001not good e e don't okay oops thank you thanks for reminding me great okay it's now is this open open on okay hi it's now 6m and I'm calling to order the regular board meeting of the Sunnyville School District Board of Education this meeting is available in English and Spanish oh are they here I just don't see them on the screen that's okay uh would the translator please give instructions on translation services available good evening everybody um the zoom interpretation feature will be used in this meeting for English and Spanish support all participants on this call must select their language of preference by clicking the language when the host turns on the interpretation feature this is found in the world icon located on your feature panel interpretation for this meeting will will be conducted simultaneously
002thank you for your attention and collaboration thank you please note that a recording is being made at the direction of the board and that the recording May capture sounds May capture sounds of those attending the meeting um I see that all board members are present so we can begin please join me for the Pledge of Allegiance Pledge of aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to theic for which it stands indiv andice okay um I'd like to invite truste hubz L to please read the live living land acknowledgement thank you s school district is located on the ancestral and insed land of Thea of tribe who have peacefully honor and care for this land for thousands of years we recognize that every member of the Sagal Community continues to benefit from
003the use and occupation of this we acknowledge our responsibilities to learn from the wisdom of the up people and to consider how we might work to repair injustices and to move forward together in horable ways thank you uh we're on to item two approval of the agenda if there's any member of the public who would like to speak on this item um please use hand feature if you're online or hand in a card do we have any cards any raised hands okay uh board is there a motion to approve the agenda tonight and you approve the agenda I second great um any discussion all those in favor please say I I carebooks I without that the motion passes we are on to item three public comments on closed session items um are there any cards
004for this item yeah online if there's any member of the public who wishes to speak on this item please use the raised hand for now the topics are item 4A consideration of student expulsion at code 4891 16c two cases and 4B conference with labor negotiator government code 54957.6 CSAA SC okay um no comments all right uh so it is now uh 6:05 p.m we're going to convene for Clos session we'll take a 5 minute break after Clos session and hope to return at her about 7 p.m. thank you e e e I get into no I said says that for everyone switching to chase you go give [Laughter] aook I'm like you [Music] I [Music] hello everyone it is 7:05 sorry it is 7:05 and I'm communion this regular board meeting of the Board of
005Education I see all members present um reminder there are translation services in Spanish available would the translator please provide brief instructions for members of the public or started once they do at the beginning of the meeting I thought they R did it when we got back as well okay last time it was in my notes because I just copied it this so they can't give instructions yet they're on the Spanish Channel already okay cool all right um great so as a reminder to everyone in the room uh this meeting is being recorded at the request of the board so from the closed session the outcome number one for outcome number one in close session the board voted to accept a stipulated agreement to expel student number 132 865 and to suspend the expulsion and in
006case one uh I'm sorry that was case two public session script case one public session script oh I'm saying script public session um in close session the board voted to expel student number 13949 and to suspend the expulsion okay hated that [Music] um so we are on to number seven item number seven comments from the board no we are y six is oh six consent agenda items sorry my computer is not loading so I'm off my notes um okay any item on the consent agenda is subject to review and discussion prior to it being approved by the board if necessary any items may be removed for separate action the public May address the board regarding any items on the consent agenda is there any member of the public present who wishes to make a comment
007on the consent agenda or pull a consent agenda item for discussion if so I need a comment card or you can raise your electronic hand online okay see none so for um item F the approval of board byw 9220 governing board elections um there was a recommend invitation to strike the sentence the district shall reimburse half the cost of printing handling translating mailing and or electronically Distributing candidate stand statements filed pursuant to the elections code because it says it in a different way in the next paragraph so um that would have been redundant so that's the change that we'll recommend you on that okay um so G would any of you like to pull an item for a separate vote okay do we have a motion I move approval of the consent agenda as listed
008okay all those in favor please say I I chotes I motion passes uh I'll try again it says try again I'll try again okay um so uh now it's time for item seven comments from the board and superintendent we can go down the line we'll start with um trusty Hub SL well it has been interesting couple of weeks but very easy also yes closer your M you just need to talk closer to your mic and I've been we had a lot of meetings with the hofman and I S my activities and today and the LA and uh today I went to the first day of the Cs uh conference it was very interesting and I will be going on this Saturday but I think that's yeah that's for today um we've been uh working on
009having a uh whole bunch of different sessions for the trusty areas I know if Bri just going to talk about or not um not trusty areas but sessions for the trustey area um and then I just wanted to share so you know I'm I always cry easily but I'm going to be extra cry easily today because I just visited a friend today who's dying and so I'm just a little bit more emotional than [Music] noral um okay hello uh it's been a very busy 3 weeks since the last board meeting I submitted my activities there were 17 of them I counted um some included um like the new trustee orientation from um Santa clar County School boards Association um I really enjoy um some of the resources seminars given um for immigrant communities um we
010brought one of those to us to our community um and that was very well received and attended um two different um webinars that I attended um really kind of came to mind um when I was thinking about a general theme for these past few weeks and that was one with um SEC SBA there's an evening Zoom with um Dr Robin avard Lal and she presented on equality versus equality Equity versus equality and the answer is yes both um we need to make sure that we think that all of our students are equally capable and hold um ourselves as Educators to that standard um having those expectations of our students and I found a very similar theme in um the webinar that we attended for SMS they had Obie Vasquez which is um funded by the
011Ed Foundation and um he had a parent seminar and has a very similar tone to that let's make sure that we have high expectations of ourselves of our children and um and Lead like that and so um those are two really really wonderful um webinars that I attended this past few weeks okay so um I two have been really busy this month uh I sent in all my activities uh through email so there'll be in the minutes if you would like to read them uh this month is Black History Month I wanted to mention that um I hope everyone is taking the opportunity to acknowledge that all people of the United States are the recipients of the wealth and of History provided by Black Culture to reflect on the complex History of the United States
012while remaining hopeful and confident about the path ahead and to commemorate the tremendous contributions of African-Americans to the history of the United States and the world thank you so uh just a real quick couple quick notes U last couple days have been really good days for me because I was actually at five different sites over two days which is great sometimes in superintendent you do a lot of things not at the schools but it's great to be able to see our our teachers in action and our kids learning um and to meet one-on-one with our principles um of note I was able to check in with um social workers and Outreach assistants um and I just want to really applaud them and give them um as much support as we can for the support that
013they're giving to our immigrant communities now and to recognize um the difficult job that that is to be dealing with emotion themselves and to be providing support so um I offer my support to them um and then the other thing I would say is I think I feels like I say this this about every year there's a day that I go to a school on a rainy day schedule and we should always always appreciate our teachers especially on rainy days because the work that they have to do um kids tend to be a little bit more hyperactive on rainy days when they're cooped up and um they lose a little bit of their um their lunchtime and not the well not well the kids too but the teachers and they Fe their downtime so they
014did I was at Vargus today and those teachers were fantastic okay so um now we're on to item number oh yes ma'am yeah I forgot one little thing I was volunteering yesterday in one of the classes at CMS and uh it was very encouraging to see the kids fire up about something they care about so they were they wanted to do a protest and they decided to H go outside the classroom they were warned that if they were chosen to do that they were going to have an absent and their parents will be immediately receive a call because the computer already will send them the C that they were absent and you know was a little bit of a parents calling how what do you mean that you don't have my key what's going on
015but it was uh you know it was very calm it was very nice they made their own they made their own poster and they went out and they walk very quietly around the field so they got like two extra hours of exercise actually and and then they went back to to the classroom so that was that was very interesting and very encouraging to see how they support each other and how they they care about something and they decided to do it in a peaceful minimal way so Kos to that thank you okay um item number eight is comments from the Sunnyville Education Association I don't see anyone here present in the room is there anyone online who's a representative of sea they don't have hand okay may me later um number nine comments from the
016California School Employees Association if there's an official representative online please use the r hand feature if you wish to speak okay see none uh item 10 comments from the public so this is the time to for the public to comment about things that are not on the agenda this portion of the agenda provides the opportunity for members of the public to directly address the governing board on any item of interest to the public however provisions of the brown act government code 549 54.2 a and3 preclude any action being taken on an item not appearing on the posted agenda time limits allocated to public testimony are 3 minutes per person and 20 minutes for public comments speakers are asked to give their name and affiliation so that an accurate record is reflected in the minutes um
017I do have one card on item 10 is there anyone online for item 10 no okay um then M Courtney jensson you are up um oops I think is it working working okay just angle um hi I'm Courtney J and SEL K my comment is actually completely uncoincidentally un not connected intentionally to what trusty Watson was going to say or did say um and I just wanted to note that with what the current Administration is doing going on particularly in terms of diversity initiatives and so forth that I want to take a moment to make sure that you guys know that I and many many other parents in the district um hope that you continue to celebrate things like black history months Pride months um I think there's Native American month Hispanic Heritage Month and
018all of those months that are so important for honoring and highlighting the diversity and importance ofin our community and I know that we are already in February and I admit that I can't remember if there is any black history amount stuff at our school at the moment so if you're already doing it thank you for keeping it up and if you aren't doing it um please get on it because February is already on the 6th so thank you thank you very much okay um I do not have another card for 10 there's no one else online so public comment on that item is closed all right um item 11 review and discussion the Strategic plan goal progress update uh with Chief teaching and learning officer Dr Tasha making my way over okay thank you and
019good evening board uh this is an exciting time for me and my team and community members as well it's a great opportunity for you to be here to hear some of the wonderful things that we've been doing uh so the emphasis is this is building along the year so we started our updates regarding our strategic plan in October of 2024 we're going to continue on those upat updates and we're going to start um with our emphasis around some of our data we've changed how we're looking at data what we're doing with data um and trying to improve our transparency about the data and so that's a lot of what tonight is about so we're going to start with our remarks um with performance fact mat you will be coming and highlighting some of the data
020um achievements that we have and also some challenges that we're um working with but he will present that and then we'll come back and Elevate some of the other exciting work that's happening good evening everyone nice to see you all thanks for having us be uh part of the journey can you hear me so far yes uh my part is brief because the The Narrative you know what I call the real story will be told by those who follow me uh folks in uh tnl uh what I like to do in two parts sort of ground the presentation briefly and highlights of the Strategic plans so we always go back to what we set out to do and I give a status report since the September data that you saw just to added data to
021it um let's see fcy clicker okay now this strategic plan the one of the most rousing parts of the plan for Sunil is the uh is the promise and from the promise we also have the port of a graduate and we have some specific goals for goals specifically for this school year two of those goals have been highlighted goal number one and goal number four and specifically for goal number one the focus is on measure uh 1B and to some extent um measure 1D so the data we're going to share this evening will be an update on measure 1 B and also on measure 4 a and 4 B okay so an update on nurturing and inclusive environment and then on the uh academics part of it the this slide I want to pull it
022out because it shows uh some of the best practices when it comes to implementing a strategic plan as you may have heard or maybe experienced yourself most plans fail because the planners don't follow through uh I really have to commend uh Sunny B for following through when I was putting this together I try to go through row by row to see to what extent are we is the the process of implementing even if we're not quite there yet even if the data doesn't quite show up are we approaching the implementation process in the right way and uh the very first role we've done that's strategic plan the next role is getting very clear about the goals for this school year and that's taking place at the school level and also at the district level it's
023the district level uh component that I'm going to focus on uh every week I know there's instructional monitoring going on every month uh I I can't speak credibly on the every month piece around capacity building but this evening meeting for example it's about the last two roughly every 6 to 12 weeks or at least twice a year mid end of the year there's a report to the board and therefore directly to the community also if that status update and we're going to give oh now okay so uh if you can switch the the data please I'm going to do the overview and again the uh personal H portfolio on uh Dr Dean's team will get into the details okay we call this a vital sence scorecard uh those measures that I alluded early on are
024the vital science with monitoring and again specifically just four of them for this school year and the first one thank you it's looking at attendance specifically regular attendance and regular attendance is defined as minimum 90 90% attendance in school and class so you're looking at the trend lines for uh September and also for uh December slight dip between those two that 3 month uh interval interval but not specific not terribly worrisome possibly for the specialized students and also to some extent for Hispanic students at some great levels but overall the the trend line is very strong you have the the data on the bottom part uh can I Advance with this keep going okay so in addition to looking at attendance which we measure of the students we also monitoring the adult practices as we've
025said many times it's adult practices that are the preconditions or precursors of how how well students perform so the what I shared with you before the outcomes for students this page identifies progress on the practices or strategies that the adults are focusing on as the drivers of student attendance and there's a Target that set at 100% for uh practice number one which is about conducting twice monthly attendance meetings you can see that for the November that was met 100% the metric around try letters being sent to students who should be receiving them uh no data to report at this point and you can see the differ with number three weekly s meetings uh last 4 months ago 5 months ago was around a third and this last reporting cycle was 100% and uh for the
026attendance education Communications home no data for the current cycle so that's the quick update on the first goal um and later on Paul is going to get into more detail about what we what that what actually happened programmatically the last two sections will be around the go number four which the academics goal and we're presenting of growth data and also achievement data so the top of the page shows the proportion of students by student group for those two uh four versus winter and it shows the percent of students who are Med proficiency standards that's the top layer the bottom one shows the growth data for by students group uh the gray bar would be percentage of all students in that particular group who are made standards the yellow will be the percentage of students who
027have not yet met standards but are making significant growth right so we're tracking both growth and achievement and then the third one will be the percentage of uh students who have already met standards and are still making sign significant growth and all three are really quite encouraging the gray would be average for that student group meeting standards B not meeting standards but meeting the growth Target and then C will be met stands already and still exceeding the growth Target and again you you hear more from Jonathan about what happened programmatically uh the I won't get into a lot of detail on the uh on this slide on the next one so these are the practices identified for this year next one and then for math we have the same breakout and we have the practices
028data also okay so overall I see in terms of just the discipline of implementing we on the right track it's a little bit too early to we have only two data points at this point but by the end of the school year we should have three or four and one of the things we will be looking for be to to what extent does the practice data predict how KS perform that's something we'll be keeping an eye on be have to take your comments or questions if that's appropriate at this point thank you thanks we just wait till the end of the presentation and then we'll do public comment and then we'll do questions is that acceptable that would be wonderful thank you so the pickup um where mat left off with regards to our um
