CorpusRecord 108299

CVUSD Board Meeting 12/13/2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / CoachellaValleyUSD
Date
2024-12-17
Location
Riverside County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
18,842 words · about 105 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening everyone I want to call this meeting to order at 532 uh Mr wera would you lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance please please please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance place your right hand over your heart ready began I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you can we get a roll call please yes sir president joyaa Jr here vice president Joseline Vargas here clerk Sylvia pass here TR Redondo pres Valerie Garcia Jesus Gonzalez a student trustee Eric wera here thank you uh try to see I we're moving on I try to um Mr Tores isn't in the audience is he T I did text him I have

002received no answer we will that item if it's okay with everybody after we come back from open not here so either we we pull it or we just move it so I'm going to move it over to um after we come back and hopefully he's here by then okay moving on item three 3.1 close session public comment public comments close session this is an opportunity for members of the public to address the governing board regarding any close session items within the board's subject matter jurisdiction please complete a request to address the governing board form and hand it to the recording secretary speakers will be limited to 3 minutes per person with the maximum of 20 minutes to each subject matter I have three uh ones um Ashley sansy [Music] hello hello okay hi good evening

003my name is Ashley Sosi and I am the chairman for cvta bargaining team and here with me tonight I also have the rest of cbta bargaining team as well and we're here tonight because we want to provide you with some information related to labor negotiations and how the district seemed to arrive at this Current financial situation Dr Esparza as assistant superintendent of ed services joined the district's bargaining team for the 2324 round of negotiations and that means that she was present and participated in the discussion I'm about to talk to you about that took place on October 25th 2023 that day is significant because that is the day the district told our team that the school board wanted to continue the Intervention Program paying them out of the general fund when the S money runs

004out our team shared concerns that it would not be sustainable for the district to continue to run a program that was intended to be temporary two direct coats from our team to the district team that day include quote is the district considering keeping the intervention teachers and the question is why that will hurt the district financially and later the same day another quote funding intervention with General funds sets the district up for financial trouble we tried to warn Dr Esparza but instead it was argued that the school board wanted to continue the program and when the program's Effectiveness was brought up Dr Esparza was the one to discuss the data being collected to support the board's decisions now we have several sets of notes from that day legal documents pertaining to negotiations and they all

005reflect Dr esparza's role in all of this less than a month after the October 25th meeting the assistant superintendent of Human Resources Dr Ellis was placed on leave and Dr sparza took over as the chair of the district's team and tonight Dr Ellis is being blamed for making making temporary positions permanent yet it would have been illegal for her to not do so when the intervention programs Intervention Program was continued tonight the assistant superintendent of Business Services who was just recently placed on leave is also being blamed for not laying off as many teachers as she should have this is because Dr sparza herself chose to create new coaching programs working with cvta on those job descriptions and this is not because the assistant soup of Business Services made a mistake Dr Dr Esparza was

006also at the bargaining meeting we when we discussed the district's reserves were at 17.5% and she did not dispute that amount although tonight she places the blame for that on others Dr Esparza was the one who made the call to board members to approve the salary increase that we negotiated so do not blame cvta for that the evidence presented clearly demonstrates that Dr Esparza and the school board made those decisions that have led to the district's Financial challenges and despite your attempts to shift blame onto others the records prove that your direct involvement and approval of decisions and actions that have contributed to the current financial situation accepting responsibility for your mistakes is a crucial part of effective leadership thank [Applause] you Simon Moore [Music] good good evening everyone um I'm speaking on on uh

007the legal potential legal litigation that is on the on the agenda there are far too many legal liabilities in CVUSD that have been the self-inflicted acts of financial mismanagement a lot of the blame has been shifted to the teachers and and the greed and all that other stuff but um no matter where it is in the course of the duties of that we must do as teachers in the course of my duties with the cvhs health Academy and hoso we are privileged to interact with agencies of of All Sorts in the valley and even the state and Beyond over the past month it happened three times where I introduce myself as a teacher they smile and ask wherewith and I with courage I tell them CV USD their face changes I'll hear comments like it

008must be tough for you over there hearing our prayers don't worry it'll all come out and change will come I can only imagine that our students experience similar reactions only not so civilized we go on to be the best role models that we could possibly be we know that it's true that it will come out and those who sat quietly weren't quiet at all they were participants over the past year there's been much about dishonesty much about control much about silencing those who speak out about Revelation about courage and those things that threaten it the same tactics that happened in the most recent elections seems to have been employed in our own School District no one really understands why or for what reason the drive to hold on to power prevails despite obvious dissatisfaction and

009impropriety the district is better than what we've been receiving there are people who care they have stepped up and will continue to now be active participants and delivering us to the place where we won't be ashamed to divulge our affiliation until then we'll continue to be that North Star for our students in this community we will continue to be the patches of land where the floods of personal interest have flooded this area please switch legal affiliation and avoid any further conflict of interest so we could start moving forward to where this District deserves to be thank you Sarah Chavis so she's not speaking anymore no no she's not speaking anymore she's not speaking she she will not be speaking anymore okay then that's all I have uh can I have a motion to go into

010close session please have a motion do I hear a second have a motion in a second all those in favor all those oppos oh actually you want to do that first yeah oh no we got to talk to him first right okay we're going to go into close session and when we come back we're going to swear in Mr tauris he has some paperwork that he has to do first so we'll do that when we come back from uh close session all right all those in favor all those opposed motion carries we will be back at what 7 7:30 7:30 7:30 then we'll uh do this morning okay I'm going to call this meeting back into order there was a motion in a second uh to return into Open session it passed unanimously uh next

011item on the agenda item 4.1 return We motion that item 4.2 announce actions taken in close session uh yes the board took the following action in close session approved expulsion case number 23 24- 005 for Clear reinstatement the motion was made by um trusty Jesus Gonzalez second by trust and the motion carried 60 the board um also took action in close session to approve expulsion case number 25-8 for stipulated expulsion the motion was made by um trustee trondo second by trustee Valerie Garcia and the motion carried 60 the board took action during close session to appoint employee number sl06 567 as interim assistant superintendent of educational services at Killa Valley Unified School District effective Monday December 16th 2024 on this 13th day of December 2024 the motion was made by trustee syia second by trustee

012Jesus Gonzalez and the motion carried 60 thank you um next up may I have an approval of the agenda submitted with the simple change of moving the saring in ceremony uh to the other section so move second have a motion in a second all those in favor hi all those opposed motion carries and now we're going to have the swearing in ceremony Dr sparza Mr tauris if you will good evening board members student trustee community members and everybody who is the audience with us tonight uh we will swear in Mr tortoise with the oath of office to become a board member here in uh Coachella Val Unified School District uh Mr toris do you can you raise your right hand do you solemnly swear to affirm that you will support and defend the Constitution of

013the United States and the constitution of the State of California again uh against all enemies foreign and domestic and that you will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States and to the Constitution of the State of California and take this obligation freely without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion and that it will and fair Faithfully uh you discharge the duties upon which you are to enter tonight yes I affirm thank you can you please sign here [Music] we have you sign some more thank you would you like to say something thank you superintendent uh for that it is an honor to be uh representing the area uh that I am living in at this time and I think that's the main reason that I uh ran for the board

014is to represent the area that I'm living in the community which is a integral part of the entire Community as represented here for the 16 plus thousand students that are in the school district now again I I'm here just to uh advocate for the community I live in but there's also an underline part that I also represent so I hope that with the future we can advocate and work together for all of the students of all communities for the Coachella Valley um School District right thank you [Applause] okay we're going to move on there's another change in here that for some reason it went yeah wrong we're going to do the um public comments now then we'll do the board member comments and the trustee uh student trustey comments and then we're going to go

015into the organizational updates um that way it stays within the public comment comment side um so uh moving forward board notifications and requests to address the board public comments Open Session IND introdu comments and requests to address the board on items on the adopted agenda and items not on the adopted agenda will be considered from the audience at this time please complete a request to address the governing board form and hand it in to the recording secretary speakers will be limited to three minutes per person with a maximum of 20 minutes to each subject matter Additionally the person making the request should State his or her name and the name of the organization or group represented please be advised that the board is not always at Liberty to answer questions right away state law prohibits

016the board from taking any action on items not listed on the agenda uh first up uh Dr Price Red County Office of Education thank you very much president Akuna members of the board uh superintendent espara pleasure to be here tonight and thank you for letting us use public comment uh for this quick item uh my name is Scott Price County uh of Riverside U Board of Education uh I'm the chief business officer there and I'm here for two short items the first is as we talked about in our last board meeting I wanted to introduce uh the fiscal adviser who has been assigned uh this is m Mr a uh Mahendra who will be uh joining our team and assigned to the district here as the fiscal adviser a has a wonderful experience as both

017a CBO and and other fiscal uh capacities also wonderful man you'll enjoy very much uh working with him and the second reason that we're here I have my whole uh fiscal Service District fiscal Services team here uh where here for your first interim tonight and and to listen to that I want to thank the board for working so hard with Dr espara and putting together a plan and a wonderful first interim for tonight so that's my public comment glad to be here thank you very much thank you Dr Price uh next up uh Gary SoDo status of professional development and coaching good evening School Board president Mr aunia school board members Dr Esparza executive cabinet and student design I am Gary stto I'm the founder of Gary D stto consulting company I want to take

018this opportunity to provide you with an update on the professional development the coaching the leadership support I've been offering the past few months some of you read or heard about my work over the last 50 years I shared 10 letters from local superintendents and instructional leaders highlighting the impact of my work and and uh in their districts these included letters from Palm Springs Bowmont Hemmet superintendents along with State leaders a prime example of my work can be seen in Garden Grove unified school district a district of 40,000 students once referred to as garbage Grove this District un underwent a profound transformation under the guidance of my former company action Learning Systems Garden Grove went from many schools near program Improvement to earning the very prestigious National broad Foundation Award board for closing the achievement Gap

019silencing the derogatory nickname forever I see coella Unified School District earning a distinguished national award highlighting student achievement I am also the co- uh author of crimes against learning solving the serial failure of public school reform a guide that has helped hundreds of districts overcome systemic hurdles to put students needs first the major message of this book is to stay on course transformative reform takes years a copy of this book has been given to all of you currently my work in coella Valley Unified School District has focused on creating an instructional framework that it serves as a Cornerstone for a multi-year effort to accelerate learning your District faces significant challenges with 71% of your students not proficient in reading and 83% not proficient in math the uh these uh numbers underscore a urgent need for

020strategies that can deliver not only just onee growth but multiple years of growth in one year what sets CVUSD apart from its commitment is to is this trans transformational development and under the leadership of Dr esparo I'm proud to report that teachers instructional coaches site administrators and District educational support staff are making remarkable progress I am thrilled to be a part of this journey thank you okay uh next up uh Monica Muro items 14.7 16.1 and 16.2 you have 36 9 [Music] minutes good evening members of the board I'm Dr spara student trustee um can you pull the mic a little bit closer sorry about that thank you I normally don't come and speak out or or complain um but I'm tired of getting bashed and not standing up for ourselves and our staff so

021I'm coming forward in good faith ahead of the board approval of our expanded learning contracts because um anytime anything it comes to the board with expanded learning or elop it always gets picked apart um claiming non-transparency needing more info by the same people before the end of last year we submitted requests to increase our independent contracts uh prior to the fiscal deadlines to ensure that our over 100 contracted staff had paperwork um for their contracts in before the cut off to ensure that their contracts were in place by the start of summer but our request was pulled for more information the following board meeting was already after the um the district cut offs and during that time the school stream form was changed which caused us to have to start from scratch submitting all of

