CorpusRecord 108724

1/27/2025 - NMUSD Special Board of Education Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Newport-Mesa Unified School District channel
Date
2025-01-28
Location
Orange County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
6,774 words · about 38 min
Collected
2026-06-20

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001all right I call the meeting to order at 6:01 Opening Ceremonies um led by trustee Cate please stand moment of reflection your hand over your heart IED to the FL flag of the United States of America and to the for stands Nation God indivisible and justice for all all right um Sam roll call vote trusty wean yes here trusty Soo yes trusty Murphy yes trusty Pearson yes trusty Anderson here trusty crane here Dr Smith here all right adoption of the agenda so move second moved by trusty Pearson seconded by trusty crane roll call vote trusty wean yes trustu yes trusty Murphy yes trusty Pearson yes trusty Anderson yes trusty crane yes the vote was 7 No Agenda has been adopted all right so welcome to our board meeting um as you know on December 9th

0022024 a vacancy was created on the Newport Mesa Unified School District Board of Education for trustee area 5 uh the truste vacancy will be filled by provisional appointment a provisionally appointed board member will hold the office for the remainder of the term for truste area 5 to to December 2026 unless terminated by petition beginning December 20th 2024 through January 21st 2025 the board accepted applications to fill this position the board received applications from Andrew Lawler Phil Mau Andrea malroy Valerie schned and ksten Walsh we will we will now receive public comment on our special meeting agenda uh trusty Murphy yes this is an opportunity for the public to address the board regarding items on the special meeting agenda only comments on special meeting agenda items are limited to three minutes per comment up to 20

003minutes per topic a speaker may not relinquish his or her time to another person all right first up we have Kate Maloof hi good evening uh superintendent Smith president wagan and Board of Trustees my name is Kate Maloof and I've been an active parent in the Newport Mesa District for 15 years my husband are three children and I have lived in District 5 during that entire time and all of our children have been educated by the nmusd system I am here tonight to speak on behalf of many constituents in District 5 three of whom are my children are are now of voting age and who have benefited from The District's education we believe it's important to ensure that our area continues to be represented by a trustee who reflects the values that our community has

004consistently supported and voted for for over four decades a diverse Board of Trustees is essential to the success and appeal of our district it's one of the key reasons so many parents choose to send their children to excuse me to our schools and for this reason I strongly urge you to appoint someone who truly understands the values and the priorities of the parents and taxpayers of District 5 which are predominantly made up of Newport Beach residents I also can ask you to consider appointing someone who is committed to the long term not for the next 18 months and not a placeholder each of you made the choice to run for public election and for this position and I thank you all for your service and for that dedication this appoint ointment is a special circumstance

005and it should be treated with a level of thoughtfulness and Care once again I respectfully ask that you consider the wishes of the voters of District 5 I truly believe there is a clear and strong Choice amongst the applicant pool Mrs maroy she is strong well prepared and dedicated and I am very confident that she will work tirelessly and serve to protect the children and Community alongside all of you thank you very much for your time and for your strong consideration thank you next up we have Karen yeli good evening superintendent Smith president president wean and board trustees I am here tonight as a grandparent of current and hopefully future and musd students while I have been away from the board's decision-making policies for over two years I am still a strong supporter of nmusd

006and hope the policy decisions of the board and future boards will justifi my continued support you were here tonight in this special session to select your partner on the school board this is a very serious and heavy decision to make I understand the gravity of the process as I was a board member when we meant to replace Dave Brooks upon his resignation in 2008 in our Democratic Society it is the local communities that vote to elect our Schoolboard members with the void left in area five this task instead has been placed with the seven of you sitting in front of us tonight in doing so I encourage you to select a candidate who will represent this area in a way that the voters in area five would approve so my ask tonight is that through

007the information you have gathered on each candidates application and your interviews this morning this this evening that you select a new trustee that fits the desires and reflects the values of the 19,000 voters in area 5 thank thank you thank you next up Ruth kobashi good evening my name is Ruth Sanchez kobashi and I'm an nmusd alumni mom longtime fan and volunteer for our school district you all know that I care deeply about our Costa Mesa and Newport Beach schools and that I respect each and every one of you I always look forward to cheering you on and thanking you for the important work that you are doing on behalf of all the students one can only imagine that the unusual circumstances of appointing a trustee is quite challenging you want to get it right

