001I calling the December 10th 2024 meeting of the Board of Education order per government code section 54950 executor and Education Code section 35140 executor at 531 PM trusty Anderson will participate via teleconference and all votes being will be taken via roll call we'll now be adjourning to close session for the purpose of discussing the following matters conference with legal counsel anticipated litigation government code section 54956.9 subsection D2 with Terry taao from to rosini APC is there anyone present who would like to address um any of these items seeing as there is none we will adjourn to close session at 5:32 p.m. all right we're going to convene to regular session at 6:2 12: p.m. and we have nothing to report out of closed session and I am going to ask trusty Young Blood to lead
002us in the Pledge of Allegiance will you please stand ready begin I pledge aliance to the flag the United States of America and to the Republic for it stands one nation under God indivisible with libery and justice for all okay all of our votes tonight or roll call will all be uh vocalized so uh Mrs Buck hi Mrs Anderson to be here I understand Mrs Anderson I'm here okay Mr Young Blood here Mr Frasier here and I am here show all of us present I need an approval of the agenda please I'll make a motion to approve the agenda for December 10th 2024 board of education has presented second I have a motion by Mr Youngblood I have a second by Mrs Buck any comments all those in favor roll roll call please Mrs Buck
003hi Mrs Anderson hi Mr Young Blood hi Mr Frasier I and I an I motion carries 5 Z public comment cards are available in the foyer cards must be completed and turned in prior to the designated time for public comment we provide a maximum of three minutes per person if translation is needed an additional 3 minutes will be given please let us know ahead of time so we can ensure that we are prepared civility policy Education Code 220 prohibits discrimination on the basis of disability gender gender identity gender expression nationality race or ethnicity religion sexual orientation or any other characteristic that is contained in the definition of hate crimes set forth in section 42255 of the penal code including immigration status and now I'm going to turn it over to Dr ches for recognition of
004trustee Shan Young Blood all right um good evening president blades members of the school board uh uh staff and Community uh at this time I'd like to take a moment to recognize and honor our outgoing trustee and esteemed colleague Sean Youngblood uh Miss Youngblood was elected to the board in 2020 and served as board president during his first year over his four years he's guided our district through significant Endeavors including navigating the unprecedented challenges of covid and championing the success of CTE programs Beyond his contributions to our district Mr Young Blood is a dedicated public servant with nearly three decades of experience as a professional firefighter for the city of Downey his leaders ship and unwavering commitment to serving others have been evident through his time on the board in the past year I've been
005deeply impressed by his kindness his passion for what's best for students and his steadfast dedication to our school Community Mr Young blood's efforts have left an indelible mark on our academic and organizational success benefiting students staff families and the entire P Community we're sincerely grateful for his service service and dedication to PUSD and Beyond and as a token of our appreciation we have a small gesture to present him this evening so thank you trusty Youngblood for your tireless commitment to making PUSD a better place thank you for putting kids first please join me in giving him a well-deserved Round of Applause [Applause] look like we're doing picture your service appreciate it [Music] you you I will now turn it over to the board for any additional comments they'd like to make any comments anyone thank
006you Sean for your service appreciate it it's been fun getting to know you and uh you're on to greener pastures or well more humid pastures right so um good luck with all that thank you for your service sir I said a lot last meeting but it all holds true still our Cowboys can let us down again last night so we will suffer through terrible seasons of cowboys for years to come together um I um just appreciate you I appreciate all your service knowing you professionally you know in the field and also to you know here on the Schoolboard I've really gotten to know you in all aspects and so I've appreciated more of who you are um and I wish you and your family the best of luck much love to Gia um and your
007sons um and all your grandkids too all right Sean you have anything to say well I I promised myself that I wouldn't cry but uh it has it has been very Bittersweet and uh um as I mentioned before um I have to give credit where where credit is due first of all I got to uh give credit to my um Lord and Savior Jesus Christ uh without his um without his strength and wisdom I don't think I could have been at this job uh at this post um he obviously had uh bigger plans than I expected because this was not on my radar but uh uh I am very happy to be um a part of something as amazing as what I've seen over the the past four years um I do know that um
008um being in this position has been uh not only one of um toil um but also a um just an education uh if there are any anything in which I could um uh tell parents to do is to get involved in something like this it truly is an eyeopener not only do you see um the very best in people but you can see uh some things in which we need to improve on I got to work alongside of uh some pretty amazing um Educators uh at all different levels whether they were teachers whether uh they they were administrators um I highly advise parents to become more involved in uh in this type of forum and in this type of position because it it truly is a um an exp experience uh you start understanding how
009um government works you start understanding that your elected officials even though we put them up on places of uh uh you know extreme importance pedestals uh at the end of the end of the day they're still humans with uh the same feelings and concerns that uh that you may have and um it hurts my heart at times to see how many people will uh try their darnest to tear those those people down that are really just looking out for your kids and if it at any time you are in one of these positions and you think that it's more about you than it is the kids in which you're trying to serve and the public that you're trying to serve then maybe you should re-evaluate what you're actually doing so so with that um I
010also have to thank um uh all all the board members up here that have uh have been very patient with me as I uh kind of stumble my way through a lot of this um and also the executive staff that I've asked several things on just because uh that the the areas that they work in I'm it's just not my wheelhouse so I have to uh have to go to them with um problems and concerns that I might have and to the parents that actually reach out and um uh want to have uh questions answered that uh is you know not not something in which I normally deal with um so they were they were very patient with me as well so um so thank you for that um I have to also uh say
011my wife being so supportive um she's been battling um illness for about four years so I've had uh uh you know to contend with a couple of things at home uh as well as uh you know some of the job functions in which I do but uh for the most part this has been very encouraging uh I love the fact that this community does care and they do um voice what they're concerned with and I guarantee you that um the people up here are doing their best to provide that uh the safety the security the education and what your kids need all right so with that God bless and thank you again for the accolades Sean or Mr Young Blood I just wanted to thank you for your service and for all your commitment thank
012you Maryland right okay we are now in public comment public comment is an opportunity for the public to provide input to the Board of Education during the public comment period board members do not dialogue with speakers or make comments regarding the information shared we have 15 people wishing to speak tonight so each speaker will have two minutes each uh we're going to call you up and we're going to ask you to repeat your name when you get to the podium we'll call Four speakers at a time the first speaker all right so we have 16 so now we have one and a half minutes each now we have 17 so we definitely have one and a half minute each all right so our first speaker will be Tim Murray Sue Sawyer Jenny Bremer and Kathy
