001at for wsas all right calling this meeting of the South San Francisco Unified School District to order um roll call please trusty Richardson trusty Shay here trusty lamb here vice president Murray here president Anthony here all right uh Pledge of Allegiance please rise I pledge allegiance to the of the United States of America to the rep it stands one nation item D land acknowledgement statement we acknowledge that the South San Francisco Unified School District is located on the unseated ancestral homeland of the ramatou alone peoples who are the original inhabitants of the San Francisco Peninsula we wish to pay our respects by acknowledging the ancestors elders and relatives of the Amat community and by affirming their Sovereign rights as first [Music] peoples okay item e public comment I haven't received any cards public comments are
002limited to 1 to three minutes is your last call All Right Moving On item F information only presentation presentation number one Educational Services 2025 accountability update math pilot update California school dashboard differentiated assistance and lcap mid your update uh Dr Mo are you introducing this yes thank you president Anthony and so it's my pleasure to turn it over to Mr Brock Meyer who will start us off this evening on the Myriad of topics that you just outlined for us Mr brockmeyer thank you guys for being here good evening everyone excited to be here to talk about math uh so president Anthony trustees and welcome trusty lamb Dr Moore cabinet uh so tonight's presentation or the initial uh start of the presentation we'll focus on uh the math adoption process it should be up appear shortly
003we've had a funfilled day full of mathing already so uh I do apologize uh always get a little nervous to start now if I talk fast just let me know to slow down all right so uh that's uh as you heard Dr Mor introduced these were the topics that we'll be covering tonight also remind me to bend down here to make sure I'm in the microphone so uh starting with um our District's commitment to selecting implementing high quality curriculum it's a critical step in achieving our broader vision of Student Success the adoption of highquality math materials plays a vital role in supporting our strategic priorities the adoption of high- quality math materials is a key step in ensuring all students develop the skills and knowledge outlined in our portrait of graduate specifically supporting the learn
004aim we want to find materials or adopt materials that Foster a growth mindset that have rigorous standards align instruction that builds academic Mastery ensuring all students are prepared for postsecondary Success additionally emphasizing problem solving and exploration the materials Foster creativity and Innovation equipping students with the critical thinking skills needed for their future so the first part of this presentation will really focus on the math pilot and the adoption process so tonight's goals and outcomes are to ref familiarize everyone with the California math framework shifts and our vision for Equitable math instruction understand the current pilot status gain Clarity on piloting and recommendation process and understand next steps with different scenarios so the great thing about tonight is uh there is uh you know the the back and forth and really trying to leave here to
005make sure we are really clear on the process and where we're at and where we're going so we're going to start with our wonderful team uh miss moleri our secondary math teacher on special assignment and Miss uh SAA seagull who is our elementary teacher on special assignment they're going to do a little math warm-up activity for you all to get you get you in the learner seat before we progress on so I'm going to hand it over to them for this next section all right great good evening everyone give me a thumbs up if you're excited about doing some math tonight yes yes let me see those thumbs come on come on there you go okay great great to know that we can all do that because we're going to need that in the next
006activity so what I'm going to do so you have this visual I believe in front of you and you also have it here and for those of you at home can see it um so this is uh our war up tonight and the activity is called which three go together and why do they go together so I'm going to give you a minute of think time to jot down which three go together and if you think of three that go together you're going to give like a little thumbs up so that I know you've got one and then if you think of three that go together I I challenge you to think of three more that might go together for a different reason so if you think of another reason I'm gonna have you put
007that second finger up and so if you if you got one give me a thumbs up and if you got more than one you're going to two three see how many can get and how many reasons why so I'm going to give you a minute of think time and then we'll come back together okay all right I'm going to bring us back together and so now I'm going to have you share your sponses with the whole group and I'm going to annotate what what you're thinking so can any of you take a risk tonight and go out on a limb and push push us to think about three things that you notice three of these that you think go together um I have a couple uh ABC for me because they all have the it
008looks like they all have the same proportions like they're all the same type of triangle like 3 four five or 7 12 whatever it is 5 12 13 there we go 512 13 it's not those but same so you said because they have the same proportions or they're the same type of triangle as always you're saying okay thank you all right anyone else notice some that go together oh oh miss Lamb hi I was trying to brainstorm a few uh yeah I also came up with ABC and um just to say that the triangles are oriented vertically and uh BCD they have a a big sister and a little sister or just a big and a little uh ACD okay hold on hold on I love that you're giving me so many but pause I
009want to make sure that I have my full understanding so you said um for ABC that the triangles are oriented vertically is that what you said yes that's correct and what do you mean by that uh they are um the the I guess the they're standing up on their tallest length Okay thank you and then you said bcn because they each have a big sister is that what you said uh yes okay and you're just noticing the different shap the sizes yes okay thank you thank you is there I think so El go ahead I think um Pam was next ABC just like a man but my reason is different slightly different so a is like a twins B is like a mom with a baby and and then C is mom talking to the
010child and Carrie I'm sorry I'm you should write AC I I meant ACD on mine ACD not ABC I'm ABC you're ABC but you're AC okay AC so you said twins mom with baby and then Mom no it's C oh sorry yeah so Mom talking to the child and then this one doesn't belong because because you have to flip it so they are this then they will be the similar yeah got it okay so that one doesn't belong okay thank you thank you all right I I chose BCD because they each had a triangle that fit inside them awesome thank you guys so much thank you for sharing all of those great thinkings and starting off our lesson today so I appreciate that and um now I'm going to turn off my like teacher hat
011and then just wanted to share that this this is one of the instructional routines from the current curriculum we are piloting it's called which three go together and um word maps are really great ways to help students get the day's lesson started um they there are opportunities for students to strengthen their number sense and procedural fluency um they prompt students to compare these images and then students use language to produce or talk about what they seeing and then you can make connections off of what students are talking about and then you know what your students are thinking it's great for students to hear what other students are thinking and then it gives students a voice in the classroom so thank you for allting me to engage yeah so quick question so what is the correct
012answer oh that's a great question I'm happy to say that you're all correct and it's really here about the Sens making and that there is an answer for all of them so it's really inviting the kids to take that risk with in in a low stakes environment but there's a way actually you could make a comparison like you could find which three go together for all of them yeah so thank you and actually you shared some new ideas with me that I hadn't thought of so thank you I'm gonna pass it on to my counterpart Saia okay um I also want to add that in the curriculum the warm-ups are very thoughtfully um paired with the lessons that follow them so uh as a teacher um I often tried to incorporate um math or number
013talks but it can be really overwhelming um to be able to have the time to locate um individual warm-ups and then be as intentional as a curriculum developer can to make sure that the warmup is not just grade level appropriate but also tied to the specific content and the standards that the students will be learning more about within the lesson um and one thing that I noticed Carrie doing during the um the warmup was she didn't describe what you said she asked clarifying questions and um asked questions to really push you to articulate your thinking and trying to link that to um mathematical language um so um uh and talking about the orientation and um relative size or proportion um of the um the shapes um and that is one way that the curriculum um
014supports um developing both uh content and language simultaneously okay so um since we have a new truste uh again welcome chesse lamb uh we wanted to review um both the standards and the updated California framework so in the last today's session I guess at the beginning of this year we talked about them we wanted to um to go over them again uh so um the standards um The Common Core uh state standards for mathematics um have not changed um and those include both content standards and practice standards also called standards for um mathematical practice the um content standards are what we want students to learn uh at the end of a grader course and the practice standards or how we want students to learn or engage with mathematics uh and then the framework uh which
015is the image on the right of the slide um the new framework and that was adopted in July of 2023 uh really provides guidance for educators um for teachers and districts and systems um about how to implement the standards uh the new framework uh from 2023 really emphasizes the mathematical practices not just uh focusing on the content of each grader course uh and it also now includes driver of Investigations content connections and big ideas and to just give you a very brief overview of what those are the drivers of Investigations aim to ensure there's a reason to care about mathematical work and that investigations allow students to make sense predict or affect the world uh the content connections organize the content and connect the Big Ideas providing coherence um within grade and throughout the grades
016each grade band um K2 or tk2 uh 3 through five middle school and then High School uh focus on several Big Ideas that have great impact on students conceptual understanding and which Encompass multiple content standards all right and then as I said um The Common Core State Standards um include content standard standards that I think most people would be more familiar with or at least familiar with the concept of um and then also the practice standard so we wanted to really highlight these because as I said these really are emphasized much more in the updated framework um there are eight standards for mathematical practice that apply across all of the grade levels kindergarten through 12th grade and they all begin with the phrase mathematically proficient students so these really are the expectations of the behaviors
