001e recording in progress all right good morning good morning everyone and welcome to the elro Unified School District special board meeting live streaming of full inperson board meetings will be available on the public to the public via the zoom platform today's meeting is being video recorded and will be available on the district's YouTube channel during special board meetings the public May uh make public comment on items that are on the agenda uh individuals with comments on General School District issues May address those at the next uh regularly scheduled board meeting requests to make public comment will be accepted for an item up until the board president announces the item generally members of the public will be given three 3 minutes to address the board if there are 15 or more comments on a specific item
002the board will reduce individual comment time to 2 minutes each if there are 30 or more comments on a specific item the board will reduce individual comments to one minute each individuals may not defer their time to another individual speaker to increase their total speaking time please be mindful that District students may be watching you are encouraged to address the board and the public in a respectful manner such that all those observing from children to adults are made to feel welcome safe and valued the board shall not permit any disturbance or willful Interruption of board meetings persistent disruption by any individual or groups shall be grounds for the board president to provide a warning and then to terminate the individual's privilege of addressing the board all right for the land acknowledgement uh Miss Davis we
003acknowledge that the elgrove Unified School District Administrative facilities and schools occupy the unseated territory of the Miwok the original people of the skies land and Waters where we work and learn the Miwok have cared for these lands since time immemorial they continue to teach their traditional knowledge that comes from and responds to the needs of the land and people who share it may our daily lives in work teaching learning leadership and Community engagement support the evolving vision of the Miwok for their community and these lands may we strive to acknowledge the past for the betterment for our of our future Generations may we look to our tribal Partners the Wilton Rancheria the descendants of the original people of this land to assist with the successful education of our community thank you very much and to
004lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance uh M Miss Buckmaster thank you very much uh all right to get us started um Mr Hoffman do you want to give us an overview of the day well thank you very much I'm so excited about today um really great opportunity uh to take kind of a deep dive for the board into the restorative practices uh work you can see we have the sample of the team that's doing the work there there's a whole lot of folks that are involved but appreciate um everybody that's here today um as we really take a deep dive into the work and as we you know as the board walks away I think one of the um common misconceptions with regards to restorative practices is it's related to only what we do
005after a student has done um something you know that that was that was that we needed to address and what you're going to see today is the Deep dive into all the work that's done um to create cultures and create openness and welcomeness for students and staff with the idea of of taking care of kids and taking care of staff so that those kinds of things don't happen but when they do we have some strategies to help uh kids uh learn from those from mistakes as well but it's much more preventative than reactive in nature and just very excited about that work so I appreciate everybody that's here to to share and then the second major topic we do twice a year this is an annual piece that we do we've uh with regards to
006reducing exclusionary discipline and there's a direct connection between the work that we're doing the restorative practices work um and the uh and the exclusionary discipline uh work and you'll see uh a great deal of work that's being done at the school site level with support of the um of all of the um Folks at the district office so again proud of the work um lots to do but U making progress so happy to share that with the board as well so thank you excellent thank you very much so let's get things started off um our restorative practices presentation Miss Lasser right good morning good morning president Vargas members of the board superintendent Hoffman Miss Avalos I'm GNA Echo what superintendent Hoffman said I am thrilled today to have the team here to present uh the
007roll out give you some information about the roll out of restorative practices in elro UniFi but before I do I want to make sure that you understand that this is a team effort this is not just me presenting we have several people today presenting there's also a team behind that as well so I just want to take a few seconds to acknowledge some of those folks um under the direction and Leadership of Mr Corey Jones who's going to present today as well as Dr Lisa Batista um they also helped with the roll out but also a program specialist Diane Stevenson and all of there not all of them but a handful of our incredible instructional Equity coaches are here who facilitate all this work so this work has been done in collaboration with this department
008with our schools and with our community so let's get started it's turned on so I want to just remind us we always start with our egusd learning vision and you're going to see here there is not one goal highlighted and that is on purpose restorative practices braids nicely into all of these goals and you will hear that today in our presentation that it will hit high quality instruction it'll focus on some of our targeted supports it definitely um impacts our wellness and our families and the community it impacts all students and all staff so with that I'm going to turn it over to Mr Corey Jones who's going to share a little bit about our agenda today and what the presentation will look like good morning everybody board members Mr Hoffman Miss Avalos thanks for
009giving me an opportunity and uh my team an opportunity to uh to share a little bit about what we've uh what we've done with this implementation excuse me so just a little bit of an overview of what we're going to talk about today um we're going to start off talking about uh what restorative practices uh or RP you might hear that throughout the um presentation mean specifically in elgrove Unified School District um we'll talk about how it aligns um with some other work that's going on in the district and we'll talk about some of the implementation Logistics and kind of how it's going um and we'll finish up uh with an opportunity for um the board to ask questions and a little bit of the plans that'll be on the horizon okay we plan to
010cover these items by sharing information data and stories from students staff Community Partners um who have been closest to the work uh for this implementation so this work started apprx proximately two and a half years ago when a 40 member task force began meeting to discuss implementing restorative practices districtwide these meetings lasted uh for approximately one year and included District staff families and community members and were facilitated by uh our Equity program specialist Diane Stevenson some of the task force outcomes decided on the initial focus on tier one practices which align with the district's mtss framework and support optimal conditions for student learning the task force also vetted and selected a partner that would provide support in this implementation that partner is restorative Equity partnership which you'll hear from directly here in just a few
011moments so this implementation this approach to restorative practices how does it fit into the work of the district so what we found in doing this implementation is that many folks kind of already have a conceptual understanding of how restorative practices supports the social emotional and behavioral legs of our mtss framework the restorative practices structures and procedures also strongly support the instructional leg of the mtss framework and you hear a little bit more details about how that happens in our presentation but uh holistically they provide Scout rles and supports for student talk active participation formative assessment and feedback collaboration and Independent Learning just to name a few of the highquality instructional focal areas that restored practices can specifically impact and these connections uh through the work have led to collaborations of District staff to braid in
012these supports so that the end users our instructional staff and students don't experience these separate things as siloed initiatives and I will invite up Dr Micky singer uh to continue with the presentation good morning I'm this uh Chief Executive Officer of restorative Equity partnership along with my business partner Dr Candace Forester we have had the amazing Unity to to work uh with El Gro unified to implement restorative practices I also want to take this opportunity while I can to truly appreciate the folks sitting in the room and those who are unable to join us the equity department and specifically the equity coaches have done a tremendous job in the implementation of restorative practices and it's truly making a difference in your District I want to pick up where m Mr Jones left off with the
013instructional framework and note that the instructional framework evolves with the integration of restorative practices to create optimal conditions for learning where students feel safe valued and heard thus increasing engagement collaboration and academic success there's a lot of research out there on restorative practices that I could have brought in to share with you today what I decided to do was focus on six related areas the first being high quality teacher and student relationships now all of us in this room know that meaningful relationships between teachers and students are the foundation of a positive School climate and effective teaching and learning the research on restorative practices confirmed that it Fosters trust empathy and respect between teachers and students which serves as the foundation for these highquality student relationships in the same regard all of us here know
014that increased engagement or students who are engaged will be more successful the research on restorative practices confirms that it increases Eng engagement because what happens is restorative practices minimizes classroom disruption it minimizes exclusionary discipline keeping students in the classroom and creating an inclusive learning environment in terms of student voice and agency I think we can all agree that Student Success is enhanced when students are able to take ownership of their education and to truly have agency what restorative practices does is it provides opportunities and structures for students to share their perspective tell their stories offer their opinions have a voice in decision making thus enhancing that agency and helping them to thrive in terms of instructional time the research is also instru Ive on that instructional time and what happens with restorative practices is that
015it deals with the root cause of Behavioral issues and behavioral disruptions thus preserving the instructional time again keeping kids engaged in the classroom a little bit about social emotional uh skill development we know that social emotional skills are crucial in schools and Beyond in my view in the view of the research more importantly restorative practices has been shown as one of the best ways to help students enhance their social emotional competencies particularly self-management self-regulation social awareness and building empathy and finally safety and wellness also critical for Student Success and candidly adult success in the school system as well restorative practices because it proactively addresses conflict and tension and intentionally builds Community ties has sh has been shown to enhance both teacher and student perception of safety and wellness of course these results these outcomes that
016we see in the research don't happen in a vacuum the results have to be carefully planned through int through an intentional initiative that integrates the head the heart and the how when we had the tremendous opportunity to begin working with the equity Department we began by working in Partnership to cultivate critical consciousness and what that means is attending to the systemic barriers that impact students success we also engaged in strategic planning that is intentionally aligning the district's Vision the mission and its goals with the tenants of restorative practices in order to meet stakeholder needs obviously we landed measurable goals and outcomes which Mr Jones we'll talk about more later in the presentation and that's important so that El Grove can make databased adjustments for continuous Improvement throughout this initiative but we know based on our
017experience in the industry and all the research that attending to the head in any initiative is not enough you also must attend to the heart so recognizing the emotional and relational aspect of Education what the equity Department did was truly commit to ongoing development of all staff to help not only build their capacity for restorative practices but also to help build capacity for empathy and for the ability to truly cultivate communities of belonging and through this lens of radical hope this district has maintained an unwavering belief belief in the potential of all students and all of the adults in the system and finally and importantly the district has prioritized the amplification of joy in teaching and learning with the intention of creating through the use of restorative practices braided with mtss as Mr Jones mentioned
018and your other initiatives with the intention of truly creating communities that are creative curious and continue to thrive me go back one last thing The Head and the Heart of course is not enough you also have to have the how and these are the strategies and pra practices that are going to integrate The Head and the how and um Miss raisen will talk about those specific practices later in the presentation but what's important for our purposes is that The Head and the Heart and the strategies the how they are part of a pedagogy that will serve as the foundation for restorative practices and the foundation begins with the definition of restorative practices that is adopted by this District before I read this definition to you I want to point out that the definition I'm going
019to show you was cre created by that 40 member stakeholder task force with the assistance of the equity Department it is Elk grov definition El grow foundation not some other District not something that was taken off the shelf and we all know that a definition is important for clarity for consistency to ensure shared goals and to enable a measurable impact so here is the definition that El grow has adopted for restorative practices I'm going to give you the opportunity to read it to yourself and I'm going to warn you I'm going to ask a couple of questions about it and and give you an opportunity to share your reflections e has everybody had an opportunity to read it to themselves fantastic now before I ask you for your Reflections I'm going to share my view
020of this definition my view of this definition is that this is Elk Grove's statement of its vision for restorative practices of the intention to build meaningful relationships and community of belonging to ensure accountability for students and the adults in the system and to dismantle inequities and inequitable structures by prioritizing individual and Collective safety and well-being so I have a couple of questions for you and I will say if I had my way if we were in a different setting and the logistics were different I would ask for you to come down from the dis and get into a circle and you might say why a circle and I'd like you to answer that question with the invitation for all of you to go out to the school sites and participate in or observe the circles
021that are happening in your classrooms that are happening in your staff meetings that are happening in the district office circles that are intended to build community circles that address and analyze content and curriculum circles that provide a safe space to offer differing opinions and have difficult conversations and of course circles that are designed to repair harm and restore relationships but short of that um we will at least do part of a circle here and we're going to use this talking piece when I pose the questions to you so if I may first uh can I approach diets and hand why a talking piece first of all the reason you use a talking piece in a circle is because it provides Equity of voice and I will tell you in the classroom it also reminds the
022teacher to be a facilitator and not to lecture thus elevating the opportunity for student voice and in particular to allow quiet voices to be heard so here is my first question we are going to go sequentially the way you're going to handle it is um Mr Vargas you have the talking piece yes I'm going to pose the question to you and then you will respond and then you will pass it you can choose which direction to pass it in pass it to and it'll go one by one okay what resonates and or surfaces for you about the definition what resonates or surfaces for you about the definition I mean the first thing that I noticed about the definition was that first bullet point it you said um that this definition is our definition it's the
023our school district's definition I remember that first looking at that first bullet point I was like yeah that's us like that that's that's our you know something that I have seen in the past two and a half years is a big priority right um is the is relationships right and it's not just our school district it's also elk grve in general relationships are incredibly important in El grve um and you know that that sense of belonging you know when when my husband and I first moved to El grov you know that was what we were looking for that was a big part of sort of um you know how we created Community was searching out that sense of belonging and we were able to find it here and so that has always resonated for me
024um you know within the school district and elro in general is this you know relationships and the sense of belonging so when I saw that there I was like oh yeah that's that's very much our you know bread and butter so you may choose the direction and uh pass the talking piece a minute there we go the thing that stuck with me was the word catalyze I got I got fixed on that like what exactly does catalyze mean in this sentence Etc I kept thinking C did it converter you know trying to figure these things out so I did I looked it up um to move forward quickly and um as slow as a lot of things move in education um you know maybe we can move this forward quickly by grasping it and just
025really taking hold and and using it that's that's where I came from uh I have to be honest I feel that from the presentation uh it's not very clear how this will be implemented so I would appreciate more clarity on that certainly safety and well-being of students are important to me and we need to ensure that for all students and not just some so I look forward to learning more thank you and I can assure you that Clarity will be provided uh throughout the presentation if you have any remaining questions at the end be happy to entertain those questions good morning um I I'll take a shot on the um second bullet point there I think that's very important um uh repair arms and restore relationship in community Through accountability ownership invoice to me you
026know what that means is that um there's mistakes going to be made um and it's going to be whole accountable however um we're going to use as lessons and we're going to implement it um with process and strategies to to make it better and uh heal uh the harm and uh restore it to um have better practices among um all members especially the students and the staff so um I think that's part of um restore practices um at its best really you know mistakes going to be made but there's going to be Resto practices so hey you oh it's made me laugh because I have a large family and we've used these at the dinner table before if not other places so um I really appreciate I think when U restorage Justice rested practices um
027has a definition that we've gathered from a lot of other noise in the world and um and I'm really excited about to see to to back up and appreciate the definition that we've created because I think it is very us and um we want every kid to feel connected because a connected kid is a successful kid um I sent my children from one area of the school district to a brand new high school and their safety and well beans of course but I want them to Bel I wanted them to belong I wanted them to have a place and uh and I also wanted all the other places on campus to appreciate them for where they were I didn't want them to be in a silo of I belong here and I don't belong with
028the rest of this group and so the idea of creating a imunity I think is wonderful and I and I've always said when things go wrong we're we're an education institution that's our job that's what we're doing we're teaching people and so this gives us a framework to teach both students and adults the correct way to have a community and to support each other and I think that's an invaluable thing that we are giving not only our students but we are giving our adults which we are the largest employer in town so we're we're doing for our whole community so that these are the parts that are exciting to me a community um a a place to work through problems um safety well-being and belonging so I think I hit on all three I I
029really I appreciate this definition well working in a school office um what resonated the most with me is the first bullet point um because the school office needs to be a place that everybody can come and be accepted be heard be seen um whether it be student parents or staff um by building those relationships I feel you go easily into the second bullet point because of those relationships you're able to address and speak up when you do have a my bad or someone else has one um so I think those two really resonated with me I'm excited to learn more about the third bullet point thank you I mean the uh the piece for me I appreciate everybody's um comments and the work that this this is us I mean I use I use the
030term people will say you know the district from time to time say oh you're talking about us we or so this this is the um an example of us uh all all coming together to do what's right um for our kids and our staff and our and our communities um as a whole and so very proud of the of the work and the commitment and look forward to the to the rest of the presentation if I hand it to miss aalo she'll smack me so all right the second question is how do your goals as a board member align with supporting the egusd restorative practices definition and we're going to go non-sequentially on this and when you go non-sequentially it allows for processing time and allows folks to speak when they are ready so the
031way we'll do this is I'm going to come and get the talking piece and I will be the person who um when you're ready put your hand out and I will come and give it to you it'll be a way for me to get my steps in it'll be perfect all right how do your goals as a board member align with supporting the RP definition in elro I could go first well I I think that uh as a board member um you should be part of the solution and to be part of the solution uh you got to learn um what are the issues what are the concerns and uh you got to get to know your your staff and um learn about each other so that you can work with each other uh effectively
032in pursuit of resolving the issues um so for me that kind of like the foundation of things and uh I have definitely done some of those work uh while I'm here um as a school board member and I think that it's um it's not an easy task uh by all means and it's definitely could be uh try and error meaning you know you use this strategy you use process and then maybe you work with the team and and the students and you kind of uh learn and uh change the strategies as you go so it's an ongoing um changing process and strategies and but the the a awesome part is that uh we've taken it seriously uh since I've been here four years ago my fifth years um we taken it serious uh we have
033increased um staff in our program and uh we have tried different uh ways of uh being effective so overall for me um as a board member um I I need to be engaging um continue to engage and continue to voice uh my um my my opinion and uh find ways to uh help any way I can um but we can't just uh sit up here on the dice and uh giving our you know opinion and um think that it's going to uh do it all but we we got to get our hand dirty we got to be involved so anyway that's that's my thought on on this when I think about my um my job as a board member I I recognize I came I come from a place of privilege um and I want
034my job is to to help those who do not and so I think that's a really important part that we need to make opportunities for everybody to for all children to thrive and learn and when you go to masa's Triangle we we need to work our way up we we are doing the things to help the children at the with with food we're connecting people through Community we're supporting children and they can only rise through that triangle and become their best selves if we provide the supports on the bottom I think the biggest thing I took away from my credential program with scaffolding and the importance of scaffolding and so we need to to provide the framework or the scaffold for everybody to rise to their best self and I think this is what restorative
035practices does um I think we need to recognize families have had bad experiences restorative practices is new um a lot of our children's parents had very negative educational experiences and we're trying to overcome that and tell them that we care about your kids right now we want your kids to succeed we look at your kids differently than your teachers looked at you we look at your child as a treasure that has hopes and dreams and we want them we want to know how we help them come true we want to help you I've never met a parent that did not want the best for their child and I've been all over this school district and so I think this provides us a framework for adults and for children to rise to be their best selves
036so I think that you know one of the one of the important jobs of uh you know being a board member is that the school districts can feel very insular um particular to particularly to people outside of uh the district so you know parents and community members often feel like it's very difficult to sort of break into like what is the school district doing and to get in accurate information quickly and effectively and we are constantly um trying to find ways to be better about that um but that is one of the roles of a board member is to be the conduit for people um when someone has an issue and the district is you know understandably busy and isn't giving them the time time that that they deserve then they come to a board