022those contracts this further delayed our contracts and our contracted staff did not get paid for working summer until well after it ended they got paid at the end of July for working all of Summer while all our District staff had been paid twice on time the process from beginning to end of requesting a contract takes over two months about two months and it goes through three different Avenues before it comes back to accounting I don't know know how many people could go months of working without getting paid they don't call you to check on their payments they call us over and over and we have to tell them the same thing we're so sorry your contract documents are in the works there was a setback with board approvals they're going to they're processing them as

023fast as as the process allows you'll see your payments soon it's not fair to them that information isn't requested prior to the board meeting because we know agenda get reviewed beforehand there's only so much transparency that you can see on paper you also have to be willing to do leg work and plan to walk with our admin and state teams when they come visit our schools to attend and stay to watch our schools perform um at school and community events our Coachella parade last week had 100 entries 70 of those entries were expanded learning come out to our sports events and see the thousand plus students parents and staff that are attending come to our office on time part day on our extra Services requests I feel the need to bring some lack of transparency

024issues to light since they weren't addressed in the previous regular board meeting expanded learning is always attacked and bashed claiming non-transparency and mismanagement of funds non-compliance are just suspicious or my favorite we do whatever we want it's dirt thrown at us so people think that we don't know what we're doing so let's be honest we get hot hot potatoed things all the time and when B brings them to us we handle it because we're the expanded learning department and that's what we do know that this is not about money it's about principle and impartiality when it comes to transparency hold everyone accountable to the same rules and standards when you see extra Services come to you um on the agenda do you know which administrator submits it has anyone ever had to ask because when

025our our department submits anything it always get gets picked apart yet when an extra service item came to board from a department using elop funds that wasn't requested by us didn't come from our office went all the way through school stream admin approvals mind you we have eight approvals this one came in through came through with five or less then it came to board it was passed with no discussion of out of uh outside of closed session even though it clearly said elop someone had to have known that it didn't come from our office not to pull it no discussion I for one was expecting some kind of discussion since we always have issues the item was only pushed back by two weeks and I was blown away when I heard we'll see if Asus

026has anything to do with it really what does that even mean like this this is restricted gr funding that our department manages I understand that one admin administrator approved the form twice then our direct a director interim admin two two individuals that don't even approve on any of our budgets fully approved came to board we found out when the board agenda came out that that there was something on there why was another department allowed to use elop restricted funds earmarked for expanding learning support that doesn't belong to their Department nor do they manage it funding was used without informing the the department that oversees it this has never been allowed before why why was it allowed now what would have happened if we did that are you kidding how much scrutiny we would be in

027we would never hear the end of it budget lines are 22 digits long seven sets of digits it wasn't by accident that they had our exact budget string and we don't give it out and that's one of the reasons why we get accused of non-transparency mismanagement of funds not being able to manage our budgets but how is what they did any different how are we supposed to be expected to manage our budgets accurately when we don't even know if other departments are using our funding how do we know it's compliant and not supplanting and when we have an interim admin stating we'll see if Asus has anything to do with it to me that sounds like we need a review of our grant regulations and compliance why doesn't transparency apply to everyone why is it

028okay to unethically use another Department's restricted grant funding and it was pushed under the rug with no discussion not pulled Hush Hush someone had an expiring deadline didn't have the funding for it said they have funding they're not going to question it because it's under the same brella of departments I'm not going to tell them it was pushed under the rug and I'm not saying quied about it our hiring process was hammered and I can tell you that none of the individuals that were approved have an application to work through our department using our funding I never saw a a flyer posted through the district how are they selected it's not about the program it's not about the money this is about how this happened the last time we hired we received over 100 applications

029and we're still scheduling interviews what do we tell the current applicants waiting for those interviews about a board item that got approved with yell funding why uh they're still waiting for an interview they're they are district um certificated classified and community staff this didn't come from our department and let's be honest it was going to come to us anyways and it already has we all work for the same organization why sabotage your own I was bumed into the expanded learning Department in 2008 and since then I have to audit all of our school sites Galaxy expenses monthly to make sure that no one accidentally or accidentally on purpose used our budget for something or transferred something that hadn't been approved yet in the past we've had to remove expenses that weren't ours who else has

030to do that we get audited one to two times a year when was the last time anyone heard of Department having compliance audit findings you haven't because we don't we know our compliance and Grant regulations and we don't do things in our department because they're easy and can cover it up or come back and fix it later we do it because it's the right thing the right way and it's for our kids you have about 10 seconds left summer school we have we processed 880 time cards just Jenna and I we're used to 240 that was was an additional 64 640 time cards could have been a grievance but we sucked it up because we don't your time has expired sorry y thank you uhas subject 7.2 I believe good evening my name is Veronica

031DZ I am the chief Union steward to CSA classified Union one of the leadership on the eboard good evening president Jo auna um board members Dr sparsa superintendent and extended cabinet uh I I don't know what to say anymore um I've heard everybody here I've heard all my members throughout these days and the crisis that we are in and all it is is layoffs layoffs layoffs I'm hearing the same thing over over and over again tonight same thing reiterated I'm tired of the blaming shaming people going on media and doing the same thing over and over again you are the board $1.7 million layoff that's going to hit classified and yet here we are I don't understand what is the disconnect well technically I know the disconnect two associations disconnected board disconnected what what is

032going to happen if state was to take over these are our people this is our district you are up there am I supposed to point and blame you guys everybody on that board has has to know what this presentation is going to show you have to have known and we can blame back and forth for as long as we want because we've all been here I have 20 years and I know every one of you I know new board members also and you've been there for more than a year to two years so you knew something had to have happened whether they didn't and whether your management didn't Val you or not tell you but you're still sitting up there how do we fix this because as as far as I see on these numbers

0336 million certificated 11.7 million classified 1.4 million on Department management 5.7 million on District Department reductions so you guys and everybody else in this room can point fingers to everybody I'm tired of that my people mine because I am their leadership are out there trying to figure out is it going to be me am I going to lose my job what are you guys going to do about this please we need to take responsibility as a whole thank you thank you and then we have on 7 7.1 uh Joshua N of cvta uh good evening president auna and board trustees I've come to speak about item 7. W the presentation on CV usd's procurement request for proposals and Public Works building procedures I was disappointed to see that you again failed to attach the information

034to the presentation on the agenda this is beginning to be a pattern of behavior pointing towards willful non-compliance with the brown act and further demonstrates a need for transparency in District Operations and board policies since the presentation wasn't attached I'll just have to make a few comments about the process as it now stands some seem to have the impression that requests for proposals are just a hoop that you have to jump through to get things done in fact they are meant to be a process which ensures that public taxpayer dollars are being utilized to the greatest effect and help eliminate conflicts of interest that may exist a mechanism which holds board members District personnel and vendors accountable to the public instead we're finding troubling interference in this process by certain board members um job specifications

035that are missing key items for projects and vendors not being held to bids that they submitted and won I strongly urge a revamping of these policies and procedures and a greater effort to making these decisions with Fidelity and transparency thank you [Applause] seeing no other comments we're going to go ahead and move on um board member reports we'll go ahead and start with our uh I'm sorry move down to that uh our student trustee report Mr W if you would please huh right there just use that microphone just press the button yeah from Coachella Bali High School Lina Bautista I am deeply troubled by the upcoming budget cuts involving layoffs and program cuts and I fear they will negatively impact our students even with our current staff we are still facing unresolved issues and many

036classrooms are relying on new substitutes every day letting go off to many positions affects students more than anyone else and without students there is no school I want to make sure these changes don't distract us from addressing the ongoing problems our students should not suffer the consequences of decisions they did not make and it is crucial that we prioritize their education and well-being Above All Else although there are many vories to come students have their own set of Victories around campus it is great to see that they take education very seriously from laamia high school Roxana Medina counseling academic progress reports take PL took place on December 5th and deficiency notices were sent home for students with failing grades our counselor is also discussing with students about filling out forms to go back to their

037previous school if they plan to transfer back next semester any questions seniors have regarding financial aid or Drea our cular will system a financial aid Workshop took place to give additional information to students about applying to for FASA and got the chance to learn how to make candles ASB is hosting lafas 12 day of attendance motivating students to attend school every day for 12 consecutive days those students will receive a special prize for their dedication on showing up to school and commitment to learning Athletics basketball season has officially ended the boys basketball team has had two victories the second one being the last game and three loses the girls basketball team had one win 89 against Manny La Familia High School would like to thank the district for the new technology upgrades in our school

038West sh High School Isabella gimenez Martinez after school tutoring and support touring began this week for students below AC level but it's open for all 19 students attended on December 11 and positive results are already being seen additional researchers like tutor.com are available for 24/7 homework help College and Career Center updates the College and Career Center now has two counselors collaborating with teachers to support students Kimberly Moreno has joined as the newest counselor to focus on college prep and pente program sport achievements boy soccer secured 9 Z Victory against 29 Palms girls volleyball earned all academic team recognition by CIF Jacqueline saravia was named scholar athlete for achieving the highest GPA in cif's League that's Maraj High School me Eric W I want to address the upcoming budget cuts and the potential layoffs that could

039impact our school if we lose staff it will hurt our students the most our students need stability and support to succeed and the cuts to Staffing will make it harder to provide that on a brighter note the Moder coach Country Club is collaborating with the MHS D MHS hosting its third annual jerky giveaway on December nember 18th to provide turkeys to local families in need helping ensure everyone can enjoy their holiday meal everyone in our community is invited on December 10th the migrant program held their December celebration where each migrant student received a toy and families were giving a box of food I am proud to share that erret a student from pente program has been awarded a full right scholarship to the University of notam worth $80,000 per year she's the Third student from

040deser March to receive this honor and became a questbridge scholar this is a huge achievement and a Testament of the hard work of our students and staff lastly I want to thank the CB USD for their ongoing efforts to improve our schools while we are facing challenges I am confident that together we can overcome them and continue supporting our students thank you all right thank you very much for that um we're going to start with board comments um board member tauris this is where board members can ask uh this is where board members can ask for anything in the future report any visits they have um or any other questions that they may have um publicly to us or to the community so um I will I know you haven't probably had a lot of

041stuff yet to to talk about but I would like to give you the opportunity to go ahead and and make you make your statement for your board uh comments thank you president kuna uh as far as what I've heard from the public today I think that's probably where I would start right is uh providing you know documents I'm not sure since I'm new that if the protocol is you know what's on the agenda approval of the agenda beforehand and and you know I I see that some of them don't have attachments but maybe there's a reason for that I'm you know like I said I'm new but um for the future I've been talking to a couple board members in the back stuff but you know where I work we've gone through the same scenario

042as far as budget and reductions and planning and and what I found you know as far as uh the budget once you receive funding there always has to be we've learned the hard way too that there there there always has to be receive you know reception of the award but not only that when you receive an award there has to be a spend down plan and we learned the hard way that you know we got this award we planned we hired and we didn't have you know we didn't have a spend down plan and then we hit that fiscal cliff if you call it the fiscal cliff and you know uh my board put it off put it off and then we we had to do a drastic change which which you know adversely affected

043the Integrity of the organization so I think that's what we would look at and uh and it just learning from that adopting procedures to address that but you know there there's never a perfect world you can always be proactive but sometimes there's going to be things you have to be react for but I think uh just better planning from this point on would would help that would be my opinion thank you thank you board member Garcia thank you um yes the conversations can you hear does okay sorry um the conversations that we're having that we've been having are not easy um and we fully understand the gravity of that I'm proud that we spent the amount of special sessions that we did to really hash out and understand for ourselves what it is that we

