CorpusRecord 107518

SSFUSD Board Meeting - January 23, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / SSFUSD Meetings
Date
2025-01-24
Location
San Mateo County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
17,586 words · about 98 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001AC for meetings muchas thank you the school South San Francisco Unified School District Board of Trustees meeting calling uh reconvening back into Open Session Trust trusty Richardson trusty Shay here trusty lamb here vice president Murray here president Anthony here um we've got the Pledge of Allegiance item C it will be led by loso fifth grade student Amir Abu garib can we have an introduction good evening it is my pleasure to introduce Amir Abu garib he is a fifth grade student at Los ritos and I have had the pleasure of getting to know Amir this year I've seen how kind responsible and respectful Amir is not just in the classroom but outside of the classroom where he lends a helping hand to those in need I often find the Mir helping Mr Tony picking up litter

002and keeping our patio clean Amir has attended losito since kindergarten and he has two sisters in second and fourth grade who also attends the school his teacher Miss Campos shares that Amir is a role model in class consistently showing commitment to classroom activities and lessons he always completes his assignments tasks and projects on time and all the while demonstrating positive attitude and dedication he is ready to help his classmates and teachers too Amir is known for sharing fun facts and cool trivia that makes um their day a little more interesting whether it's a surprising piece of History a wild animal fact or fascinating scientific tidbit so without further Ado I'm going to invite Amir up to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance good evening please face the flag put your right hand over your

003heart and begin I pledge of allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God invisible with liberty and justice for all oh okay item D land acknowledgement statement we acknowledge that the South San Francisco uh Unified School District is located on the unseated ancestral homeland of the ramou aloni peoples who are the original inhabitants of the San Francisco Peninsula we wish to pay our respects by acknowledging the ancestors elders and relatives of the ramatou community and by affirming their Sovereign rights as First Peoples item e reporting out from closed session nothing to report thank you item F review of agenda do we have anything that we need to change PLL or otherwise modify we'll do that at consent okay uh gpta Council

004remarks uh good evening president Anthony and uh trustees and cabinet we're happy to be here tonight my name is Lauren kitchen and I'm actually going to give all of our time tonight to losos PTA president Marcela alfarez and cubby the mascot of [Applause] losos good evening everyone for those who doesn't know me my name is Marcel alerz Martinez and I the PTA president of aritos this is my last year and we are recruiting no presidents no people who want to be everybody's invited if you want to be a president of the PTA of Los aritos so this is Kobe our mascot the thank [Applause] you the biggest accomplishment of PTA so far this year has being created of spirit we like you see and wearing the student showcase their school pride by designing the School

005logo families both in a winner is choosing in fact we are extending this event because of the high demand thank you to Los ceritos for helping organize and distrib distribute all the [Applause] clothing communication with paring is a highlight we address concern regarding launch setings loisto push a new benches in additional shading parents are very appreciated for this response thank you to all of you to make that possible the PTA continue to increase the school spirit with the introduction of school mascot Ki having a mascot serves multiple purpose the benefits of the students and staff and overall School Community Ki Foster a sense of community school pride not only does the Mas participates in outdoor activities Kobi enter in the special needs classroom and this desensi young children allow them to engage safely easing anxiety

006and function to have children feel more connected to their school creating longlasting memories hopefully become part of the school history and creating a tradition that future student can Embrace mascot are more than just a custume of character it is symol symbol of the sco spirit inclusivity in community it is our hope that we boost miracul and create a positive School environment the PTA sponsor speed events play a critical role in fostering the skill and qualities outlining and the posture of the graduate this framework creates opportunities for elementary school students to develop the key attributes social collaboration communication creativity and critical thinking learning consult as their life and World change events such as F here days allow students to learn creativity and resourcefulness these events encourages students to engage an artist imaginate and innovate task helping

007them think outside the books they are able to express their respons their personality creativity and uniqueness the science fairs will force int intellectual curiosity and critical thinking impact their Community with collaboration service and engagement Spirit events such as class color day a sport Day friends giving and winter holiday dinners often involve groups activities where each student create an impact in their communities for the better a students grow a sense of belonging as they bom with other students in their class and within the community as whole these events encourage excitement and a positive School environment Thrive as a person Heritage days allow students to thrive as a person not only are they exposed to different cultures they confident they confidentially Embrace their identities during the events walk work for Ruby Brides as students learn about our

008past struggles and see how overcoming obstacles were possible navigate crear day and character day encourage students to navigate their Futures knowing that there are so many possibilities out there by engaging students in this fun jet purposeless activities PTA spon per events provide mindfulness real world opportunities to nure the lifelong skill and disposition necessary for successfulness the goal for the PTA is promote change provide Provide support and facilitate mindfulness transitions these events have been focuses to events the students that more and needed to help support teachers in the classroom's environments in the cup then teachers are the Fearless leaders we are doing day by day to help to the classroom hard time often brings out the best in a community showing of The Power of nity compassion and charish purpose when people come together they find

009the way to overcome challenge support one another and build a sense of belonging the strange bones every act of kindness every shered effort and every bit of encouragement add to that strange a strong Community is one to the L for adversity grows together and emerge more res silence and connect that ever before it is a reminder that even in the difficult moments losito Community is Hope is solidarity and the power of create something better together so we are so proud to have a loser Community not just for the parents also for the teachers for the old community and thank you all of you for this opportunity thank you for coming kabby good to see you all right item H staff Association Representatives remarks South San Francisco Federation of adult Educators good evening I'm Elizabeth Bale

010stuts president of the South San Francisco Federation of adult Educators I hope everyone's semester is off to a smooth or at least a constructive start Adult Ed is hard at work serving our adult Learners in ESL and computer School classes it will come as no surprise that when I tell you in the opening days of this new presidential Administration our students are anxious we've already distributed cards with the wording our students will need should they be approached by Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents we are committed to supporting all students as they exercise their right to seek an education and I will repeat what I told my students last week your immigration status is none of my business I do not care if you are documented or undocumented I here to help you learn English and

011move ahead with your educational and life goals that's all I need to know if you need my support in any area you are welcome to come confidentially talk to me about your immigration status but I don't care it has no effect on my teaching of my students I also want to take this opportunity to affirm our solidarity with the members of the CTA as they move through their contact negotiations and I will hope that I hope that the district and the board um will listen carefully to the cta's proposals and weigh them carefully and keep in mind that teachers are facing High Cost of Living and we also are facing along with the district a lot of uncertainty about the future under this new Administration thank you for your attention have a good evening San

012Francisco classroom Teachers Association good evening president Anthony trustees um Dr Moore cabinet members and ssfusd Community First I would like to to thank president Anthony trusty Murray and trusty Richardson for joining me at our school board uh brunch on January 11th you didn't get much notice to attend and took time out of a busy Saturday to listen to our CTA leaders speak about topics on mind on the minds of California Educators and um we will try to give more notice next year so more people can attend this annual event but this was a very successful response and is evidence of your efforts to learn about Educators concerns at a state level so thank you for attending um speaking of communication I'd like to dive a little deeper into that topic tonight I've been meeting with

013teachers this year at many sites last week I visited Sunshine Gardens Elementary School and El Camino High School today I visit vised JS or junipera elementary school tomorrow I will visit Parkway Heights Middle School although I haven't been out to every site yet I ALS I have also been working on a couple climate surveys and I have uh had meetings with at least four other sites why to explain the importance of this I'd like to refer to the recent movie musical hit Wicked I don't know how many have seen it in this room but my first time seen Wicked anywhere was this film so it is fresh in my mind if you have only seen The Wizard of Oz then you and then you see Wicked you realize that without the backstory of wicked you

014naturally make assumptions about the characters and about who is good or evil you quickly realize how damaging it is to judge a book by its cover this is so true in our classrooms if educators are unaware of the depth of their students backstories they can easily make educational assumptions that might inhibit student learning the greatest challenge of Educators in my opinion is not in deciding how and what to teach but to understand how to lift our students up when they fall if we are to support them then we need to know them is this not also true for our Educators should we as a district also make it a priority to lift up our Educators when they fall and I do mean metaphorically or literally since some of you know I literally fell at school

015last week and my colleague colleagues did March me into the office who I am so grateful for but really the demands of teaching can easily cause burnout so how do we support them sufficiently we need to hear their backstories and vice versa if we support our teachers sufficiently we will also be supporting our students I know the district on the whole is making an effort to mend the communication with parents and students many employees attended customer service training this year also all grievances that have been filed by ssf CTA have been met with posit positive responses so far I truly see an effort to work on issues regarding teachers parents and students but there is more work to be done I feel a new grievance has been filed regarding solary placement which may go back

016a few years this effects pay for 30 certificated staff well those are the just the ones I know about right now who have reached out to the um district for correct placement on the salary schedule of course we hope to have a positive resolution for these employees and possibly others I am also concerned when I hear that not all educators are getting a prep time a few feel like they might be working in a hostile work environment or feel ignored by some administrators when they seek support certainly there is room for improvement in communication between ssfusd and staff it shouldn't be good versus evil or one side versus another next week we will open negotiations and we look forward to this discourse let's listen to each other find out their backstories support them so they

017can support our students I believe that strong agreement along with supported and respected teachers will ensure that we retain who Dr Moore has referred to me as our most valuable resources our teachers as the lyrics in the wicked song define gravity uh State together we're unlimited together we'll be the strongest team there's ever been if we work in tandem there's no fight we cannot win thank you very much thank you so much California School Employees Association chapter 197 is not here tonight so we'll move on uh item I Personnel commission our next Personnel commission meeting will be held on Monday February 10th 2025 at 5 o'clock pm in the district office boardroom thank you item J items from the board any announcements board committee reports or Board calendar okay moving on okay so superintendent report

018thank you one of the items that were on the genda this evening was an appreciation of Jimmy Wong um and it's bittersweet since she is unable to be here with us tonight um but I did want to share a little bit with about her and our appreciation of her and of course I will do it when she's here as well and send her the certificate of appreciation you know uh Miss Wong's schedule reflects her remarkable ability to juggle so many responsibilities as the ASB president a dedicated student an active participant in extracurricular activities and holding a part-time job Jamie exemplifies what it means to balance leadership academics and personal growth she has been a pleasure to work with her valuable insights And Timely updates from a student perspective have been incredibly meaningful keeping the board

019well informed about student life and the events happening we also really appreciate her professionalism and excellent communication style now Jamie will continue to provide updates on the amazing happenings at El Camino High School throughout the remainder of the Year we're so grateful for her contributions and we certainly look forward to hearing about the incredible work she and her peers continue to accomplish we have a certificate of appreciation that we'll be presenting her with or we'll make sure that she receives that prior to the next board meeting the next item I have I just want to share some good news with the board and our community related to the refunding bond savings to our community in November 2024 the South San Francisco Unified School District board authorized issuance of refunding bonds to generate taxpayer savings refundings

020are similar to refund financing and that they reset interest rates on existing bonds to reduce the total debt service so this is like a homeowner doing a refinancing on a loan for his or her home or at a lower interest rate to help reduce the mortgage payments so earlier today just happened the district was able to successfully price the refunding bonds to generate gross Savings of approximately $7.2 million over time for taxpayers the taxpayer savings are particularly High because the district will be able to shift principal repayment earlier year to allow for bonds to be paid off quicker than the original repayment schedule and so what it does is it helps the district manage tax rates in the next couple of years to keep tax rates relatively consistent and if you recall the district also

