CorpusRecord 108936

PGUSD Special Board Meeting January 27, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / PGUSD Media Channel
Date
2025-01-28
Location
Monterey County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
19,791 words · about 110 min
Collected
2026-06-20

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001at 6:02 PM for this special meeting um of the pgusd Board of Education and we are starting right now I guess with the First with our call to order so we do our normal yes oh sorry land acknowledgement first and we this perfect timing thank you um thank you call to order was this so I will start with our land acknowledgement good evening as we begin this meeting it's important to pay respect to and acknowledge that we are on the tri traditional land of the aloney kosan and Elin people in additionally pay respect to Elders both past and present and now we will move on to the roll call vote thank you trusty McNary abely president Dr Hazen here clerk McNary here trusty otmar here trusty shamas here and trusty wax here so our next

002item is the adoption of the agenda and it's a very short agenda tonight which is good because we're here for our board governance training and self- evaluation see how we're doing and hopefully grow together as a board further um our next item then is to get public comment on our agenda seeing no one in the room and no one online as well makes that easy any board discussion about the adoption of the agenda and would this be a good time for comments as well that we wanted to get board comments to do regarding agenda or should we do that once we break for the item a okay just as a point of order and I'm just noticing now that we don't have um board member comments on our agenda so I can say personally I

003wasn't prepared for that this evening any other thoughts on the agenda do we want to open up an opportunity for that do we want to use it as part of our board discussion here I'm okay to open it up and anyone that does do have a comment doesn't need to make one if everybody's on board with that I um would like to move that we amend the agenda to include um board comment and I have a second I'll second then so the motion was made by trusty atmar and seconded by trusty shamas to add a board comment at the I assume immediately following the Pledge of Allegiance we'll say right before we get into information discussion item a so can I get a all in favor please say I I any opposed so that passes

0045- Z with that Amendment so now we're on to the Pledge of Allegiance um Eric could I get you to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance if you wouldn't mind from your old superintendent days ready begin to flag the United States of America and to the repblic for stands one nation indivisible okay with that we'll move on now to our amended item just quick opportunity for board comment um if there was anyone on board and I don't know um trusty trusty superintendent Adamson if you wanted to add something as well um to State tonight or happy to start off with you since that's part of our normal I appreciate that thank you and yes I do have just a few you know words and comments and I've actually prepared something to just read out

005loud this evening I in I just response to you know some of the recent reaching outs that have occurred and I feel the timing is appropriate and I'd like to just use this form to share it a version of this is something I intend to share with our community in the coming days as well and I feel it's particularly important given our community engagement event that's coming up on Wednesday evening so I'm going to go ahead and just share over the past few days families and staff have shared their concerns with me and members of our staff about growing uncertainty in our community regarding potential changes to our country's immigration policies as your superintendent I want to assure all of our families that our schools remain safe spaces of learning where every student belongs and

006has the opportunity to thrive our commitment to protecting and supporting all students regardless of their background or circumstances stands firm and unchanging tonight I reaffirm our District's unwavering commitment to our core values of safety belonging and prosperity for all students in Pacific Grove unified we take pride in our culture of we a principle that goes Far Beyond Simple coexistence it means wrapping our arms around each other supporting one another and refusing to tolerate incident of racism discrimination bullying or exclusion of any kind these are the exact same words that I used in my opening video to our entire community at the beginning of the year and it's the exact same words that I refer to now tonight we fully intend to continue to uphold these values and maintain our schools as welcoming spaces where all

007students can learn and grow together this is not just our legal obligation but it's also a moral imperative and the foundation of our District's Mission with this in mind I ask everyone to join me tonight and in the coming weeks in our recommitment to our pledge a pledge that is posted and visible in every space and place across the district and one that boldly proclaims all students who come through our doors will do so with the right and the full expectation of experiencing these three core values of belonging safety and prosperity whatever challenges lie ahead I know that we stand please know that we stand prepared to meet them with resiliency and unity and remain committed to preserving the trust that our families and students place in us every day allowing every student to feel

008safe valued and supported in their Pursuit Of Education and opportunity thank you very much for that and I'll open up to the board I will start with a very short message that I'd like to read as um on behalf of the pgusd school board but as myself I also want to reaffirm the message that was just read by superintendent Adamson for unwavering commitment to creating safe inclusive and welcoming environment for every student regardless of their background Identity or circumstances in these uncertain times it is essential that our schools stand as places of safety UND um understanding and respect for all including our immigrant lgbtq plus and other students who may for just reason feel vulnerable every child deserves the opportunity to learn without bullying fear discrimination or Prejudice and I believe that my colleagues the

009board will continue to prioritize these policies and practices meeting up with a culture of we that protect and uplift our students ensuring their voices are heard and they feel welcomed how we support them will ultimately prove to be foundational as they are our future leaders so together as a district we will work to continue to build the strong compassionate and Safe Community where every student feels they truly belong so I will open up to other folks on the board if there's additional comments and again no worries if not the since it was not on the original agenda but go to you next uh vice president McNary thank you for adding that and thank you Dr Adamson for your statement and for your words president Hazen um yeah I it's timely I mean we can't avoid

010what's going on in the rest of the world and not speak to it and especially when we sit in these roles so thank you for that reminder and thank you for your commitment um to all of our students and I stand with both of you in the district and um it's going to be tough and there's going to be a lot of difficult things but we I think we're going to get through this together so thanks CH schi yeah thank you for that um I just my one comment is that we are required by law to to school without regard to immigration status where we can't even know what their status is so that's our charge and that's what I think we have to um always be aware of and um and and to me

011it it's all about the parents of those that are impacted that um I hope that we can somehow give some kind of reassurance to justy um I appreciate everyone's words and and uh with my own self support um everyone uh just trying to think of the uncertainty of what's happening in the country or might happen the country is kind of daunting for me personally but um besides our charge with educating every student I besides impacting the families and the actual students uh a scenario where um people get taken out of the school with other kids around would be um horribly traumatic if your friend got taken away or anything so I think it's we have to keep all the students and what we want to be as uh uh a society in Focus wherever we

012fall on how we approach some issues um but uh yeah I hope we'll get through this uh together and with strength thank you justar please um I don't think I could add much more than what's already been said I'm grateful um for everyone that has spoken I'm GR gr f for everything you've said I stand behind that I know there's no such thing as a th% so I'll say 100% um but um I feel as deeply as you all do um and yeah I don't think there's much more to say than that I I think that's a perfect example from each of us that we're about to enter into board governance training and self- evaluation how we come together on an issue whether we agree fully or disagree and Rec the importance of what's placed

013at our feet on a daily if not twice a month basis so with that I think I'll go ahead and move us on to item a board governance training and self evaluation I think I'll hand it back over to you Dr Adamson right to lead us on this well yes thank you for that and I I do want to point out this is our first coming together as a new board for our first governance training uh we did several of these last year uh but how exciting that you know we get to just I think you know talking about commitment so much already this evening right our commitment to one another as a governance team on how we are going to work together how we are going to uh make decisions come to consensus uh

014and in particular uh come to consensus when right you know sometimes we may not all necessarily agree about a particular topic right and so that's board governance uh and so it's my pleasure to have with us this evening our two trainers who've been with us uh for this journey uh definitely for the past year here uh who I'm so grateful to for sharing their expertise and uh insight and so I'm really going to go ahead and hand it over to Dr Eric Andrews and H attorney Lou Lozano so thank you both for being here this evening thank you guys thank you so very much we're so glad to be back with you uh just a brief introduction for those of you who have not know my background I'm Eric Andrew I work with leadership Associates

015been there for now eight years um I retired from the Campbell Union School District where I was superintend attended for seven and a half years and that's kind of my background Lou do you want to add anything about who you are and why say that it's a honor for me to be here and an honor for me to work with Eric who I've known since he went to hble and work with him there was outstanding superintendent and and a great man so love love coming here and working with you so it's a pleasure and an honor that thank you it really is and it's one of the things I was talking to clerk about that saying that I don't like board governance workshops I'll just put it out there I don't and so I usually

016don't and I only choose places where I want to be and this is always a place where I want to be you guys are a great great great board and um I'm so glad to meet you and to work with you as well I know you've been a part of this so what we're going to be doing tonight are several things one the biggest thing we're going to be doing is going over the uh handbook six of you have been been participants in revising the handbook and it's something that we recommend that you do on a regular basis because conditions change board members change and one of the things that we do know is that anytime you have a new board member you have a new team and I so happy that you talked about

017the importance of team and so we're going to go through the handbook but before we do that we're going to do a few other things such as we want you to uh Express why you ran for the boards we're going to do a why exercise and um what's going to be important about that is for us to hear Collective individually and collectively there's a there's a phrase I like to use and it's called how do can you become independent interdependent and uh and dependent on one another and that's what a good team is it doesn't take away from you having your own individualistic aspects and and things but how are you going to be interdependent in dependent on your colleagues to do what's great for kids and one of the things I want to really

018emphasize that all of you talked about kids after the sentences was was read and that's very very important to hear that and we're really pleased with that once they're going to be it we're not going to be able to get to and we're GNA we'll have a parking lot and what that basically means is we'll put that on the side doesn't mean that they're forgotten it just means that at another time we'll be able to get to them so that uh they aren't lost in the the richness of the conversations along the way we're going to also talk about the brown act and we'll go through some exercises is with you to give you some scenarios and uh in some cases there are no right answers in some cases they're definitive right answers where the

019law says no this is a violation but you'll get a chance to practice going through various scenario some that some of you may have experienced not only as a school board member but in your other businesses as well to say that wow when we did this was this a violation or not so we'll talk a little bit about that we'll have an exercise from the book trust and Inspire by Stephen Cy Jr great book and uh your superintendent is going to take you through that exercise and as well as Lou is going to talk a little bit about board member liabilities which are important for you to know and understanding how well what are the areas that you're covered uh as a member of a of a school board what areas are you kind of

020out there on your own along the way anything else you can see we have a pretty ambitious agenda tonight at the same time we recognize that you've all been working today and and we don't want to if we start getting blur eyed any of us we might want to say let's let's continue this in a discussion we're thinking of going until 9ine um at a reasonable Pace but if anytime somebody says I'm really my brain is full and I need to go please feel free to say that so we respect your personal needs yeah okay I think you can handle a little bit more yeah you can handle a little bit more so with that let's jump into the why why let's go around the table and and find out what drove you to be

021a board member why are you on this school board and we can either start some or somebody wants to just start it the discussion I'll jump in if it's okay just to help kick start a bit is that you know for me it was I've spent a good bit of my life complaining as probably a lot of us have and I realized that if I was going to be in that role of complaining and wanting things to change um you know as a result of various elections in the past maybe say about eight years ago um I realized I needed to put myself out there and do something and so that's what really inspired me to run is I had worked with the PTA I'd worked with site councils and had some changes I thought

022would be important um for our district and so I basically said it's now is a good time to put my money where my mouth is and you know R for the school board to try to help Implement some of those changes rather than just complaining thank you for that we can go around the table that's fine I'm not calling on folks this one that's all good thank you um I think we have a great great district and I think my hope and love for the district and for all kids um in general is probably why I ran um and wanting all kids to have a place where they feel seen and safe and can access their education and see success in whatever way shape or form that comes um yeah I do love being on

023the school board I don't know that may be like a odd thing to say all things considered but I love this work and I think it's important and um yeah um well I was thinking about why did I first run um and that was an interesting time um my kids graduated well most of my kids graduated in 95 but I ran and got elected in 97 um and at the time it was this crazy recall movement um everybody was all upset the superintendent that was here was causing problems in in some people's eyes and so um I don't know why I mean I decided to to run I I I enjoy the idea of it and um my kids got a good education and um so and I'm a teacher so I I felt like

