CorpusRecord 109722

Board of Education Meeting | January 8, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / West Contra Costa USD
Date
2025-01-09
Location
Contra Costa County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
24,145 words · about 135 min
Collected
2026-06-20

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e sorry everyone good evening and welcome to the January does somebody have sound on WE off okay that's good okay every oh say you hello okay I think we're good okay good evening welcome to the January 8 2025 regularly scheduled meeting of the West contracosta Unified School District School Board the meeting is called to order at 5:31 p.m. to access translation in Zoom please [Music] click access translation in Zoom please click on the globe icon at the bottom of the screen if you are here in Deon you may pick up a headset for translation in the back corner of the auditorium the board is about to go into closed session but before we do we are here to listen to public comment on closed session items individuals wishing to speak on Clos session items listed

002if you're here in the auditorium and you haven't already done so yet please submit a wccusd public comment card which you can find on the entryway table or if you are participating via Zoom individuals will need to raise their hand in the Zoom app if you're accessing the meeting by phone press star n the time allotted to each speaker is two minutes speaking time shall not be transferred from one person to another there is also no substitution of speakers we alternate between a zoom comment and an in-person comment the public comment period is a safe space where diverse viewpoints may be expressed civy without interruption or intimidation please listen attentively to each speaker's comment and respect their time as if it were your own be open to a different point of view if one is

003offered due to the bound act board members cannot discuss items that are not on the agenda and do not usually respond to items presented in public comment the items listed on the closed session agenda tonight are conference with legal council exist litigation case number c22 0277 4 Public Employee appointment volunteer positions conference with labor negotiators School supervisors Association is there any public comment on these items yes our first public comment is Francisco Ortiz good evening board members my name is Francisco ortis president of the United teachers of Richmond I'm here tonight to urge you to vote on the proposed reassignments in a public setting as required under Education Code 3553 35 subsection e the community looks to our board to hold the district accountable and ensure trans transparency and decisions that profoundly impact our students

004in school communities media reassignments disrupt stability for our students particularly those in underserved schools who rely on literacy and math coaches and neeld supports these changes are short-term Band-Aids to Staffing challenges and counter the district's stated Equity goals the board has the authority and responsibility to vote on these transfers to ensure that they are neither arbitrary or capricious tonight I ask you to prioritize the voices of Educators students and families directly impacted please exercise your oversight to keep the district accountable and Equitable thank you if I may point of order uh this is not agendized as a closed session item nor is it agendize as an open session item tonight if you want to speak on this item please save your item for item B8 public comment in Open Session thank you our next public

005communist Mark please unmute yourself okay good evening my name is Mark Mitchell I'm the executive director of United teachers of Richmond you're going into close session tonight you're likely to be accompanied by the attorney Miss Miola that the district uses um as its legal councel um I want to remind the board that the legal council Miss molo works for the board not for the interim superintendent or for District staff um I want to uh just remind the board that uh they may be discussing items in or attempt to discuss items in Clos session that are more appropriately and properly held in public session I want to remind the board of responsibilities not to discuss issues that are not properly subject to closed session discussion in closed session the constituents the Educators and other employees the

006families and students want to hear the discussion um on things that should be properly held in public session and uh want to encourage you to defer um uh on the side or to air on the side of caution and make sure that all discussions regarding these involuntary transfers or other issues are done in public session as required by law thank you so again this item is not agendized for closed session or Open Session tonight should you wish to make comment on this item please move it to open session B8 public comment thank you our next public comment is Gabby Zana trustees and Inter superintendent Moses I'm before you today to respectfully request that you add to your agenda publicly discuss and vote on the involuntary transfers set to take place on January 21st before your

007next board meeting if you seek trust in the community as so often stated you need to build it through being forthright with decisions particularly decisions that interrupt so many people's lives I want to make sure that you also understand that this is not a long-term solution to our vacancy crisis in fact it will only serve to exacerbate it many educators are tired of being moved on the whims of superintendent and have put in for early retirement or to go on leave in addition the classrooms that are being transferred to have finally settled into patterns with long-term sub who have Subs who have built relationships with the community many of whom are working towards becoming fully credential in fact principles were given the opportunity to tell HR which Subs they wanted to protect instead of listing

008the position as open and nearly every substitute was on that list I ask you to direct staff to seek long-term solutions to keep Educators here and work with universities and credentialing programs to bring in new Educators every student certainly still deserves a credential teacher but midyear disruptive chaos trying to move 20 people to f 70 vacancies and in such create different vacancies is not the answer public communist Sam clear good afternoon my name is Sam CLE and I a third grade teacher on release Siege Elementary and the organizing chair for utr the vacancy crisis will not be solved by taking Educators out of their Community Schools in the middle of the Year these Educators their communities point of order Miss clear yeah may I please ask you to move this public comment to open session

009it's not on the closed agenda uh tonight it should be heard on at B8 Open Session thank you they want me to keep going so I'll keep going um these educators are pillars of their communities many focus on Literacy for multilingual Learners and work at Title One schools they are valued by staff and families and needed at their schools we're going to continue driving Educators and families out of this District if we continue to disrespect these communities with this Choice over the past 3 years over 500 Educators have left this District we need to focus on Long term Solutions such as improving our pay and conditions instead of driving talented Educators out thank you is there anybody here not speaking on reassignments so the only item for closed session with conference with beli negotiators is

010SSA is anybody here to speak on SSA is anybody here to speak on any of the other close session items the law suit or the volunteer positions okay then I'd like to uh seeing no other public comment please make these comments in Open Session B8 the board is going to recess the close session we'll be back at 6:30 thank you CL session has been extended to 640 thank you okay good evening and happy New Year welcome to the Open session of the regularly scheduled January 8th 2025 meeting of the West Contra Casta Unified School District School Board the board is returning from closed session and I am calling Open Session to order at 6:40 p.m. to access translation in Zoom please click on the globe icon at the bottom of the screen if you are

011here in the auditorium and need translation you may pick up a headset in the back corner of the auditorium in a few minutes we will be begin item B8 the public comment item members of the public are invited to speak to the board on any matter that is not otherwise on the agenda but is within the subject matter jurisdiction of the West contracosta Unified School District please prepare now for public comment if you are here in the auditorium and you'd like to make public comment please fill out and submit a wccusd public comment card you can find them on the table in the entryway and if if you are participating via Zoom please raise your hand in the Zoom app prior to the beginning of this item on the agenda if you're participating by phone

012press star n after your comment card has been turned in cards are placed in the order received and we call on speakers one at a time alternating between a public comment here in Deon and one on Zoom public comment generally lasts for 1 hour the time allowed to each speaker is 2 minutes in the meantime we're moving on with the rest of our opening procedures B2 Pledge of Allegiance if you are able or willing please rise I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and just jce for all item B3 land labor and body acknowledgement land acknowledgement we recognize that we are presently on the lands of the chuchen morma kin alone peoples and acknowledge them

013as the first inhabitants of the land we currently occupy labor and body recognition acknowledgement I acknowledge that the burden of environmental exploitation and systemic Injustice falls upon the labor of black and brown bodies in the building of our country and its institutions I remember that black and brown people were born and died working this land against their will for Generations I also acknowledge the continued contribution of the labor of survivors over the centuries to today of all immigrant labor including voluntary involuntary trafficked forced and undoc undocumented peoples in the building of what we refer to as the United States author Dr Michelle Rogers art B4 West contracosta Unified School District School Board anti-racism statement the West Contra kasus School District Board of Education is committed to the work of anti-racism a conscious and active effort

014to identify Challenge and correct racial inequities in the systems and institutions within our schools and Community racism explicit or implicit stands in direct conflict to the fundamental principles of wccusd education to carry wccusd education into the future we recognize that we must continually renew and reflect on the roots of racism and develop new ideas to meet the times unjust ideas and policies and the racial inequity they produce have shaped us our schools and our society we strive to uncover unconscious biases and practice anti-racism as individuals and as board members we challenge ourselves to persist through the discomfort necessary for growth in learning to deepen our listening and our examination of racism and oppression and to develop a strong understanding of how our personal experiences and feelings fit into a larger picture of continual oppression each

015member of our school board individually and collectively is responsible for creating and nurturing an anti-racist learning environment where each student staff member and Community partner is a respected and valued member of the wccusd community we are uniquely positioned in it is our responsibility to identify and dismantle racist ideas and inequal policies in ourselves and across the district therefore we commit to supporting anti-racist policies programs and practices for our children's education and wellbeing while building strong and inclusive School communities we commit to holding each board member accountable towards these goals and moving the work of anti-racism forward we also commit to holding West contracosta Unified School District staff students and Community to living these standards of anti-racism in our schools board approved March 20th 2024 B5 roll call Dr Moses would you please take roll thank

016you trusty Smith folds good evening everyone present trusty Gonzalez Hoy good evening president trusty Hernandez good evening pres president reckler good evening presid clerk andana good evening presid student trustee Wilson pres and student trustee espanosa pres roll call is complete thank you B6 report ratification of closed session Dr Moses I believe this is your item thank you president reckler regarding agenda item A2 a2.1 conference with legal council the board voted to authorize legal councel to one file a petition of RIT of ciari with in the Jane do amm versus wccusd m and the United States Supreme Court and take any other actions necessary to perfect make that filing and to if necessary exhaust a pellet review at all levels state and federal in the DH versus wccusd matter the vote was unanimous thank you B7

017public AC apology this is my item before we begin public comment I want to apologize to Mr Don go at the December 18 2024 meeting Mr G's public comment was disrupted by audience discontent and he left the podium before completing his statement he also reports that foul language was used and inappropriate remarks were made to him in the meeting space such actions are unacceptable public comment is meant for civil respectful dialogue where diverse viewpoints can be made without interruption or intimidation and it's the chair's job to protect those rights unfortunately I did not ensure Mr G's rights were protected and I apologize I am hearing impaired and the Acoustics in this room along with the sound system issues at the December 18th meeting further impacted my ability to hear and respond appropriately we must address

018this incident and use it for positive change going forward the following will be implemented first the introduction to public comment is up dated to reflect new audience expectations you'll hear this tonight second if any anyone on the Das up here all of us since it's a disruption they may call for a point of privilege to address conditions that affect the meeting noise disturbance of the meeting or the ab inability to hear all qualify as points of privilege if a disturbance is noted on the floor by cabinet or staff the word will be passed to the superintendent who will call for a point of privilege I'll pause the meeting to address it to get my attention it's perfectly acceptable to raise a hand or wave at me or even to lightly touch me lastly we're working

019to improve the sound and Acoustics of these meetings Dr Moses Clerk andana and I met on December 20th 2024 and we ask that options for improvement be ser surfaced expeditiously and we'll bring those forward for discussion with this body soon so Mr degney please accept my sincere apology for this event and I intend to see that it serves as a catalyst for improvement I request this statement in its entirety be included in this meeting minutes we8 we're moving on to public comment members of the public are invited to speak to the board on any matter that is not otherwise on the agenda but is within the subject matter jurisdiction of the West contracosta Unified School District public comment will last approximately 1 hour the time allotted to each speaker is 2 minutes should additional speakers

020remain at the conclusion of 1 hour public comment may be extended the time allotted to per speaker beyond the first hour is generally 1 minute individuals wishing to speak please submit a w ccusd public comment card or if participating by Zoom individuals will need to raise their hand in the Zoom app prior to the beginning of this item on the agenda if you are calling in by phone press star9 speaking time shall not be transferred from one person to another and there is no substitution of speakers speakers can also make public comment again for each discussion and action item on the agenda after staff presentations the public will have 10 minutes per item and one minute per speaker the same protocols were cited above apply the public pment period is a safe space where diverse

021viewpoints may be expressed SI without interruption or intimidation please listen attentively to each speaker's comment and respect their time at the podium as if it was your own be open to a different point of view if one is offered due to the brown act board members cannot discuss items that are not on the agenda and do not usually respond to items presented in public comment and with that is there any public comment yes our first public comment is Mary lton president reer and members of the school board my name is Mary Lon and I'm currently employed as an instructional support coach and Reading Coach with the office of English learner multilingual achievement this is my 21st year in this District while you are charged with and elected to make difficult decisions for all of our

022students we remind you that you hold an even greater responsibility to protect our most vulnerable students this includes Foster youth lowincome students and English language Learners who alone comprise a third of this District's student body by voting to reassign District coaches and in particular pulling English learner coaches from their positions you are directly removing much needed supports for English Learners across the district's more than 50 schools but especially in schools with high concentrations of English Learners El coaches helped build the capacity of Administrators and teachers to create assets-based learning environments and provide differentiated targeted and Equitable e programming instruction and assessment for this incredibly diverse group of students and the over overloop subgroups of students they represent including almost 2,000 newcomer English learners 1, 1600 long-term English Learners 1,200 students in elementary school who are

023at risk of becoming long-term English Learners and almost 1500 dually identified students special ed and English learner these coaches work in order to improve English learner students language development and academic achievement an ultimate goal of reclassification thank you our next public comment is Tracy please unmute yourself yes yes hi my name is Tracy lrer I am a um prep teacher within the district and um this is my almost fifth year sixth year of being reassigned um in the middle of the year at the beginning of the year it just seems to keep changing that whenever they don't have um enough teachers oh well you're Expendable we're just going to move you and reassign you um without the thought of I have nine teachers that I am supporting which is um over two two schools and

024now they are not getting their science curriculum um because of the the reassignment um we are losing prep teachers rapidly and cannot hire new ones because of the this continual um reassignment that we keep getting every year getting disruptive it's not easy to close down a classroom it's not easy to um open up a new classroom and it is very timec consuming and we don't have enough time to do it um the other thing I just want to say is I was very upset that we had to hear from utr about the district's decision and that they sent out letters to the community and staff before they even informed us about the reassignment and also too they did not inform you so I just want to make it very clear that as I appreciate what

025they're doing trying to fill classrooms there's got to be other ways and I also think they need to respect us as prep teachers that we are classroom teachers thank you our next public common is Calvin W Walters good evening members of the board uh I'm Calvin Walters I am the math department chair at Richmond High I also run our was uh accreditation process uh I'm a TTL among other things um and I'm here tonight to talk about the impact that these described changes would have at Richmond specifically uh we have been working extremely hard in our math department to make sure we have trained talented committed teachers in place we have two long-term Subs who are at risk of being reassigned and they are people who have been running these classrooms effectively since the beginning

026of the year and now you could apparently somebody can just randomly pull them out and who knows who's going to go into those classrooms so this is really going to be a disservice to our students uh we have effective classroom teachers why are we messing with this we also have as Richmond High we're the we have the single largest Title One budget in the school in the district and to take the person who is singlehandedly responsible for managing that budget all of the uh contract ago with it all of the teacher reimbursements that happen all of our purchasing that happens for us as teachers the person that really makes our school really run efficiently she's almost like our chief of staff um we're talking about taking her out of that role Richman High is working