021did a bond refunding back in 2022 2022 excuse me which generated gross Savings of 3.6 million for our taxpayers so together both the bond refunding Bond refunding provide the taxpayers in our school district a total gross Savings of approximately $1 million we are incred thankful for the consistent support for our bond program and are really happy that we were able to realize these savings for our community I also wanted to give a big shout out and congratulations um with to vice president Murray who has been appointed to the board of directors for the California school boards Association this role will be an advocate for the yes thank you this role will be one of advocacy for the best interest of students representing our region and identifying the needs and being able to advocate for those

022she'll be working with other directors across the state to help influence educational policy at the state level as well we're just incredibly proud of you trusty Murray a quick reminder to our families that next Wednesday January 29th is Lunar New Year schools will not be in session we will resume on Thursday January 30th and then just lastly today I sent out a letter to our community in support of our undocumented students and families I haven't read I'm not going to read the entirety of the letter but I wanted to tell you from my heart to yours that we weather the challenges and uncertainty together and we will do so with love and support of one another we absolutely remain committed to our care core values and we affirm that all students deserve a safe and

023inclusive educational environment regardless of legal status gender identity ethnicity or background this commitment remains unwavering regardless of change in policy or leadership we are here to Pro protect the rights of our students and our families today and every day we will continue to work together to ensure that our schools our places where all of our students feel valued feel supported and feel empowered to thrive we understand that undocumented and mixed status families face unique challenges and uncertainties and we are committed to providing the resources and the support during these very challenging times thank you that concludes my report thank you so much Dr Moore and uh very much appreciate that that letter also included resources for families so if you are needing resources for you or a friend um please contact your school we also

024have that on the District web page as well super thank you all right student trustee reports I'd like to invite up first Adriana fisna um fanha sorry I knew I was gonna mess it up and I apologize for our uh who's going to be giving the report for El Camino High School thank you good evening board members cabinet and audience at home and audience present my name is Audriana fanaa and I'm currently a senior serving as the ASB vice president at El Camino High School I'll be taking Jamie's place as she is out today but she wishes her best regards I hope everyone is well and adjusting to the new year on January 11th our students gathered at the elegant Pinstripes in San Mato for a night of fun food and festivities at this year's

025winter ball the event was an absolute hit filled with laughter excitement and Unforgettable memories from the delicious spread of food to enjoying activities like bowling there was something for everyone to enjoy the photo booth was a crowd favorite and the DJ kept the Dance Floor alive it was truly an amazing and eventful night and we're so glad to see everyone having such a great time thank you to all of the students who joined us and made the evening so special we are thrilled to announce that this year's prom will be held at the breathtaking California Academy of Sciences on Saturday March 22nd the theme almost there a night of Dreams promises and enchanting evening for all the event will take place from 700 p.m. to 11:00 p.m. with exclusive access to the aquarium from 8:00

026p.m. to 9:30 p.m. tickets sales kicked off on January 13th starting at 1:30 and prices will increase $10 by every two weeks this magical night is a huge mileston for our Juniors and the most anticipated event for our seniors we can't wait to celebrate with our Colts and make your dreams come true our quad games started strong on January 17th with victories against seoa and teranova the excitement continues this Friday as we take on South City in our Mini Hoops game where the theme is silent 7 where Safari or Hunter gear upcoming games including Sano on February 7th with a party in the USA theme red white and blue frat Vibes and our big Hoops game hosted at South City on February 14th where we'll celebrate cold pride in red white and gray good luck

027to our Colts we're rooting for you every step of the way aamino clubs hosted their first ever food court during lunch on January 17th which was a huge success students pre- purchased tokens in exchange of food samples that clubs sold half of the clubs planned and executed their food sales for Last Friday while the other half of the El Camino clubs will be doing the same process on Valentine's Day students absolutely love this idea and cannot wait for next month's food court in addition clubs put up their trifolds and signup sheets as a way to promote their club and Enlighten students on who they are aside from what they are selling this Lunar New Year we're spreading joy and good fortune by hosting a special lunchtime activity as we celebrate the year of the snake

028with a festive giveaway red envelopes filled with chocolate treats it symbolizes prosperity and happiness for the year ahead Lunar New Year is a time to honor tradition Embrace new beginnings and strengthen our connections as a community we can't wait to celebrate this meaningful occasion with our school community and let's welcome the year of the snake with positivity and excitement our service commission is proud to host the Stanford blood drive on campus Thursday January 30th the drive will take place in front of the school by the flag Poole as donating blood is a simple yet powerful way to make a difference we encourage our school to par participate as each donation can save up to three lives don't miss this chance to be a hero and help those in need as our Southern California neighbors face

029devastating losses from the ongoing fires we are proud to share that we filled a 6x12 trailer with donations of essential Goods to support those impacted we wanted to express our heartful gratitude to everyone who generously contributed your donations of clothing food baby supplies and much more which made a meaningful difference all items were distributed to multiple organizations working on the ground to provide relief while our donation drive has concluded we encourage anyone still looking to consider um making a donation to the American Red Cross or the calire foundation thank you again to everyone who came together to support those in need your generosity is truly inspiring that concludes my report and unless there are any other questions or concerns I'd like to thank you all for listening I hope you all stay safe and continue

030to enjoy the new year so much Adriana um I also saw on Instagram because that's what I use um because I'm old uh that the Key Club is doing a menstrual products drive at El Camino so if you have menstrual products that you'd like to donate not used obviously uh please bring them so they can do the drive all right um Josephine harana our spring student trustee and ASB president from South High School good evening board cabinet and Community my name is Josephine harsana and it's my pleasure to represent South San Francisco High School I hope everyone has had a fun winter break and a smooth transition into the new year after an eventful finals week South City went on their much needed winter break although much of the School enjoyed their break South City

031ASB was gearing up for the new semester this year ASB has hit the ground running with a number of events and fundraisers on the way winter ball is this Saturday January 25th this annual event will take place in the scenic phalon room at Skyline College and doors will open at 7 p.m. students will be invited to enjoy finger foods a photo booth from truly memorable and music and lights from DJ South City alumni Angelo abalon we'll also be hosting winter royalty with two sets of winners between our underclassmen and upper classmen our very own activities commission are currently selling tickets for $30 this week outside the cafeteria and will be S selling tickets for $45 at at the door in order to get students excited for winter ball this week we've had our Winter Wonderland

032spirit week we started the week off with too Tuesday where students were invited to dress in cold weather clothing yesterday was warm Wednesday day where students wore pajamas and brought blankets to school and today was twinklet toes Thursday where students showed off their favorite Crocs and fuzzy socks tomorrow is a white out day we will also be having a rally where we will enjoy performances from the South City competition cheer team and the hip-hop club there will also be various games for students to enjoy additionally we will also be revealing our highly anticipated prom theme and date at this rally prom tickets will be sold starting mid-February clubs are also back in session with Club Rush 2.0 taking place yesterday January 22nd during lunch in the small gym our 20 plus clubs had the chance

033to share what their Club was all about and allowed for a number of signups the gym was packed with students and clubs alike as our students took the chance to be more involved within our school community and to view many more of our wonderful clubs that we offer at salet City we're starting off our winter sports season strong with with our boys varsity basketball team recently beating oceanana high school last week tomorrow they're playing a quad game against El Camino go Warriors the girls varsity soccer team tied against Half Moon Bay High School on Tuesday and beat Jefferson High School two weeks ago tonight they're playing tanova high school at our very own South City Field good luck lady Warriors our wrestling team competed in La last weekend we would like to shout out senior

034Ryder dises for becoming the First Student in South City history to compete in the five counties tournament a 60-year-old historic wrestling tournament Not only was he the first student from Sal City to compete he also placed fifth overall our South City competition cheer team competed and placed first at their competition on Saturday January 11th we're so proud of all of our Warriors who have accom we are so proud of all that our Warriors have accomplished this season and we're looking forward to finishing the winter season off strong additionally the South City mock trial team has begun their competition season and will continue to compete every Tuesday at the Redwood City Courthouse Defense matches begin at 5:30 and prosecution starts at 7:30 p.m. ASV elections are right around the corner and this year is one of

035the most competitive Seasons we've seen we're so glad to see so many students interested in ASB good luck to all those who are running for an officer position South City students are gearing up for our annual History Day competition students have been compiling research since the beginning of the school year and will present their work from the week of February 3rd to the 7th in the LC we invite all board members to swing by South City anytime during the school week to see the fruits of our students labor this is a great opportunity to see the students of South City demonstrate all the aims of the portrait of a graduate but more specifically aim learn as this project is the perfect opportunity to stimulate curiosity of human history and develop creative displays of their research

036finally in an effort to show support for those impacted by the Southern California wildfires I have been working closely with the Red Cross to find a way for our community to show support for those affected although the Red Cross organization is no longer accepting food and clothing donation and only monetary donations there have been an overwhelming blood drive cancellations in Southern California due to the poor air quality these sudden cancellations have drastically decreased the availability of blood for patients all around the world fortunately the Red Cross has offered South City a date to host a blood drive to directly help those impacted by the fires on Wednesday February 5th in South City small gym you may sign up for a donation slot from 8:00 a.m to 1: p.m. as this event is occurring the same

037week as History Day there are less students from South City who are available to donate I strongly encourage all community members who are available to consider donating blood please do not hesitate to reach out to me if you have any questions or would like a flyer containing more information if there are no further questions this concludes my report and for all those who celebrate happy Lunar New Year thank you thank you so much Justin all right moving on to M public comments W um to comment in person during the meeting uh you need to bring me up cards so last call as I give you this uh Spiel public comments are limited to 1 to three minutes per individual per board bylaw 9323 name and address cards are placed in the back of the room

038to be completed and given to the secretary the board president will call upon individuals in random order who have requested to speak each person may only speak once and is required to address the board from the podium the meeting is recorded and streamed live individuals may address the board concerning School business not on the agenda but public comment cannot be acted upon or discussed by the board unless placed on the agenda at a subsequent meeting in accordance with the law the brown act the board May request staff to respond orally at the meeting or in writing at a future time and for our speakers just a reminder that we have a captioner uh and so please speak loudly and clearly into the microphone uh our first Speaker tonight is Janet Shapiro [Music] almost forgot um

039good evening first of all as a retired educat educator I'd like to thank all of you for your commitment and your work on behalf of the students faculty and staff of the community it's truly appreciated so Janet Shapiro and I'm representing the Sunshine Gardens Park Coalition um we have a question regarding the measure te funds specifically we're interested in understanding the utilization process for the proposition to approve funding our neighborhood is the only one in South San Francisco that does not have a neighborhood park so we are hoping to partner with the school board and the bond administrators to optimize the use of these funds to hopefully build a community park on the 7 and a half acres behind Sunshine Garden school and our question is and I realized from the explanation now we'll need

040to get it on the agenda if we want to actually talk about it but how can we most effectively engage in the process for the distribution of these funds to best serve our Sunshine Gardens Community that's it thank you very much Happy New Year thank you so much um our next speaker is Megan connory good evening Megan hory Al Camino High School and I'm speaking my monthly uh math pilot okay first of all I wanted to welcome our newest trustee lamb I I look forward to your guidance on the board um so on January 15th we had a pullout day for the math pilot where we participated in a lesson lab session with a learning walk I had the privilege of teaching the algebra 2 honors class at so City High School a lesson on