017or the ways that we want students to be engaging um in the mathematics and um this is a quote from the framework uh they're crucial because they outline the critical thinking processes and habits of mind students need to develop to truly understand mathematics going Beyond just memorizing facts and procedures allowing them to apply math fle flexibly to solve complex problems in real world situations across different grade levels and disciplines essentially they St they teach students how to think mathematically all right and then Equity is another um key component um that is emphasized in the new framework so we wanted to talk a little bit about what Equity needs means uh so I have another passage from the framework to share with you um this is from chapter one of the framework one aim of this
018framework is to respond to the structural barriers in mathematic success Equity of the access and opportunity is essential and influences all aspects of this document the framework over urging principles that guide work toward equity in mathematics include the following all students deserve powerful mathematics instruction highlevel mathematics achievement is not dependent on rare natural gifts but rather can be cultivated all students regardless of background language of origin learning differences or foundational knowledge are capable and deserving of deep understanding and engagement in Rich mathematical tasks student engagement must be a goal in designing Mathematics Curriculum along with critical content goals and students cultural backgrounds experiences and languages are resources for teaching and learning mathematics the framework also includes these five components of Equitable and engaging teaching for all students number one plan teaching around Big Ideas by
019planning to teach Big Ideas of mathematics and designing lessons that develop important content content and mathematical practices teachers are able to build on many ideas that arise from students during instruction draw draw out students understandings and help individuals in the class as a whole shape mathematical ideas into understandings that reflect connected Concepts and knowledge in the discipline number two use open engaging tasks open tasks enable students to learn mathematics by meaningfully engaging in mathematical experiences that are visual physical and numerical and employ multiple representations and forms of expression three teach towards social justice the framework discusses teaching towards social justice in two parts first it involves creating opportunities for students to both see themselves as well as people from all backgrounds as capable and successful doers of mathematics and second teaching towards social justice urges
020Educators to empow Learners with tools to examine inequities and address important issues in their lives and communities through mathematics four invite student questions and conjectures students asking or or posing mathematical questions is one of the most important yet neglected mathematical tasks in classrooms not questions simply to help move through a pro move through a problem but questions sparked by Wonder and Intrigue and fifth prioritize reasoning and justification reasoning is at the heart of doing and learning mathematics through the acts of reasoning and justification more students can begin to see mathematics as a tool to ask questions about and make sense of the world rather than than a static set of rules when students have opportunity to reason and justify while engaging with open tasks their engagement in mathematics increases and they strengthen their identities as
021members of mathematics communities and I'll leave you with our district math Vision um I won't read it to you I'll give you a moment to review it um it was created and then revised by teams of District Math teachers um and we do see strong alignment um with uh the framework that we've uh reviewed today all right any questions so far before we get started into one of our key priorities for this year feeling good all righty so um math uh the adoption and at some point implementation of our materials is a key priority um so this is something that we are hyperfocused on um and happy to say that overall we are on track with what we set out to do this year as far as the process um so you can see uh
022through this is like where we're reporting back uh recently during a a stepback meeting just here this is where we're at the one thing we are that we did reschedule was the principal principal professional learning but overall we are on track with uh what we are trying to do with our pilot outcomes this year I shared uh these at our last board study session since then we have added one so one um you know kind of a charge from you all and also something that we heard clearly from staff was our ability to provide uh meaningful and sustained support uh this year we have went all in on doing that and I I would like to say and I I do firmly believe that those in the piloting group are feeling that support um and
023so really trying to set the blueprint for how we will go forward so really going all in on this and really with the support of cabinet and through EDS we do believe uh that we are meeting this outcome also making sure that we're supporting the process with making the individual recommendations aligned to our math priorities they're actually just starting the piloting teachers are starting that process right now um and we'll be doing that through March right ultimately leading to uh determining a recommendation early April and then something that we added and just that we've been working both with the county office we have two Representatives here tonight uh and also uh someone from the bayed fund is really just bringing Clarity to the process and tonight's one of those really going through the process explaining
024the process making sure it is very clear we have uh we're using a process very similar that we did last year but we're continuing to look at it and ensuring that there's transparency and Clarity with the process um again most of you have seen this before uh as far as what that process looks like as a quick reminder we started with a landscape analysis we partnered with student achievement Partners um did a lot of classroom visits uh empathy interviews to really determine what what were our curriculum needs uh and identified our curriculum priorities we then uh went uh through the uh going to the county office and ultimately selected the materials um and just you know to be clear that we had a basic threshold that with whatever curriculum was piloted that it Met Ed
025reports s uh satisfactory or Ed reports uh what do they call it expectations so that it's like the the the Baseline is that it does align to the standards it is rigorous and all of that so and then piloting so this year we are only piloting one material uh one curriculum and we're doing that again though we call it a year-long pilot It ultimately goes I mean they'll be piloting all year but the decision needs to be made by the end of March uh so we did we have learned that doing two curriculum in one year is very challenging and so I think this is going forward like as we continue to Pilot other materials something to really think about of giving people the time to really understand feel reflect on the curriculum uh and
026then going into the recommendation process and we'll kind of go that and then ultimately planning for implementation um again I've shared this with you uh we were trying to be very clear with all of those that were piloting what are the expectations um and both what as a piloting teacher what are the expectations and what are the guarantees that we as ed services will provide to those piloting and so very being very clear something that we have stressed is integrity of the process we do want to know um does this curriculum how does this curriculum align to our priorities and giving it all you know a full faith try so that we could have those meaningful discussions and also again being very clear of the support we are going to provide so these are our
027curriculum priorities um again you'll see a lot of alignment to the framework uh and really to our our our learner centered Vision um and our strategic plan and portrait of a graduate so focus on growth mindset making sure that there's materials for all Learners um a lot of authentic student collaboration Hands-On math lessons we want students engaged real world problems that students are solving again building conceptual understanding right going beyond the ability to plug in an algorithm or do a procedure to actually understand why why is this happening um language supports and then also making sure that uh there are ways in which to support parents with further learning at home or support some of the Milestones this year again as I reported um we launched the year with two and a half days of
028training for all our piloting teachers something that we do understand is just uh summertime is essential to supporting teachers and getting ready for the launch of the school year um through the first semester uh all of our teachers had a full release day a lot of them engaged in a lesson lab I'm being correct uh which is a form of lesson study where they get together they collaborate they look at a lesson and then they observe someone teaching that lesson to students so uh really great we've got a lot of positive feedback on that um we observed all but one classroom uh of our piloting teachers uh which is again great getting insight to how what looks like in the classroom what it looks like in action um and here we are second semester we're
029actually starting to launch our K through2 recruitment process um and then all the piloting teachers are starting the process um the recommendation process so just some data that we wanted to share um so this is ultimately looking at our math achievement over the past decade um and so really around the implementation of Common Core till now I did there are a couple years around Co that I left out um you know when when we talk about Equity when we talk about predictability uh here it is right so we see that we have an opportunity in front of us um when we think about Equity when we think about our vision and our promise that all students will achieve uh when we think about our portrait graduate um here in lies what we are the opportunity
030that lies in front of us uh our math results uh are very predictable um and this is happened over the last decade so we we do see the need to make sure that we are adopting high quality materials and then again that we're ability our ability to support implementation uh and sustain Support over the long run just having high quality curriculum does not solve the problem but it is the start it's really about successful implementation and I do believe if we do land and ultimately adopt high high quality curriculum and we do provide meaningful support we will see this shift and it needs to because it is highly predictable so this year uh we uh are giving a pre- and post assessment we're using Mars task and this is something that we will use uh
031as part of the recommendation process and ultimately see like have students um progressed in their learning and really with their ability to apply uh their learning through a Mars task so right now this is just Baseline data um so all grades three through Algebra 2 students took this assessment this is our Baseline uh they just took a second assessment in January uh we will get that data in about a month and then when we go through the recommendation process we will be looking at piloting versus non-pilot students and see what are we seeing any difference in growth um I will say just to like limit expectations that that after you know four months of piloting um you know we're not expecting to see you know those students piloting with great growth but we are very