029data some of the hard data and the slides that will be coming forth there will be some additional data but it's more so to help uh celebrate and Elevate some of the um practices that are making up some of that data so as we move forward we're going to be looking at basically how we are approaching closing the achievement Gap um for our students um also looking at um in the presentation how we're accelerating growth what that looks like what does that mean in actual adult practices um looking at our instructional leadership what does that look like and how we're supporting and then what have been some of our responsive um adjustments based upon what we're learning in the moment week to week month to month and so with that we are hoping that um
030this does a good job of showing where we've grown since October what we've learned what the successes are what the challenges are and most importantly how we're ensuring that we're keeping our promise to our students and so with that I'll turn it over to I believe yeah I just I get I'm moving forward yeah make sure good evening board um so always a balancing act between giving you enough information for your discussion also not taking up the time so you have time for discussion so I will try and highlight a couple of things as we go through um something that we keep going back to is we know that the number one impact on student learning is teacher quality and also the number two impact on Student Success is principal quality so we keep working
031on these two simultaneously and this comes from a wide body of research um part of our work is balancing urgency we feel a lot of urgency to make sure that all of our students continue to make growth and also capacity like how do we build skills with our staff members um who may be learning new ways of teaching students and also adapting the student needs um so we've been working off of a general model which really centers our principles um as the instructional leaders at the site so we've really been working on providing them a lot of support um being really clear about their goals and expectations um working on professional development for them and also their sites walking through classrooms so we can see the impact in the class room um and then also
032looking at our data so we keep working through this cycle in all of our different content areas um but I thought this was a graphic that might help illustrate the work that we've been doing um this in turn has increased collaboration between sites so sites are able to talk to each other like oh like tell me about your data in third grade can I come over and see that teacher and there's been benefit to that um it also allows us to leverage this the successes and the um skills of each of our different principal groups see if if I missed anything keep going um John's going to talk to us a little bit about data literacy so some of the pieces around expectation setting is really being clear about how much growth we want to
033see in our student group groups and how we're going to track it um as Dr Dean said we we're looking at data in new ways so we keep wanting to refine that so we have accurate data and also that that helps us inform instruction so John has a good example um of the work that we've done with penes okay so I'm going to go over a little bit this is um this is nwaa data which we take for math kindergarten through 8th grade and then reading um this particular assessment third through 8th grade um so just this a quick little kind of overview this year something that we're looking at more than we have before and kind of is a new metric that we're really intentionally making sure that uh principles starting with principles and
034then teachers know which is this growth metric so for a long time we have definitely looked at achievement like are they at grade level are they approaching those types of terms in proficiency bands but actually looking at growth is something that we found is a lot more actionable it um it allows us to utilize our time better so that we can actually look at students that may be um not yet proficient but are growing at a really really good rate that gives us information about what we're doing is working with them um or alternatively a student that is already proficient but maybe is growing um or declining like their growth rate is actually below the 50th percentile and they're actually declining a little bit like now that's something that we need to pay attention to
035so the achievement isn't telling the whole story growth tells a much more in-depth story about like the success of the work that we've put into it so the neat thing about this chart that we've been working with principles and teachers is the little pluses and squares um one of those represents math scores one of those represents um reading scores each one is a student and it's showing you the quadrant here of where are they in their proficiency and their growth so right now if we're looking at growth see the left and the right up and down so the higher you get that means that they're growing more so you can see like there's a bunch clustered up there all the way in above the 90th percentile so they're growing incredibly fast more than the majority
036of or faster than the majority of their peers and this is a nationally normed test so it's not just like comparative within Sunnyvale but they've normed Across the Nation and this is versus achievement so those that are over to the right of that midpoint you can say are more or less at grade level proficient going to the left that's now decreasing in proficiency so we want to be at above the 50th percentile we found looking at our data that the 60th percentile correlates really strongly with cast being proficient on cast so anywhere 60th and over to the right would mean proficiency wise that they're doing they're doing well um and then looking here so every everyone in that top right quadrant that would be they are growing fast and they are achieving so they're they're
037both proficient and they're keeping up that accelerated rate of growth everyone on the left hand side that would be low achievement below proficiency but the neat thing about this is it'll also highlight students that if you're just looking at their proficiency you may say oh my gosh this student is really far below grade level they have a lot of work to do in foundational literacy or other areas um and that can sometimes be discouraging to see that if you have a large group of students that may um fall into that category but the really encouraging thing is seeing your hard work pay off with the growth so what we've done is we've run a lot of different data and I looked kind of backwards mapping certain students and looked at the growth rate that within
038a reasonable amount of time they can get to proficiency and the 70th percentile is both it's a stretch goal but it's it's reason it can be done I've looked across the district we have some teachers that can definitely push the majority of their kids there and so it's it's a possible goal we can do it um and so we're setting out the 70th percentile as our growth Target um and really making sure to communicate that both with administrators and then having them in turn talk with teachers looking at their data um and kind of looking like what successes do we have when a student who's not proficient is actually growing at an extremely fast rate what's working with them what are we doing so analyzing the the the data in this way I think is
039really encouraging um and it also makes sure that you know proficient students aren't slipping behind just you know ignoring them because they're already proficient may ask a quick question um what is the St set that you ploted who is that I think this is a random class I'm not sure it's a third through eighth grade class yeah a random third or eighth grade class okay and that's staying for the previous slides the same random class seems like a lot of kids that much I actually don't know oh remember that each one each one of those plots is two yeah like every kid is two plots yeah CU it's they get a plot for Math and a plot for um for reading yeah than you they can also see this what's also needs you can see
040it at the district level School level so for principles they can see grade levels where the grade level averages in their growth and then you can dive in further and see okay which teachers are having a lot of success okay what are they doing let's let's investig all right I'm going to give us a snapshot into different pieces that we're doing in terms of what does this look like translated into the classrooms and what have we done to support our staff members um so across the district we've worked on professional development around learning and language goals zoretta Hammond and her work around cultur responsive pedagogy in the brain tells us that it's super important for students to know what they're working on and why it's important and how it connects to their past learning um
041that all goes to like brain research and being able to recall information and also make neural connections um that might seem like lwh hang hanging fruit in terms of like is there a learning a language goal posted on the board um but from a teacher perspective it actually has a lot of depth to it because that way teach when we have learning language goals one we provide linguistic access for our multilingual Learners so um I just threw in a quick YouTube video that you can watch at another time um but this is Jose Medina he talks about why language goals are important um it provides linguistic access for our students who may have cognitive knowledge that isn't recognized in our classrooms but when we give our students language to talk about their learning they're more
042capable of doing that um and you hear kids using it like and they use big vocabulary and they're very proud of it we love it um but from a teacher perspective many of our California state standards are very Broad and big and you can't teach all that within a lesson um teachers have to really Target what the lesson is in that 30 minutes of time in that 45 minutes of time so when they do that they match the assessment in that time period to the language and learning goals and then they can see am I successful and all that leads to the 70 % growth Target that John was talking about um so that's one of our goals across the district in all content areas the another the other one that we' really been focused
043on this year in our district inst structur student talk routines this is ways these are ways for students to process information that affirms again um linguistic traditional um cultural linguistic backgrounds where oral processing is part of learning um we want students to be able to process information I know that I do better when I talk to a neighbor and like did I get that did I understand it um so we want our students to be able to do that same processing in classroom before they have to answer a question um so we've worked on these across the district because these are high leverage research-based strategies that have impact we've seen that Across the Nation um at elementary school a offshoot of these two is collect and display so I threw in a quick graphic here
044it's related to our bath curriculum I am um but it's a way of collecting what the students are doing and you display it but the students orally process and explain what they've been doing um they have to they justify what it looks like but all the things around learning language goals structures you talk lead into um collecting this way keep going oh too fast um these next slides I'm going to go over go through briefly professional development that we provided around curriculum and pedagogical practices and then I'm going to move into what we're working on I'm not going to talk to you through all the slides I'm just going to give you broad overviews um so so in English language arts we've really been doing a lot of professional development focused on interventions so ufly
045materials um really great reading these are all really focused on um phonics and phonemic awareness so the building blocks of reading the reason why we've been doing this is it encompasses the science of reading and that was a gap in our previous curriculum um we want to make sure that our students have all those basic building blocks and we have it structured systematic and it builds up on each other um that's the the benefit of a strong phonic program um we've also really been working on a newcomer curriculum as you know U we've had a number of newcomer students come in from other countries um in increased amount over the last two years and so our sites were saying we really need a specific curriculum to support them in the classroom um so we work
046on that as well of course Middle School keeps working on differentiating instruction and making sure that all the students needs are met in math uh we've been doing a lot of professional development around what does math look like now um so just a brief overview in California the new math framework outlines a very different way of learning and teaching math I think it's very different than how I learned um how to do math and we was talking with a family earlier um just in this boardroom about how we learned how to do algorithms and I did multiplication times taes um we really want to support our teachers in learning new ways of approaching mathematics where it's conceptual all students can do math that idea of like I don't know how to do math is actually
047something that we build and Foster all kids can do math we have just help support them in learning and acknowledging that they can think about mathematics if I go back to that earlier collecting display example kids are like I see three and I see two awesome you just did three plus two is five but they don't see that unless we point it out to them so it's just a very different way of us teaching mathematics and we have new curriculum at elementary school with IM and new curriculum at middle school with ADM um and I am so here in in terms of um like program updates and where we are I do want to highlight um number three in progress here that we are currently exploring options for our comprehensive Ela ELD pilot potentially for
048next year um from a state level we are off cycle with adoptions the new math framework um was delayed and postponed and delayed and postponed over a number of years um and so we we've actually been off cycle for a little bit that being said where we are now as a district is we've been able to be more diagnostic about where students are um with our assessments with that our teachers are seeing that I could fill in gaps around fluency around word morphology and our curriculum doesn't match those needs now it it did however many years ago when we adopted it because we didn't know that these were the gaps that we wanted to identify so as a district we're hearing from our staff members we would like to look at a more comprehensive program
049for both Ela and ELD these two are connected in the framework and so that's something we're looking at exploring for next year um here in terms of middle school I think I want to highlight here that we're in year two of amplify um but the themes in amplify Ela really do Foster both a love of reading because we want students to like reading and also the science of reading um there's one like train of thought of like will we do one or the other and we really want both for our students we want them to enjoy the reading process reading for information being able to make an argument and also have the skills to do those things um in mathematics I think what is really exciting is what we've seen in our student classrooms um
050we hear students talking about math I was in a kindergarten classroom a week ago um the kids all said I love math and I'm very smart and they chanted it and it was amazing to hear um but they were good at math and they were really smart um so they weren't just saying it they were doing it they were um subitizing numbers they were able to explain what they were thinking they work in pairs and they do the structure student talk um but we're seeing that and we're also seeing that our teachers from last year to this year have made a lot of um internal reflection and growth and also they feel a lot more confident with I am as a KN curriculum which is very exciting um same in middle school this is a
051a example that I took from a middle school classroom um I know you have to zoom in a little bit but a great example of learning language goals here in Jess Clark's classroom also a word bank that gives students language to talk about what they're doing um but we keep working on all the same things at middle school with more dep more depth because the standards are larger just we want depth everywhere um something that we do believe in is that coaching is valuable instructional coaching is valuable this is a shift in our district in our coaching model um so have our coaches Been instrumental across a number of years they have been they've been providing a lot of coaching support which may look like I'm making materials for you to use in your classroom
052a shift for us is working on coaching for instructional practice change um what I do what I like to like in this to is working out because that's something that I'm always working on myself um can I work out on my own absolutely and if somebody always like helped me lift weights then I would never build a muscle on my own um a real good coach and trainer for me is somebody who coaches me to do it and then makes me do it um I'm not saying that I structural coach make teachers do it but we want to Foster the skill development for our teachers so they can continue to make changes in their practice after the coach leaves um and that's a shift for us in practice um from coaching support I'm going to
053help do things for you I'm going to give you resources which is also very valuable so I'm going to help you build skills so that you have them in place and that when I leave you'll continue to build your practice um we know that all teachers are skilled and our students needs vary over time so we want to make sure that our teachers can all meet their student needs the other piece is U us really working with our principles again like I outlined like that cycle where we're really working to support principles as instructional leaders we've been doing this over a number of years um but really I think where everything comes together is in classroom walkthroughs I know um Dr Gallagher Dr Dean and I walk regularly with principles we're looking at what's happening
054in the classrooms in in all the areas I just talked about learning and language tools structures student talk curriculum use and how comfortable teachers feel and then like working with our teachers to have them build a reflective practice um ultimately that's the the goal like what happens in the classroom makes the largest impact on students so before I wrap up this section like we again we know that teachers have the best biggest impact on student learning principles have the second biggest impact and they impact the entire site so we keep working on supporting our principal group in their instructional leadership and then balancing this urg capacity um to make sure that our students all have what they need all right over to Linda hi I'm Linda director of special education um I just want to
055remind the board we're talking about performance and closing the Gap and when we have a student with special education identified needs we start with IEP goals those are written always at grade level standards and they're allowing the child to approach the grade level curriculum which is going to show up on our local benchmarks which is going to show up on our state benchmarks so we really wanted to focus on the adult practice of the posting of language and learning goals but when you think about a special day classroom you've got mult multiple grade levels and you don't only have multiple grade levels but you have a wide gap of abilities within those grade levels so posting a goal on the board for all of those students isn't as applicable and posting the goals is not
056the point the point is do the kids know what they're working on is it individualized for them do the par Educators playing the small groups know what they're working on so we really wanted to focus on those practices and we wanted to hear how much student talk was going on so to collect this information this period to share with you we took four members of our Special Education team we went out to all the special day classes multiple times we did small group math and Ela instruction so we had multiple viewpoints at multiple times and we're in and out of those classrooms all the time so the teachers felt very comfortable they didn't suddenly change their practice sometimes they knew we were coming and sometimes they didn't so here's what we found I have never
