001welcome to the pgusd special school board meeting um where we are going to be in Open session for just a bit before we break to close so I'll go ahead and hand it over to Dr Adamson to call us to order absolutely president Dr Hazen I am here B McNary here trusty otmar I'm here trusty shamas here and trusty wax here perfect and we're going to start with our land acknowledgement I really did that out of order but that's okay um good evening as we begin this meeting it's important to pay respect to and acknowledge that we are on the traditional land of the olone costan and elen people and additionally pay respect to Elders both past and pre present so following on that we now have item D the adoption of the agenda so
002is there anyone in the public that would like to comment on our agenda for today oh yeah I would just like to you know put something out to the board I typically you know we have our school accountability report cards are on consent uh and I think that was definitely an error I in looking at past practice we've always had them on action and so I'm going to propose to the board tonight that we consider pulling that and just making it an action item if nothing else to really just be able to have that opportunity for uh discussion specific you know to those report cards open to comment from the any comment from the board on that if not I'll jump in with one I I agree with that this time I will say I
003I am a fan if there aren't surprises like if we're maintaining Trends if it's similar I am a fan of that sort of you know the SARS going on consent in the future but just want to mention that um but this time I think it is a good idea since that's been the past practice to have it as action good agreed I am good with um with it changing today I do have to say that I I think I would actually prefer it as action just so that we can go over it thoroughly and if there's comments to be made and all that that we're not just sort of one fell swooping it um because there were some things that I wanted to discuss um and if that comes up then each time we're going
004to have to move it off of consent so I think I'd prefer it if moving forward we would have it on action that would be my preference I appreciate it I'll just be honest part of my I'm trying to put as much on consent as possible because of our late meeting so that's why but I I agree and maybe I could introduce a compromise where if we have trusty questions we could make sure it's on action and if we don't we could consider on consent does that sound good okay that's yeah that sounds great and I think I'll just comment too I brought this to um Dr adamson's attention because in Reading previous year's agendas we have had it on action so I didn't want there to be any appearance of us just shoving something
005on consent that we haven't discussed because in past practice we have had them in action and discussed them subst so for transparency purposes for this year and then we can talk about what works moving forward yeah sounds great okay I will start us off with a motion to approve the agenda with the addition or the modification of the sarc to action from consent leaving only the contract with IID Bailey on consent got a second or is there anyone wants to second so move by myself seconded by um trusty wax all in favor please say I I I I None opposed passes 5- Z so with that we are now going to clock out at 5:33 and go into I thank you I will identify the close session item topics before we clock out at 5:3
006something and mentioned there we have five today which are negotiations collective bargaining session planning a prep with pgta for 2425 negotiations collected bargaining with the cssea also for 2425 Public Employee discipline dismissal release leave complaint um conference with legal counsel regarding anticipated litigation and then we also have superintendent goals review last but definitely not least our midyear check-in so I think we will take some public comments on close session topics before we adjourn okay with that we'll adjourn at 5:34 one minute later thanks apologies for the delay but uh lots of important discussions were had and so just to report out on that um negotiations item one with pgta information was received item two um collective bargaining for the CCA I information was also received um item three U Public Employee discipline dismiss or release
007leave complaint information was received Direction was given uh conference with legal council regarding anticipated litigation information was received and then for item five the superintendent goals we no information was received yet but we will be going back to close session afterwards to do that so with that we are now onto the Pledge of Allegiance and since Laura was so kind to volunteer she will be leading us today thank you so much for volun holding um and then we move on now to the consent agenda which is uh item four for those following along and we did agree that we were going to pull item a to information discussion the sarks so that will be coming up in a bit but we're just dealing with one consent agenda item the item B the contract for services
008with I Bailey so with that we have a time for public comment on Item B on consent okay not online board any comments on Item B or questions okay with that we can take a motion to approve consent as presented I'll move that we approve the contract for services with Ed Bailey LLP just a no I think we approve the consent as a whole right technically doing but that isn't even it's the only item on consent I think right is that correct yeah yes I got something right once that we approve the consent agenda as presented I'll second thank you so that motion was made by truste shamas and seconded by truste McNary all in favor please say I any opposed not that passes 5 Z for consent and so now we have item a
009the Sark School accountability report cards for information disc discussion I'll call that item AAA Three A's just to make it safe good point rather than information discussion and then we will be moving to the budget study session after that all right um good evening trustees Larry hagquist executive director of Educational Services here to present the school accountability report cards for the 2023 2024 Academic Year uh the purpose of my presentation tonight is to seek board approval to post the sarks that you see in the board packet to the pgusd website as well as the California Department of Education website by the required date of February 1st the sarks are important documents that help the public anybody who wants information about our schools can access these sarks uh via the CDE website and or Pacific Grove
010unified website we have SARS on our websites dating back all the way to the 2001 2002 school year and this will be added to that uh to that um before February 1 um pending board approval um how are the sarks compiled uh I think it's important to note that all 103 pages of sarc documents that you see in the board packet tonight um require a team effort to put together uh we have the site admin uh edtech department hrot and uh PE staff as well uh contributing to um what you see in the board packet the site admin are responsible for writing the narrative sections the paragraphs uh about the schools edte uh provides the seabeds information the California um basic educational uh data system information uh HR provides Staffing information mot provides the fits
011uh also that's just short for facilities inspection tool what you see in the sarc document is just a real abbreviated version of a much larger document that's contained in the fit reports uh and the uh the PE staff provide information about physical fitness test um the five elements of the physical fitness test um they provide to me and uh I help to compile the SARS um what is included uh lots of information uh everything you need to know about uh the schools you've got demographic information uh School achievement data which matches the data that I presented at the November uh board meeting about um the Casp class size information school safety dashboard metrics Staffing salaries um all of this information is housed in one place and uh not only is it helpful for the public
012who wants to learn about the schools for parents who want to make decisions about where they want to send their schools every Public School in California has to provide the same information and make it public uh but it's also a helpful tool internally I know that when I was working as a tosa and an administrator at the high school uh putting together the wasque report or the accreditation report uh this was the sarc reports were um some of my most frequently visited reports it's really nice to be able to have all that data in one place I also know that the sipsas or the school plans for student achievement uh contain some of the same information here so the information provided in the sarks uh really it's a very very helpful planning tool it's helpful
013for like I just mentioned the sipsas the lcap um to help um build alignment throughout the district and make sure that our our numbers and uh the data coordinate uh and that we have proper alignment so that's really a little bit about the sarc reports that you see in the board packet uh and once again what I'm seeking tonight is simply board approval so that I can do what uh every school district needs to do by February 1st and that is post them to the district website as well as the CDE website happy to answer any questions that I can um about these um and thank you very much great and um thank you for that excellent presentation Dr Heist any comments from the public okay not online I think we're going to go start
014at the end come towards me if that's okay with you trusty W I actually don't have any questions at this time but uh wait no I revise it um are there any metrics or like data points that you think I know it's not required by the state but that doesn't kind of um capture the full picture of pgusd or that you'd like to see not that doesn't capture the full picture of pgusd I think that um there are some metrics that we want to focus Fus on I I know something that I've talked about in our last meeting was The Chronic absenteeism metric which is available there and it's it's it's helpful to be able to look back at prior years and and see Trends and and things like that um so this came first
015before lcap correct so I'm pretty you're saying that that remember this I remember when the state said we all had to do oh yeah absolutely lcap didn't 201 yeah these these things go like all the way back to you know early 2000s lcap didn't come until I think around 2015 right so just to I'm just reiterating kind of what you said just to kind of for the public to understand that that this was is a state requirement um longstanding but that like you said it it informs the lcap and absolutely the schools um their own plans um so um it is an important document and um it's foundational absolutely it's a lot like you know teachers use student data to make decisions uh around instruction um and to to provide um uh intervention and support
016uh in attempts to improve metrics and so these are the Baseline these provide some baseline metrics where we can say hey we need to improve in this area we need to implement a plan so uh what we're trying to do in our district is make sure that all of our plans have alignment and they coordinate and you know our core values are very have been very very helpful in uh assisting with that alignment and I was able to speak to that a little bit at the city council meeting on Monday good and also um the Personnel that put have to input all this data it's it's time consuming yeah yes uh there is a lot of data in here fortunately we do have a system called DTS or doc tracking Services um that is they're
017able to um extract a lot of the data uh that is uh uploaded via ceds uh to help us with that process but there is definitely some and when do you start on this for uh we started in December thank you thank you for this um my question is I know that you had mentioned chronic absenteeism um my assumption is that you that we're going through this data and looking at areas that we've kind of dropped off and that will be our Focus um some of the things I was seeing was um in the district our percentage went down to 84.2 n% for fully credential teachers for subject and student placement um from let's see that that is that regarding chronic absenteeism or that's uh teacher I'm sorry that was 2021 maybe I misread it
018nope I take it back I think I just misread it so thank you yeah we do that look for some alarming figures or things like that that like jump out uh and and use those as U maybe potential growth areas for plans that we're creating thank you very much um I think your presentation answered all of my questions kind of about the purpose of the sarc and its role and I think even more so like our role and what we're doing we're kind of just reviewing the information and that's about it at this point okay I feel more comfortable then and I love that we're using it as a tool to align all of our goals and our cultural values and thank you for bringing that with everything that you do Dr Adamson um and
019thank you for presenting us this evening Absolutely I'll just ask add one minor question to you I noticed for I think it was science um the school numbers were particularly low I don't know if that's just due to there were dashes in 2022 23 and then low number 23 24 by the district was quite are you talking about achievement data cor the CP test results in science for stud oh yeah so what there I mean not as many tests given in 20 so there was a switch where we went at and this is the high school the 11th graders that they used to take an 11th and 12th grade and we made a switch to make it just 11th grade so that may that's the 10 or fewer dashes okay that's great and the other
020thing I'll just say is I know we heard that other districts do not have sharks in their action item necessarily so there something I'd propose for the board that when there's updates we that are outside of the norm we'd love to have it but you know we consider putting on a consent where there's no big surprises and there's no questions from the trust forward can I share a little bit about my perspective on I would love that actually yeah C for that reason the action item is a little bit anxiety-provoking from my end because there's just SO3 Pages worth of data so I'm I was a little bit concerned that I'm like are they G to ask me about a data point that I don't recall after reviewing them um and I I know that
021that's not the goal um with the action item but I do think that as an informative piece it's a good action item because it just reminds people every year that um the purpose behind uh the the reports and its value with respect to all of the other things that we're doing justess Mar you have something that you wanted to add it was just a question well now I'm gonna ask you about a data point um it was it was actually just curiosity is um with science by student group I just noticed that female has all dashes is it just that we don't report that that the student groups are reported together both male and female I'll have to look into yeah I just note it just stood out to me as as well as like
022Hispanic or Latino two or more races White English Learners so yeah it they're all listed but I'm guessing that all the information was just included under all students but it's all students and maale are the only ones that have numbers yeah the double dashes represent When there's less than 10 students per category so if you know Noti that all students is 16 so I think once you start dividing 16 you get below 10 and then you have to so there's not 10 females that took not in the it was just yeah because only it say only 15 students were tested so out of that 15 right guessing so the remainder of that 12 were male that means three must have been female three were female that's interesting that doesn't seem um like a lot yeah
023yeah that does okay think that brings another question but I'll let it go that's where I was going with it as you were saying that you know I'm trusty atar is I think the great thing about this it does it allows because of the way that it's that's you know disaggregated the data it it gives us a sense of you know do we have enough you know is there equity and you looking we're looking at it by gender or student group of you know number of students represented right it doesn't look like it so that's something that I would like to make sure that we're paying attention to that there's more than three females that are be being tested um yeah in science so thank you I think that was specifically was that for the
