CorpusRecord 108222

February 12, 2025 Regular Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Cloverdale Unified School District
Date
2025-02-13
Location
Sonoma County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,147 words · about 79 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e order um at 4:30 all trustees are present so at this time any person may address the board on any closed session item or any item not listed on the agenda pursuant to this brown act the board cannot consider issues or take action on request during this comment period time is limited to 3 minutes per person per item 20 minutes per topic and seeing how we have no one in the audience I will guess that that will be a no so moving on to close session agenda item so we have C1 consideration of student stipulated expulsion agreements case 20252 C2 Public Employee discipline dismissal dismissal SL relase see3 conference with real property negotiators um one property parcel number 117-0 4-55 located at 28 okay sorry 28398 South Cale Boulevard um two agency negotiators three

002negotiating party or parties um four under negotiation request of ingress/egress easement off of Kelly Road C4 Public Employee um performance evaluation superintendent and C5 conference with labor negotiators so we will go into close session at 4:31 e e e okay so we will reconvene to open session at 6:02 and can we please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance i al to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible liy and justice for all okay so um approval of agenda order the board reserves the right to change the order in which agenda items are discussed and or acted upon at this meeting subject to further action by the board the agenda for this meeting is to be approved as presented items may be

003added to this agenda for discussion or action only as permitted by the brown act do I have a motion Mo to approve the agenda okay so trusty Garrison do I have a second I'll second okay second from um lope white all those in favor I many dis or any Just Disagree right n yeah any nay okay we'll just stick with nay no and then absent we have our student rep okay now G public comment on consent and non-agenda items the public May address the board on any consent or non-agenda item pursuant to the brown act during this period the board cannot consider issues or take action on any item not listed on the agenda time is is limited to 3 minutes per person per item 20 minutes per topic do we have any okay please

004step up to the [Music] podium Mary Beth Kelly um so Board of Trustees um you guys have a really tough job to do and what you do and the decisions you make really matter for the future of Cloverdale I have a question for you so my question is what is cusd going to do to attract and retain the quality Educators that our students deserve it's not going to be money currently out of 31 districts that submitted their j9s Cloverdale ranks 24th and how much we pay our Educators and that's for salary and benefits so why is a teacher going to stay in Cloverdale in Hillsburg staff are treated as professionals and they get 10 discretionary days per year compared to four here in cusd Santa Rosa city schools has a safety article as part of

005their contract cusd is not interested in a safety article for certificated staff our students deserve the best quality education cusd can provide happy and healthy educators are vital in making this happen I'm worried about the quality Educators they're not going to want to come to Cloverdale and if they do that they're not going to stay cuts are happening around the County right now but young people are not going into education it's not a career choice for many young people we already struggle to get people to apply for jobs here there's a position that's been left unfilled for the entire school year because not one person has applied for other position maybe one person will apply how are we going to choose the best for our students if one person applies for a job do we

006Farm it out to a zoom call is it you know some online class instead of face Toof face what are we going to do for our students it's in your hands to make the decisions that are going to make Cloverdale an attractive place for Quality Educators and for students to stay and to learn so please consider when you make your choices what makes a workplace attractive and if we can't compete financially what is cusd going to do instead to bring highquality Educators who are going to stay beyond the two years of their induction thank you thank you any other public comment somebody asked me to read one for them sure okay that sounds good so just you know some people oh man okay I never took drama so sorry can you state who it was

007yes please uh it's an educator in Cloverdale who I feel like that's Anonymous though if you're not stating who it is and there's how how are we supposed to respond if it's I don't know I I I can't remember what nobody's required to give their name when they and I don't think I've ever had a response um so this uh to the board if our students education and overall well-being is the board's goal how are large classrooms and unhappy underpaid teachers a way to achieve that goal expensive leadership and poor past decisions have placed us in a financial crisis we are at a Crossroads how can teachers get the board to hear us the decisions you are making are devastating holding our our district to a 10% Reserve while we've met our 3% Reserve mandate

008is insanity in lean Financial Times how you cannot see a direct correlation between your decisions and our current situation is concerning is it more important to this board to feed more into our money heavy leadership with a new step and column but you won't pay teachers an extra 1% Cola things appear to be backwards Pay Teachers more respect them as professionals the professionals they are we teach your children and grandchildren don't you want the best for them as a teacher I believe the board greatly respects my admin but not me as a teacher and I'm the one showing up each day to do the work thank you for your time respectfully a see USD teacher thank you any other comment okay so we will move on to H Clos session reportable action taken um if

009was so final action on student stipulated expulsion agreement case 20252 Ed code 48918 um it was unanimous decision to approve correct so there's no need for motions okay okay so on to I consent calendar the cusd Board of Trustees utilizes a consent calendar for items that require the approval of the board but are of routine nature they act upon these items in one vote any member May remove an item for additional questions board members receive their agendas and backup materials 7 days in advance of our meetings they have the opportunity to ask questions and to do research prior to our meeting it is the intent to handle the routine items expeditiously so they have time to address issues that are more serious so are there any agenda items that any of the trustees would like

010to pull consent oh sorry consent sorry I have nothing okay so can I have a motion to approve consent calendar items I will move to approve consent calendar items 1 through eight okay do I have a second I'll second okay trusty o gamian preferential is absent all those in favor I I nay okay now on to Association reports a J1 um csca sorry um I believe there is no report for this evening so now on to um Teachers Association of cdale oh me that's me right now failing at my job letting the clock run out there might be an extra there I can give her the extra one I'm going to do my best I don't have a voice but um I was strongly urged to come here to speak to you guys tonight so

011I'm here um my name is Renee duvander I'm the teachers union president um of Cloverdale so tax president I'm speaking today to urge the district to honor its agreement and maintain the blue gold block schedule at Cloverdale High School this schedule was implemented after years of careful research discussion and Community input because it benefits students providing deeper learning opportunities stronger academic support and access to critical programs like Career Technical education science labs and our srjc dual enrollment it should not be discarded simply as a cost cutting measure despite its proven success the district is now pushing for changes not to improve student outcomes but to cut costs this decision goes against the original agreement that was continued in good faith this year and it disregards the overwhelming evidence that this schedule benefits students some have

012argued that the high school teachers have too much prep time but the reality is Jefferson Elementary teachers have 65 minutes per day of non student time that totals 325 minutes per week Washington Middle School teachers have 80 to 85 minutes per day of non-student time totaling just over 400 minutes per week the high school teachers currently have 80 minutes per day which is totaling 400 minutes per week the proposed seven period schedule would reduce the high school teacher prep time to just 230 minutes per week that's 95 minutes less per week than the elementary teachers have despite the high school teachers having 120 to 180 students and multiple courses to plan and grade for prep time is not free time it is essential for lesson planning creating rigorous engaging lessons tailored to students needs it's

013used for grading and giving meaningful feedback to those 120 to 180 students it's used for responding to emails communicating with parents making phone calls and updating grades it's used for collaborating with our colle colleagues aligning our curriculum creating interventions and supports for our students we also use that time for attending trainings researching best practices and adapting our lessons there's concerns about the proposed changes there the proposed changes negatively impact instruction the short class periods Force rushed surface level instruction reduce engagement and retention and limit Hands-On learning this is the seven periods in a single day increase student stress and make AP dual enrollment and CTE courses harder to manage plus it has more passing periods which is is a waste of time additionally it reduces the prep time which means reducing the quality of instruction

014limiting student support and making it harder for teachers to do their jobs effectively less teachers also mean larger class sizes less individual supports and fewer course offerings this increased work load significantly reducing our prep time without reducing the number of sections taught or the student contacts or the courses prepared for is going to lead to teacher burnout and drive Educators to leave either after this first year of implementation or before the schedule is even implemented this is going to worsen the staff instability at CHS T really appreciates Mr Harper's efforts to find a collaborative Solutions but this should not have been a problem for him and his staff to solve scheduled changes of this magnitude must be negotiated negotiations allowed the teachers union to work with the district to find find a balanced solution that

015does not disproportionately impact teachers or harm students access to courses this process ensures that decisions are made transparently and equitably rather than being dictated by Financial targets alone at CHS there are 23 teachers but only eight of them are tenur of the 15 probation teachers five are in their first year at CHS all the discussions about the pending schedule changes happened without knowing which probationary teachers would lose their jobs or how many this uncertainty weakened the discussion compared to the past years instead of solidarity in working toward what is best for students these changes have pitted departments against departments and teachers against each other staff members who should be collaborating to find the best solutions for students have been put into an unfair position forced to fight over who will be impacted the most if