057been prouder of our special day class instruction than I am this year I've been doing this for a while and we've provided very targeted support for our teachers and parent Educators to really affect their small group instruction we have given Paris um training in the curriculum we've been coaching them and we've been doing we sorry we've been doing coaching Cycles so what we saw was pretty impressive the kids could tell us what they were working on the parents could tell us what they were working on and time is being really well used in class but we're never going to be satisfied with what we saw so what we did from our walkthroughs is we made a list of um some other supports that we could give teachers for a quick 3 to four week coaching
058cycle things that will immediately affect student outcome and our principles are really involved they do data Cycles with our special ed teachers but we also want them to see through our lens of what they saw so I have a walk through with a principal coming up next week just kind of building that knowledge of the special education practices but again our principles are really involved and just to say it again we know that posting goals isn't the point the point is can you communicate those goals to the students and and to the parent Educators working with them and one thing that um we asked one of our teachers like what's your experience with small group instruction and the supports we've been giving you and um this is a quote that you can read but what
059I loved about it was the students voice because one of our um profile of a sunal learner is a lifelong learner and here's a child in a special day class and he is he's taking responsibility for his learning with confidence and he's taking challenges he's got a growth mindset and in this class all nine of her students to growth on the nwaa for both reading and math some little and some big changes but we're going to celebrate all of them that's it for me and now we will go to Paul thank you Linda hi everybody um my name is Paul Slayton I'm the director of student support services today we're going to go over some climate and behavioral data uh full caveat we will be reviewing the Panorama survey data in detail during our lcap
060midyear update but there were a couple of highlights that I wanted to pull for the two domains there's a survey given to grades 3 through five which is separate from grades 6 through 8 and we'll talk briefly about both again just identifying two bright spots and one obvious area of growth there are more of each in the full data for today though we're going to talk also about completion rates from Spring to uh from 2324 to 2425 and again those ideal kind of areas we wanted to highlight fall of 23 we had a 76.4% completion rate this is among students completely so grades three through eight this year for our fall survey we went up to 79.4% that is a good survey response rate we also would like to improve that to where we have
061as high as possible a response rate the family and staff response rates are more of a struggle and we'll talk about what we're doing to kind of accomplish increasing those when we discuss the oap the schools are broken out there by response rate for students and SMS the team did some of the same work they do to publicize Provide support for and they had a definite dip in response rates this past administration uh they have a plan moving forward but it is aberant to see one of the middle schools have response rates that are that much lower starting with grades three three through five an area that we wanted to highlight was students sense of belonging uh these are very small question sets at the grade three through five level that much of an increase
062is exceptional it's really good to see students responding saying there are adults in the school system that care for them if they have problems um that's General enough for a third through fifth grader to understand and we do love seeing an increase that's that significant with the caveat that we don't want to say that means we have achieved belonging schools because there is a lot of variance from Fall to spurring around this data and again with some of the other questions there's a larger question set and that's important to acknowledge as well another area where we saw an increase in grades three through five with students reporting that they had um felt that they had self-management ability I'm trying to pull up the actual questions here and having a hard time but self-management is seen
063around around when you have a problem can you resource solving that problem or at this grade level finding an adult that can help you do that these are not only academic problems these are things when there's something soci emotional going on in the classroom um down to like if you feel lonely can you talk to somebody and get some help at the school moving on to an area that we want to see some growth the idea of supportive relationships and these are academic and non-academic is critical in grades 3 through five and we did see almost a 10% decline in students self-reporting that they saw that they felt they had supportive relationships um this is both in the home and in the school and again when we talk about our midyear lcap update we'll get
064more detail on where that broke down but I went ahead and combined them for us here and this is students reporting a decline and them feeling that they had relational support not just academic and not just socio emotional not just at school and not at home but all of that combined for the middle schools uh kind of a flat trajectory here but really critical to report for middle school students to report any self-efficacy is pretty impressive and to have that sustain over three survey administrations uh is statistically significant and means whether students actually can have self-efficacy in the kind of situations them self-reporting that is a critical element to them actually being able to self- Advocate or call for help or admit when they're struggling so self-reporting that you have efficacy as a middle school
065kid is wonderful whether or not we see them implementing that is kind of the next metric and we want to go a little deeper into that when we go into our lcap uh this again significant increase in students being able to demonstrate self-management if we go back far enough especially preo and even during covid this was an area that was not something we saw students reporting High numbers in at all self-management is being able to accomplish tasks to manage things like homework and schoolwork um we'll talk again in detail but that kind of increase is encouraging especially since we're giving students what we're going to talk about in a moment which is that integrated seal not having a discret portion of the day where they're learning a lesson about bullying but integrating throughout curriculum that
066we talk about what it means to have self-confidence and to get help if there are problems Middle School is still Middle School though and we did see a drop in students feeling they had a growth mindset growth mindset can be summarized as the can I be anything and do anything um if you know any middle schoolers and I'm not trying to be snippy at all this is an area where there's a reluctance and a hesitancy when you ask a kindergartner what do you want to be they have an answer when you ask a middle schooler what they want to be some have an answer and the idea that they can be you know college going is kind of where we want to go and while we don't ask that question specific specifically we want to
067increase students self-reporting that they can grow and learn and struggle and succeed moving on to some behavioral data we talked about this data last time we spoke and these bar graphs across overall students English Learners Hispanic students Hispanic Hispanic English Learners and students with disabilities these are students who are on track for Behavior the threshold for this is really important because these numbers are great we're like oh my gosh 99% of kids this means no more than 2% of the running total of school days with a behavioral referral the reason we do that is behavioral referrals that means an incident in the classroom that went outside the teacher's ability to manage it within the class so if the student needs a break outside that's an incident that's something you report because they had to leave
068the learning environment this is still incredible that teachers are managing this much Behavior inside the classroom environment um those numbers going from 2324 to 2425 year to date that's the difference between those two color columns um the increase in reporting was something we expected to negatively affect these numbers meaning we wanted teachers to report and feel hey this is non-punitive we're not trying to find out how many kids Mrs Smith sends out trying to find out what our kids are going through and increasing in the number of documented referrals did occur which is good across all schools and didn't effect that students are still spending the majority of their time in the classroom in the learning environment we do however have discipline that requires suspension hopefully as a formative consequence data over time it looks
069great but these last numbers are year-to date and one of the board questions was are there busy months and there are every year and you don't know when they're coming there's always a fall spike in referrals and suspensions and there's always a spring Spike they're not always connected to breaks or the time change but there's always theories about why this occurs having 62 suspensions year-to date is fantastic um I do feel like teachers and administrators are using alternatives to suspension which is critical but suspension and that temporary break from the learning environment can be really important for a student understanding how Behavior works we talked about this before but these numbers are total numbers of suspensions not total numbers of students who were suspended so some students have multiple suspensions over time some students have
070one and then never again go through that so these do not break out by individual student however these next ones do these are the numbers of students that were suspended under each of our focal subgroups the reason the totals don't of the numbers that have different color coding don't equal the number at the top is a student can be multiple categories a student can be a student with a disability and an English learner and they were marked there twice so we wanted to show the breakdown of which students were suspended when uh one of the board members pointed out in the packet that we do have disproportionality in suspension that is a very complex and important issue doesn't have a simple fix the things that are fixable we don't have in sunnday Veil things like
071a zero tolerance policy uh that can be just terrible for students around disproportionality what that means is there's a mandatory um administrative response if there's a certain action we don't have that here except for very extreme behaviors so not having a zero tolerance policy a step towards reducing disproportionality there are others and we can talk about them in detail but we are on the right track to saying we don't want our administrators suspending kids as their first response to behavior for our students that are receiving bikini vento Services uh these numbers are really tricky to decide which number you're going to use the number for 2324 these are students that ended our school year receiving theck Kinny vento Services the peak number uh for that year I think was 73 students total some of those
072students moved out of our district some received permanent housing and didn't end the year receiving Services same thing for that second number uh regardless of the how we calculate our mcken vento population of students that received homeless support their attendance this year is pretty remarkable um the fact that 93% are on track for attendance is a lot to do with our social workers and school Outreach assistance this is a very volatile number and it can change dramatically um anecdotally we have a student whose mom looks like she got employment the employment is far outside our district his attendance has been low because he has not yet enrolled in his new District that number would change because we don't drop that student we keep them until we know they landed in a new school district so
073our goal isn't keeping a High attendance number it's making sure we don't lose a student receiving homeless Services by trying to disenroll them aggressively um there's no pressure to do that in fact the opposite is true we'd rather say we know you're not here but we're not going to drop you and we're not going to stop calling until we know you're enrolled somewhere else finally uh another note on the integrated seal work it would be probably worth sometime having a student or a teacher from each School site talk about their different token economies and little notes and Rewards there are too many to capture but um Dr Dean saw this one when we went and did our site like our cabinet visit at Ellis they have a thing called the notes from the nest and
074when there's a faculty meeting the card in the upper left there's a stack of these on each table and during that kind of like unusual just everybody's talking thing at the beginning teachers can write these to any of their students and then they just hand them over and the main office staff processes them either delivers them to the kid or mails them and then the yellow note and green note are um students parents that responded about what it was like for their kid to get a note from The Nest um it's a lot and teacher it's been made to fit that blank moment in the faculty meeting when nothing's going on and it just means a ton if two or three teachers a two or three if each teacher does two or three of these
075each faculty meeting that means kids are getting a personal note from a teacher just saying hello hey noticed you did a good job reading and that's just amazing so things like this are occurring at all schools these are not standardized and delivered from the district these are kind of emergent which is the goal because delivering a second step lesson is also good but this would resonate better than just teaching a lesson we want to do both but for now we are seeing that students are feeling connected to their school I think I'm handing back to Dr Dean thanks Dr de great thank you team for those wonderful updates and just want to kind of let you know where we're headed uh we're moving forward we're celebrating our progress sometimes it's hard for me I'm a
076coach in basketball as well as academics and so I want to win and there's no different about our kids learning so what is the question we're asking ourselves we're asking ourselves what does it look like when 100% of our kids are are maximizing their learning and their proficient so are we excited about all the scores and where they're hanging out no but are we excited about our progress yes we are we are addressing our challenges we're focusing in on fostering relationships we are strengthening our instructional leadership practices and forward and we continue to focus on our datadriven decisions um both at the district level the site level down to the student level we're working to get there Contin continuing to focus on our inclusive um Excellence um and ensuring that there are not um um
077achievement gaps and in particular for our historic underserved um populations we feel like we are um establishing a collaborative culture and that being transparent about data is a place that we're getting to and so we excited about that and we know that together continuing this work we will continue to build the foundation for every student to thrive academically and personally so at this time board we'd love to hear additional questions input and guidance that you may have for the team um as we move forward thank you thank you very much um Dr Dean um so if there's any this is another one yes okay um so if there's any member of the public online or if you're present in the room and you haven't already submitted a card and you'd like to speak on this
078presentation uh please fill out a card now if there's any member of the public online who wishes to speak on this item please use the raised hand feature now um otherwise I will need a speaker card um how many cards how many speakers do we have online three so far three so is that one okay so I'm getting more more fingers four on the back four on the back um so do I see another card getting filled out right now yes okay let just count these one more time yeah so Bo we have um we have 11 speakers so I'm going to call it now with 11 speakers um so we can either give them two minutes each or if we give them um we we also give them two and a half minutes each
079two minutes each we make get 20 minutes be a little over there's yeah I think just good okay um so let's call it at 4 online no more speakers and I'll accept this card if it's coming i' like to do two and a half minutes two minutes two two and a half well that would get us way over not everybody two and a half minutes but some people have prepared three minutes so um B what did you say two and half two do we have it just means less time for us to discuss so think you just make a decision I'm just waiting to see if this is another so two minutes okay two minutes it is um okay so back to this so our first speaker is going to be um go it might
080we a few it might be helpful to say hey this one's first second third so they kind of oh yeah okay so and then every couple times you can sure so our first speaker will be GA go go Goot you're gonna pronounce it better for me that's okay um this one I can paa thank you and then after that Sanji Kumar okay the next three um all right you have three two minutes thank you thank you so much I will send a more detailed comment via email because I prepare a longer comment um thank you s School District Tres Dr Giger and Dr Kean I want to start by sincerely thanking s school district for developing a strategic plan and actively seeking stakeholder input your commitment to shaping a strong vision for our children's future
081is commendable I also appreciate the district's engagement with special education parents whose input sessions had highest attendance reflecting their long-standing desire for Meaningful in involvement with our school district their voices were incorporated into the plan a crucial step forward um however deeper engagement um remains lacking a key request from the first stragic planning session and January 2024 to discuss forland data remains unfulfilled a year later while we appreciate the new data it lacks detailed school by school insights that for data provided making it harder to identify disparities and outcomes for special education students additionally the example highlighted in the present presentation is just one classroom I would urge you not to generalize it to every classroom out there on a positive note many specialist parents I've spoken to with thanks to Susan specialist committee setup
082um the monthly inclusion meetings feel district is genuinely willing to uh collaborate um unlike other districts parents resources um um parents advocacy has met with openness such as that resources remain focused on education rather than other issues the district has shown willingness to listen now I urge further investment in training with special education and general education teachers with a menu of effect intervention strategies for neur neurod Divergent students I have already advocated for just language processing and other methodologist um which were highly effective for this no single methodology can address every challenge but deep curiosity about underlying reasons behind student achievement or lack thereof can drive the search for Solutions tailored for each child after all these students have individualized education plans for a reason they deserve the opportunity to reach their full potential to
083and become productive citizens thank you so so much thank you okay um next up we have uh thank you then San Kumar and then after that I'll be Jesse J okay um good evening my name is paa I am a mom of um a special education kid in Cumberland so I would like to um uh talk about a little bit of our experience this year so imagine to be a child who drives on routine predictability and Trust only to have their own world turn upside down again and again my neurodivergent child has been navigate eight different teachers this year five different par Educators and revolving door of Behavioral therapists each change means starting over re learning expectations rebuilding trust uh rebuilding Trust and struggling with new teaching styles so for that reason um these kids
