001I'm calling the January 14th 202 2025 meeting of the Board of Education to order per government code section 54950 at Secor and Education Code 35140 Ator at 3:35 p.m. as um trusty Todd Frasier will be participating via teleconference all votes will be taken by roll call close session we will now be adjourning to close session for the purpose of discussing the following matters 3.1 Public Employee discipline dismissal suspension release leave re assignment non- reelection non reappointment resignation reinstatement pursuant to government code 54957 Personnel matters public employee appointments employment pursuant to government code 54957 Acting Superintendent acting assistant superintendent H Human Resources interim assistant superintendent administrative Services 3.1 conference with labor negotiations labor NE negotiator unrepresentative Acting Superintendent acting assistant superintendent Human Resources interim assistant super superintendent administrative Services Agency designated representative Todd Robbins Atkinson Anderson
002Lloyd lend and Romo 3.4 conference with legal counsel anticipated litigation significant exposure to litigation pursuant to paragraph D2 of government code section 54956.9 2 cases prop 39 requests for facilities from Magnolia Public School prop 39 requests for district facilities from California Republic Leadership Academy 3.5 conference with legal council anticipated litigation significant exposure to litigation pursuant to paragraph D2 of government code section 54956.9 one case District board action on Orange County School of computer science request for approval of material revisions 3.6 conference with legal councel existing liation significant exposure to litigation presant to paragraph 2 or three of subdivision D of section 54956.9 multiple cases complaints filed by various District employees 3.7 conference with legal counsel existing litigation significant exposure to litigation pursuant to paragraph 2 or three of subdivision D of section 5495 5 6.91
003case melum versus P LUSD 3.8 claims general liability claim number 6487 49 and general liability claim number 648 8854 um it seems that we have several people wanting to speak tonight um if there's anybody else here that has not filled out a blue card um if you could please do that right now so we have everyone's cards we have 31 32 speakers or 33 speakers so everybody will be given one minute and um I just wanted to make a quick statement I know there's been a a lot of um interest on social media and things like that out there um of our Clos session and I just want to remind everybody that approval of the material revision will not change this year's um school at Orange County School of computer science only next school year
004just as a denial of this revision does not change the current status of Orange County School of computer science this year or next okay so um just just so we're all talking about have correct information so first up I'll call Four at a time Mark Fury Patrick gani um Latifa Beckel and Nelly Raphael hello Mark Fury obviously there's probably a lot of confusion going on over the last month of what's been going on but can you clarify when you're going to close session who is the legal counsel and I would assume that legal counsel for ongoing litigation would be the legal firm that's been you know on staff for a long time and it seems like there's been a new legal team hired for any new litigation so if you could just uh clarify that
005and then can somebody just summarize exactly why seven people are on admin TR to leave so the public has a better idea thank [Applause] you Patrick good afternoon um I am a retired educator I came back out of retirement to help start the Orange County School of computer science I will say that you need to vote in favor of it I have never seen a better facility or a better run facility I've never worked with a better team in 40 Years of employment it's really all I have to say thank you Latifa is she not here okay Nelly while I've spoken here before about overall operations tonight is personal my kids will attend ocscs and as I witness the incredible opportunities available to students I eagerly anticipate my own children being part of this community
006I can already Envision the projects they'll create the care they'll receive from dedicated teachers and staff and the growth they'll experience in their Learning Journey the proposed petition revision seeks changes that are standard among charter schools ocss is the only Charter in OC not following these structures while the other 46 do supporting this petition ensures our PUSD Charter remains competitive and continues to provide outstanding education thank you okay the next four if they can come forward so we can move quickly um Ariana D and then quala laon caer yeah okay thank you Eric and Beth fiser hello proud ocscs parent here what an absolutely amazing exciting steam forward opportunity for our students in this District despite living in y Belinda for over 15 years this is the first time that we have put our daughter
007in public school why because until this point there has never been a school in this District that has challenged and excited her the way that private education has my daughter wants to be a Disney imagineer when she grows up the Innovation Lab at ocscs is truly the most incredible well-rounded amazing opportunity for kids at this school to learn a variety of engineering subjects it's like Disney imagineering all wrapped up into one big beautiful lab as the oral Linda resident I am so proud that my tax dollars have gone into creating this safe exciting place for my daughter and other students to create engineering opportunities and learn these skills and for the first time we have a school where she longs to go to and looks forward to attending every single day how many other schools
008can claim this Additionally the teachers that Dr fiser have amassed at ocss are some of the most incredible dedicated hardworking teachers thank you for your [Applause] time aloho to the board members and um and the community and I'm a grandparent of the student student in this district and I'm here to speak on behalf of ocscs as someone who has seen generations of my family go through different Educational Systems and as one who face s significant adversity and lived in a rural indigenous Community I know how important it is for for um the school to truly serve its Community good schooling makes a difference and great schooling can change the outcome of the lives of the kids in ways we cannot imagine industry certifications mean faster access to higher paying jobs while students study in college
009o ocscs has proven itself as place where students Thrive and Innovative learning is happening and they have all thank you for your time yeah thank you very much well as you can see by the way I'm dressed I happen to be a pastor but I'm also a husband and father and most happily a grandfather of two grandchildren who will be attending who do attend school here in the p ylusd district the welfare of these grandchildren indeed and all of your children is dear to my heart and they and you are all in my prayers a closed session will soon be called where the future of our children hangs in the balance Dr fiser and her very able team have assembled a charter school within the district that is proving to be highly successful in reaching
010our children giving them a deepening thirst for Learning and it's yielding great results but now I fear that bureaucracy is prioritizing the comfort of adults over the resources and learning of our dear children to you who are the parents behind me here this ocsc family is important this is your school children who are here this is your school thank you so much thank you very much for giving me the opportunity to speak obviously I think most people know that I have a role as a principal within our schools and I am the very proud principal of ocss but I also stand before you today as a neighbor so as we go in and look at these changes for ocss I would like to Advocate not only as a principal but as a mother of two
011who will have kids who will attend ocss now I'm going to go back into the principal part of it I want to thank on behalf of our staff trusty Cano trust and I would like our parents to know that trusty cantero spent over 3 hours inquiring about the charter school she marked up the petition documents and so I do I know know that there are parents watching and I know you can't really see my face um but so many of you reached out saying that you're at work but you're going to tune in so parents we just want you to know that this is a great opportunity for us to come together in unity and we look forward to continuing to work together thank you the next four speakers Ellie Corine Miss is um Browski
012or bro and Ben stubs got a girl where I come from school is boring but my teachers try the best that they can do at ocscs it makes a whole difference so come together to make ocss an even better place I also want to support Mr piano he used to be my sub and now now he teaches at ocscs he makes awesome stuff with a 3D printer and teaches kids how to make hands he is an amazing teacher and I hope you will support ocss so he can teach me those fun things thank you thank who's that Corine um there's a accessibility issue and I'm going to read Corine's um okay her um speech and I've not I've read it through once so I pardon me if I can't go as quickly I know she
013timed it um Marilyn and krie whatever lawsuits come our way this is on you Carrie you've cost our district Millions with your law Mass lawsuit in 2022 and now illegal cab bonds that homeowners will soon be paying back for for your fiscal irresponsibility Mar and your illegal actions directing staff to give over confidential claims and handling the documents and then calling a special board meeting using stolen documents to remove chis and Gates was outside of protocols now we have more lawsuits coming the taxpayers are not going to foot the bill for the illegal actions and working outside of your scope as a board member we demand of PUSD is sued Marilyn Anderson and Carrie Buck pay their own attorney fees how many consult um consultants and employees have to complain and file against Marilyn Anderson
014complaining of anti-Semitism and racism we have the first Jewish superintendent and first black Deputy superintendent intendent and the decision of the board majority was to remove them Marilyn how many times have you asked Dr churners if he was Jewish and violation of employment law the only reason thank you [Applause] well there it is hi Ben stubs uh p parent um and a good afternoon members of the board Community interim superintendent Dr Gray um friends and family if you expect transparency and integrity from president Anderson I believe you won't find it this is already the second closed session meeting that's been called at 3:30 p.m. when most parents are still at work and unaware take for example the emergency meeting on December 19th where she followed Apple president Linda manion's orders to place our superintendent and
015assistant superintendent on administrative leave then at 11:00 a.m. on the eve of Christmas Eve she sent an email to every parent in the district about Dr chice being put on administrative leave tarnishing his reputation in the eyes of the community these actions happened swiftly under trusty Anderson's leadership too quickly in my opinion friends and family I'm just a dad don't take my word for it as constituents you have the right to ask president Anderson why she's targeting Dr chernes Dr Gates Dr fiser and OCS bring back Dr chice thank [Applause] you Mrs Bowski is this your card I've always been an advocate especially for those who can't advocate for themselves um most of you know that I'm a proud parent of Jackson and he is on the brink of graduating from high school this year
016and as um we're approaching this time it's had me reflect upon where where we've come from and it wasn't until I met the leader of this Charter School six years ago that hope turned into action it was in this school that I finally found someone who could transform not just Jackson's learning experience but the cultures the culture for all students today I'm honored to serve as a member of The Advisory council at ocscs where I have the privilege of witnessing a vision brought to life this vision is not just an idea it's lived in reality driven by a dedicated staff committed to every student's success the revisions proposed are not just are not just reasonable they are essential they're about removing barriers to ensure that every child has the opportunity to excel there are no
017legal obstacles standing in the way of these changes only the potential for Progress so I ask you will you stand as a barrier to this growth or will you be the Catalyst that helps Propel our Learners to the school forward thank very much and bring back churness thank you next for Paul vanderlay Gary Briana Trump and Connor Borge my wife and I moved here because we learned about the quality of the schools within the PUSD and our boys were rewarded with the rich experience at Sierra Vista fast forward to sixth grade parent teacher conference and as we're discussing our boys education with her teacher begin to realize that the structure of her classroom means that our boys are going to receive the minimum education required for them to reach the Common Core Baseline standards so
018when I hear Dr Fischer share a vision of building a learning culture of what's next I'm intrigued when I hear that students who achieve Mastery expectations are given additional assignments or activities to further the Mastery of a subject and that students who are struggling with the subject are offered tutoring sessions to tackle the subject from a different angle and then should a student not achieve Mastery at Major Ben testing benchmarks they're assigned a mini elective in that subject so that no child is Left Behind while I set aside my preconceived notions about charter schools and I sign my boys up now this is a discussion if this school board is capable of effective effectively governing a school who's actively shifting its learning culture to one of what's next while at the same time governing the
019Myriad of schools under its purview who are maintaining the culture of reaching common core standards thank you Gary my wife and I are proud grandparents of seven grandchildren one a recent graduate from Valencia one will be graduating this year from El Dorado which thank thankfully has a new principal one attends ocscs and another will soon be entering OCS CS SC or CS additionally I have two grandchildren attending breah high with another one about to enter kindergarten at pyl I want to emphasize the need to restore our District's focus on uplifting and supporting our goals my grandchildren at OCS CS is not only excelling academics but also thriving in athletics and social relationships The Narrative that ocscs is an experiment or has failed is simply untrue the school's leadership is transparent listens to people feedback and
020makes real-time adjustments to benefit students there's a clear focus on safety and positive School culture and fussed thank you Brianna son my name is Brianna Trump I'm a third generation here at this District my son is a student at ocss I am also the PTA president at ocss let's put our differences aside tonight and focus on what matters the most which is the children I spend a lot of time there and I haven't seen any of you at the campus except Trisha Trisha I know you see what I see at ocss and I hope and I pray that you give these kids a chance [Applause] he's a little nervous hello my name is Connor Borg I am I am in seventh grade at LSS this year has been the best year of all my school
021years I love the mini electives I love my teachers I love the grading system and I love my school please do not take ocscs away from me and the students of ocss I want to thank Mrs fiser my principal for the wonderful year she has given me and all the students thank you for your time thank you Conor next for Marissa mallerie Andy Falco Joshua Lane and Stephanie Lee I no longer have any students in p schools after witnessing his high his sister's High School experiences our son chose to go to a private high school where he is thriving this one child leaving p p for four years cost the district over $50,000 there are currently 14 students in grades K through 12 living on my block only three attend p schools and annually that
022cost this District over1 140,000 or $1.8 million over the course of those students K 12 years right now is when the Open Enrollment windows in our neighboring districts are opening those with Charter skills within their limits support those Charters and welcoming students from P transitioning them to their traditional public schools once they complete their charter school education in other words they won't return to p schools private schools are hosting their open houses and early acceptance letters have already gone out for 2025 2026 school year the actions of this board majority have threatened the financial well-being of the school district and harmed the students in its schools P has a model noce needed nurtured it wasn't until the reign of President Anderson that I realized that this motto refers to the teachers union not to the
023students that they are to teach thank you very [Applause] much I'm going to dispense with my prepared uh comment uh because when I found out that Trisha quento was there for three hours at ocss I'm going to have the faith that she saw the greatness of that school and saw how an an amazing principal Dr fiser was able to put together a program that has changed children's lives I had the good opportunity with a bunch of friends yesterday to meet with at least a hundred parents who have children that go to ocss and it was all the same everybody talked about how amazing it was how it changed their children's lives and how many of them had simply put their kids in that school because of the planned education that they was going to get
024there uh and so I'm going to have faith that Trisha quento saw what we s we what we see and uh we'll do the right thing and vote for everything that they need to continue to be successful thank you thank you Rane the difference between a good school and a great school is the buyin from its Educators and the people that are involved in the future of our kids the curriculum that is provided at ocscs is unique my child specifically has went from a c student to an AB student and it's just been one semester she comes home and talks about the counselors the teachers and how they help her unlike in the past most importantly a seventh grader my daughter wants to go to college now she talks to us about it she reached
025out to her family to go on tours to Cal State Fullerton and UCLA where they attend and where you want to hold her back from going you all should be ashamed of yourself for even fighting this a seventh grader that went from a SE student to wanting to go to college and wants to develop and impact the future is very unique no sea student wants that and goes from that in just a couple months the future is decided at ocscs by you guys and you choose which way my daughter gets to go in life and the impact that she gets to have on the community thank you um I received this from a credentialed staff member at ocscs and I'm reading it for them because they're in fear of being retaliated our community collaboration as
026a group needs to improve during the last three board meetings some speakers presented misinformation and myths in regards to ocscs to the best of our knowledge these presenters have not visited ocscs nor had discussions with staff and teachers when a speaker presented information in contrast to others opinions both sides of the aisle engaged in disrespectful Behavior by heckling this is not conducive of a community that is open to the perspective of others we need to create a decorum open to opinions to provide Solutions and options for our students thank you okay the next four Michelle Doer Phil sits April sorry thank you Linda con hello I'm an education specialist at ocscs I spent 23 years at Bernardo yba middle school and I've been an instructional Aid a student teacher um in the district I'm a
027resident and a proud member of the community and I love placent heral Linda over the years we have seen so many changes in education um and we've always adapted the the district we've always adapted to provide the best for the students um this petition before you represents just another shift and another change in how we educate our full inclusion model ensures students remain in general education classrooms accessing grade level curriculum with necessary accommodations and modifications this approach Fosters belonging and helps students with reach their full potential I have witnessed firsthand students thank you so much thank youy my name is Phil sites and I the history department chair at ocscs I've been at Bernardo Yorba now ocscs for 28 years since I began I've heard many rors from the beginning of the school year for
028example that we're lazy in reality our professional days are packed with lesson planning creating common assessments coordinating pacing faculty meetings and teaching we dedicate ourselves to supporting sixth through eth grader students often working longer hours than many others without complaint another rumor is that we're unhappy on the contrary we spoken to nearly every teacher and the consensus is clear we're proud of our work we're aligned with the school's Mission and we're United another that we dislike our Union not at all 90% of the staff belongs to a union we've asked the union to represent our staff if we Grant if we granted autonomy it's the union who's hesitating to represent the teachers at OCS and finally that we oppose the charter autonomy almost all teachers agree thank you good afternoon everybody um I would like
029to Echo the feelings that we would love it if this all the animosity would end um we we are hoping to come together as a community um I'm asking for those of you on the dis the election is over you all have your spots and we appreciate your service it's not an easy spot to be in and when you go into the back right now to discuss whatever the possible litigation is I would ask that you do so based on the facts and the truth in the matter and not not um trying to win political points with anyone um because there's some real interest all really important things at stake couple things I just want to point out is when this was originally um presented there was a Ed code cited 15 days necessary to
030have things submitted before review and this pertains specifically to establishment and renewal of petitions and according to the um California fifth appell at court uh today's first start CH Charter versus Englewood School District there's separate procedures and criteria for material revisions they are not the same thank you very much I'm Linda con I'm honored to speak for Tiffany Gonzalez these are her words my oldest daughter attends ocscs and I have two more children that are set to attend as well therefore I have a legitimate interest in this school our experience at OC CS has been thus far outstanding not only are there incredible information and transparency for parents there's open communication my questions are addressed immediately additionally my daughter has already been building in The Innovation lab and she gives a detail description this is
031mind-blowing for my 13-year-old with zero experience or knowledge of anything before this September the way the program challenges kids to think and solve problems is fantastic applicable to getting things done in a real job in the real world while there's ambiguity and undefined Realms this is especially applicable for the job market today both my husband and I have worked in the tech industry in San Francisco and have been bleeding edge companies so that we are speaking with content and experience do the right thing thank you very much next four speakers Judy deardon um Moises Al Alonso Billy v v and lesie Alexander trusty Anderson did you say me first I'm yes you're first thanks JK you all right um yes um I toured the charter school on uh January 7th I believe and Beth fiser
032gave me the tour um I also um uh met with uh the teachers because it was uh the wind was blowing so hard that the kids didn't have recess and and I did meet with um thank you sir and he uh told me that um the teachers actually teach uh 250 minutes more than your non-charter schools uh also uh they are teaching part of the curriculum is teaching Common Core I mean teaching math the way that I was taught Common Core is a disaster um also um I left there thinking that these students are going to be able to find their passion and also I saw a young man a student giving a big presentation and I thought oh at that age that is really impressive thank you thank you good evening staff uh I
033really don't have a dog in the fight my son's this is his last year at the school but I got to tell you he coming from another school system the transformation my son came uh went from being a d student and C student to be an Onana Rose and uh that's because of uh Dr Beth and the staff at this school they really care about the students and I got to ask you I I never seen coming from another school district myself back East I've never seen a school like this to Pro provide such quality and such education to the students it's it's it's amazing and not affording the other kids this opportunity would really be a crime I mean to hear all this bickering and fighting going back and forth one has to wonder
