CorpusRecord 108297

CVUSD Board Meeting 02/06/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / CoachellaValleyUSD
Date
2025-02-11
Location
Riverside County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
16,392 words · about 92 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001we're going to go ahead and get started please i' like to call this meeting to order at 5:32 p.m. uh rep would you lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance please please stand place your right hand over your heart ready begin I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all you may now be seated thank you thank you can we get a roll call please yes sir president joyaa Jr here vice president Jin Vargas here clerk Sylvia pass here trondo present Valerie Garcia present Jesus Gonzalez Thomas torz here student trustee lyette Bautista present thank you thank you all uh moving on uh item two close 2.1 close session public comments I'm going go

002ahead and read my little thing here uh public comments closed session this is an opportunity for members of the public to address the governing board regarding any CL session items within the board's jurisdiction or the board's subject matter jurisdiction please complete a request to address a governing board form and hand it to the recording secretary speakers will be limited to 3 minutes per person with the maximum of 20 minutes per each subject matter um we have a lot of them tonight so I would ask that you be respectful to the people who are talking uh and regardless of where they are what they're saying uh so we're going to go ahead and start with uh mea Rees from the rap Foundation okay I'll keep her here in case she's in the back somewhere okay next

003up uh Len Salas followed by Teresa no and again they'll have the clock please uh L's first L's first oh sorry R oh sorry sorry and again you have the clock here please keep it to the 3 minutes because again we do have a lot of people here thank you okay this would be only one minute it's just a question uh in light of the news about um Joselyn Vargas we the community is wondering whether she will be resigning tonight that's all thank you good evening CVUSD board members Dr espara and administrators my name is Teresa nickel it's been my pleasure to serve for 29 years as a credentialed registered school nurse for CVUSD thank you all for listening and advocating for adjusting the Riff list from Seven credential School nurses to four but I'm

004also here to ask you tonight to consider keeping more than five School nurses for our district not including the possible future school nurse manager position I'm not just advocating and fighting for jobs but more importantly I'm fighting for our students lives health and safety last month one of our high school students was having an anaphylactic reaction trained members froze and did not administer the stock EpiPen because of fear if the principal had not been there on campus to administer the EpiPen serious health consequences and even death could have occurred we know how long emergency Personnel can take to arrive I retrained staff immediately for future safety School nurses ensure our students get their free and appropriate public education and prevent liability by ensuring no student has unmet medical needs and work closely with family and

005medical staff and ensure School staff are adequately trained nurse Anna was informed by one of our students with diabetes on the first day of football practice that he's playing she immediately trained the coach and other appropriate staff so the student could participate fully even when he changed his mind and switched to wrestling and now to baseball nurse Anna worked long and hard to ensure his faith and safety we prevent delayed treatment for injuries and serious illnesses that could result in a lawsuit we keep students in school by ensuring students have current medical orders for diabetes G tube feedings catheterizations bleeding disorders and more by collaborating with parents and primary care and Specialists and have many relationships with these doctors and staff nurse Stephanie used her assessment skills and knowledge to recognize signs of muscular distrophy

006and referred a student for care because of her knowledge and Swift action the student has early care and getting accommodations to participate fully in school we've saved to the district money by eliminating the contract for vision and hearing services and doing the screening ourselves we saved the district $1,170 yearly and more as prices have risen we keep students in school by assessing the need for a student to go home from the health office we build medical for special ed assessments and mandated vision and hearing screenings we brought in $66,000 last year in your packet you can see the number of mandated tests that we have completed to date and the nurse out hours that it takes to complete them this does not include our day-to-day tasks please consider the value School nurses bring to the

007district by fulfilling CV usd's mission statement our mission is to empower every student with the knowledge skills and opportunities that we give them needed to thrive in a diverse and rapidly evolving world through collaborative Partnerships with families Educators and the community we strive to create a supportive and inclusive learning environment that celebrates diversity and promotes lifelong learning thank you for your [Applause] consideration followed by yeah I'm good evening members of the school board and Dr espara my name is and I am a bilingual psychologist technician or BPT with me tonight are my colleagues also bpts and we are here to address the impact of the proposed cuts to our positions as you can see from the Riff list nine bilingual psychologist technician positions are being eliminated that means all of us these Cuts threaten to

008disrupt the essential Services we provide to students and families across the Coachella Valley Unified School District for context each of of us manages an average case load of 250 students spread across three to four School sites we serve students from preschool through adult education and our responsibilities are vast we manage monthly amendments initials re-evaluations and various other legal and procedural meetings often dealing with high-profile cases that require communication with attorneys our work is not simply administrative we are actively involved in coordina meeting and scheduling a range of meetings that require bilingual communication sometimes in real time ensuring that non-english-speaking parents are fully informed and empowered to participate in the education process we navigate complex systems such as s and Aries and we work tirelessly to ensure that the notice of meetings and parental rights are

009delivered in a manner that respects the civil rights to our families what is being proposed here is not just elimination of jobs it's the loss of critical support for a diverse group of students and families who depend on our services our role goes beyond translation we are integral in bringing communication gaps and insurance compliance with federal and state laws particularly Ida let me also bring to your attention that other districts like Palm Springs unified have one bilingual IEP support specialist at every School site while Desert Sands only employs translators we however are a team of nine qualified professionals who provide a comprehensive service across the entire District we recognize the district is facing difficult Financial challenges but we ask that these vital positions remain intact without us the district risk imbalances in its services and

010the ability to comply with legal and educational standards will be significantly impaired thank you for your time and consideration we are here to answer any questions and discuss how we can continue to provide these essential services to our students and families and I also uh passed out uh just a quick summary of what I just said thank you next is R followed by laa cont don't take our [Music] BP I am dripping hard today say who you [Applause] are all right good evening everyone my name is Ray anzala vice president for ca's Cella chapter 109 tonight is the vote for the highly anticipated stabilization plan that classified Bears the lon share of the financial impact I reviewed the 2019 fig matat report which is referenced in the plan and this plan isn't really new the

011rcoe recommendations in the plan are just fmat findings that we should have been following since 2019 for those board members who have only been on the board for less than a year or whatever time frame you claim innocence to doesn't matter because some of them some of the people you are ring probably haven't even made probation yet the report states that the board of education is ultimately responsible for the district's budget to further clarify the district's management team past and present provide financial data you need to make good decisions or in this case without all the data needed to make those sound decisions resolution 9.2 does not have any fiscal impact data to be shown but assumes it just needs to be accepted the stabilization plan that was presented tonight or that will be presented

012tonight seems to only blame issues with Cola and one time money spent on FTE but the fact of the matter is we aren't touching larger issues such as not having methods to report financial fraud student data that's incorrect and with misclassifications also the overstatements of attendance assumptions District transfers that were never questions and just signed off the lack of real information information to the board about finances keep in mind the board was mostly given summaries and snapshots of our fiscal condition and accepted it as truth the fact that Galaxy had had and probably still has no real access controls meaning that permissions that go into Galaxy to approve and edit were not watched if I was given a g uh Galaxy access today on a temporary role for 6 months two years later I probably

013still have access to it Joey used to stop progress of board meetings just to understand why the heck people submitted their um requisitions all last minute which is one of the problems we have in this District those requisitions and purchases came in last minute now require spending of unrestricted dollars which just kept happening again and again and this board continued to let management um with these poor fiscal practices let me jump to the end so we are here with more managing than before riffing 24 million and classified and who put us here this board and the selected management yet most riffs and management vacancies have no names no faces that anyone have to make contact with to let them know that they may not have a job for their year thank you [Applause] next if

014you have Mr if you have a copy of your statement you can give it to us so we can read the rest of it you'd like to do that for anyone who has is reading the statements you have a copy give it to mar mar it to next is Leticia contas followed by Roberto Ariano sure you watch got it okay hi good evening members of the board and uh cabinet members uh my name is latisa contas I am an IMA at kachala Valley high school I have been in IMA for 15 years and I have been a district employer for 23 years I'm here on behalf of my IMA family as you can see the same family that was labeled essential and called back to work on April 6th 2020 right at the beginning of

015covid-19 pandemic many of us were scared worried afraid of this new deadly disease but we all showed up and put our family's health and our health at risk to do our job for you for our students at cbhs where I work we distributed over 2,000 iPads to students and over 600 items to teachers for remote learning and teaching throughout the course of a year and a half of the pandemic imas are responsible for checking out textbooks to all students within the first couple of weeks of school to ensure that we are in compliance with the Williams complaint our libraries are are safe zones for our students where students can come in and have a quiet safe area most students do homework work on the computer print do research check out books read hang out um

016protect themselves from the heat from the rain we're always open um during class time students also come in to the library to work on assignments I ready and other uh District mandated tests um they also check out plenty of reading books for College and Career um just to read at home home and they also bring in iPads every second of the day seems like when you know they can't log into their I ready they can't log into canvas they can't log into their email their email was changed was compromised whatever the issues are we always have kids in the library regarding that we also protect the district's assets such as printers projectors projector cards TVs it's a long list iPads homework Gap iPads in which at CV we have 500 and we do need to

017meet with every parent to to get that and um iPads purging old adoptions Surplus e-w laptop laptop cards textbooks including new adoptions um Cod books Apple TV speakers microphones calculators batteries for calculators payments at CV high school we take at the end of the year about $15,000 more or less in payments and I have to man you know enter write it down deposit have to bring the money to the district deposit that we do asset tagging for items under 400 Book Fairs Dr Seuss Week buddy socials during school time I can continued with everything that of how essential we are to our students our parents and our staff but you already know because you guys just reclassified us two years ago to be 12 months because of the lad that we have of work and

018because the start date continually goes up a little bit every year please also consider the California Ed code 18103 requires school libraries to be open to students and teachers during the school day reducing our hours to 5 or six or seven will affect our ability to stay open Ed code 18100 requires School libraries to provide Library services for the students and we need to be there thank you guys for your time so we [Music] have out some information and pictures of the libraries okay next is Roberto arano followed by Fabian oros the time I'll let you know when it's at one we have to stop at Z okay okay so hold on that and can go ahead person for um [Applause] um for [Music] next is Fabiano Rosco followed by uh Jesus Lopez sorry I

