CorpusRecord 109422

Board of Education Meeting — December 17, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Placentia-Yorba Linda Unified School District
Date
2024-12-20
Location
Orange County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
26,526 words · about 148 min
Collected
2026-06-20

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001I am calling the December 17th 2024 meeting of the Board of Education to order in accordance with governance code 54950 executor and Education Code sections 35140 executor at 501 p.m. we will now be adjourning to close session for the purpose of discussing the following matters Public Employee dis discipline dismissal suspension release leave assignment non- reelection nonre appointment resignation reinstatement pursuant to government code 54957 technology Services technician 3.2 Personnel matters Public Employee appointments employee pursuant to government code 54957 3.3 conference with labor negotiators Dr Alex chernes superintendent Gary Stein assistant superintendent of administrative Services Dr Isa Gates Deputy superintendent for the purposes of CCA APLE and Plum 3.4 is claims general liability claim number 647 638 claimant is Alfred ronio agency claimed against is placen Orinda Unified School District for workers compensation claim number P L

002230001 016 in the monetary amount of $770,000 is there anyone in the audience who would like to address any of these items seeing that we have none we will adjourn to close session at 5:03 p.m. all right we're going to convene to regular session at 6 reconvene I should say at 6:01 p.m. the report out of close session is as follows the board took action in close session to terminate the employment of employee ID number 1468 a permanent classified employee assigned as a tech techology Services technician motion was made by Mrs Anderson the second was by Mrs buck and the vote carried 5 to Zer the second um close session item was the board met and conferred in close session to approve workers compensation claim number P l23 001016 motion was made by Mrs Buck

003the second was made by Mrs Anderson and the motion carried 5 and that is all that is there to report and now I'm going to ask Todd Frasier to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance would you please stand ready begin I pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all all right let it be shown that our entire board and our student board member are all present tonight and I need an approval of the agenda I'll make a motion to approve the December 17th 2024 Board of Education agenda as presented I'll second I have a motion by Mr Fraser I have a second by Mrs Anderson is there any comments seeing no comments

004all those in favor I all right motion carries 5 Z with an I from our student board member public comment cards are available in the foyer cards must be completed and turned in prior to the designated time for public comment Pro we provide a maximum of three minutes per person if translation is needed an additional three minutes will be given please let us know ahead of time if you do need a translator so we can ensure that we are adequately prepared we do have a civility policy Education Code 220 prohibits discrimination on the basis of disability gender gender identity gender expression nationality race or ethnicity religion sexual orientation or any other characteristic that is contained in the definition of a hate crime set forth in 42255 of the penal code including immigration status and now

005I'm going to turn it over to Dr ches okay we have the item 11.1 I'm sorry oh sorry 10 recognition of outgoing board president all right uh good evening president blades members of the community board members executive cabinet at this time I'd like to take a moment to recognize our outgoing board president and Este teemed colleague Miss Leandra blades Miss blades was elected to the Board of Education 2020 and this past year marked her first term as president throughout this year Miss blades has exemplified leadership dedication and a commitment to our student staff families and the greater PUSD Community under her leadership the board has navigated a year filled with um important decisions and impactful work always keeping the success and well-being of our students at the Forefront her contributions have played a significant role

006in advancing the district's academic and organizational achievements and we're deeply grateful for her service to express our heartfelt appreciation for her hard work and dedication we'd like to present her with a personalized clock as a small token of our gratitude thank you Mrs blades for your leadership and for your continued service to P LUSD and Beyond thank you thank you yes that's it all right thank you very much everybody thank you for allowing me to serve as your board president for the last year it's been a fun time we got a lot accomplished and uh look forward to another four years um and keeping with the tradition I am going to go to 11.1 which is the organization of board member position and I am going to nominate Todd Frasier as president of the board

007of of education for the period of December 17 2024 through December 16th 2025 all second all right any your discussion all right we'll go ahead and move for a vote all those in favor I no no no and I'm [Applause] I I don't vote right so I'll make a a counter motion to that I'd like to nominate Marilyn uh Anderson as president of the Board of Education through December 17th 2024 through December 16th 2025 I second okay we have a motion by Mrs buck and a second by Mrs Tero any discussion I mean just the only question I have is uh is there an issue with you being with Dr chernes individually legally order on the court court no there's no issue there's no there's no legal issue causing you to not be able to

008be there's no HR issues not that I'm aware of I will uh do my best to work with Miss Anderson and and um serve the students of the district okay I I will say though that um I will say though that I do think that moving forward if you are elected as a board president if there's anything that needs to be done from the HR standpoint or if there's anything that needs to be done to help facilitate a better relationship that it should be done and I have um offered an olive leaf to Dr turnus many times and he's reciprocated and we're moving forward very good all right all those in favor I I I no no all right Mrs Anderson is the board president motion carries three to [Applause] two you thank you [Applause]

009thank you guys very much um I'm very excited to um serve as board president um and I will do my best to maintain Civility and transparency and to um bring collaboration to our district again and and to make sure that all of our students are well taken care of so thank you [Applause] okay I would like to make a motion um to nominate Carrie buck as vice president of the board of education for the period of December 17th through December 16th 2025 I second okay I have a motion by me and the second by Mrs Quin T is there any discussion no okay um we'll take a vote um all in favor say I I I I I I okay makes um motion carried five to zero and I'll make a motion that we elect

010Todd Frasier as Clerk of the Board of Education of period December 17 24 through December 16th 25 I'll second okay we have a motion by Mrs buck and a second um by Mrs blades any discussion I'm just I'm recommending Todd because he's next in order and I think that would be the right thing to do okay all in favor I I I motion carries 5-0 okay so now I need a motion to approve the minutes I'll move we approve the November 19th 2024 board meet uh board minutes uh as presented second okay are there any comments okay so we have a motion by Mrs buck and a second by Mr Frasier um all in favor I okay so we have um it's four to zero with um five to Zer five to zero Trisha wasn't

011at the that's right you sorry you although you were here with an I from our student board member thank you Luke I'll make a motion to approve the minutes of the regular meeting of December 10th 2024 as presented a second okay I have a motion by Mr Frasier and a second by Mrs blades any comment okay sorry Luke you don't get to vote on this one okay all in favor I I I I Luke was curf that night okay I I no one no one invited me I didn't get invited so I was watching another Alo basketball game so it's whatever in case you guys didn't want me hear us it's [Laughter] fine we'll try to be better with the next student board member okay we are to 13.1 a public hearing will be held

012regarding the adoption of resol resolution number 24-7 accepting the annual and 5-year developer fees report pursuant to government code section 66008 for the period of July 1st 2023 through June 30th 2024 and we'll open that at 6:14 is there anybody here that would like to speak on the developer fees report okay come on up oh okay good evening congratulations to the new board President and Vice President my name is Patricia Hanzo and it's been an interesting four years watching the school board do many several things that I don't agree with I would like to talk about developer fees and needing for more transparency and at the same time I hope in the next year or two we can actually look at the list that was developed prior to the 2020 election to see which school

013sites got sidelined for any modernization projects or programs which school sites were ignored and moved aside the school sites that are being mzed with developer fees need to spread across the district there's a chart in today's agenda that shows mainly easts Side School sites which does not seem fair to me so across the district please look at all School sites that need to be monitored construction using development developer fees since 2023 the district office starved the community starved us from information when we asked for budgets spending costs projections program design and that included the plan on how to spend developer fees so I hope that takes a change makes a change we asked that these project projects be clear and start sooner which include construction drawings for bids to last longer than 3 weeks for

014perit permits to be used and to actually go through the state agencies that are required to be informed of any construction like DSA or any other County agencies state agencies government agencies because it felt like in 2023 and in 2024 some stuff was not in compliance so I would like this board to please Focus on future projects but also keep in mind of past rushed projects projects that were rushed and done in with under 6 months which is not typical of a governing agency to do normally agencies take a year you pilot something or you make a proposal and it gets reviewed a couple times not rushed through by a governing board like this before okay we asked that you take a look at past documents to learn which school sites were deliver please focus

015on facilities that need um updates modernization hopefully not too many got sidelined and on another note to this new board I hope that President Anderson gets on the bridges of Kramer's committee because she was sidelined from that committee which is part of her territory so just something to think about thank you for your time congratulations everyone thank you is there anybody else wanting to speak on developer fees okay okay seeing then we'll close the hearing at 617 now it's time for a student board report Mr Luke uh good evening president Anderson uh trustees superintendent Dr chernes and executive cabinet members I'm excited to be here tonight to share recent updates from our comprehensive high schools and alternative campuses and I'm sorry if I sound a little stuffy I've been a little sick these past few

016weeks so mind if I cough or if I sneeze in between these uh B of Vista Virtual Academy and park Fel School are wrapping up the semester and getting into the holiday spirit tomorrow December 18th elementary students will perform cheerful holiday songs for family and friends following the performance they will enjoy their annual gringas pancake breakfast genuinely sponsored by the PTA secondary students will have the opportunity to earn community service hours while helping serve families and spreading holiday cheer this is always a wonderful Community event as we head into winter break El Camino has been very busy with several College and Career events for students as well as festivities to celebrate the holidays and at the end of the first semester last week El Camino held career day where speakers representing career fields that students

017express interest in Shar highlights about their education background and professional highlights career day speakers included a nurse teacher police officer electrician HVAC technician cosmetologist district attorney uh entrepreneur wealth manager and nonprofit executive in addition PUSD HR Representatives presented District job opportunities and Ro met with students to share CTE course offerings the Raptors are celebrating the holidays with a Winterfest week from December 16th to 19th staff and students will show their Spirit by wearing winter accessories flannels holiday sweaters and pajamas each day the highlight of winter frest is their quarterly student appreciation barbecue where all students receive a barbecue Lunch hot chocolate and treats specific students are recognized for their second quarter successes including attendance effort Improvement and helpfulness additionally their tree of thanks has been replaced by a tree of wishes where staff and students

018will write down their resolutions and hopes for the new year on December 4th the elderado golden h hosted their annual High School showcase for eighth grade students and their families the night was a huge success the Performing Arts Center was standing room only and the Overflow overflow crowd watched the live stream in the practice gym guests enjoyed impressive highlights videos showcasing all areas of the nest including the Arts Athletics activities dmaa Ed law and of course academics the highlight of the Showcase every year is the current Golden Hawks who take the stage to share their stories about life at Lorado the evening concluded with the time honor tradition of joining the the golden hawkk drum line for the rain dance on December 13th during the annual winter rally the entire Golden Hawk student body and

019staff were treated to Sierra V Sierra Visa Eagles transitional kindergarten classes rendition of Do You Want to Build a Snowman from the movie Frozen additionally edhs ASB granted 10 wishes for students this year through their wishbox initiative both moments creating lasting Memories the old Golden Hawk marching band recently passed third and earned the bronze medal in the largest and most competitive field at the s C SB OA 6A championships at citus College the history tradition and spirit of this group are legendary in the world of high school marching bands and the nest is incredibly proud of their remarkable achievements this marks the second bronze medal in the past three years of the Golden Hawks the Aztecs are currently selling tickets for their district-wide winter formal which will bring together all students from all five pusc

020high schools this St is for p pusc students and we're all incredibly excited espon just finished their winter week filled with dress up days hot cocoa candy canes holiday hats and even snow it was a great way to get the Aztecs into the holiday spirit on Tuesday December 12th esparanza visited Ruby Drive Elementary School for their annual holiday exchange over 25 clubs and sports teams gave gifts to every Ruby Ruby Drive student in return Ruby Drive students made cards sang songs and created crafts for the Aztecs it was such a fun and heartwarming holiday event the aexs are geing up for their finals which began this week students are studying hard and working to Master the material covered during the first semester and witer sports are in full swing with all teams in preseason and

021geing up for their league competition and huge shout out to the espira entertainment unit who came home from a championships with third place finish in division 4A this is the highest ranking the EU has ever received thanks uh thanks to their amazing aexs aexs and director Mr Davis a George key students and staff would like to thank Lake View principal Mrs given secretary Sarah Basel and custodian Jose for their assistance and for hosting the Sunrise Rotary holiday party on Friday December 13th at Lake View George key students and staff enjoyed a visit from Santa gifts and a staff luncheon Sunrise Rotary has partnered with George key for over 40 years to make this event special this year Santa had a present for every student and sunz rotary presented principal Allen with a $2,000 check raised

022through rotary's Lobster Fest fundraiser special thanks to David swe Char nap and the uh rans for their generosity and commitment to George Key School at Venture Academy students had the honor of serving coffee and donuts to principles during the principal meeting on December 12th students Moises and Bailey did a fantastic job providing treats for their group Moises and Bailey enjoyed working on the coffee cart will begin set setting up a monthly coffee cart at the district office set set starting in January for you guys uh this program allows District employees to purchase a little pickme up while supporting Venture students Moises and Bailey are paid through the workability program and calculated the overhead cost time and labor before presenting Educational Service with an invoice thank you to the Board of Education Dr chernis exe executive

023cabinet Educational Service and the district office staff for supporting their growing coffee business George key and Venture Academy students and staff wish everyone a joyous holiday season at Valencia the mock trial team defeated Newport Harbor to qualify for the playoffs finishing the season ranked in top 10 in Orange County you look forward to scrimming Elder a in January in preparation for next year's competitions Valena celebrated 29 students receiving AP National Rec AP National recognition for their achievements representing diverse diverse backgrounds including National Hispanic African-American indigenous and first generation students the tigers are proud of these trailblazing students fena hosted its second annual Pate teacher fundraiser for lot 318 an organization uh serving the local Placentia Community 15 teachers volunteer to be pied by students raising $480 30 minutes and collecting over 150 toy donations for

024lot 318 would you guys get or no I was thinking about that you guys get ped okay good yeah do you like the little game you can play it's like the board game and you can press the thing and it it pies you in the face you have it it's scary it's like I'm down uh the Mustangs fall Sports season ended with three League championships women's volleyball women's tennis and men's water polo freshman Sophia uh dumitru bang placed in the top 20 in division 1 tennis the football team reached the CF semi-finals division 2 and head coach varsity Jeff Bailey was named Orange County coach of the year he was recognized at the NFL La Chargers game on Sunday women's cross country placed eth in the state for the second consecutive year in division three

025and Mustang Toren habitad placed 24th out of 20 214 runners in the state meet an impressive accomplishment at the highest level of competition um that concludes my written board report but uh this is my last meeting so I just wanted to thank everyone on the board for their hospit Hospitality everyone who's uh reached out to me it's been really nice up here and I'm really grateful for this opportunity so thank you guys and that concludes my final board report president Anderson uh if I may oh um I have a question for Luke he's not he's not escaping without his final question gosh um now that your time as student board member has come to an end what would you say has been your biggest takeaway from this experience and what would you offer our incoming

026board member advice um I was thinking about it and I was thinking about when you go to elementary school and you go to middle school and you keep going up and you kind of realize that there's always someone higher in the scale of things like when you're in elementary school you're like oh you're teacher right it's like number one she makes all the rules or he makes all the rules and then Middle School you're like oh the principal right they make all the rules and then you realize there's a superintendent and a the board and uh it makes me realize how hard you guys all work and how hard uh you guys all work to help each student and make each campus better and it's it's been really cool experience seeing all the behind the

027scenes stuff that you guys do and you know helping to be a part of that as much as I can I think that's a really cool opportunity and my advice to next board member is to just is to be yourself I mean you speak for the students so try to keep that in mind and uh just don't don't be shy you know be ready to speak I try I I try not to be shy up here too I don't know if you guys noticed but uh it took you a while to come out of your shell yeah just you definitely have not been uh but yeah that'd be my advice and that would be my answer to the question so thank you for asking well thank you so much Luke we really appreciate it I'm

028going to turn the time over to Dr chis all right so um good evening president Anderson members of the school board at this time I'd like to take a moment to recognize our outgoing uh oh boy sorry this time our outgoing student board member uh Luke Gilstrap he's represented our schools in our district well um extremely well and uh it's been a pleasure working with Luke this this semester um we had a good conversation uh before the meeting and be sure to come back and um I'm happy to help you out in any way in in your future endeavors um his reports have always been thorough his feedback insightful but more importantly he's been genuine um and really shared what what the students feel feel and believe in what you feel and [Applause] believe so