032curious and we would expect over time that this is something we' hope to see is that students ability to really apply what they're learning uh and have high higher levels of depth of knowledge or rigor um grow and this is what we want and again so we will look at that data we'll look at piloting and we're very curious to see any questions so far up to now say that one more time do what does do mean depth of knowledge so there's um actually we have a handout so there's four levels um and it's really kind of the level of rigor um of students understanding and kind of their depth of understanding so we spend a lot of time around the procedural kind of level one level two um you that's kind of where we
033live a lot um and where we tend to see struggle is when you know your ability to say apply a formula to a problem and calculate that in in different times but then when you are ask asking students to take that knowledge and to apply it to a situation they're unfamiliar with that is where the struggle is um and that's that conceptual understanding that I could take what I know and I could apply it to to a new situation um and that's critical thinking that's what we want our students to develop um when you think about you know you're not going to get in life the the formula in front of you it's really taking all that information thinking through it and then be able to apply it to that situation the great thing about
034Mars task is really um their design that every student has access um and then ramps up through level four so really trying to see where are they at in that progression and and their understanding yes trust your for all students I I'm very interested in that uh how you present the the math the problem to answer to the social justice and priorities and reasoning justification and and cultural um relevance which is one of the things that you seem to to be pushing and is part of the reason we're moving in this direction so that it has a um a way for students to critically critically uh go through whatever problem they might have and then make it a reasonable uh equation if you will in on paper so I thought that I'd like to see
035how you you go about that to bring that to those students yeah a lot of you know the big shift uh with with kind of the expectation of the framework is is that the kids are doing the thinking in a classroom um and really like you know a lot of the times and you'll see this in our classrooms where where where kids are expecting the teacher to give the answer and really as as Educators making that shift to a facilitator of learning really putting it back on the kids to use each other to build that understanding um just like here right where ultimately there's no wrong answer uh but so many students just you know what is the answer right and this is really about like hey really discovering what are the different ways we
036could approach getting to an answer and it's really not so much of course we want students to get the right answer but what we really want to know is how are they thinking about solving the problem and what are all the different ways that we could go about solving problems um and even when students get a wrong answer a lot of times really exploring that a lot of the the thinking behind it was correct but they might have taken a wrong turn somewhere and for them to really think through that so that's one of the really big shifts is you know that putting putting the thinking on to the students I appreciate that because I did witness that in one of my visits to the schools and it was really delightful to see the students
037kind of bouncing off each other and then cross answering each other and sort of opening a dialogue just on one problem and it had to do with avocados and I go oh my God they lost me about the third time but it was if that's the way that you're talking about I I think that I understand that part of the instruction yeah and this is not an easy shift right and so you know students that have been going through a lot of our classes right it's it's really kind of the consumer of of information um kind of a passive in The Learning Experience is really putting the onus on them to be part of that experience getting them engaged but also building that confidence to be able to discuss with a partner like you know
038what is their thinking sharing that with the class right like that that is a big shift in in both uh the teacher practice to facilitate those uh and and on the students to really feel confidence uh in that especially as kids get older and you know there's all the social pressures and whatnot so um so now we'll kind of move to current status where where we're at right now um so just some some data for you so currently who's piloting so you could see uh you know we got a little over a third of of teachers piloting grades three through uh High School um something that I do want to draw your attention to is just the amount of support that we have provided so we've provided about 43 hours of professional support to these
039piloting teachers um and so just something to think about time time is our most precious resource and our most scarce resource so when we do think whatever curriculum we land on just knowing that you know time is something that we desperately need um and um when we actually did a recent calculation the current time that the district controls is around 22 hours so these are professional learning days or districtwide collaboration days so when you start thinking about we're estimating that we need about 50 hours to throughout a year to support teachers with initial implementation our big struggle is if we only actually have 22 hours we control not all of that goes to just implementation of math where do we find that time so something that we do know is like we have to utilize
040summer but with summer is also it's voluntary so these are just some of the internal struggles and things that we're thinking about and those I've shared this before those are uh the sites uh the grade level teams that are or most of those are grade level teams that are represented at the elementary and then our secondary sites that are currently in the piloting process so as we said uh we have visited all but one teacher uh in their classroom uh some multiple times just really observing uh how how it is going uh how how is the implementation how is the support are the kids engaging and so um what we are seeing is structured routines and strategies so a lot of math talks kind of like the warm-ups that you're seeing and so we are
041seeing that engagement um we're also seeing student- centered practices and again this is in alignment with our learner centered vision of really you know the kids are the ones that are actively engaged in the learning um and increased engagement and collaboration so uh definitely some highlights there um successes and challenges so some successes is uh we have gotten access to time and this is really for our piloting teachers um so working with principles finding ways that we could use their collaboration time to support uh doing release days uh getting release uh from some of the portrait of graduate work where we're supporting them individually so that we could have as much time with them as possible principal support for the math uh framework and with the curriculum so they've uh they've had some opportunities to
042engage and really understand uh the shifts that we're looking at uh November 1st so we did find some time to engage all math Educators with some framework learning which uh was received really well uh that is uh with a partnership we're growing with uh svmi and through the county office and then some challenges um time allocation again just our biggest it's both a plus and a minus something that we need to work the siloed Natures of schools and so when we get to the school level there's so many other initiatives going on and that it gets siloed that it gets really hard when we're we're looking for time and Alignment that's just a struggle that we have competing initiatives right and that's at both district and site level and then release Days release days are
043like one of the best things ever and also a struggle for a teacher to do like they hate being out of their classroom so it's again just finding that time when can we get them and ideally fresh meeting after school it's really tough they've had a long day they're thinking about tomorrow so how do we get teachers when they're fresh we could really engage in the learning and then allow them time to apply apply with their learning collaborate with each other so time is time is really tough questions about our current status sorry I know I'm going or it feels like fast you're good okay I'm gonna hand it itol well I have a lot of comments but I don't know if I should save or comments y uh well I I actually want to
044back up to well let me let me give you my comment first so first of all um thank you you know for presenting so far um and um I this topic is just really personal to me um so I have two kids uh I love both of them equally uh one does you know fairly well in math so far um and the other um math has been like an ongoing challenge fir uh and it's not a matter of you know effort or like trying or you know not you know doing enough or but um it's just always been a struggle sometimes homework would take two hours you know something that would normally take someone who doesn't have that challenge you know 20 minutes or something so this is something that I just it's it's a
045source of great angst and anxiety for me um but um so I I think so I I put that out there because um those are the kinds of kids that I'm thinking about um you know despite the challenges um my I've always just tried to encourage my child to just keep persevering and um just um and we've found some supports but you know everything it's you know it's still like a DAT you know a year toe day-to-day you know semester to semester you know a struggle so um and as it turns out actually my child is in one of the pilot programs it was sort of not something that I you know even knew what was happening you know as someone just coming in late to the uh this discussion um and then it and
046just happened to realize oh yeah my child is part of the pilot as well um I don't have any special insights uh in terms of what that means for him uh other than um the great you know not that great mean anything in particular but like that at least this particular year it's improved compared to the previous year which was much more of a struggle so with that um I think uh I was looking back at like slide 20 and um you know looking at this assessment data and I know you had mentioned that um you were going to compare um pilot you know how kids in the pilot classes versus the non-pilot classes had done and I was curious if there's going to be any more analysis in that realm in terms of like
047how perhaps how kids who are in the pilot have done um compared to say previous year uh or um or if there's some kind of focus group thing that can happen with uh kids in the pilot uh classes or um and I I forgot my last thought but yeah that just something more analysis or um in terms of the people who are using it who may benefit uh you know from having a different approach to them math learning so I'll give a quick answer then I see my colleague is standing up so as far as that the the pre- and post um we can't go back and look at anything else so really that's just again our first attempt this year to look at you know are we seeing growth with this task we're also
048looking at a lot of other data with that so um this is the first time that we've given a task uh across The District in in this manner and so yeah we'll only be looking at that pilot versus non-pilot now with that there's a lot of data there that we will be looking at but this will be our first really looking like are we seeing any difference um and then I'm gonna hand it over sorry just to add on to that it is it was the same task twice so that will really show us how a student has grown from September to now go Ahad and uh also with the the pre- and post uh assessments we're not comparing the scores on the on the post test um against the different groups we're looking at