044were doing um because this is not easy of course not um uh it feels like with this first step we are riding the ship um we had all these and unfortunately because we didn't phase this in it it's going to feel like a shock for some people but um we're trying to get back to our core and become efficient again on um how we're using the funding that we have and resources that we have you you are all our employees you are all our resources and we need to figure out how to utilize you for our students as efficiently as as possible that's not easy um I'm proud that we've taken the time for this first part and I really hope that if we're going to need a second round that we take that time

045to really understand um what we're doing before we have to make any more cuts um I hope that everyone is still able to have a happy holiday rest and recharge um I know there's a lot of uncertainty out there and that's never easy um but we are doing this in good faith for our students for everyone all of you um that's my comment thank you board member Gonzalez Mr K I'd like to take the time to uh congratulate Mr Thomas toris welcome him to the board I think he's going to bring a a unique perspective U even though we're a pretty homogeneous Community I think uh sometimes uh the community the Native American Community sometimes may feel left out I think he's going to give us a unique perspective uh on issues that we sometimes

046may Overlook and I think it's a a great contribution to to this board so I look forward to working with him um we're in a a tough situation and I I hate to say it but but I seen this happening two years ago 18 months ago and I pleaded with the board um the challenge that we were going to have being that we didn't have a plan um I felt that the gentleman that was here uh as our superintendent uh was overlooking those key components or key factors that we needed to to manifest in order to not be in this position um it just it was problem after problem it obviously has uh the Synergy of of the perfect storm has manifested it's here in front of us we're going to have to make real

047tough decisions um it is it's it's a tragedy because I think people that work for us uh they depend on a check they build a lifestyle around it and obviously when you don't have an income it becomes very very difficult and so as hard as these POS these these decisions are it's a reminder that when we have a superintendent that we should have a qualified superintendent that we should have a superintendent that is going to avoid these types of situations occurring I know that holding information from the board not informing the board maybe not even understanding what needed to be done uh all factored into where we're at um these decisions again are going to be very difficult Mr COA and um unfortunately uh ultimately I believe it's going to be the right decision for

048our students uh which is why we're here um that's my report thank you board member Rondo good evening everyone thank you for being here um so I want to start start off too by uh welcoming uh storis uh to the Das uh I look forward to working with you collaboratively and as we as we move forward um really quick I got to attend the California Schoolboard Association where we had we talked a lot about at length about the fiscal cliff that many districts are having and and unfortunately we are we are a district that is is trying to uh write our our stabilization plan and make sure that the least amount people are affected I think we we're a community that that looks to our our Workforce and understands and and uh looks at the

049effects of what this fiscal stabilization plan means for everyone so I know that there are a lot of questions there are a lot of fears I definitely understand that and I know that as a board member um I've been here since 2020 and I I take full responsibility as to what's in front of me I'm not want to shy away from from saying you know this or that but I'm here to say that it you know take responsibility for what's in front of us and the only thing that I can that that I can do now is is look look at this budget work with my colleagues to make sure that this doesn't happen again and that we make sure to move forward collectively and and with a plan that's going to do the least

050amount of effect on our community and and and you know especially in our in our classrooms our students and our and our staff that that work every day in our schools you know we know that we know how we value our staff and how much our staff does every everybody from the bus driver to the maintenance to the the yard supervisors we know how much you all mean to our teachers we know how much you all mean to our school district and we want to do the most we can to make sure that that that that we do the least amount of affecting but but just want to say thank you all for the work that you're doing uh there is a lot of questions but I as a board member I've always Taken full

051responsibility as what's in front of me and I I can only assure you that I'm going to work collaboratively to make sure that we have a good plan that we can submit to the county tonight and that moving forward right that we Implement our plan and you know also look for opportunities where we can uh utilize our and and and make sure that our Workforce is part of our you know continues to be part of our district so thank you to everybody that's here um a couple more comments I just want to congratulate you know there's a few schools out there that had some big gains in test scores we know that test scores in some some of our schools have have risen I want to thank the the principles in those schools I know

052a couple of them I know Coachella Valley High School had some gains I know deser Mirage High School had some gains I know Peter peleton Elementary had some gains so thank you for the work that you're all doing to to help and continuing to help our students through these tough times I also want to thank uh I know that the Coachella parade wouldn't be the same if it wasn't for our students that are part of it through our after school program so thank you to our after school progr program who had you know all those entries into the Coachella parade um I've got to see a couple of our field Reser Renovations and I know that through these tough times we'll still continue to do the best we can to make sure that our our

053our uh our schools are are being kept up so uh with that thank you m m uh president K board member pass good evening welcome everyone um chairman Tores uh and I call him chairman not because he's a chair here okay but from the tribe um so welcome um pleasure to um have you on this Das um I do want um it's you know occasionally I don't ever keep my mail open during board meetings and then later I see that we receive an email from M about public comments that were submitted I don't know when these public comments were submitted um I do recall that they used to be read at some point and then somehow we didn't but I happen to have my email open today I received a public comment so I'm going

054to read it out loud um and this says from Juan L subject budget cuts if there is one thing that our district can save money on is by cutting the programs that are useless one of the programs that has very little use is having multiple coaches in one school side many of the topics covered by instructional coaches are already covered during staff professional development in addition many of these topics can also be covered during our two full days of professional development throughout the school year our school district has a system in place for struggling teachers called the par why not have teachers that are struggling use a program administrators can recommend a teacher to go into the program why not use it administrators should be the first line of help for our teachers as well

055administrators should be knowledgeable enough to provide instructional recommendations for our teachers which sometimes is not the case I do believe that coaching has some value in it but having multiple coaches is not necessary possibly sharing coaches between school sites would be a better idea and better use of our funding another program that has no accountability and no credibility is the vapa program which was designed for College and Career Readiness but there's no account accountability to it there are no assessments and there's no way to track student growth our students would be better off having their extended lunch recess and having time to socialize and build positive relationships with their peers which they so much crave rather than focusing on something that has no accountability to it please take time to visit a vapa classroom as

056ask yourself how will the content provide provide prepare any student for a career or college it's time to think outside of the box and get rid of things that don't work many of you sitting at the board have not spent time looking at the things you've approved there's only a handful of you that actually walk schools and walk the programs that you approve please take some time to learn about the critical decisions you take and how it impacts the classroom some of the recommendations for programs you've approved have been from people who have spent years outside the class our classroom dynamics have changed a whole lot take some time to visit one so that was the comment again from Juan L um so I now to my comments I want to welcome everyone thank you

057for the comments that you provide consistently to this board um as has been stated we are in a situation where we're making very difficult decisions and I appreciate Veronica's words right that this is not about um pointing fingers or blaming that we need to move together um because ultimately if we cannot move together the only ones hurting is our community right it's not about any one of us here it's not about who was here before us it's what we have in front of us so thank you Veronica for for those words um and the the difficult part right is that I think I can agree not I think I know I can agree with we need to be more um effective with our programs our use of resources the question becomes like do we all

058agree on what that means right like we can say one thing works and somebody else likes something else and that's where I think we tend to feel the most tension so I do ask that as we are going through this um that we remind ourselves of what's uniting us and that that again it's doing the best for our communities for our students for um the people who make um CB USD what it is and that we keep an open mind because we're not all going to agree on what the best way is there's going to be things we're not going to like there's going to think we wish we're there and are not there um and I think right now it's just about putting everything on the table that we can so that we can

059make the best decision and that as some of my colleagues have said right like how do we get to the point where this can be prevented like this doesn't have to happen every time there is onetime dollars that's those are things that we all knew and we all Tas that needed to be planned for um and here we are but I I do think again the only way we get there is if we can all be with an open mind and all hands on board to turn this over thank you VI president vas so hard to follow trusty pass with her eloquent words um well first of all welcome um chairman Tores uh I'm really glad to have you on on the board and um uh I do think that it's a definitely a voice

060and a perspective that I will um definitely needed in our in our board and and so I'm really looking forward to have the opportunity to work with you and just get to know a little bit more about you know your perspective and um the community that you've served for a long time um with respect to the you know my own report um you know I did get the opportunity to join um and attend csba this past uh weekend uh there are a number of things that kind of came to mind and stuck with me and especially as we're about to have these conversations that are you know very difficult um to have right I it's been on my mind since we've started talking about um you know trying to plan right and and I think

061we had um had we known what we know today you know two years ago I think um I think we would have you know better prepared right um I do appreciate all the public comments that were shared today um I think today's conversation um for me definitely keep in mind you know like the cuts reflect in our people right the people the community and so it is on top of mind for me um and I know I'm not being very eloquent right now but um I think it's just been hard right to think about um every decision is going to have an impact uh to our students to our classrooms to our staff um you know I I think as um we're going through this first phase having this first conversation um and approving going

062through our first interum um it's not the the last step the last conversation right we have been discussing ensuring um that we're preparing and making plans right and I think unfortunately we we failed to do that right um you know I appreciate Veronica's comments as well um you know we could sit here and blame everyone point fingers and that's not going to do us any good right and so I I really hope that we can all you know collaborate and really uh be honest about where the inefficiencies are um how we can assess what's working what's not um so that we can make the best decisions and try our best to um you know that that we are um making the best decisions and and supporting our staff and students and just looking at the

063big picture um I think I'll sh save the rest of my comments for the presentation yeah thank you thank thank you very much um I as well welcome you uh Mr tauris to the board member tauris to the to the board um we have worked together on other parts uh mostly I was on the staff side of that particular part but uh it it'll be uh it'll be nice to work with you as colleague um they've always valued your um U your kind of your your background and where you came from and how you got to where you got it's very interesting story many people don't know it but um it also gives people perspective as we all kind of came from our different perspectives and how we all grew up and and how that

064affected the way we look at life so I've always respected that and and uh appreciated that so welcome welcome on board um you know I don't need to rehash what everybody's already said um you know that you're absolutely right and again I have never been one to say otherwise I will not speak on behalf of the board but I'm responsible for everything that not only comes before but went behind and I've always said that uh the reason the county is sitting here is because last year some of the board members voted to do the right thing and make those cuts unfortunately you already know half of you know what happened who didn't do what still my responsibility my responsibility is to hold all those people accountable starting from the superintendent all the way down again

065my responsibility uh at the end of the day that that's what being a board member is about uh you may like it you may not like it in my mind that's our job and again people do things without telling us without asking permission we all know that um but again it's still at the end of the day we sit here it's our responsibility so again we are here because we did pass a budget last year that the county said hey looks good you follow this plan you're going to be okay we didn't follow the plan now we're here so now it's almost doubled in size and it's going and I don't want anyone to be under any illusion this is part one this isn't the be all end all this isn't just we're going to

066pass this and the Count's like Yay you guys are good and we're going to move forward there's more to come so I mean I I and and again I've always told you guys I tell you the truth I don't sugarcoat it I I tell you this is coming and you we all need to prepare for this and yes every position every person they have families they have things at the end of the day but we need to look at everything everything has to be put on the table youall know that we were consistently getting millions and millions of dollars every year and we were Staffing and we were doing all these great things the money ended and nobody wanted to cut anybody nobody wanted to go back that is a recipe for disaster and that's

067exactly what what happened so uh you look at everything we spent the temporary funding on um that's that's where you start those programs that we did those those people we hired the the programs we expanded all those things have to go back to where they were back to where we could afford it and that's going to be happening and again hopefully we understand that but I don't want you all to be here sitting thinking if they're Brave and they do this today that it's all over it is not I'm I'm here to tell you and I know you guys are shaking your head like oh my God I'm sorry I'm going to tell you the truth this cannot be the only thing that we do uh if we don't do things this year moving forward