029Luke um we wish you success um after graduation and Beyond um at this um at this moment we'd like to uh um present to you a commemorative plaque um to uh yes to honor your service and Luke while you're walking up and getting this I um while I was at csba I was at one of the workshops and one of the board members that was presenting had been a student board member as well so you never know what's going to happen and we'll all be waiting for the drop of your first podcast episode well I just wanted to say I think you guys aren my co-workers you're my friends you know what I'm saying so we're all friends now that's right even though you guys may might be a little more older than me but

030you know we're we're friends not not much though not much don't like 21 21 22 20 20 yeah Luke I appreciate all that you did you like were a great sport um you kept the board meetings Lively like you were honest like that people saying genuine and um you weren't afraid to say where you stood on things which was really good um and so we really enjoyed having you and um I just wish you the best in the future and good luck and I think you're going to do great things Luke um it's been really fun getting to know you and um seeing how you work in in this type of environment but most importantly I've loved seeing you on the campus at El Dorado in your element and leading the students at Eldorado High

031School it's you're a rem remarkable leader and um you're you're going to do great things and and we're so proud of you so thank you so much for serving with us okay um now I'll turn the time over to Dr ches for the superintendent's report okay good evening president Anderson members of the board um first of all I'd like to welcome atricia quento to the school board [Applause] [Music] [Applause] Mrs Quintero um is representing area one um she holds a b Bachelor's of Science degree in child development from Cal State Fullerton as well as multiple subject teaching credential and a master's of Education degree um she's lived in Placentia for 24 years with her husband and two children who are proud graduates of p schools with over 25 years of experience as an elementary school

032teacher has served in leadership roles such as grade level chair School site council member and PTA representative she's also been deeply involved in her Children's Schools including serving as PTA president at Wagner and PTSA president at Eldorado High School her dedication earned her multiple PTA honory Service Awards and recognitions as Eldorado High School's 2024 Community honory um Trisha welcome uh I look forward to working with you and um I know you're going to be a a tremendous board member member um and a great uh uh representative to our community so congratulations um as the new board um prepares for uh 2025 and Beyond um I'd like to propose a workshop session for the board um this would be a dedicated time for us to come together and collaboratively discuss strategic goals for our district um

033it's an ideal time um an opportunity for us to align our efforts and set a unified direction that will guide our decision-making in the months and years ahead a workshop would provide the time and space for open dialogue idea sharing and thoughtful collaboration by working together we can identify clear actionable priorities that reflect shared values and Visions I really do believe it's time for us to come together as a community um what I've seen is a clear dichotomy between some of the negativity that we see in here in board meetings and what I see and here when I visit the school sites our district has the best principles I've ever worked with the best group of teachers and support staff I've ever seen and there's tangible data to support this we've increased student test scores

034in our district we're growing our district we have families enrolling at increasing rates we're building new preschools and we're sparking Innovative um Innovation amongst our staff so it's my hope that these board meetings begin to reflect the success and positivity that we see in our schools um and that's my pledge to support that despite our Positive Growth we must remain focused on getting more kids at grade level and above in ela and math um that is my primary focus um and that it's that of our in our administrative team too the interventions we put in place the instructional best practices the inclusive strategies that we're talking about and and con continue to focus on we have many more students in our district thousands of kids that are below grade level and so we need to

035support them lastly yesterday's trategy in Madison Wisconsin reminds us that school safety is of the utmost utmost priority um so as a board and executive team we need to study our current school safety program um I would recommend that that is one of the board priorities um that we would discuss it should the board agree to a workshop so I do look forward to the opportunity to work together um as we outline our Collective goals and chart our path forward together we can achieve meaningful outcomes that will strengthen our district um finally I'd like to thank uh Gary Stein with uh our deepest gratitude this will be his last meeting for his contributions to P USD um although you've you've been with us for just over a year your dedication and your passion have really

036left a mark with our staff um your role was by no means an easy one yet you consistently approached every challenge with remarkable calmness and resilience your ability to maintain composure under pressure and your commitment to making things happen has been um remarkable so we're profoundly thankful to you you will be greatly missed um so we uh we wish you the best in your future endeavors and um hopeful for uh Cal calmer Waters ahead um and so F finally happy holidays um uh we want to extend our warmest wishes to everyone uh the joy and spirit of the holidays are upon us it's a it's a great time for reflection gratitude and I know many of our teachers out there um need a a well- earned break so um we're almost there we have three

037more days of school left and uh wishing you all a happy holiday season [Applause] thank you Dr chernes okay now it is time for public comment public comment is an opportunity for the public to provide input to the Board of Education during the public comment period board members do not dialogue with speakers or make comments regarding the information shared we have 12 people wishing to speak tonight so each speaker will be given 2 minutes um also if speakers can repeat their name when they come up to speak and I'll call the first four speakers to sit on the first row our first speaker is Sue Sawyer Andy Falco is our second speaker third is Anita Lee and fourth Linda con Sue Sawyer good evening I stand here tonight with serious concerns regarding the actions and

038decisions taking place in our district first why were staff members who tried to protect the district from illegal or unethical spending subjected to investigations demotions and terminations administrators have been threatened with financial penalties and then given impossible ultimatums a director with 28 years of service was forced to resign after reporting potential Financial mismanagement another was forced out by a hostile work environment after raising fiscal concerns employees who speak out against corruption and fiscal male feasant are retaliated against time and again this raises serious questions about the ethics of those currently serving in leadership positions next why does an ed services tosa have CTE in their title when their primary responsibility is overseeing the computer instructional specialists in elementary unrelated to CTE is this to justify spending or funding their position with CTE Grant monies lastly

039the board's recent decision to extend contracts for four executive administrators under dubious circumstances and then provide them with additional protection from being fired even for cause only adds fuel to the fire of Suspicion this kind of back room deal making only serves to perpetuate the fraud wasting corruption that now plagues the district and given how board members blades Frasier and yland went out of their way to minimize the significance and impact of the many district leaders and school sight administrators who have been released or threatened with reassignment by this cabinet just in the past year is the height of hypocrisy we deserve better leadership we deserve fiscal transparency and we demand accountability thank you Andy Falco out of the 50 States California schools are 40th and 49th in education and safety due to the negative

040influence of the teachers union cabal here in PUSD we have the same teachers union attacking and threatening the existence of the best school in our country Orange County School of computer science and the best principal by far Dr Beth Fischer the attacks and lies are absurd in every way in social media groups the teachers union Representatives proudly say they own Trisha quento and Marilyn Anderson and claim quento and Anderson will absolutely and promptly close ocscs and fire Dr Fischer Dr chernis and Dr Gates my son and other students at ocss are thriving at the school I recently spent 3 days speaking uh for the to the students at ocscs and spoke to several teachers in the Teachers Lounge and to a person they have OC they love ocscs and the teachers love working at the

041school I did not see a phone on a student's hand in a student's hand the entire time and I was at the school uh every day that I was at the school and every student was polite and well disciplined I pray in implore all of you to stand strong and do not allow the teachers union to dismantle this District as they claim they are going to do and before I leave I just want to say Luke is an amazing uh friend to my my son over at Eldorado High School they're on the same lacrosse team he has a great teammate and uh he's just an example of what we have here at Eldorado High School uh Luke is a hard player strong player he hits hard spends a lot of time in the Penalty Box

042uh I get lots of pictures of in The Penalty Box but Luke you are a an example of what uh we can produce here at PUSD so thank you for all you do thank [Applause] you hi my name is Anita Lee and I have never been happier to attend a school board meeting um and I just want to thank you superintendent chernes for your remarks and I hope they were genuine and I hope this is beginning a new era where the temperature and atmosphere of everything comes down to peace and civility I just want to express my deepest gratitude and congratulations to trustees quento and Anderson on their well-deserved election in reelection and um of course to trusty Anderson as you began serving as board president it has been my fervent desire and that of

043so many others in our community of vested parents teachers administrators and counselors who truly Champion public education service and care of and camaraderie among our students and families to restore peace stability transparency responsibility due diligence and listening ears in the governing board of PUSD as well as to restore High staff and teacher morale My Hope Is that this board together with trustees Buck blades and Frasier will now use all your voices and Authority humbly and conscientiously to serve reason and the common good of all students and to be responsive to the will of your constituents as shared in these public comments during these board meetings as as well as hopefully future Town Hall meetings over the next four years I hope and pray that all five of you will work collaboratively peaceably and responsibly so

044that you and we as a community find joy and confidence in your leadership and service so thank you for any willingness to pursue that too good evening welcome aboard trustee cantero uh Luke and uh Mr Stein we will miss you thank you for your good work and um bless you um last week Apple president Linda Manion told us that voters were given a lot of information in the recent election and the result was that the public convincingly chose a different direction I am not questioning the vote what I question is the information that was given to voters was this information always the truth I knocked on probably a few thousand doors before the election and when I described the Orange County School of computer science and the uh Universal Sports Institute to prospective voters there

045was almost Universal positive reaction they saw these as Innovative uh worthwhile programs to have but there was one persistent rumor that I ran up against that money to upgrade Valena cafeteria long overdue had been diverted to fund the computer science school and the sports Institute this was repeatedly denied I believe that is absolutely not true and the best proof is the fact that we're doing all of the above right now just as Dr churna said we were able to do I am remind Ed that voters in the orange recall were frequently lied to they were deceived they were given misinformation I talked to several personally they were very very upset and angry I would hope that the same thing was not widespread in our own District but I'm really quite Disturbed at the constant statements

046of deep seated corruption referencing to the uh school and my time has run out more later thank [Applause] you than um the next four we have Matt Wilkerson Patricia Hanzo yeah Holly um pich and Linda Manion and good evening Matt Wilkerson father of two in the district according to board byon 902 9021 trustees have a responsibility to act in the best interest of the district I'm here tonight to argue that the former board majority has willfully willfully neg neglected those responsibilities Miss blades Mr Fraser knowingly allowed and empowered the superintendent to unethically attempt to take the Orange County School of computer science and the USI out of the district's control and attempt to hand it off to an independent board made up of compliant insiders this was done not to improve educational outcomes as is

047their mandate but to hide Financial mismanagement that occurred under the previous administration this action would have cost the district millions and lost Ada funding as well as the loss of valuable fiscal assets that would have been paid for by taxpayer money no amount of gas lining by the superintendent can dispute that fact I implore Mr Stein to share any information he has about how funds have been moved around to fund both of these initiatives No One Believes the USI is only cost $1.4 million when you factor an Architects construction at casaloma Bernard Yoba equipment purchase Staffing insurance and the fees of the training lab is charging the district in addition to fiscal transparency moving forward I would also ask like to ask for a full review of the super inance performance as required by board

048bylaw 921b this is long overdue the bylaw State the superintendent is supposed to work for the board and the district Dr chernes has repeatedly demonstrated his own self-interest supered the obligations he has to PUSD under his administration this district has suffered irreparable neglect staff loss and potential fraud regarding the USI it is time to put an end to this self-dealing and poor leadership thank you as a parent and homeowner I'd like our tax money to be accounted for so any disclosures on financial spending by the financial department or any employee can please come out I would love to see whistleblowers as far as the workshops that the superintendent mentioned I just hope they do not violate the brown Act and I hope workshops or meetings that do not include the public are not intended to

049bottleneck ideas or filter ideas that our board trustees have those discussions required by the board by the brown act should happen during open meetings not in some Workshop where the public is not present on item 18.3 the first interim report for Bernardo Yorba Middle School School site the computer science school started in August it's only had one report card ever so it's shocking to see how it was going to be pulled away and given away as a gift to become an independent charter school I encourage you to look into the finances and I find it very unprofessional for a Park View school to be negative negatively impacted because students were pulled away that should not have happened Park View school has existed for a long time and we need to keep it strong so please

050support it do not gut it I encourage trustees to bring transparency in planning budgets program design project development and Audits and I also have this thing that I like books and so I remember the lit review process was flipped upside down putting a trustee as step one where in the past that was not the case please bring back the original lit review process and help employees do their job without fear qualified and trained teachers know what they're doing thank you m hzo hi my name is Holly Peach and I should be homeg grading 150 essays tonight but I came to support my friend Leandra and all of the others that um have to deal with quite a bit up here on a weekly basis I came to the board meeting two years ago in a

051green sweatsuit and those of you behind me know what that means I showed up in Full Green outfit having no idea what was going on I just heard there was chaos up at the district and I wanted to come check it out see for myself what was going on um and it didn't take me long to figure it out I am a teacher and I have so many conservative friends that are teachers and I text them or email them and say what what is this where lion Leandra is against teachers because Leandra is supportive of teachers and students and tolerate so much I have never seen a woman that has had to endure as much online as Leandra in fact the recent article Leandra got shived by her Ally um young blood and then others

052in this room are cheering that on saying great article this is good and yet the next uh comment out of someone up here is let's return to civility so Marilyn I know you said civility I hope that you understand what's going on in the background because it's a lot of chaos and as a teacher I have had teachers talk down about principles and then the minute that principal was removed all of a sudden they're on the Rampage to have all my students walk out of my class and boycott what was going on so they're talking out of both sides of their mouth I have had a teach stand up and say I'm Queer on the first day of school I have had a teacher put a six- foot pride flag in her classroom but I

053went in on back to school night and it was removed I have had a fellow teacher call me and my friends Maga far right extremist and yet make fun of Dr Gates wonderful outfits out of the so these things can't happen we can't be speaking out of both sides of our mouth thank you so much Linda Manion president of the association of penal Linda Educators and I'm here tonight for one reason and that's to congratulate our board to welcome Trisha quino to thank you Luke you've been amazing wish all of you wonderful holiday season and look forward to January where we can all continue the good work that we do every day so happy holidays everyone welcome and we have a new a new new New Vista in January thank you thank you our next

054speakers are Ben stubs David Peterson priia Shaw and Mark Ferry hi good evening uh members of the board superintendent and Community my name is Ben stubs and um I wanted to speak on um if I may uh agenda item 20 1.1 um I urge you to vote no as we have in the past on joining the California School Board Association otherwise known as a csba our district was previously a member uh but canceled its membership because it didn't find Value and uh chose to invest those funds elsewhere so first the cost is very significant I think uh $1,614 for six months membership or $35,000 annually for uh the csba membership and these funds they could be better spent directed um benefiting the uh students and the teachers and um improving classroom resources and expanding student

055programs second many of the S SC um csba services like legal support and policy samples of which there's over like 640 of those just kind of cookie cutter policies um those are kind of duplicate resources that we already have including legal counsel policy tools and season staff uh this makes uh membership redundant I think so lastly CS U ba prioritizes Statewide political initiatives that may not align with P usd's priorities and their mission is quote to Define and drive the public education policy agenda so I think taxpayers shouldn't pay $35,000 annually for training um aligned with Statewide politics for elected board members I think our district thrives better on on um addressing local needs and maintaining control of our policies for students and our teachers so in short and otherwise it doesn't make sense for

056me that we would elect our um our chosen leaders to the board and then have our chosen leaders um request uh training uh with the district footing the bill of 30,000 $35,000 a year in order for them to receive leadership training so um thank you for consideration uh vote no please uh on that uh item number 21.1 thank you [Applause] he did a good job of being here out right on the time uh Dave peton and good to see uh new faces and a new design here and uh speaking to a couple items first of all welcome to Trisha um so many are thrilled uh to see your contribution to the board and the future that you bring thank you uh next Gary thank you for being that smiling and objective face over there in

057the corner uh I know Huntington Beach I think that's the target uh will be you know benefiting greatly from your objectivity your Clarity and your projection thank you for what you brought us here um next the kind of picky back on the positivity concept that you're bringing Dr chernes uh kind of to the overall design helping to make that happen one of the things that happened last year in May June was that something didn't happen here at the board is that all the retiring teachers from the district were not recognized and honored for their service there was never a time for that and you know when a person puts their life into teaching U they're not looking for the reward but it just really feels complete when you get that respect back at you from

058those in leadership so I hope in next year's calendar that's included uh or those that have served you know have that opportunity to be recognized and as positivity as that moves into the the staff area and staff no longer have to be worried about keeping their heads down uh they can express their thoughts freely don't have to worry about being moved from job site to another job site without request that'll help a lot thank you [Applause] trustee gilst you did an excellent job and I wish you the best of luck in the future president Anderson you have shown that you are a careful thoughtful and persistent leader what I ask is that you continue to seek out the voices of those especially students whose life experiences are different than yours so that all of our

059students can be treated with dignity and truly put first truste Quintero congratulations on your election by an overwhelming majority of your constituents I welcome the perspective of an educator and involved parent and PTA participant on the board and I ask that you listen to all of us and to respond to our Communications trustee Buck congratulations on your position as VP of the board you have shown your dedication and commitment to our students in community for Far Over a decade now I ask that you help lead our school district forward word again focusing and returning returning us to a focus on academic Excellence something that has been lost in the culture wars of the last four years and superintendent chernes I ask that you attempt to work with this new board and with our community without