016the district must reduce certificated teaching positions at the high school school it should do so in a way that preserves the block schedule while minimizing harm to Student Learning other districts such as Windsor and roner Park allow students to take seven out of eight classes instead of eight out of eight reducing the Staffing costs while maintaining the benefits of the block schedule additionally allowing students to have a free period even as freshmen and sophomores could support their social emotional well-being providing a later start time or a lighter course load and allow for work-based learning internships or employment we have a campus supervisor to help direct students off campus when they have a free period ensuring that supervision and safety remain priorities the board has the power to do the right thing the board can reject

017any schedule changes that eliminate the block schedule and ensure that any necessary adjustments prioritize student learning and teacher Effectiveness rather than just cost cutting the board already meets the state's required reserves and the proposed 1.4 million in cuts are to meet the board's own self-imposed Reserve Target this target should not be met by sacrificing our students education I urge you to make the right decision and protect our students by keeping the block schedule in place thank you thank you very much okay on to school reports K1 Jefferson Elementary School good evening um I just wanted to make myself available um to answer any questions I know I um submitted my board report a few graphs and charts and some preliminary information it was really exciting to look at our preliminary progress and it looks great

018and um we're going to keep doing it I do just want to let you know that sort of from the 30,000 feet high look we are going to be diving into some of those numbers to um you know to look at how that's happening where that's happening and um start looking in into teacher strategies and things like that so if there aren't any questions okay then ask submitted thank you good job yes thank you thank you okay on to Washington School hello good to see everybody and you have my report as submitted thank you thank you very much okay cordale high school and Je continuation high school first it was a pleasure taking you all around campuses it was a great time seeing the The Good the Bad and the Ugly and uh it was

019it was a really great time getting to know everybody everybody a little bit more so and you have my reporter submitted thank you now on to special education and Student Services report hello you also have my report as submitted sorry I just had a frog in my throat but you have my report as submitted and you're also welcome to come tour our building if if you want to at any time thank you okay on to Educational Services report as submit okay on to n maintenance operations and transportation report is submitted okay on to fiscal report I'm not going to do as submitted okay so last month if you recall we did fun with funds and this time we're going to be getting real with resources and thanks to shaa for that title because I couldn't

020come up with anything for resources so one of the things that we're going to talk about is Sachs what is Sachs Sachs is a standardized account code structure that is universal for all schools in California and it's basically made up of eight numerically coded fields and the fields then are used to tell a story this is like the language of my people right all of these different things tell us something different so can I walk over here with the mic okay so the first thing about the Sachs is the is the first one that we talked about last month which was the fund right so that's a two-digit number the next number then is the resource it's four digits and I use the abbreviation RS you'll see that a lot in some of my reports

021the third number is U mostly all the time it's a zero um this is actually a federal number to indicate what year it's supposed to be in although they're going to start using that for one of our resources because we have to S spend the money in a certain year so um this number will start showing up in reports this next year the goal and the function then they tell us um kind of like how the money is to be going to be spent what the the thing is like is it direct instruction or is it something else the object then tells us um it drills down for the expenditure of what the expenditure type it is like ones and twos and threes the salaries and benefits fours are um like um anything under $500

022for instructional materials or supplies for um custodial things like that um fives or services six is um anything over $5,000 a single item that's like a 6,400 and then the school code which um we have several of them here and then the management code is the last four digits and it um that's used to help drill down further any additional information or things that we want to to follow to chart so here's an example this example is so it's 01 that's so it's fund 01 00000000 is the resource so that's an unrestricted resource and we're going to talk about restricted and unrestricted resources on the next Slide the zero again the 1110 and the 1000 tells me that this is K12 tk12 instruction the 1000 tells me it's direct instruction to deal with the classroom

023the 4310 tells me that that is um instructional Material supplies and the 133 tells me that it's Jefferson School and there's no further drill down on the management code isn't this cool this is like just totally fascinating right okay so what are resources those res so resources they track so last time we remember about the funds right those track um they they set aside certain funds from different monies right so we have fundo one which is kind of does everything it's got restricted and unrestricted we've got fund um 13 which is for the cafeteria program and for Food Services we have fund 14 for deferred maintenance fund all these different funds right fund 21 for a bond all those kinds of things but below the funds that because that's at the top we have the

024resources and so they tell us they tell us more there are two different categories for resources one they're restricted or unrestricted and the unrestricted resources for this District so Statewide it's 000000 -999 so anything in there can be an unrestricted res source so for this District we have 000000 which is unrestricted and then we have 0400 which is the lcap because the l cap that those monies are unrestricted but they still have to be tracked right they still have to we still have to report them and follow through on them this number for the lcap varies um County to County so here's another example that's going to tell us a story so fundo one general fund four zos is going to be the unrestricted our federal zero then 00000000 here tells us that it is

025not involved in direct instruction that it's also unrestricted the 8210 tells me that it is involved in um maintenance or or maintenance of your gr of the and maintenance of the plant plant maintenance and operations the 5330 tells me that it is um for water okay and the 800 tells me that it's districtwide and then there's no management code on this see isn't this totally cool all these numbers tell us something I I just it's so much fun revenues that are unrestricted in nature but still have reporting requirements fall into the category between 1,000 and 1999 and for this District we have two we have uh resource 1100 which is unrestricted Lottery and we have resource 1400 which is the education protection account and the only thing that we're allowed to spend in there is

026teacher salaries so that's what we do and every June we come to you with what the plan is for the next year for those and because we're that's what's required it's teacher salaries that's what goes in there teacher salaries so here's another example um fund1 and so general fund 1100 tells me it's unrestricted Lottery Federal zero the 1110 1000 tells me that it's um directly involved in K12 instru tk12 instruction 4310 again is then instructional materials with a value of less than 500 and then 133 tells me that it is Jefferson I think I picked on Jefferson today okay so what about the other side of the budget what about the restricted so the restricted resources are 2,000 through 9999 and the district has a lot of these so the first one is resource 2600

027which is the expanded learning opportunities program that's the only one right now that the state has that's in the 2000s and why they did that I don't understand because normally the state restricted resources are 6,000 to 89.99 but it is that's 2600 that's where that goes resources 3,000 to 5999 are all of our federal restricted resources so those things those include things like Title One title three uh this is title two and we have 15 different Federal resources then uh for the state restricted we have 6,000 to 89.99 we have um so there's 29 + 3 and that's because with this um with one resource 6388 which is the strong wor Workforce program we actually have three grants within that so we have 29 plus three different state resources that we use and these are

028this is um prop 49 our ases program the 6053 is upk program that's onetime money 6,300 is restricted Lottery and 7010 is um a incentive Grant and I just put up some there just as an example of one some of the ones you're going to see U resource 9,000 to 9999 is local restricted resources and in this District we have five of them two of them are 9020 which is donations so this is where we track all the donations that come in and where they're going and then 9070 is um our boot boosters our um yeah our boosters program for sports and when they make a donation to us it goes into the 9070 so some of the examples here oh this is going to be fun okay so this one is special ed right

029because 6500 is special is special education this tells me that it is oh I need my notes I can't remember everything sorry okay so the 5760 tells me that it's special education for students between the ages of 5 and 22 the 1180 tells us that it is for um non-public schools or non um or npas non-public agencies then the 5110 tells me that it's a sub agreement for um a non-public school and 800 is the designation for districtwide the next one then remember we talked about this this these this this can change to the funds so this one is um fund 13 which is the cafeteria fund 5310 tells us that those are federal dollars 3700 means that it's for Food Services 4710 is food blah blah blah you kind of get the idea right

030okay all right [Music] um that's it that's all about resources I do want to make sure though that we talk about one other thing and that is we've had a request to increase the information that we're providing you um on the board report for the checks so if you could turn to page 12 for me for a moment in page 12 is a list of all the checks um that the board is approving and we run this um on a monthly basis for the board and about halfway through the board pack or through that page on page 12 there is an item that says um the check date is 1825 to the city of Cloverdale and it says that the fund and the object is 01 5530 so that tells me that the that's a

031general fund and the 5530 tells me that it's water and then you can see what the bill was 3417 353 but if you don't know all those codes off the top of your head and you haven't read the cam man manual which is the California state accounting manual which is 630 Pages because I looked that up today then you don't know that 5530 is water right so we're going to change this report for next month and it's going to include the um the whole funding code that tells us everything about it and then it's also going to include the comment so one of the things that will come up is it'll say for next time it'll say 2425 water and sewage charges and that g then gives you more information so that you understand where

032things are coming from because we do need to be good stewards of our money and know what's happening with it so um I hope that'll be a good change for everybody and that's getting real with resources thank you yes than you okay um now on to board reports anybody would like to go first um I can start okay hold on I'm not ready okay since our last meeting um what did I do I had attend I attended um our lcap meeting got rescheduled right so that will be next week um I did tour CHS and J with Mr Harper thank you and like I told miss fanis and miss Holden I'm gonna get back to you guys it's only two that's the only site I don't have a child at so I did prioritize them

