001[Music] good evening like to call to order the uh farmy Board of Education special meeting for December 9th 2024 i' ask we all stand and uh for the Pledge of Allegiance PL alleg to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for it stands one indivisible with liy and justice for all so now we're going to honor someone very special in the Farmington Public Schools assistant superintendent qu Kim win who's sitting very far away at the end of the table um it's really Bittersweet for all of us uh for the last 12 years Kim and I work together as a superintendent and assistant superintendent team it's really been an honor to work alongside Kim her service to Farmington has been truly impeccable as someone who is an Exemplar for really owning
002the improvement work here and enacting that work um each and every day she's served as an initiator and a designer of our Improvement documents which drive all that we do with students each day within the instructional core which is our classrooms the work has been truly invigorating Visionary and playful reflecting the very best that public education can offer Kim's Legacy lives within each one of us she has cultivated our collective learning Improvement and Equity focused Innovation as well as our unique gifts as Educators and as students um I she's heard this quote before um but Kim in my opinion is uh an Illuminator and this is what David Brook says about that I think I might have said something about this in my student video too so um so this is what David Brooks says
003being openhearted is a prerequisite for being a full kind and wise human being the real process of saying building a friendship or creating a community which Kim helped to create here involves performing a series of small concrete actions well illuminators David Brooks shares have a persistent curiosity about other people they've been trained or have trained themselves in the craft of understanding others they shine their brightness of their Care on people and make them feel bigger respected and lit up so much of what David Brooks describ Des cribes is Kim's way of being as a person as an educator and as a leader over 40 for over 40 years Kim has made us feel respected bigger lit up and when you feel that way as a person an educator or a student you can accomplish the
004extraordinary we thank Kim so much we're going to miss you and we hope to continue your work and make you proud each day I do see there's some special people in the audience Kim's husband Bob and Chloe and Kelly graduates of the farming CH public schools and her daughters um we just are so happy that they're here to share um this goodbye but not really goodbye it's just you're going to see us again you'll probably work here continually because we always need we'll always need your help in some way but I don't know if the students know this but Kim is an extraordinary AR writer and has really helped after getting input from the community uh from students from teachers um she is the one who wrote the vision of the global citizen after getting
005all of that feedback and so and many of our other documents like our core beliefs and our theory of action so Kim is incredible she is a designer and someone who uh is an architect in many ways so just I just wish wish you the very best and every happiness in your retirement but don't go too far okay and we have a proclamation before we read the proclamation I want to open it up any comments many of colleagues on the board anybody want to say anything Beth so Kim I have to jot down we're so fortunate to have your dedication for all of your career in farington public schools um you're just such a consumate professional with such a warm personality um I've always felt that you're just a natural good listener who shows a
006tremendous amount of empathy as you go about things like planning and decision- making um and working with colleagues and and teachers and just across the board um you also have a great sense of humor I've so much enjoyed our conversations and have learned so much over the years just in our little conversations and some of our work together so I really appreciate that um but also your humility I think really lends itself to your being comfortable taking an honest look at where we've been at certain junctures um you know what our shortcomings were and the challenges and our strengths but working that all together um gives you just has given you a great insight for where we need to improve and kind of set our sights for the next steps um and then in the
007execution of all that too your creativity your optimistic attitude and your importance on collaboration it's just enabled this District to benefit so much from your thoughtfulness your thoughtful planning your inclusion of so many voices um and your persistence in reaching so many important and necessary goals for our district so you're leaving quite a legacy and we're so grateful um just thank you for all of your hard work I wish you so much so great wishes for your retirement and take time to enjoy and rest but yes don't go too far thank you you're welcome so Kim I feel very fortunate that I've had the opportunity to work with you on the curriculum committee the Noah Wallace fund various interview committees and then here at the board table um you are such a highly expert and
008caring educator um working with you has certainly deepened my understanding and appreciation for farmington's educational priorities um and continuous improvement work um and always putting students at the center um of decision making I've um you know working with you has I think even it's made me a better board member for sure but I think also a better parent in terms of my kids own education here in the Farmington School District um congratulations on your retirement and thank you for the 40 Years of dedication to the Farmington Public Schools anyone else U before we have the proclamation I did write down a few thoughts myself um I just want to let you know how how I feel about your work for the board and and how you've made all of our jobs a lot easier and
009how you've made our Our Town better uh we celebrate and recognize um an extraordinary individual in the conclusion of a 40-year commitment of dedicated service to the families of Farmington Kim is on Kim win's name is on nearly all of farmington's initiatives of the last decade the initial drive to develop the five-year goals and the subsequent work done over the last 10 years the vision of the graduate which is now the vision of the global citizen the framework for teaching and learning the move to Common Core Teacher evaluations curriculum development and I know I'm missing other things all have Kim's handprints on them it's fair to say that throughout your career you've served as a Guiding Light embodying leadership that inspires your colleagues and compassion that transforms your their students students our students while before
010my time I know from talking to those that worked with you at West District your classrooms are more than a place of learning they're places of encouragement and respect as you transitioned to a leadership role you took that perspective with you and continued to consistently see the potential in every student ensuring that the Farmington schools would nurture their growth and equip them for success no matter the challenges they faced now of course your leadership extended beyond the classroom whether mentoring new teachers ensuring teacher professional development was on The Cutting Edge of 21st century curriculum or just being there for teachers principes administrators and staff you've shown that leadership is not just about guidance it's about service empathy and a commitment to lead with the [Applause] heart I would also be remiss if I didn't recognize
011some other things that you've done you've helped establish priorities for teaching and learning professional development overall School culture for our district you've served as an educational leader countless times you've developed and led seminars too too numerous to mention you've handled strategic Recruitment and handling of onboarding new teachers you led the district's Initiative for the Community Council on Equity inclusion equity and inclusion and you at the Forefront of recognizing emotional learning and the need to include it as part of our curriculum before many other districts we were even aware of what that was as you can see your impact on the district is immeasurable and your legacy will long be part of the Farmington schools your unwavering commitment has left an indelible mark on countless lives such longevity and education is not just a testament to
012endurance but to a profound calling to make a difference in the lives of others on behalf of all those you've touched students families colleagues like we thank you for your extraordinary contributions you're a beacon of excellence and a true example of what it means to educate with purpose and compassion you will be missed but not for much she'll be around Andrea sure I have a proclamation to read Farmington Board of Education Proclamation um for Kimberly win whereas Farmington Board of education's mission is to enable all students to achieve academic and personal Excellence exhibit persistent effort and live as resourceful inquiring and contributing Global Citizens and whereas students in Farmington Public Schools effectively learn important academic content demonstrate skills and achievement at high levels and develop their individual talents and interests in an atmosphere that promotes
013belonging respect and lifelong learning and whereas Kimberly W has served as the assistant superintendent of curriculum instruction and human resources for Farmington Public Schools since 2012 she has also served roles within the Farmington Public Schools serving a total of 40 Stellar years of service to the school district and students of Farmington and whereas Kimberly W's dedication to the children children families faculty and staff of Farmington has been unparalleled throughout her career promoting high expectations a student- centered approach and deeper learning related to curriculum and instruction as well as commitment to equity and Innovation and whereas Kimberly win served as an exceptional leader who has utilized Community input and feedback to assist in the design and implementation of farmington's future oriented core Improvement documents which drove continuous Improvement prek through 12 in farmington's aligning system structures
014and Improvement routines to these documents directly impacting what students experience as leaders and agents of their own learning each day as a result students experience caring classroom environments and highly engage engaging learning tasks that promote students as self-aware individuals empowered Learners disciplined thinkers engage collaborators and civic-minded contributors and whereas Kimberly Wis commitment to Excellence has led to impressive results in student outcomes over the course of her career aligned to an Innovative instructional model and curriculum design core beliefs and vision of the global citizen championing deeper learning experiences for all students that reflect high levels of student engagement agency and curiosity aligned to real world learning that have meaning and value to all Learners Learners and whereas Kimberly win has served as an outstanding forward-thinking instructional leader in Farmington and Beyond as recently evidenced by her
015leadership in contributing to an Innovative design of learning spaces at the new Farmington High School facility and hosting a deeper learning convening with Educators from across North America here in Farmington and now therefore I William Becker on behalf of the Farmington Board of Education and the Farmington Community hereby commend Farmington Public School schools member Kimberly WN for her committed and compassionate work on behalf of our community and I hereby thank her for her self selfless dedication and commitment to Quality education for the children of Farmington dated this 9th day of December 2024 at Farmington Connecticut William Becker chair Farmington Board of Education oh my goodness it's very hard to be the center of attention in things like this um I'm sorry for students having to listen to so many words about such a long history
