CorpusRecord 109720

Board of Education Meeting | February 5, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / West Contra Costa USD
Date
2025-02-06
Location
Contra Costa County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
18,778 words · about 105 min
Collected
2026-06-20

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e whoa good evening and welcome to the February 5th regular uh scheduled meeting of the West contra cost Unified School District School Board the meeting is called to order at 4:42 p.m. to access translation in Zoom please click on the globe icon at the bottom of the screen if you are here in Deon you may pick up a headset for translation in the back corner of the room the board is about to go into Clos session but before we do we're here to listen to public comment on Clos session items individuals wishing to speak on the Clos session items listed if you're here in the auditorium and you haven't already done so please submit a wccusd public comment card which you can find on the entryway table or if you're participating via Zoom

002individuals will need to raise their hand in the Zoom app if you're accessing the meeting by phone press star n the time allotted to each speaker is two minutes there is no substitution of speakers we alternate between Zoom comment and the in-person comment the public comment period is a safe space where diverse view points may be expressed civy without interruption or intimidation please listen attentively to each speaker's comment and respect their time as if it were your own be open to a different point of view if one is offered due to the brown act board members cannot discuss items that are not on the agenda and do not usually respond to items presented in public comment the items listed on the Clos session agenda tonight are uh A1 Conference of Labor negotiators A2 two Public

003Employee discipline dismissal release complaint A3 public employee performance evaluation superintendent is there any public comment on these items yes we have to public comment Miss Browning Evans can you please come to the mic uh good afternoon esteemed board member members my name is bronwin Evans I'm a second grade teacher uh and one of the United teachers of Richmond representatives for Murphy Elementary School so with the guidance of utr leadership today um the utr members at Murphy have conducted a vote of no confidence in our current administrator principal Beth Miner's leadership 90% of our members I'm sorry can I interrupt you for just a second yes you're free to speak if you so desire we do request or would encourage you uh for items such as this involving staff to handle them off the microne but

004you may continue okay thank you I didn't uh 90% of our members voted in favor of the vote of no confidence with 10% abstaining um as detailed in the letter and ballot measure that I will be Distributing to each of you today um so we're bringing this to you all today because we would like on the record documentation of the efforts of both teamsters and utr members to meet with Administration and District leadership as well in order to address our concerns for the safety and well-being of our students our families our community at large um this letter that we have in our hands does not by any means contain an exhaustive list of the harms that this school has experienced under principal miners leadership um and with that we are formally and and respectfully requesting

005that the board and the superintendent number one discontinue Beth Miner's contract for the 2025 through 26 school year and to require Community input particularly in the interview panel process When selecting the next administrator thank you for your time and would you please um repeat what you had said to me before just now president re what was it that you said we don't encourage staff complaints like this at the microphone we prefer to handle them off the microphone and we'd be happy to you know to hear the complaint but you are free to make your comments understood thank you and if I may of the sound board my did you not hear me at all it's really fuzzy I don't know how to say it so maybe the tech team can um understand that that my

006voice was Fuzzy to them is it better now than you is it is it I guess not you can't hear me sort of a bit muffled for some reason thank thank you for that we're trying to work on the sound in here great thank you president Rey our next public comment is Karen vanwinkle good afternoon um superintendent Dr Moses and president reckler and Jama thank you for being here um and our district school board my name is Karen Van weel I've been here for 26 years in the school district and it's my second year at Murphy and Elsa Branny um under the leadership of principal minor a lot of things have gone wrong at Murphy um we have detailed everything in our letter um but for example you are all leaders there sitting and representing

007us one of the comments that we often get is well no one told me that um and so I brought to her attention that usually leaders go out and seek information instead of wait to be told that's an example um and many other examples are outlined including we didn't have um a behavior Matrix about what to do when a child does blank in The Recess yard or in the classroom or anything we didn't have anything agreed on until January and that's unsustainable when you have a TK to sixth grade school um so respectfully the leaders at Murphy School we're all leaders um every teacher we are respectfully asking that principal Minor's contract for the next school year is not renewed by the school district we don't feel that she's a good fit for our community

008or our school district thank you thank you very much is there any more public comment that concludes public comment at this time the board will recess into close session thank you very much to all that made public comment no Distortion okay good okay we are going to get started so good evening to everyone and welcome to the Open session of the February 5th 2025 meeting of the West Contra Casta Unified School District School Board the board is returning from closed session and I am calling Open Session to order at 6:35 p.m. to access translation in Zoom please click on the globe icon at the bottom of the screen if you're here in this Auditorium and you need translation you may pick up a headset in the back corner of the auditorium in a few minutes

009we will begin the public comments agenda item members of the public are invited to speak to the board on any matter that is not otherwise on the agenda but is within the public but is in but is within the subject matter jurisdiction of the West contracosta Unified School District District please prepare now for public comment if you're here in the auditorium and you'd like to make public comment please fill out and submit a wccusd public comment card if you can find them on the table in the entryway if you are participating via Zoom please raise your hand in the Zoom app prior to the beginning of the item on the agenda and if you're participating by phone press star N9 after your comment card has been turned in the cards are placed in the order

010received and we call on speakers one at a time alternating between a public comment here in Deon and one on Zoom public comment generally lasts for one hour the time allotted to each speaker is 2 minutes in the meantime we're moving on to the rest of our opening procedures moving to B2 Pledge of Allegiance please rise if you are willing or able I pledge allegiance to the flag the United States of America and to the public for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all B3 land labor and body acknowledgement we recognize that we are presently on the lands of the chuchen mkma kin aloney peoples and acknowledge them as the first inhabitants of the land we currently occupy labor and body recognition acknowledgement I acknowledge that the burden

011of environmental exploitation and systemic Injustice falls upon labor of black and brown bodies in the building of this country and its institutions I remember that black and brown people were born and died working this land against their will for Generations I acknowledge the continued contribution of the labor of survivors over the centuries to today of all immigrant labor including voluntary involuntary trafficked forced and undocumented peoples in the building of what we refer to as the United States author Dr Michelle Rogers art B4 West contracosta Unified School District board anti-racism statement the West Contra School District Board of Education is committed to the work of anti-racism and the conscious and active effort to identify Challenge and correct racial inequities in the systems and institutions within our schools and Community racism explicit and implicit stands in direct

012conflict to the fundamental principles of wccusd education to carry WCC education into the future we recognize that we must continually renew and reflect on the roots of racism and develop new ideas to meet the times unjust ideas and policies and the racial inequity they produce have shaped us our schools and our society we strive to uncover unconscious biases and practice anti-racism as individuals and as board members we challenge ourselves to persist through the discomfort necessary for growth and learning to deepen our listening and our examination of racism and oppression and to develop a strong understanding of how our personal experiences and feelings fit into a larger picture of continual oppression each member of our school board individually and collectively is responsible for creating and nurturing in the anti-racist learning environment where each student staff member

013and Community partner is a respected and valued member of the wccusd community we are uniquely positioned and it is our responsibility to identify and dismantle raist ideas and inequitable policies in ourselves and across the dist District therefore we commit to is supporting anti-racist policies programs and practices for our children's education and well-being while building strong and inclusive School communities we commit to holding each board member accountable towards these goals and moving the work of anti-racism forward we also commit to holding West contracosta Unified School District staff students and Community to living these standards of anti- rism in our schools board approved March 20th 2024 B5 call Dr Moses will you please take rooll thank you president reckler good evening I'm present clerk andana good evening all present truste Hernandez good evening present trusty Smith folds

014good evening everyone present truste Gonzalez Hoy is absent truste Espinosa good evening presid and student trustey Wilson good evening president that concludes the roll call great thank you so much B6 report ratification of Clos session Dr Moses is there anything to report out of closed session yes there is a report from Clos session in close session the board took action to terminate the employment of certificated employee number 23536 for failure to request a hearing following the receipt of a statement of charges that there exists cause to immediately suspend without pay and to dismiss a permanent certificated employee and direct the superintendent or designate to send out appropriate legal notices the vote was as followed Clark andana yes president reckler yes trusty Smith folds yes trusty Gonzalez Hoy absent and trusty Hernandez absent that concludes the

015report out great thank you so much we're now up to B7 student performance West County Mandarin K8 school and I believe that they are here to help us welcome in the New Year good evening president reckler members of the board and members of the community today we're incredibly excited to be able to present West County Mandarin for our student performance and I would love to invite uh principal Dr Peterson to introduce the student performance good evening turn on your microphone press the little button at the bottom there okay there we go so thank you trustees uh Dr Moses superintendent's cabinet for having us here tonight to perform it's a great honor um our students tonight will be performing a traditional lion dance as well as singing a traditional uh Chinese song called Jiang Wawa which

016means uh one interpretation is auspicious child um these kind of performances are actually very embedded in our school program as an IB School we celebrate diversity in fact our school is diverse by Design and um we are also want to welcome the board members uh and Dr Moses if you're available to come to our Black History Month celebration which is February 25th at 1 p.m. at our school which is another way that we celebrate cultures in our school so um I also want to thank Miss chase our IB coordinator H ler and Mr Wong for also their support as well as the parents that are here tonight to support so without further Ado I look forward to introducing our first song which is Jang Wawa as I mentioned and uh hang laer will uh lead

017the students in this song e e apologies for the brief delay we are trying to get the camera on it looks like we're ready to go we [Music] she [Music] did say Miss did t [Music] you can tell be your [Music] um time e e e okay everyone we are up to B8 public comment members of the public are invited to speak to the board on any matter that is not otherwise on the agenda but is within the subject matter jurisdiction of the West contracosta Unified School District public comment will last approximately one hour the time allotted to each speaker is two minutes and should additional speakers remain at the conclusion of one hour public comment may be extended the time allotted for speaker beyond the first hour is generally 1 minute individuals wishing to

018speak please submit a wccusd com comment card or if participating via Zoom individuals when need to raise their hand in the Zoom app prior to the beginning of the item on the agenda if you're calling in by phone press star n speaking time shall not be transferred from one person to another and there is no substitution of speakers speakers can also make public comment again for each discussion and action item on the agenda after staff presentations the public will have 10 minutes per item and one minute per speaker the same protocols recited above apply the public com period is a safe space where diverse view points may be expressed civil without interruption or intimidation please listen attentively to each speaker's comment and respect their time at the podium as if it were your own be

019open to a different point of view if one is offered due to the brown act board members cannot discuss items that are not on the agenda and do not usually respond to items presented in public comment is there any public comment yes our first public comment is Don gney good evening to everybody at the last meeting of the citizens Bond oversight committee I was elected as the chair for 2025 so I'm back and part of that means that whenever Poss possible I will be getting up before this body and before the public to give a standing report as much as you will allow me to do my one of my problems though is that I've got a little conflict of schedules some of the dates you you've picked I'm supposed to be at a meeting

020in in Martinez and I get paid that's part of my job so I I need the money so but I've already talked with with the president reckler and hopefully with the blessing of the board we can make an ACC commendations so that I can still give those reports at least once a month because the public appreciates hearing what's going on with their bond program and I hope that the the board appreciates it as well uh another issue I appreciate you asking if we could hear you but since you ask that we can't hardly hear you in the back anymore or in the side it's just an issue but also another issue a lot of people watch your meetings on Zoom except about 75% of the time all that they are seeing is the speaker clock

021that's just like we're seeing right now that's it we never see the speaker we never see the presentations maybe we can do something because there's a little button you can push and that clock will be a very small thing up in the corner and we can see your faces we can see the presentations we can see all the little kitties it's just something you might wanted to think about and take a look at it to see if you can make it work because the public I know would appreciate it I know that when I tried go look back and see things that happened on the the videotapes couldn't see them because all I could see was a clock thanks a lot our next public comment is Ki yanagihara please unmute yourself good evening board my

