CorpusRecord 109590

VCUSD Board Of Education Special Study Session 1/22/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / VCUSD Communications
Date
2025-01-23
Location
Solano County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
13,474 words · about 75 min
Collected
2026-06-20

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening everyone welcome to this special meeting today is uh January 22nd and it is 505 can we please have roll call trusty hajes here trusty Flores trusty young here vice president Amboy pres and President Fox present and we have a quorum thank you at this time let's do uh our Pledge of Allegiance i al to the flag United States ofer to stands is there a motion for agenda item 1 C adoption of our agenda I'd like to make a motion to adopt agenda item 1 c a second roll call please trusty Hodes I trusty Flores I trusty young vice president Amboy I and President Fox I and the motion passes thank you at this time we're going to um be on agenda item two informational study stud government board study of closures and consolidation

002of schools it is recommended that the governing board receive information and study the material provided good evening board members and community so this evening we are getting close to bringing a decision to the end around school closures and consolidation uh we want to take this opportunity this evening to walk through the options that the board has been considering um talk about the timeline and also provide direction to staff so we are prepared for our regular board meetings in February where a decision will be made so a bit of background specifically we have our vcusd actual and projected enrollment and this is projected out to the year's 2032 we work with our demographers to make sure that can you all see let me see back we make sure that this data as you can see going

003back to 2020 into our most recent enrollment data um we have considered we we can still continue to see a decline we are seeing some flattening out in the out years but the decline has continued in a previous data set we showed the tenure Outlook from the past where we had in 20145 upwards of 14,000 plus students so in a 10 year year period we more than a 10e period we've lost roughly 5,000 students as a district so we had some District goals regarding closure and consolidation we are looking at rightsizing the district ensuring that the responsible stewardship of public property and of program resources we know that having a 19 comprehensive schools and an adult school for a population of 9,000 students is significant and we know that we can provide resources to a

004much more concentrated resources if we were to rightsize the district we want to capitalize on the sub substantial programmatic benefits we've had discussions about some schools being small where there's limited resources based on the number of teachers you might have at a grade level we know that quality instruction is greatly improved when teachers can collaborate and they have people at their grade level to collaborate we also know that when students and families have options for different programs that we see a greater increase in the commitment to our district but also uh to the programs that are served we want to realize the financial benefit and avoid unnecessary interventions by fiscal oversight entities that specific specifically speaks to our status in receivership we have made our final loan payment however we're not in the clear quite

005quite yet we have some measures we need to take some of those measures include right sizing the district and that includes potential closure and consolidation of schools so the county and the state is looking at us to see our actions they're watching us to see that we do the necessary steps so we don't go back into receivership or need to borrow any more money like we did 20 years ago we want to ensure that the closed or Consolidated School site are not left vacant that was clearly something that the board is adamant about and so we held a 7-Eleven committee where we looked at what we could do with the properties we looked at five specific School properties and the 7-Eleven committee did give us a report where they offered us the ability to Surplus

006property as needed lastly we are forward thinking we want to make sure our plan accommodates future development we've disc discussed the potential development on May Island we've discussed other property developments throughout the city and what we realize is our we have the capacity among our schools we're currently sitting at 46% capacity to to grow as needed even with school closures we would have space and and and availability for students that come and join us so this is a reminder of our timeline how we got here so back in April of 2023 three the board engaged total School solutions to draft the equity impact analysis report that is a report is necessary when you are considering school closures you look at the demographic makeup of a school you look at the programs that are offered you

007look at potential receiving schools and new comparative studies there was a board Workshop a presentation of the report and the proposed budget reductions back in January of 2024 so just over almost a year ago that discussion occurred and at that point it was identified that the district would be looking at a reduction in budget of over $4 million in years 2526 in April the board gave next steps for closure and consolidation process which included the formulation of a 7-Eleven committee to look at properties that committee was formed in September of this this past year in 2024 and the committee did hold four meetings and those are listed there the recommendations of the 7-Eleven committee came to back to the board in November and in that there was designations of surplus or properties declared as Surplus

008now the equity impact analysis report is required by law through assembly Bill 1912 and whenever we consider schools for closure we need to present this report to the board and at a public meeting to allow for public feedback and then that report is brought back in another meeting for for a secondary uh approval so that report was presented close to a year ago so there are some considerations that our our legal team will talk about a little bit later with the eia as we move forward but want be cck that was for just a certain X number of schools not others that the board make consider which so the public knows would delay or wouldn't be this round or this phase correct when this eia was initially formulated there was uh five schools that were

009reviewed in this process after the report of the 7-Eleven committee and the recommendations was given to the board in November we can go back and look in November 20th the board did direct staff to look at additional schools now those additional schools will be considered as part of a phase two reduction plan or consolidation plan right now we're going to be focusing on phase one that that are schools that will be impacted in 2526 we know that our job is not done when it comes to reductions and consolidation and we will be returning to look at school closures or consolidations for the year 2627 so a bit of data we have the schools listed here on the side were parts of the schools that were reviewed as part of the equity impact Equity impact analysis

010report now all these schools listed were not up for closure consideration some of the schools listed were listed because they would be impacted as potential receiving schools but it's important that we look at both sets of schools when we did the report so you can see for example if we go across Stefan Manor is a TK to5 School the current enrollment as of January 17th the total capacity for that School site so these are the number of potential empty seats if we utilized all the classroom spaces for classrooms it's not to say these spaces are not utilized they are utilized but as regular classrooms that's how many students we could put there leaving us the available capacity and we did that for each one of these School sites as you can see in the red

011numbers we do have space at many of these schools at all of these schools the charter we don't add the capacity question because it's that doesn't follow that pattern for us do we have questions around this specific data comments from the board Charter schol we don't have the capacitor okay so Mitch will look for the capacity we do know it has that facility has large capacity as you mentioned it was a a Middle School Junior High School the reason we don't list the capacity for the charter school is because that school being a charter has the ability for us to place it in different locations so that capacity could shift depending on where it's housed in our previous Sports study session there was concern questions about ex what how much money or how much revenue

012can be saved when we close schools and so the team did look at the analysis for these School sites and how much savings would be incurred for general fund and lcap this is noting that not every staff member at a school would be eliminated because for example teachers certain programs would travel with students so this is typically operational costs School principal office manager custodial staff those types of positions that land in this chart I also want to note that these are ongoing savings so these are not oneandone savings when you close a school you're essentially saving that year after year for the public because some people last night at the Town Hall were asking about well Lincoln School only has 70 some students why don't you consider well since it doesn't have the equity report

013current you can't and it will not be done in time it cannot be considered for this coming school year that's why to answer that question from last night for valo Charter School are the numbers of savings available for that so valo Charter because it's a dependent Charter doesn't fit within our same budget stream they have their own separate budget stream so we wouldn't realize if Theo Charter closed as a school we wouldn't realize that from the district perspective as a savings that makes sense that's school is funded through the charter and they have their own separate out cap their own budget cycle completely do you want to use a mic thank you Charter capacity is currently 608 students and how many do we currently have there um I don't know 352 something like that 35

0145360 okay can you go back though I'd like to hear more about no no no no you can say that um valo tar school if that was a considered site to be moved or Consolidated can you still talk about I mean because you still have staff um that would not be duplicated if you go to another site or maybe that so that still would be a savings and then the other aspect that was looked at was the location of the land or maybe revenue from the land correct so bilood Charter currently resides on what used to be Springtown middle school that is a property when we look at actually let me I will get to a slide where we talk about um Bond money and school sites and where we've spent Bond money so valo

015Charter School's site we have not spent the bond money on it so it allows us the prop the opportunity to put a site like that up for sale which would generate Revenue Downstream but not all of our school sites are available for that so may Island Health and Fitness is a School site that we would not be able to sell and generate Revenue it also has a very specific deed requirement that site needs to remain a school facility so there was a question in a previous board study session regarding the cost to maintain a facility that might be vacant or not not utilized as a school so this chart speaks to that specific cost associated with securing a campus so for each of these campuses we have what the cost the annual cost for fire