013Ballinger good evening uh first off I'm an Eagles fan so go Birds I'm also an area one voter so Sean we don't always agree but thank you for helping to get the lights at El Dorado and thank you for your service the lights at Eldorado have been a long time coming corruption occurs when funds intended for public projects are intentionally misdirected in order order to maximize the benefits of private interests this is a US History standard and will be on my final exam it is known as a graft this community is being taken advantage of by current members of the school board not long ago we were told that USI and ocscs were going to be Innovative schools that would provide P students with opportunities that traditional schools did not provide them we were told
014these programs would help to increase enrollment I was even asked by some of you to support USI today you're asking the community to support having these schools and Innovative programs become independent Charters no longer affiliated with P run by an independent board will all P students still have access to USI that's what you promised you've even added this extra board meeting tonight and you're moving forward without listening to all your constituents you must have forgotten that earlier this year there was a petition signed by over 12200 members of this community against approving an independent Charter thank you [Applause] Tim leadership Isaiah a Leader's role is to model how to communicate respectfully handle conflict and provide constructive feedback to help others learn from from it you purposefully did not put the reprimand from last October in
015my personnel file because I would have been able to file a grievance it was meant to cause intimidation no phone call no conversation no letter you purposely left out everyone in the chain of command director principal assistant principal it which it went straight to me shame on you good leaders don't do that dressing fly doesn't make you competent for the involuntary transfer you didn't even have the tarity or Integrity to give me a phone call send a letter or try to get a hold of me during the summer if this was planned and something you all were proud of you would have announced it you would have put it on Alex's Monday message it was done vindictively two days before I was involuntarily transferred the administration spent $100,000 for live streaming at es bronza and
016two days after you spent another $100,000 on that same project good leaders don't waste $200,000 if they're not going to have a program back it indicates to me that it was not planned out at the end of the day good leadership is about more than just managing outcomes it's about fostering a culture of respect communication and understanding I hope this serves as a reminder that modeling the right Behavior starts with how we interact with one another especially when addressing mistakes or concerns you need to do better you have a lot to learn good evening I'm Jenny Brer uh in October at our at our board meeting Carrie announced that she had a um acquired 2400 double doses of Naran to distribute in our schools is now December as a teacher have heard nothing about this
017we need it to be in our classrooms I've sent emails and uh Miss blades and I have gone back forth with email and I appreciate your interest and we talked about what can be done what and what can be done what needs to be done this is really simple it takes a 13-minute video to train someone on how to use this and how to recognize what an overdose looks like if keeping this in a Cupboard is like keeping fire extinguishers in a Cupboard it's not okay I see all this circus I see all of this political wrangling and all of this nonsense we need to remember number one goal job of everybody here is keeping kids safe please we need those the Nar in every red emergency backpack in every classroom we need it yesterday
018please look at kids safety actually put them first above all this other nonsense please before a kid gets hurt thank you thank you Cathy hi and my name is Kathy valendo Polo um my family started our da journey in 2016 we made the difficult choice of leaving vanen which we loved um to give our children the amazing an opportunity to B be biliterate our first meeting as a community was the summer before kindergarten at that meeting there was a high school teacher from Corona High School he shared that he taught history and government in Spanish and how they just celebrated the graduation of their first High School da students now riddle me this if there wasn't a plan to have the program go through high school here at P why was that teacher there telling
019us about his high school program and the da graduates a promise was made to the DA families that our students would be provided with a program K through 12 not K through 8 we have felt like an unwanted exotic pet people have heard me say that over and over again that the district couldn't get rid of ever since we lost our original directors recently attention has been shown but only on the front end of the program what about our Pioneers what about the kids that the program was built on their backs please don't abandon them now I had the chance to meet with Dr chice yesterday believe it or not nine years he's the first administrator to ever ask for our community's input and feedback and I appreciate that so much he has expressed his
020commitment to making sure that um there's a d high school program and I'm here tonight to ask for your support too I have copies of a petition signed with by over 200 families am I allowed to give you guys these yes all right as she's passing that out we'll have Shanny Murray David Peterson Josh Schroeder and Darcy Garcia thank you how does making the OC School of computer science an independent Charter and taking USI with it benefit P ylusd the district you're supposed to represent how can giving away a school be the best interest for our local students this rushed change to a brand new District run Charter on the heels of an election makes it look like you have something to hide I don't know what's going on behind closed doors but I know
021this move is not what's best for our P Community if you prioritized our needs you wouldn't vote to take District resources away or to Shield the USI budget from public accountability I can't stop you from voting against P's best interests but I will keep standing up for our community more than 10,000 people voted for Trisha Quanto and we look forward to having an educator someone who actually cares for and engages with students on a daily basis as our area represent area one representative moving forward thank you thank you Shanny David right there greetings good good to be back David Pon uh Pastor in the area North Orange County 25 years 15 years special education uh retired now uh sent a letter to each of the board members uh giving my perspective on uh educational alternative
022models Charter Schools pilot schools that type of thing um I don't know I may be the only person in the building that's actually been an employee in a charter school environment or I was in a pilot school environment in LD so hope to share a little bit of that uh that model and concepts with it okay uh I had three points on the letter the first one is that alternative models are very helpful in Creative Innovative platforms for understanding how to do education in more innovative ways so I'm excited about what that can provide for the future uh secondly it benefits us to go from models that already exist the two largest school districts in the country are La D and New York those are the two places the district should be looking to for
023some of those templates and ideas to use for modification uh and finally I provide an example of a charter school renewal uh Charter of middle school and it's 280 Pages which is about half of that and um the board's current input is about 89 well 49 pages so there's a lot lot more to go so thank you thank you Josh Shredder you Josh Shader shider sorry it's fine the ocss material revision was so rushed that at last month's meeting Dr fiser admitted to cranking it out during a marathon 100 Hour Work Week joked about how it was full of typos and suggested the board just feed it to chat GPT to summarize instead of trying to read it her words trusty Frasier we need you to put on your CPA hat here and really look