084doesn't um started uh the academic part until recently and it's just the beginning of the year so we just lost half of the year but the challenge does does stop there to to keep up with general education peers we have to have we have had to homeschooling in the afternoons that means extra hour of work more frustration and constant exhaustion instead of fostering learning this instability creates anxiety regression and burnouts not only for just for my child but for our entire family and for all the families whose kids are in the same special day class in Cumberland elementary consistency is not a luxury for neurod divent students it's a necessity we need better stability in Staffing proper support structures and concrete plan to ensure these kids aren left behind and are and they are be
085ready for next school year thank you thank you okay next up is Sanjay Kumar after that I'll be Jesse ji and then Courtney Jansen hi my name is Sanjay Kumar I have a couple of kids in S I have a daughter who's currently attending Fair and I have a a son in the SDC at uh at Cherry Chase I I want to make a comment about Fairwood Fairwood is a wonderful school but there is very little publicity provided about Fairwood even parents within the sunny School District don't have a clue what fawood is about and the parent participation is is amazing but from what I heard the enrollment and fed is dropping so my urge is please increase the publicity for fed it's a great school a school of that level in in Santa Clara
086is like one of the most sought schools like milin which is a which is a lottery School whereas I feel like fedw has so much more potential uh to be one of the Great Schools and my second point is uh based on my volunteering experience in Fairwood where I actually volunteered in my daughter's class and this is kind of related to special education as well and again because I have a son of special education and from what I noticed language comprehension continues to be a challenge for kids on the Spectrum and what can we do to address the issue better and again I spoke to the the curriculum person and how do we find a balance better balance between between teaching facts vocabulary and grammar as opposed to opinions where I feel like the special
087education kids struggle a lot and my second observation again based on fedw and related to kids on the spectrum is that success School particularly the way it is thought which is very different from the model that we were that we were schooled is that it success is heavily based on Executive functioning managing oneself independently that's an area where kids on the Spectrum consistently struggle so what better strategies and Linda had some ideas as well what better strategies can you have to sort of help them succeed on on a daily basis which will help them Lear better thank you thank you okay next up is just ji followed by Courtney Jansen and then I think it's alikia bakala hello everyone um my name is Jesse jki I'm the mother of an eighth grader at SMS and
088a third grader at Vargas and I wrote out the speech and then I listen to the talk and it's very different so um I'm going to work on it on the fly a little bit here so part of that I'd love to address it'd be really amazing for the public if slides were a little bit clearer on the School Board website with regards to acronyms especially if you could spell out an acronym first time you use it if you could write a little bit more about what the data is so that the public can come in with more intelligent more reasonable questions for you I understand we may not be the top person in your group you're trying to communicate with but it still would be incredibly useful if we didn't have to look up
089every single thing every single time um anyway I wanted to say I'm very very excited about the potential for a new uh Ela curriculum um I have had terrible experiences with f f&p I'm not going to even try to say their names um and I wanted to just mention one thing that was said about balancing between phonics teaching and love of reading teaching and I want to say that phonics teaching is love of reading teaching I watched my own child go through fness and panel and hate reading and I took her aside and I taught her how to read phonetically and she's well above grade level she wants to be a writer she loves reading I have to pull books away from her now and none of that was happening when she was being told
090to look at a picture and guess what the word was um so I really hope that this group will look at a curriculum that is very scientifically based and really focuses on getting kids to read because they can't love to read if they don't know how to read um I shoot down all right thank you thank you feel free to um send us your board comments thank you Courtney Jensen then ala B and then cam okay I can't beat that but um okay so court aan and S Miguel parent um I will start by saying thank you for sharing the data I will be 100% freaked out a little bit when I looked at it and I saw the achievement numbers um and I know that's probably not what districts ever want parents freaking out
091is always a bad thing but thank you for sharing the data anyhow I think Jesse had some great suggestions um the presentation was helpful Jeremy answered my some of my questions earlier so thank you also to Jeremy do please do acronym I spent a really long time trying to figure out why about principles and the Associated Press so then I realized that's not what you're talking about which made a lot of sense but acronym SP that would be great um it would also be really helpful to see data broken about between elementary school and middle school because well K8 is important there are lots of times where the UN Middle School experience is so much different from the elementary school and frankly I want to know what my kids are going to do now and
092then where they will go so that split would be really super helpful um I also really appreciate the changes that are being made to the curriculum I also noticed that FMP is still listed there um so maybe one other comment is that now that we know that the structured literacy programs really do need a lot of supplemental material uh what can we do to encourage teachers um and have those teachers tell us hey these ideas have worked well this curriculum has been great um and really take feedback from the teachers especially in the context of teachers who have had success and someone mentioned it um you know those teachers that are hitting that 70% growth and how do we take those learnings and um incorporate in particular particularly for kids who are struggling and behind
093and I will leave the note that tying back to my first comment um it's great to see the Improvement in sense of belonging and things like celebrating Black History Month and pride month and so forth are other ways to help make sure that our kids and those kids particularly know that they are belong belonging belonging and they are important and valuable to us so um thank you very much thank you okay next is the col and then C Santos thank you yeah this is Alika first of all I would like to thanks Anil school district for supporting our kids I would like to talk more about comprehension related issues today my son attend second grade uh in La special education and also he attends general education for half of the time he's good in math
094but he has issues with the comprehension like if anybody ask him how would he came up with a solution he cannot explain that so that is one of the concern I really had and uh I'm really uh worried that he might fall apart in the further grades if he's not able to explain what how he's approaching the problem so that is one thing I would really uh want the school to address especially in each kids case how they are going to handle it and what is the criteria and how are they going to address those challenges especially on each kid's case more than the generalized uh view that you are showing earlier and also when his worksheets are returned home after each trimester I see he he cribl in most of the pages but with
095help and support he's able to finish most of them at school so he had to spend the extra time uh at home to resolve all the problems and finish his work so so he has to spend extra time so that would be like extra work and pressure on him as well so I would like to uh see like how school can address those kind of challenges and provide better support to the kids who are struggling towards their curriculum related activities and also if school can provide the weekly comments about what they have been working on kids progress that week and communicate with cor parents so that both of us can work on the same goal uh and will be on the same page thank you thank you okay let's start K Santos um hello good
096evening hello board um thank you everyone for sharing this strategic plan um with uh with us um I just have uh just two quick questions um it's just uh for how long is a child considered an English learner is it until they pass out back or is or does it go after that um and if there is a followup with their progress um in terms of English proficiency and also uh just I don't know maybe I didn't understand so well about uh why is it that um we see on the data that was explained to us uh we see English we see um Hispanic and Hispanic students English learner students and and and special ad and then we see overall why are they being singled out instead of if you can see the data for
097all students uh per se um yeah thank you okay um so we cannot oh yes online right great so um can you put through the first person for two minutes thank you so first up is Michael followed by Laura then Nancy newerk and then Maddie C hello can you yes we can uh hi my name is Michael Ward I'm a third grade teacher at Bishop Elementary School as a teacher I'm here today to Advocate on the behalf of my students I would like to begin by outlining some sobering truths about literacy instruction in our district if you're are Latino family enrolling your child in Sunnyville school that child has less than a 25% chance of learning to read proficiently this puts Sunnyville School District in the bottom 10% % of districts Statewide this number is
098especially alarming because Co cognitive scientists have proven that 95% of students are capable of learning to read proficiently when provided proper instruction it is clear that the students who are most in need of highquality instruction are not receiving it in our district I argue that this is not because these students are English language Learners yes many of them are Els but according to the elpac the majority of them are actually proficient in the speaking and listening domains they are simply not being taught to read let alone to write if we fully believe in our commitment to anti-racism and Equity we must first begin by teaching kids to read otherwise we will continue to perpetuate cycles of poverty and oppression teaching students to read begins with a highquality tier one literacy curriculum that aligns with the
099science of reading I ask the board why is it that our Tier 1 curriculum ftis and panel has received one of the lowest scores ever awarded according to the report the curriculum does not adequately address any of the five pillars of literacy and it is thus unsurprising why the writers of the curriculum are currently being sued for fraud last year's phonic adoption was promising but phonic is by its phonic by itself will not lead to higher reading achievement on the part of our students goal four of the Strategic plan states that we will ensure each student has access to standards aligned curriculum and materials our current curriculum does not fit this description adop in a high quality curriculum is a necessary first step in addressing our District's literacy crisis our students need adults who are
100willing to take Swift action to safeguard their fun their fundamental rights thank you Michel thank you you're at time thank you um may we have the next speaker please next up is Laura followed by Nancy newerk hi thank you for the opportunity to speak I would like to make two points the first is that the Serv is that SSD offers our students in special ed or with IPS are amazing I do not think my son would be where he would be without the people from his special education support teachers counselor and staff I appreciate the opportunity to give feedback my second point is that we can do better on how we support students in transitions from elementary school to Middle School my son was at San Miguel El school it was a neighborhood program with
101the same students every year because the other two classrooms are in hunos and then he transitioned to Columbia Middle School and which I love the people there and the support that they offer to my son the sooner we can support students with the fact that they will moving from a smaller School an elementary school to being in several different classes in middle school is important Elementary exic fund skills do not Prep School student for Middle School moving between classes having materials for multiple classes being organized it's great we have accommodations for students and those should stay but we also need to be Forward Thinking and build up the skills they will need to tackle challenges on their own the early we sport students by coaching them to be organized to support and repeat several times
102with individ skills and the word they need the better we will prepared for middle by doing better academically socially and in their health self-help skills and will re free up the resources to FOC and free up resources for SSD to focus on other areas of interventions for other students that's my feedback thank you for the time thank you very much okay and next next is Nancy new followed by Maddie C hello um I appreciate the work that has that has gone into this strategic planning process and how we continue to refine our um methods of assessment I would like to remind the public that this is the first cycle that we're doing and I'm excited about um how the format of reporting out um growth and progress is done in a meaningful way so that
103um there's more feedback about student progress and more Direction about the gaps that are being seen the next point that I would like to make is that I appreciate the engagement of the parents that are there and want to make sure that we continue to do the kind of Outreach that that we're um already doing um I am concerned about that um one area of of of drop in social emotional component and I have a question about when was the um testing done in the cycle um I'm sure that families are feeling more pressure because of changes in the administration um and things that they're hearing out in the community and I know that that is I know that that's impacting homes classrooms um and potentially attendance um so I appreciate the thoughtful and welcoming
104atmosphere that we have and the Outreach that's being done um to make sure that uh we can try minimize the impact on the growth that we're already seeing thank you thank you and is there a last person on L finally Maddie C thank you please go ahead um hi my name is mad Chang and sophomore and resident of Sunnyville and with this public I just wanted to share some of the concerns I shared with a I share with a previous teacher who just spoke about the current curriculum so for the fast for the past few months I've been working with low reading proficiency students at Bishop Elementary School with the ages ranging from 2nd to fifth grade and surprisingly it's the older age students who have the most trouble reading and have the lowest proficiencies
105from what I've seen and it's hard to imagine that these students who will be entering middle school next year where students begin to read 100 Pages complicated chapter books um which are actually a part of the curriculum and these students that I'm working with who are fifth graders can barely read simple sentences they struggle to read words like the word name or the where the word there like t h e r e and it's really heartbreaking to listen to to hear that low level of reading proficiency um more um moreover it's also really concerning to hear um the low amount of reading comprehension they actually have I don't think they understand understand what they're reading and while I have seen some improvement um with my time working with them by teaching them using phonics and
106using that kind of reading intervention I think there needs to be a change in the curriculum um we need to listen to the teachers who work with these kids daily who understand their struggles and know what's best for them because they are the ones on the front lines and I think we can it's like not okay to leave any of these students behind thank you thank you is that our final person online great okay so um with that I think we are going to move down the line in the past we asked a couple clarifying questions from for the um public there was there was one in particular if if if I can just shake that about why we call why we have categories such as um Hispanic English Learners and special education in our
107yes and then that person also asked how long someone is considered an English learn those are just technical clarifying questions so I I don't think can answer them yeah thank you regarding uh I think the uh note I took was singling out particular groups there's a combination of reasons for that for us um uh I'll start with um our strategic plan as a part of that process and collecting data um and talking to um our staff as well as our community um the data pointed to those were particular areas that as a school district we have not demonstrated the uh success that we need with those populations and so we wanted to call that out um explicitly so that we um are providing the level of attention and resources that we need to um so
108that's one aspect of of why those particular populations are being um called out the second is as a part of um our lcap and state requirements um um they are Target groups that are identified and some of those um are special education our English language Learners um lowincome farsy Youth and some others so the idea for this is just elevating to ensure that we're making these students the priority that they need to be and if there's deficiencies in what we're doing that we address what those deficiencies are and provide the level of attention that's needed to close the current achievement gr gaps so that's kind of how we there as far as English language Learners um there's a language survey when students are registered that's what prompts um um students moving into an El status
109initially and then there's testing and there's various identifications for that that student remains in the system as being a student who was originally but their status changes um with regards to the El status and uh Jonathan or Christina if I missed anything you want to add to that please yeah so the typically it tends to be the lpac so that is that is like the number one thing that um is the barrier for most students for reclassifying so by the time they get that lpac summited score of four most likely the the local measures that we have um fit along with that so that's really what it is um and I think as someone said a lot of times it is the reading and the writing domains that tend to be the more challenging for
110them so some of the things that we do um recently the states come out with some different kind of ways of looking at the data because some of those bands it's in you can get get a one a two a three or a four but the the two and the three bands they're so big that a student often might move from being a very low two to a really really high two um but it's still a two and so the the state has given more guidance on kind of breaking that in so we can actually now when we get the results back we can see the movement so we can say oh they were a low two they moved to be a high two um and then we can also get the information on the
111specific domains so we can say oh it was reading so the reading was the only domain that was holding them back and teachers are looking at that and same with the administrators um and trying to Target like okay these students were the lowest doming was in Reading they were you know a summative three they're almost there so let's really focus on getting that reading domain up so that we can reclassify them um and then I think you asked about monitoring afterwards so once they're reclassified when they do get that summative four and we we reclassify them as fluent English proficient um we monitor them for four years afterwards also so we continue um every and we have a process where even in middle school all of the teachers put input into how they're doing with