019can move this right yes you can oh okay uh good evening I just want to say my name is Fabian it's my first time doing any of this excuse me yeah I have to stay here oh okay I just want to say that I don't think that them dividing us and making it a classified certificated as the issue we are one Workforce we are so oh sorry hold we We Are One Workforce and it doesn't sit right with me for them to sit in their Podium having us gravel for our jobs stand here like if we're on trial when the failure has been already proven to be theirs and everybody in management I don't know about you but everywhere I've been within the Marine Corps of the fire service if you don't cut it they

020get rid of you they've failed it's not a question of if by their own admittance the fact that we owe so much money is a failure how is it how is it that the people that failed aren't being hit and then they sit there the nerve of them to sit sit there and have us gravel it should be the other way around please keep us on board we don't work for them they work for us again I don't know everybody's position and I'm sure everybody's important but the first people that must go is them okay I I've don't know about you but I've never approved those purchases I never approved the expenditure of all that money so what I ask of you I we we need I need you we all need you there's people

021that are brighter than me more articulate have greater influence help us help me fight them okay together we will fix their problem we'll show them what accountability is they speak about accountability but they don't know anything about accountability I see the little emails about we're one Coachella how are we one Coachella when you're not getting hit show you one Cella and then you sit there you look at me you failed you failed you all failed yeah you I like man so I'm sorry but I like you you kid this is a show of what not to do when be in leadership some of you over there I like you miss cindia I like you security guy I like you so I'm sorry but I'm just blanketing but anyways fight okay don't go quietly that's what

022they want they want to divide and they want you to be quiet they present these options like they're doing us a fa no no we will fix this problem we will take accountabil for their mistakes and we'll take the hit collectively but first they must go their salaries their benefits packages I bet you that'll make a pretty big dent they must go they must not be they are not part of the solution we will fix their problem we will take accountability but they must go okay so I ask you don't go quietly fight thank [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] you thank you uh Jesus Lopez is next followed by [Music] Ed let's [Music] go okay [Music] goe good evening members the board Dr sparza and CVUSD Community we the parent committee leads on Stand United

023in agreement with the proposal reduction of the of the months of 11 to 10 or to 8 to 6 hours however we are here today to express our concerns as dedicated employees who feel unheard by those me to represent and protect us we work tireless every day to support our schools and our families we serve a few ways we support our families are parent engagement community schools elac elcap School site Council parent parent workshops resource Fair family events uniform distribution parent communication dpack sixpack and naac and volunteer process throughout the efforts of our Lis on team parent engagement has significant increased and demonstrated by our school data spreesy this process is direct result for our great leadership yet despite our dedication we feel that our roles are being overshadowed by our other priorities we are

024willing to be flexible we are willing to accommodate adapt and compromise when needed we are calling on both the district and the union to work together to reach an agreement that Safeguard our jobs we here give years of service to this district and we deserve better than to be abandoned in this crucial moment we urge you to do what is right to ensure that we can continue to serve the students family of CVUSD without the fear of losing everything we have worked so hard thank you thank you [Applause] followed by Becky Alvarez good evening governance school board members parents teachers and CB USD students my name is Edna baragan I am the Ping Community Le at Mecca Elementary we we all gather here today because we each play a vital role in the Coachella Valley

025UniFi School District District Community we choose this position out of a deep commitment to serve both students and their families we act as a bridge helping families connect with schools and working tirelessly to support our community we recognize the current challenges and the proposed reductions but we are deeply concerned about being placed on the reduction in force list especially when the union has advised us to not worry about it as fighting Community leas we are united in our agreement to work 10 months at 6 hours per day however we have now been scheduled for only 5 hours a day for 10 months this is particularly ply since our work involves a significant amount of EX extra time and energy helping to strengthen the bond between our families and the school community we need those hours

026to facilitate parent engagement and school events we want to emphasize that pations consistently go above and beyond we actively seek local resources and support for our families with the passion we have we are truly dedicated in serving them at this critical moment we need the board support to maintain our positions we work the the work we do is essential and CVUSD needs pations now more than ever thank you for your time and consideration next is Becky Alvarez followed by Jessica a [Music] salutations my name is Becky Alvarez and today I want to speak about why and how to keep that on the elementary level first I want to begin with what is currently being offered every day to students in fourth fifth and sixth grade here are two posters because I was not afforded the

027opportunity to share a video I have plan B to the left are the four disciplines we currently offer at all 14 Schools Music Theater dance and visual arts a famous cult says a picture is worth a th000 words and here are 16,000 words to express what Mech elementary students are experiencing on a daily basis in the Arts next I want to share three testimonials to my right are pictures of those who I will be speaking on their behalf first is Maggie number one she says I am a parent but I also o work here at Mecha Elementary in SDC vapa is the best part of the day for my students it is a distressor but it also builds confidence in them second is Kimberly a student she says baa is the best part of my

028day because it cheers me up lastly is Patricia she says my child is a student in Mecca and I appreciate that my child receives classes and piano thanks to vappa because this is something I cannot afford outside of my school I have an audio of Abraham s play and it is darling here in my hand I hold colored papers of signatures from students I currently teach and they all signed saying we want to keep Papa the Arts is important to these students because every day they get to experience a high quality art education now I want to transition into where this money will come from well in 2022 prop 28 is a law pass and this law says that the state of California will always be given money for the Arts in addition districts with

029students classified as English language Learners and lowincome receive additional funding called concentration funds which is now two extra sources of income for our Elementary art schools the law also states that each school can determine which Arts education program it will offer as of now all 14 Schools at CVUSD offer offer all four disciplines which is required currently all vappa has been eliminated for the next year so my question to you is what plan is the district and school board have in sustaining Arts education in the elementary level which is required because we are getting prop 28 funds will you allow our teachers in the elementary level to continue the cause of learning thank you next is uh Jessica Ayala followed by uh Amaya and helos [Music] all right good evening everyone my name is Jessica

030aala I currently work as a Behavior Support at Oasis Elementary in the wellness center for those who don't know the wellness centers were implemented to provide a safe and supportive environment for students mental health is an incredibly important part of overall health and deserves the same amount of attention and support I am extremely happy that the wellness centers will continue to operate however our position is on the list to get Rift I believe the want Center needs us to operate success successfully we are not only the right hands of our teachers but we are people who are students trust to help them in whatever they may need there are many students who visit the wellness centers daily and as a team we help as many students as possible if our position were to be cut

031the wellness centers teacher would not be able to see as many students therefore they will not be able to help as many students as we do now we have been there for students who are struggling with substances students who are close to taking their life students who deal with anxiety self harm abuse use and homelessness to list just some besides being in the wellness center we also help teachers admin and other school staff with any behavior issues that may arise wherever they arise the field the NPR the classroom the quad Etc I believe Behavior Support in the wellness centers are essential to our school Success I ask that you seriously consider keeping our position thank [Music] you thank you we have uh Amaya and hel Munos followed by Anna sea hello distinguish School Board administrators

032CVUSD community and superintendent Dr sparza my name is Amaya Minos and I am an expanded learning programs coordinator at Kella Valley High School I'm speaking today about my wholehearted support for B Gonzalez the director of our expanded learning programs here in our district as an employee hired in October 2023 I have had the opportunity to witness firsthand the leadership and undeniable commitment B Be brings to her role overseeing expanded learning programs at 20 schools across the district be's impact extends to nearly 3,000 students and over 310 employees her expertise is invaluable to our community be's vision and dedication consistently demonstrates the effectiveness of dynamic leadership in educational programs her ability to manage complex initiatives Foster an inclusive environment and drive innovative solutions has not only enhanced the quality of our programs but has also improve

033student engagement and success under her Guidance the expanded learning programs have become a Cornerstone of our district creating enriching opportunities that support students academically socially and emotionally I also believe that be strategic insight and interpersonal skills have built a collaboration among staff and a deep sense of community among the students that we serve she has a proactive approach to problem solving and an unwavering commitment to educational Excellence these have made a profound difference in the lives of demoting her position from director to Coordinator would not only undermine the progress we have made but would also detract from the strong leadership that is critical to the continued success of these programs B is the ideal candidate to continue leading expanded learning programs with the vision expertise and passion that are essential essential for driving positive change

034a decision to diminish her role would be a significant loss for the countless of stud for the countless students and employees that she Services it's important that we remember that happy minds are learning learning minds and our students who flourish under our support provided by the expanded learning programs are an invaluable asset to our district thank you for your time and consideration thank you next is Anna sea followed by Omar [Music] St good evening board members and community my name is Anna sea I am a sixth grade teacher and one of the expanded learning program exlp coordinators at ois elementary school I am in my ninth year working in exlp under the direction of B Gonzalez for those of you who do not know be I would love to tell you a little bit about

035her and hopes to shed some light on the type of leader she is B1 silus is committed to the community but most importantly the students a good leader is someone who has Integrity is resourceful and instills Trust in their team these are all traits that possesses and anyone who speaks to her can quickly see she is extremely knowledgeable and an incredible source to all coordinators if we ever have a concern or question she is always there to guide us as we all know exlp plays a prominent part in the lives of our students we provide academic enrichment and safe constructed Alternatives after school it exposes students to activities like robotics music and digital media additionally our students are exposed to other trips and learning opportunities that are curated by be be has remained committed to

036provide high quality services and opportunities to the students for instance she has maintained relationships with partners that work alongside her to allow her student skills to flourish from the streets of the Coachella and Mecha parades to the high school gyms that get to witness the sprouting talents of exlp students my role has allowed me to see Beast commitment to this program at an even deeper level I am able to witness her integrity and the way she always keeps the students best interest at the Forefront of what she does she is committed to the following Pro to following the program and Grant guidelines to maintain exlp as a high quality program her dedication commitment and integrity are the key qualities that have impacted exlp in such a positive way we Circle back to the students being

037the most benefited out of our program and we only get better under the direction of b as director maintaining this T title allows her to continue to focus on maintaining and improving a high standard program additionally it allows her to lead coordinator to assure the successful exlp programs at each site with that said I encourage the board to consider alternatives when it comes to demoing be from her as director of expanded learning as she has worked effortlessly for many years to get the exlp and elop program at CB USD to where it is today I thank you for your time and undivided [Applause] attention next is Omar suello followed by lassar Mesa hello um board members and community members I apologize if I stutter I don't normally don't read scripts uh but my name is

