and reduced lunch whereas the 2016 no 20 24 24 National presidential election has resulted in thousands of students and families in Santa Ros expressing heightened fear sadness and concerns for student safety as a result of particular rhetoric and promises made over the course of the presidential campaign whereas Youth and Families across this District have already experienced and reported increased levels of hate speech based on their ethnicity religion or sexual orientation since the election now therefore be it uh resolved was there whereas that I was missing that was being provided

144yeah there were two um whereas is that I or um sorry three um where I say whereas immigration arrests attentions and deportations affect families every day and indications that deportations will increase drama ically has created a CL climate of heightened fear and anxiety for many students and their families whereas immigration enforcement activities in and around schools severely disrupt the learning environment and educational setting for students and whereas immigration enforcement activities around schools create hardships and barriers to health and educational entainment and a pervasive climate of fear conflict and stress that affects all students in our district regardless of their background or status okay let's see okay so we're back to here so the did I just copy and paste no I didn't copy and paste these right here right okay so these are the three

145that you just read MH okay and then we go to um resolv that Central City Schools Board of Education directs the superintendent to support the creation of A Safe Haven School District this status shall include designating centeral City School sites facilities and Equipment as safe havens for further students uh families and Community allocating adequate resources necessary to support diversity inclusion and the values of a Multicultural Society continuing to host trainings on cultural uh proficiency equity and unconscious bias in the district resolve further that Cent City Schools Board of Education will close will work closely with the city county and other state and local municipalities and Community organizations to ensure our students and families are offered a protected space result further that the board reaffirms its focus on promoting and elevating tolerance inclusiveness and kindness of

146all students families and staff and all district school sites facilities and material property result further that can I can I go ahead strike a word in there instead of to U tolerance can we write acceptance instead of Tolerance acceptance yes thank you what about belonging okay I like that okay um let me just copy this one because I can't edit it here [Music] can somebody just take note of that one because I can't copy it and paste it into word for some reason so right here we'll change that to belonging so that the board reaffirms is focus on promoting and elevating belonging inclusiveness and kindness of all students families and staff at all districts School sites facilities and material property result further that the board reaffirmed the authority of the superintendent to protect the data

147and identities of any student family member or before that one before that one president Medina there were the two be it resolved that the board directs the superintendent and her designes not to cooperate with Federal immigration authorities except as required by law okay so these right here yeah and to notify parents of any immigration inquiry about their children that is submitted to the district um and then there's a second beit forther the resolve that the board reaffirm the authority of the superintendent okay that's in there and then be it further resolved the third one down there should an immigration agent request access to a school site that the board authorizes the superintendent okay so am I missing one of these right here the middle one is already in our resolution apparently this second two or

148like the first one and the third one are not okay so we're adding these two am I missing another one sorry I'm not looking at the right well let me read these two just so we get them read in uh be it further resolved should an immigration agent request access to a school site the board authorizes the superintendent and or design to ask for the ice agent's credentials ask the agent why he or she is requesting access to the school sign and ask to see a warrant signed by a federal or state judge be it further resolved so I just had a quick question did we did we already include that the board uh directs the superintendent and her designes not to cooperate with it's this next one right here be it further resolve that

149District employees shall under no that's not it so there's which is just that be it further resolved that the board directs the superintendent and her dises not to cooperate with Federal immigration [Music] authorities going right there the one at the very bottom of that page to be it further resolve the board directs the superintendent you just passed it this one last one on page two oh page two right here right there and then that second sentence on page three yeah will that repl that go that's a separate one so it's like kind of one and then then we go into the board reaffirms the um authority of the superintendant four that one is the first one and then there's the be it for the resolve yeah okay so be it for the resolve that the

150board directs the superintendent and or designate to not cooperate with Federal immigration authorities except as required by law and to notify parents of any immigration inquiry about their children that is submitted to the district be fur the resolved should an immigration agent request access to a school site the board authorizes the superintendent and or designate to ask for the ice agent credentials ask the agent why here or she is requesting access to the school site and asked to see a warrant signed by federal or state judge be it further disolved District employees shall under no circumstances respond verbally or in writing to any request about the immigration status of any student or any student's family and shall refer any and all such requests about immigration status to the proper designate at the district office um

151and then where did we leave off I think here I resolved that the board reaffirm the authority of superintendent to protect the data and identities of any student family member or School employee who may be adversely affected by any future policies or executive action that results in the collection of any personally identifiable information to the fullest extent possible provided by the law and be it finally oh and be it further resolved further that the superintendent will develop protocols and procedures to train School Personnel on how to address ice agents that arrive at schools the superintendent will notify the board as soon as possible when ice is present at a school resolved further that the board reaffirms cental City School's unequivocal commitment to ensuring safe educational environment for all students serving as a safe haven school

152district for all students and families threatened by immigration enforcement or discrimination to the fullest extent provided by the law and then the final one is be it further resolved the district this is uh trusty manetti's uh recommendation um be further resolved the district shall not enter into any agreements with state or local law enforcement agencies or any federal agency to use District resources including Personnel to conduct or support immigration enforcement activities uh this resolution shall become District policy upon adoption by the Board of Trustees so that's the bulk of it um is there further discussion or would somebody like to make make a motion on this recommendation like to move to approve the amended resolution and board policy second so there's a motion by trusty DEA Cruz there's a second by trusty manetti um is

153there discussion on the motion anybody none uh to the vote please student board members Zinga hi trusty De La Cruz hi trusty manieri hi trusty Sheffield hi trusty MCN hi trusty de la Tori so I just want to state that I feel this is too important to have been workshopped live especially if this going into policy and expect us to vote on this tonight so I cannot in confidence affirm this resolution as important as it is but I cannot disrespect the importance of this with the denial so I abstain trusty Flores I president Medina I thank you uh we will now move on to our next item on the agenda oh I could stop sharing so I'm now opening up uh the public hearing regarding oh sorry opening up the public hearing regarding District uh

154Sant Rosa Teachers Association contract reopener uh Sunshine for the 2025 2027 school year that's superintendent zans assistant okay so um this is just for the public hearing so uh we are well you are actually opening the public Hearing in regards to uh reopener for um 24 or 26 2526 and 2627 Sunshine for um srcs and SRTA so do we have any blue cards or comments on this I don't have any over here no blue cards president Medina okay seeing no blue cards no comments um the public hearing is now closed we'll now move on to item uh F3 um the approval of proposed District um Center was a Teachers Association contractor reopener Sunshine for 2025 through 2027 okay thank you president Medina superintendent Dr Morales uh members of the board um I am here today