016intrusion and cameras fire inspections grounds and maintenance just some onetime cost Associated and a rough basic estimate of what the annual cost would be to maintain the facility no security there's no security listed like how much was security be to because I know we had some sites it was very expensive to have security for that site so I don't see that column but I I appreciate these columns right I think I think on this PowerPoint there's a slide that discusses security so maybe we can oh here it is you want to speak to that one MIT you can sure sure I mean you know so what we have um is a community where we find high degrees of theft and vandalism property crime and uh we we we are the beneficiaries of this property crime

017in some form or fashion on a weekly basis often most often you never even hear of it but it happens regularly um the district secures its site in in accordance with best practices so we have existing systems out there fencing alarms surve C surveillance camera systems uh Fire Systems Etc and we're constantly reviewing exposure and security modifications so take an example Franklin Franklin Middle School yes um gvrd uses the gym but that's only one small piece and um we haven't had an issue at Franklin since we were able to um restore it back from that substantial property crime we had about three years ago um we have employed Private Security Services um in in the past and and and trusty Fox what you're referencing is the Franklin issue and then the faragate issue where we

018were hit uh to the tunee of about 5.5 Million doar worth of property crime between the two our our uh insurer um required us to provide site security private security over there in order to because all the systems were down we were we were getting hit repetitively and so we put 24hour security over there which you recall is quite expensive very very expensive I think that it was over 300,000 it's about 300,000 per site if I'm recalling correctly the insurance company reimbursed us for a significant amount of that money so we were out um maybe 100,000 for each site it's it's it's no small number um but it it's uh it's what we needed to do to combat the issues in our community since then we have had so most recently this year we had

019a contract with two components one was for emergencies an example would be we lost the entire security systems at at uh Cave Elementary so we need to get we need to get 24-hour private security up there now because we don't have the capacity to do that within the district so we had that component and then we had um routine uh eight hour patrols on weekends and that was just throughout the district and just to help help us prevent any additional crime um and so that that what that amount was 10 100,000 I think which is um sort of in line to what we had anticipated and what we needed um we had to increase that you may recall we just had to increase that and that was because at our bond sites in the late

020summer we experienced property those sites were getting picked off left and right so all four of those sites we probably had some little crew running through town and they were breaking through our fences they were stealing their equipment giant tractors etc etc so they had to they brought in their security for stuff and then we had to bring in extra Private Security in order for for us to support completion of those summer work projects in order to get those kids back on August 19th if that's the right date but it was touch and go with with a theft in the community and and uh so you do you're you're correct in that you recall significant expenditures most of that was much of that was reimbursed and then our ongoing private security costs have been probably

021within reason I think given given what we're facing uh in in our community thank you there was also um a number of copper theft here in valo and some weekends it was one night after the and then the next night and we're talking that's that comes out of general fund so it's $50,000 a pop one night and another $50,000 approximately the next night that money comes out of our current general fund because we cannot submit claims to our insurance because our deductible is too high to cover so that is a frustrating thing throughout California not just here in valo but here in valo like you said we've been hit or targeted for a number um of times not just the issues you said but for the copper theft and it's really sad when it comes

022right of your general fund because your insurance is up to your deductible so high that you have to pay for it it can't be submitted because you submit too many claims and they want to drop you they don't want you to have insurance so um it's very complicated but thank you very much for your explanation and so if so in order to secure a site should we close one we know we're going we have to repurpose it right um just say Acme Elementary School and we close Acme Elementary School well maybe we convert Acme Elementary School to provide other programmatic uh facility for other programs and and uh so as an occupied facility while we get an appraisal for Acme Elementary and we put Acme Elementary on the market and we enter into an escrow

023with Acme Elementary for the next 27 year escrow right as as as we're facing with KB in the city of Alo um so so um we we would do our best as we've done with Franklin once we've we' got it back is and uh we're pretty comfortable with keeping it secure thank you so this next slide really speaks to the facilities master plan and some of the bond expenditures we have at this point utilized so you can see that for Stefan Manor and Ward law there was 15 million that were actively spent on that on those two properties Penny cook and Loma another 11 million mayor Island and Vallejo Charter those sites have five and8 million dedicated funds for future projects but at this point there's no projects that have begun and that's important to

024note because it gives us the opportunity speaking about those two sites individually Mar Island's a little different because it's not the way we're deed with that property we wouldn't be able to do things like sell it but Val Hood Charter specifically on this list is a property we could then turn around to sell to generate revenue for the district because we have not utilized those bond funds yet to provide upgrades to that Federal Terrace and Lincoln we have used bond funds 13.9 million for those sites so that if we were going down a path where we were looking at closure or consolidation of those schools we would want to repurpose those facilities to stay within the public use for our district any questions from the board on these so this takes us to options and

025I think this is really the bulk of where we'd like to have the board discuss um where where you're where you're leaning what are you thinking because this is where the direction we're going to be receiving as staff as we prepare for the regular board meetings in February where we would be getting to a decision Point around closure and consolidation so option one is when we we went down a pathway where and you can look at the far column where it says permitted and current eia that means Stephen Manor as a school could be closed by the board because we have gone down the pathway we've analyzed that school we we could talk about repurposing that facility and potentially consolidating step and Manor with Penny cook in this process in the 7-Eleven committee there was

026a suggestion to look at it going the opposite direction how could we consolidate Penny cook into Stephen Manor so we did the the data behind that but you notice there's a no at the end because that was not part of the original eia so if that is something that the board wants us to go down a pathway we would then include that in the updated or new eia it wouldn't be ready for what we're calling phase one of closures and consolidation it would be a phase two process that we would review so I'm going to open it up to the board any discussion on Stefan or Penny cook I would like to suggest that personally that this we would hold off for till phase two to another phase not the current phase either one that's

027me then I also would like to know were were uh traffic impact studies part of this because based on the two sites I know one I think is a little more forgiving to add students versus the other so if that wasn't something that was looked at I'd like to see something if you if we are going to move this into a phase two just to see which of the two would impact the community as a whole less because so far as distance to get to and from when my oldest was uh I want to see like in second grade maybe kindergarten with the big fire at Stephan Manor they had all the kids going um up to Penny cook so I know that you can walk from there it's not an unreason reasonable distance but

028adding more cars onto Rolling Wood and anyhow um I I think that's what I'd like to see if if we're not you know if we move this over to to phase two would Transportation be a factor like busing or anything like that either um for for for either way for Stephan or part of the reason we looked at these two sites in particular was that they were walkable so the distance between these these two sites would allow for them to not have to provide transportation because that Community could get to either school from where they're currently their neighborhood schools would be but that is something we we looked at closely the walkability of each of these School sites um is this on okay I um kind of the stepan manic consolidation to Penny cook um

029and uh trusty Flores was asking for a um traffic something like that okay um h was originally a high school and it had like 1500 students there and um there was never a traffic problem there with Hogan and Penny cook and stepan Manor I know because I was vice principal so that there there's not a congested area there Hogan is no longer a high school so that's minus maybe 500 students so there wouldn't be a traffic problem but to get an estimate of a expert to tell you what I just told you that's fine but I was there when it was 1500 and it wasn't a problem I I think the two schools open as elementaries yeah well I I what what I would like to look at is more so what that congestion look

030like at the site because I know that for example High School you're going to have less parents driving their kids there because they're not Elementary School age so I think you have less traffic flow in in that scenario but I know when when my son was at uh Stephan Manor it could get pretty gnarly there and folks would just jam up the parking lot at 7-Eleven and it it the congestion there was was pretty insane so that's more so not so much is it doable but more so is it going to take a parent half an hour to drop their kid off where it's taking them 10 minutes now that that's that's more of what I mean by kind of gauging what more students at site a versus site B would look like it not

031not can the city infrastructure handle more people it's just more of how's it going to impact parents dropping their kids off if you have to wait 45 minutes because the line has now doubled because you have more students at at the at the one site well there's an easier FL at Option One there's an easier flow because there's two there's there's main streets running each way alongside of it and a there's an easier flow yeah thank you pen I would I would agree with that yeah my student my kids went to Penny cook when it was well over 7 800 students and I Dro them off every day and and um because you've got that four corners you got some main streets insides where at Steph and you simply just have that one Ingress erress

