001good evening everyone I want to call this meeting to order at uh 5:33 p.m. uh Miss Boss would you lead us into the Pledge of Allegiance please ready begin I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you thank you can we get a roll call please yes sir president joyaa Jr here vice president Joselyn Vargas clerk Sylvia pass herein Redondo present Valerie Garcia present Jesus Gonzalez student trustee Roxana Medina present thank you thank you all we're going to move into recognitions item 2.1 recognition of questbridge national college match scholarship recipient uh deser Mirage I believe that is missell who's doing that [Music] missell good evening everyone my student is running a
002little late can I come back so that she can receive her certificate not yet okay thank you yes okay moving on hopefully you should get here before we go to close session uh moving on item 3.1 close session public comments this is an opportunity for members of the public to address the governing board regarding any close session items within the board subject matter jurisdiction please complete a request to address the governing board form and hand it to the recording secretary speakers will be limited to 3 minutes per person with a maximum of 20 minutes per each subject matter I have two I only have two so we're going to go ahead and go with that um agenda item 3.1 uh Dale Weissman csca I saw good after good evening I'm Dale wisman from CSA I've
003been the labor rep in the coach Valley for 21 years been in education for 32 years and I was your labor rep for 14 years and I am going to serve as your labor rep for the classified staff until we hire uh uh some more staff out here we are in unprecedented times to our knowledge never in the history of Southern California as a classified bargain unit of 1,200 people suffered more than half of the cut 2third of the cut in comparison to the teachers when we were only onethird of the budget of the teachers and the management combined that means that the cuts are falling nine times harder on classified and that's just the math on it than they are any other group Riverside County has come in and they've got something fundamentally wrong
004and I want to encourage in each and every board member to hear me nobody in rcoe has been elected by the voters of Eastern Riverside County in your school district boundaries to make decisions you have that is a constitutional right and we will be reminding Statewide as an organization All Counties including rcoe including contact with anybody in Sacramento up to an including the superintendent of State schools that Rivers saww County doesn't make decisions for you they don't get to determine what you're going to do with your significant economic Reserve now we understand there's budget issues here classifi didn't create any of them we're not going to put 200 people out on the street we don't do that we have an expired contract you have a complaint at the UN at the public employment Relations Board
005for a serious unfair Labor practice which has gone unaddressed for months and will go to hearing soon if it's not settled um you you're picking a fight with a classified service and assuming your schools are going to open or that the morale won't be destroyed by the time you actually get to September and octo and August to open your schools we don't have a contract in place there's something else going on here too I've been in desert for almost 30 years I'm a fluent Spanish speaker my wife is a fluent Spanish speaker I grew up in the central valy in a town just like this outside of Modesto California and I've experienced and watched this my whole life where the county seat takes action and uses you as The Whipping Boy out here for politics
006I watched it when we lost the California Supreme Court case for Bilal instruction remember that one I lost it the first time we had a bankruptcy remember that one and I want you guys to know that there's institutional racism going on within the County of Riverside and they're using you as an example and we need to fight back against the County of Riverside for the kind of draconian cuts that you guys are having we'll see at the negotiations table please make decisions for your District because you're elected to do that not the county thank you thank you up next uh item 3.5 uh Billy Franco I don't know if you're here for the school district or CCAA School District huh School District uh good evening president aunia school board members Dr asara and extended cabinet
007my name is Billy Franco I am the school district's curriculum resource technician my duties include ordering of curriculum materials for the whole District as well as providing support to the instructional media assistants who are in every library at each of our sites I come to you tonight to share some information about the effects of the district proposing to put the the imas at 11 months and 6 hours a day as of now our instructional media assistant our imas work 8-hour shifts over a 12-month period while we understand Financial constraints of the district faces it is crucial to consider the significant impact that proposed reductions to the ima's hours and work year will have on both their workload and more importantly on the students they serve imas are not simply responsible for checking out books and
008devices they play a pivotal role in organizing and distributing curriculum to all students enrolled in our district they also provide research support run Book Fairs complete District required inventories submit device repair tickets and ensure the availability of new and replacement devices for students and staff with these duties condensed into a six-hour workday there will be severe limitations on their ability to perform these tasks effectively especially when libraries will only be open during instructional instructional hours this proposed schedule change means libraries will no longer be able to uh be available to students before school which is a critical resource especially in extreme weather conditions nor will they have access to school to complete projects after school for many students especially those from families without reliable transportation this will significantly impact their ability to engage in academic
009activities outside of regular school hours furthermore the imas will face difficult choices during the short their short shortened work day they'll be required to decide whether to prioritize assisting students with Library tasks or addressing concerns from parents regarding lost or damaged items this divide and attention will ultimately lead to the neglect of students at C uh critical times additionally this the need for 45 minute uh 45 minute break every day will disrupt Library Services during students lunch periods further reducing their access to Library resources during school hours if the district is determined to reduce the ima's work day to 6 hours and their contract length to 11 months the impact on their of their on their ability to perform their essential duties will be even more pronounced the annual inventory process which is critical to
010maintain an organized and effective system will likely require imas to disrupt classroom instruction in order to complete these tasks further impacting student learning on behalf of the of the imas I urge you to engage in further discussions with the district's negotiation team to fully assess the ramifications of these proposed cuts the well-being and academic progress progress of our students are at stake and we must Ensure that their needs remain a priority if any further clarification is needed regarding the specific duties of imas I am available to meet with you in person to provide additional insights into ima's responsibilities thank you for your time and consideration thank you uh that is all I have for a close session um let's go back and do the recognition of principal so good evening Board of Education Dr espar
011and Community here present I'm Elizabeth soell proud principal at DES Raj high school I'm here to introduce ER NE she has been selected as a recipient of a full fouryear scholarship from Quest Bridge National College match program this prestigious award will allow Erica to pursue her dream of becoming a neurosurgeon with plans to attend the University of Notre Dame in 2025 Erica is one of the 2016 27 High School seniors Nationwide to receive the questbridge match scholarship in the third one in the history of Des Maraj high school out of more than 25,500 applicants only 2627 were matched with top tier colleges and universities through questbridge each receiving a full scholarship and one of them is our student our DM and our cbus student questbridge is a nonprofit organization dedicated to connecting High achieving low-income