022name is Kumi aniara and I'm a fourth year science teacher at Kennedy High School and even though I'm an early career teacher I am tired of having to come continually to speak to the board to ask you to put students first for the last 3 years we've had students who are taking biology chemistry and physics on Edgenuity with a teacher who lives on the east coast and assigns virtual Labs we are supposedly fully staffed in the science department but we got gutted one FTE 3 years ago and the same has happened across other departments we are also continually low balled when it comes to the number of projected incoming freshmen so we've always had to have teachers across other departments go on one 120 at the beginning of the year to provide these additional sections

023what we need at Kennedy and throughout this District overall is an increase in FTE not only to be able to offer core graduation requirements but also to expand our electives options so that students can take more science courses Beyond just physics and biology several of us at Kennedy have expressed interest in teaching other electives for example I would love to teach environmental justice or public health someday but it's just not feasible at this time because we are all stretched thin to barely cover the core classes and despite sitting on reserve funds there's a vote tonight to cut FTE special education support staff and even more people who are vital to the functionings of our schools be so for real we need better pay to attract teachers to this District smaller class sizes and more support

024services we are already experiencing strains on public education at the federal level and we don't need any of that here please do not approve these Cuts thank you our next public comment is Francis GTI good evening board members uh superintendent and community members my name is Francisco Ortiz president United teachers of Richmond and homegrown teacher I want to take a moment to appreciate the performance by the West County Mandarin um school um Team um it was a little shocking to see that the teachers who helped put on the performance weren't included in that um picture uh so next time that we do have a uh student performance include their teachers as well who worked hard on that but uh today I really want to talk about the uh uh item that's on the agenda today

025for the budget reductions um let's hear about what's happening here tonight the district is asking you to rubber stamp a plan that will go out or that will gut our schools all while sitting on $162 million of reserves they're telling you that cutting teach social workers and special education services fisical responsibility but I ask you how is it responsible to abandon our students this plan assumes that 128. n vacant positions are magically filled when we know the truth that educators are leaving in record numbers because the district's low pay and lack of support for its staff 562 Educators have resigned or retired since 2002 we will hear a lot of numbers tonight but here's the only math that matters more cuts equals more vacancies more vacancies equals more instability for students and more instability equals

026more families leaving West Contra Casta unified the district cannot cut its way to success instead of hoarding reserves use them to keep our schools whole instead of cutting Educators invest in Recruitment and Retention instead of B balancing the budget on the backs of our students demand that we spend today's dollars on today's students cuts to teachers social workers speech language Pathologists instructional coaches and literacy programs will impact lowincome English Learners and students with disabilities the most I urge you and I urge our next public comment is Andrea livinghouse please unmute yourself good evening everyone this is Andrea livinghouse utr member my comment will address the district proposed fiscal solvency plan this plan is rooted in a false narrative that the district is pushing that we are in a financial crisis in a week in which

027we learned that the Department of Education will likely be eliminated at the federal level the future of public education is under attack and this is the absolute last thing we need right now the district believes we should cut teachers special education staff including speech therapists I'm a speech therapist and we've had vacancies for 20 plus years and cutting vital student services in a district that has already with vacancies despite hoarding away $162 million in reserves we will lose students and Educators over this this is a choice the district is making this is not a necessity this is a poor demonstration of leadership who pays lip service claiming to be anti-oppression while choosing to deepen the injustices are students face members of the school board I ask that you do the right thing and oppose the

028district's Financial solvency plan thank you for listening our next public comment is Gabrielle Micheletti president reckler clera and trustees we are here before you today because the students and educators of West contracosta schools urgently need change we can't wait we need to attract and retain Educators and ensure stability in our schools for our students I'm sure that we can all agree that our community deserves the best educators are leaving our district at an alarming rate over 550 in the last 3 years 57 of our members have already put in their resignation for the end of the year and if patterns hold that number will grow to 150 by this summer these tumultuous circumstances put additional strain on the remaining Educators and create chaos in the educational experiences of our students and bring additional training expense

029to the district with estimates of educ turnover for unified districts running around $20,000 per educator in addition to this expense according to the district PCN from January utr is currently affected by 129 vacancies when multiplied by The District's per member estimate of $147,000 this creates savings to you of almost 19 million dollars on the backs of our members I urge you to keep this in mind when you were told later in this meeting that we need to cut programs for our highest need students to keep this District solvent despite massive inaccuracies in the numbers being put before you I hope during today's presentation the numbers and Analysis are actually specific to wccd and not copi and pasted from San raone Valley's report in bargaining we will be bringing you proposals based on our members feedback

030regarding what they need to succeed in their work and stay in this District the answer is clear our members need to be fairly compensated for their work to stay with this District we need more manageable class sizes and supports to keep up with students increasing needs we need opportunities to bring in more Educators particularly in hardto staff areas so we are not spread so thin these proposals we will bring to you in the coming month were created by a team of approximately 50 of our members of different work groups and specializations from all across the district working together throughout this fall the dedicated educators of United teachers of Richmond look forward to coming to a contract that demonstrates how you value the students and educators of the West Contra Casta community and what you are

031willing to invest in the future thank you our next public comment is Amanda Foster please unmute yourself good evening everyone yet again I'm speaking on beh half of the Vista K12 Virtual Academy Community our school went through the wasque accreditation process and we were given a six-year accreditation based on our current model the educational model this school district is actively trying to destroy fiscal crisis fiscal crisis budget issues first other people have mentioned the millions and millions Reserve second Vista can bring in students from neighboring school districts within our County and adjacent counties but for some reason people in this distri District won't allow that we have an education model that some people want and others need other districts have asked forus families have reached out to us you are blocking students and then telling

032us we are under enrolled you seem to really care about money yet you are blocking Ada from coming in I'll say it again you tell us we are under enrolled you are blocking students entering our program from neighboring districts who would bring in more money make it make sense the budget crisis stems from chronic mismanagement but you know what this feels bigger than a money issue this feels ableist this feels like adults are actively working against children with disabilities neurode Divergence and school-based Trauma for personal and political reasons thank you to my students who bring me joy every day I love them so much and they are why I'm speaking tonight they deserve better from this District so do better thank you for your time heed our please good night our next public commment is

033Sam cleer good evening my name is Sam clear and I'm the organizing chair with the United teachers of Richmond and a third grade teacher on release at Siege while I have been at Siege we have never never started a year with a full staff or kept a full staff throughout the year students came to the first day of school without a teacher or had to suffer from a revolving door of adults due to the district's current priorities one parent even compared his child's educational experience to musical chairs unfortunately the vacancy crisis impacts other schools all over the district as well as I visited the sites this year I witnessed the struggle that staff members endure every day I was also devastated seeing students go to school every day without a teacher our district is not

034successfully recruiting and retaining staff members at our schools over 500 teachers have left the district within the past three years and students currently suffer from over 120 teacher vacancies instead of receiving long-term solutions for our vacancy crisis we Face a severe wave of program and Staffing cuts which impact our most vulnerable students we must strengthen the stability of our schools and members of District leadership must change their priorities we must make student centered choices and provide students with the opportunities that they deserve thank you our next public comment is Masa Peterson please unmute yourself good evening uh my name is MSA and I'm a fifth year teacher in W West Contra Costa I strongly urge the board to find a better long-term solution to the budget crisis than to cut funding and positions at the

035school level doing so would create even more work for all the teachers and students and staff um excuse me doing so would create even more work for all teachers and School staff and worsen outcomes for our students additionally cutting special education and speech therapist positions opens our district to liability given that we can barely meet the legal requirements for students with learning disabilities as it is you're lucky there's yet to yet to be a lawsuit over access to special education or speech services the board should elect to use the 162 million million in reserves to meet the needs of students at the end of the day we are all here for our students and Community not revenues or budgets please listen to teachers when we are saying we cannot do more with less we literally

036cannot previous speakers have argued to keep our schools whole and the reality is that our schools are not whole we have 128 vacancies which is honestly ridiculous we're considering cutting more positions which positions how will cutting positions and cutting funding solve the problems that we've been discussing all year vacancies declining student performance these are particularly impacting our black and brown students and our low-income students if you're committed to anti-racist policies and educational Equity as you said at the beginning of this meeting you won't cut the funding when you cut funding our black and brown students suffer the most our students with disabilities suffer the most our English Learners suffer the most and your teachers are suffering we are telling you that we are suffering we deserve better and our students deserve better do not cut

037this funding thank you for your time our next public commment is Marie Ana hello okay sorry hello my name's Marie um and I come speaking to you as a parent and also a current SLP in the district I brought my two kids with me tonight um they both have special needs but they have been greatly benefiting from the special ed Department my son is going off here he both of them they are two wonderful children love them with all my heart they have been growing in Leaps and Bounds in the programs that you have set up here I ask and urge you to please vote no on doing the budget cuts my children speech therapists are wonderful they have really helped me in strategizing and helping them to communicate everybody wants their child to communicate

038to be able to talk to tell them about their day whether it's using sign language picture boards verb verbal words body language it's all a form of communicating I just ask and urge you to please vote no because when I was reading the report it says that five SLP positions will be cut and that is very devastating for me to hear as a current speech therapist thank you sir um I work this is my second year working in the district I love it I'm over in the Cameron team working with the preschoolers and I also have two preschoolers myself so it's like 247 working with them but it's a wonderful wonderful job and this parent stopped me as I was running into my office to say my child is speaking now thank you so much

039and I urge you to vote no on this position thank you our next public common is Sierra Akerman please unmute yourself hello I can you hear me yes we can all right um I am also a speech therapist for the district and I also commenting to talk about my concerns about the loss of positions you I want to Echo everything that everyone else has already said about the fact that the funds are there and that the money is there and that it's going to be devastating for our most vulnerable children you know you spent a Solid 5 minutes at the beginning of this session talking about how much you care about Equity money away from our most vulnerable children also want to tell you a little bit about what it really looks like to be

040understaffed we are badly understaffed we have about 15 therapists under for the entire District I believe five of them in just four and a half of them just in the preschool Department what does that actually look like it looks like kids never having losing sessions because there's no staff and never having those sessions made up unless the parents chase after the district for months it looks like kids not being given the means of communication if they need a tablet to communicate there's no one to do the assessments I had one child I referred in September 2023 who just got his tablet last week it looks like kids who could communicate not being able to it looks like we had three students walk off our C the campus of one of the schools I work at

041last year because the per Staffing was so low now they want to cut even more Paras that's what it looked looks like on the ground to have low Staffing and to have vacancies also I'm curious how we're even going to save money if we have 15 vacancies and you're planning to cut five of those you're not paying those people where's the savings they're already not there because they haven't been fired I want to Second everyone who says we need to hire and retain staff and provide all of the services that our wonderful children need and our wonderful families thank you our next public common is Karina Sano Pon please unmute yourself um good evening board today I'm here to advocate for our school counselors our school counselors are vital to our Student Success providing essential

042support an academic career and social emotional development according to ASA which is the American School scho counselor Association school counselors are Highly Educated professional C certificated individuals who help students suceed in school and plan their careers they assist students in forming healthy goals mindsets and behaviors fostering skills such as effective collaboration perseverance time management self motivation so I urge you tonight to look at school counselors as the professionals that they are they are working under the standards in which they really try to emphasize to deliver a well-rounded School counseling program that encompasses academic career and social emotional development however our counselors at the moment are overworked and not being compensated they are working above the 338 ratio that the district um has for us and for context ASA recommend that counselors work with a maximum

043of 250 students so our counselors are already above that at the moment as you know we're in the middle of a grievance I urge you to take a look at it we're spending money on a lawyer when we could really be compensated our counselors who are overworked and have above the number of students I also want to take a moment to recognize all of our school counselors as this is a week to celebrate all of the work they do and a week where they Advocate and educate our community on all of the work they do since I started as a lead couns that's the number one question I get what does school counselors do they support the whole child thank you the next public common is Abby morgia please unmute yourself hello hello yes we