016but I have to say that never for a moment have I regretted spending my entire career in Farmington and every single day I'm utterly amazed at what all of you do on the athletic field in the classroom um our students in this District are just amazing and my two daughters here are two of those amazing students uh who've now grown up and and moved on with their lives um I just you know 40 years when you say it it seems like unbelievable who would ever want to stay in one place for 40 years um but you know you may not know my history but I I grew up um moving a lot with a single mom who you know we just needed to move around and so so um as I became a mom I
017was determined that my children were if I could do it were going to stay in one place and have greater stability and really invest in a community and so um although Bristol is an amazing place right Dan Dan and I both are graduates of Bristol high schools um we decided to move to Farmington and um I just I have to say I I I never needed to go anywhere else and it's really about two things it's about people and it's about purpose and purpose means we know what we're here for and we're always always looking out in front of us to see what's next what do our students need where are their Futures going and how can we be more prepared so that they'll be prepared for their Futures and I just think it's the
018spirit of this District that holds the most excellent teachers here we're always you know thinking about who can we look to what can we read where can we go to better to be better and this board leads the way in that your your insights your questions you know you're always the ones encouraging us to do that work and bring it to you so I I thank you so much for that and and the second part is people um we just attract the best people in this district and we have you know people who not only have you know uh we we think we need the smartest people in Farmington to lead this work so yes we we think about that as an important component but we need people with a heart people who care about
019students and each other and you know growing up here as a teacher I always felt like my colleagues and my administrators cared about me as a person and wanted me to grow and look at all the amazing opportunities I had here so I never for a moment you know regretted staying in one place all this time um and I I can't thank you all and your uh what's word you know the people who came before you in these seats you know leading the way in this District leading Farmington to be the best District in Connecticut and Beyond as Kathy says in the universe um and I most especially want to thank Kathy for being an amazing promoter of mine supporter of mine someone whose vision is is also a secret to Our Success um so
020I I will just leave you with that thought about always having that and mindset the the tradition and Innovation you know we would we don't want to forget who we are and our history here in this District but we always want to be looking ahead and looking forward and thinking about um how we can provide the very best education for the very best students so thank you so much to everyone it'll be hard to walk away but maybe not on these late Monday nights I'll be home thank you so much okay um with that being said I think we'll uh we'll adjourn at this point in time okay weard here okay good evening I'm going to call the farm Board of Education of the meeting for December 9th 2024 in uh into order um we'll
021start with the Pledge of Allegiance pledge allegiance to the flag United States of America and to theic which it stands na God indivisible liy and jusice for all I'm going to ask for a motion to modify our agenda if we could move from item 7A under new business um uh item a board of education leadership and development session we could move that up to uh item 5B can I get a motion for that motion gonna get a second second all those in favor I'm sorry any discussion comments Bill I just I didn't hear you what do you move it's fine but I just didn't yeah we're moving the um Tom's presentation up in the agenda so Tom's not here y you know perfect thank you okay uh all those in favor signify by saying I
022I I opposed extension okay oh sure yes thank you is this now uh perfect good do you all have your P yes okay uh I just wanted to first uh say hello I've met many of you uh through collective bargaining uh but not others and so I just it's my pleasure to meet of the uh board members this evening um my name is Tom Mooney and I represent Boards of education and it's been my privilege to represent the Farmington board of education for about 30 years and uh hope to continue to do that for another 30 years or so so um let me just start with a simple question who here went to middle school is it unanimous yes okay you may wonder why I ask but you all if if you didn't you're all
023claiming uh to have gone to Middle School uh so that's when you all learned about the three branches of government okay and so what are you what branch of government are you as Board of Education members should we Refresh on what the three branches of government are Jud judicial executive ex and legislative and legislative very good so you remember your middle school Civics uh so now the question is um what are you as a board of education what branch of government yeah I I prompt prep bill on this so can't answer um anyone anyone anyone why do you say that because it's policy and I think about rules and legislation that guides what happens what does Congress do on a good day pass that would be a good day Congress passes laws what else does
024Congress do on a good day they pass a budget and what do you do what are your what keeps you busy I see on your agenda you have several policy initiatives and a fundamental responsibility of the board of education is to adopt a budget so that's a good answer do you ever serve an executive function oversight I would say I'm sorry I would say a little bit of O oversight oversight and that's a very good word I use that sometimes to try and explain you know the important role boards play in uh School distri District operation uh but there's a statute on this particular topic and uh 10-17 of the con Connecticut General statutes uh defines the superintendent of schools as the chief executive officer so there's a tension for Boards of Education because you're
025here at as I understand it no pay as citizen volunteers giving of your time and so when people come to you with problems your first impulse is often to help but quite often the problems people come to you with are operational in nature and that really is the responsibility of the superintendent and we have some scenarios in the fold uh that I'd just like to go through to illustrate some of this but before we do that the third branch of government is judicial do you ever serve a Judicial responsibility when so you do student exposion uh well that's a slightly different uh what is is what is a fundamental characteristic of a judge what do you want when you sayal impartial correct and so when you serve a Judicial responsibility it's critically important that you
026keep that in mind and when I work with Boards of education and talking about these responsibilities I can't help myself but to recall the traumatic event that happened to me over 40 years ago uh when a superintendent of schools recommended that the high school principal be non-renewed so far so good that doesn't sound so dramatic does it well here's what happened the high school principal invited 400 of his closest friends to the high school auditorium for the hearing and it was a lot more crowded than it is tonight board is up on the stage and the first thing the lawyer for the principal did is he called a board member to the stand and he said isn't it true that you told Sally at the stoping shop that you're going to get rid of my
027client yes there were three board members who had been in the community expressing opinions now expressing opinions is a wonderful thing it's a privilege we have under the First Amendment but judges cannot express their opinions on pending cases and so in front of 400 people I watched this whole case collapse because three board members have rendered themselves incapable of acting as an impartial judge now your judicial responsibilities include teacher tenure cases who can hire a teacher under statute do you know who who has the authority to hire a teacher you're saying the superintendent well that's true but only because you've delegated that responsibility to the superintendent as all school districts do I mean the last you know you have a lot of work on your uh plate you know to have to worry about hiring
028teachers is not necessarily something you need to do but the converts who has the authority to fire a teacher only the board now fortunately this is not something that comes up often but when it comes up it can be a real problem and as you can imagine there are things that happen in school districts hopefully you're reading in the paper about some other school district where this controversial thing is happening but people are want to know what you what's your position they come up to you in the store hey did you hear about the teacher who was arrested for whatever and it's very hard to resist having an opinion and sharing that opment but you have to be super careful in Personnel matters or any um judicial responsibility to keep your thoughts to yourself and
029uh wait for the appropriate time to listen as an impartial judge and then make your decision on the information you receive at that hearing now I get the questions well my kid came home there's a there was a food fight and he told me about Johnny how how he threw a hot dog and hit the this principal in the head and um now suddenly Johnny is before the board in an expulsion here can that board member who heard about Johnny throwing the hot dog act impartially and fulfill that board member's responsibilities well the answer is yes because the um Supreme Court has understood that as members of the community Boards of board members hear things and it's uh you know you're presumed they assume good faith that you can set that aside listen to the
030evidence when you're fulfilling that judicial responsibility and decide the matter on what you hear but as soon as you're on Facebook or talking to other people and taking an act role in engaging in the particular situation then You've Lost That ability to uh be impartial so we have student expulsion we have teacher tenure hearings student expulsion hearings School accommodation hearings do you think um a resident of farington has the right to actually go to court over where the bus stop is located and what role do you play in that circumstance School accommodations that is the eligibility to attend school hearing Farmington uh is is a right that people have if they're eligible and sometimes we get into a fight about whe are they eligible or not I have had cases here in Farmington where in
031fact one of my funny stories I teach school a lot Yukon and I can't this at one point this is years ago I think before Kathy's time so there was a dispute as to whether this particular family was entitled to um attend school in Farmington or mrid because their house was right on the L right on line they built a huge deck so that their the foot print of their house crossed over and when you're on the property line you can go either place but back to your role in all of this the uh uh parent who says my kids entitled Kathy has the responsibility in the first instance to make those calls and then Kathy says I've determined you're not eligible to attend school in farming and then the parent has a right under
