001look e e e okay um so now we're going to correct administer the oath of office to our new well three trustees we need each of you to grab your microphone and stand up for me please and we can either do this all together or we could do it individually because you have to repeat after me together okay good all right so you I'm going to say a little line and then you guys are going to say it after me okay I state your name do solemnly swear I swear Solly swear this is not going very good that's okay our names are that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California and
002the constition of the State of California against all enemies foreign and domestic against all enemies foreign and domestic that I will bear true faith I will bear true fath true faith and allegiance to to Al to the California the Constitution of the United States the Califoria constitution of the unit United States and the constitution of the State of California and the constitution of the State of California that I take this obligation freely take this obligation freely without any mental reservations without any mental reservations or purpose of evasion purp evion and that I will well and Faithfully that I will well and Faithfully discharge the duties upon which I'm about to enter discharge the duties upon which I'm about to ENT congratulations welcome aboard yes welcome thank you so we'll have some uh stuff as soon
003as we get done here we'll have you sign some stuff because we got to send it to the uh elections office all right okay does anybody want to say anything to their to the uh the crowd and the constituents here hi okay then are we going to move on to public comments on close session items so at this time any person may address the board on any Clos session item or any item not listed on the agenda pursuant to the brown act the board cannot consider issues or take action on requests during this comment period time is limited to 3 minutes per person per item 20 minutes per topic so do we have any comments on any closed oh okay do I need to okay yes I just want to say welcome I'm so nice
004to have fresh faces and the old board but it's nice to have you guys here and I look forward to a very good prosperous year I know we're going to go through some hurdles but look past that I know Betha screwed up a lot of things and so did some other people but look past that and just focus on our kids and our community that's it I'm so happy to see all of you here every one of you thank you all I got to fly I got to go deliver gifts thank you and you okay any other comments She's Come okay so our well um our close session AG or agenda items are D1 Public Employee um performance evaluation superintendent D2 Public Employee appointment the board will meet regarding the salary or compensation paid in
005the form of French benefits for the position of superintendent an unrepresented employee D3 Public Employee appointment the board will meet in close session to discuss an addendum to an employment um contract with a superintendent D4 conference with labor negotiators and at this time we will move into close session at 4:34 e e e to reconvene to open session at 6: p.m. there is no reportable action from closed session so next will be Pledge of Allegiance oh correct oh okay oopsies sorry I'm learning IED Al to the of the United States of America and to the Republic for which stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all okay approval of agenda order um the board reserves the right to change the order in which agenda items are discussed and or acted upon
006upon at this meeting subject to further action by the board the agenda for this meeting is to be approved as presented items may be added to this agenda for discussion or action only as permitted by the brown act move to approve the agenda okay I have a motion from trusty Garrison I'll second okay I have a second from trusty Lopez white uh preferential is oh preferential I thank you all those in favor I I nay and no one is absent okay so public comment on consent and non-agenda items the public May address the board on any consent or non-agenda item pursuant to the brown act during this period the board cannot consider issues or take action on any item listed on the agenda time is limited to 3 minutes per person per item 20 minutes
007per topic so do we have any public comment okay and then moving on to close session reportable action accidentally went out of order there is no reportable action from closed session okay now on to board organizational items J1 consideration and possible action to select a board president you can take nominations oh okay I know nominate Jenny candio or trustee Jenny candio or to be our president she was a clerk last time last term or year so following the order oh I'll second this is someone sorry okay so I have a motion from trusty Garrison to nominate me as president and then I have a second from trusty Lopez white I mean do you want to do it oh no I'd love to I'm excited sorry it's like a mix of nerves okay you got it
008and just kind of like running through stuff but I'll become more comfortable I promise um no absolutely I accept okay so then we'll open it so all those in FA oh sorry differential you got it hi okay thank you Hana um all those in favor I I okay any Nays okay and everybody is well thank you guys I'm looking forward to it okay now on to consideration of possible action to select a board clerk oh okay so the board clerk essentially is there to help and kind of work with the president um not taking kind of facilitation if I or if the president um may be absent and whatnot and so that's kind of rightest do the test anything any actions yes okay so do we have any nominations for clerk I don't one okay
009I would like to actually nominate uh trusty Lopez white sure do I have a second I'll second that okay so second and by and I'm going to get this it's zeitz yes yeah okay trusty zeit seconds uh preferential I all those in favor I any Nays nope and nobody's absent okay now consideration and possible action to appoint the superintendent as secretary to the board I moveed to appoint the secretary to the the superintendent to be secretary to the board okay I have a motion from truste um Garrison I'll second the motion okay a second from trusty Lopez white preferential I all those in favor I I I any n okay and no absences well there you go now j4 consideration and possible action to select a voting representative and Alternate for vacancies on the Sonoma
010County committee on School District organization can we explain that in the terms that I can we explain can you yeah I can't at this moment for some reason it's completely lost on me so um Sonoma County has to have a committee on school district reorganization and um so what you're doing is basically you would be nominating um one person plus an alternate in case there's a vacancy on there so that they need to be able to convene and somebody can't make it somebody can be on there from our district as well I don't well I shouldn't say in my tenure but um I've rarely seen it happened to where somebody gets appointed to it nor there's a panel that sticks with the panel that's there I want to in the past we always just designate
011the president correct yeah I believe so I was just going to say that yes so is that your motion yeah I'll make a motion the clerk is essentially what because it's the same thing okay I'll make a motion well would I is it okay if I motion myself too okay yes I will make a motion to select the board president and board clerk as the alternative for vacancies ONN count committee okay I have a motion from trusty Lopez white for the president and clerk to be those positions do I have a second I'll second it okay trusty Zs preferential I all those in favor I I I any Nays okay perf or okay so J5 discussion and appointment to District committees so the I just handed you a piece of paper that has the eight
012different committees that we have for the uh the board and we generally have like a some of them have we have two people go to the meetings and then sometimes we have just a um person that goes in an alternate I believe that the boosters has just a person that goes in an alternate is that right correct and then I think care is the same way right and SAR and SAR care and SAR okay and then the rest of would be on there so um anyway every year we come up with these some of them you'll see are already set in dates some of them have not been set on dates so um we tried to get as best we could about where they are and approximate times uh that we could and then some
013of them is my mic on some of them are during the day mhm correct where like I know Jenny yeah teaches there are certain things I just yeah right do those so measure a doesn't have a Time on there we've we've toyed with having it a little bit later on uh in the day and so we're still up in the air on that kind of depends on who's on it that's why we put that one too also because if somebody wanted to be on that and and the person couldn't make it during the day we could always put it at 4:00 let's say um and then the sard meetings are pretty locked in as far as that um and then the school subcommittee they just moved now to twice a year and they're going at
01410: a.m. because um it due to employees and staff that need to be there is why that one is so um and that one is also in person uh for that part um the Career Tech Ed ones generally do it in the evening also I just that they haven't been set yet do so delocks usually in the evening after school yeah oh yeah dck I'm sorry I thought about El generally after school also yeah and what is deac deac is the district um English language oh go ahead it's the uh the the district English language can I always forget the a advisory committee um that we have but each School site has an elac committee and then the dlac is kind of a culmination or bring um of all those together so that's where the
015district as part we usually have them here in the library and I'll just say my first six years I was on daac and I attended all the elocks and the dlac because we did not know that I only had to attend the D we can't you can yes um and then the SAR board SAR one is the school attendant review board um meetings that are there uh the lcap is the local control um accountability accountability plan okay accountability plan and then the uh school subcommittee is basically just us making sure that we're working together on those things um CTE is a cot technical Ed um which involves you know um a as well as um Woodshop and those um and then the Care Foundation is our um Foundation that's off basically from the community and
016then the eagal pride boosters is uh the booster club and then the measure H is basically a meeting to be able to talk about um the different projects that are going on with the measuring fed by me the bond funds yes so we're looking for a representative so yeah so I mean we just kind of talk about who would like to do what um there's really no um I mean if my suggestion would be is if you have a a committee you'd like to be on that you show a lot of interest in um then maybe mention that um but other than that I I the idea would be really is in your four years if you were to be here you should be able to be on most within your four years right um
017so that way you can kind of get a breadth of what um we kind of do with the district as well um but if there are certain ones that are or for example in Jackie's case she might have been on other ones and might want to do something different than she's been on before so there's really no rhyme reason for it well I know one of the ones that I would love to be on that I haven't yet is the boosters just because obviously I can't do I can't do during the actual morning hours so I would really like to be on that one if that's all right with everybody yeah what's um I guess we kind of know each other's availability what are your guys's availability I could take all mornings I I make
018my own schedule so yay Jackie and I have kind of rotated those cuz we've been pretty available these are ones I'm interested in as well so and Trust You gaman H H um with that said we're able to we have to do this side right now today is it so yeah this is what we were you know what I can make my uh I'll defer to everyone else then I will take the others because I have ability to move my schedule and I would also say that that if if we do set it t and then there is you find that that day doesn't work they can always change committees it's just it's nice to have them now and then that we can reset also we have the alternate like cuz one year Jackie was