012students with top colleges and universities they provide the students with not only a full scholarship but also a supportive Community to help them Thrive throughout their their college career Erica's academic Excellence is exemplified by maintaining a 4.0 GPA throughout all of her years of high school she has also dedicated herself to community service leadership and extrac extracurricular involvement including serving as a president of the buente program participating in the med ambiente club and serving as the desert Town Hall Ambassador for deser Maraj High School these experiences have not only contributed to her education but have also shaped her as a compassionate leader I am incredibly proud of Erica as she is a true representative of our DM students her hard work and dedication had paid off and we couldn't be more happy for what her
013future lies ahead okay much felices [Applause] um I just want to say um first off I'm sorry for getting here a little late um but um I feel like I wouldn't have wanted to be here without my mom anyways um she's really like a huge inspiration for me to try harder um especially with how like hard she works um I'm really proud of her too for being able to make it here and also I'm really proud of like how far she's come because I know um she's she's done a lot for us like especially like for me and my siblings right for being a good role model and for being able to provide for us and even then like having enough time to like take us to where we need to go um but yeah
014like honestly that's the few words I really want to say is just thank you to my mom Myas um I really do love and appreciate her for all that she does for me and yeah would like to dedicate like all that I do that all that I do like in my school life to her because again she does help me strive to become a better person and to become like somebody in my community like a change I want to I want to see a change so that my I want to I want to be the change in my community that I hope to see in the future but yeah um not sure that I say something [Applause] principal C she could come up for a a picture over here with the board please M pictures
015up here with the board [Music] I wonder e okay seeing nothing else um may I have a motion to go into close session have a motion do I hear a second second have a motion in a second all those in favor I student truste hi okay I we will be back at 7:30 7:30 thank you all right we're going to go ahead and get started we had a motion in a second to return into Open Session that motion carried 70 um item 4.2 announce uh action not taken in close session uh yes the board took the following action and close session approved expulsion case number 25-6 for Clear Rand statement motion was made by trusty Gonzalez seconded by trusty Vargas motion carried and uh the board took action during close session under item not sure
016what item um this one sorry do we have to read that yeah um the board V voted to approve the January 23rd 2025 10-day settlement offer uh 20 USC section final uh I uh settlement agreement and general release resolving a matter for parent oah case number 202 411 0491 on this 23rd day of January 20 uh 2025 motion was made by trusty Arondo seconded by trusty Vargas a motion carried 70 that's it that's it okay um item 4.3 approval of agenda submitted we will be tabling item which one is it item 7.1 to next board meeting do I hear a motion a motion have a motion do I hear a second second have a motion in a second all those in favor I all those opposed motion carries 60 uh okay written Communications I think
017board members receive written Communications I got mine earlier today um and we're going to move on to our student trustee welcome uh it's a student trustees report thank you president Akuna um my name is Roxanna and I am La familia's student trustee um so I'm going to be starting with the board report oh I'm sorry oh I'm sorry I missed that wishful thinking on my part right uh I'm sorry 5.1 board notification request to address the board um the public comments let me get that item up I apologize uh introductory comments and requests to address the board on items on the adopted agenda and items not on the adopted agenda will be considered from the audience at this time please complete a request to address the governing board form and hand it in to the
018recording secretary speakers will be limited to 3 minutes per person with the maximum of 20 minutes to each subject matter Additionally the person making the request should State his or her name and the name of the organization or group represented please be advised that the board is not always at Liberty to answer questions right away and state law prohibits the board from taking any action on items not listed on the agenda we we'll start with um I think it's Alysia VI dois I'm sorry I always mess up your last name I know um before you start it is there a reason why our monitors aren't working today yes only because I can't see the clock you go ahead hi my name is Alisia V and I work uh in Cesar chave school I'm an structure
019media system- library I want to express my feelings and uh I want to take you back 18 years ago I got my positions it was 11 months and 8 hours we started working in August and the students came in September we have time to set up for the students at that time we only have three workbooks and three textbooks and a little bit of equipment as the years went by they added more workbooks textbooks and more equipment more equipment to our job description well guess what we started in August the students came in August I didn't have time to do all my stuff example I came on on on the year 2017 I came here to the board and I told you that I had I explained to you that I have for 45 pallets
02045 pets to do it on the month that I was out July and they expecting us to do the the tees of the teachers by August 1st because they had training I came to you there were three board members Mr kuna Mr Gonzalez and Miss Bas one board member said send her help I didn't I came back and I said I did it a month without no pay a month without pay now going back two years ago we became 12 months in8 hours 12 months 8 hours because they added another department to us which is equipment anything above below 500 we need to tag it and put it into Destiny what you say well what is it it's iPads LCD projectors any is equipment we have to do it now I see that's 11 months
021or 6 months I mean six hours sorry 11 month to 6 hours think back I used to come to the board meetings and talk about my job you think I have time to do this if I start in August and students come in August do I have time this is going to affect our students yes not only students and staff I accept that there's a budget crisis or I don't know what it is but it is it is what it is but think about it make a decision does it affect the students or not ask yourself the question before you make a decision I understand where we are I hear it I read it thank you for listening thank you [Applause] uh next up is hila Castro on wellness [Applause] centers after that it's going
022to be Irma Rodriguez so if she wants to kind of move forward [Applause] oh good evening members of the board I'm Hilda Castro I'm here today to speak about the importance of keeping the wellness center open full-time personally I deal with dis um dis realization depression and anxiety I can tell you that these episodes don't happen on schedule emergencies are unpredictable and when they occur students need immediate access to help having the one Center open fulltime ensures the support is there when it's needed not just when it's convenient I went from being to scared to leave the um the house to during Sports traveling and speaking on TV about mental health in rural areas but I'm not just here speaking for myself I'm I'm speaking for the underclassman who will come after me these young
023students a May many of whom who are just beginning to deal with their own struggles with mental health house will be deeply affected if the W Center is not open full time they deserve the same opportunity and support and growth that I had and cutting the centers the one centers hours would take away from them the this one Center is not just a resource it's a Lifeline if we limit the availability we risk the well-beings of many students I urge you to um I urge you to keep it open all days of the week because um mental tell hold the crisis don't don't take days off and nether should our support systems thank youma Rodriguez herma Rodriguez followed by Evelyn sentano good evening everyone my name is Carolina Rodriguez and I'm here to talk about