155to ask for your approval of the um contract reopener for the 2025 to 2027 contracts um in agreement with SRTA when we closed our negotiations in May of 2024 we came to an agreement on which articles we would be reopening for um the following negotiations to take place in January we agreed to article 11 leave of absence Provisions article 14 which is the definitions for RSP and SDC article 16 compensation uh specifically but not limited to salary schedules athletic directors Department chairs credal IAL and certificate certificates that authorize particular kinds of services and instructions and benefits for all bargaining unit members for the 2526 and 26 27 school years we are also going to be reviewing appendices job descriptions and stiens and we are going to partner with SRTA to review clarify and make any

156necessary Minor Adjustments to any articles and sections within the CBA so we are asking for a motion to approve our uh proposed reopener board is there any questions no questions um let's see if there's any public comment any public comment I see no cards comes back to the board um for further discussion or for a motion I'd like to move to approve uh the proposed SRTA contract reopener second moved by trusty laku second by trusty sheff Feld if there's no further discussion let's go to the vote student board members Zinga hi trusty De La Cruz hi trusty Sheffield hi trusty MCN hi trusty deor hi trusty manieri hi trusty Flores hi president Medina I thank you we will now move on to item F4 this is the 202 2425 fiscal interim first interim fiscal report

157um assist associate superintendent Lisa August and Joel dantos floor is yours thank you president Medina superintendent Dr Morales when she returns uh our trustees and our Santa Rosa city schools Community um in person and online um I do want to start by saying that um letting you know that we did upload a replacement attachment today that does have um both that has translated slides as well as one new slide in there as well and that's called out as new so just to give everyone a heads up that is a combined uh presentation that is available we will eventually have the board report update um translated as well they're just very wordy and by the time that we get them done they aren't ready to be uploaded at the same time um translation needs time for

158that excuse me share my screen and okay thank you um so this evening we are talking about our first interim report um we'll give you an overview and go through our assumptions our multi-year projections there is some um duplication in here from information that was presented during the special meeting on November 20th um but that is key and pertinent to the first interim update um we'll kind of skip quickly through those slides though since it's duplicate information so just a reminder of where we are at this is our first interim report which does provide the update from July 1 through October 31st as well as information that we know at this time um is Incorporated in those multi-year projections so it is an estimate of where we expect to end this year plus a projection

159for at least the next two years um you will see in this uh interim report that we did include and thank you very much to Joel and our fiscal team um did include two additional years in the projection so that we can see the impact that the fiscal stabilization measures have on the long-term stability of our district District you will hear from us again in January when we bring you information about the governor's budget proposal as well as our audit report and then February for our midyear update for the lcap and March for second interim hopefully we won't have any well we shouldn't have any need for a third interim this year and then again in May and June as we go through this process just a reminder that it is a continuing cycle and

160it is all driven by the lcap which is heavily influenced by public participation and parent input so it really is extremely important um that we do have um that participation in those meetings coming up so again I'm just information I already shared we'll skip through that due to the adoption of the fiscal stabilization plan we in um coordination a consultation with our um County office with Sonoma County Office of Education uh we do expect that um we would have a positive certification so that is what is being presented to you this evening that means that we are expecting with the implementation of the fiscal stabilization plan which will come to you in a more detailed form after the recommendation for specific specific School consolidation and closure as well as more specifics on the um Staffing

161ratios and the um reductions that for sustainable Staffing in the future that all of that will come to you in February um in preparation for the March second interim so just an overview of the assumptions that we have in the current year plus what we expect based on information provided in those out years again you will see all the way out to 2829 that just seems really strange to say that um we do expect continued increases in Cal Pur again cal Pur is the retirement plan for all classified employees including classified administrators calsters is the retirement plan for all certificated staff so teachers and certificated admin administrators um stepping column is just an average used of 1.5 we do have what was in um included in the budget as $4,750 per sell for SRTA and

162the groups that follow their contract and then CA is not specifically called out in here we do um expect to have negotiations um later this week so um hopefully we can get to an item um actually called out specifically on there after there is a public um offer that that is in there um you do see um fairly um see a consistent decline in funded Ada and enrollment based on the projections of the the low demographics and and what we've experienced this year this is again information that was shared um during the fiscal stabilization update and the changes in what we've um predicted based on the actual enrollment this year um and the upcoming years projected with our uncertified data so those numbers could change slightly as far as our percentages but again um definitely

163an in increase in our supplemental and concentration um Grant funds um based on our increased unduplicated pupil counts which again are either they fall into one of three one or more of three categories are low socioeconomic status students so free and reduced um English language Learners or Foster homeless and those are the funds that are required to be specifically called out in our lcap our local control accountability plan so you can see that that actually provides a big um a bit of a cushion in there compared to what we had before substantially different and it really makes up some of that difference in the um drop in enrollment based on the increased and duplicated pupil count and then we do just have those Charter um projection information as far as actual enrollment as well and

164the impacts on their budgets which we did talk about during the fiscal stabilization special meeting so I won't belabor that again the assumptions based on the fiscal stabilization plan that was adopted by the board we were then able to to incorporate that information into our Uh current uh estimated budget and our multi-year projections and here you do see the difference in our uh revenues and I'll go ahead and let Joel speak to that for a moment yeah thank you Lisa um good evening president Medina superintendent Morales trustees um so since uh we adopted the budget in June um the school district my staff and everybody have been working on you know uh reviewing the budget with uh actual information through October 31st so we've shown here kind of the differences between what was last spring

165and what we have updated this fall so one thing about the the revenues and the the report we're looking at here it includes both unrestricted and restricted sources so you can see the changes in federal revenue those are all due to the uh title funding updates that we've got allocations we budgeted um some of the some of some of the carryovers so when we when we budget those we have to budget the actual uh revenues that represent the expenditures so we've spent this fall building programs and working with the state and federal and establishing those budgets um similarly the other state revenues are are those difference are due to we we budgeted the Golden State Pathways implementation program the we had mental health services budget updates um we early uh preschool Grant special education preschool

166Grant the classified school employee summer sistens program and the teacher residency implementation Grant um and you can see uh other local revenues that was uh a pretty um we recognize some uh medical medical medical billing revenues and some other uh local special education revenues that we've talked about something to to note about the medical revenues when we receive those those are reimbursements for services provided and typically it's multiple years that we receive at a time we don't know specifically when those will be received so we don't tend to budget those and they are restricted funds so while they were provided for I they're received for services already provided we're still further restricted on how we spend them in the future so um we are working um I know our our team um in special education

