CorpusRecord 109169

Special Board Meeting January 25, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / PUHSD Media
Date
2025-01-27
Location
Riverside County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
45,955 words · about 256 min
Collected
2026-06-20

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001okay good morning I will call a Paris Union High School District school board meeting to order at 9:11 a.m. I'm going to ask for a roll call to determine a quum trusty Ania here trusty Stafford just Stafford is not here trusty Hall present trusty Garcia here trusty compos God bless you and we have established the Cor the Pledge of Allegiance if you please stand with me to honor our flag put your right hand over your heart ready to begin I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation God invisible liberty and justice for all thank you and now um we're moving to 4.1 invitation to address the board trustees on agendized items are there any public comments on agendized items no public

002comments okay now at this time if possible I'd like to make a motion to have some flexibility with today's schedule there's a couple things that we kind of want to move around um so if anybody like to make that motion we need to we would like to move close session up and also the scheduling for some of the the days events it so that they're not in the order basically go whatever order I'll make a motion second Garcia thank you we'll have to vote um can you roll yeah okay we'll take a roll call vote to amend today's agenda with flexibility trusty anah yes trusty Stafford is not here trusty Hall here no yes or no yes yes is your vote oh I'm sorry we're voting it's a yes or a no I missed so

003he's making an amendment to make Mo close session yeah yes I'm sorry okay so trusty Hall is a yes trusty Garcia yes and trusty compos is a yes so on the vote being taken it's four nothing 4 Z okay [Music] and so now do we move to what close session we're going to move to close session you want to move to close session so let mean and then you said you have dates was that for close session or for open no that dates the schedule so so now that you made a motion we have to accept the motion and go close session right yeah so now is that right Miss H since we're moving close session up we still have to vote on going to close session mhm okay so that's yeah so 88.1 adjourn

004to close session be that it's actually 4.1 4.1 sorry okay 4.1 do I have a motion to adjourn to close session I'll make the motion second thank you and that's any discussion let's take a vote roll call vote I yes but you know what yes because it's not in order okay trusty and yes trusty Hall yes oh I'm sorry I missed trusty Stafford who's not present and then trusty Garcia yes trusty compos yes so upon the vote being taken was 40 we are joury to close session at 9:14 okay 7.1 reconvene in public session special board meeting will reconvene at approximate Chuck make sure you logged in 9:44 Jo the meeting the yeah 8.1 report report out of close session no report out of close session at this time Mr President thank you 9.1 okay

005oral reports 9.1 District Real Property Asset Management presentation thank you good morning good morning morning board members superintendent cabinet for having me here today my name is Serene abrahamian I'm a partner with Orbach Hub and Henderson uh I assist school districts up and down the state with uh facilities matters business matters and I do have a strong specialization in uh District rural property and asset management planning uh and as many of you know and as districts are encountering various issues around generating revenues reing enrollments and having maybe sites that aren't being utilized to their Highest Potential more and more we're being asked to provide input on how districts can plan and and utilize their assets to the to maximize uh revenues and uh assist the district District in providing the programming for its uh its

006students in the most optimal way so often times and uh what we're encountering more and more is that school districts are the largest property owners in the cities and counties that they serve and I think more and more like I said districts are realizing wow these are assets that we can utilize to our benefit to help us not only provide better programming for our students and utilize to to a degree that is more efficient but also to generate long-term revenues and what are the options and opportunities for school districts to be able to do that and often time of course we're asked what does asset management planning mean and it's important to put it in context so managing a District's properties with a priority to school functions for example what's important to that particular ular

007district is it uh more recreational opportunities for their students is it recreational programming uh is it more educational programming and how to manage their school sites in a way and utilize them so they can provide their that programming while of course simultaneously meeting Community needs and creating ongoing revenue streams so there are multiple considerations in doing efficient Asset Management planning what you're going to see in this this presentation is that uh we'll cover the Surplus property statutes so if a district is potentially going to sell or long-term lease there are Surplus statutes under the K12 uh General uh education statutes that guide that process and um and then we will jump into what are the alternatives to the Surplus process and then of course how the funds from both sale and Lease can best be

008utilized by the district so what we typically will start off with is of course we advise our clients to consider not uh that selling District properties is not always the best option and to look at alternatives for how best to retain District property and like I said to potentially develop long-term revenues from that property so jumping into the Surplus statutes again what the Surplus St statutes help districts accomplish is if they're potentially looking to sell property or long-term lease for up to 99 years just some key points selling and long-term leasing can be a little bit of a lengthy process uh because what's required of a school district is to form what's called a 7-Eleven committee so that's a committee that's comprised of between seven and 11 members it's a board appointed committee that's required

009to function pursuant of the brown act so importantly those meetings are open to the public the public can attend and provide their input and with the 7-1 committee's role is is to assess and review the properties that are under their purview and provide recommendations to the board about the best options for those properties and you'll see in further slides that there is a public offering and public bidding component to this process and I did also want to point out that one of the questions we often get is do Charter schools get what's called a right of first refusal under those public offering procedures it used to be that Charter Schools got the first right of first refusal under the public offering requirements but that law has sunsetted as of July 1 2016 and no longer

010applies so what are the steps for Surplus and we'll cover it in three categories so the first step after a board gets a recommendation report from from a 7-Eleven committee and the 7-Eleven committee has recommended to Surplus property or maybe it hasn't the board is not bound to follow what's in the recommendation report that's a recommendation and then the board can make a determination of what it wants to do next with the property so the first step is for the board to declare the property Surplus and when that occurs the next two steps uh are initiated so the second step in the Surplus process is the public offering and notice requirement so you see there that certain public agencies get what we just described as the right of first refusal so uh it would be

011the cities and counties where that property is located but in addition you see the UC regions CSU public housing authority and those notices have to go out by of course being published in the newspaper um and then uh the the Surplus resolution is also uh either published in full or there's a link to that so that the community has access to it and by direct mailed notice also the local planning agency gets notice that the property is available for uh either sale or lease whatever is specified in the notice and if there's a recreational aspect or use on the site and there are certain requirements that have to be satisfied for the nailer act to kick in then recreational agencies also get a right of first refusal and then you see there that it's typically

012a 40 to 60 day time frame for these public agencies to respond and I do want to be clear the district is not required to sell or lease to a public agency it's a arms length process if the district is interested in pursuing that public agency's offer assuming it gets one then it can continue down that that road and negotiate just like you would in a regular transaction with a private entity me can you I know we're kind of in a quy form here so can't really you kind of interject as a but can you walk the board through an example just simple example or an illustration as to the district put up this property here for ground lease and then what the city of parents could do kind of walking through that example of

013that scenario so they'll get a chance to understand what is the first R of refusal I'm looking at a couple of them they're nodding their heads but what does that mean and and so the the brown example is a little tricky because we have an opportunity to enter into ground Lees without complying with all these steps if we do it under the alternative statute okay but but given the example that would require under the Surplus statutes again once the board deems property Surplus and the the Surplus resolution authorizes that the property you put out for example in the case that that M asked so the board would deem through a resolution yes right they would vote up so the staff would work with you you bring a resolution to the board the board will then

014vote the resolution to deem the property go ahead Surplus okay they go from there okay so what that authorizes is this step two which is the public offering process the entities that we mentioned all get notice at the same time including city and county yes okay with all the respect and I understand what you were saying that you noce some m with their faces why and again with all the respect for everybody why don't we ask them what is the question what what is their concern of what do they have or if they have any questions if that's what they want to know because what you are saying is what you think the war is thinking right so my recommendation would be if there is anything if you can provide the opportunity for them to

015ask if they want to know more of these or or something more more cuz just call my attention I can see in their faces but they're here they can tell us so um just as a response number one I appreciate you're interjecting in the situation because the reality is a lot of this stuff is new to all of us and so I I think that the request and the ask to give an example is fitting and helpful to us because you know for me when it's when it's label we have multiple buildings within the district that we don't have I mean we know what they are what they're labeled but not necess neily how they're properly used or not there's been changes in staff and Personnel so I do appreciate that and sometimes you know

016you can read body language better because I I know when a lot of that was being said I was kind of stuck on the nailor ACT because of the school property and playground so I do appreciate the injection and making sure that we understand through an example of how the process would go because I would have never known okay so well how does that happen and he clearly explained it would be a resolution so thank you and I do appre app I have to comment on that too I'm glad you asked that because I didn't know we have that authority to deem it as Surplus and that that's big so thank you because I know we also have land at one of our other properties that looks like a park but it's our property yes

017yeah thank you and and actually just I think to everyone's point one of the really good places to start with Asset Management planning and speaking to kind of putting that process in context is really doing what is the UN of properties the district owns and it's actually interesting because when we do that leg work of course the district team can provide based on the information they have what that that Universal list is but it's interesting that when you pull that information through some of the title databases sometimes districts end up owning more than they think they own or like uh we've had a circumstance where in an adjacent District the the district was actually the owner of uh there were three apms that comprised the High School site and they actually own the the center

018parcel because proper transaction structures hadn't occurred where that property was deed to the the new school district so sometimes it's a paperwork issue but there's sometimes ways that of course we can get more information by pulling those lists and it's very very helpful as a first step um so uh in the example that we were talking about uh the district would then issue the district team would issue to the public agencies and the other uh required agencies uh the opportunity What's called the public offering to make a bid or proposal on that ground leas opportunity and of course the district would have to provide the parameters of what they're looking for and some detail but then it moves forward like a regular negotiation process depending on how many offers you get and you're not bound

019to specific uh public agency and you're not bound to sell it period to a public agency so then we can move to the next step which is the formal bidding process so under the Surplus statutes there is an opportunity then as a third step for the district to receive bids in open session for the potential sale or lease transaction and there is a whole of course as you can imagine procedural framework for how that occurs um it's I do want to point out that a lot of districts are starting to stray from this particular procedure because it it is a little bit cumbersome for districts to administer and the the whole idea of receiving bids in Open Session that get open um publicly is sometimes not the easiest for boards to administer and so with

020that in mind a lot of districts are now seeking waivers from the State Board of Education of the formal bidding requirements and what the request to the State Board of Education would be from the district team assuming that the board authorized it is that the district uh uh the the formal bidding procedures be waved and that the district be allowed to put the property out through request for proposal process so it's a little more informal you have more control over the process the district can of course identify all of the important terms and conditions and request proposals that meet those requirements um and we're finding that the State Board of Education is more and more readily granting those waivers so question on that so now on on the bids those bids would come into to

021the superintendent superintendent would then present it to the CBO and then they would then present it to the board as offering bidding or under the waiver process under the I guess the waiver process so it would be uh through typic your business office uh the RFP would be issued just like for example you know for the various procurements that the business office administers um and then the proposals would be received and actually the the RFP document will outline what the steps will be for how the proposals are considered of course there's you have the option of including interviews as part of that process but yes proposals would be receive and then the district would review to see which one meets the needs and and best interests of the district and then recommendations would be brought

022to the board for for a selection no and you had mentioned earlier about the the public and and not having to rent or or lease or sell to the public um is there any benefit to going outside the Private Industry and just or or does it it just depend on the situation because sometimes I'm assuming if it's you know A Private Industry trying to come in they're trying to generate money and profit so that land could be beneficial for them to do that as opposed to a public entity who's not really looking to make profit does it matter one way or the other yes definitely at the beginning of this process it's important to weigh all those considerations in some cases depending on the type of property it is and what the district's long-term goal

023and interests are we will recommend that the district go through a public offering process offer it to public agencies see where that takes them and then seek a waiver after that the the district does have the opportunity to also seek a waiver of the public offering procedures so in some cases if it makes more sense to just go out to the private entities directly um then uh the waiver can be brought uh to wave both uh uh public bidding I'm sorry uh public offering and public bidding procedures and go straight to an RFP got it thank you me the waiver goes to who the State Board of Education CDE yeah and and and M to my earlier point that more and more we're seeing these granted you do have to get into uh the waiver

024like a cue though because so many waivers are being brought to the State Board of Education sometimes you can't get on their agenda for the very next meeting even if you submit timeline used to be two months in advance and now we kind of have to plan ahead to make sure we meet their so the state board controls a lot or has a final say so a lot especially with the charters am I Am I Wrong um with the definitely with the Property Disposition yes and the types of waivers we're talking about I think maybe Marley can cover more what their purview is around we could wait yeah yeah we're good okay so last question so to Mr Garcia's Point who owns the school district property dist school district and you hold it in Trust

025of the state right correct which is why the state has the authority I just want to make sure we're all on no no that's great thank you the state we hold the property in Trust of the state yeah which is why they have to involve yourself in the process correct correct yes perfect thank you I think you read my mind on that one I know you people and thank you for that clarification yes thank you so moving into the alternatives to S Surplus um there is uh as we'll see statutes that allow for short and long-term leasing without going through all of the Surplus procedures we just cover and I'm just going to touch on those here I know these are some dense slides but I wanted to have the information there for the board

026uh and for the district team so that they can really uh uh spend some time with it uh after after today okay oh so you'll email it to us yeah perfect thank you I think the district team has has it all right thank you um so there is an opportunity for districts to do short-term leasing uh this is not a process that requires an rqp or request for qualifications and proposal or request for proposal procedure where the District offers it to multiple agencies or multiple private entities you are allowed to essentially Soul Source these if there's an interested party that wants to enter into maybe a short-term parking lot lease or use a couple of your classroom facilities uh and have uh the sole use of those of those facilities you can enter into this

027short-term lease structure it's got a 5-year term limit associ ated with it there there is an exception if Capital outlay Improvements are being made by uh for Park and Recreation purposes by public entities or nonprofits the really good component of these statutes is that the district can seek fair market rent so in other words the district as a best practice should do some leg work to establish what is the fair market value of that particular property in terms of being able to lease it at fair market rents and have that data and information in their files and be able to negotiate from a place of being informed um and then of course what the boards would be doing is making findings you see those findings on the bottom of the slide uh importantly that the

028the proposed use doesn't uh interfere with educational programs or activities of any school or class where the leasing is occurring does not unduly disrupt the residents of the neighborhood and does not jeopardize the safety of children in school so those are important findings those would be brought to the board in a resolution format and uh the lease if if approved uh would hinge on those findings being made I don't know if this is kind of going off but is that why churches rent properties from school district that falls under that um it could be that or it could be a Civic Center use depending on what the purpose of the of the use is by the church okay yeah thank you which we we don't really cover the Civic Center under this presentation but of

029course that that's we can come back with that addition the churches that use our facilities are under the civer so we do have churches yes oh okay I knew another District what thank for answering that okay that's good no no that's good information thank you would that be temporary not permanent it's not permanent considered please for shortterm for shortterm they churches don't qualify like as a nonprofit or anything so they have to pay Fair rental value when they're leasing from us different than like um like a youth sports league would get a different rate oh okay and those would be detailed in your policies too I'm sure you have detailed policies around that would that be something we vote on too I'm sorry oh okay thank you you have board policy that outlines that um

030in ter also in terms of the discounted rate that we get to to use off the top of my that I'm not going to remember the so I'll pull it up but it's as long as like the youth sports or I'm saying sports but it could be any Youth Organization has I think it's like 50% of their roster coming from within the district and they get an even deeper um discounts we actually have three rates and the threee Oh So like um Boy Scouts PT clubs all under free and then we go all the way up to like the church example I didn't know that thank you thank you so and we have a policy manual as well for our potential applicant so that they have because there's a lot of liability that could be

031included I don't need to steer off of your presentation those are really good points yeah and actually I was going to seg way into uh The Joint use we just covered we do have uh kind of this hybrid agreement between uh Civic Center uses and Joint use if maybe it's a longer term use by an uh by maybe a local community organization like what you were describing so three of these board members would have approved what you're talking about with the city of meny to run their Aquatics program so that's an example okay now I know I'm sure you remember that yeah well I do now now I'm putting it together okay thank you I'm just trying to help you know no you're doing great things together for you appreciate that yeah so on the

032short term lease on the previous slide that was the finding so if let's just say for example we wanted to partner with UC Riverside or or caly San Marcos the local the closest universities but if we were to use like our um adult school building to let's just say there was a need in the community to want to enroll in some classes then we could figure out some kind of enrollment or lease so that they could people don't have to go all the way down to UC Riverside or San Marcus if that was the case um so we could potentially go into an agreement with a short-term lease to say hey to see if this works out for our community members that way and it would be I'm and I'm just using the adult school

033as a um as an example because then you wouldn't have the issue with the the students during day and you know the adults and having them with the findings on on campus mixing kids and adults and all that other stuff with the bu buildings okay yes you can definitely do that and actually I'll just skip ahead real quick but I want to I do want to come back to join occupancy but the community recreation act depending on what the partnership is with the public agency for the use of the facility or the site you do have options under the um community recreation act to uh enter into agreements with cities and um and other public agencies uh for uh potential development of recreational opportunities and recreational is defined broadly under these statutes so like performing

034art centers for example you could procure under these statutes if you wanted to potentially put those out as a leasing opportunity you have my wheels spinning right now and and I'm loving all the information now I have another question because it was proposed a while back what if a political party wants to have some type of meeting at one of our facilities would that fall under temporary leasing as well yes okay are we like Ro shoing yeah please go ahead because I know some of the details of that are very specific to the school district so the short answer is yes Civic Center act um but there are so they can do those things because they're paying you know the the market raid and that sort of thing we have to be careful aside from

035that as the school district organization administrators all the way down to staff and board members um in terms of political activities we we can't have those and host those on our our campuses um but um an agency could come in to hold a meeting they could hold a um so many of these a debate you know one of our campuses and then they would be essentially renting the facility for C that that's good information thank you guys are on fire today good job I fire every day right I just met her today but you're meshing yes sir Mr President just want one last point they can also have liquor oh also because you're weting the facility the law says it not saying I'm going to rent it for that I'm just you know I'm curious

036okay can rent a facility you're witing the facility you're paying the rate right so and the law change so and the attorney no problem with that well and actually there are some other new Civic Center uh updates as well so I think with all the questions we're getting it would probably be helpful maybe working with the district team to bring additional information on well I'm not saying we're going to do anything anything like that I'm just I'm asking the questions because I've heard these things and I'm like I have no idea yeah yeah well you know I think that's a great point because personally I think Paris is probably Paris High School probably has the nicest theater in the area um and just knowing that that could be see I would have never known that

037you know what I mean but that's obviously if there's a way to generate funds and obviously we would have to you know figure out you know um the best use of that but it's good to know that it's good to know that there's options and so there are options that you can accept and options that you can decline so uh that's good information because I would have never know I mean I obviously want to use that theater just Community wise just to use it as much and as often as possible you know and obviously if there's a way to generate Revenue then so be it you know but because it's a beautiful facility so that's great information today so that's funny you're saying that cuz I'm I'm like nodding my head in agreement with you

038because that's what I'm thinking revenue revenue revenue to help with what we're talking about you know yeah I think we're all on the same page you're looking at me like you know what I'm saying okay did you want to add something I was not I mean I wasn't planning but I can anything I Mr Garcia we were kind of yeah yeah totally so um this is an exciting one I do want to spend a minute here the joint occupancy statute so to Mr H's earlier point about ground leasing there is an opportunity for the district to enter into long-term ground leases for up to 99 years without taking all the steps under the Surplus statutes and what's unique about this alternative to the Surplus property process is that uh it does require that the district

039maintain a presence on the site so the district can work with the private entity and developer you know the The Entity because typically this will be a a what we call a public private uh transaction and public private um why am I I'm public private partnership partnership thank you Mr Aly public private partnership that uh allows for the development of the school district property with a district use component so District test flexibility around what that could be whether it's meeting rooms whether it's you know in some cases we've had a district needs a safe data center a district needs uh to maintain a recreational space on that site for XYZ purpose or because let's say that's a real need in the community so those things the developer can bring to the table as part of

040their overall proposal and build into the transaction and we have very many districts who are going this route now because because it's a very uh open and transparent process for how you move through the procurement of the ground lease and it gives the district opportunities to improve its properties with a district use uh component on the site so just to kind of run through a little bit about the procedure we have what's called a resolution of intention that the board would approve that would put the community on notice that the district is going to issue uh a request for proposal seeking proposals for the site for a long-term ground lease um of course the district will then go through the proposal process similar to what we were talking through earlier at a subsequent meeting the

041board will receive all of the proposals that were made and make a determination and the standard here is not what's the highest uh Revenue that's being proposed or least rate that's being proposed it's what best meets the needs of the district so there is some flexibility around selecting the proposer and the that basically would meet the needs of the district in terms of whether it's that District space of course the revenue that's being generated you would consider the long-term um uh experience that the developer has in this area and if they've developed other properties things like that so um so like I said it's it's more and more this is being utilized by districts and I did want to make just an additional point sometimes districts are a little bit worried about it considering this

042transaction transactional structure because you used to have to go to the State Board of Education for approval all of those requirements have now been weighed so the decision making Authority for joint occupancy ground leases is now absolutely with the District board so Mr abim can you give them some conrete examples of what's happening today in Southern California give them examples of districts what they're doing so they can they can have a perspective because it may generate some questions because the objective of the exercise is for them to ask questions and be able to kind of sort of wrap their minds around some of this which is brand new to many so um what we're seeing of course there's a housing need in Southern California and for many of our Southern California districts uh the highest

043and best use for uh let's say property that would potentially be offered out for ground lease under joint occupancy would be a multi-residential housing project so the RFP would be issued with a general description of that that that's what the district is seeking proposals on and the district could then also identify what their Community need is as part of that process so we have examples in real time right now that are being developed where it's multi-residential and next to it for the districts use it's a a advanced state-of-the-art Recreational facility or Child Development Center that's being referred Rish maybe an existing site that needed some upgrades that the developer is paying towards so there are a lot of examples of different ways that that this particular transactional structure is being utilized and in the best

044interest of districts so if a mall developer approach the district could they entertain Macy's Target Walmart could they entertain Condominiums Apartments Etc wow that's crazy I never knew that I'm bringing that up because San Francisco UniFi owns the land that the Westfield Mall sits on in San Francisco you went to the csba conference they own that land so you get this an example then Albert also has a transaction going on Albert UNIF here a transaction going on with so that's ongoing revenue for them it is enormous on so we to expound on that and she's worked some of these deals in her day go ahead yes um of course any potential use can be considered on the site of course the district would want to do its own analysis about the highest inv best use

045and what could generate the most revenue and be in the district's best interest but talking about Revenue so I'm not saying we should go out and do it right now but would it be wise to purchase land and sit on it and then because you know our area is growing rapidly very rapidly you know I'm not saying it's the richest or the poorest but it's growing rapidly and it's bringing everyone in and as you said we're bringing in developers and I know we've talked about a little bit about this in the past so would you say that would be wise to consider if we have the funds for it that's definitely one Avenue another what we're seeing also in addition to that type of consideration analysis is if you have uh underutilized space on your

046existing campuses this doesn't have to be an all or nothing thing if you have maybe four or five acres that you could potentially redevelop through a process like this you can offer that out and see what the market bears and and in in some of the examples that uh Mr Al was speaking to uh that is exactly what's being done it's not for the entire School site because it could let's say be an active School site but there's a portion of it that's very underutilized that can potentially be put out for uh proposals like we could even rent out part of our property to for example RC rcoe for their facilities and what they use and operate Yes actually we've negotiated those leases oh with the county yeah wow so thank you Yes W money

047everywhere huh just one question Mr you mentioned that we are in the same page right so in terms of that in M mentioned an example of San Francisco and how that but probably this question from is R do we have some properties that we can replicate what Ma was mentioning is the district that we have so we can start acting upon those yeah you seren is talking about underutilized sites and then vacant land as well so so to answer your question we have I mean the most obvious is the vacant land that we bought for Middle School to back in 2013 I think I could be off by a year but over Metta area Mar maretta the city maretta the street um over in the Paris Elementary District obviously um so that was intended to

048build a second Middle School one we bought that when enrollment at penotti had Peak to 1457 wow um which is far too large for a middle school after R Us I believe you were this was a long time ago you were at P Middle School um then we have a sea of Portables you know everywhere so that was part of our then facilities master plan um we've retained that site I think one of your first bullets was sometimes it's not always the wisest move to sell excess property I know I mentioned to the board before we have to go through um a process through um me PSC in declaring it Surplus every year um or CDE or I've had very little this week as no no we know we know yes yes and we thank

049you for that I know this sounds odd yeah thank you I know thank you for not getting so a little Grace if I'm off by a year yeah yeah but anyway so we have to declare that as Surplus so that so that's one piece of property um we also um you were talking about like how the different APNs sometimes are work and so over where our alternative education campus parley high schools a scholar Plus in the adult ed behind that facility is what's known as Rotary Park yeah and we own um I I can't remember if that's two or three different APN but the point is we own part of it in the city of Paris owns part of it and together those Parcels um through through joint use operate as Rotary Park um you

050may now be asking what about Panther Park and panther Park is not owned by the district it's through another joint use um it's owned by the City of Paris and utiliz and maintain um so like we do the grounds work there by uh the school district so that's an expenditure then for us because at one point we were talking about putting cameras surveillance cameras because what's happened on that property yeah yeah so like so how much on a year would you just ref rough estimate I can't rough estimate okay well maybe in the near future you get I Can Can rough estimate how much money we put into Personnel costs of time spent um for for grounds I can work with Hector on that um I think that's important with what we're talking about yeah

051and so and that's sort of the trade-off right when you do a joint use you know it kind of has to be fair uh you know I'm not talking in legal terms now I'm just t or maybe we we could consider working with the city of Paris and building a facility to accommodate the public like a community center of some sort right there and create Revenue certainly could see what the need laundry School District in that vure utilize it we have extra athletic spes that I I think we're all this land we're talking about and I'm trying to say it publicly so it's out there I think we need to T those facilities and look at it and maybe we could brainstorm together and maybe I don't know if you want to participate but I

052think it' be wise and we come up with ideas that create more revenue for us and then in terms of underutilize sites it would be my opinion that we don't have underutilized sites that is not the same as saying if we were to take a field trip and open the door of every single classroom and office space at every single campus you might not find you know a couple a handful from campus is empty yeah but what's what's not empty today might not be tomorrow I got I got yeah yeah thank you thank you everybody this is a great information so do you consider the link for the middle school can we explore what possibilities can we explore the possibilities potential possibilities to get some Revenue yeah we can always explore that since there are

053no facilities on that property it I believe can tell agree with us limits our possibilities because you know we can't nobody really wants the lease or you know use for BAC land unless you're going to build something on it or use it as an investment or something like that yeah and and sometimes what we see there is uh there are maybe uh folks in the neighborhood that want to potentially lease it for parking or for other uses um and and I do want to point out too and that's actually good point that even if it's a vacant land if we're going to think about like doing a long-term lease develop project uh very many districts on a parallel track explore shorter term lease opportunities for that site so in the interim while the longer term