008I'm sure you hope to appoint someone who is deeply committed to our students is willing to serve Beyond two years run for election in the next cycle is a pleasure to work with and reflects the values of the voters of trust area 5 I'm speaking to you this evening because I believe that miss mroy is the best suited to be entrusted with this position her experience passion for our schools and values most closely align with the voters parents and community members of trustee area 5 I respectfully ask for you to appoint Miss mry to the Newport Mesa Board of Trustees thank you thank you next up Carolyn Clark good evening and thank you very much for giving me some time to talk about Andrea how I met Andrea is she lives in the same neighbor

009neighborhood I do which is District Five but the best thing is she's on Tustin Avenue like I am and what I wanted to share uh being a neighbor of hers is I had an opportunity several months ago to go to a I'd call it a meet and greet at 8:00 in the morning and I got to meet uh other well I they were all young women what can I say I'm the older one in the group but what I learned which was very interesting is that Andrea has the the desire the passion the love the dedication to children and how did I learned that is by going to this meet and greet and I have to tell you that um I started my morning this this morning and I passed Newport Heights horis senson and

010Harbor View which unfortunately I didn't go to newort Heights but I did go to konad delar elementary school which is now a parking lot but what I learned is that if you think of Education as the shape of a pie let's go with apple pie you can cut a pie many ways you can cut it in half you can cut it then in force then an 18th a 16th and I've learned that especially from Andrea that that pie the part that she could feel fill that I noticed at that coffee clutch was her passion to share with young children that yes education is part of the pie but she brings to that pie her devotion and passion to show younger children that there's more that part of her pie is the way she feels how

011children can learn about self-image confidence and to learn to choose what they would like to do in their lifetime and I think that that's very important for a young person to to learn that you do have the choice but it takes selfconfidence it takes self-image which I think for Andrea a part of all her um education and the volunteer that she's done through the schools she can portray that that part of a young oh gosh that's it oh Lord oh okay uh uh okay uh thank you so much I appreciate your comment yes you're so welcome I had so much more to say I know the rules I know the rules I appreciate it you're welcome all right um it is now time to um move on to discussion action which is Board of Education

012uh conducts interviews of candidates to fill Board of Education vacancy trustee area five um regarding our first item of business the board will interview each candidate while one candidate is interviewing with the board the other candidates will be in another room and they will be instructed not to use their cell phones so that they are not in communication with persons in the audience after each interview is completed the candidate will be excused and the next interview will take place in order in order that each candidate be given a similar opportunity I request that persons in the audience please do not communicate with the candidates or their representatives the candidates will be called out Al alphabetically by their last names and we will deeply appreciate their interest in serving in the district so we're going to

013bring in our first candidate um and each candidate will have 15 minutes to answer um questions um will uh can we please bring in um okay um Andrew Lawler is not here uh right now so we are going to go to the second um Phil Mau I stuck on traffic for welcome Phil um to our board meeting and we deeply appreciate your interest in serving um the district I will ask you to introduce yourself and then our board members will ask you three questions you will have 15 minutes uh we will uh stop the clock when each question is asked so it doesn't take up your time um and go ahead please introduce uh um please uh state your name and then we'll start asking three questions no problem my name is Phil ma okay

014great first question will be asked by um trusty Pearson Phil thank you for being here um simply why do you want to serve on the school board great question I think public service is very important and I think schools are the key to everything and education's the key to everything unfortunately of service and this is the best way that I've become to a part my life in which I can serve and better the community and the people around me I apologize is that better okay that is thank you um okay thank you thank you uh next question thank you for being here tonight um um so my question is uh what do you believe um is the strength of Newport Mesa as a as a district as a district the strength of Newport Mesa as

015a district I think for the most part the school district has great uh parental involvement which I found is always a very important thing in the school districts I have friends in other districts I have family members that are teachers and that's what I've seen is is that and in the schools around me um of course I'm in District Five there does tend to be a lot of Parental involvement in those schools and I see that has a very good strength um while I have not reviewed the budget I would assume the very large tax Bas that both cities enjoy way is a definite strength uh to to it yeah and you know with the parental involvement um hopefully you can lean on some of the expertise or maybe bring some of them in on