027smoothly as it is please do not allow these changes to go through because it will cause damage and I think one of their roles that you have to take into account is that no harm should be done in these changes har will be done thank you com third grade parent please unmute yourself please unmute yourself next B comment is Shelley Wharton please unmute yourself hello everyone my name is Shelley Warton excuse me um I'm an English teacher at Richmond High and I'm similarly to my colleagues here in support of um our two long-term subs and Miss par um they keep our school running Miss par does specifically and our two math Subs long term Subs are experienced teachers um one is a math major who has passed the edtpa and yesterday received notice from the

028CTC that she has her preliminary credential um excuse me I need water she emailed HR today um so they just need to check in and get that passed over um so in to remove these respected and effective subs from from their classrooms would be extremely disruptive to hundreds of math students um at Richmond High and as well I want to talk about para a lot um she has been one of the most welcoming people on campus at Richmond High she runs everything um she leads our leadership well one of the people who leads our leadership um class and many events on campus um she keeps our school running and we need her um so please do not remove her and reassign her um yeah I'll just name some other things that she does since I

029have some time um she's an on call support to our campus security team she works on the budget as previously mentioned um she purchases supplies does she's a coach for new teachers she supports on study trips and reimbursements um she was previously a math teacher and so she does on jand math tutoring when needed um and as I mentioned just handles many special projects we cannot afford to lose her so please please do not reassign our two long-term math Subs at Richmond High and Miss par um thank you so much for your time and I hope you have a great evening our next public coming is Kathy Baker members of the board my name name is Kathy Baker I am a second grade teacher at Perry's Elementary and Elementary director for United teachers of Richmond

030it's a black woman whose ancestors this country was built on the backs of I hold the board personally accountable for upholding anti-racist practices by not attempting to repair the systemic issues of vacancies on the backs of our black and brown students here to support two of our coaches at our site and two of our long-term sub um substitutes one of them who will be speaking to you in just a moment but I'm also here speaking on behalf of my 20 students that I had to leave two years ago because this problem curred back then and it has not been repaired thank you for the opportunity to speak tonight I here on behalf of students families and Educators who have been affected by this decision to decision to wait until January to address known teacher vacancies

031I'm shaking because I'm so nervous and so upset um known teacher vacancies through involuntary transfers four months into the school year this delay in the subsequent midyear reshuffling of teachers will disrup learning environments and strained relationships that are critical to Student Success imagine being a student who has finally built trust and rapport with the substitute after weeks of instability only to have them suddenly replaced the bonds of trust between students and educators are not simply transactional they are built through consistency empathy and time research shows that strong teacher student relationships are foundational to academic success please conclude your comment our next public common is sha Avon please unmute yourself good evening school board members on behalf of Teamsters Local a56 we would like to extend a warm welcome to each of you as you step

032into your new roles on the WCC USD School Board we are excited to begin this journey of collaboration mutual respect and share commitment to the betterment of our student staff and Community as your as the teamsters Representatives we firmly believe that working together with the school board is a key creating a positive effective and supportive learning environment we recognize that you have been entrusted with a great responsibility and will like to for and will like forward to partnering and looking forward to partnering with you to assure that our school schools continue to thrive we we know that the work ahead will require thoughtful decisions careful consideration and Collective dedication to our students and St sta we are confident that together we will create a a a school environment where all students staff and families will

033feel valued again congratulations on your new positions and thank you for your service to the district we are looking forward to building a productive and positive relationship with you hopefully the school board will update their website so I will be able to um invite you to have a meet and greet with Teamsters local a56 um and the pre and our Representatives which is Miguel Veronica and Edward and myself sha Von thank you and have a good day good evening public good evening my name is brn Evans I'm a second grade teacher and one of the utr Union Representatives at Murphy Elementary School this year I'm participating in a grant funded literacy lessons program run by Benjamin Le uh through the program we locate struggling readers many of whom are English language Learners to provide them

034with tutoring and intervention support every day for an hour and a half each day the positive impact that this has had on our Scholars our family our Educators our communities at our school and schools across the district is Monumental the impact that this is out on my own teaching practices as a fourth year teacher is immeasurable Benjamin Le is one of many individuals who are being ousted from their current roles to fill these vacancies to fill vacant positions many of which have been open and vacant from the beginning of the school year with literacy coaches with specialist and anyone with a credential is irresponsible and misguided I urge you to consider putting our students families Educators and communities first thank you Le shakon please unmute yourself please unmute yourself hello yes we can hear you

035all right thank you hi good evening um my name is Luis chakon I'm calling this evening really wearing multiple hats for different roles I play um I'm a Community member I'm a Richmond High alumni class of 2006 um I have a kids at in this District um I'm currently assistant principal at Richmond High Todd at Richmond High I have family and friends who choose to send their their students um to Richmond High School so it's just a lot of different responsibilities um that come from being connected to Richmond High and being connected in the community and just the changes that are being considered is really demoralizing to to put it lightly especially at this point in the year to consider taking teachers out of our classrooms to consider removing somebody like Miss Elizabeth adgo AKA

036para from her position really the the heart of our school what holds our school together and I get emotional just thinking about it not just because of the human beings that will be affected the adults I mean but the students we talk about this District being anti-racist and just need I remind you that any financial decisions any budget documents they are moral documents so we are making a choice to in the middle of the school year remove individuals that our students have learned to trust that adults around them have learned to trust individuals who give it their all every day talking about the Special Olympics at Miss par she was here at 7 in the morning to help out put up signs while then she has to go and do her usual job on top

037of the other jobs that she just takes on and just helps keep everything moving I really hope you you look at this decision closely and really think about the impact the real life impact that this is going to have on our community and really prove yourselves to truly be an anti-racist District thank you our next public commment is Valerie Simson good evening board members my name is Valerie Swinson and I am a long-term sub at Perry's Elementary I am a fully credentialed teacher I have a master's degree I taught for 37 years I taught in New Jersey and then I moved to California and I talked in the Fontana Unified School District for 17 years I uh taught in the V for 12 years before I retired in 2013 and I have never worked in

038a district that was so insensitive toward their teachers and their children so as to implement the removal of teachers from classrooms after almost 100 days 100 days of growing to know these children 100 days of building relationships Community Family and love and it's just wrong comm's iPhone please unmute yourself next for communist Jessica please unmute yourself hello can you hear me yes we can okay thank you my name is Jessica Herbert I am a parent um in the district I also graduated from The District in 2004 um I'm coming to you tonight to ask that you reconsider budget cuts to the IB Program um specifically the program at penol Valley High School my daughter is a senior in the IV program program and um she has been learning and growing tremendously throughout the last two

039years um and over half of the Juniors and seniors at penol Valley High School are enrolled in the IB Program um the program is valuable to students um because it allows them to engage in higher levels of learning um and to learn from a more Global Perspective and It prepares them for college um It prepares them for the rigor of college courses and they have the opportunity to graduate with 30 credits um 30 college credits that are accepted by most colleges and universities I'm looking forward to my sophomore participating in the program uh next year he has been without out a permanent English language teacher for the last two years of high school so I'm looking forward to him being able to receive some language instruction next year again I am just coming as a

040parent and a fellow um alumni tonight and ask that you reconsider cuts to the IB program thank you our next public comment is Cory Johnson Cory Johnson next public communist Elizabeth Hara Ado good evening I am Elizabeth s Diego also known as par I am the PA at Richmond High and at dianza high school when I was growing up my father said to me whatever your job you do do it well that is what I believe I do and that is what I believe everyone speaking on my behalf tonight will tell you if you assign me back to the classroom I will do my best to teach 180 students but if you leave me where I am I will have the privilege of enhancing the high school experience of 2300 students 160 staff and seven

041admin that I support and interact with daily I do all the procurement for both richm and deanza I handle all the community engagement uploads and tracking I handle SS agendas minutes budgets and contracts I manage spsa monitoring and support budget planning along with supporting all the other departments on campus I understand the need to fill vacancies but filling those holes will leave a vacancy that will not be filled I was one of 40 adults being reassigned but that number is now one out of 15 how were us 15 deemed as not important enough to stay where we are the jobs that we do enhance student experiences and cannot be just seen on a PCN report my job is paid 100% out of SSC site funds at both sites members of the SSC voted unanimously to

042have me continue to the support work I do at both Richmond and deanza at a minimum let me finish the commit ments to the students the staff the admin the contractors and the communities that I have started this year I ask you not to send me away from my PA position at both Richmond High and deanza and let me finish the year thank you our next public commment is re Rita sabalos please unmute yourself hi thank thank you um I'm Rita and I'm a mom for uh sophomore in pinol Valley High and I would like you to please consider not taking away the IB Program um I got a my daughter got a transfer for this school exclusively for for the IB and I would love to for her and the rest of the students

043to get a chance to complete the program um it is just two schools in the whole um you know in the whole the cities that are nearby it's just Berkeley High and that's they have almost 4,000 students that I appreciate about pinol Valley High that they're um less students and the school is really good and mostly about the IB program so please consider don't take it away our next public comment is Alejandra Baran good evening members my name is Alejandra a teacher at Richmond High School I'm here to express my frustration regarding the decision to reassign Elizabeth V Diego or how we know her at at Richmond High School Miss Cara as a dedicated educator and colleague I can confidently say that this decision to is incredibly unfair and in a disservice to both the

044staff and students at Richmond High School in her current position Miss par serves approximately 70 staff and 1,200 students may I say this is only at Richmond High School if we move her to a classroom she will only serve 180 students which to me that would be a significant loss she would she has proven herself to be an essential resource and it is hard to imagine how this decision could possibly benefit anyone involved additionally Miss par has been an outstanding co- teer for leadership at Richmond High School her work in this area has contributed to the success and growth of our students and removing her from this position would break something that is absolutely not broken she has cultivated a positive productive environment that is integral to the development of our student leaders and disrupting

045this Dynamic would only harm the school's overall progress I urge you all to reconsider this decision and take into account the immeasurable value Miss par brings to our school her contribution goes far beyond the classroom and her current role is crucial crucial excuse me to the well-being of both students and staff our district always talks about equality and right now that's not what it is thank you our next favorite common is Rodney Mo Brown please unmute yourself can you hear me yes we can i' like to say good evening board this is Rodney Al Mo Brown the community advocate here in the city of Richmond California there's an old saying when I is replaced with we even illness becomes Wellness I Echo the same Sentiments of everyone who has spoken before me and I want

046to put this in you all lap imagine children who will have to go through this severe situation not seeing the teacher whom they seen when school began in August here we are five months until the school year and transition begins to happen I want you to think about the psychological approach that these children will have I want you to also think about the climate in which these students are at at these particular schools I was visiting King Grant and deanza high school respectively this past week and I've noticed the morale of certain teachers who are in this particular position I didn't speak with anyone but I knew exactly what it was I'm urging each one of you that are on the Board of Trustees to make a significant significant choice this evening and think about

047the children think about the large impact the looming impact and I also want you to consider the families of these children think about it make sure that you make a conscious choice tonight because again your legacy hangs in the balance I'd like to say good evening everyone have a blessed night Shalom h public speakers IA santian good evening WR us Onan literacy coach at Grant I here to express my deep concern regarding the reassignment of myself and Ben who RS to literacy program as a classroom teacher and now literacy college at Grant have seen firsthand the transformative impact this program has had on both students and staff the grows that have witnessed in our students both academically and socially is something that cannot be easily replicated grad Elementary serves the largest number of El's and

048newcomers in our district with a total enrollment of 555 students many of the students face significant barriers to academic success and the support you provided by this literacy program is crucial in helping them overcome those challenges the program has provided consistent targeted support that has allowed our students to improve their literacy skills skills at an incredible rate every week we seen students at events and reading levels become more confident writers and develop stronger over communication skills there these are not just academic gains they are milestones in competence identity and belonging as part of the Staffing Solution I will be taking over a class when where the teacher is a credential student this adds additional pressure to an already Str situation as we work to Ure the best possible learning experience for our students while I

049am committed to supporting my colleagues and the student the law of this program would be create further challenges for us to as we balance our responsibilities and aim to medic academic needs of all our students especially our e and newcomers the proposed solution to address the Staffing ches through cuts to this vital program is definitely concerning while we understand the need to address the Staffing challenges I urge you to consider the long-term consequences and think of other Solutions thank you for your time next for communist Mark please unmute yourself good evening uh president reckler uh clerk inana trusty Hernandez Gonzalez Hoy and trusty Smith folds Mark Mitchell executive director of United teachers of Richmond I just want to point out to the board because I don't believe you know what's happened in this regard exactly

050um the day that Dr Hurst left the building within 12 hours we were informed of the unilateral decision of the District staff to involuntarily transfer about 40 Educators from their positions many of these same Educators had already been involuntarily transferred at the beginning of the school year in August and September and had just recently returned to their permanent positions um just a few weeks earlier um we were we asked immediately what is the contractual or legal basis for this uh decision we were told unequivocally by uh District administrators Ed code 3535 subsection e we looked at that section it said that these transfers could be made only with approval of the Board of Education we assumed that this matter would be on the board agenda for your last meeting in December when it was not

051and it was not discussed we asked board members did you know about this have you heard about this and we learned that no the District staff had not informed the board at all of this drastic move destabilizing our schools destabilizing the education of hundreds if not thousands of students please follow the law please make sure that any kind of move like this is voted on by you with all the information you need to make a good decision and please do what your District administrators are not doing and put students first let's stabilize the educational experience of our students and make West Contra Costa a destination district for our Region's most talented Educators let's not run them off like we've been doing year after year thank you our next public with K is Benjamin Le good

052evening I'm Benjamin Le and it's been my honor to lead the language and literacy lessons Institute in this district for the past two years you should have some information on the program as well as a petition with comments and testimonials from teachers parents and community members at its core this program is about Equity it accelerates the progress of multilingual Learners many from Title One schools helping to close the opportunity Gap in Reading Writing and language but literacy lessons is more than just academic growth and it transforms lives one student I worked with was barely speaking when he entered the program by the end of 20 weeks he marched into the principal's office and read alow a book he'd written about hippos instead of five adults including the principal and vice principal he left the program

053not only reading and writing at grade level but also confident engaged and ready to lead his own learning he was in first grade this is what we mean by Equity it's not not just about scores it's about giving students who've been shut out of Education the tools to their own identities as Scholars and lifelong Learners this program also builds teacher expertise Educators aren't just teaching literacy they're learning how to Foster critical thinking student-driven learning and deep engagement across all subjects these shifts are what will truly lead to equity for all students for me this work is a calling I took this job because I was called to create change in education for students Beyond just my own classroom I could make a difference for the 21 students in the classroom to which I'm intended to

054be reassigned but the impact of this program reaches far beyond 21 students it touches the 74 students receiving tutoring 475 students in classrooms across the district and the 21 teachers I'm training who will shape the future for hundreds more I ask you to support the language and literacy lessons Institute so that we can continue moving West Contra Costa closer to its goal of equity for multilingual students each of you has and next common is Erica please unmute yourself please unmute yourself hello good evening I wanted to thank everybody for speaking out tonight and thank you to the interum superintendent and distinguished board members I am a parent and former educator literacy Advocate and so much more this evening I am here to express my deep concern in the decision to take away Grant Elementary's literacy