060patronizing us I think that you will find us to be an Engaged smart and dedicated group of parents and that we can be partners in the school district not the enemy thank you all so much Mark Fury I'm looking forward to uh the new board trying to work together that would be fabulous um but I just want to maybe speak on behalf there's very few conservatives that really have the guts to come up here and talk okay and when you talk about the uh charter school and if you saw the faces of the teachers that left this room last week and the lack of support that they are perceiving they're they're afraid those teachers are afraid to speak up here the students that go to that school are afraid to speak up here and they're

061not being heard and so I just hope that you guys supported a charter school and stop putting roadblocks and say how are we going to make it successful and then if it doesn't become successful then you can start to change it but the public outside in my group is hearing the word out there that the new liberal board is wants to kill the charter school and I hope that's not true okay thank [Applause] you okay that concludes public comments and now we are at General functions and so we need a motion for 17.1 I'll make a motion to approve the 2025 Board of Education meeting schedule second okay I have a motion by Mrs blaze a second by Mrs Buck are there any comments I just had one comment that I would like we have

062um an lcap time attached to one of our board meetings I'd like to set aside some separate time to go through elcap because we'll be looking at ours as well as ocscs so making sure we have enough dedicated time to look at that so a separate one would be great and I also had a question you mentioned a workshop um and I don't see that on this proposed schedule do you have a thought about when you want to do that there's a there's a couple study sessions when I say Workshop it's a board study session so it's a public meeting um uh one would be um uh on board goals and the other would be on budget and so uh I think both of those should happen before March um what I can do if

063the if the board is amendable is have a net um look at the calendar if there's an interest in those study sessions and pull the board on availability I think that would be a really good idea to have some possible dates and sent out to the board so that everybody could be there and and um it will be acceptable um I was looking at the calendar um because I also was concerned that we didn't have enough time last year to do the lcap and um and now we have to do um OCS cs's lcap as well so I was kind of looking at April 22nd we're at Spring break the week before April 14th through 18th um how do you we should do have to make sure that um principal fiser is also available too

064so we'd have to coordinate with her well right now the lcap review study session is on the 8th so this would be a regular board meeting so you want to do the ocscs during a regular board meeting or before oh yeah yeah which one okay so the lcap review study session right now is on the calendar for April 8th right so we have to do our districts and ocss and I'm just proposing another date on the 22nd that we would have like our regular board meeting so we would take care of the lcap oh so not to so I thought you were asking to move the so or we could reverse it it doesn't either one either way works um I don't know what the rest of the board thinks about that maybe we could

065do some calendar search and then bring it back with a updated board obviously not spring break I mean board minut yeah the spring break is the 14th it's the week before so it' be like a board meeting spring break and then another board meeting so let let's you guys so you guys want to that might impact your school okay so let's um look at the calendar look at the calendar and have Mrs Newton send us out some dates for a possible date and then we can update the um board schedule at the January meeting I would also if if we're going to do that it might be advantageous to actually have the lcap be that second meeting just so that it doesn't have to be a Tuesday regular meeting so we could do any day

066of the week and not have an issue there we usually do regular meeting for the lcap study session right no I'm just saying but if we're going to have an additional meeting yeah so You' prefer that later in the month that would be great in the past when we held two separate meetings in April the lcap study session was the latter one gives us a little more time okay okay so perfect and then as just as we bring back the workshops on budget just making sure that we're pass the um January budget through the governor and all that so that we're not replicating another meeting yeah yeah we'd like to know what he's planning first yeah I don't know if he knows sometimes good question well we'll find out in January okay but it could

067always change in February okay so we have is there any more discussion before we call for the people have Outburst what so maybe we approve it as this but we give direction to bring it back as a um as another calendar as well for addition y so we're not not approving it we should approve it and then bring that back I think we should approve it but should we amend it to come bring it back to bring it back Carrie tell her the language to say you had good Lang right there yeah uh we're going to approve it today and bring it back at the next meeting to add in additional meetings related to workshop and elap perfect what she said I'll second perfect okay so I think we're ready to vote all in favor

068I I I I I okay it sounds like we have a plan a plan and um an i and any oppose I guess I should say I I figured we were unified in that and Luke um and an I from our student board member because he loves to come to our meetings make his calendar yeah okay moving on um want a motion we need a motion for 17.2 for the um Orange County committee on School District organization uh I'll make a motion that we uh the nominating representative the Orange County committee on school organization will be uh elect Mar Marilyn Anderson is the district's nominating representative to the Orange County committee on School District organization um and elect Trisha quento as the alternate you would need a second all second and the reason that I

069did this um that I nominated Marilyn is because she did it last year it's literally one meeting and you got I think you did it before that I did like all four years it's like one it's like one one thinge it's very easy yeah so if you're okay with that we'll Mrs Anderson doing that again yeah I'm fine doing that works out very conveniently okay and is there any other discussion okay all in favor I I okay looks like motion carries we have a a 5 vote and an I from our student board member okay now we're to business services do we have a motion for 18.1 sorry I'm getting my next page I'll make a motion to accept the annual independent audit report for the 2324 fiscal year I'll second okay we have a

070motion by Mrs blades and the second by Mr Frasier and I'll turn the time over to um Mr Mr Stein who will introduce this item thank you very much uh thank you president Anderson uh members of the board uh superintendent Dr chis members of cabinet and our friends and and staff members in the audience um per the requirements of Education Code districts are required to undergo an annual audit which is performed by an independent audit firm uh this report must be presented to the board by January 31st each year and it covers the financial data for the preceding fiscal year so 2324 uh with that is my pleasure uh to welcome up Miss Jessica Barry with our audit firm Nigro and Nigro uh who will be sharing the results of our 2324 annual Financial audit

071uh Miss Barry is a certified public accountant and partner with the firm and specializes in the audit and accounting uh requirements for K12 school districts Miss Barry welcome thank you and then is one live Yes sounds like it uh thank you for the introduction as I said my name is Jessica Barry I'm a partner with Nigro and Nigro uh for presentations I usually just do a brief overview of our process for the annual audit and then kind of highlights of what's in the report and then I'm more than happy to answer any questions if you'd like me to dig into more detail and particular areas so as far as our process as we're conducting the audit this is really going on throughout the fiscal year starts um beginning of the calendar year and kind of

072works its way all the way through eventually to the audit report so we're starting in kind of spring from now and we start with what we call our site visits we're looking at attendance and ASB procedures when we go out to the individual sites so we pull a sample of your school sites on a rotating basis we look at their attendance taking procedures and then for the schools with asbs we also look at their cash handling procedures their expenditures they receeding making sure they have proper checks and balances at those asbs the attendance side obviously a large amount of your funding is driven by your attendance this reported and so we want to make sure you have proper controls over attendance taking at your individual School sites fast forward a little bit we come back

073out kind of in spring or summer depending on the districts and at that point we're working with the business services here at the actual district office and some with Educational Services a few different departments and we're looking at again controls and compliance but over a quite a variet areas at that point in time your books aren't closed for the year so we're not looking at final Financial numbers but we're making sure for your expenditures that you have proper pre-approvals that there's proper documentation for money coming in there's timely deposits again proper uh documentation trails that we can trace back we also look at a variety of State compliance that can be anything from looking at an expenditure for a certain program to make sure it's allowable posting notices by certain dates some of the after

074school programs there's a lot of different things in state compliance that we're required to look at and then we also look at Federal compliance on a rotating um sample of program so we look at different programs each year and we'll kind of circle through and make sure we're hitting your different main Federal programs and look at compliance over those as well fast forward again we come back in the fall at this point your books are closed for the year we're past the June 30th fiscal year end so we're really looking at final Financial numbers this is where we dig in on the financial side we're working through your unaudited actuals and we're tying out the numbers in those United actuals to documentation this can be tracing your cash balance to County cash confirmations tracing accounts

075payable to invoices things like that but kind of working our way through those unaudited actuals to make sure they're presented fairly all of that leads to a lovely audit report that you would have received not the most fun reading in the world I admit and I actually write these but I'm saying they're a little bit on the dry side but I'll kind of give you the highlights as you go through very very opening after the table of contents is our opinion letter this is a clean or unmodified opinion so what you're looking for saying that we agree that the financial statements as presented here are presented fairly in all material aspects that's what that opening letter is once you get past that letter there's about from pages about 4 to 11 or so um is

076the managements discussion and Analysis so what this is is really just um shortened versions of the financial statements but it presents a two-year history so current year as well as prior year and you can kind of see what went up what went down in different areas with some very brief General explanations of that so I think it's a good kind of cliffnotes so to speak of the rest of the audit report that's presented in those pages move past that you've got your main financial statements these are all laid out in detail you have government-wide as well as the fund financial statements which are going to lined up more similar to what you would be normally looking at with budgets things like that and then the bulk of the audit report is really notes required disclosures

077that we have to put in there that's where the dry reading comes in lots of notes on pension OPB any type of debt have a lot of required disclosure so that's what really the bulk in the middle is of the audit reports and then toward the end additional schedules on debt and then there's a few um kind of ing schedules there'll be your average daily attendance for the year will be presented there your instructional minutes by grade level a schedule of your expenditures for your federal Awards throughout the year so those are kind of the ones that are tending to be a little bit more interesting toward the back and then we've got opinion letters after that so the first one is really the overall Financial audit opinion the ones in the back there's three

078one on governmental auditing standards and then a state and a federal so that's what those are laid out and then any findings or management comments are presented at the very end after that as well as any followup on previous your findings if there are any there so again that's a very quick overview of what's in an audit report more than happy to dig in answer any specific questions or go into more detail in any area can you talk a little bit about the findings please um sure so way in the back here when you get into findings you guys wound up this year with two that are both non-financial impact findings these are both related to State compliance areas that we look at the first one make sure I'm doing them in order here first

079one was really just the datee a a notice being posted so there's requirements of when you have to have certain notices posted in in advance of meetings and this one it was a 10-day requirement it wound up getting posted 7 days so it was just a couple days late on the posting no Financial impact on that particular one uh next one is elop ratio so this is actually a new program under audit this year so this is the first year it's being audited for any school district uh the again non-financial finding on this one um it's just having documentation on certain ratios this is I will say probably the most common a finding that our firm has written this year this has been an extremely common one some of the difficulty has been there's always

080been a 20 to1 ratio for the Asis program that a lot of districts already operated when they implemented elop they added an additional 10:1 ratio if you had Kinder or TK so it really switched because now you can't really look at it program-wide you have to look at it by individual groups because there's two different ratios in play and so there's a lot of adjustments that district has to do kind of on their documentation side of that one so again non-financial that one's been a very very common finding that we've written this year those are the two findings correct anybody else have any questions I did so the the ASB findings you had in the back um related to uh the recommendations for bank reconciliations and and all that I know we've discussed a new

081program to Monitor and manage all the ASB funds has that been put in place as of now because I know this is previous year yeah been put in place um and again this is 23 24 so you know but um yet that is in place and we're working with staff at all of the sites to make sure that they're implementing um the guidance from our Auditors I just want to follow up with that question it seems like ASB comes up every year with findings and um I'm not dishing on You Luke but I just um and I know we've talked about trainings and things like that what else can we do to help the schools so that we can get our asbs um in line well I I think the the software implementation that's been

082put in place now to manager like basically an accounting software um that wasn't in place before that I think Gary can speak to that yeah so it's it's a combination of more oversight um we are providing training we need to do that probably more often so right if you do a training once a year uh staff members tend to uh they forget throughout the year and as things and school sites are very busy we all know that um and there's a lot of rush to get things done and so I think um reinforcement uh making sure that we're doing um audits which I know our team does uh throughout the year we'll we'll pull records and and look at them and then we'll we'll follow up with school sites if we notice any discrepancies or

083anything that we're concerned about um so I think following along with that but more more training more often maybe in shorter bursts rather than having somebody sit in a room for four to 6 hours and learn something but um and and I think that the team has a plan for that okay thank you I think that would really be helpful we have a lot of new principles and a lot of new um assistant principles in all of our high schools and middle schools so um just so we can get ahead of it so we don't have this problem again anybody else have any questions okay thank you Mrs Barry thank you thank you very much um thank you Mrs Barry thank you to Jeff Nigro our our partner that we've been working with and their

084staff for their thought for work and the completion of our annual Financial audit I'd also want to extend a thanks to our fiscal services and business services team for their efforts working to get all the data and everything ready for this so um we recommend their staff recommends that the report be accepted as presented okay I too would like to thank everybody in your office for all their hard work and I know this is this is kind of like um a final for your your team so thank you so thank you guys okay with no more comments all in favor I I okay it looks like we have a five to zero with um an I from our student board member motion is carried 18.2 okay I'll make motion I to approve the 2024 to2

085first interim Report with a positive certification a positive certification indicates that based upon current projections the district will meet in its Financial Obligations for the current fiscal year and subsequent to fiscal years second okay we have a motion by Mrs blade a second by Mr Frasier I'll turn the time over to Mr Stein thank you for the opportunity to stand up I really appreciate that thank you and good evening again um how do I get over there Jeremy just press the button there we go uh good evening tonight we're going to go over a review our 2425 first inter room report this is the first official revision to the district's adopted budget uh the report contains actual financial data through October 31st of this year as well as revised revenue and expenditure projections based on

086the latest information we have available the agenda for tonight we're going to talk about the state's uh economic Outlook um we will get into the first inter room report we want to touch based on how the district has adapted to changes in overall shortfalls and revenue streams uh we'll also talk about budget challenges where we're at and um plans for 25 26 and then of course we'll talk about where we're going to next so the Lao is a legislative analyst office it's a nonpartisan agency that provides fiscal advice advice to the legislature they produce economic out an economic Outlook each year along with a number of other reports but this really this report that they provide in November is what the governor's office really bases their initial January budget proposal on or they included in

087there uh so we want to share some of that information with you tonight and I know you can all read this so Jeremy called me down down earlier today like you can't read this slide so that's true so um the common theme that that runs through this entire report is that the revenues are running ahead of the broader economy so don't worry about it I zoomed in to make sure we can all look at it so for the next couple slides the purple dots uh that you see on here are they represent the first and second quarter of 2024 so that's this current year the orange dot would be what our historical average is for the state and so um what you can see in this portion of the graphic is that the total pay

088to workers in the state is pacing our historical average which is good news um so higher income being reported however if you look at business owner income we're trailing that in the first and second quarter as well as our fewer we have fewer payroll jobs uh that are being reported so we're seeing a little bit of a discrepancy between the revenues and what we're seeing in the general economy so continuing that Trend hopefully am I on did I skip no my slides are off okay the same Trend unemployment um we are seeing higher unemployment than what our average is and then also our taxable sales are below what our historic average is so what does this all mean um it means that Eon the econom is really bumping along right we're still the money's coming

089into the state the revenues that the state is reporting are they're higher than what they projected but you got to remember that the governor's budget projected a a significant decrease in the amount of revenues coming to the state so the fact that coming in a little higher is normal uh or that's what we would hope for um the state revenues are projected to be higher but uh there are some things that are contributing to this trend so when we look at the broader economy the stock market in California because of the our population really drives a lot of our income growth uh and our taxes and so when the uh Federal Reserve started uh adjusting the interest rates for to curve inflation that has a huge impact on California because that's where a lot of

090our our money comes from from stock market growth so as they increase interest rates stock market uh it falters a little bit um but what we've seen over the last few months as the inflation is cooling the feds are reducing the interest rates a little bit stock market loves that so you're seeing a very strong robust stock market so if you're in there you're happy right now um and so we're hoping that that continues and from what we're hearing the Fed BS are are are planning to continue to reduce the interest rates um over the next couple of months so with that that's that's good news and we hope for that now I'm not going to ask you to read these slides and I'm not going to go through these or these graphs on the

091on this slide but the point in adding this is that the state budget itself is in a deficit spending pattern the same pattern that the majority if not all school districts uh most school districts are in uh for the current year and and the next year and a lot of that has to do with declining enrollment and also um the low colas the state has been providing to school districts for the lcff so just wanted to point out that the state is in a deficit spending pattern when we talk about um what they think what the Lao thinks is going to happen with the budget and where the governor is going to go with it um they believe that a majority of the increased revenues that they're seeing are going to be used to offset