024AP students right or was it yeah just yeah I think definitely we'll we'll take a look at that because the numbers do seem you a little low with it and it'll be something that we you know we'll look into a little further so thanks for bringing that to our attention but it looks like I me there were only 16 students enrolled of which 15 were tested so we're not under testing there's just not many students enrolled in the course that's being tested I EX yeah I suppose my point would be then maybe perhaps we could focus on um females and Hispanics yeah Hispanic or Latino students or um you know multi-racial students that could be you know we could support them a little bit more that's a different topic but thank you for the information
025okay I think with that um so as an action item now we do have public board discussion and a motion so any public comment on the SARS as presented by Dr heckit we did our board discussion again sorry about that before a little bit before but then um I would go ahead and make a motion that we approve the school accountability report cards as presented I'll second motion made by myself and seconded by trusty otmar all in favor I I any opposed um I I'm not opposed but I just before I say yes I would I would push back a little on this being on the consent because obviously questions do arise with this and so you know it's just a matter of how you manage that particular meeting um so it can be done
026in a way that um doesn't have to take up too much time but but still highlights some some items that board members really want to talk about or the public but Point well noted yeah we had more much more discussion than I was expecting which is a good thing yeah I appreciate that so yes okay so how would your vote be that was an i yes okay good okay so does pass Five Z as well so with that I don't I don't think I G do i g on since we're going special or do we just migrate over with my gavel in hand explain what we do okay so we're going to be doing information discussion on the 2526 uh budget given past pres many past presentations and detailed presentations by Josh but um now
027we're going to just the administration is recommending we receive information discuss it um with opportunity for public to make comments at the end as well right okay thank you e e L has to get the slide deck up uh before we get started before the slide deck is put up I just like to acknowledge that uh we have the entire cabinet here tonight uh this is a collaborative discussion with our cabinet as well as our uh fiscal officer Karly Adams is with us here this evening uh to support in this presentation very happy to have everyone here at the table and everyone's input is certainly very important and valid uh we will get that put up all right next slide leis all right so tonight in preparation for our 25 26 budget development uh I'm
028going to focus on three areas for our board and our community who's listening in number one we're going to review the district's budgetary constraints prior to the 25 26 budget development we're going to discuss restricted program funding that pgusd has been fortunate to have in Prior years uh and what we already and those that those uh resources that have already Sunset prior to the end of 2425 second we're going to review the district's historical enrollment uh ratios and those related to Staffing during this area of focus we will look to strategize with the board uh on our state of declining enrollment and the district's desire to align Staffing with projected student enrollment and third the uh the final area of focus will be the district's multi-year deficit spending Trends we're going to focus on areas
029where pgusd can reduce the unrestricted general fund expenditures and further impact uh to expiring resources on the multi-year projections we will go ahead and get started tonight with taking a look at the district financials at first interim reporting which is our financials through October 31st 2024 this was recently presented at the uh December board meeting but it's a snapshot of uh where we stand this evening pgusd has a combined deficit of just over 2.9 Million this is broken down by restricted and unrestricted you can see that up there uh our restricted deficit is just over 2 million uh 2,68 175 and our unrestricted deficit is currently at 86848 pgusd has combined revenues of uh just over 46.4 million and this breaks down in the following ways I'm going to get into much further detail tonight
030related to what lcff sources are federal sources and state sources but you can see the breakdown there in our in our breakdown of Revenue predominantly associated with lcff sources which is uh where our property tax revenue lives just a quick highlight there just over 85% of all revenue in this district is tied to property taxes it's substantial tonight as we Pro progress through the uh the presentation I'll refer back to these Revenue sources next slide so just like we reviewed current revenues uh we must identify the current state of our expenditures at first interim you'll see on the slide at first interim we had just under $49 million in expenditures projected for the 2425 school year one area to note over 87% of our overall expens expenditures are tied to salary and Health and Welfare
031for our employee groups this is over 7% higher than the state average with comparable leas local educational agencies we'll be looking tonight at some fiscal Trends in our state and locally state and federal revenue are trending downward with the expiration of onetime and restricted resources and our Revenue fortunately is trending upward as it relates to lcff a local control finding formula and local revenues this is predominantly our property taxes and then we do have state categorical programs which we'll focus uh in more depth on as we progress to the slide deck I will focus heavily tonight on the state and federal revenues that are trending downward and how this impacts the overall fiscal health of the district next slide here we're looking at some uh key budget assumptions we're going to start off with our
032uh estimated local control funding formula base in property taxes this does come directly out of the multi-year projections that I project uh that I present to the board at first and second interim as well as when we do uh October revision and budget revision on the CH top chart we'll see only Revenue limit sources the revenue limit sources are made up of all sources noted in lines starting with lcff current year excuse me this is a base allocation for BG USD which we receive per Ada in summary the lcff current year base is the state's contribution particularly in the form of supplemental and concentration grants some other lines to highlight are the uh secure and unsecure tax role which you will see there uh this is our local property taxes you can see the trend
033in the revenue limit sources from 2122 through 2425 the district had a net increase of just over six million this is an average of around 1.5 million year-over-year and around 5% of new revenue and you can see each one of those columns 21 22 22 23 23 24 those are all un audited actuals and being that were at first interim I'm showing you the the uh Revenue projections at first interim there uh also note that we do carry forward uh assumptions which is the very next column there 20 uh 2025 and 26 and 2026 27 uh those are for our multi-year projections and we always carry forward around a 5.5% um uh increase over prior fiscal year of projected property tax revenue next we can break down the federal revenue sources that's the next chart
034uh down below the biggest takeaway from this slide is the reduction of f revenue from 2122 through 2425 which is just over 1.1 million you'll see that the district's primary loss of federal revenue is noted in all other Revenue line that's toward the bottom excuse me uh we do not project in 2425 and the myps the federal revenue assumptions because they're nearly onethird of the revenue received in Prior years we will highlight on future slides the breakdown of this revenue and how it has been tied to program expenditures and I will take a pause there for questions before we move forward quick question just because we covered it recently but the the um the diminishment I thought it was of lcff that we're going to be getting this year because of the High School attendance
035days is that reflected on it is okay great question uh you will you would actually see that in the 2526 multi-year projection there in the Top Line uh of 2,505 456 that is correct the district will receive around $140,000 ction in our lcff base but that was not reported at first interim where this data was captured a great question thank you trying to keep track of all the like up and down lot numbers yeah so that Revenue will be reduced by just over the $140,000 which is associated with the um the uh lack of instructional minutes or the deficiency of instructional minutes at the high school last year in 20 324 yes uh going back a pay or not a statistic or anything but um the other districts that we compare ourselves to in terms
036of uh budget and that sort of thing what are they and how many are there okay so we have we have six comparable districts in our County however there's only one comparable District fiscally to ours in our County which is Carmel because they are a basic Aid school district there are other basic Aid school school districts in the state of California um what I will say is that uh this school district's assess valuation and property tax revenue Trends much much lower than many of those other basic Aid districts in fact it's lower than most if not all uh and that's related to some other topics I'll talk about tonight uh as it relates to our assess valuation how the how the district receives its property taxes and why our district because of Prop 13 kind
037of has a about a 60% cap on property tax receipts that we receive I'll get into that in further detail I have a question on that same topic about comparable leas you threw out a statistic and I tried to write it down but I wasn't fast enough about us being I think 7% higher can you say that again and explain it so I can right so um this district is at um I think I have a 87% or 88% it's 87 to 88% of our overall expenditures it actually is trended down or tied to salary and benefits which is around 7% higher than most districts and other leas not only comparable leas most districts carry around 79 to 81% of their total expenditures and Health and Welfare and salary and benefits thank you that's clear
038now I appreciate the response would that be Carmel is carmel's the same as ours they're lower okay next slide um this now we're taking a look at our estimated state revenue and categoric res resource ources this is a a big table right there's a lot to look at there um we do need to highlight that the state categorical revenues are are similar uh similar to those already presented at first interim uh the takeaway from this chart is that all of the blank cells begin in 2023 24 and 24 25 you can see as you move across there's a lot of blank cells there where we once had Revenue we do not have Revenue moving forward um it's around $1 million in loss and ongoing state revenue cumulative and uh we will be taking a deeper
039dive I'm just kind of setting us up for the deeper dive later when we're when I'm showing you these because these are part of the multi-year projections um myself and and uh fiscal officer Carly Adams will break down the all other state restricted revenue and the all other unrestricted revenues by reviewing the board uh exhibits A and B that were in your packet we're not doing that yet but to go into further detail we'll get to that later in the slide deck next slide all right so here we're looking at our ated local Revenue um the last summary slide of course covered estimated local revenue for pgusd local revenue is breaken broken down as noted in lines uh in the lines in this chart the largest reduction of revenues comes from Sala which is a
040special education local planning area which is uh Revenue received from our County selpa you can see at the bottom pgusd has two years of increase revenue and the 2425 year has sort of resettled to the revenue amount shown in 2122 and you can see that by looking at the bottom there so in 2122 we were just over 2.6 million in local Revenue now we're at just over 2.6 million in local Revenue you can see that or sorry 2.8 million in local Revenue but you'll see in the multi-year projections it's kind of trending flat so we did have a bubble of Revenue in the 23 2223 fiscal year and 23 24 and now we've sort of resettled next slide can I ask you a quick question on that one sorry I'll try not to how did
041we get $86 on personal tax I did not think we had partial taxes on our district yeah from 2021 that's a great question because we don't have parcel taxes um it might be an error in reporting from 2122 okay I mean that would be something hopefully we can discuss in terms of what partial taxes could look like if they were put on right that'll be I also highlight on this slide you can see sale of equipment um that's an error also in the first inter reporting which will be uh which will be resolved at second inter report which we bring forward in March so there wasn't 33297 in in in sale equipment but that was what was reported at first interim it will be revised at second interim Josh is line uh 8699 or no
04280 well the uh special education SL Dawn I don't know what that is um donations donations so is special education dependent on some sort of enrollment or that is uh basically how that Revenue gathered yeah so you have so there's two lines there we have other local Revenue restricted and unrestricted if we're looking at the 3,439 and 283 940 um you can see that it has trended kind of well it the unrestricted side jumped heavily from 2122 up to 2425 um and I would have to get back to you on the specifics of that breakdown um one area to note is if you look at the selfa funding we have been trending downward in the Sala funding and that's really a highlight in the local Revenue assumptions for this year and trending forward into the
043multi projections we're still trending at just over 1.2 million so uh revenue is in decline in that area and I will talk a little bit more when we get into the unrestricted expenditure side our unrestricted contribution from the general fund that goes towards special education and how much higher that is over year over-year once we get to that slide slide uh so this is a kind of a breakdown of the understanding of new Revenue new property tax revenue when we look at uh year-over-year I mentioned earlier that this District on average realizes around 5% new property tax revenue from the property taxes derived in our local boundary area I like to use this as an example of the uh of new Revenue calculation which highlights the following things number one pgusd only realizes around 1.5%
044of new Revenue above the cost of doing business buiness year over year that's what's highlighted at the bottom of 2425 and 2526 the new revenue is necessary to cover items such as step and column which is the natural movement across the salary schedule for our employee groups increase to the cost of employee State pensions such as stir and purs then that's associated with step and colum movement of our employee groups only so that's not an indication of an increase to stir and purs it's simply the step and call of movement increases salaries therefore stir and purs is increased associated with that step and column movement also the increas goods and services utilities which is driven in part by the increasing cost of the consumer pricing index and I give you kind of a example of
045that percentage for this year uh construction cost index and various other Rising variables contribute to the increased to good increased cost of goods and services on average Pacific gr unified receives around 1.5% in new property tax revenue that can be used for the following things employee unit bargaining negotiations increased our statutory obligation to stir and purs so for example right now stir and perss is sitting at um stirs is at 19.1% hers is sitting at uh 27.3% uh there is an increase uh projected in the school Services dartboard associated with a stirs increase of 35% a lot of numbers there what I'm trying to what I'm trying to suggest here is that that is not factored in to new Revenue it's not um if I put that number up 3% of our total expenditures associated
046with our purs our classified staff uh it would take away a couple $100,000 more of that 1.5% bottom line so the summary of this slide is simply that property tax revenue is dramatically reduced by the simple cost of doing business year over-year and I'll pause right there for questions correct sorry next SL so now that we've given some general highlights of Revenue assumptions and makeup I want to shift our Focus to expenditure assumptions for the 2526 fiscal year some key points to consider R any potential salary and benefit changes the district has not reached an agreement on salary benefits with our employee groups pgusd as a basic a district does not receive a general Cola or cost of living adjustment uh that we could pass along to our employee groups in the form of an