167our special services team is working on a plan that meets um the requirements of that and we are looking to see where we can um fit that into areas in our fiscal stabilization plan rather than creating additional new programs so trying to be as effective and efficient with the dollars that we are receiving okay so here we're looking at the expenditures updated through October 31st so the two items of um impact here are in employee benefits so you know we had a um an increase in our certificated Health Calpers plan um we had open enrollment so we had to increase the budget related to some additional um opt-in um employees did you have a question Omar I'm sorry I did you say you had an increase in like the enrollment like like no so yeah

168so our teachers they are uh they they they went with the calipers and they they can choose to take out a plan or not take out a plan so we have our inside our uh Human Resources Financial uh system we have all the all the employees that take a plan and that and all the plans that they cost and the total uh District liability for those plans but then they go through open enrollment and new employees come in and like when we do new hires they take out new plans so then we adjust the budget after actual um Employee Staffing is allocated and the plans are finalized I guess I'm just curious did we when we budgeted we budgeted based on an estimated percentage not based on the total okay well both we budgeted on

169the actual um plans that are taken out and assumptions for vacancies and different things but then we updated in the fall when actual uh plans are in place so one of the things that we did that it that um we're seeing as a trend is it looks that like based on the more attractive benefits package we're seeing a change in in what some of the employees are selecting um on a level of coverage plus there are increases in the actual cost of benefits that were unknown at the time of budget adoption so now that we have rather than a hard cap we have a soft cap where it's an adjustment of a percentage of that of the plan that does affect our our budgeting a little bit differently than it has in the past so

170we we're likely to see a little bit more fluctuation in employee benefit costs than we've than we've seen in the past where we had a hard cap where we could say okay here's the maximum that would ever be taken because it's all a flat amount so it just works differently with that soft cap as we adjust based on actual medical um or benefit costs and could you just base on what accounts for the the increase in salaries over with the budget amount I don't know if it's restricted or unrestricted because it's kind of all mixed in here yeah no I can I can so no so the certificated salaries increase was due to similar circumstances where we went through all the uh actual um placements and staff that's in and but that update wasn't something

171I that stands out as really material thing that that and that spread out over all resources all um staff throughout the whole District so there was just you know we we we when we pull all those positions for we have you know based on prior years actual assignments plus vacancies but then throughout this summer um teachers leave the district new teachers are hired on and then we re um budget all the um certificated salaries based on actual uh placements in the fall so there is an increase due to that reason but I'm looking at the increase in the employee benefits that that those are the two really impact in my I was thinking and then and then I was going to go over the the the service and other operating expenditures I think I'll just

172add just because I know it was brought up by the public and I know I had the question as well um and maybe I just didn't understand something but I think generally when when we budget I think we're budgeting based on FTE and like you know we're seeing that they're not all full I mean I would imply that I would assume that we're not even meeting that budget expenditure but now we're ere expending so it's why it's hard I think well for me to understand and I imagine even more so for the public so again depending on what positions are actually filled and the placement that people come in at so depending on their education and experience levels that's going to fluctuate um as well as the number of positions another thing that goes into

173each of those are additional pay so when we have um stiens or overages for class loads or for case loads or other things of that nature speec and something that's going to be in here that wouldn't have been in the original budget would be things that are that are new to those Grant programs or restricted funds as well so it's a combination of things it's not any one item It's a combination of all of those factors yeah and that that that's what I was trying to reference when we were saying that we increased the the uh Federal grant revenues that was also due to the some number of the increases here in these other categories as well so the revenues offset those expenditure increases the ones that are really impacting our kind of um multi-

174rejection and unrestricted [Music] um it's the word I'm looking for unappropriate unassigned unappropriate ending fund balance are is the employee benefits and the contracted services and the employee benefits was from Mostly from just the the current um health plans that our uh cpers members have taken out in that in that budget area and then in the um Serv and operating expenditure so there was um an increase in our um mental health and special education contracted services and you know we do have these nonp agencies that we contract with and we've we're seeing um not you know what's the historical differences in our Trends and those increases I know there was a there was a recent um self approved increase in those and so um um yeah it's a it's a it's a it's a it's

175a it's a a material increase in those Contract Services so we've we've identified that we've you know we've had many discussions with the special ed education department um and Lisa has um in the multi-year projection um some new assumptions that will help um um so one of the things that we're talking that um Joel is alluding to in there is that we we're really looking forward to the presentation from Dr Gillespie in January about the special education study that we had done that is really to take a look at not reducing services to special education students but how do we review what it is that we are doing to provide those services and providing them in a better way so are we Ser are we serving are we overidentifying students who should be better served

176in General general education classrooms with tier one interventions first tier one tier two interventions that really should be under general education rather than students being identified as um special special education and having extremely extremely intensive supports that are maybe one of the not maybe one of the things that does happen is that we have students who are identified potentially in elementary school for say an English you know an articulation issue and rather than that being determined and the and you know reviewed and the student exiting before they come to us in SE in seventh grade from a feeder District or even from our own schools that they're not being evaluated as to whether they should be exited out or the services changed and so we do have we know that we have overages in in

177case loads and and things of that nature so it'll be very I think it will be very um instructive when we have Dr Gillespie here to go through this the particulars of what his report um found and he does come with recommendations as far as how we Implement a plan to better provide services going forward again it's not about reducing Services it's about providing services in a more effective way for our students um but that is one of the things that that we do expect to have a a significant impact on um some of these items specifically our services and operating expenditures we are seeing a large number of non-public school placements that we are looking at revamping our programs to actually bring those students back um to our to our fold as we are

178also providing services to other districts now as well and so we're seeing an increase in revenues in a way that offset that's directly the cost that we have for operating specific classrooms so those those are I I'm probably going into a little more detail than than you want on that but just knowing that those are the things that we're evaluating and we'll be bringing more information as we get closer to Second interim after we have that special education plan and come forward with implementation what that would look like as a proposal I so um first of all I just want to say thank you for bringing this to our attention uh and you know especially now it's when we're looking at extensive budget cuts right seeing a $13 million you know extra expenditure that we

179did not accommodate for it to begin with uh sends an extremely wrong message to the entire Community now having said that uh what can we do to properly project uh in future cases so we're not in this case because right now we're in the middle negotiations with CCA timers we're going to start negotiations with SRTA and this is I mean this is this is such a low blow in terms of our ability to negotiate um so my question to you is like how can we prevent these sort of things from happening uh in the future so two pieces to that one not all of that is in unrestricted revenues as Joel mentioned a large portion of that the majority um is actually in the restricted side which has to do with the way that we're

180required to do that budgeting so it doesn't mean that there's unexpected revenues or unexpected expenditures it's that we have to budget in a way that matches the revenues to the expenditures and so it gets taken out of the budget and then put back into the budget and that's just the way that the especially on the federal side that the way that some of those um restricted funds work as well as some of the local grants there's a combination of things so that piece I think that what may be helpful in the future is on a slide like this if we break that out between what's restricted and what's unrestricted ask it make it more clear so so thank you for for that feedback that's certainly you know a great way that we can improve on