092the withdrawal that they took from the rainy day fund and they did that in June or July I should say um really to help pay for the lcf money that they did give us which is again am measly 1.07% and we'll talk about that later but they had to take money out of the rain to F to do that so they the Lao believes that the state will end up depositing most of that money back um the net result that they're projecting right now is that the prop 98 guarantee which is what drives most of our funding in in K12 uh would grow by 1.3% uh which is not very much and then the they're expecting though that the legislature will be left over with $2.8 billion uh for new commitments so what can they

093do with that there's a potential right now we do have some deferrals where we have payments the district gets in July instead of June so it's one of these uh this um kind of a shuffle board thing that they do with the state to try to make one year look better than the next year is by removing our our payment by a month it doesn't really affect districts so they they do that a lot they could eliminate that the other option is they could provide more onetime money to districts or uh actually create some other ongoing um ongoing things that they need so with that we're hoping that they apply it to lcff so that's um our our goal so we want to talk about some of the considerations for first interum um when we

094look at the overall budget there are no real significant changes to the state's adopted budget uh what they what they proposed in in June or I'm sorry in May really is what they followed through within in July and they haven't modified it since then um some things have changed here though so for placenti or Belinda our enrollment appears to be stabilizing and that's that's very good news um but it's it's and to be fair it's it's we're and I'll touch on that a little bit uh about more what we're seeing around the county but our enrollment for the first time and I don't know well since I think 201718 which I'll show you a graphing a little bit is stabilizing meaning we didn't lose any students we gained actually uh 22 students this year which

095is great um the attendance rates are are increasing so we're making an assumption of 95% where before we were around 94 went to 9495 95% so thank you parents for bringing or sending your kids to school we need them in school that's how we get uh that's how we fund everything that we do so please keep doing that um so those are some of the things that have changed now what I want to talk about is um this trend that we're seeing so this is actually a graph of uh P data um a group called Ed genomics actually produced reports for all of the school districts in Orange County and what they wanted to highlight is that as the federal government start starts um uh reducing the amount of money that they're the onetime money

096that they're giving to schools um they wanted to to basically highlight what's going on with Staffing right versus what we're doing what's happening with uh enrollment and so the blue line that you're seeing on the on the slide is on our enrollment that from 2017 18 through now I added the last two dots so if you're wondering why they were so sloppy and they put the dots off to the I did that so um I wanted to keep the trend I wanted to make sure that we're showing okay where are we now versus um where this slide ends up so what you'll see is that while we have a significant Decline and so that you see the blue arrow over there the 20 27717 students have declined but we've increased 349 staff members okay at

097that same time and there's a lot of reasons for this um the two main reasons are that we have been flooded with one-time money um and the and from both the state and the federal government and along with that they've created new programs the expanded learning program uh which which is fantastic which but it needs a lot of people so we've had to hire people to to do that so this doesn't correlate with funding it correlates with how many kids were serving and our our staffing and so but it's important that that we need to remember that we hire staff to provide services to students and families and those Services they they rely on them and they're important um and so we need to make sure that we remember that but the challenge that this

098creates is that it creates a structural deficit for the district in the long run and so there's an imbalance there and it needs to be adjusted and as the state starts drying up all of the one time money they've been giving us uh and the the and I'll talk about the the covid-19 money in in a few slides but as that happens we do need to figure out what we're going to do what services we're going to provide and how to adjust so with all that background I'm going to start talking about numbers so this is the standard slide that we include every time explains what the purpose of the first interim report is um we bring to the board the the financial report uh three times a year right so we do our adopted

099budget we do first interim second interim uh first interim these are at every one of these interum cycles that the district needs to certify whether or not we can meet our make our payments basically pay our pay our bills for for the current year and the next two years if we can do that then we're in a positive certification and that's what we recommend so when we talk about our multi-year projections and some of the factors that we have in there are built in uh what you can see on the slide is that our current year for 2425 our statutory Cola uh provided to lcff is 1.07% very low um the out years are 2.93 and 3.08 the enrollment what you'll see is we because of the trends and I'll show you the the trends

100uh in another slide we're we're assuming flat enrollment because something has changed in how we're enrolling we start we were losing 300 some kids then we lost less than that and then we we're actually looks like we're bot meing out and there's a reason why um uh well it's not just us I guess and and I'll talk to you about that in in a second um we are assuming a higher attendance rate uh because we are see seeing that and the net result of that are these figures that you see on the screen so enrollment let's talk about this for a second um I keep saying stabil stabilizing that's what it looks like um what I will tell you is that uh it appears that there are four to six other districts in Orange County

101that are experiencing the same thing so uh when we we meet as cbos every month um and as we're looking over the attendance in 23 24 and as we go into this this current year um there are a number of the districts in Orange County that that appear to be like we're we're hitting the bottom of the trough and it had to happen at some point right and so um it looks like for P that we're there like we're it looks like and what this means is that we'll probably be and I'll call it stagnant enrollment moving forward for the next few years meaning you might lose a little it might gain a little but I don't know if we'll see steep drops like we saw before and so uh because this is again a

102trend that we're it's not just us if it was a fluke and it was us I would say no we got a plan for the worst case scenario um it's more than us uh more more districts Orange County are seeing this and specifically the ones that are um similarly situated to to P so that's why it's there so want to point that out now with all that said this is where the rubber meets the road um what I so the last couple of budget reports that I've done I've we've been projecting that the the district would be deficit spending by around 9.8 9.6 million um that has grown to 12.4 um and so the let me see get to my notes so included in the estimates that you see here we're we've closed uh a

103lot of vacancies vacant positions that we've had um we have factored in here that we will stop backfilling uh when people retire so as moving out and all the out years as people retire we will not be backfilling those positions and part of that has to do with that Gap that we need to we need to address um we've increased our assumptions for interest revenue from the county because as the interest rates have been um they're better at the county level so we're earning more uh there and then we've also suspended the textbook adoption uh transfer it's $2.2 million a year for the next well for the years you see on here for 24 25 25 26 26 27 to be fair we have around $15 million in that fund right now for the textbook

104adoption so there's plenty in there to do the textbook adoption we just need to start making that contribution again in um so I've mentioned in in previous presentations that districts having a deficit number one is is normal right now with how the economy and everything's going number two is that this district is uniquely um situated to be able to withstand this for now meaning you have a lot of reserves uh we have um quite a bit in order to help the district make it through that that uh this rough period but we still need to make adjustments we stillin yes a few things I want to add here um first of all uh Jeremy can you share that slide so you so you see context of where we are with our budget so the projected

105deficit by the end of this year at first interim would be 59 point no could you actually zoom out so we could see the whole thing so should we under this projection end the year at $ 59.5 million the reserves for unrestricted Reserve would be 22.7% which is still very healthy Reserve if you look at the last five years that's right in the middle of where we are um so in uh our beginning fund balance was 47.8 million a 23% reserve in 2021 50 million a 20% Reserve in 2122 55 million a 24% Reserve in 2223 66 million so you saw it's gone up in the last three years um to where our beginning fund balance this year was $72 million um so uh this is what we hope is the worst case is ending

106of the year at 22.7% Reserve there are other factors that we think will um potentially increase our ending fund balance including uh the cola which which we're hearing could increase for 2526 um which will help our our out years um so I just want you to see yes we are deficit spending this year um but in context we are even if we uh deficit spend like we project we're right in line where where we've been The Last 5 Years um uh so that's important the sky is not falling we do need to look at um specifically positions and Mr Stein will talk about that that have been funded from onetime money that are being shifted to the general fund which explains this deficit this year so with that I'll let Mr Stein continue okay thank

107you so the U moving on so the component components of our ending fund balance are shown on screen here um as you can see the overall fund balance is $108 million 60.5 of that is unrestricted and 47.6 is restricted um I should have pointed out that I don't have that listed here so our unrestricted a lot of our our deficit spending deficit spending and unrestricted but we're also very much spending down all of the onetime money so you see that on the financial reports as well um so so despite the deficit as Dr churners pointed out our ending fund balance is still very healthy our reserves are very healthy um but again you know we don't want to don't want to gamble with that we want to make sure that we're we're making those adjustments

108and and so we will um this slide this next slide provides an overview of all the other District funds um and their ending fund balance uh now what I want to point out is that we have a number of projects uh currently in the works uh things we've talked to the board about whose expenditures are not had not hit by October 31st so these obviously will change it's a moving Target as we go through the year so uh as mentioned earlier we're required to certify our financial condition uh for first interim there are three types positive means that we will be able to meet our financial obligations for the current and two subsequent years staff recommends that we uh certify as positive so now that we've talked about the budget we're going to talk about

109some of the challenges which we've already kind of touched on but we'll dig into a little bit more um one of the things is we need to prioritize Staffing funded from onetime money that will that are now have been shifted over the general fund and we'll talk a little bit about that uh we have a structural deficit um that means that if nothing is done it will it will continue and it will be a problem so this is not a onetime thing we need to we need to make adjustments for that um we have projected low Cola for the next 3 years we have heard that the state is looking at a higher Cola for 2526 which would be fantastic for uh our 2526 budget um but it won't adjust our 24-25 uh any like

110where we end up at the end of the year but I'll talk more about that later uh we need to continue to focus on attendance please keep sending the kids to school 95% is great but it's still not where P was like we're happy 95% but that's embarrassing and that we have 95 % of kids uh that 5% of our kids are missing on on any given day so please keep sending the kids to school and then obviously we have increasing employment costs as well so we're going to talk about um onetime positions so covid-19 regardless of how anybody feels about it the funding came in um in a huge wave to school districts what we did with that and what most districts did is uh two things one we expanded a lot of services

111and these are critical critically needed services and so we hired a lot of people um all of that money Ended as of uh September 30th 2024 so a couple months ago um with that money being gone we have people working right so you can't just make that shift right away so a lot of these costs have been shifted to the general fund so what that means is that this onetime money that was covering it now it's moved over to our unrestricted money and it's part of that $12 million deficit that you're seeing okay so these things need to be evaluated we need to we need to prioritize them and figure out what we're going to do moving forward um make sure I'm covering all my notes so again it's very important that that we know

112that these are these are people these are important services and we need to make sure we carefully uh evaluate that so to reiterate the next two slides what you're seeing is one of the main reasons of this deficit that you see is these is these are positions that were funded from onetime money that are now being shifted into the general fund unrestricted and it's a lot of it's a lot of positions um and so that's one of the reasons that we see this deficit and so you see 4.5 million the next slide you'll see about 10 million so uh further so we we've shifted Staffing a lot of times when we get onetime money it you're able to hire positions or shift funding for positions off to the one-time funding freeing up general fund and

113then that's used to hire more right the key is is that we need to make adjustments when the onetime funding goes away so um again uh we will need to evaluate know what services and positions that we have and make sure that we are still addressing the needs of our constituents and invting District priorities this is an important slide because um these positions are critically important to make our district um amazing you go to the sites you talk to the principles about how they feel about theirs they're critically important these teachers are out of the class doing intervention we have amazing teachers on special assignment that are doing a lot of work that most districts either wouldn't do or would have to hire administrators to do um so we're not suggesting it by any means

114that these positions need to go away what we're showing is um these are the positions that either were funded out of one-time money or are um positions that are outside of the classroom um that are contributing to the deficit okay so to wrap up uh we're going to look at our budget step so we're at first gener room um and so once we're done with that we have our midyear lcap update in February that'll happen at the February meeting um then we have our second inter room in March already uh and then we get right back into lcap season public hearings and and the adopted budget for 2526 so right now it's it's this non-stop uh runup until until June and so but during that whole time um we're developing the LC cap along with

115our constituents and the board um and so we'll be uh bringing that back as well now before I apologize for my long presentation um I would be remiss if I didn't thank our our fiscal services and business teams for their hard work uh putting together the first interim report I've said it before but it Bears repeating so pylusd has an amazing administrative Services team um the best I've ever seen I've been very blessed to work with such talented people um a huge thank you to them for the many hours the dedication and most of all for putting up with me for the past year and a half um they deserve a medal for that but um they have really been a blessing to me and I I'll cherish them but again thank you for the

116board for this team uh for giving me this team um of gifted individuals so thank you very much and I'll take questions if you have any um one question about you mentioned the attendance rate and um the colas these are conservative assumptions that we're making right this is not I mean these aren't final numbers obviously because we haven't got it the end of the year but these 95% is a conservative attendance rate 95% is a realistic percentage yes that's what previously it was 97 is you mean in The Glory Days attendance yeah you would depends on high school or or elementary elementary is usually in the 97s and then high school and middle school a little bit Mr Stein though to that question regarding Cola yes um if the governor does come in with what

117potentially we're hearing is 4% what would be the implications to our budget so if if the governor's uh budget comes in with a 4% Cola for 2526 the I mean if we just look at the numbers real quick the the net result would be let me go back um the net because we're assuming 2.93 so it's a 1.07% increase to that so it's about $3 million uh and so basically it would shift uh it would take 3 million off of if everything else remains equal it would take $3 million off of that deficit but what'll happen is in 2728 it creates a new bench for for 2627 and 2728 so we would be climbing out of the deficit a lot faster if we if we have that extra percent so um we're going to get

118to the next steps and or the next budget coming up but we added new programs this year ocss and USI and we made an investment to do that can you talk about what kind of investment that was and how that impacted this budget um so the Investments with regard to um the infrastructure or we are we talking about Staffing both okay so uh infrastructure wise that that money would have been it was used out of a developer fees so you won't see that in this you'd see that more on the next slide that shows all the others all the other funds so fund 25 is what that would have been paid out of um the but you know with with new programs comes new Staffing and so uh there would be a lot of hiring

119that with it took place um um for both programs that would be factored in here so my recommendation is as part of the study session is to bring the cost for all programs all alternative programs the charter school USI um the virtual school Park View um all El Camino um just bring all the Staffing all the cost for everything um as part of that conversation had the workshop we do with budget yeah so likely in February in the timeline yeah I was going to ask so in the timeline Gary it shows that that second interim is coming in March yes yeah so we try and do that Workshop before the second interim okay I mean you can it after the governor says but before the second inter room yeah the the governor comes out usually

120the second week of January so sometime between then and ideally by mid-February we can have a budget study session okay because it affects the revenues but the expenditures are there right so it's not like you can't talk about those so yeah and can we talk so BBVA we've been getting a few emails this week about it is it true that there's only 10 enrolled in K through six was it they said that I'm not sure I need my call are we down to 10 students so we've seen a lot of decline in there in the K to 5 program I I believe we're down to 11 one USA yes okay and then High School um I can pull that up for you right now at the middle school we have 22 at buav Vista and

121at the high school is 73 so that's total of 106 students at buav Vista can while you have that up can you tell us how many are at ocss and how many are UCI USI sure um USI I have up and that's 12 tk5 44 at the middle school and 28 at the high for a total of 84 and then oces give me a moment ocss has a total of 740 students okay thank you I don't think I have any more question well I'm GNA say I've tried to not you know I had a student call me today who I'm responsible for and he tried to get me a Callum out of class and I said no thank thank you you're [Laughter] welcome okay I have some questions sure um you've kind of discussed a

122little bit about what factors have um contributed to the deficit um growing to 12 million when we started our bu judge what we approved was a deficit of 9 million so we've seen kind of an increase in just the first quarter can you tell us what's basically the factors I've been to that yes so if I go back to that initial really ugly slide there you go let me go back I mean I I find it beautiful but it's an ugly slide so they used to call it like an alligator or something it's it's definitely an alligator chair that's for sure um so if we go back here the the difference you're seeing so if you look at 23 24 and um 2425 it's it's Staffing that's so the 85 to 90% of the District's

123budget is people and benefits and so um this is where uh you're going to see the biggest change there so there were um some things that were built into the budget in July um that that uh didn't come to fruition and so um we ended up we have more Staffing than than planned is Staffing is this considered Staffing increase due to the preschools and the TK expansion or is it something else so the the the TK yes I mean that will always impact it the preschools are are funded out of um a different fund right so so that would not be in our general fund um but yes DK would impact um and uh as well as with you know what what Mrs Buck asked about um Staffing at at new programs as well what

124did you say I'm sorry Staffing at new programs like so Staffing it at uh at the charter and at USI yes okay also we got rid of combo classes at several of our schools a lot of its class size we added a lot of sections at the high schools um rather than hiring people we hired sections so there there's a lot of reasons plus um the 9 million and the 12 million again you're going to see fluctuations based on um once estimated actuals come in so they're projections um but in general um our class size is the primary driver and so we hit where where we have lower class sizes right now is at our high schools and so our high schools we spend a lot more money um to have lower class sizes than

