CorpusRecord 107476

December 2024 Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / South Bay Union School District
Date
2024-12-20
Location
San Diego County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
16,739 words · about 93 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001br up e e e we'll be starting in just a minute we're connecting our Network we'll be starting in a minute thank you [Music] sister my other son Pi thank you good evening good evening trustees superintendent Community welcome to the South Bay Union School District Board of Trustees meeting the time is 6:03 again welcome so good to see a full house thank you very much for coming again this is our meeting it's Thursday December 19th 2024 as a courtesy to others please silence your phone while in the auditorium we appreciate your cooperation all times we're just a tad late today because we did have close session so we appreciate your your patience and uh we want to acknowledge that thank you uh moving on there's a little housekeeping um I'd like to share with you

002today is uh our swearing in day we have three trustees that will be sworn in I'm just setting the table for everybody to know it'll be ceremonial uh family is here to uh help with the swearing in uh prior to uh the six o'clock meeting uh we were sworn in uh officially by our superintendent superintendent uh espanosa so I wanted to put that on the record and so the first part of our um page page two is mostly ceremonial and um I'm glad you're here to watch the progress and uh and uh the community um the heart of our community is our schools so I'm very proud to uh lead our trustees in this day on this day and this hour uh we're ready for number two call uh call to order the r call

003please miss Cooper Esparza here lyker here Lopez agino here Medina here kones here thank you thank you Miss Cooper moving on to ped Pledge of Allegiance tonight we have a special person that's going to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance I'd like to recognize our superintendent Jose espanosa who's going to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance or is it thank you superintendent it's very rare when our superintendent leads us in a pledge so I really want to acknowledge that effort thank you thank you uh after our Pledge of Allegiance we have noted here the pledge will be followed by a performance by the Mendoza ch chamber Ensemble who is behind me sou Union School District's always been proud of our music program as far as I can remember I was a young girl

004uh uh the music program instrumental music program was always always and even in tough times the Board of Trustees in the past 104 years have said no we want instructional music always always so here we go let's let's give them one up round of welcome for no e e for [Music] e for e for e e e I don't know about you trustees but Kelly got me let's give another round of ause again with a little history it's always been the vision of the trustees the Board of Trustees for as long as I've known that's a long time that music instrumental music and art programs were always number one and when it was hard times in the 90s and the hard times in the in the 2008 in the big recession um the music program

005was up for the chopping block and I want to acknowledge the Board of Trustees back then in both decades that saw the vision that wouldn't let go and as you can see we still have our program so thank you Board of Trustees uh we will continue to carry the torch again thank you so much for coming and listening to The Ensemble okay onto our ceremonial part of the um agenda that would be number three oath of office at this time I'd like to call up Manny asara who no yeah who and his wife who will administer the oath of office uh thank you for coming and here we go raise your right hand and repeat after me I state your name I do solemnly swear that I will support and defend the Constitution of the

006United States and the constitution of the State of California against all enemies foreign and domestic s swear that I would support and defend the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California against all enemies born and domestic that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California that I will bear true faith and all Alliance to the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California that I take this obligation freely without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion that I would take this obligation freely without any mental reservations or purpose of evasion and that I will will and Faithfully discharge the duties upon which I am about to enter and that I

007will well and Faithfully discharge the duties upon which I am about to win so help me God so help me congratulations congratulations on your election would you like to say a few words it's been an honor honestly uh to serve the community that I serve my kids my wife my family that're here in front of me and it's a privilege you know to serve you as a community and I'm a I'm gonna be do my best to what's best for our kids for our students thank you thank you so much thank you so much uh we're moving on to trustee Janet Medina Janet Medina would you please take the podium and our superintendent will administer the oath of office thank you all right please raise your right hand stand here this right face me I

008think the camera can see you okay thank you I state your name do solemnly swear that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California against all enemies foreign and domestic Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California against all enemies brain and domastic that I will bear true faith and abundance to the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California that it will bear through faith and Alliance to the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California that I take this obligation freely without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion that I take this obligation freely without any mental reservation or purpose of and that I will well and

009Faithfully discharge the duties upon which I am about to enter that I will well and Fa of discharge the duties upon which I am about to enter congratulations trusty Medina would you like to say a few words I'll just want I just want to say that I'm here another four years and um that I will be putting kids first in this next four years give her around the clock and the next to do the oath oath of office would be Cheryl kones and while I'm out of my seat I'm handing my Gabel over to my vice president medinaa my family will join me ready right raise your right hand and repeat after me I state your name do solemnly swear that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States and the constitution

010of the State of California against all enemies foreign and domestic that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California Al andit of the state that I take this obligation freely without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion and that I will well and Faithfully discharge the duties upon which I'm about to enter congratulations those two are my granddaughters first granddaughter and second granddaughter who are both in college I'm very very proud of them and my son-in-law there to my left and my husband uh my other family is enjoying a San Diego concert that my grandson is in and so they couldn't make it but um thank you family thank you for supporting me and thank you community um um this is

011my third term and uh I appreciate the community uh that uh we are all of us and that each and every day we strive to do better for children and our community and with our voices collectively together we do that and we will do that and we'll continue to do that again thank you so much for coming and um and that would be the end thank you okay moving on to board organization the president will now open the nominations uh for the election of the new president once the new president is elected he or she will carry on the other reorganizations of the business item of the board so at this time I will open the floor for nominations is there nominations for the president for 2025 open nominations trusty espasa I would like to

012nominate trustee Janet Medina for poor president do you accept that nomination um sorry I declined the nomination I would like to nominate um president Char pones because she is the most knowledgeable right now in the situation that we are in and I hope the board supports that so we got that okay um so moving on we have a nomination uh um from trusty Medina for kones uh do we have any other nominations trusties or president of the board um I would like to nominate uh trusty lyer you accept that nomination trusty ler yes yes I very good very at this time um I will take a motion right I don't have my grid here any discussion we're gonna move to discussion well before motion okay so I'd like to open up the floor to try

013like her uh could you share a little bit about um as if if elected a president what shall you uh say do and support um in all honesty it's with great hesitation as you could see because it um it entails a lot of responsibility not just um up here but also as far as responding to emails and having knowledge of things um where I have I've grown the last two years I would continue to to grow knowledgeably but I would hope that um I would see would receive Grace from the community that I receive or the community that I serve um because it is a very hard position I have seen you very gracefully up here um and I know it's not easy so um I would do my best and hope that I would

014receive Grace and blessing from the community thank you Kelling um for myself um I'd like to share that um this is not my first go around it's not my first rodeo uh this is the third time so uh um in that um review uh I've learned a lot and uh and this board here has taught me a lot and as a president uh you have to balance out um the board as a president and taking yourself out of that equation by lifting up the trustees in in the direction that we all want to go so in that vein uh I continue to work hard I'm a lifelong learner um I do many things to uh for uh professional growth that doesn't cost a district any money I study I look for ways to find money

015uh to support our staff and students and uh we'll continue in that vein um if elected president thank you may I have a motion trusty gonz I believe we have some more discussion I'm sorry more discussion I'm sorry go ahead I'm sorry didn't I just like to say a few words about why I nominated uh trustee lyer to be the president for this upcoming year um I really appreciate um like truste lers experience from being in the classroom herself um she you know has a lot of uh right a lot of experience like as a parent as a teacher um and I feel can see all different sides um of what's Happening um and I believe that you know trusty kones has done a great job as our board president this last year um and

016could be a great support for trusty liyer um you know I would love to see you know trusty Kon is like in a vice president role supporting trusty lyer in this uh process um but I do think it is a good opportunity to have like a new person that does have some experience uh trusty lyer has served as the clerk already um so I would uh really like to continue to see her grow uh in this board so thank you any other um things You' like to share go ahead well first of all uh I would like to say a few thanks uh um trusty uh Kelly she's a wonderful mother a great teacher I think we got a lot of experience coming from her I think she would do great as a as a

017board president thank you yes okay any other words no hearing none we'll call for a motion is there a motion for the name of a nomination that has accepted the role of President is there a nomination I'd like to motion to nominate trusty lyer for the president of the South Bay Union School District Board of Trustees is there a second I'll second that okay we'll call go ahead and call for the vote here on our little tablet go ahead and vote everyone has [Music] voted motion passed - Z congratulations and just as Thomas congratulations again Kelly I know you'll do one we need to go on the agenda trustees we need to correct uh the vote the vote is cor oh we have an exstension okay four and one exstension it didn't come up on

018my board I'm sorry four and one abstention correct no it is four yeses and one no four yeses and one no thank you thank you this is all a new system so thank you for your patience okay so Kelly now okay um thank you very much for your trust in me um I we will continue here okay so the next sorry all right so now it is time to um elect a vice president do I hear a nomination I nominate Cheryl kones as vice president any other nominations I would like to nominate truste Lopez for vice president um I accept the nomination and president Madam president I decline but thank you um so we uh is there any discussion yes thank you I'm so excited for next year I'm so excited because uh having new

019uh leaders on the board it's uh an exciting transition uh to hear and see uh their vision and I'm looking forward to that whole year of experience and and uh I'm going to vote for you thank you uh do I hear a motion I move that trust uino Lopez aguino uh for the position of Vice President of the Board of Trustees I second that call for a vote what's your Bo what's your vote motion carried congratulations AO um next on our agenda is the election of clerk do I hear any nominations I have a quick question what does board clerk do um thank you for your qu question um trusty kones um so as the board clerk I report out on what actions have been taken in Clos session and then I also um share

020or sign off on paperwork regarding the action that has been taken in close session I'd like to nominate trusty espara for to be the board clerk I I wasn't expecting that but uh it's it's been an honor I think I will accept that any discussion any other nominations okay I move to vote I move to accept the nomination of truste Raza for our board clerk for second call for a vote uh motion carried congratulations truste far um oh next um a appointment of district superintendent as secretary to the Board of Trustees I'm you're good I move to appoint the district superintendent as a secretary to the Board of Trustees second call for a vote motion carried 5 to zero moving right along um adopt the resolution 24-9 in the matter of Board of Trustees code

021of ethics which is board bylaw 9271 I'd like to make a motion to adopt the resolution 24- 009 I'll second that call for the vote okay it is now time for a brief intermission thank you everyone and we're just going to take a couple of minutes e e e thank you all for that brief intermission we're ready to start again I appreciate your patience as as we continue thank you um thank you at this time trustees or executive team members May recommend changing the order of agenda items oh we're still waiting for people to have a seat my apologies oh sorry I want all the pens thank you okay thank you at this time trustees or executive team members May recommend changing the order of agenda items and are request that an item from the