047increased salary increased to salary or Health and Welfare um one area to be focused on as a goal or priority to our board and employee groups is trying to align District Health and Welfare contribution which I will refer to as our cap to the Mig po60 annual plan that's something that we've discussed with our groups essentially trying to get the district contribution up to a level where our employee groups can have an insurance policy that is fully covered by the district that's one of our goals and prior years it was a lower plan it was a PO 40 we're aspiring to get the PO 60 now last year the bargain units did make Headway associated with Health and Welfare cap and the unfortunate reality of the double digit increase to Health and Welfare premiums has
048put us in the situation that we are in this year which is rising costs of Health Care in the district's cap was not enough to meet those uh increases the districts per employee or or employee plus family cap is listed below you can see that in the chart on the bottom pgusd and our Burg units have been trying to keep up with the ever ever increasing increasing cost of healthc care in our area and you can see the district contribution per employee group is listed below just a quick example pgta for 2425 the district contribution for an employee is 10,200 employee plus family is 14,820 and you can see across employee groups uh how that fleshes out from our cssea group confidential group and our Management Group um I'd like to make a note of
049MiG a lot of folks aren't quite sure exactly if they're our insurer or they're our insurance provider um to give you just a kind of a breakdown of what mix Sig is and what they do the municipalities college and schools Insurance Group is a joint Powers Authority that was formed in 1982 to establish and maintain health benefit programs and share pool pool risk sharing as well as shared expenses for Health Management for its members so it's a joint Powers Authority where they basically go to the open market and they're trying to buy insurance for our group which is not just specific of unified or even the the 24 districts in moner County it expands Beyond um mck Sig oversees the the Health and Welfare portfolio for uh for where we had a 2024 one-time assessment
050to our members based on a 200% increase in claims this year the district share of that was 20987 to you see that in the note there in the bot them um the increase to health and W welfare premiums would be passed on to the employee groups in rate increases but pgusd like all leas in Mig absorb the increase without a negotiated or increased settlement to Health and Welfare this was a one-time payment to Mig but it's indicative of the double digigit rate hike projected for the 2526 year we don't have current projected rates for the 2526 year but they are trending higher than this year which was 12.47% just just a to quick questions are those percentages compounding is it 12.47 and then 15.6 more but because of the onetime playment is the 15.6 on
051top of the original amount and then I have a second quick question it is well it's compounding so rates went up 12.47% this year which we uh contributed onetime payment plus the one-time payments which if you want if you want to look at it that way from our District's employee groups it's around a h half a percent right um so the so that the employee groups um rate may have went up to 12.9 seven right if they had factored in the claims correctly and then they'll do a reassessment and they'll reestablish rates in June and July for open enrollment in the following year and I have an understanding uh that those rates are probably going to be similar or not or potentially higher than the rate increase this year okay and then the second question
052just minutia but the 209 872 payment which fund does that come out of because I've not seen that before yeah it's something that actually has not happened before um it was a surprise so just to get into the detail on that if I can um just like our school district makes we we develop a budget which is based on projections right they develop a budget Mig does based on projected claims and within the first quarter of the year the claims were so high that not only were they in excess of the projected payout of claim amounts um they dipped into the entire the entire reserves that Mig had to cover those increases to the point where they had to come go out to their member group and ask for a one-time assessment and every single
053School District in this County as well as um I know every District in our County um had their Prat a share ours was much lower than many uh but they all had to make that payment to continue to maintain solvency within Mig for this year so which item are we going to end up paying is going to be out unrestricted restricted it was paid for unrestricted this might not be um gerain to this but just for people people listening there are limited options for mix Zig Alternatives in our in our area is that correct there are three options and the district is evaluating all three options as we speak in fact we have some really good data that payroll brought in just this week on one of the other Alternatives we have to I'm going
054to say to Mig remember Mig is a joint Powers Authority right so they buy Blue Cross of California or California's value so there's California's value trust there's also pers which we also know as a retirement system there's also a Pur um a program for Health and Welfare benefits so we're evaluating all three California value trust CVT Mig and pers right now to determine what's what's in the best interest of this District moving forward um the assessment that we're doing will be brought forward to our employee groups as well and then the district has to make a determination by uh June as to whether or not we stay with Mig or we move to one of the other insurance provider groups uh which would take place in January of 2026 so we not we would notify
055Mig in June if we decide to opt out for movement into a new provider in January of 2026 which is open enrollment thanks slide 10 so now we've given some general context on the district expenditures let's shift our attention to salaries on the chart you can see that pgusd certificated salaries which include Administration certificated admin have been increasing year-over-year you will notice the small dip in 2425 which reflects some of the efforts made by the board to include the serp and uh by our business office to reduce vacancies held in the budget let me be clear about that um we have tried to reduce the amount of vacancies that are realized as expenditures in our budget until those vacancies are realize so you reduce the number of vacancies in the budget it reduces your expenditures
056that doesn't mean we're eliminating positions it just means we're not carrying those vacancies in the budget therefore potentially hyperin lating expenditures so please note in the multi-year projections the district is only picking up the increase associated with step and column um there's no projection built in for 2526 or 2627 for negotiated settlement with our employee groups you can see in the 2526 uh column you'll see the highlighted green 1.62% and then all the way down uh that is our increase to step and colum percentage and that's how we build our multi-year projections next slide sorry regarding the vacancies who makes those decisions on what vacancies get eliminated and which ones you retain yeah sure it's a joint conversation between the business office and Human Resources uh if we've been carrying a vacancy forward year to
057year to year right then we know it's time to fold the vacancy in and remove that as an expenditure um if we're having trouble filling a position even during this the you know the current fiscal year we've advertised for a position we continue to advertise for a position we're not getting any qualified candidates at interim first interim second interim or our um October budget revision we may reduce the vacancy out again to not carry forward those expenditures that doesn't mean that we can't make a revision again we can if we end up filling the position we'll still fly for the positions but we're not carrying those expenditures and again I use the term hyperinflated but it can be looked at is you're carrying money forward in the budget that's an expenditure that's not being realized
058so we're trying to reduce that let try to be more realistic around what our budget really is welcome I I apologize we can't it we we have to wait till the end for comment I really apologize it's not personal but it's the structure of how the special meeting news I had that question too okay uh I was curious about why uh these aren't why there's there are no numbers in 22 through 24 through 25 basically for the substitutes and it's getting rolled into people support I think they rolled up into 1200 and 20 they rolled up into the 1200s sorry that's pupil support restricted pupil pupil support unrestricted and then the hourly that all rolls up into the 1100s right so if you have a teacher who who has a salary and they do hourly
059on top of it it rolls up into the 1100 at the top line so your restricted unrestricted teachers line it's all rolling up into those numbers did you want to comment Carly okay she's nodding in approval okay all right slide 11 now we're going to take a look at our classified salaries by object in the chart you can see generally that pgusd classified salaries um which include Administration as well as confidential staff have been increasing year-over-year there's been a larger shift in the expenditures and classified salaries uh primarily due to the increased classified support at school sites such as new Duty crossing guards instructional assistance and Par professionals also it's important to note that the district has been shifting expenditures that have been sunsetting from restricted resources back to the unrestricted general fund so that's
060also something you're seeing here um you will note that in the multi-year projections U that only that reflects just over 9.5 million in classified salaries for 26 27 and then just like the the prior slide uh we have a column there for step and column movement but there is no projection for negotiated settlements with our employee groups U our classified employee groups either next slide we're going to take a look at the federal and state budget impacts the district's beginning the process of the 2526 budget development this month to do so the district must consider not only our increase year-over-year as a basic a district and property taxes but also how the state and federal revenue projections impact programs Governor nome's budget was just released and the district has not dove into it uh the
061project to to determine projected Cuts uh or expansion of program I will bring this item forward to the board in February it's a regular item we bring to the for to the board in February prior to um bringing it Forward again in the May revision uh for now it does seem like in the governor's budget there is a projected funded cost of living adjustment a cola of 2.43% the cola will only be applied to certain programs the PG receives revenue on I'll just give you one example the universal meals program not every categorical program funded that the district receives state revenue on receives a cola the col is only applied to certain categorical programs so we will keep an eye on the on the governor's budget uh as it's evaluated and as it progresses through
062the legislative process pgusd receives Federal funding through Title One and title two but is out in the previous slides our federal revenue has been in Decline over the past two years much of the one-time restricted Revenue that was tied to covid-19 pandemic has sunset uh ongoing Revenue s oh sorry excuse me has Sunset moving forward uh in this presentation tonight we will discuss in more detail what are one-time versus ongoing Revenue sources and how they can IMPACT Program when fund sunset with all of the one-time revenue generated from both federal and state maintaining sustainable programs without a large impact to the unrestricted general fund can and will be challenging the board and district has already taken some actions to buffer the loss in Revenue but the 2526 budget year is an anomaly and some and
063some more difficult decisions must be considered by the board and District administration moving forward next slide so here we'll take a look at the one-time versus ongoing funding and short one-time restricted funding can I ask you a quick one on the state budget um I tried to review the csba briefing on the government budget that happened they were saying that like there was a proposal to hold off prop 98 yeah would that AFF affect us as non lcff you sure say how would that affect us if they basically due to uncertainty in the election um transition cor it could affect it could affect the it could affect the cola percentage tied to categorical funding it could affect the uh potential categorical programs that are unfunded through moving forward so for example um pop 28 which
064was the music arts program funding that could be affected right now that is an ongoing categorical Revenue stream not uh set to Sunset but if the prop 98 guarantee is not met those there would be program Cuts uh we just don't know what they are yet can I ask a question about um the positions that were created with one-time funds do we have an idea of the number on the certificated and the classified side of just what those jobs were that were created not necessarily what may be being examined for to reduce do we have an idea we do I'm going to cover that in detail it's okay and and I think it's like three slides from now great yeah I'm just kind of teeing you up for the understanding so um so what's much
065of the onetime funding that pgusd received uh was was to address the following items learning loss mitigation health and safety protocols technology and connectivity mental health and social emotional support Extended Learning Time and summer programs teacher staff teacher and staff support and facility upgrades and I will pause there uh if uh Dr hagquist or chief rogman wanted to kind of expand upon that topic for us if you'd like CER an an example I served as a tosa for two years um and uh my role was uh under that learning loss U mitigation and support um we were uh using tracking data and tracking students to see uh how the learning was being affected and trying to implement programs to uh mitigate the loss that was happening uh within our district and across the state uh
066we had programs like ather G Improvement that came from these types of funds and um so a lot of what I was doing a couple years ago was part of that and we got eliminated uh that position that I formerly held right when the co money came forward a large focus of that Co money was uh for the district to address the learning loss that uh you know had occurred while uh students were home doing distance learning and so um where the district made the largest contribution to uh try to address that learning loss was in hiring um additional people to try to increase the amount of small group instruction that could be done sometimes that meant uh an increase to the hours of an instructional Aid so that that Aid could be present more
067often in a classroom to be able to assist with that small the small group instruction um also uh some of those funds were spent to uh fund an additional intervention teacher as well as an intervention Aid because we knew that the number of students that would require reading intervention at the lower grades was going to be greater and so with that in inlux of funds those uh temporary uh jobs were um hired for us to be able to address that um another you know example of that expenditure was we understood um you know the mental health needs of our children as they returned from Co and so we brought uh so we uh brought on board the uh mental health the therapists um during the co times there was one at the high school and
068one serving both of the elementary schools and and then uh this year we also added one at the mid Middle School the funding for those positions expired at the end of last year so all of those three positions have been absorbed by the general fund and I hope I'm not stealing your message perfect now and I mean we will we'll address those as examples as we move forward um so as of 2425 all of the related onetime funding is now gone and much of the funding still carries expenditures the district must address in this fiscal year to do so could mean the reduction of program expenditures or encroachment on the unrestricted general fund these are things we're here to talk about tonight ongoing funding however of our so I'm going to move on ongoing funding
069however of our resources we we can count on year-to year uh there still may be reductions to these resources but uh much of those state and federal ongoing non- onetime uh funding sources are still being realized by leas Dr Hazen brought up a question just a few minutes ago as it relates to C C orical funding we plan to receive that Revenue with as an ongoing Revenue Source because it was an approved ongoing categorical program that doesn't necessarily mean we will that's why we have to monitor the state of the budget when the budget is released the May revise and when the budget is adopted not all ongoing funding as I mentioned before comes with a Col attached to it and therefore again the district needs to make decisions regarding the increased cost of programs