112their language um so they they don't leave our radar like we we want to make sure that even though they're reclassified we want to make sure that they're still keeping up and that they're not I'm sorry we can't have a back and forth discussion but you can always make an appointment and come and talk to the district office thank you um also did you want that's good oh um we we going to say that um for the question regarding the Cumberland classroom that um the superintendent will arrange it I'll be in contact he'll be in contact with you okay thank you okay so board um it's time for discussion uh why don't we start with um Isabelle do you want or did you want to do are you raising your hand no okay General oh
113no no sorry do we have a general like how much time we're planning to yeah I think we should take at least 15 minutes at least for 15 to 20 minutes that would be my preference and then we have a half an hour Yeah well yeah I my my main questions were about the as she was point out the curriculum for E ER that I remember that we changed and I I think I I asked this to to Mike before that we changed the curriculum for English Learners and then somehow we were we heard that we came back to the same well let's T why you answer the question so and then about the yeah sorry I don't think I heard the actual question I think they want to know what the plan is for
114the ELA curriculum okay I'm [Music] havea okay um so we'll tell you where we currently are and then um we somewhat alluded to kind of where we're headed with regards to next school year and what our plans are but I'm going to let Dr Valentine give you a bit of an overview because it's a little bit more involved than just a simple answer thanks um let me think I was trying to figure out how far back do we go um where we are right now is we have been piloting a designated ELD curriculum that's separate of newcomer curriculum for students whove recently entered the country but we've been piloting that at elementary school over the course of the year um through that pilot process and also because we have better progress monitoring measures in place
115right now um our teachers are are ready and seeing gaps in instruction and so they' asked like can we do a comprehensive pilot um comprehensive is both Ela and ELD full curriculum um what we're doing right now actually as of last month which is pretty fast in this land of curriculum um we worked with our team of principles to outline like what is our timeline what does that look like um how do we make sure that we support our teachers in implementing and then what do we do in the meantime before we adopt a full curriculum um so that's where we are currently I don't want to jump ahead of like where we are in communication um but we are exploring what that looks like for next year in terms of piloting materials at a
116state level um again I mentioned it we're out of cycle with curriculum adoptions um at the time that found panel was adopted I mean I it was a different time period I can't say what the all the thought process I would behind because I was in that this position at that time um and also I think think that the idea was that that would meet our needs at that time it it hasn't um and so last year we implemented really great reading um as a piece that we knew was missing in found pel classroom so phonics when weic awareness we knew that those were gaps in found ofel classroom and those are building blocks to reading so we brought that in we brought in hegr um curriculums to backfill the portions that we knew were
117missing in B panel um and now we're in a place where we realize that that's still not enough and that's why we're looking at a compreh as a pilot um hopefully that was a good summary I could we could spend a whole study session on literacy um the science of reading I think the parent said it like I just want to reiterate we do want students to learn how to read and we want them to love reading I'm not saying that one is more important than the other they're both very important um but we want both does that help yeah I think yeah there's some public comments and we've heard I've heard it that we need a comprehensive Ela ELD Cor um and I think what Dr Valentine is saying is we're in the process
118of developing that she doesn't want to get ahead of the messaging on exactly what the timeline is but like we're well aware every we all agree on that and it's just how do we do that in a thoughtful strategic way um that's going to have Buy in and helps us make the right decision thank you you have any other questions right now no questions Michelle uh um first I just want to say thank you and it was so cool too that like so many team members were part of it right just a reminder like the Strategic plan is like not a person in our district right that it is like really the whole District working on the Strategic plan so that was just kind of a cool thing as um you guys each were taking
119your turn coming up and sharing your pieces and you like clearly understand each other's pieces and so that was great um my only kind of question that I would love to like get a little bit more and if it's not tonight another time the the essentially the space related to you know goal four of acting Improvement and one of those pieces is the coaching Cycles right and our numbers on that aren't super great um and so I'm just again it can be another night um it does not to be tonight but I would just love to get a little bit deeper dive in that space um I know like Christina talked about just a little bit but I would just love to hear a little bit more um like what like right because it is
120it is kind of change of our culture and so just how um what the plans are to move the needle on that I have a question so are you before before you say something so I'm just wondering like as a clarifying Point are you interested in like what is your what is your question or thought around the coaching Cycles because I also have concerns about the coaching cycle number and the efficacy of it coaching Cycles because I when I think about those coaching Cycles I'm thinking teachers are voting with their feet with their time their time is so valuable and if a very low percentage of teachers continue to use coaching Cycles then per and they're saying that they're not getting the in their Panorama survey they're saying that they're not like feeling like the
121training is what they need maybe they're talking about different things but if it's been I haven't taught in the district since 2016 we had coaching Cycles then I used them really helpful for me but then I left so um it didn't you know was great for that year um but in general like that has been the constant tension right like do are people are people using them it's been a chall and so if people aren't using them and we're they're being used in other ways or they're just starting to be used like nine years later like maybe we should be doing something different with than this idea of the coach I mean in general like maybe we should do a deeper dive that or are you just saying like in general like are you just
122saying like in general like you want to learn more about the coaches uh I think mine's may be a little bit different in that I don't know exactly what you're saying I like not very me teachers are using it so I don't think we can say it's effective or not yet so I'm talking about specifically like whatever those numbers were is like the goal is like I remember 50% of the teachers are doing teaching cycles and it was like 10% were doingi your so that was more what I was referring to is to try to get to meet our goal what are the stuffs they're doing so what you're talking about I think is a deeper more comprehensive connected but a deeper more comprehensive no I'm saying I'm saying something similar I'm saying if we've
123had coaching cycles for over a decade well Dr Dean has a lot of thoughts on right so yeah that's say answer yeah so that's my question right we've been having them for over a decade teachers are voting with their time because it's optional and they're not seeing the value um so I'll emphasize three facts and I would say that yes maybe a deeper deeper dive might be needed so I'll start by saying that I will say that since I've been in the district which has been over the last 12 or whatever years right we've had coaching but I will say that as a district we've had some inconsistencies around that coaching I would say for the last three years we've been much more consistent and um many more coaching Cycles are actually happening I would
124say this year we were very intentional because of our uh communication last year and what we would be doing this year and so we have stuck to that and I think our principles are trying to be great partners with that I would also State I think I I don't know who said it of the board I'm sorry but it's not that teachers are not um welcoming and um and benefiting from the coaching we're just trying to be strategic on a few things one the effectiveness of our coaching our consistency of coaching our alignment of our practices and ensuring that when we say coaching and Sunnyville everyone is articulating a similar thing about what that means uh Dr Valentine and Miss Armstrong took a lot of time to refin our coaching framework last year which we've
125been utilizing this year I think that's consistent at each of our site visits we reiterate what coaching is and that framework along with our math and our vision um um our vision for the district in those particular areas so I think now when we say that we definitely have significantly more alignment than we've had since I've been in the district to be very honest and so our principles and and our teams understand what we're looking for and what our expectations for that right now we're going through cycles and having conversations about that and we're taking input from our teachers from our coaches and from our Administration so that as we move through the rest of this school year we finish off this year strong with those practices and then as we look to next school
126year um as we continue to be consistent with our framework and then the last point I wanted to emphasize is you know we talked about the measuring we as a leadership team um and this team that's here tonight we're trying to figure out the best way by which to actually measure that Effectiveness that is Equitable and align to that coaching framework and so that is something we're working on and so potentially when we get to that deeper dive we'll be able to clarify some of those details thank you and then and then fin another question I think we can maybe do it at the very end of this if we want to um it's actually a question for M to I would just I would love and so you can I want do at the
127end or have them do right now um because you've worked with lots of districts right to do strategic plan and what you said you know one of the hardest pieces is that follow-up and we're doing it now but right we have to do the follow-up year after year not just this one year so I would just love your feedback on for us board members right the Strategic plan is a new one a lot of us are new but it's also a new space bar District what are your recommendations to us as board members to like keep the momentum and the excitement especially as there's like times when it's right the numbers are discouraging so I just would love your feedback and bridg inside if you want that into this discussion or yeah maybe we could
128just finish the board comments and then we could do that one that be okay thank you than hi um thank you for the presentation um as you know I'm new I wasn't here and um we adopted the Strategic plan I was out in the audience here listening so I wasn't really in I didn't know what to expect with this update and I also notic the first update um so I was kind of surprised to not spend a little bit more time on the Vital sign scor card um student outcome achievement NWA numbers where we show a lot of decline over the years um and instead be talking about learning and language objectives and um structured student talk and measurements belonging um from the Panorama survey um so I had a lot of questions about how
129we are um using data to drive our instruction what our complete instructional framework is as a district um campus to campus and just based on what I see um I see a lot of different things happening across the district and um I think this is a great opportunity now that we have a strategic plan in mind now that we're talking about comprehensive curriculum for ELA ELD um based in science of reading I think this is a great opportunity for us to really move the needle on these um on the decline of literacy and what um we've heard parents say and what we've heard the teachers say about how our students are not reading especially our Hispanic students are not reading and to hear those struggles with the um the student that's in there and saying
130that the fifth grader can't read the word there and um you know we know we know what happens when students can't reap when people can't re they cannot become productive citizens and um so this is going forward I would um love to see more um focus around those metrics um and using those measurable outcomes um when we're looking at like the amount of um teachers that are coaching or the the structure the um language objectives it um doesn't really feel like we're hitting home that seems like like I think somebody mentioned low hanging through the these are measurable sure we can measure those but in what ways does that actually um impact does that does that show our students growth you know that's that's what's driving me that's why I want to be here sitting
131here is to see that we are we are helping our students and that we are providing um what our teachers need in order to do that because when I was a teacher I didn't I wasn't taught how to teach kids how to read and I don't think a lot of teaching programs do and there's a lot of um there's a lot of um just research around that now like it it's irrefutable irrefutable um we need that like this the scientific approach to reading instruction and I really feel um strongly that if that's something that our district could provide for our teachers to provide for our students then we'd have more readers and we'd also have I think maybe teachers that would Wan that would want to participate in a um like in a coaching cycle
132wherein they're learning to teach their kids how to read and it's very meaningful and it wouldn't be like a 10% um participation right for for teachers so those are just some initial things I I also would support a a robust pilot on the um comprehensive program for the science of it's based on the science of reading for ELA and El together like I would support that for absolutely for next year and as a board member I would really like to understand I would like to see the proposal for the pilot process for that because I think it's just so important and it's part of the board's purview to review the piloting process and I want to say that I appreciate you know like during the pandemic [Music] and the years that followed the the whole
133thing um I really do just the whole thing I just I really do appreciate that um with Innovation and experimentation that we were looking at different ways to um come up with new curriculum quickly do expedited piloting processes um try to move the needle on are like different things tools that we just desperately needed but I think that in the process um you know as we saw with the algebra one proposal proposed adoption in the a couple months ago in the fall um the the process is a little bit broken down somewhere like just something can slip through the cracks and like this is just so incredibly critical that I would like I mean I would propose that the board would review the piloting process and really understand what that is and maybe it's just
134we just need an update um but I I think if I think I would like that to be part of it um the other thing is um you know commenting about the joy of reading uh I will say that I did go see um Campbell unions um I mentioned when I did it was a reviewer for the um the validator for csba for their golden Bell that they won for their program and like when things were just integrated all together like the the resource room right was like just the kids were like in a system and just so excited and every room I went into the kids were having so much fun like doing phonics and like you know like just singing and chanting and doing all this stuff and like getting into the story
135and like yeah and they were playing all these games but like they were just like on just literally like lit up and they were just so excited about reading and being in school and the teachers were empowered um and because they saw that student growth and I read the Panorama survey for the teachers and you know I thought it was interesting that it was in line they felt like they were the teachers were very concerned about their students um their students academic progress or prospects for academic progress and they were very concern concerned about the support that they were getting for training um Poss probably around the things that they need so um I don't know if that can be a if you need a board a direction from the board if we need to
136weigh in on that in some way um but I would like to do that and then I'd also like to say you know I saw going to Peggy's point about where she was saying like the the things that we selected to measure for this year I think think that when we were doing the Strategic plan and we were coming up with The Columns of like oh we want to do all this stuff how are we going to measure that right like how are we going to measure um students in experiencing inclusive and nurturing environment and we're going to say oh regular attendance in school right like and I don't know I understand that that is like one measure of students experiencing a nurturing and inclusive environment but and that is a great data metric right
137like it is just so data like it's just really good but like I don't know that that's like really the one maybe for next year that we should select as like the number one thing like I think muchu you said anything we're looking at anything in the 90% is considered a success right and the the chart didn't go below 92 so I think we're doing it and I think it's great and like this is great and I'm I am concerned about what's going to happen with the people being afraid to come to school or feeling I understand we we're going to have to monitor it but it's one of those things that's sort of like a given and again like the writing the the learning goal and the language goal on the board I understand
138it I've seen Christina present it before um I I I agree with it right but like again when I was teaching probably when you were teaching um probably Isabelle when you were at your when you were teaching at Community College write the language and the lesson goal on the board like that's pretty standard and if you're ass assistant if your assistant principal walks through and it's not up there like you're like really embarrassed and also like you probably are think you're that's not your like that's supposed to be your procedure and the data for it was like you know anecdotally the principles are reporting it and you know it didn't even seem like really a great measure so and I don't know if that's the best use of principal's time is like going through and
139taking a snapshot of like whether or not a data goal is on the board and then it said on the slide it's not necessarily an indicator of great teaching just because they know how to write a goal on the board so I mean there's like I get it it's like something that we can measure but like let's for the things for next year like as we're thinking about next year's things like I think if we have measurable goals that are around the like moving those needles um around student outcomes I think that's what I would hope to see and I I really do think that the the coaching cycles that are not being utilized and the teachers are still feeling unsupported I I really question whether we should do something maybe maybe we have to
140reimagine what that role is or reimagine what that is um okay so that's my comment for that um I did have a question um for the um there was one question that I hope I we get if not now then later we did s you did mention that for the um behavioral things the tier three stuff was not in the was not in the data the three incidents the people who were um outliers sort of for behavior issues were doing check-ins separately and so that wasn't part of the data set so I'm I'm going to ask that we get that as a followup because they said it would be presented in the presentation um so the question was you know how many two or three students do we have in our district that are monitored