032and it's very narrow um around Penny cook there's a little more space and they've got a system for drop off along is that Baywood whatever one of the one streets that is where they they have kind of this process for drop off on the side lot um so I do know that it had been quite a lot larger at one time when my kids were there and drop off wasn't a major issue with the space around Penny cook because you've got the back the front the side got lots of ways I remember when I've been at step and matter at um dismissal it's very congested on the street in front of it um but I think like you're saying penic cook is much more because the streets and it's not as congested so just to

033clarify trusty Flores is asking for drop off and pickup congestion with numbers of kids correct yeah okay I also think it's important for for us to remember that in some ways this has already been tested there was a moment of time where Stefan was part of Penny cook because of the fires and I I wasn't here at the time I don't know I can't speak to the experience for parents at that time but that that was tested before I don't know if Mitch do you remember how that went you here at the time or Dr Young I think it went well because people felt a sense of community right because everybody's displaced by the fire so you had more patience you know more love for your fellow man so to speak um and and to

034and to Dr Young's Point Stefan 2 was over 700 back in the day and so um yeah and as were all of our schools I right now though if you look at our schools in traffic it's worse than it's ever been going back to that patience right culture has changed people are less patient people um run around buses they they drive over streets they disregard a principal's request to not do that so the C culture has shifted invite you to come out with me sometime you and spend a warning and you'd be amazed but all of our schools at one point in you know 15 20 years ago had twice as many students as they do now thank you so at this time is it safe to say that we're set looking for a different

035phase for this option so we can move on to the next option what I'm gathering from the board is that this would be a phase two discussion consideration looking at potentially years 26 27 for any any changes here yes you are okay I'm gonna move us to option two so option two is looking at May Island Health and Fitness and I know there's a lot of words on this screen but essentially we're looking at Mar Island a closure of mar Island Health and and fitness coupled with a relocation of AO charter school and you can see the fa the factors the fiscal benefit we talked about the bond money not being used at the villo charter school giving us the option to sell that property generate Revenue the valo charter school is as a charter

036school a choice school that is not tied specifically to a residential neighborhood so it can be placed at any location within our boundaries and then we did we did examine the current Mar Island Health and Fitness population it is also a choice school as a magnet school we know that it serves some students that reside on the island but also students who come into the island and as part of the equity impact analysis the board can move forward with a school closure and a relocation of a Leo Charter so I would to open it up to discussion and questions this option um I do like this option I want to go forward with this option personally um closing Mary Island Fitness and moving valo charter school students to that location but I wanted you to

037understand that the students that are at marilan Fitness there's capacity for both to remain so marily and fitness students now Leo Charter students there's you look at the capacity there too both can fit in that space especially because eighth graders are moving on and also some of the questions that I've asked so you would have priority for the vayer charter students you would have priority for the mar Island Fitness students to stay on that campus and you would also look forward having priority to Residents in the boundaries of um homeowners on MAR Island so those would be the three um preferences for that school going forward also I asked questions about a charter school can you change parts of the maybe some of the parts of the charter has gone really well maybe some needs

038to be refined just in in time everything evolves so involving the charter perhaps maybe things that haven't worked maybe looking into other aspects since both of them are a magnet school perhaps combining some of the magnets of both schools and also maybe combining um maybe arts or something else that it would be still that magnet school but with even more to draw to um and I think knowing the parents some of the parents at Maryland Fitness and at valo Charter I think getting those two groups together they're very from what I can tell very like-minded and I think they would be I think it'd be very well mesh myself um anyways I just see a lot of positives there so that's my own personal opinion um this is a really good option but the only

039thing that I am really concerned about is the displacement I I want the the dis I want that if that happens I want to make sure that the people that are being displaced at that particular time have the number one option to stay that's very important in building relationships when you're doing something like this um and the people that are coming in to that space understand that um it's a team now and that they're going to have to be receptive to some of the things that are are already in place or going to be the other thing that uh trusty Fox was uh stated that I'm really for is that we need to gather together since this is a good opportunity to gather together um the different programs that that are working and have them

040maybe placed in that one particular scope that's a that's a key advertisement right there you have performing what is it we have a art yeah and then we have the fitness and then we have um the other so that would be a key um advertisement um to bring people over back into that school or staying into that school so the displacement is is is my major concern and the quality and the number one priority as far as um options of those people that are being displaced and even the people that are coming in they might not want to opt in but give them the opportunity to choose where they want to go except you know instead of just placing them in their boundary areas FL want to make sure I don't want to well I

041I just had a question so far is for for clarity you know being that it is a charter school that they're they have their own budget they have their own LC cap can we mesh and can we influence how their programs within the that they currently have or is it that the way their school is and their and their programs it's basically just superseding anything that that Mar Island currently has and that can maybe get added in is or or how does that work just thank you chusty Flores yes that is a possibility and the timing is actually quite perfect because they are coming up for Renewal um their current Charter expires June 30th 2025 and so we're anticipating the submission of a new a renewal petition which could certainly incorporate a lot of the

042unique characteristics or programs or what have you from mayor Island into the valo charter renewal petition itself um as a and and then just marry those two concepts so that it's fully described in the educational program description within that that Charter itself and then that is essentially what they would be implementing if their Charter is renewed for a subsequent term so there is certainly that opportunity to do that so it's less of a consolidation and more of maintaining the charter school moving it over to the site but then carrying over some really great programmatic aspects of the existing Mar Island program right now in and incorporating that into the charter itself and perhaps more right and I think that's why even having some some collaborative efforts and communication between the two um would be nice

043to kind of see what that might look like um if that is ultimately the will of the board to move that forward um question the way I understood what your explanation is this the the charter will bring its programs into Mir Island in Tac can we tap into those programs and offer other programs or does that has to be a written proposal to tap into their proposal as a charter school right and I know that that can be a bit confusing because it's all how we're how how we're how we're trying to Envision this plane out so the way it would look is that the mayor Island Health and Fitness Academy school program would close the Cs would move on to the campus of mar Island and it would be providing an educational program that

044aligns with what is included in their Charter but remember they're up for Renewal and so there could be some revamping reworking of the language of the programmatic offerings various other components of you know of the charter school because that would be for the start of uh it would be June July 1st 2025 moving forward right so in the interim if there are certain compon components of mar Island that are very favorable well-loved you know within that school that could be integrated into the charter itself if everyone's in agreement such that they could Implement that as well as part of the charter program so the mayor Island School would no longer be operating as May Island Health and Fitness Academy but again those key programmatic components could be built into the valo Charter program should the

045children that are currently attending Mar Island decide to enroll in the charter school and remain on that same site that Mar Island was located on okay my next thing is who's going to be responsible for to doing that Amendment Amendment or whatever addon do you um I'm going to pass the mic on oh she has one okay if that's if that's going to if that is a possibility of happening that's maybe two programs that you're going to attach on as an umbrella to that other right I I think the writing of the language will have to be pretty craftfull would like to see happen like to continue as and so we're already kind of collaborating on some language um if there are specific things and we can get into specificities what are those specific things

046that the community wants to retain um because the the charter school uses the El curriculum but they also use the same district adopted curriculum they have expanded learning they have the Arts they have lots of programs that already exist at May Island they're doing PBIS which is at Mar so so we have to get to the specific what is the thing that we're seeking to retain and then add that into the language in the in the petition and what's nice about this is that they function as what we call a dependent charter school yeah instead of an independent so it does allow for greater collaboration involvement in the writing of the educational program by the district there's a Buy in there there's a buyin and an acceptance so I'm assuming that that's going to be

047um part of the agreement because a lot I've seen it happen before that programs are integrated into major programs and they don't exist exist they're integrated into major programs and they don't exist do you understand what I'm saying you have a program that's already substantial and sustainable then you decide to bring in another program and this is already Foundation you find that in doing that if you don't have a accountability and you don't have Buy in these programs fall off we still have this one standing it will need there will need to be some Artful you know like you said Buy in to get everyone on board um and the the thing to remember too is that you know there could be some staff mergers there could be some staff movement everything won't be 100%