044can hear you okay thank you hi I'm Abby Mia I am one of the academic counselors at the Anza High School um as Miss Pon mentioned earlier recognizing national uh councel appreciation week I ask our district school counselors that they we do need your support board um this is my fourth year as a a counselor I asked to address the Staffing and the workload for our students there's definitely under staff and burnout um throughout the district um on behalf of our counselors we are working overages um I am currently with a total of 338 uh students while my co-workers currently are at 354 and 355 way over the ASA um model right so school counselors will be underst staffed at a total of five schools for the entirely um of this year of this school

045year um this of course affects our students right when we're burned out um we are understaffed we do not support our students especially with um you know this the needs that our students are in our district require please address these overdress and set policies to protect counselors I ask that the counselor grievance be discussed and voted as soon as possible thank you our next public comment is Vista Virtual Academy parent please unmute yourself hello can you hear me yes okay great thanks sorry um Dr Moses and board members tonight I want to strongly urge you to preserve Vista virtual K4 for the 2025 26 school year eliminating this essential program will force families out of the district and weaken educational equity and undermine the district's ability to compete in an era of school choice instead

046of cutting a coste effective program we should strengthen it as a strategic asset for the district's future across the country virtual schools are thriving Castro Valley Virtual Academy is ranked the number one Public elementary school in California online and in person virtual education offers smaller class sizes flexible pacing and a calmer learning environment that benefits gifted students neurod Divergent Learners and medically vulnerable children and those homeschooling families looking for structure and certified teachers and curriculum these students deserve a stable and supportive learning option cutting K to4 virtual learning would be devastating families choose it because their children thrive in this setting whether due to sensory sensitivities social anxiety bullying or medical needs eliminating it would cause unnecessary disruption forcing students back into an environment that doesn't work for them additionally near nearby districts do not

047offer public virtual Alternatives meaning families who need this option will have no no choice but to leave the district and seek expensive private programs last year Albany School District transfers students to Vista virtual proving that the demand is growing and existing instead of eliminating K to four virtual learning the distri should one maintain the current structure one teacher per grade two learn from successful virtual schools to refine and expand three promote virtual education to attract more families and funding this is a defining our next public commment is Heather please unmute yourself good evening Bo I'm here this evening my name is Heather Harvey McNab and I am the proud par of a second and a sixth grade at the vista Virtual Academy I'm also a wccusd employee but I'm here today in support of the

048Virtual Academy and begging you to reconsider making any more cuts to the teachers who are an integral part of the Vista team or cutting Vista Virtual Academy primary grades all of our students deserve highly qualified and experienced teachers for their grade level and work being taught and we shouldn't be sacrificing quality education for our children by continuing to make Cuts year after year wccusd has the reserve funds and is not giving our students and teachers the opportunities or the funding and resources to grow this extraordinary program more Cuts again force reorganization of teachers and change the entire School structure again leaving our children to pay the price putting their education at risk you should be investing in our children's Futures not robbing them of a quality education from day one the amazing principal and phenomenal

049teachers have gone above and beyond to be nothing but loving supportive honest compassionate with students and families they have built lasting meaningful relationships with our students and families working together as a team providing the best education and opportunities to our children while keeping them excited about learning they provide opportunities not found anywhere else encouraging all students to challenge themselves and maximize learning potential while still having fun doing it my children have almost perfect attendance every year since joining their confidence and self-esteem has grown tremendously their increased knowledge and test scores are proof that they are excelling in every part of their education and constantly exceeding grade level expectations is a constant reminder that this program works I don't have to worry about absences being sick distractions in the classroom or their safety on a campus

050their daily uninterrupted learning gives them more time than they would in a whole day on campus please save our school our next public comment is Jeffrey Bean please unmute yourself good evening this is Jeffrey bean I teach fifth grade at Shannon Elementary I've been teaching in wccusd for the last 10 and a half years and I've been at Shannon for nine and a half years um I'm concerned about the proposals you'll be hearing tonight regarding cuts to to programs and teachers uh the big problem that wccusd has right now is a shortage of Staff we don't have too much I saw firsthand last year the effect that the Staffing shortage had on my own former students when they went for several months without a without a permanent teacher uh it made me sad to see

051them there and struggling and um I know that there are schools in uh other areas of the district like Richmond that are have this them year after year and no solution sight um I can't begin to think about what potential District employees see when they look to apply for jobs in our district and learn that the district is cutting staff that can't have a good effect on Recruitment and when I consider the fact that families are probably leaving our district because of the shortage of Staff the problem will just uh cycle um the thing to do is to use the money you have now to adequately fund schools now provide all schools with adequate staff and then in future Years you'll still have the students who will bring in the money from the state to

052fund future uh future employees please uh reject tonight's proposal thank you very much have a good evening our next public comment is Martin Jimenez please unmute yourself hi this is actually Christina wera I'm using my husband's computer um can you hear me thank you so yes like I said my name is Christina wera and I'm a teacher at Kennedy High School I have been uh teaching at Kennedy High School for 12 years now I'm very proud to be a teacher there and in this District but unfortunately this is not the first time I've had to address the school board about uh cuts that are being proposed to our staff uh we have all chosen to work in education and to work for the communities in this District but approving the cuts tonight is going to

053harm our schools and of course it's going to harm our students how can we say that we want our students to succeed when we are reducing their access to support systems at Kennedy our FTE keep getting cut every single year I teach Spanish and my world language department is now down to two teachers two of us for the entire school we have students who are unable to take a language other than English until they get to junior year which really impacts their access to attend a four-year University After High School I'm sure there are other sites who have similar stories that is very unfortunate so I can't even believe that the board is considering making additional Staffing Cuts especially when this district has $162 million in reserves these Cuts should not even be under consideration

054last year it was decided by thect district and approved by the board that scows were no longer needed at secondary sites cutting such essential staff is being felt at our site deeply so many of our classified staff is now having to wear 20 hats at once just trying to make our School site function we have everybody trying to make sure that the school stays afloat that our students are learning that we provide a safe environment for them but we cannot do our jobs if we're constantly worrying about losing additional staff and we know that the ones who will feel it the most are students vote no on budget cuts the priority of this District needs to be to recruit and retain staff and not make us feel disposable thank you for your time our next

055public comment is Priscilla please unmute yourself thank you can everyone hear me yes we can okay thank you good good evening um my name is Priscilla Lao I'm a speech therapist um in wccusd and I'm here to ask you to please say no to the district's plan we already have over 150 vacancies across the district and cutting more teachers SP special ed staff and speech therapist is going to be disastrous current speech therapist Cas sizes and workload are already setting us up to fail our students and families based on a survey of data K12 Sops and wccusd currently don't have the capacity to complete our work respons abilities within our contracted hours and are instead forced to prioritize over a period of two weeks the data showed an average of 36 missed minutes of Direct

056Services for students due to completing other work responsibilities to stay in compliance with legal timelines for assessments and IEPs other slps prioritize serving students and were therefore consequently unable to complete an average of four assessments and adequately prepare for four IEPs within legal timelines over a twoe period our overwhelmingly large Casal sizes are directly impacting the quality of services that we can provide to students and our capacity to assess students in a timely manner students are being seen in large groups of six to eight in some cases to try to meet their minutes our limited capacity from the unmanageable workload we all face forces us to prioritize and make hard choices students are not getting the services and supports needed to help them be successful at school because of our overwhelmingly large case load sizes

057and unmanageable workloads thank you for listening next public comment is Mooney please unmute yourself good evening I'm Daisy masas a student from Vista Virtual Academy I have been here for four years I'm speaking up for my teachers this teachers are important because they can give us opportunities that most kids don't get like gate math this is my second year given the opportunity we are lucky to get caring teachers but this Tri decides on taking them away and we are getting the same opportunities as we were in personis school doesn't allow us to get the opportunity to be in one grade and take a higher grade class our teachers help us to challenge ourselves we will get held back because of our of the teacher cuts they have taught me to be responsible and to challenge

058myself each day because they believe in us please don't cut our teachers in at Vista think about us we are the future thank you our next public comment is new diamonds please unmute yourself hello can you hear me yes all right I am calling on behalf of virtual Vista Academy um I just wanted to say that I just really wanted people to rethink the CET the budget cuts on this uh Virtual Academy program due to it really is about the kids education um and my son has exceeded beyond my expectations behind the class expectations um due to this program he is more attentive he is more focused and I feel like that should be the main priority for the school dist district is the kids in their education if they're learning if they're growing if

059they're exceeding then that should be the main priority it shouldn't be cutting what is already working for the children um if it isn't broken then why try to make it even worse you know what I mean so I just really wanted to speak up for the for the teachers and for other staff that are great they they actually you know are attentive and they care and they pour into the children there to make sure that they are striving and trying and just really it's about the children and it's about their education it's not about other things and other distractions um also um there isn't any discrimination as well um you could just tell that they really do care about the kids education I feel like that is the main priority so I really think that

060the school district should rethink the cut and from what it sounds like they have the money they have is just about what is the priority what is the main agenda and I feel like the main agenda should be the children in their education so thank you for much for letting me speak our next public comment is Jessica Ross please unmute yourself hi my name is Jessica and I've been a wccusd school counselor for 8 years tonight counselors myself included are grateful to be recognized as offering invaluable contributions in supporting academic social emotional and career development of students I do not want to take away the power of the upcoming resolution through my next statements but I unfortunately need to acknowledge publicly the limitations of the district's support of us and the students we serve in

0612022 wccusd entered into a contract with United teachers of Richmond committing in Legally binding language to provide our District's middle and high school students with a minimum of one counselor per every 338 students while that number is still above the American school counselor association's suggested ratio of 250 to1 it's an improvement on historical wccusd counseling resources unfortunately the board has not upheld its contractual obligations leaving counselors responsible for more than 338 students per school at five different sites they've also denied 100 page grievance the district has with two years of evidence in that grievance of district miscalculations and have used delay tactics to ensure that counselors will be underst staffed through the entire school year we're now scheduled for an arbitration hearing but not out until the furthest they could hold it in May there

062are only two explanations for the superintendent's business office and Human Resources response to this grievance either they're actively choosing to break the contract or they're explicitly miscalculating enrollment likely leaving special education students out from receiving Counseling Services something that they admitted to doing in their calculations last year at this time I encourage you all as a good math teacher would say to check their work their actions have placed the board in the district in a Los losing legal quandry to be clear the district is funding us on its contractual responsibility for a total of 6 FTE we have the staff we just need an approval thank you our next public comment is Mariana cavalin please unmute yourself I uh do you hear me yeah okay hi good evening uh Dr Moses and board members my

063name is Mariana cavalin I'm a speech language pathologist and a parent in West Contra Costa Unified School District to be blunt um these cuts are Reckless and they're going to have serious consequences for our community um our schools are already pretty much stretched to the breaking point we have like we've been saying 128 unfilled positions and now we're hearing that there's somehow a need to cut more I'm asking um tonight that you listen to those of us with the boots on the ground focus on Recruitment and Retention and don't make an already unsustainable situation worse cutting staff is only going to cost the district more in the long run uh short staffing leads to increased legal liabilities like we've seen especially in areas like special education where I am where services are still federally mandated

064parents will file complaints due process cases will increase and the district will be forced to pay costly settlements and legal fees as a result Beyond legal costs overburdening remaining staff is going to lead to higher burnout turnover and it's going to cost more um on recruitment training temporary contractors so in all uh what looks like a cost-saving measure today will create a financial and operational disaster tomorrow so cutting staff is not a solution uh it's a guarantee of higher cost deeper instability and long-term harm so um as we've seen this is not just harmful to students and staff it's just a terrible financial decision so please make your decisions wisely um invest in schools prioritize recruitment and please please we beg you reject these cuts that concludes public comment thank you to everyone who came