033um so I will be doing it touring the other class or the other sites also um we also attended a we myself and truste z attended a board coffee chat um that was kind of a while ago um it was good there was a lot of discussion there was some um feedback from us from a lot of our uh Spanish speaking population um with some requests that I will put out there um there's just little things like um they don't have a translator at PTA meetings which they would like to see if to be more involved um um things like that I have notes somewhere um but I did send them along um I think that's in my busy life I think that's all I have to report right now though okay thank you I

034okay who would like to go next yes I'll go um let's see uh first and I actually wanted to say I was able to attend the girl soccer fundraiser tamali sales it was pretty good tamali it was great um I also had a tour of two three sites the high school Contin school as well as Middle School um it was great to learn and see what's going on and what's could be improving all that good stuff um I also attended was it the daac meanie yes meanie as well um I believe we have a new uh liaison is that what they what's do we have a new direct process we're in the process of a new whatever the title is I'm not sure community community leaz on there we go um and so the plan

035for me is to just continue to attend the girls varsity senior night tomorrow if you are able to go Sho social support your seniors a little biased cuz I coach some of them as JVS but but um other than that that's all I have to report okay thank you trusty zits so I had quite a busy month um I visited all the schools um it was great to see all the efforts from everybody um for our children uh there's a lot of good programs being implemented and seeing the Buy in with the teachers is great um it's good to see changes in the positive direction and people buying into it and making it work um I was also able to attend the measure H meetings um those are moving along sure we'll touch more on

036that stuff uh je is also was a great program I never knew we had that here um that is very cool to see that working um I also went back last week and shared my story with them which uh I think they helped me a lot more than whatever I did for them I spent I was supposed to be there an hour I was there for 4 hours um that's a very moving program and I like to see things like that continue that's great um I wrote quite a bit of notes so I could have went on forever I'm just going to touch these things here U overall it you can tell the intentions behind the staff and the administration is in the good intent for the children um which was very as being new

037to this this and app parent on the outside for very long it was good to see um this has all been very eye opening for me and I look forward to the next three uh years on this but with all that said I just want to thank everybody for taking time out all your schedules I know you already have a lot on your plate and you took time to take me around your classrooms and sit down with me and talk with me and share things um and it was really nice it was good to get a relationship going with everybody thank you thank you okay trusty Garrison uh I attended the measure H um we interviewed contractors for the tkk project um so that'll be more um and then we just had a a check-in

038for the measure H um attended with truste equit two sarb meetings for January and February um I they positive interactions with the families and students and there's a lot of review with the contracts that are already implemented to see if we need to do further checkin or um if they need to be referred to the district attorney um I did a site tour of CHS and J facilities um I would like to come back and see more of like the classroom happenings um and then a site tour at Jefferson and we got to see a lot of the tier one work with youly um the reading and a little bit of math and you can really see with what you you the charts that you gave us that it's it's working so that's fantastic to

039see that that is working and I still need to make a appointment to visit Washington so we're working on that but um it's fun to go out there and see everything in action so thank you okay thank you um unfortunately the plague month at my house came a little bit early this year and the flu hit us pretty hard between my kiddo and myself so I was not able to do as much as my fellow trustees um the major thing was the School site tours and I am sorry shaa about not being able to make hours um but I definitely will reschedule to hopefully be able to come and look and see what you guys are doing but Jefferson it was great like trusty Garrison said it was great to see the reading instruction and

040the math instruction um and speaking from the mother of a first grader her reading ability it's just it's really wonderful to see um she is definitely a lifelong reader much better than her mom is um so I have to give her kudos for that and just all the hard work you guys are doing at that site it's awesome um with or our 2hour tour of the high school was super fun I've never been into je and it was nice um teaching a kiddo how to peel an onion and how to chop it properly um while they were making Tores for everybody for Friday meal was super fun and just being able to get a a lay of the land in the facilities and put some names to faces and whatnot and again all of you

041guys are doing great work so I just love it and I very much appreciate all of you um also the neon night H or the glow night I was not able to make it because I had the flu um but she went and I had some great pictures and it looked like a blast so it's so fun for them to be able to come back like at night and they think they're so cool and it's like their a little older experience so it was great so thank you I'll just touch on um also there's an upcoming board coffee chat that Miss Buon will let everyone know but it's March 13th at Washington at 7:45 oh so all are welcome to them it'll be trusty yeah Lopez white and I yes I will also say I

042would like to go back to the floral arranging room cuz that was like so much fun just to see all of the stuff it'd be great to sit in on that as well I just yeah and I wanted to touch on the tier one uh program uh that is very awesome that you can see the results um the handwriting and the reading I have to say uh in the private sector those kids are writing and reading a lot better than a lot of people I deal with daily so congratulations on even some of my seventh and eighth graders not going to lie okay so on to superintendent report yeah on the um you have the letter in front of you from the um first interim um and I'm not going to go through it because

043all of you can read clearly um and I would just say that we are um working on on a calendar for next year as well um and you should be seeing that coming hopefully fairly soon uh and also I would touch on the fact that the floral class um the floral class there's some arrangements that they have down in Dalia and Sage that you can purchase for Friday Valentine's Day um so Riley made sure to let me everybody know that those are there so basically they're making the arrangements sold them to Di and Sage than selling them also so um yeah and there's a whole display and I haven't seen it yet but she's telling me there's a whole display they also um when we went to when um a couple of Trustees went to

044the trustee meet uh trustee dinner at the county um the floral class also did all of the centerpieces for those tables that were there and it must have been beautiful 30 or 40 tables there right so um so the word's getting out so anyway that's it okay wonderful so on to sorry on to report discussion uh measure H update oh Eric yes it going good evening good evening hello everyone uh as far as reports for measure H updates uh over this last month since the last resolution was passed for uh the request for proposals and request for qualifications for the Jefferson uh tkk Elementary School New modular project we went through that procurement process over this last month interviewed contractors qualified them received all their uh proposals for the project and later on it in

045the discussion and action section three we will uh we will we will seek to to to qualify the the contractor for uh for that project so that's kind of how we're looking and then any other update that was updated in the measure H update uh kind of included a timeline on where we're looking at within the funding and kind of goals for the next month and how we'll look to update that and uh if once uh hopefully a selection is made today for the contractor then we're in a good position to just make that extra step towards getting the project under 90% uh and hopefully we have plans for the next board meetings and how we like to proceed okay thank you thank you thank you likewise okay on to S2 utk Early Education facilities

046project update I believe that just happened yep okay wonderful uh S3 South Cloverdale property update so we um we did had a an item in close session that we we spoke about um I would just say that um one of the board members um contacted me and we took a trip out there to kind of look around and see uh I would offer that to anybody uh that wants to to uh look at the property or they like to see things um we have also um the maintenance department has gone out and secured the location a little bit better put some locks on some uh Gates uh and such we did have a situation where it looked like a vehicle um kind of behind the wine Co-op snipped our um fits and did a little

047Joy writing out there in the mud um it didn't go too well for him I don't think um but we were trying to secure some video to be able to see but we couldn't get any video of that so we've fixed the fence there um and then like I said fixed a couple other Gates I just do that the fence around it's not great but it is somewhat of a deterrent um across the street across Kelly road from us is the U the tribal housing they do have a 24hour uh security out there which actually does help us uh for that part um but they aren't watching our side so if somebody does drive out there they're not really watching that um I would hope they might call but um but other than that um

048we're just kind of waiting and see it is definitely I've been out there several times it's definitely overran by Coyotes that's for sure um there's a couple Coyotes out there every single time I've been out there broad daylight uh for that so um but anyway I'll keep updating with that and then once we um we'll start having more discussions about kind of what we want to do going forward with that property as well I know we've kind of started that a little bit um but we've had some other things coming up with a med project so we've kind of put that on a whole a little bit so look forward to that being brought up again okay thank you on to S4 Cloverdale High School 2025 2026 master schedule so Forest is going to come

049up and do thank you a presentation he's taking the clerk's job by hand and everything out thank you all right hello everybody perfect and if you can yeah so what you have in front of you is what we've been working on with our uh changing our bell schedule so this is kind of a timeline of what we've done so far so that first line is the November board meeting so that was the first time it was kind of publicly stated that there wants to be a change to the bell schedule so after that we started working on coming up with some ideas so after that board meeting so these are all hyperlink and that just hyperlinks to the board uh YouTube channel for that time slot that talks in November when the board had a

050conversation about bell schedule and credits and things like that so in December we had SLT that is site leadership team so that's like department shairs so I gave a PowerPoint to the staff um to the leadership team about what we're looking at doing presenting to the rest of the staff and I got feedback from the leadership team on the idea of changing our bell schedule so if you look in your packet you can see those are the notes from our leadership team meeting in December um so lots of questions you can see and then in January the type of meeting it was a PD day meeting and so during our PD day coming back in the new semester we had a discussion about the bell schedule so you can see that's the next right after