037member and board members can kind of clear out some of those barriers um and so I think that goes that for me that is building meaningful relationships um and you know we the district relies on the participation of parents and community members in the education of children and so making sure that there are as few barriers and as stronger relationships with those individuals as possible um you know will only benefit our students and our community as a whole and so we as a board um to the extent that we are out there being present in the community um nurturing relationships with the community uh building relationships with parents and parent groups and different organizations um you know is I think incredibly important to what we do and leads to Stronger relationships between parents and students
038parents and teachers you know when students uh when parents know what's going on they are going to have a stronger relationship ship with their student with their parents uh or with the teacher um with staff and a lot of the sort of consternation that comes from I don't know what's going on and that's frustrating me um can get washed away when we have those stronger relationships built and we have a part to play in that we use a talking stick in my family too because we all talk all over each other it's ridiculous but um anyway a rain STI works really good too because it makes noise and calms everybody down um my goal uh one of my major goals as a board member is to visit the schools um as many as we have
039even if I visited one a week it would take me over a year so I'm starting and and getting out there doing it as best I can but when I'm out there at the the schools I want to listen to not just um the principal or whatever I want to listen to any other parents that are out there to the students because believe it or not they have they're very intuitive they really are um and and the teachers that are out there because uh you know things like we have the new Miwok school it's going to be what we're using to build future schools I want to go out to Miwok and I want to talk to them and find out is there anything about this that you would change if you build a new
040school that's on my agenda to do um and there may be things that they can change maybe things we can't change with the next one but at least I want to hear what they have to say and see if I can make a difference and by by listening to everybody along the line and grandmas and Grandpa whoever's there at pickup with me um I will help to build more of a Community cuz elk grve is huge when I tell people 320 square miles they look at me like wow that's huge and it is um but yet you know I have relationships with people that are sitting in front of me here and up on the deis and all of those relationships help you know people better and know what people may may need in the
041future so I I want to do more out there working with the people and finding out what their issues are and hopefully my my job will be okay let me bring it back to the superintendent see what we can do about that there you go the question that was asked um was does the talking piece have a name and I will tell you this talking piece is uh was is used by the equity Department that's where it started and the idea is what this elephant symbolizes and that is through restorative structures and through restorative circles and grouping strategies and conversations we will surface the elephant we will deal with conflict and tension in a way that repairs relationship relationships and rest the community I don't know if it has a name though y'all need to
042work on that it has a name elepante elepante all right anyone else like to weigh in thanks uh so again belonging is really important to me uh and I think you know Mr Hoffman always says we have a very diverse district and that is very important um and we need to recognize that and ensure that all students feel welcome and I don't think we always do that so we certainly need to be better at that um regarding safety uh many parents have expressed their concerns for safety and you know in the big picture they want to know that their kids are safe at the school sites and um I've heard that so many times this week just with the incidences that we've had within our district the school sites but even even more so what
043I have heard from so many parents is that they also want to know that if their child is bullied or if there's an incident of inappropriate behaviors they want to know that those issues will be properly addressed so their kids can be safe and feel safe at school every day and so that is um really important to me it's kind of funny it's an elephant because my family we always talk about we play with the elephant in the room rather than ignoring them um I I when I become a board member I wanted to take what I did at the school site and make it more Global I wanted to create those relationships with people I had not met I have a lot of relationships in the district but there's so many more people out
044there that I have not met and I want to have relationships and hear from them um also I want to use my experience my family is mixed race and well I have had the privilege of of walking the path as a a white person I've got to see and experience what my children and my husband have gone through in life my nieces and nephews and I want to be able to use that experience to bring that voice to others and to bring Insight in to conversations um and just provide places where they feel safe to be able to talk about what's really happening in their life before I move on I want to thank all of you for sharing your Reflections I'm grateful it doesn't often happen in a uh school board meeting that we
045get to hear uh your Reflections and get to know you um in a relational sense so I truly appreciate that thank you just a little bit more from me and then I'm going to turn it over to folks from the equity Department uh to provide a clear a deeper Clarity and insight into the actual specific practices and skills that are being trained and uh what the process has been in addition to the restorative practices definition El grov has also landed for itself restorative practices principles and I'm not going to take the time to read these principles to you but I will say the way these principles are used are as the framework for restorative practices in the district to each of these principles there is a core skill or practice that is aligned so that
046the adults in the district know exactly what is expected of them in the classroom in the building and in the district office few more points I want to talk a little bit about the teaming approach that your district has taken as part of the implementation process we all know that teaming is the driver of organizational change and your district has truly invested in that teaming process what they have done is they have created tier one teams for restorative practices at each School site and these tier one teams that are made up of teachers staff including uh folks who work in the office folks who work in the ca cafeteria social workers School psychologists Etc so a wide range of folks from a specific site are on this tier one team and they're leading the implementation
047efforts on the ground the district also has an incredible team as I mentioned earlier of equity and restorative practices coaches from the equity Department that offer specialized support to the school sites are providing incredible professional learning to teachers at all sites and are also providing ongoing coaching to the tier one teams themselves it is through this model of distributive leadership that El Grove will truly engender continuous Improvement and accountability for the implementation of restorative practices across School sites and ac across School roles and responsibilities and last but not least in terms of the professional learning that is going on in your District Miss raisin will give you real insight into it I just wanted to point out that the model that elk grve has adopted is systemwide it is multi-level we're staff at all levels
048are learning skills and practices to support optimal conditions for learning the core components of the professional learning is relational pedagogy truly focusing on creating authentic and meaningful relationships focusing on skills and strategies to engender accountability for act for our actions and to provide safe spaces for healing to occur in addition the a core component of the restorative practices professional learning is culturally responsive instruction practices and pedagogy and then opportunities for folks to truly action plan for long-term success with that I would ask Dr patista take over all right ler this good morning uh president Vargas uh superintendent Hoffman and Miss AOS and the rest of the board welcome the new board members uh my name is Lisa Batista I'm a program specialist in educational Equity leading and supporting the districtwide uh restorative practices implementation I'm
049also a proud mother of two young daughters ages four and six um and they attend one of the yearound sites in elro um my investment in this work and in this District runs very deep um as I see it to be honest with you elve unified is a part of my family um as a for former Elementary School teacher and instructional coach in this District I'm honored to be standing here today to share the details of the implementation the data we've collected thus far um and some exciting future work that educational Equity has on its Horizon and with that um let's give you a moment look at this graphic it's a lot of information going on in this graphic uh this graphic details the restorative practices professional learning implementation plan uh when we invest in
050people's learning the impact of their learning has the potential to transcend generations of students we began the restorative practices pilot in the monter trail region in early fall 2023 um after that uh we trained the majority of the principles and vice principles in restorative leadership workshops um and then after that in the fall of 2024 this school year we trained tier one teams um across the district and we're currently in the two-year span of the site based workshops um workshops one through four of um the site based workshops and Miss raisen will be speaking a little bit more about the content around that um another key part of this implementation process that I'd like to call out is the ongoing support provided by educational Equity leadership and the equity coaches um to share to ensure
051the sustainability of the work going on at sites um also as you can see in this timeline in purple um we're currently in the process of engaging in the tier 2 and tier three pilot process and district office um implementation so you might be wondering what is the pilot process um tier 2 tier three strategic plan has five phases the first phase is really engaging with sites the pilot sites around learning learning about their systems every site in elro I think someone mentioned earlier elro is huge it's vast and each site has its unique personality and culture and so really engaging with sites leaders around learning what's going on at sites learning about their mtss tier to one to two to three processes um to ensure collective ownership from then we move into phase two
052of the action plan or the pilot plan and that's really working with site leaders educational leadership and the site principal and vice principles to uh create an action plan that's feasible with the current resources at the site phase three is the implementation process the professional learning which strategically aligns with adult learning theory and the sites tier 2 and tier three teams will engage in that professional learning with staggered coaching Cycles um truly in educational Equity we really believe in not just the training but also the coaching involved with it uh phase four is the evaluation of the pilot plan where we'll conduct empathy interviews and um we'll gain insights on the overall perceptions that folks had and their feedback and then finally in Phase five that's the fun part educational equity and the other ed
053services departments will uh action plan for a sustainable districtwide roll out similar to what we did in tier one um some additional restorative practices workshops that we've uh uh currently um finished and completed and we have um for the future scheduled is in Fall of 2023 we did an overview with the Learning Systems leadership team the lslt um in the year of 2023 through 2024 we engaged Wellness providers in an optional overview Workshop um we were able to train over 150 Wellness providers um there was high interest there and then working in partnership with EGA Union we were able to hold a restorative practices overview workshop for uh the union exec board so they were able to share their insights on the content of restorative practices um we also held a cabinet restorative Workshop experience
054in the fall of 20124 this school year uh future exciting work coming up uh secondary counselors will be training all of the secondary counsellors uh across the district in Spring of 2025 and then some ongoing work that we've been working on with re is uh the equity coaches also receive support from RE through community of practice so they receive the professional learning from the vendor themselves some additional restorative practices uh workshops uh we know that at the site level the work goes beyond sites it's really uh throughout the whole District um so starting in Spring 2025 we'll begin offering halfday restorative practices workshops specifically tailored to district office employees um and then we'll also offer another half day for management um in terms of restorative leadership skills um we're currently working with the business services
055side uh to create an integrated restorative workshops model um that's aligned with their current system thinking professional learning plan and so that's in the works so as you can see here uh the districtwide implementation is incredibly multifaceted um and we in educational Equity are working intentionally Ally in Partnership across a variety of District departments you might be wondering okay how are we going to evaluate all of this um with a multifaceted districtwide implementation the evaluation of restorative practices is incredibly complex in nature and we like it like that uh we are engaging in intentional mixed methods design of evaluation in which we're utilizing qualitative and quantitative approaches to ensure that we measure the implementation itself as well as the impact on staff and students in our schools so some of the data sources include uh
056post-workshop surveys interviews uh one-on-one uh prospective survey data action planning documents meeting notes um we have the full gamut with this we're working in direct collaboration with the amazing members of uh research and evaluation uh to utilize the powerbi data along with uh qualitative elements such as the interview datas I mentioned earlier so as you can see the implementation process thus far is has a continuous cycle of evaluation we truly look at every level and when we know better we do better uh both the qualitative and quantitative data approaches has an intentional focus on the amplification of individuals voice as Dr singer mentioned earlier um this District's large so that is incredibly difficult um but we truly believe in listening to the voices of those that are doing the work at sites uh now that
057you've heard the large scope of the implementation I'd like to walk you through some details of the implementation and some of the incredible data sources that we've gathered thus far it's pretty exciting all right uh so I'm gonna go backwards a little bit the first level of the implementation was the restorative leadership workshops uh there were 95% of principles in Vice principles that attended these three-day workshops in the spring and summer of uh 2024 I'm so grateful for them they gave up their summer days to come and spend some time with us so raw numbers you might be wondering that's about 165 principles and vice principles across the district and you're probably wondering what about that other 5% hey what happened to them so the 5% that weren't unable to attend the restorative leadership workshops
058uh were due to new hires in the district so they they came on board post uh registration start date um and some individuals were also on medical leave from their position so we'll catch those 5% up Don't You Worry uh every site team that attended together expressed complete gratitude for the time learning and action planning together uh specifically principles that had new Vice principles uh I heard firsthand they were incredibly grateful for the three days together as you can imagine um as a principal and having a new prin a new vice principal getting to know uh one another is really important uh I think president Vargas mentioned earlier relationships are a key part of the fabric of elk grve and so really truly folks walked away from uh the three-day restorative leadership workshops really gra
059grateful for the opportunity to spend time with one another so at the end of the three-day uh training cycle principles and uh Vice principls completed a post-workshop survey I'm going to now invite you board members and superintendent Miss oblos and cabinet and everyone in this room honestly um I'm going to invite you to engage engage us in a gallery walk so as you can see around this room right here uh We've posted um some of the qualitative data that we collected from the three-day workshops with principes and vice principls uh quotes and Reflections from the survey data at the end of the gallery walk it'll be about six seven minutes give us a chance to get some steps in shake some legs um at the end of the gallery walk um I'll be engaging you
060in uh a few questions I'll ask you to share some quotes that resonated with you or what some powerful themes or statements you read okay are we ready and for those of you who are um going to stay seated we will uh have a video as well right Mr Vargas might I uh suggest that we make it 10 minutes and give folks opportunity to walk the walls and then do any um anything El they may need to take care of during that time I was going to say that sounds like a good idea so why don't we take 10 minutes um Bo so board members can walk around and if you need to um you know take care of anything else uh use the restroom anything like that grab water uh anything else uh you
061can use that extra time to do so so thank you very much thank you [Music] e e e [Music] for [Music] e e for [Music] all right folks let's bring it back board members [Music] my watch is buzzing it was exactly 10 minutes awesome thank you president Vargas yes FS get settled um similar to what Dr singer did earlier um we're going to invite you all board members to share with us um what resonates with you and or what themes or powerful statements you noticed um we'll go ahead and do this sequentially um and I'll give it to whoever would like to start um elepante is it okay to go ahead I think my biggest aha reading around the room is that everything that's said restorative practices I think could have been replaced with a
062word that says Equity it was just it's the same goals to me of seeing people as people giving everybody an equal chance and and and I think they're just they're the in so many of these quotes you could have just changed it from restor practices to equity or Equitable and and that really hit me because that is a goal that we've had as a goal as a board for a very long time and trying to find ways to do that that are um but it's it's a very vague concept almost it's very Broad and wide and it has but this just puts some um some framework to it that I think is very excited thank you as I was going through um where were you seen Equity I also seen arbinger um seeing the humanity
063and everybody um so that's exciting to me that we're going to be able to cross over there um the one slide that that stood out at me was the incorporating circles in ongoing meetings I I think sometimes we roll out ideas and then we stop and expect everybody to remember and keep practicing and I I think it's really important that these become an ongoing part of staff meetings principal meetings secretary meetings whatever meetings we're having we need to keep pieces of this going so that there's continuous learning on it absolutely thank you I kept going first earlier so I was going to go last but yeah can I go last okay all right I'll listen to the board president um well there's a lot of uh great cats um to me it's what what sums
064up to me is um there's there's caring there's passion um there's strategy involved and uh there's int intentionality um at the end of it and and that's a heartwarming for me um and the most powerful thing is that uh we don't just do for one group of um people but we doing for all and that's students staff and the community and I think that's um sums it in in the sense of we really want to be better better people across the board and uh empowering our kids uh which why we all here and it's very powerful um you know coming from a background of a refugees um English learner uh minority being a bully being this and that um discriminated and and and being confused being accepting yourself because you felt like you're not good
065enough all of that I think that um we still have it here because this is very a very diverse school district and we have newcomers um like immigrants refugees and for all the work that we do um I'm very happy to see it so thank you yeah um so a few few words that jumped out to me U empowerment somebody said that uh you know their staff left feeling empowered um obviously that's huge part of what we want we want people feeling engaged feeling like they're part of the community feeling empowered to do their work um you know another thing that really jumped out of me was um one of them said that it's created space for collaboration but also feelings um and I feel like in a in the work that we do we're
066often you know working with people young people um who are having big feelings um and you know trying to helping them work through and learn how to handle those big feelings um and you know part of that is handling our own big feelings um and you know some of us are better at that than others uh I'm not always great at that uh and so you know I I feel like that is something we don't often talk about um you know directly is that emotional management and how all of that fits in and so I'm I'm glad that kind of popped up in the in the feedback um and then the last thing was somebody mentioned uh you know in one of the quotes uh you know the that it brings in the community uh
067it brings in families it brings in parents and I think that this is one of those ways that we can sort of you know that the things we do here uh you know push out into the community they push out and give students uh and kids opportunities and and tools uh that they take home with them um and they can use in their family and friend groups and uh you know and I think that that's important it gets them you know agency as we were talking about right to and and a feeling of like ownership over oh I can handle these situations um even when I go home and I'm no longer on campus and we are no longer the ones um you know sort of uh we are no longer the community that they're
068dealing with um they're taking those with them um and that's going to be good for them throughout their entire life thank you I actually have a couple questions um there's one of them that said um I want to redo what happened on the last day so now I got to know what happened on the last day um and what exactly are circles I'm what do you do in a circle all of that kind of stuff that's that's my questions to you and maybe what is the difference between restorative practice and restorative justice and is and maybe you can explain that to me that okay should I oh okay we're actually gonna go into answering those questions at the end of the presentation okay all right throughout the presentation okay okay and other than that just
069um it's funny Susan and I are opposite opposite ends but we have a lot of the same thoughts um I was thinking also how arbinger this this seemed in a lot of ways as caring about people learning about people um learn caring what happens to them Etc and so it seems like a continuation of that which I can't see that as a bad thing at all let's put it that way yeah thank you uh reading you know all the quotes it seems like it very positive feedback uh I did like that they um you know the kind of common theme was that um the sense of belonging and supporting everyone which I think is important uh I would love to better understand how we are doing this um with this practice so I hope that
070can be um we can learn more um and then I would also like to know if you could can clarify um the difference between restorative practice and restorative justice and the differences and similarities so we can better understand thanks thank you I think we had one more down at the end part of the board but I'll take it um so for me the um the piece that comes through um is pride in being U being part of this team and um giving people uh the time they need to um self-reflect um interact with each other so much of this work is focused on who we are as individuals and what we bring to the table and our experiences and also providing the time to learn and hear about other people's experiences because everybody's experience is
071different so um hearing that and seeing that through the through the quotes I do um agree completely that there's a very clear um alignment um with the idea of the outward mindset and seeing the humanity of each person you engage with on a daily basis so that it's not it's not a completely um different concept there's a there's a lot of overlap which I think is important thanks thank you so looking through the full set of data um today you walked through and you looked at a small sample of the data and so what I'm going to present to you now are the themes that elevated from the quality ative data and they're very much aligned with um what you saw as well leaders saw practical applications and resources from the workshops and I would
072definitely say the call out between the arbinger work that this district has done um definitely primed them for that uh leaders left understanding the need for building trust in amongst their school community and how the Workshops can Empower I think someone mentioned that too Empower their school communities there was a definite call out for continuous leadership support beyond the workshops in job embedded coaching leaders saw the direct connection between RP and the mtss framework furthermore there were Reflections that RP was in alignment with the highquality instructional framework secl and the continuous PBIS work um throughout the district and there was definitely a mindset shift uh site leaders left um thinking about restorative practice as a reactionary tool for discipline issues to a proactive approach to focusing on relationship building and I think a few of
073you mentioned that the core piece of looking at folks and their Humanity right and building trust and relationships amongst one another I think president Vargas called that out earlier that's at the core of elk grve and that makes me very proud to be here um we're going to watch a video of of um some Elementary and secondary principles about their journey in modeling restorative leadership skills and the impact it's made on their campuses and as you watch these videos I'd like you to note the ways in which our leaders are becoming restorative leaders throughout the district probably one of my biggest takeaways was just the empathic listening I know I am guilty of this and and I feel like listening is a little bit of a lost art I kind of personally I fallen into