034who are the real adults in the room seems like it's the kids it's really a shame don't we all in all as parents to want the best education for our children as a parent I'll go to any length to make sure that that happens thank you thank you hi I'd like to first of all thank you all for you know working so hard for the children because that's our future and I'm a 15-day old grandfather and I was just at a funeral bearing a grandmother and I came I have nothing really to uh say except my daughter loves school she gets up early she wants to go to school she loves her principal and she sees her friends also love school and you know I I come home and I see her like working on
035school stuff and I think I it shocks me because I have two other kids that went to your school district they've graduated and my son didn't do very well in school and he always had problems he was always you know bullied and uh and it wasn't this school but you know this one seems to be really really nice and I don't want this my last child to uh experience what they experienced thank you very much my name is lesie Alexander I'm the parent of 2 pyl grads and a retired teacher from yinda middle school I would like to begin by thanking Mrs Anderson for her patience and for her leadership as president of our school board in restoring this board to duties of oversight and accountability your attentiveness and your civility are appreciated I would
036like to submit that ocscs remain a district Charter under the oversight of the P ylusd Board the rushed application for the conversion is incomplete and missing several components which are required this application is not the result of careful planning or thoughtful research that would best serve the students of that school this is a new school and there are many pieces that still need refining ranging from developing a master schedule that is workable from the first day of school to strategies to maintain enrollment these processes will require supervision monitoring and scrutiny I believe this Charter requires more accountability and oversight not less therefore it should remain a district Charter under the guidance much Bo thank you the next four Maria stubs Karen Pam and DaNell good afternoon trustees inter and superintendent gray staff and Community Maria
037lups parent in PSD last November at the Orange County School of computer science kopia event my young children explor The Innovation Labs met their future principal Dr Fisher and teachers and brought home 3D printed items created by the students my oldest is excited about attending next year and my youngest just loved it all in contrast to my children's excitement over ocss I am reminded that President Marilyn Anderson voted no on funding The Innovation Lab at the May 7 2024 board meeting she also voted no on purchasing Singapore math textbooks and other materials for ocss students however Anderson voted in favor of rehiring a law firm that includes attorney Suki who creates a common enemy out of charter schools bring back Dr chernes bring back Dr Gates and stop the attack on ocss and our children
038thank you Marilyn hi your legacy is one of boasting about confidential HR matters yet you offer no timelines for the return of Administrators who pose no threat Marilyn return them now your legacy includes Christmas coup and hostile Hanukkah no one is fooled you have it out for Dr chernes and the other admins are just collateral damage Marilyn you can't look at me the public sees how the board majority manipulates perception with fake legal claims meanwhile students suffer set aside your pride and vindictive agenda bring back our superintendent let the investigations follow the proper channels I haven't heard anyone here speak in opposition of OCS sort of the one lady that wants it done differently this community clearly overwhelmingly supports it and so any actions that you take to destroy it will only be further evidence
039of Your Personal Agenda that goes against what the community parents students and teachers at that school clearly want thank you bring back Dr chernes thank you Pam I admit I have no idea what the vote is in closed session I thought 15 days meant you were going to come to open session and talk about a material revision so I actually I don't know what's going on here and I think a lot of community members have no idea what's going on um I just came to suggest you've got the district has a communication and a marketing and therefore a credibility problem it seems like one side Will Be Loved by that particular side that voted for them and then the other side Will Be Loved by the people who voted for them and so we still
040have a split Community which is not good I was just going to suggest that you vote in a have a study session like we did with the facility fees three years ago we learned a lot of stuff in that study session we learned that a lot of your executive staff lied to the uh board members so I think having a vote having a discussion an open session a study session we can hear both sides pros and cons would be best so that everyone can hear in the open What's Happening [Applause] than my name is DaNell I have two kids in this district and I'm about to make some enemies I want to preface this by saying that my genuine desire is that this charter school is successful and a benefit to this school district unfortunately
041ocscs has not currently had a track record of transparency honesty or quality education what we have seen as a principal who is willing to muddy the Waters of her focus and sight with distractions and participate in what is best questionable Financial activities Dr Fischer has repeatedly demonstrated a willingness to address the community outside of the board through videos petitions letters of misinformation and even influencing parents to or not to attend board meetings most of all of this has been documented to the school board in previous complaints and building a charter school board that negates even a single board member shows a continued aggression and lack of willingness to work with or support the board this needs to stop being ignored Dr Fischer has IGN encouraged a community of discontent and created almost a culture War
042to avoid transparency and answering difficult questions good luck [Applause] thank the last two um Julie clink BG and Paula Powers Julie clinker proud of three pyl graduates so I've been an active participant long before these culture wars I'm a concerned Citizen and a hardworking taxpayer happy new year new Board of Trustees we have a fresh start fresh eyes on the approval of a revised Charter petition that was hastily made last December just wanted to remind the public that on December 12th 2023 the Board of Trustees unanimously voted to approve the conversion of Bernardo Yorba to a district Affiliated charter school and I think we should stand with that decision keep it under the watchful eye of an informed Board of Trustees who continues to ask good questions to support all Learners use the funding and
043spaces properly and appropriately Innovation is good it's great but rushing decisions is not look at the debacle of USI hopefully this current team that's you guys can quit pulling audibles and game day decisions please refer to A playbook which includes being transparent getting solid answers to move forward and hold each other accountable and fiscally responsible when approving material revisions we stakeholders want to ensure our students are getting a solid public school education thank you very much hello Paula Powers ocscs has not even been open for a year yet why are we already having to revise the charter for it has had a chance to succeeded it is not the right time to make this Monumental decision to go independent with so many unknowns half the people in this room are under the misconception that you
044want to close the charter the board must abide by the contract they made to our community at the start of ocscs it should remain a p school Under the supervision of the board as it was intended to do that was the promise made to us and I ask that you keep it thank you [Applause] okay that is the end of close session um I just had I had a couple questions before we go back to Clos session if that's okay we have a couple regarding closed session before we go back I believe that's allowed is that allow I'm just checking with our attorney are you asking questions about the agenda I'm asking questions yes about the agenda for a closed session before we go into the back um if you want to ask your question
045I can let you know whether okay so we have under one of I think it's probably under 3.2 there is a confidential claim that was filed on December 18th and it's going to come before the board in close session however you have already hired an investigator for this claim even though the board has given no direction for the claim and um we haven't even seen the claim as a board we haven't directed anything we haven't been directed about the claim but you've hired an investigator for the claim and so that is actually where were you given Direction and who gave you the claim I'll be providing updates about the investigation in closed session how come you're not providing this you're you're working outside confidential attorney client privilege communication so a board member may have given
046you a confidential claim because it wasn't the interim superintendent and did not get the claim before the night that I so how why did you hire the investigator I will give you an update in close session so we've admitted we've hired an investigator and the board hasn't even seen the claim wow second another thing is I would like to know um I've spoken to obviously our own PUSD Charter I've spoken to Magnolia and I've spoken to crla and none of them have any litigation against us there's no anticipated litigation and David Huff says nothing is actionable until April so if you can please explain to the community especially when we have um on the Open Session agenda we have ocscs presenting it open how are we able to go back there if there's no anticipated
047litigation and I will say that Suki told Renee gray that this is a this is something that she does she puts information under confidential or I'm sorry anticipated litigation to be able to get in the back and to be able to brief the board with whatever she would like to brief them with and then further in an email that was accidentally sent to me I would just like to point out what do we do with this when we have an attorney that is trying to so I I can tell you I'm not done I'm not done okay okay we have an attorney I'll defer to the board president to we have an we have an attorney who is essentially trying to I think we need to just go to CL no I'm going to sit
048here because this is we can't go ahead and adjourn to close session at 421 so Magnolia and crla will no longer and and definitely should go first in order to create a common enemy with the board said the attorney we're going into close session and we have a specific order put onto our Clos session to make a common enemy with the board and we have no anticipated litigation wow on the books someone control the weather and I'd like to thank everybody for their patience um we had a lot to discuss and we were able to get to it all so um it's very thankful for for your patience being out here um I have a few things to report out um one in closed session the board took action to appoint Renee gray as Acting
049Superintendent beginning um this is a continuation a motion was made by Mr Frasier a second by Mrs blades the board vote was 3-2 board members Mrs quento Mrs blades and Mr Frasier voted yes and Mrs Anderson and Mrs Buck voted no second item in Clos session the board took action to appoint Yolanda Mendoza acting assistant superintendent of Human Resources beginning effective January 15 2025 a motion was made by Mrs Buck a second by Mrs Quintero and the Boe vote was 5 to zero number three in closed session the board took action to appoint Joan Velasco as interim assistant superintendent of administrative Services beginning effective January 15 2025 a motion was made by Mrs blades a second by Mrs quento and the board's vote was 5 to zero and the board's vote was unanimous also um
050contracts that will be approved later in this meeting will be on display for your review outside or up here at the front desk and that is the report out now um I can ask trustee quino if she will please lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance alance to the flag of the United States of America and to the repu for it stands one nation God indivisible withy andice for all okay um if possible if it's okay with the rest of the board we'd like to consider moving up our student board member so she may join us at this time Mr Frasier are you okay with that I wasn't unmut am I muted now you're unmuted we can hear you now hey I'm fine with it are you okay with us um moving that up yes
051I am fine with it okay thank you okay um so I'll turn it over to Mrs cray you know what I think we need to do the motion first Mrs Gray yep before you start let me pull it up here I would like to to make a motion to appoint Leila Armand as a student board member for the second semester of the 2024 2025 school year second um we do a roll call Mrs blades yes Mrs quinell yes Mr Frasier yes Mrs Buck hi and I am also an i and the the um vote is unanimous now I'll turn it over to Mrs cray okay it's my pleasure to administer the oath of office to our new student board member Lila Armand she will serve on our Board of Education during the second semester of
052the 2425 school year so I'm going to share a little bit about Lea Leila grew up in our district attending Linda Vista Elementary y Belinda middle school and now Valencia High School as a senior Lea dedicates much of her time to passions for basketball and computer science very well-rounded she is an active member of both the international balarat IB and Cambridge International programs Lea's senior year includes a rigorous course load of IB and AP classes such as computer science physics economics math and English she is also deeply involved in extracurricular activities serving as president of the black student union a member of the United Nations founded girls up Club stem club and participating in varsity basketball lacrosse and track and field just to name a few after graduating Lila will attend Northwestern University in Fall
0532025 on a full tuition scholarship she plans to major in computer science aspiring to become an AI Tech specialist in Washington DC [Music] wow awesome you're going to do great Leila has a very strong support system behind her including her mom hea dad Jason and younger brothers Dean a freshman at Eldorado High School and Jordan a sixth grader at Woodsboro Elementary as well as her grandparents grandparents Lillian Troy Magda and Amed some of them are here with us this evening and if they'd like to stand to be recognized that would be great also in attendance to show his support is principal Chris herzfeld of Valena High School woohoo Chris we are very pleased Lea has agreed to serve as our student board member during her senior year at Valencia let's give her a big round
054of applause welcome congratulations excited for you so now we're going to do the oath of office so if you would please raise your right hand and repeat after me I Lila Armand I Lea Armand do solemnly swear do solemnly swear that I will Faithfully discharge the duties that I will Faithfully discharge the duties upon which I'm about to enter upon which I am about to enter as a student board member I am committed to as a student board member I am committed to providing a voice for students including communicating effectively providing a voice for students in including communicating effectively regarding schools programs regarding schools programs activities and student achievement activities and student achievement furthermore I will do my best furthermore I will do my best to ensure all representative opinions to to to ensure all
055representative opinions to ensure all representative opinions of the students of the placenta Yorbalinda Unified School District of the students of the yinda Unified School District are actively sought heard and considered sorry are actively sought heard and considered are actively sought heard and considered as I serve as a student member to the Board of Education as I serve as a student board M of the ofeducation yay congratulations I'm so happy could be see awesome okay we're excited to have you um let the Roll Call show that all board members are here as trustee um Frasier is participating via teleconference so we'll be doing roll calls as we stated earlier okay um I need um to turn some time over for Mrs Gray to talk about the amended agenda okay members of the board it is my
056recommendation we PLL Andor amend the following items poll item actions it action item 16.5 the contract as currently written does not align with our established guidelines amending action items 16.6 per the document provided on the dis this item requires a correction to address a clerical error the memo reads to include all bargaining units when not all all bargaining units have agreed and last to amend consent item 21.2 human resources which includes a classified report per the document on the dis this amendment reflects the removal of a name from the report so moved okay we have a second a second okay we have a first by Mrs blades a second by Mrs Buck to approve the agenda as amended is there any comments okay well we will do a roll call Miss Leila hi oh sorry
057I forgot you're next to me now hi thank you BL I Mr Frasier I I and I also an I so um motion carried by a five o with one with an I from our student board member okay so here comes the public comment announcement public comments are available in the foyer cars must be completed and turned in prior to the designated time for public comment um provide we're going to provide a maximum of three minutes per person if translation is needed an additional 3 minutes will be given please let us know so we know ahead of time and we can sure we are prepared civility policy Education Code 220 prohibits discrimination on the basis of dis disability gender gender identity gender expression nationality race ethnicity religion sexual orientation or any other characteristic that is
058contained in the definition of hate crime set forth in section 42255 of the penal code including immigration status so now we will move on to 11 .1 approving of the minutes I'll make a motion that we approve December 19th 2024 special meet special meeting minutes second okay I have a motion by Mrs Buck a second by Mrs Quintero are there any comments okay we will do a roll call and Lea since you weren't at this meeting you don't get to vote sorry um this is I ior I I I and I am also an I so the motion carries five I'll make a motion that we approve December 17th 2024 regular me meeting minutes second okay I have a motion by Mrs Buck a second by Mrs Quintero any qu comments okay um we'll go
059ahead and take the vote Mrs blades hi I I I I perfect and I am also an I so the motion carries fiveo okay so now we will have our student board report by Mrs Lila Arman um good evening president Anderson trustees and Acting Superintendent Mrs Gray I'm excited to be here tonight to share recent updates from our comprehensive high schools and Alternate campuses so currently Parkview school and Bona Vista Virtual Academy are preparing their tk12 production of Frozen scheduled for April 11th and 12th uh these annual event Fosters codery and bring together the community in February the PTSA will host their annual jagathon followed by an open house in March um students and families are eagerly anticipating these spring events um for El Camino RI High School is proud to announce that nine students
060have graduated so far this year uh 11 students 11 new students join their school at the start of the semester along with two new staff members who are teaching electives in journalism and art fundamentals the College and Career Tech team is organizing a trip to Chapman University in March providing students with valuable exposure to higher education opportunities Eldorado High School's winter sports team teams are performing strongly across various Fields courts and mats boys soccer is currently first place leading the Crest View League during a grueling schedule boys basketball has an impressive 18 to4 overall record showcasing their competitiveness and looking forward to taking a top spot by the end of the freeway league play the girls basketball team is in second place continuing to battle for their top spot in their league with six games
061to go the golden hot girls soccer team is also making a push for the League's top position with strong performances in the determined efforts as they continue to compete in one of the strongest leagues in all of Orange County wrestling has been seen has seen individual standout performances with two more matches left in the season one at home in the nest and one remaining away match the Eldorado varsity cheer cheer squad secured first place at their prestigious UCA West challenge competition highlighting their exceptional skill team spirit and black and gold Pride overall Golden Hawk winter sports are excelling with notable achievements in both team and individual performances setting a strong Foundation as they get ready for CIF playoffs um es bronza high school has preparations for the districtwide winter formal schedule scheduled for January 25th
062at wild rivers um their Visual and Performing Arts programs are gearing up for second semester events including Mean Girls the musical by the choir and theater departments the jazz band is submitting recordings by n to National competitions in arts and ceramic students are preparing for a gallery opening later this summer Academic Teams are Academic Teams are also preparing for spring competitions with Academic Decathlon team competing in February and host of students attending the state leadership conference the key parents uh for George Key School the key parent staff student staff organization is organizing several events including a percussive dance Ensemble assembly on January 16th and a Snow Play Day on February 21st February will also feature random acts of kindness week cumulating on Fe February 14th with a parent Student Activity day Venture Academy's choir is
063preparing for the love concert scheduled for February at the Eldorado Performing Arts Center the this event promises an enjoyable evening showcasing the talents of students in choir director Carmen conturo Valencia High School hosted an avid showcase today welcome welcoming over 60 visitors to observe classroom observe classroom best practices in tour morning classes tomorrow future tigers from CR and valz middle schools will attend the e8th grade showcase assembly where they explore band expl explore programs such as Esports robotics Arts ASB and more performances by the band Orchestra Color Guard cheer team and other groups will highlight the event congratulations to the Roop photography teacher and soccer coach cordoza for being named employee of the year for North Orange County Roop yinda for yinda high school their winter sports teams are experiencing great success the Mustang theater
064company will host a com Comedy Sports match this Friday featuring staff members for for a night of comedic improv the dance company will participate in the community Dance Festival next month while band and guard will showcase their talents at the Arts of paloa Event club Rush will take place in early February encouraging strong Club participation that is all thank you I don't know if they told you this was part of I don't know if they told you this was part of the job but we get to quiz you looking for so what experience do you hope to gain in serving in the Benta yalina Unified School District as a student board member I'm really looking forward to continue to gain expertise in leadership advocacy and governance all while amplifying the student um voices of P
065I'm really looking forward to hopefully you know give back to the community that has given so much to me thank you thank you very [Applause] much okay now we are to our Acting Superintendent report Mrs Gray okay thank you very much good evening again president Anderson and trustees despite the changes in our district tonight's agenda reflects that the work of the district is continuing with great momentum our dedicated staff have returned from the holiday break with energy and purpose hitting the ground running across our campuses there is a palpable sense of excitement our sites are buzzing with activities and our sports teams are giving their all in their competitions and most importantly our students are deeply engaged in learning this progress is a direct result of the extraordinary efforts of our staff they are the
066heart of this District ensuring that students remain at the center of all we do their unwavering commitment to forging ahead and focusing on what truly matters which is our students has been instrumental in sustaining the work that allows our children to thrive here are just a few events that exemplify their dedication our high schoolmy right now our four comprehensive high schools are now accepting applications and they're working very hard to get those acmy started for the 2526 school year this includes digital media media arts academy and Ed Law Academy at Al Dorado the junior Reserve officer training Corps Aztec engineering and Manufacturing Academy and medical Sciences Academy at esparanza the Cambridge AIC diploma program International balarat diploma program and Valtech Academy at Valena and last but not least the Mustang Business Academy at y Belinda