125uh the elementary where it's it's set at 24 to1 or um 29 to1 okay um Mr SE do you have any recommendations to address this as we move forward through the school year and for next besides um eliminating um you talked about not rehiring teachers is there any other suggestions that you have yeah I mean it's um so anytime you're dealing with a deficit or structural deficit I mean you've got position control that we need to make sure is is maintained um that every that we make sure that every position has a dedicated uh funding stream before we fill it um we need to evaluate every vacated position to make sure that it's still needed uh um and then eliminate possible um any categorical funding funded programs need to be self-sustaining um and as Dr

126churn has mentioned class sizes are huge right so we need to make sure that um our class sizes are are to the negotiated number uh that we have with apple and that um that we aren't aren't adding new things right now so we're in a we're in a position to where the district is to where um we don't have the luxury of really adding anything uh we need to be looking at at how to how to uh cut back what we've got we also need to look at the number of positions that are now incumbered by the general fund so right as we shared before $5 million worth of positions that prior prior budgets did not encumber the unrestricted general fund now do and so that's that one slide if you want to go back

127to there Jeremy one of the reasons for the structural deficit is all these positions were not in the general unrestricted fund last year so now they are because we can't use onetime money so we need to look at all these positions that we're now funding and and and and prioritize so in these assumptions are we assuming that any vacant current vacant positions would be filled prior to end of year or are we assuming that they are not no we we closed them well we closed them yes we did so that's not a factor that's not a factor okay yeah it's just any one that becomes vacant moving forward we need to evaluate every every single one of them yeah do we have an estimate of retirees for this year yet not yet no what what

128was our assumption 25 that we built into the budget 25 is built in we built in an assumption of not replacing 25 yes because we get about 25 retirees a year okay and then are we looking at alternative sources of funding for these positions I mean I know know that these are very valuable positions especially um the that's a great question actually I just had a light bulb because Renee Renee has been sorry Mrs Gray has been working on things but we have cbhi sorry I'm going to just start talking about it and jump in when you when you want um the community youth uh health behavioral health behavioral health initiative um we and I'm we've been meeting with the vendor uh to it basically it has a potential for us for the district to

129be reimbursed for services as we already provide so there's a lot of things we do with our nurses and our psychologists and and um uh and counselors that basically um we could be being reimbursed from the state uh for all those services that we are not right now and so that would be um one of our main drivers and I know Mrs gra been working on that with a vendor there will be something coming to the board in the next month or two um a contract with a with a vendor to help us automate all of this to make it a lot easier on staff um to report it so that we can we can get that reimbursement but that would be directly uh for some of the mental health and and wellness uh Staffing

130so are we are entitled to a reimbursement for that and we're just not we are but we don't have the ability none of the dis districts throughout the state have the ability to really Bill the way that the state wants um this program gives us some seed money that we can use to to hire and build the processes and pay for the software so that we're we're up to speed to be able to do that building um and they've provided that as a grant that we get through ocde uh sorry the Orange County Department of Ed um where uh we can basically use that to help build that program train the staff have everybody ready to go to start building we can build we but there's not a district out there right now that has

131the the infrastructure to do so yeah Mrs Gray is this related to Cal Optima Cal aim or any of the community supports no it's not related to it actually we're already doing this in special Ed so we're doing billing right now and we go through Paradigm and a lot of our special education staff is billing for the services they already provide and so what's happening is this is just expanding and so the state is looking at expanding this to General Educators naming anyone with a pupil Personnel Services credential so that's your counselors your Wellness Specialists your mental health clinicians they all hold that credential and so they're trying to teach districts how to do third-party payments and so they can build for what they already provide just like special ed oh that's great do you

132have an estimate of rough estimate of the the revenue that is potential to our district it's very very very rough but it's very very very positive so I'd hate to give you a number but it it is it's very positive so that's that and so you asked what the alternative it's it's at a point it's at a point where I'm like I don't believe it under 10 million well it's very positive but I don't want to I'd rather you know as as as Gary said let's present this so you can see it and and really get an understanding we have all the return on investment But to answer your question yes we are looking at alternative sources this is one that could be really big for us how many of these positions that are listed

133in the the fulltime that's now being absorbed by General budget would be covered by that billing service any of these yes awesome I had a question that's great um with the special ed services I know the parents kind of have to sign off per permission to bill the state is that program going to be the same way or is it automatic yes so there is an enrollment piece but that that's the key I mean there's going to need to be a lot of communication I think that it would be very beneficial for the board to hear from this vendor directly so if they were to come and actually share that with the public um the system is designed to be very user friendly integrated with Aries to where during the enrollment uh standard enrollment there

134would be extra questions asked and things like that um we already collect a lot of this information but we're not collecting it for the purpose of using it right so we talk a lot about you know insurance and those kind of things um but we don't do anything with that data unless they're in sports so now it's it's it just changes the dynamic of that and it's all wrapped in um and and very integrated so that it's it's easier for parents to use um to to uh basically sign up for services but it allows us if we're going to if we're going to ask students send out a survey to see how they're doing you know to just do a test to say hey are you feeling good today are you feeling it allows us

135the ability to do that but that counts for reimbursement so those kind of things where we're just we're touching base with kids it incentivizes us to reach out and actually um um really get in more involved with the mental health aspect so it's it's a good thing so one one question just to just to reiterate the reason that we aren't currently doing it because it's such a let's call it a bureaucratic nightmare to get it done well I mean have any people that work in the insurance industry in the cuz I'm not going to say anything bad I actually used to work in Insurance believe it or not yeah building insurance is and we tease her all the time it is a new program this isn't something that we've left this is a new program

136no but I'm saying like bringing someone in to do that is because it's so specific it's specific but they also have all of the tools built in that that um that yes they've they've done all the bureaucratic Stu everything's done they they incorporate a lot of really good things that that would be good for the kids and we are not alone other districts are entering into this too this is this is becoming more common to be fair the state put this money out like three or four years ago and and nothing happened for like two years so that's why there's a big push for for um to get more districts involved let's do it yeah so is this like a middleman for us we submit and then they like there's it would just seem like

137if there was an easier format how can we this is a capacity Grant so just in general they're trying to teach us to have the capacity to do it our eles so the we're going to get initially some money to set this whole fee schedule up and then we hopefully will take it over and be able to do it on our own it's a platform right okay I'm not going to ask taxes yeah he is there any other questions okay I think we're ready for a vote then um um all in favor I I I okay it looks like with an I from our student board member oh so yeah five o vote with an I from our student board member um I think it's time for a quick Break um so five minutes or

138five five to seven minutes we missed BK maybe we can get a highlight maybe we can get a a score update during the break okay so let's go ahead and take a break at um 758 hello everyone we're going to um call this meeting back into order so we need a motion for the charter school I'll make a motion to approve the Orange County school computer science Charter School 2425 first interim report second okay we have a motion by Mrs blades a second by Mr Frasier I'll turn this time over to you it's you okay so similar to school district's charter schools are required to compile and present budget reports throughout the year um and present them to the to their board in the same intervals as the District budget uh the Orange County School

139of computer science is a is a district Affiliated dependent uh conversion Charter under the direction of this this board of education uh the first inter report has been presented for your approval um please note that is not to certify uh because they're folded into the district's budget that you've already you've already voted on um so the updated budget has been attached to the agenda um and so at this point I mean the I don't know if we can pull it up um Jeremy if you so um but what I wanted to say is that so this is a unique situation where the school really is folded into the district's budget um so we have to pull all the data out and make a lot of estim assumptions and estimates based on revenues and um some

140of the expenditures because if you apply all revenue to a if it's too hard don't worry about it yeah if it's keep going Jeremy terrible what I'm looking at so no so um but if if you all the revenue so if we ascribe all of the lcff revenue to to a site um then you we would have to uh also go through and figure out every single expenditure that would go um to to that site as well um we don't typically do that uh and so a lot of these are I mean it's it they are estimates what you're seeing um and so you'll you'll see a deficit uh for the school um with a $12 million deficit uh districtwide every school if we did this for for all schools they would all be deficit

141spending um to different degrees and so um but with that said um I would invite any questions you're saying because if we were to do the exact accounting for it there's fractions of expenses that would be attributed to the site that are districtwide expenses that you'd have to break out we would so so for instance administrative Services uh all of the work that that my team does for purchasing and all of that um that has to be allocated on a per Ada basis and that's what we've done in in the budget that you're seeing uh same thing would apply to our Maintenance and Facilities team uh Transportation everything we would have to break it out um and so we we don't typically do that I know that the the my my staff is is planning

142on bringing forward a resolution in the in the new year to to create a fund nine which is a separate fund uh like we have for cafeteria and everything else to move uh ocscs into that so that it's more it's easier to to track uh expenditures and revenues and all that because we would apply it to that to that separate fund um but would that would that be allocating District level expenses to that fund we have to do that as well exactly okay yes is it oh that's loud sorry is it beneficial for the ocss or any reporting that they have to do or we have to do to have it separated out or how how can help very much so for the financial audits so for us like we have to uh starting at

143the end of this year we're going to have to provide a lot of a lot of data to our to our friends the Nigro and Nigro to to be able to create a separate audit report right um and so to have that in a separate fund would make that a lot easier for us just do it on the front end instead of trying to go back correct yes so um this budget just to confirm is showing a negative balance at this point um but we'll be able to come back and look at that ongoing yes well so a lot of it so when I'm looking at the the numbers that are that are posted online yes it it has a has a they're running at a considerable deficit but um part of that has to

144do with The Upfront startup costs and things of that nature um uh so when we strip those out uh that the overall deficit would be less if because this is first year um I think for context during our study session it might be good to look at total cost of Staffing for that site versus our comparable other middle schools too um as Mr Stein said it's it's hard because I can imagine middle schools in particular high schools are probably running more deficit than our elementaries are probably pretty tight um but that would give you good context on Staffing levels there versus our typical middle schools okay yeah that'd be great do you think the Staffing issue is the primary reason for the deficit I think that as Mr Stein said we're also attributing these if

145you go to that kind of that bottom section like there's like I don't know 500,000 in District level cost that we have to book there um but I think I think let's just compare apples to apples and look at comparable middle schools and we'll be able to tell very quickly is that allocation based on Ada is that how we' made that okay when I compared this budget to what was approved in um that the board approved in June um I noticed almost a million dollars additional expenditures that were not listed in the the original budget and Staffing was one of them but also materials and supplies um computer equipments up like 200,000 um um startup costs 291,000 do we see these numbers stabilizing I mean um I would hope so so the the so some

146of the major SW shifts that you see are the revenue is obviously different because when when it was initially uh brought to the board there was an assumption that there would be 800 students um what we're seeing now is 738 so that's going to be a considerable drop in revenues um it's about $700,000 less the um expenditures yes so the Staffing uh did go up uh I noticed that as well specifically on the classified side um but uh that and the onetime the one-time expenditures I would not expect that to be an annual ongoing thing um the the Staffing as Dr churn has said probably needs to be looked at in comparison with other middle schools um and then the you know the the expenses at the bottom they're a little bit different um based

147on splitting some of the facilities cost with USI okay yeah I noticed that it was divided in half with this one so it was less money for that taken out but the expenditures had gone up so high um what can we do to help the school get back on to budget or to um see if we can reduce their um debt before like set second interim is there any positive steps we can take so so second interim being um I mean really second interum is in March but really it covers up through up through January 1 right or 31st it's a little bit um and and as you pointed out a lot of a lot of the costs are are around people and so that it's difficult to make that that kind of shift uh

148between second interum um what we be more is about the dist the the board providing guidance um to the school for the upcoming year um but again we're going to have to do that with with the entire District but specifically at the site you'd have to provide guidance because the the you know you are the the governing body of the school of the charter school so um to provide guidance as to what you want to see uh for the 2526 budget are there any additional grants or funding that I know there was things that were in the pipeline is there any additional grants or funding that were potentially going to be receiving for ocss or I'm I'm not aware of of any at the moment for this school year yeah that's I'm curious about there

149was um a potential up to I think the state of California has like $95 million in Grants for charter schools and so I think one of the reasons they were going to bring forth the petition to be not to be an independent Charter but to just have a little bit more autonomy is because they can apply for these grants and they can actually get the grants if they can you you know like the governing board like they were denied I think a $500,000 Grant because they said they were too dependent on our board because there was a governing board but if they had like one of us overseeing it and they had like a parental board which was I think what was in um the last thing that wasn't presented um there was an ability

150to get at least a few million dollars in Grants that way so that is I know that that's one of the reasons that they had been looking for that was to get more money um you know in that in that Channel I think I think again let's look at all the middle schools and see if this is an anomaly or not and if there is excessive Staffing at this school versus others then um that'll be a priority that the board can decide whether they want to tighten that up any of the uh what we were just talking about where we can bill for services is that uh potential that would affect ocscs or is that not a site that would have any of those kind of Staffing so as it stands now with their current

151structure then what we're putting in place for the overall District would apply to them okay um in the situation where they if they were to um uh be more autonomous yeah if they were to do that then no it would not they would have to would they be able to build for it though on they would have to implement an entire system just like the districts doing but they wouldn't have the grant money that that would be would get that grant money okay yeah just a question um that it's a more technological School than some of the other middle schools is there a way that we can just in the future obviously we have the startup money that was put out this year but next year in the Years coming up there's going to have

152to be refreshing technology updating programs all those expenses coming up is there a way we can segregate that for the study session so we can see those numbers as well yep absolutely like anticipated what's anticipated be replenished yeah yeah it's one thing to buy it's another to actually keep it up yes okay any other questions okay yes we we we do vote that's an approval okay so all in favor I I I I so five to zero with an i with our student board member okay okay so we're having a board discussion um on the homecoming Court per bylaw 93221 a Community member requested that the item be added to the agenda for discussion so it's open to the board to discuss or is did someone prepare something or is the person that submitted this

153here no okay so the question of homecoming Court versus homecoming King and am I Gathering that right homecoming king queen because we were split okay so I'm sorry I I helped do the agenda so I let me so what the proposal was they were um there was some parents in community we received emails from esparanza and also from Eldorado um they have had parents who are upset that there is a royalty Court instead of a homecoming king and queen um I guess Valencia and then also yalin High School still does that model um and so they're questioning I think there was two boys not necessarily there was no sexual identities nothing it was just two boys you know nominated to homecoming court and so people said that that was you know what one king and

154then who was the boy there was one Queen and then two boys tied for King okay so there was two there three so there three total people on this at ELO the way it works is there's no it doesn't matter whoever gets the most votes wins court so what happened was is one person won by a by a lot and then the then two people tied for second place they have the same amount of vot so then we gave it to three people so there was three homecoming Court two of them were my good friends mhm mhm yeah and so I think at esparanza if I it was either two boys or two girls at homecoming I can't recall I remember I was at the game Todd do you remember I don't okay so that

155was where a lot of these emails came from and so a lot of what the parents were saying is that they think it should go back to you know one boy one girl um and they wanted you know to bring that out because you know they were concerned that some of the the girls are missing out there are girls who want to be homecoming you know Queens there are you know and so they're kind of missing out so they wanted to section at these two schools to go back to a king and a queen um apparently the decision was made um only the just esparanza and well or no esparanza and El Dorado are the only schools that have gone this way and so they wanted the board to discuss going back and having everybody

156have a homecoming cour of king and queen so there is equal representation by both genders and they also said that when we when they were asked why they switched um they had said that it was because El Dorado said they wanted to um give the trans students and nonb non-binary um students more opportunity but in discussing that we don't really understand if it's just a straight vote how that is giving any more opportunity unless there was actually a second category for them so that was the discussion we had and um that's what the parents at esparanza and El Dorado are concerned about so the discussion you're talking about is ones that you had with those parents specifically we've had emails emails for the last year to the board so I don't know if you can

157get forwarded the emails I got the last one and that was my concern because to me it's a matter if you like in the voting situation it's just a matter of semantics of Court royalty king queen honestly it's probably easier to buy a hundred for ASB 100 sashes that's say royalty court or you know Royal whatever it is then having individual King what do the sashes say so about the sashes this is so off topic but I had to iron on All the Little Cricket on the the sashes oh my gosh so we're saving on labor from you it took me like 20 hours I swear it was it was awful just let you know I I was the one who the sashes for everyone on homecoming Court anyway but I I yeah the whole

