CorpusRecord 110098

Special Board Meeting 12-11-24

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Vimeo / WJUSD
Date
2024-12-12
Location
Yolo County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
11,171 words · about 63 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001You ready? Thank you. Welcome everyone. It's 532. Call this meeting to order of December 11th, 2024. And before we start, we'd like to inform the public that Trustee Rodriguez has requested to participate remotely. Trustee Rodriguez, would you please disclose the reason for your request? Hi, yes. The reason is because I'm still dealing with a sciatica issue, back pain, nerve pain. Scheduled for an MRI on Sunday to see if that can lead to better pathways. You don't have to give all that detail by your appointment. It's okay. Very good. Thank you, though. Is there a motion to elect Rosario Rodriguez to participate remotely? Second motion by trustee, but these is a lot second my trustee Garcia. I was a favor say aye Any position or abstentions hearing none approved by all trustees present trustee Rodriguez? Is

002there anyone present in the room with you over the age of 18? No, thank you. And please remember to speak up when you want to say something in case we miss you so Please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance We should take a moment to acknowledge the land on which we are gathered. For thousands of years, this land has been the home of the Putwin people. Today, there are three federally recognized Putwin tribes. Ketso dehi Bandawintin Indians of the Colusa Indian community, Ketso dehi Wintin Nation, and the Yocha dehi Wintin Nation. The Putwin people have remained committed to the stewardship of this land for many centuries. It has been cherished and protected as elders have instructed the young through generations. We are honored and grateful to be here today on their traditional lands. All right.

003We're going to start with public comment. But before we call. Oh, thank you. Is there a motion to approve the agenda? Second. There's a motion by Trustee Bautista-Valla, second by Trustee Garcia. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposition? Trustee Rodriguez, what was your vote? I. APPROVED BY ALL TRUSTEES. THANK YOU. THANK YOU FOR THAT. UNLESS THERE'S AN OBJECTION, WE'LL PROCEED THE SAME AS LAST TIME WHEN SOMEONE HAS A FLOOR IF YOU WANT TO ASK A QUESTION, REQUEST. YOU CAN SAY, YOU KNOW, YIELD FOR A QUESTION, CAN ASK A QUESTION, THE PERSON CAN YIELD AND GIVE YOU TIME TO ASK A QUESTION. THE PERSON CAN TAKE THEIR TIME BACK AT ANY TIME AND SAY, YOU KNOW, WOULD LIKE TO RECLAIM MY TIME AND THEY CAN CONTINUE WITH THEIR TIME. Any objection to that? Okay.

004Then we'll proceed with that. Can you repeat that one more time, please? No problem. When a person has a floor, we will not interrupt them. The only question we can ask is, you know, can I ask a question or can you go for a question? If the person says no, then you have to wait until they're done to ask your question. If the person says yes, you can ask your question, and then they can ask you a question. Okay. Thank you. Yeah. Thank you. All right. First public comment. Marlene Molina. Good evening. I am Marlene Molina. I'm a teacher at Lane Middle School, and I have been a teacher there for 29 years. In the last few weeks, I've heard a few people mention raises have caused the budget cuts, specifically our teacher raises, and

005I needed to be really clear that... We receive a COLA from the state of California, and the COLA is the cost of living adjustment. It is an adjustment, and it is a baseline to meet the inflation that is happening in our state. It is not a raise. A raise would be beyond the COLA. So according to this, there have truly been no raises in the last few years. Going back to the year of 2018-19, the COLA that we received was 6.4. Our adjustment was 1%. 2019 to 20, our COLA was 3.26 and we received $1,000. We, I mean teachers. 2020 to 2021, there was no COLA and our adjustment was 1.75. In 21-22, the COLA was 2.7 and the adjustment was 1.5. In 22-23, the COLA was 6.56 and the adjustment was 6%. In 23-24,

006the COLA was 8.22 and the adjustment was 4%. This school year, 1.07 was the COLA and our adjustment was 3%. And so when the COLA is given to us, that becomes the new baseline. It's just the baseline to ensure that we are meeting. the basic needs of inflation for our staff. And so it is looked at as guilt tripping and scapegoating our teachers when we are saying it is because we had to give you a raise that we are having to cut. We stay here not because of the money. It's very obvious. We stay here because we love our community. Many of us have had to have two jobs to meet our needs. Unfortunately, it's also well known that several of our colleagues struggle so much that they've had to go on food stamps and

007also go to food banks. This is not the reputation that our district deserves. We need to be at the very least at baseline and quit blaming our teachers. Jenna Myers. Hi, my name is Jenna Myers. I am also a teacher at Lee. I've been there for 18 years. As the district is deciding what cuts they will be making, if they're going to be making cuts, my plea to you is to please make them as far away from the kids as they can be. Tonight on the agenda is talking about literacy paraprofessionals. I think we talk about Woodland students deserve the best. Woodland students deserve to know how to read. And as a secondary history teacher, What breaks my heart is when I have students coming into my classroom that are years below grade reading level.

008And it is setting up their education for a future that I don't want for my students. That they are not able to keep up in class, that they know that their reading skills are where they are, and to do anything that would... Hurt our students in their journey to literacy. I think is unconscionable You guys have made some choices I very much appreciate that you kept our RTI in the middle school all of that stuff our students need it and We need to just make sure that any cut that's being made is as far away from the kids as possible. Thank you Irene different orum President Villagrana, can I just make a can I make a quick comment? Absolutely. Go ahead I just wanted to let folks know that if they see me coming in

009and out of the panel, it's just it's easier for me to take a few steps away and then take a few steps back sometimes. So I'm not leaving. I'm just right here to the left. I'll be right back into your screen. No worries. The only time you have to have your screen on is when you're speaking, actually. So if you need to turn it off to, you know, take care of yourself, please do so. Okay. Thank you. I'm sorry for the interruption. No worries. Thank you. Good evening. My name is Irene Diffentorum. the library tech at Dingle Elementary School. But here tonight, I'm a community member worried about our students. Our students are losing the help that they need at the schools because of decisions that you are making. When they're losing the paraprofessionals, their

010literacy paraprofessionals, those people that can help them with their struggles directly, then we're not giving our children all that they need. We're taking away from them. I spoke to you, and I will speak to you again and again about the budget. When you ask for a line budget, it shouldn't just be money here, money there, in and out, but you should actually look at the budget. Where is the money coming from? How are we using it? These are questions that we have asked. Not only as union members, not only as staff members, but as community members as well. We can't pass bonds because the transparency isn't there. We can't pass bonds because people are skeptic of how our money is used when all you see in The board report is we have this much money

011and we're going to lose these many people. Well, I'm looking at the literacy paras. It says that we will save $184,000 if we take literacy paras out. I believe that was for three. And according to my calculations, They don't make 184,000. They make closer to, if three of them, 118,000. Please show me where the discrepancy is and why. Thank you. No online comments? Okay, thank you. All right, moving on to any comments or questions from trustees? None, okay. Yep, go ahead. Yeah, can we have the superintendent comment to the accuracy of that number of the three literacy ? Yes, I'll have our budget analyst from Ed Services to help me work really closely with the cabinet and with our budget department on how we calculated this amount. Hi, good evening. I'm Catalina Ruiz, the accounting

012analyst. So that $184,000, three FTE, they actually work .75 of an FTE. So that three FTE represents four positions. And the average cost, not salary, but cost of a person is $46,000. So 46,000 times the four positions is $184,000. When you say cost, what entails cost? Salary plus benefits. Thank you. Trustee Rodriguez, I'll answer your question. So just quickly, Catalina, so it says three positions, but it's four positions because what? It's three FTEs, but one ParaPro works six hours, which is a 0.75 FTE. So one full time would be eight hours. Okay. So the way it's displayed, it is accurate. Correct. Three FTEs because it's 0.75 times four is three. Okay. Thank you very much. Yep. Know the questions all right Moving on to g1 which is review the process for four elections to board

013officers. There's attachments there that you reviewed Again, we the next meeting we're going to elect president and clerk and or vice president and appoint the superintendent a secretary of the board the right signatures Approved the schedule for regular board meetings designate board representatives to serve on committees and commissions of the district other public agencies and organizations and then review yes those are the main things we're going to be doing per our bylaws and so today and we have our future trustees in the audience which is good so they can hear today we basically Let each other know if we're interested in different positions so that we can be ready for the meeting next week now To stay why we we should be selected for those roles and so we'll start with The president position who

014was interested in being president for next year. I would like to express interest in the president position Anyone else quick question. Yes. Is this how we've done it in the past? Yes. Okay. It happens once a year, so I don't remember no worries ANYONE INTERESTED IN BEING PRESIDENT? I'M ALSO INTERESTED IN BEING PRESIDENT. NEXT MEETING WE'LL STATE WHY WE SHOULD BE SELECTED TO BE PRESIDENT AND THE VOTE WILL VOTE ON WHO TO ELECT AS PRESIDENT. WHO IS INTERESTED IN BEING VICE PRESIDENT? I'M INTERESTED IN BEING VICE PRESIDENT. ANYONE ELSE? Okay, if at that point nobody changed their mind and nobody wants to be vice president in addition to stress Rodriguez then He will be appointed vice president at that point and bring to being clerk. I am tourist to be clerk Anyone else interested in