022consent calendar be placed within the discussion action section of the board meeting um the secretary will keep track of any recommendations please note no new items may be added without Advance public notice I apologize so as the there's no um thank you okay I skipped apart um there's no action there was no action taken in close session so as the clerk that was my duty to report that there was no action so now at this time um any changes to the agenda okay so then um approval of meeting agenda do I have a motion to or yes okay so we approve the do we take a vote I'm sorry I'm sorry who made the first I move to approve the meeting agenda as presented for the December 19th 2024 board meeting I'll second that call

023for a vote agenda is approved thank you um Communications to the Board of Trustees we have a five minute limit per group first up we have um South Bay PTA Council good evening board members President lyker congratulations um my report is very short tonight because I gave my count my president's the month off for a meeting so they've been very busy doing taxes and paying insurance and all the minutia of being a good PTA in good standing so they got today off to do family stuff school stuff fun stuff so there is a little token of our esteem on um or that we passed out to you earlier to wish you a happy holidays no not that it's the card we were not that fancy yes but to thank you for your membership and your

024your support um for South Bay PTA so happy holidays I would like to also switch hats for just a second because we just wrapped up our snowman program which I'm a part of also because I can't say no and and I know we have many of the supporters here in our audience we have um board member support so I just wanted to report that we serviced 42 families and 12 seven children with gifts food and gift cards for the holidays so thank you very much thank you so much um next we have um California School Employees Association chapter [Music] 59 all right thank you congratulations on your appointment as uh president great moving along we have um uh Southwest Teachers Association good evening trustees colleagues parents students and community members Members First I would like

025to thank our members parents students and community members present tonight to support our students SW was hopeful that tonight we would be here to celebrate an agreement reached unfortunately that is not the case our bargaining team continues to produce thoughtful contract Solutions in negotiations the district continues to refuse to negotiate in good faith topics opened by their initial bargaining Sunshine approved by you the trustees last spring swata is committed to seeking a fair deal and continues to propose language and negotiations that values both our work and our students needs it Bears repeating that the Southwest Teachers Association is asking for lower class size and special education to ensure students are safe and their academic needs are met and that bilingual combination classes receive an instructional assistant for 120 minutes per day and lower class size

026to ensure two grade levels in the same class have the appropriate support for smaller general education classes to make sure that there is room for special education allowing them to learn alongside their peers and receive grade level instruction as is required by the law to protect teacher specialist collaboration time for improved student outcomes for parent teacher conferences days to be protected because our time with parents is important as it supports relationship building for competitive salary and benefits to attract and retain the most qualified Educators for our students and for protection of our Personnel files and fairness and just cause rights in teacher discipline I'd like to remind you that there is not a money problem here in the South Bay the district has a priorities problem the district prioritize is saving versus Services money for

027classrooms set idle in the bank while Educators and students lack curriculum resources and adequate support services and Staffing especially in special education this week the Chula Vista School District approved a special education teacher signing bonus $15,000 the Chula Vista school district is putting students first their message is clear to their parents and their Community they care about their most vulnerable students if we were losing our staff to them before just wait what's going to happen in 2025 effective immediately many of our members will see a reduction in their take-home pay you heard a reduction starting today right and in this paycheck this is a direct result of the rising health insurance premiums and the district unwillingness to adjust salary or benefits a member at the beginning of the salary schedule currently has a starting salary

028of 63,0 47 minus their annual out of outof pocket health benefits of 7,710 that actually means that they only make 55,69969 before their disability before their taxes now if you thought that was a little look what's going to happen now with the health benefits increased they will only be making 53,723 n90 less annually even with the current 1% offer that is on the table the begin of the salary schedule would see a pay cut of $1,356 annually while our staff here in the South Bay are taking pay cuts our neighboring District of national city has just been given an increase in their health benefits in the amount of over 8,975 per person I'm going to repeat that to you $18,000 $975 per person and they also have a pulling system like we do so while

029national city has increased South Bay continues to only cover $15,300 per person guess where people are going to go our message is clear we want to show our community that we care that we care about our neighborhood schools that we care about what parents want for their children and not just a lip service and advisory committees but that we care about our Educators in the classrooms every day that we care to work to attract and retain Educators in measurable ways and that we care about our children's education we the Educators love our students we love our schools we love our community that's why we're still here we want you the South Bay Union School District to show you you love them too by putting students and staff first and exit savings last I hope you

030will take the winter break to reflect on what kind of District you want South Bay to be do you want us to be a district that puts students and staff first or do you want to be a district that puts upper management first happy holidays thank you superintendent thank you I would like to ask trusty kores to join me at the podium please it is my pleasure to recognize you for your service as board president this year this plaque reads in appreciation for your leadership service and dedication to our students staff and board colleagues Cheryl thank you for all you have done and for being a great partner in our work thank you superintendent thank you for your service Cheryl okay um next on the agenda we have public comments on non- agenda items we

031have six cards thank you Frank cherry so just a reminder before we get started the board will take no action or discussion on any item not appearing on the posted agenda except by authorized by law individual speakers are allowed three minutes to address the board on each non-agenda item speakers are not permitted to yield their time to another person and the board limits the total time of public comment input to minutes which I think we're going to be just fine hello yes okay Cheryl of all the board members the only only only one up here is probably going to remember um superintendent ashel superintendent th go back to grignan um all the former Su superintendents as long as there was collective bargaining swata being the largest of the bargaining units would settle and CSEA and

032the administrators would kind of go along with the me too clause and I remember time when principles had asked me when we're going to settle and sometimes they even said hey hold on a little bit longer hang out for more but all that changed when Pat petet became our superintendent you remember that he got the board members to drink the Kool-Aid and he told them that administrators need more pay to be more competitive with other districts and to retain them H well what it actually actually accomplished was it drove a wedge between swata csca and the administration the chasm that was created by that wedge has done nothing but gotten worse over the years as you can tell tonight we've got so many people here when they should be home with their families the superintendent

033now he's got 4% retro he's got 4% in the future for a few years full medical insurance for his family um I'm sure there's more car allowance whatever but what I'm going to do right now is just urge you to go back to treating all employees equitably offer the same 4% to the SWAT of members CA and health benefits um there's also something else last time I was up here I said you know you can get rid of him and I'll be a superintendent for a first year teacher salary no no no no no NOP I'm gonna withdraw that I'll do it for a dollar a year I'll do it without medical insurance without a car allow without a travel budget without anything else $1 a year you could keep me for a couple years

034and be way ahead financially um and I'm not going out on a limb too far I think when I feel confident in saying the district will be better off educationally for the students better off financially for the district and better off for the morale of the district which is probably at an all time blow bottom line I guarantee you a district whose true function and mission is to provide student centered learning opportunities that appropriately Challenge and support every child to learn grow and Thrive Merry Christmas to all and to all a good night Melissa Romo do I push a button I'm good okay good evening let me start by saying that I was extremely disappointed by the FAQs that were sent out to parents last Friday December 13th the letter starts out and I quote

035keeping our students parents employees and Community fully informed regarding the status of ongoing negotiations with swata end quote this phrase includes the word employees yet I nor several of my colleagues received this newsletter in fact we have not received an update from the district for last Wednesday Wednesday's negotiations why is that the letter goes on to say that these FAQs are intended to provide straightforward and factual information as a member of sw's bargaining team I find that this letter paints a vague picture it states that the district is offering us an ongoing salary schedule increase one-time pay payments and increased annual contributions to employee benefits but there are no specifics it does not say we were only offered 1% on schedule 2% bonus and 200 $50 a year to our employee benefits it also fails

036to inform the community that our health benefits increase by more than 2,000 a year with this communication it is not clear to the community that teachers will be bringing home less money starting today because of this increase if we accept the district's 1% on salary 2% bonus and 250 a year in added contributions to health benefits we will be making less money for an entire year or more as a bargaining member please tell me how I could settle for this in addition the letter mentions that employees have received salary increases totaling 13% since 20121 are we the only ones who have received these increases why doesn't it mention the salary increase of our superintendent and our assistant superintendence if you're going to be transparent then you must bring up all salaries does that not matter

037to the community these FAQs mentioned that members are also to re that also receive annual increases AKA stepping column increases this is not true for all of us those of us who have been working in this district for more than 21 years no longer receive this our salary scale stops at year 21 I can go on and on but I only have three minutes my point is that if we're going to inform the community of ongoing negotiations then we need to be fully transparent I urge you the board to be more involved and ask questions you have been vocal about wanting us to be here present at the board meetings this is my fourth month here I'm missing time away from my family and time away from my workout routine which helps my physical and

038mental health just as you asked me I challenge all five of you to visit the schools more regularly thank you president gones and trustee Medina for visiting our school yesterday walk into the mid mild mod mod Sever and seas classroom see for yourself while we're asking for Less students in a class walk into the 16 combo classes and get a feel for the extra stress on these teachers who have to teach double the curriculum what we're asking for you from for sorry what we are asking for is not unreasonable if you value the students and employees of sosd as much as you do the district leaders then you will encourage your team to do better for us Road s good evening South Bay Union Board of Trustees superintendent Espinosa colleagues and community members today I

039want to discuss the rising cost of health insurance for our certificated staff as you may know our monthly cost of health insurance for family coverage through Kaiser the less expensive option is rising to $950 a month I want to paint a picture for you a certificated employee at the low end of the pay scale making $63,000 per year might take home 30 uh $3,800 per month after taxes and stirs and this is being generous and using 25% what I get taken out is closer to theity personally if this employee has a family that they need to cover that number would drop down to $2,850 a month in their paycheck after paying for health insurance that's all they would have left to pay for food housing and other basic needs I looked at the cost of

040two bedroom apartments in Imperial Beach and I could find none that costs less than $2,200 per month and most were closer to 3,000 that's before the cost of utilities add in a car payment gas costs and more and a single per a single parent working as a certificated employee in our district living in Imperial Beach will be consistently in the negatives each month even for many of our more established employees who may be higher up on the salary schedule are going to be struggling with the rising out-of pocket cost of our health insurance without a significant raise or significant increase in the district's contribution to our health insurance cost even the best employed best paid employees will be losing money by staying in our district Any teacher who has to pay for their family's health