019the on the sarb committee and I was the alternate and there was one meeting that she couldn't make and then I went to it so like that's how that works I mean so were you thinking taking a s i could I mean I really enjoyed being on SAR and I just did it and I liked it it's right a great team I'll take measure H SAR sub school subcommittee and Care Foundation that's a lot well let's write them all down and then we can like say no to that please do challenges so measure H Chad yes and then sarb school and City okay I'm just making sure I'm all that down so again measure H would have two that would go yes um daac should have two that would go sarb's just the one in
020an alternate lcap would be two that go so school sub commit two that go uh CTE yeah but one one one and an alternate care would also be one and an alternate I believe and then the boosters would be one and an alternate and I I'll bow it down for CT as well well okay you know you're now on four right I know that's that's that's you sure already on four he's already on they're not weekly so yeah I could adjust the schedule accordingly I guess I'll do I'll join you in deac right yeah all right still need Hope Oh wait wait no so you're on five then cuz you said measure H S school and subcommittee and then CT and CTE no he said care he didn't say CTE yeah maybe that's a little
021overzealous there yeah you're going to be let's take CTE no CTE well and I'd actually like to do CTE and LC cap if that's all right with everybody okay and you put boosters yep so I could do booster LC cap and CTE so what is available for trusty oian so elac delac and then we need an alternate on the others yeah an alternate for the others you don't have me on anything yet or me I was being okay well I'll take off one of mine you can take the one ones I've I'm just thinking the ones I haven't done I have not done delock yet I have not done the l cap yet and I have not done Eagle the boosters or well ashle if you want to take my LC cap you're more than
022welcome to is there two on there are two on l cap aren't there okay so you and me I can do L I'll I'll go in on LC cap okay it's always nice when everybody's watching you guys too we just want to let you know that and then did you say dlck yes so okay so gaman gaman that one needs two though yep I can do dck also look this way okay uh oh do you want to be my ALT for boosters since you're you know like your hand or that's what I was going to ask the only thing I haven't done is school City subcommittee or CTE I've done all of the others so I can do whatever okay so we'll put you down for school City sure sub committee okay that's only one
023and then um CTE sure and that needs an alternate kind or is already on it there's two yeah and then we need a care alternate measure already on there yeah we need a second person for measure age I could do measure age unless you wanted to stay I don't I've been on that for a while I don't care it's totally oh okay so then we just need an alternate for care and an alternate for well no they have two for no car only oh it is now there's one and then an alternate I'll be the the SAR alternate okay so yeah an alternate for care and an alternate for uh boosters okay so um it's Jack and Jackie um where else needs another oh okay so do we want to put them on does care
024have an alternate care okay okay and then who yeah trust are you good with being the alternate for care and then what about do you want to alternate for boosters yes I have it written down you written down you want I just need to alternate for boosters you want to say it once you get done you want to be the alternate I could be the alternate for boosters okay let me just see cuz this might be a lot you want to pass that yeah for Cathleen keep on searching up the que we don't have it as action so you're just on it okay I'm appointing you secretary duties yeah exactly can we wait can we go over that real quick so I know I got it right well we'll send you we'll send everybody an
025email okay but right now it looks like on daac we have um gamian and Ashley and then we have measure h we have Chad and Jackie also on SAR is Chad and Jackie and then we have uh Jenny and Ashley on lcap subcommittee would be Chad and Jackie CTE would be Jenny and Jackie care would be um Chad and double O and then uh Eagle boosters would be Jenny and Ashley okay and we'll send an email out to everybody too let you guys know what's going on you can go on to j6 so j6 consideration not used to my microphone being on all the time consideration of adoption of regular board meeting calendar for 2025 page 12 of our packet yeah so um we we were recommending to change it to the second Wednesday um
026I believe there's also a um where we're currently at I think there's a seems to be a lot of meetings during that same time and I believe City Council meets that same day as well so we're looking to try to change that up a little bit to give a little bit more um spread out cuz um but it really is up to you guys too which just what we're required to do is to set a meeting calendar for the year um not that it can't be changed but you're not supposed to change it that way the the public knows that that to count on a certain meeting at a certain time each month um and you'll notice that a couple of them have um like in June it has two dates and the reason why
027is because the lcap and the budget can't be approved in the same meeting as the public hearing um but the rest of them just have those um as regular dates so that's just what we're proposing um on there and it would still be um six o'clock is what we're still talking about 6 o'clock on the second Tuesday instead of excuse me second Wednesday instead of the third Wednesday so June it's the 3 we have because we have to move it back a little bit because of the timing correct to get our budget stuff back yes from the count you know it behooves us to go a little farther down to create more time I'm fine I was going to say so you would the motion would approve the second Tuesday the second Wednesday or the
028count second Wednesday with the double uh date in June or you could say the calendar and then also start at 6: p.m. um for that part I will move to approve the adoption of the regular board meeting calendar for 2025 as the second Wednesday of every month um with June being the third Wednesday and Thursday okay I have a motion from trusty Lopez white did you say at 6 o'clock at 6 o'clock I did I'll second that okay trustees eits seconds preferential I all those in favor I any NS n okay so on to consent calendar uh the cusd Board of Trustees utilizes a consent calendar for items that require the approval of the board but are of routine nature they act upon these items in one vote any member May remove an item for
029additional questions board members receive their agendas and backup materials 7 days in advance of our meetings they have the opportunity to ask questions and to do research to our meeting it is their intent to handle the routine items expeditiously so they have time to address issues that are more serious so basically agenda items guys K1 um approval of minutes from November 20th budget updates agreement with Christy white certifi public accountants to conduct the district's annual audit through June or 30th 2027 document tracking Services LIC or licensing agreement for document uh creation and support Declaration of obsolete equip equipment and authorization to donate seller or dispose of and then we have our Personnel hiring so would anyone like to pull any of those items okay so motion to approve move to approve the consent calendar okay
030do I have a second I'll second okay so I have a motion from trustee Garrison and then a second from trustee Lopez white preferential I all those in favor I I I any nams okay so we can go on to um our association reports K3 California or uh CSEA Chapter 170 oh no yeah he's coming he's coming up good evening my name is Carlos men uh I'm the president for local chapter 170 CA and uh first of all just want to Welcome All to the new board members welcome um you guys are definitely arriving at an interesting time in our district with that said I look forward to working well with you guys with the school district and given that we're going into the holidays I know there's some rough and tough decisions to be
031made but I feel that you guys will be fair and wish you guys all a happy holidays that's it thank you guys thank you so much okay now on to Teachers Association of Cloverdale good evening Renee du Vander Teachers Association of Cloverdale president um I missed the meeting where I got to Express Tax gratitude to trustees Addison and Mendo Tores as for their service um but I would like to extend that um gratitude and we want to extend a Welcome to our newly elected trustees zitz and O gam okay we'll learn um and welcome back trusty trusty Lopez white um we greatly appreci appreciate and respect the commitment you've made to serve our community we look forward to collaborating with the entire board and the district as we work together to provide the best possible
032education for Cloverdale students it is this shared Vision that truly makes our district special yesterday we had the privilege of gathering for our annual holiday party and we want to thank everyone who attended it's always a joy to take the time to laugh and enjoy each other's company as a community a special Thanks goes to Geyserville Grill whose employees many of whom are our former students and current students and their families and they generously donated additional food to the Celebration which was appreciated um this gesture is a kind reminder of the incredible relationships that make Cloverdale such a remarkable place these connections are something we should celebrate and use to attract others to join our district ever as we all know it remains a challenge to recruit and retain teachers when our District's pay ranks
033in the bottom third of all districts in the county we hope we can come together to creatively address this issue and the others we face um Cloverdale deserves the very best Educators for our students and we believe that by working collaboratively we can make that happen thank you for your time and for all the you do for our schools thank Youk you okay now on to school reports L1 Jefferson Elementary School good evening um my report is as submitted however I did want to um we have a a late addition um tomorrow at 8:30 in our multi-purpose room we have our TK students um presenting their winter program and so I wanted to extend an invitation to any board member or anybody in our audience who would like to join it's from 8:30 to 9
034and it's really cute and they're um it's really fast though so you're more than welcome to come and that's it thank you thank you thank you okay now moving on to L2 Washington School report good evening uh welcome to new new board members um can't wait to kind of get to know you and see how all of this goes uh you have my report as submitted but I wanted to take a moment and point out that we have our um California League of middle schools outstanding teacher nominee here tonight sorry to put you on the spot but go ahead and stand this is Leanne Henry she teaches digital citizenship as the elective and social study um and just a fabulous teacher and we're going to go and have a big kind of celebratory night on
035Friday night and she gets to she gets to make a speech um and we're really excited to go and support her thank you thank you thank you I I actually have a question and it may come to every other it it's brought up in other places but the youth truth survey you mentioned um with the questions in that who who comes up with the questions that are in the youth troop is it like it's state it's it's actually a a non it's the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation that's where it originated okay and so these questions that's all across the United States okay so we can filter in some of our questions because it's just pretty we can filter in some of our questions but Washington did not we didn't add anything sometimes they ask
036you ahead of time hey do you have a focus that you want us to ask about we didn't and I don't know if anyone else did okay thank Youk you now moving on to Cloverdale high school and Je continuation High School good evening everyone you have my report is submitted uh to welcome the new board members I wanted to give a little gift to them and then I brought it up with my CTE department and they said it's a little awkward just to give two out of the five a gift so why don't we give it to all of them so you all have a cutting board there for you made by our construction class and you have a floral arrangement made by our new Floral Design classes so these are part of our CTE
037Pathways CTE is Career Technical education and so usually when you think of CT you think of like building a birdhouse you know a breakfast club style but there's a lot more to it there's just the in the different industry sectors and and uh last year we had two CTE Pathways this year we have six and so these are some of uh the things that are the cool the cool products that our students make from these classes so welcome thank I do have something for Mr Harper I forgot to bring Nicole so under je I just wanted to um publicly say that we had three high school three JH students graduate so that's um exciting um and I know they're doing um you mentioned their exhibitions this week um in the future I would love and