016areas in which I or other board members or other people coming in as experts come in and maybe try and tap those to assist because there are a lot of working Professionals in various Fields within the district are you referring to the Career Technical um we would like to keep to the to the um questions okay got it did you need a clarification on my answer okay all right third question what would you like to accomplish being on the school board that's great I think I would what I would like to accomplish is bring my knowledge and expertise into the field I teach at the University level for cyber security and computer informational systems um what I have seen at school districts both here and others is sometimes programs are taken in that aren't necessarily

017the best in the long run uh for example for that I a lot of programs around teaching kids programming there's way more in the stem field or the computer field than just programming there's the engineering field network engineering security engineering um and just overall Computer Engineering these are the people that build the systems that build the cloud um programming is going to be rapidly taken over by AI um pretty soon soon we're already seeing it in the industry um so what I would like to do is bring my expertise to that and help guide and create a path for success for the students to go into the technical and science programs um I was originally going into science um and took a hard right towards the end of my college career and didn't end up

018with a biology degree but I do believe Science and Technology are the provide for skill sets for success across very different areas thank you very much all right thank you that's the end of our three questions um we thank you so much for um interviewing with us and your interest in the board and we're going to um Now call on the next candidate so thank you thank you all for your time and uh yes thank you thank you very much we' now like to call um Andrea mroy okay do I go here you can take a seat or be at the podium okay that's okay perfect we give you a choice okay all right welcome Andrea Maloy to our board meeting and we deeply appreciate your interest in serving in uh the district I will

019um ask you to introduce yourself and state your name and then our board members will ask three questions and you'll have 15 minutes um to ask those or to answer those questions and we will stop the clock when each um trustee an or asks a question to not um cut into the your response time so please state your name and then we'll go and ask questions uh Andrea mroy okay can I do an opening statement or um we're just gonna go right into questions okay so okay with that being said thank you for being here of course um the first question is why do you want to serve on the school board oh my gosh there's so many reasons um I think the the biggest reason that I want to serve is because when I

020look back at what I focused on when my daughter was in in school I was so totally focused on her getting through U graduating taking all the classes that she had to take that I didn't have time to sit back and go you know what's best for her what you know what is her desire in life what you know what is her passion and so this gave me an opportunity to um use my knowledge of what I've learned to help guide kids you know at this age like I there's a lot of things that I think are really important that I didn't realize back then one being um every kid is totally different and they don't need to be put in a box they need there needs to to be boxes for everybody and my

021daughter was an art uh drama M you know she loved to act since this big and so um I think that every child needs the opportunity to pursue their passion and do what they want to do and that's one of my main reasons like what's most important you know for the student um I would say that and I'm passionate about school I'm pass about kids I'm passionate about our community I want to make sure that you know everybody is doing the right thing for the right reasons um I volunteered a lot in school when they were in school and I think and that was super fun for me I really really enjoyed you know being with the children and watching them from all different types of kids so and I think I have the knowledge

022from running businesses you know what it takes how to run you know budgets how to focus on when there's a problem how you solve it even if it might not be very easy or if people um don't like it even your closest friends don't like it but you have to do what's right um so I've learned a lot of things i' when I ran a business I mean there's a lot of challenges and there's a lot of um up and downs and you got to be smart enough to figure out how to handle it and then the other thing is I work with um San Diego State and we had a huge challenge come up for us and um it's something totally unfavorable for a lot of people and we needed to come up with

023a solution and um I think with just my background of understanding how to deal with challenges and then how to approach them and do the research and everything that really goes into it um to solve the problem and uh we came up well it's not totally finalized but um you got to get everyone's input and you got to really really look at things and go what is the best for the kids what's the best for the school and I know I can do it and I love it I'm super passionate about it so that's that's why I want to do this I have the time I the energy um I love going to all types of plays and sports and whatever I love it so and that's how I grew up and I grew up

024in public schools so I love that that's another reason so I just have a true passion for it all right thank you question two trusty cran thank you for being here uh what do you believe the strength of Newport Mesa to be oh the community every the people um just well okay so the strength in general or of you guys or you you could hit on all of them or whatever you want to hit on okay let me let me hit you guys first so I've sat through the last three months of meetings here and watched you um I then went back went through all of the meetings on YouTube because I wanted to like do my research and and like figure this out because I'm like wanted to start with going so um the

