001oh [Music] a [Music] a [Music] oh [Music] n [Music] [Applause] [Music] n [Music] [Applause] n [Applause] [Music] a [Music] [Applause] n [Music] [Applause] n [Applause] [Music] [Applause] n [Music] n [Music] [Applause] [Music] a [Music] n [Music] n [Music] a [Music] [Applause] [Music] he [Music] pap PA [Music] PA [Music] la n [Music] [Applause] [Music] pap [Music] PA n [Music] now [Music] oh [Music] n [Music] a [Music] n [Music] [Applause] [Music] a [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] a [Music] oh [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] it was nice it was all right I want to go ahead and call today's meeting to order at 8: a.m. and moving to 1.2 roll call the re the Christina will read the language under public content in order to help Assurance compliance with the brown act and in order to make
002our board meetings more effective and more efficient trustees will speak only when recognized and trustees who speak on a topic other than the agenda item currently under consideration will be out of order board meeting protocols the safety and the decorum of the school board meetings are important to Stockton Unified School District and the community SD promotes the Public's right to free speech and we and we want to make sure that all community members parents and students are able to participate in a safe environment we want to ensure all community members have a seat during the board meeting we will have the maximum number of chairs allowed per fire code 132 we ask that the members of the puup do not stand along the side of the walls or block the walkway anyone standing up during
003a meeting will be asked to take a seat if they do not comply they will be asked to leave an accredited news media representative who is standing will have a press pass credential clearly visible there is a Podium position in front of the first row of chairs no one other than the person who is speaking may be at the podium except for a guardian administrator or translator for safe people may not line up behind the speaker to wait their turn we want to give the person at the podium the time and respect they deserve each speaker will be allowed 3 minutes attendees are not allowed to enter the area past the podium where the board members are sitting no profanity or obscenity during the board meeting if there is a disruption the board president or
004designate will give the verbal warning to the person or persons causing the disruption if the disruption continues after the verbal warning the individual will be asked to leave or be removed from the premises for the remainder of the board meeting after the meeting is concluded we ask Community to clear the lobby area in a respectful manner thank you 1.2 roll call President Kena Stevens vice president Sophia colone clerk Donald Dair presid truste Angeline Flores trustee is Isabelle Perez trusty Frank Silva pres trustee shaa priest pres thank you all right item 1.3 Pledge of Allegiance could we all rise to flag of the United States of stand God indivisible andice for all you may be seated item 1 point4 oral suggestions and comments from the community regarding current agenda items only evet will announce the number
005of public comments and request each person to provide their public comment in the order they were received in Abby will be the timekeeper thank you madam president there are no comments today under agenda item 1.4 back to you thank you item 2.1 Stockton Unified School Board of Education Workshop effective governance New Beginnings facilitated by Mr Robert Bob kanaine California school board's Association consultant csba is that my Q all right well good morning everyone good morning uh just delighted to be here um a lot going on in our world in our country and our state and uh it's so important that we take the time to focus on what's really important and that's the education of all of the students in your District so thanks for your com I know Angel Anne wanted to be here
006I had a great conversation with her and unfortunately she's not well but um she voiced her interest in really serving out the terms she has remaining as pos positive as possible in terms of those responsibilities so she's was one of I think all of you mentioned your goal of wanting to work as a team um with the superintendent so that's uh you're all off on a a great start regarding that do I need to get closer Christina okay feels like I'm doing a radio show or something good morning Vietnam comes to mine the movie um let's see um I also uh I want to introduce um Chris Norwood um he is our member of the public today um Chris I'm just going to have you introduce yourself uh a little bit but we are colleagues
007friends um we are teaching classes together for cspa called Masters in governance and uh and Chris wants to do this kind of work working with school districts and school boards next year and following so um he's here to observe um our our supervisor has encouraged him not to speak which will be a huge difficulty for Chris but uh uh you know he's now a member of the public so he knows uh I it's up to him to the level of his participation so but Chris introduce yourself please good morning everyone my name is Chris Norwood I am uh in addition to being a um a member of the CB csba team I am a board member in the mpus Unified School District I'm currently the board president I have been board president for the last
00810 years excuse me I've been board president for the last year I've been board president four times vice president three times and board clerk two times so I'm excited to be here with you all to listen and learn thank you Chris um well let's um you can open up your fold folders and on the left side of your folder you'll see an agenda for our time together um we are scheduled from 8 till 11 so we will uh end at 11 o'clock um I'm going to take us through as many activities as possible during that time um it's based on kind of what I hope we'll be able to share with you is maybe the top 75% of what you need to know as a trustee I'm working as a member of a governance team
009so um that's our goal the page just behind that is a QR code and uh I have uh there'll be time at about 10 minutes to 11 for you to just fill out the servy monkey uh about your perceptions and comments about the session today so um we'll schedule that uh towards the end and uh just in terms of looking at the agenda you can see the major goals this this Workshop is number two in a series of four um in October I think it was came over and met with the uh leadership team and we kind of laid out a plan to provide uh orientation for new trustees effective governance New Beginnings as well as uh schedule the superintendent's evaluation and so um session today is is number two session three will be on
010March 1st and at that time uh superintendent Rodriguez will um do a self- evaluation updating all of you on her progress so far on the goals and objectives that have been set um looking forward then to uh her evaluation has to be completed according to her contract that you all the the district signed uh with her um that would be concluded in July so we'll look forward to coming back together in July and focusing on that process and we'll talk briefly about what's involved with that uh before we finish today yes absolutely absolutely so um csba it's called the California school boards Association it's been around for about 75 years um it is the organization for school districts and school boards um in California um it's uh a nonprofit organization uh Vernon Billy is the
011CEO he's been the CEO for about 15 years um very a a fine leader and uh and there's a the SI the the organization set up so that they're delegates from all over the state that are part of what's called delegate assembly they make major decisions for csba so it's a opportunity for leadership for uh Schoolboard members around the state to be involved in that um there um board members are president vice president um uh so there's an executive committee as well that works um with Vernon Billy um I've got some materials uh that we'll comment on later they're on the corner um there are just various programs and trainings that are available if you're you're interested so um csba uh of has maybe eight different departments one of them is the trainings department and
012that includes all the orientation for new trustees the ethics training um and it includes Masters in governance which is a five-day course for board members and superintendents um so it's a uh offers a lot of opportunities as well as what's called governance consultant services so that's a workshop that that we're having today where csba arrang for a consultant to go out into the districts and work with the governance team and so this is a it's a very different kind of a board meeting because you get to talk to each other a lot and so um you'll notice I don't have PowerPoint because I think workshops like this should be conversations where you're having conversations with each other getting to know each other better and really planning how you can be effective so does that kind
013of answer your question canthan thank you so um if you look at the goals um we have four goals today one is to uh work on developing an effective governance team csba defines a governance team as the superintendent and and all of the board members you have a challenge in your District because most of the districts in the state have five member boards and you can see with five members of a board and the superintendent that's six people um if you drew lines in terms of the onetoone relationships within a group of six there's 15 different onetoone relationships which is when you realize that's a lot so if there's one relationship that that's not very good it can influence the whole team with seven member board and the superintendent you have eight total and it
014almost doubles the number of one toone interactions goes to 28 so the challenge for all of you is to uh continue to may have good relationships with each other as well as with the superintendent and that's a big task when you just look at uh 28 different onetoone relationships so it highlights the importance of meetings like this um let me just start you know I think uh we will definitely review the components of effective governance system I'm going to have Chris uh help me with that a little bit even though he's not supposed to no I'm just kidding um we're going to identify the key roles of the board and the superintendent and we're going to look at what are the major decisions you're going to make between now and uh the beginning of the
015next school year so it's a lot on the agenda but I and I I want this to be intera active too so we'll we're going to start out actually um talking about um why we're all here and so um I'm I'm going to start with a story about students uh kids um our our family sherles and I uh took care of our grandson from zero to five uh before he went to kindergarten during the day and so Shirley was a retired uh preschool teacher and director of 30 years and so around our house we had a science center we had a library we had an art center you know we had a water table outside and so he he had some advantages uh in in our house but one day he was painting at the
016easel and he had blue and yellow and he was painting along and he started mixing the colors and all of a sudden this beautiful shade of green evolves and um I said Christopher is really unique and he says Grandpop I'm starting a new chapter in my life so four years old and he's giving me quotes uh so in a way anytime you have a new superintendent or new board members you're writing a new chapter you the chap last chapter ended now you have the opportunity to write your own chapter so um we learn from the past but we deal with the present and then plan for for the best future possible so uh I hope this is a good start for this uh this chapter um we're going to uh just I want to say
017a word about who I am um uh I'm Bob Kain um if somebody calls me Robert it's a cold call um and I am delighted to be here my entire career was in the kield school district which is north of sandraf fell uh south of Sandell and north of the Golden Gate Bridge um I uh uh I loved what I did I actually started as a crossing guard and uh after school sports coach and became a student teacher and teacher and principal assistant superintendent and I was superintendent there for 29 years I always told parents kindergarten parents that going from crossing guard to superintendent is a lateral move and if you really believe that every person in the district has an equal value in terms of what they contribute there's a lot of Truth in
018that statement so 25 years ago cspa called and said Bob would you willing be willing to be one of the trainers for the new Masters in governance program so I helped develop and uh have been working in that program for years um one of our Consultants about 10 years ago uh found she had cancer and had to retire early and so all of a sudden there were number of districts that needed uh Consultants to do workshops so I started doing a number of those and uh I just really loved doing it so um as an example um I play golf with uh some folks in in a live in a retirement committee for part of the year and they I'm missing golf today and they say so why why are you going to Stockton when