067our staff associated with these cies continue to work diligently to ensure our cies are second to none in the country County or country application deadlines are quickly approaching please visit pusd.org to learn more as far as our TK parent information night on next Monday the 27th we will host our annual transitional kindergarten and preschool information night at 6:00 p.m. in the auditorium at Valena High School families are encouraged to attend if they have children who will be turning 4 between September 2nd 2020 and SE September 1st 2021 or if they are considering keeping their child out of kindergarten for an additional year our early educational programs are excellent and designed to prepare Young Learners for school Success provide Readiness in Reading Writing mathematics and Social Development and give Young Learners the gift of time to
068develop and grow in an appropriate educational setting more information again is on our website which was stated before in the area of safety we have our comprehensive school threat assessment guidelines training that is taking place currently one of our District's highest priorities is ensuring the safety and well-being of our students staff and Community to that end we are proud to highlight the recent implementation of What's called the comprehensive school threat assessment guidelines better know better known as SE stag and this training is going across the district for all of our schools this evidence-based training equips our staff with the tools and strategies to identify assess and address potential threats before they escalate by focusing on prevention SE stag helps Foster a culture of safety ensuring that concerns are identified early and addressed effectively at the
069same time it provides a clear framework for Intervention when necessary ensuring that we respond to incidences thoughtfully and consistently with the safety of all in mind officer Shan Cronin and Rick gramer or gramar presented during this training emphasized the Dual importance of prevention and intervention in school safety their insights remind us that while it's crucial to address issues as they arise the true strength of these guidelines lie in their proactive approach identifying concerns before they become crises and building trust within our school communities this training marks just the beginning of our plans for strengthening safety protocols in our schools as we move forward we will continue to develop and Implement additional measures and strategies to ensure our campuses remain safe supportive environments for all our commitment to the safety of our students staff and Community
070is unwavering and this is the foundation for the comprehensive approach we are building together as far as the employee of the year Additionally the district um recently accepted nominations for our you are the advantage employee of the year program each year teachers classified staff members and managers may be nominated by one or more of their colleagues or supervisors for this special recognition nominations detail the outstanding contributions these individuals provide to the district that go above and beyond their regularly assigned duties the nominating individuals must also describe how the candidate demonstrates the four core values of Excellence collaboration integrity and Innovation we look forward to announcing the recipients of our employee of the year award in February So speaking of the outstanding contributions of our pylusd employees I want to take a moment to recognize the
071incredible individuals who ensure that the work of our district is Contin continuing seamlessly first are our hardworking teachers who day in and day out rise above distractions to ensure our students receive the highest quality education their dedication is the foundation of our success next where would we be without our principles they are the hard and soul of our district day in and day out they rise to the occasion setting aside distractions to ensure every day is Meaningful for our students our students Thrive largely due to their unwavering leadership and dedication equally vital are our committed support staff our school psychologists instructional AIDS Food Service workers bus drivers and countless others who work behind the scenes to make everything run smoothly and finally I want to shine a spotlight on our directors sitting here in the
072front row many of whom are here this evening for us would you please stand to be recognized o over and even the ones on the second row yeah in the second row there's some too that's right over the last few weeks your over the last few weeks I can't say this strongly enough your leadership and resilience have been extraordinary you've stepped up in ways that no one would have anticipated in uring that District doesn't miss a beat Mike where's Mike Mike you've taken on leadership duties with such Poise and Grace your steadiness has been a guiding force and Gwen and Baldwin right over there your proactive mindset and willingness to take on more always asking what else can we do what else can we do have been invaluable to everyone Liz your steadfast commitment and
073exceptional leadership of our elementary principles continue to inspire everyone around you and Don Don over there your ability to to manage an intricate web of contracts and responsibilities while taking on even more is nothing short of remarkable George and Elaine your expertise and dedication in your Technical and specialized areas are essential to the district's success and a lot of us don't understand what you do I'm telling you Ralph your humor and quick response time bring levity and support when it's needed most and it's always appreciated and Richard and Fong your specialized skills in transportation and fiscal management are truly invaluable the expertise you both bring to the table plays a critical role in the seamless functioning of our district and we are deeply grateful for all that you do and last but certainly not least
074there's Jeremy who's here every time over there I'm Side Y whose technical expertise and unmatched technological skills make many of the previously mentioned directors responsibility is possible it's because of you Jeremy and your countless contributions are so valuable to so many so thank you so on behalf of everyone in the district I thank you all for stepping up and leading during this time with courage and heart and you are an inspiration to us all and your efforts will continue to make a lasting impact so in closing I would just like to say over the past week we have all witnessed the profound impact of the devastating fires throughout Southern California many of our neighbors have faced unimaginable trauma uncertainty UNC for some like my family this has hit very close to home my eldest son
075was evacuated due to the sunset fire a sobering reminder of how quickly circumstances can change these events highlight the heightened anxiety that stems from uncertainty while we cannot control the external factors faced by those enduring this crisis we can take action within our district to provide Clarity stability and Direction it is our responsibility as a district to collaborate to problem solve and work tirelessly to restore the trust and Excellence that our community expects and deserves as we move forward let this moment serve as a call to Unity our students are watching and they deserve nothing less than our Collective commitment to their success and wellbeing that concludes my report for this evening thank you Mrs Gray now we're moving on to the public comment um public comment is an opportunity for public to provide input
076to the Board of Education during the public comment period board members do not dialogue with speakers or make comments regarding the information shared we have I believe 61 speakers wishing to speak tonight so each speaker will be given one one minute I'm going to call um we ask the speakers to repeat their name when they come up to speak and we'll call for the first four speakers to come and sit in the front to be prepared so we can keep moving with our time our first speaker will be [Music] elwin I think it's Tong or Tong Stephanie Lee yeah toine um Stephanie Lee meline gav Gabriel loic Gabriel Lo and April Gabriel Lo Owen is um elwin toing toing tobing here t o b i n g I believe with the last two numbers of
077the phone number okay Stephanie Lee hello I have a unique Vantage Point as a parent of P graduates including Bernardo Yorba and now my granddaughter is attending a p school and by the way my name is Stephanie again I'm really puzzled by the controversy surrounding the efforts to bring our schools up to speed with technology and Innovation why resist progress that benefits our kids isn't it rare for a school to volunteer appily take on more work yet that's what the whole staff at ocscs is committed to doing their dedication to making this school the best it can be is undeniable they have openly and clearly outlined a pathway to secure more resources for our students so approving their request should be a really easy decision to make I'm asking as a parent and grandparent please
078set aside differences find Common Ground not common enemies focus on what truly matters supporting our schools and our students vision for a brighter [Applause] future [Applause] mine hello and good evening my name is Maddie and I'm a student at ocss I attend after school Innovation lab club and it is very fun the teacher encourages us to use our creativity and Imagination to make incredible things things using machines allows us to talk to people usually don't talk to and collaborate it is very exciting to make and build things using tools and machines I'm very interested in learning how to use them it would be sad to see that program go away most people do not understand why we use the Mastery based learning instead of the usual a b c DF grading system I think that
079the Mastery based is better because students understand what they need to do to reach the goal instead of waiting for the next test and try to get into it also it keeps students in my spirits because if you get an F on a test you don't know how to do better and an f means fail so you have failed that is very negative whereas the Mastery based learning is you have not met the success criteria yet you just need to build a little more that's much more positive this school experience makes me excited about learning because thank you so much April so sorry I'm going to take a minute that was my one who actually likes school so um I've spoken about the other one in the past but I'm April gilovich uh thank you
080again for your time you guys and your dedication to this um I'm speaking on behalf of a few things that I can uh address regarding the revision to the petition that have been confusing regarding the governance structure it was mentioned that there won't be a position for a PUSD representative on the board and that's not true the government structure actually provides a position that is put in by um you guys uh and also that governance structure has to um they abide by the same governing laws as a Schoolboard Ed code government law all that applies and we also have to I say we not me I'm not involved um would have to provide documents to the board regularly for transparency um we recognize that this program and the things in the petition have been attacks
081on the district it's evident you guys work with thousands of students in these departments are being asked to perform needs based on the programs that are being run here that is it takes a lot and prioritizing that across the district certainly is a lot but we would be able to prioritize for those [Applause] programs the next four speakers um Paul vanderlay Beth fiser David D and Judy deer Paul is first good evening I'm Paul venderle a computer science school that relies on Chromebook apps an innovation lab that runs a fund fundraising campaigns like a school band The what's next learning culture launched by Dr fiser under a differently balanced School Board is gasping for air it's this unique culture that encourages my boys intellectual curiosity they take an active role in requesting classes and opportunities
082that they know they would not have access to in other PUSD schools ocss requires more effort more dedication and yes more funding than what the current School Board may be capable of delivering can the school board effectively govern and fund a school with a learning culture of what's next while simultaneously governing the mered of schools reaching for the Common Core Baseline standards I would suggest that the answer to that discussion is no thank [Applause] you Beth well I would love to address some of the misconceptions related to the finances I did that with our advisory Council and opened that to up our parent community so the way that I want to spend this 51 seconds is I would like to give acknowledgement to our incredible staff if your staff member at ocss please stand [Applause]
083yeah when people say Beth Fischer has a lot to gain from this I've already told you I've gained everything that I possibly can and it's right here in this room being a part of their lives you can have a seat if you are a student please Dan I love you and thank you for taking an active go parents I'm not going to have you stand because with my last 8 seconds I want to say thank you to my family and to my best friends who have uplifted our school in this process you have sacrificed for our kids and I love you thank [Applause] you you make me follow that come on um 15y resident of yal Linda proud parent of an ocss student We are firste family in PUSD because our our daughter loves this
084school what I want to talk today about about today though is clarifying some misunderstandings that really bother me due to the lack of knowledge of the subject people say ocscs is taking money away from other campuses are either disingenuous or just clueless about what's going on sure ocscs will have their own budget based on number of kids but that is all they get nearly all the funds that allocated to ocss in this model simply cover the normal day-to-day operating costs and writing paychecks that would happen regardless of the budget model What's Happening Here is p USD is capping how much money it can come from the district to ocscs if ocscs wants a new facility or project P py LS or you know whatever that is they'll say that's nice go fund it yourself this
085is doing thank you [Applause] good evening I'm Judy de jardan I'm here as a grandmother um and what I want to talk about tonight is about the administrative leave um I feel that these individuals could have still been working while the investigation was uh um began um I think that I'm concerned about the extra workload that this uh is putting on the people that have to step in and um do wear two hats now also um I think um I mean this is America people are innocent until proven guilty um and I my vote is to reinstate all and continue on with your investigation also tonight I did talk I do support the um charter school and the reason I went to see and took the tour was because of the rumors that were being
086spread thank [Music] you next four speakers um Joshua Lane Leanne Perez Erica Perez and Phil sites I'm Joshua Lane uh I spoke in front of you guys earlier today and I had a whole speech written for it today I'm just here to speak from my heart right now this little girl right here is her future right there that's this is her past right here and ocscs provides that she was able to do it and succeed without ocscs and what it does is it makes it easier and it enlightens our kids and it brings our kids to where she is earlier she that girl right there could be her boss one day all of the kids at ocss deserve that opportunity and I watch some of you smile which means I know you guys are all
087human you may not act like it sometimes when you try to take funding away or stop our kids' growth but you all know what's right to do in this little girl's future and my daughter over there and every sing single one of the kids at ocscs deserve what we're asking for and to take that away from them or not give it to them you all should be the ones who are not in office anymore thank [Applause] [Music] you my name is El PR I'm an e8th grade da student ocss I'm here tonight to tell you about positive impacts I've seen since becoming a charer school in this model of learning I'm able to have a voice and I can say what I think about changes in my school and give feedback to my principal I'm
088doing much better in my class and I have support from not only my teachers but my counselors at Aban on campus I'm having a hard time seeing why my school gets so much hate because we are different than other middle schools my school is not only a great place to learn but a place where I'm able to collaborate with my fellow peers in class and also Foster friendships outside of class thank you that was my girl right there my name is Perez and I currently serve on the ocscs advisory Council I am a parent of I'm a PTA member and I'm also a parent of that D student I also have a second one that's in fourth grade at glenw um as ocscs brings forward this petition they are doing so to ensure that they
089have the funds that they would not otherwise have so that they can maintain and grow their programs having been part of the D program for 9 years we have seen the underfunding lack of care lack of follow through from the this district office as is as our students are preparing to promote to high school there are currently no plans in place for their high school studies my fear is that if OCS is not given the opportunity to have the oversight in partnership with the PUSD authorizing board then this Charter will end up like the Spanish daa program the exotic pet that everyone wanted but no one is taking care of it seems as though ocscs is falling into the same Trend at the same time it's a good idea to ensure that people thank you
090[Applause] you my name is Phil sites I am the history department chair at ocscs I am proud to be one of the first and original staff members to convert byms to ocscs we chose to tart Charter our school to implement teacher Clarity appr proven approach to improving student learning in our classrooms every lesson has clear goals with specified skills to practice and students understand the purpose behind what they're learning our instruction targets both corrective instruction when students need further support in their learning and enrichment when students are excelling every student has a chance to grow in their learning and Mastery skills this is all a very painstaking task I am proud of our Innova teaching methods this Charter revision is essential to us continuing our work without continued financial support and increasing support as we
091grow this will not work without char revision we cannot be confident that this will work next year the next four speakers Chris yep Jessa cono Sarah Gonzalez and [Music] Steve um Bon yep thank you good evening members of the board esteemed colleagues and honored guests my name is Chris parano and I'm an engineer and a teacher at the OCS Innovation lab our world is evolving rapidly and education really should evolve with it at ocss we are committed to Preparing students for the future that is far more complex and technological than we can even imagine throughout history Leaders with vision have faced doubt and skepticism but perseverance has always been key the progress we've made at ocss has already transformed students lives and sparked imaginations I've seen it firsthand let's not cut short these benefits please
092approve the ocss charter petition so we can continue providing our students with the tools and opportunities they need to grow and succeed in an everchanging world thank you [Applause] hi I'm Jess a parent of the district PTA member room parent and a proud campus supervisor at ocscs and I'm here representing my incredible security team the concern some have had was the number of Supervisors we have and our school would like I would like to address that concern I don't think anyone should put a price on the security of their child our job is to make sure the students are not only safe but also thriving each of us have a Zone in every area of that school in our in radio communication with one another and the office as we are there to work as
093a team support and protect what comes with our role is not only being watchful but also being there for the students to confide in as I walk through our campus every single day and greet the students and staff I just love the uplifting atmosphere and energy from each and every staff member and I am so proud to work at ocscs and support the students staff and our principal Dr be Fischer good evening everyone I'd like to start off by thanking trusty Frasier for spending his evening here with us my friend Bailey let me know that it was his birthday today um I can think of many other ways than spending a birthday here so thank you for that Mr Fraser um my name is Sarah Gonzalez I am the community liaison over at OC um
094the Orange County School of Computer Sciences I am not sure people have an understanding of what we are asking with this petition revision so I will be happy to share with you we do understand our school stay the same if it is denied however we put in the revision because we want to enhance our students experiences so ocss has a hard time understanding why this is even an issue as a py school we want to make it better and this will allow us to grow the Stu the school exponentially and not create more barriers for the incredible teachers who dedicate their time to change lives thank you hi my name is Steve V can you hear me okay with that hi my name is Steve aranan I'm a proud uh parent of two boys in
095the school system I attended Morris uh Kramer and Valencia Goa go Tigers uh currently I volunteer at ocscs and uh on the parent advisory also doing volunteer sometimes in the school um I've observed that uh Dr Fischer has created in a very short period of time with her staff and amazing place um I proudly served as a volunteer and I did so when the board unanimously picked uh ocscs to be the charter school um I eagerly roluna and her have done that I kindly ask that you create a governance that allows for best possible funding options for the school thereby benefiting the students if you'd like to ask me any questions I'm available thank hey next SC Noah um arthritis James tweet alique madanan Zachary ham Noah hello my name is Noah boltis and I
096a teacher at the Orange County School of computer science I'm incredibly grateful to work alongside Dr Beth Fischer and our administrative team there are a few things that make ocss unique and tonight I just wanted to discuss one of those aspects which is our professional work days every week departments are provided with a designated day to plan create and ass student work this is all thanks to our learning facilitators who lead engaging lessons with our students on our designated days because of this opportunity courel like teachers can collaborate so that on any given day if you walk through our Halls especially our uh English classrooms you would see the same units the same lessons and even the same strategies taught so that every student is given a high level of learning no matter who their
097teacher is again this is just one important aspect of what makes our school unique and I look forward to what we can accomplish with our new ch vision and the ability to apply for [Applause] Grants good evening my name is James tweet I'm a history and language arts teacher at ocscs I'm so glad to be here with you this evening and I'm also lucky to be here with a collection of colleagues students superiors and community members as I express my support for the charter revision at ocscs and the work that we are doing while it may be different I truly see the impact that it is making if you go here if you come see us I'm telling you I'm there every day I'm one student that's qu yes and very lucky to do so
098and there's a culture forming there and I'm so unique that I get to work with students of sixth seventh and eighth grade levels and um it's something special to go there and see this thing evolving there is a culture forming there um and I know that there are opinions we all know that but we all also know that there is work to do more work to do and you are welcome in my classroom anytime if you would like to see these benefits and the work that we are doing thank you very [Music] much good evening my name is Ali madanan and I've been a proud history teacher here in P in the P for the past 5 years this year I've also had the privilege of being Mentor for new teachers through our induction program
099where we focus on Excellence growth and using data to drive meaningful change tonight I'm here to urge you to approve this school's Charter revision petition the ocss is a school that brings our District's core values to life especially Innovation it's a place where teaching isn't Bound by tradition but inspired by creativity and grounded in research-based practices as someone who recently completed a graduate program at San Diego State focused on best practices in education I see how this school is taking research and putting it into action in ways that engage and Inspire both students and teachers this is exactly what we want for all of our schools a commitment to Excellence growth and Forward Thinking education I urge you to listen to the voices of those who are directly connected to ocss and support the continuation