024Wana centners Wana centers should always be fully staffed and available to students daily because crisises do not follow a schedule they can hit at any time personally the Desert Mirage Wana Center saved my life if it had not been open that day when I needed it most I would not be standing before you here today in a moment in a moment of intense pain and hopelessness I was able to walk into the Wana Center and find someone to talk to someone who truly listened and provided me with the help I needed the Wana Center was not just there for me in my D darkest moments it has been there every step of the way since my freshman year offering me support guidance and a safe space to process my struggles it has been My Sanctuary
025a place where I could report abuse admit myself harm and Suicidal Thoughts without judgment these conversations are not easy but that proves how the Wana Center is welcoming and made me feel safe to share my story this very place has given me hope and helped me heal I am eternally grateful for the Wana Center for being a part of my high school Journey especially for helping me find my voice and stand up for myself and others so I stand before you today asking you to keep all wellness centers open and available to students daily because mental health matters these centers are very preventative measures by limiting them students life or death situations are on the line they can save lives and I am living proof of that mental health matters and we must ensure that
026wellness centers are a constant presence in our schools to support all students whenever they need help they are not just a service they are a necessity thank you sentano is that correct and Then followed by Kevin Ortiz good evening sir us family my name is Evelyn Ceno and I am a 12th grade student at D marage high school over the past four years I have the privilege of benefiting from the Wess Center which has been an essential resource in my personal and academic growth the W Center has helped me overcome significant challenges including struggles with an IND disorder and navigating and complicated relationship with my father it had provided me a safe and supportive space where I could express my feelings without fear of or judgment knowing that I had a place to be heard
027and understood brought me immense comfort and allowed me to focus better in a class by releasing the emotions I had held in into for so long as I approach the end of my high school journey and watch my younger cousins begin theirs I cannot overstate the importance of keeping these centers open removing such a valid research may be a great disservice to the Future students who may need the same support as I received I respectfully urge you to consider maintaining all seven Wess centers for the better of our community and the well-being of the generations to come thank you for your time and thoughtful consideration sincerely EV s Uh Kevin Ortiz followed by Janelle McDonald oh good evening cbz board hello my name is Kevin Ortiz and I'm here to talk about how I feel
028about the wellness and I am someone who has the privilege of attending a school where I where if I feel overwhelmed or need a mental break I can schedule an appointment and talk to wonderful people who not only care for me but every single person it has really impacted me since my freshman year and I can give you so many reasons how it has shaped me into the person I am today if I could have had this support in middle school I know it would have been benefited me benefited a lot from it one of the challenges I have been able to overcome in the W Center is a Trauma from bullying and struggling with mental health like feeling I wasn't good enough and that I was failing my parents by not doing my best
029however the one center staff taught me that I'm supposed to do it for myself not for anyone else and I'm here to use my voice to ask you to keep the one Center in every school thank you for your time Janelle McDonald good evening s CVUSD family my name is Janelle McDaniel and I have the honor of serving the students at desra marage high school as a Wellness Center teacher I'm here tonight to address an issue that profoundly impacts the well-being and success of our students that propose reduction Wellness Center intervention Specialists commonly known as Wellness Center teachers CVUSD has been a Trailblazer in addressing student mental health in February of 2022 the First Wellness Center opened at Desert Mirage High School since then districts have expanded SE have expanded to seven wellness centers serving
030every middle and high school this Forward Thinking initiative has been recognized locally and nationally including being featured on matter of fact was sold it at O'Brien as well as a feature article in the Nea magazine to provide context National Data on youth mental health is alarming according to the CDC in 2023 40% of students reported persistent feelings of sadness and hopelessness 20% seriously considered attempting suicide and 9% reported making an attempt these numbers underscore the urgency of our work at Desert Mirage the need for support is undeniable in 2023 24 school year the wellness centers recorded 2,000 visits among those students 56 sided feelings of frustration overwhelm and anxiety 27 reported sadness loneliness and emptiness but wellness centers are more than just a refuge for mental health challenges many students seek support for Fears around
031immigration family crises and even basic needs like food and hygiene products with the help of local organizations we provided Essentials like sweatshirts socks menstrual products and snacks ensuring students feel supported and ready to learn I've witnessed firsthand these Services save lives I've sat with a student as she disclosed years of abuse to her parents and watched her as she bravely spoke her truth something she said she never would have done without the safety of the wellness center unfortunately stories like hers are not uncommon tonight you heard from some incredibly Brave students who are willing to speak to their struggles in order to help others but please know that hundreds of other students are just not ready to share sadly mental health still carries a heavy stigma wellness centers not only support mental health but also
032positively impact school culture at Desert Mirage a three-year comparison of fights between August and December shows a consistent decline in 2022 there were 87 fights during this period compared to just 35 fights this year a reduction of 52 fights this highlights the significant role wellness centers have played in promoting conflict resolution I understand you have some tough decisions to make but we have a responsibility to put students first and mental health is a foundation for strong academic Scholars I encourage all of you to please visit our wellness centers engage with our students and hear their stories firsthand before making any of these decisions thank you for your time and thoughtful [Applause] consideration uh next up is Juan armenta followed by um Brendan or Brenda Alvarez I'm sorry I can't read the Ju armenta hi my
033name is Brenda Alvarez I am a am I supposed to start already I'm sorry yeah go ahead I am a concerned parent CU I've been it's been brought to my attention that they're looking to cut nurses down I have a child with medical needs and I think that would be a huge effect alone last year um he basically has Type 1 diabet he's a type 1 diabetic and his first year was two years ago it was a huge transition for me in our family and having that support from the nurses those phone calls being answered really helped out but in those conversations with them you could hear the stress of them already not having enough staff which raises a bigger concern for me finding out that they might be facing some budget cuts on that
034side of you know the district so I'm just here as a parent to bring those concerns and maybe get some answers and some more transparency of why do we have those budget cuts I wasn't even aware what's going on until now so I think maybe most of more parents should be involved and that's a conversation I'll have with my family and parents that are bump into the district but with all that being said I just really ask you guys to take a look at that department they deal with a lot of serious medical needs and it could be a future lawsuit it could even cost you guys even more if there's mistakes being done because there's not actual certified Arns out there and that's pretty much it thank you uh next is uh Noel Diana
035uh followed by zamer friend friend I'm not sure what I'm sorry okay hi good evening um we're just passing out some um paperwork that we put in there a couple things that you'll see are some letters from concerned parents that were not able to be here and then some accurate numbers as to what we see and students that we um we Service uh so good evening my name is Noel Deana I am accompanied by my colleagues and concerned parents I am a registered nurse and a credentialed school nurse through the state of California we appreciate the attention of the board to the following matter I am here because I want to create Awareness on how essential the role of the credential school nurse is you will be given a proposal if you haven't already that