019you could play golf and so uh I am my title is a consultant but why am I doing this um I just think this is the most important work in the world um there's you know no better thing to do than to really think about what's best for each and every student in your district and we have six million 5.8 million students in California huge responsibility when you think about it and I know you have a number of students in your district will talk about that a little bit later so um I'm here because this is is so valuable and I think I our goal is to really uh help you be as productive as possible and influence student achievement in a positive way so I'm going to uh be able to share with you
020some some ideas and Concepts that I think will be really helpful for that so um any questions about the agenda um all right well let's start with um why you are here so I would like you to just take a couple minutes make a couple notes like maybe two or three reasons where where people say why why are you a member of the governing team why your what is your board member but why what's behind you're wanting to be a trustee e e okay another minute f okay let's uh let's start with Donald lucky you Donald you just have to be first in in the row here so uh uh share a little bit why why you're a board member good morning everyone oops so I wrote some reasons down here the first one being
021I wanted to help the district move forward after the covid uh pandemic shutdowns I also wanted to protect and support ethnic studies diversity Equity inclusion um and I also wanted to increase uh safety and budget transparency and accountability thank you Don K for me I'm a mom and an advocate for social justice uh and high quality education for me it was is about ensuring that every student has um access to a high quality education that leads them into a bright future um supporting education and making sure that our students have what they need it helps them to be College and Career Readiness um so that they can live out um their hopes and dreams for a bright future great thanks Kena Sophia not as fast as my staff so got do this so you got
022otherwise I'm not going to get it all okay for myself um I just wrote down some I'll just read exactly what I wrote down just wait one second we'll later catch up okay okay all right okay supporting databased decision making Hometown Pride and this is a longer sentence so Stockton succeeds when the education for children has a strong foundation so as you're finishing up there um altogether I feel like U I'm here because I'm from Stockton my familyes from Stockton and I'm also a product of SSD so uh I wanted to the reason why I stepped up to this seat is because I wanted to make sure that decisions we were making were rooted in some fact some ba Based on data um that there was a strong reason why we're making changes the way
023we were and I want to see our our overall City succeed great all right shaa priest it's everybody calls me priest only my mom calls me shaa oh is that right okay priest um one of my main reasons was for our students to be able to see their potential reflected on our school board being a product of susd being born and raised in the area now that I represent and rais my own family in was something that was truly important to me like cologne said about our just our Hometown Pride um and one of the most important reasons was for me to be able to bring an educator lens to the school board I felt that was something that we didn't have um so now being able to come from a lens of a teacher
024and administrator and being able to uh reflect that back on our district um is truly important to me great thank you priest Frank thank you yes first and foremost I wanted to be an advocate for the students and and ADV voice and make sure that you know positive things get done for the children I mean hopefully we can make a positive difference in the schools and our community surrounds them our whole city as a whole and then of course the safety of the students definitely the safety of the students because we have way too much stuff going on that shouldn't be I mean I don't know the full extent of what's being going on to counter you know to do something about it but I don't know I'd like to be a part of whatever
025it is and just basically write the wrongs that the board has done in the previous years all the chaos and Anarchy that's been going on so to speak get us all unified and you know even if we don't all agree on everything but at least be unified in our decision- making for the school and know kids so you don't want to repeat the previous chapter definitely not no no nothing against the you know ones that are here still but yeah but yeah okay Isabel pH is my mic on not yet ahead and do this one thank you thank you that's good huh okay um well I I was an underserved student and I had a lot of issues I was in the Foster system and had parents that um were drug addicts in and out
026of prison and things like that and I had a really hard I'm in school um and a lot of the school staff and principal and just administrative staff helped me through a lot of my hard times and um led me to a successful future and that is really why I joined the school board because I had that and I want to make sure that other underserved students and teachers have the support services and resources they need um to help students that need the extra push and need the extra help great thank you Iselle it's great great story superintendent Rodriguez what tell us about yours yeah so I would say I um I believe that education is I believe that education is the great equalizer and so my hope is that we truly impact the lives
027of students families and our community and that we leave Stockton um a better place than great so what what we like to do is um as she's finishing up putting up a couple notes uh for herself um kind of think about the things were said and um um are there kind of some themes that you think you know are have threads that run through everybody's uh wise um just any anybody want to comment one is that we all decided that we wanted to be an advocate both for Education the protection of education and also to advocate for students okay clear efficacy role okay others other themes that you see I also think there's a theme of um collaboration us willing to work together to kind of come up with best strategies and ideas for our
028communities MH collaboration yes uh I see a theme of change big bur change change a theme of change everybody wants to see a positive change great I sense a a care and love for the city of Stockton okay a real care and love for the city of Stockton and decisions based on data um not emotion and personalities it's interesting in the Chinese language that wisdom is a combination of two concepts knowledge and heart and so um it's a you know data and and how we kind of deal with everything uh are really really important Concepts we'll switch back all right any other um it was just great hearing you know I interviewed each of you uh except priests but um very interested in in your your kind of backgrounds where you come from and how
029you've gotten to where you are at this point um and I think it's it having that hearing where other people are coming from I think is really helpful in understanding the people that we're working with so I hope you found that to be uh uh positive postive um let's uh um let's look at uh on the right side of your materials there's a a 10-page study on the Iowa School uh Iowa uh Lighthouse study so I thought I would read all 10 pages no I'm not going to read all 10 pages um I'm going to have you actually flip it over on the back side and you can read the 10 pages on your your own but um I think the lighthouse study uh was a 15-year study and they decided to look at what
030are the characteristics of successful school districts what what is consistent from District to District irrespective of the demographics and so they looked at systems around the country um in several phases and what they came up with is that there are five characteristics that are similar in all of these high performing districts and I'll just briefly go over and then we're going to discuss them um the first one is um you set clear expectations it's really clear in the district what your priorities are what are your what's your vision what's your mission what are the specific goals that you've decided to work on on a district you can't do everything when you do everything you sometimes don't get anything done so how do you set clear and high expectations not only for students staff and superintendent
031and and Schoolboard um so setting clear expectations very clear uh important one now creating conditions for success is the second one and that means the board says to the superintendent this is where we want to go what do you need from us to make that successful well how can we support you to make that successful then the superintendent goes to the principles and says to the principles what do you this is where we want to go what do you need from me to make you successful as a principal and the principles ask the teachers what do you need to be successful and teachers even ask the students what a concept what do you need to be successful so the system is built on a success model you people constantly finding out how can we be
032successful doing what we're doing the third characteristic is really tied to the first one because if you set clear and high expectations and you don't follow through on it probably nothing happens so you have to hold the system accountable to the expectations and so you do that through following through being really clear about how you're going to determine success success indicators that will give you the data necessary to make other decisions in terms of continuous Improvement the fourth one is a little more vague it's called build Collective will and in that one uh it's it's uh kind of building a sense that this is not a 10year plan we have students in in their seats on Monday morning this is this is something that we really need to do and we need to kind of
033provide some momentum to convey to others that this is something that it's we we really can change it's possible and it's within our hands the fifth characteristic is that the board and superintendent learn together as a team there's all kinds of opportunities where you're studying a topic where you're reviewing information data you're uh you know for example attending the annual conference together you're doing things as a group that really Foster a sense of team and you know that's we found that successful everywhere we go in terms of uh of the teamwork so um the way to think about this is that um see we have two um let's I'm gonna actually I'm involve Chris you want to be involved I know you are um we need another person so um what I'd like you to
034do I'm going to divide these into four groups and so um Frank and Isabelle you'll look at setting clear expectations um priest and Sophia will look at creating conditions for success knth and Donald will look at hold the system accountable and Michelle and and Chris will look at build a collective will so here's what what what I want you to do when you're talking about it see the ab CDs and all of those put a dollar sign next to the ones that cost more money and then if they don't cost more money what would it take to implement that okay so take a few minutes talk to your partner and talk about what's take about five minutes to uh to talk and then we'll talk about together your number one they're not necessarily money related
035none of them I don't think any of these cost money no we're just I mean creating an awareness the need and urgencies data experiences experiences to change belief to change expectations so I think this Collective world is all about that self eacy one of and if not what do they take I say time connection I agree that's abely know quity difference people good think how do M another minute or so and then we'll have uh each group report out on your discussion stories okay let's uh uh come back together so for each of these we wanted we were thinking about which ones would actually cost more money and if they don't cost more money what keeps us from doing those things if that's something we want to do so Frank and Isabelle can you share
036what you've uh what you've talked about can you why Frank I guess Frank gets to report out because he has microphone that works well basically we think that D would probably the focused on student learning and teaching and improving the teaching as a key strategy as a key strategy for improving learning that I did press the butt yeah I told him I talk low yeah okay this better okay say that again Frank so we everybody can hear it um we chose D focus on student learning and teaching to improving the teaching and key strategy for improving great would that cost more money well we think so because you know cost for training you know teachers and the tools if they need to be able to I don't want oh my oh being recorded Isabelle think
037okay we feel that D um would cost the most is it off is it off okay we feel that D would cost the most because um we would need to provide the necessary tools for the teachers to be successful in uh student learning and teaching and relationships so tools management tools resources Support Services anything that the teachers feel they need um to be able to accomplish this and then you look at the other three they really don't necessarily cost more money do they so they could cost they could cost cuz we kind of went over everything there are costs for those things if you if you're really trying to organize that type of system but not as much as D okay great thank you okay all right uh group two priest and Sophia all right