024okay I I know this business um and you know so when I got elected along with two other people and and I didn't know anybody you know even though I born and raised in PG but I've been away and so I didn't know who um who the players were um and I S soon found out but but it was it was such a uh amazing when you look back on it time of learning on how to be a team when you have people that are really not okay with each other and um the the recall did not happen because the two people that were going to be recalled decided to just not run again so that kind of evened that out but still you had all this energy and yet you still had that superintendent

025that half of the board didn't like and I was like in the middle I didn't have any any way I I wasn't for or against I I like the superintendent actually but what did I know so I mean he was a good superintendent I thought I he's smart and but he was ruffling feathers because they wanted to close the school so that was you know how that goes so anyway but I I totally enjoyed my time on the board and I love being on the school board and um so we went through some really tough times um in terms of coming together as a board um but we did it and I was always so proud of that like wow like you know if I can be a board member with this person who I

026really mostly don't agree with on so many things and yet we could come together and respect each other and work together and so anyway I stayed for 12 years um and I might have stayed longer except I had to move out of the district for at the end of my time so that's how come I went off the board and then after I retired I just started going back to board meetings to see oh what's going on let me check the check in on everybody and um then it just so happened that Carolyn said hey I'm not running again and do you want to run because now we're in a little District you know trustee area and I said yeah I do here I am thank you for that who's watching no um I excuse

027me um I think I've said this before so pardon repeating myself but you know it's new to you um my parents always uh stressed the importance of good Public Schools that's why we chose to settle down in Arizona where we did and uh so we are all raised in public schools and then we partially chose PG because of the public schools and I truly feel like it's a good public education system is the foundation for a great city um and then a good publication public education system Nationwide is uh you know pivotal in so many areas um I feel like you know there could be so many there could be so many smarter ways to do things in the country at a job whatever if we had a better education system so I I feel

028really committed to uh bringing everyone up um and much like uh trusty shamas um I live in an area that is part of the new District uh and I had some free time and I have two kids and they're going to be in the district for a long time so um both selfishly and um selfishly for my community I want to do uh the best that I can and making sure that everyone has a great education and that um we do right um so initially I ran for school board well I was on site counsil I have two kids in the district and um both my kids have allergies anaphylactic allergies which is why I became so involved upfront um I'm an involved person anyway but um that definitely spurred me to get involved on

029site counsil and just be involved in all the events that were happening at the school and um Carolyn Swanson also said hey um so I ran for the school board because I really did feel like um I could make a not necessarily a difference but I could be um I could be someone that could give my opinion and that's a steady opinion I'm honest I'm upfront I know that I'm highly empathetic and nurturing and caring and I feel like who better to be on a Schoolboard than somebody that actually truly cares and loves and wants what's best for kids now that I'm on the school board um my reason for being here has changed a thousand times you know you sign up for something and you think you're here for one purpose and it turns

030out that that purpose is not really why you're here at all and do I know why my what my purpose is now no I just know that I'm going to lead with my heart and I'm going to do what feels right I'm going to listen to the community I'm going to put kids first and that's all that really matters is kids and so um this is a hard job I can't say that I love it uh because it's difficult and it's difficult to balance motherhood and a full-time job and this full-time job um especially when you I care so deeply about it um but it's definitely it's definitely worth the work and you know sometimes you get a peek behind the curtain and you go oh you know it's not what you expected um and

031that isn't to say that it's bad behind the curtain it's just so intricate and detailed and um I think sometimes people look at the school board and think oh they just show up for meetings and how simple but it sits with you and it the you know I mean it just becomes a part of who you are so um that was long- winded but my my reasons will probably continue to change and evolve as I sit here for the rest of my term so that's that I think there's a common theme among all of you and that is you've all ran for the board to make a great School District better that you all want to see it improve you all want to see it succeed and that's all the right reasons to be here

032you know you're not here because you you are looking to make sure your first child gets Mrs X or Mr y as their teacher you're here to make sure that every kid gets what they deserve and that's the best possible education that you can give them and I can tell you from experience that our firm represents half of the 1100 school districts in California in some capacity and you are remarkable you are among the top districts out there really are and you have a you have a gem here that I am impressed that you all want to polish even more and there is no Perfection but we can make it better and we by your stewardship so and that's so important I love the idea of caring because you all really do care about this

033District as well as the community another thing that I did hear about and uh being able to to uh weave the importance of how a school district is a part of the community and what your role is you mentioned Laura uh the role changes all the time you're not kidding because the topics change all the time and there's this thing that I have this says there's always a story there's a story behind The Story and there's a story behind the story behind the story that's the only people know that story are the is the governance team so your public may think they have a story out there and and you realize no there's so many layers behind yes that that's out there and that you're aware of which is why it's important to have a

034handbook and when as as you're talking and understanding what your legal rights are and how do you continue to function as a governance team if that's extremely important and when you get to those points and I never want any of you to give up on the reasons why you ran because they are absolutely the right reasons to be here absolutely right reasons to be here L correct you are an outstanding War you really are and I know your where your heart is and that because of your heart's work you're gonna be okay it's just important to have a foundation of how do we interact as a board when things are going aren't going as well but also how do we celebrate when things are going well because there a lot more opportunities and a lot

035more things that are going well in a district like this that aren't going well so I don't want you to dwell so much on some of the negative things that you forget we're doing some good work for kids we're doing some good work for our community so the handbook the 900 policies the brown act are really the things that you want to hold on to and we spent a lot of time last year looking at how do we process how do we interact with each other how do we ensure that we are following not only what you said as a a governance team but what the La say from a board policy to other statutes along the way so we're going to review that for some of you it will be a review I am

036going to rely on a lot of you because there going to be areas that be frank with you uh I may not remember the story behind the story behind the story in terms of how we got there and some of you will remember those aspects of it so this is going to be very interactive and that's our intent let's the more interactive is the Richer it will be for all of you yeah uh because it's it's really your district and you are the board members and and part of our the theme that we were having here is going from I to we without losing me how do you you're individuals and the decision making that you make will reflect your community you are not rubber stamps you are individuals so you express your personal views

037on issues that come in front of you and you collectively decide that as part of the Wei but once you've made the decision you're all behind it regardless of where you started out you're all behind it that's what's going to make your District so successful so so let's uh go through the handbook itself we'll just do some highlights and uh kind to go from there I'm sorry uh the handbook itself I think it'll be up on the screen yeah yep good as well I'm okay with the screen copy thank you no thank you and so if you take a look at the uh table of contents that we have there we're going to go through we won't go through each and every section but we will highlight most of the section along the way so

038I'm going to work with our uh prusty friend Lewis who will help uh guide me as well as us in the process I'd like to start with the Preamble I think that's important work as we think about what are the foundational reasons why you have to have a governance statement and what your role is and it says ramble representative government requires a public office holders be competent independent impartial and accountable therefore the trustees of the Pacific Grove unified school district adopts this govern's handbook which is a companion to its policy manual to promote and maintain best practices and the highest standards of professional conduct norms and protocols flow from the board bylaws embody the principles promulgated by the California school boards Association and are based on the collective experience of school boards across the state

039this r resource formalizes the conventions used by the governance team and and the conduct of the day-to-day business so this is what we will always refer to and one of the things I really love working about you guys someone always says but the BS or the handbook says we should do it this way so anytime you're in a bind or anytime you feel as so you know uh how should we proceed go to the handbook because typically there's a space in there where that's worked the other reason why I want to bring you guys along or or or for I want some of those of you who are are part of it is because context matters there's a reason why some of these things were put in not just the legal reasons but what makes

040it unique to Pacific Grove and there were conversations that were had as we said that some of you are really strong in your beliefs that I think we should do it this way and we were able to get to some consensus with those types of things questions or talks about just the Preamble itself just one quick one is and I think the answer is not this time but how much are we digging into this to try to rewrite or edit this is more an understanding session and then we'll pick this up at another board governance right correct that's the intent uh yes the intent basically is to go through it because this is going to be your working document from now I think I mentioned earlier the importance of reviewing it and maybe uh and

041I'm not sure with the typical timetable is Lou maybe you have bar an idea of how frequently you should go through it one of the things you don't necessarily want to do is continue to Wordsmith it you want it to be philosophically here's where we stand this what we believe as a group but typically it which which yeah you can do the review in in a number of ways we have two new board members who weren't part of the discussion but Beth you sat in on number of those meetings uh everybody should have a copy and everybody should read it if there is something in there that you say well I don't I don't I don't understand this I don't know how it's implemented I'm not sure I agree with it you should feel free

042to bring that up at a board meeting for discussion okay so that's one way of doing the review process is bring your issues any issues forward the other possibility is we schedule a meeting sometime towards the end of the year or maybe over the summer when it's a little bit quieter and having all of you read this and bringing any issues or any revisions you want and having that disc discuss at another governance type of training so we can do it in a couple of ways and and decide you know what's going to work best for you if there's any urgency if you read this and say oh I don't know if I can buy into that then that's something you need to bring forward and and discuss okay because the last board mean this

043is a commitment this is your document and it's a commitment that each yourie are making to the collective all of you and and uh it's important that you all say yes we subscribe to this this is what we how we want to operate and as a governance team and we believe that this document reflects our values and and our principles okay so if there's something that ABS can't subscribe to then bring it up let's discuss it yes and that's one of the reasons when we talked about the parking lot there may be areas that we look at and think you know what not something is biting at me now but it's something I think um I'm not feeling great about let's put it in parking lot and bring it back to have further discussion and

044part of the reason for doing it that way is there maybe require some research by staff by Lou and someone else to be able to give you a full answer about that but we don't want to go through the document and and not have you feel as if this is your document is something you can buy into in fact one of the things I would recommend would be once we go through this that you do take some time to go through it because in the end we want you to sign off on it not necessarily tonight but we do want you to sign off to say yes I can buy into what we said here there's some things that I may want to tweak I will bring them up as they rise or we'll put

045them in a parking lot but we want you to be able to say yeah I get the general gist I understand why we're here and I can buy into this document so our trusty Lois can we move to our commitments and obligations yes I could just add something um and it's interesting too because as times change uh looking back through the bylaws at minimum annually is going to make a difference because the everything shifts and what might have felt okay last year may not be okay this year or may not some things might not sit quite right this year with changing climates and things like that so even if we've read it um rereading is probably ideal just to say yeah this still makes sense this year and you bring up another good point too

046and that is annually uh csb as's bylaw changes along the way too and so we want to make sure that you're familiar with your own bylaws so that when the new bylaws come out you aren't in conflict with them or if you are you made a conscious decision that conflict with it because we feel this is good for our community and then Lou will say you can't do that let's figure out how you can do yeah that's the most famous question we always ask Lou we don't ask can we we ask how can we make this work yes along the way so I want you to take a look at and uh first of all our governor team governance teams Unity of purpose our Unity of purpose is to accomplish our mission fulfill our goals

047and to realize our vision as we operate under best practices set forth in policy that's what you're here for and if there's an area that uh boards get in trouble and superintendents get in trouble and districts get in trouble with is taking a look at the next section government's role and responsibilities LS is there a way to blow that up just a bit just that section there yeah one through five there we go can you see that or so I want you just to take a look at that and then I'll ask for feedback e thoughts comments thumbs up you okay with it I'll do the Southwest Airlines exit row thing in terms if if you're okay with it give me a verbal yes uh ver yes or no it's very and all this is