068next year we're going to have to cut another1 1820 million off the budget again the more we do this year the less it'll hurt us in the progressing years you have to understand that you may not like that you know one of the associations you do your jobs you protect your members that's your job that's not my job my job is to make sure that the district functions that this student has enough teachers that he has enough teachers not over staff teachers not over staffed at the sites that he has enough teachers to get to do what he needs for his education and our programs are fully staffed in that way and we have to stop grabbing onetime Monies to solve our problems to try to put it in temporarily to get us through another

069year we got to stop that and that's been happening for a long time and again I only as you said we are responsible and again I don't speak for the board I speak for myself I am responsible for what has happened while I am here right now I haven't been the only one here but I will take my share of that blame for not holding people accountable uh starting from myself down to the superintendent and everybody else who you know sometimes decides that they have more Authority than they do so again I hate to be the bear of bad news here but this if we do this right this is not going to be the only one so you need to prepare everybody's talking about we're going to try not to cut no we have

070to prepare for this cuz it is coming now if people choose not to vote for it then they have the right to vote however they want to write but we already know what's going to happen if we don't do the right thing and right in our ship that man over there is going to talk to his boss and his boss is going to talk to the state and they're going to come in and take over and for those of you who have made public comments like maybe that's the best thing for the district I was elected once after the board had gone through this I came in after the fact nah it's not fun you have no idea how bad it is you have no idea what they can do and how they can do

071it you do not have an idea so we either take the pain now or take more pain later I mean it's going to be a choice but again as we vote that's going to be the discussion of the vote we either vote to do what's necessary and continue try to get the district out or or people choose not to vote and that gentleman over there is going to call his boss and the process will get started so again I I don't want to be the bad guy but you know they're calling me that anyway so I might as well accept the role we're not done if we do this right this is just the first part of it this isn't going to be the end of it so again Ive always told you I'll tell

072you the truth even if you don't like it and you get mad at me that's okay but that's where we're at and people need to start acknowledging that people need to stop promising things that oh we're going to do this and we're going to do that we're not going to do any of that stuff you know um I'm not going to pull like I normally pull you guys see me pull a extra Services report all the time for all the extra Services I had a conversation with the staff and questioned everything look extra services are great but they are that extra services and if we don't have money to do extra Services we got to stop doing extra Services we got to stop that's just that's just the end of it I've had a conversation

073with them I'm going to question all of them just cuz I don't pull them you know when I pull them you guys know they still get voted on anyway but I'm going to us keep having those conversations with them about do we need this isn't there somebody else that already supposed to be doing this we have to ask those questions so again not to be the bear of bad news but if we do this right this is our first step not our last step so with that cheerful joyous noise there uh Dr sparza well thank you that's a hard act to follow now thank you stated I'd like to um congratulate uh Miss parate and Mr bdai for for always getting us uh that Golden Bell we're so proud of our students and our staff

074uh that brought us to csba last week and uh we were able to to celebrate with about a hundred other schools um we won the uh environmental uh education award and so we're very very proud of our students and kidwind especially the kidwind program that Mr bada runs um I also want to um to congratulate transportation department who won in their area at the Coachella parade and they're holding up the trophy back there uh they've won first prize in that Coachella parade for their electric bus um I'd also like to congratulate the students of the month who won at rcoe student of the month this year I want to thank all the students and the teachers who are putting on those awesome presentations those holiday presentations at the schools uh during this holiday season um

075I also want to thank uh supervisor Manuel Perez tomorrow he will be opening or having a ribbon cutting right across the street from here uh to open up the first uh Park here in thermal and uh I'd also like to thank Lydia Rodriguez uh and Miss Felicia for putting on an amazing migrant program and making sure that our students were celebrated this year by the Unitarian Church they were all given uh gifts here Santa Claus was here to take pictures with them uh and it was a great celebration this happened here uh the day before yesterday so lots of great things happening I'd also uh like to piggyback on Mr Arondo uh congratulations to CV High School Desert Mirage High School Peter Pendleton Mount Vista um and all the schools who showed some growth this

076year we are very very proud uh that we were able to show some growth in ela and in math um and I want to make sure that all of our administrators in the back who support our uh the work at the schools that all of you are also uh thanked for the work that you do I know you are working with the coaches you're working with the leadership staff and we're making sure that we're putting reading and math first reading and math first because you heard the test scores you've seen the test scores reading and math first where an educational institution that needs to give our students the civil rights to learn how to read yes we do they need to learn how to read and so we want to make sure that we continue

077to do what we're doing to ensure that our students have the opportunities to be able to like our student that uh is sitting next to me here to be a student trustee to have that leadership skill as well as the students that he talked about one being the one from Desert Mirage who won the scholarship to Notre and so again thank you everyone who is helping us uh to make sure that our students continue to learn and that our con stud our students continue to thrive in CVUSD I understand that there are lots and lots of concerns in regards to our fiscal stabilization plan it is a plan that has been put together by the leadership team here in CVUSD and we want to make sure that every single student has an opportunity like I

078me mentioned to be able to read to do math math science social studies and to be able to have that education that they deserve and so with that we will be presenting a fiscal stabilization plan that is going to do just that it we're going to make sure that our students continue to get the education that they deserve thank you okay thank you Dr sparza okay moving on to the organizational updates item 6.1 uh superintendent Esparza approval yeah approval of the governing board meeting day time and location for calendar year 2025 anybody have any questions on those motion to accept St recomend a second I have a motion and a second any questions all those in favor hi hi hi student truste all those opposed motion carries 8 z Mr C maybe I I I

079maybe I should make this comment um this time last year uh we decided that we weren't going to have our Thursday meeting uh as part of we adopted our Master calendar uh respecting the day of the Virgin Mary and that's why we didn't meet yesterday it wasn't changed last week or the week before uh this was actually done a whole year ahead of time and it I just I heard that the meeting day was changed conveniently now just the way we're adopting uh today is what we did last year and we found out that that Thursday yesterday was was on that day and for a lot of families it's a an important day and we felt respecting it we moved it to to a Friday right just for the record thank you board member Gonzalez

080uh item 6.2 approval of certification of authorized signatures any questions there [Music] I motion the same I have a motion do I hear a second second okay I have a motion in a second any more questions all those in favor I student trustee all those opposed motion carries 80 item 6.3 approval to appoint the superintendent and secretary to the governing board so move second have a motion and a second any questions all those in favor I student trustee any opposed motion carries 80 item 6.4 approval to appoint the assistant superintendent of human resources or design as the affirmative action officer so move I have a motion do I hear a second I'll second Motion in a second any questions seeing none all those in favor I student trustee all those opposed motion carries 80 now

081we're going to move on to the presentation did I miss oh okay just so I've been reminded um we did speak about this before but just to I guess put it back on the record um the reason that we are not reorganizing the officers is because that is done usually after an election uh as you all know the county of Imperial made a mistake with the ballots they have rescheduled that to a March 4 4 March 4th election uh therefore when that election takes place and they are certified to the uh from the counties both counties actually but you know Imperial count is the one that's going to be doing that later um then they will have the restructuring of officers and trust me anybody wants to be president they can take it right about

082now I'm about done with it so but uh but that is the reason why some people have asked why that wasn't we discussed it before the order was everything stays the same board members terms are extended until there is a certified winner um U board member toras was uh appointed in lie of an election and that's why he is seated uh his election had nothing to do with the mistake that Imperial County made so could add um I think the press release from Imperial County says uh the certification of results would be on March 18th yes the election day is that they certify on the 18th 18th so after the 18 will have a certification the very next board meeting will have the reorganization of the officers uh for the board so I was reminded

083to read that we did talk about it before but just a reminder for those of you who did a couple of people did inquire about that why we weren't doing that part of the organizational meeting okay all right uh presentations sorry about that um item seven 7.1 presentation on CV usd's uh procurement request for uh proposals rfps and Public Works bidding procedures not sure who's going to take it all right I don't think it's on there we go student trustees and community members my name is Leia Torres thank you for being here today as the interim director of facilities I want to address recent concerns about our construction bidding process transparency and integrity are and always will be at the core of our operations I assure you that we are committed to the highest ethical

084standards our presentation demonstrates our transparent fair and compliant bidding process this presentation underscores our dedication to lawfulness and ethics showcasing of projects adherence to a rigorous and open procedure I express my gratitude to our team for their unyielding professionalism as we move forward your support and engagement are invaluable to us thank you for continuing this journey with us here's to a transparent and successful future providing optimal school facilities for our students and all stakeholders good evening everyone [Music] first I'd like to begin with the high level overview of the bidding process for those who are not familiar with the bidding process is a formal competition amongst qualified contractors and suppliers its primary goal is to ensure fairness quality and to award each contract to the lowest responsible bidder this process is essential in the procurement

085of goods services as it allows transparency and fair evaluation of all proposals here we have a list of laws rules and regulations that we must adhere to in order to stay compliant here at CVUSD first bullet is the casbo conference the casbo conference is a conference that purchasing and Facilities departments attend each year this conference provides comprehensive training in purchasing Public Works bidding practices and also provides updates or changes to the rules and regulations listed below edar which governs the purchase of goods under federal grants public contract code California Department of Education labor code and environmental compliance [Music] next here we have the public contract code bid limits public contract code 201111 is for purchase of equipment materials service and supplies that are not construction this threshold originally set at $50,000 but has increased to

086114 500 due to inflation over the years next you will see the bid threshold for Public Works which is $155,000 anything over $155,000 must go out for bid at the very bottom here we've listed piggybacks joint purchase agreements which are the only exceptions that do not require bidding these exceptions help the district leverage existing contracts from other public agencies please note these cooperatives still require board approval and do not apply to construction under public [Music] works okay Public Works fitting procedures First Step uh determine project scope and cost identify project need and details with estimated costs public bidding is required for projects exceeding $115,000 prepare bid documents include specifications plans bid forms deadlines and legal terms ensure compliance with applicable building codes and District requirements advertise invitation of for bids which what we call notice

087of inviting bids publish in a local newspaper for two consecutive weeks post publicly to ensure wide visibility we post this at our CVUSD bid manager [Applause] [Music] Chris conduct a mandatory pre-bid meeting any contractor bidding the project who fails to attend the mandatory job walk conference will be deemed a non-responsive bidder and will have its bid returned unopened provide clarification on Project requirements address contractor question questions to avoid misunderstandings those are the reasons for to conduct a mandatory pre bid meeting receive closed sealed bids open publicly read aloud at the time and place specified in the notice of inviting bids collect bids by the specified deadline and time in our case it's the superintendent's office where they are timestamped and held until the deadline open bids publicly and document bid details evaluate bids review compliance

088with project requirements award the contract to the lowest responsive responsible bidder and it's more acknowledge the bid okay awarding the contract the school board approves the selection of the bid that is been recommended by the facilities department or in purchasing departments notify the sealed selected bidder and issue the contract and issue a notice to proceive contract post award requirements ensure contractor provides performance and payment bonds verify insurance coverage licenses and preventing wage compliance you issue the notice to proceed after it's been awarded Grant the contract official authorization to start the project thank Chris monitor construction oversee work progress and ensure adherence to project specifications manage change orders and address disputes if necessary close out the project conduct final inspections and confirm project completion release retention funds upon satisfactory performance assure that the inspector of record

089is inputting his information into the DSA box to close with certification so here I'm going to show you I'm going to show you three different examples of what a bid summary looks like when we receive the bids we go through every single document in the bid packet and it's being checked off as you can see at the mega Playfield we had we had five five bids attend the mandatory pre bid meeting which only those who attend are able to bid the project we received four bids those are the results okay another example [Music] here Northshore the NorthShore project this project we did two mandatory free Bid meetings to get a wider you know bidding pull so we had 27 biders attend both both you know combined uh mandatory meetings and only one bidder bid we

