CorpusRecord 107516

SSFUSD Board Meeting - February 13, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / SSFUSD Meetings
Date
2025-02-14
Location
San Mateo County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
18,764 words · about 105 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e for all right the South San Francisco Unified School District reconvening into Open Session all right may I have a roll call please student trustee harsana here trusty Richardson trusty Shay here trusty lamb here president Anthony present may I have the Pledge of Allegiance it will be led by Mont verie Elementary School fifth grader Bianca lapas please stand I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible for liberty and justice for all right principal M will you tell us a little bit about Bianca absolutely good evening president and Dr Moore members of the board members of the cabinet and our own former monover ver student whose first night is on the board Josephine harsana let me tell you a

002little bit about Bianca and why she was chosen to represent mon ver Bianca is a hardworking student who meets challenge es with a positive attitude and a growth mindset she recently um her favorite things are not really School subjects but she excels at singing dancing and last year she was in the talent show and she did Impressions the thing about Bianca is she's always has a positive attitude and meets challenges with a growth mindset like I said earlier uh she recently asked me when the dates are for the cast testing now normally it's not a question that I have to answer from the students um but she asked and so I asked her well why are you asking we're not doing it until April and she said well I want to compare my score this

003year to how I did last year I want to see what improvements I've made over the year so that's why she was chosen and now it's time for your great picture here is your certificate come around this side all right item D land acknowledgement statement we acknowledge that the South San Francisco Unified School District is located on the unseated ancestral homeland of the ramatou alone peoples who are the original inhabitants of the San Francisco Peninsula we wish to raay pay our respects by acknowledging the ancestors elders and relatives of the ramatou community and by affirming their Sovereign Sovereign rights as First Peoples item e reporting out from close session in accordance with government code section 54956.9 D1 and in reference to Clos session agenda item number one Jane Doe V South San Francisco USD case

004number 22- C- 0526 the board unanimously voted to approve the settlement in the matter of Jane Doe V South San Francisco USD plaintiff has agreed to dismiss her lawsuit against the district and release the district from any and all claims in exchange for payment of $250,000 each party shall bear their own costs in accordance with government code section 54957 and in reference to Clos session agenda item number two Public Employee discipline dismissal release the board unanimously voted to non- reelect one probationary certificated employee in accordance with Education Code section 92921 the board voted three I and one nay to release two certificated administrators in accordance with Education Code section 4495 1 and the board unanimously voted to release 16 temporary certificated employees in accordance with Education Code section 44954 thank you Mr Hanan uh review

005of agenda do we have any other changes or any changes all right I'm moving on to item G PTA Council remarks I'd like to invite up waly Wong from Monte verie oh it's on hello perfect good evening president Anthony trustees superintendent Moore members of the cabinet and members of the community my name is waly Wong this is my sixth year volunteering with the PTA and my first year of the second term as president at Monty bie my kids are currently in third and fifth grade um we have a lot of upcoming events to highlight for ptas in this District this month Monty birdie is having the Feast of Nations on February 20th bur bur is having their glow dance on the 21st schools have been having restaurant takeovers all month there are for more through

006the end of February a takaria and Market will be at the losos parking lot on February 18th Ponderosa is having theirs at Nations on the 19th Westboro is also having their takeover on the 19th at MOD Pizza Jenifer oara is having theirs at jollybee on the 21st I'd like to take a moment to share a bit about Monty verie PTA but first I would like to thank all of the PTA members and parent volunteers who are here with us tonight please stand and be acknowledged thank you we are especially proud of the community events that we bring our whole family together like the welcome back ice ex social the fall Carnival craft Coco and Claus and of course our numerous movie Nights these events are only possible because of our amazing staff our dedicated executive

007board our tireless PTA members and parent volunteers even the ones that are volun told we appreciate every single one of you without all of you we wouldn't be able to bring these wonderful Community Building experiences to life and it doesn't stop there we also make sure to contribute to the magic that happens during school hours the assemblies driving to the field trips the art and Action Program the pumpkin contest the holiday gift shop and of course the yearbook there are just these are just a few of the ways the PTA helps make school a more vibrant and enriching experience the PTA is fully aligned with The Graduate aims here learn navigate Thrive and impact for learn we hold a book donation fundraiser every year where we not only raise funds but we also gather together

008to wrap the books in protective covers before donating them to our library because we believe in creating a space where kids can Thrive through Reading when it comes to thrive our community events like the call fall Carnival serve as a fun and active way to bring families together while promoting wellness and joy the holiday gift shop teaches our students about Real World skills like budgeting and planning they get a chance to set a budget make purchases and adjust on the Fly it's Hands-On learning at its finest and of course we're all here because we deeply care about the kids and nothing makes me happier than seeing our kids grow thrive and become more confident capable individuals thank you and if there are no questions that's our report for the evening thank you so much Miss

009Wong all right uh moving on to staff Association representatives of marks item H uh South San Francisco Federation of adult Educators Miss Bale suits good evening everyone I'm Elizabeth B studs the president of the South San Francisco Federation of adult Educators um I just want to cover a few things for the adult school their ESL program we are continuing a focus on strengthening our writing curriculum and instruction um and working hard to develop CTE programs um as always I also want to cover this as always we affirm our solidarity with the CTA as they move through their contact negotiations with the district um my remarks this evening or brief um so I I'm going to take off my union president hat for a moment and put on my CTI hat at Adult Ed I support

010six day teachers and two evening teachers um I I also support our office staff so I have about 10 12 people to help um I I understand that one of the CTI coordinator toa's positions is due to be eliminated and I have no idea how one person could take on all of that work um they apparently support about 500 teachers and I'm very concerned about the person who's going to be remaining in that single position and how that person could possibly adequately support all of the teacher in the district with all of the technology that we use as teachers so um I understand some of the members have some remarks for this evening and I'm just I want to express my own concern this is not as Union president but just as a CTI I'm

011concerned about the ripple effect that this could have through the district because our students are our top priority and to have our students adequately taken care of we really need our teachers adequately taken care of thank you for your attention thank you so much South San Francisco classroom Teachers Association Shar Dusty good evening president Anthony trustees Dr Moore ssfusd cabinet members and ssfusd Community including members of Monto verie family I appreciate everyone meeting together on this stormy winter night looking at the bright side we are not in Alaska right now no thankfully we are in California where the weather is usually friendlier but our political climate feels very unstable at the moment the California Teachers Association is working diligently to get answers out to our members about how to support our students if ice raids

012occur at our schools posters and cards are in production and should be available in the next week or two the Department of Education could be dismantled CTA is actually having a town hall meeting soon on the 19th of February to address concerns on how it is working to address these and other political um concerns I am sure many including myself feel the foundation beneath our feet has been demolished here locally our school district is also contemplating big changes as you will hear tonight we trust that these changes are meant to build up not tear down while I feel change in ssfusd is necessary I am counting on ssfusd to make necessary and thoughtful decisions that will shape the future for our places of learning changes that will utilize our resources in the most efficient ways

013but we'll also make these changes empathetically with students and employees in mind while true our leaders in the district office have listened to stakeholders and have researched many sources to find Solutions I still feel like teachers voices have not always come made it to the Forefront nor been included in the decisionmaking process with many stakeholders having recently returned from visiting exemplary schools in San Diego Thank You bed fun I am sure we will be hearing some amazing stories but don't forget to look in our own backyard for inspiration as well part of the presentation tonight about Strategic Staffing will be about instructional coaching I have asked that ssfusd bargain with ssf CTA regarding this new position job description because this will affect Educators on many levels we want to ensure that this position will be

014utilized in a positive way ensuring that growth in the Pro profession is what members experience among the possibilities that could arise because it could easily be used against teachers as well my suggestions for other phases of the Strategic plan are to include teachers in the decisionmaking not just feedback utilize our strengths ask us what works well with our students inform us about new best practices help us celebrate our wins with our students support support us with our challenges be the foundation we need to rise up so that we can rise up and say as we do in mon verie territory Fly Like an Eagle thank you thank you so much item I Personnel [Music] commission our next Personnel commission meeting will be held on Tuesday February 18 2025 at 5:00 p.m in the district office

015boardroom thank you so much item J items from the board um I just have one really quick announcement and I know that Dr Moore is going to talk a little bit about federal policy and what we're doing but um the red cards um one of the things that I learned at a know your rights workshop last week is that it's actually really important that people who are documented also carry the red card that way it's not just like oh Whoever has a red card is a target so um please in solidarity um think about carrying a red card as well any other announcements calendar committee reports did you guys didn't have the committee recently did you board bylaws we did and um I believe we're approving the minutes but I okay yeah great thank you

016all right moving on to item K superintendence report thank you very much president Anthony so I'd like to start by introducing our wonderful new Joseph not she's not new new ASB president but our student trustee Josephine harana she is our Springs trusty representing South San Francisco high school she has already been providing updates to the board in the community um from the student lens this year but now she will be able to engage with the board in discussions and share her insights from a student perspective to inform the board's thinking about various practices programs and policies and it is my pleasure to welcome trusty harsana we're so happy to have you here previously Jamie Wong who's in the audience tonight wasn't able to be here with us and I wanted to share once again um

017to publicly acknowledge her she has also been a pleasure to work with she's offered valuable insights timely updates and really thoughtful student perspectives we appreciated so much her professionalism and her excellent communication skills we look forward to continuing to hear from her she provides her updates on events happening at El Cino High School the next item is on resource allocation and Strategic Staffing this past fall as many of you know we engaged in our Strategic Staffing initiatives which is part of our strategic plan that's aligned to equity centered systems which says that we will work to implement a focused transparent annual planning process that allocates resources our people time and money equitably sustainably and in support of our strategic priorities so I will be presenting more on that this evening the accrediting commission for schools

018Western Association of schools and colleges recently informed me that South San Francisco high school has met the criteria for accreditation this accreditation status is based on all of the information provided by the school including the school's report and the satisfactory completion of the accreditation visit it is the decision of the commission to Grant a 6year accreditation status which is the highest status they give through June 30th 2031 with a midcycle visit during the 2728 school year we are all really proud of the staff the students the families at South San Francisco High School who really helped make this wonderful accomplishment happen so congratulations to South San Francisco recently um I was had the privilege of attending a superintendent Symposium through AXA and I wanted to thank the board for supporting me to attend the Symposium

019this is an event that invites all superintendents in the state of California to attend and engage in a shared learning opportunities to connect to strengthen relationships with each other and of course to engage in some invaluable shared learning this year I was on the planning committee our theme was leading with gratitude and embracing our purpose empowering students and Educators to thrive so hopefully you hear some evidence of of our strategic plan in the theme we offered um several sessions that were focused on educational Equity leadership leading in times of challenge operations uh ex excellent instruction and ways to provide ongoing support for ourselves as Leaders other leaders in our system and of course our staff and our students I learned a lot from other districts that had some very specific strategies that they've used for

020continuous Improvement and just always remain really grateful for the opportunity to participate in many of the sessions that I attended were intentionally selected in thinking about what aligns best to our strategic plan and then my last item I am absolutely aware that there is a lot of fear and angst in our community with regard to everything happening in our country I wanted to share at the Symposium a consistent message that I heard was to stay the course in the ways that we are supporting our community and our students during this very turbulent time despite the Myriad of orders that we are seeing that are coming out pretty rapidly we were told that we need to continue to just stay focused on why we are here affirm our commitment to our students continue to provide a

021safe and inclusive educational environment regardless of our students our families legal status gender identity ethnicity or background should things change and laws are re-evaluated we will receive additional information as to Future steps in which we can take and that would be something that we would do in concert and partnership with our board and legal council to add address but at this point in time we will continue to remain committed to our students and families providing a safe stable inclusive schooling environment so I just wanted to share that with those as I know people are worried about the implications for South San Francisco kiddos and with that that concludes my report thank you thank you so much item L student trustee reports uh first Miss harana good evening board cab cabinet and Community my name is