024at the material revision your clients are the children of this district and the taxpayers who voted for you tonight's staff report has already found these flaws it doesn't contain the financial information and budget projections necessary to operate a school it doesn't Define how special education in IEP students would be supported there's no school safety plan and the agreement on District oversight isn't even written yet the CPA's code of ethics call on you to act with objectivity integrity and give your decisions due care I ask that you apply that same standard to the material revision would you stake your profession reputation on a document like this would you risk your political future on it last month trustee blades said that requiring a super majority to dismiss Dr chernes was necessary to stop what happened at Orange
025Unified from happening here I spoke with someone involved in the ousd recall when they went door to-door explaining the problems with the board it wasn't the firing of the superintendent that swayed voters most you know what did the facts about the trustees Financial mismanagements of District funds spending Millions on an unnecessary Sports facility and letting a charter mortgage off a district owned junior high sound familiar Financial mismanagement that's what cost them their seats so I ask you all again do you want to stake your political Futures on a plan this rushed and this flawed thank you Darcy Garcia my name is Darcy I'm a parent of a student and I reject converting the school to an independent Charter when Dr fiser presented her vision for OCS last year she sold us on a great opportunity
026and appeared organized and well as well as passionate it's why we signed on unfortunately organization and wellth thought out plans aren't what we're currently receiving my child comes home with stories of unruly classmates disrupting the classroom and of teachers unable to curb unacceptable behavior my child believe it's partly due to larger class sizes than what she experienced in fifth grade when my child speaks to old classmates about C um it appears ocss is running behind our home school the impression I'm getting here is that OCS bid off more than it could chew and it's scrambling to fix the problems it didn't properly plan for I feel my child is getting a subpar education compared to our home school and is falling behind while I appreciate the out-of-box thinking for expanding curriculum opportunities in our district
027I don't support doing it at the expense of our children's based educational requirements moreover when we were sold on this school as well as the sports Institute it was to increase our District's attendance by turning these schools into full Charters aren't we going against the original intent this feels like a broken promise from both Dr fiser and this board when we were told this school would remain under the control of the district I urge you to reconsider this approach take the necessary time to plan thoroughly and prioritize our children's best interest rushing these initiatives without proper preparation is detrimental to our children's education PR sha Matt Wilkerson Linda con and lesie Alexander Pria Shaw okay I listen carefully to Dr Fischer's presentation last month the OCS Charter seems like it has great potential but there's
028no convincing argument to revise its material status into an independent Charter multiple reasons to not revise the charter do exist however one students who go to that Charter will not be counted towards the district's Ada two it continues to use District resources for transportation nutrition services professional development staff services Etc costing the district money and there's a lack of accountability The District board will lose oversight and unfortunately we can't count on the County Board under Dr Ste Stefan Bean to produce that accountability there is no reason to revise the ocscs charter unless it's a way to hide something and I can't help but thinking bringing USI into it is a way to do that so just a reminder that besides trusty Young Blood you'll all be here next week and next year and the few
029years after that and unlike this situation with the independent Charter you will be held accountable thank you thank you good evening Matt Wilkerson parent of two in the district I would like the vote to not happen tonight on the ocscs it should be stated on the record that Lander Blade's son is an employee of the OCS ocscs and according to Ed code 35107 a board member shall abstain from voting on personal matters that uniquely affect his or her relatives there is no ambiguity in this code Miss blade should recuse herself from this vote Ed code 4765 states that Charter Schools shall provide operational budget cash flow projections for the first year of operations that has not been provided you're potentially entering into an agreement without any of that in place and this memorandum of understanding
030is poorly worded and ambiguous Ed code 47605 also requires comprehensive descriptions of the 15 required elements the material revision does not the Super nant used to care about the number of students enrolled in the district and touted this a mere month ago now we don't care we're letting 838 students leave the district and take their millions in state funding with them we're also handing the facilities of the USI and the ocss off to Beth Fischer who doesn't know how many teachers she has working for her and finally Ed code requires a 15-day notice for public response to staff recommendations for this he posted this on the third this vote is illegal there is no good reason to vote on this Charter this evening it's rushed it benefits no one and it will be subject to
031lawsuits and a revote once the new board is seated you're wasting time and money Linda con Linda oh I'm sorry yeah I'm sorry I didn't hear my name no problem uh Mr Young Blood we will miss you thank you for your good work God bless you um I'd like to um thank the board and the administration for the long overdue El Dorado lights the walls at Travis and uh finally the valentia cafeteria upgrades but I'd like to thank you even more for the Innovation and choice as exemplified in the Orange County School of computer science I think we all know why the action you're taking tonight is necessary we are led to believe that if this Charter remains within the district it will no longer cease to exist so I am hopeful that the action
032that you will take will allow this Charter a chance to either succeed or fail I can tell you if the staff is any indication of what hard work and Innovation will and can do this Charter will succeed and I think that's why there are people in this room who want to stop it they do not want it to succeed all I can say is to Dr fiser and her staff may God bless your efforts you will succeed thank you [Applause] lesie my name is Lesley Alexander I am a retired P teacher the parent of two P grads and a homeowner in area 1 I would also like to request that the vote for the charter school not move forward tonight why the rush Mrs Buck asked Dr fiser this very question at the November board
033meeting a question that Dr Fischer deflected and never actually answered our students deserve programs that are the result of thoughtful consideration research and are implemented with purpose instead we have programs that are poorly planned and poorly executed a Hallmark of this superintendent for example the original site for USI on caloma a vacant building rendered unusable after a costly renovation a shameful reminder of wasteful spending a failed superintendent and the failed majority board who enabled him now they want to give away USI in the charter school the very assets into which this district has poured millions of public dollars they have rushed this Charter misled this community regarding the charter and now they will fail our students in this community by releasing those assets it reveals a recklessness and a carelessness with our District's assets our