100of this incredible school it is clear supporting the school means supporting what's best for our students thank you hi my name is Zachary H and I'm currently an innovation lab teacher at ocss as one of the original staff who helped convert byms into ocss I've been part of making the vision of our school happen I believe in creating a school where teaching methods weren't Bound by TR tradition but inspired students to think outside the box to create something new we as an innovation lab team are dedicated to bringing the highest quality of Education to students in our district I have poured my Blood Sweat and Tears into making the school one of the gems of PUSD supporting this petition ensures that the the work that not only myself but also my colleagues have devoted will
101not go to waste I know this plea could fall on deaf ears but please consider that the teachers at ocss have chosen this non-traditional way of teaching because our conviction is that the structure of the school is what will bring the most success to our students thank you next for Alexis um Char Wayne J Emily pondy Addison hello my name is Alexi Charlie chor and I been teaching for 11 years but this is my first year at ocss I left a secure position a place where I had permanent status because I believe in the power of creating a truly exceptional learning environment I saw a need for stability for consistent support systems that Empower both students and Educators I saw a need for opportunities for Innovative programs for access to resources that ignite curiosity and
102unlock unlimited potential this isn't just a job for me it's a mission I'm here to help build that dream to cultivate a school where every student feels valued challenged and supported I want to see us not just maintain this Vision but watch it flourish grow and Inspire generations to come thank [Applause] you good evening my name is Wayne I Am a p parent uh as well as a future ocscs parent um and I'd also like to say I am a product of charter schools uh when I was younger uh throughout High School I was actually at a charter school for three years and it definitely opened up my eyes to a different learning experience uh than traditional high schools would be um so I'll be the first to admit um business is my background not
103education uh but within business we we know that pivoting is something that is critical to a business um I I think that what's going on right now with ocscs is what's considered a pivot we understand that funding is not where it could or should be given the place of the district so giving them the opportunity to be more self-funded and be able to fund programs that would benefit the students directly is something that I think is critical uh another thing that I I I want to make sure that I point out uh for for clarity is the misinformation that that I continue to see I I know people have highlighted that uh throughout their speeches uh but it takes two seconds to become informed oh thank you thank you okay hello my name is Emily
104Pandy and I will be speaking on behalf of a teacher at ocss who couldn't be here tonight although I strongly believe with everything they said um they said I have worked at several districts four in particular in seven different schools during my career and none have been amazing and been as amazing as ocscs all the districts I have worked for preach the importance of research based education but none of the districts I have worked for have implemented research-based education to the level in which ocscs has committed the dedication to culture and fostering the feeling of belonging has been incomparable I'm excited to go to work I feel as though I am at my best and therefore can give my best to my colleagues and students and I can also attest with along with all of
105the rest of our staff how much we love our campus how much we love our principal and our admin and with the approval of the revision I know that we will be able to do even greater things next year thank you thank you hello my name is Addison floriano and I'm a seventh grade student at ocss I'm here today to support my school and principal and ask that you think about us when you vote tonight I love my school and teachers and pro and the programs that my school comes with and help me prepare for high school and college my fa favorite things about school are the new innovation lab many electives and teachers I love going to school every day and I have overcome so much in the the few months of going here
106I have more confidence than I thought I would have and that helps me even today standing up here talking to you thank you for letting me speak about my school and please think about us when you vote tonight thank you the next SC James Goodwin Kimmy May Don oy that for and William McCay hello good evening members of the board I'm a resident of Y Belinda and a lum of Bernardo Yorba and the dean of students at ocscs I stand before you today to request your approval for a revision to our Charter petition specifically regarding autonomous spending this revision is essential for us to access much-needed grants which will directly benefit our students and enhance our educational programs as a school focused on computer science having the flexibility to use these funds for resources such
107as software hardware and advanced learning tools is critical these grants will allow us to expand our curriculum giving our students the opportunity to engage with cuttingedge technology and develop the skills necessary for success in the 21st 21st century Workforce we've already seen significant growth in our students abilities and this additional funding will help us maintain and accelerate that progress our learning model thrives on Innovation and hands-on experience and with your support we can continue to provide our students with the best possible education and computer science this is a critical time in the life of our school this approval of this revision will not only thank you so much thank [Applause] you hello my name is Kimmy um it seems to me that Marilyn and Carrie are colluding to get Dr chernis and other staff out
108in order to cover up their illegal doings to hiring a new attorney who's costing us double as we already have an attorney but now the two of you need to go out and find one that's not privy to what you guys are doing Todd Robbins and Suki already don't have a good reputation in our community and hopefully they're smart enough to not risk their careers to save the two of you you say you want fiscal transparency yet we have seven administrators on indefinite leave to the tune of over for $5,000 a day they can't be present while you guys attempt to Strongarm the rest of the administrators and cover up the mess that you've created our district can't run efficiently there's nobody doing these jobs of these seven administrators audits filings paperwork phone calls aren't
109being returned to me um nothing's being done with these tasks um Renee gray might be in on this as well who knows um our District's fallen so much in the last month since you've become president Maryland you're an embarrassment to our district um you're so Hellen onover covering up all these messes thank you very much that you don't look out good evening my name is Don OA um first I stand before you as a pyl graduate myself knowing that I would have excelled so much more in school Under the Mastery based grading and far-reaching opportunities of ocscs I also stand before you as an ocss teacher who has seen firsthand the success students are having as they shift from valuing learning through points and letters that just live on a piece of paper to actual
110skills that they can Define and use across content areas I believe we are truly changing lives and I also left a permanent position because I saw the good that we could do with this program the work we are doing is not easy it takes so much behind the scenes and having an autonomous budget structure would allow us to continue our professional workday which leads to all students receiving instruction that draws on the strengths of all teachers from that department that's an amazing thing to offer students lastly and truly most importantly to me I stand before you as a mother of a young daughter and uh like was spoken there um I know she's going to change the world someday and in improving this revision you had the chance to open doors and Empower kids like
111her thank you so [Applause] much all right thank you guys for your time my name is William McKay and I'm a first year history teacher at ocscs one of the reasons I was excited to join the ocss team this year is because Dr Fischer has a school that's based in student centered research-based practices these approaches have created a system that Fosters student growth for both High Achievers and students who are still developing their skills our school is very highly collaborative I have the ability to meet with other members of my department make common assessments make common learning goals and create scaffolds for students with various learning needs the result of these things are positive comments we've continue to hear from the community for months now however to continue growing and offering this Innovative approach it's
112crucial that we transition to an autonomous Charter structure no one understands the needs of the ocscs students better than the staff here and an autonomous structure will allow us to meet the needs of those students this change will also provide us with greater control over our resources allowing us to continue to develop the kind of student- centered research back practices that set our school apart in the community if you want to do what's best for students that's the way to go thank you [Applause] next four speakers Jess pagia Ben stubs Amanda given and Steve sofka good evening Board of Trustees my name is Jess pagley and I'm a lifelong resident of Y Belinda former PUSD student and father of three currently enrolled in the district my wife and I have two Elementary School age daughters
113at Travis and our youngest is youngest daughters in the special ed program at Fairmont between us two parents we're actively involved in PTA both schools and we collectively serve on three parent advisory boards ocscs has been a welcome addition to the community and as a parent of younger children this has given me and my wife something very um serious to think about for our daughters Mrs Buck I've spoken with you about my daughter and you graciously shared your family's background in special education uh Mrs Gray you've served as a director of special education and as a parent I thank you from the bottom of my heart for your advocacy for special ed students and all students as we St in our home our crystal ball is broken we do not know what our daughter daughter
114will need and when she will need it however with the attention to detail and emersion program for special ed students at ocss it would be phenomenal for it to be an option for us and for our daughter when it comes time please be considered a considerate of the charter revision thank you so much [Applause] W good evening board staff and Community uh Ben stubs PUSD parent on the day before Christmas Eve at 11:00 a.m. parent Anderson emailed every parent in the district announcing Dr Alex chernis had been placed on administrative leave this tarnished his reputation and created an aura of Scandal around an excellent superintendent the email stated quote we understand this decision may arise of questions and concerns end quote I believe Anderson's intent was clear to so doubt about Dr CH chernes without
115first conducting an investigation which has still not commenced ocss families should also remember that Anderson's voting record on May 7th 2024 she voted no on funding The Innovation Labs a project designed to Foster creativity and academic growth she also voted no on purchasing signapore math textbooks and other essential materials for OCS CS students Anderson's decisions reflect a troubling pattern of opposing in iives that directly benefit students in the community and most important our family and our children thank you good evening I the proud assistant principal at ocscs I'm a resid of Y blinda and better yet a future ocscs parent my husband and I specifically moved to Y blinda to raise our children because of the wonderful schools prior to my role at ocscs I worked as a math teacher and a director of the
116UC math project where we trained Math teachers in grades TK through 12 throughout Southern California I left this dream job to specifically work in my community I've seen a lot of teachers at a lot of different schools over my past 15 years in education and I've never seen a school where all teachers are on the same page at once at ocscs all teachers love working here and they all they hold all students accountable with clear learning intentions and success criteria this is teacher clarity at its finest it's truly beautiful to watch every day we need this autonom autonomous funding to be able to access grants that we can no longer otherwise access to continue to build these great programs that everyone's speaking [Applause] of good evening my name is Steve sofin I'm a taxpayer not
117merely a guest here Mrs Anderson you ran for a re-election under this bner save our schools exactly what you were you intending to save us from was it an increase in District enrollment was it improving test scores or was it simply the creation of OCS and the maintenance of it perhaps the most Innovative school this district has ever experienced staffed by the finest education professionals you'll find either here or in any other District around you were elected to be here for the kids but let's be honest the chaos you've rained down on this District including this school shows how you do not care about them at all and you're failing them their families and this entire Community you're far too busy doing nothing but being the intellectually challenged puppet pushing the agenda of your union
118boss puppeteers we're fed up and our kids are paying the price for your corrupt and incompetent arrogance if you really want to save our schools stop insulting Us by presenting your care and resign this evening thank you for your time thank you next four speakers Donovan Nick Sam Mueller and Diane Hansen hello board members thank you so much for the opportunity to speak um I thought uh Mrs Gray made a point comment when she said let's seek unity and I think we should do that here and approve this uh Vision to the Charter cuz my daughter goes to that school every day super excited the only person with more enthusiasm is this lady right here Dr fiser and she's busted her buns to turn this school from something it wasn't to something that it is
119and it's got more work to do take the shackles off of this woman let her get the money she needs you're going to get a percentage of it anyway when they pay you for the administration so you're getting money for free give her the freedom to grow that school and finish what she started all she's asking to do is to let her work harder to provide more for these kids and these students and in the community thank you so much for your [Applause] time my name is Nick and I'm here to um read for a teacher for ocss for those of you who have not visited ocss one of the most positive and student geared method is the ad adoption of the udl Universal Design learning framework at ocss you have new and Veteran teachers
120that organize and Implement a udl curriculum with tools and strategies that benefit student Learners with this type of framework no student has to leave the classroom to access the this curriculum these tools are provided throughout the learning process to improve engagement remove barriers to learning thank [Applause] you hello my name is Sam Mueller as a former student of byms I'm here today to Champion the students who may not have a voice in this room I know the value of a supportive School environment and now as someone responsible for supporting the Next Generation I'm deeply invested in their success um it's perplexing that efforts of bringing our schools up to speed with technology and Innovation are met with resistance ocss isn't just asking for more they're committed to doing more with % of their staff dedicated
121to this Mission their clear pathway to securing additional resources for our students deserves our full support I know that when I was a student I would have loved the opportunity to attend ocscs let's set aside our differences and prioritize what truly matters ensuring the best possible future for our students thank you [Applause] Diane Hansen not here okay moving on the next four is Marissa mallerie um Mike Wier Paul barus and Mark s s SA are you ready Mrs Anderson I'm ready okay I'd actually like your attention I know you don't like to give that to everyone as they come up and speak just like you're not doing now my name is Marissa mallerie during the public comments before Clos session I handed truste blades a copy of the parent and initiated petition in support of
122ocscs I did this on behalf of parents who wish to wait who wish to remain anonymous to avoid retaliation against themselves or their children that should say a lot about this board and leadership in this District since the printing of that petition earlier today the petition is now at 1,343 signatures and growing by the minute I would expect you to look at me as I'm speaking please listen to the P community and do the right thing and approve the revision of this Charter petition and again just everyone notice Miss Anderson cannot look any of us in the eye [Applause] Mike my grandson and my granddaughter attended Santiago CH Charter Middle School and they loved it today I opened up the Orange County register and saw that the surf Brands like Billabong Roxy Quicksilver and Vol
123vcam are all failing miserably and they are being sold off bought by investment companies no one from the surf Community guide them decisions made millions of miles away no finger on the pulse no idea what's going on at retail Executives making the decisions while sitting in a luxury desk chair they lost touch I find a parallel here tonight how can two of you in good conscience vote on the fate of this school without having set foot on the grounds this is not what leaders do true leaders are informed and it appears that many of you are not or some of you are not in contrast to two of you my wife and I have stepped foot and had a jaw-dropping and Incredibly eye- opening wakeup call to what education could look like personally with Dr
124Beth Fischer and met with numerous teachers ocscs is mindblowing personally I think the two of you should recuse yourselves from voting as you have no clue what this school is all about I think it's the right thing to do and you're right Miss Anderson doesn't pay attention to anybody and that's [Applause] proud Paul hello my name is Paul baras and I'm proud to work at ocss the work there is allow me to do what I do best support students in ways that truly matter as an intervention teacher I lead an Innovative program that helps students take ownership of their actions and their learning this teaches them accountability and resilience skills that will serve them far beyond the classroom I also run academic support identifying students who are falling behind and working with them one-on-one to
125help help them improve and succeed with my master's degree in social emotional learning I'm able to ensure that every student feels included valued and seen this holistic approach to educa education creates an environment where students can Thrive both academically and socially this school gives me the ability to focus on what truly matters the growth and success of every single student that's something politics should never interfere with this is why I believe that approving the revised Charter is in the best interest of ocss and our students as it will provide access to the grants and specialized funding we need to carry out the mission thank you so much next you Mark Mark yeah flipping too many cards quickly no problem hello Mark Sarver I'm a 14-year resident of your Belinda a head coach for 12 of
126those years Sports League board member schedule for the league painter of fields fixer of scraped up knees and general proponent and supportive of all the kids in our neighborhood I'm also a concerned parent of two kids currently at ocss and a third that promoted from byms and remains in the PUSD district one minute is not long enough to present any of the facts not sure they would matter anyways given the private sessions that our members are not allowed to be a part of uh I am here today to testify as to my experience of being the proud father of three kids that have objectively and consistently performed performed well they are served and thriving in their education at ocss it is my personal testimony that Dr fiser has proven to me to be a powerful
127and effective servant leader at the school it is further my testimony that the staff and teachers at the school are going above and beyond anything we could hope for as community members and deserve recognition I support our school's dependent Charter and the instruction my children are receive thank you so much [Applause] okay the next four that it yeah that what it says Sarah cabier Kathy Binger Apollo Sue Sawyer Don Miller okay sorry de okay as a mom whose children have promoted from byms and a future student who doesn't fit the typical learning profile students look like ocss in my our my lifeline I was thankful for byms did my it did my typical kids I'm thankful for what byms did for my typical kids but what ocss does for those who break the mold May
128provide a different trajectory for their lives this is a school where the belief that every student deserves a great teacher is not left to chance but it's a core value all where special education is seen as a service not a place ocss has a commitment to full inclusion makes a world of difference not just in academics but skilled development but in fostering a true sense of belonging sorry this school normalizes that all students can Will can and will learn in the staff's unwavering belief and Alignment in this Mission have earned them the well-deserved recognitions more importantly they serve as a as to how all Learners can Thrive as a mom of a child with an identi identified disability i w know I won't have to fight for my son to belong thank you good evening
129my name is Kathy bendero poloo I have two kids in the district my daughter is at ocss I'm here today urging you to be leaders we can be proud of board members you were elected to these position positions because your constituents believe that you could aptly represent them putting aside your personal ideals we parents staff community members and most importantly students deserve to see a collaborative effort between the board and school lead leadership this should not be a place for political motivations power plays or retaliation as one me board member recently told me retaliation at this point will only cause more damage to our already broken Community it's time for you to put aside all of and focus on the best interests of our students I'd like to remind everyone that the establishment of ocscs
130was the direct initiative of PUSD in order to keep the competitive Charters at Bay Dr fiser and her team did exactly what was asked of them with little time to spare at the end of the day we have them to thank for saving Bernardo period and with the exception of truste cantero all of you voted for it and supported it now we need you to stand by your decisions thank [Applause] you my name is Sue Sawyer Renee mentioned wanting to rebuild trust however she knowingly and willingly took over a colleague's job that ultimately forced him out of his job why would Renee gray be named as an interim superintendent and now Acting Superintendent it's hard to trust someone that ask to be protected from being let go even for cause Maya Angelou says when someone
131shows you who they really are believe them I'd also like to ask about the payments and delivery of the equipment for the training lab under RFP number 22415 the contract specifies over 1.2 million for equipment including items for the metabolic Testing Lab CrossFit training room weight room Speed and Agility area and mats I'm concerned because these payments were made prior to receiving invoices has all the equipment promised under this contract been delivered to PUSD will we continue to follow the contract to not to not make further payments until we receive invoices from training lab why would it be pulled into the charter the curriculum at the charter is great it's something we use at valad as well thank you a large majority of Opp Don Miller I just want to say too the board did
132approve ocscs and it sounds like it's a wonderful school but was also approved as a district Charter and you can get grants maybe not the one grant that you're asking for but there are multiple grants that are available federal and state and local that you can use news I believe our board will support your school and they will support Innovation just like they support our schools every one of them that could come here today and probably share some of the great things that are going on but why are we going to lose the control and that is a real big concern there a financial impact we have accountability concerns you haven't even been a school for a whole year we have Equity issues it could prioritize certain student populations leaving higher need students in the