041insurance is going to see a significant pay cut in January and it will be noticed we already have a lot of certificated employees who are struggling to make ends meet we already have teachers who are leaving our district to find employment elsewhere because they can't afford to keep working here in South Bay where are they going to go while the district does not control the rising cost of health insurance which is an issue that goes far beyond the stretch of our employees the district does have the the power to increase the share that they cover and other districts are doing exactly that currently national school district is already paying $17,500 towards their employees health insurance cost each year um and the negotiations update we just got suggests that they're now up to $1,975 of their

042contribution an increase of $1,475 per year while we are losing out on our end chivista educators are going through similar uh negotiations and seeing increases there as well and San Diego unified is probably the most attractive for many employees looking to flee since they cover the full cost of health insurance benefits for their certificated employees and their families I want to finish by saying that it's logical and responsible to have savings set aside for a rainy day and as a parent I make sure I have an emergency fund and I try to save for other things however if I look down at my children and saw that their basic needs were not being met it would not be reasonable for me to continue saving for things far off in the future that might not come

043to fruition I would need to readjust and make sure my children's basic needs are being met right now our district has a significant rainy day fund and some of our employees basic needs are not being met it's time for our district to reassess how they are spending their money thank you Michelle Gates hi president like her hello Board of Trustees superintendent Espinosa um I'll remind you I'm here as one of your teachers but I do have some insight for you that I hope you will take to hurt because some of you seem to be confused about uh what this meeting is for the Ralph m brown act also known as the open meeting law is a California law that guarantees the Public's right to attend and participate in meetings of local legislative bodies the brown

044Act was passed in 1953 to make public officials accountable for their actions and to allow the public for participation in decision Mak thinking once you have agendized your meeting all the gavel banging and all the yelling that gets done up here threatening to throw people out for clapping and for being just gruntled and upset for a moment nah and whatever's been said by the superintendent regarding that n a couple other things your president doesn't get to shut you up when you are actually saying something that is not out of close session they don't it's not real tell her to stuff it if it happens again um we also know full well that you're trying to wait us out um after this paycheck I'll just say y'all screwed up because no one is going to be

045happy about the cut that they just took while y'all are waiting and playing games and being disrespectful in the way that you explain what happened in your public Communications to the community last but not least classy means admin goes last not first that applies to every single one of them and as a board to approve that before you approved the 300 plus teachers and the and and the more classified employees that's wrong last but not least you could have said no lth melindes I have my Army back here with me good good evening Board of Trustees I'm here today to ask for a fair contract as a teacher at Nester Language Academy my Duty goes beyond the contracted hours like many of my colleagues here I often stay beyond the hours of Labor or get

046there earlier to prepare and plan engaging lessons I've paid out of my pocket for student gifts parties school supplies among other things to encourage and motivate my students to always do their best just yesterday I spent over $150 to make their learning memorable and give them a little bit of winter cheer you should do the same with your teachers personally I have a one-year-old daughter that the time I spent with her is as many of you know precious time that I will never get back yet here I am pleading for a fair contract for fair pay and this is time away from my baby that I should be there with her this cut will affect my family in many ways between bills rent gas child care I'm really starting to question whether I need a

047second job or even reconsider my profession I'm in the teaching field like many of the teachers here because it's our passion not because of the pay but how much humiliation do we need to tolerate where we need to even consider a second job we're professionals here so in the holiday spirit of giving come on give us a fair contract don't be a grinch Melissa Camaro hello my name is Melissa Camaro and I'm a moderate to severe teacher at nicoloff elementary and so I decided to do something a little bit different than the average speech so the other night I was working on two IEPs so I decided to write goal for S spusd so so we can start we can start off with the Baseline our Baseline is many classrooms are filled to cap creating

048unsafe and unmanageable learning environments that are not conducive to learning teachers are overwhelmed trying to meet the needs of all of their students so the goal I wrote is by December 19 2025 s spusd will put students first by one lowering class size two putting money back into the classroom and three treating teachers like humans with 100% accuracy over 185 contractor days as measured by student academic achievement student safety and teacher retention thank you that was the last card thank you for your comments okay um we will move on to discussion action items and general functions um 2025 Board of Trustees meeting dates recognize superintendent Jose Espinosa and approve the 2025 Board of Trustees meeting dates am I thank you am I in the right president ler uh as part of its annual organizational meeting

049the board approves a schedule of meetings for the coming year we recommend that the 2025 regular board meetings continue in burus Auditorium and be live streamed as in the past special meetings may be called as necessary we respectfully request that the board approve that 2 Board of Trustees meeting dates we'll wait a moment for quiet or or do we have any discussion about that yes any discussion we need a motion and then discussion okay I was just waiting for it to quiet down for a moment thank you um do I have a motion to approve I'll move I'll move I'll move this way okay I move to accept the 2025 Board of trusteed meeting dates as presented do I have a second I'll second that discussion I would like the board to support me to

050accept the Wednesdays but until March due to I had already committed to personal since this was approved back in the beginning of the year so what I heard was that she that um Tristy Medina moves to um wants to approve it accept it except beginning in March because starting in Wednesdays beginning March because there are already appointment or something El scheduled that seems reasonable just clarifying question are you saying Wednesday meetings until March and then starting April Thursdays Thursday meetings in January February and then starting March we moved to Wednesdays so that there's no conflict with um other district meetings yes the the reason that um that it was recommended to go from Thursday to Wednesday meetings is that we had a lot of conflicts with um with sw's meetings as well and we were

051trying to avoid those conflicts um so that was a suggestion to move our board meetings till Wednesday yeah I you know it is it's a lot of conflict on my schedules in regards to Wednesdays move back to Wednesdays um but I I do support um trustee Medina to skipped a couple of months and move from started on March um I do had to um move my schedule as well as you know we all have jobs to do so now would we vote on or would we Mo do a motion first and then vote to approve starting March yeah so we would have a motion if if that is what the board is is requesting that January and February remain a Thursday meeting um we would need to look at the calendar to see which which

052Thursday it is and then starting in March we could accept the because you guys have the the calendar of meetings in front of you then starting in March we could accept that if that is what the board is is requesting yes trusty Kion thank you Madame President thank you um superintendent espanosa for uh sharing that um our labor partners partners are important to us and so much that we would do the heavy lifting to move it to a Wednesday I remember when we changed it from 7 pm to 6 pm and what what that meant to The District in terms of work to get the um board agenda ready so uh let me again say thank you for recognizing that uh we do appreciate our labor partners and by bringing this calendar as you have

053for a Wednesday uh is a clear indication that we work collaboratively with our labor Partners uh I am in full support uh of the January and February uh remaining to the Thursday uh but I want to recognize that having Wednesday starting in March March uh that um trustees we have our superintendent meetings on Tuesday the agenda is published on Friday so you'll meet with the superintendent I just share this with you on Tuesday and that will give you no time to sit and Ponder what the agenda is and we'll come to work on Wednesday night so again I support Janet uh I'm open to any kind of change but I want to recognize the efforts that that the superintendent has uh put forth here and the reason why so thank you superintendent with that uh

054if there's any other discussion I'll move to uh approve the uh calendar as amended one more I I do have a conflict that first Thursday in January um if I can get permission to not be here in January I'm not sure how that would work so then would we uh try to change it to a different Thursday in January no so right now now we have the January date is January 22nd um and if we chose to leave it on Thursdays it would be the 23rd um I think at this time um you know we may I know that there's also staff that that have some conflicts uh and it may be that because of this change um you know we just need to approve either that Thursday or the Wednesday and then if um

055you know if if someone can't be here um then you know they can't be here uh there's a there's a process for that um but I would say at this time um you know we either approve the Wednesday January 22nd or the Thursday January 23rd and for February it is also either February 18 oh that's I'm sorry that's a different one February 19th uh which be the Wednesday and we either approve that or we approve the 20th um and then you know if if um somebody cannot attend there is there is a process for that and is it possible to pick a different date January like a different th Thursday like I could do the the 16th or the 30th or the I mean I could do any Thursday that month yeah the the problem

056with the 16th is um you know the staff returns well School resumes on the 13th right for January and so we would have to post the agenda on the 10th for a meeting on the 16th so it's just a a really quick turnaround that that is that is the problem with that um and for the 30th um I will not be in the district at that time either but you know if if that is what the board chooses um I am sure we will be able to work something out so at this time from what I understand we need to vote on either keeping Thursdays January February with the understanding that one day will be missed or to should we vote on that first or we would have to have a motion with the new

057dates so whatever those are so if we choose if we choose to change the January and February dates if that's what the board is choosing then we would have to have the new dates and make a motion with the new dates somebody would have to second that and then we would have a vote on it if we choose to accept them on the Wednesdays all the way down then you would just make a motion to accept the dates that are currently on the calendar those are our choices can I make a motion to change the date for January 30th or I'd like to amend the original a motion um and have the January meeting be January 30th and in February February 20th MH and the rest as is are we open for discussion yes we're

058in discussion now okay so um I definitely I just want to say something real quick second we need a second M president so from what I from my understanding is we have a motion then we need a second and then there would be a vote and if if we wanted to do something differently then we would vote no and then you have a you have a motion on the floor then you need a second then discussion then vote okay I second that call for the vote discussion sorry okay so basically um why do want to give Su the opportunity to um be informative and have a time you know as it's also same as the board I don't want to have any conflicts I think starting in March I think will give us enough time

059uh for me it was just like couple of months the head I I need to get ready so um like I said want to give you plenty of opportunity for SW as well and for the board okay um I have to add something um just learned that um the city of IB already has burus reserved for the 30th for state of the of the city I believe um just vice president Lopez agino um requested uh the 20th 30th oh sorry okay we go and how much of a challenge is it to do it on the 16th it's going to be a challenge because again staff doesn't schools don't resume till the 13th and so many staff will be gone the week of the 6th through the 10 temp where we would be putting the agenda

060together so it's it's it's a pretty big challenge for staff um my recommendation is to go ahead and go with the 23rd um and again we have a structure in place for for a Miss meeting um I would be okay with that unless you guys wanted to consider a Tuesday the 21st discussion well it seems that the beginning of the year is going to be a little little wonky little willy-nilly if if you say so I mean a Tuesday is fine with me so do I hear a motion to approve uh Tuesday or I'm sorry you have did you want to say something I moveed to amend the amend amended motion to uh to um say that we meet on the 21st of January and the 20th of February I second the motion is there