070tied to ongoing funding without a cola next slide so here we go we were just talking about this um just going to show you a couple of examples of one-time funded resources that uh the revenue was tied to uh offset expense we have first and foremost at the top we're talking about Esser that's the elementary and secondary school emergency relief act uh the district realized just over $2.3 million in revenue and as you can see the revenue was offset with expenditures of the same amount that's what you're supposed to do with restricted Revenue you budget you budget for the exact amount received so revenue and expense off the offset uh pgusd utilized Esser uh for some positions that Chief Rogan just brought up um I have I have FTE on one side that's full-time equivalent
071so that may not be a full individual it may be a fraction of a of a person's position or an increase to ours so the Esser funding added two resource teachers which were partially funded the rsps at so half an FTE if you break that down to each of those the two TOA positions that uh Dr hagquist just mentioned that the district uh brought on board that was funded through through Esser there was an increase to six Elementary instructional assistance uh fractional FTE they they total to 1.38 but basically to increase those hours to address learning loss and provide for smaller group instruction at the elementary level the 2.0 uh which was to mental health therapists another item that another resource the district used was the learning recovery emergency block grant uh that was to
072fund one fulltime time intervention teacher and one halftime instructional assistant now that we covered that data I'll take a quick pause for questions another one is there a hope for a new emergency block grant coming in the there's no there's these are the one-time restricted resources yeah I just wasn't sure if there was some potential for more learning recovery to be passed and again I kind of default back to let's see where the governor I mean we've seen a summi of kind of a summi of uh release of the governor's budget but not details yet I just looked into it today and through school services and there's just not enough there to find out what categoricals are being funded what the coal is attached are and if there's new categoricals on the horizon or grants
073available to our district um thank you for asking that Elliot because that was going to be my question too is what's on the horizon um and as far as just clarification of which positions have been absorbed by the district you said that um two mental health therapists and have the rest gone away then yeah so Ellie Lewis next slide so this is what we're looking at so the impact of the unrestricted general fund with the positions that were retained so those positions that were shown on the previous slide these are the ones that were retained the others did go away right so the 1.38 instruction six instructional assistance the increase to the hours that was shifted into the general fund the 2.0 U two mental health therapists you can see 31,5 43 was shifted into
074the unrestricted general fund and one mental health therapist was added at the middle school that wasn't initially funded through onetime restricted resources it was a need that was uh that was requested of our district uh for for student support so that was folded into the interrior general FR you can see that in the Bold there that's a total encroaching into the inter restrict General plan of 57773 that did not exist before so we increase restricted general fund expenditures without having the revenue to offset can I just I just want to make a contextual comment on that because that was in result of a number of whether was a I think healthy kids surveys and stuff where we were seeing some pretty pluming numbers and we as a board at the time along with the district
075agreed that you know based on the maso's hierarchy is that right we need to keep the students whole before they can even begin to learn so I just want to give that context to it it's not like we did it without recognizing the cost but we did feel was an important um step to take as a district and the mhts um work with students directly or as like are they seeing kids directly or are they working schoolwide basically how many cases do they have or is that yeah so we have a mental health therapist at the high school dedicated to the high school one that's itinerant at the two elementary schools and then one is is dedicated to the Middle School numbers of student contact maybe I could default the buck maybe not on the
076numbers but actually I think um executive director cor Anthony is online with us right because she was in San Diego for a conference this week so I'm I'm hoping that she is there and could maybe just speak a little to that executive uh director cork Anthony are you there with us yes hi can you hear me oh it's good to hear your voice to you uh good evening everyone good evening board cabinet um yes the mental health therapists do actually work with students and individual and group depending on the circumstances of the student whatever their needs are um within the general education setting and they also actually provide Sports to some students with uh IEPs um in terms of Crisis and support with the staff so um they they are serving the whole the schools
077you know for check-ins with students as well uh but they do carry a case load in terms of just supporting specific students that may require more intensive needs on campus and just more context setting I believe um a couple of months ago I learned that the IEP cases or students with IEPs have risen uh like 33% or something like that in the past couple of years just to address the need for these right so the students are I um the m there's two sets of mental health therapists there we have the mental health therapists that the three we're talking about um that are were under general education fund then there's also mental health therapists who spe only serve students with IEPs and they through um a contract through Monteray County um Behavioral Health and those
078are specifically for students with IEPs and they carry a case load combined of about 50 or 52 I can address numbers um I was just looking at them so this District uh to follow up to your question uh trusty wax uh this district has around 290 uh and correct me if I'm wrong um director cork Anthony 290 uh students on IEPs and around 18050 students on 504s so if you total that up that's about 1 thir of our district yes we do support about oneir in terms of students with disabil thank you for that Josh we do actually support about a close a third of our students um with supports and various levels of services so um it is about 465 470 I don't have it in front of me but yeah it's about that
079number and I would I would suggest the rationale behind that would be a number of things number one we have some of the very best special education instructors and support staff of any laa in this County and I was at the County office for a long time and I've seen it so I can attest to that um I think that uh what we're seeing are families that are moving into the area specifically to come and attend our mod and SDC program at our school sites uh and then you know the other component is potentially overidentification of of students um but moreover it's it's because we are like really one of the very best special Leed programs in the county and I feel good saying that and I feel like that's a fact Josh on the
080mental health therapists those they sign contracts correct for the year or how did they get employed um for getting onto the you know the uh I want to call it the the whole payment yeah they're not salary they're not yeah they're not an independent contractor if that's what you're asking no there's a salary schedule for for the mental health therapists um that exists and I don't know if you're if they follow a unit they do not currently follow csca or pgta unit they're kind of on their own uh they're these are licensed uh professionals so it's kind of a professional group if that answers the question but yeah there's a salary schedule that we have specifically for so we created a a schedule for that the those services or that credentialing person correct welcome just
081one more thing to to note on this slide um for our projected budget development which we are getting into in 2526 there is another potential impact from expiring restricted resources uh this is basically the last of the the restricted expiring resources uh and that is our intervention reading Intervention Program so I have that highlighted down there below uh with the teacher and the uh5 FD instructional assistant you know cumulatively what this has done I mean these are wonderful programs for our district these help out our students that's what we are that's what we are here to do uh but this is an impact of about you know 77 or 700 sorry $785,000 uh to our unrestricted general fund that was not an expenditure before on the N restrict and general fund side and there is
082no Revenue to offset so that's big takeaway from this Slide the 7885 correct right currently this year in our 2425 budget we we're carrying 57773 um and then down below the 213473 that's being carried on a restricted Revenue resource this year but it expires at the end of this year so if we want to maintain those resources and programs for our students it would it would it would uh increase the UNR general fund obligation and the intervention teacher um goes between campuses right I Y all right this is a breakdown of our uh this is a table that highlights the changes in revenue from year fiscal year 2020 to or 2020 2020 2021 I'm just going to say 20 21 to 2425 and you can see these are the restricted revenues uh that have been
083continuing to decline over the course of the last four years um just looking at the bottom you can see in in 20121 District had just over 2.5 million in Revenue uh from these uh restricted resources and then we kind of had a balloon in 2122 2223 of uh you know just over 3.8 over 3.6 2324 dropped a little bit 3.4 now we're down to 2.89 five and in my multi-year projections we're showing this to be in steady decline next slide okay so in your packet you have exhibit a um it that's a lot it's they are spreadsheets there's a lot of data there I'm going to try to highlight um both exhibit a and exhibit B exhibit a being unrestricted exhibit B being restricted we'll start with exhibit a which is unrestricted uh the two
084exhibits are basically they further break down are unrestricted and restricted revenue and expense so let's take a look at at the exhibit IIT a unrestricted revenue and expense and I'm going to highlight some of the lines for you uh the document has line numbers on the Le hand side it's not up on your screen right now but it is accessible and actually lisis if you click the link it might pop up on the screen there uh back one and click the there we go I don't know if anyone's going to want to look at that but there it is okay everyone has it at the table um so the document has uh the line number on the leftand column then the title of the revenue on the lefthand column and I will be referring to
085those line items as we move through the next few slides so listed is the comparison again from 2021 through current year you can see the PV P pvv that's the variance year-over-year so what is the change uh you can see at the very top there just as an example line one beginning balance 2020 21 just over 4.9 million 2122 just over 5.4 that's a 170% increase that's kind of how we're reading this um if we're looking strictly at the unrestricted Revenue that's starting on on line three and and working its way down to line 22 just going to highlight a couple of lines that really do jump out line 22 which is all other local revenue is down by 109% over actuals from the 23 24 year line 23 which is the contributions from the
086unrestricted general fund has increased by 133% so 90% of that total on line 23 is the unrestrictor general fund contribution to special education I do have our fiscal officer here today and if she'd like to comment on the makeup of the unrestricted general fund contribution to special education okay um so that contribution um the 7.9 uh let's see we have 7.8 of it is the sped contribution um sped is expected to receive an apportionment of 1 .5 million and the remaining 6.1 is going to be covered with a contribution from unrestricted sped expense breakdowns 6.4 million of it is in salary and benefits with the remaining 1.4 million in operational expenses which include legal fees sub agreement for services and professional Consulting fees okay questions on the special contribution report move on that was line
087line 23 is what we were just talking about I mean so really the takeaway there is if you look at 2020 and 21 bless you um the district was just over 5.1 million and it's special ed contrib or the contribution from the mrict general fund it's now just under eight million I could go into a lot further detail on what the requirements are associated with special education contribution but it's really simple to it's simply put uh we have what's called a maintenance of effort that the district must meet every single year which means that the district must have $1 more in expenditures than we had the prior year now if we have uh a decline in enrollment we we we that that does not necessarily carry the same weight we do not have to go
088up by $1 but special ed programs maintenance of effort require us to increase the spending year-over-year you cannot decrease the spending as one of the tests is that a federal rule state yeah thee that's a whole I could give a whole discussion on that I'm not going to get into it but there's basically four areas you look at for special education maintenance of effort one of them is ex increased in expenditures year-over year and if you don't meet three of the four you fail and you don't want to fail okay let's so we're still on this this page here we're still looking at unrestricted Revenue I'm sorry no we're not I apologize the total unrestricted Revenue so down the bottom uh one thing to highlight the next line Lewis 31 um our total unrestricted Revenue
089has increased by 5.5 million cumulative from 2020 21 to 2425 that's that's a really good thing we've seen an increase in Revenue let's take a look at the expenditures just slide down a little bit leis there you go um okay on the unrestricted expenditure side I'm going to highlight a few lines let's first look at line 32 to it's up at the top there all right other classified salaries other classified salaries has increased by 49% over actuals these are positions that were once funded from restricted that are now impacting the unrestricted general fund I mentioned this earlier when we were talking about examples uh mental health therapists Bas SRP recck leads occupational therapists crossing guards campus supervisors there just those are examples there's many uh but that's that that is what makes up the 49%
090increase year-over-year looking at line 3 six uh that is our Health and Welfare increase and that's due to the 2425 Health and Welfare cap increase so when we negotiate with our units uh and we and we provide an increase to the district contribution whatever percentage that might be it equates to a dollar amount so there that's part of that increase uh as well as the 20987 to assessment from Mig which I mentioned earlier Line 39 is our Revenue abatement for our retirees Health and Welfare line 51 is the uh we'll note the substantive increase in professional Consulting from 2122 through 2425 this increase over time is attributed to districtwide professional development legal fees many other items um and for this I'm going to hand it over to Karly again and she's going to give you
091a breakdown because it is a pretty big jump so over the last four years legal fees have almost doubled on the unrestricted side right running roughly 500,000 a year um 500,000 last year um another part or component of that is the train interest repayment that we have um which has doubled uh since 2122 and is running about 20 was 269 um th000 last year um in 23 24 we incurred a $314,000 Ser fee for retirees that was year 105 and will continue into fiscal year 728 and the remaining 477,000 last year was just other professional contracted Services a large majority of it being for professional development as well that's just a good question on the Tran I mean I thought the Tran was a pretty standard payment because we're just pre-b borrowing what we haven't