015being clerk? Okay. So again same if nobody else changes their mind and trustee Garcia will be appointed as card. So clarification sir yes the newly-elected will also have a chance to be able to nominate themselves for these positions correct yes just unfortunately they can't say it now but yes they would definitely have the opportunity thank you other questions or comments on the process Okay, and the reason that just for context the reason we we we used to used to happen like way way back at the meeting itself it was a lot of confusion and so we decided to For people to state what what they were interested in the meeting before So that the board knew who was interested and then come back state our reasons and then the board would vote as to who

016to select for those roles So that's the reason why we added this extra basically an element of the process to give people an opportunity to know and prepare as well. But yes, at any point, someone can change their mind and someone else can nominate someone else or nominate themselves as well. I have a question. Yes. Is this the proper point to ask about or to make comment about a procedure about how we actually go about voting? Absolutely, yes. Do you have a suggestion? Yeah, my suggestion, I think in the past, what's happened is we put, so two people, A and B, want to go for a position president. In the past, we've said, okay, who wants to vote for A? and hands up and if they win, that's it. I think it's a better process

017if we go to each individual trustee and say, would you like to vote for A or B? Not just give one choice, but give both choices or however many choices there are. So, Trustee Batista Zavala, would you like to vote for Noel, Rogelio, or Bibiana? That's what I'm proposing, that it should be there. Any questions for Trustee Rodriguez? Is there any objection to his recommendation? My only comment is that the way it's done in the past is you get a nomination, you accept it, and then that person either seconds it or someone else could second it, and then you do the roll call. So I think you're suggesting something different than that. No, I'm suggesting it's the same, but during the roll call, you mentioned... All the people, not just one at a time. Right.

018So we would do a roll call for one person. And if that one person got the four, then we would never mention the second person's name. So it's the same procedure. But during the roll call, you would say, Trustee Bautista Zavala, would you like to vote for A or B? For each position individually. Yes. So for example for the clerk Each person would say the name of the person they want to elect for clerk and the person that had the most names Would then be obviously the person who would be the clerk and it wouldn't do a formal motion at that point So you would do president first and then that vote would happen Yes, and then you do the vote for VP and then the vote for sucker for clerk, correct? You go with

019that. I guess I need to see it play out I mean, it's the same procedure. It's just what type of question is being asked for the vote. Is there a yes or no, you give a name? Yes. So there would be no motion, no second? Afterwards. Okay. Okay. I'm okay with that procedure as long as the individuals that are running against each other are still eligible for the other positions. Always. Okay. Yeah. ANY OBJECTION FROM THE TRUSTEES? OKAY. SOUNDS GOOD. PLEASE REFLECT THAT IN THE MINUTES. THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT. MOVING ON TO SUBCOMMITTEE APPOINTMENTS. THERE'S A VARIETY OF COMMITTEES AND SUBCOMMITTEES THAT WE CAN REQUEST IN THE PAST. AGAIN, PEOPLE HAVE STATED THEIR INTEREST. SOME COMMITTEES HAVE ONLY ONE PERSON WITH AN ALTERNATE. SOME COMMITTEES, WE CAN HAVE UP TO THREE PER COMMITTEE. IF THERE'S

020MORE THAN THREE OR MORE THAN WHAT THE BOARD HAS DESIGNATED, IT SHOULD BE ON THE COMMITTEE. AND THEN THERE HAS TO BE A A VOTE. AND WE COULD DO THE SAME WAY AS TRUSTEE RORIGUEZ RECOMMENDED FOR THE OFFICER POSITIONS. PEOPLE CAN SAY THE NAME OF THE PERSON AND THE PERSON THAT HAS THE MOST, OR THEY HAVE TO HAVE A MAJORITY ACTUALLY, COULD BE APPOINTED TO THAT COMMITTEE. IT'S RARE THAT PEOPLE ARE CHALLENGING EACH OTHER FOR DIFFERENT COMMITTEES, BUT IT HAPPENS FROM TIME TO TIME. BUT AGAIN, THAT'S... the process we've done in the past. We try that as well. Again, a series of committees. You just review the committee descriptions. We added dates to the ones that we have the dates for and the handout. And for the new trustees, you don't have to join any

021committees. It's not required or mandatory, but it's just a way for you to get different experiences and exposure to the work of the district. Any comments from other trustees or questions? Okay. Can I just give an update? Yes. So we met this morning with a collaborative within youth committee and the group, since those dates are already in everybody's calendars for the remainder of the 2024 school year, they wanted to continue with the same dates. And so we'll add them here so that you have them at the next board meeting. And they're going to start with eight o'clock. THE MEETINGS WILL BE HELD AT WILLING COMMUNITY COLLEGE THIS YEAR. THE WILLING COMMUNITY COLLEGE WILL BE THE FACILITATOR. WE'LL MAKE THOSE ADJUSTMENTS. AND THE NEW, THERE WILL BE SOME POTENTIALLY SOME NEW PEOPLE APPOINTED FROM THE CITY

022AND POTENTIALLY FROM THE WOLF COMMUNITY COLLEGE AS WELL. BUT THE GROUP NOW SINCE IT'S ALREADY ON STAFF'S CALENDARS AND THE LOCATIONS THEY WANTED TO MAINTAIN IT FOR THE REST OF THE YEAR. THEY DID DECIDE TO CANCEL THE AUGUST MEETING BECAUSE WE CANCELLED IT LAST YEAR. I THINK WE CANCELLED IT TWO YEARS ON THE ROAD BECAUSE OF THE START OF SCHOOL. SO I JUST WANT TO GET AN UPDATE FOR THOSE OF YOU INTERESTED IN THAT COMMITTEE. THANK YOU. All right, moving on to our draft schedule. So these are the dates of the official board meetings. And there's two options. And in the end, again, it'll be potentially even a third option that we will approve at the next board meeting. And again, these are dates. that draft staff put together based on all the conflicts they're

023aware of, like, you know, conferences that already know trustees. If there's four of us going to that conference, obviously we can't hold a meeting. If there's only two of us going, then we can still hold a meeting. Or any other, you know, spring break, Thanksgiving break, those sort of things. So they try to stay to the second and fourth Thursday of the month as much as possible. But, again, that was not always possible. SO IT'S OPEN FOR COMMENTS FROM TRUSTEES SO THAT STAFF WILL BRING ANOTHER DRAFT, A FINAL DRAFT NEXT MEETING AND THEN WE WILL VOTE. BUT WE CAN STILL CHANGE IT AT THAT POINT AS WELL. SO IT'S NOT FINAL. AND EVEN THEN, AGAIN, WE COULD CANCEL MEETING OR ADD A SPECIAL MEETING AS NEEDED AS WELL. QUESTION? YES. I WOULD LIKE TO SHARE

024INFORMATION FOR YOUR BACKGROUND AS YOU DISCUSS. WE ARE RECOMMENDING OPTION ONE. OPTION TWO WAS THE ORIGINAL DRAFT THAT WAS IN THE BOARD PACKET BEFORE THE LAST MEETING WHEN WE DIDN'T GET TO THIS ITEM. AFTER HEARING SOME ADDITIONAL FEEDBACK FROM TRUSTEES AND STAFF, I DID MAKE SOME ADJUSTMENTS. BASED ON THOSE ADJUSTMENTS, I AM RECOMMENDING DRAFT NUMBER ONE. And the main changes were due to one, we have a heavy expulsion, some expulsion hearings that we need to bring to the board coming in January and staff needs enough time to go through the process. So they're going to be on vacations and we need to do the panel discussions. and go through the procedure and prepare all the documentation and also onboard our new trustees because this is the first time they're going to be going through expulsions

025and you remember how that feels and it's three of them. So they're going to be coming in hitting the ground running. We also made adjustments to the, there was too many adjustments. There was a board meeting on a Monday that was throwing people off so we adjusted the march to from option two that was a Monday march. 24th to a Thursday March 20th with also solved another Conflict because a lot of our staff will be attending copy and some of our trustees as well In fact, some of our staff will be presenting We have our Beamer staff that will be presenting the 50th anniversary, their anniversary as well, at the conference. Jerry and I will be doing a workshop, and Trustee Villagrana was also asked to be on the panel. So that's a big event

026for us, and that caused some movements. Whenever you change something, it causes an effect, so that also impacted the February date, so we had to adjust those. What else changed? And then last June, We this we had our last four mean on a Tuesday versus a Thursday So I went ahead and I'm proposing on in the second the first draft that we go back to a Tuesday because a lot of our staff are Needing to go and start on the vacation and and then I need them here at the board meeting and I don't want them to go to work over their Contract like for them to get started with the vacation. So moving it to a Tuesday so they have a little head head start on their 4th of July vacation. So those are

027some of the changes. And based on that, I am recommending option one for your consideration. Thank you. Questions or comments from trustees? Trustee Bautista Vela. Thank you. I just want to acknowledge all of the work that's gone into this. I know that I've been diligent in submitting all my questions and feedback. And I just want to say thank you for answering all my questions. I did have a conversation with Trustee Villagrana and Trustee Rodriguez about option one. Elodia took a lot of time with me this morning or this afternoon reviewing all of my questions. And the only date that I have a personal circumstance is on Thursday, February 6th. So I want to ask that the board consider a different date in conversations with Elodia. I will let you share the feedback and response that

028you had for me. After we discussed, I couldn't move it to a different week because it was back-to-back board meetings. It's very difficult for staff to turn around after a Thursday board meeting and have a board packet ready for the next Friday so that you have enough time to review. In case you were to ask for some additional information, it was like 24 hours to come up with it. I did discuss with Trustee Zavala is that what we could do is we could have that February, that first February week, it could be on a Tuesday or it could be on the Wednesday and that would work with staff. So there's some flexibility there. Which Tuesday or Wednesday are we referring to? First full week of February. So 4th or 5th? Yes, sir. Any objection to

029moving it to the 5th? My only objection is we need to wait until the new elected trustees to have an opinion on this, right? We don't decide today. No, we will not decide today. And, I mean, yeah, that is a good point. I know one of the trustees definitely has a very rigid schedule because of their instruction, and they might have modified their schedule around. the Thursday meetings. So I'm open to moving it as long as it does not cause an undue impact on the new trustees. But again, they can speak up at that point and let us know. So under that caveat, I don't have a concern to move to the fifth unless it's going to affect them. And then I would want to keep it on the six at that point. Right now.