061a discussion call for a vote mam president yes oh oh I'm sorry we have a conflict okay that may not have been known but Martin Luther King is Monday so to have the meeting on Tuesday would probably really be a stretch because of um agenda comes on Friday and Monday is holiday and Tuesday we would have no time to review the agenda you'd have to do it on your own okay you know that works for me I'm I'm open but we have aot going already so we um um it looks Tuesday the that's why I'm yeah I I put no because we just realized that Monday is Martin Luther King day and I think we're off that day and agenda comes out a few days before so is there any way we can go back

062now stay back too late well it looks like you guys already voted and the motion passed um so I believe we can can we vote whether or not we should revote no we can vote just on that January date so if somebody wants to open that back up I mooved to open up the January date I second it oh discussion okay all right so what dates are we looking at now I'm fine with whatever I'm so yeah I had the same concern that Jose did uh with the publishing of the agenda on the Friday and then holiday on Monday and then meeting on Tuesday which doesn't give time to uh and it's not required but doesn't give us any time with the superintendent so um I'm fine either way but um I do hear you

063Jose so the 23rd can we go back to the 23rd to see if we can uh have the board meeting on the 23rd January of next year so I would like to motion to have our board meeting on January 23rd 2025 I second the motion discussion I'm confused I thought we said on the 23rd there was something on the 23rd um truste um Lopez agino cannot attend and so we've tried with other dates and I think what the next option is is to go back to one of the or original amendments to have January February remain on Thursdays and begin Wednesdays in March so can can we get a motion to approve that Amendment okay I thought we already had a motion did somebody make a motion gonna vote now vote we had a motion

064and a second I believe Amy yes we had a motion in a second for January 23rd yes so we'll call for a vote thank you for your patience Esparza lier yes Lino yes Medina yes can yes motion passes 5 okay okay so just in summary we voted for January 23rd that's going to be our our board meeting February 20th and then all the rest of the dates that are there Perfect all right thank you so much moving on um the governance document subcommittee I recognize superintendent Jose Espinosa and to uh and to appoint two board members to serve on the governance document subcommittee thank you president president lyer um the district regularly regularly has board policies administrative regulations and board bylaws that require updating to increase theic efficiency of this process the board established a

065subcommittee in 2023 to review governance documents for referral to the board for a final reading each year during its organizational meeting the board is asked to appoint members to the subcommittee we respectfully request that the board appoint two board members to serve on the subcommittee for 2025 so do we have any nominations is that I appoint I we nominate so you can nominate someone they can accept the nomination and then they will be appointed there the board will vote on it do we have any nomination does anybody else have any nominations or any volunteers or volunteers I nominate Cheryl kones I'm sorry I've been on it for two years I nominate Jose to shame um yeah I'll do it I I nominate Manny okay I nominate Kelly I how to decline I accept my children

066are at home too though alliv work I mean okay sorry my apolog I accept Okay we have trusty Lopez agino and president liyer um call for a vote call for a vote okay oh right here what are we voting on here or do I call for a vote it's going to pop up on I see thank you okay motion passes 4 Z congratulations thank you for your service all right um next we have educational leadership uh District English learner advisory commit committee report I recognize director paa Flores for a report on the recent activities of the the daac committee thank you good evening president lier Board of Trustees superintendent esposa exe cabin executive cabinet and Community this evening our em Equity multilingual Learners and Innovation Department Emmy um would like to provide you with a

067midyear update on our daac I am going to turn the mic over to our coordinator to coordinator robless who does a phenomenal uh does phenomenal work behind the scenes to organize facilitate um and increase parent engagement so at this moment I'm going to turn it over to coronat rois good evening to all and those are who are still here present um I do want to acknowledge that we do have our elected president for our daac um seora Cynthia delin um I know she's been here a long time waiting um and she deserves to be acknowledged and celebrated um for being elected as president but also for hanging on with her two children so I'm going to fast forward a bit so that she can okay so I'm gonna have her come up and introduce herself

068hello good evening um my English is a little bit limitated but um I'm a mom represent end in um nicolov school I'm a parent of two children attending a nickolov um one in kindergarten and the other one in fourth grade um the reason why I got chosen to be a president one I voted for me and then the other moms vorted for me because they wanted me to to represent any needs or any other tools or strategies that our children need to get a better education at Nicola um one of them is to maintain our dual language program and to get better even better um [Music] and uh just like the I already and the imagine learning to maintain um them as well but we also uh need like a a little bit support and

069Improvement in the Dual language for English and Spanish as well and U maybe understanding the leader literature in English and Spanish for them because I see like in conferences I see that they having a little bit trouble understanding the um the [Music] main content of the of the stories the the teacher um always uh given like a test or examp on any um paragraphs so I believe we need um like maybe an application that helps them um understand even better the um the story the main um the main the main idea of the uh story because I see that they they they have um um they have they have struggling in uh understanding the main ideas and then maybe not given like choices a maybe see but like maybe like promoting a like open mind

070answer well that's one of the um when we had the meeting um at school with the principal that's where we talk about that it wasn't only my child but like most of the other children's students attending a nikolov they have struggle with the um with the with the with the reading and understanding the main idea of the stories in English and Spanish and well I'm a little bit nervous but yeah thank you so much thank you for that insight thank you Miss Cynthia all right so um so I'm here to give you an update regarding our um last our past two um deac meetings that we've had this far um for this school year um so in September the meeting was held at Barry Elementary and principal um prosapio um gave highlights um during that

071time we also very important important part of the beginning of the year is to go over um our deac and elac roles and responsibilities um with our with our parents um we also covered um annual notifications um as required by law we have to inform our parents each year um of our students uh of their child's e status um whether they are um long-term Els um um or at risk of be coming El's or they're just currently an e um English learner status um and so we have various letters that go out throughout the year and as they go out during our deac meetings we um inform of the parents of what the letter reads and what it looks like we also um went through our reclassification criteria we um went through it with the

072parents and we also allowed for them the ask questions um and then of course they you know they did and then it was brought to you here um during the board meeting to also um approve um at the end we ended our meeting with um inviting our parents um for the cab mini conference and in that we let them know that um our department would be paying for two parents at each School site and so we um let principles know as well they send us names and we were able to register um the parents to attend um last month I believe was our I mean November yes last month all right so moving on to our November meeting um this was held at Central Elementary where principal Salazar um was able to um highlight um

073Central um here in this meeting we voted an elect did our daac officers um one as you um saw Miss um Cynthia met her here um for our president um director Susie Chavez also went through the title one engagement policy which is a policy that outlines um how schools and ourselves as a district um need to create spaces where parents are engaged in different processes and also their involvement and input in our various settings and committees that are held such as School site Council Ela and delx um parents there were also able to provide um feedback um through questions that were provided and they were collected um during that meeting as well um we also discussed proposition 58 um to our parents we had the flyer um they were able to review we discussed discuss

074the importance of proposition 58 um including you know one of our schools um nicoloff Elementary who went through you know the process of involve um of their parents being um involved in that um and they um parents were able to ask questions regarding the process and inquiring about you know opening um dual language schools here at South Bay and lastly we ended the meeting with letting our parents know that that um in their Ela they would be given an opportunity to provide um their input through the um elac needs assessment um and so currently um we have received a few of our um elac needs assessments already um parents left with um the document um and the questions that they would be asked um during their elac so that they would go in prepared already

075into their elac meeting meetings um to be able to provide um input um during that time um and so we are very um excited that we were able to elect our deac officers um U president Cynthia delin who represents ncol nikoloff Elementary um she has um two children one in uh a fourth grader and one of a one being the first um kindergarten um and then um we do have a pending voting of Vice President um Elizabeth Basera from Nester Language Academy so during our meeting we actually had four um parents who were elected um two of them being a tie for secretary one for vice president um and one for president um however after um me reaching out to each of the elected officers and just you know explaining and getting them to come

076to one of our um meetings that just happened last week um one of them unfortunately said that they would no longer be able to commit to the um position so in that case because we did have a tie um in the secretary position um one of the parents um Elizabeth B who was elected as a secretary um um expressed interest um in being vice president so in our next um daac meeting in January um January 14th um we will be taking it to our deac um parents um to vote um and see if there are an agreement of Miss lisabeth B being our vice president for deac um mini gab 2024 was very exciting we had the most most um parents um attending um this um this year so there you see the number of

077count we had a total of 30 parent Guardians attending there are a few pictures that we um were captured um during that conference and we are excited to keep the momentum and get more parents to um join that conference as it is very um educational and informative for them and last last but not least here um during the conference we had our small and mighty group of nicolov Elementary um where here you see our two dual language teachers Miss um Miranda and Miss Anita uh Nas who along uh with their parent Advocates um they presented during our mini conference conference and so we see that there is parent empowerment and how our teachers and parents are coming together um um parent Janet Medina and Miss Ola um were present and they co- um worked and

078co-created um their presentation and were able to deliver um their presentation regarding the process of Nicola becoming a dual language school as well as also informing the uh the present parents there during the conference of proposition 58 um and the importance of that um proposition coming through and the difference it has you know um made in um us having now nickoloff Elementary as a do language school all right so strategies for growth um our really our focus is to strengthen our delx and elac and we've um really hyperfocused on some items this year um we've provided new times and these new times have really been based off the feedback that our de deac parents um provided last school year so we now have a start time of 900 a.m. because we do have early and

079late start schools and we wanted to ensure that we gave parents enough time um to drive to the location of our deac meetings um we also provide synchronous online option so during our daac meeting we also have um our Zoom um open for parents to join um this last daac we had um two parents on zoom and then we also offer the on the online evening option via Zoom um we've had also parents join our Zoom uh meeting in the evening so that's a you know uh another option for our families um who who have numerous um you know other things to take care of um throughout the day and then last but not least um our department has really collaborated with our School principles um this school year to really have functioning elax up

080and running and so we've um gathered list from our English learner um parents at the sites um and we have um contacted um parents one to one and thanks to that Outreach we now have two more three more functioning elac at South Bay and so really our goal is to get our parents informed to get them to our elac and to get those um representatives from elac into our deac um meetings so here you have our future meetings um our next one coming back from the new year January 14th and that will be at nicolov elementary thank you questions the best part of the night right questions sorry any question uh first of all thank you so much for your presentation it's excellent um anything that has to do with uh uh empowering parents you

081know that's does my goals to get all the parents involved um strong education starts at home I'm a strong believer and I'm and I can tell you that uh from my own experience how did you reach out to those parents uh what is the strategies that you guys as as what elect representative how do you uh get the word out so um last year we are daac officers they first of all they were awesome they created a brochure for us that explained like come join elac um so we did distribute those flyers um each site got hundreds of them and they were um they were tasked with um Distributing those brochures out at their sites um we also have you know various um ways that we're able to identify identify our families of English Learners