022Josephine harsana and it's my pleasure to represent South San Francisco high school I'm so honored to be sitting up here tonight with Valentine's Day right around the corner South city is spent spreading the love and joy with our annual tradition of marriage in the quad tomorrow on Valentine's Day students have the opportunity to get fake married to their friends and or their significant others in the quad during lunch Mr Capitan a legally ordained officient who has performed Real Weddings will per per the ceremonies tomorrow students will receive a physical certificate ring pops and digital photos with their friends additionally Valentine grams including a handwritten card and a rose will be sold during lunch for $3 this is the perfect way to spread love friendship and school spirit as the winter sports season wraps up we

023would like to congrat congratulate all athletes for completing another season and all seniors were concluding their last season as a high school athlete the wrestling team celebrated their senior night on January 28th they will be competing in the CCS Northern regionals this Saturday at gun High School our girls varsity soccer team recently beat Half Moon Bay and celebrated their senior night last week on the sixth with the boys celebrating their senior night the following day both the boys and girls varsity basketball team recently beat oceanana and just last night the boys team beat Westmore High School our basketball teams are preparing to play El Camino tomorrow in the big Hoops game at South City's very own big gym here both boys and girls basketball will be celebrating their senior nights good luck to all athletes

024playing tomorrow and go Warriors as for Club activities the South City mock trial team concluded their season last Tuesday placing fourth in the league overall the Red Cross Club concluded their blood drive last Wednesday with 24 life-saving units of blood leaving our school to directly help those who have been impacted by the LA wildfires thank you to all community members who took time out of their day and came to City to donate blood the Earth Club is preparing to go on their annual camping trip from March 7th to the 9th in Big Sur ASB elections are right around the corner and this is one of the most competitive Seasons we've seen we are so glad to see many students interested in ASB campaign week will last the entire week next week and voting will conclude

025next Friday the results will be announced that same day good luck to all those who are running for a class officer position additionally the ASB executive officers will be accompan comping the counselors on their visits to the middle schools on March 5th and 6th to encourage 8th grade students to join South City ASB as they pick their classes for the first year of high school this year's prom will be taking place on Saturday April 26 in Fox Theater from 6:30 p.m. to 10 p.m. the theme will be old Hollywood and tickets will be sold starting prices at $100 next Wednesday February 19th as for other upcoming fundraisers the class of 2028 will be doing a raise Kane's takeover on March 5th from 11:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m. the class of 2027 will be holding a

026milk tea lab takeover on March 12th from 12:00 p.m. to 4 p.m. and finally the class of 2025 will be holding a New Horizons fundraiser on February 24th before school finally South City wrapped up history day week last Friday with 22 projects moving forward to the county competition last week judges enjoyed a variety of projects ranging from podcasts websites live performances documentaries and physical exhibits these students have embodied the goals of portrait of a graduate by demonstrating their commitment to learning by not only complet completing a six-month research project but producing excellent projects worthy of representing our school at the next stage of the competition congratulations to all students who are advancing in this year's National History Day competition and good luck at the county competition if there are no further questions this concludes my

027report thank you thank you so much and Jamie Wong can I invite you up for El Camino report I have one question president oh sure sorry I didn't see that what time is the basketball meeting tomorrow can you can you speak into the microphone I did you didn't you um what um time is the basketball game tomorrow so it's a quad game which means all four teams so Girls JV boys JV will be playing Girls JV will be first starting at 400 p.m. thank you so much all right trust to you student trusty Wong good evening board members cabinet and audience at home and audience present my name is Jamie Wong and I'm currently a senior serving as the ASB president at El Camino High School and the fall student cheste it has been a

028while since I've seen you all as I hope you all had a wonderful winter break entering the New Year El Camino's second ever food court is happening tomorrow and we couldn't be more excited after the huge success of our first food court last month we are thrilled to bring it back to showcase the remaining clubs that haven't had their turn yet this event gives them the recognition and publicity they deserve allowing students to learn more about their missions while enjoying delicious food samples just like last time students have pre- purchased tokens to exchange for food making it an engaging and interactive way to support our schools clubs we can't wait to see everyone there to build excitement for our annual hoops rally happening tomorrow we hosted a Valentine's themed spirit week filled with fun and

029creativity we kicked off the week with cuddle love Monday where students wore their comfies PJs on perfect pair Tuesday friends twin up in matching outfits crazy and love Wednesday had everyone in Mis mismatched or backward clothing and today students showed off their spirit show your love for your favorite sport Thursday rocking jerseys and athletic attire finally we're wrapping up the week with a festive Valentine's Day Friday where everyone will be dressed in red pink or white we are Beyond excited to host the Hoops rally and bring the energy as we prepare for the big game against our Rivals South City best of luck to our Colts and we can't wait to cheer them on from the sidelines wrapping up the winter sports season we have celebrated our incredible senior athletes with senior nights for wrestling

030basketball and soccer we recognize Andrew Daman Shan deumos Michael shaili Jay sarich and Aaliyah Rivera for their outstanding wrestling season for boys varsity basketball we honored Kyle Torres Cyrus malbus Troy seora Mickey osario Marco Melendez JJ Pascal Josh pan Anthony Yen and Nathan Forester for their dedication and hard work on the court our girls varsity basketball seniors Caitlyn Santos Zoe ing Adriana Del Rosario Chelsea debasco and isana Martinez have also left an incredible mark on the program boy soccer senior night occurred last night as they won their match 4 to zero and our girls soccer senior night happened tonight in the cafeteria with gifts and Divi dinner provided for the girls congratulations to all of our seniors as they close out their High School careers and head into CCS we can't wait to see how

031they continue to shine as March 8th is approaching join us in C celebrating the extraordinary Life and Legacy of Jim crusta a remarkable educator who dedicated 57 years to inspiring Brilliance at okamina high school from 1964 to 2021 we'll honor his memory with a special Car Show featuring an impressive lineup of Classics street machines under construction builds antiques trucks and domestic and foreign vehicles pre-registration is $35 or 40 at the door additional lunch and dessert tickets for guests are available for $10 all proceeds will go to the Jim Cresta scholarship fund supporting ECS graduates pursuing a trade or vacation register your ride today and help us celebrate a true legend while contributing to a meaningful cause our flyer has been posted on our Instagram account at ecscs so make sure to check that out for

032more information that concludes my report and unless there are any other questions or concerns I'd like to thank you all for listening I hope you all have an amazing 3-day weekend and stay safe safe super all right we will move on to item M public comments to comment in person during the meeting this is sort of a last call as I get through this if you have another comment public comments are limited to 1 to three minutes per individual per board bylaw 9323 name and address cards are placed in the back of the room to be completed and given to the secretary the board president will call P individuals in random order who have requested to speak each person may only speak once and is required to address the board from the podium the meeting

033is recorded and streamed live individuals may address the board concerning School business not on the agenda but public comment cannot be acted upon or discussed by the board unless placed on the agenda at a subsequent meeting in accordance with the law the brown act the board May request staff to respond orally at the meeting or in writing at a future time all right I have four public comments for items not listed on the agenda and just want to confirm with the two yellow card providers that you want to speak later is that all right okay thank you all right random order um I will start with Michelle [Music] baroli good evening president Anthony board members Dr Moore and staff my my name is Michelle Bari and I'm a fourth grade teacher at monover elementary I

034want to express my gratitude for the opportunity to Pilot the illustrative math program over the past six months one of my favorite things about the program is all of the real world math problems that the students engage in Daily they are asked to collaborate with their peers and have Rich mathematical discussions while using a variety of manipulatives and diagrams to solve the problems although although those are two elements that I like I have significant reservations about the program one of the most glaring inadequacies is the significant lack of practice in each lesson the curriculum only gives two to four math problems for students to work through each day there is one additional problem the teacher can assign but beyond that teachers are left with limited options to provide math practice other than utilizing the centers

035I find the centers to be insufficient cumbersome and ultimately UNH helpful for the students it does not provide the robust support that the program claims to have no great a aete engineer entrepreneur or the like have ever excelled by simply doing things a couple of times particularly without instruction or teaching our students are no exception the overall design of the program puts students in the driver seat of their learning with a teacher acting as the guide while this concept seems to be a positive shift the reality is not always so students who lack foundational math skills are confused due to the lack of direct instruction with illustrative mathematics students are asked to collaborate with their peers years to solve the math problems while the students try to work together I've observed some of my students

036being confused by the subject and consistently off topic others have shut down completely due to extreme frustration pulling small groups for additional support is not incouraged in the program if we want our students to reach their full potential not only do we need to provide foundational knowledge support but also mathematical challenges for those who excel in the subject I doesn't seem to provide either sufficiently overall I do not feel that the positives of the program outweigh the negatives however if the curriculum is ultimately adopted there needs to be robust and continuous Math training significant teacher support Beyond just the first year of implementation and supplemental programs such as iel to provide additional practice for students if it is approved I would encourage the board to prioritize allocating staff time and District resources to support students

037and teachers by creating a holistic plan and a road map to implement the new math program so can add value to the new program so that the sum can be greater than all the parts thank you thank you so much Lucy [Music] Bradshaw hi thank you president Anthony board cabinet um I'm a 20y year veteran teacher and I'm here tonight to talk about my why you know we love that you know what's your why I love what I do I love my job I love the kids um today I thought I was going to get a blister from cutting out so many hearts like I love it but I'm gonna be honest my why is my paycheck that's why I show up every day okay so we're not going to play games that that's not

038your why too you know and it it's well let's talk about the portrait of a paycheck right for a teacher let's go let's do that for us to advance our pay we can go down horizontally with years though it's paused for five years at a time but to go vertically you have to take classes you have to pay for those classes and earn units to advance your pay so in the past few years we've had a major problem with teachers not knowing how many units they have or how many units they need to get to the next column and we're in a situation where almost everyone who submitted units had difficulties that I talk to at our site I talk to teachers at other sites that are having problems with pay and emails that are

039not unanswered how many units do I need oh we're moving our office the files are in a box we can't tell you we'll we'll get back to you in a couple weeks well the deadline's next week sorry this is people's pay my pay is fine I'm not here talking about my pay I'm talking about my colleagues pay who month after month have not been paid what they should be paid it went on for a year one teacher a year where she's saying oh humiliating oh hello hi it's me again I still haven't got that raise I was hoping for that I earned by paying for classes still haven't got that any idea when that's going to be fixed and it's really hard we have so many initiatives the new math we have to supplement you

040know the reading we've got the science we've got portrait of a graduate we're trying to juggle all of these things but at home people are trying to juggle their kids they're trying to buy Valentine's you know they don't have time to come here and tell you this stuff and they're embarrassed too but I'm not I don't mind my pay is fine but I will speak up for my colleagues this I don't know what you have to do and it it makes me wonder I was thinking I wonder if anyone on the cabinet I wonder if if their pay short you know maybe not like maybe you guys aren't struggling with what other people are you know it it should be fixed immediately otherwise you know I'll see you guys on the 27th we'll talk about

041it again thank you so much thanks all right Megan connory good evening Meg connory elino High School hello usual math uh pilot conversation um so it could took me a couple of days to process the information that you received last week at the study session and I have some concerns first the district common assessment or the Mars task and the data that you were shown on page 20 you can go back and look um the teachers myself included have not seen any of this data the data is skewed for the 12th graders since the 12th grader who took who had the opportunity to took the Common Assessment would have been in Algebra 1 or geometry what makes them behind a grade level already generally nth grade algebra 1 10th grade geometry 11th grade algebra 2

042also the common assessment for both geometry and Algebra 2 were on material that the students had just covered in September all geometry students just finished unit one Transformations that means that they took the same Common Assessment two weeks ago the students might actually do worse since they could have forgotten the material um for Algebra 2 students my classes had ju just learned most of the material at the end of September so again I'm concerned that they will actually not increase their score the one that they took two weeks ago I'm also wondering what the purpose of even showing you the data from the comet assessment are we going to compare pilot students to non-pilot students both teachers at Al Camino are teaching the pilot or also the honors teachers so our students are expected to