074a lot of the formulating what I'm going to say while someone else is talking instead of truly emptying myself and listening to truly hear someone so as an adult learner that was great for me our first training of the school year was during pre-service and so our facilitator came out and modeled how to run a community circle with our teachers and you know it's I think everyone's aware that you know students feeling a sense of belonging teachers need to feel that same sense of belonging at a school site just the prompts that we were walked through especially during that first meeting there were some teachers who were getting choked up and the feedback that I got from folks after the majority of our trainings was that the relationships on campus went deeper than they ever
075have knowing someone's story knowing the things that they're struggling with feeling support from your colleagues that's been a dramatic change for us I think the big Focus for us was tier one and being proactive and a lot of times people think of restorative practices as reactive and after the fact but know it is a way to community build and it can be about content and still Community build and so having the ability to then use it more as student talk and like I say Equity of voice that's huge because someone who's a little more shy and doesn't want to speak up now feels like they have a chance to talk not one person in is stealing the mic the whole time I think as the workshops went we could see different spaces for staff to
076use it and different types of staff so whether it's custodians having a meeting and working on a problem of practice or just building their community and again a newer employee being able to speak up because sometimes as veterans we think about like oh we have the answer and so then we just teach someone our way but now they have their chance to share their voice so for staff it was really helpful as well I've seen it more in action like our early adopters like I've been in classrooms where they've asked me to come and just see how hey look at this what advice would you give and in some spaces it's actually creating more student dialogue which after the pandemic is huge for us and with so much screen time for students it's such such
077a big impact to give away that students feel accountability to talk but also feel like it's safe to talk in the classroom I've seen it in action with the early adopters for sure and then like I say we use it at staff meetings pretty consistently and we had some big events over one month span where we we needed to kind of divert our attention to how do we keep our culture how we want it to be and we threw out what we were going to do with instruction and said we're going to focus on circles and getting our staff to agree on how we move forward so that our whole school culture could turn around and and luckily I think it did it shifted quick and I think the circles had to do with it
078I would say belonging means you are part of the community um your your presence makes an impact when people see you they know your name or they know something about you this you take ownership as a student as a family member as a staff member this is my school this is my community you take pride in it you don't have graffiti everywhere you have people using the restrooms the right way you have staff talking in love to one another and you see people trying to help build each other up that's belonging we we love we lead each other we serve each other we give to each other with restorative practice it's like you're giving everyone a second chance over and over to repair any damage we recognize this is the harm being done okay what
079are we going to do about it let me self-reflect now let me see it from someone else's position now let's repair it if we work on forgiving having mercy and loving people the way they want to be loved or treated the way they want to be treated we could create a better school Community I am so incredibly grateful for those leaders and sharing their experience here you can see a quote from one of our secondary principles our leaders around the district are truly invested in restorative practices but as Dr singer described earlier their leadership alone cannot move a school the Strategic implementation plan is built on empowering schools for sustainable change via strategic teaming within the mtss framework so what does that look like um after the site leadership trainings um in the spr in
080the spring and summer school sit's tier one teams attended two full days of restorative workshops we focused on empowering teams alongside principles and vice principles to ensure strategic sustainability of restorative practices at sites 100% of members from tier one teams across School sites all School sites attended the tier one Workshop days as Dr singer mentioned earlier teaming is the engine of organizational learning in a catalyst for transformative change especially in a district this large school sites utilize their mtss tier one teams as a structure for implementation there was intentional braiding of uh districtwide initiatives within the mtss framework and each site worked on their sit's action plans that were aligned with the six restor of benchmarks this was a districtwide effort to say the least there was a districtwide partnership between educational equity and all
081other ed services departments to ensure all folks that support tier one across the district attended the tier one Workshop days there were 681 individuals that attended with School site teams individuals consisted of family Liaisons from the family and Community engagement Department principls Vice principls instructional coaches from curriculum and professional learning Avid the department of multilingual education we worked in partnership with student health support services to ensure our Wellness providers such as mental health therapists social workers and school psychologists had the opportunity to attend actually some of them loved it so much they attended twice because they service multiple sites we worked in partnership with Elementary and secondary Ed to ensure the feasibility in the coordination of site commitments that's definitely we did not want to impact sites right people are off- campus for those workshops
082as you can imagine this was no small feat these tier one Workshop days also had support and partnership with our human resources department thankfully to ensure that our sites had enough sub coverages to ensure teacher leaders from each site were able to attend as well I received many emails and Reflections from individuals expressing gratitude after this opportunity um furthermore folks expressed it was the first time they had an opportunity to have Regional conversations amongst Elementary and secondary sites and that was strategic in nature I'm going to pass the mic over to one of our Equity coaches um Amy raisen as our Equity coaches are facilitating the vast majority of the restorative workshops across the district good morning board members and Mr Hoffman and Miss aalis um I'm super excited to be here um and share
083some of the incredible work that our team has done in terms of restored practices um as an instructional coach for educational Equity I just want to mention that I am one of 11 amazing coaches that are facilitating these trainings connecting with administrators staff um team members across the district so my hope really here today is just to tell a story to paint the picture of what resor of practices is what it looks like um and most importantly why we need to focus so deeply on creating community and connection for our students and staff um in order to create incredible educational experiences for everybody did I go the wrong way just kidding okay um so I wanted to start by just kind of talking a little bit about resorted practices um as a team we were
084all uh trained by Dr singer as trainer of trainers and I remember walking into our first learning opportunity of restorative practices with a circle of chairs just sitting there open and realizing that this was an invitation and almost a demand to participate um and when we walk into these types of places we sort of think we know where we're going to sit like all of you had your seats today if you had walked in and had a circle waiting for you it might have felt a little different um that's the feeling of the tier one team um when we did those big restorative practice days eight hours um for them sitting in community with us to learn a lot about what RP is um and how it's going to create Community for students to be
085able to learn for teachers to be able to teach um and for that connection to be really meaningful and impactful um when we did our tier one um our tier one uh uh days with these folks um there were some themes that really came through that were really imperative um that this was about relationship building and community building that restorative practices had this incredible transformative power uh for both individuals and school culture so that people could show up as they are in order to be able to learn and to be able to teach um empathy and compassion and accountability uh that fostered emotional intelligence and responsibility in both students and staff and the tools that were there to be able to implement this this wasn't just about touting the idea of building relationships but what
086does it mean to build a relationship how do we do that what tools are needed what strategies do we need to implement to do that um and so as we go through talking about um breathing this Humanity into the classroom humanizing experiences um the tier one teams were asked to engage in restorative practices all day they weren't in a sit and get they were learning what it felt like to be in community to use a talking piece so they sat in circles and experienced what it was like to actually talk about real issues that they were seeing in classrooms and in the school sites um and then of course what challenges they might need and that we were touting equity and inclusion as the most important components um this is just a quote from one
087of the elementary school teachers it's a tier one team member um that their takeaway was that restorative practices should be implemented in my classroom and in my interactions with my students to cultivate a positive and trusting classroom community and again one of the things that we had in conversation with folks during these times is that they recognize that these communities have to be built in order for students to feel safe enough in order to learn and so that's what we really focus on in these tier one team uh Team meetings um as far as school site uh sustainability I have to say that I can only speak from the eye in terms of the things that I know that I'm doing as an equity coach um the 10 other coaches have VAR uh different areas
088that they are supporting it is responsive to the needs of the school sites um and so one of the things that we are all doing is we are in conversation with administrators um some of us monthly some of us by bi-weekly to talk about how can we Implement restorative practices at the school site um at many of the sites we have Community circles in staff meetings on a regular basis so that staff can experience those um we also have opportunities for the administrators to practice the skills that they learned in RP as they facilitate their meetings um and then in terms of the tier one teams because we're in the midst of the site workshops being rolled out uh we're between Workshop one and two right now uh working with the tier one team right
089now to at each site to determine what it is that we're going to do for next steps with restorative practices so does that mean doing circles in departments does that mean um trying to gather more data and understanding of how circles are working um so each tier one team at different sites is really thinking about how to be responsive to that site's needs in terms of where we are in the implementation process and then from a coaching perspective um one-on-one coaching opportunities with teachers to do demo lessons to co-construct community circles content circles circles that allow uh students to embrace the idea of a talking piece to have agency and voice um I can say at one of my sites uh we had a sixth grade Retreat Day where the principal really wanted the sixth
090graders to understand the influences they were having on campus they were addressing some um concerns in terms of just relatability and Community amongst the students and so we did a community Circle for every single sixth grade uh student went through a community Circle and what was really empowering and beautiful about that is that at the end of this opportunity where students could share how they were feeling about going to middle school how they were feeling about being at the top of the the um the pile as a sixth grader and that influence that at the end of the circle when we asked one word of how does it feel to have engaged in this circle um after students shared of themselves they said things like safe comfortable heard seen valued appreciated and so when we
091listen to kids say that they have these experiences and watch them open up in vulnerable ways we as staff experience that too um and so it's been a really lovely thing to be able to see um and then just kind to go back to this slide I know Lisa uh or Dr Batista brought this up is that we are currently right now rolling out Workshop 2 um and again we are continuing this process in a very thoughtful and slow way so that we can continue to make sure these practices as they're implemented are really getting that goal of student connection and belonging and then getting that learning to occur in our classrooms so I want to talk just a little bit about what each Workshop is entailing for the school sites so that you can
092get a sense of what restorative practices feels like um we just finished almost all of our Workshop ones and what I will say is that when I do this with my colleagues and we all have partners and coaches that we work with when we um facilitate these workshops this first Workshop is really to demonstrate to staff what it feels like to be in a restorative space so it's not a sit and get they come in they walk in just like we did on our trainer of trainer days where they see these circles and to watch their faces sort of like oh gosh I have to I have to be a part of this um is really important to note and we're really thoughtful about making sure they feel connected and that we're inviting them into
093this space and we're looking forward to hearing their voices um what they get to do is something similar that you all experienced today they're looking at the restorative practices definition as it is specific to El grve unified they're wrestling with it as well the word catalyze actually comes up a lot people are really curious about that word um the idea of nurturing relationships the idea of repairing harm the awareness that we make mistakes and that we need to be able to cultivate accountability um all same exact experience that our staff members are having with that definition and they get to be in community to talk about it um so when we talk about that definition we then move into talking about those principles right those ones talk about how important it is that we have
094community and belonging and most importantly we tell staff during this time that this is their opportunity to be seen felt and heard as staff our teachers are also human beings in this process and so when they get that 45 minutes of a listening Circle what they're really grappling with is a quote that asks them to think about what it feels like to be asked to be resilient and so they're talking to one another about what this job demands of them and how they can show up and Community with themselves and with one another and for students and when we watch participants in a listening Circle where you have an opportunity to share your experience as a human and as an educator um and then hear what other people have in reflection as a response to
095that um it's really empowering and to watch teachers walk away and say wow that was the first time that I felt really heard um in a long time or this is the first time that I have been able to connect with colleagues on this campus um in a meaningful way so they get to really experience what it feels like so that they understand that facilitating a restorative space is just that and what that space should feel like in Workshop 2 um it's great that we talk a lot about relationship building and community building and belonging I think one of the things in the past 15 years as an employee of this District um I've always heard we have to build relationships but how right how do we do that so where is the actual tool
096to do that so Workshop 2 is a really nice dive into some tools that actually give us an opportunity to create restorative and relational spaces we talk about authentic relationships we talk about how we have to acknowledge every person in the room is both lovable and capable and that that is the foundation of relationships so we call on them to think about relationships that are authentic to them so that they can feel inside what that means to them and then we ask them to really think about how they can ensure that students both know and feel that they are lovable and capable in a classroom and then we talk a lot about the social discipline window that as Educators it is imperative that we are working with our students within that lovability and capabilities that
097they are going to be able to meet the educational challenges that we're asking them this is access to highquality instruction we do not have access to high quality instruction no matter how beautifully it's planned if we aren't working with our students to have them gain that access so it's not being in a space where we're doing something to students we're not doing it for them we are doing it with them so we really talk about the importance of creating space for that so that we know that students can rise to the expectations of that instruction that we want them to gain and then the empathic listening um often times teachers I think go to a place where they're not sure how to create a relation ship or they don't want to do it wrong or
098they don't want to you know uh they don't know how to fix it so they avoid right that elephant or whatever their experiences empathic listening is a tool to say really what you need to be is a set of ears and a human that just listens and holds it with a student so if there is something that someone needs to share it's just being that person to hear it and that that person and that student knows that you're there to hear it and so we talk a lot about how this is the Crux of building community and relationship so our students feel seen loved and heard so they can take off that armor in our classrooms and be vulnerable enough to learn and then in Workshop three this is the circles part so I know
099there was a question of what exactly is a circle so um this is where we get to it as well with our staff so now they know what a restorative space feels like now they know how to create authentic relationships to build that community so now when we do circles we have an opportunity for learning to occur um in this particular place we are seeing that participants um are experiencing Equity of voice right so we have a circle set up right multiple circles can happen in a classroom it's not always just one um but we're teaching multiple circles where there's a talking piece going in sequential order passed around to answer a prompt it can be a prompt potentially about community and connection it could also be about curriculum right we could be looking at
100something that is uh a quote from a from a novel or a passage from a history um book and they can work with that within a curricular Circle but the equity of voice is there there's a there's a strategic way in which we're speaking to another and students have agency and connection there's no barriers in between them um it's a pretty stark contrast from several years ago when our students were sitting in Zoom boxes and now they're sitting in front of one another and we're really humanizing the space um not just for Community but for curriculum and access as well so um in addition to that it's also problem solving Circle so that students have an opportunity to think about how they might look at something critically so the circle is the tool the what
101is is what we need to decide as a teacher is this is this curriculum Circle today is this community circle is it a little bit of both um and there are so many different circles in in the resor of practices world that we have access to so we talk about that once we've set that foundation in the first uh two workshops and then last one is Workshop four um this is kind of when a little bit of repair might need to happen or we need to redirect students and we need a tool to be able to say hey um um we need to kind of get back on track and and get back into this community space so that we can all continue to feel safe and to learn um it brings all the skills
102from the previous workshops together using affective statements to communicate impact of student behavior um so when we see something that we're we're needing a student to shift we're talking about the observation that we see the feeling that it's evoking the need or the change that we're looking for and what solution we're asking for in agreement um so it's a really structured way to have a conversation with a student to redirect that's mindful of the humanity of both a student and the community of the classroom and then the um restorative dialogue component to be speaking specifically um with those uh questions to have a restorative dialogue so that we are asking students specifically to recall what might have happened in that incident how it you know impacted them and their Community um what might need to
103happen next Etc and so these are some real tools that we are slowly trying to roll out so that sit St have an opportunity to intervene with students um when things are going in a direction that we need to sort of redirect or ret I have always said that when we are teachers right we teach science we want students to learn science and we teach math we want students to learn math but we want people to learn how to behave it tends to be consequences ideally restorative practices is not that right it is teaching them what what it is to mean what it means to have accountability and to be in space with community and be accountable to a community that matters to you if we don't have Community we don't have anything to restore
104back to so that's why we talk so much about the importance of community building and connection because we need to be able to restore back to that um and so if we don't have that initially there we can't restore back to a community with students um and then in terms of just the workshop data um I just wanted to mention that we have 65 School sites that have completed Workshop one so almost all School sites have gone through Workshop one the 81 sessions is a notable thing because at uh multiple School sites we had more than one session occurring especially at our larger secondary sites what the pilot taught us was that doing this in smaller groups was really important so trying to do a staff of 120 people in one big room for Workshop
105one uh the pilot taught us that we wanted to be in smaller groups so we tried to put them down to about 40 so that it was the same size as a classroom so we're still showing teachers that you can do this with with classroom sizes um but what we also did was we were really intentional about mixing up staff so that it wasn't just by department or by people who all knew each other already at those larger uh sites but that they had an opportunity to really mix in and talk to new people at their school sites um and one thing that I did want to share um I just had an email from one of the ones I just did last week um where she said that um this uh teacher said that
106I was trained in restorative practices at my old District when I worked in the Bay Area and have been doing community circles for years I love them do them with my classes often and would be happy to share my Reflections I was also participant in the Inner Circle of our training the other day and feel like I finally got to connect with colleagues outside of my department for the first time since I started here a few years ago that was really cool and very meaningful for me so when we have transformative experiences like that for staff we know that that will translate to students as well for a place of belonging um Workshop 2 we just are in the midst of rolling out right now so we've have nine School sites trained uh one of
107those School sites has um done two sessions so we've got 10 sessions um Workshop three and four there are seven School sites that have been um uh completed those and we of course have the pilot region um and then we are continuing as Equity coaches to be really responsive after we facilitate those workshops so if there are asks which there always are of how to do a circle um what it is that we can do to help support the work at the site um it is not just my experience as a coach my colleagues as well have emails coming in all the time about how can we get this going in my classroom how can we put the circles in place um for my students so um that is everything um that I have mostly
108uh the last thing is just um talking a little bit about um just the um the community of belonging and and the connectedness um we see that from um this the qualitative data on the survey like what your biggest takeaways were um teach teachers and staff emphasize the importance of feeling connected supported and validated by colleagues um resorted practices like listening circles help build relationships and Foster a sense of shared understanding that Workshop one uh really created space for teachers to share personal experiences and emotions which allowed teachers to feel seen and understood and strengthen their bonds with peers in creating an environment where vulnerability was welcomed and that teachers left Workshop one inspired to implement restorative strategies like Community circles the backtack building connection Community empathy with students and that the resort of practices
109experience in Workshop one provided teachers with space to release emotional stress reduce feelings of isolation and address burnout through connection and shared experiences with their colleagues um and it's really important that teachers not feel alone because teaching can feel very isolating and very much in silos so I really appreciate your time thank you so much um I'm going to pass it back off to Dr Batista hi y'all I'm back thank you Miss raisin she's taller than me all right so we're going to move into some more data and some um insights that we've gathered thus far um in the restorative practices work we really truly hope to actualize voice across the district so as a part of the qualitative data we're collecting in educational Equity we are conducting empathy interviews with individual teachers so um