048a lot back in the day so I'm not sure that that all the wordiness is necessary um I understand how it probably came about that way okay thank you okay um I'm a yes and I agree with you I think having this just be clear and succinct for us and for anyone else who takes a look at the handbook would be a a nice Endeavor to look at but I think it's bigger than what we can take on for at least tonight's meeting so yes I'll say yes and as well because you know I even was thinking back to when we added I think we added the not as individuals for example again getting in that idea of the board Unity because it you know a lot of this does talk about and we thought

049it was not it was never a bad idea to remind both everybody in the community and ourselves of the board that we are not acting as individuals in this interest we're acting as a board so that was one I know that was one of the reasons why it became wordier but I agree I I like the idea of down the road parking lotting the idea of throwing it into chat gbt and cleaning it up how about looking at the next section there was that says uh yes there we go gosh we're on a roll what what does judicial review pertain to making sure that what we're doing is legal anything surprising anything pretty straightforward understanding what the role is I guess I would add something about it I mean it it says Human Resources um

050I don't know I I think I would want to say something about staff support or you know because yes it's all about the students but secondary to that it's all about teachers and staff that support those students and um you know I just I I think that we we definitely deal with that as quite a bit of our time so um I don't know if Human Resources really says that maybe it's supposed to mean that I don't know what human resources just mean it's our domain meaning we um when you say staff support what are you what are you referring to um you know just that we're we're just we're as concerned for staff morale I think as we are you know for our students morale that that sometimes I don't hear stuff about the

051staff but I mean yes of course we're here for the students but the staff is they're part of it you know they're I almost Inseparable to me and and I just feel that they um and and it and it ends up that we are you know if you talk about well collective bargaining but even so beyond that we we interact a lot with the staff I think though when I when I look at this um these are board responsibilities and they're clearly defined and I don't want to create a situation in the board bylaws where it sounds like we are directly supporting staff because that's not our role our role is to support the superintendent and if we start getting into staff support and all of that anything beyond Human Resources I could see it

052might get a little bit murky and I'll just add a quick I mean we originally when we drafted that last bullet again if I remember remembering correctly that was social emotional and physical safety of kids but we intentionally took out the of kids kids to represent the entire District so I think that was our goal in that edit I'm just afraid by putting staff it would get a little um like too much in the weeds yeah I I'm not really advocating for staff being something a bullet on there I was just uh not seeing something that maybe reflected that but now that you're saying social emotional physical I mean we could add like right I we could add something but I think as long as we again are as a board at recognizing that that

053is the students I would still I no I won't say that but I would say it's the students and you know the District staff um are in that last bullet importantly it's not just yeah thank you for that both of you because oops thank you for that both of you because this is exactly what we're supposed to be doing we talk about context how do we get here this is exact so great question or comment on your part great uh background and feeling so here's what we were thinking when we said that and as long as the six of you have that understanding we can move through it so thank you so much this is exactly what we're looking for exactly what we're looking for limits of board member Authority and basically looking at the

05492 hundreds is what we're referring to here e I have a very minor edit because it's something I I already can see something I've violated so throw me off the board if you need to but because his her position I'm I'm joking I'm I'm mostly joking about the last part but because his her position as a board member May inhibit the performance of school Personnel the board member informs I would like to just say the board member should inform um the superintendent or designate before volunteering in his child's classroom and I'll bring up an example where let's say my wife was the volunteer in the classroom but then she had a meeting scheduled and I had to fill in for her I've definitely done that and not sent a message to you first which I

055should have done but just making the point like this is a division like is it a must inform or is it a should inform I would lean towards should personally like it's the right thing to do but it may not always happen for various reasons again that's that's my two cents please others we had a long conversation about this one long conversation yes well I mean if you just go back two bullets is it two bullets well oh no that's okay board members who visit schools have no more Authority than any other citizen so I suppose I don't understand the point of uh where's the volunteer one I've already lost it and it's just long that's the long one uh I suppose I yeah it seems redundant to me because if I'm a board member

056visiting a school and I have no more Authority than any other citizen it seems absurd that I would even have to let you know because it's already been established that I don't have any more Authority than any other citizen am I reading that incorrectly I think I'm curious like what Linda and then staff would prefer because I I get what you're saying um Dr Hazen about ideally you would inform the superintendent um but it's also not always possible and I think if we are on campus whether we are just there in our parental capacity or volunteering like we can't completely take our board hat off so I could see a situation where there's where it's helpful for us to be aware and even let Linda know because things transpire while we're on campus and we

057all want to be on the same page and you know have site Personnel feel comfortable able with when we're showing up and what's going on um and communicate about it so I do see the value of it not because we intend to do anything and act outside of our Authority I think it's because of the perception like there's a school board member on campus and just kind of having that awareness that said I agree what you mean with what you said about it being redundant but it's I think it's more pulling at something like our awareness versus just the rule I do have to say that if show up um as a visitor and I don't have my my lanyard on and I don't have my badge on and I smile at the camera and

058my sticker prints out and I put the visitor sticker on I'm officially a visitor I'm not a board member at that point I understand that I'm always a Bo board member but specifically I I have no more Authority than any other citizen I'm not there in a board member's capacity and so I don't even think I've ever reached out to you so I guess I'm off the board too Elliot you guys are in a bind but I mean I mean if I'm in my kids classroom their teacher knows I'm coming because I've arranged it and just like any other parent I don't us I'm forgetting where we landed on this but I know we had a big conversation I think really where it ended in the end is I mean you know I think we

059even talked about it you Laura that you are it volunteering all year long I think you know same thing with you know Jennifer I mean you're in there but you kind of have a regular schedule and you I knew about start it ahead of time at the beginning of the year and so it's kind of that expectation that yeah you're you're doing this you've signed up for it as a you know there's a need at the school sites I think it's wonderful right that you you get to wear you know both of those hats um so I think what we ended up kind of agreeing to was it would really just be sort of more of an inform it's not to the degree of you're not going to reach out every time you know every

060day that you're doing it but it's just a matter of you're at the beginning of the year knowing that you know you'll be you know doing this in a certain capacity you know for the rest of the year and you're working directly with the school principal and the teacher you know to get that set up so I think that's where we ultimately ended up you know agreeing you know to it um for the reason that yes as a board member you're always carrying you know that that that weight right you know and everyone's going to perceive you as that way even though you're there you know you're there in a parent you know capacity you know just I think being cognizant you know of it so I think that was the reason we ended up

061keeping it I think we adjusted it to a certain degree to make it a bit more flexible but is and maybe some of it too I don't know if I can't remember I can't remember last year but um if it's if the if well now we have a new principal at one of the schools um so if it's a preference of hers that she knows beforehand or you know if the teachers are more comfortable I would say that that's probably the thing that's most important as long as the teacher that's there that inside the classroom is comfortable and the principal's comfortable able I think that's a very good point because having been in all of those roles as a teacher it's awkward it's very awkward to have a board member come on your campus Because

062You're torn as a principal it's way more Awkward because depending on the superintendent who in some cases are very adamant of if they're on your campus you better call us it makes a huge difference I think in both of your cases where you have an agreement you're going to volunteer in your kidss classes and sometimes you may have a schedule but sometimes you may not you know there may be spontaneous and to your point OT too where oh shoot wife is supposed to do it I filled in that's not really what we're talking about because there are going to be Exceptions there absolutely are but we're basically seeing as a general rule if you're talking about a teacher and you're talk about a principal they're going to be way more comfortable because as a principal

063I'm going to run and call the superintendent because the superintendent has typically is G made a deal if a board member comes on your campus please let me know so I'm going to do that whether you guys have asked for it or not that's automatically going to going to happen so I think it's do that happen in our district not really because none of you really visit the school siid without you know being going through the proper you know Channels with it so no it has not happened you know since I've been here at all no I do know of districts that where there has been app parent that would go and might go to a teacher and be like hey let's talk about these issues and do these things and like yeah start garnering

064so I think this and that's the way I try to read this as frankly and no offense to you trustee Shas but a new board member not a returning but like as a new board member I would just read this and be afraid that I'd say okay that means if I'm going to fill in for my wife I better tell Tex doctor out of and you know that that being said yeah uh no joke I'm volunteering tomorrow and Friday every week that okay you have been notified I will wear the size to make everyone feel cool but yeah but uh good really sorry yeah but this is why we're doing it why we're doing we have an understanding we don't want this to be so rigid that there's not any flexibility and because of who

065you are it's probably a very rare experience but this is for any and everybody whether you're a great board right not so good board so to have that practice in place it's important but and when you when you take a look at this in the normal course there might be refinements that you're going to see let's let's change it uh when I read this I saw it as not reflecting an individual visit I call the teacher I said like this come by and visit your classroom tomorrow as opposed to I'm going to be a regular volunteer in that classroom yeah but as we as you see things there may be things you want to change down the road and I I've made a couple notes on our for the parking lot of areas that we

066you might want to revisit and refine a bit well um I'll just say okay where it says a board member whose child um is attending a school district well I think that it should say because this happened to me um a board member's child instead of whose child a board member's child uh is aware of of his or her parents role as a board member because uh I did have my youngest was in high school the others were already out by when I got on the board but my youngest was in high school and he was uh a little bit of a pistol with some teachers that he didn't care for and at one point he got mad at a teacher and said my mother's on the school board and she can have you fired

067yeah thank God I knew that teacher and she knew me and she didn't take them serious at all but but you know it was hilarious now but not then so it's it's something that uh you might want to discuss when your kids get a little older in the that that you know they um H might have have some uh attention paid to them because other kids know their their parents on the school board or they have an an idea of what that means what kind of power they may or may not have yeah the other thing is I look at it too what if I'm my grandparent my grandparent and and I may have guardianship it might even guardian or so I think that one we may want to look at again for sure good

068parking lot yeah y being a high caliber governance team we don't need to read that you guys know this I do want to get go to the Norms though if you may recall there were at one point how many nor or there 20 something so we basically reduced them to the top 10 when we talked about how often times conditions situations make a difference these Top 10 May fluctuate based on some things but just take a look at those top 10 else would you think and again while you guys are reading for the the past history here we actually had Post-it notes I think Beth you might have been here for some of those um but we were putting those like we each had three Post-it notes we could put on the Norms below so

069in some way I would almost Rec I mean the top 10 are important but the ones below you can see everything we were choosing from to choose you know to get to these T and so this is something I do like the idea of us doing at a later Point again not this meeting but I don't know I don't know if it's good or if it's just like you know burned in there take it I remember I remember which one we all we all voted for there was like one or two we all voted for questions thoughts me questions or thoughts well I remember you guys going through this and and there was you know reasons that you were doing this and um so those reasons change as your board changes um and because some

070of this is very parental you know um in a way that maybe isn't necessary I don't knows not all of it some of it's good but it's quite a bit um it's kind of like like a over dictor type of listing of behaviors you know that um kind of tells you like whoops you know this board was having some problems here and needed to spell out good behavior you know um there's one Behavior so and I maybe maybe it's somewhere in here later on but we can get to some maybe parking lot but I one of the things I think tends to be missing is um when you you talk about um coming to consensus or how do you handle differences of opinions and trying to get um some kind of a consensus vote um

071but it doesn't really uh tell you some methodology and how to do that and I think that would be a good place in here maybe in a later time we can think about it about how how you would want you know the board president to run it when there's obvious you know disagreements about before a vote's going to take and and see what you can do to get a consensus sometimes you can't and that's that's okay but you you do what you can so that everyone feels they've been heard and respected uh but just there's there's some details you might be able to uh write out in terms of um a procedure to just make sure that that um consensus is um targeted or yeah I've seen that where how a board manages conflict and

