CorpusRecord 108098

Berkeley USD Regular School Board Meeting - December 4, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Berkeley Unified School District
Date
2024-12-10
Location
Alameda County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,676 words · about 82 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening um welcome to the December 4th meeting of the Berkeley School Board um if you would like to follow along on our online agenda it is posted on the district website I am now calling to this meeting to order at it is what 7:05 uh Miss charz uh please call the official role for the evening's meeting director Jennifer shoski here uh student director winter Clark here um vice president kadia Brown and uh president anas will be excused this evening president Laura B sorry director Laura babbit here director Mike CH thank you acting on behalf of uh president basev and student director Armstrong here thank you um do you want are any of those persons online making check sure uh vice president Brown will be U joining us remotely um for a portion of the

002meeting thank you uh thank you Miss GIS we will now approve the agenda for this evening's meeting is there a motion and a second to approve the agenda I move to approve is second thank you so much do we need a roll call for this m hares no um uh motion so approved wait direct oh hello sorry someone's on the phone okay you're on microphone now hello good evening um I discussed a few just a few short minutes ago I am actually joining the entire meeting remotely uh my hand is being raised to be promoted as a panelist so that I may fully participate in this evening's meeting MZ can you please promote yes um vice president Brown I attempted to promote you twice and I was indicated that you declined the promotion yeah and

003so vice president Brown did you hear that you have to accept the um promotion to the panelists are all in favor of uh the agenda as is excuse me if if she will be joining us for the entirety of the meeting we need to call the we need to do a roll call for each vote okay thank you so much hopefully you can uh hear me now and I am connected I wasn't given the opportunity to join as a panelist earlier but I just saw that it is working now so thank you so much so for the role I'd like to answer uh and signify that I am here unless you feel the need to uh redo the entire role I will um make sure the record reflects that you are here vice president thank

004you very much thank you and with regard to the agenda uh Miss charz do we need to um do a roll call this is for the approve of the agenda for this evening of director Jennifer shanoski Yes student director Clark yes director Laura babit yes director and acting chair um chain yes student director Armstrong yes and vice president Brown yes great okay um so thank you so much uh Miss chares uh we'll have superintendent comments good evening B USD family good evening I hope you all are feeling refreshed after hopefully having a restful um and restorative fall break um believe it or not we're back and we're only back for a good short two weeks before we're back off to Winter Break um that said BD is is a very busy district and so there's

005a lot happening in B USD um over the next several days this Saturday we are hosting our TK Kinder and newcomer fair in the gym that's right over there um right over there towards the the parking lot that many of you all Park in for board meetings and many of you all Park in there at other times as well so right over there there's a gym and we're so excited to have our TK Kinder and newcomer Fair um the actual address of that location is 2110 Browning Street and that fair will be for from 10:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. it's an opportunity for new families to learn about districtwide curricula and programs and students um can get assigned to elementary schools on the spot so again this Saturday parent representatives and um Guardians will be

006there from each of our elementary schools to speak to attendees about their experiences in our bu USD schools and to answer any questions that you might have so please mark your calendar there's not a whole lot of you here tonight so if you don't have a baby that's starting uh TK or kindergarten B USD please make sure to tell a friend also over the next couple weeks um as we get ready for um the winter holiday we are doing our winter holiday meal it's a tradition here in Berkeley unified and it happens at Berkeley High School it will be on Saturday December 14th from 12:30 to 2:30 during the event um we serve 200 to to 200 to 300 meals um and it's not me or any of us at the day is who are

007serving a makes it even extra special because these meals are being served by our babies our students and members of our community so again please spread the word the focus this year will be to gather as many warm clothes as possible for attendees to choose from and so if you would like to donate warm clothing please make sure that you know that you can do so at the BHS student store by including BHS ASB or holiday meal in the notes so you can just drop it off with that note and they'll make sure that it gets in the right hands um food and clothing can also be donated at the BS near the BHS main office so again that is Saturday December 14th for our buusd holiday meal in this room last night it was

008packed and it was packed because we were having a city hall city council meeting but it was also packed because we had an opportunity to honor and recognize John mu Elementary School you might have recall that a couple uh months ago I share with you all that John mure was awarded the National Blue Ribbon School award and last night in this very room Berkeley's acting mayor and city council declared December 3rd 2024 as John mure Elementary day in the city of Berkeley we got a on day you I'm saying that turkey should have worn off by now people I need a little bit more energy so yes John M day um in the city of Berkeley is an official day the city council during this recognition recognize the hard work and dedication of the entire

009JN Community students staff and families which led to the school recently being awarded that highest honor that I spoke about which is a National Blue Ribbon School award John M principal Paco furland and colleagues who worked on completing the 40 page award application accepted the recognition here last night on behalf of our entire School Community our entire District Community uh principal ferland noted that the award application reviewed the entire school it looked at the focus um that the school has on the whole child it looked at PE outdoor educ education the many intervention programs and the model that they have to provide those interventions special education the school's deaf and heart of hearing program music outstanding academic achievement and so much more that makes not just John mure but many and all of our um

010B USD campuses amazing and great and he also shared that since the pandemic John M student achievement Rose nearly 20 percentage points in English language arts and eight percentage points in math and John mu is outscoring the state um by about 30 percent excuse me in both math and Ela so once again we congratulate John mu for this um outstanding accomplishment and award but we also feel Mighty proud that one of our schools now has an official day in Berkeley um in the city of Berkeley again John M Elementary day December 3rd 2024 um hopefully you all are going to stay in your seat I say this every single every single meeting but hopefully you stay for the entirety of the meeting um this night we're excited because we only have one agenda item but

011we're not just excited because we only have one we're excited because we have a really important agenda item which is the presentation of our first interim budget um for those of you all who don't know what that is it's an opportunity for us to really get a a clearer understanding about where we are fiscally as a district and many of you have heard me say um in esack or other meetings that we are moving into um what we've determined to be stormy weather fiscally not just B USD but um many districts in our in our County and for sure many districts in the state of California and so you will hear our um assistant superintendent philanthropy present on that as well as our director of fiscal Services um Emily and so I do hope you

012say and stay tuned to get us clear a sense about where we are fiscally um we're also excited tonight because we have the opportunity I think that's why a whole bunch y'all did not come to hear about the budget y'all came here to celebrate la [Applause] I told her don't get up here and start crying Laura and now I'm like why am I getting emotional I'm going to be brief but you like me are here to celebrate and recognize the um tremendous contributions of a colleague and for me a personal friend director Laura babbit clap y'all um this is director babbit's last meeting hence the smile on her face um and I don't know that I have the words to to to Really articulate who you are and what you've been um to me as

013a leader um to our district to the folks in this audience um and most importantly to our babies um yall should say thank you to the Lord just because you know she hired me and uh that might have been that might be the impact that might just like be drop the mic and leave job done um but she was amongst the five amazing folks who set me in a room over two and interview sessions and grilled me and asked me really tough questions um and and Lura didn't stop grilling me and asking tough questions after that interview psycho um every single time we check in every time we have a conversation um Laura has been consistent to ask the tough questions Laura has been a champion of Berkeley unified she's been a Critic of Berkeley

014unified um and she's been a cheerleader for the hard work that we've done I can truly say to you all that um she really understands and and tries to live by our values of Excellence Equity enrichment and engagement every single day in every single interaction is about how do we make sure that the babies in our district have access to Excellence how do we make sure that they know that they are excellent in all of diverse and buied ways she always ask the hard questions about how we're making sure the work that we're doing is about equity and that is truly about Equity not that fake Equity but real equity and what are the data points that we're using to measure that and we the conversation that we're having to make sure we're moving towards

015that end um Laura always asks and thinks about how can we enrich the lives and the experiences of our students both during the school day and when we have them at school but also outside of school as well and every single day y'all probably knew her first um in her role as a person who really believes in in how important it is to truly engage our students but I would say probably maybe first knowing her for her commitment to engaging our families she has been a true advocate for parent voice um for True partnership and for True engagement and so if you didn't know now you know Laura and I have done many things together including there's a documentary about our work together um um president vice president um Brown and director babbit and I

016um and the the documentary is called for such a time as this um or I'm sorry in time such as this but what is important to me about that title is that I truly believe that um the universe or whatever you want to say um put us together not just the three of us but the folks that you see on this day for such a time as this that somebody knew that there was going to be Co that somebody knew that there was going to be change and Chaos in our world and that somebody knew that we needed to have a a strong um Fearless compassionate and passionate leader like Laura babbett to get us through those time so I feel blessed and honored to be able to have served on this governance team with

017you Laura babit during times such as these now listen if you see the documentary you don't have to see it I don't even know how you would see it but if you see it one of the things that Laura talks about um which I tease her about all the time is this Fist and I'm G to mess it up but let me try it she she says that that the school system and the whole district is like a fist okay work with me y'all here we go so the index finger is the superintendent oh that's this finger my bad I said work with me this thank you say it's a Cooperative okay this is the superintendent and the executive cabinet right she says the longest finger that's this one is for community and it's the