034public funds and the future of our students all right so I'll call the last five Don Miller Linda Manion Steve Reynolds John Quackenbush and Mark Fury okay Don Miller uh one year ago as we've all been hearing we created a charter school quickly without transparency almost a year ago we created the sports program Institute quickly with questions not answered and just a mere three weeks ago this proposal to actually take take our heavily funded charter school now and turn it into an independent Charter without our control is being proposed and it was Miss Anderson who had stated that she needed more information recommended a study session which is very common for something like this this is and it was already being put on for today to be voted on this is a direct violation board
035policy 9251 ethics of Schoolboard members which states sufficient time thought and study to propose actions is to be devoted so to be able to base decisions upon all available facts and vote in accordance with honest convictions unswayed by partisan bias of any kind so what are the benefits to doing this only one benefit would be if we were having a problem with our budget that we had to get rid of the school there are over six reasons not to but here's what I want to everyone understand we've done all this and then our own board president Leandra blad said in an article in the register that this has been under consideration for some time so there it is folks this has been the plan of Alex chernes and Leander blades with the inclusion of Fraser
036and young blood and here is all the board policies that you have been violating thank you and you will get a copy of that thank [Applause] you Linda Manion Apple president our community has recently concluded a very difficult election in which the public was given lots of information and heard very different Visions for our school district the result of this Democratic process was that the public convincingly chose a different direction than that of the current board majority the greatest Challenge in a democracy is not for newly elected officials to take their seats it is for those who do not win elections to accept the results and allow the will of the voters to be implemented nothing hurts democracy more than those at loss an election taking actions after the election results to try and stop
037the will of the voting majority these actions are anti-democratic anti- commmunity and most importantly anti- parents and the children they send to our quality schools Steve thank you hi my name is Steve Reynolds um I'm calling about talking about something completely different than that uh I have become aware of a possibility of saving the district over $6 Million by adopting a health overlay that takes advantage of tax laws and results in this substantial savings what's this based on the county Miami dat seventh largest county United States on November number six adopted this same plan projects they will save an excess of $50 million for their 26,000 employees I think it's uh worth looking at that's why I gave you each a handout with enough information for you to see the resolution that the Miami day
038uh Board of Supervisors adopted and we can dig in it to a deeper offline with staff thank you thank you John good evening John Quackenbush uh area one voter uh so Sean thank you for your service appreciate that and may God bless you your wife and your family and your new Endeavors that uh to repeat what Linda was saying the will of the people spoke on the 5th of November that voted in a new trustee and a new board should be provided the time to re to consider this and the respect that this divor this board has received as well uh Sean I do ask you tonight to vote no on this Charter mou at the very least I ask that you abstain from it and allow the new trustee to learn about it and
039make an informed vote with the new board on that couple of things if if it's true that we have to do this or this is going to fail maybe we need to think about turning it into an academy uh I hear a lot of good things about the stuff that's going on so maybe we don't want to lose the curriculum but bring it back to that on that note with the curriculum I know we spent thousands of dollars uh on new curriculum for this how are we going to get that back are we losing all of that money how are we the all the funds and everything spent the hours of wages spent by our staff working on this how are we getting that back fortunately I haven't read theou so hopefully that stuff's in
040there or you can let me know at another time and really consider this and I please ask that we allow the next to make the informed decision on this thank you very much thank you Mark Mark Fury Mark I publicly want to thank you Sean I know how hard you've worked and uh good luck to you and you're moved to Texas but I have a question and hopefully you can answer it I've been out with a lot of people over the last several months and I have a tough time answering a couple of questions and I just want to verify some facts is it true that the district has paid for the president of the teachers union 100% of her salary for the last 10 or so years is that true yes so what's happening
041is you've got money going in paid by the district being funneled into the teachers union they goes and spend some of that money out for campaigns under funding the liberal people running for the board and we're talking about democracy okay that and saying save our schools save our schools means totally different things depending on what your position is save our schools to people who voted the wrong way because they were misled by the signs they wanted to vote conservative and they end up voting liberal and so I know I'm in a minority but I totally think it's a conflict of interest for you guys to have paid the salary of the president of the teachers union who's G up here and talking about [Applause] democracy all right thank you turn over to you okay we
042have on our agenda item not yet can I introduce the item first and then go ahe what we're going to do yes okay so item uh 12.1 uh and then 12.2 so 12.1 is the material revision submitted to the school board um by the OCS ocscs um some key talking points you obviously have the report we looked at the 15 elements um staff evaluated those and built anou based on those um some key talking points here um first of all uh theou con um contains a a 3% which is the maximum the district can charge the charter school a 3% oversight and um facility use fee so that's about $240,000 a year so to those that are saying we're giving the facility away that's absolutely not true um additionally in theou we will be able
043to we will be charging um any costs associated with um payroll um business functions for the site um on top of the 3% so to process their employees um uh Transportation those sort of um items will be charged the the cost will be charged to the Charter School um this mou uh well the petition itself if approved will would provide as indicated by the board before the ability to um for the charter school to access more funding so for example things like the charter school startup Grant they weren't able to receive in this case they would um uh as far as enrollment goes these students would still um if it if if we're getting kids coming into the charter school it's good for our district it's good for enrollment because those kids would be matri
044matriculating to um primarily esparanza but obviously any pathway they choose including the D program that's at the charter we're building out a um as a parent mentioned we're building a a DA program continuation at um ESP bronza for these kids starting next year here um and lastly I would say that I've been to this school and it's amazing um but uh they've had to uh go through extra additional Hoops to get things like books materials um things that our other schools simply um get approved um there every item for their school is always pulled discussed sometimes voted down um and when you go to the campus you see these teachers who are all here tonight and you see what's going on with the kids and it's absolutely incredible and the fact that they were able
045to put an Innovative program like this together in such short amount of time um is amazing and so the district is not giving away the program they're not giving away the school they're renting a facility there the charter agreement is for a limited time I believe it expires in 29 um from what was approved last year it's a five-year Charter um so some of that M misinformation out in the community is unfortunate but it's it's clearly not the case um as far as USI um theou continues to serve high school students um through USI districtwide so those students would still enroll in Park View just as they are now and still attend any of our schools um but grad 3 through eight could dual enroll um through OCS and attend USI it's on their facility