110in a moment you'll see a short clip a video clip um you'll also notice the teacher is not facing the camera she's actually facing me you're going to hear my voice in the background um and I'll be prompting her and to elicit some of the sharing of stories about her experiences and the experiences of her students uh you might be wondering what makes an empathic interview what is that all about so one key part of an empathy interview is to utilize the empathic listening skills we teach in the uh workshops so as the interviewer I'm intentionally using these listening skills you'll hear me uh you won't see me but you'll uh hear me paraphrasing her um I was mirroring her I was attuning to her I was validating her statements um so you'll hear a
111bit of that in the background grade one teacher I had a kiddo that was just having like a tough time and we're on our Chromebooks and I asked them to shut it and they like Slamm their Chromebook kind of put it on their desk they were just having a tough day any little thing that I said was just affecting them we were doing a writing activity and he just had his head down not really part participating while they were doing independent time I kind of like went over to him and was able to have a conversation of how his actions were making me feel and how that's kind of affecting everyone around him and then I asked him what's like what's going on like why are we doing this and we were able to have
112a conversation and he was just able to see how that like affected me and then his classmates and he was able to apologize and it turned around and I think a lot of the time we feel like oh in first grade they're not ready to talk about how they feel or how they make other people feel but identifying how they feel and their feelings and how other people feel really important if they can do that now then hopefully as they get older they're able to see that their actions do affect other people not just like physically emotionally too I can definitely resonate with that my first grade daughter has big feelings lost thought all right um so as you can see in our educational Equity team we continuously reflect on our practice our own practice
113and we adapt throughout the implementation as a team we calibrated and we realized the camera was challenging for some folks to really share their experiences so we just moved to audio um for our empathic interviews um in this audio clip that you're about to listen to It's a seventh grade teacher um you'll hear my voice again um utilizing those empathic listening skills validating her and paraphrasing you'll also hear um the secondary teacher mentioning miss mlin one of our awesome Equity coaches um as she's the regional coach for the Monteray Trail region um and she's continued to support teachers admin staff throughout the implementation one is that I've integrated some small group instruction into my classroom so I've had a few students and my second period for the most part targeting most of my second period
114English seven there's a few students and they are like very avoidant when it comes to classwork and the class is primarily classwork I don't give a lot of homework even with sentence frames just like have a really hard time time just getting work done I think earlier in the year I interpreted it as like they don't care like they didn't care about the class I asked them what was going on in their other classes like I looked at their other grades and I just like started talking to them a lot asking them about their day asking them about about their interest and kind of just realized that they weren't trying to get out of work they were just like really struggling with writing and reading I've been doing a lot of like during our Bell
115ringers when like they come in into their warmup um they we'll meet in the back and we'll go over some readings we'll go over some writing techniques and like capitalization and punctuation practice and I've seen a lot of improvements not only like in their writing and reading but also in their behavior in the classroom I think if I hadn't done the restorative practi of training I would have just been really quick to be punitive not thought about making that connection with them and just asking them about like how I could help them and support them in the classroom I'd say the biggest takeaway from the series was probably the tier one circles so it's my first year teaching so I've been like I've been really taking on any advice that people have for me and
116earlier in the year I had a lot of problems with students using casually using racial slurs in the classroom it was pretty pervasive so I talked a lot with my bits a mentor and I talked about with China yeah and we China came and met with me and we planned like some circles when we talked about empathy and it was really powerful it was like September so like they were like pretty squirly but CH came in during my sixth period which was like my most difficult class at the time and was just like another adult in the room and really helped me like with the process and I've been able to use the tier one circles in other ways throughout the year we've had like a lot of improvement in circles to structure and then
117following the structure now term four versus term one wow so i' I've been loving the term the the tier one circles with them what have been what has been the biggest area of growth in terms of your students and their experience in circles I'd say the biggest area of growth is respecting the talking piece can you explain kind of a story like in the beginning and now in the beginning I had to give them a lot of redirection about the rules with the talking piece and you know only talking when someone has the talking piece now I give them less and less redirection term two I had a student for like four days in a row a lot of attention seeking behaviors and was really challenging to mitigate those behaviors while also like being a
118first year teacher and like trying to feel more conf in front of the classroom I just had a conversation with him outside and just asked him what's going on like what happened this week that he's blowing up the classroom and I found out that his father had passed away like the week before and like he hadn't told anybody at school I was the first person that he told I wouldn't have known that if I hadn't you know have that conversation with him and it makes me think about these kids are 12 and 13 they have a lot going on at home a lot of them care for their siblings they're responsible at home and we don't know everything that's going on with them so it's so important ask them what's going on I have a
119few students this year who are chronically absent will miss eight days in a row and it'll just be like true and unverified un Synergy restorative practices building relationships having like that intentional connection with my students has like led me to wanting to reach out to parents beyond the auto dial that they get from this from the office and I've found that like when I message a parent and ask them like hey are they okay do you want me to leave some work up to them in the office usually in the the few instances where it's been like consecutive days lost usually like they come back to school the next day their parents clear their attendance reach out to parents be that adult that's like hey where are they are they coming back to school and
120I think that's been really powerful for helping me meet the needs of my students so prior to the restorative practices workshops at my site I used to think it was about a progressive approach to consequences but now I think it's about building relationships in the classroom and fostering a sense of empathy and belonging thank you we and educational Equity are dedicated to strategic continuous support structures for our schools um and we're going to move into the next segment and sharing with you the ways in which we're currently supporting our leaders our teachers and staff across the district um one of the ways that we are currently doing this with principles and vice principls are through restorative leadership monthly newsletters in which we celebrate their work each month features a new monthly restorative leadership challenge that's
121aligned to our restorative tier one benchmarks that all sites are currently working towards these monthly newsletters have given us a chance to celebrate the wonderful leadership at all of our school sites I've personally received countless emails of gratitude folks loving to see what's happening across the district um sometimes we're in our isolated communities but you know across region it's really cool to see hey in the elkov region this is this work is happening in the Floren region this work's happening other continuous support structures that we currently have are is our educational Equity employee facing website this serves as a hub of resources our goal is this Hub is to house Exemplar Circle lesson plans for teachers to use and share across the district we really you know our coaches work one-on-one with teachers often in
122one-on-one coaching they co-construct lessons together if a teacher is co-constructing a lesson at you know West Elementary we want those resources shared at Miwok um so really that's the Hub of resources across the district some other continuous support structures that our Equity coaches are currently working on our ongoing coaching of the restorative practices benchmarks and action plans with tier one teams as we mentioned earlier teaming is the approach we're taking we also have one-on-one coaching with teachers admin and staff um and then post site workshops um our coaches are meeting with our administrators to hold data analysis of the post-workshop surveys so giving admin a chance to look at the survey data how how is it Landing for my staff um and then finally working in collaboration with site admin around um you heard several
123times in those videos that um principles and vice principles are utilizing circles in their meetings so our Equity coaches are out there working in collaboration as thought Partners to co-construct those um adult circles for um administrators the support structures we're providing are truly responsive to the site needs as uh Miss raisin mentioned earlier all right so let's look at restorative practices in action um um so we're going to go ahead and take a look at a sixth grade classroom in the monter trail region the equity coach as I mentioned earlier is Miss mlin whom will be referenced often in the future video clips uh she supported the teacher via coaching to facilitate a Content Circle in her sixth grade class the purpose of the circle was to support building community and reflecting on themselves by
124considering the following questions are we truly the person We Believe ourselves to be or are we shaped by what others say about us what does it mean to have a sense of self students read the story The be that wasn't and then discussed the book via a Content Circle as depicted here on this graphic it was an inner outer and uh circle of support with some remaining students on the Outer Edge um after the students discuss the the content of the book and their feelings around it um they then did a written reflection independently uh this lesson was the start of a sequence of lessons the teacher and the miss mlin the coach work together on the goal of the sequence of lessons was to have students uh eventually begin to facilitate smaller circles on
125their own um of course the work around uh curricular content and uh those discussions around deepening the understanding of Concepts so really the teacher was utilizing this as the model lesson to hopefully in the future have students discuss curricular content on their own so we're going to go ahead and watch the video of the teacher my name is Mary mmid I'm a sixth grade teacher here at Raymond case the story that we read is the bear that wasn't and the kids enjoyed listening to the story it's the the premise of it is about a bear who um wakes up and this Factory has been built around him and people keep coming up to him and saying you're not a bear and he says I am a bear and other people say no you're not a
126bear you are a silly a silly man wearing Fur by the end of the story he kind of questions himself a little bit and isn't quite sure and secure in who he is anymore he talks about getting ready to hibernate and then he realizes I am a bear we talked ahead of time about where we wanted to be at the beginning um I said I really like the story a bear that wasn't so um the kids can get a little bit of a chance to communicate with with each other about who they are do that beginning of the year community building but we wanted to move to the point where we were doing restorative practices that was the point of it by the end of the year that we could have conversations where they could
127listen to each other and ask each other questions um the you know designated questions that we have kind of run themselves through the restorative practices and uh so that was our end goal so we started with the bear that wasn't and then we did a listening circle after that the beginning of the year we want to build classroom Community um and that usually begins with identity who are we what do we represent what do we bring from our home and our family that we want to share with the rest of the world and be proud of that so this was the first one so the bear that wasn't we read it we talked about his identity but the big idea was that they would get into a listening Circle one was a big we've had
128multiple but there was a a big listening Circle where we all are taking turns speaking to each other one person has the talking piece and then everybody else listens they said that they really felt heard they enjoyed that one they felt like the rest of the class paid attention to them and they didn't feel judged it's okay to speak up in here and and make mistakes and be who you are and then we built on that we had some listening circles that were small group with Miss moslin she kept coming in to do this our classroom counselors coming in to do some more listening circles the end goal is to be able to have the students walk through the restorative practices with each other by themselves we we are still supporting them with that right
129now so at the beginning our our first listening Circle there were several students who we couldn't even hear their voices they would put their faces down and they would speak really quietly and we couldn't hear their response and we'd ask them to repeat and they would really try but their voices would not be loud enough for somebody across the room to hear even when nobody was speaking we got to the point where people were confident in raising their hand in the classroom participating in discussions having wrong answers that was okay recording on these videos and sharing their thoughts on here so that's a huge step in confidence building for them a building classroom Community from the beginning of the year impacts the students all the way through the year and of course this is something
130that we continually touch on throughout the school year it doesn't just stop at the beginning right we have to continue we remind them to be empathetic to each other and appreciate each other whether they are correct or incorrect when they're you know answering questions in the class speaking up learning to speak up um and ask questions when they weren't comfortable with that at the beginning of the year I feel like my job as a teacher is also a mom that I'm consistently trying to help build them up they'll share things with me but I'm here to be that positive voice in their ear or to say oh hey that's a negative thought how can we flip it what could what's a what's the positive thing that we could put into our mind instead of that
131all right now we're going to uh look at the impact of restorative practices of this one lesson in the view of the student perspective uh you'll hear what the students learn from the restorative content Circle um and let's go after reading the bear that wasn't we discussed what problems did the bear face after reading the bear that wasn't we discussed that the society can affect the way you think about yourself after reading the bear that wasn't we discussed how Society can affect your opinion on yourself and your identity after reading the bear that wasn't we discussed how Society can affect your opinion about yourself and it can affect the way you live in the listening Circle we had after reading the story We PR practice listening to each other Miss mlin helped us learn empathy
132Miss mlin help us learn to never like listen to what society says about yourself if you listen to what other people thinks about you it makes the other person feel like you have more like they have more power than you do over yourself we also completed our own identity Flags because we wanted to tell and show about our identity we wanted to show our classmates stuff about our your s for example I put down these stuff this one I put it down because I love my family and my pets and I put this flag down because this is the country my dad is from I put s real down because it's my favorite character I want people to know that other people's opinions don't matter just be yourself just say like to trust in yourself
133like just believe and don't don't believe what other people say about them just be yourself I want to but know that um it's okay to be you I want people to know that you shouldn't let Society tell you who you are because you can lose yourself in the process cuz before this I used to think that I was like trash at basketball or cuz other people would tell me that and I learned I can't listen to other people tell me I can only listen to I think about myself in my own life I used to think that um I used to put society's opinions over my own and I would be scared to wear the clothes I wanted to wear that had a lot of color in it for fear that I would get judged
134and be called childish I want people to know to never listen to the society because if you do it will just affect your life and all you'll be thinking about is that think positive ideas not negative when I listen to these students I am so proud I am in awe I I truly imagine these sixth graders um entering in middle school next year with the level of confidence they've gained from being who they are in our community this was the impact of just one lesson imagine the power of a sequence of lessons imagine the transformative power of restorative practices and what it could do for our students staff and community and I'm going to pass it over to Mr Jones who'll close out this presentation kids have a way of putting things uh a little
135more succinctly and directly uh than sometimes I think as adults we've been inundated all our lives with lots of stuff and make it more complicated you know my connection to uh what the students are sharing with my own kids who are students in this District I have one that's a senior ready to go off to college and it's those very things that they are um describing that I think about the most that keep me up the most when I think about my son kind of leaving the house potentially and going to another place like is he going to be able to not only do the academics which um you know has its own set of of of challenges but most importantly is he going to be able to fit in he's going to find belonging
136he's going to be able to make those decisions that help himself and not hurt himself is is he going to listen to what the environment and Society he is now newly in help Define him or is he going to have have some um some agency and and kind of Define himself in this new environment so so definitely powerful uh things there um that were shared by those students so as we kind of uh wrap this up uh the formal part of this presentation and allow you um an opportunity for questions um just want to kind of summarize you know restorative uh practices is a relational instructional pedagogy it's not just a response to behavior restorative practices support belong longing for adults and students within our community restorative practices is a proactive and preventative approach that
137supports the other work in our district chiefly our mtss framework um so thank you very much for your attention I'm opening up for questions there was a question that was a couple of questions that were asked that all address the elephant the name so elephante um which is named after the late great Entertainer and civil rights activist Harry bellonte so there is a little uh history behind that that's connected to that there was also a question around restorative restorative justice and restorative practices um there's a lot of ambiguity around those terms sometimes are used interchangeably by some I think that's what uh was very important about this implementation there was a very definitive and um synchronous definition of what restorative practice was going to be in El Grove unified school district it's very important and
138we lead that off um in many of our workshops so we can Orient folks but in general kind of I'll say my understanding because like I said there's a lot of ambiguity out there and a lot of interchangeably um restorative justice is born out of the Criminal Justice System um and it is almost exclusively a response to an injustice or an offense um um so you might have heard stories or information around you know how that might come about um a way for the offender and the folks who were offended to be able to have an opportunity to kind of repair that harm but like I said most almost exclusively as a response to um an offense where our definition here in El Grove unified around restorative practices um is more than just that response
139even though there is you know response to behavior that's included but that response is underpinned and supported by the proactive and preventative measures that you heard a lot about during this presentation about building Community belonging connectedness and how that translates into all aspects um of the educational system um for all the individuals involved and then using that um that framework if you will to be able to provide more options um and more impact in the event there is something that goes AR or there's a new need for a correction now it's a restoring back to what we have been proactive and preventive about about creating so a little bit of a kind of connection between those two terms but unfortunately there is a lot of ambiguity and um it's one of those things that if
140you're having a conversation with somebody about restorative practices it might be worth just taking a few moments to orient each other to kind of what you're talking about um but I'll open it up for for questions from uh from the board of superintendents awesome thank you very much um and thank you all for the work that you were doing and thank you uh for the presentation the very uh thorough presentation and wide ranging presentation uh and uh before we get it uh to our colleagues um Mr Yang do we have any blue cards yes boys President we have one blue card calling Charlotte so I appreciate this presentation I have a whole list of questions but I have a whole list of examples too i''d rather do the examples so the 40 members that came
141up with this are you going to each School site and seeing the differences in each School site the school sites are all different and to be honest with you I don't see this happening in the in the elementary school that my son goes to I don't so I'm not seeing much of a difference I came a year ago almost exactly a year ago to talk about PBIS and seal and how I think that is a disservice to the students I am very curious to see how this is a good service to the students um we have a situation at our elementary school where there is a child that flips his desk he throws things at the other students and all I see is we're worried about the minority student that's causing the problems what about
142the other 23 students the other 28 students in the classroom my son witnessed an a child that flipped his desk and threatened the kids though I'm wondering how that would be taken care of and if the teacher has to talk to them student who's helping her or him um if there's not a pair in that class that's a big disaster um from my years of volunteering I believe that every class needs at least two Paras to help the teacher um or invite volunteers to come [Music] so my other concern was last week with El grow the gun was found was there any problem with that student in before probably but it came to down to the fact that we only got an email we didn't get talking points um my students didn't feel safe at
143school and then the next day we had Pleasant Grove with a rumor of a gun and they get a lock down and talking points this District needs to be consistent in their issues um and just to leave the last note so last year you had 18,000 students below standards in math 18,000 students and that was just between grades three and eight and 11 what about all the other students my kids come home and tell me how the students in high school are disruptive because they don't know their math English had 15,000 why why don't we work on that instead of all the social social justice stuff thank you thank you for president that ends our blue car thank you very much all right then we are on to excuse me uh board members any questions
144feedback um let's start at this end um Susan would you like to start us off thank you for the presentation was really informative um gave me a clear understanding of the restorative process um you kept mentioning in the the presentation about training staff um what staff was included in this training because as far as I know it wasn't to any classified staff that has to deal with like office staff y Duty people like that um so the focus was to start at the school sites um and the workshops at the school sites um were created um and scheduled individually for them um it is uh as you could imagine a challenge to try to include all the staff from the site um there was uh some some focus on the teachers um they have they
145play a big role and the students kind of experience at school currently we are you know working to try to figure out structures that would allow classified staff classified staff were definitely invited to the workshops themselves um you know their structure around their work and their hours um is a little bit different than uh the certificated folks uh but we are currently working on how to uh have more of an impact and more FaceTime with those classified Folks at the at the sites as well as classified Folks at the district office and certificated Folks at the district office so it's definitely a continued conversation um for them as well as makeups for folks and folks that are newly coming into the district how do we get them up to speed um we are definitely that's
146a definitely focal area um and we continue to to try to meet that as best as possible thank you for that um just keep in mind they're usually not invited to staff meetings so it would have to be something outside of a staff meeting okay Miss Alani okay um this is great information thank you very much um I am so it feels like we're starting we did a pilot in honorary Trail so we did all the elementary the middle everybody now when we did that do we did we hit do we we did schoolwide trainings we did teacher trainings I I'm trying to understand I think we have the diagram with the arrow um page 16 possibly but um as a teacher and I and I L the seventh grade teacher because as a second
147grade teacher my first year the Reading Coach was my best friend she saved me um so how are we getting down to the teacher level and is there a thought process which I would understand was what I'm I'm assuming so I'm not I don't want to assume so I'm asking um we started with principles and we started with with a a higher level so they can support the work that's being done at a at in the classroom so as a teacher how am I getting this if I am not on my tier one team how am I getting as the teacher is it just a reaching out for asking for coaching um that's or or I'm taking the practice from my experience and then any support I'm needed I can find on staff and I