036suggests eliminating seven of the nine registered nurses that leaves two registered nurses overseeing the entire District now we understand that there is a dire need to make budget cuts however eliminating District registered nurses will be a huge huge impact to the health and well-being of our students and our staff as credential School nurses we oversee the health offices we train our office staff to be able to care for and act in emergency situations we train admin and security we train teachers to give medications on field trips we train our health Mobility aids to be able to care for our students with G tubes tracheostomies catheterizations and so on WE oversee our lvns and our heal techs at our school sites on a daily basis we teach our fourth graders about puberty we perform mandated vision
037and hearing screenings do Health assessments for IEPs ssts and 504s and case manage are medically fragile kiddos these are duties that only a credentialed school nurse can do in short a credentialed school nurse is essential for creating a safe healthy and inclusive environment where all students can succeed because as the saying goes healthy children learn better our combination of medical knowledge and understanding of the educational system should make us an Irreplaceable asset in our district please believe me when I say the work that we do is not able to be included in this three minute speech the district is proposing to replace bachelors and Master's educated credentialed Audiology certified nurses that specialize in the field of Education with essentially unspecialized Personnel this is unsafe practice it is a liability not only for the district but
038for our own professional licenses therefore if our students health and safety is a priority you will keep your District nurses and support staff thank you next uh next up is Zander French uh followed by Maya French just my name is Xander I am a seventh grader at Toro cam Middle School I have asthma ADHD autism and I have type 1 diabetes I am here to share why you should not have a big cut to the team of nurses that help keep me healthy and safe they make sure that my diabetes is in check I have no symptoms for my number being high and the nurse Miss Yoli helps me with that she changed her schedule so I could do Asis my asthma is scary because I can't tell that's acting up but miss Yoli knows
039it's acting up and has me do my puffer so in summary the nurses helped me feel like a normal kid if there's no trained nurses because I need a nurse to help me feel more normal so I need the nurses to be in my school so if you cut the nurses I would miss them and I would be worried because I wouldn't have the same help that I have now so please don't vote to cut down the [Music] nurses stay here with over so they can see talking to them are I supposed to push do we push this just start talking I hold the microphone I'll hold it for you my name is my name is Maya Isabella French I a third grader from ois elementary school I'm talking to you because I'm Type 1
040diabetic I hope that you change your minds and don't cut the nurses because they help a lot of kids like me I'm not a regular type one diabetic I don't feel anything when I'm very low if I don't have my nurses then I could pass out or even die but thanks to my nurses that hasn't happened please remember my words when you vote yeah you can't abandon [Applause] me next next we have uh marav Baragon followed by Alberto Ooa hello my name is maagan parent of three CVUSD students two of who you just heard uh growing up as a kid and now as a parent role this district has always claimed that nutrition and health is the foundation for learning uh so I agree 100% with the district so if we agree on the foundation
041for learning um my question is why are we trying to mess with our found Foundation by cutting nurses who ensure students Health um across the entire District uh my kids are concerned about their health and safety and rightly so I am too their will being depends on what seems like a necessary evil vote on a budget right uh I want to share that a little bit about our situation with the current nurse team in place so at Middle School my son did not have a nurse available for the first day of school so he could stay for Asus me knowing first days of school never run smoothly I had taken the day off of work to be on standby I ended up staying with my son the first day so he could participate and have
042access like a typical kid after that our phenomenal nurse U Miss Yoli did like my son said adjusted her schedule so she could make sure that happens for him at Oasis Elementary School my daughter has actually a team of about three nurses who play Tetris with their schedules so she could just be a third grader uh during her regular school day um and after school even with the current uh nurses the district has in place there have been instances that we have had to pick up our kids early because nurses were not available stuff happens I understand uh but that's and that's the current situation as it is now um so as Maya shared her type 1 diabetes presents itself in a more complex way she's called U she's what's known as asymptomatic uh when
043her glucose levels reach a dangerous low she does not present any visible symptoms until it is dangerously late and being transparent with you her case is intimidating for many nurses not familiar with her um so that's when her father and I have stepped in to help train the nurses as well so after reviewing Maya's unique medical needs the RN assigned a one-on-one nurse to watch her like a hawk and has prevented so many urgent lows and emergency room visits um but she and the rest of the nurses have done so much more all the nurses give your students my kids an equitable and inclusive School environment oh sorry these are ends um and lvns open doors and allow students like Maya and Xander to access their education and programs um they allow my kids to
044be confident sorry get emotional um I know my time is up I'll be done thank Youk you Al um hello and good evening uh to the governing board um my name is Alberto Ooa and my son's a type 1 diabetic he currently goes to CV High School um his pancreas doesn't produce any insulin and there's never a day where um he won't have to monitor his glucose levels receive insulin injections and count his carbs at every meal and snack uh when I send my son to school there's a level of comfort and peace I have knowing that he has an amazing nurse and staff as a parent of child to type one diabetes I can say that it's very hard managing my son's diabetes on a daily basis and I only have one child I
045don't know how these amazing nurses managed to not only care for several other childrens with diabetes but on top of all the other students that come in with injuries and being sick um I know that at CV high school that there are about six diabetic children and that's just one school if you were to make cuts to the nursing staff I don't think that our children would receive the same level of care that they deserve I hope that um the board takes our children's health and safety as serious as we do as parents uh the nurses aren't just a number on some budget sheet they are are children's caregivers and I understand that budget cuts happen in every Department I strongly believe though that nursing department is not one of those departments that you can
046afford to make Cuts without compromising our children's health and uh and safety and um on on a side note I mean it is very very challenging I can't even tell you how hard it is to have a child with diabetes the minute they start to go high for too long it just kind of escalates and they can be you know end up being hospitalized they can have seizures they can go into a diabetic um I struggle with this on a daily basis being on top of my son's numbers and I don't see how um if you guys make these cuts that anybody will be able to manage all of these students in a healthy and a safe Manner and I really do hope that you guys just take that into consideration thank [Applause] you I'm
047going to call him again one Last Chance jua Assuming he's not here okay uh moving on uh Maria aalos followed by Russa perz Maria aalos for AC Rosa pis hello good evening my name is Rosa peris I'm a cvd alumini graduated last year I am here to talk about my experience I as well was like Mari mentioned uh student that had to go to her bus stop at 5:50 in the morning because the bus would pass 600 where there was no light at all it was just my flashlight from phone that I had to get visibility from I as well was there early morning you guys know in the summer the since the sun goes up it's really hot I would stay there until the bus would get there sometimes the bus wouldn't even get