046and they can do a lot more with the site in dual enrolling kids and getting kids involved so it would not impact the high school USI program um we would continue to offer uh the same contracts we have with USI with our partners for special needs students um before and after school classes um so districtwide students can still access the facility um and we're actually looking at more and more ways this summer to get um more of our high school athletes in there because it's such a great opportunity for our kids so we we didn't want to we didn't want to change that so uh staff would only recommend approving this revision with the maximum 3% charge with the ability to continue to to take on USI High School um and um again the the
047recommendation is to only approve the material revision um if you would also approve theou that protects the district and generates revenue for us that they would then have to build um out of their expenses I'd like to make a motion that we postpone action for a meeting after 2124 excuse me because the board failed to post the staff findings and recommendations with the um at least 15 days prior to the approval or denial of this Charter per statutory requirements in Ed code and I have a copy highlighted for every one of you it states the governing board of the school district shall publish all staff recommendations including the recommended recommended findings and if applicable the certification from the county superintendent of school is prepared pursuant to paragraph eight of sub subdivision C regarding the petition
048at least 15 days before the public hearing at which the governing board of school district either Grant or deny the charter but this isn't the public hearing this is action item one I'm moving that we postpone action okay waiting for a second that's not a this isn't a public hearing I'll second the motion okay let's go for a vote roll call please Mrs Buck no Mrs Anderson so we're not even going to discuss any having a discussion about this oh yeah we can discuss so if we do this we violate Ed code we're required to have this posted 15 days public hearing before public this is not a public hearing the public hearing was at the last board meeting this is not public hearing before we Grant or deny the charter we're supposed to have
049staff recommendation before a public hearing we're getting the the actual petition we have no ability to have staff recommendations before we get the petition submitted to us so we are actually violating Ed code now we're not allowed to vote on this today we have to wait the 15 days so the earliest we can vote on this is 12: 2124 and it has to be at a regular meeting so it's going to have to be bumped to January as well as the [Applause] mou and I was at csba and I discussed this with a number of people there who also agreed with this there's lots of um this is definitely so this was recommended by findings have to be posted 15 days they were posted on Friday that's only four days we have 90 days to
050review a charter we've had 32 days this is very rushed and if we go ahead and take a vote to approve these findings all we're going to do is have to bring it back to fix it this needs to you need to postpone this until we have followed the law legally if you do a little search in the P um uh website and you search staff recommendations and finding you'll see all of those for Orange County School of computer science from November um of last year January of this year and OC and um crla all of those we've had to do the same statutory 15-day requirement this one we did not so we cannot vote today but the character of this so but the character of this is a revision because the charter is already
051approved it's the same for revision or or a new that that part's not in here where's that that's what it it says in both it rision this is valid it Marilyn what the material revisions has the same um Ates a time frame as an original petition it's very clear in Ed code well it doesn't say revisions on this paper so this the muu is prepared by Council we weren't advised of that timeline um if the board wants to vote on this they can I'll be requesting that we bring it back again we'll we can send that to council if the board chooses to vote and approve this then we will s it to council and they'll deem whether it's valid or not okay so let's be clear though on what we're talking about right now
052the motion just a second can I interrupt for a minute yeah yeah I can't I haven't been able to understand one thing Dr turnis has said through this entire meeting and I've been communicating with Mr pal and we've been trying to fix it can he use either Dr Gates or Mrs blad's mic so I can follow along that would be very helpful to me can you hear me Marilyn can you hear me yes okay then we'll use can you hear me everybody else I've been able to hear fine I just don't know what's wrong with um Dr turn's mic can you hear me now can you hear me Miss Anderson yes Dres so I believe what I said was the board may choose to vote on this tonight as it's agendized and if it we
053we will send it to council and if it's deemed um not legal then then they will notify us but uh council did prepare theou and did not advise us that it would be illegal to take the vote tonight I too spoke to council at CB csba last week and they all agreed that it needs to have a 15-day um the findings need to be posted so obviously there's a conflict of what you're saying with what other attorneys are saying and we need to get clarity before we can move forward on this this needs to be approved within 90 days so bumping it to January won't impact our deadlines to approve or not our Council went ahead and said to approve go ahead no our Council prepared theou and did not advise us that can we
054have a little bit of res or we're just going to clear the room this is ridiculous our Council prepared theou and did not advise us that this would not be appropriately posted so if the board chooses cuz we did agendize this appropriately if the board chooses to vote on it we will send it to council but to uh to supersede a vote with something that I'm seen for the first time and you know other board members are seeing for the first time um that not necessarily should should should take Credence over a properly aged meeting Ed code so we should be following it and by postponing the vote the vote till January doesn't have any impact on us F following Ed code or not so by going forward with this today we actually are violating
055Ed code there's no reason to rush this we're still within the 90 days and we need to make sure we're doing this legally and lawfully so we don't cause undue burden on the district with lawsuits [Applause] if you search P you can see the other ones on there too we've had to do this before Oh no I'm looking at the Ed code yeah for this is not a public hearing so that's the the question I have that I'd have for councel is that this is reference to a public hearing the public hearing is when we actually get the original document there's no way to have staff recommendations and findings at that same time or 15 days prior to getting that I understand that so this is the 15 days prior to the time we take
056that action of vote where whether we approve or deny I understand that I'm just saying that this is in reference to a public hearing which this is not so that that would be my question for Council right it says right here public hearing a public hearing for a charter school is a formal meeting where the public can provide input on a proposed Charter and petition the purpose of the hearing is to allow the community to share their support for the charter and to provide testimony in favor against it and this this is not a public hearing tonight so at what point do you do the staff recommendations if you get the hear if you have the petition come before the board and front with it during the hearing so at what point do the recommendations
057come back and it doesn't change any of the fact that the there has to be a 15-day posting for staff recommendations period I think the fact that Council didn't come back with anything regarding timing different than that no you can make all the noise you want did they know we were not posting it they know known this whole time posted they review our stuff but we posted it on the other occasions so did they tell us in the other occasions we had to post 15 days prior they didn't so maybe it's a council issue but they should have told us 15 days because we missed that statutory requirement yeah I would definitely need them to weigh in on this because they did not tell us that so let's move this to uh the January board