141separately that are outside of that reporting structure and how would they affect the numbers and the the um the dis proportionate representation of different groups in in that group okay um yes Mr s is going to come up yeah you got it I have my note I didn't speak to it I apologize so we did pull these initial numbers there are 219 students districtwide receiving tier three behavioral interventions uh as a general breakdown 172 of these are kindergarten through fifth graders 47 are sixth graders through eighth graders this is casting a a pretty narrow net around students who can receive Behavior through an iup through 504 accommodation if we start broadening that for students that receive like a short-term tier three but it corrects them and they're going to a tier two I didn't include
142those numbers so 219 students districtwide who wouldn't have been represented in those bar graphs because they don't get typical out of class referrals they have a behaviorist that would go in process with them outside the environment and bring them right back in does it change those does it would it change those charts for like that number of students really wouldn't because they don't get entered into the same behavior tracking system when they have a behaviorist it's really not accurate to say this student had to leave the classroom environment um you'd be doing that multiple times a day sometimes and then ideally and Chin Chin would speak to this the the golden thing of decreasing frequency over time if you're doing correct behavior intervention so what I'd want to look at if we're including this as
143a metric is that number of students over time from beginning of school year to the end are we reducing or changing the students themselves that are receiving tier three behavior supports okay and there's not a lot of you're not seeing a lot of um differentiation I mean not differentiation um disproportionality I didn't break it out that way given that it was students with disabilities because once we start down that road I think it's a good Deep dive to say students with a learning disability does it manifest behaviorally um whether there's a students with an emotional disability obviously very different okay thank you sure have another thought yeah I just wanted to reiterate well from from a couple comments we always ask to have directions more unified from the board that I I think I say
144that few times and we say that few times that we seem to focus a lot our time in the presentation more on the no just on the Panorama which I mean is good the in the behavior and and that the kids feel nice but again if it's something that were over 90% And then we spend 60% of the presentation talking that they came to school it's great we want them to school but if we achieved that goal a few years ago I I'm more interested in in knowing what are we doing so we can close the gap that is always the most or thing and it's not like an undermining all the effort where we're doing into that I'm I'm very proud of that that the kids are school but I'm very anxious again about
145the Hispanic keep falling back about about the curriculum about that we are apparently the only or one of the few that I'm not sure how much how we embrace the the science of reading and and those things that are I feel that are more urgent and and for us and I I love that the kids are still feeling that they belong and it's important because if they don't Bel they don't learn of course but yes they focus on on the things that are more more or into the the Gap I'd like to clarify a few things that you stated because there's some inaccuracies there so I want to clarify those one is regarding the attendance I want to start there our attendance as we looked at last year and the year before were not where
146we needed to be so that was one of the reasons we focused on it we focused on it because it's a need but we also focused on it because if kids are not in school we don't get to address what's urgent so that was number one um the other area is this particular meeting we agreed needed to be more about student voice and so that's why we brought brought more student voice into this particular session because our October session was more focused on the academic uh where we we were at the beginning of the year and what progress we had made at that time this meeting was to reemphasize growth where we could show growth or challenges with regards to the academics but the emphasis was to be around student voice and then we move
147forward on that uh the third Point u based upon your comments um have to do with you know which um strategy um I think that's what you're you're referring to these are strategies that we got some feedback on and we the identified ones that made sense for where we are we do recognize that learning and language goes is something that we should be doing but the fact is we're not consistently doing it and if we can't consistently do what we considered to be foundational good strong instructional practices it's going to be that much more difficult to deliver the more complicated and sophisticated instructional strategies that we need to be doing so we're trying to get better alignment um I think between pandemic um um instructional um philosophy changes over time Etc we have some inconsistencies
148across our campuses so we want to have that alignment we want to find um um follow our instructional framework for the district and the reality is right now in each of our classrooms 100% we are not so that's kind of the rationale for some of these things and then the last point I want to make is yes we will be building on what we're doing so whatever we're doing right now now it's not like it oh yeah we did that okay check it out let's go to the next thing it's keep that going and that's kind of how we got here if you don't keep reemphasizing what you expect then that begins to kind of seep off and then you have to go back to it again so we want to keep what we're doing
149well and keep doing that and then continue to build on the next level of expectations we have instructionally behaviorally and on the other domain areas that we're trying to address yeah um so any other questions so we could ask me to to answer Michelle's questions but supporting us moving forward why would you let us to startop just give us all your wi five minutes in five minutes it's actually a the um you might not see that but there's tremendous wisdom already in terms of how you have your opportunties really and as I was sitting trying to compose my thoughts the phrase that kept coming to my mind was you have Readiness but Readiness is not Mastery and that's what patience needs to come in I mean you uh when I put up the slide with
150the um road map for discipline implementation just really sticking to that goes a really long way the conversation you you you have around that uh today is uh February 6th will be very different from what you have July 6th or December 6th but it's all the same process so the the willingness is there the mindset is there now we just have to work it uh it's no different than uh your favorite recipe the first time you make it it's not going to be quite as solid as the 50th time 6 6 but the same recipe and what I want to urge on you is to uh stay disciplined about the way you implementing it and just just you know drive it deeper and deeper on implementation really um it's very commendable that the Strategic plan
151is not just find something on paper that is super takes once in a while to say you know we got a plan but you're actually talking about it a few specific suggestions we all I said that that's really the large our men you know you got Readiness now we have to work towards Mastery and that's a journey you know continuous growth mindset continuous Improvement perseverance all those ideas just keep working it a few specific things the um this year I'm not sure to what extent the um the plans at the school level really aligns with what's at the district level I said I'm not sure that doesn't me it's not happening they we want to make sure that the because school is where the kids are it's where the teachers are it's where most of
152the money goes want to make sure that the street the data we present really reflects what's going on at the school CU as you you could be getting very high scores looking at things corporately but not really making a huge impact at the school level so that that's that's one comment the second one you're already doing and that's is a periodic report like we we have tonight I would I would recommend at least three times during the school year uh maybe we do a deep dive on one thing and more sopy feedback on on some other I me a good a good Deep dive will be around the curriculum piece for example you know but still connected strategic plan so I say you know Readiness is there we don't have Master yet and that's just
153the process of you know staying Journey uh one final point about the Strategic plan it's and I have a client well I would name District they've done a really superb job of checking all the boxes off so you could be doing everything in the Strategic plan and still not getting results all right and that's because at any given point the the strategies or the work in the Strategic plan represents our best bet regarding how to get home that's the best bet but along the way shift happens I a shift shift shift happens so we have to be we have to hang on to the Strategic plan not too tightly because what we put down uh almost N9 months ago now what it best we knew then or we thought we could pull off but if
154you get into the the the implementation science piece the discipline piece you will find that half of the strategies you must say you know we' grown them and we need to change so we change again but you go take it through the same process you're on the right track you you truly are on the on the right track with the work that's been done and the spirit with which the work is being carried out on the right track I hope that sful thank you thank you thank you to everyone and really appreciate the conversation and the update and um you know I look forward to oh do you want to say one more thing I just wondering what the um next what the cycle like the update when do we hear next update are we
155staying on the same Focus there how can we get input Direction what What's um generally what does that look like well first and foremost um of course we've taken notes and paid attention to the comments from tonight uh we have coming up in February which is our lpap and while that's a different document for us it's very tight to our um strategic plan and so we'll be giving midyear updates so that will be additional data and um additional action steps that we are working on um as well so that'll be coming in February and then we'll be coming back um in April with um additional updates um um to our lcap as well which will also include some additional details with our strategic plan and then we have um our June meeting which um will
156kind of be a final for this current year uh the other piece I want to emphasize is while we're coming forth with a few strategies that we we're using we're not coming forth with every um thing that we're actually doing and that we're supporting School sites with so I would say if we um you you want a deeper dive around what's happening instructionally or in any other area we can definitely arrange time to be able to do that to give you more comprehensive view of some of the actions and activities that are taking place um but we just try to highlight some of the main ones um that we're emphasizing and supporting our teachers and our principles with so so there's several more updates coming and we're currently working on our next update which will
157be coming in February at the end of this month so I've been asked by the board at a governance meeting to also uh summarize the any direction from the board so I just want to like consensus wise um does the board feel like we would want to take a look at the pilot process for a comprehensive El M curriculum okay so and I heard you say that was like perhaps from a in a just updates is a but not like but in a public meeting so in a public meeting I I wonder um I'd like to hear more about the the piloting process the curriculum piloting process um in general not just an update but is there a way to give some the feedback or because the last time I heard about curriculum was with
158algebra um yes and that was challenging as a member of the public and and so I had a lot of questions around um what we're doing with curriculum how we choose the different curriculum to Pilot and just what the thought is around that I I think we'd like to bring it back for review and discussion okay yeah I would okay and then the second thing would be um I don't know it's at least for Peggy and I are in agreement I don't know if the the board is in agreement but we would like to um at some point before it's set in stone have some Board review and discussion about in just input on an understanding of the next year's measurables that will be updated throughout the year for next year for the Strategic plans
159like we'll get those opportunities February and April so yes but it's I'm think they already AR that's I'm just restating what we want to make sure we cover in those meetings okay so just that as we're as you're like if you can highlight that for us like this is what we're going to do this is the plan so we can give youback okay that's it for that okay um so thank you so much and um we are on to 11b which is a support for equal access to education for all children and families and we're um once again we have a chief teaching and learning officer um is that you time oh well do you want to get just keep going I think we just keep going till we get close and you doing this
160is pa okay okay keep thank you so sorry need get there I'm still buried in strategic plan I'll come off my brain we'll come off of that in just a moment okay um we're bringing just kind of an opportunity to review and discuss the support um for education for all children in particular this is regarding our um immigration policies and procedures guidelines and Communications um that we've been engaged in and protocols for um addressing um the immigration customs and enforcement often known as Ace um and this is a summary of work that we've done and how we've been supporting uh while I've been full and a part of that I'm going to have Mr Slayton come as he's been a leader and guider um of this these particular initiatives and he can give you a
161more Broad and in-depth overview so I'm just planning to do this through a narrative and then um we can kind of clarify things as we go I think all of us know the context of why we're discussing this I don't need to go back there but we do have a unique situation in Sunnyvale where our contact with families is Staff person to family we don't have a survey we need to put out around whether families are struggling with fear about immigration we have school Outreach assistants and social workers that are working at every School site so all we did was go and say what's going on for families School Outreach assistants anecdotally reported an increase in the number of families expressing concern around what our policies were for immigration Customs Enforcement and then sharing anecdotally
162again without hard data their family's subjective experience of what's going on just sharing a couple of vignettes we have a family who I KN they know I'm going to share but they ask not even to have their school side identified that the parent is concerned about coming to the parking lot to drop their child off of school the social workers working directly with them there's a lot of mitigation we do falling short of driving to pick up the child ourselves we do have ways we help the student not be stress stressed at school the parent understand understand we don't share information with immigration nor do we allow or um Foster access to campus we have a very clear policy which is helpful so the the communities are dealing with this they are we do have
163families that have received um summons to interviews we haven't had families directly deported but a summons to an interview is a very scary thing and we process those with families we don't have a role in them but we do have a role with the family around handling stress and impact to learning so that seems to be one way we're seeing um this this issue come up in the community the second is around information we did several ways to do this first off with the community itself um Sunnyville Middle School led the way with Dr Angela Guzman she contacted County resources who did like an information night it was successful so we broadened it and did it districtwide I think there were 172 families that joined the commitment with them was that their names their questions
164the session itself would all remain unrecorded and undiscussed the questions were very clearly around how will the school handle it if I'm taken and my child is still here what will the school do if immigration comes to the school district to seek out information about my status or my child's status so we answered all those questions in that context and in Consulting with the county person this is the first phase of what we should expect to be a multiphase process not making this a district Focus but responding to the community next they'll probably be a lull well this will fall out of a news cycle and we'll have some people who are advocacy minded constantly paying attention but a lot of people this will become a silent issue that's a dangerous time for the community
165we have because we want to make sure we're offering support ongoing without making this the dominant thing we talk about with families even in families that have undocumented members this is not seeming to be the only issue that's in the family there are often socioeconomic issues going on we want to make sure we're still doing service provision to the family as a whole not just saying well now we focus on immigration services because that's not going to be adequate to what the family experience is so on the staff and faculty side we prepared some resources and sent them out they coming out Monday of this week principles and assistant principles had a chance to review them the previous Thursday so Thursday of last week they will be the front person for a staff member or
166teacher who has questions about how we handle this and if those questions get more complex or situation based they'll come to the student services department where if we don't have an answer we can get County resources involved what we don't do in Sunnyville is refer a parent to a resource we don't give them a list of websites we don't give them phone numbers if we do that we work with them to contact and say hey we we'd love to help so there's obviously bounds of privacy around how we do that but we have had school Outreach assistants and social workers help families get in touch with immigration questions and things like that so the the resources that went to the teachers defined immigration custom enforcement in two different ways there's requests for records and there's
167requests for access to the campus physically requests for records are procedurally denied um they actually have a process they go through but we don't have a cooperation option even we don't collect immigration records so were we to want to share something there's no information to share so that's one that's very simple requests for Access go through a very rigorous process that is not handled at the site level teachers have a script of what to do were they to see an immigration officer on campus principes have a script of what to do that all gets referred to Executive cabinet and cabinet and then we have a protocol with our legal team to assess whether an ice officer would have access to a campus we did look for previous incidents of immigration Customs Enforcement doing enforcement at
168a K8 school there are none there was one in 2017 which was it looks like it was in California and that was a parent who was taken into custody near a school after school pickup but though the safe place law has been overturned there is still not a protocol for immigration agents to do immigration enforcement on school campuses so they don't we don't have that happening we have a lot of fear we have reports of oh my gosh was that an immigration agent things that we're processing and dealing with as they go on so again the biggest thing here is it's not become the only focus and that we see this is a longterm issue the First new new cycle push is coming to an end we did the right thing to get out our