065and called in for public comment B9 agenda review and adoption do any board members have any adjustments that they would like to make on the agenda hold on just one second yes sir you want to turn on the teacher I'd like to make a public comment do we have time for one more sky Nelson oh do it now whenever you need me yeah now was great thank you yes please go ahead hang on we'll get the clock going for you thank you my name is Sky Nelson I'm a teacher at elero high school at physics I started teaching right out of right out of college in 2001 in Montgomery High School in Santa Rosa and I taught for four years the year that I left the opening meeting they told us we're cutting the budget

066by 60% over two years so this is not new I feel like I've time warped uh I left I left the profession after that came back last year after 16 years when my daughter entered High School to teach again and I love it I I I Adore my students I adore getting to teach them every day love being in the classroom but it's like I never left I mean the situation is the same we're just fighting battles about about budgets and I know we're all on the same page there's a power structure set up where you're trying the board is trying to manage the budget cuts and the teachers are fighting back why don't we turn around and look at the source of the problem whether it's Prop 13 or other systemic problems with unsecure

067funding turn around and face the the up upward slope and organize to get stable funding in our schools overall rather than bicker about it at the at the local level thank you thank you Mr Nelson okay moving on now to B9 agenda review and adoption do any board members have anything on the agenda that needs to be reviewed or monitor ifed seeing none we will proceed with the agenda as presented B10 approval of minutes November 6th 20th and December 4th and December 18th of 2024 does anybody have any corrections to the minutes seeing none will approve the minutes as presented b11 resolution number 2425 d52 honoring African-American history month 2025 Dr Moses you w to take that Rachelle this is your item yes uh good evening board president and trustees intern superintendent staff and Community

068now therefore be it resolved that the Board of Education and the West contracosta Unified School District acknowledges the month of February as African-American history month and encourages all educational communities excuse me to commemorate this occasion with appropriate instructional activities be it therefore resolved that the West contracosta Unified School District in accordance with its policy and administrative regul shall display the panafrican flag during the month of February and beyond thank you so much are there any questions or comments from the board please go ahead trusty Smith FS are we going to make a motion first and then comments or we going to do the comments first oh go ahead you can make a was supposed be questions but there aren't any so yes please go ahead and make and make a motion I move resolution d52

069honoring African-American history month 2025 is there a second I'll second great so the resolution has been moved and seconded we'll move on to comments does anybody have any comments on this resolution trusty Smith fols please go ahead I want to take a minute and highlight some of the work that the district does um this district has been Paramount in moving the work of anti-racism it's been Paramount in highlighting africanamerican not only history but the African-American student population and it is a job that's never complete but you will find in this District the oasa the office of African-American student achievement you will find that its director was Paramount in getting the flag flown at every site all of our sites for the month of February for the last three years you will find an increase in

070the focus on making sure that we have black student unions or African-American student unions on our campuses you will find that we have had the first black male superintendent permanent superintendent and now we have a uh black interim female superintendent you will see that we have passed an anti-s slur policy in this District we have passed an anti-racism policy in this District there's a lot more that we need to do but we are moving so I want to take a minute and just recognize the movement that happens we have an African-American mayor in El cero first time there are things that are happening City Council of Hercules has three African-American members on it there are things that we are doing at one time this board had a majority African-American board we are moving in a

071Direction that's moving towards um better we are not there yet and we have a lot to do but we are moving towards better so I just want to take a minute to acknowledge that I am complete thank you so much for those comments are there any other comments seeing none we will move on to a vote we'll start down here at this end student trustey Wilson yes student trustee Espinosa Jr yes Tristy Hernandez yes clerk Gana yes yes trusty Smith folds Smith folds yes and I'm a yes motion passes unanimously moving now to B12 in recognition of school counselors thank you yes now therefore be it resolved that the West contracosta Unified School District recog recognizes and appreciates the invaluable contributions of school counselors in supporting the academic social emotional and career development of students

072the district proudly celebrates National School counseling week February 3rd through 7th 2025 thank you so much are there any questions from board members seeing none we'll move to a motion is there a motion to approve this resolution I'll go ahead and move it I'm moving resolution 242556 and Rec in recognition of school counselors is there a second on this motion I second great hernandz seconds are there any comments on this resolution oh I'll make a brief comment which is that I really appreciate um our school counselors and all school counselors and I have been thinking about counselors um and the role that they've had to play in all of the natural disasters that we've had in California and what really spurred me was you know obviously the horrible fires that we've had in Los Angeles

073and I read many um you know very touching um statements from school students and families about what has happened to them and the school Community rallying for them especially their counselors to offer Aid emotional support and help people get back on their feet and so that was what I was really thinking about um when I think of school counselors but I also think about all the doors that they open for students especially for me my family had no idea how to apply for college in any way shape or form and our high school counselor really helped us uh to figure out how to do that because we had no idea and so to Miss Charlotte thank you you set us on the path and set me on the path and I was able to help

074my sister do the same thing so I really appreciate that and with that any other comments go right ahead I want to take a moment to highlight one of the counselors at Hercules Middle School um not to get ahead of the announcement but he passed away and he was probably one of the best individuals that I've met in a long time he was a grandfather to most of the students at Hercules middle school and he was an absolute Joy he did more than his job title required and I think a lot of our counselors do but um again I'll wait for the superintendent to make that formal announcement in your report either next week or the week after but know that counselors um are invaluable members of the school community and he was definitely one

075so again thank you to our counselors but specifically thank you to that that Titan that now has his angel wings I am complete thank you so much and with that we'll go to the vote we'll start down here with the student trusties student trusty Wilson yes student Tristy Espinosa yes Tristy Hernandez yes clir andana yes trusty Smith folds smithf folds yes and reckler is a yes the motion passes unanimously be 13 recognition of our student board Trustees for their participation so tonight we honor student trustee Wilson student trustee espanosa Jr for your work here on the board um you have been a pleasure to have here have really enjoyed listening to you and seeing the work that you've done and your plans for the future and I think you guys are amazing I'll turn it

076over to the superintendent and see if superintendent has anything more to add I just wanted to commend you on a job well done and appreciate your desire to advocate for your fellow students and to participate in this process and I've appreciated getting to know you and I look forward to hearing about the future your future endeavors and I know you hold promise for anything you Endeavor to do in your future so good luck to you and thank you for your service and I'm sure board members would like to make comments would you too like to go first or would you like the board to make comments first and then we do have some plaques and we're going to take a picture we invite all the rest of the boards to make their comments first go

077ahead uh we'll start over here anybody over here have comments for the um I think one of the things that I value and you guys may seem superficial but it's not the way that you come and present yourself and the way that you dress and you walk in you walk in knowing that you are supposed to be in this space and that is not easy to do as a teenager so you have a confidence and it can it shows from the way that you walk into a room so I think that that's something that you should always remember my father said act the way you want to be and you will be the way you act you always come in knowing who you are and I love the suits it always looks like Easter you

078always have your Easter suits on and it's always great and it shows a sense of respect to the position and the positionality but it also shows that you took it very seriously from the way that you guys interact the way you ask questions your level of curiosity and the want to learn was absolutely Stellar I think that's something that if you leave this board with anything leave with a skill and you have the skill of being curious and asking questions to leave better than you came and to have more knowledge than you had when you first got here now everyone who comes into your presence you can teach them how to govern govern because that's what you learned here is a skill of governance it wasn't easy it wasn't supposed to be but you managed

079it and you navigated it with class I am complete congratulations thank you any other comments well I just want to say thank you um I also want to acknowledge you know the possibilities when we're really opening up spaces to our youth voice you know really making sure that you guys are amplifying that you guys have demonstrated what opening these spaces up to like really listening to the input of our youth can make a difference and you know thank you for welcoming me on you know you guys have been here a little bit longer than I have so you know I really um respect that you know respect how you carry yourself respect the way that you guys are interacting and are taking leadership you know within your spaces so I congratulate you guys and I

080do look forward to seeing you know what the future holds and knowing that there's many other youth that can walk behind you guys and you know really give to these spaces just as much as you have so thank you I also want to say thank you guys for your service um for you know welcoming in into this space uh you guys like clarking yanis said you guys have been here a little longer than what me and her have but I want to again congratulate you uh you took up the challenge it was not meant to be easy but you dress to impress so those who will come after you will have to follow in the footsteps thank you again and I can't wait to see what the future holds for you guys well thank you

081for the kind words everyone on this board um I want to start by thanking the board and the cabinet for working with me with so many different topics and ideas it's truly been a privilege to collaborate and bring forward to support students in this community um as we move forward I'm excited to see how far all student Congress can go this year even with a late start I believe that we have the capacity to make real progress and change um work alongside students to bring their proposals to the board has been one of the most rewarding Parts I really hope to see the uh climate activism proposal uh continue to be worked on and hopefully voted on soon seeing ideas and seeing them shape and be created from scratch is so meaningful and so impactful

082in so many ways uh serving on the this board has been an incredible experience it has given me the opportunity to not only bring my own voice and ideas forward but also to uplift the voices of others My Hope Is that more students in our community feel inspired to get involved to speak up to take action and to shape the decisions that impact them firsthand lastly I would like to uh to take a moment to thank my parents Craig and in the audience for their unwavering support throughout my time on this board I wouldn't be here without them and I'm deeply grateful for their encouragement every step of the way thank you well I just wanted to say thank you to all the board trustees and even the assistant superintendant they have helped me and

083Luke in every amazing way that they can along with the trustees making this transition not only more accessible and more feasible for us but as well to for us to gain something even more to leave with more in this process um thank you to president reckler for always being there for us and alongside with President former president Smith folds and new trustees inana and this and new superintendent Moses I thank you all for welcoming us with open arms for being so not only welcoming but so helpful in just every single possible way words cannot truly describe will you not only mean to me but what you have done within my life because if you were have told me like 3 years ago I would be doing this stuff I would have called you crazy I

084would have never expected myself in this kind of position but and I thank God every day for you guys and what you guys have been able to not only do within my life but what you guys continue to do for our district and out in the public as not only elected fishes but as human beings as well I also like to give my sincere thanks in just doing this journey with Luke um you are very smart you articulate yourself very well and you know your stuff you have been not only a great helping hand in this process but I wouldn't choose anyone else to do this journey and road with anyone else and I would also of course love to thank my family my dad and my mom and my little sister I mom and

085Salma um they have been not only been the rock of my life and keep me going every single day to do this stuff but seeing how this district has served us as not only family but also as former students as well as Creations um products of this District it has been truly an honor and a blessing and I thank God every day for that so thank you all thank you so much okay so we do have plaques and I'm gonna just hold it up like this so everybody can see at home um both plaques say in recognition of your leadership and service to the students of the West contracosta Unified School District and we're going to take a quick picture so let's go do it e e e Okay C Business items consent do any

086of the trustees need to pull something from consent no all right seeing nothing we'll take a vote on consent uh student trusty Wilson yes student trusty espanosa Jr yes trusty Hernandez yes clerk andana yes oh clerk Smith Vols Smith FS yes and I am a yes business items consent is approved unanimously okay D superintendent communication Dr Moses this is your item thank you President reckler we could bring up the presentation um we'll be sharing with you the information that was prepared for our last board meeting so if dates are a little off please forgive us we still wanted to recognize uh the slides um myself and the cabinet would like to take the opportunity um this evening to share with you some of the things that are going on around the district and some events