030Thank you. Thank you for that point, Trustee Garcia. I think what my understanding was on this item is to review the board meeting schedule draft and then to continue offering as a collective feedback at this board meeting so that our superintendent and staff can then go back to the drawing board and see if there's any issues with the suggestions we bring up today. And then we would come back at the next boarding. board meeting with the revised version and then offer an opportunity for the newly elected to also offer some feedback and then us come to a consensus. But I just wanted to make sure that I expressed my concern with that date. I will also be meeting with the new trustees to review and prepare them for the next board meeting so I can

031ask them for their feedback prior to that to see if the fourth or the fifth work instead of the sixth. Can I make a comment? Yes, please. I think just in terms of the day, I think the Wednesday, we could start with the Wednesday first because that inevitably gives staff more time to prepare whatever it is that's before us there. And obviously the agenda committee, whoever that committee is at that time, will also have to be mindful of this as well. I believe that is the date that we proposed, Wednesday the 5th. So yes, . Any other comments? If you allow me, sir. I just kind of want to give you guys a very general explanation of where I'm coming from without going into my personal situation. But if you notice on the bottom of

032the board meeting schedule, it used to say that our meetings are traditionally scheduled on the second and fourth Thursday and on Thursdays. And in reviewing the board bylaws, there's nowhere in statute that it states that we are to stick to Thursdays or the second and fourth Thursday. It gives us the flexibility of moving around the dates, moving around weeks, and also offers an opportunity for the superintendent to best select dates that work around our academic schedule, availability, and other commitments. Having had these conversations, I realized that we have traditionally been meeting on the 2nd and 4th, and we've structured our personal lives and our work calendars around the 2nd and 4th to be able to be here. But now, given the limitations and availability and needs of our board meeting schedule that demands a 2025

033schedule, we're not really... at the second and fourth Thursday anymore. I made some notes here and I think not even half of them are the second and fourth Thursday. So as we look forward to the 2026 building of our meeting schedule, I think we should really revisit what are the needs of our current board. moving forward when we start looking at 2026 and what is what are the feasibilities and maybe working together in drafting what our priorities are and then our superintendent and staff can work from from there but this is just my feedback at looking at you know what what we had working with coming in for this schedule and then what we could do to help the superintendent and staff draft the 2026 board meeting schedule as this is our board meeting schedule.

034You know, this is the meeting of the board and we want to try and make sure that all of our board members are able to come. And yes, I know that as elected, we make the commitment, but sometimes we do have to keep in mind that we do have personal circumstances and I would love to be supportive to each and every one of you as I would like for you guys to be supportive of my special need. Thank you. And then just to add to that. And that would be great to get more feedback on this. I don't think we've ever had exactly the second and fourth week It was just something that we share those So it was been so it was good that we we discovered that we were putting something on there

035that we really weren't following and was not even in our bylaws But it's also, you know challenges with holidays Vacation days availability of staff so that I can have staff here to help PRESENT. BUT YES, I LOOK FORWARD TO CONTINUING TO SEE HOW WE CAN CONTINUE TO WORK TOGETHER TO HAVE THE BEST SCHEDULE POSSIBLE WITH THE ACADEMIC. calendar and all of the other events happening that you're all involved as well because all of you have other leadership roles as well and other organizations that you're involved in and we want to also support your staff development because staff development and growth for the board is also going to help the district continue making the best decisions for our students. Any other comments on the calendar? Sure and I'm sorry to eat up the time but I'm

036going to apologize. I think it's important to mention, like as much as we try to draft this schedule, sometimes board meetings change. We need to add special board meetings like the one we're having today. And I was just reflecting earlier today about how, you know, we tried really, really hard in 2024 to draft a meeting schedule that allowed for us to attend, you know, these very important events and conferences. And I remember being at CLSBA and we had planned for, you know, our... board meeting schedule for it not to be on the board on the CLSBA scheduled Unity Conference dates. But we ended up scheduling one and I ended up having to participate remotely. So I'm only bringing it up because even if we have this skeleton schedule, ideal schedule, sometimes we have to add

037meetings and it could absolutely affect, you know, our scheduled commitments. Thank you. Any other comments on the dates? If now we're going to go with option one with potentially moving February 6th to February 5th. Okay. So staff will bring that back. And then superintendent, like you said, we'll, yeah, we'll talk to the new trustees, trustee elects and see their insight or feedback on, on the schedule as well. So, all right, moving on to E facilities and finance. Any comment, public comments? Please. Rebecca Rossiter. Good evening. I'm Rebecca Rossiter and I'm here more as a community member than I am union representation. I just I don't have a planned comment today specifically written out but I wanted to make a few points. In the updated budget adjustment packet there's $342,000 $342,500 needed that need to be

038cut still. 1% of an additional cut to district departments would cover $210,000 and elimination of the vacant assistant superintendent position would eliminate $256,401. That's more than what you need. That will affect It will affect staffing. It will increase workload on a lot of people behind me. I know this. But it doesn't directly affect the students. You're not taking a person out of their classroom who is going to help them learn how to read. You're not taking people out of the classroom who helps the teacher support a combo class. Some comments were made at the last board meeting about the other districts and how they've done cuts and Pasadena and how they've had 224 ESSER fund positions eliminated. 91 of those positions were already vacant. 30% of those cuts came from the district office. They also

039eliminated their assistant superintendent position because it was vacant. Modesto has a budget advisory committee that consists of two teacher union members, two CSCA union members, four parents, a community member, two site principals, and two district manager positions. I just want to point those things out. There are other options than what the listed options in the packet. You can mix and match. Also want to just make the point that there has been misleading information and like the 3f te really means for people Across the board packets And the other mention is that sites have been cutting their budget At least Douglas has had their budget cut every year for at least the last five or six years They shouldn't be on the board packet as an option. That's all I have to say. Thank you. Next,

040please. Becca Bernard. Good evening. I'm also here as a community member and a teacher. And I first want to start with a moment of gratitude to Trustee Bautista Zavala and Trustee Rodriguez. We've both been in meetings three nights in a row, well into the night, to serve our community. And I appreciate all that you all do, but especially the two of you for the last three days in a row. Yesterday, the two of you were present with six of our seven school nurses, and I want to appreciate that you came to listen to the experts. And that there was a bit of frustration at the last meeting that we discussed this topic because although I appreciate very much Dr. Felicia Wilson for putting together amazing slides and doing all of the work, unfortunately she is

041not a doctor of medicine or a nurse. And our nurses felt... little upset that they weren't consulted and that they weren't Asked how this would impact their workload how it would affect their health team and so I just want to bring up that while these conversations are very important and We appreciate that our district cares about balancing a budget We also aren't bringing up the people who are affected unless they come on their own volition and and come to a board meeting and give public comment so recognizing that we did not just pass Measure P and one of the issues is community trust and relationships. These are examples of times when you can build those relationships by asking the people who are affected to come and speak and share their expertise. So that's just one

042thing I'd like to bring up and I'd again like to thank all the nurses who organized that meeting and shared their opinions on the matter. And I also want to recognize that we have $60 million in reserves. And when are we going to have a conversation about how we can spend those down to a healthy level? I was in a union meeting Monday, I think. 20 other districts were represented, and we were the third highest reserve. Everyone else was around 15 to 20 percent and ours was at 38 percent. That was not it did not feel good to sit in that meeting and recognize that we are not spending our money on our students right now. So I would love to know when we are going to talk about those reserves. For now have a

043wonderful holiday. Thank you. Moving on to E1 presentation from the superintendent. Okay, good evening. We're here to continue a discussion on the budget adjustments and reductions I'm gonna apply through some of these these Power slides because you've seen them before but I have them here available for background background information in case you need to refer back Okay, this is not working okay now we can't even see it okay, yes, okay, so if you can just click really quick We started this the purpose of ADDRESSING OUR $7.2 MILLION NEEDED TO ADDRESS OUR DEFICIT SPENDING. AND JUST TO POINT OUT, PASADENA HAS $50 MILLION DEFICIT SPENDING. THEY HAD TO GO REALLY, REALLY DEEP. WE ARE VERY BLESSED WE ARE NOT IN THAT SITUATION. WE ARE HERE TO ADDRESS OUR DEFICIT SPENDING BECAUSE OUR INTENTION IS TO BE