051the notes it says schedule change for the next school year so this is something that I was working on to prevent uh to propose uh some changes so one of the you can see that PowerPoint so first acknowledging you know there's been lots of change with the bell schedule put in the contract with the 45 minutes a day um that goes into it and then how many teachers we have and the Crux of the bell schedule is do teachers need to have a prep every single day and if so that changes whether we're going to be able to have block or not have block so if you look over the next few pages you'll see that I came up with five different options teachers helped come up with these different options and kind of played

052around with minutes and things like that um the different options are for either all day um classes for seven periods or six six periods partial block which is 4 days block and then option five which is 3 days block two or sorry two days block 3 days all classes so every schedule has its pros and its cons and you can see uh some of the cons is having to go to negotiations which is having the block schedule so that period that option one and option five since teachers wouldn't get the 45 minutes of prep every day that's referenced in the document then it would have to go to negotiation so that kind of you know takes longer it slows things down uh so then we had a discussion um you can see in here I

053also included Hillsburg High schedule Anderson Valley schedule in which they do uh different types of our options so we had a discussion as a staff what we would like to see what we would like to do at the end of the discussion staff said you know should we vote on this I said hold off I there's some you know things I still want to work out so on January 22nd we had a PLC meeting day where I did the next presentation so that's the one that says continued bell schedule change for next year and so you can see recapping what we talked about during the PD day oh yeah it's on you uh so Kathleen if you can click on the 122 PowerPoint and then if you can go to slide six let's actually go

054back to this is a summary of kind of the different options that we came up with looking it over this is all in the all in the packet so if you go forward to so this is what we looked at for these are the total number of sections we have in our master schedule everything that's highlighted blue is we have to have for grad basically graduating high school that's the California minimum so according to the California minimum you need 130 credits in order to graduate high school the orange sections are what you would need basically to go to a UC or a CSU uh so for example California minimum you only need 30 credits of English to graduate but for to go to straight to a CSU or UC you need uh 40 credits of

055English to graduate so that's why English 4 is in orange everything that is in white is optional based on a minimum California diploma so I put them alphabetically just to kind of like not say oh these are the preferred or whatever it's just just get an idea of the master schedule everything that is in this black box is how many sections we would have to go down if we had a seven period day so we would lose about 18% of our sections uh Kathleen if you go forward if we go to a six period day so that means teachers only teaching five classes we would lose 30% of our master schedule because we just teachers are teaching less so that's less classes less options we just have less sections So based on that conversation I

056I couldn't support option two which is the sixth period day so I took that off the table and we continue to have a conversation of the remaining options options one 3 four and five and so staff voted you can go to the Kathleen if you want to go back to the timeline and staff had just a simple vote you can see there that there's Option 1 3 4 five what schedule you're Mo most interested in having next year and you can see 91% of the staff chose option five and I included all the comments in the Google form that staff voted and most people are saying it strikes the right balance you know we still get some blocks so a lot of our CTE classes that we invested heavily in like culinary can still have

057that block you know uh Project based learning classes labs for science you know they can still build in those block days um and so it kind of strikes the best balance so that is what we did on 122 and then Kathleen if you can scroll down a little bit you can see on 129 in plc's staff discussed what are we going to do about advisory because in advisory we could we can kind of play around with it like if we have less advisory time we can have more advisory time and staff had a discussion about what they want to do with advisory um it was all very collaborative and most of the staff's kind of opinion was they like having advisory two to three days a week right now we have it four days a

058week um so we have it Monday Tuesday Thursday Friday and Wednesday is our short day so no advisory and so staff liked two or three days a week so since staff liked that option five we went with different choices within that option five so this is the last thing that we did just two days ago so in our staff meeting the staff met and uh with some teacher help I came up with some different choices so this is the very end of the packet where it says choice 1 a choice 1 b 2 a 2B and three so we had a conversation as a staff what do we like about these different choices because the main thing is we need to pick a framework what is the framework we want and it sounds like staff

059like the framework of uh option five the most and then once we have the framework of two blocks three all classes what are some choices within those um and so you can see the notes from the staff meeting on Monday um seems like most people liked option one or Choice One within that option five and that's everything we've done so far and then yesterday I met with Tac and basically did a kind of longer version of what I just gave you and that gets us to here so the board yeah any questions anything just one question so what do you mean by advisory what's ADV ADV so advisory is kind of like our home room class and so students all get assigned a specific teacher um this year we put students with the teacher most

060likely who they have and so um every teacher gets assigned a grade level so you have a teacher that has a grade level of all Juniors or all seniors or all freshman or sophomores and then during that time it's a 40-minute class students go to that teacher and they can work on their work so they can work on homework they can work on classwork they can get help from their teacher and we have a digital hall pass that students use it's called MinGa and if they want to leave that advisory to go to another teacher's room they go to their teacher and ask hey can you make a MinGa pass so I can come make up a test or get help or something like that and then they go to their class check in for

061attendance and then they start the teacher starts the MinGa pass they go to see their other teacher they end the MinGa pass uh so and with choice one uh what's the prep time that the teachers have like the the option one or Choice One or option your you I believe it was option five that the teachers mostly voted for and Choice One a right choice one a 1 b 2 a 2B and three are all the exact same minutes okay so yeah so but I I tried to print it in color but is the prep times what's what's the overall because they were I believe it was 80 minutes prior to this correct right so right now teachers get a prep every single day and our classes are 80 minute long classes so teachers get

062a prep for 80 minutes each day and so this if you look at Option five that is on the slide that says um oh they all say 212 cuz I them all today but if you look at the part where it says option four and then below that option five and then below that it has all those minutes you can kind of see those minutes or Kathleen if you want to scroll up and click on scroll down scroll up click on this one 16 16 PowerPoint I don't want to touch the screen so I'll leave more so I see like and then go to slide 17 I can't I if you just keep going keep going I'll tell you when to stop thank you almost there stop there it is okay so this is our

063option five which is which is all classes for seven periods 3 days a week and then 2 days a week week we would have block classes okay so these minutes have changed a bit because we've played around with it cuz one of the feedback we got from staff is that they didn't like the 90minut period because people were saying that was too long so we've kind of shortened that down and an increased advisory so we still get out at 315 cuz that was the choice three of option five staff didn't like because we were getting out at different times like each day and one of the things that made the day longer kids wouldn't be able to get the bus and so everybody liked consistently getting out at 3:15 so I think what you were

064asking for the prep time is you know this would reduce you would see we would reduce our number of prep time but it would make that contractual 45 minutes for every day except for one of the block days and since the contract States 45 minutes of prep every single day that's why it would have to so with this right here every Wednesday would always be a gold day and every Thursday would always be a blue so so overall though those classes on gold days you're having less time throughout the year in those classes rather than we we've played around with this since then so this was what we came up with in early January so actually Kathleen if you go to back to the yeah scroll down and then schedule ideas this is the more

065recent one so based on staff feedback we reduce that number of minutes so now we have the block as 85 minutes and so if you keep scrolling down right and then it's 80 1 minutes so they're pretty close and that's to try to you know get everything as together as possible can you just add a couple minutes to each class and then just shrink down advisory on that day we could to make it just even or why I I have a couple of questions but why wouldn't you have it like a the gold day on a Tuesday and the blue day on a Thursday yeah what is the what was the why back to back one one of the days we have to do our block day has to be on a Wednesday because every

066school needs to have their PLC day at the same time because that's something we're looking at doing is collaborating more with the different sites and so it wouldn't work if one one site is off so that kind of locks us into the 246 being on that Wednesday and so then this Thursday the other block day you could do it on Tuesday or Thursday um but people didn't like having like all day class Monday block then all day class then block then all day class it's a little too much like jumping around but I'm saying why can't you still have your plc's on Wednesday but just move the block I mean right now you don't have the So the plan is to continue to H if you scroll up to continue to have plc's on Wednesday

067so that's why we're getting out at 210 I know but you can still get out at 210 and not have block that day but then that would I'm thinking wouldn't be that the the classes would be so important then the classes would be even shorter because on the day that we start so each day we start at 8:00 okay I should have just controlled the TV if you scroll down a little bit so on the days where we have all of our classes we're out at 3:15 and the classes are about 50 minutes each so if we're getting out at 2:10 then that's going to make the classes even shorter and then when you have Choice 1 a choice 1 B B Choice 2 a choice 2 B and choice 3 those are all different