181on that messaging um and the other piece is really we are would say one of the things that happens is that when we have students who are in need and items are identified in plans and added without necessarily um I can't speak to always the appropriateness as far as whether something is um specific to the needs of a student if we're helping them to become more independent or if we are providing Services because it's something that's being requested Ed because somebody feels that it's a nice thing to do versus what's the appropriate thing to do in in in a placement I I can't speak to that because that's certainly not my we talked about that before we talked about the appropriateness of of MPS placements and all that and I thought that was already you

182know being set forth right and to see this being Incorporated it's it's it's it's a an unpleasant surprise to say the least absolutely I I I would agree so um we are again work that was one of the reasons for bringing in Dr Gillespie to help us to get a better handle on that our special education identification rate is about 19% and on a state average it's closer to 12 thank you thank you okay so this is something that I did want to call out specifically that you know I really appreciate the additional time that the Joel took to include two more years in the projection so that we can see that while we see lots of red down there in the short term in the long term it by implementing our fiscal stabilization plan

183by right sizing our program services and sites and Staffing to be able to meet the needs of the the enrollment that we have we do get to a point in a few years of actually being in the black and being able what that will enable us to do as we've talked about is reimagine reinvigorate you know Rec you know really um Revitalize our programming and to be able to enrich and enhance that in the future it will be a painful couple of years but there is light at the end of the tunnel um it will con we really need to continue the hard work together as a community the other thing that I want to call out on here is the way that we did um adjust that um excuse me to meet that unexpected

184about five million you know dollars in the unrestricted you know that that hit there is that we did um in you know taking um some advice or some um guidance from sko is that we do have interest in that is being earned on the bond funds that is unrestricted we have um the intention of that going towards Bond projects in the short term we do plan with the board's approval this evening to move a portion of that into fund 17 specifically to meet our reserve for economic uncertainty that helps us to maintain that 3% minimum while not being spent actually moved into the general fund so it is there specifically only for economic uncertainty um to get us through that 3% over the next couple of years until we're able to transfer that back into

185the bond funds after rebuilding um through our fiscal stabilization plan so I I just want to stop for a second if that sorry Ju Just you know and and and reiterate Joel really do appreciate the um Extended projection on this particular slide because I I do think it speaks to something that was stated in public comment that school closures don't necessarily save money you know and there is a study that indicates that but when we actually see it here in a projection I mean we're facing the reality and we're facing a public that that is having a hard time seeing that reality and when we can when we can demonstrate that what the decision the ultimate decision is going to be made is done in a fiscally responsive way um that is looking to the

186future I I anything that we can do to to to do that to continue to send that message to the to the public so that they don't they you know it doesn't create chaos or give false hope you know um I I when I saw the the um added yours on this it it's comforting you know it's not it's comforting knowing that there's so much pain going on right now and that there's reason and that there is something that will come from this ultimately and when you look at it projected out and it's not way down the road you know this is on the next block um so I just wanted to pause and and be comment to to this particular slide thank you TR FL did you have a question yeah I'm I was

187trying to uh write my question down so in terms of moving second reading glasses now uh in terms of moving the uh funds from our uh interest from our B interest so how is that going to affect our compound uh interests I mean since we're going to remove it from place to put into uh to the 3% reserves is that going to affect any sort of future projects you know how much are we're going to lose in compound uh interest if we were to do that so can can you talk a little bit more about that sure since we're since we're keeping it in another Special Reserve the plan is not to spend that which would mean that we would still be earning the same interest because all of our money is actually pulled in

188the County Treasury it's just separated by fund for our accting accounting purpose but it's all lumped together anyway so it doesn't affect the interest so in terms of long-term planning for projects that's not going to affect us uh by by moving the funds to fun 17 is that what I mean correct okay correct thank you and how would that be tracked long term like let's say that you leave right and who's going to keep track of the that that don't leave that is actually um something that's really important that we call out out in these annual or these quarterly budget reports that that that's tracked that we have it identified in our in our financial system there are notes that we can make as well but those transfer over as we're doing these reports and

189calling it out to the board I think it's really important that we have that in there we also um by by law anything that becomes above our 3% we have to provide an um information at the um to the board uh during with the budget that why we have money there that's over so if it sat there and just didn't get moved back there would so it would trigger a a why is that here and we'd have to look at what was what it was assigned or committed for and then for transparency sake how is it indicated labeled identified for the public in the way that they can understand it not thrown in uh uh um a spreadsheet so in the in the spreadsheet in the in the official state documents we have to list

190it as it's specially coded as a reserve for economic uncertainty we have to do that to be compliant with our 3% but we can call it out in our narrative in our report explaining very clearly what it's there for and why thank you thank you thank you okay and this is just an overview of our um other funds and where those are at at or projected to be at at the end of the year again you see things in there that are based remember we have a budget which is a plan and then what we actually do or how those get updated throughout the year It's Not Unusual to see changes especially in those other restricted funds um when we talk about building F it's going to be based on which projects actually move forward

191or not what time the timing of payments um developer fees it's going to be on actual receipts or expenditures out of there um just all of those things in in general those are areas where you expect to see a lot of change um from adoption to your interim reporting periods the key thing is that they are all expected to be positive that's that's the important part and we wanted to bring this slide back as a reminder of why our fiscal stabilization plan is needed why school closures are an important part of that and it is about right sizing and then again why we need those Staffing um Staffing ratios so that we stop making you know knee-jerk reactions to budget crisis or budget inflows um there may be times where we have to staff more

192leanly or where we have restricted funds that call for specific for additional Staffing those are different and you know those need to be identified and called out the enrollment history just looking from my eight years on the board that drop 2500 coming on 3,000 students and a reminder this is um only for Santa Rosa city schools um comprehensive schools yeah it's not um Charter so 2500 to 3,000 students in eight years yes so this is specifically fun1 the the impact on that and so trying to answer some of the questions and concerns from the public about you know mismanagement H you know of of this board when we can't manage 3,000 student loss in in that short of a of a time span that that is a a huge shift and during that time all

193of those one so onetime funds were received every year from 1516 through 2324 yeah and received or carried over yeah and then in that time we also had massive wildfires we had loss of you know neighborhoods in Santa Rosa we had a pandemic we had um we had the increasing cost of living in the North Bay we had Exodus M you know these are these are the reasons absolutely and this isn't a trend only for us this is a trend not only in our local County but across the state and when you look at birth rates that's a nationwide and you know issue it's the these are not trends that are expected to recover in the next 10 years yeah can I just uh note that when when that first came to the board and