148and to do in my own classroom that's what so I think it's that and so uh the instructional the workshops Workshop one two three and four those are being done at every School site teachers are present and are um receiving the professional development through those workshops to not only learn the practices and procedures themselves but also experience kind of a restorative experience um so that's kind of the Catalyst or the first step that a teacher will get and then there's often times from that um teachers will reach out to their individual Equity coach and say hey here's a particular special or unique thing that I'm dealing with or an area that I would like to you know have consideration or support at rolling in this uh approach in these practices and procedures that's great okay
149so I didn't understand Workshop one two three and four are things that are open to the entire teaching staff when you go to that school okay and then um and you go out to the schools andol or do they come here uh our Equity coaches go out to the schools and Prov provide all those individually at each School site each Workshop I think that's awesome because every school does have a different personality and a different thing so um thank you um it's a lot it's wonderful information thank you very much and um that was my clarifying question Mr yeah um good morning Steele um thank you for the presentation that's a lot of information but a lot of great information um really showcase um um the definition of uh restor practices and also the process
150and all the workshop and um you know just hearing um a couple of my colleagues ask questions you guys already clarify that by answering it um Orly um so I would like to um also ask um well first I'd like to say this first um I love the supported uh videos from the teachers and also the students um that I thought was very um uh deep as far as um their interviews um providing feedbacks however uh it is so great that I would love to see more of it and and what that means is that uh we have different uh grades of students that are being taught uh RoR practices and I would like to hear from more students in a different different um grade level and also from a different grade level of teachers
151as well and different department as well that are involved in this um restor practices um one of the thing that I don't know if it's appropriate or not or appropriate or how we could shape it in the sense of uh privacy but um interviewing students that are had experience um through being trouble and going through this process and actually um learn and and got better or or did not learn anything um I would like to see that because the students that um provide the interviews I thought was great work as far as um educating them and uh build selfesteem and so forth but I really want to hear the folk the students that gone had been in trouble and this Resto practice uh has helped them give them a sense of understanding of uh um
152what they did what they need to do better to be uh a better student better person going forward because at at end of the day uh this process is really uplift try and try to uplift our uh students uh first and foremost and staff and community so um the student are for me is our first uh subject so I would like to hear from more from them and I would like to also uh if possible get some data in terms of how many students we are actually helping out I know that I thought I saw uh a few schools on the number of schools that we have um practice or restore practice in them uh but I also want to see um the amount of students and perhaps maybe even the teachers that involved in
153this process so um that's my thought on that but um overall I'm very happy that um this work has uh progressed uh in the last uh few years and it it's getting better and I know that um there's always room for improvement and um yeah so I encourage um you folks who work so hard and uh to take some of our um constructive criticism or or concerning and and make it better so um please reach out to us as well and I I am one of the ones that would love to work with you guys in the process of making it better so um but thank you for all the work that you guys have done to this point appreciate it thank you for those comments just something I'll uh I'll kind of highlight um
154there's definitely invitation to any of the board members if you want to kind of see this in in in real time um it's uh it's challenging in this setting to kind of try to create an authentic restorative experience um you got to um engage in some ways um but definitely an invitation um please reach out to miss Lasser if you're interested in kind of observing what this might look like in a you know a real classroom um I'll also say that uh you know I too agree Mr Yang with some of the statements you made I'm eager to kind of see how this you know is rolling out you know I will point out that uh the Monteray Trail region currently is the only region that's gone through the complete implementation they were the pilot
155region so much of the um teacher interviews and students were in that region because those those staff have actually gone through the whole Workshop one through four and have had a chance to kind of conceptualize and put that into practice um the rest of the district including the alt Ed sites um you know they're still kind of at the beginning stages of the implementation and we've been real specific during the workshops to uh Workshop one in particular where it's more of an introduction it's hey staff come have a restorative experience yourself and uh you know the preceding uh or the following workshops will will definitely focus a little bit more in on some of the technical parts and the practices um so definitely looking forward to being able to uh connect with more School site
156staff as the roll out continues um and be able to adjust and respond to um how they are receiving it as well appreciate it and um I was reminded by somebody on Zoom uh board members we can these mics are very sensitive so um there's no reason to get right up to it it'll catch you from about this distance so anyway miss ballerini all right I've got a couple of questions um first what grade levels are we reaching are we going all the way to TK because my thought is the earliest we can get them in and and get them started because that's that's number one question do you want me to just I'll I'll tell you all and then I'll let you answer that we that works okay um the next thing is do
157we have a way to adapt the training if we have uh some kids on the spectrum that may have difficulties expressing themselves CU um it took my grandson almost a year to actually say good morning to his teacher so I can't imagine him sitting in a circle like that and actually sharing but it he finally did so I have hope let's see what else oh how long is the first training like how many hours is it and um the other thing I wanted to mention kind of piggybacking on Susan's question um the California healthy kids survey I helped administer that number of years one of the things that always hit me from that is the fact that teachers yes they are a very big important part of connecting with the students but you've got other
158staff on campus that connects with them too your library texts your lunch person your custodian the yard duty all of them um connect with them as well and one two three four yep that's it but oh and I learned a lot today I appreciate it too thank you so the roll outs currently focused on K12 uh even though ironically enough we have going have some conversations about uh the prek world and and how to kind of engage that staff um in those folks and doing that so that'll be that's something that's kind of on the horizon for us to uh to kind of figure out um as a department with the resources we have we're uh you know uh that capacity with kind of what we're doing right now and definitely as we move forward
159um being responsive to that um you mentioned your family member um you know the adaptability of how quickly students are able to engage with specifically the practices um is definitely something I think that is multifaceted some students are maybe primed to be able to you know lend their um voice their literal voice to um the spaces uh a little sooner than others um but I think that the way the practices and the procedures are formed and and um taught to the staff I think there's space for students to be able to kind of engage and jump in at their own time um and whether I believe whether a student is able to lend their literal literal voice um or just be um able to benefit off the environment that is more inclusive and more belonging
160um I think you know there's some benefit there um for that and the workshops that excuse me on the screen Workshop one two three and four are one and a half hours each um the um restorative practices leadership trainings I focus on the principles and vice principles there were three days of training kind of all day 8 to 3:30 if you will um in the tier one workshops um were two all day trainings once again from that kind of eight to at 3:30ish time thank you thank you Miss Moore thank you for the presentation uh the circles certainly seem positive and I appreciated the you know the feedback um as Mr Yang mentioned from uh the staff and the and the and the students uh and you know you kind of touched on what it
161would look like for a teacher interaction if there was misbehavior and that certainly seemed um positive to have those um you know those Solutions and that training in those situations what does it look like if students don't um respond to those types of um interactions that were mentioned in the videos if if their misbehavior uh is not um you know the teacher is not able to resolve that or if it affect other students what does that look like so yes students are going to have a variety of responses I think part of the uh training the restorative leadership teams or the principles and vice principles each staff first um was to give them kind of a framework um obviously if there's uh you know disruptions and things happening in the classroom the teacher doesn't feel
162like they're able to handle that they would follow the procedures that they have for their School site if that means referring them to you know the administration um administrators have been trained and restor to practices uh so there are some certain moves and certain things that administrators can use in the restorative Continuum at their level when they um you know reach behaviors and um you know with uh with the orientation of a lot of people um with restorative practices having it in a as a response to an offense um um there are some specific practices and procedures to to implement when that happens when there's an offense and all the tier one kind of um options are available that aren't working or the feel that the student isn't responding to so there is some tier
1632 tier three practices that restorative um practices would support we are currently kind of rolling that out and you heard about some of the tier 2 tier three pilots and trying to work with sites on what would that you know actually look like when we're talking about trying to support students in that manner um the school or the administration still has the opportunity to implement specific consequences um for specific behaviors that those individuals feel that that needs to happen teachers have some options and opportunities as well by Ed code and contract um so those things are still in place I think uh this restora to practices is hopefully to offer up some other options uh maybe before some of those are employed um as well as after some of those are employed and if a
164student is removed from the learning environment how do we welcome them back in a restorative way so that hopefully we can minimize or mitigate you know future potential you know offenses or issues down the road so um it's not a either it's not an or it's an and um and hopefully we are able to give schools side staff and District staff you know some differing options and how to braid in the things they doing um to mitigate some of the behaviors or the um things that are happening potentially specifically in classrooms okay uh and you you know you kind of touched on the differences between restorative practices and restorative justice is restorative justice involved in the process at all as you were talking about next steps in in those situations I think with this implementation
165restorative practices any response to any behaviors or things um it folds in those proactive and preventative aspects as well so hopefully being able to utilize the collect the community and belonging that has been formed um and inviting the student back in and figuring out how to ingratiate the student back into that Community um what needs to happen for the student what needs to happen for the staff the people that were harmed the people that did the harm so it's not I don't want to necessarily say that there's no elements of restorative justice in this implementation I think this implementation really focuses on that tier one kind of wide breath of creating environments where all of the participants in that environment feel community and belonging and be able to use that sense of community and belonging
166um when there is an offense or when there is something that needs to be repaired or harm has been given okay and so you know it was mentioned in the presentation um that we want all students to have a sense of wellbeing and safety so going along with that is safety always made a priority uh you know we want we are we considering that with victims and behaviors and so forth I think safety is the number one belonging in the school sites um and how if folks feel emotionally and physically safe um both students and staff and the community so yeah I think that's the underpinning of this implementation and how do we proactively preventively specifically provide structures and opportunities uh to not only create those spaces for all um but maintain those spaces for
167all uh even when there's some harm done thank you uh what is the fiscal impact for this program now and then looking into the future so over the past two years and then into this year there was a contract with restorative Equity partnership which Dr singer works for um and her other trainers and they came out and trained uh the team the Equity department and others and that contract is slowly starting to minimize because the goal is it for it to be a train the trainer and we take it over um as our own so over those three years it was 575,000 um divided up and it slowly is coming to an end uh so that our uh Equity coaches here can continue to take the work on thank you so the 40 uh the
16840 staff members that were mentioned in the presentation is that our some of those existing uh staff members that are supporting this program yes that is correct okay thank you uh and then it was mentioned early on in the program that this is evidence-based to support kids is there a way that the board members can have um that research uh provided to us please or at least I would I know I would appreciate that yes we can send all evaluations whatever evaluations you would like we can send that out in the board communication later in the next couple weeks thank you um let's see so the the STA the trains have been rolled out to all teachers correct and but not all staff as like was mentioned okay so do you have feedback from uh
169teacher do do all teachers give feedback or is it voluntary how does that work all Workshop participants are offered an opportunity and encouraged to provide their feedback okay thank you is it Anonymous or is it connected or do they you know connect their name when they get the feedback how does that work the feedback is provided as an anonymous way but there has been some oper some instances where a specific person might say hey I need some help you know I'm wanting to some support and they would provide maybe some identifiable information in that respect wonderful have there been any challenges or or um negative feedback that you've heard so as you could guess I've read all of the feedback as this is something that I'm um incredibly proud of the work that the team
170is doing and the one theme I think that would come up is just how um how busy our teachers are so I think a lot of them Chang their mind by the end of the training but going into it sometimes it's is this one more thing uh how am I going to add this into my classroom and then by the end of the training most mindsets have been changed and they see how easy it is to add into their practice every day okay that's good to hear the reason I was wondering that is it seems you know sometimes in these presentations we're sharing a lot of positive information which is good I you know it sounds like a positive thing but I think it's important to look at it from a well you know well-rounded
171viewpoints and I know that when I worked on on the comprehens comprehensive Sexual Health advisory committee uh it was shared with us that there were actually many um negative teacher responses to the curriculum that they you know they thought it was not age appropriate so forth uh but those were never shared you know in a board meeting or anything like that and I asked why and they really couldn't give me a response but I think it's important that we're we're recognizing that maybe sometimes staff members do have challenges or concerns and that we're we're sharing those two and not just always the positive because I do think sometimes those staff have valid concerns or questions and sometimes those need to be shared so add one more um thing one of the one of the things
172that I'm most proud of with and the whole team is not here but but some of them are here is this is a a a implementation strategy that's rolling out across the district but they also stop reflect evaluate and if they have to Pivot a little bit they do and that's the power of our Equity coaches they go out and work with our individual teachers with classrooms with grade levels with departments with principles to help if something does come up they have those conversations and make sure that they know that there's support there okay great thanks that's good to hear uh so I guess my question is because of situations that I myself has has I've had as a parent or that I've heard from other parents what does this look like for the victims
173is in restorative practices are if there's an offense um are are you know is there interactions between the victims and the you know a potential bully what does that look like and you know I just want to know kind of what that looks like so in an instance like that the individual or individuals that were harmed always have an opportunity to opt in or opt out to any part of the formal process um you know in response to those kinds of things there are some structures and strategies if the individual that's harmed opts to you know not participate in the formal um restorative structure restorative grouping uh response they can have a proxy you know attend in their in their stad somebody that they trust somebody that you know they feel would be able to
174communicate and receive and and disseminate you know their wishes um if they don't have one there's still process and procedures to allow the process to continue for the person who caused the harm so that they can have an opportunity to kind of understand how their actions or behaviors may have contributed to disrupting you know the environment so definitely definitely definitely you know the person who was harmed has the option at all times to engage with the restor with a formal restorative process um or or not okay thank you and would parents be involved in that situation would they be made aware if their child was um you know a victim or involved in that type of situation yes obviously you know when there's any incident or thing involved there has to be some kind of
175Investigation to figure out you know what happened um you know there's processes procedures for um whoever is doing that part of um the thing to involve and engage you know parents and family members and make them aware of kind of the evolving nature of of what's going on you know a formal restorative um conference would kind of be the same so you know family members would would kind of know what's going on and know what's being asked as well okay and um I'm wrapping up here but I just you know I just want to say that if I don't know if this Falls in restorative practices or where it falls in you you know kind of our systems that we have in place but if there if there is a victim one thing that has
176bothered me um is that it seems that often that they become they they have to change their behavior to avoid situations or avoid people that have harmed them and that's a concern to me um with one of my own children it was uh the principal told me that um the their bully um would stay away from them and that they you know wouldn't be allowed to sit by them and my child comes home and tells me that you know their bully was um sitting by them at lunch and so forth and the principal put it on my child to move away from from them so I don't know if that falls in here or but those are the types of situations that concern me is that yes I understand we need to include everyone and
177and listen to their their you know their situations their feelings but we also have to be careful that we're protecting students who need to be protected so I just want to know how that fits in here while I won't necessarily comment on specific circumstances around that because I'm not aware um the formal restore to process allows an opportunity for everybody's voice to be heard definitely that of the of the individual or individuals that were harmed um and so them being able to express um their concerns their feelings about um possible or potential resolutions to things um this process would amplify and provide opportunities for them to be able to share that um before during and after the resolution of of a specific incident okay thank you uh can board members attend these trainings yes we
178welcome any of you to come and attend a training or to come see a circle just email me and I'll make sure you're connected to a school wonderful that's great chel thank you uh so in closing in closing my up my thoughts I just um you know I look forward to learning more about this so I can properly understand the whole process um and I will you know try to be more openminded about about it so I can I want to learn more um but I just I always want to remember that our primary focus is to provide our students with a high quality education which was you know f u mentioned in the beginning of the presentation and so we just need to make sure that we're supporting all of our kids um that
179they have a safe learning environment so they can do that and that would be all thank you thank you uh Mr Yang did you have a followup yeah I do um just quickly um I just wanted to know um you know the last three years um how many if any uh additional staff we have add-on to um be a part of this Resto practice are we using existing staff to to do this work are you asking just want to make sure I understand what you're asking are we using our own staff here in elro UniFi to facilitate the trainings no I'm asking that do we have to hire more staff in the last three years to help this uh restore practice U process no our Equity uh department has been doing all of that I
180will say they are extremely busy they are doing a lot of trainings uh so thank you to those of you that are here um so no we have not hired more staff we have I heard 40 is that that was the stakeholder group in the beginning we have 40 are part of the the committee that uh decided what uh vendor we were going to use decided on the definitions the principles and then they came in the vendor they trained and then our our we have 11 Equity coaches so are we going to have uh funding issues regard to this program going forward uh I can tell you that in 2026 the uh emergency learning recovery block grant did I say that correctly yeah um that funding is going away at the end of the school
181year of 2026 and that is how our 11 Equity coaches are funded okay and I guess when we get closer to that we'll re-evaluate and go from there thank you yes and we're going to have a um discussion on board priorities uh coming up soon so we'll we'll get into that um thank you all very very much for the presentation thank you all for everything that you guys that you are doing um I think that this is incredibly important work uh you know as as has been mentioned um actually we'll start with I've been kind of poking at this for you know well since I joined the board is um a lot of these uh programs that we do that touch on uh seal and PBIS and um you know the the other two sort
182of uh pillars of mtss aside from academics um you know I think it's very important to always tie them back to academics right you know not just you know for the um you know the theory of it and I'm an education Theory person um but also because the public needs to understand that um you know because it does sometimes feel like you know is it an either or right you know there there's certainly uh conversation out there um about why are we doing this at the expense of academics why are we doing this at the expense of when when math is a problem why are we doing this when you know pick any of the other you know many uh you know issues that we have in education right now um and I think that
183it's important for us and you know you you did a much you did a very good job uh in the presentation of sort of tying it all in together right pointing out how this crosses all of those tier one mtss uh you know categories right academic social emotional uh behavioral because it does all tie in together um but I want to keep poking at that I want to keep that sort of you know front and center in your minds because it's so important to what we do is that all of this ties back to um you know the actual education of a student um and you know as we said right safety is you know Safety and Security on campus Wellness on campus these are bedrocks of what we do because right m L's you
184hierarchy of needs if we're not doing that then students aren't learning if we're not providing a safe space on campus students aren't learning right if students don't feel uh don't have that se sense of self-esteem right they're not learning right because we haven't provided those baselines um you know that they need and so all of these things are tied together and constantly sort of reinforcing how all of these things are tied together uh I think is hugely important it's an important part of what we do in asking questions and you know and being up here but it's also an important part of what all of you do um and so I appreciate that you know that that continues to be part of the conversation and how all of this ties together uh you know and
185builds on you know these sort of foundational pieces of um you know the the student social and emotional health and wellness uh student safety uh all of these things are really the foundation so that we can educate students right because the reality is you know our uh as our speaker mentioned our you public speaker mentioned um we have issues right now that need to get resolved right the math scores not great right and it's not just a problem for us it's a problem across the state um and those are things that need to get addressed and the only way we're going to be able to address those things effectively is if we've got the foundation down uh and we are building on that in you know in the classroom so the more we're connecting those