038so we discussed um we chatted over all of them and we determined that BNF would cost us the most money um in a sense to make sure those things were uh done correctly and really had some quality um but we also discuss um our other ones as far as time and time itself is money in a sense uh being able to juggle different things but those things are still just as important as those things that we would be spending funds on to create so it's a combination of of mindset kind of changes and also uh Financial cost potentially okay uh group three um president Stephen and I discuss that a can you'all hear me uh we discuss that A and C um have the most costs um the data um that we use will be
039coming from things like safety infrastructure curriculum assessments Transportation Etc and then for C monitoring the progress will require staff and Personnel so thinking about Dr Murphy's team with um research and data all right very good group four so we we were building off of what truste priest was saying which is um sometimes um the highest commodity is time and not necessarily funds um and how so for our number four for build Collective will it was around um high quality time that builds that connection and sometimes there is a cost because we're bringing in an outside support or we're going to a conference or something like that but really when it you boil down to it it's how do you create those safe spaces where people are able to make that connection and spend um allocate
040that time to um build that Collective will great thank you excellent reports on all four so five characteristics one of the key Concepts that comes out of the lighthouse study is the the three words focused and functional and so you can see when you you think of this as you have to be very focused clear expectations you have to hold the system accountable um but also the the district is functioning together in terms of its priorities and so um one of the things the lighthouse study also found is that when the board and the governance team are focused and functional they model that for the rest of the system and whether it's uh staff groups or um negotiations or whatever you're modeling problem solving for the system and if they see at the top leadership
041top not focused and dysfunctional it gives them permission to act that way well the board acts that way why can't we and so you have a you have an impact on the Community Way Beyond probably what you realize in terms of of U of your ability to be model problem solvers now the other concept and we highlighted it the other three words is that doesn't mean you're uniform it means you're unified so there's a big difference it's you you all come from different backgrounds and perspectives and why you're here and and you will have different opinions about things but the most important thing is that you're talking to each other communicating problem solving um resolving conflicts that come up um use parliamentary procedure to have majority rule but the rights of each person to vote
042each person to express their opinion and each person to vote according to how they wish to vote so focused and functional unified not uniform themes that run through all of these starting with the lighthouse study uh before we leave the lighthouse study um this booklet you can see it's uh I've used it so much the covers are falling off I guess that's a sign that you're using something um but this is a this in 2017 csba did a exhaustive study of the conditions for student achievement that the school board can influence in the district and what districts need to do it's online it's uh called the school board role in creating conditions for student achievement it's about 40 pages on um there's two full pages on the lighthouse study itself so it's something there's always
043uh folks that are interested in educational research um this is a great document and some boards have there's eight chapters of four pages each some have taken a chapter a month and and and just discuss it um at the board meeting so um research can tell tells us a lot and I think uh the life house study is an exemplary example of describing the kinds of things that Schoolboard should do to positively influence student achievement okay well let's go we'll Turn the Page and you can uh put the lighthouse study aside I encourage you to read the whole thing at some point but um it's uh I wanted to really highlight the uh key characteristics so now we're going to look at the next page uh on the right side and uh it's the effective
044governance system and so um this is the uh one of the two best visuals that csba has because it really lays out what we are striving for in terms of being effective an effective governance and so and this I'm going ask Chris a question here so we like to use the analogy of an automobile and so an automobile is made up of a lot of components right so steering braking transmission um cooling cooling uh and so and there what maybe like 10 15 components and what happens if one of those component is not working Chris do you have an example of maybe that happening to you so driving this morning um I live in milus I make it right into Stockton and then soon as I make it into Stockton um my red battery light
045comes on in my car um I open up my uh manual and it says on the red battery light um something is wrong with your charging system um stop driving immediately and call your dealer so that's what I did um so my car is going to be towed in a little bit back to the other side but luckily Bob is going to give me a ride back but that's an example um where when the car is not working it doesn't work at all it doesn't work at all or or there it's actually it's just it's a war light that it may totally dysfunction it's GI you a warning yes that this is and it happens to be red yes yes so it gets your attention yes yeah great so it's a great example because uh
046you know an automobile we've all had trouble with one component or another um and so uh we're looking now we're going to look at the the components of effective governance system and so there are seven components and I'll start on the left side uh the rectangle says individual governance mindset so the first component of effective governance of effective governance system is individuals being aware of their own Effectiveness and we've over time over 25 years have identified eight characteristics of an effective trustee and also could be applied to an effective superintendent and to go through them quickly you're very mindful you're very mindful of who you are and how you operate and and you're you are aware of your own Effectiveness within the group um you're a systems thinker you realize that stockt and unified is
047a huge complex system and there's all these parts to it and to try to understand how this affects this and this affects that um that that you build that as a trustee don't don't sometimes just come in and say oh yeah I understand that unless you have other systems that you've been a part of and and uh in that that role uh the next two are kind of tied together preparation is basically preparing for Schoolboard meetings so you're really ready to make decisions as necessary you know you're asking questions ahead of time of a superintendent so if there needs to be more information that can be available at the meeting um so really preparing well now deep learning means that as in this new chapter of your life um you're going to be learning about
048some very important topics and and they keep coming at us all the time there there's always a new topic that we're have to deal with um but to understand that there's so much behind whether it's Personnel issues or or negotiations or student learning and achievement there's layers to all of this and so really being committed to that deep learning and as you know you get to I had an opportunity um to take uh Fifth and eighth graders back to Washington DC for 18 years and and we actually had a contact and met with Sandra Dale Connor who was the Justice at the time and she uh she said when the kids said so what's the toughest part of your job and she said I'm constantly reading I read I read and I read and so
049um that's you know that that's just a part of particular jobs where you just have to have a deep understanding of topics now strategic Focus um that really kind of talks about um the difference between working hard and working smart you don't possib you can't possibly read everything in the world and so you have to prioritize your time and energy to to be strategic about how you do that and so you apply that um to uh your work as a board member um you realize your manner and what who you project in terms of manner has a lot to do with what people know and think about you and so you probably see in the UCLA study of years ago that that 55% of all communication is is non-verbal and 35% is the tone of
050voice and seven percent are words so you realize that when you say something you're you're you're conveying a message of communication message that really is is multidimensional multi-dimensional so being aware of that and and as uh they say in the governance core another way of looking is managing your public manner I mean you know what you do in the confines of of your a h a room in your house you can probably say almost anything you want but it you just have to really be aware of how you're coming across in the public Arena uh commitment um you're all made a commitment you you uh took an oath of office to duely fulfill uh your responsibilities and uh and that with that commitment time comes time resources and energy now confidentiality is a difficult one
051i' I've got another uh grandson story so um uh he was outside playing with something and he drops it and he says damn and I said well Christopher you know that's not a word that we use I said where did you hear that he says my dad and so a week later something else happens he goes oh shoot and I said Christopher that's not a word that we use um you know where did you hear that he says I'm not supposed to tell you so confidentiality has to do with when people say tell us about X Y and Z and you had just have to say I'm not supposed to tell you you know so you know what happens usually in close sessions is almost totally confidential um and so effective trustees understand the importance
052of that um and and keeping that clear so those are eight characteristics of effective trustees um I'm going to skip over to the the green rectangle that's the team governance mindset and you see there's we you've all been members of teams and maybe you've been a part of a real successful team um good teams know their roles and responsibilities but there's a Unity of purpose to it and this is a really important concept because if you develop a Unity of purpose within your team it creates its own energy and so um again are are the famous Consultants Davis Campbell and Michael Fen um they introduce the concept that it's we it it's a moral imperative that we do this you have a choice to be dysfunctional and not do what's best for kids and that's
053happening places but they say no you don't have a choice you have the moral imperative is to work together because you're not arguing about how to build another Lego toy you're dealing with a kids education in their Futures and so I'm very strong that that the importance of of of that kind of approach to teamwork again unified but not uniform those next three are principles norms and Protocols are all part of how we treat each other the the principles are you know transparency good decision making deliberation Norms are how we treat each other we respect each other we build trust and last Protocols are how we work together and we'll talk a little about that when we just highlight some of the things that are in your draft uh Ban's handbook so that's the team
054and there's a board member from sanell he played uh professional football and he was a defensive back and he I he was taking one of our classes and he said well I have an example to share about that he said as a defensive back I know what my role is and my responsibility if I try to do somebody else's job on the defense the defense falls apart and so understanding your role and responsibility as a team member is important because you can't do somebody else's job you each seven of you have a vote and you you will exercise your vote um as superintendent your superintendent so um just to remember uh the importance of that so how do we go from the individual to the team and we call that the transition to collaborative Partnerships
055and that somehow we have we don't leave oursel behind we come with our issues and interests and all but we commit to be a member of a team what's involved with that and there are different ways that we we phrase that one is it's a transition from campaigning to governing when you're running for election it's all about this is what I'm going to do when I get you know we're going to work on this and this and this but all of a sudden you take the oath and now you're you're no longer a candidate now you're a governing team member so making that transition is sometimes a hard transition um and another way that we like to say it is it's it's it's going from I to we without losing me so you're making a