038Omar satell Felix I am a certificated substitute teacher here at the district I am one of the exop coordinators like my peer U mea um I've been under uh Oasis for seven years now under the direction of uh Miss B Gonzalez I'm sure uh those of you who are here very frequently hear her name very often uh but I just wanted to mention the impact that she has had on her students under her leadership uh B has created a program which Fosters students individual skills developing them into students with goals and aspirations B has assured that exop offers students a variety of enrichment activities where students can develop their non-academic skills for example most C the uh sites offer Drumline as an enrichment activity for those of you do not know when joining High School

039bands not under the exlp umbrella families have to pay anywhere from $500 to $1,000 per student and band fees to participate in the program this goes to pay for instruments repairs and pay for staff as a former band member myself these band does were personally taxing and my family because there was two of us and that can be get very expensive compared under B leadership cbsd uh students who are interested in developing their music skills have the opportunity to join their school's drum Ling class at any point in their k through eight years at little to no Financial cost to students and families students who enroll in drum Ling class can develop their skills from Elementary grades through middle school to better prepare them from high school drum line in addition to daily drumming and

040music l lessons at each site students can collaborate with districtwide peers in cly drum line camps where High School drum line students can develop their younger student skills this helps the young students by allowing them to gain new knowledge but also help students develop High the high school students develop their teaching skills students get an opportunity to apply their new found knowledge in yearly parades family performances and drum link competitions where all district drum Lanes compete against each other and are judge based on the performance the staff and equipment and maintenance interpretation is all covered by exop which is great a lot of parents but also great for students this allows a higher number of students the ability to develop their skills and pursue their passions into high school and higher education for example I

041was initially hired at the school as dring instructor six years ago which is great for me as a recent graduate who got to develop teaching skills and one of my passions but now those students from six years ago are now seniors who have gained six years of experience in music and are now telling me that they want to go to college earn a degree in music and they want to come back and teach drum line themselves by focusing on the students and providing safe environment for students to explore their interests and passions it allows them to achieve High educational outcomes and a higher sense of achievement this would not be possible without the guidance from be I ask you to please uh consider this when discussing her demotion uh also on the side note I

042just want to mention that um it seems that elop has a lot of money and everyone seems to be asking for be money seems that she has managed that very well thank you so much next is Laro Mesa followed by Monica Gara muo all right good after uh good afternoon everyone uh board members uh it is with great honor and deep appreciation that I stand before you today in support of B Gonzalez an extraordinary leader a dedicated Advocate and a true champion of our students our exlp director once again B Gonzalez B has not only LED this program with unwavering dedication but she has also propelled it to new heights ensuring that more students than ever before have access to this enrichment to this support and many opportunities that they so deserve under her leadership

043our program has flourished growing to meet the needs of our community in ways we have never thought possible one of her most significant achievements obviously has been securing State Grant approval for our schools a crucial victory that has allowed us to expand our services to provide more resources and to reach even more students this accomplishment alone speaks volumes offered R lless commitment to ensuring that our program remains strong well funded and impactful but be's great work goes far beyond securing funding she's also looking out for the students always asking how can we serve more how can we do better that commitment is evident and her push to hire more exlp staff ensuring that no child is left without the support they need thanks to our leadership we've been able to expand our reach offering more

044students the academic and personal enrichment that helps them Thrive and that is exactly why we are here because now at a time when our program in is its most crucial period of growth and expansion demoting beegan siles would not only be a mistake it would be detrimental to everything she has built and to the future of our students her leadership is the backbone of this program her vision her passion and her dedication are what make this program a success we cannot afford to lose the Steady Hand that has guided us this far we cannot afford to disrupt the progress we've made most importantly we cannot afford to jeopardize the future of the students who rely on this program every single day vegan silus has given her heart and soul to this work and we owe

045it to her and to her students to ensure that she remains in the role that she has allowed that has allowed her to make such profound difference let us stand together in support of her continue leadership so that our exlp program can continue to grow to thrive and to change lives for others for years to come and with that being said I've been uh in NIS probably like 20 years and I yet have to see some of you guys out there in the tournaments so with that being said it's not about just going out there and shaking hands it's about volunteering to be a ref and actually be seen as a board member and not just sitting out there at the chair thank [Music] you next is Monica Gara Moro followed by Jordan Silva good

046evening Dr spara members of the board student trustee sadly one of the things our district is known for is layoffs or purgings this is the fourth we've been through in my 21 years I was bumped into expanded learning in 2008 to a staff of seven people in the purging of 2011 our department was gutted from 7 to2 B and myself a bilingual secretary and program coordinator admin at that time expected us to fail because how can two people run a program that serves 21 schools and handles millions of dollars well it's 2025 and we're still here with ground funding for kids because of B our department learned to be strong because we had to be with no reliable support from admin and attacks from every direction the jobs in our department are extremely challenging and

047stressful because of the massive amounts of work we produce with the Skeleton Crew we make our jobs look easy but I can tell you it's because of be leadership I don't know how many of the district um I don't know how many people know but the district takes almost 2 million of indirect funding for district level oversight from our grants and you're still taking another 6 million from kids to help fix the mess someone else made you're punishing be and you're punishing kids this demotion to be is unjust and you're trying to hide it and cover it up in between this new budget purging our entire department is fully funded by grants none of our positions are paid out of the general fund so it doesn't make sense that she's being demoted for fiscal stabilization

048our department brings Millions into the district and we help the district and we're self-sufficient because of be diligence in continuing to secure these Grant dollars but I'm sure she'll be expected to continue doing all of the duties of a director because that's how this District rols when it comes to expanded learning this is a direct Target to be straight from those the ones who have been hounding about her position and our department for years before she was made whole as a director she did this job successfully and was a awarded grant funding for 11 years before she was given the title you tell me who else would do that or give up every weekend nights holidays for events and tournaments for the kids just to tear her down not even two years later try being

049in the ICU from stress from your job and the only thing people want to know is when you're coming back to approve your budget cues it happened we get audited one to two times a year and even internal District staff calls Auditors and state officials on us yeah we know our audits are clean and they piss people off we know our compliance and our grants and we don't do things in our our department because they're easy or easy to cover up we do it because it's the right thing the right way and for our kids that is be's Legacy we pay the entirety of summer school $12 million for staff and supplies last year from elop funds and we're doing it again this year we process and B signed 880 time Parts twice with a

050staff of two requisitioners someone twisted my words last time and made it seem like we didn't get paid but we're compensated fine I'm appalled that you have no problem taking grant money or spending Grant dollars applied thank you I'm sorry Monica thank [Applause] you Jordan Silva followed by Jenna Nunes good evening my name is Jordan Silva I have been working in the exlp office since 2022 as the attendance clerk I am in charge of collecting attendance data for Grants which be Works TIR tirelessly to constantly obtain and maintain so that our program can be what it is today working with be I quickly became excited to learn about how I program I have come to love love so much functions on the inside and let me tell you it's a lot of work but her

051passion for what she does is extremely contagious I work alongside some people who are truly dedicated to not only our exlp program but CVUSD I have never experienced so much push back from people who claim to who to want what's best for our students yet yank everything we try to do away from us I've had the privilege to attend meetings with be where other directors from after school programs from other districts are present and let me tell you they flock to her like a Shining Light cuz she does stand out because of her perception always being rooted in how can I do more for our students and families she is an amazing and strong leader and I have seen and heard the attacks constantly aimed at her and our department personal and professional proposing the

052elimination of director of exlp is not only a professional attack but a personal one to our department no one seems to talk about the millions of dollars at El elop funds which B has managed was used to help the budget deficit and save jobs yet she finds herself now on a list as a part of those cuts what a slap in the face she has been director there for many years and clearly has been doing an amazing job looking at other departments having a constant turnover yet Be Still Remains director should say a lot about how she does her job exlp remains to be a big part of our district yet is constantly swept under the rug if 30 years dedication to this District doesn't show how much she's worth then go out to view

053the programs at any School site you'll see the smiles and laughter she has helped to create thank you next is the Jenna Nunes followed by Antonia Munos hello uh my name is Jenna Nunes and I work for the exlp Department I'm up here along with my co-workers to express the disappointment in seeing my Department's director Gonzalez's position being added to the reduction list I'm fortunate not to have my title on the layoff list but I'm also uncertain along with all my peers if I'm safe or will I be bumped with the domino effect that comes with layoffs but I don't understand why be specific position was included in this fiscal stabilization when our exlp positions are strictly paid out of our exlp grants that she applies for these layoffs have all of us worried and

054unfortunately we have to pay for other people's mismanagement of funds but to add be's position that will not help alleviate the budget strain coincides with the personal attack she continuously receives from the board thank you Antonia and followed by Karina Rodriguez hi everyone I'm Antonia Munos and I am a coordinator at Desert Mirage high school for expanded learning programs I want to take a moment to recognize what an exceptional director B Gonzalez is for Extended Learning programs here at cvus St her dedication to our students go beyond the day-to-day responsibilities she makes sure that every child in our program learns feels valued safe and most importantly has fun doing all of our activities she doesn't just go she doesn't just work behind the scenes but she shows up she's at every tournament parade and event

055that matters to her students she is well respected and recognized to our community not because she seeks that recognition but like I mentioned her impact is UN undeniable because she shows up to every single event it's on the weekends holidays during breaks she still shows up to every single event that we have for our students her priority is the students and ensures that every opportunity we provide for them without without is for them without having to worry about costs or barriers we are fortunate to have her as a director because she truly cares about everyone that makes up expanded learning programs not just students but staff her leadership is essential and demoting her is not only a disservice for the program but for the students we are dedicated to serve thank you thank you um

056next is uh Gina Rodriguez and then I will call uh I was told she came back uh Mara Rees for talk about the rat Foundation she'll be speaking next goad uh good evening Dr sparza president Akuna and board members um my name is Gina Rodriguez I am a Community member a parent of this district and a district employee um I want to make it clear at three minutes is not enough time but I will do what I can in this I'm here to speak in regards to reduction of Workforce the reduction that includes the exlp director position to be reclassified to a coordinator it is the understanding that the exlp department and programs are completely funded through Grant funds so how does a reclassification of a current director position help the district's general fund is