072this is how we manage conflict yeah and so I think you're looking at something like that to say when there is disagreement and when you can't reach consensus and you've got to go to vote you know those are things that do happen as a part of board I would love that yeah I like that I would love that for all of us to be on the same page about what our resources and supports are as board members um and how to communicate with one another when these things inevitably do come up because they will I'll just say we have a oh sorry go ahead was sure um for item four solidarity I mean we don't have anything that speaks to that exactly but that would be a great spot for it to potentially go and

073again I would also agree with that coming and you know for these top 10 Norms per your point also uh that was well said Beth I mean I think items five and 10 are also like if we're doing five we we're doing 10 and and you know so I do think 10 is one of those that I feel our board um trying to say how best to say but I don't think it's something we need reminders on um and it would be something to consider for our next top Norms or just cut oh I think number eight served its purpose when it was put on there and I don't necessarily know that that is something that we need to remind each other on this board I don't get that sense but if others think that

074it's important to be on there I think that that's fine I would love for us to re-evaluate the list because the more I look at this the more like you said this is clearly a group of people who were being very mindful of each other's actions and there wasn't a strong like feeling of trust um and we this feels like a more Collective group that is focused on governing and the kids and what our charges collectively and so I would like that to be reflected a bit more um so we can model that so we can RIS revisit the top the Norms in general and maybe create another top 10 based upon what this board feels more comfortable with Mak sense yeah the Norms always reflect the times yeah and times change yeah I I

075put in the questioning last but because uh top 10 Norm review something we were doing taking a look at dayto day number one I think that's pretty self-explanatory about to a through G well one hot word out there that's really has a um probably a different definition to every one of us is the word micromanage and yeah I mean okay I agree you don't micromanage but um what I consider micromanaging Jen may say that's not micromanaging that's doing my job so you know there's there's that you have to recognize that that you know um that micromanaging is kind of that word that uh gets thrown around without um a clear understanding of what micromanaging is so um you can put it up there but I I don't know that we're all going to understand what

076that means thoughts comments either that comment or other D think we're okay I appreciate your comments and I think where I'm at is I can it's just such a difference for us sitting in this room that a year makes um that we're having a conversation about whether or not micromanaging like what that looks like to each one of us and that it's okay that it's different um so I appreciate you bringing that to light and and just just having a moment of reflection that we're here and we can have the conversation and it's good and one thought on that because this is where it gets it gets difficult for the Norms is like how much you know like you say the there's kind of the like the cheat sheet and then the Playbook right that

077actually spells everything out and I was recently reminded on the how not to be a terrible Schoolboard member book and they have a great section for example on micromanaging so I do wonder if that's the kind of thing I think we did some of this last time like to point at when but you know micromanaging as it's defined in this book we could say or something like that so that we're not having to redefine it but it's pretty clear there where that line is drawn I feel and I think one more thing to consider too is that we each have our own relationship with the superintendent and that's a give and take so if we have something and it is going too far acrossing a line I want Linda to tell myself or feel comfortable

078telling any of us hey like you know you've gotten to staff territory or in the kind and very respectful way that I know you would tell us but I would want to be told like hey this feels like you're getting into micromanaging territory or this isn't a line I'm not comfortable with you asking you know to for us to do something about so I think it's kind of like upon all of us you know to be be able to say like I'm comfortable when you tell me no or when you tell me like you're getting into parent land instead of wearing your Schoolboard hat or whatever it might be um yeah so maybe we one of our new Norms could be that we're all okay with being told that we're in the wrong track sure

079and to be to be clear that's been part of our superintendent goals with Dr Adamson as well is exactly that is please do tell us no and tell us that even recognizing the difficulty sit difficult situation that puts her in because you're as an employer telling your employee you know to correct us but again especially with this makeup of the board too I think it highlights that and the importance of that moving forward and I think it's you brought a very good point je that being what a difference a year makes and sometimes you put those things in based on those current circumstances and you know you may not be needed it's it is a cautionary place though and I say that because a lot of it has to do in you you mentioned that

080that being the superintendent telling one of you back off basically that's what I'm telling you you Michael managing me and and of course she'll say it more articulately and kindly than that but it it is a interesting place to be in in her shoes but being able to at least have the conversation is important yeah so I think that's the word we definitely can look at and look at some other res yeah I I think too that um the word micromanage is is um reflective of a value and it's the value that the person is really caring about and they're trying and they're using what's looking like micromanagement to get it heard or bring it attention to it so you know there's ways to um address it without it feeling the that the other person

081is wrong about something you know but but getting to what what is really causing that person to be upset or feel that they need to interject some way well and um that is coming from somebody that has a a big heart and is filled with caring and there are people that are just wanting to control and there's a difference there you know and micromanaging to somebody that is a control freak that just wants to be in charge is very different from somebody that cares and wants to um sees something that needs help and wants to contribute do you know what I mean and so that's a perfect example of like the vast difference of the definition of the word micromanage you know because somebody that is a controlling human being it probably wouldn't [Music] even

082I don't even know that it would occur to them that it's micromanaging they probably just see a job that needs to get done and they want to do it themselves you know so um I don't think that's anybody here no I think that's true what you're both saying though it looks different over time like what micromanagement might have felt like or look like in a different version of the board and a different iteration of staff may totally feel like um it's unnecessary now um and I can say just from my experience being clerk the first go around there was a lot more um responsibility put on us as the president and the clerk to kind of do some of the leadership duties in the district that I'm now learning aren't our roles as board members

083even and so things that might have come off as micromanaging or appeared as micro managing at the time it was kind of like an absence of anyone leading us or telling us how to be managed I mean I don't want to be managed but um I think now that we're where we're at today like I you know if it comes to a point where we're concerned about each other's Behavior like you always say I want us to be able to tell each other yeah and I want us to be able to for Linda to be able to say like you know are I genen won too many times you know or whatever the circumstances are and I hope that we're kind of creating that environment where we all feel comfortable doing that agree agree and

084I was just G to say I mean I don't know if it helps to all go around the table and look at L like you have a th% there you go a th% but whatever School La it's 100% I get reminded at home there's no such thing as a thousand per but you have my permission to ever tell me if I overstep or if I micromanage in any way and so that's being recorded in a Forum so please do I mean I'm accepting of it and I think that that's and it's important it's important the feedback is important because there's no way to know if there's an overstep that's happening if it doesn't get addressed yeah yeah right and F us right you're absolutely right Nora y agree and I'll just put a second on

085that because again is that it's not just to Linda but to each other like if if I've done something that you know offends you or you you know and you know I I mean if wore the wrong color socks please don't call me about that or text me but if it's something that's honestly is you know offended you or something that's you know that you think I made a mstep like that's to me the importance of the board is do reach out to me and let me know because that's and I you know I think that's important for us to all be on the same page we're not the same page but on the page of that's something we want or not because that is something we had issues um agreeing with as a previous

086board remember the topic high quality governance team so how do we be become sustain maintain being that along the way and so I think taking a look at that word I think it's great is for us to look at it and maybe come up with a diff maybe even a different word but also appreciate the idea of you guys giving Linda permission to say if we're overstepping feel free to jump in and let us know okay good good I mean I'm a new board member but uh Dr Adamson has yelled at me multiple times already I don't believe you I don't believe you get he just cursed me out no no I appreciate honesty from anyone from Dr Adamson and everyone else's so bu yeah you want to move up u h through T oh

087I I think this is going to be one of those areas where you want to look at it yourself you'll come back and I'm looking at it just for the sense of time and so I want to go through the the main topics looking at ethics in Integrity keep going up and really if I if you don't mind my interrupting area but I think all of these are ultimately if we're going to do that followup activity with the top 10 this is where we're going to be selecting our top and just to point out number five how The Bard communicates you know a couple of you you know really Drew out you know some of the importance of that and there's some nice you know sort of bullets you know in that section in particular

088so but again yeah I think we can cover all of that in that activity and even looking at six I think uh just listening to the conversation tonight I feel like this is the board who's going to be supported respective and and considerate of one another and understands that your roles are can I say something this time it's serious or I mean semi serious and it's kind of off topic but there's oh uh we do not withhold or obstruct the flow of important information that point and you know General points about transparency I I OB or maybe not obviously I believe in that clearly but also I think there's a a time where um public transparency can can actually uh be a detriment to how you feel like like the posted notes for how for

089how the board took these if you're publicly doing it you know I worry about kind of just like seeing the physical representation of lots of posted notes there and then oh I should put it there or like that's where the group's leading it kind of um kind of the user interface of that decision making is a little um persuasive in in one way or another so I I think sometimes there at least for an initial vot or something I think there is a usefulness or utility to um to taking a blind Vote or something like that and then and then talking about it that's something completely different but I just um it's just uh stuck out while going over these yeah I mean that seems like a potential close session type topic and I don't

090know if that's something that's done in close session where you would have a a blind vote before a final vote just to see where people stand and then the last time I remember doing that was on a hiring committee I think right didn't we do that with or I don't even mean a a blind vote for for something big but you know sort of really just a post- and note thing in general you know it's not it's not a big hiring decision or something but I just think it's important to be mindful of right influencing sway basically yeah yeah yeah like a um a blind vote for when we're selecting our Norm yeah yeah yeah so we're just kind of so yeah so so that way we're all it's this uh sort of or we're

091picking them organically right individually and then coming together to say like this is what I found was I think is most important for our board and then we kind of come together as opposed to it being like this sort of know everybody go up and make your mark So homework for next governance meeting would be for us to come with our top 10 from all them yeah and then we could start that that way rather than doing it yeah and you know that was just the example that I thought of now but um yeah thank you thank you for that looking at uh board meetings this was one we had a little spend a little time on Lew it's on page eight you just following on Mike's Point for M we want to make an

092exception for course of profane language when Linda's telling us what we've done wrong right I second Louis we need like a bleep button two second delay yeah oh boy okay Mo our protocol next please you guys are okay with that and Lou's gonna Lou is gonna talk more about the brown act as we move forward and so a lot of this will be covered either in scenarios or conversation with us along the way I'm not going to spend a lot of time on agenda preparation and meeting preparation I do want to look at page 10 briefly which one onone there 10 and 11 kind of splitting it and again Lou will talk more about that if necessary in in the other aspect of things I'm going to skip Lou and have them read the rest

093of it yeah that's good visiting schools as a board member I think we spent a little time on that one earlier I would like to go to handling complaints concerns or complaints from the public e can I ask a scenario question on these RS sitting now that I have to sit in a different role than I did last time um you know specifically what you know we've talked about this before but if there's a member of the public that ask a question sometimes the board will say we have that question as well and I seem to remember that's not always the best practice that was recommended and then the secondarily is if there is a question being asked that is actually a good question like you know or or like you know what you know

094when on the agenda are you going to discuss this is that still the kind of thing that you still just don't respond like I mean sorry it's a two-parter but yeah listening to those RS yeah remember you are there to conduct a Public's business but you're it's not a town hall meeting so nor is it a press conference so the public has a right to comment on each item on the on the agenda and if people are inclined to ask questions out in the public so they'll say what about this what about that if it's a easy answered question that the staff you refer it to staff if it's more complex at a later time or yeah that's a qu good question for staff it's almost a judgment call on whether or not you're going

095to do that there and put somebody on the spot or let me have the superintendent or Administration get back to you on that and you're not taking up valuable meeting time to get into a debate on whether or not something should or shouldn't happen in a certain way okay but it's you want to keep your meetings focused on the business you're doing you want to be respectful of the public that's addressing you you want to listen to what their comments are and at some point if somebody goes on too long and it's too complex say you make some good points can you bring those issues up with contact the superintendent office or the business office or the HR office to explore that further I'm I think they can answer your questions more appropriately let's go