090do not control who bids or the amounts they did on our projects here's another example Palm View Palm View we decided to do a multi-prime award multiprime bids so we we sectioned off everything by trade by category by trade we receive received 68 bids and out of those bids then you see the results of the lowest responsive responsible bidder then again we don't control who bids or how many people attend our pre bid meeting and the board members just for clarification board members are not involved in any way everything is sealed bids we open them up no one has any idea of what the results will be until the end we when we do the comparison so in conclusion the thresh the threshold for bidding public bidding is required for projects exceeding $155,000 pre wages

091contractors and subcontractors must adhere to State mandated wage rates and be registered through the division of industrial relations the dir transparency sealed bids must be submitted to superintendent's office at date and time specified and bid openings must occur publicly to ensure fairness pre-qualification requirements districts may require pre-qualification of contracts for large scale projects of over $1 million in this case we use a third uh party agency uh it's called PQ bids and they do the prequalification for us change orders change orders are allowed only under specific circumstances with board approval funding sources developer fees Redevelopment funds state funding Federal funding General obligation bonds and grants our projects are not based on uh the general fund and we do not take away any salaries thank you um before I open it up to questions um I

092know who you guys are but could you identify yourselves and your titles uh in your positions in the department please letia Torres inum director of facilities Randy mokin director of purchasing Christoper L Roa my project manager Mario L project manager facilities thank you now they all know who you are what you do okay thank you any questions I have a couple questions y um thank you for presentation um then these might be very basic questions cuz I'm not part of facilities are you know necessarily part of uh that process right but um I was curious to understand um when the bids are submitted it was mentioned that they're submitted to the superintendent's office is there a process once you start like are those bids um when they're reviewed um is there like a is it

093like a blind process or like how do we ensure that it's like a fair process that you're considering each of the bids that are submitted so they have to be they all have to we give them a list in the bid packets they have a list of all the documents that are required to be submitted so if they fail to to provide one of those documents they're considered non-responsive so let's say they're all four bids submitted all their they competed their package we go by the lowest responsive responsible bidder and make sure that they're compliance with all the licenses proper licenses and then their uh bonds are being provided okay and my last question I think in this it's in this slide that says um bid openings must occur publicly uh does that mean that

094there's like a public meeting that's a public like what does that mean no so when you advertise the notice of invite bids you're stating there the Lo the date time and location of where the bids are going to be publicly opened so anyone is invited to attend or public uh bid openings uh when you say openings of the it's like literally you're opening the bids yes and reviewing them so where do we notify the BS arrive the bids arrive to the superintendent's office and they get date stamps so at 2:00 we go and we pick them up from their office and we come either to the boardroom or to one of our conference rooms and anyone that would like to attend is is welcome cuz it's an open uh bid and that's where we we

095just they're sealed we open them up and start going through each packet but where like if I as part of the public um so the next bit's coming up how would I know when you're in the newspap and the notice of inviting bids it's going to be stated there like when you're going to literally open up the bids yes and that's open to the public it's open to the public okay thank you anybody else any questions [Music] just wondering because that does sound like um a lot of moving Parts uh literal right um with the paper envelopes the time stamping them being in in um Dr esparza's office all of that sounds tricky why haven't we moved to digital for digital bidding you mean MH mhm CU we've always we've always done it like this

096I mean that's something we can look into uh cuz for me that just feels like it would streamline the process for so many people involved the contractors as well um it just seems like there are so many moving parts and I understand that it needs to be tedious we want the best price of course um but it also seems like it could open up the pool of people that could fill in all of those Gap right the paper copy not missing any anything in particular um it not having to be in Dr esparza's office it all be timestamped digitally there was a dig digital fingerprint to all of that um so security wise I don't feel like there would be a reason for that to not work um I'm sure even the county does that

097you know so many have moved that way I don't want it to be just because we've always done it I want it to be as efficient as possible um for us so that we're getting the best prices right um so if this is a revolutionary idea we've never thought of I'd like it to be something we look into why aren't we doing this digitally yes we can look into it yeah thank you for your presentation um so so Le on on can you explain a little bit about emergencies and how that's sort of uh work is done out for our district when emergency takes when emergencies take place how do we select what what contract what contractor we're bringing out that would be under maintenance because I just do Public Works I do not handle

098emergencies repair Mr Baker can you please come up to the podium to answer that question I'd also like to um state that when the the bids are provided to my office they're provided to Mari Tarango who is the uh who is my executive uh secretary she timestamps them and I don't get to see them so I'm not a part of the bidding process uh hello everybody Baker Alo director of maintenance and operation can you repeat that question one more time please yeah so when we have emergencies as as sometimes we do right how do we select our contractors who come out well we try to do everything inhouse to start with um we do not Outsource anything unless it's out of our capacity to do so we have a master uh contract which went actually

099exactly the same steps and that's for thir maintenance and just a quick comment Regarding why AR we doing the digital form of bidding because the DSA requires hard copies just in case they want to go back and review the whole process and this is a common thing I worked in three districts and all three districts follow exactly the same bidding process it's all paper there there has to be a paper trail I understand that but we could print out whatever was submitted and have a hard copy or have them sign sign a a printed or a doc you sign like there are ways around yeah yeah I think they're working on a system very similar to Galaxy but it's not I know they're in some districts they're testing it right now but they haven't ruled

100it all over but they are they've been working on something to go digital to save time and paper and all that stuff right I do have a follow-up question um so I understand that we get these bids and we choose the the lowest bid is there ever a study done where we find out the final numbers after all of the change orders that can happen and where our bids actually fall CU people can lowball us and then it end up being several change orders later that we we ended up paying so much more than what was said in that initial bid right do we ever conduct studies that show something like that are we aware of of looking back and seeing how that goes because if that keeps happening over and over again and it's

101the same company I would prefer us to uh look at that more closely and become more efficient so so I know in deferred maintenance we actually let's say we have a master contract for plumbing for example so in the plumbing we know uh from experience what's the 100 things or items that we use for a plum job whatever the pipes how big they are and all that so these are actually the prices are listed in the bid and they also they list how much they're going to charges for per square foot of work if it's digging how many feet and it's different from how much uh how many feet they're digging in the ground so when we get the invoice most of the 99.9% of the time we actually do go back and look at

102the menu let's say the price menu that we have in these bits and sometimes I like it happened you know uh months ago when I was here the first time we got a code we we had a gas leak at CV High School it was a big thing and they we had a vendor come in and go ahead and do the work but when we got the the number it was too big I really felt that the distance was too long so we went and measured it so in in maintenance I I know it's easier for us than facilities because they work on way bigger projects but we have actually a price menu we know so when we see something that looks hey kind of like this is too much we actually go and look

103at we we we when we do the measurements we we look at the equipment that was used so Baker I want to ask answer her question as well so when we award the contract there's an allowance built in to the to the contract amount for unforeseen conditions which will cover change orders every change order gets approved by the board you have the choice to accept or deny it you can control that increase the allowance is disclosed to all the biders yes and that allowance is disclosed to all the biders so when you're awarding the contract we already have a cushion in there for any unforeseen conditions but it's it does we do bring it back to the board and you have an opportunity to either accept or deny it is [Music] that um so just

104to clarify um on your on your change orders though sometimes when they come to the board they work that has already been done or or will you always bring it to the board first CU I I've seen I've seen both before and sometimes I had to open it up us to liability right if we have a change order and we sometimes we have to approve it right if the work has already been done so how do we decide that it depends it depends if if it's something that it's urgent and it can't wait and it's within the budget sometimes we need to proceed and it comes back as clarification but the proper way to do it is to bring it in to you before work is completed thank you Le can yes sorry yeah I'll

105get to you one quick clarification it comes to the facilities committee first and then the facilities committee we never vote on anything we vote on recommendations to the board so if you hear that the facilities committee is doing all this we don't the facilities committee simply votes on recommendations to the full board if we accept we kind of do the shortcut and we are the ones that do all the work we see what it is we give a recommendation to the full board and the full board decides not the facilities committee we make recommendations just like everybody else who makes recommendations uh everything on the agenda so it normally comes through the facilities committee first not always because sometimes there's an urgency and we don't have a meeting in between but just for um and

106you should know this you're on the facilities committee with myself and uh board member Gonzalez it comes to us for recommendation to the full board that's the process so just doesn't go straight to the I just wanted to make sure cuz somebody's going to ask well you guys vote on it at the facilities meeting it does go through US those votes are recommendations to the board not votes to award a project or to okay change orders or anything else so just a quick clarification on that uh is he is he allowance a set amount like is there a like kind of like what you said we have a price like is it do you have a debt like a set amount that is allowed for a specific amount on a contract there isn't a set

107amount but we usually normally use a 10% okay thank you letisia staff thank you for taking the time to to bring um light on on something that there's been a lot of propaganda on right we have a racist uh reporter guy on TV who has used two board members the union president to to put a light over our bid process and and thank you for for letting us know uh that we follow the state standard on sealed bids it it is the methodology it is the way every public institution we are looking at digital development there's been some criticism on that because people are able to breach uh the information so uh institutions have gotten away from that and until they are completely comfortable that they can't breach uh the information I did want to

108tell I think Miss Vargas asked a question I believe she was describing every bid is sealed uh and you you open them publicly when you open publicly normally who shows up are the comp are the competitors right the if there's four guys normally they'll send a representative at that hour they'll watch the opening of these sealed bids and then you go through and you procure them and you pick the lowest responsible bidder I have a question for you Leticia as it relates to PMW School how many millions of dollars were we over budget at Palm View school for Palm View it was 12,900 okay Andia do you remember um I wrote a letter to the board uh when staff uh using they started with construction management subprime then we had Larry mowen and Mr Eric

109Lee as a finance director do you remember I wrote a letter uh warning the board that that project was going to be grossly over budget yes and and and it was done in a very simple way they basically took a construction management subprime contract as they bid it and when staff ratified the contract they turned it into a construction management contract period no subprime well it doesn't mean much it doesn't look like much but when you go from construction management subprime to construction management you basically are removing the insurance and liability responsibility from the construction manager if if if they were to put a pipe in the middle of the concrete and they had to remove it well guess what the construction manager isn't responsible the school district is uh another thing that they did

110magically and I I included this all in the letter but basically they took away the liquid of Damages for we had a 2-year uh uh it was bided a 2-year performance to deliver the school they they they they changed it to 5 years right in the final contract ratified and then they they did something very magically they removed the construction uh the what we call the liability uh for for delivering the project late in the original contract it was $2,000 liquida of Damages per day delivered over 2 years and they changed it to $100 instead of 2,000 well it doesn't seem like much but if but what these guys did for a year plus and that's how we got to that number is they basically every month they were collecting $130 to $150,000 from this

111institution and they were paying us $100 a day they paid us $3,000 in liquida of Damages they were no longer paying the 2,000 a day and they basically were paying us $3,000 and they were collecting $150,000 and they did that all the way to the end so I that was the reason that's the reason our our our finance director is no longer here that's the reason our construction guy is no longer here but but these are things that happen and I think it's imperative that we're we're following the process as you have I I wish that that and and we've had two board members have bought into this idea that we're doing something wrong here there's nothing being done wrong here no one board member letia does one board member have the ability to award

112a contract no does any one board member has any one board member ever been at present at a bid opening no does the facilities committee control who gets the work no does it does a facility committee to Mr President nuna's Point does a facilities committee have anything to do with who gets picked uh as a and what kind of work the final realization of what kind of work we're going to do no and so with that lety I want to thank you for being here I want to thank staff we're not the Wild Wild West we're Coachella Valley Unified uh School District we're a school district that operates and integrity and and we just we need to resonate that message because there is no wrongdoing here and I want to thank you guys for the