048the same um and you know as they're as they're writing the draft we can be thinking about the language of what goes into that petition because whatever the petition is that it's approved that's the program um and so if there are key components of programs that are happening at Mar Island that are really high quality that should be maintained we just have to make sure the language gets into the petition because the petition defines the program but the charter Council must also be in agreement with that so it's definitely not a you know slam dunk you know it's not just Heathers say right it has to be um worked on together and there's a district oversight component of course I mean obviously the the oversight looks a little bit different for our independent Charter Schools

049as it does for a dependent just because you manage the budget and the Staffing and all the other details but that could certainly be something that we ensure that they're implementing those programs with Fidelity that they're not dropping off if that is obviously a priority in addition to ensuring that they're implementing the petition as it's been written so I understand that there's going to be some major collaboration since this is part of phase one will it be enough time to do that to to get an understanding on what's necessary what we're looking for well first I'll say there's never enough time right um but the the draft is in process now um the current principal at VCS is you know supporting the draft writing they expect to get a draft to us next week um

050which I'll send to Leslie to help me start reviewing and unpacking the details and making sure that it's sufficient um and we can start having conversations about what are the programs that we need to make sure identified or that are at least referred to in such a way that um that what is great about Mar Island isn't lost in the process but you know Community is community and and some of it some of it is undefinable what makes something great right it's the people that make it great so you know it's kind of hard to say that it'll be exactly the same because it'll thank you change is good I think also like um attorney Leslie Locker said Leo Charter has to have this done by June so this process is is already in the

051timeline that we're looking at so the revisions and then merging the programs together on what's best of both programs and if we add in More arts or something like that then I think it's just it's a win-win for both and it's still a magnet school for what both parents were looking at at this site when parents were looking at the other site they're still going to get plus plus more so it's actually a win-win because they're going to get more program and more benefit than what they had at their other site so I see it for the students a lot more opportunity and for the parents so so in bringing these these together are you thinking about how that's going to impact the teaching the teachers so there's closure and consolidation letter uh language in

052the vaa contract um that the district has to adhere to with regards to um Staffing and identifying the needs of the site what we try to do because we have gone through this before is we try to maintain the Integrity of the staffs that are impacted um we know that when we close and consolidate we move teachers typically with kids however because there is a seniority process we'll have to look at um you know those folks who are more senior in the organization who maybe have been working longer and determined where their assignments will be but we usually start off with identifying um the seniority based on those two sites and then we start making adjustments based on that and then it'll kind of fall out as we're placing and identifying who goes where um

053we have to make sure that we're assigning People based on their seniority and not just seniority at that school site but seniority in the district so is the only based on their in seniority I'm got to regroup in my mind what's going on here what I went through okay B they're they're categorize according to seniority yes but they're also um criteria picking language in the contract and since I haven't done this in about five or six years I'm revisiting it right now because the last time we did this was when we if you recall when we closed Franklin and move Franklin to Hogan and then Clos Weedman and move Weedman to Solano so um there there's specific criteria for who gets assigned where and and also we have to look at seniority as a big

054part of that so like for example at Mar Island they have a lot of uh veteran senior teachers there's not a lot of new new teachers so a lot some of those folks who may opt to stay because whenever you're impacted by closure and consolidation you also have an option to to say hey I want to stay I want to move or I want to stay or want to transfer we have to take care of those folks that are impacted by the closure and consolidation first and it's all based on seniority so in that process sometimes the creativity and the um the creativity that that particular staff brought to that program is lost no not necessarily so for example um if you recall maybe it's been a while since we've done this but we will

055bring language to the board that PKS language when we're reducing or making programmatic changes so we bring it's particular called particular kinds of services and so sometimes the criteria will be adjusted based on what is needed for that particular site or program right so that also comes into play that's what I was trying to get to yeah exact I wanted to know if there was going to possibly be an adjustment yes thank you you're welcome everyone go ahead okay go ahead I'm kind of jumping a couple of options right now but it it ties into this so I'm looking at the the language and the action part of option two uh so far as the updated attendance area for for federal terrorist and Lincoln what what happens to that because when I look at Option

056four I I look at that as something that also needs to get pushed back to to a phase two because of the lack of the uh eia uh study so that that's for and option four addresses like I say Federal terrrace and Lincoln so what happens to that for now is it that there's going to be no redefining of boundaries until something occurs there or or are you guys still going to redefine the boundaries and push the students to to those places um that that's my first question and then the second question for valo charter school is there a student plot points as far as where the students come from from Belo Charter do do do we have anything like that I do I have a visual I'll get to it after I answer the

057first question I'll I'll show it around the room okay and then the next And in regards to that would would then Transportation costs come into play if Belo Charter is moved or is it because it's a charter it's just completely separate because okay so let me let me try the first question around the attendance boundaries if we were to go with 2 a and 2 b right which is um closing Mary Island and move valo Charter over as as we think it through um the Charter School boundary is the city of valo it it has no defined boundary except for City Limits we also think that the residents of mar Island those students who live on MAR Island the valo charter school out here on MAR Island through the petition this would be their home

058school so by definition valo Charter would be their home school because they live on the island everybody else that goes currently goes to Mar island is busted in there's about 12 kids I think that live on the island that go to Mar Island everybody else is either busted in or they live throughout the city limits as well because this is a choice school so I'm understanding Dr Young where she says those current students in Mar Island would be incorporated if so if they so choose they get to choose to remain at Mar Island as a valo charter school student that is those students that are currently attending for the students who are not currently attending we would redefine the boundaries because Mar island has a component of their boundary on the other side of the

059water we had we carved up Lincoln and federal terrorist boundary uh some time ago and there's a small segment where the people that live in that small segment between those two schools come to Mar Island and and they're all bust in right the students who who who call Mar Island their homeschool and live on the Eastern uh part of the western part of the Mainland um are all busted in or their parents drive them in so we would just simply move the federal Terrace boundary over to I think would be Tennessee Street and then from Tennessee Street over would become the Lincoln boundary for um as as we continue to grow Lincoln from its current configuration of a K2 to a k6 K5 um with each successive year we increase one grade level so we

060would in fact need to revise the current Lincoln and federal boundaries to absorb a piece of the boundary that's currently aligned to m Island follow so did I capture the busing question too because all the students out here either their boundary is on that part of the island or they get bust in with the charter school out here there would be no reason to um have transportation out here and one and one of the issues one of the benefits to The District in very trying time is transportation so how how does that how are we going to help the kids that are currently being bust in that let's say the kids that are currently being busted in the May Island that want to stay at valo Charter but then we don't offer bus services to

061the Charter School how how are we going to service them well for for those students who who live in that small attendance area I mean we haven't thought we haven't really thought that aspect of the question but I guess we can continue a couple of runs you know for for the next year or so um and so we would bust in that small portion if a student lives um attends this school and lives up by Ward law they're not being bust in anyway mom or dad or grandpa is driving them in so if they choose to stay here and they live in any other area they would still need to find their own way into school yeah I'm I'm not worried about them because like you said they they get busted or excuse me they

062get driven in but when I leave most mornings down the block I'm watching 15 20 plus kids get on a school bus to get brought over here what happens to them if we don't offer busing Services now that it's a charter school that that that's I think that's something that needs to be addressed ASAP I think we have to keep that consideration open for the current Mar Island Health and Fitness students and it's something we would eventually phase out but I think right now for those students that are receiving Transportation we'd want to keep that in play what I don't want to happen is what happened again what that I found out at Lincoln where a kid that was living two blocks away wasn't allowed to get bus services because they weren't part of the

063move over to Highland so they had to walk the Highland because the family didn't have trans Transportation so that that's that's that's a key thing right we're talking about equity and and whatnot make sure these kids are getting it while he's doing that just to keep in changing boundaries and stuff like that re redefining boundaries isn't there a process that we have to go through the process is we do it and we bring it to you for for approval you you make it's it's a formal action by the governing board oh okay yes thank you you're welcome when as you're getting that information just to move the meeting along um it sounds like for this option 2A seems to be what I'm hearing and but with these aspects connected to 2A that the valo charter