055coach shout out to miss Anan and all these disruptive changes to our schools across the district Grant Elementary is currently at over 550 students Yes you heard me that's 550 students has a DL program DLI program and the highest number of English Learners and yuk cumber students of this District taking away our literacy coach will disrupt the progress of our Latino and African-American students it will disrupt the essential and positive team that works endlessly to make students Learning Journey a successful Journey my children and many others are happy and thriving at Grant Elementary please do not disrupt the success please do not make a struggle further please find another solution thank you so much for your time and dedication good evening I am complete our next public hon is Kate Gil Wiman good evening board

056my name is Kate lickman I'm a teacher on special assignment in the literacy Department here to speak on the subject of involuntary transfers if I am reassigned the literacy Department of West contracosta Unified School District will be reduced to a staff of one my role has been to coordinate and facilitate literacy professional development and coaching for transitional kindergarten through 12 gr teachers across all of our schools this work will be greatly effective this department is reduced to one person I respectfully thank you for your consideration and your time next com Ison Harrison please unmute yourself good evening board how are you this evening I have a couple of comments I would like to talk about um the Richmond High Miss par Miss parar Elizabeth oh my God you guys have to keep her um she

057always engaged with the African-American parents and making sure that APAC was involved in our rebuild and everything that was done there she made sure Equity was at Richmond High this would be a huge disservice for her to not be able to be there you guys cannot do this in peace this will not happen in peace um I will be having a child go back to Richmond High and this is not what I'm looking for this district has made great gains with Richmond High including all their students and for her to leave I we will be going backwards so please do not um do what you got to do so she's not removed and with stge I I really hope that you all put stge as a standing report on the board agenda on the rebuild

058to make sure that the community and parents are aware of what's going on at all times and this does not get pushed to the back of the line as it has in the past so please make sure that we do some respectful things to ensure that we have up on stti and um the IB program at Peno I love it I appreciate it but not taking it from our most needest students please find another way to fund the IB Program because what I seen it was coming out of our lcap funding and that is not fair for our most need of students to have that funding come out when the students that participate in IB are not mostly qualified for that services so please find another way to fund that very valuable program and it's

059much needed in our district because like the last speaker said that we don't have we're a unique district with that program so that's all for this evening and I'm complete thank you our next public commment is Arisha green good evening members of the board I am a teacher at Richmond High School and I would like to First remind you all that it's not just your job to make sure that operations happen successfully now but also to create a platform that safeguards the future of our district and impacts the future um and you know how things go for our students at richm high we have such a large population we have a ton of fantastic programs and it takes a lot of effort to keep all of those pieces running smoothly collaborating with each other navigating

060around each other and it's not um it's an effort that involves of our teachers our longterm Subs the scows which we've recently lost we have long-term Subs who are going to be impacted by these reassignments potentially our long-term Subs they didn't come in acting like Subs they came in they have fostered relationships with our students they care about the quality of service that they offer and their names come up when we when I hear my students talking about which teachers they trust which teachers impact them they refer to our long-term Subs at Richman High we have an Internationals Academy those students come from a variety of backgrounds and circumstances as do students not in the Internationals Academy and I love to watch when a new student comes in they kind of rally around them and

061they tell them oh this teacher will help you with this this is the cool person this is who you go to for this and that and people who are on this reassignment list are the teachers who are impacting our students F lastly Miss para she keeps our school running it is a challenge to figure out who to go to within the district when we have to collaborate with different departments she knows she is effective and she is not selective in who she helps and she gets things done we need that please reconsider this this would be a disservice to our students we start next public comment is Don gney I'm grateful for the Pres reers a knowledgement and words of remorse for the angry and hateful actions taken against me when I tried to speak

062at the board meeting of December 18th I'm also appreciative of the comments emailed to me by truste Smith Falls sadly almost as soon as the agenda was posted with President recker's comments comments from members of the public started appearing claiming that this was just another white person standing up for another white person once again the district allowed things to become racist for those that may not have seen what happened or could understand what was being said either by the zoom video or live and in person after proclaiming my support for more than 15 years for a total rebuild of Siege Elementary I tried to suggest that while the district was shut down for the holidays that the board hold off on voting on a plan for three weeks while the bond oversight committee the media

063the two brand spanking new trustees and the public might have an opportunity to review this brand new data and controversial plan speak amongst themselves and deliberate with the board of trust to SW sworn to represent all 268,000 residents of West County within four seconds of me starting to speak on this idea the crown behind me vehemently booed me used vile vulgarities calling me a racist with suggestions of carnal activities I had with my mother and actually threatening me I no longer felt safe here in this room after I packed up my gear and tried to leave the building two from this crowd followed me outside cursing me some more calling me a racist and threatening me keep in mind that we had one District employee several months back that at one of these private public

064meetings tell the crowd that he wasn't afraid of me he could whoop my behind except he used a more vulgar term for it and all the while while this is happening no one from the board staff for security did anything to put a stop to this or protect me just a few moments ago we all heard you proudly boast of the district's anti-racism policies how can we expect these Hollow words to make a difference on our campuses when here in your own house no one was willing to step forward to make a difference that night as the saying goes you can talk the talk but can you walk the walk and we still have the question is left unanswered about exact the next public comment is Ralph Bedwell please unmute yourself please unmute yourself next

065public com Kenny Moore good evening everybody good evening board my name is Kenny Moore I am the Community Schools director at Richmond High School um I just wanted to uh reest first of all express my frustration about the reassignment um obviously everybody's working hard at their sites to create an ideal environment for our students to thrive in I know strategizing becomes really tricky however in this situation it kind of feels like a little bit with Robin Peter to pay Paul um I know we're trying to feel in other holes but we're also creating major voids at the same time and um we have long-term Subs that have like has already been mentioned significant relationships and significant impacts not only on the students but the rest of the community but also speaking up for Miss Elizabeth

066Argo aka Miss par um and specifically from the community schools perspective I know you all multiple times have already heard a long list about the way she supporting Richmond High but she has also been really essential in our community schools efforts everything from uh supporting with our collaborative leadership teams recruiting facilitating um participating on different teams helping us organized she's been a a major part of um supporting and resourcing our parent and family engagement events you all know at the high school level how little parents can be involved at times um don't want toble but I just really W to implore implore you all to reconsider your strategy um we don't want to create a bigger void by addressing other voids uh you know the people that we have on campus we we've become community

067together we work really hard together and um this is a removal that would have significant Ripple effects please reconsider thank you Comm is Calvin miles not so tall here good evening board members District administrators my name is Calvin miles I'm a teacher at deza high school I'm a parent I'm a district graduate and with respect to the challenging task the district has and addressing teacher vacancies I would like to offer that move to reassign Miss paa was obviously not exactly the result of research and thoughtful deliberation as you can tell by the contingent behind me the impact Miss par has on both Richmond High and dianza is phenomenal and impressive along what you've heard about her contributions to Richmond High School Miss Paul has also contributed greatly to deanza particularly with regards to fiscal stability

068administrative guidance School community and climate student support and professional mentorship I'm one of the representatives of the student I mean the School site Council SSC and we have unanimously agreed to proove funding for her position and I'll tell you now I heard that from someone else over there that she doesn't come cheap but she all that and then some this should serve as a testament to our determination as a site counsel that such an investment would be essential to the continued outstanding outcomes that she's provided for us at deanza now I'm sure there are others who have been negatively negatively affected by this process and I hope you can find a better way to address this issue but as far as this particular instance but as far as moving Miss par away from Richmond High

069School our next public comment is Rich seber just a little taller good evening board members uh intern superintendent my name is Rich seber I am an instructional coach with English learner multilingual achievement for the second time in a year I stand here asking you to reverse the actions of District Management in their decisions to eliminate supports for our most most vulnerable students in our highest need schools if the decision to reassign some of the most knowledgeable and valued professionals to classrooms is approved it would disproportionately affect the schools with the highest concentrations of atrisk students including students of color in fact predominantly so how do you reconcile this with the district's anti-racist stance how do you reconcile this with your commitment to equity how can you reconcile this with your commitment to student achievement in

070literacy mathematics and language development how does this decision demonstrate leadership and vision you know this isn't a solution to the teacher shortage it's already been exposed for the flaws in its execution the list of re assignments has already been reduced to such an extent that it will have almost no impact on teacher Staffing but it will have a detrimental impact on teacher support School functioning and student learning thank you public comment isape mik next for is Jenny s hi everybody I'm Jenny Ernst I am a math coach at Perry's Elementary along with K Kelly fimas who was a Ela coach there as well um I have a lot of respect for what you do as board members and I have a tremendous amount of respect for all of us Educators your Educators too we're all

071in the same boat we all care for students we all love students that's why we're here I was hired two months ago two months ago I answered an ad and Ed join for a math intervention coach this is exactly what I've been trained to do I was a classro teacher for 26 years I've been a curriculum coordinator which is exactly where I wanted to land two months later I get a notice about reassignment and so my worry and possibly a worry as board members is what this mess Mage sends kind of out there in terms of wanting to work at this District um just that I went in I onboarded I'm excited and now I don't really know where where things are going I just wanted to give that perspective um as well um so

072that's about it for my perspective and I just again I really appreciate what we're all doing here and I do want us to be careful of the reputation of this great District thanks our next public comment is Jessica Vasquez my name is Jessica Vasquez mam I teach at Ford at Title One School I've been teaching in the district for 21 plus years and I'm one of the literacy lesson graduates from last year's cohort the professional development that I've received through the program is some of the most valuable training I've ever had it's made me a better teacher for all of my students not just the ones I've tutored this reassignment disaster that might affect Ben lay or TSA who's not even paid with District funds um this might make our Intervention Program a very invaluable

073Intervention Program likely will discontin knew it very likely which we don't want to happen we don't have enough intervention as it is please Practice What You preached and help us increase Equity by offering much needed intervention to our students please do not return the money to the state that was supposed to be allocated toward supporting e students this reassignment disaster is no way to retain quality teachers it's disrespectful to our hardworking loyal District Educators thank you next public communist Andre rookie how's it going I'm gonna try and keep this as focused as I can about par because I could talk to you guys about a lot of stuff um many of you know I I teach at Richmond High School I run the music department there I built the music department there from nothing um

074and it couldn't it could not have happened without par because to navigate the systems and the barriers that have put in place by District staff at almost every single turn I can't do it bro because I got to teach kids so while you are in an office Eric condition doing whatever you doing that's the person who makes it happen for the kids and I know that's I hate to seem disrespectful to you I do but when I get calls two days before an event from this District that you must have had on a calendar be like can you please play at this after two nights of 14-hour days providing concerts for hundreds of children in Richmond and San Pablo that I then have to go listen to our then Super inen and talk about anti-racism

075when they take our community outreach workers away from a school that's 40% English Learners you call them and talk to their parents and explain the complexities of what's going on we are we are burdened with the task of bringing these families into our country and I don't think you fully understand the weight of that we can't do it without people like par when I'm having a hard day which is a lot because it it is and they all know because I'm very vocal and so is para but para has a little bit of tact and she knows how to navigate the systems I can't do what I do without par I cried when I found out par was getting taken away from us and I get that you guys got to do whatever but there

076are other Solutions stops coming up here talking about being anti-racist you got rid of the Internationals Academy for the kids who just got to the country you take away School community outreach workers you just pull adults from our campus is getting unsafe and next public comment is Lawrence Madden oh I'm sorry can can I just interrupt for a point of order we're at the one hour mark how many comments approximately are remaining 17 comments REM board I would like to recommend that we continue with the next 17 comments at one minute a piece do I have yes trusty Smith FS extend public comment did did you said yes okay trusty how many speakers do we still have S okay trusty hernandz yes trusty esposa Jr trusty Wilson okay yes we'll continue on the clock thank

077you our next public communist Lauren smen mad I'm a multi subject science teacher at Richmond High and as a scientist if you want to find out how something works you take out the pieces that are working until it breaks and that's what you're doing and you got to stop because why would you want schools to grind to a halt when we've got it working we've got Math teachers who are teaching their students when they haven't had Math teachers for years and bringing them back up to grade level giving them the skills that they need after school we've got par who's running this school behind the scenes but everybody knows she's doing because she's in everybody's pot everybody is benefited by missar and our students are greatly benefited by our scows and our teachers that are

078here even if they're long-term Subs we're making it work for the students and you're trying to figure out what's making this school work by taking it away from us and breaking it you got to stop com is assani Royal Isani Roy I am a student at diza high school I feel like if you guys been new which we all know everybody sitting behind me been new y'all know about budget cuz since the since Co how are y'all all of a sudden now oh well we don't have teachers so now we want to put them in other places why for what for instance last year I didn't have a mandarin teacher and now y'all want to all of a sudden put these teachers in different places these kids us as kids have good relationships with these

079people and y'all are wrong and y'all know that y'all do wrong for instance Miss par she's been to help me for any question that I need or any concern are y'all going to come down there to my school and come help me no y'all not y'all don't care about nobody but y yourself and y'all here for the dollar and we know that there if these people behind me leave we're all going down we say students is going with them and y'all going to be mad y'all not going to have no schools no funding no money and y'all going to wonder why we leaving this is the thing that we talk about y'all don't give us a fair opportunity and this is the problem you gave us one minute that's not fair our next public common

080is Sam Taylor hello I'm Sam Taylor I've worked at Richmond High School for about nine years now you've all heard about how important par is to our school so I won't belabor that point however did someone made a comment that she didn't come cheap I would argue that paying one person new job of five people is an excellent fiscal decision I would urge you to consider how damaging this poly considered and poly communicated plan is not only for the Richmond Community but in the future hiring needs of the district in order to make Public Schools more attractive to potential teachers it is important that they can trust decision makers at the district level to communicate with them to respect them and to not jerk them around I cannot currently in good conscious recommend that my

081friends apply to work here which is deeply frustrating because I'm proud of my school and I am proud of the work that we do only works when the community can move to support each other when we need each other teachers are required to be endlessly resilient but resilience is not infinite resilience requires support our next public communist hadasa deelo good evening here we meet again as you all may know my name is hadasha Dello I am ASB senior class president and president of the climate team at deza high school I am here on the behalf of Elizabeth adgo or as we know her as Miss par I am here to discuss the decision to cut someone from their position within just one day raises serious concerns about fairness transparency and the evaluation process while supporting

082clubs managing resources is essential it seems only one person is equipped to make budget cuts leaving room for questions about oversight and accountability who is making these evaluations and how are they determining which individuals out of a group of 40 are fulfilling their roles effectively for instance Miss par should be evaluated to understand the true scope of her contributions more than budget cuts are being implemented responsibilities are being stripped midy year without clear communication or input from those ected why are these decision why are the decisions that disrupt staff and operation our next public comment is jaria jaria youngen Sharia youngston a senior at deza high school and I'm speaking on behalf of Miss Para help we need help our school needs help Miss par has truly been a blessing to De High School's black