158ordeal about the the court or the royalty I just I don't know I don't know how to describe it when I came in I I think I I thought it was king and queen and then when it came to like the voting for you whatever in a student mind doesn't really matter you still probably vote for a king because usually it's a couple who runs like sophomore year me and my now ex-girlfriend won sophomore sophomore homecoming royalty so you usually a couple wins no matter what usually a boy and a girl win this year it was just kind of fuzzy especially with the senior royalty because I don't know yeah it was just weird I don't know why so do you think that it would be fair to go back and say let's all vote

159for one boy and let's all vote for one girl I mean it's are you talking boy girl or identify as boy or identify as girl I mean there's two different yeah that's where it's kids like well I don't I mean I mean to me cuz it's it's the way El dorado's doing it's more it's like he said it's in the email it's more Community Based it's connectedness belonging so no matter what they are yeah exactly what they identify as whatever it is they're getting included in the vote and then the kids ultimately choose who it is well if they identify as a girl then they would go on the girls vote corre and then if they identify as a boy they Bo are you looking straight for boy girl or are you looking for no

160just boy what they identify whatever it is king and queen that's it that's all they're looking for let's get back to the way it used to be but typically they're boys and girls so should be Prince and prince and princess I mean and technically true in a classroom if we're not if we're not referring to our kids as boys and girls it's students Scholars then why are we going to delineate king queen all right we're not we're not referring to them as boys and girls well in classrooms you don't say girls line boys line right everybody lines up together you know students Scholars you don't say I just think I just think it's so insignificant yeah and that's like well I think okay so Luke say that it was weird this year so but you

161know and you said okay well it's just weird this year you know it wasir my biggest weird because of three people cuz of the tie right but I'm saying is for some people you know there are some girls who are like devastated if they're out beaten out by two boys for homecoming queen we're seeing a lot of stuff where girls are the vote right you know like so should we go vote boy vote girl and you can put it doesn't matter how you identify you put yourself in that in that site thank you guys for being quiet and if and if you know what if somebody who identifies as a girl if they win but at least it's back to the boy and girl vote I mean when you did the votes was it total

162number of boys total number of girl votes or was it just cuz it could been three three three people could have tied and they're all be girls think I think total votes he said I would keep it the same way at ELD I think the way because I I don't see a problem with it I think if I think if a girl want to win and then you would can like campaign for homecoming votes or whatever I know like atorado that doesn't really happen you know it's kind of just like that you know of yeah there's campaigning for sure come on there's like um people deny it like our director will say like oh you got nominated do you want to come be in people like no I don't want to do this so I

163I just think the whole homecoming Roy is it's just a little but but think of your other ones for you it thinks this way but we've had a lot of upset parents and a lot of upset kids who really wanted you know to be homecoming queen and instead it was awarded to two boys and we had two no we had two princes not Kings right what is it carry Roy well it should be prin buty two boys one girl it's Royal but yeah my opinion is I think it should just the RO way should just say the same I don't think I don't see a problem with it I don't my my the people I surround myself with I mean I don't like you said there obviously is complaints but I don't I don't I

164don't see a problem with it yeah and my thing too reading the email that was sent at least the one that was forwarded to me my issue with it it was going back to a religious region reason why it should be changed back and that's not what we're here for we're not here to debate religious beliefs we're here to debate educational issues what's you know so to me reading that email I'm like this is not truly looking at at a standpoint from just school like you said feelings being hurt whatever it is it went back to from someone's personal beliefs and to me that's not for us to debate that's how they feel that's fine but that's not us to make a decision for that yeah so that's going to go into a lot of

165different areas then but I think I think lot of different areas I personal beliefs I wouldn't have said personal beliefs but I mean I look at it from a biological standpoint like that's that's what it's king and queen traditionally forever and the girls that have dreamed of being homecoming queen may not get to have that opportunity so I think I mean there are lots of them that aren't going to get it only one will absolutely at has a chance I think we don't do a lot we don't dictate themes we don't dictate dictate events we don't I think it stay with the school that's if I could add that's how we've responded when we've received inquiries from families is you know this is uh student Le ASB Le and the district we are not inclined

166to direct a policy on royalty and court because that's not to do with the education stud who brought the idea it went to um okay sorry for the for just like the overall royalty and to do it as like a one big vote I ever since I came into elderado I was I I I when I first when I was a freshman that's how it was it was one big vote so I I mean and I was an ASB I joined sophomore youve been in ASB the whole time no I joined sophomore sore year when inquired with the activities directors at the two schools they shared that it was about 5 years ago when they attended the Orange County leadership Association where this was a discussion and so the activities directors brought it back to

167their asbs and the asbs decided to make the change so I was in eth grade then so just didn't just didn't make a decis it wasn't on you yeah I say we leave it with ASP yeah I personally think we should have homecoming king and queen I mean I AG I agree with that I would like that but I think that to dictate what that is I don't know what our you get into parameters you get into lots of things potentially but I do I think that it makes a lot of sense to have homecoming King and homecoming queen or prince and princess if you'd rather age wise yeah technically I was I was a prince sophomore year I was a prince gotta well so I guess I guess if the two schools that are

168doing this practice if they want to bring back Prince and princesses next year then they have you know to do it because it sounds like they went to this activities director you know meeting and then they decided to try to you know start to just change it change it um and so you know I guess they have the opportunity to change it back if they'd like to yeah absolutely so per each site how they want to handle it I we're not voting on this this is just a discussion I went through um our board bylaws and our policies and there's nothing in there that says that we have authorization really over your government um I think this is a school discussion and if it's important to the school and they can make their choices and

169you know and they could call it pretty much whatever they wanted to they didn't want to have a Royal Court they could have a I'm sure there's things they can't call it well they could have a hot court but there's things that they can't call legally yes there are probably are some legal things but you know ethically too and some schools even do where you have class Wars and then whoever whatever class wins that that's whose homecoming king and queen so it could be a sophomore freshman junior senior there so many ways you do it you know differently by a lot of different schools so I think they'll have fun researching that good yeah I'm glad I'm glad I can take this back too because just like I I yeah exactly I'll tell Mr C

170and I think the discussion is I think the discussion was a good it wasn't good because obviously class Wars that could be something completely new on how you do homecoming king and queen there's all kinds of different ways and so even the traditional way that they're doing it if they want to go back to a homecoming king and queen through a class war deal you know it all works okay I think that's the end of the discussion um we will move to the consent calendar um actions proposed for the consent calendar items are consistent with approved practices of the district and are deemed routine in nature the trustees receive board agenda backup information in advance and scheduled meeting and are prepared to vote with knowledge on the Block vote items is there any items to

171be pulled 21.1 22.4 okay and I am going to pull do you have some water down there Luke here bad that was terrible I'm going to pull um 22.2 and 22.9 okay ELO's up 5249 going in fourth quarter oh okay who is it wait what I miss 49 ELO fourth quarter start yeah okay thank you for our update thank you Luke okay is there um anybody else want to pull an item okay so I need a motion to approve um the remainder I'll make a motion to approve the consent calendar as amended second okay I got a motion by Mr Frasier a second by Mrs blades all those in favor I I I I okay we have a five o vote with an I from our student board member he is Going the Distance tonight

172let's go you're not curfewed I mean yeah finals tomorrow who cares you probably don't have a final tomorrow you probably already took it we didn't hear that yeah I'm just going to say yeah I studied so much just I have so much knowledge in my brain that I don't have to worry about it tomorrow I'm so prepared okay the first one is um 21.1 okay I'll make a motion to approve the district membership in the California School Board Association education legal Alliance in gamut from January 20 January 1st 2025 through June 30th 2025 I'll second okay um so this is the csba um once again and the one thing that we have said we don't have any problem with anybody going like to the California Schoolboard Association but one of the things that um has

173been brought up is I've attended um some conferences I think you've attended some conferences we've all attended conferences but it's never requiring a $35,000 fee just to be a member of it like to have a membership fee and so um I know that the three of you just attended csba and you were still able to attend the conferences you're still able to attend um if you have any of like workshops or other conferences that you want to attend you could still attend even if we don't pay this big membership fee um and so one of the things that was mentioned in fact a few teachers reached out to me and said was perhaps everyone just is able to go freely attend what they want to we don't necessarily have to be a member and we're

174able to give that $35,000 back to um like for science camp do we give it back to the school sites for like their AR programs um do we give it to the school sites for you know professional development do we give it to the teachers for school supplies you know for their classrooms is there better way to spend the money than to pay a just a straight membership fee because even when we um go to these conferences we pay $35,000 but that does not include any the conferences any of the things that we go to so it could potentially creep up to you know almost an additional $ 15 or $20,000 and so I have no problem with anybody going to the csba or whatever but do we need to have a membership fee and

175just say like we're not going to take the membership free fee because we get all the information through our attorneys we get all the information through the County board but we're just going to save ourselves some money and not pay a $35,000 membership fee I had I being the first time that I attended the csba conference this last couple weeks ago um I just think that we should be held to the same accountability as our teachers if we're all asking our teachers and staff to stay keep to go to the same trainings and be on the same page about things and learn the same things then I think we should be doing the same thing as well because us going to hodg Podge is putting things together everybody's getting different information somewhat I mean the

176Bas is obviously board bylaws and things like board policies are the same but the training you're getting is different so so if we're going to ask teachers and everybody else to be trained a certain way than we should be as well and then as one thing I did learn too as there is I you guys probably know more this about this than I do but what does the 35,000 include it's not just you're paying for nothing and you're getting nothing in return um but a a lot of things that we're other districts have discussed too is that sometimes it's more one costly if we're not doing on the same page and lawsuits get brought up it's costing us more in the end if we're not all TR the same way and following the same guidelines

177and two for paying outside lawyers every single time I think legal assistance is included in csba so I mean a little bit so yeah so at least our basic stuff could be covered rather than paying other outside entities and in the long run I think to me honestly it'll save us money because like I said when be on the same page we're not doing anything but we're not all required to attend and we all would be nice that we all offered the same thing still go at increased cost and then we don't have everything else that goes with it as well well we just but we haven't had it for a year over a year and haven't missed it so that's that's my there's actually a lot of things that I learned there that we

178don't have in place here I a governance notebook with protocols for each situation things that other I've talked to other people from other districts superintendents board members at that conference at the first day at the new board meeting board member meeting and or um training and there's a lot of things I was like well I haven't seen this I haven't seen that or they have in place that we don't so it' be nice to kind of get on the same page one with all the other boards in the state I mean there was 400 of us there that attended just that one conf that one day and like I said in kind of like you know what we're lacking it would be nice to be have those protocols in place so we all are responding

179the same way we're all know what to expect we all know what to do do we all want to respond the same way I would we want to respond like the email that we got about you know homecoming we all know what to do if that came to us individually that's that's my point and that's the thing that like I said teachers are expeced you're not asking teachers oh go ahead and go get trained on glad by yourself go figure it out we'll pay for it or go do that we should be held to the same accountability I don't see it as the same thing and I I think that you're putting a lot of um hope in something being great when we haven't missed it for a year but did you have it have

180you used it before well and I think too if you're saying that we're missing all of these things we were a part of the cspa for like 30 something years so if we were missing all of this stuff and we weren't following what they were telling us to do then obviously there was something missing all this time it didn't just happen that all a sudden we're missing stuff in a year obviously things weren't implemented and these are just suggestions that they say you're not required to implement these things no I understand that but what I'm saying is it would be nice to be on the same page as everybody else in who's the majority of people in the state I don't understand the same page this isck so I have been part of csba for

181the whole time except for last year I found it incredibly valuable I all of the me the bylaws we have all of our um our policies all of that stuff before last year had all been done and vetted through csba I think it's an incredible membership um it gives us a lot of access to things around the state that we wouldn't have access to um and so I'm going to vote for it I think it's great and I'm glad that we're going to hopefully go back what access do we not have you can't go to anything or get any information from csba without being a member so to the confence you can go to the conference and pay a separate membership anything outside of that related to csba you don't have access to okay so

182you're saying like the the boilerplate um not agendas but the all of the doc all but we have that through ocde it's it's not the same and and csba is an A and it's an organization of a thousand boards all around the state with 5,000 board members the ability to get um information and best practices and hear about what's happening around the state is so much more vast there than anywhere else it's a lobbying firm it's a lobbying firm they have lobbying um people within csba and one of the things that they did was make sure that the governor last year didn't cut prop 98 so it was incredibly valuable for every board and every District in the state I'd also like to add that I find Value in this program as well um you

183talk about we could go to any conference we want the member rate to attend this conference is $775 with a non-member rate at $560 so even if you just taking the three of us it really helps um the governances classes that you can take to better yourself the professional development um that you can take throughout the year the training updates um you still have to pay for that though that does not in the membership thing every single one of the you just listed you pay for but you can't attend if you're not a member you can't go to a training on um Master governance unless you're a member um this last year I had a lot of questions on bylaws and I couldn't reach out to um csba and ask those questions I'd be you

184know I didn't have the support that I wanted did you reach out to the OC Department of Education or attorney I had to reach out to our attorney okay and even then he was like I I'm not sure or he would you know advise but I'm like I'd like to see what other districts are doing um I when we were working on um some of our updates on our board bylaws in the past I reached out out to our field rep and they sent me samples from several different districts so I didn't have to do the research they were assisting they're there to answer questions and help so I'm going to be voting for this as well so we did have a question too what csba attorney did you guys speak to at the conference

185you guys said the last meeting there was a csba attorney so how did you speak to a csba attorney and get advice at the conference they're at all the classes no I understand that but who was it what was the name I talked to a lot of attorneys they're and I understand you can look at the but obviously he gave a certain type of Direction so what was his name I don't recall you don't recall and who was there when all of um I don't think this has to do with well it actually does no this doesn't we're moving okay okay so you don't want to say who was there and who spoke to to the attorney and how they gave advice to our board when I went up to the attorney at the end

186of the class and asked questions so was you by yourself yeah okay then you don't remember the attorney's name I could look him up he was from the charter renewal class perfect thank you I'm ready to vote okay we're all ready to vote all in favor I I I no nope I'll obstain you'll obain good that should be your pod I obain I Iain a good one okay motion carries with a 3-2 vote and our board our um student board member board member excuse me abstains so the next item will be 22.2 I'll make a motion we approv warrant listings in the following amounts check 2691 99 through 2711 current year expenditures November 10th 2024 through December 7th 2024 10,225 19729 and payroll registers 5A 15 m2830 $116 I'll second okay I have a motion

187by Mrs Buck a second by Mr Frasier so I pulled this item because on the warrant listings from 1117 to 1123 there were several um items from Culver Newan and um I asked about this these purchases and um these purchasers this payment was for purchases for furniture for USI and Extended Learning um the the amount for USI for the furniture alone was um $45,000 and that was for 30 chairs some tables whiteboards and other student needs um I keep getting the answer that we and made the investment last year for USI but every month we keep getting additional um fees for USI last month we did 36,000 for baseball equipment and this year is this month 45,000 for furniture and so I just kind of wanted to know um why do these athletes need this

188furniture is this furniture in use now can it be returned I mean where are we with this furniture and if I could add had are these things being approved on the front end or on the back end um can I take that last question first what do you what do you mean by approved on the front end of Are We approving it now after it's been spent and did it come to us uh before it was spent to to the board it should have been come to the board on a on a purchase wreck last month okay so um are these part of the the budget that was originally submitted I mean it's in within the spending limits that we're talking about for you I have to look and see what what account code it

189was charged to um I I can't ask that these These are coming out of the general budget okay so then it then it would be part of the the budget that you saw um considering that the payment is right now um it would not have been included in that in the figures that that were presented at first interim uh for ocss or that's not OCS sorry USI part of the district's general fund by yes it is so it'll show up in second inter room um as for um are we done purchasing I these these don't come through uh I mean they're obviously processor purchasing but they're they're approved at the site they're requested and it goes up through the approval process so um I'm not sure when uh the purchases are all done like we're

190we're constantly buying things uh for all Sites um what I'll say is the the the the chairs and everything uh for the I guess what I'm being told is called the team room um which is where the students go when they're um not being trained um and so that that's what it's used for and they're I guess they're configurable so that was my question of being for a team room was that I was reading is there 30 since there's 30 chairs 30 tables are there teams of 30 that go in there because we to understand we have a little bit of this sport a little bit of that sport there's not quite a team so could we' have done with like shares like half the amount since there's not 30 people using it all at