041discriminant to determine the number of solutions in a quadratic function um the purpose was for the participants to uh explore and apply effective strategies that promote deeper student engagement and thinking I really enjoyed teaching their class they were good bunch of kids um we also had a zoom session with Christy Hinman I hope I'm pronouncing that correctly um who is an Imagine Learning contractor um so we asked questions about stuff that had come up in the past few months and the main question I had was about the missing common core standards in illustrative mathematics um IM am does contain the national common core standards but not the California common core standards so that means three standards are missing from Algebra 1 four are missing from geometry and seven are not covered in Algebra 2 for

042example I am currently teaching a unit on exponential functions and logarithmic functions and the curriculum doesn't cover the log properties so that means I have to come up with separate lessons in order to teach three separate standards on logarithmic functions um I am does not also cover the plus standards the plus standards typically support mathematics that all students should study in order to be College and Career ready these standards are beneficial in preparing algebra St students for stem particularly for pre-calculus when we discussed this proficiency we were told that the Press standards are not necessary for all students so I took a time and I looked at the 191 students at El Camino that took Algebra 2 last year 40% are in pre-calculus and 5% are actually in AP AP Calculus so they're saying that

043the plus standards are not necessary for you know 46% of the or 45% of the students so um I'm concerned I'm watching the clock I'm concerned um that we are piloting a curriculum that is not geared towards stem now the curriculum that we piloted last year um Carnegie Learning um did doesn't need to be adapted it actually contains the California standards and the plus standards so I'm asking you please do not adopt the curriculum the IM curriculum but rather let's look at Carnegie Learning again thank you thank you right that concludes public comment uh number item n information only presentations um Educational Services teaching and learning presentation losos Elementary School principal Karen Hong will share with the board educational priorities and programs at losos and are you introducing okay sorry good evening president Anthony trusty

044marray trusty SE trusty lamb trusty Richardson Dr Moore members of the cabinet and the South San Francisco Unified School District Community my name is Karen Hong and I'm the new principal at leros elementary school it is my honor and privilege to present to you tonight the teaching and learning overview for the 2425 school year and some of the Wonder Wonder F things happening as well as share areas of growth at leros the portrait of a graduate is our road map it's our commitment to our students to help them develop these characteristics to be successful by the time they enter middle school and graduate from our high schools later on in this presentation I'll take you through the slides and we'll be making connections to how leros is working on the portrait of a graduate there

045are five district priorities over the course of the next five years as a district we are focusing on Priority One and five exceptional instruction and Equity centered systems at leros our mission is to Foster creativity and Independence using a growth mindset we are committed to encouraging our students to collaborate about our successes and challenges and we will provide a caring and enthusiastic environment to our community of Learners throughout the presentation this evening I'll be connecting the data the actions and goals to our priorities and our core values I'll also be going over the strategies and action plans in the sipsa looking at our student demographics we have 309 students currently enrolled in TK through fifth grade with smaller enrollment being in first and fourth grade English learners and social economically disadvantaged students make up 44%

046of the school and 24% are students with disabilities this is the School's attendance as you can see here in the chart the overall trend is that the average daily attendance and chronic absenteeism in the months since August has slightly improved from the year before but we recognize that there's room for growth in this area in order for learning to happen students need to be in school every day and come on time one of the strategies and action items to Target chronic absenteeism is regular communication to parents on the importance of School attendance early intervention is critical to Student Success and building up a healthy attendance habit so that our students can be prepared for middle school and Beyond this year the school is prioritizing building strong and positive relationships with students and families through regular

047and consistent communication the school utilizes the remind app the family newsletter and Wednesday hip folders for regular Communications in addition to our face to-face interactions Miss Eleanor our amazing admin assistant um maintains our school's Facebook page where families can stay connected on social media keeping up to-date with our family engagement events and opportunities to um stay connected with the school the electronic Marquee is also updated regularly to promote and remind Remer families of important dates like holidays spirit days and other um school events through individual attendance meetings we're actively identifying the root causes of student absences and then providing support to address any underlying issues such as mental health or Transportation challenges in order to be more proactive and engage with students who are at risk of chronic absenteeism we're looking to build out the

048attendance team with more members so that we can be more efficient utilizing our attendance data a second strategy and action item is to recognize our students who are coming to school on time every day we want to motivate and encourage our students who are making growth in their attendance with C certificates and prizes for incentives a third strategy is collaborating with our Community Partners and organizations to support our parents I'm very thankful to our amazing Community uh Community School liaison miss Karen Palamino she works um at leros but also for Star Vista which is a nonprofit uh that works with schools to provide a wide range of support and services for our students and families and many of which are free or low cost through these resources we're able to better support our families and

049their needs as you can see here in the year-to-date attendance chart 55.4% of students are satisfactory 28.3% of students are at risk and 14.3% are moderately chronic educating our families on the negative impact of missing school is a work in progress so far during back to school night conferences family newsletters are different ways we have been sharing about the importance of coming to school every day the schoolwide approach is critical and I look forward to reduced absenteeism in the months to come as we continue to look at the data this graph shows the Casp performance areas and the percentage of students within each achievement level the latest Casp scores from 23 to 24 show that 27.9% of students met or exceeded standards in ela and 19.7% met or exceeded standards in math this graph also

050shows areas of growth where 19.8% of students nearly met standards in ela and 30.6% nearly met standards in math the following two graphs show our third fourth and fifth graders in comparison with the district and the state it's broken down by Ela literacy and Mathematics you can also see results by our Target groups English Learners students with disabilities and socio economically disadvantaged students 44% of our students are English Learners this is an important piece of data for us we can see here that 10% of our English Learners met or exceeded standards in ela and math it's evident that the school needs to be more strategic around our efforts to support our English Learners I'm very thankful to our school site Council team for coming together to discuss ways that we can better support our English

051Learners I want to also highlight our Summit of elpac results showing areas of growth overall 35.1% of English learners are at a level one 22.7 6% are at level two and 33.1% are at a level three 8.97% are at a level four this graph illustrates our dibble's student performance at the beginning of the year across K to 5 categorized into four levels well below below at and above grade level standards based on this information we find that the majority of students in Kinder and first grade fall into the well below category indicating a need for targeted interventions at these early grades in grades three to five there is a noticeable increase in the percentage of students performing at or above grade level which is over 50% of students we are fortunate to have two amazing

052reading specialist teachers M Denise stuffy supports the primary grades and Miss Stacy Alvarez supports third fourth and fifth grade both their Data Tracking progress monitoring and intervention groups Have Been instrumental at identifying students at risk in addition to their intervention groups Miss Stephy and Miss Alvarez are key members of the school study team and I appreciate their insights and knowledge as we discuss student progress and growth we had a successful early literacy event thank you to all the parents who attended and learned about the different ways you could continue to support students students at home there was a gradual buildup this year on the portrait of a graduate awareness we had over 200 parents attend our back to school night and parents learned about portrait of a graduate and our district aims our POG posters

053are displayed in every classroom serving as reminders of our road map this year we have ongoing professional development during our staff meetings teachers discuss El strategies share best practices and reflect on their teaching and learning I personally have a lot of empathy for our lero students and families especially because I too didn't speak English when my family immigrated to the United States but it was in South San South San Francisco Unified School District and our teachers here that taught me how to read I discovered a new world through books and literature I share this not to boast but to inspire our leros Cubs that they too have a bright future ahead and they can accomplish anything that they put their mind to I am incredibly grateful to the staff and Educators at Los ritos who

054are bringing the portrait of a graduate to life even as early as kindergarten students have been practicing academic discourse routines for example Miss Ruiz our kindergarten teacher models the academic language and students practice these skills it's wonderful to see our students make meaning um connect with ideas build on to other students ideas and be engaged in their learning in addition to academics we recognize that social emotional learning is an important piece to developing the whole child our students get recognized for demonstrating Cub behaviors caught using brilliant behaviors that demonstrate our PBIS initiatives on Ruby Bridges walk to school day we had a huge turnout of students and parents who came to walk with us to school it's amazing to see our community come together to reflect on the courage that Ruby Bridges showed and honor

055her Legacy of bravery and courage with the dedicated staff who care deeply about our students I look forward to further supporting our students and helping them to learn impact navigate and thrive in our school Community as I wrap up this presentation I wanted to mention the core values from the Strategic plan Community really is our strength at Los ritos and authentic relationships matter there are nine new teachers who are new to loritos or new to their grade level and challenges the community has faced but we are resilient and Propel forward with Equity guiding us I want to take this opportunity to thank everyone who has been vital in helping the school Community to grow and to learn I'm especially appreciative of the PTA and our parent volunteers especially Miss Alvarez our amazing PTA president thank

056you not just for being here tonight but for your overall support and partnership I am incredibly grateful for our parent volunteers your thoughtfulness and the small things that are not so small but make a big difference is very much appreciated for example your time your effort and the care that goes into things like decorating our school Christmas tree putting up ribbons around the school for a festive holiday look organizing our Scholastic Book Fair to support the school's initiative with literacy the fun spirit days the parent cafes and all the behind the scenes that go into the amazing events we have at school is very much appreciated thank you Miss Marcela alfarez Miss Tina J Miss Joseline Corpus Miss lordes cisos Miss Alita Perez for your heart and dedication to making lost Doritos a great place

057to be here are some photos from our family engagement and community events from this year as you can tell here from the photos we are prioritizing and focusing on the community coming together and this couldn't have been possible without our amazing parents staff and students I would like to end the presentation with a quote of gratitude gratitude is the healthiest of all human emotions the more you Express gratitude for what you have the more likely you will have even more to be uh grateful for by Ziggler I'm grateful to ed services technology department facilities for your support as we prepared our staff for a successful year I'm grateful for all the campus improvements from replacing old blinds replacing the foam in our play structure to new tables and sun umbrellas for the patio the Los

058ritos Community is appreciative for your continued support thank you Board of Trustees for your attention and care for lost Doritos I'm also grateful to the staff for showing up every day to to support our students and to the Bay Ed fund for your generous Grant to support our community building efforts and of course our hardworking students who show up ready to learn every day every day I come to school with humility as I work with people who care deeply about our students I'm honored to be able to lead such a caring uh wonderful Community as your principal thank you for affording me this opportunity to share about leros and listening to this presentation tonight I welcome any questions or comments you may have I'll open it to our trustees any questions or comments trusty Richardson

059you want to start to you so much for this presentation we we had a rocky start but it's seems like you won the whole community over and I I am the head of the uh uh tell to tell you that I appreciate very much your um dedication to our students I know 60% 67% is a lot of little ones that don't speak English and uh did you learn Spanish yet no I just kidding I know it's it's hard but you know somehow where there's a will there's a way so um I'm happy to hear that you know your your students are attending school in the 90s I'm always optimistic that we just have that little bit more to go so thank you for hanging in there for us and I'll see you pretty soon thank

060you thank you and much gracias for too I'm learning a new word every day thank you just L can you hear me okay sure yeah I gu say a little bit I just want to say yeah quickly yeah thank you for being here for presenting um you know I'm pretty new here uh I may have only been a resident here 17 years so I don't have the you know uh haven't attended Elementary School here but I will share you know my husband actually attended El leros Elementary School back when he was a kid some 30 years ago so you know there is some familial connection to the school um so you know so so by that you know being L Serio is adjacent in a way so you know I'm kind of rooting for you