068options for option five correct okay correct so those in the back are only different options for option five yeah that's why we called them choice and option so it's trying to differentiated a bit um Choice 1 a and 1B is only differentiated with moving flip-flopping advisory in fourth period which we talked about as a staff you can see in our notes and we decided we want to pull students and get their feedback before making any kind of final decisions there and then if you look at Choice 2 a and 2B is um having advisory three days a week and staff didn't like that so Kathleen if you pick the one over to the right one over to the right there so with Choice two is we're having advisory 3 days a week and so then

069we would have multiple schedules which people didn't like because we'd have a Monday Tuesday schedule with no advisory and then the other all classes schedule is with advisory so it's it's a lot of different schedules and so people weren't a fan of that and then choice three was reducing block periods down to 80 minutes which means those days we get out earlier but then you take those minutes and put them into the all classes all day and those days get out later and we found out that the city bus kids would be able to miss uh the bus if they get out that late and that's the last bus that comes over here so that's why people liked Choice One the most how is with the um the one that's the most popular whatever that

070one is one um is that easy to adjust for weeks where we don't have school on Monday or like this week we don't have school on Thursday and Friday correct that's why when we were looking at kind of like what Jackie was saying with our block days is having those kind of in the middle of the week and not on a Monday or on a Friday because then teachers are off a day and that makes you know it makes it challenging so yeah so our block days since we're locked into that Wednesday the block day would either be Tuesday or Thursday and I think we liked Thursday the best I forget why but you could just flop it to Tuesday like sure since this week would have been right right and so that's like um

071when we have advisory 4 days a week whenever we have a pep rally we just do that during advisory so we're not taking away from class time and since in this schedule we wouldn't have advisory on Friday we would just do a special schedule for a pep rally week and so for this we would have to change the kind of special week to say hey blocks are this day so if my math is mathing this allows 225 minutes of prep time for teachers with the option five I I I don't know off the top of my head well if there's three days of 45 and one one day at 90 that comes out the the 224 okay [Music] it's a little bit more on one yeah because we got rid of the advisor it's closer

072I think it all kind of equals out because we also reduce the minutes there the the minutes should be all pretty pretty much the same okay do you guys have any more questions we're not making a decision tonight right it's just information presented to us right and sorry and uh it would be helpful if we got some direction also of what we're thinking I mean if we are if the board is thinking that no we would like to know what what you would like us to go down the road we feel like this matches up U the best with the current language and the contract uh for us to be able to do that um but with the original contract because right now theou is expired correct that's correct cor what's the contract not the

073mlu correct okay and so it would be helpful for um us to figure out what kind of our marching orders are from the board um but we wanted to make sure the information was there because know we started it a while back it came up a while back but now we've had two new board members to to be able to to talk about this as well um and I would just uh I know it was said earlier and I would commend uh forest and and really everybody at the high school that's really worked hard hard on collaborating to get this and we understand that it's it's a change and I get that um but um for us has really done a good job of of trying to do as many uh and have a lot

074of meetings and everything too so I would say I appreciate that very much uh for that so we're trying to get everybody's voice to make sure that they are heard um and even tonight we heard a voice as well so we're kind of we've been doing the four I say we am not me uh Forest has been doing the work um and so we're presenting it to you so that now we're looking for direction from you guys not action but more of just Direction because has been um if the board decides to like option five Choice One um within reason I mean there could be tweaks right but the the general idea of it then we need to negotiate on your behalf because it is a change to the current contract right and any change

075to the current contract needs to be negotiated as was stated clear and if no decision is made then it reverts back to the contract cor correct we have to use the contract as our correct I just think before it gets comes back to us for an approval because ultimately that's what would happen correct correct I just want to make sure it's we dive into it as thoroughly as we can so if this is the route we go that we're not making another change in a couple years or and I want to make sure that this is it is fair across the board for teachers and adequate prep time to their contract and to what is sustainable and financially this is what we can do and what it I just I don't want to keep yeah

076and I keep the course less do those sections and still keep the programs we want to we could also have um special meetings also to to deal with this also um it just really it it takes us a while to get to this point so we didn't want to come to you in Midstream so to speak right so we wanted to make sure we had all the back uh information and so we're kind of at a point now where we need direction from you guys for that and whether it's um more meetings that we'd like to have just on this topic we could certainly do that we just were kind of to the point where we need more Direction on that part I have a question goad yes I just was curious why you chose

077Hillsburg and Anderson Valley as the block schedule schools to compare us with because those in in that original um the five options you you don't really need to see the what ises an all class day look like because it's like well it's 1 through 7 Monday through Friday so it's like it's very easy to kind of understand so I gave the examples of option one and option five because block complicates things it it's easy it's easiest to have a schedule where it's all classes all day you know it it makes things simple and so I put the example of how other schools do it because they do it pretty differently like Anderson Valley has advisory and a home room so two days a week they have home room and then they have advisory at a

078separate time and then heldsberg is interesting uh because they're they're out like at all different hours so you can see Hillsburg oh God I can't read that they also start later than yeah they start later and then there's sometimes they're out of like out at 350 so just not as like hey we should do this it's more of here are some comparable you know not 1700 kid high schools you know smaller comprehensives right cuz that's that's kind of the problem if you look at Sonoma County you have us Geyserville and then every everybody else is you know Elsie's I think 900 something and then everybody else is over you know 1300 so you know with elmolino closing they were kind of our most comparable and so now there's not a lot like we're kind of

079better compared to like Lake County kind of size of schools for comprehensive high schools and when I mean comprehens I don't mean like Charters or Independent Schools so do we want more meetings what would you guys like to see probably more discussion about it to make sure we have the most optimal um choice and financial financially responsible choice as well for my opinion can can we get a copy of the one where you had the black Square where it was like if we dropped it to this many it would be these ones and all these be eliminated can you share that with us cuz I didn't see it in here unless I'm or it's really tiny it's in there but it's in the smaller PowerPoint I can print out yeah cuz it it is very

080oh I can print it out soon and then um if it was eliminated to the smaller block one of them just as a scenario what would happen to all the classes that are Grant funded what do you mean the smaller block what do you mean you had it blacked out so if I think if you go back to to the one where it was blue and orange and then white um you you showed a change and you said if it's seven periods it's this and then if it was only this it was this and it looked like some of the white classes got eliminated from that or am I not those it's just a list of class not which ones would be eliminated he was just trying to sorry he was if if I understanding

081you right the ones if you're saying the classes that were listed as being cut those were just listing the number of classes they weren't saying those specific ones would be cut they just okay they were just yeah they were just trying to show the number of classes that would be left over it's a visual to show if we went to a six period day how much we would have to cut because we're already cutting back with teachers and sections but if we taught less then it's even more on top of that okay and so that's why I took out option two as an option because and that's why you said it's just alphabetical it doesn't mean that right right cuz I didn't want to say like these are the ones I like and not you

082know it's a visual to see how much would go I appreciate all the effort you guys put into this so far this is showing that you're trying really hard and um but being a new board member I have to side with gamian and I I would like to meet and talk about this more to make a proper decision and sure really evaluate what you guys put together here yeah we've we've had lots of meetings and lots of discussion just as a staff to kind of get up to this point so you can that's why meeting type is a column you to show how much how much conversation I would ask what what sort of information would you like us to bring to the next discussion so that we have that information I need a better

083grasp on the two schedules just from start to finish a l to digest right now seeing it right here for the first time to then like think about right and I will say my only two sents are this needs to be done pretty quickly only because building a master schedule takes an incredibly long time so I'm not saying let's make this hastily but at the same time we definitely need to be doing this sooner rather than later just so that there's not scrambling only because I am very well aware of all of the time and effort it takes to build that master schedule well we're we're already meeting sorry we're already meeting next week for the governance handbook the governance part we could actually just add that on to that since we're already meeting which

084is next 20th yeah so is thatth 20th I believe yeah house no I know I'm just saying so there's that option to be able to do because it's a special so you're only going to need 24 hours notice so okay do we have do we have um part of the reason it was or how it was sold to us is it would help increase student outcome do we have data on that to show if how students were performing prior to the block schedule versus during the block schedule I can pull that that would be helpful yeah you will email them your PowerPoint so they have that what they were talking about yeah and I could just email this document and everything's hyperlink I just want to make an educa yes and then Rene decision she

085was talking oh yeah that is 122 no the second PowerPoint not that one yeah I found it in here it's just super tiny to yeah yeah no go forward there that one jaie this one yeah okay go to the one where one probably mic because I have voice okay so one of the things that we discussed as staff because when we went to block schedule we took on teaching an additional class that's how we were able to do the block schedule originally without adding additional staff so when we went from teaching six out of seven class no we T sorry we used to teach five out of six classes at CHS when we switched to block schedule we started teaching six out of eight so we took on an additional prep at CHS so we