092yet received from the state so how is that going up is it because we're borrowing more or so the cost of issuance is based on market rate it's all interest rates y it's all interest rates y um yeah sorry about this isn't the largest thing but the approved textbooks just as a newcomer do we have to relicense those each year or the answer is no um the uh textbooks um typically have a contract that lasts like six or seven years and so when we redo something um at the high school there is no mandatory re renewal schedule that we that we have what we did was we um lever some of the one-time money that we received um from the government during during covid to try to update some of our purchases of the textbooks
093um the textbook budget uh is set at the beginning of the year and then it also gets a augmented by the lottery funds that we bring bring in and so um it depends on the curriculum that you purchase some of them will have a term of 5 to S years some of them will be for two years some of them will be for three so the renewals come at different uh times if that answers your question so looking down at Total expenses line it's I guess it's 71 there um what you'll see is the total expenditures have increase by just over 7.3 million cumulative from 2021 to 2425 and really one takeaway here to note is that uh the district has been carrying a deficit relationship with unrestricted Revenue to expense our expenditures have been
094higher year-to-year higher than our Revenue that we've been bringing in therefore on the unrestricted side we have been deficit spending and that's a relationship that has existed for some time next slide sorry not next slide next worksheet so and this just summarizes what we're talking talking about let's go to the next worksheet exhibit B yeah Lou has it that's exhibit a again oh second tab no I think he I it's Link's wrong but link might be wrong oh hit the link and go to the second tab there you go there it is okay I'm looking out okay so here we're gonna take a look again just like we did at uh restricted revenues and restricted expenditures uh we're going to start out by looking at line uh sorry line five all other federal revenue which
095is down by 150% over actuales from 2324 since 2021 pgusd is loss over 1.3 million in federal revenue and that is specifically tied to Esser which I mentioned before Esser one 12 and three cares act ELO and other restricted programs uh line eight take a take and highlight that all other state local Revenue has decreased by 19% over the 23 24 year this resource has been in Decline as you can see for the last three feso years the total restricted Revenue uh has increased by 1.3 million cumulative over the 20121 through 24 25 year which when we get into Revenue actually I'll just highlight it now so yes the revenue increased over those four years but the expenditures increased by 4.4 million milon back to the deficit the deficit relationship that we're having with expense
096and revenue um but I would like to still break down and continue to look through some of these other items here [Music] um stop at sorry oh no next slide now we're on slide 19 oh no sorry line 22 other classified salaries are down by 46% on the restricted side uh over 23 24 these are uh restricted these are restricted positions that expired with rest with restricted funding and those were shifted to the general fund as I've mentioned earlier uh books and supplies this is line 31 l31 is uh up 93% due to previously unbudgeted local library specific monies and grants that were encouraged uh we're encouraging site we are currently encouraging our sites to utilize first again back to restricted and unrestricted um we encourage those restricted dollars to be spent first before sites
097use their unrestricted general fund uh allotment or contribution contribution is the wrong wrong word um budgeted item we want them to use the restricted first so uh in this case we uh our library books and supplies they were pulling from unrestricted being paid for either or unrestricted when we had a restricted pot of money that could be used um my fiscal officer to my left here is very diligent about that this year and she's H she has meetings multiple times a month with our with our programs and our site specifically to address spending down the restricted dollars first so as to avoid the encroachment to the general fund let's take a l look at line 32 it's materials and supplies which is up 64% uh and that's due that's due to the increase of the
098associated carryover from local resources from the prior year that was not budgeted so if we had expenditures that were not budget budgeted in the prior year we carried those forward so it's just around 715,000 Line 39 you can note the substantive increase in professional Consulting from 2122 through 2425 just like we looked at at the PRI on the prior slide of unrestricted this is made up of legal s uh Legal Services associated with claims investigations and special education settlements and placement and uh going to hand it back to Carly to kind of break that down a little further for you on the restricted side um just as Josh mentioned yeah sped does account for a good chunk of those restricted dollars that's the one we give the contribution to from unrestricted um this year they
099have um 1.1 million budgeted for healthc care services a a contract and marriages um Legal Services positive behavior we also have ongoing and major maintenance um that gets rolled into restricted as well and we have 110 um, budgeted there for their professional Consulting fees um and then other local uh Revenue we're getting in from the sites we have contracts budget in there as well so um the the um site assessment plan or basically like the preparation for the bond and that sort of thing that was part of the Consulting money uh to do the facilities um maintenance plan and that sort of thing that was unrestricted it wasn't restricted it would have been in the unrestricted expenditures which you covered on the other slide or other exhibit Josh um with with special ed we get
100monies from the county to help with that right yeah we do get a we get Salpa we get we get an apportionment from Salpa and it was one of the ear your slides we've seen it kind of tapering a bit do you know why that is you know I've asked the question and I'm waiting for a response and I don't know if Carly does know the answer either but we did ask the county um it could be associated with the identified mod severe population I believe that's what it is tied to kind of look into Lauren in the back of the room but um and our mod severe numbers they've been staying relatively level okay yeah so I I I I will get back to the board on that because um initially I thought it
101had to do with our mod severe um apportionment from this from the county through the Salpa but if our numbers are still going up but the revenue is going down that would not make sense but does this have to do with fatee settlements potentially no okay all okay the marus I wasn't sure of that in the next what's that oh that's fine okay let's highlight line 44 so line 44 is the indirect cost that has been in Decline uh because indirect cost is you know predominantly associated with our restricted Revenue sources those are so when the revenue is expiring so is the indirect that the district charges those resources right so it's been in decline because as we're losing Revenue we're losing the indirect yeah exactly so again back to what I mentioned earlier toal
102the next line down total expenses 97 um we've increased by 4.4 million over the PO past four years and pgusd again on the restricted side is carrying a deficit relationship with revenue and expense so the caution here on on the restricted side is that pgusd cannot continue to maintain programs that have expiring revenue or it will dramatically increase the general fund deficit I mean that's like a pretty simple takeaway right if we continue to maintain programs that are funded out of restricted revenue and if those programs they need a source for revenue and funding and it's shifted the unrestricted general fund that begins to increase the deficit which one of the points tonight we're looking at is ways is to decrease our deficit I'm not making any recommendations it's just a point that needs to
103be considered moving forward next slide actually let's move back to the slide deck Lewis and let's go to slide 20 all right so the boarding District must as a basic Aid District maintain a health a healthy Reserve balance School Board should ensure that Reserve policies align with long-term goals and fiscal Health regular review of reserves can help avoid over accumulation or depletion of funds while building reserves it is important to note the uh is important for the financial stability transparency and communication with our community uh especially if reserves need to be used for specific purposes like restoring programs or addressing shortfalls some major areas that we're monitoring include the volatility and local property tax revenue you can see the kind of the summary of that up there on the board uh as an example if
104there's a downturn in the real estate market that's just unrealized the district May realize less property tax revenue because of the downturn in the real estate market on the other hand if there's an uptick in the in the real estate market um assess valuation tends to climb more homes being sold at a new market rate increases assess valuation which increases property tax but it's something that we need to monitor uh this District has I mentioned on average 5% over year to year in proper new property taxes we've had a couple of years where it was higher there was an 88.9% year in new property taxes and that was directly tied to the commercial property tax assessment covid deferrals we don't see anything like that in the future but what we do see is potentially the
105impacts of Prop 19 uh which essentially um creates a situation where our uh the current homes in our Market are being assessed at the current market rate which were formerly cap under Prop 13 if if those if those homes are sold if those homes are moved to a um a Survivor as a benefit through a trust that would increase assess valuation other areas to look at is the uncertainty in state funding and federal funding we talked a lot about that tonight so even though basic a districts are largely largely funded by property taxes they still receive federal funding for specific pro programs Title One and title two are examples um and we're not exactly certain what's going to happen with Title One and title two funding moving forward we're budgeting for it to stay level
106uh but that's something we need to seriously be looking at uh for for our targeted student populations another item to look at is pensions and long-term liabilities um the larger Reserve can help the district meet its obligations for those long-term liabilities but our reserves have historically uh been utilized to Stave off the impact of the unrestricted general fund um the reserves have not been used historically to Stave off the increase to stirs and purs but that is something that we need need to be aware of right now stirs as I mentioned earlier is flat at 19.1% and stirs is going up by sorry Pur is going up by 37% that's just what's in the proposed budget it may it may change um and we're not sure if it's going to this year but again that's
107something that needs to be evaluated budget flexibility and financial stability so we just talked about our TR that's our tax revenue anticip anticipation note which this District uses for cash flow inflection um what that means is basically the district receives its line share of its property taxes over 85% of our revenue's property taxes it comes in in December and April well if our last influx of major Revenue comes in in a April we start to have a cash flow problem usually around September or October uh and it's pretty tough in those in those couple of months before we see a massive influx of Revenue in December where we get our big influx of property tax receipts um but as uh you know president Hazen mentioned rates fluctuate the market fluctuate the TR can cost us
108more but it unfortunately is it is something that is necessary for this school district uh it's if property taxes were more spread out throughout the year which they're not then we wouldn't have to carry a TR um and a TR is just basically a it's a it's a bridge loan to uh replenish our cash flow to make sure we can meet our shortterm obligations lastly we need to avoid pressure for midyear Cuts we don't want to ever be in a position where that is the case larger reserves can can impact and they can help impact the need for midyear Cuts in the middle of a budget year right if if there are substantial uh issues that take place in the market and again we have issues with trans issuance we have issues with receipt of
109property taxes so for example uh if our property tax revenue in December instead of coming in at just around 19 million came in at 14 million the district's going to have a really big problem to get from De de to April that TR that we issued is not going to carry us from December to April it's designed to carry this district from September through November so that's something that we need to look at but that's why the reserve potentially could be used kind of as a TR to span us into that next property tax influx I'll pause right there and a few here sorry you'll hear from me um one question I'll ask well I'll make one comment just because the reserve has something I know we've been discussing the past two years a bunch
110and you know as a board we've kind of suggested targeting a 10% and I just don't know if this is the right time for us to discuss that probably let you finish first before we come back to it okay I'll just throw that out there because it has been something we mentioned in the past um how one question is how much of a reserve would we need to avoid a TR is that even possible it's okay if you need to get back to us so that I would just say that that's not um probably not fiscally responsible budgeting I'm guessing it' be like the 60s almost like if you I mean 50 or 60% Reserve to be able to cover yourself half the year right right so I mean so this District takes about we
111take a 7.5 million not to exceed Tran is what we take um do we use every penny of it not every year it's not to exceed and we only pay interest on what we've used um so that 7 and a half million again is a bridge for for SE member October November um to not have a TR at all you know we would need I would be comfortable with like 20 to 25 million in reserves knowing that we need 7.5 to bridge those months and then having another you know right that's about 50% if everybody is 49 that's about 50% okay just the trend has come up before the other question is do we get any interest on our Reserve I'm Sur proba that's a stupid question like if we have a larger Reserve do
112we get more like it's we we okay we don't we don't have a high savings yield account with some it's no it's I'm trying every time every time matters right yeah trying yeah it's it's interest like a savings account it's not the the trans or sorry our reserves are not being used on the open market to um to Garner interest like high levels of Interest as like being utilized for Investments so to speak last question again if it better to wait till we discuss 10% neighboring District Reserve do we have any numbers on that I know of you like you said carel is one of comp comparable so yeah they're in the 20s um and so and again what is a reserve a reserve is the percent of expenditures for the year right so a
113percent on total expenditures so as you can see I'll show on the next chart our Reserve percentage and Reserve amount have changed over the years dramatically as expenditures increase right so uh I don't know where carmell is sitting right now they're high 20s in their percent of reserve and their expenditures are higher than ours too so um other districts in our County lcff districts are carrying higher than 3% remember the the districts Reserve statutorily per in fact leis just jump to the next slide if you could please yeah so under Ed code 42127 the district must maintain a 3% or higher Reserve statutorily right um and there are are lcff districts that are carrying four and 5% reserves 6 8% reserves uh but as a basic a district to have a single Reserve I think
114is something that we as a as a board as a district as a community to start taking a hard look at because uh we're looking at this chart here we just look at 2016 to 17 to 2425 and you can see the reserve percentage has declined from 17.4% to 8 8.9% you can also see the total assigned Reserve is somewhat you know tends to be comparable right because expenditures went up right so I think that you know some of the areas to highlight here are um let me look at my notes sorry um reserves are percentage I mentioned overall expenditures sorry second so at first interim we have a Reserve balance of 4,587 90 and a reserve percentage of 8.9% which is down from 14% the reduction of the reserve is a direct result in