043have better scores than the non-honors classes so how is that reasonable data so this week the students took survey questions which I'd love to read to you but I'm running at a time um but most of them were pertaining to the class this year and do they have opportunities to learn from ideas from their classmates do they work with classmates to solve problems well my kids have been in groups since before covid they work together every single day they Converse about the math every single day so this curriculum has no different in my classroom when it has those things also the survey is not given to non-pilot students so what why is the purpose of the survey then um just last 30 seconds um some of the students in my algebra 2 class have actually

044been in the pilot for two years because they piloted last year in Geometry honors so they have seen both curriculums they've seen illustrative mathematics and they seen the car learning I would be very curious to see how they rate the two um thank you for your time see you in two weeks thank you so much Char Tapia okay good evening um I have been a dedicated employee of South San Francisco Unified School District for over 10 years my daughters have attended School in the district since 2011 I intended to speak to you tonight just as apparent but the truth is I can't separate those two roles I'm here because I am deeply concerned about the safety of our high school students my daughter a senior at El Camino High School does not feel safe at

045school she has been physically attacked by other students twice most recent the most recent occurred on January 27th her 18th birthday it took two teachers and several of her friends to pull the other student off of her my daughter had her hands in the air telling the aggressor to leave her alone yet she was still attacked she did not fight back this time because the last time she defended herself she was suspended this situation did not happen in isolation my daughter reported harassment to school administrators last year yet nothing was done she finally reached a Breaking Point and stood up for herself asking the student and their friends to leave her alone only to met be met with violence these two incidents are apparently unrelated after the January 7th 27th attack I picked her up

046from school and kept her home I immediately sought help from the director of student services to discuss alternative options for her education instead of support I was met with dismissive and rude comments the director who works in the same office as I do and was aware of the previous attack on my daughter never once asked if she was okay physically or emotionally I was shocked by how I was treated not as an employee but as a parent seeking help from my CH child the lack of response from the school administration has been unacceptable while my daughter stayed home that week not a single person neither principal Vice principls counselors nor anyone from student services reached out to check on her well-being this is not just a about my daughter I know other parents who have

047felt unsupported by El Camino's Administration and The Districts The Districts student services I can only imagine how poorly other parents have been treated now my daughter faces the trauma of walking into school where she does not feel safe imagine going into work every day and having to see the person who physically attacked you how would that affect your ability to function tonight one of the items being presented is well counselors for elementary schools while that is important I'm here to tell you that high school students also need more options for support people who will listen take action my daughter's teachers have reached out to me saying that they have seen her in tears thank you all right moving on to item G or item P consent agenda the following items are submitted no I skipped

048a lot of things sorry uh item n information only presentations number one Educational Services teaching and learning presentation Monte Verde Elementary School Dr Moore thank you president Anthony it is my pleasure to introduce principal Debby Mt who will provide the board in our community with key information data and insights about monover elementary school good evening again um I'll get right to it because I know the agenda is very packed tonight this slide should be very very familiar to everyone this slide shows the district and monover values and strategic priorities uh I have to say that Community or wait a second there we go Community is definitely our strength and we have strong relationships with our among our own staff and um with our families you see we had a few of our teachers even speak

049tonight so I would say were empowered Educators there we are and later on in the slides you'll see that um no matter which subgroup our students are in we have the same expectations for them as for any here are the aims that we are implementing all four in the work that we do we are actually real evidence of portrait of a graduate I can say that we have 12 El Camino and South City graduates on campus every day making an impact in the classrooms or in the office where they teach and actually many of those graduates have their children in our schools here's who we are this is our student demographics something to notice here is the number of English Learners that we have has decreased over the years we're down to 35 our number

050of students with disabilities over the a few years has gone up to 58 and that gives us 11% we used to be in the range of nine this is our attendance green is good but mon Verde is Green Mountain so you see why um it's we have 80% in satisfactory and this is um this is pretty good I have to say we only have one student in the severe chronic range and that person is actually very ill so that we have allowances for illness and I'm happy to say we don't have any students in the extremely chronic range here we are year to date January seems to be our worst month for attendance um overall most months are over 96% but like I said January is not our best in both years our best month

051seems to be September and our overall attendance has increased uh from last year 23 24 to this year 2425 this is the attendance broken down by subgroups our highlights are our that our Pacific Islander group has improved over last year our special education students are coming more often and our other subgroups have been consistent over the three years here's our reading uh screening the Dibbles reading screening uh now I have to say that um the beginning of the year scores are are pretty valid but if you look at the middle of the Year slot uh for every grade level you can see that not at the time that this slide was put into the presentation not everyone had been tested so we have a little bit of uh data in Integrity issues here we can't

052count everything if all students are not counted here's our Casp overview 79% almost 80 for language arts 77.27% proficient in math both outstanding scores um we increased in language arts by the same amount that we decreased in math from the year previous I have to say it's really hard to keep those scores at that high range here this is the language arts for the past five years by grade level you see the gray band was the year after our distance learning of which I am proud of the work that monerie and the effort that our teachers did during distance learning but there was a definite decrease across the board it seems students do need direct instruction from the professionals and we did find out that the the students don't teach themselves same thing in math

053math we drop dramatically in some of the grade levels you can see the overall average we were 79% before covid and dropped to 59% after and we're on our way [Music] back if you look at 22 23 and then 2324 comparing them we did have a decrease in two of our grade levels third and fifth grade I hate to say it those were two grade levels that piloted the math last year and the previous year in 2023 there was a third grade that had a 94 proficient rate and that's one of the classes that dropped here's our breakdown for our student group groups some highlights here 73% of our Hispanic students were proficient in language arts 68% of our English Learners were proficient in language arts 44% of our special education students were proficient in

054language arts and 40% were Prof in math so as you see most of we're working very hard with the students in all of our subgroups this is our science Baseline and what you may not realize is that we do departmentalize our program for science in grades 3 to 65% 65 and almost a half percent proficient for science um compared to the state was 30% our district average was 33 now the one this dashboard on the right is sort of a question we have sort of a work in progress but strange so you see our lpac scores are in the orange range the strange thing is our eel's our English Learners scored in the blue range on the language arts for the Casp they also scored in the blue for for math we have to remember

055that on the Casp third through fifth graders are being represented but with the elpac it's kindergarten through fifth grade who are tested and if you think of it it could be that our numbers of Els have gone down so the percentage will be different and the students that were um who are going to be taking the lpac are most likely ones and twos a few threes here's a few pictures of what's going on at M Verde and the our culture of our school and the Traditions that we have uh we come together every year and we do our wathon and we have schoolwide incentives that are earned earned we have cheering every day that top right picture is the last um cheer before our wathon that was on the day of the wathon and all

056fifth graders were invited to lead the cheer that day because it will be their last um we do have a good time together we try to make things enjoyable so everyone wants to come everyone wants to participate I chose to also show our part participation in the Ruby Bridges walk to school event which is one of our newer Traditions there's also a picture from a fourth grade field trip and mostly you can see that everyone participates everyone has the opportunity to be involved I included this slide just as a reminder uh we started out our school year with our office in the cafeteria um it wasn't pleasant but I just put threw these pictures in to give proof and evidence of our flexibility and our resilience to survive through construction and we had a few

057Bond um visits the other day and I'm just looking forward to what's coming next um I have to say that our presid our PTA president did a better job of relaying the information about how we are bringing portrait of a graduate to life um through all of the wonderful examples she GES about the things we're doing on campus I had chosen this these pictures here because um the students were doing something themselves we the third and the fifth grade teachers run a relay once a week and the students race against each other and they have to work as teams and they figured out how to handicap it so it's always a close race well the fourth graders decided that they needed to do their own relay so they got together as teams they figured about

058their common goal and I would say that they they handled it themselves and it was so funny to see that when there was a problem or they wanted to do something uh they were able to put it into real life and all work together toward a common goal now we come to the thank yous for our volunteers and these are the the parents that we're recognizing tonight um I just want to especially thank these parents they've been responsible for Ceremony earning for learning movie Nights running the snack bar there a couple of them are the PTA officers you heard from our president earlier tonight uh they run the holiday gift shop it becomes a full-time job during the week that they uh that the shop is open they've been field trip chaperon they drive on

059the field trips they help with art and action they work in the garden they're helping in classrooms and I have to say pretty much anything that happens at Monie they are involved with do I do it now or okay all right so we have Janine Alvarez Wendy Chan [Music] Beverly deso who happens to be Bianca's mom uh tomaco Joe and waly Wong if you're here come up you go thank you and yes some of them have been ball and told to do these things and my last slide is the best slide here are a couple of pictures of exceptional Educators who provide exceptional instruction and I just want to say thank you to the monover staff um a huge thank you we work hard we play hard we laugh together but I have to say

060that they have been a wonderful support to me this year and I thank [Music] you all right thank you so much comments Jesse Richardson thank you oh I want to thank you for your resilience and putting up with all the construction and disturbance and I know it's been a long time that uh I finally saw the bathroom that that was finally finished so I appreciate your patience and appreciate all the staff and the students especially the volunteers who are very you know volunteering is a full-time job so I understand that they can be a vital support for the whole school so I want to acknowledge that I do appreciate them as well and thank you for your presentation thank you thank you so much TR trust student trusty harana I didn't ask if you wanted

061to make a comment so I am a former mon Eagle um as a former student there um I just want to say that uh I think it's really amazing how quickly that Monty birie has recognized the goals of portrait of a graduate and then actually implemented them and to see like results within a single year is just absolutely wonderful um I love my time at Monty verie so I'm so glad to see that the community and the staff are keeping up the spirit and that other students can experience the the joys of Elementary School we do have a good time so did Josephine thank you so much just L I have a few words to say so um yeah thank you Miss M for being here I and thank you all of you I uh

062I've been really looking forward to having you all here for the longest time um you know as you know my two my well I have one kid there now my I'm a graduate from there I know Dr Moore you know you're fifth grader there um it's such um it you know where I I think once my older or my younger one graduates I'll be one of the long haulers which is kind of an an interesting honor but uh so yeah for about nine years now I've kind of known the Monty bir Community um so uh you know I I just wanted to say publicly you know you uh miss m and your um all teachers and parents you know your team you know everyone here's a team um who have P personally supported um the

063community um and have you know supported me um you know my my husband my kids um for the longest time um you know it's talking about the covid times um you know my my older one went through that and know I know what a huge Challenge and you know stressful time that was um but I I know Miss M you I from what I observe you go through things in a very practical no-nonsense way you know no drama you know whatever the kids are doing that you know may drive the parents crazy you know you just kind of know how to handle that and not get too caught up in all that so to laugh at it yeah I appreciate so much um that kind of um yeah that approach um so yeah just again

064just want to say I'm eternally grateful for the impact that you've had on our kids lives and all of you collectively um and just personally you know it's an honor and a privilege to serve on the board as Verity parent um because you know the culture of the caring creativity and volunteerism both you know up and down all levels from the parents um and teachers um you know and uh you all a big reason why I am able to even be here and serve on the board because I know you have um our families back um and miss m you've had a big part in building that culture up for many many years um so I just want to you know acknowledge that publicly and just know how much I appreciate that and and recognize

065that um also so just you know the Halloween game is strong yeah ever the first time I met you uh you were Prince and you know and now you and you did the the inside out too and I it's great so thank you again thank you so much thank you thank you so much uh principal mer I always enjoy your presentation thank you just make sure you here hear it no problem and then I I'm so proud of our students there as you highlight our casps uh almost 80% on both subjects exceed and meet the standards that's outstanding so continue with the great work that is really amazing and I also appreciate you share your data on the thoughts about our math pilot that is very insightful thank you thank you so much trusty Shay