038when we first did it to we were able to attend their presentation so if that's something in the future that the board can attend I would love to attend that so if you could pass that on to to them um I don't want to overwhelm them I would want them to be like prepared that we're coming to to watch that so maybe in the future and then um I just wanted to also acknowledge I know we had multiple students reclassify but having 14 students at the high school the high school is the hardest to be able to get reclassified in so I just wanted to acknowledge the students that were able to do that that's huge so good job thank you uh we're quite proud of that uh I compiled data from every Comprehensive High
039School in Soma County and Cloverdale high school has the highest El progress rate in all of Sonoma County comprehensive high schools and so that's something we're going to look at at our PD day is is that data but yes we are very proud of that thank you very much and we can easily invite the board to come to exhibitions cuz uh the superintendent and administration is invited I attended two today and I'm attending a couple tomorrow so in the future we can totally do that great thank you sure thank thank you thank you okay now special education and Student Services report oh and I don't see Nicole she's she's been sick the last few days so so as submitted let me quote her as submitted okay now on to you I think she just didn't
040want to defend Forest anymore so why she got um mine's that submitted also okay so maintenance operations and transportation report G yeah you have yep okay so I submitted yes did okay so Hana um our students had their Thanksgiving break the last few weeks of November all of our sports teams have stayed very active having numerous tournaments and games throughout the past month uh for the 2024 Sonoma County Office of Education uh CHS presented its student Showcases of our CTE classes like um Floral construction farm and table artart Child Development development and animal anatomy and our school also had a fun door decorating competition within our advisory classes to bring some holiday spirit to the campus and currently the school is halfway is at the halfway point of finals week and with the stressful time
041for students ASB members created a motivational Post-it wall in our main hallway to encourage students through their testing and yeah with these last few days um students are pushing through preparing for winter break thank you so much Han okay now on to board reports now trusty o' gamian and trusty zeitz obviously we're going to unless you guys would like to share anything participated in anything anything that you'd like to share it's all good you guys can continue sharing cuz we just got here dit okay then trusty L way anything to report um I I did a attend a measure h meeting it was just um the superintendent and I and we have a new what would you say representative from vanel mhm they're here um back we met online nice to meet you in person
042um so that was we'll go over measure H new consultant there we go to our district um and we have measure H coming up on here so we can talk about it then and I also attended a sarb meeting um and like always the sarb team is great I think it's a great collaboration between everyone um it's very I would say it's uh it's about attendance and getting kids to come to school but it's a very supportive environment and trying to help the families get the kids to come to school and what they're what they're facing and trying to get them so I think Nicole's doing a great job and I as always I appreciate her work and um all of the admin that come to represent their school sites um I think everyone works
043together together very well to try to focus on the kids and what they need and um improve their attendance um other than that I'm just getting ready for the next four years thank you okay trusty Garrison uh for boosters um I just wanted to report that the eighth grade girls had won uh basket backto back basketball champs so congrats to them that's um really exciting um and then for the care board uh we met last night thank you uh Tac for the invitation but I had a prior engagement so I attended the care board um meeting and uh January is Board elections um there is the giving book tree at Delan Sage if anybody um wants to go pick a a book off the tree and they can purchase it and it goes to one
044of the um three libraries at the school district um and miss ferdin andson the Washington Middle School um principal she presented a request for the fifth grade music after school program um for funding and uh the board is going to meet to discuss um how they can help with the after school program and it would be for fifth graders um there's 57 instruments between flute clarinet trumpet and trombone um they had an assembly today about it and sent out permission slip so they'll find out by Friday how much interest there is so that was exciting as well thank you can I ask is that what Mr Collins is working on the fifth grade that's awesome okay and then if depending on um how much interest for your fifth grade it could possibly open up to
045to six right that' be awesome that's true that would be so awesome um well a couple of things for me number one I got to go to my very first Elementary um holiday Extravaganza for the first graders today at Jefferson it was adorable they did such a great job and I do not know how all of them remembered what about six or seven songs I was highly impressed um of course my kid's a ham in the back row so you could still see her um but that was really wonderful this morning to go to I appreciate that um started our governance series online last night um really great kind of overview of what the series is going to be about great learning opportunities which I'm looking forward to um and then also went to the
046championship game for the Sandy Mac basketball tournament um and i' had never actually gone to one of those before and so um it was great just to see everyone and Bernard is ridiculous but go them but everyone did such a great job and it was awesome to go and watch so I'll add and I I think St Bernard's has won twice two three times in a row they are a tough team in Clover did really good against them did so well they were it was fun to watch yeah a lot of fun so that is the extent of my report so on to superintendent report uh I don't have any report because you'll hear enough from me later okay sounds good okay so report discussion so we have um S1 measure H update yeah uh
047we don't have anything right now we got a few other things coming up okay that's what I thought and then utk so S2 utk Early Education facilities project update same a little later okay um South Clover or South Cloverdale property update so um we are in well I've been in the process of um going out there and walking around um I actually reported last time that there were no was no Active water on the on the uh property and that's incorrect there's actually a spring on the property um so that actually brings um potentially some fire mitigation cattle back into play potentially um so there is quite a bit of water on there actually so um I'm working on that um with uh Michael G to see what we can do to maybe do that
048um our fence surr around the property could use some serious help um so anyway we're we're trying to look at different ideas just again we're talking about in the summertime in Spring to the summer it's it's a fire hazard basically right so we're looking at try to mitigate some of the fire um stuff this is open discussion right to talk about sure yeah okay so now that we know that there's a spring out there and we have an a class in FFA can we we is that something we can look at and work at work with this newly found spring for me is pretty new like Sunday so yes my plan is to because it's been raining so my plan is to maybe take um Angelica out and stuff like that to see what's going
049on and see what we can possibly do yes and we realize Springs run out of water this one this one apparently is pretty much year round okay yeah okay yes so um in talking with some of the neighbors yes said it's a year round spring nice yeah that's a good sport like I said we got to do a little more research on it we'll see okay anything else guys and then again we have some other stuff coming up later on with easement and stuff like that too okay so then um as for mtss update so our plan is and we just talked about it yesterday and our um admin meeting is in January our plan is to give you guys little update on what's going on um with that where we've come to at this
050point okay and then do we want to if you just to cuz I know it's a lot for me if mtss like all these acronyms just stop as it took a lot a while to remember it all we're going to explain all of that next month well and I do have a question do we have any data that we're going like any metrics that we're looking at to see or is it just because obviously it's only been implemented for a semester then maybe by the end of the year we could we're going to talk about it the next month about what we've been doing working on to get there so for that part yes welome question I just noticed I didn't realize this before but in our packet we have but it's not on the
051agenda okay so since MTS starts with m we could probably see it's some music one too um so we are as we talked about before we are basically trying to uh initiate it with that fifth grade stuff that we're talking about see it's kind of our first step in to it to see how that goes what kind of Interest we get for that part and we'll be going forward with that okay any other questions okay so moving on to T1 consideration and acceptance of donations um I would like to recognize um there were various people that donated $1,140 to chale high school for sat fees Care Foundation donated $1,203 to Cloverdale high school for freshman binders and care also donated $1,184 40 to the Washington School library so thank you so much for those donations
052so can I have a motion to move to approve donations okay so I have a motion from trustee Garrison I'll second okay second from Tristy Lopez white preferential I all those in favor I I any nay okay so now T2 consideration and possible approval of the delivery method for the Jefferson utk Early Education facility project yeah so we have uh somebody here from Van Pelt that can um so there's a couple things at play here um we talked about last time that we have to be under contract for 90% of the project before the this the opsc which is the Office of Public School construction will release the funds um for us to be able to um we Le the funds for the project however um it's a little scary to think about signing a
05311.5 million project contract without the money right so it's a little bit of a double edged sort so um there are some ways for us to be able to hopefully not have as much at risk uh out there to be able to still get our um funding so Brian right Aaron no worries we're both B there's Bri and Aaron that are helping us so cool 50/50 chance I had no you're good help me with the pronunciation of your last name sinr sinr yes sin okay cool and so uh Aon is here to be able to kind of explain to you guys I know that the three of you at least the two of you have had some experience with the Le EB versus the straight bin so anyway go ahead cool definitely uh so like
054you said uh my name's Aaron uh brazer I'm project manager with vill construction uh uh along with us on our team we'll also be hanging out with uh Brian Cameron in the future senior program and project manager Van Pelt and then we'll also bring on jnet Johnson she'll be a project coordinator kind of handling a lot of the invoicing and pay apps and helping see through some of the loose ends on the construction projects uh as far as the lease lease back um and speaking to Glenn we know it's really important that we don't encumber too much funds uh the lease lease back on this project works out really well because it allows us to bring on that contractor um low at risk so we would only bring them on for a really small pre-construction
055fee or no fee at all um and then you don't actually encumber the cost until uh you would see the GMP to the board which is essentially the bid um what's really helpful about this um is we're able to one the project already has been DSA approved through the division state of Architects and we already have a Contractor on board for the modular so and a new construction project of this size I think it's important that you kind of bring on a contractor and kind of be able to work in a team a little bit more uh rather than hard bidding the project and bringing on the lowest bid um so I think it's a it's a good opportunity to bring on start the project um at a low cost and uh once we get