115the deficit spending right every time the district deficit spends especially on the unrestricted side it brings down the reserve amount it brings down the reserve percentage so to provide just some perspective uh on the Reserve balance pgusd has a monthly average payroll of $2.7 million just over on average we have $865,000 in Health and Welfare liability on average monthly we have just over $600,000 in accounts payable and other liabilities short-term liabilities monthly that's a net liability per month on average of just over $4 million of just doing business business every month sometimes it's 4.6 sometimes it's 4.1 but it's just over $4 million our current Reserve amount would carry us for one month right but there's many other factors I mentioned here the TR I mean I'm not I'm not suggesting that all of a
116sudden we would have to use the reserve to make our short-term liabilities but when you put it into perspective it's it you know it's kind of glaring it's the fact that the district's one month of operations could be covered by our Reserve I think that's something we we need to look at sorry um I may have missed this in the rundown on the exhibit B but is there a reason or was there an explanation as to why materials and supplies jumped up to like a million from 350,000 last year you know off the top of your head I can look back that's just in there to offset all the local Revenue which comprise a a large portion so the local revenue is like site collected monies donations um and we do budget that expense so
117that the site see that money is available to spend um because obviously we're trying to get them to spend the restricted versus unrestricted so that's that's why it's in there it's you know it carries forward into the next year if it's unspent um but we do want the sites to be able to see that it's there Josh to what's your best guess on why there was a an astounding 17.4% Reserve in 2016 17 I mean remember it's based on expenditures so the expenditures were much lower than too right so the 3% Reserve amount was only 750,000 you know the total assigned was 4.4 17.4% it was between 1617 and 2425 we've had ma major cost escalation yeah dramatic well just in proportionally I mean back in the day not that far away but when I
118was on the board I mean never ever saw a percentage even getting to 12 so so what I'm asking you is what is okay increase in cost I get that increase in people but still you're looking at a proportional you got an increase in income too so I'm just wondering how song maneuvered that because I think she did I mean I think not not in a a bad way I just think that she probably um worked the budget so that she was putting more in the reserve than previous superintendent of businesses so the whole discussion on reserves could evolve a bit um related to unrestricted versus restricted um what I've seen is very so in song's era there were very high uh restricted Reserve balances carried forward that could be used to offset restricted expenditures
119um which was helpful right because she was augmenting potentially The General fund yeah abs and we're in a state where that's not that that's not the case anymore uh and it really started to come on I mean we did get an influx of the eser dollars I mentioned but um yeah there was a there was pretty large restricted carry forwards in the components of the ending fund balance every year that now is we're down to I mean I think we projected like 1.3 million in restricted revenue or restricted carry signed restricted in the reserves carry forward to 25 26 where last year it was 2.8 million the year before it was 4 million um so once we're losing that restricted dollars we're also we're losing the ability to carry it forward in our reserves so
120so do you okay do you guess then that the restricted dollars the loss in that Revenue over time is political in some way I mean I because restricted monies are coming in because from State and Federal right I mean those are that's where you're getting your restricted funds in from so who's controlling that that's the politicians that are controlling the amounts that come in and and you know boom years not boom years bust years so I'm just wondering like it's it's just an amazing contrast to me um based on my previous experience yes I just had a little aside with with Carly because a lot of restricted dollars are tied to our unduplicated pupil count also our UPC or up we use it um and the district's percentage hasn't gone down right it's actually our
121targeted youth population has went up small percentages half fractional percentages so you should be seeing Revenue increasing from those restricted resources um year-over-year and that's not we're seeing and the potential for that I mean if I tried to delve into it my first best guess would be that the apportionment per pupil has went down but the pupil numbers have went up right so what was once funded at $100 a student is now funded at 50 I was going to ask too I mean there have been cases in the past where boards have put more money like I'm thinking of the 200 right the 200k 200k that's a way to put money aside that helps buffer the Reserve I mean that might be part of the I mean I'm asking the unrestricted Reserve not the unrestricted
122you would have to ass so right now that the two that you're mentioning the $400,000 unrestricted contribution to two funds fund 40 and 14 you would just the board would have to uh direct staff to take $400,000 and assign it in the component of vending fund balance for a purpose but we're talking about in fund transferring that doesn't that does not turn it into restricted funds when we put the fund okay sorry as I mentioned I mean so let's use an example we had restricted money which was the Music Arts discretionary block grant the board directed staff to take um I think it was $175,000 and commit it in the reserve to Future stir and purs increases so that was an assignment taken from a restricted resource restricted Revenue we assigned it in in the
123in the ending fund balance and and that makes up part of our reserves yeah and it and that is actually unrestricted right but it's set with the board goal of if we have next year a I mean honestly if it's like it may we may take up what we have now if next year's increase is over half a percent for purs right so it's it's trying to help us buffer and back to the discussion I had earlier that's what that's what we use the reserves for usually it's not to pull from when we're deficit spending it's to pull from when we have unanticipated increases in expenditures like an increase to pers s so when the board decided to take that one-time money and move it into the component of ending fund balance and assign it
124that that is absolutely you know what the board that was a great decision by the board at that time is it going to help us if stirs and purs go up by 1% but it's it will help with a half a percent so you know that's good foresight and that's something we probably need to look into but I mean in the future if there was more onetime dollars Associated that were discretionary that you could pull from and do that with um sorry I apologies for like focusing on kind of the smaller numbers and I'm not able to see if this is like a pattern over eight years but just the pattern over the past four years the equipment over 5,000 went from 8,300 to almost two or 279 and it was kind of like on
125a trajectory up again apologies if I missed the explanation but is there any background on that no um so no apologies needed it's we only addressed kind of certain variances we kind of tried to look at like what were the large variances um I don't have it in front of me are you looking at unrestricted or restricted restricted on exhibit B okay exhibit B yeah restricted so that could be tied to some of the restricted grants we have so for example let me take prop 28 um we have an 80% requirement to spend 80% of that Revenue that we receive which is restricted on salaries the other 20% has to be used on we call the fours through the sixes that's materials and supplies professional growth services and other so the district probably budgeted where
126it needed to to align the budget with the restricted resource requirements given to us gotcha okay okay looking back at the what Beth had mentioned with the SE 17.4% um 2016 is like year two of lcff right and so back then the discrep the the doar the the restricted dollars uh were more discretionary right because the whole goal of lcff was to give districts more control yeah so I but I think that the the funds more recently have especially the covid funds were more targeted absolutely very so it would been easier to put that into the general fund correct good point yes yeah the Inception of lcff was 1516 was it no 1314 first year being 1516 and absolutely the influx of categoricals restricted revenues at the time gave the districts more discretion as to
127how to spend those dollars yes so next we're going to kind of take a total shift off of expense and Revenue and take a look at our historical enrollment to Staffing ratios in the district if that's okay yeah so pgusd has been in a declining enrollment for the past decade we've went from just over 2,000 students to just over 177,000 students this is a net loss of 274 students from 1314 through 252 through 2425 pgusd has been adding labor force as well which has which has been to address many programs such as learning loss mitigation mental health concerns and others some a lot of what we spoke about tonight that's why we've been adding staff but it's it's it's important to contextualize all of this however you can see in 134 the district's total FTE
128equivalent was 200 was 22.6 staff districtwide and now in 2425 the district's FTE full-time equivalent is 262.50 n staff the total increase to staff while in a declining enrollment equals just under 50 FTE with a declining enrollment of 274 students we've added 50 FTE now again that's not 50 people because some folks have fractional FTE that could be added to Prior fractional FTE but I have all of this data from song and Rick Miller and that's where we stand right now just a quick question about pgta and csca everything like this is districtwide districtwide thank you so even with the expansion of universal prek uh and our upk mbers have not made up the losses from declining enrollment which we had anticipated um our declining enrollment alongside PG usd's historical smaller class sizes can play
129a role in addressing deficit spending in our district with fewer students pgusd may have the opportunity to reduce overall Staffing levels and operational costs to address shrinking revenues in the context of declining enrollment districts must strategically manage resources using these shifts as part of the broader plan to stabilize finances without sacrificing the quality of Education pgusd has been known for next slide see 23 some of the areas pgusd can focus on to address deficit spending and align our resources to declining enrollment is that of class size optimization my district has class SI goals and maximums as shown on the slide there is a recommendation to begin looking to align class-size goals with enrollment in lie of maintaining much lower than class-size goals to be clear we're not recommending pushing classes to goal or Max but
130we need to begin taking a look at the state of our declining enrollment and better align our class sizes depending on grade level with the appropriate Staffing Dr Adamson that was really well said assistant superintendent John I think the only piece I want to add here is I think this really is it's a reminder for us it's an opportunity for us to be sure that we're very closely you know looking at that enrollment from from year to year I think we've you know definitely P practi has been you know if we go one you know one number over uh projected numberers in the summer you know we've been very quick at that point to add another class so I think you know this really is a chance for us to sort of reset our practices
131and really look at numbers and ensure that we're you know adding and Staffing according to you know the need uh and maybe you know holding and waiting to be sure that you know those students are going to actually show up uh in the fall when we open class because that doesn't always necessarily happen and we know that and this gives us that ability to go back and look at those Trends so um again just it's an opportunity for us to you know and and and really sort of a little bit of foresight that you know those will be some practices that we'll be implementing um in moving forward pgusd has benefit pgusd students have benefited from small class sizes at our elementary school sites uh just to give you you know I think it's important
132to note kind of our averages here so 2425 TK class sizes they are set to 24 to two that's statutory one instructor and I say one to two instructional AIDS because there are some TK classes that have more than one instructional Aid they also have volunteers Kinder classes are averaging 20 to1 with some instructional Aid support first grade 25:1 2 23:1 3D 23:1 fourth 20 to1 and fifth 2 24 to1 again these are averages across our two elementary schools I think what's important to highlight is what's in parens next to them um with some instructional Aid support this district has quite a few instructional assistance which certainly help with small group instruction they help to address the learning loss mitigation that this district has has felt as well as many other school districts but looking
133at our comparable districts we don't see this many instructional assistance at other comparable districts in the classrooms at these grade levels at the middle school we benefited also from smaller class sizes you can see here some of the averages uh sixth grade class size is 25 to1 7th grade 25 to1 8th grade 24 to1 so this doesn't I'm not including in this average the smaller elective class sizes this is this is simply core high schools also benefited from smaller class sizes but they also have more Singletons that they offer at PG high school that's more sections of classes for interested students that this District can offer which has been a draw to our high school and that's a that's a testament to our to our teachers at the high school ninth grade class sizes 29
134to1 10th grade class sizes 30 to1 11th 29:1 and 12th 26:1 again averaging all I'll take a pause there I'm sorry my mind is like two slides back perpetually but so um the students have gone down and if we're using historic the the class sizes have remained the same from 2013 to 2024 roughly is that safe to assume well basically where are these FTE coming from do you think are they I know there's some mental health increases but is it the cumulative instructional AIDS no the instructional AIDS are on the that's on the classified side um you know I'd say diving in a bit which I did at the high school I didn't do so much at the middle school um a lot of The Singletons we offer uh requires additional staff to teach those
135classes I mean if we if we try to instruct students and carry um um you know just Core Curriculum that's not going to be a very interesting High School to attend so uh I would suggest that the expansion of FTE even in a declining enrollment was for the district and for the high school to provide Singleton classes for our student population uh classes that are of interest to our students even if they yield a you know 10 to 15 student class size those are class sizes that we should be offering our students because there's interest I would say that over the course of that same time there's been other Serv services that that have been expanded you know um that uh because that uh just in my tenure at Forest Force Grove I know that
136Counseling Services were you know expanded throughout the district um uh in two separate actions um one focused on you know an elementary expansion of counseling hours and the other uh focused more on the expansion of counseling at uh the secondary schools um I think uh it's important to note too at the um same time there has been some support staff additions made um within the district office you know that's that that's part of the uh um count there as far as the 49 go to but then at the same time that as the you know enrollment declined um the amount of Staffing at the elementary schools remained pretty stagnant you know until the last like year um that's where we tried to do some reductions based on attrition basically if a teacher retired and the
137group's coming up didn't fill the three classes it was an opportunity to go from three at a grade level down to down to two um then uh there's also been um you know an increase or an attempted increase in the numbers of um folks that we had supervising at noon at noon duty to try to increase the safety of the environment you know uh there um I believe that the number of computer texts through throughout the district also has increased um as there has been a greater you know infusion of technical devices with the you know the funding that we got from measure a with that many more div devices it took more folks to sub support those devices so um just uh kind of trying to paint as broad a picture as we can