049for each child how they scored on their preest and then how they scored on the post test um to look at growth and so then we'll be looking to see if we if there are trends that emerge uh especially thinking about the depth of knowledge um and students ability uh to reason and then communicate their thinking if we see Trends as uh in differences in growth um from the pre and the post of the students in the pilot versus the students who are not in the pilot and then just to add on you asked if there was other data so we did um we are administering a uh student survey to all of our students students um with the option uh for an empathy interview so we will be conducting some uh there are lots
050of students that are interested I don't know how many we'll get to um but we are going to conduct further interviews with those um students to really Elevate student voice and I do want to just say too with with the Mars tasks like we have outsourced all the scoring of the task so that is being done they do not know who the kids are the schools are anything who pil you know so that's all being done independently of the district so that we do really get quality data um so that just so that you do know that so um all right well with that said I think we're gonna talk about some the professional learning that we've had um yeah so just really um excited to talk about this our professional learning day on November
0511 that we got to um meet with all teachers um all Math teachers in the district um it was really fantastic um to partner with the county office um and svmi to plan this day um and present so sbmi supported us because we have a lot of teachers um so it was about 200 Educators that got trained on that day it's a lot um and what we did was we had them engage in a collaborative math task and a debrief we updated them on the new framework um which a lot didn't really know about um and then we shared the components like we shared with you of Equitable and engaging teaching for all students um and then these are just the comments of these are non-pilot teacher comments um of just the feedback that we
052got so 85% agreed or strongly agreed that they learned something new about the framework that day um and we feel like you know if we had had more time we could have gone a lot deeper so just the feedback was really positive um and we already are thinking about plans for how to get more of these sessions um for future opportunities for our teachers to to learn more about math and the framework and just really grounding them in the priorities and the framework so that was exciting um any questions about that because the next section is a little different um I I actually have a question too like and that's slightly unrelated but I was you know I know there's a seems like there's an emphasis on you know uh group I just speaking you
053know amongst the group or you know in class what about the shy kids who are just you know shy kids like me or just who have a hard time speaking up yeah I think that's part of where we're trying to build that like that low floor that task that you feel like you have an entry into and just really trying to build that collaboration amongst the peers in a classroom to encourage each other and to feel safe in that environment and to feel like they can share right so that's something we have to cultivate and develop and so like that's something we also try to cultivate so when I run professional learnings with my team I'm always saying like Okay who's going to take a risk just like I said to you guys today right
054we know it's there we just have to cultivate and continue to um work through that yeah and I'll just add that often um when teachers are using um group or collaborative tasks um they know who those kids are I was one of those kids who in high school I still wouldn't uh respond when the teacher called on me um and I think teachers these days have um a larger toolbox for ways to respond and sometimes are a little more sensitive uh to kids like maybe you and me um and that can include um sharing what your partner said so if a teacher knows um that Amy is too shy they might ask Amy to share with a partner and then maybe ask the partner could you share what your partner said um to just make
055sure that or allowing you to share what your your partner said if you're feeling vulnerable about sharing your own idea or building in roles within collaborative tasks so that all students are participating even if they're not doing it verbally uh in front of the class so I just wanted to add that context to um I have a question too if I you don't mind um is you said that um you would have been able to go even deeper if you had had more time is there a plan to continue to work on the math framework in future professional development yeah definitely um we've already started talking with svmi and County about future professional learning you know we're thinking about summertime we're thinking about where we're going to find that time and we would love to
056do some sessions you know especially we've got our K2 pilot starting we're we're already doing that for them and then how can we build some stuff into the summer not a deal but it is there and yeah we're definitely in the works on that yep we good I just want to know have you recruited been successful in bringing in more teachers into a pilot do you want to talk about that or um I mean for this pilot we have 41 teachers um piloting it and we already have lots of interest for the kada too yeah than okay um so the next slide is just kind of highlighting all the support that Satia and I have been providing throughout this year um you can see there's lots of different Avenues um the pictures are of secondary
057teachers engaging prior to the school year starting um working with uh their course teams and outlining uh reading unit narratives and outlining that um on the right hand side we have our quick links so each of us has a quick Links of like upcoming events what they need to know um and then any support and then there's also in the bottom right that's our um resource padlet so different blog posts or questions and answers um are shared there um we're sending weekly updates uh we're excited to go on a field trip to ousd next month hopefully some of you will be joining us um to see it in action um we did lesson Labs like we spoke about uh we have observed all the teachers we tailored the professional learning to the needs of the
058teachers so we're constantly listening to what the needs are and responding um uh like do Mr Brock Meers has talked about 2.5 professional learning days prior to school um we have been curating all the materials and black line Masters for everyone and um we've demoed a couple lessons as needed so that's been really fun too um and then we interviewed every pilot teacher so that's where the next slide is going um and when we interviewed each teacher um you know we chatted about the three things so what are the current strengths that you're seeing what are some of the challenges that are coming up and then what support is really going to be needed as we continue um and um you know we recognize that there's no one perfect curriculum and so these these really
059gave us the knowledge of how we can you know keep doing what's working well um you know for our challenges you'll see that one is um communicating shifts to families and caregivers we're already currently working with um someone at Bed fund to help us strengthen that Parent Connection through um we're talking to some different parents we're doing interviews really going to uh start prep preparing for that and then whatever other support is needed building that into the professional learning plan um and implementation plan for future um um yeah so this will drive the development of that plan and then ensure adequate a support if needed um and then this is our recommendation process um so our outcome like Mr brockmeyer said earlier is to support all piloting Educators in making individual recommendations based on strong
060evidence and reasoning aligned with our math priorities um so piloting the curriculum is the big thing and then there are five pieces um to the recommendation process which get looked at by the district team and so I'm going to talk about how each one of those kind of plays out in a in a timeline of how what we've been what we've been engaging in because this is a very rigorous process and we want to ensure that you understand um how long we've been doing this so um the First Column is what's happened in first semester so our students were experiencing the pilot our teachers were teaching and then we administered that Common Assessment that we spoke about um in September and then this uh sorry last month um we actually the Ser student survey came
061out this month um the teacher survey is um coming this month as well and then um we administered that DCA again and then um we started our strengths and challenges protocol with both of our teams uh for our first meeting we'll continue that in our February and March meetings and then in our our final meeting with our team um in March we're going to analyze um the student survey data the teacher survey data the assessment data we're going to analiz that strength and challenges and come do a rubric in consensus process and then um teachers will submit individual recommendations so there is a lot that is going into this and it's been spanning for the entire year so it's been process to get to that point um at that point all of those things um
062will go to the Eds team and so I'm going to the next slide because um and I believe uh Dr yaku will also be included on this um and we will look at we will each look at the individual data and review it and then um do a final um collabor we'll engage in a collaborative consensus building process to determine the best path forward so using all of that all of those data points so any questions on that process or anything I can clarify um because it's a lot okay all right you good okay all right I'm gonna pass it back over to Mr brockmire then all right we're almost there uh uh so just try to lay out a couple of scenarios there there are tons of scenarios we kind of bucketed them into
063three right so first we make a recommendation and we ultimately uh the recommendation to adopt grades three through Algebra 2 is approved and we move towards implementation uh scenario two is we make a recommendation to adopt some grade spans are approved others are not or scenario three is we don't make the recommendation to adopt um and go down that path so um if when at some point we will be making a recommendation uh and ultimately that recommendation will be approved be it this curriculum or another one just kind of giving you idea of like all the things that start happening once that decision is made again as we've discussed um we'll have people that are at all different uh parts of the spectrum as far as the support that they've received so some teachers that
064have piloted for two years others that got their first dose of the framework right so first we got to start thinking about how do we make sure we're getting everyone what they need when they need it um also determining like how many are we launching it especially when we think about elementary is every single teacher grades three through five going to implement or just some uh grade level teams not so there's a lot of decisions we need to make um and then when do we find the time I can't stress this enough is we know we need about 50 hours uh we know that we have very limited time that we have control of so when do we find this time and it's not just year one this is over the next several years and