113work that you're doing it because it is very thorough there is no moving Parts there's a system in place that people need to follow right and when bidding online those types of systems become Dependable enough for the California uh for for California to to accept that as the norm I think we should go that way until then we should do it and protect the Integrity of every bid that's submitted to this school district thank you any other questions go ahead um for the bids when when a bid is put in the newspaper how is there a standard time for how long it's open two weeks two weeks in that standard and then how are the biders told that they receive it that they don't receive it is that standard as well so when they are

114awarded or not awarded are they told them we issue a letter okay to each of them and that's standard as well um thank you all I know this is tedious but it's important for us all to understand what our process is demystify it for the public um i' still say that if the federal government is able to figure this out that we can too um so again just figuring out how to safely do it digitally to take away barriers and really make sure we're getting the best rates that we can we know we need to be as efficient as possible for our students um on our community these are jobs these are important things for us so thank you so much for this information you're welcome any he other questions thank you all very much

115appreciate it Okay the reason you're here I guess 7.2 Dr sparo Financial stabilization plan whatever there it is you're showing my notes I don't want my notes it's not it's it's s this room check with tny no he had the right one [Music] [Applause] I know watch just M okay we're just making sure with it that this is the most updated version okay good evening board president Akuna board board memb CVUSD staff and community members uh I am Dr Esparza the superintendent of CV uh USD I've been the superintendent for a little bit over four months now officially uh and although I'm the proud superintendent of CVUSD I'm also the superintendent that has inherited a unstable budget this that is why we're here tonight I've brought uh this information to the board uh along with

116requiring support from rcoe who have been uh so much help in these past few months um and they've sent support to us to ensure that we make the right decisions in regards to the lack of concern that they have with our budget here in CVUSD therefore as a responsible superintendent I've created a fiscal stabilization plan with some recommendations from r along with our staff here we have danela tabarz who is our interim CBO we have Miss uh Dr Monica mowitz who is our assistant superintendent of human resources and we have our consultant Miss Debbie [Music] deal and I went to the next slide but it's not taking it there you go thank you and so on this slide I'm going to start with stating that uh ultimately every superintendent has the duty to inform the

117board of any concerns uh related to District Operations to student achievement and to the budget and this is about the budget that runs the district and it should run the district seamlessly our budget needs to be planned for and so as it reads there the board takes action on the recommendations brought forward by the superintendent so unfortunately the board was not aware of many of the concerns that I've discovered in my past few months so I have been bringing a lot of this to the attention of the board how did we get here how do we have an unstable budget these are the areas um that we know that there's been question so the lack of former leadership oversight over the budget assumptions for cost of living which we call arola Implement uh implementing overstatements

118and I'm going to have slides for these throughout the presentation the governing board approved staff reductions and it didn't materialize assumptions for negotiations were overstated with the claim that there was a 17% ending fund balance and I do want to state that when I did become the lead negotiator for the district the negotiations went well and we did settle because there was an overstatement there was an overstatement provided to the district we also know that it was mentioned in regards to Staffing that their Intervention Program was going to continue it was November December when I became the lead negotiator of course it was going to continue into January all the way till the end of the year with the conversations of creating the positions of literacy coaches and math coaches and mtss coaches in our

119district understand that there was an V vention program that had close to 60 teachers in it that were paid out of one-time monies and so as the assistant superintendent of ed services I needed to make sure that we lessen that amount that we made sure that we were not going to run on onetime monies so what did I do I made sure that we had some of our teachers in a literacy grant that would serve as coaches and we had some of our teachers in a block grant which was also a part of a literacy grant that were going to be coaches and we lessen the amount from 60 to 35 making sure that they were not going to be a part of eser anymore because I did know it was ending and I brought

120this recommendation to the superintendent so we did have a peaceful negotiation based on the 17% reserves that we had been told we had and we made sure that we followed through with the rifting of our teachers however many of them were number six placed one-time monies used to fund ongoing positions and so some of those teachers were made whole they were made permanent positions on onetime monies which is not something that districts are supposed to do um me go to the next I want to share with everyone that today this is our Year's deficit that's today that's 2425 we're in this year already deficit spending our coe's concern is about our deficit spending but it's also about our reserves because when we deficit spend we put our reserves in Jeopardy and so they have advised

121us to ensure that we have a fiscal plan that is going to allow us to have at least a 3% reserve and that's the minimum a 3% Reserve so the impact of overestimating the cost of living put us in this situation many things as I mentioned a lack of concern put us in this situation Miss Debbie deal did inform the district in December that we should not move forward with our first interim at a 3.94% cola so went ahead and did that and presented first interim with an inflated Cola the business department used those Cola numbers causing an estimated $16 million local control formula funding combined this is what happened in may we have the May revice it was said and this is this is in 2023 it said we have a 3.94 so of

122course our fiscal staff goes with a 3.94 but in early December it's recommended that we move quickly because there are several several things happening with the state's budget we move quickly to accept less than 1% or at least 1% for 2425 and then 2526 the final estimate came on May 2024 of 17 by that time we had already inflated our budget at a 3.94 causing for close to $16 million overstated budget we got into riffs we wanted to make sure that we were going to Rift our teachers to make sure that we were going to stabilize and these were our teachers that were in the Esser so former human resource leadership made several one-time funded positions into permanent positions without explaining that to the board that was given to us in an in an executive

123cabinet meeting that it had already been done and the board did not know and so they made decisions on a budget that they were not aware of had underlining ramifications that God is here our former human resource leadership failed to fully follow through with the board directive the board authorized reductions in force they missed deadlines they didn't get it correct the former business department leadership app approved human resource to move some staffing into grants instead of releasing them as approved by the board and and here we are this information that was provided to me to go into negotiations was incorrect and so we went into a loyal negotiations we made sure that we were on the same page with our bargaining members and we agreed on a percentage we also went into impass because we

124were at a point where we didn't agree and to to come out of impass we had to move up another percentage and then accept a 044 for the stiens that we give to our staff rcee's concern position control that's another concern that they have here so it's our reserves with our budget but ultimately it comes down to position control with human resources and so we need to have internal controls as a superintendent now I've noticed that there have not been internal controls I sat down with Dr Price I sat down with the executive cabinet to get an understanding of where we were with internal controls our business office ran internal controls when it came down to positions they are not human resources they do not hire they do not give contracts they manage the money

125but for several years position control has been taken place in the business office and not in Human Resources ultimately we received lots of one-time money as you can see here 199 million 199 million all the way back from 20120 and what was this all for was for learning loss this was for our students this money is for our students our students deserve more 109 199 million for our students and we're still at 80% deficiency in math and More than 70% deficiency in Reading unbelievable this is not right we need to rightsize the district and do the right thing we don't have this money anymore and we can't jeopardize that our students leave our district without learning how to read and do math they deserve more they had $199 million for learning loss and we're in

126the same situation that we were 10 years ago cuz our data looks the same even before covid so rco's recommendation for Staffing these are some of the things that they've asked us to do to ensure that we rightsize the district that we make sure that we have position reductions that we have Rifts and layoffs of those folks who were hired with one-time monies and Beyond and that we make sure that we rightsize the district by putting a Freeze and stop hiring and hiring and hiring in positions that we don't need they want us to implement the freeze immediately so we will be bringing something back next semester to ensure that we can do this but one thing I do know every student will have a teacher in their classroom we want to make sure that

127we reconcile position control for the current Year's budget as well and then we analyze the impact of any positions currently being funded out of one-time monies the option for the governing board to address the the district's deficit structural deficit this is a recommendation we looked really hard to find monies in the budget to make sure we didn't have to cut 500 or 600 positions all of us looked really really hard and what we found is that we can do an inter fund transfer and that's what I brought to the board at the last board meeting that we would be able to use some of the Redevelopment money to save jobs that we would make sure that we have departmental expenditure reductions and that's also reductions in Staffing a few months ago when I spoke to

128Dr Price I immediately brought the extended cabinet together and those are all the directors sitting on the outside of the room right now I made sure that they brought me their organizational charart and that they provided at least a 25 to 30% cut in their District I mean in their Staffing or in their their materials that they receive something that they would not need that they can do away with that they could help us to make sure that we are making the cuts needed in order to stabilize the district every director brought me their plan their plan of their Cuts is a part of this stabilization plan our options to decrease expenditures we have the six different options the ones that we have looked at are all here the rede Redevelopment agency funds to our

129general fund so that we could use for our deferred maintenance so that it's actually going to maintenance what it was intended to do it was intended to be able to help us develop our schools so we are using that wisely shifts of expenditures for unrestricted to restricted sources utilizing our one-time restricted funds according to allowable uses and when I say that it is because we will be using the elop money as well we want to make sure that our Auditors look at every single thing so that they know that we are allowed to use that money for those those items or things or people we want to utilize available prior year restricted balances for current year and we need to reduce vendor costs but this is the one that hits home it's the one that

130hits hard the reduction in force because it's hitting our classified staff our confidential staff our certificated staff and our management staff so as your superintendent this is not easy I need to put students first I need to make sure that the students again have a teacher in the classroom and have the necessary materials to be able to thrive so our summarized reductions are here and they're 46 million almost $47 million although the county has asked us to cut 44 million this year we added a little bit more where we saw we could make reductions not that what president Akuna stated is that this is not the first piece we will come back in January we still have to look at several different things throughout the district to see how we can continue to right siiz

131so this is what is required this fiscal fiscal stabilization plan is required to be a part of our first interim but what we are bringing you in January is what we feel the district needs in order to right siize and make sure the oute are not a catastrophe and I'll be showing you the next slide and the next slide is going to be mouth-dropping because you are going to see positions on there and you're going to know whose positions they are but this is what we need to do to ensure that our students receive the education that they deserve by rightsizing the district we have shifted from fun 40 which is our Redevelopment money to our general fund we're aligning unrestricted expenses we're reducing our contracts we're cutting our departments by 25 % we are

132cutting several staff at both certificated and classified levels and management as you can see we also have on the side of the FTE we have vacancies there are vacancies some departments are still wanting to hire those vacancies are are going to be closed we have a total of 197 staff members on this list per rco's recommendation the fiscal stabilization plan is step one it's a requirement we have to make sure that we right size the district to ensure that we give our students what they need the second step is stabilizing CVUSD even after rcoe isn't here even after Auditors aren't here we have to make sure that we are spending our money correctly to ensure again who's first here our students our students at this point as your superintendent I am presenting this presentation and

133the fiscal stabilization plan to the board for approval so we can continue to put students first thank you thank you Dr Esparza um might as well do the questions now then later when we vote on this thing so we can kind of get it out of the way wants to go first you want to go first so I noticed that there are a couple of discrep between what was uploaded and then what you presented right now um a couple of the tabs are a little different and then definitely slide 18 wasn't on the agenda and you and we don't put that on the agenda when the agenda is published and that's why we put an aster to make sure that we are going to provide this so as soon as the board meeting is over

134this presentation will be uploaded okay excellent um I did notice that some of the figures it was on there quickly was a little it looked a little different than what I remember so I want to the number of FTE here you go feel different than what we talked about the last three times I know that there were mistakes two of the times that we saw this but I still think that that's a higher number than it is because of the vacancies we didn't have the slot for the vacancies so they were already included in there and what you asked at one point was for us to outline the vacancies so that's how it gets to a little over [Music] 200 yeah I'm still that number is different than I remember before so the initial uh