056commitment to have these relationships remember the onetoone relationships to maintain those are part of the team development so now we'll just look quickly at the purple one so you go to the grocery store Donald goes to grocery store and somebody says okay Donald you're on the board now you've been on for a couple years so what are our five respon what are your responsibilities and he says I know what they are what what are they Donald what are the five responsibilities go ahead set the direction strategic goals establish the structure creative supportive environment ensure accountability demonstrate Community leadership all right so you have those five fundamental responsibilities in all of these District functions Frank what are these District functions we'll read those off for us with the mic right up there I would be setting
057the district dire the district's Direction student achievement Finance facilities human resources policy judicial review collective bargaining community relations and advocacy all right there a lot of responsibilities you know how to really accent something when you do [Laughter] it okay great thank you so all of those areas that's amazing that's a big that's that's boards have responsibilities in all of those areas in terms of setting Direction establishing structure now look at the bottom line here current trends and issues in publication public education there's just a few of those aren't there you think of all the things that you deal with you read about in other school districts uh it's new legislation it's New Direction it's it's Federal it's state it's local um and so how do you you know you you can see the arrows going
058up they inform everything that we do now last but not least uh is the last component on the right side success for each and every student that used to say success for all students and we had some feedback from truste saying that kind of sounds too general you know can you be more specific and so the suggestion was it our primary goal should be success for each and every student it's kind of our North Star it's if you're doing all of these other components and that's not the focus you're probably wasting your time so um as an example uh do any of you have more than two children more than two children how many children do you have sopia five okay okay okay do you know Sophia didn't say oh I have about five so
059I have five five kids so um does anybody know how many kids are in the Stockton Unified School District pretty close the number that Christina gave me is 35 5,144 it's pretty close so the the point we make is that when you say if you really believe in success for each and every student shouldn't you know the number of kids in your district and it's just it's a message sent and so you know I think when people say well we have about 34,000 and of course that's success for all students if you really believe it's success for each and every student then it's 34,1 6 and so I think it's a the sometimes the language we use also sends a message in terms of that commitment so seven components um I'm going to ask you
060to uh see one two three four that's great um so I'm going to give each of you a component you have individual governance mindset Isabelle Frank transition of collaborate Partnerships priest team governance mindset Sophia fulfilling responsibilities Kena District functions uh Donald success for each and every student and Michelle you have current trends and issues in public education so what I I want you to do is just make a case give you a couple minutes of why the the component I gave you is the most important of all okay why why is that component when you think about the whole system and it's integrated why is the component I assigned you the most important just make maybe give a reason but I'll just give you a minute to think about it and then we'll hear back
061from everybody for come come in why is it we got this is okay let's uh let's just hear your comments so just your thought on maybe one of the reasons why your the component I assigned you is maybe the most important okay your first so which one did we give you uh you gave me individual governance uh mindset um I feel that this uh area is the most important because it is a commitment within yourself and this is an image that you have to carry throughout your time of this position um so in order to be able to serve those around us we have have to understand our role as an individual and if we are able to provide what what the ask is successfully and in unity great very good so um pretty important
062having an individual aware of their commitments and and and how they operate absolutely absolutely great Frank why why is uh the second component important oh the team governance mindset the transition to collaborative Partnerships oh I think it's very important that we all collaborate and be on the you know be unified and especially with the decision- making that we have you know it just has to be you have to be able to be open and to be able to you know not everybody's going to agree on everything but just to be open to if you're the way you feel isn't the one that was chosen or voted you know NE voted for the way you wanted it to be but you know you have to be able to adapt and you know look at the big
063picture for what we're trying to do and willing to be a team member yeah yeah great because there's no I in team yeah all right good thanks Frank priest how about the third component important one um yes I had team governance mindset so really being able to understand um well our roles and responsibilities uh within our team um really bringing um our different backgrounds and perspectives but knowing that we're here for a bigger purpose um really being able to work together I think Frank had mentioned earlier today we may not always agree but still keeping that main purpose uh in mind and one of the main things I took away from this was just that positive governance keeping that positive mindset when we go into discussions and collaborations and really understanding um that we are
064here uh for positive change okay great good good teamwork all righty Sophia your responsibilities okay so I feel my uh area is most important fulfilling responsibilities because um it tells one what they ought to do so it's of all of these it's telling us exactly what we should be doing establish the structure create supportive environment so these are action words I feel if we don't have the um clear outline of what we are responsible for um then the rest don't know what they should be doing great thank you so I have uh District functions which I classify as the systems uh of the district But it includes all of the other others that comes before it right so when we talk about the function of the district you can't get there without having an individual
065mindset um transition to collaborative Partnerships governance uh fulfilling the responsibility so I think this one it it includes every single one leading up to this one to get the job done okay very good so it's um it's the kind of the work the work that needs to be done the topics okay Donald well let's see I'm Gonna Let You Go last okay Michelle why don't you go next certainly so I believe mine is most important because um a system needs to Pivot evolve and change based on what's Happening so that the system and we continue to provide things that are relevant and meaningful to all the people which are within the educational system right so being aware and responding as necessary that's great Donald do you get an important one what's that did you you
066get an important compon I did I did on the chart I think it's the most important because all the arrows point to it but beside from that um everything we do in how the board functions how the district functions internally should lead to the success of all students and so um just thinking about the different skills that we have on this chart the individual self the board the district and that should emanate outward towards the Stockton Community um and to end off I wanted to quote uh the great Miss Lauren Hill how are we going to win if we're not right within ah well great so uh uh success for each and every student uh Northstar primary it's a it's the best description in terms of I think where talking about what what we want
067to have happen in the system and and if we really are serious about that then we're aware about the equal opportunities that people have we're aware that students need specific services we're we're trying to match the services with the needs um and and reach a um and it's a huge task but it's I think the the focus is a really good one and appropriate one um for Effective governments so it's uh it's 91020 23 so um let's take a 10minute break move around um and then at 9:35 we'll uh come back we're right on schedule so uh um thanks for all your participation so far e and mic check testing testing mic check mic check mik mik mic check microphone check mic check mic check ABC one 2 3 24 25 you got to press
068hard mic check mic check microphone check one two three no it's on microphone check one two3 ABC 23 24 25 26 Kool-Aid no sugar check check talking hearing seeing speaking smelling tasting all right and we are talking now yeah now when you're not talking go ahead push it back for this one this one mic test mic mic mic mic test yeah you gotta be within two two three inches that's good yeah right e for e for e e no e the e it's been a l yeah exactly exactly good point yeah oh I test test yeah test test test is that too far still test [Music] yours is way louder than mine test it okay that's PL okay yeah it is huh but I have a loud voice what it sounds okay yeah just stop
069talk louder okay outside okay let's uh come back together and uh we're right on schedule so we're uh it's we're moving along great um the next visual uh i' is uh in your uh notebook is the ven diagram which is the one of the top two uh available from csba in terms of providing a visual that's a great teaching tool so take a look at that for a [Music] minute and take a look at that and uh the question is what what what do you think we're trying to teach here with the with this diagram just think about it for a little bit and maybe make a couple of notes what are we trying to teach with this for okay let's uh let's just kind of work our way around the the room here uh
070Isabelle um what's something that you think we're trying to teach here with this diagram what would you guess uh I guess uh I I guess it's an overall view of uh the governance team and their role and then administrative staff teachers and their role and how we come together in the middle all right so delineation of responsibilities between the board superintendent and staff in better words yes no you did very well Frank what what do you take away from this I I felt like it was like unification amongst everything all together working together for one common goal so it it describes how you can work together how they all go together and work together and how it should be great okay priest what what do you what do you see in this um just showing
071us kind of the the middle ground and kind of how we can get there um and as one of them say just how we can be successful by bringing both lenses together to meet in the middle and meeting in the middle what are the the two things we're focused on there in the middle uh our strategic goals and success indicators all right very good Sophia what do you take away from this um I'm really encouraged by the interpretations already so far I don't have much to add um just that I see I agree our roles how how they work together and come together for the middle ground all right so there's a couple of things we hav't mentioned yet but um ktha what would you uh add to that so I would just add that
072we are the what when we talk about what's happening in our roles we are the what the superintendent and her team they are um the how so we set the tone for what's going to happen and then they go out and they make it happen and then we look at those success I think truste um Perez said it best like meshing the two together because there's this overlap of what's Happening how do we meet those goals together um but they are the actionary piece of what moves the district for not us in our roles very well said the what and the how Donald we kind of I'm sure you can come up with something here you okay I I missed uh some other folks answers but for me um the analogy that's coming up is
073um uh bringing up the question where's my Lane as a board member where's the lane of Staff um teachers School site um and where do those Lanes merge into each other and then thinking about two words Direction versus action who sets Direction who does who does the um the actions of the direction okay very very good Michelle what's your take on this so piggy backing on the story of your grandson um and the colors right so you can only get to the green if you are working together to get to that point right so when you blend the yellow of the um belief vision mission policies and then you've blend the actions of Administration staff um and I would even say community then that is when we can get to the true goal which is
074the middle and the green which is the Strategic goal and ultimate Student Success great well that that's a well thanks for picking up on the story so so it is a blending um the V diagram you know came out of mathematics actually and it was started as a way of describing attributes with numbers um but it has a lot great application and this is a great application of it um and so um you clearly have covered kind of the main uh components just to focus a little bit on strategic goals and success indicators what why does the board need to be involved in the Strategic goals setting the Strategic goals Donald why why does the board have to be a part of that cuz the community uh elected us and chose us to represent them