018longest because it has the most and the longest reach so far so good Laura all right then she says the the fourth finger that's this one these are the fingers of the principal they represent the principal because these are the folks that are married to the schools look at y'all got your fingers put your fingers up everybody let's do this together right then there I can't the smallest what's the smallest finger Laura teachers oh yeah sorry the smallest finger is the teachers um because they're the closest to the students right and then the thumb the last finger who you think that is that's the Board of Education because then they have to touch all of these different components is that cool I didn't think so when she said it but then what she says is

019that they all come together and so whatever you know about Laura you got to know that Laura is Big about it all coming together to have a powerful impact on our babies I think that's really cheesy y'all but I also think it is so lore because you might think that she all rough and tough but she's so cheesy this is cheese however like it stuck with me and it sticks me to think about how all of us have a role to play and that no individual can do it on our own but together we can do powerful things I think about a fist not just for fighting or not just for impact but fist also make me think about strength and I cannot think about um Lura babbit without thinking about a person that is

020incredibly strong that is strong in her conviction that is strong in her commitment that is strong in her ideas um but that is also strong in her determination that all of these pieces might work together I Feel Again incredibly blessed to been a part of this finger this hand to be what am I the long whatever I'm blessed to work with her and I hope that you know that you have had a tremendous impact on the lives and the babies here in B USD um I would argue you had impact before you took the role and sat on this day is I am convinced and know for sure and I'm not going to to list all the things you've done cuz they're going to all say it that you've had a tremendous impact on the

021babies while you were sitting at the Das and I trust and believe that you will continue to have an impact on the babies the families the staff and all of us who make up BD and Berkeley um in the years to come it's been such an honor to serve with you and I say thank you now you guys clap oh my gosh okay she likes nice things so what we have for you Laura babbit is a plaque real diamond it says Berkeley Public Schools Berkeley Unified School District Board of Education presented to Laura babbit in recognition of your vision dedication and commitment while serving as a member of the Berkeley Unified School Board 2020 to 20 24 thank you for the work that you done on behalf of our [Applause] students people thank you that

022is the end of my um comments director Jang thank you so much um and of course there will be lots of opportunities coming up to uh show appreciation for director babit and her amazing efforts and work here um now we have uh public comments um and before we begin I would like to remind you this is all boilerplate so bear with me of our decorum expectations during this in all parts of tonight's meeting no person shall disturb the order of this meeting such Behavior includes but is not limited to booing hissing creating or participating in a physical disturbance speaking out of term in violation of applicable rules preventing or attempting to prevent others who have the floor from speaking preventing others from observing the meeting entering into or remaining in the area of the meeting

023room that is not open to public or approaching the de without permission as Miss chares has already explained there are two opportunities for public comments at each meeting um now and at the end of the meeting if you do not get to speak at the beginning of the meeting we encourage you to stay and speak at the end of the meeting you may also email us your comments at board ofed berkeley.net um the board does not respond directly the comments or questions made during public comment board members the superintendent and staff do take notes during public comment and they might follow up with the speaker after the meeting there are hybrid meetings so we have public commenters in the boardroom and online we have designated 20 minutes who are inperson speakers this will be followed

024by 10 minutes for any speakers online and as folks know um if there are students we we tried to give our students the opportunity to speak in advance given the late hour as far as I know for now there are no students in person or online I'll double check that anyone online who wishes to make public comments should raise their virtual hand so that Miss charez can organize each public commenter will have up to two minutes to speak depending on the amount of speakers please note that the microphone will shut off at the end of each speaker a lot of time there's always that alarming beeping sound so time your comments accordingly I will call your name in the order of speakers per agenda item to keep things moving I'd like to ask the that

025the speaker who is next in line come forward and wait near the microphone I apologize in advance if I pronounce anyone's name incorrectly we will now begin our public comments uh with those in person um are there any student commenters Miss chares no thank you um our uh if if so our also want to introduce our our student board member who I have not uh met until in person until this time um Mr Armstrong Tabit and if there is an online student commenter um today we will have director Tabit um present that public commenter we don't though um so um I'm going to call up Martha Kaine am I pronouncing your name properly thank you I'm so glad we met on the longf fellow site Council in 2017 17 and have had this opportunity to

026work together for the last s years in um under your leadership as a school board director we succeeded in passing the climate literacy resolution in November of 2021 and since that time thanks to administrators and teachers and you and your guidance and others we've begun to make progress on climate literacy curriculum in the district and um thank you for your service it wouldn't have been possible without you and I look forward to continuing our partnership in creating a more just Equitable and sustainable world for our children and our children's children can I approach the dice and give her the yes yes you may thank you so much [Applause] really thank you Miss Kane um and next up we have and again apologies for mispronunciations pronunciations s Harkins [Music] good evening my name is s Harkins

027I'm a representative on behalf of Senator Jesse adagen um and it is my deep honor to present you with a certificate on behalf of the senator um director babbit your four years at B USD have been marked by advocacy on behalf of the community parents for equity and importantly for the school district thank you for all that you've done thank you for your commitment to the community and the dedication that you've demonstrated um and I would like to formerly present you with this Proclamation from the senator thank you [Music] thank you so much Mr Harkin and the City of Berkeley for their recognition of director babbit um next on up we've got Peggy Scott I thought I wasn't G to choke up good evening and thank you for the opportunity to be here um I've

028been coming here for more than a Dozen Years um speaking here usually about sexual harassment sexual assault literacy and I would often be up here and i' turn around and there would be this beautiful woman with this big smile going and then she would get up and speak and she would turn around and I was sitting there going mhm and it dawned on me eventually that it was all about equity and Equity is not a theory Equity is not a concept Equity is a real thing and Laura you are the champion of equity everything you did always no matter what the subject it was about equity for kids so that everybody could have an equal chance and it's been an absolute pleasure getting to know you it's a a pleasure getting to see what you

029could make happen because you insisted on kids first always and there it was on your yard sign and there it was on your postcards and it was kids first always and it is I think um not just conceptually but legally what a school board is supposed to do that is the Mandate of the school board is to advocate for children to advocate for students first above everything else it may be tempting to think about all the other interests and all the other possible constituents your constituents are the students and Laura I have seen you fight for kids every step of the way and I just thank you from the bottom of my heart thank you so much Miss Scott um next up we have Mimi pulit Hello I'm here to express my gratitude to Laura

030babbit for her service to our district both in her capacity as a board member for the past four years and as a committed parent deeply involved in District level issues for over 16 years throughout Laura has consistently advocated for Equity accountability and fiscal responsibility what has set Laura apart from other board members past and present is her laser focus on driving solutions that meet the needs of students and their families thank you Laura we will miss you in the impact you've had thank you so much thank you so much for your um kind but also uh apropo words for director babit um our next speaker is Rebecca [Applause] levenson so thank you for allowing me to speak you know the thing about the hand is that when you make it into a fist it's the

031size of a heart and that's so fitting it's the other piece right of the system you're thinking about and the way that you work in the system which is with your heart I think Laura I've been doing this not as long as Peggy but decade and one of the things that I can I can say with my whole being is that I think you really hear people you really hear the hurt you really sit with that hurt and it doesn't matter who that hurt is coming with you hear it in all directions there's no part of human suffering of putting kids first of recognizing that things aren't Equitable and we need to do things differently and asking hard questions is a part of that I wasn't in the school district when Co hit I was

032in a Oakland um School for the Arts but what I knew was happening here even though I wasn't part of the school district was was the fight for parents to be able to bring their kids back to school and one of the things that came up over and over again as we were knocking on doors for you and campaigning for you was the power of that choice that vote and so I feel like on behalf of all those parents who were desperate and whose kids were depressed and whose kids were not learning and were turning their screens off and all of those things I want to say thank you for that but I also want to thank you as somebody who's been working on sexual harm and harassment there was a reason Diana Gordon and

033I both um put a letter in for you in the Berkeley times and that is because the way that you've held that issue all this time so deepest thank you Laura for your heart for your work for your wisdom for asking her questions thank you Miss lenson um next up we have Pat Riley I'm pronouncing the name correctly okay cool um thank you so I've got democracy on my mind um probably everyone else do here too um I'm pretty disappointed in the election results I'm disappointed in the American people and the choices they made I'm really disappointed in the people of Berkeley the choice that they made [Music] um it's hard to believe that we're about to have another Trump Administration it really is and it's really hard to go back and think about what

034happened in 2020 and it's particularly um anxiety provoking to know that you won't be here for us because as we look ahead at the next four years we it's going to be principal people who are fearless who will always do what's right despite the politics that is going to really make a difference for all of us and you did that Laura and I you you and I have had conversations about our mutual hero shirle tism so I'm going to just say I don't know what your future holds but I'm going to hold on to this you got it like I'm going to cover up these things you got to run again okay you got to run again we need public servants like you we need people who will always do the hard things and will

035always put kids first no matter what and I hope that everyone else on this dis but as we look forward we don't know what the future will hold but God forbid if there's another pandemic or there's some other kind of Crisis I pray to God that your leadership and your willingness to stand with the people with the least power will mean something to everyone on this Das and everyone in this city I want to thank you again from the bottom of my heart thank you thank you thank you so much Miss Riley and I'm sure that while Dr babit is not here here She will be around advocating and doing the work that she's done for many years um next on up Mike Pearl mutter thank you sorry about that a little it's a kind