061guys and um yeah thank you for sharing um and I look forward to you know coming uh to a future site visit and checking everything out and yeah keep up uh the efforts and um and and cubby uh thanks for coming and uh yes thank you thank you maybe we should ask council member nagales to dress a as cubby for a future event that's an excellent idea we'll put it on the next agenda thank you thank you excellent presentation really appreciate how you lead the school and your auth authenticity showed show through um your speech so thank you so much for your caring for our community trusty maray I doo want to thank you um this is your first first time here welcome um it was it was a great report and I can tell

062that you fit right into the community it's I have no connection other than I'm on the board and I love your community so um and you just I think that it shows in your report how much you love your community and how much you bring to your community so thank you I'm grateful for that thank you thank you and thank you so much for the presentation um I'm super happy to see the decreases in chronic absenteeism and the efforts that you're making together with your PTA um to build community um with your teachers your staff your school your students um it's really wonderful to see uh I know that it's hard to learn subjects when you're learning English so I I hope that we continue to build new strategies to help our students with both

063language acquisition and the key information about literacy that they do so thank you oh and we're going to take a picture so if you can invite up our parent volunteers e e thank you so much leros Community uh we'll move on to item 1B uh or n yeah no 1B uh teaching and learning presentation District's Che development program thank you president Anthony I'd like to welcome supervisor clayon who oversees numerous Child Development programs for us here in South San Francisco plus some after care programs so without further Ado I'm gonna pass the mic to supervisor Claybon good evening good evening president Anthony Board of Trustees superintendent cabinet community members and Families my name is Eric Claybon I am the child development program coordinator and it is an honor to share with you uh some information

064about the child development program tonight's board presentation includes the following program and data overview goals and action plan and questions if there be any the child development program is Guided by our District's Mission portrait of a graduate Vision Vision core values and strategic priorities aligned to our lcap goals the portrait of a graduate represents our commitment to our students and families that every student will have the opportunity to develop our four graduate aims which are the ability to learn consistently as their life and World changes Thrive as a person navigate their future purposefully and impact their communities for the better our strategic plan outlines five priorities that will help us to achieve our portrait of a graduate com a commitment to all of our students by making sure that our instruction is exceptional all of

065our students are engaged and supported as self-directed learners our Partnerships are purposeful allowing every student to benefit from trusting quality relationships with families and Community our educators are empowered and our systems are centered on Equity as a program we are consistently intending to communicate with our parent community in ways that are honest transparent and professional therefore the South San Francisco child development program continues to use the following tools to communicate classroom and program information as needed learning Genie which is an app that allows families to receive messages and schooled uh updates in real time remine 101 which provides us the opportunity to send text messages to parents for upcoming events and also to send out information in case of an emergency and finally We are continuing to utilize the zoom platform to conduct many of

066our program meetings for parents and staff to assess academic and developmental achievement in the field of Early Education we are currently utilizing the following assessment tools the desired results developmental profile or drdp is used to assess student knowledge skills and development Al level the classroom assessment scoring system or class 2.0 assesses the quality of a teacher child interaction in center-based preschool programs and igd the individual growth and development indicator is a new literacy assessment tool utilized to support the growth and development of early Learners these three assessment tools are compiled and used to inform form instruction and to determine program quality overall and finally relationships the child development program has established a wealth of Rich relationships over the years each of our professional relationships continues to be greatly appreciated and valued program and data overview

067the child development program continues to offer quality child care to the South San Francisco Community since 1943 currently we are happily serving five full day preschool classrooms under our state and County contracts three of our full day classrooms are at the children center and two more are at Hillside and our Southwood campuses we also have four part day classrooms under our County contract two are at the Children's Center and two more are at Martin Elementary School campus okay one more slide please this slide represents four areas of our preschool demographics the age of the students we serve and their percentages the number of English Lang language Learners we serve and their percentages the number of students with IEPs and the number of students that remain in our district after preschool the child development program also

068operates two school age programs one subsidized and the other is fee based the subsidized program is located at the Children's Center having the capacity to serve 70 spruce elementary students our Feebas program is called the District extended daycare activities program or dap is located at two of our elementary school sites bub and Skyline our goals and action plan seeds of learning is a professional learning framework that empowers childhood Educators to prepare children for kindergarten through the devel through the development of oral language emergent literacy and social emotional skills the framework focuses on the big five literacy predictors oral language phonological awareness print concept alphabetic principles and vocabulary here are our three literacy goals for the year goal go one to improve literacy outcome for all preschool students through the implementation of differentiated instructional strategies goal

069two to improve our preschool students foundational reading skills through daily explicit instruction and goal three to increase Educators awareness and understanding of writing instructions if individual growth and development indicators or iges is a literacy assessment tool for young children that monitor the growth and development of students before they go to kindergarten the purpose is to give Preschool teachers more information about students in order to identify areas of strength and areas of growth here are the iges measures that we will be assessing this year for both uh ages three and four mixed oral language picture naming sound identification and alliteration questions thank so much Mr clayon um comments from or questions from es okay trusty Richardson sorry I appreciate everything you do for our children I had a couple of questions for the TK is that

070the age group of three year olds or I I always have a kind of a problem trying to figure that out is it the three-year-olds or the four year olds that are called TK it's basically basically the four year olds basically in the four- year old range okay supervisor clay Bon's correct it's four year olds are TK so remember the state of California has slowly moved the birth date yeah back so now next year yeah that that really got that's that's the key so that's why we showed a slide of who in the CDP programs threey olds four year olds and five year olds and the percentage because due to TK in the future there might be some movement in terms of the numbers of students in the ages in the CDP program I'm sorry

071supervisor claim I should let you answer that thank you very much appreciate so what are the threeyear olds called babies or I don't know preschool students Scholars preschool Scholars winners yeah because you know we're capitalizing on this growth at such an early age that I know I understand that's the movement and everything so I I appreciate everything and we heard at the uh Capital Advisors uh that we are going to keep funding TK it was a five year old fiveyear uh uh how do they call it it was a a pilot sort of now they're thinking about keeping it I'm how how's our space do we have room for all those you should um I can come back and do a presentation and answer that with TK um ed services and myself oversee TK right

072now okay so we have six TK classes in our school district right now and we're looking to expand based on numbers so cabinet is looking for potential spaces this year and future years to ensure that we can educate all foury olds for TK great you know I I I know you moved here and you have a class here of of those children are they TK or are they third three year olds none none of these classrooms are TK classrooms they're they're preschool classrooms I okay even though it's the same is that a temporary classroom still temporary classroom here the baen school Mr CL the B so our Southwood preschool program here is a preschool program oh that's preschool okay well thank you so much I I always enjoy uh visiting your school and uh every

073time you uh ask us and we hope we can okay your your requests for a new mural and that last mural we you requested it's up and looks really nice so thank you it just lifts up the whole school thank you thank you as well thank you trusty Richardson see then i' to offer I asked a couple questions U well first of all thank you for the presentation um I think uh speaking as a you parent my kids are a little older now but um you know Child Care um in general is such a need in our community and um you know we frankly can't get enough you know we need child care to make a living I think you know many parents in the community uh I just had a general question um just

074for the benefit of folks who are curious uh you know what the uh average weight list is for uh the various uh sites both preschool and the after care programs and then what is the uh wait time for those weit lists as well okay so um currently in terms of uh weit list uh for our preschool programs um at the Children's Center we have for our full day um classrooms we have a weit list of five families currently uh and for our part day uh program we have a weight list of eight families uh for our hillsite Martin and Southwood currently right now we have a weight list of zero uh in terms of our dap program our after school program we have a weight list of 16 families that's where we are currently and

075how long typically does it take to I don't know get through um like how long do families typically wait or does it kind of just depend on as I guess as kids age out then the spots open up is that kind of how it goes that's ABS that's absolutely true um when um spaces are open our enrollment team our amazing enrollment team contacts them right away and takes them through the process the process itself um could take about three weeks in terms of getting information back back and forth from the families but um the weight U the weight time varies uh depending upon um the when families are able to provide all the documentations or not um so uh basically three weeks or so very good thank you very much you're welcome thank you so

076much trusty lamb trusty Shay yeah thank you thank you so much for your excellent presentation I'm I enjoy it every year and you are always present precise and very short and sweet to the point thank you you thank you so much agreed but I do have one question what kind of IEPs do the the 27 students have it um it varies um but the majority of the students have speech have IEPs that are related to speech okay so you you start to identify them at that age and then yeah yes mostly speech the Children's Center Works in conjunction with our special education department so there's lots of Assessments that occur and that lead to some services to help kids right at the beginning and usually like supervisor claymon said it's around speech two of my

077kids were in speech at three so um also the the assessments are they consistent throughout all your campuses yes thank you very much absolutely thank you so much Mr cayon um super happy to see the programming um hope that we can I would say personally increase the number of people going from our child development program to our South San Francisco schools and thank you for your presentation and I hope that the kids still get to play a lot and it's not just focus thank you thank you have a great thank you as well okay we have nine minutes and a whole bunch of audit presentations and I'm guessing that they will not get those done in nine minutes so uh I'm gonna choose to take our break now uh for the benefit of the captioner

078so we'll reconvene at 8:31 e for e e hi Mr Park can you hear us are you ready uh can we get the presentation together for you or yes uh I do hear you fine I am ready to go just let me know when is there a presentation are you just talking to us and walking I feel terrible I saw the two presentations ahead of me and I guess I missed the boat I usually don't have a presentation okay so you're going to be speaking so good evening welcome we're ready to hear your report awesome do we have copies of the audit reports we do okay wonderful so why don't we start with the main audit report which is the thicker report it I'm sorry we have it okay so I do see that there's

079a new trustee so I just want to preface um what we do for the board so technically I am the board's agent work for the board and if you look at all the correspondences or the issued documents it is addressed to the board my primary responsibility as it pertains to an audit is to audit your financial statements now what exactly does that mean so I'm sorry uh trusty lamb you weren't here for this but uh back in September of ' 04 you were presented with a document called un audited actuals in essence that document is an overall Financial statement of a school district and at the time of of the information being presented it is UN audited my primary responsibility is to come in and audit the information and report back so as part of

080my audit there's that main financial statement audit but there's also a bit of a compliance audit component to it very specifically Federal compliance and state compliance now when you look at an audit report it is a bit daunting there's a lot of of numbers in there and there's a lot of accounting jargon and in all honesty if you don't practice in the governmental sector as a CPA and very specifically as an auditor it's a bit overwhelming now for the sake of understanding how the audit went there's a single page that all board members should refer to and I'm going to take you to page 94 with the header of summary of auditor results if you could please flip to that page okay looks like we're there okay so the fastest way to gauge how the

081audit went is to look at this page and then very specifically you see three sections both faced on this page first is the financial statements second there's a header of federal Awards and lastly there's a header of State compliance now before I get into the results let's talk about some tech technical terms that I have to use and I can't avoid so just like your attorneys we render a professional opinion using an objective criteria and we do this by varying degree the highest level of assurance that any Auditors will render including governmental Auditors and publicly Auditors uh that audit publicly traded companies private entities nonprofit the highest level of assurance that any Auditors will provide is an unmodified opinion please keep this term in mind followed by a qualified opinion and lastly a disclaimer or

082an adverse opinion now what what does what does all this mean so in essence think of it in terms of we are in a tax season we're heading into a tax season or we're kind of need deep into it IRS will not send you a letter saying you did a good job if you did your tax return correctly Unfortunately they will send you a letter if you did the wrong thing and they'll correct you right so in essence we do act like the Auditors of our IRS we only point out the bad we don't necessarily say he did a good job because we're not allowed to okay but all in all unmodified opinion is the highest level of assurance meaning that it is a clean opinion so knowing those terms let's go through each of