075that's right and so that yellow part does include the community it's it's you're you're representing your area but you're also representing all of the students in the district and your role is to be clear about the beliefs of the community um the vision for students the mission for the district the policies for the district and priorities those are your primary responsibilities as it relates to kind of the value driven part of it now it says that Governor's team with the arrow the superintendent actually lives in the Blended green area for a number of reasons one working with you to develop the Strategic goals and coming and then working with the staff to come up with success indicators um so if the board's not involved in that they're not fulfilling their responsibility remember the lighthouse study
076to set clear and high expectations you do that through goals and strategic goals why should the staff be a part of that that's the overlap for the staff too if the St Kenia you want to try that one yeah so they're they're the doers right so they are the actionary piece to the Strategic goals we talk about the goals as what we want to see happen for the district align that with policy right policy and money to make those things happen and then her team says guess what we can do this thing or they'll come to her and say guess what that's a heavy lift and maybe that's a three-year plan and it's not a 2015 2016 plan so they're the the doers um they know the data because they work with the people that
077will go out and do the work that will support ultimately support the kiddos and and the staff knows how to measure success and if staff's not involved in in that it's a the they sit on the Shelf strategic goals sit on the shelf and don't get implemented so this is a great diagram in terms of you know it's maybe an oversimplification a little bit but it's really helpful so um most as new trustees you may be familiar with the local control accountability plan which was uh funded in 2013 I think it was for the local control funding formula so it changed the way funding was set up for a California and so there's a bra base grant that all the districts get and then districts get additional funds for having certain categories of kids that
078need additional funding to meet their needs so in a nutshell that that's and then so the state there a couple reasons why they did this one is they were aware that across the state of California there were a lot of districts that did not have an accountability plan they weren't being clear about where the district should go and we did involve staff in this and everybody just kind of kept going um the state said no everyone will have an accountability plan we're going to call it the local control accountability plan and so elap then is the the short version of that but that's a very important document because that's the state is saying you want local control then you decide what are the areas we're going going to tell you the areas you should focus
079on but you decide how you're going to do it what objectives you're going to set what action plan you're going to follow and therefore you end up with an LC cap which is a big document but it represents the accountability plan for Stockton so do you see how that lcap is really what the state was saying is implement this diagram for accountability the board has responsibility and the superintendent to collect public [Music] input the goals and are set and the action plan is finalized and the three-year plan is developed uh by staff primarily deciding how it's going to be carried out in terms of action plans implementation evaluate the programs and do progress reports so is that helpful in terms of kind of understanding what lcap is um another way of looking that at this
080is it's also um a way of looking at superintendent evaluation um as you know a board has a responsibility to evaluate the superintendent every year and the board and superintendent agree on the format and they agree on the the goals and success indicators and then the superintendent plans to meet those and then provides a midyear report and end of the report in terms of success Meeting those goals so in a way the school boards need to really recognize that that green area is an important point of Leverage for boards because you you're getting to be a part of setting the direction clearly and and you're going to know that the accountability is built in remember the loudhouse study set clear expectations but hold the system accountable so this the LC cap is is intended to
081do do that now whether it's been successful in every District that's a whole another topic but if you're really doing this right this really should be be should drive the direction of the district Michelle would you kind of comment about the value of an lcap and what you have here and I know you've set a lot of objectives around a whole another top yeah sure so I think you are right I think some school districts prior had C IC plans and some didn't um some superintendents do still choose to have a strategic plan apart from the elk cap I have always pushed against that because we because of the amount of work that we do do to get feedback around the lcap um especially here I think this year in particular but even last year
082we have had pretty much two meetings a month with the lcap this year we're doing something really different different and we're doing data Dives with our with our parents and um I think it's been really helpful to really cuz it's a thick document so just the summary portion even the summary portion for most parents probably isn't comprehensible and so we developed an infographic and I think if you've gone to some of them I can put it in our weekly communication so that board can see it again but um we developed an infographic because you know we know that some of our are not going to even read the 30 page summary um but what we've done this year is really um break it down and look at um different data points and how those data
083points and goals are linked to specific sub goals and then board wise um what we do and um Dr Murphy always does a really good job of trying to link them is then we link those required um seven goals through the state and we have developed keyp so key performance indicators that then link to it so that we're not just doing the end result and looking at the end result but every month or about six weeks um we're looking at our key performance indicators and we do that um with our with our parents um and then so for example I just did chronic absenteeism with all the packs which is the parent um advisory committees and we just did chronic absenteeism with the board this last board meeting so we try to do those kpis
084so that we're keeping a constant look on it again the goal is for us to Pivot and shift so just like Ryan hessie for example just talked about um how well we are doing or we were doing currently um as of January on chronic caps anism but what we know these last two weeks because of some of the things that have been happening with immigration and others that our um attendance has once again gone down and it was reflective in what was presented to the board um in the January data when they looked at it they were like woo what happened um and so again that's going back to knowing what our overall goals are and then um and then really monitoring it both at the leadership level which for us is 240 people or
085so and that's every administrator in the district and then expanded cabinet which is about 130 of us so that's all District administration um and then obviously bringing it to board as well to make sure that we're all keeping a pulse on what's Happening and pivot quicker than um if we are only looking at it yearly or every six months right so how how quickly can we pivot um so um Tiffany Ashworth is our director of elcap and she does a really wonderful job um of continuing that work um what I'm proud of is she she's doing an amazing job but we also have a lot of other departments that are involved in those meetings too so Dr Murphy for example is there or has a staff member there and after each um lcap we actually
086look at Trends in and comments and information that we actually learned off of that lcap meeting so for each lcap meeting we have we're looking at Trends just within that so what are what are family saying off of the data that we just looked at or what are family saying off of the goals that we just had um and then we obviously do a lot of surveys as well so um I think Stockon is doing a really amazing job of reaching out um I still want more families there we still want more families um there it's much more than it was last year but I still think that we we need to continue to figure out how to get it at the school level a little bit more so that and some some do do
087it but at the school level so because some families are not going to come to the district level they'll only go to the site level and so how do we help all of our principles and and you know and maintain expectations for how they need to engage with staff um you know we're we we have to evolve over time and so you know we've set some expectations we we'll we'll keep ratcheting up as we go along um but yeah that's I I'll finish with that yeah very good any uh questions the board has about kind of that the whole lcap process or um if not question oh sorry um no question but just as you were talking I was thinking like um maybe even outside of our packs creating lcap leadership teams at the school
088site level so we can really Drive what it looks like to have um families involved at the local level but then also having them connect around the larger piece to support Tiffany with more of that Community engagement uh for the lcap because the community piece is what really drove this piece is to make sure that there was local autonomy uh for families to have a say not just with the funding um but also with what the plan looks like for their kiddos when they go to school and what are the achievement goals and how do students engage back at the school site level so it is extremely important that we have parents at the table and that parents that look just like you and I to say these are the things that we want to
089move forward and then to also just continue to build that relationship with families and the district across the board for sure and we definitely will Leverage The Community Schools work um so we just um we the board just approved the job description for the brand new family Liaisons that are going to be at the school sites um through the Community Schools funding and so um that can definitely be um one of the groups that they form as we're doing our community schools work um we're doing we have 27 schools of the 55 that are Community Schools right now and then um lu I mean it may now change but they were going to do another cohort um for Community Schools for California and so hopefully they will continue to have that as a funded element
090and um we're planning on having all the rest of our 55 schools go after that um so we would have it across the board so we can definitely have that work sure so we have 27 um right now that got approved this last year um and so currently we have 27 and so we'll hope to extend to the 55 uh Chris do you have a comment um asked the superintendent to talk about um the cpsa the School site plans and how they roll into cuz that's another approach yeah thank you explain the acronym and then sure yeah so sypsa is a single plan for student achievement so that is the El that is the individual site version of what the district has to do and so you may have heard from some principles of some
091frustration because we actually made them re redo their sipsas so as required by law they did their sipsas and had it approved by their School site Council um in May or April of last year but as you all um or many some of you know um maybe all know um we re we rechanged we changed our lcap goals pretty significantly this year so each School District in the state of California did a um did a brand new three-year plan um for the El cap um I wasn't from my from some of the listening sessions that I had had um I wasn't necessarily sure if the goals always met what families were asking for and so again um Tiffany and her team did a great job of getting feedback from people and we reorganized our six
092lcap goals so what happened for example and there was some concerns off of aab Pac um that each individual School site for example didn't have goals explicitly linked to goal six which is African-American um student thrives and so what each and every school district or each and every site had to do is take the brand new six schools um because we kept some consistent but we changed some and then we added some and they had to then draw a link an explicit link between each one of those six goals and their um single plan for soon achievement their sies and so um it was a an effort um and because we had made such a big shift on the lcap goals um it was a pretty big shift for them so they had to realign
093all their funding so they to do goals and actions and then they align their individual funding that they receive to those and so now if you look at the sipsas and the question is asked so where is English Learners in there you can draw a through line where is africanamerican Black of student achievement there's a through line so there is actually a through line now at each one on with each one of the sipsas um these upcoming years because it's a refresh um instead of a whole renewal of the LC cap um next year will be easier for um for the principles this year was a a pretty big shift they pretty much had to redo their entire sypsa um but believe in the end it will help us both track are we using our