066I also interested about the math pilot comment and also just want to point out that I don't think we should compare third grade to third grade to third grade as much as we should compare third deg grade to the rising fourth graders but if you look at it it did go down third to Fourth but the pilot was in 2324 right so you can't see them until next year right right so we don't know if it went down what we do know is that the fourth graders who were at 75% % remained at [Music] 75% from fourth to fifth from fourth to fifth right [Music] but over it's this I have to say our our teachers are consistent and so usually their scores are pretty close the following year they're doing the same thing they're

067teaching the same lesson they're giving the same intervention and so it to go down a few points like that it's we're doing the same things it's some some of the students what we're doing is we're lifting them all up whether they don't when they don't understand we're putting the extra time into it to bring them up so a little dip like that is Meaningful okay thank you all right thank you so much all right moving on to 1B Performance Management multilingual learner Dr M do you want to introduce Dr Garcia yes it is also my privilege to introduce Dr Marcos Garcia and he will be providing the board and the community with an update on our multilingual students really highlighting uh just the overall continuous improvement process and some of their successes Dr Garcia great

068thank [Music] you greetings Dr Moore superintendent and Board of Trustees tonight I will be presenting the multilingual learner Performance Management presentation and I I do want to note the shift in language uh we are now using multilingual Learners um to celebrate and acknowledge the assets that our students bring into students and families bring into our schools so this is our agenda you'll also note um our shift and presentation will will align to how our department supports the five strategic priorities that will bring the portrait of a graduate to Life we'll start with the Department overview so you knowe we have a small But Mighty team of six uh multilingual learner tosas three that support the elementary and three that support the secondary and we have one curriculum instruction uh specialist that supports all curricular um

069implementation piloting and um professional learning next you'll see what our Mighty team of six does they supported um nearly 1,700 multilingual Learners across 15 sites 400 educate Educators and um you'll see more once we talk about the five uh priorities one note I do want to acknowledge we are going to be having a districtwide uh reclassification ceremony so please save the date April 17th uh so put that in your calendar so now we're going to go ahead and talk about our goals so we are committed to providing excellent customer service to students to staff to Community Partners we're committed to establishing a datadriven culture with site Educators and uh teachers we're committed to providing research based professional learning that is culturally and linguistically responsive uh promoting multilingualism for our students and families so that they

070are seen and treated as the assets that they are and advocating for the needs of multilingual Learners as well as partnering with families and Community Partners for Student Success now here you'll see our actual um numbers so you can note we're at about 16 um over 1600 multilingual learners and of that 181 are long-term English Learners which is they've been designated uh El that's the state classification uh for 100 uh for more than six years six years or more and then we have the category of uh at risk which is four to five years as English Learners the other thing that I want to note is that we have 750 uh rfip students those are reclassified students and we still have the responsibility and obligation to monitor them for four years after they are reclassified

071and that's what um our multilingual tosas um help to do here you'll see uh this past spring Summit of elpac and I wanted to go ahead and highlight this by the four particular domains so you'll see that they're assessed each year in the area of listening speaking reading and writing and there's one of the domains that I didn't put any numbers and that's because there's only 18 students that scored between a one and a three that means that most of our multilingual Learners when they take the summit of Alpac they're scoring fours okay in speaking which highlights the fact that our students uh are grasping the oral language okay with ease our challenge ising is four sorry which color is four uh so you don't have a four there you'll have uh Light blues being

072zeros you'll have dark Blues being ones uh threes being um dark green and then so light light green and then dark green being the threes so of the total number of multilingual Learners only 18 received that score uh in those ranges but I do want to note that we do have an issue with our reading scores and our writing scores and also the listening uh scores which means we do need to emphasize um academic discourse in classrooms and we also need to emphasize designated ELD across all of our school sites with attention to writing so that's something that we do want to uh ensure and that's what our multilingual Lear ntsis um Provide support with here are our reclassification um comparisons from 23 uh to 24 you will note um a decline or difference between

07323 and 24 and the main difference uh is that in 2023 we started to align our reclassification criteria with neighboring districts and that's why you see that jump in 2023 and we did that because we realized by having and I don't want to say this the wrong way but by having a higher threshold we are actually gatekeeping we want to be be able to reclassify more of our students by the time that they they get to um middle school and high school here you'll see our Ela uh progress and now you'll start to see um the long-term e English learner uh criteria because that that is something that we are now going to be responsible as a district to plan for in our lcap and as well as in our site plans what are the

074actions that we're doing to address our long-term English Learners and that's why I wanted for us to take a look at how our students are scoring in our lpac we'll we'll see a little bit more in a minute so note that our English Learners in general are in the uh de in right so are our long-term Els however we still see the same pattern that we just saw with the um Monte Verde students that the arib students are still uh outperforming our English only students so we we do have to recognize the performance of our reclassified multilingual Learners this is math and we see the same pattern overall a decline for our English learner and um ltel category and the same pattern is true for our RFB students in math continuing to out outperform our

075English only uh students this is our LP our English learner progress indicator what this shows is um on the lpac of students make uh are making growth of at least one level each year and here you can see uh that there is a decline that that is problematic for us this really um is stressing the need to um take a look at our core instruction and how can we also uh not only uh support designated ELD but our integrated ELD how do we support our language Learners in their core content areas particularly English and in math now we're starting to take a look at some bright spots so here for our El graduation data you see that we did increase uh graduation by um for English Learners by 10 uh percentage points long-term Els also

076increased by six uh percentage points some more bright spots now I wanted to go ahead and highlight the bright spots um according to our five strategic priorities so start starting with the first priority exceptional instruction this is our um ml tosa team supports exceptional instruction primarily through training and professional development so they have been involved in the professional uh development uh as it relates to math and science curriculum and ensuring that our teachers are are learning how to support the language needs for um those content area um implement ations they're also supporting with our glad curriculum with with our glad strategies currently uh we have um over a hundred teachers that have been uh trained and certified and glad they also support the professional learning communities they support culturally and linguistically responsive um professional learning

077like trans languaging which Builds on the home languages of students and bridges it to academic language supporting with newcomer and ELD lab curriculum uh last year there was a question about what are we doing for newcomers we're proud to say that we've actually um adopted a curriculum and we're supporting the implementation across um uh K12 now this is how our team is supporting engaged students as I mentioned before culturally and linguistically responsive practices are really important particularly to to acknowledge the the assets that our students bring again there's a trans languaging uh professional learning that we've been part of both for elementary and secondary uh encouraging U and increasing the access to the Seal of biliteracy home home language recognition and as I mentioned earlier the reclassification ceremony we're going districtwide with that because we

078want to show our commitment to uplifting the biliteracy and the multi- lingual um gifts that our students are bringing into our schools the other uh component is our newcomer intake our uh Community liaison team alongside with our uh multilingual learner toses have developed this process to collect the academic journey of our newcomer students which then they share uh via elevation to their to our teachers as well as the needs the basic needs that families might uh have and we connect them to our Family Resource Center we're supporting the purposeful partnership um priority primarily through our um family community and family engagement team they've supported through a variety of engagements uh such as the daac cafe the parent Cafe uh as I mentioned the newcomer intake we've also been developing a family engagement uh Playbook that

079we're going to um be able to Pilot this spring and the development of Our Family Resource Center as well as our Community Learning exchanges last spring we held a community learning learning Exchange in this space here where we had over 250 uh participants 40 of which were Community Partners all coming to share what are the ways that they're going to go ahead and help bring the portrait of The Graduate to life we've also been involved in uh coordinating and facilitating uh know your rights uh trainings um in in this uh current climate Okay empowered Educators we support this primarily through the way we're Staffing so again we have our tosa team we have have also uh been able to ensure that we have bilingual AIDS across all of our title sites uh newcomer AIDS at

080uh Parkway and South San Francisco we're currently funding an ELD uh teacher to support the flooding model at Spruce and we're also um providing stiens for newcomer um uh PLC leads as well as glad PLC um participants we support Equity centered systems by the monitoring that I mentioned earlier of our arib students and our goal is to connect that monitoring to site based mtss and um RTI systems next steps next steps we want to continue to look for opportunities to develop um professional learning by site so customizing um based on the the needs of uh individual School sites we want to be able to implement a coaching model we want to be able to uh continue to to develop more datadriven professional learning plans an area of growth currently we haven't had mandatory access to

081uh all staff or PD day or or District collaboration and that's an area of growth so we're hoping to have more access so that way as we mentioned earlier in the data there's a need for us to be able to talk about tier one instruction and the language needs of our students in tier one instruction we're currently short as uh a partner uh senior office assistant crucial role um but the team is stepping in to support uh another area that we're looking to support is additional uh ELD teachers across the title one sites so hopefully in the future we can support that any questions all right we have four minutes before uh a break it do we have a lot of questions or comments I I think it'll probably be better to just break and

082then come back so we'll come back at um 8:36 thank you for e e e e e e all right we are we are back please come sit back down trusty lamb we are one minute over trusty Richardson we are one minute over we have a lot of things on the agenda I am not trying to be mean I am trying to be efficient all right tressy Richardson you had some questions or comments to say to Mr uh Dr Garcia about uh commenting on our state um requirements and uh I I found out at the break how uh difficult it is is for some of our students to actually leave the designation of el learner and uh if you want to explain to us M uh Dr Garcia about what the process is for a

083a student who's been designated as an e learner and then therefore and has actually uh learned enough English not to be considered with that designation or classification right so at that first uh slide where I was showing the Alpac scores from 2024 you see the four domain so every year our students our multilingual Learners take the Alpac and they're tested in these four areas they need to get an overall four uh on the lpac meaning that and not in one area of these four domains they can have below a three they need to make sure that their overall um points uh they they score a four in addition to that they need to also be uh proficient in the esack right the Casp sorry the Casp um so they need to have those those two

084criteria in addition to um teacher input and parent uh agreeing to reclassification so um our students are actually our multilingual Learners are held to a very high standard uh and I think that that's why you our rip uh uh data for ELA for math outperforming our um English only uh data because they they are held to a very high standard now the challenge when our students have been designated more than uh six years or become lels is that you'll see uh they're they're proficient in conversations they they've been in our schools since and a lot of times since elementary since first grade since Kinder and they're in our middle schools and in our high schools deal with that designation and our concern is in the area of reading and writing right um so we encourage

085the the use of academic discourse the the implementation of designated ELD particularly in our elementary and with the that focus on writing uh at the secondary level we we already have in place like this um in the the structure of middle school and high school they're getting their designated ELD right so there there's classes for that where we and this again this is my opinion is that where we need to strengthen is the ways in which we support language in content area classes like math like science like social studies so one of the things that we're currently exploring for secondary is um through El achieve and there's there's a um a set of uh um practices called constructing meaning which focuses on the academic language that can be supported in in uh various content areas

086so I'm hoping to explore that this spring with our secondary team and having convers conversations with our secondary uh leaders and uh and that's that's kind of where what I'm thinking for now thank you anything else trusty no okay trusty lamb oh hi Dr Garcia welcome thank you for your presentation um yeah I had a couple of remarks and questions um so well first I wanted to remark um I believe on slide seven um there was just something that I uh was really hardened to see um you U one of the bullet points was like promoting multi lingualism so our students and families are seen and treated as assets that they are um I'm just so grateful to see that you know kind of written down um you know I I do believe you know

087multilingualism is an asset and you know whatever challenges um you know uh English you know Learners are facing you know that um that they can treasure that and hold on to that um because it's you know having uh that uh language you know access to you know multiple language or knowing multiple languages is just a bridge to you know multiple cultures multiple communities um so I um thank you for uh you know promoting that um and then I just uh yes so I to my questions um one is um so I I know you've mentioned uh supporting uh families with various resources and doing the no your rights workshops and so forth I know there's a lot of anxiety in the community about the current political climate um I do believe like you know there's