096on to the next agenda item okay it's a judgment call there and one of the things we were going to talk about as well is like what's the role of War President because it is you're the one whose shoulders it falls on to do that okay but I can nominate someone else right like yeah so is there anything wrong with just saying thank you for your comment because with some people that will come and ask some people will come and make comment and then uh on occasion we'll ask questions and then some people will get up and they're heated and they're asking questions and if you refer one person to somebody and not the next person then there can be this feeling of well you didn't pay attention to me and all of this so

097in yeah looking at it from because we're in such a small community I thank you for your comment um or if it is super simple to just look at somebody and say we can have somebody we'll have someone follow up with you just blanket instead of calling out a staff member because that is a better policy I always did that sort of a general yes because you will at some point be accused of playing favorites that's if you answer this person's questions all the time and then someone who has a heated question or someone you don't necessarily care for you know they have an angle and you don't answer theirs in the same way so I would typically say thank you for your question at best I would say we'll have staff reach out to

098you and not put him on the spot to your point at that point yeah yeah so that's what what I've done and it's been I was fairly successful not everybody liked it because it's sometimes lose favor term of of no comment you know worst thing you can say in many cases but the reality of it is they're appropriate times and I I did exactly what you said but yeah I just kind of feel like it's a safe it's a safer bet and it's fair across the board I agree I agree with you I think the the message that we respect and appreciate all feedback and that we're going to treat feedback consistently and that's how everyone is can be received is I want people to feel welcome regardless of their questions or their concerns or

099whether I personally agree with them I think there should be space for that so I think if we're consistent in our messaging about public comment and that helps create an environment where people can share that's part of why I brought it up is that's what I want feedback from everyone in the room here on and I I agree with that completely is I like the idea of just saying thank you for your comment and I you know I can even think about making a comment at the onset before you know if if there's a questions asked or comments raised them you know I'll direct them before even yeah and if if staff is following up with somebody um depending on what the question is and who the person is and how you know heated the

100topic is um I kind of wonder what the follow through would be where if staff follows up and then there's another question and then staff follows up and then there's another question and then staff follows up and then there's another question and sort of where does it end so is it a followup one time to that specific question or does it continue and maybe that's not my business but I just wonder how exhausting it can become if this an open-ended sort of back and forth email situation I think it depends on the situation uh but typically yeah when we have followed up in the past I mean we try to cover you know everything in one conversation if it feels like it's more than that sometimes just a meeting or a phone conversation you know

101is easier um I think we just gauge it you know according to and I will say I think I don't think there's been a situation that I can think of you know in the last year where we followed up with something and it's sort of you know gone on forever um but I you know I think typically it's appreciated number one the followup you know whever you know is asking um and the second part of that is the follow-up questions that come after one answer is received you know tend to be better you know addressed in a phone a phone conversation what we found I think I'm I'm just sort of anticipating the upcoming year because there's a lot changing right now and there's going to probably be a little bit of upheaval and emotion

102coming out so I just sort of wondered what the right it was more of a general wondering than than anything but okay yeah yeah and you know I think just to add to that I mean typically this is specific to questions that come out I we're not going to follow up if someone just you know going in and they're making a statement right that they're wanting you know maybe you know a listening ear right it would be a specific question would be the only time I think we would then say you know in response to those questions you know a member of Staff will follow up you know to that I I would love to ra I I would honestly not even like to put stuff on the spot that they have to I I

103like thank you for your comment and I will try like how many if it's like a number question but if it's like what do you plan to do on blah blah blah blah blah blah it's sort of like thank you for your comment we've we've heard your comment thank you very much yeah even I even now the thing I worry about is even if even if it's certain we're getting a little more weedy here so if it need to parking lot but even if it's a question that would just number question like you can get those people that will ask lots and lots of number questions and it comes down as you know is it so you know might be one of those that is just a trust issue and and maybe feedback where you

104know I can try to give a look and you know without saying it verbally just to make clear that we're on the same page that there's a need for that followup or I don't know no that's getting around the transparency but I I just worry that if we even if we're even if it is a question that we could have staff follow up with I don't want it to be exhausted exactly right oh everyone's doing yeah there's yeah a lot on everyone's plate so exactly so I would love to put that more in your hands superintendent Adam Adamson to make the decision whether it needs to be followed up than the boards that's fair I I was just processing um you could have an absolute rule that you don't take questions the board doesn't take

105questions it's not a press conference uh you refer everything to the superintendent so if you have a question the super please contact the superintendent tomorrow morning uh or follow up the St after the meeting sometime and she'll make sure that your questions get answered and and you know you might refer it to somebody else who's expert in that particular area but you are not taking questions to either staff or the board at them you could you certainly could do that um there are the easy questions like uh I forgot what night is parent open house okay to well I don't understand that budget item and I don't know why you're spending $3 million on that item why are you okay why are you doing that and you're going to approve the budget and I want

106to know now as a citizen why you you're spending that kind of money it's my taxpayer money and you're voting on the budget tomorrow the super gives me an answer but I have no idea what you're voting on I mean there is that kind of situation that can come up and create some tension um if it's if it's tense if things aren't going well at the meeting you can always take a break okay and deflect it and let staff go talk to that person okay right to get that question so we're gonna take a five minute recess just refresh get some water or whatever um and then staff can go say Let me let me explain something to you and that can take place there rather than putting the board members on the spot of

107answering some complex questions I would even I mean I again put this out there but I like the idea even of rather than responding to the question question at the time having a board member write it down if it is something that's important and a board member could bring it up later if if it is a valid question like if there really is a question you know because I think we've had the Habit as a board of instead saying yes I also have that question can you please answer it I'm wondering if it's better to parking lot till the board discusses it I think it's not probably a good practice to say I also had that question because no you have your own questions and you can ask whatever questions you want of St make

108sure you're satisfied of that the things you're voting on you're comfortable with okay that's your job uh and your positions um so I would say well let the public comment end and then whatever questions you may have they may be some of the same may they may be different then you can ask staff or Clarity on your questions thought comments that's exactly where I was going well I think there's two different kinds of uh public um upsetness one when you already know this topic that we have on the agenda is going to get a lot of hot blooded people here and so when you know that then you can decide ahead of time how do you want to handle that do you want to maybe say we're going to have um a short question answer

109session where you get to write out a question and hand it in or whatever you want to do but I mean so that's something you can plan for because a lot of times you do know a certain subject is going to come up and maybe you even heard the rumors like you know we know Planned Parenthood opposition is coming okay so what are we how are we going to handle it um but the other one that I've experienced and I'm I really would like to see us be responding to is when you get a parent who is upset about something that happened to their kid in school and they come up to the podium and they're very upset and they're trying to explain to you how bad this was or how wrong this was then

110just to say thank you for your comment is not going to be good okay so I would like us to be able to say we we as a board are understanding these emotions and we take it serious and you know and and then is you know you can't say much more thank you your comment with context basically yeah yeah that that it's important because I've seen parents walk away feel feeling like wow nobody heard me you know and um you know it's so it's it's that's just something for the board president to to keep in mind that they there are going to be times when it's important to be human and say you know we we are taking this so seriously you can you can sometimes do something that effect uh we hear you and

111uh that's where the president and Lind can look at each other and say and we'll have staff follow up with you simple as that and and letting it go but it's basically exactly what lur was saying earlier is that we hear you and we'll have staff follow up with you on that aspect because you're right they they are different yeah and the how it's conveyed to them that we're not we're saying thank you for your comment moving right along like that doesn't demonstrate that I was listen and that it was important so being able to really just like take a moment take it in not react quickly and then connect with the person um before we move on even if there isn't anything else that we can do in that moment which there probably isn't

112other than listen um yeah and I like the piece about kind of meeting the emotion of the moment not in a way where we're reactive but just in a way that we're aware and mindful of the importance and seriousness for this person who is brave enough to bring their concern and sit on a hot mic for three minutes and share something that's probably been really difficult right um yeah so how we do that and just being able to say three a sentence or two or three that's the yeah yeah just conveys empathy for I I I printed up your bylaws on the role of the board president and I thought I just hand hand that out there's reference to it in the handbook on page 11 Lewis could you put that section up on page

11311 the role of the president of the board okay so it's just a brief statement in your handbook but it it refers to this particular bylaw what the what the president's role is and I think it's a pretty good summary of what the expectations are uh you know it's basically while the president doesn't have any more power than any other board member the president is sort of the parliamentarian that runs the meeting calls the meeting uh makes sure the meeting agendas are put together in advance uh Prides over it calls the agenda items uh calls on people to speak make sure that every board member and I think I've I've watched your board meetings I've been at your board I think you did a really good job of H giving every board member an opportunity

114to express their views on things and then before you move on to a vote so that's one of the things that you do and you you also call for the vote you make the motion okay uh so just a question I got louder real quick um question on that like is it always on the president to make the motion because that's one thing we haven't always done I just see that as number nine there president has the authority to make motions just as every other board member does right and then once the motion is made to call for the vote on the motion but you wouldn't you wouldn't recommend that the president be the primary per like because I could see a situation I mean I could help zip through things if I agree with

115something just every time make that motion and go but I don't think that's the right you don't want to dominate the meeting because you don't want to lessen any other board members presence or authority okay and most of the time a board president will sit back and wait for the somebody to make a motion rather than make the motion if it's not going anywhere and you do control the agenda you aren't going to all sit there and stare at each other so you you know sometimes motions are put to that are going to fail or put out there just to see what the vote is okay and it fails so then you move on um but I see most presidents being differential to their colleagues on the board and and see if somebody wants to

116make a motion on something and then I what I see if there's no motion well I'll move so and so and see where the vote happens okay but it's basically the orderly conduct of the meeting and when those tension arise over those controversial issues that will come up we're not at the end of that I can guarantee you they will come up um you listen empathetically to people uh if it starts to get out of hand you just call for a brief recess take a 10-minute recess and then let let staff go and deal with the upset person and see if they can calm them down yeah and then reconvene sorry one more quick question is is the recess the first recourse of action or is it okay for the board president to try like

117first or just really would you recommend recess should be I mean and it depends on degree right like we're talking about yeah let let's say somebody it doesn't happen very often but I've seen it where somebody goes over there three minutes and they just keep talking okay um you're supposed to manage that if you're going to extend that three minutes it probably should be you're over your 3 minutes does the board want to extend the time or not you know rather than just putting up but or if you don't want to do that you simply could say you're at the end of your three minutes thank you very much for your comments I think we all heard what you had to say uh I'm ready for our next speaker okay and our next do you

118do the cards I forgotten you don't do cards okay okay you just people just come up and speak on items okay should you should you do cards no that's my personal opinion you don't have to state your name or give any identifying information for public comment so requiring that think that works comports with the law I have a question about and we've seen this here where somebody wants to give their three minutes to the person that just didn't get the rest of it has been speaking for over three minutes and then somebody comes up and says I'd like to give my three minutes to Bob Smith who couldn't get out all of his thoughts in three minutes so that we've seen it and it doesn't happen but I I I don't think the three minutes

119are a commodity to betray but it's interesting the way that it happens because you know it gets leveraged and all that so um I don't know if that is something that we discuss up front like everybody at each individual gets three minutes three minutes will not be com whatever however we have to say it but it might be worth saying in the beginning don't for it is I thought that was already in the past board Pro p uh protocols because I think we updated that last time for that exact read before every I don't read everything so it's I mean I try to do the highl on the you know how many people are in the room I try a lot there's a lot of people in the room we might want to read it