025one thing that I really liked about you guys is that you really work well together even if you don't have the same opinions you you you work as a team and so I really like that about this board um I liked one thing I like Ashley that you said well two times ago um like you thought about this you thought about this problem or you you had a thought and it was it was about the appointee um position and you said we had to like do all this paperwork and all these things and and and do a full campaign and this this appointing just has to fill out you know are you over 18 whatever and it really made me think like she's so totally right so I like that you were expressed that and

026so that's really what motivated me to really do all my research because it's it it's right I I don't get to run a campaign I don't get to tell my story to anybody and but you made me realize that so that was that was really cool and I and you guys kind of talked it all out so I really like the way you guys work together so um and and then I met uh superintendent Smith and he's amazing so that was awesome so I liked that experience um so about the board that's what I like about the school district um all of our kids went there I love the schools I love the teachers um that I knew I also um I grew up in Huntington Beach and um public a school like I said

027and we had a very diverse uh uh student body and the schools that uh our children went to like Newport Heights andon it's very diverse and I love that because that's the real world like that's who you're you know what you are doing for the rest of your life you have to work with people that maybe aren't like you so I like that it's diverse um I love our neighborhoods I like the whole Newport Mas that not just Newport I like everything about it um I grew up here I get it people are really good they have good Hearts here they care about their children they're passionate about their schools they passionate about their neighborhoods they work together well um there's just I mean I could go on about all the things I I I

028like about here um is there anything else you want me to hit on or that I that I like I've been quieted oh really okay sorry us to ask followup questions we're just gonna stick to the script okay okay okay yes um and yeah question number three what would you like to accomplish being on the school board um okay so career two things I mean not two I'll say two things first and then there's a million but the I love that the pathway classes or the the career trade education because um some people are really good at some things and lots of kids don't like school but this gives them an opportunity to find something they like um so I want to expand on that and um give kids opportunities to do things that are

029different that might Inspire them I want to um not instead of having a problem I want to prevent problems meaning like let's focus like not you know for example kids that don't like school well what would make them like it you know and then and then how can we help them um I would like so I'd like to expand on on things I want kids to write in cursive I want them to know how to type on a typewriter or you know on a computer um I want them to have their grammar to be correct so they have Real World skills in the future um what else uh what else what I I just really want to work on oh oh this is another big month for me sorry personal finances when you get out

030of school you don't know how to balance a checkbook or do those things but those are things are so important to to learn in school you need to know that you can't write a check for $25 when you only have $20 in the bank you got to learn that stuff and sometimes we just don't learn that at school the other thing is taxes why do we pay taxes what is it for um how do you fill out a tax form I mean just real life situations the fundamentals of life and I would like to focus on making sure I know you guys are doing it already but expanding on it and just really hitting like things that are going to make these kids succeed if they go to college or not you know just get

031through this is this you have to get a high level education and it doesn't have to be taking 15 levels of math it can be taking a mechanics class or sewing class or whatever um and then and then expanding on the arts program I think it's huge U my daughter grew up her whole career has been in the Arts and I think that makes kids learn how to express themselves makes them socially you know not awkward they get build confidence kids have to have confidence and I think that expanding on all of those other type of things that you don't always focus on is super super important so that was what what I would like to not change but develop more and more thank you all right well thank you so much um Andrea um

032we appreciate you being here and um you know applying for this position and now we're going to go off to another candidate so thank you so much that was easy I mean not easy but thank you all right now we're gonna bring in um Valerie shed uh point of clarification yes have we um is are we going back to Mr Lauder some point um we will if he shows up oh not here yet yes you can either stand or sit whichever you feel more comfortable doing I'll sit okay great a little bit yeah a little more comfortable and do I use the mic too yeah yes please use the mic thank you for all the people watching at home all right well welcome Valerie um to our board meeting and we deeply appreciate your interest

033in serving the district I will ask you to introduce yourself just state your name and then our board members will ask you three questions and you have 15 minutes to answer those questions and we will um stop the clock when someone's asking those questions to not cut into your answer time so please state your name and then we'll go off into the questions my name is Valerie shed great and trusty Pearson with the first question thank you for being here Valerie thank you um the question number one is why do you want to serve on the school board I've been in public I was in public education for 34 years so I love education um I also was a parent in Newport Mesa so my students I moved here from Michigan when my children were