057a 34 $4,680 help the general fund of the district when the position is fully funded through these grants it has been said that expanded learning department is in need of more staff a team of six is not enough so why not have the conversation of expanding dep Department while being in compliance with the grants I would like to give some historical information on the exlp department as I find it important to know in 2011 the current exlp director was given the responsibility of the after school programs with a staff of two including herself in 2013 another staff member was added to this team in 2022 the coordinator became the director of the expanded learning programs but please keep in mind that the years of 2011 to 2022 this employee was a coordinator with the responsibilities

058of the director in 2024 a coordinator for the exlp Department was added to the team which is myself since 2011 the exlp department has been led by our current director and in those years the current director has applied and been awarded over $148 million for the after school programs fully funding part-time staff supplies equipment extra Services current CB USD staff and all our exlp full-time staff the district receives a 15% overhead cost for all Grants awarded for expanded learning and receiving these Grant Awards our current director has seamless reporting documentation and visit from Grant funders which have allowed for continuous funding throughout these years in the program the exlp department under the direction of our current director has created and fostered significant Partnerships increase programming increase activities and resources for our students it is not

059a team that has been formed by exlp it's a community it's a community that consists of coordinators Lin staff principles office staff the list goes on students and also most of all students that who we work for students who call exlp programs home students who have experience in drum light Dance Art sports music academics and the list goes on they have a community of their own and we have a competent director and leader who knows how to lead the team this leader is our current director of expanded learning she always puts our students first and always remind us it's about the students I have been with the school district for six months but for the past 10 years I have known B Gonzalez our current director as the after school program person now being part

060of this team it has allowed me to understand what exlp is I would ask that you reconsider this classification and Lins with the cvs2 mission statement were Excellence equity and Innovation and our guiding principles thank you uh next is M re followed by Miriam Wes hello my name is Mia Rees and I am here on behalf of letia Thea who had a scheduling conflict let the asset I read her statement for the record I understand the school board is faced with some ult decisions it came to my attention that one of the decisions you will be considering today is to make a change or rather a demotion of one of your administrators B Gonzalez Who currently serves as the ases Director as a CEO of the regional Access Project Foundation I have had the opportunity

061to work with be on many occasions be has served on the r board as a volunteer since 2016 she is a strong advocate for the community there is so much that I could share about B but I will limit it to a project that rap is currently providing through anou with CVUSD the CV Healthy Living Program although the school district recognized and adopted the mou in 2023 there was a there was no action being taken by the elementary schools to accept and allow my team to offer the free nutrition and recreation activities this is understandable since School principles and teachers have a great deal to address in their educational programming when be heard in November of 2024 about her slow start she took steps to ensure that resources that could benefit kids would be made

062available through the Asus program The Healthy Living Program kicked off yesterday and is offering services at seven schools B knows everything there is to know about Asus and has successfully secured grants and donations created strong programming and AD administer these programs with responsibility accountabil and accountability she was a perfect go-to person because she understands the needs of the kids and key deliverables and the complexities involv in managing the after school program because of her administration of acis kids and parents benefit from creative and nurturing activities according to my rap team this extra effort from B to connect them to ases was quote this is for the kids we will make it happen unquote again I know you have tough decisions to make but with without a doubt CV healthy living resources would not be offered

063through Aces without be's essential role as director of the program she has the ability knowledge and drive to carry on in this leadership role and should be allowed to continue to serve the students parents and overall Community thank you for your attention and consideration I appreciate your service to our community and the position you are in thank you uh next is Medi Warez followed by uh Leon Lopez [Music] El ad EX p G [Applause] thank you Mr Lopez followed by Matthew Maldonado Mr President is it 20 minutes per subject it can it can be but but as president I made the decision to let everyone speak we have unless you differ with that well I'm just he he can speak but I'm saying you know it's usually 20 minutes per subject you didn't mention that

064when they were talking about the other stuff when they were supporting you but you know who's supporting me so again it is it is my decision as president to allow everyone to speak regardless of the time limit if the board chooses to override me make a motion I'm not making a motion I'm just bringing that to your attention okay Mr Lopez go ahead hi board members my name is leam Lopez I'm in hi board members my name is Le Lopez I'm in the fifth grade and I go to CV elementy I'm here I'm here to tell you to please reconsider changing Mrs B role from director of EA xlp to coordinator I say this because Mrs B does a great job of making sure the program Asus and other programs are in good hands if

065Mrs B does get her role change Aces could get in bad hands which could lead to the discontinuation of Asus this is bad for lots of families who depend on Asus while they are at work if families don't have anywhere to keep their children safe it would be bad for them especially families of younger children thank you for listening next uh Matthew malalo followed by followed by Rebecca areta good evening borne I will waste absolutely no time back in 2011 I scheduled a walk out from Desert Mirage high school because the then superintendent and board fired my principal and I wasn't very fond of that decision here we are 11 years later and I have to fight for my mom yeah that's right B Gonzalez is my mother I have to sit here and watch

066every single one of you act like she hasn't given her life for this place like she's not the reason you sit in your ey Towers like nothing is wrong she deals with parents she deals with disgruntled students none of you do none of you if it wasn't for her this District wouldn't be seen the way it's seen this District would be nothing without her as far ASA you've known her for the last two years you got the best version of her the version that was spat out that was beaten that was told she wasn't good enough that was told she was a single mom she wasn't going to do anything she was going to lose her home that's the woman sitting there and you think she's not worth this position and every single one of

067you knows the kind of mouth I have you're very lucky I'm being respectful right now there's a lot of things I want to say to you and by the way that's a violation of free speech my friend this this lady right here I've had the 28 years of pleasure of being her son watching every single student come up to her be Miss B this program is so awesome she had kids go see LeBron James for the first time in their lives what have you done for them like that she went to take them to a hockey game for the first time these kids have never seen anything like that nothing nothing because of her because of the I'm sorry because of the connection she makes in the in the district and our in our communities

068and you're sitting there telling her she's incompetent she can't do her job she's mismanaging funds where it's the most successful program damn near in the entire State how is she mismanaging funds I was a I'm a product of this District I was in the after school program I've seen the evolution I am so proud of where she's taken it and like Monica said I've seen her kill herself in hospital beds because she wanted to make sure this program ran correctly making sure all of you looked good all of you that call this place home like we do this is our home and she is one of ours she's one of yours too why are we doing this what happened to M what happened to that this isn't the way we treat each other this is

069the way the people that want see us down treat each other this is not the way we treat our elders this is not the way we treat the people that kill themselves for you and all of them too they're killing themselves for you too but I'm here for my mother I apologize everybody she is the reason people want to come to this District Kina she brought Karina Kina is one of the best pickups you could have ever gotten we took her from the drd do you understand how hard that is to bring somebody that's actually worth the damn from there and you guys want to get rid of the one lady that did it thank you I yielded my time next up is uh Rebecca aretta followed by uh zulma Hernandez good evening my name

070is Rebecca aretta and I have been a teacher of fella Valley Unified for almost 15 years as an education specialist I have worked with a vast amount of service Personnel within our district for students with special needs I have valued each and every one of their dedication to serve our students our special education population is one of our most vulnerable populations to maintain and continue to grow with I have seen how having bilingual psychologist technicians uh how having them have improved our special education services the previous speaker Bianca pointed out so many important asps ects of their job that we don't always see at the school site I see how they have helped to stay in compliance with laws pertaining to special education timelines and accountability to the state not only are they valuable to

071help um maintain compliance they are valuable to our continued growth and connection within the community they are a direct connection to our families their role throughout the day is imperative including scheduling meetings rescheduling for additional meetings contacting parents for assessment plans going to fam's homes to contact if needed and translating during meetings they are providing translations and meetings to allow parents to be active participants in the IP team if you decide that their job is no longer valued enough to keep whose responsibility does this become as a special education teacher I can tell you I maxed out it can't be us if um if the responsibility is put on Administration how will this affect our timelines how will this affect our ability to maintain compliance how will this affect opportunities to have conversations with the

072parents regarding questions for meetings and amendments and scheduling all Personnel that are necessary to be there how do we make sure notifications are sent on time how can you guarantee that we will continue to be in compliance admin's responsibilities are consistently increasing and positions are decreasing so to put this on them only adds additional stress and important special education needs will be missed in the 15 years that I've been here there has always been some form of a bilingual psychologist technician and I've always valued their ability to keep us in compliance if they are taken from us can you guarantee that we will continue to maintain that connection with families in the community and our most vulnerable population I urge you to reconsider eliminating this position because it is a valuable and pertinent position for

073our community and our school district thank you thank [Music] you next next we have uh Hernandez followed by Alysia Vada I always get it wrong I'm sorry [Music] Hernandez I think she left she left I think she left okay hang on to that for a [Applause] while is what maybe I in the come to the library you got to stop now last two week the last two weeks I came here and I explained to you my duties now you have it in paper okay you have it in paper I started in the year 2006 eight hours 11 months it was okay because the students were coming at September we had one month the job increased so much the past two the two years ago you decided to make us 12 months 12 months eight hours

074I was your last two weeks ago I thought it was 11 months and six hours when somebody told me it's 10 months and 5 hours look at my job description I will start on the first day we have to distribute workbooks textbooks teachers material iPads for the students equipment message or broken from the classroom from the teachers we don't do not sit down and just check out a book we do not what my co-workers said it is true but with a process of one broken iPads how many minutes do we take 10 minutes 10 or 15 it was just one but when you have like how many I had 160 160 to process to send it to the insurance so we start on on if we start on September do we have time to distribute

075the textbooks workbooks iPads if I start early the teachers come early and the first thing they said I have a student from out of District I need an iPad like this you if it pass it's 10 months 5 hours I don't think we could do it okay no way I call shanet she's the one who created us she retired I called her Shannon could this be possible 10 months 5 hours she said no 11 months in 8 hours it is your decision I understand that we're in crisis I do understand that but if we're not there who's going to do the job nobody and the teachers are going to complain to us parents are going to complain to us you were not hearing this we are over there on campus and you over here and