120right but that that's a good reminder if it comes up I have no problem also just jumping in be like yes thank you for that kind suggestion but we do not pass along butes everybody has their own three yeah but that's a I mean we have seen that for sure good conversation guys thanks so much we're going to drop down to page 15 which is the compact itself take a few minutes to read it because in the end this is where we want to be where you all sign off on it down the road yeah GL how non-committal we have read every single word and phrase maybe we can in the September yeah I'm sorry no I don't think so I think that was there I think that was there yeah we will be targeting

121a similar date September to resign or that's something we would do is early early in that yeah you can I I think that you can either commit to it now and say subject to change um or you can I it's really the three of you have already committed to it so it's really a question of whether the two new board members are comfortable with this document now and commit to it or want to go through the review and revise process before they commit to it right and the committing does not stop the revising no right not no point can always be revised they what's the board's wish moving forward we look at you trusty wax and trusty shabas no pressure just the technicality the three of you are in the majority so no this requires

122every single one of us so if you say no as a board we say no it's not a vote that's right it's a commitment each of you make to each other unanimity of from the perusal yeah I mean uh but it it I can sign off of I will let my name to it but it do seem like they're a few matters up for uh review and editing yeah I on this page 16 I had a bunch of little notes I mean 15 page 15 I was on there is no 16 wa I don't have my glasses must be 14 on there because that's before well that yeah it's the before the com it's before the compact so it's welcoming you know welcoming new members to the board and then avoiding in improprieties and appearances

123thereof I don't know there's just so much extra wordage in here that I am like Blown Away by um redund y yes um but in in light of that just there were some things that I that I wanted to put new in here um and that was we didn't talk about welcoming new board members to the board right no no okay but that's in here so I don't think I really want to sign into I mean we haven't perused it right I mean much like micromanage you know Peru for one is it's different for each person um look how easily suede I am I could I'm also I mean I don't yeah I'm I'm not sure how much um what does it change I mean what effect yeah I mean does if we're going to

124review if we approve and may make changes how is that different than not approving it and making changes I'm I'll just in interest of of moving us along what I'm hearing is the two new board members are not totally comfortable with it I suggest that you go back and and and go through the process again with everybody and have a document that everybody is committed to I have clients who don't have a handbook it is not the end of the world okay you will function but but I think everybody does if you have one everybody's got to buy into it and feel comfortable with it and so until they do I think you need to work with your colleagues coming up with something that everybody says yes I'm behind this um in the interest of

125of limited time for all of us in our lives I'd like to not draw the process for like a whole four hours or something I I think maybe if I personally had the chance to actually read it word for word I know I have had the chance but to read it with this in mind and then um maybe have a shortened um session I mean I I I don't want it to stop us from doing business or or that but I just would also like to be more um learned in what in what the document says I'd like to just propose then possibly you know we've talked about bringing this at you know an upcoming governance session so what and be even you saying there things you want to add I mean I think they

126you know there's place for that to you know bring prior to that next meeting if you you know sort of have a list of the things that you want to do same thing for you Mike and then that could even be shared with the you know board ahead of time and then that's something we could spend maybe 45 minutes at upcoming session you know to just kind of go through the additions that are being proposed um to add uh and then you know we can just agree to it at in in terms of how it would work would be all right to kind of send questions or proposed edits to you and kind of make a document like we do for every meeting and just kind of have answers and you know like highlight what

127a particular person would like to change or sure yeah we could do it as like a Shar document that we do for board agenda yeah absolutely can I ask a quick question as far as my time on the board we've kind of done and I'm appreciative that we're having governance trainings I'll say that first and foremost very appreciative um we kind done this retooling of the handbook and I think each time we've looked at it we've all kind of left with the impression like this needs an overhaul how do we get there and I know that's not tonight's task but like what are the steps or do we create a committee or I mean how what is that endeavor like like making the handbook uh more digestible and understandable and succinct that type of can

128I just throw an idea out is maybe we all walk away with a handbook we take it home and we mark it up in whatever way we feel works for us and then we bring it back and then we can each just sort of say this is what I was thinking for section one for I mean I was looking at the new uh trusty whatever yeah there's some stuff in there that could just get totally wiped out I mean personally I think it's just seems but anyway so maybe we each bring our changes or our additions and then we go over it and we all just sort of know we could take a vote on it or we could just sort of all we're either in agreement or we're not in agreement and majority rules

129and then we just move forward maybe that's how the overhaul happens I don't know the thought I love that idea I just I do like the idea if we wanted to set we could either send them with questions or thoughts so there might there might be some nice situations where we all have the exact same five edits magically so those could be kind of cleared off and be like rather than having to vote on that but if we we could either bring them to meeting or send them send them to Lyon in advance I think either approach works for me I like that idea I think if you send them to Linda Advance it'll give it'll make your meeting more efficient go through and you can note Laura thinks that this section should be rified

130Beth thought that this sentence should be like you so you can attribute so that you can have a discussion and Laura can give her reasons why she thinks things what area should be changed and I don't see you spending four hours doing that yeah I would agree with that I think that the body itself is fine what I don't want us to do is do too much word smithing where it becomes a document where you've got five different perspectives of something and then you will be back to spending four hours on it from that perspective but if there are things that that really resonate with you and think you know do we really need this entire your point the section or this word or looking at the word peruse and thinking and well we all

131kind of know that that needs to go but the more we can keep it basically intact and then with our ideas of well maybe someone can tell me the story behind this because I'm not quite understanding that we can shorten the process because I have also seen is it's the opposite where you were Smith this thing to death and it never gets completed because it continues to get revised and have the same conversations okay good thank you do you all need a comfort break or should we just keep yeah okay how about we take a 10 minute five minutes five five minutes five that's oh okay thank you guys sorry for laying down the order but please continue Lou and Eric yeah okay Lewis if you can go to like Slide Five in the overall

132presentation that would be good we're GNA talk about the brown act and do a little very quick review and then we're GNA do some exercises on the or some hypotheticals on the on the brown a and all right here thank you Lou so the brown covers all local governmental agencies and it basically says that all of the Public's business has to be conducted in public unless there's a specific exemption to have close session discussion on it so it's got to be very specific if it's not in the close session authorizations in the brown act it has to be done in Open Session okay all votes in Open Session have to be publicly stated there's no secret voting ballot in Open Session okay um the public has a right to comment on every item on the

133agenda at a regular board meeting the public has a right to comment on anything that is within the jurisdiction of the board incl as well as the agenda so it may not be on the agenda but if it's within your jurisdiction the public has a right to comment it at a special board meeting the public right is only to comment on things on the agenda they don't have a right to comment on things that are not on the agenda okay the agenda has to be posted 72 hours in advance of regular meetings 24 hours in advance of special meetings you can only talk about those things that are on that agenda um it also has to be posted on your website ask you a question about that for the agendas in particular and again this

134is wedi but if there's a typo in the 72-hour period so let's say we notice a typo 48 hours before a regular meeting and the I my thought is if the typo is substantive enough that a public member would not be able to understand is it necessary to pull that item or are there ways to address that yeah the question is is the wording sufficient to tell the public what you're going to be talking about there's no it it it doesn't have to be more than 20 words it can be very brief um but the question is would a reasonable member of the public know that you're going to be talking about that topic so it depends on what the what the typo is you know and how substantive it is and does it affect

135knowledge and would the ordinary person have sufficient knowledge to say yeah I I knew with that okay second part what's a meeting a meeting is any Congregation of a majority of the board at any place so anytime there's three of you since you have five on the board you've got a quorum you've got a meeting okay the meetings require notice meetings require an agenda and the meetings require no action to be taken anything that is not on that agenda why don't you go to the next slide okay um one more there are different kinds of meting one more slide um there are the obvious is when three of you are in the same place at the same time the not so obvious is three of you are communicating about the same subject it may not

136be at the same time it may not be in the same place so that's the chain Elliot sends an email to Jen Jen responds to Elliott Jen forwards that to Beth just so she's aware you just got a meeting okay it's any communication becomes a meeting it can be a Spokes and chain it could be you communicate to the superintendent and the superintendent then says well I heard from three board members that their view on this subject is XYZ that's the spoken Hub you still have a meeting to be clear there The Hub does not have to be a board member The Hub does not have to be a board member passport member anybody is anybody who is alive and can speak or question or communicate in any way okay it could be a carrier

137pigeon okay um if the communication is going to a majority of the board you are having a board meeting okay um one more slide Lis and then we're going to do some fun hypotheticals just to test so it could be phones it can be by email it can be on text message it can be in chat rooms it can be on social media so let's say I'm a board member and I have a social media page and I put all my thoughts on about what's coming up on that on my social media page and Mike reads it and Mike makes some comments on my social media page not a board meeting yet but then Laura reads it and she puts her comments down I I've got a meeting okay so it you can see any

138time there's Communications on the same topic between board members under the brown act it's going to be a meeting in that instance you just described um what about the time frame does that matter at all or I mean no okay so he so Elliot posts something on his page and Laura comments on it and a week later Mike comments on it it's still then it's still a meeting yes so the time doesn't have a no because you could have it instantaneously with the calls right or you can have it delayed 10 minutes one day one week if that communication is taking place on a on a subject matter that's within the board's jurisdiction it's Communications among a majority of the board and that's what's prohibited by the brand act so do I Elliot okay Elliot

139stop posting frankly I apologize posts and I read it and I comment and then Beth reads it even if she doesn't comment is that still a brown act violation because she now has information from two board members and she can you know you can sway your Vote or whatever yeah so technically have to not brown act violation okay technically it's not a brown but I remember in this District probably the time that Beth recalled the big commotion what happened was one board member commented to another board member about a colleague on the board I don't know how it happened but that colleague found out about it and I don't know how he found out about it okay this is the controversy that was right before you got on the board okay and that board member

140this is this District went to the DA's office and said look at these community ation now in my opinion that was not a brown act violation because there was no three-way communication the da was out of town at a conference one of his deputies looked at it wrote a letter to the board members saying you violated the brown act that's what gave rise to that recall movement that whole recall thing I was here and all that and it was tumultuous it was a terrible time in this District yeah and it wasn't a brown violation no one has gone to jail in California for violating the brown act the D actually prosecuted the city council of Seaside a number of years ago for brown act violation which probably was a brown act violation took him to

141trial and couldn't get a conviction you you won't go to jail but it's the accusation of a brown act violation that does the damage the real damage and it's it's the damage of shaking public confidence in you and your board and this board and that's something you just don't want to do at all okay um because you need the public support to do your work and and the more Angry members of the public are the harder it is for you to do your work and to do do good work okay so don't even tiptoe to the edge that's why I I caution if two board members are talking it's not a bound act violation but how does it make everybody else feel is there collusion going on why are you talking to that board member

142or Not Another board member it's not a good way to do business for public agency so while it may be legal I don't think it's a good idea I I don't think it's a right approach that's going to get you where you want to be and you'll get a diversion so having laid that out let's take a look at some can I ask sorry absolutely you're passing very detailed legal question make you excited I think um for ab 992 that was passed in 21 it says board council members are prohibited from responding directly to any post or comment that is made by another board member so that suggests the one one V one is well it really well I don't know where you're reading um it's from uh the a a l r r So

143Different yeah I I I don't I would disagree that that's not a brown act violation but it's not a good idea right okay I was just curious that that makes it sound because this was the update based on social media so I wasn't sure if the social media update I don't I don't agree that that's I would not call that a brown act violation but I would it's right definitely not a good idea as you know as elected officials the uh Court of public opinion is critical for you guys and so that's why you really want to stay away with it even if it's not a violation just their appearance of one it's not a good optic right all right let's take a look and and work through some of these hypothetical scenarios board member