034going into sixth grade and nth grade and it's an amazing School District so um so happy that I landed here and I just retired in July or June 30th so um I when my kids were in school I looked into the idea of serving on the board um I love to give back to my community I love to serve I love to be involved with kids and help kids and at that time when I looked into it um that spring I was looking into for the 2008 year I got my first principal position so I knew I couldn't be a good mom a good principal and a good board member so no definitely no time for that so uh I continued on with um doing both those other things and now that I saw the

035opportunity I thought I could bring a lot of experience potentially knowledge that I have um from being on the other side of a school district I'm still passionate about helping my community I'm passionate about serving students and so this was an opportunity for me to be able to serve students in a different way thank you great thank you trusty crane yes thank you for your time um so what do you believe the strength of Newport Mesa to be um I'm a local whatever level how do you interpret this question so when I think of Newport Mesa I always think of Excellence um I look at what I watch the school watch the experience that my children had and I looked at the experience of the children they went to school with the neighbors that because

036I have lived in the area now for 18 years uh the education that my kids got was topnotch um and I moved from Michigan from a college town and we thought we were the best school district but I would have to say and um I also taught in that school district that the education my children got here was Bar None compared to what I experienced back in Michigan and so that is something that has always that I'm proud of to be in this community um being on the other side working for a school district in Orange County I've looked at data for the last 15 years so I look at um one of the things I look I I keep aware of things that are going on in my community and um I look at

037your looked at your vision the board's priorities and that is to improve student achievement and to continue to I know that the scores go up have gone up and they do continue to go up most years but your commitment is to improve academic Excellence even more and um that is something that I feel I could work together with you to help move in that direction um I think that in addition to the academic Excellence that Newport Mesa offers a lot of other opportunities for students so they have strong Athletics they have strong Community um you know clubs at the schools at the different levels um you know strong Arts programs I was impressed with you know the amount of different activities or different opportunities of Art and Woodworking and things like that music I think

038those things are all super important and not every school district has that so I think that this school district is fortunate to have it and I know it takes a lot to be able to offer all those things and I would love to work with each of you to continue to just keep the district going in the right direction thank you thank you trusty Anderson thank you um the next question is what would you like to accomplish being on the school board I would like to I'm very collaborative so I would love to work get to know each of you were I so fortunate to be able to serve with you hear from you what your priorities are and what the constituents in your trustee area what's important to them um I think that it's

039critical to make sure that as a school district um that we are we we understand what is important to our parents that we always are thinking about what is best for our students so I would want to um make sure that every decision that we make is serving our students every student and whatever that is um serving all students looks different because every student might have a different need but um I think together a school district this strong um I think a school a a board and a Administration can meet those needs so I would hope to continue to work with all of you to meet the priorities that you have established increasing student achievement improving um some of the services for the whole child um one of the other ones is the communication with

040your community and constituents I think that's critical and then I also know that um facilities and maintenance is a huge thing and and one of the things that um in my previous District I oversaw special education so I always had to like how do we manage everything with not a lot of money and so I think that's also a unique thing that I could bring and I would hope to try and help you accomplish all the goals that that you have already started to establish thank you all right well thank you that's actually all of our questions are going to ask so we thank you for your um interest in this and we thank you for being here here and um we're going to bring in another candidate and then um and then we'll see

041you back out here after thank you for the opportunity okay thank you so much um if you can bring out uh Kristen Walsh right welcome welcome um it's Kiren right yes okay Kirsten Walsh to our board meeting and we deeply appreciate your interest in serving the district I will ask you to introduce yourself state your name and uh then the board members will ask three questions you'll have 15 minutes to answer those questions and we will stop the clock when um a trustee is answering the questions to not cut into your 15 minutes so state your name and then we will ask start asking questions okay Kirsten Walsh trusty Pearson Kirsten thank you for being here um question number one is why do you want to serve on the school board I would like to

042serve on the school board because I think everything that I've done over the last 13 years has led me to this point very organically um I have my I have two children I have a senior and a sophomore they have gone through Newport L they've gone through ensen and they're now at Harbor and my in a short quick pinch my son is a type 1 diabetic and so I stopped working when he was diagnosed at five and I'm a pediatric occupational therapist and so I immediately started getting involved at Newport l um so I have been PTA president at ensen I have the last two years I've been PTA president at Harbor I'm on the Harbor Council I'm on the water polar boosters I've done so much for the community and this just feels like