076I've been coming years past and telling you my job description I invited you many times thank you so much for listening thank [Applause] you I'm going to go one more time with Miss Hernandez if she's here if she left then um we we'll go ahead and pass on that I have one left so if there's anybody else who wants to speak please do it now come forward give Mar the the right there uh next is and I believe it's Dani uh Zuniga Zuniga I'm sorry did I pronounce that first name right no Missa or Miss Hernandez all right seeing none I'll wait for this final one to come up we have two more final ones to come up just one just one oh you got another one oh they're finishing it up okay well we'll

077go ahead uh D [Applause] Weisman on this is your labor rip classy wow thank you um my name is Dale wisman I've been in education for 32 years I lived here in the desert for a little longer little little less than that I come up from a family of teachers and and I've been the labor rep for all but just uh I think seven or eight years here I was the labor rep back in 2004 and I've never seen it this bad I have done layoffs in other districts that are smaller than you that were 115 people I've never seen a layoff list go 254 deep here's the problem an outside group of people who are not you from Riverside County have taken a hatchet to your services without reference to how the work actually

078gets done and that means very basic things you've heard it tonight how you going to get kids back forth to school how you going to hand out textbooks when you're you're cutting hours and work year to such an extent CSA approach is going to be to negotiate everything that we can negotiate for the purpose of retaining jobs and student services it's not about taking a hatchet it's about taking a scalpel and finding out where we can repurpose people in places where you still need help such as special education par Educators and finding places for those folks to continue to be successful at the district to serve students the biggest problem you're having is you're attempting to follow a raw number coming from rcoe that is a 2-year cut that you're moving all the way up

079to this year so you don't have to do it again that is fundamentally a wrong approach you want to try to get your balance budget next year less what you can take out of your economic reserve the purpose of $80 million in the bank is for when it's raining if it ain't raining now it's never been raining in this district and then you can see what next year brings because people will retire and quit and leave and we will have further positions that we might have to look at in 2026 seven but you can't make this level of cuts and open your schools it's not going to happen nope it it just is not I mean I've looked at this list myself and looked at your position control and I got to tell you I

080don't understand how you have numbers in there like books and Supply at a higher level than you ever spent how you're cutting places and saying that you're going to spend too much on labor when after these Cuts you're proposing to spend more on classified school employment than you've ever spent in the history of classified school employment so your numbers don't make any sense because I know your budget and what I want to do is see what it actually looks like on July 1 when you have an audited return and we can really look like what it needs to be to open schools but slow the roll a little bit folks because you're going to collapse your school district and we're not going to let you do that because this is a great group of people

081give these people a hand good me veras followed by good evening my name is Veronica dwas you all should know me by now I am the chief Union Stewart for CCA as you can see behind me this is what Unity looks like we have done this before and I'm guessing we're going to have to do it again I need for everybody to understand you all on top of my people because these are my people I've been there done that been there done that I have 10 years on this Union board and I have 20 years of service in this District everybody has come and gone I am still here they are still here this is a revolving door so I say this with much respect we as csca leadership will negotiate until 12 1 in

082the morning because guess what we've done it before right okay and we will do it again but please stop and understand what everybody has said you all have lives I have life I have bills you have bills they have bills they have children I it's it's a rolling cycle here this District these students the this community what you see in here matters to every each and one of us that's why you're all sitting up there okay so please new board members semi new board members old board members look at what you are voting on understand what is being brought to you and ask the question before you decide there is something called the brown act you should all be aware of it cuz that's why you're there but there's also something called training for board

083members each and every one of you should be taking it and not deny to take that training so you can understand what comes in front of you you know what it is 20 19 you guys already knew about the deficit not the new ones but the ones that are there $6.9 million is where it was at how could we not stop it back then how cuz we took the cuts then and now 2025 TW $24 million again I told you guys this is not on anybody but the board that's right please thank you very much have a good evening next next we have uh Rafael Delgado followed by Elizabeth Tavarez um um [Applause] and for super the graas thank you uh again last call this is the last one I have today Elizabeth Tavarez good

084evening board members I want to thank you Joey for allowing all the public comments I wouldn't have been able to speak tonight if it wasn't for you so thank you um but I am going to start by making a very direct question to miss Vargas on your interview to kesq you said that maybe perhaps you were going to move to India that is a very poorly disguised yes so what I'm asking is for you to step down because whether you do or not you're out probably next month with the vote because you will lose the election and you are going to take Asus Gonzalez with you now um I already discussed the people that will need to leave that are in the room I want to address now the person that needs to stay which

085is B Gonzalez B Gonzalez has been the coordinator of Asis since my daughter started going to school which is at least 17 years if not more um during her stay the most recent thing she has accomplished which I thought was amazing was the early start program um as you know Child Care is extremely hard to find right now um especially for our community out in thmo I don't think there's a lot of licensed childcare providers so the work that she has done as you've heard from other members extends Beyond where her job description entails I mean she secured funding and I'm afraid that that funding might go away I mean I didn't volunteer to speak today because my child is graduating this year it doesn't affect me um the the changes directly but I know

086it's going to affect the community and the Immigrant community of our um city uh of our cities in the kachala valley another thing that I want to point out to about be this is a very hard thing to say and I've noticed said it publicly but my daughter's friend passed away in a fire back in and her brother passed away in a fire Mr Miss Bey Gonzalez missb Dominguez and her little brother passed away you know who was the hand that held her that woman when she saw that trailer go down be Gonzalez have any of you done anything like that for any of the parents here she went out and tried to find a place that will hold the service for her daughter and find resources for her she goes Way Beyond what her

087job inails I've seen her at all the events I've go to which from you the only face I recognize outside of this boardroom is Joey and triny I would invite you and I SEC other people that have came up here to tell you that you guys need to be out in our communities I'm just going to go back to my notes to make sure I don't leave anything out but thank you for letting me speak and you guys really need to keep be gon soles you want to keep the one thing that's good in our district thank you thank you uh that is the last one I have so at this point I would entertain a motion to go on to close session a motion I have a motion do I hear a second second

088I have a motion in a second all those in favor I all those opposed motion carries uh I know it said we're going to come back at 8:30 oh I'm sorry sorry I'm sorry um trusty B this in favor sorry about that it's already been a long meeting he started um I know we said we're going to come back at 8:30 but because we pushed it out so far we're probably looking at it a little bit later we'll try to get back as soon as we can thank you like to call this meeting back into order we had a motion and a second um to return into Open Session the vote carried unanimously um Madame clerk would you read the actions taken in close session [Music] please okay so in close session the board took

089action to release certificated teacher ID um number sl8 SL 675 and directed the superintendent or designate to send out appropriate legal notices the roll call vote was as follows eyes Jesus Gonzalez Thomas toris binondo Valerie Garcia Joey auna Joseline Vargas and Sylvia pass that is it thank you um next on the item approval of agenda as submitted do I hear a motion motion have a motion toar a second second motion and a second any questions any changes seeing none all those in favor I I student trustee in favor any opposed motion carries uh item next item Communications or public comments Open Session board notification introductory comments and requests to address the board on items on the adopted agenda and items not on the adopted agenda will be considered from the audience at this time please

090complete a request to address the governing board form and hand it into the recording secretary speakers will be limited to 3 minutes per person with a maximum of 20 minutes to each subject matter Additionally the person making the request should State his or her name and the name of the organization or group represented please be advised that the board is not always at Liberty to answer questions right away state law prohibits the board from taking any action on items not listed on on the agenda um I have two of them so if anybody wants to anybody else wants to speak uh check in with Mighty right there uh Dale wisman hey I wanted to come back up and uh talk talk with everybody again um when it's a little quieter uh I want to make

091sure that all the board members the administration know the other side of this which is that CSA is an organization and others in the education Community recognize the scale of what is happening here and how difficult and unique it is for Coachella Unified School District and you are not alone you're not alone uh some of the things that are happening you are simply a canary in the coal mine that happen haven't happened to other districts yet certainly there's some internal issues in terms of how the money worked but you know ice Bakersfield is experiencing that um the loss of um members don't you know and people who join cowers as an example uh doesn't just impact Coello Al unified if you can imagine this happened to every single District what the impact on cowp would

092be as an example so uh you know CSA addresses these things on a much bigger scale than my pay grade obviously uh through government relations department Calpers and so on and you're not alone we're we're going to have to work through this and we're going to do the right thing to make sure your school district stays open but I just just wanted to introduce somebody who drove all the way out here because of uh that potential those potential issues that are far beyond just what's happening at Coachella Valle unified so Kevin paly is a Cowper's board member who drove all the way out here and wanted to observe and and and see this kind of canary in coold mine what's happening to you guys as uh not the only one maybe just the first that

093is experiencing those kinds of things um other districts by the way are as I told you guys are actually having budget cuts but they're not getting this level of focus and they're not seeing this level of multiple challenges occurring at the same time so Kevin paly's come out tonight he's actually the next person on your list and I want to come up and just introduce them so you understand why it's so important that that cowers and that other uh larger bigger picture of people sit on these huge Statewide boards you know cowp has a half trillion dollars in it now right that are paying attention and what's happening out here in uh coo and just thanks uh Mr paly for driving out good evening board members uh as Dale mentioned my name is Kevin paly

094and I represent uh School Employees from the northern part of California to the southern part of California on the cowers board um I don't envy the seats that you sit in right now I know the difficult decisions that you are faced with and um I know what it means to um have the members and the community and the best interest in everything that you do um so but I would like to encourage you to continue to look at the long-term effects uh whether it's on the School Employees themselves their families the communities they live in all of it is interconnected um a loss to our schools hurts much more than our students it hurts our communities it hurts our our great state of California um and the effects uh could be longlasting so continue to

095look at the the long-term effects uh these days were so there were surrounded by so much noise and the immediate um trying to respond to things immediately but uh you know a lot again a lot of that is noise and as long as we're looking at the long-term goal and the long-term effects I know that we can make a big difference in the state of California as well as in our communities so thank you thank you that's the last one I have anybody else okay we're moving on uh next item Communications board members and superintendent uh written Communications that any um our student board member report good evening so I'd like to start off with uh just a report of all high schools so I'm going to start with laam media High School it says