194you know this is my next to last meeting uh one of the things that I discussed here with the previous superintendent the two previous superintendents was right sizing right and then we came up with a plan of reducing FTE but then Co hit right and then um that never took place right so I I just want to reiterate that we've been talking about R sizing for with the since I've been on the board which it's only been four years and I'm ass the sort of conversations happened when you were you know I want to say we had fires and the impact that that had on students and another theme that came up in the conversation was the mental health of our students and we received federal dollars and we received State dollars to help address

195these things but those weren't given permanently right so so and I just want to say that you know it's it's no we we were dealt a a very um strange sort of hand right by Fate in the last four years uh eight years eight years thank you at least yes thank you uh and and we're here and as painful as it is you know hopefully you know I won't be here making that decision unfortunately right hopefully we don't have to close any schools but we still have to write uh you know right size the school district to make sure that we're so I mean that we we're solvent in terms of our you know to be able to pay our bills uh and I just want to say to the community out there and you

196know I didn't want to take time this you know earlier today to talk about this because I wanted to hear from the uh Community but it's it's been a conversation that we've had at least for the last eight years right over and over again uh and uh it is very painful that we're here at this at this juncture uh and I I wish we didn't have to do any Z Cuts uh but I'm want to go back and say that finding extra sort of you know um expenditures uh doesn't vote well uh for for us in terms of making sure that we have the uh the trust of the community absolutely thank you let me get back to so looking at our historical Financial factors because again we want to make sure that we tell

197the story of how we got here and Al this one we're we're just trying to mix it up with you you know go from right to left instead of left to right this time um when you look at what the um when we talk about the retirement cost increases again this is across the board it's not specific to our labor Partners this encompasses all of our staff So Cal Pur this is the employer portion the employees also have a have a share for kpers and for calsters and so we went from 11.4% back there um in 1213 up to 27% and it's projected to continue to increase Cal sters does not fluctuate as much um or as often because that does take an act of the legislature to make that change versus the Kel pers

198board um for for the classified retirement we also had remember some years there where there were large um gaps so in funding so that LC F Gap funding percentage that was to make up for funds that the district did not receive um during the time of the recession statutory Cola is our statutory cost of living based on six factors um as required um and then you see in some years like in 2021 before we had that increase um in the following year we had actually a zero so we had we were required to get 2.31 and we actually received zero so when that compounded it was compounded on no Inc you know there was no compounding that year so that is why they did add that um augmentation um in the 2122 year again in

1992223 the state had extra funds and so we did see a little bit of catchup there essentially and then remember 23 24 8.22% and then to 1 0 7% and you'll see in another slide I think or a couple slides later the difference between what was projected for this year and what was actual for this year and and the long-term effect of that so that jump in in purs and stirs from I just want to look at my my time on this it was even lower when I first started in 2007 uhhuh so how does what the percentage wi what is that equate as dollars I can't tell you off the top of my head but we that would be a good one to bring back um the difference in in what that means on

200an annual basis okay because that's another one for the public to really wrap their heads around what that means in dollars and that is something that we've been talking about my entire time on this board is that not a a steady uptick this is a pounding stomping jump right it it's outpacing if you look um in the one year what was it uh 1718 or if we look at 1617 to 1718 it jumped you know and so that the cola was eaten up entirely by the retirement increase let alone that's supposed to cover all of our increase costs including our step and column our you know negotiated increases with with staff our increased operating costs for utilities all of those things and so we are constant we are consistently underfunded as far as the just

201natural increases that are required we don't receive enough to make up for that which puts us in a deficit already when you look if we configure the math on that that might be something to you know to to provide to the public what what those dollars mean and and again going back to my to that that 2016 2017 that massive that was the first thing we talked about you know in one of my first meetings was what that impact really means and it was also the discussion that um and the push back that other districts were giving to the state um that same year because how how how painful that is going to be for the districts and other school districts were dealing with it as well thank you um and again just a description

202with this was actually a really long spreadsheet that I had to split into a few um a few slides so you know this was a lot of work on Joel and and team um as far as Gathering the information and just some information on some factors that happened there so in 2425 State overestimated those tax revenues because of the delay in the in the um T the the extension for tax tax returns um we had an L-shaped economic recovery and that megaa which were good things for us but again issues later on because it we come to expect those larger colas and those are actually unusual um so just some information there here's where you see the difference in the enacted Cola the 1.07 versus versus the 3 94 that was originally projected for the

2032425 year in the long term when you look at the compounding of that that's a $6 million difference and so that's $6 million a year really when you look at that you know it's that compounding effect and so you know that's not even thinking about the the decline in enrollment in that period that is strictly the difference in Cola could you just explain that a little sure so at the time so this time so when we were looking at the budget adoption in for 2324 the projected Cola at that time for 2425 was 3.94% when we came to First interim last year I think we all had a little bit of a panic when we heard that oh the legislative analyst office was saying it was going to be 76 so we were actually a

204little happy to see the 1.07 in comparison to that because it this number would have actually looked worse um so what we built original multi-year projections on was almost four times what we actually had in this year as far as for that cost of living increase so that that Cola amount there so for this year specifically you can see it was a 4.6 million hit for next year that compounds to be 5.3 5.5 5.6 and 5.8 as we go into those out years because of that change in that Cola and you can see up up top that the 2526 also dropped from 3.26 to 2.93 so you have a smaller amount compound compounded on a lower amount so again these are just things that change as we make those updates we always have a plan

205and it changes just like thinking oh I was counting on a raise at work and I didn't get it you know I was counting on you know in you know Less in my electric bill this year and here it is more those are all the the things that compound to create that the issues that we have and again um a look back at all of those onetime funds and the years that they were received in and then to this year where we don't have those any longer and to look back at out the certifications at each of our interim reporting periods the thing that we want to really commend the board on is that by adopting our fiscal stabilization plan and moving forward with implementation and continuing the right sizing and stabilization we're hoping to

206get out of the mode of cutting of always going from qualified qualified oh is something you know bad going to happen are we going to be able to weather the storm by really making long-term lasting impacts we should return to a state of having positive reports going forward yeah that that it'll take us a little while to get there we may dip in and out of positive and qualified based on those changing factors until we get to that finalization of of really having some some stability in rightsizing our our district and our services and in that 20 24 25 SRTA um R um could you let us know approximate what percentage that would equate to for that year I do have it somewhere I believe that it ended up being an average of around 5%