036of Chicago baseball sounding apologies the Cubs thanks for that introduction I'm Mike pearlmutter I'm a parent of a fourth grader at Sylvia Mendes and I'm part of a group of parents who are concerned with the safety of the Sylvia Mendes building remodel we are experts in construction and air quality and environmental and human health and safety regulations these comments that I'm sharing are in the interest of syia Mendes and all future District construction projects facilities assistant superintendent John Kalise repeatedly stated at Community meetings that this project would H um have above and beyond safety measures yet parents passing by have documented and reported unsafe conditions since the start of the school year at least uh August 22nd this is not above and beyond only recently have additional safety measures begun that should have been there

037from the start we would like this project completed as quickly as possible and um speed and safety is not a dichotomy those safety has to be part of this um we want to ensure the safety of our students our teachers our staff and all the workers in the site and I have five asks of you one is that there's a qualified construction safety oversight two there's transparent and truthful Communications about what's going on three that there's complaint acknowledgement within two business days and a report back of findings and resolution four realtime air quality and noise monitoring data at the site and five access this year 2024 to the digital copies of the instruction documents and complaint investigations uh one of my colleagues requested them and uh was told it would take at least 150 days

038to receive documents that are already in existence thank you thank you so much Mr pear mucher um next on up to the podium is Matty tum thank you it's tum thank you for table I'm frequent enough that probably people know um thank you for allowing me to speak um the first value superintendent was talking about the values and actually the first value in the uh District's website is uh students are our priority and uh the first time I saw it I thought this is this is stupid nobody should have that in a school district like du of course and in the five or so years that have been more involved in what's going on here every single time I realized how important it is that it's there and how elusive that is that concept to

039so many people in this District incl including so many sitting on this Das present and past except for Laura it's just as simple as that um through the dark days of Co when I suddenly realized that there's actually somebody who's listening to me to us to the hundreds of us nobody here in the room that actually was there I know kadisha Brown is on on the call um you were listening to us and we responded and thank to you our kids went back to school it was it took long because there was so much resistance but you were there for us and for so many things um and you made a huge difference and I appreciate that and um get me saying in many of these hours and now um against the laws I also

040feel like I have a friend thank you [Music] Laura thank you so much next on up is Nicole Harris thank you I am a parent of a seventh grader at King Middle School and a graduate of Berkeley High and I'm also a member of the African-American success advisory committee I'm here today to express my heartfelt thanks to director Laura babbett for her years of service to our community first and foremost I want to thank director bab for her unwavering commitment to advocating for our African-American students her efforts to secure additional support and re resources for programs aimed at closing the achievement Gap have made a tangible difference in the lives of many young people in this District additionally I am deeply grateful for advocacy and ensuring that our students were able to return to inperson

041learning when it was safe to do so this was a crucial step in supporting not only the academic but also the social and emotional well-being of our children finally I want to thank you for inspiring so many of us as parents to speak up not just for our own children but for all the students in BSU buusd your leadership has empowered us to become more engaged and shaping a better future for our entire Community thank you Lord for your dedication and service and we are grateful for everything you have done and continue to do for our students thank you thank you Miss Harris um next on up as far as last person in person here is excuse me I'm mispronouncing your name Mari law Amon law so I apologize Moy law thank you so much

042good evening you deserve all the flowers director babbit and I didn't bring any I'm sorry I didn't have a chance to get some but I intended to four quick things my name is mon law I'm a resident of Berkeley graduate of UC Berkeley USF law school and and I've been back here for 14 years um recently the four things I wanted to quickly address are the Kudos and gratitude for director babot I worked on your campaign when you first ran and your daughter was out there we knocking doors and I still have my flag says black lives matter with your name on the other side I appreciated all your service thank you so much secondly youth are our future leaders and I have to leave cuz my son's on TV at 8800 p.m. Shameless plug

043he's in Abid Elementary I'm playing the it guy um and uh three our teachers Spencer Pritchard want to get a shout out to one of my favorite teachers here and uh Lum of UC Berkeley and was one of my mentees they call me auntie Mony or Mama Mony um also I want to give a special thank you to miss Irma Parker who came out of oh gosh retirement three or four times I think right maybe five I don't know she's inless and I love her so much and I really appreciate what she does for our youth the fourth thing I just want to quickly raise up and thank you I'm director shanoski I haven't been able to talk to you since we ran into each other at the um National Night Out at Mickey Avenue

044Baptist Church other plug this Friday violence prevention ceasefire Community conversation at McGee Avenue Baptist Church 5: to 6:30 p.m. this Friday it's going to be very powerful live free is starting the first conversation to get our ceasefire program off the ground um but on Mental Health um I wanted give a special thank you to Eva Mary Ginger Haley and Lily five Berkeley High seniors who created the mental health guide after their friend died by suicide in their guide it includes a section on gun violence and on Mental Health my son did um something on Mental Health as well but I what I want to make sure I don't lose is that $325,000 thank you thank you so much Miss L you can of course effective you cut them off yeah there's the be the city

045council you can you can send your comments by email to us and by the way that's a totally perfect last name for someone who's a lawyer excellent Miss L um so are there any uh speakers online um yes we have two two hands three hands rice are any of the speakers students no okay so I can't actually see I'll start with the T oh oh I see Miss nelt would you like to speak please yes I'm speaking tonight to thank Laura babbit for her service to our community she approaches challenges with a sense of curiosity and willingness to roll up her sleeves she is a champion of children and I am so grateful without Laura the board will need to dig deep and bring bravery humility and and an attempt to truly understand the problems

046we face as an educational Community for decades there's been talk about child well-being from our board members but if kids can't read are the children well we graduate nearly all high school students but the percentage of those able to attend State schools declines the USD brushes brushes it aside because compared to the state of California we're doing great but our state scrapes the bottom of the barrel not much of an accomplishment this is why engaged community members want engaged board members like Laura we want you to ask questions in public venues when a slideshow speeds past a questionable bullet point we want you to ask about it we all deserve to understand the challenges ahead thank you Laura for your service really appreciate you thank you so much Miss noeld up next we have healthy

047black uh up next is the first name is oh healthy okay thank you so much can are you folks ready to speak you may start nowy black um you must accept the promotion this has been sent by Miss charz they've declined they've declined um okay if you want to come back uh at the end of our meeting you may do so um Ben Ben is up next thank you so much director babbit hello uh Ben Bartlett here calling in for director babbit and apologies I couldn't be there in person it's a child care evening for me uh and you know back the days all those years ago more than a decade ago we connected around pead you work there and I knew that you were a stalwart Champion for our children and you realize for

048me as is personal right because um the issues we talk about now the achievement Gap and so on uh were the same issues that were spoken about when I was a kid a Thousand Oaks and so now 40 something years later uh not age of myself here but a number of years later uh these issues continue and so when you stepped up to run Laura I was the first one to endorse you you remember that because I knew you had it in you to fight for our children and in your every step of the way you made hard choices unpopular choices but there were the right choices I even came off vacation overseas when at 3 in the morning for me to to town hall with you and parents about getting kids back in school

049and so I want to thank you from the bottom of my heart for being there for the children of Berkeley and standing strong for Equity the real equity and Berkeley's the capital of calling itself the capital of equity but Laura you are the real thing when it comes to that word and I thank you for your service so does my family and so does everyone I know and you will not be missed because you'll be around thank you and congratulations for your tenure of Supreme service thank you thank you so much council person Bartlett um and who do we have next I'll attempt to promote healthy black one more time okay they've raised their hand again um I'll play black Miss charz is attempting to promote you again accepted hi there we can hear you

050hi my name is aana Davis am I the deputy executive director at health families and here to um thank Miss fabbit for her service to community to give her a big bunch of flowers a bouquet as well as a couple Bunches of roses for her work um what stands out in my mind is of course her work with pad but also Lord taking the time to come to our Community Education Forums on kindergarten Readiness and to present for for us to come to our different family centered events with her daughter and to um support the work that we do and to be the voice for equity and the voice for our most vulnerable community members I believe that you will it would be a loss for our community to not H not have your voice

051on the school board but I look forward to working with you and Contin continuing to work with you and to support you and any other endeavors that you have I don't know if this community knows how valuable you are to to us and your strength your power your intelligence your fearlessness um all have been an asset to all of us and I congratulate you as you move and evolve in your life and on your Life Path and know that um in this moment you are being moved forward to do even greater work so I'm also speaking for our staff Laura and our community members because when we're present we know we're all we we represent thank thank you Miss Davis Miss charz do we have any more online we know thanks everybody for um all

052the public comments and all the very thoughtful and um uh thought-provoking uh commentary uh in support of director babit um so um that now concludes our public comment period thank you to everyone who who came to speak um you again if you did not get to speak remember there is extended public comment period at the end of the meeting also you can email board ofed berkeley.net or you can contact us individually if you so wish um now we will continue on to committee comments Miss charz do we have any committee comments yes African-American success advisory committee the African-American success advisory committee and we have a gack also cool good evening board directors my name is Spence Pritchard I'm one of the co-chairs of the AF American studies Department a member of the AF American success

053advisory committee and a representative of the committee to the superintendent's budget advisor committee and have the pleasure speak five minutes on success of the committee so far a committee that's been championed by director babit um I'm excited to share a brief update on the committee's work over the past month on November 13th we met to learn more about the meeting of math Minds initiative that director albec has been working so hard to steer as highlighted at the October 30th board meeting while American math profic proficiency rates have increased from 19% in 2022 to 26% in 2024 there's still important work to do to support the 74% of African-American students who are still not at grade level the committee will continue to advocate for best practice for students and families to accelerate this progress in math