043a very natural organic next step in uh supporting the district and the community great thank you next thank you and thank you for your time for being here um question number two is what do you believe the strength of Newport Mesa to be the students the community the staff the teachers I've been fortunate to be really involved in getting to know the staff primarily because of my son Milo um I've had to be an advocate for him when he was smaller and develop those relationships with the teachers um with the staff and the schools um and I feel that the the the district does a very good job of hiring the Educators and the staff that's put in those schools um and then the students I have a 15-year-old son that went through enson and

044I dealt with those problems that happen in a middle school and the way that these situations were handled um and how I was able to separate myself from being a PTA president and then being a mom in certain situations and having the respect to do that from the community and the staff and the teachers was awesome um I didn't grow up here I didn't go to school here I've only been in Califor California for 23 years I grew up overseas and my my whole childhood is very unique um to why I'm kind of in this position but that's a whole kind of other story um but this is the first time that I've seen my children be in kindergarten and then going through an entire till their seniors and graduating and it's super unique to

045me and the community that I've surrounded myself with with sports and education and everything I I I can't say enough about Newport Mesa I just think it's a wonderful District I'm I'm happy there okay great thank you trusty Anderson what would you like to accomplish being on the school board I want to be part of a team that is making decisions for the safety of the children and the students and the staff and the community um I personally do not have an agenda I want to be part of a team that wants to improve the infrastructure of the school um whatever situation and issues pop up um I want to be able to support what is needed from the board and I truly think that if I'm that if I'm the person that can make

046that happen then this is where I want to be I like I said I don't have an agenda I make decisions not politically based I'm I approach things very Broad and open-minded I'd love to get everybody's input um from all different sides and aspects of where people are coming from and what they think and then collectively making a decisions that's best for the community and best for the students it's pretty much simple for me with that like kids are first they're the priority um and I want to be part of a team where I can be an asset to that to the team thank you okay great thank you um that's the end of our questions so we appreciate your time um we're going to have you go back to the room and then we'll

047bringing back out for deliberation but thank you so much for replying we really appreciate everything that you've done thank you now we're going to um bring everyone out um we don't believe that um Andrew Lawler is going to show up and so at this point we're going to move on and deliberate with the four candidates that we have here try Wan can we can we take a moment to like reflect on our notes before we start deliberating or is that um in your in your mind like no um we're going to yeah if you want to read your notes but not um we can't speak no no we can't but can we have like a five minute sort of like downtime to look over our notes um yeah you can do that right now uh

048and um once everyone gets in here we'll we'll start deliberating but but start thinking thank you on all right thank you guys thank you for um being here um we really appreciate you guys being put on the hot seat and really having interest in the in the district and just everything that you um spoke about we were really appreci appreciative um having completed the interview process and now that all candidates are present I'm going to call for the nomination for the provisional appointment to be named to the Board of Education now a sample motion would be I move that blank be provisionally appointed appointed by the Board of Education to be named the trustee to the Board of Education trustee area 5 effective January 27th 2025 and that notification of the board's appointment be published

049in accordance with Education Code 5092 that's that's an example um following the motion by name of the appro of the potee and a second to the motion then discussion by the Board of Education will occur following discussion a roll call vote will be taken on the motion which will require four affirmative votes to pass all right I'm gonna open it up do I have a motion trusty Anderson um yes I would like to make the motion to provisionally appoint Kirsten Walsh for the remainder of the term for trustee area 5 effective January 27th 2025 um do I have a second I second okay um moved by trusty Anderson seconded by trusty Murphy uh discussion I have my trusty Pearson I move to substitute the motion on the floor with a motion to appoint Andrea maoy

050to the school board so uh moved do I have a second um I'll second that uh so it's moved by uh truste um Pearson seconded by truste wgan um since that is a substitute motion do we um have a discussion on the substitute motion first before the uh first motion yes okay so since there is a substitute motion made um we have a discussion on the substitute motion first and vote on The Substitute motion first before the uh first motion that was made so um discussion on um on Andrea marroy do you want to go I'm G start yeah you can um well first I want to thank all the applicants I mean everyone here is genuinely here for the kids and our community which I I thank um Michelle Barto ran for this position