056that GMP to the board for the total bid then we be uh able to complete that 90% of the construction uh documents which would allow us to then be four to six weeks out from receiving the funding um so that's just kind of the last little hang up but we think it's best to to to go with the least polias back delivery method honestly whatever the board you know prefers for the delivery method we we could do it but um we do think that is the best option uh keeping cost low for now and uh allowing us to kind of work out any of the Kinks being we already have a Contractor on board for the other part of the project can you remind us who the contractor for JA construction and they've work with
057a lot of school districts oh yeah yeah they work on a ton of school districts um but it is important uh in this kind of unique circum stand where the one contractor is not doing the site work and the buildings uh doing the least lease back interviews I'm sure JL would actually come sit down for the interviews and potentially uh we could bring them on for the site work as well and bring it all under one contractor but if not for a project that has an extensive amount of site work and new Modular Buildings uh it's important that they kind of work as a team because there's so many moving Parts when it comes to the stucco and the concrete timing and the foundations and whatnot that we really need them to kind of be
058working on the same team so I think it's a kind of a win-win situation for that and for historically I think we did this the least lease back with the Washington gym the football the track and field the two story it's totally yeah no it does it works out really well um for both parties um and then yes I've I've worked on multiple leas lease backs as well uh right when this came right when we kind of came over and we seen kind of what was slated for uh the 2025 year uh we felt like this was probably be the the best delivery method to get that funding in but not uh incur too much cost while we uh work on the bid to submit to the board any questions any questions at all yeah
059um I guess what's our timeline for starting we have a yeah yeah definitely we know that I can speak to it as well whatever works best um we are through the the the DSA and well as the CDE so now the next thing we're working on is trying to figure out the the funding basically so well we have we know the funding we're figuring out when we're getting it right the timing of the funding and the amount and the total amount of the funding too it's kind of a double thing there um so we have to because we put in for a financial hardship which we're in a financial hardship so we don't have the cash to put out front right so we have to be we're dependent upon the state funding and um but
060we don't know the total cost of what the Project's going to be until we bid it right and so it's a little bit of a double-edged sword because you don't we can estimate it but we don't know the actual cost of what it's going to be um for that part and of course the longer you wait the more expensive things get as well um so but again like I said before is we can't have we can't they won't release the funds from the opsc unless we have unless we're under contract from for 90% of the jobs so that's what we're trying to be able to get to that point to be in contract but yet have the contract be predicated on us getting the funding does that make sense I think it's also important to
061note as well that within that lease leaseback contract document that we would put something in there that the contract is determinant on funding so we're not on the hook to bring them on to go through the interview process to put together the best team for the project uh and I've seen precon uh fees be as low as $ Z I've seen them you know be as high as 50 75,000 so it just really depends but when you do a best selection you're allowed to select the contractor that you want so whatever of those kind of uh preferences for the district we're able to kind of focus in on that and and cater to that when we bring on that contractor so sorry go ahead essentially the verbiage could be worked in contingent upon F oh
062yeah most definitely and then when you bring them on the pre-con fee is going to be so small um that in percentage compared to the construction cost it's it's going to be quite you know quite small that if it were to be delayed or or plans changed uh the pre-con would be be much smaller and still would be useful uh down the line if needed where are we in the timeline of having it completed like the whole entire project completed like we had you know the initial start from when we got the approval for the funding to then you know submitting and everything like are we still on track for that or are we behind or ahead of schedule or we are definitely behind our initial thought um because the CBE and the DSA took
063longer than we thought it would to get approval um and then now that's we had to wait for them to get approval before we could even go out to get bids to be able to get that and then the funding then once we were qualified for the funding and for them to release it it's for to six weeks by the time they say you had to release it before we receive those funds also so how far behind are we then so I would say probably I would guess probably two two months behind so original remember original thought was really was like a fast track to get there were we thinking that students would be in the classroom in January coming back from winter break or was it not no we were looking at at starting
064in the classrooms the end of in August of yeah and that's probably iy at this point okay and the reason why I say that is because we're coming into the rainy season 2 right so that's going to push us back on that part too and if I remember wasn't one of the stipulations and I could be misremembering this is that we have to have the project completed by a certain amount of time 3 years okay was a shorter timeline than that years but then they changed it to three years oh okay r on getting everything approved because the funding had to be it was based on the funding so us being back a little bit we're not it's not and by us rushing to get in for the funding was beneficial ended up being because
065now they're not funding those like were but we're already been funded okay so um that was beneficial but again we were originally we thought we had 24 months to get it done and then they changed that to 36 months because they knew there's no way that's going to happen and not just us but entire and then um there's been some other snaks that have happened as well for DSA and and through CDE is it three three years from groundbreak or from documents sign three years from when we we submitted off for funding the clock started ticking yeah okay any other questions I guess what's the repercussions if we don't have it completed in the we have Mone you can file a petition I think Jen said that we can file from King Consulting she said
066that we could file or petition so we're a year in now correct so then we have two more okay for so are we going to meet that I mean it's we should be able to I'm just worried about our original timeline getting in there before August but I think when we started doing this when we decided on that modular that was kind of faster than anything because pre okay y yep and I'm not on measure well I am on measure H now but I was going to say when we go to choose whoever theas the committee yeah then you know we always best price but also change orders oh because that can add to the cost and stuff so look at all of that that's one of the best best uh things about the least
067lease back agreement is that right when we get them on board we'll start our pre-con meetings uh we have a full set of drawings which is really nice we don't have to kind of wait on those which is kind of uh typical and then we're able to go through those drawings vet everything out uh work with the district if there's any last minute things that we need to get and then what they're going to do is submit a bid based on all that precon that we have so and you're kind of mentioning the timeline that's why we wanted to kind of come to a conclusion on the delivery method being that we kind of got to get on board before we see the funding come through so kind of based on us chatting with Brian
068and our VPS and everybody we felt like the least lease back was the best method for these circumstances okay thank you m so Doone like to make a motion I'll I'll make a motion to approve the delivery method for the Jefferson utk Early Education facility project do the leas E back okay I have a motion from trusty Lopez white do I have a second I will second okay a second from trusty Garrison preferential I all those in favor I I any Nays nay okay so interesting Okay Okay no Okay so on to public Hearing in the matter of the conveyance of an easement of real property for public utility purposes so we need to adjourn into um a public hearing okay so that people can make a comment on this if they they choose and
069then you'll close that and then we will then have the then the board will have a uh be able to have a debate or bring the item okay so we are moving into public hearing at 6:53 are there any public comments doing for like 3 minutes or we just wait if nobody's going to speak we're just cool we go I think there's no set amount of time okay well if no one's clearly making their way up to the podium then we are back in Open session at 6 right yep okay at 654 and then you can call the seven attemp T4 to um okay you can call that so then T4 so consideration and possible approval of resolution 2257 in the matter of the conveyance of an easement in real property for public utility purposes
070so um last time we left our meeting um remember this is a two meeting process right for the first meeting basically they um the board approved for us to be able to um post it in the paper that we were we were considering this easement um and basically the easement is for a guywire to be put up on a um on a PG pole um down on our South property which is the at the corner of um Kelly way or Kelly Road and um I don't know if it's Dutcher Creek or it's Cloverdale Boulevard there a lot of multi names in streets here um and um and so this meeting would be to make to actually approve the resolution to allow the guywire to be um an easement for the guywire to be there uh
071I will say that we um worked with um um Ashley and Preston and I met with the um the dry creek Rancheria and um we came up to a conclusion and got anou regarding um kind of an in kind um match for uh the easement um and that was to put a um a fire hydrant kind of on our side of Kelly Road to help us some of our fire mitigation and we reached agreement on that as per the um Direction the board gave us um so just know that when this gets signed then I will sign thatou as well because I didn't want to sign theou prior to the board approving the easement because it's predicated upon that happening um and so we have met uh legally all of our um requirements for the
072conveyance of an easement um for the board and I can answer any other questions and I know Kevin doble is here also from the uh as well as I'm sorry I forgot your name David um that here representing the tribe um as well so if you guys have any questions for that I'm getting to know this South property quite well just want nice piece of property if you ever get a chance the Kelly Road they put in is a beautiful Road gorgeous yeah um I think the last meeting we kind of knew where we stood and we were're just up to a vote after you guys came with the you guys did what we asked or what they asked and yep let both okay well would anyone like to make a motion then to approve
073T4 I'll move to approve uh item T4 okay so I have a move or I have a motion from tro white do I have a second I have a second okay so from trustees equit preferential I all those in favor I I any Nays okay now on to T5 consideration and possible approval thanks guys we appreciate it thank you yes thank you consideration and possible approval of resolution 2258 regarding accounting of developer fees for 2023 2024 fiscal year in 25 which is our Capital facilities fund okay um Senate bill um ab2926 authorizes school districts to Levy um the developer fee for any sort of development project to mitigate impact on school facilities as a requirement of that we need to um present an annual report of what we spent the money on how much we