135presentation that was taken to the board uh had didn't have the FTE added correctly if you recall and I think it was like 230 something the initial one after we went back to the table and we started you know updating and having further conversations this is uh the plan that uh cabinet decided to move forward with I mean it still looks different than what I remember but I can okay yeah so what I remember was the FTE being less but um so what what were the changes that you just stated that you that that cabinet came for uh that changed on this so if you recall when we presented to the board uh during close session the numbers weren't adding correctly um nothing was uh added additionally I think the first uh slide that came

136forward to the board had a number of 231 or 237 um here we divide we separated the uh actual FTE against the vacancy so it's the 197 plus the 8 which is uh close to what was uh taken to the board in close session so 20 205 FTE yes yes correct but none of the everything else Remains the Same yes that's correct thank you question I have a couple questions um in terms of looking at the positions um I know we've been discussing our enrollments um I don't know if you could speak a little bit to you know how did we consider our district enrollment numbers are projected decreases is um to ensure that you know the comment was made earlier that we want to make sure that every student has a a teacher right

137um I don't know if you could maybe speak to that so that it's clear and we understand speak to it so our enrollment is it's our enrollment is uh close to 16,000 and we need to make sure aside from making cuts and I brought this to the board that we have an attendance campaign being put on because what is happening is that we are losing Ada we are losing millions of dollars in attendance and so we can't have 14,500 students showing up every day when we need to have 15,900 and so it's about pushing at the schools it's about making our leadership at the schools and our parents responsible for bringing the students to school we need to make sure that we do a better job of tracking attendance and if we have chronic absenteeism

138that we take care of that immediately um I think a couple comments um it's hard right um I we went to CSV well I went to csba um I think uh we're not the only District kind of going through this right um I mean I unfortunately I I mean I wish we weren't one of those districts right but but we are uh nonetheless um I mean I think in looking at District budgets right I think it's common it's not uncommon to see budgets that are 70 to 80% Staffing right typically we see a lot of budgets that it's 10% 15% it's just like programmatic expenses right um you know I do see that there's a number of vacant positions I think it kind of speaks to me um our planning right like uh we we

139knew that these funds were going to go away and unfortunately we failed to plan right um and I think by the time we got around to the planning right um this is what it resulted in um so I I I appreciate staff trying to be as um creative um you know last week two weeks ago last week uh we saw the rest solution right and and I'm glad to see that you know um with the support of the county and staff um to look at that um I one of the things that I think comes to mind efficiencies right um we talked about again the planning right but I think in our mechanisms our protocols ensuring that if we identified these positions right um that it's for for the best of the district right um

140and that's hard to say right but um I think you know last year what comes to mind you know we try to plan right we we offer incentives uh you know for individuals who maybe wanted to retire early um you know we we voted on making reductions and I think the Hope was that we would avoid this right uh but unfortunately because of the lack of mechanisms that we have in place it's hard to hold us accountable right as a district uh and unfortunately we'll have to you know get familiar with Mr aay in the back right for the next couple weeks cuz he's going to hold us accountable right um and so I I hope that as a district and and I know I I'm not going to say I hope I know that

141we've been working with de deal the staff in the back um to develop the the mechanisms to do that right in the last week or so I know galaxy has been uh I guess for lack of better word scrubbed down um cleaned up and so um I don't know if you can maybe speak a little bit to kind of those mechanisms that in the coming weeks we'll be utilizing to ensure that that this isn't just a recommendation right we still have a vote um but it's really a directive right um and that's you all are asking us to be accountable to the decisions that are being made um so I think I like to hear a little bit about how we're going to hold us ourselves accountable to the decisions and um with the hopes

142of ensuring our stability uh fiscally that is a great question you know first of all well you know on that question we'll go back a couple of years we'll even go back a year and it's one thing to make a plan and start going forward it's another thing to monitor that plan and those are called the internal controls and we need to look deeply at those internal controls that are in place to make sure that what the board has approved happens in the budget and we also need to make sure that the internal controls that are between departments such as human resources and business are adhered to that positions are closed when they're supposed to be closed and that people have no authorization to open those positions so that's part of the work that we

143still need to do the other part of the work that we still need to do is looking at the revenue side of the books the revenue enhancement opportunities this district is hovering somewhere around 90% average daily attendance that's how we're paid that's where the money comes from more than 70 75% of your money comes from there a district of your nature which is an um un the unified districts they're normally around 95% now we do realize that over the course of the last few years with covid that those numbers went down but most districts are back to normal again yours is not just to put it in context that's somewhere around $4 million a year that we're losing ongoing and we need to do a better job with attendance so we not only look at

144budget reductions and what we can do with restricted dollars legally but we also need to look at those Revenue enhancement opportunities and do a better job with that at the same time we need to ensure the board that we are working on the internal control structure that's going to get this District going in the right direction and stay in the right direction so I hope that answered your question thank you can I just say the last the last thing I think you know it was mentioned that this is kind of the first step right um I I I think we've spoken or even public common right there's we've known there are inefficiencies within our district right so I think that the next step is really um you know unfortunately also looking at our programs right

145how are they working what's being what's effective um I think uh in a conversation with the teacher it was mentioned we do a lot and so I think it it is going to be a time we're going to be assessing and and um we've talked about cutting programs that are not working like the the comment that was submitted submitted online so um you know I guess you know let's make sure we're all part of those conversations and uh be honest about what's working and what's not I want to clarify two items the first one is on the total number of reductions it seems to me that I think my colleagues were adding the 197 plus the8 but I no you were reducing nothing you were not okay cuz I just wanted to make sure that

146it's 197 what you're proposing it's not 197 + 8 okay just wanted to clarify that so it's what they're proposing is 197 out of those 1978 are vacant and we're not going to fill them okay and then um with with regards to the shift from fund 40 to the general fund I know that the 13 million um was announced at the last board meeting but there was also a comment after by Dr Spa that it may be more so we are saying that it's not a maybe more it's 13 million by the resolution it is 13 million we still would be able because we got authorization from linta Coachella and Riverside uh we would be able to use more but we want to be conservative with 13 million right now okay thank [Music] you I

147know there already issues with our buses such as the overcrowding and the late arrivals to school I'm concerned that this Cuts might worsen the situation and I wanted to ask if you could please um clarify how this is going to be addressed so we'll be working um on making sure that we're also right ex sizing Transportation so routing methodology is going to be implemented we will have and I know we mentioned this uh a few meetings ago bology to be able to help us with that that's where you're going to be able to see on your app but making sure that we are bringing our students to school on time and that is all going to be electronic we're going to be able to see all of that there's going to be tracking of the

148buses and making sure that uh we're working with our staff to promotee the all-in attendance and so uh at this point we do see uh we do foresee that all students will be able to get to school on time and this is not going to hinder that thank you president k i I um I want to thank you for the work um it it obviously isn't easy we all talked about it Dr spara I I got a especially thank you um I when I met you it took me a while to actually have a conversation with you we kind of said hi and we I started asking you questions and I was concerned about about one-time funding going away I was concerned about uh test scores and performance and the holding of of the results

149I was concerned about a lot of the practices that our former superintendent had and we started having a candid conversation about about this that this could turn out this way and and it's been some time uh Debbie thank you for the work that you've done I think you were God sent had you not been here I honestly believe that that the state would have taken over by now um and and I want to thank you for uh you know we had a Sunday when I met you first it was a Sunday I believe Joselyn was on the phone call um Adonis was on the phone call and we were talking uh about some of the challenges that we had and obviously it was hard to hear and I we don't know it just it never

150for me personally one day we had a lot of money the next day we didn't have any and we could never get a straight answer out of finance and it was especially difficult when we negotiated because In fairness to the unions you know they would say hey well you have money over here and yet our department couldn't find uh for whatever reason couldn't add the nickel together to to say no or yes and so the fact that you ladies have been able to really uh tighten up the numbers uh you know it again it's a tough situation we're in unfortunately if we don't do something about it now and continue to do something in January uh it's going to get it's going to get even worse so with that I'd like to recommend staff's recommendation

151Mr Co I know that somebody else might have a this is just yeah I'm sorry that's going to happen yeah I'm going to be glad to recommend staff's recommendation on this item as it comes up later in the agenda huh Mr in the back want to comment anything well I'll ask him in in a minute um board member toras I know this is your first one and you're seeing this all for the first time um if you have any questions or comments or wait till later and and say what the hell's did I get myself into and uh but uh I just want to make sure well like I said our organization faced the same thing because of the onetime funding and the uh positions didn't State on the job description that you know it's

152only due the positions only due to funding availability right and that's one of the major things that should have been done that we've learned you know from from that mistake but we also looked at like you said earlier Mr President that you know five years six years ago that's the ground zero that we had to get back to because when we looked at you know the graphs and how we are spending and then we had to get back to NE zero Again The Net Zero budget and that kind of helped us and and I think that's what we need to look at as as a guide here to what we were spending you know a few years ago and then what we added but then blending that together like we're all talking about what's going

153to be best for the students what's best to keep um but we had the advantage of working with the government and our legislators to uh say that it it's going to be a a tiered staged uh SP spending down spending budget so we had bought a little time and I don't know if you have that opportunity to do here um if not then you know what what's presented is you know is what's presented and if the board prior has had time to look at the you know the repercussions and make sure like you said earlier Mr President that every student has the teacher has the education opportunities that we had 6 years ago before we were afforded you know all of these extra funding ability um but I but I think that's what we're looking

154at is my other question is this a task item on the agenda today or just Okay y it is so that's how I'm seeing it then is that uh you know I would go rely and defer to the board if you have reviewed this before I know I've seen on Zoom that uh some of it was on Clos session and so um I of the board you guys have been seeing this you guys have been reviewing this and looking at all of this I just want to make sure what I've heard from the public today and from the students that that the students you know my kids go to the school too and that that uh they're not going to be affected in an adverse way uh especially with with this bus and the transportation

15510 uh cuz I drive you know to school every day and I see the kids out there it's you know 30° and and 120° and I just want to make sure that that that's not affecting that you know they're all of that Domino affects their learning ability everything that we see here that we're looking at is going to affect them you know through the domino effect uh so if it's the best decision of the board then uh I I would defer to your defer to your decisions all right anybody else have anything Mr President yeah I just wanted to say also that uh as was said by the staff here that if you look um on online that we again we like we said we are not the only District um Pasadena laid off 200

156staff Paris laid off uh staff uh Santa Barbara uh unified their three schools there that laid off staff so uh and if you look there's more schools that have done the same thing and had to lay off staff we just have to make the best decision that we can for the students thank all right thank you um I'll simply close with a couple of things and since I'm already the bar bad news I'll just continue it as uh continue along um I want everybody to understand just because we enhance our revenue does not mean that we need to start spending it again that doesn't mean oh we can stop looking through and making sure we're right side izing and prioritizing everything we cannot oh we got money let's just go back to our normal ways

157we have to stop doing that that's how we get into these messes so if we're able to boost our attendance that doesn't mean that we're going to bring everybody back or start hiring more we need to be very deliberate and how we do this we need to right size make sure our staffing is is where it's supposed to be for not only our contracts but for our needs of our students so just because we start figuring out ways to enhance our revenue does not mean that we get to start spending again all right just understand that and and uh I I'll say the dirty word that nobody wants to say that that in my mind anyway that it goes along with with salary increases and and benefit increases at best we need to hold on

158to what we have uh with Benefits I think the board is pretty pretty solid in making sure that we maintain that level because I think that's important uh to everyone but for myself I'm not speaking for anybody else we need to you need to understand that means all that as well uh you know just cuz we enhance our revenues doesn't mean oh hey we can go do spend a lot of money no we can't that's how we got in trouble in the first time okay and then the other thing I want to reiterate because I said this before and people thought I was joking people thought I was being funny I'm not this has to be a unanimous decision from the board if it is not I will not vote for it we are not