083the sections as it relates to the financial statements from July 1st 2023 through June 30 uh 2024 our opinion was unmodified as it relates to your unit actuals okay that is a clean opinion so bulk bar procedure pertains to the understanding of what in our industry we call internal controls now what exactly is that so you've heard of the term called checks and balances now if I tone this down to the the simplest form in essence it's the process of a dollar of transaction being processed within a system of financial controls and how does that dollar get reported on the financial statement it's really the flow of information or we call this internal controls or otherwise known as checks and balances um so we spent substantial amount of time on this and under the government

084auditing requirements if we identify any type of deficiencies as it relates to the preparation of the financial statements in this case the UN audited actuals or any flaws associated with that we are required to report it um so there's two degrees of findings that we could potentially report first is what we would call a material weakness okay and second is second to a lower lower degree is a significant deficiency material weakness basically alludes to the fact that the the deficiency was so significant well I don't want to use the term significant so um major I guess that's another term that it directly had an impact on the financial statements whereas the lower degree of deficiency basically means that there was a deficiency and if not corrected it will have a direct impact on the financial

085statements as far as an audit difference or basically mislead the the readers of the financial statements to believe that the financial statements are correct okay so going through the Section again I just wanted to preface that but as it relates to the financial statements we did not identify y any type of deficiencies as it relates to the checks and balances or internal controls that have been implemented by your business services division to ensure that the financial statements are fairly stated okay so no findings that I have to report moving on to Federal Awards so Federal Awards is is is actually a federal requirement so what the requirement stipulates is that if a non-federal entity receives federal assistance and spends that federal assistance in excess of$ 750 ,000 annually you are subject to what's called uniform

086guidance compliance requirement and is a requirement that's stipulated Again by the feds in other words if they give you the money there strings attached and you have to comply otherwise the feds want their money back okay um to give you a general idea in terms of what your federal subsidy was during the 2324 fiscal year South San Francisco Unified School District spent spent $8.6 million in federal subsidy last year now in case you're curious it's going to be on page 71 and 72 you don't really have to look at it but just to quench your curiosity you could certainly look at this page and just kind of get an idea of what type of federal subsidy that the district receives okay now going back to the summary so on the summary page with me I

087lost my page here we go so going back to the summary page on 94 a full listing of all the programs that we audited during your 23 24 fiscal year is identified as you can see there's a lot of references to coid-19 these are all programs related to your one-time funding that you received um from the feds along with uh Your Child Nutrition which is a federal subsidy for your free and reduced meal program and also your title One funds which is a federal subsidy to provide assistance to your underprivileged students okay so based on the audit procedures that we performed on all of these identified program our overall opinion was unmodified as it relates to the compliance District's compliance with these programs um during the course of our evaluation of the checks and balances

088or internal controls that are deployed to ensure compliance with these programs we did identify find exception and the details of the exception is in the subsequent Pages under the finding section hopefully you had a chance to look at that um okay so moving on to the final section of the audit which is State compliance now again this is for the sake of trusty lamb uh State compliance is rather a unique section it's not something that we would select to audit it's actually dictated To Us by the California Department of Education primarily and some other uh parties that are also involved with the the creation of this audit guide but there's a comprehensive listing of all the programs on page 90 and Page 91 just in case you're curious now when you look at these two

089pages there's a full listing of programs and then you'll see yes and not not no C below or not applicable notations yes notations indicate that we were required to audit these programs simply due to the fact that the district administered these programs or received subsidy and as a result there are strings attach na basically means that it basically did not apply to the district and as a result we did not perform any of these procedures pertaining to these specific requirements indicated with a not applicable notation So based on the auto procedures performed on all of these programs that are notated with yes are overall District opinion as it relates to the state compliance requirement was unmodified okay however we did identify an exception related to I believe it was instructional material compliance requirement now um

090there there there was a finding associated with this in the subsequent Pages hopefully you also had an opportunity to look at this look at the the details of the finding just kind of gauge what took place um so overall our opinion was unmodified which is synonymous with a clean opinion for each of the three areas with a slight um exceptions noted in the finan I'm sorry the federal section and the state section so that pretty much summarizes the audit from an overall standpoint do you have any questions for me that I may try to answer truste any questions I know you're look I know you you had quite a few but I don't know if you want to ask them thank you for the presentation um every year we look forward to this a clean

091bill of health our fiscal health and you always deliver or Mr O delivers and you just tell us he delivered so I appreciate uh the consistent um ratings so that we could continue and do our businesses it's uh very challenging we understand to have um uh School uh School budgeting is not the easiest and it's unconventional as when compared to Conventional uh uh uh uh accounting so it is a a big a big chore or big job to do this and somehow Mr O makes us look good and do you agree and I agree too thank you thanks if we don't have any more questions we can move on to 2B measure J Bond audit uh for the fiscal year ended June 30th 2024 okay so let's move on to one of the smaller reports

092it should be labeled me measure J so Bond a reports that we issue and all the practitioners that issue within the context of school district is a two-part audit report first half of the audit report pertains to the financial statements and second part is what everybody's interested in it it is the performance aspect of it or we call it compliance of it okay so um I'll speed this up a little bit quick so as it relates to the financial statement audit this is a financial statement that's kind of audit that's scaled down not necessarily using the thresholds that we use for school districts because again we're talking smaller dollars so it's a scale down audit where we look at smaller numbers and to kind of determine whether or not the financial statements related to measure

093J in this case is fairly stated as of June 30 2024 in this case um so to kind of quickly go over the uh results based on the audit procedures that we performed we believe that the financial statements are fairly stated in all material respects we provided an unmodified ified opinion as it relates to the financial statements pertaining to measure J as of June 30 2024 um I'm sorry I'm not I'm not uh referencing any Pages I'm just kind of talking because there's really nothing for me to report so it was an unmodified opinion as it relates to the financial statements related to measure J we also did not identify any type of internal control or checks and balances efficiencies that have been basically procedures related to prepar financial statements there's really no deficiency to

094report to the board pertaining to the financial statement side so overall it was a clean opinion okay um moving on to the second half of the report which is a little bit more interesting to most readers of the financial statements including the community so what a performance audit is is it's basically a compliance audit now what am I addressing when I'm talking about compliance now compliance in this case is basically answering the question the ultimate question of did the did the district take the bond proceeds and spend the proceeds in accordance to what the voters have approved okay in other words is a district uh spending the money responsibility and in accordance to what was actually voted on okay and it's basically There's No Gray there it's basically I I go through and I test

095and I report back yes or no okay um so to kind of give you some statistics as far as how much we tested if you could refer to page 17 of this report towards the end okay page 17 at the bottom number three okay so to kind of give you an idea um during the 2324 fiscal year the district spent approximately uh 208,000 out of the 208,000 we tested um rounding up here 206,000 which roughly represents 99% of the total amount spent from measure J funds so what was the result so based on the testing from a compliance perspective is that um we believe based on the audit procedures that we performed on the expenditures that we reviewed we believe that the district had spent the proceeds in accordance to what the voters have approved

096so we have nothing to report to the board in essence no news is good news just like the IRS audits right any questions on measure J outstanding glad to hear that any questions okay if not we're going to move on to item two c measure T Bond audit for the fiscal year into June 30th 2024 okay so I'm gonna speed this up a little bit it's essentially the same information again it's a two-part audit first half is the financial statements uh pertaining to measure T um our opinion was unmodified with respect to the financial statements as of June 30 2024 pertaining to measure T we also did not identify any type of internal control deficiencies uh that have been deployed on the pre procedures that have been deployed to prepare the financial statements associated with

097measure T now moving on to the performance aspect of it um if you could turn to page 17 Again number three the same information um during the 2324 fiscal year which is basically July 1 through June 30th of 2024 um the district spent approximately $4.8 million we tested $3.8 million which is roughly 80% of the total expenditure spent so what was the result based on the audit procedures that we performed on the sample selected we believe that the district had spent the bond proceeds in accordance to what the measure T voters have approved so nothing to report on this as well no exceptions noted any questions on measure te I do okay trusty Richardson thank you um when we take out the first trench of bond funds um how long do we have to spend

098or pull you know again uh cash out or the next uh phase of uh bonds because we didn't take out the whole amount um is it do we have a specific timeline that we have to use up that money from the bond uh I think question I think it's a question for Mr O um who is ill today I don't think that's the question for the auditor was Mr O there no he's not I think but I think that's a question for Mr O our auditor wouldn't have an opinion answer it I don't believe so but if you want to try Mr Park um well yeah I'm not first there's a specific Department unfortunately yeah let's save that question and then we can talk to Mr O about it that's all thank you super thank

099you any other questions about the bond uh just quick comment um thank you so much uh Mr Park those three reports really excellent work that you helped us to understand and highlight our District's strong physical management commitment and no findings that's excellent so we will continue continue to move that and then I know there were a couple of the um findings that that uh I think is not significant right from what you mentioned a little bit earlier that is correct okay thank you thank you so much thank you so much for your time Mr Park we appreci appreciate it you're very welcome all right moving on to 2D uh Business Services energy program projects and savings staff from NG will present to the board so they should be are you here in person thank you

100very much I'd like to introduce David Baldwin and Ken Willits who are representatives from NG who will provide a presentation on the district's up-to-date energy program savings and so with that I will turn it over to Mr Baldwin and Miss Willets good evening uh president Anthony trustees and superintendent Moore uh thank you for this opportunity to present the energy program savings update um this is basically a summary of the two phases um which describes the work for each phase um you can see in phase one which began in October of 2012 that was a long time ago um we installed solarpv across 15 schools and we also upgraded 10 of the schools lighting at that time we upgraded hbac and boilers at two sites and we installed a new energy management system at all Sites

101um there were new uh irrigation control systems at all School sites and at three schools that were new roofs uh and then along with that there was a stem education uh program that was uh highly successful and we'll mention a few words about that also phase two began in March of 2018 and that was centered around the LED um Sports Stadium lighting at El Camino High School um and then that also included uh an additional 1800 interior exterior lighting uh LEDs at other schools and then the 352 KW of additional solar which is mostly at the district office uh that was at in phase two um and again the stem education which is right here um the energy program included this stem education program which resulted in numerous District Awards ws and you can see

102the awards that the district received um and enie was very involved between 2016 and 21 where um there was a lot of Hands-On uh work going on we also offered professional development uh for the teachers activity kits over 1,800 students uh were engaged and um to keep it going uh we have U Been engaged to enable the District to keep things going on their own and hopefully that's the case so um very very successful summer program of stem so um quick overview of the phase one project um the uh project net savings over 25 years is about $23 million and we we also offered a a guarantee along with that on the solar Savings of 15.7 million and that's that's in the contract um currently we are through 12 years of solar savings and um

103I'll show you a summary on that in a minute but that's over $9 million and through uh the 12 years we're about 15% over the guarantee estimate of PV production um the other thing that is of note is while the project in phase one was $24.5 Million um 13 A5 million of that was for the solar uh this the lighting across the 10 sites was 1.2 million and then a whole bunch of infrastructure work was almost $10 million so we replaced new roofs irrigation controls Energy Management Systems boilers HVAC so there was a lot of stuff that was also done um the that original project there were rebates for solar so that rebate program provided almost $2 million uh back to the district after the project was finished and then um we have been providing