074got in all of that um the rates right now are $5.7 per square foot for residential 8 4 cents for square foot for commercial and 25 cents per square foot for a Mini Storage are there any questions about the resolution is the 517 per square foot for residential is that like a average cuz wasn't there like um a difference between the type of Residential Properties or no it's just any residential any residential property anyone have any other questions and I would say that's just based on the study the king consultant did for us yeah to get to arrive at these numbers okay these aren't arbitrary it's a study that they do to and these are actually set by the state this is the highest that the district can got qualify for okay okay so would
075someone like to make a motion to approve T5 I'll move to approve T5 okay I have a motion from trusty Lopez white I will second okay second from trusty Garrison preferential I all those in favor I I any n okay now on to T6 consideration and possible approval of resolution 2259 to identify the amount of budget reductions needed in 2024 2025 for 2025 2026 and to require that budget reduction for 2025 2026 be included in the 2024 2025 first interim report could you say that again I know no no just checking so um you guys have a um a copy of my presentation um I thought 10 extra was was going to work but I didn't realize we were going to have so many people so if you guys could maybe share with each other
076a little bit soor I apologize I just I thought 10 was overkilled to be honest with you is okay and if you if you don't have one I have here on the lovely screen here too by the way so um put it right there there we go are we good to go yes does anyone need another one because I can share with do we have to be in a certain spot for them to see me or can I no I can move around okay good excellent think a little better when I'm out walking around I know that's not I get to say okay thank you like a coach and the pendal might have to be in my coach's box right nice work um so we've been meaning to do this for a while um the
077the kind of the a budget update basically um but we waited till this um month because we knew we had two new board members coming in and so it was just really it would be a good opportunity to be able to get you guys kind of up to speed um sorry to kind of blow this on you right at the first meeting you guys have but you know you get some gifts so maybe that helps a little bit um so also my plan is just so everybody knows my plan is to also have the same conversation um with all of our staff at each one of the sites in January um and so um really we're trying to um not trying to we want to make sure everybody understands kind of where we're at um
078financially uh to this point and kind of how we got here so I try to think of a funny title but the best I could come up with the title we get here so I know it's not super original but that's where we're at so do I I got to get my clicker it's my favorite part whenever I'm lecturing to do the clicker and the laser pointer I Mak an appropriate jokes okay so you're going to see that I have several different areas that we're going to talk about that I've labeled area um and so no one specific area is is responsible for our entire situation it's just kind of everything kind of has happened at once and so um if any questions do come up throughout please um ask them or uh because I
079think it's going to be difficult to kind of wait till the end and ask so I think that maybe it might be good maybe each slide to ask if I could just ask people if they have any questions um mainly for you guys too to ask questions um so I I really wanted to give we really wanted to give an idea of kind of where we're at right now financially in clado Unified School District so um for those of you that that know some of you may not is we have there's two different things in school districts that are called one's called attendance or average daily attendance which is Ada which is how we get funded how many kids are in the the seats on a given day right and throughout the year uh it's
080not by enrollment uh and enrollment is basically how many kids are signed up to go to school right um so that there's there's a discrepancy there A lot of times I mean ideally we would have our attendance would match our enrollment ideally right but that's just not reality and um so our attendance is B our enrollment is basically flat and that's the misnomer part is you think okay well if the attendance is flat why are we having an issue well I'll get into that in a second um so our attendance rates over the years and we're going to talk about them here have fluctuated Co did change the landscape quite a bit um and so you'll see that pre-co we were at a certain level and postco we're starting to come back and I would
081just say that I would credit all of our teachers and our staff really we've been hitting it really hard on getting parents and families to bring their kids to school um and and it's working our our tenance is definitely up this year and that's a way we can increase our income is by having more students come on a more daily basis um and so I want to emphasize that we've also been doing a lot of emphasis on mailers and parents Square to uh really communicate to uh to parents and to families to get their kids to school because we all know when they're in school they're going to learn a lot better they're going to learn because they're in school okay um so on our funded Ada um so we have and if we look
082back at 2021 and 22 um we've got our enrollment um was at a little over about 1312 um our Ada our Ada was uh about a 95% Ada which is really good um but if you'll notice here on our funded right our funded Ada was actually more than our enrollment you probably thinking well how can that be how can more kids show up than you have signed up to be there well it's because our funding has three different models right you can either do the current year that you're in or the previous year or you could also during covid you could use the average of the three previous years okay so what happened in this case was is we have an enrollment of 1312 but our Ada was only 1253 we were fun in 1320
083because the prior years was a lot higher in the Ada and during Co we were on on a hold harmless MH right exactly I was just going to mention that yes correct and so we were being able to be we were given the funding such that we didn't have to do the fluctuated because there was it was hard on whether we would allow kids to come back how much they would come back and so on intend right so what this is is this just shows you the different enrollments throughout the years and what the different Ada looks like as you can see it's dipped down a little bit but now we're coming back up again right which is good and then here's the amount that we were funded on so if you can see these
084here we still funded pretty high because we were able to use the three-year average right and then down here again we're having to use the current year so that's what we've got but if you notice we're actually losing Ada right and so we're down quite a bit so um the decrease in Ada funding was during Co was supplement was supplemented by onetime funds that the state were giving us right to kind of as actually said to hold us harmless essentially right because there were a lot of things we had to add because of Co right we had I'm sure well I wasn't here but in forun we had to add like taking temperatures we had to do all that stuff right so these were staff that we had to add um the L so if
085you can see that we and I forgot to change the numbers this should be at 3703 but just on the loss of 37 Ada is almost $500,000 that's just Ada right out the door because of the funding models the way they're kind of funding us has changed a little bit because of we were held a certain standard and now we have to go back to where we were before right so we're not able to capitalize in some of those other years we had previously right questions on that okay um fund allocation um with some of these onetime monies we had a lot of our Personnel costs were covered by those onetime monies um and as you know the the danger about onetime monies that the state of California likes to do is they like to
086say well you got this extra funny you can keep these extra people but it's hard to keep ongoing cost with one with onetime funds right so there's another so not only is the Ada part going down we're losing funds there we've also losing a lot of one-time funds that we've been getting year after year to be able to do that so that's kind of our second hit we've got to our revenues coming in as well okay um and again onetime monies were allowed for additional Personnel to be maintained through the last few years so that's just a different area of um cost or of lower um funding coming in as well yes ma'am I mean is it okay that I oh bring them the mic I would say to the podium actually why don't you
087ask me then I'll re reiterate the question no you have to to come for the a for but for people to see who's speaking yeah this will give you good practice for Friday we're being recorded yes oh come on sh the Stag can you give an example of some of these people what jobs they are one time fun thank you thank you um do you want to help me with that I do okay phone a friend so um this year for 20242 we have two funds left that are being used as onetime money for ongoing costs and those two funds are resource 6266 which is the educator Effectiveness grant money and 7435 which is the um L which is learning recovery emergency funds money and the positions that are being funded for those for instance
088are well let's see one of them is a science teacher currently at Jefferson um I mean at Washington I'm sorry I'm looking at you and thinking Washington and say Jefferson um they're they're regular classroom teachers and then the other chunk is out of um we have a lot of AIDS at Jefferson's school and they're being funded out of that onetime money great question remember were were tosas funded by onetime money or were those grants or in Prior years in Prior years yeah I okay I assume so I couldn't answer that off the top of my head I think they work I think so you probably better answer that than we would be yeah good question though thank you appreciate that took you a long time to get here to get the question but it's okay
089it's worth it so and again like I said before all I'm doing is we're just hitting at different areas that are causing this issue one of the other um things uh were areas that we were is we did have increased Personnel costs um we did have uh we did in 2223 we gave a 10% raise to staff and in 23 24 we did give an 8% increase to staff as well and that lists all the different staff it was not all the teachers it was not all classified management also got it classified management got it so it's not one group that got it the whole District got that um but that is an increase and that is an amount that is an going cost and these costs that are up here the 1.4 and the
0901 million that's just what it costs each year for that and that actually increases because of the step and column part right so just want to be clear on that um this I think is is worth mentioning ab200 is the public disclosure you have to do anytime you reach a collective bargaining agreement and this was done in uh 2022 um and it basically talks about the affordability because we have to whenever you have an agreement you have to prove um and the board has to take action to approve and affirm that you're in fact can afford what you're giving right um and so part of this what it says in here because I think it's important is it says that the enrollment is projected to be flat with the addition of 13 4-year-old TK students
091each year of the two subsequent years which did not materialize and if it says if the projected enrollments is not realized the district will have to identify increases to class size and reductions to program R Staffing we're here that's where we're at so we knew that going in and so unfortunately the realization of some of that that was predicated on didn't happen right so again please I'm not pointing any fingers or anything like that too I'm just trying to give us a state of where we're at okay um so another thing is uh we've talked about reserves quite a bit um the state has a reserve minimum of unrestricted funds of 3% for our district size we um and and the board has passed in in its in ago or and its previous times of
092wanting to have a 10% reserve for that which is a great idea to be able to have because we all know 3% um 10% gets us about one one month worth of expenses um and we always like to have more than maybe one month worth of expens expenses on hand but we're only required to have 3% by the state of California so by this slide what we want to do is to show you and the difference too and when I say unrestricted in here unrestricted means just that this is money that has no strings attached to it right which means you could spend it on whatever okay because then there's restricted dollars um for example that that have a a string attached to it right that can only be spent on certain things okay so