144a fames having dinner at a restaurant and board member B approaches at a local restaurant and they share a table together do we have a brown act violation no no okay um doesn't look good but but it's not a brown act violation and there's nothing that says you can't be friends and you can't have each other over for dinner and talk about who's going to play in the Super Bowl or anything else you want talk or yeah know you can you can do that but think about the appearance so what if board memb C shows up can she join the party if it's social yes but if it's an issue then no think but when we're talking about the Optics and the appearance that does put three of us together in a room at a

145table Optics two of us is like the start and then three of us now they could be making a plan to make decisions and let's say someone in the community walks in and you know agree on Optics but just speaking of the letter of for the letter of the law for sure I think the Optics are what I worry about the most because that's where the stories start and that's where the rumors start and that's where we lose like like Lou said The Confidence from people who are starting to yeah have questions what's it look like so what if more member so we don't have I think we can all agree that socially social conversation is not brown act violation but that's an optic issue and whether or not you want to create a a

146problem with the Optics that are occurring but if the board memb see says I'm so glad to run into you guys tonight because there's an issue at the middle school I want to discuss and they proceed to have a discussion we got a brown act violation okay because we're talking about something within the jurisdiction of the board so clearly that's that's a last scenario is a viol violation of the brown act all right hypothetical two board member B reads an interesting article on high school graduation standards throughout the United States board member a sends a copy of the article by mail to the other four board members Brown act violation I vote no not by the letter of the law yep oh I missed that yes that is sorry well I read it the other

147round this is just okay here's some information about high school graduation requirements this is what one school district is doing we not discussing it Mr I'm just sharing information with you about what I read not a brown act violation but it opens that door yeah exactly it potentially that's the key like if I send that to Laura and Laura texts me like great article let's chat then we start let's do that here yeah right right even further o um yeah um if you want if you see interesting articles that you think are helpful send it to the superintendent and say I just read this and I wanted to share it with you and what you think and if she wants to share it with she can go out and send we're not you're not commenting

148back you're certainly not commenting to each other but that's just information sharing okay but again for Optics purposes it's better to send it to the superintendent than to send it to each other okay because what we haven't talked about and I don't want to get deeply into it is under the public records act every email you send to anybody in the world about school business is a public record regardless of where you send it from your District email or your personal email if it's about school business it's discoverable okay um all right so what if board member a emails the article to the other for board members well not a brown act violation but probably not a good idea because of the Optics what if board member a hands the article to superintendent ask she

149plac it on the Friday letter to the board perfectly okay it's not a brown act violation s can share information about the school district with all the board members does it make a difference if the board will consider the adoption of a resolution to modify the higho graduation standards no because you get information from the superintendent Advance a board meeting so you can make informed decisions at your board meetings okay it's not you're just not going to be discussing it among yourselves okay so board member C on our third hypothetical uh calls board member D to ask for board members D opinion on whether or not the board should consider changing an attendance boundary board memb C and D discuss the issue and then board member D calls board member e and discusses the issue

150Brown act violation yeah probably yes probably uh if board member D never shares what board member C said this technically it's not a brown act violation Bo but the Optics not good not good you're you're putting your toe very close to the line and and you want to be far away from it what if board member C instead ask the superintendent to call board members d and e and get their opinions Brown act violation I've been spoke okay if the superintendent doesn't spoke that back out like if she just collects it and doesn't actually release it in theory that would be okay right potentially yeah I think you've got an Optics issue but you may not have a technical Brown act again but we don't want to end up where we were in the bad

151old days okay yeah this is also off topic but is this a good law just like in terms of in terms of how many like potentially it's a brown act violation like shouldn't it be more like clearcut about a situ like this is a California law are are do publics operate in other states like just willing to lay yeah with you know I'd say every state has some version of the brown act okay whether it has been interpreted to the extent of technicalities at California there's another degree question but but you said no one was prosecuted so it's like California it's like a a spectre well they've been prosecuted haven't been convicted oh yeah Seaside city council was prosecuted but the jury didn't convict uhuh I mean it's is a really interesting jur PR Prudence

152question because in some ways the worst written laws are the most fun for legal unless to dig into and and if you have a brown act violation uh the public has a right to make a demand to cure and correct and if you don't cure and correct within 60 days they can bring a lawsuit against you and recover attorney's fees what does Ken correct mean that means within 60 days you go back let's say there was an action taken in close session that should have been an open session okay and they say we demand that you cure and correct this you could re agendize it for Open Session and then have a have the same discussion have the same Mo motion and take the action over again in fact and basically corrective action that happens

153probably more than you think that's typically what happens when somebody accuses a board of a board of a brown act violation sometime the board will say you know what we'll just re agendize it and go through it and do it again it's a lot less expensive than lawsuit and risking attorney's fees um but the real damage is the public loss of public confidence and the accusation and and where I see districts that are in struggling with this it's usually over it's not a brown act violation but the public is up in arms over some controversial subject and this is a way of attacking you for a technical violation rather than the substance issue that they may be unhappy with but again I'm so sorry this is off no but this is why my question about

154whether it's a good law because if it is a controversial issue then the the the threat of the brown act seems to be used as a c or like a threat you know as opposed to it actually being a sub substantive claim so like you are correct I don't I don't know it it seems sort of achieving its its goals maybe but I I think most public agencies are now very sensitive to allegations of brown neck violation sure and make every attempt not to there are a few that are are are a bit Cavalier but that they're very few and very far between because the risks are so high yeah yeah and whether or not it's a good law I leave to it's the law yeah it's the law I I don't make those decisions

155but okay we're now entering the blogosphere parent group in The District parent group operates a Blog about the district all seven board members regularly read what is on the blog is that a B Brown act violation no no no that would be not be what if at least four of the board members post comments or responses on the blog yes we're getting there yeah yeah um what if only one board member post a comment or response on the blog not a brown violation okay if it's a board member's Facebook page with their comments about school matters and other board members rarely visit that page to see what the board member is saying that's not brown act violation going one way it's one way communication it's not two-way communication okay but if you start posting your

156comments and you have a majority of the board posting their comments on that one board member's Facebook you got a bradic violation and would that be the case of any response by three or more liking the comment loving the comment thumbs up to the comment so on So yeah thank you exactly yeah any indication of preference is going to be BR violation okay uh penultimate hypothetical board member D sends an email to the other board members sharing his opinion uh on the School attendance boundary question BR act violation One Way communication one board member to the other not a good idea but not a v Brown act violation okay that opinion should be expressed at the board meeting but it's still not a brown act violation because it's one board member saying this is what

157I think what if the other board member never responds they not a brown act violation right sorry take back to Beth's point it's always kind of in that Purgatory because they could respond a year later yeah or a month later or a week later they could respond but if they never respond it's not a brown act violation do you have a perception issue possibly possibly on the like the Facebook question or page where more than one board memb responding even with a on the Facebook page example more than one board member is responding um and it would seem to be a brown act violation does that mean that those board members have to be um identified what if it's an anonymous comment well what if never get caught I'm commenting on uh we'll use Elliot

158again Elliot's post and and um I don't identify myself as the person who's commenting and then Laura comments but she doesn't know that I commented yeah then it's it's a matter of getting caught uhuh it's a br violation because you're a board member and you're simply masking that okay so you've done it but you haven't disclosed that who you are you still done it okay it's sort of like wearing the mask when you when you rob the bank you're still robbing the [Laughter] bank it wasn't me yeah okay um f uh board member D sends an email to Other Board member sharing his opinion on School attendance boundaries Brown act violation no oneway communication if the other board members never respond not a brown act violation if DS the superintendent send the email Brown act

159violation potentially it makes an issue if it's on the it doesn't make an issue whether or not it's on a future agenda that's irrelevant okay now it could be cured if somebody then claim sheded a a brown act violation you could then put it on a future agenda and have that discussion and that's your cure and correct okay um and then I'm going to go to the last one on the last page ask a quick quick question about cure and correct is the cure and correct discussing the brown act violation in a public setting is that what that is or is it discussing that thank you Laura that's an excellent question yeah it's a great question basically like a public if you get a demand uh uh an accusation of BR and a demand to

160cure and correct you in order to cure and correct you are supposed to say we have an allegation of a brown act violation we are putting this item on the agenda we're to be discussing it publicly and we will never do that again okay and do you name names at that point to say like no you don't you wouldn't say well Elliott violated the brown act and he put me in the situation as president I will take the hits is the expectation to be I mean if it is it is that it's probably good but you have to admit that you violent yeah to say that we've had three board members that violated Brown act and that would narrow it down pretty good you know because only two didn't but I would think at that

161point that and we won't and you have to basically say we'll never do this again never do that again okay yeah yeah I wasn't aware of the last part of it that you have to say you won't no apology if you will yeah acknowledgement and okay yeah besides the allegation is there or of a brown act violation is there like a self-reporting line like I think it's just personal responsibility yeah there isn't a requirement for self-reporting well okay now they're hypothetical yeah so say we're at a birthday we're at a kid's birthday party is it mine is it mine it's my birthday it's OT kids who just celebrated his birthday party at paintball were all at paintball and where you know there's another parent who brings up a topic about some pgusd topic and the

162three of us happen to be there and we talk about it now there are other families out there who see us in public or not public but at the party so they could make an allegation but to kind of jump ahead of it what if you were like we're going to cure and correct this option or go you you don't have a brown act violation but let's say Beth was at that party too and she made the comment and somebody says you violated the brown act you'd have and they send you a demand to cure and correct that's what you would would be responding to then you'd have to go through this process let's say you didn't have a demand and you said I want to get out in front of it so that I

163don't put ourselves I think wouldn't make a confessional about it I would simply put it on the agenda and have that discussion in public session and then act on it and that's what I I've done as a superintendent sometimes I said we're g to pull this item and then bring it back again not necessarily indicating that uh we've been accused of violating the round act or anything but say I'm going to pull it yeah yeah does that answer your question Mike okay I think I can speak from experience when I say there are attorneys who are watching those things um for public agencies like whether or not you're posting your agenda 72 hours ahead of the meeting and it's not because it's a good or bad law but it is a law so for transparency's

164sake like we're supposed to be consistent in how we how we follow the rules and how you know we apply the same rules to ourselves so if there's something that's not predictable or consistent then it kind of just begs more questions so if we say the agenda is up 72 hours before a meeting but it's inconsistent maybe it's 48 maybe it's 36 for me as a concerned Community member I start to wonder well what else are they not really you know being as mindful about or transparent about so it's not necessarily like the actual Brown act you know you didn't get you got 70 hours and not 72 but it's like kind of the questions that could come from like going down that road than you Jen answer good um last hypothetical and this leads

165into the our last topic uh board member gets home late from a board meeting is exhausted wants to crash in bed dropping their materials on the dining table board memb spouse who is high on tidiness picks up the materials in the morning to move them to the board member's desk and sees a report and recommendation regarding a stud an expulsion and out of curiosity reads the report do we have this a brown act violation H well is there potential liability to the district is there potential liability of the board member for sure such material made public yeah because that information is not only protected by fur but it's highly confidential information that only board members have access should have access to not their spouses not their friends not their kids not their neighbors um so

166on the issue of liability which was one of the topics we're going to touch on in the last few minutes under the government Court claims act board members and public employees have 100% protection of liability when they're acting within the course and scope of their employment so anything you do as a collective board and anything that your staff does in the course and scope of the there's personal immunity whether or not there may be liability for the institution there's personal immunity uh and there's a a obligation for the public agency to defend and home hold you harm okay so acting together you've got complete 100% protection acting alone you're on your own so the board member who left the board agenda packet it if that situation happened and I can tell you situations that do