054outcomes as we look towards the second half of the school year we encourage to learn more about the aasf initiatives focused on student intervention at both Mendes Elementary and Berkeley High School these two models are potential examples of sustainability of the African-American success framework beyond the three-year implementation window we remain committed to the implementation of goal two which is focused on professional learning and human capital development during the three-year a aasf implementation professional learning sessions have impacted approximately 200 plus teachers and classified staff across sites including Longfellow Willard bam Mendes BTA and Berkeley High School these professional learning sessions are scalable are a scalable impact given that these professionals impact approximately 2,000 plus students this highlights the importance of the that CLR practices are not just for African-American students but are good instructional strategies for

055all students um I also want to plug as a one of the facilitators for the black staff collaboratory next Friday we'll have one of our winter social celebrations it's an important space for staff across the district to meet in affinity and support one another and also I want to the next Friday I'm sure director Clark will have a very exciting update and event to share with the community as well I also want to shout out director Armstrong for his college acceptances and more house if you're listening give him an acceptance and finally we would and I would especially Express a special thank you to director babbit I met director babit I don't think we met met but at that rally back in 20 before black Liv matter I think really started part one um met

056to advocate for black lives black youth at berly unified um my Bud Marcel I was an undergrad at Cal back then taking a class on the educational system it was that committee and PCAT and the efforts we LED that inspired me to become a teacher in the first place so director babbit I would not be here as an educator if it wasn't for your advocacy and be like oh there are people organizing in Berkeley is I want to be here so thank you so much for inspiring me and just remembering the different things that we've done remember that that celebration at BTA you really pulled that off that was really all you thank you but that was beautiful for for those that don't know is a kin folk celebration at btech we had students we

057had Littles we had high school we had BCC students we had Cal students we had family members we had staff um we had a whole community of intergenerational event that definitely needs to be brought back because that was a very powerful event and you really helped lead it especially with that raffle thank you I think miss m law was there too thanks for the shout out um but that to helping me transition into chair to the black graduation ceremonies to all that you've done for all students it's been a remarkable tenure that you've had and you will be incredibly missed um in the spirit of Quanza with a focus on two of the seven principles udima Collective work and responsibility and ammani faith I thank you Laura for your efforts and the board for your

058time thank you so much thank you sir and the African-American success advisory committee uh up on next is G Shack good evening board and superintendent my name is Rebecca levenson and I am the co-chair of the gender Equity sexual harassment advisory committee and I was also just quoted in an article in the Berkeley scanner this week talking about next steps for B USD after the $13.5 million payout to the survivors harmed by B usd's former teacher Matt Bissell I want to address a piece of the article that could confuse history with our current board and to set the record straight when I was speaking about pushing against both the administration and the school board and being frustrated with the lack of change relative to gender-based harm and harassment I was referring to school boards and

059administrators in the past it was not my intention for it to be taken as the current state of affairs at all I have come and thanked the board numerous times for the positive steps that we've taken over these years to address gender-based harassment and harm our wins include a formal gack committee Green Dot having a newly mted full-time consent educator for Berkeley High School and an additional investigator for Title 9 compliance office so many good things gack is deeply proud that you all passed the trans support resolution this year it is also deeply appreciative and wanted to wanted you to know yasmina at our last gack meeting had been sick as a dog she had been out for a week and prior to that meeting she put together a brand new slide deck to alleviate

060the fears of our trans and non-binary students and parents on our committee she walked through the state law of California so that folks would have their anxiety go down and have their sense of community lifted up so when I told you at the last board meeting that gack is a dream committee I wasn't kidding it's a place where everybody wraps their arms around everybody and that's what we're here to do today we want your help wrapping arms around every student in our district given the anti-trans and misogynist movements at the federal level Our concern is that there's always trickle down spillover we currently don't have the most robust welcoming schools curriculum nor do we have a robust consent education curricula K8 at our last gack meeting I mentioned this at the last meeting I came

061to speak to you all um we had the opportunity for two middle school counselors here in Berkeley talk about ongoing bullying and harassment of trans students this year how much worse will it be next year what happens when there's more permission for this kind of bashing at the federal level to kids here in Berkeley this is what we want you to be thinking about with us for my friends watching who don't know what welcoming schools is it's a curriculum that helps teachers talk about trans and nonbinary students to promote a safer less discriminatory more Equitable classroom and Community environment gack is urging the board the superintendent and the principles to make a liais Zen position at each site happen this year in anticipation of January 20th and Trump being sworn in it's a safety issue

062it's a prevention issue but but it's also eminently doable this change represents a tiny tiny amount of money with a potentially huge impact think of it as tutoring in fact that's a perfect way to think about it we are looking to pay some teacher who has the heart for this work some amount of hours per week to support their other classroom teachers with PD or to provide a presentation in somebody's class there's lots of ways you can slice this pie we know it will look different at each site and there are different ways of making things work because we do it with tutoring all the time as a superintendent always says we can do anything but not everything we are hoping that this will be one of your anything this year wouldn't it be amazing

063to complement our trans resolution with the site liaison focused on welcoming school and consent education that would be a pretty cool Legacy I'll send this to you an email and thank you for all you do thank you so much M lenson and thanks to you and to the African-American success advisory committee and all the other um committees uh for what they do um next on up do we have any Union comments I believe you think have some online comments are coming up soon there we are Berkeley Federation of teachers president uh we don't have volume right now do we need tax support okay [Music] for Morell in the Berkeley School Board I wanted to thank director babett for the past four years of serving the Berkeley Unified School District your service began in the midst

064of a very turn just a little bit great than good um patch but is it possible to get it louder turn your mic off let's do this one more time superintendent Ford Morell and the Berkeley School Board to thank director babit for the past four years of serving the Berkeley un School District so sorry about that almost afraid to put my hello superintendent Ford Morel in the Berkeley School Board I wanted to thank director babit for the past four years of serving the Berkeley Unified School District District your service began in the midst of a very challenging time for any school board member and especially starting in the middle of a Public Health crisis you were expected to make hard decisions right away and basically become a public health professional you're an important Laya on

065between the district families and staff you always kept students at the center when thinking about how to spend scarce resources and oversaw District leadership transitions we appreciated your active role through the Committees you served on especially the by two the city and District collaborations are stronger now more than ever it was great seeing you at all the various community events supporting our district Educators and students just know that your impact will continue to make our district a more welcoming place for all students I also want to thank the board for approving the buusd bft 2024 tenative agreement we understand how difficult it is managing various priorities especially at a time of reduced State funding our Educators appreciate the attention given to neg negotiations this fall our agreements will help the district retain Educators and create

066more stability for our students thank you thank you so much um brookley Federation teachers um and uh thanks again for all those who came to speak to us before we start board member comments tonight I'd like to remind our colleagues boiler play again to review our governance team commitments our full list of governance team commitments can be found in our board meeting meting agendas let's be the best role models that we can for our students I'm going to start with board member comments tonight and then open it up to my colleagues um actually I'm going to uh give the space to our um director babit as she's um sitting right next to me and this is her her time here to uh to speak and I will follow up afterwards thank you so much right

067well thank you and thank you so much to all of you who've come out and for all who um spoke tonight and you really encouraged my heart and uh made me feel uh so grateful for the for the work that we've actually done together these past few you years and thank you to all who sent uh me emails and text messages and um to for this um great Proclamation from our new state thank you council member Bartlet who literally was the first person to endorse me and I want to thank everyone who has hosted and participated in the many Bon boyage parties that we've been having um I've enjoyed them all it is unfortunate that I didn't win reelection however to those who will continue the work I hope that you will press for accountability

068which is the first step in treating professionals as professionals reverting to the status quo will only continue to serve those at the top while offering lip service to those who need help I hope you will maintain the good and work diligently to improve the bad rubber stamping and playing politics will get you reelected but I would rather be here for 4 years having served with integrity and a long list of accomplishments then be here for eight and have people wonder what I did with all that time I feel grateful knowing that the impact of my years of service has and will continue to benefit kids and staff throughout this District my work as a parent advocate for equity and a board member has been fulfilling and while the list of accomplishments is long there are

069highlights that stand out I'm proud to have been part of the Berkeley High School BP team that first funded the bridge program and even prouder to have had the opportunity to help expand it further as a board member from my early work as app parently aison to the African-American studies Department to chairing its 50th anniversary celebration and later ensuring that the best teachers were hired and supported in this department I've seen firsthand how the commitment to Excellence makes a difference I worked with parents of children of African descent to help BSD create its first Equity centered lcap strategic plan in 2013 2014 and later helped fully fund the black lives matter resolution through the African-American success framework as a board member I was there to advocate for 30 minutes a day for English language Learners

070in the first elcap plan and later to approve the updated multilingual learner master plan I led workshops with the developed handbook to help families navigate the special education process and was able to expand our sped Staffing I pushed for expanded Mental Health Services on campus and was part of the Opening Ceremonies for wellness centers I fought for sexual harm prevention programs established clear policies and allocated funding to interrupt the normalization of a sexual harm culture I watch students year after year educate previous boards on zero waste practices and then funded an expanded the work through our climate literacy resolution perhaps most personal to me I was deeply concerned about the phonic exempt guess the word curriculum which limited so many of our students ability to learn to read I'm thrilled to now see the new