093we're talking about restricted dollars here and in 21 and 22 the reserve and the reserve for the 3% is based upon your expenses that the district has that's the number that they used the 3% of so that in 2122 the reserve the minimum requirement for the state was about $550,000 okay we also had which again the board wants to have a 10% Reserve which is 7% in addition to that 3% that we had about $1.3 million in that part and then we had another unassigned amount of that and so we had a total in our reserves of about $3 million that's a pretty healthy bottom line right then in 2223 the the um the minimum requirement Reserve went up because the expenses went up right so that's why that increased um we also still had
094the 7% um and then we had an unassign but you can see it decreased by about $1.2 million from our Reserve okay okay and all the areas that I talked about before and something I'm going to be coming up in a second contributed to those losing part right because if you have something that you're spending money on that you're anticipating more revenue for and it doesn't come in you got to dip into the purse a little bit right in order to pay for that right I have a question if the I didn't mean to say Pur I meant to say you know get in there but yes for 22 23 the 3% and the 7% the 3% is higher than the year before but the 7% is lower than the year before so this is
095mathing ain't mathing for me right now right um this is the required amount cuz it doesn't make the 10% that's correct it didn't make the 7% corre that's correct thank you thank you for that the last two I should be okay and comfortable with numbers being a math teacher to me for uh so yes so we were losing on that part already yes and then the difference would be the next year we had to dip in those reserves by almost 800,000 so as you can tell we've gone down significantly through our reserves only we're burning through those right and as you know anytime you're burning through just like we're burning through onetime monies which essentially this is right it's like our savings account once you burn through it it's not replenishing itself unless you're replenishing
096it right um and so anyway just again we're painting the picture of why we're here right um next thing is too for the causes for those decreases in those two years again this slide and this is a reason for that slide does that make sense um so the 1 Point 235 decrease is due to some of these things underneath here we've had some payouts um and I I don't want to air our Dirty Laundry again but these are some things again we're paintting a picture right of what's going on so it wasn't all the staff increases there were some other extracurricular activities we'll call them that happened that cost money right um and again no judgment I'm just reporting what what what's there and then the next one um again would be more of the
097increase stuff like that too and I don't have exact dates on the stuff but just trying to paint the picture of what's going on I just want to make it clear though we didn't pay out $1.2 million for what is listed correct correct it's kind yeah I just want to make that clear I don't want people to say like you paid out that much money no we did not that's no it this is like all that stuff correct well it's all this stuff oops all of this stuff combined into there and I don't have it broken down into what's what but we didn't want to go into that rabbit hole either so okay okay we also have another area of things that that this is going to be just um you know naturally R PG
098our electricity on natural gas and stuff have gone up through the years as well um our insurance has gone up um supplies paper all that stuff's all increased right fuel gasoline diesel maintenance of facilities costs and the list goes on so again there's no one sector to be to blame to this at all right I think that maybe there were some things that we might be able to bring up a little bit but it's it's a combination of things to get us here at this point um so why the resolution so those of you that were here last month um or two months ago I think it was two months ago two months ago this the uh Sonoma County Office of Ed which basically has kind of oversight over our budget said hey guys you
099don't make your 3% minimum that's a problem so they said you have to do some things some measures um that we want to see this year to be able to show that you are making those movements forward uh for us to be able to conditionally and approve and hopefully approve your budget knowing because we have a plan the first thing was was to identify um some of the stuff we did in November right to be able to do that to get us to the 3% and then the second thing is going to be is to have you guys approve and agree essentially to be able to cut about $1.4 million from our budget and the reason why is because currently we're using the 1.15 money uh expenses from onetime money and one time money will
100be gone and then we also have a structural deficit of about $230,000 on top of after the onetime monies are being exhausted and these are just rough estimates too but the second piece of what we're doing in the steps for the for us to be able to come a little more fiscally solvent is to be able to to cuz what the what the county office wants to see from us is a guarant guarantee is not the right word but a commitment on the board's part to understand the problem and to say that we're committed to making these cuts um approximately these cuts for us to be able to come and have a future because as you know when we approve uh the first interim what you're going to talk about in the second and the
101second interim of stuff is you have to not only make your expenses for this year but prove you're going to make them for two years plus after out right and I get that we want that the board's desire uh is to have a 10% um Reserve I just don't know if we're going to get there for a few years and so we uh when it comes to our interim report which is going to see next is we have we're using that 3% part to be able to get there knowing it's really low but that's what that's kind of the gauge that we're being able to use um so questions about that presentation part there and so this is kind of all wrapped into that same um resolution I don't have that resolution on me but
102oh thank you so basically the resolution that you have in front of you says that um it basically describes the same thing here where it says where um a cumulative amount of approximately 1.4 1,434 $450 is because of the um structural deficit plus the amount of money that we're using onetime funds that we're using for ongoing costs so that's where we get there and that's to get the minimum 3% so in a nutshell we have to cut 1.4 million from the budget roughly to meet the 3% if we don't do that for 2425 excuse me for 2526 2526 if we don't do that if we don't meet our 3% the next step is that the the county or state takes control of our budget correct well I don't know we go that far yet when
103does that I mean well basically what would happen is the Sonoma County office would not approve our budget okay and so if they don't approve our budget what's the next step we'd have to then go back to the drawing board correct did you don't approve your budget so you don't have a budget you got to go back and yeah yes so State takeover that's let's not even talk about that that's what always been talked about that's I I don't want you to think we're not no that state takeover would be as if we're sitting here not doing it not doing it we're saying hey we're going to give another 10% you know crazy stuff and so I'm not to say that doesn't happen it's it happens but we're to the point now where they're like
104hey meaning sco is saying you got to take these steps in order for us to even be comfortable with your budget at this point and so again they're looking for confirmation from the board and the commitment to understand number one it's a we have a problem on our hands and number two are you committed to being able to cut what we need to cut at a bare minimum of what we need to cut to make it sustainable and um and our job as a staff is to provide that information to you um and give you thoughts um and between now and the next couple months my job is to reach out and work with our staff and everything like that too to be able to to come up with Solutions potentially to bring to you
105guys that we feel like would help us meet that meet this but still maintain a really good program for what we've got right and I'm not going to say it's going to be easy so we we have to have this done by March then essentially if we have to do that well March is a piece I mean let's just call it what it is March is a piece of this because that's where our layoff Parts happen yes but remember March is only a notice piece right it's not a a full layoff piece but yes that's a piece of it there's no doubt do RS by um and if you notice if you've been paying it I shouldn't say that sounds kind of condescending but if if in the news you see we're not the only
106ones doing this folks we're just it's just every I mean I think San se's got to cut3 million I think uh and closing schools I think so close so so we we have a piece of it too we're like everybody else but so we're not it's not a unique Cloverdale thing right now we're all doing that and you can see that's what's there but it affects us and our community there's no doubt about it so we're going to try to do the best that we can uh to work together and that's what I'm talking about when um we've met to talk about I'm going to do this same talk with with all the schools and I want people to ask questions or everything like that too um and so just I think it's important that
107we get out ahead of it and we are transparent and we see what's going on and it's not going to be easy I'm just going to tell you it's not going to be easy um and unfortunately it's probably going to make us not as good educationally for a while until we can get a handle on this CU we're going to have to cut some programs probably that are really meaningful programs and um but we're going to try to do the best we can not to have that so may I interject here of course the 1.4 gets us through one year sko wants a threeyear budget review correct you they want a projection for them so 14.4 this coming year is going to push us out for the next three years meeting that 3% yes that's
108correct and then what we'll do is we'll continue to make decisions depending on what it looks like the um Financial Outlook and out years right like when the next June comes around they pass a new budget maybe we end up getting millions of dollars extra we didn't contemplate on but so that's something also as a state of right now that's what we're having to do to get to this year to meet the the the out years from what we know right now for those out years does that make sense so it sets us up for the for example right now um you're going to see her Christa talk about at the next um uh um item for um first interim report is right now we're trying to like for example there are there are different
109organizations that are projecting Cola for the next couple years and they're all over the place right so what we've done is we've kind of averaged what it is right but let's say that one one group says the next one's going to be 4% the other one's going to say it's going to be 2% we're going to put in like 3% MH just middle of the road right but that could change it could be 5% and then we do that so so it's a snapshot in time and so I know but and that's different than maybe the private sector would be but in the public sector we're always dependent upon what the state's going to do right and so we're always it's always a dart on the board that maybe the board's there maybe it's not
110right and so that M makes it difficult but good question Ashley sorry go ahead I was just going to say the governor's budget you'd left that off but that also has to do with us getting here what was it it was like 67 million billion under what they thought it was going to be MH this year when that came out so that it's kind of why all of the schools are feeling that also yeah they were expecting more but the main part why we're here though is is we've got a couple of cliffs right the one time monies are gone and then now that with the the we're we're realizing the loss of students right and again California's losing students statewide right so declining enrollment is a thing for everybody I shouldn't say everybody but