082um so really the best way that we found is really uh making that connection and calling them on the phone um and informing them one onone um and so we know that the best way would really be face to face um we have it in our list to um be in front of the schools and heading out whether it's those brochures or just really um informing so it is our job as a district as our department to do that but we also know that you know the principles are there at their sides and so it's collaborating with our School site principles um and just doing what we have to do so yes we'll be doing we'll do the phone calls at 6 PM whatever all different times of the day until someone picks up thank

083you yes we've also contributed to uh the newsletter that goes out districtwide really wanting to highlight Spotlight daac and elac in that format so we're trying everything and anything and that's another Avenue oh that is great and and like I said it's uh it's nothing better than you know to see you're trying we're trying you know I understand parents have some priorities you know work stuff but uh it's it's wonderful to see you guys are doing one wonderful job thank you um thank you for the presentation it's really great to see like more more parents participating and I love the fact that you're giving people phone calls um get them out to the meetings um and I was really happy to see that you all did like a presentation on Prop 58 at the last

084D meeting um is that something that we are planning on doing like at each School site like during the elac as well yeah so it's with the with the goal that once we um hold our daac meeting um that uh the principles take and their daac representatives also take it back to their elac so the information that is shared in deac um should be going back to the sites and presented during their elex yes oh and yes so today we um we also recorded our prop 58 video so beyond the lookout it's in the process of being edited um and so we will also be sharing that um via newsletter to their sites and so forth families thank you thank you so much and thank you for meeting our parents where they're at with the

085flexible times and phone calls and everything thank you okay Business Services we have our first interim financial report for uh 2024 202 five I recognize we recognize um assistant superintendent Rara and director Jonathan morz and approve the submission of the positive certification for the first interim financial report for 2024 2025 good evening president lyer Board of Trustees superintendent Espinosa staff and Community the first inum report identifies changes to the district's adopted budget through October 31st 2024 so we're providing you an expenditures um update up to that time although it is after December 16th the county has continues to let us know that we are still in compliance as long as we submit the proper documentation ahead of that ahead of that date it's a simple chart we you you've seen this before but just kind

086of just demonstrating the submittal process obviously the fiscal department works on the report um six days prior to the board meeting the materials are available for public Ewing includes the board agenda and the actual report is posted uh currently we're on step three and step four uh at the board meeting uh we expect the board to approve submit of the report to the county office and after the board meeting the board president will sign the report and then we'll we'll submit it to to the county office and here's our Ann budget cycle we've moved on from phase two where we adopted the budget and now we are in phase three into the new fiscal year uh today we are providing you the first uh inim update the first report and those are again that is

087an update through October 31st quickly coming back um in January we will be awaiting the governor's budget proposal and depending on what is proposed at that time we begin to plan for the following fiscal year which is the 2526 f um budget soon after that we'll also be providing you the second inim report so the second update to the budget that will come in March and that's an update through January 31st so our recommendation to the board will be positive certification that the district can meet its Financial Obligations for the current year and the next two fiscal years a reminder what we want to stay away from our qualified and negative certifications a qualified certification being that the district may not be able to meet its financial obligations and the word is may not in

088the current year the next two years a negative certification is stating that the district cannot meet its um Financial Obligations in the current year in the current year or the following year again we are recommending any positive certification so that is good news at this time I will ask direct um director metas to talk a little bit about the um Financial numbers good evening in the next few slides we're gonna talk about revenues expenditures and onetime funds here you can see uh unrestricted and restricted revenues and unrestricted uh revenues are funds that you can use that it Seas fit um to meet the district needs restricted are basically funds that are for a specific use you can see the major contributor for revenues is a local control funding formula which means we are funded on

089students in their seats throughout the year that's why it's so important talking about the communication with parents and engaging to get that ADA up um other source sources of revenue are other local for example is Cal shape uh Federal would be uh Title One funds so let's just uh to show you guys a little bit of where the our funds are generated here you see unrestricted and restricted unrestricted and restricted expenditure so the other side how we're spending and you can see that major uh piece of the pie there are salaries and benefits a little bit of books and supplies uh one thing I want to highlight here is our Capital outlay uh which increase from uh 0.1% to 2.2% and uh one of the sources of that is our excellent M maintenance operations facilities

090team uh was able to guarantee the Cal shape grant for the district which helps with the plumbing and heating and air so uh uh congratulations to them to helping the district get those funds um it's a very beneficial to the district and the students here we can see the unrestricted how we're spending our unrestricted funds and again the district continues to be a very people Centric District 93.4% of our expenditures from the unrestricted side are um benefits and salaries for staff uh the other sides are books and supplies and other operating expenditures here's a little recap of our onetime funds just a reminder Esser funds are now depleted they they are gone so this will probably be the last time the board sees this on this report uh we plan to get rid of the

091Esser reporting and we have two other grants that we we have about $2.5 million remaining on that and the district plans to expense those funds in the next couple of years here you see a an overview from adopted budget to First interim the major thing I want to highlight here is there is a component from the AED actuals which we brought to you back in September uh there was an adjustment in the ending fund balance for 2324 which affects our beginning balance in 2425 and that brought up our uh beginning fund balance to $42.6 million you can see that adjustment right there highlighted among other adjustments in revenues and other expenditures that uh they adjust up and down in the interim reports throughout the year that we bring to you guys um with our estimated

092uh uh ending fund balance for the year being at $ 36.1 million and I'll invite Mr assistant superintendent L to speak on the multi-year projections thank you so looking ahead to the curring and next couple of years multi-year projection so our every budget's uh based on assumptions I share that with the board uh each time I come up and those assumptions are based on the information that we know today um from various sources they will change and they do change over time but again we're working off the information that we know today um our current 1.07 Cola says projected but it's our current Cola obviously a very anemic uh cola this during the this year um but that that is what we're working with uh We've made some adjustments slight adjustments to decline in enrollment

093over the next several years we the numbers have improved slightly I will talk a little bit about that a little bit more in the next slide uh the decline in enrollment um slide that we have there and prays continues to be in impacting an impact to the district and and expenditures there our Health and Welfare rates continue to rise they Rose 6% this year from last year and the cost of doing business with in special education those those costs continue to increase also uh each and every year here's our declining enrollment and I said that we have just adjusted um the numbers as a slightly better Outlook over the the next several years we're still expected to decline uh this year we had projected a higher number loss I believe one 196 was our projected

094uh decrease we are at 136 so that does help us but we're still losing kids so again that number is is is better than we had projected or estimated um so we've adjusted the enrollment over the next couple of years although the Outlook is better it's still a 10% decrease over the next three years so it's still impacting us and here a reminder of our Cola again I talked about the anemic Cola that we're currently receiving at 1.07% although that is an increase in it seems like it's an increase in Revenue it really is not when you're a district in decline in enrollment so our 2324 funded Ada at a little bit over 4,100 you see now it's a decrease of about 400 and how does that impact the district Revenue wise you see a

095drop in Revenue about5 A5 million so again a cola when it's so small does not even um that 1.7 1.07 doesn't even keep up with our fixed cost which average about three years um excuse me 3% every every year so that $5.5 million decrease is is a percent of a 9.26 decrease over that over one year that's just one year so our multi-year ending balance again not looking only at the ending balance in the first year but we need to look o over a two-year period that is what we are expected to do and should do to ensure that the decisions that we're making today does not have a truly negative impact in our finances over the two-year period over the multi um year the myp so you see that the $36 million ending balance

096when you're look to the deficit spending the impact of deficit spending at $9.2 million and then a 10.8 estimated projected um deficit and our ending balance is now at a six approximately $16 million over the probably the second out year so again looking at the first year when we're looking at that amount we also have to consider that the decisions that we make today many of those decisions will impact well they do impact us over a period of time so we need to remain fiscally solvent over that period the components of our ending balance and a reminder to the board that when we're talking about the ending balance um sometimes we hear the reserve or we mix up the reserve with the ending balance the reserve is a component of the ending balance so it's

097a 5.6 million amount uh other components include our our revolving cash need to have cash in in hand um for any issues one example I always give is someone's paycheck does not arrive we do not want that employee to be impacted by waiting to see what what happened we would provide that check immediately our inventory adds up to $250,000 there uh commitments and assignments are the remaining components of the ending balance and has changed there a little bit so you see our commitments and our assignments I do want to let the board know that there are expenditures that were not captured by October 31st first that you'll see during the second inum so those amounts for example the $6 million that you see there for security and and safety and improvements uh that number will

098be decreased because we're currently working on phase two um next steps and safety uh throughout the school district and by by the next time that we provide a budget update you'll see that number decrease because we will have um encumbered it for future expenses around Safety and Security uh the same with uh camp and some of the other items there that you'll see the um the actual decreases from from expenditures this this school year there will be a new line item and I'll discuss that in the next slide um and provide a little bit more background why we are thinking or will be uh bringing to the board the idea of committing certain funds because of new litigation so uh things to consider looking forward uh cautionary notes again uh the governor's proposal in January

099we depend on the the health of the California economy how the um when it's healthy when it's going well a lot better for us when it's not going so well obviously it has a a bigger impact combined that with the decline in enrollment than it has a really um devastating impact or could have our deficit spending decline in enrollment um director Matas mentioned one time restricted funding it's really almost basically gone so that helped us in the last few years it helped us continue our day-to-day operations and being able to have certain um Implement certain programs or Staffing we really need to look at um that going away and thinking about how else we're going to uh fund those things assembly Bill 218 I'm not sure um I know I provided a board update but

100it's been a while so just to give you a refresher that is new sexual abuse litigation that will be impacting uh many district or all districts throughout most districts throughout California uh South Bay being one of them and that law extended the statute of limitations of sexual abuse claims from well the the T the period that will impact South Bay is from 1996 to 2008 so any new claims coming from those from that time period we will be responsible for contributing whatever result comes from that so currently we receive updates every March every March from the um School excess liability fund which is the the jpa that we were part of back then which is why we're paying out now uh we at this time they're recom they're we're budgeting about $200,000 a year for