207because it it ranged you know depending on where on the salary schedule due to the um flat dollar amount and so if you look at the other groups as well it went anywhere from about 2% to closer to 7% so it really just just varies thank you just wanted to highlight I know that um educational Finance is really complicated but if there's one thing I want to be able to teach um our families and our community is if you understand positive qualified and negative that gives you a really simple way to be able to see if if if a district is in distress because when you look at this and you go back to the fact that we've been qualified off and on since 2016 that right there tells you a picture it you know

208this is something that the district has been talking about and struggling with for for quite a bit of time it didn't happen overnight I know it feels for the community that it just happened overnight and they're just hearing about it now but if there is a message we can share is for them to know okay what were we qualified where we positive because that really helps them understand where we stand fiscally as an organization can I can I ask a question um so all of this didn't happen in a vacuum right like we're seeing the big picture and I really appreciate all this and I know that getting us out of the red is also not going to happen in a vacuum and even though we've adopted the fiscal stabilization plan that's only really one

209tool and one way that we're going to get out of this and so I don't want to like jump the gun or derail this but I am really curious to know and other people might be thinking this too what else are we going to be doing um what else are we going to be looking at you know are there are there ideas are there policies are there things that this board can do and work on um as we move forward to also make sure we don't end up in this place again and that we're not in a place of continuing to make cuts and having that be our only solution so some of the things that we've talked about like really looking analyzing what we're doing how so our systems our processes making sure that

210things are standardized as much as possible I mean I can tell you that even in our custodial team you know over you know the years since the custodial manager position was put in place and the standardization that happened out of that that saved millions of dollars over the last several years based on standardizing and creating real processes and systems for how things are done that's the importance of bringing in Dr Gillespie it's the importance of creating our staffing ratios of looking at how do we structure our schools differently you know how do we reimagine doing this in a better way you know um sorry um I know we're not supposed to negotiate here or anything like that but something that I would love for us to start thinking about is how do we standardize our

211high schools for example uh our scheduling system our busing system so we can you know uh not uh you know so we can say so it'll have some some some sort of cost savings and I know that's a negotiable sort of item but that's something I would love for us to start looking at uh because um there's a lot of um um cost associated with that right but um that's just you know for for us to think about uh to uh and to start thinking that's out the box and know what other things can we do you know uh can we include our you know our partners in education to see if if we can work collaboratively in ways that we can do some sort of cost Savings in the future long term so um

212just FYI right uh but I'm not negotiating okay so in case I'm getting an angry tax from the SRTA president here so no okay great I know is thank you it's just a reminder that our fiscal stabiliz stabilization advisory sorry I'm going to back up for a second you talked about input and yes our lcap meetings are the the times for that parental involvement not just parents but all of our Community Partners our educational partners are key in that because we do have to identify how we prioritize the the funds that we do have and specific while it's specifically our supplemental in concentration it also helps to guide how we develop the rest of the budget thank you and fiscal stabilization advisory committee I know everybody's probably tired of hearing about this every presentation but

213it the work that that happen happens in there is has been ongoing for a long time and it's a um I feel like it's an extremely helpful um committee that that does bring things um forward and we have input from our labor partners and we will be going out asking for parent Volunteers in January I do have a couple people who have reached out um which is great because our parents that we had have their students had have moved on okay and again our school consolidation advisory committee we did already talk about this earlier in my report so I won't belabor this one just again our timeline and the makeup of that committee our continued areas to monitor our federal programs and funding um in our fun in our general fund 01 Federal funding accounts

214for about 3% and that is restricted for us um collective bargaining always has an impact on on the budget and it's an important thing to keep in mind our economic Trends um definitely legislation around enrollment and Ada funding um Dr Morales and I are going to the um legislative action can can I just say something about that so I I know there's been a few bills about um enrollment right U but I I think we have to be cautious in terms terms of opening that Pandora's Box because prop 98 will uh prop 98 it's it's pretty robust as it is right now uh if we go into enrollment uh that would do a constitutional amendment uh and that could affect uh negatively our actually uh appropriated funds from prop 98 so it's something else to

215look at in terms know when we're NE uh legislating just to ensure that because there are other groups out there that prop n were to be opened up again that we would get a lesser you know slice of the pie so just just keep that in mind when you are out there and talk about how this would affect in terms of you know doing a you know constitutional amendment to um to the California um um Constitution thank you a absolutely there there are a lot of it it's not a straight across the board and it doesn't even if that if it weren't on that side of it you still would have this even if that nothing changed as far as prop 98 it's still the same size pie and so our slice of that pie

216may not even change when you because it's really it would depend I mean as for us as a district if there were no change to the prop 98 piece of that um no but changing from ada8 to enrollment that will be a constitutional amendment so that that would definitely change you know it could potentially change right our size of the P just just just talk it talk about with legal and see how it would affect us okay so it's something to think about absolutely it it's certainly an important piece of that and then again all of the other items that that we've talked about on there with that and I know um you know more to come as we go forward this work continues it's never done in a vacuum as you said and it

217is um ongoing it it juar you indicated that you and the superintendent were going to what something about leg I missed the part sure Association for California school administrators legislative action days um so they do um so ACTA covers the the cost for us to go and meet with legislators to advocate for for schools and I'm also um involved with casbo um California Association of business officials working on the on the same type of of thing do we ever collaborate with our our bargaining units to do something collectively to so the way this came about is um Dr rainy from the county office she is the assistant or associate superintendent of HR she reached out to the superintendent um because we have AXA has three Region 4 um openings to be able to go advocate

218in terms of the acts that covering the the bulk of the cost and so I threw up our my name out there with Lisa and after she talked to all of the superintendent she came back and said nobody else volunteered so you and Lisa are in so I'm like okay we'll go so they'll cover our hotel and most of our meals we just have to cover transportation and a few of the meals but um Lisa and I they told us to wear our tenis shoes you know we're going to be pounding the ground um this will be March 17th and 18th of next year I don't know if anyone like understands how big this is like that is such a huge thing that you are doing to be in front of legislators and to advocate

219for for our district I like I congratulate you Daisy for being able to do this and and Lisa like this is such a big deal and something that we all need to do more of so congratulations and thank you maybe get a few tips from these two over here thank you so um I really appreciate your work and efforts that went into this and Reporting um it's so good to get this information out to the public um on what's Happening I just want to reiterate enough that we have to be creative we have to be Innovative we have to find New Paths um we are two of 10 school districts in the city of Santa Rosa um and that it continues to come up a lot we we tried to have that conversation with sco

220about what district consolidation would look like for our city um we did not get uh as much communication as we hoped on that we were able to look at some preliminary numbers of what that would look like but that does not prohibit us from communicating with our eight other districts in this city and it's not about who gets there first it's about how do we get there together because we are all trying to educate students in the city um collaboratively we are the only Public High School District in this city so we got a lot of feeder districts feeding into that how are we aligning and what opportunities can we find that um similar to going to the csba as board members and collaborating with other board members throughout the state everybody's dealing with a