032statute to have a hearing before you in 10 days uh School accomodations here and that's another situ situation in which you operate as an impartial judge um and uh then they have the right to a state hearing and they have the right to go to court um so uh but back to bus stops transportation is dued as a fundamental element of school accommodations how do you go to school if you can't get to school and so um uh whether or not this board has provided a particular family with reasonable transportation is part of school accommodations and so if someone thinks the bus stop is in a too far or in a danger spot they have a right to hearing before you and I say that without judgment because I actually one time was in one
033of these bus stop hearings and um I'm not here and they made us go stand on the bus stop and it was scary uh you know in their you know trying to figure out bus rugs they put this bus up there and and we all agreed that it was not reasonable a transportation so those are the judicial responsibilities people are going to engage you in attempt to engage you in conversation about those responsibilities you just have to say it's not my job I'm really not going to comment on that grievance hearings are a little different fortunately we don't have lot of board level grievance hearing but that's a contractual matter the other issues involve property rights and due process grievances are collec so uh the the standards are not quite as are rigorous so that's
034just a brief introduction uh to to your role what we have in the packet is on the left a little outline legal rights and responsibilities and behind it a caution about Emil um which which I'll talk about uh more because it's so critically important uh and on the right hand side we have uh five scenarios and I know that you have other items on the agenda as much as uh I enjoy talking with you um we'll go through those and I'll try and um be out of here in what about half an hour is that uh work for you um but I also want to say I welcome your questions and as we're going through this um don't you know I'm going to ask actually this is kind of a Socratic exercise so when we
035get to the scenarios it's really your turn to tell me uh what you think the appropriate course of action is and and I say that with humility the last time I was elected to public office was in eth grade you are all here because you're serving your community as eled members of the Board of Education and so I can only tell you what I've seen what I think works but you have to decide for yourselves how you want to fulfill your public responsibilities so jumping to the scenarios uh we have scenario one three members of the Board of Education write a letter to the Valley Press address the Farmington Public Schools community in the letter the board members talk about the upcoming budget and they urge people to vote in support of the budget the
036board members identify themselves as members of the Farmington Board of Education other board members see the post and are mad that three board members did not let them know about it in advance like their Glory they out publicly but not including everyone so if a if a board budget referendum is pending is this supposed a violation of state law and you've had your experiences with the budget referend in fact here we are in beautiful high school approved through a referendum um but if a referendum is pending can you still speak in favor of your budget I think you can but only for a certain period of time right is like there's a what we call the quiet period once all the prerequisites for a budget referendum have been set then a a very specific law
037kicks in right are you saying bill that once that law kicks in you have to do you can't that's how we always conduct ourselves we conduct ourselves in a way where we don't speak about the budget publicly collectively once the quiet starts well uh I'm glad I'm here um because that's an overly restrictive view okay and and I appreciate your caution because uh as you probably know board members take action on behalf of the community and every so often a claim can be made against you and the question is do I need my own insurance the answer is absolutely not because public policy and a specific statute protects you the indentification statute of claims made and you've acted within your Authority as board members even if you might be wrong you're fully protected and even
038legal fees are covered so there's a strong public policy in favor of protecting board members but this issue of referendum is the one area of the law where if there's a violation it's expressly prohibited board cannot indemnify board members who are fined under the uh uh state law on referenda which is 9 369b which says that no public official shall authorize the expenditure of public funds to affect a referendum result and so you are perfectly free to speak out in favor of the budget at any time you cannot however and your principles have to understand this as well they cannot let school property be used they can't even let um a a flyer advocating the referendum one way or the other to go out with kids because that's used as the equivalent of a postage
039you know in terms of a financial expenditure so boards have to be very careful not to off and in fact if you have something on your website that um uh advocates for your budget and now it's coming up you have to take it down because that's viewed as an expenditure as well but this scenario is is oh is that it okay so uh did the three board members do anything wrong by writing a letter without involving the other board members you're saying no say yes and in piron I say yes you say yes what did they do wrong because they're speaking on behalf of the bo are they on the board they're only speaking of partial they did identify themselves as members of the board correct and so that would be the concern that they're
040out there I'm a member of the Farmington Board of Ed um this is a little complicated because it could also be a problem in the converse what if those three board members wrote this and didn't identify themselves as members of the board is could they be then accused of being sneaky and advocating without identifying themselves so it's it's a little tricky and all I would suggest is that when you are speaking it's a you're you are members of the board and you can be identified as such but I think all board members would always want to be careful to with a disclaimer I'm speaking as a as a person I'm not speaking on behalf of the board under your bylaws who speaks on behalf of the board the chair the chair right and that's Universal
041as well um but there's more to the story wouldn't it have been nice if those three board members reached out to the other board members to say Hey you know we're thinking of writing this letter to the Valley Press would you like to sign on and you're shaking your head no yeah no I mean I I feel like I speak for myself at at least if I write something I don't speak for others so I want to be my Approach I don't know okay um so you're saying you that is it okay for the three board and you're saying it's notze that board whether I'm meeting other members would constitute a public meeting if it isn't maybe they can get away with it but if it's if it's like I'll say here if five people
042got together that would be a Bo meeting right and um what's the problem with that need to be and so what has I use the scenario uh because this comes up actually not infrequently and what happens is there's a issue of controversy that the board wants to address and suddenly out of nowhere comes a public statement signed by the members of the Board of Education and invariably someone says oh that's interesting at what meeting did you decide on that letter and that's when the Board of Education apologizes and goes hands up at the Freedom of Information commission oop sorry uh and um uh so in these circumstances the the the law expects and requires that you do your business in public now less that quum and talk about whatever you want as soon as a
043quum is involved then uh you're in a meeting and uh the uh email caution see if I can do this without dropping it um the email caution includes the definition of a public meeting for your reference and uh it's in the middle of the page and a meeting under the freedom of information law is any convening or assembling of a quorum of a multi-member public agency that would be you or a communication vior to a quum of that public me multi-member public agency whether in person or by means of electronic equipment and the next words are critical to discuss or act upon sometimes the intuitive view is well we didn't make a decision so who cares but the law specifically defines a meeting as including any communication among a quum to discuss and that's why
044uh and you're a sophisticated Bunch right so I understand I'll predict that you all know not to hit reply all um Cathy can send something out bill can send any of you can send something out that's fine that's not a discussion but as soon as someone hits reply off then at what point along that path is it a discussion um I don't want to disappoint anyone here but I have lost cases before the Freedom of Information commission one of them involved this very thing uh where a board member was upset wrote to the chair copied of all the board members the board chair wrote back to the person copied all the board members and someone F an fi complaint my argument at the commission was it was not a discussion among the board it was
045just two people talking and the other people were just listening you're you're laughing at my argument well they did too uh U they're very rigorous about this uh so we just have to be super careful uh about uh reply off um so face uh scenario a board member is Facebook friends with a teacher in a post on his Facebook page the teacher complains that his principal unfairly denied him three days of personal leave to attend Nature's Classroom in a neighboring School District to serve as a chaper room for his fifth grade son the board member calls the principal to find out what the problem is you can picture it right what's the problem then the teacher files agree does the board member and it gets up to the board level does the board member have
046a conflict of interest such that the board member should not participate in that grievance heing maybe I don't think so CU I mean they're just they're friends with them they didn't comment or interact oh they call the princi well let me ask you this let this this scenario and we will'll get into the point the answer but it's really important just for all of you to consider this issue because you make decisions on behalf of the public so how do you define a conflict of interest and when would you think it appropriate to what the LA say accus herself with draw from the discussion so who gets to decide if you have a conflict of interest just you just you just you so for example if a board member is college roommates with this guy
047with this expensive contract pending before the board could the board say Hey Joe it's your roommate you you guys you guys go on vacation together you have a conflict of interest can the board vote to tell that board member he can't vote because he has a conflict of interest I'm sorry who gave each of you your power and you have significant power on behalf of the public where does that power come from it comes from the voters and and so the the law of the matter is that um uh only the board member can decide decide whether he or she has a conflict of interest and the board cannot deprive a board member the board is the board cannot deprive a board member of his or her Authority that decision has to rest with the