051in 2022 um she had 65% of the votes um a 30o lead um my mission is to find somebody who aligns with her values and most importantly the constituent's values um and I believe that Andrea um is that person thank you uh any other discussions um trust crane okay so I I I had the pleasure of meeting with um three of the well not meeting meet having conversation with three of the candidates and I I was very impressed and we're we are in a unique position and typically it's enviable however when it's this difficult of a decision because of the qualification and the passion of our candidates it's it's a tough one and we don't we're sitting here this is not an easy job it may seem like it's you know we're up here comfortable

052in our chairs and everything but you know we we have a very very heavy lift and um for me yes because I have heard how um um we're here to um act in the you know in in the I guess in in the spirit of trusty Barto and trusty Barto was very much uh similar to uh two of the candidates that have presented themselves tonight and um I my thing is that I I do I do I do favor a trustee just as trustey BTO that has the students in the schools because they have the pulse of the community and uh also trusty Barto was a a parent leader at the PTA and the PTA and all that so it's so hard and and I understand the passion because I sat down with with Andie

053you're you're amazing um I just can't I I just I'm looking at a candidate that can be a compromise because we're also here as a governing team that has to move forward and I I want to hear a little more from um the other trustees about this truste Anderson thank you um yes I appreciate all of you for applying while it is easier than doing a full campaign as stated um I I think one of the takeaways that I've learned um during my time of um being involved with their District being a student in our district at some point um it's really important to have um people who represent everyone in the community um and so for me there's a reason that I it's a nonpartisan position and I continue to run as an independent

054there are a lot of um considerations that do come into play but I think um for me it's really important that people are able to weigh what is best for each student in circumstances that come up um and so for me it's really important to have um established I worked in each of our schools that I was representing before I was on the board um and so and at schools that were not in my zone I think it's really important to have um a really deep understanding in a role um previously where you've you've seen different parts of the district um so for me it's important that we have people who have outside perspectives who have um diverse um views that they've learned from being out in the world um or not just in Newport

055Mesa so for me it's really important that this we do we do um work very well together and I think a lot of that is because um we each try and listen to each other's points of view it's has not always been that way and I think it's really important to continue with that mindset that each thing that comes to us someone doesn't necessarily know ahead of time how someone's going to vote for it it's based on the information that comes to us um and it's not based on um National political things that are not necessarily relevant to us so that is um for me what's most important thank you any other questions comments okay I I have a comment um I would one of one of the comments I would make is that you

056know we have this area that is um you know we're filling an appointment by someone that won an election favorably so it is important to look at the constituents to see um who aligns with that voter base um the most um one thing I would have to say I like about Mrs um mroy is that you know she's a she's a product of public education um she supports um you know Career Technical education she she supports um you know the the uh arts in our school which I think on the board if I look at us you know um not not not too much of us are very artsy but you know we appreciate it but it would be great to have someone on the board that would um you know Be A Champion for

057that for that um and and I I do believe that you know being in the harbor Community is is very important specifically in in the past you know 10 years um which I I I think has been um instrumental um um but for me you know I definitely want someone that is also um going to carry the torch um past two years um and would love to see continuity on the board because I think we work well together because of that continuity um and so with that any other comments or questions before we go to a roll call vote um [Music] I'm I'm going to clarify oh truste go ahead go ahead I was going to clarify that this vote is for the substitute motion um to appoint um Andrea maai I I I did

058want to make a comment um what why what I needed to hear is is uh the fact that um a candidate understands the uh tenant of governance which is um you're one of the team in and you are part of a team um that you collaborate and so I did I did hear that but I I I heard it a little more clearly from I Believe Miss Walsh as far as understanding the bigger picture of being a um a governing team that that works well and collabor collaboratively together and also comes to decisions based on um input from everyone and I appreciate that being a direct um directly communicated uh trusty Pearson I respectfully disagree I feel like um Andrea came to the last three board meetings purposely to kind of see what where all