071English language arts curriculum adoption process in the works and look forward to seeing it approved this spring also deeply personal was the movement in our students graduating eligible to apply to for college with black and brown students leading this increase a minimum of 45% looking at the physical changes it is incredible to see how far we've come from staff members who for years had to rush to move their cars during passing periods at Berkeley High School to students who had to cope with limited bathroom access to the requests for digital music expanded Digital Arts stem and CTE programming we fulfilled those needs with plans to continue growth today we have some of the best support facilities and programs around and those tangible positive results will continue to be felt through policies that cut red tape

072Foster safe welcoming environments and ballot measures that have been passed through increased educator pay and share of cost benefits and creating a culture of data informed decision making we've made great strides together all of this has been done to ensure that bosd is better equipped to deliver on its Mission and improve the lives of every student as I step back I do so knowing that the foundation we've built together will continue to strengthen the district and serve future Generations thank you for the opportunity to contribute to this incredible community I leave not having buzzword to say I support but having real actions which have made a direct impact in closing I want to thank my children who have been giving to the Berkeley Community year after year as I left them night after night to

073be present for this community my children who have all been extremely independently successful amid this sacrifice to my oldest daughter who was often the second mom in our house and who was the first person who told me I was needed at Berkeley High School to my middle daughter who at 19 is in grad school because she grabbed hold of every opportunity available to her to reach her goals and finally to my youngest daughter who made me popular as Na's mom and who also probably endured the most hurt during this campaign season but also gave me the most encouragement you are loved and I am looking forward to spending more time together thank you to the entire team that I've worked with these past four years to all of you in the audience to all of

074you watching to all of you who came to board meetings when I asked you to come to those who came to marches and protests and Community Gatherings to learn more uh and to figure out how we could strategize together thank you thank you to the entire team te and best of luck to each and every one of you [Applause] can we take a picture yeah let's do it and then we'll come back to um Other Board member uh comments as well we also have a video as well okay [Music] High e friend thank you what [Music] well thank you so much thanks for everyone for taking the time to take photos um and I want to give an opportunity for other board members to provide comment our colleagues um is there somebody we also have

075a video but is there somebody present who would like to um director shanoski I want to go before um director Brown because you know I don't like to follow her and I don't like to follow you um so before I um give my comments about Laura I I want to give a really warm welcome to Armstrong I'm really excited that you're here to join us um and give some additional student perspectives on the work that we do um so I I look forward to getting to know you better and working beside you um I also want to just announce to the uh community that we are having a special meeting um tomorrow night yes tomorrow's Thursday at 5:30 p.m. in the Sylvia Mendes Library um to give an update about um the construction that is

076underway at Sylvia Mendes um and that hopefully will be done soon soon soon all right so director babit um I feel so sad that I will not be sitting by your side anymore on the dis but I'm really hopeful that we'll continue to have a really strong relationship I have learned so much from you um I have so much respect for you and I really I feel like you and I don't always agree but we can always dig in together um and in some of that disagreement is where I learn the most and so I just really appreciate that I know that you have been doing the work and as an organizer myself I just have the utmost respect for people that do the hard work in the community year after year after year and

077come to this seat um really from that work and from that space um you know my kids are both in BD and they benefit from all of that advocacy and all of that work and I'm going to miss you and I hope that we can go for another walk on the marina and grab some coffee soon um and that you know that my you know you have my number and that um I'm always excited to learn from you and work beside you than thank you so much director schanowski is there another board colleague who would like to speak next you're the only other one I including the students would is there anyone else would like to go next or yes our student director Miss Clark winter Clark okay good evening everybody it is great to

078be back here and diving into the important work ahead um I truly enjoyed hearing from everyone during public and committee comments and I'm looking forward for the rest of tonight's meeting um to start off as Mr Pritchard alluded in his committee comments uh I'd like to begin by sharing an upcoming event the African diaspora dance and drum winter showcase happening next week on Friday December 13th in the BHS big theater the performance runs from 7 to 9:00 p.m. with doors opening at 6:30 p.m. and tickets can be purchased online at bhsm studies.org and I believe you can purchase them in person um on the same day this showcase is a wonderful opportunity to witness the talent and hard work of our incredible student dancers as they bring to life the rich and vibrant culture of

079the African diaspora while also giving back to the off afham department at our school um on another note in closing I would like to take a moment to express my heartfelt appreciation and admiration for my fellow board member Laura babbit um as her time on the board comes to an end I just want to take a moment to honor her incredible contributions to our community long before I even joined the board Laura played a pivotal role in impactful initiatives like measure y1 and is consistently champion inclusivity and Equity within our district during my time here she has been an outstanding mentor and truly an inspiring presence though I haven't known her for as long as some of you her ability to inspire and motivate in such a short time speaks volumes about her character Laura

080thank you for your guidance dedication and unwavering commitment to our community that concludes my comment thank [Applause] you thank you so much director Clark um do we have other board members who would like to speak is director Brown's hand up online yes okay go ahead director uh vice president Brown vice president Brown you are a panelist oh thank you good evening everyone Mike were you going to give comments I should you should probably go before me if you are um I was going to say excuse me I'm gonna give something briefly okay go ahead thank you and also our student would like to speak as well um director Tabit um hi everyone um um it's a pleasure to be here today and it's a pleasure knowing Laura and I haven't known her for too long

081cuz I haven't been in the Bay area for a long time but just by knowing and the comments people say about her I know she's a great great lady and I just I appreciate the fact that CU me being here she played a role in me being here and just the colleague oh she always comes with a smile with a positive attitude and she's a great leader and I just appreciate her so much for her work and always being so strong for the kids and always being the first to be to show up and I'm just so grateful for and yeah and I also want to say I'll be this probably my last time being here because I'll be heading to college on I don't know the college I'll be going to but I just

082want to say that um thank you for everyone for knowing everyone for meeting everyone and thank you guys for also showing up and yeah that would be it can I can I just break protocol director CH cuz he's being really modest um he got exception into San Francisco State University he got a full ride to Arizona State University and he said to me superintendent this is just the beginning so he is being humble he is definitely going to college but he's going to college with choices and so I want to shout you out and big you up for that congratulations all right thank you so much congratulations good job director um I know you'll have many many options and you'll have to make your decision at that point amongst the many options that you have

083um so I guess I'm supposed to go ahead of director Brown I will um I want to of course start with um thanking all the folks who have come out here and spoken and as always again uh it's important for us as board members to hear hear you and hear your hearts and minds and that kind of advocacy is so important at the local level in particular and this is one of the most accessible public forums for many of us and I really want to um remark that I know it takes a lot of time out of your day courage as well to come up and speak and so I appreciate that and um on that note uh you know we've been working away on policy and um again uh folks come on down come

084on to the policy meetings and come in person and we're listening to you we've got lots of feedback uh in public last time and also uh via email that's how that works that's how it's supposed to work so thank so much and um you know we have promised to try to do a earlier ending than normal today um as partly a gift to um director babbit but I want to say something briefly she might have a party to go to after this um I think that's uh when our superintendent used the terms a champion and a Critic um I I really like those terms as a descript descriptor for director babit so as a champion and a critic that really is a very challenging space to occupy and of course many of the folks on

085this um board are might fit into that I do have to say that um in the past two years that I've worked with director babit I have marveled at her ability to both Advocate on behalf of families while also doing the hard and sometimes mundane work of governing governing um so her efforts particularly for addressing disparities is especially important for All Families across Berkeley uh but in particular uh she is an important Ally for our African-American families and I recognize that as well and I think we do here um and with that I also want to remark that the beautiful Orchid on the deis for director babbit is so apropo given that orchids are known for the resilience um so director babbit thank you for your many years of public service to the school district

086thank you thank you so we president V we're going to do the video next and then lastly um well vice president Brown thank you so much good evening just wanted to thank director babbit so much during her last meeting for all of her service for all of our students I particularly wanted to thank her for her work during the covid-19 pandemic we got elected during such a difficult time to serve and you did it with a lot of Grace and always making was at the Forefront of how we made decisions on the school board I also wanted to thank you for your leadership on the climate literacy resolution and continuing to support all of our environmental efforts at the USD thank you so much thank you president vasev and next um we have vice president

087Brown who is speaking from online we we're having a bit of a volume issue we can hear it in the room hopefully you can hear it out live as well okay I can hear you can you hear me oh yes great wonderful good evening everyone I deeply wish uh that I could be there with you all but I am here in Atlanta Georgia uh doing work on behalf of the African Methodist Episcopal church but I wish I could be there to see all of your faces uh but most importantly I wish I could be there to hug and love on my colleague my friend my Confidant and my co-conspirator in the fight for justice director Laura babbit who will be deeply missed on the Berkeley School Board uh this is going to be pretty long