094money where we say our goals are um and then also it will help us um ensure that each site is actually tracking the six goals that we've set out for the district so thanks for the question great other questions about uh elcap Isabelle could you do me a favor and just have bring these around that one everybody so we're going to shift gears and so remember Sophia uh reviewed all the responsibilities five responsibilities and kentha re uh reviewed the district functions and the within the work areas and so how in the world can we keep track of all of this and csba has a tool um that we're going to just show you as a template um some districts have uh used a similar format uh some uh uh districts have uh have a different
095version so uh it's not there's more than one way to kind of uh manage the numbers but um just a quick overview in terms of what the calendar is you can see across the top of the uh calendar are the months of the year corresponding to kind of the the school district calendar July 1 to June 30 um then you see different job areas or District functions down the left side effective governance setting Direction student learning achievement and then Finance then if you flip it over to the other side Finance continues and then facilities line uh policy judicial review uh Human Resources uh collective bargaining community relations and advocacy so that's a big it's a big chart so I thought I'm going to um I think what we should do is focus on maybe some
096of the key decisions or most critical decisions to make in the coming year and so um I'm going to give you Bob's top 11 decisions based on my experience what are the ones for sure um that are may be more important than the others um you'll note that some of the Bold ones are are are mandated but um I'll start on on with the effective governance we're going to start where it says eff of governance at the top on the first line yep it says yeah F page 15 on it you probably wondered what happened to page 14 so on page 15 uh for effor governance lots of some things are repeated there um and uh but I would highlight in April and May uh conduct board self-evaluation and develop action plan for improvement um
097something that csba recommends is that you do a board self evaluation once a year your bylaws probably prescribe that and so um that's something that uh uh is recommended for a couple reasons one is um your modeling accountability uh for the system you know we expect the superintendent to do a self- evaluation as part of her evaluation we have principles and teachers and students we all want them to be evaluating their own performance and therefore uh uh improving the way they operate and so they don't recommend that you do a board self- evaluation until board members have been on the board at least 6 months because you just don't have enough experience at that point to to actually complete the valuation process but csba provides a a process um if there's interest so setting Direction
098on my top 11 is in March and April every two three years review the district vision mission using an inclusive process so csba recommends that when you do have new trustees or new superintendent that you look at your vision statement and mission statement and so that be if and it doesn't mean that you have to change it it just means that there should be a complete support um by the governance team for that um to the degree that you involve the community staff is a a individual decision um but a vision and Mission shouldn't be the language shouldn't be negotiated it shouldn't be well I'm not com you know it it should really be the words that the board and the superintendent feel are giving the best Direction um to the district so under student
099learning achievement my number three is approve the lcap way over in June um but it's interesting when you see all of in and shell did a great job describing the process that these these evolve and the reports uh on how students are doing as well as you're collecting information for the next year um so I put lcap as as my number three um dropping down um over on student learning aligning the district vision and vision and student learning and achievement goals so again that's what kind of what you do with lcap you're constantly and I use the word pivot I think and with based on new information you make adjustments so to make sure that that again Allah the lighthouse study setting clear expectations hold the system accountable there's a an a conscientious effort to
100make sure those are aligned um I put the next one and it's not an action it it's an action if you schedule them but I put scheduling presentations and board progress reports regarding student results local assessments critic impementation professional development um there's another study uh uh that was done by a national group that uh decid that high performing districts spent a certain amount of time on finance and a certain amount of time on student learning and achievement low performing districts spent much different percentages low performing districts spent 60% on finance 10% on student learning high performance in districts it was the reverse 60% on topics relative to student achievement and 10% on finance and we haven't gotten to the finance part that's an important part but the Temptation is sometimes to spend all the time
101on the dollars and cense and not on these other issues relating to uh to students so um they did the survey really just they did a a minute count on all the agendas and it was amazing because one of the things that you're modeling with your board meetings is what's important and so um just something to remember as you're uh as you're planning your agendas so we're up to one two three four so my next three have all to do with finance and so when you're thinking about PR new trustees what are these decisions and you found out right away at your first meeting that you receive the audit so I I circled that one receiving the audit because that's the analysis of last year's budget now remember the board the board hires the independent
102auditor so the independent auditor reports directly to the board when the board the auditor reports to the board they're saying this is what we found um and so that that is very important information now you can see my next one is adopt the budget in June but you can see all the things that happen in the course of the district in the year to adop that get you to budget adoption so now if you'll flip over to the other side and of course there's two sides to everything um in December approving and certifying the first inter report so what's in what you what you we have to realize why a calendar like this is important is that you've got three years running at one time almost every program you're reviewing last year's program you're operating
103this year's program and you're planning for the next year in the future all at the same time well how do you keep track of that in terms of your responsibilities and you can see that first inter report why that's so important because that's the staff's well okay we we we've through the first three three months of the year um I think it goes to October 1 first interim covers through October 31st so that's the staff's perception about how well are we doing what we thought we were going to do in terms of the budget but also tied to that is a multi-year projection so remember the audit is from last year first inter report is monitoring this year and you're doing a multi-year projection to see how well you're going to be doing in in
104two to three years I don't have to overemphasize probably the importance of paying attention to the finances um you're very fortunate from what I understand you have healthy reserves and for some districts that is not the case and if there are some changes in in funding in the next couple of years uh in some districts already um in difficulty um binglewood is an example of a district I think was about 10 years ago because I was down there for a couple years but they they didn't have enough money and they when you the district goes bankrupt the state takes over so the superintendent loses his or job the business manager loses his or her job and the board no longer makes decisions for the district it becomes an Advisory Group and so and that situation
105stays is the same until you pay back the money you the state gave you to bail you out so how do you possibly pay back alone and operate your program it's a NeverEnding kind of a process so it gets it's very hard so the importance of knowing the numbers and you don't have to be an expert in finance but as as a a group to be conscious about really paying attention to the reports that come in we used to laugh about the fact if you wanted the boardroom to clear out have the auditor come in and start going through the numbers because Auditors that's what they do is just numbers they're not there to entertain people they they're there to really lay out what the numbers are so something like this allows you to see
106decisions that are coming up and so you can be prepared so I'm going to hop down to uh human resources that March 15th date for those of you've been on the board know that's extremely important um layoff notification to staff uh not only for layoffs but um non-election letters are letters sent to staff members in their first two years saying we do not want you to return if you don't receive one of those letters in your third year you usually become tenured which is very difficult to uh uh have deal with 10year teachers that are not doing well so that data is very important for the district and and is U um will certainly be discussed um in close session then I also circulate uh Circ circled evaluate the superintendent in May June um that's
107done at different times um the agreement U with Michelle is that she would like to be able to use the the data from this year as part of her evaluation so that will really be accomplished in July um some districts do it earlier and then they're they just deal with the information flow differently but that's a you know you're committed to evaluate the superintendent we're going to just chat about that a little bit before uh we break up for today now I just in collective bargaining I just the way on the far right there says under May June approve negotiated contracts um that whole process is so important and I'm going to ask Michelle to com make some comments about number of these things but um nothing will influence the climate in your District more
108than negotiations in terms of positive or negative so while that's a little kind of thin line across there that is so important uh in terms of you're being aware of the process and and helping to maintain a real positive culture around that so I'm going to come back to to you Michelle in just one second I'm my number 11 under advocacy um I put advocate for each and every student year around that's in the bottom there and so um uh um Michelle I'd love to have you comment on some of the decisions and timing and everything particularly negotiations but um and then we'll uh we'll talk more about this so go ahead sure so um I so we we were behind on negotiations prior so we're unique in that we have nine unions so we
109have nine unions um we have one that is our so we have two that are our largest so we have sta which is our certificated staff um and so that's about 1,300 staff members we have over 5,000 staff members in our district um the next largest is um CA normally in most school districts they're bundled together but for us we have three CA units so we have cssea 821 that is the majority of our classified staff so over a thousand staff members and then we have um CSEA 318 318 is our pair of professionals um and I know if there people watching this they're going to say you didn't include me so I'm doing broad Strokes so I know who's in each bargaining unit but um and then um 885 is our transportation um then
110we do have we're unique in that we have a separate um for our spa so that's all of our counselors um speech and language pathologist school psychologist um we have our Police Officers Association has their own Union we have our own Union for our mental health clinicians um and we have our own Union for our principles and assistant principal so site Administration um has that as well um so our goal so we were able to we settled with all with eight of them we settled with eight of them for last or for the 2324 school year and the 2425 school year for um CA 318 um because of when they're contract ended they selected only to settle for the 2324 and we're um almost solidified with the 2425 right now are we just as you
111saw we just sunshin at the last board meeting so how it works is they Sunshine their items to just say what they want to speak to then following that um we are unique here in that we don't sunshine and approve at the same time it's in the contract that it's two separate meetings which is unique normally you sunshine and approve at the same meeting my understanding is it was put in the contract that way so that people had ample time to understand what was going to be negotiated and so um that was sunshine on their part and then approved we will do the same process so pretty much everywhere we you allow the bargaining unit to Sunshine first identify what they want to um discuss in the contract it identifies unless it's a full opener