104ongoing operation and maintenance and measurement and verification Services um and you know those have cost $800,000 so that comes out of the 9.8 8 million of savings so the savings was around Net $9 million um which is still significant general fund savings back to the classrooms so um basically the these are the numbers um for the savings um and this chart lists years one through actually zero through 20 year zero is during construction so as we finish something we're still in construction though and you're getting use um so uh one of the columns is the years and then the um guaranteed production is the next column that that is in the contract um and then we have a a a p gen rate the reason why the first five years are more is that P

105gen paid a rebate back per kilowatt hour and that extra amount is the amount of the rebate um and you can see after a year or five it drops to 24 cents that's because the rebate was only for the first five years um and then the guaranteed savings is simply the multiplication of those columns uh and then every year we have uh acred the measurements we actually have metering and it's measuring the production of the solar um over that Year's period um and this report is presented to District staff on an annual basis so you can see Year bye what the energy produced uh was through year 12 and then U the the the dollars are calculated based on the um the rate that's in the contract and then every year we compare that to

106um what was in the contract and come up with are we under or are we over so that gives you view of of phase one U so phase two the project was a a bit simpler um as far as the scope goes it was only U solar and lighting basically um the net savings projected over 25 years is $2.7 million and the 20y year solar only guarantee is um $3.7 million and the reason for the difference is the net savings has some costs deducted from the solar savings um this project was not Bond funded it was funded by a tax exempt lease um so that got deducted from the the savings through year six the savings are 931000 for the so um and that uh is also above the um guaranteed production uh and then

107you can see the costs of each thing uh the solar costs $1.8 million in lighting RR fit including the St Stadium lighting uh was $3.1 Million uh so the total was just under $5 million and you can see the funding mechanisms prop 39 was a state funding mechanism 700,000 the uh District used 300,000 in capital and then the financed amount was $3.9 Million um the operation and maintenance for the first six years is $33,000 so this net savings is about six or 900,000 when you deduct that 30,000 from the 9 or 930,000 in savings and this is how it looks on the spreadsheet uh you got the years on the left and then the contracted amount guarantee and then we compare that to the actual numbers um in the actual column through year six and

108then year by year we show the um percentage of what the amount of the production was so that's the numbers and then I wanted to say just a few words about the uh measurement and verification Services uh we do measure um the systems we monitor them on a continuous basis um and that's the solar part um these monitoring systems send us alarms so that in that allows us to identify and react any system problems and um it this system also allows the district to access the data so the district can go on the web and and take a look at how things are operating and then you know on an annual basis this data is compiled and then uh we present um that information on an annual basis uh to staff um likewise on the

109o operation and maintenance services uh we do provide a comprehensive onm program and um basically uh there's two major components of the system there's the panel themselves and then there's the inverters I mean obviously there's a lot of other electrical stuff but those are the two key pieces of equipment the panels have a 25-year warranty and so um they've got a ways to go um the inverters have a 10-year warranty we're a little past that now we're in year 12 um so they are out of warranty um however you know um like anything if you have good maintenance you can make things last longer um and that's basically the service you'll see all the different things that is maintained on an annual basis so on the inverters for example there's been five inverter problems since

110the um warranty has been up and all five of those have been um repaired for $25,000 total um compare that to if you wanted to replace all the inverters like their pass their warranty oh we better replace them all that's over $3 million so we would recommend that you keep doing the repair route for a little while because we think we they last quite a while um so in omm uh you know we do array cleaning on an annual basis um and then you know while we're doing that we're checking also to see are there any damages to any of the arrays and we always bring that to the uh District staff uh if we see anything um there's a lot of preventative maintenance that we do visual inspections um changing out um air filters

111and just checking the equipment to make sure there's uh no dirt and debris over things and you know that kind of stuff so so there's a lot of things on our checklist that we go through um and then as far as electrical systems we have infrared scanning that we do on the electronic equipment so we're pointing that at the inverters we're pointing that at um the components and the the connections to make sure that uh everything's tight and you know again that's in our annual report and we'll note with the district if there's anything to be repaired um same thing with circuit uh testing we do tests to circuits with this fancy analyzer and so the district gets a uh report on that also um all of these reports are um on the this website

112that we provide for the district so Wy can go in and look up all all of this stuff including the guarantee reports um are years uh all the way through year 12 are available on that website also uh and then finally uh we do have conversations with the district on on various topics um you know as far as what's possible in the future um the first thing had to do with inverter Replacements obviously the district wants to stay on top of that item because now they're out of warranty um we've done a lot of research on this as far as what would need to be done what the costs would would be and you can see to replace all the inverters for phase one across all those sites would be $3.6 million um luckily the

113inverter that we're using in San Jose there's a spare parts store that has all the parts so we just need to keep them in business so um that's why it's been um duable and so as long and we're we're monitoring that we have other customers that have the same inverter so we're using that that repair place you know on a regular basis um and and they're very fixable pieces of of equipment um so right now we're recommending the repair option rather than that let's go out and you know replace all this but you we're also suggesting you might want to think about a budget you know somewhere down the road either part of a bond or set aside every year some money that you know would create a budget maybe 10 years down the road

11415 years down the road you're going to need to eventually do some sort of replacement um the second item is um uh addressing um uh more lighting I mean we did a lighting project a long time ago but you know LEDs are like a game changer and it's not a bad idea given all the savings to just go in and wipe out all the rest of the lights this measure has a lot of good savings so uh and then the last item was um uh it had to do with power outages and um you know there's obviously concerns about poweres nobody wants their power to go out and you know that there's losses obviously classrooms get disrupted but also if one particular site goes down the data center goes down or the food Refrigeration goes

115down that's a whole another set of problems so it might make sense to prioritize sites on which ones could use this micro grid idea and you know the cost that's shown there is putting a micro grid everywhere and so obviously that's worst case scenario but you could put it in two schools or you know something more uh you know focused um but you know we put this together just so that they have the information um anyway um thank you and I'd be happy to answer any questions thank you so much and thank you for sharing future planning uh comments questions from our board trusty trusty lamb thoughts are fine too thoughts no I no I'm just I was actually counting back when that first phase was completed and that was I think my child was

116one years old so so so I wasn't around for that that project but I I really applaud the district and you know this project and you know your company for um yeah bringing solar power and bringing um yeah just being at the Forefront of this because now you know seeing all the savings that we've been realizing um in terms of not having to pay PG all that you know Millions or you know in funds it's it's great um and you know the conversations about uh climate resiliency I that that's just going to continue on so to know that we're kind of at that Forefront of that already with the solar power um that's huge so um yeah so thank you for the information I think about that same thing with my age also I was

117involved from the very beginning yeah any other questions or comments thank you so much for your time thank you for coming just want to extend it if anybody needs you know further explanation after you've sat with the the presentation and looked it over we're happy to answer any questions and sit down with you obviously we're the experts in this and we don't expect you to be so um please don't hesitate to reach out did you leave us your email address okay thank you yeah I have too many questions and I just like o under overwhelmed with all this data figure it out I appreciate yes nice meeting you super thank you moving on to consent agenda the following items are submitted for board approval one motion will authorize action for those items so designated um

118I understand that we may want to pull two items for secondary consideration item are we on consent agenda p oh okay yeah so for um the yeah the educational services um i' I'd like to U set aside items f and g um I had a question oh you oh we're on are we on there yeah we on the consent agenda for the um item let's see the uh uh the mathematics Community Practice convening for uh January hold on a second okay first all we're just the one for um October 24 it's down the list the cath California Mathematics Community was item I item I you said I and then the next one oh no no that's the wrestling one a and the wrestling oh no that's one yeah that's another one um I I got

119the uh I don't have the item trusty Richardson I think the one that you were looking for is one a trusty Richardson one a what's the other one on you said you had a second one what oh yeah there you go a and b and uh I I brought it up I'm bringing it up so you want to pull those for discussion just for a Clarity um okay super what we will do is we going to take one motion authorize 1 a CDE e h i j k l m n o p two human resources all three Business Services all can I get a motion to approve second thank you um can we get a what what do I call all in favor no I I I okay uh we have an a second motion

120to approve uh items one f and g with I need to abstain yes from okay can I get a motion move second second okay uh trusty Murray trusty Shay can I get a all in favor uh minus trusty lamb I I any opposed okay and now we will address items 1 A and B um which had some questions yes I found it a little bit strange that we at and I did ask for it before and it but after I got the response I still didn't understand it because it was approved after the fact um that's what we're doing it's on the agenda that is for was for initially for October 24 to attend uh the California Mathematics committee uh on October 1 and 2 and 24 then again uh something to approve for tonight

121oh oh is it okay well it said something else on the other anyway um yeah it was for approval for tonight for January 30 so Mr Iris wanted to explain again and now I sort of understand it but it uh it needs a little Clarity for the public so I understand why we are approving things two months later the vard is thank you uh trusty Richardson um for the opportunity to provide Clarity so on 1A we have a great relationship and partnership with the Sano County Office of Education they often help and support not just our district but numerous districts in the county and provide professional learning opportunities so when we first engaged with Sano County Office of Ed they said that they were going to take care of all costs related to the professional

122learning opportunity for our staff since it was not an overnight trip there was no reason for us since we just had our audit internal controls and processes for me to bring that to the board because there was no cost and there was no approval what occurred after our staff went when they submitted reimbursement samel County said we must have misunderstood or there's miscommunication Sano County said we do not directly reimburse any District employee re reimburse an invoice have districts invoice us and then they give us the money and then we pay so it's not our money the county office is more than willing and have already sent the funds here once I found out that this occurred because we have our own internal processes with around professional learning I had to bring I wanted to

123bring the board memo back to the board for approval so you could see what was occurring um so in full transparency like you were saying trusty Richardson that's why it's here now but there is no cost to the district but our staff can't get reimbursed for this until it goes through our internal process so we now know that that's the case with the sale county office ofed so we apologize again do you see this happening again I picked up something along the same line a while back and I just don't feel comfortable approving something after the fact or in front of me so I'm not I kind of worry about that because it's a liability maybe somewhere so um I just uh is there any way that we can Sid figure that out and plan

124not to have it happen again or well we know now I mean I know now probow different curve and change the rules rules because that's that's the that's the new style now people changed the rules thank you so much uh we're going to take can I get a motion to approve auction for items one A and B so moved so moved uh second yeah Shay okay first by trusty Murray uh second by trusty Shay can I get all in favor I any opposed okay motion passes 5- Z all right public hearing hear ing uh in accordance with California government code section 3547 prior to commencing labor negotiations all initial proposals of exclusive representatives and of public school employers which relate to matters within the scope of representation shall be presented at a public meeting of

125the public school employer and thereafter shall be public records the South San Francisco Unified School District and the South San Francisco classroom Teachers Association will be negotiating a successor agreement um for the 2025 to 2028 term a public hearing will provide an opportunity for members of the public to comment on the sfcta proposal um with that I will open the public hearing with that not seeing any comments I will close the public hearing all right uh moving on to information discussion Human Resources uh one a do we want to just go do one a and then I'll pull one b or two okay yeah I meant to pull that in review of anyway one a the passage of legislation in the wake of the Williams case settlement Education Code section 35186 requires all school districts