096quarter Awards took place on January 31st to recognize students that showed Improvement and dedication in a particular class Cod Financial a night seniors are welcome with their family to join and receive personalized support to complete financial aid applications located at cod's Palm Desert campus on February 6th and March 12 indio's campus is to be announced Sports laaia boys and girls soccer team received their first Victory against Amad High School scoring 11 points in its first game of the season Desert Mirage High School would like to share many seniors have completed their fasta and DREAM Act applications counselors are helping with those who haven't scholarship opportunities are also being updated regularly on canvas to help students find financial aid the wrestling team has had a strong season with several athletes qualifying for CIF including I'm sorry

097if I pronounced this name wrong Kenia it's k n a Roso and Victoria sandal and Owen Amaya West sh High School would like to share that on February 5th students at West sh High School took a stand and solidary uh with immigrant family immigrant families by participating in a protest many chose not to attend school work or shop as a way to raise awareness and show their support as a result our schools saw only 50% attendance that day while actions like these can have an impact on the district they can also highlight how strong students feel about issues affecting their communities now this is mine for cachell Valley High School I'd like to talk about a meeting we had today with security uh we had a group of ambassadors and some students um we had

098a meeting with the security beforehand last year and I brought it up in a board meeting as well um we were going to address it with Jesse and another one of the security but they got busy during the period which is understandable so Mr Castillo stepped in um we voiced our concerns it was mostly about like how we see them huddling up and our concerns being that they to what we see in our perception of it is that they huddle up more than what's needed in a way where we see them on their phones or sometimes on a phone call or they're just like socializing which we understand all social socializing at work getting to know your colleagues and stuff like that but when we see kids who are ditching or people who are smoking

099in the restroom and we see our security huddled on one side of the campus and not patrolling rolling especially during passing period or right after passing period the bell rings and we see all that cuz after the first 10 minutes of class where you're allowed to use the restroom and we see a lot of kids in the restroom still they're still in there they're smoking and stuff so us seeing our security huddled somewhere else and not patrolling the areas they're supposed to be in was a concerned Grace to them um Mr Castillo answered it with um he'll raise our concerns to them um but there's one part I didn't like about this meeting which was towards the end um we reached the end of our meeting and our ambassadors reached all their concerns and we

100had nothing else to share and he said he asked us if we all had our IDs and which was fine and so we shared that yes we do we showed our IDs and he followed up with they took a jab at us why not took a jab at them we're on the same field now I didn't like that personally and I got feedback from our ambassadors they didn't like that because as an admin that's not professional and I understand asking us for ID cuz we're on campus but when you're talking like that to students who are voicing their concerns about the safety of their school it's not right and Dr Williams was there he didn't address it at all so it's something that I would like to share with the board because I didn't see

101it as right and my colleagues didn't see as right which is something I need a voice higher um and is why I'm saying it now um um so I hope this is something that gets attention it's something that you guys follow up with even if it's like having a sit down with just them but as long as it's being addressed with them um now on an opposite side the young women empowerment Club has been invited to a feminist majority Foundation um for their commitment to social and political activism the national young feminist leadership conference is taking place in DC March 28 to 31st of this year and I can tell you they're very excited they're hoping this goes through they're very excited they've been committed all year they have meetings all the time they're they're

102staying for long hours and they're really working to get this done making sure it goes through and from what I hear it's one of their first big field trips if it gets past so they're really excited to see how far this goes um and then I'm really glad to hear I got a presentation today about lcap I'm really glad to hear that if I understood correctly lafa will soon be getting an after school program or it's looking that way I'm really excited to see that there's some um programs going out to laa because it's something that the trustee this year has been pushing out that um it's something that she wishes uh gets inputed so it's something I'm glad to see that they're hearing the students and it's something they're getting feedback into and then

103I'd like to show appreciation for the red cards that got passed out um that showed our rights when ice comes and everything I know some kids like those they have them on the back of their phone cases so I I'd like to say thank you for those not a wrap minor report thank you thank you I stated Dr sparza will look into some of those other items um board member reports uh Communications uh request for uh other meetings uh Mr Gonzalez you want to go ahead and start us off I have no report Mr Co Mr ad good evening everyone thank you for coming out uh we heard a lot of public comment we we uh we know that these are tough times but uh you know it's also uh as as a board it's

104important that we put the district on a right path to sustainability and make sure that we have funding to for our students our families and and those that are within our district um I got a chance to uh see some of the school sites that have been uh that have new playgrounds and so I just want to thank staff for um those those new playgrounds they they you know the kids are happy that that they have green grass to to run on and they have these amazing amazing uh Park structures they they they look like in big parks now um so thank you to staff for for that um I also got a chance to go to laia High School uh walk around um you know I'd like to commend uh Mr for the work

105that he's doing La Familia uh I talked to uh some students really quickly about their experience at La Familia and they like that small just uh 250 students there they like that small environment and are really excelling so um I know our student trusty ask for new tables and I know that you know we have budget constraints but I did go by there and you know see that they also need new lunch tables at some point um but uh other than that I'd like to um just uh once again I thank everybody that's here thank everybody that came public comment it's important and we we are working together to make sure that that we see this District through the these difficult times thank you nothing further Mr President M gcia thank you to everyone who

106was here earlier today thank you for everyone who stayed this long I know this is a long meeting and it's been a doozy um thank you to everyone who's reached out to us via email sell I mean text messages phone calls back and forth to people uh we hear you and all of your concerns um this is our worst case scenario and there's no going around that it's never easy to make Cuts like this every single person who was in here talk talking to us is part of our Learning Community I know and I've seen firsthand how you work with our all of our students all of the parents I mean just going in to ask a question about my own son I see the students go and they know every single person in the

107district office every single person and they're so confident they you can tell they feel safe and seen because our staff has such a beautiful con connection to our students I can't say that one of you is worth more to our students than the other it's it's an unfathomable um feat that we have here it's not easy at all I don't like it I can't change the past I can only work with what's in front of me and unfortunately we have a very steep uh timeline with rcoe even more steep than the Rifts unfortunately and I don't like it I don't like that it's so much money in one year uh I would have preferred it was separated so it doesn't feel like such a huge impact so none of this is lost on me um

108I don't like hearing that even now before the riffs have even beneficial we're losing talent talent that's going to be very difficult to to replace I don't want any of you to go anywhere you have a connection to our students they love you our parents love you and I hope that you can sit through this discomfort and see how many of you we can save cuz honestly I know that the list shows riffs but there is an option for for many of you to be saved and I hope that that's the case please work with your labor unions and secure those positions I have to say that it's a possibility to ref you but it's definitely in your hands to mitigate that please um push for language for ratios if some of you don't have

109that language push for it it's a safeguard for yourselves and it's a safeguard for the district so do that work with each other get that language so that we don't so that we have a bigger parameter around us right um I know that there's a lot of talk about cutting but we do still have very strong funding streams we do have I heard prop 28 money our um EXO o p money right all of this money we are still going to get all of these funding streams what we're going to do now is push ourselves to be as creative as we possibly can to make sure that we're not losing programming for our students um in some cases we may be able to even provide more funding and what my push is is that this

110funding for this year students is spent on this year students that we're not on this constant backtracking I want to make sure that we're providing as much as we can because our students deserve that so it's not easy I don't like it as I've said if it is in this very difficult process possible to trust the process what we're going to vote on is the absolute worst case scenario my hope is that we're not going that far um because I know that it's absolutely detrimental people that are on this list we absolutely need to function at our school site so please please trust the process hang in there I know it's uncomfortable but we won't know for several months how many of you we can save so if you can work with that and work

111with us I don't want to lose any of you um as far as what our student representative spoke to I don't like the sound of the back and forth with security um our students are there in a in a particular capacity but I think that was the way it sounds it was unprofessional and hopefully we we get that worked on um my heart breaks for for where we are but the only way forward is to make these difficult decisions so please please we thank you for all of your input continue to have it we're listening thank you m ttis thank you president uh for that thank you for everyone for your comments we do take that to heart when we go back and discuss you know what the concerns are for the community and we

112have to remember that you know I myself am part of the community my kids go to these schools and they also are going to be affected by uh whatever happens you know there services that they're using that you're talking about my kids are also there I'm not a person that's disconnected so you know it's hard for me to see that you know what am I what are my kids going to what are they going to do without these services so it it you know it hits my heart with my kids that are in the same situation using these services that may or may not be available but when we're looking at the concerns and hearing the input from the community um I don't know if anyone has looked at what the California has to offer

113when I looked and I did my research on the school Coachella Valley there's a website called the school accountability report card and when I look at that in the past 5 to 10 years Coachella Valley School District was coming up we went from a low rate of graduation English learning mathematics we're up to past 50% of meeting or exceeding our um you know achievement rates it's called achievement rates so we're almost 50 and then Co hit and then we went down English learner went down to 3% meet or exceed the achievement rate math went down to 7% but one year after covid two years after covid we brought that up to 30% English learning within the last two years of covid math came up to past 50% again so we bounced back after covid and

114and I think that had to do with the funding that we were uh awarded we were able to get the programs we're able to get the students back on track with the staff everything that we are we're talking about we're going to missing out we're going to be missing out now and I think that's the concern but I think it's just a test of time that I I I liked what Mr Dale I think it's Westman said to negotiate and then see where we are within the year and I think that's a good take right to look at where we are now uh probably take a hit just like we did with covid but we're going to bounce back we're going to uh be able to advocate for initiatives and funding we're going to be

115able to um like I said just bounce back and I think these programs will be back if even if we have to you know look at sparing some of them for a little bit but you know again it's just something that a lot a lot of the programs throughout the state are going to just like what was said earlier and I know that a lot of the community was saying that the Board needs to be held accountable well all politicians need to be held accountable every single one of the politicians need to be held accountable and for the school board for every politician there is a recall system there's a recall procedure and if you go to the Secretary of State for the State of California and look up recall there is a system where