087that um have taken place so we'll get started with a presentation next slide um we'd like to acknowledge the city of Hercules something very exciting happened last weekend heres held their very first Lunar New Year parade it was a festive event uh it was covered by media I actually saw us on channel 2 and uh that was largely possible because of the community effort but also because of the participation of our schools so I want to say congratulations to the city and congratulations to our schools in Hercules for a job well done celebrating the new you the New Year next slide we'd also like to highlight the education fair that took place January 25th this was a combination um this was an event that was a collaboration with uh go public schools as well as

088our district in order to share uh the offerings and um the offerings in our city and also programs that we highlight for our school so we want to recognize the Hercules School band that performed and um penol middle sorry can't see all the slides I'm not sure if there's an issue for everyone um but we had several of our schools attend and uh showcase our students and the hard work of our staff and the great school programs that we hold next slide shout out to Sheldon Elementary School um we were fortunate to share in their growing together program it's an organization uh that comes in to offer nutrition and gardening classes for all students at Sheldon uh we're really proud of the program and we wanted to shout them out today congratulations for a job

089well done Sheldon Elementary I also want to acknowledge that they have fresh produce at Valley View Elementary so shout out to Valley View as well um during the month of January uh myself and several board members uh performed visits at our school schools and we wanted to shout out the schools that we had the pleasure of visiting uh this past month uh that's Chavez Downer Murphy Olinda Ur Stewart Shannon and Peno middle I wanted to share some of the uh footage that we got at Ella Hurst their students uh hard at work uh they showcase their outdoor education their media production and their future writers uh it was a great visit to all of our schools and we're excited to continue that practice practice not only to learn about what's happening across our school district

090but also to hear from our uh School staff and community members regarding their their programs and their students um achievements next slide we are celebrating this month uh 15 substitute teachers completed the credentialing process last month and are now eligible to become full-time teachers in our district so congratulations teachers we are so happy you chose us I'd also like to highlight that we are also invested in a pipeline initiative Grant uh through the delpi program uh we have a partnership with UC Berkeley to also grow our own administrators within the district uh we are proud of this partnership and we received an award so that uh these Educators can receive this Education and Training at little cost to themselves and return to our district um to serve our students in our communities in a um

091a larger way so congratulations uh for those who are participating in the delpy Grant and shout out to our cabinet members who were instrumental in ensuring that this grant happened next slide uh we we'd like to share the progress of our reading difficulty screener sometimes called the dyslexia screener s sp114 is an education Omnibus trailer bill that calls for a screening tool for all California schools to identify students having difficulties with reading early on in order to provide in um Provide support to those students early and often in order to support literacy across the state uh so I just wanted to share the timeline here that we are in the process of working with a committee to select a screener for um this process and we will will also offer opportunities for our teachers across

092the district to learn more about these screeners and have input as well on the selection process uh we plan to bring uh recommendation forward in May um and that the process will continue so that by June of um 2025 we will adopt a screening um instrument that will be approved for use in our schools so we're excited about this work and we wanted to share that with you we anticipate implementing the screener in the fall of 2025 next slide Hercules science building we will have a ribbon cutting ceremony tomorrow [ __ ] woop shout out to facilities and shout out to the Hercules community and the students that will benefit from this new space tomorrow at 9:30 a.m. at the Hercules science building we will have a ribbon cutting ceremony and everyone is welcome next slide we'd

093also like to remind our community that the Richmond promise scholarship is open and that the scholarship is offering 1,500 per school year for uh with at least four years of funding guaranteed for our students who are qualified for this opportunity the deadline to apply for Richmond promise scholarship is Friday March 14th we encourage all students who are looking to attend college uh to apply for this opportunity uh for financial support in their college Endeavors next slide we are under uh we are undergoing our new family enrollment at this time we want to remind everyone and ask everyone to remind community members as well that open enrollment is happening we have a QR code on this slide you can also find this information on our website please spread the word about our wonderful school so that

094we can uh work to get our community members enrolled to start the school year with us for the 2526 school year next slide this is the same information in Spanish please share as needed next slide and we also want to publicize our transitional kindergarten enrollment as well this enrollment is open and you will register at your uh school of residence and there's information on this slide that shares the documents needed for full enrollment uh please enroll so that we can plan accordingly and welcome you in the fall next spot and this is the information in Spanish as always we'd like to remind our community of opportunities to engage we are invested and uh focused on increasing our community involvement especially through our parent advisory committees this slide highlights the APAC the ASAT the dlap committee

095and the mdat committee with descriptions of what the work that is happening there this next slide shows the CAC which is our special education Community advisory committee and the DLI pack which is for dual language immersion parents we'd like you to uh find a committee that fits your needs and and show up to the meetings as publicized to share your ideas and be a part of our decision-making across the district next slide two more committees the cboc and the 7-Eleven committee if uh you'd like to be involved in knowing more about our facilities and bonds program next slide and that concludes the superintendent report thank you and I'm happy to answer any questions thank you so much does anybody on the board have any questions okay seeing none thank you and we will move on

096to our action items the first action item is is [Music] E1 fiscal solvency plan thank you president reckler I believe that is my item uh board trustees at our last Board of Education meeting on January 8th as a discussion item we presented a plan for fiscal solvency for the 252 through 27 school years um I want to just review the summary with you based on that based on current projections we must Implement a $13 million reduction plan in order to achieve a positive bu in order to achieve a positive budget certification for the 2526 school year although our current budget meets the standards of positive certification it relies heavily on over 35 million in contributions from our fund 17 Reserve in order to address the structural deficit that we're currently experiencing across our budget the

097next two years um we are in a position where we need to address this fiscal uncertainty to ensure that we can continue to meet our financial obligations in the current year and the subsequent two years to address these concerns we've we outlined on January 8th a reduction plan that uh demonstrated our need to reduce 7.2 million and in potential Cuts in the school year of 2526 and an additional 6 million in reductions for the 2627 school year um we have provided the information for your review and it is now time uh to weigh in with your consideration um while the minimum required reductions are 13.2 million um these reductions must extend across the next three fiscal years in order to maintain fiscal stability according to our current projections and in addition to these reductions we

098continue to rely heavily on reserves to cover our annual costs over the next three years it is due to this reality that we are asking the Board of Trustees to approve the fiscal solvency plan as presented on January 8th to address the ongoing structural budget deficit at this time I will ask if there are any questions by the board that concludes my review of this item for Action this evening thank you is there any public comment on this item we have no public comment okay does any other the board have questions on this item trusty student trusty to espanosa go right ahead um I'm trying to think of how I would like put this question into the best way I can but but I guess just to ask it in more simple terms is it

099there like any way or chance this soleny plan could be extended for like the next week since we had our meeting that was scheduled for last week cancelled could this be like extended for next week to like determine if there's like any changes that could be done thank you for the question the reality is we were under a deadline to have this decided last week and so we have missed a deadline set forth by the county we're trying to ensure that this can be resolved this week and we do not anticipate any changes in the budget that would change the need to move these reductions forward that answers my question thank you are there any other questions please go ahead trusty Smith fult Dr Moses can you speak to the 162 million and explain what

100that is and where it comes from what it looks like thank you for the question I cannot explain that figure because it's not a figure that is an accuracy in our reality I think I'd have to ask our Union officials how they're calculating that amount the reality is currently in our reserves we are holding 37.6 3 million and the current plan is exhausting most of that in order to allow us to meet our um annual fiscal responsibilities are there any other questions on that side okay I have a I have a question I'd like to address the template because there have been some questions about the template that was used to make the reports would you be able to speak to that please absolutely thank you for asking the question I also have heard um

101allegations that this perhaps could have been patterned after San Ramon's plan the reality is the creation of a fiscal solvency plan has to be based upon the actual budget in the district those are our numbers those are our ideas those are our realities um I do want to share that the template the form of the template was actually patterned after San Ramone that county that superintendent shared with all of the Contra Casta County superintendents his template as a model for how to present this work we did use that template to present our information as well as some of the statements that are generalized across the state of California to describe the fiscal situation that we find ourselves in in the moment there were no areas of plagiarism as in this actual report only pertains to

102the needs of West Contra Casta the budget projections for West Contra Casta and the the recommendation for reductions that makes sense in this moment for West Contra Casta in order to satisfy our need to have a fiscal solvency plan that will allow us to have more stability in our uh budgeting over the next three years thank you very much okay are there any com oh I'm sorry uh can I uh have a motion to approve the fiscal solvency plan for 2025 to 2027 okay seeing none I will move the item to approve the fiscal solvency plan for 2025 to 2027 may I have a second I will second that motion thank you are there any comments on this item yes um point of order point of order you need to do public comment it's an

103action item we do public comment after the presentation didn't I ask for H comment on the item sorry I may have been in the restroom that's okay was I in the party okay I'm sorry you thank you if I could ask can I have the timer up for two minutes that's fine no I need all the corrections that any any help is appreciated may I have the timer up for comments from the board please thank you um so I'm aware thatmy at high schools receive a specific budget to spend at that Academy um for activities whatnot um I El High School the ITA Academy is receiving uh way more funds than they need and the teachers are aware of this but they um they know that if they don't spend the money that money will

104be reduced so what is happening is they're finding any way and every way to spend that money so that their budget is not reduced that money doesn't need to be spent necessarily I believe that we need to look into ourmes throughout West contast Unified School District and go in a deeper dive on how the funds are being spent and if they actually need those specific funds um there's a lot to talk about these are kidss talking but oh why not just do a $1,000 scholarship for each student in the class because there's about 90 students in the it Academy graduating including myself at El stre High School I can't speak for any other Academy but I'm aware there's a lot ofies and I I want to have a deeper dive into how these uh funds

105are actually being spent and not just spending them because they want the same budget the next year thank you anybody else okay well I have a couple of closing comments on this so first no one wants to do this no one runs for office to do this no one works here to do this this is an absolute necessity we're staring down dire fiscal situations and the people up here are I don't know what they're going to do but I know what I'm going to do and it's to literally save the district this is not a joke why declining enrollment more importantly attendance attendance number one over enrollment so even though we're in a very difficult space right now with Mr Trump and his actions we have got to encourage kids to come to school every

106every day we love your kids we want them here we're going to keep them as safe as we possibly can we're going to support them in every way that we can and it's not about unfortunately the way California calculates it it is about the money about money but it is about their health and well-being and their ability to live a wonderful successful life and if you come to school and you're educated you'll have much more of a chance to have the life that you want and deserve you'll be open to possibilities so that's job number one is everything we can to work on attendance I understand it's very difficult right now um the other thing I just want to talk about sourcing if you're using a template anything put your sources down it's okay people

107have better ideas than we do give them credit for it that's all and with that those are my comments on this item and now we will go to vote we'll start down here with student trusty Wilson yes student trusty Espinosa no trusty Hernandez yes trusty inana yes trusty Smith FS forgive the pregnant pause um you asked for comments and I was still kind of formulating it in my mind is it okay if I say one comment sure I think that this is the part of the board job that is the hardest because these numbers are attached to people in our district I think that one of the things that we have to do is we actually have to come together I think that we don't have a choice but we have to figure out how

108to work together I think that we were on the right track when we were doing the budget subcommittees I think that that gave us a chance to everybody sit at the table and get an understanding and a learning about school budgets School budgets are the most complicated things in the world I believe I don't think there's anything more complicated than looking at these budgets um the vote is always difficult because it's it feels like you're trusting One Source over another source and that should never be the it should never be that way it should be everybody coming together same numbers same intentionality same goal setting same outcome so we have to figure out how to get that right in our district so moving forward in times of tribulations because they are here we will be