086had to prep a new course whether it was a new elective or an add for me an additional math class we took on a new course for us so we added a new little cell to this thing but we're now being told we can't go back to this and the reason why we can't go back to this is because of the FTE it's because we're cutting the four teachers at CHS so that again that's in your hands that's not in Forest hands and that's not in tax hands that's in your hands how many FTE we have to cut at CHS so if we wanted to do a schedule like this if we have to drop down to seven sections but give teachers enough prep time we have to have an additional FTE in order to

087take on additional sections for your students thank you so I want to make sure I have my marching orders correctly so uh data on performance of students grades graduation cast scores before we made the change which was 3 years ago correct right that's going to be messy because it's covid times but we can do that before and then since then so I can get that data for you maybe even include attendance in that I mean the main criter Years cuz that's kind of an would skew it but yeah yeah I I'll get a range okay and so the main criteria of those Student Success and then um print out the six and seven physical copy with the larger print and then further discussion share it with them on the email sure yeah could do that

088and then further discussion how do we want to do that well I think that what I'm hearing is you guys once you guys get a better idea then you have more questions potentially for that so I think it's just understanding from their perspective okay we'll just have to meet on the 20th and we'll see what happens okay well and to Rene's point I that's kind of an ass but that would have to be negotiated correct like that's not an automatic thing that would have to be negotiated where she what that I'm I'm confused where she said if we went back to this we'd have to add an extra FTE that's I guess negotiate it no it's not no cuz that only time to negotiate is if you're changing the language to send the current contract

089okay right Staffing right Staffing is not a negotiated item a um the change in contract language would be a negotiated it okay and the reason why again that it would be a negotiated item is because the the option five doesn't give a prep every day okay and currently in the contract it says they get a 45 minute every day um it doesn't say a total number of minutes for the day correct right so that would be a change in the contract which would trigger negotiations for that kind of from my perspective we as a staff has kind of gone as far as we could go like at at this point we've gotten pretty far along with all of these discussions so um I'll just wait to hear what else I okay so I think you

090said this and now I'm confused on Choice 1 a uhhuh this one they do not have a prep every day correct because when don't they have a prep if I'm on on the Block schedule days if you can hit back or hit Escape you prep on3 go to that dog scr down four and six would have their Prep schedule ideas so it all depends on what class period they have off C that for prep so so you have prep on Wednesday you don't on Thursday so Ashley for example let's say a teacher saying okay if let's say a teacher has second period prep right so they would get a prep Monday Tuesday Friday then they would get a prep on Wednesday and then Kathleen if you scroll down since they have a second period prep

091they wouldn't get a prep on Thursday thank you so that that's the Crux of the problem okay so do we feel clear on the marching orders yes okay that would be the same for one as submitted thank you Forest on to discussion action items I know T1 consideration and acceptance of donations first I would like to read them off and then we can go from there so Kanas Club of Cloverdale donated $200 to the Cloverdale High School football program um Kanas Club of Cloverdale donated 500 to the Cloverdale High School class of 2026 C candy shops donated $315 to the Cloverdale High School class of 2026 and the blackb giving fund via P gen donated $40 to Cloverdale high school so we would love to see thank you so much for those donations and do

092I have a motion move I'll move to approve the donations trusty Lopez white do I have a second I'll second the motion okay trusty zits preferential is absent all those in favor I I nay okay anyone oppos that's what we're talking about okay so anyone opposed will be what I use from now on it's like using name because you never get to use it okay so now on to T2 consideration and possible approval of candidate to elect as California school boards Association delegate assembly sub region 3A um candidate um we get this every year and you're supposed to vote on your delegate that you wish to serve a two-year term um I don't know either one of these people um the only criteria to be on be nominated is you have to be a current

093sitting board member at a at a district that is within our sub region can someone explain to me how bisha is our sub region makes no sense the regions are all different you have AXA regions you have csba regions you have there's all over the place there's no real R reason for that okay they consider it the snowa County Sub region but okay I don't so we just do do we go down I nominate Shelby Mo Moher okay if that's how you pronounce it from so motion for Shelby mhler do I have a second I'll second okay besto gami in seconds preferential is absent all those in favor I I any opposed okay then Shelby Mohler is our candidate all right go Shelby yep I think I've met her I'm not sure so that's a

094very good choice well I like what she um okay here wait let me get this okay so now on to T3 consider and possible approval of selection of lease lease back contractor the Jefferson School utk Early Education facilities project resolution 22512 finding that right Contracting LLC represents the best value of the school district and awarding and approving the leas lease back agreement yeah so um I know aon's uh aon's making his way up to the podium but uh basically we had um a panel that interviewed uh a couple of contractors one happened to be uh disqualified because they did not uh file their paperwork correctly and um so we the the panel chose a right construction uh to do the um and remember this is just the site work portion of the um project not

095the building the building Parts already been taken care of so it's just a site uh work portion of that and so what we were asking uh the board to do is to basically approve the resolution that selects right um and then Aaron and I will go get to work on working on the contracts and everything like that too but this essentially Awards them the contract but then we'll get the language um that'll come in front of you guys and you're also basically authorizing me to start working with those contracts um I don't know if you have anything else to add on that that was perfect yeah I was just heading up here just in case you want me to give a little breakdown like that so and then also um that would be the the

096action we're looking for and then if you wanted to do that separately I do have another thing that I wanted to talk about with the lease leaseback um why don't we do this first or then we'll talk about that secondly okay if anybody has any questions er's here I'm here and also um Chad and and Jackie were on the um yep the panel as well so they can participated in the contractor interviews with us I don't have any questions sounds like a motion a motion to approve right Contracting okay Lopez or Lopez white makes a motion to approve do I have a second I guess I'll second okay you gambian seconds referential absent all those in favor I I any opposed okays and the second thing on that is that um as we've been talking

097um before is we have a funding there's a funding criteria that we have to be in we have to be in contract for 90% of the work before they're released to State funds so what I'm asking the board and this isn't an action item it's just more of uh direction is what we're hoping is is that the the fact that we've chosen both contractors and we're going to be in contracts with them um that your comfortability of us proceeding knowing that information and waiting to for us to 8 weeks for the funding to come in are we good with that or do we want to wait for the for the to hit our bank account before we start proceeding um we've we're waiting on confirmation from the opsc and the State Board of Education to

098basically approve that fact but remember there's that 90% thing that we're trying to figure out if that works if if entering these contracts works for that so um I don't want to make that decision on my own because that's a lot of money um so I just I guess I'm curious of what the again the comfortability is with going forward with just knowing that we're ow that money or do we want to wait till the money gets in our bank account before we move forward I feel if we want to stay on schedule that's what I was thinking then we need to move forward we are we're pushing at least two months down the line if we waited yes and foreseeing other possible snags whether it be weather or whatever it might be you know

099what I mean for project times and whatnot I don't know construction that well but still um I yeah I'm all in favor of going for for my recommendation is that we move forward I'm fine with moving forward for you a wi yeah no I was thinking in my head 90% of the work has to be in contract correct 90% of the amount of the project has to be under contract yes exactly okay and we have that we are for sure at 90% if we now that we've this or go ahead go ahead over this next month we'll work with the contractor to present to you guys the GMP so we'll be applying their post construction and construction fee to a schedule of values for each component of their part of the project once we've done

100that that would bring uh our contract value to 100% so right now with just JL construction at estimated value they don't reach that 90% for us to be able to complete that application and move forward not me personally but King Consulting in the district to uh complete that application process to release the funding what he [Music] said I think we're okay are we in agreement it sounds like yeah okay good thank you appreciate that likewise okay so on to um discussion action item T4 consideration and possible action on board policy 3100 budget and review of resolution 222- 04 committed fund balances okay this was um brought up I Believe by me Ash we uh at the last meeting to look at um the the two different um one of them is the board there two

101different things we have here so one of them is the board policy which is 3100 which talks about um the board the district shall maintain a 10% Reserve um and then it says other words obviously but that's I think the piece talking about yeah and then the second piece of it was that I think I don't I'm not sure if it was Jackie or if it was it was also me also you okay never mind um was talking about the resolution that was and I'm not to it yet but I can't remember the year it was 178 I think it was that um says that the board instructs the district to set aside monies for it was after 2020 cuz I was on the board when we did that okay and to set aside monies

102for um the track replacement or the athletic field replacement as well as um there's a different fund that that deals with technology and Furniture yeah and I believe also one of the um questions came out um was is are we setting aside enough money or too much money or what and remember we talked about um the fact that it's it's it's somewhat difficult because during Co times we had monies and we also had uh you know we we bought a lot more things during that time for you know whether it's sneeze guards or things like that too so it's it's a little bit um difficult but I know that we've um Christ and I have been working on and this is another piece of paper that you have in front of you um working on