048there so we would be standing there for up to like an hour with no shade at all so we would all be suffering from the heatness and well I would like you guys to take in consideration what I've just said so we can see what you guys can make a change in thank you uh next up uh udana Vasquez good evening board members and superintendent my name is yuriana and I am here on behalf of the school RN and LVN as well as my daughter who attends Mecca Elementary I am the mother of a now 12-year-old who was diagnosed with type 1 diabetes at 2 years old Her diagnosis day was the worst day of my life I was uneducated on the issue but have since learned a great deal it is my perception that
049the superintendent and board of members are also not well informed and lack Awareness on the weight of the duties the district RN and LVN take on every single day I advocated tirelessly for my daughter to have the services that she needed at school and these ladies helped me through it all I would not be able to confidently drop off my daughter at school without knowing that the coordination they carry out within their program will ensure my daughter's safety in the school and prevent a medical emergency proposing that what is now a team of nine be reduced to two is insane and overall irresponsible it is a systemic form of discrimination against children with medical conditions educational inequality by jeopardizing their opportunities and racial inequality being that most kids in this District are of Hispanic origin
050whose parents are unaware of their rights when advocating for them the only reason I'm able to hold a job is because I rest assured that these ladies are certified and well trained to handle any emergency that arises from my daughter's diagnosis I refuse to leave my daughter's safety in the hands of unlicensed front desk School staff the district RNs do an amazing job at enforcing doctor orders coordinating field trips and monitoring my child's blood glucose levels reducing the district's health department and expecting it to function in the same manner is irrational the quality of their work will be compromised and with it my daughter's Health God forbid a medical emergency occurred who will be held liable for not having medically certified staff on campus my daughter is currently in sixth grade she still has six
051more years to go do not infringe on her right to have a proper education without having to worry about her medical diagnosis if anything validate and be considered of the work these ladies carry out and the enormous responsibility that comes with it just for reference and undetected low blood glucose level on the field while playing baseball can induce a seizure and lead to a head injury a high blood glucose level can interfere with her focus and cognitive processes while State Testing so although it might not seem like it it really is a matter of health of life and death and it poses very serious and unprecedented health risks her safety in school wouldn't be possible without everything this team does thank you for your [Applause] time thank you uh I'm sorry I put you in
052the transport it said Transportation that's why I stuck you in the transportation P apologize for that uh solangel Cruz for for foror gracias [Applause] Mar com for Ma repr Baragon bues for for Amalia sea Ro graases [Applause] that's the last of the ones that I have is there anybody else that wish to speak that I didn't get it is there anymore all right seeing no more we're going to go ahead and move on uh going back to where we were the written Communications we all got them uh on us and now I apologize our student board member to report thank you president Akuna um good evening um I am La Familia student trustee and I'm going to start with CV um to give updates about the school the board report um wait so our student
053trusty Lynette said i' like to follow up on what's being being done for the restrooms at Coachella Valley High School this being the gaps in the doors and how the walk through went I also want to give a shout out to all the sports team for their excellent performance we're excited about the new technology coming to our buses and the positive changes it will bring I also wanted to share how much I've appreciated the student ambassador group it's been great seeing them in action especially when they talked with Alejandra kovos about an idea we all support the initiative attention to communication aims to bridge the gap between students with minor disabilities and those without promoting inclusion and stopping un unnecessary separation any help or ideas for this event would be incredible to hear thank you
054um and for DM sport report counseling seniors are receiving help with FASA FAA DREAM Act applications and scholarship opportunities um all pente seniors have completed fava and received admission to C state universities with UC decisions coming in March CTE web design students have successfully created their own personal websites achievements girls wrestling play second in league and boy soccer is in first place in the Sun Sun Valley League Health Academy job shadowing opportunities are scheduled for next month and um for the West Shores board report um second semester has officially begun and our counseling team is working on course changes interim I ready reading and math 98% [Music] completed um um Cod did their Edge pledge with the seniors they also had gifts and resources during lunch where they had their swag table available for all
055for all high school grades um and on February 6 12th graders will be taking their senior portraits basketball and so soccer are our two main sports right now um and for the lafas B report um I have something to say students have expressed their concerns regarding the school buses not showing up at all on many occasions we really hope there is a solution to this issue however in comparison to months ago we have seen many improvements in transportation starting from implementing the direct bus routes and not needing take not needing to take the CB or DM bus um and I've also talked to some students and they've said that they had to call someone to take them to lafa because the bus wouldn't they wouldn't even show up and well obviously that that's sometimes they
056can't even get breakfast and they arrive late to school and we have also had issues with the outside tables in lafa some of the tables have deteriorated and leaned down I would like students to feel comfortable and feel safe in our school thank [Applause] you thank you for that um next up board member reports um board member Arondo if you want to start good evening everybody thank you for coming um it's always good to hear from our residents our students uh and and anything that that comes before the board I just want you to all know that we we do take into consideration everything that's being said uh and and we believe and we must come to an agreement that students will be put first and to make sure that we have services to serve
057our students at kelal Unified School District thank I said before we take responsibility for this budget and what we need to do to make sure that we have a a a good budget going forward we have to work together we have to work uh we have to keep working at the budget to make sure that that we can continue to serve our students and families at CVUSD okay um over the past month I got a chance to visit some of the field Ren Renovations I'd like to thank staff to you know I got a list of the shade structures that have been fixed and worked on and that's that's good to see especially as we're we're getting uh close to Su summer again to make sure that our students have uh green access spaces to
058play um I also got a chance to attend La Familia uh ceremony where uh students that were going back to their High School were acknowledged and and I I I mean the room was was uh full here at the boardroom so I like to thank the families that came to that to that event I will continue to do uh School visits and continue to have conversations um today is not a is not a day that we are are voting on any specific plan but we continue to work on the Budget moving forward to make sure that we uh we do our due diligence here on the board so I'd like to thank everybody for the work that you're doing uh for the work that you're doing for our students I'd like to thank all the