065again this is going to happen whenever we do decide to adopt material so be it this year be it next year like once that decision is made um it is very important if we want to fulfill um that Vision our math vision and we do want to see those outcomes change of our student Learners we need to make sure that we're providing the time and the support to our Educators uh to implement successfully again as a reminder we've heard loud and clear that EDS additionally has not done a great job and again there's various reasons for that but a lot of it is just being able to prioritize and provide that time we know that we have to access time in the summer um just because uh of the reality to prepare them to launch
066and by that that means it is voluntary so there will be some staff that are unable to attend that so we got to think about how do we support them if we've had teachers you know 10 hours of professional learning leading up into the launch um what do we do with those that were un able to access so there's a lot of things that we got to think about um and that we're also looking at how are we measuring the success of implementation we look at Casp data we know or we expect if we do this well over five years we should see like that growth start we're not going to see that year one year two so what are we going to measure internally to ensure that we are implementing well right and that's
067really what what is that that we want to see what should we see at the year the end of year one year two so these are all things that we're thinking about um also um is the pilot so with the pilot so we're starting that process next year Elementary we have one uh Elementary too we're gonna have a team possibly implementing and a team piloting or grades K through five piloting I will stress too that we align our priorities you know we're talking about coaching and those things how do we again provide that support we're going to have you know 100 plus Educators possibly implementing new m materials how do we provide that support um you know throughout all of our nine elementary schools and then at the secondary level so just things we need
068to really think about and getting things aligned so um and then lastly if we don't uh if we ultimately do not recommend for adoption or of some again we go through the process we go back through our district lens identify materials that align to our priorities go through that process and then start the piloting process over a question that's been asked by a lot of our educator is um well what if we kind of like IM but you know we ultimately don't adopt can we use it and just reminding them that we stick with our currently adoped materials until we formally adopt new materials and so we continue piloting uh until that we ultimately formally adopt new materials and then we start implementation so um something interesting that I learned or a way that it
069was it was thought is we really do want to make sure that we find materials that are well aligned to our priorities and we'll meet all of our students needs um generally a district adopts math materials every 8 to 10 years um so the decision is really going to affect a whole generation of Learners so it was really profound when someone said that and kind of laid that out to me like so we really do want to make this and make sure we're making the right decision because we've already seen over the last decade and again there's multiple reasons where we want to see that change and this decision is huge because it will impact the next 10 years of Learners in our district so all right that's it yeah so I have several comments
070thank you so much for this very comprehensive uh presentation and I want to acknowledge several many great things here so it's very clear pilot outcomes so we are all understand what is the outcome and then the clear adoption process so we are not guessing what is the process so I really appreciate that and also on page 17 when I read this curriculum priorities I'm so I'm so proud to be South San Francisco Unified School District Board member it's this maybe this is already there for a long time but when I read it like you walk us through Reading those bullets this is exactly what we believe about our curriculum our priorities so I just want to say that out loud and then the other one is um and I also appreciate you summarized teachers teachers
071interview what we learned all those strength challenges and support and then I also appreciate the um the scenarios so we understand as a board member like you said the decision impact is huge if it's scenario one this is what going to happen if a scenario two this is what going to happen or three so that give us understanding what's the next step so thank you and I do have another comments I want to make so about the this I am is um aligned with the California math framework so I did research on that and it's a The Challenge from various research and you already did a lot of that and we all know Pro and cons I just want to point that out that it has a good intention about equity and accessibility but could
072backfire by lowering math riger and you already know that you guys already did all the research but I want just want to share my thoughts the concern is instead of raising struggling students up it may hold High achieving student back and leave them less prepared for college and stem careers and then research always have the right the the pro or or cons and I just want to make sure that we are all aware of that there is no perfect um uh yeah the perfect curriculum or framework we just need to work with it and then meet our students needs so I want to be mindful that we are as our district ensure that advanced math pathway does not in the intently limit opportunities for students who are prepared to excel earlier particularly in an underserved
073Community where access to supplemental resources is short so I just want to to put it out there and then then the students population for the high achiever students may not that great but we also need to be mindful they are there and then my second point is we will also want to make sure that our professional development which you already described that we are on it and curriculum resources are being prioritized to help teacher effectively Implement an inquiring based in learning while maintaining fundamental math fluency so I just wanted to point those two out and I'm not expecting you to comment but if you do please thank you yes so you said a lot there so first of all no curriculum is perfect and did did you say you were referring to research as far
074as the rigor was that research you were referring to or I wasn't quite sure where when we say that uh uh that the curriculum would lower standards was that is that so again so you know the basic threshold was looking at uh Ed reports right so an independent body going in and looking this at all curriculum and all curricula sorry and determining like does it meet the basic threshold does it meet the expectations of the framework and the rigor and so we would not look or at any curriculum that did not meet expectations I am was almost perfect so um again it it is going to be different and I would actually say when you look at the levels of rigor at as with our assessment data around that Mars task that is an area
075that we actually really do need to accelerate and improve in and I um and again this isn't really about IM itself this is really about the process um but that just you know that we are ensuring or we are looking at a independent verification that that any curriculum that we pilot meets the expectations of the standards and the framework so that is just to make sure that that is very clear I mean I guess I can just add on the definition of rigor from the framework States rigor refers to an integrated way in which conceptual understanding strategies for problem solving and computation and applications are learned so that each supports the other so it's really all of them together and that is a high level of rigor so I think when we look at a
076curriculum like I am it does have all of that embedded in it so yeah I don't know if you want add I I I'll just piggy back on on what what I'm hearing and I think what I the only thing that I am still concerned about right is and I is we know that there's a large group of students who are not successful with our current curriculum and I'm excited about doing something different to support them but to Dr Shay's point the point about not holding back our high performing students who have succeeded with the current curriculum you know it's there's a couple things that I've been thinking about is just let's say somebody who has not traditionally felt confident and competent in math they start to get it and they're like oh my God
077I want to do more right like are there resources to be able to help them move ahead faster are there resources within the curriculum to say okay you get this now let's you know I'm not going to say drill and kill it because you don't want to drill you know kill the motivation but is there a way for them to like build on that that new knowledge and take it further or is there a person who's like I already get this and I need more right I think that's that's also a concern of mine yeah again we we're not at the recommendation process so these are questions I mean one I would love any any research that you have found to send that our way so that we can explore um and again it's not
078about you know really can you explain why like what you know and that's where students struggle like they can they plug in a formula can they you know in their head do math quickly but do they know why can they explain to others can they apply it to a novel situation they struggle mightily right we have the data to support that and so whatever the curriculum is we do find like we do know um that again rigor isn't the ability to do 100 problems quickly it's really about to understand and be able to explain why why did this happen What strategy did you use right how do you explain that to your classmate what strategy did they use can you use the strategy that they did um and it's just a really it's you know
079conceptual understanding it's just such a big shift of the way that we all probably learned the way that kids are traditionally and our Educators have learned so again part of the process of that we're going through was really looking at that and the Educators that are piloting um to ensure that do they meet these priorities that we have identified of our curriculum priorities and then from that so um again we could only look at our you know the external evaluators of the curriculum itself again met all expectations in regards to rigor um it looks a lot different than a traditional curriculum the framework's very clear of looking at a problem-based curriculum uh for students to really explore and understand or again building that conceptual understanding and really leaning into the mathematical practices which is going
080to be you know again a lot different than just kind of this standard you know the traditional standards approach that we've taken so the the piloting team will go through that process uh and and and again they'll evaluate the curriculum uh they'll look for that evidence to support um it with our priorities and 100% right our job is to really say are the core structures of any curriculum there um what are the strengths and then with the challenges are they solvable right that's the big question right is like hey is this a problem that we can solve right U because that is what we're going to be weighing when it gets to the end is um we've heard a lot of like extended practice at home right we say well that's probably a pretty solvable
081problem um so lacking rigor that's a big problem that's unsolvable right so that those are things that that we are going to look at with the strengths and challenges so um I just I'm just going to add on from like the curriculum perspective so in the curriculum there are these questions are you ready for more in a lot of the activities so like if your class finishes one quick or you know is ready for more there's more and then there are also optional activities so like each um has you know the warm-up and then Activity one and two and sometimes three and so U you know we if you get to Activity one that's good but if you are if you are ready for more and you have time you can engage in those other