138um and uh and in terms of like the uh you know the class sizes and things like that um we are starting to see you know um Staffing that uh that may be in excess of the numbers of students that we have here yeah um Josh so just piggybacking on what Buck said um from my perspective okay I left the board in 2009 now I'm back what's the difference okay what I see as the difference is well we have a resource officer we pay we have um a director that we pay for facilities and maintenance we didn't used to have a director we had a foreman um we have other directors and I'm not criticizing this I'm just this is just how I what I see like wow how this ballooned and and but I
139I understand the reasons for it um like you mentioned it look at the it and we have to have it but that's a big department now so um what didn't look different to me was really the classes but um the class sizes and and when you look at uh I mean historically we have had declining enrollment since probably 19 in the 80s that's when it started um because when the you know the Silicon Valley people came down here and started buying houses without negotiating for a price just plunking down the money and we started losing families that's when our our yeah foror left and that's when our enrollment started to decline and it just little by little by little by it it's just been a continual March so um but anyway but but that's what
140I noticed like oh my God we have um a a lot of administrative Staffing that is necessary but definitely is a difference going back to the same era I've been here this is year 27 no campus security uh extra campus security not just not at s we had zero campus security we had uh my current position the the curriculum coordinator barbar noelli was a halftime position so there's just so many more needs now uh and the irony with local control is it tries to give more control over to to the district so you have less like state bureaucracy but it creates more bureaucracy locally and and with that is accountability and with that is a need for jobs and people to fill those position um and then basically the entire tech department you know it's
141new got two slides I'm sorry just one thing I think the other thing that's not being brought up is we did experience a pandemic and there was a lot of Mental Health crisis that occurred and continues to occur and I think that's going to continue so when it comes to any mental health therapists um anybody that's there for student support I mean those are areas that I think are absolutely essential like it I mean we can't exist without it anymore and that's just the world that we live in as well as security campus security so it's it really is just a changing the entire climate has changed to a point where it's no longer what it used to be and that's just the facts so how we get out of deficit spending I don't know
142how long that relationship has already been happening but to try to get out of it now is going to be tricky because our requirements are so much greater now so I guess it's more of a comment than a question okay let's talk about addressing annual deficit spending so we want to address the balance between managed and unmanaged and unavoidable cost escalation in school districts which is crucial for maintaining fiscal health and our Educational Opportunity manage costs such as such as discretionary spending on programs administrative overhead Capital project they can all be controlled through strategic budgeting efficiency improvements and prioritization of of essential Services I do highlight efficiency improvements because it's something this district is doing to try to drive down our operational expenditures which are tied directly to our unrestricted general fund we're only in
143year one of that but there are anticipated savings associated with reducing our operational costs on the other hand unavoidable costs like employee salaries benefits pension obligations inflation d driven expenses often increase often increase annually and are harder to adjust so to effectively manage both we must adopt a proactive Financial strategy and include long-term forecasting Cost Containment measures and leveraging available funding resources clearly distinguishing between what we can and cannot control pgusd can prioritize its spending we can Implement cost-saving initiatives and ensure the essential Educational Services remain intact while addressing escalating costs so just these are just some of the managed costs and unavoidable costs that this district is dealing with um but it's something that we absolutely have to consider and to you know to bring it down to a more simplified term sometimes we
144have to look at the like to haves versus the must or need to haves right we really need to start looking at that this is nice to have and it's great and it's and it is something that we pride ourselves on as Pacific gr Unified School District but is it a must and those are the tough decisions this board in this District are faced with right now um we are a wonderful District we have so many great things to offer our students the but unfortunately is we're losing Revenue dramatically we're dipping into the reserves every year and that is something that's not sustainable so we are going to have to take a hard look at all of our programs and our staffing and make some hard decisions let's look at the next steps so the
145next steps in the process we've already started the budget development process uh we're going to have our site budget development meetings that are February through April we will review enrollment to Staffing at each site School site and at the district office we will review expiring restricted and categorical revenue and prepare Solutions which include reduction of expenditures or sizing of programs at able to the revenue being received we're going to review and address the unre unrestricted General friend encroachment from prior years of restricted resources and with our two subsequent outy years with restricted resources and finally we need to bring a draft budget forward by May 15 to the board so we can have public comment and we can bring a board a budget to the board in June for approval as we move forward into
146developing the budget for 2526 year it's crucial that we address several key challenges while ensuring the continued success of students and the sustainability of our programs first we must strategically plan for the loss of one-time Revenue finding ways to absorb this shortfall without sub uh substantively impacting the quality and bread of our educational offerings and with minimal impact to the unrestricted general fund at the same time addressing our deficit spending requires us to prioritize efficiencies identify area areas for cost saving and adjusting were necessary to create a balanced and sustainable budget equally important is aligning our Resources with the realities of declining enrollment as student numbers decrease we must adjust Staffing and resources in a way that preserves the Integrity of our programs ensuring we make we are making the most effective excuse me use
147of funds available this means making tough choices but also seizing on opportunities to create more streamlined responsive District lastly our budget must remain fully aligned with the local control accountability plan the elcap ensuring that all funding decisions prioritize equity and support of our District's long-term goals it is essential that as we navigate these challenges we do not compromise on our commitment to providing all students with the resources and opportunities they need to succeed while doing so in a fiscally responsible manner in summary developing the 2526 budget will require will require careful planning continued transparency and a commitment to prioritizing Student Success a Time District fiscal solvency by balancing fiscal responsibility with our mission to serve every student equitably we can build a resilient sustainable future for our students and our staff at pgd that is
148the end of my presentation so I think at this point okay let's do a very quick um maybe five 5 minute gets us back at 9:20 but we're going to go into public comment next um just a quick comment on that if I can before we break is reminder we're only doing three it three minutes per person and I apologize for that but I do want to encourage everyone to reach out with any thoughts comments you know after the fact as well and then we'll come back for board after that so see you guys back here at 9:20 um with that we have Miss Richmond at the mic please go ahead Sally Richmond Pacific Grove High School I'm also a resident of Pacific Grove and I have a few questions which I realize that you
149cannot respond to I also have some comments so my first question is that we um refer to restricted costs that now need to get moved to the general fund and specifically that had to do with like mental health therapists ET ET I wanted to know what costs there were if any that uh were Beyond covid inspired costs that were being moved over okay uh the second question that I have is when will we have information on proposition 19 um I wanted to talk about our reserves and I'll do that now so could we bring up uh slide 21 please okay uh the question came about where did this 177% come from and I don't really have a better answer but what I wanted to say is if the years extended further up than 2016 so
150if they went back to like 2013 Etc um we would see around 10 11 12% and what happened was there was the housing crisis and then we found ourselves with stirs uh just increasing through the roof and so from the teacher perspective we were all summoned to the auditorium and told in no uncertain terms that we were all getting pink slips and this was the end of the world and that the sky was truly falling well the sky did not fall I don't know that many people got pink slips but the board went into like a deep deep dive and really cut down on their spending in general um at that time we were trying to of course negotiate for raises and we were told oh no we need to get the reserves back to
15110% we need to get the reserves back to 10% we did get the reserves back to 10% and then the goal was 12% and then it became 15% and when we were sitting there at 177% we were told the goal was 20% reserves so this leads to my request that we that the board set a reasonable goal for the reserves and that we stick to it and it does not not become a moving goal poost okay thank you very much my next comment would be that given our current situation perhaps we consider not moving $200,000 into the reserved maintenance as a deferred maintenance as has been done before um especially with the measure D money that's coming our way um I'll save the worst for last uh the I have two more comments the first
152is that the high school has actually shown an increased student population over the last five years I have not gotten back 10 years over that five-year period we have had a reduction in the number of FTE so when we start talking about Staffing it always sounds to me like teachers but I don't think that that is necessarily true and since I'm down to my last 15 seconds I would like to suggest that the board do a full study regarding whether or not there would be any cost savings to restructuring the elementary schools we can't make a decision on that unless we have the data thank you very much good evening I'm Nicole beich I'm an English teacher at the high school in a middle School parent um forgive me because I have some questions um
153that I'd like to pose I know you will not answer them um and they don't really go together um the first question um Josh mentioned that over the last 10 years there has been a total increase to staff um in the number of approximately 50 FTE my question is is it possible to disaggregate some of that data and determine how many of those FTE are certificated staff versus classified and administrative staff um I think it would be really important to look at that data in addition Josh uh shared the class siiz goals um which we're going to be trying to maximize um for the next school year um I saw a goals for TK all the way through fifth grade but not goals with regards to middle school and high school as a secondary teacher
154and um parent it would be nice to have those um delineated as well and then lastly um on slide 14 there were some examples of one-time funded resources and I want to point to two positions in particular um the first is the two resource teachers it's partial funding RSP um it's a 1.0 FTE um in addition to that fulltime employment there is the one FTE one intervention teacher and those were positions that have been in this District this is my 11th year um those were positions that we had before covid so I'm just wondering kind of why those became a one-time funded resource um and that is it thank you any other comments in the room or online thank you so much okay Lauren Davis I am the resource teacher at Robert down and just
155a few comments um one of those is special education teachers are very impacted in our district Josh mentioned we have great programs here families move into the District um because of those programs but some of the special education teachers in this District are Beyond past their Breaking Point um the load is very overwhelming and another point would be um well I know we're looking at where can we cut costs there are some areas where um maintenance we need more maintenance people in our district and so how can we look at um being really strategic in where we cut our costs thank you any other comments in the room or are anyone [Music] online okay if not I will close public comment and come back to the board and I will go freefor all style if
156anyone has any questions or comments please jump right on in Laura please um so I do have a question about Prop 19 do we have an idea of when we'll have info about that so we have not seen any trickle in effects thus far this year in increase to property tax revenue associated with Prop 19 um the district I just presented this at the last meeting uh as it relates to property tax revenue and actuals to date uh our actuals in uh through December brought us to just over 1.3 cumulative for the year we're anticipating somewhere around two I don't I don't want to misstate huh yeah it's like a little over two so it's tough to tell whether or not the April tax receipts might come in substantially higher than the December tax receipts
157if they do that would certainly be an indication of property selling in our area with a higher assess valuation which means we Garner more tax revenue off of that long-term simply put this will impact our district in a positive way um I use this as an example all the time we talked about it at Rotary a couple of weeks ago uh Patrick Finn did a wonderful presentation over 2,000 homes in the boundary area of Pacific Grove School District have a Cess valuation of $200,000 why is that well it's Prop 13 right that's great for people that live in them right and want to pass them on to their families Prop 19 did change that so for those of us that own homes in this boundary area it's going to be tougher to pass those homes
158along to our children that wasn't that's a result of a state law that passed um but that's staggering to hear that 2,000 homes in our boundary area I mean and some of those I want to say it was like I want to say it was like 800 or Pebble Beach okay because those homes were purchased in the 1950s or the 1960s and they're capped on Prop 13 so Prop 19 will impact this District in a very positive way at some point it's just it's tough to know when we're hoping we start to see a trickle in on that this year because it passed I'm sorry I think it passed it was went effect January of 24 so we should see some residual effects and not to be morbid but we do live in a community
159that is elderly and I mean I'm sorry but it's the truth and um and so that I think is going to it makes an impact sorry sorry just a sorry to anyone that may have taken offense I apologize a quick counter point to that is that we will lose some families potentially as the housing prices go up so we're going to deal with more I mean we're it it potentially but it's if it's handed down through trust then it's just property taxes that they're having I mean yeah I'm thinking more like new families that would move here to place yes absolutely very so I think of another Silver Lining being that uh families of the you know families that might inherit that property now might be able to move here and live here because because
160they would be able to move into that home and shelter that wouldn't help the district but it would help with more students it would shelter that increase to the property tax increase right if they move into the home and live in the home for two years due to Prop 19 their property tax rates are left at The Prop 13 cap rate so it could bring in more families or they sell it and get this St down anyway sorry I did a lot um one other question there you know I brought this up earlier I'll bring it up well let me let me ask other people let me let other people okay the 10% Reserve I said I this is something that we've been Banning about since I've been on the board is this something that