058meeting postpone this action [Applause] it's better be postpone than violate Ed code and not only that it would cause some issues likely with ocscs with the up and down of what we're going to do so it should all be handled it should be vetted through Council this should be discussed with them um it states in their 15 days for with staff recommendations it's clear iion that it's clear on the way that you read it versus the way that an attorney I mean we're not none of us are attorneys which is why we have Council um it says public hearing it doesn't say anything about so maybe this should have been an another public hearing instead of just move to approve two public hearings I'm still at the point where how do you have a public
059hearing when you're just receiving the information and also provide staff recommendations you can't you have to have it first then you have staff recommendations then we approve and then we come back with theou all of these steps are so fast we're not following the statutory requirements so if how come you didn't bring this up to our Council today can we have them in the back get out please you have to give a warning PA Paula powers can you have to give a warning can you be quiet for a moment I will give her warning I was about to say Paula Powers you've been warned great thank you Paula powers please thank you so how come you and Marilyn if this was discussed at csba which was last Wednesday Thursday and Friday how come you didn't
060call David Huff how come you didn't State his concerns and then you just sprung it at the board meeting tonight I'm not the president of the board so I am not entitled to communication yes you are you call him all the time you Mar called him yes he's told me several times I haveed to him once or twice and when you go through and you look at who the communication goes through uh related to board issues it goes through the board president for our bylaws right but Marilyn has made several phone calls as well Marilyn did you call David huff at from csba or he was at csba see him at csba I did not see David H at csba and I did not call him I talked to csba attorneys that were there okay
061and also I didn't know that this was going to be on the agenda until Friday night when it came to me no one said that this was I got no forewarning no telling me what was going to be on the agenda and that's when I started doing my research so if you want me to be more prepared then how did you ask at csba information ahead of time Marilyn then how did you ask on the agenda Marilyn Marilyn can you hear me Marilyn who's the speaking it's the the mics at the district coming through are very garbled so it's very hard to understand Marilyn this is Todd can you hear me now Marilyn yes who's speaking this is Todd hi hello Mr Frasier um so my question is if you just found out about this
062Friday how did you ask about it at csba because we were there on Saturday as well the conference goes through Saturday okay thought you said Wednesday just now Thursday Friday Saturday th Wednesday's the pre-conference got it should we take a break and I'm Marilyn calling by phone so it's easier for her to hear yeah I think so how is she calling in that's what Jeremy suggested okay okay yeah we maybe you suggest it because your mic is on and she can't hear his yeah Marilyn we're going to take a break and we're gonna be calling by phone so you can hear us better maybe that didn't work I don't think she can hear that thank you okay we'll take a five five minute break okay can Marilyn can you hear us yes I can hear
063you okay all right so we have a motion on the table to push this out and Council just told us that there is um nothing that you guys are stating he says that there's nothing about material revisions it's only for Renewal or for a startup of a charter so there's no evidence of that he went through all of the statutes he had his partner on the phone and they had said all that so he says go ahead um you know it's it's in his opinion that there's nothing CED uh cited whatsoever for material revision and in fact the only thing that talks about for material revision is 4605 a subsection 4 and it doesn't talk about anything all it says that you have to have a public hearing doesn't talk about anything posting or what
064whatnot I have conflicting comments from other attorneys so you can go ahead with it but I'll be bringing this back and requesting other attorneys look at this okay sounds good so this vote the vote is the vote is to your vote was to push the postpone action to the January meeting okay so the vote is to move the action to the January meeting Mrs Buck I Mrs Anderson I Mr Young Blood I are you sure you're voting I okay all right no no and I'm a no okay so it will be pushed to the January meeting [Applause] I move that we also take the memor memorandum of understanding between p and ocscs off as well since that will have to come afterward I second that yeah I mean it's kind of a moot point if
065uh I I definitely recommend we bring that back with the petition yeah oh so do we need to vote then on that or would it just come back automatically move theable just pull it pull it and just just a quick explanation guys the um I wouldn't feel in good conscious if we were to do that I believe in this charter school I truly do but I want to make sure that we do it correctly I don't want it to get I don't I don't want it to get hum uh ham string um but I I do realize that there are um uh entities out there that would that would like to see this fail I would not want that to happen and I don't want to start it off in a way in which is
066going to be uh against Ed code and against the the the whole reason that we're putting it together so um that's okay that's why I did that all right so so we don't need to approve the m so we'll just go on to Valencia okay we are going to turn it over to Mr Gary Stein for the Valencia cafeteria before Mr Stein starts um we've had challenges with the Valencia kitchen for some time now given the fact that we have so many students there um in such a small serving facility so what we've been looking at is ways to um improve the facility um in in manners that can be both efficient and cost effective um I'm personally very concerned about a new build there um given the cost of knocking down down buildings and
067and rebuilding um so what we're looking at is where actually the old kitchen was there's actually still even a sign on the auditorium multi-purpose room whatever um you call it multi-purpose room that says kitchen Valencia kitchen so um that is where the um the old kitchen was and so we think that it's more cost effective um and and also um it makes a lot of sense to have it go there so with that uh Mr Stein thank you took a little bit of my thunder so um that's good though so um okay I'll start thank you president blades members of the board superintendent Dr chist ex executive cabinet staff and community members I'm happy to hear to be here to talk to you about the Valencia High School cafeteria or the kitchen um and what
068I want to say I want to say thank you to our to our teams who put in a lot of work um to find different options to we've met with lots of vendors to make sure that we um are bringing different options forward to the board that are possible right um that are affordable um but they give you the best options uh to look at we will be coming back to you at a later meeting with a decision so this is just a discussion we're going to share the options and then uh we can of course get some guidance at a later meeting so I wanted to go into just the background a little bit Valencia High School for those that didn't know I didn't know this until we did research established in 19333 uh
069graduating class in 1934 was one student um and we had some significant growth U through the 90s and uh got to a point where we had uh 2,782 students on seabeds day in 201617 so tremendous growth um during that time there's been a lot of change in the national school lunch program um I mean we went we didn't have the program then we had the program and then uh they changed the nutritional standards uh and then when you have the combination of the lowering of nutritional standards and the growth of all of these schools most school districts in California at the time really closed down or or shrunk their kitchen sites because they didn't need it and we we did the same and so um what happened is is that uh just a few years