054development is being considered and and and uh moved forward that there's an opportunity to get short-term lease Revenue in the door from that site and if I could you mind if I could just inter a little more things since I was talking about all the different types of property and trying to give real life examples in our district so um in 2019 and 20 um what seren was talking about in the very beginning we we did own a piece of property at forgetting the address on D Street um back in the days the Old Post Office exactly what I was going to say OG people like you and I call that the Old Post Office yeah yeah um I like that OG that's a term of by the way um we uh the school district

055uh used that uh for a charter school that is no longer a charter it's another dependent Charter School Mary so can we raise the temperature if they're all cold please it's it's on its way up oh okay that was a short TR fix um I lost my train of Cl so we used to have a charter school choice 2000 Charter School at s closed like CMI as a dependent Charter School uh in part meaning they were utilizing a district owned facility and I know talked a little bit about I know you'll go into more detail on this the 1% and the 3% oversight Factor Mary will go more into that way I know she will um they were utilizing one of our facilities they closed down and we were not utilizing that facility so initially

056what we did is we leased that facility to a private individual who used it as office space right um and so we did that through one of the processes you were talking about we did a public you know bid open only got one bid so that wasth L rental income that we had and then we sold it right and then and so you were on the board you were the board president at the time I pulled up the resolution yeah so we we went through that process where the board declares it um you know as Surplus we have the 7-Eleven um committee they made their recommendation we offered it for sale to the governmental agencies um City of Paris ultimately through the entire through the long as you're right a long processess um we sold

057that to the City of Paris um and so and there's I can't remember if you covered this there specific uses for those dollars you can't you can't just put it in the general fund last one oh sorry I getting no no no I'm glad you're covering it but the lock change you definitely want to talk about that change in lockers you have that yeah and this was back in 2020 when the sale was finalized so it was so we have to use that fors essentially and that's what we did thank you okay I think I'm done sorry no problem that's all very good information thank you um just moving through these Alternatives uh as we're talking through how the district can prct your vises so there is the fee generating statutes under the government code

058this is again another public private uh type of partnership uh and and contemplates that as the as the structure but we typically will use this for um for example cell tower leases because we're talking about you know how does this the a district generate Revenue outside the box opportunities um and in addition to that we also have Billboards uh Billboards are generating quite a bit if you have property that uh is adjacent to a highway and you can do a double-sided digital billboard those will sometimes generate um and and actually we're doing a couple right as we speak and just recently got some comps approximately $300,000 a year just for not one structure yeah so um so we have and and the reason why this is a really good uh statutory scheme is because it

059does have pretty robust auditing requirements uh that the district can demand certain things of the private entity that's utilizing the district's facilities and has a maximum term of up to 35 years so it does give the district some flexibility on uh the leas term I said I was interjecting we to have cell to relases what about the digital billboard because CMI is right there by the freeway right and and so is the Park yeah I was thinking of student service center yeah yeah yeah yeah but no we don't have any of that we'll ask questions later about how much all that stuff costs yeah and and you do have a RFQ or RFP uh requirement for utilizing these statutes okay so that's good because it's a public and transparent process for procuring the billboard project

060we did touch on the community wreck act I just wanted to revisit this for a second again it authorizes cities and school districts to enter into agreements for recreational uses like the Performing Arts Center what we discussed and this actually is good because it doesn't have a term limit so the joint use has 5 years the fee generating has 35 we talked about uh uh ground of up to 99 years this doesn't really give you guidance on the lease term so you have flexibility when entering into agreements with other uh public agencies I did want to cover exchange transactions I don't know if the school district has engaged in any exchanges but uh just like on the private side public uh entities like school districts can uh exchange real property for the real property of

061another entity and what we're seeing here is that of course because a lot of districts are trying to pursue Revenue generating opportunities if the district has an underutilized site or a site that maybe they feel like potentially serve a better purpose they will exchange that for let's say uh a multi-residential uh complex that's generating revenues or a commercial a property that has commercial leases on uh that are associated with it um we did one recently where Starbucks is on the site along with some other commercial uses so you're exchanging into property that's already got uh Revenue that's being generated through long-term leases yes you guys are so good at saying things and just like I said my my wheels are spinning so for example we were talking about performing arts and then you brought that

062up Paris High School has a wonderful theater are we able to like rent that out to the city for their use usage as well really yes so we can make money there too wow yeah that would be for civic center could be for joint use but yeah like you know special events that they have wow because we have parking we have the infrastructure they need most typically um off the top of my head I don't think we have any churches using that facility but that those are generally the facilities that churches want to utilize and they do at Pala and Heritage and we even have churches um renting L High School Church I I know one of the conversations we've had with City personnel is we want everybody to want to come to Paris if

063we had a Performing Arts Theater open to the public that would create a lot of Revenue they could have plays here we could bring all of that over here to Paris and you know Tula wouldn't be the highlight Paris would be the highlight we're already talking about CMI yes sir when I was in uh B when we created the Performing arent we actually came into agreement with a red theater company so they can utilize the new for the guess what your new job assignment is today no I'm just kid yeah that's a great idea actually so that's a question that I was going to ask about um you know when you mentioned the the recreation act so I I know that one of our um things that we want to do is we want to

064build a football stadium or or replace it CMI but now so in thinking and yeah this is like our heads are spinning because so let's just say for example I know Snoop has uh organized football leagues but if we wanted to partner with someone like him and his organization he'd be willing to do it to Joint use with our our facility so that we get obviously facilities for our students and our community but then we can also build it on a partnership where we're growing you know football or promoting football now on on that sense who would be the the ones in NE would that be something that you guys or is it our staff that kind of goes out and makes the connections the connections and the Partnerships or is it all everybody together

065I think we'd work hand in hand like first to establish what the parameters are but we're actually negotiating something very close to that with a local um a baseball group for one of our districts they want to it's an underutilized site that the district owns that has Fields but the fields are dilapidated so they want to come on make quite a few improvements so we have to assess like what is the value of the improvements that they're proposing um so then we can calculate what's a fair amount of rent also considering the district Civic Center fees that are charged um yeah so we we and then we would do a a lease agreement with that entity where the district has the opportunity to also utilize those fields at certain times and and it details all

066of that Mr abim just to supplement his president's question and your answer so yes the District staff will make the partnership I give an example comp College as a partners with Major League Baseball Major League Baseball invested Millions on a facility on the campus as a part of a joint occupany there several other districts around uh you can sell naming rights you can sell the name on the auditorium to whomever for x amount of million to put the name that's Revenue generator it's been done trust me I've done it and so then you go on down to other partis the staff is really responsible not the attorney for making those relationships and getting out there generating whether it's leveraging their Logistics Hub there's a tremendous amount of companies Hondas around here list goes on and

067on staff be responsible do but they're just making sure that the deal is all legally sound yeah way down the line yeah way down the line but again because of where you live you have vard up the way I mean just just a lot of Partnerships could be established a Napa Nappa School District as well as the Community College world class programs because they partner with v around that science right as a part of CTE so it can be done just what you can name yeah yeah okay so I'll just up on the exchange piece real quick so as far as uh the process for approving an exchange a 2third vote of the board is required but you would move through approving an exchange project similar to how purchase and sale transactions are approved it's

068a similar structure so just wanted to point out that this is also available to District as a transactional structure outside of the Surplus statutes um the use of proceed slide um so just generally speaking the district has the most flexibility with these proceeds which is why that is being considered more and more by school districts because then that could potentially be utilized for general fund purposes but it's as the board direct whereas if you're looking at Revenue let's say from the sale of surplus property that would be deposited into I'm just going to use a a shortcut phrase the facilities fund and go into facilities improvements and it's more restricted so you have the absolute most flexibility with lease proceeds and I think to Mr Al's earlier point about the type of Revenue the amount

069of Revenue that's being generated off some of these long-term ground leases for example for the joint occupancy projects I mean hundreds of thousands of dollars ath a month and and you know really getting to the point where then the district can potentially consider borrowing against those income streams as well if it wants to do like a cops financing structure or something like that to then develop uh it property something else that it needs like a district office or something along those lines so can you give them an example of the CU you know what help I know what will help this group is give them real a real example of Charles Drew the county how much money was deposited in escro walk them through that so they can understand exactly what you're referencing yeah they

070want the dollars and sense okay great the Charles Drew project is a really good example so that's actually a public public private transaction so we've got the county the school district and then the Charles Drew University as a private university that's partnered under a joint occupancy structure um to develop a closed School site that the district owns and actually the county has also contributed a small piece of property to the to the project as well and the the long-term goals for that site are to assist the Charles Drew University in having more space for its students some student housing some commercial uses but also some recreational opportunities on the site for both the district students the county and employees that are you know in the adjacent areas and uh as an upfront payment there uh

071what's what was negotiated for that project was approximately between 10 and 15 million upfront and then of course uh uh robust lease payments through the term of the lease and so it's satisfies the community good aspect it helps the the neighboring uh businesses and community and then also generates the revenue for the school district and for the county so on that one it's the draw of the Charles Drews use use of advancing the university and then the benefit goes to the the two public entities who own the property okay so okay I know you asked a lot of questions throughout but if there are more questions I'm happy to take them so whenever we um rent our facility out uh the insurance part of it the person that's Renning they bring in their own insurance

072or do we have to cover part of that so it's pretty much like a rental insurance and stuff like that yeah and the district will have certain requirements for you know meeting the insurance okay so we have guideline that we need to we do and and not even a guideline they're policies right okay yeah as an example if they're utilizing our pool they have to have much higher limits obvious so we Reas do a walk through like they use our auditory right hey look this seat wasn't torn when you left and we gave it to you yeah so all that stuff yeah we have all of that in our and they they sign all kinds of wavers and it also depends on which type of feet you know if they're using one of our synthetic

073turfs you know kind shoes you know can they put on gym floors um we had a CO addendum we have people signing so that we weren't responsible for any transmission of Co back that you know it's it's an intense process but we we we have to make sure that we are protecting the district when outside people come in and in the contract they can select the extra services that they would like oh yes good point that is another thing maybe we can U ring you a records of the leases that we have done to different Community organizations here for the board to know and a copy of the contract so they have an idea of what we already have have in place right so we already have that in place but something that is really

074interesting for this presentation I would like to know those examples in that M was mentioned they share with them about the amount of money what is something that we can identify here right because different District different situations but something here that we might be able to replicate or or to act on those examples right because just knowing that something was happening there is good is a good thing but how can we is it possible to do this year what would be the next step in order to explore those possibilities trusty G did you have no I'm good thank you you know what actually um I got a couple things uh because you actually brought something to my attention and then to kind of connect with with what Makai said so so for example it ikia

075that you were partnering with yeah so maybe we name you know or we asked hey would you guys like Paris Theater you know a nominal fee how about we negotiate yeah but that's what I'm saying I think you know we have uh dealerships car dealerships here um that we could you know not knowing that we could have done that and now um knowing that we potentially can I mean we have beautiful facilities that you know we we can now partner with and I would have never known without having this presentation the commentary there and you bringing your building your relationships with the local community and Industry which is great and this I know for me um it helps me to consider you know moving forward maybe with a bond in 2026 I know at the

076time 2024 just it was a in our our opinion at the time was wasn't a good time a lot of different things were going on but I think obviously new Administration going on new different things going on um to look at it because now that I think about land acquisition and purchase um it could be short-term long term and so obviously it depends on and obviously the community's interest in where you know they're obviously because they're they're are Partners in it and in the taxation of it but um you know sometimes we're going declining enrollment but when I look at you know from Paris to mene there's a lot of land yeah a lot of land which you know in Southern California there is there's only a couple places where there's a lot of land

077that can be developed and so now it just kind of gives me a new interest in thinking hey what can we do in the preparation of anticipating student growth I mean right now we're de declining enrollment as a state but it's not to say that within the next two to four years that things don't change and that those now properties are something that are valuable you know for us as well as the community depending on how the development goes but um thank you for the presentation because I know for me it gives me a lot of different ideas and a different perspective on kind of how to approach things uh but obviously the sooner we approach it you know I mean now I'm starting to think okay well now let's look at 26 um and

078just see where it goes from there and in the process I'm sure that we'll be working with our team to figure out what assets we have and and then what role you guys will play and I know that you guys will walk hand inand with that and make sure that uh it's in the best interest of the district so so thank you for the presentation and all the different ideas and conversation it was greatly appreciated yeah and and we will uh provide at least through the title searches what the district owns that's relatively easy for us to pull and I think it's a really good starting point just to confirm that you have that full universe so M just we don't want the superintendent's point to be lost superintendent wants to Step One just so

079we're clear Step One is you're going to provide all of the assets correct and then you're going to detail if they're in the unincorporated area of Riverside County city of miny City of Paris correct and they'll have a chance to understand what the real estate portfolio is absolutely all the zoning etc etc plus you give them the Paris City Paris and Min housing element yes and and and the zoning of the I want to say thank you you started reading my mind that's what I was going to say next absolutely thank you yeah thank you that was that was excellent oh yeah okay moving along oh sorry wants to char give me a break and I'll come back you guys do that be fine yeah other duties as a you know what's funny I didn't

080know the Ral Brown okay I just knew the brown I didn't know Ralph so uh Ralph and brown ACT public meeting laws and rules governing board members so just to provide some cont context uh we do of course also give similar presentations to board appointed committees and these rules do apply to both boards and committees and we'll touch a little bit on that as we're going through the presentation um we in addition to of course providing the purpose and the background of the brown act uh we will focus on what constitutes a meeting under the brown act and then there are actually some very interesting new laws that we will cover as part of the presentation um so the Ralph and brown act uh the open meeting Act was enited enacted in 1953 it of

081course provides a procedural framework for boards to meet debate act and listen to their constituency and the goals are of course to have in an open and transparent fashion keeping the public informed and giving the public an opportunity and enough information to attend the meetings and be a partic participant in in the process of the legis ative work that and in your case the work of the board so Brown Act applicability of course it's an important point and we try to remind committee members and board members that there is an expectation that they know and conform their conduct to the brown act this is even before taking office so and to keep up with the requirements and the laws under the brown act and importantly we want to emphasize that that's why these gr act

082trainings occur as regularly as they do because of course uh School District board members want to stay as informed as possible about the updates in the law we often get the question and I touched on it a second ago about does the brown act apply to standing committees in addition to en Force the board in your case if you've appointed a a a committee a standing committee like typically the 7-Eleven committee that we just covered in the prior presentation the citizens Bond oversight committee those meetings are public meetings those committees function under the brown act and have to adhere to those procedural Frameworks so typically good rule of thumb is if the advisory committee or standing committee has continuing subject matter jurisdiction fixed meeting schedules and was created by resolution which is typically how those

083committees are formed then of course they have to adhere to the BR act requirements and Mr just as we walk through an exercise yes I'm president Campos I want to create a committee a facilities committee I would bring a resolution to the board to create the committee the board would approve the committee and I will make appointments to the committee if I Appo just two board members do we have to post that meeting if it's if it's a standing committee with continuing subject matter jurisdiction yes board appointment how about a blue ribbon just we're going to meet one time and never again no because that does not have a continuing purpose oh good to know yeah so there are committees that are formed outside of the brown act parameters and requirements uh another really good

084example superintendent advisory committees there's more loose requirements around that because that that's typically to get to a recommendation to provide to the superintendent those committees are generally not formed Brown act committees but you can still have in detailed of course what type of membership you want represented on that committee like that so in terms of the what we were just describing a second ago what constitutes a meeting under the brown act a meeting is when a majority of members of a board uh meet to hear discuss the at or take action on any item that is within that board's subject matter jurisdiction and I I want to point out I think it's easy to think about doing that here in a room right where you're all gathered together but uh it's important to also think

085about it more in kind of our modern world where a lot of uh communication also occurs via social media by telephone by you know so so we want to think about if the the board has to be very conscious about what activities it's engaging in that could potentially lead to a collective concurrence or decision making yes oh wait bless you God bless you so just based on what you're saying here I want to make sure this would not be a meeting where we take a tour of a facility to look at technology and N Dogs would that be if we invited certain members of cabinet and department heads to look at the technology and get just to gather information and then who knows where we go with that I've seen it done both ways sometimes

086uh through an agendized meeting process and sometimes not I think it depends on how you're procedurally going to engage in that tour yeah cuz we don't know right so then it wouldn't be a meeting if we don't know we just want to gather information on our own but yet that's the only time those people would be available that's why I'm asking Mr what would be your recommendation for something so I give an example the LA County Board of Supervisors very huge political body they post they go out of state they post DC Sacramento Etc even though the code says you don't have to post they post in this instance if it's three of you going soup staff Etc just post it it's not not a big deal you're going to post it you're going to

087go want to go at Ontario airport or whatever just post it so there's no issues and no concerns so that's like being preventative big preventative you don't to cost legal fees over simple just a posting of a meeting in the sense that so let's just say now in today's digital age so you know someone sees two of the trustees say there's three trustees there and they're like oh what are they doing here and they take a picture then obviously the community can make its own assumptions but if it's posted it's like no they were supposed to be there that was organized they were there for a particular purpose and it's just being transparent insane cuz I mean that would you know that makes sense just post it that way no one can say oh well

088look at aha you know it's like no well that kind of opens the door like for example let's say all of us happen to be going to the grocery store at the same time and we run into each other hey how you doing there's a picture you don't post that no you don't post it but here's here's the the issue and challenge with with the word meeting so the law doesn't distinguish workshops uh teaming events uh what is this what do we call this today boot camp what meeting special the la la that is the largest simply States meeting it's either special emergency or meeting three words it's either emergency meeting a special meeting or meeting so we can get fancy probably we want to get fancy with all the nice adjectives and nice terms

089Describe the meeting but as far as the Public's concerned three of you were hanging out in the barbecue nine times of the pretend something came up as a result of some District aspect and there could potentially be a problem we just always want to discourage people from from coalescing around too much together even though you have relationships that you may have known I may have known you for 20 years it doesn't matter now we're governed underneath the provision of the rough and brown act even if we're there for a barbecue what if we're talking about the food man that is a social Gathering that is an exception so we'll walk through oh okay it is an exception but again some communities are very hyper sensitive and people there are attorneys in serving communities they sue

090so you always want to he because remember you're not paying the law the district having to cover that fright yeah no I I'm I'm just trying to understand because you're saying like we all intended on going but what if I didn't know everybody else is showing up we're all doing our own thing and we happen to be somewhere the law allows an exception right and again on the side of caution I just wouldn't plan too many barbec together right well well I was yeah a couple of them a year we would to be at the barbecue every Sunday before the board meeting right so when you you know we get uh invited to events football games Awards so all three of us together at a football game or a basketball game or all five of

091us is that but that's why I'm asking because we're doing that on our own it's not like this is exactly I was going to get to the test slide but I'll I'll get to it sooner so we think this is a really good way to think about when you know the the meeting parameters for the brown act so if a discussion can potentially contribute to developing a collective concurrence that's the term we have to keep in mind it likely constitutes a meeting under the brown act so if a majority of you are meeting and in a way let's say even at a social Gathering but you're discussing something that is under the purview of the board and you're reaching a collective concurrence that can be that is a violation of the brown act you have

092to be really careful about that but you can be at a social Gathering and as long as you're not reaching a collective concurrence generally staying away from talking about anything that's under the board's prview would be the recommendation then you're okay and I think what you have here and if you go to the slide of that definition of a meeting it it even says the previous one to hear right and some other things any item within the subject matter jurisdiction so just the fact of listening that can have an impact but it has to be an item directly related to the subject jurisdiction so we are in a footb football game and we're talking about some other things not related to the subject jurisdiction it would be it would be okay but just listening to

093information like that like this one we're listening here we're not making any any decision right but just listening it can lead to have the concurrence of the minds you know I'm so glad you're posting the government code because when we went through well when I went through csba and the mid course they were telling us you guys could show up at a event whatever as talk whatever and people could say whatever they say but if you're talking about a potential action item and that was the key word action item then you're in violation of the brown otherwise you're not but now I have more clarity so thank you very much than that yeah I I kind of feel deceived by csba right there but you know thank you so again just to emphasize so there

094is a Prohibition against a majority of the members using a series of communications of any kind directly or through intermediaries and we'll see some examples of that to discuss deliberate or take action on any item of business that is within their subject matter jurisdiction and again that goes to the collective concurrence test and it's a good way to think about it can you go back and I want you to Define intermediaries yes I have some sles on that okay very well CU that that's where it gets really tricky area with intermediaries okay question for you um so if we're in a closed meeting area well and then we ask close session close session um superintendent to leave is that okay for us all five to be in there talking about something or no well if

095it's so if it's a closed session exception and it's agendized properly and you're strictly adhering to what it is that you can discuss behind closed doors um and we have some slides on that then yes that's you can continue that action except except if the discussion is going to be over something that is agendized for an open meeting right you cannot discuss anything agendized for an open meeting in a s it's very specific as to what you can what you can discuss in close session and we will we will talk about that um okay so just wanting to point out that of course there are some procedural and administrative matters that don't constitute meetings right so if you're not involved in a substantive discussion on a topic um generally for example Communications limited to providing

096information like a superintendent's weekly report to the board um procedural or administrative matters like scheduling meetings determining agendas and the time allotted to each of them those are more administ matter so even if you're reaching a collective concurrence that's not the type of thing that the meeting prohibition is is directed to uh it's of course more substantive matters that are under the board's Pro so I think this is where Mr Al I think this is where we have some examples of the intermediary and other things so again just thinking Beyond sitting in a meeting room and how board members communicate group texts and emails that's a big differ difficult subject matter right because you could get a message in where you're messaging each other um and uh in which a majority of the board or

097committee is copied that's problematic if you're reaching a collective concurrence on subject matter that's under the board's perview even consecutive forwards and replies of electronic messages May constitute a Serial meeting that's in violation of the ground act some other examples that we don't always think about as we're communicating is the Hub of wheel examples so if you have consecutive conversations with each other as board members so board member a to board member B to board member C and that's leading to a collective concurrence that is a violation of the brown act M Abrahim can staff facilitate violations of BR act yes so that's the daisy chain example so if you have through an intermediary I'm sorry Hub of wheel is the intermediary example daisy chain is what I was describing as board member to board

098member I I I I uh took those out of order uh but uh Mr Ali's example is the Hub of real example so if you have an intermediary who's polling the board so polling board member a and board member B and board member C and that is reaching a collective concurrence that can also be considered a violation of the ground act so that's say I'm a Staff person I would like to get a raise I pull the board I talk with the board which just happens a lot I talk with the board about me getting a writings with that constitute knowledge yes orless I want to fire the time here K Carter I come and I want to fire KT Carter that' be a violation and that's the Hub of wheel so there's someone yes

099the intermediary the intermediary I mixed them up earlier but the daisy chain of course would make sense because that's what a daisy treatment is is if you're each speaking to each other and that's leading to colletive have a quick question so if there is like an issue with a staff and they would go superintendent and not us right or how does that work if and not violate anything yeah of course they can go to the superintendent if they have a concern or question they should be coming to us for job you should be a superintendent well here okay so there there's two parts of that you have a uniform complaint process here in the district my good friend here the HR I'm just saying he's my good friend I love him I think he's a

100great guy I just met him for the first time but but there's a uniform complaint process so I have a grievance against Mr compos who's the superintendent I go to HR and follow the process I should not go to a board member I should go through the process it's documented there's Collective bargain agreements between your various unions it all spells elements of this out so if anybody comes to you mam board member hey you know what go HR that complaint I don't want to hear it you'd be nice of course I could be mean but I don't want to hear it go to HR you're absolved of it because you don't want to put yourself in the middle of that potentially impact an ability to actually hear the case because the school board members you're

101executive and you're no you're legislative and judicial superintendent executive you wear both of those hats because you're able to arbitrate your cases right you don't want to make it when they come to you it it can get personal well very much then of course you become a part right you become a center of that so everybody's following the process it's just very clean plus it's it's your it's your policy as a government board member you've approved it and the public as well as the state is under the supposition and believe that you read it would that be the same process as if a parent gets in in uh involved with you know talks to you about something sure good rle of thumb is he Mr Hall I have an issue and so and so hey

102no problem send me an email etc for with email to be superintendent okay you don't want to try to arbitrate that because again you never know what the issues are right and you have to hear that matter yeah it's a and typically these are special education parents they normally will cover the issues but they already have an attorney but they're already addressing issues with respect to an i 504 Etc so it's always better just to get them writing send it to the superintendent allow the staff to be able to deal with it and let it find its way on the agenda so that it can be discussed whether open or close in a public setting or they have to come to the board let the staff just handle those issues administratively right kind of keep

103some of that that mess down and parents are going to come to you because they elected you so you can't just tell the parent I don't want right get away they're going to come you just want to be able to get the superintend all of those complaints and agreements he can deal with them as well as the staff are we allowed um when parents come to the board meetings with an issue are we allowed to go to the superintendent and ask to put it on the agenda so we can talk about it is that well you can but but to be honest if a parent comes with an issue the expectation of the superintendent is going to address the issue and resolve it right right some of the issues might not rise to a level

104where we require AO acction so I give an example the bus was late hey you guys all can go to you know where the bus would I'm sick of the bus hey we can address the bus issue that's an administrative function right the food was called administrative function now the building fell in it's a different story we have collapsed different story right but many actions the you're really paying bills mostly at your board meeting you hearing special education matters you're hearing HR matters Etc a lot of the parent grievances can be handled by the principal by the staff and you really want them to be able to manage and handle L of that stuff locally right has a good rule of Cl and I'll add to that that on the step four of our complaint

105process it's the board you're you're the last reviewer of the of the complaint so if we bring it out to open session soon you're not allowing us to go see what's going on and and then like I said you will be the last reviewer if the go through the proc so just I'm just curious if I a parent if I I see a parent how problem I person just want to know what's oh how how is it resolve am I allowed to ask or be talked about in open public you can talk with the parent by yourself to figure out you know hey was the issue resolved to your satisfaction okay but again the objective is really to keep superintendent in the loop if I go let's say if I go to him instead of

106the parent just to keep myself out as I'm just CU was it resolved or how was it resolved absolutely well that's customer service right absolutely that's what we're here for representative democracy people elect you sure to solve their issues you make sure that things are okay now what you get off into is if you ask superintendent for a report on the issue then perhaps we could give you the report as well as share that report with the other four members so that everybody understands what's going on there's no nobody hiding anything right yeah thank you M for meaning that uh yes and that is exactly the the process right the parent comes to us to you as a when they used to come to me we listen to them you as a member leaser and

107make the recommendation follow the process and also I would ask you to let me know right this is what this parent Shar shared with me and I directed him or her to follow follow the process so I'm going to be following up on that and I just want to expand a little bit more when some parents have come here to the to the board meetings and express some concerns sometimes immediately we have one of our staff members and when the parent lives we talk with them or we can ask can we talk with you and we start that conversation this is going to be the next step you give me more information so we start usually addressing the issue right away right after the meeting over thee and can ask a question on the hub