221crushing budget situation in the entire State we're not the only ones so how do we communicate and collaborate and not have all these isolated datas a silo with the other school districts but share some information and talk about what opportunities we may have for long-term cost savementa that are going to benefit um our students our teachers our staff so every time we get an opportunity I'm going to talk about it let's let's talk to our friends and our Community Partners and how do we collaborate and work together smarter to save some fun money shortterm and long term thank you okay our next steps um you'll as I said we'll see you we're going to have our you know continue our community messaging you'll see us in January with updates on the governor's budget proposal and

222the school consolidation enclosure advisory committee work will continue as well fiscal stabilization we'll have the special education study presentation along with um an implementation plan uh again continue messaging and we'll have those uh Town Halls scheduled we expect those flyers and we're working hard to get those out this week if we can um we want to get have people reserve dates uh to come and and share their input with us and then in February we have um the audit will actually come forward to the board then um School consolidation recommendation um more detailed plan for fiscal stabilization and again continued Community messaging and I will stop sharing so I know we answered a lot of questions along the L any other board questions not I'm going to go to public comment um and then we'll

223come back to the board um for public comment I have have um Mar Margie Brady long followed by Jeff gosby Margie and you have uh 90 seconds good evening I'll keep it short my name is Margie Brady long and I've been a student a parent and a teacher in Santa Rosa city school since 1972 I try hard to attend every board meeting until a Bitter End because I care deeply about Santa Rosa city schools I rarely speak out you may not believe that but I don't but this item has me pulling my hair out and I must askas two questions tonight number one after all the energy eliminating people and positions last year how does Santa Rosa city schools have 34 full-time equivalent employees more this year and number two you tried to explain it

224but I'm sorry the projection of spending 13 million more than budgeted this year makes me wonder what's the point of cutting 25 million if we spend without restraint thank you thank you um next Jeff gosby be resident of the district I just wanted to share an experience in a neighboring District because I think it's instructive for what you're facing in 2019 because we had declining enrollment we had to reconfigure four schools close a school and converge to other schools so a total of four um in doing that first of all it took a couple of years we engage with our staff and the community and ultimately the reason it worked is we focused on sharing the what and the why for the vision of where we were moving to rather than what we were losing

225until you can share a compelling vision for how things will be better and what communities can look forward to it's going to be challenging for your stakeholders to see anything other than what they're losing without Vision being shared many people will choose other districts or private schools and you need to give them compelling reasons to choose Santa Rosa city schools also concerning uh the budget um while it's great in the short term that there's more money from the unduplicated count going above 55% I believe that that is a short-term increase that uh has a systematic underlying problem that reflects better resource students being able to leave the district for other districts and private schools furthermore the Lao in the csba meeting said I think the Cola with six of eight data points in will be

22647% Less on 166 million of lcf that's another 800,000 you need to cut and you need to give raises so you need more reserves you need deep cuts and most importantly you need to give people a reason to stay in Santa Rosa city schools thank you so goes back to the board um I did have a question um I know Margie brought up that point of having more FTS than before is that accurate could you elaborate on that sure there are a couple things for that one we actually have seen an increase in a shift from some of our contracted employees to some additional District hire employees so those that's a good thing when we look at our AIDS and our CNS we are seeing some success there not as much as we would like

227to see but there is there is a shift there um and have to say I don't know um on the on the other ones from that something that I can bring back to you but this is above the FTE that we budgeted yes so it would have been in so when you look at the FTE that we put in they're used to be an issue with the way that that was reflected um in the the difference between and so specifically if we think about special education and you look at the contracted costs versus the actual FTE listed as available in Escape it didn't use to match up it was because there was a concern about double counting those costs so Joel's taken the time I know to go through and pull out those costs when

228we're looking at at the vacancies versus the contracts so when you have those come in as actual filling of vacancies then that's going to increase your FTE it would come off of the contract side so it's just a trading one for the other as for some of those that's not going to account for everything I mean I'm just assuming that a vacancy is a budgeted FTE so it should have already been budgeted so that's not what we do I mean yeah so these are the actual FTE for our general fund across all um restricted and unrestricted sources so one example is we got a increased supplemental concentration Grant and we updated our lcap to include uh school-based therapists and other um increased campus supervisors so there are factors behind why we have increased FTE overall

229but we do have an increased FTE so those that FTE is actually what was assigned at those in those years and reported in our financial Sy in our human Financial system so those are some of the reasons that there is increased FTE but there is increased FTE so to revenue for those you you had you had pointed out some some grant money to pay for those positions well so there are we still have those grants monies there was significant one-time monies throughout all those years and as well um we there was a there's one other thing that happened during those years we also had hold harmless our Ada from like8 so so we and we didn't know that so we would have plans to make reductions and do these things but during the pandemic and

230for um you know to to recover that learning loss and we made the decisions that we would um maintain existing services so yeah but so for all the right reasons I get that absolutely so the end result of those that history is that is the actual FTE of actual employees we had uh we assigned in our district that we were so so the difference would be that when you're looking at actual FTE if you recall last year we had a lot of vacancies and some of those safety positions and things like that so those have been filled and so those would now show as FTE where before they would have been showing as vacancies not as actual FTE but if they're okay so it would be me it's it's if they're FTE whether they're filled

231or not our budget our budget should include even those empty spaces because we're budgeting for those positions because if we're hiring if our budget's only what we currently have fill then we have empty positions and when we going to out outside of our budget so that would not be correct for any that are that our plan to be filled with a contracted service because then we would be double budgeting those funds so that's that get yeah so that that is a portion of it so that's part that is part of it is is in there it would not be all of it but that is a portion of it as well as during the year there are substitutes that we budget and then there's class siiz overages that that offset we so we reduce the

232vacancy budget for that but yeah we start off the year projecting an FTE and then we go through the year updating the budget with what's actually happening I I think just again for transparency and for helping our community understand and US understand I mean that makes sense you know if we were Contracting out versus not bringing it in it makes sense my understanding the past is that the Contracting out was more expensive so bringing it in would be cheaper but it seems like we're still spending more um so I think as as information comes up to us and is presented I think one really making clear what's restricted and what's on in situations like that I think maybe highlighting that or separating that or explaining it so folks understand I think would be very helpful