112meaning you're doing the full contract um as we did with sta this past year um then you are limited the number of articles that you can open and so what they do is they identify their priorities and which articles they want to open we then will then identify what articles that we wish to open sometimes um it will be um redundant meaning we will say we want to do the same article um most of the time that's not the case so if they open article then that means that it's up for full discussion we are trying um to um settle before the end of the school year for the upcoming school year so we're technically ahead at this point which I I guess it is unique and that hasn't happened and so we're trying to
113keep that Trend and be ahead of ourselves instead of H talking about past years and then worrying about Retros and and all that and so we um our goal is to we always generally most school districts wait until the governor's proposal which just came out in January so you wait until the governor's proposal which can change by the May Revis but you wait until the governor's proposal so you have at least a backdrop of what is what monies are going to be available and so the goal is to then settle last year um it came to you in April May and so that's when we hope to settle by um and um you know and then we we always um try to as I say to all staff we always try to provide the best
114compensation package that we possibly can there is really no reason to not provide the best compensation package that you physically can however um we always do have to be fiscally conservative because of um downturns we are declining enrollment as well however um the board does have two resolutions as they as they're aware there's two resolutions so we have a resolution that has 56 million that's set aside um to account for declining enrollment and also um increasing medical benefits because that is something that we did this past year we gave every full-time employee in Stockton Unified has access to free family benefits for their entire family through Kaiser if they wish to they can um you know um pay up and they can have a different setting um but that is something that we will we
115do often here talk about total compensation because we believe that the health of our employees and their families is important and so um that is part of our compensation package and then we look at the salary schedule to try to put as much as possible on there um and still maintain positive certification through um for the three years out right um and so um hopefully we we do um we have now Sunshine we'll bring our Sunshine forward and then we will start negotiations and um hopefully we'll be able to come to a conclusion because as we saw previously um when we were in difficult negotiation times um it there was some you know stress on the relationship and so we always try to work with our our unions as best as we can so that
116we provide our staff the best possible so they can provide our students the best possible great great great summary so one of the purposes remember uh our effective governance system and we have so what a what a a board planning calendar something like this does is that allows you to fulfill know you're fulfilling your five responsibilities and all of those District functions you're you're aware of current trends and issues because as a issue comes up you can say can we have a workshop on X and you look at your calendar and you say well it looks like the timing would be great for March or whatever so um it's an and and obviously the whole focus is success for each and every students so as you know while it might not be on a student
117line these are all uh they're all integrated with each other and so they're a dependent you don't start a new program for students without building that into the budget and so um one of the things that um you really want to do and this goes back to that first uh uh individual governance might set relative to preparation and deep learning is you want to be ready to make decisions and so you know you have seven votes on the board and you want everybody to feel like they are informed enough to actually make these decisions and so you won't be surprised to see in the first meeting in June the LC cap show up because that's when it's supposed to and it's supposed to be approved before the regular budget which is usually approved later in
118J in June so it's a it's way to kind of look at the sequence and feel comfortable that you're fulfilling your overall responsibilities um and is a great Tool uh questions about the calendar or timing or um I think you know you probably may have had a workshop already on the brown act relative to board meetings you know that there are open session topics and Clos session topics um I think one of the key phrases is that the board the brown act in three words is openly and collectively and so any any direction to the superintendent needs to be done uh openly and collectively one one board member can't say to the superintendent we think all the schools should be painted red white and blue and and so it would for your case it would
119take four trustees out of seven to make a decision to direct the superintendent so or to make a decision so remember also Robert's Rules of Order is not necessarily order meaning versus chaos Robert's Rules of Order is a process for decision making that allows you to reach a decision in a constructive fashion through motions and and amendments um it protects as I mentioned before the rights of an individual and his or her opinion and his her ability to vote as they feel that they need to vote um and so uh the brown act decision making planning making decisions all kind of tied together so do um any of you newer trustees or or anyone have any questions about the calendar before we uh move on would you help me again sure I'll give you extra
120points thank you okay so um what are we're what's going around the table now we're not going to take time to go through it but again back to the effective governance system remember the first three components indiv idual transitional collab of Partnerships and team what a governance handbook does is it puts in writing agreements for you to fulfill those three components so you can see that there are really three tools available to you there's the ability of having a governance handbook a governance calendar and the opportunity for board self- evaluation so those are a way that you can be systems thinkers and also aware of of uh of what's uh ways that you can uh reach agreements on these topics so um if I um let's just uh let's page through this quickly just so
121I want to spend some time on the protocols but you can see the way this is this is a was developed was it a year ago two years ago okay so it' be three years ago then almost two years two years ago so this was drafted by the board at that time um and so at some point the board should schedule a time to to go through this it could be a workshop or whatever you may want to have a a board subcommittee look at it first and save everybody some time but if you we look at just page one uh has the current mission statement um and and then you'll we'll just page through page two talks about Unity of purpose uh three roles and responsibilities um four governance keep culture uh governance Norms
122remember we talked about norms and protocols being a part of the effective governance system page four has norms and now there's really an extensive uh Pages five six um seven and eight um are are what's called protocols so those are agreements that the board and the and the and superintendent have about certain um issues um what's a good one to uh yeah okay so this is a it it's a we'll leave an enlarge the font size for draft at the top it's even bigger than that size so consider this total draft um it's you're not bound by a previous board but they've done a lot of work when you look at the protocols and I I think uh uh let's look at uh let's see let's look at number 12 on page seven because this
123is a good this is superintendent trustee Communications so we'll look for your comments too on this Michelle so um trustees use their judgment in keeping the superintendent informed superintendent shall communicate regularly with two-way communication with the trustees regarding District related items and concerns according to the trustees individual agreed upon preference trustees trust the superintendent and exercising judgment in informing the Board of Trustees of issues this is really a draft um but it's a it's a starting point so from your perspect perspective what what do you think is the best way for board superintendent Bo trustee superintendent Communications so I know none of you like surprises I I don't like surprises either so I try to um so generally it's um I I try to do it through um things that need to be done quickly
124um it is through text I try to don't do I do it individually so that we don't have a brown act issue because otherwise if you respond then there's an issue so I try to be really responsive I generally I'm not one that's sitting in my office reading emails and so I I I let all board know that if they if they need me right away that text is the best and if they need to call talk to me then um they can call a lot of times I'll I'll have to leave what I'm doing to get there so sometimes I I have to do do that so for me personally text is is best um but I try to treat each board member in the preference that they want so you know um I
125have had some I'm not saying here but I have in the past had some board that's on a need to know basis meaning um I I don't really I've actually had board say I really don't want all your t and I've said okay um but generally I believe that if I if one knows the majority knows um we do do our weekly communication that's from all depart or all assistant soups and so that's a way of both ensuring they have celebrations um knowing when um things are happening and um I try to be as 247 as possible so I hope that I'm always seen as being responsive and um I don't even if I'm on a on a break or whatever I I prefer to know so I know um some of my staff used
126to be like well we didn't want to tell you on the weekend because we didn't want to ruin your weekend and it was like no I need to know right now I don't tell him don't wait to tell me a Monday don't wait to tell me till the next day like I'm um for me the sooner I know the better and I then use that premise with um with the rest of the board um I generally do always um have first initial communication with the President and Vice President and then clerk um and then um the trustee area and then the rest of the board but that's all that's generally within a two minute process because I'm just literally cutting and pasting um but I I do um I do obviously have agenda setting and
127other things with board leadership and so um there is some additional conversation that happens with board leadership just because of the creation of the agenda and the positions and roles in which they hold um but um you know our president and vice president and clerk are are wanting um a governance of seven and so I you know we we try to be transparent with all can you describe a little about the leadership team um in terms of what their responsibilities and and the rest of the board you mean the U principles and all that no the uh uh or board leadership yeah board leadership yes so um I mean board leadership we have agenda setting um and so we we meet um to discuss the agenda um we also meet um in different ways just
128to ensure that we're prepared for these type of meetings for example and so kind of similar to any leadership group um work they're kind of the steering committee so to speak of of the board right so um they um give perspective on what we should be doing so for example that that group was a group that um had the communication with csba to determine okay we're going to do this good Beginnings um you know we're going to um do the superintendent evaluation a little bit different than we did the previous year um and so you know I think we um try to work collaboratively um the four of us together as as leadership but then again how do we help then um involve the rest of the board so that um we're a team of
129eight great any questions or comments I know if did President Stevens you want to add on any or are you good with what I said so I would just say ditto to everything you said but it really is about so we we continue to have this word about this Unity word right but Unity isn't just a word it's about what we do and how do we set the groundwork and making sure that when we do have new board members they're actually trained and ready and have the skills and tools to be able to lead the work and I think that comes out of the conversations that we have not just as board leadership but as individual trustees also connecting to um the other board members so that they know that's happening too if there's questions
130excuse me questions comments or concerns um they know that they have the opportunity to do that but I would just say dto to everything we do try to be as transparent um as possible but Unity is about making sure that people have the knowledge to do the work that we're actually elected to Doh very good other comments or questions before we move on all right we're ready to look ahead um March 1st um has been designated uh as the closed session Workshop um there is in your uh your folder a page that uh so suggested sequence for evaluation of the superintendent and uh so basically this um you're you're basically following this sequence and so uh and and have you know congratulations and to uh the superintendent for for really connecting the lcap in the