108wheel can a Community member or a parent that intermediat getting a consensus from the board no can you say that again Community member or a parent just be so the board is get understand can they be an intermediary and create a consensus with the board no school violation another question we talk about parents staff members coming to more members they going to refer that the concer to me what about union union members that they address the individual or members one at the time they they go to another one yeah intermediary is any person like that right if it if it's leading to a collective concurrence that's under the board's subject matter jurisdiction it's a violation of the no matter who that intermediate exactly yeah thank you and then and to the superintendent's point which is

109very S one let's dis lobbying versus me trying to get a contract right I I want to sell the furniture to the district and I'm going to go lob I'm going to go Advocate there it the law distinguishes that and unions are generally held a little different in that vein so essentially they can applicate for pay raises they can applicate for better working conditions they can call the board members and encourage do that that's generally not viewed as violating the brown act okay now it gets a little bit tricky because the unions also support candidates and finance candidates which is legal right so again I'm sorry can you say that one more time it's legal to finance C it's a political body right so all of us have been supported we receive campaign donations it's

110not illegal it's not anything that's icky you just CL it all right right so again it's just it's a thin line between somebody advocating for working conditions and somebody advocating for you to you know buy my new it computers and uh etc etc etc so again the law does contemplate unions slightly different an aspect we live in a state that unions have tremendous amount of influence from the gator Mansion all the way down to school board I did want to point out just on that last bullet that when it comes to internet use and blogs and also social media use which we'll get into a little bit more when we talk about a992 again to for the board to be very careful because even doing a like uh or a thumbs up emoji or emojis

111where you're expressing that you agree could and if a majority of the board is making comments in response to let's say a post that could potentially be lead to a collective concurrence so um just wanted to emphasize that on this slide now is that on um because I know this has come up in little South from here um is that on like Po like like they there because you know how some people they they create social media for their campaigns um and then they post things you know so is that is is that the kind of obviously not using their District anything I don't have any of them but I just know that that has kind of come up as an issue some people use their Instagram or whatever they have um and they post

112things and then other people might chime in but that so that's the kind of stuff that you want to avoid so you you as a board member can post if you'd like right on various issues but if your um board members uh if the other board members are then commenting and liking that post and that's a topic that's under the subject matter jurisdiction of the board it could be problematic so that could lead to a collective concurrence that violates the ground act and I did want to touch on just since we're talking about it uh AB 992 so this became effective January 1 2021 and it's codified in government code section 5495 2.2 and it clarifies the social media interactions what violates the brown act and what doesn't and I think what was happening is

113more and more board members were running into and committee members were running into these issues as they were posting or responding so just to think that this goes as far as Twitter Instagram Facebook Tik Tok um in chat rooms and forums comment sections on blogs and online media and so just some general well we would say best practices around this you can use social media to communicate with the public about board business to answer questions provide information updates and solicit information you as an individual board member but do not use it to communicate with other members about board business so what's prohibited is commenting on other members posts for the most part A no no um liking or otherwise engaging with another member's post even through the use of emojis and then also even sharing

114another member's post and if it has nothing to do with Schoolboard business acceptable not acceptable to post or to respond both you the around posting there's more flexibility but it's really in the responses and the comments that you run into issues so I I think for the most part it's just safer to stay away from responding a posting in response to another board member's post is that even including like a board members from another District no because that's go back tole concurrence test okay I just what's under this board subject jurisdiction okay I I went out of order so now I'm go thank you for bearing with me um okay so we were talking about what are uh common scenarios that are likely not meetings and we were talking about individual contacts with community members

115so those are typically not not considered you know that's not a violation you as a board member can have contact individually with a Community member um or even another member of the legislative body as long as it's not a majority of you congregating um but uh just of course keeping in mind some of the parameters that we were talking about earlier and then of course conferences the attendance of a majority of the members of a legislative body or the board at a conference or similar Gathering open to the public that involves discussions of General issues of general interest so again the key is for what you're going to see listed as examples 2 through six the if you can all attend these events but as long as you're not collectively reaching a concurrence on subject

116matter jurisdiction that's under this SP perview and and really reaching a decision on things that could potentially be perceived as uh BR act violations so other examples are Community meetings uh public entity meetings the attendance of a majority of the members at an open and notice meeting of another body so that's allowed of course again as long as you're not reaching a collective concurrence parties so social Gatherings you can of course attend with that same caveat and then district meetings importantly you can attend the meetings of let's say your standing committees that you formed um but uh uh only attend as observers and again with the with the general overarching prohibition against uh a majority of you reaching a collective conference question as we were we were thinking of having Town Hall meetings with two

117board members at each of the Town Hall meetings with the public but if there's different board members at each town hall and maybe some of the same subjects come up to that be can we have a town H home post it be all well why don't we just have a town hall and invite all the board members and post it right wouldn't that be easier yeah sorry I'm using your brain today okay so uh close session exceptions just touching on these um of course all the boards General work should be done in public to meet what we were talking about as the purposes of the brown act to keep an open and transparent process with the public but there are certain exceptions that you see listed there Personnel matters discussing appointments performance or dismissal of

118a Public Employee uh litigation so this is both existing and anticipated and under the anticipated category it can be when the district is potentially considering filing a lawsuit or could potentially be sued so those are uh so just to point out that it goes both ways for anticipated real estate negotiations are are limited to price and term of payment discussions for the transaction and then labor negotiations instructions to to provide instructions to District Representatives on labor contracts you have a question Mr I did and I'm really trying to figure out how to actually ask it because I don't want it to come out wrong what about prayer prayer in open or close open or close yeah because I know some people have ask me about it like do you guys pray or anything you know

119what your religion believe and all that we don't but is it allowed um you know I'd have to look into that do you I don't know if your bylaws cover anything around prayer or if the district team knows at all what the parameters are we can look into the happy to bring that information I don't have an answer that's all you asking yeah and that's under closed though right yes which would be different if it's just your meeting before because it's before anything has opened and been any type of meeting whether it's an open session or closed session the the prayer yeah right well I'm just saying so that because that was discussed under a closed I the question is is broader than just what's allowable in closed right are you asking more generally I

120was asking generally but we we could do it anyway whatever answer you get information I guess it's good for us um I did want to point out this is a new law that took effect on January 1 actually uh AB 2715 so the board can meet in close session to discuss cyber security issues so you see there if it's uh related to critical infrastructure controls or critical infrastructure information you may hold a close session to address threats to critical infrastructure controls or as we said information including cyber security risks we'll be able to get a copy of the slide so we have all the laws absolutely and that's why again some of them are a little dense but because it's a new law we just wanted to put as much information as possible so again

121here's some best practices around closed session to strictly adhere to the exceptions so those exceptions that we covered including the new cyber security exception um and only discuss the topics that are permitted under the brown act for CL session to provide clear notice in your agenda clearly identify the reason for the Clos session uh using the statutory language there's uh there is recommended statutory language in the brown act for how to agendize close session item so uh really to adhere to that as much as possible report out transparently after a closed session publicly announce any reportable action taken so if action was taken in close session that should be reported out and a really good example is settlement agreements for example um and then finally to document properly uh the topics that are discussed and

122especially if action is taken so that the reporting out can occur in a proper manner is is it a good course to have to have a lot of Staff in close session I know people would like to do that around the state typically not usually it's limited limited to senior cabinet if and then really depending on the topic also pick and choose who exactly would be in that post we're doing it right what about notes taking a post session would you take notes and provide notes no but again just accurate record keeping in order to report out the the reporting out is important but uh for that purpose it's important to take notes but otherwise no on the reporting out just as um um so for example if it's an employee action you know whether

123to release or um is it recommended that the the the vote be voiced out in terms of and I'm thinking in terms of like safety so let's just say um you know there was a vote to terminate or release the employee and then as a roll call is being given uh instead of just being given a 32 um if it's reported out how everybody voted so then then the the the employee would know who voted against who voted for um is it encouraged to do it that way or is it encouraged just to kind of simple numbers no the law is clear oh you report out 5 vot Ali so and so Mickey miles Donald du Miss Piggy you call you Call okay and how they voted how they voted okay law says Voice vote

124okay so we been doing good right then okay good okay so agenda requirements this I think um I'm sorry if you know that law that you just mentioned is there any way you could send that to us I appreciate that sorry so for regular meetings of course we know that the agenda has to be posted at least 72 hours before the meeting and for special meetings like today um at least 24 hours and typically what is required is that the agenda is displayed in a location that's freely accessible to the public and on the uh District's website a brief description of each item and uh that contains sufficient detail importantly so that the public knows if they should attend that meeting and also for them to make a determination about whether they want to provide

125public comment that's really the rationale I I want to make sure I'm not overthinking this you said sufficient detail doesn't mean the whole item right it it just has to be described well enough that the public knows what you all so we don't have to list everything yeah perfect anything that's going to be considered by the board should be listed yes oh okay so and of course action items should you can presentations action items so it should be open to the public prior to it should be agendized in a way that the public can understand what the No No well you said presentation so I'm asking on the agenda does that presentation need to be attached no that's not necessarily required as long as the board doesn't see the presentation in advance and hasn't received

126that it can be brought to the board the way we did it today which is you're receiving it today for the first time oh so then if okay so if we're getting presentation we want to get it in our meeting and not prior to to review it got it that's okay if you do get it in advance of course then yes it should be attached to the agenda H okay that's good information thank you the last point is that as a board you can State I want this presentation to be placed in the minutes you you have full Authority you have full Authority you you can say I want this presentation as long as the attorney States this is not privileged which is normally in close session privileged documents uhhuh this the you want these

127documents to be added to the minutes of the meeting now now you just uh triggered another thought you said privileged so what if we're presenting with something in Clos session do we have to post privilege information or anything like that no no the public can't have that at all perfect thank you let's say you're negotiating with um you know I don't know a union you know JayZ pen and then they got to buy so and so that's all privilege that that never becomes public until the end of the deal are you negotiating with the Union right that agreement would not come public until after it's been consummated and you voted on B will go up as a public document right so there's some actions you would entertain in close session right for example if you

128authorize the attorney to negotiate on your behalf of settlement you wouldn't report out you have consensus to the attorney to go forward with a certain amount until there's an agreement and a document then that goes public right and that's what the law requires at that point and the law everything I'm saying is not my opinion it's what the law states all cifi got it thank you so much okay sometimes we just need to hear it again you know that's important so there are exceptions to the standard agenda requirements and we've listed them there and what's required so uh just so you can take a closer look at that um teleconferencing so I think many of you are familiar to the extent that you're teleconferencing into a meeting as a board member a form of the

129legislative body must be meeting in person in the agency's jurisdiction in order for the teleconference attend attend to be uh authorized posting of the members remote location is required on the notice and agenda uh public access to each teleconferencing location is also required so again that would be described and identified on the agenda agendas must be posted at each teleconference location and the agenda must provide the opportunity for the public to address the legislative body at each location and so this is what we would call the traditional teleconferencing rules and then you'll you'll hear a little later on that there's some exceptions to this now under ab24 format so just wanted to point out another new law AB 2350 in emergency circumstances School boards must provide timely notification to the public and media about urgent

130meetings that are scheduled and of course if you can't adhere to the 24-hour time frame for posting for a special meeting um what was required is that the legislative body can bypass the 24-hour notice requirement by um by making phone notifications of course so notify spec specified media Outlets one hour before the meeting or at the same time members are notified um and if phone service is unavailable notification must occur as soon as possible after the meeting so again this is for emergency circumstances the change in the law now allows for email notification in addition to phone permitted as an alternative to phone calls to notify media Outlets the contingency is that if both the phone and internet services are unavailable notification must occur as soon as possible after the meeting so similar to the

131prior law but just that it now allows for email notification and phone notification is not possible ab2 449 so we touched on this a second ago uh it ab2 449 amended the brown acts the traditional teleconferencing rules that we just covered it's a hybrid model for physical and remote attendance so this of course developed as a result of the covid and and being loosening some of the brown act requirements around the teleconferencing procedures so it does still require that at least the quum of the members participating person from a single physical publicly accessible location clearly identifi on the agenda and within the local agencies or in this case uh board's territorial jurisdiction and it does require that real time access uh to the for the public be given as part of that process and we'll

132touch on so for example say we're all at a conference out of state and something happens and they're like hey we need to meet emergency meeting what do we do and we all want to zoom we can't do it because we're not in our territory um you can't utilize 2449 but under the Emer Mercy procedures you may be authorized to do got it so we're good thank you um so uh again there are two uh exceptions now that allow for remote attendance so one is Just Cause And you see there what's considered just cause under the statute Child Care contagious illness defined physical or mental disability that has not been accommodated or traveling while on official business of the legislative body to another state or local agency um um the notice requirements under this are

133a member must provide the board with notice at a and a general description of the circumstances justifying the virtual attendance and they can give notice at the start of the meeting so it can be as late as at the start of the meeting which is an important Point um and to utilize this the board board members are limited to two virtual attendance is based on just cost so it's interesting because under the emergency exception uh it doesn't say what the limitations are but then there's a new law we're going to cover in a second that does delve into that a little bit so uh board members can utilize the emergency exception so this would be uh unforeseen situations that prevent inperson attendance including physical or family emergencies so one question we get is okay well

134I mean how much information should a board member Committee Member be providing about their emergency circum circumstance right if it's an illness or if it's something private you don't want to delve too deep um it just has to be enough and you see that provided General description of the circumstances justifying their request so it can be a little bit broad without getting too much into the details but just generally explaining why you're you're relying on the emergency circumstance exception and the member must make a request as soon as possible if they plan to use this um unlike the just cause exception we don't see it as specific as they can exercise it as late as at the start of the meeting it just has to be as soon as possible and then the legislative body

135in this case the board must take action to approve the remote attendance by majority vote at the start of the meeting so that the member can be allowed to participate remotely so M AB in this District I will call the board secretary on superintendent I will say I'm not going to be here notify the the president they'll then have to have zoom Etc right and then you can vote up or down to allow me to do it we have to vote you have to vote you yes V majority up or down allow me to do it and then of course if you allow me to do it that we can go forward and I can participate and I can get credit if I'm not here I don't get paid roll call is is how you

136get paid yeah cuz we vote on that District count you guys have any experience that yet huh so you say you tell me no but I cannot participate but if you have to vot it up sorry and then the only question I have I know you mentioned Zoom but I've seen it then were they're there by phone yes yes and so the district would have to quickly pivot in order to allow telephonic or Zoom because the rationale is that the public still has to be given an opportunity to participate if a board member is appearing virtually uh the public should be able to provide public comment that way because unlike the traditional teleconferencing rules where the the public is getting an opportunity and notice in advance of where that uh board member is appearing from

137and can potentially attend that meeting or that location here it's happening at the last minute and the agenda wouldn't specify where the virtual attendance is occurring from so you have to give the public the opportunity to provide their input uh virtually by or by phone authorize that and then this is the new law a I'm sorry one question how about if I'm on government business I'm on Parish Union business and I want to call in how does that process yeah that's under the just cost so traveling while on official business of the just want to underscore that's so if you're away on the conference you can participate via just calls and how do they record it how do they record the uh so that's we get meaning in terms of record keeping re no no

138no the posting the posting posting on just calls just so we're clear the notice requirements are as soon as possible you have I'm sorry for just CA it's uh as early as late as the beginning of the meeting they can give their notice for just CA okay so that's been any of those aspects under just C just to be very clear because many people are not doing this and if they are doing they're doing it incorrectly because they're not doing the second part of it is the record keeping which she's going to talk about in the second so just want to make sure that you at a district conference you are allowed under just calls to be able to participate remotely as long as addition should PPP Zoom Google meet and our V if you're

139at a conference that necessarily wouldn't be an emergency because you would we would know in advance and we could have jendiz it follow that regular way right well well you could but here's the only caveat with that is that you'd have to coordinate with the hotel of wherever you are to post it yeah and so that would be a little bit more work for staff so he's 100% correct you could you can post it wherever you are and the rule of thumb is again you know work with the hotel staff they generally are not that good at posting because guys be visible to the public and it get to be a little bit murky with them trying to post at window so again you can try people haven't been successful at it but this way

140here just allows for you to be able to participate where go through all those exercis I'm sorry it just opens the door to all these questions so say you're out of state at a funeral maybe the funeral ended but you're still in that state you could still Zoom for the school board meeting like that would that fall under emergency it wouldn't fall under emergency and it wouldn't fall under just cause because physical or family medical emergency I don't know I mean I I think we we would have to look at that specific example okay and see if it qualifies so I had to do this one time when I was a board member and we worked with a hotel we posted outside I had to keep my door open to my room post the agenda

141on the room and have the door open for the link to theour meeting oh it was very yeah so that's under the traditional rules here we don't we don't have to post the agenda and take those steps so um okay I did want to point out that under AB 2302 which was recently approved there are now caps on being frequency and how often you can exercise these exceptions so it's tied to how often you have board meetings so for example if you're meeting once per month members May participate remotely in up to two meetings per calendar year and then you see if if it's twice per month then you can participate up to five meetings per calendar year when we say that meaning remotely under just cause and emergency but a really important Point here

142is that remember we said under just cause you can exercise that two times per calendar year this these limitations are in addition to the two times you get under the just cost statute so it's two plus let's say you're meeting once per month yeah so just want to emphasize that okay really important component of this is recordkeeping by the District of course you see that they're trying to clarify how often board members can do this and the reason is because they want some controls around maybe uh as you can imagine in some cases maybe there's uh a potential that it's exercised too much so um recordkeeping you have to keep track of which member has made a request to appear remotely who will be in physical attendance at the meeting and Confirmation they will be

143there will be a physical Quorum so that's similar to the traditional teleconferencing rules how many times each member has appeared remotely because we want to keep track that of course you appearing to the statutory limitations and the members reason for appearing remotely and any action taken by the legislative body in order to approve that remote attendance and so the district team has to find a way to of course uh keep track of of these remote attendances in a way that meets these record keeping requirements and that's the end of the presentation I know we covered a lot and there were a lot of questions throughout but if there's anything else just some questions oh does the ACT addresses the roles of the roles of members meaning the president the vice president yeah in overall is

144a legislative body uh in detail on that and I would have to look at your bylaws that may be covered in the board bylaw bylaws cover so in the past now knowing the law has changed if a member was absent it would come up on the agenda and saying hey vote for them if we're going to pay them for that month do we still vote does that is that still continuing on let me make sure I understand he's talking about the excuses so if I'm absent you would vote to excuse my right the the board yeah whether there's an excuse or not the board it's always an action item it comes up the following month whether they get compensated or not so that board member goes in the back while the rest of the board

145member votes board members vote well they can actually sit right there and obain okay well I'm just telling you what we've done in the past so so if if you've not forgiven their absence they can't get paid right so what I'm saying is do we still conduct that vote since the law has changed and broken down things do we still continue on with the vote meaning so if I'm absent next month it would come up as an agendized item they would all take a vote and traditionally it's approve whether they vote Yes or No I would continue because if they haven't exercised one of these exceptions or they haven't utilized the the uh traditional teleconferencing rules then it's it's a straight absence right so continue in the normal procedure that you and then I have

146another question because I have noticed we get a stip in for being board members I know it's California law I just don't understand why they give us sick days so how does that work because I know if you if you cut your ties with your employer you cash out and what is that all about like why do we have them what is the purpose I'm tell you now there's no sick days given a board if you give six days here then well on the pays we will look into that oh there we go thank you yeah yeah you're not you're your captive conf a right by Statute so if there's anything above and beyond as you depart it's a problem thank you and that's the law yeah that's what I thought I wasn't sure I

147was wondering why it's on there my my guess on will look into it it corrected is when the change in law for substitute employees changed where they get some cly very limitedly not like a traditional employee because you are grouped in Galaxy our financial system is not a regular employee somehow you got oh so they try I get so it's labeled that way even though we're not employees perhaps I'm speculating with our payroll department me well maybe we need to call rcoe because that's where the check very next thing I was going to say but you don't get sorry you said it first so you were the well thank you everybody we got like $400 yeah I do cash out anyway just like if I left I could cash out my I did just want

148to add that we have some recommended procedures for how to agendize to need to be able to quickly pivot to the just cause or emergency in case board members exercise it um you want to have some language that goes from agenda to agenda that carries on so that you can quickly accommodate that and we can advise on that any any other questions thank you okay yeah thank you great job thank you thank you yeah sorry we picked your brain right so you want to take a break you want yeah you know what can we can I make a motion to take a quick break that way everybody can kind of refresh 10 minute break okay yeah come back at 11:53 okay we'll come back at 10 11 oh 1153 yeah okay I'd like to rec

149reconvene the Paris Union High School District board meeting at 11:56 and then we're moving on to board government's boot camp part one okay all right MERS of the authority m h is your mic on yes yes M can you hear me yes h so I wanted to I'm limited on time but I do want to walk us through board better board governance and so uh this is of course our first slide representing your beautiful School District's logo and so what brought us here today wasn't necessarily me of the weather but really we're here because of the pupil the students within our districts and families we serve within this school district and our general community and so of course better governance ought to equate to better student outcomes in a much more fiscally solvent school system

150here are the outcomes what are we expected to gather from today unapologetically Embrace commitment to student achievement to exclusion of all other distractions only your responsibility to drive the activities of the district to produce excellent outcomes for students understand how to use the tools of concise and clear governance and then of course for each of you to create a comprehensive plan in order to move your governance Journey along the first aspect I would ask members if the board just throw out you what is what leadership qualities are essential to effectively govern the Paris Union High School District just give me a word one word communication leadership qualities are essential someone who knows how to communicate listening communication listening any other qualities honesty Integrity Integrity yeah you well he said listening I think I want to

151go deeper and say receptive to everybody and everything what does that type of leadership look like your opinion someone who's engaging the community and the students and staff some someone who cares yeah passionate what does it sound like how do we communicate that being transparent multiple meetings you know I know that sounds crazy but everybody's involved buying I think it it's taken also um initiatives to attend things to have an open mindset to different things that are out there that maybe we're not doing but you it maybe compared to others just trying to figure out what's a better way to to not be to constantly be looking forward to see what can we do better remember that leadership profile report that we B the board a while ago got to make sure the new board

152members receive that report remember the the survey we did an exhaustive and extensive survey and in that survey your community did talk about intense and engagement and enrichment I also talked about uh the school district being far more involved within the community and so that then lends to how people feel how do you make people feel about your system based upon the qualities of a leader how then will parents say we want our children to attend that school system and then we address the issues of declining enrollment and all of the other issues that generally PL Urban systems and you not necessarily in the inner core but there's some some density around here which would in my opinion qualify to be quasa Suburban quasa Urban so in that context when we're looking at the challenges

153the objective of leadership in this community is to look a certain way to sound a certain way and then has a this real reaction it makes people feel a certain way when you're out there on a campaign Trail you have a chance to talk with people and so your talk then translates into policy and of course thus action I want to play this video if you guys would indulge me this phenomenal video around leadership look at that beautiful I always wonder Is that real mhm it's an exceptional video which deals with the explanation of leadership from a a business it's still applicable prove it we're what's the metric give me the number do you love your wife you want to play ready yeah yeah prove it like what's the metric give me the number that

154helps me know right cuz when you met her you didn't now you right there we go all right do you love your wife thanks prove it like what what's the metric give me the number that helps me know right cuz when you met her you didn't love her now you love her right tell me the day the love happen it's an impossible question but it's not that it doesn't exist it's that it's much easier to prove over time right leadership is the same thing it's about transitions so if you were to if you were to go to the gym like exercise right if you go to the gym and you work out and you come back and you look in the mirror you will see nothing and if you go to the gym the next

155day and you come back and you look in the mirror you will see nothing right so clearly there's no results can be measured it must not be effective so we quit right or you fundamentally believe that this is the right course of action and you stick with it like in a relationship I bought her flowers and I wish her happy birthday and she doesn't love me clearly I be love that's not what happens if you if you believe there's something there you commit yourself to act an act of service you commit yourself to the regime the exercise you can screw it up you can eat chocolate cake one day you can skip a skip a day or two you know it allows for that but if you stick with it consistently I'm not exactly sure

156what day but I know you'll start getting into shape I know and the same with the relationship it's not about de convents it's not about intensity it's about consistency right you go to the dentist twice a year your teeth will fall out you have to brush your teeth every day for 2 minutes what ises brushing your day twice a day for two minutes do nothing unless you do it every day twice a day for 2 minutes right it's the consistency going to the gym for 9 hours does not get you into shape working out every day for 20 minutes gets you into shape so the problem is we treat leadership with intensity we have a two-day offsite we invite a bunch of speakers we give everybody a certificate you're a leader right those things are

157like going to the dentist they're very important good for reminding us or getting us back on track learning new lessons but it's the daily practice of all the monotonous little boring things like brushing your teeth that matter the most she didn't fall in love with you because you remembered her birthday and bought her flowers and Valentine's Day she fell in love with you because when you woke up in the morning you said good morning to her before you checked your phone she fell in love with you because when you went to the fridge to get yourself a drink you got her one without even asking she fell in love with you because when you had an amazing day at work and she came came home and she had a terrible day at work you didn't

158say yeah yeah yeah but let me tell you about my day you sat and listened to her awful day and you didn't say a thing about your amazing day this is why she fell in love with you I can't tell you exactly what day and it was no particular thing you did it was the accumulation of all of those little things that she woke up one day and as if she pressed a button she goes I love right leadership is exactly the same there's no event there's no thing I can tell you you have to to do that your people will trust you it just doesn't work that way it's it's an accumulation of lots and lots of little things that anyone by themselves is innocuous and useless literally pointless by themselves people will look

159at little things that are good leadership practice and say that won't work and you're absolutely right but if you do it consistently and you do it in combination with lots of other little things like saying good morning to someone that looking him in the eye my friend George Who a three star general for he says his test for leadership and I love this he goes his test for a good leader if you ask somebody how their day is going you actually care about the answer the number of times we're walking to a meeting we're rushing how are you not good I got to get to you later I got late for a meeting if you ask a question you were standing there and you were listening to the answer it's those little innocuous things that

160you do over and over and over and over that people will say I love my job but I like my job I like my job means yeah the challenge is great they pay me well I like the people I love my job means I don't want to work anywhere else I don't care how much somebody else is willing to pain me I'm devoted to the people here and I care desperately about the people here as if they were my family in business we have colleagues and co-workers in the military they have brothers and sisters that's how they think of each other if you really have a strong corporate culture the people will think of each other like brothers and sisters don't live like a family right no brothers and sisters deep love fight but the

161love doesn't go away vicker but love doesn't go away and I'll fight with my sister but if you threaten my sister you don't have to deal with me right we'll fight internally go bicker with each other but nobody's going to hurt each other and if anything from the outside shows up you got you're looking at a unified front brothers and sisters now how do you create brothers and sisters out strangers common beliefs common values you know parents in other words Executives who care about their children's success who care to raise their children teach them skills discipline them when necessary help them build their self-confidence so that they can go on and Achieve something more than you could have ever imagined achieving for yourself that's leadership any thoughts that Mr Hall it's true very true it