101any for current um payouts now that can hopefully decrease if there aren't any new claims but if there are new claims and a court Awards somebody $100 million well we we need to prepare for that so which is why I I say we need to um in the previous slide really look at it an amount there that we want to um have a healthy um balance for again not knowing what future expenditures will come from there and we're in negotiations obviously you know that and another thing to really consider which may have a I will say will have an impact um on our district is that there's a new president and administration coming um into office in January a lot of unknowns come with that um but there is things already said out loud and

102that um you know things like deportations when our families hear that it it can have an impact with it I'm going to say it probably will have an impact on whether or not they choose to enroll or or stay um it depends right so again just hearing about it I think will have an impact whether it happens or not it still will have an impact being a district that's so close to the border so something to just for us to Monitor and and to really stay up to date with again just things we're hearing but you we have to just be ready to prepare for that I have a question Mr Laura on the I want to go back back up to assembly bill um 218 um are those any new claims in our district

103only can you talk about that a little bit yeah so when you're part of a jpa you're really just pulling you know um like this came about in the 90s really when there were a lot of um difficulties with districts getting Insurance on their own so the some of the the strategies for school dishes were to come together and Pull and then kind of take on the contributions um liability uh contributions coming from any type of lawsuit but because you're pulling you are contributing if there's an a lawsuit from another District so if you're those districts are part of the pool um if there's a lawsuit there every District needs to contribute their piece so as of now um and thank you for being able to clarify this these aren't coming from South Bay these

104are coming from anyone who was part of the self um in back in the 990s or during this time period so other districts who who are being sued we are also responsible for part of that contribution whatever the result is of that lawsuit thank you and of course the benefit of that is um you know South Bay if something uh came forward in South Bay uh we would be able to uh share you know the the the cost cost um with other districts so we wouldn't be paying the whole amount if it was it it was a claim in our district but you know the the bad the bad side is that when something comes up in another District then we have to also share that cost um you know good and bad in both

105and back in that time the majority of school districts were part of the the self so we're really looking at many many districts our next UPS I mentioned the the governor's budget proposal as soon as his proposal comes out we begin working on next year's um budget but we continue to work on the current budget so we're working on both at that time and whatever information comes from there you you'll be receiving that update the second interim update in March will will come to you in March but that update is through January 31st again negotiations School consolidation recommendation coming in early 2025 is my I was going to say my wish but I'm going to say my my I'm assuming it it will come early in 2025 um as far as a recommendation and again

106we continue to look at ways to reduce expenditures be responsible uh when receiving the revenue that we do and and ensuring that we're fiscally solving over the the multi-year projection and be happy to answer any questions I I have one more question before the board jumps in um and I may have missed this do we have a percentage or a number um for our uh deficit spending at this point yes it was right right here in red the deficit right here the Surplus SL deficit in red okay so in 2425 our current deficit spending amount just looking up 2425 is 6.5 million it's not the current amount it's the projected amount at at the end of the fiscal year okay and and then in 2526 we're projecting 9.2 million towards the end by the end

107of the year yes can you talk by the by the end of the 25 26 year yes okay can you talk a little bit about how that number is how is that deficit spending how was that created how what what's happening so director metas showed the the 93% salary um where expenditures are unrestricted expenditures 93% are are people uh we're we're a school district of course we work with kids um we're not using AI we're humans and we're interacting right and working with our kids um when Revenue drops so quickly when we lose so many kids from one year to the next we can't keep keep up with the reducing the expenditures at the same rate it's a that's the challenge um with school districts so so losing kids from since covid the way we're

108losing we lost kids and continue to lose kids uh that Revenue when we're talking about per student I'm throwing out this number it's close uh about $133,000 per student um a class of 20 I'm mess up the math here uh class of let's say we lose 20 that that's a class um even if a teacher were to retire and not fill that class the amount of Revenue that we're losing is still more than the the the salary or total comp of that staff member so it just happens so quick so fast at a such a high amount uh we we just it's it's a real challenge to reduce expenditures at the same rate especially with inflation and you see the year-to-year fixed costs that happen no matter what we do we're those are out of

109our control so that average of 3% you saw the Health and Welfare benefits that's that's impacting everybody those rates just you know they went up out of our control uh 6% so you add all that together the expenditures rise uh revenue is not keeping up in fact revenu is dropping year in and year out okay so for staying with 2425 the revenues that we're projected to have for the school year 2425 is 63.3 million yes and our expenditures our projected expenditure are 69.9 million and that's how you we are coming up with and and the reason is we're not able to cut expenditures enough or reduce expenditure enough to offset the loss and revenue it's a challenging rate to try to keep up at the same the same time okay thank you just got a

110quick question uh so this is a projected uh are we even con considering the bonds that was passed uh for some of the schools are in their need of repairs others probably you know needs to do some maintenance heavy maintenance what's what's what's the take on that so the bonds will allow us to not have to use our current unrestricted or restricted funds um because the bond passed so you do not see that data here as far as uh the bond dollars the several steps still have to take place before um we we show any data around the bond dollars and that is first bringing a resolution to the board uh and once that's uh adopted then we can begin uh the first issuance uh which we project to be around $12 million uh we

111would bring a project list to you and and get your feedback and guidance around what we um expect or and hope to do um but those that the those numbers that data that money is not seen here in in the in the report but we will be providing you with constant updates around the bond projects thank you madam president thank you very much for your report I always look for that uh the friendly budget that gives the schools budget and by school and then they overall and it's you know user friendly I haven't seen that for a while I think our parents would be interested to see how much money that say only on TI gets and how um the money is spent I think we need to superintendent we need to uh share that

112a little bit more in our parent engagement groups how our schools are funded and where that money goes to uh because parents think that they need to buy supplies and uh that's the wrong message that we need to send that's the wrong message um on the blonde thing I'm glad you brought that up um I've been doing a little studying about this uh what is our district rating at this point at this money um with our ending now just at this minute okay what would be our rating if when we go out to a bond because we have so much I will I believe our last rating or Moody's credit rating are our last issuance I want to say it was A+ um now A+ sounds like the highest it's actually it's not the highest

113rating um but I can provide that update and a Friday board update but we are in a a credit rating um place where it's it's a good rating not the best rating but we are in a good rating as far as dwide but this was the last rating we received was at during our last issuance which was measure X um what that rating will be moving forward it it will depend on on the credit rating agencies so the more money you have in your ending balance when we do that uh the higher the interest rate or bond rate or how it worked backwards they look at various things they obviously look at our budget they do look at Ada funded Ada over the next few years they they do see the decline in enrollment but

114they do look at um an ending fund balance as well so they take various components from the from the budget they don't just look at one thing so having a u ending balance of today one would look at that and say that we're healthy it the ending balance what they would say is that it it it's helping absorb the deficit spending or the loss of Revenue um which will then affect their rating yes again what the rating does come from them and and what they their criteria um at this point I can't predict what they may what may be our rating moving forward well you know correct me if I'm wrong but if we don't have any money it's going to be high rate right yeah okay where we at credit risk and Trust can

115is you're you're right um currently because our ending fund Balan is ever able to cover our deficit spending then our rating is much better if our ending fund balance was not covering our deficit spending then our rating would plummet thank and you know there's always a question about the numbers that we give the district gives not me you um declining enrollment you know there's always a convers ation about that everywhere and numbers over here numbers over there numbers over here and now we have new numbers so my question here on the declining in rment thank you very much for you know charting it out like that but I'm looking at this and is this include um total enrollment counting the charters no it does not it Just counts our really important because when we're talking

116at this level we really need to know because we'll go back out there and then the question question will say will be see see they're not telling you the number okay so I'm just sharing with you the chter chatter out there that um we get caught up in the numbers and and they they look skew to some people yeah what we can do moving forward is provide a second slide and just showing the history of the charters and enrollment there and then it will show that there's there's two different data points there when we're talking about enrollment someone can enroll tomorrow and now enrollment changes so it's really a moving Target that impossible to just say it's perfect it's it's correct as of today well actually since we submitted the report so again if kids

117left and kids came of course it's going to change uh if there's an expectation to be 100% accurate at every moment that's really unrealistic expectation it's a moving Target um like we said we we looked at um the demographer data around what they're projecting but we're also Revisited our historical data and see where are some Trends where can we adjust now it's about I believe now it's two years moving forward where the projected decline was a little bit was higher than anticipated so we re were're revisiting and I want to acknowledge that director metas actually began doing that and saying um let's look at some more historical data and moving forward what our projections might be a little bit different well I appreciate that um one and it's trending towards the positive so again still

118losing kids but we're projecting a little less stabilizing that one more thing about the charters and the numbers um our administrative costs for the charters um that has that increased based on the economic boom well all costs have increased but I more comfortable providing that in a more um in a summary with more detailed information in a Friday updates as far as if you want more Charter information um and we can even touch more on the their budget and their and their costs yes definitely we can do would be great superintendent because this is only giving us um a little snippet it doesn't give us all the three leas and so that would be helpful maybe in a Friday update thank you thank you thank you um thank you so much for this um would

119it also be appropriate at during these presentations to give like little Snippets of how we compare Statewide um when we look at I mean we'll just like just like we have the sending fund balance and and we hear like we have all this money but um going to the most recent um conference that I went to that most districts in California are sitting on the biggest ending fund balance they've had in a long time because of one-time funds you know and when when we look at how much we spend on on people um what how do we compare to other school districts in California like I really appreciate this but I also really appreciate the big picture so that it doesn't look like our situation is unique like we are we we are in the

120same boat as many other districts you know what I mean I don't know if that or maybe that's a different presentation or so we go with the direction of the board so if if there's an Ask of providing new information during these presentations we're definitely open to it um my I will recommend that you share that with our superintendent what would be cons for by second intrum um again we go with your direction of some additional information will be helpful to the board we'll be happy to present that yeah and I I would add just give me some specifics that way um staff can really uh focus in on on whatever information that is um I I also would like to hear more um in the future about like the impact that like the charter

121schools have like on the district as a whole definitely yeah thank you and you're just talking about financially the the fiscal impact financially and then I mean I was not sure if I was supposed if I need to wait for the end of the meeting for like a future agenda item but I am also interested in learning more about um like charter schools in general um or if there's something that we can do to like I guess educate us or the community about like what is a charter school right um and the impacts it has on like regular Public Schools yeah yeah any other questions or comments okay thank you so much thank you can I say something one more thing actually I'm supposed to say because I don't you're not going to thank yourself