088you know members of our community um who are you know want to support um our neighbors as you know in what whichever way they can so I wonder if you could speak to um ways that uh other folks in the community could you know support families yeah thank you for that question um so today we did host a uh know your rights educator training for North North County it was a collaboration with uh Jefferson Union High School District uh and the Sano uh County Office of Ed Sano um County Office of Community Affairs and one of the the things that really stands out is the Santo County um hotline and that H hotline um is is really important because it helps to uh disseminate actual information true information versus spreading rumors and fear uh the

089more that we use the hotline the more accurate it can be the other um services that they provide is actual Legal C counsel uh in case um some of our our community uh members are either arrested or detained they can provide legal counsel immediately so as soon as we know of something like that for us to go ahead and call and report so that way they can Pro be able to provide legal counsel um to our our our community members um in addition they support with relief for uh the families of uh detained uh community members so that's a what I would encourage is try if folks are trying to figure out how to support the hotline um I would reach out to faith in action and later I can share some other contact to

090see about like how do we maybe even donate to that um that fund right because it it is funded through the county but currently they're Pro able to provide up to like three months of rent support and and uh things like that but if we were able to share that with the community at large I think we could support um even more so I would encourage um supporting the Sano County hot hotline yeah thank you for those insights and then um my second question was I believe on slide 24 you spoke about um I guess areas of growth and um and I I think I was just curious about the last Point sorry let me scroll all the way to the end uh about the Dual dual immersion pathway I wonder if you could just

091speak to I guess you know expand on what you would like to see from that sure um so yeah this is an area of growth um primarily due to capacity uh as you see our our small But Mighty team of six um is is providing support in what we call maintenance you know uh each year supporting the professional learning uh uh planning and um the assessment and the case management of our multilingual Learners and I believe that in order for us to engage in the meaningful dual immersion um exploration we need capacity to do so um what that would involve would be having um authentic conversations and engagement with the community to understand their interest and then moving from that to exploring what are some possible models this is a a larger undertaking because it

092would be uh not only conversations with with our community members but also with our our labor Partners what what what would that mean for trying to uh recruit um bclad certified teachers and um what does that mean for our current uh programs so it's something that I would love to explore and we need some capacity uh to begin that great thank you thank you thank you so much for the amazing presentation and the dat thank you thank you thank you so much Mr Garcia um I really um am excited about the districtwide um reclassification ceremony and um I'm just a huge proponent also of the Family Resource Center I'm really glad that we're doing that I think it is um a really wonderful thing to show what we can do when we all work together

093to solve problems and and and help our community um I'm a member of my buy nothing group and I was like I need boys clothes and the community came out I had to pick up like literally two car F car loads of men's and boys clothes um in the last couple of weeks and then our wonderful wonderful community leaz on Fatima Maldonado helped me unload so many things and I hope that it gets into people who need it I know it will actually so um thank you so much um I'm really happy about this as a person who learned English or learned polish um as an adult it's true right like I I speak fluently I listen fluently I read fluently and my writing still looks like a ninth graders and it's really hard and

094it's it's sort of unfortunate that they have to be perfect uh in so many C categories in order to to age out or grade out um you know it'd be interesting to see how some of our like native English students would do on the same assessment right right um I think it probably be telling um yeah I I uh I'm glad about the work that we're doing I'm really excited about the model I'm looking forward to seeing how um what comes out of the flooding model at Spruce and and getting more updates on that as we as we see kind of two years of data right um and with that I think that's probably enough thank thank you so much have a good evening all right we have another presentation uh this is a presentation

095with potential action item o uh Administration Strategic Staffing plan aligning Resources with priorities um superintendent Shanta Moore will present the Strategic sapping plan to the board for implementation oh um yes that's right I do have two public comments thank you um last call for any public comments on this item all right um I'd like to in invite up uh leens oh sorry good evening board cabinet and South City Community uh my name is Leah lens and I'm a tech tosa in the district and I'm here to address the Strategic Staffing plan proposal which includes um adding instructional coaches but it does not to my knowledge mention the removal of several tosa positions in their place cutting support for social science ethnic studies technology and multilingual Learners I appreciate the district's goal of improving teacher retention

096and growth through coaching but toa's already served this role in 2016 as a first year teacher at Parkway I was offered coaching by multiple toas and their support was invaluable and now I'm even coaching my replacement at Parkway replacing toses with coaches only increases teachers workload while the remaining tosas must take on the responsibilities of the eliminated positions furthermore these new coaches will be placed at Title One elementary schools While most eliminated tosa roles serve secondary schools this removes critical support from secondary teachers and students and forces out experienced tosas creating roles that will be difficult to fill due to mismatched expertise another major concern is the lack of clarity and teacher involvement in the proposed coaching model rather than leveraging the expertise of teachers and Ed services staff the district is outsourcing its development

097to an external company unfamiliar with our community a successful coaching model needs to be developed internally with those who truly understand our schools I don't believe any Toast of pisen should be cut but I wanted to highlight the work of tech tosas and our importance to the district Tech skills has a dedicated section in our port of a graduate and my partner Jen Chan and I have played a crucial role in its development to ensure meaningful integration in just my first year as tosa we have trained pre preschool through 12th grade Educators on multiple edtech programs um guided families in using District technology and led three educator teams to develop Tech scope and sequence establish AI usage guidelines revise and ensure delivery of digital citizenship curriculum and support CTI sight leads in collaboration with our

098Wonder it Department these critical projects cannot be sustained with only one Tech tosa next year with tech and embedded in every grade and subject and the rapid growth of AI this decision will directly undermine the district's commitment to digital literacy and Equitable access to technology I urge you to First retain the toasta positions to uphold high quality curriculum integrated technology and digital literacy and educator support across TK through Adult Ed and secondly post approval of the Staffing plan until the coaching program is clearly defined and prioritize the expertise of tosas and the rest of ed services before turning to an external vendor I know I am new to this role but I have been in this district for nine years and I can confidently say that that the tosa team is a small but incredibly

099dedicated and hardworking group of Educators losing any of them would be a huge loss for us thank you for your time thank you R Campbell hi president Anthony Dr Moore uh board and cabinet members I had some questions in regards to the slides um for the sorry for the upcoming slide on slide 28 I see a budget deficit of around 27 million and um like some clarity on why that ask for $2 million more um for more directors and assistant superintendant when the student enrollment in the district is trending down um I was part of the portrait of The Graduate for the community events and I'm really happy I was part of that and nowhere in that talks did we get to the point where we were trying to Dole out this amount of money

100for directors um and that's all the comments I had thank you thank you all right good evening trustees incredible Community uh tonight I do have the privilege of being able to share with you and present on our strategic plan one of the initiatives that we have within the Strategic plan which is how to align our resources to that of our strategic plan priorities I stand here as the one who is presenting but I have to really give just an incredible amount of Kudos and appreciation for the amount of work that went into this there was a full team of people that helped to really think about and um plan for the presentation that we have before you so I'd like to start really with a big thank you first to our Board of Trustees for

101your leadership your Relentless focus on doing what's best for students and for your trust in approving our bold strategic plan A couple of years ago um or last year excuse me with all of the initiatives within I want to express my deepest appreciation to all of our principles our union leaders our directors our cabinet members and our District staff whose feedback did help to shape the plan that you have before you and then of course thank you so much to all of our students our families and community members whose feedback over the last two and a half years has shaped the plan and the changes that we have indicated we want to make in order to realize the promise that we set said we would do for every last one of our our students so

102this particular quote has been top of mind for me last year as you know we launched into our new strategic plan to help us achieve this bold portrait of a graduate vision for every single student in our district in order to meet this bold Vision we realized we need to work differently we need to be open and willing to change to adapt to learn new things and to think about learning in new ways we know that the way that we are currently organized and using our resources don't always necessarily allow us to do things differently and we do believe that we have to be open to doing things differently if we want to get different results in order to realize the promise for our students to do this what we have committed to doing which

103is outlined also in our plan is to being bold to being inclusive and responsive and adequately resourced while remaining fin finally disciplined of course we want to be inclusive in our planning we want to hear the feedback that we've received and we will take that feedback into consideration and of course as we are implementing the plan we want to make sure that we are adequately resourced and financially disciplined and ensuring that throughout we are really thinking about this lens of equity and being very thoughtful about how we use our resources in that Spirit today that is what I'll be discussing to meet these objectives before you many of us have seen this slide before we worked a couple of years ago to set a new vision for the students in South San Francisco Unified our

104portrait of a graduate our promise that each of our students will learn constantly we'll Thrive as people we'll know how to navigate with purpose and intentionality and will be able to impact their communities for the better we also spent time clarifying our care core values and we identified five strategic priorities that will help achieve our portrait we set our new vision and then we started identifying the specific strategies achieve that Vision that was me thank you recognizing that there are things and opportunities for us to really think about how we might approach things differently from the way we have in the past so what was our driving question the driving question we had this fall as we started implementing our strategic plan was how can we allocate our resources to advance our strategic priorities more

105effectively and more equitably what did we hear from the people with whom we we spoke so I'm going to go back a couple of a couple of years over the past two years we heard from thousands of students families and staff about their vision for our district district and our graduates and ways and ideas on how we might bring that to fruition so we went back to that thousands of feedback that we heard through the strategic planning process to be able to help reorient ourselves to what our community had asked for this past fall we then engaged principles directors Union partners and cabinet members about what they thought we needed to do differently to meet our ambitious goals what you see on the slide our cutouts of all of the quotes that we received you

106just have a snapshot and we spent hours pouring through these quotes we got a hundreds and hundreds of data points about what we could do to change and improve across the district as I said cabinet came together we then started reading through all of the quotes internalizing what everyone shared and then we grouped our feedback into four themes ways we can better focus on instruction especially with exceptional instruction as one of our main priorities the need for more student and family support especially around mental health and schools the need for more capacity in human resources which we heard from a Community member today that shared that and the need for more transparent clear decision-making across the district driven by data accessible data so much of the feedback gathered primarily focused on the need to make

107some adjustments to start at the district level in in order to more fully and seamlessly address the needs at the schools by doing that as we shared it would help to eleviate some of the barriers and the challenges that we were unintentionally causing that is why you will see in this plan that for this initial phase we are seeking to prioritize Investments to start at the district level so we put these in themes regrouped them and then we prioritized them so I'll share with you the intended planning priorities for the fall based on what we heard we heard the importance of strengthening instruction F investing in instructional leadership coaching and better alignment we heard that we need to invest in wellness and strengthen our student and family services that we needed to improve Human Resources

108customer service and responsiveness and invest in Talent recruitment hiring and retention and we also heard that we needed to clarify decision-making planning and approval processing just so it's just clear for people on who is making the decision and who is responsible for uh who's going to be accountable who's going to be responsible for carrying it out who needs to be consulted so how will we change so the team got together we went through these priorities and then started thinking about so what does that mean here's the first thing that we indicated we would prioritize piloting an instructional coaching program as an investment into instructional leadership and and so our first is to propose launching a site-based instructional coaching program beginning with our title1 schools we know and we have heard that our Educators need more

109support in instructional practices and effectively utilizing curricula instructional coaches will be hired to help provide that support we would like coaches to be selected by and to report directly to our site leaders because we want to make sure that they are also supported by District leaders in terms of training ongoing professional development and Fe Fe back on coaching practices our coaches as we have it will be members of the CTA they will not supervise teachers their job is to help coach mentor and support support teachers in getting better and we have as you heard started working with one of our partners partners in school and partners in school is helping to facilitate but it is with a committee of South San Francisco Unified School District Educators teachers and teachers on special assignment who are helping

110to shape the coaching program something that we do hope to launch at the beginning of the 25 26 school year the next part that we are proposing is sharpening our focus on instructional leadership we want to shift some things in our Educational Services Department and we'd like the first change that should the first thing to Signal A change is the title retitling it teaching and learning Department a lot of the feedback that we heard was focused on this department and the desire for deeper levels of curriculum instruction EX accessible data and more support and alignment with our schools as over the years our educational services department has been incredible they see a need they step up and they're willing to address that need but what we found over time is that the department has picked