059staff that's here we hear you we know that you you you uh you know everybody our district plays a role in supporting our students and we know that we just have to work to continue to work together and get our budget on the right track thank you Mr President board member Gonzalez uh I have no report mruna thank you board member Garcia thank you again um to Echo a bit of TR um it takes a village and we really did have a an excellent representation of our full community here who spoke to us and we take that so seriously um everyone who's come up to me called the text emails I mean I'm reading them hopefully I'm getting back to you quickly um this is not an easy situation happy New Year right um I
060know it feels precarious on so many levels uh I'm really hoping that we can work together to protect each other um and as far as the work that we're doing here on the board this is not something we take lightly uh last week I was at my son's school volunteering for the day and every single person who touches um each of our students right throughout the day they know their names um I almost cried when the yard Duty lady had a conversation with me about my son when she has so many students that she's watching during recess during all of those periods and she still knew my son and could talk to me about him and what she's seen so that was amazing and we know we know the impact of what what you do
061and how important it is so I promise you that the plan plans that we're doing we're asking the questions to better understand how this is going to affect you um I'm making sure that we I understand the plan that would be in place if there's a an alternative that I feel um makes sense for our students then that's something that I'll go for in the end any budget that we have any regardless of the amount of money we're going to have to divvy it up and where we put that money is where we put our values as far as I'm concerned so pay attention to what that's going to be I'm going to promise that I work my very hardest to ask questions for understanding and really push to understand what is the plan because
062we wouldn't just leave any Department with nothing um seeing the numbers just offand it it seems uh very disturbing right to see what could be what we could be losing but as long as we have a plan in place to keep ourselves safe to keep the students safe and as long as that's something that makes sense to me and my values for the district and what we're hoping for that's where we are right now um unfortunately we do not have unlimited funds but whatever we're doing my hope is that we're working together so that it's something that our students deserve if we had all the money in the world our students deserve everything but whatever we do very targeted with planning so that you still feel um safe to bring your students to us certainly
063that's not lost on us um thank you so much and continue to talk to us thank you board member tauris thank you president Akuna for the opportunity thank the community for giving me the opportunity to be here it's little over 30 days as my uh Cher's uh board representative uh mainly for Avenue 69 The Oasis Sultan City Sultan sea area um so I lived out there for uh more than uh almost two decades so and I have yet to go visit the school though I will will do that soon and so just letting the community know if there's any concerns that are you know based out of Oasis on see then I'm the representative the new representative out there and the reason I got and wanted to be on the board was because of school
064safety my my my son and my daughter have been through you know Coachella Valley since kindergarten uh almost ready to graduate so I'm aware of you know a lot of the situations that have gone on all through his time in school and uh again safety is what brought me to this board and I'm glad that uh I had the opportunity to hear the community and your concerns about the safety of the kids and the numbers that that were presented with the sheets that are here and I think it it puts in a lot of weight on the board now to take those concerns into consideration uh these numbers I think I was not aware of these numbers before so I'm very appreciative that the Community has come up and stepped up and let us know
065how you feel but I think that that that says a lot to the board then next time we go back into close session and start talking about the budget and and I think transparency is a huge it's a huge you know exposure to the community we we need to be very transparent and where we are how this started and and from this point on and I think uh a lot of the governments put out a state of the you know state of the union state of the county and I think what what the board is going to do is start maybe talking about uh state of the the um the district right so and that's what we're working on uh with you know starting with this budget and like president said you know it really
066doesn't uh outside of holding people accountable it really doesn't uh help us to progress by you know looking back and and and you know you know looking at retribution I think the the better point is to uh grow from this and and look forward and and like I said the main thing is taking all of the concerns and um using that with our budget uh with our budget voting so again thank you president for giving me the opportunity Community for giving me the concerns and for letting me represent you on this board thank you thank you vice president berus yes uh good evening everybody um thank you all for public comment tonight um just a couple things that I had the opportunity to join um I think last week we had the policy committee we're
067still reviewing the workplace violence prevention uh plan but I'm hopeful that we'll get to a point where we can you know publish it and um you know doing um reinforcing that with our staff and and promoting that um provide that and have it available um I also had the opportunity joined the I visited the CB USD science fair award ceremony it was really great to see all the students um and the parents were really excited um you know with their projects um that they shared um I shared with folks I don't feel like I was that smart as an elementary kid they had some great topics um and the last thing I had the opportunity to do um I was invited to uh join a conversation with parents out at West Shore so listen to
068uh some parent concerns and um I'm hopeful that staff will be following up with them to um just provide you know some Assurance to some of the concerns that they raised and um I'm hoping that they will connect with other board members as well um with respect to the public comments tonight I you know I really appreciate everybody um you know as trusty Garcia mentioned our budgets are a reflection of our values and um it's really difficult right I I think uh you know we've had to well for me I've had to you know really spend that time to think about um you know the direction and the decisions that we'll be making in the coming months um you know every single person that came um today to provide public comment and and I do
069apologize for running late so I'm hopeful that Pro hoping to follow up with some of the folks that I comments I missed um but it's hard right like how do we um decide which of my values is more than the other right um is Health uh more important right um for me I work at at the college and provide assistance with basic needs and um to see the impact that basic needs has on a student's academics it's very very difficult right so that even that comment to me directly was some something that that I value right um and so you know I'm I'm hoping that we'll continue to have those conversations with the public um you know I I don't acknowledge that I don't have all the answers I don't know that any of my
070colleagues maybe I won't speak for all my colleagues but um um you know I don't think that I have all the answers right so I'm I'm open to having conversations and just listening to to folks and um I'm hoping that we can all kind of work together right there are pieces that we need to have negotiations around right and so I think for all of us um The Hope is that we can minimize that impact right um staff is family and and you know it's it's not easy to make these decisions so um I just thank everybody for for being you know honest and coming up and and sharing the the thoughts right um so thank you thank you vice president Vargas uh well welcome back everyone 2025 kind of starting the way the 24
071ended in the same manner we're still here we still have a budget deficit um and uh we need to move forward um also wanted to mention I did attend also the La Familia on track uh celebration um it was great to see the students who are back on track who came in who are doing many of them are going back to their original School sites to hopefully graduate by then I think one of the great things that I heard that night was that while we were all very proud of where they're at uh the job is not not finished it's not finished until they actually graduate and I think many of the parents and even the students understood that this this was a good time to celebrate to reflect on what they have done uh