162doesn't happen over one night or an hour it's it's your time yeah I I agree I always tell my husband it's easy to uh be respectful and kind to people you don't see every day but know when you go home and you can't be respectful and kind to your husband and your children and it's not in you if it's in you in your close proximity then it's easier to do it to others completely agree Garcia M Mr President I I agree with everybody I think you know if if being kind is in your heart there's an intensity to you that you go above and beyond and if like he said if you care you'll stand there and listen to the response and you know Society has been it sound like oh they don't care about

163my ANW so I'm not going to respond I'm just say it's it's fine even though they're hurting inside but if you generally care you'll recognize that and you'll try and have a conversation with them get to know them and understand what's going on Mr presid yeah so for me you know uh where I learned it was through Sports you know it was one of those things where you know you were doing things you didn't want to do but once you were with a group of guys for a certain amount of time and years you build a bond and and obviously the bond was always to to win and be successful and the reality is is you know the the wins are great but it's the losses that teach you in my opinion more so that's

164usually when you because the losses stick with you longer than the winds and if you win more then the winds kind of just but it's the losses that you look at so the lot of times through struggle I think that's where we start to test each other and and we start to say hey you know what we're in the same fight you know what I mean but we just there's a bump in the road and how do we fix it how do we resolve it because you can't just sit there and do nothing you have to start throwing out communicating ideas so that's been my experience so let's look at the research so when you look at the advocacy of a school district is directly related directly correlated with the positive effect that school board

165members have on on on public policy and the general oversight I watch that word oversight and accountability so the board has oversight the superintendent has accountability not the other way around 17 years doing this superintendent tell me what to do be very clear huge paradigm shift and when the superintendent or staff believes that they are providing you with a measure of oversight and that would a problem jally that's where the RO begin to fall off so here's what the L the uh literature States from around the country this academic development Institute in 2013 effective schs develop shared and strategic goals with companion implementation plans to drive Focus bold change efforts and ensure the budget process and priorities are aligned so in California we have something called the local control funding formula the local control accountability

166plan essentially that can serve as a a strategic guiding document where there's a plan that's devised and there's budget that aligns with that the law give school board members the authority to amended as so desired but also you have an opportunity to set the course of your community so in fact as a high school district only 25 of you in the entire state so you're an anomaly right as a high school system you want to focus more on concurrent enrollment dual enrollment Early College CTE Etc then that's what the board would simply State as a top priority and of course the staff would fund that the board has the Vision V has the vision and that's clear and that's cified essentially in law you set the vision the superintendent implements that Vision as well as

167the staff if the staff finds themselves in a position where they're doing things outside of that which is budgeted again we have a problem so we're now having to establish and facilitate a structur way in which we plan this right now you're in the elcat planning phase right now at least you have to be your communities are being engaged around that and then of course you get into the budget phase when you're appropriating resources to that and so again let's look further at the literature this is out of University of Nebraska linol and the role of the board around uh learning so the board there's tools for the board to improve the functionality of the system through effective policymaking addressing student needs so let's say you have a tremendous amount of multi-lingual Learners it persective

168as what happens in DC you still have an obligation to provide a free and fair public education access therein as well as to address the differentiated needs of your student whatever happens in sou Europe you're still compelled to provide a level of academic enrichment and so as a as a governing board again you want to support the superintendent success not as a perfunctory agent or rubber Stamper but as a willing franchised participant in the governance journey we'll talk more about the role confusion which often times causes issues and systems throughout the country and I can cite numerous examples of places where I've worked and all the places where I've devised where the board and superintendent really struggles with relationship further into the the research into the literature so the board sets mutual and ongoing expectations

169for the superintendent and the superintendent's contract it has a provision where you may evaluate but I wouldn't wait to evaluate after a year worth of work what we're doing is we're working in a very cohesive symbiotic relationship because there not I got you moment right we're in this together so we're working each and every month right we're paying bills we're evaluating test data we're doing walkthroughs know we're visiting we're participating because the objective is not for you to be an ambassador but for you to be a leader and work a concert with the superintendent to implement uh pedagogical best practices and transform this community as well as the system of course there's ongoing dialogue around that and we can if you have any questions just stop me but I just want to walk us through

170with some of the the literature stat this is out of Lighthouse the lighthouse project and the lighthouse 2 project so this is 2022 and 2027 compared in districts with low student achievement versus school systems with High student achievement and they identifying seven conditions for school renew where it impacts to achievement let let's look at six of these characteristics for which underscore a very successful school system stability among board members been on my board 17 years superintendent been there 13 years 17 years so been there 13 years go pull the data go pull the financial data go pull the academic achievement and then let's compare that with similar size districts around California I'm not saying the longevity needs a job well done we're talking about as if in fact you're effectuating short regular board meetings you're

171doing goal setting you're effectively managing What complaints were referred to the administration as Miss Anaya talked about earlier this complaint complaints complaints are resolved we effectively communicate those complaints Etc there's effective communication between the board president in some districts that person acts as a go-between in California we don't necessarily do much of that as a goet because of the brown act and so again working very collaboratively someone said trust High degree of trust because in the end if I can't trust the administrative team then we have a problem as a governing body and we can site districts we can roll call districts where there's literally been very little trust and you see these districts with massive layoffs struggling financially their budgets are not positively certified at all it's just really a horrific experience and of

172course children are very impacted about that let's look at the Panasonic Foundation report where we talk about four sacred duties of abort member to establish and promote ownership of the district's vision and values which means each and every board member go righte sorry question go ahead um will we get a copy of this absolutely okay great I was like all right I got right all this down absolutely so no and I have a question um so uh on establishing you know the district visions and values is that something that is done through an agenda item or how like at a at a at a like a situation like this at a workshop where where we're reviewing you know what it says in the past knowing you know but we don't know how long if there's

173a mission statement or this that and the other sure um so that's just something that you can CU then you talk about the brown neack stuff so is that something that could be discussed if we're doing a School site visit you know with the superintendent and some staff and we just start to see some things and we just start to have an idea of hey you know what what about this what about that that is all okay but or or should that all just be presented then as an agenda item to kind of discuss at a regular board meeting yeah yes and so I'll give an example and again Parton can but you have a dependent mod charter school here a phenomenal program that deals with this this Military Institute one a few systems in

174the entire state with the Military Institute let's say the board wanted to expand that that's a policy decision whether it's a dependent mod Charter or not that's for the board to decide if you want it to continue down that bin okay those are policy decisions those are also vision and value decisions because let's say you wanted to expand that Military Institute throughout the entire system right your high school district so let's say you wanted to leverage your community college partner and establish an early middle college construct increases enrollment addresses the issue of equity right provides an opportunity for differentiated learning for some students who outperform and outpace the other and this provides a measure of affordability for families because of course two years will be completed in high school off you the college two years

175off you go now I passed a resolution in 2015 I wrote it and brought it to the board which was a director to the superintendent to establish an early medal college for which we were able to do it because the board took an affirmative action directing the superintendent the superintendent takes direction from the board you run the shell very clear and simple these people know it because they worked in systems right so if the board wants to set that as a vision that we expand the military institutee we decrease let's say you had a school off to the side of the system on the outskirts that a continuation we don't want that anymore we want continuation schools at every High School you Bo says that Vision staff figures out way to that comes back with

176appropriate recommendations right there issues and challenges let's say master schedu it I know you wouldn't get into the granularity of Master scheduling however you ought to be in the position to ask the questions if you pull data and students are all going to marett the question is why you going to our the question is why then what are we not doing so I I have a question um because I've heard it different conferences it's coming up it's come up before so you mentioned Early College uh I'm aware of IB systems I'm aware of the AP systems the dual enrollment um can you define early college that or early M mdle college that way you have two things going on in California a288 which is concurrent enrollment okay students are able to take classes at the

177collegate level perhaps 11 or 12 They will receive re certificates perhaps alive with CTE Etc with the Early Middle College construct and there some phenomenal information we can present with the subsequent meeting the board is so inclined bringing an expert to talk with you about that at no cost phenomenal expert who's like the mother of the Early College movement in California it's exceptional ear long essentially what you do is establish a high school that would partner with the local Community College now in AB 288 students who are UND documented that was the reason why we we pushed that bill that was one of our pieces of legislation we advocated to address the needs to to ensure that children gr document have access to the Community College via high school it's a brand new school where

178students from 9th through 12 graduate with an AA degree within four years cuz your Department of the Community College provide that middle college concept you integr the systems now there not many schools system leveraging this in California the science comes out of mardia high school in New York and another great example is another aspect of that is called a pathway in Technical High School where you partner with industry to be able to provide a brand new high school you can have as many high schools as you want you're not just restricted to what you have again back to board vision and what the board wants to see as far as Community transformation so bringing in someone to help your staff and you this could easily be added to the LC cap and fund it simple

179this is not that difficult and as a matter of fact it most certainly will keep many of the students around might even have students come to the school of do neighbor and dist are not leveraging that I could tell you now many of them are not they may be leveraging 288 AP 288 but they're not leveraging the Early Middle College concept and again I can certainly provide some information for you within that M so you can be able to mold over that because I know there's a lot of information being provided today so we definitely follow up and provide some some uh nuggets for which you can reference and every day so when you're creating conditions for achieving or achievement through five areas of of board authority deciding on and propagating policies everybody always tells

180you every superintendent has taught all over the state the board's R is policy no it's not you're not passing policy every single day you're not passing policy every half the policies you that are profer you do not even write they're written they're they're extracted from the state of from csba they're modified and off you go the board has to ensure that the community is included there effective executive board relationships negotiating and approving Union contracts you're a fiduciary you're fiduciary your Chief role is to ensure that the district remain solvent you approve a budget your appropriate resources the notion that you just policy simply means you come to the board meeting as a perun agent of the administration it is not the case and if you look at what Jerry Brown did during his tenure as

181Governor by changing the way in which school systems are funded through the local control funding formula and having school system develop in an lcap the power is back in the hands of board members to decide the direction of their respective District which is why some districts are funding more of the Arts and others are not and some districts are funding more Early College and Career Pathways and others are not and the list goes on and on and on that Authority rest within the power of the LA I've debated superintendent about this all over the state the old way of thinking that the board just simply comes and votes on policy and then they go home that day is over which is why you approve a 300 page El and the STM of the belief and

182supposition that you read it so again these are some these are are new ways in which we're looking at how school systems are done around California you can stop anytime you have a question I want to jump back to that last part the number four is for sacred duties of board ensure CommunityWide climate of commitment respect and Trust because you people are sending that children to your school systems right so it's incommon upon you to be able to develop that and be very honest and forthright with the community effective boards not blur the role with their superintendent of administration this is goes back to the discussion earlier you trying to arbitrate and manage situations or crisis you want to constantly work with the superintendent and staff with that b but going back to the higher

183level thinking of strategic planning and policy they consistently monitoring the performance of the superintendent in addition to increased student achievement now make no doubt about it I love my superintendent we but we have a relationship a contractual relationship he's is responsible for delivering ABC or D 13 years with a positively certified budget so it's a school board member I'm expecting as a community person that you understand that the studenttion services division is running in the black that the Jour fund is not having to lend money I'm under the belief that you're doing needs assessment of the facilities and making certain that there needs to be additions or augmentations Etc that that's the Assumption the community makes because you're the Congress and you're the speaker of the legislature You're simply legislative and judicial and the community

184sees you as such because your title your true title is governing board trustee what in the law so this is where I want to jump to and then we can Poss I know we going to lose some folks so I really want to get to this governance model this governance model so the organizational model on the right it illustrates how effective organizations are governed within the school district Paradigm so as you can see up one side is the board on the green side the prevailing belief is that the board is very strategic in how it thinks now again old school ways of running school systems where we normally would blame the board for all the distri failures right but remember you don't put the budget together nor do you negotiate contracts and you don't run

185the day to day but back in the day it was very easy to say it was the board's fault right so we're looking at this as you can tell I'm pretty much Pro board R so so looking at this you you see a very high level of thinking as to the the board's focus is in the green the superintendent and Stat functions in the blue we're talking about uh stat buiness setting goals Etc so let's say for example District up in Oregon set a 6% goal for black children with respect to literacy and that made about 2 and a half 3% the board set that goal the board can set whatever goal you so desire have that Authority you can set whatever goal you so desire the board can set whatever strategic Vision with respect

186to optimizing how the district operates utilizing staff research in order to make informed decisions and then down the line the staff is more uh technical with delivering and implementing the action plans as well as executing the vision of the board that's done by budget that's done by elap the staff decides I want my I want to have my own Department I my own Vision I want to do my own thing well it's going to be some problems because you have to pay for that every decision that staff wants to make there should be aairs of go environment here right we want to have a tremendous amount of people in the central office where the board believes we want more Folks at the school site right board has that authority to set that as a strategic

187focus and then challenge the staff through questioning the overall benefit of the board meeting is really for the board members to question the government you're not an employee as we stated earlier even though we have you pay in the system right you're getting vacation days you're not an employee you're representative of the community here to question the government around the business of the Lea right so again this is not the objective is everybody defining their role as being one of strategy as being one of execution and operation and then we we walk that very fine line now again what I'm preaching teaching is not a spoused by most right most you're here for policy and then you get bored you become angry because you're not seeing things happen right and the notion that it takes

188a long time for things to happen well that's with construction with respect to moving the system forward on the pedagogical more curriculum side you want to see some results especially if you're new to the board you didn't get elected to wait five years to see something happen so then we talk talk about the board work around vision mission and values and articulate that and the goals around operationalizing Vis Vision so here we go back to looking to the left right when you look at the mission and vision the objective is for there to be core beliefs and philosophies around what the board believes the mission ought to be which is why it's important for you to actually read that hcap I know it's a lot of pck work but again you pck the pig bucks

189so we do want you to be able to read that to be able to make sure it aligns with what the board believes as the schools roll their LC caps up there's a larger District lcap now you could do a strap plan outside of the lcap you can do your own strategic plan basic on what you believe the district ought to focus on now I'll be very candid with you I I'm the the uh relationship that the district has with the dep pent Charter is an interesting one because the charter document is very lame opposed to traditional Charter documents which are very Hefty we been 16 Pages 300 to 16 so board really should ask some questions about that so are we missing stuff out of that I mean is there stuff that should be

190in there that it's not I mean what's yeah you get to that presentation after but again it's just it's an interesting document so you know you're the board for the charter grp by the way right you know that right correct we have a separate board meeting so yes so you're you're the board for the charter school so and there's just a lot of questions that I would have if I were on the board relative to what are we doing with that asset and how to if you all these students fighting to get in why not expand it right again I'm not giving you a policy position I'm simply posing a question right if you have something that's phenomenal and something that's exceptional then why not expound and why not elaborate on that right so continuing

191on the board administration's collaborative Works strategic challenges we talked about research we talked about synthesizing Cate realities now let's be very clear the state is in a recession we haven't felt it yet but we soon will so how then do we understand and this is why it's important to follow the fiscal Trends along the way Mr President you received a letter from the County Office of Education you haven't gotten it yet but you probably I think you got your first letter from the county y okay so it's important to read that letter and then to be able to have some discussion which would be agendized you're going to have Financial discussions you do want to be able to ask their appropriate questions whether it's closed if you can get and closed legally or open around

192around year of your budget because again you want to understand the challenges with respect to perhaps why can't we Implement elements of div Vision why can't we Implement elements in this particular plan how are we forecasting etc etc etc one big forecast you do every year as enrollment you have a norm day and actually get actual numbers so you're funding the last year's appropriation last year's numbers right so you want to be able to understand these elements right and often times this information is not free Flor because things are moving kind of fast so as a board you do want to be able to read that letter mrost will get consume Bo as a copy of that letter county superintendent so everyone will understand the County's perspective based upon either the first or second interim

193or whatever other financial documents that distri is s to the county and they looking at strategies to determine leveraging points core strategies Etc back to the implementation of our goals and this is all predicated upon the collaborative work between the board and the superintendent we're talking about a different way in which we look at governance not theatrical but more deliberative again not theatrical more deliberative and really put yourself in a position of be able to ask the tough questions a lot of times conversations are had privately and the attorney talked about Brown act violations because sometimes you know you you just want to be very careful with how we're moving information along because really and truly the core of the information you want to know is the wise all the why is associated why we're

194not moving this direction why are we doing this Etc that's a public discussion public discussion then we continue on with tactics and action plans Del necessary to implem each plan now the staff's doing this but we're saying pull this discussion out so we can understand what's going on a lot of information is going to be moving again rather rapidly and people develop F you want to be able to break down those silos to be able to ensure that you have information especially if folks have been around for a very long time right and every system that happens I don't care if you working for the post office or working for a church the silos that develop right so as a board you want to be able to understand the delivery of these various action plans

195and then be able to question the government accordingly so as we any thoughts on that those those slides all right so as we look at boardsmy aborts role at setting policy and the long-term vision for the district long-term vision for the system you you guys many of you work for school systems literally at one point in time I think all you did previous board members are teachers and folks were the county offic of education so you guys are immersed in what's happening in your neighboring districts you know what's going on in Tula Etc and so understanding your role the vision as far as the dayto day I would say it's important understand every aspect as to what's happening not looking from a micro macro perspective topical topical understanding what's going on day and a day

196off so that when there's a request to appropriate dollars or there's a request to high Architects so there's a request to do this you understand why so you don't meet every single board item with a measure of incredulousness or there's doubt there a hesitancy because you've not been brought along the way not saying that's not happening but as a as a good board member you want to understand the decision-making process the key elements associated with how the administration is thinking and how your colleagues are thinking because your Visions might differ You're Not Elected to think alike you all bring a different level of diversity to the days you reference going to i' seeing that some dogs or whatever the case is right hey maybe I'm passionate for you I don't understand it I can learn

197from it if we can go together we can understand what other folks are doing by way of utilizing whether it's support dogs or whatever other types of dogss you're talking about right so again understanding elements of of the the court Vision typically members of school boards are not necessarily as franchise you kind of almost like a a a a renter you you rent at the vision you didn't really like buy it you put that 30 to 20% down on it so you already have an investment right just kind of going along to get along and that's cool in some instances but if you really want to have an effective school system you want to lean in with a different set of lenses you want to lean in a little bit more aggressively and again I

198am I talking about a very strong School Board yes very strong School Board um am I talking about a school board that is full control of the system unequivocally yes because at the end of the day when something goes wrong you know who's blame you you folks can get other jobs but if something goes wrong you're held to account and the state and the counties see you as such because you are the elected governing board complimentary roles so what does the board do going back to what I said earlier as a as a as we recap monitor the overall operation divide with the superintendent make sure the train runs well watch this superintendent monitors operations and forms the board of progress successes and setbacks oversees evaluation of all staff runs the train make sure the

199train runs well superintendent runs the train now making sure that the train runs well we can look at that with a great level of ambiguity the type of train fast train slow train the type of track monor rail Light Rail underground right that's Vision what do we want to see right and then the conductor is the superintendent Ro shouldn't blur now when the roles do blur that's why you have a Governor's team to help you put FK back in check and we would work as a as a cohesive team to make sure that that no one is stepping over the line many members of the the board are franchising upon the superintend ability there to manage the system so I'm not going to run us through this because I we have to do this at

200another time but I did want to jump to conflict actually let me just ask a question uh thoughts or perspectives feelings on what we discuss discuss Mr superintendent first of all thank you M for addressing this and starting the presentation and being very specific in terms of what the the board can do and working together right I just would like to see if you can expand a little bit because I completely agree with you many years ago when I was a war member it was the the opposite right that the district was telling the board members now here the B is going to set the direction right but it has to be the bo right when we talk about the bo we're talking about 5 41 or 32 correct the direction is not set by

201one or two more members so that is could you agree with that 100% okay perfect 100% the other thing I just would like to see if you can expand or confirm this when you said the ball runs the show you can do everything that you want is based on what the community that they are representing wants right because tell me here if you this could be okay not influence but any personal needs personal interest group needs or anything is what the community that we as award members I'm sorry being 8 years there against four months here in this in this C well what the community wants right the on that we are representing based on the needs that they share with with them would that be okay can you explain it on those topics so

202to the superintendent's Point you're definitely not looking at self gain the FPC and the district attorney and every alphabet soup will take care of that so we don't have to worry about that put that in the parking lot okay so nobody's making any money off of any deals right won't be a good sign the beauty of the lcap and that process is you elicit the community's input School site counsels dlac etc etc etc you're hearing what the community desires as a part of that process and then once it bubbles up to the board then you have an opportunity to glean from that and so me saying you can do whatever you want to do well I'm under the belief that what you want to do enhances the quality of the system and supports that which

203the community has provided as what they like to see within the system so if we were in a K12 with ver or we're tacular Mar the k12's around you we want full day Kinder there's a cost for that we want TK prek there's a cost for that we want zero period there's a cost for that want an eight period there's a cost for that right okay we want a certain kind of organic lunch there's a cost for that we want electric buses on down the line so again we're talking about setting a vision that's strategic in nature but helps to move the system forwarded to the other point that was profer by the superintendent is that of course the the board one not two board is one now the board is also three okay now

204generally speaking let me just expound on this point for many superintendents I've engaged around the country if you're reading the tea leaves you kind of know the direction the Bo's going to go in so if I me to make I probably could be sure that board leans a certain way and perhaps we're going to have to move a little differently just a fact if I'm in cver City or Santa Monica the board moves a little different it leans in a certain direction and the system has to modify itself accordingly adhering to the provisions of the state right and and implementing that which the state says you ought to as well as the county Etc but on certain issues we know where we're going to lean this is a rather purple board it's a purple board

205and so you get a little more blue as you go Mo valy right some more purple board okay and so the the system has to be very conscious and cent of that not play political but really stay focused with respect to student achievement and addressing the issues that you have before you right and I'm not saying these other systems are plan political but we to be very careful what we say and what we do because it matters the impact of words are great the reverberations can be felt for Miles so as as a board if this board decided we want to open an early college and and one thing I understand about the president the president wants to understand the mechanics he likes the mechanics of it all you say it how does it find

206its way to the de there many ways it finds its way to the de whether it's the director the superintendent on the floor or whether you agendize a mechanism to it direct the superintendent to research Etc come back give him time 30 days 45 days 60 days what have you come back with a plan right cuz Hope's going to happen overnight because it involves franchising the Community College District and what that represents F question Mr Mr President I do I have a question because and this one's kind of constantly on my mind um so we have you know within we're a union so we have you know I represent the mene area right and so then there's it's Paris and mene the two cities um so our role as a board I mean obviously student

207achievement that's a no-brainer you know I mean we want our students to achieve at every site right um now every site might have different student achievement focuses that they might have it might be that you know they're struggling in one high school with the language arts others it may be math now our role as board members um I know we advocate in general um for the whole but so when we're discussing or like I guess when we make visits so because I'm elected by uh trustey Area 1 if I make it should I spend more of my time with the superintendent and and the jurisdiction of my trustey area um or or do we kind of share I mean obviously I want the well-being of all the kids under our jurisdiction but at the same

208time you know my community is the one who elected me um and and and the communities can be a little bit different politically but you know I think outside of the the politics I think we can all agree we want what's best for the two cities and the two communities that we oversee right with with their education regardless of where it's at but I guess as you've brought things up I've started to think like okay so am I supposed to be spending a lot more of my time you know hearing from that truste area and working with that side administrator and through the superintendent obviously working with the superintendent and in building the lcap and working with the administrator to say hey what is it that you need what are your goals you know that

209you want to achieve and accomplish you know through the lcap as opposed to you know me um comparing that to what maybe Paris is because they're completely different schools but you know should my attention really be more drawn there but also and I don't want to say that it's like because I saw this done in TMO where you had board members who just advocated for one specific site their trustee area and I always looked at it as like well they're kind of overseeing everything with with obviously again student achievement making sure that we have literate students leaving our school with early middle college program through our CTE programs whatever it may be um I guess my question is how do I how do we spend our time wisely to make sure and it's not and

210I don't want to make it sound like it's the purpose of a re-election because I could care less about that um but you know like you said we only have a certain amount of time and within that time frame we have to get to work and at least hopefully move the direction of where we want to go so that our trustee area is pleased with what we've what we've done and advocated for for their sites but as well as in general um for the whole Paris Union because we represent the whole District okay so I'll take it a few ways so you're elected and I trusty area one there's a mechanism for that particular area those schools are mechanisms for them to collect all that data all that data comes up through the lcap makes

211your job easy not much to Advocate because the principle is essentially managing a franchise Principle as a McDonald's franchise and the prevailing belief that the principle was engaging the community working with the community communicating with the community involved in after school programs other enrichment Etc that principl franchised that entire Community well enrollment is up and so they're able to do whatever needs to be done because they have extra resources based upon the Ada level whether it's an assistant principal whatever they want to spend their money a curriculum specialist whatever right as a board member my question Mr President is this do we have a comprehensive facilities needs assessment done to be able to know all of the issues not just in trustee area one but all of the issues impacting the entire system because they're

212in it strictly connected there the larger lcap well now we have an issue of an inequity if the high schools in the South are outperform of the high schools in the north you know where I'm going I have to say it okay so we don't have to use any buzzword but we're allowing this data to drive the discourse and there needs to be targeted interventions for students who are underperforming predicated oppon percentile okay that is the macro discussion the board is having at the oversight level now back to the wise Mr Hall why is the north not performing as great or equal to the South greater than or equal to okay that's a huge question oh why does the South have a beautiful water found in front of the school and you walk in and

213there's L crystal glasses and everybody hey what about the north right those are B questions as to how do you bring forth a measure of equity within the overall system now let me say let's say you went out for a bond well Parish High SCH was beautiful might not requiring any resources maybe the resources were required in the South maybe based upon the deputy soups project enrollment might increase here this year right maybe a decrease here postco there's an increase as as a board you're looking at the forecast all the leading indicators you're analyzing data and you're questioning down so if they're not in a position to answer those questions right then and there no problem continue the meeting right continue the meeting so let me just jump over here to effective ways and tools

214of governance motion resolutions leveraging staff Ali goes to Super hey hey I I believe we ought to buy a brand new podum this one is ugly well that's you one vote man now he hears three people playing by Podium obviously get a new Podium okay just a measure of Intuition or we're bringing forth many for Resolutions to be able to direct the staff accordingly which makes things clean and clear makes things clean and clear what does that mean well you employ staff your attorneys more cost you much money to put together just simple motion send you a copy of one I'm directing the superintendent to come out with a comprehensive report to look at establishment apcd within 60 days clean it's clean again we're talking about effectively governing at a strategic level so there's no

215role confusion in a super doesn't feel compelled to listen to one person now now what happens in in these situations and settings the there's always conflict with a superintendent the board president or the board chair because the board policy extends the president of different level of authority and normally the president many instances M KK Carter going tested this in many instances the the president was elected among a majority of his peers on the board if not a unanimous vote at least a majority well there's sometimes a prevailing Bel the president or would it should be preven president car's support now this isn't talking about a understanding the group dynamics and the politics of a board because now if the president the superintendent there's conflict it requires you to then go to finding ways to direct