126in California to prepare a report summarizing data on the nature and resolution of all Williams uniform complaints received by The District in the past 3 months districts must submit these reports even if there have been no complaints received during that time period the information is to be reported publicly at a governing board meeting and submitted to the county superintendent of schools in April July October and January no complaints were filed during the second quarter spanning October 1 2024 through December 30th 2024 super thank you so much um 2A Business Services I'm sorry at the riew of the agenda we should have pulled this Mr O being sick will not be making this presentation and we'll move that okay we'll bring it back to the next board meeting all right moving on to our action items

127action item one Administration a resolution 2501 African-American history month staff recommends the adoption of resolution number 2501 honoring African-American history month can I get our clerk to read this into the record yes okay trusty Mur we read this into um African-American history month resolution 25-1 African-American history month February 1st through February 28 2025 whereas negro history week was established in February 1926 and grew in popularity to eventually be designated as African-American history month by President proclamation in 1976 and whereas this year's theme is African-American Americans and the art which celebrates how African-American artists including poets writers visual artists and dancers have historically served as change agents through their crafts and whereas the month of February was chosen as it marks the birthday of abolitionist Frederick Douglas and President Abraham Lincoln both of whom dramatically affected

128the lives of African-Americans and whereas the purpose of African-American history month is to recognize the important role that African-Americans have played in the history of our country and to acknowledge the injustices they have suffered and the challenges they continue to face and strive to overcome and whereas African-Americans have contributed economically culturally and socially to the development of the United States history especially in the area of Human Rights and whereas African-Americans have progressively served as elected and appointed officials at the local and National levels including passy Joe Hillyard who was the first African-American and woman to serve on the south San Francisco Unified School Districts Board of Trustees from 1975 to 1980 and whereas California Education Code section 51245 specifically calls for instruction in in the social sciences to include the study of the role and

129contributions of African-Americans to the economic political and Social Development of California and the nation with particular emphasis on portraying the role of this group in contemporary society and now therefore be it resolved that the South San Francisco Unified School District Board of Trustees hereby recognizes and wishes to honor African-Americans during a africanamerican History Month regularly passed and adopted this 23rd day of January 2025 thank you so much vice president Murray can I get a roll call vote please trusty Richardson yes trusty Shay yes trusty lamb yes vice president Murray yes president Anthony yes thank you so much moving on to 1B resolution 252 School counseling week staff recommends the adoption of resolution number 252 I'm sorry excuse me can we get a motion for the resolution oh sorry I thought we just had to get

130the roll call can I get a motion to adopt the resolution second okay Dr Shay so we have to go back and do the roll call for the previous one again huh for resolution 251 2501 yeah sorry I didn't open the motion okay trusty Richardson yes trusty Shay yes trusty lamb yes vice president Murray yes president Anthony yes sorry okay moving on to 252 um can we read the resolution into the record trusty Richardson the South San Francisco Unified School District resolution 2502 week of the school counselor February 3 to7 2025 whereas the week of the school counselor focuses attention on the unique contributions of those of these highly trained professionals who guide students in their educational Journeys by providing educational career and personal Social Development and whereas they are a source of continuity for

131students amidst charges changes and challenges both within and outside of the school and whereas in the K through 12 education system school counselors make sure students have the social and emotional skills to be successful now and in the future and provide opportunities for exploration to ensure those students Forge their uh best path forward and whereas they provide a safe and comfortable space to meet students needs whether in group settings or in one-on-one sessions oftentimes before students even realize they are in need of this support and whereas school counselors provide constant advocacy and creativity creatively remove barriers to learner learning and and engaging with peers always leading with putting students first and whereas in the last few years when everyone from students teachers and families have required more extensive support than usual school counselors have faced

132new challenges but we're always there to lend a helping hand and find a way to turn anxiety confusion or fear into positive supportive and productive action and whereas through through their work in helping the building to build a positive School climate school counselors model effective conflict resolution and collaboration and their leadership has had a positive and effect throughout the South San Francisco Community Unified School Community now therefore be it resolved that the South San Francisco Unified School District Board of Trustees hereby commends the school counselors for the contributions they make daily to advance the health well-being and academic achievement of students during the week of the school of the counselor regularly passed and adopted on this 23rd day of January 2025 thank you so much trusty Richardson can I get a motion so moved second

133second okay I think lamb had first Murray had second um can I get a roll call vote please just Richardson roll call vote roll roll call vote roll call I yes trusty Shay yes trusty lamb yes vice president Murray yes president Anthony yes all right moving on to action 1 C approval of districts updated board bylaws and policies staff recommends the approval of the following updated District board bylaw and policies in a wave of second reading as presented to the board are there any policies that any trustee would like to pull for any additional discussion I do I would like to um pull to for a second reading item number 12 actions by the board to include some okay did we don't have to talk about that yet uh you want to pull number 12

134any other anybody else want to pull anything else are you okay I'm just asking for what we want to pull you were you asking what you want to pull sounds like number 12 so can I get a motion to approve C1 through 11 I'm to approve second okay Shay uh second by Murray second reading and W the second reading um and can I get a just all in favor I I I I any opposed okay uh motion passes 5- Z okay now come to item 12 yes uh 9323 point2 actions by the board um trusty Richardson could you please propose 183 we discussed that uh the board actions uh and I wanted to add that um should there be board uh it says it is essentially says that there should be uh that there's if

135there's a violation uh applicable in the government code provision that there should be um a c something to cure the situation and I wanted to add that um that uh should there be a violation that the Board needs to um repeat the vote and the person or person's in violation of policy should not vote the second time and so that's the change I would like to see in this policy to uh uh to to in essence a remedy for voting against policy she current now you are current you probably want to take a look at the proposed one okay well it doesn't matter this it's the same one it's slightly different this is the proposed one that was the proposed but I also but what I wanted to include was what I just mentioned that

136should there be um so the way this proposed section I think reads right now is challenging board actions before seeking to file a civil action to stop or prevent a brown act violation or to invalidate a prior action taken by the board the District Attorney's office or interested person shall first present a demand to cure and correct the alleged violation to the district so you're saying that we should hold our own vote before the district attorney makes a demand to cure and correct no in order to cure the situation or remedy before it goes to an attorney it does not have to go to an attorney we can handle it on our own but we have to acknowledge those that made the policy error and in in so doing those uh ones that voted for

137the will not be allowed to vote on the second uh at the second time so in other words repeat the vote without the the ones who violated the policy and eliminate those from the vote so you would not bring this to the district attorney's office that the attorneys uh recommend on this one that uh before it gets to that point we can remedy the situation it doesn't that because the district receives a proper demand from The District Attorney office civil action to stop a prevent a brown act violation or invalidate a prior action taken by the board the District Attorney's office before see it says before our interested person shall first present a demand to cure and correct the alleged violation to the district and I'm saying I need to add that language you need

138to add what language okay it's sounds like should there be okay go ahead should there be a violation of policy and there's a vote and there's a an objection then the vote needs to be if it's a violation of the policy then it has to be the vote has to be repeated and those voting will be eliminated in the vote in the second round vot you're proposing the solution of how we correct Brown act or uh or uh Brown act or what's the other one uh policy trusty Richardson I understand what you're saying or I think I do I think you're saying that you believe that the Cure and correct solution would be to take a revote with two people or whoever was involved that you felt was in violation of this but this board

139policy is saying that the District Attorney's office or interested person shall first present a demand to cure and correct the elagent violation to the district if they receive a proper demand the board shall consult with legal counsel on if and how to respond as provided by law and so you're saying that we should just decide what we're going to do without consulting with Leal Council exactly I do not agree with that that's the spirit of this of this law is that and ethically actually it's ethical training that you're you're jumping to what you think that the legal council should advise us to do but this policy says is for us we're reasonable people we could figure out whether or not we violated a policy okay um do I have a motion to include language that

140instructs us to take a revote as the first course of action to cure and correct as part of this policy violation of policy or brown act violation okay those two before it goes to that right so can I get a motion to include the language that in the case of a brown act violation or a violation of policy that the district take a revote as a solution of cure and correct the alleged VI to cure and correct the alleged violation before referring to the district attorney's office correct can I get a motion so can I get a second okay motion fails no second can I get a motion you have to go to the uh district attorney and then wait for whatever you can present a demand to cure an interest interested person can present

141a demand to cure the alleged violation to the district that's what it says yeah and that's and the remedy to and the remedy would be decided upon after the board shall consult with legal council on if and how to respond as provided by law yeah but you know this is if I could jump in like I I mean I don't agree with I don't personally agree with like in the language that you're proposing simply because like in the policy it does talk about Consulting legal counsel about the remedy I mean I think you know this are we don't know what scenarios may happen in the future so I think it's always best to just consult with legal council if this certain situation like this for a Consulting of legal counsel and it hasn't happened and

142I haven't had a chance to take that I make a motion um so okay um I've had uh occasion where the motion failed we will move on thank you can I get a motion to approve the policy as written make that motion I second okay first by trusty Murray second by trusty Shay I uh can we get all in favor say I I I any opposed oppos all right motion carries 41 for item 12 moving on to 2A Educational Services approval of agreement with the Bay Area writing project ba awp for the 20242 25 school year staff recommends the approval of an agreement with the Bay Area writing project in baen high school for professional development sessions for the 2024 2025 school year can I get a motion second thank you uh first by truste

143Murray second by trusty Shay any comments or questions all in favor I I I any opposed motion carries 5 Z 2 B approval of agreement with Unbound Ed learning Inc and participation in the 2025 math adoption workshops staff recommends the approval of agreement with unbounded learning and the participation in the 2025 math adoption Workshop series can I get a motion so second first by Murray second by Shay any questions or comments okay uh all in favor I any opposed okay motion carries 0 approval of agreement with welum for the 2024 2025 school year staff recommends the approval of agreement with welum for special education staffing needs for the 2024 2025 school year can I get a motion so move okay first by trusty Shay second by trusty Murray any questions or comments all right all

144in favor I I any opposed okay motion carries 5 Human Resources 3A provisional internship permit for social science teachers at Parkway Heights Middle School staff recommends the approval of pip of the PIP oh that's why we were confused about pip earlier trusty Shay um the approval of the PIP for social science teachers at phms for the 2024 2025 school year as presented to the board can I get a motion so can I get a second okay first by trusty Shay second by vice president Murray any comments or questions all in favor I I any opposed all right motion carries 5 Z Human Resources 3B approval of the Merit District classification and compensation study proposal from Gallagher cof and Association Associates staff recommends the approval of the Gallagher cof and Associates proposal to conduct a classroom

145and conf classification and compensation study for the South San Francisco Unified School District through June 30th 2026 as presented to the board can I get a motion so Mo can I get a second a second okay first by Murray second by lamb any questions or comments on this item I have a question and I didn't ask this before is this the same as the Ying study that was done a few years back but vice president R yes you youing and uh although I was not here I am told that Ying had previously conducted the last classification and compensation study and that was during 2016 2017 thank you okay I also had questions and I i' asked but just for the sake of the public um just uh could you briefly walk through um I guess

146when how frequently we do these studies um and some of the basic reason why we're doing it now and then um why we chose um Gallagher cof specifically over the other rfps that we received sure thing uh so it's recommended best practice that Merit districts of which South San Francisco Unified School District uh is a merit District should conduct the classification compensation study minimally every five years uh according to District records as I just shared the last classification compensation study was conducted 201617 which puts us at almost uh eight years out um prior to that according to District records the last study was conducted in 20201 it happens to co inside at a time when we've passed a strategic plan and we think about the uh sustainability of our Workforce our Educators including but not