059of us stood um went back and studied I mean I been looked at us on television um or in the tape so I don't know I feel like she specifically um did tell us that she was work as a team good okay trusty Murphy um well I guess I would say that I did hear the collaborative tone in spirit in uh Mrs Walsh's answers I would also say that she did reach out to me she was the only one who reached out to me to talk to me about the position and to get a better understanding of what it is to be trustee to be in a nonpartisan position that just represents the best interests of all of the students I found her answers to be above and beyond what I would want in a

060trusty colleague so um I appreciate certainly Miss Mary's you know experience and her opinions but for me um Miss Walsh having kids in the district is very very important um our children as we all know are living through very different times um what happened during unfortunately during you know covid as we all know changed how our students are learning how they're growing how they're developing and it is extremely important to me that the trustee have children in the district that are currently going to our schools um I think they're just in the best position to really understand what our students need moving forward um there's a lot of decisions that need to be made about our schools and our students future uh to me that will require in need somebody who is on the ground

061boots on the ground their kids are in the classrooms they're they're going to to events because their kids are there they're talking to their kids friends they're dealing with you know all of the issues and the emotions that are coming up with um I think we're dealing with sophomores and seniors here in high school uh as well as middle school and Elementary School parents come to me all the time with uh problems and issues that they're dealing with at the schools that even I haven't experienced yet with my kids so having kids in the district currently going to school right now is one of my number one issues and one of my number one priorities I just think it is most important so that's my feeling on that okay uh NE any other comments I

062see my no more lights light up um so just wanted to reiterate that this vote would be um on the substitute motion for um Andrea mroy and if we go to that vote I just wanted to make sure that you know that as we go to a vote okay roll call vote trusty wean yes trusty soyu no trusty Murphy no trusty Pearson yes trusty Anderson no trusty CR no all right um seeing that that uh motion did not pass um do I have a second motion it's sorry do I have air do I have another motion excuse me another motion oh I do it's already moved yes that's right thank you thank you for reminding me that it's the original motion okay substitute failed so now we have uh the first motion at hand which

063was um moved by trusty Anderson seconded by um trusty Murphy and this is on uh Kirsten Walsh do I have um discussion seeing none any going once going twice no more discussion okay um let's go for roll call vote trusty ween no trusty yes trusty Murphy yes trusty Pearson no trusty Anderson yes trusty CR yes all right um I wish to thank you uh the motion passes uh 42 and congratulations uh Kirsten Walsh future TWY T Walsh um I wish to thank all of you for your candidacy and for your support of the Newport Mesa Unified School District we are now going to take um about five minute recess and then we will proceed to the swearing in of Kristen Walsh to the Board of Education congratulations and thank you everyone for being here and

064for applying we will begin shortly to administer the oath of office okay um Kristen come with me to the uh [Laughter] Podium we um look forward to having you on our board thank you for being a part of this process and if you would like to oh you um yes you can face the board does a matter or I mean the cameras are all on so yeah all right well if you will raise your right hand and repeat after me I kren Walsh do solemnly swear I that I will support and defend that I will support and defend the con Constitution of the United States the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California and the constitution of the State of California against all enemies against all enemies foreign and

065domestic foreign and domestic that I will bear true faith that I will bear true faith and Allegiance and allegiance to the Constitution of the of the United States of the con to the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of California and the constitution of the State of California that I take this obligation freely that I take this obligation freely without any mental reservation without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion for purpose of evasion and that I will well and Faithfully discharge and that I will well and Faithfully discharge the duties upon the duties upon which I'm about to enter which I'm about to enter congratulations thank you welcome to the team you want picture pict that's [Music] right it's make the tallest this is so cool I'm sorry it's

066just just instead of my phone was stolen so I had to get aat [Music] and I think Kristen you sit over here oh yeah yeah you can come up you don't have to watch us yeah feel what it feels like to sit there um I want to thank everyone here that um that attended and everyone that submitted their name for this application process I know it's it's kind of daunting um and I also want to thank the board for um going through this process with me and um you know it's it's been interesting getting to appoint your own your new colleague and I think we did it with um transparency and professionalism so welcome Kristen ohy and trusty Walsh thank you sorry um I just wanted to say thank you you did a great job

067oh thank you and it was and it was a pleasure working with you and we really appreciated it all the professionalism you put into this endeavor so it's greatly appreciated okay well well thank you I appreciate that um and now with that let's adjourn the meeting at 7:09

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.