216the superintendent in a more corporate open setting without the president dictating to the superintendent what the president believes the super AR to do now president can have any of y'all can put something on the agenda this lady right here can put something on the agenda citizens Camp so putting it on the agenda is not an issue that's already been covered covered in court cifi not an issue what often times come up is how you move things around on the agenda and how you want to schedule so your board policy very interesting which is almost similar to Tula has probably the most interesting Bo policy as to how the Super Bo president works relative to how things come on the agenda but the language uses in consultation almost like advice and consultation now now not to

217say the president can't remove something but then of course if you want to put a little more teeth in your policy change it just change the policy so everybody's on one Accord and there's no conflict or confusion among anyone right and we be able to keep peace and move the system forward and so when you look at conflict as defined competition between independent parties who perceive that they have incompatible needs goals desires and ideas the process in which two or more parties attempt to frustrate the others go tment the factors underlining conflict to threefold interdependence differences in goals differences in perception we all want the same thing for the system right but I just believe we ought to have cornfed beef and you believe it ought to be grassfed two cows right it's beef I

218prefer corn you prefer grass okay how can we meet in the middle lamb so so again you know as a board the objective is to you want people to be happy right you want them to come to work you don't want to have you don't want to have pressure as a board thinking I can't get anything done this this place is just like post office I can't move anything it's like ham trck so again these are ways in which we can effectuate good governance as a board I know I move through this rather rapidly we can always do a part two but I did want to be able to I then we're going to be losing we going to be losing someone in a second any thoughts questions on conflict board motions resolutions tools of

219governance perspectives just one really one really quick one on on the the allocation of like elcat fund so um if one School site is obviously performing well do you reallocate assets or or finances to another one who might be struggling or or do you maintain obviously it's like because usually there's there success because there's programs and resources that are in there and they're being properly managed and used and they're resulting in that effect um but you don't take away or or all that's built up on the I don't know if it's udps now or UPS or the separation of uh of the funding because you know it just doesn't seem like it would be sensible you know to have a program that's successful a site that has successful programs and then to now start to

220strip and I've seen that done in districts where they start to strip um some resources to give to maybe a different site or a different area and then all of a sudden now you start to see that that it was those resources that caused the success and show I could tell you now based upon your District's demographics you have resources grants Etc within this system they provide targeted interventions I I could say this unequivocally the deputy probably going test there's no Robin Peter to pay Paul with respect to student achievement their resources in the system and so I wouldn't see there being that level of an some of your neighborhood districts receive very little very little supplemental concentration you're not in position her head is she's agreeing so you you have nothing to worry about

221there okay if there needs to be issues or concerns from a pedagogical standpoint or it standpoint Etc they're here now we were down south couple districts to the South it's a different story cuz the revenue moves a little bit different limited are you very limited As you move north and some of your neighboring districts of North you go up positionist I like to expand a little bit of the question from Mr Campos because I think it's really important Miss Reign would it be fair to say the allocations to each schools is based on the needs right so if we need interventions and there are needs to improve in one school of on this side that is already represented in the allocation so they need to invest that money in the students who are there to

222support right we might have in another school the need for even more funding but first they need to spend that money satisfy the specific needs of those students because that was the reason that money was allocated am I addressing your question yeah would that be fair to say that yeah it's fair and if I could expand just a little bit um maai is exactly right there's targeted intervention money for specific purposes some are um competitive grants some are awarded you know from the state you know base like the equity funding multiplier as an example those are for two of our schools you know that meet those criteria um I would really like to um participate with the board maybe at the next board meeting and go over the budget process because I think it was

223M that we're about I think you have at the beginning of his presentation did you say we're we're starting that process we've actually already started that process um but what should not happen is the board first hears about next year's budget at the public hearing the first week of June that's not that's not effective um nothing in the budget is done in a vacuum or should be done in a vacuum right um it's getting stakeholder input it's um getting the input from each of the school sites because because they may have similar needs and they may have different needs the l cap is um one of the processes within the umbrella of the budget as is Title One and some of these other funding sources lcap is run by at services but all of those

224same principles I just mentioned of it not being done in a vacuum also holds true Joe has Diana is responsible for putting together the lcap document she does that under the guidance now of of Joe Joe seeks input as part of the whole budget process um from others it it fits so nicely into this the strategy and man management we talking about the board provides the big thank you we are in syn here now ser and I were you you you're this Arrow we're this Arrow right I think that was your point all of and so we take those big picture um initiatives from you we work with each site we're Gathering that data we're putting it all together no one person um is making decisions you know for the budget often times when people

225are disassociated with the budget process that the natural inclination is to think the CBO or in this case Candace makes all the decisions in the district that's not true I I just have the ultimate responsibility for putting all the pieces together um and presenting it and lcap is a big piece as you said because we have a high piece so when you ask you know when I'm talking with the principal that's certainly fine I'm not saying that it's not but it's it's our primary responsibility to talk with those side administrators and understand their needs at a very inde depth level so that we can include the resources that they need for their students in the overall budget and their discretionary allocation which as getting back to your question does follow allocation um methods um because

226you know we can't we can and we should give one school or one set of population of students more money what it's targeted in and need right is that hopefully that wasn't too end up can I give one example so we're in the Brit process with elcap I'm over elap with the curric instruction and Innovation U you know look over the historical data of what we've been funding why we've been funding it looking at the efficacy of it looking for reducing uh you know outside contractors using inhouse Tal it um looking at class siiz reductions for Els we have El release time for Le so one example would be uh you know not doing status quo so for meeting with the district directors on things that we were funding um and then meeting specifically with

227School principles like uh the other day Paris High School for the bar program which is behavior assets reducing risks pulling the data on the effectiveness of the program and all those data points so that before I'm committed in my new position to be putting allocating the funded I wanted I want to make sure that I have the data I want to make sure that the right people are on the right seat of the bus because the program could not be effective because of the people who are are leading the program so the level of depth that we're doing is at at the ed services um looking through the budget allocations looking at historical record but before we start to finalize in that negotiation with what we do principles and directors are bringing us data um

228I was an English teacher so I do appreciate uh you know operating in a system that provided resources that provided release period provided training uh and that kind of stuff that way we were able to and I know right now we're just talking about budgets but also another big part of my role is effective teaching practices best first instruction um but you have to have the funing so as an example Mai and the board this is one one one portion of one light item that you will see on the budget you'll see bar but the amount of u of due care that we put into those decisions are pulling the data meeting with the people making sure that it's effective and that it's also ongoing um and that it's sustainable as one example for one

229item line item you'll see on the budget all of those steps are taking place if that helps all right so we're we're going to quickly pivot over to miss KK card she's a few slides as far as the budget is concerned or the uh physical health ass where do we get they give us presentations so before I begin you're going to think that M and I actually cheated off of one another but we did not compare notes at all um and doing our presentations um the one thing he didn't say and and before I I I don't I don't want to take elaborate but the one thing he didn't focus on completely is that you could which I'll talk about in my uh it's in part of my presentation is deliberate a strategic planning and

230deliberate visioning you had asked does it happen at the agenda level does it happen at the workshop level it happens both places but I've seen it more effective at the workshop level and the one thing that he might want to talk about one day is how as a board member he guided a district that was in state receivership to an award woman district and that is miraculous in California it doesn't happen and I'm not saying that because he's my friend he's my friend because I called him because I took over a district that was in trouble but as a board member he guided his superintendent he helped guide his district he helped guide his community and all of that are things that you can't teach in a little PowerPoint but to learn it would be

231great for this District I just he didn't say it I'm saying it for him so um you um the district retained um me in uh late April early May of last year to perform a a independent fiscal Health analysis for um the district for the incoming superintendent is this for me I'm not technologically appr okay let's go so um between your next speaker and maai I don't need to focus on a lot of my presentation but I want to go over the the things that you probably already know um as well as be available for any questions that you would have of me um the data that I studied might be a little stale because you just had a first interim presentation of your 24 25 budget but there are things that um I can

232uh elaborate on here um that your super your CBO probably already knows Andor things that you just may want to ask me as a season CBO the new board members probably you have no idea who is this SCH but I was retained I'm a I'm a retired School District administrator uh 39 years I've been in the business I started in 1986 I know I know I but but I did um I was a member of the Caso board of directors and chair of the legislative Comm committee that actually was involved in uh for many many years in guiding the uh the laws that um govern our school's business uh casbo is the California Association of school business officials and so that's where us as cbos learn our craft that's where we hone our Craft um

233I retired in 2019 from Beverly Hills Unified School District as the assistant superintendent of Business Services um in 2012 I was hired by Tom txen to come take over uh Englewood Unified School District we had gone into State receivership that's how I met uh Mr Ali right there because I took over a district in distress um I have a reputation for working with districts in distress um prior to uh taking over Englewood the uh Los Angeles County Office of Education superintendent had called me in 2006 to take over sella Valley Union High School District which is what comparable and help I helped even though I was there um I was there two and a half three years the road map to guide that District back to Financial Health was what I had put into place

234before I went to another District uh I am a fraud autter I'm one of the only cbos in the state of California that has eight felony convictions under my belt um that were um a superintendent a construction manager and two clerks have served prison time because of fraud audits that I completed and um lastly and since retirement I have been part of the Consultant Group that that is guiding Santa Monica Malibu School District to separation both districts will be basic Aid and I am one of the only cbos in Los Angeles County that has worked with a basic Aid School District a basic a is a different type of funding than lcff that's when you're funded specifically on property taxes only and so you are pretty independent and it fluctuates I want so I say

235that all to say I've been in school districts a very long time and I believe that um the board president at the time Mr Garcia Mr compos um allowed me to do this analysis for you because I've worked in the the business so long in total I've worked in a total of 11 districts over my career including the ones that I I consult in now the project scope that I took on um was a full review of your multi-year budgets your balances your um ending fund balances I looked at your audit your audit findings your internal controls your reserves your um Revenue projections I looked at your cash management I looked at your internal controls I looked at your Associated student body uh Records I interviewed SE I can't remember how many cuz I talked

236to them on the phone I was in your district for two full days um with no lunch nobody fed me but but no your your staff is wonderful but I I interviewed your staff um about budget development budget controls fairness of budget how they felt how they felt about how the um their contribution to your budget processes um like I said I talked between seven to 10 of your administrators coaches uh teachers and the like um let me see I'm trying to get through this quickly children the summary of this presentation focus and again stop me if I'm moving too fast or if I'm not um uh telling you what you want to know from me I feel like I know your budget fairly well uh I like I said I spent a lot of

237time working in it uh it's a it's a big budget this is not a little District it's 200 million that's an that's a in in other any world that's a large budget you have a lot of responsibility as a school board you have a uh your staff has a lot of responsibility and I I feel I I'm very um happy or the honor that you allowed me to analyze your budget and be a a participant in you all taking your rightful place as the best school district in in the in the Empire the areas that I found were um the the physical health analysis that I did talk to um I don't know how to pronounce your last name I called her Mose but supposed to call you Doctor you can call me continue to

238call me not a problem in terms of my last name any way that you can say your try like a mouse aous a rouse like a mouse you know what if I if I don't mind I'm just going to interject something for the new school board members so one of the reasons why this kind of came about where we um looked into her Services we we were we were dealing with um a hiring a crisis where we had to release some employees or we had a budget issue and so there was a lot of different things going around in the community a lot of just and and some of us were new board members at the time as well well at least I was because U Edward had already been um a board member before

239and so with all of the stuff that was going on within the community and just us not completely grasping everything that was going on um we just wanted to make sure in the process we were we were going we were moving to hire a new superintendent and so we just wanted to make sure that we did an outside audit which was it's something that's pretty I would say standard right in in the transition because what we wanted to make sure is that when we hired our superintendent that this was in place so that he knew hey you know what here's a report this is where we're at financially because um throughout and I'm not saying that we were in that boat but there's I mean you'll read about different school districts neighboring districts some the

240South um where there's scandals and all of a sudden next thing you know there's you know people are going to jail and all kinds of other stuff and you're just like how does that happen you know so for us we wanted to make sure that that we just said hey look we want the next person who's coming in we want to make sure that they have a clean bill of health in terms of uh fiscally and that we've done this AIT so they don't have to worry about a lot of you know figuring out okay where we at what's going on so we want to make sure that we came hired her to do this to then give him and in preparation to say okay I've already got a lot of this stuff worked out

241so that he can then hit the ground running know where the target her recommendations were and and also to also prove to the community hey this is there's all kinds of stuff going on but this is what we have this is what was found this is why we spent the money now it can guide us in the future to make sure that we're making the best financial decisions that we can knowing where we're at and what when when Candace gives us her presentations in the future of kind of what what's going on with the budget and the projections so that's kind of how it all came about and so for us it was I mean it was good news to think because we thought you know what well where are we going to be you

242know we didn't 100% know because it we didn't know but this really helped us in in in the process so that's why we went ahead and went with um Contracting her Weather Services to do this audit so and it's part this presentation is just a snapshot of our logger report and if you don't have a copy Sarah can I'll send it to I think we okay it's a large report but again um I wanted to stress and I started off the report you are you all are in solid physical health you're not like when they I was hired for Sentinel Valley and they were on their way to receivership that's why Leo hired to come be their CBO um in Englewood uh when I became state administrator of a failing District they had failed you're

243nowhere near that L can you please just explain to them what and I don't know I'm not trying to insult you intelligence takes over yeah the state the district is in um it's just like bankruptcy it uh the district is in receivership of the state because it can no longer pay its bills it has gotten a certification a negative certification from its County Office of Education and that the the district cannot is not fiscally solvent it doesn't even have enough cash to make payroll the board is dismissed the superintendent is dismissed the CBO is dismissed and they call in a team the state I reported directly to the state uh superintendent the state comes in and begins to clean house you see massive amounts of fraud massive amounts of um you basically are running uh

244which I looked at here you don't have those problems you're basic running two two payroll systems three payrolls of Staff where you have half the staff out or 34 of the staff on absence so you're paying somebody to to be at work then you're paying for their substitute then you're paying workers C cost for the ones that are off on workers come it's just a district in total failure where all of the systems are gone District right so yes because we are recording this I want [Music] anybody listening audio recording so it's another District that's I I think the reason why Mr asked me to re uh to elaborate on it because I know I knew I know what to look for to see if you were headed down that path and I immediately or

245one of my um overriding statements in my report is that you're in you youve have positive certifications you're in good physical health you have balanced budget even though you are deficit spending and you know that and we'll talk about that you you are planning for you know it's coming um your finances are are honest in a failing District they submit Englewood for example submitted fraudulent financials to uh to Leo with fraud fraudulent uh revenue revenue that was never going to come in none of those things are happening here this you yes I didn't want to cut you off um so if you have layoffs that doesn't necessarily mean that you're in a failing no if you're declining an enrollment and your de ISS spending you have to start thinking about lay offs you start thinking

246about it two ways though now as a school district the old way you know when I started 39 years ago we only talked about layoffs we only talked about budget reductions of course you have to talk about budget reductions you have to look at budget deductions you have to budget based upon that strategic plan and that vision and that lcap so that you are actually using your resources towards the goals that you want for your students instead of just blanket budgeting but these days you also have to think of a school district like a business I think that might be the other reason why I was retained because I understand that a school district now doesn't the students don't have have to come to you they don't they have Charter Schools they can go to

247they can they get permits to go to other neighboring school districts you have to Market your District the same way you were Coke or Pepsi or you know AMC Theaters you have to make your District attractive for your students and your community um so that the parents want to send their children to your District you have to have the sexy programs that districts have what whatever Mai said I I'm not an educator Early Childhood learn who knows but those are the things that parents and the um uh the media look at and that's how you attract your students because you can lose them and that's what happened with Englewood Englewood lost had a preponderance of charter schools uh dependent and independent and they it wasn't a natural Decline and that's what you're why I talk

248about your enrollment and declining growth that you that needs to be studied where are your students going why are you're not meeting your enrollment projections a natural decline is when what we learn in school business you can look at the housing market you can look at the housing growth starts or the the the birth rate you can do the cohort method and you can figure out we're going to get this many new students or we're going to lose this many students what you what we now have to um study as school business people are what are the charters doing to us the ones that we not your dependent Charter but even your your dependent Charter is not who I'm talking about I'm talking about your independent Charters that Riverside County Office of Ed um authorized

249I'm talking about your transfers um to other school districts I'm talking about the students that are supposed to enroll with you um in um after middle school or Elementary who don't so I'll get into that in the report but those are the things now as school business people that we never had to study before we didn't have to fight for our students but you have to make that your always thought I can lose that student that student is not is your dollars but it it the more you lose the more keep walking out and it when it becomes a unnatural decline that you can't budget for annually because you don't know who if you don't address it then you don't know that your revenue is going to be you can't project that Revenue because those

250students have now they don't need a permit to go to a charter school so you don't know they they're gone until they don't show up can I give an example I know that and it's been within the past decade I'm sure you guys will have remembered this but I do remember uh when Vista Mareta was built and it was probably like a decade after that um people started to leave so the people within my community we didn't have Liberty High School they were zoned for Paloma U but there were I mean it could be it could be something simple as lacrosse you know that they have a lacrosse program and we don't that would give them so when a parent wanted to transfer out all they had to do is say well you're not providing

251the services that we want for our children you know V maretta offers a lacrosse program or they offer a girls this program or you know a boy this and that's used I mean at the time I want to say we were losing Paris Union was losing probably about 300 students a year and it was to little programs like that now obviously just like uh uh M had mentioned earlier you know you have to be competitive you have to understand okay well what's it going to cost us to to build that program to have that there do we have the the the students to be able to fill those programs to not lose those programs and and when they started I remember at the time when they were discussing it it was a big issue because

252a lot of people in our community had it was that's all they were talking about was well they don't do this you know I'm my kids's in eth grade right now but I'm going to make sure that I get a transfer because they're offering this and they're offering that and that's where it kind of goes back to the the marketing and being competitive we have to be able to Market and say hey we're going to provide you everything that you guys need academically uh on the extracurricular side U and in doing so I think you know uh M Dr Ral with his trying to bring in Partnerships with you know Ford and Kia all those things are marketing the district and I think that's where we stop the bleeding we start start to generate new

253income and then just we revive the community the commitment to the community in providing the best uh High School experience Middle School experience academic I guess uh experience in the area and and we do have competing areas where they're doing different things and we have to stay at least in competition with them there to make sure that we're not losing our students so and I know that simple things like that my presentation that's it that would be it because enough many school boards don't understand stand our or superintendence and Dr arous does because we talked about this we talked he and I consciously had this he already knew but it's like you have to fight we're fighting for these students we have to develop and we talked about your Aroma decline that's important you have

254to focus on it you need to I mean you can't I I I've been a CBL so it's like there are certain things that you might that candidates may need a consultant to come in and and a study for her why are her growth projections not meeting what she thought they were going to meet because they should like you said mini is growing um you have areas that are should not have the level of decline that you have and you need to understand where those students are and why they're not coming to you as well as uh Dr Jose and I talked about the transfers I told him when I when I got to Englewood I put somebody not just my child welfare in attendance person I said oh no we're not giving no more

255transfers that's not what we're doing we're marketing our district we're going to sell it we're going to go to that parent who's asking for that transfer and what do they want that we can we can put together so that we don't lose that student um they're they just implemented Inglewood one of my my ideas to um attract students the Dr Dre Jimmy iine Academy as said we live in Englewood that's the heart of music rap uh um athletes that's what we're marketing to our students that's what we're going to Market to this community to get these students to come back to us and they just started the Dr Dre Jimmy I I who you know runs beats of Academy for does not not a charter that's a district program it's a sexy District program that

256they produce they have on the radio they they're there it starts in 20 SE Fe September 2025 and it's been all over the radio to have the eighth graders try their rooll in the school and and following up with Mr Camp mention we have wonderful programs here in our district we have Pathways at Liberty High School we are working on in partnership with Kia and other corporations to have CTE taken to the next level like Certified Technician and these for example but during my conversations with you and if you can expand a little bit you talk about the marketing we need to Market that we need to advertise all those programs and develop a strategic campaign addressing that so our community knows and learn about those possibilities can you explain a little bit that's exactly

257what we talked about we and I talked to cace I know she she does your public information I'm like why why are you doing public what's he who has time for that and do your other job but it's not just public information it's social media marketing it's just strategic Partnerships and now that you all are looking at your asset management it's your asset management too all of those things are not things that school districts traditionally used to do but you should have someone um in addition to the superintendent but the superintendent cannot go to Every kawaiian and Chamber of Commerce and and rotary and Women's Club meeting you need a a district Emissary to all and you have two huge communities that you serve but those are your strategic Partners as well as the industry

258in your area and the incoming industry in your area when you were talking about Asset Management I mentioned MLB to maai because I worked at um comp College before but in my working with Santa Monica Malibu School District we our tongue and cheek joke is that Santa Monica school district is has a is an educational District that has a real estate business on the side because they actually own a hotel next to their a long-term um lease NE next to their district office they just bought their District office they own an apartment building that was empty land that is a long-term lease that now is a an apartment building they they saw their enrollment decline declining in Santa Monica area because it's singles not families and they put in a vision and a plan to

259grow their own legitimate Revenue so you not only want to keep those students you want to get those students to school you need to look at independent sources of revenue as well I question for when you took over um the district what was your proficiency uh scores were they really low all right how did you get those up because I'm looking at ours and we have a high graduation rate with low proficiency scores that concerns me so I was in a district that Englewood was in catastrophe that's not what you have what we had and I can tell you but I I did I was there 3 and A2 years before I couldn't it's a lot of work I mean when everything is broken there's nothing that was working but I really looked at teacher

260um teacher outcomes what what was happening not just so I did two things for me for Englewood I had brand new principles who were not were so busy being principles that they didn't have time to do classroom um uh visitations classroom observations then have time to deal with i i my goal um this was not popular with the unions but the worst teachers who never came to work who had the worst student outcomes those are the teachers that I had the principal's Target but I gave each principal so we had a mentor for every three principles to help them learn learn how to do their classroom observations learn how to um review their lesson plans the lesson plans of the teachers to learn how to um discipline staff that were not uh doing what they

261were supposed to do and so it wasn't all and out assault on the teaching staff the certificated staff or the classified staff it classified staff it was there's a new sheriff we're not doing what we used to do anymore anymore these outcomes are not not uh uh not what we want and we at the time and they're not now I think I think they're I mean I've been gone now I left Englewood and went back to Beverly Hills and then I've been retired now almost six years but at the time we have the worst test scores in LA county uh worse in in U most elementaries but definitely our our three high schools were the worst and so to have now for that school district they we did another thing our our our facilities were

262dilapidated and crippling um as a district and receivership we passed a bond I worked hard to pass a bond I did the the footwork because our schools were so terrible you could look through the floor rats running all around the no school it was just the then and it's not like some of the things that you guys might have addressed but there for me having being brought in by the state I felt it was criminal because you had a rich part of town that had beautiful school districts beautiful School sites they had all the materials that they needed and then you had the Poor Side of Town that had nothing and you could literally put your foot through the floorboard of this of a of a classroom and so I went about equalizing the entire

263District I mean it was I I worked with fmat and we put together I lived in the area so and that that was the my strength is that I knew the area I knew the students I knew the parents I knew what the parents wanted to see and what they wanted to do what they wanted to hear and that's what they went about implementing but that's where your strategic plan and your visioning comes in the purposeful is that the proficiency is not acceptable anymore I know you you know it's not and and and anybody doesn't want to get on board well and that's when I walked around talked it was it was safety and school scores why would I send my my students to uh a school that they don't feel safe teachers don't feel

264safe the parents don't feel safe dropping them off and then with all that you're going to get bad scores absolutely safety and and and good I mean and not just Beverly Hills but at Englewood the same thing I I I developed a um well I developed a partnership with the mayor of Inglewood because my life was threatened and I had to have a CHP detail because they were going to kill me for all that I had done so I actually had had a CHP officer picked me up and take me home and stand outside my office for the two years I was there but you have to have I I'm it's it was tongue and cheek but it happened but it's because I had the courage to say this is not working anymore we're going

265to turn this District around and that's what they hired me for in the state to do and that's what I went about doing and so the same thing we I got extra patrols from the Inglewood PD at my schools I have other staff in security more um uh uh qualified staff right in Secure so that this so that the parents weren't afraid to bring that that their kids be dropped off in front of the school the last thing on this slide though that I do want to highlight and you're going to get more about it from your next speaker so that's why I said our our presentation is overlap but I think because we all know how to run Great Schools your Charter School oversight and management your dependent chart I'm going to talk about

266in another slide but I believe that even that same position that we talked about or person that does your public information and and or maybe someone in your ed services needs to develop a a partnership with Riverside County Office of AED they authorize those Charters that are taking your students are they are they doing their oversight that was the thing that was happening at wood there was no oversight so these Charters were running a mck they weren't teaching the kids any more than we were teaching them but yet they had the more sexier Pro programmatics the radio sponsorships the things like that once I started doing Charter School oversight when I had the the the person go out to these Charters to make sure that they were they were delivering what they promised in their

267Charter applications and we were able to get their Charters revoked I was we were getting our students back and so Charter School oversight management is key here because you didn't authorize these Charters but they are taking your students so the way to deal with them is to make sure that they're doing what they said they would do as well as I know you already know and she's um my colleague is going to talk about when you get um applications and you get a uh a charter that wants to open in your district and how to deal with that when I got to Englewood they were doing it themselves I'm like oh no we're not dealing with another application I did hire an attorney and the attorney dealt with every Charter School request that we got

268that we could then deny because we were uh uh delivering those same educational programs in the previous slide there was about the Ada to enrollment in if you can I'll talk a little bit about I'm sorry I'm I'm I'm rushing I apologize that's okay but I think that is really important because that is one of the laser focus that I have been talking with the board about instruction St achievement something that Mr Hall was saying that we are addressing it through curriculum instruction innovation F thank you so your 880 enrollment is just that you get funded based upon your average daily attendance your enrollment are the number of students that are enrolled your goal of course would be 100% Ada nobody gets 100% but you need to get as close as you possibly can in

269the districts that I've worked in the high performing districts the Ada to enrollment percentage is between 98 and 99% yours is currently 89% that means 89% of you're only getting paid for 89% of your student population you your goal should be at I think a a attainable goal is 93% and that's what I talk about in the report is to get those students to class and there are lots of mechanisms I'm not an educator I know that in the districts that I've worked in as Educators do they not only dealt with their um graduation requirements or their they they set up Saturday school set up after after um after school makeup sessions so that you can get that ADA and and and um count those students that's a way that's Revenue growth that's Revenue generation