233absolutely and I can share that one of the so while yes we have we have some areas where we've brought on staff it doesn't mean that the cost of the contract has necessarily decrease because the costs of the employees with of the actual Services have increased also so just as our costs increase so do the contracts that's something that because many of of those are actually negotiated through the selpa as a master contract those are things that we're looking at as areas where can we negotiate a a better rate than what we're getting right now through the Sela Master contract those are things that we are that that uh executive director John fiser is actually looking at right now as how we could be more effective and efficient with that as well I think we're

234all really looking forward to seeing how that part improves other questions no okay we did public comments so um if there's no further questions board um is there any motion and this would be a motion to approve the 20242 first interim Report with the Positive certification and and just to clarify because earlier you mentioned something about this would also so this motion approves moving the the interest money into fund 17 so that's included in this certification that is correct that is included in the saxs reports that are attached along with the the budget narrative um with the explanation of that so that would be approving that because it's within those reports could we then really have a clear one sentence summary as to why just as we end this before I make a motion of

235why that that fund 17 interest what yes sure so it's a it would be an in fund transfer to maintain our reserve for economic uncertainty specifically in fund 17 which is a Special Reserve for non- Capital expenditures and where did it come from that concept that idea from fund s from fund 21 from the interest earned on bond funds yes unrestricted interest earned on bond funds and the total amount that total amount was do you recall the number on there it's in the report I don't remember off the top of my head the the the interest earned on the bond so it was dated for the recent bonds back the interest earned was $7.3 million and it's in the sax fund and if you looked at the other funds you can see where the ending

236reserve for the fund 17 increased by that much and the fund 2021 and do by that much and like um Lisa said you're required to um report on your statement for XX reserves in both fund 17 and that would be be there and it's also um assigned as reserve for eom excuse me it's also assigned for reserve for economic uncertainty in fund 17 in the sax and lastly it's kosher right yes and the multi-year projection shows it transferred back in the third year so with that I will move um approval of 2425 fiscal interim um report first interim report um with the hope of positive certification second moved by truste Sheffield seconded by truste De La Cruz is running discussion board let's go to the vote student board members zinka hi trusty Sheffield hi trusty

237De La Cruz hi trusty MCN hi trusty de la Tor hi trusty manieri hi trusty Flores hi president Medina hi and uh can we just make sure that that last uh language is actually typed out in the minutes please I'm not just in the video um thank you uh let's move on to um um C can we um move to extend the meeting maybe like till 10:30 motion to extend the meeting uh till 10:30 second moving seconded um any objections none okay meetings extended to 10:30 okay item F5 discussion interaction there's a first read imposs wave waiver of second read for board policy 6158 let seeing who's presenting got Dr Castro here yeah good evening superintendent Dr Morales president Medina members of the board student staff parents community of sen rosa city schools um we're

238here to um update the board policy to reflect the updates in Senate Bill 15 three I will turn it over to coordinator of alternative education Aaron gild and Goran for the specifics uh superintendent Dr Morales president Medina members of the board um the specific changes to this independent study board policy are um a decrease in the minimum number of days from three days to one day for independent study uh as well as um multiple times in the board policy uh changing the number of days from 15 to 16 for um uh for the number of days uh needed or for the number of days before needing to engage in long-term independent study that's to reflect uh as Dr Castro said um the changes in Senate Bill 153 allowing for up to 15 days of short-term

239independent study um yeah uh thank you any questions board I see none um any public comment I don't see any cards see none back to the board is there a motion um move to approve the first reading and wave the second reading for board policy 6158 I will second moved by trusty lauz second by trusty Sheffield um any discussion see none uh to the vote please student board members Zinga hi trusty De La Cruz hi trusty Sheffield hi trusty mcnali hi trusty deor hi trusty manieri hi trusty Flores hi president Medina I thank you well now move on thank you uh move on to F6 this is uh an action item on the establishment of the annual organization meeting of the Board of Education um oh this is me um so uh we need to

240establish this by law it has to be um after the second Friday December obviously um next well this Friday so um we had to uh add one more meeting to our calendar for our organizational meeting um any questions see none I don't see any public comment um comes back to the board for uh a motion move to establish the annual organizational meeting on December 18th 2024 second mooved by trusty lauz seconded by trusty Sheffield um any discussion see none to the vote student board members Zinga hi trusty De La Cruz hi trusty Sheffield hi trusty MCN hi trusty de laor hi trusty manieri hi trusty Flores hi president Medina hi thank you we will now move on to our consent items um can I get a motion for items G1 through g12 who Moved moved

241by trusty the Cruz second by trusty Sheffield um to the vote please student board member Zinga hi trusty de Cruz hi trusty Sheffield hi trusty mcnali hi trusty deor hi trusty manieri hi trusty Flores hi president Medina hi thank you motion carries now we'll move on to the approval of the minutes for the meeting held on November 13th so moved second moved by trusty lacruz seconded by trusty Flores the vote please student board memb Zinga hi trusty DEA Cruz hi trusty Flores hi trusty Sheffield hi trusty mcnell hi trusty de la Tor hi trusty manieri I president Medina abstain now moving on on to approval of the minutes for the special board meeting held on November 20th we have approval of the special board meeting held on November 20th second I give that to ever

242so moved by uh trusty Sheffield second by truste Flores um to the vote please student board memb Singa yep abstain uh trusty Sheffield hi trusty Flores hi trusty d Cruz hi trusty MCN hi trusty deor hi trusty manieri hi president Medina hi thank you now we will move on to board member requests for information are there any truste Manti please yes I would like to know or be notified if we have any AR um policies that uh tie to the SA Haven resolution that we should be aware of um and any procedures and protocols documents that come out of that um and ideally and the reason I'm asking for that is so that they can be shared with Community as well so I'd like to see those when they're ready thank you other requests for

243information yeah I mean I made this request last time I don't know a while back uh to to and I think um TR lria made the same sort of request to ensure that we get a document mentioning the uh um uh um the a fair share of our um um approved Charter Schools um especially the one that we approved last time uh for special education yeah thank you it's on the list just yeah I it's on the list I only have one more meeting so no pressure um any other requests um not I do have a another request um first uh following up on what trila Cruz mentioned earlier regarding the 2018 and guidance on policy what we implemented so following up on that request earlier I'd also like to request um what the implementation

244plan would be of the safe haven um policy including um what resources we have available for our employees to provide families um such as our family engagement facilitators or counselors Etc um to provide our families or what um Community Partners um they might refer folks to um as well as uh uh um any information on encouraging our students to participate and know your rights workshops and bringing them working with our Community Partners to to have those led by them so that they're better informed um as it relates to um being safe anything I have another one yeah sorry that as well um I know like so uh retirement incentive if we're going to start looking at that as a as a potential cost savings as well homor all right is that it board okay um

245information items are attached to the agenda um with that said um I will now turn the meeting before 10

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.