064school students will go move to the new site first priority that the mayor Island Fitness students that are currently at Maryland Fitness will have the right to remain and that mayor Island residents will also have a priority and the second aspect that I'm hearing is that since the charter is being renewed currently by June that we're going to look at merging key aspects of mariline Fitness to marry with key aspects of Leo Charter and perhaps even add more arts or whatever so those are the what I've heard to be discussed for option A is there anything I'm missing we are going to continue the busing for the one aspect of students that live between LOL and federal Terrace but all other students that do their private are going to continue on their own so it'll

065remain the same Transportation okay now does that cost is that incurred by the district now that's that wouldn't be a part of valo Charter's budget or or is that a possibility to Bright it into the the charter into their into their char okay okay here's here's a so with that can diagram of the scatter diagram of where students at valo Charter live in the community I'll I'll pass it around the table because it's hard to see from here but uh take okay board we're going to move to option three which is LMA Vista to salano Weedman so when the eia was developed we were looking at Lan M Vista and there's an option 3A and an option 3B here option 3 A and B combined is a full School closure and consolidation of LMA Vista

066to salono waman that is an option that still is available to the board if the board chooses to do that that would be a phased one school closure that would take in effect this coming school year we've also discussed a phased process where we move the Middle School component of LMA to Salon wedaman for next school year and then revisit the TK to 5 as part of phase two in in that discussion so I will turn it over to the board to discuss and ask questions with this item um looking at 3A the middle school which is approximately 808 students moving to uh salano weerman that is something um I'm definitely for um as long as they keep getting maybe have access to farm um components or um 3B I have to talk with my

067Ed educator hat on just have to um having a farm next to a school you have agriculture you're teaching students how to farm and garden you're teaching students about um livestock and it's an aspect that many cities do not have in the Bay Area we're fortunate to have that aspect it's kind of like a magnet that parents would maybe choose um to have their child at a school learning about agriculture and livestock so that to me is a huge plus here in valo that we've had um so as an educator I know we even have students come from other school districts my district have send kindergarten students I think it's $5 each they come and they get to tour and see the animals and um tour the farm so um I just feel that that's

068such a vital asset here in v that again many cities in California do not have um to be able to utilize that and maybe increase or use that Agriculture and livestock thing to increase pro programs and standards and curriculum I think is such a great thing to have far as the middle school is so small though moving to solal Weedman I think that would not be that big of a deal but I also see that having that farm there I just can imagine that other places in the bay would be are envious of that they wish that they could have a school sitting right on the same lot as a farm and as agriculture so I just want to bring that up that that's not something common and that I think looking at our resources

069in our city and those that have been here for a while is it's just something I think we have to consider a school sitting on itself with just a playground that's that's great but we're talking about something much bigger than that with LMA Vista so I'm having a hard time with 3B for those reasons um because of the educational benefits of having that farm so that's just where I'm coming I'm fine with 3A but 3B I think I personally would need more time like a phase a different phase like phase two or Beyond just to talk about or looking at other models of the few Farms that are within California and school districts and how they are utilizing and how what their growth is and how is that helping with standards and with with the

070students and are parents drawn that they want their children in that environment so I guess I need more information for 3B before going forward with that that's my own personal feeling um I'm noticing in the action the relocation of special education programs to Mar Island fall of 2025 what's that look like because you already have a program that you relocated there already uh and it's that would be that would be that be changed oh did I catch a Bo okay so you're saying that's not okay thank you I didn't think I was crazy that sounds weird with option three this is something we can consider for phase one yes option 3A 3B partial consolidation full closure and consolidation can be considered as part of phase one all those options are available to the board for

071for LMA Vista Forest I I agree with you in the sense of the the uniqueness of of having the farm but I also just wonder if it's something that's with with the closure of the school complete you know would we not still have access to the farm even the kids that are going to be moved over or or Consolidated over to Sal Weedman would they still have access to the farm would they still be able to do all the same activities they currently do but just from a different building would there be would there be any impact on what they can or can't do with consolidation so just moving the middle school students from that one building on on the on the site down to salana Weedman of course everybody has access to the farm

072including salana Weedman I think we were talking about should a future phase close close the elementary school you know um but we would need to if we ever close that school we would need to determine the future of the farm as well at that time whether we keep it open or not but simply by moving the middle school down CH does not change anyone 's access to the farm it's still fully operating and Solano has access L has access everybody has access so I think the question is if if we were to choose 3B where you're closing the whole school how would that impact the students because you're saying now that if you're doing that where you're closing the elementary school as well now we have to figure out what to do with the farm

073is that correct not no not necess so maybe the super someone else wants to save me here but but if we were to close the elementary portion it doesn't necessarily mean that the farm must close the farm is an independent entity operated by friends of LMA Vista Farm okay so right which is a nonprofit now we support the farm as well significantly but the primary datoday operations is is managed by the friends of LMA Vista Farm super supervised by the principle of LMA Vista Elementary and and I think that's where my question is if the if the closure went to the full site Elementary and Middle School how would that impact those students access to the farm would anything change Pro program wise um Access wise anything I I don't think um I don't think

074if we repurpose it for like um we talk about expanded learning or something we'll still have a presence so the kids the kids that move down to salana will still have access to the farm Sal weed as I hear even Mount Diablo classroom has access to the farm um so the farm is accessible to all of our schools right and some of it's a field trip right if students at Patterson want to visit the farm they can but that's a trek and we know that and and the reason I was asking the question that way is just to kind of confirm that if the school was no longer there it doesn't necessarily mean that those students or or that all the programs that we do at the farm you know with the farm would be

075impacted that the students would lose something no the farm would still function it's just the sort of regular dayto day not that wouldn't get the same sort of use but it would be available to our schools and salana Weedman being the closest District school could still access the farm yes I think it's about 13 minute walk but I think what I heard you say is the utilization I know also how bus busy all teachers are and if you're at another site then you have to plan and figure out when you're already bombarded with standards and getting juggling Act of try to getting your day-to-day schedule done and you're not being able to something that was R on your campus probably is not going to happen because you're going to prioritize what you you're must do

076and you can do I'm telling you for me I would have to it would be too much it would be very seldom but when you're on the same campus and it's part of your standards agriculture how to grow crops livestock if it's part of the theme and the culture of your school and part of your curriculum then it's right in your own backyard you don't have to go anywhere and you don't have to take time out of your SK well it's it's in your schedule because it's in your own lot so I I do fear greatly the utilization as you said will decline greatly and then we'll be looking at well why are we funding something that we can't afford for friends of Vista so I see this also for the city of valo something

077again is a resource to the city and I would like data to know how many cities in California have a school with the farm on it very few so with that data and again it I don't think will be utilized will it even I mean within a few years will it even be there so well I I would just to play The Devil's Advocate I I would say I don't see why it still wouldn't be planned into a teachers's program why why anything would change in that capacity because you have to go an extra quarter mile if that um and being that we're part of closure is about bolst stream programs we might have more funding to concentrate for specific things like the lovista farm in regards to teaching it might even be able to

078bolster it to more sites so that more sites could get there more often so I I I don't think that I think that's almost like a knock on the teachers ability to adjust and and adapt here in valo we we we be able to do it our teachers will be able to well if we're not utilizing it to the max now and I'm telling you looking you straight in the eyes as a teacher we don't have enough time in each day so in each day if now you take something that I'm over here and you're taking that I'm going to take more time for me to go do this you just put more in my schedule just for the transportation aspect of getting to and from that I don't have I cannot get through all

079the curriculum that that I must do juggling act each day and anyone that's been a teacher in this room knows exactly what I'm talking about so if you haven't been a teacher and you haven't lesson planned for every curriculum area that you must do each week and now you're telling me I must figure out Transportation you just caused me a whole new Dynamic that I don't have time for because I also have to do mated PE each day I have to do mandated ELD each day so the mandates are priority then my key standards are priority so if you take away the farm aspect of my culture of being on that site it's not my culture anymore my culture is that site whatever the culture is that's a fun thing that farm over there that's

080whatever how far that's a maybe that's not a priority it's a maybe I hope you're understanding me really clear from an Educator's aspect of time limitation and it doesn't mean I'm a bad teacher it means I can't I have to do my musos not my candos or may just real quick I don't think this is a matter of good or bad you know and no I'm not an educator no I have nor have I been a teacher so I don't understand th those Concepts but what I don't want to say is now all of a sudden teachers just won't won't or can't I mean it we could find a way and if there's support needed I think part of what this is all about with the closures and bolstering is for that to to free