044ABLE TO CONTINUE PROVIDING MORE, BE IN A BETTER POSITION TO BE PROVIDING RESOURCES AND SUPPORTS AND RISKS FOR OUR TEACHERS. NEXT SLIDE. We went over discuss the consideration so we continue the process of using those who continue I've talked about these already Again focusing on our LCAP goals of being trying to see where we can move reduced and eliminate and still keep the focus on our LCAP goals and depending on how deep we go then I will have to come back to the board and be very honest and say we can't do certain things anymore, but we're trying to keep the focus on that Keeping the focus on our priorities next slide So these are just, again, trying to keep our focus on a priority. I'll have to talk a little bit more about the

045literacy plan and the impact to the literacy paras in a bit. Continue. And the board approved $7.2 million adjustment to the general fund by doing a 5% reduction to all department budgets and transitioning some of those funds to LCAP and other funds. Continue. And so just click through all those as approved. So there's lots of work that the board has done to approve. Continue on. Contracts continue there's movement on staff hours and extra hours continue materials and supplies being over three million dollars continue We had needed to look at other pet positions as well as an amount of 1.8 million dollars continue the board met on the number 20 First and made some difficult decisions on additional cuts and we have a remaining three hundred and forty two Hundred and sixty five dollars still left

046in order to meet our target continue So here's the summary thought I'll go discussion here. So again, we the target was seven point two million dollars need to make adjustments in the general fund moving Expenditures ongoing expenditures out of the general fund to address our deficit spending and we the board on November the 19th took action on six point four million dollars in so Then we met again on the 21st AND AGAIN, IT'S 342. SO AT THE BOARD MEETING ON THE 21ST, THE BOARD ASKED ME TO COME, THE 19TH, I'M SORRY, THE BOARD ASKED ME TO COME BACK AND GIVE YOU SOME SUGGESTIONS ON WHAT WE CAN DO TO FIND THOSE 342 ADDITIONAL ADJUSTMENTS TO THE BUDGET. NEXT SLIDE. SO THIS IS WHAT I'M PROPOSING. I'M PROPOSING THAT WE MEET OUR TARGET BY TAKING ACTION

047ON THE FIRST FIVE ITEMS. I'M GOING TO DISCUSS THEM. I'M WITH YOU SHORTLY. THE FIRST ONE IS CTE COORDINATOR. WE HAVE A FULL-TIME CTE COORDINATOR. THANK YOU. I CANNOT FIND MY PAPER. WE HAVE A FULL TIME CTE COORDINATOR AND AT THE TIME OF THE INITIAL DISCUSSIONS, DOING OUR ANALYSIS OF WHAT WE CAN MOVE AND ADJUST, AT THE TIME, STAFF HAD ALREADY REACHED OUT TO CTE IN THE PAST, LIKE LAST YEAR ACTUALLY, AND THE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION DID NOT AT THAT POINT APPROVE US PAYING A POSITION FULLY OUT OF CTE FUNDS. So I asked staff to review that again and to have additional discussions and to contact the Department of Education again. Based on that, we got positive results and they did allow us to put the other 50% into the LCAP, saving us half of

048that position out of the LCAP to make space. We also have an admin secretary three that we were able to identify as a That's paying half of their position out of ELOP to justify that and so we're able to move another 39 and Then we looked at our literacy paraeducators and I might need so literacy paraeducators. So To reduce by three point FTE. That's actually for People but it's three three FTE total budget wise when we're looking at the budget We're looking at we look at it as FTE. That's the language that we use us and we keep track That's how it's in our system, but it's actually FOUR PEOPLE THAT COVER THE 3 FTE. YOU HEARD OUR BUDGET ANALYSIS EXPLAIN HOW THAT WAS CALCULATED. I HAD HR RESEARCH BECAUSE WE HAVE BEEN THROUGH A

049LOT ALREADY. THE BOARD HAS BEEN THROUGH A LOT, OUR COMMUNITY HAS BEEN THROUGH A LOT, OUR STAFF HAS BEEN THROUGH A LOT. I JUST WANTED TO SEE WHERE I CAN FIND WAYS THAT WE CAN ADDRESS THIS LAST PIECE WITHOUT HAVING TO FACE POTENTIALLY PEOPLE LOSING THEIR LIVELIHOOD THROUGH THIS PROCESS. SO WE DID SOME RESEARCH, ASKED FOR THREE YEARS OF DATA OF HOW MANY PARA EDUCATOR TURN OVER WE'VE HAD. AT THE START OF THE YEAR, BECAUSE WE ALWAYS HAVE POSITIONS OPEN. I WANTED TO KNOW HOW MANY DO WE HAVE? WHAT IS THE AVERAGE? AND THE AVERAGE IS 10 POSITIONS. We have over 78 paraeducators in the district and 56% of them, 49 of them, are literacy paras. So that's more than half. SO WE CAN FEEL COMFORTABLE ESTIMATING THAT ABOUT FIVE OF THEM, THOSE POSITIONS, WILL

050BE POSITIONS THAT WE'RE HAVING TO FACE IN THE BEGINNING OF THE YEAR. WE DO THIS ALL THE TIME BECAUSE WE ADDRESS IT WITH THE STAFF. WE'RE VERY CONFIDENT, CAN'T GUARANTEE YOU 100%, AND WE HAVE AN ODD YEAR FOR WHAT REASON, BUT IN THE LAST TWO YEARS, WE'VE HAD TEN POSITIONS. SO WE'RE COMFORTABLE MAKING THIS RECOMMENDATION AND FEELING THAT THAT WILL BE A LOW INCOME OF CURRENT PEOPLE IN POSITIONS. You need to feel like anything else okay, so that is the recommendation for that piece Recommendation number four is reducing five percent of site discretionary fence. We've done a lot to try to protect everything we could from the sites AND WE HAVE TALKED TO THE PRINCIPALS ABOUT THIS. IT'S 20,000 ACROSS THE DISTRICT SO IT'S VERY LIMITED IMPACT BUT IT'S FINDING WAYS WHERE WE CAN FIND

051SOME OF THE ADDITIONAL FUNDS AND SO IT WOULD BE VERY LIMITED IMPACT. THEY WOULD STILL BE ABLE TO RUN AND FUNCTION THEIR PROGRAMS. AND I'M TRYING TO PROTECT EVERY DEPARTMENT INCLUDING OUR SCHOOL SITES TO STILL BE ABLE TO FUNCTION AND RUN THEIR PROGRAMS. I ALSO LOCATED, WE ALSO HAD AN ADMIN SECRETARY LEVEL FOUR, A VACANT POSITION IN THE DISTRICT OFFICE. AFTER DISCUSSING WITH STAFF, DISCUSSING ABOUT THE ROLE AND HOW WE COULD ABSORB THAT IN OTHER AREAS, WE WERE ABLE TO AGREE TO THAT WE COULD ELIMINATE, RECOMMEND THE ELIMINATION OF THAT POSITION OF A .5. SO BASED ON THE FIRST TWO, FIVE RECOMMENDATIONS, meets our goal. The total would be $342,500, a few hundred dollars more, but it would meet our target of $7.2. There's two other recommendations that I have options to consider, and of

052course there's other options that you've discussed in the past that I did not add, but you can definitely bring them up. or any other ideas that you'd like to discuss is to reduce the flex program only to secondary and transition elementary into the k-8 independent study program the reason i hesitate making that a recommendation but an option for you to consider is that i feel kids our students and families need options and for some of our families and students that is an option that has been very I WANT TO POINT OUT THAT OUR ELEMENTARY PROGRAM IS VERY LOW ENROLLMENT. WE WILL HAVE TO KEEP A CLOSE EYE ON THAT AND POTENTIALLY IN THE FUTURE I MIGHT NEED TO COME BACK TO THE BOARD AND POTENTIALLY ELIMINATE IT. I'M NOT QUITE READY TO MAKE THAT RECOMMENDATION.

053IT'S AN OPTION BUT NOT A RECOMMENDATION. Also, our Kamba paraeducators. We had three FTE positions. We are in process it we have a hard time finding paraeducators So right now we're in process We just found two and one is still open and I just feel like it's too early since the board just approved the combos To pull them out when we haven't had a chance for the teachers to benefit from those combat those combo paraeducators So but that's an option since we aren't not used to those positions yet you know, but WE DID HAVE THAT CONVERSATION AT THE BEGINNING OF THE SCHOOL YEAR AND THAT WAS ONE OF THE ACTIONS THE BOARD APPROVED TO SUPPORT OUR COMBINATION TEACHERS. SO I'M HERE TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS AND REQUESTING THAT THE BOARD CONSIDER APPROVING ONE THROUGH FIVE

054TO BALANCE AND MEET OUR TARGET OF 7.2 BUDGET ADJUSTMENTS. WHO HAS QUESTIONS? NO QUESTIONS? WE'RE READY FOR DISCUSSION THEN. TRUSTEE RODRIGUEZ, YOU HAVE A QUESTION? I HAVE A QUESTION ABOUT THE a line item on the literacy paras. So I'm not sure that I quite understand exactly what that means. Are we saying that every school right now has one para educator to work on literacy? No, we have more than that. We have right now 49 literacy paras. The 49, we have support for all our kinder, first, second, and third grade teachers all get some support in the classroom with para. So depending on how, some schools only have two kindergarten classes. Some schools have four kindergarten classes. So depending how big the school is. The you know, they have to get additional Paris for support and