186things together the better um one other thing that I I point out it's not it's not so much a a critique as a um you know just an awareness is you can't like I recognize that even in three hours and thank you so much for the a full like that was a very full presentation and very good and um I appreciate you guys you know sticking it out for a full three hours um you know but even in a full you know three hour uh three-hour presentation right we're not getting we're not digging down in all of these things right there's still jargon in there um you know and I understand some of it because of my background I understand some of it because I was sitting up here and Googling words as you guys
187were talking um and like things like you know radical hope um which what when I Googled it was I was like this is this is wonderful like I I'm going to go read the book on it um again nerd uh but like Equity of voice uh effective statements um you know uh restorative circles versus uh Circles of support right things like that that you guys you didn't really dig down on but like when you get in there and you know and so I would encourage my colleagues and anybody listening um dig down on some of these words that you you that you see in here because there there's really interesting um thought and if you really want to be a nerd you can dig into all the theory you know and read the books and
188articles and things like that and sure it's fascinating um you know but like dig down a little bit and there's some there's really interesting stuff there um and so I I appreciate appreciate that you all have uh sort of put some of that out there uh you know for us um some of it you fully explained some of it is there for us to explore as needed um and I think that that is all really interesting and I like I like that that's included um you know and to the extent that we can get more into that you know there I'm sure there will be opportunities um but I appreciated that like there there's a lot of really interesting Theory here um um something else that jumped out at me uh you know as as
189you guys were talking is that there's nothing nothing struck me as revolutionary right nothing nothing in this struck me as um we're doing something you know that is just going to change well change the world yes we do um but you know nothing nothing here is New Right new or novel right some of these things have been around forever and what we're doing is putting structure to them um what we're doing is putting a little bit of theory behind it and saying hey this is why this connects to this and this is how we can strengthen those connections um you know obviously circles have been around forever right we call them restorative circles Circles of support because we're adding some structure we're adding some meaning um and we're adding some guidance to why why we
190what are we what are we doing in this particular Circle and why do we have it right um but circles have been around forever right uh you know even when I was when I was in education and you know 20 years ago um 25 30 30 years ago uh you know we we still had those things and there was less structure to that I'm I'm remembering back to when I you know we did those when I was in elementary school and there's there was less structure to it there was less theory behind it there was less you know of that but it was still there and we still s we still understood why it was important um and so putting words to it calling it a restorative Circle calling it a circle of support calling
191at these things um puts structure to it but it doesn't change that these things have been here forever and we've always understood why they're important and I think it's important to sort of reinforce that you know with the community is that what we're doing is putting um getting our arms around something that's always been there we've always known is important um you know and and trying to you know make make it even more effective um so I think that's a it's important part of what we're doing nothing we're doing is revolutionary we are just doing it better and better and better uh every year um you know constant Improvement that's what we do uh and then I think that was all of my major comments and I think the last the last point I'll make
192is you know sort of piggybacking off of uh you know Miss Moore's uh comments I think that it's important to remember very much what you said that this is not a replacement for discipline this is not an either or for you know student safety on campus this is an and right you know this is we're adding something in the process we are creating uh Alternatives um because what we are trying to do and I think you you got this throughout you were you poking at this throughout the presentation is that you know restorative practices and discipline and everything we do is individualized it is the student right it is not students it is not we are not responding to groups of students we are not responding to the student body as a whole everything we
193do is focused on the student who's in our focus at any given time and remembering that not every student is going to respond to the various tools that we have in the same way right the point you made right students respond differently to things um and so having a toolkit that is out there that includes discipline on one end that includes restorative practices that includes teacher managed pra you know teacher managed responses and we're going to get into sort of the the universe of discipline in a second um but I think that having all those tools in the toolbox is so important because it allows us to be that much more specific and that much more individualized to the student who is in front of us at any given moment um because that's so important
194to what we do is being able to respond to each and every situation for each and every individual student um so I think that's an important part to talk about in this conversation um is that this is a toolkit and but the focus is still on the individual student in any given situation and their specific situation um right that's why cultural responsiveness something that was pointed out here is so important right understanding where that specific student is situated in any given moment um and so that is it I will get off my high horse uh I I appreciate this presentation so much really I appreciate everything that you all are doing um and thank you so much there you just one quick comment please so um first of all thank you to the team um
195you're amazing and um and I appreciate um each of you um very very much you know the the Revolutionary thing here it it's not it's not brand new um knowledge but the systemic way in which the work is being done is revolutionary I mean this this is not um how it's done everyone it's one of the things that makes me proud uh to be part of the uh the elk grve uh Team so the commitment of the folks doing the work work um and the openness of the staffs at our school sites um that are engaging this work is is also amazing so I appreciate the commitment of the board um in leading and letting us um do this work um and obviously uh the thoughtful um questions and and and sharings that you did
196um you know share share with the staff that you see it as important um and just know that we appreciate you very very much thank you thank you all right um let's see what time are we nine minutes ahead of schedule woohoo keep doing we're GNA keep the in there uh all right so uh do we have Let's see we are at lunch break um do we have lunch ready are we all right sweet um then we'll we will take our 30 minute lunch break and we will be back at uh 12:45 uh for uh our exclusionary discipline presentation so thank you very much thank you e e e all right let's start up again all right we are open up to our last item of the Open Session um exclusionary discipline uh Miss ay
197and Mr spiter all right thank you good after afternoon president Vargas members of the board superintendent Hoffman and Miss Avalos when and if she returns we are here today to talk about the efforts that we are doing to reduce exclusionary discipline so while we have a team from elementary and secondary education I do want to make a note that this is a districtwide effort that involves departments in ed services and of course all the work that's being done at our school sites and so also a perfect segue from the morning presentation as the restorative practice work you'll see is called out as a tier one U measure activity that we would do and we look at it as a preventative strategy so our presentation format we're going to start off talking about what our guiding
198principles are that's important to us as we frame the work and we talk about the data and look at the strategies that we're going to use we have uh Mr fine and Mr gutiz who will share with you a data update on where we are at this point in elro and then we will move into how we make decisions and some of the successful practices we have and then we'll end with the work we're doing in ed services and schools when we're looking at tier one supports so as we look at our guiding principles these have been around for the last few years and haven't been really modified much because we find them to still be very relevant so we want to note that all of our responses to behavioral incidents they're all based on
199a restorative versus a punitive nature so it's an opportunity for students in our system in elro to be able to learn from their mistakes and to try to have different responses and reactions as they move forward uh one thing we want to note is eliminating disproportionality with exclusionary discipline is absolutely what we want to do that is one of our main goals as we look at reductions in exclusionary discipline we um have positive relationships we want students to be more connected much like the work you heard with restorative practices we want our students to be connected to the school uh to other students their teachers and to how they're achieving because that's part of the system of why we're here and our last guiding principle goal is really just ensuring that the classroom behavior is
200conducive to learning and our main goal is always maintaining the school safety uh that is one of our expectations uh we will note that as we hear different things that came up in great board questions about individual students we look at discipline on an individual basis uh case-by case basis and we also look at the student as a whole student so we'll be presenting data today that is really about the behavioral piece but we know that that's just one slice of it we also have the academic needs and the social emotional needs as well and with that I'm going to go ahead and turn it over to this next Dynamic team very much good afternoon everyone thank you for having us um we're excited to be here as we continue to support our students by
201examining our practices and calibrating our approaches to reducing exclusion AR discipline uh we're pleased to report that the overall suspensions through the second quarter of this year have thank you continue to decline he's usually my my my clicker guy um so as we get started today uh for the data sections we're going to be following um statistics commonly used to to um report suspension data namely counts uh counts namely the numbers of suspensions where we count every suspension incident that occurs and the number of suspended students this is the number of students who received one or more suspensions so we have one is an incident count and the other is a student count so our first table today shows through the second quarter uh the number and percentage of students that were suspended there's two
202years of data for each uh and for each year there are three data points enrollment number of suspended students and percentage of suspended students down the left hand side you can see that we have the district and then the three segments of school elementary middle and high school and then with each in each within each one of those we have our Target subgroups African-American Foster Youth and students with disabilities please note that for this slide there are students um that are counted only one time in the overall overall total uh even if they've been suspended more than once so they're counted one time even if they've been suspended more than once however some students may fit into more than one subcategory so as an example is we could have a foster youth student that was
203also let's say on an IEP and they would show up in the Foster youth row and the students with disabilities count okay so diving into the data um to start I'll just go across the top um starting with the district and looking at the enrollment of 64,8 32 students we suspended 158 students or 2.3% last year this year 24-25 our enrollment grew about 700 students um and 1264 of them were suspended or 1.9% if we look at the subgroups um last year our African-American students 446 students students were suspended uh this year at 373 a reduction of 73 students or about a percent our foster youth not much change from 26 to 25 students our students with disabilities however went from 467 students suspended down to 375 a reduction of 92 students for the elementary
204segment um looking at that middle column of number of suspended students last year 178 students were suspended or about a half a percent this year we suspended 149 students a little less than um half a percent but a reduction of 79 students our African-American population uh we 62 students were suspended uh this year 42 so we're down 20 our foster youth from 5 to two which is a reduction of three and then finally students with disabilities 84 suspensions last year U cut in half basically this year to 41 or less than 1% Richard's going to take you through middle and high school thank you Mr fine uh contining the same format that Mr fine was going um I want to point that for our middle school students there was a 250 student increase of enrollment
205between from 2023 24 to 2425 having said that we did had a minus 98 uh reduction of suspensions overall in the middle schools um if I go down to our African-American students you see that there also was a reduction of uh 20 uh 26 students from 167 in 2324 to 141 in 2425 with a faster use I want to make a note that um there was a um decrease of enrollment between one year and another by two students but there also was an increase of suspens pensions with uh by three students that's why you will see that there is an increase in the rate because there was a reduction of enrollment but there was an increase of suspens of suspensions so um we went from 34 enrollment to 32 from 23 24 to uh 24
2062532 and then suspended students 10 in 23 24 to 13 in 2425 uh with our students uh with disabilities it was also an incre increase of 72 students uh of enol of qualified students between 23 24 to 2425 that leing us uh reducing of minus 17 of suspended students from 2324 to 2425 with our high schools um you see that there was a slight uh decrease of enrollment um of about 66 students uh but we did decrease overall suspension students as well by 105 105 from 676 to 571 with our African-American students uh we saw a also a reduction of suspensions from uh 195 to 176 that is minus 19 students with our foster youth at high school um we had a minus one um difference between 23 and 24 to 24 25 and with
207our students with stabilities we did see also a minus 31 decrease uh um from 204 to 173 one of the reasons why I did not point out the um the percentage as because in the next slide you're going to see a visual representation of those rates overall this required you do see a plus 2% with our faster youth there uh from 11.5 to 13.5 but you can also see in the other um student groups there was a reduction um with our African-American in minus one .1% with our students with disability minus .9% and with overall egusd we had a reduction of minus .4% with with a group that we just uh reviewed over with in the next slide you're going to see an overall uh representation of um of all of our groups um this
208is just more of a visual representation where we are with all of our groups if you really see and try to kind of follow follow the lines uh you see that the overall there's a reduction in all of our percentage of students suspended by ethnicity there's only one that was that had an increase that as those who um state that there are two or more uh there was an increase of. 3% but the rest of them uh the rest of our groups there were a reduction again with our African-American students there was a minus 1.1% with our American Indian that was a minus 1% with Hispanic was a minus .5% again with the two or more there was an increase of 3% districtwide again a minus. 4% decrease with our Pacific Islander was a minus
2093% with our White Community we had a minus. 4% with our Filipino students we had a minus. 2% and with our Asian was a minus .1% so if you see kind of like between the trend of 2223 we had a slight increase but then from 2324 to 2425 we had a slight decrease in the same TR in the same um um semester quarters our next slide you're going to see that we this represents the percentage of students uh by group um first again there's the increase of our faster uh uh group students by 2% um but we do see a also a decrease with our homeless by negative 2.7% as well with our student with disabilities a minus 9 point uh 0.9% um with social economic disadvantage with the ACG there is a minus 6%
210again overall gusd is at minus 4% and with our EO population we had a minus. 2% decrease there as well and again you see con from the two-year 22 23 to 2024 slight increase but then a slight decrease in 23 24 to 2425 Mr Mark will go take us in regards to the suspension of incidents so this next set of data shows uh through second quarter the number and rate of suspension incidents now this is different than actual students this illustrates the number of incidents that the students from the first table were suspended for meaning some students have been suspended multiple times for different incidents an example would be um you could have uh eight incident suspensions that were generated by two students okay so diving into the numbers as we did on the first
211table uh starting with the district again 64,000 students enrolled there were 2116 suspension incidence or a rate of 3.3 compared to this year uh down to 1729 a reduction of 387 incidents in our African-American subgroup uh we had 656 incidents last year down7 this year to 549 Foster youth saw a slight increase last year at 37 this year at 47 and students with disabilities uh had a nice reduction as well from 7 18 incidents um down 116 to 602 for our elementary segment um saw the same types of reductions last year having 245 incidents that resulted in a suspension down this year to 21 uh net difference of 44 our African-American students from 94 down to 51 almost cutting that in half down 43 Foster youth again a slight decrease from 5 to three and
212then our students with disabilities um cutting that in half from 140 down to 68 this year with our Middle School um so again we had a minus 185 decrease of incidents between one year and the other from 943 to 758 overall with our middle schools uh with our African-American students we had a 277 to 249 that is a minus 28 incidents with a faster youth we did had an increase uh so with 13 students there were 31 incidents with you know that were committed with 13 students that's why you see kind of the increase of percentage there after 96% because the that that difference of rate and also involvement um with our student with disabilities we uh maintain Plateau is equal from one year to another uh didn't went up or down the only thing
213is that we did had an increase of enrollment with with student with disability but they maintain a 284 uh incidences um um from one year to the other with our high schools we had also a decrease of 148 incidents uh from 877 to 729 um with African-American students there were a minus 29 incidences from 262 to 233 faster youth uh minus two incidents from from 15 to 13 and from with our student with disability at the high school we had a minus 44 decrease from 280 to incidents uh the next slide is just again A visual representation of that uh as you notice our foster youth they had an increase of plus 99.1% but then again uh this just again kind what I I explained earlier is the difference between 13 students committing 31 incidences
214and then the difference between enrollment from one year to the other with the African-American students there were minus Point minus 1.6% decrease with our student with disabilities a minus 1.1% and with overall edusd a minus 6% decrease uh of incidences a lot of numbers to digest especially after lunch so we're going to throw some more at you uh this is a great visual representation of violation categories and how they were responded to on the right side are the individual violation categories and the left side is the type of response and the percentage it was used so looking at the the the right column the red and the orange on the very first one is Defiance disrespect and non-compliance there were 6265 violations in that category so far this year through second quarter the left side
215corresponds with that defines disrespect um non-compliance and it shows you how those things were handled so for instance uh 64% of them the the bright blue were teacher managed the dark blue uh would be admin managed using other means of Correction and that was 34% and then a little less than a perc um was met with a suspension and so as you as you take a look at the numbers and and looking at the left side your eyes might gravitate toward some categories that have the majority of the orange bars if you will fighting or possession use of drugs or alcohol or a weapon uh and you can see that those specific categories were met more so with a suspension rather than a teacher dealing with it or um you know other means of Correction
216just quick shout out and kudos to teachers and admin teams because uh year to year we're finding more and more of these um incidents are being handled by teachers and admin uh without suspending students so that's our goal okay some additional respon oh I'm sorry let let me get this first um to wrap the the numbers up really uh seven uh 7% received a suspension of of the incidents behavioral incidents which is the same as last year uh the reason that we saw a reduction in suspensions this year even though the percentage is the same is because we had less incidents um to that we were faced with 93% received an alternative to exclusionary discipline of that 93% 54% received uh some type of teacher managed classroom response and that's up 10% uh from last
217year 19% received some kind of alternative from an admin could have been a student conference guarding contact Etc that's up from last year as well 10% received a detention which is a a sharp decrease from 27% the year before um thinking that a lot of that is due to the fact that at the elementary level you can no longer take recess away so they that detention is eliminated and then 7% receive some type of M response like restorative conversations I know you you heard a lot about that earlier today um or could be student contracts Etc that's up 1% from last year all right now that we've taken a look at our data we'll walk through and review what our decision-making model is um and how we use that data so we definitely want to
218use data to influence um our decision making process and a little bit of a review or if it's the first time that you've seen this basically this is our decision making model Continuum and we'll read it from left to right and essentially we always want to begin with our data uh what is our current performance level where are we and this helps us to understand um the data we have to look at our inputs our outputs and then analyze the data that those are giving us after we take a look at the data we definitely want to analyze that gap between where we are and where we want to be um the data will help us identify that we can set some goals to where we want to be and then we'll take a look
219at our cause analysis so this is the step where we ask oursel what's causing us to get the results that we're getting uh so these first three steps help us confirm the why why are we getting this data and then the next three help us decide what to do how to do it and how to measure what we're doing to see if it gets us where we want to be uh so we can look at this through the how uh through the design and development uh what do I need to do to get where we want to be with our data so have our starting point have our goal set and then what do I need to do to get there and uh ideal situation is where we review our research-based best practices so those
220are the things that we want to implement to get us where we want to go and then how do we ask ourselves do we know what we need to do to assure what we're doing is working so we monitor that uh once we implement the process we Implement those best practices and then we evaluate if they're impacting us the way we want them to uh through further data analysis and kind of starting the process over so have I implemented something is it getting me the data I want okay let's continue that and is there's something else we could add on or we've implemented something and we're not seeing the data that we're hoping to so let's go back to the beginning and go through another cause analysis and see if that's the step and then
221start the process over so what are we doing as a result of the data excuse me we continue to utilize uh the mtss framework and its processes uh looking at all three Frameworks the academic social emotional and behavioral and we use it because it addresses all the needs of all the students it aligns the entire system of initiatives supports and resources and it helps us Implement a continuous improvement process at all levels of the system so focusing on the the behavior leg of this pyramid tier three is uh where we'll start and um that's the most intensive tier for mtss and it has the fewest students um but that's where you find the Intensive practices you may find a a behavior support specialist doing a functional Behavior Analysis for a student or developing a behavior
222intervention plan for a student if we look at uh tier two that houses more of the Strategic practices and examples of that could be a checkin checkout with a trusted adult where a student would every day meet with someone set a goal for the day or maybe check in on a goal they have for the week and go through their day and at the end of the day they would come back and meet with that individual again and and share how it went uh you might see passes for for quick breaks from class um you could see small group counseling or Behavior Support social groups etc for today though we're going to be focusing on tier one the universal um tier uh and the mtss process uh it starts in the classroom uh taking this
223Universal approach by defining schoolwide expectations uh and at the elementary levels students are walked all over campus to understand um you know how do I behave in this certain area versus this certain area because my behavior in the office or in the library is probably much different than it is in the lunchroom and out on the yard uh we utilize PBIS and restorative practices to teach and model appropriate behaviors uh and then of course acknowledging those behaviors for students we establish routines and procedures across campus we provide instruction that's culturally and linguistically relevant and we integrate seal into academic instruction some additional responses uh examples to how Behavior incidents are responded to on the left side you can see uh titled teacher managed and on the right would be more of admin other means of