083student union ever since I formerly met her as our club's vice president this school year she goes above and beyond to ensure my club is taken care of and has the proper resources we need to be effective on our school campus she attends our school two times out of each week but the progress she helps us make is as though she never skips a beat she is truly incredible we're not here simply talking about a role we're talking about an amazing woman who is loved out our school and not only that but who plays a vital role here you may think you get it but I don't know if you do we're not the only school but deza cannot take another year of inconsistency or unexpected changes I've been here before unfortunately advocating for the

084misconstrued idea that the impactful staff's members within our institution can be replaced or moved around as pieces in a chess game but no one's realizing the damage caused by the pieces you're knocking down in the midst of it students and lives are in your hands schools and education are in your hands stability and growth are at your discretion most favorite comment is Alandra Herrera perz good evening members of the board I am alz student body president at Richmond High School and I am here to express my deep concern about the reassignment of Miss Elizabeth adgo par Miss Mara is not just a teacher she is the heart of Richmond High School her positivity and dedication inspires every student to grow believe in themselves and take on leadership roles personally she has gued Ed me through

085AP Calculus and college applications offering support that goes beyond academics her mentorship shaped me into a more confident and resilient individual to lose Miss paa would be a great loss to Richmond Heim I urge you to reconsider her reassignment her continued presence is essential for the success and growth of my peers thank you for your time and consideration most communist ktia San good evening my name is ktia saso I'm a fourth year math teacher at Richmond High and utr area 2 director I have been teaching full-time for years under emergency and long-term substitute certifications I graduated and joined West Contra Costa in Fall 2021 and stayed loyal despite the consequences the vacancy crisis impacted on me as a Richmond Community member and a quote unquote vacant teacher reassignment is a decision that disrespects the work

086that I and many qualified Educators do it does not prioritize teacher attention stability at our schools and instead creates harm by pushing valuable community members away the next we comment is Leslie good evening esteemed board thank you for hearing my comments my name is lesie brand I'm a science teacher at Richmond High School I'm here to also implore you to reconsider the detrimental um changes that you're trying to put in place which are extremely shortsighted and from a teacher perspective there's two main things one is it's just disruptive um which is really counter to the over overall goal of filling vacant teacher positions um so it's disruptive to the teachers as I've heard heard others say it's would cause um you know the decrease reputation for this district and it decreases the overall support for

087teachers which causes burnout so it in every way is counterproductive to the overall overall goal of retaining teachers thank you our next public comment is Beth castler um good evening Beth castler science teacher at Richmond High School I've been teaching in public schools around the bay for 22 years um I chose to come to Richmond High last year turning down significantly higher pay in other districts because I wanted to work in my community and teach in my community par was one of the first people I met at Richmond High and I knew to my I just said to myself like I want to work with this woman you you just have a sense after a while being an educator the people that make schools work and as everyone has said here I was exhausted coming

088here tonight like probably everyone in this room but when I look behind me this is Richmond High and this is I feel like I still made the right decision to come and work here but taking para out and then as many said the Ripple effect of Shifting all these other people is absolutely unacceptable we can't do it this our next public comment is Daisy shakon hello my name is dy Chon and I'm the education Justice manager at the rice Center I'm a product of this district and most importantly I'm a parent of a current student at do elementary school I'm here today because I'm concerned about the decision to reassign teachers like Miss McCarthy who's been at do since I was a student they were in the 90s teachers like Miss McCarthy are crucial to

089the education and social emotional growth of our students when my son started his educational Journey at do he didn't speak any English but with support from his teachers and Miss McCarthy he has continued to expand both in Spanish and English now in second grade he was recently uh qualified for reclassification but this is bigger than my son's educational goals this is about the district continuing the pattern of responding to problems rather than planning ahead to support their students teachers and Community because that's what this is a response not a solution our students are consistently burdened with the mismanagement of District resources our students will not only see this change as losing a teacher they're losing a member of the community and an adult Ally and Mentor we keep telling our students that we're moving towards

090being anti-racist our next public comment is Kim Chamberlain good evening I'm the student Information Systems supervisor for the school district I am also the SSA IAP chapter president I am here actually to to two roles really quickly one we have enrollment coming up on the 21st and I highly encourage everyone to start paying attention to what we have coming in and making sure that you are encouraging our students to come to our school district well in that case I'm also as a SSA president stating you are taking away student services one of them is our safety safety at our school sites we have Cuts coming up on the budget this evening and that is I know not definite yet but they are still conversations about safety safety is something that we all need to really

091pay attention to and our students need it and then I am going to say I'm supporting our teachers and our teachers are back here supporting our students and to have those students safely in the classroom where they feel secure is very important thank you next public common is Georgio centino different topic my apologies okay my name is Georgio centino I'm a former uh Richmond High School biology teacher current Hercules parent and I'm employed down the street the California Department of Public Health in their State fibrology uh laboratory I was born with ADHD and Central auditory processing disorder my diagnosis was rated as a severe impairment um mostly I work in a laboratory where my duties are in writing I have the difficulties following uh instructions verbal instructions my employer is not suited right now they

092they're strugg to figure out how to help folks who are on the um neurodiversity Spectrum uh those who have ADHD and related um uh disorders and disabilities so they my employer wants to do better in this area and so we're working together to start making something happened I said well we need to get some input from folks right down the street right here Richmond I want to hear we want to hear from the students and Par I'm aoid I'm sorry so his time I think cut out the mic at can I get a few seconds again just repeat that five seconds back on please are we ready okay okay so I'm gonna I'm gonna come back I'm gonna reach out to folks and you're uh and I want the the students here who and parents

093to help build uh put in place at the employ down the street at the laboratory uh you guys can be part of making an environment that's very inclusive to uh to the to all of us folks who are uh who struggle thank you and next comment is Karen Larson hello I'm Karen Larson I'm a par educator at Richmond High and I've been there since 2018 I'm also speaking in support of Miss par she supports both students and staff staff with things like budgets and money and and she acts as coaches for new teachers but probably more importantly is with the students in the leadership class she empowers students to create the events and activities that make their time in high school memorable things like rallies Spirit weeks and dances she supports both students and teachers

094by providing OnDemand math tutoring um her one of the overriding qualities she brings is her positivity and desire to build community not only is she on the climate committee but she's also on the Richmond High Sunshine committee which celebrates our Richmond High family raises morale and helps us build connections she if she is involuntarily transferred she may bump a teacher who's close to having full certification and who's already built strong relationships with their students please do not transfer her she's a critical person in a critical position our next po common is Kelly Cari good evening my name is Kelly KY and I'm a kindergarten teacher at Perry's K school I am speaking to express my concerns regarding the recent decision to reassign credential staff back into the classroom in the communication sent on December 11th

095it was stated that this decision was made after exhausting all available options however the specifics of those options have not been transparent can you please share with the public what steps have been taken to address this issue two years ago when there were numerous vacancies central office employees stepped into to fill these teaching positions perhaps the solution can be Revisited to ensure every student is taught by a highly qualified certificated teacher additionally have noticed that many of these reassignments are taking a staff away from our most underserved schools this raises concerns about equity and the persistent chances faced by these communities can you please address why these schools continue to Bear the brunt of such decisions I strongly urge you to engage in further discussions to implore all possible solutions that will allow these much

096needed Educators to remain in their current position our next public comment is Diego garciaa members of the board my name is Diego Garcia I'm here as um a teacher and also athletic director original high school I had a 25 minute speech reduced to two minutes and now one minute so what I'm going to do is I'm going to be silenced for a few seconds because I'm here in support of Elizabeth at Diego AK no as MPA and two other substitute teachers because I want you guys to know how it would feel like if we didn't have her there everyone already spoke and I don't want to seem redundant so let's just have a moment of silence again having all these people in support of missa is what com in practice is you as a public

097servant we ask you to do what is common sense thank you the next public communist Carla Gales Lima good evening board members I came tonight um to highlight uh this evening that I stand in disagreement with any actions that involve the removal reassignment of literacy coaches uh from schools and perhaps the termination of IB dual language immersion programs that will set the foundation for my children to be able to attain a seat and graduate from UC and Cal State schools why you might ask you see I am a UC Berkeley student graduate at Cal San Francisco State University graduate who was originally an English Learner in an underserved Public School uh system in Los Angeles I would later be busted to more affluent K through2 schools with literacy coaches honor courses and over 25 advanced

098placement courses in order to earn a seat at these Elite schools who have high expectations for their students in terms of literacy foundations in international World schooling to set to be able to read analyze and apply the caliber of academic material that these colleges and universities demand of their students I struggled while working and facing health challenges but I obtained two degrees only because and our last public comment is Paul scatter PA scin Scot that concludes public comment okay thank you very much thank you to everyone who gave public comment tonight we are now moving on to B9 standing reports I believe we have reports from United teachers of Richmond here in person and we have uh Asad online president Smith F I mean I'm so sorry president regular I apologize for that I'll have

099it um I was wondering if we could take a five minute recess did you say recess yes if we could take a f minute recess okay I'm good with that let's put uh 8:23 is the start time thank you the educational stability that is essential for Student Success literacy coaches ELD Specialists and other noncl classroom Educators play a vital role in supporting our most vulnerable students and new Educators learning our craft removing that midye creates unnecessary setbacks for students who rely on these relationss and supports to thrive across the district these reassignments risk doing undoing years of hard work and progress they do not address the root causes of our staffing challenges and instead create new problems for students in school communities Education Code 35035 subsection e explicitly requires board approval for reassignments it is

100a responsibility to ensure that these decisions are made not in arbitrary or capricious reasons and that they serve the best interest of students the district's current actions bypass this requirement undermining transparency and accountability that our community deserves we urge the board to place the proposed reassignments on the agenda for a formal discussion and vote to fulfill your statutory Duty reject short-term fixes like midyear reassignments that harm students and instead invest in Sustainable Solutions such as competitive salaries robust recruitment efforts and professional development support let's work to stabilize our schools for the long term stability is the Cornerstone of effective learning environments reassignments disrupt disability particularly for our most vulnerable students I urge the board to invest in long-term solutions that ensure consistency and continuity in our classrooms utr remains committed to collaboration with the district

101and the board we want to work together to create solutions that address Staffing challenges without sacrificing the stability and success of our students and communities I thank you again for your leadership on resolutions 24 25-54 and 2425 46 your commitment to equity and rebuilding is a foundation that we can all build on now let's extend that commitment by addressing the needs of stge Educators and students and ensuring that the proposed re assignments are handled transparently fairly and with a focus on what matters most our students thank you is as set mron Harrison please unmute yourself can you guys hear me yes we can okay thank you Happy New Year everyone um ASAT has been still dealing with a lot of the same issues and barriers and we're hoping that this new year but um continuous

102of this school year with a new board that we can get some of these issues resolv one of the main issues is that um we no longer um have a lant um o Christian was appointed to us by um trustee FS when she was the president and now we don't know if that's still going to happen um communicating with the District staff to get um information on activities that we have recommended put on a calendar and get feedback has been struggles this is not going to change educational for black students when we continue not to set up intentionally ways to engage the parents we have had the same group of small parents advocating for communication clear communication with this District so we can communicate with others and it still seems a challenge to be happening

103and we need support from the board to assign us in Lason another lant to work with the district so we can get some forward motion on parent engagement and involvement and give parents a clear pathway how to be involved with their children's academic outcome changing it the negative ones and and celebrating the positive ones and also sharing more positive our district is doing a lot of good work that is not recognized and black students don't have access to we need to work we want to work with you all so we can change that we want to work with you all so that our students are looked at like the rest of the students when we want academic success and parent engagement so we would like for the board to um give us a lant so

104to support us with that and also we've been having challenges with uh principles engaging the parents to start I've had calls for over three School sites where principles have not had their first APAC meeting and are not holding SSC meetings by law so these are barriers again from black parents being involved black parents want to be APAC leaders and principles are not holding the meetings I don't know what what solution we need to come up with but I thought we had come up with one but I just feel the board and the um cabinet and our Dr Moses if you could support principles with looking at how when you especially have parents that want to volunteer their time to organize um with with them and with other parents and they're not getting support from their

105site principles so can we get some more support around that and then another thing that we're really concerned about is how the data on our children and how the district is as a whole ensuring that our children there are programs and services that the parents and the students know about so that we can change and like also show the bright spots on the things that are working the information is not getting to us clearly the information is not getting to us in a timely manner for us to engage in the good things that you guys are doing and that you guys are hosting and then it's not very collaborative the way things are being planned in our district a lot of things are being planned without us and this is another student this is another

106big concern of ours but it's from the student perspective the use of the nword on our campus we read a lot how the equity policy but I feel what would be good instead of reading that policy is giving reports out on how we're making a difference with different committees with different clubs somebody needs to organize intentionally to make a difference about equity in our district and support students with not saying the n word because our children deserve to go to school in a safe welcoming environment and not feel threatened either so using that word by adults and other students needs to stop and we want some support and policies around that the use of the nword not happening in our district and that would be equ be equ Equitable for all students if we work

107on that and build on that and get some correct professional develop professional development and community support and student support around that and I think that's it and I'm complete for this evening thank you thank you to everybody who gave us standing report we're moving now to B10 agenda review and adoption does anybody have anything with the ex leaving out consent to adjust or review so I would like to propose that the discussion item on fiscal solvency immediately follows the superintendent report and I would like to propose that E4 four which is the cell phone usage policy becomes number one on the action items so that's my my motion would anybody like to second that I'll second is there any discussion or questions we'll go to a vote then trust student truste Wilson yes student truste

108espanosa Jr yes trusty Hernandez yes trusty Yana yes trusty smithf Smith F yes try gonzale yes and army yes thank you moving on now to b11 resolution 2425 d49 recognizing Fred kma today 2025 Dr Moses I believe this is your item thank you president recor to invite our cabinet member director relle Forest to acknowledge the resolutions thank you good evening board uh staff and Community now therefore be it resolved that the West contracosta Unified School District Board of Education salute the legacy of Fred Toya suburo cor matu and designate January 30th 2025 as spread T cor matu day thank you so much is there any public comment on this item there's no public comment great are there any questions from board [Music] members would anybody like to put a motion on the floor president I

109move that we approve resolution number 2425 d49 recognizing Fred D is January 30th 2025 a second I'll second is there any comments on this item seeing one will'll go to the vote trusty Wilson stent trusty Wilson yes student trusty Osa Jr yes trusty Hernandez yes truste Anana yes trusty Smith FS Smith F yes trusty Gonzalez yes and yes the motion passes unanimously item B12 resolution number 24255 Dr Martin Luther King Day of Service 2025 Dr roses I believe this is your item thank you president reckler I'd like to pass it over to director Forest to acknowledge this resolution as well thank you now therefore be it resolve that the Board of Education and the West contracosta Unified School District recognized Monday January 20th 2025 Dr Martin Luther King junor Day of Service and encourage all

110schools to commemorate this o this occasion with appropriate instructional activities great thank you so much is there any public comment on this item we have no public comment thank you are there any board questions seeing none would anybody like to put a resolution a motion on the floor to approve this resolution president make I make a motion that we approve District resolution number 2425 D50 in recognition of Dr Marther King Junior Day of Service January 20th 2025 okay is there a second I'll second that are there any comments on this item please trusty smth FS go right ahead Dr Martin Luther King Jr said in part that the greatest stumbling block in the strive towards freedom is not the white citizen counselor or the clue planner but the moderate who is more devoted to order