109able to stick together so with that being said I want us to start coming together and I think the way to say that is to abstain get together and then re let me move forward with that positive vote because we're as one so I say I'm complete and I'm a yes vote passes three yes one abstain student trustee Wilson is a yes and Espinosa is a no okay E2 comprehensive coordinated early intervening Services plan Mr fleshman I believe this is your item thank you very much um we are here to present the um cace plan or the SIM for sigis plan as it is now referred to and I'd like to introduce our um cace coordinator uh Christine Hatcher to present to the board good evening president reckler board members superintendent Moses community members thank

110you for the opportunity to speak with you this evening my name is Christine ganh Hatcher and I'm here to present our comprehensive coordinated early intervening Services plan here to referred to as the CCS plan I get the next slide please the next one thank you are you running the slide presentation who's I'm sorry can we go back one I'm sorry that's a bit different okay I'm sorry I'm coming together I'm sorry a little late in the evening for me thank you all right our district has been identified as being significantly disproportionate or sigis uh this means we must design and Implement a plan to to address equity and educational access for students to prevent further disproportionality and please at if at any time I start to go too fast please just let me know and

111I'll slow down next slide I know there's a lot of text on there so I'm trying to summarize um our interest is to address student need to find effective strategies that will prevent further findings of significant disproportionality for our district next slide thank you this slide represents the four phases of the programmatic improvement process the plan requires that we apply a cultural lens to addressing the needed Improvement as well as academic adjustments we are in what is known as the third phase or the third cycle of our CS planning though we were notified in March of 2024 I want to be clear that this plan the Cs plan is not a special education plan it is a general Ed plan and its intention is not just to mitigate or lessen the impact of the significant

112disproportionality but to actually disrupt what the identified disproportionality is next please thank you the ratios that determine the significant disproportionalities and the area that is calculated annually as previous L mentioned by the California Department of Education and you can see in this going one slide back our significant disproportionality and a risk ratio was for white students overidentification of white students to separate schools this plan is designed to address the success gaps identified through data collection academic data quantitative special education and districtwide data and qualitative stakeholder data is considered these resources resources that are allocated or we will be allocating excuse me resources to support the plan's activities this plan is not designed singularly by me it is designed with the support of many stakeholders as are identified on the slide these same stakeholders will participate

113in quarterly meetings where we progress monitor the sea safes plan over the implementation cycle which ends September 30th 2026 keeping in mind both the root causes and the significant disproportionality categories sign disc categories criteria for the Target population was established by the CCS team to primarily but not exclusively support students who are in the sigis impacted subgroup and on the right hand side are this year's or this plan's focal schools so Fairmont Harding Kensington Madera Mir Vista and Coram matu middle within the focus schools Our intention is to provide direct support to students who meet the three criteria that are articulated on the on the slide for this next slide details the estimated number of students that the plan will support support ser and support root cause were identified based on the data collection process

114and stakeholder discussions that occurred in phase two of the C planning process outcomes and activities were designed to address the identified root causes root cause number one was determined that inconsistent use of inclusive and culturally responsive multi-tier systems of support supports staff Training Positive Behavior strategies limited schools abilities to fully support the whole child in academics Behavior attendance and social emotional learning our desired outcome our measurable outcome or the measurable outcome that was identified was by 2026 the district will improve mtss and SE and Section 504 support to ensure consistency and cultural relevance reducing separate School placements for white students and suspensions for African-American students by 5% root cause and measurable outcome number two inconsistent policy enforcement and underuse of Section 504 plans contribute to the overplacement of students in separate settings and higher suspension

115rates for black students by June 2026 the district will enhance are multi-tiered systems of support to provide consistent culturally relevant support reducing separate School placements for white students and suspensions for African-American students by 5% root cause and measurable outcome number three lack of transparency and engagement has led to distrust especially among black and white families implicit bias f limits authentic parent Partnerships the equity initiative that we've identified in in root cause and measurable outcome three should focus on reducing bias and building cultural proficiency to strengthen relationships and improve communication by June 2026 the district will strengthen authentic parent engagement increasing participation satisfaction and Trust success will be measured by higher involvement in parent groups 75% positive feedback on engagement sessions and improved Communications reflected in surveys we wanted to be sure that our measurable outcomes

116align while ensuring that we are addressing the needs of students as well as supporting staff in in the goal of meeting these needs meeting these articulated needs while measurable outcome number one addresses the need for consistent inclusive and culturally responsive support systems to ensure Equitable student outcomes across academics Behavior attendance and social emotional learning activities will include but are not limited to staff training in the area of Asis or adverse childhood experiences which considers the potential role of trauma on student beh behaviors it also supports implementation of positive behavioral intervention system plans which include alternatives to suspension and family engagement and resources will be dedicated to staff training and on-site student Support Services measurable outcome number two includes but is not limited to um the addressing the need for consistent policy enforcement and proper use

117of 504 plans to reduce student segregation and racial disparities in discipline activities will include staff collaboration in creating a more staff specific multi-tiered system of support triangle to outline resources for student needs not just at tier one but tiers two and three to also support the implementation and Pro press monitoring of the social emotional learning MTS framework at the six sites and resources will be dedicated again to staff training and onsite student support services for social emotional and behavioral needs measurable outcome number three addresses the need for transparency cultural proficiency and bias reduction to rebuild trust and strengthen parent School Partnerships especially among black and white families activities will include but are not limited to similarly to the measurable outcomes of number two activities excuse me site specific work site specific collaboration to create an

118mtss triangle to outline resources for student needs at TI years 1 two and three it also will support implementation and progress monitoring of seal as well as academic Frameworks at the six sites and again we will be be res dedicating resources to staff training and on-site student support services to ensure and improve illiteracy proficiency this last slide just details or or or shows the next steps for the implementation of this plan um I didn't change the dates I planned to do this last week but I appreciate the opportunity to present this evening we will be submitting pending the board's decision to the California Department of Ed for approval um and then our team Begins the work of implementation and supporting the six sites that were identified in the presentation and between now and September 30th

119of 202 six we will be progress monitoring those activities that were articulated in the plan however I also want to say that as the needs of the students at the sites may change we reserve the right to amend the plan to make sure that we are adequately addressing student need and that is the end of my presentation okay thank you so much is there any public comment on this item we have no public comment thank you we'll go to questions anybody has questions we'll go to three three each none okay I have a I have a couple of questions so I believe the last time the plan came forward was in 2023 is that right the last Cays plan yeah there have been a couple so there was a cesay plan in 2021 um each

120plan cycle and I'm gonna actually call on superintendent Moses to correct me if I get this incorrect I believe it's a 27mon cycle so there was a plan in 2021 which ended in September September 30th 2023 there was a 2022 plan which ended September 30th 2024 sometimes they will overlap depending on the annual determination by the state so come this March March 2025 we will receive another letter from the state with an annual determination which may be something very different than the one that we received in 2024 but if we are tracking the data and the state actually does provide this and I'm going to actually look to uh CA director Flashman to jump in it help me if I misspeak um it is looking like we have an increase in special education referrals for

121African-American students under the classification of other health impairment the ca plan that closed out September 2024 was overidentification African-American students under uh the designation of emotional disability um we had and suspensions of greater than 10 days so we're just kind of tracking to see so all the data that we actually receive from the district can kind of help us predict what our possible annual determination will be in March okay so what happens to the schools like I just found a plan for 2023 I can't remember anything in 2024 coming forward but you know I'm looking at the plan for 2023 can either of you answer like what happened with that work is did were those schools corrected do they do you just do the work and the time expires and it's like okay we're done

122or like how how does this overall process work if that makes sense I think the intention president reckler is to build the capacity of the school sites to meet the needs of their students so if for example there were focal schools and we were looking at suspension data and we saw a disproportionate number of these schools or or the disproportionality was around suspension for African-American students of more than 10 days there was a process that the csas coordinator and team went through at that time which included looking at suspension data could be looking at attendance data looking at academic data and a plan is formulated so if in the plan the activity was to provide on-site counselors if it was to train teachers in adverse childhood experiences if it was to do a concentrated Outreach

123to parents to increase attendance the the int the plan or the intention of that is to build the capacity of those folks that are charged with implementing that work so that when the when the money goes away it's not the money that's driving the change it's actually the knowledge of the people that are there so had it not been corrected from 2023 would it would we expect to see it in another year we would expect to see a decrease using the example I just write around suspension we would expect to see a decrease in suspension we might expect to see an increase in attendance we would expect that surveys that went out to show increased satisfaction with the work that the school is doing with in in terms of parent engagement as as examples okay

124and then um what more specifically what would um interventions look like for white families and students I'm sorry would you mind repeating that what specifically would an intervention or professional development or working with white families and students look like in the previous plan no for the one that you're presenting for this one yeah some of the things that we have identified is providing mental health counselor on site we will be providing academic support providers working with students the three criteria wa let me go back to my I printed the PowerPoint so I won't ask that we bring it up again so if you'll if I can beg your Indulgence for just just a moment the three criteria that we use to determine who the focal students were chronic absenteeism below grade level Proficiency in both

125English language arts and Mathematics and there was a documented incident meaning maybe there was a referral so to address the ABS The Chronic absenteeism we are doing an intentional engagement of parents what are the barriers to to attendance what are the things that we can do to mitigate the impact of chronic absenteeism what we do know is that absenteeism 100% impacts academic achievement so if we can in if we can increase attendance then we can increase academic outcomes time in front of a teacher a good teacher is going to to improve the academic outcome for students we know that research supports that um documented incidents if students are struggling not just academically but social emotionally then we want to make sure that there are people on site to help them develop mechanisms to address whatever

126it is again that might be a barrier to their achievement I I think I saw your hand up so I just want to pause for a minute okay um yes sir uh president record i' I'd also refer back to slides um 17 18 and 19 um in the in the presentation give some of the more specific um examples of some of the interventions that are going to be happening at the school sites for example there's for activity 2.1 provide professional development for specific to the effective implementation of discipline behavioral Matrix that contains mtss implementation then activity 2.4 um talks about tier one um and tier 2 interventions so some of those uh pieces give a little bit more of that specificity I think that you were asking for okay thank you very much and certainly

127if you want more detail I can always send you a copy of our action plan development that we've submitted to the state okay thank you thank you for that offer okay any other questions okay seeing none I will entertain a motion which would be to approve the district's comprehensive coordinated early intervention services plan in order to meet CDC submission requirements for Cay okay I'll move the item as I previously noted is there a second I second the second was Hernandez and are there any comments on this item Rusty Smith FS go ahead but please wait for the timer there we go thank you so much for the presentation I attended when you did this online and it was just as good I think that having the input from the parents and the community and all

128of that I think added to just how great the presentation was um I appreciate you doing the presentation for us now I think that this is a dynamic plan and I'm looking forward to seeing the continue implementation I am complete thank you thank you so much okay if there are no further comments we'll go to the vote trust student Tristy Wilson yes student Tristy espanosa Jr yes trusty Hernandez yes clerk andana yes trusty Smith folds Smiths yes and I am a yes the motion carries unanimously okay we are thank you appreciate your time this evening thank you very much we are now up to E for Education Code 44258 do3 variable term waivers I believe this is Dr Johnson thank you good evening trusty I'm president reckler and members of the school board the current

129colle collective bargaining agreement for United teachers of Richmond expires on June 30th 2025 the district and UT proposed to engage in good faith bargaining by sunshin the initial propos proposals provided to you this evening okay wait a minute I just want to uh correct my I I skipped one accidentally um so we're on E3 accept public comment and approve receipt of initial bargaining proposals for United teachers of Richmond and the West contracosta Unified School District the West contracosta Unified School District in United teachers of Richmond will post the initial proposals of the Board of Education to receive any public comment on the initial proposals and approval receipt of the submitted proposals so I need to open a public hearing so this is a public hearing on the sun shining of the initial bargaining proposals from