081up the ability to to to help within the district to help teachers to to help programs that's one of the key things of school consolidation school closures it's not just you know saving money so um yeah so for me it's not about good or bad or or whatnot it's just about not limiting based on your experience as as a teacher in your District well I also want to say that with declining enrollment and when we look at that map of our students going down um through the years the limited resources that we will have to deal with with more school closures and more programs I don't see how putting money for a farm is going to be when you're talking about people's jobs so anyways it's a nice concept what you're saying but we're doing

082that I don't see the reality but we're doing that now right so far as putting money towards a farm but you have a site there that's being utilized daily the farm or the School site because I'm talking about the usage of the farm for salono weerman students so far can you get us information how often Salon weerman goes to the farm and what grade levels well I I think that's that's kind of any of our schools actually I I think that would be partial data because what's currently happening isn't going to necessarily be what would happen moving forward with a consolidation and Improvement of programs or what but absolutely let's find out how often Sal weed goes yeah but I I think it wouldn't be the most accurate data to base a decision and it's

083a resource to valo which I think we need to look at what does valo have resources I just wanted to add kind of one additional thought on this on this idea and that is I think one of the alternative uses of the LMA site has been to do an Extended Learning Program which could include after school programs that could be tied to the farm right so there actually is the potential I think to bring in additional students from other sites within the school to kind of give them a uh a structured way to access the farm and farm programs that may not be in existence right now um so just kind of one one other thought outside of you know um structured use of the farm as a part of everyday schooling I still think

084you do have that Extended Learning option to kind of bring in you know Farm use and again that would be at at those facilities that are right next to the farm right now uh President Fox I appreciate your perspective um it's it's given me a new look on it um and I'm kind of leaning towards your perspective with having a school there on the site is it possible to have the extended um the the expanded learning there with the the the K through five yeah because I recognize your fear your fear is is that it's I mean it's it is it's a magnet it's something that's unique it's something that could attract um parents and students to the school district and your fear is is that if we remove all the students from that site

085that it it'll get used even less and then we'll have to try to justify why we're supporting it yeah I get it um I support that LMA Vista stays as an elementary school um and as far as the farm is concerned that's my farm I used to take my kids there to that farm that has I have memories there and that is n that was 1972 when I came into the district I think I started taking my kids to the farm um in maybe 74 whenever it started that was an annual trip and I was took them each time now we had a we had a procedure at that particular time that every seven years teachers changed okay every seven years teachers changed if they had been at a school site for seven years they

086changed sites I got the experience during that time to be in all geographical locations in this District I started at uh Penny cook I ended up at w law and in between was Dan Minnie and Elsa Weedman each school that I went to I made sure that my kids went to the farm that's an experience you know they they find out that chickens do lay uh eggs they found that that that the the Llama needs orthodontic work you know it's it's it's an experience an exposure it was even an exposure to me to see how the milk a cow okay so that is an experience that that is it's it's no words for you just have to it's a unique program I would hate to see it Go dropped well no I went there with

087your kids I guess in 1972 I would walk there almost every day on my way home from school go past the farm and just hang out for a few minutes I think the farm is a very important aspect of and unique to valo Val city unide um I believe there there has to be grants available to help upkeep and maintain that farm um and where we can actually Bridge our other schools in in in terms of an expanded expanded program um so that we can utilize it a little bit better now we do have to be fiscally um responsible of what needs to get done and we do need to still focus on I mean as much LMA Vista I mean as we as we heard there's such an emotional attachment um to LMA Vista

088and how much it means to to all um to the valoin in general um but you know I think we really need to focus and you know figure out what needs to what what with the job in hand question and just real quick also I mean I think in in the process of this conversation I think our emotions of the love of our schools and and the community kind of obviously is into play so this isn't a conversation about closing L Vista farm this is a conversation about the school sites per se so I think to go to to talk about all the benefits of the farm and what can happen what can't happen I think aren't part of this conversation you know so with that being said I I noticed that closing of the

089LMA Vista Middle School program only there is no dollar amount attached to what the fiscal benefits would be do we have a number for that because I see that you know it shows what it would what what the cost seems would be for the whole school but what is it just for the middle school and is is this just a delaying of what would end up being an inevitable closure of the site itself are we just delaying the closure because in phase two are we going to come back and say well we need to close the elementary school as well is that something that could be answered now just a quick question on the inevit nothing is inevitable we have the ability to to turn this community around in many ways you know not just

090us but the city of valo so hopefully there are no further closures if we close this year maybe there will be but it doesn't necessarily have to be that's my opinion as far as savings on the middle school campus the only change we're rece we're realizing most of the savings as a result of support personnel there are three classrooms in the Middle School on the middle school campus one 6 17th 1 18th those three teachers would relocate probably just relocate to stepan Manor I mean to salana Weedman excuse me I don't go across and and um but other than that and then on that side any expenses regarding utilities security things like that would probably we would be working with the expanded learning program to assume some of those operational costs because their budget is

091substantial they're they're very well funded through the state of California so they can pick up if they sort of have a dedicated facility which we think it will be for the most part they can assume some of those costs like say the pg& bill on that side of Campus as an example the water on that side of Campus as an example alarm systems Etc so there can be a contribution from that program to sort of offset our general fund expenses but it's really hard to capture at at this moment unlike the captured savings for personnel right that's clear someone a question so so the after school program was a separate entity expanded learning programs are part of vcusd excuse me expanded learning I'm sorry I've been trained I was trained to make sure I said

092it right um uh they are they have separate budgets that can be used for no other purpose but expanded learning um and it's very well funded and their funds can improve the site to their needs to meet the needs of that program it can pay for all kinds of programming it can play for all of the um Associated costs with running expanded learning so um and and as you know we have to run 30 days of additional programming outside of the school year for 9-hour days their funding pays for all of that right so when they come before you and share all the exciting activities they're doing they are you know maximizing the use of their funding thank you for sharing that because I know a lot of people do not know that they have

093the ability to pay their own way they have absolutely the ability to pay their own way and so when we utilize space for expanded learning it is not a hit on the general fund in fact we're just not allowed to use that money in any other way and in fact the board authorized us to to work with our Architects and the expanded learning program to make some improvements uh throughout the district one of them is at this particular facility and those improvements are multi-millions of dollars and we're we're waiting on the action of the board before we move forward with those final plans it would make some significant improvements on that part of the LMA Vista campus I want to touch on something that Heather said about the 30 days of additional programming that's part

094of the requirement of expanded learning so if we're pro we're let's say we go down 3A and we do 3B and we make that a northern expanded Learning Hub you have a campus now where you can do 30 days that does not interrupt any other program or facility and it could be a 30-day Farm program you know it can really use those Services just something to consider because we that is a pot of money that does impact a general fund in a positive way so could that scenario also be done if we close the Middle School aspect part just with that part and still get the exact thing you're saying but still have a school K5 Elementary School yeah okay so we can still benefit in both ways and I think something else we need

095to remember is the more magnet schools or the more why parents want to put their k kids and keep their kids in our schools cuz we're competing we are competing every day to keep school students in our schools not charter schools in our schools the more we have magnets the why to come to this school we have lots of schools that don't have anything connected to them they have great programs but if they don't have a magnet the we're going to be looking at other schools for different phases and because declining enrollment that number you showed closing schools and right sizing the district is going to be going on for many years so this is not a done topic it's not even close to being done unfortunately but I personally would like to see magnet

096schools we have cave dual language we have Mar Island Fitness we have valo Charter we have LMA Vista with a farm those are schools that are unique to valo for parents to choose to have their children in like a magnet school we also have schools have specific programs so I think we need to be very careful when we want the enrollment and we want the intendance we need to look over our whole city and see which schools would parents get the most benefit and want and the why why are those ones going to bring students and programs so that's another thing that we have to be very focused on closing a school to me that doesn't have a farm or doal language or Charter or Mar it's easy I don't want to say easier because