116you can petition and remove board members and it's also in the Coachella Valley board policy bylaw number 9223 when you're talking about failing vacancies if you petition to get a refall recall so um I'm just putting it out there it's we're being transparent and I think we're going to be more transparent in the financial in the financial um realm as far as where we get funding how that funding is uh spent and um I called for uh the board to be very transparent on the spending of all the awards and I think we're going to start uh very soon probably the next meeting or so maybe the meeting after that with the superintendent has a plan now to be transparent on all the awards and I think that's the misinformation that goes out to The

117Community is that everyone thinks that we have funding from this source and this source and this source and it it can't be co-mingled if we get money for um English Learners it has to be spent on that it can't be spent on anything else so and that's just one example so there are several cases of awarding agencies where we get funding and I think that's what needs to be promulgated to the community so that you understand where we are and then where we're going to be within the next year and now we're going to bounce back board member pass good night everyone um thank you for being here so nothing that I say will make the decisions and the impacts of the decisions any better for any of you for any of us probably definitely

118not for me um we are in this difficult um situation and I was in Mr Thomas's um seat in 2018 when I got appointed and my first meeting I was handed a notebook by our then superintendent about all the cuts that needed to be made right and that was um exactly I mean 2018 till now um around this time January February and um there's been reference about well we knew this we knew this yeah I mean in 2018 again was my first vote and it was a difficult vote and I I made the vote based on the information that I had in front of me because that's the best that I can do right um and um having reviewed and then less than two years from those decisions Co happened and then all of the

119focus and attention went there right and here we are it it caught up to us and again um this doesn't justify this doesn't soften um the cuts that we're making and um and I do want to appreciate everyone who comes out and who came out back then and who continues to come up here to tell us what you're seeing how it's impacting you um and I want to think um particularly I couldn't reference and address everyone who spoke and that I I was like no in my head and you know yeah cuz many of you and um Mr I think it was elisondo um who gave us like a very balanced analysis right it's not one thing or it's the other it's not just numbers there are things that need to be improved in our

120district um one of the things that U Mr Thomas stord is just referenced now in terms of the things that we've um asked the superintendent to do in terms of having the controls in place so that we know exactly right like how are money is being spent and where that is going and that um I'm looking forward to receiving from Dr esparta that list that lists all our funding sources and where we are right like and that that's a public document that that's something that's presented to the board so that we can know ahead of time where we are with our money and not just us but that there is a public discourse right about hey I noticed that in this grant you over spent or in this grant you funder spent and what's happening

121I mean I think that's those are the types of things that it's important for everybody to know and um and so I look forward to receiving um that and having that being implemented um so again thank you um for being here and I mean my commitment is to make the decision again with what I have in front of me given the the circumstances we're in and um to make sure that we are putting those things in place so that we're not here again and uh I I feel confident that that's um what I'm going to do and that that's what we're committing to doing so thank you again for all of you coming and um thank you for um our unions who are sitting um with our team and are negotiating um I mean that's

122that's the path forward um so again um thank you Mr K if I if I may I on uh Miss boss's final comment I know we have Union representation I understand there's going to be some uh some work done tomorrow in negotiating I challenge uh the union and staff to to come up with a solution to save many of the jobs that uh were being talked about a lot of the people that showed up today I think there's an opportunity to start working on language uh that that comes up with an amount of hours that we could afford and and hopefully we can salvage a lot lot of a lot of jobs in those discussions tomorrow Tuesday Yeah Tuesday vice president Vargas yeah um well thank you I want to start off by thanking Lynette

123um you know for taking the Having the courage to speak up and um you know it's unfortunate that you had to experience that um so thank you uh thank you for modeling you know what's good um you know to speak up for us right um I do want to thank everybody who came out tonight to provide public comment um you know your voices are are important right and I appreciate the time and effort that everyone has taken to to come here tonight um so a lot to be said um to this day and over all the last several months my priority has been to focus on addressing the fiscal challenges uh of our district and really meeting the needs of our of our school Community our students and and staff right um we're facing significant

124challenges it's our responsibility as board members to ensure that uh we're made making decisions in the best interest of students and the community right um you know leadership is about setting priorities making tough decisions and standing up for what's right um you know our uh Mission as an educational institution right is to provide quality education uh through shared responsibility and a safe supportive environment for all students and um you know I um had a lot of time to really reflect and think about you know um some incidents over the weekend right as public officials I understand that we don't necessarily have uh the privilege to privacy that maybe others do um you know I recently became aware that I was followed um you know and maybe it was part of an effort to discredit me

125um you know and I I asked my colleagues to maybe condemn and speak up to stalker-like behavior right um I don't know that any elected um or not uh deserves to feel you know threatened or intimidated simply because we have a passion to serve and as a woman you know it was uh definitely difficult to know that I'm being followed right and so you know it just doesn't quite feel right um you know Sally some of my colleagues are raising daughters have strong uh independent sisters who just like me uh often navigate very male dominated spaces and you know for no one to acknowledge that it's difficult um you know the reality is that I was followed at late at night uh in the context I'm not sure that there's any context that would make

126that acceptable um you know and so I think for me it's we get back to the work right um so in my board report uh last week I had there was a series of executive orders from the federal Administration that put a number of our programs uh that are F federally funded within our district at risk and one of those programs is our free and red reduced program uh among others right uh directly impacting more than 90% of our school um our students um and although these programs uh these orders were resented resented um you know it should serve as a warning for us uh we really need to take practic steps uh to work and strengthen our relationships with our federal elected officials uh to continue to ensure that those resources are being brought

127to our district um and really Safeguard uh those fundings for our most vulnerable uh student and families uh on Monday evening um late at night in Northshore I also attended a meeting with residents uh families from ICU who raised concerns again about our transportation uh about our public uh bus stops um or our bus stops right and although um you know um it doesn't necessarily some of the issues that they raised don't all pertain to um or we don't might not have the authority to to resolve ourselves um I think it's important to maybe hold a 2 by two with our Riverside County counterparts and maybe Identify some ways um to address some of these concerns maybe possible uh grant opportunities that we can share that responsibility right um some of the things that they

128brought up are are concerning right it's about their safety and um I think we we need to try to make those efforts um and have those discussions um you know I tonight uh I mean we're making very difficult decisions right and like it was shared earlier there's nothing that we could we could say right um these decisions are going to impact a number of our staff members across our district uh these choices are are never easy um I mean when I started I I was also ripped as a classified employee back in the day um but we need to remain focused on our long-term responsibility to our district right um uh over the last several months we've we've heard a number of comments and that included tonight right comments from our staff asking us as

129a board to take responsibility and I believe that our sta our staff is really looking for us to step up as leaders and to hold ourselves accountable uh for the decisions that we made regardless of who followed through or didn't right um I think there's uh a number of us um and I I'll say myself I I've already made the personal choice to minimize my travel um travel costs uh attendance to events and conferences to ensure that there's no additional cost incurred to our district but I really really truly believe that we need to do more um you know as board members we receive $400 stiens um and that includes our health benefits right um and the stien helps cover some of the cost of our travel and time and um you know I think

130although it's a minimal in the con context of our financial deficit I think we really need to Le by example right um so I'm hoping that our colleagues can um you know well I'm asking that we adopt a resolution that at the next board meeting we freeze our monthly stien um I don't know that it's about the amount I think it's about leadership and if we are asking our staff to carry the burden of the financial cutbacks I think that as board members we really should be willing to do the same and we were asked to do that tonight um I hope that my colleagues will step up and carry the weight of our financial challenges along with our district um staff right we really need to be focused on the issues uh take fiscal

131responsibility our student safety and the well-being of our district and um you know it's Moment Like These that um it's going to really show and demonstrate like who like what leadership is really about right um I think for me the last thing I'll say is I REM I remain committed to priority iing and serving our students our families and our staff and you know continue to meet my obligations um as I've always done I'll seek legal counsil when necessary and um you know really advocate for what is right and um you know do make the right decision right for a family so I thank you and I um you know I I'm eager to get back to work and and do the work for our community which they expect us to do yeah thank you

132thank you uh vice president v g it's a u a setting that uh you not have to worry about being stalked and being followed and as probably many of us probably have been and we just haven't noticed or some of us don't care um if they follow you around and uh I I think it's sad and again unfortunately um I can say it's something here locally it's something that's happening uh across the country you look at the things that are happening the the the attacks that are being made on our institutions uh they're talking about dissolving the Department of Education so they can uh you know eliminate all these other things for us and so those are things as you mentioned with the school lunch program um there are things that are going to affect

133us and these are National things but the attitude and and the vit vitri and the lies and the you know the that you know people just going on TV saying lies and and you cannot compete with that you know people getting funded by special interest groups uh to run campaigns against certain people you you can't fight that you can't fight social media with the truth and it's happening across our country people are are just it's just hard you know it's it's it's you get the the truth unfortunately uh you know though saying that the the LIE will get around the block 20 times before the truth even gets out the door so and and unfortunately that's not only happening here but that's happen across and and unfortunately uh I think you know the people who

134did this to you uh personally have no shame um they basically are cowards Who hide in the shadows as most people who do this stuff online refuse to put their names I'll always put my name to anything I say so uh in that sense I I do uh I I I agree with you I support you and and and hopefully whoever is doing it will knock it off I doubt it but hopefully it'll knock it off um again I also want to thank everybody who came out tonight I've always said this in the past whether you come to support me come to oppose me to come and yell at me whatever the fact that you took the time to come out here should be recognized and commended um for getting involved so I do appreciate

135everybody coming out here and and um uh and and talking about that um you know I I've looked at this plan as everybody else here there's parts of it that I truly hate I truly detest programs that I fought to to create to put here over years and years and years and we finally got them uh you know now we're cutting them um you know to take something out or to put something back in you have to take something out and it's you know again but I truly believe and I've said this before yes there's a lot of things of who didn't do what I've said this before and I'll say it again at the end of the day and I won't speak for my colleagues I am responsible as a board member for everything

136that happens in the District whether I did it or directed it or didn't direct it we're still responsible I am again I'll never speak for my my colleagues they can they can speak for themselves but in looking at this plan um again there's a lot of bad things in here that I truly detest but one of the things that I will have to say is that unless we fundamentally change the way we do things in this district and I mean across the board I mean in all the little spaces and all the little silos and all the little unless we fundamentally change that I believe we'll be back here in 5 years the same thing and as was mentioned we had a report it's called the figment report from 2018 2019 it's basically we're doing