167happen that the board could say we're not going to defend you because you were negligent and you caused us liability or the board could say we we will defend you we'll protect you from that it was an inadvertent error and we're going to protect you from your own NE you have discretion to do that but you have discretion to also deny it um in other districts I've had situations where board members intentionally go out and leak information to somebody maybe to an employee who is subject to discipline maybe just gossip maybe negotiation strategies that were discussed in close session shared with the Union people or just one teacher um that board member is not acting in the course and scope because it's not the course and scope to divulge confidential information and potentially to the

168detriment of the public agency and I've I've seen boards tell colleagues on the board that if we get sued because of your misconduct on this board we're going to turn around and seek Indemnity from you okay that usually gets board members attention but anything you do as a group you're 100% protected from liability okay uh there will not be any personal liability at all with the exception and the sole exception and it would never happen here I am certain there were um boards that intentionally discriminated based on race they were sued and they were found individually liable even though they're acting collectively because it was a racist board okay um so intentional violations of state and federal laws by a board is going to eliminate protection that's not going to happen here uh but any

169within your course and scope if employees or community members or citizens don't like it you are 100% protected from my ability can I ask how that applies to our individual board member comments um because we sit on the dis and we give our comments as a board member but also they as an individual board member stating my experience or myew you or you know how does how does that first amendment versus like District liability excellent excellent question thank you for that um there actually is a separate section in the civil code that any comments you make in a board meeting you are protected from defamation and liability because part of your job is to make public comments as a board but if you were to go out on the street outside of a board member

170board meeting and you said something defamatory or released some conf then you're on your own so what you do together you're protected what you do on your own outside of the meetings that's on you so if a board member left the meeting and said well we got rid of that scoundrel superintendent finally and and that person was a crook from day one that board member is going to be allowable for defamation okay um there's actually a a case yeah let me I was just thank you Bev there's a case Baka versus Board of Education out of this is this woman who was a gadfly in a community and she went to a Schoolboard meeting and she stood up at the board meeting and there was an African-American assistant superintendent who she called an Oreo there

171was a prin uh Elementary School principal this is literally true Elementary School principal she called a child molester and he shouldn't be okay they GED her down she wouldn't sit down they called the sheriff in and had her physically removed from the board meeting and she SU and federal district court said she had a free speech right to say that yes that's she had said the same thing out on the street she could have been sued for defamation saying in a board meeting anything that's said in a public agency meeting or in court is protected from defamation yeah it was outrageous it was an absolutely outrageous case the district chose not to appeal that decision but it this woman was AB just out of control outrageous with that woman was a board member or she

172com she was a citizen and they gabbled her down and they had the sheriff physically remove her from the board meeting and the federal court said she had a right to be there and right to make her comments and and they couldn't those people couldn't sue her for defamation which is why we see some of the behavior that we do see in board members I mean in board meetings it's because they have the right of free speech yeah leis has a question but I'll follow him one more topic I think I clarified this with Carolyn is that I won't stop the rep I won't cut off a mic unless I get direction from President right I can't even take technical action that's right right yeah it's the board president who can control that you can

173hold them to the three minutes but when they when they're up there if it's within your jurisdiction they can talk about it but only for three minutes and another question on that what if I'm acting as board president in line like if I'm at a public meeting representing the board that still counts as yes you're representing the district and you're speaking on behalf even if it's not during a board meeting okay right then I can call people whatever I want right well I don't know about that uh and and one of the roles that you have as board president as you're the spokesperson for the for the any other board member who would speak would be speaking as an individual okay and this three minutes then um once the three minutes is up if the

174president decides that the microphone should be cut then that's okay to cut because it has been do we have a microphone that cuts online I can mute them turn down okay but I think we want to notify people before we take any of those types of steps that their time is up and give them an opportunity to wrap up or not um and then go from there before we're you're a small District but I've SE seen some some boards have a light that goes on green orange red it doesn't yeah formally yeah and some people hold up signs that say you know 20 to 30 seconds you can control that and if you're GNA do it do it uniformly do it consistently the problem districts have is when they don't do it and then all

175of a sudden they start doing it and there's an upset okay so if you have done it for 10 years why are you doing it now or why are you doing it for me okay yeah we don't want the perception that some people's comments are valued more than other people's depending on the perspective so it even may be an opportunity for us to like create a script you know um so that we are Mindful and empathetic but also consistent with how we respond because like Laura was saying this year is going to be I think an emotional year for people and we're going to have to be aware and still be mindful that we have to be levelheaded and making decisions well I think that there's something to be said for like kindness counts too

176abs and so if there is a parent that's up there and they're expressing emotion I mean and somebody else is just you know it's it's they're not affected as D you know as directly affected you know fine kindness counts like letting somebody go over their three minutes because they're sobbing about their child I think it gets tricky because then if we have somebody who's like a person who comes to our meetings often and has comments that maybe aren't we we might view them differently if I was the person who showed up and I was like the commenter who wasn't emotional I would want my stuff to be kind of taken seriously I don't know what the balance is Laura because I feel like there It's Tricky and it's like a case by casee but almost

177we don't want it to Case by case well I was going to say two quick comments on that one is I probably would have a quick recess at that point if it's really going on and they're sobbing I would just say thank you through comments maybe we can have a break so we can do this and then my second point I was gonna say is I remember at one of the cspa presentations they were showing these students like how student voices matter and these students were just saying the most amazing things they got to their three minutes and the board president's like your time is up it's like so like you have this that you know it gave me that respect for the president that even when the students are saying something that everyone wants

178to hear you're holding them to that same standard maybe you say we really love what you're saying but we have to yes oh yeah I know they said it very curtly but I was just remember I was like wow that is I don't know if I would have the foot spot to do that yeah I think that's where the consistency comes in though and even just having a script that you know we talk about and we reshare at the beginning it's that you know reminder that everyone in the room is hearing the same thing um I've seen you do it already already Elliott and you know I remember Brian doing it last last year where you know it was really just I think when we're talking about compassion and kindness you know I'm so sorry

179you know and we we're hearing you you know but really you know your three minutes you know up I think how we do it as well you know can really speak to but I still think it comes back to addressing it and setting out the you know the the protocols and the Norms at the beginning so everyone in the room he it you know at the same time with with those things there's a perception of fairness but it's it's not a legal issue is that right not a legal issue no it's it's a community relationship issue but okay but legally people have a right to to public comment absolutely what about restricting how much time you give people yeah um you that is allowed on the brown act uh that you can set reasonable limits

180I know one board that limits it to two minutes this probably the lowest I I know of and I know the same board that limits it to two um says all public comments whether on or off AG genda topics are going to take place in this you can set the amount of time 20 minute period at the beginning of the meeting and then after that just now they had a problem in that community that problem in the community was the community was so divided and there was a core group that was sabotaging their meeting so they just okay we're gonna give this Core Group 20 minutes of our at the beginning of our meeting they'll have their say and then we're done and we're going to go on to our agenda and no more public

181comment so it's going to be reasonable but it's usually in the context of what's going on in your community three minutes is pretty standard five minutes is the longest I know and two minutes is the shortest I know I've also seen in that situation where you're gonna get 20 minutes where in this is cases where people have to give their a docket to the work and so on and so that's when I see seen I'm going to give my three minutes to so and so that's when I've seen it most often but you can also not only limit individuals you can limit the amount of time total time right so you can say 20 minutes of public comments but I don't know I know a few that do that not a lot we do we

182have a limit for 20 minutes per a public comment per agenda item and then also public comment on on agenda items there's 20 minutes for that as well we have extended it in the past right and I think when there are issues that come up like plann Parenthood or something where we know we're going to be hearing from the community that night it's a discussion topic worth having you know yeah I mean again it just comes back to that consistency is do we want to say we're going to do the 20 minutes and we everyone who's here like we please submit your comments to the you know but it's it is a really tough one and then at that point we vote on it and you know someone makes a motion someone seconds and we

183vote on it if it doesn't pass it doesn't pass you know so I think that night though just referencing when we had we knew we had quite a few there I mean it actually worked well but you know I think Brian did a good job at the beginning of kind of reminding everyone we have 20 minutes total so please you know sort of you know gauge your comments and it really did get to the point you know where if it was everything was being said you know on on one side of things right you know to kind of remind if there's something else that different to what's been said already you know and really kind of putting up to the public a little to of gauge you know how they want to use those remaining

184you know minutes within that 20 minute frame um but yeah I think that worked well that night remember we have come upon the witching hour where would you all like to go at this point home I no what justly what is on the on the items that we proposed i' happy too May Skip and we can save for for next time how about that yes and then really the parking lot items I think we want to maybe just go through what we have on that list and um you know just be sure we've captured everything right for future sessions couple things that I wrote down on my notes on just the parking lot uh that were comments the board members made that I thought you want to revisit one was the handbook uh and the

185revisions of the handbook and the modifications and I think we we've talked about that um the other thing I heard was a discussion of methods of achiev achieving consensus and when consensus is not achieved what do you do how do you handle that and and the review of the top 10 norms those were the three things that I had WR other thoughts comic you think the only other P thank you both the only piece I would like to add to that is I've given you all a copy of the governance core 2.0 book um so it is the most you know sort of current and revised version of the governor's cor 1.0 uh you know recently um you know just revised uh this was actually spoken about and really referenced a lot in the new

186trustey orientation session that I I I attended with both Beth and Mike back in December at csba uh in Anaheim and really the facilitators and presenters for that day took a lot of information from you know this particular book so I would like to propose you know that this is something that really sort of guides some of our sessions in in the coming month um and for our next session if you know everyone doesn't feel it's too much but I really feel as I'm reading through exactly what those you know first sort of 30 pages are in topics it really aligns nicely with the review you're going to be doing of the handbook and you'll probably see as you're going through the handbook it even just the the topics that are in there in the

187in the the index at the beginning it really aligns nicely with the same uh you know titles that you're going to see referenced here um so if everyone is in agreement with that my proposal is uh to you know really read through the introduction politics governance and system uh Improvement and uh the first uh topic one moral imperative and the governance core so essentially Pages 1 to 28 by our next session um and then you know we can really sort of embed you know something in there as far as a discussion and how that's tying into the work that we're doing how does everyone feel about that we the homework though on just the revisions or would you rather save those the homework of the revisions for after we read the 28 pages I think

188we could do them together right I feel that reading this is going to help guide I think some of your revisions that you're going to do in the handbook right I think together right yeah we look at that we're sufficient laur's already found something oh my goodness all right so Pages 1 through 29 will be sort of our homework cover right and then of course yes homework to you know really review the handbook and U present and I'll give sort of a deadline for that maybe a week prior and I'll do reminders in our trusty updates as to when you know we'll want that in um and I think the other piece will be yes we want to identify you know the date for our you know next session um which I will connect with

189mind y so that's that I just want to thank you all for coming tonight with such Open Hearts and Minds uh to really just I think listen to one another and you know receive the information in such a I think insightful and thoughtful Manner and each one of you I'm so grateful for just the input and the feedback you've brought the questions you asked are just you know so how many times did I hear both of you going wow that's an excellent question so again just indicative of so the commitment and dedication you've given to this process Unity of purpose purp I keep coming back to that Unity of purpose and where we started too right we go from I to we without losing me and that's really what this is about right all of

190you really sort of committing to working together as a team uh and coming to an agreement on how you conduct your your business in public right because it starts with us our entire community and district is looking to us for uh for the example we are the models of what we expect uh from everyone down to our students and so it starts with us so just thank you for coming with just such Excellence when it comes to that appreciate you all and appreciate you Eric and L for being alongside Us in this journey and just sharing your wisdom and insight thank you thank you Angela and Lewis for being here tonight as well for getting everything ready we're grateful for you was wonderful L I know keeping us you know on online with the talk

191have a lovely evening of wait

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.