097it's still very difficult but it's not a magnet school it's not a why that parents would oh that's unique other cities don't offer this I like the valo has this this and this I want my child in there so I want to make sure we have an overview of selling our district of the why in which schools are magnets and what's unique to valo that is not unique to other cities in California so I want to make sure we keep that as we go forward to be able to keep our population and that those numbers don't go down even faster because we don't offer things that we could have offered or should offer so I think we need to be con cognizant of that can can I just echo on that a little bit as

098well I mean I for me my goal is to every school in the district is a magnet school that every school wants to be attended because some of the things I've heard during this process breaks my heart because to hear some parents say well I don't want to take my kid to that other school that that's heartbreaking to those to those administrators to those teachers to the staff that's working hard at those schools and and you have folks tearing them down you know and not even because of the school but because of the neighborhood and the surrounding which we have zero control over so I I want us I want the district to be a magnet District you know I I don't want one or two schools and everybody else saying oh leave those I

099don't want to be over there I want the district to be a magnet district and I think this process in the hopes of bolstering our programs and raising our scores because really as a parent prior to my role on the board as a Layman parent the way I determine if I want my child to go to a school is what do the score say what what does a safety look like that's the numbers that parents you know we as a board for better for worse have to do the business of education but our parents do the do the raising of of of of of their children right so the numbers that they care about are the test scores the safety that those are the numbers that they care about and I feel like that's that's

100the ultimate goal I think that we as a board are striving for not just magnet programs not magnet schools but a magnet District that it doesn't matter where that newcomer into the city or that new parent that's put enrolling their child in the first one they are going to be jumping for joy because they went they got ass sign to Lincoln because they got to sign to Federal Terrace because they got ass sign the cave that that's I think where where my heart is in all of this because like we all know it's it's this is not an easy process by any means on this let alone for the for the parents that that are facing it you know and and I I want the community to know that that myself as a as a

101parent and a board member I I I am fully understanding of the sacrifice we're asking you to make because it's not anything shy of that that we're asking the parents to do for the greater good of the district it's not that we're trying to close your school or end your program we're trying to save the district so I I I thank you and and I promise you that the sacrifice that you all are making I am being at the utmost diligent and taking everything in consideration in in my decision on on all of these that we all are I don't want to you know I don't want to speak for all but I'm but I'm sure I know the heart of this board and this staff and the superintendent you know so I know that

102the sacrifices that are being asked of you parents and I thank you for it and and know that we're we're not taking it this lightly so you know I I just look forward to the magnet District that's what I want I would like to look forward to that too but I think in our reality of looking at today January 22nd 2025 what resources and what we're dealing with today and this year and next year and the following year with deficit spending and with the clining enrollment unfortunately our realities dictate other things and when you look at test scores that are flat and we're hoping to move um through this and other processes if you already have something in place with Magnus schools the parents and Community are happy with and that are working I think

103you have to be aware of that not the carrot in the sky that could happen in five or 10 years you have to deal with what resources that are working today and then bring them up as fast as possible all the others I would love for this District to be a magnet District but that is not the reality today hopefully it will be someday so looking at the reality of today what do our certain schools how do they draw so we can sell attendance so we can sell our schools the parents in community that moved to valo would want up their students in our schools today in the near future yes we have our goals yes we have our strategic plan yes we want our goals our scores to go way up but right now

104dealing with that I think we need to look at our reality that confines us going forward right now and protect the resources we have going forward especially things that draw parents not things that will make the community upset more than we're going to already we have to value our resources and be careful of what resources that have been established for many years by many aspects of AO so that's why I'm very nervous about this LMA Vista thing and honestly I feel the farm would probably not last if we closed the school not for very long and we won't have the money to support it in reality because of our numbers and the reality is shown on these slides so anyways I'll just say that the magntic schools we have today the programs that are successful

105were once carrots in the sky so we have to look at that we have to have a vision we have to have a goal we have to think about making it better as we're improving it so that's the purpose of the Strategic plan that's the perf the the purpose of the four pillars because there's our plan to get to that point but to say that because things aren't where there's where we want it to be today doesn't mean that we're not pushing for it or or we can do two things at the same time we can deal with the reality of what's going on right now declining enrollment declining uh money and we can also strive for a magnet District that that's kind of the balance I think that we're doing right now you know

106so I mean that yeah I'm going to always keep that carried in the sky because that's where that's where you got to start right you got to start with with that dream so where are we now let's keeping moving where are we now okay so we're going to move past LMA and the last option we have here is really an option that would would look forward to a phase two um and that is the the board directed staff in once they received the the 7-Eleven report to look at additional schools and these two were added to the list to investigate if we could move forward with closure consolidation so Federal terorist in Lincoln and you can see the data there about what possible fiscal benefit repurposing the site the key indicator here is that it

107is since it was not part of the eia we wouldn't be doing anything with these two sites as part of phase one it would have to wait to be part of either a second phase or a third phase in the future so really the only direction we're looking for is is this something we'd want to bring back is a phase two discussion I know for the public with Lincoln people were asking you only have have 70 some students why aren't you looking at closing that was brought up last night the town hall meeting and as I said earlier with the E the um Equity we haven't had enough time to get that report done and also at the State of California we were told probably will not let us because of demographics in certain areas

108downtown valo which is makes me kind of sad that the state thinks they know more than our current jurisdiction but anyways we know our city better um one thing for this that some of the thought was that if you close Federal Terrace and you take the TK students and move them to Lincoln you've just put increased that 70 some students and put more into the school whereas Federal Terrace I think only has about one teacher per grade level um so that model was looked at since we were told that probably from our attorney that because of the demographics we probably cannot close Lincoln so therefore for the board how can we utilize that and put more students and take resources that we need to cut from local close proximity schools to be able to get

109to um the next closest school proximity uh so that was one thought and one Theory um what other things were I know one thing that we've brought up with the city a lot that I have is the different and was brought up last night is the safety outside Lincoln which is out of our hands we do the best we can we have Lincoln School fenced off the best we can we have it secured as best we can but there's still undesirable activity on snowa Avenue daily that we is out of our control so we're trying to partner with the city of Alo to try to help with that but again that's out of our control we're doing the best we can um so with these this would definitely be a phase two um along with

110other sites too well you know I I it's a shame that the the state or the law or whatever it is is is is is sitting up high and we're down here in in in the low lands looking at what's actually happening at Lincoln okay the trafficking back and forth of school you know and then they say that because of that particular location we cannot shed it down at this particular time is that what I'm hearing yeah so we have initial concerns that that um once this would be further studied through the EAS right so that's that's you know kind of one of the initial issues is really more um of a procedural one now right is that we we haven't had a chance to really study the closure of federal tariffs or Lincoln from

111an equity perspective um but when we look at some of the initial enrollment numbers and the demographics of the students at that site there is some concern that if uh that if or when we moved forward with doing a further study uh through the eia that there there would be concern about a disperate impact on a large number of students at the school that fit a certain uh like racial backr ground um so so it's not a foreclosed option at this point it's just that it kind of raises a flag for us to want to really analyze that and make sure that we wouldn't be putting the district at risk from an equity perspective if we did make that if the board did decide to go that that that route so at this particular time

112Lincoln has how many students 74 how many students does Lincoln uh does um Federal terce have 200 huh 600 22 so you're going to think about moving or [Music] closing Federal terrs with 200 and moving those kids to Lincoln is that a possibility no was another phase not this phase not this phase okay all right it says close Lincoln and federal tariffs that's the 4C then close Federal tariff that's for being closing so those are separate entities Al together separate things to think about yeah they're being proposed as kind of three separate options right so you could close just Lincoln you could close just federal terce or you could close both the issue though is that because um none of these options are contemplated in the existing version of the eia it's not something you

113can take action on um for implementation in this next year so it's we we you know wanted to bring this information to you because there was discussion about these sites being closed but it would but but it would have to be a phase two essentially because we would need to study the impacts of of these closures in the eia okay anyone else I think if if we're moving it to to a phase two I I'd like to see what programs are going to be in place once these sites were to close if we go with either with any of them because if I'm not mistaken all of these fall under Bond Bond restrictions so we can't do anything with the sites other than repurpose them so I'd like to see what are we going to