111up things that traditionally don't live in the ed services department our current team has done a wonderful job um bringing us to this point and preparing us for the types of reorganization that we are proposing as part of the renewed focus and vision for the work on instruction instructional leadership the assistant superintendent along with the director uh new director of school leadership will support our principles much of the data that we heard from leaders is we would like to be coached we also want uh someone that can help us on a day-to-day someone we can call someone who um can help with the problem solving so I I evaluate all of our site leaders but we all know that my evaluation and is very different from having someone who is on the ground with them

112week to week month to month day-to-day helping them problem solve the various things that come up for them the director of school leadership and assistant superintendent will be the two to really provide that to our our school leaders they will also work to ensure that the teaching and learning Team Works in alignment with schools and that Communications are streamlined also feedback that we had previously heard about sometimes receiving a lot of different direction from within one Department the St director of student performance position Position will remain the same staying even more focused on data analysis in providing data and training and helping people to analyze and interpret director of innovation will continue to focus on math and science and our partnership with Genentech director of el and categorical programs continue to focus on literacy and

113our multilingual Learners and categorical programs however over time it is part of our goal is to have someone that holds curriculum instruction and assessment for all of our student groups so that they're not parceled out amongst different directors and finally the new director of school leadership is the person that would help to manage the coaching program to ensure that coaching practices that teachers are working on are in direct alignment with school leaders support they would also be supported by a coaching coordinator note that we will have five directors in Edge services in this initial phase with the fifth director not being funded by South San Francisco Unified but funded by Bay Ed fund phase the next phase would be when we return back to a status quo of having four directors in the ed services

114department and you'll also note I haven't mentioned much about special education I know many of you might be thinking what's happening there we have been working very closely with director yakub to make improvements in our special education department we're eager to finalize those conversations and share updates with the board over the course of the next few weeks but these conversations are happening in parallel so that's why they they're not explicitly shared tonight next piece is really strengthening instruction by adding designated substitutes at each school we will be planning to add a teaching fellow at every school next year which will serve as a floating substitute principles can then utilize that teaching fellow to cover a classroom when teachers are out or to provide coverage so teachers can observe and visit one another teach start is

115one of our partners um as we're growing our teacher pipeline so we're just excited about that this is something that came before the board a few months ago the next piece is about how we invest in wellness and strengthen our student and family services and so as we think about student and Family Services we heard from our community and they indicated we need more support for students and so that is where we are proposing adding Wellness counselors to the tital one schools to start and continuing to build the relationships and the supports for them we also are planning on expanding our student and Family Services team and so what you see on this slide is counselors currently are being um they are currently reporting to someone in the educational services department it would mean that

116counselors would then move over to the student services department uh the new title that we are looking at for student services is student and Family Services to really think about how we're serving our our families Community liaison currently report to the educational services department they would then shift to student and family services department and and then this team would be the team that's responsible for really helping to make and create a welcoming inclusive environment particularly in our reception areas next improve our human resources customer service and responsiveness so we are also proposing to invest in Human Resources we are creating new positions that will focus on certificated Recruitment and classified recruitment we're proposing having a new position that focuses solely on HR systems and data so that we have accurate organized actionable HR data to

117inform our hiring and retention efforts we're also anticipating uh another director that focuses on Talent strategy especially when it comes to that Recruitment and hiring and of course under Mr hanan's leadership prioritizing a superior customer service experience for both those outside of our organization but also those within our organization and then the last piece is on clarifying decision making and I am committed and I know my team is committed to making sure that we just do a better job in being really clear and transparent on behalf of our students and so part of what we wanted to do is really go through a process of listening to what people were saying were some pain points and some barriers and being able to address those so many of the new Investments that you see will directly

118impact students and families lives like well dedicated Wellness counselors elop coordinator to help work directly with families for Afterschool programming others will directly impact Educators day-to-day experiences like initiating at uh instructional coaches at Title One schools the impact of others though may be more indirect but are just as important most of the feedback like I said that we heard was about the district office services and operations to create a more effective Baseline uh level of support for our schools we do think that by improving our services and operations we can help site leaders Educators and families focus on their primary responsibilities which is caring very deeply for our children for example increasing HR capacity will take some burden off of recruiting for our sites who often have filled in the gaps and helped us getting

119a dedicated support person in the form of a direct of school leadership will help to streamline Communications to principles and assist them in problem solving their day-to-day concerns and challenging both operational or instructional and moreover throughout this process we made some conscious conscious decisions not only about what to add or to change but also about what to keep we consciously did not touch positions or programs that directly impact students even though they have been funded by one-time grants and instead we have elected to dip into our Reserves if needed to preserve them for example roles like reading Specialists site-based intervention interventionists larza air tutors for kiddos with IEPs those were conscious decisions that we made in realization and value of the services being provided on our campuses so you're probably thinking how do we how

120do we plan on resourcing these things we know that these investments will have an impact on our students and our families and our educators we also know that these Investments require resources so I mentioned that throughout the process we have been trying to be very disciplined so I want to share with you some of what we did to do that so under Mr O's leadership with er's support which is education resource uh strategies we did a full review of our financial landscape I'm proud to say that our finances are relatively stable as you hear Mr O presenting frequently about the state of our budget while other districts are facing significant challenges we are in a good Financial spot right now however as Mr O shared during his first interm report we do have a number

121of grants that are ending or that have ended and as you know we are um enthusiastically negotiating a new contract with our CTA partners and so we have to be ever Mindful and responsible in order to think about where we might want to some point make some reductions we can do anything but we can't do everything but that is why When developing the Staffing proposal we strove to be fiscally disciplined so our staffing proposal does include both Investments with a recognition of the ways that we will be offsetting reductions and by additional Revenue so how are we going to reorganize ourselves to make room for these strategic Investments we are planning on reducing our y SP contract as noted if we're bringing in Wellness counselors to the title one sites in house we're no longer

122going to be utilizing ysb Ser for those Services we're going to be reducing District off some district office based roles everyone whose role has been impacted has already had a conversation with our human resources department even peoples who may have a role that changes or shifts we are opening new roles and we do want to find the right place for all of our people where they can make the most impact for our students and families and schools we are negotiating in the process of negotiating contracts with two of our partners that you heard a couple of community members mention for next school year that we're going to be gradually uh relying Less on external consultants and More in our own capacity as we invest in our Educators and then of course we are seeing increased

123revenues for various reimbursements and funding from the bay Ed fund what I am proud of that this team has done is really seeking to man manage change in alignment with our care core values these are really exciting Investments we also recognize it is a significant change to how many teams and people have operated in the past and so throughout this process we are rooted in our care core values we are really committed to managing this change thoughtfully and intentionally and with care for particularly those who've been impacted what I will also say is I know that this isn't everything people may have wanted in may not be everything that people think we need to do but it is a start and this is It's a beginning for us to think about we have this incredible

124strategic plan how do we then align resources and service to that and it is our proposed way of doing it that is bold that is inclusive that is responsive and that is disciplined and so at this point I want to thank the board and the community for the feedback that we have re re have received um I will open it up for questions we are requesting this is a a presentation that is for approval this evening I also would like to invite my colleagues Mr O and Mr Hanan who will also be helping to address any questions that you may have so I open it up to the board thank you so much Dr Mark sure Dr Shan you want to start trusty lamb somebody needs to go first trusty lamb call in on you

125much time do we have I'm just gonna be brief um yes I I I appreciate this outline it does give a road map to everybody what our plan is where before we weren't really sure when we're started but if we've already started and I understand we've been on this plan for two years and it's a big lift okay I understand that but do we have a do we want to project at this time how long this process would take our specific District um you know we have these benefactors and I appreciate them so much I mean they really and to you Dr Moore because without your leadership they would have walked away with their millions of dollars so I I totally get it but you know honestly we see some things and I I'm just

126waiting where is the the benchmarks that we want to say we've achieved this much we've been into the plan two years what are the benchmarks yeah thank you trusty Richardson so part of what the board did was approve the plan last year we are in year one of implementation and so what you are seeing is some this plan is representative of an initiative under Equity centered systems that we said we would do in order to be able to hit the benchmarks we said we need to look at the plan and then allocate resources differently in support of this plan so that we have the right people in the right places and the right positions to be able to do the work work in order to carry out the Strategic plan so this is year one

127for us and this is one of the initiatives that we said that we would accomplish this year that update justy L hi uh know I had post I had posed some questions about the budget and it's and know it's s of a big topic because there there is uh you know some initial resources it seems to implement um this first phase um I I know in the memo um there was talk of like uh the plan costing two million for the first two years um if it's possible to kind of give an overview of what that looks like why it's necessary and then how the that increase will draw down um in subsequent years maybe Mr O if you want to jump in or yeah take that question thank you for the question so you

128know just like you know when I present my financial report I I had to break down the cost the impact to District over three years so we call the multi-year projection so that's one of the things I did to make sure that we can afford the uh additional expenditures so the net impact to South San Francisco univ School dist budget you know over the three years is about 2.5 million and to break that down you know the first year is about 1.4 million uh second year about 600,000 and the third year about 500,000 so that's what makes up the uh 2.5 million over three years if we just count two years I mentioned it is around two million and I have in trouble phrasing this because I think uh I think if if I mean

129I know when I was I was curious to see why um yeah why that first year um was necessary it seems like there's sort of this U it seemed like there's kind of like an overlap like we we have old positions or and and we've we're going to create these new positions I guess I'm I'm just trying to understand or maybe create like a mental model of like why the that first phase um seems or that first year or year or two seems to be a higher and then um but and then things are going to gradually draw down uh and I could answer that question if those are very good questions actually so the reason for the cost reduction for 2026 27 and 27 28 has to do with the funding from bayed funds

130so so so as Dr mentioned we'll be phasing out some of our partners for example like Partners in school Innovation PSI learner Center collaborative LCC and Ed Pioneer So eventually over the next three years we will phase out with the Partnerships so once we phase out the funds are dedicated by better funds to these organization will be used to help offset some of the positions that were added so that's why you know we still get the funds but instead of paying to the partner it'll be paid to the district to offer some of these uh new positions so that's why you see a reduction in the cost in the out years the other thing trusty lamb to note is that one of the things that we've been really intentional about doing is not so you

131heard us say that we have several one-time Grant funded positions many of these have expired or will be expiring and we have not made those reductions and so it is on top of the onetime positions that we have absorbed as part of our general fund budget that is also what's contributing to the the rise the larger cost because we haven't made the reductions for some of these one-time Grant funds okay thank you sure thank you um I have a couple comments I really appreciate the the thorough and transparent approach to the budgeting that Mr O and the team has presented it's very clear that our district is being proactive in participate anticipating Financial challenge and planning accordingly so Mr O can I ask you one more simple question can we afford this Staffing plan uh

132yes definitely for 2.5 million over three years we should be able to absorb that in the budget but what we need to think about in the future is you know we have additional cost from negotiation or maybe U you know Staffing or uh funding cuts from the state because we're not sure what's going to happen with the new Administration so we need to prepare for that you know so you know you know you saw my first in financial report presentation yeah I mentioned there's about about over five million of of positions charged to onetime stimulus funds that's expiring about coming to an end or depleted so you know so So eventually you know like most School District in California we're going to have to make some Cuts some tough decisions but how much we determin

133to that we need to cut or depend on you know what how we settle with our uh organ units got it and and one more comment I really want to point it out with uh Dr more your presentation that this is this Staffing proposal is very clear to me it's grounded in research and extensive stakeholders feedback so I really appreciate that and that's well aligned with our strategic uh priorities so I appreciate the phased implementation plan that you share a little bit Ure leadership is in place before rolling out additional roles I think that is very strategic and very important and so and also the how I also want to uh comment on the conservative budgeting approach this commitment to review existing programs that you mentioned on the slide uh to determine their effective Effectiveness