130the United teachers of Richmond and the West contra cost Unified School District tonight the board will conduct a public hearing on the initial proposals from the United teachers of Richmond and the West contracosta Unified School District pursuant to the sunshin requirements of California government code section 354 7 during the public hearing the focus will be on Gathering of input from the public including district teachers employees and parents regarding the initial bargaining proposals being presented the proposals of this meeting is to inform the public on the topics of negotiation between the United teachers of Richmond and the district tonight's item will proceed as follows first will open the public hearing just did that second the district's negotiator Dr Camille Johnson associate superintendent of Human Resources will make a presentation to the board regarding the initial proposals

131from the United teachers of Richmond and the school district third upon the conclusion of the presentation the board will take public comments on this item the time allotted for public comment is 10 minutes and each participant will have one minute and at the conclusion of public comment board members may ask clarifying questions of District staff and then the public hearing will be closed at this time I invite um okay I'm sorry about that um I invite Dr Johnson to make the presentation sorry about that you were complaining about your glasses I think I I picked up a old spare because I'm having trouble reading tonight would you like me to repeat okay nope I'm fine I'm hearing okay tonight and now I'm just not seeing tonight so I'm sorry it it's can you can't hear

132you can make your proposal you can you can make your presentation on the bargaining proposals okay once again the um the current collective bargaining agreement for United teachers of Richmond expires on June 30th 2025 the district and utr proposed to engage in good faith bargaining by sunshin the initial proposals provided to you this evening the articles for westc Costa include article one agreement article 10 hours of employment and daily assignment article 12 class size Article 15 evaluation article 22 school calendar article 23 salary article 25 employee benefits article 46 staff development article 52 special education the district Reserve reses the right to open other articles as needed during the negotiations and will exchange proposals at the bargaining table we also resolve reserve the right to add ATT amend or delete proposals during contract negotiations utr

133has brought forth the following articles article 1 agreement article 10 hours of employment and Duty assignments article 12 class size Article 19 safety article 23 salary article 25 employee benefits article 46 staff development and article 52 special education and they are proposing a new article 54 International Educators thank you thank you very much now we are going to public comment as a reminder it will be 1 minute per person with a total of minutes we will alternate between an in-person public comment and then one on Zoom is there any public comment on this item we have no public comment thank you are there any board questions seeing none I will now close the public hearing I will now accept a motion to approve receipt of the initial bargaining proposals from the United teachers of Richmond

134and West contracosta Unified School District I move to approve the receipt of the initial bargaining proposal for the United teachers of Richmond and West pasta Unified School District motion by Hernandez is there a second I second second by clerk inana is there any comment on this item Bo comment we'll put two minutes on the clock go ahead trusty Smith folds thank you so much for bringing this forward I think that um I'm just going to repeat a little bit of the comment that I said before I urge us to work together as a team I urge us to always censor students and not adults when we're doing this work at the bargaining table I urge it not to all be on you Dr Johnson I urge it to be a real collaborative communication among everyone

135and I urge us not to go into it thinking that there are sides there's only one side and that's the student side so I also urge us not to leave the table until we come up with solutions that we may not all be happy with but we can all agree to because at the end of the day and the beginning of the day this is about the kids of West Contra Costa Unified School District and I think that having the most dynamic people people at the table that includes District staff and our bargaining unions that we can actually move the district in the direction that we all wanted to go also think that comes with under the leadership of of course a a dynamic interim superintendent who's been on both sides right so again I

136don't want it to be sides but I'm happy that we have knowledge in the room or knowledge that's going to be in the room so um it may not be easy but it can be done hard is not impossible so again thank you very much for everybody who's going to participate in this process and we look forward to the updates I look forward to the updates I am complete thank you so much seeing no further comments we'll go to a vote student trusty Wilson yes trusty Espinosa Jr yes trusty Hernandez yes cler inana yes trusty Smith folds Smith FS yes and I'm a yes the motion and the item carries unanimously all right now back to E4 E4 sorry about that E4 Education Code 44258 do3 variable term waivers recommended for approval Dr Johnson this

137is your item thank you president reckler Ed code 44258 three allows the governing board of a school district to authorize the holder of credentials to teach departmental classes in grades K through2 provided the teacher has adequate knowledge of the subject matter thank you okay that was right to the point is there any public comment on this item we have no public comment great okay we'll go to board questions anybody have questions on this item seeing none I'll accept a motion to approve Education Code 44258 do3 variable term waivers I'll move the item is there a second I second Hernandez is the second on the item is there any board comment seeing n we'll go to a vote student trusty Wilson yes trusty espanosa Jr yes trusty Hernandez yes cler yes trusty Smith FS Smith FS

138yes and I'm a yes motion and the item carry E5 carries unanimously okay we are all done with all of our action items and we now turn to number F which is discussion items point of order yes go ahead it looks on my agenda that we need to do E5 acceptance of contra cost County I'm sorry gosh you're absolutely right thank you okay E5 acceptance of contracosta County Office of Education annual report for Williams settlement legislation thank you very much for that I Believe Miss Payne this is your item good evening board superintendent and Community um wanted to give just a little bit of introduction on this item as this is the annual report so the term Williams comes from a legal agreement made in 20 four that applies to California schools this agreement resulted

139in new laws to ensure that schools provide a certain level of services to students parents Guardians and Educators every year the county superintendent is required to produce a report about the state of schools that are monitored under Williams agreement these schools are visited at least once a year and at least 25% of these visits are a surprise visit the main goal of these visits is to check three things whether they are enough textbooks and instructional materials whether the school buildings are safe and don't pose any immediate health or safety risk and whether the information given on the school accountabil accountability report card known as the sarc um about availability of textbooks and conditions of school buildings are accurate uh the county is required to make these visits within the first four weeks of school and

140so tonight we ask the board to accept contracosta County Board of Education annual report for the Williams settlement for the fiscal year 20242 this report provides site specific reports for 35 different sites which includes 19 elementary schools five middle schools two high schools and eight charter schools all Sites received a fit that's our facility inspection tool score greater than 84% one site received an exemplary rating that is our new Lake Elementary School uh one site received a fair rating and all of our other sites received a good rating before uh completing the presentation tonight I just really want to thank the county uh the district inspection teams our site leaders and our maintenance and operation teams who worked really collaboratively to ensure that all of these visits were completed and then partnered with the county

141to prioritize a number of these repairs uh that concludes the presentation great thank you so much is there any public comment on this item there's no public comment thank you are there any board questions on this item we'll go with three I have a question yes go ahead um the concerns listed on the facility inspections are how are we addressing those and what's the timeline to make sure that we address those in a timely manner thank you so much it's a great question so once the fits are completed all of those items are turned into work orders in our work order system and then our work orders are prioritized based on the type of work order um the fit itself has three different categories and so uh when it's an extreme deficiency the prioritization of

142completing that work is as quickly as possible there are other items that might be identified in the fit we're going in and doing that repair work is best done when we don't have school so for example we have a couple of breaks coming up um when we don't have school uh like in April when our site when our staff is working but our students are not at school and that provides opportunities to do things like flooring repairs without interrupting instruction um but we do track in our work order system all of the fits in addition to the fits that are done by the county for the specific set of schools identified by the state the district also does fits for all of our schools and so um we're able to track and provide data then

143on completing those repairs thank you are there any other questions on the side okay I've got a couple so I'm wondering if you can help me with how um projects get prioritized so you know a water fountain there was one water fountain issue which ranked at 73.91% point you know they're both in the 70s and they're ranked as poor do you look at is that how you make these determinations like do you look at okay these scored in the below or how do you rank between two items that are in the 70s excellent question um what you have before you tonight in the annual report is the fits cumulative score um there's a lot of additional pages to the fit that identify the location and then the specific item that was noted the score that

144gets calculated and provides then a percent score for the 15 different categories is a ratio of number of items reviewed and then what was deemed as okay meaning no deficiency what was identified as a deficiency and then what is identified as an extreme deficiency so if you have an extreme deficiency in any of those categories your score goes to a zero um so extreme deficiencies definitely are the highest priority and ones that when something's deemed in extreme deficiency that's something that we're addressing right away within that total score there's individual work orders that we have and different locations for those work orders and so as those work records go into our um maintenance queue they're then assigned to the different trades that would then do that type of repair work um to then complete the

145noted deficiency okay and is any of this in the realm of facilities master plan or is this just basic repair type of items it's both um it's a great question um in fact for those that might want to dive in the auditor produced the auditor of California produced a report in November of this year where they were looking at the fit reports um at multiple districts throughout the state because it's not a perfect process but it is a process very prescriptive and code and it was identifying and talking about some of the ways that the fit could be improved and it was also talking about this interesting line between repair and new project one of the things that the Ed code for which the fit the facility inspection tool criteria of good repair States is

146that that good repair is to the level that the project was designed and constructed so you wouldn't see a fit deficiency identified for something that was beyond when that school was designed and conr constructed and with so many schools that were built at different times based on the code of that time we do have kind of a patchwork across our district but the code in the Ed code it's very specific that what is indicated in the fit meets those categories and is as the school was originally designed and constructed so for the most part what you would see come through in a fit inspection which would then turn into a fit work order it's going to be a repair of existing versus the installation of something new or an alteration to the site got it

147okay all right since there we are done with questions we'll move to a motion and the motion is to accept acceptance of the acceptance of the kraasa County Office of Education annual report for Williams settlement legislation does anybody want to make that motion I will then and I am looking for a second on that I second okay Hernandez will second the motion then are there any comments on this item from the board trusty Smith folds please wait for the clock go right ahead teacher pain there's nothing more difficult than having to clean up some somebody else's mess and you have done that with Grace you have come in and you have been not only transparent but you have been honest you have looked at all of our sites through a lens of um Justice equity

148and um following our journey of anti-racism so I just want to put that out there and to tell you thank you you are seen and you are valued and I know more now than I did before you took that seat so for me that's what growth looks like to be able to speak intelligently about something and you truly are a teacher I am complete thank you very much and we will now move on to the vote we'll start down with our student trustees student truste Wilson yes student truste Espinosa yes trusty Hernandez yes trusty kerana yes trusty Smith FS Smith FS yes and I'm yes motion passes unanimously okay now we're up to F1 discussion item and reports and the item is to receive the annual Financial audit for 2324 whose item is that Dr

149Moses Mr Hart that's your item whoops shut the lap top at the wrong time he uh we will be joined by H um Hugo Luna from Christy white who will be doing the presentation thank you very much for having me here today it's a pleasure to be here with you all um I'm going to share my screen now with for my presentation [Music] okay so I'll be presenting the results of the um audit for the fiscal year ended June 30th 2024 so our responsibility as a thirdparty Auditors is to issue an opinion on the financial statements um basically ensuring that they are in materi that they are materially um correct um not only that but we're also making sure that they're in line with federal and state requirements um I I want to point out

150that our opinion doesn't address the financial condition of the school district that's done through your um internal presentations with uh your excuse me your first interum your second interim reporting your budget presentations um we did we did Issue an unmodified opinion which is the best opinion um that we can issue for the school district is the best one possible um so I'm going to read our opinion as it's listed on the audit report on page one I won't make you turn to the page I listed it here word for word um in our opinion the financial statements referred to above present fairly in all material respects the respective financial position of the governmental activities each major fund and the aggregate remaining fund information of the West Contra cross Unified School District as of June 30th

1512024 and the respective changes in financial position and where applicable cash flows thereof for the year that ended in accordance with accounting principles generally accepted United States of America so in order to issue this opinion over the financial statements um we had to perform a series of internal controls just to list a few of the many that we conducted during this audit um that includes accounts payable department the payroll department um the deposit process and what we're essentially doing we're looking at the district internal control procedures we're analyzing them we select a sample of transactions from each department each transaction type and we make sure that they're lining up with what the district internal control policy says it should be um we're also looking at uh once they once the books are closed we're looking