111than to Justice who prefers a negative piece which is absence of tension to a positive piece which is presence of Justice I urge you all to hold on to these words of Dr Martin Luther King Jr it is the moderate who needs to be bold courageous and to choose Kendy said there is no neutrality when it comes to racism you're either actively fighting racism or you're actively choosing to allow it to persist when we celebrate Dr Martin Luther King Jr we need to understand that he stood on the right side of History even when people did not believe him I'm complete I any other comments okay we'll move to a vote student trusty Wilson yes student trusta yes trusty Hernandez yes Trana yes smithf falls smithf falls yes trusty Gonzales yes and I'm a yes

112the motion passes unanimously now we are up to see business items for consent would anybody like to pull anything from the consent the consent calendar seeing n we can accept it as it stands great moving now to D superintendent communication Dr Moses it's your item thank you president reckler could we bring up the presentation I'm delighted to share that after the superintendent's report concludes we will have a presentation by our student trustees as a part of uh this presentation this evening next slide we want to start off by saying Happy New Year and on behalf of the the cabinet and the staff at West count Costa We wish all of our families students and students alike a Happy New Year we look forward to collaborating with everyone in this new year and continuing the great

113work across our district next slide we like to acknowledge President Jimmy Carter the 39th president of the United States uh we're grateful for his contributions his leadership service and service to our country especially in education we wanted to highlight that President Carter um first held office public office as a school board member a Schoolboard trustee and as later and later um in his presidency he signed a Senate Bill 210 establishing the modernday US Department of Education we are grateful to his contributions and in honor of his service I'd like to ask for a moment of silence thank you next slide um we're grateful for the resolution and we'd like to also acknowledge uh Dr Martin Luther King Jr day um and encourage our school sites to uh utilize this day as a day of service

114and commemorate this occasion with appropriate instructional activities next slide this month is school appreciation School Board appreciation month we' like to acknowledge the work of our board uh their time their effort their dedication to our students our community our parents and staff alike I know that this is a very difficult job a very serious job and I want to just commend our board for their um tireless efforts to make the decisions that will best move our district forward and improve outcomes for our students so thank you School Board next slide uh we'd like to acknowledge a longtime employee who retired from the business services department after 30 years of service David Johnson was the executive director of General Services uh and served in that role in our district for over 20 years uh we just

115wanted to acknowledge uh his level of service and this was meant to come forward in December to wish him uh a happy retirement so congratulations David next slide I also would like to share that uh there were some uh pivotal activities in December the first one was our student Summit our students uh high school students across the district came together uh and there was a student Summit that was hosted in order to provide a safe space for students to share uh their opport their experiences across the district and also to have their voices heard as students of color uh those sentiments also uh be implemented uh by administrators in order to create safe spaces across all of our schools a special thanks to the team that put it together it was a great event for

116students and um it was uh enlightening for administrators as well administrators did not join the student SE session but instead had their own session to also discuss safe spaces for students and their experiences next slide uh we also in December hosted a city schools tour we had dignitaries and local officials representing five cities in WSC uh within our district and we visited five schools across the district uh principles and students at those School sites shared their school programming and the goal and go goal of this event was to increase collaboration spread the word about the great things happening in our district and um solidify relationships of support and partnership for existing and future initiatives for our students and communities next slide uh we included this slide uh to honor the staff that came together to

117make this an incredible event uh so this is a slide of all of the staff members that both attended and plann for this event and just an appreciation um for making this happen for our communities thank you staff next slide we wanted to acknowledge the osero Jazz Ensemble they performed at the Midwest international band and Orchestra clinic in Chicago uh this was an exhilarating experience for our artist and not only did they get to perform um with professional musicians but they also got to uh tour and uh see bit of Chicago so we wanted to share that as one of the highlights of uh how our artists are learning more about their craft next slide uh it is time for students to apply to colleges and scholarships and we are so very pleased to announce

118that one of our students a Richmond High School o oer CES Mahia has earned a full ride scholarship to Columbia University through the questbridge St scholarship program we want to appreciate questbridge for acknowledging our students and their hard work and providing this opportunity for our students to move on to an IV League fully funded um college experience so congratulations cesia and congratulations Richman High next slide we are beginning our enrollment period for new families the enrollment period for the 2526 school year will begin on January 21st at 9:00 a.m. uh please check the website for information on how to uh work through our enrollment process with ease and uh ways to get questions answered if they come up as you begin to enroll please spread the word throughout our community that we are ready and

119happy to accept our new families and serve them well next slide this is the same flyer but for um in the Spanish language next slide we also want to announce that uh transitional kindergarten enrollment is starting as well um if you have a four-year old who is not quite ready for Kinder but is eligible for transitional kindergarten we want your student in our school district so please plan to enroll uh there are some informational sessions happening for parents who are new to the district or new to the school system and would like to have their questions answered and learn more about our program those sessions are happening virtually January 7th uh that one was yesterday we have another session happening on Tuesday January 14th please encourage our families to attend should they need to uh

120learn about our transitional kindergarten program next slide uh it is time for our students to leverage their opportunities to support funding their college education the Wiman promise scholarship is open and ready for applicants to apply they are offering 1,500 $ scholarships per school year with at least four years of funding guaranteed uh counselors are spreading the word about this opportunity for our Richmond students and we wanted to highlight it here as well so apply for those scholarships next slide we are happy to announce that the Ed fair is coming up on January 25th 2025 um we'd like for our families and our staff as well to register for this event to uh share in um spreading the word about opportunities within our district and also learning about programs across our school sites so we encourage

121you to participate in this event uh RSVPs before January 10th will enter into a raffle to win a $100 gift cards or RSVP early next slide I like to uh read our district statement regarding addressing the Staffing vacancies across the district um as an educational institution it is extremely critical to our work that we have our students um with effective and consistent instruction each day uh so we did want to explain our reassignments and uh why we um have landed on this decision as difficult as it may be California is experiencing a teacher Staffing shortage many districts across the state struggle to find a solution to address this Nationwide teacher shortage our district has reassigned is in the process of reassigning Highly qualified and credential teachers who are currently not assigned to classrooms um in

122order to fill where vacancies exist while we do recognize that this shift is disruptive to our dedicated staff members who are being reassigned to new positions uh this trans transition will directly benefit over a thousand students who have been without a consistent credential teacher in their classrooms these students will now have access to a high quality stable learning environment which is the priority guiding these changes we will support our teachers and S sites during this transition period it is our goal to provide effective instruction in order to improve the academic outcomes for our students and that is what has led this decision next slide finally we just like to remind our community about the opportunities to engage in our district uh committees Committees of where the work happens and where decisions are often made and

123information is shared uh we have the APAC committee the ASAC committee the doap committee the mdac multilingual District advisory committee the dates and times for these meetings are listed here and are also listed on our website you can find information about when these meetings are occur occurring if you check our events calendar on the website we also want to acknowledge that CAC which is a special education Community advisory Council and a DLI pack which is a dual language immersing parent advisory committee we encourage you to get involved and engage with us to collaborate regarding uh supporting the students across our district next slide oh finally two more the cboc and the 7-Eleven committee are two additional opportunities to engage and decisions that are being made across our district for facilities and that concludes the superintendent

124report I'd like to now pass it over to our student trustees and have them introduce themselves in their presentation can you bring up the presentation all right this is your item well good evening to everyone once again cabinet and the rest of the board trustees thank you again superintendent Moses for this opportunity and for your help and supporting all this um so I would like to introduce once again my paring trust student truste Luke Wilson in our student trustee report so this report consists of what we have been able to accomplish and what our aspirations and our goals are in the not only the long-term end but as well as what we're looking at right now so what we're looking at right now is ensuring awareness of student rights and what this looks like is

125that student rights are presented throughout all classrooms and staff facilities in every wccusd classroom and school on October 23rd 2024 um me alongside student trusty Luke Wilson proposed ensuring awareness of student rights in wccusd and the goal once again is to ensure all students know their rights by displaying these rights throughout every single classroom and the reason for this is to empower student students to know not only know their rights but to also PR Moree respect and accountability not just within students but also all of our staff as well and the next step is to finalize a clear list of Rights using surveys designed and distribution and distribute posters and our expected implementation is still to be decided I would also like to give a round thanks to um trustee Gonzales o for taking time

126out of his own time to even go to California governance to bring this presented to them on his own without not even our own knowledge and I would like to thank that once again for ensuring that our voices are heard especially at whatever level that is next slide please we also decided Well not decided the board decided that there will be a revision of bylaw 9150 so that means that student trustees are now officially paid by law on December 4th 2024 the vision of BW 9150 was approved which allows CC us student trustees to officially agree financial compensation and high school credit I would also like to once again give thanks to trusty gz or once again for cooperating so well and so closely with me and student trustee Luke Wilson and getting this revised

127in the better language so that way not only student trustees can understand what they're expect which they should expect but also um to make history so this revision was initially passed on July 17th for those who do not know by law in 2024 9150 was adopted in compliance with assembly bill number 275 in school governance and revised language and Logistics of how student trustees are compensated and finalized and pay were of that revision of the bylaw and we explain how which is how me and my founding student trusty Wilson work diligently and cooperatively with the board for the revision uring Clarity for details and what we look ahead is the not only the continuation of this revision but also Clarity for future student trustees more Community engagement and opportunities for student trustees and more aage

128for student trustee diversity next slide please I would also like to announce that all student Congress is back all student Congress is a student group formed by two student representatives from every 7th 8th 9th 10th 11th and 12th grade um from each K3 School Middle K3 Middle School excuse me and High School in WCC usz so what we do is we unite to influence School culture and climate and provide meaningful input on student voice and decisions that directly impact them so something new this year at all student Congress is we want students to learn about the uh dlap District local control accountability plan and provide feedback to the uh District local control accountability plan parent student committee the deadline to join is January 15 2025 and for more information you can contact Myra next slide

129please so goals and aspirations aspirations at West contas Unified School District uh student Bill of Rights can be adopted finalized uh revision of bylaw 9150 for student trustees and there's a special report coming up goals implementation of a student advisory panel more student trustey Community engagement which can look like visiting School sites alongside the board to be able to interact with students oneon-one and really hear from them and CTE programs for K through 8 students next slide please so moving on to our special report next slide so supporting student Le uh proposed climate resolution next slide so just to give some background a student at El High School drafted a resolution uh titled education response to the climate emergency FOC focusing on in integrating climate literacy into West contas Unified School District education some key

130highlights from the resolution is uh the pure commitment to climate change we want students to graduate with a deeper understanding of climate change and how it impacts the world around us and the possible solutions we can take to combat it uh creation of an environmental literacy working group development develop a k through climate literacy curriculum provide professional development for educators and assistant coordinate existing environmental initiatives I would like to thank uh Gonzalez ho for working closely with me with with this resolution and I hope to bring it to the board for a vote in the near future next slide to wrap up our presentation if you have any questions please let us know great thank you so much that was fantastic does anybody have any questions yes please go right ahead thank you uh president

131uh thank you uh Dr MOS for your report and thank you s juses uh that was great um I was curious to hear a little bit more about one of your goals aspirations for the future which is the uh student advisory panel could you talk to us just a little bit about what that would look like and what it is just so that we get a little more context be close to working with old student Congress and having um a specific group in old student Congress uh advocating for changes that they foresee so it would be Beyond just giving the student trustees information to bring to the board actually having a group possibly doing public comment and things of that nature to bring to the board oh what else like to add on that this

132was also a goal in terms of reference to what we see to our neighboring districts not only in state but out of state many of these districts have representatives from every High School within their District as a student advisory panel panelist which basically they advise the board on every resolution every bill every bylaw that is passed or discussed or in review in discussion and how it impacts not only their school and their peers but on a deeper level as in the district as well so continuing off what Luke says instead of just having it specifically nine students it could look as like students from all student Congress who represent the high schools that are representing that are being represented in all student Congress these are of course aspirations these are up for more discussion whether

133it's now or even behind closed doors this is one of our aspirations thank you thank you so much for that president that was my only question does anybody else have any questions I do so first that was fantastic would you be able to talk to the timing on a student Bill of Rights and also a climate resolution was there any you know was there a time frame that you were thinking about for the student Bill of Rights because I understand that me and trusty Wilson are soon to be headed off to whichever our designated College admissions tends to be but our designated timeline would be as soon as in one to two years because we understand the long process and structure in navigating the system to get something like this on the agenda Alone um

134let alone for it to be passed and to give get all the thumbs up so for the student Bill of Rights I think me and trusty will seem can agree that we would like to see it in at least two years if we're given enough Grace of one year one and a half year but that's our hope hope for timeline in terms of the student Bill rights I would just like to add to that I would hope that we can have a first draft completed by the end of this school year since oon and Congress will be starting next month so hopefully we can work with more students than just ourselves to get more feedback and have a draft ready for the board to review climate literacy or the climate climate resolution is there a

135timetable on that one as well president may I add to that because they sent it to governance um what we talked about with trusty Wilson and the author of The Resolution governance is that um it ended up being a really great and lengthy resolution that had a lot of financial impact so um staff asked for a couple months to review what was needed for us to actually be able to what we didn't want to do is downsize it to the point where it wasn't effective um so staff just asked for a little bit of time to review it um and find out what we would need to do in order to actually implement it to fruition um and it's supposed to come back uh for a first read at the next governance meeting for that

136committee okay thank you very much for that and so just one final thing just so I'm writing and taking some good notes so the student Bill of Rights the the expectation is that this work is going to continue to live in the all student Congress they'll continue to carry that forward yes ma'am okay great thank you okay if nobody has anything else on that item we will now move up F1 fiscal solvency plan 2025 to 2027 for discussion Dr Moses I believe this is your item thank you president reckler I'd like to just introduce the item uh with a little context um it's in the summary of the prees that based upon current projections our district must Implement a $13 million uh reduction plan in addition to the reductions that we were able to achieve

137last year um that Although our current budget meets a standard of positive certification it relies heavily on over $37 million in contribution from fund 17 reserves in order to be able to meet our financial obligations and address the structural budget deficit in the current year and the next two years so we must address the future fiscal uncertainty to ensure that our district can continue to meet its financial obligation I'd like to uh present to you a summary of the plan that was attached to the agenda um and so I'll begin the presentation now um with this first slide uh which outlines the executive summary of exactly what's happening here um we are in year two of a previously adopted fiscal solvency plan by the previous board 19 million in reductions were achieved last year and

138implemented this current year year two of the previously approved plan requires that we identifies $7 million in reduction to be implemented next year in addition to that requirement and uh reviewing our budget um stance at first interim our current projections require that we plan to identify further reductions totaling 6 million in the 2627 fiscal year um due primarily to our heavy heavy Reliance on reserves in order to meet our 3% reserve requirement next slide M didn't change oh there we go okay um there are need for reductions uh the reason why we need these reductions is uh that for many years now our district has experienced significant structural budget deficit what that means is that we're spending out uh more than we're bringing in in as Revenue in order to take care of our basic