082activities um and like for example I just had a pilot meeting with my teachers and I engaged them in a seventh grade lesson now they're all Educators right and they still were able to dive into that problem and the way I was able to take them to the next Next Level was when I was walking around listening to them you know they would say oh we got your answer 1 million blah blah blah and I would say okay how can you make we're sorry the question was how many heartbeats have you had in your lifetime and so they were trying to answer that question and refining that so asking them like well how could you make that a more um accurate number so then having them really think and dive into that problem even deeper
083really brought understanding and then they would like flow off of each other so I I think there are ways to adapt that and I think the other thing to remember is We Trust our Educators in this District to make those decisions and that moment um in the curriculum there were um as a teacher looking at that there were adaptations for scaffolds right I chose not to use that with my group because I knew they didn't need that and that's what we really emphasize when piloting is we trust your judgment so you make that call whereas other districts may not be doing that same thing and I think that's really tripping them up and I think we know that our educators are the experts and if they are ready for more there is more and if
084they feel like we need to develop more than that we're open to host hosting tlts and if we need to and and making in those supplements um but I think what we really want to ensure we're doing first is really diving into that curriculum and making sure that they're explaining it and really able to be clear because what we find sometimes is those students who are really quick at solving things and they've got that you know their that algorithm rthm down right they struggle when we ask why and so it's important that our kids have toolboxes and can pull from different things to solve these problems and it's not just oh what's what's the formula what do how do I plug it in but like why why is that happening and how can you adapt
085that and actually after talking to a parent that was a really important thing that their students loved like I want to know why this works right and so for even our Advanced Learners knowing why it works will propel them even further right because then they'll be able to adapt it to more situations in the future so oh right and thank you um and we do have Pathways still in our Middle School that can get students to algebra um by the time they're in eth grade and Pathways to calculus in high school so we still have those classes and we have data science too so we have lots of Pathways and we're working on you know strengthening those and we want to get more kids to those right so that's that's where we're at so uh
086very quickly I know the riger is a trigger word I would not use that word and I just want you to know we are not math expert so we respect your your Jud your uh your expertise it's just we try to like those thinking that we we have share with you so we are not challenging you you expert on that's why we lean on on the experts right and that's why we take external you know people that are filtering for for us right so we too uh I am far from a math curriculum expert so again that's why we're leaning on our partners with the county office uh you know with like you know organizations like Ed reports so that they are it's an independent auditor telling us like hey this meets the expectation again
087it's the basic threshold right and then from there we look through our our local context and then go through the process so and again if it if enrichment like you know we are looking you know we you know we have a lot to solve when comes to our math Learners in our district right and so we do want to make sure that you know that curriculum is preparing those students and meeting uh you know our our vision of our portrait of a graduate and again is enrichment a pro a solvable problem right to me like look if that is our issue if we're looking for ways to extend again that seems to be a pretty solvable issue uh instead you know regarding of like there's just not alignment to the framework and the expectations so
088yeah but again you know this is really about the process we want to make sure we're very clear on the process and team goes through that so um I wanted to thank you for this report it's so thorough and and you anticipated like every single question that we could possibly have um the only the only concern that I have is you know the list of challenges are we goingon to have enough time to so that we can train the teachers properly so that they so that they feel comfortable moving forward with the um curriculum and then the other thing that we spoke about was um training parents so parents could help their kids are we going to have those those supports despite the challenges yeah so one I mean time is is is you know
089uh is definitely a challenge uh again uh solvable to an extent I think we already talking to principles we do know that this is going to come we do know we need alignment uh we do have control of District time um and I you know I think we all really want to do this well um I do know like our Educators want to do this well again what it uh regardless of the curriculum when it comes time to implementation um they have made it very clear they want they want to be supported and not just initially like through implementation um I do believe whatever curriculum that we land on it it's going to be uncomfortable for most if it's comfortable we're probably not making the right decision right we we need to see a shift
090in who's you know who's carrying the cognitive load in our classroom so um again we're hoping to you know continue find more time uh but but definitely is is one of our biggest challenges um and again being able to provide time over summer is great uh but that doesn't get get everybody but I think if we could get enough and then we could problem solve with those that we're unable to attend um when do math curricula curriculums need to be aligned with the the framework is there a date that the California framework they're they're submitting now okay yeah um well thank you very much you guys did a great job and and I appreciate it thank you sorry I just wanted to add on to those questions that you had is like we are thinking
091about like the implementation is not just year one so when we present a plan it will be over several years and like working just so you know I'm working and we're working with people who have implemented and like what our strategies and where where do we take like all that feedback we got from our teachers and build that into a plan over time because we know there's a lot of pieces but we can manage that right and then like I I mentioned earlier like we are working with a partner with bed fund who is helping us you know open the doors with parents you know we're doing um Family math nights um really trying to help people understand because I think it's it's there's there's not that lot I'd love to go to one if
092you have a family math night send an invitation for sure any other questions or comments okay thank you so much thank you and I would encourage um you know getting into math classrooms across the district right it it's the best way to really observe and see it in action and you know without you just going in observing seeing what how kids are engaging both with piloting and non- piloting materials and it's a great way to learn uh we are going to Oakland to go see a district uh that has been implementing uh so again just uh thank you all for the time and I'm glad that we brought Clarity to the process that was one of the key outcomes for tonight so thank you thank you so much I'm gonna pass it over to Dr
093Hugh I am gonna ask Dr H to take a break we have the caption or break in 10 minutes and I'd rather just not break you in your presentation so uh we'll come back at 7 o'clock on the DOT you guys that e e e reconvening fellow [Music] trustees all right welcome back director Hugh we are ready for you okay uh good evening Board of Trustees cabinet Dr and South San Francisco Unified Community can you talk more in the mic or move it down problem there we go nope it's on okay so I'm here tonight to talk about our California school dashboard and our accountability system and as it ties to our lcap so we are required to give an update to the board at the midy year of our dashboard which came out in
094late November and our cap progress at the midy year so that is what we're going to start with tonight uh first talking through a little bit about our California school dashboard this is our state accountability system this is how we as a state um share information about our state priority areas and accountability indicators uh we include in the dashboard a measure of both status and change and so for districts for schools for student group groups uh we are looking at two measures one is a status that is uh a capture of the most recent year of data whether it's graduation rate chronic absenteeism or test scores and then we also look at change from the previous year the accountability system uh is not the same for the dashboard as the data that is reported for
095an individual measures such as cast test scores or graduation rate or absenteeism and so those are that's important to look at if you are ever looking at the data Quest website to look up what is our graduation rate uh what's included in the dashboard is a little bit different because they are accounting for that growth in addition to that one-year status we also have as part of the dashboard local indicators these are self- evaluations that we do as a district we conduct the evaluations we report out on that we look at different data sources that are more local such as survey data and we report that out and that is something that the board adopts in June as part of our lcap process and then that information is also shared in our school dashboard on
096the uh the state websites for this school year we also have some new uh features of the California school dashboard so one they've added another student group so we are now up to 14 student groups and that includes a long-term English Learners or LEL group as a separate student group to report out we are now including science for the cast test in our California school dashboard now the state is still determining how it will be included for accountability measures so for this year it's included as information only and you can just see what that one year would look like and then we also have a return to the California uh College and Career indicator so with now enough data to produce both status and change we are back to a full dashboard with colors performance
097level colors in all of our indicators this is the first year that we have a full dashboard since 2019 so pre pandemic because again for some of these measures there are multiple years of data that are required in order to calculate that performance s can you say that one more time the uh dashboard accountability results are not the same as our annual casps can you say that one more time sure so what is reported on the Cal on the dashboard is a different interpretation or a different performance level because it includes both status which is one year and change which is compared to previous years so if you look at the graduation rate that is reported on the California school dashboard it is just a little bit different from the graduation rate that's reported as