055literacy. They've been coming and getting training. We invested a lot of work with them So what I'm proposing is because we have turnover Natural turnover and that's a place that we can naturally reduce without having to the work that we can potentially avoid any layoffs and We and then we I can adjust and prioritize our most ACADEMIC NEEDED SCHOOLS. I'M NOT SAYING SOME OF OUR SCHOOLS WILL NOT RECEIVE ANY PARA EDUCATORS, BUT I'LL GIVE YOU AN EXAMPLE. SPRING LAKE, FOR EXAMPLE, RIGHT NOW THEY HAVE THREE PARA EDUCATORS. SO POTENTIALLY, YOU KNOW, THEY MAY END UP WITH JUST TWO OR 1.5. I WOULD LOOK AT IT THROUGH THE EQUITY LENS AND THROUGH THE STUDENT ACHIEVEMENT NEEDS AND PUT THE PARA EDUCATORS WHERE THE HIGHEST ACADEMIC NEEDS ARE AT WITH THIS PROPOSAL. So in eliminating these positions,

056are we actually eliminating people that are currently working? Right now, what I'm saying right now is that every year we have 10 positions. Every year in the last three years, I have naturally turned over because they move. OUT OF WINDLAND OR MOVE INTO OTHER POSITIONS. THEY GET ADVANCEMENT IN OTHER POSITIONS THAT PAY MORE MONEY. THEY GET INTO A DIFFERENT JOB. I ASKED FOR OUR HR DEPARTMENT TO GIVE ME WHAT IS THE NATURAL TURNOVER IN THIS ROLE. WHAT CAN WE EXPECT? EVERY YEAR WE HAVE 10 POSITIONS. that the average in the last three years has been the trend. Unless we have an odd year where all of a sudden nobody leaves, but that's very unlikely. That is very, very highly likely that we would not have to lay anybody off. I can't guarantee you. I can

057only base it on the data and the trends that I have. We're saying these FTE positions are basically positions that go unfilled. Because of people leaving. And that's the amount of time that people leave essentially add up to these FTEs. So a person would start the year, but they don't finish the year. And so this is an accumulation of time that goes vacant because we can't fill it as a natural process of people leaving. Is that what we're saying? What I'm saying is at the beginning of the year. we're trying to hire at least 10 paraeducators for this specific you know for uh in these areas and we're saying that out of the 40 uh 78 paraeducators 49 of them half of them more than half of them are literacy paras so out of 78

058if there's 10 of them that we're constantly having to fill BECAUSE PEOPLE MOVE AND WE HAVE TURNOVER. THAT IS THE TREND. WE HAVE THE DATA TO ANALYZE THAT. AT LEAST HALF OF THEM ARE LITERACY PARENTS. I'M PROPOSING THAT WE REDUCE ONLY FOUR. WE WOULD END UP WITH 45. LITERACY PARIS. THAT MEANS I WOULD HAVE 45 TO PLACE ACROSS OUR SCHOOLS AND I WOULD PLACE THEM USING THE EQUITY LENS AND MAKING SURE THAT ALL OUR SCHOOLS HAVE LITERACY PARIS BUT MAKE SURE THAT WE PRIORITIZE OUR MOST NEEDED SCHOOLS AND REDUCE IN THE SCHOOLS THAT HAVE THE LESS NEED. THEY ALL HAVE NEEDS BUT SOME HAVE LESS NEEDS SO I WOULD REDUCE A LITTLE. in those areas and I would look at it through an equity lens you data to review it rank schools and use that

059process and then you know sites would have a sign para and they could decide which classrooms would need the support. Okay thank you. Any other questions trustee Rodriguez? Not at this time. Okay anyone else has questions? Trustee Bautista-Vela? Thank you. FOR THE ITEM 3, LITERACY PARAPROFESSIONALS, DO WE HAVE THESE 4.75 FTE VACANT RIGHT NOW? LIKE RIGHT THIS MINUTE? CAN YOU COME HELP ME ANSWER THE QUESTION? I MEAN, TRUSTEE. SUPERINTENDENT. Yes, so no. Well, we do have vacancies, but this particular adjustment is based on funding where we don't have vacancies right now for the literacy paras. So the answer is no to that. So, sorry, would these four individuals be able to move over to the existing unfilled positions? So if the if the board decides to reduce a particular classification Then we would look at

060the individual seniority to see if first and foremost they could at the time Be moved to a vacant position in that same classification And then look to see also if they have any rights to other positions. So I think what superintendent was was referring to is that because we have turnover each year in this classification and about five in the literacy para group that technically the savings could be obtained by just choosing not to fill a vacant position that may become vacant between now and the end of the year. Thank you, and then number seven the combo pair of professionals my understanding is Is that these are the newly newly hired pair of professionals to help alleviate the combo classes at some of our elementary schools are those four people in Three, I'm sorry are

061those three full-time employees or those four point seven five FTE Those are those are six hour positions and we are onboarding three people right now for those positions Okay, so those three FTE are those three point six people Can you stay up there, please? Sorry, I just want to make sure no you're good Each position is six hours a day. And so six hours is the equivalent of 0.75 FTE a full day is eight hours a day So there's four total positions, right, of six hours each position. Okay. Just so my colleagues know, I'm asking these questions in the event that we don't want to reduce the three FTE or four people. you know if we wanted to reduce and make an equitable reduction to the combo to the combo pair of pros and the

062literacy pair of pros now we know what the equivalency is I'm not sick I'm not saying I'm not proposing that right this second but that's why I'm trying to figure out how many people we're talking about thank you so much Lini other questions or those are your questions that's it and the trustees have questions Nope, okay, so ready for discussion on these adjustments Do you want to do like the last time we're going one by one? I'd like to go by one by one. Okay, so is there a motion to move Point for 50% of the CT from El cap to the CT funds for the CTE coordinator So moved second. There's a motion by trustee Richard. All are second by trustee about the savala. I was a favor say aye aye Trustee Rodriguez, I

063didn't hear you. Aye. Thank you. Any opposition or abstention? Hearing none, approved by all trustees present. Is there a motion to approve the reduction of three FTEs, literacy, parapros, reduced or prioritized low-performing schools only for $184,000? Motion to approve. Is there a motion? Is there a second? Second motion by Trustee, but so I'll a second my trustee might also favor say aye. Discussion opportunity for discussion. Yes. Thank you. Yeah, I have to say that I'm not I'm not in favor of this. I think that I know that we've asked them to come back with cuts and this is you know part of what they came back with but to me there's so much need. that we still need those positions. And it's correlated to our number one goal. It is a way to help balance

064the budget, but I just don't think this is the way to do it. We said we were committed to literacy. It's our number one goal. This to me does not match up well with what we're saying are our priorities, right? Even though we would recalibrate, perhaps, you know, for the most neediest schools still, even if it's a... I'm sorry. I think the president skipped number two. I thought we were talking about number two. No, I said number three. I skipped number two. Okay, then I agree. I'm sorry. Let's start over. I'm taking back my motion. Yeah, listen to what I say. So if I make a mistake, you can catch me. So, okay, let's go back to, sorry, Trustee Rodriguez, we're going to restart it because there was misunderstanding as to what we're- Is there

065a reason why we're jumping to three? I just missed it. Okay, so. All right, so let's stay to three, the discussion, we're having the discussion, and we'll have the vote, and then we'll go back to two since we're already here. So, all right, go ahead, Trustee Rodriguez. With no motion. No motion, yeah. Okay, so we're on three still. Everything you said still applies. Wait, there's a motion on the table. Well, yes. So we're in the discussion. So after discussion, we have to vote on the motion. It was motion based on incorrect information. But we still have a motion on the table. So after we do discussion, we have to vote on the motion. Is the motion still the one you made? Unless you rescinded. But right. I don't want, I'm retracting my motion because I'm

066not. Yeah, it was not the motion that she wanted to make. Okay. Trustee Rodriguez, go ahead. So in order for me to discuss it, that discussion only happens after? No, we can discuss before and after. Oh, okay. So essentially, I just don't think it calibrates well with where we want to go as a board, where we set our priorities are. I know it's an option, but I don't think it's a very good option. I think we can still go back and look at some other things before we have to come back to something like this. I understand that, you know, there may be some natural attrition and natural space because of attrition and to be able to maybe accommodate some of this. But the fact is that I don't think we should be thinking that

067way. We should be thinking about what we need to do to fill these positions because we know that literacy is a great need for our most vulnerable students. So this is I'm just not ready and I don't really think this is. I don't think this is a good option for us. And I don't think it matches the need, the deep needs that we know are currently here. We'll have to go somewhere else for this, I think. Thank you. Any other, Trustee Richard Felder? I completely agree with Trustee Rodriguez. I am when this is our first priority and the last time we had decent ELA scores on our dashboard was over five years ago. I think that we need to go hell bent for leather focusing on our literacy. I appreciate that you guys are finding

068positions that are fulfilled switching things over. But again, I stick with my prior recommendations requests that we do one more percent for the district departments and see where that gets us, because I am not down with our literary scores. I mean, and this is me coming off of our staff meeting where we went over our dashboard records. So this is in the forefront of my mind. I'm not down with cutting the literacy paras. Other comments trustee, but so thank you I think we really need to identify, like, what is the issue that we're having turnover with our paraprofessionals? You know, is it salary? Is it, you know, the coaching, the training, the support? You know, what are they leaving to? And, you know, what is our strategy for hiring and filling these positions within a