147limited to classified Personnel so uh your other question was related to criteria so I did include in the board packet a copy of not only our proposal uh excuse me Gallagher's proposal but also our RFP we went through an RFP process as a standard practice and all the criteria that we used uh is public facing on our website and is also enclosed in that packet thank you you're welcome thank you for your questions Jesse lamb any other questions or comments okay all in favor I I I any osed okay TR motion carries 5 z um I'm going to keep doing it this way but next time I will switch it up and start with comments uh and then do the motion later but just so you guys know um I'm G to keep opening the

148motion and discussing uh 3C approval of theou with the sou San Francisco classroom Teachers Association SS sfcta for the elementary site science site leader teacher for the 2024 2025 school year can I staff recommends the approval of the memorandum of understanding with the South San Francisco classroom Teachers Association for the elementary site science Lead Teacher for the 2024 2025 school year as presented to the board can I get a motion second all right first by trusty Murray second by trusty Shay any questions or comments on this item okay all in favor I I any opposed all right motion carries 5 Z 3D approval of theou with the South San Francisco classroom Teachers Association s sfcta for the special education education specialist sign on bonus for the 2025 2026 school year staff recommends the approval of

149the memorandum of understanding with the South San Francisco classroom Teachers Association for the special education education specialist sign on bonus for the 2025 2026 school year as presented to the board can I get a motion so move second first by truste Murray second by trusty lamb do we have any questions or comments all right all in favor so I any opposed all right motion carries 5 Zer 3E approval of agreement with Sun Belt Staffing LLC staff recommends the approval of agreement with Sunbelt Staffing LLC to support the South San Francisco Unified School District for staffing needs with certificated and classified substitutes the 2024 2025 2025 2026 and 2026 2027 school years can I get a motion so move can I get a second second all right uh first by trusty Shay second by trusty Murray

150any questions or comments on this item okay all in favor I I any opposed all right motion carries 5 Z 3F approval of agreement with Robert haer recruiters um I see that in this agenda it's spelled wrong sorry um and employment agency for 2024 2025 staff recommends the approval of the agreement between the South San Francisco Unified School District and Robert Half recruiters and employment agency for 2024 2025 as presented to the board can I get a motion so moved thank you trusty lamb second second trusty Shay so first by trusty lamb second by trusty Shay any questions or comments all right uh all in favor I any opposed all right motion carries 5 Z 3G man you really killing us tonight approval of theou with the South San Francisco classroom Teachers Association ssf CTA

151for the guided language acquisition design glad for the 2020 uh 4 2025 school year staff recommends the approval of the memorandum of understanding with the South San Francisco classroom Teachers Association for the guided language acquisition glad cohort for the 2024 2025 school year as presented to the board can I get a motion shall move second all right first by trusty Murray second by trusty Shay any comments or questions okay all in favor I I I any opposed motion carries 5- Z all right moving on to business services Business Services a um acceptance of notice of completion for the HVAC replacement and re-roofing project number 424 at benen High School staff recommends the acceptance for the HVAC replacement and re-roofing at baen high school project uh number four Z number 0424 as complete and ratify staff's

152action to file the notice of completion can I get a motion so moved second trusty Lamb with the first trusty Shay with the second any questions or comments all right all in favor I any opposed okay motion carries 5 Z 4B Business Services approval of pro of Proposal with Hy Architects for the HVAC replacement project at Skyline Elementary School staff recommends the approval of Proposal with Hy Architects for architectural and Engineering Services for the Skyline Elementary School HVAC replacement project in the amount of $124,000 as presented to to the board can I get a motion trusty Richardson second trusty Shay um any questions or comments all right all in favor I I I any opposed all right 5- Z motion carries C approval of Proposal with dsk Architects for the security gate project at Spruce

153Elementary School staff recommends the appro the approval of Proposal with dsk Architects for architectural services for the spruce elementary school security gate project in the amount of $59,000 as presented to the board can I get a motion so move Dr Shay second second trusty lamb any questions or comments on this security gate project I have a comment uh I was just at Spruce on Tuesday dropping off some stuff before the daac meeting and I think this is a really good project super glad to hear that we're doing it yeah any other comments trusty lamb you have something say Okay um all in favor I I any opposed all right motion carries 5 Z 4D Business Services approval of Proposal with Plum Architects Inc for the architectural and Engineering Services for the temporary Central Kitchen meal

154program support space staff recommends the approval of Proposal with Plum Architects Inc for architectural and Engineering Services for the temporary Central kinin meal program support Space Project in the amount of $7,500 as presented to the board can I get a motion so move second all right first by trusty Murray second by trusty Shay any comments or questions on this I mean I did ask uh some questions ahead and I actually appreciate these explanation yeah so uh could I know it's a little difficult Mr O being out sick but if someone could summarize briefly um how uh this particular project uh fits in with the uh the ren Kitchen renov yes we actually have director Shelton who I believe is with us so she can respond to that Wonder thank you I'd like to uh suggest

155that we um agendize uh for the board parliamentary procedure and or oh we're talking who we talking thank you ch Richardson that is a topic that we can address at the end of this meeting um right now we are discussing approval of Proposal with Plum Architects Dr Shelton M Shelton could you can't hear you because you're not talking directly to your mic good evening uh this is director Shelton um and I if I could request um a repeat of the question I'm sorry I I trusty lamb sure I I just just wanted to hear maybe a brief explanation about how this particular project um which my understanding is like a kind of a a smaller staging area for um what should I say well maybe you should just explain that how does this project fit

156in with the uh renovation of the kitchen the Central Kitchen uh great question so um as you're aware we are renovating the Central Kitchen at El Camino High School um and during that time um the kitchen will be completely closed um so we had to figure out what we were going to do um in order to feed the the students uh so we investigated um preparing um a temporary kitchen adjacent to the existing Central Kitchen um unfortunately due to the amount of space and the uh cost it was prohibitive uh to do that uh where we initially um did wanted to do and then we did not have an alternate location um where we could uh create a temporary kitchen so what we decided to do was invest in a third-party food vendor um that

157could provide meals during the construction period part of what was determined between the bomb program and the uh student nutrition uh Department was that we wanted to be able to also uh retain our um staff so uh part of the staff will be uh housed at the district um offices Warehouse that will bring in um certain services like milk and fruit and then break those down and redistribute them out so we we um are just creating a space to enable this uh part of the process to continue uh and in addition we'll have that third- party food vendor so it was a long iterative uh process excuse me um to uh ensure that we could continue to um feed our students thank you director Shelton and I I appreciate um you know the business services

158look into all the different um options and um and this does seem like the most um uh cost effective efficient route so um thank you you're welcome um I I think trusty lamb another question that you had asked that was really good was um what is the cycle for uh soliciting a third party vendor Dr director Shelton what's what is what is our timeline for selecting a thirdparty vendor she still there I'm still here but I believe director Chan should be um yes uh good evening um this is director Chan um the timeline for selecting a vendor um but on our RFP schedule um the proposers uh the deadline to submit the proposal is on February 7th and um we are expecting to make a decision after that and um we are looking to um

159uh get an approval by the board on March 13 um so this is our timeline super thank you so much Mr Shan thank you all right we have a motion open to approve can I get all in favor I any opposed all right motion carries 5 Z moving on to review of future agenda items and meetings trusty Richardson what we're at the review of future agenda items and meetings it sounded like you had a request earlier future item yeah um I'd like to request that the board uh receive parliamentary procedure training um and I would like to see if we could arrange for that and or brown act uh again we've had uh I've had some requests or offers from the dwk um firm and they've uh offered to take on um but I don't

160know if it's passed training for board for uh Brown a violations I believe every year we should all take that again as a refresher and uh what is the other one uh oh and parliamentary procedure so that the board understands how to follow follow a meeting and so we're on the same page sometimes it seems like we're not I I can't follow some of these because I think we're not following procedure okay thank you should thank you cheste Richardson so what I hear you requesting is you want a training for the school board on the brown act or parliamentary procedures and yeah both okay Brown act and parliamentary procedures is that the pleasure of the board for me to schedule look for a time to schedule a training for you all no I would say

161no on Brown act I took the training last year I mean we can do it at the conference if we want to they always offer it we could include parliamentary procedure in the special meeting board Workshop the good Beginnings just to go over that errors okay if we're comfortable with the proposal we could include parliamentary procedures at the special board Workshop yeah can be part of the workshop you could there is online offerings no I don't think we're talking about an online offering would the rest of the board yeah would the rest of the board be open to that idea have it it review at the board Workshop sure yes okay I will make sure I work is capable end of that on that thank you all right thank you summary of board directives there

162are none all right thank you good and Welfare we have five minutes comments anything I hope everybody only five minutes so keep it quick I mean otherwise we have to take a 10-minute break and this is just for fun stuff everybody I hope everybody has a great period in between meetings and whenever just in general I hope that everybody has a wonderful time what was agreed upon we are on good and Welfare comments from board members and superintendent prior to that what did we agree upon for uh future it that we would not have one for brown act and that we would have a we would include it in our topics for the special meeting board Workshop parliamentary procedure oh you were you are going to have a special meeting on that it will be

163included in the May 10th special meeting board Workshop special meeting Workshop when is that we have a special meeting board workshop on May 10th called the good Beginnings board workshop and we will include it as a topic trusty lamb anything quickly happy lunar new yearor uh I I did want to mention I'll be at the uh South San Francisco celebration this coming Saturday but uh you know Lunar New Year goes on for you know the 29th and then two weeks or more so uh please enjoy the holiday season what time is the city thing uh I believe it's it starts at 10 o'clock 10: a.m. and I think there will be a night market on February 7th oh yes yeah that's right all right trusty Richardson anything for good and Welfare we got two minutes

164I I'll do it in a minute uh microphone talk in the microphone you yeah okay so I went to uh yesterday I went to the budget perspective uh workshop and the budget looks pretty good so so they were worried about it but there'll be funding for all the programs um and it was very enlightening and then uh before then I went to a Workforce housing education Workforce Workshop number one uh it was a uh Zoom call but it was very informative but uh I will not be able to attend the second uh cohort because I'll be going to San Diego with a delegation of about 16 members of our community our school community so it just happened to bump together and so uh after that uh I also in like last week we had occasion

165to visit uh South San Francisco high school and we visited some of the video technology programs I uh and uh we found out what the kids are doing you pass those and those are the products of what the kids are doing I I shared a uh live in the On Demand is a uh a program that is sponsored by the students and uh you're welcome to look into it on their daily um programs that they show everybody uh the whole school is um and it was pretty exciting to see and just right after the intrud intruder uh was um it was fresh in the people's the students minds and and uh it was great to see how resilient our students and teachers are so um well coordinated and uh you know very uh alert on

166who comes into campus and I was happy to see that I also visited the uh trusty Richardson we were gonna have to take a break if you're going to keep going we got to take a break if you're going to keep going otherwise I'm gonna adjourn well I'm not finished yet okay so we're gonna adjourn for 10 minutes for a break for our captioner we we have to take a break for the captioner like now if we're gonna take a break if we're GNA keep going oh okay do you want us to take a break and then finish this okay so oh I see I didn't know that uh you should you should say that I did all right thank you I also had the to attend the PTA uh 17th District superintendence lunch and

167it was lovely our ptas are amazing keep up the good work um and with that thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.