088so stretch out get comfortable um but I think that uh all of these things that I'm going to say definitely deserve uh to be said and we need to take as much time as we can to honor um the amazing Powerhouse that is Laura babbit I uh remember being home a few years after having graduated um from college and I remember getting uh re acclimated and re-involved with uh Berkley politics and I continuously heard the name Laura babbit mentioned in many many spaces but especially throughout the Berkeley Public Schools her reputation of being a strong and fierce Advocate that didn't take any mess and definitely didn't take no for an answer preceded her and then one lucky day I finally got a chance to have my first in-person uh encounter with Laura babbett during a

089Berkeley school board meeting and uh she wasn't a board member just yet but a well-respected parent advocate and during the meeting Laura was doing what she did and what she continues to do best which is advocating uh at the time she was at the podium giving comments on behalf of parents the children of African descent and Laura spoke uh like she does today with truth with power with conviction um and with authority and in that moment I thought to myself wow everybody has it wrong she's not just as good as they say she is she is a million times better you see Laura wasn't just calling out the challenges that impacted black and African-American students in the district but she was providing recommendations for Solutions that would benefit all children but especially those who have

090a history of being underserved in the school district in less than five minutes she provided a dissertation like committee comment that inspired parents and students to wish for more and invigorated staff and the board to work for more fast forward um after I was elected to the board I personally became inspired by Laura watching her uh as well as the members of the Berkeley High African-American studies Department 50th anniversary celebration committee work tirelessly to create what was a year-long celebration to honor the work of the historic and first of its kind African-American studies Department if there is anything that you must know about Laura it is that she is innovative and full of creative ideas that work to bring people together and bring people together they did by creating inspiring events that students staff members

091families community members and alumni still talk about to this day and if you thought that was enough then you know nothing about Laura babbit because the truth of the matter is that the girl was just getting started in 2020 Laura was elected to this very board in her in a historic election her Grassroots campaign once again brought people together and gave the city something to be excited about during an uneasy and unprecedented time as soon as director babbett was sworn in she hit the ground running and in fact I don't think she has taken a moment to breathe since 2020 in her four years on the board Laura has helped to support and and Elevate The District in more ways than I can name but I will attempt to name a few in your time

092lord we approved a wonderful transport ation plan approved a budget that we could all be proud of with no cuts to the classroom we supported our district and superintendence goals of organizational Clarity by approving new positions including but not limited to a new director of facilities maintenance and operations a new director of curriculum and instruction and a new literacy coordinator we approved our sipsa and improved to put BP on the 2024 primary ballot where it passed and did exceedingly well at the polls we redirected taxpayer funds from a building parking lot to modernized our school campus in your time on the board we strengthen safety and plans practices that make sure that every student and their families feel included in our district we funded the African-American success framework achieving measurable success we brought in the

093exceptional program uh you brought in the exceptional program College Bound helping to get more of our black Scholars to and through college we know you Champion bu usd's climate and environmental justice literacy resolution and led efforts to significantly increase the use of reusables in our cafeterias and finally in just one year alone we approved and adopted more policies and administrative regulations than in any other time on the Berkeley School Board working alongside you and our staff to get all of these amazing and ground groundbreaking task done has been the highlight of my political career uh throughout this work you have been a shoulder to cryon in times of trouble and a hand to high five in times of Triumph on a personal note at least once a quarter somebody calls me Laura or someone calls

094Laura kadesia and although so baffling and kind of crazy because we look nothing alike there isn't anyone else that I would want to be mistaken for Laura words cannot express how much I appreciate working with someone as thoughtful brilliant hardworking selfless meticulous forward-thinking Equity focused and student centered as you are your voice and truthtellah your leadership style and your impact will be missed on the board your advocacy for all students and especially the most vulnerable vulnerable students and students who look like you and I will be missed on the board your support and teamwork will be missed on the board and yes even your mom jokes will be missed on the board Laur you are a precious gy who can't ever be replaced we can elect a thousand board members but none of them will

095ever be like you in closing as you embark on this next chapter please know that you didn't just talk about making a difference you were the difference you didn't just hold a seat and and take up space but you made space for others because you believe in lifting as you climb you didn't just show up for a photo op or put on a show but you showed up when it mattered Laura you are a living legend and a true Agent of Change who is leaving a legacy to be proud of thank you for your service to our school's director Laura babit job well done wow thank you so much that was amazing our vice president from Atlanta um so I believe we have all our board um comments now it is time in our agenda

096to approve our consent calendar um can I have a motion and a second to approve consent calendar do we have a consent calendar I'll move to approve thank you so much um director shinoski move to approve the consent calendar I'll second thank you so much director babbit seconded roll call roll call vice president Brown I'm trying to get my tears together yes Sor director shinoski yes student director Clark yes director babbit yes um director Chang yes director Armstrong yes looks like it passed sure motion carries unanimously thank you motion carries unanimously all righty um our only item this evening is uh for Action items we have 13.1 we'll be hearing an update on the district's first interim budget thank you so much looking forward to this conversation oh someone's missing the phone a Laur Laura

097is that your phone oh yeah your phone is you're at your be so good it good evening everyone um director babbit this is very very bit oh sorry thank you um this is it last presentation of our um budget and I've enjoyed presenting and getting the hard questions and trying to respond but we'll be in touch we'll definitely stay in touch um so this is our presentation on our first interim and again we're presenting um in accordance with our mission and our for EAS and our agenda tonight we're going to take a look at the um the general fund so this is a little different um from what we usually do we usually just focus on the unrestricted general fund but we will be looking at the general fund um the summary of funds 1

098through 4 looking at our budget cycle and where we are in the budget cycle then turning our attention to the unrestricted budget um general fund including a budget recap um the summary and our highlights variance report multi-year projections and then next steps so on the next slide um I can do it on here so um we talked about the general fund and um we want to make sure that every all of us are on the same page when it comes to looking at The District's general fund including the parcel taxes versus our focus on just the unrestricted general fund so when we're looking at the general fund um including our parcel taxes we're looking at revenues of 218 million and this is a breakdown um in terms of lcff State revenues parcel taxes and local

099revenues and the graphic representation shows that the largest part of our funding comes from our lcff but of course another significant section is um our BP and our parcel taxes so next slide and this is a um a representation in terms of where our focus is versus the entire um um fund one form one which includes our parcel taxes so we tend to focus on just the First Column which is the unrestricted general fund but when you get a report um with our sax sax reports they're looking at the last three columns so this is a little confusing because not many districts are in our position where we have our parcel taxes including in the general fund so we keep um addressing this difference because it's important that our um our the listening public understands

100as well as our um Union partners and the board and that everybody's on the same page so um the budgets the next this is just a two things so where are we in the budget cycle so we're in the we're starting to work on 2425 we got an early start this year but of course while we're building the 20 actually 25 6 budget we're currently um working on the 2425 so this evening we're bringing you the first interim the first interim in the 2425 budget which will have a multi-year projection that also looks at the 25 26 so um so the cycle um we're starting in January with the governor's proposed budget so as we're building 2526 when we're getting additional information we're going to have to to change our assumptions and then we'll be

101bringing updates to the board um February through June while we're working on the 2526 budget and of course this is the timeline that um that the timeline that we go through with every cycle with our budget we have our March presentation of our second interim and of course we have the governor doing his May revise um which is what we use to actually build our budgets on and then um we present the the budget and the LC cap to the board in June um of 25 so now we can turn our attention to the unrestricted general fund so before we look at what's going on at the first interim we have to take um uh take a step backwards and look at what we've done in our budget um year to date I can actually

102see up there so um so as a reminder the 2425 budget was constructed um with $7.9 million in board approved budget balancing Solutions $5.5 million is ongoing 2.4 is one time and that $2.4 million we have to to revisit in terms of trying to make sure we have funding for these one-time Solutions and as I mentioned earlier we did start um looking at our budget a little bit earlier this year we we uh reconvene the budget the superintendent's budget advis Committee in October and this is because we knew we had a heavy lift and a lot of challenges in terms of um constructing the 2526 budget and um as we're working with the esbach um or the superintendent budget advisory committee we came up with a tentative Target based on the adopted budget and that

103was $8.5 Million that was never shared in public um but it it has been discussed in various committees um now that we're looking at the first interim we'll see how um how the first changes at the first inter will actually impact that preliminary Target that we had set and um just in terms of the first interim um reminding everybody it's a general fund on restricted general fund Focus the cut off period was actually October 31st but it's projecting activity for the entire year and or it's now based on the governor's enacted budget which was passed in June um whereas our adopted budget was based on the May Revis and just um some highlights in terms of the unrestricted general fund at the first interim we are having um we're expecting a positive certification because we

104do have a positive ending fund balance for the current and the two subsequent years but of course we're going to need to implement some significant budget reductions um the multi-year projections it does not include negotiated increases um and then instead of the $8.5 million that we were thinking of at adoption at first interim we're now looking at $7.6 million in budget balancing Solutions and in the other year it's going to be an additional .2 million of course this is still very preliminary because we're waiting for the Governor's January budget and as I mentioned that's going to impact our assumptions so now um oh I forgot about this one the section so um the superintendent mentioned um Stormy Weather ahead um we're definitely in the perfect storm in terms of the different um challenges we're facing

105we're having declining enrollment and these numbers actually um are for the for the entire I think it's for the entire state right so this is um we're having um declining in in um enrollment throughout the state um all school districts have no longer benefiting from the one-time pandemic dollars we're facing in ongoing increasing costs as we're and there's competition for Staffing and we're also having to account for inflation and of course our expected services for academic and social emotional they're actually increasing at the same time um so next slide um but we're not alone um a lot of districts um in Alam County 17 out of 18 districts are in the exact same situation that we're in um they're tapping into their reserves and they're also needing to implement budget Solutions we call them budget