131objectives for students as part of her evaluation that's not um necessarily a u a practice that's done across the state but it's very encouraged because um they have found out that one of the factors that influences student achievement from a research standpoint is that student outcomes are part of a superintendent evaluation you wouldn't you that kind of makes sense but U they did have shown that to be um uh the case with uh with the research so um what will happen um at the um March meeting uh which will be close session is that the uh superintendent will uh provide a self- evaluation based on all the objectives that are in her evaluation and uh then give the board opportunity to talk about that and then uh we would look ahead to July to have
132the board have another would be another self- evaluation by the superintendent the board completes the evaluation form uh the board president collects the information creates a summary provided to the superintendent and uh then there's a conversation around that so the the the idea is is to really it's it's a great process that you are tying the superintendent's evaluation um into the goals and objectives that you have for the district um through the elcap so do you want to add to that given your perspective sure so um one of the things that I try to do is hold people accountable and so I do try to publicly hold myself accountable as well so um in March 1st we'll be going over the five goals so we have set five goals for us if you look at
133it they are all directly linked to um student achievement or to goals within the district which is why I asked to have the special board meeting which we just approved at the last board meeting um in July because I don't have this data before that time so the first school is around graduation rates um so we all know that um so I'll be I won't I won't um pre myself on from March 1st for a time but um we'll be talking about the goal one is around graduation rates goal two is around literacy rates um goal three around chronic absenteeism goal four is around equity which has multiple facets including reclassification the equity audit black student thrives success plan and expansion and broadening of our CTE programs and then number five is around relationships with
134the board and community so it's around my site visits conversations with the superintendent one-on ones with you all um board orientation my superintendent student advisory and all the subcommittees um and so um what I'll be doing on March 1st is giving a preliminary of where we're at with all those indicators and then on July 1st will be generally it's about 90 minutes 75 90 minute um presentation presentation um I do it's not required but I've always done it my entire superintendency um career I then um make that presentation that I present you in close session available for staff to see um when you do my contract in August which has to occur at um a regularly scheduled board meeting um and so I do that um to hold myself um accountable to the work that
135we're saying that we're doing for children great thank you all right so that's looking ahead um we have three things to do before we close today one is I want just to make uh trip around the tables again and uh have you share uh your kind of impressions for today and uh anything any uh uh comment you want to make relative to either appreciations or recommendations and we're actually going to call on the member of the public also to share his observations before at the end so I'll put him on the spot right off the bat is he ready do you [Laughter] think um you want to go first again no no okay Donald why don't you go first we'll go this way sure uh thank you Bob this is um I really love these
136these meetings um especially when new board members come in so that we're all on the same page I think um just in my own experience in the last two years um I'm just looking really forward to um you know getting better since the pandemic great thanks D Ethan so yeah so I think these are just opportunities for us to kind of um build and set the foundation with the new members um coming on I think I said it a little while ago like making sure you all have the tools to be successful in the roles that you're um elected in and I think we talked a lot about Unity it's like that's the word that continues to say with me and it's we have to be unified in the work that we do but I
137think um skills and communication are the way that we build that right we're individuals coming to a table to do big work um it's no easy feed there there will be time to don't agree right but um disagreements that does not mean that we don't like each other that means that we wake up tomorrow and we come back and we yet do the same work again right because there's lessons around what we do here at the district and I want to make sure that our superintendent is successful because that's part of the role that we pick up right our role is to make sure that whatever happens at the district we stand behind it 100% good batter and different um but our role is our role is to make sure that stock and unified moves
138forward no matter what at the end end of the day so excited about what's taking place here I'm excited that um we're able to come to the table and grapple with things right some things are new some of us have been around just for a little bit um but I'm looking forward to great things coming out of stock and unified and I just want us to keep that optimism um days will get tough for us uh but just know that you have a partner here at the board that wants to see you all succeed as well so kudos to everyone for giving up their Sunday morning to be here great thank you Sophia okay what more can I say um kind of hit the nail on the head with everything little closer oh what more
139can I say is what I'm is what I'm saying because um I think I'm I'm most encouraged I'm hearing a lot of the same things come up for for the new and for us we're not so new right we're not I want to say old because we're still feeling new in some of some respect as well um and especially as we're building a relationship together I'm really encouraged what I'm hearing um your why I think is something that's kind of going back in my mind if I'm trying to reflect on just our brief couple of hours here today um like President Steven said some of the conversations we have and decisions we make will be challenging but what's helped me is to come back to the why and again just looking at your why that's
140that's encouraging me I know a lot of this was overwhelming for me when I first started too there's a whole calendar we just yeah know a whole calendar we looked up like how are we going to do this but it's together it's it's together we can't do it all alone um we have to do this together as a whole team so that's kind of what I'm reflecting on okay great priest yeah I definitely um agree um nobody really tells you when you first become a board member it's like drinking water from a fire hose um so you're trying to take all this information and decipher this information and figure out how to put this information you know back out to make sense uh to everyone so it's a great opportunity for us to um come
141together and collaborate because we don't really get the opportunity that often between schedules lives and all those great things but just to be able to um pick each other's mind and that kind of helps you build a rapport and relationship with each other to kind of understand each other's perspectives and what's really important to us great thank you right yes um this is I'll be honest kind of overwhelming the whole process it's new to me I didn't come from a teaching background or any kind of you know anything that would pertain to being a board member but I was elected and I'm glad that I have you know fellow board members that are willing to you know help out and guide me through this I mean I know I'd ask a lot of dumb questions
142sometimes but if you don't ask you don't know mhm but yeah so any in all training that I'm getting it's like I'm glad to be getting it and I'm think I'm getting it you know little by little so I just hope to be able to do the best that I can because like you guys said that we were elected to do this by our you know communities and I want to do the best that I can great thanks Frank Isabelle I am just enjoying any opportunity that I have to be with all of you together in one room um and hearing about your wise um I I know Shauna's why cuz we went through the whole campaign process together but I was unsure of Frank's why and and your your wise um and hearing that
143today helps me understand a little bit more about you and why you're here with us um and overall the unity in what we do together means so much to our community um and those that were serving so it is important for us to be synced and in unity um and I I love that we can make our decisions and understand that we're not all going to agree all the time but that we still respect each other and move past it and go back to the main point of the process of why we're here um so any opportunity to learn and train and connect with all of you is what I enjoy the most out of all of this great Michelle so I just have a deep appreciation for all of you I'm I'm so heartened
144that we when we look at our Wise It's all centered around our students our families our community our staff and so um just know that I'm I'm here for you just as I'm here for the students and so um please continue to reach out and I think continuing to have times where we can break bread together where we can have conversations um to just reinforce and um encourage each other um to continue to do the good work because it's hard work but it's the heart work right so thank you nice um Bob started today's training um with the lighthouse study um and he made a recommendation um the reason why it's called a lighthouse study is because board members in a school district are seen or are the lighthouse we protect we communicate with the
145community we're Community leaders we're elected officials but our role is to shine that light so that the district can miss the rocks I highly recommend that you read the the lighthouse study every so often because each time you read it as you go on this journey you're going to learn more about the work that you're doing you're going to recognize the importance of this governance team the superintendent has she's the superintendent she's the board secretary and she's a member of the governance team she has more information about how all this works than will'll all ever have combined so your superintendent is your ally whether you agree or disagree or you want to see something happen she is your ally just like each of these board members are your allies in getting the work done for
146the entirety of the district I'm really encouraged by again the reasons the Homegrown the educator um there's never a dumb question the only dumb question is the one you don't ask I will tell you when I first got to the board board my hand was always up what's This Acronym what's This Acronym what's This Acronym because I wanted to do the job well and your board president has challenged you do the work you've been elected do the research do the reading come prepared because if you do that what you guys all want to see happen for all 35,000 34,1 7 students is going to happen great thanks Chris well let's we have one activity uh that um I'm required to require you to do and that is on the left side behind the agenda is
147a QR code um it'll connect you to survey monkey monkey and uh there's only about five or six questions I think so it would take three or four minutes to do but it's really important that we collect the information from all of you so I'm not going to say anything for three or four minutes give you a chance to fill it out and then I do have some closing comments and then we can adjourn by e e for yeah you did you did very well first teacher first yeah I know nice big printing looks like everybody's just about done I let's just let finish work another minute or so for you okay Frank you about done are you about done oh yeah okay yeah I no no no I just uh I didn't want interrupt
148you oh yeah okay uh just in closing before I turn things over back to our president um uh Michael fulan has written a book called leading in a culture of change and he says there are three characteristics that these leaders need will need to have um one is a sense of hope one is uh the energy and one is enthusiasm um hope is not a false uh idealism it's a it's a belief that yes together we can get this done um energy comes from a faith in something it could be religious Faith or a or belief and children and public education um enthusiasm comes from the interactions we have with the people around us and it it just it it builds that Spirit um that is really important so hope energy and enthusiasm uh carry
149it forward and uh I'll see you in a month that's great uh back to you thank you so much Bob and team and to the leadership team for making this happen as well so we're looking forward to some great things and I would like to close us out moving on to item 3.1 I would like to adjourn the board meeting at 11 a.m. enjoy your weekend your