070ago in 20 I believe 2022 I can't read that far 22 22 23 we had Universal meals it was passed by the California state legislature um which basically puts a lot more pressure on kitchens at schools and so we need to do something quickly about that um and also at that site we have lots of students waiting to get lunch so we want to make sure we're able to to serve them latest enrollment that we have uh at at Valencia High School is 2410 students um the average number of meals that we serve on Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday and Friday is 1,53 uh meals per Stu or meals per day so that's 52% of students get fed on a daily basis which is fantastic it's it's higher than any other site we have um on
071the minimum days It Go drops considerably because we only have one lunch and the facility is not really built to serve that many students so um the kitchen is far too small um and so we've been looking for ways to enhance the facilities serve more kids make sure the kids can get through pretty quickly and get their lunch so for those that have not um looked at Google Maps and and went through to see where it is uh where this kitchen is when you walk on campus uh when you walk through the main gates uh you see something that says cafeteria and the first visit I had to Valencia High School I said that is the coolest building I've ever seen it's it's it's a very historic building and they said that's not the cafeteria
072it's over there so I'm showing you where it is on the map and it's kind of drilling in there um so in case case you're curious that's where it is on the campus as we were going through different options um the first option that we were presented with was take taking the the current kitchen which again is not the cafeteria it's the kitchen right next door demolishing it and building a bigger facility and so that was the first option that that was recommended to us as you can see um the the building would be bigger right because we need to serve more kids we need a bigger kitchen we need more ability to to um to have more lines where kids can go through so it would be located in the same space but it
073would take up a much larger footprint on the campus which right now we have shade structures and benches and things that would all have to be uh repositioned so some of the pros and cons and I think this shifted over a little bit um so it is a larger kitchen that would be fantastic we do need that um we wouldn't really have any impact to any other student spaces on campus because we would be putting it in the same location just expanding the footprint uh and it would give us OPP when you start fresh you have the opportunity to really optimize the space to the best way possible the cons to this would be um there are impacts of students we'd have to close off that section of Campus um and and the construction would
074be much longer um estimated I'm saying two plus but I'm saying it would be probably three years at least um and then during that time um we would also have reduced student lunch area which is currently where they're hovering around and eating um and then the cost so the cost that we have estimated um based on what the Architects brought us is $5.2 million to do a complete demolish and rebuild of a kitchen so that is option one option two um really came about when we were looking at we love that building and we'd love to reuse it right so when we look at the building we said hey if it was the cafeteria at one point there must have been a kitchen um VHS is a is a historic site it's it's a very
075old school that is a historic building it's a beautiful building and I'm going to show you what it looked like or at least the drawings for what it looked like when it was first built um you have a large and connected alumni that go to VHS everywhere I go I run into VHS alumni and I'm like I yes I do know Valencia High School in Placentia absolutely um and they are very connected um the reason that we really zoned in on or really focused on this uh option is that the community there's a lot of support in the Placentia Community a lot of support with with the alumni um we would love to uh do something with the building to help the kids have more uh pride in their campus which I know they have
076a tremendous amount of pride but it would be a feel-good moment and use what we have rather than trying to build something new so and I'm going to show you some design or schematics and things in a second but the pros and cons so Pros uh we get to take this uh really neat historic building and Revitalize it make it new make it beautiful again um and I'll show you what it looks like and and what we've done over the years and and what how that's going to change um we would love a campus beautification project at Valencia High School and um we would pres uh give us an option to to have two different serving spaces one that would be optional but it would allow us to retain the current kitchen re uh structure
077it so they can serve more kids by having pass through Lanes but then shift the entire cooking uh Machinery upstairs to the uh to the cafeteria where it was before so it gives us an option to actually serve more kits uh and then we have the option with uh that building to create a new student meeting space I'm going to talk a little bit about that far shorter construction timeline um part of the cons would be that we would be needing to take up there's a space that's being used by ASB right now and then it's a work room right next door we would be taking that space back um and so that would be one of the cons uh we're limited by with design possibilities because that kitchen was there before it's not like
078we want to shift our plumbing and the gas and everything into different places so we're limited uh with how we can optimize space um and just any construction is a problem on a school campus so the estimated cost though of this is $2.8 million um to do the revitalization so what I wanted to show you just some pictures of of what it is now so if you're famili amiliar with the campus this is the current um state of that building that beautiful building um what we've done over the years are we've covered up Windows we've put in air conditioning units in Windows we have we've really kind of blocked it off there's a lot of cool graphics um but the building looks very different than what it did when it was built this is what
079it looked like when it was built full of Windows lots of uh natural light coming into the building um there were no AC units there were no uh things sticking out of Windows it was a very it was a beautiful building uh when it was first built due to the fact that we had to convert it to being usable space and this was prior to AC then we you know now we have uh need to have AC obviously um things changed what we're proposing is take it back to where it was is to make this building look like this again and um make the kitchen happen again so um the design of it uh if you so provided some schematics um this was actually the first design to where we were going to take over
080a large portion larger portion of the building and and put storage and things we're not going to do that anymore so what you've got are those two spaces on the right the purple shaded space is where the kitchen was and that it will be again and it's actually the same layout that it was when the building was first built um we would be adding some dry storage and freezers underneath so there's this basement really neat basement area underneath that right now we use for uh like golf carts and other things that are parking in there uh we're going to turn that into some storage which would be great um and then the idea that we had is that that that area just outside the kitchen which right now is being used as a workroom could
081be used and transformed into what we're calling maybe a student student union or uh we were just toying with different names tiger Court was one that we threw out there but somewhere where we can basically Revitalize that space may it somewhere kids want to be um make it a little more modern but but also allow alumni maybe we celebrate all of the classes or as many as want to contribute to put up in that building so that the kids can go in there they can see the the rich history of Valencia High School so it would be a really cool thing um for that campus and all that's included in that cost so that's where this is a pretty exciting um idea so that's that's the main building and then we've got um the current