139operating expenses this reduction plan um pertains to our operating fund only um if you read through the plan that's attached to the board agenda there is an explanation of another funding source which we call restricted funds I just want to name that those funds are not addressed in this fiscal solvency plan and cannot be um identified as a part of our fiscal solvency planning um fund Reserve fund 17 reserves is our um for lack of a better word we can call it our rainy day fund in order to support us during um certain fiscal times such as now um however we are estimated to exhaust almost all of those funds in a current multi-year projection and that's the issue that we need to address uh one time covid funding has expired um we're experiencing declining

140enrollment and at the same time time our average daily attendance rate for our students which is how we're funded is is decreasing um so the unfunded and underfunded mandates from the state and federal government are also impacting our bottom line more specifically uh the contributions that we must make for a special education program in order to ensure that we can meet the needs of our neediest our um our most intense students and make sure that they have a uh the educational experience that they deserve and require as well next slide this slide demonstrates our enrollment Trend and uh we have three data points here if you look at the purple uh trend line that is our funded Ada I'm going to explain shortly uh the dashed orange line is our actual average daily attendance and

141then the blue bars represent our enrollment our prior enrollment our expected enrollment currently and our future enrollment projections if if you follow the bars starting at 2018 you can clearly see the reduction in enrollment that our district has experienced and uh 2018 we had 28,1 122 students in the current year we've certified uh enrollment of 2,273 students the decline in enrollment has resulted in a decline of Revenue um our in addition our student rate of average daily attendance although we have 20 5,273 students currently enrolled um it's projected that based upon our Trend and based upon what we've seen in Prior years that our average daily attendance is going to amount to about 23,32 students um our funded Ada is an average we're able to use an average of the the current year and the

142prior two years and if you notice that purple line um we were receiving more funding than we had realized in our attendance because we were able to use our prior year enrollment when we had more students in our district that was calculated um in the formula to determine our average daily attendance funding rate well unfortunately our enrollment is now flatlined and at threeyear average is not um an elevated number as we were able to benefit from in the past so we're now needing to adjust just in order to ensure that the amount of funding that we get that we bring in is U matching the um expenditures and resources that we spend out next slide um these slides have a lot of numbers on them but I wanted to give you a clear picture of

143our multi-year projections for unrestricted operating budget I am not going to review them all in their entirety but they are here for your review and I'm always happy to take questions by email um from the community if you are inclined to to share um if we could click the Flyin I'd like to highlight a few things on this slide um the first thing I'd like to highlight go Ahad and click is uh This scen Bar shows our contributions from fund 17 so if you look at the revenue that we're expected to bring in it's the first three I'm sorry the first four rows uh the restricted revenue from our federal government you'll see there was no funding there because we are not able to um that funding is restricted solely it cannot be added to

144our operating budget uh we're expected to contribute 11.5 million from our uh fund 17 reserves this year 13.5 million next year and um previously this was 13 million in year three we need to get that down to 7 million in order to satisfy uh the ability to comfortably meet the obligations of our 15% Reserve click yes I'd also like to highlight our contributions to our required program click if you see in that row it shows that we are actually contributing in the current year 106.8 million dollar to our restricted programs this is a requirement in order to ensure that we can serve our special education population uh to Fidelity and if you'll notice in the out years that amount is expected to increase slightly um due to step- and column increases for staff the yellow

145bar below shows our total revenues and these are revenues after we've contributed uh funding from fund 17 and also after we've subtracted the contributions that were required to make to those programs next slide on this slide we're showing our our expenses that um we have budgeted for the current year in the next two years and these budgets are created based upon our current rate of spending and our program needs it shows that total expenditures um for our next three years are expected to be 263 milon 271 and 275 uh over the next three years next slide I've repeated those numbers here so that we can do a comparison to our revenues and our expenditures and the the net decrease that we'll experience due to the lack of funding that we have to cover these exper

146these expenditures you'll notice that even with the fund 17 reserves that we are still operating at a deficit in this current year 5.2 million is the estimated deficit and in the next Years you'll see those numbers represented there is as well um when you look at our beginning fund balance and our ending fund balance after expenditures are taken care of uh you'll see that we are just barely making the state's requirement of ensuring that that 3% Reserve is um set aside as required by law next slide oh sorry uh this budget reduction plan is represented here in the Yellow Boxes and it is showing that we have to identify 7 million in cuts for the 25 26 school year and then in the following year we have to make sure that we keep those cuts

147out and identify an additional $6 million in reductions and by doing that we can meet our 3% Reserve if we were not to do that then those amounts would appear as uh deeper structural deficits and we would not be able to set aside our required 3% reserves next slide I want wanted to highlight that it appears in this current year that we may have an ending fund balance of about $2 million the reality is uh the budget team has planned for that ending balance uh to be there as a placeholder because every year in January um the health um the cost of Health Care increases and the increases to Health Care are not yet built into the budget because we do not know exactly how much that's going to cost for all employees at the

148end of this current month January we will understand what those increases amount to we anticipate that they're going to be about $2 million so what you see there is a un fund balance when we present our second interim report that amount will not be there because it will be dedicated to paying the increases in the health premiums that uh we are required to pay starting January 1 next slide so reductions are extremely difficult our district faces so many challenges already and the need to reduce is an uncomfortable space to be in for all of us um not just our our board trustees our leadership team but absolutely for our staff in our community and we try to identify ways in which to accomplish what we must accomplish in these reductions and do it in a

149way in which we have minimal impact on programs with that said as an educator I recognize that all of our programs are valuable and every penny that we spend on students is a penny well spent however the number of pennies that we have is not enough pennies to cover everything that we have um that we desire to allocate Monies to so we must identify ways to align the revenue that we receive with the expenditures that we plan to spend out this reduction plan is an attempt to provide a plan in order to ensure that we can meet our financial obligations and also satisfy the requirements of the law in the budget reduction plan uh planning document uh these reductions are presented differently they're presented by position in this presentation I wanted to share with you

150the reductions in a different way so that we could quantify exactly where these cuts are happening and and identify how our district team is trying to accomplish these reductions and make adust ments to programs with the least amount of impact to students in schools um we do know that any reductions we make there is going to be an impact I don't want to minimize that fact and I want to acknowledge that this is going to be very difficult moving ahead but that we're dedicated to doing this with dignity and with support and in the um in the best way possible in order to retain our level of service and our programs for our school sites and communities so what I'd like to show here is how we've restructured our c office services in order to

151achieve some of these reductions last year we made1 19 million in reductions and the reductions were um across the board and they were very difficult to achieve we were clear this year that we needed to identify reductions that did not take away um critical staff from schools and in that these reductions were identified in a way in which we had a plan to maintain a quality level of service even though we must reduce uh so we're proposing are reductions to the central office staffing uh in the business services department the educational services department the special education department General services department and the it and integrated technology department and the operations Department uh the cabinet sat down put heads together and tried to figure out how we could restructure and Achieve these reductions and still accomplish

152the work and um and dedicate the time and energy needed to ensure that we're building continuing to build great programs and getting great results um within our school sites so these reductions to central office positions and services total $3.2 million and the cabinet is hard at work trying to ensure that we have a plan um to cover all necessary and required work to move our programs even though these reductions are necessary next slide this slide addresses program alignment and adjustments each one of these lines represents a plan a plan to adjust um how we are managing programs across the district so that we can align them better to the revenue that we have to run them um so you'll see that we are making some proposed changes there is not an attempt to eliminate any

153programs I did hear the concerns about IB I know that in the first line you see independent studies in the last line you see Visual and Performing Arts and I want to say very clearly that we are not eliminating programs we are not eliminating programs what we are doing is working within the programs to align them based upon what makes sense fiscally and how we can best serve our students with least amount of impact to what we currently offer them um after a conversation uh and discussion this evening by the board um we will look at these and and explain more in depth exactly what all of these Lear items mean um but I can say with certainty that this this plan does not impact our staffing model as it relates to making sure that

154the students that are enrolled in our district have quality instructors to implement programs that will continue to to move along uh their academic uh success and the experiences across our schools we have however identified programs where we do believe we can make these adjustments and still provide a quality service for students realizing that this is a heavy lift and I'm not taking this lightly and I assure you that no one on our leadership team does take these Cuts lightly but we do have to do the job of aligning our budget and ensuring that we can meet our financial obligations so um look forward to going in depth with you and I encourage you to look at the plan where there is a little bit more level of detail about what these Cuts entail next slide

155I wanted to also provide a summary of what these Cuts look like in terms of positions and impact uh these are the reductions that are proposed for the 2526 school year what we just um witnessed on the previous two slides and I just want to point out that um although we know that reductions are difficult regardless of what our current Staffing um model is that um we are proposing that we reduce 43 positions in order to achieve fiscal solvency and those 43 positions equate to 1.28% of the Staffing that we have in the district so I want to reiterate that uh we do want to ensure that this is done with dignity and that we're doing everything we can to ensure that we don't lose staff but that we find other places for them because

156we also know that we have vacancies across the district but we are proposing that we do reduce 1.28% of our Workforce in order to achieve 6.6 million in reductions in order to achieve our fiscal solvency planning I also want to highlight that there's also 584,000 in service reductions and the two um uh components equ to the 7.2 million which is our cut Target that was agreed upon in our previously approved fiscal solvency plan next slide I also wanted to present just an outline of uh our explanation of how we might achieve the $6 million in reduction for the oute of 2627 um there has not been a plan put into place but in order to satisfy um the requirements of ensuring that during our first interim we could show that we're addressing our structural deficit

157we did estimate on what these reductions in the 26 27 year could look like and so that's represented here uh with the expectation that we would need to cut about 1.4% uh additionally of our total Workforce in order to achieve the reductions in the 2627 school year uh who would have careful planning and thoughtful conversations about how to achieve those when the time comes next slide and finally I just wanted to go back to the summary of why we need these reductions if we do not achieve the reductions for the 2526 school year and the 26 27 school year we will not be in compliance which could lead to um receivership of our district which means we would not no longer be in control of making the budgetary decisions for our schools next slide again

158highlighting that need next slide I just wanted to summarize and I want to read this statement because um want to be very clear that we understand this is not um something that we take lightly the continuation of our fiscal solvency plan is necessary it's necessary to ensure that District's fiscal solvency our district is fiscally solvent and can maintain local control over our budget decisions we understand that these reductions will directly affect individuals who have dedicated their careers to serving our students please remember that these recommendations are not made lightly and are driven only by the need to align our expenditures with our revenues and address the district structural deficit next slide we also understand that we have a responsibility to try and um work on ways to increase revenue for our district uh School budgets

159have to be planned based upon what we know to be true in the moment however we also know that if we are successful in increasing our attendance or increasing our average daily rate of attendance for our students that that will equate to increased revenue for our district and what will happen if we can increase the revenue for our district then we will resend the reductions that we're approving so we do have a plan to support um increased attendance at our school sites I want to leverage and raise um a fact that Although our revenue is driven by attendance if we can improve attendance if we currently we're at 92.2% of average daily attendance if we increased that by 2.8% and we were able to get to 95% of average daily attendance that would increase our

160Revenue by $7.7 million and that would erase our need to make these reductions at all so I wanted to lift that up and say that as a system we all need to work together in order to try and increase the attendance across our district and within every School site uh because with each 1% increase in our average daily attendance that would equate to about $2.75 million so if we could get Beyond 95% that would be even better um but we're also looking at ways to increase enrollment to attract families to our district um and also uh ways to decrease the operating expenses that we currently have um there's also a potential and opportunity to shift some of our supplemental services for our students to the restricted funding sources we do have grants and onetime monies

161that can supplement our instructional program however those monies are restricted and uh set aside for specific supplemental services so we do need to plan long-term plan in terms of uh what we can do with those firms as we have to trim our general operating budget expenditures next slide that concludes my presentation on the fiscal reduction plan and this evening we are asking the board just to review this plan and to hold discussion and we would we would bring this plan back in some form on January 29th to ask the board for Action in order to stay compliant with what been um asked of us by the County Office of Education and that concludes my presentation great thank you so much is there any public comment on this item yes our first public comment is Alon

162Harrison please unmute yourself can you guys hear me yes we can okay I just want to say um Dr Moses that was a wonderful report horrible to hear but a wonderful report and I just want to say your report that you did earlier was also awesome and I like that you highlighted all the things that were coming you made it a Bittersweet and the tour was awesome that I feel you guys need to do more of that and the students trustee information was good I just hope when you're doing budget when you do this when you look at Equity ensuring that the data is good for all students requires different resources so when you look at the resources you can't find one resource and say oh this is all we can do the uh data

163the resources that different students need I hope you're taking into consideration so that we can change um the data and continue the programs and services that are working that they um can that the ones that you're going to continue to fund and say and I hope that our district does better in the future I'm complete next forv common is Sarah toy please unmute yourself hello how are you guys doing tonight um my name is Sarah torney and I have a junior at penol Valley high school and an eighth grader at penol middle school I'm going to quote a notice that is circulating saying that there may be a million $100,000 cut to the IB programming and um although it is unclear if this cut is aimed at a particular school or a portion of the

164IB Continuum it will reduce funding of material and administrative costs or if it is aimed at the price of personnel or even exam fees um we're unclear about that but what is clear is that a loss of funding will affect the program implementation and perhaps even the ability to continue to operate as an i World School we do not have AP at penol Valley High School um and although there is not a specific School named pbhs is on the chopping block and there are over 52% of Juniors and seniors taking IB classes right now and that would be detrimental to their college careers thank you so much that concludes public comment great okay we're going to questions from the board we'll do three each and z have questions that they would like to ask on

165this item trusty Gonzalez go go ahead thank you um Dr Moses thank you so much for the presentation um my first question is around the multi-year projections um the governor just released the first draft of his budget for next year the cola I noticed is less than what's on your slide so so does that mean that our deficit long term is greater than what's shown in the multi-year projection thank you for the question yes that's exactly what that mean I don't I'm not looking at the numbers but if I remember correctly we anticipated a cola of about 2.93% and I believe the governor has um shared that they expect the cola to be about 2.58 or 2.53 2.43 yeah so there's about a half% reduction in what we expect to receive in CA we'll have

166to adjust that at second in room so we will be showing less Revenue at second in a room okay thank you um uh we heard a couple public comment about the elimination of dual immersion and the Internationals program is that part of this no there are no proposed cuts to those programs thank you and then third I heard you there's no elimination to programs uh just some reductions and Alignment in The Proposal um can you talk about the Arts materials and supplies reduction for the sites is that the whole allocation for arts and supplies or is it just a reduction to it thank you for the question so that reduction uh line item prepare pertains to two specific uh funding sources so the first is um for many years through the elap program our vapa

167department has asked that we allocate $250 to each site in order for them to be able to purchase arts and Material supplies like paints and brushes and and things of that nature it's a very small amount but we realized that it it was a help to our schools um so the total amount of the $250 per site was $114,000 we now have prop prop 28 funding we also have uh currently for the next couple of years Arts and Music block grant that can supplement that $14,000 so we're recommending that that $14,000 be reduced from the general fund because we're able to supplement it with restricted funds um similarly the remaining amount of that reduction is $220,000 that was previously going to the high school to the secondary theaters they were getting $5,000 each in in