048individual so it's critically important how do you decide what goes into your thinking when you maybe it's your second cousin twice removed you have a conflict of interest Charter to thats conflict we have ethical Provisions our top Charter and typically that would the bright line is financial interest uh what's not so bright is roommates and friends and enemies because conflicts of interest are not just you can have antagonism and so how do you um how do what what goes into your thinking in terms of what is or is not a conflict interest what is your job your job is to act on behalf of the public do circumstances you confront impair your ability to act on behalf of the public whether it's an affection or an antagonism um can you this is back to this
049issue of this concept of impartiality can you act impartially uh on behalf of the public and not on behalf of your friends or your enemies and that's the question you have to ask yourselves but there's a further question and that is not withstanding the fact that I've like searched my heart and I know that I can be impartial in fact yeah he was my roommate last week I don't even like the guy I can be impartial what and and I'm saying let's just accept the premise that board member can act impartially should that board member act in that case or is there an appearance of conflict that undermines the Integrity of the board of education so to that it's first you have to search your heart and then you have to say well okay I'm
050clear but I'm not uh uh convinced public would presume that I don't have some affiliation uh that um would uh impair my ability to act on behalf of the public and another example just for your consideration I in this hypothetical have spent my adult life advocating for youth Athletics I finally get elected to the board of where I can do something about it and the vote in front of the board is should we put lights up at the high school football field what you've done um dating yourself you remember those battles so so is it a conflict of interest when I finally get on the board to vote in favor of those lights or whatever of Youth thing or maybe I was on the PTO and a PTO issue comes up is that a conflict
051of interest and my answer is no because you're elected to the board for who you are and you're not achieving any selfish goal if you get lights up in the in the high school football field you're achieving a goal that you think is in the public interest so so as we look at this issue of conflict of interest it's always really separating your personal interests from your interest on behalf of the community and when you're expressing an interest on behalf of the community or you've been involved in activities on behalf of the community that now come somehow come before the Board of Education it's perfectly appropriate for you to vote to promote that public good in your mind um not everyone thinks lights on the football field are public good third zoning cases going on
052right now about that in some districts uh uh so uh but just to close this out um when should a board member call the principal with a concern on behalf of a teacher when is that appropriate never that's great that's the right answer never uh uh you know you're I'm sure you're all sensitive the fact that as as parents you have every right toate be you know engaged on behalf of your children but don't kid yourself when you walk into a school building it's what I have in my mind is like in the banks they have the silent alarm you know you walk in uh to a school building everyone knows a board members there and so you just have to kind of bend over backwards and to be clear there in your role as
053a parent uh and um uh not uh acting on behalf of the board um and when you have questions in your role as board members because of your special status as board members you have to be so careful you go through Cathy and I'm sure that is the protocol here right that goes to the chair fair enough and um uh finally on on the it's not a comfortable answer but the right answer is that board member um uh if that board member wants to sit on the gance hearing you know there's really not it's not improper you can say it's not a good decision but it's not improper so scenario three uh you run into an acquaintance at the post office and she complains that her son's fourth grade teacher has not returned homework to
054her students in two months of course you want to help her but after reviewing board policies you determine that there's no board policy on whether and when teachers must return homework to students you check with the other board members on whether they received similar complaints about this teacher or they have not do share this information of the superintendent I'm sorry what's your opion I don't know for what is it two months no homework for two months that seems pretty serious uh what what what were you going to say off the teacher first so so you you've raised a very important point the subtext here is you want to help but the appropriate way to help a person with a problem like this is to help them understand that you're just a Boardman and that's not
055your department uh you've mistaken me for someone who's important um there's a chain of command you talk to the teacher if you talk to the principal if you talk to the assistant superintendent that is you're helping that member of the public by helping them understand your role which has enormous importance as a collect and no Authority as an individual with that of the operational issues uh that are governed by the teacher the principal the assistant superintendent the superintendent um so um but so now we've decided how you're going to help that person you're going to help that person understand the chain of command and good luck um but have we decided that you shouldn't tell tell the superintendent about this teacher who hasn't returned homework in two months and what if you hear that a
056teacher is using sexual innuendo that's well that's a different level is it okay well I agree it's a different level but where what's where along that Continuum do you say I will or I won't share that information with the teach with the superintendent it's up to you see some of these questions are just more you have to decide and um but it's always appropriate if you hear something that causes you concern there's never a circumstance where it's inappropriate for you to share that information with the superintendent you just have to draw those judgments is this trivial is this or is this something but that that could be serious and so I I'd like to share that so that Kathy has the benefit of that information you are really you benefit the superintendent because you hear
057things in the community and when you hear things that are of concern it's completely appropriate for you to share that information with the super yeah so I actually in scenarios like that I think I would also I think I would go to the principal first in a situation like that you know me like I would go to a principal first if I had you know CU I would have talk you going to Kathy first go to Kathy first I would go to teacher first as oh no as a parent no I'm talking about the sexual you know it gets that I'd go right to the super and the reason for this but again you know my disclaimer I've not been elected anything recently you have to decide but um individual board members talking to individual
058administrators about circumstances is is in my mind problematic the Su they all work for Kathy and Kathy ultimately has to make these decisions what if you tell the principal the principal doesn't do anything right then you're kind of both in trouble it's like so anyway my recomendation but you decide what you how you want to handle it is that uh any issue of concern should go to the superintendent who is the chief executive officer of the board and is also responsible for assuring it all board employees are supervised and evaluated um so the last thing on this scenario is uh how and when should you report back to the parent who raised the complaint you picked right up on that right that because reporting back is really part parts of what in other settings would
059be called constituent service like if you write to your Congressman he's AOL I'll look into that for you uh and that's that's how they get elected that's fine that's up to them but as board members that's not your responsibility to do constituent service you're here as a collective that's where you have your Authority that's where you have your your responsibility uh so um you wouldn't want to leave you know like be the Emissary for parent okay here's the problem and I'll get back to you um so you're doing great inario four and there's only two left um members of the policy committee are concerned that the number of complaints from the public have escalated and they're considering a proposed policy that would limit the type of complaints the board will consider this proposed policy has
060received a lot of public attention because some members of the public do not want want to be limited in their opportunities to complain about the board they like to complain about the board they don't want to be restricted given that fact some board members who are not members of the policy committee want to attend the meeting of the policy committee at which the public complaints policy will be discussed is it a problem if a Corum of the full board attends a meeting of the policy committee yes I don't yes I I don't think it's an issue cuz they can attend but just not as a member of the policy committee so like if I'm not on the policy committee if I attend the policy committee meeting I can listen and just take it all in
061I can't speak as a member of the policy committee or a member of board I just there as like another par um along those lines uh when this comes up I say well where do you sit with the public the arrangement of the in these circumstances because the issue is whether the policy committee meeting has morphed into a meeting of the board and as soon as board members show up and act as board members as opposed to observers as you describe then that's the danger so uh in one District they would say oh yeah we just come up S you know but the other districts are more careful and appropriately so um those board members are in that Contex of the public they're they're free and it's not an fli issue unless you let it
062more there's a explicit provision in the Freedom of Information Act saying that if a quum of one public body attends a meeting properly posted by another public body there's no need for a separate posting that's and so when you go to a board Finance meeting for um but we just have to be rigorous in making sure that board members to attend these meetings that would otherwise be a COR of the board but they're not on that committee don't have special privileges now if the public is permitted to speak then the board members who are visiting uh can speak there um uh and then the last thing and maybe I'll just mention it uh is it legal to limit the type of complaint the board will consider uh all I'll say on that is that um
063there are first implications whenever you open a form for public comment and um uh I in my experience I have seen what I describe as happy talk policies where the board public comment policy invites the public to say nice things but no criticism of any a board member and and a board employee will be permitted and um that's a per se violation of the First Amendment uh because that's call Viewpoint discrimination if you if the topic is you know you can limit the topic this is a budget hearing we're not here to talk about uh you know whatever else that's fine but as soon as you restrict People based on their viewpoint on the topic that's the subject is the for uh then uh you're running into a First Amendment problem um interestingly are all