224correction but starting with the teacher side teachers rely so heavily on their relationships and the connections they make with students and families uh that they can handle so many situations with just a a talking to the student a conference um they may utilize you know sometimes they have to do a little more they they might have to utilize a timeout in a buddy room or adjusted seating of course utilizing the mtss process when that's called for on the right side with other means of Correction our admin teams do much of the same uh having those conferences with students involving the parent calls sometimes they have to to go for student contracts things like that but once again utilizing the mtss process um to give you an idea um of how these things happen if if
225we think back to that other chart that had Defiance disrespect and um non-compliance there were 6200 I think in fractions in that in that category you know if a student was being disrupted in class A teacher could pull that student aside and and sometimes simply that's all it takes to have a quick conversation quick conference but sometimes the student is going to test the waters maybe and they're going to continue with the behavior and that might result uh into bringing the parent into the the mix with a phone call or a conference uh that could progress into maybe a timeout in a buddy room or ultimately maybe a referral to admin where admin has a conference and and starts that process over so we definitely look at Progressive discipline um when we're looking at how
226we handle uh kids bottom line is we want to teach uh students the rules before they break them thank you Mr fr um this is going to be a um some some of our current practices that we currently have not only at the district level but the site level as well Mr Vargas earlier mentioned something about having a foundation right and the importance of the foundation to make sure that we have a clear understanding how we're going to deliver those foundations so everybody can have that sense of of understanding so some of the things that we do here at the district office and school level is um one example is calibration of practices right the foundation of that is so important that how our vice principles and principles and staff kind of calibrate in in
227every meeting that we have when we have our principles with us we calibrate with then we bring real life scenarios to make sure that they collaborate and they brainstorm in regards to how would they handle different situations at different things also we do the same thing with Vice principles and then those practices and then our principles and vice principles Tak into the site so they can continue that calibration the the importance of ensuring that everybody has a clear understanding of those restored practices you guys just went and experienc resed practices earlier this morning and this is one of the things that our campuses and school SCH do very very well in regards to how they work training and how our teachers are using those restorative practices how our admin are using restorative practices is so
228important and key for them to have those Foundation skills and how to handle this with our diversity and Equity inclusion the majority of our staff not all of our staff have gone through this training you know districtwide in regards to how um important it is to to have this extensive training which we learn to embrace and support and understand each other and how you know we all come together and have the foundations of that our instructional framework um our CPL um department has done a great trendence job in regards to bringing that into Forefront with our principles and vice principles in regards to our uh framework of high quality instruction with our fun walkthroughs and the in other trainings that they do over at District 56 uh mindfulness um I am aware of many of
229our teachers in at many different sites that how they bring that into our classrooms you know to make sure to Res set our and get ready our students for them to be prepared for the learning often times there are so many things happening in the in the in the lives of our students that that they need that five minute to decompress and kind of set their minds in regards to that aspect of the learning so many of our uh teachers practice that social emotional learning you know we know that that brings academic success improve mental health and positive relationships betweenin students and teachers the escalation um that is in how we communicate and how we use our body language and how we do our personal space and how become active listeners and provide empathy right
230and how to deescalate different situations in our campuses in crisis and prevention and intervention just how we prevent and we can intervene more and more with our with u um with our students um I continue with uh with these foundations and Cent practices is the use of um the discipline Matrix back in 2017 2018 we brought this are discipline Matrix to all of our all of our admins and all of our schools so we make sure that our vice principles and principles really really kind of engage in this in this in this tier one tier two tier three different uh um size of the Matrix and then they take it to to the teachers you know I know that many of our principles uh either at pre-service or throughout the year they engage our teachers
231in regards to how would that look like and how we handle different uh situations differently because it's a student is a behavior and it depends on what tier they are as well um interventions and alternatives to suspension these include again restorative practices uh well we some of our schools have wellness centers and some of our schools have similar to wellness centers but they they call it something different but nonetheless we do provide a space for our students to go and engage and have conversations with their with a wellness counselor or with a counselor so to make sure they they they again they get ready to go back to the classroom and learn we collaborated with Wellness providers from outside our schools um and also students um student study teams and individualized education plans team collaboration
232um our sites U monitor um disaggregated data often we have provided them with a lot of tools this include summative informative some of our formative are powerbi something that they get weekly by our research and evaluation Department to see where they are at that time frame between this year and last year and compare that data our principles really engaging these conversations not only with leadership but also with our staff um and then we have also set up a lot of good reports and Synergy where we also have driven our principles and vice principles and how to access that data when it comes from grades discipline and attendance talk and they can filter that by in different many ways U um and also with that information in principles and vice principal meetings we we have what
233it call progress Summit where our principles come invest principles come together and they share their current practice that they have on in a um on their campus and then they share with their colleagues and their colleagues you know give them feedback in regards to forces them to think strategically in regards to things differently of different things they can bring into their campuses and then of course we have the summited which is California dashboard in in the term data um along with that we also try to improve our focus and instruction and connections to social emotional learning and along with our curriculum um and continue additional funding Staffing and supports um Vice principles counselors social workers campus supervisors academic inter teachers that with all of their support and help that we also have seen a trend
234of change of our practices and our campuses and support of discipline connect uh students to campus through clubs Sports and expanded learning that is a focus that we always push our vice principles and principles to have to make sure that every student is connected to something to either a club a program a sport a pathway in a academy uh something that is going to really resonate with students and the experience and have a good good experience on our campuses and uh expand student voice and decision- making via student Equity councils black student union and student government we always seeking for their voice we always want to make sure that the schools have the practices that is going to support them because their voice really really brings them brings our campuses more into life and make
235sure that we have the services that they need um and lastly but connect with our uh families to BU relationships in order to support their understanding of school culture and commutations this is something that I know is a challenge many of our campuses to bring families in into our campuses but this still a push that we have we work collaborated with our U family community engagement uh Department to make sure that our families can engage more and more in different things that we do on our campuses and they inform also of the things are happening on our campuses so that they are aware of all these great things that we have okay just to touch on a few promising practices uh that are supporting all three of the Frameworks uh for mtss we have developed
236a universal study team process um all the elementary schools have been trained and are using the process uh next step is to get secondary schools trained which should come this spring early fall completing deescalation training that that Richard mentioned having mtss meetings at all schools to review data including uh charting the number of requests for assistance thinking that stronger the tier one the foundational um strategies are it would be less and less need for request for assistance uh and then consistent implementation of the tier one mtss supports and PBIS and lastly just to talk about a couple Pier One accomplishment tier one accomplishments um PBIS continues to be strong in our district with 66 out of 67 seven schools receiving awards for their implementation all light all site leadership teams have received tier one restorative
237practices training I think you heard about that earlier over the next two years site staffs will receive uh four days of the same training and then finally 88% of elementary schools and 87% of secondary schools were trained uh or participated in the D escalation training on how to identify the functions of behavior how to remain rational Detachment in an elevated situation and how to work with a student who is verbally escalating so with that we would thank you and um entertain any comments or questions thank you very much uh let's see Mr Yang do we have any blue cards on this item board president no blue card on this item thank you very much uh all right so we'll move to board member questions and comments let's start on the other side this time uh
238Miss Moore would you like to KI us kick us off sure thank you uh so first of all in the future if there's a reference made to a previous specific action taken by the board it would be helpful if you could give us you know that reference so that we have that background I would really appreciate that uh so am I correct that Miss A said that we are using restorative justice practices um in these instances is that what she said in the beginning of the presentation yes in many incidents yes okay uh so uh could it be argued that in order to connect one student or to connect with one student um to avoid exclusionary discipline that we are negatively impacting the learning or um even the safety of many other students if I
239understand you correctly you mean um having a student on campus or in class is disruptive versus a suspension of removing them from the class yes um so we practice Progressive discipline uh and we want to you know especially in elementary school we want to teach the students you know behavior um all behavior is learned both positive and negative so following Progressive discipline allows um a teacher within their class to be the judge of when it's time to say this is escalating to a certain level and I'm going to remove you from learning environment for x amount of time or refer you you know up to the office Etc and then the office would look for alternative means of Correction to the Behavior now there are some behaviors that are so severe uh that you know
240suspension is the answer I shouldn't say the answer but suspension is the response but but most often teachers are trying to keep students in class to continue learning and at the same time balancing that level of disruption do you think that puts a burden on a heavier burden on teachers in some ways have you had any feedback in that in that way uh no not really um you know being a teacher myself once it it sometimes you can get frustrated and you have to catch yourself but uh our teachers are doing a fantastic job as evidenced by um some of the data in uh managing those behaviors I'm sure at times they get frustrated I mean they're human and um you know you're you're trying to conduct something in class and it's not going the
241way you want because maybe you've got a couple students that aren't paying attention I think I think also P like at first when this is introduced to our teachers there there's always that that um feeling of the unknown how is this going to be in my classroom how am I going to do this because it's a in New practice and it's change um I've had teachers where they express that sentiment with me that feeling in regards to this is you know something else that we have to do how is this going to um this going to get me behind by a curriculum is I but once they try it in and and and how to restore the behavior in the classroom it kind of help then then come back to me oh my God I
242did restore a circle in my classroom because of this behavior and everybody was engaged and everybody had a conversation and everybody helped each other to restore that behavior and and this happened two weeks ago and I haven't seen that behavior again so I I guess it just depends on if it is uh kind of the the introduction stage versus once to started doing in the classroom um Miss Mo I was going to add to that also our teachers are evaluated and also expectation for the California standards for the teaching profession so part of the work they do in a classroom is about managing students and part of the work that we are demonstrating with the strategies that we're choosing is looking at where we are right now in 2024 25 school year the needs of
243students and making sure that training we provide to teachers and the supports we provide them is the most accurate and reflective of student need right now so the restorative practice piece when we look at that we're seeing that as a a way to prevent some of the behaviors by building that community in the classroom um but acknowledging the fact that that is the work teachers do it isn't just the academic side of it it's the management of students and teaching them the behavioral skills they need in addition to the social emotional learning can I add to that real quick I think the other piece that's really important uh for for us to understand as a former teacher is a lot of value in having the other kids in the classroom Express the impact that this
244one student had on them and on their learning and giving children the safe place to express that helps build empathy and nine out of 10 times in my experien is when the child who was destructive or who was behavior is is is a communication of need so if the child who communicated his need inappropriately or not within how we wanted them to communicate that need when they hear from the other kids and when they hear how their behaviors have impacted other kids it actually helps to create a sense of belonging it also helps to say say to the kid when you do that then we can't learn and that's important for the child to sometimes hear that because that has more value and what their impact is on their own colleagues so when we think
245about restorative practices or circles it's not always just about um the the kid who's engaged in the behavior more often than not it's also about the other children sharing the impact that that has had on them and teachers do that really well because they they know the kids they are in the classroom and it avoids um sometimes future interventions because then the child who exhibits the behavior realizes oh when I did that last time this is how my friends were impacted by my behavior I should really think about re-engaging in that behavior so it's more of a preventative tool if it's used stri okay thank you uh so I previously in the last presentation I specifically had questions about victims with this this you know the way that we're you're mentioning that your you know
246the changes you've made how does that impact victims are they expected to change their Behavior or they they you know are they expected to make changes absolutely um one of the greatest things that we have uh that we are doing is re-entry meetings with our students so whenever the students are asked to serve their suspension because the infraction warrant is suspension when they come back they do meet with a vice principal and a counselor and if they have an IU or they have an in 54 and then they bring some other folks in to make sure that uh that during that re-entry meeting they go over expectations and they review kind of the what the behavior was and what is it expected moving forward so we have within that and then some of our sites
247it depends if if it is like as an example a fight with two students and then upon their return they do offer the resered practice or the mediations within both students because we want we want for that to that behavior to stop um because often times you know during a a fight situation doesn't stop only one time they come back and they want to re-engage because they were not happy with the outcome of that fight or whatever was po so and social media about that fight so we we always wanted to make sure that we intervene and go over expectations with them okay well my concern with that is just I I understand what you're trying to do and I think that it's overall a good you know good goal and good ideas but we
248do have to be really careful that we are protecting victims and that is a huge concern for me as a mom but also what I've heard from a lot of parents I mean you hear it even at the at the board meetings I've heard it with people in my community it's common at schools where people feel that their child is victimized and the schools don't listen and that the bully is honestly kind of doing we're going through the processes we're you're talking about now which sounds great but there's a victim there's a child on the other side who's dealing with that and sometimes it's cyber bullying uh that's happen even at elementary school level and so it's easy to say oh we're going to talk about it but those things really affect kids and it
249it you know it can affect them outside of the classroom and if we're just kind of talking about things but not actually addressing those situations there's kids at school who are left feeling like they're they're not validated that they that they don't no one cares about them and they shouldn't be put in those situations um so that's a really big concern to me when I hear when we have these discussions is yes I understand that there's things we can do to um you know reduce suspension rates and things like that if it makes sense but we also always have to make sure we're we're keeping kids safe and we're making them feel safe when they come to school and that has to be a priority so so what I mean what are we doing to
250make sure that the victims are protected I think you very good um U you know point of view in comment I think uh one of the things that we have offer is counseling there is many many times where we know where there's a victim and then and especially because of things that transpire and how the incident transpired on campuses so we do have kind like those wellness centers we have a counselors we have some social workers on our campuses and then we also sometimes refer out you know to make sure that we they get the services that that they need unfortunately there's often times that our our students don't come to tell us right because they're they they you know either because they had a bad experience or because they felt that they were not
251listening to or so they stop coming to us so they go to the parents and then the parents you know then you know sometimes they say they they they TR ask at home regard how to handle it but sometimes they don't call us as well right but and when they do I'm hoping that our campuses do respond to that you to to that you know to to that call because that is something that we it is our priority to make sure that a social emotional wellbe of our students are supported in all different ways um so thank you for that and I'll make sure that we follow up with our campuses to make sure that they are following with our victims to make sure they're supporting them one piece just as a followup Mr Mo
252um it is it is part of the reality of these reports is um suspension is a tool we use and we and you you can see we use it hundreds of times and so uh the idea that we and our goal isn't zero suspensions because suspensions are kids that do act um that we do need to remove them from our schools for a for a period of time and or you know move forward with expulsion as well so that that balance of um what is the right number of suspensions and and are we using the tool appropriately um is an important one the the thing that uh as ay spoke to at the beginning was the disproportionality is is the uh the thing that we're really working towards to make sure our systems don't identify
253kids um um Andor um Levy discipline uh disproportionately based on whatever criteria that you want to use to describe the kids so we want make sure we're clear uh we do use suspension and it it is a tool sometimes we're required to by law some things are actually mandatory suspensions and mandatory move forward for expulsion so we'll never be at zero um and the goal isn't to get to zero but it is to find that right balance of how are we using restorative practices how are we using PBIS how are we using the tools of suspension when necessary but doing so um equitably across the district and when a kid does something at one site or a kid does the same thing at another site that the consequences um are very similar that's the work
254around the The Matrix and um making sure that we're calibrating across the district so that um similar actions receive similar results to the same point uh president Vargas spoke to is each situation is about an individual kid and we do have to take the consideration of what what's going on in that situation so there's a lot to balance through through all of it yes and I understand not everything is necessarily suspension worthy or expulsion worthy but you know I do think that consequence con sometimes kids need to have consequences so they can learn lessons and also to protect other kids that's just my thoughts uh and then also on page let's see I think it was page 22 we you know you listed several of the um current District practices um I still have some
255questions about the restorative practices um especially how that's implemented as I mentioned um I just learned that Dei cost taxpayers more than $7 million um and then social emotional learning and PBIS are something that I've been trying to learn about for a while um they've the The District staff the superintendent has reported that they're evidence based but there's really not any evidence so I guess what I would like to say is just that I understand that what we're trying to do here is support our students and learning uh you know like again we were talking about we want to make sure that we are giving our children high high quality evidence-based curriculum and I understand that all these things are meant to support them so they can be successful um something that I would like
256to see possibly is that we have some sort of GRA or something um to actually to chart you know when each of these things was implemented and then how that is how uh the academic outcome of our students has has changed I mean because data is important and all of these things cost money and resources um and we want to make sure that we're actually supporting our students so they they can be successful and um yes there's more to suc Les than just academics but we are an academic institution so we need to make sure we're measuring that um and you know just I think that that's kind of all I have to say I just I do want to say though that this the again going back to the victims a real life example
257is I I know someone shared a story with me where their child um had been bullied by a group of other children and the school just kind of um pushed it away I you know I don't know exactly the details of how it was dealt with but ultimately because it wasn't there was not consequences um one of the bullies ended up uh cornering this child and ultimately their head was pounded into the concrete multiple times at school so I know that's an extreme situation but we can't ignore um these issues when someone is saying these people are bullying me these people are attacking me um we have to take that very seriously and um because our every child does matter and that is you know that's not okay with me and also that's a li
258becomes a liability for us and um then going back to the public comment that was made about safety you know we need to make sure that we are ensuring that we properly deal with these situations so it doesn't become a school sight safety issue uh my children were personally involved with the the incident this last week where they were in a lockdown and it's very scary to get texts from your children that something like that is happening and that their you know their teachers have um scissors in their hand waiting behind the door like that's many staff and students were very scared so we need to make sure that like if we're going to say every student matters we need to make make sure we're keeping every student safe and that we're doing what we
259can to prevent those big situations where every student can potentially not be safe so that's what I have to say thank you for your presentation thank you this ballerini okay I have a couple little clarifying questions actually so um you can go to slide six so it say enrollment for this year this year [Music] 65,7 and I'm confused because we got ceds paperwork that says 63,0 and7 we're were 21 kids really absent on seabeds day is that what we're saying I uh that I don't know I mean and I it wouldn't matter if they were absent if they're enrolled um they'd be counted this was through the second quarter of this school year I know ceds is in October um which would be the first quarter I believe that could be a reason but I