168order to um purchase mat material and supplies replenish repair take care of our theaters uh well after some evaluation what we found is that we actually have the the rental fees that we've been collecting from our theaters can actually be used to supplement the amount that was coming out a general fund to support our theaters so we will absolutely continue to support our theaters but the funding source will now be from the collection of rental fees so that's a good example of how we've tried to work within these proposed reductions to ensure sure that we maintain what sites need but also make a reduction to the general fund thank you Dr Moses uh those are my three questions president thank you great thank you so much questions on this side please go right ahead uh

169thank you Dr Moses for your presentation I only have two questions my first question is when you mentioned uh the alignment with enrollment where is the enrollment data being sourced from is it for current year is it projection is it uh enrollment from the past two years a year ago thank you for the question there's two things that relate to the enrollment alignment uh the first was the proposed changes to the Virtual Academy program currently that uh program serves very few students in grades K to3 so we're trying to um make changes to the program so that we're not allocating full FTE for classrooms that have very few students students in them uh we'll be working with the program um they administrator over the program in order to accomplish that but currently and I think

170I can share we have approximately 11 students in grades K to three but we have four teachers allocated to K 3 um so the four teachers should be serving about 88 students instead the four teachers are serving about 11 students that's a longer conversation because I do understand they've been repurposed in other ways but so the reality is they're allocated for that purpose and we don't have enough students to justify that that's an example of how the enrollment is being adjusted um we do not currently have a waiting list for those grade levels and so we're looking to make some adjustments based upon the need there uh the second thing is that um we did assign some additional FTE to secondary schools with special schedules special schedules outside of the contracted Staffing um mod model

171and we will be um trying to align closer to the Staffing model and so in that way because we've assigned additional teachers outside of that's required for enrollment we do have a plan to pull those back and um continue to staff our schs so that we can serve all students but not we we aren't in a position to continue to give them extra thank you and my second question is how will the proposed reduction impact our historically underserved populations to name some our elll community our students with disability um moving forward and in the future thank you for the question so um this is the reason why I try to highlight our availability of restricted funds uh because we do believe that we can continue to provide higher high levels of supplemental services for those

172students because there are funding streams that are dedicated to serving those students and those students alone we have our Title One funds which are it's a healthy amount of funding each year we have title three funds for El's um we have several grants that we utilize for example um we have a grant called CMU that supports the um expenditures related to our newcomer program and our um uh Elementary newcomer program so we're leveraging restricted funds in order to ensure that we are planning to use all of the restricted funds to meet the needs of those students um however we aren't in a position to use General funds to provide those supplemental services so we're very fortunate to have additional um millions of dollars in allocation that we can spread across the district to leverage services

173for those students of need thank you thank you Dr mes for your presentation um my question questions are uh what specific strategies are being implemented to address the decline in enrollment and increase the um average daily adaa that's a load question thank you for the question clana well I think that there are levels to what we need to work towards in order to attract families to our district I think um first and foremost the relationship the relationships that we hold with our communities um really go a long way in order to reinforce our desire to provide not only a great academic and educational experience for students but a partnership with parents I think the first level of addressing that is to really work with our site staff in order to leverage um their relationships and

174Market their schools to share the great things that are happening um with that said attracting students to our district is going to take more than just a campaign of you know sharing some of the great things that we're doing we also need to retain the programs that are desirable to families and we need to figure out a way to do that in addition we need to work with our school sites primarily with the average daily attendance issue um increasing enrollment I think will happen authentically once we are able to continue to highlight the great programs that we do offer so I think it's part marketing it's part relationship and it's a lot great plan a lot of great planning so that um what we're doing for our students is evident and that we're proving to

175the community that we have a lot to offer their children okay my second question goes right along there are you thinking about targeted plans especially for schools with the lowest Ada like we emphasizing on that thank you for that question I may pass it this over to our um associate superintendent of operations because it's her Department that's implementing um the planning in order to address the enrollment and attendance growth that we desire uh but I will say that I think we need more than just one plan and I know that we are on our way um to we have a few plans that are happening now and we're continually putting heads together as a Cabinet in order to come up with more ideas on how to address that and I'll pass this over to miss

176zler for additional comments yeah thank you I would agree with Dr Moses that it is multifaceted our approach for the last few years has been to deeply Target clonic absenteeism with the idea that if we reduce chronic absenteeism we will increase attendance that campaign has been successful and we've continued we actually have a 133% reduction in chronic absenteeism year to dat the good news is our kids don't meet the threshold or not as many for chronic absenteeism the bad news is that strategy is no longer pushing up overall attendance because the number of students that are chronically Trent has reduced so we need to switch strategies we will still address chronic absenteeism but we need now to broaden the Outreach um and look at students who are missing a few days of school but don't

177actually meet that chronic absenteeism level the why we show up campaign is launching uh and we are also looking at how we allocate the time with our principles to make this part of the climate plc's we're really looking at how do we make this tier one how do we invest teachers office staff principles in the Outreach so that the same message is going to parents okay my last question um what Innovative strategies Beyond 88 increases are we exploring to generate revenue for the district thank you for the question um the last slide in my presentation we touched on some of the ways in which we think we can make an impact on that um it's difficult to predict the future what we can do is plan in the in you know here and now in

178order to make our district more attractive I think that as a Cabinet we're constantly discussing ways in which to generate more um to increase our enrollment however I don't know that that's within our realm of influence in here and now it's going to take some time to build so I think we need a multi-year plan I need that I think that there are some things that we can do right now which was addressed and um I also think that an analysis of how we're spending can go a long way I'm going to pass it over to who had their hand up was it you I thought somebody raised their hand to speak no okay um but I agree with you that we need a multifaceted approach however it is um when it comes to the

179operating budget it's really cut and dry we only get the number we only get the revenue based upon the number of children we have in seats and because that's the case of how we generate funding for the operating expenses of our district the only way in which we can increase that revenue is to increase the number of students in seats so we'll continue to work at it um and I welcome your recommendations and you know other commun members that might want to work with us on that but um plain and simple we get Revenue based upon number of students so the only answer to how we can generate more in terms of addressing this issue is by increasing our enrollment thank you okay I've got the couple they did great work so I only have

180a couple of things um I also want to come back to the unrestricted myp and I want to touch on fund 17 which now adds up over these three years to 32.2 million just at the first interim it was at 38.2 million and you know you explained that you thought that there was going to be interest in that number so what happened between December 18th and tonight where this comes down to 32 . 2 million great question so our budgets are reviewed and accepted and we get feedback from the County Office of Education which is our oversight unit um based upon the way in which our contribution to restricted programs is increasing when we adopted our budget um we anticipated that our contribution to special ed would be 14 million less than what it is

181currently because the contribution increased by 14 million um the county office and reviewing our numbers really felt that it was risky just to exhaust all of our funds because hidden expenses are popping up and we can't control them when it's connected to something like a restricted program so there was a request from the county office that we re-evaluate our fiscal solvency plan in order to ensure that we weren't exhausting all reserves because they anticipate that in year four we're going to also need some relief from fun 17 and they were not comfortable giving us a qu um a positive certification um we self-certified as positive but we run the risk of being downgraded to qualified if we don't satisfy this requirment to further reduce in order not to exhaust reserves I think the fear there

182is once reserves are exhausted if we have a $14 million deficit we don't have anywhere to um support our district in meeting our financial obligations because reserves would be gone so that's the difference in why we what we're trying to do is not exhaust reserves and leave about 7 million in reserves that year four we actually estimated to continue to be at a structural deficit even with these Cuts if we don't drastically change the alignment of how we're spending okay and then I'd like to touch on the IB because of the way the LC cap was written I can no longer tell how big that program is well what does taking $100,000 out of that program do is there anything left to thank you for the question we look to the overall budget for IB

183it's a very desirable program but it is a very expensive program um we are not proposing that we make any changes to Staffing we do understand that the courses are needed um however what we're looking at are the fees that are charged by the international baloran um oversight entity um perhaps in looking at um for example the number of exams that we're paying for or we're finding that the rate of passing those exams is not very high so we're spending lots of money to pay for exams that ultimately our students are not really successful in completing so the primary thing that we're looking at is perhaps changing the structure of how we offer students exams in that program meaning um how well are you doing in your courses and do you desire to take the

184the exam um that is where our initial thoughts were for how we could achieve reductions because ultimately paying um large amounts of money for students to take an exam that it's we we can already predict won't go well is in a good use of funds okay and then finally so the next time we have a reg regularly scheduled aidant meeting is on January 29th and this is on the docket so we've just sort of unpacked this what's your plan to hear us out hear Community out gather your gather us together what what does that look like we've already had a some community outreach we held a couple of budget committee meetings um there isn't really a plan to adjust unless the board gives direction to adjust so I think that uh for me next steps

185could be agendize this for a retreat that's coming up in order to take a a deep look at exactly what line items are included in this plan for further discussion um at that point um I'm happy to take whatever Direction the board gives but we don't as a Cabinet we don't have a plan to go back and rework unless we're asked to okay all right so we'll make sure that's on that Retreat agenda um okay so we'll move to comments does anybody have comments please go ahead two minutes on the clock thank you sorry for everyone I'm waiting for the clock not just thank you um so I mean I think that we all understand that really our schools are starving for resources they're starving for staff they're starving for programs they're starving for supports

186and I think for our school specifically they have a lot of needs especially in the Flatland area where students are not achieving academically um and they actually need even more uh and greater supports and I think that the last few years what we've been doing and two years ago we cut $10 million last year we cut 19 million now we're cutting even greater and we're going to have to apparently do it for the next three years I think it's imperative for us that this becomes a priority that instead of just cutting and cutting and cutting we do the opposite and we bring resources um and I know I'm looking at you Dr Moses but really it's for us as a board to figure out like what our plan is going to be to increase attendance

187but I really appreciate it I think Tristy Yan's question about what is our strategy to look at our schools where we have the least attendance um and I think that we need to ask more of those questions because we have to do something because on top of these cuts the partial taxes ending which is $10 million Community Schools Grant which 34 38 million it's at this point ending right and then on top of that our sped costs which we need to do continue to increase in 2020 we're spending $38 million in sped costs this year we spent over aund over a hundred million doar on sped costs so I think that it has to be a a burger approach or sandwich approach where we're looking at how we're investing but then we're also looking at

188how we are looking for further revenue and every year we talk about it like oh we need to partner we need to do this we actually need to have a plan as a board because otherwise we're going to slowly disappear to the point where we have nothing else to cut and we're already hearing the impact of those cuts as it is um so I encourage us to do that and figure out a way thank you so much does anybody else have comments pleas please go right ahead two minutes I think that to trusty Gonzalez hoy's point there has to be a both and approach but also think that we need to continue to look at those things that are in our Direct Control when we're talk talking about how much we spend in legal fees

189when we're talking about simply going to a school and we don't have the lights cut on all the time there are ways that we can start chipping away at this that I think that when we are in when we were in our subcommittees we talked about it I think that it's going to have to be everyone has to be T toes in and they have to really commit that this is not an US versus them this is an all district all Community all students everybody has to have the in the understanding that there's no enemy here we all have to work together to keep local control over our budget and we all have to work together to keep these doors open with our schools with our neighborhood schools to do that everybody has to take

190a hit and I think that as we get closer to March and as we get closer to these decisions and if we're not lobbying in Sacramento and if we're not making education local education a priority then we are doing an injustice to this body and its position and how it is supposed to make the decisions for the district but I think that we have to stand in front and not hide behind the district decisions and we have to be all together knowing that our budget is our priority but to what Dr Moses said all the time as a CP A CBO you can do everything but you can't have it I forgot how you say it but can you tell me how you say it Dr Moses you can have anything you want but you

191can't have everything you want right so I think that with that we need to prioritize and we need to be clear in our prioritization about our budget and what it looks like I'm complete thank you for the presentation thank you at this time we're approaching 10 o'clock I'd like to extend the meeting put a motion on the floor to extend the meeting until 10:30 may I have a second I'll second it okay let's go to a vote to extend to 10:30 trusty Gonzales way yes trusty smithfields yes oh I'm sorry trust sorry I looking this way Tristy Wilson extend the meeting until 10:30 yes trusty espanosa Jr yes trusty H landz trusty yes sir yes yes okay so I don't have too much to add to those two comments except that I see a lot

192of reductions which are great but we need to make money and how we make money is through an attendance campaign I'm not on a lot of school Communications but I haven't heard anything we love your K I know there are different messages for different audiences and I've read done some research on what works and what what not we love your kid we want to see you you know I haven't seen any any of that how important attendance is is I think that's really really important to just pound this into the ground and for certain communities the fiscal impact is going to be important so for c for certain communities you can tell them hey every day that you take your kid out before vacation and you fly out a day early that's costing us and

193those people will respond they really will not everyone but I know who will so there are different messages for different people and that has to be immediate the biggest thing though is enrollment and on programs and what you want to grow what are you growing what can you grow put a number out there look at what we have to offer and find out what can we grow I mean the kids are here I keep saying it over and over again there are kids here there're more kids in here than ever before it's a capture rate and there has to be selective programs this is what we're going to grow this is what we think we could going to get and go get them set a goal and go get them so I think it's really

194possible um and uh yeah and I think the board has to decide on some priorities I mean I don't think the Strategic plan really gives us I don't think it's a finished document that really tells us this is what we really need to invest in and that's board work that needs to get done quickly um you know just to you know get a few things going that we really want to protect and then we can then we know that we're in line on that um so there's work to do there but really there's growth there's growth and while I see the the cost management side what I haven't seen for years is this is how we you know there's upside and this is how we're going to get get it thank you okay so that

195concludes that item and now we are moving on to action items and we'll move up E4 which is the cell phone resolution 5-51 cell phone usage Missle this is your item go ahead thank you and good evening we are bringing forward tonight a resolution regarding cell phone use in schools and a little bit of background on this um the phone free school Act was signed in September of 2024 and what this bill does is it requires governing boards to adopt policy to limit or prohibit the use of smartphones while at school this is a little bit of a departure from the 2019 legislation which granted school districts the authority to regulate the use so the key shift is that we were previously authorized to regulate the use of phones we are now required to regulate

196the use of phones uh we have to do this by the 2026 school year and the policy has to be reviewed and adopted each school year next slide please so when we think about the impact that we would like to have from a resolution on cell phones there's really three key pieces we'd like improved academic outcomes improved social emotional outcomes and improved campus safety next slide please one thing to note is there's an emergent body of research around the shifting landscape that technology and supervision are creating so if we think to an analog world pre cell phones when students are in our classrooms or in our hallways supervision is not perfect but we largely know what's happening as we've shifted into a digital world a student can be right in front of us physically safe