069timely manner before the academic year starts? I brought up, you know, asking the questions of, you know, how many positions were actually in the combo pair pros i needed to better understand you know what that what that body meant um i i'm not i'm not there yet okay let's see that's three who are not so there's really no point of asking for a motion okay let's go back to number two then admin secretary two which is move um 0.5 ft uh into elop so moved There's a motion by Trustee Rich Fowler, second by Trustee Bautista Valla. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposition? Trustee Rodriguez that was aye. Aye. Perfect. All right. Moving on to four which is a reduction so five percent reduction to site discretionary funds. Any comments or questions from

070board members? Total of twenty thousand dollars across all schools. I have a question. Trustee Butler and then Trustee Rodriguez. So this 5% reduction, how will that be distributed across all of our sites? So we would look, some school sites have access to Title I funds, supplemental concentration. Some school sites only have discretionary funds and a little bit of LCAP. So for example, Spring Lake and Samora. THEY DON'T HAVE TITLE I MONEY, SO THEY WOULD NOT, I WOULD NOT REDUCE THEIR BUDGETS. IT WOULD JUST BE THE SCHOOL SITES THAT HAVE ACCESS TO OTHER FUNDING SOURCES. OUR SCHOOLS ARE ALSO RECEIVING ADDITIONAL FUNDS FROM THE ARTS PROP 98, 28, 28, THANK YOU, 28 FUNDING. SO FOR EXAMPLE, I DON'T HAVE THE EXACT NUMBER, BUT I DO KNOW close it's very close a pioneer high school would be

071receiving two hundred thousand dollars of money supporting VAPA and So that will support some of the expenditure expenditures. So they're receiving other there's other funds that school sites are getting so they will have ability to shift some of those expenditures in some areas and So they'd be able to afford losing a thousand two thousand dollars potentially from their budget but i would be protecting the schools that do not have access to additional funds like spring lake and some more using the equity lens because those still students needs to be served and they don't have those funds so i would be using our equity lens and making sure that everybody has what they need to run their school just richard fowler does answer your question yeah it answers my question any other questions trustee oligas and

072and so this twenty thousand dollars part of my understanding is that All our sites don't always spend all the money that's allocated to them. And so is it my understanding that this $20,000 represents that portion of monies that our schools aren't actually utilizing? Would that be a correct interpretation of what this $20,000 is? Yes or no. Our school sites tend to use this money quicker and fast because it's discretionary. They can use it on anything they want. It's easier to spend it without having to use their Title I money. The money that they have carryover in is Title I. which is the most important money to spend because Title I is specifically directed for intervention of our most needy kids. So I want them to be more focused and using Title I and more direct

073and using the carryover and not this other that's more discretionary. And so they'll need to, I have some schools that have 80% of their Title I that has not been spent. It's already December. Right, so they'll what they do is there's monies that they could be using Title one money instead of discretionary. It's just easier to spend the discretionary So this just kind of refocuses our schools to actually spend their monies better and in the right areas And so because that seems is that that kind of a common thing in essence? Yes and so because we're having trouble getting through our Section one is that what it's called? I'm sorry. Title one. Title one. Yeah. Title one monies that in essence, we do have these pool of leftover monies in discretionary because we're not able

074to get through these title one monies fast enough, right? For them to then consider the rest of the monies that they have left. Yeah. So I can give you an example. So if I want to spend title one money, you have to align it to what goal are you trying to meet in your school plan? They have to identify what goal, right? Discretionary money, you don't have to. You just do a purchase order. So they'll spend that one faster. And that's the general fund. That's what we're trying to address right now. We're trying to address the general fund. So I'd rather have them spend down their Title I money because we're an underperforming district and we should be using those monies more. and more effectively to meet the needs of our students versus discussionary funds.

075And so I hope that sample helps. Yeah, no, so let me ask another question this way. And so is there, by asking them to utilize all their Title I monies, is there any, does that allow them to essentially have the same expenditures that they would if they use their discretionary as well? Title I monies, no, discretionary monies is different ways of using funds. So for example, in Title I you have to do above and beyond the core. So an additional support for parents, additional support for intervention, additional support for additional staff development. Discussionary money. It could be used for lunch for staff. It could be used for, there's less limitations and less focus. Less impact in that money. Yes. Right? Less impact. Not that they don't need those funds, but they can do it without

076$1,000, $2,000 and help out with this process. And that would be my third question is what is the largest impact that a school would have by utilizing these $20,000? What impact are we aware that it would have that something that would happen that wouldn't? So if I was a principal and I had let's say $15,000 and my budget was reduced $1,000, the impact may be, Oh, maybe I don't buy certain materials. One of the things that happens at the end of the year, you see a lot of POs that people haven't spent their money, and they start buying stuff, supplies, and actually people, teachers get a list, like, what are your wish lists, you know, and what is your wish list so they can spend down the money. So maybe that wish list may be

077a little smaller, but we're only talking about $1,000, $2,000 for that. Peace. Okay. Yeah, I mean I think that's an impact you know that's not none of this is desirable this whole process has not necessarily been the most desirable process of it has been a difficult coming up and making these recommendations But you know we've been trying to do the best that we can that's not going to directly impact our goals That we can still function and deliver services as by departments that departments is to function as people are expecting to have their laptops working, they're expecting to have our computers, our cyber protection, they're expecting the contracts for K-12 informed instead of doing paper. So there's a lot of things that we need to function and run as an organization. That is the reason

078I would not. recommend recommend another percent from departments the one percent from departments also just to clarify the department budgets includes all the salaries as well so that percentage cut is bigger than what the impact would be for the discretionary funds from the school sites because discretionary sites for the school site does not conclude positions so if you see a BUDGET IN THE DEPARTMENT INCLUDES ALL THE POSITIONS SO THERE'S A BIGGER HIT WHEN YOU TAKE A PERCENT. I JUST WANTED TO EXPLAIN THE DIFFERENCE OF THE 1% IS NOT EQUAL THE WAY THAT WE LOOK AT IT THROUGH THE BUDGET, HOW IT'S OUTLINED IN THE BUDGET. So the impact would be minimal but again our sites are also going to receive a big chunk of money that I haven't received before for VAPA. I think like

079I said $200,000. I don't know why I remember that one. Some schools are going to be getting $85,000, $40,000. They're going to be receiving next year. They have to develop plans for them. A lot of our school sites use our discretionary funds to pay for an assembly. And they could use that VAPA money to do a VAPA type of assembly for students. Other things, and enrichment that they do with those discretionary funds. So they will have other funds that they will have access to. So just lastly, I'd like to say I think this, well, I don't like doing it. This sounds like it would have minimal impact, so I think I tend to be more in favor of something like this. And then especially, I mean, I'm not sure where the right place would be,

080but we talked about this at the previous meeting where, you know, whatever decisions we make, I would like to have, you know, a survey, a follow-up about the impact of those decisions down the road so that if for some reason there is an impact that the board is aware. That's an important impact, and maybe we can pivot in a different way, possibly using one-time monies to correct or maybe undo a decision. I don't know. But in terms of trying to find a lower impact, I know it all has impact. I think I tend to be in favor of moving forward this way, and as long as we're following up about what the impact actually is so we're aware of it. Is there any questions, Trustee Rodriguez? Anyone else? Trustee Grieser-Fowler? I'm incredibly concerned to hear

081that we're not using all of our Title I funds since they go to approve student achievement, and we know where we are. I'm okay with the site not having spent over 81% of their Title I funds in December. considering if they have a big initiative coming up in the spring or if they have gotten permission to use that 15% carryover for the next year if they've got a good initiative coming. That being said, I'm not okay with cutting the $20,000 considering all sites that get Title I funds should be exhausting that fund because, again, it goes to improvement of student achievement and educational programs. And those funds can be spent on instructional material, PBIS strategies, counseling, behavioral intervention, professional learning. parent engagement so I absolutely do not see why we're leaving money on the table

082and I would really like to get a little bit more clarification on why we are leaving money on the table when that money I repeat yet again goes to improvement of a student achievements and our dashboard numbers are not where they need to be other questions or comments use me I know I'm waiting for an answer ARE WE LEAVING TITLE I FUNDS? ARE WE LEAVING MONEY ON THE TABLE BY THE END OF THE FISCAL YEAR? THAT IS WHY WE HAVE CARRY OVER ISSUES. WE HAVE TO ADDRESS THAT ISSUE. ONE AREA OF CARRY OVER. There's different. What percentage. Like how much of the funds are we actually spending on Title 1. I don't I'm not prepared to answer that question. I can. I'm really concerned to hear relieving that much money on the table for Title

0831. Yes, it is a concern so we have been Working on providing more support for our with budget for our principals. We've been doing budget reviews and that's why I know already what who's spending what now because I'm Monitoring that and to see what support our principals need And what support our office staff to support the principals need as well. I'm helping them with You know addressing how they're using their budget A LOT OF IT IS BECAUSE THEY ARE NOT ABLE TO FILL POSITIONS. THAT'S A BIG ONE. SOMETIMES THEY TEND TO, THEIR INTENTIONS ARE TO HIRE EXTRA SUPPORT STAFF AT THE SCHOOL SITE AND THEY'RE NOT ABLE TO FILL THEM BECAUSE OF STAFFING SHORTAGES. THAT'S ONE OF THE MAIN REASONS. BUT, YES, THAT IS A REALITY. ANYTHING ELSE? TRUSTEE RUSHENFELDER? YEAH, DEFINITELY. Good information and