270and those students are yours so you just got to get them to school there has to and and there again it's a it's um a conscious effort in in one of my in Beverly Hills we were at like 95% they w at 98 every school had the thermometer uh I mean I'm not again I'm a business person I can look at it and say listen we need 98% participation but they develop they put a monitor of eight you know attendance where's our attendance compared to the last month how are we growing it what are our strategies when you talk about proficiency those are the things that are conscious efforts to grow your student achievement because if the students are there they're learning if they're not there they're not learning and thank you for addressing that

271and I just want to address the board I I really asking you begging you to support us in the efforts to increase Ada because there is a direct correlation how you mention the high performance in schools they have a high Ada attendance students need to be in school in order to be to learn with that 4% increase or 5% increase board members we're talking about $1.7 million for every 1% so 4% we're talking about close to seven little bit more than 7 million that that can transfer into more stuff to provide safety to our students during after school activities during the regular day to provide and byy generators so when we have these issues that are going to continue to come our students are in school because sometimes we cancel classes we don't have the

272electricity so all of those small variables if we act them up that is going to transfer into higher student achievement and better services for our students so it's of the utmost importance to start focusing on our Ada so students are in class and we provide better Services those 7 something million dollars they want to go back to our students Direct Services to them to address what the community members have be sharing with you Mr Hall about safety and a student achievement right we have to uh not I mean it's got to be 100% on everything the kids that are in school on their their scores Plus getting the kids students that are not going to exactly so you know we have to make sure we are balancing out that's right our our focus on all

273these areas that we have to work on yes I completely agree with you thank you for bringing that that up that is just one variable right or two but we have also a curriculum instruction Innovation that we want to have that laser focus there to support our teachers so they can transfer the the best to the best of their abilities that instruction to our students so we can increase the student so it's a multivariable process but we are addressing it yeah so one more time your health is very important I could just jump in quickly we've been talking business this is curricul instruction um and I can tell you that you know we started out the year and we're kind of getting Baseline academic performances and we're looking at growth and there's a number of

274things that we did but there were a number of things that we also recognized because you mentioned the re the effort that we have to get them to school but the efforts we do when we have them in school correct right and so a concern about graduation rates and proficiency rates so so going forward we started this year with some really three three easy goal uh best first instruction and best first instruction also meant that we were uh protecting instructional time and minimizing distractions uh and and uh and so you know we're enforcing our cell phone policy we removed all social media we're using these e-hall passes to get students to classroom so talking about the students there we had our Union president at the beginning of the year you guys were on you guys

275weren't elected yet who said I was able to get to teaching within the first day or two of school right so one of our so best first instruct the other one is engaging in and highly rigorous courses for all levels for for all schools um and how those and how those are taught right the last part would the goal was you know uh the culture of the school well the culture of the school also had to do with behavior right and so when we we we've been digging into that type of behavior so if there's any perception that this that there uh there's apathy on the students behalf or they're not safe I'm going to tell you the best behavior plan is a great lesson plan a highly engaging rigorous lessons going to keep kids

276wanting to come to school and the last part of this part that I'll say is we want to give kids two other reasons to come to school than school right if we said you come to school because you have to go to school give me two other reasons why you're here oh I'm here because of this program I'm here because of that program I'm here because of these course so so you know I just got here just got here um we're making some great gains uh and uh for educating them you know once they're here but for those that aren't here I think like the benefits of membership for students who haven't been attending school to now all of a sudden see that we have highly engaging rigorous courses teachers that are engaging students from

277the get-go inquiry based learning Discovery learning so that so that they want to be here uh and just recently this second semester we did some enhancements on those things and immediately started seeing some data like less use of students using VES right just because we're doing all these other measures because they're engaging in the classroom all the distractions are removed uh they're they're they I mean it's it's early on but those efforts should not be overlooked I know we're talking about business and and and no but without that classroom experience it all relates to business I was say it all relates and it's one of those things that you think oh you're doing it you have to publicize it because you have to get that your message is that you're what you're doing now you

278you not just give reports to the board which for staff I used I you can ask my secretary I'm like oh my God I gota give the board another report but we gave the board reports monthly on different initiatives that they wanted us to do and those initiatives that those reports to the board became our public information tools those are the tools that our gains in what whatever particular area whether it be the ADH or those were publicized amongst all of our schools amongst all of our principles amongst our parents it was in our newsletters on our website all of our goals and our our new initiatives that becomes part of your marketing campaign so it is definitely applicable cand just wanted to say something I did I have a few things I want um

279I wanted to address you mentioned 93% is an attainable goal and then you start speaking about attendance so um 93% is precisely as it happens what our capture rate capture rate percentage um pre pandemic so I absolutely think it it's attainable um I do want to just correct the record if you don't mind Dr The $1.7 Million number for each 1% that Dr arous said is absolutely accurate it's accurate because I gave him that number number so um but if we were to increase let's let's say 1% the capture rate we have to remember that's based on our current enrollment and we are declining enrollment so do you do you it's part of the reason why we spent I think about 45 minutes with the first interam budget presentation with questions and they were great

280questions I appreciated uh the questions but you you'll remember me focusing on on really three key Concepts and and you're hitting all of them so it's one there's cool people we all think and everything in L's report of course it's accurate um it supports everything we've been talking about but the reason I wanted to correct the record you back to that when we're in a declining enrollment situation we will not realize all that we could realize in terms of Revenue in terms of increasing capture rate because it sort of establishes the base we're going to be fun this year on our prior year Ada so as an example we put the J1 13A approvals before you um was that last month or earlier this month I don't remember that won't change anything for this year

281but it helps with our base for this year which then becomes our Ada for the next year and now under new law we can be in the post I know you know this but it was after you retire uh we can now be funded on current year prior year or the average of three years so if we're declining um we're not going to realize all of that increase in capture rate now we still need the students to be in school of course you know so that they're learning and you know wanting to come to school um but but it's why we focus that first interim on deficit spending on declining enrollment and on our capture rate being the three biggest risks to our budget and while I I appreciate and agree we're not in fisal

282the addess or anything we have to keep our eyes on those things and we have to continue to talk about those elements of the budget um otherwise it'll impact us more greatly sooner thank you for the clarification appreciate and that should be in my opinion that should be one of your strategic plan one of your vision and goals two things why are we declining what are we doing about it and what are we doing to grow why are we declining what are we doing to grow the Board needs to know you need to know that you to know what your plan is because if you fail to plan what's going to happen you keep declining we're used we're in school districts again I having had to take over a failing school district they saw the

283decline they couldn't stop it again it was an unnatural decline because it was a charter decline so they didn't know who was leaving why they were leaving I as soon as I got there one of the things I did was look at the number of charter schools within a two M radius this is Los Angeles County so a two M radius takes you 15 minutes to get to the 2 m radius outside of our borders I have 27 Charter Schools but I I developed a partnership with Leo uh uh Los Angeles County Office of Education and said listen I need you to help me these I these charter schools have got to go if if we if we're going to stay solvent if we're going to remain a school district I need Charter oversight over

284these 27 Charters that are not mine I can't do anything to them but they're they're the ones who are stealing my enrollment the one thing that they that I don't know if you all have this problem but we had the problem in SEL Valley Union High School District they would keep my children or my students until um the P2 cut off the the P2 um P2 is when you is the count Day Count month ail of when you know how much money you're going to get for the next year so they we call it P2 period two so that's your second ENT reporting they would keep my students till P2 and then send them back at the end of April because they weren't graduating so not only did I not get money for those kids

285it was messing up my graduation rate right and your budget I again as soon as I got to Inwood I identified the things that that tore this dist that brought this District to the ground and they had not looked at that because we're used to as school people we're declining okay let's adjust our budget we're declining we're deficit spending we we're doing our job if we project the right deficit we're doing our job if we do the right amount of budget reductions but our job now is why is it happening and what are we going to do about that's our new job as school people so I don't need to harp on the fact that you all are deficit spending you know why you T they've talked about it with you they talked about the

286co one time funds that you were spending that spent down your reserves the one thing that Candace said um earlier in this presentation budget planning should not start in April budget planning is all year long it's all year long with your principls with your site administrators with your curriculum people with your department you need to we um one of the things that Dr um is it Dr Camp Steve Camp No Doctor talked about with me and I I I can talk about it right here because it's applicable is um kpis we call them kpis key performance indicators but you're looking at all year long how are we performing in how are we spending our money in compared to other districts just like us other high school districts within the state other um students with uh

287districts with 11,000 um 11,000 or so enrollment are we spending too much money at are we spending too much money in central office are we not spending enough money on master schedule initiatives are we spending too much money on grass where are we spending our money and that those are what kpis are and you don't have to spend a lot of money to to to get reports on those things to get that information um casbo has a number of vendors that have wonderful programs that gather data from everybody and you can spit out a report um one of the people that Ken and I know mutually he works for a company that has a and I'm not not recom there's a bunch of them and it's okay to have our RFP and look at these

288these products that are on the market where you look at other districts so when when you're developing your budget you're like well what do other Union High School Districts spend their money on how do they how much money are they spending on certificated St how much money are they spending on Athletics how much money are they spending on college readiness or counseling or what's the new buzz word so that the kids mental health they have puppies in Beverly Hills you don't even know I'm like really the kids have to have puppies come on now but how much money are are other school districts and that helps you in budgeting and making your decisions but you need to be budgeting all year long especially when you have def uh declining enrollment and deficit spending this is

289a year-long proposition you shouldn't have you should talk about the budget much more than first interim second interim and budget approval that you need to be talking about the budget at least monthly in one of your board meetings it's it's interesting that you said that I that is something that I ask Miss Reigns PR yeah days ago that I was providing the budget update and I don't remember how they call brief to the point specific clear concise I look at your dependent Charter and I don't I don't need to harp on it because I think you all are already looking at it I think I mean and I didn't know that it was such a great program I'm glad to hear that because you guys are you all are managing it but I think that

290their in addition to their planned uh erosion of their ending fund balance their budget might be a little bit out of sync they have a large staff their staff um I don't know I again I don't know the school I don't know the education program but looking at just my eyesight View and then I had my colleague look at it with me um who used to be the CBO at um um maren County Office of Education and she too said I think they should look at the spending at this charter school because it's yours and how they're spending their money is compared to either other dependent Charters or charters of the same enrollment is applicable here and so this is a area that I think you should have more more uh look side into one

291of the things that in Candace knows I talked to her about you guys have a $200 million budget and your auditor managed to find five things I tell my Auditors listen don't come to me with my I want to know audit my financials audit my department a I I I send them out into I want you to look at this ASV I want you to look at this cafeteria program I want you to look at the vacation AC I mean every year I I I'll give them things that I want them to look at but they they need to come to me with more than five findings because that's for me that means that you've gotten comfortable that we're not fraudulently spending money but you're not helping me with my internal controls you're not helping

292me as a CVO look at the things that I want to look at that I can handle internally but I need you as my auditor to give me the ammunition to look at these things so one of the things I told I said tell your aitor don't come back to me with little five findings you you need to find some stuff for $200 million you can find some stuff that that needs to be addressed the one thing that I will say is that every time you all get a finding it is fixed there's nothing in your audit that was not um repaired and it is a good it's a clean audit it's just maybe your auditor panel needs to be refreshed um May I know that you were were looking at doing a new RFP

293for new Auditors but again 200 million if somebody gives you an auto report and they have five finding you're like you you you didn't do your job 200 that's 20 million is a lot of transactions uh payroll and purchasing and so a a good auditor will be a so that's one of the areas that I think you should definitely look at and I did talk to um Candace about it in summary um we've talked like I said when I heard Ma's report I'm like I wanted to focus on strategic planning and visioning that was that was the area that but the the the well the the the the districts that are moving in lock step where school boards and superintendent have a vision for their District they have identified the programs that they want to

294highlight or that are their capstrong programs they have made it their mission to say I want to be the best in my area they do that by strategic planning and vision and then their expenses and their um how they spend their money is geared towards that it's not geared towards ambiguous my goal this goal that goal it's marching a lock step so that's why I said he stole all of my thunder um I talked about the kpis and getting a program in so that you can see you can ask those questions what are other school district what are they you can look at with these programs you can look at what they're doing in the how they're spending their money in ninth grade Master scheduling you know how are other high school districts what are

295they what what are they offering those types of things and it it doesn't cost you a lot of money but it gives you a lot of data that you can you can work on um one of the things that I talk about and it's in the report about reorganize reorganization of key roles I talked about it here that those roles are not how we used to function you know we we didn't have somebody looking at our Charters working on our relationships working on making sure that our social media is up to date making sure I think it well at least in Englewood um they get free radio time they've gone to their radio station they give free radio time on the local station and they pump up the you know the programs or what they're

296doing they have banners all over the all over the streets now in Englewood of all of the things that the school district is doing on the Billboards there it's a public information marketing campaign the same way you would Market any business that's what this is It's a $200 million business what you have uh and then of uh lastly is a resource allocation um when you are looking at your budget you're looking at are we um funding our school sites and excuse me you all talked about this a little bit are you funding your school sites um equitably um is one School site getting way less than another is one School site having to use their parental money and the other school site gets to use the district money I mean parents shouldn't be penalized because

297they fund raise I just it's not fair to the parents if they take the time to fund raise they deserve to use their fundraising money for what they they used it for those are the things where you need as a board I think you should focus on I have one question for you if you could just give me a brief um so in your on page 21 of your report on the Strategic recommendations and the strengthening part Partnerships you mentioned the name change to Paris manae Union High School District can you just briefly expand us to what I mean obviously now that you're you're you're mentioning the marketing uh because that comes up a lot of the times on our side of town on the meny side where you know they want to have their

298own high school district and have their own high schools and I think that recommendation was was a very smart and well recommended one because obviously it is a partnership between the two cities and when you're speaking of marketing that obviously combines the two and it gives in my opinion it gives uh like the buyin on the meny side of the two cities and in the Union School District if you don't mind and so the reason why I recommended it uh in the report and we I talked about to Jose the primary reason why Malibu wants to leave Santa Monica school district is because Santa Monica doesn't pay any attention to Malibu the name is there but the the Mal the school district doesn't go talk to the Malibu mayor they don't come talk to the

299Malibu parents as far away as 25 miles away um Malibu doesn't feel like they're included in the decisions they feel like they're afterthought so I was talking to Jose I I lived in Corona for 25 years I said you know there's the Norco School District you guys need to be the Paris Min School District that area is a I I I stayed there the two times that I've been here and I'm like oh my God these people have money somebody sees something here because you would never have that type of Commerce those type of stores if people hadn't if if um economic folks hadn't done their homework and put every food place in every deposit store you ever want in a little area that's a growth area those people need to be paid attention to

300a first step is putting their name in your school district because you don't want to lose them you don't want to be like Santa mon cibu where you get like we don't want to be here anymore you don't see about our needs you don't care about us we're not part of you and they take their ball and they go away it'll be it's harder for them of course but you don't want decision you want what what you want to bring your whole Community together I told um Jose I said you need to be meeting with the mayors of both of your cities regularly we met I meet I've met with in both all of my districts I meet with my Mayors I meet with my city coun um the ad Hop City Council Members that

301are part of the school district we been asked we have a we have um the city council uh uh appointed two members to meet with the school district from each City Council in um when I was in Beverly Hills and then in Inglewood you don't want what's happening with Santa Monica and Malu Mal's going to leave they're going to get it but it's Santa Monica did it to themselves because they did not bring them into the family and that's why I recommended it because the power of Paris miny school district is pretty big yeah they think um all of min's money goes to Paris and we have romal land over there as well as miny uh school districts and they so the first step is adding to the to the name but you're right they're

302they property tax dollars they're uh their L lcff comes here and so they need to be part of you but I think that it goes part of it's part of that marketing that I'm talking about as part of growing that Prestige there's no reason that valver should ever think they have more Prestige than the par Paris um uh miny school district is you should have it and that's why uh in the end we do I I think you all for letting me research your District letting me meet your staff and um there are many areas that again and I I I did find it a little comical that all the school people all think alike and we put this same things in our reports but the one thing about school districts and I talked to

303you about this Steve you know what you don't have to do is recreate the wheel there's over a thousand school districts in California so a bunch of people are doing it right you know all you have to do is look at the ones that you want to be like and you can create those same same things here anything else TR I rush through thank you very much thank you so much thank you okay so now we'll be moving on to Charter School basics hello I'm Marley Fox with or and Henderson thank you for having me welcome thank you for your patience thank you C for the jacket um so I'm here to talk to you about some basic Charter SCH stuff but I need to figure out how to work this first okay so just

304first off some general information about Charter Schools charter schools are public schools as I'm sure you know they oper operate pursuant to a charter which is a contract between the school and it's authorizing agency so a charter both authorizes the Charter School's existence and it also outlines the terms and conditions of its operations a charter school can be authorized by a school district or a County Board of Education and it used to be that the State Board of Education would authorize Charter Schools but now there's a change in the law and so if on appeal a charter petition goes to the state of Education the state board will choose either the school district in which the charter school seeks to operate or the County Board to serve as the the authorizing entity so the law

305provides that charter schools are supposed to operate independently from the existing School District structure um and they are created to among a bunch of other things provide increased learning opportunities for students more education options competition within the public school system to stimulate improvements in all public schools and allow for encourage use of innovative teaching methods so like other Public Schools charter schools are not permitted to charge tuition they have to be non- sectarian in their policies programs and practices and they have to also admit all students who apply or who want to enroll and and they may not discriminate on the basis of ethnicity national origin gender or disability if it so happens that more students apply then the charter school can accommodate the attendance has to be determined by a random public drawing and

306charter schools are provided more flexibility in the way they operate and in their curriculum than a traditional public school but they are also held accountable by what's in their Charter and so that goes to a question that you raised earlier Mr Hall that we'll talk about in a minute about the CMI CH petition which maybe we won't get into great detail today but I can provide some information about it so previously uh charter schools in California were provided some flexibility with teacher credentialing and uh in CL courses that were not for or for non- colge Preparatory courses teachers didn't have to have the correct credential but now the law has changed so all newly hired teachers in charge schools have to hold the proper credential permit or other document that's required for their certificated assignment

307and so teachers that were employed by a charch school during the 201920 year were given some time to obtain the requisite credential something they they have to have it by July 1st 202 2 so a charter school can be considered independent or dependent uh the Ed code doesn't distinguish between them but um they both go through the same process for establishment and renewal an independent charter school is basically an independent entity and it's required by law to either be governed by or to or or as I'm sorry a nonprofit public Corporation so it operates independently of its Charter authorizer and has its own governing board and it can be formed by a charter management organization or by parents or teachers or community members so a dependent charter school is different because it's established by or

308remains part of the school district or a County Office of Education that grounded granted its Charter uh it's treated as one of the district schools it's in the school district or authorized by the school district excuse me the school district's governing board is also the charter schools goverment board as you know um and the charter authorizer typically administers all the funding for the charter school a dependent charter school because the the Ed code does not distinguish between a dependent and independent Charter School dependent Charter Schools too are entitled to the same degree of flexibility with regard to their curriculum as orded in independent charter school so like other Public Schools Charter Schools also receive funding based on the number of students that attend in each grade level and the funding follows the student so if

309a student decides to go to a charter school the funding Will Follow That student there Charter Schools either can receive their funding directly or indirectly direct means the Charter School receives the state the funding directly from the state it usually comes to the county but indirectly or locally funded Charter Schools receive the funding on a past through basis through the school sponsoring School District so a dependent charter school is typically indirectly or locally funded meaning the funding comes through the school district quick question on that so an organization a group decide to um create a charter school and they're going to create an independent one so they go to the the county they apply and get send whatever they have to do but so are are we notified if they're targeting you know hey we

310want to put one right in between you know meny and Paris over here are we informed of that or so so typically what I mean sometimes they can go directly to the county if they want to create a a countywide charter school but typically the the application would come to the school district first and so the school district would have an opportunity to review the charter petition and then decide whether it warranted being granted or given a charter or not and then if the school district denied the charter then the charter school would have the ability to appeal to the county and the county could then Grant it so you would be aware of it you would know when you would know if they appealed to the county and then you would also know if

311the county GR the charter because chances are they would want to be well they would you know that they want to be located in your district and so you might be responsible for providing them with facilities as well and so now on the process of a dependent Charter would that be something that would come internally or how would that process of someone will to come in to create a dependent it would come I mean it would be the same same yeah it's the same process to start a charge School whether it's dependent or independent they they have addition we'll get into how that works um but it's the same process and just three on the same page Mark the first bullet in green CMI is a dependent shter school right and it is indirectly locally

312fun it is yes it's F yeah it's funded for the district and the district right disperses keeps the funds in a separate fund yes it follows um they're they fund they're funded on an lcf funding model just like the school district so um as Marley said the funding follows you know the students so they go through the same lcff um calculations process that kind of thing the dollars tied to that flow um through the county office to the school district and are kept in a separate fund um they're um just like I don't get too detailed State and property tax work they they get those same elements but but up to what they're funding is we do a property tax transfer to them and then saying made up of the differ so it all flows

313through the district but then has counted for separately it's important that it stays separate is we'll get into that a bit later too question on CMI so are we losing students from our district or it still tied you know what I mean so theoretically yes um and and this is um this is the part I think people maybe don't want to talk about but but we have to be transparent we have to understand right so CMI can be and is a great school and it's a great option that's what Charter Schools you know are there for that's why we have Charter Schools but we there 1,29 students or whatever it is you know today that that they have some percentage of those come from outside of the district but a large majority of those students

314come from inside of the district so CMI were not to exist those students most likely would be in our district which means we would get the funding um on a per student basis for those students similarly because it's been talked about here and before um so I would be remiss not not to mention um I think almost every presenter has said what a great school it makes sense that we want to increase enrollment there and provide things for them of course that's human nature but we have to recognize the other side of that let's say we were to because they'll be soon um going for a charter renewal prop petition we're do process Marley's helping the charter with that um as said their Charter you know is very small um and it needes to me

315more more robust um and and cover all the new legal elopements but let's just say they petitioned for and the Paris acting as the Paris Union High School District Board of Trustees only you approved that position and instead of 1,50 they were at, 1500 maximum enroll so an increase of 450 students we have to think where will those 450 students come from and so the declining enrollment that we are experiencing currently that I've talked about that Lata talked about that will exasperate that problem and so I'm not saying it's the right thing to do I'm not saying it's the wrong thing to do I'm just giving you a fact so there's no and I've heard this from somebody else so and I've only been here a month I know get the learning curve it's okay

316right so there's no percentage that comes like when a charter school comes in they get the the district would get a small percentage because it's in the district oh and then they would you know like a 10% and then they get to 90% is there anything like that I I think what you're you want me to take this yeah sure I'm not exactly sure you're asking I think what you're talking about is the so so something happens with all Charter Schools dependent independent uh there's oversight responsibilities we heard Lan talk about that Ed code provides for the the school district or the chartering Authority which can be a County Office of Education it could be the state um receive a percentage of their revenue uh between 1 and 3% there's criteria there uh for providing

317that that oversight it's 3% which is the case in our district if you provide the charter school I think the education COA said substantially rent fre facilities that's right and so that is the case with cm I think I heard you say 10% because you probably heard me say that before and you're right I'm just I was just throwing out there no you're you're I think I was thinking oh let me remember you I talk about this so um as a dependent they can be a dependent uh Charter School um but because well because let me rephrase that because they're a dependent Charter School um how's their payroll being handled how's their accounts payable being handled how's their Human Resources their curriculum I could continue on they're not managing that themselves the Paris Union High

318School District staff is doing that and as much as we might like to we can't do that out of the kindness of our heart because when we do that it would be similar to if let's say Paris Elementary School District said to us hey you do a really good job at you know payroll and all of these things you do all of those things for us we would have to charge them something and so the established way that we said we would handle that is that they pay a 7% of their expenditures um payroll expenditure Supply expenditure Services electricity you know all of those things um obviously there's costs that are directly associated with them that they're responsible for so that I think that's maybe where thinking 100% so I have I'll stop after just

319one more point I have heard people say hey wouldn't it be advantageous to the district if you increased the capacity of the charter school because then you would get 10% more and that's accurate but we have to think about 10% more for 400 50 students we could do that math and figure out what the the dollar amount would be but it's 10% versus the entire lcff dollar amount per Ada were sacrificing but I'm just dollars and cents I'm not programmatically or anything making a judgment and the other thing that I would like to be clear also the facilities that CMI are using they belong to P High School District so my understanding is we're kind of leasing those facilities to them and what would be the cost of the Le of the rent or how

320do that work for understanding from the well I mean I think currently there is no if I'm if I'm correct there's no these no facilities use agreement in place but that's something that I would recommend that you do put one in place um and then you maybe when you consider there's different ways to goow about charging them there's you know if they apply for facilities through 39 which is something I'm going to get to in a little bit then there's a prog a share that can be charged to them or you could enter into something that's called an inl or an alternative agreement you could see you know if they would if they took over the whole facility which I think they have you could charge them perhaps you know a fair market rent it

321just would depend what you negotiate with them but but there should be an agreement started discussing it and Miss Fox just just just to be very clear you know I guess it's interesting because this came up during the superintendent search members of the board asking questions this is a very very very novel area because even the way that the charter was designed you could have gotten more money at the onset as more than the 7% so I think the question that some of the board members had had and asking me in years fat or a year Circle who wants the charter if it doesn't make sense to the system then why do it so that's big question that yeah right question I'm sorry Mr Hall you were going to say something oh no that was

322kind of like where I was uh you know if it if it doesn't make sense why why do we have it and I know it's you know good for the students because that's where they want to go or whatever um but can't we adopt those programs that they have in our Public Schools you know stuff like that that's that's an excellent question and there there are ways we can do that um but without into all of the legal elements of merley can expand on of course if if you would like that but in car and High School District we're authorized essentially to operate grade 7 through 12 as a high school district CMI is currently 5 through 12 so immediately on the out let's say we were to transition that school to a district school

323we would no longer be able to have those fifth and sixth graders just on the outset and other implications you know we yeah legally it it raised a question for me because I was at an event two weeks ago or so and it was a guy from Hillsdale promoting you know Charter Schools or something like that coming in and I'm like me in my position now I'm like what well that's going to take you know funds and I get it what parents want but that's why I'm looking at proficiency scores cuz I can go here and have my kid learn you know and safe versus the school who has low proficiency scores and that's my whole being here is to get our proficiency scores up so we don't lose students and we bring in we

324you know I moved into uh Eda School District 20 years ago because of the school district and it was number one in the area so that's what I want people to look and go wow Parish miny school district is number one or in the top five and we're just not there so that's my whole process of thinking and wondering why charter schools and the I see the purpose of them and you know so I'm just asking questions sorry yeah that's a very good question right in terms of embeding the same program into a regular schools we already have the facilities in the regular schools having that and thinking about what we were talking with was here in the first presentation about getting Revenue all those buildings that there are for CMI that is something that