133district District runs schools and we are also could be competing now for students we brought on the charter school so that we could get our enrollment up for the district thank you you next four speakers Nelly Raphael I think it's Ari casperson Cameron KU b b basa um uh Caba who's that Caba Pam hello um I strongly support the reinstatement of our superintendent Dr chernes Deputy superintendent Dr Gates and other administrators who are unfairly targeted due to political retaliation our superintendent has been instrumental in implementing Innovative initiatives that have set ocscs apart from other schools it is unfortunate that his leadership has been politicized at the expense of our students under Dr chinis and Dr Gates our school has thrived by embracing change and fostering a culture of excitement for Learning and that does not
134ex exclude Dr Fisher this Visionary leadership has created a foundation of excellence and Innovation that our community takes pride in reinstating our superintendent will ensure the consistency and expansion of these Innovative programs let's continue this momentum for the benefit of our students and their future reinstate Dr chernes and Dr Gates we admire you Dr fiser for everything you do for this community as well I personally admire you and we all love you hi my name is Craig casperson uh and I hated school when I was a kid uh so when my son was born 10 years ago I made a promise to him to myself and to every kid who dreads coming to school every morning that I do everything in my power to create a better system of education system that values community over
135Conformity critical thinking over compliance where students feel safe and seen and reconnected with the drive to learn about their world that is inherent in all kids before they enter most public schools unfortunately most paths I've tried over the last 15 years to keep that promise has all too often been impeded by a seemingly endless amount of red tape but when Dr Beth MF Fisher shared her vision with me I knew I was where I needed to be through her leadership and the dedication of the incredible staff at ocss I found a real opportunity to keep that promise if you're still wondering why this petition was submitted I ask you to take a look around the room and see how many of my colleagues are here because of their dedication to a shared Vision they aren't
136at home with their families or getting some well deserved rest after spending a full day with hundreds of young teenagers don't here because we doing [Applause] it my name is Cameron kubisak and I am I am a sixth grader at Orange County School of computer science I know this hasn't been said yet but I'm here to support my principal Dr Fischer she's already made a difference in my life she's opening so many do for me and my future she listens to students and all of our concerns for example she's trying to get different programs into our school because so many students want one she protects her students when something happens like bullying or other personal issues I love the different mini electives we have at ocscs and how I'm learning to be how to be
137a leader I believe in Dr Fisher and I believe in this school the heartbeat of this school is Dr Fisher so don't ruin it thank you hi everyone with our children at the heart of this message I stand before our community and its elective Representatives as an obvious ocscs supporter I'm also a parent of an ocscs student and a volunteer on campus within a mini elective I understand somewhat the scrutiny surrounding the creation and funding of P's finest Charter School doing what is ethical and empirically supported can be a unique challenge in the field of Education I'm sure you're all aware of that I've utilized various trustworthy sources to understand that autonomy for ocscs will strengthen us as a district as a community and as Neighbors when we adopt the charter revision the placenti or
138Belinda Unified School District will win thank you so much for your [Applause] time Pam maybe I'll provide a much needed break um I want to talk about ASB um I have nothing against the organization itself I don't have anything against the contract that's on on your agenda but there always seemed to be something unfair and discriminatory about ASB are there any other organizations in the school district where you incentivize parents to fund ASB and then give them discounts on the yearbook or football tickets Etc um why can't why can't parents have the option of funding something else and get a discount on the yearbook um do parents actually pay into to ASB once their kid is part of that program I'm sure there are a lot of parents who funded you know something on the
139dance team or a football team or basketball team who'd like a break on paying other fees um especially when their kids sat on the bench or didn't get to participate so to me there just seems to be something unfair about how ASB is funded thank you next four speakers lesie Alexander Shanny Murray Crystal Noel and Ellie my name is lesie Alexander I would like to begin by saying what a pleasure it is to see Ila as our student board member when Lea was a student at WMS I knew that her hard work commitment to Excellence and her kind heart would serve her well congratulations Lea this is well deserved secondly I would like to submit that ocscs remain a district Charter under the oversight of the PUSD board the rushed application for conversion to an
140independent Charter should be rejected as it is missing required components additionally USI should not be included in any proposal as it is a district asset that has cost the districts millions of dollars also the proposal should not include any component that that undermines the current program at Parkview School furthermore the charter school should be able to demonstrate over time that it can maintain its enrollment that it can operate with a functional master schedule that does not require a large amount of substitute teachers on a daily basis that addresses poent thank [Applause] you Shanny Murray uh it sounds to me like ocscs is off to a great start in p so I don't understand how making it an independent Charter and taking USI with it benefit PUSD the district you're supposed to represent how can giving
141away a school be in the best interest of our local students I have been part of the P family for almost 20 years and there's always been a tremendous sense of community I truly believe ocscs has more opportunity for continued success by remaining in the district and leveraging P wealth of knowledge and resources I hope you as a board engage with the charter students families teachers and staff to learn how best to support them but I trust you can find that support within P if this board has the best interest of P students at heart and if it can put aside partisan politics then I see no reason not to vote in favor of maintaining ocscs and USI unity and P is working together not walking away you got it I have a dream that
142I can go to OC s s yes so please support OC s yes because good is in our hearts I like go yes yes yes his things because they they have things I love us yes yes is in always ways thank you [Applause] so cute um hi Crystal Noble mother of three in the district um regarding ocss our district Charter which will remain our district Charter provides incredible opportunities um for our kids we have a unique opportunity support its continue growth I want to express my gratitude to the staff for their dedication Hands-On learning um skills-based instruction and Project based learning opportunities and especially to Dr Fischer who has poured her heart and soul into the school what ocss has accomplished hasn't been easy and they deserve our full support these changes will open the
143door for more funding which directly translates to more opportunities for our students our focus should remain on giving our children the best possible access to Quality education let's stand together to ensure ocss can continue to thrive for the benefit of our students this opportunity will benefit our district as the do as the school as the school has promised to be one of the best charter schools in California I want us to be known for the greater learning opportunities our district provides please vote to approve these changes thank [Applause] you okay next for Sonoma Debbie Bender Chelsea Kaiser and Mark Holtz good evening I'm here to advocate for kids not just ocscs I want to advocate for kids to learn at their own level I wish you would ask what kids like me want we are
144the Next Generation and we want to learn the way OCS teaches thank you [Applause] sorry my name is Debbie vanderly our twin boys met astronaut Mark Kelly when they were five since then they wanted to become astronaut just like Mark Kelly and his twin brother Scott the very first time we heard Dr Fisher Dr Fisher talk about ocscs is vision and future our boys say this is where they can start their journey of of become becoming engineers and eventually astronauts we live in fingon we drive our boys across Tower every day to be a cscs that's an investment we are willing to make ocscs is an investment in the PUSD but in order to fulfill its Vision it needs a greater investment than this board is capable of providing please vote Yes for ocscs to
145be autonomous in order for the school to apply for the grants that they will fully fund our school SCH initiatives support our students enabling their dedicated teachers to grow the next generation of Engineers astronauts and more I hope you all thank you so [Applause] much all right here we go hi my name is Chelsea Kaiser I'm a parent of a sixth grader at ocss and have been a parent in the PUSD School District since my child was 3 years of age I want to come and share with you our positive experience in being able to reach kids with different learning needs and special education students my son is on an IEP and is doing well at ocss their flexible schedule and learning model has allowed for my son to effectively get accommodations and services that
146he needs without being pulled from classes the unique skill-based and master based learning that is used to monitor student progress helps to identify more specifically where his strengths and weaknesses lie providing a reference uh a reference for targeted intervention for not just my kids but all of the kids the amazing Administration positive learning culture teacher dedication enthusiasm flexibility with the school day focus on full inclusion and commitment to helping children that learn differently makes this school a huge asset to PUSD I feel honored to get to be a part of it and so happy that PUSD has brought this school into existence I hope the board will continue to support the Innovative school by voting in ways that will allow the school to flourish PUSD and ocscs had the potential to be champions [Applause] my
147name is Mark halty I'm a business owner and my wife and I have four kids that have either gone through the district or are in schools I think we all do want unity and I think we're all tired of divisive politics and things like that and the sad thing was that during the election there was uh people that were obviously not focused on the kids but focused on Power and slander and character assassinations and things like that but what's encouraging is even though then people were saying oh that school is horrible and the people don't like the principal and the te and all the teachers are are miserable and all these things but we have the truth here with all the people and the kids coming up here especially saying how they love the school
148and they look forward to learning there and and the teachers that are doing great and the principal that's doing awesome and that's what we need and this computer thing it's not a fad it's it's kind of like gonna gonna keep on [Applause] going next four speakers Samantha yeah French um speli mayic Cruz H and Ryan Lynn hi my name is Dr Samantha French I am a Community member a parent a neuropsychologist and on the advisory council at ocss uh I want to talk to you first and foremost as a parent uh my son's been in school with PUSD uh since kindergarten he hacked your school's firewall in second grade he Rick he rickrolled your entire principal School list last year and uh he's not neurodivergent he's not neurotypical he's a 12-year-old boy whose to be
149goal is to be Sigma um and he learns a little bit differently he didn't thrive in school in fact during fifth and sixth grade he was bullied endlessly he was sexually harassed and nothing was done he feels safe at ocss he feels that he's learning his executive functioning has skyrocketed uh he can problem solve he can use judgment and now he wants to be a lawyer so he can argue and get paid for it um I will say as a neuropsychologist however allowing the school to do their own grants puts expertise where expertise lies and that's in Dr fiser as a PhD I also know about writing grants and it takes a special skill to seek out these grants and I have faith Dr fiser can do that thank you as an advisory council member
150at OCS CS I've seen incredible things one of the most inspiring moves has been proving that special education is a isn't a place it's a service special education doesn't mean segregated classes to sustain sustain the success at ocscs they must become an autonomous Charter to qualify for critical grant fundings that they don't aren't currently um accessible to signif this significantly increases the res resources for the whole District why would you want to limit their growth why wouldn't you want money that's going there that can come to the rest of the district you're limiting everyone if you don't want this to happen please vote Yes to approve the revised Charter petition and as Renee gray said restore our trust and bring back Dr chernis and Dr Gates and the other people that you have put under
151investigation they can work while you're doing your thing to look at what they're doing we are all innocent until proven guilty I urge you to make a change thank you so much hello good evening my name is Mari Cruz HTI and I just wanted to uh remember that you know technology is super I mean moves so much I want to ask you how many times have you changed your phone your computer because evolves so fast so if um the charter has the possibility of getting more grants then because these kids are going to be our leaders we're going to we're getting older and we need to have those kids well prepared to help us with the new challenges we're going to have so if we can have unity and think about what is the best
152for our students what's the best for our kids thank you so much have a good [Applause] night hello I'm Ryan Lynn and I'm a recent 2024 IB graduate of Luna I'm here today because I am concerned about the petition for uh ocscs as an independent Charter what I'm not doing is discounting the work by ocscs faculty I am alarmed at about the lack of transparency by OCS SS and USI I urge for fiscal transparency and accountable spending in this board as a p p uh alumni I know the amount of good we can do when we invest in our education and teachers I wouldn't be able to thrive today without the advice and guidance my teachers have given me by allowing the conversion to an independent Charter this District loses the millions of ADA funding
153and obscures the potential mismanagement of District leadership over the past few years moreover PRL will be giving away millions in equipment to an independent Charter and all the equipment from The Innovation lab and USI by making these rush and Brash decisions without full uh financial and administrative transparency we drive away the amazing faculty and families and reject our most fundamental principle of putting kids [Applause] first next four speakers Alyssa Wong David and Scott Sheba hello my name is Alyssa and I'm a proud Von IB and Val grad from Valencia uh congratulations Leila I'm I'm a current computer science major and I firmly believe that computer science is the future however I am concerned about the OCS cs's Charter Pro process I worry that ocscs is hastily pivoting to an independent status when its place in
154the district does not seem to be clear here ocscs has not kept its initial promises while constantly changing its identity and by becoming independent we lose the money invested into the program and uh we should continue I believe that we should continue supporting the students there but not at the cost of the majority and the other students that are currently in uh PUSD I believe that sorry I believe that ocss can remain as a public charter or turn into a magnet uh thank you all for your time thank you David Dave radlauer we keep hearing about misinformation by the same people who are pedaling it no one is trying to close down the ocscs stop telling us that stop telling the board that and stop telling your children that that is not on the agenda
155tonight we're hearing words like mind-blowing incredible amazing life-changing impactful something special inspiring thriving students all of those all of those adjectives have been achieved at the ocscs as a district run Charter this is putting the cart before the horse we haven't even been there a year we made a two-year commitment let's see if the if the model continues if it does we can consider changes at this point with a deficient position requiring anou we're we're being Hasty and we're putting assets and students at risk the nobody I have yet to hear anybody talk about the benefits of adding the USI and the charter and the thank you independent study program Scott good evening Scott Sheba parent of a third grader at glenv here um I'm not here to speak in support of or against the
156independent Charter I just want to at the financial implications of the charter as it's written right now uh as mentioned by few the speakers it's not really clear why this revision calls for absorbing the USI into this Charter uh as we saw from last month's interm financial report the costs of that program are not yet fully known uh we just had a discussion last month about how $30,000 worth of couches and having to put limits on purchases over $220,000 which seem to be happening all too regularly uh as a parent of a DA student at Glen viw that makes me a potential future parent of the school and I would worry would happen to the other programs like da music Etc that that be limited by the Ada from only ocss students not being sufficient
157to absorb the financial burden of this program uh especially uh if we're not able to find these grants that everyone keeps talking about so I would only ask for those people be careful what you wish for because you might run out of money and if the board does choose to approve this petition um please move the daa program to a different school that doesn't Force us into a charter than you okay that concludes our public comment and I think we're going to take a 10minute break okay I call this meeting back to order at 8:42 um at this time we'll ask ask um Dr Beth Fischer principal of Orange County School of computer science to come up and give her presentation actually what she says might I think the reason why I want to question
158this so much is in the effort of being in unity and transparency and so can I just say without the timer I need to clarify something Renee gray not everybody actually has been very supportive of this charter school and so as Renee is taking on a new role I need everybody I need my oces community to hear me very clearly Renee gray has been one of the few vocal and consistent champions for this school and for me so I need that clarified regardless of what happened I need you to hear she is a champion okay okay we need to move on with our meeting so if you want to do your presentation Now app I want to voice my concern okay because I have had two legal attorneys advise me pro bono and what I
159am concerned about is the good faith effort and that there is a lack of fairness towards our Charter School especially when there is a separate attorney who has been hired and in the words of that attorney create a common enemy to the board so I am more than happy at the end of the day I just want to be here to answer your questions I think the public comment was very clear um it's going to be really hard for me to say other than this I'll point out key facts okay when we talk about not being supportive to the Charter and people who are some of the findings that were presented in December have to do with our original petition so I am questioning why were those not brought up last year were those brought
160up now because people want to make it difficult for this Charter and with the 9ine minutes left I'm going to become a teacher right now okay so we're going to do a little bit of check for understanding turn and talk to your partners for no more than 15 seconds by making these changes if they are approved are we an independent Charter or we a dependent Charter turn and talk to your neighbors okay please stand up if your partner said dependent Charter okay you will notice that the these are the people who have taken the time to get informed we did not make the request to become an independent Charter so as people keep on saying I don't want it to be an independent Charter I don't want it to be an independent Charter I don't
161want it to be an independent Charter those of you who stood know we are only asking to change our funding structure go ahead and have a seat so let's check for understanding because I know that sometimes we need to hear it in different ways by requesting these changes give me and no other fingers we do teach Middle School give me a thumbs up if this change results in US remaining a dependent Charter a thumbs down if we become independent let's check for understanding thank you now that 100% of us and if you see a friend who did not raise their hand because they're shy let them know they can have the courage to speak in the class and please make sure that you correct them the other thing too I presented to my advisory Council
162every bit of funding that was represented and approved by the board board so we based on the accounting of people who are no longer here the total startup cost for o was $1.38 million $1.38 million not that much so what I hear this board saying okay or I should say I heard one person say nothing will change so what I'm walking away from hearing is that this board regardless of if they want to let us have additional access to funding and that's completely your choice I hear that this board is going to make the commitment that we still get to fund a Ada I'm going to make the request that we actually enter into anou for that because I don't want in two years one of you to be gone and then say oh I
163don't know if we're going to do this anymore as the state of California tightens their belt and as we bring in more Ada I am the principal of this school the parents want me to advocate for more more improved tools learning everything so do I like being demonized for being in this position but guess what you kind of got to have a thick chin to be able to do it so yes I will stand here and Advocate day after day after day for our children the other thing that I want to address and then I'm going to look to some of my staff what are some of the other misinform that we keep hearing want it teachers don't want it okay you guys step je am I am I torturing you like my goodness um
164the other thing too I want to address some misinformation and I do recognize to our retired Educators to those of you who put in so many different years I'm grateful for your years of service when I hear let's take P back I often question because my husband and I went to UC San Diego and we went to college with people who graduated here when esper was in their Glory Days prec CST okay nobody's taken away the greatness of this District I am from the 909 my husband is from the bay area and we know esparon a football now I have to ask you guys what do you want to be known for right now in 2025 because I'm going to tell you we are it's embarrassing I sent out a letter to this board and
165to my advisory Council the foremost leaders of Education sent letters of support for this school and why did they send letters of support for this school because they ultimately know because one of the three of them runs their own independent Charter they ultimately know when Charters are given the opportunity to access funds they can do incredible things my mentor runs a charter school an independent one reminder we are dependent Charter recursive learning is very important important guys we can always revisit what we've learned we are a dependent Charter I want to be able to like my mentors do bring in $3 million annually I heard some misinformation that needs to be clarified oh you can get Charters uh you can get grants no matter what in your structure I am more than happy or do
166a PR it's not going to be the first time people do it to me do a PR you will find in my email from the charter division that we were denied grants because of our budgeting structure department chair Phil sites dep department chair Michelle dater were on the in the room with me when I was on the phone with the charter division for a second time hi I really want to make sure don't really want to go through this pain Beth you are eligible for a minimum of $800,000 turn around and resubmit this was the reader of the application turn around and resubmit those documents you'll get at least a minimum of $800,000 now additionally I'm also not new at this game I hired CTE credential teachers let's give a shout out to our CTE
167teachers over here at the middle school level that's right you too Noah that makes you additional eligible for additional funding in addition to this please go ahead and Google the unprecedented funds that are going to be going to Charter Schools this year $93 million between now the spring they're about to release and June 30 there is the potential to have two funding cycles for charter schools with an autonomous or independent budget structure so I recognize I'm telling you guys it's like a full-time job to keep up with the changes of the charter schools I would question if any of you and frankly the one person who is an expert on Charter Schools is on leave right now so I am questioning why when there we don't have a desire to be in competition we do