084that's one of the things that has happened because the staff was has delved deep into the budget They were able to identify some of these things that will be corrected now They were happening without you know again awareness So that's you know again There's been some positive things that have resulted from us doing a deep dive into and we've identified other things that have been corrected as well So it's a good thing trustee, but so Allah Thank you. I want to echo Trustee Fowler's comments and feedback and her sentiment. But I also have to her points. Do we require for our site leadership to submit plans for site discretionary funds and Title I funds at the beginning of the year that states like what they're going to be doing with their money? So there's school

085plans. There's a budget portion in the school plans that comes to the board Yeah, and in that school plan they have to show their budget and has to be approved by a school site council So if the budgets have been approved, why aren't they spending the money? like yes part of it is Like I just mentioned is when you support on how to spend their money how to better plan ahead and also some accountability I've had conversations and I DON'T LIKE TO SURPRISE THEM. I TOLD THEM, YOU ARE HEARING FROM OUR UNIONS AND THE PUBLIC ABOUT OUR CARRY OVER. IT IS NOT ONE PARTICULAR BUDGET. IT IS A LITTLE BIT HERE AND A LITTLE BIT THERE. THEIR BUDGETING AS WELL IS PART OF THE CHALLENGE. A HUGE CHALLENGE WE HAD HERE AT THE DISTRICT OFFICE,

086SPEAKING OF THE CHALLENGE OF THE CARRY OVER, IS ALL THAT ONE TIME MONEY THAT WE GOT. We were hit with over 30 million dollars of budget that came to us and we needed to we didn't want to lose it because if you don't spend it you lose it and there's other monies that you can carry over and some money that you can't carry over either you spend it or you don't spend it so we want to take advantage of this and you've heard about all the ESSER funds and one of the directions from my board was do not send a penny back to this. TO THE STATE OR FEDERAL GOVERNMENT ON THE COVID MONEY THAT WE RECEIVED AND THE ONE-TIME MONEY THAT WE RECEIVED. SO THAT CREATED SOME OF THE CARRY OVER OF THE DISTRICT.

087AND WE'RE NOT THE ONLY DISTRICT HAVING THE RESULTS OF A BUDGET. AND WE WILL BE LOOKING INTO THAT FURTHER. BUT THAT DOESN'T ADDRESS THE GENERAL FUND ONGOING MONEY AND BALANCING THE BUDGET THAT THE BOARD HAS ASKED ME TO DO REGARDING THE YOU KNOW THE GENERAL BUDGET SO THAT'S A DIFFERENT DISCUSSION BUT RIGHT NOW UM IS ADDRESSING OUR OUR GENERAL FUND AND THE DEFICIT SPENDING AND BEING ABLE TO MAKE SURE THAT WE'RE PREPARED TO CONTINUE MEETING THE COMMITMENT THAT WE'VE MADE ON THE ONGOING EXPENDITURES WE HAVE TO UH TO ADDRESS THE RAISES THAT WE GAVE TO ALL STAFF NOT JUST TEACHERS OUR CLASSIFIED STAFF OUR ADMINISTRATION STAFF EVERYONE SO I think we need to do a check-in with our sites and seeing how they're doing quarterly on the spending of those budgets. When you say you

088know our site councils have helped draft and voted on these proposals There's a lot of time and effort that goes into that by our teachers and parents and sitting there at site council meetings to put this together And then when the money is not being spent in the areas that they have designated Who's holding them accountable for the spending? So I mean I would really I know you know I'm I'm talking about this in terms of our budget adjustments. So like we also need to make sure that we are doing our part for accountability. But I'm also not in favor of the 5% reduction on site discretionary funds. I know it sounds like $20,000 is not very much, but just this year I was. I was commending how Lee Middle School was using site discretionary

089funds to pay for our students ASB stickers and how that was a really good use of site discretionary funds. And I'm only bringing that up as an example of what I would fear to be a cut because of these $20,000. Because that's something that's new and innovative. And they were just trying it out this year. So I know it sounds like not that much money. But I fear that something like that, that's so well received by our students and families would be the first on their chopping board. Other questions or comments? No for discussion then? Okay, is there a motion to reduce 5% the site discretionary funds for a total of $20,000? Motion. Is there a motion to approve? Is there a second? Second. Second by Trustee Rodriguez. DO A ROLL CALL VOTE. TRUSTEE RODRIGUEZ.

090YES. TRUSTEE MOTT. YES. TRUSTEE RIGSENFAULER. NO. TRUSTEE GARCIA. YES. TRUSTEE BATISTAVALA. NO. AND NAMA, YES. APPROVED FOR THE TRUSTEE'S PRESENT. KNOWN BY TRUSTEE RIGSENFAULER AND TRUSTEE BATISTAVALA. OKAY. MOVING ON TO ELIMINATE .5 FTE ADMIN SECRETARY 5 WHICH IS VACANT FOR TOTAL 42,000. ANY DISCUSSION? IS THERE A MOTION? SO MOVED. SECOND. SECOND BY TRUSTEE GARCIA. ALL IN FAVOR SAY AYE. ANY OPPOSITION? NONE. APPROVED BY ALL TRUSTEES PRESENT. WE HAVE 184,000. THERE'S EXACTLY 184,000 IN THE PARAPROS. Anybody interested in having that discussion? I know the superintendent is not recommending. Trustee Mott, yes. I was going to throw something out there for consideration just in terms of maybe spreading out the impact a little more, maybe taking one of the FTE for literacy, a pair of pros, one for the combo, and one for the newcomer so that

091it was a lot less impact in each category. Newcomers and not up there, but previously had okay. Yes. So any Discussion on that proposal Trustee Rodriguez and then trustee Garcia. I think that you know I'm not really interested in necessarily eliminating call. Like I get I think it's a good basic premise to try and spread it out for sure. Um, yeah, but I but I am interested in the piece that you're saying is to go back and revisit the I think you said the newcomer, Paris, did you say that was that part of what you said? Yes. And go back to see if we can revisit and see if we can take a second shot at that. Because the last time we had that discussion, we weren't eliminating those positions. We were just trying to

092switch them to a different. funding source and we were going to give them the very same skills so that our students would receive the very same services. So it wouldn't really be a reduction of services. So I don't know if anybody wants to go back to that, but I think that we, that we, that that's a place where I think we should be able to reach some sort of consensus, especially, you know, if we're, we're not, the students aren't really going to lose services. They just, it's just going to be called something different with, with other folks. And we can. maybe even shore up the newcomer paras if we move them over to the tutoring. We can give them some different responsibilities, perhaps. I don't know if that goes into negotiating new contracts or not.

093But especially with the new presidential administration coming in and what the impacts may be on federal laws for newcomers, immigration issues, we may want to get a couple of people who are... who we would get out of the tutoring, but train them up in, you know, DACA information, immigration, immigration. We could use some one-time monies for that. I think we can do something there. Sorry, I didn't mean to hijack what you were saying, Trustee Mott. That's kind of where I went when you said that. Thank you. Trustee Richard Peller. I THINK IT WAS. THANK YOU. THANK YOU. I DON'T WANT TO GO BACK TO THE NEWCOMERS PARAPROFESSIONAL. I APPRECIATE YOUR MOTION, BUT I I WONDER IF WE CAN DO HALF OF THE NUMBER THREE AND HALF OF THE NUMBER SIX. IT CAN BE ANOTHER OPTION.

094I DEFINITELY DON'T WANT TO GO BACK AND REVISE THE NEWCOMERS. TRUSTEE GERGENSFELLER. AN INCREASE OF THE DEPARTMENT BUDGET REDUCTION FROM 5% TO 6% WILL ALLOW US TO HAVE $210,000, 462. SO THAT'S WHAT I WOULD LIKE TO SEE. SO... There's four different ideas. I mean, the other option is to continue deficit spending or deficit structural deficit of the 184 and then revisit this later in the year as things have adjusted as well. Again, it's not a huge amount anymore, like $7 million. SO THERE'S ANOTHER OPTION THAT WE CAN ALSO DO. AND THEN AGAIN, STAFF HAS MORE TIME TO IDENTIFY OTHER OPTIONS. AND THEN TRUSTEE MOTT DOESN'T HAVE TO WORRY ABOUT IT. I'LL ALWAYS WORRY ABOUT IT. OKAY. OKAY. WORRY ABOUT VOTING. THAT IS DEFINITELY AN OPTION. WE'VE BEEN THROUGH, WE'RE SO CLOSE THAT IF THE BOARD