098a four-year graduation rate on data Quest because that is just looking at one year at a time in the dashboard it's looking at not just the one class so the class of 2024 but it's also including previous classes um we talked about previously that dashboard uh graduation rate includes fifth and sixth year graduates so students who've stayed for an additional year in order to finish up their graduation requirements so the numbers are a little bit different great question so if you were to look at the State website this is the first shot that you would see of our school uh our our school dashboard for their District so you can see all of the different indicators there the first ones with a gauge are the indicators that we report through the dashboard with the measures
099the other ones that have a blue uh so the second column or the second row the right so it says Basics so teachers instructional materials facilities and then all that bottom row those are our local indicators those are the self-reported ones that we evaluate ourselves on each year so drilling down each indicator has what's called a card so on the left you see the card which breaks down first status so number one is the status that's the most recent year two is the change so from the previous year and then three is an equity rep so you can see for each of our student group how many student groups are in each level of performance and that is again that performance level or color is a determination a calculation of both status and change so
100from there if you click on that view more details you get something that looks like the following one on the right and that is a breakdown by each performance level which of our student groups fall in each one so a little bit more about student groups so again now there are 14 student groups we've added that long-term English learner group each indicator so academics chronic absenteeism suspension rate have different rules for how they count the students in that student group and so that means that for one student group you might have 120 students and for sorry for one indicator you might have 120 students and for another indicator you might have 110 students so that might make a little bit of a difference in terms of you know whether you're seeing a color a performance
101color on the dashboard for example and you'll also see sometimes that a student group does not have a color a performance color because it is a smaller student group and so if the numbers fall below 30 or 15 for certain student groups then they won't show up that often happens when you're looking at things like graduation rate because it's one class uh that's our seniors only and so that does mean that it is possible that we have student groups for which there are no performance levels or no color we might have some data but not always enough to calculate two years worth of data for that status and change so under academic performance we have four different indicators or four measures so English language arts is based on our cast El and our California alternate
102assessments Ela results and again both status and change you can see in the card there and then the same for mathematics Casp and California alternate and then we also have English learner progress now English learner progress used to be just one number but now we've added that long-term English learner student group so now you will see actually there's two different data points that are under that English learner progress or LP and then the other measure that falls under academic progress is College and Career and again that is this is the first year that we have both status and change and so we have color performance colors back on our college career indicator for English learner progress you can see here the English learner which is our overall aggregate student group uh is the first card
103and then the second card is a breakdown it's a subset of that English learner group that is long-term English Learners only for the California school dashboard um calculation they Define long-term English learner as a student who has been an English learner for more than seven years you can also see on the right with the columns this is our students making progress on the lpac which is the English learner uh performance assessment that students take uh from one year to the next and so it breaks down the levels of progression there so you can see how our students are progressing and moving up in terms of their scores from one year to the next we show a similar one for our alternative lpac that is for a much smaller group of students who are taking an
104alternative version or an alternate version of the lpac academic engagement is the next section this is is both chronic absenteeism and graduation rate now chronic absenteeism is the indication of uh student engagement in the classroom and the school environment and that is for elementary and middle schools for high schools they do not report chronic absenteeism on the dashboard because high schools have more than enough measures we have the graduation rate and we have the College and Career rate or indicator that the middle and elementary schools do not have and so the state of California decided Well try and even it out a little bit and so that's why there's no chronic absenteeism card on the dashboard for high schools is because they have those two others that doesn't mean that chronic absenteeism isn't important for
105academic engagement and for things like graduation at the high school level it's just not included as one of the measures that our high schools are going to have a performance level for but we can still see the data about absenteeism on data Quest or individual year-by-year reporting and then under conditions in climate we are looking at suspension rate this is again for all of our student groups all of our grade levels elementary middle and high and then again I mentioned that under informational purposes we are including the science test for the first time this year so they're just kind of testing it out they've included the data there we're looking at it we're getting used to it as a state what does it look like to have it on there and the State Board of
106Education will be discussing and making a determination about how it will be included as a measure for accountability purposes in the dashboard for next school for this current school year for next year's dashboard for 2025 and we expect a decision about that sometime this summer so undergraduation rate uh you can see here on the left is a graduation rate Year bye and again remember that for the dashboard we're looking at not just the most recent graduating class and their four-year graduation rate we are also including students who in 2024 um graduated as a fifth year student or a sixth year student so those numbers are just a little bit different and then you can see here how that breaks down so we do have 13 students who did graduate with our four-year graduates as fifth
107year students so this wonderful to see that we do have students who are continuing their education and fulfilling their graduation requirements uh beyond their graduating year class for the College and Career indicator you can see here our progress over time I included the class of 2019 which is the most recent year that we have a full performance level uh so again colors status and change so that was pre- pandemic and you can see there that our numbers were very different uh at that time we had 30.3 % of our students met the prepared category for College and Career Readiness since that time there's been a lot of work that's gone into helping students find ways that they can increase their College and Career Readiness so we've we've launched a lot of Career Technical education programs
108we've done a lot of work with our counseling departments to help students really think about what they want to do after high school we've added different elective classes that are college preparatory and you can see the results there so for the class of 23 and for the class of 24 you can see that there are significant improvements to our college career prepared rate for students so this is the result of a lot of people working very hard to make things happen for students so these next few slides I'm going to go through pretty quickly you can see here this is our district aggregate student groups for all of our student groups and then each of the indicators so English learner progress chronic absenteeism which again is elementary middle only suspension rate graduation rate again high
109schools only uh Ela math and then that last one is college career indicator so you can see here um a lot of different colors performance level colors for each of our student groups one thing I do want to point out is that with our status and change model for accountability performance level performance colors might be because we are rewarding change or Improvement in the data from one year to the next and it might be that a student group has a lower status so perhaps their graduation rate is not as high as another group but they improved or increased more significantly and so when you see the colors that doesn't mean oh this group has a good graduation rate or bad graduation rate again it's looking at both the status and the change this is bur
110burries neros Sara loritos Martin Mont Verde Ponderosa Skyline Spruce and Sunshine Gardens so again I put all of the schools by grade level span so you could see kind of train your eye certain indicators are not there uh and then also remember that at this at the elementary level in particular we might have some pretty small student groups and so that's why you see a lot of cells where it's just blank there's no data or color there and that's because the student groups are not um they don't have enough students from one year to the next to Warrant a color and the dashboard moving into Middle School you'll see more student groups because our middle schools are bigger and then you see more colors because there's also um you know the other indicators are there
111as well altaloma Parkway Westboro and then at the high school level Maiden has fewer student groups there are much much smaller campus so there's a lot of areas where we don't have data represented here uh we can look at that data for individual students on our own but not on the dashboard and then elino and South San Francisco High School so I'm going to pause for a moment if there are any questions about the California school dashboard I have a question um thank you I appreciate that because we pay attention to attendance but I notice it's not it it's not it's not that it's it's not quantifiable anymore that I thought we could see um in these charts and I was wondering why is that why don't we think it's important to keep track of
112this because I know we're we're a basic a district and we don't go by the Numbers per se but we do need those numbers if we want to apply for certain grants or federal programs and so forth and that that is indicative to me that are we not applying to those grants anymore why why the is this a state thing uh why don't we keep track like we used to thank you oh sure uh absolutely we keep track of our attendance and we monitor chronic absenteeism quite closely and so that is true regardless of what the dashboard has for accountability purposes because we know that if students are not in school they can't they're not going to learn as well as if they are with us and we can provide the additional supports that they
113might need so when I said that chronic absenteeism is not included in the dashboard that is for the high schools only for elementary and middle it is an indicator on the dashboard and our schools do receive performance colors on the dashboard as we do as a district at the high school level because there are additional measures with um as they relate to graduation rate and college career Readiness the College and Career indicator they did not include the chronic absenteeism as a separate indicator because there are additional other measures and they wanted to Bal they provide a little balance the other reason for that is because graduation rate is also included as part of academic engagement and the rationale there is well if students are not attending they probably are not graduating at as high rep