103tracking that and you'll see that we have um spending all the way back to 1415 um and it shows there and what we've spent um but we don't really have like when it says Furniture we don't really have what that furniture was right so there's no way of we didn't get that information yet as far as whether they're sneeze guards or whether they're desks or things like that um from what I've been understanding from staff is we haven't gotten a lot of you useful furniture for a while so I'm assuming these are other things that were purchased because we had to with those funds to be able to do that um so I know this is a long-winded answer but we it's hard to figure out exactly if we have enough or too much we're

104setting aside on the on the um computer and and uh Furniture part and technology and Furniture part I believe that the number for the the 100,000 a year for the the athletic field part was to get us to a million in 10 years essentially which would obviously be 100,000 a year um so that one's a little bit easier but naturally we haven't dipped into that one at all because of that but I would also mention that we did not as you can see for 2425 the current budget year we did not make those right um uh contributions so we made one contribution that was 75 to Which F 14 fund 14 correct so we didn't do the three that we're discussing tonight the the repairs that because there has been repairs done to the turf

105and to the track where did that those repairs come out my routine maintenance yeah out of that money that money they did come out of that money okay so I guess for me why I wanted to see this and and I feel like when it first when that resolution came to us the idea is great we had all this money sitting there but there was and this is just me personally I felt like there was not a this is why we're deciding this much money a ton of oversight with it right it was like it was just being it was kind of told to us this is what how much money we're going to need in 10 years for the track to be replaced I didn't see that in writing of I never never saw

106what the lifespan is of the track how much it'll it would cost I don't see I didn't see where this these numbers were generated from and that's why I want to see this and we it was presented to the board though not not when I was on the board not the track when we made the decision to move $100,000 a year into it that was presented to the board it was told to us that that's what the cost was going to be when we when we made the decision to get the track and field that was one of the question I wasn't on the board then so that's what I'm saying is I never saw it was just told to us say it was I was on the board then and that was presented to

107us and told to us that that would be the cost in that amount of time to replace it so when we made the decision to purchase it that was what was told to the current board at the time and we are currently working with Aaron and his group to figure out approximate cost of replacement because we know every year that goes by it changes right so we're trying to figure that amount out well and how can we stretch the dollar with the track and field like what I I guess there's more it's more intui on that one in particular like what deems It lifetime is up well well the the the field itself let's say has has what like a warranty Lifetime right and they have a predicted lifetime whether it's 10 years or 12

108years I don't know um and it could last 20 right but it's you you go by kind of what industry has shown how long it will last right um and so but I also don't know that a million's close yeah I think it's probably at least 50% more than that they not checy the 3100 so I think for me the correlation is is that what we all need is more flexibility with what our funds look like and where they go from what I'm hearing and I feel like whenever we State The District budget shall have a 10% Reserve I think that really ties our hands and I do think that it would be great to have it as a goal but the sh really restricts us on top of the fact that we're not even

109going to in the next 3 to four years it's going to be enough to try and meet the 3% Reserve that we're literally breaking our own board policy and so it would be great to have it as an aspiration but the likelihood of that happening I feel like we need to change the language and I would say that right now we approve you remember back in June we approved the budget and we told you that when you're we when you approve the budget is not going to have the 10% so we made that decision knowing full well that was not at 10% and we are not at 10% um and so um I mean it ties our hands with deferred maintenance it ties our hands with salaries it ties our hands with all of these

110different things when we have that high of our reserve and we've seen how it kind of comes back to not really work out well in certain situations so I would even argue that maybe we need to be thinking about is that 10% really feasible for the vision we have for the district well how did the board come up with 10% in the first place it was before me so I think Jackie I will say Having excess funds got us through Co without having to take loans out where many other districts did um but then a lot of onetime money came in and then a lot of spending happened so what's the next step if you're proposing we change the verbage I like the idea of changing the verbage to having it as a goal but

111not a standard a yeah so it just proced but I don't know how to word that procedurally um all you need to do is it does not take two meetings to do that because the board the policy already exists it takes two meetings to create a board policy it just only takes one meaning to uh amend a current board policy um I'm I'm not suggesting we do that now um because I think it's one of those things I think we need to kind of think about and think about what is our goal um do we want to change that um I would just say in my experience I I've I've only seen been Limited in my districts obviously but I've only it to where it says that it would that it has it strives has

112a goal of 10% um clearly we've this last year we did approve a budget without it so we we did make the decision but it does feel a little weird to have a board policy that we're not fall well on top of that too I think that unfortunately what's gotten all of these districts in trouble is the shortsightedness and the onetime dollar spending and not having sustainable practices and I think that what ever we're talking about a 10% what I would love to see and Christa this is obviously up your alley is looking at what does a 7% Reserve look like what does you know what I mean some different options to see will still have a good buffer because I know that's what all of us would love just in case heaven forbid like

113another Co but at the same time is 10% really absolutely necessary and I get that we're changing the verbage so that all but it it just I don't know I I was just kind of thinking of of that as well planning for a future retaining our programs we want to grow the facilities we want to up like update and not feel like oh no we're not trying to hit that 10% and then us walking back on that is not what I would one thing that I would add though is the 10% barely I don't even know if it does cover one month's worth of expenses for our district okay so it so think about it that way right now remember the state of California for our size District says we're only mandated to have a

1143% Reserve that's the man that's the the minimum we have to have right that's we've had that discussion about you know whether you're positive or negative and things like that right um whether they'll your um budget will be approved um so but just I think it Bears mentioning that we do have at least 10% a month on expenses you know water yeah we saw the water bill you know our payroll and everything like that too so keep that in mind as well um um I I the reason from what I recall be the 10% came to was because prior to me being on the board we had State coming in and we were going to be taken over by the state because we were in such bad financial times so once the board was able

115to digs out of that hole it was a goal for us to not get back there and we were able to budget and come out of those lean times and still make sure that we were able to pay our bills if a catastrophic event happened because teachers and staff are not going to be happy if we can't pay their payroll so we wanted to make sure that we were able to do that and that was why it was very important because we did live through those difficult times and I know that at those times like even teach staff took Cuts so there was a lot of things during that time where you know I don't want us to go back there so that's why it was really important for us to have that and I

116feel like we were on track and when these Co dollars came in it kind of threw us as off the route that we were going of being a able to maintain that budget and maintain that proper reserve and now we're we're having to get the the you know get back to where we were and we're figuring it out with that budget and I feel like there's always good times and there's always bad times and unfortunately we're going through one of those rough bad times um so I don't I don't think it's just like anyone's fault or you know like that we don't know how to do a budget because school budget funding is totally different than someone's personal home funding because the way that it is funded and you have to look at it 3

117years out and you're having to guess when you don't actually know what you're getting spending all the money before you even get it or know what you're getting let's hope not but but but remember art board policy have should be looked at right to reflect what the current board does yes right and so we have to you know because these are your rules essentially right these are your contract that you're saying with with the community basically right and with the state so if if you if if at one time the the board or the majority of the board felt like we needed to have that sh then they did it right and so um and I don't think it's a bad thing I just said that it is it we just look at stuff constantly

118because of the turnover so is the current board happy with how the language is and if they are great and if they aren't then we can then you have the ability to change it right and so keep that in mind that it that it's your that even though these were created before you got here that these are supposed to be reflective of how the board feels right and that can and flow and that can change throughout throughout the years right so um I don't think of it as a bad thing I just think in this in this case just my opinion is is the sh to me is if let's say we're close right to the 10% and that requires us to get rid of a program because we have to do that then it

119doesn't really give you guys a lot of Wiggle options wiggle rooms because of your own policy right and so um I think that's just my own personal opinion um but I'm also not a board member um and I haven't gone through in my experience I haven't gone through any possible stake takeovers either but um but remember just keep in mind that this is supposed to be reflective of of people that are currently sitting on the board right that are making the decisions I would like to change the language so it gives us the wiggle room I mean I like strive said that we would have to I like the concept that I I think I see the intention behind the 10% was we don't want the teachers and administration to go without pay for their

120services and we also need a reserve um so I can see the logic behind that um decision I could also see the need for maybe supplementing strive uh at this time um to help meet other needs we have um and to unlimit the limits that are presently on that verbage trusty gaman how are you feeling I'm just pondering um whether we change the language or not we're not going to hit 10% so I mean let me rephrase it's not feasible right now so I'm indifferent at the moment I would say it's not not feasible it can be feasible we just have to make the budget yes so that it correct it is reflects it yeah we would have to cut a lot deeper on um and my suggestion also would be feel like I have

121a lot of suggestions but my suggestion would be is is let's get an you don't have to decide now but let's get an idea and then that way I can kind of take it back to legal to find out what you know what kind of better language might be um then we can come back and we can approve it if we so choose or not so I'd like you to do that um because I don't think this is something we need to just talk about right now and then change I agree like U um double is saying is that we're already not doing it right so it doesn't change anything per se right now um so can we but we're going against our policy can we put that on does the does the majority of