064over the place in terms of public comment um I think it's implicit that public comment and I noted there was no public comment tonight but uh uh it's implicit the public comment should relate to the farmton public schools we had recently in another District someone would come and rail against things completely unrelated to that school district and so they had to like rain so but that's the for so I'm presuming that you uh have public comment for people to comment and you welcome their comment on the operation of the Farmington Public Schools but if you'll let people say nice things you have to let people say critical things and then scenario five Miss labeled six a good friend of a board member sends the board member an email marked personal and confidential to the board
065member's personal email in that email the friend of the board member complains to the board member that a teacher was mean to her daughter a reporter makes an foi request of all board members for a copy of any email sent or received from a third party during a specifi period time period which time period includes the email and question so personal friend private email private email but it has to do with a teacher being [Music] mean is that email a public record you think it's a public record so because of the kind the topic specifically uh so in in fact back to the firstand up when we look at the caution about email uh the definition of a public record is in the first paragraph and it's a public record is Def very broadly any
066recorded data or information relating to the conduct of the Public's business prepared used owned received or retained by public agency so as you say if it deals with the Board of Education and you're a board member and you receive it it's a public record now in this particular case would the reporter be entitled to the email about the teacher being mean to the daughter probably not probably not personel personel issue it's a fur issue right uh in other words that is now student information because they may be your friend uh but they have a daughter who has a concern with the school district so I just uh use this example to draw the distinction between what is a public record and then the next question is is it subject to disclosure and there are 27
067exemptions under the Freedom of Information law most of which never help uh but so you have to go on the premise that if it has to do with board business and I'm engaged in an email even receiving an email you don't even have to respond and it's still a public record because as the definition States it's any recorded information relating to the Public's business received by or created by so I use this example um really uh to help you consider whether you want to um tell your friends to be careful uh the phone still works but as soon as they write an email it's recorded information and if it has to do with that public business um you're you're stuck you don't have a choice in the matter uh there was a terrible situation in
068another District where a board member and a friend were back and forth on a matter of great public concern in a flippant and disrespectful way a reporter asked for those emails and they all had to be disclosed um I'll just end with a question I think Bill you said that this board is good about not texting during board meetings would would a text could a text be subject to F absolutely any recorded information and in fact it can also create an illegal meeting uh we were dealing with this one district and it was very convenient the superintendent had a text list with all the board members on it you know group text and so superintendent could text the board members and the board members could text back and it just like this ongoing illegal meeting
069so texts are subject to all the same rules um including the same reply all problem that you can have a communication uh that uh comes to all the board members by electronic means um interestingly that language in the statute by electronic means or otherwise was written in 1975 and what do you think it referred to conference calls that's what it meant in 1975 but now in 2024 there's a whole new body of law on emails and searches and what's a diligent search and so on and so forth but I just would leave you with the caution and you know there's information in that hand up um that you just have to be super careful um abouta and help your friends uh be super careful as well well um that those are my scenarios I'm happy
070to answer any questions I know you have other items on the agenda but up [Laughter] questions you mentioned illegal meeting what constitut things to watch out for they might not think right what where do caucus rules Come to answer that um the definition of meeting ex excludes certain things and um exclusions include collective bargaining strategy negotiations with regard to collective bargaining that's your internal discussions as well as the actual negotiations they don't need to be posted another is a a chance or social uh Gathering so if yall go to a retirement party uh it's it's not a meeting but you have to be careful not to hang out at the bar board business because that would be different um caucus of the members of a single political party is excluded from the definition of meeting
071now for the uh a party that has fewer than a quum it's irrelevant because it's never a problem but for the party that has a quum of the um uh a caucus is permitted but there's a a wrinkle and that is that the definition talks about excluding from the definition of meeting discussion among members of a single political party who may also compose a quum but where uh people have gotten in trouble is that they've had that meeting that non meeting with cl and had the uh Town chairman of that political party in that meeting or the mayor or whatever right at that point the commission has ruled that it's no longer within the or corners of that statutory definition of caucus so those meetings have been declared illegal but a clean caucus even of
072the members of a single political party um without others present and that without others present includes the superintendent um uh that's excluded from the definition of meeting and the last one is a personal search committee uh boards can create a a search committee for an executive level position and the operation of that committee is outside of fi as well and that's for an executive level position which commission has ruled High School principal typically it's up for the superintendent but boards can create these committees and that V once they're created and if they're in the process of engaging in the search like collective bargaining or caucuses those are not considered meetings that have to be posted well I'm so glad meet the new board MERS see the experienced board members and um Kathy has my number
073so I'll thank you very so we're going to go back to item five b we'll call it whatever okay all right we're returning back to paragraph five of our agenda um we'll go to item five b now I'll say the package that I have does not have this um one of the emails one of the things that was emailed to me isn't clear I have two 5bs Federal funding summary and they have the federal sorry Tools for Schools IAQ but we're going to go with Federal funding summary D sure I'll show you so at last month's Board of bed meeting there was a um I'll say there was a thought exercise a query about what would happen if uh the Department of Education ceased and there was no more Federal funding uh than the impact
074it would have on Farmington Public Schools so this slide is is a summary of the funding that we get through federal grants um all in all uh you know our our budget was you know $795 million we get about a million and a half from federal uh funding we probably we get 1.6 or so in state funding as well so without state or federal funding we would the the town would need to come up with approximately you know 83 million to fund the current services that were budgeted this this year for purposes of of federal it's 1.5 million and you can see that that's uh broken down to these various grants uh and those grants are determined through uh you know government allocation and District demographics so for example uh Title One grants are there
075to support uh students who uh come from um you know lowincome families and so a lot of times with with Title One grants there's a perception that you know uh districts are considered Title One districts and they can be but schools you know within a town can also get a title one designation um title two focuses on uh you know uh professional development title three focuses on English language Learners uh title four is kind of a more of open-ended one covers a few different categories uh an Ida uh covers uh special education and then Perkins really covers career techn technology education so those are the really the categories there the Esser funds were the ones that came out of obviously Co that are expiring so those funds uh we won't be U continuing those funds
076uh kind of moving there um so so it's really uh less than 2% would be of the of the total budget uh so about 1.5 million is is the impact that we we get from the federal government thank you Dan any questions is what did you say was for the state yeah state was 1.6 and so just uh to kind as a reference when you get your uh monthly um you know financial statement at the end there's you know very detailed summary uh of breakdown of federal grants state grants local and and so on I think this is really good information for the public um as we go into the budget process I mean it is it is part of all of our it's part of every you know monthly update it's also part of
077our budget book you know but it's still something that I think you know what people are concerned about we should have this information I think in front of Mind as we think about budget uh challenges in the upcoming year uh the money that's encumbered by Esser and arpa um those are grants that we are not going to be car other words the things that we're covering with that money will not be carried over into next year's operating right yeah yes unless it was determined to stay in the budget but then at that point it would be regular regular a local funding would have to to pick up that expense okay all right um okay any anybody else thanks Dan you're welcome um next item is Tools for Schools so I want to invite uh samel
078Patrick our director Phil to come up to assist me with this presentation and just I just will add for Tools for Schools we have implemented that for many many years in Farmington but more recently new state level mandates have set forth that we are required now annually uh each local and Regional Board of Ed will provide for a uniform inspection and evaluation program uh of indoor air quality within each School building using the epa's indoor air quality tools for schools program so even though we've used it for many years here in Farmington now it has become uh a mandate and the requirement is uh related to Connecticut uh General statute 10-22 D Public Act 22-18 and Public Act 23167 and so part of this requirement is that we have to pres we uh need to
079present uh to the board of education at a regular meeting and make the reports available uh to the public so um you would expect that this would come to you annually and so I'll hand this over to Sam and Dan so just once again as a historical as Kathy was talking about um you while we had done this the requirement had gone from every five years and then they switch it to every three years and then again they update again now to make it annually um and and working through that part and then to that point of now doing as an annual presentation at Board of Education and also posting uh results on the website and so we'll we'll kind of talk about that a little bit um in there as kind of more of