082kitchen which we would change it around to remove a lot of the uh cooking equipment and just have heating stations and then we'd have a lot more service lines so the kids can really pass through so we would be able to um serve more kids a lot more quickly and I forgot to mention this there's also an option to add in a serving line in that kitchen itself so that's not what we're prop those doors will be closed most of the time so that the kids can use the space but if needs be we could and so it gives us different options there as well so when we talk about uh where the funding would come from what you've got also in here are some proposed uh spending um options and what funds they would
083come from and so what you'll see is we in we do facilities projects we use a lot of braided fundings uh funding stream so we use developer fees we'll use the Redevelopment agency uh funding and also some fun 40 in order to make the projects happen so either one they are doable over time um but but option two obviously is my favorite because I have you know 15 slides of that one and like two of the other but um it's it it's and it's cheaper which I twisted his arm a little bit there on super cool my arm hurts you know but um but yes but it's a I feel like it's a great opportunity for the school um for the students there it would be a it would be quite a boost uh for
084that so wanted to share that and then um I guess engage in discussion and answer any questions so yeah before we get into those real quick just next steps if we do get direction that this looks like a good direction to go the next steps would be to um bring back an architect to actually do the designs for it um and then as far as projected costs you know these are projected construction costs can go up significantly sometimes they go down but usually they go up so um the 2.8 is is what we're our best estimate at this time um we do generate developer fees each year so I think it's it is a good um fund to look at to primarily fund this the project um but U just want to put that out
085there yeah when I when I saw this come through I I'm really excited about that revitalizing that because there's such a historical um it's such a historical campus and that building is cool even the way that CF is written on the outside like the the super retro and I think that's awesome so and they've needed this for a long time are we going to have issues using developer fees again though with the community no we we had that cleared with the with the lawyers last year I I did have one question about the ASB use uh have you talked with principal herfeld about what that would what that would do yeah yeah he's on board he's on board yes we we have space we can we can move that uh the ASB and and okay
086we're not we're not taking away space we're just changing it we would be shifting okay I personally love the my question is about the cost of Shifting them is is there space that building is really large and um are we shifting them into that building or U totally relocating the current students to a new section of the campus so we would need to relocate there's one classroom there is a work area and and then there is actually that that's all we would be U relocating so um we would need to relocate the classroom to more most likely a portable somewhere the whole storefront and everything that's that's all going to stay so everything to the that's outside of that big room would stay we would just need to find a different place for ASB to
087to for workspace they're in a couple of different they're they're currently in both sides of that which is actually pretty large when you look at different asbs yeah um so I mean it's relatively reasonable as long as we're making sure we create some space or or ensure that they have some space I I love the idea of keeping it an a historic building it matches the auditorium we've got the old elementary school campus or um building on there I think it adds so much character it would lose a lot it would just look like one of those other buildings like like the um the kitchen or all the um culinary arts we have next to it it just it would just kind of vanish in there um so I am a fan of that cheaper
088also is great um and it allows us to maybe have some other creative things that we can include in it because we aren't having to stretch it so far um so I'm interested to see what an architect potentially could bring us and and see what it looks like and you're okay using developer fees M and Marilyn you're okay using developer fees for this this is what developer fees are for yeah and as an alumni of ala high school I'm very excited about this and I would personally like to tour and see um when I get back what this is going to look like and um and see and see how the rest of the building is going to be utilized um because I'm not sure how the the preschool is being utilized if that's going
089to be incorporated it's hard to tell from these drawings that are small on my little handout that I got so I would really love a tour and um to see exactly what the vision is happy too thank you Todd for bringing up Chris herzfeld because it's important to have the site leader be part of that and understand what's going on because they can help facilitate the conversations around campus when people are watching all of it happen and obviously we're going to need to because it's no matter what we do we're going to be um imp ing the kids lunches for a period of time and so we need the uh the local site leaders to help us with that messaging that that something better something Great's coming and you know make sure kids are excited
090about it but also they may have to um shift how we're getting lunch for a little bit well that's what I was going to ask what do we do with how how do we do that if we have no kitchen there are we just going to be utilizing you know a outside food distributor for the time being and then pick up where we left off once the kitchen is done or do the other Schools are they do they have the ability to cook for them them and bring it over so that's what we'll be doing so we the good news is is that we don't have to shut down the current kitchen because we we can start construction of that one without impacting it it's just that time when we do have to shift to
091work on the on the new serving lines that's when we'll have to if that one's not available we're going to have to bring the food down and distribute it a different way but the I mean because I was going to say it's a timing issue then because if the new kitchen is done then it's just serving line yes when we are revamping that so that seems reasonable we could strategize that being done in the summer that particular building oh yeah absolutely there there's option I'm just like timing wise whenever we plan something for the summer it's always a it's it's pretty dicey because every school district in the world wants everything done in the summer Ralph is freaking out right now yes he is he's I can feel him buzzing in my pocket yeah okay
092thank you very cool okay so the next step we bring back a um a proposal from an architect for the [Applause] project all right so we're moving into the consent calendar actions proposed for the consent calendar items are consistent with approved practices of the district and are deemed routine in nature the trustees receive board agenda backup information Advance the schedule meetings and are prepared to vote with knowledge on the block vote items are there any items tonight that need to be pulled none all right then I need motion please I'll make a motion we approve the consent calendar second I have a motion by Mrs Buck I have a second by Mr Young Blood we'll have to do a roll call vote Mrs Buck hi Mrs Anderson hi Mr Young Blood hi Mr Frasier I
093all right and I'm an i motion carries 5 Z Sean why don't you you be the one to make the motion close uh at this time I'd like to make a motion to adjourn the December 10th 2024 Board of Education meeting at 7:53 there you go 1953 I'll second all right I need a roll call vote Mrs Buck hi Mrs Anderson I Mr Young Blood hi Mr Frasier hi and I'm an i all right we'll see you next Tuesday w