111majority of of of schools yes any other questions everybody else is afraid because I have to come up here to ask the question appreciate that well you're getting ready for Friday so that's good so uh so thiso or this what we're resolution the resolution it's just saying that we're going to commit to making yeah because you think about it from the from sko's point of view right it's easy to say it right but if you if you have action on it then that gives that gives also me to be able to say listen guys we talked about this in December right and you know so I think it shows the urgency level for for sko to be able to understand that and I think it it does show a commitment on your part now if
112things change and we don't have to do that great but as of right now to be able to go forward that's where we're at okay move to approve resolution 2259 to identify the budget of reductions needed in 2425 for 2526 to require the budget reductions for 2526 to be included in the 2425 first in report it's fun to say isn't it um okay so I have a motion by trusty Garrison do I have a second I second okay so trusty oan can I say one other thing I would just say that we got um Sarah lampenfeld who's the lady at sco that basically talked to us about our our budget issue is wanted to express our thanks to you guys to understanding you're taking this um seriously and you're making the the proper actions that
113you need to take uh to be able to do that so um it's not going unnoticed that we are um you know some districts are just kind of kicking the can down the road and we'll deal with that later so they appreciate the fact that you're taking it head on and you're understanding and appre and um voting to be able to make some cuts that you have to make and understand that you have to um commit to that thank you preferential I okay all those in favor I I any Nays okay so now on to t7 consideration of possible approval of the 2024 2025 first inter term report again okay here we go hello Okay so let's talk about first interim a little bit um I kind of put this together a little bit differently
114than what you have done seen before but I wanted to talk about a little bit about our unrestricted dollars and Glenn talked a little bit about the difference between restricted dollars and unrestricted dollar but I just want to reiterate it again we get restricted dollars like for special education or for the Career Technical education program or different things and those revenues are considered restricted and then the then the expenditures that go along with them are also considered restricted because we can only spend them on certain things we can't take the special ed money and just go you know to Tahiti or something like that it has to be you know spent only on special ed all right so we're going to talk a little bit about our unrestricted revenues because this is where we're really
115impacted with that 3% and making that Reserve so where do we get our revenues from so as you can see by the graft the local control funding formula is how we get our funding now and that went into place because Governor Jerry Brown couldn't understand three pages of the revenue limit calculations and so he had to sorry so he had to um develop the local control funding formula which which is now over 45 pages much easier than the three-page revenue limit calculations so the lcff state aid portion is for this district for 2425 is the 6, 95135 the other part of the local control funding formula is then the property tax and property taxes right now for this for this District are estimated by the county as being 10 million 83,84 so our total unrestricted
116revenue for this year is 16 , 92650 .99 that's for the local control funding formula in addition to that am I going too fast in addition to that we get $513 513 $ 53,6 129 in additional state aid and that is primarily unrestricted Lottery and then we also get what's called a mandated cost Grant and that's where the state mandates you to do something but they don't give you they only give you pennies on the dollar in order to do th those mandates and that's what that that that's what those are the two fundings that are in that money the other money that we get is the is local and that's $25,200 25 this is in unrestricted fund 01 our general fund funo one and fun okay so there idea would be is that the
117uh stuff that we take in for the developer fees has a specific purpose for it it can't be spent on other things it's got facility stuff specific report because the idea behind it is is if we're expanding right we might have to do some infrastructure improvements so you can't just say hey we're charging you because we're going to pay for a principal right I mean it's got they're specifically listed for what they're collecting it for right thank you and we have fun 13 for instance thank you I appreciate that okay so then then this next slide talks about enrollment average daily attendance and then funded average daily attendance and this kind of Builds on the slide that you saw earlier from Glenn um this to shows our enrollment in 2021 as 1312 the Ada that
118we actually earned was 12530 but the funded Ada was 13 2084 so I want you to look at the last year which is 2425 and right now our enrollment our enrollment count is done on the first Wednesday of of October every year and that's called our seabeds enrollment count and that number we're we get some funding based on how that number works that number is what we base our attendance on by a percentage and this year what we did was because our we had improved attendance particular particularly at Jefferson and Washington we estimated that the um percentage of attendance is going to be 93.5% and so far with Washington and Jefferson it's tracking right about there so we're on track at this point then um the funded Ada because we have had this financial cliff
119that we dropped off of we are going to be funded only on the Ada that we actually received this year and right now it's projected to be 1,223 2.52 82 that's P wait that's the number of stud like do we know the cost Associated per student we get approximately $14,000 per average daily attendance if that's for 100% right if they're there 100% of the time so your kids that have perfect attendance that's how much they earn for us for the for the year okay all right so then where does our money go and again I'm only talking about the unrestricted side of the of the pot right we're not talking about cafeteria or any of those other things our our unrestricted expenditures for 2425 right now are you can see that we have certificated at
1206.5 classified at 2.4 and benefits at 3.5 and I want to talk about benefits for just a second because benefits doesn't mean only Health and Welfare it also means um Cal sters which is the state teachers retirement system which is at 19.1% and it also means Cal pers which is currently at 20 which is um California public employees retirement system which is currently at an all-time high of 27.03% then you add on to that the 6.2 for um social security 1.45 for Medicare and then our workers comp rate of 2.33 and um unemployment insurances was 0.05% so all of those things add up to be the benefit costs and right now for our unrestricted budget salaries and benefits are running 90% of our budget so when we're talking about having to make cuts and things
12190% of our budget is people the other remaining part of that is supplies and operating expenses we also you can also see on there there is $115,000 on there for Capital outlay and that's because um Riley Dale was able to get a grant from the Farm Bureau for $115,000 for the um greenhouse and those things so that's what that is that's not a normal expenditure but it's considered donation so it's considered unrestricted but our operating expenses like Glenn talked about before on the previous slide that's pg& it's water it's sewer it's the it's picking up the trash it's those kinds of things that it's really hard to cut money out of those things so that's kind of where our expenses are at for unrestricted dollars any questions about that okay so components of ending fund
122balance so um Glen talked a little bit about our past ending fun fund balances and I'm going to talk for a minute about our current year and the two out years with the approval of your of the of the resolution to commit to cutting the 1.4 million we're able to make the 3% in 2526 but so let's take a look at these numbers for a minute our beginning fund balance in 240 5 is 1,616 75 the estimated ending fund balance is $ 8329 of that the 3% Reserve is $732,500 is um the board's commitment toward that 7% That's one of those things the committed funds were are by board action the assigned then are resources that are intended to be used for a specific purpose which unrestricted Lottery is so then we go look at
1232526 because of the commitment of the board the beginning fund balance is estimated to be $832,500 with an ending fund balance of 74478 of that your your unrestricted your reserve for economic uncertainties is 628 th000 your assigned which is what's left of your lottery is 2,946 and your committed is 36,18637 there's no Lottery money left we're only getting then what we would get for that year and the committed is 35,8 28 that's that that's the that's your entire ending fund balance when you say committed can are you saying the committed is the 7% or is it the committed funds like deferred maintenance track field replacement is that anywhere in here or is that because in the budget that was presented it does talk about that a little bit but I'm just on the on that
124is any of it on there so the uh the committed that's referred to here is the amount of money that's available toward the 7% so that is the the track and field all of that the's already in already in there there's already in it correct just this year we did not take that we only took out 7 75,000 and so this has the whole commitment in it from the resolution but what she's saying is and that's a good I'm glad you brought that up Jackie what she's saying is is that the committed part is that extra 7% that the board has the has committed to I don't know how many years ago that was four I guess I'm confused where where is the Deferred maintenance track and field technology and classroom furniture on here like
125is it in the reserve for economic uncertainty where is it where does it fall under on that it's not on this page not be separate a bud item it would it would be under your it's on your form 01 which is in your packet um for unrestricted okay all we're talking about here right now is the ending fund balance and we're showing you the amount so if you look at and correct me if I'm wrong Christa but if you look at the First Column when it goes from 1 million to $832,000 it's just that's the def spending amount right so the next two years we're defit spending very minimally right does that make sense yes so it's just showing you how we're cutting into our leftover balances but the 25 26 and 26 27 already
126has those expenses already taken out okay that and it's listed in here it says on page 20 wait not I don't know what page it's on page five I believe of the interim budget that you put in our packet yeah so this would be so we would be quite a bit less of the seven extra percent okay correct as of right now correct sorry Christ go ahead no that's okay thank you um okay so then what's next um some of the quick facts about the first interim budget it is it does have a positive certification um but that does include the 1.4 million reduction for 2526 and then there are also some significant risks to this budget this budget has extremely narrow margins right now there's a after first arum there's $4,790 left in the
127supply budget that's unrestricted that's not been encumbered yet that's not very much money when you're looking at a $22 million budget so when I say narrow margins I mean really narrow margins there's been a drop in enrollment of 20 students since the October census that's going to have an impact on our Ada and there we've also seen a slight decline in um in Ada particularly at the high school so we're kind of trying to monitor that too the next steps are going to be we're going to have P1 which is the um first reporting of all of the attendance it's due on January 8th so we'll be able to bring that to the board with where we are with that for attendance for the year for the our projection the governor's propos state budget will
128be released in January honor about January 15th and so we'll get an idea of the state of the of the the State of the State where they are where they think we're going to go um and we'll also get some ideas about where they think colas are going to be because colas have a big impact on where we are um and then the second interim will be coming to you during the March meeting so each interim session season basically which you're in the first interim now is the board has the ability or or you report it basically either you're positive which says you're going to meet your financial obligations again with the 3% minimum not the 10% minimum right and then for the current year and two years out um I will tell you this