161we could propose that our policy committee take up if it's of interest to the board to say this board feels a 10% Reserve is what we should be targeting because that is and maybe it's too soon maybe we want to get through this budget process to say that but I just want to again bring that up there because I agree with the comment that was made that this is something that we target but we say it we haven't actually set it up in our regs or policy I'll go to that again that would be the direction of the board and you know absolutely that would be the process through our policy committee meeting right developing that policy for it yeah um I do like how Josh presented the 10% being you know a um when
162I don't know if you mentioned 10% but that the reserve um the purpose of the reserve okay so I think when if you bring a policy forward you would be including that in that policy that this were the purposes of this Reserve um because I think that gets lost and and it it becomes I mean I've heard past um and I won't name anybody but I past superintendent of business say things like well you know we have to have money in case of this an extreme emergency or you know so but that's not what Josh was referring to so I like that um definition because I think it's more speaks to a more reasonable situation and it gives a good explanation to the general public and and our staff are are you seeing the definition
163of like the runway for how many I mean I know there's other factors into it but how many months we could pay people or what definition of the it it wasn't just that it was um more about how um The Reserve is there to U buffer certain expenses um not not that one I think was a little extreme on the trans uh loan that that's that wouldn't be a good explanation but but a buffer I think on on some of the other issues that come up and why why do you dip into your reserve you know so um identifying that is helpful can I just quickly just for clarity um I kind of used the the salary monthly obligations to kind of contextualize like dollar for dollar but really um what trustee shamas is talking
164about is volatility to local property tax revenues right that's one big one I mean we had a a housing market crash in '08 right there were deferrals on property taxes and if the district did not have did not receive the proposed anticipated property taxes we would have had a serious problem meeting our short-term liabilities because the TR the tax revenue anticipation that the district took on wouldn't cover that that reduction of potential Revenue so that's a realistic example and I there was many others State funding you know deferrals there's a lot that goes into that but for us I think the biggest one is housing market right what what happens if we hit a recession what happens if the housing market flattens what happens if people stop selling their homes uh or can't afford their
165property taxes I mean that's a that's realistic and it has happened um I would be in favor of uh this being brought to the policy committee for purposes of discussing a concrete figure with regard to the reserve and in the way that it has been discussed and we've been educated about tonight in terms of unanticipated expenses not a pot of money that we pull from when we I don't know I I don't even want to think about what's gone down um I um I also am curious about the 50 te people um I had that in my notes too I was curious about a districtwide breakdown what that looks like um and then um also as a former Elementary parent and parent whose children have benefited from Intervention and resource teachers um I am curious
166about what is going on with that program um and why it's potentially up for being cut right now um yeah I just I think I would like more information about that um a lot of gaps to fill um it's been yeah um I think the if we can all get on the same page and create a system that we know is going to be that something we can rely on that the public can rely on and what the same number we're all going to be working from then at least we all know what the bottom line is and even when we it's hard we can all be on the same page and it'll be transparent for everybody so maybe we start there for tonight I don't know if we're going to get to the bottom
167of like answering all of our budget questions I'm not sure what additional Direction I guess staff is looking for in terms of where we're headed well I think a lot of the questions that we're you know making note of is the will be information we're going to obviously bring back and it could be that it's in the form of a you know the trusty update or is it you know additional information that we share out at a future um you know presentation so we'll look at that and kind of determine you know what the best you know Avenue of doing that is um just as far as you know specific sort of a plan and a proposal on you know how where you know we're anticipating some of these restrictions you know happening and moving
168forward that will be something that you know we as an Administration will bring forward to you staff will bring that um for your approval and that very likely will happen you know between now and and the May um you know budget proposal so yeah that will all be forthcoming two quick thoughts on that because I think that's a really important point is I you know we are going to be posting this presentation online now that it's been done right would it be possible for some of the board questions like that are easily answerable like the 49 number be put into like that kind of a document I just how that way it's available online so we're it's not just a trustees we we could look at something along those lines yeah I think Josh you
169and I can connect on yeah I mean one fortunate thing that I inherited is all the way back to 20089 the budget book I mean it's really well built this I mean I'll tell you when I first started and started looking through this thing it was very tough for me to absorb but the historical data the historical data that has been kept in this District everything I mean there I have like 87 tabs worth of data that go all the way back uh we have it readily accessible it's all on the website but yeah we could do a summit of paper and share that because my other comment I was just going to make on that and this is again this is not a direction this is a a feeling an emotion I mean I
170am I do well I'll just say similar to the discussion that was brought up about um you know reconfiguring the elementaries for for cost savings I feel the same way about class sizes increasing class sizes I realize the halves and the wants but I I want us to make sure we're exploring all avenues and I know we will but I just want to say like feeling wise that's something that does seem like something we want to do in worst case scenario when we've you know dealt with some of the other things that we might be able to so just a feeling not a Direction but um Josh um in terms of declining enrollment what's the part you mentioned the the universal um preschool so you had an expectation that that was those numbers were going
171to come in higher and um how much higher um and and also beyond that what other kind of declining enrollment is like costing us money so for Universal prek we actually it's a new grade level and the district even though we're lcff funded we do receive an apportionment for upk implementation so that's from the state um and we anticipated the growth of the TK grade level to be oh gosh I would say probably 25% higher than we're realizing Buck wants to jump in so the only reason I want to jump in is because um I helped build the projections when we um started off when we started looking at the TK program and um where we thought that we would wind up settling is um going to be pretty pretty close because we thought that
172where we eventually would get to when the entire year of the four-year-olds were eligible to attend the transitional kindergarten which is going to come next year would be um four transitional kindergarten classes districtwide just um the way that the increases were trending as each three-month period started to attend school we thought that we would probably wind up with uh four you know four times 24 96 students um with the governor um threatening fund the ratio to 1 to 20 this year then that would mean that if we hit 80 students that that that would well anything over you know 60 students would give us the four classes that we you know anticipated so even though the projection was to be at 96 the projection to have four transitional kindergarten classes at this time seems like
173it's folding last minute comments um I'd also like to this isn't exactly for the budget but I would like to have some class- siiz goals for the upper grades to or they're in the contract it's just it's not reflected on the slide should no the maximums are but not the go oh there are not go no so there actually are not secondary goals that's correct it doesn't exist in the contract the goals are set for elementary oh I had I had another question about Dr Adamson made mention that um the projections aren't exactly actual in terms of uh students like we think 100 students are coming to FG and then 90 students come she didn't use those numbers I'm just saying do we know historically like what percentage that is off by or so I
174could so I run uh when I do the enrollment projections I do cohort What's called the cohort survival model I know that sounds weird right but um so there are percentage increases and drop offs associated with each grade level I'm just going to give an example but this isn't the rule um if you look at our fiveyear if you look at our fiveyear average a one-ear average a grade roll a two a three a five and a 10e average that's how we build en rollment projections um looking at the three and fiveyear averages we see that we get drop off from fifth to sixth grade and we get drop off from 8th to ninth grade we also have real weird anomalies which is uh an in like so instead of a like 100% of the
175third graders would move to fourth grade that's a 100% sometimes we have 115% movement right so that is um the that is our uh transient families military families that come in and out of the district they here for a couple of years and they so it's it's it's really hard to to kind of Target those percentage increases and decreases the one that I that I feel has been more consistent is leaving Elementary School going to middle school and leaving middle school and going to high school we do see some drop off and that is you know a decision being made by the families right maybe they I there's many reasons I could go into right um they both parents are teachers at Stevenson so they're going to send their student to Stevenson they've been at
176PG PG middle or you know Forest Grove PG middle and now they're going to go so there's that we do get that I mean depends there's movement right family mo families move out of the area uh it's hard to kind of track that but in my cohort survival uh survival model I have all of those percentages waited on actual movement of grade level students so if you're interested I could sit down and show it to you it's no no that that makes sense but I guess in the past or or presently basically we budget if the if there's one extra kid that we're presuming then we staff for that position is that right and I was wondering if there's maybe like more of a buffer or yeah and that's exactly what I think you know
177we're going to be looking at I mean in particular when we're talking TK because we know that there's a specific ratio we absolutely can't go over we're you know literally fine by the state if we do um you know that's always sort of a little bit more of an unpredictable approach you know we may have you know a certain number of registrations but not necessarily all of those students will show up on the first day of school so sometimes waiting until we can be you know for sure that we've got all of those students you know in in their seats um you know we can make decisions that way um but at the same time also just looking at you know we have that ability to look at past Trends so we kind of get
178a sense of which grades we know you know we can uh be certain if we've got you know 30 students in one particular grade that they're going to be 30 students next year whether will be you know increase or decrease either way um looking at the trends analyzing what the information we have according to it and making the decisions based on that um is really what you know we're anticipating doing going forward just add a little bit of information to you I think that historically the most difficult grade to predict has been a kindergarten and now that ttk is um you know entered the system now that is the most difficult to PR predict so one one of the things um that we do is our um staff calls all the local pre preschools and
179tries to see who has an intent of sending their children either to TK or kindergarten I would say that the projections of the grades following that typically are very accurate yeah that that that they don't VAR by much the only anomaly that I can remember and um it's just because I you know still experienc the pain from it was we had an influx of seventh graders when I was um the principal of PG middle to the point where we did have to um expand all of seventh grade by one section in math English social studies and science um because that's like an entire class of kids coming in we never experienced anything like that before or after but it was just a an anomaly um is a little in inexplicable although I think it was
180tied to the housing crisis and it might have been a return of private private school students so you know yeah there's there has been discussion about possibly having you know combo classes for the Kinder and TK you know level and so that is something that we haven't considered in the past so that would be another you know sort of creative approach to you know our considering it as opposed to then you know opening up a whole another class which will require a whole you know full-time you know teacher for that position as well so I think you know it was said earlier on you know I think the bo what we're hearing from the board and I think you know this is what we feel you know strongly as a staff too is we really
181want to be able to look at you know all possible creative options available to us uh that can really you know obviously ensure the Integrity of the programs that we offer ensure that you know our teachers are able to you know really be able to give their best you know instruction possible with you know reasonable uh numbers in the classroom that's not sort of taxing them um it's you know it's considering all of that involved but at the same time we are tasked with having to make reductions somewhere right and what we do know what I can absolutely guarantee you is that those are not going to be easy decisions you know no matter what it's we're having to let go of something um you know but please know you know whatever that ends up
182being it's going to be you know done with the atmost amount of care and attention and thoughtfulness um you know considering everything possible uh sorry one more question um with the instructional AIDs that you kind of highlighted that we're above average in in that number um is there a possibility of those AIDS floating between the classes like they do they do okay and those numbers don't include the student teachers though right do they the the C right so that might be an opportunity for expansion of programs like that to counteract some of the costs but again creative sorry thinking okay I'm going to make a quick motion that we extend because we're coming close to 10 and we're gonna have to go back to close session so I'm going to make a motion that we
183extend this meeting to 11: PM because Laura doesn't have to work tomorrow she told me no she actually encouraged us too yeah exactly but no in in reality just we have close session to go back to and then we'll have to come back my goal is not to go to 11 but I just want to let folks um at least put that out for the board and anyway second okay we have it on the table all in favor of extending till 11 at the latest please say I I hi it was one Grumble it was still an I pass is 5- z um I think with that we'll go ahead and close this there are a lot of really good questions and just again encourage I really appreciate how the district is being proactive with
184us but also just encourage um keep up with the transparency guys are doing and engaging with everybody at all the sights so thank you all for sticking through and see you again at our next board meeting or or when I gavel out if you're really Brave to stick around reconvening gaveling us out at 1059 after closed session um information was given and D direct yeah information was received and Direction was given thank you guys so much