168not have a desire to be in competition and yes am I speaking here firm do I get criticism because I am a strong female leader oh yeah I get lots of criticism for being a strong female leader but I do not want this community Bamboozled I do not want this community misled I do not want this community up in arms anymore I don't want an attorney to stand here and say that we can't overcome anything that's in a finding because it's simply not true La UniFi does it often there is a lot of charters in La there is nothing preventing us from working together besides will so I am standing here asking you okay it's not about me my husband asked me this key question babe it's not looking like it's ending well read the
169writing on the wall so I'm going to ask you a question would you do it all over again and you want to know what my answer is I don't actually care what happens to me I don't actually care what anybody says about me or what is posted because in order to make change you have to be willing to do difficult things and over and over and over again I will fight for my kids I will fight for you Maddie I don't know if Jen's still here I don't know if the boys are I will fight for you baby girl you are worth it you are worth it the kids are worth it parents when we have to do difficult things together you are worth it none of you drive me I love you guys I
170love you I'm literally screening my emails today to see our parents talking to me about real things today so all I am asking is that we can take I'm telling you right now as leader I will bring notoriety to PUSD this is my district I live here a Your Belinda realtor sold me my home my children go to these schools I don't understand why this is being so adversarial it's time let stop let's go together and let's bring notoriety to this District [Applause] okay now at this time we have legal counsil here to speak um Suki just my computer just went to sleep for a second good evening members of the board members of the community Suki alalia from Atkinson Anderson um and I'm here to provide the board with um with an opportunity to
171um I'm here to provide the board with the information about the material revision that's been submitted and also to provide you with information about some of the ramifications from the modifications that are being requested um first of all as was um stated at the beginning of this meeting by the board president if the material revision is denied by The District board tonight the charter school will still continue to operate in accordance with the provisions of the charter petition that was um approved in December 2023 so there is nothing that is on the agenda tonight whereby the charter petition excuse me the charter school would be closed the only thing that's being requested is that material revisions be approved I'd like to talk to you a little bit about the process for material revisions what has
172happened so far and then discuss some of the actual revisions that are proposed when a material re so a charter petition is essentially a document between the district and the charter school that defines the and responsibilities of each um back when the charter schools Act was first enacted we used to see Charter petitions that were 15 to 20 Pages we now see Charter petitions that are hundreds of pages currently at this time without the approval of the material revisions this is what's called a dependent Charter School um there is no legal definition of what a dependent charter school is there's nothing in the charter schools act there's nothing that has been decided by any court of law a dependent Charter School um the phrase has just been used to describe a very close relationship between
173the district and a charter school in almost all instances when we have a dependent Charter School the charter board and the governing board are the one and the same that's what we have currently now the um I'm going to talk about a couple of different documents because um there's not a single document that the board is being asked to consider um there are a number of documents so this process started on November 14th with with the submission of a clean document and a Redline document um unfortunately those two documents were not the same but nevertheless um on November 19th there was a revised document that was submitted and then at the December 10th board meeting there was a document called guide to revisions that was submitted which purported to respond to The District staff findings
174and made a number of fundamental changes that are not part of the charter petition that document was now further revised um I believe earlier um or last week or earlier this week so at the present time you don't have a single coherent document on which to even take action um with respect to the most significant change that is being proposed is the um operation excuse me the creation of a separate 501c3 Corporation and all of the roles of the operations excuse me roles the duties responsibilities of the operations the hiring Etc everything would be transferred to that separate 501c3 Corporation by having that governance structure that makes it an independent charter school it is absolutely an independent charter school if you allow that govern if you approve that uh structure additionally I'd just like to
175point out that when the petition revision was initially submitted there was um reference to that particular Charter board being selected by the executive committee in the guide to the revisions that was just submitted that's no longer the case now the charter board would be selected by the founder of the corporation additionally there are a number of changes that are in the charter petition that would expose the district to potential liability and significant liability for example if you approve the revision and the separate Charter board is the board of the school making it an independent charter school then um they wish to remain under the district for Sela and be considered a school of the district and they also wish to have the district provide the back office services and they also wish to remain under
176the district's insurance if you are an independent Charter you should be getting your own coverage and the district and the jpa will not allow the charter that is an independent Charter that does not share the same governance structure to be insured under the district's insurance so that that proposal would be the district would have the liability and would have the exposure but would not have any day-to-day um control over the operations of that school or even the employment decisions Additionally the charter has proposed excuse me that it would be the exclusive employer for purposes of the ER currently everybody that's at that Charter is a district employee and has the rights under the Education Code and has the rights under under the collective burning agreement with that change they are stripping the District Board of
177the ability to make employment decisions at that site and the employees that are at that site also would no longer have all of the rights and protections as District employees and under the collective bargaining agreement this is not simply a change that you can cross out the district and add you know the charter there are many many implications um the charter proposes to add an independent study program of up to 12200 students currently the charter operates an inseat program for grades 6 through 8 they're proposing in the original proposal it was going to be an independent studies program that was going to go all the way to 12th grade as part of the guides to the revision they've now changed that to 8th grade however the charter is prohibited by the California Education Code from
178adding an independent study program until January 2026 there is an absolute moratorium on new independent study programs so they cannot add those 1,200 students Additionally the charter proposes to have the Universal Sports um Institute transferred to the Charter if it's an independent Charter which it would be because it' be governed by a separate 501c3 Corporation the transfer of that program and all of the equipment in that program would be a violation of the Education Code Surplus property procedures as well as violations of the Education Code procedures for the disposal of District equipment the charter school as an independent school has no greater right to that equipment and to that property than anybody in this room and that's why we have specific Ed code Pro Provisions that call for the disposal of disposal of surplus property
179as well as personal property and finally um the charter currently pays the district um a prish share and the pret share is I I'm not really going to talk about it at length unless the board has specific questions so under prop 39 which is Ed code section 47614 a charter school is entitled to a district facility if you have a district facility there are two ways of the charter paying for that facility one is what's called a pret share and it's set forth and calculated pursuant to the provisions of the regulations the other way is to charge 2% of the Charter School's budget but as you are probably aware um in because it was agenda for closed session the district is also taking a look at two other prop 39 requests that have been submitted
180from Magnolia and from C crla the law provides that all charters regardless of whether they're authorized by the district but if they're independent charters all charters have to be offered the same costs so whatever CR whatever ocss pays that's what crla and that's what Magnolia would pay those are two countywide charters and um the district will be having to make an offer of some type in response to their prop 39 requests that they submitted so I'll stop for a second um I know that that's a lot of information are there any specific questions that the board has or comments anything that I can address what is what do the normal um charter schools that are like running out what's the percentage that they normally are you said it would be two they pay two or
1813% to us what's the normal so the normal um it it is very specific to a district but um when I looked at the onepage budget that was submitted with this Charter revision um it looks like the district has been charging the charter $10 a square foot and it also has been charging the um for the district ad administrative space so the budget contemplates a payment of approximately a million dollars to the district under the current Arrangement and under the new proposed Arrangement that million dollar that currently comes to the district for the provision of that facility would be reduced to about $200,000 so our so ocscs has paid our district almost a million dollars yes that's what the budget shows okay so they started up at 1.2 something million so we're not losing as
182much money as this is space that's not for services I think that they pay separately for services so I'm talking only about the space okay and so what is the $10 a square foot what is that is that two or three% no no so the $10 a square foot like I said comes to about a million dollar so it's about 10% okay but the proposal would have it reduced to 2% and so whatever you give to them if they're an independent school you have to give to Magnolia and to um the rla and so um the revision is for 202 2025 25 26 and so in 202 January 2026 um will the independent study you said that there's going to be new terms for the independent study do they do we get opened up the
183independent study we don't know yet so originally the moratorium was supposed to be for three years and the moratorium was instituted because there were a number of fiscal improprieties um and it was supposed to be for 3 years it's been extended several times and some of the studies that were supposed to be done as part of that moratorium haven't been done so I would suspect that that moratorium is going to be extended but as of right now say that there could be possibly be independent study technically for the 2526 school year independent study could be starting in January 2026 exactly so it's not necessarily illegal or whatever the whatever the term was yeah yeah I mean well it's illegal in the sense that if you offer a beforehand you're not going to get funded for
184it right but we're just saying is if it's just in the charter revision that says we are going to start January 2026 because that's when the state's going to allow it yeah we can keep there such other time as the moratorium is lifted that's what I would put in there okay and then the Sela sorry I have more um the Sela so if we obviously we were to take that on what is the what's the financial strain on the dis what's different about taking that on then like what we already do we take a lot of out of District transfers already so what is the change what's this what are you talking about with this so with Sela a dependent or an independent Charter School can remain a school of the district for purposes of
185special education so what that means is that even if they're operating independently by the separate Corporation they can stay under the district's umbrella and the district then has to provide all of the services to the students in exchange for that the district gets what are called the 602 funds and also is able to charge an encroachment and an encroachment is approximately from what the budget documents that I looked at is about $1,300 a student and so that is the money that is then paid to this District to provide services to the Sela to your point like you may have a lot of outof District kids but those are kids that come in through um the transfer the inter District transfer process Charters don't have jurisdictional boundaries and so they can enroll from the Orange County
186or any of the contiguous counties so as long as somebody's willing to drive over here that anybody can enroll in that school so with the charter then if they were independ independent even though I'm so confused if we're saying that there's no such thing as either one um would the charter be able to take that $1,300 a student would they take that money on instead of the district taking it on well they would have to um be a member of a Sela in their own right and that usually takes at least a year or two okay yeah so if so they would have to join or so let's say we how how established were we 7 months by now six months so is there a process to join so like a year or two and
187so there wouldn't be any of that funding because they wouldn't be okay perfect areest go on the Califoria Department of Education website and Char when you look upano Charter their status says so I want to make that as this attorney is representing this I will agree with her that we look at what legal opinions are we are modeling vital it is vital that I advocate so just two things um first of all just a second we're asking questions and um if we have a question to you we will ask you but please don't interrupt our meetings and also I think I I think I kind of asked I mean or maybe you should just come up to the podium so you guys can jump back and forth um so the absolutely pursuant to the provisions
188of the charter school act she is entitled the petitioner is entitled to equivalent time and procedures that staff has I am not staff I am the board's counsel so um the time limit does not apply to me secondly with respect to what she has indicated um and I saw also a posting about this El Rancho Charter School which is authorized by the um Orange Unified School District governing board is a dependent Charter because it is not run by a 501c3 corporation that is why it's a dependent Charter okay so I do I do understand so with the whole USI thing I understand about the equipment I understand all of that and that makes complete sense but technically if the dependent study or the independent study is coming in 2026 what besides the equipment transfer um
189would there be any issues for for them to become an independent study program um somehow like some type of dual enrollment I don't know I was just trying to think like how do we do that because we do have some USI students who want to also attend the ocscs like so I'm wondering if that's if it does go on in 2026 are we okay to like do dual enrollment like that if you have it remain as a dependent school with the District board being the governing board what if we have anou that says that these USI kids can also you know go into the charter is that legal can we do that you're still giving a district resource and asset to an independent um Corporation we would have to charge for it if we were
190going to do that right so that means we wouldn't be able to give any of the equipment so if they became and they added independent study in 2026 that would not automatically include any equipment whatsoever because if that were the case then we are triggering the um Surplus property the Surplus property and well I wasn't talking about the equipment I'm talking about like dual enrollment if they wanted to dual enrollment thing yeah there's a number of things you know that there's a number of things that need to be understood by everybody about what's being proposed and I think your question is excellent question but it probably should come after some of the other things have been discussed and understood well we're voting tonight so that's why I'm asking well but as I indicated to you
191earlier um you we don't really know what the board is voting on because there's so many different documents and so many different representations so you're saying that there's currently five different proposals that we have been given since November 14th yes and the just for purp and the staff has only really reviewed the one document is that correct so staff reviewed um I think three I I have reviewed the revisions the guide to the revisions and that's the one that responds to the staff findings and recommendations and as I said it doesn't just respond it makes fundamental changes such as as you know dropping grade levels such as changing the corporate board um and this and that okay if I understand this correctly if we approve this tonight um our insurance could cancel us is that
192with the district Insurance because we'd be creating a liability of ensuring a nonprofit organization they they wouldn't cancel you what would happen is if there's a claim that's filed arising out of something that happens at the charter school they would deny coverage for that because you don't you would then no longer have the shared governance structure so the the charter would have no insurance basically the charter would have no insurance H but um so the charter schools act provides that when the district is the authorizing Agency for a charter school dependent or independent um it has certain oversight responsibilities duties and obl a if it doesn't fulfill those responsibilities duties and obligations then it is responsible for the debts and obligations of that charter school so if the charter is not covered under the district's
193Insurance because it doesn't have the shared governance if something happens over there the insurance will deny that claim but that claim will be something that the district has to then pay out of general fund but this is for the following school year so if we approve this tonight we're not approving anything to change the school as we've said earlier this would be the basically September of 2025 would that the charter school need to have that insurance and and everything if they were to become the so-called independent yes so we couldn't get we couldn't get bounced from insurance tonight because it's not changing anything until September but we're opening the door for if we app how do we open the door how do we open the door if nothing's happening until September 25th that we won't
194need to be insured until September 25th we're open the door to nothing I I see it differently I disagree well I'm not surprised so I do have a question and I don't think that this is giving away any secrets from Clos session but if this is the same presentation here as back there then what why was this done back there first first of all I don't think it's appropriate to discuss what happened in close session that's attorney client privilege communication okay and the presentation tonight is for the benefit of the board and the public and the community to understand what the proposed changes are because I think that there are a number of individuals that don't understand what the changes are clearly from the very beginning of um principal Fisher's presentation when she didn't understand
195the distinction between dependent and independent and clearly the community didn't understand that distinction and it's up to the board to make a determin ation as to what you would like to do but so your options tonight are to deny to approve or approve with um conditions and so have you spoken to our um attorneys from orbock huff and Henderson who have been handling this and have you talked to the staff who've been handling this up until now I have not spoken to the attorneys and I have spoken to some staff members which staff members have you spoken to um Beth no sorry I don't know why Renee um and I also spoke to um I'm blanking on his name Gary before he left okay um I think can we have Beth Fischer come up to
196the podium to give us whatever answer who does excuse me I I know but that's a board decision I will not clarify information no I'm just saying there's a procedure why don't you bring her up to the podium so she can speak why don't why are you trying to you gave her 10 minutes bring her up there you got a vote bring her up there it's the board decision bring her up this is want to know I'm just in a matter of time and going back we can go back and forth all night I think I mean I just we've read the revision we have the information we have the council's information and she's here to answer questions um I don't see the need for back and forth okay Mr Frasier I know I'm hard
197to hear but I would like to actually hear what Beth had to say because I couldn't hear anything since she's in the audience so that that would beneficial I would think to hear her response I I am concerned about the insurance issue um the equipment issue there's several things that if we wanted to move forward with this we' need to adjust as well but I I would like to hear what Beth has to say but I can't my opinion um no I think we need to just keep moving forward we've had the statements we've had hearings we've been through this we've had the statements from the staff we've had our attorney I I think we're here I think we do need to move forward because we could we could be rebuttal everything back and forth
198and we we just need to keep moving forward Suki is five is uh El Rancho Charter is that they have a do they have a 501c3 they do not we is there anybody in the audience who might work at that Charter that is saying differently so the I made a Ranch so El Rancho might have excuse me we're not this is the board's meeting and we're not are you this is your warning I don't know your name but you've been warned okay thank you Santiago is okay you have been warned too okay okay Brown says she does have a time limit and you guys keep doing okay sir you need to leave can we will why are you looking at me amazing I love her okay let's get back to questions that the board have
199for Suki is there any other questions that anyone has my only my only concern is um obviously we have Magnolia and we have the crla coming in and I understand what you're talking about with if we offer um our district Charter the you know a certain price that we have have to give everybody a certain price I do understand about the USI uh about the equipment um I think the independent study I think it's I don't think it's correct to just say it's illegal if it's actually you know in a year and a half or maybe just a year now because we're already January so in a year we could possibly you know have this independent study back um I I understand I understand where they're coming from and so I was going to ask
200you Suki um how would in a position like this since you have 30 years of Charter School experience how would totally aging me okay I'm sorry I meant 13 um how would you um what would be a solution like in all the things that you've seen obviously we have this El Rancho Charter we have them fundraising we have other all these other Charter Schools fundraising but then what we've run into issues with is it appears that in the past a lot of the funding has been questioned the community has complained about the $1 million being put into the Innovation lab which has really put a lot of stress on the school you know saying taking fun away from all these other places so this is exactly why this was brought forward tonight was because they
201were looking for ways to move their school forward if they had a board that was not willing to fund anything further and the school is going to stay stagnant at where it is I mean it's not a stagnant school but they won't have the ability to grow and so what would would your thoughts be for them to stay in this model into our school what are their legal options or what what is their opportunities for them to try to fund raise extra money to try to do anything like that or are they stuck and they can only have what the board provides I I think that's an excellent point and an excellent question um uh I've been doing this for 30 years and a lawyer for almost 40 so I'm now dating myself but um