106balancing solutions for 25 26 and 2627 so um we are in the 95% um not particularly great company to be in but I think there's just one District in Alam County that's not actually experiencing that so now I'm going to turn it over to our executive director of fiscal services and she's going to take us through the variance thank you um so our variance report is where we're comparing the budget that you've most recently seen so our adopted budget with our first interim budget so what changes uh we projecting and what are the the major causes of those changes and so this first slide you're looking at are the revenues and so you'll see here a decrease in our Revenue due to our lcff funding and that's because of our funded Ada so our our

107overall Ada as a district is increasing but pre-co enrollment is no longer being included in the rolling average used for funding and so we're seeing this decline in our funding um we're also though seeing some of our other state revenues increasing a little bit and that's primarily due to Prior your lottery Revenue being recognized I I'm not sure why these Bloods are not working I think Um this can advance it for us if it's not working I don't know if we lost the internet connection it just kind of disappeared BL slides got in there but it's not even up on the screen we can our slides are offline and we're trying to pull them back up oh I think somehow a bunch of blank slides got inserted in the middle um if yep oh really

108oh yes sorry about that oh yeah that's true I saw that standing and sitting when did that happen I think it's we're projecting the live version of the the de oh um sorry about that and so uh this next slide that you're looking at are our expenditures and so we've broken it down into to some of our major categories where we're seeing changes so with the items labeled with a B those are our salaries and benefits and and we're only seeing minor changes there same with the items labeled C so our supplies and our Capital expenses um typically uh we don't expect to see large changes in these categories during our first interim analysis so that's pretty part for the course um with letter D our services and operating expenses you'll see that there was

109an increase and that's primarily due to Prior Year Board priorities as well as midyear ongoing and onetime increases that were're recognizing during the first intrum so as we discussed during our um unaudited actuals presentation there was a a collection of Prior your board priorities that um we we designated but not included in the adopted budget we've now folded those actually into the budget and then the final section you'll see is uh letter e and that's referring to our indirect costs so our indirect costs are the percentage of funds that we uh take from Grants in order to fund our operations that's increased primarily due to uh budgeting our prior year carryover at the first inim and so once we budget new Revenue we also account for those indirect costs and so that's leading to an

110increase of projected indirect costs to recoup um this slide here is looking at our other uh financing sources and uses and so you'll see that um uh the largest item to note is our interfund transfer in from our fund 20 Reserve uh is uh increasing from $2.1 million to $3.8 million and that represents a one-time budget balancing solution of Shifting $1.7 million of funds from our retiree benefits account into our budget and that's to address um ongoing cost increases oh sorry I don't slide deck is not my fun is not my friend today thank you yeah yes yeah she good that her too just set it on the desk and not accidentally brush it um okay thank you um if you could go back one slide please thank you um so on this slide here

111we're looking at our contributions in and out and so contributions in include an increase in our projected contributions from BP and that's to reflect updating our average salary estimates based on our both our average teacher cost Cal calculations which we trew up based on um the beginning part of the Year expenditures as well as um accounting for our 2% uh Berkeley Federation of teachers raise um which we'll discuss a little bit later in this slide as well as historical uh costs for substitutes and so our hope is that by TR up these projections at first interim we'll better match what we're projecting our endof year uh expense transfers to end up being um on the flip side we've also sorry uh increased our contribution out of um the unrestricted general fund and into the special

112education program and that's mainly by uh $1.4 million and that's primarily due to increased program costs for non-public agency Services uh next slide please um so looking at our um um our uh fund balance what we're projecting is that a uh undesignated ending fund balance that is about a million dollars lower than what we had projected at our adopted budget um but still uh a sufficient undesignated ending fund balance to have a a positive fiscal certification um if you go to the next slide uh this the main driver of this smaller undesignated ending fund balance is that we've designated additional components in our ending fund balance um with the items most to call out are designations related to uh raises and salary changes that we will be incorporating in the budget for second inter room

113and so we're setting aside uh $200,000 for our classification study uh as well as $1.5 million for the bft 2% uh raise on salaries uh and so those will be incorporated in the budget but because they were approved by the the negotiation was approved by the board after October 31st we've designated them here because we know they're the costs but we didn't want to put them into the budget um during the first interim period next slide and so looking at our average daily attendance so our Ada as well as our enrollment this is a major driver of what our state funding uh is which is a very large piece of our our overall Revenue pi and so overall you'll see what we're basing our first interim presentation on is uh using our um enrollment projections

114from the admissions office we are assuming that our um average daily attendance rate will stay comparable to what we had in our adopted budget but we're then TR up those projections based on what we're seeing is our our actual attendance our actual enrollment right now in the school district as of October 31st uh most important to note with our average daily attendance we've gotten used to seeing two different Ada numbers in these charts we've had our uh Ada projected and our Ada funded uh in Prior years we've benefited from a larger Ada funded than projected and that's because we've been having a rolling average of the prior three years we're now in the position where we've moved out of that benefiting from that rolling average and so we're now being funded on our actual projected

115Ada so those numbers now match at around 8600 or 8,700 and I will turn it uh back over to miss fenby to discuss the multier projections okay thanks Emily so um we're now going to look at our multi-year projections and um it's important to note that it's based on the governor's enacted budget as I mentioned before but it does not include estimates for negotiated increases so next slide so these are the assumptions that we use to actually build the multier projections and this comes from school Services dartboard um we we talked about the Ada funded on the previous slides the coder that we're looking at is based on the the um the dartboard that we have at the moment um but this is likely to change um with the January budget but we're basing the

116budget based on the information that we have at the moment so in terms of our Revenue you can see in that bottom um in that bottom row we're actually benefiting from a 2.93% cola um all the other factors have pretty much remained unchanged so the cola is giving us significant increases Year over-year from 2425 um to 2526 and from that year to 26 27 so next slide our expenditures um this is again um what we're looking at in 25 26 would be the impact of the um the raise is now in the budget um in the multi-year projection so we no longer have to um we don't have to designate that anymore but the um the most important thing on this slide I'd like to draw your attention to is a target so this is

117what we're talking about it's now $7.6 million and that $7.6 million in on goinging costs with an additional point to so it's a little different from what we were talking about at adoption and this is just because of the changes that Emily discussed um um the variance report so um still a heavy lift still a lot um it's a challenge for us but without this um reduction we're not going to have um a positive ending fund balance and we'd have a qualified um opinion um the other section so our income statement looks at income expenses and it also looks at sources and uses and sources and uses are transfers in and out um of our budget so um we we talked about the transfer in of $3.8 million in 2425 that was an increase from

118the adoption but you can see that's a one-time solution so it's only the 3.8 is only in the first year and not in the second two years um we're also transferring in amounts the fund 67 our self Insurance Fund we're projecting an increase due to the ab218 cases that we're facing or Insurance costs are going up so we're anticipating um an increase in that as well um we kept the BP contributions flat because um we're not making any assumptions at that time but our special ed program is going up in 2526 and that's because of the um increase in costs for bft salaries which in turn um will mean that we would have to contribute a little bit more so that's one of the contributions that we're making and that's actually shown in our AB

1191200 that's on the um consent agenda um next slide Sam is no describe thanks Sam so um so with it with the changes that we've actually put in the um the budget balancing Solutions you can see that the ending fund balance which is in the middle of the screen it's positive 3.6 million and positive 1.9 and positive 1.1 however we have to designate as Emily explained in 2425 we're designating for the things that we haven't put in the budget but in 25 26 these are now in the budget so um we're projecting an ending fund balance of 0.9 keeping that pretty flat um but in the last year we're looking AT3 million so um we can go to the next we can go to the next slide s so um so what that shows we

120have a very tight budget um .9 million is not um it's it's really not a healthy fund balance but we it is causing us to have a positive certification because it is positive but we definitely need to look at um our structural deficits and um looking at Cost um um budget balancing solutions to to make sure that um we maintain a positive certification um another thing to note is um we are basing the multier on the CER that's in the dart board at the m at the moment but if the governor comes out and reduces that Cola um in his January proposal by 1% that was going to translate to a loss of $1 million in lcff funding so our Target would go from 7.6 to 8.6 so we're very um sensitive to the cola

121and the impact on our um budget balancing Solutions um so that's it so next steps um so um we talked about the January proposal we all um will be attending the workshop on that and seeing what how what the um assumptions are in that budget and how it will impact us and our operations and we're going to be continuing our discussion with our budget partners and of course we're facing our near near and long-term challenges in terms of um state revenue forecast um reduced Ada because we're no longer benefiting from State mitigating measures and we're also um seeing the expiration of one-time funds so of course our challenge is as always is to develop comprehensive plans to maintain fiscal solvency and preserve the Integrity of our educational programs so with that um we can take

122questions or comments colleagues other questions director shinoski please I have one question and then I have two comments um or maybe I have two questions and two comments um first on slide 41 it's where you're talk where you have the variance for the BP contribution I'm just wondering for my own education why it's not matched perfectly why is the BP contribution a little bit in excess so why is the BP contribution at first inum higher than the projected BP contribution in the adopted budget so it's higher because now that we have a little bit more data on our actual salary costs for this year especially with a 2% raise um we've re redone the calculation because it's done as a a per um based on our number of teachers and so if the the pay