197and exposed to a world of emotional or psychological harm and so we'd like to acknowledge that parents and educators are jointly really grappling with what appropriate limitations are in this new world world and how to handle it the anxious generation uh is a book that I would recommend to anyone who is seeking more information it really is a comprehensive resource around what exposure to unlimited internet access unfettered resource is doing to our teens and how this access really impacts and stun the development specifically of pre-teens and early adolescence next slide please so we are academic institutions and our primary goal is to educate students academically uh and we know that cell phones become a challenge in the classroom and a distraction a Temptation you know the longer you can focus on a task usually the

198more successful you are and the cell phone is a constant thing that buzzes pings and gives you access to the world outside of the classroom cell phones create an Avenue to cheat or create shortcuts and we know that they're creating diminished academic tasks performance uh in Spain there was a 2015 prohibition of cell phones and they found that Bing in schools decreased 10 to 18% and in another study this one was in Great Britain they showed that limiting cell phone use created an average gain of 6% academically and 14% for students who were previously designated low achieving next slide please the social emotional impact of cell phone use is also incredibly strong uh we know that the access to soci cell phones and specifically social media encourages unhealthy comparison among teens and there really is

199fear of missing out we know that our students see images that portray Perfection or unrealistic expectations that they then strive for and they create emotional distance between bullies and victims or even just student to student we know that people will say things online that they wouldn't say to someone's face and they act as a trauma amplifier things such as a schoolyard fight that we don't condone but we know occasionally happen and can be taken care of and students can be supported with little lingering harm now can have lingering harm because they're replayed over and over and over again and students not only experience the trauma of the fight itself but the trauma of everybody's comments about the incident also students who weren't even in the area now see it both the psychological impact and the

200physical impact and it creates fear for their own safety next slide please we also know that cell phones Impact Physical safety really cell phones create a device where students can coordinate activity that adults can't monitor or see they can bully students who aren't in the same room and we know that students use cell phones and particularly social media to keep conflicts happening after mediations have occurred we'll have students in Conflict who are very clear that they are done with the conflict and it reizes because they're constantly exposed to the opinions of others and I added trauma amplifier on this slide again because I think this is a physical and emotional impact to our students according to the New York times 16% of students have reported that they have been bullied online next slide please so

201there's a lot of highlevel research and there's some longitudinal studies from other countries that have long-term bands but what about more locally San Matteo High began implementing a cell phone ban in 2019 it was phased in in 2021 they became a cell phone free campus they have experienced since then a 1% reduction in their rate of suspension and a 3% increase in the perception of school safety however I was able to speak with their principle and she said that the impact goes far beyond what the hard data shows she said that teachers report that their classrooms are more productive happy spaces that they actually feel that because they're in solidarity that cell phones are not used on campus that it's reduced the burden of enforcement that they have improved peer-to-peer interactions and actually the focus

202and the product and the conversation in the classroom has improved and she said she has teachers that say they would quit if they went back um so she had pretty positive things to say next slide please Greenwood Academy is also a cell phone free campus and I spoke to principal Johnson and he had similar things to say as principal Shu from San Mato he said that they do have fewer office referrals he really emphasized that students actually really hold back when they know other students have cell phone access because there's a fear being filmed or recorded and so he said they've noticed that students are more willing to participate in lunchtime activities or in class because they understand their interaction is with the people in the space not with a wider audience I asked him

203how do the students feel and he said you know the students no student wants to give up their cell phone let's be clear but they will grudgingly admit that they need the support that they need the help in putting their phone away and this is in line with what research tells us that really the cell phone use is becoming so addictive for teens that asking them to make the decision alone isn't fair next slide please should you all decide to move forward with the resolution this evening we do have a proposed roll out that is in line with the legislation uh assuming you approve it we will immediately begin the Gathering stakeholder feedback phase and this was something that uh principal Shu from San Mato said was critical in their roll out parents have questions

204in theory people understand the need but they need an opportunity to ask every question and to help us think through pieces of the plan that we won't think through alone we then also need an education campaign people need time to sit with and understand the why to do their own research should they so choose and to Think Through how this works for them their family their classroom then in the summer in August we'd like to launch the implementation at school sites monitor Implement and then we need to reflect after the first quarter we know that this is a culture shift we know it will not be perfect and we know we'll have learnings along the way and so this piece of coming back to refine based on what we've seen and learned is critical next

205slide please we have a few procedural considerations uh once again the partnership with stakeholders is incredibly important we also want to remember that when we're working through policy enforcement we really need to remain restorative and educational we don't want to roll out a policy that increases exclusionary practice and lastly right now we don't know that we have the capacity to purchase Yonder pouches which have been a strategy um at Greenwood and at San mono high and so while we would love to have a physical device to support us in this we don't know that we will and so we need to plan assuming that this is a culture shift um not a physical lockup of the cell phones and that in this communication and patients will be key to our implementation next slide please so

206you've all been waiting now for the resolution language now therefore be it resolved that the district will adopt clear and consistent guidelines in accordance with the California state legislation to prohibit the use of cell phone use and wearable communication devices in schools in accordance with Education Code 4891 1.7 the district will work in collaboration with parents and Guardians to ensure that families understand the reasoning behind cell phone guidelines and support the district's effort to provide Focus distraction free learning environment and in accordance with Ed code 48917 the district will period periodically review and assess the impact of cell phone policies on student achievement safety and overall School climate at at least every five years now therefore be it resoled that the West country Unified School District will develop and adopt a comprehensive policy explicitly outlining

207expectations that there will be zero unauthorized cell phone use during school hours this policy will include clear guidelines including consequences for violating the cell phone policy full implementation of the policy will begin in the 2526 scool year and until then schools should continue to follow the cell phone policies outlined in the student parent handbook site policies and protocols will be reviewed to ensure that they are in accordance with District policy and that the security of student devices is taken into consideration the policy will be communicated to students staff and families with an emphasis on fostering a collaborative effort to create focused and productive learning environments regular reviews and updates will be conducted to ensure that the policy remains effective and aligned with the district's goals next slide please we just wanted to include references um

208in case there is a desire for the board or the public to look at any of the research on their own um and at this point I'm happy to take any questions great thank you so much is there any public comments on the them we have no public comment great uh board members time is very tight if I may ask for your one most critical question if you have one student Reon go ahead I'm just curious if the pouches are not going to be used to band cell phone use then what do these bands actually look like yeah so if you think about it a Yonder pouch is a device of control it's not a device of policy so it means that we're asking people to comply with the rule and then there's a consequence

209if they don't um the same as any other school rule the nice thing about the pouches is they take Temptation away right and so we know that without that we're asking students to really make a mature decision on their own what do these consequences look like so that has to be developed um and so this is really a resolution to say this is what we're moving forward with right now all of our schools do a little bit different enforcement but most of it includes if a student violates a cell phone policy is it locked in the office does a parent pick it up does the student get it at the end of the period we know it looks a little bit different at every school and that's something we would need to streamline any other

210questions I'll move through uh I just have oh sorry I just have one question kind of just following up with um what trusty Luke Wilson mentioned you mentioned how there's not going to be basically an implementation using the Yonder pouches how are these these are not exactly going to be all day like restrictions like let's say for lunch or like a break for example can they have like their phone back or like they're off to like oh I got to go somewhere real quick like let's say for another example that like a student may have an emergency or something that they need like parent contact or resource to network to be able to assist them at that time how does that work yeah so the intent is that it is all day including passing periods

211and lunch um and that actually is the only way you really achieve some of the social emotional and safety goals we do know that students need to communicate right and so um when I talk to the San Mato High principle how how they do it and it's something we could think about mimicking here is let's say um a student knows something's going on at home and it's weighing and they're like I need to be able to check in they ask that teacher send the student to the office and the students given a space to make that phone call to do that check-in but it's not them standing in the hallway making the phone call right that there's sort of a a situation lunch is a little different because I think students particularly in high school

212are used to just having access so we would need to think through if you're going to make a phone call at lunch maybe there's a designated area area or space where people know hey you know this is allowed in here but you're not just standing you know in the middle of the cafeteria breaking a rule um I don't think the intent is to totally stifle communication but it is to make sure that it's happening in a productive way that answers my that answers my question thank you go ahead can you talk to us about the the speed of change in technology right because you can take my cell phone but I can do everything from my watch and then next year you may be able to take my watch but I can do everything from

213a pair of glasses or something like you click on it or whatever so with the speed of Technology how are we keeping up with the policy because we know the state moves a lot slower than what actually happens so can you speak a little bit to a little bit about what that looks like yeah I think it's going to be our constant challenge to be honest um in the book The anxious generation he really talks about how since 2010 which is when social media went to cell phones our our teens have basically quadrupled the rates of anxiety and if you think about it if from a historical perspective 15 years isn't that long usually and the advances and changes that our youth have experienced are now something that we are on the back end trying

214to deal with and so we are now trying to get ahead of this um the state did also just sign legislature requiring us to now limit social media use and I think this is all going to go together um and I think the critical thing is really our Tech filters and our filters on our devices work pretty well on our internet and our devices and that's the lever that allows us to keep up when students have access from their own devices we lose the support that we can give them okay we are super short on time would anybody like to put a motion on the floor yes I'll make a motion thank you um I'm move that we approve resolution number 2425 d51 regarding cell phone use in the school district s a second a

215okay great uh if I may ask comments be held because we're going to be talking about this is a policy so you'll have all that time to flesh out this is what I want to see what I think what I hear in policy this just really kicks off the process and with that if we'll go to a vote uh student try Wilson is there no quick home at all if you wouldn't mind saving it because we're g you're going to oh you're not going to be you might not be on the board go ahead quickly president reckler I I do think this one is really important to me so I wouldn't want it to fail because of lack of comments because in governance we talked about it for seven months so I want to make

216sure that we give it I know that we're in time but this is really important I think for students administrators and teachers um and it's just obviously the start like you said but without this then staff won't get the direction to do the policy so okay could we do like a minute comment okay I'll keep it super brief but a couple points one fear I have is that the good aspects of cell phone use will be stopped and the bad aspects will continue because students that want to get their hands on something will and I see it leading to many clashes between Educators and students I don't believe that uh this resolution should be passed if there's no consequences set in stone and in terms of anxiety rates I believe that there's many factors involved

217personally my biggest Factor would be the increase in the selectiveness of college admissions and I I feel most of my friends can attest that too um yeah that cones my comment if there wasn't anything more true than what Luke Wilson said justy Luke Wilson said about college aditions and I don't know what is because I've been checking all my tis and emails ver just any admissions but um there's one thing that comes to mind is when I think of these things is that hearing on the news about the God forbid one of the worst things to ever happen is a school shooting to happen often times the First Responders when they respond to these emergencies it's coming from the kids Fs in these situations and that's almost every single school shooting that occurs in this

218country I'm not saying that that's ever going to happen thought forbid but it is something to take in consideration the flexibility of how a phone is can be utilized in a way on the students end while also developing that maturity to when to put it away because this thing could be the best thing ever and then the worst thing ever and I'm speaking from experience cuz it's can be a distraction at times as a student but also we need to take in consideration maybe more flexibility not amongst letting just students R along with their phones but more so how they can just utilize it in a proper way because I've seen teachers and professors utilize phones in a lot of their projects for like statistics and all these things data collecting and a lot of

219times students do these projects based on like phone use technology so I think this one excellent way we can can utilize that usage but of course this is not a one said oneone thing this is going to be a continuation of things like how truste Smith mentioned about like the advancement of Technology every day thank you thank you president um thank you both student Tres for sharing that perspective also want to uh Miss Sigler there's a lot of research around the danger and the problems that techn has caused we have heard the Mental Health crisis our district suffers of suicide of um anxiety of depression and a lot of it comes from our overuse in technology and a big piece is cell phone use uh for the last 10 years what I've heard from princip

220High School principles as a huge problem is the use of Technology without the accountability and the supports um and there's a reason why by the US general general surgeon and you know the governor are saying this is a problem that we need to fix so the governance Comm talked for seven months on on really the research and the why it needs to happen and the reason we didn't bring a policy was because we want to solve those problems that were brought up with stakeholders to make sure it's done right because the stud Jes right if you know uh there's a safety issue we want students to have their phones that's why it's not a ban where you can't have your phone in your person it's it can has to be stored in your backpack right

221um and that's what's different from this to other policies that around the state that's not what we want what we wanted the purpose is not for students to not have access it's just so that it's not at school but if it there need there needs to be uh that situation they'll have it um sorry I went a little bit over time but I I want to talk about that piece because it is essential so that we can start the conversations sobody ask that we pass it and that then with the next six months staff really engages with Community all of us students students have are not part of us initial conversations in the governance committee on what that would look like including the consequences thank you go ahead I think to everyone's Point education education

222education I think that if you don't educate about the why and if you don't turn around and educate about the accountability level or the response to if it happens also think that if you don't provide those necessary um social emotional skills then everybody's just going to store it up to after school and then as soon as the bill Rings it's going to be the w w West again right I can't have it at I can't have it from Bell to Bell but I can then go across the street and Report the fight or I can go over here and do this or I'm going to go to the bathroom and use my phone so I think it's one of those things that students are the most craftiest individuals around and we need to recognize that

223and also have some Grace that if you take it away immediately or change something immediately and not give the why and give the the grace to it then it's going to create the very thing that we don't want which is like a push back against it so I think that we do it educationally gently and with students and not just against them I'm complete thank you and with that you guys have anything okay and with that to the vote student try Wilson so this is strictly for discussion voting on this full discussion on the policy the motion is to approve the resolution which kicks off the process of a policy creation with Community feedback student feedback and that's also in the law you have to do it yes is there oh yes okay yes okay

224tryand yes just click yes trusty can yes trusty Smith vs Smith vs yes and I am a yes as well okay in four minutes can we jam through uh can we move E3 which is The sunsh Shining of the uh SSA contract and then save Williams and variable term labers for Saturday yes okay so if we can move up E3 sun shining of contract Dr Johnson this is your item go ahead yes thank you superintendent Dr roses and president reckler and members of the board the district is proposing to engage in good faith bargaining with regard to the specific articles Sunshine by the district and the school supervisors Association ifpte Local 2 specifically article three salary and the salary schedule article four hiring promotion Article 5 benefits the district and SSA reserve the right to

225open other articles as needed during the negotiations and will exchange proposals at the margeting table the district reserves the right to add amend or delete proposals during contract negotiations SSA also reserves the same right thank you great thank you so much is there any public comments on this item president uh recular sorry you just got to do the uh opening the public hearing and then you clo public comment and then you close it um right after thank you for that okay so the hearing is now open we are accepting public comments in the hearing we have no public comment great and now I am closing the hearing all right there we go okay um are there any questions from board seeing none may I have a res may I have a motion I make a

226motion that we accept um the uh excuse me sorry the um initial uh can someone help me with the wording I'm so sorry the receive of the initial proposals uh for opening on negotiations for SSA I apologize slate not the problem second that is there any questions on this any comments good seeing none go to a vote oh they can't they they're not okay go ahead yes yes yes yes just yes Jesse Smith vs Smith vs yes reckler is yes motion passes unanimously we are out of time so we are going to move E1 Williams and E2 variable term labors to Saturday and I'm adjourning this meeting at 10:29 p.m. thank you everybody

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.