080some of the details into the statute so there are these required checklists that uh each School requires to go through uh buildings and grounds Waste Management ventilation integrated Pest Management Food Service and Health officials uh there's also uh teacher checklists that that uh go through and each School convenes an uh indoor air quality IAQ committee to to go through and do the walkthroughs of the schools so um not to to overwhelm you with with paper here are all the individualized school results that are here um once again we're working there going to get scanned and they'll be um through the school on the website you know through our um you know within our facilities website that they'll be there and so we're hopefully to have those along actually with this presentation linked onto that page
081um in the next day or two um if there but if anybody is really interested and wants to do a deep dive or uh we we have that available uh as well um yeah uh Sam's going to talk just a little bit about just kind of summarizing a little bit of of some of the results that that we have here um so is this on yeah all right the light isn't working so um so yeah as Kathy mentioned we've we've done this for years in my time I've been here four years we've already done it two other times uh so really it's just you know the annual is is really the only difference for us with the with the exception um of some different forms uh that Dan talked about that we're asked to do
082this time interest interestingly the teacher uh checklist wasn't part of this new regulation but it's really been an integral tool for us um Through The Years so um so we did Implement that as well this year that goes out as a Google form um through the principles so we worked with the head custodian group the principal group and they really spearheaded this whole thing brought together the IAQ committees um and we got some valuable uh responses back um so we're in the process now of taking that boiling it down uh to um further investigate any of the issues that are listed or or clarifications that are needed majority of the atoms focused on room temperature as as you can imagine um which again even on that end we have to we have to look further
083into that um a hot room a hot room at Westwoods is a little different situation than a hot room at no Wallace so the Westwoods could go in as a work order it could be a building management system uh system thing that we have to fix whereas Noah Wallace that's something that will um obviously be addressed through a capital type project like what we brought forward um with the hbac projects through Capital um additionally there were some general cleanliness items so head custodians are going to work to um to check in on those follow up on them and uh put them in as work orders we also have major projects so some of these items you may see um there there's a section where it talks about shades we might find out that we have
084some broken Shades in a room and and you'll see that we have a um a major project that addresses that coming up so um some of the other statutes that have been updated is uh now increasing the frequency of radon testing in the schools um you know we've talked about obviously doing the the tools for schools on an annual basis also a revised timeline for HVAC assessments and even those are are constantly also uh getting updated uh and then the emphasis on the government submission which is you know posting on the websites coming to Board of Ed meetings and and such um you know our radon testing which last occurred uh in 2021 they've now moved it to a a a shorter time time span but we're we're kind of grandfathered in so we're we're
085still within the the time frame to do it having said that um we're going to look to still kind of do it to to try to kind of meet into that that timelines there just to want to you know making sure we're proactive you know obviously you know student safety and overall health and and is is important and so we don't want to just uh you know be at the level of compliance we want to make sure we're we we're looking at it thoughtfully and and once again looking after the safety of students so um and then uh Sam's going to talk a little bit more about the HVAC assessments and and kind of that the the the requirement but also our larger plan that that we have here um in Farmington great um just
086a tag on as well about that radon it we're sitting in a new building we have uh it's 19 months within a new building that you have to establish initial testing as well so uh high school will be part of that process as well uh for the HVAC assessments uh uh you may remember we had a capital allocation last year to start conducting these hbac assessments which originally were due at the end of this month which uh there was an uproar that that wasn't feasible um was pushed out a year and now there's actually a much more implementable timeline where we have 20% of schools are due at the end of 2027 and then uh 20% each year until 2031 when you have to have them complete that said we've we've gone ahead uh with
087the 4k4 schools here in District because there is a stipulation with the within the regulation that to be um uh available for the any HVAC grant that you need to have this done uh so uh so we're we're in the process at n Wallace East Farms Union and West District and we should have that done shortly um that's that's really about about it um be glad to answer any questions if there are in the a it anybody You' fulfilled your statutory Duty thank I will when I fill out the state form that says that I presented to the board tomorrow thank you professional appointments uh no professional appointments resignations or retirements in this month's report okay deeper learning uh just for deeper learning once again um there are just so many impressive deeper learning updates
088to share with you and our community so as you r these updates you're going to see examples of the importance of deeper learning experiences for all students K12 aligned to our vision of the global citizen framework for teaching and learning and our core beliefs thank you Kathy all right um forgot what we said we're g to move up yeah can move that up all right um given that we have some uh executive session work to do and there's people in the audience we who schedule would like to accommodate um I'd like to get a motion if if I could to move item 9 executive session up to make it the new item six of our agenda to and so that we can discuss uh for the discussion of two central office administrator appointments motion second
089comments discussion all those in favor signify by saying I I I opposed exstension okay we're we're going to go to Executive session at 8:32 I just could you read the motion I'll read it because of um sure I'll read it so for the record the motion is to adjourn the meeting to Executive session at 8:32 as permitted by Connecticut General statute section 1- 225a for the following purposes as Allowed by section 1-200 6A that is discussion concerning the appointment of two central office administrators GNA get a motion for that motion than you all those in favor signify by saying I I I oppos Obion okay for executive session okay we back um can I get a motion to return to public session at 92 9:22 motion second all those in favor signify by saying I
090I I opposed motion carries okay we're back in okay so um continuing along with the um change in the agenda item I need to move up items seven d to make it new item for move it up to the agenda you know what I'm talking about they'll fix up they'll up fix it in post can I get a motion to do that please uh motion second all those in favor signify by saying I okay so now we're considering item seven d um and then I need a motion to approve the appointment of Eric Martin to the position of director of curriculum and instructor with the effective date of January 21st 2025 motion second second any discussion all those in favor signify by saying I I I opposed motion carries congratulations Eric welcome welcome welcome welcome
091and now I need a motion to approve the appointment of Dan atun to the position of assistant superintendent of finance and operations effective December 10th 2024 motion second all those any discussion all those in favor signify by saying I I opposed motion carries congratulations Dan thank you all right moving on with our agenda item will be item uh six uh a budget impact budget update getting you right to work love it I would I wouldn't have it any other way uh I would like to thank the board um for your you know your faith in me um and I've just been so excited and glad that that um this partnership has has kind of been created um you know you always take a leap of faith whenever you take a position and um you know
092every day I'm super excited to come and work for Farmington and obviously with um you know it's been a um um challenging time for for myself and the family and and you have all uh embraced the whole Zune family and and made me part of the family immediately and we're so I myself but even my whole family so appreciative of everything everything you've done so we're we're we're grateful and glad to be a part of the part of this family and continue to look to do outstanding things for the Farmington Public Schools thank you you're welcome D thank you uh budget budget impact so um really key piece there you know as we talk and we'll do the October financials U later on in the budget but just a couple things there um you know
093overall taking a look to to see where we are with with this year um we have had a couple good things uh happening uh most most ly through kind of the state right now uh we don't have the full details yet but we're looking to be able to get a little bit more money through excess uh um excess cost Grant through special education there's a threshold that that districts are expected to pay and then after that the state kind of reimburse at a certain rate so that's looking a little bit more favorable um you know a little challenging is reason part of the reason it's favorable is because our our overall costs are are increasing um but but helping that piece of it out and then also the state has um um given us our
094reimbursement rate for magnet school tuition um at a rate a little bit rate higher there so so we're going to be getting expected some extra Revenue there that should help offset some of the overall um you know uh expenses that that that we have there so so those are are look into there and so overall uh we we feel good that we're you know we're on Pace and and and doing well for for this year's budget um Dan we with the last meeting we had talked about um conversations you've had with specialty uh um can you kind of give us an update on that yeah so um you know specialty we we' we've had the conversations um and you know they recognize that you know even from the the September meeting um you Mike Turner
095when he we attended that that was not the service that they expect um for us here a specialty and so um after we've had some conversations take a look things you know kind of as they've kind of leveled off and settled and you know and and you know we're we're seeing some consistent service right now you know obviously you know there's going to always sometimes be some challenges with with bus shortage and stuff but but we're feeling good about um you know how how the the the operations are are going um but specialty is is um planning to give us a credit of $7,000 uh toward um you know just toward you know back uh as a credit there as a kind of a gesture of of Goodwill and and you know wanting to maintain
096a positive relationship with Farmington to help you know just um you know offset some of the the you know the craziness and and and of those of those first few challenging weeks okay um I'm going to open it up to the board for any questions on this I know people have lots of questions Angela start with you jend work our way down yeah so um Dan I just brought up the contract again the bus contract because I was trying to like understand when the discussion came out we were hearing there was like a $4,000 credit now you said $7,000 so I'm just going to read a few things on the contract just so everyone's on the same page like you know there's like rules of engage and then like kind of rules like one of