122the board want to kind of me to look into that language and to maybe like I said St goal of or how that's going to be yes I want to know how much more we would have to cut to get the the 10% okay and I guess I'm just going to play Devil's Advocate if you say strive or instead of shall or may what what um how are we going to actually hold ourselves accountable to that because you could put that in there but then okay well we're just going to maintain the 3% because that's what we are legally o at to that's just a strive or may may are not actually going to hold you accountable how do how do we hold my response to that would be is that we don't approve the

123budget you guys approve the budget right so if you guys wanted a certain thing we have to have a budget that represents your wishes right so the reason and this is going to sound weird picking on on things but it's not but you ultimately have to say of what the budget's going to be right you give us direction we create the budget that you want and you have to have oversight on that budget to know what's in it right so if it wants and that's what I'm saying is the budget needs to reflect your wishes for the district whether it's 10% whether it's 15% whether it's 8% you're going to have to make that decision so whatever we're we we as staff is tasked with to bring to you has to match your goals you

124set for the budget well and and oversight so oversight needs to happen yeah I'm going to do a quick necessary and proper clause from our constitution I like the idea of strive because again it all reflects on the year it's year to year it's different board members Visions it's whatever superintendent you know it's all of us together and like we need that General language I think Jackie to be able to be flexible enough because what one person you know what one board thinks is super important may not be what the next board does and I think just having that flexibility and making sure that we're all that checkpoint for what the budget looks like will kind of naturally build itself into it even if we have the word strive I I think that by having

125a board policy in general with the 10% memorializes the importance of having a 10% Reserve but by changing the words the verbage by striving yes we're going to try to do that every year but like this year we can't we're not even there and right now I don't like that we're not following our own board policies because if we're not following the board policy we have it to me signifies to the public well they're not going to follow what's it what's going to stop them from like doing a different going against a different board policy to where we're in this situation where we can't we cannot meet 10% like there's just it would be significantly harmful and disruptive to the students in our district if we were to cut things to make the 10% yeah

126so that's why I there's a board policy 10% every it's here that's what our goal is but it I would like to reflect I I have to break in though I'm with Jackie a little bit I mean what complacency happens so there should be some kind of verbiage like in years of trying budgets or something to that effect so people don't get complacent and think we could just manipulate this cuz I think actually you could even manipulate those words you would have to make them very much Ironclad because again it all comes down all of this is subjective and it all changes with who is in these five seats you know what I mean and and I think that that just has to be something that somehow the board then holds themselves accountable I mean

127I I can't all of it is subjective language every single thing and what we know right now for fact is that without having to do some really devastating Cuts we're not going to be able to follow our own policy and I think that is what is the black and white here you know what I mean I would argue morea we're already doing oh well yes no I'm sorry I don't mean to say that it's not already but I mean we have to go even deeper and it's already hard enough to be able to do you know what's being discussed so I would also add um when we set this strive or this goal um each each time we have well I'm going to use my OT brain each goal you Rite you have to have

128some type of intervention and some type of plan and so to keep us accountable to keep everyone accountable we have to have processes or tasks to meet those intervention to get to get to that goal goal so I'm hoping that we I know we won't get complacent and we'll work on budgeting we'll work on different strategies to reach that 10% of Reserve but it doesn't put handcuffs on us that we must exactly hit that and so I mean that's how I would look at it for this year and hopefully in future years we're able to get back to that or get closer and closer each year I don't know that's how my brain works I think there are and I think Christa can all of the different Financial reports we do throughout the year and

129I think um are we are planning to keep what was today's called resource okay real with resources things like that on and I think that's a good way that we can if that's a standing item and you might have to get more creative with all of the new names but that's a something on our agenda that's a standing item to where we're making sure we are touching on it where we are learning all of the things but also it's an opportunity for Christa to tell us you guys are screwing everything up or you need to make some changes more often throughout from someone whose job it is to do that yeah so are we proposing that we change the board policy as well as what we're putting into the funds or we just looking at

130board policy right now I think it's two separate things really I think right now it's just the board policy from what I'm hearing I don't know that we have enough information yet the other two think we do um or on the other three I guess it would be um and then this is an update for fund 17 and fund which no but I'm saying and then fund 14 is the other one for the maintenance right the maintenance I think what we'll do is we'll continually update you on those especially the fun when we spent money out of it and things like that as well so and 17 is the track and no 14 is the track and four 1 17 is Furniture um technology correct okay so my question on how to read this so

131the Top Line there says interest right and then the next one is the amount of Revenue that we've been putting in there right couple holes right and then oh this is broken down between then the next one is expenses straight across for the year and then that's broken down by the site and that's when it's broken down by the site it's a combination of the two yes okay there no oh just Furniture I see that oh okay sorry yes yes only Furniture yes I'm going to throw another question here um for furniture how do we determine like what site gets what percentage like it's a good question I don't know how that's been determined cuzz I mean I know through school like um School site councils and whatnot that they're able to obviously evaluate their

132needs and then therefore obviously appeal to the district as it fits their l cap or sorry their sipsa goals um and whatnot and and then teacher motions and stuff like that um to be up for sure I think the way it was done in the past is each grade level got one classroom and they were kind of like the tester of that and so then some grades if I remember and then some grades were like oh I don't like this one and then the different grade level might switch with some of them um it would just from what I remember how we originally did it it would just be great to see a little bit more Equity whenever it comes to the different School sites because I mean we've got there was one grade per

133yeah so it was like one Kinder one first grade one second grade one third fourth fifth sixth and up yeah but if you think about it for example on our technology I mean just for new Chromebooks every year it's like 40 something th000 so that already takes care of most of the 50,000 we put away for that right so there's some that we're going to have to adjust um but you know because that only about eight 5 to 8,000 left over for anything else besides after the UHS when it comes to technology can we ever revisit the whole one to one one policy you can revisit whatever you guys want okay yeah control they're they're obsolete after a few years and it just seems very unsustainable to sit there and keep on forking out money

134for Chromebooks our entire is our entire District on a one to one still not the entire District No I think you guys just have so what school is oh well Jefferson isn't I as well right but and those none of our technology mov student okay you're so it's middle and then High School Washington fifth and sixth grade have carts in their faster seventh and eth grade students have their so like high school for seventh and eth and then High School's got everybody's got a Chromebook yeah okay but I would say that the Chromebooks do follow the students when they get it in s through 8th 7th through high school yes it does get turned in and gets re uh like fixed or whatever over the summer then it it goes back to the students we

135haven't been but yeah in the past they have yes correct but at the end of their High School career we they're generally not worth a thing I think last year was the first year yeah I mean we generally just offer to sell it to them because there's really nothing it's not worth anything to re we keep a couple to recycle for looners but it's by that time they're already four to five years maybe even six years in so they're only designed to last maybe three three years at most so yeah okay I was just curious that's all so if I could wrap up here not wrap up at least figure it out um so what we're asking to do is maybe work with legal to maybe look at some different language that's in there um

136uh to what um Mr gaman said was talk about striving for 10% maybe goals stated in there too maybe have some uh and then some ability to be able to hold accountable some language things there as well so um is that what I'm hearing and then we'll just keep tallying um and trying to drill down a little bit more on the the other expenses and things and I'll try to get replacement costs and and that sort of stuff to be able I mean obviously it would be approximate but well at least have a better idea so part of the questioning last meeting was how are we evaluating depreciation so that way we can make more educated decisions on how the money is should be yeah well obviously like technology depreciates well that's the easy one

137I'm talking about furniture goes and stuff yeah it's a good idea yeah and then is there I don't know anything about the track and field but is there some sort of like can someone go and evaluate the track and field and say hey you're actually doing a lot better than we thought yeah at this point we've had the turf for what almost five five years now I don't know anyone remember four at least four four I would say and is there a way or something that some someone can say well you're doing better than or you're not not looking like you're on track on the track like I don't know probably yes I would assume once we start getting some um approximations people will come out and look and see what kind of state we've

138got that's what I'm hoping to get V pel that that's a service that we could okay so do I have a motion well we're not not there's no oh that's right Sor it always throws me whenever it's like are you part of the same meeting yes I am it's been a long time okay okay so you have your direction okay so on to Future agenda items you won High School graduation requirements is there anything else that anyone would like to addal yes okay so future board meeting dates February 20th our special board meeting at 4:30 p.m. March 12th regular board meeting at 6 April 9th regular board meeting at 6 and then May 14th regular board meting at 600 p.m. I move to adjourn the agend the meeting at 8:03 p.m. okay trusty Lopez white

139makes a motion do I have a second a second okay trusty oian preferential is absent all those in favor I I any opposed okay thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.