202what I would say is my recommendation given the amount of uncertainty about the independent study program some of the other things that we've been discussing is to keep the governance structure the way that it is the governance structure I think from what I understand listening to all the comments it's a phenomenal school it's a great choice for the community I think every single person on the board supported it when it was approved and every single person supports the charter as it is right now it's these changes which have been brought in like a really really rapid period of time and are constantly changing and evolving which has caused some of these um concern concerns and issues um with the dependent Charters I work with one um Al Rancho I work with one Western Center in
203Hemet there's also one um in Yuka there's a bunch of them that are over by LAX there are any number of individuals that really want to support Charters and they are willing to provide that funding for the charters and so what we could do is we could have um something that's set up that the funding that comes in is given like that's directly for that Charter is funneled to that Charter and it's not necessarily coming into the district so that if there I heard somebody saying you know um I supported um El Rancho and Santiago so we could set up something like that we could set up a foundation that is specifically for the benefit of the charter so that it the vision that Beth Or principal fiser has for this and the vision that
204the parents in the community have for this is realized and then if we did a foundation and if we did set up things like that there's no way that the district could take any of that money right right yeah I mean that would be the intent and purpose behind it for real though like we couldn't say oh we have $2 million in the the ocscs fund and we need to you know to to take it somewhere else if they were to set up a foundation that way could I just add even maybe as a like an asp or a PTA something Todd speaking well just a second Todd um the like an ASB structure or a um a PTA something like that where it's a donation where it can be housed separately exactly I would
205like it to be I mean we're talking 501c which means you have specific requirements from the government to have that that uh that denoted status and therefore the funds could only be used for the purpose set forth by the governing documents of that entity similar to uh reach I think would be probably a good an um closest structured like that but we could fund raise for that potentially and then it'd be outside the district but it would only go towards um ocss is that what we're talking about yes exactly there's many different kinds of 501c3 corporations the one that is being contemplated here is one where all of the governance control operations employment decisions Etc would be made you could have another Corporation don't approve this one have another Corporation to address exactly what you're
206talking about you know how can we fund raise how can we get some Grant monies how can we get all the things that the OCS um Community parents and principal fiser want and dedicate to that school so we would needed somebody at the district to write grant money for or to write grants for ocscs yeah or somebody like even from like a lot of times you can have people even outside the community that really believe in a school that are happy to you know provide that as well and you mentioned the word Corporation are they able to become a corporation somehow to be able to to because I think that's this is the whole thing is obviously you know you're it's it's just like what the speakers were saying things are changing so rapidly especially
207with you know the things that they're dealing with at their school so you know in two years they could be an outdated school so I think the funding is is you know and then I also think too that in the past you know the they've asked for extra professional development and we've had questions from people on this board as to why or denying the professional development for the teachers when you know we're introducing New Concepts and it's like a constant evolving thing and so I think that's the fear here so I would say like I really think this board has to step up and say we're going to support 100% we're not going to defund and I think everybody needs to make that commitment to go forward with this with this school we're not going
208to fire the principal we're not going to defund the teachers we're not going to take away the Innovation lab like we're not going to do all these things because that's the fear here and that is exactly why they came to us with what they've come to us because of that fear of being shut down not being funded and that they were going to be blood dry and so I think that that's one thing we can commit to I think it's fine I I mean you know I'm not really about the control of the school so if we have a school you know and they're going to they could I think they could Thrive definitely by themselves but I am concerned about their ability to thrive um unless the board is making the promises and we're
209able to um you know like maybe have these other fundraising options um I just like to State um when my kids were in elementary school we had a principal and her name was Dory stack and she she wrote many many grants for our elementary school um we were the um kickoff for the T um TK early intervention and she wrote a grant and started TK and then it spread throughout our district she wrote a a grant to teach um math skills through music guess what we got it and we started it she wrote a Grant and we started the Kasa program that is now spread out throughout the district so these Innovations and grants are out there we just need to look for them we need to support them and then I'm also want to
210say that many of our schools fund raise right now and they donate money to their school and it's put and we approve those funds every every month at our meeting in the gift funds so um it will tell you exactly how much money was donated and what it was for and then that money is spent for those reasons and um it it kind of blows me away because um I'm on the west side of the district and the amount of money that is raised on the east side of the district is really quite shocking to me um you know because we've have schools that have raised money to build all new playground equipment which is over $100,000 and they've been able to do that so I think we we just need to use our resources
211we need to use our Innovation as we like to keep saying and um I think there's other ways to support this school without some of these very concerning issues that are coming forward um I obviously as you know visited I agree it's amazing school and things that they're doing are great um my concern is the financial part if you after say my part if you can explain the grant if they were on their own and the grant money they would be getting how um that would be I guess I don't want to say restricted but how that would be implemented and then also I agree I mean there's like you said there's a lot of schools that are are funding their own things I know I was just at um Venture and George key and
212they have a Community member who has funded and gotten community support and business support to build their sensory garden that same um Community member is going to go hopefully secure funding from businesses and outside resources to make them a new playground that's accessible for their students students um so it can be done and again being on the fundraising side too as well with PTA I mean there's like you said there's amazing things I mean we were able to give Chromebook hearts and things like that when we use our resources and um that's my concern because as it is now um because I asked this question earlier for um just clarifying information but as it as it stands right now ocscs is running about a million and a half dollars I believe pass their Ada um
213allotment so even if they kept their Ada as it is now they's still a million and a half more that they're spending over the Ada so that's my concern is I would hate to put this program in Jeopardy and possibly not either get as many grants as we'd thought we would if it was an independent Charter and then what do we do and then there's also I think misconception too because I did look into the AL Rancho model I've done a lot of research this weekend and and El Rancho I know everybody kept saying they fundraised or they um had money for their gym when they built it that was actually from what I found out it was actually a loan taken from the district they funded that with that so they had to come
214to the district with District help to get the money for that gym and then they had to pay the district back with a with the constraint of that if they didn't pay it back that school would now be come back to the district so that's not a place I would want to see ocscs have to be in um like I said it's it's new we're not quite sure of with Innovation and progress and things changing things get more expensive too so we don't what what may cost something now next year or two years from now may be a lot more so I would hate to see them get in a bind financially and not be able to support themselves and then what happens so I'm concerned like I said of the financial side of it
215and then if you can explain the grants sure so let's talk about two different kinds of Grants so first of all to um to the question that was raised earlier you know what else can what other kinds of money can this charge get there are a lot of Foundations including the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation the Walton Foundation a lot of those organizations that have Grant monies that are specifically available to Charters and they don't necessarily take a look at the operational structure or the governance structure so I would strongly encourage OCS to look into at least those two um if they work with California Charter Schools Association they can provide them you know numerous other references the grant monies that have been discussed are those Grant monies that are Federal grant monies that are
216then dispersed to CDE and then CDE takes those Grant monies and disperses them to the charters so the grant money is dispersed to a independent Charter it has nothing to do with the way that it's funded okay so there's indirect funding and then there's local funding funding so indirect funding means that the money for whether it's an independent Charter or a dependent Charter comes to the district and then it's dispersed out we rarely see that except for dependent Charters or for like brand new Charters and we're a little bit worried that they operational structure or that they don't have the business Acumen to really get it up and off the ground so what they're proposing is to have the money go directly to them and that's what most independent Charters do the grant money is
217not tied to that the grant money is tied to the governance structure and I know that because um about 15 20 years ago many many um districts that looked at all the grant monies that were available to Charters said why don't why can't we have some we educate you know all of the students why can't we have some so we started um having District boards authorize and approve dependent Charter petitions then the the the federal government and CDE said no you can only get these they're called pcbg Grant monies you can only have them if you have a separate governance structure from the authorizing agency so that is the only way that they are eligible for those Grant monies right now um because they're already so those monies are available to new schools expanding schools
218and replication schools so they're no longer considered a new school but they would still be eligible for an expanded school if they were to add grade levels or add like a another type of program obviously we talked about independent study is not an option until January 2026 but if they were to add for example grade levels they could potentially be considered for that there are Grant monies um the 24 25 cycle I believe is closed also the thing to understand about the grant monies that are the Federal grant monies is that they cannot be used for the standard operating practices sorry expenditures salaries and things like that because what those money say is that if you have state or federal monies that are already being allocated to you for those expenditures you cannot use these
219Grant monies and it's also a reimbursement Grant so you spend the money and then you submit the you know request for reimbursement and they send it back to you now if you're coming up with like a new program you might be able to use it for professional development or something like that um these are usually one-time Grant monies that are distributed over um a 1 to threee period and then depending on what you submit what you're asking for they give you a window um for expanded schools they give you a window of about three years to expend that but they're usually one time Grant monies and you're saying that they can apply for this now at in this in the type of structure that they're under they cannot right okay but they can't apply for
220other Foundation grants and grants just anything outside of what this specific Grant is for exactly and and there's lots of Grant monies that are available to Charter I personally know um of you know Bill Melinda Gates Foundation and the Walton Foundation have sent or given a lot of Grant monies and I think to um the points that were made earlier if there were Grant monies that were received perhaps they should be put into a separate fund that's dedicated to just that school and is not coming into the district's general fund we have a lot of business in Orange County that this particular program would be of interest to I think and um we have Samuell found found Orange County um Community Foundation there are a lot out there that would focus on this I I
221live in the grant World um and there a lot related to Arts and Music and um innovation technology all of this kind of thing so I think that there are some available it's just not in the education realm as we're seeing um but um just for all of you um I like this school I toured it in October I went around with uh Mrs fiser and her and Mrs given and um one of the math toses there I went to the classrooms I talked to the kids I talked to the teachers I saw what was going on I voted for this even though I have questions um it's okay for me to have questions and it's okay for me to wonder um what some of the funding is because I I didn't feel like I
222was getting the information that I wanted that doesn't mean that I think that this school should go away um it doesn't mean that I want to take things from the school I want this school to be successful I think computer science is part of what we all need to be doing ideally I I would like to see us find out what are the best practices related to this and how can we utilize that in other schools around the district I thought that from the beginning um what I what I also want to make sure you all know is that we were elected to this position we are here to um oversee the schools and that includes ocscs um but we also support all of the schools I think everybody all of the schools should be
223treated fairly um it should be Equitable if we're doing a lot of extra programming at this school we should also be considering extra programming at other schools so that it is expanding what we're doing maybe we have computer science at one school but maybe there's something else we should be considering at another school it doesn't mean we stop here and it doesn't I I don't want this to go away so just so that you all hear me please please believe me don't listen to what is on social media nobody speaks for me out there I like this school I want it to succeed I want these kids to have opportunities that interest them I had kids that went to different schools around this District because they had specific interests and I want that for all
224of your children I want that for my own grandchildren so please believe me please stop listening to what's on social media saying that I don't like the school I don't like the teacher I don't like this I don't like that that's not true if you actually go to my social media Pages I'm barely on it so I just want you to all know that and I love this district and I want every school and every student and every teacher and every parent everybody in this District to be successful but I do have questions about [Applause] this anybody else have any other questions okay no comments miss Lea yeah since you are the computer science expert on this table um I just see I can kind of see both sides of the argument I feel like
225um you know you should be able to have funding especially because computer science is fast and developing um but I do have concerns in terms of like Financial stability I think you know with the switch to the insurance in September of 2025 like I just want to make sure that that transition would be smooth so that nothing like it would just move in an upward trajectory for the kids I don't want it to be like oh well now we're switching our financial structure and you know now there's some instability in the school those are my only concerns thank you so I have a I have a question um we how come they had asked for um ENT attorney ocscs you know to come and I guess talk to Suki or do whatever and we never
226granted them would we have been able to like basically talk or like mediate between this um and sort out all these problems and then come with a better petition had we done it that way um I'm just I'm just curious because it seems like a lot of this like it seems like okay like USI can't go into this independent study not till 2026 um you know just certain things it seems like we could have come to maybe an agreement and I think that that's what ocscs was trying to do you know with the district and I also think too um some of the funding I and I understand because they haven't received some of the funding um the the person that was here before we would approve funds and they weren't getting their funding so
227I understand what their struggle is is because we have I think two or three teachers in this room who have spent over $11,500 out of their own pocket because we approved funding and it didn't teacher no I'm sorry but what not for your own school supplies not for school supplies not for some not for Kleenex or something for your room it was something for the Innovation lab that was approved by this board but we they didn't get their funding they were never paid for it so to open their school they paid the the money out so it's not no they have not been reimbursed well then we should definitely look into that Mr great can you put that so that's why I think that there is that certain concern is you know when you talk
228about the grant so I understand I understand exactly why they want to go and find their own money because we've approved money and it hasn't even gotten to their school um so that's my question is when we didn't when they asked for the money for the attorney and we didn't give it to him I kind of feel like we jipped like this whole process because we could have came we obviously we brought on a new attorney our attorney never spoke to the person who is basically doing this whole thing for the last year like we could have came together and been able to maybe work this out and then to present something um to the board and I think that that is still something that um you know can be done and I think it
229would be very easily to be done but I guess does this board you know want to do that so I I just have a question so when this originally came up well not even a question just a comment this originally came up and this was presented as um a a charter petition that was created and written by Miss Fischer um when it came up from for them and I asked at the time Dr chernes at you know did the staff was the staff involved in any of this at all and I was told no and I was told no on the dis and when when the revision came up um it was I asked about it um a day or two before because I heard rumors about it and Dr chis told me nope he
230didn't know anything about it and then I'm also hearing that we were heavily involved in it and and working through it with um with Dr fiser through all of this so it's um difficult who was heavily involved in it the staff the staff was involved in it working with Dr Fisher on it I guess that would be I guess you can't make exitation because there she well I I was told by Dr chernes No and then I've read in um other instances yes and I've heard people say it was um so that has always been a confusion and Conflict for me because I wasn't getting the same information and I I agree like you said to we should have in hindsight probably done this different but that was my concern as well is that we
231rushed through this so much that we could like you said we could have done that but that would have taken time and that's what we're ask we were asking for is time to look at this again and so I think that was part of it and a lot of the community me thought it was time more time was needed well this also shows that yes more time was needed so we can go through all that those steps so that was a valid valid concern with the whole thing as well right but I think they I think they have attorneys that are working with them or or want to work with them and that's why they needed the $5,000 and I think their attorney wanted to come and sit down at the table with Suki and
232like work this all out and they asked for this in December and we just didn't give them anything but we've thrown a lot of money at Suki to represent this board and yet we kind of through I think a study session would have solved a lot of these issues and if we would have stopped and come together at a table and discuss like you know the charter school what are your issues and what are your problems and what can we do as a district and what legally and things like that a lot of this could be Sol but we you know I asked for a study session last fall about the charter I've asked for a study session about the revisions and that hasn't happened and I I just think we haven't been communicating we
233haven't all been getting the same information I mean just tonight the misinformation that has been said and that every I mean three quars of the room things this is a a dependent study but our attorney is assuring us that's an independent study this is this is why it's so important not to rush these decisions this is why it's important to sit down and study these out and get direction from the board and so we can help the schools but isolating board members and not giving them information does not help um who who isolated you we've all had the same information this whole time we've had the exact same information I've never seen a I've never seen the revision until it was given to the whole board so your accusations are baseless and inflammatory so I
234want to say I did Vote for This Charter originally because I was excited about it I'm excited tonight to hear the kids come and talk about their experiences that they're having wonderful experiences at this school which every kid at every one of our schools should be having and our job as a board is to support all the students throughout the district and make sure everybody is having excellent um experiences I have been on the campus I went to the DSD Los mores event I spoke about it I even showed the the things that I purchased with my own dollars from the from the students that was made at the Innovative Labs um you know know we just need to slow down and look at the these things so that we can support this school and
235every school in our district and every student because every kid learns differently and every kid needs we need to have options for our students and that's what we're doing I think it's time that we um make a motion and I'll make a motion that we deny this material revision to the Orange County School of computer science second have a motion by Mrs Anderson a second by Mrs Buck um are we ready for a roll call okay um Mrs blades so I want to approve Pro it so what will my answer be you want a motion to deny I you would say I think you would say no no no Mrs quintell um unfortunately because of the new facts and the new I guess twist in the whole thing um I would have to say um
236I I would say yes to the denial Mr Frasier I am going to say yes to the denial but I would like to have this reviewed and and possibly have another revision brought back so that we can get what we need at ocss um unfortunately there several items that it doesn't it it doesn't seem like it works at this moment okay Mrs Buck um I uh will approve the denial but that does not mean that I am lacking an any support for OC ocss and I too will vote Yes to deny and I hope that this does come back and I hope we have a nice study session and really do some problem solving together so so the board does need to adopt um written factual findings supporting the denial so I will be stepping
237away and preparing those based on the questions and the comments and the information that's been provided and I will be coming back and having you adopt that resolution okay thank you will we be doing that tonight yes okay okay so the motion Carri um 4 to one oh yes student board member I forgot you sorry um no so when you say no if a denial yeah okay so that is a yes okay well she said to deny right are are you denying or are you denying or are you approving the the revision you approve oh you approved the revision okay so that four four to one plus four to one plus a one it it gets very confusing confusing it's a double negative um would you like me to do the next one yes okay