169information and now it's sustaining relationships with vulnerable families to make sure we're available to help so that's kind of where we're headed next what that time frame looks like don't have an answer I'll Trust social workers and school Outreach assistant to have that Community kind of dialed in and to know when it's time to do something more public as a district again and I really want to thank Mr Stayton for the work he's done in the coordinators uh coordination with our student Support Services team I think they've done a phenomenal job I think they've kept quiet um keep things calm which is very important and also not to become um how can I say it uh knee- jerky we don't want to be that way we want to maintain our calm approach to service and
170support and wraparound Services which is what we do and when it um gets beyond our scope as a school team then we have the experts that we can pull in to kind of help us with that work and so we' kind of maintain that system which um is what we want to do so that it doesn't also disrupt learning to be very honest we want kids to be continue to be joyful and continue to be able to learn and focus in school and so our approach is keeping that at the focus while we're also wrapping around and supporting families and students for I think we are going to need to um extend the meeting Beyond 9:30 so um between this I how much discussion time you want for this and then we have um the
171public hearings for the this is really our last major discussion thing I think I you made the motion for the agenda so you need to amend it okay I move to extend the meeting for what do we say just in case half an hour and then well I think I think we have to if we did it I think we should do it till 10:15 and try to finish okay 15 so I move to change the end of the meeting until second we will try to okay um so um are there any comment we need to do a quick vote I'm sorry we need to vote on okay um all those in favor sure I mov uh the meeting is extended until 10:15 thank you okay um so we're on to um public comment um
172is there any member of the public online who wishes to speak on this item please use the raiseed hand feature now I do have one card nope see none okay um so we have Heather burn hi come on up thank you okay hello my name is Heather bir and I'm a teacher at s Miguel I'm here because um myself and many other teachers are very concerned with the slow pace of the district's response to support our immigrant population I can see it's finally picking up a little bit now um recently but I think we can work towards a much more supportive and coordinated response there's been a lot of confusion amongst staff and the decision making process is often very unclear um a lot of information is being disseminated between teachers um kind of like
173Word of Mouth almost like whisper Network um again I'd like to thank the board for reaffirming our District's commitment to keeping students safe and to advocate for increasing our support for immigrant families by better collaboration with the Santa Clara County rapid response Network this is a network of local nonprofit organizations and is funded mainly by the county through grants which works to support immigrants and threats of ice are causing a lot of fear and anxiety within our communities and US teachers are already seeing this affect our student attendance the rapid response Network offers free trainings to community members to know their constitutional rights um for example a major way to avoid being detained is to understand that you do not have to open the door and let someone in without a warrant they also have
174trainings to help people make a plan if they're picked up by ice and it steers them to legitimate legal council because unfortunately during this time there are predatory practitioners taking advantage of people and scamming them there's also a hotline that someone can call if ice is at their door for advice and verifies rumors of ice rates when people know how to check and see if a rumor is false they can go on with their everyday lives without fear in addition they distribute and deliver free of charge know your rights print materials including red cards Yellow cards and posters in multiple languages the other day after school in the workroom I saw a teacher um making DIY know your rights cards and I was so disappointed that this information has not been disseminated effectively and that
175teachers are duplicating their efforts and are struggling to pick up the slack we're so lucky to be living in such a supportive County and it is very sad to see these incredible resources being underutilized or going to waste I want to conclude by urging the board to increase our supports for immigrant families and collaborate with the rapid response Network to support our community thank you very much thank you okay um so B do you have any uh questions or comments yes ER Mike I think you say before that there was already a training for everybody on the site and oh do you want to address what training we've done yes so we did not do a separate all principles must pull teachers from classrooms and do a training we provided a self-guided slideshow that included
176all the details of how the district responds they also got the scripts I mentioned around how they manage it if they have immigration Customs Enforcement and then how the principles handle that included there was also managing student anxiety managing your own anxiety and then kind of one of the important pieces as an educator knowing when you are overwhelmed and how to reach out and get support as well so those items did go through principal excuse me through the superintendent's office to all staff members on Monday but no we didn't pull teachers and do a online or Zoom or like come to this training about immigration policy okay I heard other districts have done like a try outs and acting out what to do so the people in the front office feel like exactly how it
177would look like and what to do in case of this or that whatever happened today the conference they were talking about that like acting out Ro play the front office staff and how will you call to who what if the principal is not there do you have an AP what is what would they say to you and everything and how they look like in different so the people in the front office know what to do and the teachers still reur and uh they in most places they have the yellow posters and they have the red cards also for the in the offices and for right our red card Supply is depleted so we've already ordered the new ones but we've also done the uh PDFs in multiple languages to sites so they can print them
178if they'd like while we're waiting for them to arrive like you'd imagine everybody in Santa Clara County ordered red cards and we're on the list to get a replenished Supply also the um just piggyback on what Isabelle was saying for all as far as all staff training like we heard that mil had up all hands like a a zoom call yes for all staff members and there was Q&A available and things like that and I've heard some positive feedback about that from staff people and yeah I would certainly not want to rule out whether that's a good idea but again the cyclical nature of this impact on our community is critical we cannot do a big move in in then think well we we did it we have to get the initial information and then
179see if it is a breakout staff training type thing or if it's more through social workers and appropriate resourcing for families we we don't know which response is most effective yet since we don't have immigration customs and enforcement coming to schools and the impact on families we're dealing with with the rapid response Network and with the resources that county has but I do I do understand that there may be a training type scenario that we go to as this comes to be a longer term thing I want to add one more Factor um I realize there's a fear and this is a new Factor but the reality is for us as a school district this is considered um um within our crisis protocol so while it's the the title of the activity may be different
180our procedures are pretty consistent so as far as training our staff that that's a part of our safety um protocol and our crisis prot call so we have educated our principal specifically as it relates to this particular issue and also our front office staff so kind of going through a scenario um that's kind of why we have a safety plan to be very honest because you're supposed to apply the same methodology regardless to what the crisis or the event is and so that protocol is in place we're just changing what the subject matter is and so we Paul has provided that additional um information resource to our principles and our front office staff and if it gets Beyond as he talked about earlier their level of expertise we are there to come in and support
181the school sites as needed so I just want to clarify um procedurally how we approach it because um there's a moving subject matter depending on where we are um in any given day and we have to be able to follow that protocol and apply it daytoday regardless to what the activity is and then maybe will be great to clarify that also to the staff so they know that is part of the safety protocol that I heard that they are going to added to the safety protocol of the site in case of immigration r or something like that you know as we do fire and everything that we do it's going to be like an extra s session and they were talking about that today and I thought it was very interesting now we have to
182add well I mean I'll just say that that is like very I understand I understand the I understand the desire to have it be um just following this protocol and I understand the desire to keep it with the social workers and to keep the control over like how the information's getting out so that we understand who needs to support but I also would say that there is like a broader Community like that is interested like for example um I talked to a couple of Trustees from Cupertino um Union district and um and also from uh Fremont Union High School District and both those trustees had been reached out to you by Teresa casos who did the training for us about trying to reach out to the API Community because they were getting they were Fielding
183calls from the API Community um and I've talked to like my neighbors who are H1 Visa H1 I don't know if it's b or which which H1 they are but they're all freaked out they're talking about where their kids are going to be in school and what they should be doing and so I think that it's the the temperature is elevated for more people than just the Spanish-speaking Community like if there if there could be a way to have some information session that could be with the the high school district copertino that we could invite everybody to all the school district could invite people to in English because there's so many different languages spoken anyway right um so that people could in a similar format um and I think we could because I know there
184will be these like just responses we want to give to people like in the Urgent moment because there's going to be more crazy stuff that comes at us right like we know it um which kind of brings me to my second point which is um I really do feel that they're like just like that um I'm really glad that for our lgbtq community we have a web page with some resources on it um right now we have a web page for um for immigration but it's like link through a banner um I think this might be a topic of Pinterest for the next four years is so um you know maybe we need to think about a more like a visible just a tab or something people can click on just like what like what
185in a visible way um but I I really think collaboration and working with the rapid response thing and last thing I'll add is that um when uh Isabelle and I went to see supervisor Wong and you were at AO Lee as well right so we went to go see the County Supervisors for something and both of them spent a lot of time telling us about how the county has a a a stance of non-cooperation um that they are side by side with the rapid response team they let the rapid response team give their information and even though they're not the ones presenting they're there they've invited people there they're in the room and they're standing there with them and I think that would be very powerful for us as a district to even if we're
186not the ones running the shows could be the city of Sunnyville it could be Sunnyville Community Services could be anybody but for us to invite people to continue to invite people and to be present would be very supportive and now that might be online and everyone's invisible to each other and that's okay too but I just I just think think that us inviting people to those resources um and to those kinds of discussions um would be super helpful so um that's that's what I wanted to say sorry um Michelle um I just want to say thank you for the work that you guys have been doing and um right it is we're just in a tricky time and Heather right is that your name um so I just what well one thank you for coming
187but I just wanted to share if you haven't yet maybe you probably already have but if you have suggestions right of how we can better get out then share with your principal and I didn't know if you're were talking about with staff or with with families whichever we can't really have it back and forth right now but just share if you have ideas because I think right as a parent like I get the emails and I'm one of those weird parents who reads everything so I feel like we've gotten good information but I know I'm a weird parent who reads everything a lots of people don't and so that's just generally a space that we struggle with of like we have information we have resources and how do we get it to so if you
188have ideas please share with your principal and your principal will share with our staff and that's always a space we're looking for that's [Music] it hi thanks for your work on this um and the presentation um I see this as a great opportunity for our community and the district to really partner and to show that we we are a safe space for our children um and what I've heard from the community is that that is the message that needs to be clear this is a safe space um it's safe to send your kids to school um and some um aspects of of demonstrating that safety is to share like what is the front desk training share that with the families um having really clear communication and a plan for continued communication um we got some
189really pos positive messaging from um Dr Gallagher which also included the you know um lgbtqia U messaging and that was wonderful but I think knowing that this is a continued dialogue that we're in a very um Dynamic moment where there's a lot of unpredictability and having the district as a partner with the families I feel like this is a great opportunity um we have heard mention and and I also um I love that we have such strong support oneon-one support with our um Community like with our um Outreach coordinators and with our social workers but I do think that we are overestimating those oneone um connections and that there are a multitude of families that do not have a safe person on their campus to say I'm going to reach out to you when I
190feel like I might you know I have a fear of being deported or I don't know like who's going to take care of my kids if I'm picked up during the school day there is they are not comfortable speaking to somebody at the school site in fact the School site might be a source of great stress and you know we don't want that to be that hence the you know opportunity for building trust relationship um so I would like to see more information go out just on the website I know right now we have that Banner that is linked to the Santa CL County Board of Education resources um and I heard Paul that you mentioned we don't want to just give resources we want people to like come and ask for them but then
191again I I do think that there is a need for us to just have resources available and even if no one's really coming to them to show that you know we care that we're not the keepers of information this is information that's accessible to all but we put it all in this one place and we have some really great um I've been researching like a lot of really great districts that have all this information in one place and talking like they they encourage us to you know take that and just plop it onto our website but also have it very accessible um I one of the comments in Patrick pecker review was about um that there's a website that's it's hosted under the teaching and learning Department under student services tab but I couldn't find
192that and I just saw the banner to the um Santa Clair County and then but I did found the really awesome lgbtqia that has a lot of great resources um so I think a very um visible presence just um even if it's for like PR like look at Sun School District look what they're doing they're providing resources um that would be really important and and we do know this is going to be an ongoing situation very fluid um so I want to treat this with urgency um and I feel like we need to treate a lot of things with urgency going forward but again opportunity for um that that relationship and the trust and um there's one more thing there was a um message um that was sent that included um SSD immigration policies and
193procedures presentation that was sent to staff and it was mentioned that we'd send it to families too and I haven't seen that as a family and I think that people might want to see that and also just like some of the information even like the executive summary of what we are doing um translated into different languages would make it more accessible I would wonder if we could like because of the circumstances like if we could talk to our teachers union and our staff to see if they would like to if if they're interested in a Q&A training session because even though we provided them the information and this is a very standard way of responding I think this is very emotional for people I think staff staff could have mixed immigration status in their family
194um you know they're dealing with their students uh everyone's trying to help everybody and you know sometimes when you look at things in a in a in that sort of a way you just want to like you just have something you want to check and it's not quite clear and so even though they could talk to the principal they could reach out to teaching and learning if if staff was interested in having that I don't know if that would be like a conversation that you would have with the teachers union or you know um but I think it'd be worth it to to inquire if that would be something that they would they would appreciate so um anything else the webinar with Teresa castanos I I don't understand a lot of Spanish but I listened
195to the webinar and um the previous one through SS and um and it was Anonymous and I think that was wonderful and we had 172 people we didn't nobody knew that there are that many people attending but that does speak to the urgency um the want for information and um there's a question like could we use those questions like just as FAQ there are questions and I know there was some note about well we kept that private and we weren't going to record that webinar but they are common questions that we are hearing and I don't think um putting an FAQ out on a website would like expose anybody as asking it in fact that might give people a little bit more knowledge and comfort about oh I have that same question you know I'm
196also wondering what's going to happen if um you know I official show up at the campus what is that going to look like at the front desk and to see that um when I'm in a situation where I don't know what's going to happen there's a lot of uncertainty I want to know like all the scenarios that might happen and that gives me Comfort um I don't know if most people are like that but for me I'm like I want to know what could happen and then I could prepare for the scenarios and um I think just have having that knowledge out there could help ease some of the anxiety people feel I'd like to follow up on that particular one I think we'd like to give our general protocol um for crisis rather than
197specific because there's so many different scenarios even on this particular topic so I want to clarify that that's okay like kind of what is our protocol as it relates to crisis Communication in a front office type of situation versus all the different particular scenarios just the make it one like the number one is what happens if I shows up right like that's like like the basic ones that we're hearing over and over as you go around to the PTA meetings or people are communicating about or that are coming up in the things I think like the the basic FAQs would be helpful like things that you would hear so anyway um I think the S board for the board Direction and consensus which seems really weird to ask but um I just want to go