072but the true uh the true job ends when they graduate and then go on to their next career so I thought that was very uh uh inspiring and uh a lot of the parents that spoke that I spoke with and other parents that spoke up uh very uh supportive of the job they were they're doing at La Familia obviously nothing's perfect everywhere we can improve everywhere but they were very uh uh appreciative of the support that their kids were getting at La Familia and being able to to either stay there and graduate or move back to their original sites and graduate um I did have an opportunity to uh to go check out the new uh uh the uh the sports field over at Palm View School uh it's pretty much done there's a there's
073a couple of things that I I did have questions on this afternoon um there's as I was walking around I noticed there was only one water faet um it's a big Park a lot of kids and uh so thankfully at the facilities committee today they're going to be looking at possibly adding a few or making recommendations for that I think that those things are kind of important only because again they're the little things that sometimes uh The Architects forget oh we'll put up a water faucet you know it's okay the kids can line up uh when you have you know what do we have they 800 kids or so there I don't remember it P you huh 600 students there in the playgrounds the after school program it gets hot and they're all standing in
074line for one water faucet so thankfully the the facilities committee and the staff are going to look into that and hopefully they'll give us a recommendation to uh write that mistake that that that happened during the design of that project but it does look really good um and so and the kids were out there having a great time um as far as all the people that came to comment today uh I've said this before whether they support what we're doing don't support what they're doing I always appreciate people taking the time out of their lives quote unquote getting off the couch and coming out here uh to partic participate I always appreciate it again whether I agree or don't agree it doesn't really matter I think the fact that they're engaging in the process and
075coming out especially the parents uh I think it's very important um you know we have a situation with our budget uh that needs to be fixed and uh we asked our staff to put a budget together for us they did uh it's the board's job to either accept it or change it or put anything else in there there's many things in there that my as talking about values that I value a lot but you know we all have to compromise we all have to sacrifice we all have to do what we think is right and again as I've mentioned to my colleagues and I think I've mentioned to some people who have asked me in public we have a target number we have to reach if you want to put something back in we got
076to take something out and so that's a trade-off uh everyone's going to lobby for theirs side that's fine and that's what they should do but at the end of the day this board is going to have to make a decision across the board of you know things that again we can say we value there's a lot of things in there I value that I'm fortunately taking as a whole I might have to vote for um and that's that's our job it's irresponsible to just say well I want to put all this stuff back and keep spending money that we don't have and those who are out there saying well just keep paying people and you can't fire anybody that's irresponsible as well because we have a target number and we have to meet it uh
077we can point fingers and blame at who how we got here yeah we can do that I'm I'm I'm willing to play that game um you know for those of you who don't remember in 20 we were discussing a little bit about this but in 2018 2019 we already started down this progress about cutting and reducing staff and doing all these things then Co hit we got all the money in the world and everybody kicked the can down the road myself included you know I was on the board I have to take responsibility for the same thing we kicked the can down the road and then when we started trying to do that last year obviously when we uh passed the budget some of us who voted for a budget to actually start acting responsibly
078we were not able to implement that that budget that's why the Count's here now and when they say that you know they don't kind of trust us well I can't blame them we told them we're going to do something last year and we didn't do it so until we actually vote for the actual Cuts not the cuts on paper then hopefully we can regain a little bit of confidence of Confidence from them and we can keep moving forward uh there is one thing I do want to to mention and I've unfortunately I've seen a lot of people go on TV uh do interviews with the media and just a quick correction uh we did not lose 40 million dollar we did not mismanage or lose or or or you know it's not missing we had
079a lot of money from covid come and it stopped and if you look at all the money we got during those years it probably equals $50 million a year that we're getting extra and that's what we need to cut and again for those of you who want us to keep spending money people have said let the state take over well that's the vote of the board if the board wants to let the state take over let the state take over it's very simple you don't vote for the budget the state takes over that's on them I choose to be responsible and try to do what's right for our district for our kids but that's just me so again if you have a proposal fine but everything that you want to put back in has to
080come out and that's something has to come out it has to balance out and that's where we're at and again I'm not going to be happy voting for for this budget if I in if I do vote for the budget and again I'll reiterate what I said last time it has to be an unanimous vote for me you know people can't stand on one side and say oh well I'm not going to vote for it because I don't want anybody to yell at me you guys do the right thing that's not going to happen with me anymore if people choose to vote against it well I'm just going to support them and I'll vote against it as well and uh that way we're all in the same boote so um again we do have to
081start working together we have to start acting responsibly uh myself included and again but if a majority of the board or some people decide that they don't want to take the hit they don't want to get yelled at for cutting jobs which sucks and I've done it before it's not a happy thing I've done it I've been around long enough that I've had to cut positions in the past but again I I believe it's unfair to allow a majority of people to take the blunt while the other ones decide stay back well I'm not going to vote for it cuz I don't want to get yelled at I think that's irresponsible as well so uh with that we're going to go ahead and move on to our U superintendent report you want to go forward
082thank you so during layoffs sensitivity is extremely important it's extremely important for us to be sensitive to our staff uh that is going to be laid off and so I want to make sure that you understand that you know we know that it's crucial because the impact on our employees goes beyond just losing their job it can affect their sense of security their selfworth and their mental health and so it's important to approach the situation with empathy and clear communication we've been putting out communication on why we're here so these layoffs know that they will take place June 2025 it's not something that's going to happen this month it's not going to happen in March in March people will be informed uh with a letter but their last uh their last part of their employment
083with the with the district will be in June 2025 so we'll be providing supports and resources like unemployment workshops retirement workshops and mental health counseling for our staff um what we've done is reduced site Department budgets to make sure that we can meet our Mark so that this doesn't continue so what happened in 201617 1718 and was reported to The District in 2019 while covid money masked it from 20 to 2023 that we look at it and that we are fiscally responsible as your superintendent that is my job is to be fiscally responsible so we're utilizing Redevelopment funds totaling $13 million utilizing restricted funds were possible implementing contract reductions and this was all done prior to the consideration of the layoffs we were able to reach almost $22 million of other monies aside from the