134and this approach I really appreciate because that's how we ensure our resource are alloc reallocated it or where they have the uh greatest impact to our students so please continue doing this excellent work make sure that the program that we we are going to keep we really evaluate them that has strong impact to our students so that's my comment thank you thank you I appreciate that I think trusty Richardson was alluding to something very similar for us and really thinking about as we continue to do further analysis we have a lot of programs in our district and they may not be the same across the district and so for us really getting very clear on what is the intended impact and are we actually meeting having that impact for the students that we serve and

135so that will certainly continue to be one of the the principles that we hold as we're moving through this process go ahead president Anthony um thank you so much for this presentation um I I really like that truste Shay writes out her comments mine are going to be a little bit more off the cuff but um spoken from the heart and from experience um changes really hard I mean I think that everybody knows that um I think that all of you are aware that um Mr Hanan is currently the super assistant superintendent of human resources and student services and how much does time is he get to spend on student services it's very little right it falls to the director and that's fine on some level but we are saying that one of our five

136priorities is empowered Educators if that's a priority then we should have a person dedicated to doing that if one of our priorities is purposeful Partnerships we should have somebody who's working on those Partnerships and those Partnerships are with our students and with our families I think one of the things that we hear a lot um in Anonymous public comments that we reive beforehand is a questioning of um the intelligence and the intent of the people making decisions and um I'm not super into the challenging of the intelligence or why people are doing things these things are if we believe that people are experts and you believe that you have Union representation that is where the teacher voice comes in you should be speaking to your union rep that restent person is representing a lot of

137things during the last year when we heard a lot of things about math adoption we heard a lot of not nice things about tosas and now we're hearing all the wonderful things about tosas which is wonderful and I'm really glad and I also think what we hear is that we want them to be in the classroom more we want them to be coaching more we think they have capacity for coaching more and now we're saying oh well but we need to have all of these positions and that's really really hard there are going to be trade-offs and every decision set that you're going to make is going to have trade-offs and the other reason I mean looking at this I can understand why we're not you know going wholesale two feet deep end on all

138of these changes um but as looking at what we're adding and looking at what we're doing in the shift I'm really excited about shifting um and combining the positions of English learner director and Innovation and community outreach director into a curriculum instruction English language Learners multilanguage Learners are Learners special ed students are Learners I know that our director of special ed is doing her damnest to do this I know she also has a lot of compliance and I think that in a lot of these spaces we've had to focus on compliance because we haven't had time to focus on excellence and I think that this program will help us focus on excellence and I'm excited about that and I also know that it's going to feel like Band-Aids pulling off your skin and your hair

139and you're just not going to like it and I hope that what happens is that you come back and you say you know what we are doing better for kids because at the end of the day we're here for students we are here for making sure that our students and families feel appreciated that they feel wanted that they have the chance to achieve their goals and dreams that they are able to achieve their portrait of a graduate and the way that we're set up right now it's really hard to do that we have a lot of people running at a million miles an hour and our principles are looking to Dr Moore for more guidance and she's dealing with a lot of other things it's this it's that it's this and there's only one human

140right I look at my city manager that I work for and she is all over the place she's got all of these things going on and then people say well she should be doing more I mean it's your job it's not your life and she actually makes it her life for most of the time I mean we are here so much they are here so much and I know that you are all putting a lot of effort in the classroom and my hope is that this plan and I understand that we um are delaying the adoption of the instructional coach um job description and I think that sounds like the right decision in order to get it right so that we're talking about it in the right way and we're finding the right skill set

141and we're saying this is what we really want out of this position but I'm excited about having more ability and more um uh resources at the school level um when I worked in Chicago Public Schools everybody agreed that the principal was pretty much the key to the school um your your District leadership is really important and it's having that District leadership that you can go to and you can say I trust that this person is going to get their job done right I trust that they're going to support me this system I think will help support that better and it will also enable our principles to do what they do best which is manage their campus and support their teachers and ultimately and most importantly support their students so I'm I I recognize that there's

142going to be some some Growing Pains um it doesn't feel good I don't feel good about that either um I I think that everybody in this room knows that we are talking about people and we're talking about their real livelihoods and their real skills and I don't want to diminish that but I am also really excited about what this can bring for our district so thank you thank you president Anthony and just uh I'll put a pin on it after this we are also very committed as we think of purposeful Partnerships to partner with those in our community and part of that pulling of that job description was to make sure that we are partnered and working in Tandem and in Partnership so that we can provide the very best to our educator so I

143appreciate that you Amplified that point Thank you so with that we move to action Administration a approval of the Strategic Staffing plan do we have any other comments okay may I get a motion I motion to approve okay second motion from Dr Shay second from trusty Richardson all in favor I all opposed okay motion carries 4 Z thank you so much thank you all right um I'm just trying to get my screen back up here my agenda All Right Moving On to P consent agenda the following items are submitted for board approval one motion will authorize actions for those items so designated do we have any questions or comments about this consent agenda okay I have one comment I just wanted to call out on number 2A Education Services um hidden in that item uh

144is a note that Derek Padia from El Camino High School will be awarded the Henry Betton Court award uh for area B which highlights his outstanding contributions to Student Activities and leadership development so congratulations Mr Pia and I hope that you um have a good time okay may I get a motion to approve the consent agenda so moved okay uh first from trusty lamb second from trusty Shay yeah okay um all in favor I I I um all opposed motion carries 4 Z all right information discussion oh man we have a lot of informational things tonight number one b a business services update on Governor's 20125 2026 budget proposal okay good evening okay yeah I was supposed to present this on the last board meeting unfortunately I was out sick so so I'm presented on

145this board meeting okay so this is the update on the governor's 2025 26 State uh budget proposal so on Friday January 10th 2025 Governor Nome released his State uh budget proposal for next year 2526 and but this year rather than the governor presenting the budget proposal it was done by Joe stefen Shaw the director of Department of Finance so on January 21st my staff I attended a inperson Workshop given by school Services of California in Sacramento to gather the details of his proposed budget so we'll be using this information to update the district's 2425 second interim financial report which will be bring to the board in uh mid-march uh so keep in mind that this is still a proposal at this time the governor has another opportunity to make changes from now through early May

146before he releases his uh during time where he releases his May Revision in miday so the governor presents a budget a balanced budget that assumes steady uh stable National growth he also noted that the uncertainty about the fiscal or federal policy as the most immediate risk to the economic forecast the 2025 26 State proposed budget was prepared prior to the uh devastating Los Angeles fires which caused Total Property and capital loss ranging from 95 to 164 billion since the population of Los Angeles County makes about 25% of the total state population and home to 14 of the 14 500 companies this isur to have a significant impact on on the California economy and the state budget in addition the IRS and cap California state following deadline extension for Los Angeles County will make it very

147difficult for the state to obtain a good estimate of this Revenue because this County contribute more than 50% of the state's Revenue in the pr year so according to school Services of California some of the risk the state budget include the stock market volatility extreme weather uh events delay tax deadlines due to natural disasters and also the federal policy uncertainty uh relating to the tariffs and immigration and also elevated uh interest rates for education Governor Nome proposed a state budget to preserve Investments made during the boom years and propos an education budget that invests in core instruction and learning through a combination of one time and ongoing funding there are no midar cuts no referrals and no program roll backs like uh in the past the bad news for education is a shrinking local control

148funding formula uh due to a heavy declining enrollment in the state and the tiny cost of living adjustment Cola for 2425 of 1.07% and a small Cola proposed for 2526 of 2.43% only tonight I will be providing an update on some areas of the proposed budget and its impact on education so regarding a local control funding formula lcff on the this formula the government proposed to fully fund this for 2526 with ongoing dollars so the proposed 2.43% Cola for 25 26 if is a revenue reduction of about half a percent for school districts from the proposed uh 2.93% Cola uh when we finalize uh the current 2425 budget uh lucky for us you know this doesn't really impact our school district because we're a base a community funded School District which means we get the

149bulk of our revenue from property taxes and not So Much from the state uh regarding C and C Pur which are the employee pension on employee pension the government did not uh provide any new funding for the California State teachers retirement system what is C St or the California Public Employees Retirement System C Pur and his 24 2526 proposed budget the employe rate for C Pur would uh increase from 27.05.2012 St if it will still remain the same at 19.10% so this will be a increased cost to to school districts uh regarding Universal transitional kindergarten the governor's budget proposal includes a total of 2.4 billion ongoing for full implementation of universal transitional kindergarten in 2526 he also wants to provide a total of 1.5 billion ongoing to reduce students to adult ratio from 10 to

1501 from yeah 10 to from 12 to1 to 10 to1 in 2526 and then last year he was the invest 10 million onetime funds for the state to provide a new English language screener for uh transitional kindergarten students okay so the uh Governor's proposed budget also includes several one-time funding grants one of them is called the student support and professional development discretionary black Grant and these funds may be used for the following purpose to address specified raising cost unspecified rising cost professional development for teachers on the English language arts and English language development framework and literacy road map professional development for teachers on the mathematics uh framework teacher Recruitment and Retention strategies uh and career Pathways and dual enrollment so it's has multiple uses for this uh Grant proposed Grant so he's proposed to allocate

151about one .8 billion to this new one-time block gr another one-time blockr he's proposing is the language recovery emergency BL Grant the government wants to provide about three7 378.5 million to this BL Grant and this block grant uh was initially established in 2022 uh budget act and supports learning recovery initiative throughout through the 27 28 school year and lastly the government has prior teacher Recruitment and Retention programs over his tener the governor's proposed budget continues that Trend and provides 150 million to create the teachers recruitment incentive uh grant program that will provide financial assistance to teachers candidates in addition the budget allocates 100 million to support the existing national board certification incentive program and to support the national board of certified teachers to serve in high poverty schools so so there these are some of

152the one-time funds that the government is proposing for 25 26 so by keep in mind that you know these funds uh with the funds needed for the devastating Los Angeles fires you know there is still a lot of uncertainty if there will be sufficient funds you for these one-time grants you know because uh they were not included in his proposed budget in January and the the governor's budget also proposed that you maintain funding level for special a at the 2.43% C as well so again these are just proposals from the governor at this time during the next few months the legislature which is the state senate and State Assembly will go through the proposals either pushing back on the governor's priorities or proposing their own in miday based on the latest financial information which includes

153the impact of the LA fires the governor will release his May revision which is an update to his proposed budget for next year and then staff again will be attending a workshop to gather more information at that time to share with the board thank you any questions see Richardson thank you Mr O I um I'm interested I was interested in that value for special education because that was a staggering amount that we have to budget for them um I wanted to ask you is that that um 2.3 of the cola um going to impact our services to special education and do don't we rely a lot on the federal government to supplement some of these costs well we we get both uh federal and state funding for special education but you know the what they

154provide us is not nearly enough we basically can shoot more than 30 million from our general fund to that program to cover the the Our obligation for to provide those Services all right thank you so much Mr okay thank you all right we move into the core action part of our agenda um and I will just make a time check we've got about 25 minutes before we have to take another Break um we may have to extend this meeting but I will try to get through this um as quickly as as we can with enough time for questions all right action one Administration B approval of District's updated board bylaws and policies staff recommends the approval of the following updated District board bylaw and policies in a way of a second reading as presented to

155the board do we have any questions or comments so I move okay to approve uh the following updates of board policy by law and bylaws and wave a second read thank you so much motion by truste Shay do I have a second I'll second second by trusty lamb all in favor I I I any opposed motion carries 4 Z moving to Educational Services 2A approval of agreement with document tracking Services DTS for 2025 2026 staff recommends the approval of the renewal agreement with document tracking services for March 2025 to March 2026 do we have any questions or comments I do okay justy Richardson is this um this service for the document tracking includes our projects for the bond program or is that is there a separate U software for that yeah this document tracking Services