114as high levels as they could and so it's just another way of looking at academic engagement so for elementary it's a little cleaner because you know they don't have graduation rate in elementary and then as they move into High School attendance gets factored into and shows up in different ways in terms of students progress toward graduation but we do we do measure and we do monitor attendance and chronic absenteeism across all our grade levels uh Mr sers and his team actually we were just talking about that today I'll talk about that in a little bit with our differentiated assistant um and that is something that we are tracking at all levels across our system and we do report that out in other formats it's just not on the dashboard for high school sure let me
115scroll there we go okay so sorry any other questions we're good okay okay so page 45 I'm so pleased to see this college career indicator that we are so good on the prepared and then also approaching prepared so what is the definition of the approaching prepared so um in the summer I do a presentation on College and Career Readiness indicator and if you remember back to that one I'll try and explain it quickly there are eight different ways that students can meet the prepared measure for College and Career Readiness so meeting the standard on um Casp Ela and math is one possibility that actually counts as two because Ela and math uh taking and passing to AP exams with a score of three or higher uh taking college level classes meeting a through G requirements
116which are the our University of California requirements there's a bunch of different ways um completing a CTE pathway is another one and so if students have met in two or more criteria then they are considered prepared if they meet in one of those criteria then they are considered approaching prepared and if they don't meet any of those or did not achieve a high school diploma they are considered not prepared got it it's on the side yeah so I'm just wondering so approaching prepare they only need to meet one on the side that those bullets and then a prepare is two or more yes okay wonderful yeah thank you sure okay so from our dashboard the state identifies school districts that are um that they are going to offer differentiated assistance which is their system of
117support and so that is for schools and student or for for districts that have some student groups that are not quite achieving where we want them to be so the short definition is a student group that is red in the red category for two or more indicators would be considered eligible for differentiated assistance so last year this was our differentiated assistance status we entered differentiated assistance for I'm looking at the bottom uh for our Pacific Islander student group and that was for people engagement or academic engagement which is chronic absenteeism and graduation I think it was chronic absenteeism really and for school climate which is suspensions we also last year exited differentiated assistance for three of our students groups which was awesome so our African-American student group our homeless student group and our students with
118disabilities all exited differentiated assistance last year based on results from the 23 dashboard so we did a lot of work with our Pacific Islander student group engaged with our County Office of Education and then uh and you heard us talk previously about chronic absenteeism especially monitoring our student groups such as our Pacific Islander student group with this year's dashboard if you remember back to that slide I showed of our student groups for the district level we did have a student group that was read in two or more indicators and that was our African-American student group so this is is actually the third time that our African-American student group is back into differentiated assistance and it is for student achievement in ela and math and for school climate which is the suspension rate now what I
119should point out is our Pacific Islander student group and our African-American student groups are both pretty small and so that means that each student within that has more numerical significance to those percentages and so that is part of the reason why uh these are student groups that go in and out um from one year to the next on our dashboard so Pacific Islanders we have made progress uh if you recall back our Pacific island or chronic absenteeism rate and suspension rates have improved from the previous year uh so we actually do not meet the criteria for differentiated assistants based on the dashboard because they're not read in those two areas however because differentiated assistance Cycles stay and that offer of assistance stays for multiple years we are considered in year two for Pacific Islanders for
120differentiated assistance so we met with the county today and talked about the different ways that we are looking at providing additional supports targeting these two student groups in particular to make sure that we are capturing and making sure that students are achieving attending school uh looking at those suspension rates to see that we are providing supports in the appropriate ways and then the last piece was I gave you a 100 page document to look at which was our lcap midyear update uh and so that is a midyear snapshot of the progress that we've made in our local control accountability plan so we aligned our local control accountability plan for this cycle so 24 through 27 school years uh to our strategic plan so we have five goals and they are aligned to the Strategic plan
121five goals so this is an update of strategic plan goal one which is our exceptional instruction some of the highlights are that we have been working on our instructional Vision so this is work that we have been drafting collecting feedback and input from stakeholders uh We've shown several drafts to our site leaders to teachers across the district are continuing to refine that and we're hoping to finalize that sometime this spring we are also reaching out and providing additional support in different ways especially to our students with disabilities and multilingual Learners via homework centers air tutors uh and and different ways that we are able to provide additional supports to students at our school level we also have a district advisory committee that I am working with uh focusing on strategic plan progress monitoring and looking
122at graduation requirements and potentially changing or updating our graduation requirements in Le of some legislative updates that are coming our way and so that is something that we're continuing to discuss we're looking at a lot of data that we shared tonight as well and we expect that we will have uh more information about that later this spring and then our math pilot and math placement procedures as you heard Mr Brock Meyer and his team talk about earlier this evening with strategic plan priority to engage students uh our goal is really working toward a comprehensive School counseling model so we have done a lot of work to really help students with the navigate a graduate Aim so looking at College and Career Fairs we did the College and Career Fair at camon mall this fall we
123are coming up on a number of career events at our schools so I believe Parkways is later this month and then we have Spruce coming up in March and then we have Sunshine Gardens and altaloma are doing career fairs in May so there's lots of opportunities to see our students engaging in conversations about careers uh we also have Wellness counselors and we're developing our wellness program we are also launching wellness centers at our secondary schools and we have a few of our school sites that are working on peer counseling programs and then as I mentioned earlier there's a lot of work that Mr sers and his team are doing around school climate so in so specifically uh chronic absenteeism and suspension rate especially focusing on restorative practices and alternatives to suspension for goal three purposeful
124Partnerships we are doing a lot of work with our community and Outreach uh engaging with the partners that and just a few of are listed them down below to help our students see the impact of themselves in the community and then for us to work with the community to help support our students and families goal four is empowered Educators and what I wanted to highlight here is the positions that we were able to fill this year uh that are highlighted in the lcap what you see here is what was is the actual so there were a few more that were planned that we were not able to fill for c for different reasons and um what you see is these positions and that results in work that's done at the school site so a lot
125of support around reading around math around providing those supports to our teachers and their instruction and then goal five is our Equity centered systems so there's been a lot of work with Mr O and his team around multi-year annual planning and resourcing uh We've also been working on a strategic plan Community dashboard so that we can showcase to our community how we are making progress on our strategic plan priorities and then there's been a lot of work done on our portrait of a graduate and a lot of Engagement with our students and teachers and showcasing the work that they are doing there to implement and bring awareness to the portrait of a graduate so with that I think that concludes my overview of our 100 page elcap midyear update and happy to take any questions
126uh very quick one on page 69 uh the dual enrollment so I'm just curious how many students are in the dual enrollment program if you don't have the answer that's okay I will need to look up that number it's a slightly in it's a fluid number because we have students who say they're going to do dual enrollment and they don't follow through for different reasons they aren't able to and so by the end of the year I will have a true number to report to you okay about our dual enrollment participation for the year but if you'd like a midyear snapshot I can get that data to you um okay whatever is convenient and I don't want to add on more work I'm just just curiosity yeah thank you I can certainly do that I
127certainly can can offer that 70 students 35 in uh Juniors and 35 so 70s uh students oh are you talking about Middle College I think you're you're giv the middle college number but Dr sheay is asking about the dual enrollment number which is separate from middle college no oh it's not thought it was so all of our middle college students do take dual enrollment classes because they are taking Community College classes on or they're taking classes at the community college we also have a number of students who are taking Community College they're taking dual enrollment courses meaning it's a high school course and they are earning college credit at the same time and so I can share those numbers um at a later time just quickly than you very much for appreciate all these numbers
128because I've seen a change in since I was here now uh more than five years later I've seen a dramatic change in the uh restorative justice and we see changes in the expulsion rate we've only had one incident so I think we're making progress and I'm happy to see the staff uh understand and have a pulse on what the community needs and the equity is really I've seen it taken off and I think I see it in the numbers of the students coming to school so I'm feeling very optimistic where we are and I think you guys have a pulse on the whole thing thank you thank you I just want to say thank you very much I appreciate the update it's uh it's it's always um a pleasure to get that information and to
129have you present anything really thank you thank you you are a great presenter um if no other comments or questions um this meeting is returned thank you