325belong to per high school and it can be used of company or something I'm not saying doing that right now right but pathetically speaking based on the presentation that is a big source of of a revenue there if we made those programs there yes it's definitely something to think about so let's talk about establishing a charter school in order to to start a charter school the potential Charter petitioner must submit a petition for the establishment of a charter and submit it in this case to a district office and they have to sign it with the certification that they believe the petition complete and then once it's submitted the district has officially received it for purposes of starting the timeline that applies so the District subing board must hold a public hearing on the provisions of

326the charter within 60 days of receiving petition so public hearing allows the board to consider support by the teachers um employees parents of the community for the school and then the the district must either approve or deny the charter within 90 days of receiving it but there is an option the parties can agree to an additional 30-day extension to give a little bit more time because a lot of times the charter petitions are very substantial as M Mr Ali mentioned earlier and it does take time to get through them thoroughly um the district governing board has to then after it's completed its review and and conducted the public hearing publish all staff recommendations on the charter including any recommended findings regarding petition at least 15 days before the meeting at which the board is going

327to Grant or deny the charter and then at the meeting where the board will grant or deny the charter the district has to make sure that it gives the charter school with equivalent time like if District staff is going to present on it on its findings the charter petitioner has to have equivalent time to do the same and equivalent procedures to do the same so if the district gave a PowerPoint presentation for example going through its recommendations that the charter petitioner would have to be given the same opportunity for the same number of minutes so a charter petition has to be signed by a number of parents or Guardians that's equal to at least half of the number of students the school estimates it will enroll for its first year of operation or a number

328of teachers that's equivalent to at least half the number of teachers that Charter School estimates it will employ during its first year so that's one of the things that's like the first thing you look for when somebody submits a Char petition do they have the requisite number of signatures because that's a reason right off the bat to deny the charter if they don't have that so additionally a charter petition has has to contain reasonably comprehensive descriptions of the 15 Elements which I'm going to talk about in a minute but reasonably comprehensive means that the descriptions in the petition have to be substantive and are not just a listing of topics with little elaboration so that's one of the issues with the CMI petition is it's it lists all of the requisite topics but it has

329a very little collaboration can I ask a question we're talking about this little bit and who prepares that petition is that petition is to us to per Union High School District right so who is the one preparing that the charter petitioner the person who's this entity that's submitting it the CMI right yeah CMI is the one and we are overseen from the Personnel Department from the the budget curricul instruction and and this so that's something that we are going to address with them right okay yeah because it was coming across and I don't know that was just my my feeling that it might have come across that it was us the ones that we were developing just three pages and it should be a lot of a lot of information that is missing there but

330that is going to be presented to us in this case to the district to to so our role is going to be to make sure that CMI do CMI does their job that they need to do comply with those 15 elements and then the district is going to review the petition make and we review it do that okay I just wanted to be very clear on that right if was okay we need to focus on that making sure that we 15 elements right but it's not thank you just a question to be who who submitted the petition way back the charter school if the charter school submitted a dependent model petition to the district well do you mean way back when like in 2003 yes I I was not here then so I I would

331have that's that's how it should work so I'm assuming Ral petitions work I don't believe it work that way so so the district someone in the district wanted the school and it came to be I'm I'm very confident the CMI based upon the research the CMI Folks at the time did not was a district sponsor Charter right I wasn't here then but I know that there's people with long memories who tell me about how that came about and there was a person named Major gther and he was part of the jrtc program at Paris High School and that and that and that the impetus of that was uh him and his pushing for it and then they used like a storefront in the beginning so just so part of the history was it was a

332a teacher who was who who launched that yeah right but so now you say same thing but so now in that kind of situation obviously they might have thought that there was a need to create something because I know um when was mentioning so when I was working in Haw School District we were Ka and we actually sent our kids to sentinella Valley which they were in they were in a mess back in the mid 90s um and then the neighboring districts you had Englewood which again another kind of situation so what Hawthorne did is they created because we didn't have our own high schools so they created a charter high school and uh you know it it served the community or a certain Community because you can it wasn't very big but it's still

333uh functioning now and doing well but what that was doing it actually I think improved in Hawthorne because what it did is the people who didn't want to send their kids to Lennox or to a Lennox school or to a uh Englewood School you know it could have been morning Engle high school or sen Valley Hawthorne or it could have been uh losinger at the time and I believe lale was it was gone and then so there was a lot of things going on but that was a good thing for them at that time in the community because there was a lot of parents who you know and it was application so it was you know something where kids had to but those kids in those other community surrounding communities they were forgoing having to

334go to their those high schools where they deemed that they weren't safe in academic Al sound and then that provided like a safe environment and not only that but an academic environment because it was one that was concentrating on math and science at the time um and so I know that and so there must have been a reason why that was created or a need and that fulfilled the need and who knows where it started at you know it might have started at you know 50 kids you know 100 kids and then if it grew it must have been because there was something there maybe there was a different set of structure that was working for that community or maybe it was keeping I mean I know they're they're outside of Paris but if they

335were I mean I don't I just don't know I guess we're as as we look into things we just need to make sure that when when the charter is structured um that you know it it's benefiting all obviously Paris un because we don't want but if it's attracting um people from outside districts you know what I mean that's not necessarily a bad thing you know I mean but obviously in the rewriting I think it'll be interesting the way that we kind of it unravels and unfolds and then we move forward and I think we need to research to really find out in know to understand to really understand that just following up about major Gator Mr Williams was saying I was in AP up iny and I remember him in CMI and actually he was

336on a building next to the City Hall it was not there when it's right now it was really small and that's how we started but we are going to be looking into that and just adding a little bit of what you said attracting students from minor districts I asked Dr datson about the data it is about 25% of the students from CMI from the 1,29 students currently about 257 around that number are from outside of the district so it's about 35% just just picking up with a little bit more explanation of what reasonably comprehensive means for purposes of all the elements of the charter petition it also means for elements that have multiple aspects to address all of the elements not just seleced aspects it has to be specific this is not in the outline

337sorry I but it's specific to the Charter petition to issue and not just to Charter Schools or Charter petitions generally and it describes as applicable among the different elements how the charter school will improve pupil learning increase learning opportunities for its pupils particularly those who have identified as have been identified as academically low achieving provide parents guard Guardians and pupils with expanded educational opportunities hold itself accountable for measurable performance-based people outcomes and provide vigorous competition with other public school options available to parents Guardians and students so all of those things need to be included all all those elements need to be included in each of the 15 elements that we're going to talk about now in order to make it reasonably comprehensive so the first element that needs to be addressed is the school's educational

338program and its annual goals and if the school serves high school students a description of how the school will inform parents about the transferability of courses to other public high school and the eligibility of courses to meet college entrance requirements so this educational program I didn't identify all of the different subcategories that go under that but there's a lot that goes into it so the charter school a charter petitioner should provide a bunch of detail about its educational program um so next is the measurable people outcomes identified for use by the school the method by which people progress in meeting those outcomes is to be measured the governance structure of the school including the process to ensure that parents are involved the qualifications to be met by individuals employed by the school procedures to ensure

339health and safety of students and staff and including a student safety plan that has to be updated in March of every year the means by which the school will acheve balance of racial and ethnic pupils and there was a change in the law that now it used to just require balance of racial and ethnic pupils but it changed and now requires balance also special education English learner pupils including redesignated fluent English proficient pupils that's reflective of the general population residing in the district admission requirements if applicable the manner in which the financial audits will be conducted and the manner in which a exceptions and deficiencies will be resolved procedures by which students may be suspended or expelled Provisions for employee coverage under St Pur or federal Social [Music] Security um Public School alternatives for students

340residing within the school district to choose not to attend Charter Schools description of the rights of any employee of the school district upon leaving the employment of the school district to work in a charter school and have any rights of return to the school district after employment at a charter school the procedures to be followed by the charter school and the authorizing entity to resolve disputes relating to the provisions of the charter and the procedures to be used if the charter school closes and that has to also include a final audit to determine what happens to all the assets and liabilities of the Char school and plans for maintenance and transfer of the Student Records now I may ask a question this is really important and interesting these elements right and we are going to

341be analyzing them when we receive the petition from CMI now if that is not happening it has been little bit how can we support them because at least they need to know that they need to comply with this what would be the next step that the action from us in order to make this right because at the beginning when former president Garcia president was telling me right I wanted to know what is what I need to do as a superintendent to ensure that the 16 elements are in compliance but at the same time I said this doesn't make sense because we are the receiving entity so how do I need to ensure that the 16 elements are going to be presented to me right so I want to be the in the elements that I

342want to present to myself it didn't make sense so now right it's very clear that the shatter School needs to do that and if they have not doing it well they're students they part of the community how can we support them so they can present that to us well the elements are laid out in pretty clear detail in the Ed code in Ed code section 47605 and there's also a regulation California code of regulations Title 5 Section 119 69.7 5.1 which really they really spell out what's to be included in there so I mean I have also gone through cmi's petition and I've made notes and I was going to be providing them to the district okay so the next practical step something that we need to do is that uh me through M Reigns

343or Mr Williams provide that or you meeting with them we ask cordinating that what do you suggest and this question would be for you m Reigns and even in this in this case well I think my my intention was to get my notes in better order and to provide them to miss rain okay yeah and um if I recall i' have to check my notes though I'm pretty confident in Remembering this correctly we had an initial meeting January 6th or 7th one of those first two days back from the break cabinet with Miss Fox and with Dr doson to review all of this much more and um and of the takeaways from that is and Dr doson asked for this is for him to be able to work with Marley uh to better understand that

344I do get your point that you know how do we formalize you know that that happen so maybe after I get those notes and we can um review them and then I'll review it with all of you at cabinet and that sort of thing maybe would you recommend maybe just like a formal letter or or simple you know letter summarizing what we've talked about and you know we do that okay so now just so I'm understanding so because it came up on on on the petitioner right who's so who is the petitioner is it um because it's a part of the the Army Branch um in our armed forces are they the the petitioner and then um how often do they have to be up for Renewal because I so obviously if it's if we're

345at a very thin document and then you know most of them so are they 10year Charters you know know where you have to look at and and review or I guess I'm just a little confused as to now because if they don't you know if we're the ones overseeing all the board stuff um so who is the petitioner that's you know who is California Military Institute is that the branch of the government that's doing that on the Army side or you know what I mean I'm just a little now because now they men like well who's the petitioner like that's a good question says California Military Institute so I mean I guess it is it's so um totally get the confusion um and it wasn't this way well I don't know how it was in

346the very beginning I wasn't here I came in 2006 in a different position um the petitioner is California Military Institute that's what listed on the documents we're talking about as a bin document where the army or you're mentioning comes in is at some point since I have been here so I do know about this they entered into they and the Paris Union High School District collect employ and as separate entities entered into a Cooperative agreement with the California Military Institute um which was part of then Governor Jerry Brown's yeah yeah I'm sorry I just got excited you're right you're 100% right I know that's I lost my TR so so there there now exists this Cooperative agreement it was funded um through and continues to be funded um for the California Military Department to provide

347Personnel assistance um as well as dollars and reimbursable um basically so more revenue and more resources um to the school as you might imagine having people who don't work for us being on campus every single day at one of our schools we have to have a solid agreement you know in place um you know red flags go up from HR people business people with liability and so we worked um extensively when they wanted to come in with then legal council to make sure we have a solid agreement now that we use ohh one of the things I did ask Marley and I know she hasn't had a chance to get to it yet we've given her a whole bunch of things to look at is could you please while you're because this is Paris Union

348High School District is party too as well so on behalf of Paris Union can you look at this with your eyes and make sure we're still you know good there as well as the mou the thank you for asking that question and I want to be very honest like always even as a world member was not clear to me how how was the situation came CMI we contined to talk about CMI but it's part of us then more members are part of them and then we talk about the California military program that that exists can we develop to understand this once and for all miss m reign in infographic where we have this Paris Union in CMI California Military Institute in parenthesis who who are really they who is really CMI because he says CMI

349made an agreement with peris jion high school district that means that it's another entity what is the address of CMI and and who is the person that represents CMI that may the agreement with us you know so to have that very I really would like to understand it through through an infographic if if that is possible can we work on that I'm here to do anything you or want me to do super top priority that we needed for Monday right maybe for Tuesday well called me last night at 8:00 with a whole list of things too Mr superintendent perhaps we could if the if the president is so inclining and M of the board maybe this could be a part two cuz now I think we're like we at a fork in the road where

350there needs to be some in-depth research and it doesn't make any sense to go forward until we can at least the superintendent the deputy and Marley Miss Fox can work collaboratively to bring the board back a recommendation right because at some at some point this will come on the agenda and we probably need everybody here yeah yeah right all the full compliment just a suggestion kind of land the plan to come back and I do want to answer your question about the term you asked it was 10 year term this so This Charter was granted or I guess last renewed for a 5year term but due to the co pandemic there were some changes in the law that allowed for additional extensions there was a two-year extension that was automatic for Charters I have this

351somewhere in the presentation I can't remember the exact dates but basically this Charter was entitled to a two-year extension and then one more onee extension so a total of three years so there are a bunch of Charter schools now that haven't been renewed for eight years but t a typical term for a charter is 5 years although now there's a provision for a high charter schools are are I was going to get into this a bit later too but charter schools are classified by CDE as either High performing middle performing or low performing and a high performing charter school can be renewed for anywhere between 5 to seven years but a middle performing char for 5 years and then a low performing charter school is presumed non-renewed but if it's taking steps in the right

352direction it can be renewed from more than two years so we can we can go through that slide when we get there but so back to what goes in a charter petition in addition to those 15 elements the petition also has to have information regarding the proposed operation potential effects of the charter school in including detail about where the school intends to locate uh a budget that includes startup costs and cash flow and financial projections for the first three years of the operation potential civil liability effects of any upon the charter school and the school district and also the manner in which administrative services will be provided oh my goodness I made this so small so the authorizing agency must approve the charter unless it makes written factual findings supporting one or more of the

353following conclusions first that the charter presents an unsound educational program petitioners are demonstrably unlikely to successfully Implement their program the petition does not satisfy the parent or teacher signature requirement the petition does not contain the requisite affirmations um that's one other thing that ter petition has to have there's a whole list of affirmations that has to go usually it's in the beginning of the petition basically that's saying the school's going to be non sectarian it's not going to charge tuition that's not going to discriminate and a whole bunch of other stuff um okay so another another basis um to deny is if it doesn't contain reasonably comprehensive descriptions of the 15 elements you talked about uh if the petition does not include a declaration of whether or not the charter school will be the exclusive

354public employer of the employees of the charter school that the charter school is demonstrably unlikely to serve the interests of the entire Community where it seeks to locate and or the school district is not positioned to absorb the fiscal impact of the proposed Charter School those two last the number seven and eight there they're not actually numbered that demonstratively unlikely to Ser the interest of the entire community and not position to absorb the fiscal impact are newer additions to this list and there's more more detail is provided within the EG code and also in the regulation that I mentioned before but I just would have gone really crazy to include all the detail here so thank it would have been even smaller and more difficult to read okay so if if approved a charter is

355to be granted for an initial term of not more than 5 years if a school district denies a charter petition the petitioner has the option of appealing to the County Board and then if the County Board denies the charter the petitioner can appeal to the State Board of Education and then as we talked about earlier if the state decides to Grant the charter it's going to designate either the school district or the County Board to serve as the authorizer they have gotten out of the authorizing business so next Once if if assuming that the district approves a charter it's now disable for conducting oversight of the charter school so this means that the district is responsible for making sure that the charter school operates in compliance with applicable laws and the terms of the charter

356and that's another reason why the charter terms should be laid out pretty clearly because it's hard to conduct oversight if the charter is very Bare Bones and you don't really know what the educational program is supposed to have or what the student outcomes are supposed to be so the Ed code provides I code section 47604 32 provides the the minimum that a district must do as far as oversight has to identify at least one staff member as a contact person for the charter school has to visit the charter school at least annually to ensure that the charter school complies with all the reports that are required charter schools by law to monitor the fiscal condition of the charter school and to provide timely notification to CDE if the charters were voked or if the charter

357school decides to close for any other reason so there are some annual reports that are required and it's the district's responsibility to make sure the charter school is actually doing preparing them as it should um before to honor before July 1st every year Budget on before July 1st the charge LED do own elap or annual update um on before December 15th and interim financial report honored before March 15th the second interim financial report and honored before September 15th and final un audited report for the whole prior year in addition to those specific oversight duties the charter authorizers uh also provide charge of General guidance on issues of funding and compliance so a charter authorizer should also routinely or periodically inspect the credentials of the teachers to make sure that now that all the teachers are

358required to have the proper credentials that they in fact do um and as the district has with CMI that the charter authorizer can establish a memor of understanding regarding format frequency and scope of oversight activities and will supplement the terms of the charter and provides additional detail so as we just discussed a little while ago Charter uh May School may also choose to contract with his authorizer to provide administrative Insurance maintenance payroll or other services and the district can charge th charge the charter school for those Services as we also discuss that's separate and apart from the oversight fee that we also talked about Mar just for my full understanding of that if we can go back to okay it says that chatter school they can make the decision to select somebody else to do

359the M maintenance payroll and all the maintenance of their buildings that is assuming that the chatter owns the building uh no no no even I mean you can the districts because I'm not seeing anything about us providing about you providing the building yeah it's well so that's not in here but but so it just you know that would be details like that would be in a in a facility use agreement it doesn't exist so um yeah thank you um but so I I do recommend that we get one of those in place um and so okay Charter authorizer should also be in regular communication with the charter school that it authorizes and just because it's a dependent charter school doesn't mean that the district can not comply with its oversight responsibilities still has to do

360that and so it's an interesting thing that the Ed code states that the legislature intends the charge schools shall operate independently from the existing you know District structure but it does allow for dependent charter schools so where it's possible to maintain some separation you need to do so and this is something we talked about earlier with maintaining independent fiscal operations having a separate fund already talked about this and so if you co- funds it's difficult to track the Charter School's goals and actions so as we also talked about the charter authorizer is entitled to charge for the actual cost of oversight and it's not to exceed 1% of the revenue of the charter school unless the charter authorizer provides the charter school with substantially rentree facilities which is the case here in which case you

361can charge for up to 3% of the revenue of the charter school so technically renting the facility is 2% right this R if if if we look at the first two bullets M so technically we can say it's 1% for the supervisor oversight 2% for the for the facilities I know a followup questiony is on you know this separation of substantially rent free facilities and a charge for the lease we well so you if you charge yeah you basically if you if you charge for use of the facility you can't get you have to go back to 1% to 1% yeah but we can see how much we can we can Char this see discussion be interesting right exactly interesting figure that out do an analysis and see what makes sense why don't you explain

362to them alternative agreement to we will I I got you because because there there you can generate you do an alternative agreement you're essentially we she'll get you that point but you can generate some Revenue right yeah I just have that L later but no it's okay no problem we can actually we could talk about it now if you want um okay so okay and I just have the revenue of the charter school for purposes of calculating oversight is the amount that's received in the current fiscal year from the local control funding formula based grant supplemental Grant and concentration Grant uh the charter authorizer should also document its oversight actions and key records okay so this this is um if if a charter petitioner wants to once it's been once the charter petition has been

363approved it may want want to or need to change something in the charter or the district may need it to change something in the charter and so if it's something that's considered material the the charter school will have to go through a material revision process and a lot of things can be considered material I've listed three things here if if the charge School wants to out or remove level to relocate to a different site change it Sala just would depend what what wanted needed to be changed and so then we have to decide whether it was material or not but those are some things that are considered material for sure and so if a Char school is considering making material revision it should submit a request and writing to the authorizer and also a revised

364vision of the charter petition that's redlined so the district can see what the changes are that are being made and then they also so material revision is also governed by those the standards and criteria that we went through earlier for a new establishment of a new Charter petition so a materially revised Charter would have to include all of that same stuff but it would also have to include um again reasonably comprehensive descriptions of any new legal requirement of charter schools that was enacted in law into law after the charter was originally granted or last renewed and so then the governing board of the authorizer would either would review everything and either Grant or deny the material revision okay so Charter renewals um as we said earlier Charters granted for a specific term it's usually five

365years and it has to be renewed prior to the expiration of the existing term so there's no Gap [Music] um so we also talked about earlier so all that everything was extended basically by 3 years and the reason for that was because there wasn't enough data to properly assess charter school performance because of the co pandemics um so what and basically again Charter renewals are governed by the same standards and criteria that we went through before and the same timeline applies they submit the petition they sign it to say they've certified that they you know the best of their knowledge it's complete and then the district has 60 days to conduct a public hearing and then a total of 90 days to make a determination on whether to plant or Deni renewal with again the

366option to extend that by 30 days for a total of days um but unlike a petition for the establishment of a charter school renewal cannot be denied based on economic impact on the school district or failure to serve the interest of the entire Community those were the two bullet points that I mentioned were new kind of new additions new reasons to deny the petition for the establishment of the charter school you can deny a material Vision to expand grade levels or add a School site for those reasons but you can't deny a renewal petition for those reasons got it um so also this is something uh that is a new addition here as an additional Criterion for determining whether to Grant a charter renewal the chartering authori is required to consider the Charter School's performance

367on State and local indicators so CD we talked just briefly about this before has California school dashboard places charter schools in one of three categories High performing middle performing and low performing and there's a separate analysis that goes along with each of these um so basically a high performing charter school is entitled to a streamline renewal process and the presumption is that it's going to be renewed um so they only need to update the petitions for to add any new legal requirements or as necessary to reflect current programs and this is the one that can be renewed for five six or seven years and you cannot deny a renewal of a high performing charter school for academic reasons but you can deny it if you find that the school has fiscal or governance problems and

368it's not serving all the students who wish to attend Marley quick question on that um to determine the the high medium low uh is that something that's labeled on the dashboard um so so when you open it up it it's it's labeled I I don't know it's not actually on like the dashboard dashboard but there's a way I mean yeah it's on CD's website there's a way to find it it's not don't think it's directly on the part that has like the colors and stuff it's somewhere else but it is on there it's pretty clear okay you can hun for a charter school so I know CMI is a middle performing Charter School um so low performing charter schools are schools that have low AC performance they are presumed to be denied and they can

369only be renewed if the authorizer makes a written factual findings that are specific to the particular provision sorry petition that the charge SCH is taking meaningful steps to address the underlying cause or causes of low performance and those Steps either are reflected or will be reflected in a written plan that's adopted by the CH school's governing body and verified data shows that have one year of progress for each year of school or strong secondary out um and if renewed it can only be renewed for two years no more than that and so then the charter authorizer also has to consider and making a determination of whether to grant that additional two years or not what's in the best interest um of the students so middle performing charter schools are those that don't meet the high

370performing or the low performing criteria and this is actually like most Charter Schools land in this category yeah um so the authorizer has to consider schoolwide performance and performance all the subgroups on the dashboard so that's when you look at all the different dashboard um criteria and you might You' got to provide greater weight to Performance of the measurements of academic performance and the the district would also need to look at using well verified data which we'll talk about that in a minute um whether the charter SCH achiev to meas measurable increases in academic achievement as def at least one year's progress for each year in school or strong postsecondary outcomes as defined by college enrollment persistance and completion rates equal to similar peers so for Middle performing Charter the renewal term is 5 years

371um but you can deny a renewal if the authorizer makes a written finding that the schools fail to make sufficient progress towards meeting standards that provide a benefit to its students that closure is in the students best interest interest and that the authorizer decision provided greater weight to academic performance and again there's there's more detail about all of those different categories in the end code as well but part to list everything here um so for for now charger schools that fall in the middle and low performing categories have to provide what's called verified data for the authorizer consideration in connection with the chart of renewal and it's assessment data from nationally recognized valid peer reviewed and reliable sources that are external produced and this the State Board of Education has a whole list of the

372verified data that's you know it's on it website um what they all are but and the thing is these are being phased out though so beginning July 1st low performing Char schals are no longer required to provide verified data beginning January 1st 2026 middle performing charter schools are not required to provide that either okay so despite all the stuff that we just talked about and performance categories the charter authorizer can deny renewal of the charter uh if it makes a finding that the school is demonstrably unlikely to successfully implement the program set forth in the petion due to substantial fiscal or governance or is not serving all the peoples who wish to attend but in order to do that it has to provide at least 30 days notice of whatever the alleged violation is to

373the charter school and also give them a reasonable opportunity to cure it and provide a correct plan so then the the charter authorizer would either then make a finding that the corrective action that the charers will proposed was not successful or the violations were sufficiently Sever and pervasive to make a corrective action plan unviable so again if the district were to deny a renewal petition the charter could appeal to the county and then to the states the state same with the initial petition to establish a charter school um okay so facilities there are different ways that a t school can acquire facilities uh from the school district which which in which it wishes to locate um there is for one thing something called Proposition 39 Ed code section 47614 it requires a school to submit

374a written facilities request to the to the school district onor before November 1st of the fiscal year preceding the year for which they desire facilities and then there's a whole timeline that applies there by December first the district would look at the projected Ada that the charter school projected I'm sorry IND District Ada that the charter school provides in its facilities request and determine whether it's a reasonable projection and if they project there's there's a minimum of 80 IND District students that have to be has to be reasonable um but if the charter school doesn't come up with a reasonable projection of at least 80 80 in District students then the District can deny the facilities request but if they have at least 80 the district is required to share facilities fair with the charter

375school so sharing fairly means that the school district will be required to provide the charter school facilities that are sufficient to accommodate all of the charter schools in district students in conditions that are reasonably equivalent to those in which the students would be accommodated if they were attending other public schools in the district District the school district is not required to provide facilities for students that do not reside in the district although it may choose to do so um and if it does choose to do so it can enter into what is called an alternative or an inl agreement where it could decide to charge so so when it when a school district provides facilities percentage of Proposition 39 it's only allowed to charge a charter school that's called a pro a share and it's

376a calculation that the district makes each year um and it's based on the ratio of space allocated by the district and the charter school divided by the total space of the district and there's only certain things that can be included in there it's not like a regular rent payment the district is not supposed to be making a ton of money off of it however if a school district is providing facilities to a charer school that has a lot of outer District students they might want to enter into an in or alternative agreement where you can charge fair market rent for you know the percentage of the facility that is for the out of District kids or you might in some instances Mr is familiar with this you may get the Chargers schol to agree that

377they're just going to if they rent the entire facility you can just charge them a certain rate for the entire facility that's just a negotiation and that would be outside of prop 39 that that would be would be pursued to an agreement but pursuant to Proposition 39 the law provides that you the district is not permitted to otherwise charge the charter school for use of the facilities other than the pram share that it charges so if a school district provides a charter school with Proposition 39 space based on the projection that they've provided in their facilities request and it turns out that the charge school has a lower Ada than what it projected then the school district and I'm sorry the charter school is required to reimburse the the uh school district for the overallocated

378space and every year there's a rate that the stateboard of Education sets so it's a formula and it's not it's not just if there's one student you know if the projection is off by one students it has to be it's either 25 students or 10% whichever is um so we just talked about in agreements in prop 39 Agreements are not District compliance with prop 39 but the regulations allow for that okay that's it so one thing that I did not put in here just briefly is that the district has the ability to revoke a charter once it's granted and there are certain grounds that on which it can do so one if it committed the charter school committed a material VI violation of any of the conditions standards or procedures that are set forth in