084monies for the layoffs and so I want to continue to look for additional Cuts believe me we are trying every day uh for those out years for 26 27 and 2728 cuz we will still have to make Cuts in those years it's not just 25 5 and 26 so it's totaling $60 million $60 million in 3 years and so um it it's it's a long-term plan that we have to stabilize the district's budget to fix operations in the district that have not been working and to provide a high quality education for our students so again as your superintendant it is my job to make this District fiscally stable thank you okay thank you let's move on item 8.1 uh Educational Services uh Mr lto requesting authorization to amend contract with zto West holding LLC uh
085eate year 26 category 1 white area Network Services providers to include Northshore Elementary do I have a motion a second I have a motion and a second do we have any questions all those in favor student truste I have to do separately sorry I all those opposed president can you just explain to the public 7.1 that we tabled it excuse me uh can you just explain 7.1 that we tabled it for um 7.1 was actually requested by board member boss but she had to leave today so we're tabling for next week so she can be part of the discussion for next month two weeks thank you we're going to uh so she can be part of the discussion she had to leave uh unexpectedly all right um item 9.2 uh Mr mokin uh approval to
086enter into a memorandum of understanding uh with gov deals motion I have a motion to Second 9.1 Sir Mr President 9.1 is that the one I read oh I'm sorry I read the wrong one U Mr marukin authorization to piggyback uh Omnia contract number r- tc-17 006 motion the same a second I have a motion and a second any questions all those in favor I hi student truste sorry I have to do that um all those opposed motion carries now item 9.2 Mr mukin uh approval to enter into a memorandum of understanding mou with gov deals motion I have a motion do I hear a second second I have a motion in a second do I have any questions seeing none all those in favor I I student trustee I all those opposed motion carries
087item 9.3 um Mado approval of purchase order with Granger motion a second I have a motion in a second any questions um I think I had a question about the dates on this if this was something we we already purchased you know what in the sent sorry oh okay that that's a good distinction let me let me um actually mention this this is an item that was purchased from transportation that was never brought for approval to the board um they they ordered it they bought it they brought it they're using the equipment and it was never brought to the board so that is one of the items I think there's a couple of them maybe one's going to come later but this is one of those that we have to um they're using the equipment
088they already we bought it they open the box and we're using it so in essence unfortunately this is one of those times where we have to go back and uh basically approve a purchase that we never approved originally so just to make it clear uh this was never brought to the board and it was purchased and done without our consent yeah I think the D so the due date on this says 829 2024 so I just want to make sure I mean I don't know if it's like a training that needs to happen with staff but we need to ensure that we're following you know our policies um and procedures um and bringing these items to the board in a timely manner and so what has happened is that our purchasing director uh has been
089making sure that they're scanning everything with the fine tooth comb and has been finding items that some directors in the past had put in and never got approval for the board that's over the $10,000 threshold so we're bringing those to board so that is this one y any other questions question Mr President so with with the audit those become findings or recommendations for the manager right and documented with the audits right and and then we have to submit um the correction right so um we're documenting that now right going back yes and uh so this doesn't happen frequently right I mean we're we're progressing we're progressing um it it there's some um steps that were not being followed in the business office and and so um our purchasing like I said our purchasing director started
090finding these things and bringing them to my attention all right very good thank you anything else all those in favor I student trusty I motion carries five 5 z Mr Adon step down um item 9.4 uh Mr authorization to approve purchase order with Access Communications motion motion I have a motion do I have a second second uh any questions on this I mean I think I mean I feel like it's important to know you know it's same kind of thing this is dated uh May 24 2024 and I think as we're you know going through our budget assessment just you know that we're yep correct processing those things yeah okay any other questions anything else okay seeing none all those in favor I I student truste I all those opposed motion carries 5 uh 9.5
091um's adoption of resolution number 2025-the section 66006 and 66001 a motion I have a motion do I hear a second second oh I have a motion and a second any questions on this seeing none all those in favor I student trusty I all those opposed motion carries 5- Z Item 9. six authorization to uh M authorization to issue a purchase order to Dave bang Associates Inc for the replacement of two existing playground structures at Las palalas Elementary School that also includes a shade cover it's not in the title but it does I have a motion do I have a second second I have a motion in a second any questions on this we're replacing the Sha the structure the whole thing not just the shade oh okay okay any other questions seeing none all those
092in favor I student trustee I all those opposed motion carries 0 item 9.7 lus again consideration for adoption of resolution number 20 25-26 resolution of the governing board of the Coachella Val Unified School District declaring certain structures as non-school structures exempt from division of State architect DSA review and approval a motion I have a motion I have a second second I have a motion and second uh is there any questions on this we're all good all those in favor I I student trustee I any opposed motion carries 5 uh item 10.1 um Dr mt's approval of pro uh provisional internship permit requests for secondary 7th 8th grade science teacher do I hear a motion motion do iar a second second I have a motion in a second any questions on this seeing none all those
093in favor I all those uh student truste I Mr I okay uh motion carries 60 next item is our consent calendar all matters listed under the consent calendar are considered by the board to be routine and will be acted upon on in one motion there will be no discussion of these items prior to the time the board considers the motion unless members of the board or staff request specific items to be discussed Andor removed from the consent calendar in which event the items will be considered separately the superintendent assistant superintendent of ed services assistant superintendent of business services and assistant superintendent of Human Services recommend the approval of all consent calendar items uh do I hear a motion for this to approve approve uh I'll motion to approve the consent calendar respecting anybody wanting to
094pull an item okay do I have a uh second second I have a motion and a second anyone wish to pull an item I just have a comment okay well let me see if anybody wants to pull something first anybody want to pull something we're all good today okay oh my only comment um just to reiterate to you know the public um we do have our fiscal uh adviser here right that takes takes a look at the items that um are coming to coming to the board in terms of you know he really is looking at if it's going to make a fiscal impact on our budget right so as we're going through these items approving them um you know rest assur that we also have that second kind of uh eye letting us know
095yes you can do this no this is going to impact your plan um so just assuring the the the community and the public that that's that that is a case that includes items um that uh any Union would want to negotiate we need to uh make sure that we have the fiscal adviser involved uh to get any types of recommendations and to make sure that we're in line with what we have stated on our plan all right seeing nothing being pulled all those in favor I I student trusty I all opposed motion carries 60 uh seeing no other issues to go into close session I take a motion to adjourn I have a motion do I hear a second second I have a motion in a second all those in favor I student trustee I
096all those opposed motion carries we are done at 9:37 thank you all see you two weeks