097them is no student shall arrive at School more than 15 minutes prior to the school opening in the morning no student shall remain at school waiting for transportation home for more than 15 minutes after school has dismissed the second item is after school vehicle should not leave the school until at least five minutes following dismissal no student will be dropped off at his or her stop um later um her bus stop later than 50 minutes after leaving the school except under extraordinary conditions and then it further goes down for like the invoice and pay pay like we'll get itemized invoices and it says under invoice and payment if in the event one or more Vehicles do not operate in compliance with this agreement over each independent route on any school day the entire daily cost
098of such vehicle shall be deducted from the contractor's invoice charges so I guess what I'm trying to understand is that $7,000 what is the daily cost of a vehicle for any like a you know on an independent route on any school day to understand what that $7,000 represents CU like if you're telling me a bus C costs a daily route is $700 and that 7,000 represents 10 of those infractions for September I would probably say that that $7,000 isn't enough because I think there was more than just reading those two and honestly I probably could go over it a little bit more fine tooth comb those are just blatant ones like after 50 minutes after school dismisses I mean I think we all agree probably the that first month there were a lot of occasions
099where it was over 50 minutes when children were getting home so I guess I guess my simple question is what is the daily um cost of a vehicle or can we find that out to understand what that $77,000 represents so we can articulate back to even know I don't know if $7,000 seems like a good amount or not um sure and at the same time I want to have a good relationship with them too but I think it's good to have like some accountability in terms of being able to measure progress so so you know this is pretty clearcut if we know how many times they were laid and how many infractions they have and what the daily vehicle is that's a pretty easy equation we could all kind of then be able to like
100rattle off so sure and so just to clarify I believe um and and I'll confirm I believe the uh the bus um you know for for the bus it's it's $540 I don't believe that's just you know for the rate but the key there is when we did a review of the contract when we you know we reached out to Shipman to kind of do the analysis of it as as you read the provision really it's it's when they violate some of those Provisions there's a it's like a $100 fine you know per per violation for them to get the full cost of a bus for the day for that you know that that money it would be you know the bus not showing up you know the bus you know not you know it
101it would be there so the provisions are there that they could be um you know like I said so that's when we kind of looked at those each of those fines or each of those infractions is kind of like a $100 fine of of kind of being there and so when we looked through those those pieces you know we went through kind of the spreadsheets that we had for the time and then you know the reality is you know is some conversations there there were some that's like okay wait you know let's let's look at the GPS system it was you know 48 minutes when did they actually leave the school you know when when were those pieces there and so you know we what we didn't want to do for both cost and both
102you know relationship is we didn't want to sit there and have like the attorneys having to go through all the the the GPS things to see because at that point whatever costs you're potentially you know getting you know they're probably going right back to both of us for legal fees and and and time and such so a lot of it was just kind of looking at you know kind of the the you know the clear violations that like no one was going to argue about right that no one was going to um you know um you know uh you know an hour and a half two hours you know the bus driver getting lost or something like that so those were the ones that we kind of looked through um and and went through there
103and so um you know when we when we had the discussion you know like you said there was a prelimary conversation of $4,000 then after that you know there's some conversation back and forth about you know is that going to be enough and and and so you know specialty said you know um you know uh because we want to make it right we're willing to kind of go to 7,000 and and and this way not have to go through you know any any of the the pieces and to do it as a like I said to do as a credit um so this way it's also not feeling like you know they're being you know fined for you know they want to kind of do it proactively um just once again out of out of
104maintaining and building this positive relationship that we'll have with them for you know after this year in additional four years so do you have at least the summary of like so that I understand everything you just said um so like maybe they're not all in fractions so if they were all in fractions at $100 that would be you know 70 infractions for $7,000 but probably some of them are the daily cost of like do you have anything that we could summarize if we were speaking to someone about it to say like okay we did get a credit in um September for whatever infractions of the bus being late this many times or something like that just so that we can quantify to some to some extent as to like what we're getting the credit for
105yeah we don't um you know in doing it we don't have like I don't have like an itemized list which would be you know Westwoods bus 11 you know on this day it was kind of going through and and kind of charting that and working there like you said it was really because it was really more about wanting to um do it as a like I said as kind of a credit as opposed to here's you know here's your itemized fine right like we want to kind of to to have that piece of it so um so that's why even though we kind of you know they had the conversation of saying hey take a look show you know take a look at at the you know the infractions you know where's it at kind
106of let's ballpark it and then from there we'll kind of um you know work toward getting a final number that that feels fair to everybody and if a bus didn't show up at all we're not charged for that bus correct yeah so that would not even be on the invoice so in the times where you know I know we all heard you know about different buses not uh bringing a sports team to a sporting event or whatever might have happened they're not on the invo yes correct right well that's actually helpful yeah that's helpful helpful I I think I to Angela's um comments was more concerned around there was a lot of involvement from a board perspective there was administrators on buses there was teachers on buses the amount of effort that it took in
107that first month I was expecting to see a little bit more so I'm thankful that they've relooked at that but it would be helpful to get kind of what compris of that but if it's in good faith and you're comfortable with that I'm comfortable with keeping the good Rel relationship and keeping the good service um and you providing us the details along the way if there's anything that changes no absolutely um and like I said I and I you know I do feel um you know it's a it's a fair settlement like I said I think uh or it's a fair offer Fair Credit um you know once again you know I I've seen situations like this where you know kind of gets ugly and then you know kind of gets very litigious and then
108even maybe you're getting a little bit more money but then you know that relationship is is is need some repairing right and so so we think that this is just a uh you know kind of a good balance and I think especially what we've seen over probably I'd say maybe now the last seven eight weeks of seeing consistent service and seeing um you know that ability to do it and and once again with with there as we're even seeing um just the general invoices are uh special services transportation number still going but that's not through you know especially that's just the need right student needs meeting the needs there so going a little bit there but overall our you know um major buses were still trending much better than than historically we've done through M&J
109and in the past and you know being able to use utilize fewer buses being able to save on fuel so we're also finding savings you know in other areas um you know overall there we might not see at the in the final line like I said because of the special services that would be there um but the the transportation budget line could actually be significantly worse um if it wasn't you know once again for for for a lot of the things that are that are putting into place in the specialty just real quick bill to follow up are the invoicing much easier to understand and clear of what you're the the finance office is um has been very happy with you know the the the invoice the detailing the clarity to to what it is
110um you know they would talk a lot with the previous company about you know you know you know the recredit and and invoices and things and going back and forth and needing to check but but here there's there's a lot more transparency there's a lot more clarity to it um so so like I said even in that level that that relationship is is has been uh better and I think ultimately helping um you know save you know farming Public Schools more money through that transparency and and Clarity and voicing you have anything Andre and my questions were similar to Angela's and and I with naen you know if you're if you're comfortable with this and that you feel that this is fair um you know I'm supportive of it I think the only other things
111that I would add is that there's things that you can't put a price tag on that happened in the beginning of the school year um you know like you can't put a price tag on safety um or poor communication um so those are some of the things that um I wanted to to see specialty improve on and um you know I don't want to say be held accountable for but you know that they they show a good faith effort at acknowledging yeah we our performance was unacceptable and we're going to do better I mean Mike Turner came up and said I I need to do better we need to do better um and I guess the only question that I have is um you know we're not in the business of transportation we hired a
112company we're paying a lot of money for this company are you finding that you still have to kind of monitor oversee as much or no and actually back away from that because that's your time too which is also no and that and that's and that's no I no and and I appreciate that um and I think that's a great question and and you know I can say you know for myself that um you know the vast majority of of you know any type of smaller issues are you know happening you know with you know specially like you know they're they're you know you know they're getting it much more under control to handling those situations um I can't you know I don't I'll probably jinx myself um I don't remember the last email that I've