095WANTED TO STOP THERE, I THINK WE WOULD BE VERY COMFORTABLE WITH THE BUDGET AS, WITH ALL THE WORK THAT'S BEEN DONE SO FAR. I'M NOT SURE IF IT'S A GOOD ONE OR NOT. HOW DOES THE BOARD FEEL ABOUT THAT OPTION? NEW SPEAKER PEDROZA, CAN I ASK A QUESTION? NEW SPEAKER PEDROZA, OF COURSE. NEW SPEAKER PEDROZA, AND DO YOU THINK I KNOW PART OF WHAT WE'RE DOING IS ALSO AT THE BEHEST OF YCOE AND WANTING TO SEE A BALANCED BUDGET IN THEIR PARTICULAR ROLE AS OVERSEEING BUDGETS. DO YOU THINK GETTING IT DOWN TO 184 WOULD BE FAVORABLE? WOULD THAT BE SOMETHING THAT You know, they would be okay with. They would be very impressed. Yeah, going from $7 million to $184 million. And again, our budget fluctuates so much that that amount could go up or

096down, you know, by mid-year and then again at the end of the year just because of expenses that we do or don't do throughout the year. So, you know, there's opportunity to do that. So, again, that is an option. I'm going to stay with this deficit. Okay. That's two of us. TRUSTEE RODRIGUEZ? I AM ALSO. OKAY. ONE MORE OKAY WITH THAT? OR ELSE WE HAVE TO DISCUSS WHAT TO CUT. SO WE CAN END HERE. HOW DOES EVERYBODY FEEL ABOUT ADDING ONE PERCENTAGE TO DEPARTMENT CUTS? WE HAD VOTED ON THAT. WHAT? WE HAD VOTED ON THAT AND SAID NO. NO, NOT TODAY. I'M JUST SAYING THAT'S HOW PEOPLE FEEL. YEAH, I MEAN, THAT'S ANOTHER ONE. YOU WANT TO CUT 1%. AND IT DOESN'T HAVE TO BE 1%. IT COULD BE .5. WE CAN GET CLOSER TO

097THE BOTTOM LINE. BUT AT LEAST WE'LL HAVE ALREADY THE IMPACT. THE SOONER WE DO THE CUTS, THE SOONER WE'LL BE ABLE TO ADJUST TO THEM. I NEED TO BE VERY HONEST. WE COULD DO WHAT THE BOARD DESIRES. WE WERE ALREADY WORRIED ABOUT THE 5%. AND SO I'M VERY UNCOMFORTABLE ASKING TONY AND THE REST OF MY TEAM TO CUT ADDITIONAL. BECAUSE EVEN THOUGH IT FEELS LIKE IT DOESN'T IMPACT STUDENTS, IT DOES IMPACT STUDENTS. BECAUSE THAT'S TRANSPORTATION, FOR EXAMPLE. THERE'S, YOU KNOW, IMPACTED MAINTENANCE AND OPERATIONS. WE ALREADY HAVE OUR SCHOOLS WITH NEEDS AND I WOULD HATE TO TAKE AWAY ADDITIONAL FUNDS FROM A GYM TO WORK WITH. THE BUDGET, SOME DEPARTMENTS HAVE VERY LITTLE BUDGET. THEY ARE ALREADY TRYING TO BE FRUGAL AND TAKING A 5% HIT. I HAVE TO REMIND EVERYONE THE MAJORITY OF THE BUDGETS

098THAT OUR ED SERVICES TEAM IS ALREADY HAVING TO DO LESS WITH $6 MILLION OF CUTS FROM THEIR PROGRAMS. SO I JUST WOULD, FOR THE BOARD'S CONSIDERATION. Also the music program right exactly the music program So I want to emphasize what the superintendent said that like these other percentages are from discretionary operational funds The percent from the departments was across all Including salaries and benefits. So is a huge amount so adding another percent To that is a huge amount not it's not it's not equivalent. So I'm definitely not in favor of that trustee person fella What is the carryover at the district departments for every year at the district department level? Is there a carryover? The carryover we sweep the carryover. So when there's carryover like let's say in the super let's say in my department

099There's five thousand dollars. I didn't spend I don't get that money in my office next year It sweeps into the general fund to help Louis with balancing the budget The carryover that you hear from district office is but title one And it looks like it's all district office title one, but it's from all the money the schools didn't spend and there's a portion of the school site. I mean district level title one that the The all the money that our schools do not spend and including our district office don't not spend in the LCAP That's part of the care viewer. So it's really depending on how You look at that sometimes and maintenance operation. Maybe there's a contract that didn't go through because they're still dealing with legal or still dealing with contractors and sometimes

100that in IN SOME CASES THAT CARRY OVER WE GIVE BACK TO JIM BECAUSE THE WORK WASN'T DONE YET BUT IT WAS PENDING A, B AND C. SO FROM OTHER DEPARTMENTS THAT DO NOT LIKE MINE AND THE REST OF US, THAT MONEY GOES BACK TO THE BOTTOM LINE. IT DOESN'T CARRY OVER. I DON'T GET TO SAVE MONEY. AT THIS POINT I'M WILLING TO GO INTO DEFICIT SPENDING WITH THE 184 AND SEEING WHERE WE GO FROM THERE. Okay, so trust you those trust Rodriguez trust yours and Fowler trustee Garcia trust about this as well trustee Garcia He said yes that you're okay. We continue with a hundred and eighty four thousand Deficit spending. Yes, and I'm also in favor of that. So, okay Perfect. Any other questions or comments on this item? I want to thank the

101board. Just hold on trustee Rodriguez. Sorry Sorry, I did want to try and make a motion, which we had talked about at previous meetings, about going back and surveying, you know, the people that are impacted by the cuts that we're making so that we get information about. about what the actual impacts were, information about maybe unforeseen consequences, and so that we get more feedback about the decisions that we're making. So that could be at the end of the full year of the cut, but I would like to see that process be voted on if my fellow trustees thought that that was worthwhile. I do, I do. I DEFINITELY OPEN A SECOND. SUPERINTENDENT, ANY COMMENTS ON THAT? YES, I THINK I'M NOT SURE IF IT COULD INCLUDE A SURVEY. I WOULD LIKE TO ASK THE BOARD

102TO GIVE ME FLEXIBILITY ABOUT HOW I WOULD PRESENT THE DATA BECAUSE IN SOME THINGS SURVEYS THAT CAN BE PART OF IT. I WOULD LIKE TO HAVE SOME DISCRETION ON HOW I WOULD PRESENT THAT INFORMATION. OF COURSE, IT WOULD BE WITH TIME BECAUSE WE WON'T KNOW UNTIL ALL OF THE DECISIONS YOU MAKE ARE NOT GOING TO BE IMPLEMENTED UNTIL NEXT SCHOOL YEAR. IT WILL TAKE SOME TIME TO GO THROUGH THAT PROCESS. I'M ALSO, AND I APPRECIATE THAT BECAUSE THERE MAY BE SOME PLACES WHERE WE CUT TOO DEEP AND MAYBE WE SHOULDN'T HAVE OR MAYBE SOME OTHER PLACES SO IT'S A LEARNING PROCESS. SO YES, I WOULD SUPPORT THE IDEA OF COMING BACK AND PRESENTING TO THE BOARD THE IMPACT. BUT I DON'T WANT TO TIE MYSELF TO A SURVEY. I WANT TO HAVE SOME FLEXIBILITY. NOT

103SAYING I WOULD NOT DO A SURVEY BUT MAYBE MULTIPLE WAYS I WOULD BRING THE REPORT TO THE BOARD. NEW SPEAKER SO TRUSTEE RUTIGA, YOU'RE SAYING SIX MONTHS AFTER NEXT YEAR STARTS, RIGHT? BECAUSE AGAIN, THESE IMPACTS DOESN'T AFFECT UNTIL NEXT YEAR. NEW SPEAKER YES, YOU'D HAVE TO BE UP TO THE SUPERINTENDENT TO PICK THE TIMELINE THAT WOULD GIVE GOOD INFORMATION. NEW SPEAKER I SECOND THAT. ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION ON THAT MOTION? ALL IN FAVOR SAY AYE. ANY OPPOSITION OR ABSTENTION? HEARING NONE, TRUSTEE RIGOS'S MOTION IS APPROVED TO GET THE SUPERINTENDENT DISCRETION TO PUT TOGETHER METHODS TO GET FEEDBACK FROM STAFF ABOUT HOW THE IMPACTS HAVE AFFECTED THEM. IT COULD BE SURVEY OR OTHER THINGS AND ALSO ON THE TIMELINE. JUST TO RESTATE THE MOTION. ANYTHING ELSE ON THIS ITEM BEFORE WE ADJOURN? I JUST WANT TO MAKE

104A COMMENT. YES. I JUST WANT TO THANK THE BOARD FOR your courage, your patience, the time that you spent listening to our teachers, our staff, our administration, to our recommendations, even though sometimes they were hard to hear. And, you know, these were tough decisions. I want to thank my staff. FOR THE HOURS AND HOURS AND HOURS AND KEPT PULLING THEM INTO MY OFFICE AND RACKING OUR BRAINS TO SEE HOW WE CAN DO THIS. I WANT TO TAKE OUR UNION LEADERSHIP AS WELL. I KNOW THIS IS DIFFICULT FOR YOUR MEMBERSHIP. BUT I ALSO WANT TO SAY THAT I'M VERY PROUD THAT WE ARE MAKING RESPONSIBLE DECISIONS FOR THE FUTURE OF OUR DISTRICT AND HAVING A HEALTHY BUDGET SO THAT WE CAN BE IN BETTER POSITIONS TO EVEN DO MORE FOR OUR STAFF. ANY OTHER COMMENTS? See

105non-media's adjourn at 7 11 p.m. Thank you everyone

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.