123rate for those teachers is higher than the amount of the C average teacher cost yes average teacher cost perfect um another question I have and and maybe this is for the superintendent is um you know we do allow a certain number of uh in District transfers into our district and I'm just wondering what this decrease in enrollment and the impacts it's having on our situation if we have thought at all and I know that it's it's controversial um and not everyone um agrees with it but I'm just wondering if we've thought at all about increasing the number of interdistrict transfers that we are willing to accept or able to accept one of the many conversations that we've been having is how do we increase um revenues and and increase in Revenue um we've also considered

124not just in addition transfers but just how do we increase um enrollment in general um and transfers has been a part of that conversation but there's been no decision made and also I would say I don't know that we have data that says that we have restricted or or limiting you know if we're not granting um transfer requests when they come in but that's something that we're looking at and we'll definitely follow up with the board on great and then I have just two comments I think looking at this budget and then looking at the projections in the future I mean it really goes to show that we're just not funding education to the level that we need to be funding education from the state and so we really need to listen up our new

125state senator we really need to advocate for increased funding for public education or we're going to always be just scraping along you know bit by bit and we're a district that's really fortunate uh because the taxpayers in this city have have given us additional resources um so that's one comment um and I hope my colleagues will stand with me as we go to Sacramento and try and Advocate um for improvements there my other is simply yes we need to increase funding from the state and also as I think about sort of this scarcity mode that we we are moving into and I'm reflecting on the um presentations that we had at our last board meeting with the latinx resolution and the African-American success framework I just really think when we look at some of these

126Cuts we're always looking at the cuts we're always looking at cuts to the programs that are impacting the students that need supports the most and I really hope that as we move into this budget cycle we are really truly looking at our budget in a comprehensive way um we I know that in the higher ed system um it is the students that are the highest achieving our UC students that get the most dollars from the state and our community college students get the fewest you know the the least of those resources and I have a sense that it's the same in in uh public education and so I just I really hope that we we we take a larger View and we're not simply cutting out the little pieces for the students that really need

127our supports the most okay the end so um I just wanted to say one one thing about um one of the comments you made you said that our ad actually decreasing or Ada is actually um increasing but the funded Ada um while you're seeing a difference is that we're no longer benefiting from the three-year average so it's actually um we had there was a a um there was something put in place to assist us during covid so that's what um Emily was saying there are two rowes the funded Ada versus our actual Ada so you do you want us to to show that you want to explain that I understand the three-year rolling average but doesn't that mean that our actuals are lower than what we were funded for because they've decreased over time so

128so what happened um in we also benefit benefited from um a hold harmless Clause right so if you looked at 2021 our Ada projected was 9,9 but we're funded at 9 9,426 if you look at our Ada um in 2324 it was 8,604 we're funded at 8,9 so we're still benefiting from that but if you look at 2425 oh I see we've gone up since last year okay since last year we've gone and our enrollment we have to keep the enrollment story we're not declining our enrollment is actually pretty much flat or um actually increasing it just decreased when you look at two or more years that's why we keep stressing about the averaging of the three-year average and the hold harmless class yeah sure thank you so much can I follow up really quickly

129with that and the timer is on checking that 20 oh I see um okay so um with regard to the Ada just because there's a um there's a perception or um information out there that um since the pandemic uh enrollment has been down um so this is from 2020 to 2021 I 95.7 sounds relatively High to me though I don't know what it was beforehand um has there been a overall trend that you were aware of like prior to the pandemic that uh the Ada um would have been higher than 95.7 yeah so the Ada was higher before the pandemic and that's why I think the state kind of came in and and um assisted School districts with the hold harmless Clause so we're actually funded on our um on our Ada yeah so they

130were things put in place so our funding didn't um wasn't impacted drastically but because our we're those are now behind us we're being funded on what our true attendance is right now I see so um thank you that's helpful from the perspective of the conversation about uh Revenue that that the superintendent just had with director schanowski um uh thank you so much other colleagues other other um questions from the thank you Dr babit has questions this is too much you're just going to end on my favorite subject the numbers on top of everything else but I do want to say uh thank you so much for uh all the years in which you've taught me how our budget works and um the ends and outs of what we've been doing I was sitting here thinking

131back to to being at a B set meeting the first time you came came in before you were the assist the associate soup um and I was just grilling away in those meetings what about this what about that um and so now U just want to appreciate you for all your hard work over um the length of these years and the ways in which you have um made sure that we as a district um have U remained solvent for many years uh you've kept it together we appreciate your hard work so much um and thank you for your diligence and training our new director who's come in and got up to speed uh and um really want to say to uh the district that when when we're looking at an additional 7.5 million uh now

132we are in the the real the real uh thick of impacting the classroom right um and so while budget balancing sounds great um the reality is we read there are a lot services that just have to be redesigned um and when we talk about accountability a lot of um the redundancies and the the supplementing which is really only here because of the lack of accountability during um those who are actually charged to do a lot of this work um is really missing and so during this redesign process uh our superintendent or focus on organizational Clarity will will be all the more important and um for example if we just look at some of the redundancies we redundancies that we have um Even in our enrollment processes where we have uh families taking documents to our

133central office and then taking the same documents to their local school um that's working very hard but is it working as smart as we could be working right um and then if we free those staff members time up from the redundancies now that first level touch has more room to do the other things that we're going to have to redesign out right um so then how do we look at our automation processes now where we are and how do we get there quickly um it the when I make suggestions around having um one Wednesday a month to make sure that our teachers can make these family connections at home uh to home that's family engagement right um when we look at our sped cost and we see it through the roof not just because of

134increased salaries but because we when was the last time we really took a step back and look at our full inclusion model and looked at what is it producing compared to what other districts are around us are also producing and how much it's costing us to get these same results um so I'm sorry I won't be here to help with this redesign process but I look forward to um continuing the conversations uh hopefully I can still join your audit committee meetings yes and be a part of um offering different um ideas and suggestions because um it really is time to be uh the leaders in a redesign effort and not just um going for loow hanging fruit Cuts because long term it's not going to make us a world class District so thank you thank

135you so much um colleagues other other comments or I'm sorry questions or comments and director Brown is Vice President Brown is still online make sure that she doesn't have any questions not ra not raised um uh thank you so much we really appreciate the um review and uh it looks like we have an action item though is an approval of the first interim budget I move to approve and thank you thank you thank you so much director shinoski has moved to approve I was second and director babett is seconded roll call roll call director shinoski yes director Clark yes director Chang yes director Armstrong yes director babit yes vice president Brown yes motion carries on a unanimous vote thank you so much um that is 13.1 so um looks like we're uh now at to

136add information for .1 so this is for our review yep okay extended public comments um that concludes all of our agenda items for this evening's meeting we will now move to 15 minutes of extended public comments is there anyone here for public comments in person or online someone's raising their hand thank you so do we have a card for you no you can come on up thanks um I neot I just wanted to thank um Laura babit um there has been times over the past um few years that I've actually really considered leaving the district um and not doing all of the things that you know being in committees and stuff like that but um your leadership and what would Laura do and um you're just such an inspiration to so many people and thank

137you for taking the arrows and taking the hits um seen and unseen um and then I'd like to thank thank the School District board um for filling the holes at TI in their Playard so thank you for that um I would also I've been to facilities meetings and listen to part of the 2 by two and I would just really like to encourage the um School Board the district to really think multiple plans when we start building projects um because I have just some concerns about um some of the future ones that are coming up and not wanting them to um balloon like Longfellow and um because just logistically the space of where your where students are going to go um and then let's see all the things that I always want to tell you

138guys um consider reimbursing um teachers for the Long Fellow move because I know we reimburse movers be be be um so anyway thank you thank you so much of course if there's anything else you can send them via email thank you um are there any other inperson public commenters I don't believe so I think we have some online though we do Pat Riley Pat Riley would you like to speak have we elevated them yeah there you go hi I'm actually a Pat Riley's son my name is Zachary Winslow and I'm a junior at Berkeley High School and a vice president and treasur of the parent teacher student Association at Berkeley High I would like to thank lorda babbett person for service to Berkeley students and families I was at Martin Luther King Middle School during

139the pandemic and my brother was at Berkeley High we weren't actually at school as you know we were home on screen mainly bored sad it was hard when elementary schools uh kids went back and we were still stuck at home and uh when Laur babbit helped us open the gyms again to play basketball together and she was the only Schoolboard director who pushed the distress to let us play basketball in the gym again and uh to you guys it may seem like a small thing but to me my brother and my friends it meant everything I voted for you Laura thank you again for prioritizing student health and wellness I'm sorry you lost and I hope you'll stay involved the kids and families of Berkeley High and all Berkeley schools need your advocacy thank [Applause]

140you wow thank you Pat Riley's son and for basketball too um so uh do we have other public commenters online no that's it so uh colleagues do any of you have extended board comments that You' like to share seeing like we don't is it's some we're saying it's time to party meeting closing I want to thank you all again for coming out this evening um for the uh BSD board meeting and uh it's hereby adjourned thank you thank you thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.