260I don't know I can answer that this is total enrollment so any student that was enrolled even for one day would count in the enrollment numbers because if they were enrolled for a short period of time and still had an incident we would count that so this is our total enrollment doesn't necessarily mean our ceds count so kids kids would go in and out you know there a kid that transfers in yeah but then a kid and then the kid transfers back out that kid counts in this number um because right but not in seabeds not in ceds got it ceds is the sensus of how many kids are enrolled on the day we do the seabeds and then you do P2 again later okay that's related to ad yes okay all right so that
261that helps me there because and are both 23 24 and 24 25 just the first and second quarter yes okay so it's not all of 23 24 you you're I didn't wanted to make sure you weren't doing apples and oranges you're doing oranges to oranges yeah this time of year this this report we do um for through December so the first half of the year and then we'll come back in August and we'll do the full year got it all right that makes sense also um is there a way we can get some kind of paperwork or the Ed codes that show so what is suspendable and ex expulsion is that right that's expellable I'm like expulsion isn't a word expellable um because I have no idea what the severity difference is between the two
262of them and that might be helpful is uh that [Music] and where's one and two other than that um I appreciate all the numbers back and forth and the little graphs and all of that it's it's a lot and um yeah it's it's amazing to me how many kids mess up let's just put it that way and I hope for Less thank you uh Mr Yang yeah good afternoon uh thank you for the presentation um certainly there's a lot of numbers um on the presentation as well uh but it's much appreciated because we needed to see so um I did do a study on uh suspension uh in the saal county school district so it indicate that um a kid any students that has been suspended or five times more likely to be go to
263jail versus a kid that hasn't been suspended so this is a a big factor of uh their life success and uh it's very important and and so gradually um as far as I could remember these number has show a trend of going uh lower reducing suspension uh over the course of my uh years and in in the school board which is uh is a good thing um I I'm just curious to uh to know and perhaps maybe clarified I heard um you guys mentioned that the the number of suspension per one kid um I just want to make sure that it's a it's it's understanding understood correctly so if a kid is been suspended one kid same kid been suspended for more than one time now the number of students remain the same but the
264number of suspension goes up right correct the number of suspension incidents goes up okay all right and that that's why we show it in both formats you know one is related to number of kids but then there's another one that's related to incidents that catches the the one kid that does more than once yeah I just wanted to clarify that um so we we do account for all suspension okay all right that's that's good news so um now do we I'm sure we know the reason reason why the kids uh get suspended are we um are we plan to incorporate that into this presentation uh because I I mean I hope that it's it's probably incorporate in your strategy as far as interventions right so that you identify the cost of thep suspension and um
265you could uh get the kids into the proper intervention to prevent uh future occurrence so um is that a thought that you guys might want to put on here so that we have better understanding of the rate of uh if you guys did maybe uh I missed it I think we can perhaps answer this two ways um thinking of mtss uh and having that foundational base the universal strategies that we employ and when students um have a behavior and they might need need something more strategic we would find out you know what's causing that behavior and then how can we be more strategic to address it and then once again if we had to even go higher uh to the Intensive tier um we would know at least what we've tried and perhaps what driving
266that behavior that makes sense Richard pull at page 12 this was this was an attempt to be able to capture um part of what you're um you're speaking to uh Mr because it is critically important to know why kids are being suspended and at what rates and as you see and you know there's um acts of violence drugs those those kinds of things are where we're really focusing um the use of the suspension tool and we use many of our other tools when it comes to um you know actions that are that are not violence related and so that's that was the attempt it's really difficult to put it all together in a usable format but that's that's the attempt of this particular chart oh I appreciate it I think that very uh help for
267transparency um purposes um I do want to U make a comment in addition to what I already said uh is that um you know I have had parents in our school district um came to me and express concerns of ongoing bullying that um was not being addressed properly and I I had taken upon myself to speak with Chris and and and move forward in that regard and been successful addressing it properly but the concern that I I had and still having is that uh why do we have these um staff not addressing the The Bullying um situation way sooner um and and so so that is I'm sure ongoing um work in progress to make sure that our staff understand the the seriousness of the bullying and if if that occurs it has to put
268into stop right away and and and and I have seen it multiple times and so so my thing is this I think that if that happens in any uh school or staff we have to address in the sense of putting that um staff rather is a teacher or principal or all together that are involved that knows the situation and and they kind of kind of you know I guess derail a little bit of uh really taking it to the level where it needs to be because what I am disappointing of when I heard those kind of situation is the the the just kind of like let it it Go and and when it comes to the top tier uh which is the superintendent um concern or the board's concern and then it's been addressed and
269then it gets addressed at right away and because it's how serious it was but then it wasn't that serious to those staff so so I want to see a you call intervention or a um a training you know if that occurs in future then we have that sort of uh training for staff to say hey if this happened if you're not really sure then you need to talk to you know the the director or or the superintendent right away but don't don't just let it you know slide and then let it keep going and I think that's detrimental uh to the students and the parents um both sides really and and what that means is I mean being very detailed here because it's important um is that the the booer you know it's detrimental to
270to that person as well because that person doing it wrong but nobody disciplined that person but that person probably think it's okay to do it right so is is damaging that person more um as as he progress exercising that kind of behavior and then to to the you know victim as you know yeah I mean being bullied and no one really uh repent in the situation then the Buller I mean the the victim you know get into deeper trauma and then other stuff so this and then and the parents get involved and so it has that Domino fact so I think this sounds like a pretty straightforward situation but it just gets lies you know um time to time so I just think that if we if we can you can you guys speak to
271that if we have something at concrete to uh train our staff if that happen uh in the future I don't know if we have a specific training um but I can tell you with um great certainty at the elementary level if if a student comes in or a parent comes in to report that their child was bullied there's somewhat of a clarification that's made because the term bullying gets used as you are aware often um and you know a child saying something to another child may not be bullying just may be that that child is not being very nice and shouldn't say things like that um but when there is a report of something like that it's investigated like I said with with great certainty I can tell you that um principles and vice principles
272interview the other student they the one that was the receiver um they go follow up with the U the bully as you're using the term um and it's not just left alone now um sometimes the student the victim if you will they may not see what happens because we don't discuss what we do with other children with you know other children or other families and so I could tell you I get so many phone calls from parents saying nothing's the school's not doing anything and I call the school and there's a a list of things they're doing and supports that have been offered to you know the victim so I know that they they are acting on this um but oftentimes students continue that behavior I'm a parent myself and I you know you do
273the best you can bringing up your kids and you hope when they walk out the door they're going to represent you well and often times they they might not they might make a mistake and do something that's unkind or um and then you deal with that on that you know those occasions so I just don't want you to think that things are pushed under the table um and not dealt with and and when I speak of that I don't mean like you know uh but it there's a very very small percentage that that happened and I I I I know that our school is doing really good but you know sometimes we do um have individual staff that uh conduct it a little bit different right and maybe their torent a little bit U higher
274but you know it's it's not the torens of our school uh uh policies and I I have seen that and and what I speak to I don't want to go too too much detail on that but you know it involved in uh you know verbal bullying uh abuse uh physical abuse as well right and it it it drag on months and um and so to that kind of uh uh issue or I should say situation U I'm just wanted to know if we have anything to train those staff um so that they're more cautious of the um way that they approaching to that kind of uh uh I would say it's uh it's it's outside of the boundary of okay you know we do have the mandated reports mandated trainings that we have all of
275our staff go through through Power works that everybody is required to go through and at the same time you know at our sites you know our our counselors you know they they they are in the top vle regard to supporting their students there has been many in where things are happening outside the school and it happens through social media and the school is not aware of right and the parents assume that the school is aware of but it's not aware of and sometimes when it comes to the school the school are addressing it but then all this time I already had pass and and that's why sometimes our parents have the perception that schools are not doing anything about it but we do engage our our to support both the victim and the victimizer another
276piece just just remember this really important is um I appreciate the um recognition that the the vast majority of bowling situations get addressed at the classroom level on a daily basis and our folks do a phenomenal job and then there's other ones that get to a higher level and require other people to be involved um and there may be situations where we fail um as as staff to intervene in the way we should and um the expectation is that those things are taken care of and if we come across a situation where we didn't do our job then we we do need to follow up and we will follow up with staff members and whether that's an additional training that those folks would need and or a reminder of expectations but I do want to
277be clear and you and you said it the overwhelming majority of the time our folks are well trained our folks deal with these kinds of situations on a regular basis and they do it at the lowest level possible of the overwhelming majority of the time but as things move up the scale and they're and they're more intense or U then then we deal with them but if someone's not doing not meeting expectation on the adult side we have to hold people accountable for that as well yeah yeah so I mean I I said it and Chris reiterate that so so you know I do give credit to our team as overall you know more time than not for sure we we we have done an excellent job and continue do an excellent job I just
278wanted to point that out that those uh you know those kind of exception uh situation we we still have to have that you know intervention of training our own adults right making sure that we're taking care of them uh with that said um I just want to end on a good note that uh you know even though it's kind of separate but I think it's an interwine you know as a a um underline is that the the face um program we have our staff visiting uh homes with schools I'm sorry visiting homes talk to students and parents and I think that that relationship um of building and understanding their situation and also on our situation be able to conversate to that uh personal level I think it it helps tremendously to um to reduce suspension
279in a way uh and um I want us to be intentional about these kids that are being suspended in particularly um the disproportional kids like the African-American Foster youth students with disability be very intentional about um visiting them and their their family and uh you know just be a uh a listener and you know and provide whatever that we can so just want to say uh great job on the face uh program as well and thank you for the presentation thank you very much Miss Alani thank you for the presentation can um looking at page six can we assume all other groups are lower than these or are these picked out because they are um put on the dashboard okay I'm sorry one more time um our numbers here we we always show African-American Foster
280youth students with disabilities we do that because that's what's on the California dashboard correct correct and we've identified them in the past as being um disproportionate okay and so we wanted to be able to try to focus efforts there and track data over time okay I think that's a view of our transparency um can I can we assume that the other groups are not are at a lower level these are our top three yeah and if you take a take a look at it because we did get some feedback um when we did these presentations in years past we only focused on our targeted groups and we did get feedback from the board that they they wanted information about the other groups as well so that's why on page eight we list the the wider
281range of of of groups and they are they are lower than those targeted groups for sure thank you um on page seven I um not sure what our Peak was about last year but it's very exciting to see this drop um these reports alone have come to be since I've been on the board and we've watched them go around but I was excited um we actually closed some Gap last year so so I mean that's what we've all been trying to do congratulations it's huge it really is huge and and we did we missed it with um the foster kids and I do feel good that we have a foster staff that helps try to help those children and we and we do have a focus there but um it's it's really exciting you guys
282we this is what we've been working for and to watch this start to happen um I hope we're we're taking note of what's working and and I think we we did talk about that on page 23 you talked about um replicating best practices and I and I think that just is where all the strength is going to be because we we're starting to figure out I feel like from here we're starting to figure out some of the stuff and um and we just need to make sure we're doing it across the whole District to make sure all students have a chance to benefit from it and the only other thing I wanted to point out was on slide 12 and 13 um we talk about the teachers and when we first saw these s they
283did not have that much turquoise color on them teacher managed color um you know huge thank you to all our teachers out there thank you very much and I think you couldn't have two things that work together better restorative practices which is very equal to to equity which is very similar to arbinger it's all that idea of building a relationship and when you have a relationship with someone a short correction goes a long way and those teachers can make them now because they're investing in our children to make those relationships and more of them are and we're providing them ways to do it so I think it's really exciting more um it went up 10% last year that's that's a celebration point in this report and we're always we will always have suspensions because there's
284things we need to suspend kids for and you I mean you take away your kids's phone at some point or your car at some point that's the same idea in parenting there's levels and um I think our levels are becoming more appropriate and I appreciate the work that a teachers are putting in towards them thank you Miss Davis um I'm glad to see that we're doing the restorative practice because I really don't like the word victim I think we're teaching our children not to be victims by making them a part of process teaching them how to Advocate and have their own voices in this um that goes all the way to adulthood you know we all deal with bullies even in adulthood and need to have the skill set to deal with them working at
285a school site I agree with Mr fine um the word bullying is throw it around way too easy um when you try to explain it to a parent um that it's something that's pervasive and is ongoing rather than just a negative interaction between two kids one time but a lot of times it's viewed as bulling even if it is just one interaction so I think that's something we need to educate our parents on knowing the difference when they come in because they are part of the the solution but we need to get them past the verbiage to what the actual problem is um we also have to be careful with what's being brought to us um you brought up cyber bullying a lot of that happens at home we have no say and have no
286right to intervene in those issues unless it's disrupting our School site um so so we have to be real careful of what we're expected to take care of what we're expected to fix um at the school sites and I think they do a really good job sorting through that it doesn't always make everybody happy they would just want it solved but sometimes is not our problem um we also have to keep in mind too students are coming from homes that have different expectations you you have gentle parenting all the way to strict parenting and we as a school district are trying to to absorb them in teach them one set of rules one set of um Behavior it's a big job and I think our people are doing a really good job based on the
287all the differences that are brought in um and coming back from Co we just we seen it at the school sites it was different a different children all the way around two years home with Mom and Dad was not the best thing that could happen with them um we're retraining is what we're doing and and like I said we're doing a really really good job on that um but I'm liking what we're doing with it and teaching our children to be a part of the process instead of the victims that's all I have to say thank you thank you uh thank you for the presentation um I it gets it gets better every every time we have it um the data gets clearer the uh you know there's there's more information that's incredibly helpful um
288you know and so I appreciate that you all continue to you know work hard on that and um to improve it every time and I think it's you know part of why we do this you know sort of going back to basics is you know this data is the canary in the coal mine right data this data tells us you know it's not the fact you know disproportionality is you know a problem but it's a problem because it tells us something things wrong um it's a problem because you know it says Hey something else is going on here that we need to address and you talked about this when you talked about you know our continuous Improvement model and how we go through and make decisions every single time and we try and improve it
289every single time um and I think that's why we have to keep doing this right we have to keep having this presentation because it keeps it in the Forefront of our minds it keeps it in the Forefront of your minds um and says we are going to continuously improve here um because it is something we need to keep an eye on uh because the minute we take our eye off of it it's going to get worse again um so I appreciate that you all are taking that very seriously every time you come in um let's see uh one of the things I want you all pointed this out just want to reiterate it is I love that we are seeing uh significant declines at the elementary level I think that is particularly a place where
290we can uh you know where this is going to have a big impact um you know because we just shouldn't you know in a perfect world you we just shouldn't be suspending Elementary School students right there's so much learning that can happen there there is so much they are learning about Behavior they are learning about um interacting with each other interacting with adults there so much of that is happening in elementary school um that we can just have such a huge impact just by changing you know how we are setting expectations how we are implementing these things all of that is going to be so important and so seeing the results of that um you know is really hardening in this um so I was really happy to see those big drops at the elementary
291school level I think that's really really important um and I look forward to that continuing um uh let's see uh I I really appreciated uh that you mentioned bringing in students and parents into the tier one process I think that's so important in terms of setting uh expectations for the entire Community right making sure that parents are not only part of the problem but part of excuse me making sure that parents are not only part of the solution to the problem excuse me um but also understand these expectations as you know um you know so that they can then uh you know work with them at home uh work with the students at home and understand what the students are coming home with um you know I think that's also you know really important and
292I'm glad that you all are doing that um uh one of the things that I would love to see going forward um just as as you guys are improving this presentation uh every year would be um you know you guys give us three years of data in those in those graphs now that we have more data now that we've been keeping track of this longer I would love to see those Trends on a longer scale um so you know I obviously uh you know 2019 2020 2020 2021 are a little bit of an aberration we expect that we understand that um you know but I would love to kind of see how those how all of that works uh works out on a longer timeline um um I think you know jumping off of something
293that Miss albani said I think uh you know I one thing I also appreciate that about this is that it's making our practices much clearer um not only are we getting to a point and and agree where our you know um where our practices um are getting better but I appreciate that they're also getting clearer and what we're trying to do is getting clearer every day and the expectations we have based on this data is getting clearer every day um so I think that's also important um and I think you know just the last thing I'll say is you know jumping off of what my colleagues were saying about bullying I think you look at this data um and it is clear that that bullying is something different right uh you know because you see
294places where suspension is just suspension is the is the remedy right um possession of drugs uh you know um possession of alcohol bomb threats you know drug paraphernalia weapons things like that you see on here suspension is just the thing um and then you see also other areas where teacher managed is the response and that's overwhelming response for you know um for that and then bullying is somewhere in between it really is sort of that frustrating rub that we have to deal with um you know between the the things that can be you know addressed by teachers and the things that clearly require suspension or some form of Separation um and you know so you see physical aggression fighting fighting is a little bit more suspension um you know but harassment bullying things like that
295where you know it's not teacher managed it's something more um but it's not always suspension there is something there and I think that you know you we talked about this both in this presentation and the previous one um of sort of being Guided by this idea that we are creating Community right we are Guided by this idea that um we want people we want our students to all be engaged and all feel like they belong um and that includes students who do harm sometimes and students who are harmed sometimes and um you know community means everybody it has to mean everybody and that is often I mean that's difficult that is incredibly difficult to do sometimes it feels like separation is the right you know answer and should be the right answer and you know
296I I understand um you know when you're in that moment you know with uh I I don't have kids but having been in situations right where you just want to respond and it's much more intense when you have kids and your kids are in that situation and you want to respond right you you want a response um you know that is the struggle is how do we how do we do all of that while still building that Community because separation we also have to remember you know yes it is a struggle when um you know students are and anybody when you're in the same place as somebody you you know don't agree with or don't like very much right those are difficult situations to be in um but we also have to recognize on the
297other side of that is the danger of Separation right there is a danger there is a risk to separating um the more you separate a student the more that student becomes isolated we know what happens when that stuff happens and so we have to be really careful as we're in this Balancing Act and this is the precarious balancing act that we have um is that balance between building Community how do we make sure that Community is cohesive how do we respond to things within that community and how do we use separation in a way that that is safe and healthy and you know is not going to result in something that is counterproductive to what we're trying to do so anyway with that thank you for the presentation I appreciate it as always um and
298we're good okay um let us move to our consent agenda uh Mr Yang are there any blue cards on the consent agenda board president no buer on this item thank you very much uh would any board members like to pull an item from the consent agenda seeing none I will entertain a motion to approve items one and two on the consent agenda move moved moved by Mr Yang seconded by uh miss ballerini all those in favor please say I I any opposed motion carries unanimously all right all right so uh the board will now meet in close session to address items one and two on the Clos session portion of the agenda um Mr Yang are there any public comments on these two items on the agenda board president there's no blue card on these
299items um then I will close the public comment and I will recess us into close session at 2:18 p.m. e e all right I'd like to call the meeting back to order at 3:04 p.m. uh and announce that the board met in closed session and no action was taken therefore I'd like to there no be there there being no further uh business before the board I'd like to adjourn the meeting at 3:05 p.m. e for