114put in there so there was like a seamless transition and and we could let and the community would have something to look forward to based on on what we find so um I think that's what I want to you know look at some more yeah where do we put the the the rest of the kids out of Lincoln where are they where where were they placed Highland and are they doing doing okay there yes so there's another question that comes to my head we're going to displace them and put them back at Lincoln or where are we getting these kids to do Lincoln the current second graders would rise to become third graders and we would if we grow back Lincoln we would do it year over year a growing pain thing it would be

115if if that was the option elected we would just grow it back year overy year um is that if that's the question that is a question you answered it's a growing pain they grow okay um so we wouldn't bother the kids that are now settled in no no okay that's all was my main concern so we don't need to decide on phase two then it's options it's there for us but not I personally would yes I don't know about others so just to summarize the this whole night one A's on the table 2 a 2 B 3 a 3B is all in consideration for phase one correct so I think phase one we said no option right so in my in my notes the Stefan and Penny cook we would Reserve that conversation ation to

116a phase two approach so we would not be bringing a resolution to the board to vote on regarding any closure or consolidation for Stefan and Penny cook so in regards to Mar Island we will be bringing forward a resolution for closure and a resolution that of the relocation of valo charter school right and the enrollment options and things like that and transportation and trans yeah with the the remaining the trans keeping the transportation in place for those students who are attending Mar Island Health and Fitness and that that whole structure would be included in a single resolution a single resolution so three is where I'm hearing mixed a little bit on three and what we can do is bring forward two resolutions that the board can essentially hash out or vote on we could bring

117a resolution that would be a full full closure of LMA or a resolution that is just the sort of phased approach where we're only moving the middle school but could it also be something to put something in PH two yeah and you can always yeah I could I phase two can get developed later as well because we we we might find in addition to Federal and Lincoln penny and Stephen cook LMA Elementary that there might be other programs or schools that we want to look at as a phase two because I think some of us wanted more information on the elementary school at LMA could that possibly be moved to phase two so I think you have two options from from like a procedure standpoint I think the first option that the superintendent is referencing

118is we could bring two two options to you in phase one right so you would have the two LMA resolutions in front of you and if the board decided we just want to move the middle school program you would approve one of those resolutions if the board decided we we want to move the entirety of the of we would move all of Loma to Salo wedaman you would approve the other one so ESS just reject but I'm saying because we there's been discussion of more information needed that's what I'm asking to just put that one on phase two now if there's enough people that want more information on that one I think we would need to hear I guess my take on it is we would need to hear from the board that you don't

119want to be presented with that second option as a phase one option because that that's what I'm hearing right so what we're offering is but when the information get to us on the second option because if I don't have that information by then how can I make a vote so I already know that I want to close the middle part not want but the the middle part of LMA that's already fine for resolution but since there's so much information that I feel from the community and for myself that I need for the elementary school how will I get that information by February 5th I would say you might not and then you would decide to reject the the optional resolution that is put in front of you you would just decide to approve who we

120decide tonight so that it's less to deal with at that time the board can the board can decide that and because the superintendent said we must have multiple phases anyways which we also described to the public last night that phase one could only doesn't need to be so many and we could have more when we get more information for phase two I just think being diligent and doing our fiduciary responsibility and Gathering all information possible instead of to me that's rushing I want to make sure this is done very strategic so I guess I would say um I mean we don't want to take action at this meeting because it's not agendized but just getting some general direction from the board as as a body about how they would like to be presented with those

121options at the next meeting I personally would like to go forward with a and then table B for the second phase until we get more information but that's just me personally okay can we can we hear from some other members I'd like a little bit of more information on some of uh on what we asked yeah okay so would so you would not like to be presented with the second option um yes at the board meeting okay um four 4 a and then um or three I'm sorry 3 a and then uh uh 3B for phase two yeah yeah so just to confirm what I'm asking I want to make sure everybody understands we're asking that we can bring two options to the board right so I'm putting aside the mayor Island option right that

122we already know we're going to bring a resolution for board consideration now do we want a 3A option and a 3B option at this meeting or do you only want to see one option my understanding is I just I just okay understood can we hear from the other members yes that would be great but we're not agendized right so even if there's a of three we're not voting we're not voting okay I just want to make sure because you knowre regardless of how many in favor yes um that was all I just need it I just want a Clarity on that okay are you interested I think I I would go along with a fellow board members in this case and just we just keep it with 3A only 3A yeah okay I agree okay

123so just to recap yeah please recap this was not a vote for any action we're just getting direction on if the board wants to see one resolution or two resolutions related to LMA what I what I'm sensing is only one resolution that would be option 3A and that's what we will agendize right okay okay great and for for option four there would be no agenda item that is a phase two process I'm sorry real quick when when it comes to threea can we have a dollar amount of some kind on there because if if it's based on Savings of utilities maintenance Etc I'm sure there's past months payments on whatnot so we got to get a rough idea knowing that it's not going to be the exact but at least a rough estimate based on

124like 6 months average on payments on those areas where we're saying that we're going to get the savings I think part of the reason and I'm not saying we we can't we can't provide that I think part of the reason that it wasn't included is it's it's honestly like a very it's an almost insignificant number right so this this decision uh 1A is not really a cost saving sorry 3A 3A is not really it's programmatic right it's not you're you're not going to see the you know like Million numbers that you're seeing for the closure of the other sites because it's just the it's just relocating three you know three classes but isn't that about $300,000 or more in just those three salaries with benefits to move take off the docket of LMA Vista to

125move transfer to a different site I'm gonna I I can respond to that so moving those students not students the teachers well well the this if we're talking about LMA Vista the Middle School the students would move and so those teachers will be reassigned to a different site because they have a multiple subject credential but you're not on the payroll for LMA Vista you're now on the payroll for Solano Weedman or wherever we're filling a vacancy okay because those because LMA Visa there's there it's a programmatic difference so when the superintendent at programmatic those students are going to move to those 6th through eth grade students at classes at salano Weedman and if you remember it still runs as a middle that part of the program is still middle so meaning those teachers have single

126subject credentials so they'll have teachers for two subjects as opposed to one teacher all day in a in a multiple subject teacher classroom so it is different got it but I think also there's a um benefit Mr posio you're talking about so now that that site is going to be open for the Middle School portion you said that we can look into programmatic I what benefits and money that can be accumulated that someone else will have to pay for well not someone else it's still vcusd funding but it's but it's targeted money for the expanded learning program can we get a maybe a dollar for that or see how that's going to benefit us uh well we we can estimate the improvements and we've had conversations about some um uh site improvements but we might

127do more if it's just going to be a full Hub we don't have a quote for all of that possible work yet um for the site improvements and then whatever current costs there are for cleaning and um Heating and and electricity those costs could be accured by expanded learning since that's the program running there okay so we'll find that later but it will benefit for having that yeah those costs would be whatever costs they're currently being acred in the general fund would be part of expanded learning costs awesome all right are we now on agenda item three yes so for the sake of putting my fiduciary hat on in this sense I'd like to see 3B includ included in in the agenda so far as the full closure of the school so now we are

128on three uh announcement of upcoming meetings is there anything else before that are we good is there anything else before agenda item three so the next meeting will be February 5th Wednesday it's going to be at Mar Island Fitness Academy in their gymnasium I think and then the next one will be on the 19th regular Bo so we have some adjustments we need to make to that um based on the eia the equity impact analysis because the last time the board saw that report is outside a full calendar year we need to hold two sessions again with the with the report so now that's pushing off the final final decision to the 19th so we're most likely going to flipflop the locations we will be back here for the 5th and we'll be at Mar

129Island for the 19th it just it bumps the the timeline a little bit because of the equity impact has to be presented at two meetings is it at the is um Auditorium or where on the 19th on the 19th but the fifth will be here all right and is there anything else before we adjourn thank you everyone can just real quick can we ask about just in general things or are we just sticking to this topic is it regarding upcoming meetings agenda three no no this is just a a general question I I don't know go to the order I don't know the question okay well depend the question in regards to um immigration rights information I don't think that's on the agenda so I don't think that would be y okay okay so with

130that we are adjourned at what time is it 711 go figure have a good evening

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.