152at cash to make sure it was accurately recorded um accounts receivable and accounts payable transactions that are close to the end of the fiscal year let's say for example in July and August to make sure that there're recruit in the correct fiscal year and even when it comes to U making account changes over the journal entry process for the closing of the books we're also looking at the approval process for that so upon review of internal controls over the financial statements that's um we issued an unmodified opinion uh no material weaknesses U and no significant deficiencies to report so there is a federal component of this audit because federal funds are restricted and can only be used for specific purposes depending on the program um each state program is selected as a major fund um

153has a as a major program excuse me has its own set of audit guides um audit procedures that we conduct so the district as a whole spent approximately 66.6 million in federal funds and we selected two major programs um based on what's been tested in the past based on what we identified as a measure major program um and those programs were uh the title one part A and the education stabilization fund discretionary grants also known as the Esser funds um those are those are common ones we tested across the state and that also needed to be tested for your District this year um and upon testing of those procedures we issued an unmodified opinion over Federal compliance uh no significant deficiencies to report and no material weaknesses um so when it comes to State compliance

154it's a it's an area that it's really hard to not have any findings just because uh as opposed to other areas where we're able to work with materiality um when it comes to State compliance it's very it's black and white it's yes or no right so it's even one little word for example if if if there was one word that was off on the sarc it would be a finding um and state compliance there's actually um it's a wide variety of areas it's a large umbrella underst State compliance so um basically it's comprehensive school safety plan the elap the transportation plan um this list seems to be getting extensively longer as the years go by it seems like there's a new state compliance area um every year but um um that being said um there

155were no material weaknesses and no significant deficiencies but we did have we did have two findings which I'll go over in my next slide um so one of them was over instructional materials and uh it's like I said if there's one little thing that's off in state compliance we the audit guide states that we have to have it as a finding and um this one had to do with the public hearing the notice that was posted for instructional materials it looks like it was posted after the 8th week of school it needs to be posted before the eth week um and uh there's no question ca for this finding it's not a repeat finding and upon review and conversation with the school district it looks like this won't be an issue in the next audit

156um if if the information provided to us is correct it looks like in 2425 U the first day of school was August 19th 2024 and the public hearing was held um on October 9th um which which which should fall under before the 8we period so should be okay for the next fiscal year it's always nice when we could put in the corrective action plan that it's already been implemented uh the the other one was related to instructional time and it was really it was very close to being in compliance so there's um there's a requirement for instructional time for for grades 1 to three um the annual instructional minutes required was 50,400 what we do is we take the lowest of all the school sites the lowest minutes reported um of instruction so it would

157so the required grades 1 to three was 50,400 and the lowest one was 50365 so it was it was just it was just under for grades 1 to three and for grades four to 6 the requirement is 54,000 and the um the lowest one that we observed was 53,9 45 so also right there there was a fiscal penalty for this one of uh 12 $6,000 56,58 um and there is a calculation that that goes with it if that U I can send out if um anyone is interested District should have it but um I can always send it again um so that that concludes my presentation um and I again I want to repeat with the state compliance because it this it's it's it's difficult to not have any findings because it really as opposed

158to other areas where we're working mainly with school department uh we're working with pretty much the many departments in state compliance we're working with the instructional side Child Nutrition um the facilities Department even for some requests so um yeah it's but um overall that's that's those are the findings that's my presentation if there are any questions I will take them now great thank you so much for the presentation is there any public comment on this item we have no public comment thank you are there any board questions on this item we we'll have three questions per board member go right ahead trusty Smith folz Dr Moses what strategies are we using to ensure I'm sorry point of order can um can we check if there's a public comment first did you want to speak to

159this item can you hit the little button so that we can hear you thank you yeah I had a clarification question is this the shortfall of attendance in the schools that were being penalized for how does that how does that relate to the uh the budget shortfall thank you for your for your comment um that seems to be more of an in answer for the for internal um if anybody wants to step in yeah we we'll we'll sir I'm sorry we we'll address it up here with with board questions thank you uh trusty Smith Vols do you want to go ahead please Dr Moses and I know that there are some strategies that you or the district has put in place to ensure that we are compliant when it comes to minutes is that just

160educating our site principles is that looking more at um the schedules site schedules can you tell me what strategies and I know there may be multiple but what strategies we're using to make sure that that compliance is in place thank you for the question yes this particular finding this school uh you'll noticed oh it doesn't name the school I'll name it for you um it's olone Elementary School oh it is there um alone elementary school has not changed its bell schedule for the last six years however during this year what happened was there was there was an additional minimum day for parent teacher conference week which caus them to be 35 minutes short uh for primary grades and 55 minutes short for upper grades just that one day uh based upon the school calendar uh

161we try and make sure that schools have a little cushion however we can't mandate that that's one way in which we mitigate this the other way is that we have um Excel spreadsheets that we use to check the minutes uh been working with a team to try to figure out how this one was missed what typically will happen is we will catch the era we will call the school site and ask them to revise the schedule I think because this was a long-standing schedule and there wasn't attention paid to the minimum day this one fell through the cracks however I'd also like to to name that the uh fine that's being assessed of $126,500 up but the rule is we have to make them up twice so we have to make up the 35 minutes

162in uh the current calendar year and also in next calendar year if we make up those minutes over the two years they will wave the $126,000 fine thank you so much for the clarification and thank you for um ensuring that there is a strategy to make sure that we're catching those things and helping our principles I'm complete are there any other questions on this side so can I expand on that just a little bit so we've had this happen before um is is that the normal strategy that the school routinely makes up the minutes in the following year that is the strategy to prevent the fine I mean of course we want want schools not to make this mistake but there is a strategy um in order to mitigate the fine um if you'd like

163me to elaborate on the other situation I can but there are other circumstances related to that prior fine no it's that's okay I'm just wondering in in general if when that has happened you know has that been you probably don't know like is that like standard of how yeah go ahead I can name right now that there is a uh we're trying to get a find way for a specific Secondary School however in order to add instructional minutes we also need permission of Labor because it's a change of the work hours we're trying to work that out with the site leadership and with labor in order to prevent that fine uh the state has been gracious and giving us extra time to try to figure it out but up until now we haven't been able

164to uh get the cooperation in order to prevent that fine so I just want to name that sometimes it's a you know it has to be a collaborative effort and it has to be agreed upon with labor to add minutes to the instructional calendar per their contract okay thank you and then finally there was a question out here about how does this relate to attendance um and I'll let you answer it I don't think it does I think it relates to something else but go ahead than the only relation to attendance is the expect expected annual minutes or the required annual minutes by the state uh this doesn't generate an absence of any kind it just triggers that we were deficient in the required minutes by the state okay thank you um no other question

165okay good all right so no other questions on this we will move to a motion and the motion is to accept the Contra cast the County Office of Education annual oh no it's not I'm sorry oh it's a discussion item we don't need to do anything with it oh my God help me okay so there are there any comments no one further on this item okay and we're done with this gosh I am really struggling tonight okay we're going to G comments from the Board of Education and future agenda items we'll start down here with the student trustees we'll put two minutes on the clock I pretty much got everything else out that I wanted to say but again thank you for this amazing opportunity and experience and I hope to take what I've learned

166here and implement it into everything I do um as a lot of you might be aware you know I'm an inspiring attorney I hope to to be an attorney one day I hope to be in politics one day so this was a great intro into that thank you stent trusty husbandos a junr um just once again just another repetition of what I said earlier mentioned earlier thank you again for all of the support and the love and care you guys have shown as a board and as staff especially to the cabinet members as well thank you all for explaining everything in the most simple terms a high school student can understand and for all the work that you have done as well thank you all for your service and alongside I can agree with Luke

167in saying that I do aspire to be an attorney as well serving this community as well um in the highest level I can and yeah just thank you for making this the best experience ever trusy Hernandez do you have anything yeah um today's decision um that we had to make today in regards to the district Financial challenges the solvy plan wasn't an easy one while it it was a difficult choice to make um I know that I remain committed to making sure to finding a sustainable solution that is going to prioritize our community or students our staff our Educators and working collabora towards a long-term physical stability that our district really needs and that's all I have to say thank you thank you cler yeah I want to Echo a lot of what um trusty

168Hernandez just said I think it's you know really hard decisions um sitting here trying to do what's best um for our students um it's going to come with a lot of decisions that might not be everyone's cup of tea but I think that we need to work together we need to make sure that we are staying student focused and making the best decisions with the knowledge of where we sit financially you know decisions are going to have to be made and though they are hard we are committed to the work um that we need to do to you know really Thrive and for our students to have the best future possible um another thing I think when it comes to Future agenda items or things that I would want to see is creating messaging and

169guidelines on immigration support I think with everything that's going on right now it really has to be focused we need to reach out to our state superintendent and governor and get clear Direction on how do we move forward what you know what are guidelines that they're setting for districts here in California and really make it a priority to make sure that we are supporting our immigrant families that we are safeguarding them because every time we talk about you know loss of re venue especially on Ada that needs to be of importance how do we make sure that our students are coming to schools that our families are feeling safe having their children in schools and that they are not frightened by what you know might not be tomorrow and and I say that so um

170that's just my thought on future agenda items are you finished yes thank you I'm looking at the clock okay thank you for that swinging around to the side trusty Smith FS you have anything I think that we should take a moment and recognize that we have made it through the first 100 days of school the 100 day of school was Friday we now have 77 days left in that 77 days it's going to go 77 school days it's going to go fast then graduations are upon us TKS go to kindergartner kindergarteners go to first and then you have your seniors that get out into the real world to the student trustees I want to tell you that if you're going to be lawyers be educational lawyers trust me they get paid so um then come

171back for the district um I think that when we're talking about our fiscal responsibility and our fiscal budget we have to work together we can only get there together so that means all of us coming to an agreement that we are centering students well-being and centering their uh best outcomes and that means that we all have to do it together because we have all had our educational experience it is now time to make sure that they have their best version of theirs um it's not always what we do but it's how we do it and I think that if we can do it together with transparency meaning everybody has to choose to come to the table they have to choose to have these hard conversations in a soft way and we have to choose to

172make our yes our yes and our no our no we cannot waffle on that and we have to stand together uh again it's February is Black History Month understand that black history is every month this is just our anniversary where we celebrate it but if you are not talking about black history black achievement and black successes in all of your classrooms and on all of your campuses you are doing a disservice to your students into the community we are 365 24/7 and 7 days a week uh Mr Hart welcome to the board welcome to a board meeting this was an easy one um and then again we need to make sure that we're centering the safety social emotional safety of all of our children including our immigrant families and our black students who go to

173school every day and get called names I'm complete thank you and uh wrapping up so again nobody runs for these positions to do what we had to do tonight nobody works here to do what we have to do tonight I'm not sure that the district's message about how fiscally fragile we are uh is resonating I I'm it surprises me but I think we need to work on that yet again um I want to address uh Mr Trump and his executive orders um this really is disturb me in ways that I wasn't really prepared for we're here in this country my family is here in this country only by the grace of God and we were given a life when could have been very devastating my father was an immigration attorney because he knew what it

174was like to be in an immigrant family and we have to do everything we can to protect our students um that also extends to our non-binary families because they have also Fallen under Mr Trump's evil gaze so we do need very clear messaging about what we're going to do how we're going to do it why we're going to do it and we need to be clear with our families on what they need to do as well I also want to thank Rob BTO who's the Attorney General who published a very good guide about steps that we can take as a district to strengthen our policies I already printed everything that he touched on and we're going to be bringing that to the governance committee immediately strengthen what we have so that we can um give

175our students the best shot and [Music] um we're in this together and we're not going to go down without a fight next regularly scheduled board meeting is February 12 2025 at laan Dean middle school and we are done at 9:34 p.m. this evening thank you for

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.