379the charter again another reason why it's important to have specifics in the charter petition uh two failed to meet or pursue any of the people outcomes that are identified in the charter that's all stuff that needs to be in the charter in order to use that as a basis for revocation failed to meet generally accepted accounting principles or engaged in fiscal M mismanagement or four violated any Law And so there's a there's a big process that you have to go through if you're going to revoke a charter you have to give them notice of any violation you probably would start by sending what's called a notice of concern give them an opportunity to remedy it then if they don't you send a notice of violation and you kind of put some back and forth and

380to allow them time to fix things but ultimately if they don't do what they're supposed to do they you to have you know can't get it together then you can roke their Charter and and is that kind of in reference to I know uh Miss Kirk Carter mentioned a couple things but it was the outside agencies that were but obviously you could move towards the replication of their their Charter because they're not fulfilling their obligation and yet they're taking your students and the the funding um uh you can only I mean you can only move you can only move to revoke a charter that you off okay got it yeah yeah now a quick question and I know um obviously in the process of now uh redoing the charter I've noticed that every time and

381it kind of bothers me at times but um when I see that the best high schools that are you know posted um they're always Charter Schools they're always um you know a science school here Science school there and the reason why it bothered me because it it's almost unfair in the sense that they get a PLU kids who are the maybe the best and the brightest of certain communities and then Target whatever that Charter is science you know whatever it is innovation whatever but so I'm wondering um to in the rewriting of all this if it were to happen I I'm just hypothetical you know is it possible so if it was you know the California instit California Military Institute of science and technology or science and Innovation um is that something that can happen

382or to change the name of the school you or or even kind of the the emphasis or where where it's I just I don't know and I don't know if that would be something that that would be I'm just giving a hypothetical or you know down the road if there's a um a charter within the school district that's you know a science and the only reason why I'm asking is because it seems like a lot of school districts or charter schools are doing that and they're drawing the the students because of their emphasis on the math or the Sciences or or innovation you know and you know we're we're in an area where there's we have you know Air Force and all kinds of different things that are out there and so whether you can

383and and I just don't know if if you can do that at full comprehensives because it seems like at comprehensives you can't do that and you know bring in targeted students whereas Charter Schools somehow are able to do that and draw in but they're pulling them from other districts you know what I mean so I don't know if that if that question is in my mind just kind of a little well first of all CMI I mean it could change its name or its folus that would all be part of a material revision of its Charter and so I mean if it decided to do that it would have to submit at the time it was well even beforehand it would but if it was going to do it at the time of its renewal

384petition it would have to submit a separate material revision of its Charter which just I mean it's revising its Charter just would be a different a separate agenda item for the district to consider doing that um but a charter school you're asking me if a charter school can have a focus like that is that yeah yeah they can yeah sure so let me ref rephrase the question because uh I was thinking something similar can we redesign CMI with the same Focus right CMI California milary Institute with some Focus let's say Aerospace or something like that and eded into our district so instead of being shatter is part of our if is part of our school it's part of our district it it help us overall well so CMI would need to close as a charter

385school first and then it would need to yeah and that's a whole probably a separate discussion okay all right it would have to go through the closure procedures and it's fortition but nevertheless it could like he said um if if it was to add something you know like you said the be flight or whatever the I guess what did you call that yeah some directed or with an emphasis of one branches yeah yeah and I guess that's just it emphasizing adding an emphasis to it with another emphasis out there yeah that would just we they would require material that's you know those happen yeah it is an excellent program Ser is right now we have excellent performance and all that so we just looking into balancing the situation CM un High School District based on

386the challenges that we are facing okay so that's it for me don't you guys have any other questions I have a question um do Charter Schools uh Target certain areas to to try to plant a school oh yes I mean and and why is it because of proficiency scores is it I don't know wide range I'm sure it's for mul of reasons yes I'm sure we do okay and I have a summary of next steps of actions that I need to make sure that I coordinate with this brains and I just want to take the Liberty to read read them real quick so you can tell me no it's not like that h CMI as an entity needs to know how to comply with the 16 16 elements it's 15 15 it used to it

387used to be 16 but now it's 15 15 okay perfect they cannot only address selected items to present to the approver that is this for the approval of the renewal and we are the approver per un High School District since they are selecting only few elements they have few pages we need to have all all the 15 elements and that is going to imply a lot more information that is going to be present okay so we are going to be focusing on providing support so we compli so just just to be clear their petition identifies I believe all of the 15 elements in there just doesn't go into nearly enough detail in a lot in some of the sections and some of them it might because some of the sections are are short in other

388Charter petitions as well but particularly the first three elements that the educational program and the measurable outcomes and that kind of thing those those definitely need to be be up because they have a lot of components in the Ed code or in the regulation that need to be addressed that are not fully addressed here those were the educal programs me yeah exactly the next one we are going to focus on developing Andra sorry just so much I'm not it's not to say that everything else is perfect way it's not but yeah just yeah those those are usually the largest sections in the in petitions and then also you know there are sometimes a lot of attachments to the exhibits to the Charter petition also that are not were not included here the attachments might vary

389depending on the particular school but I can I can try to provide some guidance there to you as well appreciate that even though we are telling them what they need to include to present it to us but Le for the benefit of our students with don't mind about doing that the number two is infographic to understand the fundamentals of CMI how we function who what is CMI and all that that is going to be ination Miss R but I'm a little bit confused is because I thought we want to explore the you about how we can do the rent of our facilities right ER but now later on I saw that the district is required to share facilities fairly with CMI based C so if we are required then can we negotiate the r or

390how well they didn't I I mean I don't know how the whole facilities Arrangement came about with them honestly but I'm just in agreement I couldn't find a document yeah so I don't know I mean if they apply pursuant to Proposition 39 and have at least 80 District students which I think they do that you're required to share facilities fairly with them pursuing to prop 39 but but you nothing says that you can't enter into some other sort of agreement outside of Po 39 they don't even have to submited facilities request you can negotiate something with them and have the facilities use agreement that goes through all the terms and that's the amount that they're going to pay so we need to know what is behind that in order for us to determine what would

391be the next steps and in order to do that we need to know who they are right when we talk they are entering an agreement with f Union so it must be a different entity too get it I right okay okay so those are the the three elements that I have there so we have some some work so who's the uh District representative and who does the oversight on so really every there there's different elements Marley had a slide several back so so there's the fiscal and I handle that and so that's making sure that they do all of their reporting because they have theou with us to do those things you know we do a lot of that um with them for them I mean yes they have a separate Bell cap that budgets

392within our budget that sort of thing um there's the credential monitoring I don't do that that's not my area of expertise that's Alfredo the oversight curriculum piece also you know not my area of expertise that falls with the curriculum and there's nothing that says you just just have to have you have to have at least one person who does it so you can have as we have documentation and detailing of everything that goes on over there and we do because it's it it's it's part of our general Practice in terms of them being dependent being in being disclosed and all that good stuff and that's from the business department in a we also need to really look in depth in terms of the HR perspective I know with regular staff but I know that there

393are some staff members that depend from the California I'm sorry c cforia military Department the military Department in those cases and they're interacting with our students how do we handle those situations potential complaints or any issues that we hear Cas yeah it's in the we just approved it in the last board meeting the updated memorandum with and it describes specifically how okay so now we are we are ready those okay I'm sorry I forget forgive me I forget who asked it if was one person um traditionally I've been sort of the the person that helps coordinate you know all of the pieces working with um legal council the last time this was Rewritten was you know was with two previous legal councils you know and so I don't mind continuing you know to to be

394that but I can't I can't do it all myself because it's different any other questions or TR anything trusty Hall I'm good and you know what I just want to say thank you I I knew that this is it was very important I knew it was going to be like we're drinking out of a fire hose but I I think the important part is that we had to start somewhere with a basic understanding and I I appreciate you know your patience being here all day and and the way you're explaining it at the very simplest level I mean obviously it's I I know for me there there's like a little anxiety but but at the same time I know we're in good hands so I know that this isn't something new to you uh well

395to you specifically and obviously or bakov and Henderson but so I'm I'm glad that we've partnered um and that you guys are able to to present everything and I'm very confident that you know we'll be able to work with staff you know once that Charter is ready to go and and that the community like you had mentioned is going to be served appropriately and properly you know with their student population community so thank you for that we we really do appreciate the the effort and everything that you've done for us thank you thank you so much hope everybody has a good rest of the weekend thank you too thank you anything else I just wanted to to add a and also I have a brief summary of uh the basic learnings that we have I

396already review related to Marley presentation from Latania ER the fundamental the G of the presentation that I captured was about the financial situation of the district that it was okay that it has been handled appropriately that's what I heard from her so thank you m Miss Reigns the focus the need to focus on 88 for the different reasons that she mentioned student achievement is one of them the other one is the reimbursement that we get from from from the state and potentially considering the mark marketing of District the wonderful programs that we have right and she she talked she was specific about the public information officer and I understand ER dur some crisis for example we have been trained on how to address of issues but I was uh at Heritage High School when we

397have the dismissal of students for power outage during lunch the princip that is supposed to be doing this right or assistant principles they were focused on the logistics on on the Practical elements of how handling the steps at that moment right and when you handle a crisis that what you you need to be focus on so I think that is important the recommendation that Latana made in terms of the public information officer from Serene I learned about a that she's going to be working on the list of all options that we have to get Revenue ER what what what what are the possibilities that we have right based on land that we might have or different properties that that we can have from maai and I think he left but he was talking about part

398two I that he he mentioned that setting the direction the role of the boarding general of set setting the direction for us giving us and telling us what is what you like to see in general right the big picture let's say and we take care of the daytoday a of operations that you are going to be monitoring and holding us accountable for the goals that you said right and we talk about that I ask you also about the support in order to focus on on the attendance ER perspective there are some still some pending things that I need part two is going to clarify in in terms of in terms of the roles we agreed also with the board about the decisions that the whole board is the one who makes the directions and you

399give them to to me and it can be 5 Z 41 or 32 right and that's how we are going to be doing this from from now on and I think that's all I I have from kind of a summary if I miss something that you I just would like to see you reach out to um the mayor of M Mr Estrada oh yes I I yes I him out here as well you know let let's let's combine that together that is an excellent we we are doing it that on a I believe it's a trimester what every four months with the council but I'm going to try to do that the same thing that I do with mayor Vargas do it with st on a monthly basis yeah yeah so and I want to

400probably your your help s fer to to look into that so I can have those those meetings because it's so so important like the situation that we have with a student who was missing we would have those contacts with a sh of police and all of that that would have been very very helpful and everything we can see comes back to support for our students in the but thank you Mr for reminding me about minut SCH Mr anything else that I miss here that you look like of on what you the information was presented that you would like me to address or Focus or bring back to you for a final decision to the cour I just I had there's a like a list I made it sounds like goals that we kind of need

401some obviously are going to be more important than others is there like a way we can get together without having to bring everybody out of their you know on Saturday or just to or or maybe we can add it in a close session just to prioritize go goals give us time frames and directions on how we want to get those goals done just in my mind I work through checklist so I just would like to see what goals do we have that we can all agree on and how are we prioritizing those goals so we can kind of all be on the same page because right here so much information was and obviously we can't attack everything at once but just so we can see that there is movement and like we don't you know

402just like keep the perfect video was perfect we want to see what consistency what the change and when we see the change being brought it kind of will give us more motivation to keep going and we want to know that what we're bringing is helpful or not helpful and how when do we address that because just we've only been in the two meetings but um you know a lot of things are talked about and um I just want to be able to mentally understand what's more important than the next and how we can work together to check check you know what and so and I and I think um I think you've already kind of started that like I think when you went to uh the the what would you call it was the the

403awards I think the more that we get together with the superintendent to go to things and to do things um like I've never been to those those student uh the the month student of the months but you did and then and then when you express that you know and you shared what you learned that is beneficial to me even without having to be there now obviously the goal is to try to do that but I think I think some kind of like the informality of having to do it all scheduled this way I think whenever we have those opportunities where we're meeting together um going to a a function some type of function whether it's a dinner and obviously there's not three of us but you know you're there with maybe another board member some

404staff you know whoever that may be I think having those conversations um it could be something about the vision you know or or whatever it is and you're having those conversations then you know he'll he'll be able to address hey you know what hey that was a good idea was brought up or maybe you want to agendize something you say Hey you had a conversation with the superintendent you know you went and now you want to agendize something to discuss you know if it's a vision thing or if it's you know a program or whatever then that I think is the way that we do it without having to come with the formalities because we know we're going to meet once a month and and you know at that time we can discuss about a

405lot of different things that go on and you know if you agendize it because maybe you want to expand something maybe you want to look into something more and say hey this was very beneficial for the community for the parents it was special it was this I think in doing that I think we'll kind of accomplish that without having to get it like in a flood you know what I mean because um you know conversations you know I've always told uh everybody here you know when I go to conferences uh a lot of it I get a lot of information a lot of the information already know a lot of it's new but I think one of the most important pieces for me is the networking because I I want I've I always want to

406figure out what can we do to bring it here to make it better you know and like I said and that happens in all kinds of different ways you know when when I gave blood one time I met that's when I met the the the law enforcement officer mene and he was talking to me about that program so I think when we do all that kind of stuff and then eventually I would like to put him on you know once we coordinate you know put him on the agenda to just speak to what he does and what he can bring to the district because his presentation in my opinion would benefit um you know our students with special needs population and how it can not only will it benefit them now but in the future

407because then when they become adults and they're outside of our our purview or our um obligation or responsibility for them but they might walk away with something like the bands that I had mentioned that will help them for the rest of their life that way if they're ever involved in a situation you know then law enforcement might know hey you know what I see that you know and I know that you know they may be having an episode or they you're anxious extremely and they know how to kind of go about it so I think all I mean I think it happens and kind of like you said in the video it happens slowly you know it seems like it's it's the minutia that is where it all happens because it's it's we're constantly discussing

408things learning new things sharing information and when we get those opportunities where we're at District events or functions um I think it helps you know because then it could bring us ideas and and maybe you know like I said he goes to an event talks to the superintendent hey let's put it on the agenda I want to discuss something well then we agendize it we discuss it uh how's that process you know you have a topic can I just who do who do we because we don't know or I don't know agenda we'll make sure that hey this is brought forward because my frustration is um you know at my work I'm there every day and I see the the development and coming here once a month like you know we talk about it it's

409like okay you know so I don't know how to maybe process it as a workload because I'm not doing it every day so can I you get updates every week that's we keep communication with you but to what Miss Amaya said the vision that would be part two of the board governance that M has set up and we set that up that they'll help you develop those goals develop those but when I was part of board we have every January we had we knew we were going to have two special board meetings in January right one to review our current goals do we are do do they still meet what we're doing do we have to change them do we have to give different direction for that year how are we doing there's a lot

410of things that go support governance um that once you start getting into that rhythm you're you're going to see that okay this is how it works um I believe I don't know this from my understand this probably the first time that there was the board governance uh Retreat like this right so a lot of information a lot of information is takeen but the more you do it the more you're going to know um vision and all that like Serene said that's an open session we have to have this open session meeting that's why I asked the question about town housee and he said well probably easier just to agendize it that way we know we're going to have a meeting there I would like to follow up on the question from Miss Anaya and if

411I understood correctly that would be my my proposal in order to set that direction for us of what you would like to see accomplish I was thinking we can make we can help you and support you right with our experience also as a former World members and you can tell me if you like it or you can say no we let's think about something else make a presentation on data all of the decisions and the directions in my mind is based on evidence right on data how we perform me right a make a presentation of this and we can make a proposal to you this is the high school graduation rate this is the number percent of students who are meeting A3 year requirements this is the number of students who are taking AP classes

412do an enrollment concurent enrollment and desegregated by data these are the goals that we are proposing to you you discuss it right you discuss that right something reasonable 2% 3% once you discuss that from you agree on that and then we would like you to focus on achieving this for next year that is our goal focusing on this right and that's just one idea to help you on that if you identify any other issue from that maybe you can say the whole board we are going to vote on three top priorities three top things that we would like to see during this semester that you need to focus on and you make the decision and you talk about it here in public the people is going to know it's going to be recorded what are

413your priorities what is you want for for our students once we show you H this number of students are on track to meet the C the ai ai the AI the general end requirements to go to a four-year College what Ma was talking about a is not a anymore it's called what Mr William said the requirements of a 2E degree yeah it's the minum re I get it yeah and and then you can say we wanted to focus on that oh you know what at this time the most important thing is high school graduation rates for these Subs because it's really low and that's what we want to work on on this one and this one because we can identify seven eight different things but are we going to be able to achieve all those

414so my recommendation would be would be go by parts right but you decide that and that would be the beauty that you can say this is a direction that com from the war comes from the superintendent and comes from everybody El that's my question how do we decide that because we have so much we can do without so much parties being involved and that so that's CU I'm I get I um you know I don't like to hear what Chuck has to say through Steve and like I just I would like for all of us to be on the same page give input um but without making it so you know have to make a grand meeting or whatever so I'm just curious on how we can and stay with exactly we can agendize the

415presentation in terms of student achievement for example you you wanted you mentioned St a that's my goal okay we can start addressing one of the goals from Mr Mr Hall is that part of your goals Miss Ana as soon as my goal I'm I'm thinking like well we need to stay a float so I'm thinking attendance like attendance so we all have we do an achievement attendance what would be one of your top priorities if we ask you to select one oh gosh see and and and it's it's like they're almost all intertwined see I I would like to bring in the Arts or more Arts yes INF using our facilities which are beautiful and that but I think they're all intertwined you know I mean I think that relates to that cuz that'll relate

416relate to kids showing up yeah that'll relate to them showing up well guess what now they're getting better test scores better test scores and I'm even thinking like social media why haven't we I I've been on the on the social media of the par it's very boring like as a person that uses social media it's not very attractive if we use more social media we can encourage Arts T scor so just everything is all is embedded there right so we can start with this first of all changing the mindset said that our meetings we had meetings once a month and the meetings by 8:30 8:00 they need to be done right probably we need to change some the mindset that it's going to be a little bit more right so we can address that there

417are other districts that they had two they me twice a month and they go until midnight I'm not saying that we want two minutes but but at least having the time to discuss that yeah right we all know we have what my my thought is we got to work twice as hard yes to be able to work less later on yes so we have a big hurdle to jump and you know we we need 100% from everybody so we can get this accomp to get our district on the map and say wow look at what they're doing why are they doing it and how are they doing it let's go find out that's what I want to see perfect so would you then from where I'm hearing that transferring to changing that mindset that by

4188:30 by 8:00 we need to be don't we need to address what we need to take right to address that and maybe some presentation is not going to be 15 minutes it's going to be 30 minutes 40 minutes because it was so important like the budget presentation last last time right that I consider and I allow that person to continue I didn't say anything even though I was uh he was just 15 minutes because I knew you needed to know that it is important so whatever time I'm not talking about what in the right that's something reasonable extra time right we have new world members you need to know that and even experience more members with this model where we are going to be focusing the student achievement that can be the first thing good

419you three agree that or we can go attendance because it cannot go a we cannot have a student achievement if students are not in school so we can say attendance so we can talk about attendance present the data come with some a what is going to be our laser focus F hopefully we have the new assistant soup we go through the process to go fulltime with that person right with a new assistant soup on that the next one can be St a shiping in the next the next meee and you tell us the direction you you tell us the goal and that is going to be very powerful yeah so that's what I'm like think you so we're we're all in L that attendance is important so that position is really important to be fill

420cuz I'm hearing you guys already have a lot on your plates so like that's what I'm talking about when goals like let's set a goal once that's checked off we can now focus on another goal and then once we have something you kind of clean off the plate what you can clean off real quick and get it done yeah the quick things and then can focus on the things that are going to take the consistency talk about the quickness one thing that I that I heard throughout meeting today was about parish and medic right um in other districts that I've been involved with is one of the things that we did to correct that and it doesn't have to be like a lot of meetings but have a board meeting many I don't know about

421the logistics how that would work out but if you can exactly you know that opens the door to the menic community to come out to a board meeting and and see how the word meaning what in man yeah I I it becomes over here and even the name changing that's something I we can do quick and that that would be nice because just like you know they want if they see their name on the title anyone likes to see their name they more something that's so quick and it's psychological and it's quick and easy and just stuff like the quick and easy stuff what can we quickly easy do and then we can get more into the stuff yeah I like to see check this person oh no yeah all right so so one of

422the things summarizing for because we need to get in action I think what you mentioned is really really important do we agree the first one next for the next word meeting is going to be what we have to and you decide you tell us one of things if I can mind is is in in board meetings and Jose and I have been around for a long time uh when when board members any other it by board members a board member might say something like you know I'm I'm really interested in more of the district's efforts in arts right and so the board would say yeah let do the presentation we'd also agree on the time because the staff's going to have to compile that material so part of the request would be exactly what you

423said is like the when we're going to bring it back uh so you know if it was like could you have a next board meeting and it was something really comprehensive we would say that's going to be difficult because that's going to take all of our time so the question about when is important yeah and and I have a question and I don't know I guess uh I haven't see done but like I guess on the appropriateness or if it would be something that would be um a request that's you know possible um is to bring in like I know for me I would like to hear from the teachers that are in those programs you know what I mean for them to you know let's say we were going to talk about so in

424February for the uh information item for the novels the teachers will be okay yeah exactly and I think that's that's helpful because you know well once we have the direction or we know this is what we're going to do then we obviously organize it and coordinate it that way because I know that you know it it's it's great to hear from staff and I don't and I don't know if how the chain of command is supposed to be you know are they supposed to direct or or speak with the directors and then the directors represent um I I know for me it it's like if you're hearing you know from the people who are doing it and they're telling you they're going to tell you what's important you know what I mean as opposed to

425they're going to try to be concise with their time and tell you hey this is what we could use we could use X Y and Z and and like I know Ken says we can't Grant everything can't do everything but at least we can hear and okay well we'll take that and we work with that to figure out how you know we hear all the different sites cuz every site might be different and what they so that is the direction that I've given to curriculum instruction Innovation on our presentations that we're bringing the people doing the work so in February I met we met with the c committee for novels and they they selected a few to to bring that information to you to let you know of the committee work and read so that

426is a direction that I too want to go rather than me and other quantification here we too want teachers to come and share that kind of stuff so we agree and also regarding that detective uh for the training for autism um Alfredo and I we met with him we had another meeting something else and he was there and we got exchange cards um and I I think uh John Hanah was going to have them work with the campus supervisors first so that they could recognize FYI on that oh thank you well and I know like his it was like there was that piece then there was the working with the parents and because there was so many things I mean we we we spoke for about an hour you know after we had given blood

427we just there was so many things that we had talked about that was so beneficial and it was just like wow like this would be great for our community um to do it you know what I mean and so yeah I mean I think that those are the things that you know I know for me you know knowing that you've had those conversations you know it lets me know hey you guys are listening and and you guys are using the time that you can to move that forward and and again at the end of the day down the road it's going to be a benefit to our students to the community so we are we looking so for the February we have there's three presentations one of them is a midyear elcap which probably be

428longer than 50 minutes yeah and then novels and then Community Schools uh the county will be here so that's that's a lot of presentations that we looking for March I mean we compile and we can put stuff in the update as we go or are you looking for I I just was want to add something before making that decision ER Makai mentioned something that I'm completely agree with him about holding us accountable but give us the direction and when you give us the direction and the resources you hold us accountable let's start with that Mr Williams can we say you are because I don't want to miss anything that the board is is recommending right and it seems that they they agree in terms of the training for students with others you are going to

429be coord inting that with Mr Hann to provide that okay can you have an update a quick update just like that for the board at the next board meeting you update on what are we doing on that okay the next one and if you can decide what would you like to see as an introductory is going to be kind of a test right because we haven't done this focusing on attendance instructional or or a shment what would you like us to bring next month it's going to be probably 30 40 45 minutes an hour more we were going to be finishes at 8:30 now it's going to be 9:30 but we are willing I'm willing to stay more time because our students deserve that how one of you mentioned we need to invest time now

430to get the the results later so can you decide what and then we are going to be preparing that we are going we are going to call us accountable to bring that presentation and you can set the goals there okay is what you are telling me we this is what we would like to do we would like you par to focus on in deliver on this and give us an update on a monthly basis on what are you doing about what we told you to do that that's my proposal that you decide how you want us to so now obviously today's been a long day um is it possible that you know we just take some time to chew on that and then you know if trusty and I or trusty hall or Stafford and

431Garcia if they want to just send you a text email whatever and then then you can share it with us or remember that we cannot make decisions right based on the brown act would be allowed to make that kind of decisions but they want not a decision but they can send you their ideas yeah like whatever her priority is we can come back at the next board meeting and discuss those okay yeah because I don't necessarily need to know what her top priority is you know once she decides what you know we have a for me in a week and a half well just do you guys have um anyone for the position yet it closes tomorrow okay and so far we had 10 candidates that met the criteria uh three that did not so

432and we we're still getting more application so we're going to have a good P so the idea is to bring the Qui we and then we can all my my thing is just I think they said like a float that was attendant so yes I would just like to see that position fill so you guys can start yeah I on Monday we're going to review the applications to select our our to screen some applicants and then we'll move from there pretty quick yeah and and in those terms Miss Anaya and Mr Mr campus I said well we have been waiting for too long we need to do something and Mr Williams and I we are getting together to look at the community leas we have community relations at each side we have Premier at the

433district office what is what they are doing so when the new person gets here we already going to have an idea a proposal this is what you need to focus because remember it's going to be February we're not going to have too much time so time is of the essence that is our priority and I'm glad to hear that that we have at least two board members and he said Mr campus agrees with you that you have a similar priorities than me because actually should come from you right I was just presenting that that was my recommendation that's what we are going to be doing giving you information so you can make educated decisions and you can say this is the direction that we want to to go and that's what we are going to

434be focused on but I'm really excited because I'm seeing something that it makes sense and that is for our students and is going to help help our district and our community and that's what our students need and deserve that that Focus that ler Focus attendance to an achievement in uh addressing specific needs of our students Arts also is going to be helping with the students and we can talk about details potentially Mari at peris high school B different things that like that that we can have okay all right I think we are at adjournment for the special board meeting of the Board of Trustees of January 20 5th 2025 do I have a motion a motion you have a second thank you okay seeing that I think she wanted to keep on going well I

435mean at this point so we can vote oh wow to journ I know oh oh can we just do it do you want do this way okay you trusty Garcia and trusty Stafford are not present take the opportunity to say thank you to the C members for Sara f for being here today we really appreciate all your help and your support and to Mr campus for organizing this uh this great uh yeah it was a excellent excellent Retreat I'm live hey F taking a vote the vote was 3 0 and the meeting is adjourned at 401

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.