191once but at any point in time you've got a certain number of students that are there and if there's 30 students at a given time then that would make sense but it's not for a there's not a usit team this is the recovery um team room slash everything else the mental health happens in that room too they do homework in there you have to see it it's it's there's the main area and then there's this other room so when I was I was wondering cuz it's a team room so I'm like is it available for other teams to use if they have functions like from another school they can go in there that's that was my question was what was the purpose of calling it the team room I'm guessing it's just kind of a

192general term it's not specified to a team when when I was there um watching one of the classes there was I think like 15 kids working out in the middle and then you had like some of the kids who had just gotten done and they were doing like a second class so they were in the back in that team room doing homework and doing all their stuff and so all their stuff was in there that's what that's what I saw when I was there yeah stud purpose of it yeah when I toured USI you know there was the kids studying and then there were kids in the other room and they had you know a typical um table in there that you see at every school in the district and they had um desks for

193individual and so this is not that equipment correct this is a this is like an upgrade it's it looks like that right so I I um this when you asked the question that was the first I've I've seen of uh of the layout in those chairs so that have anything you want to add I know when they first opened it was temporary um folding chairs tables so that may I'm not sure when you went to tour at what point but the new furniture did come in and it it's really like um it's really pretty but like cushioned chairs but also tables so it's also the team room is really the catchall location where the coaches go and pick up the students for their workouts where the students are stretching and getting ready for the workouts

194they're doing their um homework assistance with the instructional Aid so it's like a multi-purpose classroom that's so it's a multi-purpose room but we took away the multi-purpose room from Bernardo but now they have a multi-purpose room of their own to use so that's what I'm it's small okay yeah but I'm just saying but they're given a multi- type of multi-purpose room to use for that like you said it's a catch that is there it's a pretty big room I think it was the choir room is that correct no the auditorium is where no it was actually it was the choir room yeah because it's tiered and they also have um like the loungers and the massage chairs in there as well go to USI Luke submit a request Luke is there a lacrosse USI okay

195okay I will not be voting for this um I'll be voting against this we just need to be careful the money especially now that we've seen our budget when we started off the school year we were at a $9 million deficit and now we're at a $12 million deficit and this kind of spending I think is um not prudent I think we need to be careful what our M where our money is coming especially since this is coming out of the general budget so I will be voting against this and you just voted $35,000 for csba membership but that would be benefiting the whole District not just 84 no it's only five of us it's only five of us the whole District because we all no I I disagree I disagree this money goes directly

196to the students they $5,000 is just us stud proved have that's probably like said an up from what normal we go without csba we proved it this whole year but yeah but again it's not the normal furniture that was at a regular school so I just wanted to point out that I understand that the sentiment are not wanting to appr to approve this item um these are payments are that have already been uh cut so um the would would be um anyway they're already issued so it would be difficult to not approve this item um I would recommend that that uh you know when we're evaluating the purchase orders like that would be the time to to pull and uh and deny those at the time well the purchase orders are really hard because they're

197General they're like a large amount there's no backup information um what kind of controls can we put in at the sites and and before approval so that we're making sure that we're making responsible decisions before they come to us as a warrant what what can we Implement I mean it would be up to the board to decide if there was a threshold that you wanted to see more the detail for certain purchases or certain types of uh um like object codes like if we're buying furniture or buying equipment things like that um the board could specify that you wanted to uh have more information on those typ types of items but is the spending in line with the expected budget or is this outside of the expected budget see I think that's the part that

198I'm I'm questioning because it's not I don't think if when you make a purchase you say is it in our budget right there so there's a number that they have is it outside of that so USI doesn't have a separate budget okay um so that's a Parkview thing you know right it's part of Parview but I'm saying that so that it it's as part of the program that's been you know start that's been created by the district um the purchases are taking place because of that program and so there isn't a budget necessarily for it per se um it's it's what Authority that the district is granting to that program to make those purchases and then the total number of Parkview students so if a Parkview student is enrolled in Parkview but they're not enrolled

199in USI they don't have access to that but it's their money being used to purchase well I just mean that you yes so USI is part of the Park View program yes because this is a new program and we haven't had a full accounting of of what funds have gone in and out for USI I would I I'm I guess we're going to have to approve this but I do want to put some stop gaps in place I think especially for where we are with USI right now we just keep buying more and more equipment and we're already at a 1.3 million doll deficit at USI we need to figure out ocss I'm sorry so I'd like to know where we are with that before we do any more um chairs tables more equipment weights

200any of that stuff if we could put a hold on it until we can actually get numbers together the board can make that that would be my recommendation right now what is the approval process for this kind of expenditure at USI um it would start generate from the program and it would go up through does it go up through ed services or yeah it goes up through ed services and then purchasing so it doesn't go through the principal at Parkview it goes that's the ultimate yeah that's a question I I'd have to look at the workflow for that specific program I just um our next item that we pulled was the developer fees and um which we're going to be talking about in a minute but last year alone we spent 1.4 million on USI

201and we are anticipating another 288,000 coming out out of developer fees so these things are USI budget grows so by the end of this year we're looking at 1.7 million just in startup fees and we keep every month there's more cost to USI and they're not Staffing and you know we were told that we weren't going to have additional costs this year we were we were just focusing on Staffing so that's I just feel like we need to really um stop the spending at USI focus on spend um Staffing and see when we come back with our budget meeting is and see what happens so in February we'll put together all the costs where where they're coming from whether it's one time what funds they are for USI Park viw um OCS bvva El Camino

202all the programs and all the costs and in the meantime we will instruct um USI not to put forth any purchase orders that's what I'm hearing can we get I think we need to do it just districtwide then until we go sit through and look at every single program say no more purchase orders at all for anybody don't order chairs don't order tables don't order anything that might be problem we could do we can do as Mr Stein said we can have a threshold of a certain amount of money that the board is requesting to be able to know what it's for because we spend a lot on furniture you know many many sites all the time um but if the board wants a threshold that we provide explanation it's more staff work but we

203could do that uh can we also get just an outline of the approval process so that that's clear like just who does it go does it go through the Parkview principle does it go does uh Dr Holloway go through somewhere else before it gets to ed services or just how does that work just information's good also I think it would be interesting to do an inventory of what we have on hand of I mean I've heard that our warehouse has lots of um lots of furniture is that correct you're just saying like what furniture do we have on hand I have a lot of pianos too in case people want those so we got pianos and so maybe you know kind of an inventory of what we have on hand before we are purchasing additional

204equipment to see what is usable well if we see a piano we know not to say yes is does is the inventory reviewed annually it it depends so if there's things that sites are sending back to the to the warehouse we do inventory everything we do Surplus a lot of it so you'll you have that Surplus that comes to the board item that then we try to sell that um um on Surplus sites but U so yeah they I mean we do know what's in the in the warehouse okay so you're saying the check has already been sent basically in the mail it's it's been cut yeah we should focus more on PO listings and ask yes that's where because that's where it's coming before it's being paid up right because we're making a purchase

205request and a purchase order and then you're approving that and then after that's been approved really it's just it it's everything's ordered everything is received we catalog it and then the payments issued and then then the warrants come back do we have direction to to put us stop to all purchase orders before coming to the board at a certain threshold cuz we can do that I think a threshold would be good um I don't know what's a reasonable threshold I was going to say U Mr SE what what do you think well that gives me a lot of power on my last meeting well I I just saw you were very hesitant so iant to put a I I think if if you would like to see more information for from a specific site for

206purchases I think that's reasonable um to see that before it goes out putting a threshold on it means like so if we had a science classroom that needed to do that then that's going to put a real stop on that and the kids aren't going to get the benefit from from that I think what they're asking let me rephrase that rather than a a stop gap an explanation yeah I think there needs to be more detail for the board to receive so for example if it's a purchase order of 20,000 or more can the board get uh the site and what it is yeah and not even a huge paragraph just yeah I mean of course of course just an explanation and and you know and what fund it's coming is it coming out of

207the general fund is it coming out of you know yes it's entirely possible and then what you'll find out is we buy a lot from the same vendors over and over and over again you're going to get tired of see but yes absolutely we can well I've learned some of them so and yeah so I mean 20 25,000 would be would be something that we could do just to see what it looks like and then you can decide to to to adjust that um because I I have iect ECT that you're going to be shocked at him how much a lot I mean if you look at the I mean we're cutting $10 million worth of check so it's going to be a lot of uh lot of purchase RS but so would you recommend

208a higher threshold I think I think you start at one and then we'll and then go from there honestly what was the amount for the tables and chairs again 45,000 45,000 45,000 okay and so just for one school and I understand but they're saying that this happens quite often at the schools in this amount so is this a normal amount for like tables and shes at a school site it's 45,000 a large amount of money so we know where to put the threshold I'll be honest it's those it's it's a it's a large amount for for 30 chairs um so um but you know it just depends on what you're buying and and what the what the design of them uh is so um I mean 25 $50,000 e either way like it just the

209if the board picks a picks a threshold we we'll work within it and then you can decide if you want less information 25 I just for comparison cuz I there were several items there and the other two items were for expanded learning and they got desks chairs filing cabinets and other related office furniture and they spent 16,000 so expanded learning spent 16,000 on furniture USI spent 45,000 so that and some some of expanded learning come out of elop yes and then there the tables and chairs at UC USI are coming out of General so that also factors in for me but elop was it came out of the general fund this is out of the general fund for the general the elop is in the general fund but it's a separate resource in in the

210general fund we do we do track that separately we agree 25 25 25 25 and then when we're bombarded with lots and lots of stuff then we can reduce then we'll we'll retract thank you okay we need take a vote we need to take a vote I all in favor I I I I I okay motion pass 5 to zero with an I from our student board member I I pulled the next one the 22.4 okay um I move that we adopt a resolution number 24- 07 accepting the annual and 5-year developer fees report pursuant to government code section 66001 66006 and 66008 for the period of July 1 2023 through July 30th 2024 a second okay we have a motion by Mrs Beck a second by Mr Frasier um I pulled this because of

211developer fees and I just wanted to review it and go over some of it with this if you wouldn't mind kicking us off oh okay uh so I didn't have anything prepared for this um so this is just something I mean we we bring this report to the board every year uh let me see if I can pull it up over here so basically it goes through and it's for last year and what was received what was spent and then it kind of sets the stage for um plan future planning so um what where would you like to start um our expenses from last year page four m okay and guess we're at a 1.9 million and what am I are we on a different page oh I'm looking at four on the bottom of

212it but it's actually six okay yes so some of our projects funded and um I'm looking at Universal Sports Institute and um the kitchen from Valencia so last year we did have part of the Valencia kitchen planning planned I must be looking at the wrong one page I'm not seeing Vala Kitchen in this one but um it's not we yes that's for future um and this past year we spent 1.4 million on Universal Sports Institute and correct just out of developer fees and did we spend anything else outside of developer fees uh yes with so that would be the 1.4 is just believe for the equipment purchase and some of the work done um there would be more for the preparation of the building and I'm assuming that that was out of uh RDA Redevelopment

213uh agency fees or Revenue I liked your glasses Mr Stein by the way I just wanted to comment on that oh thank you they look good yeah I can't read without them one of the benefits of being my age so do you have any idea of what those fees were from from the Redevelopment fees for USI the revenue we get in about $4 million a year four and a half million if I if my memory serves me correctly okay but what um for USI what portion of that um I I would be estimating at this point um but I want to say that the the last time we were looking at the totals for um the work done was probably about 1.2 and the two yes is that the site including ocss I I believe

214so okay anything else okay um it's here that's projected that we're we're going to spend another 288,000 on Universal Sports Institute do you what what did that cover I think that's just completing the project that that bled over into July and August and that would be facilities work it would not would not be further purchases I don't believe of equipment and that's not developer fees I think that's what uh the 288 Anderson's it's in the report yeah add in the additional correct and and we feel like the Universal Sports Institute is going to end this year correct you mean the the construction work on funding out of yes the funding I'm let me be C the funding the developer out of the developer fees correct that was just checking because it grows um can you

215explain the timeline for the Valena kitchen um it's being added here as a project um mhm and with its date of completion and and how that's going to roll out sure let me let me uh yeah we we pulled that as well um it is the next one hey Gary real quick on the side since all of USI has you just said it's been done with developer fees so there was never $1.9 million pulled from the Valencia of kitchen project into USI die from what you're telling us is everything has been paid for with developer fees the the initial purchase was um and then that extra whatever 288 whatever is from developer fees but there there's funds from Redevelopment and other other things used for it yeah right but it's still all considered in the

216developer feas we never pulled from a project to fund USI right right no it's it's okay thank you right let's see let me pull up the my notes did reprioritize projects correct yes that is correct but that's not pulling money if we're just reprioritizing do one project ahead of another that's not pulling money from the project right and then we do receive those I mean we we get different levels of developer fees every year um and so that the money that we that we have allocated for the Valencia kitchen would would be uh received not only this year but in coming years as well so you asked about the timeline for the Valencia kitchen so we have a an item coming up 22.9 um which would basically start the design of the Valencia kitchen um

217if it's approved uh if it if it is we would start the design the official design January 2025 um the the work to design and get all the way through DSA approval because we're going to be adding um uh freezer and dry storage in the bottom botom of the building uh we estimate that we wouldn't get approval of everything probably until fall of 2025 so it's going to take us a good you know eight eight nine months to get that done um and approved and then so after that the earliest we could see putting a bid on the street would be probably um well right after that and then the earliest we could start construction is January 26 um but that would be in the middle of a school year whether or not we want

218to do that that'll be up to the board um but uh right now we're saying well maybe we we just plan for summer of 2026 to start uh construction but that timeline can be moved up depending on DSA approvals and all of that okay okay thank you I have no further questions I do I do think because I know in one of your campaign Flyers you specifically said we allocated 1.9 million away from the Valencia kitchen to us and so I think you should come out and say that we did not do that um as just I say I also wanted just to clarify with the wording of pulling funds very prioritizing so technically if we would have slowed down on USI and not implement it right away maybe use less money for that in

219the beginning we could have at the same time concurrently started the Valena kitchen project and ran those two and then gone from there and like slowed the process started it sooner and USI was added after we had already done all of this so reprioritizing is actually taking it and bumping it over other things that we had prioritized so technically maybe it's not pulling it away from it because it's still on the list but bumping it off the list is actually accurate but it's not taking $1.9 million from a project it's not doing that it's diverting the money that was set aside not diverted I think it's all semantics and we're getting a kitchen bu the good news is we have enough money to do the kitchen we've haven't started this project in I don't know

220how many years and we're starting it now and it's it's going to take some time and it was because of the $43 million that was found that were able to do these projects so we're going to get going it's going to take it's not going to be a quick project but we have funding for it good design yeah okay okay let's take a vote to um approve the developer fees all in favor I I I I I 5 to0 with a I okay on to 22.9 I'll make a motion we approve the architectural services agreement for architectural Design Services for the kitchen renovation project at valentia high school with I'm going to butcher that name g to OD I don't know Bannon Architects effective December 18th 2024 through December 31st 2026 project number 5730 I

221apologize for getting that wrong second okay I have a motion by Mrs Buck a second by Mrs Quintero um is this the one I pulled yes okay I just really wanted to highlight that we are making our first significant um expenditure for this kitchen I'm extremely excited about it um I'm looking forward to turning the site in January and and really seeing um what the vision is and um that's why I pulled it me too um for someone who doesn't have a lot of I know Eldorado has a kitchen right they make just is is do other three schools have one and fenes doesn't have one or is it just fenes is old I have a lovely Grandma went to fluna so yeah yeah yeah so their kitchen the same but they have a but

222they have a kitchen they're just upgrading it yes okay it's not at all like El Dorado it is not really a kitchen it's just a like a food linee they have one oven and they feed all the it's a portable almost where you push people through so it's the one my grandma got back in the day probably probably is and she was excited cuz it was new then okay I I I vote vot okay any other questions anybody wants to ask about the kitchen No No but there's a lovely presentation available um on video that you can watch from last is it from is it from you yes oh you know I'm there if it's your presentation I'm walked in is if maybe too if there's a day that the tour is going to go

223so we don't have to do like five different tours we can just kind of walk through it together only two of us can go will be happy to schedule as long as we're not voting and not talk yeah no talking I mean you guys went to csba together so as long as we're not trying to pull in getting people to vote a certain way it's not brown act violation and it would be fun F and then they only have to tell us once okay perfect okay I think that's it I'll in any other comment no more loving on Mr Stein and his glasses his presentation czy sorry that's okay you're allowed to he's put it back on okay I let's go okay all in favor I I Luke did you vote I yes okay also