122thank you for the reminder I do want to thank it does take a lot of work from the fiscal Department I mean yes it's their job but it's still a collaborative effort it's an effort with other departments and other staff members and and director metas is the the leader of that team and I do want to thank him and I want to thank his team for for that work that they do um any ask that comes their way it it even if I say not urgent it it gets to me back in by the end of the day so I do want to thank the team for that we need a mo a motion to approve the positive uh what is it called it's positive certification thank you so much all for the vote motion

123carried thank you thank you so next up we have human resources employee of the year selection committees we recognize the superintendent Melissa Griffith and recommend two community members to serve on the employee of the year selection committees for certificated and classified staff good evening president lyer Board of Trustees and superintendent uh tonight I am here requesting for the board to recommend two community members to serve our employee of the year committee uh we would like to start with the certificated recommendations first um so I will take your recommendations for certificated uh staff committee members Madame President I would like to um nominate um I don't know if that's the right word but uh for certificated the certificated committee would be Mitchell McKay our protm mayor of Imperial Beach so then do we have a motion

124to to approve that nomination or or we just accept that does anybody else have any recommendations we certificated first um I have a couple parents that come to mine that I like to nominate um the first parent is um Iris gavada um she's a parent at Onan and also um Sandra Del Rio also from Onan so do we then choose out of the three to CH pick two or so you're recommending the nominations and then you will decide on those together um and then the human resources department will reach out to the folks that you've recommended and then from there we'll determine who is interested in moving forward okay thank you so much thank you I I have I we have everyone on the list for certificated are there any other nominations for certificated next

125we will move over to our classified committee so if you could provide me with any nominations for um our classified committee that would be helpful thank you my apologies um Melissa we need to vote on the certificated and then move on to classified you want to vote on them separately yeah okay yes that's the way it was posted okay so that's gonna come up on me and we nominate a teacher right correct we're looking for community members to serve on the certificated committee for our teachers okay question Madam President we are voting for three names that we recommended okay I believe yes okay thank you the motion carried for those three nominations thank you so much for the nomination the next for the the classified commit classifi take recommendations for n I'd like to recommend

126that's the right word recommend for the classified committee um Jack fiser our city council member um I'd like to recommend uh recommend the parent from also from Onan uh her name is Valerie Fernandez any other recommendations I move to approve those nominations hope for a v motion carried 5 Z so thank you um Department update again thank you um Melissa Griffith for an update on human resources and organizational development thank you m Griffith can I just clarify so we voted for a couple of members and then what happens next is you contact them to make sure that they want to participate and if they do then they are on the committee correct so we will contact them to see if they're interested in participating on the committee and then if we have multiple people out

127of the ones that have been nominated are interested then we have to select one person from that group um so obviously it would be a blind draw in order for us to determine which person will service the committee depending on certificated or classified okay perfect and in the in the case that we don't have like none of the people wanted to do it then do we bring it back we would have to bring it back okay perfect thank you thank you all right so for tonight we are here to provide um an update um related to the human resources and organizational development department um so I'm going to go over some key functions as well as some of the work that we are um working on this year um so key function um in Human

128Resources we're responsible for recruiting hiring and retaining Talent um you know obviously making sure that performance is happening for employees in our district a key piece is employee engagement our labor Partnerships um along with the negotiations staff development and training uh compensation benefits Personnel records and maintenance um as you all know we are currently in negotiations with our teachers union uh we recently um some time ago go um seal our negotiation deal with our classified unit uh we will continue negotiating with swata when we return from winter break um so those are the main functions that our department um works on uh throughout the year we have some current projects and events that we've been working on um as you know we just voted on making some recommendations for the employee of the year event

129which is one of our big events to where we highlight our employees um we are respons ible for that event um and each department as well as um different sites they nominate they vote um we highlight uh those events at an event here formally at the district um and then those recommendations are sent forward to the county um as our folks work through that process as well to be highlighted um across sangu County uh two new areas that we're working on this year um we are currently working with our labor Partners to identify um different folks from csca as well as from swata as well as from management to launch our employee recognition committee um this is an opportunity for us to continue recognize employ recognizing employees throughout the year versus just a one-time event

130uh that some you know more formal um lots of our sites lots of our departments are recognized employees all the time um but really trying to identify ways to do that in a more formal way out of the human resources department um another area that we are working on this year is um a project launch for new employee orientation and substitute training uh we feel like based on our feedback that this is an area that growth for us um so really wanting to make sure that when we on board new employees um that there's um something other than just our new employee orientation event so elaborating on that we're partnering with our technology department um as you know it falls under this division um in order for us to lay that map out and work

131on that project together so there will be a lot of different departments that are part of that process um the same feedback has been given related to substitute training uh so really wanting to make sure that when we onboard our substitutes when they go into the classrooms or they go out into the field that they're prepared um for the work uh one of the areas that we really want to focus on is making sure that our certificated substitutes uh really have an understanding of classroom management how classrooms work how to implement lesson plans um to ensure that their days are successful um as we know we need substitutes um but we want to make make sure that they feel confident about their work and we also want to make sure that when they're in a

132classroom that our teachers and students are are comfortable with the work that they're doing um when they're away employee recruitment um this is an ongoing function of HR um we participate in internal and external job fairs uh many of you have probably noticed that we have some of those here throughout the year either at um a School site we advertise for them on the community we have them on our Marquees we might do that here at burus Auditorium uh we do that multiple times throughout the year so that's what we refer to as an internal um job fair when we're looking for different people within the community um this is a an opportunity especially for our classified employees to be able to come in um and interview not necessarily interview but more the less apply

133on the spot uh we typically have folks available that are working directly with people that come in um and participate in those internal job Affairs our external job Affairs um there's a lot of different ones that we we participate in throughout the year uh some of those are at University some of those are at the County office um there's a variety of different things that happen another opportunity for recruitment is our Ed join um education board that everyone uses pretty much across the country for different types of positions in education both classified and certificated um it allows for for candidates to apply online um and that's another opportunity for us to advertise for openings a new partnership for us that we're launching in January is our LinkedIn partnership um as many of you might be

134familiar in the business world or our world's outside of Education LinkedIn is a very popular platform um that businesses use to recruit employees um that has launched obviously and has started growing in the education um sector as well uh so we have a partnership as a pilot partnership with LinkedIn for us to have um access to candidates that are looking for jobs in education um and through that partnership um it gives us a different job applicant a different pool for us to pull from um so employee recruitment some things are consistent with practices that we've already had in place and then trying to look at you know new ways that are Innovative to connect with people um either locally or nationally um that are interested in um having positions in San Diego employee data uh

135this year alone we have already onboarded 61 employees uh we have a total of 500 50 classified employees 357 certificated five confidential and 41 management employees which gives us a grand total of 957 um within our system when we think about employees we also know that we need substitutes this is an area that we've been growing over the course of the last few years uh we currently have this year alone onboarded 71 certificated substitutes that will continue to grow this is just for this current school year um as the year continues we've also onboarded 31 classified substitutes um and then as we've been growing this over the last couple of years we we have 293 active certificated substitutes 277 classified substitutes which gives us a grand total of 570 uh when I first started in

136the department a few years back um that number was around about 150 total um so we definitely have been growing the thing that we have to remember is that that um are classified as well as our certificate as substitutes they work for multiple school districts um and so when they're picking up jobs they pick up jobs all over San Diego County um so all of the districts are using a lot of the same pool um but we will continue to advertize and support um on boarding as many substitutes as possible which is also a reason why uh we need to grow our area of professional learning for our substitutes because that number has grown uh we have a lot of new substitutes that um are willing to work and they need some professional learning so

137that is an area that we're working on um in addition uh volunteer data uh we have unboarded 139 uh from the beginning of the school year to present day we have a total of 935 active volunteers um we do feel strongly that you know that connection with our parents as well as our community in our schools is beneficial to everyone uh we will continue to grow that number um it is helpful that we're now the rolling records which I brought to you last year when we were talking about us being able to fingerprint employees um or potential employees as well as our volunteers here on site um so that is up and functioning and running very well uh we have people that are you know coming into our office daily in order for us to

138be able to process them through the onboarding process um and being able to fingerprint them on the spot definitely helps uh versus some someone having to go out into the community um to look for that service so overall this is just an overview of um some of the work that we're doing in HR um obviously it's a lot more detailed than tonight's um overview but um an opportunity to to take any questions if there are any specific to the highlights that I brought forward tonight thank you so much uh for your presentation I think it's it's it's an eye opener so um so you do mention you did mention about this active current uh job positions right now there we still hiring is that correct uh we are hiring for some positions uh we are

139hiring that job board goes out every Thursday uh so we do have some certificated positions that we're hiring for um and we have some classified positions that we're hiring for just to classify how about the certificated uh positions those as well yes we are still looking for um a special education teacher uh we have all of our positions are currently filled either with the new people that we will hopefully um approved tonight in the consent calendar when you get to that part of the agenda um we have two agency folks that are currently still in our special education classrooms um that we are still hiring for but those are the only two that are left thank you for certificating we have a few more uh for classified as well and those job boards are posted

140on our our website thank you mam President we don't often get the time to say thank you to your department but I want to thank you and the activity list when were to look at it uh there's a lot of work here on on boarding anybody and uh where it starts and uh to a you know an employment status um it's a lot of work so thank your department and I'm really happy to hear about the onboarding of volunteers and the uh ability to come and share those members with us and um a lot of people ask what do I do they send them your away uh but real one real quick question if I may uh what is the turnaround after someone comes there and say I'd like uh to volunteer it varies um

141there are times that prints are delayed uh which we don't necessarily have control over that um we print give or take typically six weeks for some people um though some folks can turn around in two weeks so you know it's definitely anywhere from two to eight weeks um but typically if something is happening in there we're notified that there's a delay of some kind um and a delay isn't always something negative it it just sometimes through the doj um those prints don't necessarily populate um as quickly so thank you so much for your presentation thank you okay um up next we have the consent calendar all matters listed on the consent calendar will be enacted in one Motion in the form listed below prior to approval of the meeting agenda there was an opportunity to

142request placing consent calendar items in the discussion action section of the board meeting there will be no discussion on these items prior to the board vote the superintendent and staff recommend approval adoption ratification acceptance of all consent items unless otherwise noted do I have a whoa I have a motion of to approve the consent calendar I move to approve all the items on the consent calendar as listed including the superintendent's recommendations for denial or approval of leaves of absences I second that all right um consent calendar is approved 5 to one okay so all right so future agenda items we are now at Future agenda items any thank you madam president um I'd like more information about how uh families children that are interested in uh instrumental music uh can apply to go to Mendoza