238so I'll make a motion um that we approve resolution number 24-10 dedicating February 2025 as Career and Technical Education Month I need a second a second anybody second second oh I said it I wasn't loud enough nope I heard you Todd but you're quiet you can give it to Todd maybe okay we have a motion by Mrs buck and a second by Mr Frasier at this time I'd like to turn the time over to Mrs Renee gray to introduce Mike young director of secondary education who will read the resolution okay as if people are leaving if you could please keep your voices down so we can continue our meeting thank you okay February marks Career and Technical Education Month a nationwide initiative aimed at raising awareness of the vital role Career and Technical education plays
239in equipping students with the skills needed for high demand careers spearheaded by the Association for Career and Technical education this monthl monthlong observance underscores the value of CTE programs and emphasizes the collaborative efforts of Educators industry partners and communities in fostering Workforce Development so our director of secondary education Mr Mike young will present the career in technical education resolution thank you Mike thank you whereas February 1st through February 28th 2025 has been designated Career and Technical Education Month by the Association for Career and Technical education and whereas profound economic and technological changes in our society are ridly reflected in the structure and nature of work thereby placing new and additional responsibilities on our educational system and whereas Career and Technical education prepares students to be College and Career ready by providing core academic skills employability
240skills and Technical job specific skills and giving all students leadership opportunities in their fields and in their communities and whereas the ever increasing Cooperative efforts of Career and Technical educators business and industry stimulate the growth and vitality of our local economy and that of the entire nation by preparing graduates for career Fields forecast to experience the largest and fastest growth in the next decade now therefore be it resolved that the placa Yorbalinda Unified School District board of education does hereby support and designate February 1st through February 28th 2025 to be Career and Technical education month thank you anyone have any comments no as a North Orange County Ro board member I appreciate all of the CTE work that we do and the collaboration that we have with them as well we have amazing teachers we
241have amazing programs in our district and if anyone is interested before the cut off date I highly suggest you watch some of those great videos so that being said let's do a roll call Mrs blades yes Mrs quino yes Mr Frasier yes Mrs Buck yes and I am a Mrs a yes as well and Miss Leila yes okay motion carries five to zero with um an I from our student board member next item I'll make a motion that we approve the Acting Superintendent employment agreement between placen Orinda Unified School District and Renee gry second okay I need to read something else so I got to find that sheet here okay so Acting Superintendent Renee gray pursuant to government code 54953 approve the employment contract for Mrs Renee gray as Acting Superintendent of Schools providing one
242a term beginning December 20th 2024 an employees appointment as Acting Superintendent may be terminated by either the board or employee at any time for any reason and the Acting Superintendent salary shall be paid at a daily rate of 1,518 $22 except as modified here all other terms and conditions including in Acting Superintendent assistant superintendent contract shall remain in effect is there any questions okay let's take a vote Mrs blades yes quell I Mr Frasier I I I and an I from me and our student board member I perfect motion carries 5 to zero with an I from our student board member okay next one we have is 16.2 16.2 oh oh yeah um I we're going to pull this right because we already because we already did her contract so we're g to skip that
243one and we're going to go to 16.3 I'll make a motion we recommend approval of interim sup assistant superintendent administrative services employment agreement for Yolanda Mendoza um sorry Joan Velasco finalized in close session prior to the Open session of this meeting sorry wrong order second okay I have a motion by Mrs Buck a second by Mrs Quintero and let me read out her contract interm assistant superintendent admin Services um pursuant to government code 54953 approved the employment contract for Joan Velasco as interim assistant superintendent of administrative Services providing one a term beginning January 15 2025 and employees appointed as interim assistant superintendent may be terminate by either be terminated by either the board or employee at any time for any reason and two the acting assistant superintendent shall be required to render up to 960
244hours of work three the acting superintend assistant superintendent salary shall be paid daily at the rate of $884 62 the acting assistant superintendent is not entitled any additional compensation or fringe benefits and four the employees appointment as interim assistant superintendent shall be terminated upon the effective date of the board taking a action upon another individual being appointed as assistant superintendent are we ready for the roll call okay Mrs blades yes M quo hi Mr Frasier hi I and I am also an i and our student board member I perfect we have um motion carried 5 to zero with an I from our student board member okay last one I guess read um I'll make a motion we recommend approval of acting assistant superintendent Human Resources employment agreement for Yolanda Mendoza finalized in close session prior
245to the Open session of this meeting second who that M blades okay sorry okay I have a motion by Mrs Buck a second by Mrs blades any comments okay let me read it out pursuant to government code 54953 approved the employment contract for Yolanda mza as acting assistant superintendent of Human Resources providing one a term beginning January 15 2025 and employees appointed as active assistant superintendent superintendent may be terminated by either the board or employee at any time for any reason and two the acting assistant superintendent shall be required to render up to 80 work days the acting superintendent salary shall be paid a daily rate of $884 62 the acting superint assistant superintendent is not entitled any additional compensation or fringe benefits and four the employee appointment acting assistant superintendent shall be terminate terminated
246upon the effective date of the board taking action to either reinstate the current Deputy superintendent or upon another individual being appointed as Deputy or assistant superintendent any comments okay Mrs blades yes hi Mr Fraser I heard it hi and I'm also an i and miss Lea hi okay perfect motion carries 5 to zero with a an I from our student board member you know you can go how's Mom doing does Mom want to go [Laughter] home okay um yeah 16.5 is as amended so can I ask a question before we go to it what is the VIP LLC for fiscal Services no yes we did we pull the LLC yeah that was yeah was 16.5 that one's pulled so it's no longer okay yeah but now okay and the 16.6 is where we are and
247that one is not amended it is Amed the 16.6 okay sorry I missed that oh this isud allain oh and it was not all correct okay so I'll make a motion we approve the agreement with the placenta Linda unified managers Plum and the placenta y Linda Unified School District p USD as amended second okay I have a motion by Mrs Buck a second by Mrs blades any comment I'm glad we're finally settling this yeah I am too okay Mrs blades yes I I I I'm an i Lea I'll stay because I don't I don't know what this one is okay perfect okay motion carries 5 to zero with an exemption from our student board member okay so we are at the consent calendar actions proposed on the consent calendar items are cons consistent with approved
248practices of the district and are deemed routine in nature um chest's receive board agenda backup information in advance of scheduled meetings and we are prepared to vote with knowledge of the block vote items is there any items to be pulled okay anybody um I have I'd like to pull number 21.2 and 21.3 those are both the classified and certific ated reports okay and then I didn't get an answer to this so I'm going didn't we didn't we pull 21.2 already you pull I thought you pulled 212 and 213 amended it okay we amended it okay and I'm going to just pull um 19.5 anyone else okay so now I need a motion I'll make a motion to approve the consent calendar besides the pulled items second second okay I have a motion by myself and
249a second by Mrs Buck um this is blades yes I I I and I'm an i student board member obene obene okay smart girl don't ever vote for something you don't know okay so motion carries 5 to zero with an absens from our student board member so now we will go to 19.5 I'll make a motion we approve the services agreement with booster Enterprises Inc for Bryant Ranch to participate in their annual Jon fundraiser on October 29 2025 that's far away that's why I pulled it um I'll second okay so we have a a motion by Mrs buck and a second by Mrs Anderson um I just pulled this because it was so far away and I just um it's in the next school year and I just thought we'd have a quick explanation so
250we understand why so in order to reserve booster Enterprises you need to get this in before I believe it was December 9th I'm looking at yeah yeah so we had to get this in um earlier in order to be able to have them for the following year it seems so like it's so far out October 25th which it is but they required it do we have another date that's why they're all here thank you so much for this Academic School year they want to get the contract for the perfect oh yeah yeah these things have to be way in advance yes yes okay perfect thank you thank you for that explanation okay any other questions okay Mrs blades yes I I I I'm an i and miss one again okay okay motion carries 5 to
251zero with an abstention from our student board member so we can take these two together because it's actually the same comment if that's okay for the next two the certificated and classified I'll make a PO a motion we approve the classified human resour sources report and the certificated Human Resources report I need a second a second um I just had a question to see if I had to recuse myself from from this one no you already okay no it's already been okay okay a second okay we have a a motion by Mrs Buck a second by Mrs quento um the reason why I pulled this is because under Park View under um classified and certificated there is a lot of sports that is assigned to their school middle U Middle School Flag Football middle school
252wrestling um flag football cross country um it's seems like it's been classified incorrectly can we make sure that those are classified to the to the right school yes I think this came up at the the last time we approved this and it was for the Middle School sports program and I think we asked for it to be clarified so that we know where the funding where the kids were were going and I think yeah it's either going to be turey or another Middle School maybe it's turey because it's on that same site but it needs to be class at the right school okay yeah we need to make sure we get that y right see that all schools are getting Middle School sports and it's just not all going to the one school there were
253two in the classified list and multiple in the certificated okay none of that's related to USI at all it may or may not be but right now it's tied to park viw and we just need to clarify it but isn't USI Park View it might be Park View yeah are they doing all of the Middle School sports over there I mean how many I'd like to just have it I'm not going to deny it no I'm not saying that what what flag football flag football um wrestling cross country they've got their own set of coaches so I don't know if it's related to that so I just want to make sure because there are sometimes we've put USI and sometimes we haven't so Mr Yang did you have a comment want to come to the
254podium you got to push the button hi hi everybody um what I do know is that the secretary who orders for all the intramural sports um Deb Ortiz um she actually works out of um USI um which is also kind of underneath Park View so I think all the orders that I'm getting and approving for intramural sports come from her so but we do need to classify that better so that it's really clear for you guys that this is Middle School sports so if you could also go back and just double check anything that has been done in the past um to clarify that as well so that we're delineating it would be awesome yeah I'll do that thanks in all your free time okay there's no other questions we'll go ahead and take a
255vote Mrs blades Hi I hi I I I'll obain I'll obain okay motion carries 5 to Z with an exstension from our student board member okay we are done with the consent calendar so now oh we need that resolution printing push the button Todd yeah printing it's printing and so we will do our board report we'll do our board reports that will'll give you a few more minutes and can we let Leila go now I think it's probably time right thank you Lea thank you you've gone the distance [Applause] Lea okay we'll start with our our board reports Mrs BL me to go yep very short because of time very short so I've gone to a lot of basketball games you know because of winter sports and I just have to give a huge shout
256out to um I've been to I haven't made it to Valencia's basketball games yet but I've made it to esparanza and to El Dorado and to Y Belinda and so yalin high school boys varsity uh defeated Villa Park with 1 second on the clock um and it was amazing it was like the most intense game I've been at in a long time um and so so that was a great time the dance team did great um watching a lot of these cheer performances um just kind of being out and about and uh your Belinda boys also beat Eldorado boys and so you don't really know what to do in these situations because you have friends on both sides you don't know who to cheer for what to do but since I still have a kid
257at your Belinda High School I you know can show some Mustang Pride um esparanza girls basketball's doing well I'm not going to say anything else because I'm sure Todd will talk about it um but yeah just uh getting back in and and I'm really thankful for all of the staff because you guys have been under undue stress lately and you guys have really risen to the occasion and so we thank you um for this you know for stepping up to the plate especially in a time like this and you know uh getting the work done and really focusing on making sure our students and our teachers you know have what they need uh to continue on and uh yeah that's it I'm going to keep it short and I actually like I actually kept my
258promise so okay again I would like to also reiterate um our gratefulness of your help and um stepping up and making sure that everything's taken care of I know it's a lot and thank you to Renee as well um for you know leading this whole thing and making sure everything's done right so um I really appreciate everyone as well um it was a busy month um I'll keep mine short as well but I did have luckily I had an extra week of vacation so I was able to make a few School visits and I'm very excited um but I hope everybody else had a great holiday break um I was able to visit George key and the Venture Academy um it was great I felt the caring the warmth the um attentiveness right away when
259I got on campus they're amazing the staff um seeing what they're doing is just short of remarkable I mean it's it's really really good to see and to see their principal really just leading the way and setting the tone for the whole school was great um I was able to see their um sensory garden like I said I was informed about their um hopefully their new playground that'll come in soon I'm hoping we as a board could help them um get that sooner than hope hopefully than they um are anticipating and hopefully we can find some way to help them with that um I do want to um I was excited to see the Venture Academy getting ready to go out onto their job sites I was able to catch them before they left and
260I was just saw the excitement in their faces and you know ready to go so that was great and I want to kind of put a plug out there if there's any businesses um anybody you know in the community that would love to have the um Venture students help and and employing them um I know it's been a difficult time for them to find um proper placements and placements for their students so I would say the more the marer if we can get the word out that would be great um and I want to thank the teachers there as well for welcoming me into their classrooms I know it was a day that there weren't many students cuz it was right after they came back from break but um it was great to see them
261and have that welcoming um community and then I on the next day I also went to oh I'm sorry that same day I actually went to Parkview and BB bvva and it was great to see their um their um their you know hom School model independent city model um I got to walk through the classrooms I guess should say and see some of the teachers got to talk to them between their sessions and that was a great thing to see firsthand um I had a great conversation with the principal and um really wanted to um thank them for their hospitality as well and there's great things like I said going on there and um with especially how they've been changing they've been trying to adapt as best as possible um the next day I went
262to OCS ocscs I've said it a million times and I did have a good visit I was able to um tour many of the classrooms I saw the Innovation lab unfortunately I didn't see it when it was in action they were having a PD day that day but I was given a tour of the machines that they have and the technology that's in there and um it was good it I was glad I went because I did get to see their PD model and how the time that they were um given I got to talk over their agendas that they were meeting about and um it was great to see the common language that they have on the boards it was great to see all their like you know to point out their quotes that
263they have around campus to see um that many adults interacting and being there on campus with them as well like I said I got to go into some of the classrooms um talk to some of the students and see what they're doing and it was great it was really great to see the good things going on there um and then I think that's about it I had oh and I had a great conversation with Dr fiser too and she was able to answer a lot of my questions so that was really um good to see so yeah that was are my visits and hopefully I can do some more I know at the end of the month I'll hopefully be at El Dorado High School and um helping with their career day so if there's
264anybody you know as well that wants to do career day um and present at El Dorado that would be great and um hopefully that's what I'll be next so thank you all right I know that I'm a little bit hard to hear and I don't have a whole lot to discuss um other than the fact that it's cold here and that's always a fun reason to come to Alaska um it is also my birthday so thank you for spending my birthday with me everyone happy birthday and I uh just want to give a big shout out to uh Renee for all the work that she's been doing it has been a hectic back and forth the the um the level of emails and phone calls and things that I'm receiving I can't imagine the level
265of what she's been receiving so I just want to say she's doing a great job in uh where she's been put and I know that moving forward we're going to get her the support she needs to make sure that everything can get done well and the district continues to move forward um in spite of the unique situation we find ourselves in so thank you very much and I look forward to being back at our next meeting in person than thanks to I just have a few quick things I'll just highlight um before we left on uh our little um holiday um I attended the holiday lunch with everybody the manager's lunch and at uh at uh lak View and it was fantastic as usual nice to see everybody there and the costume the outfit you
266had on uh Baldwin was like top I can't wait to see that again and or maybe the next iteration of what it's going to be um I was so lucky to be able to uh I was asked by first five to um talk to some of the Early Childhood coordinators around the the county um related to family homelessness and um what they experience and how we can support and as a result I was asked to um speak at our preschool advisory committee and talk to some of the parents there the CCT and just talk to them about resources that are available it was really nice to um be able to do that and provide some needed insight um and uh lastly uh I attended the threat assessment that was uh mentioned the the professional development
267that was held last week um by Mr REI Rick Grammer um he's an Irvine Police Department um officer and I met him probably a month or two ago a couple of months ago and we sat down for coffee and he walked me through all of this process that he thought would be great for us so I am thrilled that he was able to um to come over and start to do some training it was a really well attended um training and it I'm looking forward to what that is going to look like in the future I think if we the more we plan ahead the better off we're going to be in the long run so thank you very much thank you okay first um I got to wish Mr Frasier happy birthday um I
268hope you're having some fun up there with all the snow um I too am so grateful for Mrs Gray and all the staff for stepping up and helping you guys have been very helpful and supportive and and I feel um I've just heard really good things about what's going on and that everyone is feeling really supportive um throughout the district I too attended the district Christmas party and um the musical entertainment by Valdez show choir and the lake view kindergarten class it was amazing and so many images um of just seeing cooperation and those kindergarteners you know and we played a game um at the party and so now I know who the competitive people are in the district um so um I just wanted to thank everyone who participated and making this um event
269so special so also um I stopped by um as Mrs Buck said to the comprehensive school threat assessment guidelines and um that are taking place throughout our district right now and I'm just so grateful for our law enforcement partners that are taking this training serious and training our staff and that we're all getting on the same page and I I really love the focus of this that it's on prevention and really working as a team approach and I I picked up some reading materials and at the training and I look forward to um being able to read through it and learn more about this program and as we hear more about it um Coming forward so that is the end of my report so now we are to the resolution this one members of the
270board um I've given you a resolution setting forth the factual findings that are necessary for denial of the material revision um I do believe that the electronic copy was sent to Mr Frasier um so you have the hard copy we also have copies that are available for members of the public um as I indicated you do have to make the written factual findings so what this resolution goes through is um for example we talked about the governance structure we talked about the independent study moratorium we talked about the insurance we talked about the transfer of the Universal Sports instit and then of course we talked about the fiscal and budgetary concerns um so those are all identified in here and um I'm happy to answer any questions that the board may have about this resolution
271but um you do need to adopt it um in order to effectuate the action that was taken by the board for for what yeah for well I want to make I want to make one suggestion may I so on page two under be it further resolved I see there that it says um hereby denies the material revisions and the material revision Charter and finds granting the material revisions not to be consistent with and then it says sound educational practice and interest of the community I think I'm not sure if sound educational practices I think they have sound educational practices there I think it's more that we were saying interests of the community which is why there was a denial is that could that be crossed out okay I don't know if you you'd have to
272agree to that but it's just a suggestion I had what is the board are we okay with that okay totally agree the only thing other thing I noticed is on the first page um where the first States uh where 1 2 3 four fifth paragraph um it just says p y LD instead of PUSD I don't if that makes a difference but this is what happens when you're rushing back back we just need a motion to adopt I'll make a motion to adopt resolution number second okay I have a motion by Mrs Buck a second by Mrs quo um we'll do a roll call Mrs blades I I I I and I am an I so the motion carries 5 to zero and with that we need to make a motion to adjourn I'll make
273a motion second okay we have a motion by Mrs blades second by Mrs quento and Mrs um blades I this is good I I I I and I'm also an I pushing carries 5 to zero and the meeting is adjourned at 10:29