224ELO won by 10 points by 10 yeah they Clos it out in the end so it's a 5 to0 with an I from our student board member okay that's it that's it okay yep board reports so um Mrs blae do you want to start sure okay okay looking forward to having a couple weeks off um as you guys all are I know that a lot of people are um needing the break and so I hope everybody has a really good Christmas holiday I'm going to keep this pretty short um one thing that some teachers have come up to me about is um they're asking for I know and we brought this up a couple years ago and I remember that like we had taken AR from all the school sites and then we like implemented

225again we allowed them to purchase it but some of the teachers are asking for AR for the elementary school sites um they're questioning the fact that do we have a format of assessment to check students comprehension of reading books at their own level um I ready is assessing their skills but it does not reinforce independent reading um and so they would like some accountability and motiv motivation for kids to read independently and if we can't measure and help them set goals and good reading habits um you know how how can we help them because they feel like this is lacking um obviously they're not complaining about I ready they just want something to go further um not everyone is born to love to read but by helping them and showing them books to read of

226their interest and set goals and measure the understanding um that's kind of what the teachers are are asking for um they said that I already gives their level of ability but air measures their achievement and their motivation to read and the air quiz is allowed to see the stratified and skills applied to independent reading books at their own level it also helps goal setting to encourage and monitor reading habits and so that's just one thing as you know you go to different sites that they have said and I know that this was an issue a couple years ago um and so I I'm assuming because I know I asked you for the cost I think topaz is like $44,000 for the program and woodsb was like two 2,000 2,500 for the program but I think

227that this is a good um idea and if we can help the school sites and the teachers um get this into their classrooms um it would be good and when I was at Fairmont I was the AR person in the library J so I did like the air reading um the reading prr it was good and then also to um some of the teachers have requested they said that they have a district um teacher who comes out to the school sites and teaches art like six times a year one thing that they have said is they've um you know while they appreciate the teacher what a lot of them have said is they really like the meet the master's program and it's been at some school sites and what they really like is that um

228it has a teaching P purpose um it meet the Masters you learn about the artist and you use those art like the same skills that the artist was to produce their art and so they're asking if they can have that option at some of their school sites um or maybe to you know like if you have this person coming out six times a year can the next year they do the meet the Masters or have a little bit of differentiation um also too I just wanted to also say that um we get a lot of emails and we get put up to date um and um I guess earlier I want to say maybe it was a few weeks ago there was or maybe it was it was a little bit closer to November but

229there was um some teachers who wanted to transfer and somehow some of the transfers were stopped momentarily and like the board members had we had no no idea about it until after the emails and after like maybe the transfers were stopped or whatever is happening I don't want to go further into this but I really didn't appreciate um some of the Union telling the teachers that I had stopped the transfers because I don't have that authority to do so so I would love to have an apology from the union leadership who was telling those teachers directly that I stop the transfer because I don't have that power and I don't have the authority to do so and in fact the board after the fact was told about some of the incidents just like you know

230we get kept a breast of of issues and against things you know sometimes while they're ongoing and sometimes while they're already happening and then you know something's already happened and now we get emails from the parents and so we're brought into it so no way did I ever try to stop any type of transfers you know or work unilaterally it seems that um the rumor is that the board president so I don't know if they'll do this to you maryn since they support you um but it seems like I could do I had awful lot of power in this last year to do things unilaterally which just wasn't true so um for the teachers who were told this it's completely not true and um like I said I would appreciate if the clarification could also

231um come from the union about this um incident and I'm really glad we were hoping that we would be able to see Theon Eldorado game but we missed that watching a lot of sports congratulations Jeff Bailey for being coach of the year and for having a very successful season um looking forward to uh the winter sports now um more and more of them are popping up I've been seeing aspiron wrestling elderado wrestling yalan High School wrestling um watching our Middle School sports Middle School sports is taking off everybody's getting excited I actually ran into a middle school sports um coach in Starbucks the other day and he was telling me how successful the program was um and another thing I think we could think about too which I don't know if they're going to be

232happy to hear but the flag football I've heard from a lot of parents there's like a 100 kids going out for flag football but we only are putting a team of 14 together and so we have 80 kids or 70 kids that are kind of left out I don't know how we would do it and I know it' be a lot of work but possibly if we're having this much is there a possible way you know to expand and maybe have several teams so we can really get everybody involved and keep the involvement growing so that's um something that somebody brought up to me as well and uh yeah I think that's it I said I would keep it short so everybody Merry Christmas have a happy New Year um I hope you all have

233a great um holiday season and we will see you again in January okay Mr verer all right uh I will keep mine more brief um I had the chance Last Friday to go to yal Middle School there's a something called schools to watch in California we have uh tuffrey Middle School and yal Middle School are in the process of um being I believe redesignated and I was able to sit in on the student panel on Friday whereas I think there was 12 students that got to sit there in front of the evaluator and he just asked him a bunch of questions about the school and they gave their their replies it was very slow starting middle school students that are um actually very respectful and very very articulate and then it started to pick up

234and the feedback from these students was they love their schools they love their friends they they a couple of them only a few of them said they wanted longer school days now it was met with a a lot of uh um I'll say negativity with the other students um but it was it was really neat to see that process and get a little bit more insight in what's happening actually directly on our campuses from our students uh there actually it came up to the I believe two of the girls were on the flag football team Yan middle school and one or two of the girls didn't make the team and when I heard them say that I thought oh that's interesting so to your point we have a lot of interest in girls flag football

235so I don't know how we do that but getting as many uh students to be able to participate as possible would be great um I also then did get to enjoy a double double uh with grilled onions with them afterwards which was phenomenal lunch with middle schoolers is just different right it's it's a lot of fun we had we had a good time um beyond that I'm glad that Luke didn't mention it es Bron of high school on their turf field if you haven't seen they have a really old scoreboard or they did and they just got a brand new scoreboard so it's phenomenal that scoreboard has been broken all season and the football team was very disappointed but the soccer team gets to use it so that's awesome that's been a long time coming

236um and then I just want to re reiterate a few things that I've mentioned in the past to the executive cabinet um da high school program I really want to make sure that that is a focus that we make sure that there is a place for those kids after they get done with their eighth grade year so that they're able to continue the da program because it is super unique and I love that we have that here in our district um second science camp fee process have we communicated with the principles on the best way to do that and then get that to the parents so that everybody that is available good cool um and then lastly I heard somebody say something in comments about Park viiew and some students going away from it Parkview

237is a phenomenal gem that we have in this District it's something that's unique it's not all students learn the same and the thing that we have at Park viw is very unique and I for one I mean my my kids go there have all of them have gone there um and it is I think one of the maybe Best Kept Secrets the wrong way to put it because I don't want it to be kept a secret because it's an opportunity for students to be able to participate in independent study and then learn other life skills along the way so um if there's any concern about dissent about Park viw I am a big advocate for Parkview and I think that I only want more support and I'd love for them to be able to get

238um as many of the things that they need as possible so that they can help our students succeed and even maybe bring more students to Parkview so that's the end of my board report thank you um Mrs quento well I'm excited to get my first board report so I actually wrote it down so I wouldn't forget anything but I just want to thank everyone um for the support the last few months and um really excited to be starting my journey today um I'm really ex um excited like I said again to get to know the board members and work together and hopefully have a more positive um impact on the district and with each other um I did have done a few things since since being elected so I just I attended Peter and the

239star catcher at El Dorado which was great it was amazing um they do always do such a great job in their theater theater Department I also attended like I said earlier the csba conference um it was very informative I met a lot of new board members got to um really you know pick everybody's brain including superintendent and um during the meeting is um the first day was obviously new board members but during the other sessions I got to really um hear some input from um seasoned board members as well so it's nice to hear that and from the trainers I attended um school safety sessions so I have a lot of information about that I know Dr chis was interested in that um School governance Finance civility um and meetings superintendent avows Brown act Basics

240uh science of reading that I know is coming up around a lot of districts and how it's going to affect our board and um I just wanted to know um like I said earlier if we can have how a study session or somehow get together and create um and review any bird protocols that we may have in place or create new ones just so we're all on the same page like I said and that we all are getting the same information um since I didn't see anything in writing about those um I'd also um figur it'd be a good time to reevaluate them too since we're relatively um starting out as a new board and um so I also did that and then I also attended the Apple Christmas giveaway away um event which was

241great I got to see a lot of the families who received gifts from the um staff and teachers of the district and it was great to see how each school really supported their families and really great to see how much was given I mean these families were very overwhelmed with the generosity of our staff and teachers so it was amazing wonderful heartwarming to see and wonderful to see during this season in the holidays so again that was a great event Santa was there Mrs Claus and also um Santa Paw with the little pups so that was wonderful and again thank you to all the staff and teachers who donated to that that was great um I did know I know we've been talking a lot about Park View but I also wanted to kind of

242put out there um the BV bvva concerns that I've been hearing um I've gotten emails about is it going away is it getting being pulled out is it being sucked into Park View um I'm just concerned about that and if we can address that to some of our families that are concerned I know some information has been out there but if as a district we can kind of put that out there to make sure that that's not that program isn't being dissolved or being pushed out since it is great just like Parkview as well so it's one of the great Services we have but thank you well welcome thank you did a great job on your first board report thank you um mine will be short um I'll just highlight a few things that I've

243done um in interest of time um I got to attend a number of schools and and visit class classrooms which is always one of my favorite things to do um I went and visited almost every single class at esparanza high school it's harder to get to every class at a high school so I try um but I got to the majority of them um with Mrs sakusa did I say that right sxa oh I tried I even had it like all written saroa um it was great I had such a nice visit um going around and seeing the art class and uh manufacturing and engineering and into special ed and um get to visit all the teachers it was a really lovely visit uh I attended Woodsboro one morning and got to visit and Tour

244all of the classrooms there um with Mrs Collins they had so much wonderful things to say about her they just love her over there she's very well-loved and um there's fun things going around uh the school they've got new activities the day that I was there they were doing a book exchange so the older kids had had brought a book that they were donating to the younger kids and they were um they were even uh being like salese at the book fair it was really cute um and then having all the kids come in and and talking to those older students about the book and what was it about and and giving advice it was um adorable um van Beren i h got to visit there as well with Mr camarado and I visited all

245the classrooms there but there was one class that I went into and I just happened to be there at a particular moment where there was a a special education student that had struggled for a really really long time and didn't have a lot of interaction with a lot of the other kids wasn't very um um well what happened was that that that student got upset about something and instead of getting upset like he normally would he came up and told the teacher he was upset gave her a hug and she consoled him and that was the first time he had ever done that that it was um remarkable to see and just a shout out to that teacher she knows who she is um it was just it was just lovely um that made my

246day I uh did go to some sessions at csba for for our conference um a couple of them on AI and what that looks like and um what's coming for us so I'm really interested in in digging in more of that um we probably should already have policies in place related to Ai and what that's going to look like for us so that should be added to our plan coming up in the next year um I attended a legislative um session where they talked about all the different laws and things that are coming from the state at this point for education and I presented with with um North Orange County Roop on the Meer program which is a medical Innovation and research um uh group that um or a group of students did um with

247UCI was um fascinating so I'll pull some of my information and share it with all of you a couple highlights from each of them because it's really um I thought it was valuable information um I looking forward to the holiday luncheon on Friday I hope to see um our administrators there to kick off the the holidays um I wish all of you the best uh of of a break this is going to be the first time where our students are going away with finals already done so it'll be interesting to see what they think when they come back um instead of having to do that right when they come back from their break so um it's so nice like I don't have to like like you like the first week of break and you're like

248it's all fun and like the last week of break you're like oh man I got to come back and do finals like now it's like I feel like I'm G I mean I haven't had a break yet but just already I have one final I have one final done and I'm already more relaxed cuz I did it again uh it's going to be fine during break so that's what I feel about it that was that was the whole goal I know that it's been a little wonky with dates and all of that but I know some of the teachers are taking a break during your holiday is super important I think the only thing is the teachers like how to change their thing but I know they can all adapt we we'll figure it out

249there's always there's always changes that have to be made nothing's perfect the first time so we'll keep working on it but um have a wonderful holiday and we'll see you all in January we'll see you in January okay um so for my board report um I attended the Pena um prayer breakfast and um the that morning was truly inspirational I don't think there was a dry eye in the room um Dr Gates was there um the guest speaker was Stephen Kim he's the director of the project kinship and he really shared his inspirational story of being bullied as a child and becoming a juvenile delinquent homeless it was it was pretty incredible story and the the work that they're doing and um to support students um those that are coming out of prison but now

250they're also reaching out to at risk and they're starting programs at our uh at local school district so that might be something to um look into um they also he also brought you know some graduates um I thought this program would be really good for um El Camino and um possibly our Gear Up program so I can give you more information I attended the in the um showcase um and I got there late and it was a packed house so I couldn't quite get in but I had a lot of time walking around the gym and talking to the students and um hearing more about them including you know yearbook journalism Avid dance drama all the the wonderful programs there and um your Belinda offers a lot of great programs that will fit many different

251types of students I attended the elementary um superintendent advisory council meeting and it was great to listen and learn um and um hear about all the wonderful things that are happening in our schools um I think my favorite part was hearing the principles and one thing that was like a reoccurring theme at that meeting was just how important um the families and the PTA and the community are at each of these schools and how they really do make a difference for the students and the staff so um a big thank you to all of the parents and ptas and Community for supporting these schools and really helping them I uh also attended El Dorado High School showcase and uh Luke was a definite big star there and I loved watching his spirit and his interaction

252um with current and future students um he was very busy and um I just one thing that as I go and go to all these different showcases is each school's personality comes rising to the top and their culture and that's what I love about it and um it was just great to see the students and hear them talk about their what programs they were interested in and I talked to several families that night um I attended the csba conference which has been very well documented tonight um one of my favorite um things that I did there was during one of the General Session a Dr Laura Santos um spoke and she talked about um basically the science of well-being and she is the most popular professor at Yale and um she covered her top she

253basically gave us this semester long course in about 45 minutes and what's so interesting about Dr Santos is she offers these programs for free you can go to her website and you can take these classes for free and she has a teen program as well and one of the things I was listening at the um the advisory was um Baldwin was talking about how he's working on a resiliency program and Dr Santos pretty much has one and I don't know where he is but to look into it and see how um it it could be incorporated is just a possibility um I attended the legal issues facing school boards where they covered parent notification um school board members free speech on social media labor unions um how to lead when you don't get along and

254um that was another good class um I attended a class on artificial intell intelligence Charter renewal um the political outlook for 2025 and that's where I heard that the um the cola is looking more promising from that meeting so that was really good news to bring back to the district I've made Dr chis very happy with that information um I attended the um El Dorado um Jazz Christmas breakfast um and Mrs um Buck was there as well and it was it's just a fun morning it put me in the Christmas spirit and I just a big shout out to Mr Samson and the band boosters and the um jazz band students for making my morning just so fun um and I'll do a Shameless plug for them they are wrapping presents at Walmart so if

255you need your presents wrapped they will be there Thursday and Friday from 4:00 to 9: and Saturday through Monday from 9 to 9: you can't miss them and they're even going to be there on Christmas Eve from um 9 to 6 so donations I'm guessing I don't know I I I I think it's donations isn't it it's yeah that could be very convenient so um so I will um do the plug for them um I I also um had a great time at um the Apple gift giveaway um it just every year I go to this event event it just blows me away um the the generosity of our staffs and how they come together to support our communities and to hear these students stories and these family stories and and it's such a blessing

256and it it's um just a really special experience to go be there and it just feels my heart with lots of Hope and um how we can come together as a community and support each other um I too would like to have some discussions about our dual Language Academy and and um things like that and I would just like to thank Mr Stein for his time here and his service um I'm very grateful for him and all the hard work he does to keep us all in budget and I just like to wish everybody a Merry Christmas a happy Han Happy New Year's please enjoy your break and and um and be refreshed for the new year so Marilyn before we adjourn um how are you guys learning about this staff and apple um thing

257because we're not getting the invites so is this an invitation thing that you're you guys are receiving I suggest you reach out to Apple and invite them but and invite them and ask them to invite you okay um this is um good to know yeah just to be clear we're not supposed to have discussion during our our board reports because it's not agendized so I just don't want to say much okay I'm ready for a motion to adjourn I make a motion to adjourn the meeting second okay we have a motion by Mrs cundo a second by Mrs Buck all those in favor I I okay fiday everyone plus an I from our student board member and we'll adj happy holidays have a great vacation at 9:44

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.