156is the agreement that we utilize for our school plans for student achievement I believe that there is a separate service for Bond tracking okay thank [Music] you okay any okay um can I get a motion so move F first by trusty Shay second by trusty Richardson all in favor I any opposed motion carries 4 Z Educational Services Tob approval of theou with Silicon Valley Education Foundation svef for 2025 staff recommends the approval of the mou between svef and ssfusd to provide the Elevate math program designed for third to nth grade students effective June 1st to August 1st 2025 have questions or comments no so move okay first by trusty Shay second trust second by trusty lamb all in favor I I I uh any opposed motion carries 4 Z to C approval of the service

157Proposal with young audiences of Northern California YNC for 2025 staff recommends the approval of the service Proposal with young audiences of Northern California effective March 1st to September 1st 2025 any questions or comments um I uh I did have a question generally about if we offered uh language support for students uh who speak uh language other than English um during for these summer programs um that I don't know about it does say in the plan for this one that there's additional elll support which may translate to that but I would have to check with um Dr Garcia okay I also didn't check this um compared to last year but I feel like this year they included professional development for teachers on a level that they're not they haven't done in the past is that true

158okay okay great um can I get a motion to approve so moved okay I think that was a first by trusty lamb and a second by trusty Richardson um all in favor I I any opposed motion carries 4 Z 2D approval of the work experience education Wii program District plan for the 2025 2026 school year staff recommends the approval of the work experience education we we District plan for the 2025 2026 school year any questions or comments um I yeah I did have one question um and well let me start with my comment I'll try to be brief um I I just really appreciate that the oh actually that might be for the next proposal but I'll just mention anyway that the that I appreciate the topics that are covered um in this program um

159and I just feel they're very sophisticated in terms of um addressing uh environmental sustainability financial literacy um business planning and Leadership and I just um just wanted to commend that um and I had a question in terms of um how work site placement or employment um is considered to be eligible for um this program all right um I think you were asking about the students and how they were placed is that the question yes yeah how how I think the placement um I I guess I was under the impression that students some were either could choose the work site or if or were they just placed by the class so I think for this one um the student would need to be at the work site placement associated with that particular CTE pathway um that

160they are either currently enrolled in or previously completed so if they're in a specific pathway and they film like an after school like managerial production Arts pathway who film an after school activi such as sporting events they would be eligible but they would have to the teacher and the CTE Coordinator would be the ones to determine eligibility for placement okay great and I I think I mean I we should let uh coordinator Rockette eventually answer this but what I've seen in other schools districts is that the work site placement the student can find their own if it's out or off- campus um and then they would be approved they would bring it and say this is the tasks that I'm doing and so it could be approved um and if they need help in finding

161it sometimes the CTE coordinator also helps coordinate with School site or with job sites that are interested in having CTE students and then they might be able to be placed that way so it can be student driven or CT coordinator driven as well I'm not sure if that's the same program but like work placement for CT typically where the model you've seen okay thank you so I move all right um motion to approve by trusty Shay second second by trusty lamb all in favor I I four to zero uh motion carries all right approval of the Career Technical education work experience education ctwe course proposal for the 2025 2026 school year staff recommends the approval of the Career technical work experience education course proposal for 2026 um I think we do have a question I

162think this is probably the one you were yeah I think I jumped ahead my question but anyway it's um I also just want to acknowledge Jennifer rucket for her great work in building out our CTE program so just continued appreciation there any other comments or questions all right can I get a motion to approve so move trusty Shay second by trusty Richardson all in favor I I I any opposed motion carries 4 Z all right we've got approval of theou with the Exploratorium for the 2024 2025 school year staff recommends the approval of theou between Exploratorium and ssfusd to support the evaluation and development of instructional resources as part of the elementary science instructional innovators cohort Initiative for the 2024 2025 school year good thing we have four people before yeah I have to recuse

163myself because the Explorer term is my employer but please receive so we got three any questions or comments on this one That's mighty Noble of you it's good all right uh we got a motion from truste Shay can I get a second second by trusty Rich uh Richardson all in favor I I any opposed motion carries three Z with uh trustey lamb recusing herself all right moving to Human Resources 3A approval of theou with classified School Employees Association chapter 97 for the par educator Recruitment and Retention strategy for the 2024 2025 school year staff recommends the approval of the memorandum of understanding with classified School Employees Association chapter 197 par educator Recruitment and Retention strategy for the 2024 2025 school year any questions or comments so move I got a quick comment which is that

164I'm really glad that we're doing this I know that par Educators have um been traditionally a very hard position to fill and I think because they need to get paid more so I'm glad that we're doing some new things to try uh and attract more okay we got a motion from trusty Shay second second from trusty Richardson all in favor I motion carries 4 Z all right 3B approval of theou with the South San Francisco classroom Teachers Association sfcta for the early notification retirement incentive for the 2024 2025 school year staff recommends the approval of the memorandum of understanding with the South San Francisco classroom Teachers Association for the early notification retirement incentive for the 2024 2025 school year any questions or comments no I don't have a comment on this one what thank you

165I mean I I did have a couple questions it's right to ask um I'll I'll just ask to um so one um uh is this a cost cutting measure and how so and two is there any intent to freeze positions of those who choose to retire early thank you trusty lamb um I guess you could look at this both as a potential cost cutting measure uh as well as a Workforce uh planning strategy so as an example um if a an experienced veteran teacher took advantage of the early ification incentive uh you know we would potentially be hiring someone who generally on average would have lesser experience than someone who um has been in our district right and that ties to their salary step placement as an example um from a Workforce uh planning strategy

166perspective we would have advanced notice of potential vacancies and we would work with our school sites around enrollment and determining whether or not we would need to backfill the position um you voted earlier about the release of temp teachers There's an opportunity there to potentially tap one of those temp teachers to backfill a position those are a couple examples and then your question about freezing positions we are not currently planning to freeze any positions at this time great thank you okay so move sorry have we offered this program in the past president Anthony yes we have our last uh with our partners with CTA was in the 2020 2021 school year okay thank you uh I heard a motion already from trusty Shay can I get a second I'll second all right trusty lamb uh

167all in favor I I I um motion carries 4 Z all right approval of the assistant superintendent of teaching and learning job description for the 2025 2026 school year staff recommends the approval of the job description for the assistant superintendent of teaching learning effective for the 2025 2026 school year any questions briefly I saw that the uh the days of employment is 260 days versus I think 220 days um how does that figure into our school year please I think you may be referring to the difference between a director uh work calendar versus an assistant superintendent so we have a longer work calendar thank you all right so move okay got a motion for trusty Shay second by trusty Richardson all in favor I I any opposed motion carries 4 Z 3D approval of the

168director of data educational technology and accountability job description for the 2025 2026 school year staff recommends the approval of the job description for the director of data educational technology and accountability effective for the 2025 2026 school year any questions or comments all right can I get a motion so move trusty Shay second second trusty lamb all in favor I I I motion carries 4 Z all right approval of the director of school leadership job description for the 2025 2026 school year staff recommends the approval of the job description for the director of school leadership effective for the 2025 2026 school year any questions or comments briefly will would they be on charge of the uh the the district's web page and putting it together what it it says data educational technology and accountability oh we

169moved to 3E for the director of school leadership that's not included it's already done we passed that one wondering what where the category was for maintaining the district's website and updates on newsletters and I'm just sort of wondering who's who's uh you know trusty Richardson uh that position is held by our uh chief of strategy and communication okay thank you all right can I get a motion to approve the director of school leadership job description move Mo motion for by trusty lamb second by trusty Shay all in favor i i i u motion carries 40 all right moving on to 3F approval of the director of curriculum instruction and assessment job description for the 2025 2026 school year staff recommends the approval of the job description for the director of curriculum instruction and assessment effective

170for the 2020 2026 school year any questions or comments so move all right I've got a motion by trusty Shay second by trusty Richardson all in favor I I any opposed motion carries 40 okay item G approval of the coaching coordinator job description for the 2025 2026 school year staff recommends the approval of the job description for coaching cour coordinator effective for the 2025 2026 school year any questions or comments trusty Richardson okay can I get a motion okay first by trusty Richardson I'll second second by trusty lamb all in favor I I motion carries 40 till um 10:7 because we came back at 8:37 all right moving on to four Business Services a approval of agreement with ID Bailey for auditing services for three years staff recommends the approval of agreement with ID Bailey

171for auditing services for fiscal years 2024 2025 2025 2026 and 20126 2027 any questions or comments so move got a motion by trusty Shay second second by trusty Richardson all in favor I I I um motion carries 4 Z all right business services B approval of resolution number 253 supporting the award of the lease leaseback and agreement with Alton Construction LLC for the ecchs central kitchen and cafeteria project staff recommends the approval of resolution 2503 supporting the award of the lease lease back site lease and Facilities lease agreements for the El Camino High School Central Kitchen and cafeteria project and authorizing District staff to enter into these agreements with Alton Construction LLC in the amount of 410,000 any questions or comments yeah I want to say I appreciate their thoroughness and uh I can rely

172and show the public when I get asked where all our money is going to and I do get those questions where is our bond money going and I just you know I really appreciated the the breakout of the selection thank you for that all right can I get a motion with the waving of the reading of the resolution come move second all right perfect we got a first by trusty Richardson uh second by trusty Shane this is a roll call so can I get a roll call Joanna trusty Richardson yes trusty Shay yes trusty lamb yes president Anthony yes motion carries 40 all right review of future agenda items and meetings any questions or comments do we have a summary of board directives there are none all right uh good and Welfare we have about

173six minutes because I have a a little thing to say at adjournment so we've got six minutes for good and Welfare do you want to start at trusty Richardson this yes we have six minutes just to to do this basically we just got back from a wonderful two-day intense uh immersion of our staff with 25 of us including uh Dr uh Moore and Mr Hanan and Mr O and myself and a few 20 23 other people and uh we had a wonderful time we'd learned so much and uh it was uh impactful and we feel I feel energized over the the uh P you know the the attendance so I just wanted to give the board an update that um our strategic plan is aligning nicely and we have we're I'm very excited so thank

174you so much for everybody's thank you so much trusty Richardson trusty lamb all right I'll go as quickly as possible so uh first of all I was uh really jazzed to uh visit the future lab uh event at Genentech uh with Tristy Anthony Mr Miss um Miss rocket there there was some folks on out apologize but um it was uh great the Suzanne Lee gave us a tour and uh let us know that this was the 10th anniversary of the event and um South San Francisco high students got to uh you know try out different aspects of the biotech business not just the lab work but um also you know legal marketing uh there was a new topic about AI so it's all different things U that I think it's very rare to see people

175engage uh on all different aspects um of the Biotech Industry um I also had a chance to uh visit the Children's Center a couple weeks ago with Dr Moore um that was very uh great visit um the uh I think that was the first time I've been to uh the prek uh program um that the school district runs um so was very uh eye opening and enlightening to see um the the kids that were serving um in the prek programs and they're all really cute and friendly as well um and then I'll just mention that I'm going to attend the uh the mon birdie uh Feast of Nations on February 20th for the first time ever sorry I've never gone before but yeah okay I'll try to think of something to bring um and so

176thank you thank you so much Jessy lamb Jessy Shay all right um I just want to remind uh families that the TR transition to middle school and high school event is coming up I think that it has been shared with all of our um Elementary School and Middle School principles um so please encourage your transitioning students to go and also just another shout out to the Family Resource Center I believe they had their first open hours um just a few days ago so with that that we come to adjournment and I want to say as we close tonight's meeting I want to take a moment to honor the memory of Mrs eileene christofferson a cherished teacher and colleague who made a lasting impact on the skyline and ssfusd community in recognition of her dedication kindness

177and unwavering commitment to educ education we adjourn this meeting in her honor our thoughts are with her family friends and everyone mourning her loss May her Legacy continue to inspire us thank you the meeting is adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.