143districtwide thank you anything else I have one just um I think I might need to talk with the superintendent a little bit more kind of flush this out a little bit better but I am interested in learning more about like charter schools in general and like the impacts they have specifically in our district um I mean I remember when I was going to Barry I don't think there was any charter schools and then later on I started to hear that there's um yeah that's schools were yeah I think it was like imperal beachs elementary school before right now it's like IB Charter and Nester all of a sudden I drove by and it said charger school and I was like what is that right I think a lot of people in the community might not

144be 100% sure like what a charter school is um and it'd be really interesting for all of us to learn more about charter schools and the fiscal impacts that they have on our public education system okay thank you very much um so what I'm hearing and and we can talk about it a little bit more that way we we get the right information but what I'm hearing is you you want a presentation that talks about what charter schools are number one that's the first step let's talk about just what a charter school is and then number two it sounds like you want to know the um kind of the history of charter schools in our district specifically and then what are the what are the impacts of charter schools on our district so very focused

145to our district yeah correct yes perfect and sorry if I could just add like maybe not just like the charter schools in our district but even like the charter schools in our region right if there's any way to get information on that as well thank you okay so now um followup on H we recognize superintendent Jose Espinosa and provide on Direction on next steps on future agenda items from previous board meetings all right thank you very much um and we have one item uh trusty Lopez agino requested um that we research uh the process to add a student representative to the board um the research that we have done really points to student student Representatives being high school students uh most districts um that have student representatives are high school students um I did uh

146identify a couple of districts that start with middle school students but what they're doing with the middle school students is really preparing them because they're K12 districts they're preparing them to be high school um High School Representatives so I didn't really um identify any schools with uh middle school students that are participating um and the csba policies are all written um around high school students I do have a suggestion um I think that we can establish a student advisory committee where a couple of board members could be part of the committee as well as myself um and we could meet students you know once a trimester so three times a year maybe you know beginning of the year middle end of the year um and you know really look at how we can Elevate their

147voice and their experiences here in our school district um so I would uh offer that as a suggestion yeah I think that that's great and um I would like to be if possible part of like the process of like developing like the program or curricul whatever we want to call it any discussion among the board if I could add to that request um a letter was sent out to the families about attendance recently and uh if you're agreeable to uh amend your request um for student uh Advisory Group that we could add that piece to it about attendance and uh how the district is recognizing perfect attendance and why I think it started January to June right so we're going to recognize them probably when we do our Scholars but you okay with that sure

148I mean I'm not sure exactly how can you explain a little bit more how it like uh work would work well the district sent out a letter to families about recognizing um perfect attendance from January to June well we got voices from both sides about that and uh um mix messages I should say and why are we doing that now and um so I would like to have a the student Advisory Group work on on communication you know why it's important to come to school like a video right so that would be part of the curriculum like you requested that they could put out some information about how why it's important yeah I think that sounds good the way I'm kind of thinking about it is like a part of like the education piece for

149those students uh regarding like how attendance impacts like the schools and why it's important to promote good attendance um because just to clarify a little bit like my my idea behind this is to like get more students like in in a younger age to understand the way that like our government works in general right because like our schools are impacted by the way our government operates um and like I mean I I think I learned like in high school that you know we got paid for attendance right um and then I think at that point I was one of those students that thought they just want me to come to school so they can get money right um but really like you know getting people to understand like the the system system that we're currently

150operating under and like how like the government I guess works as well as like We the People participate in it right a lot of us just think like the government is this thing that just operates on its own but like like instilling that like a Civic engagement like in our students in a very young age okay so let me just kind of pause for a little bit here right now the board is discussing the idea of engaging students um around Civic engagement um and I have suggested pulling students together from across our our our district um in some type of advisory committee um I can definitely see us doing that I think we're and and I think it's I think it's fine I think we talk about that now um but I want to make

151sure that I'm hearing from the board first because what we have to do first is to say yes the board is interested in pursuing this and having staff spend time um you know following up on this student engagement whether it's on you know around civics or whether it's just their experience whatever that may be we we can we can kind of you know clarify that a little bit later but first I want to make sure that the board is is interested in staff spending time to do that that's kind of what this part is got it any more discussion or question I I support um Jose's request in a limited version uh like uh pilot and um I would suggest that Jose uh speak to our president in that I know but she doesn't so

152that conversation needs to happen and uh and then perhaps you can report on it at the next meeting or something because it would have to come back to us anyway well if the board reaches consensus right now it sounds like we may have consensus on yes let's spend some staff time let's commit some resources to looking at this then I would work um specifically with uh trusty Lopez agino to to kind of uh clarify um the direction that that we want to go with that um so this is the consensus it would really wouldn't come back it might come back later as a here's what we've come up with and that I would work through uh president Laker yeah that that's my suggestion uh in limited form because I I I know you guys have

153a lot of work and this is like a a a whole little Pro program uh so um I'd be interested in the in a in a pilot limited uh space so um trusty L actually brought up a really good point I have seen it done but in the high school level there's a representative uh in the board it sits there you know listens to the whole you know the whole motion appearing and everything else I have not yet to see it in the elementary type of settings I'm not sure how would that impact the parents um having to state but you know sometimes it is kind of confusing in a way but I mean um not sure how would I go about I do support uh superintendent you know having two board members meet up

154you know have a some sort of committee and bringing to the kind of like an School site type of um coordination but that I would support so do we call for a vote oh do we have consensus Madam president before we go forward I know it's not on here but it should be and uh and I think you should know uh last Tuesday I met with the superintendent and Amy Cooper uh last Tuesday at 1:30 to 2:30 uh we talked about my request for an agenda item which we all approved about uh the communication um plan for our district and how we communicate to our parents and staff Etc so I wanted to let you know Madame President uh that we did meet on that and uh uh we came to uh as the president

155came to a sens is that uh in a year in review uh it would come back to us in June so just put that on your radar I yes I it's something that is on my radar thank you trusty commun all right I believe we've reached the time where we have communications from the Board of Trustees well first of all um um I had the opport to attend to the csba uh it was a four days it was a lot to learn it's it's it's one of those classes that you just keep learning and learning and you know this is an eye opener uh I did um learn a lot of activities a lot of programs a lot of I even heard from a lot of people board members from other districts how their District

156are doing and uh you know it's a is really it's it was a really good experience for for me also uh I did attend to the Mendoza's uh Irish um Merry Christmas event uh it was my goodness that place was was packed and was rocking I mean it was it was a lot of a lot of activities going on uh a lot of the happy kids they got presents and even the Santa Claus came down in a helicopter it was really good to see see all the parents and the students you know being together in one place thank you um I just want to thank everybody for staying here till the end of the meeting I don't know if you have to but um appreciate you all your hard work this year um this year

157has been extremely tough um and who knows what next year is going to look like um but I think that we're making a lot of strides um really excited to see like the soccer program that I believe started this year um and you know just continuing to figure out how we you know work together with like the District staff and the teachers and getting the community involved um so I'm really excited to continue to serve on this board um thank you for nominating me to be a vice president um and you know I wish you all uh have a nice break get some rest and you know come back ready to keep keep going keep doing your your thing so thank you all and hope you all have a good night happy holidays everyone and

158thank you for being here thank you madam president and congratulations on your presidency I look forward to your leadership uh vice president Jose thank you for stepping up and you too uh it's a one F World up here and when uh when you're in leadership positions um uh we should acknowledge that leadership and so I appreciate you uh coming forward and doing that for us uh and when the Torches pass it's really important that we all stand together as one so and with that I'd like to report out my activities for the month by May Madam president I know it's late but I've done a lot of things okay so let me begin uh on the 21st of November I uh attended a webinar and these two webinars that I'm going to share I shared

159with the board and and asked if you had any questions to uh speak to the superintendent and so the 21st was spotting the signals understanding behavioral threats and assessment came with a video live webinar uh I got the slides in the webinar and I sent it Forward um on the 24th of November which was turkey day at Barry it was over 10 I know 30 turkeys and parents lined up and um in the car in the car parade and on the on the sidewalk so uh that was really fun to do and uh I want to send a thank you card if we could Madame President to uh uh Vivian Moreno who sponsored the event and she's the council uh member at San Diego we don't hear Too Much from San die so it's really

160important to push them up thank you uh let's see on December 2nd I was at the elap advisory committee I attended that uh uh on the TW on the 4th of December I was at the IB city hall meeting as your president uh representing our school district for the second grade fire uh posters winners they second graders and uh I think it was Central onata and we had on a teacher and a principal there so I was really proud to do that uh the 10th I was with the superintendent from 1:30 to I don't know what time uh on the 10th also at 3:30 on the 10th also I attended the facilit facilities Asset Management committee the sack committee so I was there I had a long day uh on the 11th uh again I

161I attended a webinar a live discussion on threat assessment strategies and best practice practices and that was put on by the uh Tennessee uh Board of Trustees the state of Tennessee so it's really interesting here here and here and the first one I went to on the 21st was uh hosted by csba but the panelists were the superintendent of Sweetwater uh their assistant soup and a board member so it was really something that I could you know think that that was about us so I was glad to do that on the 13th uh I attended the bull a bull cup for the soccer games uh uh it was really fun and it was freezing and uh Janet was with me and uh um so the girls Nester versus Mendoza it was a nester win and

162uh all all the excitement that goes with that and the trophy is like this big okay so and then the next game it was a double hitter boys Nester versus Onan and Onan came out with the wins so congratulations to both schools and again thank you trustees uh superintendent Amy management team you're always here I know it's late but it's a long day the day is long but what what we do in the moment is what matters and I want to thank all of you for doing it in the moment all year and staying as long as you can and with that I wish everybody a happy holiday and a happy New Year thank you thank you thank you m president thank you so much um thank you for your uh nominating and electing me

163as your board president it's an honor um I hope to serve the board well um this month I went to my third um annual education conference for the California School Board Association um um there's so many great amazing sessions it's sometimes really hard to choose which ones we're going to go to but um what I thought was amazing about our team was we all kind of have different interests so we could um you know go to different things I really focus this year on um the budget the laws how money is um received um the history of the funding for our schools and programs uh the history of it and and where it could be headed right now um but right now we a lot of things are just unknown so um but hopefully uh

164everything goes well but even the things that are being said that might not happen just the fear itself is going to affect our community and hopefully we can stand together and Trust in believe that we're all here for the kids and for our fam so with that have a wonderful holiday a wonderful break and see you next year

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.