198through that um what do we for the board Direction on this we're is there agreement about a more um a little more robust website presence website and yeah more communication and and and what about for is there agreement is there a board Direction regarding um a inviting people to a event in English for multilingual I I think definitely and I I think there has been on the top behind ER behind the public right now but I keep hearing that we're going to try to partner with the town and the city and and try to sort show support from from other sources so people feel like we're not alone I don't know how that that will be like with the unity like with the unity things that we Unity that is not just the schools but
199yeah we have support enforcement and down and everything that would be Al a good show good show of support and unity and that that will that will help a lot and then for the red cards and the yellow posters to be displayed in are those displayed in the offices in the front office the red CS we don't have left we've ordered new ones those will be in the front office I want Clarity on the yellow posters I've seen a couple of different versions I want to make sure I understand what the board is actually looking to see the on from Guadalupe Amigos of Guadalupe I think that has the number how to call and somehow even I think part of the challenge right now is that this is getting really prescriptive yeah which I understand
200the urgency of this so I'm just just just saying getting into which post that's that's pretty yeah it's really just so resources in the office and and resources on the office and it shows we will have resources in the H yes and and something that is you know is kind of on your face kind of thing like we support you we a family we we're together okay like it's it's not just the whatever you decide that has the content in it the content needs to show that we're together M we're family we we acknowledge the issue and we up where where are the problem okay okay and then I'm sure we'll check in about that again sometime because it's going to be ongoing but thank you for all the work behind the scenes I know
201it's been a tremendous effort and um you know we're all going to learn as we go uh and I'm really trying not to relate it to the pandemic because I don't didn't like that at all uh but it is one of it feels a bit like that it feels like it's in a kind of that same space you know that same kind of crazy emotional space JY Jeremy thank you so much okay excellent um that brings us to item 12a under review and action um these are the next two items are two parters there's a public hearing aspect and then um we would love the the board to take action to approve our interest statement and accept receipt of SAS and csda so just a little road map uh bridg to help uh since we're
202changing topics so the first item uh up is the um actually I'm pleased to bring forward the interest statements both from the Sunnyville School District to the Sunnyville Education Association as well as the Sunnyville education association's interest back to the Sunnyville School District as we uh prepare to Embark Upon Our 2025 2026 negotiations um both of these uh interesting statements are being presented publicly to Sunshine and I'm doing the air quotes because there are quotes in it um both proposals and provide an opportunity to accept public comment in accordance with state law so again this is the um sea and sunny Bale School District um the sun shining process okay um so thank you Mr nishara I am now opening the public hearing at p.m. uh if there's any member of the public who would
203like to speak on this item please use the raised hand feature now in person I would need a speaker card do we have any speakers online no okay I'm GNA give it a minute actually one minute that's my plan you open and close at 9:48 yeah that looks good that would look bad techically 949 okay all right I'm now closing the public hearing at 9:49 um so thanks for all your work uh do I have a motion of the from the board to approve the interest statement i i a different interest statement from s Education Association and um I as well you have a second I'll second thank you any discussion from the board no thank you for all the work okay yes than that is the discussion thank you thank you okay excellent all
204right so um board uh let's vote hi hi hi I statement passes thank you again that brings us to 12b um uh I'm equally as excited than to bring forward the inter statement with Sunnyville School District um to csda chapter 205 and then csca chapter 205 is back to the Sunnyville School District um these initial statements will be presented publicly in order to Sunshine both proposals and provide an opportunity to accept public comment in ACC of state law okay um I'm going to open the public hearing it's [Music] 9:50 is there anyone in the public who would like to comment on this item uh if you're at home and you're ready to comment please use the raised hand feature now just stare yeah we're just gonna watch the clock for a second it seems like
205such a long minute all right there go okay um so it is now uh I'm closing the public hearing at 9:51 uh board we have to accept this one or we just yes please okay accept uh what is it approve ours and accept uh cscs okay poor do I have a motion to accept cca's um statement I motion to approve the initial inter statement of the Sun School District governing board and the initial interest statement of the California school in employees Association CSA chapter 205 etc etc negotiations second second thanks Michelle um all those in any discussion good job thank you thank you discussion is thank you and good job uh ready to vote all those in favor please say I I okay chair voice I passes excellent thank you so much we're off and
206running excellent okay we're on to item 12 C approval of eate eligible products and services bid award Category 2 for all oh no not for all children and families regardless of image Recreation status that is a different thing that is correct okay Mr nishihara yes so before you is approval of an e project um for our Network and refresh um our network is currently about 8 years old that includes the switches and the access points um I do want to point out that we'll be utilizing eate funds as part of this funding um component eate is is a federal program that allows um you know libraries universities and schools to be able to provide connectivity um all basically the pipes to to connect internet as well as the actual service of of the internet service
207providers I do want to thank um Rob Smiley and Lori Van go this is going back aways they did um they worked with executive cabinet that time to create fund 17 um that Arthur is also looking after for us so that we have um a one-time pot of money that doesn't impact the bond um but it also is forward looking for technology refresh and then so we're augmenting that with the eate reimbursement and we hope to stretch these dollars out um with future uh infrastructure projects I will add that um we are in the third year of the of this funding cycle for eate um given uh some confusion at the at the federal level I am now mildly concerned as well as our the organization of of California it for Education about the future
208of eate um that to benefit school so it's just something we we another thing we'll wanted to keep an eye on for support so um before you is um I recommend the board approve the contract with CDW to install Arista access points licensing and the Arista Cloud Vision um to refresh the district's wireless network infrastructure okay thank you very much uh if there's any member of the public online who wishes to speak about this item please use the raised hand feature now here in person I would need a card seeing no there is nobody there for that okay um board uh do we have a motion uh I move approval of the eay eligible products and services bid award Category 2 a second I second thank you okay any discussion you more thank you for
209discussion okay uh board let's vote um all those in favor if you say I I chair's I motion passes and uh last but not least well almost last but not least item 12d um discuss and review the superintendent search timeline and activities and the selection of the board subcommittee yes so um so the process for replacing the superintendent it's weird to talk about it that way um has begun um the request for proposals has gone out on September on January 22nd um tonight um what I'd like you to do is to select a subcommittee of um of the board for the superintendent search process I'm going to defer to Michelle because she was on that last time and I was on the other side of it um so you would know the most um about
210what that particular process does a few more dates that are coming up the 12th of February is the deadline for submission of proposals for potential search firms think I mentioned that we sent um the RFP out to three the big three in California then another local one um um approached us and they've actually are the first one to turn in their their um proposal um two firms have asked questions so that's a good sign um anyway so 12th is the is the deadline um and then by the 14th um I'd like to choose between two and three search firms as finalists um and then our thought is this is weird of depending on how many candidates we have for the board vacancy in in um District 5 um uh truste area 5 um if it's
211a small number we could maybe do the search firm thing and the trustee thing on February 25th if it's a larger number then we can use the date we already have set aside on March 4th um and then the rest of the the um calendar kind of flows from that at that point once we pick the firm then the firm will work with us to kind of set dates so um I'm open to any questions of course on this but what we I would like to do is find out who would like to be or who you're going to select to be a subcommittee um for the superintendent search process okay so if there's any member of the public online who would like to comment on this item you can raise your electronic hand and
212if you're in person you can fill out a card in person I know so um okay so seeing none um there is no motion here right it's just review and discuss but it's under review and approve no we need to form we need to approve yeah okay so board is there a motion can we just have a conversation before make a motion so let's just have a conversation maybe say what we pick the two then we can make a motion sure oh make a motion for the motion is right okay sure more discussion yeah sorry I'm trying to get my we have 17 minutes so we turn into a pumpkin well I actually can't give a lot of information bridg and I were since bridg and I have been subcommittee you know for the um
213trustee area we've been meeting and so we we actually had about this a little bit and I actually don't remember I think because it also was all happening like during Co too I don't actually remember a lot of like that being process so I know Reed and I worked on it um I was the president she was vice president um and so I know we did so for but I actually have no memories of what we did until after like then after the part I do remember was after we had picked our person then we worked on the contract and that was actually a lot of work and like need and stuff and then the two of us like talked with Mike and like before everything was like official official so that's the only part
214of it that i' actually remember what I remember about the superintendent search process was actually it was very collaborative with the whole board like I was a fairly new board member and um and we all got to see every application because we asked to like they said well we can I remember Eric Andrews was kept being really surprised by us about the process because they're like U well we can narrow it down to speed things up and we're like we want you to talk to everybody and then we'd say things like um he' go well we can like you know basically give you our chosen candidates to expedite the process and we're like we want to read them all like we want to read all of them and then he said well we can give
215you like our recommended candidates for the interview and we said you can do that but we want to invite some too and so we ended up like inviting a lot of people um for and and then but was a very it was like very satisfying because it wasn't like we invited all of them um but we had a really good discussion about the I remember having a good discussion about the candidates and then I remember um the candidates that we actually interviewed like um they sort of came to life from their paper right like so you really got to kind of get feel for like oh that was like you could connect things that they were saying um and then um you know Mike we brought we brought Mike back for round two with someone
216else and like I'm sure that was like very stressful like for for like us to like call you and say hey we want to talk to you one more time you know so then he had to come back in so it was like um and it was surreal right it was sort of surreal but I want to just like say like no matter who ends up on the the search committee like I think we all a search search on the on the subcommittee like I think everyone participates in the process and I even as like a new board member who like I really felt like it was it was all of us we had to pick it it really like I said I don't remember this I mean I remember the whole process what she
217was talking about but the like what read I did so I'm guessing it was mostly just the logistical of okay what are we talking about at that meeting okay when we do the meeting where we're having interview people what is it going to look like questions did you choose the questions maybe we don't know I would guess that they would I would guess that it's similar and that you're choosing the questions but I think we all kind of get to weigh in on the process on like how we rank them and how we discuss and I'm guessing our search firm probably really guided most of it like probably it was their questions and we probably were like that sounds great we tweaked it slightly yeah so who wants to work on this thing I okay
218and Michelle would like to's not in your head she would like to so you know like I said brid I to talk about this a little bit for you know just one person um I the so what what because what I told Bridget was like I'm happy to be involved with it I figured other people want to be as well the piece though that I do I really would push that I really want to be involved with is the after the contract part so what I suggested to Bridget was this idea of like I don't care which two like it does kind of make makes sense having the president be one of the two um I think that's a helpful space um so I'm good with like someone else like I think Bridget and someone
219else should do it but I would love to jump in like so all that pre stuff right but then I would love to it almost make make us then it's like that was the subcommittee and then when we do the contract piece if this is allowed it's me and somebody else I don't care who but that is a piece that's how I would like to do it even though it's a little bit different and I just want to say like I trust the whole team so even though I'm board president president and I you know I probably expected that I do it I don't feel like I have to do it so I'm okay so if you make a motion yeah go ahead hi I moved to um Appo Bri Watson and FL as the
220sub commmittee for the superintendent search okay I love the face okay well so how about can we can we do this like maybe at the um can we split it after can we for the contract can we can we redo can someone step off the committee like during the [Music] contract yeah I that okay okay so just like if we can switch at the at the um at that breaking point is that does that seem we'll discuss it at the breaking point because then we'll see from the consultant prob yeah we have a lot of information but keep that in mind that we me do you want to establish well I'm just I like I just really want to be a part of the Contracting so like waiting till then okay right like then I
221might push a little harder now to be on the committee like I don't care about the beginning but I really really you can do the contract thing I you can even just do it without me that's fine I trust you I know you're going to like go after it because the thing is is that going through the contract with a fine tooth comb like it's not a fun process it so is completely unfun and additionally but it's important and additionally you have to review it with all of us so you know if you're doing it in that space you're doing it twice it's not it's not pleasant so um because then you have to explain it to the other people so either way we're going to see everything and we're going to talk about it
222and we're going to argue about it so it's like it's totally fine Michelle I love it that you really want to do that because it just sounds like hard because if I don't then I won't know what I like that too I mean it's totally fine so I think we're in agreement like if we can just agree that like whoever is going on rock paper scissors he's going to go do the rest the final contract and we're gonna mail that down and it's GNA be awesome yeah we're really sad to see and then specific for dates uh earlier is better yes so if if the two of you get right like bridge and I were able to talk about this stuff so brid and I like what Mike said that on right unless there's some
223crazy unless there's some crazy amount of people but I don't think we're a crazy amount of people at least four on February 25th we will do we will first do the the trusty area and then we will do the having the the the firms thank you present to us and we will pick the firm no I can we do the firms beforehand can we do the firms can we just start earlier then we don't have to end like late and be tired when we're picking the firm start the firms earlier in the day start the firms earlier sure start the firm on how many if you want to start at 4:30 we could just tell them yeah let's do that let start with the firms and then be done by six and then and then
224have a friendly meeting with our TA5 applicants focused and ready yeah that should be fun okay sounds like a fun day and then and then and what also uh I would like and I think I think this what Bri and I talked about is then right we currently have on hold that next Thursday March 6th right that was the like on hold if we needed to like swear them in later so I would love to have March 6 be then the meeting our first meeting with the consultant to start the process and timeline stuff just so we can kind of on top of that yeah are we talking about the fourth or the sixth the sixth six is a regular board meeting we do not have a regular meeting on March 6th I thought it
225was the [Music] 13th no not March 6 Yeah March 6 was the placeholder saring so instead of swearing in yeah yeah so instead of swearing in March 6 would be a special meeting just about the superintendent search with our firm that we picked on the 25th or yeah if we needed a second meeting we would still have the fourth available that's what you're saying if we have like a torrential outome outpouring of interest in TA5 and we oh yeah she's saying get started on the fir search on the six the night that if we have to do a second swear if we have to do a swearing in March 6 would be a swearing in right and the superintendent but most likely it'll just be the superintendent I get it I agree discussion with our
226consultant I love it let's do that does that work for everybody it's a it's the celebrate s Awards six o' okay so the so the date we originally said was March 4th and maybe it was because of the celebrate Sunny bail Awards maybe that's why we said the fourth yeah so the date we're holding is the fourth mph Awards which we get inv which we hardly we didn't get to go to last year so yes we get the fourth we'll hold the fourth and we'll see if the firm can come in on that day so think we have a decision you guys ready to vote to vote all those in favor please say I I sh votes I motion passes B to gble on that okay so I think that was our last agenda item
227except for item 13 which is future meetings and adjournment which happens to be uh Tuesday February 25th at now well it says 6:m but now we're going to say 4:30 yep 4:30 p.m. so we'll want to make sure when we send out information to applicants that it's very clear that they don't start I don't want them not to come at so we'll tell them to come at 6 yeah or few before it'll all depend on how many of each there are we'll make it clear okay it's uh 10:08 and this meeting is adjourned thank you I