137another one today and it's going to say exactly the same thing it said back then we're overstaffed we have to start cutting back we have to hold people accountable and to do it unfortunately Co hit and we got lots of money that we're able to just kind of paper we're over that we're all good we're all fine but we're back to 2018 2019 we're back to where we were and yes that is the responsibility of this board whether you were on the board in 2018 or you just got elected it's now your respons our responsibility I believe so unless the other things come with that and that and I know people are going to get mad but that means how we process things how we do things our collective bargaining agreements all those things have

138to be looked at to make sure that this doesn't happen again because again every so many years it seems to be happening to us when I got back on in 2014 we're in the middle of one we solved it for a while came back in 2018 Co hit now it's back again we have to fundamentally change the way we do things or we're just going to keep repeating over and over and over and over it'll take a few years Co bought us a few years you know but we do this we get back on track in five years if we don't change the way we do things we're going to be right back here so and you'll all come out and yell and you all be you know we'll be cutting jobs again and we'll

139doing this we have to do better um uh I I'm encouraged that our superintendent we've been giving her Direction and she's been brave enough to actually start doing this and you know a lot of people are angry at her too because she's following the direction of the board and again it's easy to get mad at our superintendent but remember everything she does is at our Direction so if you want to get angry come back to us so again um we'll see uh my my thing has stayed the same I believe that this vote should be unanimous and if it's not unanimous then we shouldn't vote for it uh that goes back to my my thing we are all in it together or we're not right we're either all in it together or not and the

140vote in a few minutes we'll we'll test that theory uh if if we're all in it together so we keep saying that but we'll find out in a few minutes um thank you all for coming and with that Dr sparle your report good evening I want to thank everyone who came up to speak uh I truly appreciate that you're expressing uh your concerns please know that uh again reducing staff is a difficult decision as it directly impacts many of the individuals who contribute to the success of our programs here in the district um and I I want you to know that I'm focused on tangible outcomes I'm making decisions that strengthen the foundation of the district and as your superintendent I'm taking the responsibility to make difficult decisions when needed and always keeping the long-term

141success of the district and of our students like her as our primary focus and so please know that that's something that we need to do and um we will be able to to make some adjustments as we move forward but as uh Miss Garcia board member Garcia stated earlier this is something um that is worst case scenario at at this time and so we look forward to uh sitting at the table with our uh CCA partners and making sure that some of those changes um can take place uh immediately again um I want to thank rcoe for being here with us I also want to thank fmat who spent the week here uh with us and gave uh some suggestions and guidance and and asked a lot of questions in regards to where we're going

142and basically you know commended us and said as long as the board and the work with the board uh stays on course we will be fine in the out years as well so I I want to commend them for coming in and staying so long a and again asking those courageous questions and looking at all our information we will be receiving a fmat report in between 6 to 8 weeks and it I they're going to come here publicly and uh give the results of the report uh here at the podium to the board and let us know where and how can we improve what structures are we currently putting in place and where do we need to go and so again I want to thank rcoe and fmat for being able to support us through

143all of this and so it's not a an easy decision uh to make to put these types of uh reductions together but as your superintendent taking the responsibility of moving forward for our students is what I need to do thank you all right thank you Dr Dr sparza item moving forward item six information presentation the CVUSD fiscal uh stabilization plan um this is just for information correct so unless anybody has any more questions on this I think we probably beat it to death but anybody have any questions seeing none the report is accepted uh item 7.1 Mr Boomer requesting approval of memorandum of understanding with the creative Club from tools to tomorrow motion I have a motion do I hear a second second I have a motion and a second any questions on this all

144those in favor I student trustee in favor all oppos motion carries item 7.2 uh Mr Michelson requesting approval excuse me of purchase of purchase with the esta for for site vehicle for La Familia High School motion a second I have a motion and a second any questions on this all those in favor I student truste in favor all those opposed motion carries item 8 8.1 um director thadis approval of the stabilization plan do I hear a motion a motion I have a motion do I hear a second I'll second I have a motion in a second any final questions all those in favor hi all those opposed sorry I did that on purpose student try fa motion carries unanimously item item 9.1 assistant assistant superintendent MTZ approval of resolution number 2025 d29 regarding certificated reductions

145or discontinuance of particular kinds of services uh deviating from the seniority order and establishing a tiebreaking criteria motion I have a motion do I hear a second second I have a motion and a second any questions on this seeing none all those in favor wait can can you explain that a little further for me excuse me can you explain that a little further for me sure like a little more detail the resolution outlines the positions that will be Rift that are certificated which is uh teachers um um nurses um anything that falls with the certificated uh license and then um we do do a seniority list based on number of years working and then there's also a tiebreaker where we have some shortages in certain areas and that tiebreaker will help us um determine um

146if there's any exceptions to the seniority thank you okay all those in favor hi hi student trusty I'd like to St sure all those opposed motion carries item 9.2 assistant superintendent MTZ approval of resolution number 20253 regarding layoff of classified uh classified management and classified confidential Personnel due to lack of work and or funds do I hear a motion so move I have a motion do I hear a second second any questions seeing none all those in favor I student trustee in favor all those opposed motion carries item 10 consent calendar all matters listed under the consent calendar are considered by the board to be routine and will be acted upon in one motion there will be no discussion of these items prior to the time the board considers the motion unless members of the

147board or staff request specific items to be discussed and or removed from the consent calendar in which event the items will be considered separately the superintendent assistant superintendent of Educational Services assistant superintendent of business and finance and assistant superintendent of Human Resources recommend the approval of all consent calendar items do I hear a motion a motion to approve the consent calendar respecting any board member wanting to pull an item do I hear second I'll second go ahead and I have a comment not that it's going to so I don't know I don't need to pull it cuz I'm not going to but I have a comment on ask who wants anything pulled and then I'll let you make a comment can I pull 13.5 just want to vote on a separate 13.5 okay anything else

148anybody else no I'm actually going to pull 14.2 part 10 items 3 4 and 5 and 14.3 part 10 item one okay we have a motion in a second um B you want to make your comment yes um I'm seeing the agreements here as we always see every year for you seeing the Tennis Gardens for our um graduations the Tennis Gardens are like open right I know that um Acer Arena has been holding some graduations I went to a graduation there from um College of the Desert it's indoors we don't have to be worried about either being elements so hot that everyone's you know dehydrated or um that it gets windy and what not as it typically does so I just wanted to mention that because I I had thought about it but I hadn't

149brought it up in the past that's a good idea I I can respond to that we did look into that because of those reasons but it was $555,000 per day and that doesn't include um like the vendors the setup chairs nothing so that was just for the use of facilities how much is it uh compared to we um um tennis garden has always been working with us this year they um Extended their gratitude I I should say so they're not only giving us $25,000 per per school but they're also paying the stage which is $177,000 they worked with the vendors um to make sure to lower the cost and that gave us a savings of $3,400 so in total um last year we paid $80,000 right now we're looking at $47,000 total w a savings

150of $ 34,000 understanding the fiscal predicament we okay it's expensive yeah I sorry um seeing no other comments all those in favor I I student justy favor all those opposed motion carries uh 13.5 I believe just wanted to vote on it separately I took a campaign donation from somebody connected to a SE Farms so want to disclose that for the record you want to vote on the separately okay fine do I hear a motion a motion do I hear a second second have a motion in a second all those in favor I student trustee in favor any oppose and I'll abstain I obstain oh I'm sorry any extensions I motion carries six okay my items are and Personnel reports uh they Personnel items so there's no discussion I just want to vote on them separately

151as well what numbers were those again 14.2 two part 10 items 3 four and five they're the last ones on the uh Personnel report 3 four and five 3 four and five yeah 3 four and five M can your motion to approve item want to do all three or do you want to do one at a time we should do one at a time whatever you desire all right I have a motion to approve item number three mhm do I hear a second second any comments all those in favor I I student trustee in favor any oppos I motion carries 61 uh item four do I hear a motion a motion I have a motion do I hear a second a second have a motion in a second all those in favor I I student

152truste in favor all those opposed I item five do I hear a motion a motion I have a motion do I hear a second thank you I have a motion in a second all those in favor hi all those o I'm sorry stent truste in favor all those opposed I motion carry 61 uh next item 14.3 part 10 item [Music] one a motion I have a motion do I hear a second I have Motion in a second all those in favor I I I I student Justin in favor all those opposed I motion carries 6 to1 that is all I have uh no reason for close SE good good right can I have a motion toour a motion a second I have a motion and a second all those in favor I I student truste

153in favor one was the S I apologize a change in the agenda they added the item was not 14.3 was 14 you might have to be I'm sorry I'm sorry I actually haven't called uh the item that I had pulled was not 14.3 it was 14.1 oh it was yeah simply I don't know if you want to revote on that or do you just want to Simply go back and say it was 14.1 sure well I was are we good with that you want to have a revote or just I just got the numbers confused okay one and so was three four and five on 14.1 14.1 and the 14 sorry about that I got they added that other one and I got them mixed up that wasn't my fault my fault all right um

154having a vote motion uh all in favor I hold on I need to open the document again I post everything wants to see the it yeah it's the last one on that document yeah I apologize that was my mistake it was the Personnel reports 10 13.3 yes that one we I my mistake I did not want to pull that one I wanted to pull 14.1 that for the 14.1 was the three that we voted against or we you approved and then 14.2 was the one that was by itself 14 very last one [Music] we can go back and revote if you're more comfortable or if we just make the change in the number so items you pulled out 1 2 3 4 and 5 no part 10 3 4 and 5 the items were correct

155the numbers at the top it was 14.1 and 14.2 and the Motions taken one by one were to approve the recommendation right correct okay and the other one was the same so again I ask are we good with that simple change that we did the numbers I'm good with it on what I motioned we're good okay do you make that correction in the minutes uh Mar and then make sure that it reflects the vote was for the 14.1 and 14.2 apologize for that I got my numbers wrong and just I mean I'm curious that these were pulled out because everybody voted and it's to do what's already here corre Jo we wanted to V all right thank you everyone sorry for the confusion at the end that my fault uh have a rest good rest

156of your evening 10 10:05 uh not too bad thank you all

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.