113had to receive about a parent being upset about the the buses you know that they've they've gone to you know specialty they've been timely replied most of them have you know kind of acknowledge or most of the challenges just have been like you know with with driver shortages or or things along those lines but you know operationally they got you know they they they definitely are are back um running much you know running smoothly now um and so yeah so you know the amount of time that you know those first few weeks that that I was the you know you know involved in that and the answering things has has dropped tremendously which also then you know allows you know for for me and now an ex Matt to be able to to spend our
114resources on the other Focus you know focus on budget focus on you know um you know the other aspects of of the role which which have been which been critical so uh I've seen a tremendous Improvement in in that and so that's um you know another piece of it we know we used to do weekly meetings um and now we're actually moving to bi-weekly meetings because you know before the agenda was like all right Tim here we go let's go we got it and and now uh we're we're not seeing as as many issues at this point and I think you'd hear the same from Prince because you know as I'm talking to principles they're all telling me Oh so much better and it's not you know at the Forefront of their work any longer
115so anybody el el anybody down there comments questions all right I'll wrap up um first of all by saying Dan thank you for all your hard work in dealing with this um you one of the reasons why I think the board was so supportive of your candidacy was I think you were you know baptized in fire to some degree uh but in the process you earn the Trust In of our school Community uh so I think that makes that you've been coming here full-time you know U we're removing the interm title a lot more easy a lot easier for us to do um I do want to say also thank you for getting the feedback just so everybody's clear you made the comment we heard was four now it's seven it was four until we
116pushed back um Kathy and I spoke last week absolutely and she reported to me that they wanted to come back at 4 and after getting consensus everyone and I felt very much the same way we pushed back um because we felt it was important to do that um and I appreciate you carrying the message in a way that was heard and uh responded to favorably so well done there so thank you for that uh and I would also want to Echo and Andrea's comments as well that you know there's the economic piece which is important for certain but it's the accountability piece as well and I think we've seen that in the last uh six to eight weeks nine weeks um you can see they do they are trying to do better so you know
117hopefully this is behind us now once and for all and uh we can continue to move on forward with the partner for the next four and a half years yeah so thank you for that okay next item on the agenda item six C review discussion a potential action on 2025 2026 Boe meeting schedule we discussed this um at our last meeting we moved the December meeting to Union School everything else has stayed the same any other anybody have any comments or questions about it all right hearing none can I get a motion to approve uh the Board of Ed School Board of Education 2025 2026 meeting schedule as presented motion second all those in favor signify by saying I I opposed motion carries just oh sorry yeah sorry about that okay next we have to
118do policy repeals I apologize guys I'm kind jumping around tonight um losing my place uh first is a policy repeal 4119 personal technology repeal second reading um I get a motion to approve the policies listed below uh 4119 and 4123 uh for repeal as the second reading motion second any discussion all those in favor signify by saying I I opposed motion carries all right sorry about that guys um um so the next would be item 7B Kathy approval of updated policy 0200 fiveyear goals uh yes so this is simply an update of policy 02 uh 0000 to reflect the November meeting's approval of the 2025 2030 goals uh as a first reading for the policy so you approve the goals for 25 uh to 30 and then uh we have to update the policy to
119reflect that right so the policy has to reflect the goals yes okay any conversation comments questions okay can I get a motion to approve updated policy 0200 fiveyear goals for a first reading as presented motion second all those signify by saying I I carries next up um 7e established Farmington High School graduation Daye yes so this is yeah we have um by Statute the board can approve a graduation date at any time during uh the school year provided that it's the 18 180th day of the school at the time of the approval so at this time we had one snow day last for this year so our last day of school will now be June 10th uh instead of the original day of June 9th there is also a need um because of Project Graduation
120to lock in a date I think you remember from last year we had to do the same thing most districts set their date very early some of them at the very beginning of the school year and when they do that they lock in a date and so in the past when that didn't happen we had flexibility as as school districts had snow days everybody moved um but we are um you know we we try to wait as long as possible because of snow days and it's just come to the point where we have to do this earlier in the year to ensure that our Project Graduation goes smoothly and on the day of graduation and not a different day so what happens if we wind up banging banging up five school days in February you
121know yes you know that is absolutely a possibility we never know what a winter is going to bring or even Spring weather could bring you know it's always up in the air and we don't know people should the spring vacation is on the table at that point right when we are well usually we use everything in June first um and then we could go back to April but the board really could make the decision that you don't want to go late into June and you'd rather uh look at April that the policy gives that um ability to look at it in different ways I would say that if we had five days um that you know first of all you're within statute to do that to do this now and say we had 5 days
122I think what I've discussed with the High School administration is that well that means five less days before graduation for students and they would really have to work very hard to ensure that every student had every opportunity to fulfill the requirements of graduation and um that wouldn't hinder a student from graduating that's very important to all of us Kathy just to clarify this is for the graduation date not necessarily the last day of school oh yeah it's just graduation date so the elementary midle schools even the rest of the high school could still continue on kindergarten through 11 raade will continue the 5 days it's only the graduating class but I still as superintendent always worry about those students who might be at a point that they need as much time as possible to meet
123those last graduation requirements so that is something that I know counseling and uh the administration here has been very clear with me to say that they're going to do everything possible if that were the scenario let's hope it's not but if it is uh that's how we would handle that but it's very important to the whole purpose of Project Graduation is to have that all night graduation party the day of graduation and not a different day that would we it would defeat the purpose of that very important event that keeps students safe on their graduation day okay any other questions can I get a motion to approve June 10th 2025 as the Farmington High School Graduation Day motion second all those in favor signify by saying I I I opposed motion carries okay next is
124the um approval of the 202 October 2024 uh financial statement Dan yeah thanks um so you know we were able to uh do our October um financial statement uh last time we weren't able to complete it yet the insurance numbers hadn't come in yet so we'll have that and then once again the goal will be for hopefully the January meeting to able to do November and December and and then kind of be caught up um you know just taking a look just highlighting like I said before with the budget update and impact uh you know we're we're trending well to to be able to finish off the year well uh just a couple areas is of of no obviously that you know the teacher salary always tends to to you know still kind of keep
125it balanced there couple areas though that that you might that point out that that might be some you know concerns or some questions is you know you'll see nurses uh um down 176,000 and just to clarify for that is that's not an additional nurses um like School nurses there these are nurses that we need for students um with with high medical needs and IEPs and so uh for for those increases so there uh having said that we we anticipate as I talked before the increase in excess cost excess cost grant that the state will kind of help defer some of that and so uh um you know for for some students where we're it get through threshold uh the other area um that's a little high you'll see is summer teachers which really is a
126misnomer we're looking to change it's really about the whole summer school program um and I'm looking at that uh there what we're looking to do is um identify some invoices that got put under summer school that probably should be better directed in like private tuition or in certain cases Professional Services like the OT that we do and so you'll see um you know while the the the the invoices of the expenses still exist they'll just be recategorized in different areas um and and and putting it there so just to be consistent with what we've done with some of the past practices there but um you'll you'll see kind of right now uh at least ahead with the Transportation uh services and then gasoline we're doing better than expected like I said you know that you're
127probably going to see a little fluctuation over the next couple months um with you know special uh individualized Transportation costes going up um but that um you know overall the major the the major things I don't know if anyone has any other um questions you know obviously public you know tuition and some of the other special services costs Run High kind of like they they historically do any questions sure um for Excel it looks like a big number there but maybe so uh know for Excel you know it's interesting because they um you know when they kind of start running their budget there's a lot of initial expenses that come up and they haven't you know gotten the the you know the TW will keep coming in so you'll probably see that level off um
128you know historically I think probably by January February that'll probably get you know to level and then actually you're going to start an increase uh and kind of you know finishing off in you know in the black in there so that's just kind of a cyclical piece of where their expenses go and then the the tuition you know it's expected tuition for you know for those but once again they've kind of paid on a monthly basis so so they'll start getting more Revenue each month that will will offset those expenses right any other questions can I get a motion to approve the October 2024 financial statement report as presented motion second all those in favor signify by saying I I opposed motion carries okay next up on the agenda is the report of the board
129chair our next meeting is Monday uh January 13th I believe um we are at the end of the year uh calendar year it's been a long year been a challenging year but also an exciting Year we're able to open up this building um we brought some new people in it's been it's really been an excellent 2024 was a good year for the Farmington Public Schools uh so I thank Kathy and everyone uh in the district office the entire entire school district for all their hard work this year uh I wish everybody here a happy holidays Merry Christmas Happy New Year happy Hanukkah whatever you celebrate and uh we'll see you next year I end that with that get a motion to adjourn motion a second adjourn [Music]