129that that we are requesting that it be positive because we do make it but as Chris said it's a very thin making it but still we're making it um there are ramifications for qualified and then negative there are some severe ramifications and I know actually you brought it up before about takeover and stuff like that too not those severe but for example if you have a qualified or a negative you have to do a third inim report throughout the year so um we consider we could be uh by the second interim be qualified um we're going to work our taals off to not be um and I think that that um the staff has been doing a good job of of um helping with that you know it's it's a concerted effort and it's a
130collaborative effort um but we just want to be real and transparent in the fact that this is not and when she says a $4,000 unencumbered out of a 22 million budget I wouldn't even consider that to be razor thin I'd consider that to be ridiculously thin um so we're not out of the woods yet by and and I know here's what I'm worried about I'm worried about saying we're a positive um because that sounds like okay we're meeting all our obligations great which is true but the obligations are pretty minimal when it comes to that right because like I said it's about 10% for one month's expenses and we're only being required to show 3% right and we're barely making that 3% so I want you guys to understand that um but at the same
131time it is positive so we're asking it to be positive not because of smoking mirrors or anything like that it is truly to be positive but not positive in the sense of the 10% ENT that the board wants to have I just want that to be thrown out there um because I think again I don't want any the worst thing that can happen in times like this is when there's misunderstandings or some people thinks it's a certain way um and it's not so the idea is to really be as clear and concise as possible because a lot of stuff we're doing is not very so our job is to try to make it where people can understand that um and so it's important to ask questions but also we need to we need again we're
132talking about a positive interim here but at this point in time but again by thin pieces any other questions thank you for your slideshow it's easy to call thank you thank you apprciate it I I appreciate it um and it the transparency um what is concerning to me the $ 1.4 million just gets us at the 3% but again on page five under summary um at the June adoption for the 2425 I'm just going to read this for btim the district is only able to make the one-time commitment of $75,000 to fund 14 for deferred maintenance the 100,000 and not track and field not technology and not classroom Furniture the 100,000 for track is not included um however it is planned for 2526 and 2627 the 110,000 to fund 17 is not made in the
133current year or the projected two years so we're not funding technology infrastructure replacement or classroom furniture for the next two years um it does make the district have 3% this year and the two years out but not our um commitment of 7% that the board wanted so to me I feel like we need to cut more than .4 million because we're not even making this I mean we need to what's going to happen if we have to replace all of our technology where's that money going to come from um if the we have to replace a roof like we need to plan ahead so for me I just want to say I feel like we need to cut more than $1.4 million and and you know make a list of here's here's things at at
134each site that we you know could possibly go list the amounts of them and go through and and see where they are and you you know like the top ones might be one color where like yeah those have to go then the next ones are maybe they can go and so on and so forth to look look at that but for me I would say we need to look at cutting more than 1.4 because if our CBO is telling us that um it's a risky budget that is that's not okay for me that's that's scary because she's you know you're our our business person and you know our a goal of the district is to be fiscally responsible and we don't know what's going to happen so we need to plan yeah and I think
135to that point it's what we've been talking about tonight too is this is to get us there it's by no means yeah correct by no means solving the problem it's getting us through and on a road back to the to the to being L um I I would agree with you I I just don't know if we're able to cut that deep in a in a single year just being honest and I I understand that but yeah and so um I don't think anybody disagrees with your thought I just I don't know if practically that's I feel like it's going to be tough to even get to where we need to Min minimum so just again in all honesty I think it's it's pretty I do deep cut I have I so I wrote down
136some stuff that I want for future agenda items but I feel like it's okay to talk about it here are we still talking about my goals I'm just kidding no no um but because we touched on the the different funds that we didn't and I want to say it was like four years ago cuz I was new when we brought it on but we did a um the funding for what Jackie just talked about the track and field deferred maintenance uh classroom furniture and technology and there were certain set amounts the set asides right set asides um what I mean is there is it possible for us to revisit those because I I feel like it was numbers that were thrown out but now we're in this budget crisis and I don't know how much
137it's going to cost to replace the track and field or the furniture or any of that and I feel like is that if that's something that we can mean like do we do we do a Hiatus for a couple years to help ease the cut or or even look back what's the realistic cost and lifespan of the track well my answer to that would be is the board can do what it wants you have ultimate say in that um we're just we're basing it upon as can I said we're basing upon what our parameters are that we have to build a budget on right and what we have what what your wish is what's been in what policy and stuff like that too right so those are things that we are going to give you
138options with if you remember last time we did the the the we approved the budget right we said listen hey this doesn't have this only has 75,000 of let's say 250 we're supposed to put aside you guys could have said nope not going to do that and then we would have done some other things maybe we made some hires that we made for example for that or we would have cut something out you know what I mean yeah so that's always going to be a discussion this is just the tip of the discussion that we're starting right so we're just kind of laying the path right now and then we need to figure out where we want to do those cuts from and those cuts can come from anywhere as long as there ongoing costs
139right for that so the the monies Ashley speaking to are unrestricted funds you guys budgeted yes that we're setting aside that's correct yes and the idea behind that is is a great idea is is that for example let's use the the the turf field right it has a a life right It's let's say the life is 10 years right so and that's going to be a million dollars well you have to have had a million dollars the idea is to take 10 years and have a million dollars and you have replacement when it's supposed to be changed instead of being like okay whoops we got $100,000 and we got a million dollar field we got to change so I get that but to your point I think actually is maybe we maybe a couple times
140we don't for example in my experience we we had we set aside $60,000 every year and after 5 years we would be able to get a bus right so we do a bus replacement well we had some down years and we thought okay well we're not going to make that um we're not going to do it in six years to buy a new bus we're going to push that to 10 years to buy a new bus and so we're going to push that aside those are decisions that can be made yes but as of right now we're building it upon what our parameters are right now right so that but to reiterate is the 1.4 is the minimum we're going to need to cut to make it to your point yes it's cool because we're
141talking about this and she has to stand up to this this is great I just want to add too and that is that the district has already been making reductions for instance we've had some resignations and we're not filling those positions and that's what gets us to where we are tonight that's accounted for with this it's it's just it's it's almost impossible to make Cuts during the year because everybody's usually on a contract on a year contract so it's really hard to make Cuts during that um and so that's why most of the stuff we're talking about is for next year because that's what you you can kind of control going forward well and we've had to suspend a lot of the um and I I don't know the acronym for this that maybe Michelle
142can help me the sipa what does it stand for single single single plan for student achievement we had to suspend a lot of those this year because we had to slice $165,000 out of the ELC cap dollars because we didn't have it so we've already made and started a lot of those reductions well that we can in general My overall kind of comment to everyone here and just watching and people within the district as well like with all of these different presentations I just hope all of us can work together and create solutions that it's going to be difficult this is incredibly depressing to me to be quite Frank um but they need to happen um but I just hope everyone can kind of work together for those Solutions um so that this can be
143not as horrific as it sounds on paper to me so it's yeah just a collective effort would be much appreciated so to bring us back to the meeting we are asking that the board approved the first interim report for 2425 as positive I'll move to approve the 2425 first room report okay I have a motion as positive as positive positive um I have a motion from trusty Lopez white do I have a second I'll second okay seconded by truste ztz uh preferential I all those in favor I I I any NS I just would say appreciate everybody's what we need to have um I appreciate the communi being here or that and staff as well so um I I just it's it's beginning of what we're going to start talking about so um buckle up
144rough first meeting for a couple of you not night meeting I know yeah mine was until midnight the for whenever I was torn in mine was too yeah yep so one other thing too just remember that our next board meeting is actually up one week remember the 15th nope the 8 cuz the first is on a Wednesday oh so so it's on the 8th so just remember that so it's going to be one week ahead of time so it's yeah so whenever you move it up right actually the first one's going to be quicker so then it'll be after that so any future board agenda items that you want to add can can I request it doesn't have to be right away but can we revisit those the was it board policy that it was
145set that were what were they it was a re re resolution resolution can we revisit those all those different funds that we designated as a board yeah I think it would be good to bring that back as well as the uh the board policy for the 10% too so everybody can kind of see the language especially with two new gentlemen on there too that's okay anything else that anyone would like to add uh can I just ask that when we do bring it back can we get actual numbers for C like just throwing out the track and field mean like what it what the cost revised yeah revised cost in lifespan yes and when we installed it versus and how much we have yeah how much we have set aside for it and how much
146we would need to um I was just curious can we and maybe it's too soon and it would be later is um I guess um how our reading scores are doing going through because we've changed the way that we're doing our reading okay I'll have to think about how I want that so I'll I'll come back to that that that because that doesn't have to just looking at the metrics of new implementation of reading progr or re strategies correct yes sir um did we ever come to a conclusion about the high school graduation numbers or what what was that it was bit still confusing to me how we had an extra elective and then we had a particular like 24 or so do you want so that will be coming also oh okay thank you
147thank you okay anything else okay so future board meeting date it will be January 8th 2022 or 20125 at 6 you guys be getting your stuff on January 1st or 2nd oh it's my kiddo's birthday oh excuse me probably the second apparently okay at least day after that's okay okay um and then I'm not I moved to a a journ okay trusty Garrison moves to a journ do I have a second second all second oh okay so truste seconds preferential I all those in favor I I no NS no exensions okay so we are adjourned at 7