159going through that thing that people decide well you guys vote for it CU I don't want to be called out later politically that I I cut people you know no it's a unanimous decision or I don't vote for this thing and we all know where that heads us um with all due respect and I'm not speaking for the board members uh you know board member thus if you know if if you want to abstain from this I would understand only because you haven't seen all the numbers if you if we prove it unanimously then I guess you know you understand that all of us agree but I'll just put that out there only because it's a tough first meeting you know it's a tough first meeting so now you haven't been into the meetings where

160we've seen all this we've asked all our questions and we've done all this so I I would offer that to you when M said unanimous I will give you that out so to speak only because you haven't been in all these meetings but I'll leave that decision up to you okay all right and anything else okay moving on the next item is the um uh Mrs dadis presentation of the 20 2425 first interim financial report which is what he's looking for good evening my name is anela Tavarez and I'm the inm uh CBO for CVUSD and this uh evening I'm going to be summarizing some of the points of our first inter on budget the governing board uh goal is to maintain a fiscal responsibility and it is done by uh maintaining a responsible fiscal

161budget that involves and seeks business and Community Support the superintendent is recommending the approval of the first um interam report which includes reductions identified in the district's fiscal stabilization plan that was just uh presented uh previously the district has been working closely with rcoe to ensure the necessary reductions uh needed for the district to remain uh solvent are followed through uh prior to finalizing our first interm report the district provided our Coe uh with the specific actions that the district was working on uh to identify address um our financial uh challenges the following slide is uh the budget assumptions that were used uh to prepare our first interum it covers uh Ada um we the district is funded on a three prior year average Ada so even though our current actual Ada is lower we

162get the benefit of being funded on a three prior year average at average is out our Ada for the three previous years um these assumptions are as of uh the May revision in January the governor will be releasing uh his estimates for the new fiscal year and when we bring forward our second interum those estimates will be included in the budget um the assumptions used are also a step and column for our staff 2% for certificated and 1% for classified um our annual CPI uh the Health and Welfare um statutory benefits and the cola for the current year and to the in the two subsequent fiscal years the next slide is uh a capture of our enrollment in Ada in the last four years as you can see the district has been experiencing a declining

163enrollment um as mentioned before we are funded uh on a three prior year average which uh gives the district a little kick in the in in the funding um but as uh Miss Debbie mentioned earlier uh our current attendance percentage is about 90% The District needs to work in trying to increase that percentage to a 95% which is the average for a unified uh school district and that would generate us about $400 million uh dollars uh year-over-year on an ongoing basis four 4 million 4 million 4 million 4 million I'm sorry scar Z said man I'm going to go pick up kid um this is a snapshot of our combined general fund and un uh unrestricted and restricted um budget uh and preparation for first interum the fiscal Department in collaboration with our Coe and

164their support uh worked very diligently as previously mentioned and uh reviewing and reconciling our position control and and aligning our budget um for fiscal year 2425 it's project it's projected to end with an unrestricted ending balance of 59.2 which of that 46.7 will be committed as part of our district stabilization plan and 12.4 million is our 3% required reserve for our multi-year projection um the district stabilization plan reductions were included in fiscal year 25 26 and 2627 um additionally in fiscal year 2526 the fund transfer from from 40 for our RMA was included in the budget unrestricted ending balance is projected at 40.3 million with 29.4 million being committed for the district stabilization plan in fiscal year 2526 and 10.5 million is the required 3% reserves and fiscal year 2627 a 3% uh salary cut

165across the board is included and required in order to be able to meet the 3% uh requirement uh of reserves annual Stefan uh annual staff step and column increases were included in the current and subsequent years negotiations for fiscal year 2425 have not been settled and they were not included in the budget and in summary uh previous recommendations that would have helped improve the district's Financial Health were not implemented including staff reductions while the specifics of these past recommendations have unfortunately evolved the underlying necessity for responsible financial management remains constant our actions today built on these initial steps are aimed at rectifying our fiscal challenges while maintaining our commitment to our students in education the the decisions regarding budget adjustments particularly those that involved Staffing changes have been some of the most difficult ones that

166have to be made these decisions were made with a clear understanding of our share responsibility to ensure the long-term fiscal stability of our district our Focus must remain on moving forward learning from our past experiences and building a stronger District together it is with this perspective that we now approach the necessary budget adjustments ensuring that our fiscal resources continue to support the high quality education of our students the stabilization plan will ensure that the gella Valley Unified School District remains fiscally solvent so at this time it is recommended that based upon the first interm report the governing board approve a positive certification I open it up for any questions this's a little different but go ahead so on your budget assumption plan I mean the that slide there we go that one um I noticed

167that in the actual Ada there is a projected decline like a continued decline how did you come up with those figures so that's just uh Ada is projected based on Trends kind of the trend that we see annually uh we have a spreadsheet where we track every year what our enrollment is what our Ada what percentage it is the district has consistently been averaging like about an 89.9% attendance so when um we're estimating Ada in the future years it's kind of like those same formulas based on enrollment and Ada what puts us at a 90% because that's typically what the district has been at so 90% of the last figure so it's always going to be lower that's what you're telling me 10 correct because the district is is working on a three-year rolling average

168um and because the district is declining so as the district declines the Ada factor is also declining still maintaining at 90% of that level um and taking into account the funded Ada model and so you will see that until the district stabilizes enrollment um you will see the Ada Factor go down as well as the enrollment Factor and that definitely makes a difference on the projected figures I mean because for our students in this District because our up count is so high we get a base for each student and then we get those concentrated funds but even just a couple students makes a difference um so this this formula I mean we're hoping to improve it it could mean a little better even than what this is I understand it's you have to project something

169and our trend has been such but uh it that's a big figure so essentially what What's Happening Here is that while we look at Revenue enhancements it doesn't solve your problem but you are leaving money on the table um so it's it's about getting all of the money that the district deserves to service the students right and so yes it's a complex formula the local control funding formula you get base Grant in some grades you get a little bit of an add-on called grade span and then for kids that qualify as unduplicated pupils for you know Foster use homeless um children also the free and reduced kids and English Learners you get a 20% bump and then if your certain population is up over 55% of those qualifying students then from that point on up

170you get another 65% of the base and so it really is a huge amount of money it's almost double the money when you look at the 20% in the 65% so every time that you enhance that formula by making sure that you know you increase enrollments and that you are really working on your average daily attendance then it means that you're going to get more money from the state that you deserve um because you still have to hire the teachers in the classroom whether the show up or not right absolutely um making sure that we get everything from the state that we deserve is really important and making sure that we're conservative but also working on it so that again the students this year still get funded for this year's funds because 93% of our

171students fall under that extra category right that's why our up count is one of the highest in the state so making sure that we're doing right by our students there's a reason why they get that extra funding there is that compounded learning loss we're still combating it I'm so glad we're making strides but doing right bar students means that this year's money goes to this year's students but thank you this information anybody else go ahead I have a question in the same slide regarding the assumptions um I see that we have a statutory Cola for 2526 that's 2.93 and um my I know that you know January is really when we're going to get a so is this um 2.93 based on some projections at the state I like um I feel like we got

172in trouble the last time because we weren't as conservative as maybe we should have been and so I'm a little worried about one to 2.93 are we being as conservative as we can be so let me walk you back to about a year ago um about this very same time where the next fiscal year was projecting at 3.94 we were getting a lot of messages from the state we were getting messages from the county office from fmap from school Services saying hey it's coming down it's not happening we're not getting those same kind of messages right now the next time that we will see a first peak of what the governor thinks next year's budget budget is going to be for Cola will be mid January right now we're not hearing anything different so those

173are the factors we're using and when Cola is set that's May Revis and then it is set for good and we go forward so we anticipate looking at the governor's budget about mid January for any any Cola changes up or down but right now we're not hearing anything different than the projections that we have from the state anybody else nothing all right thank you very much appreciate it [Music] okay uh let's start voting um item nine action Educational Services uh 9.1 u m Rodriguez requesting approval of memorandum of understanding with bu County Office of Education California mini Corp a motion to staff's recommendation Mr I have a motion in a second a comment any yes go ahead uh my only comment um I want to make sure that staff is monitoring the I I think

174it's said in the agreement that if we exceed the number of hours that we will be responsible for paying for that cost um so we just want to make sure that we're monitoring the the number of hours good point any other questions or comments seeing none all those in favor I student truste all those opposed motion carries 80 item 9.2 of Miss Sanchez requesting approval of a through G initiative to compete to complete excuse me data dive with kacheli high school leadership team I motion the same a second I have a motion and a second any questions on that any comments seeing none all those in favor I I student trustee all those opposed motion carries Z there we go now item 10.1 um Miss moldonado approval of resolution 20252 to open a purchase order

175with Daniel tires so I have a motion do I hear a second I'll second I just have a question okay um did did we how did we end up with Daniel's tires I mean I'm they might be the best thing in town I'm just wondering if there was a piggy bid process on this or Mr Osuna wait a minute Daniels Tyler is a service right they're a service provider for flat tires I'm sorry it's the piggyback it's a piggyback it's not a I have no question thank you sorry forgot to mention that I mean it's not in the thing but it's a it's a piggyback on the country is this on there anybody have any questions seeing none all those in favor I student trustee all all those opposed motion carries 80 okay and item

17610.2 uh Mr saladis adoption of resolution 2025243519 motion can I hear a second second have a motion in a second any questions on this all those in favor I I all those opposed any extensions student trustee all those um motion carry all those opposed motion carries 80 sorry I kept you late last only because that this is one of the ones we need to vote on first no worries um item 10.3 uh MRIs again approval of the fiscal year 2024 2025 first interim report and multi-year projection a motion I have a motion do I hear a second second any questions all those in favor I st truste any opposition motion carries 80 okay item 11.1 uh assistant superintendent uh meitz approval of second reading for board policy 411924 and 421 9.24 and 431 9.24 regarding

177aing regarding maintaining appropriate adult student interactions do I hear a motion motion I have a motion do I hear a second I'll second I have a motion in a second anybody have any questions any comments all those in favor I all those opposed student trusty motion carries 70 Mr Ado stepped out of the room for a moment oh s left too yeah I'm sorry um the motion carries 50 six with the student trustee sorry I didn't notice that he I saw him leave um item 11. two uh Dr Monica um assistant superintendent M sorry approval of State of California minimum wage increase 2025 motion I have a motion do I hear a second second have a motion in a second any questions this is just what it is this is our minimum wage seeing none

178all those in favor I I I st trusty any opposed motion carries 60 with both board member uh I believe board member Gonzalez had to leave and I'm not sure oh okay I forgot he mentioned he was going to leave after we voted on the other stuff um good uh item 12 consent calendar all matters listed under the consent calendar are considered by the board to be routine and will be acted upon in one motion there will be no discussion of these items prior to the time the board considers the mo unless members of the board or staff request specific items to be discussed and or removed from the consent calendar in which event the items will be considered separately superintendent assistant superintendent of ed services business and finance and Human Resources recommend the approval

179of all consent calendar items do I have a motion I have a motion do I hear a second a second with respect to anybody that wants to pull anything okay so um anybody want to pull something I already said my piece so I'm not pulling anything good okay they're over there going thank you uh seeing none all those in favor student TRD all those opposed motion carries um where am I one more you don't want to pull in no we're good um any we don't have anything more for close session correct uh item 17.2 motion to adour motion second I have a motion and a second all those in favor I I all those opposed motion carries we're adjourned at 1047 release based on what was voted today in the uh stabilization plan uh board

180members don't leave

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.